ML100740523
| ML100740523 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Bellefonte  |
| Issue date: | 03/15/2010 |
| From: | Tennessee Valley Authority |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| SECY RAS | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML100740521 | List: |
| References | |
| 50-438-CP, 50-439-CP, ASLBP 10-896-01-CP-BD01, RAS 17562 | |
| Download: ML100740523 (11) | |
Text
March 15, 2010 Page 1 of 11 TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY Bellefonte Nuclear Plant, Units 1 and 2 Initial Prehearing Conference March 1, 2010 ERRATA Page Line Action 21 13 change why to flawed 21 15 change be to begin 21 15 delete dealing 21 16 insert in an after front 21 16 change August, 28 to August 26, 2008 21 18 after permits insert, which we will refer 21 18 delete referred 21 20 change surrounded to surrendered these CPs 21 21 after in and before 2006 add September of 21 21 add s to CP 22 1
after explained insert why there is good cause for reinstatement 22 1
add an s on purpose = purposes 22 2
change Bollwerk to Bollwerk, 22 3
delete, after generation 22 3
add increasing costs per kilowatt of installed capacity among before generation 22 6
insert, and after construction 22 6
delete, Or And; capitalize Finally 22 7
delete s, from units, 22 12 delete nt off of wasnt = was 22 15 change present to precedent 22 17 change that to at 22 17 add in after issue 22 19 insert that after recognize 22 22 change recommend to recommended 22 22 change recognize to authorize it 22 23 change 1 and the PC to the unit 1 and 2 CPs 22 23 insert 18th after February 22 23 insert Commission in fact authorized the after the 22 23 insert to reinstate the CPs after staff 22 24 delete AUTHORIZE 22 24 change placed to place 22 24 change terminate to terminated 22 25 delete I had 23 9
change CLI-1006 to CLI-10-06
Page 2 of 11 Page Line Action 23 22 replace therefore will with thereunder 23 22 insert the after shown 23 25 insert for the good cause standard after Act 24 2
change CLI-06 to CLI-10-06 24 2
insert in order after that 24 2
insert its after exercise 24 3
delete the 24 5
insert for after not 24 8
change license to licenses 24 10 insert logical derivation of the after the 24 12 insert its implementing after and 24 13 change 55(b) to 50.55(b) 24 13 insert seminal after The 24 14 insert find it after Seabrook, 24 15 change CLI 84.6 to CLI-84-6 24 17-22 The sentence should read: It holds that in order to meet the good cause standard, and Im going to quote, the proponent of the contention must articulate some basis to show that the applicant is responsible for the delay, which the petitioners here claim is not the case and acknowledge, and has acted intentionally and without a valid business purpose.
25 1
insert reasonable after number of 25 2
place a. after alternatives and capitalize the c in Consistent 25 3
delete the s on precedents = precedent 25 3
insert the before Commission 25 3
insert expressly after Commission 25 4
insert and this is after CPs, 25 6
change legal to logical 25 9
change relegation to relitigation 25 10 change will be to were 25 11 change the, to a.
25 11 insert as a separate matter after NEPA 25 12 add. The scope after CONCLUSION 25 12 delete come 25 13 insert is limited to the proposed action - here, after NEPa 25 13 change reinstate to reinstatement 25 13 change of to of 25 14 change license to licenses 25 14 insert again after and 25 15 insert in this case after that 25 16 insert NEPA as it has issued after under 25 16 change assessments to assessment.
25 16 change and to So
Page 3 of 11 Page Line Action 25 17 insert to the Board after left 25 17 insert then is the question of after here 25 17 insert TVA has shown "good cause" warranting reinstatement after fact, 38 5
change parts to subparts 38 12 change that to they 38 12 insert later after addressed 38 13 insert as it was plead after 3-A 38 17 change purported to purportedly 38 18 change CP to CPs 38 21 insert groundless and after is 38 21 delete, after factually 38 22 change this to these 38 22 change reason to reasons 38 24 insert of the CPs after reinstatement 39 1
change (f). 13 to (f)(1)(iii) 39 3
insert a after that 39 10 change (f). 15 to (f)(1)(v) 39 13 change B-4 to before 39 13 change discharge to discharging 39 21 change Secy, 080041 to COMSECY 08-0041 40 4
change for to before 40 5
insert for this reason after again, 40 6
change disputes of to dispute on a 40 7
change (f). 16 to (f)(1)(vi) 40 11 change with to of 40 14 delete the 40 14 change legal to illegal 40 20 change (f). 13 to (f)(1)(iii) 40 24 change permanent to permitting 41 4-6 The sentence should read: Therefore, no EIS is required, as CP reinstatement is not one of the agency actions listed in section 51.20 as requiring an EIS.
