ML060580015
| ML060580015 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Davis Besse  |
| Issue date: | 02/07/2006 |
| From: | Gutierrez J Morgan, Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP |
| To: | Brock S NRC/OGC |
| References | |
| Download: ML060580015 (28) | |
Text
Morgan, Lewis & Bockius uLP 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW M orgm lzm s Washington, DC 20004 MOrgan L
AW Tel: 202.739.3000 COUNSELORS AT LAv Fax: 202.739.3001 www.morganlewis.com Jay M. Gutierrez Partner 202.739.5466 jgutierrezrmorganIewis.com February 7, 2006 VIA FEDEX Sara E. Brock, Esq.
Office of the General Counsel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 Re:
Request Under 10 CFR § 2.390 and 9.17 to Withhold Materials from Public Disclosure
Dear Ms. Brock:
As I mentioned in my January 31 letter, FENOC has asked the owners of documents that may contain proprietary information to review their documents and to supply FENOC with affidavits by mid-January 2006 for any such document that the owners determine should be withheld from public disclosure. Consequently, in this letter I am forwarding to you the vendor affidavits that FENOC has received so far:
I.
Affidavit of Mark Seymour, of the Trentec division of Curtiss-Wright Flow Control Service Corporation, requesting withholding of an August 31, 2001 budgetary pricing information (attached); and
- 2.
Three affidavits from Gayle Elliott, of Framatome ANP, requesting withholding from public disclosure the documents listed in the tables attached to each of the three affidavits.
Both of these vendors request that all of the documents cited in their affidavits be withheld in their entirety. Consequently, I am not providing any redacted documents in this submittal. I expect to have the remaining vendor affidavits in hand shortly and will forward them to you once I receive them.
Please feel free to call me; or, if you have any questions or concerns regarding the enclosed affidavits, then feel 'free to contact the vendors directly.
Morgan, Leis
&Bockiddus Sara E. Brock, Esq.
February 7, 2006 Page 2 Sincerely, Jay M.
ierrez Attachments cc:
Christine Lipa - Chief, Branch 4, Division of Reactor Projects
STATE OF OHIO
)
)SS:
COUNTY OF CLERMONT
)
AFFIDAVIT OF MARK SEYMOUR Mark Seymour, being duly sworn, states the following:
- 1.
I am employed in the position of General Manager for the Trentec division of Curtiss-Wright Flow Control Service Corporation, have been employed by Trentec since 2004, and am authorized to make this Affidavit on its behalf.
- 2.
I am making this statement in accordance with the requirements of 10 C.F.R 2.390(a) and (b), and request that the information submitted by Trentec, a copy of which is attached hereto and identified by the Bates Stamp numbers S14R-01975,, S14R-01976, S14R-01977 and S14R-01978, be withheld by the Commission from public disclosure, pursuant to 10 C.F.R. 2.390(a)(4).
- 3.
The information submitted by Trentec and identified in paragraph 2 above contains proprietary design and financial information, which Trentec deems trade secret. Such information is of a type customarily held in confidence by Trentec and is being transmitted to the Commission in confidence. This information represents valuable proprietary data; is not available to the public; and disclosure to the public is likely to cause substantial harm to Trentec's competitive position in the marketplace.
FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT.
Date: Amtb
/0, MA~EYMOUR Sworn to and subscribed before me this 0 )day of January 2006.
Notky Public My commission expires on:
CYNTHIA S. COLLINS No" Public - Stae of ago W Coams Exow Ju 24,2008
!NW
-F-M-11 CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION SUBMITTED UNDER 1Q C.F.R. 2.390 4600 East Tech Drive
- Cincinnati, Ohio 4524 513/528-7900
- FAX 513f(28-9292 August 31, 2001 Framatome 165 Mills Ridge Road Lynchburg, VA 24602 Altention: Ms. Samantha Overstreet, Purchasing Manager Mall Stgtion 14 Telephone: 804-832-3974 Facsimile:
804-832-3979
Subject:
Containmert Equlpment Hatch Budgetary Prialng
Dear Ms. Overstreet,
Pursuant to our discussions this morning we are pleased to provide you with the following budgetary pricing Information:
Item Qty Description Unit Price 01 1
Containment Equipment Hatch, 20 Ft. dia clear opening designed, manufactured and tested In accordance with ASMf-' Ill, Close MC. NPT Stamped, and painting n aecodance with a painting system qualed environmentally for containment erice. Unit Prie.Includes the embedments, struoutwe steel for the Equipment Hatch Cover Hoisting System.
02 1
Outage Equipment Hatch to match the Outer End of the Equipment Hatch, complete with large door clear opening and penetrations 03 1
Lot Diamond Wire Concrete Cutting Service to cut the containment waNl an approximate 3OY x 30' area
$ 800,000 S 300,000 S 260,000 Lead limes for the above items are as follows:
Item 01 Item 02 Item 03
- 18 Months 12 Months 2 Weeks S141R-011975
.s.
