ML042190033

Draft Section a Operating

ML042190033
Person / Time
Site:	Millstone
Issue date:	07/19/2004
From:	Wilson M Dominion Nuclear Connecticut
To:	Conte R NRC/RGN-I/DRS/OSB
Conte R
References
50-423/04-301 50-423/04-301
Download: ML042190033 (80)

Text

Job Performance Measure Approval Sheet NRC Ad ministrative JPM SRO JPM A . l 1 of 10

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 2 of IO

1. JPM

Title:

Administrative Requirements for Shift Manning Activities - W.orking Hour Limitations JPM ID Number: SRO A.l Revision: 0 II. Initiated:

Nuclear Regulatory Commission 7 May 2004 Developer Date I I I. Reviewed:

Technical Reviewer Date IV. Approved:

Cognizant Plant Supervisor (optional) Date Nuclear Training Supervisor Date 2of 10

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 3 of IO

SUMMARY

OF CHANGES Change Description Date 3of 10

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 4 of IO Facility: Millstone Unit 3 . Student:

JPM ID Number: SRO A.l Revision: 0 Task

Title:

Administrative Requirements for Shift Manning Activities - Working Hour Limitations System: n/a Time Critical Task: ( ) YES ( X ) NO Validated Time (minutes): 15 Task Number(s):

Applicable To: SRO X RO X PEO WA Number: 2.1.5 WA Rating: 3.4 12.3 Ability to locate and use procedures and directives related to shift staffing and activities.

Method of Testing: Simulated Performance: Actual Performance: X Location: Classroom: X Simulator: In-Plant::

Task Standards: Applicant determines working hour limitations would be exceeded.

Examinee completes form OA 18-001 Authorization to Exceed Established Overtime Limits.

Required Materials: OA 18, Overtime Controls for All Personnel at Millstone Station Form OA 18-001 General

References:

OA 18, Overtime Controls for All Personnel at Millstone Station 4of10

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 5 of IO I will explain the initial conditions, which step(s) to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objectives for this JPM will be satisfied.

You may use any approved reference material normally available in the Control Room, including logs. Make all written reports, oral reports, alarm acknowledgements, and log entries as if the evolution was actually being performed.

Initial You are the Shift Manager for the off-going shift.

Conditions:

The time is 16:OO on Thursday, 22 July 2004.

You have just learned that one of the on-coming CROs can NOT report to work. Therefore, one CRO from your shift is required to holdover for up to four hours to maintain minimum shift manning requirements. Another CRO has been recalled from vacation and will report to work at 22:OO.

One CRO on your shift, Jane Doe, has volunteered to holdover. Her work history for the current shift (07:OO to 19:OO) is:

Saturday, 17 July 2004 OFF Sunday, 18 July2004 OFF 0 Monday, 19 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time Tuesday, 20 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time Wednesday, 21 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time Thursday, 22 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time Friday, 23 July 2004 Scheduled OFF Initiating DETERMINE WHETHER JANE DOE IS ABLE TO HOLDOVER FOR FOUR Cue: HOURS AFTER SHIFT WITHOUT VIOLATING WORKING HOUR LIMITATlONS .

ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS?

YOU MAY BEGIN.

• • • • NOTES TO EVALUATOR ****

I.Critical steps for this JPM are indicated by an asterisk after the step number. For the student to achieve a satisfactory grade, ALL critical steps must be completed correctly.

The students performance is graded by an Sfor satisfactory or a U for unsatisfactory on each step.

2. When the student states what hidher simulated action/observation would be, read the appropriate Cue.

3. If necessary, question the student for details of simulated actions/observations (Le. What are you looking at? or What are you observing?).

5of 10

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 6 of IO 6of 10

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 7 of IO Start Time:

DETERMINE WHETHER JANEDOE IS ABLE TO HOLDOVER FOR Examiner Cue FOUR HOURS AFTER SHIFT WITHOUT VIOLATING WORKING HOUR LIMITATlONS .

Applicant obtains/requests a copy of OA 18, Overtime Controls for All 1.

Station Personnel at Millstone Station.

Applicant determines that Jane Doe will

2. Applicant evaluates holdover time to exceed working hour limits because she determine if working hour limitations

• will work more than 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> in a 48 hour5.555556e-4 days <br />0.0133 hours <br />7.936508e-5 weeks <br />1.8264e-5 months <br /> are exceeded.

period.

Applicant obtains copy of Form OA 18-001.

Applicant completes Form OA 18-00 1 Applicant completes Section A.

0 Task or Duties portion should refer to or relate the safety significance of the CRO duties Refer to Answer Key. Exact wording is not 0 JUSTIFICATION portion should critical. Examiner must use judgment to refer to minimum staffing determine if performance is satisfactory.

requirements. May also refer to medical emergency.

0 Applicant signddates as Supervisor.

Applicant completes Section B.

Must check or mark c. More Applicant may also check or mark a. for than 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> within any 48- > I 6 hours6.944444e-5 days <br />0.00167 hours <br />9.920635e-6 weeks <br />2.283e-6 months <br /> straight or b. for > I 6 hours6.944444e-5 days <br />0.00167 hours <br />9.920635e-6 weeks <br />2.283e-6 months <br /> in a hour period. 24-hour period if Applicant elects to 0 Applicant signddates as authorize more than 4 hours4.62963e-5 days <br />0.00111 hours <br />6.613757e-6 weeks <br />1.522e-6 months <br />.

Manager or Designee.

Applicant indicates intent to forward Form OA 18-001 to the Operations TASK IS COMPLETE.

Director Stop Time:

• denotes critical step-7of I O

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 8 of IO Appendix C3 Form ES-C-I VERI FI CAT10N 0F COMPLET10N Job Performance Measure No.

Examinee's Name:

Examiner's Name:

Date performed:

Facility Eva1uator:

Number of attempts:

Time to complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response

Result: SAT or UNSAT Examiner's signature and date:

8 of 10

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 9 of IO 90f10

Job Performance Measure Guide Page i o of i o Student Handout JOBPERFORMANCE MEASURE INSTRUCTIONSHEET DIRECTIONS TO STUDENT When I tell you to begin, DETERMINE WHETHER JANE DOE IS ABLE TO HOLDOVER FOR FOUR HOURS AFTER SHIFT WITHOUT VIOLATING WORKING HOUR LIMITATIONS.

Initial Conditions You are the Shift Manager for the off-going shift.

The time is 16:OO on Thursday, 22 July 2004.

You have just learned that one of the on-coming CROs can NOT report to work.

Therefore, one CRO from your shift is required to holdover for up to four hours to maintain minimum shift manning requirements. Another CRO has been recalled from vacation and will report to work at 22:OO.

One CRO on your shift, Jane Doe, has volunteered to holdover. Her work history for the current shift (07:OO to 19:OO) is:

Saturday, 17 July 2004 OFF Sunday, 18 July 2004 OFF 0 Monday, 19 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time 0 Tuesday, 20 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time 0 Wednesday, 21 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time 0 Thursday, 22 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time Friday, 23 July 2004 Scheduled OFF 10 of 10

Job Performance Measure Approval Sheet NRC Administrative JPM SRO JPM A.2 1of8

~

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 2 of 8 I.. JPM

Title:

Determine the maximum rate of power increase and control rod withdrawal restrictions.

JPM ID Number: SRO A.2 Revision: 0 II. Initiated:

Nuclear Regulatory Commission I 2 May 2004 Developer Date III. Reviewed:

Technical Reviewer Date IV. Approved:

Cognizant Plant Supervisor (optional) Date Nuclear Training Supervisor Date 20f8

~-

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 3 of 8

SUMMARY

OF CHANGES Change Description Date 3of8

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 4 of 8 Facility: Millstone Unit 3 Student:

JPM ID Number: SRO A.3 Revision: 0 Task

Title:

Determine the maximum rate of power increase and control rod withdrawal restrictions.

System: n/a Time Critical Task: ( ) YES ( X ) NO Validated Time (minutes): 15 Task Number(s):

Applicable To: SRO X RO PEO WA Number: 2.1.25 WA Rating: 3.1 Ability to obtain and interpret station reference materials such as graphs, monographs, and tables which contain performance data.

