ML103090708

OL - FW: Rad Mon Questions

ML103090708
Person / Time
Site:	Watts Bar
Issue date:	10/12/2010
From:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Division of Operating Reactor Licensing
References
Download: ML103090708 (8)

Text

WBN2Public Resource From: Poole, Justin Sent: Tuesday, October 12, 2010 6:59 AM To: Singh, Gursharan Cc: WBN2HearingFile Resource

Subject:

FW: Rad Mon Questions See below Justin C. Poole Project Manager NRR/DORL/LPWB U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (301)4152048 email: Justin.Poole@nrc.gov From: Crouch, William D [1]

Sent: Monday, October 11, 2010 7:22 AM To: Poole, Justin

Subject:

FW: Rad Mon Questions See below.

William D. (Bill) Crouch (423) 3652004 WBN (256) 7777676 Cell From: Clark, Mark Steven Sent: Thursday, October 07, 2010 3:23 PM To: Crouch, William D

Subject:

FW: Rad Mon Questions Bill:

Please forward to Justin for Gursharan Singh.

Thanks, Steve Steve Clark Bechtel Power Corp.

Control Systems Watts Bar 2 Completion Project Phone: 865.632.6547 Fax: 865.632.2524 e-mail: msclark0@tva.gov From: Chavez, Hector [2]

Sent: Wednesday, October 06, 2010 4:42 PM To: Clark, Mark Steven; Mather, Dale C 1

Cc: Temples, Joe T Jr

Subject:

RE: Rad Mon Questions Mark, It all seems fine, no additional comments.

Hector Chavez Project manager General Atomics Electronic Systems, Inc.

(858) 5228341 Hector.Chavez@gaesi.com From: Clark, Mark Steven [3]

Sent: Wednesday, October 06, 2010 12:54 PM To: Clark, Mark Steven; Chavez, Hector; Mather, Dale C Cc: Temples, Joe T Jr

Subject:

RE: Rad Mon Questions I dont know what happened but I lost my numbering. This one is easier to read TVA has provided various documents in support of The Sequoyah RM-1000 v1.1 Software RM-1000 high range monitors for WBN2. Verification Report 04508006 and RM-1000 v1.2 Please clarify the following: Software Verification Report 04508006 are RM-1000 v1.1 Software Verification Report applicable to WBN Unit 2.

04508006 (Sequoyah)

RM-1000 v1.2 Software Verification Report The RM-1000 System Verification Test Results 04508006 (Sequoyah) report is not applicable to WBN Unit 2. This RM-1000 System Verification Test Results document was for the non-safety related software (Sequoyah) and was superseded by the 04508006 v1.1 and v1.2 reports for the safety-related software.

These documents were prepared for the Sequoyah plant. IS the version provided applicable to WBN2? Please confirm and explain if these documents are applicable to WBN 2 as provided or with differences?

TVA has provided a proprietary and a non- (i) These documents are applicable to WBN proprietary version of Technical Manual for RM-1000 Unit 2.

Digital Radiation Processor under ML101680582 (ii) This was an error in document preparation and ML101680587). that occurred when attachments were assembled for a previous letter.

(i) Are these documents applicable to WBN2 (iii) The Technical Manual is not intended to as provided (October 2003 version). include equipment requirements.

(ii) Why is DCN38993-A attached at the back of Requirements would be found in the the proprietary version? It is for WBN1 applicable TVA Specifications for the Turbine Governor Control Valve. contract.

(iii) This document does not state the requirements for RM-1000 units. Please provide a document that states the requirements for the RM-1000 radiation monitors for WBN2.

TVA has provided the following documents for RM- (i) Applicable to WBN Unit 2. 04508905-1QR is 1000 equipment qualification: applicable only in regards to the RM-1000, with the exception of re-qualification of certain (i) Qualification Test Report for RM-1000 RM-1000 equipment differences covered in Processor Module and Current-To-Frequency the -1SP report. The Current-to-Frequency (I-Converter 04508905-QR (January 2001) F) converter module qualifications in the base (ii) Qualification Test Report Supplement, RM- report and the -1SP report are not applicable 1000 Upgrades 04508905-1SP (June 2006) to the RM-1000s, and will be used later as (iii) Qualification Test Report Supplement, RM- references in the WBN Unit 2 specific 2

1000 Upgrades 04508905-2SP (June 2008) qualification reports.

(iv) Qualification Test Report Supplement, RM- (ii) Applicable to WBN Unit 2.

