ML20238D954: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
VisualWikitext
StriderTol Bot insert
 
StriderTol Bot change
 
Line 19: Line 19:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:.-
{{#Wiki_filter:.-
*                                                         *
*
  e       ,
*
                                                      se 4 % a                             ,
e
      y
,
      ff          o
%
                    g
,
                    g
se 4
                                                UNITED STATES
a
                                    NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
ff
                    E                     WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555                       4
o
      74. g ;'r//                                                                          1
UNITED STATES
      %       ,, #                         September 8, 1987
g
Docket No. 50-286
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
          Power Authority of the State of New York
y
          ATTN: Mr. John C. Brons, Executive Vice President
g
                  Nuclear Generation
74. g ;'r//
          123 Main Street
4
          White Plains, New York 10601
E
                                                                                          1
WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555
                                                                                          1
1
          Gentlemen:
%
          SUBJECT:     SAFETY SYSTEM OUTAGE MODIFICATION INSPECTION (DESIGN) 50-286/87-013
,, #
          This letter conveys the results and conclusions of the design portion of the     I
September 8, 1987
          Safety System Outage Modification Inspection (SSOMI) of the Indian Point Unit 3 i
Docket No. 50-286
          power station conducted by the NRC's Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation. The   l
Power Authority of the State of New York
          inspection team was composed of NRC personnel and consultants. The inspection   l
ATTN: Mr. John C. Brons, Executive Vice President
          took place at the Indian Point Unit 3 station and your offices in White Plains, l
Nuclear Generation
          New York. It was conducted April 22-23, May 11-15, May 26-29, and July 12-14,
123 Main Street
          1987.
White Plains, New York 10601
          The purpose of the design portion of the SSOMI was to examine, on a sampling
1
          basis, the detailed design and engineering which was required to support
1
          modifications implemented during the outage. At the conclusion of other
Gentlemen:
          portions of the inspection, the NRC will provide a report summarizing these
SUBJECT:
          efforts.
SAFETY SYSTEM OUTAGE MODIFICATION INSPECTION (DESIGN) 50-286/87-013
          The design inspection team noted significant areas of weakness in the design
This letter conveys the results and conclusions of the design portion of the
          and design verification process associated with the replacement of the service
I
          water pumps. The team also found two instances where PASNY was using relaxed
Safety System Outage Modification Inspection (SSOMI) of the Indian Point Unit 3
          design criteria from that specified in their FSAR and NRC Bulletin responses
i
          without obtaining prior staff approval and examples where the FSAR and techni-
power station conducted by the NRC's Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation. The
          cal specification bases had not been updated to reflect changes made during a
l
          previous outage. Weaknesses were also noted in the areas of design change
inspection team was composed of NRC personnel and consultants. The inspection
          control, the performance of safety evaluations in accordance with 10 CFR 50.59,
l
          control of FSAR information and the ability to retrieve design basis infonna-
took place at the Indian Point Unit 3 station and your offices in White Plains,
          tion, as noted during the team's review of the 25 kVA inverter installation.
l
          Based on the findings of this inspection, PASNY management should take action
New York. It was conducted April 22-23, May 11-15, May 26-29, and July 12-14,
          to ensure that (I) adequate controls are in place to maintain plant configura-
1987.
            tion; (2) the plant licensing basis is updated to reflect design changes as
The purpose of the design portion of the SSOMI was to examine, on a sampling
            required by 10 CFR SC.71(e); and (3) the engineering staff and design agents
basis, the detailed design and engineering which was required to support
          are aware of the plant's licensing bases. It is important that during any
modifications implemented during the outage. At the conclusion of other
          modification the licensee examine carefully the original design and licensing
portions of the inspection, the NRC will provide a report summarizing these
            bases to assess all the design considerations that are affected by the change.
efforts.
                                      _.
The design inspection team noted significant areas of weakness in the design
    .
and design verification process associated with the replacement of the service
            (7 cM d/34,
water pumps. The team also found two instances where PASNY was using relaxed
design criteria from that specified in their FSAR and NRC Bulletin responses
without obtaining prior staff approval and examples where the FSAR and techni-
cal specification bases had not been updated to reflect changes made during a
previous outage. Weaknesses were also noted in the areas of design change
control, the performance of safety evaluations in accordance with 10 CFR 50.59,
control of FSAR information and the ability to retrieve design basis infonna-
tion, as noted during the team's review of the 25 kVA inverter installation.
Based on the findings of this inspection, PASNY management should take action
to ensure that (I) adequate controls are in place to maintain plant configura-
tion; (2) the plant licensing basis is updated to reflect design changes as
required by 10 CFR SC.71(e); and (3) the engineering staff and design agents
are aware of the plant's licensing bases.
It is important that during any
modification the licensee examine carefully the original design and licensing
bases to assess all the design considerations that are affected by the change.
_.
(7 cM d/34,
.