Method of Testing: Simulated Performance: Actual Performance: X Location: Classroom: X Simulator: In-Plant::

Task Standards: 0 Applicant recognizes the Fuel Condition Category as Partially Conditioned up to power level, P, of 80% and rod position, N, of 218 steps on CBD.

0 Applicant correctly identifies the following limits:

+ 10% per hour to power level P where P=80%.

+ 4% over any 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br /> period, 7% over any 2 hour2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br /> period, 10% over any 3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> period to achieve a nominal 3% full power per hour rate, and

+ Control Rod Withdrawal restricted to 3 steps per hour above 218 steps on CBD.

Applicant correctly applies the limits to determine that schedule adherence is possible without exceeding authorized fuel condition load increase restrictions.

Required Materials: 0 Operating Procedure OP 3204, At Power Operations.

0 Attachment 4 of OP 3204 General

References:

Operating Procedure OP 3204, At Power Operations.

40f8

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 5 of 8 I will explain the initial conditions, which step(s) to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objectives for this JPM will be satisfied.

You may use any approved reference material normally available in the Control Room, including logs. Make all written reports, oral reports, alarm acknowledgements, and log entries as if the evolution was actually being performed.

Initial You are the Unit Supervisor of Millstone Generating Station, Unit 3. The plant Conditions: has recently completed a refueling outage and plant startup. When returning to power following this refueling outage, the plant reached 80% and then was forced to reduce power to 50%.

Specifically, on Wednesday, 14 July 2004 at 09:00, the plant reached 80%

reactor power. The plant remained at 80% power until Saturday, 17 July 2004 at 13:OO when a Main Feedwater Pump malfunctioned and had to be shutdown for repairs. The plant reached 50% power on Saturday, 17 July 2004 at 19:30.. Since then the plant has been operating steady at 50%

power and CBD step 218.

Now the time is Wednesday, 21 July 2004 at 08:OO hours. Main Feedwater Pump repairs and post-maintenance testing are complete and satisfactory.

The plant is ready to begin its return to full power in all other aspects.

According to the current schedule, the plant should be at full (100%) power by the end of shift today, Wednesday, 21 July 2004 at 18:OO hours.

Based on fuel conditioning alone, is it possible to reach 100% reactor power as scheduled? Assume that control rods will remain at CBD step 218 throughout the power ascension and that the power ascension begins immediately.

Initiating YOU ARE TO DETERMINE WHETHER THE PLANT CAN ACHIEVE 100%

Cue: POWER BY THE END OF SHIFT WITHOUT EXCEEDING ANY MANEUVERING LIMITS.

ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS?

YOU MAY BEGIN.

1. Critical 5 eps for this JPM are indicated by an asterisk after the step number. For the student to achieve a satisfactory grade, critical steps must be completed correctly.

The students performance is graded by an S for satisfactory or a U for unsatisfactory on each step.

2. When the student states what hidher simulated action/observation would be, read the appropriate Cue.

3. If necessary, question the student for details of simulated actions/observations (Le. What are you looking at? or What are you observing?).

50f8

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 6 o f 8 Start Time:

Applicant obtainshequests a copy of OP 3204, At Power Operation.

NOTE: Provide a copy of OP 3204, At

1. Applicant may only request Attachment Power Operation.

4, Fuel Condition Load Increase

- Restrictions.

Applicant reviews the initial conditions

2. None.

- to determine recent Dower historv.

3. Applicant correctly determines that the plant has been at 80% power and CBD

• step 218 for at least 72 hours8.333333e-4 days <br />0.02 hours <br />1.190476e-4 weeks <br />2.7396e-5 months <br />.

4. Applicant recognizes that the Fuel Applicant should state or write this Condition Category is Partially

• determination.

Conditioned to 80%.

5. Applicant determines that the Applicable Range of Power Level is

• 50% to 100% power.

6. Applicant recognizes the maximum NOTE: step can be conservatively read rate of power increase as 10% per as 3% per hour or 10% over any 3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />

• hour to 80% and 3% Der hour to 100%. period.

Applicant applies the identified limits to determine the following times:

Accept 9:00 or 9:40 because 10% in 3

7. 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> to raise power 30% (from hours reduces the required time to 9 50% to 80%).

• hours. Both interpretations are 6 hours6.944444e-5 days <br />0.00167 hours <br />9.920635e-6 weeks <br />2.283e-6 months <br />, 40 minutes to raise power acceptable.

20% (from 80% to 100%).

B Total time = 9 hour1.041667e-4 days <br />0.0025 hours <br />1.488095e-5 weeks <br />3.4245e-6 months <br />s: 40 minutes.

9. 4pplicant recognizes and reports that Based on fuel conditioning alone, it is there are I O hours scheduled to possible to reach full power by 18:OO (or

• Zomplete the power ascension. similar words).

N O i: I Order or sequence of performanc 1 is NOT critiial Stop Time:

6of8

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 7 of 8 Appendix C3 Form ES-C-I VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.

Examinee's Name:

Examiner's Name:

Date performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of attempts:

Time to complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response

Result: SAT or UNSAT Examiner's signature and date:

7of8

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 8 of 8 Student Handout JOBPERFORMANCE MEASURE INSTRUCTION SHEET DIRECTIONS TO STUDENT When I tell you to begin, YOU ARE TO DETERMINE WHETHER THE PLANT CAN ACHIEVE 100% POWER BY THE END OF SHIFT WITHOUT EXCEEDING ANY MANEUVERING LIMITS.

Initial Conditions You are the Unit Supervisor of Millstone Generating Station, Unit 3. The plant has recently completed a refueling outage and plant startup. When returning to power following this refueling outage, the plant reached 80% and then was forced to reduce power to 50%.

Specifically, on Wednesday, 14 July 2004 at 09:00, the plant reached 80% reactor power. The plant remained at 80% power until Saturday, 17 July 2004 at 13:OO when a Main Feedwater Pump malfunctioned and had to be shutdown for repairs.

The plant reached 50% power on Saturday, 17 July 2004 at 19:30.. Since then the plant has been operating steady at 50% power and CBD step 218.

Now the time is Wednesday, 21 July 2004 at 08:OO hours. Main Feedwater Pump repairs and post-maintenance testing are complete and satisfactory. The plant is ready to begin its return to full power in all other aspects.

According to the current schedule, the plant should be at full (100%) power by the end of shift today, Wednesday, 21 July 2004 at 18:OO hours.

Based on fuel conditioning alone, is it possible to reach 100% reactor power as scheduled? Assume that control rods will remain at CBD step 218 throughout the power ascension.

8of8

Job Performance Measure Approval Sheet NRC Administrative JPM SRO JPM A.3 1 of9

~~ ~

~~

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 2 of 9 I. JPM

Title:

Shutdown Safety Assessment Checklist Review and Addition JPM ID Number: SRO A.3 Revision: 0 II. Initiated:

Nuclear Regulatory Commission 24 May 2004 Developer Date I I I. Reviewed:

Technical Reviewer Date IV. Approved:

Cognizant Plant Supervisor (optional) Date Nuclear Training Supervisor Date 2of9

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 3 of 9

SUMMARY

OF CHANGES Change Description Date 3 of 9

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 4 of 9 Facility: Millstone Unit 3 Applicant:

JPM ID Number: SRO A.3 Revision: 0 Task

Title:

Shutdown Safety Assessment Checklist Review and Addition System: n/a Time Critical Task: ( ) YES ( X ) NO Validated Time (minutes): 15 Task Number(s):

Applicable To: SRO X RO X PEO WA Number: 2.2. I O WA Rating: 3.3 / 1.9 Knowledge of the process for determining if the margin of safety, as defined in the basis of any technical specification is reduced by a proposed change, test or experiment.

Applicable To: SRO X RO X PEO WA Number: 2.2.1 8 WA Rating: 3.6 / 2.3 Knowledge of the process for managing maintenance activities during shutdown operations.

Method of Testing: Simulated Performance: Actual Performance: X Location: Classroom: X SimuI ator: In-Plant::

Task Standards: Applicant accurately completes Form OP 3260A-004 and recognizes ORANGE condition for RCS Inventory Control.

Required Materials: 0 Operating Procedure OP 3260A, Conduct of Outages.

