ML19340D002
| ML19340D002 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | McGuire  |
| Issue date: | 11/21/1980 |
| From: | Beverly Clayton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Ziemann D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8012180501 | |
| Download: ML19340D002 (7) | |
Text
b f.' i ! _.
- j p* * *r q
[(* ~c,, h UNITED STATES j
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION s
svASWNGTON. O. C. 20555 l
Novemcer 21, 1980
.....f Occket No. 50-369
=
MEvCRANDUM FOR: Dennis L. Ziemann, Chief Precedures and Test Review Branch Division of Human Factors Safety Con H. Beckham, Section Leader [
THRU:
Section A Procedures and Test Review Branch Division of Human Factors Safety FROM:
Brent Clayton Precedures and Test Review Branch Division of Human Factors Safety
SUBJECT:
TRIP REPORT MCGUIRE UNIT NO.1 - E.MERGENCY PROCEDURE REVIEW NOVEMBER 11-12, 1980 On November 11 and 12,1980, the McGuire emergency precedure review team (see Enclosure 1 for memcers) visited the McGuire site to conduct simulator and control room walk-throughs of the emergency pr0cedures.
We first met..ith memcers of the applicant's operations staff, training staff, and licensing staff to discuss our coments from the desk review of the plant's emergency procedures. Enclosure 2 provides the list of attendees.
Folicwing this meeting and a brief tour of the site's training facility, the review team observed ocerators from the plant perforn various casualties on the simulator. Specific cements on each of the precedures were provided by the review team members and the operators as they went through the A problem of particular interest noted by the operators and the precedure.
review team was the lack of clear distincticn of when to use the abnormal operating procedures and when to use the emergency coerating procedures for a given casualty condition. This orablem was observed during a steam generator tube rupture condition and w ring a loss of feedwater condition.
Another problem identified was that inadequate guidance was available in the Inadequate Core Cooling procedure. If it becomes necessary to open the PCRV and if auxiliary feedwater is subsequently restored, the peccedure did not tell the operator wnat actions to take.
8012180$0 \\
g
Cennis L. Ziemann Novemcer 21, 1980 After observing all the procedures performed on the simulator, the team observed a walk-througn of a loss of coolant accident in the plant's control room. Again, scecific ccmments were generated by the operators and tne review team memcers.
An exit meeting was conducted with tne plant mank,er and other Duke
- ersonnel (see Enclosure 3 for attendees). The comments generated during the on-site review, including the problems addressed above, were discussed.
The applicant stated that they would revise the emergency procedures to address all of the comments and to submit copies of the.evised procedures to us in abcut two weeks. We informed them that if we receive the revised precedures in two weeks and if the revision resolves all our comments, then we could write our SER input to support their scheduled full power license date.
It shculd also be noted that the applicant's personnel with wncm we worked were very cooperative and aided us greatly in doing our job.
/
/
h: w ' [. i : -- -
Brent Clayton '
Procedures and Test Review 3 ranch Division of Human Factors Safety
Enclosures:
1.
Review Team Memoers 2.
pre-Walk-Through Meeting Attendees 3.
Exit Meeting Attendees cc w/ enclosures:
See next page
N i
Mr. William C. Darker, Jr.
Vice Presicent, Steam Precucticn Ouke ocwer Ccm::any P. 0. Box 2173 1
422 Scuth Church Street Charlotte, North Carolina 28242 cc:
Mr. W. L. 3crter Dr. Cace: H. Hanc, Jr.. Director Duke Pcwer Com::any Sodega Marine Lab of Califcenia P. C. Scx 2173 P. O. Sox 227 422 Scuth Churen Street Bedega 3ay, California 34923 Charlette, North Carclina 2S242
~
Richard P. Wilson, Esc.
Mr. R. S. Hcward Assistant Attorney General
?cwer Systems Division State of Scuth Carolina Westingncuse Electric Cor;:cratici 2500 Bull Street P. O. Box 355 Columcia. Scutn Carolina 29201 Pittsburgn, Pennsylvania 15230 Office of Intergovernmental Relations Mr. E. J. Xeith 116 West Jones Street EDS Nuclear Incor acr ated Raleigh, Nortn Carolina 27603 220 Montscmery Street San Francisco, California 94104 County Manager of Mecklenburg County 720 East Fourtn Street Mr. J. E. Houghtaling Charlotte, Nor n Carolina 23202 N'js Corpcr ation 2526 Countryside Sculevard
!!. S. Environmental Protection Agency Clearwater, Florica 33515 ATTN: EIS Coordinator Region IV Office Mr. Jesse L. Riley, Presicent 345 Courtland Street, N. W.
The Carolina Environmental Study Group Atlanta, Georgia 30308 854 Henley Place Charlotte, Ncrth Carolina 23207 Mr. Tom Ccnat Resident Ins:ector McGuire NPS J. Michar.1 !!cGarry, III, Esc.
c/c USNRC Debevoise ?. Liberman Post Office Box 215 1200 Sevtateenth Street, N. W.
Cornelius, Nortn Carolina 2S031 Wasningten, D. C.
20036 Roter: M. Lazo, Esq., Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Scard U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission Washington, D. C.
20555 Or. Emmeth A. Luebke Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U. S. Nuclear R_gulatory Cccraission
.Wasnington, D. C.
20555 i
. a
-w=.,
4 em
. 9 ym
,,,e
- - - +,
e--
+-
--wp
,9e g., -
--g w p,yy
.g
-9y
--#p,g-g.i.*y 9y.--
~g 6-y--mw.,
y,r-p-w g-
,pr m
..r,e*
y*w*=s'*y ar-
ENCLOSURE 1 i
MCGU1AE EMERGENCY PROCEDURE RE'/IE'd TEAM MEMBERS NRC i
- 3. Clayton, CHFS/P1TRB J. Clifford, CHFS/PSTRS M. Goodman, DHFS/P&TRS Battelle
'd. Apley - Pa:ific Northwest Laboratories R. Shikiar - Cattelle - Seattle, '4ashington L. Myers - Battelle - Columbus, Ohio XYZYX Information Corocration J. Engelschall G. Slack 1
7 i
L L
ENCLOSURE 2 PRE-WAL.<-THROUGH MEETING ATTENDEES Duke J. Painter G. Gilbert D. Cleckner L. Reed R. Darke S. Frye NRC T. Ocna McGuire E.T.ergency Procedure Review Team (See Enclosure i for members) i 1
ENCLOSURE 3 EX:7 MEETING AT ENCEES Ouke G. Coco M. McIntosh W. Sample D. Lampke G. Gilbert G. Cage J. Painter NRC T. Ocnat McGuire Emergency Precedure Review Team (See Enclosure i for T.emoers)
I l
l l
i l
.--