ML020350308
| ML020350308 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Salem  |
| Issue date: | 01/08/2002 |
| From: | Salamon G Public Service Enterprise Group |
| To: | Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| LRN-01-0433 | |
| Download: ML020350308 (27) | |
Text
PSEG Nuclear LLC P.O. Box 236, Hancocks Bridge, New Jersey 08038-0236 JAN 0 8 2001 0 PSEG Nuclear LLC LRN-01-0433 United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555 Gentlemen:
INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM RELIEF REQUESTS S1-RR-B01 AND S1-RR-C01 SALEM GENERATING STATION - UNIT I FACILITY OPERATING LICENSE DPR-70 DOCKET NOS. 50-272 Pursuant to 1 OCFR50.55a(a)(3)(ii), PSEG Nuclear is submitting Inservice Inspection (ISI) relief requests S1-RR-B01 and S1-RR-C01 for NRC approval. These requests address Salem Unit 1 - Second Inservice Inspection Ten Year NDE Examination limitations affecting ASME Section Xl Class 1 and Class 2 components, respectively.
Salem Unit 1 2 nd Ten-Year Interval ISI examinations were performed in accordance with the requirements of ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section Xl 1983 Edition up through and including Summer 1983 Addenda Article IWB-2500 to the extent practical.
Imposed September 22, 1999 Final Rule requirements 10CFR50.55a(b)(2)(xv)(A),
10CFR50.55a(b)(2)(xv)(G), and 10CFR50.55a(b)(2)(xvi), defined new requirements for coverage and examination demonstrations. These requirements affected both piping and Reactor Pressure Vessel (RPV) examinations.
The requests seek relief from performing the inservice examinations for the inaccessible or physically obstructed portions of the examination areas identified within the respective Salem Unit 1-Second Inservice Inspection Ten-Year Relief Requests' NDE Exam Limitations tables, attached.
The attachments to this letter provides the supporting justification and proposed alternative and for each relief. Based on the evaluation contained in each attachment, PSEG Nuclear has concluded that the proposed alternatives provide reasonable assurance of pressure boundary integrity, and an acceptable level of quality and safety.
Accordingly, this proposal satisfies the requirements of 10 CFR 50.55a(a)(3)(ii).
PSEG Nuclear requests NRC approval by April 1st, 2002, as these relief request are applicable to the Salem Unit 2, 10-year second interval vessel examination scheduled for the spring of 2002.
95-2168 REV. 7/99
Document Control Desk LRN 0433 JAN 0 8 ?07?
Should you have any questions regarding this request, please contact Mr. Howard Berrick at 856-339-1862.
G. Salamon Manager - Nuclear Safety and Licensing
Attachment:
I. ISI Relief Request S1-RR-BO1 I1. ISI Relief Request S1-RR-CO1 2
Document Control Desk LRN 0433 JAN 0 8 2002 C
Mr. H. Miller Regional Administrator - Region I U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 475 Allendale Road King of Prussia, PA 19406 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ATTN: Mr. R. Fretz Licensing Project Manager - Salem Mail Stop 08B2 Washington DC 20555-001 USNRC Senior Resident Inspector - Salem (X24)
Mr. K. Tosch, Manager IV Bureau of Nuclear Engineering P. O. Box 415 Trenton, NJ 08625 3
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment I Relief Request: SI-RR-B01 Salem Unit 1-2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Component Description Class 1 Component Limitations identified during Salem Unit 1 2 nd Ten-Year Inservice Inspection Interval ASME Code Class:
ASME Section XI Class 1 Code Requirement Salem Unit 1 2nd Ten-Year Inservice Inspection Interval inservice inspection examinations were performed in accordance with the requirements of ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section XI 1983 Edition up through and including Summer 1983 Addenda Article IWB 2500 to the extent practical.
Imposed September 22, 1999 Final Rule requirements 10CFR50.55a(b)(2)(xv)(A),
1 OCFR50.55a(b)(2)(xv)(G), and 1 OCFR50.55a(b)(2)(xvi), defined new requirements for coverage and examination demonstrations. These requirements affected both piping and Reactor Pressure Vessel (RPV) examinations.
The 3rd Ten-Year Inservice Inspection Interval inservice inspection examinations will be performed in accordance with the above Final Rule requirements and ASME Section XI 1995 Edition up through and including 1996 Addenda Article IWC-2500 requirements to the extent practical.
Basis for Relief Pursuant to 1 0CFR50.55a (a)(3)(ii), relief is requested from performing the inservice examination for the inaccessible or physically obstructed portions of the examination areas identified within Salem Unit 1-2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations table attached. This information is also contained within Salem's Unit 1 Inservice Inspection Program Long Term Plan.
In addition, previously issued RPV qualifications do not met the new requirements for single side access, that are listed in the September 22, 1999 Final Rule, 1 OCFR50.55a(b)(2)(xv)(G)(1), (2) and 1 CFR50.55a(b)(2)(xvi)(A).
The prevailing limitations and the specific relief for each weld are contained within the Salem Unit 1 - 2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations table. The table contains the following entries pertaining to each subject weld/bolting areas:
S1 -RR-BO1 1
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment I Relief Request: S1-RR-B01 Salem Unit 1-2nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Component Summary Component Exam Method Summarized Exam Number Identification Limited Results for Area Inspected Interval/Period/Outage Geometric Estimated total Restriction Type Number configuration coverage area Exam Date ASME Category Code Required Restriction Volume Requirement Description Details Description System Designation ASME Item Number Obstruction Augmented Exam Description (General)
Description The subject welds received volumetric examination by radiography and/or surface examinations during fabrication, in accordance with approved construction code requirements that provide adequate assurance of the structural integrity of welds prior to plant operation.
Throughout 10CFR50.55a (g) numerous references are made allowing performance of these inspections "to the extent practical". Some of these specific paragraphs are:
(g) Inservice inspection requirements. Requirements for inservice testing of Class 1, Class 2, and Class 3 pumps and valves are located in §50.55a(f).
(1) For a boiling or pressurized water-cooled nuclear power facility whose construction permit was issued before January 1, 1971, components (including supports) must meet the requirements of paragraphs (g)(4) and (g)(5) of this section to the extent practical. Components, which are part of the reactor coolant pressure boundary and their supports, must meet the requirements applicable to components, which are classified as ASME Code Class 1. Other safety-related pressure vessels, piping, pumps and valves, and their supports must meet the requirements applicable to components which are classified as ASME Code Class 2 or Class 3.
(4) Throughout the service life of a boiling or pressurized water-cooled nuclear power facility, components (including supports) which are classified as ASME Code Class 1, Class 2 and Class 3 must meet the requirements, except design and access provisions and preservice examination requirements, set forth in Section XI of editions of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code and Addenda that become effective subsequent to editions specified in paragraphs (g)(2) and (g)(3) of this section and that are incorporated by reference in paragraph (b) of this section, to the extent practical within the limitations of design, geometry and materials of construction of the components. Components which are classified as Class MC pressure retaining components and their integral attachments, and components which are classified as Class CC pressure retaining components and their integral attachments must meet the requirements, except design and access provisions and preservice examination requirements, set forth in Section Xl of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code and Addenda that are incorporated by reference in paragraph (b) of this section, subject to the limitation listed in paragraph (b)(2)(vi) of this section and the modifications listed in paragraphs (b)(2)(viii) and (b)(2)(ix) of this section, to the extent practical within the limitation of design, geometry and materials of construction of the components.
SI-RR-B012 2
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment I Relief Request: Sl-RR-BOI Salem Unit 1-2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations The ASME Code itself provides allowance for "limited" examinations. The ASME Section V 1983 Edition up through and including Summer 1983 Addenda paragraph T-441.4.4 Extent of Scanning and later editions of the code indicate state: "Wherever feasible, the scanning of the examination volume shall be carried out from both sides of the weld on the same surface. Where configuration or adjacent parts of the component are such that scanning from both sides is not feasible, this fact shall be included in the report of examination.
PSEG Nuclear utilizes approved technical procedures written in accordance to applicable ASME Code section/paragraph criterion for area/volume requirements. Recognizing that because of component design, construction, etc. there are cases when examinations can only be performed to "the greatest extent practical". In those cases, plant procedures require the documentation of the location and cause of the limitation.
The Performance Demonstration Initiative (PDI) is in agreement with the NRC's September 22, 1999 Final Rule regarding single side access for piping. The Final Rule requires that if access is available, the austenitic steel weld shall be scanned in each of the four directions (parallel and perpendicular to the weld) where required. Ultrasonic examination of ferritic steel welds requires scanning in the two axial scan directions. Circumferential scanning is required in two directions only when axial indications were noted during preservice inspections. Coverage credit may be taken for single side exams on ferritic piping.