0 Form OP 326OA-004, Shutdown Safety Assessment Checklist General

References:

Operating Procedure OP 3260A, Conduct of Outages.

4 of 9

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 5 of 9 I will explain the initial conditions, which step(s) to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objectives for this JPM will be satisfied.

You may use any approved reference material normally available in the Control Room, including logs. Make all written reports, oral reports, alarm acknowledgements, and log entries as if the evolution was actually being performed.

You are the Work Control SRO during a refueling outage. The new core has been loaded and the plant is in the following condition:

Mode 5 RCS Pressure is 200 psia Pressurizer Level is 60% - cold calibrated scale.

ATrain is protected B Train unavailable for an electrical outage. Buss 34D is deenergized.

A& D Steam Generator levels are 50%; both available for steaming & feeding ATrain of RHR is in the cooidown mode.

ATrain of Spent Fuel Cooling is running The Spent Fuel Pool water level is normal.

ACHS Pump (3CHS*PlA) is in pull-to-lock (PTL)

ASIH Pump (3SHI*PIA) is in pull-to-lock (PTL)

Both offsite electrical power sources are available.

The Station Blackout Diesel-generator (SBO) is available.

The Shutdown Margin Monitor is available.

Containment closure is set.

RCS Boron Concentration is 2,100 ppm.

Shutdown Margin Calculated Boron Concentration is 1,950 ppm.

Dilution paths are tagged per SP 3604C.6 The RWST Level is greater than 1,000,000 gallons.

3RHS*V43 is tagged and locked closed.

Electrical Maintenance has asked you to authorize replacement of the breaker Initiating DETERMINE WHETHER YOU WILL AUTHORIZE ELECTRICAL Cue: MAINTENANCES REQUEST TO PERFORM WORK ON 3SIH*PIA.

ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS? YOU MAY BEGIN.

5of9

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 6 of 9 MAINTENANCE'S REQUEST TO PERFORM WORK ON 3SIH"PlA.

Applicant obtains/requests copies of Examiner provides copies of 1.

OP3260A and OP3260A-004 OP3260A and OP3260A-004

2.

• Circle " Aas the Drotected train TODof Form OP 326OA-004 Applicant marks appropriate boxes for

3. *

- RCS Decay Heat Removal

a.

• RHR Train " A All conditions satisfied to support natural circulation in the RCS VERIFY all of the following are satisfied to ensure two steam generators available and proper RCS conditions are established to support natural circulation:

Both available SG NR levels > 17% Value = 2 Condition = YELLOW 0 Capability to feed SGs w/ MD AFW Pp 0 Capability to steam available SGs

b.

• RCS pressurized or capable of being pressurized to between 170 psia and 330 psia prior to core boiling RCS openings being tracked RCS loops associated with the available SGs; filled, swept, vented, &

unisolated Pressurizer cold calibrated level 50%

mless a steam bubble is established in

he pressurizer Applicant marks appropriate boxes for 4*

SFC Decay Heat Removal Value = 2

a.

• 3FC Train A Condition = YELLOW

b. * > 23' pool level above fuel 4pplicant marks appropriate boxes for

5.

• nventorv rrain A CHS PP N C and associated flow Value = I

a. *

- 2ath Condition = ORANGE b.

-

• 3WST Level > 250,000 gallons c.

-

• 3RHS*V43 taaaed & Locked Shut Lakes credit for 3SIH"PlA availabili NOTE: this time. Critical task is for Applicar to recognize that taking 3SIH*PIA of service raises the INVENTORY risk :ondition from YELLOW to ORANC 6of9

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 7 of 9 Applicant marks appropriate boxes for

6.

• Power Availabilitv

a.

• A EDG

b.

• RSST Value = 4

c.

• NSST/Main Condition = GREEN SBO EDG

d.

• Applicant should recognize that time to boil is > 30 minutes.

Applicant marks appropriate boxes for

7.

• Reactivity

a.

• RCS Boron > required SDM Value = 4

b.

• lnvetorv FlowDaths 0-2 (1 Condition = GREEN

c.

• At least one SDM Monitor Train ODerable

d.

• Dilution paths tagged per OP 3604C.6

a.

• Applicant Containment marks appropriate boxes for

a.

• Containment Closure Set.

9. Pressurizer Surge Line Flooding

a. Reactor core refueled RCS DHR 2 Yellow SFC DHR 2 Yellow Inventory 1 Orange Applicant sums the points for each Key IO. Power Availability 4 Green

• Safety Function and circles the associated Reactivity 4 Yellow color condition.

Containment 1 Green See note followina Ster, 5 above.

If Applicant continues beyond st p 1.2.1 .j (page 9 orOP 3260A), dire iner Applicant to stop, evaluate checl list and make recommendations to Shift Manager (Examiner).

Applicant reports that Key Safety Function INVENTORY will become 11.

ORANGE if work proceeds on 3SIH*PIA.

12.

Applicant determines from Section 1.2.2 of OP 3260A that he does not have

• sufficient authority to authorize the requested work.

Examiner Cue I This JPM is comdete.

7of9

~~

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 8 of 9 Appendix C3 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.

Examinee's Name:

Examiner's Name:

Date performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of attempts:

Time to complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response

Result: SAT or UNSAT Examiner's signature and date:

8 of 9

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 9 of 9 Applicant Handout JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE INSTRUCTIONSHEET DIRECTIONS TO APPLICANT When I tell you to begin, DETERMINE WHETHER YOU WILL AUTHORIZE ELECTRICAL MAINTENANCES REQUEST TO PERFORM WORK ON 3SIH*PlA.

Initial Conditions You are the Work Control SRO during a refueling outage. The new core has been loaded and the plant is in the following condition:

0 Mode5 0 RCS Pressure is 200 psia 0 Pressurizer Level is 60% - cold calibrated scale.

0 ATrain is protected 0 B Train unavailable for an electrical outage. Buss 340 is deenergized.

A& D Steam Generator levels are 50%; both available for steaming & feeding 0 ATrain of RHR is in the cooldown mode.

0 ATrain of Spent Fuel Cooling is running 0 The Spent Fuel Pool water level is normal.

0 ACHS Pump (3CHS*PlA) is in pull-to-lock (PTL) 0 ASIH Pump (3SHI*PlA) is in pull-to-lock (PTL) 0 Both offsite electrical power sources are available.

0 The Station Blackout Diesel-generator (SBO) is available.

0 The Shutdown Margin Monitor is available.

0 Containment closure is set.

0 RCS Boron Concentration is 2,100 ppm.

0 Shutdown Margin Calculated Boron Concentration is 1,950 ppm.

Dilution paths are tagged per SP 3604C.6 The RWST Level is greater than 1,000,000 gallons.

3RHS*V43 is tagged and locked closed.

0 Electrical Maintenance has asked you to authorize replacement of the breaker for the A SIH (3SIH*PIA) pump.

9 of 9

~

Job Performance Measure Approval Sheet NRC Administrative JPM SRO JPM A.4 1 of9

Job Performance Measure Guide I. JPM

Title:

Determine and Perform Actions Required to Remove a Radiation Monitor from Service.

JPM ID Number: SRO A.4 Revision: 0 II. Initiated:

Nuclear Reaulatorv Commission 24 Mav 2004 Developer Date I II. Reviewed:

Technical Reviewer Date IV. Approved:

Cognizant Plant Supervisor (optional) Date Nuclear Training Supervisor Date 2of9

-~ ~~

Job Performance Measure Guide

SUMMARY

OF CHANGES 1 Chanae I Descrbtion I Date 3of9

Job Performance Measure Guide Facility: Millstone Unit 3 Student: .

JPM ID Number: SRO A.4 Revision: 0 Task

Title:

Determine and Perform Actions Required to Remove a Radiation Monitor from Service.

System: nla Time Critical Task: ( ) YES ( X ) NO Validated Time (minutes): 15 Task Number(s):

Applicable To: SRO X RO X PEO KIA Number: 2.3.1 KIA Rating: 3.0 12.6 Knowledge of I O CFR: 20 and related facility radiation control requirements.

Method of Testing: Simulated Performance: Actual Performance: X Location: Classroom: X Simulator: In-Plant::

Task Standards: Applicant determines the requirements of OP3250.62.