UUNFIDENTIA INFORMATION SUBMITTED UNDER 10 C.F.R. 2.390 I;.
With respect to the acual Installation cost, wevdo not have any historical infomston regarding this acty arid we would be reluctant toj rovide you wvth an estimate, Encled with this lette3r Is a CD which delineates our Products,
$Sevices and capabilities as you have requested. Also enaloed is a typical General Arrangement Drawing of e Contelnment Equipment Hatch. Thank you fhr considering Trentec and should you have ny questions regarding our capabilities, please feel free to contact us.
Very Truly Your,
TRENTEC, INC
- h.
Clark Mice President of Sales e
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION SUBMITTED UNDER 10 C.F.R. 2.390 I 1 4.
r at 4
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION SUBMITTED
-WWI=
'it)
C 8
I 7
I 6
5 A
UEAO S
§'ECITCI I:
7
~iAct.
C, i1 i.,_ _
@I &
1ZV 1
5 M I SI4R-01978
AFF IDAVIT COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
)
) ss.
CITY OF LYNCHBURG
)
- 1.
My name is Gayle F. Elliott. I am Manager, Product Licensing in Regulatory Affairs, for Framatome ANP ('FANP"), and as such I am authorized to execute this Affidavit
- 2.
1 am familiar with the criteria applied by FANP to determine whether certain FANP information is proprietary. I am familiar with the policies established by FANP to ensure the proper application of these criteria.
- 3.
1 am familiar with the documents listed in the attached lndex of Proprietary Framatome Documents Supplied to NRC 01 1br which Proprietary Treatment is Requested," and referred to herein as "Documents." Information contained in these Documents has been classified by FANP as proprietary in accordance with the policies established by FANP for the control and protection of proprietary and confidential information.
- 4.
These Documents contain information of a proprietary and confidential nature and is of the type customarily held in confidence by FANP and not made available to the public.
Based on my experience, I am aware that other companies regard information of the kind contained in these Documents as proprietary and confidential.
- 5.
These Documents have been made available to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission in confidence with the request that the information contained in these Documents be withheld from public disclosure.
- 6.
The following criteria are customarily applied by FANP to determine whether information should be classified as proprietary:
(a)
The information reveals details of FANP's research and development plans and programs or their results.
(b)
Use of the information by a competitor would permit the competitor to significantly reduce its expenditures, in time or resources, to design, produce, or market a similar product or service.
(c)
The information includes test data or analytical techniques concerning a process, methodology, or component, the application of which results in a competitive advantage for F:ANP.
(d)
The information reveals certain distinguishing aspects of a process, methodology, or component, the exclusive use of which provides a competitive advantage for FANP in product optimization or marketability.
(e)
The information is vital to a competitive advantage held by FANP, would be helpful to competitors to FANP, and would likely cause substantial harm to the competitive position of FANP.
- 7.
In accordance with FANP's policies governing the protection and control of information, proprietary information contained in these Documents have been made available, on a limited basis, to others outside FANP only as required and under suitable agreement providing for nondisclosure and limited use of the information.
- 8.
FANP policy requires that proprietary information be kept in a secured file or area and distributed on a need-to-know basis.
~ 9.
The foregoing statements are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief.
SUBSCRIBED before me this /
day of 2006.
Ella F. Carr-Payne NOTARY PUBLIC, COMMONWEALTH OF \\VIRGINIA MY COMMISSION EXPIRES: 8/31/09 ELLA F. CARR-PAYNE NOTARY PUBLIC Commonwealth of Virginia My Commission Expires 8-31-09
INDEX OF PROPRIETARY FRAMATOME DOCUMENTS SUPPLIED TO NRC 01 FOR WHICH PROPRIETARY TREATMENT IS REQUESTED l Nam Documeent Document Des iptionl No.
