ML042330049
| ML042330049 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Catawba  |
| Issue date: | 08/06/2004 |
| From: | Cottingham A Duke Energy Corp, Winston & Strawn, LLP |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| Byrdsong A T | |
| References | |
| 50-413-OLA, 50-414-OLA, ASLBP 03-815-03-OLA, RAS 8353 | |
| Download: ML042330049 (19) | |
Text
RAS 9353 N.
August 6, 2004 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA DOCKETED NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION USNRC August 17,2004 (3:15PM)
BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD OFFICE OF SECRETARY RULEMAKINGS AND ADJUDICATIONS STAFF In the Matter of:
)
Docket Nos. 50-413-OLA DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION
}50)414OLA (Catawba Nuclear Station,
)
Units 1 and 2)
)
DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION'S PROPOSED CORRECTIONS TO THE JULY 14-15, 2004 HEARING TRANSCRIPT IN THE MIXED OXIDE LEAD ASSEMBLY LICENSE AMENDMENT PROCEEDING Duke Energy Corporation ("Duke") proposes that the July 15, 2004 hearing transcript in this NRC license amendment proceeding be amended to reflect the corrections set forth below.
Transcript Page Correction July 15. 2004 Morning Session 2341, line 1 Replace "factor he" with "factor. He" 2341, line 2 Delete "is" 2344, line 7 Replace "17-value" with "1750 degree value" 2348, line 8 Replace "1,841" with "1,841 degrees" 2351, line 13 Replace "tariffs" with "comparison" 2351, line 25 Replace "cooperating" with "core operating" 2352, line 10 Replace "stated that ever" with "stated what" 2352, line 12 Replace "time and life" with "time in life,"
1
-rlnlofi =SEC'/ 03 a 5Oj a
2355, line 15 2356, line 25 2357, line 19 2362, line 10 2377, line 13 2377, line 14 2381, line 21 2387, line 13 2389, line 19 2395, line 5 2398, line 1 2398, line 2 2402, line 4 2403, line 19 2408, line 2 2408, line 10 2408, line 11 2408, line 22 2413, line 8 2414, line 9 2415, line 15 2415, line 25 2416, line 6 Add "say" after "would" Replace "20,000 gigawatt stage" with "20,000 megawatt day" Replace "16" with "1600" Replace "sufficient" with "efficient" Replace "that, the" with "that, to" Replace "and" with "an" Replace "Ellemen" with "Elleman" Replace "its powered oxide pellets can change inside" with "it is powered oxide pellets contained inside" Add "lower" following "was" Add "performed a" before "best estimate" Replace "can be tied" with "are" Replace "somewhere" with "similar" Replace "Duke Exhibit 16," with "Duke testimony,"
Replace "applied" with "apply" Replace "Plutonium" with "plutonium" Replace "Plutonium" with "plutonium" Replace "Uranium" with "uranium" Replace "exempt" with "exemption" Replace "--" with ".8."
