ML20217D957

Provides List of Questions & Comments Re Gnm & Assoc That Came During Review of Proposed Cost of OWFN Marble Insp & Rept

ML20217D957
Person / Time
Issue date:	08/20/1998
From:	James Heck NRC
To:	Cunningham E NRC
Shared Package
ML20217D954	List: IA-99-314, Provides List of Questions & Comments Re Gnm & Assoc That Came During Review of Proposed Cost of OWFN Marble Insp & Rept ML20217D947 ML20217D957
References
FOIA-99-314 NUDOCS 9910180190
Download: ML20217D957 (19)

Text

'

k'@ K4 fctw4 4

Ip ftwEcuw, '% 80.&sso s ors v ef W.s Ocv FiJ Yt<%Stl PMMS /us/Sh' c ffder / /Grz e Gzunm.y Aty sus . d

&l'skt ue tif+ 7?w i .

Cskkt+9 s W 6DMg As 9oc

, he g .

I }fedtz7 Hwr%u p-ivie. is he tu4s ( p / Vir //fa/c)

~

S' $$ $' hje 67t?.r.c707%c $$4146gc, , y p ,, y p S -l' % q m"iws. se py;;,ws ,gg ws,99gya u, N T$$ f h S /08'O g<5-[~ fri Gvpius Ws

+ - 1M "CousTveur * 'essr }~),02c} is Too pmd Y'I Nt?5$pi ~161" Ib De a yc, 7t{t u!Afct?wd R W,yff 7 /5 2 M V 85 for- P. H . , w A.f<eia7 $ S. /kei+> 'w-7 Pofu?

hhh NWO'M ' W fffA*j%c7Wst.: ~ [/5'7 /sd {p$

[FH745cd I" Ba'.

kaa .,2~ * / cenwseW z - Ja 5- yggf A'e'jy2~Sproc <z m,wnt(

p.,p pp- g_/S,97s y g .7 psa

. ' [dvSuu 7& '16 "

y ,

" (-1? %Vt7A/1" ($61. f f, (p9 $] / 5  % (($tt .

5- O %su yu1 ~ wai5, re. Triecr ? (f%k) b' LUIM7 i5 &9 f/ cuts ~ Ps4 P bfi Sn<>. Abb-M7 p

^

J R. . )%1cth'Tk-f fct '

2- tWH) p94pc(hwe or= t'AEffeAcesV@s7* off'7f}

B- %4 19 ' DftpT5fazsv /surs 6s 154 Gees des) 9910100190 991000 '

' :T}

f l PDR FOIA

-Q  ;

l SCITZ99-314 PDR

". / .

08/'i9 '9F 7:08 NO.997 02 l

1 INSPECTION OF THE EXTEltlOR MARBLE / GRANITE at Nuclear Regulatory Commission, OWFN ,

August 20.1998 Breakdowpd of Cons 9 tant's Fce 1

1.PHASEI Pre-p cview of cxisting pertinent documents: Original construction documents and [y,24 g at'sJI&# the Government provided rel ris relative to the marbic/gramte veneer stablization and dw ,,

g repair reciuirementsg )$# gzW- q% WC 1 %QA k't ~$pg 1 , C /b N fig Project director:j S rs x S154 00 [ni as 1,237teg g y / p e f. Q N 4 g Setuor architect 4 rs x $129.09 = 1.032 72 C'

,g, g Juniogar ig $s x 5 71.26 = 570 08 ('7) 57c.7 ,7g 7 y g l Sub-tot al --------- ---- S 2,834.80 #

• '" WrD$o' l

fv(

• B.f f[

Inspect marble / granite facade with a total of seven (7) swing-stage drops and document the nature and extent of any marble / granite panel and/or sealant distress / failure -

! g observed during the mcpecticm 3 v, 2 cf t>

FA pu2, luT* Senior archteN4QC@rs x S129 =S 0915.490.80 l Junior architect fl20 hrs x $ 7126 - 8,551 20 Sif 7#

Junior engineer - R,355 60  % ,voe I 120 hrs x S 69 63 l Reimbersable expenses (mileage /filnfetc) = > 750 00 .M

1. Contractor to set up & operate 7 drops of stage - 25.000 00 4 EM n, d'D , ft S u b t o t al --- ------ ---- 558,147.60 #~

.' LW - ( R efy ' f fue

(,010 7 -

2. PHASE H N/N 5 t ,q vi -

hp/Li 3 s

g Ivig M .0 hg and performance of theJulkj marbic/ granite faca

@ H W ,Yg p AdN*

service

,c. M 2 40 V i .

sk - $ "~h

) p g,, roject lirector Grr, x $154 00 -5 1.232.00-

j V w Senior orchitect & rs x $129.09 - 5,163 60 ( ~

W#

g 4 g h. WQl/AA gf Junior architect gt:7 Junior engineer t rs x S 7126 - m 5,700 08 irs x $ 69 63 - 1.f371.12 #

1. " I f/t/

Reimbersable expenses (mileage / film, cic ) .500 00 - D d '

Y8 ~

Sub total---- ---------- $14,266.80 %fh 4d I

'E58 .................................... s si u.I i

' '/,@7 l' i spc, <

b//- (qq gl 9

.f ,

1AN W NW n. t$$~ 'vMW

.-f 08/19 '96 */:08 NO.99/ 02 JG b INSFECTION OF THE EXTERIOR MARBLE / GRANITE  !