1000 Upgrades 04508905-3SP (May 2008) (iii) Not applicable to WBN Unit 2 (iv) Not applicable to WBN Unit 2 Please clarify whether all of these are fully applicable to WBN2 or are they applicable with The 04508905-3SP report was prepared for exceptions? If with exceptions, then please clarify another TVA plant, as a monitor system-level what those are. report, where the system included equipment mostly based on the base report equipment items.

Supplement 3 was issued one month prior to These two -2SP and -3SP supplement reports supplement 2. Please explain the reason for the were essentially worked concurrently, but the -2SP same. document review/release process resulted in the release time difference.

TVA provided System Verification Test Results See Response to letter item __ (RAI Matrix Item 04507007-1TR (July 1999) for Sequoyah to support 316) for non-applicability of 04507007-1TR. The test verification. However, the document states recorded anomaly was later resolved through the (page v) that it is not applicable for high range verification of software version 1.2, reported in RM-monitors with an action noted for fixing a problem 1000 v1.2 Software Verification Report 04508006.

with the high range RM-1000 monitors on page vi.

TVA to respond to the following clarifications: The high range verification documents are the Sequoyah RM-1000 v1.1 Software Verification Has the anomaly noted on page vi been resolved for Report 04508006 and RM-1000 v1.2 Software the high range monitors? Verification Report 04508006.

Provide the high range verification document for WBN2.

Regards, Steve Steve Clark Bechtel Power Corp.

Control Systems Watts Bar 2 Completion Project Phone: 865.632.6547 Fax: 865.632.2524 e-mail: msclark0@tva.gov From: Clark, Mark Steven Sent: Wednesday, October 06, 2010 3:46 PM To: 'Chavez, Hector'; Mather, Dale C Cc: Temples, Joe T Jr

Subject:

RE: Rad Mon Questions Hector Thanks. I did a little work on the responses to make then read better for the NRC. Please review and let me know if you have any comments.

RAI Response TVA has provided various documents in support of The Sequoyah RM-1000 v1.1 Software Verification RM-1000 high range monitors for WBN2. Report 04508006 and RM-1000 v1.2 Software Please clarify the following: Verification Report 04508006 are applicable to RM-1000 v1.1 Software Verification Report WBN Unit 2.

04508006 (Sequoyah)

RM-1000 v1.2 Software Verification Report The RM-1000 System Verification Test Results 3

04508006 (Sequoyah) report is not applicable to WBN Unit 2. This RM-1000 System Verification Test Results document was for the non-safety related software (Sequoyah) and was superseded by the 04508006 v1.1 and v1.2 reports for the safety-related software.

These documents were prepared for the Sequoyah plant. IS the version provided applicable to WBN2?

Please confirm and explain if these documents are applicable to WBN 2 as provided or with differences?

TVA has provided a proprietary and a non- These documents are applicable to WBN Unit 2.

proprietary version of Technical Manual for RM- This was an error in document preparation that 1000 Digital Radiation Processor under occurred when attachments were assembled for a ML101680582 and ML101680587). previous letter.

The Technical Manual is not intended to include Are these documents applicable to WBN2 as equipment requirements. Requirements would be provided (October 2003 version). found in the applicable TVA Specifications for the Why is DCN38993-A attached at the back of the contract.

proprietary version? It is for WBN1 Turbine Governor Control Valve.

This document does not state the requirements for RM-1000 units. Please provide a document that states the requirements for the RM-1000 radiation monitors for WBN2.

TVA has provided the following documents for RM- Applicable to WBN Unit 2. 04508905-1QR is 1000 equipment qualification: applicable only in regards to the RM-1000, with the exception of re-qualification of certain RM-1000 Qualification Test Report for RM-1000 Processor equipment differences covered in the -1SP report.