However, for austenitic piping, a procedure must be qualified with flaws on the inaccessible side of the weld.
Current technology is not capable of reliably detecting or sizing flaws on the far side of austenitic weld for configurations common to US nuclear applications. To demonstrate that the best available technology was applied, PDI provides a best effort qualification instead of a complete single sided qualification. PDI Performance Demonstration Qualification Summary (PDQS) austenitic piping certificates list the limitation that single side examination is performed on a best effort basis. When performing single side access of austenitic stainless steel piping welds the best available techniques are used from the accessible side of the weld, as qualified through the PDI.
This will require that the far side of the weld, which can only be accessed from one side, must be listed as an area of no coverage. In these instances PSEG Nuclear has documented and claimed credit for only obtaining 50% of the code-required coverage for any completed single side austenitic stainless steel piping weld exams.
Alternative Examination Alternate examinations were considered for each exam area where a limitation exists, however no alternative examinations were considered to be sufficient or appropriate.
Sl-RR-BOI 3
Document Control Desk LRN-01 -0433 Attachment I Relief Request: SI-RR-B01 Salem Unit 1-2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations System leakage tests were conducted upon class-1 pressure boundaries during station start-up after refueling outages. Likewise, surface exams were conducted, when required ASME X1 requirements to provide an additional level of assurance for the acceptability of the system's integrity and plant safety.
Applicability This Relief Request is applicable to the following:
Salem Unit 1 - Second Ten-Year Inservice Inspection Interval.
SI-RR-BO1 4
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment I Relief Request: S1-RR-B01 Salem Unit I-2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Interval/
Period/
Exam Examination Code Summary Outage Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Required Exam Results for Restriction Augmented No.
No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Additional Restriction Detail & Type Exam Upper Long Seam Exam limited due to outlet nozzle Recordable Physical Restriction-Examination limited due to 000900 2/3/2 05/14/2001 RPV 1-RPV-1042B
@ 7 degrees B-A RI. 21 UT 66%
IWB-2500-3 boss.
Indications Noted Configuration outlet nozzle boss interference No Lower Shell to Bottom Head Exam limited due to lncore Recordable Phisical Restriction-Examination limited due to 001200 2/3/2 05/14/2001 RPV I-RPV-10042 (Circ Weld)
B-A BI.11 UT 74%
IWB-2500-1 Penetrations interference.
Indications Noted Configuration incore penetrations interference No Lower Head Disc Exam limited due to Incore No Recordable Phesical Restriction-Examination limited due to 001300 2/3/2 05/14/2001 RPV 1-RPV-4043 to Peel Segments B-A B1.21 UT 21%
IWB-2500-3 Penetrations interference.
Indications Configuration incore penetrations interference No Meridional Weld
@ 270 degrees in Exam limited due to Incore No Recordable Physical Restriction-Examination limited due to 001400 2/3/2 05/14/2001 RPV I-RPV-1043-A Lower Head B-A 11.22 UT 70%/a IWB-2500-3 Penetrations interference.
Indications Configuration incore penetrations interference No Meridional Weld
@ 330 degrees in Exam limited due to Incore No Recordable Physical Restriction-Examination limited due to 001500 2/3/2 05/14/2001 RPV I-RPV-1043-B Lower Head B-A Bl.22 UT 700%
IWB-2500-3 Penetrations interference.
Indications Configuration incore penetrations interference No Meridional Weld
@ 30 degrees in Exam limited due to Incore No Recordable Physical Restriction-Examination limited due to 001600 2/3/2 05/14/2001 RPV I-RPV-1043-C Lower Head B-A BI.22 UT 70%/o IWB-2500-3 Penetrations interference.
Indications Configuration inore penetrations interference No Meridional Weld
@ 90 degrees in Exam limited due to Incore No Recordable Physical Restriction-Examination limited due to 001700 2/3/2 05/14/2001 RPV I-RPV-1043-D Lower Head B-A 51.22 UT 70%
IWB-2500-3 Penetrations interference.
Indications Configuration incore penetrations interference No Meridional Weld
@ 150 degrees in Exam limited due to Incore No Recordable Physical Restriction-Examination limited due to 001800 2/3/2 05/14/2001 RPV I-RPV-1043-E Lower Head B-A BI.22 UT 70%
IWB-2500-3 Penetrations interference.
Indications Configuration incore penetrations interference No Meridional Weld
@ 210 degrees in Exam limited due to Incore No Recordable Ph sical Restriction-Examination limited due to 001900 2/3/2 05/14/2001 RPV 1-RPV-1043-F Lower Head B-A BI.22 UT 70%
IWB-2500-3 Penetrations interference.
Indications Configuration incore penetrations interference No Physical Restriction-Examination limited due to CRD 40% Due to penetrations interference. Exam coverage was personel exposme Dollar Plate onperst oCoerage Exam limited due to CRD No Recordable estimated due to personnel exposure concerns. Dose 004400 2/3/2 04/23/2001 RPV 1-RPV-6046B Closure Weld B-A 51.21 UT wasestimatsd.
IWB-2500-3 Penetrations interference.
Indications Configuration rates in excess of lR/hr on head were present No MERIDIONAL Exam limited due to head WELD @300 transition and shroud ring No Recordable Physical Restriction-Exam limited due to head 004500 2/3/2 04/20/2001 RPV I-RPV-1046A DEG.
B-A B1.22 UT 83.18%
IWB-2500-3 interferences.
Indications Configuration transition and shroud ring interferences.
No MERIDIONAL Exam limited due to Closure No Recordable Physical Restriction-Examination limited due to 004600 2/3/2 04/21/2001 RPV l-RPV-1046B WELD @ 0 DEG B-A B1.22 UT 67.790%
IWB-2500-3 Head Lifting Lug interference.
Indications Configuration Closure Head Lifting Lug interference.
No MERIDIONAL Exam limited due to head WELD @ 60 transition and shroud ring No Recordable Physical Restriction-Exam limited due to head 004700 2/3/2 04/20/2001 RPV 1-RPV-1046C DEG.
B-A BI,22 UT 83.18%
IWB-2500-3 interferences.
Indications Configuration transition and shroud ring interferences.
No 12/2012001 5
$1-RR-B01
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment I Relief Request: S1-RR-B01 Salem Unit 1-2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Interval/
Period/
Exam Examination Code Summary Outage Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Required Exam Results for Restriction Augmented No.
No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Additional Restriction Detail & Type Exam MERIDIONAL WELD @ 120 Exam limited due to Closure No Recordable Physical Restriction-Examination limited due to 004800 2/3/2 04/20/2001 RPV 1-RPV-1046D DEG.
B-A B 1.22 UT 67.790%
IWB-2500-3 Head Lifling Lug interference.
Indications Configuration Closure Head Lifting Lug interference.
No MERIDIONAL Exam limited due to head WELD @ 180 transition and shroud ring No Recordable Physical Restriction-Exam limited due to head 004900 2/3/2 04/20/2001 RPV I-RPV-1046E DEG.
B-A BI.22 UT 83.18%
IWB-2500-3 interferences.
Indications Configuration transition and shroud ring interferences.
No MERIDIONAL WELD @ 240 Exam limited due to Closure No Recordable Phyical Restriction-Examination limited due to 005000 2/3/2 04/20/2001 RPV 1-RPV-1046F DEG.
B-A B1.22 UT 67.79%
IWB-2500-3 Head Lifting Lug interference.
Indications Configuration Closure Head Lifting Lug interference.
No Exam limited due to the Longitudinal componenfs insulation support No Recordable Physical Restriction-Insulation Ring limited exam to 006325 2/3/2 04/24/2001 PZR I-PZR-20 Weld Shell J B-B B2.12 UT 41.76%
IWB-2500-2 ring is present in the area.
Indications Configuration 5 inches No Exam limited due to the 4 lower vertical steam generator supports interference, name plate, outer Physical Restriction-due to the 4 lower vertical steam Lower Head to blend radius and tsbesheet No Recordable generator supports interference, name plate, outer 007901 2/3/2 04/19/2001 13-STG 13-STG-11 Tube Sheet B-B B2.40 UT 69.77%.
IWB-2500-6 configuration.
Indications Configuration blend radius and tubesheet configuration No Indications were noted and evaluated to be aceptable based upon ASME XI code equiremeants (1983 Ed.
Exam limited due to the 4 lower Wth Addenda thtough vertical steam generator supports Summer 1983).
interference, name plate, outer ndications possessed Physical Restriction-due to the 4 lower vertical steam no measurable Lower Head to blend radius and tobesheet hrough-wall generator supports interference, name plate, outer 008801 2/2/3 02/20/1997 14-STG 14-STG-11 Tube Sheet B-B B2.40 UT 75%
IWB-2500-6 configuration.
dimension.
