ML072980763
| ML072980763 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Oyster Creek |
| Issue date: | 10/22/2007 |
| From: | Kuyler R AmerGen Energy Co, Exelon Corp, Morgan, Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP |
| To: | Abramson P, Anthony Baratta, Hawkens E Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| SECY RAS | |
| References | |
| 50-219-LR, ASLBP 06-844-01-LR, RAS 14486 | |
| Download: ML072980763 (17) | |
Text
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD Before Administrative Judges:
E. Roy Hawkens, Chair Dr. Paul B. Abramson Dr. Anthony J. Baratta
)
In the Matter of. ) October 22, 2007 AmerGen Energy Company, LLC )
) Docket No. 50-219 (License Renewal for Oyster Creek Nuclear )
Generating Station) )
)
AMERGEN'S MOTION FOR TRANSCRIPT CORRECTIONS In accordance with the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board's ("Board") Order at the September 25, 2007 evidentiary hearing, AmerGen Energy Company, LLC submits the following transcript corrections for the Board's approval.' For ease of review, AmerGen has combined its corrections with those of the NRC Staff.Z A. September 24, 2007 Page No. Line No. Correction 3 8 Add "Julien Abramovici, Jon Cavallo, Scott Erickson, Barry Gordon, Dr. David Harlow, Jon Hawkins, Edwin Hosterman, Martin McAllister, Ahmed Ouaou, Francis Ray, Peter Tamburro, Dr. Hardayal Mehta" 3 9 Change "Hans" to "Hansraj", "Asher" to "Ashar", insert "Dr.", change "Jim" to "James" and "Mark" before "Hartzman" Pursuant to the 10 C.F.R. § 2.323(b) and the Board's October 3, 2007 Order (Ruling on Joint Motion for an Extension of Time to File Transcript Corrections) at 1, AmerGen e-mailed the proposed changes to the NRC Staff and Citizens for their concurrence. Citizens agree with these changes. The Staff has not commented.
Italicized changes indicate proposed changes already submitted by the Staff. AmerGen was unable to combine its corrections with those of Citizens because of time limitations.
1-WA/2832864
Page No. Line No. Correction 5 8 Change "Jay" to "Roy" 5 25 Change "Judges" to "judges" 6 24 Change "Subpart (1)" to "SubpartL" 6 25 Change "Subpart ()" to "SubpartL" 7 17 Change "Judges" to "judges" 11 7 Change "mics" to "mikes" 11 23 Delete "Gary Harlow" 11 23 Change "John" to "Jon" 12 10 Change "Saloman" to "Salomon" 23 21 Change "Honor" to "your Honor" 24 14 Change "occurrence" to "recurrence" 25 18 Change "it is" to "its" 28 11 Delete "corrosion during" 29 10 Change the 2nd "It is" to "And" 29 11 Change "environment. It" to "environment, it" 29 21 Change "margin" to "margins" 30 10 Change "odd number" to "odd-numbered" 31 3 Change "queer" to "clear" 31 9 Change "manipulates" to "manipulate" 31 14 Change "make inference" to "make an inference" 37 4 Change "ha" to "has" 37 24 Change "Hausman's" to "Hartzman's" 1-WA/2832864 2
Page No. Line No. Correction 44 22 Change "insure" to "ensure" 45 4 Change "board" to "Board"
.45 19 Change "Judge" to "judge" 46 25 Change "Asher" to "Ashar" 47 1 Change "MR. POLONSKY" to "MR. WEBSTER" 53 4 Change "if yo usee" to "if you see" 59 6 Change "insure" to "ensure" 59 7 Change "insure" to "ensure" 61 5 Change "agreed" to "agree" and "bag" to "bundle" 61 22 Delete the word "except" 62 23 Change "refueling the wood" to "refueling mode" 66 16 Change "is" to "it" 69 18 Change "1,154" to "1.154" 71 5 Change "imbedded" to "embedded" 71 6 Change "pour" to "pore" 73 22 Change "age" to "page" 78 4 Change "Susan's counsel" to "Citizens' counsel" 79 7 Change "nota"to "not a" 80 18 Change "sine" to "since" 82 6 Change "Garrett" to "Gary" 82 7 Change "John" to "Jon" 82 8. Change to "Harmetta" to "Har Mehta" I-WA/2832864 3
Page No. Line No. Correction 82 8 Change "Wo" to "Ouaou" 84 15 Change "Hauser" to "Hausler" 91 25 Change "saving" to "saying" 92 1 Change "curve" to "curb" 92 19 Change "thank" to "Thank" 93 2 Change "Base" to "Bay" 93 20 Change "Mr. Tibler," to "MR. TAMBURRO:"
95 24 Change "curve" to "curb" 99 19 Change "Ashray" to "ASHRAE" 101 19 Change "MR. POLONSKY" to "JUDGEABRAMSON" 103 2 Delete "the are would be" 106 17 Change "out" to "output" 112 2 Change "sine" to "since" 112 15 Change "radway system" to "radwaste system" 115 24 Change "Soloman" to "Salomon" 116 12 Insert "no" between "have" and "objection" 118 7 Change "Baratta" to "Abramson" 119 23 Change "Amergen" to AmerGen" 119 13 Change "the third solution" to "the theoretical solution" 121 11 Change "eery" to "every" 124 7 Change "M284" to "N-284" 125 7 Change "so-call CALC" to "so-called Calc" 1-WA/2832864 .4
Page No. Line No. Correction 126 13 Change "transmitter" to "transmitted" 129 7 Change "thought" to "though" 1'30 21 Change "worse" to "worst" 131 5 Change "days" to "bays" 132 4 Change "wold" to "would" 132 8 Change "WILLIAMS" to "WEBSTER" 136 24 Change "were put" to "were to put" 138 18 Change ".53 76" to ".536" 138 18 Change "conditioned" to "transitioned".
