ML031530580

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Safety Analyses Transition - LAR Submitted March 25, 2003, NRC-NMC May 20, 2003
ML031530580
Person / Time
Site: Prairie Island  Xcel Energy icon.png
Issue date: 05/30/2003
From:
Nuclear Management Co
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
TAC MB8128, TAC MB8129
Download: ML031530580 (26)
v • d • e


Text

M-7""q 7

77M777=777MM j

a a

n. a' se rans ion, I......................

subm'itte'd'....M a ch,.,,2.5.,....

2003 N -M C ;

a M

e t M a -,-,2 0.....

.. 2 0 -0,3 1 I I I

I I I...........

I................

...... 11-1.1.1

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.

o-au,c~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

on

~~~~~~~~~~~....................................

lntroc u.c

lons 9 0

! !~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.....

........... 4

~~~~,RC

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...........

MC--;

j ; ; ;~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

, Westin;ghouse e---

................................... 1-1 -, -;.......................

I.,...........

..I...............

L:R
2

S u m m a r y.....

n..-h o u se.................

g ro u p..

p e rfo rms..

c o re..............

d e sign.................

~~~~~~'r e...

.* T r ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

0.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~.,...,.,..,.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~............

. -Ini-hou;se group perfobr'm's core d'esign-;

.: etnhueprforms m st AOR; e...e ic n

.,.,~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~........

M......

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...........

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Meth-odol ogies........

. + Adopt NRq approv'ed methodologies~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.

i, ;,,,.,,

i~~~~~~~~~~~~~

j-evi io a

-- pec--

~~~~~~~~...........

...................................S

. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.....

,~~~~~~~~~...

......,e,,

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~..............

..,Z..

~~~~~~~~~~.................

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~..

N M C....S. f. t.........s s.T.a....io........................

LAR

4

.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~

Org=

niztio 6fLARW

. *Lcne Evlato Exii A.

f *SRevised S/Baes pageR F.s

- Exibt C

  • Instrument Unertite fo Plan

... Wstinhous Revisd TemlDsg

-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~......

ove..-Ieite r..

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.....................................

LcneEvl uto-.

A-.....

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~..

.........................................,..........j

..........r cedures -

Exhibi.t

.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~e...........

NC...Safety.Ana yses.Tr

............ ',, O.p

.e

'at i.n

.g' Pa.ra' veter T.n.p uts to th e

'~~~~~~~

...,tmicethse.

E_a u ti-.

,_.,x.h bi... A

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~....................

....................... I:i'...

1'

NC.

f6r`Pn iIy'....

Ta'ii'....'

n~~~~

rum ncertaintie.s'.a5

.* G r o u p 12

.~~~~~~~~~~~~..........

Safety Analyse T a st 6.

Gro up 1 - RAO C

.~~~~~~~~~~............

...... +f.........

; ; ; ;~~~~~~~~~~~~.

.*Relaxed Aial Offset Co-ntrol

.............. Revise TS/Bases. 3.2. 1 a nd 3.2.3 Currently

..use NP vrsion.of CAOC

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.........

.. Adopt approved W CAP-10216-PAT..............................

Miscellaneous changes-1....1..1.1...

I....

............. I.................................................................................................................................

~.........,.

NMC*S S

A T ransiitio...

Re' i.'

T-B~s6

.`.3.`.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~e s i.

~.

..... d.

A.

.0.1...

@4...........................

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~

~

~

~~~.

N C.

Sft.nIs io

................................. I.........

.... jjjPjjjjjj.4...........

"rou a -ion o 411 Re'v i SI al, S B a' s e

...Relotatel.K.- Fig'u"re C O LR I...

I...........

I I.........................

w"'

S L...............

......... t i'b '

o............

I.......

I-

1.1.1.1

'W AP 144 3;X t ci 0 C..........................

I......

--.Q -p...........

..,,p r o v e..........................

.......... N M C '-..Sfet.-A nblys6s,.T-ranition m

LAR

'8

' ; ; ; ' ; ' ;~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

.' ~

-Pr m

.te

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...................................

...................... '......... I.........

1 Jr.o u.p v............

-we ocatlon ot

-l m

lts

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.

..... r.:.

P A,.

a p p ro

.......AP.T

~~~~~~~~~~~...........

pt.............

d -

R )

i.

.o-...

~ ~

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~~~~~~~~~~~~........

~~~~~~~~~...........

I.....

  • CaIuIte.....

A/...O

.peaprod

~~~~~~~~~...............

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~........

e R

e o

te

... I.i mwl.s

.t CO.4.LR~~~~~~~~

............-.1.11

- 1. 1..........

... /z....

~~~~~~~~~~~............................

................... I.......

... ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~..................

...............ro-oc

-io-

.... J....

ot.t

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...........

.............,,,,V-.