Replace "confines" with "combines" Replace "20.56" with "2056" Replace "M-5" with "M5" Replace "M-5" with "M5" 2
2416, line 15 2416, line 23 2417, line 3 2417, line 8 2417, line 9 2417, line 10 2419, line 5 2419, line 25 2420, line 4 2420, line 19 2421, line 3 2421, line 3 2421, line 10 2421, line 11 2421, line 23 2423, line 2 2423, line 3 2423, line 4 2423, line 5 2423, line 17 2424, line 14 2425, line 12 2425, line 14 Replace "M-5" with "M5" Replace "M-5" with "M5" Replace "M-5" with "M5" Replace "M-5" with "M5" Replace "M-5" with "M5" Replace "M-5" with M5" Replace "disparatization" with "discretization" Replace "structures it" with "supports and" Replace "vertical" with "virtual" Replace "regular" with "radial" Replace "rebut" with "refill" Replace "rewaxing" with "rewetting" Replace "real" with "realistic" Replace "transfer" with "calculation" Replace "insulated" with "influenced" Replace "This" with "Duke" Replace "behavior, these are" with "behavior is either" Replace "dry base" with "design basis" Replace "evaluation. Clearly" with "evaluation, clearly" Replace "potentially" with "potential" Replace "and at four" with "in the core" Replace "M-S" with "M5" Replace "PCT 17" with "PCT and 17" 3
2425, line 15 2425, line 16 2425 line 18 2425, line 19 2426, line 10 2428, line 10 2429, line I 1 2429, line 13 2429, line 21 2429, line 23 2429, lines 24-25 2430, line 2 2430, line 3 2430, line 8 2431, line 9 2431, line 18 2432, line 14 2434, line 10 2435, line 20 2436, line 4 2436, line 5 2436, line 5 2436, line 9 Replace "M-5" with "M5" Replace "Zercoloy-4" with "Zircaloy-4" Replace "Go to 3 for the impact" with "The M5" Replace "report at BAW" with "report, BAW" Replace "balloon sections required have developed" with "ballooned sections is required to develop" Replace "like" with "look" Replace "radiated" with "irradiated" Replace "as" with "at" Replace "fuel" with "fuel melt" Replace "fuel" with "fuel melt?"
Replace "included our core design analysis" with "included this criterion in our core design analysis" Replace "populated" with "postulated" Replace "centerline" with "centerline melt" Replace "operation" with "operating" Add "decay heat" after "higher" Replace "illusion" with "allusion" Replace "operating" with "operated" Replace "both get no bum-up" with "both at no bum-up" Replace "prepared" with "proposed" Delete "of'; add period after "issue" Replace "while" with "While" Delete "so" Replace "Europeans" with "Europe" 4
2436, line 15 2436, line 16 2437, line 22 2440, line 13 2440, line 13 2440, line 23 2441, line 9 2442, line 21 2446, line 10 2446, line 10 2450, line 16 2450, line 23 2451, line 3 2451, line 5 2451, line 8 2451, line 12 2458, line 4 2462, line 2 2462, line 25 2471, line 12 2485, line 7 2488, line 12 2488, line 21 Replace "our's" with "ours" Replace "their's." with "theirs."
Replace "HARVEY" with "NESBIT" Replace "M-5" with "M5" Replace "4" with "Zircaloy-4" Delete "demo" Replace "there" with "their" Add "of' before "ballooning" Replace "action" with "accident" Replace "LPAs" with "LTAs" Replace "M-5" with "M5" Replace "M-5 with "M5" (both references)
Replace "that." with "that?"
Replace "M-5" with "M5" Replace "M-5" with "M5" Replace "M-5" with "M5" Replace "it's" with "it has" Replace "Grandjean/Hach-Wunderle" with "Grandjean-Hache-Rongier" Replace "Schwartz"wvith "Schwarz" Replace "Poor" with "Pore" Replace "Leap" with "lead" Replace "Hach" with "Hache" Replace "Hach" With "Hache" 5
2489, line 8 2493, line 22 2493, line 24 2493, line 25 2497, line 20 2504, line 2 2515, line 16 2516, line 13 2516, line 14 2516, line 17 2516, line 20 2516, line 20 2518, line 8 2522, line 1 2523, line 19 2523, line 20 2523, line 25 2524, line 1 2526, line 23 2526, line 25 2527, line 11 2527, line 24 2528, line 13 Replace "phased" with "phrased" Replace "testimony 3" with "Q.R-3" Replace "or" with "where" Replace 'up" with "F" Replace "of' with "at" Replace "priority" with "proprietary" Replace "Intention 1" with "Contention 1" Replace "of' with "if '
