ML082110458
| ML082110458 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Indian Point  |
| Issue date: | 07/24/2008 |
| From: | Rader R NRC/OGC |
| To: | Marlen Rodriguez, Wolfe C US Federal Judiciary, Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit |
| Robert Rader | |
| References | |
| 08-1454-AG | |
| Download: ML082110458 (9) | |
Text
OFFIC GENERA UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555-0001 E OF THE L COUNSEL July 24, 2008 Catherine O'Hagan Wolfe, Clerk United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit United States Court House 40 Foley Square New York, New York 10007 BY OVERNIGHT DELIVERY Attn: Maria Rodriguez Re: Brodsky v. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, No. 08-1454-ag
Dear Ms. Wolfe,
Pursuant to FRAP 16(a) and 17(b)(1)(B), I hereby submit the Certified Index of the Record for filing in this case. Enclosed please find the original and three copies.
Please date-stamp the extra copy of this letter to indicate date of filing and kindly return it to me in the enclosed postage pre-paid envelope at your convenience.
Thank you for your kind assistance.
Yours truly, Robert M. Rader Senior Attorney Office of the General Counsel Nuclear Regulatory Commission (301) 415-1955 (voice)
(301) 415-3200 (fax)
Robert. Rader(-nrc.gov (e-mail) cc: All Counsel by first-class mail, postage pre-paid, and by e-mail.
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
)
RICHARD L. BRODSKY, et al.,
))
Petitioners,
))
-V.
)
)
U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION) )DocketNo.
08--1454-AG
)
)
and
))
)
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
))
Respondents.
)
CERTIFIED INDEX OF THE RECORD I hereby certify that the documents listed and described below constitute the record for the administrative proceedings resulting in the issuance of "Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc., Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 3, LLC, Indian Point Nuclear Generating Unit No. 3; Revision to Existing Exemptions," Docket No. 50-286, published at 72 Fed. Reg. 56798 (Oct. 4, 2007), and the Commission's denial, by letter dated January 30, 2008, of petitioners' request for a hearing on the issuance of the aforementioned "Revision to Existing Exemptions," the two decisions that are the subject of the Petition for Review in this case.
Respectfully submitted, Annette L. Vietti-Cook Secretary of the Commission Dated at Rockville, Maryland this A3ttay of July 2008.
CERTIFIED INDEX OF THE RECORD BRODSKY, ET AL. v. U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Docket No. 08-1454-AG Thursday, July 24, 2008 ID DOCKET NO.
NUMBER DOCUMENT DATE ACCESSION NO.
PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION 1
50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 2
50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 EXEMPTION FROM SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS OF 10 CFR 50, APPENDIX R FOR INDIAN POINT UNIT 3 (ATTACHED TO 9/28/2007 LETTER FROM J. BOSKA, NRC TO M. BALDUZZI, ENTERGY AND PUBLISHED IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER AT 72 FED. REG. 56798 (OCTOBER 4, 2007) 18 PAGES INDIAN POINT UNIT NO. 3 -
ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT AND FINDING OF NO SIGNIFICANT IMPACT (ATTACHED TO 9/24/2007 LETTER FROM J. BOSKA, NRC TO M. BALDUZZI, ENTERGY AND PUBLISHED IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER AT 72 FED. REG. 55254 (SEPT. 28, 2007) 8 PAGES NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF SUSAN H. SHAPIRO 3 PAGES 09/28/2007 ML072410254 09/24/2007 ML072110018 3
50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 12/03/2007 ML081960375 I
ID NO.
DOCKET NUMBER DOCUMENT DATE ACCESSION NO.
PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION 4
50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 5
50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 REQUEST TO CHAIRMAN DALE KLEIN AND IG BY SUSAN SHAPIRO FOR THE COMMISSION TO WITHHOLD FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE PURPORTED SECURITY RELATED INFORMATION THAT ADDRESSED THE GRANT OF AN NRC EXEMPTION FOR IP3 FROM THE APPLICATION OF 10 CFR PART 50, APPENDIX R 2 PAGES OBJECTION TO GRANT OF EXEMPTION AND LICENSE AMENDMENT, PETITION TO REOPEN FOR CONSIDERATION, PETITION FOR LEAVE TO INTERVENE AND REQUEST FOR HEARING, AND CONTENTIONS, WITH SUPPORTING EXHIBITS AND THE FIRST DECLARATION OF ULRICH WITTE.
398 PAGES LETTER TO CHAIRMAN DALE KLEIN, NRC FROM S. SHAPIRO, REPRESENTING SEVERAL STAKEHOLDERS. THE LETTER TRANSMITTED A COMPACT DISC CONTAINING ITEMS 3,4 AND 5 ABOVE (APPEARANCE, REQUEST TO WITHHOLD DOCUMENTS, OBJECTION AND SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS) 1 PAGE 12/03/2007 ML081970234 12/03/2007 ML081960773 6
50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 12/04/2007 ML081210183 2
ID
'DOCKET NO.
NUMBER DOCUMENT DATE ACCESSION NO.
PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION 7
50-247/286 8
50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 INDIAN POINT 3 LETTER FROM ANNETTE VIETTI-COOK, SECRETARY OF THE COMMISSION, TO SUSAN SHAPIRO, ESQUIRE, DENYING HER OBJECTION AND HEARING.
