ML062480379: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
| number = ML062480379
| number = ML062480379
| issue date = 06/30/2006
| issue date = 06/30/2006
| title = 2006/06/30-Email: (PA) Fwd: Questions and Answers of Pilgrim LRA Aging Management Reviews
| title = Email: (PA) Fwd: Questions and Answers of Pilgrim LRA Aging Management Reviews
| author name = Hoang D
| author name = Hoang D
| author affiliation = NRC/NRR/ADRO/DLR
| author affiliation = NRC/NRR/ADRO/DLR
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:James Davis - Fwd: Questions and Answers of Pilgrim LRA Aging Management Reviews                 Page 1 From:           Dan Hoang To:             Duc Nguyen; James Davis; Peter Wen; wapavinich @comcast.net;jacksonwr@ msn.com ;erachp @comcast.net Date:           06/30/2006 2:07:32 PM
{{#Wiki_filter:James Davis - Fwd: Questions and Answers of Pilgrim LRA Aging Management Reviews Page 1 From:
Dan Hoang To:
Duc Nguyen; James Davis; Peter Wen; wapavinich @ comcast.net;jacksonwr@ msn.com ;erachp @ comcast.net Date:
06/30/2006 2:07:32 PM


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
Line 22: Line 25:
Enjoy Dan
Enjoy Dan


c:\temp\qW)00001 JMP                                                                             Page 1!
c:\\temp\\qW)00001 JMP Page 1!
1 c:\tem,\GW}0001..TMP.P...
c:\\tem,\\GW}0001..TMP.P...
Mail Envelope Properties     (44A5685C.5BF: 17: 35826)
1 Mail Envelope Properties (44A5685C.5BF: 17: 35826)


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
Fwd: Questions and Answers of Pilgrim LRA Aging Management Reviews Creation Date        06/30/2006 2:07:24 PM From:                Dan Hoang Created By:          DVH@nrc.gov Recipients comcast.net wapavinich (wapavinich @comcast'net;jacksonwr@msn.com;erachp@comcast.net) nrc.gov OWGWPO03.HQGWDO01 JAD (James Davis) nrc.gov TWGWPO01.HQGWDO01 DTNI (Duc Nguyen) nrc.gov TWGWPO04.HQGWDO01 PXW (Peter Wen)
Reviews Creation Date From:
Post Office                                                         Route comcast.net OWGWPOO3.HQGWDOO1                                                   nrc.gov TWGWPO01.HQGWDOO1                                                   nrc.gov TWGWPO04.HQGWDO01                                                  nrc.gov Files                         Size              Date & Time MESSAGE                       444                06/30/2006 2:07:24 PM Mail Options Expiration Date:             None Priority:                     Standard ReplyRequested:               No Return Notification:         None Concealed  
Created By:
Fwd: Questions and Answers of Pilgrim LRA Aging Management 06/30/2006 2:07:24 PM Dan Hoang DVH@nrc.gov Recipients comcast.net wapavinich (wapavinich @comcast'net;jacksonwr@msn.com;erachp@comcast.net) nrc.gov OWGWPO03.HQGWDO01 JAD (James Davis) nrc.gov TWGWPO01.HQGWDO01 DTNI (Duc Nguyen) nrc.gov TWGWPO04.HQGWDO01 PXW (Peter Wen)
Post Office Route OWGWPOO3.HQGWDOO1 TWGWPO01.HQGWDOO1 TWGWPO04.HQGWDO01 comcast.net nrc.gov nrc.gov nrc.gov Files MESSAGE Mail Options Expiration Date:
Priority:
ReplyRequested:
Return Notification:
Concealed  


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
No Security:                     Standard
Security:
Size 444 Date & Time 06/30/2006 2:07:24 PM None Standard No None No Standard


.c:\temp\GW}00001 ,TMp                                             .Page2.'
.c:\\temp\\GW}00001,TMp  
.Page2.'
Junk Mail Handling Evaluation Results Message is not eligible for Junk Mail handling Message is from an internal sender Junk Mail settings when this message was delivered Junk Mail handling disabled by User Junk Mail handling disabled by Administrator Junk List is not enabled Junk Mail using personal address books is not enabled Block List is not enabled
Junk Mail Handling Evaluation Results Message is not eligible for Junk Mail handling Message is from an internal sender Junk Mail settings when this message was delivered Junk Mail handling disabled by User Junk Mail handling disabled by Administrator Junk List is not enabled Junk Mail using personal address books is not enabled Block List is not enabled


James Davis - AMR -_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                             Page 1 I NRC LRA AMR Audit of PNPS Number Status Request                                                     Resonse                                                            NRC        PNPS Lead 341   AcMeed InTable 41-I dists LRA te applicant ddrotIdenlfy             The license renewal         tie, In 10 CFR543, dalines aTLAA maa         Paid. Erach Fitch Ron ca"e lead cycle  *Unit as a TLAAlotrte Crawe within the      licersee calculaion or aralysie that. am'on other things. lranee sope datHeow renewa. Nonatmy,based onUnedesgn              tinrr-limiled aseurrics definael by Us arat operfling lani For code d Uhecrane, a lead cycle lUit Issptcified at rated      crans, Ihtwr Ia calculatior r arelysie rlased tocrare load capacity ovar the rerael projected lilfeTherfaore. ie        cycles. In addliton iU t arber atcycles IsNOT basadonthne geralty naecesary sopealotrn                      u eTLAA relating ocrane  ead  matra qcring tarn, ClMA-70 apecillesa allowable ltrmas cycles eatinsaledtoscur upto Useaddthe  U      teaded      range based onjirt cataelry and sevilceclass.aservice clasn Is period opaslkn Please actain w Uths        crareload cycle  tased onsload lams(nrho ective load lector) and rut' of timit was not included as a TL.Ak                          cycles. The projtcled cycles lot UhePNPS reactor buikldng crawe we wall below "t d Use cycle rarias, gven In CIAA70 The dscus'sio aoduram,     Atwn 33,1-1 alTable 3.31 willhe clariaed Io reed as followse -No PNPS calculaion,or anlysis rdalal ocutnAlive tawgue darrge lo a*ea cteCrawe       rc the datiatlior adTLAA In tO CFR 543 The proectade cycles tor Us PNPS r*eL' bilding san's         we well below U cycle ranges given InClAkA.70. Stwi cres we evaucaed as etructural csrry'eels in swum 3.5" This reapree anaenadmrne Ioths LRA 342  Asceted InTable 43-I. Lh*insm CUFor Clue I Cc res, noae              The assifls onthe RPV rain aloen vcl ard Iranerae nozzles           Paid, Erach Firrin, Rlu 2 addre*ses actiwn rues for ASME Csda Flees. mplain          we rild and vreeeee reanin balow Us acturat-e lUrnl. The wt tsee res ate,                                              'sigirt CE (Corrustion Engineerfg) vsesd ansysie deaisrratee Ust Uherealraonerats t IASE Seclion Ill-196S wilhaum-r 196 Atdends (Origirel Csolrrictia Coda), PFraraph N-4151 Vessels Nd Readring Analys*i for Cyclic()pas'ior were mL Th*e wae Ia. cortirmadto be the case Infs Atran ayal.ysi`
James Davis - AMR -_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 1 I NRC LRA AMR Audit of PNPS Number Status Request 341 AcMeed InTable 41-I dists LRA te applicant ddrotIdenlfy ca"e lead cycle *Unit as a TLAA lotr te Crawe within the sope dat Heow renewa. Nonatmy, based onUne desgn code d Uhe crane, a lead cycle lUit Is sptcified at rated capacity ovar the rerael projected lilfe Therfaore.
A nistake .. lls In Table 43-1 at hU LRA The recirctiationcui*
ie geralty naecesary sopealotrn eTLAA relating ocrane u
ead cycles eatinsaled toscur upto Use addthe U
teaded period opaslkn Please actain w Uths crareload cycle timit was not included as a TL.Ak 342 Asceted InTable 43-I. Lh*insm CUFor Clue I Cc res, noae 2 addre*ses actiwn rues for ASME Csda Flees. mplain wt tsee res ate, Resonse NRC PNPS Lead The license renewal
: tie, In 10 CFR543, dalines aTLAA maa Paid. Erach Fitch Ron licersee calculaion or aralysie that. am'on other things. lranee tinrr-limiled aseurrics definael by Us arat operfling lani For crans, Ihtwr Ia calculatior r arelysie rlased to crare load cycles. In addliton iU t arber atcycles IsNOT basad onthne matra qcring tarn, ClMA-70 apecilles a allowable ltrmas range based onjirt cataelry and sevilceclass.aservice clasn Is tased onsload lams (nrho ective load lector) and rut' of cycles. The projtcled cycles lot Uhe PNPS reactor buikldng crawe we wall below "t d Use cycle rarias, gven In CIAA70 The dscus'sio aoduram, Atwn 33,1-1 alTable 3.31 willhe clariaed Io reed as followse -No PNPS calculaion, or anlysis rdalal ocutnAlive tawgue darrge lo a*ea cteCrawe rc the datiatlior ad TLAA In tO CFR 543 The proectade cycles tor Us PNPS r*eL' bilding san's we well below U cycle ranges given InClAkA.70. Stwi cres we ev aucaed as etructural csrry'eels in swum 3.5" This reapree anaenadmrne Ioths LRA The assifls onthe RPV rain aloen vcl ard Iranerae nozzles Paid, Erach Firrin, Rlu we rild and vreeeee reanin balow Us acturat-e lUrnl. The
'sigirt CE (Corrustion Engineer fg) vsesd ansysie deaisrratee Ust Uhe realraonerats t IASE Seclion Ill-196S wilhaum-r 196 Atdends (Origirel Csolrrictia Coda), PFraraph N-4151 Vessels Nd Readring Analys*i for Cyclic()pas'ior were mL Th*e wae Ia. cortirmad to be the case In fs Atran ayal.ysi`
A nistake.. lls In Table 43-1 at hU LRA The recirctiation cui*
nAszle USage tact'o see not nd the crileiad praglraph N-ISt1.
nAszle USage tact'o see not nd the crileiad praglraph N-ISt1.
LRA Table 4.3.1 willberrevisled Iadd the apprclriale usage factor lor Usereclrcdalion oCl razzle Nol 2will o lnger bearplied Io iU recirculiarion".'ootelr    et Ndle 2 wi be revised so reed as olue.
LRA Table 4.3.1 willberrevisled Iadd the apprclriale usage factor lor Use reclrcdalion oCl razzle Nol 2will o lnger bearplied Io iU recirculiarion".'ootel r et Ndle 2 wi be revised so reed as olue.
Detailed fatige anatysis ia not r-yired sircea Crristst nests Uhe requmareie atAShds Section In -1965 wilhearrotwr lIt9 Addna (Origial Coulrmation Code), Pasagraph N-415t1 Veees Nd Reqiring Analys*i for CyclicCplalion Thesreqtree anarneetwl           bssfh LRA Pag 1d 77
Detailed fatige anatysis ia not r-yired sircea Crristst nests Uhe requmareie atAShds Section In -1965 wilhearrotwr lIt9 Addna (Origial Coulrmation Code), Pasagraph N-415t1 Veees Nd Reqiring Analys*i for Cyclic Cplalion Thesreqtree anarneetwl bssfh LRA Pag 1d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                             Page22 Number Status   Request                                                     Response                                                          NRC        PNPS Lead 343   Accepted Sectia 4 31.3. Class I piping and camrp.-I. states all       Section 431.3 dthe R~AIoscrart. PNPS 1.a noahelapeciric            Paid, Erach  Finrin, Ron rerai~rnin RCS prssure bsmrdy pipig Indesigned and           folig. analysis lort. leek-er ip iiog Section 433 dth ll RA arslyrzedIn a-rea44l     "ithANSI B31.1. Howasa. In         Isdiscmaing the offets d tha raomewcoolantPdrwirawo on sectimnAla3, on page 4 3- Itinplie V la higee analysl       Iiig-    Eriargy willornroe ft generic (NUREG-52in( va1445 $or wrists for I~looa   piping (asoh in pad d the RCS prsswoa   theawe spray    asal od the FIR Ufa15nozzle and the Iawha51er boasdoy piping =as.       and .iyzai lAW B31. .).         piping iron Table 43-a TherewearPtdPS-secaific wel4yse lo, Ploeas olrgly the dsocreorcy.uinceB31.1 dcoeal r"Asra,       teeIasa      onelle a taligia analysis OdotUaidi aSeine rasycose t Qustison 346A belvw for the PNPS
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page2 2 Number Status Request 343 Accepted Sectia 4 31.3. Class I piping and camrp.-I. states all rerai~rnin RCS prssure bsmrdy pipig In designed and arslyrzed In a-rea44l "ithANSI B31.1. Howasa. In sectimnAla3, on page 4 3-It inplie V la higee analysl wrists for I~looa piping (asoh in pad d the RCS prsswoa boasdoy piping =as.
                                                                                              =lswt          for parforatnrg EAF(onvinxrssarlly adfutedlalIotiq)
and.iyzai lAW B31..).
TH. raeira. ananvaotnerl Iofta RA 344   Acoepted Sovlon 4113. Clasi pipik and oowp-nal sasad                 PN;; wiIladd f foldloingasentence al11    ft d d Swticn 411.M      Paid. Erach  Finrine Ren paragraph aides thal Ith design trarseons we bacedka and       'Th. effects d the reasolocoolert Porprmonal onlatioir wre oasakatad to ara that cycle Iirnil, wenoroea, aoa     d,     addresedl In Section 4 33 d ft IRA*
Ploeas olrgly the dsocreorcy. uince B31.1 dcoe al r"Asra, a taligia analysis OdotUaidi 344 Acoepted Sovlon 4113.
Unreby asa~ing that CUF. do M, .ead 10A ithtlwt saltas Ma con~fstionta d tis prograt lOwelore will           TheaTLAAaddressedby Sevtion 4 31.3 Iscalcujielm OCIJFa SatO "14the aIlcoted nanbor d Inrersas cycles Isa,          willosi arlooriig Ior the effecs drawls, coolaterS  aionars,ae
Clasi pi pik and oowp-nal sasad paragraph aides thal Ith design trarseons we bacedka and oasakatad to ara that cycle Iirnil, wenoroea, aoa d,
                                  ..oawlo Caaayseloly, the TLAA(fatgue analyasas)       [or TH. TLAA orneina valid for ft periodci ortendd capratim as Clase I piping andconponent willir anfaid fo0     r the     kng as lie analyzednrbore d transients Isnct .. cewal periaild olrtded opeaion In aoer"ow with 10CFR 642 1(c)(1)(l)m orte oabec. daging w,1   th Iteded Ifolin(ar)     TheacalculatondSCIJF accountingto, the affects d the reats willbeaderi~tedy nonagod IWthe pariodd adenla               coolant Wir1100nwr1ceosnot aris, as thWetsrers licensing basia oparaliss In aoosrdaro with 10CFR 5421(c)(I)(MIi The by     cdcas rot raqrol consclraeicon dS oirormarosI Idiomatacura.
Unreby asa~ing that CUF. do M,  
Itself 00.44 baa tu slas 51.1.,     Imwwas cyicl coO1.iic       Since 10 CA 114    3 dolins. TIA~s as ficwe.. calcsicra anPd doas rot address the effetla dSariO'r-tal Iig.^ wtich       analysesa. Uwe Isaoa aTLMA Owicorko~ers .orwroreratl gaigue Is rot Includedlher, Akncwled~jrg gtha setiss 433s           ImicnoN arldrear" eroirrvanial W~ig^~ pt.. clarity low OW4 goclion Isgod inio the 11sonlusis mrade In aoction43.1.3,   Tore-ro the parcaeive inpdisaticn dim arcaaling the atlowale ronter dStranset ati          oI.nsa
.ead 10A it htlwt saltas Ma con~fstionta d tis prograt lOwelore will SatO "14 the aIlcoted nanbor d Inrersas cycles Is a,
                                                                                                                              -4    CUFato exceed I., the followinrgc1W~ will benmod tot In RA, IRASection 4311. page 434 willhawolified asldlona Th.
..oawlo Caaayseloly, the TLAA (fatgue analyasas)
P14PSFatigue Mcbiloring Progirs ar"am. that ftWnater od tasirent cyclsas.ryenrel by ft plerS roaian withinthe allowable waters dScycles.Prd hence the ossyonal CUF.
[or Clase I piping and conponent willir anfaid fo0 r the periaild olrtded opeaion In aoer"ow with 10 CFR 642 1 (c)(1)(l)m orte oabec. daging w,1 th Iteded Ifolin(ar) will beaderi~tedy nonagod IW the pariod d adenla oparaliss In aoosrdaro with 10CFR 54 21 (c)(I)(MIi The by Itself 00.44 ba a tu slas 51.1.,
rorrain below "rW analyzedvalues.
Imwwas cyicl coO1.iic doas rot address the effetla dS ariO'r-tal Iig.^ wtich Is rot Includedl her, Akncwled~jrg gtha setiss 433s arldrear" eroirrvanial W~ig^~ pt..
IRA Section,4.31.3. SecondsartecealOur    ta aood paragraph, will ba ochanged  as lollowa
clarity low OW4 goclion Is god inio the 11sonlusis mrade In aoction 43.1.3,
                                                                                                -Th. design trersier. wetrakedbr Pnd wacisted to "ars.tast cycla lirt.seawi m.ossde Oedry assaringtat CUFa rernain below ther analyzedvluesras TN.rapeeeradre  serreoS      o"  IAA Pbge 2d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                              Page 3 Number Status  Request                                                      Response                                                             NRC        FlPS Lead 345  Accepted Sectio 4.3.I.4, Feedwater Nozzle Faigue stlaese Iis          ThMThlwntl Poer Oplimizatia Task Report T030 up aedthe              Paid, Erach  Fin1,%Ron earapoted wage factor fotr flaeedwaler nozzles.               teedwaternozzle CUF to<1.0 beted onthe aessociated (15%) peter conridertg th the cerretly analyzed sylate deign              Wetre Th extrapalion InaLRAsection 43L1.4 Is tha o longer translents and rapid cycling Vro.u meperiod d Warded          valid PNPS will odlfy the LRA todlde islatrapdatiora PNPS geeaUoM, Is ft. .0 899 THe nate        Is no carted. Pleae  willperform a raw, Ieadwater ozzle fatigue a*alysl prior tomfe wiplain ht ths naurber wm cacuated                          period l extended peerswa THieco*irrtned      Is Iter 3 5  mfePNPS com.er.re    tor license THosreaprsenatetrnatrr          tometIRA 346  Open -  Ssctiol 43`3, Effect o Relor Water Exawrwierwt on            A Further relireenof te    f ASME Class I lmiguearelysls for mhe    Paid. Etach Firrirn Ron NRC      FMagta Lile                                                  RPV and nozzle localtios willbe perlored considering      mhe Please provide tee detals onyour Iknpemertlii        plen    proddaed uranber Iranmierns e        ch location at*aled o the and A 1owwills  fterth reriret        ofl fte ligue selysos be    cf fte aerdedd icerse period wsingrefined fIrle dated perfornee Wit t consider firtle d-ted erelysee?              .atvu.tiom a sapicabe The refined arWysis will amourd tor B. Kan aging ewroarnert progtr Is wed, please        Imtlide  entrlnri wri decls as apic abIe wing oe FEN methedolog a at-mitmtte IoDssutor NRCappral 24 nuoh priorso              described bymeGALLreperl or *ohe Indrstry Codes and Starsdds snlering perlodof lersied operalion.                           a approved by NRC.
===Response===
C. WO11replaernatw beaot  me eats neerial typ?
Section 431.3 dthe R~A Ios crart. PNPS 1.a noahelapeciric folig.
B License rerneal Cormaent 31 1rclubs a cwmlti                to sabTil meaging e'atine            progranio tome NRC 24 trnths prior t1ome periodcfmterdaod operaion Ift            ging nweagrnrtd prograt option is chsera C. Apprvrises replacerdnt Male ril willbe slected In accordarce with PNPS designeortrd Iocedam. If repleateo n Is acloest 347  Accepted Tasle 43-$ Note I stales 'No PNPS-specifo vasue was          A Yes.     lsis a lypo It    tid be NUREG-4281.                     Pald. Erach Piorrt%Rat available; wed generic value froa NUREGCR-=."
analysis lort. leek-er ip iiog Section 433 dth ll RA Is discmaing the offets d tha raomew coolant Pdrwirawo on Iiig-Eriargy willornroe ft generic (NUREG-52in( va1445 $or theawe spray asal od the FIR Ufa15 nozzle and the Iawha51er piping iron Table 43-a There wea rPtdPS-secaific wel4yse lo, teeIasa onelle aSe ine rasycose t Qustison 346A belvw for the PNPS
a Wrong NUREG leratfied - sheid ft be NUREG-62MO?            B ThMCUFvalws fato NUREG-6M were Indedeo am typical btTh. NUREG-81W CUF is be          aedtmtespecific plant    values wed to preit tme rgil*d            othe efct ofconsidering me used IntOe NUREG ard Is dMpadel onatW plart* piping          reactor ceolat erwirotrel onfaligue torPNPS. PNPS willaseod configuraeionTha value cardbM ed tar PNPS                    meLRAto reaove the CUFs fromTa*ie 43-3 me we taean frt calcjationIPlease justiyhow h value applies toPNPS          NUREG-62X0.
=lswt for parforatnrg EAF (onvinxrssarlly adfutedlalIotiq)
rieas me NPS piping wconiguslions          atrnsasme NUREO-6260 plaed arproolde ePNPS specific CUFvaluw          see Ite 346 for PNPS's omrraim-et topelorm adtditionel sfirornmW9dl y eacusledtai          angslyses prier tome period oi Tls response reqlirm  te    arta*trel    tome LRA PFgu 3 1 77
TH. raeira. ananvaotnerl Iofta RA PN;; wiIladd f foldloingasentence al11 ft d d Swticn 411.M
'Th. effects d the reasolo coolert Porprmonal onlatioir wre addresedl In Section 4 33 d ft IRA*
TheaTLAAaddressed by Sevtion 4 31.3 Is calcujielm OCIJFa willosi arlooriig Ior the effecs drawls, coolaterS aionars,ae TH. TLAA orneina valid for ft period ci ortendd capratim as kng as lie analyzednrbore d transients Is nct.. cewal Theacalculaton dS CIJF accounting to, the affects d the reats coolant Wir1100nwr1ceos not aris, as thW etsrers licensing basia cdcas rot raqrol consclraeicon dS oirormarosI Idioma tacura.
Since 10 CA 114 3 dolins. TIA~s as ficwe.. calcsicra anPd analysesa.
Uwe Isao a aTLMA Owi corko~ers.orwroreratl gaigue ImicnoN To re-ro the parcaeive inpdisat icn dim arcaaling the atlowale ronter dS transet ati
-4 oI.nsa CUFa to exceed I., the followinrg c1W~
will benmod tot In RA, IRASection 4311. page 4 34 willhawolified as ldlona Th.
P14PS Fatigue Mcbiloring Progirs ar"am. that ftW nater od tasirent cyclsas.ryenrel by ft plerS roaian withinthe allowable waters dS cycles. Prd hence the ossyonal CUF.
rorrain below "rW analyzed values.
IRA Section, 4.31.3. Second sarteceal Our ta aood paragraph, will ba ochanged as lollowa
-Th. design trersier. wetrakedbr Pnd wacisted to "ars. tast cycla lirt. seawi m.ossde Oedry assaring tat CUFa rernain below ther analyzedvluesras TN.rapeeeradre serreoS o"
IAA NRC Paid, Erach Paid. Erach PNPS Lead Finrin, Ron Finrine Ren Pbge 2d 77


