ML19318B225: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) Created page by program invented by StriderTol |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) StriderTol Bot change |
||
| Line 21: | Line 21: | ||
NWT 160 June 1980 4 | NWT 160 June 1980 4 | ||
NORTH ANNA OPERATIONAL | NORTH ANNA OPERATIONAL | ||
. BACKGROUND CHEMISTRY REVIEW | . BACKGROUND CHEMISTRY REVIEW 1 | ||
(' S. G. Savochka W. L. Pearl C | |||
1 | |||
(' S. G. Savochka W. L. Pearl | |||
C | |||
~ | ~ | ||
!O Prepared for Virginia Electric & Power Company. | !O Prepared for Virginia Electric & Power Company. | ||
| Line 34: | Line 30: | ||
f' 8006250 llt '3 | f' 8006250 llt '3 | ||
r | r i :\ | ||
i :\ | |||
: t. ,.., | : t. ,.., | ||
4 | 4 | ||
. O-This document was prepared for. Virginia | . O-This document was prepared for. Virginia | ||
~ Electric & Power Company.. Weither NkT Corporation nor any person acting on | ~ Electric & Power Company.. Weither NkT Corporation nor any person acting on its behalf assumes .any responsibility | ||
its behalf assumes .any responsibility | |||
, ~ for liability. or damage which may result f, 2 | , ~ for liability. or damage which may result f, 2 | ||
from r.he use of any information disclosed | from r.he use of any information disclosed | ||
| Line 81: | Line 72: | ||
Summa ry : "Of the approximately 1070 tubes inspected in three SG's with , | Summa ry : "Of the approximately 1070 tubes inspected in three SG's with , | ||
the 400 kHz probe, 2 tubes were identified as leakers. | the 400 kHz probe, 2 tubes were identified as leakers. | ||
C, "Approximately 34 percent of the 910 tubes inspected with the 7.5 kHz probe in three SG's indicated support plate / tube intersection corrosion and/or possible ligament cracking. Most of the tubes inspected with the 7.5 kHz probe showed some indication of minor support plate / tube inter-section corrosion. . | C, "Approximately 34 percent of the 910 tubes inspected with the 7.5 kHz probe in three SG's indicated support plate / tube intersection corrosion and/or possible ligament cracking. Most of the tubes inspected with the 7.5 kHz probe showed some indication of minor support plate / tube inter-section corrosion. . | ||
($ "One tube in SG 'C' was found to be slightly restricted in Row 46, column 41. It would pass a 650 mil probe, but not a 700 mil probe. | ($ "One tube in SG 'C' was found to be slightly restricted in Row 46, column 41. It would pass a 650 mil probe, but not a 700 mil probe. | ||
| Line 109: | Line 99: | ||
by the Vepco staff and are summarized in Appendix B.1 i | by the Vepco staff and are summarized in Appendix B.1 i | ||
To further evaluate possible effects of the resin intrusion incident (s) on the North Anna steam generator corrosion, NWT was retained to perform an independent | To further evaluate possible effects of the resin intrusion incident (s) on the North Anna steam generator corrosion, NWT was retained to perform an independent | ||
, review of secondary, system chemistry control at North Anna. Results of this | , review of secondary, system chemistry control at North Anna. Results of this review are presented herein. | ||
review are presented herein. | |||
4 | 4 | ||
.) | .) | ||
| Line 189: | Line 177: | ||
A recorder is provided with the sodium analyzer on the Powdex system effluent e only. Sodium readings f rom the steam genreator blowdown Calgon analyzers are recorded in the dai,1y chemistry logs. | A recorder is provided with the sodium analyzer on the Powdex system effluent e only. Sodium readings f rom the steam genreator blowdown Calgon analyzers are recorded in the dai,1y chemistry logs. | ||
B. Analytical Procedures Routine analyses for pH, cation conductivity, sodium, chloride, boron, silica, ammonia, hydrazine, oxygen, iron and copper are performed for various locations throughout the secondary side (Table 5). Analytical techniques are shown in Table 6. Blowdown analyses for all species except iron and copper are * . | B. Analytical Procedures Routine analyses for pH, cation conductivity, sodium, chloride, boron, silica, ammonia, hydrazine, oxygen, iron and copper are performed for various locations throughout the secondary side (Table 5). Analytical techniques are shown in Table 6. Blowdown analyses for all species except iron and copper are * . | ||
performed daily. Although a detailed review was not perf ormed of calibration techniques, etc., procedurer and analysis frequency appear adequate for - | performed daily. Although a detailed review was not perf ormed of calibration techniques, etc., procedurer and analysis frequency appear adequate for - | ||
monitoring steam generator chemistry. | monitoring steam generator chemistry. | ||
| Line 295: | Line 282: | ||
[i ' -l- 'd i' 4 d# 8 | [i ' -l- 'd i' 4 d# 8 | ||
-N[ | -N[ | ||
il. g g | il. g g | ||
., % i W ' I .y#; L.-. :- | ., % i W ' I .y#; L.-. :- | ||
| Line 396: | Line 382: | ||
g 89:5 / 1.-- ..df ? J' -C"i "El.arY '-' '. E-4d:19F ::sai - | g 89:5 / 1.-- ..df ? J' -C"i "El.arY '-' '. E-4d:19F ::sai - | ||
I | I | ||
=: ..O g , - i -- -gj ;-i :- ig-Kj.3 : 4 :4': ; . cr.. , | =: ..O g , - i -- -gj ;-i :- ig-Kj.3 : 4 :4': ; . cr.. , | ||
Q:t ?:- g --i-9 33 f -- , pc 'i@ ,, i : : ,-p M.}.h tn - Irig g- .!-- | Q:t ?:- g --i-9 33 f -- , pc 'i@ ,, i : : ,-p M.}.h tn - Irig g- .!-- | ||
| Line 652: | Line 637: | ||
0 saJN . | 0 saJN . | ||
U. Q Jic1." | U. Q Jic1." | ||
:ui ;. n. g.-r n2 | :ui ;. n. g.-r n2 p... g.. | ||
p... g.. | |||
- r.- | - r.- | ||
t fll - | t fll - | ||
| Line 736: | Line 719: | ||
';-) ' -i. .!- - !-? .1 . | ';-) ' -i. .!- - !-? .1 . | ||
-r..a*-t s ,y | -r..a*-t s ,y | ||
~ | ~ | ||
.C p-g N: 1: r1 -.i. | .C p-g N: 1: r1 -.i. | ||
| Line 756: | Line 738: | ||
* t" .4 t. | * t" .4 t. | ||
j3 .i. - i. | j3 .i. - i. | ||
.. q.i . | .. q.i . | ||
: i. ,, | : i. ,, | ||
| Line 763: | Line 744: | ||
{ | { | ||
,p - . . | ,p - . . | ||
:.j - :- | :.j - :- | ||
(, :". : .-a . t. | (, :". : .-a . t. | ||
| Line 773: | Line 753: | ||
. -4 : | . -4 : | ||
.; mm J m- .9 - | .; mm J m- .9 - | ||
,- .. t r | ,- .. t r | ||
* r_ b .d 4 i.' | |||
r_ b .d 4 i.' | |||
* . i.: , !:: .-- t J.- ~. i JEi O 'tio ".i; h 55' ". 9: ".Li;' G.T. i.! . .. L'~ | * . i.: , !:: .-- t J.- ~. i JEi O 'tio ".i; h 55' ". 9: ".Li;' G.T. i.! . .. L'~ | ||
- ity"-4 -~i . I1: - T'; :i?- * | - ity"-4 -~i . I1: - T'; :i?- * | ||
| Line 802: | Line 781: | ||
':{.~ '; - | ':{.~ '; - | ||
.i sn -49 :. - -J . .. ! . . | .i sn -49 :. - -J . .. ! . . | ||
O | O L' -: :.- t :[j :. . t f; J? ri , t: | ||
L' -: :.- t :[j :. . t f; J? ri , t: | |||
9t J;.7 n.: -.'"l- :-t : s. F.e . 1. 3: st * 'd | 9t J;.7 n.: -.'"l- :-t : s. F.e . 1. 3: st * 'd | ||
-;' .-e l:- - - - - | -;' .-e l:- - - - - | ||
| Line 869: | Line 846: | ||
.. ..): e, | .. ..): e, | ||
: 4. .- a l. , | : 4. .- a l. , | ||
). f . 4i ,..I.. 5 | ). f . 4i ,..I.. 5 | ||
:{ . . .l ' .j.i; N $ | :{ . . .l ' .j.i; N $ | ||
| Line 939: | Line 915: | ||
: l. . -l ~'T j i; | : l. . -l ~'T j i; | ||
.. ; q.. | .. ; q.. | ||
J-._ n t -$ | J-._ n t -$ | ||
! r. - -t | ! r. - -t | ||
| Line 978: | Line 952: | ||
,a | ,a | ||
- 3:.a. _a. :n .1 -p. | - 3:.a. _a. :n .1 -p. | ||
l- .f nt- | l- .f nt- | ||
,m r hea: s. : : s1. La . -- | ,m r hea: s. : : s1. La . -- | ||
| Line 1,167: | Line 1,140: | ||
4 - | 4 - | ||
1 ._ t ".- j . | 1 ._ t ".- j . | ||
a -.t t .t..- g( | a -.t t .t..- g( | ||
r !- | r !- | ||
| Line 1,195: | Line 1,167: | ||
;- e ., | ;- e ., | ||
.--j 9 a e' . | .--j 9 a e' . | ||
q. | q. | ||
.~ | .~ | ||
| Line 1,273: | Line 1,244: | ||
''* * . 1 M -* 5 "'-1 M . ? -. i.N Id 'O i | ''* * . 1 M -* 5 "'-1 M . ? -. i.N Id 'O i | ||
* 7 * *: r d "S = ' " - - | * 7 * *: r d "S = ' " - - | ||
+: gG. .. + D - % u..i - i i.i .% .-.=. +G =Y:- :.i.: 4 o C .. -M.....-.G.,,.. | +: gG. .. + D - % u..i - i i.i .% .-.=. +G =Y:- :.i.: 4 o C .. -M.....-.G.,,.. | ||
: u 6 w-*-N. i U. .' | : u 6 w-*-N. i U. .' | ||
| Line 1,291: | Line 1,261: | ||
2 c . i%s ,.. JR.. I a [ ' i. . -. ; y ,, e au. . . -4. r-i.-- )r,4 dis _ .. : p- . | 2 c . i%s ,.. JR.. I a [ ' i. . -. ; y ,, e au. . . -4. r-i.-- )r,4 dis _ .. : p- . | ||
gem:. - | gem:. - | ||
; &". 9 .=< | ; &". 9 .=< | ||
2 .p- pri ;p cTim | 2 .p- pri ;p cTim | ||
| Line 1,444: | Line 1,413: | ||
'{. ' | '{. ' | ||
.: . . . L . m . .s .. .'.J"+" | .: . . . L . m . .s .. .'.J"+" | ||
.;s 4,- | .;s 4,- | ||
atu e . . ..: . . i .s .. . . ' *+. .is a . . .s.a. . a s . i . s .t' . | atu e . . ..: . . i .s .. . . ' *+. .is a . . .s.a. . a s . i . s .t' . | ||
| Line 1,531: | Line 1,499: | ||
.-b ' | .-b ' | ||
"- ~+ N- "-4l ah - HI 1 | "- ~+ N- "-4l ah - HI 1 | ||
E | E | ||
,-_ .:_ : .- ,:- ...:. :qJ~- t f; 'q" < | ,-_ .:_ : .- ,:- ...:. :qJ~- t f; 'q" < | ||
| Line 1,575: | Line 1,542: | ||
: 72. . ,:r . | : 72. . ,:r . | ||
u tr. . .s. - . . _ | u tr. . .s. - . . _ | ||
CC | CC m 11 e: .r.} . - | ||
m 11 e: .r.} . - | |||
.i .J - . | .i .J - . | ||
ii ).. .:t :1 . | ii ).. .:t :1 . | ||
| Line 1,595: | Line 1,560: | ||
~ jr'- :-- | ~ jr'- :-- | ||
i | i | ||
.t . | .t . | ||
- 1 3 q g, l 'r 4? | - 1 3 q g, l 'r 4? | ||
.M. . !- . si r) . | .M. . !- . si r) . | ||
| Line 1,722: | Line 1,685: | ||
:5.- :.=r -Gi 2ap ii | :5.- :.=r -Gi 2ap ii | ||
._& -$i j . ; ... g ,, { _ | ._& -$i j . ; ... g ,, { _ | ||
g- jg; e j. , .. p. | g- jg; e j. , .. p. | ||
l ' .~_p | l ' .~_p | ||
| Line 1,800: | Line 1,762: | ||
;;. :c. :V .) . 'T , | ;;. :c. :V .) . 'T , | ||
p-00 | p-00 | ||
:. 3:. . . 'r4 m -- m ..; - | :. 3:. . . 'r4 m -- m ..; - | ||
4 1 | 4 1 | ||
| Line 1,814: | Line 1,775: | ||
s. | s. | ||
4 i: r . us c | 4 i: r . us c | ||
J | J i. | ||
i. | |||
} | } | ||
. . r. . | . . r. . | ||
| Line 1,901: | Line 1,860: | ||
{ | { | ||
N t- . -g 2 7 | N t- . -g 2 7 | ||
u5: p 'ik 8: 2kj = :r s- | u5: p 'ik 8: 2kj = :r s- | ||
\ chy::r:h i | \ chy::r:h i | ||
| Line 1,981: | Line 1,939: | ||
' ,:.: . - y | ' ,:.: . - y | ||
: 2. 12. | : 2. 12. | ||
I' J::J 101 . i-:.1 ga | I' J::J 101 . i-:.1 ga F | ||
W r | |||
~ ; | ~ ; | ||
.r . . :'' "iFi: i:W 3.il:i. vic-O ~~; | .r . . :'' "iFi: i:W 3.il:i. vic-O ~~; | ||
| Line 2,129: | Line 2,086: | ||
p ..I . .i i ,1 .e4 J* ~4 : :L . ..r"~ !. | p ..I . .i i ,1 .e4 J* ~4 : :L . ..r"~ !. | ||
q- a | q- a | ||
;f . | ;f . | ||
'i- - : -n. 44e -.i t. . :. r- , i h | 'i- - : -n. 44e -.i t. . :. r- , i h | ||
| Line 2,182: | Line 2,138: | ||
c.if .1 : =. ! | c.if .1 : =. ! | ||
H c; i; St: | H c; i; St: | ||
.~.2:-ic ," h are | .~.2:-ic ," h are a: ?. a gi. : i-~; :: . L;;:- . '.m. 1 -- | ||
a: ?. a gi. : i-~; :: . L;;:- . '.m. 1 -- | |||
vip .::- -- -;U 6 . h | vip .::- -- -;U 6 . h | ||
.i'-:::- . | .i'-:::- . | ||
| Line 2,227: | Line 2,181: | ||
t r .p- | t r .p- | ||
~ | ~ | ||
g' -H 4~ g | g' -H 4~ g | ||
' s: . | ' s: . | ||
| Line 2,262: | Line 2,215: | ||
L a. _ | L a. _ | ||
.[ | .[ | ||
g . , | g . , | ||
+- x | +- x | ||
| Line 2,380: | Line 2,332: | ||
20 , .- ===. | 20 , .- ===. | ||
_ , = - - . ._,_:_- | _ , = - - . ._,_:_- | ||
.=;= = ,==._r=,. ._ _ _..._ | .=;= = ,==._r=,. ._ _ _..._ | ||
_ _r- A_ = t_=-r. _ : : : . == - =2_ =uc- -_-: ==- :-uz- - == - .=:-._ .m _ . - | _ _r- A_ = t_=-r. _ : : : . == - =2_ =uc- -_-: ==- :-uz- - == - .=:-._ .m _ . - | ||
| Line 2,525: | Line 2,476: | ||
-5= fi-- -Ei Li/.It=lY=it=:!=~E 4i-ihtEt-s =il-l==l:#=hi=: -j'= !M=ti =-} :Er :-i-M i i = =m r h 2 | -5= fi-- -Ei Li/.It=lY=it=:!=~E 4i-ihtEt-s =il-l==l:#=hi=: -j'= !M=ti =-} :Er :-i-M i i = =m r h 2 | ||
}i>i= i;=iFi != - = W= I * =I" = ="~ #- E= 5 iY-5 "i== N= =i W== =NH C 0 = = . -fi .- ;-n=p1= .=j.jj'_gj- = =j:-ij:-[1.ijij.f_rj i_i=.j_2d _=j==;[-j= :: 21=- | }i>i= i;=iFi != - = W= I * =I" = ="~ #- E= 5 iY-5 "i== N= =i W== =NH C 0 = = . -fi .- ;-n=p1= .=j.jj'_gj- = =j:-ij:-[1.ijij.f_rj i_i=.j_2d _=j==;[-j= :: 21=- | ||
--p -.jg=.c=q0-pgi 4iiN .cr Ti ? #--EE.itiMl=s"+=""9=i=%=iq'i IPME! iO =L+6= .5+ ==I+ =-5;i=r._=ia.rr | --p -.jg=.c=q0-pgi 4iiN .cr Ti ? #--EE.itiMl=s"+=""9=i=%=iq'i IPME! iO =L+6= .5+ ==I+ =-5;i=r._=ia.rr | ||
=i5 :-t- O .r is:=-4 # -=+*#E'i.-lM-b=_ . - i i- :=i =ts::E" : - i-- Ih _m..-d=-i="=: - . - - ' | =i5 :-t- O .r is:=-4 # -=+*#E'i.-lM-b=_ . - i i- :=i =ts::E" : - i-- Ih _m..-d=-i="=: - . - - ' | ||
| Line 2,546: | Line 2,496: | ||
'' no sodium increase was observed, this behavior appears to be associated with . | '' no sodium increase was observed, this behavior appears to be associated with . | ||
resin intrusion. That a minor resin intrusion did occur is supported by the plant logs: "Powdex vessel damage when placed io service". W' ith a subsequent power reduction to below 80%, cation conductivity and sodium levels increased simultaneously without any significant change in blowdown pH. This transient 4 (September 12-17) reflects chemical return f rom local regions in the steam generator.. | resin intrusion. That a minor resin intrusion did occur is supported by the plant logs: "Powdex vessel damage when placed io service". W' ith a subsequent power reduction to below 80%, cation conductivity and sodium levels increased simultaneously without any significant change in blowdown pH. This transient 4 (September 12-17) reflects chemical return f rom local regions in the steam generator.. | ||
Based on the available chemistry data, it does not appear that any other significant resin intrusion incidents cccurred during 1979 or 1980 (through March 10). . | Based on the available chemistry data, it does not appear that any other significant resin intrusion incidents cccurred during 1979 or 1980 (through March 10). . | ||
C- In submittals to the NRC, three miner resin intrusions into the steam generator following the February 27 intrusion were reported as having occurred. This observation is consistent with the result of our review if it can be accepted that the July 25 transient was associated with an intrusion. | C- In submittals to the NRC, three miner resin intrusions into the steam generator following the February 27 intrusion were reported as having occurred. This observation is consistent with the result of our review if it can be accepted that the July 25 transient was associated with an intrusion. | ||
| Line 2,564: | Line 2,513: | ||
:. . . . ._ a. _ . .+.. -2. . .m_ ;- _:_.=.+a__ =. .- i _i.=._;=w. . .u. ._ . .;._..=_:- | :. . . . ._ a. _ . .+.. -2. . .m_ ;- _:_.=.+a__ =. .- i _i.=._;=w. . .u. ._ . .;._..=_:- | ||
-t.,g;;_........_._. | -t.,g;;_........_._. | ||
=..F_ PV. "i2.=.= =_-:.!I"!Wi"MWi34=s?MM#d-f:E2 | =..F_ PV. "i2.=.= =_-:.!I"!Wi"MWi34=s?MM#d-f:E2 | ||
.:+. =_:;._ -. i =.=. ,t : | .:+. =_:;._ -. i =.=. ,t : | ||
| Line 2,574: | Line 2,522: | ||
n-- :r== :-=~ r .. =-- - sn . .. ..-:: .- --- =--: =_ =. . . _. .: .: =:- | n-- :r== :-=~ r .. =-- - sn . .. ..-:: .- --- =--: =_ =. . . _. .: .: =:- | ||
r :=:-:--- = = -- ="- .e.==::=._:=. - - =.=====- =:===:~: = = ~: = :' * ::: ;: =..== : =i'~*i | r :=:-:--- = = -- ="- .e.==::=._:=. - - =.=====- =:===:~: = = ~: = :' * ::: ;: =..== : =i'~*i | ||
.. = =_:: . u =. . .=.:.-- | .. = =_:: . u =. . .=.:.-- | ||
.--- - ;* m *-- - - ---- .-- _ .:. = = :_ :..u== r:- | .--- - ;* m *-- - - ---- .-- _ .:. = = :_ :..u== r:- | ||
| Line 2,617: | Line 2,564: | ||
- - = | - - = | ||
g, g,gw==.===.==..=__...=_==.;==_...=___=;=._._m.._:=====----=.=.=;=.,._.;__.=-_.=_=_=._=.__=..__,--3 u _._ . | g, g,gw==.===.==..=__...=_==.;==_...=___=;=._._m.._:=====----=.=.=;=.,._.;__.=-_.=_=_=._=.__=..__,--3 u _._ . | ||
._.:--. __, - - _;-:: .__._.4 | ._.:--. __, - - _;-:: .__._.4 | ||
__.=--=_w__..m. .: | __.=--=_w__..m. .: | ||
| Line 2,631: | Line 2,577: | ||
0.6 _;._-.".-_._..-___u=..=;-_--,,.-___._3__.;--7_---...:::=._._;-.=-.=_.=:n__.;=-._..__._:d | 0.6 _;._-.".-_._..-___u=..=;-_--,,.-___._3__.;--7_---...:::=._._;-.=-.=_.=:n__.;=-._..__._:d | ||
.= | .= | ||
_.u._ =-:._2._ . _ : . . _ . - _ _ . . . . | _.u._ =-:._2._ . _ : . . _ . - _ _ . . . . | ||
. ... - _ ;- -=- .:-- ...__- _a _. _:=.2 | . ... - _ ;- -=- .:-- ...__- _a _. _:=.2 | ||
| Line 2,638: | Line 2,583: | ||
. . - - - - - =.. . . = = . = = - . . - . - | . . - - - - - =.. . . = = . = = - . . - . - | ||
-..._._...=.-==-- _. :_ . - . _ . | -..._._...=.-==-- _. :_ . - . _ . | ||
.=-_=-==--..==5_=_~--~==_:_..----__y-.-y.5__3___7=====.=.--.____--:.._:=~_-___._-=.=- | .=-_=-==--..==5_=_~--~==_:_..----__y-.-y.5__3___7=====.=.--.____--:.._:=~_-___._-=.=- | ||
-_._a._-.- | -_._a._-.- | ||
| Line 2,651: | Line 2,595: | ||
__ __ ;__. .g__:: - _ | __ __ ;__. .g__:: - _ | ||
_._...-_____.---:=_----.===._--.._==.._t | _._...-_____.---:=_----.===._--.._==.._t | ||
__=.-- | __=.-- | ||
ss __. -- ... = _ _ _-- | ss __. -- ... = _ _ _-- | ||
| Line 2,770: | Line 2,713: | ||
== -bb--- | == -bb--- | ||
t o :-' | t o :-' | ||
- - r " '=m- '- - ~-r=~=*==='r=- ;w''=+=r, =-h ; :='= = = 3r-==12 | - - r " '=m- '- - ~-r=~=*==='r=- ;w''=+=r, =-h ; :='= = = 3r-==12 r= =i .i" '==# i=_ _= = m.2 /-2;=-: -- ==. .i-- =_= | ||
r= =i .i" '==# i=_ _= = m.2 /-2;=-: -- ==. .i-- =_= | |||
1- 5 10 15 20 L May 1979 | 1- 5 10 15 20 L May 1979 | ||
: c. Figure 7. Steam Generator A Blowdown Chemistry (May 1979) 27 | : c. Figure 7. Steam Generator A Blowdown Chemistry (May 1979) 27 | ||
| Line 2,816: | Line 2,757: | ||
f' | f' | ||
?. D:.= .=.Es.r_. f. _.f.-'.-~__~..u._ r= N_EE- . - 1. .:^.__ r__Z__ -~._. -- ;_: . - :m:..- -_ . .;;; ;; , _- _- - ._h.7.-"-._.',;y--'---.G_.--:.=..-..._ | ?. D:.= .=.Es.r_. f. _.f.-'.-~__~..u._ r= N_EE- . - 1. .:^.__ r__Z__ -~._. -- ;_: . - :m:..- -_ . .;;; ;; , _- _- - ._h.7.-"-._.',;y--'---.G_.--:.=..-..._ | ||
, ;;1-,,,., ,yw ;= ,__ | , ;;1-,,,., ,yw ;= ,__ | ||
----.__.=;-==--~===--==-:=_:=-====.-yQg =_- :====:=== == = y n 7... _ | ----.__.=;-==--~===--==-:=_:=-====.-yQg =_- :====:=== == = y n 7... _ | ||
| Line 2,854: | Line 2,794: | ||
_ _--.~~'=- | _ _--.~~'=- | ||
( | ( | ||
l _ | l _ | ||
.n.--.___ .._:__._ . d- _. _.._.. cr- _ . _ _ ___ .__ | .n.--.___ .._:__._ . d- _. _.._.. cr- _ . _ _ ___ .__ | ||
| Line 2,891: | Line 2,830: | ||
._._.-.-.-=__._.;;;t=..=._=._=.=..._._ . . | ._._.-.-.-=__._.;;;t=..=._=._=.=..._._ . . | ||
. . = . = . _ = . _ _ . _ . _ . . _ _ . ._ = =. ;4 | . . = . = . _ = . _ _ . _ . _ . . _ _ . ._ = =. ;4 | ||
. _ . _ - . - - _ = = . = _ = _ . = . . _ = _ . =_. -_..._=l | . _ . _ - . - - _ = = . = _ = _ . = . . _ = _ . =_. -_..._=l | ||
.==-_____, | .==-_____, | ||
| Line 2,971: | Line 2,909: | ||
m - | m - | ||
. .a= ---=..:.:. | . .a= ---=..:.:. | ||
2:== _ | 2:== _ | ||
-i-- = - a ;. = - | -i-- = - a ;. = - | ||
| Line 3,033: | Line 2,970: | ||
0.4 _ _ _ , . _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ . __,_._ . _ . _ .__.._ _ _ | 0.4 _ _ _ , . _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ . __,_._ . _ . _ .__.._ _ _ | ||
:_- .:.__.._...---_--m | :_- .:.__.._...---_--m | ||
~ . . | ~ . . | ||
___.___i -- | ___.___i -- | ||
| Line 3,070: | Line 3,006: | ||
.__4_--,- _ _ _ _ -- ~-- | .__4_--,- _ _ _ _ -- ~-- | ||
.a., --,- --_ :-_ . | .a., --,- --_ :-_ . | ||
--w. y j,=i --, -1 | --w. y j,=i --, -1 | ||
== *--~ | == *--~ | ||
| Line 3,081: | Line 3,016: | ||
__.a _3_ .__,! _ _ _ : | __.a _3_ .__,! _ _ _ : | ||
r | r | ||
= __,___ .a__.._,_- ~~ | = __,___ .a__.._,_- ~~ | ||
-M ^ - | -M ^ - | ||
.$.40.1 -, : | .$.40.1 -, : | ||
| Line 3,148: | Line 3,081: | ||
_ .__. ___ _. . . . 2 | _ .__. ___ _. . . . 2 | ||
~ | ~ | ||
c . . . _ . . ,_ | c . . . _ . . ,_ | ||
- - :1 _.__ | - - :1 _.__ | ||
| Line 3,161: | Line 3,093: | ||
e , . | e , . | ||
- v _, h=t_mq_- | - v _, h=t_mq_- | ||
x=4_-r N:~I=h_d_; }}-f_:_ - | x=4_-r N:~I=h_d_; }}-f_:_ - | ||
u - - * ' | u - - * ' | ||
| Line 3,170: | Line 3,101: | ||
_ -=--- =- =z=. _- g --+_t__==-- | _ -=--- =- =z=. _- g --+_t__==-- | ||
=2= == 3 | =2= == 3 | ||
._= | ._= | ||
=}= -!. ._2_-q__=. =3=---- | =}= -!. ._2_-q__=. =3=---- | ||
| Line 3,358: | Line 3,288: | ||
O.02 r ; rt - | O.02 r ; rt - | ||
..r | ..r | ||
--ri ; ; .i @i.t- .". . . r.r-:-- -t - | --ri ; ; .i @i.t- .". . . r.r-:-- -t - | ||
. ' i ; , ,. i t- . ,, , | . ' i ; , ,. i t- . ,, , | ||
| Line 3,394: | Line 3,323: | ||
. s. .] . | . s. .] . | ||
-l . . . . | -l . . . . | ||
}. | }. | ||
j . | j . | ||
i, ; | i, ; | ||
qp. j- : : .a. | qp. j- : : .a. | ||
! ' * . .!. i | ! ' * . .!. i | ||
,....._.'..!._ .$.__._. j- . . . - . a :. _a- | ,....._.'..!._ .$.__._. j- . . . - . a :. _a- | ||
| Line 3,423: | Line 3,350: | ||
zir il:i 't= =i! Resin Intrusion .or . | zir il:i 't= =i! Resin Intrusion .or . | ||
* ... . n.j:":1 . . : .... | * ... . n.j:":1 . . : .... | ||
: n. .;. :. :. . . .i.i i. i. ..*... | : n. .;. :. :. . . .i.i i. i. ..*... | ||
M T ~~'" ~: . - = t* n :;::!;; ; nt:i4:xtr;;p'i= li!!! "i!!" - - | M T ~~'" ~: . - = t* n :;::!;; ; nt:i4:xtr;;p'i= li!!! "i!!" - - | ||
| Line 3,431: | Line 3,357: | ||
Ou iiN!!! | Ou iiN!!! | ||
2ii'i PIiE M ' : !! is di. ' .rliiii: ~ . ]'y - | 2ii'i PIiE M ' : !! is di. ' .rliiii: ~ . ]'y - | ||
= | = | ||
i:i .!jijhl :' uM!F; IE!Qi: - | i:i .!jijhl :' uM!F; IE!Qi: - | ||
| Line 3,481: | Line 3,406: | ||
-= tr | -= tr | ||
=: n | =: n | ||
=, 2;: n.. ;=;Ei:n= _= =:= | =, 2;: n.. ;=;Ei:n= _= =:= | ||
n2= . =: = | n2= . =: = | ||
| Line 3,582: | Line 3,506: | ||
g, __ ..ng. _.; ; -*-.- | g, __ ..ng. _.; ; -*-.- | ||
n ::= = n =;" =!= ,. "=== ;.: r;;;O--~;-a -4;n-= | n ::= = n =;" =!= ,. "=== ;.: r;;;O--~;-a -4;n-= | ||
= r'=== = 'n == | = r'=== = 'n == | ||
~ - ' =: = =l=_= ;=;_. ,i= ~iU r ;.;,n.,;i . .g . . .;.ri= =II:= | ~ - ' =: = =l=_= ;=;_. ,i= ~iU r ;.;,n.,;i . .g . . .;.ri= =II:= | ||
| Line 3,596: | Line 3,519: | ||
. !.C . . . =. !. . .n.. .._}.... | . !.C . . . =. !. . .n.. .._}.... | ||
"*.*.~~.:.. .;.. !I. . :.W. . . . . . ........C . -- _ | "*.*.~~.:.. .;.. !I. . :.W. . . . . . ........C . -- _ | ||
*. j= 2--' n2 .. :!n. J . ";.;.- : | *. j= 2--' n2 .. :!n. J . ";.;.- : | ||
,= : : ;, = ;;::.= n;5n : | ,= : : ;, = ;;::.= n;5n : | ||
| Line 3,641: | Line 3,563: | ||
* M 1;'*: | * M 1;'*: | ||
: ** l :. M $.... ... . . . . | : ** l :. M $.... ... . . . . | ||
] ' .!. ' . . . . - *r.1 ".. n .....'r;: . .". g; . . ? | ] ' .!. ' . . . . - *r.1 ".. n .....'r;: . .". g; . . ? | ||
=...g.. | =...g.. | ||
| Line 3,649: | Line 3,570: | ||
....l.._n..=.. . | ....l.._n..=.. . | ||
ut. =. | ut. =. | ||
: n. . ! . .". .' .." . * =.n. . i. r_.. * :. l x."**-'.u. | : n. . ! . .". .' .." . * =.n. . i. r_.. * :. l x."**-'.u. | ||
..,2: , . . 'n. . ! .::. | ..,2: , . . 'n. . ! .::. | ||
...:= :;r 31 : n t - .4 ... | ...:= :;r 31 : n t - .4 ... | ||
| Line 3,813: | Line 3,731: | ||
1 3. | 1 3. | ||
ii, | ii, | ||
:t g ,f | :t g ,f | ||
\1 \ | \1 \ | ||
6.5 \j _1 (' -) | 6.5 \j _1 (' -) | ||
| Line 3,822: | Line 3,738: | ||
l 3 5 7 8 11 13 15 17 10 21 23 25 27 29 31 DAY OF MONTH t | l 3 5 7 8 11 13 15 17 10 21 23 25 27 29 31 DAY OF MONTH t | ||
( N0 DEL 8INI.'CONDUCTIVITYCUMH0/CM)-SEPTEMSER ISO _._ | ( N0 DEL 8INI.'CONDUCTIVITYCUMH0/CM)-SEPTEMSER ISO _._ | ||
120 , | 120 , | ||
80 n , y se a | 80 n , y se a | ||
Revision as of 16:17, 21 February 2020
| ML19318B225 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | North Anna  |
| Issue date: | 06/30/1980 |
| From: | Pearl W, Sawochka S NWT CORP. |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19318B221 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8006250143 | |
| Download: ML19318B225 (46) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:.-
,L'. .