Replace "IRS" with "IRSN" Replace "Cotaba" with "Catawba" Replace "IRS and" with "IRSN" Replace "Cotoba" with "Catawba" Replace "coal" with "coolant" Replace "Nesbitt" with "Nesbit" Replace "Nesbitt" with "Nesbit" Replace "Cotaba" with "Catawba" Replace "and" with "in" Replace "Contaba Core" with "Catawba core" Replace "layer and" with "layer in" Replace "conglomerates and" with "agglomerates in" Replace "glow-down" with "blow-down" Replace "con-accident" with "coolant accident" Add "in" after "particles" 6
2529, line 2 2529, line 3 2529, line 11 2533, line 16 2533, line 21 2534, line 18 2535, line 25 2536, line 14 2536, line 25 2537, line 5 2537, line 13 2542, line 4 2543, line 22 2544, line 6 2545, line 9 2546, line 13 2546, line 16 2549, line 5 2549, line 9 2549, line 10 2549, line 14 2549, line 17 2550, line 2 Replace "zircaloid" with "zircaloy" Delete "(phonetic)"
Replace "argonne" with "argon" Replace "erradiated" with "irradiated" Replace "erradiated" with "irradiated" and "unerradiated" with "unirradiated" Replace "unerradiated" with "unirradiated" and "erradiated" with "irradiated" Replace "erradiated" with "irradiated" Replace "unerradiated" with "unirradiated" Replace "erradiated" with "irradiated" Replace "erradiated" with "irradiated" Replace "erradiated" with "irradiated" Replace "unerradiated" with "unirradiated" Replace "embriddlement" with "embrittlement" Replace "in" with "and" Replace "Lemon" with "Lyman" Add "is" after "apparently",
Replace "at" with "out" Replace "CATHARE hovel" with "Cathcart-Pawel" Replace "reactive" with "reaction" Replace "interpelation" with "interpolation" Replace "reactive" with "reaction" Replace "temp" with "temperature" Replace "P" with "peak" 7
2550, line 16 2550, line 18 2550, line 23 2555, line 12 2555, line 15 2555, line 17 2556, line 23 2556, line 25 2557, line 2 2557, line 13 2557, line 19 2557, line 20 2558, line 1 2558, line 20 2559, line 2 2560, line 6 2561, line 6 2561, line 9 2562, line 19 2562, line 21 2565, line 9 2565, line 19 2565, line 22 Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "P" with "peak" (both references)
Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "low in rich" with "low enriched" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "conservatives" with "conservatisms" Replace "be counter for an appendix" with "be accounted for in Appendix" Replace "marked graphs" with "micrographs" Replace "RSN" with "IRSN" Replace "RSN" with "IRSN" Replace "ISRM" with "IRSN" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "eradiated and five" with "irradiated MS" Replace "eradiated" with "irradiated" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" 8
2566, line 17 2567, line 1 2567, line 7 2568, line 15 2568, line 18 2568, line 18 2568, line 20 2570, line 11 2571, line 3 2571, line 7 2572, line 6 2572, line 8 2572, line 9 2572, line 18 2573, line 5 2573, line 11 2574, line 14 2574, line 16 2575, line 9 2575, line 25 2576, line 6 2576, line 7 2577, line 3 Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "substandard" with "substantial" Replace "privied" with "privy" Replace "and the" with "in a" Replace "routine" with "routines" Replace "the" with "a" Replace "broad" with "rod" Replace "had the bolt effects" with "had both effects" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "TCP" with "PCr' Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "note" with "node" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "apposed" with "opposed" Replace "74" with "75" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix K" Replace "part" with "Appendix" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "aren't"' with "aren't" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "affect" with "effect" 9
2577, line 3 2577, line 6 2577, line 15 2578, line 23 2579, line 3 2580, line 12 2580, line 12 2580, line 14 2580, line 18 2580, line 22 2581, line 8 2581, line 14 2581, line 15 2581, line 24 2583, line 3 2583, line 9 2583, line 25 2584, line 2 2584, line 5 2584, line 6 2584, line 7 2584, line 8 2584, line 9 Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "affects" with "effects" Replace "P" wvith "peak" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "on" with "one" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix K" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "of' with "on" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "on" with "one" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "too" with "to" Replace "to" with "2" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "DUKE" with "Duke" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "is appendix" with "in Appendix" 10
