ML20247G513

Intervenor Exhibit I-MAG-70,consisting of 881219 Memo Forwarding Listed Documents Re FEMA Interim Evaluation & Recommendations for Plant.W/O Encls

ML20247G513
Person / Time
Site:	Seabrook
Issue date:	04/12/1989
From:	Donovan R Federal Emergency Management Agency
To:	Flynn J, Krimm R Federal Emergency Management Agency
References
OL-I-MAG-070, OL-I-MAG-70, NUDOCS 8905300420
Download: ML20247G513 (4)

Text

h._ h,, _ _ Federal Emerge?dfManagement Agency ww g

4 g

f Region X -_

FederalRegionalCenter Bothell, Washins 98021 9796 s

- g, December 19. 1988 5

MY 23 p3 4,

'OFF,

^f'; ',, t,,. l j g~

MEMORANDUM FOR: Richard W. Krima Asst. Associate Director. SL-NT "M~

Joseph H. Flynn General Attorney GC-PL

SUBJECT:

Interim Evaluation and Recommendations for Seabrook k

Attached are 50 copies of the documents that comprise the Region's Interim i

Evaluation and Recommendations for the Seabrook Nuclear Power Station. Please D'

reference my memoraadum of. December 12.

Please destroy all previous drafts and

'b versions of these documents.

1 I

As I reflect over the last year and the various tasks and assignments related h-to the Seabrook site. I find the following dates to be of interest:

\\

1.

12/19/87:

I was called to my Regional Director's Office and on arriving a conference call was established with FEMA Headquarters.

I was asked if I could support FEMA Region I regarding Seabrook.

1 t' \\y (I then went on scheduled leave for 2 weeks.)

L hL 2.

12/22/87:

Mr. Krina, representing FEMA. stated at a public meeting that FEMA would begin in January to review the Seabrook

(

Plan for Massachusetts Communities (SPMC).

3.

12/30/87:

Mr. Vickers appointed me as the RAC Chairman for Seabrook regarding SPMC.

0\\

4.

1/7/88:

First discussions with FEMA Headquarters regarding the scope of FEMA Headquarter's commitment for the Agency, and FEMA Headquarter's expectations of the Region.

5.

5/9/88:

Mr. Vickers transmitted Review and Evaluation of SPMC to MY FEMA Headquarters (4 months and 3 days after I started review process).

1 6.

6/3/86c Mr. Vickers appointed me as RAC Chairman for Seabrook for

\\g A all offsite plans and preparedness.

V 7.

6/14/88: Evaluator packets were sailed to 151 FEMA evaluators.

Separate controller packets were also sailed.

8.

6/25-7/2: Managed Seabrook exercise evaluation process.

8905300420 890412 PDR ADDCK 05000443 O

PDR

.mm__ _ _ _ - - - - _ - - - - - - - - - = - - - - - - - - - - - - -

, i c

8

(/

9.

7/2/88: Conducted participant briefings and Public Meeting.

10, 8/2/88: Draft Exercise Report forwarded.

11, 9/1/88:

Mr. Vickers forwarded final Seabrook Exercise Report to FEMA Headquarters.

12.

9/2/88: FEMA Headquarters forwarded Seabrook Exercise Report to NRC.

13.

10/11/88:

Mr. Vickers forwarded Review and Evaluation (R&E) of SPMC to FEMA Headquarters.

14.

10/14/88: FEMA Headquarters forwarded R&E of the SPMC to NRC.

15.

10/18/88: Forwarded draft Review and Evaluation of Maine and New Hampshire, and draft FEMA Find 2ng and R&E of SPMC.

16, 12/7/88:

I completed final editing of Interim Evaluation and Recommendations for Seabrook Nuclear Power Plant.

17.

12/13/88:

Mr. Vickers forwarded Interim Evaluation and Recommendations to FEMA Headquarters.

18.

12/14/88: FEMA Headquarters forwarded FEMA Finding and Determinations for Seabrook to NRC.

The above referenced accomplishments could not have been achieved without your trust and confidence.

I want to thank you for your support, advice, counsel and recommendations over these months.

)

i I wish you joy this Holiday and happiness in the New Year.

l Richard W. Donovan RAC Chairman for the Review and Evaluation of the Seabrook Offsite Radiological Emergency Plans and Preparedness Attachments as stated cc: w/o attachments Craig Wingo. Chief. SL-NTH Margaret Lawless. SL-ONTH Marshall Sanders SL-ONTH rBill Cumming. DGC g

1 l

an e s em an onsvinm y omoNs Amt o8SoLETE.

14901 1

_MrN'FLYNN: 'Ha maintcinsd thtm as' input to his 2

report.

They fell in the same category as draft material.

3-JUDGE SMITH:

Am I correct, Mr. Flynn, that these 4

were notes taken at.the time of the actual events by the 5

FEMA observers of the exercise?

Did you hear me, Mr. Flynn?

6 MR. FLYNN:

Yes, I did, Your Honor, and my 7

response was that, yes, that is correct.

8 JUDGE SMITH:

All right.

Until we have an 9

opportunity to figure out what FEMA's legal responsibilities 10 are and what the tiscovery aspects are, is there anythJ.ng we 11 could do'to assure that there won't be any further 12 destruction of documents?

13 MR. FLYNN:

I will take that as a directive from 14 the Board and I expect to be talking to Mr. Donovan later 15 this after.

I will pass that on to him and I will make it a

> 4 16 point to pass that on t6 the --

17 JUDGE SMITH:

Yes.

I would call it a direct order 18 of the Board until we can inquire into the matter, not to 19 destroy any documents relating to the June 1988 exercise, 20 until we can sort out the legal aspects of it.

I'm not 21 sayin'g what he did was correct or incorrect; I ust said we 22 don't know, but we want to stop it now until we can unsort 23 it.

24 Judge Frye came into the room and pointed out that i

25 it is not a matter of concern to the Shoreham Board because q

l Heritage Reporting Corporation (202) 628-4888 h

j