NWT 160 June 1980 4 NORTH ANNA OPERATIONAL
. BACKGROUND CHEMISTRY REVIEW 1
(' S. G. Savochka W. L. Pearl C
~
!O Prepared for Virginia Electric & Power Company. Purchase Order No. 21139 l . tih n; C0rD0Tation
., 1, W 7015 REALM DRIVE, SAN JOSE, CALIFORNIA 95119 ,
f' 8006250 llt '3
r i :\
- t. ,..,
4
. O-This document was prepared for. Virginia
~ Electric & Power Company.. Weither NkT Corporation nor any person acting on its behalf assumes .any responsibility
, ~ for liability. or damage which may result f, 2 from r.he use of any information disclosed + in this document. , I i j C 4 4. 6 i 4 i c' 9 9 r . C l-t 4 i-l I f- , I I C !
)
t.
..t n
l . c. w- " b r e , ..,-e ae 9 -*gm--f't r F e e- e = eWig%gn3e9 p +w g' q wiwty-y FW ,es vyqg- y 9 +? wye-yM=W,,w g y w
- d. .
+
NORTH ANNA OPERATIONAL BACKGROUND CHEMISTRY REVI N V. BACKGROUND-The North Anna Nuclear Generating Station of Virginia Electric & Power Company. (Vepco) is located on'the southern shore of Lake Anna in Louisa County, Virginia. The plant has been operational since April 1978. The first scheduled refueling outage began on September 25, 1979. During that outage, a routine steam gen-erator inspection was planned. However, extensive support plate corrosion consistent with the early stages of denting, was detected dictating a more 2 extensive inspection (Table 1). Inspection results were as follows , Steam Generator A: 'Wo indications of -tube defects were observed with
> the 400 kHz and 100 kHz EC probes. Approximately 36 percent of the tubes inspected with the 7.5 kHz probe exhibited signs of tube / support plate intersection corrosion and/or possible ligament cracking."
Steam Generator B: 'Wo indications of tube defects were observed with the 400 kHz and 100 kHz EC probes. Almost 16 percent of the tubes in- , (3 spected with the 7.5 kHz probe exhibited support plate corrosion or possible ligament cracking." Steam Generator C: "Two leakers were detected in row 1, columns 50 and 61 in SG 'C'. One restricted tube was detected in row 46, column 41.
~
Approximately 37 percent of tne tubes inspected with the 7.5 kHz probe C. showed indications of support plate corrosion or possible ligament cracking." Summa ry : "Of the approximately 1070 tubes inspected in three SG's with , the 400 kHz probe, 2 tubes were identified as leakers. C, "Approximately 34 percent of the 910 tubes inspected with the 7.5 kHz probe in three SG's indicated support plate / tube intersection corrosion and/or possible ligament cracking. Most of the tubes inspected with the 7.5 kHz probe showed some indication of minor support plate / tube inter-section corrosion. . ($ "One tube in SG 'C' was found to be slightly restricted in Row 46, column 41. It would pass a 650 mil probe, but not a 700 mil probe. Tube nominal ID is 775 mils."
"The extensive inspections performed with the 7.5 kHz EC probe indicated minor corrosion in the tube to support plate annuli. The corrosion (3 observed appears to be the very early stages of the denting phenomenon affecting some other; plants, especially those with salt water cooling."
C/ 1 I
.U f, TABLE 1
. , 'N /
NORTH ANNA UNIT 1 EXPANDED STEAM GENERATOR INSPECTION PROGRAM O Steam
-Cenerator EC Probe Tubes Inspected Indications sj A- 400 kHz* 440 None 100 kHz (diff) 181'(rows 1 & 2) None 7.5 kHz 370 132 ,
C, B 400 kHz 133 None 100 kHz (diff) 88 (row 1) None 100 kHz (abs) 89 (row 1) None 7.5 kHz- 119 19
-C 400 kHz* 480 2 (leakers) 400 kHz 163 (cold leg) None 100 kHz (diff) 178 (rows 1 & 2) 2 (same leakers) f.' 100 kHz (abs) 117 (vicinity of 2 (same leakers) leakers)***
7.5 kHz** 421 155 O ~
- Initial Regulatory Guide Inspection .
** Additional Initial Inspection ;
c ***117 Tbbes Including Leakers Numbers are approxinate and data are still being reviewed. A final report will be issued for retention in etation records. . O O' v
' i;, N p7
. \<
In light of the eddy current observations, several reviews of secondary chemistry at North Anna were performed, and recommendations solicited from Westinghouse relative to a future course of action. A major conclusion of the reviews was that the corrosion attack probably was related to an ingress of powdered resin' into the steam generators from the condensate filters. This incident is described in Appendix A.1 Chemistry ef fects of the resin intrusion and the major findings of a Westinghouse data review subsequently were addressed 4 . by the Vepco staff and are summarized in Appendix B.1 i To further evaluate possible effects of the resin intrusion incident (s) on the North Anna steam generator corrosion, NWT was retained to perform an independent
, review of secondary, system chemistry control at North Anna. Results of this review are presented herein.
4
.)
i i C' i e d l 4's S
~
g
.(/
(, PC r,
, SYSTEM DESIGN AND DESCRIPTION North Anna Unit 1 is a 907 MWe Westinghouse PWR with 3 U-tubed steam generators.
Tubes are Alloy 600, and support plates are drilled carbon steel. The plant was Condenser cooling water is engineered and constructed by Stone & Webster. taken from Lake Anna. The water is of high quality (Table 2), but it is relatively rich in sulfate. A schematic of the secondary system is shown in Figure 1. The condenser is tubed with stainless steel. Hg.ater tubing materials are as follows: , 1st point 80/20 CuNi 2nd point 90/10 CuNi 3rd point Arsenical Admiralty 4th point Arsenical Admiralty 5th point Arsenical Admiralty 6th point Arsenical Admiralty Air Ejector 304 Stainless (316 stainless no-zles) Condenser 304 Stainless Gland Steam 90/10 CuNi Ci Three half capacity condensate pumps draw from two hotwells. Until the 1980 startup, the condensate was processed through Graver powdered resin filters. Because of the possibility that resin leakage was associated with the steam sa
~
generator corrosion detected in 1979, the filters currently are bypassed. Each filter vessel has 420 non-segmented polypropylene septums. ' Specific flowrate is approximately 3 gpm/f t2 Typically, filters are precoated with 6 bags of hydrogen form cation resin, 5 bags of ammonium form cation resin and 6 bags of hydroxide form anion esin (cation to anion dry weight ratio of 3:1 and total dry precoat weight of 296 lbs). A precoat (V/V)5 f 50% 15% is sought during normal operation. Tighter v. precoats are employed during startups or transients (increased " Solution A") . Ecodex, a f tFer-resin mixture, also has been employed during startups. This gives improved suspended solids removal but higher differential pressure drops. i 4
r'
- e r.; q. c, C C li .
, Moisture A HP Turbine Separator
.\ / / Reheater (4) LP Turbines
>v O x 7 B/ '
_J
+
v s / N -- N/ N / N / N
> /
.L )! 1l )f V Steam Generators MS Drain
[ Tank
\
l I Reheater Drains l V Condensate g g Pumps u v 9 Heater Drain Tank I V V
~
- lA 6A
}A B C D E 2A F 3A -
4A - - SA - - y y Powdex Filters 1B - 2B E 3B - 4B - - SB - 6B -- d h Air Ejectors d V Flash Gland Evaporator Steam Condenser Pumps Figure 1. North Anna Secondary System Schematic k e
. . ., -s -
g p O-Q O %
. s
. =-
. TABLE 1 NORTH ANNA VATER CHDt1STRY Calcium Hannesium Hardness. Bicarbonate ChloEide Sulfate Silica Suspended Solide Copper Iron Date pas pra ope as CACO 3
ppm pra ppm ppm ppm _ pra y
- Phosphateppm Mitrate ppm Conductivity, pahos/cm 1 9/28/78 5. 2 20- 20 3.7 5 , 0.15 . <0.05 7.2 11/1 5 2 20 3 10 4.4 5 <0.05 0.25 <0.05 7.1 11/3 5.12 2.05 3.5 5.35 0.01 0.37 12/4 5 2 22 18 3.0 10 5.0 . <5 <0 '. 0 5 0.30 <0.05 71 6.8 12/4 5.12 2.04 -
2.5 . 5.88 0.01 0.26 1/2/79 5 3 26 20 3.4 10 4.1 15 <0.05 0.30 <0.05 -70 7.1
. , 1/2 5.25 2.08 3.5 12.5- 4.28 0.01- 0.24 0.181 7.g 2/6 4 2 18 14 3.3 10 4.8 <3 <0.05 0.15 0.05 '60 7.2 2/6 4.88 1.96 2.75 9.5 0.75 0.01 0.14 0.028 67 7.26 3/1 6.88 1.80 3.13 7.3 0.22 0.02 0.76 0.174 65 6.22 3/15 2 4 20 14 3.2 10 6.2 10 <0.05 0.20 0.05 1.7 56 6.7 4/2 2.4 . 1.92 3.0 14 3.75 0.01 0.21 2.30 7.1 5/3 4.12 1.71 2.25' 8.3 0.25 0.01 0.34 55 6.92 6/1 4.51 3.25 7.5 0.30 0.01 0.26 0.292 55.5 7.57 7/3 5 4 28 ,
22 3.5 10 3.7 <3 <0.05 0.25 < 0.0 5- 0.9 59 7.1 7/5 4.52 2.99 7.5 3.02 0.004 0.43 0.307 58 7.61
- {
f a
U
\ / ,
C: CllEMISTRY MONITORING A. Continuous Monitoring Instrumentation Secondary cycle in-line chemistry _ monitors are listed in Tabic 3. Table 4 lists the instrument manufacturer and range. Cation conductivity is recorded for the steam generator blowdown, condensate, and Powdex system effluent. A recorder is provided with the sodium analyzer on the Powdex system effluent e only. Sodium readings f rom the steam genreator blowdown Calgon analyzers are recorded in the dai,1y chemistry logs. B. Analytical Procedures Routine analyses for pH, cation conductivity, sodium, chloride, boron, silica, ammonia, hydrazine, oxygen, iron and copper are performed for various locations throughout the secondary side (Table 5). Analytical techniques are shown in Table 6. Blowdown analyses for all species except iron and copper are * . performed daily. Although a detailed review was not perf ormed of calibration techniques, etc., procedurer and analysis frequency appear adequate for - monitoring steam generator chemistry. I' C. Specifications i Current secondary system operating guidelines for condensate, feedwater and , steam generator blowdown are shown in Table 7 for operation with and without c, boric acid. The only dif ference between the two guidelines is ph, and of course, boron concentration in the generator. , t 7 F
. l
- ss
, s .
IN-LINE CHEMISTRY MEASUREMENTS - SECONDARY CYCLE t' Dis::olved Oxygen Sodium Sample gli Specific Cation
,, S/G Blowdown X N XR X X A, B, and C XR XR X X Condensate X XR N X N Feedwater X XR N XR Powdex Effluent X- N X = Analyzer .
R = Recorder
. N = none U
- TABLE 4 SECONDARY CYCLE CHEMISTRY INSTRUFENTATION Variable Analyzer Range c,
Dissolved Oxygen , Hays 0-100 ppb S cif a d Catio.: Leeds & Northrup* 0-10 pahos S dium Calgon 2000 i l-100 ppb C)
- Exception - Secondary Demineralizer Beckman Solu-meter 0 to 1.0 pahos O
O ! g 8
.t ; .
W
$f TABLE 5
,, \ /
STEAM SIDE LABORATORY ANALYSIS ( Location Parameter Frequen_cy Steam Generator Blowdown pH Daily Conductivity Daily j Cation Conductivity Daily Sodium Daily Chloride Daily Boron Daily (. Silica . Daily Ammonia Daily - Hydrazine Daily Oxygen- Daily Fe/Cu Monday Feedwater pH Daily Conductivity Daily . O , Cation Conductivity Daily Ammonia Daily Hydrazine Daily Silica Daily O Oxygen Daily Fe/Cu Monday Condensate pH Daily Conductivity i Daily O' Cation Conductivity Daily Sodium ' Daily Ammonia Daily Hydrazine Daily Silica Daily Chloride, Daily Fe/Cu Monday
. c, Main Steam pH Wednesday Conductivity Wednesday Ammonia Wednesday Silica Wednesday Sodium Wednesday
(. 9
21' TABLE 5 (cont) t' a Parameter Frequency
' Location Daily Powdex Effluent Sodium Silica Mon., Wed., Fri.
- Fe and Cu Monday pH Daily Flash Evaporator Dist, Conductivity Daily Daily Chloride / Fluoride
- c. Daily Sodium .
Daily .
-Silica Flash Evaporator Demin. Out. pH Daily Conductivity Daily Daily Silica Daily Sodium Daily Chloride / Fluoride ,
i' pH Daily Brine Conductivity Daily Other Secondary Bearing Cooling As required Service Water Reservoir As required
.(. ,
As required Air Conditioning, etc. 5 li ! o l l t e 10 p _,
s, 4 v s aI TABLE 6
,, /
NORTH ANNA ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY PROCEDURES G W Species _ Technique
. Ananonia Nesslerization Chloride Met. ric thiocyanate Conductivity Wheatstone Bridge Fluoride Specific Ion Electrode Oxygen Iridigo Carmine or Winkler pH Electrode Suspended Solids Filtration 2
Dissolved Solids Evaporation .*
- 3 Soluble Silica Anunoniu:n Molybdate .
9 5 0 O 9 j il
-' 11 l l
1
. f:
}
TABLE 7 1
- WESTINGHOUSE SECONDARY . SYSTEM CHEMISTRY AVT OPERATING GUIDELINES FOR NORTH ANNA UNIT 1 Without Boric Acid With Boric Acid Condensate Oxygen, ppb <10 <10 Feedwater pH, @ 25'C- 8.8 - 9.2 >8.0 Conductivity, umhos 1.8 - 5.0 <5 0xygen, ppb <1 <5 Hydrazine, ppb [0 2] + >10 [02)+ >10 Ammonia, ppm <0.5 <0.5 Steam Generator AVT Chemistry Guidelines
, In the Absence of In the Presence of Locatable Condenser Leakage Locatable Condenser Leakage Without With Without 2 With " 3 Parameter- Boric Acid Boric Acid Boric Acid Boric Acid
,H @'25*C $8.5 >7.0 >8.5 >7.0 Cation Conductivity 2.0
<2.0 <2.0 2.0 pahos/cm @ 25 C ,
O Boron, ppm NA 5-10 NA 5-10 Sodium, ppm <0.04 <0.04 0.1 0.1 Chloride, ppm <0.05 <0.05 0.15 0.15 . Oxygen, ppb <5 <5 <5 <5
- 8.' Hydrazine, ppb [02] + > 20 [02) + "20
[0 2] + > 20 [023 + "20 Ammonia, ppm >0.06 >0.06 >0.06 . >0.06 Silica, ppm <0.05 <0.05 0.05 0.05 Blowdown, gpm - Continuous Continuous Continuous Continuous G
- 1. Continuous overboard at air ejector drains.
- 2. Continued operation with locatable contaminant ingress is not recommended.
4 M 3. Operate at the minimum continuous blewdown rate required to natain continuous monitoring capability, approximately 5 spm/SG.
- 4. Blowdown continuocaly at a rate required to maintain chemistry parameters.
. tr ,
12
Q
, ./
e SECONDARY SYSTEM CHEMISTRY Because of the possible effects of resin intrusion on steam generator corrosion, and the several such incidents reported at North Anna, a brief summary of resin ingress effects on blowdown chemistry is warranted. Cation resin, which is a sulfonated polystyrenc/divinylbenzene copolymer, decomposes to yield sulfuric acid as an end product. Therefore, as a resttle
" of cation resin ingress, a depression in steam generator pH will occur concurrent with an increase in cation conductivity reflecting the formation of sulfate ion. During anion resin ingress, tertiary amines, methyl alcohol, and a variety of other organic compounds are formed. These decomposition products generally .m ^
can be considered volatile, i.e., they are steam distilled from the steam generator. Decomposition of the polystyrene /divinylbenzene matrix also occurs leading to f ormation of a variety of aliphatic and aromatic organics. These cowpounds also should volatilize and have a negligible long term impact on U, steam generator chemistry. Recent data on resin decomposition at steam generator operating conditions (collected by Combustion Engineering and Battell'e Northwest under EPRI i( contract) are consistent with the above general description of the decom-position process. Based on this description, the expected effect of resin ingres- should be a rapid decrease in pH and an increase of cation conductivity. No major change in sodium or chloride level is expected unicss significant resin exhaustion to cooling water contaminants has occurred prior to the ingress. Thus, the concurrent variation of blowdown pH, cation conductivity, and sodium level- can be used to distinguish probable resin intrusion incidents from those caused by other factors. Steam generator A blowdown chemistry for 1978, 1979 and 1980 is shown in Figures 2A through 2C, respectively. Similar data for generator B blowdown is shown in Figures 3A through 3C and for generator C in Figures 4A through 4C. C'- Chemistry during April /May 1978 was not evaluated in detail because of , the unstable power pattern; as such, minor resin intrusion incidents could 13 v,
- e
[i ' -l- 'd i' 4 d# 8
-N[
il. g g
., % i W ' I .y#; L.-. :-
I---- --mO:I,
- s. .
Q.b '
- F M": ' \:
t, e-
?__ r3 * ! p t 3 6
es a- . J:; -
. j; i i. r.
n, ,. -s. ' a : at ,
,I r
n.-
, ;* .,. .i .
l )e s
;- r.Cs 9. + I : ( t. *i
. .: .to,, .i #
I f rd'*'
- i i$ 1 > N r g &f: .J$> 5- .^
-fi. , , 5 . .y. . //.J r a
l: 4 M (I=.:.4
- t. -T-
.-1
,e e
f: 1i t ,
,[
-.9. . is- t
+.
+t -
g It;: i - !%g.a p i-. *- .--- - i - - a
;a g -. y r- .i -i._&-
a f. J.-.p . i
- i. . Mn .
- .g ,
ai ui r- ' ) ::
'. . p i.
- .m p ,i . -Q o- . c,' ,j a .h . ? C JC' H -'i-[Y .) FN j + :I -. - - '
4i' b '" d
- iITNE, :a **.jf E -)- ; Ch i- . . ;i - - --
^; . ,
M.f Jgy: {p g.3
*j -t ,y
)
, ~
*; ,Q Le .s .- ' ::s 1A,1. 1 ,
- u-
_ . .:' g T
- ! = -
r.- -11 .. fj., -- i - t-Q u+- Q.: "r . .
'N v ~ a ---c._; _
a..! . 3 i i -g a ? _ : t @, .o e ~t 9: E
, M:* i. -
>ji
.a.
;:: .=.J -
F.. .L? . J T ..i : 4" -
- i. J'- ^l i -j i" ' -I-
- fi : _ ir:. i. !:- . e .. l .id !: : t mi-rf -i.g
_-j 9 g i .t i . !%. ig-- i 3, EIH _ . .Q .Y.r+at . t: f[ g <_:p :-ir :. '.l . : 1 ,!
.% " " -j ' . i- j*
[~ .ns_ .:- - +-
.
- 2-(i ! - p. i- !.kfl gr---i .--r i .c -
i:Nh: 2 j-t' -
- ? w i i?- er %f;*pai i e.: 41 - - -
-h >
- .I* d.b- -O 6Dv .i~ :- Nm i 3 31? M :- "' f W I.T .:l.'i{%'. Oi ih :.:;p u!) (". L: . h
@$ u.! - .211 : - 7 e . .
~( . _.
, r, . u
- c.t . : t :, L. a. ,: - j r.- , :; . .
AO 4. 1. g- - , _s _ . . _ .y m
.s 71- .I .r4 ,
y . . - - '
':.i.p-.:. : K.T.p a. .i : 'Y. u_,,rd., - edi..: . -.-- i '.i; . gtf ..
_R_- ,. ,f ~. a. r % - ,g _ ' -i M. ;4 e g - .
. i.Nt N.~ 'l. ai.. 9qos 4 .. 17 8% ,
.c F;i== f i:.hD ,; -y - SC W -42b: 9- mim. X. - 1.F . ,
- s : - y .- -
& ).W:.! . : .sdTys . . i. .: . ... Y ] _u. 3 -Q.=V. .pi d. ..: . h ..
5' -.::ij.]:
~
'~h..-- _'.a='"* @ . :i: .
- u.- .CQ.Jj .i.i .:.,p.i;:[:
. . - .1. . .
-Q . p- : [e -
j -1 - f O g .. ..
- M-3" _ j __
g 89:5 / 1.-- ..df ? J' -C"i "El.arY '-' '. E-4d:19F ::sai - I
=: ..O g , - i -- -gj ;-i :- ig-Kj.3 : 4 :4': ; . cr.. ,
Q:t ?:- g --i-9 33 f -- , pc 'i@ ,, i : : ,-p M.}.h tn - Irig g- .!--
'~
- 4 ':g*
y:th y iau:.:gAcr-m W YL-- : .m .-~~M 3g ht: - -: a n= . :~r( .1 %%. .g- , m 2.ifW A -- n ..% - Q-',3 - M cd: . ..ivgi-- :ii- - i 1-:.- : :: :
-:r-" r+- d .
q:.tl in
!3 -.r:
i:
- ---S --: - tt- :i ' - , ,
g " i.h.lC
- 9; y3:.g'. r-. i' H' :i p.?.3 i iQ .U.-It4r7 . gtv-h J.J -
r - .-- $-Q
.- siM f- - -f ; .