0 SRO Applicant performs those administrative requirements.

Required Materials: 0 Operating Procedure OP 3250.62, Removal and Restoration of Radiation Monitors.

REMODCM 0 Shift Manager Log - simulation General

References:

0 Operating Procedure OP 3250.62, Removal and Restoration of Radiation Monitors.

4of9

Job Performance Measure Guide Initial Conditions: You are the Work Control Supervisor at Millstone Generating Station Unit 3. It is 0200 in the morning. I&C wishes to perform emergent SRO maintenance on 3HVR*REI OB, Ventilation Vent Stack radiation monitor.

Initiating Cue: YOU ARE TO DETERMINE AND PERFORM THE ACTIONS REQUIRED TO REMOVE 3HVR*RElOB FROM SERVICE.

ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS?

YOU MAY BEGIN.

• • • • NOTES TO EVALUATOR ****

1. Critical steps for this JPM are indicated by an asterisk and unshaded box after the step number. For the student to achieve a satisfactory grade, & LJ critical steps must be completed correctly. The students performance is graded by an S for satisfactory or a U for unsatisfactory on each step.

2. When the student states what his/her simulated action/observation would be, read the appropriate Cue.

3. If necessary, question the student for details of simulated actions/observations (i.e. What are you looking at? or What are you observing?).

50f9

Job Performance Measure Guide Start Time:

Applicant obtains/requests:

0 OP 3250.62, Removal and Restoration of Radiation Monitors.

0 SP 3883 Normal Vent Rad Monitor System - Inoperative REMODCM.

0 3670.2-004, 3HVR*RE1OB, Temporary Sampling Surveillance.

0 3670.1-003,3HVR-REI OA & 3HVR-I OB Stack Flow Surveillance.

A phone call may be used to notify Health Physics and Chemistry NOTE 3-part Departments of a radiation monitor being removed from service.

preceding forms no However, a three part memo must be used to notify Health Physics Step longer and Chemistry Departments of any actions required, e.g., sample 4.1 .I used.

, rigs, temporary monitors, etc.

NOTIFY Health Physics Applicant notifies Health Physics that 4.1 .I Department which radiation 3HVR*RE1OB will be secured. Telephone monitor will be off line. I call is adeauate for this notification.

Refer to Attachment 3 and

• PERFORM specified Applicant refers to Attachment 3 of OP responses for the radiation 3250.62 and determines that Response 2, 4.1.2 monitor being removed from 5, 6, 8, & 19 are required.

service.

Examiner Cue: All Chemistry

• CONTACT Chemistry Department notifications are complete.

Department in writing for sampling to meet Att A, MS3 no longer uses 3-part forms. Proper Requirements.

Act 2 notification is a phone call followed by a Condition Report.

IF radiation monitor indicates Examiner Cue: The Radiation Monitor OFF-LINE, that rad monitor is does NOT indicate OFF-LINE Att A, inoperable, RECORD all Act 5 applicable actions in the SM Applicant recognizes that Response 5 is log. not applicable.

• Applicant states that SP 3670.2-004 must Complete SP 3670.2-004, be completed/performed.

3HVR*RE1OB Temporary Att A, Sampling Surveillance.

Examiner Cue: PEOs are performing SP Act 6 3670.2-004 every 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />.

6of9

Job Performance Measure Guide

• Applicant states that SP 3670.1-003 must Complete SP 3670.1-003, be -completed.

3HVR-RE10 A & 3HVR-Att A, REIOB Stack Flow Examiner Cue: BOP RO is performing Act 8 Surveillance 3670.1-003 every 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />.

Applicant refers to REMODCM and determines that Continuous Operation is permitted provided best efforts to repair are Refer To REMODCM Section exerted and that Action Statements A, B, C

• V.C.2 and Table V.C-3, are complied with:

Radioactive Gaseous Effluent A - grab samples every 12 hours1.388889e-4 days <br />0.00333 hours <br />1.984127e-5 weeks <br />4.566e-6 months <br /> /

Att A, Instrumentation, and analyzed within 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> (Chemistry)

Act 19 PERFORM applicable actions. B - continuous sampling with auxiliary equipment (3670.2-004 & Chemistry)

C - estimate flow rate every 4 hours4.62963e-5 days <br />0.00111 hours <br />6.613757e-6 weeks <br />1.522e-6 months <br /> (3670.1-003).

IF one of the following radiation monitors is being removed from Applicant indicates that Chemistry must be

• service, REQUEST Chemistry notified to perform SP 3883 for refer to the listed procedure 3HVR*RElOB.

and perform applicable actions:

4.1.3 SP 3883, For 3HVR*RE1OB: This surveillance satisfies Chemistrys Normal Vent Rad Monitor sampling requirements.

Svstem InoDerative SRO Applicants make a log entry to open LCO REMODCM V.C.2.b (30 days to restore Operability and, if unsuccessful, explain in next . . . report why not corrected in ENSURE all applicable T/S, timely manner.

TRM, and REMODCM actions 4.1.4 REMODCM V.C.2., Table V.C-3, Lines are recorded in Shift Manager Log. 1.a. thru e. (Actions A, B, C). best efforts to repair &

A - grab samples every 12 hours1.388889e-4 days <br />0.00333 hours <br />1.984127e-5 weeks <br />4.566e-6 months <br /> B - continuous sampling, analyzed every 7 days C - flow rate estimate everv 4 hours4.62963e-5 days <br />0.00111 hours <br />6.613757e-6 weeks <br />1.522e-6 months <br />.

Stop Time:

• denotes critical step-7of9

Job Performance Measure Guide Appendix C3 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.

Examinee's Name:

Examiner's Name:

Date performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of attempts:

Time to complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response

Result: SAT or UNSAT Examiner's signature and date:

8 of 9

Job Performance Measure Guide Student Handout - SRO Applicants JOBPERFORMANCE MEASURE INSTRUCTION SHEET DIRECTIONS TO STUDENT When I tell you to begin, YOU ARE TO DETERMINE AND PERFORM THE ACTIONS REQUIRED TO REMOVE SHVR*RElOB FROM SERVICE.

Initial Conditions You are the Work Control Supervisor at Millstone Generating Station Unit 3. It is 02:OO in the morning. I&C wishes to perform emergent maintenance on 3HVR*REl OB, Ventilation Vent Stack radiation monitor.

9 of 9

Job Performance Measure NRC Administrative JPM SRO JPM A.5 1of9

Job Performance Measure

1. JPM

Title:

Emergency Plan Classification for General Emergency JPM ID Number: SRO A.5 Revision: 0 II. Initiated:

Nuclear Regulatory Commission I 2 Mav 2004 Deve1oper Date Ill. Reviewed:

Technical Reviewer Date IV. Approved:

Cognizant Plant Supervisor (optional) Date Nuclear Training Supervisor Date 2 of 9

Job Performance Measure

SUMMARY

OF CHANGES Change Description Date 3 of 9

Job Performance Measure Facility: Millstone Unit 3 Student:

JPM ID Number: SRO A.5 Revision: 0 Task

Title:

Emergency Plan Classification for General Emergency System: n/a Time Critical Task: ( X ) YES ( ) NO Validated Time (minutes): 30 Task Number(s):

Applicable To: SRO X RO PEO K/A Number: 2.4.41 WA Rating: 4.1 / 2.3 Method of Testing: Simulated Performance: Actual Performance: X Location: Classroom: X Simulator: In-Plant::

Task Standards: + Determine the EAL and State Posture Code

+ Determine the minimum required PAR Required Materials: MP-26-EPI-FAP06-003 MP-26-EPl-FAP-01-001 MP-26-EPI-FAPO6 0 MP-26-EPI-FAP06-005 General

References:

4 of 9

Job Performance Measure

• CXREADTO THE STUDENT""

I will explain the initial conditions, which step(s) to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objectives for this JPM will be satisfied.

You may use any approved reference material normally available in the Control Room, including logs. Make all written reports, oral reports, alarm acknowledgements, and log entries as if the evolution was actually being performed.