140 17 Change "the schedule" to "our review" 140 18 Change ", " to ". " Capitalize the "b" in "but" 140 19 Change "20.424" to "Calculation 140 23 Insert "criteria",after "CLB" 141 9 Change "cap 24" to "Calc 24" 145 18 Change "no" to "yes" 146 7 Change ".09" to ".490" 146 8 Change "is" to "as" 146 20 Change "could" to "would" 147 23 Change "TDR1 108" to "TDR 1108" 147 24 Change "Applicant" to "Applicant's" 150 1 Change "corrosions" to "corrosion" 150 20 Change "Dr." to "Mr."
I-WA/2832864 5
Page No. Line No. Correction 157 18 Insert "a" between "with" and "well" Change ". " to ",'"
157 19 Insert "and" and change "A to "a"
.158 4 Change 'fact" to 'factor" 158 6 Change "cast" to ."case" 158 7 Change "determine" to "determined" 160 20 Change "understands" to "understand" 164 7 Change "third typically" to "theoretically" 164 8 Change "the use a capacity of' to "they use a capacity" 164 10 Change "in Factor 5" to "a factor of 5" 165 1 Change ".563" to ".536" 165 22 Change "need for construction" to "construction" 165 25 Change ".04" to ".204" 170 9 Change "mature properties, although the mature" to "material properties, although the material" 171 4 Change "as built" to "as-built" 172 8 Change'. to 172 9 Delete "it is" 172 11 Change "into the analysis of the as built, of the as built" to "into the analysis of the as-built, of the as-built" 172 20 Change "call" to "recall" 172 22 Change "evaluations" to '.'evaluation" 175 23 Change .. to 175 24 Change "Even to "even and insert ", after "better' I-WA/2832864 .6
Page No. Line No. Correction 176 6-7 Change "with a curve" to "would occur" 177 3 Delete "were" and the "." after "Citizens" 177 16 Change "I" to "In" 178 16 Insert "," after "two" and change "For" to 'for" 178 18 Insert ", after "along" 178 19 Change "The" to "the" 178 20 Change "2.736" to "to 0.736" 180 8 Delete ", "after "two" and change "For" to "for" 180 10 Insert ", "after "along'"and change "The" to "the" 180. 12 Change "2. 736" to "to 0. 736" 182 13 Change "was" to "is" 191 21 Change "cap" to "Calc" 192 11 Change "depending of' to "depicting" 192 18 Change "then" to "thin" 198 1 Change "B" to "19B" 198 3 Change ".10" to "Point 10" 198 17 Change "on one incentives" to "in one inspection" 199 15 Change "mls." to "mils."
199 16 Change "mls." to "mils."
208 11 Change "bag" to "bed" 237 5 Change "2206" to "2.206" 237 8 Change 'fitting" to "thinning" I-WA/2832864 7
Page No. Line No. Correction 266 5 Change "mil" to "mils" 268 13 Change "dry wall" to "drywell" 268 15 Change "bias" to "biased" 268 16 Change '"bias" to "biased" 271 3 Change "coded", to '.'coated" 271 5 Change "removing the sand bed," to "removing the sand,"
271 24 Change "round"to "ground".