REQUEST CONCERNING THE NRC GRANT OF AN EXEMPTION FOR INDIAN POINT UNIT 3 FROM THE COMMISSION'S FIRE PROTECTION STANDARDS I PAGE INFORMATION NOTICE 2005-07:
RESULTS OF HEMYC ELECTRICAL RACEWAY FIRE BARRIER SYSTEM FULL SCALE FIRE TESTING 8 PAGES GENERIC LETTER 2006-03:
POTENTIALLY NONCONFORMING HEMYC AND MT FIRE BARRIER CONFIGURATIONS 13 PAGES IP3 RESPONSE TO GL 2006-03 01/30/2008 04/01/2005 ML080300243 ML050890089 9
50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 04/10/2006 ML053620142 10 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 06/08/2006 ML061720091 12 PAGES 11 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 IP3 ORIGINAL SUBMISSION OF REQUEST FOR REVISION OF EXISTING EXEMPTIONS FROM IOCFR50, APPENDIX R FOR HEMYC ELECTRICAL RACEWAY FIRE BARRIER SYSTEM IN FIRE AREAS ETN-4 AND PAB-2 18 PAGES MEMO FROM DRA TO DORL SUBMITTING REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON IP3 EXEMPTION REQUEST 3 PAGES 07/24/2006 ML062140057 12 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 02/02/2007 ML070310544 3
ID DOCKET NO.
NUMBER DOCUMENT DATE ACCESSION NO.
PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION 13 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 14 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 15 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 16 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 LETTER FROM DORL TO ENTERGY REQUESTING ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON IP3 EXEMPTION REQUEST 6 PAGES IP3 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 7 PAGES IP3 SUPPLEMENT RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 10 PAGES IP3 SUPPLEMENT SUBMISSION OF REQUEST FOR REVISION OF EXISTING EXEMPTIONS FROM I OCFR50, APPENDIX R FOR HEMYC ELECTRICAL RACEWAY FIRE BARRIER SYSTEM IN FIRE AREAS ETN-4 AND PAB-2 11 PAGES MEMO FROM DRA TO DORL SUBMITTING THE FIRE PROTECTION SAFETY EVALUATION INPUT FOR IP3 EXEMPTION REQUEST 15 PAGES LETTER FROM DORL TO ENTERGY GRANTING EXEMPTION FOR IP3 REQUEST FOR REVISION OF EXISTING EXEMPTIONS FROM 10CFR50, APPENDIX R 18 PAGES 04/30/2007 ML071280504 03/15/2007 05/23/2007 ML071520177 ML070730309 08/16/2007 ML072400369 17 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 08/27/2007 ML072350095 18 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 09/28/2007 ML072410254 4
ID DOCKET NO.
NUMBER DOCUMENT DATE ACCESSION NO.
PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION 19 50-247/286 20 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 INDIAN POINT 3 21 50-247/286 22 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 INDIAN POINT 3 MEMO FROM RES TO NRR TO COMMUNICATE PRELIMINARY TEST RESULTS FOR THE HEMYC 1-HOUR RATED ELECTRICAL RACEWAY FIRE BARRIER SYSTEMS 9 PAGES FINAL REPORT OF HEMYC I-HOUR RATED CONDUIT AND JUNCTION BOX ELECTRICAL RACEWAY FIRE BARRIER SYSTEM PERFORMANCE TESTING 542 PAGES FINAL REPORT OF HEMYC 1-HOUR RATED CABLE TRAY, CABLE AIR DROP AND JUNCTION BOX ELECTRICAL RACEWAY FIRE BARRIER SYSTEM PERFORMANCE TESTING 522 PAGES MEMO FROM RES TO NRR TO PROVIDE TEST RESULTS FOR INDUSTRY-SPONSORED HEMYC 1-HOUR RATED ELECTRICAL RACEWAY FIRE BARRIER SYSTEMS 35 PAGES MEMO FROM RES TO NRR TO PROVIDE TEST RESULTS FOR INDUSTRY-SPONSORED HEMYC 1-HOUR RATED ELECTRICAL RACEWAY FIRE BARRIER SYSTEMS 24 PAGES ORIGINAL IP3 EXEMPTIONS FOR FIRE AREAS ETN-4 12 PAGES 03/28/2005 04/11/2005 ML050880176 ML051190046 04/18/2005 09/02/2005 ML051190096 ML052450387 23 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 11/22/2006 ML063260420 24 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 02/02/1984 LL8402170510 5
ID DOCKET NO.
NUMBER DOCUMENT DATE ACCESSION NO.
PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION 25 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 26 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 27 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 28 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 IP3 APPENDIX R FIRE PROTECTION PROGRAM DESCRIPTION WITH PROPOSED MODIFICATIONS 6 PAGES ORIGINAL IP2 EXEMPTIONS FOR FIRE AREA ETN-4 (FOR COMPARISON) 52 PAGES IP3 PROPOSED EXEMPTIONS FOR FIRE AREA ETN-4 13 PAGES ADDITIONAL IP3 EXEMPTIONS FOR FIRE AREA ETN-4 AND PAB-2 31 PAGES REGULATORY GUIDE 1.189, FIRE PROTECTION FOR NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS (REV. 1, MARCH 2007) 134 PAGES NUREG-0800, 9.5.1, STANDARD REVIEW PLAN, FIRE PROTECTION PROGRAM (REV. 5, MARCH 2007) 26 PAGES ASTM E 119-83, STANDARD METHODS OF FIRE TESTS OF BUILDING CONSTRUCTION AND MATERIALS 27 PAGES 09/19/1985' LL8509300292 08/16/1984 10/16/1984 LL8408230164 LL8410290219 0 1/07/1987 LL8701140391 29 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 03/28/2007 ML070370183 30 50-247/286 31 50-247/286 INDIAN POINT 3 INDIAN POINT 3 03/23/2007 ML063190014 07/01/1983 6