Module and Current-To-Frequency Converter The Current-to-Frequency (I-F) converter module 04508905-QR (January 2001) qualifications in the base report and the -1SP Qualification Test Report Supplement, RM-1000 report are not applicable to the RM-1000s, and will Upgrades 04508905-1SP (June 2006) be used later as references in the WBN Unit 2 Qualification Test Report Supplement, RM-1000 specific qualification reports.

Upgrades 04508905-2SP (June 2008) Applicable to WBN Unit 2.

Qualification Test Report Supplement, RM-1000 Not applicable to WBN Unit 2 Upgrades 04508905-3SP (May 2008) Not applicable to WBN Unit 2 Please clarify whether all of these are fully The 04508905-3SP report was prepared for applicable to WBN2 or are they applicable with another TVA plant, as a monitor system-level exceptions? If with exceptions, then please clarify report, where the system included equipment what those are. mostly based on the base report equipment items.

These two -2SP and -3SP supplement reports Supplement 3 was issued one month prior to were essentially worked concurrently, but the -2SP supplement 2. Please explain the reason for the document review/release process resulted in the same. release time difference.

TVA provided System Verification Test Results Responder: Temples 04507007-1TR (July 1999) for Sequoyah to support test verification. However, the document states See Response to letter item __ (RAI Matrix Item (page v) that it is not applicable for high range 316) for non-applicability of 04507007-1TR. The monitors with an action noted for fixing a problem recorded anomaly was later resolved through the with the high range RM-1000 monitors on page vi. verification of software version 1.2, reported in RM-TVA to respond to the following clarifications: 1000 v1.2 Software Verification Report 04508006.

Has the anomaly noted on page vi been resolved The high range verification documents are the for the high range monitors? Sequoyah RM-1000 v1.1 Software Verification Report 04508006 and RM-1000 v1.2 Software Provide the high range verification document for Verification Report 04508006.

WBN2.

4

Regards, Steve Steve Clark Bechtel Power Corp.

Control Systems Watts Bar 2 Completion Project Phone: 865.632.6547 Fax: 865.632.2524 e-mail: msclark0@tva.gov From: Chavez, Hector [4]

Sent: Wednesday, October 06, 2010 2:25 PM To: Mather, Dale C Cc: Temples, Joe T Jr; Clark, Mark Steven

Subject:

RE: Rad Mon Questions Dale, Following is our response to the Rad monitors questions, Item Numbers 316, 317, 318, 319.

1. 1. The first two documents listed are directly applicable to WBN2 RM-1000s, as the code version results are applicable to both the present WBN2 safety-related contract, and to any future SQN safety-related RM-1000 contract. The System Verification Test Results 04507007-1TR is not applicable to WBN, because it is only applicable to Sequoyah non-safety-related RM-1000s. The 04507007-1TR report was requested by TVA/SQN, when TVA suspended GA-ESI work on the safety-related portion of the SQN contract in work for RM-1000s. This 04507007-1TR report was solely used by TVA to provide a level of software verification commensurate with their application of non-safety-related RM-1000s in the SQN contract, leaving GA-ESI to later continue with safety-related verification separately. This later GA-ESI work developed the safety-related software verification, including a Critical Digital Review by TVA, where RM-1000 software Version 1.1 was approved by TVA for future safety-related procurement. And, this work produced the first two listed documents, that are the applicable results documents for the deliverable WBN2 safety-related RM-1000s.

2. 2. i. These documents are applicable iii. The iii. Technical Manual is not intended to include equipment requirements. Requirements would be found in the applicable TVA Specifications for the contract.

3. 3. With regards to the RM-1000 modules, the first two documents are applicable to WBN2, but not the 04508905-2SP and 3SP documents. The base document 04508905-1QR is applicable only in regards to the RM-1000, with the exception of re-qualification of certain RM-1000 equipment differences covered in the -1SP report. The Current-to-Frequency (I-F) converter module qualifications in the base report and the -1SP report are not applicable to the RM-1000s, and will be used later as references in the WBN2-specific qualification reports. The 04508905-3SP report was prepared for another TVA plant, as a monitor system-level report, where the system included equipment mostly based on the base report equipment items. These two -2SP and -3SP supplement reports were essentially worked concurrently, but the -2SP document review/release process resulted in the release time difference.

