ML072070145

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Summary of June 27, 2007, Public Meeting Regarding Fenoc'S Re-analysis of the Time Line and Root Causes for the 2002 Davis-Besse Reactor Pressure Vessel Head Degradation Event
ML072070145
Person / Time
Site: Beaver Valley, Davis Besse, Perry
Issue date: 08/07/2007
From: Thomas Wengert
NRC/NRR/ADRO/DORL/LPLA
To:
Wengert, Thomas J, NRR/DORL, 415-4037
Shared Package
ML072070184 List:
References
FOIA/PA-2007-0299
Download: ML072070145 (12)
v • d • e


Text

August 7, 2007 LICENSEE: FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company (FENOC)

FACILITIES: Beaver Valley Power Station, Unit Nos. 1 and 2; Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, Unit No. 1; and Perry Nuclear Power Plant, Unit No. 1

SUBJECT:

SUMMARY

OF JUNE 27, 2007, PUBLIC MEETING REGARDING FENOCS RE-ANALYSIS OF THE TIME LINE AND ROOT CAUSES FOR THE 2002 DAVIS-BESSE REACTOR PRESSURE VESSEL HEAD DEGRADATION EVENT On June 27, 2007, a Category 1 public meeting was held between the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) senior staff and representatives of FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company (FENOC) at NRC Headquarters, One White Flint North, 11555 Rockville Pike, Rockville, Maryland. The purpose of the meeting was to discuss FENOCs June 13, 2007, response to the NRCs May 14, 2007, Demand for Information (DFI) concerning FENOCs re-analysis of the time line and root causes for the 2002 Davis-Besse reactor pressure vessel head degradation event.

The NRC staff issued the May 14, 2007, DFI to determine whether further enforcement action was necessary to provide reasonable assurance that FENOC would continue to operate its licensed facilities in accordance with the terms of its license and the Commissions regulations.

The DFI required FENOC to provide detailed information regarding the process used to evaluate the report developed by Exponent Failure Analysis Associates and Altran Solutions Corporation (Exponent Report), a detailed discussion of the differences between the operational data underpinning FENOCs earlier root cause reports and the assumptions underpinning the Exponent Report, and a position on whether FENOC endorsed the conclusions of a second contractor report prepared in connection with an associated insurance claim.

A list of principal meeting participants is provided as Enclosure 1. A list of meeting attendees is provided as Enclosure 2. The licensees presentation can be found in the NRCs Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS) at Accession No. ML071790596. The NRCs meeting handout materials can be found in ADAMS under Accession Nos.

ML071240254, ML071340333, ML071340325, ML071640480, and ML071710346.

The NRC senior staff opened the meeting by stating the purposes of the meeting, as follows:

(1) To discuss FENOCs response to the NRCs May 14, 2007, Demand For Information (DFI). Specifically, to understand the timing of FENOCs review of the Exponent Report, and the factors FENOC considered when determining if the conclusions of the report should be communicated to the NRC.

(2) To understand what lessons FENOC learned when they were preparing the response to the DFI, and what actions FENOC has taken and plans to take to address these lessons learned.

(3) To understand FENOCs position regarding a second contracted report that was prepared for FENOC entitled, Report on Reactor Pressure Vessel Wastage at the Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Plant, dated December 2006 (Mattson Report).

The NRC also provided some background on the events that led to the NRCs issuance of the DFI and the public meeting. A summary of the background is contained in the DFI document found in ADAMS under Accession No. ML071340333.

The licensees presentation to the NRC senior staff addressed the three elements of the NRCs May 14, 2007, DFI. The presentation included a description of the time line of events from when FENOC received the Exponent and Mattson Reports in December 2006, to FENOCs June 13, 2007, DFI response; FENOCs initial consideration of the Exponent Report; FENOCs consideration of the NRCs April 2, 2007, request for information, and their May 2, 2007, response; a summary of FENOCs analysis of the Exponent and Mattson Reports, and the differences noted between the Exponent Report and the root cause reports; and identification of commitments FENOC intends to make to address the issues raised during their review of the Exponent and Mattson Reports.

