ML060670216
| ML060670216 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Salem, Hope Creek  |
| Issue date: | 03/22/2004 |
| From: | Blough A NRC Region 1 |
| To: | |
| References | |
| FOIA/PA-2005-0194 | |
| Download: ML060670216 (9) | |
Text
. -
I
- I I ---
[ A. Kanuocpn biougn - ie: marcn -lo meeting wi PSEG on Salem/nope creek worK environment 11-1-111---------1---111 A
From:
A. Randolph Blough, To:
DRP All - Nuclear safety Professionals Date:
3/22/04 12:13PM
Subject:
Re: march 18 meeting w/ PSEG on Salem/hope creek work environment Below are excerpts of one of the several articles about last week's meeting with PSEG.
I have bolded some sections to show you how Hub presented the overall perspective.
I've also shortened the article for easy reading, by eliminating some detail of what the company said, as well as quotes of one local activist who called for immediate S/D.
- regards, randy NRC, PSEG Meet To Discuss Safety Issues Bridgeton News Friday, March 19, 2004 By BILL GALLO JR.
Staff Writer LOGAN TWP. -- The operator of the three nuclear power plants at Artificial Island is taking immediate action to help create an atmosphere in which its employees are comfortable in raising safety concerns, federal regulators were told Thursday.
The meeting here between representatives from the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and PSEG Nuclear, the operator of the three plants at the Island in Lower Alloways Creek Township, came as a result of an extraordinary letter sent Jan. 28 by the NRC warning the utility that it needed to take steps to prevent a "chilled environment" that could lead to problems at the facility.
At the heart of the NRC's concerns is the process at the Island for finding and fixing problems at the plant, the second largest nuclear complex in the U.S.
"Let me just say at the outset Salem and Hope Creek units are operating safely. However, events, results of inspections and other assessments that the NRC has performed have revealed weaknesses that require PSEG's attention," said Hubert J. Miller, regional administrator for the NRC and author of the letter.
The Jan. 28 letter to the head of PSEG Nuclear's parent company, Public Service Enterprise Group, was described as a proactive step by the NRC, designed to prevent any potential problems at the plants because of what has been described as "safety culture" issues at the Island. The NRC referred to equipment problems and the apparent reluctance or fear among employees to raise safety concerns with PSEG management.
"Nuclear power plants are complex machines and all plants have problems. The best plants are the best plants because they are very good at Identifying problems and fixing them at an early stage," Miller said. "The best plants are the best plants because they are good at maintaining equipment."
Miller said it is critical for employees to have a willingness to report problems, then find them and fix them.
The letter from the NRC came as the agency was winding down its own special review of the work environment at the Island which began last fall.
PSEG officials said two surveys have been conducted of Island employees concerning the relationship
I II h
71StIVTFpi-i 111 ald~I/lUUG uU1iWlV~HVIIUI III I:
IL Fas>
between workers and management and some o1 the the same findings have emerged.
"Let me tell you right up front, what we have concluded from these assessments so far confirms that we are below industry norms in creating a safety-conscious work environment," said Frank Cassidy, president and chief operating officer of PSEG Power said.
Cassidy said several meetings at the corporate level have been held over the NRC's concerns and steps needed to correct problems at the Island. Cassicly said the needed resources will be committed to fix the problems.
Part of PSEG's response to the NRC concerns has been the creation of an eight-member in-house assessment team consisting of members who have formerly worked in the nuclear industry or in regulation of the industry.
While conducting their own interviews with present and past PSEG employees, they are also studying the results from the two earlier surveys of employee attitudes referred to by Cassidy.
This team's report is due to be delivered to senior management on April 15.
The NRC expects to discuss PSEG's plan for improvement during its annual assessment of performance at the Island later in the spring. Information from the performance surveys and the self-assessment will be posted on the utility's Web site, PSEG officials said.