41 7
insert s EA after staff 41 8
delete the, after address 41 16 change McQuire to McGuire 41 22 insert essentially after rejected 41 22 change argument to arguments 41 24 change CP to CPs 42 3
change requesting to request and 42 12 change entirely to entirety 42 13 change second legal to litigable 42 14 insert a after on
Page 4 of 11 Page Line Action 42 15 delete 15 and 6 and replace with (1)(v) and (vi) 42 24 insert to come after process 43 8
insert presumably after hearing 43 13 delete admissibility 43 13 change right to ripe 50 22 change SCIS to SEIS 51 4
insert Well as you know, Judge Bollwerk, before TVA 51 4
insert to support after so 51 7
insert and after construction 51 9
delete, after unit 51 9
insert an before AP 51 9
insert a before third 51 16 change with to what 51 17 change EIS to SEIS 51 17 insert environmental after our 51 20 change BMW to B&W 51 20 insert an after or 51 20 change A P1000 to AP1000 51 22 change BMW to B&W 51 23 change BMW to B&W 51 25 insert them after giving 52 4
insert be after would 52 7
change SCIUS to SEIS 52 8
insert at the site after unit 53 16 insert, as a Federal agency, after TVA 53 20 change operation to operating 53 20 insert to the staff after application 53 21 change - - to to - - if 53 25 insert basically after that 53 25 change has to as 54 2
change BMW to B&W 54 12 insert to before begin 54 12 insert, after with 54 12 change as to is 54 13 change equal to equivalent 62 2
change there to they are 62 2
insert TVA after the 62 4
insert the before staff 62 13-16 The sentence should read: And consistent with that, your Honor, TVA also did an EA regarding reinstatement and came to the same conclusion, just that the supplemental EIS is for purposes of their Board and their decision as to whether or not to construct and operate.
62 20 delete pop per rail 62 21 insert units, that's correct your Honor after two
Page 5 of 11 Page Line Action 62 21 delete urge 63 5
insert and after forward, 63 6
change doing to going 63 8
change BMW to B&W 63 13 insert and before operation 63 14 insert was our original EIS after units 63 19 insert EIS after 1974 64 4
insert back in 1978 when we adopted it in our operating license application after units 64 12 change units to unit operation and construction 64 20 insert while they are conferring, can I add one other point to this?
after Honor, 64 20 insert that after reasons 64 22 change without to would bound 64 23 insert and I believe it after analysis 64 24 insert when it is bounding after it 71 14 change (f). 13 to (f)(1)(iii) 71 16 change score to scope 71 19 insert whatsoever after nothing 71 25 change PCs to CPs 72 3
change or to of 72 5
change concluded to precluded 72 14 change for to of 72 14 change and to for 72 17 change failed to fails 72 19 change (f) 1, 4 & 6 to (f)(1)(iv) and (vi) 73 7
insert has confirmed completion of construction after and 73 10 insert operate after to 73 11 insert those implemented after including 73 13 insert to this point after Further 73 14 change CLI-1006 to CLI-10-06 73 16 change CLI-1006 to CLI-10-06 73 21 change and to is 74 2
change defactor to defacto 74 3
insert they are after therefore, 74 7
insert fourth after this 74 13 change forage to point 74 15 insert present a before sufficiently 74 15 change in to and 74 20 change comply to compliance 74 20 insert NRC after with 74 22 change does to do 74 22 insert (1)(v) and (vi) after (f) 74 23 delete F1, 5 and 6.