                                                                              _____.   . _ _ - _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -
l
l                            e
_____.
          .
. _ _ - _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -
                        ,
.
    -d'
e
        ,
,
      J
-d'
                    Power Authority of the State             -2- .                   September 8, 1987
,
                        of New York-
J
                    During the inspection, a newly initiated program to reestablish the design -
Power Authority of the State
                    basis of the plant was explained to the inspection team. This effort indicates
-2- .
                    your awarenessiof this weakness and that some positive steps to achieve con-
September 8, 1987
                      figuration' control. are being taken. Clearly, more work is needed in.this area.
of New York-
                    Because of the team's significant findings related to your service water pump
During the inspection, a newly initiated program to reestablish the design -
                      replacement design, you decided to defer installation of the new replacement
basis of the plant was explained to the inspection team.
                    pumps.- These findings indicate serious shortcomings. in your vendor interface
This effort indicates
                                                                            -
your awarenessiof this weakness and that some positive steps to achieve con-
    ,              <and design. verification programs. Accordingly, I request that you respond to
figuration' control. are being taken.
      .              the findings of this report within 60 days including a description of.the
Clearly, more work is needed in.this area.
                    actions you'have taken or plan to take to strengthen your control' of design
Because of the team's significant findings related to your service water pump
                      interface and design verification activities. . Also, please include-in your
replacement design, you decided to defer installation of the new replacement
                    response a description of your self-initiated program to reestablish the
pumps.- These findings indicate serious shortcomings. in your vendor interface
                    plant's-design basis.
-
                      In contrast to these weaknesses, the team observed that many things had been
<and design. verification programs. Accordingly, I request that you respond to
                    - done. correctly and that you have taken an active role-in identifying problems
,
                    and correcting them in a timely manner. The proposed replacement of the
the findings of this report within 60 days including a description of.the
                    service water pumps,' for example, was ' initiated to improve system reliability
.
                    as a result of a poor maintenance history for the original pumps. Also, the
actions you'have taken or plan to take to strengthen your control' of design
                      flow model testing and improvements made:to the service water system intake
interface and design verification activities. . Also, please include-in your
                    bays.should further enhance pump performance and system reliability.
response a description of your self-initiated program to reestablish the
                    During the inspection, the team found that Indian Point 3 does not meet.its
plant's-design basis.
                      FSAR commitment in the area of moderate energy line break. The FSAR states
In contrast to these weaknesses, the team observed that many things had been
                    that the plant can mitigate the consequences of a LOCA with a simultaneous
- done. correctly and that you have taken an active role-in identifying problems
                    guillotine failure of a moderate energy line. However, the team found one
and correcting them in a timely manner. The proposed replacement of the
                          _
service water pumps,' for example, was ' initiated to improve system reliability
                    . example where this comitment was not met. This- FSAR comitment is more
as a result of a poor maintenance history for the original pumps. Also, the
                    conservative than the guidelines set forth in Standard Review Plan 3.6.1 for
flow model testing and improvements made:to the service water system intake
                    moderate energy line cracks, and we call this to your attention so that it can
bays.should further enhance pump performance and system reliability.
                    be resolved as promptly as possible.                                                                   *
During the inspection, the team found that Indian Point 3 does not meet.its
                  '
FSAR commitment in the area of moderate energy line break. The FSAR states
                      Some of the items identified by the team may be potential enforcement
that the plant can mitigate the consequences of a LOCA with a simultaneous
                      findings. Any enforcement actions will be identified by Region I.
guillotine failure of a moderate energy line. However, the team found one
                      In accordance with 10 CFR 2.790(a), a copy of this letter and the enclosure
_
                    will be placed in the NRC Public Document Room.
. example where this comitment was not met. This- FSAR comitment is more
                    Should you have any questions concerning this portion of the inspection,
conservative than the guidelines set forth in Standard Review Plan 3.6.1 for
                      please contact me or Mr. E. V. Imbro (301-492-9664) of this office.
moderate energy line cracks, and we call this to your attention so that it can
                                                      Sincerely,
be resolved as promptly as possible.
                                                          I
*
                                                          _
Some of the items identified by the team may be potential enforcement
                                                        even   . aNa,   b
'
                                                      Division of React r ojects-I,II
findings. Any enforcement actions will be identified by Region I.
                                                      Office of Nuclear   ctor Regulation
In accordance with 10 CFR 2.790(a), a copy of this letter and the enclosure
                ,
will be placed in the NRC Public Document Room.
                      Enclosure: . Inspection Report 50-286/87-013
Should you have any questions concerning this portion of the inspection,
                      cc w/ enclosure: See next page
please contact me or Mr. E. V. Imbro (301-492-9664) of this office.
Sincerely,
I
_
even
aNa,
b
.
Division of React r
ojects-I,II
Office of Nuclear
ctor Regulation
Enclosure: . Inspection Report 50-286/87-013
,
cc w/ enclosure: See next page
_ _ _ _ _ _ . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ . _


_ _ __
_ _ __
                                        ,             ,
,
        *                       ,.
,
            .   .
*
      4',
.
        a
.
      4          Power Authority of the State       -3-         September 8, 1987
,.
                    of New York
4',
                cc:
a
                Regional Administrator, Region I       Resident Inspector
Power Authority of the State
                U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission     Indian Point Nuclear Generating
-3-
                631 Park. Avenue                       U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
September 8, 1987
                King of Prussia, Pennsylvania 19406     P.O. Box 337
4
                                                        Buchanan, New York 10511
of New York
                Mr. Gerald C. Goldstein                 Mr. Robert L. Spring
cc:
                Assistant General Counsel               Nuclear Licensing Engineer
Regional Administrator, Region I
                Power Authority of the State           Consolidated Edison Company
Resident Inspector
                      of New York                         of-New York, Inc.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
                10 Columbus Circle                     4 Irving Place
Indian Point Nuclear Generating
                New York, New York 10019               New York, New York 10003
631 Park. Avenue
                Ms. Ellyn Weiss                         Mr. A. Klausmann, Vice President
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
                Harnen, Weiss and Jordan               Quality Assurance
King of Prussia, Pennsylvania 19406
                2001 S Street, NW, Suite 430           Power Authority of the State
P.O. Box 337
                Washington, DC 20009                     of New York
Buchanan, New York 10511
                                                        10 Columbus Circle
Mr. Gerald C. Goldstein
                                                        New York, New York 10019
Mr. Robert L. Spring
                Mr. George M. Wilverding Henager       N6yor, Village of Buchanan
Assistant General Counsel
                Nuclear Safety Evaluation               236 Tate Avenue
Nuclear Licensing Engineer
                Power Authority of the State           Buchanan, New York 10511.
Power Authority of the State
                      of New York
Consolidated Edison Company
                123 Main Street                         Mr. F. X. Pindar
of New York
                White Plains, New York 10601           Quality Assurance Superintendent
of-New York, Inc.
                    -
10 Columbus Circle
                                                        Indian Point 3 Nuclear Power Plant
4 Irving Place
  -
New York, New York 10019
                Director Technical Development         P. O. Box 215
New York, New York 10003
                      Programs                           Buchanan, New York 10511
Ms. Ellyn Weiss
                State of New York Energy Office
Mr. A. Klausmann, Vice President
                Agency Building 2                       Mr. R. Beedle, Vice President
Harnen, Weiss and Jordan
                Empire State Plaza                     Nuclear Support
Quality Assurance
                Albany, New York 12223                 Power Authority of the State
2001 S Street, NW, Suite 430
                                                            of New York
Power Authority of the State
    -
Washington, DC 20009
                Mr. Leroy W. Sinclair                   123 Main Street
of New York
                Power Authority of the State           White Plains, New York   10601
10 Columbus Circle
                      of New York
New York, New York 10019
                  123 Main Street                       Mr. William Josiger
Mr. George M. Wilverding Henager
                White Plains, New York 10601           Resident Manager
N6yor, Village of Buchanan
          -
Nuclear Safety Evaluation
                                                        Indian Point 3 Nuclear Power Plant
236 Tate Avenue
                Ezra I. Bialik                         P. O. Box 215
Power Authority of the State
                Assistant Attorney General             Buchanan, New York, 10511
Buchanan, New York 10511.
                Environmental Protection Bureau
of New York
,                flew York State Department of Law       Dr. Lawrence R. Quarles
123 Main Street
l                 1 World Trade Center                   Apartment 5
Mr. F. X. Pindar
                  New York, New York 10047               Kendal at Longwood
White Plains, New York 10601
                                                        Kennett, Pennsylvania 19348
Quality Assurance Superintendent
                                                                                            {
Indian Point 3 Nuclear Power Plant
              -
-
-
Director Technical Development
P. O. Box 215
Programs
Buchanan, New York 10511
State of New York Energy Office
Agency Building 2
Mr. R. Beedle, Vice President
Empire State Plaza
Nuclear Support
Albany, New York 12223
Power Authority of the State
of New York
Mr. Leroy W. Sinclair
123 Main Street
-
Power Authority of the State
White Plains, New York
10601
of New York
123 Main Street
Mr. William Josiger
White Plains, New York 10601
Resident Manager
Indian Point 3 Nuclear Power Plant
-
Ezra I. Bialik
P. O. Box 215
Assistant Attorney General
Buchanan, New York, 10511
Environmental Protection Bureau
flew York State Department of Law
Dr. Lawrence R. Quarles
,
l
1 World Trade Center
Apartment 5
New York, New York 10047
Kendal at Longwood
Kennett, Pennsylvania 19348
{
-