4. 4. See Response 1 for non-applicability of 04507007-1TR. However, the recorded anomaly was resolved later, through the verification of software version 1.2, reported in 04508006.

Thank you for you patients Hector Chavez Project manager General Atomics Electronic Systems, Inc.

(858) 5228341 Hector.Chavez@gaesi.com From: Mather, Dale C [5]

Sent: Tuesday, October 05, 2010 9:03 AM 5

To: Chavez, Hector Cc: Temples, Joe T Jr; Clark, Mark Steven

Subject:

FW: Rad Mon Questions Hector Please respond to Item Number 316, 317, 318, 319 AND GIVE ME A CALL.

Dale Mather Bechtel Control Systems Engineering Watts Bar Unit 2 865-632-7527 Fax:240-379-2045 From: Clark, Mark Steven Sent: Tuesday, October 05, 2010 10:45 AM To: Temples, Joe T Jr; Mather, Dale C

Subject:

Rad Mon Questions

1. NRC Request (Item Number 316)

TVA has provided various documents in support of RM-1000 high range monitors for WBN2.

Please clarify the following:

RM-1000 v1.1 Software Verification Report 04508006 (Sequoyah)

RM-1000 v1.2 Software Verification Report 04508006 (Sequoyah)

RM-1000 System Verification Test Results (Sequoyah)

These documents were prepared for the Sequoyah plant. Is the version provided applicable to WBN2?

Please confirm and explain if these documents are applicable to WBN 2 as provided or with differences?

TVA Response:

2. NRC Request (Item Number 317)

TVA has provided a proprietary and a non-proprietary version of Technical Manual for RM-1000 Digital Radiation Processor under ML101680582 and ML101680587).

(vii) Are these documents applicable to WBN2 as provided (October 2003 version).

(viii) N/A (ix) This document does not state the requirements for RM-1000 units. Please provide a document that states the requirements for the RM-1000 radiation monitors for WBN2.

TVA Response:

3. NRC Request (Item Number 318)

TVA has provided the following documents for RM-1000 equipment qualification:

Qualification Test Report for RM-1000 Processor Module and Current-To-Frequency Converter 04508905-QR (January 2001)

Qualification Test Report Supplement, RM-1000 Upgrades 04508905-1SP (June 2006)

Qualification Test Report Supplement, RM-1000 Upgrades 04508905-2SP (June 2008)

Qualification Test Report Supplement, RM-1000 Upgrades 04508905-3SP (May 2008) 6

Please clarify whether all of these are fully applicable to WBN2 or are they applicable with exceptions? If with exceptions, then please clarify what those are.

Supplement 3 was issued one month prior to supplement 2. Please explain the reason for the same.

TVA Response:

4. NRC Request (Item Number 319)

TVA provided System Verification Test Results 04507007-1TR (July 1999) for Sequoyah to support test verification. However, the document states (page v) that it is not applicable for high range monitors with an action noted for fixing a problem with the high range RM-1000 monitors on page vi. TVA to respond to the following clarifications:

Has the anomaly noted on page vi been resolved for the high range monitors?

Provide the high range verification document for WBN2.

TVA Response:

Regards, Steve Steve Clark Bechtel Power Corp.

Control Systems Watts Bar 2 Completion Project Phone: 865.632.6547 Fax: 865.632.2524 e-mail: msclark0@tva.gov 7

Hearing Identifier: Watts_Bar_2_Operating_LA_Public Email Number: 134 Mail Envelope Properties (19D990B45D535548840D1118C451C74D6FD36BBAEB)

Subject:

FW: Rad Mon Questions Sent Date: 10/12/2010 6:58:47 AM Received Date: 10/12/2010 6:58:52 AM From: Poole, Justin Created By: Justin.Poole@nrc.gov Recipients:

"WBN2HearingFile Resource" <WBN2HearingFile.Resource@nrc.gov>

Tracking Status: None "Singh, Gursharan" <Gursharan.Singh@nrc.gov>

Tracking Status: None Post Office: HQCLSTR02.nrc.gov Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 17676 10/12/2010 6:58:52 AM Options Priority: Standard Return Notification: No Reply Requested: No Sensitivity: Normal Expiration Date:

Recipients Received: