ML20148F716: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot change)
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:m-2I U'         m                DISTRIBUTION:
{{#Wiki_filter:m-2I U' DISTRIBUTION:
G%.vDock'et Files (3)
m G%.vDock'et Files (3)
                                                                                                "NRC PDR (3)                                               E Dockett Nos.:         50-29 W ~ "                                                   L PDR (3)                 JRBuchanan             E 50-309                                     -
"NRC PDR (3)
ORB #1:8 Rdg               ACRS (16)               p and. 50-271                                                         VStello                   ORB #4 Rdg             !R KRGoller                   QA Rdg.                 E=. . .
E Dockett Nos.:
TJCarter                   NRR Rdg.               E-RReid                     Topical Rpt. File Yankee Atomic Electric Company                                                   VRooney (2)               JConway ATTN: Mr. L. H. Heider                                                           PDiBenedetto               AGarland Assistant Vice President                                           ABurger                   JHeltemes 20 Turnpike Road                                                                 RIngram                   DSkovholt Westboro, Massachusetts 05181                                         Attorney, OELD                                           =
50-29 W ~ "
OI&E(3)                   ASchwencer
L PDR (3)
JRBuchanan E
50-309 ORB #1:8 Rdg ACRS (16) p and.
50-271 VStello ORB #4 Rdg
!R KRGoller QA Rdg.
E=...
TJCarter NRR Rdg.
E-RReid Topical Rpt. File Yankee Atomic Electric Company VRooney (2)
JConway ATTN: Mr. L. H. Heider PDiBenedetto AGarland Assistant Vice President ABurger JHeltemes 20 Turnpike Road RIngram DSkovholt Westboro, Massachusetts 05181 Attorney, OELD
..=
OI&E(3)
ASchwencer


==Dear Mr. Heider:==
==Dear Mr. Heider:==
DEisenhut                 RReid                               s RE:       EVALUATION OF AMENDMENT. TO QA TOPICAL REPORT We have evaluated Amendment No. I to Yankee Atomic Electric Company's Topical Report Y0QAP-1, " Operational Quality Assurance Program" sub-mitted with your {{letter dated|date=December 9, 1976|text=December 9,1976, letter}} to detcrmine its confomance with Appendix B to 10 CFR 50.
DEisenhut RReid s
The NRC staff's positions, which were discussed with members of your staff on December 17, 1976, relative to this topical report are                                                                     j enclosed. Your responses to the enclosure should be submitted as                                                                     ..
RE:
an amendment (50 copies to the attention of C. J. Heltemes, Jr.) to                                                                 !.
EVALUATION OF AMENDMENT. TO QA TOPICAL REPORT We have evaluated Amendment No. I to Yankee Atomic Electric Company's Topical Report Y0QAP-1, " Operational Quality Assurance Program" sub-mitted with your {{letter dated|date=December 9, 1976|text=December 9,1976, letter}} to detcrmine its confomance with Appendix B to 10 CFR 50.
the original report by January 14, 1977.
The NRC staff's positions, which were discussed with members of your staff on December 17, 1976, relative to this topical report are j
                                                                                                                                                        ]       y If you have any additional questions regarding this request, please contact John Gilray or James Conway on (301) 492-7741.
enclosed. Your responses to the enclosure should be submitted as an amendment (50 copies to the attention of C. J. Heltemes, Jr.) to the original report by January 14, 1977.
]
y If you have any additional questions regarding this request, please contact John Gilray or James Conway on (301) 492-7741.
i.
i.
                                                                                                                                                      'S Sincerely,                                                                             :g f
'S f
Q) k hAWWm> u                                                                 n u
:g Sincerely, Q) k hAWWm> u n
Karl R. Goller, Assistant Director                                           i V           for Operating Reactors
u Karl R. Goller, Assistant Director i
V for Operating Reactors
["
["
i Division of Operating Reactors                                                             '
i Division of Operating Reactors