at Nuclear Regulatory Commission. OWFN ,

August 20,1998 Breakdowpd of Consultant's Fce

1. PHASE I A. Review of existing pertinent documents: Original construction documents and the Government provided reports relative to the marble / granite veneer stablization and

. repair requirements Project director: rs x $154 00 -5 1.232 00 Senior architect phrs x $129.04 = LO32.72 junior architect -

570 08 g / hrs x 5 7126 S u b-t o t al -------------- - S 2,834.80 l

B inspect marble / granite facade mth a total of seven (7) swing-stage drops and document the nature and .- ,

of any marbic/ granite panel and/or sealant distress / failure observed during .L. ncpection 0h < <

g b 'd NSenearchteett-- r20hrsw $129 09 =S15.490 80 l Junior architect kl20 hrs x $ 712ti - 8.551 20 l Junior engineer 'b20 hrs x 5 69 63 -

R.M560  !-

-MMr h R /

7 eimbersable e.rpene (mileage /tilnt etc)

/ Contractor to set up & operate 7 drops of stage - 25.000 O&

=

/0< g [/

S u b-t otal- - -- - -- - ---- 558.147,.60

&AAss

2. PHASE II JM J 2

Os Prepare a draft report summarizing the results of sursey related to the esiso nI and perfonnance of the marbic/ granite facade pancis and status of repair anchors in ser ice h'h Project director A 8hrtxk 00 S154 00 -$ 1.232.00 i Senior architect $ 40 ... .s S129 09 - 5,163 60 Junior architect Nefthrs s S 7l 26 = 5.700 08 Junim -gi .cci %M b *.P O -~

r.~u cr@

g Rumhrrsable expenscr(mileagcifiln+:-etc )~ ZZ30f70F

_, Sub total--- ------ $14.266.80 N eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee see s, 3 Q(h) Csb Q0%

i

4 I

e

'~r , $l a sa C 's :.0 n.,. . . . . _ , ,

~~ ...

'~~ - ~ . _ __

"} s hs, k e

-9

.)

=p

• sl f#

ft ..

,' l e fs- t y,

• , p) p.

>

• e.

r9 s #) 7j,

- . -t

, , e L < ,

a f m

) .'.,

_ ., g u

., . l (, ,

l j ,,,

< c-

','b

, ~ .

([

[,1 1 ;' fu

/><.

h I# g4 [ *

(7, M

/,3 57 /'

'? '/

- . + ._.

. . -I)%n p '

./ s

/.

/' -y .

t f

b Y .h di ,, y  ?'  ; f 6 h '}

,,. .?-/ ?!, . y / !f :'ef  : I , .* 4 0 I , ,

g, u ?6*

l~?fn - %4.. > p g. 92 .

, h %s. 7 /. 2'c e, o

. ,4 f II ) */

[L  ; 5 c"o J

r ,

) /

• /

(

l

{ l, S'S l.

08/18 '98 :47 No.989 04

,a,....-

l ARCHITECT - ENGINEERI Ltvate ?if>

"*~

T. .= 2.

[ COST ESTIMATEl W. 7,gg;;,, '

inspection of Morbia Facade. OWFN Bueng . PHASE ll SPECIAIJTIES JOn 'a lTIE AIAN RATLs Of ot. vi N rO'tAEs lifKMS (5) (5)

PROJECr MGMT, (1)

FMINCIPAL

& COORDINATIO.% m ., ,,,. _ .

ARC 111TECTilRAl.

PROJUT M ANAGER On- $l29 09 13,09ft 13.098 WENIOR ARCIll1 E(.T 1# $ 71.24 $ 2,NM  : ..

JUNIOR ARC 881TECT O 1r 547.32 u.7a6 DESIGNF R $64.70 '$ppyg NO. OF D%GN 't.

DuA>TEPERSON 40 W 139.91 STRl'CTUHAE ti.194 59.s3[3 NENIOR ENGINt,tH 143.45 A w JIINIOR RNGINEFR 546.24 Dita >TEPF R%ON h

No. Or D%c1;. $44.33 j Att.CHANICAL SENIOR F.NGINEER JI:NIOR ENGIND R 568t.40 .

1J'.kA e 4 A . .*

DRA bTSPFR AON NO. 06 DM(M. $3u.2 7 [k $.<d elf (.THICAL SENION EN(ilNEF.R 568.30 ~ ~ ' '

f

.II:NIOR t.NGINFFR 146 7s f DMADTSPERSON SMIT As%I NO. OF 81% GA. .

$rECIFICATIONE hPEC %'RITF.R 169.63 4f No. OF rACEM WOND FNOC./ PROD. 111.1s M,.54fk EATI.sIATES COST IWl'IstATOR 569.63 ML. _-

OTIIE,RE SF.NION ESCINF.F.R -

g KNION ENGINEER fM,g g f t r-Total Drawletts l' '

Total Man Hours 224 'I014L sALARIEN A 112 Silt 1 Cosisukaut:534,266 I.I D. u)NNI:I. TANT.s (attuh eu6 ..ece olot N1x ,4tM/hww 1116tl .Q(

3  !

d >

5 kh L9 fk

'I OT AL COsst'I.T ANTS U $15.693 C. OlllF.H DIRECT CONT 5 #nrtsh estimare. umisan) Olut. VI N Midl.giTei!

I Meyndiateluses:

11.179 rg 3 .

si 4 .! l S  ? l

't OT AI. OTilER DlH ECT C OSI N C 51.179 D. OVERliF.AllPOOLS A%10 t.NT4 k lidh TITLE 5 RATFS %

?*AW3 UAsF.N % ITnts

.' -#WM . . . ,

S, u..n- . wu F-.