Configuration blend radius and tubesheet configuration No Exam limited due to the 4 lower vertical steam generator supports interference, name plate, outer Physical Restriction-due to the 4 lower vertical steam Lower Head to blend radius and tubesheet No Recordable generator supports interference, name plate, outer 009701 2/2/3 02/20/1997 12-STG 12-STG-11 Tube Sheet B-B B2.40 UT 78%
IWB-2500-6 configuration.
Indications Configuration blend radius and tubesheet configuration No Exam limited due to the 4 lower vertical steam generator supports interference, name plate, outer Physical Restriction-due to the 4 lower vertical steam Lower Head to blend radius and tubesheet No Recordable generator supports interference, name plate, outer 010601 2/2/3 02/20/1997 1 1-STG 11-STG-11 Tube Sheet B-B B2.40 UT 77%
FWB-2500-6 configuration.
Indications Configuration blend radius and tubesheet configuration No Nozzle to Safe-Exam limited due to nozzle and No Recordable Physical Restriction-due to nozzle and safe-end 023400 2/3/2 04/21/2001 PR 6-PR-1 104-1 End B-F B5.40 UT 34.38%
IWB-2500-8 safe end configuration.
Indications Configuration configuration.
No SI-RR-BOI 6
12/2012001
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment I Relief Request: SI-RR-B01 Salem Unit 1-2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Interval/
Period/
Exam Examination Code Summary Outage Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Required Exam Results for Restriction Augmented No.
No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Additional Restriction Detail & Type Exam Nozzle to Safe-Exam limited due to nozzle and No Recordable Physical Restriction-due to nozzle and safe-end 024600 2/3/2 04/21/2001 PR 6-PR-i103-1 End B-F B5.40 UT 38.10%
IWB-2500-8 safe end configuration.
Indications Configuration configuration.
No Nozzle to Safe-Exam limited due to nozzle and No Recordable Physical Restriction-due to nozzle and safe-end 025900 2/3/2 04/21/2001 PR 4-PR-1100-1 End B-F B5.40 UT 34.38%
IWB-2500-8 safe end configuration.
Indications Configuration configuration.
No Exam limited due to nozzle configuration. No exams were performed from the nozzle side No Recordable 029700 2/2/1 05/06/1992 PS 14-PS-1131-2 Nozzle to Pipe B-F B5.40 UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 due to the OD configuration.
Indications Configuration Physical Restriction-due to nozzle configuration.
No Safe-End to Exam limited due to nozzle and No Recordable Physical Restriction-due to safe-end to nozzle 033500 2/3/2 04/21/2001 PS 4-PS-1131-29 Nozzle B-F B5.40 UT 34.38%
IWB-2500-8 safe end configuration.
Indications Configuration configuration.
No Exam limited due to nozzle configuration and limited scan Physical Restriction-due to safe-end to nozzle area and the elbow's materials configuration limits exam to the weld only.
acoustic properties associated Material Properties-The elbow's cast stainless steel with cast stainless steel (A-351 No Recordable (A-352, GR CF8M) does not support ultrasonic 039200 2/3/1 10/18/1999 RC 31-RC-1130-2R1 Nozzle to Elbow B-F B5.70 UT 25%
IWB-2500-8 GR CF8M).
Indications Configuration lexamination due to acoustic properties.
No Exam limited due to nozzle configuration and limited scan Physical Restriction-due to safe-end to nozzle area and the elbow's materials configuration limits exam to the weld only.
acoustic properties associated Material Properties-The elbow's cast stainless steel with cast stainless steel (A-351 No Recordable (A-352,GR CF8M) does not support ultrasonic 050210 2/3/1 10/18/1999 RC 29-RC-1130-5R1 Elbow to Nozzle B-F B5.70 UT 25%
IWB-2500-8 GR CF8M).
Indications Configuration examination due to acoustic properties.
No Exam limited due to nozzle configuration and limited scan Physical Restriction-due to safe-end to nozzle area and the elbow's materials configuration limits exam to the weld only.
acoustic properties associated Material Properties-The elbow's cast stainless steel with cast stainless steel (A-351 No Recordable (A-352,GR CF8M) does not support ultrasonic 052600 2/3/1 10/18/1999 RC 29-RC-1120-5R1 Elbow to Nozzle B-F B5.70 UT 25%
IWB-2500-8 GR CF8M).
Indications Configuration examination due to acoustic properties.
No Exam limited due to nozzle configuration and limited scan Physical Restriction-due to safe-end to nozzle area and the elbow's materials configuration limits exam to the weld only.
acoustic properties associated Material Properties-The elbow's cast stainless steel with cast stainless steel (A-351 No Recordable (A-352,GR CF8M) does not support ultrasonic 054300 2/3/1 10/18/1999 RC 29-RC-1 110-4R1 Elbow to Nozzle B-F B5.70 UT 25%
IWB-2500-8 GR CF8M).
Indications Configuration examination due to acoustic properties.
No 1212012001 SI-RR-BOI 7
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment I Relief Request: S1-RR-B01 Salem Unit 1-2nd Inservice Inspection Ton-Year NDE Exam Limitations 1212012001 IntervaLl Period/
Exam Examination Code Summary Outage Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Required Exam Results for Restriction Augmented No.
No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Additional Restriction Detail & Type Exam Examined 17 of 24 bolts (70%).
The remaining 7 studs (30%)
were unable to be examined due to inaccessibility resulting from permanently installed Physical Restriction-Seven bolts were unable to be miscellaneous piping (oil pans, examined due to inaccessibility. Access restrictions CVCS piping and were due to permanently installed miscellaneous Instrumentation Lines) located piping (oil pans, CVCS piping and Instrumentation over top of the stud UT Lines) located over top of the stud UT inspection Il-PMP-Bolts inspection heater holes for studs No Recordable Inaccessibility heater holes for studs 3,4,5,6,13,22,and 23 that prevent 190800 2/1/1 05/14/1992 1 1-RCP 1-24 Pump Bolts B-G-1 B6.180 UT 709%
IWB-2500-12 3,4,5,6,13,22,and 23.
Indications (7 bolts) hansducer access.
No Examined 16 of 24 bolts (670/.).
The remaining 8 (33%) studs were unable to be examined due to inaccessibility resulting from permanently installed Physical Restriction-Seven bolts were unable to be miscellaneous piping (oil pans, examined due to inaccessibility. Access restrictions CVCS piping and were due to permanently installed miscellaneous Instrumentation Lines) located piping (oil pans, CVCS piping and Instrumentation over top of the stud UT Lines) located over top of the stud UT inspection 12-PMP-Bolts inspection heater holes for studs No Recordable Inaccessibility heater holes for studs 3,4,5,6,7,13,14,and 23 that 191600 2/3/2 04/17/2001 12-RCP 1-24 Pump Bolts B-G-1 B6.180 UT 67%
IWB-2500-12 3,4,5,6,7,13,14,and 23.
Indications (8 bolts) prevent transducer access.
No Branch Connection to Exam limited due to the branch No Recordable Sin le Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Elbow 030100 2/3/1 10/20/1999 PS 4-PS-1131-1 Pipe B-J B9.11 UT 75%
IWB-2500-8 configuration.
Indications Configuration to Branch Configuration No Exam limited due to the valve to Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Exam 036500 2/1/2 02/23/1991 PS 4-PS-1111-23 Valve to Tee B-J B9. 11 UT 78%
IWB-2500-8 tee configuration.
Geometry Noted Configuration limited due to the valve to tee configuration.
No Exam limited due to the elbows materials acoustic properties Material Properties-The elbow's cast stainless steel associated with cast stainless No Recordable (A-352,GR CFSM) does not support ultrasonic 045600 2/3/1 10/20/1999 RC 3 I-RC-1110-4 Pipe to Elbow B-J B9. 11 UT 37.70%
IWB-2500-8 steel (A-351 GR CFSM).
Indications Configuration examination due to acoustic properties.
No 8
$1 -RR-B01
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment I Relief Request: SI-RR-B01 Salem Unit 1-2nd Inservlce Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Interval/
Period/
Exam Examination Code Summary Outage Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Required Exam Results for Restriction Augmented No.
No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Additional Restriction Detail & Type Exam Exam limited due to the valve to Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Exam 096700 2/2/2 10/26/93 SJ 10-SJ-1141-14 ValvetoTee B-J B9.11 UT 0%
IWB-2500-8 tee configuration.
Other Configuration limited due to the valve to tee configuration.
No Physical Restriction-Pipe to Elbow Configuration.
Exam limited due to elbow No Recordable The elbow's shortened intrados radius precludes 098500 2/2/3 10/26/1995 SJ 10-SJ-1131-10 Pipe to Elbow B-J B9. !1 UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 configuration.