James Davis - AMR_- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf .                                      ..                                ..                                      .        .        .Page         41 Number Status   Request                                                       Response                                                              NRC        PNPS Lead 349  Closed    13.11-W-01J                                                  Usting TLAA -nstl taltge inthe latle in Section 3hindraies            Wear Peter  FinPh Ron Oetthe ooltJor lonteige weeprelee, add tha              y reeded to In r-m - lineItIn nTablee 342-2, 3.2-14-3. 9.10.              be toelsedi      Associted orrponerthe were st*e*"rinty I,17and 18d    ice StWel and Power Cemerlion System          evarmted InLRPD-C, TILAA        - MoldaFatigue I Waeevalutiona toud pic.ant cradte TLMA- MWal Fatig" to nengy Wne ape                                                      no TLA. Itwe rnotfisled InSect-a 4Ad fte IRA For aging afect d end latig.. (convilive ati;gu d-ego).          clarificatio, Entergy will revises e Section 3 tahes to rernro Whe and Itdlcites Wetthe eraludion ci 54 TLAAis addressed        TLA*-rials totgue arieswhueev tosre waee oessCciata:
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 3 Number Status Request 345 Accepted Sectio 4.3.I.4, Feedwater Nozzle Faigue stlaes e Iis earapoted wage factor fotr flaeedwaler nozzles.
InSection 4A3ofo IRA Hower', happesawl the                   TLAAdocsds1 inSection 4Al lb LRA writ,      dthe Section 43 does M co.' Wthe of                                  dioelscri loi rntel omo          ,'ePlease  tlsai Whedscrepertcy          The item haclosed toit"    MS.
conridertg th the cerretly analyzed sylate deign translents and rapid cycling Vro.u me period d Warded geeaUoM, Is ft.  
35O  Accepted  (.*4t-W-M                                                    The Secthon 34222 (1) lrotthr salutuon dectssion Ih referenced Weor Peter          Ungvotdter.
.0 899 THe nate Is no carted. Pleae wiplain ht ths naurber wm cacuated 346 Open -
byTaie 341 somenl3 -Z24t1-4 and41-6", Thedsocein Section 34222 (t)dft'RA(ppge            34-4), ft- appicant  tintt entry otilen 341-6 irdcite tha lhe PSPM proaresn applies to fe coda-sate storagetorts. AJthoid the wat.' In theseeta-ts wooed btubjein tothe wa.er chttantry corols -BWR L cd otaerialdue to general. pittirg and crtwice              progevm We PS'M p rargsto stlicler to tlweage loseoi rmaterial corrosioni icecotbo, sledt dying pipingcontyora-is. and    and was theOnlyprogren credlted ifor se latos. See OW terioeysed totreatedwit.' ard forcarbon stelepiping      rtponse tovptsstion 3 4"- (iltm i353) weich dotum lt gatthe and carnpant exposedltoetst- I[amsong elect                  We.er Cheristry Ca-trdl - BMR pIOger shoald have been cr*dted reqoiring trere~          Inthe stem and power corverslion      alongwith et PSPM progea lot Whewlensae storage totMs systemnoit PN        ald haisnage by We Watet Chesnistry Coarolr -BWR antd Priodc Sta~llaerc and Preventive            This reanresi sJoIeer/erns          nems  lo the WRA hrtlnwerr (PS'4 Proga'nes" Please tlarity,e ftoe      suarwy, regarding the u of PSPM proram Is the we d PSPM progam Is infimJof the OTI progra to verity We electiser.s o thf V*We.
Ssctiol 43`3, Effect o Relor Water Exawrwi erwt on NRC FMagta Lile Please provide tee detals onyour Iknpemertlii plen A 1owwills fterth reriret ofl fte ligue selysos be perfornee Wit t consider firtle d-ted erelysee?
Cheoistry Coarol -SWR prograes or we ofetAEM oaritirton willbemanaged by wing PSPM alone 351  Closed    (34.t-W-031                                                  Sirces e Ore-Time Anqyection(OTt) Progr. to applicable Is          hch Wen, Peter  Froaterger water cheidrity conrd progan, tI is also applicaie toeach line W1 h. OTI prograr not crdlted lor those linetter. In          Item that cre*its a waet.' ohonitry contro progano RAWTaTle Tinles 342-x and Table3.32-14.x (mrosporcing to              34`1 Inciates en IW OnisTino Inspection Prograem Is urthed Vtll E-33. oordeonele syslemrnVlt.C-.6. .trectiat stesm      along wihthe wat.r dlensitry otrdrl prograem lot lineiHhem lot systentVtIIID2-7. leodwer system and VIItB2-6, tain        which OALLrearrvc dse            -hI1m Irnsecion toooahirm water atem systern) OW rference tohn 34.1-4?                        cheniatry control Table 2tredts We OTI progamntough rdeterce tohe associated Taile I line Item Thiererpireevnarnetrrct        sothectenstry progea deocritionr In WRA eAppend-      Aard BIo clearlyitncite Wel  t Wa O-Time Inspection Prog*am wiltocvhirm the slftctiveres of We Whter Cheristry Control.-MR. Water Cho iatry Cntrol- AmMatirySysteom and We Water Chreniatry Cotroh- Cloese Coding Water prorrem.
B. Kan aging ewroarnert progtr Is wed, please Imtlide a at-mitmtte IoDssu tor NRCappral 24 nuoh priorso snlering perlod of lersied operalion.
Tis it"    is closedto tem 372 Page 4 d 77
C. WO11 replaernatw beao t me eats neerial typ?
347 Accepted Tasle 43-$ Note I stales 'No PNPS-specifo vasue was available; wed generic value froa NUREGCR-=."
a Wrong NUREG leratfied - sheid ft be NUREG-62MO?
bt Th. NUREG-81W CUF is be aedt mte specific plant used IntOe NUREG ard Is dMpadel onatW plart* piping configuraeion Tha value cardb M ed tar PNPS calcjationI Please justiyhow h value applies toPNPS rieas me NPS piping wconigu slions atrns asme NUREO-6260 plaed arproolde ePNPS specific CUFvaluw


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                  Page 5 I Number Status  Request                                                      Response                                                              NRC        PNVPS  Lead M5  Closed  1311.1-W-041                                                Sims Me. Ons-Tirns Inspection(071) Prograrn Isapplical 1so        eah Wen, Poteo  Fronacrgb.r watercarnisry control Program itIs1. aloapplicablet each liIne Wiry Is OTI prgrr      Mocradled for tl&#xfd;      nhoerni. In 000np0.,0.0 i1condon8801, e78180.) that reforeme    it-. along w4th11, ot lercenrisry control p00grari.I lineft.nt for.1 which1GALLreconwrar1 a00.0.110. Inspectimoe conf.irm,water 3.41-11?
===Response===
atan stry control. Table 2 credits the OTI prog.'ntrI~ough referenceb01  IheasociatedTidl I.lifet.em.
NRC ThM Thlwntl Poer Oplimizatia Task Report T030 up aed the Paid, Erach teedwater nozzle CUF to<1.0 beted onthe aessociated (15%) peter Wetre Th extrapalion InaLRA section 43L1.4 Is tha o longer valid PNPS will odlfy the LRA todlde islatrapdatiora PNPS willperform a raw, Ieadwater ozzle fatigue a*alysl prior tomfe period l extended peerswa THie co*irrtned Is Iter 3 5 mfe PNPS com.er.re tor license THosreaprsenatetrnatrr tomet IRA A Further relireenof f te ASME Class I lmigue arelysls for mhe Paid. Etach RPV and nozzle localtios willbe perlored considering mhe proddaed uranber Iranmierns e ch location at*aled o the and cf fte aerdedd icerse period wsing refined fIrle dated
THerectuires  00warnordre lothe charritry p000,0.1descriptions In LRA Appedices A and 81Solealy Ir000. that00        ft    -Tko.
.atvu.tiom a sapicabe The refined arWysis will amourd tor entrlnri wri decls as apic abIe wing oe FEN methedolog described by me GALL reperl or *ohe Indrstry Codes and Starsdds a approved by NRC.
Irpecti0. Prograne0iltoo0.0ir th. .effcir.ero 011the      Water and th0, Waler Chernist Control- Closed CoolingWater prograrne.
B License rerneal Cormaent 31 1rclubs a cwmlti to sabTil me aging e'atine progranio tome NRC 24 trnths prior t1o me periodcfmterdaod operaion Ift ging nweagrnrtd prograt option is chsera C. Apprvrises replacerdnt Male ril will be slected In accordarce with PNPS designeortrd Iocedam. If repleateo n Is acloest A Yes.
Tisherno  1.0closedto0110.37M 353  Closed  pal1.W-CS)                                                    Sims Itn.00.010.80(8 storage larit cortai. flud OeW10sotect10          WON.Peter  GrIiwkl, Jac0k theate Charritry Conrold- OWR Program~the the controls 01f1 TI. applicat ref.oremt GALL IternVlIiiE-4D (.1.1 tank In    pro00,. applies to11  thelak TI. LtA will beclarifid to wpicilly cond0ensate systar) 10. f condensate01storage apteI          crad1 the Water Ctanien Cont1rol- B'AR Progan, Inaddtion to cabo I.W.lank, m listed InLRA Tek11.      142-t. (paeg      PSPM with nwoegng Oneeflects cofging 1rII.       the codensat 34-28). but t-k.. credit of PSPPJ1. ns"eg ther    agingeffc 010.05 bl( 5,01000.s      aposedbth tr1eaed0010  water.arst,1,0 r.0 of0..
ls is a lypo It tid be NUREG-4281.
loss f      .1. Th. GALL                  uson~e~.ing
Pald. Erach B ThM CUFvalws fato NUREG-6M were Indedeo am typical values wed to preit tme rgil*d othe efct of considering me reactor ceolat erwirotrel onfaligue tor PNPS. PNPS willaseod me LRA to reaove the CUFs from Ta*ie 43-3 me we taean frt NUREG-62X0.
                                                                                    'War.
see Ite 346 for PNPS's omrraim-et topelorm adtditionel sfirornmW9dl y eacusled tai angs lyses prier tome period oi Tls response reqlirm te arta*trel tome LRA FlPS Lead Fin1,% Ron Firrirn Ron Piorrt% Rat PFgu 3 1 77
Chernisry .r0d OCTrprograrr Ior 11i.compne.nt en AEM        Sims the Ore-Ti,,. Inspection (OTi) Progran,Is applicabe to each
                                  ..100ia, P1700.11the PSP. a desribed In PNPS               water charrstry control prograrn 11100Is aloappicoble t0o  eachtire LRA Si.211( IPe -0~ stringent Inspection rqirwnert than      1(0,011thatcrcnlie a,0. aercwni00117control progran Assee0d In OTI. itdos,.. Include0.1conro~llingwatercIhoristry 10        LFIATable 34.1, the GreTirsIn.sp0ection Progrer00Icradled to1 Ml(5MZe cornp-40,      wopm.. 10egyasiva, -,ir-.t            weily                  the water chernistry owrol. pr00,orn for tir ofclons Please :I;=      ,ly relying ort PSPM alone is suficient for 1100,.11100. 11.rfeece.l      3 4.14-treaing the GAL. rseornrnnc,01os7e 10rna-eg 1. agng effect of loss of Inal.10110. 11Wecoroneae storage 07010.1  Th* rectuiresanarnordywat 1011. charrisy p000,0n descriptions car.ori stee  lar0k                                          In LRA ApprdicesAanl lBt1olarl Indicatethat ft Gr-Tin.
inspeciion Prograrrl wii conf1irm,11 0theti      . of the Viol, ClWdetrp Cortro1-SMI Viter Ctwneislryd0.001l- Auxiiiry Opel.,.
sy010., (paeg 3.3171) and1 Table 33.2-14.11, 10ee3.olo        0.0d the Water Chardstry Conrord-Closed Cooling Water progran..
                                            ,.~0 header dananed            8701.0yser (paeg 33-1781).also referene GALLften Vill E-40. Wt7 10OTIprv~ogr M0            Th* 110. Isclosed 10110. 372 credited 10.tos line.
10.11, OW0,,      .refreckern 341-6 PFa 5d 77


James Davis- AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                             Page 6 1 Number Status Request                                                 Response                                                                NRC      PNPS Lead 354  Closed 34.t-W-0C]                                              During lhe peornemce      roetine rreirlenmce onecirenei            f Wen, Per. Frortue*rgr.
James Davis - AMR_- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf.
soatin klbicaling oil vieua irepecl"      df these oari-owl.
.Page 41 Number Status Request 349 Closed 13.11-W-01J In r-m lineItIn nTablee 342-2, 3.2-14-3. 9.10.
Whf In OTIprosare not crdled for fle inre hew In        would Idetlity degtaded oowdlienl ti-at sxid beeatribled loan Table 332-14-35 (wresponing to VILA-I14)thet redeuence  inerfective Ol Aslyss program The corrective action progton at e-n 34.1-77                                            PNPS has alow tireehold lo tIe ntification d degraded wsrdtiio such th-h.tcroson or crackingrc ornlonerts woud be Idrntified as peanoft is proge'n The reiew of crerating tpereice S PNPS fr the last five yrea id iM Identily aew condtion reportsin Iindcted -I nelitecline il aenalysisprogeer or
I,17and 18d ice StWel and Power Cemerlion System ape pic.ant cradte TLMA - MWal Fatig" to nengy Wne aging afect d end latig.. (convilive ati;gu d-ego).
                                                                                          -n Idwrled degeaeld ceyoren I condtilie stch as corosion a cracking Ina libricating oil envireortoiw Tide reviewer  d    eracing e.pyiewe atPNPS eneva Inle sifa re-ine Irepection to proetde oordim.,,on d re eecilvuee de              Oil Ataetysi Prog'aeo During t peet five yes. ney visel Irnpechonedcomnpormes ontainrng hdhlcing li-heve tees perlorreddxing corrective and preventie rteirene e achvilim. The visuel Inpectione ci ihe oonionels woUIdidetitfy degrade cordtionr sucheas croslm ac cracking  ta coLad be attrbied toes Inotelctive Oil Amelytis Progran. PNPS hm elaw thre*hld Wline I*lwlic*l*on c deg          conslie-eetch O wroslon w cracking s s*ertwlaens oed waid bee~litiel aet eue- lloothe wrsctioveaclon progrnoa No condition reports M idart Itied degraded ca-prpst ontlionr, eJch s sorstic, t smoracking    in Ialbricating oil envirortret were Initiated esa reeuit of tme lirspeclion. The-e past iWtectio a PNPS e nvelinfie      s croe-inm. Inepecton to proide saoIroorfi c ihe difectivness c tie ail Arnlye[s Program Tie iten Is s*omed o Iten 376, 355  Closed (3.4.1-W-0"                                                ime the One-Time Inspection (OTI) Pograrn is appcable toech            We. Petu  Frorebarger.
and Itdlcites Wet the eraludion ci 54 TLAA is addressed InSection 4A3ofo IRA Hower ', happesawl the
water chseitry weal progrum Itie also applicble        eoteh      line Wy Is OTI progra not credled for tIre.
: writ, of dthe Section 43 does M co.' Wthe dioelscri loi rntel omo
Hoeiew    In         eis Uzincruetd a water chetistry coinrol pnogeao LRA Tide Table 122-4, HPCI System (pags 32-49) and Table        341 tIncatsa O tie One-Time Inspection Prograo Is creited 12-5. RCICSystem, (pge. 32-62) (onrraspondin to       along with the water cheristry wortdclprogeara for line hornsbte V1i E-tO) that rderence ite 341-9?                      whychGALL reoiefnds se-hUne Impapectiontowconirmwaler civeistry werld. Taebl 2 creits tie OTIprograin tnvji rderence toft ass*ciated Table I line item Thid redree esanearendent the c&#xa2;eritry progran descriplions IntLRA 4*pudceeAand Bto clterly idicae that the Ore-Tine Irepectl* n Progrem willoortirm the dtuectivenuesof the Vateu Citestey Ceird-OWR. Water Chen Isy Cotrid- Ami*eruy Sysleres and fe Water Cheoisy Cortrol- Ckoed Coding Wauer progrews Ths id t  le cisla to i*edn372 Paw 6d 77
,'e Please tlsai Whe dscrepertcy 35O Accepted
(.*4t-W-M Section 34222 (t)dft 'RA(ppge 34-4), ft-appicant L cd otaerial due to general. pittirg and crtwice corrosioni ice cotbo, sledt dying piping contyora-is. and terioeysed totreated wit.' ard for carbon stele piping and carnpant exposedltoetst-I[am song elect reqoiring trere~
Inthe stem and power corverslion systemno it PN ald hais nage by We Watet Chesnistry Coarolr -BWR antd Priodc Sta~llaerc and Preventive hrtlnwerr (PS'4 Proga'nes" Please tlarity
,e ftoe suarwy, regarding the u of PSPM proram Is the we d PSPM progam Is in fimJof the OTI progra to verity We electiser.s o thf V*We.
Cheoistry Coarol -SWR prograes or we ofe tAEM oaritirton willbemanaged by wing PSPM alone 351 Closed (34.t-W-031 W1 h. OTI prograr not crdlted lor those linetter. In Tinles 342-x and Table3.32-14.x (mrosporcing to Vtll E-33. oordeonele syslemrn Vlt.C-.6..trectiat stesm systent VtIIID2-7.
leodwer system and VIIt B2-6, tain atem systern) OW rference tohn 34.1-4?


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                -                                                                                          Page 7 Number Status  Request                                              Response                                                                 NRC       PNPS Lead 356  Closed    ,l1i-W-O8]                                        Durirg thte rfortlcere d -ini          trairtetw aorpo  o      .     -e War%Peter Proiabarger.
===Response===
conlain kibricatirg oil. viaLel Irspections of these conivonos Wy IsOTI proran rot cradted Wofoe e ertiar In        aouid blaniry dejaed cordteis WettoAd be attriloed loa Table 312-6, Staion BackoeL Dieds.l (Ogv 13-90)and    Ireflecvtie 0i1 Anlysie Prograr The co-rectivo action progoa at Tabl 32-6, Securly Dined Geneastor System (page      PNPS lee a le S                  heW idenfication Vdto-aded tesidd 13-110) (correspordog toVIII,0-15) tl reference iten  wriditio: such ft! corrosion ow rackingrofdV    orporne      wodd be 341-(10                                              Idu-ified aseert po fis      program The ravowofdoperating et ierice at PPPS he te last five year. dd rot kdlrifty any conrition reports tl Iredcalted    an Inaeotive oil trelyeie program or tat Idanified dograded conp-ar I conditions euch secorrosion or crackirg Inna tirk'icatng oil awirrerr        Teis review f operating apariernce al PNPS area Inlie V e one-tirre Irepecti-n to provIde nord*drtton of We effectioveensof te Ci Arelysis Program Doringte    paet five years, Inaty visual I.pec:ot      of ooneotryc s reaingrt brt*fOs cWheoe been perormad                rOtWncorrecti*e aod prevertive neirta*roe ecivities. The vaiel InspectioseVI theen otrponaran woaid idaity deg-aded orodltiora euch as coroicln or cracking ea coud bestilosied tow Intlfectlve Cil Anelysi Progrem PNPS lee aloe tfeshld iorthe          We krtifiosn o degeded cordloe    nsch    fl-t corrosion a crackirg ofIcortrpevts would be idMrasfiedand eel IneoWhe          corrective action progTern Nooordsion reporle tat  *dt        Modde7aded conporte- cotdtions.
NRC PNPS Lead Usting TLAA -nstl taltge inthe latle in Section 3hindraies Wear Peter FinPh Ron Oetthe ooltJor lon teige weeprelee, add tha y reeded to be toelsedi Associted orrponerthe were st*e*"rinty evarmted InLRPD-C, TILAA
ewch asnorroeion or cracking Inn ludicating oil -ihorne            wawn (rifilated-sa reattl ofte      Irapecotme. Thees past Itepetirlm at PNPS e-e Inlie. of a cne-ioie irpnton lo proide cordio*rhetiarVIe  d              enf        Oil Anysis Progem ollethWe TN. taer is closed tofelr 376.
- Molda Fatigue I Wae evalutiona toud no TLA. Itwe rnot fisled InSect-a 4Ad fte IRA For clarificatio, Entergy will revises e Section 3 tahes to rernro Whe TLA* -rials totgue aries whueev tosre waee oessCciata:
357 Cloede    ,14l-W-OM                                          SoremWeOne-Time Inspection (OTI) Pro7ant Is ap*v-.ate tIo ach              Wan Ppter Frotne.W, waeer chiaristry cornrolprogearr ItIs also apidiase bI each line WVAIs OTI pograrm ro crated lo thoee lint a*roeIn    Item Via credits a water chermstrycontrd Program (RA Table Table a42-2. lMn C-olr er and ISIV L.Wage Pat;ray,  33.1 Irdcalta tl Whe      One-Time Inpection PFroasm Iscraded Table 332-14-9. Extincfion Ste System Table          aorg wit the water ohereiery control ponsgme for Ilne              e hoe 332-14-16, HPCI. Tade 3.32-14-18. bln Slent System  waich GALLreoorandf e onre-tli Inspectlon toconfirm water and Table 3a2-14-1I. OClgre and A*grnarned C11ge    chwriatry corlrd. Table 2 credits WeCOI1        progant through Spate tU rdelence ita 34.1-137                      rferenrce to fe associsled Table I line iter TNs readree anaeror*rf loe            ofthernietry progran doscriptions InLRA Aeaoerce A a- Bto clearly iriscate VW We Gte-Tine Irpecyion Program willcoirm the dinotivene; of We Water Chearitry Corlrot-BW, MtWerChlarn ry Coradi- Aueiliay -yster.
TLAA docsds1 inSection 4Al lb LRA The item ha closed toit" MS.
ard the Water Chetvwriy Control- Cloeed Coding Water proga-ne.
The Secthon 34222 (1) lrotthr salutuon dectssion Ih referenced Weor Peter Ungvotdter.
TN. ita    Is cloed Iohoart372 PIg 7d 77
byTaie 341 somenl 3
-Z 24t1-4 and41-6 ", Thedsocein tintt entry otilen 341-6 irdcite tha lhe PSPM proaresn applies to fe coda-sate storagetorts. AJthoid the wat.' In theseeta-ts wooed btubjein tothe wa.er chttantry corols -BWR progevm We PS'M p rarg s to stlicler to tlweage lose oi rmaterial and was the Only progren credlted ifor se latos. See OW rtponse tovptsstion 3 4"- (iltm i353) weich dotum lt gat the We.er Cheristry Ca-trdl - BMR pIOger shoald have been cr*dted along with et PSPM progea lot Whe wlensae storage totMs This reanresi sJoIeer/erns nems lo the WRA Sirces e Ore-Time Anqyection (OTt) Progr.
to applicable Is hch Wen, Peter Froaterger water cheidrity conrd progan, tI is also applicaie to each line Item that cre*its a waet.' ohonitry contro progano RAWTaTle 34`1 Inciates en IW OnisTino Inspection Prograem Is urthed along wihthe wat.r dlensitry otrdrl prograem lot line iHhem lot which OALL rearrvc dse
-hI1m Irnsecion toooahirm water cheniatry control Table 2tredts We OTI progam ntough rdeterce tohe associated Taile I line Item Thiererpireevnarnetrrct sothectenstry progea deocritionr In WRA eAppend-Aard BIo clearly itncite Wel t Wa O-Time Inspection Prog*am wiltocvhirm the slftctiveres of We Whter Cheristry Control.-MR. Water Cho iatry Cntrol-AmMatiry Systeom and We Water Chreniatry Cotroh-Cloese Coding Water prorrem.
Tis it" is closed to tem 372 Page 4 d 77


