ML20135F545

NPDES Noncompliance Notification:On 970113,sample Obtained on Unit 1 Sewage Treatment Effluent Indicated Setteable Solids Value of 3.5 Ml/L Which Was Above Instantaneous Limit of 3.0 Ml/L.Caused by Operator Error.Terminated Operator

ML20135F545
Person / Time
Site:	San Onofre
Issue date:	03/07/1997
From:	Gibson G SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON CO.
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM)
References
NUDOCS 9703130039
Download: ML20135F545 (9)

Text

.

~ WS E. -,aa- u,on.

,k?,,,j E DI SON An LDISON INTERNATIONAL Comruny March 7, 1997 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attention: Document Control Desk Washington, D.C. 20555

Subject:

Docket No. 50-206 Report of NPDES Permit Violation San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station, Unit 1

Reference:

Letter from H. W. Newton (SCE) to John Robertus (California Regional Water Quality Control Board, San Diego Region), NPDES Discharge Monitoring Report, Unit 1, February 24, 1997 Section D 6.15.2.c of the Permanently Defueled Technical Specifications to Facility License No. DPR-13 for San Onofre Unit 1 requires violations of the NPDES Permit or State certification (pursuant to section 401 of the Clean Water Act),

to be reported to the NRC by submittal of copies of the reports required by the NPDES Permit or certification.

This letter provides a copy of the referenced letter which reported one (1) NPDES Permit violation during the month of January 1997, to the California Regional Water Quality Control Board, San Diego Region.

Please let me know if you require any additional information.

Sincerely, l

Gregory T. Gibson l Manager, Compliance l Enclosure cc: J. E. Dyer, Acting Regional Administrator, NRC Region IV K. E. Perkins, Jr., Director, Walnut Creek Field Office, f NRC Region IV L. C. Carson, NRC Project Manager, San Onofre Unit 1 J. A. Sloan, NRC Senior Resident Inspector, San'Onofre g/' f7/}

Units 2 & 3 0 7

s d 9703130039 970307 PDR ADOCK 05000206 S PDR P. O. Box 128 San Ckmente, CA 92674-0128 l  % gg g

50L1Hf R% C AlllORNR

" EDISON

• Ar IInw\ I\11R\ 1llo\ tl u nge.

February 24,1997 Mr. John Robertus California Regional Water Quality Control Board San Diego Region 9771 Clairemont Mesa Boulevard, Suite B San Diego, California' 92124-1331

SUBJECT:

NPDES Discharge Monitoring Report San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station, Unit 1

Dear Mr. Robertus:

The NPDES Discharge Monitoring Report (DMR) for San Onofre Unit I covering the month of '

l January is submitted in accordance with the requirements of Order No. 95-02 (NPDES Permit No. CA0001228). A summary of the generating unit's status and significant analytical results is I

provided below.

The unit was permanently removed from service in November 1992. All sampled water sources .

were found to be within permit limits with one exception. l On 1/13/97 at 0900 a sample obtained on the Unit 1 Sewage Treatment Elliuent indicated a settleable solids value of 3.5 ml/1. This was above the instantaneous limit of 3.0 ml/1. The settleable solids condition at the plant returned to limits later that day. The cause of the event was determined to be operator error that resulted in an overaeration event that led to the settleable ,

solids exceedance. It was also determined that there was not enough flocculant addition to the l clarifier which resulted in solids floating to the surface of the plant. Corrective actions included the termination of the plant operator and a return to the sewage treatment plant to it's normal mode of operation.

Pursuant to Order No. 95-02, Reporting Requirement 14, the following representative has l prepared and is authorized to sign the reports required by this order: Robert K. Heckler, i Environmental Engineer.

4 I certify under penalty oflaw that this document and all attachments were prepared under my direction or supervision in accordance with a system designed to assure that qualified personnel properly gather and evaluate the information submitted. Based on my inquiry of the person or persons who manage the system, or those persons directly responsible for gathering the information, the information submitted is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true, accurate._ l P.O. N\128 San Clemente. CA 42tC4-012o I

Mr. Robertus Page 2 Febmary 24,1997 and complete. I am aware that there are significant penalties for submitting false information, including the possibility of fine and imprisonment for knowing violations.

Sincerely, H. W. Newton Manager, Site Support Services Enclosure cc: Environmental Protection Agency, Region IX l

1 I

1

Southnrn C llfornia Edison Monthly Raport Pags 1 of 6

" Facility : Sengs Unit 1 Exact Samplo Point : Intake and i Order No : 95-02 Discharge Conduits

Report Freq

Monthly Collected By : Songs Envir Grp Report For : January 1997 Analyzed By : So s E vir Grp Report Due: Feb 28,1997 Signed :

Waste Stream : a r i" "

Title : Environmen al ngineer '

{9 ne Discharge PARAMETER: Temperature Difference (degrees Fahrenheit) = Temperature at Saltwater Cooling Outlet Minus Temperature at Saltwater Cooling Inlet Date and Time Saltwater Cooling Saltwater Cooling Calculated Outlet 'F Inlet *F AT 1/14/97 8:00 am 60.0 58.0 2.0 1/14/9710:00 am 60.0 58.0 2.0 1114/9712:00 pm 60.0 58.0 2.0 1/14/97 2:00 pm 60.0 58.0 2.0 1/14/97 4:00 pm 60.0 58.0 2.0 Avg 60.0 58.0 2.0 Max 60.0 58.0 2.0 Regt .. ..

5

l. ,

. South rn California Edicon Monthly Raport Pags 2 of 6 Facility : Songs Unit 1 Exact Sample Point : Points of 95-02 Discharge Order No :

Report Freq : Monthly Collected By : Songs Envir Grp

)

Report For

January 1997 Analysed By : Songs Envir Grp Report Due : Feb 28,1997 Waste Stream : Combined Discharge Slgned :

j

\

q ;

. Low Volume Waste Title : Environmental Engineer i and Sewage j Parameter : Flow Rate Units : Million Gallons per Day (MGD) 1.

Combined Cire Water Total Low Total Sewage

. Date Discharge intake Volume Waste Treatment 1 5.061 5.040 0.010 0.011 l 2 5.103 5.040 0.010 0.053 3 5.088 5.040 0.010 0.038 l 4 5.072 5.040 0.010 0.022 5 5.069 5.040 0.010 0.019 6 5.087 5.040 0.010 0.037 7 5.088 5.040 0.010 0.038 j 8 5.082 5.040 0.010 0.032 j 9 5.087 5.040 0.010 0.037 4 10 5.085 5.040 0.010 0.035 11 5.068 5.040 0.010 0.018

[ 12 5.072 5.040 0.010 0.022 13 5.091 5.040 0.010 0.041 14 5.085 5.040 0.010 0.035

15 5.099 5.040 0.010 0.049 16 5.083 5.040 0.010 0.033 17 5.081 5.040 0.010 0.031

18 5.071 5.040 0.010 0.021

19 5.061 5.040 0.010 0.011 20 5.082 5.040 0.010 0.032 21 5.087 5.040 0.010 0.037 j 22 5.088 5.040 0.010 0.038 23 5.083 5.040 0.010 0.033 24 5.075 5.040 0.010 0.025

25 5.075 5.040 0.010 0.025 26 5.075 5.040 0.010 0.025 27 5.081 5.040 0.010 0.031

! 28 5.086 5.040 0.010 0.036

29 5.091 5.040 0.010 0.041 30 5.082 5.040 0.010 0.032

(

31 5.070 5.040 0.010 0.020 Avg 5.081 5.040 0.010 0.031 Regt l 13.76 0.510 0.160

. South rn California Edicon Monthly Raport Page 3 of 6 Facility : Songs Unit 1 Exact Sample Point : Point of

. Order No : 95 02 Discharge Report Freq : Monthly Collected By : Songs Envir Grp Report For : January 1997 Analyzed By : Songs E Feb 28,1997 a 'r Grq

, Report Due : Signed : ..

/

Waste Stream : Combined Discharge Title : Environmental Engineer i Date &

Parameter Sample Req't Req't Result Units Time Type Type Value Value Collected Mo" hly Turbidity NTU GRAB Avg 75 2.7 1/07/97 01:25 pm lY NTU GRAB [yg 100 2.7 1/07/97 01:25 pm NTU GRAB 225 2.7 1107/97 01:25 pm Sf pH -- GRAB -- 6-9 8.0 1/07/97 01:25 pm ug/l " "*

• lbs/ day GRA"a Median

• 0.8 Res d al GRAB

, Ibs/ day Mx a Chlorine ug/l '"*'

• lbs/ day GRAB Max

• 23 4

e i

t No CHLoRINATloN WAS PERFORMED IN JANUARY 1997

' South:rn Cclifornia Edicon Monthly Rsport Pago 4 of 6 Fa'cIlity : Sengs Unit 1 Exact Gample Point : Point of Order No : 95-02 Discharge

Report Freq : Monthly Collected By : Songs Envir Grp i Report For : January 1997 Analyzed By : pvir p Report Due : Feb 28,1997

^

Waste Stream : Plant Drains Signed : (Jong;s d

Title : Environmental Engineer 1

(Low Volume Waste)

Sample Date &

! Parameter Units Req't Req't Result Type Time 4

Type Value Value Collected t

mg/l Monthly 30 9.6 117/9 7 j lbs/ day . GRAB i Avg 130 0.80 09:52 am Total mg/l 1/7/97 Daily 100 9.6 Suspen d Ibs/ day GRAB Max 430 0.8 09:52 am mg/ Inst 100 9.6 1/7/97 lbs/ day GRAB Max 430 0.8 09:52 am mg/l Monthly 15 2.7 1/7/97

{ Ibs/ day GRAB Avg 64 0.23 09:52 am Grease and mg/l 20 2'7 1I7/97 GRAB *"Y Oil lbstday Avg 85 0.2 09:52 am 4

mg/l Inst 20 2.7 1/7/97 j Ibs/ day GRAB Max 85 0.2 09:52 am

)

i i

e

(

1 1

4 4

h 4

.' South rn California Edison Monthly Raport Pags 5 of 6 Facility : Songs Unit 1 Exact Sample Point : Point of

. Order No : 95-02 Discharge Report Freq : Monthly Collected By : Songs Envir Grp Report For : January 1997 Analyzed By : S ngs r Gr Report Due : Feb 28,1997 Signed : #

Waste Stream : Rad Waste System Title : Enviror ental ngineer (Low Volume Waste)

Sample Req't Date &

Parameter Units Req't Result Type Time Type Value Value Collected mg/l Monthly 30 lbs/ day GRAB Avg *

• 130 Total mg/l Deity 100 Suspended Ibs/ day GRAB Max Solids 430 *

• mg/ Inst 100 lbs/ day GRAB Max

• 430

• mg/l Monthly 15 lbs/ day GRAB Avg g . .

Grease and mg/l DaHy M Oil Ibs/ day GRAB Avg

• 85

• mg/l '"

lbs/ day GRAB Max 85 * *

• NO FLOW IN JANUARY 1997

Southern California Edison Monthly Report

., , Page 6 of 6 Facility : Sengs Unit 1 Exact Sample Point : Point of Order No : 95-02 Discharge Report Freq : Monthly Collected By : Songs Envir Grp 2

Report For : January 1997 Analyzed By : So s c e pistry Report Due : Feb 28,1997 Waste Stream : Sewage Treatment Signed :

Title :

$g '

. nvironmental IEngineer (

Daily Max Monthly Ava Sample Date/ Time Sample Req't Sample Req j Units Type of Sample Value Value Value Value i Sewane -- Unit I

$ Inf mg/l 11:40 821.0 -

791.0 -

T.S.S lbs/ day GRAB 119/97 362.9 -

204.5 -

! EFF mg/l 09:25 < 2.2 75 < 2.2 25 G&O lbs/ day GRAB jgjg7 EFF mg/ 11:45 7.8 205.3 '

7.3 197.8 T.S.S lbs/ day GRAB 1/9/97 3.4 90.7 1.9 51.1 ml/l GRAB 3.5 3.0 0.3 1.0 S s jg7 I

09:00 4

pH Units GRAB 7.7 6.0 - 9.0 7.5 6.0-9.0

1/10/97 I

09:25 Turbidity NTU GRAB 7.6 225 7.6 75 1/22197 i Sewaae - - Mesa inf mg/l -- --

T.S.S lbs/ day GRAB , ,

J EFF mg/l 75 25 G&O lbs/ day GRAB *

• 63 21 EFF mg/l T.S.S lbs/ day GRAB , ,

Sett.

Solids ml/l GRAB

• 3.0

• 1.0 pH Units GRAB

• 6.0 - 9.0

• 6.0 - 9.0 j Turbidity NTU GRAB

• 225

• 75 4

• Mesa Sewage Treated at Unit 1 Sewage Treatment Plant 4