ML19331D727: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Created page by program invented by StriderTol
 
StriderTol Bot change
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
| number = ML19331D727
| number = ML19331D727
| issue date = 08/26/1980
| issue date = 08/26/1980
| title = Requests Permission to Suppl Wi Environ Decade Previous Filings Supporting Adjudicatory Hearing Re Petitioner Preliminary Contentions.Nrc 800808 Ltr Authorizes Facility Restart W/O Offer for Adjudicatory Hearing
| title = Requests Permission to Suppl Wi Environ Decade Previous Filings Supporting Adjudicatory Hearing Re Petitioner Preliminary Contentions.Nrc Authorizes Facility Restart W/O Offer for Adjudicatory Hearing
| author name = Falk K
| author name = Falk K
| author affiliation = WISCONSIN'S ENVIRONMENTAL DECADE
| author affiliation = WISCONSIN'S ENVIRONMENTAL DECADE
Line 11: Line 11:
| contact person =  
| contact person =  
| document report number = NUDOCS 8009030498
| document report number = NUDOCS 8009030498
| title reference date = 08-08-1980
| package number = ML19331D728
| package number = ML19331D728
| document type = CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS, INCOMING CORRESPONDENCE, PUBLIC ENTITY/CITIZEN/ORGANIZATION/MEDIA TO NRC
| document type = CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS, INCOMING CORRESPONDENCE, PUBLIC ENTITY/CITIZEN/ORGANIZATION/MEDIA TO NRC
Line 17: Line 18:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:-~
{{#Wiki_filter:-
  -                                                                                                                                                                                                     -
-~
                                                                                                                                        -
c
                                                                                                                                                      ,
., * -. _./,I, A f gJ
          .-
,c..
      .
~
                -
.a ll,; Q '
                                              .
? ~'
      .                                                                  .
I? e STAFF BOARD CF CSECTCRS V,-ance C.p;cse w w.
c                                                         . -                  .
Prof. John Neess. 04cr.t tw./04 r,~ e.ncesen wee Lsse
                                                                                                                                                                                          ,
,1 g 41
                                                              - '                                *
-g Petar Anderson. uc mos to cn
                                                                ;
: 4. 9 Do"xo' -
                                                                                      ,' ,
C' c r *
                                                                                                      *
: res, t caces W Esa
                                                                                                        . , * - . _ ./ ,I , A f                                                                   gJ
?,%
                                                                  <              ;                  .. ..                      ,c ..
Kc'hieen Fo*. Esq.,"siw. cc M.
                                                                                                                                      ~
. ;. y! '.
                                                                                                                                                                                                    .a
~
                                                                                                      ,,'
,v;e eec.e<
                                                                                                          '
ll ,; Q '                                                             ? ~'
BOARD CF CSECTCRS                        .-
                                                                        '
                                                                                    ' ,          *-                        " " ' -                                                              I? e                           STAFF V ,-ance C.p;cse w w.
                                                                                '
                                                                                        -
                                                                                                        ' ' - ,'                                                                                                      Prof. John Neess. 04cr.t tw./04 r,~ e.ncesen         wee Lsse
                                                              "
                                                                ,
                                                                  ,1             g 41                                                                                                           -g                   Petar Anderson. uc mos to cn
                  ,v;e eec.e<                                                                                                                                                                    4. 9                 Do"xo' -                   C'
:e ;c n Neess
:e ;c n Neess
              > .ruascre crc Mcro desret                       . <?; . y!v' '.
<?
                                                                    ,
v'
                                                                                                                        ~
>.ruascre crc Mcro desret
                                                                                                                                          .
. e-mer en Nancy Sc ce u.L-
                                                                                                                                                                      ? ,%
.I T j, - RP
                                                                                                                                                                                          ,
.. X w,7% ? g c
                                                                                                                                                                                                    -                 Kc'hieen Fo*. Esq.,"siw. cc M.
-+.-n.ac:e5
cr*    res,      t caces W Esa                      . .
%rcs von Ahea
                                                                                                            -
.. w
                                                                                                                                '
.3~
u.L-                                   .I Nancy Sc ce
'c,-
            . e-  mer en