  - -,--- _             _
- -,--- _
                                                                                  '
_
            .
'
      ....'
. . . . '
                    .
.
          .
.
      .-
.
              . Power Authority of the State     -4-           September 8, 1987
.-
                    of New York
. Power Authority of the State
                                              <
-4-
September 8, 1987
of New York
<
!
!
                  cc: ' Contd.
cc: ' Contd.
L                 P. Kokolakis,' Director             Mr. Jay Dunkleberger
L
                  Nuclear Licensing                   Division of Policy Analysis
P. Kokolakis,' Director
;                 Power Authority of the State         and Planning               l
Mr. Jay Dunkleberger
Nuclear Licensing
Division of Policy Analysis
;
Power Authority of the State
and Planning
l
1
of New York
New York State Energy Office
'
'
                    of New York                      New York State Energy Office 1
123 Main Street
                  123 Main Street                     Agency Building 2 Empire
Agency Building 2 Empire
l                 White' Plains, New York 10601         State Plaza
l
                                                      Albany, New York 12223
White' Plains, New York 10601
                  Mr. S. S. Zulla, Vice President     Mr. R. Burns, Vice President
State Plaza
                  Nuclear Engineering                 Nuclear Operations
Albany, New York 12223
                  Power Authority of the State       Power Authority of the State
Mr. S. S. Zulla, Vice President
                    of New York                       of New York
Mr. R. Burns, Vice President
                  123 Main Street                     123 Main Street
Nuclear Engineering
                  White Plains, New York 10601       White Plains, New York 10601
Nuclear Operations
                    _
Power Authority of the State
                                                                                  i
Power Authority of the State
            *
of New York
                      - _ - _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _
of New York
123 Main Street
123 Main Street
White Plains, New York 10601
White Plains, New York 10601
_
i
*
- _ - _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _


                                                                                _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
      -
-
        ,                                       .
,
    .
.
      .
.
    .-
.
                                      Power Authority of the State                                                                     -5-           September 8, 1987
.-
                                                    of New York
Power Authority of the State
                                      Distribution:
-5-
                                      Docket File
September 8, 1987
                                      DRIS R/F
of New York
                                      RSIB R/F
Distribution:
                                    HWang, NRR                                                                                                                                                 E
Docket File
                                      Elmbro, NRR
DRIS R/F
                                      RStarostecki, NRR
RSIB R/F
l                               'CHaughney, NRR
HWang, NRR
                                      BGrimes, NRR
E
                                    JPartlow, NRR
Elmbro, NRR
                                      JKonklin, NRR
RStarostecki, NRR
                                      LNorrholm, NRR
l
                                      BBoger, NRR
'CHaughney, NRR
                                      DNeighbors, HRR
BGrimes, NRR
                                      JDurr, RI
JPartlow, NRR
                                    WJohnston, RI
JKonklin, NRR
                                      RCapra, NRR
LNorrholm, NRR
                                    MSlosson, NRR
BBoger, NRR
                                      RGallo, RI
DNeighbors, HRR
                                    JJohnson, RI
JDurr, RI
                                      PKoltay, SRI IP-3
WJohnston, RI
                                      BClayton, EDO
RCapra, NRR
                                      PBarkley, RI IP-3
MSlosson, NRR
                                    WKane, RI
RGallo, RI
                                      SCollins, RI
JJohnson, RI
                                    SVarga, NRR
PKoltay, SRI IP-3
                                      LPDR
BClayton, EDO
                                      NRC PDR
PBarkley, RI IP-3
)FC :RSIB:DRIS:
WKane, RI
                              Oh                                                                          Sb W
SCollins, RI
                                                                                                        : SIB:DRIS:NRR : B
SVarga, NRR
                                                                                                                            r                A$
LPDR
                                                                                                                                  :NRR:DD: IS:       :DI
NRC PDR
                                                                                                                                                              //
Oh
                                                                                                                                                                  RR:         R I II-
Sb W
.....:........__..__:.......___.                                                                                       ..
A$
                                                                                                                              f{{___.:...     .. ._:S  .   _f_...,
//
                                                                                                                                                                  :        .   __...:...__...
r
MME :HWang/vj                                                                                         :EImbro                 ney   :B   .e     ,
f{{___.:...
                                                                                                                                                                -
_f_ :
                                                                                                                                                                      : ar         :
:NRR:DD: IS:
.....:............ _:... __ .....                                                                                         ...........:......___.. :. ........._: __ ...... :.....___
:DI
) ATE :08/Jo /87                                                                                       :08/78/87         8/V/87       :087Z587   !
RR:
                                                                                                                                                      :08/t[/87       :@/ /87       :
R I II-
                                                                                                                                                                        (p)
)FC :RSIB:DRIS:
                                                                                                                      '                                     '
: SIB:DRIS:NRR : B
          -
.. ._:S
                                                                                                                                            y%d
__...:...__...
            _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _                                                     _
.....:........__..__:.......___.
..
.
...,
.
MME :HWang/vj
:EImbro
ney
:B
.e
-
:
ar
:
,
.....:............ _:... __ .....
...........:......___.. :. ........._: __ ...... :.....___
) ATE :08/Jo /87
:08/78/87
8/V/87
:087Z587
! :08/t[/87
:@/ /87
:
-
y%d
(p)
'
'
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_
}}
}}

Latest revision as of 05:36, 2 December 2024

Forwards Safety Sys Outage Mod Insp Rept 50-286/87-13 on 870422-0714.Weaknesses Noted in Areas of Design & Design Verification Process Associated W/Replacement of Svc Water Pumps.Action Mgt Should Take Listed
ML20238D954
Person / Time
Site: Indian Point 
Issue date: 09/08/1987
From: Varga S
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To: Brons J
POWER AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK (NEW YORK
Shared Package
ML100271221 List:
References
NUDOCS 8709140015
Download: ML20238D954 (5)
v • d • e