You are the Shift Manager at Millstone Generating Station, Unit 3 on Wednesday, 19 August 2004. The time is 14:05. Emergency Diesel Generator 3EGS*EGA is inoperable and undergoing emergent corrective maintenance. 3EGS*EGA operability can NOT be restored in less than 16 hours1.851852e-4 days <br />0.00444 hours <br />2.645503e-5 weeks <br />6.088e-6 months <br />. The plant is at 100% power and no unusual evolutions are planned.

The following events occur in quick succession:

1. The plant loses off-site power (LOOP) and the plant trips,

2. Turbine Drive Auxiliary Feedwater Pump (TDAFW), 3FWA*P2, does NOT start,

3. Emergency diesel generator 3EGS*EGB started BUT its output breaker did NOT close. Attempts to close the 3EGS*EGB output breaker remotely from the Control Room have failed,

4. Steam Generator Narrow Range levels are currently 7% and lowering.

The Unit Supervisor dispatches a Plant Equipment Operator (PEO) to investigate the problem with the 3EGS*EGB output breaker. Shortly after leaving the Control Room, the PEO reports that the breaker housing is bulging and charred.

You call CONVEX to explain that the unit has tripped and currently has no AC power.

CONVEX reports back that a blackout throughout the region has occurred and she has no way to provide off-site power to Millstone. Duration of the blackout is currently estimated at 14 hours1.62037e-4 days <br />0.00389 hours <br />2.314815e-5 weeks <br />5.327e-6 months <br />.

The current wind speed is less than one (1) mile per hour. The current wind direction is from 010 and into 190.

A PEO dispatched to TDAFW 3FWA*P2 is still investigating.

5of9

Job Performance Measure DETERMINE THE APPLICABLE EMERGENCY ACTION LEVEL AND MAKE ANY APPROPRIATE PROTECTIVE ACTION RECOMMENDATION.

This is a time critical task.

0 You have 15 minutes to determine the Emergency Action Level and State Posture Code.

0 You have 15 minutes after classifying the event to determine the minimum required PAR.

ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS?

YOU MAY BEGIN.

Notes to Examiner

1. Critical steps for this JPM are indicated by an asterisk after the step number. For the student to achieve a satisfactory grade, critical steps must be completed correctly.

The students performance is graded by an Sfor satisfactory or a U for unsatisfactory on each step.

2. When the student states what his/her simulated action/observation would be, read the appropriate Cue.

3. If necessary, question the student for details of simulated actions/observations (i.e. What are you looking at? or What are you observing?).

6of9

iten Standard YOU ARE TO DETERN NE THE APPLICABLE EMERGENCY ACT1 liner Cue LEVEL AND MAKE AN ' APPROPRIATE PROTECTIVE ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS E: I Record the Start Time I Applicant obtains or requests copy Of MP-26-EPI-FAP06-003.

Applicant may request copies of:

MP-26-EPI-FAP-01-001, CR-DSEO Checklist MP-26-EPI-FAPO6, Classification and PARs NOTE: Provide copies when Applicant MP-26-EPI-FAP06-005, CR requests or seeks to obtain the procedure.

PARs MP-26-EPI-FAP07, Notifications & Comms MP-26-EPI-FAP07-001, Incident Report Form Applicant recognizes a LOSS OF A loss of off-site power, unavailability on VOLTAGE ON BUSES 34C AND 2.* one EDG and failure to the available EDG 34D (STATION BLACKOUT output breaker deenergizes 34C & 34D DIESEL CANNOT BE CREDITED).

Entry conditions for EOP 35 FR-H.l are:

Applicant recognizes HEAT SINK -

3.* Minimum AFW flow not verified and RED.

All SG narrow range levels 8%

Applicant may conclude that This issue is arguable and not necessary to RESTORATION OF POWER TO recognizing that General Emergency PGI 4.

AT LEAST ONE BUS IS NOT exists because critical safety function LIKELY WITHIN FOUR HOURS HEAT SINK - RED exists.

Applicant reviews MP-26-EPI-Loss of voltage on both 34C and 34D FAP06-003 and determines that a 5.* AND NRC EAL of GENERAL Heat Sink - Red EMERGENCY. PGI exists.

Applicant reviews MP-26-EPI-FAPO6-003 and determines that the Tables are color coded to reflect the 6.*

Dlock for PGI is the same color as State Posture.

State Posture BRAVO NO'

- is Completed I 7.* Applicant indicates the minimum required 105 to determine the PAR. PAR is to evacuate a 2 mile radius.

N01 In Recommendation is Completed 70f9

Appendix C3 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.

Examinee's Name:

Examiner's Name:

Date performed:

FaciIity EvaIuator:

Number of attempts:

Time to complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response

Result: SAT or UNSAT Examiner's signature and date:

%of9

STUDENT HANDOUT JOBPERFORMANCE MEASURE INSTRUCTION SHEET DIRECTIONS TO STUDENT When I tell you to begin, YOU ARE TO DETERMINE THE APPLICABLE EMERGENCY ACTION LEVEL AND MAKE ANY APPROPRIATE PROTECTIVE ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS.

Initial Conditions You are the Shift Manager at Millstone Generating Station, Unit 3 on Wednesday, 21 July 2004. Emergency Diesel Generator 3EGS*EGA is inoperable and undergoing emergent corrective maintenance. 3EGS*EGA operability can NOT be restored in less than 16 hours1.851852e-4 days <br />0.00444 hours <br />2.645503e-5 weeks <br />6.088e-6 months <br />. The plant is at 100% power and no unusual evolutions are planned.

The following events occur in quick succession:

1. The plant loses off-site power (LOOP) and trips,

2. Turbine Drive Auxiliary Feedwater Pump (TDAFW), 3FWAXP2,does NOT start,

3. Emergency diesel generator 3EGS*EGB started BUT its output breaker did NOT close. Attempts to close the 3EGS*EGB output breaker remotely from the Control Room have failed,

4. Steam Generator Narrow Range levels are currently 7% and lowering.

The Unit Supervisor dispatches a Plant Equipment Operator (PEO) to investigate the problem with the 3EGS*EGB output breaker. Shortly after leaving the Control Room, the PEO reports that the breaker housing is bulging and charred.

You call CONVEX to explain that the unit has tripped and currently has no AC power.

CONVEX reports back that a blackout throughout the region has occurred and she has no way to provide off-site power to Millstone. Duration of the blackout is currently estimated at 14 hours1.62037e-4 days <br />0.00389 hours <br />2.314815e-5 weeks <br />5.327e-6 months <br />.

A PEO dispatched to TDAFW 3FWA*P2 is still investigating.

The current wind speed is one (I) mile per hour. The current wind direction is from 010 and into 190.

This is a time critical task.

0 Within 15 minutes, determine the Emergency Action Level and State Posture Code..

0 Within 15 minutes of classifying the event, determine the minimum required PAR.

Emergency Action Level (EAL)

State Posture Code Protective Action Recommendation (PAR) 9 of 9

~-

Job Performance Measure Guide Page Iof 8 NRC Ad minist rat ive JPM RO JPM A . l

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 2 of 8

1. JPM

Title:

Administrative Requirements for Shift Manning Activities - Working Hour Limitations.

JPM ID Number: RO A.1 Revision: 0 II. Initiated:

Nuclear Reaulatorv Commission 12 May 2004 Developer Date III. Reviewed:

Technical Reviewer Date IV. Approved:

Cognizant Plant Supervisor (optional) Date Nuclear Training Supervisor Date

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 3 of 8

SUMMARY

OF CHANGES Change Description Date

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 4 of 8 Facility: Millstone Unit 3 Student:

JPM ID Number: RO A.l Revision: 0 Task

Title:

Administrative Requirements for Shift Manning Activities - Working Hour Limitations System: n/a Time Critical Task: ( ) YES ( X ) NO Validated Time (minutes): 15 Task Number(s):

Applicable To: SRO X RO X PEO WA Number: 2.1 .I WA Rating: 3.8 / 3.7 Knowledge of conduct of operations requirements.

Method of Testing: Si muIated Performance: Actual Performance: X Location: Classroom: X Simulator: In-Plant::

Task Standards: Applicant determines working hour limitations would be exceeded.

Required Materials: OA 18, Overtime Controls for All Personnel at Millstone Station Form OA 18-001 GeneraI

References:

OA 18, Overtime Controls for All Personnel at Millstone Station

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 5 of 8 I will explain the initial conditions, which step(s) to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objectives for this JPM will be satisfied.

