ML20072E808: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
StriderTol Bot change
StriderTol Bot change
 
Line 17: Line 17:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:-             _                                            _ _ .                        . _ _ _ _ _ _ _
{{#Wiki_filter:-
r     l i
l r
ENCLOSURE 1 THE CINCINNAT1 GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY                             cinciwwei.owio seoi t
ENCLOSURE 1 i
w.m.nieswowen
THE CINCINNAT1 GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY cinciwwei.owio seoi t
            """"                            February 28, 1983                         i
w.m.nieswowen February 28, 1983 i
                                                                                          \.
\\.
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission                       -
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region III 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 Attention:
Region III 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 Attention:       Mr. James G. Keppler Regional Administrator Gentlemen Re:   Wm. H. Zimnar Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1, Order to Show Cause and Order Immediately Sus _pending Constructi_on, Docket No. 5_0-358 ___         .
Mr. James G. Keppler Regional Administrator Gentlemen Re:
On Nove ber 12, 1982 an Order to Show Cause was issued                               ,
Wm. H. Zimnar Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1, Order to Show Cause and Order Immediately Sus _pending Constructi_on, Docket No. 5_0-358 ___
which suspended all safety-related activities on the Zimmer project.
On Nove ber 12, 1982 an Order to Show Cause was issued which suspended all safety-related activities on the Zimmer project.
The order directed us to obtain an independent management review o                                 ,
The order directed us to obtain an independent management review o of the project and to submit a comprehensive plan to complete the project.
of the project and to submit a comprehensive plan to complete the project. As you know, we had proposed that the Bechtel Power Corporation perform both the independent management review function l and the project management function. We have reviewed the opinions of the Commission as contained in the February 18, 1983 memoranda on this subject as well as your letter of February 23, 1983. Based on these memoranda, it is our understanding that the Commission will                                       ,
As you know, we had proposed that the Bechtel Power Corporation perform both the independent management review function
not permit Bechtel to perform both tasks for the Zimmer project.
:l and the project management function.
For your information, it is our desire to proceed with I
We have reviewed the opinions of the Commission as contained in the February 18, 1983 memoranda on this subject as well as your letter of February 23, 1983.
that part of the project for which we are pennitted toAccordingly, do under the                               l Order to show cause and the February 18 memoranda.                                             we intend to effectuate the following:
Based on these memoranda, it is our understanding that the Commission will not permit Bechtel to perform both tasks for the Zimmer project.
: 1. Bechtel will not undertcke the independent! management                                       j review. CG&E will transmit to you shortly for the NRC staff's consideration a revised propocal for the independent management reviewer.
For your information, it is our desire to proceed with that part of the project for which we are pennitted to do under the Order to show cause and the February 18 memoranda.
: 2. In the interim, we intend to retain Bechtel as a consultant                                 1 to assist with current activities that are not restricted by the November 12 Order to show Cause; no activities will be undertaken which are cafety-related construction -
Accordingly, we intend to effectuate the following:
Bechtel will not undertcke the independent! management j
1.
review.
CG&E will transmit to you shortly for the NRC staff's consideration a revised propocal for the independent management reviewer.
1 2.
In the interim, we intend to retain Bechtel as a consultant to assist with current activities that are not restricted by the November 12 Order to show Cause; no activities will be undertaken which are cafety-related construction -
activities.
activities.
8303230072 830311                                       -
8303230072 830311 PDR ADOCK 05000358 A
PDR ADOCK 05000358 A                     PDR gg
PDR gg