10fAL Ct>SI 10 ARCHIT) C1-ENGINI+H 529.600 gnu a Amocinea. ta. F PROH 1 to% OF E INCLUDED g

j sa tu l'ensna krece. 8mk v20 dh0TAL CUhl lO Cd>VLJt.NMENT 329.800 u wes @ fo m io .m ,~.,mm.-r.

l segpenso er gaiyan .w vei,3 m

I

.m -

l l

s 08/18 '98 .:46 NO.989 03 r.m. . ,_

l A RCHITECT ' ~ ENGINEER -

nl,a a iTu I. ", u ,

ICOST ESTIMATEI "L. iRl.;RI, a-m_.

_inspeelsen of Mortile Faenee. OWFN Bueleng . PHAGE I A. palact s si.Auv rosT 4  !

SPECIALITIES JON TITI.F. \f4N KA I L*> A\lOl31% ' TOTAL 6

!!Ol'R$ (51 ($) (5)

PRO.fF.CT MGMT. l'MINCIPAL s ME j

& ('DORDINATION ANCillTF(TI N Al.

ruoJt.cr MANAGEN 91NIOR ARCillTECT g(Jffgu s129.m

%71.26 55.164 15.$51 55J64 _

JifNIOR ARCit!TF.CI g [] $4*J2 15.67e DEslGNF.R 564.70 NO. OF DWCS. 539.92 $14' W)

DRAFT $PFHM){ , _

FTRUCTUR.Al.

MENIOR F.NCINF.Fk 583 #%

JUNtost F,N:IMEN $46.24 DRAFTsPRR5 ION $4J 23 No. Or 0%cs. _

M ECllANICAL SENION 6.NGINFFR MM.le86 94, mNIOR FN61NFI N SJ7 $6 fN hI l puArtsrEnsON 530.27 6t*iM 4,9Ell ,

NO. OF DWC53.

ELECTRICAL ' NENION ENGINEER

.II:NinN FNs:l W N

%N.3848 SJ6.24 Q k, p l$

un A rTst*F N SON $ 30.27 '

1 NO. OF DWC4.

RPF.CIFICATIONS SPEC wul'sEM M9 63 w o up ru o csFu O n. s i t.7m f .. ]#4 NO. OF PACE $

F.STintATF.N COST F. STIM ATOu uv.63 WAJ ___

T asal IN _ _._; I~ Total Man flaun 280 'l O I AI N Al .A Rit.5 A 119.393 R. CON 8L LI ANI s 4MOL N'IM lMif-t Cennukaats: $60.942 t 1.1 u7,ovo W $f 3

IN

! l TO' sal.tt b Nt1.1ANIN R $47,000 i C. OTHER DikM 1 t usix (aresch neleinto as nerenser.g) AMOl'NTS Mf' s finpa.d.weanen 5J65 g (, ,y .

2 Phu + Process

• 12 swlis s 513.50 5362 3

4 b$ %

& VA '

S Md Total.Ollit M lHul.Cl Min 1h r $427 II. OVEHilEAD POOL.h OtOUNTS jdt hem TITLES RATFA % MAsE4 % ITa e MIM SNMF54 1

2 n+===ma asas=== 11 ~lul AL COS) 'l O ARCHi u .C 1-hNU1NhhR 587.100 UNM a .wuma, lac F PROFIT lun OF E INCL.1 H )LD 86*t hman suro. suiw v2n G l(JTM. CONT TO GOVLRNMEN I 587,100 55wr Spnne. AfD 20010 ons ar.noveo er ts., .. .no raer; wr

- ey faiyum.. .w rae.)

a

• ' ~~

08/18 '98 :46 NG.989 0.5 t 4. R F e te a.

~

l A RCHITECT - ENGINEER i,a ,,n, 5 2n

. - ,...~,

LCOST ESTIMATE l ".';c ..J,i.;;-lLn ,n.

Inspection of MartWe Facsoc. OWFN Buildmo -PHASE 1

4. DlHLCl N 41 AH4 ( O%14 SPECIALITIES JOll11Il.E \1 \N KAiLs 0101%lb TOTALS

!!OL Rb d. 3 (si 15)

PRO.lF.(T TIG.\lT.. l'HIM IPAL s NN@ N

& COORDINATION rMOJtcl' si %N 4GER # Il 5 8 2 9. " 16J 55.164 I A NCilllT(*fl'N Al - 4ENIOR AMCallTEC T _~___-

^~

I ' .

JttNIOR ARCIIITFCl ,ndgr D $4U2 15.618 utsu:Nru s'4.m . 4 NO. OF DWCS. DRAFTSPFR40N 139.92 51

. STRUCTLMI. s>.NIOR F.N(;iNFFk 5N3 #8 JIJNION P..%4lIM1H $46,2 4 DRAFTSPF.R40N 54J.83 l NO. 0F DwCS.

%IECIIANICAL hENION ENGl%FF!! %N W 3:4' I piiNion FN(.INFI N 147 W6 4 No. Or DWCS.

uuArtsrEH.wis s3o 2- J. J ELMTRICAL NLNIOH ENGINEhl4 %4.W 5.

.II'Ntou > sa:isics.u 146.2n g{M4 .

j nn ArtsrF wv2r. 53 a.2 ' 4 NO. OF Du GS.