You may use any approved reference material normally available in the Control Room, including logs. Make all written reports, oral reports, alarm acknowledgements, and log entries as if the evolution was actually being performed.

Initial You have recently been relieved as Primary Reactor Operator and traveled Conditions: home. The time is 19:45 on Thursday, I 9 October 2006. The plant was steady state at 100% power when you left. You are now watching television and enjoying a glass of ice tea.

The night shift Work Control Supervisor has called to ask if you can report back to work. At 19:15, your earlier relief, Jane Doe, experienced severe chest pains and was taken to the hospital. This has left the crew below minimum staffing requirements. The Work Control Supervisor has arranged for another NRC licensed Reactor Operator, Harry Callahan, to work the shift.

However, Harry cannot get to work before 23:OO.

Your current work history is:

0 Saturday, 17 July 2004 OFF Sunday, 18 July2004 OFF Monday, I 9 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time 0 Tuesday, 20 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time 0 Wednesday, 21 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time 0 Thursday, 22 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time 0 Friday, 23 July 2004 Scheduled OFF What should you tell the Work Control Supervisor?

Initiating DETERMINE WHETHER YOU ARE ABLE TO REPORT TO WORK Cue: IMMEDIATELY WITHOUT VIOLATING WORKING HOUR LIMITATIONS.

ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS?

YOU MAY BEGIN.

• student to achieve a satisfactory grade, critical steps must be completed correctly.

The students performance is graded by an Sfor satisfactory or a U for unsatisfactory on each step.

2. When the student states what hidher simulated action/observation would be, read the appropriate Cue.

3. If necessary, question the student for details of simulated actions/observations (Le. What are you looking at? or What are you observing?).

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 6 of 8 Start Time:

WITHOUT VIOLATING WORKING HOUR LIMITATIONS OR FITNESS FOR DUTY REQUIREMENTS.

I Applicant may obtainhequest a NOTE: Provide a copy of OA 18, Overtime copy of OA 18, Overtime Controls Controls for All Station Personnel at for All Station Personnel at Millstone Station. Applicant may request a Millstone Station. procedure list to determine the appropriate course of action.

2 Applicant evaluates holdover time Applicant determines that he will exceed

• to determine if working hour working hour limits because he will work limitations are exceeded. more than 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> in a 48 hour5.555556e-4 days <br />0.0133 hours <br />7.936508e-5 weeks <br />1.8264e-5 months <br /> period.

NOTE: Applicant may merely state that he will exceed overtime limits. In that case, prompt the Applicant to state what specific limit will be exceeded.

3. Applicant reports that he:

0 will exceed overtime limits if he

• reports to work as requested (or similar words).

I Examinercue I This JPM is complete.

Stop Time:

• denotes critical step-

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 7 of 8 Appendix C3 Form ES-C-I VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.

Examinee's Name:

Examiner's Name:

Date performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of attempts:

Time to complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response

Result: SAT or UNSAT Examiner's signature and date:

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 8 of 8 Student Handout JOBPERFORMANCE MEASURE INSTRUCTIONSHEET DIRECTIONS TO STUDENT When I tell you to begin, DETERMINE WHETHER YOU ARE ABLE TO REPORT IMMEDIATELY WITHOUT VIOLATING WORKING HOUR LIMITATIONS.

Initial Conditions You have recently been relieved as Primary Reactor Operator and traveled home.

The time is 19:45 on Thursday, 19 October 2006. The plant was steady state at 100%

power when you left. You are now watching television and enjoying a glass of ice tea.

The night shift Work Control Supervisor has called to ask if you can report back to work. At 19:15, your earlier relief, Jane Doe, experienced severe chest pains and was taken to the hospital. This has left the crew below minimum staffing requirements.

The Work Control Supervisor has arranged for another NRC licensed Reactor Operator, Harry Callahan, to work the shift. However, Harry cannot get to work before 23:OO.

Your current work history is:

0 Saturday, 17 July 2004 OFF 0 Sunday, 18 July 2004 OFF 0 Monday, 19 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time 0 Tuesday, 20 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time 0 Wednesday, 21 July 200407:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time 0 Thursday, 22 July 2004 07:OO to 19:OO excluding turnover time 0 Friday, 23 July 2004 Scheduled OFF What should you tell the Work Control Supervisor?

- ~

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 1 of 8 NRC Administrative JPM RO JPM A.2

~~

Job Performance Measure Guide Page z of 8

1. JPM

Title:

Determine the maximum rate of power increase and control rod withdrawal restrictions.

JPM ID Number: RO A.2 Revision: 0 II. Initiated:

Nuclear Regulatory Commission I 2 Mav 2004 Developer Date I l l . Reviewed:

Technical Reviewer Date IV. Approved:

Cognizant Plant Supervisor (optional) Date Nuclear Training Supervisor Date

~-

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 3 of 8

SUMMARY

OF CHANGES Change Description Date

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 4 of 8 Facility: Millstone Unit 3 Student:

JPM ID Number: RO A.2 Revision: 0 Task

Title:

Determine the maximum rate of power increase and control rod withdrawal restrictions.

System: nla Time Critical Task: ( ) YES ( X ) NO Validated Time (minutes): 15 Task Number(s):

Applicable To: SRO X RO PEO WA Number: 2.1.25 WA Rating: 3.1 Ability to obtain and interpret station reference materials such as graphs, monographs, and tables which contain performance data.

Method of Testing: Simulated Performance: Actual Performance: X Location: Classroom: X Simulator: In-Plant::

Task Standards: 0 Applicant recognizes the Fuel Condition Category as Partially Conditioned up to power level, P, of 80% and rod position, N, of 218 steps on CBD.

0 Applicant correctly identifies the following limits:

+ 10% per hour to power level P where P=80%.

+ 4% over any 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br /> period, 7% over any 2 hour2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br /> period, 10% over any 3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> period to achieve a nominal 3% full power per hour rate, and

+ Control Rod Withdrawal restricted to 3 steps per hour above 218 steps on CBD.

0 Applicant correctly determines the minimum time as 9 hour1.041667e-4 days <br />0.0025 hours <br />1.488095e-5 weeks <br />3.4245e-6 months <br />s: 40 minutes.

Required Materials: 0 Operating Procedure OP 3204, At Power Operations.

Attachment 4 of OP 3204 General

References:

Operating Procedure OP 3204, At Power Operations.

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 5 of 8 I will explain the initial conditions, which step(s) to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objectives for this JPM will be satisfied.

You may use any approved reference material normally available in the Control Room, including logs. Make all written reports, oral reports, alarm acknowledgements, and log entries as if the evolution was actually being performed.

Initial You are the Reactor Operator of Millstone Generating Station, Unit 3. The Conditions: plant has recently completed a refueling outage and plant startup. When returning to power following this refueling outage, the plant reached 80% and then was forced to reduce power to 50%.

Specifically, on Wednesday, 14 July 2004 at 09:00, the plant reached 80%

reactor power. The plant remained at 80% power until Saturday, 17 July 2004 at 13:OO when a Main Feedwater Pump malfunctioned and had to be shutdown for repairs. The plant reached 50% power on Saturday, 17 July 2004 at 19:30.. Since then the plant has been operating steady at 50%

power and CBD step 218.

Now the time is Wednesday, 21 July 2004 at 08:OO hours. Main Feedwater Pump repairs and post-maintenance testing are complete and satisfactory.

The plant is ready to begin its return to full power in all other aspects.

Based on fuel conditioning alone, what is the minimum time it will take to reach 100% reactor power? Assume that control rods remain at CBD step 218 throughout the power ascension.

Initiating YOU ARE TO DETERMINE THE MINIMUM TIME REQUIRED TO REACH Cue: FULL POWER BASED ON FUEL CONDITIONING ALONE.

ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS?

YOU MAY BEGIN.

1. Critical ! eps for this JPM are indicated by an asterisk after the step number. For the student to achieve a satisfactory grade, critical steps must be completed correctly.

The students performance is graded by an Sfor satisfactory or a U for unsatisfactory on each step.

2. When the student states what his/her simulated action/observation would be, read the appropriate T ue.

3. If necessary, question the student for details of simulated actions/observations (Le. What are you looking at? or What are you observing?).

