ML22019A083

IP 45052 Review of Geotechnical and Site Characterization Activities

ML22019A083
Person / Time
Issue date:	04/05/2022
From:	Laura Smith NRC/NRR/DRO/IQVB
To:
Smith L
Shared Package
ML22083A239	List: Inspection Manual Change Notice 22-006, Table of Contents for Inspection Manual Change Notice 22-006 ML22007A055 ML22007A056 ML22019A083
References
CN 22-006
Download: ML22019A083 (7)

Text

NRC INSPECTION MANUAL IQVB INSPECTION PROCEDURE 45052 REVIEW OF GEOTECHNICAL AND SITE CHARACTERIZATION ACTIVITIES Effective Date: 04/05/22 PROGRAM APPLICABILITY: IMC 2501, IMC 2502 45052-01 INSPECTION OBJECTIVE To verify that the applicant's proposed quality assurance (QA) program, as applicable to early site permit (ESP) or combined license (COL) geotechnical activities, is being implemented in accordance with the requirements of Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50.

45052-02 INSPECTION REQUIREMENTS 02.01 For each onsite organization with QA responsibilities for geotechnical activities, review QA programs, work instructions, and/or technical specifications, and observe geotechnical field activities to determine that the QA elements conform to the criteria in Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50.

02.02 Verify that procedures, instructions, and drawings prescribing site exploration, inspection and testing activities are developed and implemented, and include appropriate quantitative and qualitative acceptance criteria, as applicable, for the areas below:

a. Test control (e.g., surveying, subsurface exploration, standard penetration and cone penetration testing, bearing and downhole/crosshole testing, soil testing, and others as appropriate).

b. Measuring and test equipment.

c. Handling, storage, and shipping of soil samples obtained from borings or excavations.

d. Applicant/contractor oversight (e.g., audits, surveillance).

02.03 Verify that records of geotechnical activities are approved by the proper authority, appropriately stored, and maintained in accordance with QA Program requirements.

02.04 Verify that personnel associated with geotechnical activities are qualified to perform their assigned work.

02.05 Observe work in progress and verify that work is performed in accordance with the appropriate procedures. Section 45051-05, References, lists the typical ASTM and other Standard geotechnical field tests commonly performed during site investigations.

The inspector should observe in-process testing activities for conformance to the Issue Date: 04/05/22 1 45052

standards. The listing of standards is not all-inclusive, and the inspector should be alert to the use of other or newly emerging standards, if applicable.

45052-03 INSPECTION GUIDANCE General Guidance. This inspection provides an assessment of the effectiveness of QA requirements implemented at an early stage in the application development process. Early involvement of NRC staff will facilitate and support prompt identification and resolution of issues, and timely completion of the acceptance review process following submission of the application.

The team will review a suitable sample of in-process documents related to ESP or COL site characterization activities to verify consistency with standard industry practices for the successful completion of the activities. Observation of these activities should determine if QA program requirements are being adequately implemented as required by the applicant and/or contractors procedures. If the observation of activities or the review of specifications or implementing procedures identifies significant inadequacies that may indicate weaknesses in the implementation of QA program requirements by the responsible organization, the inspector will inform appropriate NRC management. The issue should be addressed at the appropriate level of the potential applicants management prior to the submittal of the application and the corrective action should be included in the application or in a separate submittal to the NRC.

03.01 QA Program.

Verify that a QA program has been established and implemented (including plans, procedures, and instructions), and addresses safety-related work related to activities in support of the ESP or COL application. Specifically, verify the following attributes of the QA program:

a. Verify that the applicant retains the overall responsibility for the establishment and implementation of all QA requirements, including those aspects of the program delegated to contractors and consultants.

b. Verify that activities affecting quality, such as, preparation of analyses, calculations, design drawings, specifications and procurement documents, related verification reviews, and control of documents and document changes are accomplished in accordance with established instructions, procedures, and drawings.

c. Verify that management of the organizations implementing the QA program, or portions thereof, regularly assess the adequacy of that part of the program for which they are responsible to assure its effective implementation.

03.02 Procedure Review.

Verify the implementation of work and quality instructions, procedures, and drawings related to surveying, subsurface exploration, standard penetration tests, cone penetrometer tests, bearing tests, soil testing, and others (as appropriate) for the areas detailed below.

a. Test Control. Select a sample of completed tests and determine if controls for testing have been adequately implemented by performing the following:

Issue Date: 04/05/22 2 45052

1. Verify that a test program is established to ensure that all testing required for site characterization is identified.