Indications Configuration examination of 4".
No Physical Restriction-Elbow to Pipe Configuration.
The presence of the wall penetration limited supported Exam limited to due to a No Recordable examination from the elbow side only due to the close 100200 2/3/1 10/20/1999 SJ 10-SJ-1121-8 Elbow to Pipe B-J B9.11 UT 47.40%
IWB-2500-8 )enetation wall obstruction.
Indications Configuration proximity ofthe weld to the wall penetration.
No Exam limited due to valve to Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Valve 103700 2/2/1 05/08/1992 Sj 10-SSJ-1111-18 Valve to Elbow B-J B9. 11 UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 elbow configuration.
Geomelry Noted Configuration to Elbow Configuration No Exam limited on the downstream Pipe to Branch side due to branch connection Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Pipe to 104100 2/2/1 05/05/1989 S1 10-SJ-1111-22 Connection B-J B9.11 UT 50%0 IWB-2500-8 configuration.
Geometry Noted Configuration Branch Connection Configuration No Exam limited due to the inner No Recordable Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Pipe to 111300 2/2/3 10/26/1995 SJ 10-SJ-1152-19 Pipe to Tee B-J B9.11 UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 rdius of the tee configuration.
Indications Configuration Tee Configuration No Exam limited due to the reducer No Recordable Physical Restriction-Exam limited due to the reducer Yes 115300 2/2/1 05/19/1992 SJ 6-SiJ-1141-1 Reducer to Elbow B-I B9. 11 UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 to elbow configuration.
Indications Configuration to elbow configuration.
IEB 76-06 Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Exam Elbow to Branch Exam limited due to the elbow to limited due to the elbow to branch connection 117000 2/1/2 03/11/1991 Si 6-SJ-1141-18 Connection B-J B9. 11 UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 branch connection configuration.
Geometry Noted Configuration configuration.
No Exam limited due to elbow to No Recordable Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Elbow 122300 2/3/1 10/15/1999 SJ 6-SJ-1121-2 Elbow to Valve B-i B9.11 UT 63.90%
IWB-2500-8 valve configuration.
Indications Configuration to Valve Configuration No Exam limited from the downstream side due to valve Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel 122700 2/1/1 05/05/1989 SJ 6-SJ-1112-1 Reducer to Valve B-J B9.11 UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 configuration.
Geometry Noted Configuration Reducer to Valve Configuration No Exam limited due to the reducer Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Exam 124100 2/2/1 05/19/1992 SJ 6-SiJ-1111-1 Reducer to Valve B-J B9.11 UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 to valve configuration.
Geometry Noted Configuration limited due to the reducer to valve configuration.
No SI-RR-801 12120/2001 9
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment I Relief Request: SI-RR-B01 Salem Unit I-2nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations 12/2012001 Interval/
Period/
Exam Examination Code Summary Outage Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Required Exam Results for Restriction Augmented No.
No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Additional Restriction Detail & Type Exam Exam limited due to Branch Physical Restriction-Examination limited due to short 129400 2/1/2 02/21/1991 SJ 4-SI-1182-18 Pipe to Elbow B-J B9.11 UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 connection configuration.
Geometry Noted Configuration elbow radius configuration.
No Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel Exam limited due to the tee to Examination limited due to the tee to reducer 133800 2/2/1 10/19/1992 SJ 4-SJ-1 172-28 Tee to Reducer B-J B9.1I UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 reducer configuration.
Geometry Noted Configuration configuration.
No Exam limited due to valve to No Recordable Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Valve Yes 016700 2/3/2 04/24/2001 CVCS 3-CV-1141-14 Valve to Elbow B-J B9.21 UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 elbow configuration.
Indications Configuration to Elbow Configuration IEB 88-08 Elbow to Branch Exam limited due to branch No Recordable Sinite Side Access-Austenific Stainless Steel-Elbow Yes 016801 2/2/3 10/30/1995 CVCS 3-CV-1141-15 Connection B-J B9.21 UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 configuration.
Indications Configuration to Branch Configuration IEB 88-08 Exam limited due to valve No Recordable Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Valve 018300 2/2/1 04/30/1992 CVCS 3-CV-1133-15 Valve to Pipe B-J B9.21 UT 50%
IWB-2500-8 configuration.
Indications Configuration to Pipe Configuration No Exam limited due to snubber No Recordable Physical Restriction-Examination limited due snubber 161100 2/1/2 02/16/1991 Si 2-SJ-1128-57 Coupling to Pipe B-J B9.40 PT 83%
IWB-2500-8 clamp and plate interference.
Indications Inaccessibility clamp and plate interference.
No Physical Restriction-Examination limited due welded Exam limited due to welded pipe No Recordable pipe support. No exam able to be performed for 3.5" 180900 2/1/1 05/09/1989 1SJ 1.5-SJ-1122-7 Tee to Pipe B-J B9.40 PT 75%
IWB-2500-8 support interference.
Indications Configuration (6" and 9.5").
No IWB-2500- Exam limited due to permanent No Recordable Physical Restriction-Examination limited due to 191000 2/1/1 05/12/1989 RCP I i-PMP-iLG Lug B-K-I B 10.20 PT 83%
15 support strncture.
Indications Configuration permanent support structore between 83" -to 3".
No IWB-2500- Exam limited due to permanent No Recordable lPh sical Restriction-Examination limited due to 191100 2/1/1 05/12/1989 RCP 11-PMP-2LG Lug B-K-I B 10.20 PT 83%
15 support structure.
Indications Configuration permanent support structure between 83" to 3".
No Exam limited due to the Physical Restriction-The bottom side of the lug was IWB-2500- configuration of the pump No Recordable inaccessible due to it being covered by the pump 192600 2/3/1 10/08/1999 13-RCP 13-PMP-ILG Pump Lug B-K-i B10.20 PT 77.50%
15 support structure.
Indications Inaccessibility support structure.
No 10
$S -RR-BOt
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment I
Relief Request: SI-RR-B01 Salem Unit 1-2nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Interval/
Period/
Exam Examination Code Summary Outage Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Required Exam Results for Restriction Augmented No.
No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Additional Restriction Detail & Type Exam Exam limited due to the Physical Restriction-The bottom side of the lug was IWB-2500- configuration of the pump support No Recordable inaccessible due to it being covered by the pump 192650 2/3/1 10/08/1999 13-RCP 13-PMP-2LG Pump Lug B-K-I B10.20 PT 77.50%
15 structure.
Indications Inaccessibility support structure.
No Exam limited due to the Physical Restriction-The bottom side of the lug was IWB-2500- configuration ofthe pump support No Recordable inaccessible due to it being covered by the pump 192700 2/3/1 10/08/1999 13-RCP 13-PMP-3LG Pump Lug B-K-i Bi0.20 PT 77.50%
15 structure.
Indications Inaccessibility support structure.
No SI-RR-OI 111212012001 11 S1-RR-B01
Document Control Desk LRN-01 -0433 Attachment II Relief Request: S1-RR-CO1 Salem Unit 1-2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Component Description Class 2 Component Limitations identified during Salem Unit 1 2 nd Ten-Year Inservice Inspection Interval ASME Code Class:
ASME Section XI Class 2 Code Requirement Salem Unit 1 2 nd Ten-Year Inservice Inspection Interval inservice inspection examinations were performed in accordance with the requirements of ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section Xl 1983 Edition up through and including Summer 1983 Addenda Article IWC-2500 to the extent practical.
Imposed September 22, 1999 Final Rule requirements 10CFR50.55a(b)(2)(xv)(A),
10CFR50.55a(b)(2)(xv)(G), and 10CFR50.55a(b)(2)(xvi), defined new requirements for coverage and examination demonstrations. These requirements affected both piping and Reactor Pressure Vessel (RPV) examinations.
The 3 rd Ten-Year Inservice Inspection Interval inservice inspection examinations will be performed in accordance with the above Final Rule requirements and ASME Section Xl 1995 Edition up through and including 1996 Addenda Article IWC-2500 requirements to the extent practical.
Basis for Relief Pursuant to 10CFR50.55a (a)(3)(ii), relief is requested from performing the inservice examination for the inaccessible or physically obstructed portions of the examination areas identified within Salem Unit 1-2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten Year NDE Exam Limitations table attached. This information is also contained within Salem's Unit 1 Inservice Inspection Program Long Term Plan.
In addition, previously issued RPV qualifications do not met the new requirements for single side access, that are listed in the September 22, 1999 Final Rule, 10CFR50.55a(b)(2)(xv)(G)(1),(2) and 10CFR50.55a(b)(2)(xvi)(A).