(Iten j abe 1
18 S14Q-07254-07312 Serial 2777; Affidavit attached to document from J.F. Mallay.
S141-01405-01421 2
21 S14A-00717-00718 B&WOG RV Head Repair Bulletin 3
40 S14G-00995-01000 11/12/01 e-mail from P. Goyal to distribution with Calculation Package 4
46 SI4G-00286-00327 10/12/01 e-mail from D. Wuokko to distribution attaching Finite Element Gap Analysis from SIA 5
i54 S14G-00814-00854 10/05/01 e-mail from R. Bax (SIA) to P. Goyal attaching Calculation Package 6
75 S14H-10666-10667 B&W Owners Group RV Head Repair Bulletin 7
89 S14H-111883-11888 B&W Owners Group RV Head Repair Bulletin S14H-12117-12118 8
90 S14H-111904-11906 E-mails from W. Gray to P. Goyal and S. Fyfitch to W. Gray in 11/01 timeframe re:
_ _ Vg-&J W00
%.# F LOIV iaCI 9
104 S14H-12522-12559 SIA Calculation Package, File No. W-ENTP-IQ-306 2S2-00938-00972 2S2-01089-01126 10 118 S14H-00916-00953 Calculation Package, File No. W-ENTP-1 IQ-306 S4S14H-01339-01376 11 135 SH14-03013-03014 B&W Owners Group RV Head Repair Bulletin 12 166 S14P-03298-03345 B&WOG's Safety Assessment of Postulated Flaws for B&W Design Reactor Vessel Incore Monitoring Instrumentation Nozzles 13 177 SI4P-01718-01719 B&WOG RV Head Repair Bulletin S14P-01723-01724 14 183 S14P-02790-02792 Framatome Seismic Tie-plate Drawings 15 190 S17-00001-00055 B&W Report No. 51-1229638-1 16 197 2S2-00973-00977 Calculation Package, File No. W-ENTP-1IQ-309 2S2-00986-00994 2S2-01822-01871 17 199 2S2-00995-01043 Calculation Package, File No. W-ENTP-10Q-308 2S2-01193-01240 18 205 2S2-01270-01282 Framatome Technical Document, titled "Stress Report Summary for Reactor Vessel" 33-1201205-02
INDEX OF PROPRIETARY FRAMATOME DOCUMENTS SUPPLIED TO NRC 01 FOR WHICH PROPRIETARY TREATMENT IS REQUESTED Filee lame' 0Document'Bate'-
Document Dsc-ipt ion No.
(termt.. j L ;t0abel-
'--' ; ;0i :-0'0^~A':
19 211 2S2-01727-01771 Calculation Package, File No. W-ENTP-1 1Q-307 20 220 2S2-00192-00230 Calculation Package, File No. W-ENTP-1 1Q-306 21 236 S14N-00889-00902 12/93 B&WOG's External Circumferential Crack Growth Analysis for B&W Design Reactor Vessel Head; BAW-10190P, Addendum 1 22 237 S14N-00903-00940 12/97 B&WOG's Safety Evaluation for Control Rod Drive Mechanism Nozzle J-Groove Weld; BAW-10190P, Addendum 2 23 238 S14N-00047-00102 5/97 B&WOG's Safety Evaluation for B&W Design Reactor Vessel Head Control Rod Drive Mechanism Nozzle Cracking; BAW-10190P 24 241 S14N-00276-00277 Undated B&WOG graphs assessing nozzle crack probabilities over time 25 246 S14Q-02809-02845 10/08/01 SIA Calculation Package re: Finite Element Gap Analysis of CRDM Penetrations (Davis-Besse) 26 25S4 Q a~w-u0690o 10181'01i SiA Caalculaion Package re: Finite Eiement Gap Anaiysis of CRUM
_________-_Penetrations (Davis-Besse) 27 300 S14D-01590-01629 06/07/01 Letter from Duke Power to U.S. NRC re: request to use an alternative to ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code (with Proprietary Framatome information included);
Affidavit attached to document from R.W. Ganthner.
28 311 S14D-03476-3513 SIA Calculation 29 314 S14D-03879-03916 SIA Calculation 30 315 S14D-03918-03955 SIA Calculation 31 3116 S14D-03957-03994 SIA Calculation 32 319 S14D-04683-04722 SIA Calculation 33 321 S14D-05372-05409 SIA Calculation 34 327 S14D-06136-06173 SIA Calculation 35 330 S14D-06348-06363 Draft template for 2001-01 response 36 331 S14D-07049-07086 SIA Calculation 37 335 S14D-07560-07600 SIA/FENOC calculation comments 38 347 S14J-02282-02319 SIA Calculation 39 380 S14M-06511-06520 SIA Calculation 40 385 S14M-06678-06687 UT Inspection Data 41 399 S14M-01972-02004 SIA Calculation for response to 2001-01 42 402 S14M-03913-03940 SIA Calculation for response to 2001 -01 43 416 S14R-00848-00885 SIA Calculation for response to 2001-01
INDEX OF PROPRIETARY FRAMATOME DOCUMENTS SUPPLIED TO NRC 01 FOR WHICH PROPRIETARY TREATMENT IS REQUESTED
'File lName Document Bates Docu Dection No.
(Itein J ae 44 441 S14R-01082-01085 Non-disclosure agreement between Framatome, FENOC, and SIA 45 443 S14R-01440-01477 SIA Calculation 46 472 S14Q-04886-04923 SIA Calculation Package 47 Serial Serial 2735, 'Supplemental Information in Response to NRC Bulletin 2001-01, 2735
'Circumferential Cracking of Reactor Pressure Vessel Head Penetration Nozzles' (177,9).pdf 48 Serial Serial 2741, "Responses to Requests for Additional Information Concerning NRC 2741 Bulletin 2001-01, 'Circumferential Cracking of Reactor Pressure Vessel Head (1796).pdf Penetration Nozzles';" Affidavit attached to document from C.M. Powers.
AFFIDAVIT COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
)
) ss.
CITY OF LYNCHBURG
)
- 1.