2 agerrces vc rc Ac+sen
            -+.-n .ac:e5         %rcs von Ahea
? '
                                                                  ;- ' ,'    '
/-
                                                                                          -                                                                      T j, - RP                .. w
c,-
            'c,- 2 agerrces vc rc Ac+sen                                 -                                   -
4? T4 oo. r rc:,av nne t.erce g
                                                                                                                                    .3~ . . X w,7% ? g c      ;
,, ceres we
oo. r rc:,av
~ f. 4,.;v
                          ,, ceres we nne t.erce g                     '
. i
                                                                            -
,. p. f.4 302 East washdoton Avenue. MoosorfWaconen 53103 (006) 2SUO2O. '
                                                                                                        ? '
August 26, 1980 Mr. Herbert Grossman, Esq., Chairman Dr. Richard F. Cole, Member Dr. J. Vern Leeds! Member Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.
_          /- "              ~
C.
c,-              4? T4                                                                      .
20555 Re: Wisconsin Electric Power Company i
                                                                                                                                  - - .'. f. 4,.;v                                                 . i
Docket 50-266 (Point Beach Nuclear Plant Unit 1)
                                                                                                                                                ..
                                                                                    ,                ,
                                                                                                                                                                        , . p . f.4 302 East washdoton Avenue. MoosorfWaconen 53103
                                                                                              .
(006) 2SUO2O . '                                                       -
                            .
August                               26, 1980 Mr. Herbert Grossman, Esq. , Chairman Dr. Richard F. Cole, Member Dr. J. Vern Leeds! Member Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U. S . Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 Re: Wisconsin Electric Power Company                                                                                                           i Docket 50-266                                                                                                                   l (Point Beach Nuclear Plant Unit 1)
Gentl<: men :
Gentl<: men :
This is to request permission to supplement our previous filings in support of an ajudicatory hearing on the matters ennumerated in Petitioner's Preliminary Cententions based upon new information not previously in existence.
This is to request permission to supplement our previous filings in support of an ajudicatory hearing on the matters ennumerated in Petitioner's Preliminary Cententions based upon new information not previously in existence.
In accordance with the Staff's April 4,1980 Modification of November 30, 1979 Crder, in the above-referenced proceeding, Point Beach 1 was shut down for its 90 effective-full-power-day inspection of steam generator tubes on July 25, 1980. The April 4 Modification had required written approval from the Staff before the unit was permitted to return to service, as had the prior orders.
In accordance with the Staff's April 4,1980 Modification of November 30, 1979 Crder, in the above-referenced proceeding, Point Beach 1 was shut down for its 90 effective-full-power-day inspection of steam generator tubes on July 25, 1980. The April 4 Modification had required written approval from the Staff before the unit was permitted to return to service, as had the prior orders.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        .        .
'Ihe Staff 's !bvember 30, 1979, January 3,1980 and April 4, 1980 actions allowing restart had all been issued in the form of orders that, arong other things:
                              'Ihe Staff 's !bvember 30, 1979, January 3,1980 and April 4, 1980 actions allowing restart had all been issued in the form of orders that, arong other things:
(1) required written approval from. Staff before returning to service after the following inspection and (2) offered the right of an ajudicatory hearing on the action to an age -ieved party.
(1) required written approval from. Staff before returning to service after the following inspection and (2) offered the right of an ajudicatory hearing on the action to an age -ieved party.
However, the Staff's action following the July-August 1980 inspection outage at Point Beach 1 marked an abrupt departure from this past practice that, we believe is legally relevant to the question now before the Licensing Board.
However, the Staff's action following the July-August 1980 inspection outage at Point Beach 1 marked an abrupt departure from this past practice that, we believe is legally relevant to the question now before the Licensing Board.
For this time, instead of issuing an order similar to prior orders auth restart, requiring written approval before returning to service following the next inspection and offering the opportunity of an ajudicatory hearing, a letter dated                                                                                                                                                         /O August 8,1980 was issued authorizing restart (a copy of which is attached), alluding to some informal understanding between Staff and Licensee about a future inspection
For this time, instead of issuing an order similar to prior orders auth restart, requiring written approval before returning to service following the next inspection and offering the opportunity of an ajudicatory hearing, a letter dated
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    -
/O August 8,1980 was issued authorizing restart (a copy of which is attached), alluding to some informal understanding between Staff and Licensee about a future inspection BD.0.0 0 3 0 4 9 8
,
    --__ _                  BD.0.0 0 3 0 4 9 8                                           - -                                                --                          - - - . - .                      - - - - - - -              _ - - -        -  ---
                                  --            . _ , . - _                _-
                                                                                                . _ _ . . . . _ _ . _ . _ _ . _ _ . . _ . . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . . _ . _ . _ . _ - _ _ . , _                                                              . , , . . , . . . .