S T s 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~......5 n...

vise list~~~~~~~~....

feo iec f 6' 'CO FZ--

........... -.0...........

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~..

...Addmetodolgie rC..L

.......................I i m itS A~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~~~~R

i. e,1,, t`

.,, :' cii' ti' Is

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~............';';;;',;

' ~ ~

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~..... I.............

t~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

4 s

  • I
  • i *

-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.

i 4 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.

7...................

A

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~............ I.........

'e
A ' ly '

i..

Revise. to.....184.........

,G

.s valu3,;,

e,v is.n c.orvAvei 1-a directionu

.Adopt WCAP -

8745-P-A~~~~~.......

'ise'..TS.NMC3.

... SFeuycAnaoysesT8ansition LAR...

R. e V

"A::::^cce ptan ce: Criterion::Chan:g:e::::::::::::::::::

.Tedh SpedBases 32.--1

.. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.............

.......... '...6'A................

.:::::+

Ba sed on Westi ng h ouse meth odo logy l-- -for--RCCA--Ejection

t X

-Z

@.w

  1. -P.#.#.e.+.e.S f..................................

4Maximu m hot spot enthalpy criterion:

vreduced from 280 ca1/-g to20 al/g

~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~A L................................

s..,

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~.

.g

y.

...........I.......

.LAR.i i

12

---re e r m~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

t q < <

  1. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~d.. !o;
- b f2f8r0f

- l "t..

C< a

.~~~~~~~~~~~...............

NC.

Sft.nIs....

Tasto

. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~.

N M I S f t n l s s. r it o...................

.~ ~

~

~~~LR1

..~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~..........

.; w

..... _.','5.....

................. S p...o w e......r...................................................

  • ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~n W sigouse des e pw s

. ~ ~ ~

~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.....

I.......

+.

1

.. ~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~~

~~~~~~~~~..

...............rm

, r c e AA..............

H.'v

--- 6 conitios-adrsed w

We tingho

-Aed o diti nd.1istedb

. ~ ~ ~...........

~~~~~...........................

~~~'

re s se d g

-d'iti'on'~~

bd E--b W.

.n.h.

d,i io h..

d

, r. s d,.;b -N M

.... -J..................................................

.......................................................................1

.......... v::1....'

.............................. M.-S.Anlss..............

LAR 1 4

" " ''' +'¢ eSr............

~.

  • "!Design Basis or the Thermal OverpowerA and ThermalOvr
theme atureA ATrip.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.......................

F...............................................-

u.nctions"

. Condition-of SER-Approval

  • , ' ' ' ' The adeq uacy of the stan dard pow r shapes in..........

.. establishing DN protection sstem must be evaluated-whenever changes are introduced that could affet core power distribution

~~~~~~~~~~~.................

Response

.............-;,- s ~........B O

T AT./ OPA parameter values will account f'o"rPrairie.'''':''''''''''''''

Island specific conditions N MC..

.S fet.y..s.T.

.Ana e Ta.

LAR 15 N

...-......fW..

An'.Iys s.........

P,.revIous mplementati6ns

-+Cmparison t.o Other NMC Units

,,...... Point Beach. has implementedthe O

...... n.of.........................................

th.R.C L.............i.........

changes.(N U R EG -143.).'.....--..

ewaunee has implementedthe R aoC and elocation f Li...................

mits changes.(Custom Tech Spec)

Both Plants added references to reflect methodologies for

^

the -RA-Othe and the COLR--RelOcation of Limits.

...... Prairie Island will be made the same as these units or the

-AOC. Band Relocation of Limitstchanges'

'-o-Po Refren cs sed by Kewaunee and-oint Beach for the L, OC and Relocation of Limits changes-are also in the i

P.rai.ieIsl.nd

.A.

submit.al.

p e

A

.1

....................a u.....

n e e........................

s.........................................

.............. Set. An y'......anito

.......... ~~~~~~~L A

e......s...or.............;

,~B th

.Pla.

,s.a'.

rcs t,-efe'tm h

d6

.gie

A 4-4,,,

44*,4*,~ ~.......

TS Page~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

C hanges....

.*Basease

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~T T

"3 9..........

.N M C..

...... S..fe.... A n..lyses. T a s 1 7..

~~~~' ;

-n

-e s

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...

sL C ° 3

.-2.1

/B ases

~~~~~~"B

............-~....

~~~...........

-Oa m...........-

m I' b m e R ' O

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...

dr-8ases..."3.,;,2.;,4;~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~~~~...........

