3F0988-02, Forwards Info in Response to NRC Bulletin 85-005 Requiring That All Piping Supplies,Inc. & West Jersey Mfg Co. Supplied Matls Be Identified & Determination Made as to Suitability for Intended or Actual Applications
| ML20154B853 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crystal River  |
| Issue date: | 09/02/1988 |
| From: | Widell R FLORIDA POWER CORP. |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM) |
| References | |
| 3F0988-02, 3F988-2, IEB-88-005, IEB-88-5, NUDOCS 8809140163 | |
| Download: ML20154B853 (16) | |
Text
,
,.. s e e,,
i 84 O *.
t 9
g 80 0 JOGI I
7.*
Ee'p'tYm5>er 2, 1988 l
}
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attention:
Document Control Desk Washington, D. C.
20555
Subject:
Crystal River Unit 3 L
Docket No. 50-302 l
Operating License No. DPR-72 l
NRC Bulletin 88-05:
Nonconforming Materials Supplied by Piping Supplies, Inc.
i at Folsom, New Jersey and West Jersey
[
Manufacturing Company at Williamstown, New Jersey Dear Sirt Florida Power Corporation (FPC) hereby provides the following information in response to the subject IE Bulletin.
The Bulletin requires that all Piping
- Supplies, Inc.
(PSI) and West Jersey Manuf a -turing Co.
(WJM) supplied material be identified and that a determination be made as to its suitability for the intended or actual applications.
FPC's record search indicated that the subject material was located in the storerooms and also installed in the Nuclear Service and Decay Heat Seawater (RW) System.
The storeroom material is in a "hold cage" until further notice from the NRC.
An EQUOTIP portable hardness tester was used to established the ultimate strength of the installed material.
The EQUOTIP hardness number obtained was then exprussed in terms of a
Brinell Hardness Number using the EQUOTIP conversion tables.
The lowest hardness value obtained to date is 115HB without the EPRI temperature correction factor.
This hardness value did not fall within the acceptable range for ASTM A-105 material.
An analysis to justify continued operations was performed because of the substandard material, but did not require a report under 10 CFR 50.72.
However, notification to the NRC Operations Center was made within 48 hours5.555556e-4 days <br />0.0133 hours <br />7.936508e-5 weeks <br />1.8264e-5 months <br /> on the dates of July 13th and July 27th per Supplement 1 to Bulletin 88-05.
The analysis demonstrated that the subject materials are suitable for the intended service.
9809140163 880902 '
I PDR ADOCK 0S000302
/J G
PNU fl
. (813) NE{515 i
GENERAL OFFICE: 3:01 Thaty fourth Street South.
P.O. Boa 14042. St. Petersburg, nortda 33733 A Florida Progress Company
e September 2, 1988 3F0988-02 Page 2 Enclosed are material worXsheets which list the PSI and WJM supplied materials that are found not to be in conformance with the applicable code requirements or procurement specifications.
Sincerely, i
Rolf C. Widoll, Director Nuclear Operations Site Support RCW/GMF/sdr Enclosurea xct Regional Administrator, Region II Senior Resident Inspector l
l 1
i
P r
STATE OF FIDRIDA l
COUNTY OF CITRUS Rolf C. Widell states that he is the Director, Nuclear operations Site Support for Florida Power Corporation; that he is authorized on the part of said company to sign and file with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission the information attached hereto; and that all such statements made and matters set forth therein are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information, and belief.
i l
\\
Rolf C. Widell, Director Nuclear operations Site Support
[
t subscribed and sworn to before me, a Notary Public in and for the j
State and County above named, this 2nd day of September, 1988.
i 4
l i
h f
I?@ M 1$ld (NctaryPublic v
~
1 i
l Notary Public, State of Florida at Large, My Commission Expires June 21. 1991 I
i l
l i
1 I
I
(
Mmr.In = sRm j
Plan.
C/W > i Unit 3 j
Line Item 1 Heat-Lot CTY ASME Class 3
[
Commodity FLG Diameter 2:00
[
Schedule 40 Rating 150 l
Type SW Spec 105
[
(
Grade N/A Source PSI Vendor (WJM or PSI) P CMTR Date 9/30/87 NCA-3800 (Y/N) Y Secondary Supply Chain....
Supplier Dubose Supplier Dubose Quantity 1 Quantity In Stock 0 Installed-Access 1 Installed--Not Access 0 TEST DATA 410RKSE M Test Results For Line Item 1 Specimen ID (Required) 1 Test Data CMTR Data Tensile Strength W4,725 Yield Strength 53.890 Forcent Elongation 35.0 Percent Reduction In Area 67.8 Hardness (BHN)
HB166 Not Specified Carbon
.27 Phosphorous
.010 Sulfur
.039 Chromium N/A Nickel N/A N/A Molybdenum Heat Treatment N/A REMARKS 1.