NPECIFICA FIO.N 5 SPECwMilER %96.6 '

wOWDPHOc.Puou 5 68. 3 Nt .D ' .

NO. OF PACES F.STI%I ATEN COST F.S fI\14 I Oil %943 WW4f1PIllR ..

OTHER T!NIsht,4tji: I w.em Tasal prowings I e Total \tati ll..un 2bu 101 si Mal Al416.s A SI9JV3 A 'l R. ( 0.NsLLI AN i s 010l'%~3 % ,1 Hgug5-g 1 Co..wkanter $60 9M v I.I n'.owo :RNH,175ffR4 3 l b$0kk$$YN 3 i / 14TX #M ,

V 4 Mjd s 4RS TOI AB.CO%Ni 1.1 \N rs R $47.00P C. OT HER lbf ktCI IllNI N (dttwh estinistes 46 avsessaro A%10L NTS ?DHafssamP I R ,,,..d u..n.,

5465 @l'yT, ,,, 5 2 FEni + Prenes 12 n.IIs s 513 50 5162  ?"N4 3

4 D

np '

E 3 S:h'd . 2 Tol'AI.Ollit.R DIRECl (11xl A C $627

11. OVEMllEAD POOI.h 0100NTS ##hilll>Mm'W TITLE & R &T F4 sh itAsE s *.. ITa'M> MiM19ff95N I

2

.a=== Il ~101 AL COSI TO ARC Hi 1.C 1.E.NO LNLER 587.100 UNM a w.uaia lac F PROFTT 10% OF E INCL 411)LD seso h,uon sin.w sm= sin G IOTAl.CO%T TO OOVLRNMhNI $87,100 su m spnas un 20eso .

.m.m ., ii., .. e.., c.

suspassoev se, w en <

[

. Ud/ld /O '. 6 : !,' NC . ')CV V4 l A RCHITECT - ENGIN EER! bm, t 5'.~5= u LCOST ESTIMATF.l m  ;, , , ,,,s.lc o. , , ,

mspection of Marbie recade. OWFN Bulding PHASE ll SPECIAI.ITIES JOH 'llTI E nl AN RATLs \\10L vi s TOl ALS I!OL HS (5) (5) e51 PROJECT' % Hat T. PMi%CIPAL

& (1x)RDINATIO.N N c d:tT 4 %

ARClit s terlik AI.

PROJEcr M ANAGER () e 5129 m itek 53Nv0 sEston ARC 910 tel 9 e $712 n n z.nsa jNidd JtlNIOR ARCIIITECT () IIT 5J 7.32 5.l.7 A6 , p.ki, DEslGN F R 164.70 ,,

NO. OF D%GM DlutTSPERSON ATRI'(TL'K4L 41 W $39.92 53,194 59.810 NtNIOR ENGI.NITH 14.l.35 M E- w

' Jt?NIOR l'.NGIN EFR DRAFTEPERh05 546.J 4 h h NO OF linC5.

544.53 ~-M

.\1LCHANICAL SENIOR ENGlNEER 1/Jt.20 K '

Jt:NIOR ENCINtt H $4' me.

DlutTSPFRAON 0 0.27 ,f..

M.

f,.; iL W!

NO OF 11%GE.

EIJerPICAL Sf NION tNGINEER 568.80 jj . .

.it'NIOR ENGINiiFR tv. ?w y]f DNAFTSPERV>N NO.OFfluGM.

5.50 27 'M. .7 kPLC1) ACAYlON A SPEC WRITER 569 6.1 4Qt

_NO. OF PACEN MONDPHOC.! PROD.

SM "8 :15d k.dNW .3 F.ATi>I ATES CONT Mi tMATOR 569 0 4tihD4F"iY OTI!ERS .%ENIOR ENGINEEN

}&g. Pif, JUNAGH k NGINEER ':fd%(? Y ... .

Total Drawines l 1 Total Man Hours 224 i01AL%ALARitS 4 512,924 (7 T D. CON %TI.TANTS (attach e.ii.. e<<l Diot N1x d.BWIFKW l Confidtdtil: $14.2dt 1.1 } ~

$ 1519.1 .? {

2 l } } 8 3 I / > - .Y

.e \

/ -

idj!S $

5 -'

dN #

OT A L C Os%t't.T ANTS u $15.693 C. Ollit.R DIRECT CONT 5 tarruli estmutes a. ierrenani 4%IOL N I s .' uui pfMd!

I Mtper.dese Ikans; [/

/

11.179 g. ' f 3 T h[

d 9

[ I 3 3  ;

l

.7 - '

t O rAl.OTilER 1)IRR T C Os't N C ll.l?9 I1. OVERitE,u) POOLS TITLEN 4% lot.NTN WdMFKGP RATES % uAsim % ITints .Mth . .

T __

==c,... F.

~ 1OfAL COS 6 iO ARCHDl C1-ENGTNI+H 529.000 GNM a Amoem in. 1- PROfil 10%OFE INCLUDED

,j #4 to l'easaa sews. h :20 G IDTAL CUSl K)0OVLRNMFNT 329.800 EAer Mrwins. MD 209:0 nos .mmo n, 4,,, m . m an8PARio er telenehee e.1 Tem 1

1

r-

• UOJ OJ '/ G r !.JG h . I'l l VC

, (.