1;L-xI M:\\TtMP\\GW}WOUU1. I MP P;ade 1 9 uu i
Mail Envelope Properties (405FlEA4.FC8: 9: 34932)
Subject:
Creation Date:
From:
Created By:
Re: march 18 meeting w/ PSEG on Salem/hope creek work environment 3/22/04 12:13PM A. Randolph Blough ARB(nrc.gov Recipients kplpo.KPDO AFF BC (Anne Ford)
Action Delivered Opened Deleted Emptied Date &: Time 03/22/04 12:13PM 03/25/04 10:09AM 05/27/04 01:34PM 06/01/)4 10:20AM nrc.gov kplpo.KPDO ACP (Amar Patel)
AEP (Anne Passarelli)
AFF (Anne Ford)
ALB 1 (Arthur Burritt)
ALR (Amanda Rancourt)
ARB (A. Randolph Blough)
BDW (Blake Welling)
BEH (Brian Holian)
BEK (Beth Sienel)
BJF (Brian Fuller)
BJM (Brian McDermott)
Delivered 03/22/04 12:13PM Opened 03/22/04 12:32PM Deleted 03/24/04 07:46AM Emptied 04/01/04 01:05AM Opened 03/23/04 09:02AM Deleted 05/27/04 01:34PM Emptied 06/01/04 10:20AM Opened 03/22/04 12:17PM Deleted 03/22/04 12:25PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:06AM Opened 03/25/04 08:25AM Opened 03/22/04 12:16PM Deleted 03/22/04 12:16PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:06AM Opened 03/22/04 12:14PM Deleted 03/22/04 12:24PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:07AM Opened 03/22/04 02:18PM Deleted 03/22/04 02:20PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:07AM Opened 03/22/04 01:16PM Deleted 07/26/04 12:26PM Emptied 07/29/04 01:04PM Re: march 18 meeting w/ PSEG on Salem/hope creek work environment Opened 03/22/04 12:15PM Deleted 03/22/04 12:16PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:07AM Opened 03/23/04 07:17AM Deleted 03/23/04 07:18AM
1..-T=ivirxuvvtuuuu i.i-ir CEO (Cynthia O'Daniell)
CJA (Cliff Anderson)
CJB1 BC (Cjbl)
CLN (Tina Newgent)
CRW (Christopher Welch)
CXS 1 (Craig Smith)
DADI (Douglas Dempsey)
DCJ1 (Dante Johnson)
DJF1 (Donald Florek)
DLP1 (David Pelton)
DLS7 (Daniel Schroeder)
DMK (David Kern)
ECB (Ellen Bartels)
ECK (Ed Knutson)
FJA (Frank Arner)
FLB (Fred Bower)
FML (Felicia Hinson)
FWJ (Frederick Jaxheimer)
GDS (Galen Smith)
GJM2 (George Malone)
Emptied Opened Emptied Opened Opened Shared Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Opened Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Deleted Emptied Opened 04/23/04 01 :05AM 03/22/04 12:38PM 04/28/04 01 :48PM 03/22/04 05:38PM 03/22/04 12:26PM 03/22/04 12:27PM 03/23/04 08:0OAM 03/23/04 08:06AM 03/31/04 01:06AM 03/22/04 12:41PM 04/08/04 03:23PM 04/16/04 01:06AM 03/22/04 02:21PM 03/22/04 12:15PM 03/22/04 12:16PM 03/30/04 01:08AM 03/22/04 12:13PM 03/29/04 09:42AM 03/29/04 10:14AM 03/22/04 01:56PM 04/19/04 06:55AM 04/27/04 01:08AM 03/22/04 12:36PM 03/22/04 12:36PM 03/30/04 01:08AM 03/22/04 03:49PM 03/22/04 02:25PM 04/14/04 10:52AM 04/22/04 01:07AM 03/23/04 08:1OAM 03/23/04 08:15AM 03/31/04 01:06AM 03/22/04 12:48PM 03/22/04 12:50PM 03/30/04 01:08AM 03/23/04 07:20AM 03/23/04 08:12AM 03/22/04 12:50PM 05/20/04 10:46AM 05/21/04 10:58AM 03/22/C04 01:24PM 03/24/C04 02:48PM 04/01/04 01:06AM 03/22/C'4 12:13PM
I C:\\TEMP\\G)0001.TMP Paqe 3 lii C:\\TEMP\\GW}OOOO1.TMP Pane 3
GKH (Gordon Hunegs)
GSB (Scott Barber)
GTD (Glenn Dentel)
GWM (Glenn Meyer)
HJM1 BC (hjml)
JAB CC (Jennifer Bobiak)
JDO (Daniel Orr)
JEH3 (Jorge Hernandez)
JER4 (John Richmond)
JGS CC (Joseph Schoppy)
JMB3 (Javier Brand)
JMD1 (Justine DeVries)
