ML042290158

Hearing 07/14/04 - Intervenor Exhibit D (Official Exhibit 28), A. Mailliat and J. C. Mélis Slide Presentation at the Phebus Stloc Meeting

ML042290158
Person / Time
Site:	Catawba
Issue date:	10/23/2003
From:	Mailliat A, Melis J Govt of France, Institute for Radiological Protection & Nuclear Safety (IRSN)
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Byrdsong A T
References
50-413-0LA, 50-414-OLA, ASLBP 03-815-03-OLA, Catawba-Intervenor-D, RAS 8290
Download: ML042290158 (37)

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:I V ,AS DOCKETED USNRC August 9, 2004 (11:45AM) OFFICE OF SECRETARY RULEMAKINGS AND ADJUDICATIONS STAFF EXHIBIT D NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION DocketiNo. 5b-qt4 3Atq- 0 Offid Eh. IlNo. _ In the matter of J-Ltko-GaCdQJ= Staff IDENTIFIED 7/LI /09 Applicant RECEIVED Intervcrr './ REJECTED Cont'g Offr-Contractor N DATE Other Witness Reporter 41k1,t YII/ lTerv'e%-5,c~b 5EC I ~'. I r. 1 !07, PHEBUSSTLOCMEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A MRMA Tet at 1 I

t 54 d W -'.- w- ..8 vlini v'Ln V PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washiigton, D.C USA A AILLU T et al 2 I,

VNucle; data base v/Conse ~Due 1 -The i accider /prob uncerta How rnuc7 I.- PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A. MA ILLIATet al 3 I