James Davis - AMR -_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                   Page 8:1 Number Status Request                                               Response                                                          NRC      PNPS Lead 35  Clneod  1341-W-101                                            Sircem e One-Tirme Inpecti      (OTI)Proaar Isapplicabe beach    Wen.Pale  Frorebager.,
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 5 I Number Status Request M5 Closed 1311.1-W-041 Wiry Is OTI prgrr Mo cradled for tl&#xfd; n hoerni. In 000np0.,0.0 i1condon8801, e78180.) that reforeme it-.
water cherAlry contral rorara 1liseso applicable b each limn Sinm. Wan Ward 'C'were ued invariow Tabe              hen th crodtsawafer cheistry corrol progarn LRATatte 312-14-x line ilens, whch reterenaw 0-34l-14, wyOTl  331 Incicae tEato O&#xfd;-Tina Inspection Prag-arnI creadled prOca hibno crediled for Eoeeline?                   along withbth water helristry coertrl proeg-m for Jim itane for which GALL recommends awoe-tlam Inspection boewlirm waler chemistry contrd. Table 2 credits to OTI progr-a Uhr refererce lothe aesocialed Tabie I line then Ths reqdreemanamardbt loate cheaialry p-ag-em descrptirs In liA )Apendicen Aand Eto clearly Jndicale OW the One-Timr Impection Program willoorfirm the ecrivete dtthe Waler Cernsety Control -*MER. Water Ctshatlry Corcrd - Aailiary Syslern eat and      Wafer Chlrde*ry Control - Closed Codirg Watr pro~ragw.
3.41-11?
Ths iel lcloed
353 Closed pal1.W-CS)
: 1.       o Item 372 359  Closd  [34.-W-t1]1                                          Si the One-Tine hIspeclion (OTI) Proagean Is applicable each      Wen. P.er  Fromaergar.
TI. applicat ref.oremt GALL Itern VlIiiE-4D (.1.1 tank In cond0ensate systar) 10. f condensate01 storage apteI cabo I.W. lank, m listed InLRA Tek11. 142-t. (paeg 34-28). but t-k.. credit of PSPPJ 1. ns"eg ther agingeffc of0..
wafer c*nealry correl propaanit lie Meoappicabe b eech lIne Seirde "C8was wed InTable 33.2-14-4. Condeasate      hemrn    credits a waler chairalry controlprog-arn IRA Tale Derineralizer System line ilens, which reference tern 33. Indlcale dM the OCw-ThaeInspection Bragem Is cr*eled ml.twld or thee line?
loss f
3.41-15. why OTI prograa i.cre                        alon wits. waler chaniety control p-oagare 1r line le for whichGALL rerraxc ewe-67aw Inspection locorirm waler chertniry wontrd.Tabe 2 creits "m OTI frog-am lfrou*
.1.
reaferemelothe asacialeod Taibe I line itear The reUire anawrdnrt            Ilotheciherdlry p"egar enweriptiow In IRA A nwdce. A and B boclery Imicate thnt t On-Time Impection Pro'ag- willcortirm fhe elfeclicerwe d ft Waler Cherelry Cemrl - EWM,Waler Ch**try Conrrcl
Th. GALL uson~e~.ing
* Awiaiary mhs Waler Chernstry Connrol - Closed Caolir Waler salerM and pro'harb.
'War.
This ften1 closed boharn 372 Pb-g 8d 77
Chernisry.r0d OCTrprograrr Ior 11i. compne.nt en AEM
..100ia, P1700.11 the PSP. a desribed In PNPS LRA Si.211( IPe
-0~ stringent Inspection rqirwnert than OTI. it dos,.. Include0.1 conro~lling water cIhoristry 10 Ml(5MZe cornp-40, wopm.. 10egyasiva, -,ir-.t Please :I;=
,ly relying ort PSPM alone is suficient for treaing the GAL. rseornrnnc,01os7e 10 rna-eg 1. agng effect of loss of Inal.10110. 11We coroneae storage 07010.1 car.ori stee lar0k sy010., (paeg 3.3 171) and1 Table 33.2-14.11, 10ee3.olo header
,.~0 dananed 8701.0yser (paeg 33-1781). also referene GALL ften Vill E-40. Wt7 10 OTI prv~ogr M0 credited 10.tos line.
10.11, OW0,,  
.refrec kern 3 41-6


James Davis - AMR - Reoort to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                         Page L Number Status Request                                                 Re#'onae                                                              NRC       PNPS Lead
===Response===
__0   Closed 134.1-W-121                                             Sims toe COn-Tin, Itoiocticn (OTt) ProgramI. apocaleto           acah Wen, Peter Fmrobergr, wate ctwrri"y controlprgamiIst also egtiCab. lo ch line Scims wlot "awci OCwwo din      ITable 342-1A          lion trotretsa.wcon Cicottry comrtol                     L ATable Cadio,"      Sorawge Systoniard vaic Table 3,a2-14-x    33.1 Irdoic tot       tOWO One-Tim. Iropoction Prcgram Is creidle line Name witch referenc Htnn3&IMG&#xfd; wh/ OTt program Is  along with toe walechmilsry cc,-tro pograns icr Iina It.,e for not credited Nor0-9o tflo?                            nItichGALL recmornds aoconetim loportion 10confrmr warer chmlstry control. Table 2creds Ito 07t Programtwoocgr referencoto the associatedTable I line Item.
Sims Me. Ons-Tirns Inspection (071) Prograrn Is applical 1so eah water carnisry control Program it Is1.
Ths rotpira, onawcrmldf to Ow cherctotryProgram dw~r~lors In LRAApperdea, Aarci8 to clearlyiricoleto              theCO-Timo lrap iontoPrognra wiltcoodirm toe                 , cit.
alo applicablet each liIne along w4th 11, ot lercenrisry control p00grari.I lineft.nt for.1 which1 GALL reconwrar1 a00.0.110. Inspectimoe conf.irm, water atan stry control. Table 2 credits the OTI prog.'ntrI~ough reference b01 IheasociatedTidl I. life t.em.
dtcto YA Chorristry Control - BWiR.Wate CtwnriciryCoircio .Amilwry Syaternenar-itreWalw ChemistryCorircil - Closed Coding Wftw The it-, 1. closed Ito 11-372 Owing ft       eoprmnoceofcoi01.no irinowce mcronponens tOw           Wrh Peter PRorhobgw.,
THe rectuires 00warnordre lothe charritry p000,0.1 descriptions In LRA Appedices A and 81 Solealy Ir000. that00 ft
contan kirricaling cii nitoal Irspections ci Ira, comonentsol Mity I. OTOprcgrcs Mwcrdedw to, tic.. line ItemsIn      ocoi Identiutydsg'rdod vordtlcr OW acrid baftnitAo lown T&abl3A 2-14X Twrbin Oonwattw ar Amiliary Sys[o.        Ircleitoctil.C Analysis Program The corroti. action Programa (correpoming ioVIll.A-3) fto referece leronM41-18?      POtS Fee slow.threshlddlorto kletficrtiCoifl citgradel cordior-O owth Mat corrcosio a crackinrgcf corgo-orl. world bo katitiwi a, part di tis Program Tho reiw wof opcherating wprpiocs a[ PONtSIcr tho 1831In. ywe ld MoIdonlity r cordiion rep"t "o Ircicotei a, Irinelwfti oil nlysis Program or tot Idlitiriw degradedcompa.- I ccrnitioro s~in a, corrosion or cracidng IM&hirriootiry oil wtwimronti. TN. rovecparatin orpwience EAPONtSsrasn Ow ofia,co-UrnosIropati or prmkQci       irrrmoiiflc tho Oia~ofa         fito Cil Arrolysis Ocirg fto paut Ive yews. Iron vinrol Inapsecionaofccomponent corlaring trWicating oil two. been peroromod "ring correctiveoan pcowanire merreawooo activities.The viaWoinopotions of troo.
-Tko.
wccdd klarlify dagracle c Aodro-eawha, corrosion or crackin3o'cnl tot cold bea~ittrii       a, Ircitoctiv. C1 Arotysis SodI Program POtS ltw a lowttinasbnd I-r th o rtlitcation at dengraeld ocacfiton ech tot ccnrceiona cracking of cor-rorror world bo Iletiwlifed er-l wwel Itro toe ccorrectie action potors Noecordion reports tol dlorajfieddegradorlcourpcro cordliont, owth acrcsono arcracking In. ta icaing cil ervironirnwt, wo Initiatediasa roach of to.s. Irgchtion These pralInspections at PNPS O"ve In ha, cof.co-na   tim . ropection to oincud.
Irpecti0. Prograne 0iltoo0.0ir th..effcir.ero 011the Water and th0, Waler Chernist Control-Closed Cooling Water prograrne.
Tisherno 1.0closedto0110. 37M Sims Itn.
00.010.80(8 storage larit cortai. flud OeW 10 sotect 10 the controls 01f1 theate Charritry Conrold - OWR Program~ the pro00,. applies to11 thelak TI. LtA will beclarifid to wpicilly crad1 the Water Ctanien Cont1rol - B'AR Progan, Inaddtion to PSPM with nwoegng One eflects cofging 1rII.
the codensat 010.05 bl( 5,01000.s aposedbth tr1eaed0010 water. arst,1,0 r.0 Sims the Ore-Ti,,. Inspection (OTi) Progran, Is applicabe to each water charrstry control prograrn 11100Is aloappicoble t0o eachtire 1(0,011that crcnlie,0.
a aercwni00117control progran As see0d In LFIA Table 34. 1, the GreTirsIn.sp0ection Progrer00 Icradled to1 weily ofclons the water chernistry owrol. pr00,orn for tir 1100,.11100. 11.rfeece.l 3 4.14-Th* rectuires anarnordywat 1011. charrisy p000,0n descriptions In LRA Apprdices A anl lB t1o larl Indicate that ft Gr-Tin.
inspeciion Prograrrl wii conf1irm,11 0theti of the Viol, ClWdetrp Cortro1-SMI Viter Ctwneislryd0.001l-Auxiiiry Opel.,.
0.0d the Water Chardstry Conrord-Closed Cooling Water progran..
Th* 110. Is closed 10110. 372 NRC Wen, Poteo WON. Peter PNVPS Lead Fronacrgb.r GrIiwkl, Jac0k PFa 5d 77
 
James Davis-AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 6 1 Number Status Request 354 Closed 34.t-W-0C]
Whf In OTI prosare not crdled for fle inre hew In Table 332-14-35 (wresponing to VILA-I14) thet redeuence e-n 34.1-77 355 Closed (3.4.1-W-0" Wy Is OTI progra not credled for tIre. Hoe iew In Table 122-4, HPCI System (pags 32-49) and Table 12-5. RCIC System, (pge. 32-62) (onrraspondin to V1i E-tO) that rderence ite 341-9?
 
===Response===
During lhe peornemce roetine rreirlenmce onecirenei f
soatin klbicaling oil vieua irepecl" df these oari-owl.
would Idetlity degtaded oowdlienl ti-at sxid beeatribled loan inerfective Ol Aslyss program The corrective action progton at PNPS has alow tireehold lo tIe ntification d degraded wsrdtiio such th-h.tcroson or crackingr c ornlonerts woud be Idrntified as pean oft is proge'n The reiew of crerating tpereice S PNPS fr the last five yrea id iM Identily aew condtion reportsin Iindcted -I nelitecline il aenalysis progeer or
-n Idwrled degeaeld ceyoren I condtilie stch as corosion a cracking Ina libricating oil envireortoiw Tide reviewer d
eracing e.pyiewe at PNPS eneva Inle sifa re-ine Irepection to proetde oordim.,,on d re e d
ecilvuee e
Oil Ataetysi Prog'aeo During t peet five yes. ney visel Irnpechoned comnpormes ontainrng hdhlcing li-heve tees perlorred dxing corrective and preventie rteirene e achvilim. The visuel Inpectione ci ihe oonionels woUIdidetitfy degrade cordtionr sucheas croslm ac cracking ta coLad be attrbied toes Inotelctive Oil Amelytis Progran.
PNPS hm elaw thre*hld Wline I*lwlic*l*on c deg oed conslie-e etch O wroslon w cracking s s*ertwlaens waid bee~litiel aet eue-lloothe wrsctioveaclon progrnoa No condition reports M idart Itied degraded ca-prpst
: ontlionr, eJch s sorstic, t smoracking in Ia lbricating oil envirortret were Initiated esa reeuit of tme lirspeclion. The-e past iWtectio a PNPS e nvelinfie s
croe-inm. Inepecton to proide saoIroorfi c ihe difectivness c tie ail Arnlye[s Program Tie iten Is s*omed o Iten 376, ime the One-Time Inspection (OTI) Pograrn is appcable toech water chseitry weal progrum It ie also applicble eo teh line eis Uzin cruetd a water chetistry coinrol pnogeao LRA Tide 341 tIncatsa O tie One-Time Inspection Prograo Is creited along with the water cheristry wortdcl progeara for line horns bte whychGALL reoiefnds se-hUne Impapection towconirm waler civeistry werld. Taebl 2 creits tie OTIprograin tnvji rderence toft ass*ciated Table I line item Thid redree esanearendent the c&#xa2;eritry progran descriplions IntLRA 4*pudcee Aand Bto clt erly idicae that the Ore-Tine Irepectl* n Progrem willoortirm the dtuectivenues of the Vateu Citestey Ceird-OWR. Water Chen Isy Cotrid-Ami*eruy Sysleres and fe Water Cheoisy Cortrol-Ckoed Coding Wauer progrews Ths id t le cisla to i*edn 372 NRC Wen, Per.
We. Petu PNPS Lead Frortue*rgr.
Frorebarger.
Paw 6d 77
 
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 7 Number Status Request 356 Closed
,l1i-W-O8]
Wy IsOTI proran rot cradted Wo foe e ertiar In Table 312-6, Staion BackoeL Dieds.l (Ogv 13-90) and Tabl 32-6, Securly Dined Geneastor System (page 13-110) (correspordog toVIII,0-15) tl reference iten 341-(10 357 Cloed e
,14l-W-OM WVA Is OTI pograrm ro crated lo thoee lint a*roe In Table a42-2. lMn C-olr er and ISIV L.Wage Pat;ray, Table 332-14-9. Extincfion Ste System Table 332-14-16, HPCI. Tade 3.32-14-18. bln Slent System and Table 3a2-14-1I. OClgre and A*grnarned C11ge Spate t U rdelence ita 34.1-137
 
===Response===
Durirg thte rfortlcere d -ini trairtetw o
aorpo.
-e conlain kibricatirg oil. viaLel Irspections of these conivonos aouid blaniry dejaed cordteis Wet toAd be attriloed loa Ireflecvtie 0i1 Anlysie Prograr The co-rectivo action progoa at PNPS lee a le S
tesidd he W idenfication Vdto-aded wriditio:
such ft! corrosion ow rackingrofdV orporne wodd be Idu-ified aseert po fis program The ravowofdoperating et ierice at PPPS he te last five year. dd rot kdlrifty any conrition reports tl Iredcalted an Inaeotive oil trelyeie program or tat Idanified dograded conp-ar I conditions euch se corrosion or crackirg Inna tirk'icatng oil awirrerr Teis review f operating apariernce al PNPS area In lie V e one-tirre Irepecti-n to provIde nord*drtton of We effectioveens of te Ci Arelysis Program Doring te paet five years, Inaty visual I.pec:ot of ooneotryc s reaingrt brt*fOs cW heoe been perormad rOtWn correcti*e aod prevertive neirta*roe ecivities. The vaiel Inspectiose VI theen otrponaran woaid idaity deg-aded orodltiora euch as coroicln or cracking ea coud bestilosied tow Intlfectlve Cil Anelysi Progrem PNPS lee aloe tfeshld iorthe We krtifiosn o degeded cordloe nsch fl-t corrosion a crackirg of Icortrpevts would be idMrasfied and eel Ineo Whe corrective action progTern Nooordsion reporle tat
*dt Mod de7aded conporte-cotdtions.
ewch asnorroeion or cracking Inn ludicating oil -ihorne wawn (rifilated -sa reattl of te Irapecotme. Thees past Itepetirlm at PNPS e-e In lie. of a cne-i oie irpnton lo proide cordio*rhetiar VIe d
olle enf thWe Oil Anysis Progem TN. taer is closed to felr 376.
SoremWe One-Time Inspection (OTI) Pro7ant Is ap*v-.ate tIo ach waeer chiaristry cornrol progearr ItI s also apidiase bI each line Item Via credits a water chermstry contrd Program (RA Table 33.1 Irdcalta tl Whe One-Time Inpection PFroasm Is craded aorg wit the water ohereiery control ponsgme for Ilne e hoe waich GALL reoorandf e onre-tli Inspectlon to confirm water chwriatry corlrd. Table 2 credits We COI1 progant through rferenrce to fe associsled Table I line iter TNs readree anaeror*rf loe ofthernietry progran doscriptions InLRA Aeaoerce A a-Bto clearly iriscate VW We Gte-Tine Irpecyion Program willcoirm the dinotivene; of We Water Chearitry Corlrot-BW, MtWer Chlarn ry Coradi-Aueiliay -yster.
ard the Water Chetvwriy Control-Cloeed Coding Water proga-ne.
TN. ita Is cloed Io hoart 372 NRC War% Peter Wan Ppter PNPS Lead Proiabarger.
Frotne.W, PIg 7d 77
 
James Davis - AMR -_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 8:1 Number Status Request 35 Clneod 1341-W-101 Sinm. Wan Ward 'C'were ued invariow Tabe 312-14-x line ilens, whch reterenaw 0-34l-14, wyOTl prOca hi bno crediled for Eoee line?
359 Closd
[34.-W-t1]1 Seirde "C8 was wed InTable 33.2-14-4. Condeasate Derineralizer System line ilens, which reference tern 3.41-15. why OTI prograa i.cre ml.twld or thee line?
 
===Response===
Sircem e One-Tirme Inpecti (OTI)Proaar Is applicabe beach water cherAlry contral rorara 1liseso applicable b each limn hen th crodtsawafer cheistry corrol progarn LRATatte 331 Incicae tEato O&#xfd;-Tina Inspection Prag-arn I creadled along withbth water helristry coertrl proeg-m for Jim itane for which GALL recommends awoe-tlam Inspection boewlirm waler chemistry contrd. Table 2 credits to OTI progr-a Uhr refererce lothe aesocialed Tabie I line then Ths reqdreemanamardbt loate cheaialry p-ag-em descrptirs In liA )Apendicen Aand Eto clearly Jndicale OW the One-Timr Impection Program willoorfirm the ecrivete dt the Waler Cernsety Control -*MER. Water Ctshatlry Corcrd - Aailiary Syslern and eat Wafer Chlrde*ry Control - Closed Codirg Watr pro~ragw.
Ths iel
: 1.
lcloed o Item 372 Si the One-Tine hIspeclion (OTI) Proagean Is applicable each wafer c*nealry correl propaanit lie Meo appicabe b eech lIne hem rn credits a waler chairalry control prog-arn IRA Tale
: 33. Indlcale dM the OCw-Thae Inspection Bragem Is cr*eled alon wits. waler chaniety control p-oagare 1r line le for whichGALL rerraxc ewe-67aw Inspection locorirm waler chertniry wontrd. Tabe 2 creits "m OTI frog-am lfrou*
reafereme lothe asacialeod Taibe I line itear The reUire anawrdnrt Ilothe ciherdlry p"egar enweriptiow In IRA A nwdce. A and B bo clery Imicate thnt t On-Time Impection Pro'ag-willcortirm fhe elfeclicerwe d ft Waler Cherelry Cemrl - EWM, Waler Ch**try Conrrcl
* Awiaiary salerM and mhs Waler Chernstry Connrol - Closed Caolir Waler pro'harb.
This ften1 closed boharn 372 NRC Wen. Pale Wen. P.er PNPS Lead Frorebager.,
Fromaergar.
Pb-g 8d 77
 
James Davis - AMR - Reoort to the NRC.doc.pdf Page L
Number Status Request
__0 Closed 134.1-W-121 Scims wlot "awci OCwwo din ITable 342-1A Cadio,"
Sorawge Systoni ard vaic Table 3,a2-14-x line Name witch referenc Htnn 3&IMG&#xfd; wh/ OTt program Is not credited Nor 0-9o tflo?
Mity I. OTO prcgrcs Mw crdedw to, tic.. line Items In T&abl 3A 2-14X Twrbin Oonwattw ar Amiliary Sys[o.
(correpoming ioVIll.A-3) fto referece leron M41-18?
Re#'onae NRC Sims toe COn-Tin, Itoiocticn (OTt) Program I. apocaleto acah Wen, Peter wate ctwrri"y control prgami Ist also egtiCab. lo ch line lion trot retsa.wcon Cicottry comrtol L ATable 33.1 Irdoic tot tOWO One-Tim. Iropoction Prcgram Is creidle along with toe walechmilsry cc,-tro pograns icr Iina It.,e for nItich GALL recmornds a oconetim loportion 10confrmr warer chmlstry control. Table 2creds Ito 07t Program twoocgr referenco to the associated Table I line Item.
Ths rotpira, onawcrmldf to Ow cherctotry Program dw~r~lors In LRA Apperdea, Aarci8 to clearly iricoleto the CO-Timo lrap ionto Prognra wiltcoodirm toe dtcto
, cit.
YA Chorristry Control - BWiR. Wate Ctwnriciry Coircio.Amilwry Syaternen ar-itre Walw Chemistry Corircil - Closed Coding Wftw The it-, 1. closed I to 11-372 Owing ft eop rmnoceof coi 01.no irinowce mcronponens tOw Wrh Peter contan kirricaling cii nitoal Irspections ci Ira, comonentsol ocoi Identiuty dsg'rdod vordtlcr OW acrid baftnitAo lown Ircleitoctil.C Analysis Program The corroti. action Program a POtS Fee slow. threshldd lorto kletficrtiCoi fl citgradel cordior-O owth Mat corrcosio a crackinrg cf corgo-orl. world bo katitiwi a, part di tis Program Tho reiw wof opcherating wprpiocs a[ PONtS Icr tho 1831 In. ywe ld Mo Idonlity r cordiion rep"t "o Ircicotei a, Irinelwfti oil nlysis Program or tot Idlitiriw degraded compa.- I ccrnitioro s~in a, corrosion or cracidng IM& hirriootiry oil wtwimronti. TN. rovecparatin orpwience EA PONtS sras n Ow ofia, co-Urnos Iropati or prmkQci irrrmoiiflc tho Oia~ofa fito Cil Arrolysis Ocirg fto paut Ive yews. Iron vinrol Inapseciona ofccomponent corlaring trWicating oil two. been peroromod "ring correctiveoan pcowanire merreawooo activities. The viaWo inopotions of troo.
3o'cnl wccdd klarlify dagracle c Aodro-eawh a, corrosion or crackin tot cold be a~ittrii SodI a, Ircitoctiv. C1 Arotysis Program POtS ltw a lowt tinasbnd I-r th o rtlitcation at dengraeld ocacfiton ech tot ccnrceion a cracking of cor-rorror world bo Iletiwlifed er-l wwel Itro toe ccorrectie action potors Noecord ion reports tol dlora jfied degradorl courpcro cordliont, owth acrcsono ar cracking In. ta icaing cil ervironirnwt, wo Initiatedi as a roach of to.s. Irgchtion These pral Inspections at PNPS O"ve In ha, cof. co-na.
tim ropection to oincud.
confirmation di toe elloctiverasof. toe Oil Arlysis Prog'ram TN. fIeto Is cloudr to No 376.
confirmation di toe elloctiverasof. toe Oil Arlysis Prog'ram TN. fIeto Is cloudr to No 376.
FIar 9d 77
PRorhobgw.,
PNPS Lead Fmrobergr, FIar 9d 77
 