Page 6 of 11 Page Line Action 75 4
change They to There 75 9
change staff to staffs 75 13 insert that the Commission in after And 75 14 change 1006 to 10-06 75 14 change argument to arguments 75 16 change these to this 76 4
delete State 76 5
change agrees to stated reasons 76 8
insert it will be after and 76 15 change inadequate to an adequate basis to change their course of action 77 2
insert proceeding after application 77 21 insert if we were to go forward after action 78 7
insert, its own internal environmental assessment for its NEPA requirements after assessment 78 9
insert EA after separate 78 9
change issue to issued 83 11 insert the after Under 83 11 insert that after assumption 83 12 change under to part of the 83 15 change right to bright 83 15 change and to that 83 16 delete second have 83 24 insert meeting after as well as 84 1
change State to Statement 92 9
insert Thank you Mr. Chairman, before My 92 13 insert somewhat after something 92 15 change those to the proposed 92 15 change contentions to contention 92 17 insert it before does not 93 5
insert part of after is 93 7
change we thing it meets to of rethinking 93 22 insert an after and 93 23 change contentions to contention 93 23 change as to is 94 2
insert Bellefonte units after day, 94 2
change is equally to will be economically 94 9
change CPR to CFR 94 9
change (f) 1, 3, 4 or 5 to (f)(1)(iii), (iv) or (v) 94 18 insert installed after of 94 18 insert new after than 94 19 insert now on the table after construction 94 25 change had to are 95 6-9 The sentence should read: Petitioners focus is almost exclusively
Page 7 of 11 Page Line Action on cost projections for alternative energy sources in the Bellefonte Units 3 and 4 Environmental Report. This is not the forum, though, for dealing with costs related to Bellefonte Units 3 and 4."
95 18 change various to the very 95 22 change this to what they want to raise 96 4
change continued to contend that 96 13 change in instances to instances (delete 2nd in) 96 16 delete we 96 20 change large to largely economic and 96 20 change judgment to judgments 96 21 change and to in the 96 25 insert is the standard after standard 96 25 change e to the 97 1
insert initial before issuance 97 3
insert The before Commissions 97 3
change 1006 to 10-06 97 4
insert they after reason, 97 7
change it is our position on to has embarked, as I mentioned 97 8
change need to needs 97 13 change need to needs 97 14 insert itself after motion 97 15 change It to In short, that TVA has initiated an update to its broad resource plan 97 15 insert or material after relevant 97 15 change TVA to TVAs 97 22 change license to licenses 98 5
insert that are before pose 98 5
change are to as 98 9
insert relative before cost 98 9
change alternative to alternatives 98 10 change suggestions to suggesting 98 11 change with the to than would be 98 18 insert at this point and time after do 98 18 change by to of 98 19 change relevant to relative 98 24 insert of the after reinstatement 99 1
insert would have relevance after relevance, 99 1
insert proceeding after license 99 7
insert simple statement after that 99 7
insert explains what after and 99 7
insert cost after those 99 7
insert and those factors are after are 99 19 insert Judge Barratta, the sentence after sorry, 99 20 insert was after to
Page 8 of 11 Page Line Action 100 5
insert point that we make in our response at after the 100 6
delete response we are making on 100 11 change BLM to BLN 100 18 insert flout the Commission's after again 101 1
change their to that there are flaws in the 101 2
insert wholly after a 101 25 insert that after just 101 25 insert is after matter 102 14 change just to yet 102 22 insert is what we are looking at, that's correct after 2011 103 12 insert In this case as well, it will all have to feed in, before Thats 104 1
change it and a to the 104 9
insert it after serviced, 104 20 insert Let me just reiterate, though, before If 123 19 change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER 123 24 insert to after subject 123 25 change though to now 124 14 insert of after statement 124 15 insert seeking reinstatement of the before construction 124 22 change f1, 3, 4, and 5 to f(1)(iii), (iv) and (v) 125 6
change preceding to proceeding 125 13 insert compliance with after assure 125 13 change They are to TVA, under its approved NQAP, the nuclear quality assurance program, and its related corrective action program, is 125 19 change had to expressed 125 19 insert while not a commonplace occurrence, after views, 126 11 change attending to the tendon 126 20 change represented to presented 127 12 change 2206 to 2.206 127 21 change or to are just 128 4
change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER 128 15 change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER 128 22 change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER 129 5
change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER 129 6