7
,y
' u 4'd J -
lil i : u'
--M-if, . t:% kt' - @@ W @ :'L ; 'i' ' , y ec
~
if d .-g i =. :.:Tr -- - -tr % ;, - d! - .l '. . J ;p-).:,4.r - 10 29 Q-j ' r-
' ~
*h (e
-i- -- fN: ^r:
[p--' -4.::4 . :r. : a @,f F.i .J.
-- -P. , . u Q ,
cap- --y o ---
. w-- :q - r- qet: . .b 4 6 ..e .t - - - - =
U
- =p.1- . rp - - - - -
;. _ r :: - - .
-; __ - -:.Li ' :{j jh .:!"~IC h ?] Si!?
g # :.;y.;.g a j :.:.i
. pi _.I- .- E!
-li iM:' L '.fp up... i: 2f- i:Fi - ,
- JdQ*lhil +M? lM N -hies I ." " 'M:
l OY3- P M ' CWI u h I - :.17 - -t .i : :< 9- ": x: O E-1.- - _- pk. a..f Q ^;q ' .if-I. Y ~~~'-
-hh lE: . Q '!.:d k W.h - .
hi -
.}
JJ -: 'O.f
. ,-Wil r'j' QL --12T 6 ' UW - 'T - -> d !N : 4 -- .' ,
a : -- qtj'.V i. - . s.hG.;- - r Q. O '. j.- .,' {, r - 6 i.1 .( < N
. g -. . .g.. -.F _ . 3p : .1 , ' qw.e. Q,: ,
.. i. : ~,:. .g - _
.A. .. ,
_E7 . . _
.gl .
^ : .1 '. J.i _n . . . .a i : k} : .2 ..i .;. g
- 1. . -
.+- 1.. .(.-. t t
U g' 2
-.. c.o t
. . . . . 4 .i. p '
(,' ' 4:, , . -.
- Q .. ; 3 [_. .j . .
4: [ c.'
- ..L: :b ..
x ; :.b L
. .p;g .-
i t .:_ ;... .. .._: . .. ... . _ .
~
c t : r- : 4 :;g
.: q ._ -
i ..
..i.-
p _j.. - I
- -4 .
-i:
a v.s- v: m 6 - 1, . i r;
.1 - r +- i? .
(;
- i.
, l-y a
e
.'- ~}!.- ds c . .I .- u
- a. . -. . a ..
;. .f :"'-~ g.:
, .. .- -g t -
f.
- 1.:
[ :91 1 r-1 u . . :.i : .O. : [. .i. f: ___. r
-@ r!m_. c d j
'T]4a.
, -i.
2: e i b.* ' . a;. .;e 1 p .; ' ; f 3 m 4. v .... a c g l 3 I - 4' P e: ' f'
- j: . F i-t2 : -
q-
- ';,
- t.
g o a C o o S
*
- 9 k e
O. 8
- R o o o o add *t3uossey add *enipos ,
gd
- Lap 12xpues m>)3 3 14
- I i /
1.:9 i -1.i !
~
3 - .i - Q- i: l '
-l; :i 9 I
l t + . : i f l .: i : p ; -- j p 4. s J. s- :a s...i. ! [ [ .
~ f. I '.! .i !:
.. i. . i- ,
j .1 .s s .1 i. 1. I s:
..: .sQ .e- .,
. t: ne ,e t- -r - ! i j i
' -c.-
;.. .s: e.U: .s: ghf .s . : . r. .i.. :. .. ; .-l i.:: . :- .i >
- r .. s.:- .: n , -i w
~ .. s:
- - -.- :--} - . .I
..:s-h l w! - t: -
$ twil:- : M.i:;. : . i-
- d .c .:: :- La U.s m 9:. ; it -l : .:4 1 ri ( '
[ { . u. : .3 '12. Q1 . ..:gr . .ij . .. a_ j .i . . :_! . ,. ' ; .j [ - a; . l. r.4.-. . l .: . ,
,. 2.:; c: -. 8
;a =-
Li p - -- j . . *
. :-i ' -.r-- ni. - rj: -
..- t. = r . i:= . l -te-t. -
".Y. EN N .'i.y-: .*_[-
- ? :*r N - .~.'i- +-i. =-... -jd. -i. ~.2i .. !? g 4 f. .. -
f ' 1.:14 ~.*. .i N . *..:. -
; E fi iF- E ri- i s t 'i-g "j9 ri.- r. -
=-i';p s... f i- -:i- : v - -4 r.i -im. s :-:W ; -
'..:- -4.5 .- .f : t : ".r ur i.:n: ..s i - : 1 > p:.a_ j Afitf. .'-+ .~ r :.- .:. - . .:-it? rm.-
==:iu .je =ru - .c.;-in i' n- hi '8di-'i.in . '; i _:. 1: 4. . ;- vr.m
}
{ uia idruh ii. .- .ra: * .:h: " il P 4 :;. .. -t e t .: 'r .W
--y .= :.i.i n p J r-f m E- _4. -e. . :-!%: 1. --i::-- . -( i + bl . , ,
-l :is:. --h ::. t :.:s; a.k : a %. j. u. an i i nf:1 ~
7.:i r:- Di:-id.;: .=:1 ..: .;.sia:f
- r-j
- -:. - .3 3.w yr:44 1.rt :uimj rn :i: : :. ' 3 g :: .j j : ,
'^
.: 6 - +i - i t--chi ': .4:fh 3 +Mpha ;-- q.r 4. i c;,,.,,gt MM-d:& -2 :4M 4 i..i -c-i-di :, u i i&;* ;;
- C d"i :W, [
rii s:W: I, r-1:-J =-rW U ';"- :- - "J . .y N::N%e . : :i: 7 ~-*Q' - S # i h
- i*:Ci 15gr L.pJ- h; --i@6.E " : jf=i" ;.=Q.s irj:d4.i-p.1;--j 4i - iti.i {.j:f FiCr ,
..=
- 2.jJ_ ta-Q.i :-j.7: U d.i'iir-b -.% i =-2: dit.'
~M' --
y
"-{J . 7:=i cys a_ . ::-i@',, :nH n- j;I' E- :i-ilei" ild's:il h i3t i.!
- i Zlld'. ,
i:8:5f.[[iii ***-if ~;i EU ii:MII.y"5 diLfjhD'll .
~A~3*- LiC-i i MU ~i I5 4-? 8 C.S c rd l- -T :i"'2 n N i~j 3-iTI-i K =--
g i@iiE' (h_* - hdlE i
-a:-54pt: .al,is,:f?.d: :0!:n... if u. 1 -- d%J nri y ai : -+ :i- q j g
g f.;f .:$ 9
~: qe " .L Q ~ - - :- u .. g . Q . ' i' ^ : ' "i - :!
' .s (,)
% M;i= f tibi+ "U -i , != = in :-
{ . =EiniHb W -4==& :-GO-En -'== s:n, ry,,;1 +, t .e.;-w;.;ir_u:: ;r - c..c e,y.. ai. ... - -T - .g.p . '!f r a. 2-i 9 m-
^ -
5 .... .T. 2: .h' :f- . . . . ~ j C .' _ - . . . . .n M. F. . }'.: '( d...i M: g g
;._ -%- g c. -QM . .e.~ n s.;; -.:pn.13h! .- -t; :- - -ri r-j. ::t:-l a -- :4 :.c h
.-h. -i MQ.h.9'pi g y:-j.l.-i td5idi'.ii - .2.i : tcM.29 ~-: : -) - tu - .*
.t-$ iM F i !"- -N 2.Y*.' 'i'ilr i). 4 J.-! ; .% I .lill.'. . :- n -
, N . 'i' -
- -j" ' E!
Eh5 di.C :4 L -d g 4 n 'Istidhpi ? :'.UJ'- Ul: :-ari~b Q Ieriu- =i ,
- i='-, i i'd':: ' $fgtr:.!!:* a ..!
9
;E:i.-i J :
i r"QQ: f. : n:-- =p *-i= 4 :PQ d :S :.] . ngpMp; . =: pr:
,,. O
- ri- : h Qgu 4-- i ;- = 4 -- - &qi . . w'L, Y =.ru% r:} . it rQ:- .: -ihy--
--g.) f=C '.T=i ;-- m :.-: p, b. :L- .; i-- .i _:.q i. g
@ M -M. * -!:r:.= ~.% : -
i -jf'r - :P. :. - : d *"=M -i F 4;r hE $ f 9.-W-. ?.Q' ;--MM"'"dM.i-T-- c re ._
- -~ :- t :.: : . -), . . . . .e,n- -: . a *=
7
$Cl ::! - W:-~ r=
~
T --b.7 '$ U! 5 : : d.;- !4.= 4 -i i ,
- e
- @y :t:. .. y: :k.,' ~-
^
.a i::
a&{@r u &&W V d:u .r: li(l-- Ji-j - pi */:
'y~h!Mh r3;* l[k,j, c. 3 !i'jj .l- g.p.! p-H .-ij:.* gi*
W . U: C- UtYbb 3i3 'ini T ; --!i ri _ ::l .aD,.NFi 'I E- {- l' . < = rie . i: r h (. g e iM9 .d.! 26_ '.!-A v 4FO . .i:9. .: $ i- -MY n4-~ M
--27% .. :4:q r--gydai-i.-C T q.y .:.
, .tii .
pr : -- t J.- ." NN"'[h""
-cer : t .
l1
$ -i: .e.G u ."j!'n j 2:giu-y.I: j-G-} :s :n Q-. f.%.
. +~.::L ::! :::,
l [.
~ inn. d%i2jiIP'lhi: -!. -.C.i .!: X:E .a- N r.; is f:; ..j- aj id- ; Jff. .Q: *
' M * ~"; :* .- .MM 2 -ii% Oi 1: . :2 " : -
. ' Juhu# -- '
il f Fi- g 7 3i- -: --
- .m:N-d .2.jQ.. lit 9 2.h .u. . ahi; 2. .i:1.:C u
. :. j. C. 2.T .Kl.'; . -* ; m- - J.}. .:. .ih .-Z .- L. :p41. ;J:iq 1- -
251au { C, ( w e-h- a
- a. -
e.n -
=i- ne .stre ima : ..r.tedi ,. .4:re : yr --
- r =: +.2== -[ b a
.-613 ._ . Lit.; .~= ?j:: 'd : [ir -h
. -O ."?
. : .f. ' ~-
..J
'.h d.:T7:- dH p. xg :u .u.
;$O .: 7.'.:i'. .:pF h hi* h i %
. d. MI_ N:1 -ilii - 2f rj }
g m-"' 9 21 i i
'th',
- i. 4 .
0 saJN . U. Q Jic1."
- ui ;. n. g.-r n2 p... g..
- r.-
t fll - _. ,--- s t
- 2.-
- - 4, . .r~. .
.. b.: %.
-. .-1'- i ---- . :.
.f ;& . m {g.,, .
y I* - - g
.$ s . .-A 3 --t t- i H "---b
/.Q> {- - 1%~ -+ i-{
p ' d6 +- ' -i > -+--
% idf . QC.----f--S !
ON:O- . M!dN'__t
- ^! '_f I --
g y .- r,._ ;P-t .WQ F- %4 u y - l t-
. .l . - -
.g.- _.y 1 q(. .,.: .. . :. . ..J-
. i k ._ c ,g
_+ Q^@.:
- i. :
t g 6
!r_.1 - - [, My% $. M ::.'%gf l u ]; -
.:.g , -- .pv: 3
;u al- v"g.r-g
- i! . :q - . h3 .,.
i ;-
~
.:l(m yi -
-51 g:} gb ' I ' C-r.D l
U
- i- P
.;,j ,_gi - t Ii
- i:
t d-ft
- 4. i-i ..I ,1 i ., ' . p 1 , ,
F 4 i .. W! i ]~T /r@ . l 4 +. u t
'4I.D OM-K . t y .;. .h. !. l--
id' Y <- i - ' - .; ,t.:lf-DH e l :
-!- # l- F' --
n4=: o g o- o o, *- * *
. *: o O g .g o e +e
$ d d t/
add *.ntpos us/sogun 3 *aenog 3d med *e}ueeuy 15 mun=ruevnn .
- k I
.r * '*rv' e + e l t t s s-9 f i. .
-.4 .,.-.
I t t i e, g
. s.I ls s a: .( r 3 3 ,
t t .- t i I ) l i i l j.? .t I t i,4- I t ! i a.
- s. s .:
- g .; l l l 6, i e t
,1 . r .: y . s i ( , t-)
..:. i . .. i. -
ji .
- s l l l
%- e ;. < , .; i. : u i i -J_ i.. r 4 p: .
- t. :p9 s- i. e y -i- --i ;. . ,
}
{,1 -j. t- a
.6- g' + .x- s "t 4 Sn 1
.i .4 F ". : % .i- =~s .l..s
.j .
..ia al '
- i. .. i - . - . -
.i i :.. ! . :: .[ . t . t
. .: a .i: , <f a
-1 :i.
^ i:' l I ' l ' I ;*
i :!'. a v: !.l.. .li* 'T' ~
- [; .-i ':
g -j2 'i; 6- d- : :- :ia ... : i- . l: ? -- I - L.
';-) ' -i. .!- - !-? .1 .
-r..a*-t s ,y
~
.C p-g N: 1: r1 -.i.
g, -p- .p. .i-
.i . 7- ,
"; }
g!. ;e .
. ;. .y i : .:.
{ "' H.?' i..).u 'd - ) . i.: -- i :.r 4 . j. b !
- . } - l t .p .. ) . ..f-
'i .!.
, "-r . .j . *i - ..i.
.a. ..
.a d .. -.c s . ) : ..i ., .}. p :.( . .t._
' 3 .-*
l.
~3"- tr-'-- ] '
;rr . .) ,:. l .
- t" .4 t.
j3 .i. - i.
.. q.i .
- i. ,,
_p . s . .. g , ,. . .., ..p. .
-i -) f-
{
,p - . .
- .j - :-
(, :". : .-a . t.
-d
- i'.
4
~} t .Ja -i*". f. .f f' c.- F . - } ~. .g.- 4 . $: e;- t -
--4 .i. : 2 -t : ;: e i-: ,
. -4 :
.; mm J m- .9 -
,- .. t r
- r_ b .d 4 i.'
* . i.: , !:: .-- t J.- ~. i JEi O 'tio ".i; h 55' ". 9: ".Li;' G.T. i.! . .. L'~
- ity"-4 -~i . I1: - T'; :i?- *
. p .:- .: .i- - j.: * -
^
-i-. 'is f h
k
- i. ' * . - h..e . .: ; ? .u..i. .
5 M
^ -rJ. .H. ' 1. h J. ,
c.a p.. ..- j 7 - ::t : :a. 1 T- '.3, 4 -' 'p
- - .tv .~j . .
yF ') (I~I~i- '
.-t .l3
.-i t . Lh5 -
- ; .: :f . i+ r ,.
- bif '
, [ y
- '.s :. . ::n -i : 73- :1. . .i. l Q
- .! . '. a i -
- T. .i.V.: ti i 2. .
Hi~ .! Op, 9} ' t; :. f '
'f; y .:l. . ; ,
':{.~ '; -
.i sn -49 :. - -J . .. ! . .
O L' -: :.- t :[j :. . t f; J? ri , t: 9t J;.7 n.: -.'"l- :-t : s. F.e . 1. 3: st * 'd
-;' .-e l:- - - - -
. .ii :
,) i O. "
E ag -
. .i-. .. i Q- di. 3 j ,, - ,
p;; y . gt - t: -if ..j -f . ;
= '- ;--
~ s :- : ?j- :- + 1 s-A ar 4: .;t b.; . -* t a j .. p: . . : :. .i:=- . i^Q=- vs.:q i -- .
N ai.. ..s; . .Q:.- - ::U-: r{ - W j .k--- ~s - .s Tla .j : -) :: . : t.. -
+ jr (l:
7gt 3;4 : T .;
;: 4 5.i -i-t et.. j .c 1- - . . ,.
.,f+ q: 4- . i. -: .: y . ~2 r.f. . 'ii-- =::"y jy v c: . i- - t? ,
y
..'%r r : :.-t h- ; j. : . g O
- - _::$.; g. , i.
.= 4 . . :. .'.U i.F dii j .;::g .-
g , 7j .i.: t2 I
- O g H- ..
Hi* i. j; i: .- .."i.' ~ h 4 e -j..: - -
.i
- 6
.. .i C hj . ...
, u e -
M '- mi: .
-r_ . y g
- .r. " ic . r d . --
e
.2 i; *
.E '
T- g U.' J- : _!. : !R . ~! .i T' g. *
+
d- -
;; yi a ,l g
,-WF :: ;. cir - 'p..
- t i.- _
( it -1,. !. g* d
, : 1.! :'
gg - 3 r
- d. '.~'h t .1 *
'.E r.y.-i
' L "-
- .i9 . :.- ! @ s- a: 4 i. y p.v cv -
--jpr :-riq , 2-- -
t/3
~: r4- .. ," :: . +- t. -
n r-t: . i -- .r; m i- . f- J: . 8.jk- r:je{$2 a f.. . v. t .:' ii - .i s t ,,e
..r. .- :.r : .. r-[- J.: fien :::
i i _. , r :. ; . . .
.,a r
~ :? f .. . i ;4. :- - .
'. U
- 3. . . .
s.l :.
.).a m . g C' : . .-
- . y ..=a.:-
.. ..): e,
- 4. .- a l. ,
). f . 4i ,..I.. 5
- { . . .l ' .j.i; N $
" ."- b ' H.-
b l.: #- 4:: y jl . .p . v - 4- i: a g t; $
.:t ; . ,a .i -g. :- ; ;, _ ~ l ., . . l' : ,
J. .i : . . .
. p .:. :.Q : . .: ;in 4
- b. r. :.j .; *:" Q: :" g. .
', ke af ~l ; n!
- - 4 .t: -(3- '
.-w: C e-s::
t t- . *. - ' - t Y. p m )- _ J
-.. . . p : , u' -::j . .-. ,3
- : -( - .r
.cr s ; g i j:t . i_b- in
- M .t. r
~
I - ;Le p :p
- - } t
-i . .t.
e it b
.\. e.- m 'r.:q :- .
-Q. . -_-
T- ' 4 b 1-
' b ~
l a g _ h- ). . . < . i- . r2;, W 9 i. vi r. l C y ; J. -y + .!-
,l -
.p :l.. : h. t. I L2" 4 .l.
(1 T W? .& :t- _% f ,LW , l. b:
.N.
- i:
i
"" -~ i ig k.h ~i'
'g +
l1. r- $- h"Y' .'1 .:c &=b', -e vs -
--3&. ;
.- r.
' w' -a -, f:
. s j , ,' c.:.c#%*g- 6 f-~
. +-- -- +--j----- *,*%;
(. j ,, -f":.
' ~ ~
MM. ,iP, t ^t ,., N;
*- i-i .,
.._.I.
@ i-- _
i :
-i , _T . ..e--
't-
- i. ..-
y
,a
.l 8 ,- '7 I. i *
-J f
- l. . -l ~'T j i;
.. ; q..
J-._ n t -$
! r. - -t
- ,:_ -lr 4 [:a ; a u o o o n e e . . o ,
o .en ao .*. . ..- - .
- o. o. e a o o o o w
ma/soqsst 2 *menog add *rtueawy add *engpos 34 warninnpuo3 wn"3 16
e .. . s. Ce [ i . pt i [
' . .. y N, . . ; z . I - i-C5 i ;-.i - a. . l: , c
, __a._S>^ M% l._ybf
^
. .q. .. ..- L. :
; t {- , s r.
.5 _.,4 .-.[. e. .IL _l '.% ;e, ____..._.gi
..- #.; . e.> ._1 .
t e gs (". .< p. :.
- . ., 4-
.d- -_ '.
r.- , - M
.E 1 0$ 4 ** p3 Ig >; 6
.p .;i i - 9
..O.,
1 a Ls ir 7.t n s , . -Q,. 5. i vi. s ( - t
.m o*' i h.5 . j gy*i 5 L. - .
L-
.-~a ~:f. 4- %. . , ,
,,-a
- a. . . p .- .- . .% l,' .
t ,s
.i
,a
- 3:.a. _a. :n .1 -p.
l- .f nt-
,m r hea: s. : : s1. La . --
l* lg y ,kg'_-' , . . i d^ s-S -- t I ;{
- 1 5. k .- l - -i, l -,-t e,g" j :* r u . !- ) _: ,-Y, . ; d 't J.I_
s., .%
.n p.
1J-- 4 o . . . t 6.r i - i .% *
- i- % g ?I i- y, 'b -y, Q N .M Jhr
- i-- ' -
iI ' l_W- f
- . Gip . -H i;. - .; ri- ;.E :LLf ;- .-
-~j g. -
y 4, e mi ,,7Q i .c . - L 2:.4 r _ 4 re . - ;i . .e . -- l = t - n MQ e --
~Np -(se
- 4. rt s O
. . -4
- $.- + p :( .
M;i. - h t CW" C+ a .s , .fS b -l: . : 4:e "* - -%M,
....-1 =L I
.i
~
L. = * :: . ::.i Gl.: ,
- m .i.
, t- l u s:: r . . . . . .-
.:q; a .: t.. *- -
8: e i v. .. . t r- ri: 1.1 t-. n - -
-j' -(' : 6- .
n .: N t Aq .&. x .:u - ii.' :
".iX .
Ig ,,l+ .5, - c.hl
.i. .
- s -
- C_ '$
ja,_gy r -- j i .q:- i- e ..y ':: , g . raw j i : is
-t , saga
.-i-hd j y . .jea -i: :
J~ 1" !_: j -b_ i.g c .q q' T&* @9,-I -
. :t .i ,.,'$ -'g;
~
g g..J %..= a r .: , .LM.i : r . .!
=irr) f-.. Tr,g O J r -ia R '" ire! .rMF !:1- d:: -J t ':- Dil ~ -- i -
~
r l-.J. :- ;
,- r a. P-M'I..al. .!..I i WJr. gl. - i .d .
^
. k1!..: i 1:. @ i-.!
2.F'.r ) ? t . a' p
- .). W U)r 4:.j'. Jii:iE?paa M~i'-
, ,j N
i Q y. .t' 8 Oi# -N' I%# d
- Y- ~~
d l - b- g 1% .h d U 3*Jd$ M! i--f - E
i h,*
-- *[M ? h_C E.I : $f M C M rN:.it ,
(p. i. .lG.c s et.! j ""h @..I.ap.i i.ie - d'$."; # d. h- n. m :tril.}.6d l ..:! : i::'ll
= i -:d - s. % i.jf '*-' - 2' G
Rf3 fr y. -. .t . QxQI -.4.-: .. . .e d f. QR'sV. . l =. . ._(=. -
.1. 2 . z
.<l ;. !L" uqj:"; ' I ni .. ) U .@.
g
.- g: Q @
_.7- ,4,Qv: .iQ .lg ~ .y
-' LJ. 9 v .-5 W e
~
. i- Ti3 tihi @ j - ~:r .il = : .i-i . ~ Q1 - :-b-- i.-6 4 O p
'g E TD ? Ti + FM Wi 'N-- M*) 'f d.:7 '- _4 li -}i" i- - ir 6: -'! i: l i - $}* g
'O
=-i : Mi iegw : .W _.?'. g a.J if r ^:+lrb ~1 :. ; :!.4-7.yi:j - . , h
[-4"*a ' . sH 1 ih a-F. :i.e.: Fh EdiTa Q i.i. j *.: ." b C"'p, . . i- N'hQi - : vi i -m- 1: .: :- M -;WrN c W L Q g U-j : . Jy) a c ;.i-E -
- t. . Q --).. .: . . l j--- u--
- p--g' h. .-H-i"-- f- j.:r - ' :;t M
@t 4k'f- --ir- w i .Gi [;f'-4 v -J-- 4 . m . . t-v
. . J:: :t- ,
i/ ,
.=1J' :k.::; :.: i - . .Qg.; i_: .y. _'" ti*y=~-t... us; .! a. .- ' - ~% L-< i. . , r. : J i- ( h p
-QD..p* . ' =
Qj i :.
- t. ,a ~
Sh R:LJ .Q-s- ; hjf - 'i i .
]-~=b:hk _
L 'W &__, G
%% W&. 'I. -
l'9'I V US: .:--
= d. '. Od : ;a: _ . ac.Y. : .t .- : Gt V .r.Ja . - . -
= l .. .@ N -i- *==is.e::
.J . C
- d. if. '
- f. d. _ . .- f. . : ,
'.ie :Ti J:M. ._r . j i. ?-j3 *: 7.- d. . :.
r .
- 1. ].:.:. . - i. -
a n T-- -i p r ' i;-. '. . ; . 21 '-- Ji -il - 8 (,3 g .ii:. E._ :-f.Li.
-i r - i :. ])rdi . i .
-*4 M. ' g
.Y_ ;;
3-
~
M.C2.: :.. ! ~ ; *T t? 1:I . 1
/
_L" 4* 4'I e
*[o i::h:h *.~?-I 1,_",_i.. . %, , r-
= : -d--
-= =
-- c- -
4$ A i l'
- b. [C.- y '. U; C - .: =.: EEi r h, ry: . 5: r u -
hi '-- .. C.J - [ Q '"* . d J Q r: .p.' ' u5hDN.
.: L.e KhN. ;- - V)
-g. m .p M g-- ig u , .J .' i :-} . . , . _
T r. -! g i
, Me' - .V- N-J : = Q:i*dil i l.. S:!J ' tgN .ri el- e 7Qg
~ . . . J.y .. . _ - p .a
'.;V-0 ~. i. .;. :. . y i ".:. 4:p. J .j ..' ;i g3 l ::.l.L 4..' 4.). .
~
.a
,k
_ ~
-l .i .T.v_i- .
- : i--- ;--i i -
O i-r -
.,12) :- :3 1
t :s - -l . : p bl- :.j, 9: . . . [ '+ -
. :: 7 i- ~4. :t ' ' .hr. -- -- -
.:p . ai:i ~ -
.'. .L ; - :a.- .: .13 : .di - J .j.
+4
. :q. :. .J : .T 4. ' J H. . t i:. .!".1. . ~ ..;..
C N
' {j - - .:p. -. :!. : .
- g. -
--+ '-- :;. m g
- - - :- 4- m. : - l-p .
g a r: . .4 :, .l . i; .; & 1..;. .p : . l. .. 74 g} e .;l J . r: y ;, .;,. .f; - .- 4 .. _,j g .;
- y. . . , . . .
g a . . . _. .. q. .- :
; ., 4 e
fd , : r.'
- m. q- q-:- .t. . _
p :-, me :i:
.1 ,; ..g. .p. .
T ~ .. ) ; .! - J .!
- r.
.- . .I - -
A
+-
E .
. ' .s (:1. ,.. l- r
][
;h .!-
(['-g D _ .c ,- .j. ' 8 ,i.. .. . . r; F '
--7.-
.i..
. .i :. .,.- ]. . ..... , .[. .
.T?
.1-j : .4 -!.. ..r.:.
