ML19261F292

Abnormal Occurrence 74-2:on 740422,during Testing,Potential Set Point Error on Pressure Switches for High Reactor Bldg Reactor Trip Found to Be Plus or Minus 0.135 Psig.New Set Point of 3.75 Psig Recommended & Agreed Upon

ML19261F292
Person / Time
Site:	Crane
Issue date:	05/01/1974
From:	Arnold R METROPOLITAN EDISON CO.
To:
References
NUDOCS 7910250745
Download: ML19261F292 (2)

Text

'

AEC D7 T ""-~ c% "" " ;'1T 5 0 r""7 :A t.L

( E 12C? lay FC3);) CC:;T20L 1:0: 4042 FILE: /3/O _

FRC' : . DATE OF ECC DA~E REC'D LTR I li;;;0 12T 012 Metropolitan Edison Company Reading, Pa. 19603 5-1-74 5-6-74 X R. C. Arnold TO: CRIG CC CTHER SE!.T AEC ?"R N _

D. L. I signed SET LCCAL P:'R X CLASS UNCLASS PROP INFO IUPUT NO CYS PIC'D DOCKET 1:0:

XXX 1 50-289 DESCRIlTION: E';CLCSURE.S :

Ltr reporting abnormal occurrence A0-74-2 on 4-22-74, regarding setpoint error........ ,

g

, 00U Oggo ACKNOWLEDGED PLANT NAME: Three Mile Island Unit #1 FOR ACTICN/I"FC?2'ATICN 5-7-74 CC BUTLER (L) /CiD ENCER(L) ZICLEN(L) REGAN(E)

W/ Copica W/ 7 Copies W/ Copies W/ Copiec CI AF2(L) STOLZ(L) DICKER (E)

W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Ccpies W/ Copies PA'1R( L) VASSALLO(L) ICilI,iiTCN(E)

W/ Copics W/ Copies W/ Copies w/ copies KNIEL(L) PURPLE (L) YOUNGBLCOD(E)

W/ Copias W/ Copice W/ Copies W/ Copies INTE?2'?L DISTRI UTI ~ ~.i

%G FIL3 TECli RZ'lIZ. I DE':TCN A /T T"3 wf!ENDRIE GRII::S LIC ASST 33AIn 23 v.EC PDR g4GC, RCCM P-506A SCliRCCDER G!d 2:ILL gvcc-

• UUO S ALT 2':AN

/

)!Ur'ITING/ STAFF # ACCARY KASTNER 3* I' v CASE ,)0!ICliT PALLA2D [Gn.RIN(L)

ULECURNE (L) PL1"3 GIM;3USSO vFAWLICK1 SPANGLER (L)

L.-

t- ,,C-..,,,.. x..n-v BOYD W.40 MAIGRET (L) DUS:v/ Input ACCRE (L)(E!R) @TELLO ENVIpp. REED (E)

DEYOUNG(L)(FIR) wr.CUSTON MULLER SERVICE (L)

SKOVE0LT (L) WCVAK DICKER SHEPPARD (L)

C. MI.ES COLLER(L) 40SS 10i1GHTON SLATER (E'j B. Y G G/ 35E)

P. COLLI"S vfPPOLITO YOU::G3LOOD wtLECKER SMTH (L)

DENISE JEDESCO REGAN A 13CNNUT TEETS (L) jEGOPR .,LONG FROJECT LDR WADE (E) VThmp569 6 )

FILE & REGION (3) vLAINAS g1Lt1Aug (g) ,

d! ORRIS LEENARCYA HARLESS STFETI' WOLTEER WILSON (L) 1 \'b EXTE'"\L DISTRI"U"Ti. /d _

4 - LCCAL POR Harrisburst . Pa. #'

1-FDR-S;/*'/ W wi - TIC (ASERNAT!:Y) (1) (2'X 10 )-NATIC'.*AL I '.E ' S .

LA - USIC(3UCFCAN) 1- ACL;? O'j .- "1d 2, y. 2 0) 1-G2RALD LILLCL:.2 1 - ASLB 1 ',' . P ES.:~ %!O~.. , T. E-201 GT ERC0KIM"?:.N NAT. 1 1 1 - P. R. DA'/IS (AEROJET SUCLEAR) 1-CONSULTA'.;I' 3 1-AOMED(i.ath Gt-c :

g,A6 - CYS ACKS X]OC00 DOC SENT TO LIC. ASST. NEUMARK/ FLUME /AG3A31AN 101- D- 12 ' , GT .

5-7-74 GOULBOURNE l-GERALD UL.UZSC'.i. . 0RiiL l-RD . .'iULLEd. . F- 3 0 -

1-3 & M SWI5EER0AD, Pc E-201 GT 7910250 7#/S' d'

Regulaiory I)ocket He WNEIKJ C, 2 g - .,,..x.~

METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY FOOT OFFICE BUX 542 READING, PENNSYLV ANI A 19CC2 TELEPHCNE 215 - 929-2601 May 1, 197h - f s ek ,7' ,

a  ?$% % i .\ / ,f;,',[..

,7 6 . '

Director ffg '-

Directorate of Licensing 2 8 d ' !!Y k' )

U. S. Atc=ic Energy Cc==ission @ 4, cyg. 78h[&, C,'

Washington, DC 205h5 Cc p ' ,r g L[. ['j'! } -( -

Gcatlemen:

Operating License DPR-50 Docket No. 50-289 V'M CM'd .

Abnor=al Occurrence No. A0-Th-2 In accordance with Technical Specificaticns for the Three Mile Island Nuclear Statica Unit 1, Secticn 6.7 2.a.h. , we are reporting the folleving incident as an abnormal occurrence ( AO-Th-2) as defined by Section 1.8.a.

At 1100 on April 22,197L, during initial fuel loading, the pressure svitches for the High Peacter Building Pressure reactor trip were decreased by Instrument Technicians frc= L.0 psig to a =cre conservative setting of 3 75 psig to account fcr pctential set point errors. The Test Ccordi-nator, in reviewing the test results, discovered that the as-found setting for Channel A was 4.1 psig and for Channel D was h.15 psig, which ecnsti-tutes safety system settings less conservative than the li=it of h.0 psig as defined by Section 2 3.1 and Table 2 3-1 Ite 8 of Technical Specifica-tiens.

Based upon a review by on-site engineering persennel of the Technical Manualc- for the associated equipment, the pctential set pch errer was concluded to be +C.135 psig. The Plant operatiens Review

_ -4ttee (FCRC) met prc=ptly after the incident, concurred with the analysis of the set point error, and recc==?nded to the Plant Superintendent that the new set point of 3 75 psig was adequate to prevent recurrence. The Plant Superintendent has ccccurred in this finding.

Sincerely,

..b

' 'i R. .

w&

'"iOLD Vice President-Generaticn -

RCA:DNG:sh ec: Directcrate of Regulatory Cperations, Regien 1 U. S. Atc=ic Energy Cc==issicn 631 Park Avenue King of Prussia, Pennsylvania 4()f2 19hc6