ML20247L216

Transcript of 890911 Meeting in Rockville,Md Re Affirmation, Discussion & Vote.Pp 1-5.Related Correspondence Encl

ML20247L216
Person / Time
Issue date:	09/11/1989
From:	NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
To:
References
REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8909220156
Download: ML20247L216 (8)

Text

-

,8 W,,

^

TNej g,

[:

., 7 A"

UNITED? STATES OF?AMERIC A-

. NUCLEAR 1 REGULATORY.COMMIS SION m

Title:

.-arriaMArron/D1scuss1on ino vors

(

. LOCatiOII:t accKv1LLE, MARYLAND t

hake:'

SEPTEMBER 11,-1989 ii Pages:

5;rAass NEALR.GROSSANDC0.,INC.

COURT RFPORTERS AND 1 TRANSCRIBERS

~

1323 Rhode' Island Avenue, Northwest Washington, D.C.

20005

.. ( 202 ) 234-4433 OFof 8

oa D -:

'8909220156 890911 i

PDR-10CFR PT9.7 PDC l

i.

4g..

BISCLAIMER~

h This is'an unofficial transcript of a' meeting of the ' United. States Nuclear ~ Regulatory - Commission held on

.y September 11, 1989 in the Commission's of fice ~ at. One ai!

White ' Flint North, Rockville, Maryland.

The meeting was open-to public attendance and observation.

This transcript has, n'ot ' been ' reviewed, corrected or edited, and it may u

~

contain inaccuracies.

The transcript is intended solely for general informational purposes.

As provided by 10 4/ 9.103, it is

~

not'part of the formal or informal record of decision of the: matters discussed ~.

Expressions of o' pinion in this transcript.do not necessarily reflect final determination or beliefs.

No pleading or other paper may be filed with the Commission in any proceeding as the result of, or addressed to,.any statement or argument contained herein, except as the Commission may authorize.

'I NEAL R GROSS court REPORTER $ AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHoDE ISLAND AVENUE, N.W.

(202) 234 4 433.

WASHINGTON, D.C.

20005 (202) 232-6600

, X:?

,i5 tbj,h.y.

s.-,1

\\ i; ;> ' -

j

+.,

f' 6

I l

-3g z.' ;';ps 3_)

?

'~,\\

hM p

g eB

=

g.

c 1

. 1...

)

a-7 p,-

im 4.

1 s

=

M.

}f {

~

f j',;

j _

i r

l

-- g,;

%uw...,. g> -

UNITED STATES:OF! AMERICA 4

- Mi l...,

f, NUCLEAR REGULATORY; COMMISSION a

9-fj ",

s 't*

i

\\

w.,

,f, gs f

i 6 ri

'"4 m

4 /l@

AFFIRMATION / DISCUSSION,AND VOTE

x At E

,t

.t'..

in,

.~

.v,

Nuclear Regulatory Commission

~

~

One. White. Flint North-

%o g

'Rockville, MarylandJ

(;.'y p

.F Monday., September 1 1,- 1 9 8 9.'

a 2

x

-5 I '

?. 7. 3,

lThe Commission met in'open' session, pursuant

' to. n'otice M at' 10 : 00 a.m., 'Kenneth L M. 'Carr, Chairman,.

f.;;

' presiding.

.y u

.'.k'g'

) l'$

g 4

C' COMMISSIONERS PRESENT:

M y :.

w., m.

KENNETHLM. CARR,. Chairman:of;the' Commission THOMAS:M. ROBERTS,--Commissioner KENNETH C. ROGERS, commissioner' JAMES.R.JCURTISS, Commissioner j,

i i

a A

\\

I i 9

3,s r

...f

.r m}iM:

n.g

/.,

ll.

m

[,

-i '

NEAL R; GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS D[

1323 RHODE ISLAND AVENUE. N.W.

s 4 f 202) 2%4433 WASHfNGTON. D C. 2000'-

c021232 4 00 yh.

5, a

,.- w*ww..

i, -

m

,' i

,h 4

, m

~' f r5

J) ?,

L 1

A l

2 s

s s.

+:('2Q lmv. n 1

- u jn. :

. +.

sun a p, q

• i. y.yw% c.