My name is Gayle F. Elliott. I am Manager, Product Licensing in Regulatory Affairs, for Framatome ANP ("FANP"), and as such I am authorized to execute this Affidavit
- 2.
1 am familiar with the criteria applied by FANP to determine whether certain FANP information is proprietary. I am familiar with the policies established by FANP to ensure the proper application of these criteria.
- 3.
1 am familiar with the documents listed in the attached "Index of Proprietary Framatome Documents Supplied to NRC 01 for which Proprietary Treatment is Requested, and referred to herein as TDocuments.0 Information contained in these Documents has been classified by FANP as proprietary in accordance with the policies established by FANP for the control and protection of proprietary and confidential information.
- 4.
These Documents contain information of a proprietary and confidential nature and is of the type customarily held in confidence by FANP and not made available to the public.
Based on my experience, I am aware that other companies regard information of the kind contained in these Documents as proprietary and confidential.
- 5.
These Documents have been made available to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission in confidence with the request that the information contained in these Documents be withheld from public disclosure.
- 6.
The following criteria are customarily applied by FANP to determine whether information should be classified as proprietary:
(a)
The information reveals details of FANP's research and development plans and programs or their results.
(b)
Use of the information by a competitor would permit the competitor to significantly reduce its expenditures, in time or resources, to design, produce, or market a similar product or service.
(c)
The information includes test data or analytical techniques concerning a process, methodology, or component, the application of which results in a competitive advantage for IFANP.
(d)
The information reveals certain distinguishing aspects of a process, methodology, or component, the exclusive use of which provides a competitive advantage for FANP in product optimization or marketability.
(e)
The information is vital to a competitive advantage held by FANP, would be helpful to competitors to FANP, and would likely cause substantial harm to the competitive position of FANP.
- 7.
In accordance with FANP's policies governing the protection and control of information, proprietary information contained in these Documents have been made available, on a limited basis, to others outside FANP only as required and under suitable agreement providing for nondisclosure and limited use of the Information.
- 8.
FANP policy requires that proprietary information be kept in a secured file or area and distributed on a need-to-know basis.
- 9.
The foregoing statements are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief.
SUBSCRIBED before me this /G day of 2006.
Ella F. Carr-Payne NOTARY PUBLIC, COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA MY COMMISSION EXPIRES: 8/31/09 ELLA F. CARR-PAYNE NOTARY PUBLIC Commonwealth of Virginia My Commission Expires 8-31-09
INDEX OF PROPRIETARY FRAMATOME DOCUMENTS SUPPLIED TO NRC PROPRIETARY TREATMENT IS REQUESTED 01 FOR WHICH O..
to sFileiNo.
Doce Decpon 019413 Nonconformance Report 6002763-00, p. 1-3, 4Q2000 019416 Nonconformance Report 6002763-00, p. 4-7,42000 019421 Nonconformance Report 98-00165-00, p1-2, 4/1998 019705 Outage Log, Davis-Besse 1ORFO, 4/1996-5/1996 019767-Ta Log, Davis-Besse IORFO, 4/1996-5/1996 019769' VideoRefueling Services, Davis-Besse 1-RFO, 4/1998-5/1998 019770 Telephone Number Log' 019771 RWP Numbers and Titles 019772 j Tape Log Davis-Besse 11RFO, 4/1998-5/1998 019773 Outage Log, Davis-Besse 11 RFO, 4/1998-5/1998 0209721 51-5008393-00, "Davis-Besse D10 CRDM Nozzle Flange Repair Data," 5/2000 021004 51-5019332-00, "Davis-Besse 12RFO Data Sheets," 7/2002 021134 CRDM Maintenance Class Attendance Records for 12RFO 021137 B&W CRDM Maintenance and Repair Certification Matrix, CRDI 16A-CRD1 16K; NRC030-0589 021138 Lesson Plan CRD120, B&WCRDM Maintenance 021139 Lesson Plan CRD116.0, B&W CRDM Maintenance - Introduction, 2/1993 021147 Training Requirements Reference Procedures 021149 Lesson Plan CRD116.0, B&W CRDM Maintenance - Lesson 1,2/1993 021156 I Lesson Plan CRD116.0, B&W CRDM Maintenance - Lesson 2,2/1993 021168 Lesson Plan CRD116.0, B&W CRDM Maintenance - Lesson 3, 2/1993 021188 Lesson Plan CRD 16.0, B&W CRDM Maintenance - Lesson 4, 2/1993 021196 Lesson Plan CRD 16.0, B&W CRDM Maintenance - Lessons 5 and 6 Notes, 8/2002
4 AFFIDAVIT COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
)
) ss.
CITY OF LYNCHBURG
)
- 1.
My name is Gayle F. Elliott. I am Manager, Product Licensing in Regulatory Affairs, for Framatome ANP ('FANP"), and as such I am authorized to execute this Affidavit.
- 2.
1 am familiar with the criteria applied by FANP to determine whether certain FANP information is proprietary. I am familiarvwith the policies established by FANP to ensure the proper application of these criteria.