2. Verify that test procedures:

(a) Incorporate or reference the requirements and acceptance limits contained in the applicable design or regulatory documents.

(b) Include provisions for ensuring that all prerequisites for the given test have been met.

(c) Ensure that adequate test instrumentation is available and used.

(d) Ensure that testing is performed under suitable environmental conditions.

3. Field testing and laboratory procedures must provide for verification of correct material usage and correct selection of reference standards and should prohibit discretionary selection of inspection and testing parameters.

4. Verify that the test program provides for documentation and evaluation of test results to ensure that test requirements have been satisfied. Results of testing should be reviewed by qualified personnel and a determination of acceptability of the results made.

5. Conduct field observations to determine if work is being performed using the proper revision of the respective procedure(s) for the test activity witnessed.

b. Measuring and Test Equipment (M&TE). Select a sample of M&TE equipment documents (e.g., records, logs) and determine if controls for calibration have been adequately implemented by performing the following:

1. Verify that procedures establish measures to ensure that tools, gages, instruments, and other measuring and testing equipment used in site characterization activities are of the proper range, type, and accuracy.

2. Verify that procedures provide for inspection, calibration, adjustment, and maintenance of measuring and test equipment at prescribed intervals, using national standards as a basis for calibration. When such standards are not available, verify that the basis for calibration or method used is documented.

3. Verify that procedures require that inaccurate M&TE is identified and removed from service or otherwise segregated from inadvertent use and provide for verification of the validity of previous tests and inspections.

4. Verify that calibration results are documented and traceable to M&TE.

5. Verify that M&TE is uniquely identified and displays the status of calibration or is otherwise traceable to calibration records.

6. Conduct field observations to determine if work is being performed using the proper revision of the respective procedure(s) for the calibration activity witnessed.

Issue Date: 04/05/22 3 45052

c. Handling, Storage, and Shipping. Select a sample of documents (e.g., procedures, inventory logs) and determine if controls for handling and storage of soil samples obtained from borings or excavations have been adequately implemented by performing the following:

1. Verify that instructions have been established for marking and labeling, packaging, handling, and storage of items to adequately identify, maintain, and preserve the item, including indication of special environments or the need for special controls. Also verify that sample identification is maintained either on the sample or on records traceable to the sample throughout use.

2. Verify that special protective measures (e.g., containers, special moisture content levels, and temperature levels) have been specified and provided to maintain acceptable quality.

3. Conduct field observations to verify that handling, storage, and shipping activities are being performed in accordance with prescribed procedures.

d. Applicant/Contractor Oversight. Select a sample of audit/surveillance procurement reports and assess the adequacy of oversight activities by performing the following:

1. Verify that the applicant implements planned and periodic audits to confirm that activities affecting quality comply with the QA program and that the QA program has been effectively implemented.

2. Verify that procedures and responsibilities have been established for auditing, documenting, and reviewing audit results.

3. Verify that audit/surveillance results are reported to and reviewed by responsible management. Verify if follow-up action of deficient areas is initiated when necessary.

03.03 Record Control.

Select a sample of QA records generated during the conduct of site characterization activities for review and assess QA records controls by performing the following:

a. Verify that procedures identify the designated person or organization responsible for records access, including receipt control, processing, corrections, and safekeeping.

b. Verify that the records sampled are complete, legible, adequate, retrievable, adequately protected, and traceable to markings, identification tags, or other means of identifying materials, components, and activities important to safety.

c. Verify that records are reviewed and approved by the responsible authority.

d. Verify that records are stored in a manner that prevents deterioration, environmental effects, damage, and loss.

03.04 Training and Qualification of Personnel.

Select a sample of training records and determine if controls have been adequately implemented by performing the following:

Issue Date: 04/05/22 4 45052

a. Verify that programs are implemented for the indoctrination and training of personnel performing activities affecting quality to ensure that suitable proficiency is achieved and maintained.

b. Verify that qualification records and certifications exist for inspection/test personnel, auditors, calibration, repair personnel, and similar specialists performing activities affecting quality. Verify that qualification records of personnel are certified in accordance with industry and/or vendors program requirements.

c. Conduct interviews with personnel associated with geotechnical activities to ensure they have an understanding of the activities they are performing commensurate with their responsibilities.