INSPECTION OF Tile EXI ERIOR MARBLE' GRANITE at Nuclear Regulatory Commission, OWFN o

.\ugust 20 1998 Breakdowpd of Consultant's Fee l

1

1. PHASE I A. Resicw of existing pertinent documents. Original construction doc unents and the Govenunent provided reports relatne to the marble /gramte veneer stabhzation and repair respiiremco Project director: rs x $154 00 -$ l.232 00 I

Senior architect phrs x $129 04 = 1.032 72 Junior architect - 47008 g / hrs x $ 7126 Sub-tot al ---- - - - - 5 2,834.80 B inspect marble / granite facade with a total of sesen (7) swmg-stage drops and doeument j the nature and extent of any marble / granite panel and/or >ealant d. stress /tailure observed during the incpection

@/,

{ ' s ' NSenior arehteet 120 hrs x $I29 09 =515.490 80 j,

junior architect djl20 hrs s S 712ti - 8.551 20 --

Junior engineer 120 hrs x 5 69 63 - R.335 60 e ', '

/7 Reimbersable Contractor to set expenses up & operate

/

(nutengeitilnt 7 drops of stage

=

etei 750 00

- 2t000 00 /2 k "',,,I Sub total ---- ---- -- 558,147.60

2. PHASE II l

Prepare a draft report summanzing the results of suney related to the esistmgtbndinon l- and performance of the marble /gramte facade panels and status of repair anchors in

! service 2 8hhr-t it t d h Project director x 5154 00 =$ 1.232 00 h Senior architect k44hrrr$129 09 - 5.1o3 60 junior architect %efrhrs s S 7126 = 5.700 08 Junior engineet - M614hs,-s S 69 63 - 1.671 12 500 00 g Reimbersable expenses (mileage /rdm. ete--) 514,266.80 Sub t ot al---

i ....................................

d 'g ' )

s 6s( Oh MLM

F WM \ %ad.T

~-

Ptw [ ain a, u> Y V.T - .

btt&f Nbl y 9 75 ,, 7m l4 b'- A h* k /F 9 = fog '

51 %, 24. w , 7 .x , ,- ,u, A / 2 's, y (W

'l' 1 l  : f. ?c; .,

\ ) At 'h'h y 6 9.&3 = g, s I?>a 17sv

% $ Loc i b

' h5cc

/ UE # k 2'L,. 3/ f P  : 3E,3 l N Zu4 76 y 7'. 2 & - \+2 ./ Iro+"

)

f ,' G 4 $i,. y / if c'9  :

f.Ga' 2. y )

IL fh- % % .> $9.<12 e -

)y'3av .

n- u ec  :

k un pn 5c~

)

/

fo '

2150

/

z i, 067 f

- - 08/19 '9,- 1/: Uc % +>/ J2 INSPECTION OF THE EMERIOR MARBLE / GRANITE at Nuclear Regulatory Commission, OWFN ,

August .'O 1998 Breakdowpd of Consultant 3 Fee L c :-

1. PHASE I yk

.,,,,j, cvicw of existing pertinent documents. Original construction documents and Y/Ip . i,

,fM $ M t- M the Government provided rep $,rts relative

,7 to the marbic/gramte M wt m, e  %'~a'M and vencer stabhzation V g.a repair reciuirementcg )p.

ph fyf ,i f*N

• O t*j' * / C n')

7g f},pf Project director:f4 djirs x $154 00 / -5 1.232 00

= 1.0.12 72 gjc /y t, .y ; ;_ _ ,

- f bn 4 g. - Senior architect + Ghrs x $129 04

, ', junior architect

,1%Iis x $ 7l 26 - 470 08 ' .') ', c,j ,g; . , .~

.[, S u b-t o t al ---.............. $ 2,834. N0 , ' i;(/p/

,,qt'p ap uYer B inspect marble / granite facade mth a total of sesen (7) swmg-stage drops and document 4vi the nature and extent of any marble / granite panel and/or walant distressitailure .-

paI c. observed during the mcpection 3 F" s ~

r archtedi: WM./,($lts x $l29 09=515.490 80 [g

~

4 put, iv L > ; Mr .* 4 7

Junior arcrutecq 120Tirs s > e i en 3..

Junior engineer 120 hrs x 5 69 63 -

R.15 4 r.0 % e .w.*

kOO K he.,chhc-, m imk;ife7tnuh & --.. w i s '- M

' Contractor to set up & operate 7 drops of stage -t . s.> m- . .

d'M Ir.,f l1 s

Sub.t ota1................. 558,I 4 7.60 M '

(p :I . Of* ' f .

6N7 (~Q./

f

2. PHASE II ';

i,;

.i_

! 6,/J M i g rrepare a draft report summanzing the results of sur e.s related to thc eUsting conditio ,

v l 4 g gu 0 qV 40 and performance&of the marble /gramte6di facade

. appanels and status ofi;6 PUl f , *.  ;

s M t? W < Ysmice f , s'"4 dk - 5 f~'d 1 gg T'roject director ' Ors x 5154 00 -$ 1.232 00 '>l'y, (~J';[' )

v \/ 2 (a Senior architect S brs x $129 09 - 5.163 60 ( g , i

< f # *' "'"

Id unior J architect /p rs s S 7I 26 - v 5.700 08 ,

[~~~ J 4g '

h (W D o Junior engineer 2m"2^

.

- /> ,

Aygl,171 Reimbersable expenses (mileage /rdm. etc ) OVlt- wD s ub.iot ai.......... ..... sia,266.80  %#'

"g5'a' g<4 i

l

,fM )

9 .................................... .a My/ c f, (s%k '

29s ' y, b/!- (p - 7779 l

-f .