' t..

m p.. g L;, y, ~.sv.

ws.,

s

_v.,

b, 2.

c, gy j_ y,

x m,

m -, r:

.m.

we-

,e

_w oe7 ;-

v T.h r m y.c;m,s 3;W %.a+, %n 3.~ w~:a. a :

<s m.c e.

3

w

,i.

s c.

yc 1

mm

n..,

v

-n 4J.

n p..y

' 2 :,, ;

', < g,,

- 2; s ;. ',.!i: !: m

-... -: f.,.

m r

.a g

a-r

e f

4 1;.

g y;2_;- i+<

s

^

~

f

e.,. -

, m.s d.

G-

4 1

.y.,

Nh'gl

$Y STAFF)SEATEW AT THE.-.COMMISSIONLTABLE:.

I " ',

I 4

mqm,,:W:w

e

• n

r a '

s n

a

.~

s w

. W,J:

t k"-..

r.

t i

a : e.:

c',.g.;

W rs.

v f ::

',e' %~'. -

n:::']

p-

' { :^_'

A 4 q},b.';; q; yn q m.qr; g' L

S'AMUEL'J W C' HILK.k, Secretary.

J e

~.

~

~9:?

ne R bi%

+

C Th.

z o,,q r,

%y~,.

s i

1, :<.

s a

r

.n c

E p ' u. [,

- c 1

_.f,.

,Y (s

r_

/

3

,g 4

5.

m LWILLIAMtCa PARLERW General. Counseli y.

v.to e

y' t '..y,

'4+

. teh p

-d.

g'M

]

3,,

<f.g.? { m s

s-1 5

v %

(

0 J

Iy v.;

1

/

'T I

,/f"

_.., i.;,.: v. ;,

.7..c 4

,t

,;.-p.

1,

+

(

9:

f l'.

t,--

4 a

ej k.1, s

s (4

!.}

J.

Y co.',

L.M.,'-!.

3 f-L

.r

~. p. ?

4v :

g s,,

I 5

5 i

,h y

-3 t

r.:

' yay p; u.

t[f 4

f-[

iM r h L[(

l 4

4 i 1p o g v.y Nh * '.

kJ W

yc-i r@5.e. m,. o t

~_)'

oa n.i.

a

.n..,

>i m

s c,

.i.

y, t

4 i e ;:p '

.;g 7,.f.

.o m- ;,

o

. by 9,b,.

q-'

r 9

br'g,

.;. f ) i 0'

4 f J,e;

-..l$

j

(

,'y'

- ; f ;'

' -)

p,,. L p.i.

..I,'\\t J

l f

J 4*.

p e

I pc e g

yr i

a m

3.-

-e m,

3 e

. c' y

' t 5:

I' f is s,,4 e-j-

[

..%,, 4,

_:. y

.r.

' g.

f. Qg' s

.s

, 3; ')

7,'.]..; -,

..q.,

,~.{-

m ' '

E

[ f {_ ',_

7".-

-4

?

cJr:

w

-3}..

s

e' :,

.3 i

g I 'l

' _3

> :]'p 8

E 1

l Q (','

H j,,

t.' '

s

~.,

b

g piJ p 1

(

a g' 'r i_-7 y

_l'

}

-m

c. W -

,,j u,

r Q ~ ', ',,,J O

u o

. :n '

p-.,

a t

>/

3

s. m', -,.,/. c..

~h

'

i

-i I N 4 J

{-

t R. <

J,..-

• h x

g.

t w 4

f; ',

,'t' jf,7 e.

, 6;

.),.[.

i.1

/[

I e

-1,;

t n.

YI s

ge ti

..c.

-l

!,. g s' F..

T, ft

.c 3 ;

O !/.

d' #1I'N J

i rg

,..q.7 d:

r' j

'g. *,

y y

4 5

.\\ k

\\

(

w

,-.-l a

1 4

NEAL R. GROSS m<

L Ji,.

t.

j;,w.,,"'.

s c

l' COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS

._,1,-,

-c.

z

A.

s gy g

s, r

1 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVENUE, N.W.