                                                                                                          -'
<7 7,
<7         .
t r.
7,
a
        -
\\
: r.     ,        ta
(y f.I s
                                                                                                                      \
NUCLEAR UNITED
                                    ,,,
%,,* yo '
    .
REGUL STATES 00cket No. 50-266 WA$MNGTON. DA COMM August
(y             f.I       '
.C.20555 8, 1980 Mr
                                        % ,,* yos'                         NUCLEAR
.Exe. Sol Burstein Wisconsin Electricutive Vice 231 West ent Milwaukee, Michigan Streetc Power Compan Wisconsin Dear Mr. Burstei 53201 n:
_
The NRC Unit No. staff has 1
UNITED REGUL STATES 00cket No. 50-266                                     WA$MNGTON.
Novemberdated Augus,t 5 steam ge reviewed the easons 30, 1979, 1980 results r
August      .C.20555 COMM DA 8, 1980 Mr
in of results stated in theOrder. accordances inspectio restriction acceptable attachedBased on the are with the Aprilwhich wa c
                                        .Exe. Sol Burstein Wisconsin ent 231 West                     Electricutive Vice Milwaukee, Michigan Streetc Power Compan Wisconsin 53201
Plant, Unit Noon the r s st.
 
S results 4, 1980 and, thus,afety Evaluation of esumption We 1
==Dear Mr. Burstei       n:==
it of is Orderwould like to operationnot necess port, w-and of remain in the January 3 emphasize that all the Point Bea effect in acco,rdance1980 Modification It is the 1980 our understanding that Utheir terms.the N with s to ns of for the Nos a
 
and e r fueling outage e
                        -          The NRC Unit No. staff1      has reviewed rNovemberdated Augus,t                                     5 steam ge the easons       30, 1979,   1980 in           results of resultsare    stated in theOrder. accordances       with          inspection    c restriction acceptable attachedBased         S the on  the Aprilwhich     s  wa st.
tubes,ddy curr nit 1 will be perform d.ent examination,s will provide the NRC and during that outbe that and schedule for, th e
Plant, Unit Noon the r                                   results of 4, 1980 We                      1            and, ofthus,afety esumption           it is       Evaluation port, w-Orderwould and           like to                      operationnot of         necess remain in         theinJanuary 3 emphasize that                     the all Point Bea It is          effect                                 the
of 100 percent of all within 15 Pursuant staff's servi review ese days to 10 age given to the un hydre of your CFR your proposed plsteam gen of 50.54 f)plu,gged modifying necessity of your program to ans t
      '
we requ issuing an Order.hedulee insp If and sr you hive questions establish additionalconfi Fo llow.
1980forour                  acco,rdance1980 Modificationc a                                with           s to ns of and e         understanding e                          that U                              the Nos will r fueling outageand tubes,ddy curr nitthat  their 1 will         terms.the N provide thebe      NRC perform           d.ent of        examination,s and schedulewithin staff's e
any y
for, 15 th Pursuant          during thatalloutbe 100 percent ofage                  servi days         to 10 given to review the       of ese                  of   your     CFR         un          hydre modifying                                                          50.54 f)plu,gged If your proposed necessity of your program to                     ans           plsteamwegen t           requ you hive any                  issuing       anand    sr Order     .hedulee insp Fo llow.
m on this subject, pleaserequire your Sincerely, contact us.
questions establish additionalconfi            m your y
w
on this subject, pleaserequire Sincerely,       contact us.


==Enclosure:==
==Enclosure:==
 
Safety Evaluatio Edson G Office. Case, Acting Dir n
Safety Evaluatio cc w Seenext
of cc w next page Nuclear Reac See /enclosurc:
                    /enclosurc:
ector egula
page n
                                                                            -
Edson G w
Officeof. Case, Acting Dir Nuclear Reac           ector egula
__}}
__}}

Latest revision as of 04:40, 31 December 2024

Requests Permission to Suppl Wi Environ Decade Previous Filings Supporting Adjudicatory Hearing Re Petitioner Preliminary Contentions.Nrc Authorizes Facility Restart W/O Offer for Adjudicatory Hearing
ML19331D727
Person / Time
Site: Point Beach 
Issue date: 08/26/1980
From: Falk K
WISCONSIN'S ENVIRONMENTAL DECADE
To: Cole R, Grossman H, Leeds J
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML19331D728 List:
References
NUDOCS 8009030498
Download: ML19331D727 (2)


Text

-

-~

c

., * -. _./,I, A f gJ

,c..