!-lf -
]: __._ .-
l _J. .l u 4 - 1 ._ t ".- j . a -.t t .t..- g( r !-
. i '
4- i
' {f f 'T
.h ~~ ; 4 1 g .
. j ;.
-'q. . . .'.-
l . -l
. , , . ,- .i,lt-- .p ., . a. . .
- q. . .
* *
- O ' ** C g o o
*. 'T , 9 8 g.
o o %. o o o Q sysogast g*wg
- f. add *ricousy odd *enipo3
. *421aT3 upm3 poises 17
- e
.-i- d ':4 A r 1 i 'l
- 2
{ .' !" !-(.
- i. 2 il 3 7jj s
i .{ r . -l. < t..
;- e .,
.--j 9 a e' .
q.
.~
]
1 1 , t
- i ic i i .- -* *g g
..,i. .i .t ,.. i. e ;- r- . y,
{- i-
.; ! 4 }
J.i . i
.. . . . ' . .'s. , , , e
- 9 : . .1- .s i
4 .
..f . 1 . 1 . s- -j- !- 3 , i- s-
. .i :sdi- a-
? - t ~s r- (.g i 4 t- .; --
. -ii k. . p. -
.pt. ;
or "y - r".
- y : .4 .: - t s : .r . + i : s.
y-a:n . 1 ..L :i:L D.) - : d - .;
.a.
. x.
.. u -r.r
~.s c i..rs 1 :t i.- . .i . .1
-s st :( ' .a : - :- tt, . - F.
.I.
d.p -'. t::i . j . q t-
.. .a s i. J . ,
4:J. +*
;: t- r E~ l - in 26 - 2;.i.L i i t- .t: _.i.-
&i':th4$' :.hq' '*y:; ' Ff 4 $- ' V .Q " f '::. . :(*&i rf" --* W #i *i' W $ t- Ut~.
.a ; .. 4. ,; .- .,,y J.j j . -i..e- .- , t .. a ;.; .;. rjc : i. w n :- -
- 41 -- ..-,.. . A -1 .s .r . e- t-- 1_ 4, s .
.U* 1.- ;M . a-ir 1;
- -i - = : i. :. -. r. -t - p q a -m.j._ .r m4: t; . : - :e -
.- Q.
g-2
.-j e 1 e-- .- . ..-m. i ._ t : yF j; -- j . ."; si ' . ri: I -d -- 1 : **f-!- ,
.sdra: ::i..t : i..I .. . . -C} L.f.:. $ n.! --s d - "- - #- '
.y ..=' d.: i mi ..d.: .u. l" J-t:
; .,- c : re t.; - w ;.- -t . ) :
f: . 14- :: 1 - -! ' [N .-- :: t%<$ :- uW --i : . $3:"'"-
- . - q ..
-e~.W+j - +p .ag 9!. i;=
(r -.nikr ;4 h{ a[ j t ::] .: : f, i=: x-
- t.s J y : M
,.3, aq4rnaW . s
% &l3 57 mE .7.,b m=.+ = = !;
, : rp,4.; .tr. . .
+ e.r=+ Jwi=
=<m;w .i : '=
r==
- ar~
a:-q g-i==
! a.+:- .c & E -> f f -
- --+r,.pi h;.n.1.Uri- += + !
4+;: :.y
-se3.W: ..
"ni := w rt::: vt-r.r, =n & w --pav.d-- Q .Rw 'a=w ..-.e .,
g.a yg.. G:.= :.
=g Ww: +u-a ga s .ay 'if .m zi . : m.. % .q. .
, 3 ,
.g! Skt :L4 ::pi-Q. :.L . 2:-
Le ,j H
;p ; dG4.if.
eT_" L ..a.. - :i : Z 7 -j T- --"rW # U- '=. ni ;. i f., r- t : 2.
- .L 4- i. g .. - - . + .-i 3
a #1 r 1 *e N k '/Ia = +.
* * . 1 M -* 5 "'-1 M . ? -. i.N Id 'O i
- 7 * *: r d "S = ' " - -
+: gG. .. + D - % u..i - i i.i .% .-.=. +G =Y:- :.i.: 4 o C .. -M.....-.G.,,..
- u 6 w-*-N. i U. .'
.'ti .' f.. ,
4 Q g _'U!-h. .$d. .in V.E:N? Y i ii- 5!'.J 9 id i r :.'N3 "$ ~~i.'-~ 'i J 2 g
, - "I-d@!*R3 i - - :@M Mfg. ts;"Syr = i--h;.$ ~~dl cc-nc-4:=. e z 1.:7y mi, :- e :L- i.:
a $
-igct ;@ .e .{-tqs e
%, =
" ';ir3: .WM- .p ,. . )-q g.m;.T- p3qe:.p3.ai. .a .-$ .c nc;; ..y ,g Yg s-.-. ,=..-jg . p;ri =::-r na@c12=.g -J.gi:af:Fr-.i(#p.,- ..c.g . m .:. t-J] : . ,
g wyw.m m.w: m.au=,.-w.- m. m. , - i wt J -4.#'rQ 4- mi ? ii- :! .:Qnf.1 i-Q.i.j'.rji J.M-- - fj, ;. . . ' . . . ;* - . gQ h9-pi_+ d*: -a u Q. . i --d- - , . h :.'. . . t -- wWu
- m :9 : ::: n :, .
.s @*i , SQ
.: .t.:te. L;Ji L.*r.3. t, .ap . r:
2 c . i%s ,.. JR.. I a [ ' i. . -. ; y ,, e au. . . -4. r-i.-- )r,4 dis _ .. : p- . gem:. -
; &". 9 .=<
2 .p- pri ;p cTim
- u i. . e a & =x = ei.i.
'I g: o r3 ::f n ! -ID ' E l' .5 tM:i'"l$-
,-Nd rh ~ lJ ?% r
-a:.
;+i : tv. . .L 4 ;- L.e . 43 r=t:.- w.cw e r -r .1= r:..w. p: i, u
- so.-p Ji ; ta .m b -
+.jgg r- q,3 : g-c.; ,@g : - =?= v +; _ g
@pt sW y .7.*": C LG9 @ il- 4. ,.@k4 m r F.; - -D: 3+ -
, y
- w. .=M= 4 f F-' M *O M :R - TC54h r -4: :.iJ . "Nr L.il ru a t.
~[-
3 8,
; IIi$h:i-L H:<,g.D u 4-EM- (M W.P i "=4- g
=- m:ia
-=- r s y .c;-- : .6 a.g. :.a : i= . -w-y.on .: y a= +. p g
- gh ' - -= r.q, +
i-c-- e .
-,sm+ m.v . run an. ii-is: q - Q ::p.:- .+r w.qy ;. +a r g
m ;-s a;_ w: c. . ._4 r_ : ,. s .gr +
-g. . r.m 4 w rs .
c
- c g 1. N- -'i: W E E- *#
' riE '
@ ' ~~
J.--
- .d le.. :.
- - _; '*1 a.:. 21
,i~u;
'::i? -:r '.
,_ !Up r.
l';
=:_4 g
SQ h.T"'e F j! ..-'i
,f
.T. i- .i..
.!; 6J. - : ..
- M
~;~W- :'=1 -
.. - t =i a :ii -~
.: :7 c. . -+ <- a . i -J J-q:ia . ;ic' - .% -i.
= ;
.h-- C
$I :.: , , .
2,j:, .- m. .a ' a.h.- h + .
- . a ?. d. _ F...i.m.- . .i: ' .
. i. f. = ' , y yiT~ -
-y.i. ..;.. , . .N . j.Lil: " ir;.:: J p;.' i UJ:: _::d.:= _. p yd : I M l. . f . .. .. l . Ih . , ;&rdM. j j d.f. ,1 lii'- 7.j d '* h i .p h..i ; l ;.gI i
- n- 1' h ":iL._f =P'
^
k..i Q g c QQ
'a g .
1
; .is.-p n.
> . . 4-wg. - y. g . -m 4'~ =
3, : -R 7 W. - W~he'
~M i: -9 tN r # % -i p SI - ;I
- .g, -w apyy e y: y .c- d- n, %- m , w-- -i : ,
-a-) _,myr. .; ; , ., :-. ., m : g- si eM- ptt , ; _. +:i -a .
g =v n -
~ -<._ % -- ~.rQ, ~~a.Q:p .
.: g. e. . . . o.m d .. .. c v -T r
;w@ 'n. 4-
. sw 5 .001 .:: i .d, .l.e IIi ng$ E'! -11 i: .b f $at ~"1t -
.$c.1;$ !:4 , .-
- $ 1 : 3 dp_ i ! =M, - *
~*
5.qQ{}!- '. ; M 2:1 $. Q - 1-
.. t- : f, . ;- .. .: , i. i di :. 4: .Ia gg vi:.- -
c.g r fg- p. m ,l .:..
- g '={ ,
w> .
... &y 4:
- t ,--
---,- , w -
- .! . . g. .
."Q
.a. ; i.
h ,. i ..
. q l- ro . u. n.a i t -. ., .
'T "(
..i r f7- .. T t:- %'l .- -
- s. -
vL. 4..pi- - 1 N 4&D -Tin.. ,_j:M[1% .k'j-.,. c .' I:- L_10.+ :i . d.,_! : 1 -
.g f.gyr :.ec_
y Q3 t - -m L :- A p.ra a. - :t-, g e =
-e.
~ ~o ~, .g g o . ~ o g g o
~
o o
.f g g 11 art *mnipoS
, led add *ricouwy 83/80 9 1 g
- 2 ,q
'431atasetuos moises .
18
- e 5 ,, , 8 Eg# 't .j . 8.' h. f.. .:l 1 .? {. .
i f. j f 'f {l. - r, n jr-- p .s t .
' l.- -.
7
+ s:
8, es i- f f
)
. . . . *i. $ e4 : $ 5
-1
; t a 4- 6 gg
{g 'f , 4
..ra * *6
, ,. I t -i l j s. ,
, I s :;. w. F C. .t- .L t I. . t
+ -.4 ., :i i , -+ y p l- #- : + . 4 e .i l
. p ; .t. I t !4 . j- I.
. , rd e . n
,j
, -i i
, . t .. .
i- me -- -4t*
, {, .' - ) .a.a i , at . .-i.- y-W gr ra tr :-
i.i - t49 .i - ~t" .i.
-f-u.: -
,)
g :. ;r.:-{ ---.- a. .. i --eem - - - e s -- r1-ut r-- c. i. , ,a i. - -
- up .. .i . :s; .j .l-t .. j . 's . ,
.u n. n .:. _ .
.ot . i .: .- .t- L .! 1- .i:I
!Cd- - Ni?" .E. t .H ".. i, '- er.%. . r; . 'm i
J"f i. - ! - 41 '.' : .s '-
. 21 . .i" h-i~ . 'i.i. i "I
-4 g
ir'-f-r_t . i-~ ry - .- v):' - -- ,s. -ti 2- % . .g.- -
. s-- :t -
.! u ,
n .* r- : ty _p :-! 1 9.-' -
--r l - ' nti :- t - i-ad.i : is. V n.W ma -r(: W. .. .
T - - -
. .J . . n t - Jur r-g m .e. .L a 1. 3 ; t. .r l- -i*
.r . .t i i . s. l.: .
^
'{. '
.: . . . L . m . .s .. .'.J"+"
.;s 4,-
atu e . . ..: . . i .s .. . . ' *+. .is a . . .s.a. . a s . i . s .t' .
<.t> .g .6 : -- 1 : ta - -n 4 .s
- a i .d +. ru- ,
;t v f. , 9. .
-r:_ .I y up. 4 . :. 3. , - ti - ;r : t -
, e pi-4 .1 i
4- i- is - et- ,,
~ -~
g ,r try - i. i -- s a.- . .i .p.: ". . - ' .d i - . s:- . :( - ai- ;[ fe - 'f. :J - Ii. N:. f-
}- i 3: ; .(% uJ : ~}- . s.:. .
j J.y _ y.a a- :, i:- .. ; H .. 3 y y. - :-< . m +-- +. y.i . . .w a , w -, 9,6 r J.; J.: I.J.- L O v. T. !.
. :" p:t. ?. . .h , . .6.:1 : .:: -- ' ..i .
-i".N .L ';l*$ / ."fi j . si'. ;: - 'M r . :p.i . $ J.i ;. .' T:ld :F ". i. : .'I-II' .Ldi. ~!'
? . l .: .' AJ
.n._.- .. -
a .!' .
- l d. . : i .s- .r
~
3.3. 7,ill .ij ' : 1.: .
. c t..: t- 3, g g
- :. s:; 2.
- :at a ' :.5 I' ~ r i[ir .2i: *r Jr, es["
' ^ '
( s. . -t- . .,.q 2.3 : .~4-
" - I- 'l f.
i.'.; 7 .df "-f4 . t: i.ii J
+
.a
. m.v x- = = s -r- -e. --= -
-l ,- .
t U-
, .h - r.1 Ji = 1:- .. J :. -. s .i . ai. ;:J i". ;" .s .1 .ial re-
,J }. ~ :.s. 6 a - .z:S .
cap %.].:' .i.k. . ~ ~:q " f.'
- - *l il* 'E
, .-5. D. . -M_*f S. Wl:i. . .
?"F- *: h' .I ~. :. l. .i. . -
Vi+r0 r_ . :. - .s ; --:t . . _. 6.r # -:- i la.- -
-n ' .t . . .: : .I :. - ( o
, .r i r i'a --ia:. cpr : st s s:. s.i k : : i: - .u a.'4r :}'.J _ . . >
.i: ..t- y g'
y tp y =i t :: :v L. t v 3
- i. .It -
, :p ~1 y. 1c ' I *-
. = per -~. .s "L.. t.:4 J, r .: , ...
s.r.r :a=-
. : tr.r. a.: :: ..r. k. e s -m rf :.s. ..
..}+ ,
gq
;.1:_ ,; ri:qa ? 3.w ::si - :. r> : .t: ., .:n-v .r i ' ti c.: -
-- - :: M- - --4-" -l , #
si -
--j --t .t:Y . ) '- .
..!; m. 3.; - . F.. :- I -
-i e -V r-p- a- a--
Q.- - -!:
- r p--- - -..: 2 .-
\)
; ei+ rpy 7:.+ :4;::t n : s .r arlr . %- -J--- -r 4 . -3
.; i. y* 4. :: r, o y
- (~ ~ '-
?_t;; .: ..) .s ; . . .V - - y. : s4~ ai:rbt:W .~. i(- .. s s.a .
sj+ i t.:.
.: T i :- - Erl. < . ..t- - "
.} :
+ s" me a kr u
* . s:ta:. : A s. .F a i.-r .
. /.l._.*
. 'p 1
- f '
(, z. -
. .a d bJ, -
;- y
- z. :f h- r.b . ;i ,at apJ ~}. M F _.Mij s .:- ; . -
..i.- :6 "i r m .- 1. 9 .:: ) s l ; y-r ni r- -- H . :$ .a ..t .
f
.:: H 2 w .
, l'i -
?;.i ai ": sij? r;i.- "in ; il; : .:t.- - -[ - O i- -
.-b '
"- ~+ N- "-4l ah - HI 1
E
,-_ .:_ : .- ,:- ...:. :qJ~- t f; 'q" <
6 i: .; ." - - p :.r;: - w. ; 1 r. -
, f.- .2.. _ . . _.. - <
.: -14 .
- s; ' - Li:
y:*- --jv-
~
? : -
g
;.f L J7 M" Q 4 'i - ;.
- f-- _ -j ;
~]. 4.3 p
*-T. .r: - ~~
ay : : ar e. : :..- ,; 1 - -i . :. , 3 -2 N
;h.) :- F. r. : 4, eG u- '! -s is. . : v. - " - - -
.:- .. r? e-- -
.i : ..p. ,
.+ . b. t ta - . su- .f h i:- -
.. Jis3. ..h. --i i .2 .:J E
'. :j i c: .. .. t . : :
' tT. . ;l - -
.; - Di , ' i.:
i . d (') ' ' y; JJ
/.t . . r. j .1 i_ ::t .
- g. .. .a g ,_ .1 .a."
.j . .; J a: I ~. :1;- _: J..1 i.- .f ;. .l. y
.. { . : I_ .
~J. . .. . :
r she .~ m M a.
+ - -12
- s
.31 . v. - : u. . i- 2..-
- .t :
t = c 0..
- 72. . ,:r .
u tr. . .s. - . . _ CC m 11 e: .r.} . -
.i .J - .
ii ).. .:t :1 . [
)r~ 1r 3: 1. ,
's y :
K .
~
r d: . .iX i..l:: . fa 1- 'z; .t' - -' -r :+ ; 7 7s -
- l-: +s. ,
izi u. n. i 2 ;- - .a ..l. ' I
.Y. E s ..
.~ .4 e . ;.
g g -
~ jr'- :--
i
.t .
- 1 3 q g, l 'r 4?
.M. . !- . si r) .
+ *- * " ' - ' <
r - d~ DC'".i 3 - i i t . p' "4 JL 6-3 s _ ( 1, f -- .. . -- .. .. .{ : ~~' L. -- i
,5 t. _
_s.
.. .. . , br af " ,
s / *
.itn~; _
'Q ;_ .s Qf' f ,
w %: g-
- e s: bgv g !.$ :
.r mw o-e--
- r. .
9 . e ,;- : 1 --<-- q4- );_.
=
w W t
..-t" ie v' J'h ' l-5 -+ O-d
?
- -C _, ._
.6.
.[*
., 9 -
g l ,,. ..t i~ ' s: I- __. s{ 1: l :. 'g- - g
.i e o r t:
- y. if4~ ;. ..- g^
-1 . [. ,.
e n e e, n. e n g g o e n o g g o
~
*
- 6 6 6 (I med *unspos . as/seque 3 *anaoa
~uJ. add 'tiisemary
'A31 A)33Mpud3 WD13t'$
- J y.N -
'i t J -
b IJ ..y i , E 9 -l !
.-c . ,.
-.a i. f.
.U L r,, _
, t
.,SO -_e. ifg% - ~~-
to g m er lg l' * - )p.: i.i . *h *b _. 8
% 8 I
L _'g [ i
' " ' "? M!8 l3 ,x i 8 g ' iM g h
*g- I _r [d*5i.* *
. i In4 : Ll ,
l 3 {
. . ;'. . s, i . a ik' t i ! .
] t :d 6 {
g- h t$ e f
- k ? f .-l* _
- I' -
z I M y? I d$ 8 "4-f- INI ? 3 .. t- f b ,]
, {, q . q' ,-
s, f h"e ce.
.t 4 . ' py
- d. :
s i a e - i .s i ] .
! i. '+g g
{ --vi---.-Q ;j'i- 6 4 .r. j ,,,,' $ g ! . - : .i .p
.ve-
.. i-
.t t
g
. :i
.a3 f.
.,g 2 >f< , { -
{4- t. . t .-]% : - . Ni- g! - 7i*- ..t Og r t. . 2 g y"{b:2 6 3r W - * . i"'-~ h'-f"-
- -W - :- - Q Q. . -i - -,.- u- ha, - --- e
[%*l f . rim :- t. - :9-:te
,t t$ rt - ,l j, -! i h... ,- - 4 :. j . -t _ gy, . --
.j p1- -t. y ip -etit& g y'
j, +:.. . @,, r n_Wh t iF - M _ j n :7 3 p }9 - trf- ..)
-} G Hcnt:, os' i -l .a %: 9 ,
Q, M' ~ .1 2 .e $ . .G : ==O -
..i: ).:.sw *-Q - 15 0 L ._q
- .; .i. ." } . .. . . . .. .g i .7: : :- + ..t- izp p i . .tr.42 r e 1. * - ,
n .y et ,c3.; -% S n_ i - Q1g:--i - 3 1-4 g
.q y/ -- H-i ; J t ? .i: : f 'Mi a g
y, '::,:.- H s . - i- ic ... 6- < Aay ,. x..,. -e +-ts-r j p ,:. ,ta . g., . .- t , -6pp pc s -
..i%p :ec l- -- =y n .s. ,
- 2. .
t- ,
~
. 1 m@f r .r- . :4 L ,( 2 _
L 4.. v( : \N3 :i- I il ===? I-R en bt- mT t :- g i.Q M. :..t e ::ic.p, w4 eY A, , -
, . i n 7 1 V t:. -
q.ga v.:: - .i ! Wp. a . y$. 1 2,: .g h -
.t G4 . %M .:: yi
. ,p air
.e.. e . 4
's ' .k i . .$
{ J MTpa a s- l ; Q 'W.,r- '. e . , t- Q# L) . ' - . . w :- Q)' . u WdM - . -OM.f;u - -
'--- u,p,y .y ,n -?O,Q$ ut. J.i P. ~
l
.1 r- .. ; ,q i -- U .,.4
.12 J.-!fM" j. f : :.4 . -@';.1 ! in
- 5.- :.=r -Gi 2ap ii
._& -$i j . ; ... g ,, { _
g- jg; e j. , .. p. l ' .~_p
.; g r. j,h 6 - " -, ';. ': g, p, ,.g ^ , ,;, j.f,
..~ $'; ,, . - .T ;l r v t:* O :
,2 n .
7.'..
-r. , ,
.71 *.:
4 M 7;tO ': . .- J *(% . 85 .: s:: t < _
, p; Q i d Iisi i~ .:i-4!*Mj . e t" . tP:.r .- e . . g p .,4. .k ~.M .4 a: . Gr.3 g i
;.s.-
&* -W' *iU- WFW$
- n :h"A & "
O b5 :! i
\ hI 'A .
3-y o m?.i+ 6 :4 , :_ ct r .. . <N r.yg-w -qa ::!ry - .
- < 's it r 4 -*i : . n a 8 .i . .d:i sV bQa i. ? . s 2.t :s - r jhfk,7 7 r ' t- :i t :. d .t z.- :' t -- .
F p O i \-h ; - .[3 H, i :i-)CQ* -di- 2.:J-2
;f"'--9% y .t-
-; ,,,p A. ,
-"- . .y-; v = :-i= 1 % q6- r---- ..p.-g h @ W .. i.+ % - -y ' t- - rg .- J-4: g C f:1 = . .: . -j.
3 i 3.'l ' i ,, U l-E.= %1 j et iQg a 2: 1.s'. :,' " ldy :.! J.
- t g
'" -j : r:3 ;
g
- M- M ..r- 4
_ l1
" i ::. kM f r- 9fQug.
g - r ..r r ..?-
~
g p~ c- a Nc
=4 M y- i J... , -
3 33 -
-aw ===mus y
,1
- -'s %. - .
V. .z: t -:h.h. .i . . ?'4 '. . -v-
'? .i-j & % )j'h . z-;!
- i T:n NT! 7. T .,
N'i .il j J V. }~ .-
'I - *1i, '.I'- "j jid '.~~ -'
N
. ::t . 2i .in -: .: ..
- -k : J c
; itA g43 - 9 a C4 i- .sa :*! _ ,% c- < d I <3 e .
O _' - iIM' I G pgf:i - -%l :'q U n p- :- 4) .J i 6 .: ; i 1.: :sM ~.N e 8: -: We e 9 g p :. c - _,:. . yt .; i= .u ..
- 3) 9 v ..
- q9~ T- M E hsiy.t:O'd~;: - w- ' - -
- i. Dor #: -<'R 4 - M O Q1; dh <* -l 3 9 II * ^ '!
g 4} NN( --!" Ti.O F
- -();: .U .C .. ..? :.y
% :.'73: Q 4
.. 4_ .
^U .
d m. 2: a .. - ~ 35 2.v..-. . W. J., iF ..' _ : J.. 2. .O '. t ;- i.?( :t: : t- . .A. M
-- .p. -d .C: . ; :-
N ir 4 4+ (./ #
~
i.. cd -. : .: af ji!. d. -3: . L.
~
$- .J; y
^ ' ;qi
.l : . y
;;. :c. :V .) . 'T ,
p-00
- . 3:. . . 'r4 m -- m ..; -
4 1 r .y :w u. si ii - g gs,n
.}I,7 : ~ : G y .- -l : 1 r . . i 5
4 1: # iI
* . 1. n. .p i.
#: - 3
%r4 9 . . ,
-- f-
- L ---9 t
s. 4 i: r . us c J i.
}
. . r. .
.4 '
- -t*
,l l *
- i. i? :: ; ; i-i
~
.a : - i
.: + c -
f .. . "' " . ' . l. .. ,. r '. f. g i . v -!: e- g{ i, ! ,
- 3 .i.. . p: - '[
.( . 4 lp t, .)-
4-g 'T ir -Q3 l- b t [ _- . l :vp: ?{- -ty :.g . ? . .;-: .d e i i- l .
@ u: - , - l ..
o e m 4, w o -n g g o , u o g g o
#
- d d d.
yd add *riwamy med *wnipes es/soqsit 3 *sean 8431a133 arm 3 w13e3
- 20
- e
.) 3'5. u p. a .. .l - r - 4. ; - U ,s.,
- t.- .i . i. j e l.- (
d g,.y , i
) s. .6 -l .
IT: ..s e- : i "s- -
- t. r.
. .a . j e nsa tt- .i ((!.4 <- s.., -: ,[
gg " t. j'- 1. J :_ t .i s .. j , i l [ l/ -.i
, .). d 9
; .). J1 e .; i.i i i i
sA : s iL
. s.t ' .
. l .t .s .i. .1- r s.
i: t. f. j- t
. s. . 4 ! lv; e-
!:s. . s . .u..i. rLu 7- . 2i .to 4. t
.ns-. f..
. .a :. .
~z e 4 - -i -
.: :r
?!
, 2 e i~ : ~.t r .z i '
-i- - . r i -
st s-i .i -d . b t at.
- 3:- . tU -
.40. * -I ::
;;. ').: "t... 1 .:.s t .t h '
_ i L. T 'iu .: -. i fi .. : }. ~ j a
. .$li . ;- 4.1.7 : ,
.i m 4. . i . :r
- 1. . .i: . l-+).n .H:f r . -
- =; -H:. .:i+.: i ua :
Yis .;t ' uh .t - d iY-fe 18 3"f ** Mi s'i I !T.aW N'Il"* : Ni! :-$'Z i*-{dN.hi' : F "- ? :p": }N f~i i-I N* ui e u_i . - :r-: . - ~ . --- : -W =
.C.: "; :7."^ i = .(-- t :- ::d.
- ,:} i :p - . - . ~; .: u .i + ~:
- i.i. - .b- ~s .;p) : 4.4 (: - :- -O :s i -r r. - ra :.0 2- ; i. l
- w.i .- .su.- ht;-
. ::13-- :.y ts-
- . g( $ .Le .;.4 s -1: ::r p .4-r- .::iEiU Coni :.J t b.
ii-iid :P.J 3: r, :t9}@!c.4 :2: - Wi !"? . . _ .i e f.h.L . I isl .. :a, _.i'.~. i+. .s.- - M-ld
- 4. ,
- --j i .:, ._ d .a ' .i . 4:K::.. 2 ih::.f M u ".~.!- i : .M:.r::' . :..r . . ,;; j_
- i .es e 4: . ~ m:'
ji - q i e :.c $ .e s .- g r .
- i: usz i-y ?j.- - y:f p ii;= ' -.s- ( ' ' t t--. g
- 9. f .: -p . , s - .1 C. :. " p :- 2 " C- .y ?! -;tff .m- g ';-r i., W im*1 .