- 3.
1 am familiar with the documents listed in the attached "Index of Proprietary Framatome Documents Supplied to NRC for which Proprietary Treatment is Requested," and referred to herein as mDocuments." Information contained in these Documents has been classified by FANP as proprietary in accordance with the policies established by FANP for the control and protection of proprietary and confidential information.
- 4.
These Documents contain information of a proprietary and confidential nature and is of the type customarily held in confidence by FANP and not made available to the public.
Based on my experience, I am aware that other companies regard information of the kind contained in these Documents as proprietary and confidential.
- 5.
These Documents have been made available to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission in confidence with the request that the information contained in these Documents be withheld from public disclosure.
- 6.
The following criteria are customarily applied by FANP to determine whether information should be classified as proprietary:
(a)
The information reveals details of FANP's research and development plans and programs or their results.
(b)
Use of the information by a competitor would permit the competitor to significantly reduce its expenditures, in time or resources, to design, produce, or market a similar product or service.
(c)
The information includes test data or analytical techniques concerning a process, methodology, or component, the application of which results in a competitive advantage for IFANP.
(d)
The information reveals certain distinguishing aspects of a process, methodology, or component, the exclusive use of which provides a competitive advantage for IFANP in product optimization or marketability.
(e)
The information is vital to a competitive advantage held by FANP, would be helpful to competitors to FANP, and would likely cause substantial harm to the competitive position of FANP.
- 7.
In accordance with FANP's policies goveming the protection and control of information, proprietary information contained in these Documents have been made available, on a limited basis, to others outside FANP only as required and under suitable agreement providing for nondisclosure and limited use aF the information.
- 8.
FANP policy requires that proprietary information be kept in a secured file or area and distributed on a need-to-know basis.
- 9.
The foregoing statements are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief.
SUBSCRIBED before me this____
day of qa iJ ta I2006.
I-~
AlAn^
O<Y7L n
I.
Brenda C. Maddox NOTARY PUBLIC, COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA MY COMMISSION EXPIRES: 7/31/07
, I INDEX OF PROPRIETARY FRAMATOME DOCUMENTS SUPPLIED TO NRC 01 FOR WHICH
- PROPRIETARY TREATMENT IS REQUESTED File Protect0on No am oumnentDesecripton.
W eComments/Qetinleconmmendations:
.P...4.
(Iem 3 rodnced
- -dto NRC Documents Produced to NRC O1
- 1.
10 Framatome Presentation 2.790(aX7)
Marked proprietary by Vendor
- 2.
11 Serial 2735 2.790(aX4)
- of Serial 2735 is designated 2.790(aX7) proprietary by Framatome.
- 3.
12 Serial 2741 2.790(aX4)
Attachments 1 & 5 of Serial 2741 are designated 2.790(aX7) proprietary by Framatome in affidavits, dated 10119/01 and 10/30/01.
- 4.
15 Serial 2747 2.790(aX4)
- and Attachment 4 of Serial 2747 are designated proprietary by (if) Framatome in letter/affidavit, dated 11/29/01 and (ii) FENOC re:
Dominion Engineering calculation in affidavit, dated 11/30/01, respectively.
- 5.
17 Serial 2761 2.790(aX4)
- 6.
20 Serial No. 1-1268 2.790(aX4)
Affidavit included with Serial re: proprietary 2.790(aX7)
Framatome information
- 7.
22 Framatome/FENOC Letter of Intent re: RPV Head Replacement 2.790(aX4)
Proprietary
- 8.
24 Framatome RV Head Nozzle and Weld Safety Assessment (Draft) 2.790(aX4)
- a "Framatome ANP Proprietary"
- 9.
29 Framatome Designs 2.790(aX7)
Framatome drawings
- 10.
32 Miscellaneous Fyfitch Documents 2.790(aX4)
This document was identified in the Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 transmittal letter
- 11.
33 03/30/00 e-mail from S. Fyfitchto P. Goyal (with CR) 2.790(aX4)
Has Framatome Bates numbers 00555-00559, but this range is not included in Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 transmittal letter.
- 12.
34 10/17/01 E-mail from S. Fyfitchto P. Goyal (withFramatome PowerPoint 2.790(aX7)
Has Framatome Bates numbers 00660-00670, but re: crack growth calculations) this range was not included in Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 transmittal letter.
i
-77 Basis for -:V~
fiile Protecdion No.
xn6 0:
Document'Description When CommentslQue tins Recommendations 13, 35 10/21/01 e-mail from D. Killian to S. Fyfitch 2.790(aX7)
Has Framatome Bates numbers 00675-00678, but this range was not included in Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 transmittal letter.
- 14.
36 11/06/01 e-mail from D. Killian to S. Fyfitch re: growth rates and Growth 2.790(a)7)
Has Framatome Bates numbers 00689-00693, but Rate Curves table this range was not included in Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 transmittal letter.
15, 39 Framatome Response to CR onEWR-01-0462-00 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 16.