The prevailing limitations and the specific relief for each weld are contained within the Salem Unit 1 - 2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations table. The table contains the following entries pertaining to each subject weld/bolting areas:
SI-RR-Co1 I
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment II Relief Request: SI-RR-C01 Salem Unit 1-2nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Component Summary Component Exam Method Summarized Exam Number Identification Limited Results for Area Inspected Interval/Period/Outage Geometric Estimated total Restriction Type Number configuration coverage area Exam Date ASME Category Code Required Restriction Volume Requirement Description Details Description System Designation ASME Item Number Obstruction Augmented Exam Description (General)
Description The subject welds received volumetric examination by radiography and/or surface examinations during fabrication, in accordance with approved construction code requirements that provide adequate assurance of the structural integrity of welds prior to plant operation.
Throughout 10CFR50.55a (g) numerous references are made allowing performance of these inspections "to the extent practical". Some of these specific paragraphs are:
(g) Inservice inspection requirements. Requirements for inservice testing of Class 1, Class 2, and Class 3 pumps and valves are located in §50.55a(f).
(1) For a boiling or pressurized water-cooled nuclear power facility whose construction permit was issued before January 1, 1971, components (including supports) must meet the requirements of paragraphs (g)(4) and (g)(5) of this section to the extent practical. Components, which are part of the reactor coolant pressure boundary and their supports, must meet the requirements applicable to components, which are classified as ASME Code Class 1. Other safety-related pressure vessels, piping, pumps and valves, and their supports must meet the requirements applicable to components which are classified as ASME Code Class 2 or Class 3.
(4) Throughout the service life of a boiling or pressurized water-cooled nuclear power facility, components (including supports) which are classified as ASME Code Class 1, Class 2 and Class 3 must meet the requirements, except design and access provisions and preservice examination requirements, set forth in Section Xl of editions of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code and Addenda that become effective subsequent to editions specified in paragraphs (g)(2) and (g)(3) of this section and that are incorporated by reference in paragraph (b) of this section, to the extent practical within the limitations of design, geometry and materials of construction of the components. Components which are classified as Class MC pressure retaining components and their integral attachments, and components which are classified as Class CC pressure retaining components and their integral attachments must meet the requirements, except design and access provisions and preservice examination requirements, set forth in Section Xl of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code and Addenda that are incorporated by reference in paragraph (b) of this section, subject to the limitation listed in paragraph (b)(2)(vi) of this section and the modifications listed in paragraphs (b)(2)(viii) and (b)(2)(ix) of this section, to the extent practical within the limitation of design, geometry and materials of construction of the components.
S$ -RR-C01 2
Document Control Desk LRN-01 -0433 Attachment II Relief Request: S1-RR-CO1 Salem Unit I-2nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations The ASME Code itself provides allowance for "limited" examinations. The ASME Section V 1983 Edition up through and including Summer 1983 Addenda paragraph T-441.4.4 Extent of Scanning and later editions of the code indicate state: "Wherever feasible, the scanning of the examination volume shall be carried out from both sides of the weld on the same surface. Where configuration or adjacent parts of the component are such that scanning from both sides is not feasible, this fact shall be included in the report of examination.
PSEG Nuclear utilizes approved technical procedures written in accordance to applicable ASME Code section/paragraph criterion for area/volume requirements. Recognizing that because of component design, construction, etc.
there are cases when examinations can only be performed to "the greatest extent practical". In those cases, plant procedures require the documentation of the location and cause of the limitation.
The Performance Demonstration Initiative (PDI) is in agreement with the NRC's September 22, 1999 Final Rule regarding single side access for piping. The Final Rule requires that if access is available, the austenitic steel weld shall be scanned in each of the four directions (parallel and perpendicular to the weld) where required. Ultrasonic examination of ferritic steel welds requires scanning in the two axial scan directions. Circumferential scanning is required in two directions only when axial indications were noted during preservice inspections.
Coverage credit may be taken for single side exams on ferritic piping. However, for austenitic piping, a procedure must be qualified with flaws on the inaccessible side of the weld.
Current technology is not capable of reliably detecting or sizing flaws on the far side of austenitic weld for configurations common to US nuclear applications. To demonstrate that the best available technology was applied, PDI provides a best effort qualification instead of a complete single sided qualification. PDI Performance Demonstration Qualification Summary (PDQS) austenitic piping certificates list the limitation that single side examination is performed on a best effort basis. When performing single side access of austenitic stainless steel piping welds the best available techniques are used from the accessible side of the weld, as qualified through the PDI. This will require that the far side of the weld, which can only be accessed from one side, must be listed as an area of no coverage. In these instances PSEG Nuclear has documented and claimed credit for only obtaining 50% of the code-required coverage for any completed single side austenitic stainless steel piping weld exams.
SI-RR-CO1 3
Document Control Desk LRN-01 -0433 Attachment II Relief Request: SI-RR-COI Salem Unit 1-2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Alternative Examination Alternate examinations were considered for each exam area where a limitation exists, however no alternative examinations were considered to be sufficient or appropriate.
System leakage tests were conducted upon class 2 pressure boundaries during station start-up after refueling outages. Likewise, surface exams were conducted, when required ASME XI requirements to provide an additional level of assurance for the acceptability of the system's integrity and plant safety.
Applicability This Relief Request is applicable to the following:
Salem Unit 1 - Second Ten-Year Inservice Inspection Interval.
SI-RR-COI 4
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment II Relief Request: SI-RR-C01 Salem Unit 1-2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Exam Examination Summary Interpaleriodl Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Code Required Exam Results for Restriction Additional Restriction Detail &
Augmented No.
Outage No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Type Exam Physical Restriction-Examination Examination limited due to vessel No Recordable limited due to vessel supports and 204400 2/3/2 04/27/2001 BIT I-BIT-A Shell Circ. Weld C-A Cl.10 UT 85.900%
IWC-2500-1 supports and nozzles.
Indications Configuration nozzles.
No Examination limited due to Physical Restriction-Examination insulation ring, branch connections, No Recordable limited due to insulation ring, branch 204410 2/3/2 04/27/2001 BIT 1-BIT-B Shell Circ. Weld C-A C 1.10 UT 65.50%
IWC-2500-1 and welded lugs.
Indications Configuration connections, and welded lugs.
No Physical Restriction-Exam limited Exam limited due to support due to support structure interference structure interference and flange to No Recordable and flange to shell configuration 205030 2/2/2 10/13/1993 RCF I-RCF-2 Flange to Shell C-A CI.10 UT 73%
IWC-2500-1 shell configuration.
Indications Configuration between 17" -20.25".
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to flange limited due to flange configuration c onfiguration and nozzle and nozzle interference between 205150 2/1/1 05/06/1989 RHRHEX l1.RHRHEX-1 Flange to Shell C-A CI.10 UT 80%
IWC-2500-1 interference.
Geometry Noted Configuration 112"-5" and 52"-66".
No Exam limited due to flange Physical Restriction-Examination configuration, nozzle and vessel limited due to flange configuration, 205160 2/3/2 04/14/2001 RHRHEX I 1-RHRHEX-2 Shell Circ. Weld C-A Cl. 10 UT 16.03%
IWC-2500-1 supports.
Geometry Noted Configuration nozzle and vessel supports.
No Recordable Physical Restriction-Examination Indications Noted-limited due to a welded support legs PSBP 324293 and that caused a scanning obstruction.
50.59 Performed Scan area was obstructed for 13" at 4 Exam limited due to a welded (CR 70001790 locations at 45,135,225, and 315 204800 2/3/1 10/15/1999 CVCT 1-CVCT-2 Shell Circ. Weld C-A C1.20 UT 81.60%
IWC-2500-1 support obstruction.
Initiated)
Configuration degrees.
No Physical Restriction-No Obstructions were noted on the head side. The total length of the two branch connections is at top center of Exam limited due to two branch the vessel and the other is at 10.5" 204870 2/3/1 10/12/1999 ELHEX I-EL-EX-2 Shell Circ. Weld C-A C1.20 UT 71.70%
IWC-2500-1 connections configuration Geometry Noted Configuration clockwise to 14.5" clockwise.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Upper Head to Exam limited due to flange No Recordable limited due to flange configuration 205020 2/2/2 10/13/1993 RCF 1-RCF-1 Flange C-A C1.20 UT 74%
IWC-2500-1 configuration and head curvature.
Indications Configuration and head curvature.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Shell to Lower Exam limited due to support lug and No Recordable limited due to support lugs and 205040 2/3/2 04/10/2001 RCF 1-RCF-3 Head C-A C1.20 UT 57.34%
IWC-2500-1 nozzle interference.
Indications Configuration nozzle.