-:iwn ' gali j, =l, :-#p ..r- -
4 -
;f.,';g;.I. m-1-r 4.: q;.e
&i m
-- g . p :. r. : h-$;d== l!.Ai_.- d , ---* ' : .a a f b- u.:1
{ N t- . -g 2 7 u5: p 'ik 8: 2kj = :r s-
\ chy::r:h i
2 r-qx.y : W ::: .iti.:1.= --2 =c." al;0;4--+Mt;.:h-.i"i-i".;klar ' +164 a: fi _ - - q .a .= -1 .W#. w ::.- ++ wia= -g sL :.
- ?$'it: ICD . JF:r M.I$_%!!hT. iiit"-iI :!:lL=ici
- u ha -* =t$ui ?ii ::IE-T:7-::i; . -' ~ .
h :r.:hr# 2.: Q h -b;Ji
}:t i. J 2.:i .~. .J' (.h;. i.S : . -TJ.~1 . N
- b::i f 'I. N ~_ he. .g -
i.' . .L u ii'.;.j 1 :-i idd T :O=r"g -l ;- -6]!
. .,7 -in Q Id.i.T='
y .:~e~g f. # {i.- .- Qi p li
;34!' _ - -
3 i; ;Qirn P_y . :? 7 ~ { f-i.i J .W #2 - 2.c .f. - :L: g C
.-~ slg,L4 ji: ...{ T @ * ;;-".y 13i y.jf : .= . r': a-- : :f, ify .- Tarh.Ts$34T ~--ij: 3d;.9 -i:li:.:' % ;- -: ip-%ii-W
- ilf; .h'. .Qd-* Qf.f mi..:;' J. Ed.3i.: i : iCQ h ::q 32I#_. b. .I. s.iG.fj E= i. i.i" t3 he:- L g
'b.hY2- * ? 0"*"*~ A=$ .b 1'?$NKC: : ^-b
- E-i:- ::M'bt: 'uMt-i==- H.i .1ge . e . -1=hM -ir: q .8 g -
2rn!4M .=. -4 o &'+ > fei=-Mi - 7.W *"Q2.= Ms.W~Caff-E '="i:2=:-t *E -t.c4
, =E@ t " c 8 - =qeI E, .s ar [q
- M .i. .i.J..';) i a ; _ '.i.I. '.M .a i.n
% . .t . :. g y d.i:H. M.sJ. :rs!. . . .i.p- ..f.:.;C;i:.Ip- .
_ , _ - :re u M
=: : --irr.:r 77 C ; gt= j=.:rt:.p:ce:. .%;
,. . . . . .--p.. ,
- ..c..Q*). . 7: = :- .i-
, ._ iH -= ::.-! % iM;{=. ^=i3 : 6- (=% , y b.iE- $: .. :s . . .rgJ- s .r.Q o m : 4:=- . i=-i .IG.:d2d.+ij r'I
=.y.gG '-+ } ;i : ::h- - M ip::/ .;b .-(t a ; ( $4
[e . Q y g- s q ,
. - yiM ' 6:ii.'.: ::r'ji.
- %. W'- %" #C2 g O
, #I ~ _ : 1'l ;M1 (d'*N 'ENNFI*M ~~ii33 :' !!-- f MIh* tW:"di S '
E - U
, :*2I:I
- .11.3 kW
- UW:.u=21.:::-..H~ '..Q F3+'.i :q=
i '.r.T - es s- : a-.L.lt
h: -b:b
.rs t
.:-:kTL;h khih ' ';.:.. -
- h::[yW-li: s " b -
'~
= .8 i.c ...: di:L- h
'}'$-5. Id-tY. '# E S-dd?-i2 T E O-$'. ' /*"'""~iT .E
**
- M i' di Cl tY
+W 4:'
. g.'q * '
.- d = L _ _ Q .;- .- G
.: :t. --4.-n&W.i- V:. *= 1h= . hr.
t.
.j.i :- @ t ? .h "?';.):. i NI.Y -
bk M /Ni h-N M M'5IN ME@ ': 8.h lam 5f 5 ENI-5 g g
":r;* esiE@;+b=!20 =::-74 dei.ie @i'r :q 5.:-i-i iiE- :H 14 , @
yr. - ~. g- .;t+f 4:i -die 9_g c d :. ed .:dFif::M'W:M c- " ih2ri . ::El= A ! -i i+=24r: le ,
.7d ?:g : .:!:: :& .7~~'*i r -Q. .i;d= [ ] 1
$,ri l .:3 1-r- :h'-N J 4Q.1'5.-92'f'.* - . .. _ _ . .
y -::: 32 2.4 : p. , .g ::.2.=.
....4......_..._..: :-4.; ;; :
.p ..._r.Mo
.=- :, .."s . - .""".t.a. ! m-dt,-.:. =.4,.. .m.i ::-:::.; ,
& 's-- 'Cf.*: := y Cr"~Q :.Qidy L 5.'.- ui ._; .
~ - L.4 2f.}.M;' ,
J.Q :
- a. p :
i: A. . i .J.T . := 9;;p; 5ini -rza.iq jin, ai- .. :rf Ji:r;= : rti.!:a:idctd- t W::-y; c e s
- j }:ii iijd.'.:- ;213:j '..: ,i. r
, m . . fi/ 3ilii 2
- i r2. ..i::. . . :h. 7 4.J.i i:.J J.T..J: Wa.t.pl T;ii .- Spf g _3 ,M . Q:Fi E .:{.'s C3.i.a2 fin. RJ.p.li.
JJ. a.: . p
- .t i nr '! Q- W::- :. e n:: :4. f- rppi:- :iFi? =id _ -3Q a a mi-::::: p p- Q.! d-lif -
(, ,,0 l-':: :. [--) .:k + v: E.lii .: . 'iH : - '[p I.j p ): .t i- :
' ,:.: . - y
- 2. 12.
I' J::J 101 . i-:.1 ga F W r
~ ;
.r . . : "iFi: i:W 3.il:i. vic-O ~~;
z Q : .n. ,.
. :.l M - .g. .l...,.}.-
,.q.. ~ ...
- g
( h,:. :.b.. .s , . .{ W 3. a.F. ,
- h. %: . :.L ' :tr. .@g_ r,.,.. '..
; ' - . - y. + : r. .
- "" : W "'I. : - g. ,,.h .
- hr- r"~ ' '~~' - g
,, " ^;- ui; * ? 9- ,g
% i d'p' ?
{MM s -@y
- Pb' ..hh,1. Q* M V: ..: #
~3
- -f-- t@iF il
- J -U ', .- f*pH f- L.+ 9 ~s
- ::jn+ Qu -- .g. &fe ~s p u -
- . i-- ; Y-M h y --! ' g.& . :{ +:\ H '- -~:,.
.p , j -- .-[
* :. r i h g==-j -~9 . _. j y $""V:: .& p% t.: 7.i-l W A kMO .' l - 4 6- v.-
,-<~ --M f .
gj - -
'. JI]gh d $?
b l.1 ' lj h %i '
*y - --
t
)=W .idl .. "*..s f l V ^'%;- 1a . . tp* ..g ' j S
,..gE &._. i . . p.
9" - . f"C_. M.'*i. , . ,I .r . r i.- q:.j p s -y h : ) .' k.D*;%Q. s*-
- p
-i4 p:
-i,p
. fi.7
~~~[
.e j .- 3i: -j. .; . .s..M u;. i.
g %.7; 3.;; jg Q. 8 Jar ; _
. .y ,
T. " G
- ?.
- - M d :- -:. . -j : *
(![ ~ . [
. Y- kj .3- t, ..'.l,. i ' 9, I .. g. -t..hDx'- . i. - ,!h -Q'. .
t
- k. _u_4, . .-
i.e. . .: h.mI N !
. .s.,r w. . .:, a T :
..- d. :
- . j.: :, .- : - (, -t -
tm . f.Q pr 7 l-- p: -p {...9 gy .; i q a /.
.-i .i: , i- -( q , ,.. t o
o o e O P
- 3 9 o y g. g o e sw e o O o o
#dd **a1P05 53/soyen 3 *seand nd *dd ' 'I "8"V W 1A13anpuo3 motsyg 21
e e l j 8 l -j -!'I al":I .-
- n. j - 6 l2- -4 l '!
- a
) i
- 3. s . m *
>t a _t . 1 a
l -e -. . ,b .
- t. e es --
- e e e s. t , f.
--t(
6- ; (t e
**l 4
I
$ ! I t gh l .
-i
- a i
' I j.-
? f l
- i 8 l l- t ! ,,
- .4 e i i a. 1 l iJ h. . ..i .t $. s . *
-j -5 ; { _,
_v.~... . i.. 6 (.
, t t r. I g i ' .s l.i Ce
- *e' . . :j - u. i z . a. .s- . . .
- } .g 7 4 et- .4 t
- t .. l q I a 1:
g.3 :- , .r :- a
, IL - 2 s" --.J . .:_- -$ . _s:- a t- g{
g , ii r 7 1 .. a L. ; . :;.
- I . L: ,
- .:. ) $ . . .
. ..a 5 1.r , : : s i. :- i - s. .4- t i. i, e .(. +. as
~' Je "5~
-* t ) , j . t !.*:- 44 . *-
* *j . hi" - "
- d. : .I" { " '
*} -
, t -th ar#: f - s.. -- .%- ... j r , - r-
--_~.,p,. ;q.. ..,. 4 . . . .
-t . la .s.
' 'i ~j- I- j
- z - p
- r -- -
-rs : :.
im -, lC .. i i. . in -M -J. .t -,. t -:'l :i1 ' g
*- g
; . = f-d l..- : he - i t. . . si e.
g.
.-s..
.t:
... . . ; J.-
- . - { " is : .+ f( .i } ,g
- a. .6. v.g . .a ;- . t. : .
. 4 . :::. .: 6 :4. ' n 9 .: ::.
- . a d ; 2:.l. a. - . .:J;. .. J r 4s <; . :: . ...:--
- p- *
..! I" :q f'
.: .p a i. ..F... gs. ;. 5
.~ . !;.- -. - .- !.
3- .j <i- . ! - ,e
.s 2.- . : .t s., .r ..e z. -
.t :j. .:; .! I ie ,l g .t2:- 3
; i- : .i ea ! !!
T . .T '-:. . q- .j J .. .: - :S: s. . 1 .
=a at I i
..s:: n -! .- .i. .: s - i . . -! . - } . i m --..
7s . i g J.: :' :i. -Ju :.12. l .--i . L * ..j. ..la t 1
-"I II. *I ;i 4.. :h .::! - 1 W -*:j. T. ~.*J 2:: .G:. :.s.[7 ,
- .J. ; .;.r : ;.; -l a'. 3hikI N: 1.2 . .71: !. a
~t i. . ' .
M
". i. : :-s i 4 's a. {
;, z.. a . :::. .. h .l. L .{l .
p ..I . .i i ,1 .e4 J* ~4 : :L . ..r"~ !. q- a
;f .
'i- - : -n. 44e -.i t. . :. r- , i h
.;.. * -s- t i .e eC A. . a"i) .' f r
. . . : _. ::.t -
O
- l 2.
at. - re j : c;. :s g...i., ;t . . l ;;: :l: e- m p . . .j. ., .if 1 y .
- i mi :-i : [. & f , g
;; y .
h- .'t O
. ?h i::.- . f" e t- . *
- t. .a L.: ras.. 1. ( ~P _..:". W: 0 -i.4 . . . . . ._ ,,
; 1._ h-j::
- -f ' .h -- : .!: ',,
~Q
-e 4-f;, . :-[- ..}; . :::s -: .
-:: ii. '. j :;.: .
. -t
=i:i.a 'l.
.. ,. . : 4 .t; - t :j..: a= :fr . . L. : . : r.r; 4: . [: ,
h : -j - +J mp- -a: .r- ..- - gg
.: i} s. j. ..i.. ..r.<.. -i$ S
, e
- -i - it e i: . :t + y;, q i gj .p p -t -t- .t- ~- .:i iyii ~5- j - :- j :~ remJ - [,- ..- -
- }-- -jp - i-
- 4n } 9: . ,
( ; wl: n -1gj .q a . .a- j ;; jj . . g:- .i: , g j '-l.-}c= dj.: - :-) . -i.. -t. . .. _i j, _ a
.p . n 2.
-i. ,. .. i .:
. w. . . y .
.p.
..e. ;- .. p . ,..;
i L Q L -
;_ ; .- u(.. .. j . -
9
. ..t- t- ,
.e ,; ; -ar ct a :6. .:4
- j- 0
.e- i. . _i .s. ,. ta .
'r - V -C "2.hQ m -: U. It i- .F-
?
- Wj ;-
,"yf ,
'7I! 1'E t -
'.' _ - -~{.. };.
- d. ti
- g. . . 4;. ,
Th-i ::= . c.if .1 : =. ! H c; i; St:
.~.2:-ic ," h are a: ?. a gi. : i-~; :: . L;;:- . '.m. 1 --
vip .::- -- -;U 6 . h
.i'-:::- .
M
't-
-ii . . i. s .-
w ei t .r - 3. Nr .- . .: lc. :a :_i ti . e i. -- , g
.h.
1.. 4 l 2.: .l.: g i- 7
. J un .L . t -/ +: : .c i:1 1:. .
HJ. . '
':, t.: . 4.. :.[-. .. :-' .,,,, p ,, ,
.t :
. ;:- ,~.: :. - :a :4 J. ! r.. .. . :.m :. U e T .1. } :. : { .; . .
.4.. ,
4 a: . % Ji - .-l:. 1W : .]' - a.. J..;. . . ..'. . a.: i . .l . . . an . m
,d o
( .,..; . . - . ..; ; .
... 3 -. _.:
i k t .
- p. 9, .4
- H :
. y. . .
.: .t.-
, g
(... , .[. ~
' 60
- :: t 1. : .c l. g J. T. -. w i.. .
^- .j k4 g
..l.. - d. I.h ' I-!
*L
*l l'
; g e ::F - . r- -
- .p tj- - :- e . . :.
a ,
.t- .
t r .p-
~
g' -H 4~ g
' s: .
3 r .l.- 6-- f.. .
-[
- e ..
k U' I .j,
~.-
h c
'*"%I i. : - f~~
q
.j.3 .! - y 1. .y- h 3 "!-' i ). 6-f -M-- N Q "-? --
y.N- <
- r. *p L:[:. . .l.
. ' " t
- r. - --
' ' ~
i 4 - [ ; .; U s.. C- -I ; L, 4 ., f- .. . Pf- g 4 P' 7 7 s.
.t .
< T1.
it. i- . )g~ M ,- a_ ,4=;q MT ___. D._ I C?D, . '
..3 'l'v.= b g.*.-r, - . _L . g%.M*
;g I.. * - <
.d L#_h ;
W c i _.:' .:; 2.
.".:*t ::. "a-C .n . ;, .-- c i
- i. %,,a s l.- ..
L a. _
.[
g . ,
+- x
.: a 2.
1 1. 6
,1 g ,. g, g j- - .
gt
. L. -
r - 1-I: '
'i i :l u ! -
. o o o e ~: . .. c.
o
- o. 3
. c.
8 n a o . o o o add *esue==y and entpos e3/sequa 2 *assna
*! ud -
'431432snpws uolais 22
f .~ have occurred (for example between Iby 5 and 10,1978). However, there did not appear to be any significant resin intrusion as evidenced by a cation con-ductivity increase concurrent with a blowdown pH decresce (in the absence of a power transient). On an overall basis, chemistry variations appeared to reflect a gradual though long term cleanup. As a result of condenser cooling water.inicakage, relatively simultaneous increases in sodium concentration and cation conductivity with a negligible pH change would be expected particularly during power transients. Several such chemistry transients t' occurred during 1978. In 1979, blowdown chemistry transients became considerably clearer with respect to probable cause. If one focuses en interpreting the chemistry transients which cou.o be associated with resin ingress, the transients in late February to early March, mid Ebrch, mid May, mid July, late July and mid September warrant consideration because of the significant cation con-ductivity increases above normal levels. Therefore, a review of these () transients was undertaken. During the chemistry transient on February 27 (Figure 5), blowdown cation conductivity increased to approximately 25 pmhos/cm concurrent with a pH
- t. ,
depression to 6 even though ammonia _ concentration was increased. There was a negligible change in sodium concentration associated with this incident. This transient clearly is associated with a resin intrusion, the extent of which is discussed below in more detail. On February 25 immediately prior L: to this incident, a simultaneous increase in sodium concentration and cation conductivity occurred with a negligibic blowdown pH change. Th'is transient was associated with the power reduction on February 25; it does not evidence the characteristic blowdown chemistry response to a resin intrusion. On tbrch 24, a similar transient occurred (Figure 6), i.e., cation conductivity increased to approximately 5 pmhos/cm with a concurrent sodium concentration increase to approximately 350 ppb. No significant change in steam generator pH or ammonia concentration occurred. The magnitude of the sodium and cation conductivity increases were similar to those observed during the February 25 power reduction before the major resin intrusion of February 27. i 23
e .
/
4 e d :f.-li A H a-.: b a-= #-r . O .4-a -i.e= r4 -
'-H - -
n .: l 4 -.] . ' i - Jj p
=p--)h-ACSNTF-ht.WIrv3%=Fm@w-:-t=-4-== i- %
gi M ii=T i= --E g, B e.v. .
=r,t- -w;@i =i== : r m.a-:= t=1-a.: 4_u:-4 =r2:i .
.,g m y ... -_4_m= g.a. : ; -3 ; q. . . 973 4. y - y . g v.g.-4, g M-i= : ~-I y -i-r j =. :: i. Ni =.4. r.Hf' =ri. . i: . .:l =. F. t: ~ .t. i =t.-h t- / *i .J.=. : k. . t..=. 4 . i =. . ' =. i=P.-T
~.
- =*:4: = ~=Il : =31! 54 i=rt -=IE=hh! Wi- i=2-F 6E IM=i3:G '=.=-!Gi-= b
= ~ 4 i ='
Z=W' === ~ % =K = ^ =
^
6 W-4 h~- #= V 'i= ~Q =i i= =
;... - .. =i=i-M=- .r. ; ===i-=-:h=-i J =~-it
.- . .i. t. h. i=-- :.=_ :r:3 : s:-m : . i -.- . . . -. i . _
- =:5_a -= .::-V F--i =iit = w _ _._ %:-li-t= 1 : i =t.:-p i;=i j=:jf= ri =2 :r P:==u-E_-d'=-5 c.=-t-4== ==
k 0.6 MNIM=" Nb}NDNi5u ;=.=ie E=I-N3NFNN 4-i=i Ei=s=F==JM:=i=F=Jf+=b=1 =#=i'=P=4= =-+ s= rim = mi_=~i :; .:4 4=Mg:==fe
-W= *i i~ E'!= '=~ ~ '% =;==b:lin
^
M=L '
'= f&
~~~iI -4 'T'~' I'd'5*=E*'"*
~
?*
0.4
*i" ".I'H**5'd
- m2 =:- #%=~-f.j-:.+=Ve=:&Q.d.V@hEi=Y
+\ h=i= n9==tn h-==-L-Rt==4-E=M=t==#E+2 =si+=ubi:Mi'= ==
4 l M.M ;=i=. -u:=.=i% i-+ 7iE==i'==5-l W4= E= = i==ii^iE h:-I.M E9is-i=d =/= 1 =3"li.E=rl =5='.*: D 52 /I_.7"CE*= !I-l!MEON= I -Ni:9N~NENi- ~~.
= -
rQ:F;i=M.N- riMWidi-i =iMM .-. =fid=i=.: J4 MiE E EM-fEI~"i-E=E=d E M
.--I=.=.=.
. - . -: = s -: -a = . ~.= = :== .=& ==.E
- s. , o .~ . - - - - ..
-- . h.w,= w: = =- -=-* = -
- -: .-- r- . ---: . . ------
W -$*="==N =~t- bli5N==*~"jF i - .=E=E=Cl-52.ENiE5.i=5--~5 M IN NEi 1-c >> mm wa== = . x= mEmew== kt = i: = :.===-38==;iE=+it =EiG=-?;;;Enfi ~ =ieE- :- i:-T; -G- :~ -
- --a1 Eu 4E 'Ek 7. jgj ;7,; =3t=3=j-:gg;=:,
g 0.20 __,;_ig__j=g :q=g, g-igg = :=g==~3-: En:i=j==2_=g;_;,__
= ~ - __. .;._ . :: . -1.= 5. ===~= =- =x- . _.:=
a, - - . _
. . l yA. :-. .. : =. ==w =. .=:.=- ==.=-=.._.=_-=:=_5:= s
--. =. .-
._ _x -. .
.==..p...====m.==--
- m - .< -.: =. === = - - -----:-- a . =a= : :=.:.
= 0.15 -
w== := =.. g = _= - = :- =. .x=. - r=4-
\
. p._;2wp = = ==5*~=^ '== - ^ ===: = : _~3 5_- g-.55 3=_=_p' 5.=y = =.=.====:.=_.=25====;-- ^ - = = =u
. - . , . - ~' ~~~ * ~
* *' r -
,ru__s..;=.=g'..._n_-_'_'__=..=..---.--..-.._=.-.t._=1:--.-m'.-._--
- ~
'8 0.10 ;_"g=_
- a ^ ^ ; ~ ~
.; _ * ' gg ; -- - :q.-5:5==
p .2= .
=_.m' e : =3 u
.._,-.i. 'p h. 2 A- M-MWMl=?=0 =FND'MEEN-MMl T ~1-" -bl-55EE5E'I ~ E we _- _..
o.05 g4g=3=gg,gg_;mg5g;___g,;_3;p,=gggggf3=g=;32,c,__=,=_2;=_==# y=g
=_==u=...;.=... =: y:w ._ ..
g:. _;--
. m. .=- .g =-4._._=,:3-g=.p. -. -.._.u.._.=_.m....._.._._-= . __ . -- ===.
-:=
- _ 7._ ;_; ==s;- ;;I:=y==i ;g;
. . 0 ==-4== g=;_=ag 2 - ja 7gg =j$=~ =:g-5jgjst-= _- igg-E=_ .._==-,=_r---.: -
.---w_..;- ;
-- . , . ---: - .= 1. .
- ..a u._,_v.----- - = , . -
- == :-- .
._;==;_-n-=-==.=_-,-,a:.==.,==,-=-_=_==-.=:=..=_-:-=1-=.-..--
20 , .- ===. _ , = - - . ._,_:_-
.=;= = ,==._r=,. ._ _ _..._
_ _r- A_ = t_=-r. _ : : : . == - =2_ =uc- -_-: ==- :-uz- - == - .=:-._ .m _ . -
=E"g==.Eif==-s-s7:5h ME-=Et=4 m =FTI L-@=~-'Ei .~ ~!=-iU-G P=E_E=Mri5EE =
6==i=t="i : ="4 i=+11== J.# s R=li-EJEE=7 ~ =-ihi'itE'iE E!!=:E4E. EiFiK4-ff=M:="bE=? Z=;-slE=i=--U95;iEEi+T - 6=-isiE#iErf4@E=izi!Es:i== T="-i-EbE -=iN#*li -iE F=iM=TE"E4=J ii L~1E=Ei-EEE i=m = ==!=d=%.LJMGGNU=r=F.LG:=S-i=iE-iiEi=i&4==.~. i- i-Q= D E47: E=~ --~ 2: =~=M5:=i
= =Wi-T-f=='E-i = =j7J --if ~ ~=i4'" 3 :.=lT=EMEit="=55tF5=M=G iE=
t e E-;&=E:' DJE-i-E;EEi = '-f=_=,=EiI=isiEi::ii4MiE=sd2 JT'=s#i"-i-44-?=f=M=Eis: f '==3=. =~V=FE(EEE' #E~~- k' !~I' ~ EEL =:'ERlE=^ i=#t = FQE=~='r-iCML*=W=i';3EEEE1= L'~~D W'=
- = 22 Ei:-M=.dEiRM EiEl=-' E: i?_E=~iE-E:'=15E5-11J=
?#;)i=_iE_=t 1 - #c.i :M9;t-T~~----~'i=~=
= Eli=EIEEi--Eli ET51=EiEl "= C ;-l=i-ME=-i==EsE 5:i=l'iE== :l :: :iE iE
=H==EM =l:iM=N# .
.=:gf :=7g43g1;rgsp= ;;7,c==.5pg=g n
10 = gg cy_s 3sjagggg g =2 =s- 2$ arggt , ;_j=f==I=L==EE!== -EF4-E4E=fEi-E'=i=i+E==i=='=taK gg24m.;g= ,
=i~=' *:l: 3=34 t"~&=d=-'= =r*
0 :=i.E.Ef Els5 =="
="i: 1 9 st C==- M jgpl =E= rim ==t= = =Eidd E -M5'=Liitt= d=3?==f=si =M:i=SistR
=
(,
$ F-it i~E,:.=113i.i=? sa:I.?izig =-lj i-t ad'i: 12.5-i-;7E3 j=W=-j =3=_lE_ts;=d=
y = = = _ =2.TfEi-iV.I! .
-i =jf=iE'i--- ~-hie"=1 i5
.ju af=~t MEGiiD- si?-
5 t=t2aiq = i=: : 5lwF1;:i= =y:Mi.c- lEiYtis@i!N ==!-
+ = E i-12=rEi=-
m: 2=-fiq:=j!5ii.i=E pi p-him.i =a=g-en-13=g=jri+-is-in 5 R irj=c -iT-t".=iM;i '-hylt= < Wi!~M2= "ihiE=!Hisihi=5 fti+ *it! -i==iEi%-E E O iT-f :+ =Mi @ l
- i ;-- 91:4--iii. =El T-iE=JiEE =-!E9'P#4E-iE4 52i-* 91=tlEi+15:tii-0 ti Mmr if ==.k iM :
i i=[=FM=niaW#t:P.Mi .kt::k ==5E}.5 i=nwi=biE 21s=1Mt=im M.a =MS c== hie = E*-l "r =i=.s=f e=:Ei==i=eil Mia =mili=Es.k-i===li=1 tem:.=pI:5 L, 0 5-59. -==.-z-i5: .. *:d.-s.:=}=-;5=r.=-;= hr.ejr _gagg=}_=.j=g ; .ig gggg s;==_g-a. _pIj E M==E" =iE.==21===9 die 2 mi ri=:- . =r@l=s2El=E!E! :-W=im:?-d=K:s=-M=t-Ei=t
===
=. 2 i=jiip=r.4=l:'.:;j=2) = =j= ~ 1 R=.; =F:i.;A _=_ ? E i =.. -d=-l7..fi i-y=. sig.5j E
==iE: = = =>-J -n,V:ini-i:i-:= .525= s-45' -K-w ' =;=}+= .E=.=igy=f; 2.T._ i-fi- =T =l w
M .- r=..._:: .:_ 4.1 . i m -- .% =:gr-T ' T- e-A7+1il e v i=H =-0 -
+f :i1=5
~; _-p= !_:.=-W:; - &! .4--r- -y-i -E i--
. ::., :;-ily . 42.-
,. iEj;=-/="F . I-- ziip.3- .:.ie :
.:; ;.._;_..=_ .y .: 5 .. . g. ._._ .g . .-. i -4 y.5. .;. ..
-_:=, ;y ....a . ; . q. .. .