James Davis-AMR_-_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 10_
Number Status Request
 
===Response===
NRC PNPS Lead 362 CloecI
[341-W-141 Drirng ft p*fow-fce mi reain. mrltlte onoorponef VW War% pglm Frfebfger, flon trckting oil. visual inrpedicnre dye eorolpowes st OTI program nt oradled lot thoe tine enta In would tdottfy degraded cord Itt coWld be aelribwed toan TWde 342-14-35. Tultm Geneatof ard Am iliary System Inctlecilve ail/ *keyds Progrem. The arentive action po*acm al (oorsepordirg io Vitt A-9 wed Vlt.O-3 )itha referene h-em PNPS Ia a low Ctahed lot r " idrtifcation d degraled 34 M-t?
Oondtifo awch Ml coroeion cracking d cw.M s newocd be idefied as paet d s progr-an The raciew di operating pesyweme d PNPS lot u test five yeses tld r.l Idotlity ondtlion ?Wafts Vt tndcaleoe an lreitective cil areysit rogream or Wt Idetdifi dowlej oaen I crdhtot etch - corrsion a oactking ina t&ricaling oil ervtrormsfw. Thes reaiew O operating apertere S PNPS seees In iet olea ore-drm. Impection lo prnoide oorirn-dion ct ftelolottivenee d We Oil Aretysie Progrem Coring f pest live youe.
any visual Irepecticre d oNonaoes OnOtring tfbrtlting Ot htae bean performed "icin corrective mci mcwaive nterarorrce ecttinee The viet Irapapeclt d 11se 9onpoewie woodr Ility degraded contior etch s
comrtion ot cracking W couLd beeasbtrdd loa Inbflective 0it Analysl Progrm PNPS Pas a low fleshd lot Whe Id fiatioston d degraded cordtioe etch IWe oroeton ot cracktngd c oponnesf woUsd belderiflied Wrd aered tnro the coreofiveaction progr*er No ordtion reports ItW Mdalifiel deaded owryrt cojrior, etch as =&#xfd;crin or Cracking toe totitoting ottei oni wee Irtitited asa rtes te d
se ilepeo&#xfd;ttor TThee past irpyctio" at PNPS *-e tn lieu doa ot-Nm ln.pa o Itoo op-ovtde oinrnation dc We effectveness ci We Oil A-etysis Progrant TNs hem Ist osed bltem 373 Alp Tod 77
 
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 11 '1 Number Status 3M Open -
NRC Request 1341-W-151 Table.4.1. bn,,34. I., stee heitntyceed loni,-
coddor PNPS wase Sn Sytern lmkdzown Prog'on "0 "mop~ the egog eflect of Ion. of ntraln doe togeneral.
pittn~ and crevc corrosin hrough the ue dperiodic vistot Inspections. The GALL Report reooninands the, AWo di Abooeground Steel Tn*. Prog'nrn (GALL. )0. M29) to be used WVId te 5.Sysle. Wlkdtown Prograno nry b~e n aceptable efternaot for Aboveground Sledi Tanrs AWd lor Inspectiort thn Abomeground Steel Tit.
NAW has eorn.
prograr ttriLitjee rota ddresed intl., Systen, Waikdhown Progre"" Forexant~ple, the Sysltno Welkdow. Progtym Is silent ten prwlion actions. he the A qotrord Sleel Taink Aid' Imloeso proertn'v hneasure to rniligme corrosion by protecting the sottwti surfaeoefc steed tanks withpain or contings tnnlooedarce with elnoteed Irobustry toacric&
Pleae. ntplain how the prate Iva actions and detection di 84.g 41nt. at Iroconnthte loations euch es I' two, bdottn msoeoe will be pedrolree he the at5ieot twit.. wing the Syster VWolkdofl Aid.


James Davis- AMR_-_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                        Page 10_
===Response===
Number Status Request                                                    Response                                                            NRC       PNPS Lead 362  CloecI  [341-W-141                                                Drirng ft p*fow-         fce reain. mrltlte mi                    onoorponef VW    War% pglm  Frfebfger, flon trckting oil. visual inrpedicnre dye          eorolpowes stOTI program nt oradled lot thoe tine enta In       would tdottfy degraded cord          Itt coWldbe aelribwed toan TWde 342-14-35. Tultm Geneatof ard Am iliary System        Inctlecilveail/ *keyds Progrem. The arentiveaction po*acm al (oorsepordirg io Vitt A-9 wed Vlt.O-3 )itha referene h-em  PNPS Ia a low Ctahed lotr " idrtifcation d degraled 34 M-t?                                                    Oondtifoawch Ml coroeion cracking d cw.M                s newocd be idefied as paetd s progr-an The raciew di operating pesywemed PNPS lot utest five yeses tld r.l Idotlity ondtlion ?Wafts Vt tndcaleoean lreitective cil areysit rogreamor Wt Idetdifi dowlej oaen            I crdhtot etch - corrsion a oactking ina t&ricaling oil ervtrormsfw. Thes  reaiew O operating apertere S PNPS seees In iet oleaore-drm. Impection lo prnoide oorirn-dion ct ftelolottivenee d We Oil Aretysie Progrem Coring f pest live youe. any visual Irepecticre d oNonaoes OnOtring tfbrtlting Ot htae bean performed "icin corrective mci mcwaiventerarorrce ecttinee The viet Irapapeclt d 11se woodr Ility degraded contior etch 9onpoewie                                  s    comrtion ot cracking W couLd beeasbtrdd loa        Inbflective 0it Analysl Progrm PNPS Pas a low fleshd lot WheId fiatiostond degraded cordtioe etch IWe oroeton ot cracktngd        c oponnesf woUsdbelderiflied Wrd aeredtnro the coreofiveaction progr*er No ordtion reports ItW Mdalifiel deaded owryrt cojrior, etch as =&#xfd;crin orCracking      toe totitoting ottei oni wee Irtitited asa rtes dte se ilepeo&#xfd;ttor      TThee past irpyctio" at PNPS *-e tn lieu doaot-Nm ln.pao              Itoo op-ovtde oinrnation dcWe effectveness ci We Oil A-etysis Progrant TNs hem Ist osed bltem 373 Alp Tod 77
NRC PNPS Lead Prevwoive Actios:
Weon Pter Ford Bry*n P0.9Ie coatns warser applied drilngtaloNion or Instrailtion co the estimt tanks well before dcreocpm of agirng rnwenonart proran for license renewal The Syster Waekdown Prog'an isils vistal Inepectiot. of snrel surfaces dcarbon sled oenk to id*ty dograddion of eolings. seeearts.
d caulkinrg plus Indications ofleage The sile correctrie action process wool d retire "umlion and repai., K nacesmy, dldeogradod coaings orcanrihir Deaction d Aging Effects The conrotoe etorage tatk Ise a
-on feelty related cabon eled twtk that contains teeted water. The tank site on a eocrele pod withasand and noI base cuthion that Is designd to reorne rootebte om tn he l om of the tan to nennreze t.e poentlial for coerrelort The ned.ls of the twit wich Nob eskecited to oortinuow welling we pwetod.a Ilyireynced loh corrosion and piting Iudng ir In ib-e ereas (urder water) as docuewled in siteprocedure NES&- TNo*
n en procedure also.inwocts0 I
e erior cmnkir attho basen ofthe tank for cracking Inorder b prevent weter accmilalion ndithen Inwk The proc re iscredited In he Periodic Srell.ce and Prverlivne W1l progetan secttl. 4.17 and Atlachmre 3d LRPO-2 hore tnager-i of the xnternal and Ierred etlrcee of this tWtk Anr degrdyon of the kieteres of the tttk will rese Ina codition report nd an weluation ofthe n tenln ofthe cordltior whichy rW Irvolve dtltasono xnnrinelion to-doienrr remnirnng thickness.
Booma. the onvironrne*, Inidene e to I eidslinicartly hbrt thn the en viro,1 o*nthe unddeside of the twit. irnd degrdnaton wtotd be ntep ed long beo. corroeion onthe odi~d.
N degradation cmcuro the Irede (ircluding en lrm).
amtinetione d the degraded waos would tetyire a delnninrtioe, of the rarniring waot thicldkes wtich mures the itegrily of th itn*
Is nairtained However, o0enoure et significant degradation on the boton ofhel e tak Ihs rotocurring PNPS cm'ti. to pnero rm a ore *0n tieerasco i ticknens Warin*tion Inaoeassitble aess ontre bollo n
of t condenslae tlage twit priort othe priod of Wleadrd operaion Stwarvd wartiration and snrVIing techinigme willbetitlized Thes Is tolnrti number 36 This rtree anareno :re t to the LRA Pbge lld 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                      Page 11 '1 Number Status Request                                                       Response                                                                        NRC      PNPSLead 3M  Open -  1341-W-151                                                    Prevwoive Actios:                                                              Weon Pter  Ford Bry*n NRC Table .4.1. bn,,34. I., stee heitntyceed loni,-          P0.9Ie coatns warser        applied drilngtaloNion or Instrailtion co coddor PNPS waseSn Sytern lmkdzown Prog'on "0                the estimt tanks well before dcreocpm of agirng rnwenonart proran for license renewal "mop~ the egog eflect of Ion. of ntraln doetogeneral.
James Davis.-AMR -Report to the NRC.doc.pdf_.
pittn~ and crevc corrosinhrough the ue dperiodic vistot Inspections. The GALLReport reooninands the,AWo      The SysterWaekdown Prog'an            isils vistal Inepectiot. of di Abooeground  Steel Tn*. Prog'nrn (GALL.)0. M29) to be      snrel surfaces dcarbon sledoenk to id*ty dograddion of used WVId te  5.Sysle. Wlkdtown Progranonry b~en              eolings. seeearts. d caulkinrgplus Indications ofleage The aceptable efternaotfor AbovegroundSlediTanrs AWd lor        sile  correctrie action process  wool  d retire "umlion and repai., K Inspectiort thn AbomegroundSteelTit.      NAWhas eorn.      nacesmy, dldeogradod coaings orcanrihir prograr ttriLitjee rota ddresed intl., Systen, Waikdhown Progre"" Forexant~ple, the Sysltno Welkdow. Progtym Is      Deaction d Aging Effects silent  ten prwlion actions. he the A        qotrord Sleel Taink Aid' Imloeso proertn'v hneasure torniligme            The conrotoe etorage tatk Isea            -onfeeltyrelated cabon eled corrosion by protecting the sottwti surfaeoefc steedtanks    twtk that contains teeted water. The tank site ona eocrele pod withpain or contings tnnlooedarce with elnoteed Irobustry    withasand and noI    base cuthion that Is designd to reorne toacric&                                                    rootebte om tn    he om l    of the tan to nennreze t.e poentlial for coerrelort The ned.ls of the twit wich Nobeskecited to Pleae. ntplain how the prate Iva actions and detection di    oortinuow welling we pwetod.aIlyireynced loh corrosion and 84.g 41nt. at Iroconnthte loations euch esI' two,            piting Iudng irIn          ib-e ereas (urder water) as docuewled in bdottn msoeoe will bepedrolree he theat5ieot twit.. wing      siteprocedure NES&- TNo* en                              I n procedure also.inwocts0    e  erior the Syster VWolkdofl Aid.                                    cmnkir attho basen    ofthe tank for cracking Inorder b prevent weter accmilalion ndithen      Inwk The proc re iscredited In he Periodic Srell.ce and Prverlivne W1l -                  progetansecttl. 4.17 and Atlachmre 3d LRPO-2 hore                        of the xnternaland Ierred tnager-i etlrcee of this tWtk Anr degrdyon of the kieteres of the tttk will rese Ina codition report nd an weluation ofthen tenlnofthe cordltior whichyrWIrvolve dtltasono xnnrinelion to-doienrr remnirnngthickness.
Page 12 Number Status Request  
Booma.the onvironrne*, Inidene eto I eidslinicartlyhbrt thn theen viro,1 o*ntheunddeside of the twit. irnd degrdnaton wtotd be ntep ed long beo. corroeion onthe odi~d.
Ndegradation cmcuro the Irede (ircluding en                lrm).
amtinetione d the degraded waos would tetyire a delnninrtioe, of the rarniring waot thicldkes wtich mures the itegrily of th            itn*
Is nairtained However, o0enoure et significant degradation on the boton ofheletak Ihsrotocurring PNPS cm'ti. to pnerorm a ore*0n                tieerascoi ticknens Warin*tion Inaoeassitble aess ontre bollo of t n condenslae tlage twit priort othe priod of Wleadrd operaion Stwarvd wartiration and snrVIing techinigme willbetitlized Thes Is tolnrti              number 36 This rtree anareno :re t to the LRA Pbge    lld 77


James Davis.-AMR -Report to the NRC.doc.pdf_.                                    .      .-.                        .        ..        .                .                            Page 12 Number Status Request                                                      Response                                                         NRC       PNPS Lead 364 Closud 1341-W-161                                                   ABotting Holity Progrom willbedevoloped OWwilladdrcss fts         Wetn Peter Frortaber.e aglng nagow         of ltitig Inthe op. liLcense renewal.
===Response===
Tabe 34.1. hei 341-2Z. or teel botting and oloae4 tiling wqxsed toar withatemn or water leatagok air -       Th. Bolting logdty Prooei witllbeinerroraiod prior to the period oedioor (edterret). or rirdoor urcodrotils (eaterra,). The     of atteded operation Inaooordence withtowuwtowl otter 3Z aWicart rderernes GALL HerneVIU.H-I ard H-4for Os clswe blting In vario Siestr eod Power Corersion             TH. rectpree anawor, rt       tothe LRA to include decrilion. of SysBen W lised In LRA Tabe 342-1 and332-14-., 1L.             IOnSolting Inlegrity Proga..n InApperndes Aand Btad toiestlFy taken credit tr the Systern AWokdown   Proga-en to enruge     where the prograr Is applicabo Ine agen diect of lossedrneorial. Th. GALL Rerot nnoo d       AM' XtM18, Boltling ineaity Prog*-e wth         T~is item Is closed to itn 373 Indcueo saoorprteheiv boiling Iietog-y progrant as delinretet InNUREG-13W, and Irontry renonmiwdeliora, so dolinseed In Ow EPRI report NP-5769. Poe.. jmsity how ft. addltional atititxes listed InGALLAMPXI M18 tor alngr naenagarwit docawsJ b:ting are adressed Inf.
NRC PNPS Lead 364 Closud 1341-W-161 ABotting Holity Progrom willbedevoloped OW willaddrcss fts Wetn Peter Frortaber.e aglng nagow of ltitig Inthe op.
liLcense renewal.
Tabe 34.1. hei 341-2Z. or teel botting and oloae4 tiling wqxsed toar withatemn or water leatagok air -
Th. Bolting logdty Prooei witllbe inerroraiod prior to the period oedioor (edterret). or r irdoor urcodrotils (eaterra,). The of atteded operation Inaooordence withtowuwtowl otter 3Z aWicart rderernes GALL Herne VIU.H-I ard H-4for Os clswe blting In vario Siestr eod Power Corersion TH. rectpree anawor, rt tothe LRA to include decrilion. of SysBen W lised In LRA Tabe 342-1 and 332-14-., 1L.
IOn Solting Inlegrity Proga..n InApperndes Aand Btad toiestlFy taken credit tr the Systern AWokdown Proga-en to enruge where the prograr Is applicabo Ine agen diect of losse drneorial. Th. GALL Rerot nnoo d AM' XtM18, Boltling ineaity Prog*-e wth T~is item Is closed to itn 373 Indcueo saoorprteheiv boiling Iietog-y progrant as delinretet InNUREG-13W, and Irontry renonmiwdeliora, so dolinseed In Ow EPRI report NP-5769. Poe.. jmsity how ft. addltional atititxes listed InGALL AMP XI M18 tor alngr naenagarwit docawsJ b:ting are adressed In f.
System Wlokdwn Prog-en Ige 12d 77
System Wlokdwn Prog-en Ige 12d 77