N..1. w, Y

[

S Yt202) 234MI

WASHINGTON. D C M005

'?c2) 232wuyj af)'

,'k

'h A

^

g

[.,

~__.E.".,

x

---

"--------^-^~~-^--'~-'^^-^~^'^'"-^^'""y

7

,M 7

3 1

PROCEEDINGS 2

10:08 a.n..

3 i

CHAI'tMAN. CARR:'

Good morning, ladies and-4 gentlemen.

5=

This is an affirmation session.

We have two 6

. items to.come'before us this morning.

7 Bef ore' I ask the Secretary to lead'us 8

through the items for affirmation, do any of my fellow 9.

Commissioners have any opening comments they would 10 like to make?

11' (No response) 12 CHAIRMAN CARR:

If not, Mr. Secretary, you 13 may proceed.

14 SECRETARY CHILK:

Mr. Chairman, the first 15-item is SECY-89-276, a motion for reconsideration.

16 filed by Joseph J.-Macktal.

17 The Commission here is being asked -to 18 respond to an August 18, 1989 motion by Joseph J.

19 Macktal requesting that the Commission its decision in 20 CLI-89-14 wherein it declined to dicqualify itself 21 from deciding any future matters involving Mr.

22 Machtal.

U 23 All Commissioners have approved an order 24 with modifications by Commissioner Curtiss denying the l

motion for reconsideration.

25 NEAL R. GROSS

}

COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVENUE, N W.

(202) 234 4433 WASHINGTON D C 20005 "2' 27?"Y j

l___ _i

t

[

aG.

M a

.. ? '

j\\-l:[ 'O y

'~

Le

'4

'^f g F-4

[@

1 ji rn ~,

1

'Would you~please. affirm your votes?

f 2L (Ayes) b s',

3 -;

SECRETARY, CHILK:

The.second' item is SECY-t h

L41 189-194,: amendments to 10 CFR Part 34.

Lm.

'5~

The Commission.is b e i n g a s k e d to; approve t

[

l6i tame'ndments to 10'CFR Part 34 which apply: to industrial-

[+s

' 7; radiography.

. The amendments are intended to reduce R't. &

L8 radiation. exposure to both radiography personnel-and

$sM

, f 9

the ' general' ipublic f rom the' use of ' radiographic n

10

' equipment.

L

'll The Commission' is also modif ying-its J'

12 Enforcement. Policy to add a' specific example. to put' 13 11icensees-on' notice that the failure to-implement the-y

~

' 14 '

1 requirements' f or dosimetry and equipment ' may be

[p f

15' considered a violation of 'significant ' regulatory 16' concern.

17:

LAll Commissioners have approved the rule and

~

18

' agree with. the modifications proposed by Chairman 19

'Carr.

-20 Would you please affirm your' votes?

21 (Ayes)

'22 SECRETARY CHILK:

I have nothing else sir.

23 CHAIRMAN CARR:

Is there anything else to 24 come before-us today?

?

25-

-If not, we stand adjourned.

.s NEAL R. GROSS i

COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVENUE, N W.

2

..s-i y'

. Nl? V

~ (202) 2344T3 WASHINGTON D C 20005 (202) 232-M00 1

wg. -,-

I

'~

5.

1; (Whereupon the af firmation/ discussion ' and 2

vote was ' concluded at 10:12 a.m.).

3 4~

-5 6 '

.9 10 11

'12

' 13 ~-

14 15' 16

'17

.18 19 20 21 22 23-24 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRAf4SCR'BERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVENUE, N W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON O C 200%

r?C2: ???##X) w--_

7 cme- --

.:4 ;;;.. -

l

.,. a. : i *

[

CERTIFICATE OF TRANSCRIBER

.This is to certify that the attached events of a meeting of'the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission entitled:

TITLE OF MEETING:

AFFIRMATION / DISCUSSION AND VOTE PLACE OF: MEETING:

ROCKVILLE, MARYLAND t

'DATE OF MEETING:.

SEPTEMBER 11, 1989 were transcribed by me. I further' certify that said transcription is accurate and complete, to the best of my ability, and that the transcript is a true and accurate record of the foregoing events.

v Reporter's name:

[

g y

+

b A

NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBER 5 1323 RHopE ISLAND AVENUE N.W.

(202) 234-4433 '

WASHINGTON. D.C.

20005 (202) 232-6600 l;.'...