==Enclosure:==
==Enclosure:==
U Staff Positions                                                                                                 '
U Staff Positions I
I in
in t
                                                                                                                ' '                                  t cc w/ enclosure: See next page THIS DOCUMENT CONTAlf6                                                         ,
cc w/ enclosure: See next page THIS DOCUMENT CONTAlf6 POOR QUAUTY PAGES/
0 POOR QUAUTY PAGES/
0 wi SVV C-0 f 46R C-0RB#
                                                                                                  ,      wi                       SVV C-0     f 46R             C-0RB#       R     AD-0R: DOR (mes y                  u nway                                                          'kwencer               RRe'i d':       K'R' Goll er (JWGil o A i t +-
R AD-0R: DOR (mes
1   3/76      1 12/u /76 12/  176 y) .                                         . . .2/[776- ~IE75f/7f
'kwencer RRe'i d':
                                                                                          - . . . . . . . . - .'12/J5/76 Irm MC 318 sf.ev,9 53) MCLI C240                             W u. s. covC ANMENT PRINTIPeG OF F'tC tt 1974 526.199 80110co 709                                 f                                                                   _
K'R' Goll er (JWGil u
nway y
o A i t +-
1 y).
-........ -....2/[776-1 3/76 12/u /76 12/ 176
'12/J5/76
~IE75f/7f Irm MC 318 sf.ev,9 53) MCLI C240 W u. s. covC ANMENT PRINTIPeG OF F'tC tt 1974 526.199 80110co 709 f


        ..                                                            c
c
                                ,                                                                          ~
~
5 Yankee Atomic' Electric'                                         -
5 Yankee Atomic' Electric' Company cc: Mr. ' James E. Griffin, President Brooks Memorial Library Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corporation 224 Main Street.
Company             .
y 77 Grove Street Brattleboro, Vermont 05301
cc: Mr. ' James E. Griffin, President                       Brooks Memorial Library                         "'.;
~
Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corporation         224 Main Street.                     y   "
Rutl and,: Veront 05701 Mr. Donald' E. Vandenburgh, Vice President John R. Stanton, Director Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corporation Radiation Control Agency Turnpike Road, Route 9 Hazen Drive g
77 Grove Street                           ~
Westboro, Massachusetts. 01581 Concord, New Hampshire 03301 John A. Ritcher, Esquire John W. Stevens Ropes & Gray Conservation Society of 225 Franklin Street Southern Vermont Boston, Massachusetts 02110 P. O. Box 256
Brattleboro, Vermont 05301 Rutl and,: Veront 05701                                                                             :
~
Mr. Donald' E. Vandenburgh, Vice President       John R. Stanton, Director Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corporation         Radiation Control Agency Turnpike Road, Route 9                           Hazen Drive                                     g Westboro, Massachusetts. 01581                   Concord, New Hampshire 03301 John A. Ritcher, Esquire                         John W. Stevens                   .
Townshend, Vermont 05353
Ropes & Gray                                     Conservation Society of 225 Franklin Street                               Southern Vermont                                 ~
~
Boston, Massachusetts 02110                     P. O. Box 256                                     ~
Gregor I. McGregor, Esquire Assistant Attorney General
Townshend, Vermont     05353 Gregor I. McGregor, Esquire Assistant Attorney General                     -Mr. David M. Scott                   '
-Mr. David M. Scott Department of the Attorney General Radiation Health Engineer State House, Room 370 Agency of Human Services Boston, Massachusetts 02133 Division of Occupational Health P. O. Box 607 Richard E. Ayres, Esquire Barre, Vermont 05641 Natural Resources Defense Council 917 - 15th Street, H. W.
Department of the Attorney General               Radiation Health Engineer State House, Room 370                           Agency of Human Services
Raw England Coalition en Wa shir. ' ton, D. C.
                  .                Boston, Massachusetts 02133                   .
20005 Huclear Pollution Hill and Dale Farm Honoreb e M. Jerome Diamond West Hill - Faraway Road Attorne. General Putney, Vermont 05345 State et Ve rmont 109 State Street Public Service Board 7
Division of Occupational Health P. O. Box 607 Richard E. Ayres, Esquire                       Barre, Vermont 05641 Natural Resources Defense Council                                                           _
Pavilion Office Building
917 - 15th Street, H. W.                         Raw England Coalition en Wa shir. ' ton, D. C. 20005                       Huclear Pollution                                 .
. State of Vermont Hontpelier, Vermont 05602 120 State Street Montpelier, Vermont 05502 John A. Calhoun Assistant Attorney General State of Vermont 109 State Street Pavilion Of fice Building lbntpelier, Vermont 05602 Anthony Z. Roisman, Esquire Berlin, Roisman and Kessler 102515th Street, N.u., 5th Floor Washington, D. C.
                                  -                                                  Hill and Dale Farm Honoreb e M. Jerome Diamond                     West Hill - Faraway Road Attorne. General                                 Putney, Vermont 05345 State et Ve rmont                                                                             .
20005 O
109 State Street                                 Public Service Board 7
Pavilion Office Building                       . State of Vermont Hontpelier, Vermont 05602                       120 State Street Montpelier, Vermont     05502 John A. Calhoun Assistant Attorney General                         ,
State of Vermont                                                                         .
,'                                  109 State Street                                                                         ,
Pavilion Of fice Building                               .
lbntpelier, Vermont 05602                                           -
Anthony Z. Roisman, Esquire           '
Berlin, Roisman and Kessler
* 102515th Street, N.u. , 5th Floor Washington, D. C.       20005 O
e 6
e 6
l                                     3 1                                                 e-
l 1
e-3