2584, line 12 2584, line 15 2584, line 16 2584, line 21 2585, line 1 2585, line 21 2585, line 24 2586, line 2 2586, line 5 2586, line 13 2586, line 18 2586, line 21 2586, line 23 2586, line 25 2587, line 1 2587, line 14 2588, line 14 2588, line 19 2589, line 19 2589, line 21 2590, line 3 2590, line 4 2590, line 15 Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "state din" with "stated in" Replace "affects" with "effects" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "mix and group" with "mixing grid" Replace "radiated" with "irradiated" Replace "advanced test reactor" with "Advanced Test Reactor" Replace "performed" with "performed, not" Delete "t" Add comma after "criteria" Replace "P" with "peak" 11
2591, line 18 2591, line 24 2593, line 10 2593, line 22 2593, line 24 2595, line 8 2597, line 6 2498, line 5 2498, line 16 2598, line 24 2599, line 4 2599, line 10 2601, line 3 2601, line 4 2601, line 12 2601, line 16 2602, line 5 2602, line 12 2602, line 16 2602, line 17 2603, line 2 2604, line 12 2604, line 23 Replace "no" with "not" Replace "through" with "their" Replace "eradiating" with "irradiating" Replace "Oregon" with "Argonne" Replace "eradiated" with "irradiated" Replace "eradiation" with "irradiation" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix K" (2 occurrences)
Replace "towing" with "filling" Replace "ration" with "ratio" Replace "IRSM's" with "IRSN's" Replace "towing" with "filling" Replace "throwing" with "filling" Delete "Then we'll ask."
Delete "to" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "opposed MOX" with "opposed to MOX" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "Oregon" with "Argonne" Replace "Oregon" with "Argonne" Replace "Oregon" with "Argonne" Replace "Oregon" with "Argonne" Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" Replace "logo" with "LOCA" 12
2605, lines 24-25 Replace "in a quality" with "inequality" 2607, line 12 Replace "of new" with "of viewV' 2608, line 25 Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" 2609, line I Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" 2609, line 4 Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" 2609, line 11 Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" 2609, line 12 Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" 2609, line 15 Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" 2609, line 16 Replace "appendix" with "Appendix" 2611, line 13 Replace "bur-ups" with "bum-ups" 2611, line 14 Replace "conglomerates" with "agglomerates" 2611, line 22 Replace "sue" with "issue" 2612, line 23 Replace "uneradiated" with "unirradiated" 2613, line 10 Replace "aerial" with "areal" 2614, line 9 Replace "nee do" with "need to" 2614, line 10 Replace "close" with "closed" 2614, line 24 Replace "entitle" with "entitled" 2617, line 17 Replace "I" with "it" July 15. 2004 Evening Session 2623, line 12 Delete "Dr. Lyman states that neither the staff,"
2624, line 16 Add "were" after "Where" 2624, line 19 Add "Where" before "Were" 2629, line 5 Replace "Nicholas Waekel" with "Nicolas Waeckel" 13
2629, line 6 2633, line 12 2634, line 1 2635, line 1 2635, line 2 2635, line 16 2635, line 23 2636, line 2 2636, line 5 2636, line 17 2639, line 2 2639, line 16 2641, line 15 2641, line 16 2642, line 23 2644, line 9 2645, line 24 2646, line 17 2646, line 21 2648, line 8 2648, line 13 2648, line 14 2648, line 18 Replace "Electricity" with "Electricite" Replace "gigawatt base" with "gigawatt days" Replace "their" with "they're" Replace "then IPS" with "the IPSN" Delete "and" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "of' with "or" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace"R2 data" with "FR2 data" Replace "P clad temp" with "peak clad temperature" Replace "the LOCA stated" with "the relocated" Replace "1.4 o" with "1.4 on" Replace "endplugs" with "end plugs" Replace "experience" with "experiments" Replace "like 62nd vibration" with "like 60 per second vibration" Replace "plutonium," with "plutonium."
Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "fond" with "found" Replace "DR. MEYER" with "DR. LANDRY" (first reference);
replace "Dr. Landry" with "Dr. Meyer" (second reference)
Replace "quotes" with "quoted" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "P" with "peak" 14
2648, line 23 2648, line 25 2649, line 24 2651, line 14 2652, line 16 2652, line 25 2657, line 12 2657, line 17 2657, line 19 2658, line 9 2664, line 3 2668, line 2 2668, line 6 2668, line 13 2668, line 22 2669, line 8 2671, line 11 2675, line 13 2676, line 12 2677, line 23 2678, line 4 2678, line 5 2678, line 9 Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "one?" with "on?"
Replace "effect" with "affect" Replace "so me" with "some" Replace "base" with "based" Replace "annual" with "annulus" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "P" with "peak" Add "of' after "less" Replace "started" with "stated" Add "using" after "calculation" Replace "conservatisms" with "conservatism" Replace "finding" with "filling" Replace "answer A" with Answer 8" Replace "Mr." with "Ms."
Replace "with the 46 in Appendix K" with "with 50.46 and Appendix K" Replace "LYMAN" with "LANDRY" Replace "LYMAN" with "LANDRY" 15
2678, line 12 2678, line 14 2678, line 24 2679, line 6 2683, line 23 2685, line 16 2690, line 14 2693, line 24 2694, line 4 2694, line 16 2695, line 5 2697, line 14 2697, line 15 2699, line 13 2700, line 4 2702, line 11 2702, line 14 2703, line 14 2703, line 24 Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "LYMAN" with "LANDRY" Replace "P" with "peak" Delete "Catawba, the" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "P" with "peak" Replace "ration" with "ratio" Replace "intersticial" with "interstitial" Replace "coalesce" with "coalesces" Replace "in" with "and" Replace "inner-action" with "interaction" Replace "Thermal couples" with "Thermocouples" Replace "in" with "and" Replace "investigation" with "investigate" Replace "thermalhydraulic" with "thermo-hydraulic" Replace "effect" with "affect" Replace "effect" with "affect" Replace "Judged" with "Judge" Replace "them" with "then" 16
Respectfully submitted, David A. Repka Anne W. Cottingham J
WINSTON & STRAWN LLP 1400 L Street, NW Washington, D.C. 20005-3502 (202) 371-5726 Timika Shafeek-Horton DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION 422 South Church Street Mail Code: PBO5E Charlotte, N.C. 28201-1244 ATTORNEYS FOR DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION Dated in Washington, District of Columbia This 6h day of August, 2004 17
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of:
DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION (Catawba Nuclear Station, Units 1 and 2)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Docket Nos.
50-413-OLA 50-414-OLA CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of "DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION'S PROPOSED CORRECTIONS TO THE JULY 14-15, 2004 HEARING TRANSCRIPT IN THE MIXED OXIDE LEAD ASSEMBLY LICENSE AMENDMENT PROCEEDING" in the captioned proceeding have been served on the following by deposit in the United States mail, first class, this 6th day of August, 2004. Additional e-mail service, designated by *, has been made this same day, as shown below.
Ann Marshall Young, Chairman*
Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 (e-mail: AMY~nrc.gov)
Thomas S. Elleman*
Administrative Judge 5207 Creedmoor Road, #IO01 Raleigh, NC 27612 (e-mail: ellemaneeos.ncsu.edu)
Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Anthony J. Baratta*
Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 (e-mail: AJB5(nrc.gov)
Office of the Secretary*
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Attn: Rulemakings and Adjudications Staff (original + two copies)
(e-mail: HEARINGDOCKET~nrc.gov)
Adjudicatory File Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 1
Susan L. Uttal, Esq.*
Antonio Fernandez, Esq.*
Margaret J. Bupp*
Office of the General Counsel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 (e-mail: slu~nrc.gov)
(e-mail: axf2(nrc.gov)
(e-mail: mjb5@nrc.gov)
Diane Curran*
Harmon, Curran, Spielberg &
Eisenberg, LLP 1726 M Street, N.W.
Suite 600 Washington, DC 20036 (e-mail: dcurraneharmoncurran.com)
Counsel for Duke Energy 2
DC:369291.1