03.05 Corrective Action.

Select a sample of corrective action documents and determine if controls have been adequately implemented by performing the following:

a. Verify that measures exist to promptly identify and resolve non-conformances and conditions adverse to quality in a timely manner. In the case of significant conditions adverse to quality, verify the measures ensure that the cause of the condition is determined, and corrective action taken to prevent recurrence, and such measures are documented and reported to the appropriate management.

b. Review a sample of identified problems and verify that the applicant or contractor(s) adequately implemented these controls.

45052-04 RESOURCE ESTIMATE This inspection procedure is used for pre-docketing audits of ESP or COL applications. The resource estimate for this inspection procedure is about 50 hours5.787037e-4 days <br />0.0139 hours <br />8.267196e-5 weeks <br />1.9025e-5 months <br /> of direct inspection effort.

45052-05 PROCEDURE COMPLETION Sample size may vary significantly for each inspection. Inspection of samples discussed in section 45052-03 constitutes completion of this procedure.

45052-06 REFERENCES ASME NQA-1-2015, Quality Assurance Requirements for Nuclear Facility Applications.

ASME NQA-1-2015, Quality Assurance Requirements for Nuclear Facility Applications Subpart 2.2 Quality Assurance Requirements for Packaging, Shipping, Receiving, Storage, and Handling of Items for Nuclear Facilities.

Electric Power Research Institute, Report TR-102293, 1993; Guidelines for Determining Design Basis Ground Motions.

Regulatory Guide 1.132, Site Investigation for Foundations of Nuclear Power Plants, October 2003.

Issue Date: 04/05/22 5 45052

Regulatory Guide 1.138, Laboratory Investigation of Soils for Engineering Analysis and Design of Nuclear Power Plants, December 2014.

Regulatory Guide 1.198, Procedures and Criteria for Assessing Seismic Soil Liquefaction at Nuclear Power Plant Sites, November 2003.

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Engineering and Design Geotechnical Investigations, Engineer Manual 1110-1-1804.

American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM), Book of Standards, as follows:

ASTM D 5778-20, Standard Test for Electronic Friction Cone and Piezocone Penetration Testing of Soils.

ASTM D1452/D1452M-16, Standard Practice for Soil Exploration and Sampling by Auger Borings.

ASTM D1586/D1586M-18, Standard Test Method for Standard Penetration Test (SPT) and Split-Barrel Sampling of Soils.

ASTM D2113-14, Standard Practice for Rock Core Drilling and Sampling of Rock for Site Exploration.

ASTM D2487-17e1, Standard Practice for Classification of Soils for Engineering Purposes (Unified Soil Classification System).

ASTM D2488-17e1, Standard Practice for Description and Identification of Soils (Visual-Manual Procedure).

ASTM D420-18, Standard Guide for Site Characterization for Engineering Design and Construction Purposes.

ASTM D4220/D4220M-14, Practices for Preserving and Transporting Soil Samples.

ASTM D4428/4428M-14, Standard Test Methods for Crosshole Seismic Testing.

ASTM D4633-16, Standard Test Method for Energy Measurements for Dynamic Penetrometers.

ASTM D5753-18, Standard guide for Planning and Conducting Geotechnical Borehole Geophysical Logging.

ASTM G57-20, Standard Test Method for Measurement of Soil Resistivity Using the Wenner Four-Electrode Method.

ASTMD1587/D1587M-15, Standard Practice for Thin-Walled Tube Sampling of Fine-Grained Soils for Geotechnical Purposes.

END Issue Date: 04/05/22 6 45052

Attachment 1: Revision History for IP 45052 Commitment Tracking Accession Number Description of Change Description of Training Comment Resolution Number Issue Date Required and and Closed Feedback Change Notice Completion Date Form Accession Number (Pre-Decisional, Non-Public Information)

N/A 05/29/03 Initial issuance N/A N/A N/A ML072500062 1. Incorporation of new N/A ML072620473 10/03/07 requirements of 10 CFR Part CN 07-030 52 and SRP 17.5 guidance.

2. Incorporation of guidance provided by the Geosciences

& Geotechnical Engineering Branch.

3. Researched commitments for 4 years and found none.

N/A ML22019A083 1. Editorial revisions made to N/A ML 04/05/22 meet IMC 0040.

CN 22-006

2. Added section 45052-05, Procedure Completion.

3. Updated section 45052-06, References.

Issue Date: 04/05/22 Att1-1 45052