f'
f'
                                                                                        ~
~
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission                                           -
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission httn Mr. James G. Keppler Page 2 7 ebruary 28, 1983 F.e :
httn       Mr. James G. Keppler Page 2 7   ebruary 28, 1983 F.e :   Mm. II. Zimmer Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1 I
Mm. II. Zimmer Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1 I
: 3. All activities undertaken by Bechtel will be at our risk, and subject to the outcome of the independent management review to be performed by another party.
3.
All activities undertaken by Bechtel will be at our risk, and subject to the outcome of the independent management review to be performed by another party.
CG&E recognizes that some of the activities undertaken during this interim period may require amendment or elaboration when the independent management review results are known.
CG&E recognizes that some of the activities undertaken during this interim period may require amendment or elaboration when the independent management review results are known.
Our interim activities include the following:
Our interim activities include the following:
: 1. Review or develop a Project Procedures Manual.
1.
: 2. Review documentation programs.
Review or develop a Project Procedures Manual.
: 3. Review the existing training programs and initiate additional programs if required.
2.
: 4. Establish programs to organize the data available one
Review documentation programs.
: a. Welder qualifications
3.
: b. Material qualifications
Review the existing training programs and initiate additional programs if required.
: c. Heat logs
4.
: d. Vendor qualifications
Establish programs to organize the data available one a.
: e. Others as identified h
Welder qualifications b.
I               5. Review status of FSAR.
Material qualifications c.
l
Heat logs d.
: 6. Walkdown to determine the physical "as built" condition of the plant.
Vendor qualifications e.
      !        7. Analyze existing computer programs and develop new ones I             as required, In our view, these interim measures provide a workable and efficient means of accomplishing the goal of the Commission, the lRegionalAdministrator,r.ndCGLEwhichisassuringthatconstruction, lwhen resumed, will proceed in an orderly manner in accordance with the requirements of the commission's regulations.
Others as identified h
Yours very truly, 3                                  THE CINCI!RMTI GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY
I 5.
        '                                  By bdt I                                       W. H. Dichhoner
Review status of FSAR.
        !. %}}
l 6.
Walkdown to determine the physical "as built" condition of the plant.
7.
Analyze existing computer programs and develop new ones I
as required, In our view, these interim measures provide a workable and efficient means of accomplishing the goal of the Commission, the lRegionalAdministrator,r.ndCGLEwhichisassuringthatconstruction, lwhen resumed, will proceed in an orderly manner in accordance with the requirements of the commission's regulations.
Yours very truly, THE CINCI!RMTI GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY 3
bdt By I
W. H. Dichhoner
!. %}}

Latest revision as of 05:30, 15 December 2024

Responds to 821112 Order to Show Cause Which Suspended All safety-related Activities.Interim Measures Assuring That Const Will Proceed Per NRC Requirements Listed.Bechtel Will Consult on Activities Not Restricted by Order
ML20072E808
Person / Time
Site: Zimmer
Issue date: 02/28/1983
From: Dickhoner W
CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC CO.
To: James Keppler
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
Shared Package
ML20072E802 List:
References
NUDOCS 8303230072
Download: ML20072E808 (2)


Text

-

l r

ENCLOSURE 1 i

THE CINCINNAT1 GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY cinciwwei.owio seoi t

w.m.nieswowen February 28, 1983 i

\\.

U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region III 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 Attention:

Mr. James G. Keppler Regional Administrator Gentlemen Re:

Wm. H. Zimnar Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1, Order to Show Cause and Order Immediately Sus _pending Constructi_on, Docket No. 5_0-358 ___

On Nove ber 12, 1982 an Order to Show Cause was issued which suspended all safety-related activities on the Zimmer project.

The order directed us to obtain an independent management review o of the project and to submit a comprehensive plan to complete the project.

As you know, we had proposed that the Bechtel Power Corporation perform both the independent management review function

l and the project management function.

We have reviewed the opinions of the Commission as contained in the February 18, 1983 memoranda on this subject as well as your letter of February 23, 1983.

Based on these memoranda, it is our understanding that the Commission will not permit Bechtel to perform both tasks for the Zimmer project.

For your information, it is our desire to proceed with that part of the project for which we are pennitted to do under the Order to show cause and the February 18 memoranda.

Accordingly, we intend to effectuate the following:

Bechtel will not undertcke the independent! management j

1.

review.

CG&E will transmit to you shortly for the NRC staff's consideration a revised propocal for the independent management reviewer.

1 2.

In the interim, we intend to retain Bechtel as a consultant to assist with current activities that are not restricted by the November 12 Order to show Cause; no activities will be undertaken which are cafety-related construction -

activities.

8303230072 830311 PDR ADOCK 05000358 A

PDR gg

f'

~

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission httn Mr. James G. Keppler Page 2 7 ebruary 28, 1983 F.e :

Mm. II. Zimmer Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1 I

3.

All activities undertaken by Bechtel will be at our risk, and subject to the outcome of the independent management review to be performed by another party.

CG&E recognizes that some of the activities undertaken during this interim period may require amendment or elaboration when the independent management review results are known.

Our interim activities include the following:

1.

Review or develop a Project Procedures Manual.

2.

Review documentation programs.

3.

Review the existing training programs and initiate additional programs if required.

4.

Establish programs to organize the data available one a.

Welder qualifications b.

Material qualifications c.

Heat logs d.

Vendor qualifications e.

Others as identified h

I 5.

Review status of FSAR.

l 6.

Walkdown to determine the physical "as built" condition of the plant.

7.

Analyze existing computer programs and develop new ones I

as required, In our view, these interim measures provide a workable and efficient means of accomplishing the goal of the Commission, the lRegionalAdministrator,r.ndCGLEwhichisassuringthatconstruction, lwhen resumed, will proceed in an orderly manner in accordance with the requirements of the commission's regulations.

Yours very truly, THE CINCI!RMTI GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY 3

bdt By I

W. H. Dichhoner

!. %