ML20247L216

Transcript of 890911 Meeting in Rockville,Md Re Affirmation, Discussion & Vote.Pp 1-5.Related Correspondence Encl

ML20247L216
Person / Time
Issue date:	09/11/1989
From:	NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
To:
References
REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8909220156
Download: ML20247L216 (8)

Text

- - --

,8 .., , ,

- W,, .-,

' ' ^

g, TNej

[:

., 7 A" UNITED? STATES OF?AMERIC A-

. NUCLEAR 1 REGULATORY.COMMIS SION m

Title:

" .-arriaMArron/D1scuss1on ino vors

(

t

. LOCatiOII:t

. accKv1LLE, MARYLAND hake:' SEPTEMBER 11,-1989 ii

'; , Pages: 5;rAass NEALR.GROSSANDC0.,INC.

~

COURT RFPORTERS AND 1 TRANSCRIBERS 1323 Rhode' Island Avenue, Northwest Washington, D.C. 20005

.. ( 202 ) 234-4433 8 OFof oa D -: ,

'8909220156 890911 i

PDR- 10CFR PDC PT9.7 l

i.

4g ..

BISCLAIMER~

h This is'an unofficial transcript of a' meeting of

.y the ' United . States Nuclear ~ Regulatory - Commission held on September 11, 1989 in the Commission's of fice ~ at . One ai!

White ' Flint North, Rockville, Maryland. The meeting was open-to public attendance and observation. This transcript has , n'ot ' been ' reviewed, corrected or edited, and it may u

~

contain inaccuracies.

The transcript is intended solely for general informational purposes. As provided by 10 4/ 9.103, it is ,

~

not'part of the formal or informal record of decision of the: matters discussed ~. Expressions of o' pinion in this transcript.do not necessarily reflect final determination or beliefs. No pleading or other paper may be filed with

, the Commission in any proceeding as the result of, or addressed to,.any statement or argument contained herein, except as the Commission may authorize.

'I NEAL R GROSS court REPORTER $ AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHoDE ISLAND AVENUE, N.W.

WASHINGTON, D.C. 20005 (202) 232-6600 (202) 234 4 433 .

I

+. , f' 6 s.-,1 \ i; ;> ' - j l

, X:?  ; ,i5 tbj ,h.y.  %,

-3g z.' ;';ps 3_) .

p

?

'~,\ >

hM 1 a-g eB c  ;= g.

7 p ,-

im >

4. .

1 s ,

. 1...

=

)

M.

~

}f { f j',;

j _ <

i r l

-- g,;

%uw.. . , . g> - -

4 UNITED STATES:OF! AMERICA

- Mi l . . ., ,

f, NUCLEAR REGULATORY; COMMISSION

,, a 9-s fj ",

gs i \

't*

• w.,

,f, i f 6 ri

'"4 , , _ _ .. _  :

m '

4 /l@ , ,

AFFIRMATION / DISCUSSION,AND VOTE

x At E

,t .t'..

in,

.~

.v ,

~

Nuclear Regulatory Commission

' ~

One. White. Flint North-(;.'y

%o '

, , g '

'Rockville, MarylandJ p '

.F ,..

Monday., September 1 1 ,- 1 9 8 9.'

a . ,

2 x-5

.I .' .

?. 7. 3 , ,

lThe Commission met in'open' session, pursuant

' to. n'otice M at' 10 : 00 a.m. , 'Kenneth L M. 'Carr , Chairman, .

f.;; ' presiding.

, .y ,

u

.'.k'g' g 4

) l'$

M C' COMMISSIONERS PRESENT:

, , y :.

w., m . KENNETHLM. CARR,. Chairman:of;the' Commission

< THOMAS:M. ROBERTS,--Commissioner KENNETH C. ROGERS, commissioner' JAMES.R.JCURTISS, Commissioner j,

i i

a A

\

9 Ii 3 ,s r

.r

...f n.

m}iM:

g

/.,

ll .

m .

NEAL R; GROSS

[, -i '

COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS D[ 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVENUE. N.W.

s 4 f 202) 2%4433 WASHfNGTON. D C. 2000'- c021232 4 00 yh.

, , a 5,

,h 4

, .- w*ww ~'.. s.

. +. sun af r5 ;J) ?,:.. i, - s s m *

,' i L >

1

, m , .

'  ! A 2 ,

+:('2Q lmv. n 1 ws .,

_v., ' t. .

c, gy

- u jn. : j_ y , s x

m, .,

b, 2.

p,<s q *we- m.c i. y .yw%,e c. e.

m_w s

p..oe7 g L;,  ;-m y, - , ~.sv. r:: w

.m.

v .