Im plem en RAO aI

~~~~............

..nc...

....... q9d.

  • T z z

~

~

LR 1

e w

...................... y.....,,,.

TS Page Ch~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

es,..,

>~~~~~~~~~,

  • LCO 33.l/Bases

-ble Func ion 7

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.......

....... -_s,.....

  • Curre tTS iffer.... fro ohr lat

- ?

Remove f(A.) input...............

to OPAT...

  • RemoveSR3.3.13/SR 3.3.16-

...................... ~~~.....................................

........................ sZ 4 LCO !3.3.1.- Table Function 8.a Increase Allowable Value 4LCO 3.3.1 hots 1and 2

"'.L CO.3.3.I.

.t~

.. a" n

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...........................I.I.-

.1..1..

.......- R ct-prmtr

....... t o.C.LR..

i

~~~~~~~~~

r a m

...... Relocate paa eters to COLR f

Rem e f(A.) from OPAT

...................... S

........... A.........

NMC - Sa~~~fety.Analyses.Transition.....

~~~~

~~

~

~

~

~

~

~~~~~LAR, 19'

e --

o S

v t

0 j

f R

~~~~~~j

- TS_P, Fa e Chnanges:

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~..............

......... '.. :':':'A':..

' ' '.'+

T 'S

' 5 ' 6 '.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-

ne:.................................

-Add Specification references.......................

'.'.'.Ad d m e th o d o o

' I g......

re re n e

~~~~~~~~~~~............e.I..I..I...1.11.I.I.O' Ase i e p

e v os mthdl g

'¢es.. ........

.'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~A

,,,' 'et d'o I o.'.

're.,.re i e ...

A A'

Kev.........:NMC a

at......Taniton..

. LA..........

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~................

~~~~~~~~~~~~..............

R;.............

N C...Sft..A

..nito

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.............

i.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...........

........ y...

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.

' ' C

'o ':c Iu s i'o n : ' -

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~....................

.7

~~~~~~~~~.

~~~~~~.........................I

~~~.....................

...... f..

......~~~~~~~..........

...........-.I..I.I.1

..1.

.I..~.

.I..............

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...........;......................................................................

  1. + ~

~ ~

a

$ e e - Z ; e R R w w r ~~~..-'............

,~~~~~~~~~~.

~~~~...............

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~............

M....

ft.n y'.......Tasto

..lA R.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~.......

4.......

~~~

~ ~ ~ ~

~

~ ~~.

~

~

~

~ ~~~

~ ~ ~ ~~...

i.....;.,,,.........

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.........,..

~~

~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~tat..........

.~~~~~~~~~~~~~.........................................

........... ~~~~~~~~e l t6....

-s s R`emve-'datesrevisions et: fom;;COLR ;

.~~~~~~

-F.....BTases 'agaes^

1..

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~.

i~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

..... ~.......

i

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~.

............ N M.I

.ft

, n l

s

.ra.ti.

.... I.............

i

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~..

i 9A

,,^

... : :.: :..... ~~~~~~~......... :::..

..m p :m

-n a

1 n

.ACtl.

'.ltl, e, n..

.............~~~~~

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

-e ~~

gho

......~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.................

- -.com plete 0CFR 50.-59 Eva uations.-.--.-

.............~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~O...........

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.

E,'Z'5Z

' ;~~~~~~~~

' 'R.'

................; ; -~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

i~~~~~~

`4e 0

t s

X Re;

  1. f#Xtl#i wgi;

'n't i<

v~

is e ;tti

....i. :..........

.................................................1..1 1 1 t...................

w~

a

.......... ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' NMC'.-

.. S'fet An Iys sTra...ns.....i.

.................... t i

...... o.

LAR 23

~ ~~.....................................

I........

'.v.......'.

j

........ e rn. -e rnte n-tatton........

c., eau -e

.......... e u e s e N,R C,-,-A ;

v
1, I.-

e 3-1 20.03.

N,.,.,De'em'b r, w a a v a a

I' h

mpemen o

uhits]

--,J h u a; ry 3.0,r 2 0 0 4 -- l a

p j

a a

NMC'-..S6fet..Analysbs,Trantitio'n LAR 24

a a t

w o

j w w a t t t

o t

s i;

t i;

--Tec ica peci -ca --on-c anges............................

I..........

nera I ly;

... cib nform'Ab _-,NU-R--EG;--143l_J

"""""R e v is ' ib -- 2 u

aDi)rove

'Ni....

e th o.....

do o........

a--;J'e's-- !"O" r.......e Vlo ';'s v ty"t r..................

I M

I.I.I.I.I.11I.I.I.

-th e'......

N, R' C d

M th""d""I" OqV

-raine l"""I....

a"'in t'.

........ NMC".:7,Sa'fet,An'alyss.-Tran§itioh LAR 25

uostio-nS?'

I.,

c o M im e n s.,......................

a a I......

.I.I.I...l.;.l.l...l...l'll

....... M

7-S  fe ',A n ly sp-s.T ra n itio h LAR 26

..........................

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML031530580&oldid=5419170"