See also: IR 05000286/1987013

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:.-

e , % , se 4 a ff o UNITED STATES g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION y g 74. g ;'r// 4 E WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 1 % ,, # September 8, 1987 Docket No. 50-286 Power Authority of the State of New York ATTN: Mr. John C. Brons, Executive Vice President Nuclear Generation 123 Main Street White Plains, New York 10601 1 1 Gentlemen: SUBJECT: SAFETY SYSTEM OUTAGE MODIFICATION INSPECTION (DESIGN) 50-286/87-013 This letter conveys the results and conclusions of the design portion of the I Safety System Outage Modification Inspection (SSOMI) of the Indian Point Unit 3 i power station conducted by the NRC's Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation. The l inspection team was composed of NRC personnel and consultants. The inspection l took place at the Indian Point Unit 3 station and your offices in White Plains, l New York. It was conducted April 22-23, May 11-15, May 26-29, and July 12-14, 1987. The purpose of the design portion of the SSOMI was to examine, on a sampling basis, the detailed design and engineering which was required to support modifications implemented during the outage. At the conclusion of other portions of the inspection, the NRC will provide a report summarizing these efforts. The design inspection team noted significant areas of weakness in the design and design verification process associated with the replacement of the service water pumps. The team also found two instances where PASNY was using relaxed design criteria from that specified in their FSAR and NRC Bulletin responses without obtaining prior staff approval and examples where the FSAR and techni- cal specification bases had not been updated to reflect changes made during a previous outage. Weaknesses were also noted in the areas of design change control, the performance of safety evaluations in accordance with 10 CFR 50.59, control of FSAR information and the ability to retrieve design basis infonna- tion, as noted during the team's review of the 25 kVA inverter installation. Based on the findings of this inspection, PASNY management should take action to ensure that (I) adequate controls are in place to maintain plant configura- tion; (2) the plant licensing basis is updated to reflect design changes as required by 10 CFR SC.71(e); and (3) the engineering staff and design agents are aware of the plant's licensing bases. It is important that during any modification the licensee examine carefully the original design and licensing bases to assess all the design considerations that are affected by the change. _. (7 cM d/34, .

l _____. . _ _ - _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - . e , -d' , J Power Authority of the State -2- . September 8, 1987 of New York- During the inspection, a newly initiated program to reestablish the design - basis of the plant was explained to the inspection team. This effort indicates your awarenessiof this weakness and that some positive steps to achieve con- figuration' control. are being taken. Clearly, more work is needed in.this area. Because of the team's significant findings related to your service water pump replacement design, you decided to defer installation of the new replacement pumps.- These findings indicate serious shortcomings. in your vendor interface - <and design. verification programs. Accordingly, I request that you respond to , the findings of this report within 60 days including a description of.the . actions you'have taken or plan to take to strengthen your control' of design interface and design verification activities. . Also, please include-in your response a description of your self-initiated program to reestablish the plant's-design basis. In contrast to these weaknesses, the team observed that many things had been - done. correctly and that you have taken an active role-in identifying problems and correcting them in a timely manner. The proposed replacement of the service water pumps,' for example, was ' initiated to improve system reliability as a result of a poor maintenance history for the original pumps. Also, the flow model testing and improvements made:to the service water system intake bays.should further enhance pump performance and system reliability. During the inspection, the team found that Indian Point 3 does not meet.its FSAR commitment in the area of moderate energy line break. The FSAR states that the plant can mitigate the consequences of a LOCA with a simultaneous guillotine failure of a moderate energy line. However, the team found one _ . example where this comitment was not met. This- FSAR comitment is more conservative than the guidelines set forth in Standard Review Plan 3.6.1 for moderate energy line cracks, and we call this to your attention so that it can be resolved as promptly as possible.