Ve?#M wnei O '9# ?W n i$? w/uJAT j

e 08/19 '9F "7:08 N0.997 02 l

t INSPECTION OF THE EXTERIOR MARBLE / GRANITE i at L Nuclear Regulatory Commission, OWFN ,

j August 20,1998 Breakdowpd of Consyltant's Fcc 1.' PHASE I A. . Review of existing pertinent documents: Original construction documents and the Government provided reports relative to the marbic/ granite veneer stablization and repair requirements Project director: Bhrs x S154 00 5 1.232.00 Senior architect Shrs x $129.04 = 1,032 72 junior architect 8 hrs x S 71.26 - 570 08 i Sub-total -------- ---- $ 2,834.H0 )

B. Inspect marble / granite facade with t. total of seven (7) swing-stage drops and document the nature and extent of any marbic/ granite panel and/or sealant distress / failure observed during the inspection .

Senior archtect: 120 hts x Sl29 09 =515,490.80 Junior architect 120 hrs x S 71.26 - 8,551 20 Junior engineer 120 hrs x $ 69.63 -

8.355 60 Reimbersable expenses (mileage / film /ctc) = 750 00 Contractor to set up & operate 7 drops of stage - 25.000 00 i Sub total - - --- ----- 558,147.60 l

2. PHASE H -

Prepare a draft report summarizing the results of surs e) related to the esisting condition and performance of the marb!c/ granite facade pancis and status of repair anchors in service i

Project director 8 hrs x $154 00 -$ 1,232 00 Senior architect 40 hrs x $129.09 - 5,163.60 Junior architect 80 hrs s $ 7126 = 5.700.08 Junior engineer 24 hrs x $ 69 63 - 1,671.12 Reimbersable expenses (mileage / film, etc ) 500 00 Sub total--- ----------- 514.266.80 9

- - 08/19 '98 *7:08 NO.997 01 GNM FACSIMILE TRANSMITTAL GNM and Associates,Inc. -

Engineers, Architects & Planners  !

8630 Fenton Street, Suite 820 Silver Spring, Maryland 20910 Tel : 301-588-6110 Fax : 301-589-5107 REFERENCE :

GNM Project No 91642 , PCN: Task 26 Title : Inspection of Marble and Granite One White Flint North TO : Ms. Elinor Cunningham, TWEN 7-I-2 )

COMI'ANY :U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l FAX No. : 301-415-5761

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • An********A ***

Total number of pages sent, including this page is,,,,,,2 .. Please call 301-588-6110 if the transmittalis incomplete.

emetepeneeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeemmenneeneeAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA Breakdowns of our consultant's fee per your request DATE : 8-20-98 SENT BY : Soo II. Koh, P.E.

Vice President

08/18 '98 ":46 NO.989 02 I

P 4.V I ,V 4 PACIM ARCHITECT- ENGINEER COST ESTIM ATE SUMM ARY ,

rw.w :.. .

Inspection of Marble Facade, One White Flint North Building Task 26 Rockville. Marylans! GS111'95 EGD-0016 COST BY DESIGN STAGE ELEMENTS rurssi rursen DIRECT SALARY COSTS 519,393 S12,928

, CONSULTANTS $67,000 $15/'83 OTHER DIRECT COSTS $627 $1.179 OVERHEAD, INCLUDED INCLUDED INCLUDED INCLUDED INCL,UDED POOL TITLES INCLUDED INCL.UDED INCLUDED INCLUDED INCLUDED TOTAL COSTTO A E $87,100 $29,800 PROFIT INCLUDED INCL,UDED INCL,UDED INCL.UDED INCLUDED TOTAL COSTTO GOY'T. 587.100 529.800 TOTAL ESTIMATED DESIGN COST FOR PROJECT S $116,900 REMARMs l

u usu u .u ~ ., - , - c.. m u.w u.w, ~ n GNM & Associates,Inc. TELEPHONE 18630 Fcntan Strect. Suite 820 rnrworse mstar k Silver Spring, MD. 20910 (30t) 588-6110 curaw m p,.gwe .a ..:wj .t N I NA Gir y ; gpungg ung Lalps

e .

4 08/18 '98 '4:46 NO.989 03 Pe.K I of a PAm l A RCHITECT - ENGINEERJ n"km. SIo I. "us l COST ESTIMATE l Nw c,, , ,,,s. , c om 1

_.. i Inspeoleon of Martelo Faoade. OWFN Bueng PHASE I 1 l

4.1)IHMT SAI.ANY CONT 4 l

$PECIC,ITIES JOR TITI.E MAN RA'I ES _OlorNTS TOTALS IlOUR$ ($) ($) (3)

PRO. LECT AIGMT. PRINCIFAl,  ?#E

& ('OORDINATION PMOJiff M \NAGEN 40 $329.uv 15.8 6J $5J64 _

A NCIllTF4 Til'R AI. 9ENIOR ARClitTITT 120 571.26 15.553 JttNIOR ARClllTECf 120 547J2 15.678 Dk.51GN F.R 564.70 NO. OF DWCS, DRAFT $PF.RRON 139.92 114

~

STRUCTLhl. . EENIOR F.NGINEFM - ss3 us JUNION F.M:IMZH $46.24 DRAFTSPRRSON $4J.83 NO. OF DWGS.

MErilANICAL SENION ENGINFFR 5M me .

.IllNIOR FNCINFI'M 547 36 DMA}TSPEMNON 530.27 L'3 .