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 6 of 8 Start Time:

INCREASE AND CONTROL ROD WITHDRAWAL RESTRICTIONS.

Applicant obtainshequests a copy of I OP 3204,At Power Operation.

NOTE: Provide a copy of OP 3204,At I. Applicant may only request Attachment Power Operation.

4, Fuel Condition Load Increase Restrictions. I Applicant reviews the initial conditions

2. None.

to determine recent power history.

3. Applicant correctly determines that the plant has been at 80% power and CBD

• step 218 for at least 72 hours8.333333e-4 days <br />0.02 hours <br />1.190476e-4 weeks <br />2.7396e-5 months <br />.

4. Applicant recognizes that the Fuel Applicant should state or write this Condition Category is Partially determination.

• Conditioned to 80%.

5. Applicant determines that the Applicable Range of Power Level is

• 50% to 100% power.

Applicant recognizes the maximum

6. NOTE: step can be conservatively read rate of power increase as 10% per as 3% per hour or 10% over any 3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />

• hour to 80% and nominally 3% per period.

- hour to 100%.

Applicant applies the identified limits to I determine the following times:

0 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> to raise power 30% (from Accept 9:00or 9:40because 10% in 3

7. hours reduces the required time to 9 50% to 80%).

• hours. Both interpretations are 0 6 hours6.944444e-5 days <br />0.00167 hours <br />9.920635e-6 weeks <br />2.283e-6 months <br />, 40 minutes to raise power acceptable.

20% (from 80% to 100%).

0 Total time = 9 hour1.041667e-4 days <br />0.0025 hours <br />1.488095e-5 weeks <br />3.4245e-6 months <br />s: 40 minutes.

8. Applicant reports or writes that it will take 9:00or 9:40hours to reach full power

• based on fuel conditioning alone.

NO Stop Time:

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 7 of 8 Appendix C3 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.

Examinee's Name:

Examiner's Name:

Date performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of attempts:

Time to complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response

Result: SAT or UNSAT Examiner's signature and date:

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 8 of 8 Student Handout JOBPERFORMANCE MEASURE INSTRUCTION SHEET DIRECTIONS TO STUDENT When I tell you to begin, YOU ARE TO DETERMINE THE MINIMUM TIME REQUIRED TO REACH FULL POWER BASED ON FUEL CONDITIONING ALONE.

Initial Conditions You are the Reactor Operator of Millstone Generating Station, Unit 3. The plant has recently completed a refueling outage and plant startup. When returning to power following this refueling outage, the plant reached 80% and then was forced to reduce power to 50%.

Specifically, on Wednesday, 14 July 2004 at 09:00, the plant reached 80% reactor power. The plant remained at 80% power until Saturday, 17 July 2004 at 13:OO when a Main Feedwater Pump malfunctioned and had to be shutdown for repairs.

The plant reached 50% power on Saturday, 17 July 2004 at 19:30.. Since then the plant has been operating steady at 50% power and CBD step 218.

Now the time is Wednesday, 21 July 2004 at 08:OO hours. Main Feedwater Pump repairs and post-maintenance testing are complete and satisfactory. The plant is ready to begin its return to full power in all other aspects.

Based on fuel conditioning alone, what is the minimum time it will take to reach 100%

reactor power? Assume that control rods remain at CBD step 218 throughout the power ascension.

Job Performance Measure Guide Page Iof I O NRC Administrative JPM RO JPM A.3

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 2 of IO I. JPM

Title:

Review a Completed Technical Specification Surveillance and Take Appropriate Follow-up Actions JPM ID Number: RO A.3 Revision: 0 II. Initiated:

Nuclear Regulatow Commission 14 May 2004 Developer Date II I. Reviewed:

Technical Reviewer Date IV. Approved:

Cognizant Plant Supervisor (optional) Date Nuclear Training Supervisor Date

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 3 of i o

SUMMARY

OF CHANGES Change Description Date

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 4 of IO Facility: . Millstone Unit 3 Student:

JPM ID Number: SRO A.2 Revision: 0 Task

Title:

Review a Completed Technical Specification Surveillance and Take Appropriate Follow-up Actions System: n/a Time Critical Task: ( ) YES ( X ) NO Validated Time (minutes): 15 Task Number(s):

Applicable To: SRO X RO X PEO WA Number: 2.2.1 2 WA Rating: 3.4 / 3.0 Method of Testing: Simulated Performance: Actual Performance: X Location: Classroom: X Simulator: In-Plant::

Task Standards: 0 Applicant identifies & corrects math error.

0 Applicant recognizes that 3CHS*P2A vibrations are outside the immediate action range, declares 3CHS*P2A inoperable.

Required Materials: 0 Surveillance Procedure SP 3604C.4, Boric Acid Pump 3CHS*P2A Operational Readiness Test.

0 Surveillance Form SP 3604C.4-001, Boric Acid Pump 3CHS*P2A Operational Readiness Test.

ENG Form 31121-008, IST Pump Test Plan for 3CHS*P2A.

0 Engineering Procedure EN 31 121, IST Pump Operational Readiness Evaluation.

Millstone Generating Station, Unit 3 Technical Specifications.

Millstone Generating Station, Unit 3, Technical Requirements Manual.

General

References:

Engineering Procedure EN 31 121, IST Pump Operational Readiness Evaluation

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 5 of IO

~ ~ ~~

• • • READ TO THE STUDENT*"

I will explain the initial conditions, which step(s) to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objectives for this JPM will be satisfied.

You may use any approved reference material normally available in the Control Room, including logs. Make all written reports, oral reports, alarm acknowledgements, and log entries as if the evolution was actually being performed.

JPM Number: SRO A.2 Revision: 0 Initial Conditions: You are the Work Control RO at Millstone Generating Station, Unit 3.

The crew has just completed Technical Specification Surveillance SP 3604C.4, Boric Acid Pump 3CHS*P2A Operational Readiness Test. The Work Control Supervisor has asked you to review the completed surveillance for any potential problems.

When I tell you to begin, YOU ARE TO REVIEW THE COMPLETED SURVEILLANCE AND, IF NECESSARY, RECOMMEND APPROPRIATE FOLLOW-UP ACTIONS.

Initiating Cue: YOU ARE TO REVIEW THE COMPLETED SURVEILLANCE AND, IF NECESSARY, RECOMMEND APPROPRIATE FOLLOW-UP ACTIONS.

ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS?

YOU MAY BEGIN.

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 6 of IO I **** NOTES TO EVALUATOR ****

1. Critical steps for this JPM are indicated by an asterisk and unshaded box after the step

~ number. For the student to achieve a satisfactory grade, critical steps must be completed correctly. The students performance is graded by an Sfor satisfactory or a U for unsatisfactory on each step.

2. When the student states what hidher simulated action/observation would be, read the appropriate Cue.

3. If necessary, question the student for details of simulated actions/observations (i.e. What are you looking at? or What are you observing?).

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 7 of IO Start Time:

I REVIEW THE COMPLETED SURVEILLANCE AND, IF NECESSARY, P~

Examiner Cue

- I TAKE FOLLOW-UP AC IONS.

1. Applicant obtains/requests: NOTE: Provide the requested procedures SP3604C.4. now or when requested. All procedures SP 36046.4-001. may be distributed at start of JPM if ENG Form 31121-008. administering to more than one Applicant 0 EN31121. simultaneously.

0 Technical Specifications.

0 Technical Requirements

- Manual.

2. Applicant recognizes that the NOTE: Provide a copy of Form OA 18-001 surveillance was completed before to applicant.

- its late date

3. Applicant recognizes that the test

- equipment is in calibration.

4.* Applicant recognizes that I

Applicant recognition that it is a calculated pump d/p at step transposition error is not critical.

- 4.2.21 .c.l) is calculated incorrectly.

5. Applicant recognizes that the check Applicant may recognize that the off line valve d/p 3CHS*V296 is within T/S and on line values are transposed - not

- Acceptance Criteria. critical

6. Applicant recognizes that the make up flow to VCT at step 4.2.22.d meets acceptance criteria.

7. Applicant reviews ENG Form 31121-008 and recoanizes that:

A.* Vibration Data Point MOV is above This data point should be circled per EN the Normal Vibration Range but 31121 Step 4.3.4.