3 .~ w~:a. a :

c.

ycm y.c;m,s 3;W %.a+, %n 3 ,i.

. , 1 v -n '

- n. . , '

T.h rmm m r

.a g ,

a- r  ; e f: 4

., - 2; ,

y;2_;- i+< s ;. ' , .!i: !:1;m. s n p..y ' 2 :, , ;

g

', < g ,,

^

,m G-

.s

4 1 4Jd.. .y., - . . . -

f.,. -

~

f ,

e. ,. -

Nh'gl mqm,,:W:w .~

$Y >

4 STAFF)SEATEW AT THE.-.COMMISSIONLTABLE:.

e I I " ',

s w a

. W,J: '* :,, t *n r a ' s n a : e.: c', .g.; W i n:::'] f :: ',

e' %~' . -

v k"-..p-

' { :^_' r.

t A

rs.

R bi% *

~. ne +

4 q},b.';; q;q yn C Th. J e .,

~9:?

m .qr;

, . ~ '

z g' L o, ,q r , s

S'AMUEL'J W C' HILK.k, Secretary .

r 1,  :< .n . a %y~,. s ' -

i c ,., ,* 1 p ' u. [ ,

_.f,. r_

3

/

-c > ,Y

,g E

4  ;...... ,, .. . -

(s

5. m y.

v.to e LWILLIAMtCa PARLERW General. Counseli

• y' t '..y ,

p '4+ . teh ' ' '

-d.

<f.g.? { m 1 g'M >

] 5 , ,

3,,

s

, s-v%

( 0 J I 1 / 'T Iy v.; ,

,/f"

,;.-p. +

1, (

9: _. . , i.;, f.: v. ;,

-. .7. .c 4 ,-

,t

, t,-- l'.

4 a , ,

(4

> < , s s

• ej k.1,  ! .}

co.', , J. Y

.r L.M.,'-!. L 4v :

s, ,

f- g 3

,. . . . . - . . . ~. p . ? .-

I 5 5 '.

i '

y -3 t '

,h

' yay .;p;, r .: '<:' "

u. -.

4 >' , .-

f-[

iM r h L[( l t[f , '

4i 1p 4

' ' ' og v.yWNh i r@5.e . m, . o t ,.

• '. kJ ,

yc-n.i .. -

a

.n. ., ~_)' >i  ; oa m

s

.i.

y, c, t , ,

' 4 i e ;

p '-

.o .. -

.;g 7, .f.

,-. q-'

r

. by 9,b, .

, , m- ;, '

9 o

br'g,

• 0' 4

j (

.;. f ) i

,'y' f

J ,e; -..l$

I 4*. p e .

f J ,

..I,'\t J g

- l; f ;' ' -)- , .

pc e yr i

• a p ,, . L p.i.

m, m , 3.-e

-e

. c' 3 ,

y

't

. . . .:, 5: I' '

f is s,,4 e- j- .

[

. .% ,, 4,  ; '

f, 3;. ')Qg' s .s _:. y ,

.r .  ;' g.

m ' '7,'.] ..; - ,

..q., -

,~.{-

-4  ? E [ f {_ ' ,_ *'

-3}.. cJr: 7".-

w

, s

e' : , :.

.3 i g I 'l ' _3

> :]'p .. 8 E 1 . '

. . lQ

(',': -

> H j, , t .' ' s

~:g piJ b

(

p1

} y _l' ..

-m a g' 'r i_-7 ...

. c. W - ,,j '

r u,

Q ~ ' , ', , ,Ju

. :n ' ,

oO

p- >/ . , 3 a

, t

s.  ;~h :'

,_,m', <

' , -,.,/. - c.. '

i

-i I N 4 J

{- t , '

R. < , _ , J,..- '.

• h

g. x .,.

t w

f; ',

4

,'t' -

jf,7 e. .),.[.

, 6; ,

i .1 /[

I e

, n. .

-1,;

t YI s

ge ti ..c.

-l

!,. g T,s' F.. -

ft

.c 3 ;

O !/. '

J d' #1I'N i rg

, ,..q.7 r' j d:

'g. *, y y 4 5

.\ k

\

- < w

(

,-.-l a

1

, 4 m< >

NEAL R. GROSS L Ji , . .

t.

j;,w -c.

.,,"' . z s

c

._,1,-,

A.

l' COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS gy g s

, ;s, .

r :1 , 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVENUE, N.W.

N. . af)'

1. w, Y [ ,

S Yt202) 234MI ,'k g

WASHINGTON. D C M005 '?c2) 232wuyj

'h A ^

[ ., ~__.E."., - - x - - " -

---

"--------^-^~~-^--'~-'^^-^~^'^'"-^^'""y

7 ,

,M 7 3 1 PROCEEDINGS 2 10:08 a.n..

3 i CHAI'tMAN . CARR:' Good morning, ladies and-4 gentlemen.

5= This is an affirmation session. We have two 6 . items to.come'before us this morning.

7 Bef ore' I ask the Secretary to lead'us 8 through the items for affirmation, do any of my fellow

9. Commissioners have any opening comments they would 10 like to make?

11' (No response) 12 CHAIRMAN CARR: If not, Mr. Secretary, you 13 may proceed.

14 SECRETARY CHILK: Mr. Chairman, the first 15- item is SECY-89-276, a motion for reconsideration.

16 filed by Joseph J.-Macktal.

17 The Commission here is being asked -to 18 respond to an August 18, 1989 motion by Joseph J.

19 Macktal requesting that the Commission its decision in 20 CLI-89-14 wherein it declined to dicqualify itself 21 from deciding any future matters involving Mr.

22 Machtal.

U 23 All Commissioners have approved an order 24 with modifications by Commissioner Curtiss denying the 25 l motion for reconsideration.

! NEAL R. GROSS

} COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVENUE, N W.

(202) 234 4433 WASHINGTON D C 20005 "2' 27?"Y j l___ _i

1. * ... t [

a

..  ?

aG. .. M :

j\-l:[ 'O y

'~ .;

'^f g F- ,

Le '4 4

[@ 11

'Would you~please. affirm your votes?

ji rn ~ ,

b f 2L (Ayes) s

', 3 -; , SECRETARY , CHILK: The.second' item is SECY-t ,

h 189-194,: amendments to 10 CFR Part 34.

L41 Lm. . . .

'5~ The Commission.is b e i n g a s k e d to; approve t

[+s

, [ l6i tame'ndments to 10'CFR Part 34 which apply: to industrial-

' 7; radiography. . The amendments are intended to reduce R't . & L8 radiation. exposure to both radiography personnel- and

$sM

,n f 9  : the ' general' ipublic f rom the' use of '. radiographic 10 ' equipment.

L '

'll The Commission' is also modif ying- its J' 12 Enforcement . Policy to add a' specific example . to put' 13 11icensees-on' notice that the failure to-implement the-y ,

~

' 14 ' 1 requirements' f or dosimetry and equipment ' may be

[p f 15' considered a violation of 'significant ' regulatory 16' concern.

17:

~

LAll Commissioners have approved the rule and 18 ' agree with. the modifications proposed by Chairman 19 'Carr.

-20 Would you please affirm your' votes?

,' 21 (Ayes)

'22 SECRETARY CHILK: I have nothing else sir.

23 CHAIRMAN CARR: Is there anything else to 24 come before-us today?

?

25- -If not, we stand adjourned.

.s , NEAL R. GROSS i >

COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS i

2

..s- 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVENUE, N W.

y' '. Nl? V ~ (202) 2344T3 WASHINGTON D C 20005 (202) 232-M00 1

wg . - ,- I

'~

, 5.

1; (Whereupon the af firmation/ discussion ' and 2 vote was ' concluded at 10:12 a.m.).

3 4~

6

.9 10 11

'12

' 13 ~-

, 14 15' 16

'17

.18 19 20 21 22 23-24  !

25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRAf4SCR'BERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVENUE, N W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON O C 200% r?C2: ???##X) w--_ -

7 cme- -- , ,

.:4 ;;; .. - * <

l

., . a. : i *  ;

[

,, CERTIFICATE OF TRANSCRIBER

.This is to certify that the attached events of a meeting of'the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission entitled:

TITLE OF MEETING: AFFIRMATION / DISCUSSION AND VOTE PLACE OF: MEETING: ROCKVILLE, MARYLAND t

'DATE OF MEETING: . SEPTEMBER 11, 1989 were transcribed by me. I further' certify that said transcription is accurate and complete, to the best of my ability, and that the transcript is a true and accurate record of the foregoing events.

v Reporter's name: [ g y -

+

b A

NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBER 5 1323 RHopE ISLAND AVENUE N.W.

(202) 234-4433 ' WASHINGTON. D.C. 20005 (202) 232-6600 l;.' . . .