ML091811163

2009-06-DRAFT Outline Comments

ML091811163
Person / Time
Site:	Callaway
Issue date:	06/30/2009
From:	Apger G NRC Region 4
To:	Ameren Corp, Union Electric Co
References
50-483/09-301 50-483/09-301
Download: ML091811163 (2)

Text

DRAFT OUTLINE COMMENTS Facility: Callaway First Exam Date: 6/19/09 Written Exam Outline (4/6/09)

Comment Resolution 1 None.

2 3

4 5

Administrative JPM Outline (4/6/09)

Comment Resolution R&SA1: Ensure the QPTR calc is not It is not the same. This is manual calc.

1 duplicated in scenario 2, rod drop event.

Re-label: RO( A1a, RA2, RA3, RA4) Changed 2

SRO(A1a, SA2, SA3, SA4, SA5)

ES-301-1 and -2 are not the correct Resubmitted 3 revision: Resubmit with Rev. 9 Supplement 1 revision.

Do the tagout review in the classroom, Changed location.

4 not the simulator.

5 Control Room / In-Plant System JPM Outline (4/6/09)

Comment Resolution 1 Identify the RCA in-plant. (K) is in the RCA. Form corrected 2 JPM e. is ESF. (EN) Supp. 1 forms provided.

3 Re-Label: S1, S2,,S8, P1, P2, P3 Changed 4

5 Simulator Scenario Outline Comments (4/6/09)

Comment Resolution Transient and Event checklist identifies Scenario 4 is the backup. Will submit.

1 scenario 2 as the backup. Shouldnt this Backup submitted. Forms corrected. OBDI 202 - IOLE Process

be scenario 3?

T and E CL double counts the normal Corrected and reactivity evolutions for the BOP, ATC and CRS positions. There is only one or the other. The RO should get the 2 credit for Rx manipulation. The BOP and CRS should get NORMALS. If there is a component failure requiring a power change, then this can count as a Rx manipulation or I/C, but not both.

Scenario 1 Event 1: Critical task Changed 3

identified is not a critical task.

Scenario 2 Event 2: Critical task Changed 4

identified is not a critical task.

Scenarios 2 and 1 have a failure of a Removed pump failure on Scenario 2 5

CCP to Auto start. Change this.

Scenario 2: Start at 60% and raise Done 6

power to 65%.

(ALL) We will not grade the EP OK 7 declarations unless it is incorporated into an admin JPM.

8 (ALL) Reactivity manip credits incorrect Corrected (SB) Event 5 is not reactivity manip since Corrected 9

this is an auto power change.

ES-301-5 incorrect crediting for events A Corrected 10 and 3 for scenario 1 and 2 Scenario 3: Need to determine an actual Will be 30 percent.

11 spray valve failure amount - do not guess.

Schedule: R5 will have to stand watch on 3rd scenario per 1021, Rev. 9, Supp. 1. (Schedule changed)

Security Agreement: Where is the exam developer on the security agreement? (Security agreement provided) OBDI 202 - IOLE Process