Vr iR P el 'L4 Ls ewe ?'ag a4vaisqg. ir w 1Updating and upon '.Fuel beh

Anll optimized

experiments Pro A few

~~~~~-.>.,..P '-i "g .AcBeading t -~. 4 PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A.AM4ILLUiT et al 4

-4~ F 0 f ~- ' - ~ < .l f v Part 2 lz.,' I- "
. '. ' ' l.!
-'-;'-- ' " I -I I 4." 1. -I I. t. I .
-. ': "
-'
'. .I -Source Teri bc

. I

: t7. i.... l.: t --16 . 'm tl:-
':.. ip I.I -
h, Z-PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A MAIZLIA T et al 5s

" W'% 6;%
:. -
j 9 4
i _i
.1- .4 -. K. A =9 Pending Questions: l 1Mar 6 0 MO. g Releaesfor MOX fue Wg Bu st-ructue is diffreri gbup Impa teh iKey high burnup in 1i.usc efshpcs l~u-an4J chemistre th gd o oy~~r~ FP. releas for obeudriei ai0 VlLow but sgufitbci-, 5%.fbrT Degradationqo~s VERCORS Cs &tkaf hrer i SoeDunl lau4~1OX 'gaw ll:

• -9 e

e I i.I II II vav PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A M.Aff.LUT et al 6

V. RM i?% r-It I
k.117-. IN, %

! L, .4f L so U U - II U P P t r r~ztrs-- ER. The Zirgd iion process - egrada

uld be increas h/Zircaloydxiation kihm

.- vEnergyee ridwi from-single diestsd HCF..3 test H02 sh~eathed DorlUngton fuci, 189 00C PHEBUSSTLOCMEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A AL4H-M Tel al 7

Pending Questions : k-'  . Ia.'.udhy 'or S she~ismn t muh xe 4Vlbiyti reore; 'm i'ateff r epree

m ater q: s vahb frl p r:a m e

'.Q' .IIT .-ld Ži '¶Cs$n ' C a .n .. U
i-,),
""', ! 'A;." 5 PREBUSSTLOC MEETING, October 231h, 2003, Washington, AC USA A MAILUA T et al 8

Rm 9lRrl--% ,,,-1,, f --I-L-i e.. in M .   K]w *'  TO build valuable data bases, res from. experments wichwil h the.pyical nwiscmasms. i-p degriaio l reease privys - rrectnss. C..,..... .7 a Three repiI g.tZ! 5000 C4 m* i E i 4000 la .3000 E- ' at 52U 50 1400K 25U -6Zr7ZO U-Z5 wtQ. 5U - 90Zr - SO ,ZriNbi Exposure time [tm 2 4 6 8 10 2000 1000 0 0 K..,p7 PHEBUSSTLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A AfALUM T et al 9

499 n.-
- C-7 -.jjr-7v 2!;
=
,=F iiiiii ' - EIPMENT MAIN 0E .^VE.:........ u-,". t t.,. i.",,
.;,%,,, Taking accuu te Ph~bus P

thi&SIOC ror~mesaulm es do tuitiuoeatio~is h

• -; t,

,; u;-{ e-M ous M Such a cynsiki can bebaicu .y .rmtxept te -o. Trainment.~.,,,, PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A.M4lLLL4Tetal 10

IR S __J !;iwy 4---. .~, 1U

9

-5:: EQU IPNT MMNaOPT

• SIrLFIDOCRCUITS
• NO MORE NzD
• NQMOR NEEM

.N- .0 m .:- MORE EXNEy .. i A SIMJlyD SAMl I ' ^ of i PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A. MAILLLAT et al 11

ll
ZA %4 F='.. I PI L ia j I 4. r JNW; L I a~cal~hic daz i kI x 1 ".-* I

r -.i,

)NTIANMENT \\VITH -INTEGRAL FILTERS

• STEAM CONDENSER DRIVER CORE un^,%-

l r, ME MEASURM COMPARTbU 0.. -l-4 I PIEBUSSTLOCMEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A AWLLL4T et al 12

PM mlik 94 & e WW V.- I- -tl i
"-:
L'i so wi9 .. CAISSON E( MAIN ASPECT OF THE MEA The measureme cmparfen The MC inkyud -if-i T,,.., e Un ~AS C &4',46,. Each samplingti .d... I -. disco PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A MALU.U T et al 13

IkRSLJ N, AP l M E A S U R E M E N T S T RE G. MEA 1T STRO Highlights i tlhe measureme] Fuel dg sure V e,,&, .. -, I I Z, ,.
, ZI
,: term est ..:,.'s, PHEBUS STLOCMEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A. MAILLUT et at 14

al MA% A t ':,,,.;7 MEASUREMENT COM... IENT fl --ziSEQUENTIAL.,- RESUSPENTION RATE G

MMA SPECTROMETRY POSTCIE XMIAI