The licensee acknowledged that their initial review of the Exponent Report lacked sensitivity to the regulatory interest and that their commercial and nuclear processes did not sufficiently interface during their review of the report.

At various times during the presentation, the NRC staff queried the licensee about aspects of the DFI response and the content of their presentation. The NRC acknowledged the licensees commitments to develop a process to review reports prepared for commercial matters, to provide operational experience to industry, to improve their NRC correspondence procedure, to assess their Regulatory Communications policy, and to develop lessons learned from their May 2, 2007, response to the NRC. The NRC staff is considering further regulatory actions with regard to these commitments.

Several members of the public were in attendance and others participated via teleconference.

Some members of the public asked questions of the NRC staff after the conclusion of the business portion of the meeting.

One member of the public asked the NRC what the next steps in the process would be. The NRC responded that FENOC needs to make the changes they have described, and that the NRC will need to determine if the corrective actions identified are necessary and sufficient.

One Public Meeting Feedback form was received following the meeting, which consisted of the following:

As indicated on the June 13th meeting notice, meeting categories are defined in a document dated May 28, 2002, in the Federal Register. Why doesnt it also refer to an ADAMS document, like the May 21, 2002, Policy Statement (Accession No. ML021350492) such that a person can stay within the NRC document system instead of having to refer to an outside document system, in order to find the information about the meeting categories?

This comment has been forwarded to the NRR Senior Communications Analyst for action.

Please direct any inquiries to me at 301-415-4037, or tjw2@nrc.gov.

/RA/

Thomas J. Wengert, Project Manager Plant Licensing Branch LPLIII-2 Division of Operating Reactor Licensing Office of Nuclear Reactor Docket Nos. 50-334, 50-412, 50-346, and 50-440

Enclosures:

1. List of Principal Meeting Participants
2. List of Attendees cc w/encls: See next page

This comment has been forwarded to the NRR Senior Communications Analyst for action.

Please direct any inquiries to me at 301-415-4037, or tjw2@nrc.gov.

/RA/

Thomas J. Wengert, Project Manager Plant Licensing Branch LPLIII-2 Division of Operating Reactor Licensing Office of Nuclear Reactor Docket Nos. 50-334, 50-412, 50-346, and 50-440

Enclosure:

1. List of Principal Meeting Participants
2. List of Attendees cc w/encls: See next page DISTRIBUTION:

PUBLIC C. Carpenter,OE LPL3-2 R/F W. Kane, OEDO RidsNrrDorlLpl3-2 J. Caldwell, RIII RidsNrrPMTWengert S. Collins, RI RidsNrrLAEWhitt L. Chandler, OGC RidsOgcRp J. Dyer, NRR RidsAcrsAcnwMailCenter RidsNrrDorlLPL1-1 R. Jasinski, NRR J. Lamb, EDO Region I RidsNrrAdro T. Bloomer, EDO Region III RidsNrrDorl RidsRgn1MailCenter RidsEdoMailCenter RidsRgn3MailCenter RidsNrrDci RidsNrrAdes LPL1-1 R/F Package Accession No. ML072070184 Summary Accession No. ML072070145 Meeting Notice Accession No. ML071710346 Licensees Slides Accession No. ML071790596 NRC Assessment of Exponent Report Accession No. ML071240254 NRC DFI Accession No. ML071340333 NRC DFI Letter Accession No. ML071340325 FENOC Response to DFI Accession No. ML071640480 NRC-001 OFFICE LPL3-2/PM LPL3-2/LA DCI/CPNB OE/D LPL3-2/BC NAME TWengert EWhitt TChan CCarpenter RGibbs DATE 8/7/07 8/7/07 8 / 2 /07 8 /1 /07 8/7/07 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY

LIST OF PRINCIPAL MEETING PARTICIPANTS PUBLIC MEETING REGARDING FIRSTENERGY NUCLEAR OPERATING COMPANYS RE-ANALYSIS OF THE TIME LINE AND ROOT CAUSES FOR THE 2002 DAVIS-BESSE REACTOR PRESSURE VESSEL HEAD DEGRADATION EVENT JUNE 27, 2007 9:00 AM - 12:30 PM Nuclear Regulatory Commission C. Carpenter, Director, Office of Enforcement W. Kane, Deputy Executive Director, Office of the Executive Director for Operations J. Caldwell, Regional Administrator, Region III S. Collins, Regional Administrator, Region I J. Dyer, Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation L. Chandler, Associate General Counsel, Office of the General Counsel FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company G. Leidich, FirstEnergy Senior Vice President - Operations J. Hagan, President and Chief Nuclear Officer D. Pace, Senior Vice President, Fleet Engineering G. Halnon, Director, Fleet Regulatory Affairs C. Price, Director, Performance Improvement, Davis-Besse J. Powers, Director, Fleet Engineering Enclosure 1

LIST OF ATTENDEES PUBLIC MEETING REGARDING FIRSTENERGY NUCLEAR OPERATING COMPANYS RE-ANALYSIS OF THE TIME LINE AND ROOT CAUSES FOR THE 2002 DAVIS-BESSE REACTOR PRESSURE VESSEL HEAD DEGRADATION EVENT JUNE 27, 2007 9:00 AM - 12:30 PM NAME AFFILIATION

1. A. Rueangvivatanakij NEI
2. D. Johnson NEI
3. J. Rinckel FENOC
4. R. Reffner FENOC
5. T. Schneider FirstEnergy
6. E. Anderson FENOC
7. S. Sands NRC/NRR/DORL/LPL3-2
8. D. Pace FENOC
9. J. Gutierrez FENOC
10. J. Lieberman Talisman
11. G. Halnon FENOC
12. T. Matthews MLB
13. J. Schmutz ML&B
14. D. Jenkins FENOC
15. S. Eaton The Plain Dealer
16. J. Powers FENOC
17. A. Ireland NRC/RES
18. J. Kaizer NRC/ACRS
19. R. Anzalone NRC/DSS/SNPB
20. W. Jessup NRC/NRR
21. C. Carpenter NRC/RES
22. G. Caputo NRC/OI
23. J. Fitzgerald NRC/OI
24. G. Gulla NRC/NRO
25. B. Garde Clifford and Garde
26. S. Shepherd Clifford and Garde
27. T. Kellum NRC/DIRS
28. T. Houghton NEI
29. K. Klump NRC/DIRS
30. A. Zogrates NRC/NRR/DE Enclosure 2

LIST OF ATTENDEES (CONTINUED)

NAME AFFILIATION

31. T. Hedigan NRC/NRR/DIRS
32. A. Turlin NRC/NRO/DE
33. J. Davis NRC/NRR/DLR
34. A. Valentin NRC/RES
35. B. Cullen NRC/RES
36. M. Srinivasan NRC/RES
37. K. Hall FirstEnergy
38. P. Pettey Williams & Jensen
39. D. McIntyre NRC/OPA
40. J. Cai NRC/OE
41. A. Powell NRC/OCA
42. T. Steingass NRC/NRR
43. L. Regner NRC/NRR
44. M. Cash NRC/OIG
45. R. Laufer NRC/OEDO
46. H. Nieh NRC/NRR
47. D. Solorio NRC/OE
48. K. Cyr NRC/OGC
49. J. Beall NRC
50. D. Starkey NRC/OE
51. C. Gratton NRC/DORL
52. E. Duncan NRC/RIII
53. B. Burgess NRC/RIII
54. T. Wengert NRC/DORL
55. D. Horner Platts/McGraw-Hill
56. M. Fahey NRC/OI
57. S. Hackworth NRC/OI
58. R. Haemer Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman
59. D. Zaslowsky Baker & McKenzie
60. J. Grobe NRC
61. B. Bateman NRC
62. J. Collins NRC
63. D. Persinko NRC
64. M. Evans NRC/NRR/DCI
65. S. Lee NRC/OCM
66. T. Mensah NRC/NRR/PSPB
67. T. Hibschman NRC
68. P. Gunter NIRS
69. T. Henry The Blade
70. U. Shoop NRC