272 2 Change "bed" to "bay" 274 17 Insert ". "after "model" 278 9 Change "ACR"to "ACRS" 287 7 Change "upper" to "EPRI" 287 10 Change "upper" to "EPRI" 291 25 Change "days" to "bays" 292 23 Change "MR. FP" to "MR. POLASKI" 294 9 Change "but" to "what" 302 25 Insert "talk" after "could" 302 25 Change "through" to "about" 303 1 Change "there's a" to "it's" 303 6 Change "Per" to "In" 303 12 Insert "Calc" after "to" 303 22 Delete "D" 305 4 Change "John" to "Jon" I -WA/2832864 8
Page No. Line No. Correction 305 5 Change "Hawkens" to "Hawkins" 305 8 Change "Hawkens" to "Hawkins" 305 10 Change "HA WKENS: My name is John Hawkens" to "HA WKINS: My name is Jon Hawkins" 305 25 Change "HA WKENS" to "HA WKINS" 306 4 Change "HA WKENS" to "HAWKINS'"
306 8 Change "stand" to "scan" 306 24 Change "Mr. Hawkens" to "Mr. Hawkins" 307 3 Change "HA WKENS" to "HAWKINS" 307 12 Change "HAWKENS" to "HAWKINS" 307 19 Change "HA WKENS" to "HA WKINS" 307 25 Change ,Hawkens" to "Hawkins" 308 25 Change '"'is that" to "that is" 309 9 Delete "We're developing codes nowl But I can think -"
309 20 Change "fitness" to "thickness" 315 14 Change "day" to "bay" 316 8 Change "thee" to "there" 318 7 Change "UTED" to "UT'd" 320 20 Change "shelf' to "shell" 321 9 Change "worry" to "sorry" 321 17 Change "fills" to 'fails" 324 25 Change "FP" to "POLASKI" I-WA/2832864 9
Page No. Line No. Correction 326 9 Change "what" to "with" 326 16 Change "FP" to "POLASKI" 326 18 Delete "ring" 328 1 Change "take" to "took" 328 2 Change "drywall" to "drywell" 328 13 Insert "." after "recall" 328 13 Change "having" to "Having" 328 16 Change "FP" to "POLASKI" 329 9 Change "FP" to,"POLASKI" 329 12 Change "FP" to "POLASKI" 329 13 Change "MR. POLONSKY" to "CHAIRMAN HAWKENS" 329 15 Change "FP" to "POLASKI" 329 23 Change "636" to "736" 330 4 Change "FP" to "POLASKI" B. September 25, 2007 Page No. Line No. Correction 345 25 Change "ACR" to "ACRS" 347 1 Change "establish corrosion" to "establish a corrosion" 348 25 Change "the" to "one" 349 10 Change "area" to "error" 352 19 Change "that" to "at" I-WA/2832864 10
Page No. Line No. Correction 354 5 Change "NPY" to "MPY" 367 17 Change "a thin site" to "the thin side" 368 25 Change "Hawkens" to "Hawkins" 370 21 Change "Carbon" to "current" 370 23 Change "taking" to "taken" 377 25 Change "HARLOW" to "HAUSLER" 380 18 Delete 'feature" and after "the" insert 'future analysis to be" 381 21 Change "fire" to "finite" 383 19 Change "computer" to "compute" 383 20 Change "inspeculative" to "speculative" 384 8 Change "they" to "the" 385 3 Change "asymmetry" to "any symmetry" 387 8 Change "13.7" to "13, Point 7" 393 1I Change "valued" to "value" 398 2 Change "variant" to "variate" 398 4 Change "reduce to "reduced" and "variant" to "variate" 401 1 Change "a lamination is allowed a not exceed" to "a lamination is not allowed to exceed."
402 7 Change "When" to "What" 402 9 Change "SA212" to SA-212" 402 10 Insert "." after "inclusions" 402 10 Change "if' to "If' I-WA/2832864 I1I
Page No. Line No. Correction 402 11 Insert "," after "material"; and replace "You" with "you" 403 4 Change "minimally" to "minimum" 403 6 Change "delamiantions" to "delaminations" 406 24 Change "trend" to "trench" 407 14 Change "that" to "that's" 407 15 Change "with -" to "with concrete,"
407 24 Change "bonding" to "bounding" 408 2 Change "bonding" to "bounding" 408 12 Change "10.3 inches" to "10 feet, 3 inches" 408 16 Delete "11 feet -"
420 8 Change "seal" to "sealed" 420 15 Change "yews" to "yes" 420 15 Change "yews" to "yes" 422 10 Change "and" to "in" 426 22 Change the word "uncoded, the upper drywell is uncoded" to "uncoated,the upper drywell is uncoated" 426 \ 25 Change "activity" to "cavity" 431 22-23 Change "is now referredto damage in Exhibit 7" to "AmerGen Exhibit 7" 432 20 Delete "A)"
432 21 Change "is" to "Is" 433 10 Change "frequency.," to "frequency,"
433 11 Change "side" to "slide" 1-WA/2832864 12
Page No. Line No. Correction 433 17 Change "MR. POLONSKY" to "DR. HAUSLER" 433 21 Change "MR. HAUSLER" to "UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER" 434 7 Change "MR. POLONSKY" to "UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER" 435 3 Change "created" to "credited" 444 13 Change "was" to "were" 447 16 Change "bet" to "be" 448 23 Change "Erickson" to "Erickson,"
450 9 Change "UT-]" TO "VT-]"
453 19 Change "Electrocar" to "Electric" 453 20 Change "Electricitas" to "tlectricit6" 456 18 Delete "not" 456 23 Change "-" to "testimony" 458 12 Insert "less" between "much" and "likely" 465 12 Change "SILVERMAN" to "POLONSKY" 467 18 Change "That" to "An" 467 21 Change "pre-fire" to "pre-filed" 470 7 Change "and" to "in" 470 8 Change "sent that back in" to "the sand bed region" 470 9 Insert "6 inches" after "about" 470 10 Change "before" to "on the floor" 470 16 Insert "it" after "having" I-WA/2832864 13
Page No. Line No. Correction 470 17 Change "the" to "The" 470 19 Change "live" to "vibration".