._ . . i.. _ . . . . .. .._
- . - =i--p_d.;c-j= [f qii= egd :ei.Of_a; .; gi_ _
r=l-a-f
.. - j= - :"y ar in==l=tf EI:- J fdE=
0 1 5 10 20 25 February 1979 March Figure 5. Steam Cencrator A Blowdown Chemistry (February-March 1979)
~
24
e . e i;irie
- .4 c : l : u; { i . d.'. J l : : -F l i .- 3 ~j: t a l' ii M al: = =1 # --4 -i.: ! - : ~
=..u .;p g.; . ~_ gt _;. .- ;;=4 4_ j m _%w g-j = . sc.+rn..r w:
Q W g.rf-QQ=W -WfWW% yxX E ~:}='~i=^=Y -
-4:=b. - 6 1-"+ :-N=-i qi-:=1 : _ i L " " :: :HR*}'a=.= 4 : - : ='9F" -
I-'- r ^ : =:=*:=r d'=i + : -= -! =i =3@= i== =i :%
~
; ririr '.:== ::? & ': ut= mi'ci -
g v_$.:._-W =,:.b -H n=I+-i?i' =U=jls-il43E1. =i Eis;ii_5:=i"-l -c=:Z=~~-f-fi:V.:ii::iim:i"-iM
- = = i ===-4 ===?=R: ~--@ --#-i==f.0 = r:3yi=. !-% d is=E. i - i " 3-i-Yi's
;!= : r= +N.!- h--ir 2 =i- I i E 2 #= i5-i ~Y4-
.MIEi T a---- 5 i _ ; ; - :-il . :-- II.T: h iM -3 ~ -
r- wUT =P-Gi C _-i =l .d E = ire =:i ei-=5 -f73 ="---i '=i:= EM='.== u=3: ~i+- N-i
.iL -=IS= =
ji 4 i.d u p f.q ; N ' p.ri7-i=4 n: :El -#i=-id=i;=_c==i--j-MIi==Eii -ZP- 55-' =t:i=:ii: :===I 2 J: i+-h= =i i- t = :=f C+%: =i=~i== &+ i d=E-"fli=i==+ 3=r*Ei"
- i ^Mi= W-? = - G i =1 =T W-:E=
T-'i-' _-i-Y-f2 -S. i :i'=i#"E.-E : -P-i--:E-l E'ii?-i:M5 ~? =f== :
~.:f~ *5 'I #M k -
- H:'5E :ZiE: N "I
- * .f9:=i = =i=M-A : -- =\ I F -leJ - i==i- 5= :-i = ==3_-ii E=iiEd =91==i O W :-ip ; -- [ i :-: _.=rji- : r bEi!J:iP Z-9Ei =2):; - =3-?== iEi =f'JIi-il.i:E-i' = '=.:'-=E-M #:M%
8 0.2 3_m ;g_p, p.7; 5_= g,;==_=ijg_g.y_3;= gig =:_;; gj=_;g3__ig2 =g =;t _,g g 3;=_y3 42,=r==,__
--ii 'E E+I=i-*-' =l+-i' 9 -EWf==Pi+Pi ==-StfMii
- E r #i 9-Wii : : NUSi#l'5~ TJ ! = =
-~r=M=i=i=- W =P=~t.s =M" i 3+51:-E= i .=b= =='-isi:i== G i=J- =" r! =i "_"#=F t=i =Q 0 5 5 --@NE'- -5N Il N E5 ' ' ~
di=E- --i =i=idb'5it:2 -Ji=i :!!=i#li-i -5Ei-~~=--F:=~i=di=:i i sii-N-i --=E=li:~Sr=29=~-E:SM C. _: _ . i. . .-I_ = r. _ . ;._ . '- _ R.+. . _= i =__-i_=. 2=_==E. .i.=_3=. ._=.'.= = 1: ~ T_l=J.E. _19. :=E ":0 --Z- . - - - . - X_ .E. =_=_. _ . 339. =. .^_:a. . r"
~ . . - - . -
i E- =-" ":E#i'It=ir- 1-~J .iG T==tfrIT 41+"' . "" -"f =f :"-iE# d=. i-f _Js-- lr--EiZ@_~ _ 0.4 b~~EUI-i-5 f'N E!- -- 2 2=NE WEs N EEN NS-I#Ni#N*~
--i5 C- : _.:== _--- 5~ H;;= =E!Z _ . ..re:=ai=-E:NE-15$555 .i. .-25=5 =
E 5:5:i=;i=-l= ==i --E = r==
. _ ._._ 3. q _. _3_ _. z._ . . . _ rg- _ . - _ === :=_ : =_. =. .q3=.=. N.==.: ____-1T _ . - . . - - : . .:=:=r g_- 1=3. ___ :_;
., ._ .n_ . __. 5pc;._ j =2.
; .""Mi#i- .f-"-i=~i?-i=V= =it == r---i:U r===- r==J3E:: =E x
- Q ==_55_ . _g=_ _; y. _;u5=. 5_m. _ =gn Ei 3 ?i - E fi_ E_f_=~-E~T=~
_=-.45=_ 1 ;_ ;=- == ==: 995=-- =55 y=- =1 -1.-g._i___ _=__ _ . ., . . _ _ u= =_._ _ __3 _ . .;_- __ _._= .,_- 0ee. ..
. ..y: g, _ - = - . . =. . . . . _ . ..._._., . . - _.- -.5. _
- _=- g =:----->__. . . . . . . .
l, :=. : = . m...._.;;..._...._.....=_..=_=....=___%_-(._m- r_ .a _ _ g.:,:J,=;r
=. _ ;=_2 ;
=_5. ; .=_5_=_3. _ __a. ..t_ _.:_=p. . _ _ .5 . =..r;.
g _.
=- _ , -(;=z;=c=, v- _=g= =_.y== =-- === y-
=== _: == =_ .._ ._== . _:=w~ __; _r
=- == -- ~. - _- -r -r:- t==:...-==;_==
= .=- : := . _ - _ _ -
g O 3 p:_E m_- :f
- tf=F :5-F =- . ='.- " -'"""EfiC#:E TJ:Ei=disiE=i": ' pie i::M:.i M= ~:-P='si 0 i:E i - =i= ; - ==P.=!=Y ~=~_ - i=M:-izTi-~=i - Tsi *=aE=f= h=t4===X-iEtEia 3
- iK=H #!Tii f=Es:-i -ii T:; /r-?;-l3EIIIiE=E='i '=-Eir" 7 .Z M=-i ===ifE-i== ":- 4Ef4 _
tiri-= d' .'i=5=1-t = 'ir-I: i=i =T= ri=i=$ - =u- =-itiI=i != 3= ==?= -MJ E-i=E e?"jiii E
= -4_. . 5_.=._q:.E. _= t ._ =. =_; .=. =.*.=.=.=__j=__._-2=.-i.E J. E_=. 4. i =.5. :__fe;_=_ e.=_ .=. =_cj:_+_ 5-E_ I. ;.= _- _.". ._=. _d =: =_=_ : =. _- _
~
g
.:.e:-.-a_ =. i=j _. - . _._ .:=i. .=. :_i:._-t_i_.E. _._.Z ~
= _= = l=_d. a, w : a. _ . F_ E ==s_ En -~._ .~.. _~_h.r : Z. i.=13,=_
=._ . _=..i:. 2_ =. $= .c-.
.-: t=
=.=.=.'2_=_-.=1...=.&...=.+..E...-. -- ====.=.L_ -i .1E=&. 5.*._=. =,=_:~n.M.i=i.=._
- -- - - .eEE.:_=3==. n _ . -5_2 +- 1.=_}___ .E_E+.=_ - _=_
.=. =. . .. _ - =5. ; .. . .
-' ~ . =. :- .
.N 5 .=_.=.2....
. . . 2. _. ; _a. _s.r. 7 == .3. .. _.-
_: _ q._:.: pc.q=. .=. . =. ._3._=; .g; . i.c4 33. __p._;_3. =_.4
._ . y__=. =_=.j __ __. =. _.
s ,3 _ r r . :.=3 ;r..- . :: - . - _ . - - ;_ + 1 -;.1 ..r.a.. g:-- L= 7 ; 1 _, .. : :.r a * =_; -
. . =, = : .r:- 2-._-_. .._.:- - ==i-:1.t:=
. ._p--.
a = _ :-- _. :---:===-_~----<-==_=-=:- 3 e .
-1. ..
o _y5: 5h-; _=1 5 E F ITJ_-IEE:~F=E 4 2iF;fI!I=~2-a ~ fred"f H li=r""i M =i- E 72ri=li=5EE E31,-l==i;i!! = J: * [s = Ei si=-l
==. 5. =.
r+.:= P Fif=!*f-idE EIIj=i =i PE;iEINh=1_i -~;= !'Eiid=:=it-5EiME- f;s" = ==t L. ==T{i_=1"_. . . :_=. y ==-a-
== = =:E. =;=. ..=1___ 1-._==j- -i=5
.r- _== :- a. n _q. . _ .=r. ..=. .=_ . r - _ . - __ .
j - =..t. .. . u y . - .- . . . 5f2 E _ -f. =11-Q=J=t E iEiE-E m 7 -i.i=_l--i:=l #ii ri=iii:fisIFi-551-FEs=Ed c=i' K==2-si2*= RTE: U 7 .EE-i af+1:+-!Ti-#=12 +=- i=S -*=t ==iTEiz- 1 ='I! L T==fiisisiE=i=E!3= =P iE*FEinE:"ii
=
l dMf=k= izeiS =f=L*f=s11=%Yl=fP*='l-M^=WRii=Eis-ifMe- W- 15:il=w=_1512= 6 1 Z%M -i % g-E!=3:TifEIN _l ?.2:i'-M_W.--F -E :W#=-i -~'~ lE=iE
=M M L "JWz =2- -! :Y i ="* t\#EA i=r- r tid =.ds==2 == M_= i=fmt%if :-55E
~
b =t"' r Ei-sf-l ti I Gj==ilO =ff-iMEi'-iE 2iI=3lE309.d"- ri=M ~ i #i=l -!='E=:=E
-5= fi-- -Ei Li/.It=lY=it=:!=~E 4i-ihtEt-s =il-l==l:#=hi=: -j'= !M=ti =-} :Er :-i-M i i = =m r h 2
}i>i= i;=iFi != - = W= I * =I" = ="~ #- E= 5 iY-5 "i== N= =i W== =NH C 0 = = . -fi .- ;-n=p1= .=j.jj'_gj- = =j:-ij:-[1.ijij.f_rj i_i=.j_2d _=j==;[-j= :: 21=-
--p -.jg=.c=q0-pgi 4iiN .cr Ti ? #--EE.itiMl=s"+=""9=i=%=iq'i IPME! iO =L+6= .5+ ==I+ =-5;i=r._=ia.rr
=i5 :-t- O .r is:=-4 # -=+*#E'i.-lM-b=_ . - i i- :=i =ts::E" : - i-- Ih _m..-d=-i="=: - . - - '
200 N- -I -#1'-MNi-TE=5= 5 V NI4=E 'M *F=P~".='1 ===iMEW= . .
= 24 + v =/ ia-4 r= 2 := fi l s = = ' ~:.=-.'c=i=I=i-i[-
- === === = =1. .-+rr_=1..-F- 1 .._=rs =:r=-
",- =T" -d'~ f OI- 4I I' " l-
- 2*ii 4 'i"-I i=TI5EI5I"5=" A-II '
=i= : =ir e r : ===- -i=1 t. 35 4:i=$ i h - .r=? :=="4"=- C2 ;"ipiiy'.u.=;k iz i-i! 6 50 ' -
O a. l pi-2 7 3- . _-r c=u Essjin+ y=j=j-g3 j;-i,=a +_i .i j r. ,E_ _ :--[yg__4-_i ggg_}c .=Er2+ 20 25 1 10 15 April March 1979
. Figurc 6. Steam Generator A Blowdown Chemistry (March-April 1979) 25
e f> In early and mid May (Figure 7),' simultaneous increases of sodium concen-tration and cation conductivity occurred during plant startup af ter short duration shutdowns. Again, these incidents ~ appear to be associated with a shutdown /startup transient and the return of chemicals from hideout.
- Similarly, blowdown chemistry transients on July 15 and July 27 to 28 exhibit the characteristics of chemical return as a result of a power transient-(Figure 8). They do not appear to be associated with resin intrusion. The transient on July 19 to 20 (and possibly July 25) exhibits .
E' the characteristics of a resin intrusion, i.e., an increase in cation conductivity without a concurrent increase in sodium. That ingress did . occur is supported by comments in the plant logs: "D and E vessels broken due to high AP from excess resin". t In September 1979, several chemistry transients were associated with plant power variations (Figure 9). However, on September 10, an increase in cation conductivity occurred with a pH depression of approximately 0.3 units. Since
no sodium increase was observed, this behavior appears to be associated with .
resin intrusion. That a minor resin intrusion did occur is supported by the plant logs: "Powdex vessel damage when placed io service". W' ith a subsequent power reduction to below 80%, cation conductivity and sodium levels increased simultaneously without any significant change in blowdown pH. This transient 4 (September 12-17) reflects chemical return f rom local regions in the steam generator.. Based on the available chemistry data, it does not appear that any other significant resin intrusion incidents cccurred during 1979 or 1980 (through March 10). . C- In submittals to the NRC, three miner resin intrusions into the steam generator following the February 27 intrusion were reported as having occurred. This observation is consistent with the result of our review if it can be accepted that the July 25 transient was associated with an intrusion. v I s 26
"e pa 6
%e g
; * . h- ,
4 _ k* E-Nh.,hiN' $ - ai'h*.h'~
'b-~ Nh5NN.Ni'- .
.- 'h = a.
[. - 2 bf)$= hh = f ~. 5ib"; h["'i Y I B 2: _ ..-~ e ;
- . . . . ._ a. _ . .+.. -2. . .m_ ;- _:_.=.+a__ =. .- i _i.=._;=w. . .u. ._ . .;._..=_:-
-t.,g;;_........_._.
=..F_ PV. "i2.=.= =_-:.!I"!Wi"MWi34=s?MM#d-f:E2
.:+. =_:;._ -. i =.=. ,t :
g L S:*Jl'Or __"~M E"T= aEli:i-' Ei"#E -
';N5E=-iMinfr@.#:i?.f:ir.ds: ! .. ~ .f"JL'EN. .";'..1:J:fIf a__:4N -'If-=~~35N'*Mii:~5~'~=fr-$
~
I - 2.r=- n-- :r== :-=~ r .. =-- - sn . .. ..-:: .- --- =--: =_ =. . . _. .: .: =:- r :=:-:--- = = -- ="- .e.==::=._:=. - - =.=====- =:===:~: = = ~: = :' * ::: ;: =..== : =i'~*i
.. = =_:: . u =. . .=.:.--
.--- - ;* m *-- - - ---- .-- _ .:. = = :_ :..u== r:-
* - =.: .: _ --
. =_ 9 ;.="r: *.*_ . 'r:=: .r:
^
*=*.I=""i- .2.. =;- ===:.r:;.. . 1:=. - .. _=...=*.=L::.~***.T._
_?-*- = .'.t.=: :.=. .=._.r:- . . . . ._-
*_ =. 1-r =:=" - . .---=:- . = . n. . . _ . -: =:- := r - --.. . . _ . _: =. =' '"':~-. .'.
3.=:..~ =-- :=r - :-- 0.6 '_F" :._...in" ='E" iI"-7" E=.=ta =. :=_' = - .:=r=: = . : :. : ====:= =.% -=" .-- - -- =: r=:--F
= w . : _ : : ::..; ._===:. _ - .; :. -
- r. :_.:. . .:*:.;; * ** %: _
E *_:*g=.-~*.^..=*._-'J*: _ . _ * * - - - T* _ E . .2.i .-.. :: ......__*-.._ . . . _ -
=~=~F'93i4*i'~=-**===.,::;--*,.--*.-***"....--r..=_.._._-,,=.-...==...=......*=......-..--
\- a6 g3
~it. I:=-L::E: . a - .-.= .- .=b=E =:: = - =_==E=r.L---: - _. r; _ :-_:_
n --E--: = i ~E-=-'.'J:
- - .- _: - .= - -.
= .== m:.=: m_ =.a=.:===:..-.:.a=_c====_.-,.=_:.=..:,.=a=_=.=.=.=:-_-_-.=.....r::.
. = =:==. :_ :._
,. .- . = ~- . .r.:
1:w; ::: . :: .- .;. _. -g. _ _.f.*~~._ n. _ _ . . . . -. =. .._, _ -==. =. ._= r. =_ .__=.:.:y.=_ .2. _. ;. _._.5. _ _ _ _ _ _-..5.y_: . _ . __%___:5.-
- .=._ . . =-.= . ."*,' . . =3=
0*2 _ - ..a _u.- : =.m,=~=-~= - - - - - - - .
- .s;-_: :--::=- . =..: :,.;.;,:-%= =:- -= ;=. - -- - :---: := =
- .= : n a: _:=_n ===: -- - .g:p =: ~::T::: ' . --- .
= a o. _==_ .
~
. E;i:i_t! .i-a. d=== -. -~~ " r_==E. 5.::W_ .e.;7:.. _. '# . ~._=+ =. . = = - : ;==-_ ;- -. ; .r_ - d.=:==-.:=. - : g-
~
0 ~~ -- M- - - - - - -- - ----
-s.-==.u---
--~~=----.;q
- - =- ==a _=:_=. . .::; _. 2.: _-. _ _=.. =-: .=:.: _
L.=:.:,=;: :. =.= - _== = =.;. -
= =.=---=:==-_-:-==--:--=2=.=.=---- - -.. := - : :: =. _.. . - _----t
==-_ = = - .r.: r 2.= : .__:=---- _ _- : =-a.- -
=--- -
- - =
g, g,gw==.===.==..=__...=_==.;==_...=___=;=._._m.._:=====----=.=.=;=.,._.;__.=-_.=_=_=._=.__=..__,--3 u _._ .
._.:--. __, - - _;-:: .__._.4
__.=--=_w__..m. .:
-=.=...-=-----_=.._-..=:=__
.2 ;;: -.__..a_=..- .=.=_.=_-===--____:=--- _
- ......_----__.._.__.l=...;=;._-=.._...:=_==_=.._..._=;__;.;_=__=.==..__a_;__.ag.
u; __._..=_ _=_._.,-.. _ _--_a._
. _ . . - . ---__;._ _-..=.-- __
. . _ _ _a- _. ;. .;_-- . .= _--_. ; w. - :
._-t===::=t....=-==_-__:==:.-4..:.-___=-=-------:-==.:==-:-=_==_=--======-t. = =_ . 2 - _ .;; _ ;- - .
E4 !. _:____ 0.6 _;._-.".-_._..-___u=..=;-_--,,.-___._3__.;--7_---...:::=._._;-.=-.=_.=:n__.;=-._..__._:d
.=
_.u._ =-:._2._ . _ : . . _ . - _ _ . . . .
. ... - _ ;- -=- .:-- ...__- _a _. _:=.2
____.2.. ;..= =..;-._ .---__.- _._ .- =- g ._. . c, _,.;.; .;_;. __ a-..__-._ -_. =__.._.- _--.
. . - - - - - =.. . . = = . = = - . . - . -
-..._._...=.-==-- _. :_ . - . _ .
.=-_=-==--..==5_=_~--~==_:_..----__y-.-y.5__3___7=====.=.--.____--:.._:=~_-___._-=.=-
-_._a._-.-
_ __ a __-_._.._ -
. _ _ _ .,-._Y::':-....__..__.__..,.,-.___,,_
g _-__ - _ _ ~ _ _ - _ _ - - , _ _ _ . . _ ~ . _ - - -- . - - -
-- -- n
=_=______~=_;=__...._.._______a_=.===...-.____--=_.=.===______..-=-:_----_-.-
g z;.=- ._.u. ._-
- .=_.~=.=._....-_.==;=_=-.___---..==___-_.
__ __ ;__. .g__:: - _ _._...-_____.---:=_----.===._--.._==.._t __=.-- ss __. -- ... = _ _ _-- 2~ =T= ;== .~.i~=_=;-f3== !'..= __ ._-.-... __-.-_:._._== _. - .._ _._=- == _33E -i-- _ = _ _ _ ~2-___=._ , e, 0.2 _: -i - __...__.=;2_=_=_._-----------.__-._..=.:r------ -
-.==-_-.
-==----__=
.s. - _ __. _==:. _.
(,
] 73 .g.:.a.W = ^*. :_ . _- ..__. _. .- : : .==;O== .- - . . . . _ _ . . _ = _ = - - - - - __ _ _ _ . . - - . _ . - - ~ _ - _ _ ~'
m - - - - - - - -
- _ _ = - -- _
- ..=. := -.=: %=a==- - g := _,. 3. ~ . .....-.._.-,--3;,__- rN ==--_. .-._.:_ .----
u_.c .:n w_ .__ - - - : _ . . . .- -= ..- . _:3
= ~ - ~ -~- ;j
---._=..-.=_._=.._u.';..w;.._.--_.~.2.-=_y=.==.._.=_..____.__.__.__=.=_=_=:=:=-=-$
0 a_ :.- ..___=-:.u=_:= _ = . = = = = . . .=_=.=.2--
...._..=_=.__=====r---====.==_:_::.-._.._-
~
- :=-: .
__-..=_===1__-.==-.-.
. _;- _. .. _ _.._=__._: . -=
___ - _ . - . _ =:~. _ _ = = = - - - = ,
= = - - - .= - --=.__-_._. ___. - - . - - -= .. : _.
1$ __----_..--.=_._;._-_-_--..____-._-_.
-A t _- _- . . = __-_ . . - . - __ _ .- . . - _ - - = . _.._-
t
=. _ : ^- -=:====..===_-
..__._:.: a := =.=
===r__
x==--_==,=.--_._.4.=__==_=.-----=_=-----=-=_=_-_.=_.=__=.=.==----__=.3
.__::.-=:----===..=.
r - -- - ---- i :
.r - - - . - =
...__:=-=_.==.-=-3 E
- 3. --
- u_.__u_.._..=_._. ._-;_.._._,-._.__A.__.._._ .m_ .._._.___ . . . _ _ ...__:
_ _ . _ ..-:--_..__=._.___=. u
._. = cur. _
__=_._-.=L.__. _===.==;g;__.-__..._._---w.g__=u_.___---- N - _ _ . - _ . . . _ . _ . _ _ _ _ . _ . . . . _ . _ _ . . . -
= _
..___=.=._=_=_=-----_:;___z_.m
- =-----
" .:r=:- _ _ = . . .: = w _ .._q =: =_.. . . _ . _' ==2:---:=-*3=_=_.a=_==:__:=.-_- rt-- _ _ . . _
._..=_=
40 .=._-_.w=._.== =_ . _ r-- _ : . . _ :_==i=..=....______.._..--_.----=_...=..===2===_=q__.=....-.....
. . = . . _ .
, _:n== . r: .s- _ _ _ . . .
- E;.__..._.=:--- _
=.___..==c=.:=:.____-+=._..._._=x=a==..=--
.% =__.=_.m=;.1=.=_:=.==w-.;.=__=_..:=__t===_==.
_ . . . . _ _ _ = -- _ _ . _ = _ - _ . - _ . = = - - -
~*
.:- -=-. - * =; = :.== L I"== - - -
.- - -- =...:= -_ '__. -. -=-~ =----_=.=-==:_u.=-~..=.:--.-+----=.==
= = -. --.- . .. .._.. .. . ._ ,. ... __=. =.. _.- =_. .- =- -_-- . . _ . . - - -24 r A,
.=_=4__!-=:..-- --=--....._I..=_._. =_r=~dE3 ==
.._....-..-.m==..:-----==---1
._Y_..__._n E -
- =_- = En=~==w : =====i=--======_= E
=o8
.3 _=w=:=-=---_5b.,_=+_.___,...t-=._--w==4.-_.*a._=~m=_=._-.._:=n.=c___.:=-.:_
= :_ ..=
--===.m-*-= - ' .
=n- - - - - :. -
' * - ~
=.'..._-'?- : 1- r=. .=-v-----.._e. __.._..._
*: 1-* .: ;, - -
t-:=. u
- - =s=as3= gg. _:2:.x g Eg; ncz _h_r =-..L.. . i= .;;;;- s=.x;==g=, =d '~.' ; _ _ - ..t===e ._. . . .. .---
.,, ~_..- ..=n__. y=..= =- . = ;==y._=, .
-= ==_=_.==_=_i.,_:._:=..-._m.,__.=_.==.=_-,=_r=-i_=_=_=z,=__.=g
_ _.=2. .. _.__ .. _.=.__:_,=.== = . s=_-;==c _
- = ..:-_-.-
~- a ------.: .
"e 2.a.
= ==.r- y1=- .h3%= =.= :a.===. =-- - - -- - ---- -- 1 x - - --
3 .= =sa - u
, ma =.m_: ,=.-_.-=e. : y,m: ..=-r.
#-=:===En.:-53 .wNDn--,-.= =s.- =g
-:=-_-n .. =.=, = m _. _.- --- .-_..=.- =- .= :--.,.= =. _ = . = _-
r-- _ . =x=..=M=. -M=..
. g<. g
=====v- .. = . . , _ . . . . , . . ~ _ . v-
=...=.=.r.~...-=-u=e_.:_=.=x=.--s===r=+=-.._.__..==__._u=..:r-=_.-.=..=.:;==.,=_=.=_.p
=-i=-,.. _- es . = = _ =r_-- .h.- 2===== =.=.r:/_=E r===
= w .= ::=.v = -.;==:.= .=.*a:=i==.._._=r._.=.~.-...
=.. ::
4~Y =? '1:=.m_7s.n~= -._-~-..=-:=:a==_===.
* - - t =-* : _ _ : - -W ~ _ . ~ .-.-*~--U_.. '
d ggg 3 r=I= =.=. m. . . =. . r. c_ z z__. . .:. =_.EE
. _ . . _ . =. =. . s.- E5 s=+-sc. +. =. . .-===
. - _ . . . . __ue=. .:
._. 2= ._. .:. : :. . - =.=. = 4 -. . - ._ .
M - -5 ..a__:a..w _p :.2p.d.a.h-din =..=.=.". =:. =J3 Ac=j=.d=:_-.i :_.:.-i.- ..:_.+__ . s.-.i. = d. ..=. _.l. _= .=,i
=-E,Ai = 4"$a :=.p.=. _=_0.:.a =.c. . _ .. . . . - -
=-
Je 50 r?B rW5 4E . . ..T.-i@I ?=. "=.!=OiE uG='==4=i;5"E : =_ .E==_Ei~=?a"... =_%-- g i==. d.= =Gi ...E=l.... . . _._.===n.=.:=
. .=? - @'~u~Ii ?E= ===?=a e'" =MO==E ===! ' L2=E- ==r :==U--t=23: .Q .g a.
0
- r
== -bb---
t o :-'
- - r " '=m- '- - ~-r=~=*==='r=- ;w=+=r, =-h ; :='= = = 3r-==12 r= =i .i" '==# i=_ _= = m.2 /-2;=-: -- ==. .i-- =_=
1- 5 10 15 20 L May 1979
- c. Figure 7. Steam Generator A Blowdown Chemistry (May 1979) 27
e a.
;)'
n+s= .c.=n-n==um mtmi-4= -rn-sr=.mrt 5&c2=.=_=Twc- -ww.r =im=m.,:ri :5..; k $$ Y .5-Y=N'==Ji.'ib;^5iE=.NEh?.hTi-!-i@II-Ei='C=M 3=E55-=:'-
~
'- 7" -
~~
- =i ==.5 1 ===:..J=sE #.=:2 J.]
* '=.95$4 *EE ~ .rW==h='. 3-#_=C'TK=?'=DEE=l:'=#=WE5N+T*~NEi"=~-45M~~S
=~r:.S."=% -l .=@ 555TNd?'@ $5!";=!tI5i5=*_#~~-iE50MN==3i-15:5i= #SM 5f~:r55 I=5 5IN 0.6 b IENE" " 'U ~2- NE -- N- 'N
-=
N d-y=.=. _u. . ._. ._ m ==. .=_.3. .