- below the Maximum Limit.

B.* Vibration Data Point MIH is above This data point should be annotated the Maximum Limit. UNSAT and circled. The Test Plan should be annotated UNSAT. The Surveillance Form should be annotated UNSAT at step

- 4.3.1 5. See EN 31121 Step 4.3.5.

8. Applicant reviews TRM % 1.2 and Applicant may recognize this from memory.

determines that the requirements of

- LCO 3.1.2.2 are met.

Stop Time:

• denotes critical step-

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 8 of IO Appendix C3 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.

Examinee's Name:

Examiner's Name:

Date performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of attempts:

Time to complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response

Result: SAT or UNSAT Examiner's signature and date:

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 9 of IO Job Performance Measure Guide Page i o o f i o JOBPERFORMANCE MEASURE INSTRUCTION SHEET DIRECTIONS TO STUDENT When I tell you to begin, YOU ARE TO REVIEW THE COMPLETED SURVEILLANCE AND, IF NECESSARY, RECOMMEND APPROPRIATE FOLLOW-UP ACTIONS.

Initial Conditions You are the Work Control RO at Millstone Generating Station, Unit 3. The crew has just completed Technical Specification Surveillance SP 3604C.4, Boric Acid Pump 3CHS*P2A Operational Readiness Test. The Work Control Supervisor has asked you to review the completed surveillance for any potential problems.

The time is 14:30 on Tuesday, 20 July 2004.

The plant has been operating at 100% power for 97 days. No significant evolutions are planned.

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 1 of 9 NRC Administrative JPM RO JPM A.4

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 2 of 9

1. JPM

Title:

Determine and Perform Actions Required to Remove a Radiation Monitor from Service.

JPM ID Number: SRO A.4 Revision: 0 II. Initiated:

Nuclear Regulatory Commission 24 May 2004 Developer Date III. Reviewed:

Technical Reviewer Date IV. Approved:

Cognizant Plant Supervisor (optional) Date Nuclear Training Supervisor Date

~~

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 3 of 9

SUMMARY

OF CHANGES Change Description Date

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 4 of 9 Facility: Millstone Unit 3 Student:

JPM ID Number: RO A.4 Revision: 0 Task

Title:

Determine and Perform Actions Required to Remove a Radiation Monitor from Service.

System: n/a Time Critical Task: ( ) YES ( X ) NO Validated Time (minutes): 15 Task Number(s):

Applicable To: SRO X RO X PEO WA Number: 2.3.1 WA Rating: 3.0 / 2.6 Knowledge of 10 CFR: 20 and related facility radiation control requirements.

Method of Testing: Simulated Performance: Actual Performance: X Location: Classroom: X Simulator: In-Plant::

Task Standards: 0 Applicant determines the requirements of OP3250.62.

SRO Applicant performs those administrative requirements.

Required Materials: 0 Operating Procedure OP 3250.62, Removal and Restoration of Radiation Monitors.

REMODCM Shift Manager Log - simulation General

References:

Operating Procedure OP 3250.62, Removal and Restoration of Radiation Monitors.

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 5 of 9

• READ TO THE STUDENT***

I will explain the initial conditions, which step@)to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objectives for this JPM will be satisfied.

You may use any approved reference material normally available in the Control Room, including logs. Make all written reports, oral reports, alarm acknowledgements, and log entries as if the evolution was actually being performed.

Initial Conditions: You are the Work Control Supervisor at Millstone Generating Station Unit 3. It is 02:OO in the morning. I&C wishes to perform emergent SRO maintenance on 3HVR*REl OB, Ventilation Vent Stack radiation monitor.

Initiating Cue: YOU ARE TO DETERMINE AND PERFORM THE ACTIONS REQUIRED TO REMOVE 3HVR*RElOB FROM SERVICE.

ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS?

YOU MAY BEGIN.

Initial Conditions: You are the Balance of Plant Operator at Millstone Generating Station Unit 3. It is 02:OO in the morning. I&C wishes to perform emergent RO maintenance on 3HVR*RE1OB, Ventilation Vent Stack radiation monitor.

The Work Control Supervisor has asked you to determine what actions are required to remove 3HVR*REl OB ftom service. DETERMINE THE ACTIONS REQUIRED TO REMOVE 3HVR*RElOB FROM SERVICE.

Initiating Cue: DETERMINE THE ACTIONS REQUIRED TO REMOVE 3HVR*RElOB FROM SERVICE.

ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS?

NOTES TO EVALUATOR

1. Critical steps for this JPM are indicated by an asterisk and unshaded box after the step number. For the student to achieve a satisfactory grade, & critical steps must be completed correctly. The students performance is graded by an S for satisfactory or a U for unsatisfactory on each step.

2. When the student states what hidher simulated action/observation would be, read the appropriate Cue.

3. If necessary, question the student for details of simulated actions/observations (i.e. What are you looking at? or What are you observing?J).

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 6 of 9 Start Time:

Examiner Cue DETERMINE THE ACTIONS REQUIRED TO REMOVE 3HVR*RElOB FROM SERVICE.

Applicant obtains/requests:

0 OP 3250.62, Removal and Restoration of Radiation Monitors.

0 SP 3883 Normal Vent Rad Monitor System - Inoperative REMODCM.

0 3670.2-004, 3HVR*REl OB, Temporary Sampling Surveillance.

0 3670.1-003, 3HVR-RE1OA & 3HVR-1OB Stack Flow Surveillance.

A phone call may be used to notify Health Physics and Chemistry NOTE Departments of a radiation monitor being removed from service.

preceding However, a three part memo must be used to notify Health Physics Step and Chemistry Departments of any actions required, e.g., sample 4.1 .I rigs, temporary monitors, etc.

3-part forms no longer used. Phone Call followed by Condition Report is NOTE:

the standard wactice.

NOTIFY Health Physics Applicant notifies Health Physics that 4.1 .I Department which radiation 3HVR*RElOB will be secured. Telephone monitor will be off line. call is adequate for this notification.

Refer to Attachment 3 and Applicant refers to Attachment 3 of OP

• PERFORM specified 3250.62 and determines that Response 2, responses for the radiation 5,6, 8, & 19 are required.

4.1.2 monitor being removed from service.

• CONTACT Chemistry Applicant describes process for notifying Department in writing for Chemistry. Per Training Dept., 3-part sampling to meet REMODCM forms are no longer used.

Att A Requirements.

Act 2 IF radiation monitor indicates Examiner Cue: The Radiation Monitor OFF-LINE, that rad monitor is does NOT indicate OFF-LINE Att A, inoperable, RECORD all Act 5 applicable actions in the SM Applicant recognizes that Response 5 is log. not applicable.

• Complete SP 3670.2-004, Applicant states that SP 3670.2-004 must 3HVR*RE1OB Temporary be completed/performed.

Sampling Surveillance.

Att A, Examiner Cue: PEOs are performing SP Act 6 3670.2-004 every 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />.

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 7 of 9 "3HVR-RE10 A & 3HVR- be completed.

REIOB Stack Flow Att Surveiliance" Examiner Cue: BOP RO is performing Act 8 3670.1-003 every 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />.

End of JPM for RO ADDlicants.

Stop Time:

• denotes critical step-

- __ ~~

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 8 of 9 Appendix C3 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.

Examinee's Name:

Examiner's Name:

Date performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of attempts:

Time to complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response

Result: SAT or UNSAT Examiner's signature and date:

Job Performance Measure Guide Page 9 of 9 Student Handout - RO Applicants JOBPERFORMANCE MEASURE INSTRUCTION SHEET DIRECTIONS TO STUDENT DETERMINE THE ACTIONS REQUIRED TO REMOVE 3HVR"RElOB FROM SERVICE.

Initial Conditions You are the Balance of Plant Operator at Millstone Generating Station Unit 3. It is 02:OO in the morning. I&C wishes to perform emergent maintenance on 3HVR*RE1OB, Ventilation Vent Stack radiation monitor. The Work Control Supervisor has asked you to determine what actions are required to remove 3HVR*RE1OB from service. DETERMINE THE ACTIONS REQUIRED TO REMOVE 3HVR*RElOB FROM SERVICE.