~

NO. OF DWC9.

l ELECTRICAL NENION 6.NGINEER Su.hu - $ l '

.ll NION FNGINFFW $46.24  ;' I' f ~

DRA!788'FNVJN $30.2 7 /_~

NO. OF DWC4. h RPF.CIFW.ATION5 SPEC WMl's F.it WOMD PHOC./ PROD.

569(5 Ell.7N 3g.

NO. OF PACES l ENTIMATF.N COST ENTIM Alotl My.(,J h __

l Tasal Drawines I: Total Mamfloun 280 'lo t AI. N AI.ARilLS A $19.393 l

8. CON $t't./I AN I 4 AMOl'NTM %E-1 Conmukants: $60.942 r 1.1 567.050 YMt 2

3

]Of hi "

4 0 .

W$#$ l' Tui At.(1)NSt.I.I ANIN R $0.000l O. OTHER 1)IkFCI i1INI N (attach estimates es hereseary) AMOL NTS C 1 Rependeante.nman f

5465 < .<--

l 2 fem + Process: 12 rutas 5 3.so 5162 Jh<

3 it$h.L 4

_S

'iNdd l TOTAL.OsItEN t>lNmt rtaxTh C $627 l  !

?l. OVEMilEAD POOI 4 AMOUNTS :sd!MC . _ __ - _

TITLES R ATI'4 % HAWS % IT ash -HM MFWW

' I 2 g

. m === E ~101 A1. COSI TO ARCHIil .C 1 -ENGINLER 587.100 l UNM a A=wiewen,Inc . F PROFIT IV% UF E INCL.11DbD ]

800 hwn smi. sua, s20 O l( ATAl. CONT TO OUVLimMEN1 587,100 1 Silwr Spring, MD 209to - ears amiowro se tsww mie rent we WWGPGAfD9V fAlpeneemed ute)

08/18 '98 14:47 NO.989 04 t

,.m....._

' IARCHITECT - ENGINEERI Luvai. Ui> 7.".= 2.

-. n wa LCOST ESTIMATEI LL 'ii;;ua,. .

inopoclon of MPetWe Facade OWFN Budding - PHASE 11 -

NFliCIAf.TTIES JollTITI E hfAN RATLS AMOLNTS l

TOTALS '

llOL'MS (5) (5) (5)

PROJECT hMWT. PMINCIPAL

& (13 ORDINATION PROJECT M ANAGER 14 5129.09 u,99a 53.090 ARCillTE(.TilRAI. EMNIOR ARCllituT da 52,asu

~

{g

$ 7 3.16 JUNIOR ARCHITECT no 547.32 53.786 l3;;

DESIGNER 564.70 NO. OF DWGN.

h k. -

DNAFTEPERSON W $39.92 53,194 5 STRUCTUMAL MENIOR ENGINEt:N $83.95

~

4 JIJNIOR KNGINEER $46.2 4 9 DMADTEPFRNON $44.53 l NO. Or linos. - l NIECHANICAL SENIOR IGNGINEER 54N.40 JIINIOR ENCIN EFH 541 m DNA>TMPERM)N .

53n.27 . . . . . _.-.<l  !

NO. OF 13%(IS.

EI.F(.TRICAL SENION ENGINEF.R S

568.80 4

IITNIOR k.NGINFER 546.2N i NO.ornwns 1)RA6TSPER.40N $30.2 7 ~ N e d SPECIFJCATIONS 8PEC WRITER 569.63 ^

M) OF PACES WORD FNOC/ PROD. 531.78 IN trrIMATES COST 19t!'IMATOR 569.63 K. _ _ _ __j OTIIERE 8F.NION ENGINF.EN JUNION F.NGINEER NN Toed Drewhtas l" ai Total Man Hours : 224 TOTAL SALARIF.N A 512.918 D. CONNill. TANT 5 (attach es 6n..ee.) .ufot'N1 x MMU wu I Censultshi: $14.266 r 1.1 2

51 A.691 i .

rr 3

4 4

h 5

L

'I OT A L Cowl'I. TANT 4 U $18493 C. Ol'IlEN DIRECT (.t>Nl N vastach estimates == necessan) AMOI. NTN CWlilf 9 ( '

I I Merr.' tauns:

$1.179 Sh .

7 M

3 4 .g.E S )#arn.?fyy TOTAI.OTIIER IMH VCT COS'l N C 51,179

13. OVERily.AI) POOLS A%fOI;NTN L#tt h TITLE.s RATES % UA%EN % ITEAlb 1

fh. -- -

2 5 su.a.===.wasses F. IOTAL CU.Ti iO ARCIIITIC1 ENGINhhR

~

529,800 _

UNM a Associates, tu F PROFii 10% OF E INCLUDED j een Friwan breet, m r20 G l'OTAL CUS'l iO C,OVLRNMENT 829,800 Edwr s#=4as, AfD 20910 a ,s e.una e, <s,wm ans w we sessenseav reones ,4 fees

I '

- 08/18 '98 *4:46 No.989 01 l

l GNM FACSIMILE TRANSMITTAL l

GNM and Associates,Inc. .

f Engineers, Architects & Planners j 8630 Fenton Street, Suite 820 {

Silver Spring, Maryland 20910 i Tel : 301-588-6110 Fax : 301-589-5107

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • l REFERENCE :

GNM Project No 91642 PCN: Task 26

. Title : Inspection of Marble and Granite One White Flint North TO : Ms. Elinor Cunningham, TWFN 7-1-2 )

COMPANY :U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Conunission l FAX No. : 301-415-5761 Total number of pages sent, including this page is 4 . Please call 301-588-6110 if the transmittalis incomplete.