42 11/07/01 e-mail between R. Baker (Framatome) and P. Goyal regarding 2.790(a)(7)
FRA ANP Proprietary calculations
- 17.
56 Framatome Document # 5013435-02 (CRDM Nozzle/Bore Dimensional 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary Analysis)
- 18.
58 11/15/01 e-mail from S. Fyfitchto R. Baker with documents attached re:
2.790(aX4)
Framatome proprietary nozzle heat information CRDM nozzle heat for B&W design nozzles
- 19.
62 06/29/01 memorandum from B. Gray (Framatome) to B&WOG Materials 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary Commiitee, including P. Goyal, attaching Framatome Document 51-5013435-01, titled "CRDM Nozzle/Bore Dimensional Analysis"
- 20.
65 08/14/01 & 08/13/01 e-mail from W. Gray to Duke, Entergy, FENOC re:
2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP Proprietary revised safety assessment forthe B&W plants and attached Framatome report
- 21.
74 Framatome's CRDM Nozzle ID Temper Bead Weld Repair Process 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP Proprietary Qualification, prepared for B&W Owners Group, Duke, Entergy,
_Amergen, FENOC Florida Power Corporation Doe 77-2409-00.
- 22.
76 Framatome Record 51-50113435-02 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP Proprietary
- 23.
86 Framatome Technical Document 08-5015881-00 re: Reactor Vessel 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary Closure Head Replacement Davis-Besse
- 24.
94 09/21/01 e-mail from M. McLaughlin to P. Goyal re: attached Framatome 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary Proposal for Davis-Besse RV Head Lower Service Support Structure Access Openings Analysis (FRA-ANP Proposal # 4160076)
- 25.
95 08/16/01 e-mail from B. Grambau, Framatome, to P. Goyal re: attached 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary Framatome document, "Distribution of Dimensional Fits in Davis Besse RV Head (5013435-02)r
- 26.
100 Framatome Engineering Information Record, #5015229-02 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 27.
101 Several Framatome Engineering Information Records, including 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 5016956-00 (Evaluation of DB-1 RV Head Penetration Repair on RCS Chemistry) and 5015229-01 (Corrosion Evaluation of DB RV Head
_ Penetration IDB Weld Repair) and 5015231-00
- ~
S ::
f-Basis for 0:.-;
SV Iie Protecton No.
eN.me Document.DescriptionWien Co-mmentsQ est ons ecommend aons (Ite~n..j Poducetd to NR'C 28, 102 03/22/02 e-mail from Framatome to P. Goyal re: conceptual design 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary drawing package submittal with attached EN-DP-01230 (Major Change for EWR 02-0111-00). E-mail notes that some of the information in package is proprietary to Framatome
- 29.
103 Framatome Engineering Record, #5011906-00 (DB-1 RV Closure Head 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP proprietary Flange, Dome and Assembly Stress Relieve)
- 30.
106 Framatome Engineering Infonnation Record, #50170-Draft, DB I Weld 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary Repair of Boric Acid Wastage in RVH
- 31.
107 Framatome's Ambient ID Temper Bead Repair for B&W CRDM Nozzles, 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary Contract No. 1231216
- 32.
109 06/29/01 memorandum to B&WOG Materials Committee (Exelon, First 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP proprietary Energy, Florida Power, Entergy, Duke) re: attached Framatome document
- 51-5013435, "CRDM Nozzle/Bore Dimensional Analysis" 33, 119 E-mails from W. Gray to P. Goyal and S. Fyfitch to W. Gray in 11/01 2.790(aX7)
Framatome ANP proprietary timeframe re! Davi.Re. hmlwt CRDM heae information
- 34.
122 06i27t01 & 06/20/01 memorandums from P. Goyal to Distribution re:
2.790(aX7)
B&WOG proprietary Mode 5 Reactor Vessel Head Inspection Recommendation (Reference to EPRI & B&WOG reports)
- 35.
136 Circumferential Growth of Through-Wall Flaw in CRDM Nozzle 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP proprietary Document was identified in the Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 transmittal letter
- 36.
137 Calculation Summary Sheet (Document Identifier 32-5015455-00) 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP proprietary Document was identified in the Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02
.transmittal letter
- 37.
138 Results of OCONEE CRDM 3D Transient Analysis (Document No. 86-2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP proprietary 5011866-00)
Document was identified in the Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 transmittal letter
- 38.
139 Calculation Summary Sheet (Document Identifier 32-5015455.00) 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP proprietary Document was identified in the Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 transmittal letter Baslisfor No.
Name Document Dh/Qiestions ommendatios (Item J Produced~'
39, 140 Several e-mails between D. Killian to S. Fyfitch and other FENOC 2.790(aX7)
FRA ANP proprietary employees re: updated circ. crack growth rates (with attachments)
Document was identified in the Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 transmittal letter
- 40.