          .      Yankee Atomic Elect $ic Company                                                                         .
Yankee Atomic Elect $ic Company cc:
i cc:           E. W. Thurlow, President                                         j     -                    -
E. W. Thurlow, President j
Maine Yankee Atomic Power Company                                     ,
i Maine Yankee Atomic Power Company 9 Green Street.
9 Green Street.                                                                           -..=
-.. =
Augusta, Maine 04310                     ,
Augusta, Maine 04310 Mr. Donald E. Vandenburgh Vice President - Engineering Yankee Atomic. Electric Company 20 Turnpike Road Westboro,11assachusetts 01581
Mr. Donald E. Vandenburgh                                                                       -
~ '
Vice President - Engineering                                                                   ,'
John A. Ritsher, Esquire
Yankee Atomic. Electric Company                                                 ,
.,m.,,,.
20 Turnpike Road
Ropes & Gray
                  .              Westboro,11assachusetts 01581
=
                                                                                                        ~ '
225 FrarMin Street Bostor, Ma'.sachusetts 02110
John A. Ritsher, Esquire                                                                     .    .,m.,,,.
                                                                                                                                          =
Ropes & Gray                                               --
                  .              225 FrarMin Street Bostor, Ma'.sachusetts 02110                                                                                 -
:L*:*..,
:L*:*..,
Mr. Jsiin M. R. Paterson                               ,
Mr. Jsiin M. R. Paterson Ass!stant Attorney General State of Maine Augusta: Maine 04330 Harold P. Green, Esquire Suite 1000 Thh Watergate 600 New Hampshire Avenue, fl. W.
Ass!stant Attorney General State of Maine                             -
Washington, D. C.
Augusta: Maine 04330                                                                               . . . .
20037
Harold P. Green, Esquire Suite 1000 Thh Watergate 600 New Hampshire Avenue, fl. W.
=.
Washington, D. C. 20037                                                                             =.
~
                    ~
Mr. Nicholas Barth Executive Director Sheepscot Valley Conservation Association, Inc.
Mr. Nicholas Barth Executive Director Sheepscot Valley Conservation Association, Inc.
* P. O. Box 125                                                                   .
P. O. Box 125
                                                                                                                                          =
=
Alna, Maine     04535-
Alna, Maine 04535-
                                                                                                                            -l   -
- l Wiseasset Public. Library Association High Street Wiscasset, Maine 04578
Wiseasset Public . Library Association
[
-                                  High Street
1 i
* Wiscasset, Maine 04578                                                       ,
e ed S
[                                                                                               .
3 j
1 i*
s._
e ed S                                   #                                                                                                        3
                                                          -  .                                            _            s._                     j