James Davis-AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                             Page 13 -1 Number Status Request                                                    Region                                                                  NRC      PNP$ Lecad 3   OPM-   136Z2-N-011                                               Th. PNPS electrical NcPI.AVIE-0t. Insetent 34.1 attic. Iloe              Ng~jw%Owo  StrO.c4lott NRC                                                                coblecorrections(rnealdiopartse).    *An wlonion di thermal InLRA Table3 62.1 tdc, Cablecconnatiocrts     (fltallio   cyclingschntiO hatirU electrical tranaiena, vibration, oharnica parts'. y   aes "Woted that no agig tofftsardno AWIs'1   contarintdio      mwroso andOmcltimoalrercng Ior ito teldtiO roqtAir NUREO-l,1t. Risicl 1.AM' )a.E6'Electrical         part dloottleol cabile    correlcetionliWeetitie c~noag    altooto C.i. Cc~i2"n "a Sdject to10 CFR50.4 Ercir-netwtel 0,colitcation Racid~rctwis spotif. that 0-doe'oot W=ciatld withcables within the sieepal           - Mialolic Parsdelectricaileocableconntections. potertialty expcose c     enWi..patcd~'thsi proqar r~grd...dcOito, to Ileetmi cynlirg td crnrio Nlls ng we thoe. carrtyig Silgntoott
James Davis-AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 13 -1 Number Status 3
                                .noialdwk nh ccii,.empmsoc on~onon. AJo.rdwt 1         current Inpownercstl circtit. Typically.powtercables we Ina peg   107. M ard 257 ofNUREG-I= sTachincol             cortitn-a not fronthe uq~Ay10'thebad Thoew,dothe~
OPM -
B... lan Recsickntothe License Re'newl Gdaroc.           on      11tit' e* pat d.a oti-WWnrnaledr        W        ed.*Ljod1 Dmwwbte     lot wici~ition I nfotrion regorclingAM' (I.E&   agng neagtoret. recieto.
NRC Request 136Z2-N-011 In LRA Table3 62.1 tdc, Cablecconnatiocrts (fltallio parts'. y aes "Wo ted that no agig toffts ardno AWIs'1 roqtAir NUREO-l,1t. Risicl
Ponolia be~. is ~os   ar incknc     moMS withU'. Ion ong Oo,~ei 'or cable ecantectlnotor p'onkle sitwiictioion for
: 1. AM' )a.E6 'Electrical C.i. Cc~i2"n "a Sdject to 10 CFR 50.4 Ercir-netwtel 0,colitcation Racid~rctwis spotif. that 0-doe'oot W=ciatld with cables within the sieepal Wi..
                                                                                        - Th@.mled ohncdcimdtt prodectinedevces 81hig w nitignte strnsO wnoond" witheletrol faiLts ard Itrsionuits orart.
c en patc d~' thsi proqar r~grd...dcOito,
wN an AW 1. n. necessary.                                In ackuilor4 rrohaicn l cutreaasicittt with electricolhLlAs Is rot condble a~ng rnuehonim beoo. di the tlnwtrcl-ecy di
.noialdwk nh ccii,.empmsoc on~onon. AJo.rdwt 1 peg 107. M ard 257 ofNUREG-I=
                                                                                          =weonece ke acchlotiti Thedeorei       electricaltransients    wor'd applicbeaicc'crcear.
sTachincol B... lan Recsickn to the License Re'newl Gdaroc.
* MatioicWe d.Olctroli.Icali Oo                   wel icceeo~d lovibratIcn we Ithon, iseotiaetn with wliv eeewonatthat caoa vibration, Booaa Ity we p.1 dnancmei            ooerponuni they wet rM cotwlo 10egg  r--wQ s           -1teli
Dmwwbte lot wic i~ition I nfotrion regorcling AM' (I.E&
                                                                                        *Cetroech~caieoiia.n SoleclIn cas a .dftiarpltS.
Ponolia be~.
Reltin el"           cori enicinerdals dd..                   IooaretenaItuitlo plar Wirting.tben cotr dotrn plantS       apeticon Sucth     a releae.atd Isaloects. wotocibew en t M~l       On fclet c aieo Irtewclition, their locaim nsride ectiveconpwootcs protects Ithernitiloe potts dielootrielcolic coe tin'sronmetotnrchone Thereforetis croncot   1. en apilicable,
is ar
                                                                                          *Oxcidatimn-     ooerononmuetocyoccur Inth' pretnce d tro~tire a ortaffiroition etcohae Irdolusotr   poehtIonst ctd coit dopoeitis.
~os incknc ong moMS with U'. Ion Oo,~ei  
Etolocone. on mlic.icnideriols proe"draltrl connections front nnvituro, or oceerrnatiton.
'or cable ecantectlnot or p'onkle sitwiictioion for wN an AW 1. n. necessary.
Stern boned connections weeconsideredpott di an ctli,* dnice ard :a n'rtei" nd by the lart briroenonoo Ruleprograr, Owee wec noagig efltnts ro*4ring trocorrctt lot bolted oort'.otiot'. d coble Smnteo Since PNPS uirtoic'. cable connectoo'.tattlera ccerc neaitiew         progrant ard tean o itictio doan a~gir n=tido dot 10 ncceconnections..nto                 Is nccedo In witiohn to1the Wrtwottc* Rtle progran&#xfd; Fb, 13d 77
Region Th. PNPS electrical NcPI. AVIE-0t. In setent 34.1 attic. Iloe coble corrections (rnealdio partse).
*An wlonion di thermal cyclings chntiO hatirU electrical tranaiena, vibration, oharnica contarintdio mwroso and Omcltimo alrercng Ior ito teldtiO part dloottleol cabile correlce tionliWeet itie c~noag altooto
- Mialolic Parsdelectricaileo cable conntections.
potertialty expcose to Ileetmi cynlirg td crnrio Nlls ng we thoe. carrtyig Silgntoott current In powner cstl circtit. Typically. powter cables we Ina cortitn-a not fronthe uq~Ay 10' thebad Thoew,dothe~
on 11tit' e* pat d.a oti-WWnrnaledr W
ed.*Ljod 1 agng neagtoret.
recieto.
- Th@.m led ohn cd cimdtt prodectine devces 81 hig w orart.
nitignte strnsO wnoond" witheletrol faiLts ard Itrsionuits In ackuilor4 rrohaicn l cutrea asicittt with electricol hLlAs Is rot condble a~ng rnuehonim beoo. di the tlnw trcl-ecy di
=weonece ke acch lotiti Thedeorei electrical transients wor'd applicbeaicc'crcear.
* MatioicWe d.O lc troli.Icali Oo wel icceeo~d lovibratIcn we Ithon, iseotiaetn with wliv eeewonat that caoa vibration, Booaa Ity we p.1 dn ancmei ooerponuni they wet rM cotwlo 10 r--wQ egg s  
-1teli
*Cetroech~caieoiia.n SoleclIn cas a.dftiarpltS.
Reltin el" dd..
cori enicinerdals Ioo aretena Ituitlo plar Wirting. tben cotr dotrn plantS apeticon Sucth a releae. atd Isaloects. wotoci bew en t M~l On fclet c aieo Irtewclition, their locaim nsride ective conpwootcs protects Ithe rnitiloe potts dielootrielcolic coe tin'sronmetotnrchone Thereforeti s croncot 1. en apilicable,
*Oxcidatim n -
ooeronon muetocy occur In th' pretnce d tro~tire a ortaffiroition etcoh ae Irdolusotr poehtIonst ctd coit dopoeitis.
Etolocone.
on mlic.ic nideriols proe"draltrl connections front
: nnvituro, or oceerrnatiton.
Stern boned connections we econsidered pott di an ctli,* dnice ard :a n'rtei" nd by the lart briroenonoo Rule prograr, Owee wec no agig efltnts ro*4ring trocorrctt lot bolted oort'.otiot'. d coble Smnteo Since PNPS uirtoic'. cable connectoo'. tattlera ccerc neaitiew progrant ard tean o itictio doan a~gir n=tido dot 10 ncce connections.. nto Is nccedo In witiohn to1the Wrtwottc* Rtle progran&#xfd; NRC PNP$ Lecad Ng~jw% Owo StrO.c4 lott Fb, 13d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                               Page 14 1 Number Status   Request                                                         Response                                                            NRC        PNPS Lead 30   Acceped   13622-N-124                                                     As shown by the OE (Operiing Experience) cited In    eNs imsstor%  Nguyeci D. Sou4 Mk.
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 14 1 Number Status Request 30 Acceped 13622-N-124 In LRATdse 3,62-1 mde hig voltage Inudalor (SBO), you have al ted noaging offeic and no Ao Is r*iy,.dr You bathe itaed In Section 36222 dfo I.RA. thea PNPS 1. locald now, the ea o wk.. selt*raay Is coaidored How-.m salt Wpay oildUp Isa shorl-ler.
filashoverdue to salt oontatneifo nof insaators Is cased by In LRATdse 3,62-1 mde hig voltage Inudalor (SBO), you             eents. lyttcally ato-m. regaedess of t. ageo the Irsdators.
Coten based on local weeath cordtions (woot driveo)
have al ted     noaging offeic and no Ao Is r*iy,.dr           ThesIs cloerly rd      11.ctS aging Therdore s&rlace You bathe itaed In Section 36222 dfo I.RA. thea                   eortarrnaction lord anapp floos aging eschnronm for PNPS 1. locald now,the ea o         wk.. selt*raay Is           hitp->dage Ifreaors at PNPS sitho Ithecdition ls caused by coaidored How-.m salt Wpay oildUp Isa shorl-ler.                 seies weate conditiorn =crelated I*o agi ancaging mreege Coten based on local weeath cordtions (woot driveo)               progrom lar aKVcrla to address tlhl            - fcetHowWe. Wuile Therdooe. you huve concluded lhit Lautace cordaniruso Is         Salt sway loihdipi s afet-lerm cncesn beasedonloal wpedar nol enalricable aging in'ctsism lor high voltage               condit.n (wert-drlven). aCh bldup eancase pr0fern with the Irudelorsat PNPS.                                                 oftae power s'Wy ystleo Boca-e Sea operating siperieure, PNPS heas -liled Sylgead (RTV silicwie) cairg ooorne NUREG t800 RAw. 1. Standard Rolaw Plan lor Revliow               awictyean Irsiatoas loroues flasaliva. The addition d Sylgeid to
Therdooe. you huve concluded lhit Lautace cordaniruso Is nol enalricable aging in'ctsism lor high voltage Irudelors at PNPS.
[k-       Rocal Aplicalionlot N.1-, Pa.w. Pl1,                     to k.l-ator      In At                              lhan hai liktlihdoodd lraifakur      r.
NUREG t800 RAw. 1. Standard Rolaw Plan lor Revliow
Section 36222 ideltified degradation of high voltage ilrdalot Inpaeeoc. S salt deposits or   mUfiac.                 Systeonwalkdowm we perfornmd at least eone par raluding cycle ocrtandtwo       Vats. arorn. ciderls             ih sdoalu     aid we r*Wrery pelf'raid emnsIrs**tly todo a visual Imrpetion salt ane Indrtrial S"lu'ed car ooarniane Imsia,                   S toe ultwtcy*sdhIi-**lage ilsualors Vlst me Ir-ccoe of s-faces A large loalap, odconweiretion crities the               loese renewal Inacoodanc. with EN-DC-178 These walkdewn oomnLlor voltage o track Wong fth swlace eno           beeiyaid will*otitus Iiobe perloreil into tie pwiod of elendcd        eagaino on lead to Ilaor     flash oer. Surface 0ortannnaion can beproblar Inareea where flies we garear coeoaration of asrbarner p.ttle. such as h     lacilitiss tist dicherge cod     LRPD-02 win be revised asfollows:
[k-Rocal Aplicalion lot N.1-, Pa.w. Pl1, Section 36222 ideltified degradation of high voltage ilrdalot In paeeoc. S salt deposits or mUfiac.
o* nor U luas oast whe.e salt eprey I. preodeMt. Irdtty           The SysternWalkdown Program will brevised IoInclude ft vi"al apageding ecprileme Identified to potential of loseof olsilte     Irnpeclion of Nhvilotage Irtialo rein-acape of llcene renewal.
ocrtandtwo Vats. arorn.
Power "u lont dcposieion Poswibchyardieuiatot. On MIDech 17. Ite, Crystal RiveUt a3sepericed aloss ol th 2 kVecitolyrd (wnr           offtsilepower to sady-rdale d losase) when a lipht rain caued icirngacross sait-ladtn 232 iVinuailor and opened brais             Inn witclylard in March 1993. the Brursick Unit2 switchyard poerorcd s lash cerSofeons hifvollage Iraniakors The lncierl was crilboed loe witer steorm In th **       Sim*r OZ Pilgrim st.tic has alsoIseperienced s-eda Ios dollsts power eoeos when weon storem dPositel salt onlthe 345 kV swilchyar oaasing the inidalor toare logruand In lidh S ihese Indalry and plait opedat ing erpriencrs, proeide f.iticaion ofuty iAM'P la m( necssary, Pay 14d 77
ciderls ih sdoalu salt ane Indrtrial S"lu'ed car ooarniane Imsia, s-faces A large loalap, od conweiretion crities the oomnLlor voltage o track Wong fth swlace eno beeiy aid on lead to Ilaor flash oer. Surface 0ortannnaion can beproblar Inareea where flies we garear coeoaration of asrbarner p.ttle. such as h lacilitiss tist dicherge cod o* nor U luas oast whe.e salt eprey I. preodeMt. Irdtty apageding ecprileme Identified to potential of lose of olsilte Power "u lont dcposieion Poswibchyard ieuiatot.
On MIDech 17. Ite, Crystal RiveUt a3sepericed aloss ol th 2 kV ecitolyrd (wnr offtsile power to sady-rdale d losase) when a lipht rain caued icirng across sait-ladtn 232 iVinuailor and opened brais Inn witclylard in March 1993. the Brursick Unit 2 switchyard poerorcd s lash cerSof eons hifvollage Iraniakors The lncierl was crilboed loe witer steorm In th **
Sim*r OZ Pilgrim st.tic has alsoIs eperienced s-eda Ios dollsts power eoeos when weon storem dPositel salt onlthe 345 kV swilchyar oaasing the inidalor toare logruand In lidh S ihese Indalry and plait opedat ing erpriencrs, proeide f.iticaion ofuty iAM'P la m( necssary,


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                        Page 15 Number Status  Request                                                              Response                                                             NRC        PNPSLead 367  Cleat    13622-N-031                                                        AJ PNPS, bw tobt c**ecti*s wre waodod Ireland of boiled                Nguyen. Owo  Sroud4 Mile Switchyard bate ae cornn-oted      by fltible con'oiots totaicolors In LRA,Table 362-4, udor swittchyrd ba and                          ad tiac c ateoront . Sinceawithanid buo is typicaly ladeora connectionr, pc y      aohsstaIedtha hooing dfils reoqirinl          cstantr lad lberanal cyctingthal oodLdcaase torque relacolion Is engorat ard MAW lasqiredA NUREG tBM. Re 1.                         Irfreuert. With roooaectiaos lowlratirgeapellna, *ibrationis Standard Rootw Plan for Review of Ucaes Renewal                    na amaing siachanism Ia switchiyardbts. The switchyard Application Ior Ncsleo, Power Plat, Sectioc 36223                  on-csot s to thb otartp trasftrnr se pert of the active Idklifios Ios odpreload Is an aging afect for switlchyard          esattby rnitrianed by the plar srairlesrce progra            Thdrore.
===Response===
bul corretons. Toqe toaxaaton fir bolted connection Is              toriquerelaxatiorn Is ha ana*ing lst rairilng fftnr*aga          hoa a concern for totchyardbus correctionr and trasaission              switctyard bat orotdctor cor-ections. An sledtricacorwtion coat be designed to remaian tig sandrratan good              fodlithvity    Inatdtili    ternogrpy hI performad at test or0e wary6 orthe Outa large learperalre range. Moding aIs deign                    tornsiktan An irsogrity oft tscorroctiron The progisecwitl rqurae.l        tdilfficift *n serald specified Wtthe bolt          cortir    IntroAn peiod of letaadedcpraon and An couctor are difterel and have diffren raiet of taron eyaowio.         For ewrsa      copper o      ur.al w,
As shown by the OE (Operiing Experience) cited In eNs imsstor%
bul/cordsioor        Wnerialsspelrd Mast. thet mswt boting itdocole    Ih.arS stiess isadded tostr-sse Icrre al ass..tY, An jori atbers or last-ers can ield S plastic deforuation            th wre dring      ersallodig (i.e.
filashover due to salt oontatneifo nof insaators Is cased by eents. lyttcally ato-m. regaedess of t. age o the Irsdators.
hietqP) whan ta connectioncoos. tPe ()or willtbeaose EPRI docmerat TR-10421Z Bdted Joinit lorerswce &
Thes Is cloerly rd 11.ct S aging Therdore s&rlace eortarrnaction lord anapp floos aging eschnronm for hitp->dage Ifreaors at PNPS sitho Ithe cdition ls caused by seies weate conditiorn =crelated I*o agi ancaging mreege progrom la r a KVcrla to address tlhl fcet HowWe. Wuile Salt sway loihdipi s af et-lerm cncesn beased on loal wpedar condit.n (wert-drlv en). aCh bldup ean case pr0fern with the oftae power s'Wy ystleo Boca-e Sea operating siperieure, PNPS heas -liled Sylgead (RTV silicwie) cairg o oorne awictyean Irsiatoas loroues flasaliva. The addition d Sylgeid to to k.l-a tor In At hai liktlihdood d lraifakur lhan r.
Agppicatio*t&W          rscocr*,ads I.tec ion ofblted 1*di.
Systeon walkdowm we perfornmd at least eone par raluding cycle aid we r*Wrery pelf'raid emns Irs**tly todo a visual Imrpetion S toe ultwtcy*sd hIi-**lage ilsualors Vlst me Ir-ccoe of loese renewal Inac oodanc. with EN-DC-178 These walkdewn will*otitus Iio be perloreil into tie pwiod of elendcd eagaino LRPD-02 win be revised as follows:
or evidence dof-ehalir          signs d blring r disolorsici, ad Irdlcalion d toes hods Pmoide adecasior.i.                  twl Iorqe reFoato fIr boiled carootcion ofwilchyard bus is no a conern fir PNPS.
The Systern Walkdown Program will brevised IoInclude ft vi"al Irnpeclion of Nhvilotage Irtialo rein-acape of llcene renewal.
368  Closed  13622-N-04]                                                        The preferred e-         of oWtait.power oron        Aftics345kV        Ngyt,, Die  Strood Mks swithyard The foodfrt Ahen        awilctyard Ieoaens. 352-2 and 3523A In LRA. Section 36 223. y- hamesltatec t            PNPS doe        betds by switctard beobth startp Ira*a*aner, X4, and Pa ri Silize trarwmissionconodctors inlhe circwits lor                berds by owcrgoiwnd cobeasboth eddey basa In te plart The reocay d Staita pow. lotionig amSO. Decrie 1*0                        talecateollsito power aouce cone freornft23kV awilchyard ad reovery Ipae-a fIr PNPS. Cortirm that nortaraftnsion                trews tIos breaerc 252 by unodlargoud* cables lobe shuAdown coidCtora asretlized In the circwts fhr recovery peths.             trareforna. X13,ad ha by crodrgrwod calete bobls A8. Fretn Sllcqt thleearasws with a              .main ow line dagrats            ASftn lpowe troeas bycrorgicun d cables tothe sedy blaeiasin the pIf. Neithr PNPS recovery path for offtite power wee trardesorion ocroctors These palhaastohw onFigos l25- od AneIRA Ifa 15d 77
NRC PNPS Lead Nguyeci D.
Sou4 Mk.
Pay 14d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.Ddf                                                                                                                                      Page 16 1 Number Status     Request                                                 Response                                                      NRC        PNPS Lead 39 Closed    13612-N-c6                                              ASPNPS. the station blackout deed goneat or provides the      Ng.ye.x Dwc  Ssroud Mle alterrtseAC power source. Al SSC associaledwithhe AAC desed ae Inacope lor license renewal. Te LRA proide the Slxttee. art VOW-aee (SSC*) relied mI. eddoy              h m-goWel rariew ruLets forlo-ivedt passive SSCS song ervitysee er pieri evaluation topw.*ca furclin diet    aessodatel with fet AC power seuce In each decipline secton
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 15 Number Status Request 367 Cleat 13622-N-031 In LRA, Table 362-4, udor swittchyrd ba and connectionr, pc y
: d. . ,,.de ecevirew with teo            "Ohesde        cithe LRA cegddnee kaetdiontieehvd(IOCFR5063) wewliothe scoe CiUow. r              VOW1lyour atrrsdo ac (MAC)
aohs staIed tha hooing dfils reoqirinl engorat ard MAW lasqiredA NUREG tBM. Re 1.
                                      ... c    Weo I. Od S80 requiremntse?Areall 20Cs (irchdrg sdodricet o-onpwwls) es-ieode wth AhC ewcaa lrehetel in th. scope,of licensee renewal? Kt0" weed  not,mlan wPV Mn. N tOW wer p-oide an AM fhe Iorg-liro paesive S9Cc associafedwi~thttwAC sources.
Standard Rootw Plan for Review of Ucaes Renewal Application Ior Ncsleo, Power Plat, Sectioc 36223 Idklifios Ios od preload Is an aging afect for switlchyard bul corretons. Toqe toaxaaton fir bolted connection Is a concern for totchyard bus correctionr and trasaission orotdctor cor-ections. An sledtrica corwtion coat be designed to remaian tig sand rratan good fodlithvity Outa large learperalre range. Moding aIs deign rqurae.l t dilfficift *n serald specified Wtthe bolt and An couctor are difterel and have diffren raiet of taron eyaowio.
370    Accoplal  [3022-N-06                                              The PNPS IRASeti- 3622 willbereoised ra          reeaIdlowt. Ngwner Duc  Strou*lAke
For ewrsa copper o ur.al w,
                                                                                            *Sorne f tme p1endraionessenliee at PNPS are rut EQ The Are all electricat erd t&Ccordarivcl psenhatinta 20? I rce-EO penetraton aseetblies aweaubject boagirgnenree t rid. prcIde Ah~s ard AWs for ton.EO electrical areSt&C  ereiew.The aftf meregmenwl review is procidel InAMRE.01 ar-ecrtatirw,erl  penelralion.TheAlsWettri Ircitoe  bthl  me  AWP fo pentaton assertly pigels Is provided Inthe non-EQ organc ( I.PE. XLPO. arx! SF1trierat coni~clorlogla I    Insulated caebes erd conectiora proamrn will marege te gng Ingieson etc..) as wailta fnoerro etwerialC-oh as        dffectsof ft penetration Merty cabse ard conections. Tabel cabeilattrs. spoxejee pctting conypoerds,correcto, pcin. 362-1 Ictludes    mhe selciced pnrelclion eCoxdutor ard plugs,areStold gwonende).                               cornnections In the lir tetmfor electrical cabes and coreeion Mr e.*ject 1o0t0 CFR 50.49 -EQ.
bul/cordsioor Wnerials spelrd Mast. thet mswt boting itdocole Ih.arS stiess isadded tostr-sse Icrre al ass..tY, An jori atbers or last-ers can ield S plastic deforuation wre dring th ersal lodig (i.e.
The tntural repon for  he k connmtliee, AMWCC6,acdresses the penot-aoen esser"      cortponeri, aeds are seding dests that mhe horm radological ortrol berrierher cotlaitrert InhTatle 352-1.
hietqP) whan ta connection coos. tPe ()or willtbeaose EPRI docmerat TR-10421Z Bdted Joinit lorerswce &
The reiree aneamrdcre        some lILRA Pba 16d 77
Agppicatio*t &W rscocr*,ads I.tec ion of blted 1*di.
or evidence dof-ehalir signs d blring r disolorsici, ad Irdlcalion d toes hods Pmoide adecasior. i.
twl Iorqe reFoato fIr boiled carootcion of wilchyard bus is no a conern fir PNPS.
368 Closed 13622-N-04]
In LRA. Section 36 223. y-hame sltatec t PNPS doe ri Silize trarwmission conodcto rs in lhe circwits lor reocay d Staita pow. lotionig am SO. Decrie 1*0 reovery Ipae-a fIr PNPS. Cortirm that nortaraftnsion coidCtora asre tlized In the circwts fhr recovery peths.
Sllcqt thleearasws with a
.main ow line dagrats


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                    Page 17 1 Number Status    Request                                                        Response                                                             NRC        PNPS Lead 371  Closed    [G331.-P-0t                                                    Section 14 Irldoh al ,110. yl.te- Iveol      Iht*ootd functicns      Paod, Eraec  Frombergr, th out 10CFR 544(a)(2) or ty*hsical Irneraction To IOicale Tabls a33214-1 throuh 33aZ4.35 adress non-saelny                IndvivW eystm IncludedIn the rg n-garnore* rensw for reatedcwn'oSnereaffecting seaty relted .stgrne                  (a)(2),Tade 332-14 Is$,1bcllvded by syslem For exanpl*, Taole H -owe  r. these 1..le. ads*... II sal h systems Inection      332-14-1 Is for h cir(culatingwater sysltem a syste mWolOh only 33%  Aoiliary Systerms. w.0.0                on these systers Owns,                   e. cor*pornertsIncludedlor (a)(2). For th cre mseWy system, bdeon tosecton 32. ESF Systeon. and section 34, Seett          Tale 332-14-7 shows thenne crts          Included foh (a)(2)t K since "l Power Cwersion (S&PC) System. Tables 3314-7.                to systmn hi also Inscop. he other reasons. Table 332-2 shows 14-16. 14-25, ad 14-28 we lor sysbem tal belotg to              theowponens Inctludedh544(a)(1) and(a)(3)
===Response===
Section 32 ard tables 3314-1. 14-Z 14-5.149. 1410.
AJ PNPS, bw to bt c**ecti*s wre waodod Ireland of boiled Switchyard bate ae cornn-oted by fltible con'oiots totaicolors ad tiac ateoront c
14-11. 14-17. and 14-.Ire8      [or systern that belong to      The argin mananeentr review of the eystn. tW hwee fuecions Section 34 The Toble I Ifte referece also specifies              OUsmot IOCFR 54 (a)(2) f phyica fInteraction, was done Table 321 ard341. The af.l report and the SE we                  eparately from the r-iew otfethen. with irnended furcio      that based on.ysterns sadedli          InGALL Repor sectin. f            IOCFR 1o 0      044 (&)(t)or (a)(3). The redcs dotis review were ESF, Adiliary. aod S&PC systoes. As written in the IRA, it      presented seperatelyso Owl they oomld be reviewed eepaaeldy on will rn0e the audt report and SER corfusing beca.se to          th bssi. Otphysi*e 1proirrity ralhe *tn yster furclionr TH*
Sincea withanid buo is typicaly ladeora cstantr lad lberanal cyctingthal oodLd caase torque relacolion Is Irfreuert. With roooaectiaos lowlratirge apellna, *ibrationis na amaing siachanism Ia switchiyard bts. The switchyard on-csot s to thb otartp trasftrnr se pert of the active esattby rnitrianed by the plar srairlesrce progra Thdrore.
ESF syslemnswciOn 32 write- will irclude Tables from            0tOwsa reniewer toclearly delingish which componret ty"e. In.a section 3.3oand the SPC yet-            section 34 wrie-q will  system were irlucded for t0CFR 04 4(a)(2) hoe"*siael Ireractiono kwIrde Taeles from.eclion 33 Different relmenewrite              Since moet of these. yster re eiliary syst-n they were added theae sections.                                                 as paet oftt swiliafy Nysles section Piassejustify whythe rn-,-sde.y sytlerm assocliled with ESF and S&PC systernm wre lnclued Inthe Aemillary system leactirt 372  Accepted  1Q33 1-P-02                                                    Since the Ce-Ticr Inspection (OT1)Pfonn Is oyli*bl.*e boeach          Petd. Erach Fgo.-.
torique relaxatiorn Is ha ana*ing lst rairilng fftnr*aga hoa switctyard bat Inatdtili ternogrpy hI performad at test or0e wary6 orthe tornsiktan An irsogrity oft tscorroctiron The progisec witl cortir In tro An peiod of letaaded cpraon The preferred e-of oWtait. power oron ftics A 345kV swithyard The foodfrt Ahen awilctyard Ieoaens. 352-2 and 3523A betds by switctard beo bth startp Ira*a*aner, X4, and Pa berds by owcrgoiwnd cobeas both eddey basa In te plart The talecate ollsito power aouce cone freorn ft23kV awilchyard ad trews tIos breaerc 252 by unodlargoud* cables lobe shuAdown trareforna. X13, ad ha by crodrgrwod calete bobls A8. Fretn ASftn lpowe troeas by crorgicun d cables tothe sedy blaeias in the pIf.
water cheristry Cortrol programr it i also applicabe lo each line Di.screpncy between Tale 331 fine item. and Tables              ItecmOhacredits a water chetestry cortl program IRA Toble 332-X Ior thoe lim    nle      111Wcredt water cherl*etry owal  331 Itotaoeo tht to One-Tirm Inspection Progarn Is credted analysi. programnan      a verilficalionprogram such a          along with the water chenistry cntrol prograns hetline Ite, hr on.rtimeInspeclion (OTI) program The Taell I itemtI          whch GALL recorMneds aoornoime Inspection to ortirm water cositern with theGALL reporl "ndcorrecty creits the              chornisry corrd, Table 2 credits to OTI program through charn'try proeani and the OTI progeam or lor pdart-epecilfc      reference tothe associated Taole I line hlem progrtm lesocredts chlrwstry and OTI programs. However.
Neithr PNPS recovery path for offtite power wee trardesorion ocroctors These palha astohw onFigos l25-od Ane IRA NRC PNPS Lead Nguyen. Owo Sroud4 Mile Ngyt,, Die Strood Mks Ifa 15d 77
the Table 2 line Itenr th reerence these Table I line            This ruorcrese naerndne*r    totho cohrrsry progoa.r dloscriptiors Ite do not cmr0tthe OTt pogran The.. Table 2 tine              InLRA AppendicesArad B1to clearly Indicate " the One-Time hen. however h.0e &Imro. 'N, or 'C'w~ch slel. t1 it            Inspection Program willconrirm te effectivrenes ofthe WtVoer 1I consisterl with the M.AP cobination inth. GALL                Chenristry Control - BMi. Witor Chenristry Conrlrd - Auxiliary Systrne*ond the Water Chernistry Cortrot - Closed Cooing Water pron*rre.
Plea.e tusli17 why the OT progra Is      1ot crdled inTable
: 2. een th'ough I is creadled In Table I and Wrote A ilonies totea consitency with GALLfor MAP ooenirelior, Page 177d77