141 E-mail between Framatome and FENOC re: heat calculations 2.790(a)(7)
FRA ANP proprietary Document was identified in the Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 l_
transmittal letter 41, 142 12/03/01 Letter from P. Goyal to Framatome re: Dominion Engineering 2.790(a)(7)
FRA ANP proprietary Calculation Number C-3206-li Rev. 0 Document was identified in the Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 transmittal letter
- 42.
143 Presentation re: OD Circumferential Flaw Growth in CRDM Nozzles 2.790(aX7)
FRA ANP proprietary (with calculations)
Document was identified in the Framatome affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 transmittal letter
- 43.
144 10/01/01 e-mail from D. Killianto S. Fyfitchre: CRDMPWSCC thoughts 2.790(a)(7)
FRA ANPproprietary for Davis-Besse Document was identified in the Framatorne affidavit submitted to NRC with 08/08/02 l_
transmittal letter
- 44.
151 04/09/01 e-mail from S. Fyfitch to Industry re: attached final draft of 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP proprietary
_subject safety assessment.
- 45.
154 Framatome Engineering Information Record 5011603-01 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP proprietary
- 46.
160 09/11/01 letter from Framatome to FENOC re: Framatome proposal for 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP proprietary Davis Besse RV head Lower Service Support Structure Access Openings (Analysis - #4160076)
- 47.
162 Framatome Tables re: Closure Stud Elongation Data 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP proprietary
- 48.
164 03/10/00 Letter from Framatome to FENOC re: FTI Recommendation on 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP proprietary the Use of Insta-Coat as a Sealant During RFO 12
- 49.
165 Framatome Enclosure 10.1 Service Structure Map 2.790(aX4)
FRA ANP proprietary
- 50.
171 Framatome Enclosure 10.1 Service Structure Map 2.790(a)(7)
FRA ANP proprietary
- 51.
182 09/21/01 FAX from M. McLaughlin to P. Goyal re: attached Framatome 2.790(aX7)
FRAANPproprietary Proposal for Davis Besse RV Head Lower Service Support Structure Access Openings Analysis (FRA-ANP Proposal # 4160076)
- 52.
183 Framatome Seismic Tie-plate Drawings 2.790(aX7)
FRA ANP proprietary drawings lie Pro tecton No.
Nm Docmet esritin he CoiMmeht8/QuestiVonsleconmmendaktioni (Itemn J roduced
- 53.
234 Davis-Besse CRDM Leadscrew Uncoupling/Coupling Parkding &
2.7909(a)(7) s FRA ANP proprietary Replacement Procedure (marked "Controlled Copy")
- 54.
249 4/30/02 Engineering Mechanics Corp. of Columbus, "Failure Criterion 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary Development and Parametric Finte Element Analysis to Assess Margins for Davis-Besse RPV Head Corrosion"_
- 55.
257 Affidavits of J. Mallay (813/01) and R. Ganther (5/15/01), re: Framatome 2.790(aX4)
[ [Included for FRA ANP information only]
ANP proprietary documents, with attached copy of NRC Regulations 56, 304 Framatome NRC Presentation 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 57.
305 Framatome Repair Presentation 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 58.
307 Framatome Repair process qualification 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 59.
308 Beaver Valley IR14 inspection resuilts 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP drawing on last page
- 60.
317 Framatome CRDM Inspection 2.790(aX7)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 61.
337 Dimensional data for CRDM interference fits 2.790(aX7)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 62.
373 Framatome CRDM UT Datasheets 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 63.
388 SIA Calculations.
2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 64.
397 Framatome ANP drawing of BV-1 Rx Nozzle penetrations.
2.790(aX7) a Framatome ANP proprietary
- 65.
405 SIA Calculation for response to NRC Bulletin 2001-01 2.790(aX7)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 66.
406 SIA Calculation for response to NRC Bulletin 2001 -01 2.790(aX7)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 67.
408 SIA Calculation for response to NRC Bulletin 2001-01 2.790(a)7)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 68.
411 Framatome UT Technique Assessment 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 69.
412 Budget information for DB head repairs 2.790(aX7)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 70.
422 Framatome proposal for DB inspection and repair services 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 71.
423 Framatome proposal 1231216 for inspection and repair service at DB 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 72.
427 Framatome letter of intent for replacement vessel head 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 73.
435 Framatome site requirements document for CRDM repair at Crystal River 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 74.
436 1 Framatome CRDM Nozzle/Bore dimensional analysis 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary
- 75.
437 Framatome CRDM Nozzle/Weld Safety Assessments 2.790(aX4) m Framatome ANP proprietary
- 76.
438 Framatome Reactor Vessel Vent Inspection, Affidavit, and specification of 2.790(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary Framatome proprietary information contaned in SIA Calculation.
- 77.
450 Framatome conceptual proposal for replacement vessel head.
2.790(a)(7)
Framatome ANP proprietary
.File
- roeion, No.
fDocumet Decriptio W
L E
Queon/Retomen aiX (It79.
452 Prodo*
- 79.