                      . Yankee Atomic Electric Company                                                           l=.d
. Yankee Atomic Electric Company l=.d
                                                                                        .                                  .".2-l                 *::                    .. :
.".2-l E,
E,                                   ....
cc: Mr. Donald G. Allen, President 25E' Yankee: Atomic Electric Company
cc: Mr. Donald G. Allen, President
.=J 20 Turnpike Road '.
* 25E' Yankee: Atomic Electric Company                                                           .=J 20 Turnpike Road ' .                                                             EM
EM Westboro, Massachusetts 01581 Greenfield Public Library '
.                            Westboro, Massachusetts 01581                                                           -
~=
                                                                                                          ~=
'402' Main Street'
Greenfield Public Library '                                                                         -
~
                              '402' Main Street'
Greenfield, Massachusetts.' 01581.
                                                                                                                              ~
Greenfield, Massachusetts.' 01581.                                                           &
m:
m:
:::=
:::=
                                                                                                                    .l,fC.
.l,fC.
[$
[$
a.
a.
o
o
          . g
. g b
* b 8
8 p
p                                                                                             .,.
f ?.
f ?.
i :-
i :-
                                                            !                      ~~
~~
j.
j.
p .
p.
                                      ~
~
E.
E.
a 6 M g
a 6 M g
em t
em t
                                                                                                                                    .p
.p 5
                .                                        g                               5
g
                                                                      .r.-   ,      ,
.r.-
w-
w-


1
-.y
~.
~.
                                                                                                                      - .y.;
}
                                                                                                                                    }?
?
                                    '                                      '                                ~
Y"ANKEE ATOMIC' ELECTRIC COMPANY
Y"ANKEE ATOMIC' ELECTRIC COMPANY                                                       k" QA TOPICAL REPORT (Y00AP-1)
~
                                                                                        - --. . .          ,                      ;q 421.0                 QUALITY' ASSURANCE                                                                                 e.es Gl.9 (RSP) Appendices C, D, E which list the safety-related structures, (II)-     - - - systems, and components controlled by the QA program should                                                     ,
k QA TOPICAL REPORT (Y00AP-1)
be modified to include " fuel assemblies" and identified                                                   .
;q 421.0 QUALITY' ASSURANCE e.es Gl.9 (RSP)
expendable consumable items such as boric acid, welding
Appendices C, D, E which list the safety-related structures, (II)-
    -      ~
- - - systems, and components controlled by the QA program should be modified to include " fuel assemblies" and identified expendable consumable items such as boric acid, welding
                          . rod, and diesel fuel . In addition, on page 1 of Section II delete "The safety class designations of" in the last                               ~
. rod, and diesel fuel.
            ---            sentence under 2' scope. "     _        _
In addition, on page 1 of Section II
421.10 (RSP)         In Section'II, note "No. 5" on page 5 should be modified (II)                 to read as follows: "Programatic changes (except those that are editorial in nature) in the QA program as described herein shall require written NRC notification                                                     -
~
prior to implementation. Orgnizational changes which affect the QA program will be reported to the NRC within 30 days after announcement."                                                               .      g.ti .
delete "The safety class designations of" in the last
421.11 (RSP)         In Appendix B (Exceptions), item "C" on page 8 should bc (App. B)             modified to read as follows: "The Yankee Nuclear Services Division Radiation Protection Group shall at least include an individual that possesses a bachelor's degree or the equivalent in a science or engineering subject, including formal training in radiation protection and at least five years of professional experience in applied radiation protection. At-least three years of this professional experience should be in applied radiation protection work at an operating nuclear power plant."                                                         ,
~
sentence under 2' scope. "
421.10 (RSP)
In Section'II, note "No. 5" on page 5 should be modified (II) to read as follows:
"Programatic changes (except those that are editorial in nature) in the QA program as described herein shall require written NRC notification prior to implementation.
Orgnizational changes which affect the QA program will be reported to the NRC within 30 days after announcement."
g.ti.
421.11 (RSP)
In Appendix B (Exceptions), item "C" on page 8 should bc (App. B) modified to read as follows:
"The Yankee Nuclear Services Division Radiation Protection Group shall at least include an individual that possesses a bachelor's degree or the equivalent in a science or engineering subject, including formal training in radiation protection and at least five years of professional experience in applied radiation protection. At-least three years of this professional experience should be in applied radiation protection work at an operating nuclear power plant."
i t
i t
i.
i.
4                                                                   4the d         @w.     .g   .
4 4the d
@w.
.g
[
[
4 d
4 d
                                                                                                                                            !}}
.}}

