Westinghouse is evaluating an identified inconsistency between test assumptions and the test rig configurations used for Generic Safety Issue (
GSI) 191, "Assessment of Debris Accumulation on
PWR Sump Performance," testing. Specifically, this issue is related to jet impingement zone-of-influence (ZOI) tests and it applies to testing done for
coatings and insulation.
Prior to discovery of the inconsistency, Westinghouse provided letters to the utilities to summarize the testing, analyze the test results, and propose acceptable ZOIs to support resolution of the ZOI aspect of GSI-191. The ZOI tests assumed the smallest diameter in the nozzle producing the jet to be at the nozzle. Westinghouse discovered however, that the inner diameter of an upstream component was smaller than the nozzle. This inconsistency may have resulted in undersized ZOIs being proposed in the letters.
Westinghouse has not yet concluded its determination as to whether there is a defect as defined by 10 CFR 21.
Westinghouse has been working with the Pressurized Water Reactors Owners Group and the NRC NRR Safety Issues Resolution Branch to resolve general test protocol issues and establish methods to evaluate the test results in terms of ZOIs.
- * * UPDATE ON 2/16/2010 * * *
Corrected the title of GSI-191 above and removed incorrect reference to
NUREG/CR-6874 since it is not related to the Part 21.