insert first of all to correct, I think after Baratta, 129 7
insert probably after were 131 7
change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER 131 17 change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER 131 18 change theyre to there are 131 19 change too, to could 131 19 insert own after its 131 19 delete, one,
Page 9 of 11 Page Line Action 132 13 insert program and after assurance 132 13 change activity to activities 132 18 change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER 132 24 change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER 133 6
change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER 133 24 change subwise to stepwise 133 24 insert, your Honor, as after fashion 147 14 change MR. VIGLUICCI to MS. SUTTON 147 14 insert Like its predecessors, before Proposed 147 16 change and to a 147 16 change impact a to impact assessment and 148 3
insert staffs after the 148 7
replace under section 2.309 9E013 with here pursuant to 10 CFR 2.309 f(1)(iii) 148 8
change 2206 to 2.206 148 11 change and in order, to and order, 148 16 change 2206 to 2.206 148 17 change COI-10 of 6 to CLT-10-06 148 17 insert that before should 148 20 change 2N50 to 2 and 50 148 21 change N01 to YOL 149 10 change to to in 149 12 insert, however, after issues 149 12 change recognizable to cognizable 150 20 insert to the plant after applicable 150 23 insert for compliance with these requirements after plans 152 20 insert at the present time after status 152 21 insert that after anticipated 153 1
insert That's correct, your Honor. before But 153 7
change NCLA1006 to In CLI-10-06 154 4
change is to has been 154 6
change presence to precedent 159 7
change MS. JONES to MS. SUTTON 165 2
insert the claim after repeat 165 3
change reinstate to reinstatement 165 4
insert permits for after construction 165 4
change but here to This time, however, Petitioners allege 165 5
delete alleges 165 6
insert an after or 165 8
delete and 165 8
insert SSCs after life 165 9-18 This paragraph should read: "In support, as you just heard, petitioners cite 10 CFR 50.49 concerning the environmental qualification of safety-related electrical equipment. Proposed Contention 8 further evidences petitioners recurring failure to abide
Page 10 of 11 Page Line Action by the clear terms of the March 2009 Order. The subject of this proposed contention, the purported advanced age end-of-installed life SSCs, has no nexus to TVA's good cause justification for reinstatement of the CPs, and, accordingly, the contention must, yet again, be rejected as falling outside the scope of this proceeding pursuant to 10 CFR 2.309(f)(1)(iii)."
166 3
insert a after raise 166 4
insert material after genuine 166 4
change section to Section 2.309(f)(1)(vi) 166 5
delete 2 309f16.
166 11 change will to while 166 11 insert in this proceeding after litigable 166 17 change addressed to addresses the issue of 166 17 insert that after clear 166 17 insert procedural after TVA 166 18 change aged, to any age-degraded 166 19 delete degraded 166 24 insert hypothetically after could 166 25 change 2206 to 2.206 167 3
insert the after evaluates 167 6
change reservation to preservation 167 16 change SECKY 0804 is, which to COMSECY-08-0041, this 167 17 change plans to systems 167 17 insert that were after equipment 167 18 change suspense to suspension 167 20 change build to built 167 21 change regarding to for compliance with 167 21 insert basis after licensing 167 22 change requirement to requirements 167 23 insert an after on 167 25 change aiming to aging 168 4
insert as yet after TVAs 168 8
change 2206 to 2.206 168 8
insert proceeding after 2.206 173 24 change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER 173 25 insert - he starts by after argument 174 12 change proceed sueding to proceeding 175 5
change 9307 to 9308 175 7
change b to 9b 175 7
change the subject to suggest 175 8
change four units be to for units three and 175 8
change - - for units to - - and not related to units 1 and 2 175 9
delete he, and four 175 11 insert Basin after River 175 11 insert proposed contention before 9c
Page 11 of 11 Page Line Action 175 15 insert nuclear after Bellefonte 175 15 insert, again contemplating four units after units 175 15 change And to Proposed contention 175 15 insert increased after addressed 175 15 change check to chemical 175 20 delete proposed 175 20 insert s, proposed contention after contention 175 23 insert reinstatement after permit 176 2
insert that after declaration 176 2
insert largely after they 176 3
change early to earlier final 176 7
change have been resulted to that may result 176 9
insert good cause after focused 176 13 change referred to refer 176 14 insert -8 in that proceeding after NEPA 176 16 insert such as that after proceeding 176 17 change foyer to four 176 17 insert it is after but 176 18 insert reinstatement proceeding after permit 177 7
change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER 183 7
change VIGLUICCI to CHANDLER DB1/64535923