JMO (Joe O'Hara)
JMT1 (James Trapp)
JTWl BC (Jtwl)
JXH4 (Jeffrey Herrera)
KAMI (Kevin Mangan)
KAV (Kathy Venuto)
KMJ Opened 03/22/04 01 :53PM Deleted 03/23/04 09:12AM Emptied 03/31/04 01 :06AM Opened 03/29/04 10:40AM Opened 03/22/04 12:43PM Deleted 03/22/04 12:59PM Emptied 03/29/04 07:27AM Opened 03/22/04 03:5 1PM Opened 03/22/04 02:36PM Downloaded 03/22/04 05:58PM Deleted 05/07/04 01:40PM Emptied 05/15/04 01:07AM Opened 03/23/04 06:55AM Deleted 03/23/04 06:57AM Opened 03/22/04 12:36PM Opened 03/24/04 07:14AM Deleted 03/24/04 07:16AM Emptied 04/01/04 01:07AM Opened 03/29/04 08:50AM Opened 03/22/04 02:3 1PM Deleted 03/22/04 02:35PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:09AM Deleted 07/29/04 01:28PM Emptied 08/06/04 01:04AM Re: march 18 meeting wI PSEG on Salem/hope creek work environment Opened 03/25/04 12:01PM Opened 03/22/04 02:24PM Deleted 03/22/04 02:25PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:09AM Opened 03/22/)4 03:08PM Deleted 03/22/04 03:09PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:09AM Opened 03/22/04 01:05PM Deleted 03/22/04 01:06PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:09AM Opened 03/29/04 10:37AM Emptied 06/01/04 05:39PM Opened 03/22/04 01:24PM Deleted 03/22/04 01 :24PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:09AM Opened 03/23/04 09:04AM Deleted 03/23/04 09:05AM Emptied 03/23/04 01:40PM Opened 03/23/04 07:16AM
MPREFRM
§:1ti\\VVUUUU 1. I lIU rgUe Deleted 03/23/04 07:17AM Emptied 03/23/04 03:55PM KRK Opened 03/22/04 12:27PM Deleted 04/01/04 08:3 1AM Emptied 04/08/04 10:20AM KSK Opened 03/22/04 12:20PM Deleted 03/22/04 12:20PM Emptied 03/22/04 02:OOPM LMC1 Opened 03/23/04 07:43AM Deleted 03/23/04 07:54AM Emptied 03/31/04 01 :07AM LML2 Opened 03/22/04 12:39PM Deleted 04/07/04 10:25AM Emptied 04/15/04 01:08AM MAG Opened 03/22/04 12:17PM Deleted 04/12/04 07:53AM Emptied 06/09/04 02:32PM MJM4 Opened 03/22/04 12:13PM Deleted 03/22/04 02:O1PM Emptied 03/25/04 01:09PM MMS1 Opened 03/22/04 05:1 OPM Deleted 04/09/04 11:16AM Emptied 04/17/04 01:08AM MPP1 Opened 03/22/04 02:1 1PM MPS4 Opened 03/22/04 12:14PM Deleted 06/22/04 09:48AM Emptied 06/30/04 01:05AM Re: march 18 meeting w/ PSEG on Salem/hope creek work environment MRC Opened 03/22/04 02:14PM Deleted 06/03/04 01:25PM Emptied 06/11/04 01:09AM MSF2 Opened 03/22/04 03:42PM Deleted 03/30/04 06:47AM Emptied 04/07/04 01:09AM MXG3 Opened 03/22/04 01:47PM NSP Opened 03/23/04 11:39AM Deleted 03/23/04 11:42AM Emptied 03/31/04 01 :08AM PASI Opened 03/23/04 09:19AM Deleted 03/23/04 09:20AM Emptied 03/31/04 01:08AM PCCI Opened 03/22/04 12:15PM Deleted 03/22/04 12:16PM Emptied 03/22/04 12:17PM
P5 Cw{TIX I lFIU-LPge5._
PDD Opened 03/22/04 12:32PM Emptied 06/25/04 04:46PM Re: march 18 meeting w/ PSEG on Salem/hope creek work environment PJH2 Opened 04/02/04 04:41PM Deleted 04/02/04 04:41PM Emptied 04/10/04 01:08AM PWE Opened 03/22/04 01:42PM Emptied 06/29/04 03:08PM Re: march 18 meeting w/ PSEG on Salem/hope creek work environment RJS Opened 03/22/04 03:04PM Deleted 03/25/04 10:49AM Emptied 04/02/04 01:09AM RKL BC Opened 03/22/04 01:19PM Deleted 03/22/04 01:19PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:11AM RLJ Opened 03/22/04 12:14PM Deleted 03/22/04 