Latest revision as of 11:45, 11 December 2024

Forwards NRC Positions Re Evaluation of Amend 1 to Util Topical Rept YOQAP-1, Operational QA Program. Requests That Util Responses to Positions Be Submitted as Amend to Original Rept by 770114
ML20148F716
Person / Time
Site: Vermont Yankee, Yankee Rowe, Maine Yankee
Issue date: 12/28/1976
From: Goller K
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To: Heider L
YANKEE ATOMIC ELECTRIC CO.
References
NUDOCS 8011060708
Download: ML20148F716 (5)


Text

m-2I U' DISTRIBUTION:

m G%.vDock'et Files (3)

"NRC PDR (3)

E Dockett Nos.:

50-29 W ~ "

L PDR (3)

JRBuchanan E

50-309 ORB #1:8 Rdg ACRS (16) p and.

50-271 VStello ORB #4 Rdg

!R KRGoller QA Rdg.

E=...

TJCarter NRR Rdg.

E-RReid Topical Rpt. File Yankee Atomic Electric Company VRooney (2)

JConway ATTN: Mr. L. H. Heider PDiBenedetto AGarland Assistant Vice President ABurger JHeltemes 20 Turnpike Road RIngram DSkovholt Westboro, Massachusetts 05181 Attorney, OELD

..=

OI&E(3)

ASchwencer

Dear Mr. Heider:

DEisenhut RReid s

RE:

EVALUATION OF AMENDMENT. TO QA TOPICAL REPORT We have evaluated Amendment No. I to Yankee Atomic Electric Company's Topical Report Y0QAP-1, " Operational Quality Assurance Program" sub-mitted with your December 9,1976, letter to detcrmine its confomance with Appendix B to 10 CFR 50.

The NRC staff's positions, which were discussed with members of your staff on December 17, 1976, relative to this topical report are j

enclosed. Your responses to the enclosure should be submitted as an amendment (50 copies to the attention of C. J. Heltemes, Jr.) to the original report by January 14, 1977.

]

y If you have any additional questions regarding this request, please contact John Gilray or James Conway on (301) 492-7741.

i.

'S f

g Sincerely, Q) k hAWWm> u n

u Karl R. Goller, Assistant Director i

V for Operating Reactors

["

i Division of Operating Reactors

Enclosure:

U Staff Positions I

in t

cc w/ enclosure: See next page THIS DOCUMENT CONTAlf6 POOR QUAUTY PAGES/

0 wi SVV C-0 f 46R C-0RB#

R AD-0R: DOR (mes

'kwencer RRe'i d':

K'R' Goll er (JWGil u

nway y

o A i t +-

1 y).

-........ -....2/[776-1 3/76 12/u /76 12/ 176

'12/J5/76

~IE75f/7f Irm MC 318 sf.ev,9 53) MCLI C240 W u. s. covC ANMENT PRINTIPeG OF F'tC tt 1974 526.199 80110co 709 f

c

~

5 Yankee Atomic' Electric' Company cc: Mr. ' James E. Griffin, President Brooks Memorial Library Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corporation 224 Main Street.

y 77 Grove Street Brattleboro, Vermont 05301

~

Rutl and,: Veront 05701 Mr. Donald' E. Vandenburgh, Vice President John R. Stanton, Director Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corporation Radiation Control Agency Turnpike Road, Route 9 Hazen Drive g

Westboro, Massachusetts. 01581 Concord, New Hampshire 03301 John A. Ritcher, Esquire John W. Stevens Ropes & Gray Conservation Society of 225 Franklin Street Southern Vermont Boston, Massachusetts 02110 P. O. Box 256

~

Townshend, Vermont 05353

~

Gregor I. McGregor, Esquire Assistant Attorney General

-Mr. David M. Scott Department of the Attorney General Radiation Health Engineer State House, Room 370 Agency of Human Services Boston, Massachusetts 02133 Division of Occupational Health P. O. Box 607 Richard E. Ayres, Esquire Barre, Vermont 05641 Natural Resources Defense Council 917 - 15th Street, H. W.