No Exam limited due to branch Physical Restriction-Exam limited Tubesheet to connection, hanger and restraint ID Geometry due to branch connection, hanger and 205095 2/1/2 02/27/1991 RHE 1-RHE-3 Shell C-A C1.30 UT 75%
IWC-2500-2 interference.
Noted Configuration restraint interference.
No SI-RR-COI 12120/2001 5
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment II Relief Request: SI-RR-C01 Salem Unit 1-2 "d Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Exam Examination Summary loterval(eriod/
Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Code Required Exam Results for Restriction Additional Restriction Detail &
Augmented No.
Outage No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Type Exam Physical Restriction-Approximately 16" of weldment is unable to be examined due to the physical location of the steam generator's insulation ring located on the shell. Removal or movement of the insulation ring would require a large amount of resources and personnel exposure and time to erect/remove scaffolding, and remove/reinstall insulation Examination limited due to No Recordable located above/below the nozzle in 204001 2/3/2 04/27/2001 1 1-STG 16-BFN-21 11-1 Nozzle to Shell C-B C2.21 UT 70.64%
IWC-2500-4(a) insulation ring on the shell.
Indications Inaccessibility order to gain access for examination.
No Physical Restriction-Approximately 16" of weldment is unable to be examined due to the physical location ofthe steam generator's insulation ring located on the shell. Removal or movement of the insulation ring would require a large amount of resources and personnel exposure and time to erect/remove scaffolding, and remove/reinstall insulation Examination limited due to No Recordable located above/below the nozzle in 204001 2/3/2 04/27/2001 11-STG 16-BFN-2111-1 Nozzle to Shell C-B C2.21 MT 85.21%
IWC-2500-4(a) insulation ring on the shell.
Indications Inaccessibility order to gain access for examination.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to the nozzle No Recordable limited due to insulation ring, branch 204450 2/3/1 10/20/1999 BIT I-BIT-2 Nozzle to Shell C-B C2.21 UT 21.20%
IWC-2500-4(a) configuration.
Indications Configuration connections, and welded lugs.
No Physical Restriction-No Examinations were performed from No Recordable 1"-2" and 58"-60" and from 28"-32" 205163 2/2/1 05/06/1989 RHRHEX 1 1-R.HRHEX-IN Nozzle to Shell C-B C2.21 PT 18%
IWC-2500-4(a) Exam limited due to adjacent welds.
Indications Configuration shell side due to proximity of welds No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to nozzle limited due to nozzle configuration 25.44%/-45S configuration, support lugs upstream No Recordable downstream, support lugs upstream 205163 2/2/1 05/06/19g9 RHRHEX 11-RHRHEX-IN Nozzle to Shell C-B C2.21 UT 22.47%-60L IWC-2500-4(a) and proximity of welds I and 2.
Indications Configuration and proximity of welds I and 2.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to nozzle limited due to nozzle configuration 25.44%-45S configuration, support lugs upstream No Recordable downstream, support lugs upstream 205168 2/3/2 04/24/2001 RHRHEX1 11-RHREX-OUT Nozzle to Shell C-B C2.21 UT 22.47%-60L IWC-2500-4(a) and proximity of welds 1 and 2.
Indications Configuration and proximity of welds I and 2.
No 1212012001 SI-RR-C01 6
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment II Relief Request: S1-RR-CO1 Salem Unit 1-2'd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Exam Examination Summary IntervamPeriod/
Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Code Required Exam Results for Restriction Additional Restriction Detail &
Augmented No.
Outage No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Type Exam Physical Restriction-Total Weld Length 24.5"- Examined 6.5" due to Exam limited due to dle close No Recordable limited access caused by the close 214910 2/2/2 05/14/1992 FW 14-BF-2121-3PL-1 Pipe Lug C-C C3.20 MT 26.50%
IWC-2500-5 proximity of the penetration.
Indications Configuration proximity of the penetration.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to inaccessibility limited due to inaccessibility of the of the exam areas resulting from the exam areas resulting from the restraint system associated with the No Recordable restraint system associated with the 218050 2/1/1 05/12/1989 BF 14-BF-2111-3PL-I Pipe Lug C-C C3.20 MT 67%
IWC-2500-5 lugs attached.
Indications Inaccessibility lugs attached.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to inaccessibility limited due to inaccessibility of the ofthe exam areas resulting from the exam areas resulting from the restraint system associated with the No Recordable restraint system associated with the 218060 2/i/I 05/12/1989 BF 14-BF-2111-3PL-2 Pipe Lug C-C C3.20 MT 67%
IWC-2500-5 lugs attached.
Indications Inaccessibility lugs attached.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to inaccessibility limited due to inaccessibility of the of the exam areas resulting from the exam areas resulting from the restraint system associated with the No Recordable restraint system associated with the 218070 2/1/1 05/12/1989 BF 14-BF-2111-3PL-3 Pipe Lug C-C C3.20 MT 67%!.
IWC-2500-5 lugs attached.
Indications Inaccessibility lugs attached.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to inaccessibility limited due to inaccessibility of the of the exam areas resulting from the exam areas resulting from the restraint system associated with the No Recordable restraint system associated with the 218080 2/1/1 05/12/1989 BF 14-BF-2111-3PL-4 Pipe Lug C-C C3.20 MT 67%
1WC-2500-5 lugs attached.
Indications Inaccessibility lugs attached.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to inaccessibility limited due to inaccessibility of the of the exam areas resulting from the exam areas resulting from the restraint system associated with the No Recordable restraint system associated with the 218090 2/1/1 05/12/1989 BF 14-BF-2111-3PL-5 Pipe Lug C-C C3.20 MT 67%
IWC-2500-5 lugs attached.
Indications Inaccessibility lugs attached.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to inaccessibility limited due to inaccessibility of the of the exam areas resulting from the exam areas resulting from the "restraint system associated with the No Recordable restraint system associated with the 218100 2/1/1 05/12/1989 BF 14-BF-2111-3PL-6 Pipe Lug C-C C3.20 MT 67%
IWC-2500-5 lugs attached.
Indications Inaccessibility lugs attached.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to inaccessibility limited due to inaccessibility of the ofthe exam areas resulting from the exam areas resulting from the restraint system associated with the No Recordable restraint system associated with the 218110 2/1/1 05/12/1989 BF 14-BF-21 Il-3PL-7 Pipe Lug C-C C3.20 MT 67%
IWC-2500-5 lugs attached, Indications Inaccessibility lugs attached.
No St-RR-CO1 1212012001 7
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment II Relief Request: S1-RR-CO1 Salem Unit I-2nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Exam Examination Summary ltervalueriod/
Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Code Required Exam Results for Restriction Additional Restriction Detail &
Augmented No.
outage No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Type Exam Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to inaccessibility limited due to inaccessibility of the of the exam areas resulting from the exam areas resulting from the restraint system associated with the No Recordable restraint system associated with the 218120 2/1/1 05/12/1989 BF 14-BF-2111-3PL-8 Pipe Lug C-C C3.20 MT 67%
IWC-2500-5 lugs attached.
Indications Inaccessibility lugs attached.
No Exam limited due to a permanent obstruction from adjacent Physical Restriction-Examined 14" components and the component No Recordable due to limited access caused by the 218130 2/3/1 10/15/1999 FW 14-BF-2111-3PS-1 Pipe Support C-C C3.20 MT 32%
IWC-2500-5 configuration.
Indications Configuration penetration support lugs.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to support lugs and No Recordable limited due to support lugs and 227900 2/W/2 03/12/1991 MS 32-MS-2141-2PS-2 Pipe Support C-C C3.20 MT 25%
IWC-2500-5 instnumentation lines interference.
Indications Inaccessibility instrumentation lines interference.
No Physical Restriction-The upstream Exam limited due to a permanent side of each lug was unable to be 32-MS-2141-2PL obstrsction from the penetration No Recordable examined due to the close proximity 228000 2/3/1 10/15/1999 MS 1 thrm 12 Pipe Lugs C-C C3.20 MT 65.40%
IWC-2500-5 wall.
Indications Configuration of the penetration.
No Physical Restriction-The upstream Exam limited due to a permanent side of each lug was unable to be 32-MS-2131-2PL obstruetion from the penetration No Recordable examined due to the close proximity 229000 2/3/1 10/15/1999 MS I thru 12 Pipe Lugs C-C C3.20 MT 65.40%
IWC-2500-5 wall.
Indications Configuration of the penetration.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to lugs and No Recordable completed from 29.75" to 43" due to Yes 230000 2/2/1 03/12/1991 MS 32-MS-2121-2PS-2 Pipe Support C-C C3.20 MT 13%
IWC-2500-5 instnrnmentation lines.
Indications Configuration lugs and instrument lines.