Test temp 85 - 105 F 2.
Temp. correction applied t
1 i
M l',
MC SS 05 M M IA1A WORESRErr Plant CRYST Unit 3 l
Line Item 2 Heat Lot 6027949 ASME Class 3
]
Comunodity FLG Diameter 24:00 Schedule N/A Rating 150 Type 50 Spec 105 Grade N/A Source PSI Vendor (WJM or PSI) P CMTR Date 7/9/87 I
NCA-3800 (Y/N) Y Secondary Supply Chain....
Supplier Dubose Supplier Dubose l
Quantity 2 Quantity In Stock 0 Installed-Access 2 Installed--Not Access 0
)
TEST DATA WORK 5RIrr l
Test Results For Line Item 2 Specimen ID (Required) 2 l
Test Data CMTR Data l
Tensile Strength 77.000 Yield Strength 46.700
)
Percent Elongation 34.0 Percent Reduction In Area 59.0 Hardness (BHN)
HB142/HB144 N/A
.27 j
Carbon i
.86
)
.20
)
Phosphorous
.011 Sulfur
.014 Chromium N/A t
Nickel N/A Molybdenum N/A Heat Treatment N/A RIMARKS 1.
Test temp 85 - 101 F 2.
Temp correction applied
Revised 7/26/84 MRC 64-05 MATERIALS if0EESEIrr Plant CRYST Unit Line Item 3 Neat Lot CTY ASME Class 3 Commodity FLG Diameter 2:00 Schedule N/A Ratins.150 Type 50 Spec 105 Grade N/A Source PSI Vender (WJM or PSI)
P CNTR Date 10/13/87 l
NCA 3800 (Y/N) Y Secondary Supply Chain....
Supplier Dubose Supplier Dubose l
Quantity 4
Quantity In Stock 4 Installed Access 0 Installed--Not Access 0 l
TEST D&TA if0EESEIET Test Results For Line Item 3
Spectmen ID (Required) 3 l
. Test Data CMTR Datt Tensile Strength 84,725 Yield Strength 53.490 Percent tionsation 35.0 Forcent Reduction In Area 67.4 Rardness (EMN)
Not Specified
[
.25 Mansanese 1.35 Silicon
.27 Phosphorous
.010 Sulfur
.039 Chromium N/A Nickel N/A Molybdenum N/A Heat Treatment N/A RIMARKS:
1.
No testing conducted 2.
4 items unaccounted for 9
Revisst 7/26/88
(
i NRC 44-05 l
nAT stats woarsaur l
Plant CRYST-Unit 3 Line Item 4 Heat Lot CTY ASME Class N/A l
r Ceaseodity FLG Diameter 2:00 l
Schedule N/A Rating 150 l
Type 50 Spec 105 Grade N/A Source PSI f
Vendor (WJM or PSI) P CMTR Date 10/6/87 l
NCA 3800 (Y/N) y j
Secondary Supply Chain....
Supplier Dubuse supplier Dubose Quantity 15 Quantity In Stock 0 Installed-Access 15 Installed--Not Access 0 TEST DATA N W Test Results For Line Item 4 Specimen ID (Required) 4 Test Data CMTR Data Tensile Strength 84,725 Yield Strength 53.890 Percent tionsation 35.0 Percent Reduction In Area 67.8 Hardness (BHN)
HR 119/138 Not Specified Carbon
.25 Manganese 1.35 Silleon
.27 Phosphorous
.010 Sulfur
.039 Chromium N/A Nickel N/A Molybdenum N/A Heat Treatment N/A RENARKS:
1.
Test temp. 85 - 108 T 2.
Temp correction applied
u MC SS-05 MATERIA 1A N #8mer Plant CRYST Unit 3 Line Item 5 Heat Lot CPC ASME Class 2 Commodity FLG Diameter 6:00 Schedule N/A Rating 150 Type BL Spec 105 Grade N/A Source PSI Vendor (WJM or PSI) P CMTR Date 7/24/87 NCA-3800 (Y/N) y Secondary Supply Chain....
Supplier Dubose Supplier Dubose Quantity 1 Quantity In Stock 1 Installed-Access 0 Installed--Not Access 0 TEST DATA m ener Test Results For Line Item 5 Specimen ID (Required) 5 Test Data CMTR Data Tensile Strength 76,596 Yield Strength 39.313 Percent E4ensation 25.0 Percent Reduction In Area 57.0 Hardness (BMN)
N/A Carbon
.29 Manganese
.76 assicon
.23 Phosphorous
,017 Sulfur
.030 Chromium N/A Nickel N/A Molybdenum N/A Heat Treatment N/A RD%RES No testing conducted
es v.