James Davis - AMR- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                Page1*81 Number Status Request                                                       Reponse                                                          NRC          PNPS Lead M7~  Acepte jG3.31-P-03                                                    ABcitirg Irlogrity Progranr willbedelocped Ot wllttmaasa Ith      patel. Erach  Frcabarg.r, agrng n                          r ao of bagla inthei        f license reerwal A PNPSdoes rel IrcntneBoiing      Q k1ogrtyProgmran    InthaLRA. copyct      a    rrtaea nml progra baasisdoc    d n      Ir to howwar credta Cittm progmrarnWalternate lo the bohingr        Wtirg Ilegrity Programwillbelproided lor raiso with ft LIRA Integrity progrann The GALLRqxdr AM' )O.M18,Bolting IrWaity, Prograrprwio. solaran ma    eoyarci            othe s In' 10-slmn,w11 usohion spec~iicalyraoorom-midion                  The Bootirg hriagty Progart willbaintrpl~or prior oothe priod asotaoolod  with preventive 0330,, such as selection di        d wdrtao operation Inraccocnk        with coartrtitle rl-rdtm 3Z bolting rnstaril, weaofcibr Ii      ardo -Mc ants arol witittional reo-r-witions of NUREO-139 Borne di the            Thlarequirsaaarnamamerr lotha LRAbtrclude doscriptionsca afttrrmtaprogratrtray beaaooapito forlpecolion                tI- Boltirnghorgty Progatr InA*g*dca                  m oidtnity Aarsd Bard h-...OWa dranot0wkires. Ith prtwenthro        action.-        wheroatha prograc Isapplieable Plasnaclarifytow PNiPS      trade threserooonwtw~ordil whan w.ing attarrate,prograns, wrplease cracit a Botilin Iteria~tyProgrn forthe  t variotaT~o 22line    Herne    as appropriateFor section    a3, tis applieoITabl S33.II.ln it-a 3.1- 19. 3.3.1-27.      3.3.1-4Z.
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.Ddf Page 16 1 Number Status Request 39 Closed 13612-N-c6 Slxttee. art VOW-aee (SSC*) relied mI. eddoy ervitysee er pieri evaluation to pw.*ca furclin diet
a3.1-43, 331-5%,ar 311-711 374  A ..ple 1T.3&1-P-0tt                                                  Asdined In 10 CFR 543, a TLAAIn aIIoaeea calculation or            Paid, Erach  Fincrn, Ron analysis that. roMr coa things, Involves fi&#xfd;-lirritwl T~alll33?. Rom3111. 1orstolecrns withmagang                    saamptiora defined by the currern operating term TheoreIn afftofl curvooorwiifatiu Idia-agr.g      tha GALL raconrarnb    anatysia for sled crams. alPNPS that aatisfies theddirlitiorn TIA to be wcahatod for satvretura gilrsdo-   i rt.     Tha  CMA-70 dcefineaallowable stresa range blasd ojniot category dacrasronaotio.Zsates. a-attis lineItentwasnot wed In          and sarvice class SeMce class Is batnl on load class (r.an
: d..
                                .aaction 33, however st." ca.- maretwatale 1.n*action            etilve load Lador)a"f rtbw d cycles.
,,.de ecevirew with teo "Ohesde cegddnee kaetdiontieehvd(IOCFR5063) wewliothe scoe Ci Uow.
35 Tact, 35.2-2 aci &S52.4 atkkaaa Grin.. b1Ak, an a~rgeffedtlcib.dciWetrials. C-Arrald alg-o danaga              Howa... thenr.o ci        f yclea I. NOT basad on 4 yaws of of cranesaisrcmwfsee  aoal ainsetion  35 r tnl n TLAA          operation dtIis crane The arlicitpted cyctaa for th PNPS reactor section 4.7(4art1specificTLAA).iAlo saoTLA queation.            bildg cena . we watl belaon anyof th cycle rangas gvar In CMAA*7Q Based o-realistic atirratae arid11- htoriol rataeo we odth r"an.. oa.          a-a PNPS reactor blilrng ar kratir Pleasaalpyben    wheratisa lineHannas  addressed  Intih RA    .lk.dg cr*me would take ovr- 350 yanrs to reach It. rrirruc cycle range for CMA.A-70.Comewaryay tro Is no TLAA associated with a"      load cycles.
r VOW 1 lyour atrrsdo ac (MAC)
Fagel8d 77
... c Weo I. Od S80 requiremntse? Are all 20Cs (irchdrg sdodricet o-onpwwls) es-ieode wth AhC ewcaa lrehetel in th. scope, of licensee renewal? K t0" weed
: not, mlan wPV Mn. N tOW wer p-oide an AM fhe Iorg-liro paesive S9Cc associafed wi~thttw AC sources.
370 Accoplal
[3022-N-06 Are all electricat erd t&C cordarivcl psenhatinta 20? I rid. prcIde Ah~s ard AWs for ton.EO electrical areS t&C ecrtatirw,erl penelralion. The AlsWe ttri Ircitoe bthl organc ( I.PE. XLPO. arx! SF1 trierat coni~clorlogla I Ingieson etc..) as wailta fnoerro etwerial C-oh as cabe ilattrs. spoxejee pctti ng conypoerds, correcto, pcin.
plugs, areS told gwonende).


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                          -Page 19 1 Number Status  Request                                                  Response                                                            NRC         PNPS Lead 375  Closd    Ti3ll-P-O]                                              Sme the Owe-Tims Inspection (OTI) Program Is aplicae to.ech          Paid,e rach  Frosbager, water cherniwry corcrd progan, it ls also applicable to ach line Tabled.1, hean311-5, lorkhS exchanger eiposed bo          hoen M crdles a water chlanstry carcl progranm LRATate tr=d wafer G C (I40F), dascusaion oald. that OTIwl        331I Inrdateio a  tin. Ons-Tiws Wpection Program I credited be wed ai vrification programfor wao cl-han"iry.          along witheiv, water chearaitry co*r*r progras for line hers Sr lonelIosnelai In Table 332-3 where iem lcwwer.
===Response===
l:,                                        whmchGALL r ,tract asatin-,      -        vp*clkn tooortimr water 331-5 Ia r .elasot    OTI program h.notcrailed See      Cha.iWtryrerd. Tabls 2credls the O0Iprogram noug queslion G(3l.2 above                                    releece tobte so*cialed Ts          I line item THs reuires asnrawt            lothe chenioaty irogram descriptios in LRA Atpesdose Asard B to clearly dlcae inat the Ors-Tince Irspaction Progran wlllcordirm ft effectveness of Ins Water Cheiatary Codtrod
AS PNPS. the station blackout deed goneat or provides the alterrtse AC power source. Al SSC associaled withhe AAC desed ae In acope lor license renewal. Te LRA proide the song h m-goWel rariew ruLets for lo-ivedt passive SSCS aessodatel with fet AC power seuce In each decipline secton cithe LRA NRC PNPS Lead Ng.ye.x Dwc Ssroud Mle The PNPS IRA Seti-3622 willbereoised ra reeaIdlowt.
* SMl. Vter Cherristry Contro* - Auxiliary Synlatr. and .heWater Coni*stry Conmro -Closed Codiing Water ThisIten Is closed to Ite 372 378  Closed  [7    I-P-Cm                                            During      pelrformanrce d rourin rrnaid rce acrconorna n o          Paid, Erach  Fronbagar, conion lutricating oil. visual Inspesoho. d ten.e Oworvnwth Taee 131, IIn3 .I-I4      f1 sted ciounarts fepo.eld to  would detly dgrwld cordtio          nto coid beattributed tow Itrlcatirng Oil.GALL report reconrerch lubricating ol    Irdleclive Oil Arlysis Program The correcrhn acsOn program al aenlysis progam ard OTI as.a veriuication prog*am        PNPS hea s low ttsshcdd r ft- lderfioatian        d degraded Howe-e, In fth docesio section only the di sartysis      oon'lior such thnoaoroste. o creaking OfCorlpents would be pregram I cretled Sectan 3.3227. tern Ist1ates      OWa  Idontilied en pa dtis of    program The rtiewo loperating orerrig      pwience at PNPS Ias nornirmnd "h            eperience at PNPS 1w 1ft las* five years dd not kdernily effectiveness dlofthe prom In naintairing cotlanirnth    cordlion reports no Irdoaed ani    snldfectho oil alynis progran oa withn linits mh that corrosion hns not and wil rWtslecl    nOIdontidliwdagra cd-op.nenIS -ditons such s corrosion or li      -We Ereijor      Ovis caqor, doos                craaking Ins lifricaling ol eniromerfn TTa tarrylo          ating eperlence at PNPS so.ee InHeau      O a -- thme Inspectin to PlMn explain hw PNPS can make I.s slateart It            provide condirmioionofd"    effectiveness o the OhiA-,lynis Irspecon has rnt been perormnd.                          Program_
Ngwner Duc Strou *lAke
During the Irat  lye yearsmy visual Irapecs*,ies of opornse owtning litrialing nil haee been perormed during corrciveeard preverve rrairerwce actliviles., Th visual Irpecies of Unese onipnareis wauM Idety deg-adw o'orduim each ae corrosion or cracking In acid be att-ibuted to en indlfectve il Anlysis Programc PNPS as a low ineshDidfor itn Vidionhifafonof degraded coritions such no orrosion or cracking of aonporends would be denailid ard wded I into      t corirslivo acton pinogram Nonondliwon reports o derstified      degraded conaoe      cordliona, mclh -=rcreion or cracking in a lubricating oil enaironrr*. were Inlialed n a reeiul di nOeInapeohona These post ikpeclions at FIPS serve In lieu ofa c dihneInspection to prakide ondirion i ihce dlelivensies dO.the      Oil Arlysis Program Pag 19d 77
*Sorne f tme p1endraion essenliee at PNPS are rut EQ The rce-EO penetraton aseetblies awe aubject boagirg nenree t
ereiew. The aftf meregmenwl review is procidel InAMRE.01 ar-me AWP fo pentaton assertly pigels Is provided Inthe non-EQ Insulated caebes erd conectiora proamrn will marege te gng dffectsof ft penetration Merty cabse ard conections. Tabel 362-1 Ictludes mhe selciced pnrelclion eCoxdutor ard cornnections In the lir tetm for electrical cabes and coreeion Mr e.*ject 1o0t0 CFR 50.49 -EQ.
The tntural repon for he k connmtliee, AMWCC6, acdresses the penot-aoen esser" cortponeri, aeds are seding dests that horm mhe radological ortrol berrierher cotlaitrert InhTatle 352-1.
The reiree aneamrdcre some lILRA Pba 16d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                           Page 201 Number Status   Request                                                 Response                                                          NRC        PNPS Lead 377  Closed   [T3S1.P-04j                                              Since the One-Time Inepection (OTI) PFogrn Is applicabe to each    PaFl, E.ach  FronbaWrger.
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 17 1 Number Status Request 371 Closed
water craistey contrd program. it is aso aplicatle tosech line Table3 3.1 hem 1&1-17 for steel elementsexposed treaed~n ibm S. creditsa waler lhenlwnyno r'ol grogeam.       LRATable Walerd ewnonstates te OTIwillbe ade w Verification      331 Irdcales ttl at One-Tire Inspetion Program is credled progrm, for Waerdch"W~ary. R.I.eW %"~.eei- T331.2 and along wth the waler &#xa2;hTristry corol Iproge*sa or linefianes Wo W33.1.2 Tleis ppif sosem" line law. Invenoca          whochGALL recommendis a              kisacon l0cod/irmwater
[G331.-P-0t Tabls a33214-1 throuh 33aZ4.35 adress non-saelny reated cwn'oSnere affecting seaty relted.stgrne H -owe
                                                                                                                          -onseine Tdabe* OW ntelrdn it- 3321.17.                           cherristry control Table 2 credte OneOTI progrm throtlr Odererve tote associated Table I line heIm.
: r. these 1.. le.
THe requires eneenckeni lote oherlnieryprogran deecriptiorn In LRA Aperdcee Aard Bto clearly Inclcale that the OeTime InspectionPrograen willoorlirm ft e                fleite *ater
ads*... II sal h systems Inection 33%
* tineee Choeristry Cornrol BWSM.Water Chrnistry Control - A.iliaty Systerm end ft Water Cernistry Cont0,* -Ceoed Colirg Water programs The It" Is cosed lo t-r 372 378  A-aeped (l,33.1-P.C6                                              Erewnemerwe Willbe nede to te Fire Proeclion program tooredl      Paid, Erach eeislingor irrplnearl nen prwenline    irtlmeenle tasn $or Ine Ire Tabl. 33.1. lmi 13.1-18 loe steal mid SS deeel a~ron      purp cdeed to morve W all aging effects IdeMoriid In Table eeleeel pip u Inth deoeeeon Ocokenreferdencesectoion      332-9 lineileeIls e apply tothe ireepump deedl conporen we 13.227 "Mn3k lor th.eeedalsiort Secio 3.3227 it-        adeuwately mneaged art reraed fotlionre ra9n      irtireel withoe 3 sttese that the carbon at"l deed1 P-Mcapipling "      crediirig te delectlion oleakagnekasmranig      aginegalect comonoents In " tireprolectimn csyt"n lIsnnegac by,the Fire Pro'eclio Prog-t The Fire Frotection Frowarn twee    The recirme naormna eri IoLRA aplrodcee Aaed B nioalwinspectionsof deseat satmat piping ard conponred to mnnae lotwd material. Howener, A~pini 8.1.1a i pogrant claecnipticn wboohkiclonlifieS sp nlondor-aod lies In scopeIct Inspeclionicee .ut cobol. ft. hececlion ofIlhe desel eeteal piping ard contowrtsl. Thare Ismne    erernoenl klertiiied hll,.
Aoiliary Systerms. w.0.0
program wrile~vt~coIrcolue fig isection lbrnig the period of eatWop eration.
: Owns, on these systers bdeon tosecton 32. ESF Systeon. and section 34, Seett "l Power Cwersion (S&PC) System.
Fleae, mpaidnlii. dacrepecy beweneri    seclion a33227 Ile-3ard itreAkP~al.13.1 progrant dencdplin or heolsl the Inspection 1n.teAKV e- an erietrnane Pabg20d 77
Tables 3314-7.
14-16. 14-25, ad 14-28 we lor sysbem tal belotg to Section 32 ard tables 3314-1. 14-Z 14-5.149. 1410.
14-11. 14-17. and 14-. 8 Ire
[or systern that belong to Section 34 The Toble I Ifte referece also specifies Table 321 ard 341. The af.l report and the SE we based on.ysterns sadedli InGALL Repor sectin.
f ESF, Adiliary. aod S&PC systoes.
As written in the IRA, it will rn0e the audt report and SER corfusing beca.se to ESF syslemn swciOn 32 write-will irclude Tables from section 3.3o and the SPC yet-section 34 wrie-q will kwIrde Taeles from. eclion 33 Different relmenewrite theae sections.
Piasse justify whythe rn-,-sde.y sytlerm assocliled with ESF and S&PC systernm wre lnclued In the Aemillary system leactirt 372 Accepted 1Q33 1-P-02 Di.screpncy between Tale 331 fine item. and Tables 332-X Ior thoe lim nle 111W credt water cherl*etry owal analysi. programn an a verilficalion program such a on.rtime Inspeclion (OTI) program The Taell I itemt I cositern with the GALL reporl "nd correcty creits the charn'try proeani and the OTI progeam or lor pdart-epecilfc progrtm lesocredts chlrwstry and OTI programs. However.
the Table 2 line Itenr th reerence these Table I line Ite do not cmr0t the OTt pogran The.. Table 2 tine hen. however h.0e & Imro. 'N, or 'C'w~ch slel. t1 it 1I consisterl with the M.AP cobination inth. GALL Plea.e tusli17 why the OT progra Is 1ot crdled inTable
: 2. een th'ough I is creadled In Table I and Wrote A ilonies totea consitency with GALL for MAP ooenirelior,


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                              - Page 21 I Number Status  Request                                                  Resonse                                                                NRC        PNPS Lead 379  Closed  [TZI.I3-P-C6J                                            Durng theperlormence of ruine nairawn.ce on*oompowts a                 Paid. Erach  Ftmsbarger.
===Response===
cotain kluricalirn oil, visual Irspscons of Owas chrporal Table 3 1. h      3a3 1-21 lor stle carpoties eposled Ib  wsold detily degraded cotditio, fla. could be attribued loa lutbricaing oil This Is hiusame Issue as in queltion      Ineffective l Anlysis Prosgrm The corrective action program d T.331.3 dooe. except V*  fssoni    Is3.3229. Iten 2     PNPS has a low hOrshiidSm ft Identicatlion c degraded conditions suchhVt sorrelo a cracking ofdospowis wolddbe Icrtiwled as Part of sia progbam The review of operating ypeiarnce al PFPS for thr last five yests id rot Ideniy tany cordtion rports Owl Idcated as Indlectioe oil stlysis proram af hu idablied 1de.ahl sorpon s t co&#xa2;nd*onesuh as sorrosion or cracking Isa lubriiry cil oir*rolrwsto      Trrdsresview opertsieinr acpeience a PNPS svei, insiu c a on-t.im Inspection to Provide costiration oO f slsoiveares of the Oil Aralyss P'rogram, Drir fth psl fivt ypets, re visual Ispections slssomponests owttdiry ktutlcalir 0 otl hwoe beent perforred during corretive and prevetntve rintenace activities The visual inspections      dtes sawooulr rO  Identify degraded condition suh as corosion a cookin Ma urd be atlribuled to an Ineffective ait Analysis Prosgrm. PNPS as a low Uneshold Som        ft Idnlfioasiorn of degraded codiroras such OW corrosiona ocracking of ctonw s wold be rlaelified ad aiowedloo te correcto action progam Noooilitiort r Os*           ldatifieddagraded component    cordolio, such as cotsiors a. cracki      Ina lubricating oil ir&#xfd; snir were Iritiialel asa reull o W*. irp*sp ons. Thee last Itspsctiosr aSPNPS sane In    sle ofa ane-thie Irnpection lo provide confirmation sift i.affeciveress of the Oil Anaysis Progran TNis hae Is losed tolae      376.
NRC Section 14 Irldoh al
380  Clousd  ['.1.P.O7]                                                Sic ft Orns-Timr Inspoction (OTI) Program Is aqyicdole to each          Patd, Erach  FPordb9r.
,11 0.
water olarnstry ontrol program, his ais applicable      tiosch line Tablee*1.      Isem3 -1.23for S8hemu mclor*er              itm ha crtall a waler  acemstry cohrol Pogramn iAA Table comporans asposed5toeared water. Tinsisthesime            33.1 Irlcabee B*utthe Om-Tire Inspection Program Is cradled I-seIn      questio- T.331.2 above, except th pectio, Is along with ft water cerstry corol programs Somline htemsSom 332210, U-e2                                              whrchGALL rexrmmsnrn aonsw-tira Ispaclion OCtoirm wale' cohristry contro. Taele 2 credtallx OTIprogram Oveugh rdsorace lothe easociated Tales I ins hemr Tics raequir asasr      ms-swlotha cherristry program descrimlioe InLRA Appaodcea A asd B soclearly Itdcale 9folts          Cra-Time Inspection Program willowfirm the effectliowens of Ithe Wale Chlanistry Control - BWERWViee        ChemnstryCothrci - Auxiliaty Syslem and "t Waie, Chemistry Control - Closed Cooling Waler programs This hrt Icloead to hen 372 fPge 21 d 77
yl.te-l Iveo Iht*ootd functicns Paod, Eraec th out 10CFR 544(a)(2) or ty*hsical Irneraction To IOicale IndvivW eystm Included In the rg n-garnore* rensw for (a)(2),Tade 332-14 Is $,1bcllvded by syslem For exanpl*, Taole 332-14-1 Is for h cir(culating water sysltem a syste mWolOh only
: e. cor*pornerts Included lor (a)(2). For th cre mseWy system, Tale 332-14-7 shows thenne crts Included foh (a)(2)t K since to systmn hi also Inscop. he other reasons. Table 332-2 shows theowponens Inctluded h544(a)(1) and(a)(3)
The argin mananeentr review of the eystn. tW hwee fuecions OUs mot IOCFR 54 (a)(2) f phyica fInteraction, was done eparately from the r-iew otf ethen. with irnended furcio that 1o 0
IOCFR 044 (&)(t) or (a)(3). The redcs do tis review were presented seperately so Owl they oomld be reviewed eepaaeldy on th bssi. Ot physi*e pr 1 oirrity ralhe *tn yster furclionr TH*
0tOws a reniewer to clearly delingish which componret ty"e. In.a system were irlucded for t0CFR 04 4(a)(2) hoe "*siael Ireractiono Since moet of these. yster re eiliary syst-n they were added as paet oftt swiliafy Nysles section PNPS Lead Frombergr, Since the Ce-Ticr Inspection (OT1) Pfonn Is oyli*bl.*e boeach water cheristry Cortrol programr it i also applicabe lo each line Itecm Oha credits a water chetestry cortl program IRA Toble 331 Itotaoeo tht to One-Tirm Inspection Progarn Is credted along with the water chenistry cntrol prograns het line Ite, hr whch GALL recorMneds aoornoime Inspection to ortirm water chornisry corrd, Table 2 credits to OTI program through reference tothe associated Taole I line hlem This ruorcrese naerndne*r totho cohrrsry progoa.r dloscriptiors In LRA Appendices Arad B1to clearly Indicate " the One-Time Inspection Program willconrirm te effectivrenes ofthe WtVoer Chenristry Control - BMi. Witor Chenristry Conrlrd - Auxiliary Systrne *ond the Water Chernistry Cortrot - Closed Cooing Water pron*rre.
Petd. Erach Fgo.-.
Page 177d 77