MEB 3-1 Physical Restriction-The upstream Exam limited due to a permanent side of each lug was unable to be 32-MS-2121-2PL obstruction from the penetration No Recordable examined due to the close proximity 230100 2/3/1 10/15/1999 MS I thru 12 Pipe Lugs C-C C3.20 MT 65.40%
IWC-2500-5 wall.
Indications Configuration of the penetration.
No Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to pipe support No Recordable limited due to permanently installed 231200 2/3/1 10/15/1999 MS 32-MS-2111-2PS-2 Pipe Support C-C C3.20 MT 35.80%
IWC-2500-5 configuration.
Indications Configuration structural elements.
No PhyLsical Restriction-The upstream Exam limited due to a permanent side of each lug was unable to be 32-MS-2111-2PL I
obstruction from the penetration No Recordable examined due to the close proximity 231300 2/3/1 10/15/1999 MS thrd 12 Pipe Lugs C-C C3.20 MT 65.40%
IWC-2500-5 wall.
Indications Configuration ofthe penetration.
No Physical Restriction-A permanent obstruction from the penetration wall Exam limited due to a permanent exists within 1.0" of the exam obstruction from the penetration No Recordable surface. Area is not accessible to 263332 2/3/1 10/15/1999 RHR 14-RH-2112-7PS-3 Pipe Support C-C C3.20 PT 67%0 IWC-2500-5 wall.
Indications Configuration support PT examination.
No S1-RR-CO1 1212012001 8
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment II Relief Request: S1-RR-C01 Salem Unit I-2nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Exam Examination Summary Interval/Peiod/
Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Code Required Exam Results for Restriction Additional Restriction Detail &
Augmented No.
Outage No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Type Exam Physical Restriction-A permanent obstruction from the penetration wall Exam limited due to a permanent exists within 1.0" of the exam obstruction from the penetration No Recordable surface. Area is not accessible to 263334 2/3/1 10/15/1999 RHR 14-RH-2112-7PS-4 Pipe Support C-C C3.20 PT 67%
IWC-2500-5 wall.
Indications Configuration support PT examination.
No Integrally Physical Restriction-Examination 11-CHG/SI-PMP-IA Welded Exam limited due to pump supports No Recordable limited due to pump supports and 205280 2/3/2 04/10/2001 CVCS (1-4)
Supports C-C C3.30 PT 73%
IWC-2500-5 and pump end cap obstruction.
Indications Configuration pump end cap obstruction.
No Physical Restriction-No exam able to be performed between due to an Exam limited due to surrounding No Recordable obstruction from the 12 main steam 277900 2=2/2 05/20/1992 MS 12-MS-167-VS-1 Valve Support C-C C3.40 MT 81.90%
IWC-2500-5 support structure Indications Configuration header permanent support structure.
No Physical Restriction-No exam able to be performed between due to an Exam limited due to surrounding No Recordable obstruction from the 12 main steam 277940 2/2/2 05/20/1992 MS 12-MS-167-VS-IA Valve Support C-C C3.40 MT 81.90%
IWC-2500-5 support structure Indications Configuration header permanent support structure.
No Physical Restriction-No exam able to be performed between due to an Exam limited due to surrounding No Recordable obstruction from the 12 main steam 277960 2/2/2 05/20/1992 MS 12-MS-167-VS-lB Valve Support C-C C3.40 MT 64.10%
IWC-2500-5 support structure Indications Configuration header permanent support structure.
No Physical Restriction-No exam able No exam able to be performed to be performed due to an obstruction between due to surrounding support No Recordable from the 13 main steam header 278140 2/2/1 05/04/1989 MS 13-MS-167-VS-IA Valve Support C-C C3.40 MT 81.90%
IWC-2500-5 structure Indications Configuration permanent support structure.
No Physical Restriction-No exam able No exam able to be performed to be performed due to an obstruction between due to surrounding support No Recordable from the 13 main steam header 278240 2/2/1 05/04/1989 MS 13-MS-167-VS-2A Valve Support C-C C3.40 MT 81.90%
IWC-2500-5 structure Indications Configuration permanent support structure.
No Physical Restriction-No exam able No exam able to be performed to be performed due to an obstruction between due to surrounding support from the 14 main steam header 278240 2/1/1 5/4/89 MS 13 MS 167 VS-2A Valve Support C-C C3.40 MT Qo/o IWC-2500-5 structure Other Inaccessibility permanent support structure.
No Physical Restriction-No exam able No exam able to be performed to be performed due to an obstruction between due to surrounding support from the 14 main steam header 278340 2/3/1 10/15/1999 MS 14-MS-167-VS-IA Valve Support C-C C3.40 MT 0O/%
IWC-2500-5 structure Other Inaccessibility permanent support structure.
No 1212012001 S1-RR-C01 9
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment II Relief Request: SI-RR-C01 Salem Unit 1-2 nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Exam Examination Summary n.ftlrvaPerdI Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Code Required Exam Results for Restriction Additional Restriction Detail &
Augmented No.
Outage No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Type Exam Physical Restriction-No exam able No exam able to be performed to be performed due to an obstruction between due to surrounding support from the 14 main steam header 278440 2/3/1 10/15/1999 MS 14-MS-167-VS-2A Valve Support C-C C3.40 MT 0%
IWC-2500-5 tructre Other Inaccessibility permanent support structure.
No Physical Restriction-No exam able No exam able to be performed to be performed due to an obstruction between due to surrounding support from the 14 main steam header 278440 2/3/1 10/15/99 MS 14 MS 167 VS-2A Valve Support C-C C3.40 MT 0%
IWC-2500-5 tructure Other Inaccessibility permanent support structure.
No Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Limitation exists for the valve side of the weld due to outside diameter geometry.
Additional angles were used to Yes Exam limited due to the valve No Recordable improve code coverage to the extent NRC RAI 263422 2/3/1 10/20/1999 RHR 8-RH-2173-2 Valve to Elbow C-F-i A-E<3/8 UT 59.509/o IWC-2500-7 configuration.
Indications Configuration oractical.
11/9/88
_Single Side Access-Austanitic Yes Exam limited due to the valve No Recordable Stainless Steel-Examination limited NRC RAI 263616 2/3/1 10/29/1999 RHR 8-RH-2116-2 Valve to Pipe C-F-I A-E<3/8 L
UT 57.20%
IWC-2500-7 configuration.
Indications Configuration due to the valve configurations.
11/9/88 Exam limited due to flange to valve No Recordable Stainless Steel-Exam limited due to 263620 2/2/3 4/9/97 RH 8-RH-2116-4R1 Flange to Valve C-F-I A-E<3/8 L
UT 50%
IWC-2500-7 configuration.
Indications Configuration flange to valve configuration.
No
_Single Side Access-Austenitic Yes Exam limited due to the flange to tee No Recordable Stainless Steel-Examination limited NRC RAI 263620 2/2/3 04/09/1997 RHR 8-RH-2116-4R1 Flange to Valve C-F-I A-E<3/8 UT 50%
IWC-2500-7 configuration.
Indications Configuration due to the flange to tee configuration.
11/9/88 Single Side Access-Austenitic Yes Exam limited due to the valve No Recordable Stainless Steel-Examination limited NRC RAI 354640 2/3/1 10/20/1999 CS 8-CS-2123-46 Valve to Elbow C-F-I A-E<3/8 UT 64.40%
IWC-2500-7 configuration.
indications Configuration due to the valve configuration.
11/9/88 Single Side Access-Austenitic Yes Exam limited due to the valve No Recordable Stainless Steel Examination limited NRC RAI 356360 2/3/1 10/20/1999 CS 8-CS-2114-46 Valve to Elbow C-F-I A-E
<3/8 UT 73.50%
IWC-2500-7 configuration.
Indications Configuration due to the valve configuration.
11/9/88 Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-No examination could be performed from the Pipe to Branch Exam limited due to branch No Recordable downstream side due to the nozzle 263110 2/3/2 04/20/2001 PR 6-PR-2101-13 Connection C-F-I C5.11 UT 56.91%
IWC-2500-9 connection configuration.
Indications Configuration configuration.
No Single Side Access-Austenitic Exam limited due to flange to pump Stainless Steel-Limited examination 263304 2/2/2 10/19/93 R
.H 14-RH-2114-18 Flange to Pump C-F-1 C5.11 UT 50%
IWC-2500-7 configuration.
Configuration due to flange to pump configuration.
No
$13-RR-COI 12/2012001 10
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment II Relief Request: S1-RR-C01 Salem Unit 1-2nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Exam Examination Summary Inl/Period/
Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Code Required Exam Results for Restriction Additional Restriction Detail &
Augmented No.