..as-NRC 88-05 MATERIALS WORKSHEET Plant CRYST Unit Line Item 6 Heat-Lot CFY ASME Class 2 Commodity FLG Diametet 2:00 t-Schedule N/A Rating 150 Type SO Spec 105 Grade N/A Source PSI Vendor (WJM or PCI) P CMTR Date 10/13/87 NCA-3800 (Y/N) Y Secondary Supply Chain....
Supplier Dubose Supplier Dubore saantity 8 Quantity In Stock 8 Installed-Access 0 Installed--Not Access 0 TEST DATA WORKSHErr Test Results For Line Item 6
Specimen ID (Required) 6 Test Data, CMTR Data Tensile Strength 84,725 Yield Strength 53,890 Percent Elongation 35.0 l
Percent Reduction In Area 67.8 Hardness (BHN) tiot Specified Carbon
.25 l
1.35 f
i Hanganese I
.27 f
Phosphorous
.010 l
.039 l
Chromium N/A Nickel N/A Molybdenum N/A Ileat Treatment N/A i
REMARKS - No testing conducted e
- R2vissd.7/26/88 NRC 88-05 MATERIALS WORKSHEET Plant CRYST Unit 3 Line Item 7 Heat-Lot COL ASME Class 3 Commodity FLG Diameter 2:00 Schedule N/A Rating 150
/
4 Type BL Spec 105 Grade N/A Source PSI Vendor (WJM or PSI) P CMTR Date 11/4/87 NCA-3800 (Y/N) Y Secondary Supply Chain....
Supplier Dubose Supplier Dubose Quantity 3 Quantity In Stock 0 Installed-Access 2 Installed--Not Access 0 TEST DATA WORKSHEET Test Results For Line Item 7 Specimen ID (Required) 7 Test Data, CMTR Data Tensile Strength 95,680 Yield Strength 64.123 Percent Elongation 26.0 Percent Reduction In Area 51.0 Hardness (BHN)
HB 140/ IIB 129 None Specified Carbon
.29 Marganese
.76 Silicon
.027 k
Phosphorous
.033 i
.034 Chromium N/A Nickel N/A j
Molybdenum N/A liest Treatment N/A f
)
j REMARKS 1.
Test temp. 107 F j
]
2.
Temp. correction applied i
3.
Only installed items tested (2 items) i 4.
One (1) used in Non-Related application (Test Fixture) not available for test I
d
.,, -.. ~,. - -., -
--.7
~,%-.,-----,.--,,g-.,,-----%
,.-ww c-.%-m,.,
,,.-,-m-
.----pe-_---
,--,--,r-
-m
."k.
NRC 88-05 MATERIA 13 WORKSHErr Plant CRYST Unit 3 Line Item 8 Heat-Lot AAY-40 ACME Class 2 Commodity FLG Elametar 1:00 Schedule 40 Rating 150 Type SW Spec 105 Grade N/A Source PSI Vend'.,r (WJM or PSI) P CMTR Date 11/30/87 NCA-3800 (Y/N) Y Secono.cy Supply Chain....
Supplier Dubose Supplier Dubose Quantity 4 Quantity In Stock 4 Installed-Access 0 Installed--Not Access 0 TEST DATA WORKSHErr Test Results For Line Item 8
Specimen ID (Required) 8 Test Data CMTR Data Tensile Strength 81,235 Yield Strength 52,499 Percent Elongation 24.0 Percent Reduction In Area 43.0 Hardness (BUN)
N/A Carbon
.28 Manganese
.18 Silicon
.23 Phosphorous
.018 Sulfur
.029 Chromium N/A Nickel N/A Molybdenum N/A Heat Treatment N/A REMARKS 1.
No testing conducted
NRC 88-05 MATERIALS WORKSHErr Plant CRYST Unit 3 Line Item 9 Heat-Lot CND ASME Class N/A Commodity FLG Diameter 6:00 Schedule N/A Rating 150 Type SO Spec 105 Grade N/A Source PSI Vendor (WJM or PSI) P CMTR Date 10/13/87 NCA-3800 (Y/N) Y Sacondary Supply Chain....
Supplier Dubose Supplier Dubose Quantity 1 Quantity In Stock 1 Installed-Access 0 Installed--Not Access 0 i
TEST DATA WORKSHErr Test Results For Line Item 9
Specimen T.D (Required) 9 Test Data CMTR Data Tensile Strength 78,444 Yield Strength 46,365 Percent Elongation 30.0 Percent Reduction In Area 47.0 Hardness (BHN)
N/A Carbon
.28 Manganese
.75 Silicon
.23 Phosphorous
.015 Sulfur
.011 Chromium N/A Nickel N/A Molybdenum N/A Heat Treatment N/A REMARKS 1.