. .r ..v 4&L-.* ->' 4  i iii PRESSURE TEMPERATURES i MASS FLOW RATES POWER HYDROGEN, STEAM CONTENTS' RELEASE RATE bEPOSIT RATE RESUSPENSION RATE GAMMA Spec, TOMOGRAPHY DESTRUCTIVE EXAMINATIONS CHEMICAL ANALYSES &.**,**. PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23*h, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A AWLLU T et al 15

I. .l Part 3 X Xuce X--.i PREBVS STLOC MEETING, October 23tht, 2003, Washintgton, D.C USA W: t '7 And-oNwa-An MAILLM T et al

M x ADI `i- -.. 4., -I .-...  I I . ---.1 -
,

'I !
,

1. ; --...,

"N -:- .;
. ;
, 41 ,' 4,

4 I

, 1- - -
"

,; ".; ":

j.,,

-,, i 7-',
.,,, I

1 D gr any LOCA transient a core geomeNty which preserve

coolability must be guaranteed it means

A Shattering of the fuel rods has to be avoided =4Core coolability has to be maintained PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A. "LLIAT et at 17

Qw Wait ;R r- ! e SE Z- V

• ~~~~~~~~~~~~~

m ._V"'.-' fe az'A-, r4>: -s z ant: XT It means: to know the quantities which control the cladding residual di back to cold conditions and core coolability, the values not to exceed. 77, ."O CHC7oITCIEI R O RUE O ECO O~ of.'+.-.',r t,;

• ..:, 4i A ne, a-

= W li at on It means: To demonstrate, through calculations tools, that whatever is the kind of`,E" LOCA trnkt nohrntecr.teciei ausaeecee PREB US STLOC MEETING, October 23ih, 2003, Washington, D. C USA As A4LIJUAT et al 18

a n am - n t
= m
---o 111-ONM U~ I ,
; ";. In thecnxof em reactory revii i-; me. I'.4 4', '4 "4 ~s unpses b PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A. AWLLL4 T et al 19

-vr K t

e " -.- - K - -;r-V'. sJj r4- )r4t' t!ts.A

• '.H,

  "4 .-.,,&,p1/2$.. >.yVf .. < ,...t.1; A4..4- ,-a-h- .4,1 'C. 4 PIEB US STLOC MEETINVG, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A. MAlILLIAT et al 20

l

E-- P endio Ise itPending Issi I _mume .:.'44,j... ..v  'I VeS : 17--- Temperats TYPICAL LOCA TRANSIENT P4e/ocation 400 PRE-TRAN5SIENV POST-TR~ANaDENT Peak Cl Fina1-..o Hydrog PHEBU.AS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA AMAILLUTetal 21

I-RS I- ~ AK1 Pending Is: 1* I(IIJ KWJ 91au RV V. 11 V A PHEBUSSTLOCMEETING, October23ih,2003, Washington,D.C USA A. MILLIATet a2 22

ft p6 e F
= m -4

. j.E w E-115L, N .1 Z: = - - L J t4., oba 2 ,<zI*K Pending Issues: hi~ What is th for irradi e4 u d es? _~ Hot and cold poiuts!i e es ydt o th reorganisation duun 'a bm0X:.f hg/ fr*es L I,- fHIa= I A e '-LOC n-j fcrv 1emDer oi uro 'KO Quo ............ Rod 606 Gi irradiat ed rost locatons I1 } X Burst 'IT 1070K -11, -12 %._C 0 L-n 0 -I, No-10 TeMDear1ure Rod 60. I.. 3-3 3-4 X Burst To-1115 K irrodicited I..
'A:
,. z I. - - I. -- '1 I PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, IO.C USA A. WIATetal 23

z a wg XL.nZW DT:aP

77=j:

iZJ Pending Issues : I

.......
- --

,- -1, 1,11.1--11...... 1.,, 1,
A,
. I ES= Corrosion and 1hy-better kept. L bigger the bylaons NSee references T to 9 < 150 I ..........I IN 9- .,
_ Htydrogen Uptace ot MB" Is. extrenwety low upper bound E~ CL 0(a C 4a)9E Zr Hydrided 600ppm Test Temperature (*C) PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D. C USA A KULLU T et al 24

p -. E -4"- t K Li

i. A.,s

'endino "P-X -a't 2 ~~ A T

• ~W4

-7 19 Irssues : Same Ten'eii big ge b d highe bt g 200 U 180 160 . ;-_140

O flag>

100 180 s60

. n At 40

-;20 PREBUS STLOC MEETING, October 231h, 2003, Washington, D. C USA A. MILLIAT et al 25

• r, 4 1zP R