12:14PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:1 1AM RMB1 Opened 03/22/04 12:13PM Deleted 03/26/04 02:36PM Emptied 04/03/04 01:12AM RSB1 Opened 03/22/04 01:05PM Deleted 03/22/04 01:07PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:11AM RVC BC Opened 03/22/04 12:22PM Deleted 03/22/04 12:25PM Emptied 03/30/04 01: 11AM RXM2 Opened 04/08/04 09:46AM Deleted 04/08/04 09:47AM Emptied 04/08/04 10:26AM SFF Opened 03/23/C'4 08:38AM Deleted 03/23/C04 08:40AM Emptied 03/23/04 08:42AM SGI Opened 03/22/04 01:46PM Deleted 04/05/04 04:41PM Emptied 04/13/04 01:12AM SIN Opened 04/01/04 09:36AM Deleted 04/01/04 09:36AM Emptied 04/09/04 01:1 1AM SJD1 Opened 03/23/04 09:58AM Deleted 03/23/04 10:00AM Emptied 03/31/04 01:08AM SLH1 Opened 03/22/04 01:47PM
~TTE1VU-'W V7yUUUU1. I M1' Replied 03/22/04 01:54PM Deleted 03/22/04 01:54PM Emptied 03/23/04 06:38AM SLL1 Opened 03/22/04 12:38PM Deleted 05/03/04 02:40PM Emptied 05/11/04 01:14AM SLS1 Opened 03/25/04 09:56AM SMS2 Opened 03/22/04 01:55PM Deleted 03/23/04 07:24AM SRK Opened 03/24/04 11:01AM Deleted 04/29/04 08:32AM Emptied 05/07/04 01:09AM SWS Opened 03/22/04 12:28PM Deleted 04/06/04 10:18AM Emptied 04/14/04 01:09AM TEW CC Opened 03/22/04 12:15PM Deleted 03/22/04 12:17PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:11AM TJJ Deleted 03/29/04 05:30PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:19PM TMH Opened 03/23/04 08:OOAM Deleted 04/12/04 01:59PM Emptied 04/12/04 02:04PM trh Opened 03/22/04 12:38PM Deleted 03/22/04 12:39PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:12AM TVW Opened 03/22/04 12:34PM Deleted 07/30/04 02:57PM Emptied 07/30/04 04:16PM Re: march 18 meeting w/ PSEG on Salem/hope creek work environment VMRI Opened 03/22/04 12:36PM Deleted 03/22/C04 12:40PM Emptied 03/23/04 03:1 1PM WACI Opened 03/22/04 12:55PM Deleted 03/22/04 12:58PM Emptied 03/30/04 01:12AM WDL BC Opened 03/23/04 07:44AM Deleted 04/16/04 02:41PM Emptied 04/24/04 01 :09AM WJR Opened 03/22/04 02:12PM Deleted 03/25/04 10:06AM Emptied 03/25/04 10:46AM nrc.gov
r.[ C:\\TEMP\\GW}0000I.TMP Page 7 L
'..--.-----
-.-...
-----
owf2_po.OWFNDO BAR3 CC GXM CC NTS1 CC Delivered Opened Deleted Opened Opened Deleted Emptied nrc.gov owf4_po.WFNDO AXV1 CC CFH CC FPB Delivered Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Emptied Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Deleted Emptied Opened Deleted Emptied 03/22/04 12:13PM 03/22/04 12:13PM 03/22/04 02:05PM 03/22/04 01:04PM 03/22/04 12:49PM 03/22/04 01:47PM 03/31/04 01:27AM 03/22/04 12:13PM 03/22/04 02:35PM 03/26/04 01:19PM 03/29/04 08:22AM 03/22/04 12:34PM 04/06/04 09:27AM 03/22/04 02:11PM 03/22/04 02:12PM 05/07/04 01:19AM 03/22/04 12:48PM 03/22/04 12:48PM 03/30/04 01 :24AM 03/22/04 12:35PM 03/22/04 12:35PM 03/26/04 06:55AM 03/23/04 01 :42PM 03/23/04 01:43PM 03/28/04 01:36AM JLF2 CC LNQ CC SAR CC nrc.gov owf5_po.OWFNDO CXL1 CC Delivered Opened Deleted Emptied nrc.gov twf2_po.TWFNDO TXN1 CC Delivered Opened Emptied 03/22/04 12:13PM 03/22/04 12:13PM 03/31/04 03:19PM 06/17/04 01:06AM 03/22/04 12:13PM 03/22/04 12:55PM 04/22/04 12:00AM 03/22/04 12:13PM 03/22/04 01:O1PM 03/22/04 01:01PM 03/22/04 01:O1PM 03/23/04 07:15AM nrc.gov twf5_po.TWFNDO CSH3 CC Delivered Opened Deleted Emptied Opened DBT CC