Raw England Coalition en Wa shir. ' ton, D. C.

20005 Huclear Pollution Hill and Dale Farm Honoreb e M. Jerome Diamond West Hill - Faraway Road Attorne. General Putney, Vermont 05345 State et Ve rmont 109 State Street Public Service Board 7

Pavilion Office Building

. State of Vermont Hontpelier, Vermont 05602 120 State Street Montpelier, Vermont 05502 John A. Calhoun Assistant Attorney General State of Vermont 109 State Street Pavilion Of fice Building lbntpelier, Vermont 05602 Anthony Z. Roisman, Esquire Berlin, Roisman and Kessler 102515th Street, N.u., 5th Floor Washington, D. C.

20005 O

e 6

l 1

e-3

Yankee Atomic Elect $ic Company cc:

E. W. Thurlow, President j

i Maine Yankee Atomic Power Company 9 Green Street.

-.. =

Augusta, Maine 04310 Mr. Donald E. Vandenburgh Vice President - Engineering Yankee Atomic. Electric Company 20 Turnpike Road Westboro,11assachusetts 01581

~ '

John A. Ritsher, Esquire

.,m.,,,.

Ropes & Gray

=

225 FrarMin Street Bostor, Ma'.sachusetts 02110

L*:*..,

Mr. Jsiin M. R. Paterson Ass!stant Attorney General State of Maine Augusta: Maine 04330 Harold P. Green, Esquire Suite 1000 Thh Watergate 600 New Hampshire Avenue, fl. W.

Washington, D. C.

20037

=.

~

Mr. Nicholas Barth Executive Director Sheepscot Valley Conservation Association, Inc.

P. O. Box 125

=

Alna, Maine 04535-

- l Wiseasset Public. Library Association High Street Wiscasset, Maine 04578

[

1 i

e ed S

3 j

s._

. Yankee Atomic Electric Company l=.d

.".2-l E,

cc: Mr. Donald G. Allen, President 25E' Yankee: Atomic Electric Company

.=J 20 Turnpike Road '.

EM Westboro, Massachusetts 01581 Greenfield Public Library '

~=

'402' Main Street'

~

Greenfield, Massachusetts.' 01581.

m:

=

.l,fC.

[$

a.

o

. g b

8 p

f ?.

i :-

~~

j.

p.

~

E.

a 6 M g

em t

.p 5

g

.r.-

w-

-.y

~.

}

?

Y"ANKEE ATOMIC' ELECTRIC COMPANY

~

k QA TOPICAL REPORT (Y00AP-1)

q 421.0 QUALITY' ASSURANCE e.es Gl.9 (RSP)

Appendices C, D, E which list the safety-related structures, (II)-

- - - systems, and components controlled by the QA program should be modified to include " fuel assemblies" and identified expendable consumable items such as boric acid, welding

. rod, and diesel fuel.

In addition, on page 1 of Section II

~

delete "The safety class designations of" in the last

~

sentence under 2' scope. "

421.10 (RSP)

In Section'II, note "No. 5" on page 5 should be modified (II) to read as follows:

"Programatic changes (except those that are editorial in nature) in the QA program as described herein shall require written NRC notification prior to implementation.

Orgnizational changes which affect the QA program will be reported to the NRC within 30 days after announcement."

g.ti.

421.11 (RSP)

In Appendix B (Exceptions), item "C" on page 8 should bc (App. B) modified to read as follows:

"The Yankee Nuclear Services Division Radiation Protection Group shall at least include an individual that possesses a bachelor's degree or the equivalent in a science or engineering subject, including formal training in radiation protection and at least five years of professional experience in applied radiation protection. At-least three years of this professional experience should be in applied radiation protection work at an operating nuclear power plant."

i t

i.

4 4the d

@w.

.g

[

4 d

.