..gm.'.
___ g. =_"=_.
. _ ;g.; . == ._= . --_. - --,1._= --- =.
. ;=.=.
- 7. g . p .z.:.w== -- :..5.==.=. i.=. ai. . -
~=WM:fT -'.# - 2~ "
.=~E=
=E=i=W-i#54= die =W=ri----eE.E5=?=f==W==W- .-
~
l.f.-53 =i d =tIi=~"+ M -M s. M ii~@ T .s _:5E M M M S~"- E._l_I a= # =2f N M ~E .-==ES$53
- 55=lW=&i"'~*~5i%IN-Wr^'? "' ==I-T==n =$
0=4
$M=iE~-9.~.LTR~5E!=2~-4*-'^l~=-5EEGE:
_------=:-.:===_: - _ - .
=: .a : r - . : =.;.====--==.-.=======r.=_=..-,=_=.-=-.._=_=t=g:_p:a.=.=_.;==:=:===m . . = . ---- - ,=,=-
- .-- -m..--:.===- = . -
3MMipE-?5 3~=#=E.dWEfEf""."iEE'P~~_S .~-i~:~1-M@~:$$FEEi!5ME.Mi:iE!=.EEE t !=f=E- .q=g=_th.;i .
=~=."E EiaEl=N .M=P!i"E3=diffstE: ui=EEi ~#~-~-!:2~ c. "t 'l"i!T _ .
-~L
- :i;=ef=TE=fi=2i-E=Wri=E!:ii-P_+Ai=rE=W##:-rW=r*=:.=:="~"f=RiW===sE=G e
- n,1 m
-a = ::= ==,;_;y -- = . = :._- ,_._;_=
p=v =.=:-/= = = =:=. . =.==w_y=:.=
-- == : >:==== .-:==-= ; .- - - . . =:r-
- _gx==-_
. .u.= =__.= - = =
f'
?. D:.= .=.Es.r_. f. _.f.-'.-~__~..u._ r= N_EE- . - 1. .:^.__ r__Z__ -~._. -- ;_: . - :m:..- -_ . .;;; ;; , _- _- - ._h.7.-"-._.',;y--'---.G_.--:.=..-..._
, ;;1-,,,., ,yw ;= ,__
----.__.=;-==--~===--==-:=_:=-====.-yQg =_- :====:=== == = y n 7... _
< _.._=%==3..-...-.~.
==-:u.:-.:==.==_.-.-=.=..=__=_.=_=-..-_c==_._.-_.-------.~=.=:=.,==.:==-:======u=-=-;
- . . . . ..--==u- -
0 .=.- - .
--:=----====::=.=====_=...=._:=..=r..=_==.===--=-=-.=.=-===_.=.=__-_--.:---
====
- -. = --_-., . -
- - - - = = - - - - - . . ===^' '
=
=_- . - . --
- .=-.ra=.:-=_.-_._-=.==:--u=..-.===a==.~:==._:.=-====.=_._-..=._=_=-i=+--- _.-
_s _ . _ , - _ _ =.. _-.. - ._=---=._==---=-l
- . -~ - - -
.__ L x. -T- . - - =:__
'" : ==- - _====:__-.~~~~:(=~----_=__ ..
_.__;u=._-.._ _- _ - - .__ - - . . . . _ - _ - -' _._. -=:-=
=_----===E'-~
-~
.._====.u._.4
_-___:.---.a_._.- ------
-=JE E=E =. . _ -- __ -- -
0.4 a
- . - .== - --======.=-----.==-.3.:.:==-=------==----_-----==-.
_ x =__ _ _ . ==. r -
.=_=..q__,..
- = _ . _a=._.w _. __ . a .c =.__ __
.__.- -----=_. _-
._.__-_.c_ MEG._..:.e_=_-__._._._.._._-_.._-. .: .__ _ . _ _ ,,__s'
.=._..__;-.__._.__
. - __- .___.=.._ ~
_ . _ _ _ _ _ - _ . _ = = =. _ _--.~~'=- ( l _
.n.--.___ .._:__._ . d- _. _.._.. cr- _ . _ _ ___ .__
.._.-=..
.._~._.___=.____.._,__..___2..= _____________.___--
, =--- -
0.2 ._._.=_;...y=a=.==-=_:.,s_r=_s.g======__-..==.-.=--
. : _ __ ; - - . . ._-3 -= = _ ~ - - -- - = - = .
n :=-- _ . =. - :-~ ==u _: . .N.==. --.. _ . .: - =.. . ;_ - r:_ __.-=. . - - - . . _ . - - - - . ~ _ _ = - - - - - = = :== 4 _ . . . _ 3 t=-=- .- r_._- -2;i;E~~- - == = E ='*'^=~*
= .=. r . _ . ,- ._-=
M-.- ;;- == =_3
' ~ '
1' v $ m 5:[=5~j-
&tz w_.;. .= =_= -- :=._._ === =.~==W=_=rr=
iEW-St$5%Y-Wa. .= =f2-.g:=y==.=__;rrht._: = =?'^ -?=. = = (=--
- u .. ,
= . = . = _= . = ,.-- -.-=-
n +=__=,==..___===__r-.. . _ __ = .__._ _ - . = - __.___.__=_=_..__._.:-._..______._._=--
. . - ._ - - - - - - ~
_ . = . ---a._..._a==_... a --- n- _- _----
..=._.__=._=-.-..=.-_.___..-__._.=.__==_a.
. . _ ...: x =-
. _ . _ _ = = = . _ _ _ . . _ _ " - -. = _ . .
- _..g
= :p- =.:=n .--- - - - - - - -
_ . _ _=_...__ _=__ =:;___ . . = . _u=------- v g .._.__==-.=.,.=__;__.=_.:-....-_. _ _ ,;a
._._.-.-.-=__._.;;;t=..=._=._=.=..._._ . .
. . = . = . _ = . _ _ . _ . _ . . _ _ . ._ = =. ;4
. _ . _ - . - - _ = = . = _ = _ . = . . _ = _ . =_. -_..._=l
.==-_____,
=_=_=._p.__.=_--_ _ . _ - . _ . . = = = . . = = - = = . _ _ .
(, .____=2_:.. . _ _ . _ _.._._.._ ___ .,w _ __. .==,_._-=._~.=_;._______,___,_.__;.__._-.y
-r...- _
y _ _ . . _ _ _ ==. _ . - .- . - - - - - .
._.=_=_-=___==:-u==_.=-=.
= ~~ ~ ~ .===1-.-.~---_.===- ~]5= ==.
~ ~===4
==V==5.====sUT.~~_~~--.----.----.-
r--- n
- !f% ~~~ --~~_ .79 -I'~ --- 1]- -
- ~
i ,
@ 5_f$ '_!.v..._==.=.=-.=_.__=.=_=s======..__..
!E=2_-Z=.: %.=.5 d-E F .~_ ~ ~~~ ~ ~.~ ~=--_=:5-=
-. _. ===
__-=_1_-..._._--__.==2.____
== y.=; : =._.=.=. .2 :
-:=.. . .
- =q a ==._=_x.=-=== _==p_.:lj=_=_=.w-...=.=_=..__=..=:=-==.
= . _. ----._.._=x=.:=_a.=_.=_=_---_-_.....=:.=.-=--=_=D
. .-s . _. -
- ==------.==----_v:--=--===.-__-=----==:=-
==.=a.=.:.=r- .=v_ . =. . .u :a . . =-.
- y . . :=
= =:=r. = -t--:---:..- = . . . - ._ .==:-- = - = . = . =
- ===: : z.-wr_==--
('
..=-==:--=-==
C N =,:= ::.: ==
- - =-s . . = - - =~:== .:==.g.-1.=:=._=_ . ;_ _.-r=_=. ; : :==_=. _= =. =_;==-
u
> -- ,p=.=: = =-f- +==- : : := =.=_ =. : :==_n:==.
=
^--
..:=:= - :: :- . . . -. :.3. ==h _a:=. _=_ . : -= _ .- -...__=.1..=.==d
~.'~..==-- :,_.
==- - [- i =nt= - *v:r-t.===- .
, y -
. u.w= 1 ==: =.. .- . . .
= . - - - .- -... -:
y L5%kn=Hc.2=Listi=i==hr=.li: =E=i=:n E =====-pL=L.= LT.G :2# 12 = ==_=111.& _=_]3 __.g= :==.y=---==-- ,..==t_m _ngr'Eig' .= g'=~ ~ ' - ' ' -~gr.3:;3jEi;= v gip'=_=:: ' - ' ' ' ' _- - - -=. r_:=.:
- =v
- '-' - ' ~ ~ ' - - - ' - - ' '
' - * ~~ -'
8 2 : 2 =-='1=.c=. .-s ,: r' y"=.a': :p'-t-~~ =-s2m"t ~~'--'--' ' - ' ~ ~ ' - ' - -t = n : =-t=- . : = =- . = - - - - - - U ==-t. = = s.gt
= . =
g E M '==!5: ==M:,_ =:it!'Eip:Ei4"M-=#f =.==n=.= " = =-5= : =~:=- ===.=== _= ~:aisfE!" = -- ==:EEEE t =.==: h:= =t - - ====- -==_--- *
=.=: = = : = -
----a=
u - -g.. 6 c .a,. g, - Og ./_.m 6- : 2=n_ '
-N , g-- .p-=:==
-a=%,,
.=.=.C. =- cyi - ---y,=,_
=:.;==
- - - - = . =
.. - . - : = = r. =_;.:-A-g-1 :.x==,q=.;=-p=T"F:_-
= . . m- m -
==:==
.-----n.
==:=======22r-...-.
. u* =---2=
0 =-_=.====t=_=_... A= ====:.== =.T # T == === ='="==='~~==..=.'.-_===a========"==:*1=:-==-:--:q.-
= :- : .=_=u-r =;. ,=
.3=. . =_; =_= =i ==:;. . ==
-. =:
m -
. .a= ---=..:.:.
2:== _
-i-- = - a ;. = -
2:
- =.- ==- -: = . :===:=2- =- =-= : = = =--=r-
- .=-,_=M =:- - ==r==3 : 1 == = ~:==s. ==_=~=._:=_=.=..;=....:=_.:.-==. . . -= . _ . _
. . __. .=-_
. __:=-= = = = = =- _--=.=5rc=.2_,=_s--._-:=-=.1_=.=.=_:..=.. = . --
==:= - _
- =: - -d_=._= :-i.:
e fi=.u= -c. =.=: ..=._.=:.m==:-u==.==:.=.__
= . r ===:--: m_ i=
;Mi-i i =lr M = I C =="-!!~--7!r'E55 ="iEi 'r==4~E IN"M==."ENi:=E!! ' " ~= '".-iE'=5iE' ffifi#i5
=EEEE=. sir'i [E22dEddf.iiptis. =iq+;f_ji-U =s-d_~=Hi2R=g
=
^
Q;;js+i'i'l=r . W ==I.E'jE s;,1==ll l E u ssx ss. b=:=r-a r ; =. risa + .c.=. ;iu=.ns :a=ri .=.me u t 5o . . - :=w.c =:. ;. = t=ngi,:s=-ph;;nz,-=.=%Emssw5 mas. :-;=:i===++..p
- m = -^-
= =E 3===rsi=:=:
n.__::.:=.:_ : :. . = := .-
=rr :T .. ' : = E=iF r= q;/im. r:-i i= : ==-i-=izis-IL=== ==r.=;55 =E:-
6
.M#M "$ff- biAY'N? :m .!r5 5 T 5 E; M 5 ="- 2: E FU+1 13 ~E"iNEi"IEWN- )
0 10 1) 20 25 July 1979 August Figure 8. Steam Generator A Blowdown Chemistry (July-August 1979) 28
9 ==-1==t=== ____._3,=h rr- .=-=yre,_-- =
-p- --
!====j== = g =4. g=+m- r-=r===r ====
g*,
wew._
==n
-,-: =%;g__w_.,,gizm= r:7
--A.=.=----._.
te g .. h g+ = i~IM=
..g.........
.. ..:EEi=1=
e s
.==t7 .
"*-}- m=.g
=:i==-
-m y m===:====ia= _; ;= ,
"".~
._.._4__== -
----; -~---r-Figure 9 == -
== :== =_ =1 =- ==s : - -- n:--=- == = :t =_. =.;. =. . _ i = = 1 ==== . -
6 Steam Generator A "._.- __.._.r=-=_,:=_=_f___...__._-.__.._=_=.__...___.--,___.;-_=_;.__.__._,_...___..__(_==:=.= Blowdown Chemistry
-,-====:=--+- 2: __. _. == , , = = = = =_=__.: _ . . _._ . . - ;.m. =r_ _ _ L__=_ _ _ .; _.--
(September 1979) -
==
,_=-_z
. ___: -- -- - - _ _ . _4 - . - - - - - -
_a
,__.__.____4.__..
_..._.=._=._c. . _ , _ _ . _ _ _ . _ _ . . _ . . . . . . . _ - ,-- - . _ . _a; 4 ._._.___c-
- ___ - _ ._ : ---r=.
t.- .____: 0.4 _ _ _ , . _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ . __,_._ . _ . _ .__.._ _ _
- _- .:.__.._...---_--m
~ . .
___.___i -- _ _a__.._ t- -+ -
+
m - - - - - r:_r= ___._.-t.===:-. , _. r ._.__.__.; v n===--, e----- ._==:- i=n . a =_=.<2..... _a _. _ t -
....-__.=.t==.
a.
- o. =, :==- - ___p__..__- - . . . . _ - - - - -:
- e. _ -:- __. = ._ _-_ ._. ., _
z
- -.m
; 0.2 .. . _g_g_. . -,.m_Q_g__
._ __ g _ . , _._,
--(- , .= ;-----------_g
_y=_._..s 7 :=_ g =_ g _.y s_. _ . _ ._ _. _ .
== == Q= - .=. n=r = :=r c -----t----- ----t l--_ i~y--r* _ % =.-_.=.1__-~._*--"--*----.i-----U O L - . J --- ..ji __ J . = . . A ; t-f = t- : --*
- ===: === ;;i- n-y .__.3.==.L_= s --M.s.c
=_. =.=._, - r+r =.g r;e--: t- =2 =_.~_a.c 1 . ==-=s _- - - . .- _ ::._ : -y=r; =;L_.-tv 4 - - - - - - - -
4
- ______. t==== _ __._- -
' - :- *- _: r- a___ _ ~ ~ - ~ - '
.__4 0 - ~' _ "_._,.__ ,- _
._______g.__
4._ _2 --
-- - -4 3--_,
_2 _
,_=-__;:--._g==.._.__.._____4__._2-
- , - - - - __,=2
.=_-_:- __
.__4_--,- _ _ _ _ -- ~--
.a., --,- --_ :-_ .
--w. y j,=i --, -1
== *--~
0 . ,,4 _,
,;=3.___,
._ 4
---+ ~-N---+-*-i a E
c, _ . . _ _ _ , 1=DJ i _2 C- __.__g .
. -+ ; -*
__.a _3_ .__,! _ _ _ : r
= __,___ .a__.._,_- ~~
-M ^ -
.$.40.1 -, :
- .__._=; .
s ; _. 4
+-
=2
'O _. :-- t _.__a _.- - - - -
o -4 .
~
4
.- -4_:-~~___ ,e .
- + - - , - - . - - - _,_ .._-_.-
- - - i - ;__.__-_2-,
,':_,a--*--
^
c ._ ____gx ~__. m 4 =; g*- Q a_2- -. _ .__i t -- r~ - e , _ ,_f.
-'&"'M_ .v- - 3=:,p~f;-
- :. y ~'C v_ 2.ri3L -_s, ; .__: ,
0 - _3 . _ _ ,_- _2_- a .__ __c _- - _
= : ---
- r-+ -- * --
2-- o -4 __r i
)o _+_
._.--a j _= - i --"-i--- :__ _; __.=-:_.__.2.-
n = -
- =1 _+__.__
- _=:--"
4
=4 g.___,___. __._4 ,_, ..=3~- -- 1_,r)
A __ .._ ,
~- - - -"-' +
a 4 :- __.___w - - , - - _: =
--- -~l=
=:= ._. s ny=-
p, : x l___.
==
= _,_.__
< w _!=. -.-m _._;l=
m__.. = =4 i=] __p- - J .__ ; ;_. - : :- u _ _ _ _ . 8 _a___
. __. =] =_j=___g __ _-- _
._.=_;g = p:t_=_ _g=_=, __ ._ ___ _; ___,,_ ,_- I. . _ - - - _-_ -. -_ -__.; =: = r - -- .y __
__.a__ ;_ _ o . _ _ , _ . . _ g __
. _ _ - _ -__._ ,__ y-.=*:=._:___.r. ._
. . - ,f_ ;=$_ 5_ j_ .,J.__. _- ___a.___-.i
-+
j_g__ _ ._,_s _ _ ~_j_; _
,=jgg=a f__. _.
==_
o 2 - __= - -
..__._._r__..m------ _==-i -- - - - -- -- =2 = : _, ._2 := -- ^
- = ;=_=i W '=_ .;= ::f=_ ,_..___.s
_ .__. ___ _. . . . 2
~
c . . . _ . . ,_
- - :1 _.__
o _.-__,._ . _ .
.- - .__. .- ___ . _ _._.3__ 4.___3 -. ._. 3 3_,..__ __.._,. . - _ ~ . _ _ _ _ _ _.=___1__=_j __.
, . . e a := =-1.:w.g= .
= - ;--- -W== : ,-
=-s .- - _.__,__4==__1- =4_. ------4
. i-. --F==--*,_]~-
. . . __ - = f. __ -
=:x: ::
e , .
- v _, h=t_mq_-
x=4_-r N:~I=h_d_; }}-f_:_ - u - - * ' _j=C-
*i {!=
--4=} _._-l=k:=: L.3 _.__ F- O= - - - - - - - -
==2_._..,_a=
_ -=--- =- =z=. _- g --+_t__==--
=2= == 3
._=
=}= -!. ._2_-q__=. =3=----
.= 2 := + t-- .
,=
=1-
_ _ _ _ _.- - -_-_=_. _ .=_:=+ = _C..= =_ =_ := 2_-L = =} ==!i=.1 ._i4 _ . _ t = ==; = f == = l . . - +4 __ _: .. _ =_==_:. .- i==2_22._ .-- :- _
=__. -
= r- ---- =-1. = - ,--- =
=:r -t --- }=- -: = . =4 = 1 -
= =r=
--: = := =i=a = ===l.= = 2-:= , - ,=- t= =: -
-,-== =:- .t= = = =i=t.=____ _r=_. . l ===== .
q ==j
= === = ---
.t- :- -.- --=2=__ _ . -
= .! =_;I=___a _M-
_ . r;.==_ ~- +t_=: w =:=".= l===== =2 -l' =" =="==_:m=_~l :: 8
'= r 2: == .= _. _., =
100 .__ , _u.=j== = , -_._: I==._._ .. =: ;=-I==. == n .. . _ _ . .
.~ _ ~w,. .-__. .__
==:= . _ =
,_ .2 _ , _
= ==; = ! =_,_ 2:m
= } __ m _ . _2 ;-_ _ _ .
__ s_==
= -
= {=!=_
=:=-
- - t =; =i =
= := =. : =cm. _ ._.
C =z= =:==: =_ =2=='
===*= == :=l =="=_ ==:'=- =
= = = - -- I = m '=t==b==~=lgb::_.
== =='- ='~= 2=-"= g- ;=uI==;=
- = = ==== = = ~=:'===': =
c 50 a o _=_a ===
- .=. . =:_= = q ===
=. == ::===:=:p== , =--~=; == a =
= .:
.= _=
=; .: r =_=
_. . .= ):=r ==.%g _i = = == =r .
-(=: - . ==_3_ _==_; =... _=.:=...: =- _=g== r=--
- ==:= = =:= =:=m
=: ,_
N . =, :: = - + = ==r=.
= }:~a - =p-= ==:== =r = == =L==:lr=-
2_:- =t = ==
+
==.=;=.=;- =:-- == ;r:- .v m:r= , -h ;- u= =:r= :=1=::_-a=,- :21=- ._! = _ l =:::=4 =2.p
=q , :
0 15 20 25 5 10 29 Septe:::ber 1979
4 - I o N
, To estimate the quantity of resin which entered the steam generators on February 27, it was assumed that all of the cation resin was in the hydrogen form, and decomposition proceeded totally to formation of sulfate. With this assumption, the total amount of sulfate removed from the steam generator by blowdown can be employed to calculate the amount of cation resin that entered the generators. From the variation in cation conductivity, the sulfate concentration can be estimated as shown in Figure 10. In the absence of a balancing cation, the maximum sulfate concentration in the generator would give a room temperature pH of approxi=ately 4.
This predicted pH is sig-nificantly lower than the value of 6 reported by plant personnel during the incident. This leads the authors to conclude that the resin intrusion incident occurred rapidly enough that steam volatilization of balancing cations was not sufficiently rapid to allow the full pH transient to be experienced in the bulk coolant. However, lower pH levels probably occurred in local areas where concentration factors above that in the g, steam generator ecolant are much greater than those in the bulk. Based on the blowdown sulfate concentration variation, the total sulfate removal by blowdown was approximately 17 pounds (Figure 11). This corresponds to
.(, cation resin ingress on the order of 44 pounds (dry). Corresponding anion resin ingress (C:A = 3:1 precoat) is 14 pounds (dry). inc total resin ingress estimate of 58 pounds is somewhat lower than that previously reported to .
the NRC -(technique unknown). Based on the ratio of maximum cation con-l
, ductivity during resin intrusions on July 10, July 21 and September 10 to that on February 27, resin ingress during these three incidents.vas estimated
-to be 3, 1 and 2 dry' pounds, respectively.
/
v 9 30 e
10 !!Li !! i!
- !!+? :li i it; !!
+
i ii ei!? +:vi" istiil itli- iii e ili !!ill
+ . . :
!!. 2. + r - '
ji ji 4 2 ;r! . , . t . . i:~i' +ifi-
- - '!Fi4 i424 H :- -
44 +i. . .' -
~.ki id ' iii+i ' ii i H i:-i iii!i' Ei-!S H ~: IE 1 i i~U . Ii35- iiTN iH-Mi M-M UI M 5.N! M55'ElN51 Sif NiN1 .-
Figure 10 - --- - - 5 . _ . . .. _ _ - Sulfate Variations during -
.==:=- 2- - -
- 2. . _:. . : .r = . . : :.== :.=.r==. . =- February 1979 Resin Intrusion -.=e1= :_=:2 ==-
v: = - .- .. ---v := = :- :... . ..... =---
. . _ . . .. _ . .. . . . . _ _ . ~ .
=_. .--
_. I ~ .. -.
,f _
) ... . . . . -.
- 1 _.
~{ .
9.j -.- 1 f- . r- _ la.. .,\ a' . . .
.. , . .. 2 . .' i .
. ea, . ei
. . i . .ee., . . 4 . ,I i l,
..t i
. i ',
.A . - ,
f _66 .I'* I iI!t 4 iiiI (: f 9 e , V'. l ',' , *8 l ?I I! .t : I t - I , i,. e' Ie? e i i . i ii
, j' ' ti **. .I
- ii *!i: 11 - ,ii !i. .t i , ei' c iiii !
y i* .I ,
- g. . . ..q
. . . _ 4.3,
. _ . . _ _ . _ . . _ ._ _ _. . . _ . . . . _ - .. _ _ _ _ _ _ . ._ _ _ _ _ . ___.r.__._ . _ . _ . . . . _ _ -
.m.._ .._..._ . . _ . . __ .. . . _ . _ _ .
., .__.._.._. -==:4.___..._.,____
.L_ ._ T :- ;_=___ -
.=: . A =- - ==== == . _-
- - - = . -
-m
=.._=-___=
_ . .g ..#
-+ ',M.___
E % _,_,- g, -
/
s\ ?
-* M- r O.5 '
_W w. .
/ Nn y
.y. _ .y*
v - %-- -;---- .
=% - __.1 _
_. \ x __4 - i ( ._ C 'f_. ; w .- Q. , Q 4 a g ' x - a i x h 0.2-i \^ y o . t , i , u
. i . , . _-.
e4 ...i , . . i i
- i. + *
( M U 1 i it sie i 1 i!
. . ..t i.
.p .
s 6 , .
, . I i 1,.,
; M%7~- - m D'.) i
, . ,.. , ., ..., i .. . , , cs , , ... ...,
6.. , i . . ii , i . i i 3 i. e i* i i . . i ..eii .i. , !..i . a.: . .,.. .... ,,.ii. i i + set lit, I jl. 1 i- !il i ll i til ittit e i i Il i it i. . Iei to i i i Ii 4lll 1I ll lI l ! l{ }iI44 l l6I il1i8 8i ll f lt1 i il I i I'I I I l.' i i.!i i i, init it 11 :t I t 1 1:: : : 6til 1146 's si e i{t sia.i tiili iiili 0.1 _ _ _ . , _ _ _ _-- ..=_= =-==:==. r==--- - = = _ = = . = . _ ._==. _ = _._-.:_=. _ , _ . _ - =x==_ - _--~__1=__=..__.==L.===_= =
=_.-. _ _ _=.- __ __1 -
g: _--:==__ 2.===__.
=
_ _ . =.~..._. _ . . _ _ . _ . _ . . . - _ . ~_ _ . _ y __ . __- p __ . _ _ _ - - _ - - _ _ - _ . . 7- ,,
~ _ .. _. -.
-+^
~
0.05 , 1 e 1 1 i ! I F a (9. ____.=
.._.4; .- . .- _ _ . _ = = =_==_==_
_; . ===. =:=--- u . : _-=_:=.=. = = = =
,] .-
;~"~ =__
r -
~
. ..=
- 1 1 I +,~_
I i
~ ,
, _H+
O.02 r ; rt -
..r
--ri ; ; .i @i.t- .". . . r.r-:-- -t -
. ' i ; , ,. i t- . ,, ,
- .,, , i.
--1. -i i ..
7 - b, I ii . .. i>i,? i r~t -t-* .. ir.. i Tt-~~+ ., .. ri.i i; i; i , , . i4 I f-
. .i
. ,i .
t" ,. - ,,, ; i t iii . q 1.ii. ,
._- ii . ,, , . .. . .i, ... , ,i,. . ,, . ii ,.* .
.. i,i __ . ,_
.i i
.. it i. , ,, 6 .... i, ,, -
i i . .- -
. t. i 4. ,,. i i.ti
-T 16 i, 4 :6 , t .i .iii .iiri t it et ! i i _ .
!i .._.i. i .
i ,. litt i , i i i i tr! it t; itt .,
- i ei tit it _.i s.
i._.i' s_t e, ti i sii till IIlli siti I t., I si I i i t i 4 t :- tii II 'i t i 0.01 1 5 10 26 February 1979 March 31
e p
. . e
-. e *
.n.j.u.. .. . ' ... .; :.} ;n .
l..
. s. .] .
-l . . . .
}.
j . i, ; qp. j- : : .a.
! ' * . .!. i
,....._.'..!._ .$.__._. j- . . . - . a :. _a-
.,i. -
..tn. ,i . .: Io I.
- m. . t : .. .!
+I . .i. r.
ili:! - .i!b
'~
Figure 11 ji!!: . . ' -. IMi - ****t-- E ,
..d'*
g
-' . :]l
~~~
.:*: ..t'.. . . . . :- :.
- -- ......j.
ng.: '- Sulfate Removal from System .. . .
. . ]; : u
". . . . ..."2 .1 : j. during February 1979 2 :: pia !
~! .
zir il:i 't= =i! Resin Intrusion .or .
* ... . n.j:":1 . . : ....
- n. .;. :. :. . . .i.i i. i. ..*...
M T ~~'" ~: . - = t* n :;::!;; ; nt:i4:xtr;;p'i= li!!! "i!!" - - yF - g . i - Ou iiN!!! 2ii'i PIiE M ' : !! is di. ' .rliiii: ~ . ]'y -
=
i:i .!jijhl :' uM!F; IE!Qi: -
-.i jM iff]i
*U Wi2: - u:i iii!Ni}Eu!! 9!N!ili!-it: ili
- i'ii- Oi- 55!di id.irG i N ' 'l: . . i. i E:
- 2. . . -; . . . .
3..--- 1
- x. :::. .: n ..nl.
t-
- n. ..... :. g:. :. - n. . . -.l.. . 2 . :. n ,. . r =. .. tf :.. t . :. rI-
-., .:_ . .. -r.. .=- :
-jjjn :idiiH= n;;: -- F J :- _ n"k- :=:n.; 1.,.[:.;jjnj .h--ij.[j ailiE. . 3, 12 .,'.; ..=.
7 . ._ j "._.h .
- 3......_..!=..........., nl : =. . + .. = r. : r =..
- =. !. . n : n. . ._
=. .=. .: .:.=
_ , . . _...r..=....n_.
=.: : = . = =... . ... .::: =_.1..t-
- =. . :. :. . : ur . . . . ..-- . n. !. _.. . : =. . .: . ! .
!! ! . : . 5 id L
- Ei! . .
a=. e EME!)=!== E!E=l=1 Ei==iEEE: =!!@ 2;iME ==sils siils E - .=v =m=i=!4 =r+ MEs '=ii u n.: a ' _ .. : = sk-5 i
- n.; = a=. .. -- -
-----l===
. _. h_:= = = = = =
= = == = r-r==i===n-= ---- ===n=- -l=-- ::n =:=;== ..... =irr:==Q n =U =l=r._ =.n.nl ...
. : .=._ . I=_n:nJ rain...--.~.-1.......- :h== =- =-. *
. ... .-. :.C... .r. .. jn. :. I'. n. .":.
. n. . =. i. ..:.. ..*-.:.:r h . . . . ..j. . . {. n.
. .s.;.-.
. . . *C] .. . =.. ..=. . ._. n. _ .
+
. . .--. *_n r..-.~-~...~..n!=-. ,_ ..."..Y......._-..f.........._.a...r.=....{-.., =. - --
._.-C,=..=..,
..s ._......_.......l.....=.
. m. -1.;. . r_ J. . :.=._ . _-*.=. ..
- - - - - 2 22 2. - - } =-
- - - - - - . :=-
=
=.O, 1=_.:=__j ======4:=. = = .; =d: .= ==- 4:=r. _== ;: a . .- == - = = =
== uu . =a - -
- 3=--
==d==== ,: =2 ::: = ::: = ==2 r --
=== 1== = . .= -
- --*i nr = -n.fr
=:=
-= tr
=: n
=, 2;: n.. ;=;Ei:n= _= =:=
n2= . =: =
== =3=
n
=_.4.22, p -=:=h.r:
.12 -- b--q=r .=n= .:= =~. :nj=r nl=:- .:=:r:t 1
= =='n=r=* = == = = } =.l
= r;- nni:r
. . .==
au;= *n =: u. 4
=::=
r= . = ._: :=:. =t- 2 = ;==.l =- .2....}_=,_ = a : }.==.- = == l
- . ; =i- :!== =:= t = =
m
==._.=:==..el = :=3= =:=_= : =: =n :
x=:.u =. l ==in- i=.
._..n=_._.
_.w. . . . . . _=_=_.1=....._
. _ =. l . .. _ _ . b . _ l. . . =. . ==. i,=.
.. _--__.i.._c r. :.=. . _ ...,.---l=...._._._.L._.._~._...T-*1..
. 1.+=.._=__._....._=-.=.:..,......
__._- . : ._ . . . ..1.. =. . .:.:. n. .=.t. =. - K.;. ) =. .=. . :- . . 22.. I.r_. t . ._ . _
= = . . = . =.=..:._=.. ..
CC 4 ..l :
...,d_...... .
. . . . . C. ., .;.
** :_ :.j .=. _ ; ~1._=..0._0.-,=..y=.._2..*.J.*.*_=...b.._..f.:............__....k,...,._,_._,__._.....__4.....~-C.
_= .
. . ..--$. . . .=._.U.=. . *.0!..
. .. .$.. 2.4 .J .~_: C.. . l. z._Z: . .-
- l. *C.
- Ei. *** . . . {
g . . J_ *1. ; J 1 5
~
nn.=. =2:=.In.4.. =: Mf;. == === =: .u'1 ---. :=1 = L;7. f,= *=j =-"=]= <* = .], :=
~
4 .~ =:.7
= =7tnual a== ;.- :J _.. LI=1:=. .. =~ := 1. U.Crnl.=.=M
- u= d
-*.=n.r = :=:= --;==-=.
- - ' ~ ~32 ;I = =r27== ' 2.:rr
=:= = n= =.*:n: ..*qT . "":t !-*- _ -~-6='" 1 =1.. . . = . l .x.4= 1 - .:. ! =
***~_~12^ '*M.***~
M -" M
= = 3 : _= 2 *-- ; -
!-- ! U*:n~'- 12;:=1 ; !r Zir*.;1--". I -~*-
- h' *n C* " 1:; !!". U$;.'
2! =.="! p:* -
.M "_-"_-'."Cl*--**"-* . . . * . . _ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.=!..........,_s...l=_....f' : ';n. . } =.1C. = .,: -. _. . _.._..
- =
.r_ . . - . . :*r.n . ..=. _r. . . .C. .=.~ j .-*=. . . .U. . . ...[. .. . = *r.O. .C.'.".T f. . . . ._.
.._t.._ . . . . . _ . - .. n . . .=. 7.C_:.. n_20. 0 '
.22 = . - ; *=
i = 7:.*:-12r; = _, j nr;;= n.: = n.-;RC' Un f==.=t = =j -2r1;.:.- *=.Z
=u nu; : = nng =,n=n.{_=.1.u4.;.23.::*n -
=t= wV r :l==: :n==t---t .
Q :== .- :--n - n = en -- =~ . _ . . _ . . . _ . . .m . . . _ u -;=. 2_._ nP:n = = Cr C r !. .
.=r:-* *s -
O 72= ::t-- ;r:: . U; r. =- g=In * .21*- = 1.=-*CT= u* l =.= {=n.*t = 1. . nt = - "* * : = _ .! * *n ! " - lun n- ;24jr:r .4=1=I -
=~*:".=l - - - nf
.;*n".*L :17*::=.
1: U: rp.n =UC! -- r-T 4 =; ;= _.. %:*tr]. . := : nur= .::ur;=.:= :......._.. .=:r-g - . . . . . . u . : =
- 3 ==;:
=.= === .}22: =l===: van = , _ . .
=_g
.. .--. -=:= = :p=- .=n--= -. -. -. _- =_ b.n==
_ . . . = = = ~ rr=vr = = = === -- r - m _ , _ .
==. : =
=:n:p=u=--- =i. nh===:=r e=n=: == ru t =.d u. 2 _: -== ==7. =: == :: =:_.
=; = 4 -
=2=
= -- = m.-l_==.l ===: ===1==: =- =--==l=== =f=t=t= =n= _._
.i . * "
N b b "
.--d.. . . . _ '
! L . ~
. . ^
. . u t =: .b. .. . n.=_
. . . . . . .~
. ._. .. _=:_,n._. ..r.*:
.'*".1...... .g .._ .'.'".}.
. . . f . ;*.;n. .==:!.. ;.O .' =. . ;* :~. l _. l ... .".**7 . .1..5. .=..-.t..n..;._....__=...$.=_.
. _ { =. ._ . . . . , . . h.* ::::.. . . ... f_..
. .t. r- r. .r.1'_r=._ . l n. ._r : n.n C.*.T...~.~ . ..... . _ . . . . . .
n-..
._y. . _ . .g. ;.,. .n. ;.. . . .
g, __ ..ng. _.; ; -*-.- n ::= = n =;" =!= ,. "=== ;.: r;;;O--~;-a -4;n-=
= r'=== = 'n ==
~ - ' =: = =l=_= ;=;_. ,i= ~iU r ;.;,n.,;i . .g . . .;.ri= =II:=
3 =I_m_ ==1= EE!" uiSEEl8:Mi !!$i" ~*El!"+E!!F5.iE' ".0"il~iEiEd.5Ei5" "--E"i i!!!E Elii" ~EIE:- "i~-E "EiE Ei=n =Eif:E! MEs Mik ; - diff =:ii= EliE" iMils-i :siW=5hi- RiE= iis! -iElE "..iiElEME.Nz;=MEU
.4_ .. . _ . . . . _.*
-mEE i!Eiis
*;***! - .-' '*.. l.u.n. . . .= . *. .20.. = _. .. .r_I'n. '_ . . . . _
. . . . . . .7...:.1I..:.:..*J.
2*..* .. *J. . 22. 1. ' . 1'n. . -..:._.n__ _ "..d!.. tr. . C. : .*. :. .=...i.=.. ~_% }..==.3*....t* .. .. ;' *. :1d
. !.C . . . =. !. . .n.. .._}....
"*.*.~~.:.. .;.. !I. . :.W. . . . . . ........C . -- _
*. j= 2--' n2 .. :!n. J . ";.;.- :
,= : : ;, = ;;::.= n;5n :
= h. . V . ,.
n !: =* 7 :2 Z:.!nr ..i=
= l!".:
-t= :::= =:!== =_r=,_...=_.
. ; . 4 *":
- t. 4_:*i=. =.... =. ...=..
- =. . . , = . . . . = .=..g==...
- , , ==
. . . . = . . .: =. .
=_.12 ......-~~*i=
_ . . = = . . . == . = . _ .
.';- ;=.
=.=b..=--
Z. . . :
'~.C. .-..: C. .;.C. '
. ~n-
.! n. . . . M. .f ..::::.
~~-.j =. . C. . .l. *:T. .Z..rgt.. .. . .=. f. U.. =. . =. _ =. . j :. :. ' : : . f. =. :. , ".*.1.
7 2 =.}. .?. !1.n. . fn'. l 2. ~. j r. . .
'~
Eiii!E MEi"- . iiE" =. ...g:n.! 5.Sifi .iiEE Eid i ". EEI" "ENi #Ik =Mi@i}i: 1 f~?=iE
#i =ii W 5EG; #EEEi "Ei i EEE
.:.'In.-- =_ :. : . .n
- t --
-~-'.;'=**.-
- x. . %:.*l.M. :. . r.. !*= : .nh. -*'i 2 . I ....1=...
. . n..n' . J :~.*t . n. .n =..f_.. .
. . . . . . .*n;"! :. '
*~:"._... . =.. 1L.-.': . .!.I =. '. .'~' '. 'i. :.:. . n. . ' M.
1
. ; n. . "
"ZZ
=$n. =.V .C. i. * * : . . : .1. .... nt;; . *! . ' ' . . . ] . . :.] .: -.
-*n~.
- Ck ur.. :Mj'!"
.M. ;:1:... ..::!::
=l-"" .nl'.nj .
l .;
- ;; " 2;1M *:!: ;: *:!C.
** n ,
- M 1;'*:
- ** l :. M $.... ... . . . .
] ' .!. ' . . . . - *r.1 ".. n .....'r;: . .". g; . . ?
=...g..
- 4. . . ...r. " . .n::
=. . t. n. . - n.n. n. .}.. . --"n.1. . .t :
- ...."h . .
....l.._n..=.. .
ut. =.
- n. . ! . .". .' .." . * =.n. . i. r_.. * :. l x."**-'.u.
..,2: , . . 'n. . ! .::.
...:= :;r 31 : n t - .4 ...
;*::: .' - .. I n . . ..r 1:- : N. . . ;:i:' = : .. ni;; :.I.: .
'= .. . . ! 1 ...:.. =:
- r*: '
- -- .....::t / . ....'"..ir
..: 8 % . . ..::.. :. t;- .
- .1;r:
}
T...
- n!
....{....
. . . p. . ~.~.~.j.. ..'.....
. . . .. : { n . .. . . . . . .. . g#
. . . . . . ....c.. .3#
. .' . .i . '.'3..
~
- n.f n. . -*n. .
...l....';"."
.. ". . . . ....i.. .1*.- -
}.. . .. . I U. .
- .f..
L{n
;. :: ::l;. nj;. .: . . . . . .
. ' .* : f ; . ..
6
- EC+E' . %=i [*:. =-
=i:rE= = 'i= Pl" 4.. = == ... = 12. aiA. .= .-... . " *:= 0+ =4+: =i4 j;-' *'
].:
*. ;' s e!: .; . ; ;*lj. : :j
^ ,
.!j , .
h'
;';*:. . . ' .' . . . :n. . ; r. . . ;;j M. . . ': g ..g.' M.:. M. . .;;;,.;;;,
*. -*"I O* *. .' *.. .. ....l.J.j .C. ..;. . =...f"..__. ' .';;'
**j.:....; gg . . . . ,
,; . 3 ! =. . ..
- ...:..!. : *** n. n.. ;. . . . . . .. .
- p : - . . 4~ ~~':b+ :
.. ;. ~
JHr"" "!:"F = ~!!iii:
~
!! < . ai i +'i +- " ' " e-
=ir T::l::" .::.
i;!)" i "' ~ ..." '
' ' "' ~'
0 -O 10
- 26. 1 5 February 1979 March 3:
..t
.~
* - EFFECTS OF LAKE COOLING WATER INGRESS Lake Anna cooling water chemistry was employed in the NWT model on crevice chemistry in PWR steam generators to assess effects of condenser inleakage.
Lake water leakage rate was adjusted to give a 100 ppb blowdown sulf ate level. As shown in Figure 12, lake water ingcess in the absence of condensate polishing would be expected to increase crevice pH, i.e., basic not acid solutions would be formed. Unfortunately, detailed ionic removal efficiency ( data for the North Anna powdered resin filters were not available thus the effect the polisher has on each ionic species could not be considered in the . analysis. Nonetheless, it appears unlikely that acid forming colutions could be formed during lake water ingress even if the effect of the powdered resin filters were considered. e 9 i e e 9 n W U 33
. c. ,-
I i i i 9 - - 8 -
/~~_-~%
Without Silica - -
.s
/
/ .
/
/
7 - ' ._ - 100 ppb Silica O b 6 - - w
> N - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _ .
U n ______~~.,,,---' Neutral pil - - 5 - - , - Q. - m Yo . y 4 - _ 3 - _ I f I I 3 10 10 10 10 10 10 Crevice Concentration factor Figure 12. Variation of Crevice pH during Condenser Leakage (Blowdown Sulfate = 100 ppb) 4
e C
, /
DISCUSSION Steam generator blowdown chemistry other than during the resin intrusion of February 27, 1979 appears to have been controlled reasonably. However, average cation conductivity and sodium levels pr.rticularly during 1978 were much higher than expected considering the high quality cooling water, the full-flow condensate polishing system, and tha high capacity blowdown system. Although not abnormal with respect to the overall response to a power transient, chemical return during plant startups and shutdowns before and subsequent to the resin' intrusion exhibits a distorted sodium to anion ratio, i.e. , sodium return is higher than expected. This enrichment of sodium return could be resulting from continued low level condenser leakage with pref erential sodium leakage through the condensate filters (as expected) or sodium input from fresh precoat material as a result of a fraction of the new resin being in the sodium form. In any event, the anion return (sulfate or chloride) cEidenced by the cation conductivity increases does not appear highar than' , that expected to be associated with the sodium increase in the absence of resin decomposition products. This infers that these decomposition products were removed from the generators as they decomposed. This position is 2 consistent with the following Westinghouse sludge analysis results: s
" Microscopic examination of the sludge showed its physical appearance
- to be similar to other plant sludges with no distinguishing characteristics.
The carbon analyses in each sample was in the range of the carbon content (, of sludge from plants without condensate polishing units. Also, the sulf ate concentration in each sample was similar to that found in sludge from plants without condensate polishing." Only limited studies have been made on the effect of resin intrusion on
'? steam generator corrosion. The most thorough program to date has been per-formed by ambustion Engineering (CE) for EPRI.
In Phase 1 of EPRI RP623-1 performed by CE, cation resins (sodium form) and
'~ anion resins (chloride form) were injected intermittently into a 16 tube model boiler, and the extent of Alloy 600 and carbon steel attack assessed.
Average model boiler chem!atry is given in Table 8.8 t. 35
V TABLE 8
- MEAN SECONDARY CHEMISTRY VALUES - PHASE 1 pH G 25*C 8.9 Specific conductivity 22 umhos/cm Intensified conductivity 47 pmhos/cm Sodium 1.5 ppm
(, Chloride 0.8 ppm Sulfate 2.0 ppm Sulfite 1.0 ppm i-Model boiler chemistry. variations are shown in Figure 13 for the last 2h months of the test. As shown, the model boiler underwent several chemistry transients as severe as the major transient at North Anna 1. Combustion Engineering s'ummarized v their corrosion observations from this phase of the program as follows:8 "After 94 days of steaming, the unit was shut down and opened for an interim examination. ECT was performed on all heat transfer tubes at C1 100 and 400 kHz. No indications of any corrosien degradation was noted on the tubing. Visually, the tube surfaces were coated with a thin adherent dull grey oxide, which subsequently was analyzed to be Fe3 On top of the' magnetite film was an intermittent layer of mustard-ycklow , resin fines. Resin fines appeared sporadically on the carbon steel internals and shrouding material." ; _O
. The model exposure was continued for an additional 182 days in Phase 2.
Resin injections were continued, and chemistry transients were considerably more severe (reference Figure 14 for " typical month"). Average monthly
'c> conditions are given in Table 9. After this additional exposure, observations were as follows:'
"The final examination of this model was performed af ter an additional t' 182 steaming days (276 days total). At this time, ECT indicated tube denting at all locations within the carbon steel drilled support plate and in the tubesheet crevices for those tubes which were not installed by: explosive expanding.- The maximum radial constriction at the support (as measured by ECT) was 0.0165" with an average radial dent of 0.011" 36 1
10 i j i i j 3 D *i l ! g g 8
~
' ~
\. .
yh , 3 9 99 m o ee e , 100 - i 80
.l2 _
- i D
- c. E .
{ 60 - l 4 g i . u . .
~
C 40 1 / U
% f kl
[
\
20 c ( o 8 w
?
- O O OO O 00 OO 00 e
Y I r I i y r 15 1 15 1 15 1
October 1976 November uecember l
Figure 13. RP623-1 Phase 1 Chemistry (Combustien Engineering) 37 l l
MODEL 8 PH - SEPTEMSER 9.5 l, l g l L ,, l [, ,
, / r vr f.-sy n v p/ ~
.v
- r, 8.5 p ; y; j.n
/ - j
/
7.5 1 1 3. ii,
- t g ,f
\1 \
6.5 \j _1 (' -) V i! !l 5.5 i g 3i 4.5
~
l 3 5 7 8 11 13 15 17 10 21 23 25 27 29 31 DAY OF MONTH t ( N0 DEL 8INI.'CONDUCTIVITYCUMH0/CM)-SEPTEMSER ISO _._ 120 , 80 n , y se a 40
- x , , * ,
" n n n n 0 , ,
3 G 7 9 11- 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 t 1 31 I.. DAY OF MONTH (: . I CHEMICAL / CONTAMINANT ADDITIONS , SBR 0 HGR 0 0 0 0 HYD U 0 0 00 0 03 0 00 TRIP 00 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 DAY OF MONTH
. Figure 14. Typical RP623-1 Phase 2 Chemistry (Combustion Engineering)
.. . = . - - .
g, 7, O C- C ' TABLE 9 ' MEAN SECONDARY CHEMISTRY VALUES - PHASE 2
-{umho/cm) ppm Date pH G.C.* I . C .*
- Na -
Cl S*** NH __._3. SiO 2 4/77 8.8 14.0 -- 0.3 0.1-5 -- -- 0.2 5/77 9.0 22.5 49.5 1.2 1.2 2.9 1.9 0.2 6/77 8.5 24.5 ' 55.4 1.5 - 1.7 4.5 1.6 0.1
. 7/77 8.8 23.0 43.5 1.5 0.9 4.3 2.1 0.1 8/77 8.5 28.1 75.4 2.1 1.2 9.8 2.9 0.2 9/77 8.6 24.9 54.0 1.7 0.5
~ 10.3 2.4 0.1 10/77 8.6 - 13.7 16.4 0.5 0.26 3.0 .1.5 0.2 g 11/77 8.6 10.2 10.6 0.05 0.10 2.3 1.7 0.1
- specific conductivity -
** Cation conductivity '
*** Total sulfur as sulfate e
1 9
CO
-t (n
o A '
/L for the 32 tube / plate insertions. At the tubcsheet, the average radial constriction was approximately 0.004". Also, ECT indicated approximately 20% wall thickness loss for several tubes in the steam blanketed U-bend region..."
" Samples of the tubesheet sludge were obtained at model shutdown and analyzed by x-ray dif fraction and fluorescence. The diffraction pattern indicated that magnetite was the major species although the pattern showed other unidentifiable species.... Note that in addition to Fe and Cu, substantial quantities of C vere f ound. This is probably the result of thermal decomposition of the organic resin structure. Other elements, whose concentration was found to be greater than 0.5% (by weight), were ,
Hn and Ni; Cr and S vere detected in concentrations greater than 0.4%." '
~
Since in i'hase 1 of .RP623-1 aggressive tube support plate corrosion was not experienced in the model boiler, it became dif ficult for the authors to accept that the single incident at North Anna 1 could have led to " denting" and possible ligament cracking. However, although the model boiler chemistry 1., perturbations and normal chemistry appear more severe than at North Anna th'e model boiler heat flux was much lower. This difference could explain - . the apparently more rapid attack at North Anna. As the final step in the evaluation, more quantitative estimates of the attack magnitude at North Anna were sought. Unfortunately, available documentation e' did not specify average dent size or range. Discussior.s with Vepco personnel also did not allow estimates to be developed. In some instances, the presence of "only minor support plate corrosion" was indicated.1 In other references," full blown denting is indicated to be present, and North Anna is. listed in a tabic with Indian Point 3. Kori I, etc. This classification appears questionabic 4 since only one tube restricted passage of the 0.700-inch ECT probe at North Anna whereas several hundred such tubes were detected at Indian Point 3 during their second inspection.s Clarification of the magnitude of the attack will be regaired before further assessments relative to the relation of the resin intrusion incidents to the attack can be quantified. Q t 4 . 40
Q4: I n ; REC 0miENDATIONS The following actions are recommended for Vepco consideration:
- 1. Develop and/or make available quantitative estimates of dent magnitude at each intersection based on ECT records. The authors recognize the inaccuracy of the ECT technique for dent. magnitude assessment, however, even semiquantitative estimates would be of value.
4
- 2. Characterize b, lowdown chemistry' at North Anna during current boric acid injection program. Blowdown samples during steady and transient conditions should be co11ceted and submitted to Imr for analysis for Na, Ca, Mg, C1, and SO4 .
- 3. Transie.nt and steady state effects of powdered resin filter insertion and long term operation of one vessel should be determined. Condensate, "
demineralized condensate, moisture separator drain, f eedwater and , blowdown levels of the above 5 species should be determined for several
. weeks during which one or more powdered resin prccoated filters are put into operation. .
4
- 4. Routine operation of the resin filters should not be reinitiated until resin strainers are installed, and appropriate interlocks are provided to prevent future occurrence of premature filter valving into the system. Adequacy of operator training also should be assessed.
O 41
.. a -?
eye w as
, /
REFERENCES
- 1. Stallings, C. M., Virginia Electric & Power Company, letter to H. R. Denton, Nuclear Regulatory Commission, December 10, 1979.
- 2. Doutt, V. W. , Westinghouse Electric Corporation,1cteer to B. R.
Sylvia, Virginia Electric & Power Company, January 22, 1980.
- 3. Baldwin, M. H. , et al. , "C-E/EPRI Program RP-623-1, PWR Model U-Tubed
' Steam Cenerator Corrosion Studies, . Fourth Progress Report", Combustion Engineering, July 1979.
- 4. London, R. S. , Westinghouse Electric Corporation, letter to C. M.
Stallings, Virginia Electric & Power Company, November 27, 1979.
- 5. " Attachment III, Safety Evaluation related to Steam Generator Inspections",
Power Authority of the State of New York, Indian Point 3 Nuclear Plant, January 1980. 9 o e t 42
+-
- 1 1
- g APPENDlX 4 "POWDEX RESIN DISCHARGED INTO STEAM GENERATORS" "On February 27 1979, while placing a Powdex vessel in the condensate polishing system back into service, the filter tubes were ruptured allowing the Powdex resin to be carried to the steam generators. The exact quantity of resin
~
discharged to the steam generators is not known, but is estimated to be 200 to 300 pounds.
- "The operational events leading to the discharge hinge on the timing of fill and pressurize operations on a single Powdex vessel during return to service following installation of a new resin charge. Normally, after the filter elements are coated with resin, the vessel is slowly filled and pressurized
' to establish flow through the filter clements. The operat'ing pressure differential across the ' filter elements is established as the discharge-side pressure follows the inlet-side pressure up to operating pressure. Thus, when the main condensate inlet line is opened, admitting condensate at operating . pressure (s400 psig), a controlled AP across the filter elements has already been established.
"Duting this event, however, the condensate inlet line opened before the vessel t had been completely filled and an operating AP had been established across the filter elements. This surge of higher pressure condensate created an abnormally high AP across the filter elements, rupturing the element seals. This permitted -
condensate to carry the resin off the filter elements and out through the vessel (' discharge valve."
- 9
.g-4 43
'N'f(3fA(11
.. /* APPENDIX B'
" STEAM CENERATOR CHEMISTRY SU}CIARY" "A review of plant chemistry data logs was performed to investigate the cause of the steam generator corrosion. The discharge of Powdex resin into the steam generator on Fcbutary 27, 1579, caused chemistry parameter excursions as shown in the table below:
Steam Generator Chemistry Parameters Before and After Resin Discharge Event Baseline Immediate Effect pH 0 25*C 8.8-9.0 6.02 Cation Conductivity <0.4 pmhos 25 pahos Chloride <0.05 ppm 0.05 ppm (unchanged) Sodium <0.04 ppm 0.1 ppm . Silica <0.'1 ppm 0.33 ppm Ammonia <0.2 ppm 0.59 ppm The long term effects of the resin discharge on steam genera' tor chemistry were as follows:
- 1. Cation conductivity returned to less than 2 pahos on Parch 7,1979.
This is the first time since the discharge on February 27, 1979, that. this parareeter was within recommended limits. Load reductions and shutdowns have caused cation conductivity 2. excursions to as high as 40 pahos (5-2-79).
- 3. Steam generator chemistry approached baseline values toward the
( end of May 1979. The major findings of a Westinghouse review of plant chemistry data logs are as follows: .
- 1. Reported anions, cations, and cation conductivities are not in balance.
(.
- 2. Sodium concentration consistently exceeds that required for chloride <
stoichiometry.
- 3. -Cation excursions not due to chlorides. .
(c 4. A large anion inventory exists in the steam generators and evidence indicates that this is due to salphates.
- 5. Numerous events of silica passing through the Powdex system due to resin saturation have occurred. Silica in condensate results from condenser inleakage."
1 44
.}}