~

.a ll,; Q '

? ~'

I? e STAFF BOARD CF CSECTCRS V,-ance C.p;cse w w.

Prof. John Neess. 04cr.t tw./04 r,~ e.ncesen wee Lsse

,1 g 41

-g Petar Anderson. uc mos to cn

4. 9 Do"xo' -

C' c r *

res, t caces W Esa

?,%

Kc'hieen Fo*. Esq.,"siw. cc M.

. ;. y! '.

~

,v;e eec.e<

e ;c n Neess

<?

v'

>.ruascre crc Mcro desret

. e-mer en Nancy Sc ce u.L-

.I T j, - RP

.. X w,7% ? g c

-+.-n.ac:e5

%rcs von Ahea

.. w

.3~

'c,-

2 agerrces vc rc Ac+sen

? '

/-

c,-

4? T4 oo. r rc:,av nne t.erce g

,, ceres we

~ f. 4,.;v

. i

,. p. f.4 302 East washdoton Avenue. MoosorfWaconen 53103 (006) 2SUO2O. '

August 26, 1980 Mr. Herbert Grossman, Esq., Chairman Dr. Richard F. Cole, Member Dr. J. Vern Leeds! Member Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.

C.

20555 Re: Wisconsin Electric Power Company i

Docket 50-266 (Point Beach Nuclear Plant Unit 1)

Gentl<: men :

This is to request permission to supplement our previous filings in support of an ajudicatory hearing on the matters ennumerated in Petitioner's Preliminary Cententions based upon new information not previously in existence.

In accordance with the Staff's April 4,1980 Modification of November 30, 1979 Crder, in the above-referenced proceeding, Point Beach 1 was shut down for its 90 effective-full-power-day inspection of steam generator tubes on July 25, 1980. The April 4 Modification had required written approval from the Staff before the unit was permitted to return to service, as had the prior orders.

'Ihe Staff 's !bvember 30, 1979, January 3,1980 and April 4, 1980 actions allowing restart had all been issued in the form of orders that, arong other things:

(1) required written approval from. Staff before returning to service after the following inspection and (2) offered the right of an ajudicatory hearing on the action to an age -ieved party.

However, the Staff's action following the July-August 1980 inspection outage at Point Beach 1 marked an abrupt departure from this past practice that, we believe is legally relevant to the question now before the Licensing Board.

For this time, instead of issuing an order similar to prior orders auth restart, requiring written approval before returning to service following the next inspection and offering the opportunity of an ajudicatory hearing, a letter dated

/O August 8,1980 was issued authorizing restart (a copy of which is attached), alluding to some informal understanding between Staff and Licensee about a future inspection BD.0.0 0 3 0 4 9 8

<7 7,

t r.

a

\\

(y f.I s

NUCLEAR UNITED

%,,* yo '

REGUL STATES 00cket No. 50-266 WA$MNGTON. DA COMM August

.C.20555 8, 1980 Mr

.Exe. Sol Burstein Wisconsin Electricutive Vice 231 West ent Milwaukee, Michigan Streetc Power Compan Wisconsin Dear Mr. Burstei 53201 n:

The NRC Unit No. staff has 1

Novemberdated Augus,t 5 steam ge reviewed the easons 30, 1979, 1980 results r

in of results stated in theOrder. accordances inspectio restriction acceptable attachedBased on the are with the Aprilwhich wa c

Plant, Unit Noon the r s st.

S results 4, 1980 and, thus,afety Evaluation of esumption We 1

it of is Orderwould like to operationnot necess port, w-and of remain in the January 3 emphasize that all the Point Bea effect in acco,rdance1980 Modification It is the 1980 our understanding that Utheir terms.the N with s to ns of for the Nos a

and e r fueling outage e

tubes,ddy curr nit 1 will be perform d.ent examination,s will provide the NRC and during that outbe that and schedule for, th e

of 100 percent of all within 15 Pursuant staff's servi review ese days to 10 age given to the un hydre of your CFR your proposed plsteam gen of 50.54 f)plu,gged modifying necessity of your program to ans t

we requ issuing an Order.hedulee insp If and sr you hive questions establish additionalconfi Fo llow.

any y

m on this subject, pleaserequire your Sincerely, contact us.

w

Enclosure:

Safety Evaluatio Edson G Office. Case, Acting Dir n

of cc w next page Nuclear Reac See /enclosurc:

ector egula

__