Outage No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Type Exam Single Side Access-Austeniic Stainless Steel-Examination limited Exam limited due to the pump and No Recordable due to the pump and valve 263614 2/3/1 10/29/1999 RHR 8-RH-2116-1 Pump to Valve C-F-1 C5.11 UT 23.10%
IWC-2500-7 valve configurations.
Indications Configuration configurations.
No Single Side Access-Austenitic Stainless Steel-Examination limited Safe-End to Exam limited due to nozzle upstream No Recordable due to nozzle upstream and adjacent 264206 2/3/2 04/14/2001 Si 6-SJ-2104-4 Nozzle C-F-I C5.11 UT 37.50%
IWC-2500-7 and adjacent weld downstream.
Indications Configuration weld downstream.
No Single Side Access-Austenitic Exam limited due to the tee No Recordable Stainless Steel-Examination limited 360500 2/3/1 10/20/1999 CVCS 3-CV-2156-1 Tee to Pipe C-F-I C5.21 UT 58.30%
IWC-2500-7 configuration.
Indications Configuration due to the tee configuration.
No Single Side Access-Austenitic Exam limited due to tee No Recordable Stainless Steel-Examination limited 384000 2/1/1 4/28/89 SJ 4-SJ-2113-19 Tee to Valve C-F-I C5.21 UT 77%
IWC-2500-7 configuration.
Indications Configuration due to tee configuration.
No Single Side Access-Austenitic Exam limited due to the valve No Recordable Stainless Steel-Examination limited 385020 2/3/1 10/20/1999 1SJ 3-SJ-2121-2 Pipe to Valve C-F-i C5.21 UT 56.50%
0 IWC-2500-7 configuration.
Indications Configuration due to the valve configuration.
No Exam limited due to the valves Physical Restriction-Exam limited 385040 2/2/3 08/15/1997 SJ 3-SJ-2121-3RI Valve to Valve C-F-i C5.21 UT 0%
IWC-2500-7 configuration.
Other Configuration due to the valves configuration.
No Exam limited due to the valves Physical Restriction-Exam limited 385060 2/2/3 10/22/1997 SJ 3-SJ-2121-4RI Valve to Valve C-F-i C5.21 UT 0%
IWC-2500-7 configuration.
Other Configuration due to the valves configuration.
No Physical Restriction-No UT No UT performed from Upstream performed from Upstream side due to side due to welded collar, No UT welded collar. No UT performed performed from downstream side due from downstream side due to pipe to pipe taper. Exams unable to be taper. Exams unable to be performed performed since the weld is since the weld is inaccessible due to inaccessible due to structural design.
stnrctoral design. I-Beams are too I-Beams are too close to the exam close to the exam area to allow Yes 222400 2/2/3 11/03/1995 MS 34-MS-2131-1 Pipe to Pipe C-F-2 C5.51 MT 0%
IWC-2500-7 area to allow examination.
Other Inaccessibility.examination.
MEB 3-I Physical Restriction-No UT No UT performed from Upstream performed from Upstream side due to side due to welded collar. No UT welded collar. No UT performed performed from downstream side due from downstream side due to pipe to pipe taper. Exams unable to be taper. Exams unable to be performed performed since the weld is since the weld is inaccessible due to inaccessible due to structural design.
structural design. I-Beams are too I-Beams are too close to the exam No Recordable close to the exam area to allow Yes 222400 2/2/3 11/03/1995 MS 34-MS-2131-1 Pipe to Pipe C-F-2 C5.51 UT 0%
IWC-2500-7 area to allow examination, indications Inaccessibility examination.
MEB 3-1 12/2012001 SI-RR-COI 11
Document Control Desk LRN-01-0433 Attachment II Relief Request: S1-RR-COI Salem Unit I-2nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations SI-RR-C01 Exam Examination Summary tntervalPeriotd/
Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Code Required Exam Results for Restriction Additional Restriction Detail &
Augmented No.
outae* No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Area Inspected Type Type Exam Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to permanently limited due to permanently installed installed structural elements and No Recordable structural elements and insulation Yes 224100 2/2/3 11/07/1995 MS 34-MS-2131-2 Pipe to Valve C-F-2 C5.51 MT 70%
IWC-2500-7 insulation sheathing.
Indications Configuration sheathing.
MEB 3-1 Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to permanently limited due to permanently installed installed structural elements and No Recordable structural elements and insulation Yes 224100 2/2/3 11/07/1995 MS 34-MS-2131-2 Pipe to Valve C-F-2 C5.51 UT 19%
IWC-2500-7 insulation sheathing.
Indications Configuration sheathing.
MEB 3-1 Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to permanently No Recordable limited due to permanently installed Yes 224200 2/2/3 11/03/1995 MS 34-MS-2121-1 Pipe to Pipe C-F-2 C5.51 MT 18%
IWC-2500-7 installed structural elements.
Indications Configuration structural elements.
MEB 3-1 Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to permanently limited due to permanently installed Yes 224200 2/2/3 11/03/1995 MS 34-MS-2121-1 Pipe to Pipe C-F-2 C5.51 UT 0%
IWC-2500-7 installed structural elements.
Other Configuration structural elements.
MEB 3-1 Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to permanently No Recordable limited due to permanently installed Yes 225800 2/2/3 11/02/1995 MS 34-MS-21 11-1 Pipe to Pipe C-F-2 C5.51 MT 50%
IWC-2500-7 installed pipe whip restraint, indications Configuration pipe whip restraint MEB 3-1 Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to permanently limited due to permanently installed Yes 225800 2/2/3 11/02/1995 MS 34-MS-2111-1 Pipe to Pipe C-F-2 C5.51 UT 0%
IWC-2500-7 installed pipe whip restraint.
Other Configuration pipe whip restraint MEB 3-1 Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to permanently No Recordable limited due to permanently installed Yes 227500 2/2/3 11/04/1995 MS 34-MS-2111-2 Pipe to Valve C-F-2 C5.51 MT 70%
IWC-2500-7 installed pipe whip restraint.
Indications Configuration structural elements.
MEB 3-1 Physical Restriction-Examination Exam limited due to permanently No Recordable limited due to permanently installed Yes 227500 2/2/3 11/04/1995 MS 34-MS-21 11-2 Pipe to Valve C-F-2 C5.51 UT 70%/o IWC-2500-7 installed pipe whip restraint.
Indications Configuration structural elements.
MEB 3-1 Physical Restriction-Examination limited to one side only with no examination performed between 68"
- 85" due to structural interferences Exam limited due to permanently No Recordable associated with I-Beams and piping Yes 230500 2/2/3 11/07/1995 MS 32-MS-2121-3 Pipe to Elbow C-F-2 C5.51 MT 87%
IWC-2500-7 installed structural elements.
Indications Configuration in the area.
MEB 3-1 12120/2001 12
Attachment II Relief Request: S1-RR-C01 Salem Unit 1-2nd Inservice Inspection Ten-Year NDE Exam Limitations Exam Examination Exam Results Summary Interval/eriod Component Geometric ASME Item Method Completed Code Required for Area Restriction Additional Restriction Detail & Augmented No.
Outage No.
Exam Date System Identification Configuration Category No.
Limited Amount Volume Comments Inspected Type Type Exam Physical Restriction-Examination limited to one side only with no examination performed between 68" - 85" due to structural Exam limited due to permanently No Recordable interferences associated with I-Yes 230500 2/2/3 11/07/1995 MS 32-MS-2121-3 Pipe to Elbow C-F-2 C5.51 UT 83%
IWC-2500-7 installed structural elements.
Indications Configuration Beams and piping in the area.
MEB 3-1 Physical Restriction-Examination limited to one side only with no examination performed between 71"-90" due to structuiral Exam limited due to permanently No Recordable interferences associated with I-Yes 230600 2/2/3 11/07/1995 MS 32-MS-2121-4 Elbow to Pipe C-F-2 C5.51 MT 48%
IWC-2500-7 installed structural elements.
Indications Configuration Beams and piping in the area.
MEB 3-1 Physical Restriction-Exam limited to one side only with no examination performed between 71"-90" due to structural Exam limited due to permanently No Recordable interferences associated with I-Yes 230600 2/2/3 11/07/1995 MS 32-MS-2121-4 Elbow to Pipe C-F-2 C5.51 UT 81%
IWC-2500-7 installed structural elements.
Indications Configuration Beams and piping in the area.
MEB 3-1 Physical Restriction. Examination limited due to restraints on pipe and elbow at the intrados of the elbow, both restraints are close to Exam limited due to permanently No Recordable one another thus precluding exam Yes 231800 2/2/3 0/31/1995 MS 32-MS-2111-4 Elbow to Pipe C-F-2 C5.51 UT 61.20%
IWC-25007 installed pipe whip restraint Indications Configuration access.
MEB 3-1 SI-RR-COI 13 1212012001