LIST OF ATTENDEES (CONTINUED)

NAME AFFILIATION

71. D. Terao NRC
72. T. Campbell NRC
73. R. Anderson* FENOC
74. S. Arndt* Ottawa County Commissioner
75. B. Beach* Consultant
76. M. Beiting* FirstEnergy Corp.
77. D. Ferraro* Member of the public
78. S. Focht* ANI
79. J. Funk* The Plain Dealer
80. J. Goebel* Indian Point
81. J. Greer* Ottawa County Emergency Mngt.
82. T. Griesbach* Structural Integrity
83. T. Gurdziel* Private Investor
84. H. Hegrat* FENOC
85. S. Helmer* OH Department of Health
86. R. Janati* PA Department of Protection
87. M. Kaplan* Congresswoman Marcy Kaptur
88. S. Langan* NRC
89. Y. Leidorf* Executive Assistant
90. M. Leisure* FENOC
91. J. Mangels* The Plain Dealer
92. K. Meade* FirstEnergy
93. R. Miller* House of Rep.
94. J. Nelson* DTE
95. K. Nesser* FirstEnergy
96. C. OClaire* OH Emergency Management
97. J. Penny* Law Firm Killiam & Gephart
98. H. Robinson* Gordon & Ermer
99. J. Rogers* FENOC 100. J. Rutkowski* NRC 101. K. Schaefer* WKSU 102. J. Schultz* FENOC 103. L. Strauss* FENOC 104. R. Strauss* FirstEnergy 105. J. Sturdavant* FirstEnergy 106. K. Turosky* FirstEnergy Corp.

107. S. West* NRC Region 3 108. M. Wilk* NRC 109. J. Young* FirstEnergy

  • participated via teleconference

Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1 cc:

Manager, Site Regulatory Compliance Attorney General FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company Office of Attorney General Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station 30 East Broad Street Mail Stop A-DB-3065 Columbus, OH 43216 5501 North State Route 2 Oak Harbor, OH 43449-9760 President, Board of County Commissioners of Ottawa County Director, Ohio Department of Commerce Port Clinton, OH 43252 Division of Industrial Compliance Bureau of Operations & Maintenance President, Board of County 6606 Tussing Road Commissioners of Lucas County P.O. Box 4009 One Government Center, Suite 800 Reynoldsburg, OH 43068-9009 Toledo, OH 43604-6506 Regional Administrator, Region III The Honorable Dennis J. Kucinich U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission United States House of Representatives Suite 210 Washington, D.C. 20515 2443 Warrenville Road Lisle, IL 60532-4352 The Honorable Dennis J. Kucinich United States House of Representatives Resident Inspector 14400 Detroit Avenue U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Lakewood, OH 44107 5503 North State Route 2 Oak Harbor, OH 43449-9760 Joseph J. Hagan President and Chief Nuclear Officer Stephen Helmer FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company Supervisor, Technical Support Section Mail Stop A-GO-14 Bureau of Radiation Protection 76 South Main Street Ohio Department of Health Akron, OH 44308 35 East Chestnut Street, 7th Floor Columbus, OH 43215 David W. Jenkins, Attorney FirstEnergy Corporation Carol OClaire, Chief, Radiological Branch Mail Stop A-GO-15 Ohio Emergency Management Agency 76 South Main Street 2855 West Dublin Granville Road Akron, OH 44308 Columbus, OH 43235-2206 Danny L. Pace Zack A. Clayton Senior Vice President, Fleet Engineering DERR FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company Ohio Environmental Protection Agency Mail Stop A-GO-14 P.O. Box 1049 76 South Main Street Columbus, OH 43266-0149 Akron, OH 44308 State of Ohio Manager, Fleet Licensing Public Utilities Commission FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company 180 East Broad Street Mail Stop A-GO-2 Columbus, OH 43266-0573 76 South Main Street Akron, OH 44308

Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1 Perry Nuclear Power Plant, Unit No. 1 cc: cc:

Director, Fleet Regulatory Affairs Resident Inspector's Office FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop A-GO-2 P.O. Box 331 76 South Main Street Perry, OH 44081-0331 Akron, OH 44308 Sue Hiatt Jeannie M. Rinckel OCRE Interim Representative Vice President, Fleet Oversight 8275 Munson FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company Mentor, OH 44060 Mail Stop A-GO-14 76 South Main Street Manager, Site Regulatory Compliance Akron, OH 44308 FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company Perry Nuclear Power Plant Richard Anderson Mail Stop A-PY-A200 Vice President, Nuclear Support P.O. Box 97, 10 Center Road FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company Perry, OH 44081-0097 Mail Stop A-GO-14 76 South Main Street Mayor, Village of North Perry Akron, OH 44308 North Perry Village Hall 4449 Lockwood Road Mark B. Bezilla North Perry Village, OH 44081 Site Vice President FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company Donna Owens, Director Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station Ohio Department of Commerce Mail Stop A-DB-3080 Division of Industrial Compliance 5501 North State, Route 2 Bureau of Operations & Maintenance Oak Harbor, OH 43449-9760 6606 Tussing Road P.O. Box 4009 James H. Lash Reynoldsburg, OH 43068-9009 Senior Vice President of Operations and Chief Operating Officer Mayor, Village of Perry FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company P.O. Box 100 Mail Stop A-GO-14 Perry, OH 44081-0100 76 South Main Street Akron, OH 44308 Chairman Perry Township Board of Trustees 3750 Center Road, Box 65 Perry, OH 44081

Perry Nuclear Power Plant, Unit No. 1 Beaver Valley Power Station, Unit Nos. 1 and 2 cc:

cc:

Daniel Z. Fisher Transportation Department Manager, Site Regulatory Compliance Public Utilities Commission FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company 180 East Broad Street Beaver Valley Power Station Columbus, OH 43215-3793 Mail Stop A-BV-A P.O. Box 4, Route 168 Barry S. Allen Shippingport, PA 15077 Site Vice President FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company Commissioner James R. Lewis Perry Nuclear Power Plant West Virginia Division of Labor Mail Stop A-PY-A290 749-B, Building No. 6 P.O. Box 97, 10 Center Road Capitol Complex Perry, OH 44081-0097 Charleston, WV 25305 Director, Utilities Department Public Utilities Commission 180 East Broad Street Columbus, OH 43266-0573 Director, Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency 2605 Interstate Dr.

Harrisburg, PA 17110-9364 Dr. Judith Johnsrud Environmental Coalition on Nuclear Power Sierra Club 433 Orlando Avenue State College, PA 16803 Director Bureau of Radiation Protection Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection Rachel Carson State Office Building P.O. Box 8469 Harrisburg, PA 17105-8469 Mayor of the Borough of Shippingport P.O. Box 3 Shippingport, PA 15077 Regional Administrator, Region I U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 475 Allendale Road King of Prussia, PA 19406

Beaver Valley Power Station, Unit Nos. 1 and 2 cc:

Resident Inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P.O. Box 298 Shippingport, PA 15077 James H. Lash Site Vice President FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company Beaver Valley Power Station Mail Stop A-BV-SEB1 P.O. Box 4, Route 168 Shippingport, PA 15077

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML072070145&oldid=2175035"