474 15 Change "pre-file" to "pre-filed" 475 3 Change "pre-file" to "pre-filed" 7
475 Change "applauded" to "applaud it" 477 18 Change "cold" to "Code" 477 19 Change "cold" to "Code" 486 13 Change "the" to "The" 486 14 Change "as built" to "as-built" 486 25 Change "we haven't answered it" to "we have it answered" 490 2 Change "flaw" to "floor" 497 19 Change "pour" to "pore" 501 3 Change "HAWKENS" to "ABRAMSON" 505 12 Change "5rd" to "Firebar-D" 505 16 Change "5rd" to "Firebar-D" 509 15 Change "reaction" to "reactions" 519 22 Change "answering" to "answer" 522 8 Insert "I" after "May" 533 23 Change "buffering" to "buckling" 535 13 Change "currently" to "current" 543 11 Change "Amergen" to "AmerGen" 544 13 Change "Amergen" to "AmerGen" I-WA/2832864 14
Page No. Line No. Correction 552 17 Change "intervener" to "intervenors"'
553 13 Change "Amergen's" to "AmerGen' s" 555 22 Change "Amergen" to "AmerGen"
.565 20 Change "part" to "path" 570 19 Change "iterate" to "interact" 572 18 Change "done the" to "done with the" 586 4 Change "LOCA" to "local" 586 8 Change "LOCA" to "local" 586 12 Change "competence" to "confidence" 586 15 Change "competence" to "confidence" 586 24 Change "competence" to "confidence" 587 2. Change "competence" to "confidence" 587 9 Change "competence" to "confidence" 587 11 Change "competence" to "confidence" 590 19 Change "competence" to "confidence" 590 21 Change "competence" to "confidence" 592 14 Change "NRC staff" to "CHAIRMAN HAWKINS" 593 3 -Change "criterion" to "criteria" 593 6 Change "misunderstand" to "misunderstanding" 593 15 Change "LOCA" to "local" 593 17 Change "LOCA criterion, LOCA" to "local criterion, local" 593 20 Change "center 536 surrounded" to "center of 536 mils surrounded" I-WA/2832864 15
Page No. Line No. Correction 593 23 Change "LOCA" to "local" 594 1 Change "Amergen" to AmerGen" 594 3 Change "LOCA" to "local" 594 6 Change "LOCA" to "local" 594 18 Change "present" to "prevent" 595 22 Change "from" to "for" 596 11 Change "contour of' to "contours have" 596 18 Change "behind" to "beyond" 597 13 Change "pressured" to "pressurized" 598 4 Change "prefile" to "prefiled" 598 7 Change "goal and every" to "GALL and EPRI" 598 10 Change "Citizens" to "Citizens"'
598 20 Change "prefile" to "prefiled" 598 23 Change "entire year. The" to "entire year, which" 598 24 Change "it's" to "as" 599 12 Change "LOCA" to "local" 599 15 Change "LOCA" to "local" I-WA/2832864 16
599 16 Change "seven" to "736" Respectfully submitted,
/onaldf Silverman, Esq.
Kathr'n M. Sutton, Esq.
Alex S. Polonsky, Esq.
Raphael P. Kuyler, Esq.
MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Washington, DC 20004 Phone: (202) 739-5502 dsilverman(morganlewis.com ksuttongmorganlewis.com apolonskygmorganlewis.com rkuyler(2morganlewis.com J. Bradley Fewell, Esq.
Associate General Counsel Exelon Corporation 4300 Warrenville Road Warrenville, IL 60555 Phone: (630) 657-3769 Bradley.Fewell@exeloncorp.com Dated in Washington, D.C. COUNSEL FOR AMERGEN ENERGY this 22nd day of October 2007. COMPANY, LLC I-WA/2832864 17