No tests conducted
i t
NRC 88-05 MATELIALS WORKSHEET Plant CRYST Unit 3 Line Item 10 Heat-Lot CND ASME Class N/A Commodity FLG Diameter 4:00 Schedule N/A Rating 150 Type SO Spec 105 Grade N/A Source PSI Vendor (WJM or PSI) P CMTR Date 10/13/87 NCA-3800 (Y/N) Y Secondary Supply Chain....
Supplier Dubose Supplier Dubose Quantity 1 Quantity In Ctock 1 Installed-Access 0 Installed--Not Access 0 TEST DATA WORKSHEET Test Results For Line Item 10 Specimen ID (Required) 10 Test Data CMTR Data Tensile Strength 78,444 Yield Strength 46.365 Percent Elongation 30.0 Porcent Reduction In Area 47.0 Hardness (BHN)
N/A Carbon
.28 Mar ganese
.75 Silicon
.23 Phosphorous
.015 I
.011 Chromium N/A Nickel N/A Holybdenum N/A Heat Treataent N/A REMARKS 1.
No tests conducted i
-~
4 NRC 88-05,
MATERIAIS WORESHErr Plant CRYST Unit 3 Line Item 11 Heat-Lot 4871 ASME Class 2 Commodity FLG Diameter 4:00 Schedule N/A Rating 900 Type BL Spec 105 Grade N/A Source WJM Vender (WJM or PSI) W CMTR Date 5/17/83 NCA-3800 (Y/N) Y Secondary Supply Chain....
Supplier Guyon Alloys Supplier Guyon Alloys Quantity 2 Quantity In Stock 2 Installed-Access 0 Installed--Not Access 0 TEST DATA WORKSHEET Test Results For Line Item 11 Specimen ID (Required) 11 Test Data CMTR Data t
Tensile Strength 74,953 Yield Strength 44,943 Percent Elongation 27.4 Percent Reduction In Area 56.5 Hardness (BRN)
N/A Carbon
.20 Hanganese
.90 Silicon
.18 Phosphorous
.021 Sulfur
.028 Chromium N/A Nickel N/A Molybdenum N/A Heat Treatment Normalized to 1650 F for 1 hr per inch REMARKS 1.
No tests conducted L
NRC 88-05 MATERIA 13 WORKSHErf Plant CRYST Unit 3 Line Item 12 Heat-Lot A66 ASME Class 2 Connodity FLG Diameter 6:00 Schedule N/A Rating 600 Type BL Spec 105 Grade N/A Source WJM Vendor (WJM or PSI) W CMTR Date 5/17/83 NCA-3800 (Y/N) Y Secondary Supply Chain....
Supplier Guyon Alloys Supplier Guyon Alloys Quantity 2 Quantity In Stock 2 Installed-Access 0 Installed--Not Access 0 TEST DATA WORKSHEET Test Results For Line Item 12 Specimen ID (Required) 12 Test Data CMTR Data Tensile Strength 81,354 Yield Strength 51,344 Percent Elongation 27.8 Percent Reduction In Area 61.8 Hardness (BHN)
N/A Carbon
.26 Manganese
.89 Silicon
.026 Phosphorous
.013 Sulfur
.011 Chromium N/A Nickel N/A Molybdenum N/A Heat Treatment Normalized to 1650 F and held one he per inch REMARKS 1.
No tests conducted
NRC 88-05 MATERIALS WORKSHEET Plant CRYST Unit 3 Line Item 13 Heat-Lot 45786 ASME Class 2 i
Consoodity FLG Diameter 20:00 Schedule N/A Rating 150 Type SO Spec 105 Grade N/A Source WJM Vendor (WJM or PSI) W CMTR Date 11/18/80 NCA-3800 (Y/N) Y Secondary Supply Chain....
Supplier ITT Grinnell Supplier IIT Grinnell Quantity 4 Quantity In Stock 0 Installed-Access 4 Installed--Not Access 0 TEST DATA WORKSHEET Test Results For Line Item 13 Specimen ID (Required) 13 Test Data CMTR Data Tensile Strength 75,242 Yield Strength 43,524 Percent Elongation 27 Percent Reduction In Area 59 liardness (BHN) 11B 130, HB 137 Not Specified 11B 133. HB 145 Carbon
.023 l
1 Phosphorous
.016 Sulfur
.018 Chromium N/A t
Nickel N/A Molybdenum N/A f-Heat Treatment N/A REMARKS 1.
Test temp 95 99 F 2.
Temp correction applied p-
--~-e--~
v--
mv
-ym
,, 7
-g-p,
-. _ _. _