James Davis - AMR-,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                           .                                                                                                                Page 22]
James Davis - AMR-Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page1*81 Number Status Request M7~ Acepte jG3.31-P-03 PNPS does rel Ircntne Boiing Q k1ogrty Progmran Intha LRA.
Number Status Request                                               Response                                                                NRC        PNPS Lead 381  Ckosd    IT3-P.P.C8l                                            Snce 1he O-Time Irepection (OTI) PsogasoIa1oiblte to each                Paid, Erach  FPerotrgor.
howwar credta Cittm progmrarn W alternate lo the bohingr Integrity progrann The GALL Rqxdr AM' )O.M18, Bolting IrWaity, Prograr prwio. solaran eoyarci ma s In' othe 10-slmn
water cherristry cotlrol program flti          ooalsolicaeIobach line Ta e33f, ioen 331-24 foe SSaed alurinurm coorers-sl    lorn thl credltsawler oharristry contol progara LRATlale sposed to oretedwater. Theis ih easeIssuea In        331 Irdlates live tIe OfwTirns Irspotion Progas Is crudted qustion TZl.1.2 above. sc.0t
,w11 usohion spec~iicaly raoorom-midion asotaoolod with preventive 0330,, such as selection di bolting rnstaril, weaof cibr Ii ardo
* ection 1 33.2.2 10. along withhfe water cheosly conero proarse forIrlies                lor fe iten 2 Thee weover 80line Iles ass*ialed wththlis In  wMichGALL recmronds conewtin Inspection locorfirm water dflerel Wide23.                                       chenistry conred. Table 2redts Ie OTI progon throU ,
-Mc ants arol witittional reo-r-witions of NUREO-139 Borne di the afttrrmta progratr tray beaaooapito for lpecolion h-...OWa dra not0 wkires. Ith prtwenthro action.-
rdece-. lothe essoaied Ta.e I line Item TN. re*ires an wxlrn              bo te ohwrdslry progio*n decrlptlio In LRA A'peadoes Aard Bto aInty 'dalest t                  he One-Timn Impaction Progrwn willoorfirm It elellctieness of ft Water Chemistry Cortrol
Plasna clarify tow PNiPS trade threse rooonwtw~ordil whan w.ing attarrate, prograns, wr please cracit a Botilin Iteria~ty Progrn for the t variota T~o 22line Herne as appropriate For section a3, tis applie o ITabl S33. II. ln it-a 3.1-19. 3.3.1-27.
* BM, Water Clesistry Controd- Amitiaely Syst1neard the Waier Chw,9dty Conod - Closed Cooling Waier progan's.
3.3.1-4Z.
TNs hen Is closed to tern372 Closed  rrzal-P-Ch]                                            During the peeforme of routine niares-ce onconpone-ss tW                  Paid. Erach contaln      oebricaling cil. vistualInspeio*e ofithese cootponarts Table 3.3A he,3.1-26 Ir    topper altoposoporon        would kdortifydocgaded condition te could beitributed toan ePOSedtoklbricaing oil. TNsIs ft sace Issue wn      Inellsctive C1lArlysie Program TheI orreclive adion progrm at queslion T.311.3 aoot scmW the    lectcon is&322l0. PNPS has allow 'rnhold lorthe Identtfioion S degralwd fte 4                                                 soodltions ech tel oreosion or cracking of corponees would be kidrified as peerlo fis program The rio dolopenaing eoperieice dl PNPS loth    a    lasl live years dld no Idkily wy cosmolionreports l        Inctcaled an Ineffective ol iwtysis progont or fed kidrlifie degraded *e*rper I codhos tuchas orrosion or ocsking Insa luricaling oil  dvirronmrs This reviewonqOpeeaing cpeeie-ce  al PNPS seoves Is lieu o ane-Iioe Inspection Io provinsdeco-nion ote teactivse at                oe    Oil Arwtysis During " peal five yers,,ey              invst irsua eiora cioerponasi.
a3.1-43, 331-5%, ar 311-711 374 A..ple 1T.3&1-P-0tt T~a lll33?. Rom 3111. 1or stolecrns withmagang afftofl curvooorwiifatiu Idia-agr.g tha GALL raconrarnb TIA to be wcahatod for satvretura gilrsdo-i rt.
Ohti'nig liubric.aing* lhave been perlormeld dueng oarective an preoslive        tarnelarce activilies. The visual iupectioe cithese cornoonsoswould kierlily deg-aded corcior scth-as-o-rnon or cracking Vel otid bea*truited toeanInsffectve OCiAnwlyss Program PNPS Wo a low thres:tcd                tot*eidMeification of degradod co-ilio such el corosion or cracking o sotryosort.
Tha dacrasron aotio.Z sates. a-at tis line Itent was not wed In
would beldontifihe sid sared iro the        Icreclive action program Nocoendlion epots  o    tee    orlilid degrwdedhorl      lpose-rwdtiors, euchas corrosion or &#xfd;racking Ina lubricaling oil sclirotw, were IritiaeWd"sa    real chies. Inepetoohe Thee peol Irlpections el =NPS serve in lieu a ow- rwirsir                tion Io provide orfirrmnon d "teatctlivenrs ofite Oil Arsysis Progaom TN. iteon Iledb          horn376.
.aaction 33, however st." ca.-
x!22fd 77
m aretwatale 1.n*action 35 Tact, 35.2-2 aci &S52.4 atkkaaa Grin.. b1A k, an a~rgeffedtl cib.dciWetrials. C-Arrald alg-o danaga of cranesaisrcm aoal wfsee ainsetion 35 r n tnl TLAA section 4.7 (4art1 specific TLAA). iAlo sao TLA queation.
Pleasa alpyben whera tisa line Hann as addressed Int ih RA Reponse ABcitirg Irlogrity Progranr willbedelocped Ot wllttmaasa Ith agrng of n
bagla inthei r ao f license reerwal A copy ct a
rrtaea nml progra baasisdoc d
n Ir to Wtirg Ilegrity Program willbelproided lor raiso with ft LIRA The Bootirg hriagty Progart willbaintrpl~or prior oothe priod d wdrtao operation Inraccocnk with coartrtitle rl-rdtm 3Z Thlarequirsaaarnamamerr lotha LRAbtrclude doscriptionsca tI-Boltirng horgty Progatr InA*g*dca Aarsd Bard m
oidtnity wheroatha prograc Is applieable Asdined In 10 CFR 54 3, a TLAA In a IIoaeea calculation or analysis that. roMr coa things, Involves fi&#xfd;-lirritwl saamptiora defined by the currern operating term Theore In anatysia for sled crams. al PNPS that aatisfies the ddirlitiorn CMA-70 dcefinea allowable stresa range blasd ojniot category and sarvice class SeMce class Is batnl on load class (r.an etilve load Lador) "f a
rtbw d cycles.
Howa... the nr.o f ci yclea I. NOT basad on 4 yaws of operation dt Iis crane The arlicitpted cyctaa for th PNPS reactor bildg en a c
. we watl belaon any of th cycle rangas gvar In CMAA*7Q Based o-realistic atirratae arid 11-htoriol ratae o we od th r"an.. oa.
a-a PNPS reactor blilrng ar kratir
.lk.dg cr*me would take ovr-350 yanrs to reach It. rrirruc cycle range for CMA.A-70. Comewaryay tro Is no TLAA associated with a" load cycles.
NRC PNPS Lead patel. Erach Frcabarg.r, Paid, Erach Fincrn, Ron Fage l8d 77


James Davis -=AMR - Report to the N.RC.doc.pdf ..                                                                                                                                           page 23 Number Status Request                                                   Response                                                               NRC         PNPS Lead 3M   Cloed   T3a31-P-10i                                             SLes OheOCi-Tin. Irs otsen(OTI) Proor Is           bagTica' l each     Paid. ErBch  Froeabarg*r, waler heaeisry aold prog'am I.It also applicable to each line Table33.1t.hln 31-30 for SSeOerorancs -ePoed Io          II.. lVS cr*afs a water &#xa9;cnislrywoetr* ogarn             RA Table sodiut, peaborale Isolutio Tis isthe sane Issue as In    33.1 indcaes M to Ot-Tirni Impaction Prega Is erated question T.331.2 above. ecept uh slectionIs 13 22I0.      along Withte waler cnhildry oetrtol programv for linarts lor htj a                                                      wich GALL recoenvradr awono-UirnInsmpeiot locornirm waler canistry owerod. Table 2 &#xfd;erlle ft OTI proga freem rder-n . bIthe associated Table I line htem ThN raedrea amanrdral tobtse cetstry progran doaerildow In LRAAFppdiea Adard8 lo       blerly Indcate "- the Onr-Tin.
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf
hrpal*n Progarn ailloonfirm the sfftlivaea df the Waler ChMsry Control- BR, Waler Chwistry Coered - hAillaey Systeas and w Waler Chwistry Certrd -Cleaed Cooling Waler proIngra Th     aeIs        bloaed lo ft- 372 384  Closed    231-P-it)                                              Drirg thw paiernses       l roedia friarta cs oncenyonsraid             Paid. Erach Fronsarga.
-Page 19 1 Number Status Request 375 Closd Ti3ll-P-O]
wertain lubrionting oil. vsual Inspect     d tsie samiger/a Tale 3a1i, kem333.1.33 forSScenwoc*ws          xposed to  would Idertify degraded cordion l         sa iould beOir*buled loan lubricaing oil. TN. is the ae Issuie as In question      Inefective 0il An~ysie Progaren The worecliv action prograrn at T.13.1.3 tb7.A eAq the secton Is 33z221i. It- 2          PNPS has asow tvashld borth*         Intrialion adogadad wondtionsetch Ol woeoion o cracking d         ooopones Woeldbe Idilliied as pad dl INs proga       The reaiew of operaing aperaels a PNPO1.the lau             a s liveayt s rs     . Identtly any wondlion reporlt I     Irdealted an Inoalelivs dl aralysis pregan or ta Idertile da gladl saoponenI wotdlions such as worroesina rawkingIn a lubrkicsinrioil enawreraer. TNs.ra*iwA cdqaaling atpetaiee S PNPF saew Inlia               one-lire Impaeslionbo prav. confirmation d us       affectve- d the 01 AjtlyaiS Prograi During us past flye years. n"       visual Inesptioer decrqtoerws ortaieig lubricating ol hhawbeen plernd during   s       oha-raieard prevenive linirenance aechtivit 1.he visetal iapalies d Ineae soarpss awould Idertify dgraded condtlioe etch as reilon or cracking IW could be       atiled lo an Infaictie C0IAnalysis Progam. PNPS bas a low Icymhold         Ior uhs Idenlication ol dssayd sashdier-esuch t           watroeionor crackdngd cenagarco would be1dartilied andereed Ino us woreacliveaction Pro*earn Necordhion rorli OS Ider ifled d*ogaded corporerS e*niliona.
Tabled.1, hean 311-5, lorkhS exchanger eiposed bo tr=d wafer G C (I40F), dascusaion oald. that OTI wl be wed ai vrification program for wao cl-han"iry.
suchas          e' s'aking In a luereaietg W*lal           wfeers -ea Inflaled as a realt oftI-as lesecao-s. These peelinspetions S PNP; sase In lOeu a onea- rns Irnpselion lo prwide ceetirnaeiondoue fectinveras d the 01       i-Alysis Prog-am Tha itean Is doed lo Itesn376.
lcwwer.
l:,
lone lIosnelai In Table 332-3 where iem 331-5 Ia r
.elasot OTI program h.not crailed See queslion G(3l.2 above 378 Closed
[7 I-P-Cm Taee 131, IIn3
.I-I4 f1 sted ciounarts fepo.eld to Itrlcatirng Oil. GALL report reconrerch lubricating ol aenlysis progam ard OTI as.a veriuication prog*am Howe-e, In fth docesio section only the di sartysis pregram I cretled Sectan 3.3227. tern Ist1ates OWa orerrig pwience at PNPS Ias nornirmnd "h effectiveness dlof the prom In naintairing cotlanirnth withn linits mh that corrosion hns not and wil rWt slecl li
-We Ereijor Ovis caqor, doo s
PlMn explain hw PNPS can make I.s slateart It Irspecon has rnt been perormnd.
 
===Response===
Sme the Owe-Tims Inspection (OTI) Program Is aplicae to. ech water cherniwry corcrd progan, it ls also applicable to ach line hoen M crdles a water chlanstry carcl progranm LRA Tate 331I Inrdateio a tin. Ons-Tiws Wpection Program I credited along witheiv, water chearaitry co*r*r progras for line hers Sr whmch GALL r
,tract asatin-,
vp*clkn tooortimr water Cha.iWtry rerd. Tabls 2credls the O0I program noug releece tobte so*cialed Ts I line item THs reuires asnrawt lothe chenioaty irogram descriptios in LRA Atpesdose Asard B to clearly dlcae inat the Ors-Tince Irspaction Progran wlllcordirm ft effectveness of Ins Water Cheiatary Codtrod
* SMl. Vter Cherristry Contro* - Auxiliary Synlatr. and.he Water Coni*stry Conmro -Closed Codiing Water This Iten Is closed to Ite 372 During pelrformanrce d rourin rrnaid rce acrc on orna n o
conion lutricating oil. visual Inspesoho. d ten.e Oworvnwth would detly dgrwld cordtio nto coid beattributed tow Irdleclive Oil Arlysis Program The correcrhn acsOn program al PNPS hea s low ttsshcdd r ft-lderfioatian d degraded oon'lior such thno aoroste.
o creaking Of Corlpents would be Idontilied en pa of dtis program The rtiewo loperating eperience at PNPS 1w 1ft las* five years dd not kdernily cordlion reports no Irdoaed ani snldfectho oil alynis progran oa nO Idontidliw dagra cd -op.nen IS -ditons such s corrosion or craaking Ins lifricaling ol eniromerfn TTa tarrylo ating eperlence at PNPS so.ee In Heau O a -- thme Inspectin to provide condirmioion of d"
effectiveness o the Ohi A-,lynis Program_
During the Irat lye yearsmy visual Irapecs*,ies of opornse owtning litrialing nil haee been perormed during corrciveeard preverve rrairerwce actliviles., Th visual Irpecies of Unese onipnareis wauM Idety deg-adw o'orduim each ae corrosion or cracking In acid be att-ibuted to en indlfectve il Anlysis Programc PNPS as a low ineshDid for itn Vidionhifafon of degraded coritions such no orrosion or cracking of aonporends would be denailid ard wded I into t
corirslivo acton pinogram Nonondliwon reports o derstified degraded conaoe cordliona, mclh -=rcreion or cracking in a lubricating oil enaironrr*. were Inlialed n a reeiul di nOe Inapeohona These post ikpeclions at FIPS serve In lieu of a c dihne Inspection to prakide ondirion i ihce dlelivensies dO.the Oil Arlysis Program Paid, e rach Frosbager, NRC PNPS Lead Paid, Erach Fronbagar, Pag 19d 77
 
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 201 Number Status Request 377 Closed
[T3S1.P-04j Table 3 3.1 hem 1&1-17 for steel elements exposed treaed~n Waler d ewnon states te OTI willbe ade w Verification progrm, for Waerd ch"W~ary. R.I.eW %"~.eei-T331.2 and W33.1.2 Tleis ppif sosem" line law. Invenoca Tdabe* OW ntelrdn it-3321.17.
378 A-aeped (l,33.1-P.C6 Tabl. 33.1. lmi 13.1-18 loe steal mid SS deeel a~ron eeleeel pip u Inth deoeeeon Ocokenrefe rdencesectoion 13.227 "Mn 3k lor th.e eedalsiort Secio 3.3227 it-3 sttese that the carbon at"l deed1 P-Mca pipling "
comonoents In " t ire prolectimn csyt"n lIsnnegac by, the Fire Pro'eclio Prog-t The Fire Frotection Frowarn twee nioalw inspections of dese at satmat piping ard conponred to mnnae lotw d material. Howener, A~pini 8.1.1a i pogrant claecnipticn wboohkiclonlifie S sp nlondor-aod lies In scope Ict Inspeclion icee.ut cobol. ft. hececlion ofIl he desel eeteal piping ard contowrtsl. Thare Ismne erernoenl klertiiied hll,.
program wrile~vt~co Ircolue fig isection lbrnig the period of eatWop eration.
Fleae, mpaidn lii. dacrepecy beweneri seclion a33227 Ile-3ard itreAkP~ al.13.1 progrant dencdplin or heolsl the Inspection 1n. teAKV e-an erietrnane
 
===Response===
NRC Since the One-Time Inepection (OTI) PFogrn Is applicabe to each PaFl, E.ach water craistey contrd program. it is aso aplicatle to sech line ibm S. creditsa waler lhenlwny no r'ol grogeam.
LRATable 331 Irdcales ttl at One-Tire Inspetion Program is credled along wth the waler &#xa2;hTristry corol I proge*sa or linefianes Wo whoch GALL recommendis a
-onseine kisacon l0cod/irm water cherristry control Table 2 credte One OTI progrm throtlr Odererve tote associated Table I line heIm.
THe requires eneenckeni lote oherlniery progran deecriptiorn In LRA Aperdcee Aard Bto clearly Inclcale that the OeTime Inspection Prograen willoorlirm ft fle e
tineee ite *ater Choeristry Cornrol BWSM. Water Chrnistry Control - A.iliaty Systerm end ft Water Cernistry Cont0,* -Ceoed Colirg Water programs The It" Is cosed lo t-r 372 Erewnemerwe Will be nede to te Fire Proeclion program tooredl Paid, Erach eeisling or irrplnearl nen prwenline irtlmeenle tasn $or Ine Ire purp cdeed to morve W all aging effects IdeMoriid In Table 332-9 lineileeIls e apply tothe ireepump deedl conporen we adeuwately mneaged art reraed fotlionre ra9n irtireel withoe crediirig te delectlion oleakagnekasmranig agineg alect The recirme naormna eri IoLRA aplrodcee Aaed B PNPS Lead FronbaWrger.
Pabg 20d 77
 
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 21 I Number Status Request 379 Closed
[TZI.I3-P-C6J Table 3 1. h 3a3 1-21 lor stle carpoties eposled Ib lutbricaing oil This Is hi usame Issue as in queltion T.331.3 dooe. except V*
fssoni Is 3.3229. Iten 2 380 Clousd
['.1.P.O7]
Tablee*1.
Isem3
-1.23 for S8hemu mclor*er comporans asposed 5toeared water. Tinsisthesime I-seIn questio-T.331.2 above, except th pectio, Is 332210, U-e2 Resonse Durng the perlormence of ruine nairawn.ce on*oompowts a
cotain kluricalirn oil, visual Irspscons of Owas chrporal wsold detily degraded cotditio, fla. could be attribued loa Ineffective l Anlysis Prosgrm The corrective action program d PNPS has a low hOrshiid Sm ft Identicatlion c degraded conditions such hVt sorrelo a cracking ofd ospowis wold dbe Icrtiwled as Part of sia progbam The review of operating ypeiarnce al PFPS for thr last five yests id rot Ideniy tany cordtion rports Owl Idcated as Indlectioe oil stlysis proram af hu idablied 1de.ahl sorpon s t co&#xa2;nd*one suh as sorrosion or cracking Isa lubriiry cil oir*rolrwsto Trrds resview opertsieinr acpeience a PNPS svei, ins iu c a on-t.im Inspection to Provide costiration oO f slsoiveares of the Oil Aralyss P'rogram, Drir fth psl fivt ypets, re visual Ispections slssomponests owttdiry ktutlcalir 0 otl hwoe beent perforred during corretive and prevetntve rintenace activities The visual inspections dtes awooulr s
rO Identify degraded condition suh as corosion a cookin Ma urd be atlribuled to an Ineffective ait Analysis Prosgrm. PNPS as a low Uneshold Som ft Idnlfioasiorn of degraded codiroras such OW corrosiona ocracking of ctonw s
wold be rlaelified ad aiowed loo te correcto action progam Noooilitiort r Os
* ldat ified dagraded component
: cordolio, such as cotsiors a. cracki Ina lubricating oil ir&#xfd; snir were Iritiialel asa reull o W*.
irp*sp ons. Thee last Itspsctiosr aS PNPS sane In sle of a ane-thie Irnpection lo provide confirmation sift i.affeciveress of the Oil Anaysis Progran TNis hae Is losed tolae 376.
Sic ft Orns-Timr Inspoction (OTI) Program Is aqyicdole to each water olarnstry ontrol program, his ais applicable tiosch line itm ha crtall a waler acemstry cohrol Pogramn iAA Table 33.1 Irlcabee B*ut the Om-Tire Inspection Program Is cradled along with ft water cerstry corol programs Som line htems Som whrchGALL rexrmmsnrn aonsw-tira Ispaclion OCtoirm wale' cohristry contro. Taele 2 credta llx OTIprogram Oveugh rdsorace lothe easociated Tales I ins hemr Tics raequir asasr ms-sw lotha cherristry program descrimlioe In LRA Appaodcea A asd B so clearly Itdcale folts 9
Cra-Time Inspection Program willowfirm the effectliowens of Ithe Wale Chlanistry Control - BWER WViee Chemnstry Cothrci - Auxiliaty Syslem and "t Waie, Chemistry Control - Closed Cooling Waler programs This hrt Icloead to hen 372 NRC Paid. Erach Patd, Erach PNPS Lead Ftmsbarger.
FPordb9r.
fPge 21 d 77
 
James Davis - AMR-,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 22]
Number Status Request 381 Ckosd IT3-P.P.C8l Ta e33f, ioen 331-24 foe SSaed alurinurm coorers-sl sposed to oreted water. The is ih ease Issuea In qustion TZl.1.2 above. sc.0t
* ection 1 33.2.2 10.
iten 2 Thee weover 80line Iles ass*ialed wththlis In dflerel Wide 23.
Closed rrzal-P-Ch]
Table 3.3A he,3.1-26 Ir topper altoposoporon ePOSed toklbricaing oil. TNsIs ft sace Issue wn queslion T.311.3 aoot scmW the lectcon is&322l0.
fte 4
 