z . e: ~ U Oa A ji Pending Issues: : A BUNDLE g It provides temperature f ifuel rod Temperatuz& field crucial top-rQd re ,r-,' PHEBUS STLOCMEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A. MAILLUAT et al 26

i; g% e-% r. t gI Z-Z,

t I , z Q 'I-L. am Aw Vic Wi f4"r -14 Pending Issues: U A..->. ,4 A., ..S-.,S, _...., i, :1 A i-. ,w,

• .'-.#--

-

• .

kbund1e blockage georneti o ai I,.. I I 165 171 177 183 189 195 201 207 213 219 distance from toh of heated zone fcnl 7_n_ __v! WJts PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A. AWLLIA T et al 27

=lRO ~rA Pending Issues: Ii A BUD~ A..:: Radial interaci . Blockage ge~i PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A. AMILLUT et al 28

11" 14% 1^ r. ei I V Z 5 Le -117 Ani, s.T-S4 Pending Issues: M bundle ? X A.. 1. No. 1 7IJAERI

50mm,

.~'The ~ PHEBUSSTLOCMEETING, October 23*4,2003, Washington, D.C USA A AWLLU T et al 29

Y.= = ti i Pending CLA 1200 BOO .0 "UN .U Issues: 40 TAPEUTURES PCT EASY Time (seconds) PREB US STLOC MEETING, October 23th,2003, WashingtonD.C USA A MALLLU T et al 30

.4w VA Al V -ZIA klN
41'1 o"'c Z,
Capitalized. jj
zz y Pending IssUes 1 I "A" -j Elm Are they auy-.
,
;iqu

.p ec qs
,,-,Ar-id d'i ue -,'iro s--, oc ge, 1, quenchin idd 't i, J-assembly
,Z 4
;
i 477 h' A4Y,

' T A
4. -7' Which 11W6uth ,e-ve, k 7 1*
SA

Beverly

',7 .1 PREBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C. USA A MfiJLLL4 T et al 31

w mp , a R r "
A M.'. N L ! 0.. i:t
=a =a "'*>2 $M ~ R~ ~ ~*i' TO DERIVE CRITERIA ...... :-:;,!";,I":,- -
:.4;ji""'
.I-izr

L Post Uncons 4z-; TAGC1E HEYDRAZCRCNOG JAERI

1. t^s*/ -rP zs >X4

>X S Quench/g s' g.... TO CHECK THAT CRITERIA ARE NOT. VIOLATED FOR REACTOR LOCAs WSN _w_ I 1.
- U r 111'
"- 1, -1 B"* , 4. M . I. Relocation Bundle Blockage Geometty And Heat Source Accumulatio-of Cladding Ox-j4 PHEBUS STLOC METING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, AC USA A AMUMT et al 32

IR ak; gm S* P4. ~ i' .::'-%A ¶4&tt4.A 2 '-4 4'4 -,'4..- I I Movie produce f tsmission tomr e

.-.....,w.

1, x %,.. 1-" zdle Blockage Geometry d Heat Source Accumulation I., .., 1 - ~. .'~:z '.i

t.

A:,., 4' .,1. PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23ls, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A AL4LUJA T et al 33

.1R". S W-W, tM t R Z .... 7
" Chris -Cra f t -1 Z-A S STLOC will be an,
Ju "A "Our e e-bun-le-k'eome ry X, U, e! he,
mwof
. source additi C., on phenomenaoft a, Je _7

I_, e, -x4 -0, 4, A_ A!t_
w 4 TESTS IN;' C, 4
I V
Z
4
21 t 0 9. ivf 4 N' 1
ji, Coefficient

• Teniperatu.

0 diff Characteristic A FIRST TEST .7 i It--- I X-1 7% Chiddhiff k,,
Wfiij' QQ pe "I"Do fil
hf-P"Impael Z A SECONi Di".0, PRERN 7t _7
M6d) A `
qr n 14
n "V 6' A'
l W'; 1.17-aff Or 11 YP .,e ock JoWj 7, -1.- PHEB US STLOC MEETiNG, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D. C. USA A ALMLIA T et al 34

the PHEBUWS Fclt.iyti a RN will take advantg L teko-o. accumulated whentwprVQSi ,A pro grainme withfrsfilwaru PHEBUS LOCA' IN ULDWDOWN TANK7 7 M FEW PUMP iAM IFIQNL;A# i MUMN ACCUMULATOR Phebus FP Caisson A PHEBUS STLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washlington, D.C USA A. MAWLLA Tet al 35

'I

no J'X
gR zw -% I 4
U:. k U I ; t to Z_- m as -Stj1 V P r PO -4
11/LWR fuel rod behaviourli6 'tA-i KfK 3346-March 1983 21Relocation of fuel fra g 31/NRC Generic Safety i 1Ui !A 41Behaviour of irradiate l._ 4i behaviour, 19-20th jughiE 511 PBF LOCA test LO GES

• A:'

.irnlatig th b~a-u ~ "has ofaLOCA, E., 1 a. PHEBUSSTLOC MEETING, October 23th, 2003, Washington, D.C USA A. MALLL4Tet al 36 IV}}