452
& O FResatnse to 97-01 Framatome Doumnent 43-2301 -00 2.9(a Framatome ANP propnietaiy
- 79.
451 FrmWom presponsafovesslha npci 2.790(aX7) o Framatome ANP propr-ietaiy Pr"Otetidon NoiieNm ou etDscription W
nCo retl etisl commenaon I
ocmnturoment oN CAumne Inspection Teamo Re
' 46 MCA lm
- 80.
BAW 10190P (1400)
BAW-1090P, "Safety Evaluation for B&W-Design 2.390(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary Reactor Vessel Head Control Rod Drive Mechanism Cracking"
- 81.
BAW 10190P Addendum (1401)
"Addendum to B&WOG Report BAW-1090P 2.390(aX4)
Framatome ANP proprietary Entitled, 'External Circumferential Crack Growth Analysis for B&W-Design Reactor Vessel Head CRDM Nozzles,' dated December 1993'"
- 82.
BAW 2301 (1516)
BAW-2301, `B&WOG Integrated Response to 2.390(aX4)
Marked "Proprietary" Generic Letter 97-01: 'Degradation of Control Rod Drive mechanism Nozzle and Other Vessel Closure
__=_
z uuuin
- 83.
BOOK 2 (1890)
At p. 20: BAW-2337P, "Safety Assessment of 2.390(aX4)
Marked "Proprietary" Postulated Flaws for B&W-Design Reactor Vessel BAW-2377P at p. 20 of 77 Incore Monitoring Instrumentation Nozzles"
- 84.
BOOK 8,(1741)
Atp. 46: B&WOGNo. 51-5011603-1, "RV Head 2.390(aX4)
Marked "Proprietary" Nozzle and Weld Safety Assessment" FRA proprietary drawing at p. 39 of 107
- 85.
BOOK 8 (1743)
Framatome PowerPoint Meeting Presentation, 2.390(aX4)
Marked "Proprietary" "Alloy 600 Inspection and Repair
- 86.
CHART n-a (1460)
CRDMNozzle Heats at B&W-Design Plants 2.390(aX4)
Marked "Proprietary"
- 87.
MISC 03-501248A-01 (1645)
CRDM Roll Expansion Procedure 2.390(aX4)
Marked "Proprietary"
- 88.
MISC 51-5013435-02 (1886)
Framatome Engineering Record No. 51-5013435-2.390(aX4)
Marked "Proprietfly" 02, "CRDM Nozzle/Bore Dimensional Analysis" 89, MISC N-A (1637)
CRDM Roll Expansion Review Sheet 2.390(aX4)
Marked "Proprietary"
- 90.
REPORT 51-1258525-00 (1546)
B&WOG Report No. 51-1258525-00, "CRDM 2.390(aX4)
Marked "Proprietary" Nozzle Heat Treatment"
- 91.
SERIAL 2735 (1779)
Serial 2735, "Supplemental Information in 2.390(aX4)
Finite Gap Analysis is "Proprietary" Response toNRC Bulletin 2001-01, P. 100 of III
"'Circumferential Cracking of Reactor Pressure Vessel Head Penetration Nozzles'"
-r BoAsi for, P~rotection:
No.
File Name Document Decriptio W
OMMn/QuetionslRecmommendations Piroduced;
- 92.
Serial 2735 (630)
Serial 2735, "Supplemental Information in 2.390(aX4)
Finite Gap Analysis is "Proprietary" (p. 111 of Response to NRC Bulletin 2001-01, 128)
'"Circumferential Cracking of Reactor Pressure Vessel Head Penetration Nozzles"
- 93.
SERIAL 2741 (1796)
Serial 2741, "Responses to Requests for Additional 2.390(aX4)
Framatome proprietary attachments Information Concerning NRC Bulletin 2001-01, BAW-1090P at p. 32 of 245
'Circumferential Cracking of Reactor Pressure Vessel Head Penetration Nozzles'"
- 94.
Serial 2741 (633)
Serial 2741, "Responses to Requests for Additional 2.390(aX4)
Framatome proprietary attachments (BAW-1090P Information Concerning NRC Bulletin 2001-01, at p. 33 of 260)
'Circumferential Cracking of Reactor Pressure
_Vessel Head Penetration Nozzles'"
- 95.
Serial 2747 (642)
Serial 2747, "Supplemental Information in 2.390(aX4)
Framatome proprietary attachments (p. 13 of 98)
Response to the November 28, 2001 Meeting Regarding the Davis-Besse Nuclear Pnwer Stt1inn Response to NRC Bulletin 2001-01"
- 96.
Serial 2761 (645)
Serial 2761, "Reactor Pressure Vessel Head 2.390(aX4)
Framatome proprietary attachment (p. 9 of 43)
Penetration Examination Plans for the Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station"
- 97.
TEMS A16892 (1232)
BWOG Committee Meeting Materials 2.390(aX4)
Attaches B&W proprietary reports and 2.790 affidavit re same BAW-1090P at p. 29 of 89