A*AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAeAAAtekAAAAAAAAAA Breakdowns of our fee prc,posal for the referenced project.

l

• • • ve**************************************************A.*******9 '

DATE : 8-19-98 SENT BY : Soo H. Koh, P.E. ,

Vice President  :

1

l , AUG.24.1998 9:58AM GSA gE F.1 2 5 h.9t)

GSA Contract No.: GSIIP95EGD00t6 GNM & Associates,Inc.

B.24. CONTRACT MAN-HOUR RATES OPTION YEAR 2 as negotiated January 30.1996. ,

The Extended Contract Man-Hour Rates set forth below apply to this Contract for payment purposes.

SXTENDED ACTUAL PROFIT CONTRACT PAYROLL OVERHEAD @ MAN HOUR DISCIPLINES RATE /HR RATE 9 %/HR. RATE Management- GNM & Asseeistus, lac. 4 138 %

Project Mgr. (Reg.) 549.76 568.67 $10.66 5129.04 Architecturst-GNM & Aseecistes,Ime.. @l39W Sr. Architect (Reg.) 527.47 S37.91 55.88 371.26 Jr. Architect S18.24 $25.17 53.91 547.32 Sr. Designer / Planner f24.94 S34.42 $5.34 564.70 Draftsperson _

S15.39 $2:.24 S3.30 $39.92 Mechank'mi GNM & Assocates.Inc. @ I38 %

Sr. Engineer (Reg.) $26.52 536.60 $5.68 568.80 Jr. Engineer S!8.45 $25.46 $3.95 547.86 Draftsperson $11.67 S16.10 S2.50 $30.27 Electrical . GMM & Associstes, Int:. @l38%

Sr. Engineer (Reg.) $2152 $36.60 $5.68 568.80 Jr. Engineer 517.84 $24.62 $3.82 546.08 Draftsperson S t 1.67 $16.10 S2.50 S30.27 Structurei-Brandes& Onesagnet $150%.

Sr. Engineer (Reg.) $30.77 $46.16 56.92 $83 85 Jr. Engineer $16.97 $25.46 $3.82 546.2J Draftsperson $16.45 524.68 S3.70 S44.83 Civil.SealF-7 4 @ 150 %

$r. Engineer (Reg.) S27.48 S41.22 56.18 574.88 Jr. Engineer S19.13 $28.70 S4.30 $52.13 Draftspersea $i4.85 522.28 $3.34 540.47 FireProssetime-Gess Babeesk4 @155%-

Sr. Engineer (Reg.) $32.89 550.98 S7.55 $91.42 Jr. Engineer $19.80 $30.69 S4.54 555.03 Draftspersea $16.45 S25.50 $3.78 $45.72 itutOthe>+ . , @ 138 % ,

Cost Esthmator $26.84 S37.04 SS.75 569.63 Spec. Writer $26.84 $37.04 S5.75 $69.63 Word Processor $12.25 $16.91 S2.62 S31.78 i

L AES - 45

v M. 24.1998 9: 58Af1 GSA W;.767 P.I 2 GSA Contract No.: GSilP95EGD0016 GNM & Associates. Inc.

11,24. CONTRACT MAN-HOUR RATES - OPTION 2 The Extended Contract Man-Hour Rates set fonh below apply to this Contract for payment purposes.

EX7 ENDED ACTUAL PROflT CONTRACT j PAYROLL OVERHEAD @ MAN HOUR DISCIPLINES RTE /HR. RATE 9%/HR. RATE

[ Asbestos ADassenes.t- Appued Ray.

@ 127 % i Env. Specialist 536.0/ 545R $7.37 589.22 Cer.. Ind Hygknist $32.h 541.7 56.71 $81.28 Ind. Hygienist 519.63 $24.9 54.01 548.57 Techsleian _

514.85 518.f 3 53.03 $36.74

[Historie Cons .%==e==rhein Artflitect' @ 150%': -

l Historic Consultant $41.38 562.07 59.31 Si 12.76 lRooling- Ses! Engineering @150%

l Senior Consultant $27.48 541.22 $6.18 574.88 l Inspector $21.22 $31.83 $4.77 $$7 S2 l Elevator- Was,limatt & Associates @ 125 %

Principal 541.38 551.73 58.38 $ 101.48 Project Manager $32.02 540.03 56.48 578.53 Drsfter 516.45 $20.56 53.33 540.34

[ Cost Consehnt- Hauscanth Assectets @'150%

Project Manager 534.48 551.72 57.16 $93.96 Senior Estimator 131.30 $46.95 $7.04 585.29 Support Estimator 521.45 $3218 $4 83 558.45 Technician i15.94 $23.9l $3.59 $43.44 Laborassey e.. .,,..,

cf;;g ;,

m Poesd4 N; Applied

. unsetsii , , " ' PirSeasple I

Asbestos Bulk Samples $T5.00 (by Polarized Light Microscopy - PLM)

%M54m+um Asbestos AirSamples 58.00 (by Phase Contrast Microscopy- PCM)

g. , . ~ w ca. . .

Lead Paint $amples 525.00 I

(by Atomic Absorption Spectroscopy- AAS) 5 Other mdustrial hygiene sample analyses Cost - 15%

l AES - 45a i

L +

- ,