Some of the items identified by the team may be potential enforcement ' findings. Any enforcement actions will be identified by Region I. In accordance with 10 CFR 2.790(a), a copy of this letter and the enclosure will be placed in the NRC Public Document Room. Should you have any questions concerning this portion of the inspection, please contact me or Mr. E. V. Imbro (301-492-9664) of this office. Sincerely, I _ even aNa, b . Division of React r ojects-I,II Office of Nuclear ctor Regulation Enclosure: . Inspection Report 50-286/87-013 , cc w/ enclosure: See next page _ _ _ _ _ _ . _

_ _ __ , ,

. . ,. 4', a Power Authority of the State -3- September 8, 1987 4 of New York cc: Regional Administrator, Region I Resident Inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Indian Point Nuclear Generating 631 Park. Avenue U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission King of Prussia, Pennsylvania 19406 P.O. Box 337 Buchanan, New York 10511 Mr. Gerald C. Goldstein Mr. Robert L. Spring Assistant General Counsel Nuclear Licensing Engineer Power Authority of the State Consolidated Edison Company of New York of-New York, Inc. 10 Columbus Circle 4 Irving Place New York, New York 10019 New York, New York 10003 Ms. Ellyn Weiss Mr. A. Klausmann, Vice President Harnen, Weiss and Jordan Quality Assurance 2001 S Street, NW, Suite 430 Power Authority of the State Washington, DC 20009 of New York 10 Columbus Circle New York, New York 10019 Mr. George M. Wilverding Henager N6yor, Village of Buchanan Nuclear Safety Evaluation 236 Tate Avenue Power Authority of the State Buchanan, New York 10511. of New York 123 Main Street Mr. F. X. Pindar White Plains, New York 10601 Quality Assurance Superintendent Indian Point 3 Nuclear Power Plant - - Director Technical Development P. O. Box 215 Programs Buchanan, New York 10511 State of New York Energy Office Agency Building 2 Mr. R. Beedle, Vice President Empire State Plaza Nuclear Support Albany, New York 12223 Power Authority of the State of New York Mr. Leroy W. Sinclair 123 Main Street - Power Authority of the State White Plains, New York 10601 of New York 123 Main Street Mr. William Josiger White Plains, New York 10601 Resident Manager Indian Point 3 Nuclear Power Plant - Ezra I. Bialik P. O. Box 215 Assistant Attorney General Buchanan, New York, 10511 Environmental Protection Bureau flew York State Department of Law Dr. Lawrence R. Quarles , l 1 World Trade Center Apartment 5 New York, New York 10047 Kendal at Longwood Kennett, Pennsylvania 19348 { -

- -,--- _ _ ' . . . . ' . . . .- . Power Authority of the State -4- September 8, 1987 of New York < ! cc: ' Contd. L P. Kokolakis,' Director Mr. Jay Dunkleberger Nuclear Licensing Division of Policy Analysis

Power Authority of the State and Planning l 1 of New York New York State Energy Office ' 123 Main Street Agency Building 2 Empire l White' Plains, New York 10601 State Plaza Albany, New York 12223 Mr. S. S. Zulla, Vice President Mr. R. Burns, Vice President Nuclear Engineering Nuclear Operations Power Authority of the State Power Authority of the State of New York of New York 123 Main Street 123 Main Street White Plains, New York 10601 White Plains, New York 10601 _ i

- _ - _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _

_ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - , . . . .- Power Authority of the State -5- September 8, 1987 of New York Distribution: Docket File DRIS R/F RSIB R/F HWang, NRR E Elmbro, NRR RStarostecki, NRR l 'CHaughney, NRR BGrimes, NRR JPartlow, NRR JKonklin, NRR LNorrholm, NRR BBoger, NRR DNeighbors, HRR JDurr, RI WJohnston, RI RCapra, NRR MSlosson, NRR RGallo, RI JJohnson, RI PKoltay, SRI IP-3 BClayton, EDO PBarkley, RI IP-3 WKane, RI SCollins, RI SVarga, NRR LPDR NRC PDR Oh Sb W A$ // r f{{___.:... _f_ :

NRR:DD: IS:
DI

RR: R I II- )FC :RSIB:DRIS:

SIB:DRIS:NRR : B

.. ._:S __...:...__... .....:........__..__:.......___. .. . ..., . MME :HWang/vj

EImbro

ney

B

.e -

ar

, .....:............ _:... __ ..... ...........:......___.. :. ........._: __ ...... :.....___ ) ATE :08/Jo /87

08/78/87

8/V/87

087Z587

! :08/t[/87

@/ /87

- y%d (p) ' ' _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ }}

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20238D954&oldid=3918370"