===Response===
Snce 1he O-Time Irepection (OTI) Psogaso Ia1 oiblte to each water cherristry cotlrol program flt i oo alsolicaeIo bach line lorn thl credltsawler oharristry contol progara LRATlale 331 Irdlates live tIe OfwTirns Irspotion Progas Is crudted along withhfe water cheosly conero proarse for Irlies fe lor wMich GALL recmronds conewtin Inspection locorfirm water chenistry conred. Table 2redts Ie OTI progon throU,
rdece-. lothe essoaied Ta.e I line Item TN. re*ires an wxlrn bo te ohwrdslry progio*n decrlptlio In LRA A'peadoes Aard Bto aInty 'dalest t he One-Timn Impaction Progrwn willoorfirm It elellctieness of ft Water Chemistry Cortrol
* BM, Water Clesistry Controd - Amitiaely Syst1ne ard the Waier Chw,9dty Conod - Closed Cooling Waier progan's.
TNs hen Is closed to tern 372 During the peeforme of routine niares-ce onconpone-ss tW contaln oebricaling cil. vistual Inspeio*e ofithese cootponarts would kdortify docgaded condition te could beitributed toan Inellsctive C1l Arlysie Program TheI orreclive adion progrm at PNPS has allow 'rnhold lorthe Identtfioion S degralwd soodltions ech tel oreosion or cracking of corponees would be kidrified as peerl o fis program The rio dol openaing eoperieice dl PNPS a loth lasl live years dld no Idkily wy cosmolion reports l Inctcaled an Ineffective ol iwtysis progont or fed kidrlifie degraded *e*rper I codhos tuch as orrosion or ocsking Insa luricaling oil dvirronmrs This reviewonqOpeeaing cpeeie-ce al PNPS seoves Is lieu o ane-Iioe Inspection Io provinsde co-nion ote teactivse at oe Oil Arwtysis During " peal five yers,,ey invst irsua eiora cioerponasi.
Ohti'nig liubric.aing
* lhave been perlormeld dueng oarective an preoslive tarnelarce activilies. The visual iupectioe cithese cornoonsos would kierlily deg-aded corcior scth-as-o-rnon or cracking Vel otid bea*truited toean Insffectve OCi Anwlyss Program PNPS Wo a low thres:tcd tot*e idMeification of degradod co-ilio such el corosion or cracking o sotryosort.
would beldontifihe sid sared iro the Icreclive action program Nocoendlion epots te e o
orlilid degrwded horl lpose-r wdtiors, euch as corrosion or &#xfd;racking Ina lubricaling oil sclirotw, were IritiaeWd "sa real chies. Inepetoohe Thee peol Irlpections el =NPS serve in lieu a ow-rw irsir tion Io provide orfirrmnon d "te atctlivenrs of ite Oil Arsysis Progaom TN. iteon Iledb horn 376.
NRC PNPS Lead Paid, Erach FPerotrgor.
Paid. Erach x !22fd 77
 
James Davis -=AMR - Report to the N.RC.doc.pdf..
page 23 Number Status Request 3M Cloed T3a31-P-10i Table 33.1t. hln 31-30 for SSeOerorancs
-ePoed Io sodiut, peaborale Isolutio Tis isthe sane Issue as In question T.331.2 above. ecept uh slection Is 13 22I0.
htj a 384 Closed 231-P-it)
Tale 3a1i, kem333.1.33 for SScenwoc*ws xposed to lubricaing oil. TN. is the ae Issuie as In question T.13.1.3 tb7.A eAq the secton Is 33z221i.
It-2
 
===Response===
SLes Ohe OCi-Tin. Irs otsen (OTI) Proor Is bagTica' l each waler heaeisry aold prog'am I. It also applicable to each line II.. lVS cr*afs a water &#xa9;cnislry woetr* ogarn RA Table 33.1 indcaes M to Ot-Tirni Impaction Prega Is erated along Withte waler cnhildry oetrtol programv for linarts lor wich GALL recoenvradr awono-Uirn Insmpeiot locornirm waler canistry owerod. Table 2 &#xfd;erlle ft OTI proga freem rder-n. bIthe associated Table I line htem ThN raedrea amanrdral tobtse cetstry progran doaerildow In LRA AFppdiea Adard8 lo blerly Indcate "- the Onr-Tin.
hrpal*n Progarn ailloonfirm the sfftlivaea df the Waler ChMsry Control - BR, Waler Chwistry Coered - hAillaey Systeas and w Waler Chwistry Certrd -Cleaed Cooling Waler proIngra Th ae Is bloaed lo ft-372 Drirg thw paiernses l roedia friarta cs oncenyonsraid wertain lubrionting oil. vsual Inspect d tsie samiger/a would Idertify degraded cordion l sa iould beOir*buled loan Inefective 0il An~ysie Progaren The worecliv action prograrn at PNPS has asow tvashld borth*
Intrialion adogadad wondtions etch Ol woeoion o cracking d ooopones Woeld be Idilliied as pad dl INs proga The reaiew of operaing aperaels a PNPO1. the lau s liveayt s a
rs Identtly any wondlion reporlt I Irdealted an Inoalelivs dl aralysis pregan or ta Idertile da gladl saoponen I wotdlions such as worroesin a rawking In a lubrkicsinri oil enawreraer.
TNs. ra*iwA cdqaaling atpetaiee S PNPF saew Inlia one-lire Impaeslion bo prav.
confirmation d us affectve-d the 01 AjtlyaiS Prograi During us past flye years. n" visual Inesptioer decrqtoerws ortaieig lubricating ol hhaw been plernd during s
oha-raieard prevenive linirenance aechtivit 1.he visetal iapalies d Ineae soarpss awould Idertify dgraded condtlioe etch as reilon or cracking IW could be atiled lo an Infaictie C0I Analysis Progam. PNPS bas a low Icymhold Ior uhs Idenlication ol dssayd sashdier-e such t watroeion or crackdng d cenagarco would be 1dartilied and ereed Ino us woreaclive action Pro*earn Necordhion rorli OS Ider ifled d*ogaded corporerS e*niliona.
such as e' s'aking In a luereaietg W*lal wfeers -ea Inflaled as a realt of tI-as lesecao-s. These peel inspetions S PNP; sase In lOeu a onea-rns Irnpselion lo prwide ceetirnaeion do ue fectinveras d the 01 i-Alysis Prog-am Tha itean Is doed lo Itesn 376.
NRC Paid. ErBch PNPS Lead Froeabarg*r, Paid. Erach Fronsarga.
A,- 23d 77
A,- 23d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                               Page 24 1 Number Status   Request                                                       Response                                                          NRC        PNPS Lead 35   Closed [T,33.1.P.I21]                                                 Origina Type 304 slainless sled piping and fitting between drfyall Paid. Erach  Taylor. Ady penetration X-14 and the 0"x 4Cresdcr donmrstrean d M0-1201-5 Tatle 331, Item3.3.1-37 lor SSwconpoat           wpomed lo   wemepulaced with type 316L.Mairoest s$led.
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 24 1 Number Status Request 35 Closed
IOledl da. >r0C (>140F). Th. line len applies IoRWCU ytsle ard GALLRepor recpoort           ALP ]M5, BVWR Reanlor Wae Cleaspe Syslenr The aplican *lidea "SwOemwt I to GLWO-l Olain thai K=SCCInpection a RWCU piping o dsi.dete Conlairnenl Ioldaion vain. Is reoeor-ded only Wll acuitansassoclaed withGOL9-t0 on,ncor oprlte aive.ae.oorrplede Sinte PNPS lea salisfaltorlty corroed all actios requested InNRC GlL M9-10.fe Wane Chleniory Control BWR Program s wsed In lies of lhe O Rae           Wate Clesnp Systen Progm- to Menage thei polnial aging elfect. Howe*, ft AMP also siaw S"I       addition to med lIng th criterior piping Is oWs natlerial that1.rI. imilntto 3SCC.
[T,33.1.P.I21]
Please co9-rm wcil grati         sdtanreimsniorlnN in wed and jutlfy tl it . resistant to K3SCC.
Tatle 331, Item3.3.1-37 lor SSwconpoat wpomed lo IOledl da. >r0C (>140F). Th. line len applies Io RWCU ytsle ard GALL Repor recpoort ALP ]M5, BVWR Reanlor Wae Cleaspe Syslenr The aplican *lidea "SwOemwt I to GLWO-l Olain thai K=SCC Inpection a RWCU piping o dsi. de te Conlairnenl Ioldaion vain. Is reoeor-ded only Wll acuitans assoclaed withGOL9-t0 on, ncor oprlte aive.ae.oorrplede Sinte PNPS lea salisfaltorlty corroed all actios requested In NRC GlL M9-10. fe Wane Chleniory Control BWR Program s wsed In lies of lhe O Rae Wate Clesnp Systen Progm-to Menage thei polnial aging elfect. Howe*, ft AMP also siaw S"I addition to med lIng th criterior piping Is oWs natlerial that 1.r I.
396 Closed     .T.311-P-122                                               Since sheOne-Timn Ispection (OTI) Progean Isapplicable to aoch      Paid. Erach  Fiort*uger.
imilnt to 3SCC.
water aranistryc<liro progan Ht  is also amioadde      eto ech line Sarre Issue as qemdio T.3312 above aim>apies here             hen, tie credits a water Chimisry wontrdprogran IRA Table whcre OTI is noi credited in Table 2 line Krenswhce            33.A Idicales that e Ctom-TirneImpection Progran Is crealed 3.a1-37 s rdareced                                             along Withth waer Choaisiry conrol progra1om    for line ilere mI which GALLreonoranfonisee-ore          pllupct Iocoolurc war.'
Please co9-rm wcil grati sdtanreims niorlnN in wed and jutlfy tl it. resistant to K3SCC.
cIOisry ctntolrd. Table 2crllas t*e OTI progran thlrough rdefr*nce S letoalald Toasl I lire ien Thie rooirns morranw ree toite cheanrty prog"e dwScrlpiorns In LRA Appendices Aand to clery Indicate Owthe One-Tine Iepej0io Progran willcolirm the sllelvenna d the Waler Chrerostry Control . BM. Waler Chonristry Contrl - Auxiliary Systanmaid We Walte Crari.ary Ccora - Cloed Coding Wale poogroms Thi iemnis cosed Io Nern372 y No2rd77
396 Closed  
.T.311-P-122 Sarre Issue as qemdio T.3312 above aim> apies here whcre OTI is noi credited in Table 2 line Krens whce 3.a1-37 s rdareced


James Davis - AMR -_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                ..                  ...                                                                         Page,25]
===Response===
Number Status  Request                                                        Resonse                                                            NRC        PNPS Lead 387  Closed    T.3I31-P-131                                                  Sims the OC Ti          Inpection (OTI) Ptogram Is applice to each Pald. Erach Fror-brger, watercherritry contro prog*amn IfI alsoapicabe toeach Uni Table 3.1. 1,ier331.38 for SSooenponents arposedto              iem tHat credits a waler cIenistry cornrol prorarn LRA Tatbe treaed water '60C (>,1F).                                         a1I nrdates t he    N    a-Tn Inspection Program Is credted Th. i. the sarne Issue as in quetion T 11.2 aboven              along with the waler cheansiry coorol progrnare 1or  lins R  lo which GALLrenoraot acnts-ime Inection tocortirm water chelnistry wontrd. Table 2credits N OTI progthrough rdererce tothe associaed Table I line lam,+
NRC Origina Type 304 slainless sled piping and fitting between drfyall Paid. Erach penetration X-14 and the 0" x 4C resdcr donmrstrean d M0-1201-5 wemepulaced with type 316L. Mairoest s$led.
This rayiressnarnudaowtrothe    oNchaastry program doeocriptimns In LRA Appendices Aand btoclmerlykidcal.,          the OraTimn Inpection Program willoorlirm the dfectivenes of e Water Chenistry Conror -SWM. Wter Cherislty Conrd - Aailiary Syslnea a the Waler Chardstry Control - Closed Cooling NI" progrars.
PNPS Lead Taylor. Ady Since she One-Timn Ispection (OTI) Progean Is applicable to aoch Paid. Erach water aranistry c<liro progan Ht is also amioadde eto ech line hen, tie credits a water Chimisry wontrd progran IRA Table 33.A Idicales that e Cto m-Tirne Impection Progran Is crealed along With th waer Choaisiry conrol progra1om for line ilere mI which GALL reonoranfoni see-ore pllupct Iocoolurc war.'
Thie Heam Is ctoeai t hem372.
cIOisry ctntolrd. Table 2crllas t*e OTI progran thlrough rdefr*nce S letoalald Toasl I lire ien Thie rooirns morranw ree toite cheanrty prog"e dwScrlpiorns In LRA Appendices Aand to clery Indicate Ow the One-Tine Iepej0io Progran willcolirm the sllelvenna d the Waler Chrerostry Control. BM. Waler Chonristry Contrl - Auxiliary Systanm aid We Walte Crari.ary Ccora - Cloed Coding Wale poogroms Thi iemn is cosed Io Nern 372 Fiort*uger.
88  Ac.paled IT 31-P-14                                                      No carbon sed larts InNte W oil systel ea sed to air -cwidoor      Paid. Erach  Nichols. Bill ar. Inctded lnacope for Iaa* renewal. Th. WRAwill be Table 31., laen3,1-4D Ib ed lank Indeed fuel oil                arweded tolrebraoi.he line Kam Intabe 332-7 oe carborn *led lysamaqxoeoad Ioair-Ldoor a*dm awiroremt. The                tan-to apoaed toair-oudoor . The discussionfor  b ine em &3140 GALLReport reewrnard AW Xl C9 Abovego.ld Sled                  will be aner      to Irate te line he Isar used Tatne. howee PNPS Iacreding a iffered prograrM Syslam Walkdown Program. This program Is oonaistert with        Thlsrerqdres asplertam    rr      a endrr  othN WRA GALL Report AMP X].IM . Exlernsl Surlacae W orini.
y No2rd 77
While Nh Ssteam Walkdown Program Ise aoooplable alterabe rAn"greexo Steel Tarts AWP eI nleapc.ileot howa.e the Atovegoud Sled Tates AMP                sncner prevenrive actiors aoocied. wilt A th are rd aterased in the System WalkdcownProra        Furherore NheGALL AM apecifieewall tickness rneurearndl of t          bortoam iK Ni s pqporld onte~e o*monene. Io.&#xfd;raions.
PIesse clarifyH the eoo tarks .we ca(ed wilh protective pairl ot oating Inacoo*lsr    ewith irdatry practie, and whether eadla orcaLlking Is applied atte Interface eale betwean t.Nabk and N. fbadation asm      pmrthe GALL MVl l.W9 Pleasa  sta.e how the tar* [a uppouted ft? ZIo 77-


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                           __Page 26]!1 Number Status   Request                                                     Response                                                        NRC        PNPS Lead 389  Closecl    T.1I.P.151                                                AB~dng eogrityProli-         wlillbecoveoped tW willalbbee tihe  Paid. Erach  Froebargem, aging tin-gusime d bolting Inlho e<ope olicense renewal.
James Davis - AMR -_ Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page,25]
Tae 33.1. lIem 1i.t143, I" steel bolting aed tions.
Number Status Request 387 Closed T.3I31-P-131 Table 3.1. 1,ier331.38 for SSooenponents arposed to treaed water '60C (>,1F).
b1irIngeosed to air -Iedoor esncrolieI (sduerel) or aire-  The Bolting Integi-ty Prograe wiilbeinmpleerield prile otho peeod Atoer (Externl). The GALLReportc mmmd. AM                d ederded opeation Inaoortdance withcomistrilne wnbe 3Z XI MieBtirg Ilngrity prom e howteer PNPS Is creiting a dffwwe pogram System Walkdown Progeein PNPS              Thie rep        maenenbimitothe LRA oirudedldescriptin    o d Irdc.ls hae thes*ystemi wallen progarn i. eintlat  lo    she Bolting Irlegrily Progamn leAtperosces Ae t B and to iartily XIM. Exlernal Surfaces Ibtitring Progrwen Howewer, the     where tin progran Isaglicate XI.tc AP does nt lave my preventive actin. wherleg th Boting Itegrity Prograni c*ders preo*entiveaction      THid hen I. closed to ltemn373 Pese Justify how the pvereive actios d GALL NA' XI.MISWe a.diressed inthe.ssten walkdown prograin 390  Acetoode IT.alt-P-lO(                                                ABolting WI-egrityProiaen willbdeviopedthat willgdrews            PalE, Erach Ugrfdtme iineing the effects of aging onbltling Inthe goopeolliceree Table 3.3it. itei all-O8. ke sled exlenal sluacem          reenwal. The Bolting Integiiy Proge"n wli be inplenmrled prlor to
Th. i. the sarne Issue as in quetion T 11.2 aboven Resonse Sims the OC Ti Inpection (OTI) Ptogram Is applice to each water cherritry contro prog*amn IfI alsoapicabe toeach Uni iem tHat credits a waler cIenistry cornrol prorarn LRA Tatbe a1I nrdates t
                                                  -
N he a-Tn Inspection Program Is credted along with the waler cheansiry coorol progrnare 1or lins R lo which GALL renoraot acnts-ime Inection tocortirm water chelnistry wontrd. Table 2credits N OTI progthrough rdererce tothe associaed Table I line lam,+
WaP<.ed toair--l'oor        rtdled (d(ermi),air Uldoor    tn period ofntedel ep*eral Inecoehrdee witht velnmi (Wc-e1). ad codenejton (dmernei). For those line itee        mwble 37 InTalle 2s whereinelsTale Ilin MenIs referenced 6or boiling, sa Issue s colestSonT. shsouldbefeel*tdrs          The WAAwillbecealehied tolncfulle FireePrdeliton IotPigan inth detaesono If the 3al1-58 df Table 3,1.
This rayiressnarnudaowtrothe oNchaastry program doeocriptimns In LRA Appendices Aand bto clmerly kidcal.,
teTable 33.2-10. LRApsge al-t23. for la tinelon            Th. reiled disagson Itxt will read as lol.ons Th. Systen eystl    which rerences line hnm 331-58, Fire Prclection  Walktown Progren mnnags Ioss of mn tral for extend surfaces Pio rn I. cradled Plesse justify whlyte Fire Preecteio      of gled onponnes. For menefire prblieion eymeii cofpotrmf.
the OraTimn Inpection Program willoorlirm the dfectivenes of e Water Chenistry Conror -SWM. Wter Cherislty Conrd - Aailiary Syslnea a the Waler Chardstry Control - Closed Cooling NI" progrars.
Proein- was eel IdMrlifien lthe dectasion odurnn of        the Fire Prldetim Piorg-n nll nmr" loss(Aieeli." The Ndte Tile Ill. ftemn3al-S8 or.LeVOewd thInLRAtoilude          lot the redled line inTaile 332-10 (sled hWis Va exposedlo tis progren                                                W~r)will be.l emkrm *B"o      1 E&deg;.
Thie Heam Is ctoeai t hem 372.
Thid requir enensen nt toft LRAtoInuclue descridionod tih Bolting Irlogr-ty Proga-n InA cpencse Aand Beand to busriy where the prog-en Is applicable T.de eirepeel ofId.s Ien I. closed to Nen M The FirePrtectPion porte of lids Hen reqries anarnaemdi      to the LRA Pa    2d    77
No carbon sed larts InNte W oil systel ea sed to air -cwidoor ar. Inctded lnacope for Iaa*
renewal. Th. WRA will be arweded tolrebraoi.he line Kam Intabe 332-7 oe carborn *led tan-to apoaed toair-oudoor. The discussion for b
ine em &3140 will be aner to Irate te line he ar Is used Thlsrerqdres asplertam rr endrr a
othN WRA NRC Pald. Erach PNPS Lead Fror-brger, 88 Ac.paled IT 31-P-14 Table 31., laen 3,1-4D Ib ed lank Indeed fuel oil lysam aqxoeoad Ioair-Ldoor a*dm awiroremt. The GALL Report reewrnard AW Xl C9 Abovego.ld Sled Tatne. howee PNPS Ia creding a iffered prograrM Syslam Walkdown Program. This program Is oonaistert with GALL Report AMP X].IM. Exlernsl Surlacae W orini.
While Nh Ssteam Walkdown Program Ise aoooplable alterabe rAn"greexo Steel Tarts AWP eI nleapc.ileot howa.e the Atovegoud Sled Tates AMP sncner prevenrive actiors aoocied. wilt A th are rd aterased in the System Walkdcown Prora Furherore Nhe GALL AM apecifiee wall tickness rneurearndl of t bortoam iK Ni s pqporld onte~e o *monene. Io.&#xfd;raions.
PIesse clarifyH the eoo tarks
.we ca(ed wilh protective pairl ot oating In acoo*lsr ewith irdatry practie, and whether eadla orcaLlking Is applied atte Interface eale betwean t. Nabk and N. fbadation asm pmr the GALL MVl l.W9 Pleasa sta.e how the tar* [a uppouted Paid. Erach Nichols. Bill ft? ZIo 77-


James Davis- AMR_- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                   Page 27 I Number Status Request                                                     Reponse                                                                NRC        PNPS Lead o91   [ce3ed  l331-P-I17                                         In Tale 352-6 on Page 35-82 of " LRA, the egng fecr for Ath             Paid. Erach Ungunddtuer.
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf
doaslorm corlonert peetration sealarl and searoc joint filler in Tabe 13.11NaIl l- 1. for 1d-sbnto fireebarler                a protected from welher nirmn*erw awecracking and clange In p tration sels    e xsaposedNoair-mtor a air Indoor        material Properties Depending lite specifio s         .i.adiorl,At Fire tortcoled PNPS credits Fire Protection Program and      Protection Progra-mor ie Sireute Irtorilorirg Program wil tles In'lot daciasion oolrn U thisalineAesswas rot        r-r.pge af       ctduot agog For dtaiifoatoir thea o-porni lit-
__Page 26]!1 Number Status Request 389 Closecl T.1I.P.151 Tae 33.1. lIem 1i.t143, I" steel bolting aed tions.
                                  .ead nthe auiliary systemm tales. Fire baSier seas we        airnswill be separaled iro individal line Ierns as ftofs walualed assltrntural oornjen      InSecti.. 35. Cracking anid tlit arge In material p uoperl  s.ofolasorr s.      ar  ODaot ft bllowing lit- it-manage by Ot Fire Prolection Proganm                        Peneration selsil(fire risect 5oo radialion) H/EN. FB, FILB,PB, SNS
b1ir Ingeosed to air -Iedoor esncrolieI (sduerel) or aire-Atoer (Externl). The GALL Reportc mmmd.
* Easlorrer *ProFecteal Irom weal-e *Craeocig Changs In Hoev.r, Insection 15. Tade 5.2-6. BuIkComvowliee,          trlelal propeties I Fir pro(eo tiortrlcrtures IMcniloring//iI.A&#xa3;1 12 onWsg 15-8z and 35-8m, where lineiltem 3.3.16 Is              (TP-7)*35I1-M *1C rvierced PFNIPSoredtIslbe Fire Protection Program and lie Shrrlures MAnitoringprogramn Howevr, line Sam            Smisio joir1 Allu7/FB. SNS2//Elasloer */Protected from weahtr 311641 ceae"IlCedit ret    sitrure mcriloring program Assa # Crawkrg Chige inerraeialpropert*e #Strr*es Montorina rrsllu d lafct,U S".uc.res or loing Program Is            FireProtu.li6n *V1I-I (A-th)*331-61 &C
AM XI MieBtirg Ilngrity prom e howteer PNPS Is creiting a dffwwe pogram System Walkdown Progeein PNPS Irdc.ls hae thes*ystemi wallen progarn i. eintlat lo XIM. Exlernal Surfaces Ibtitring Progrwen Howewer, the XI.tc AP does nt lave my preventive actin. wherleg th Boting Itegrity Prograni c*ders preo*entive action Pese Justify how the pvereive actios d GALL NA' XI.MIS We a.diressed inthe. ssten walkdown prograin 390 Acetoode IT.alt-P-lO(
                                      /t.enced i0addgiiece for Inspection d Weleorrc seal.,
Table 3.3it. itei all-O8. ke sled exlenal sluacem WaP<.ed toair--l'oor rtdled (d(ermi), air Uldoor (Wc-e1). ad codenejton (dmernei). For those line itee InTalle 2s where ine lsTale Ilin Men Is referenced 6or boiling, sa Issue s colestSonT.
                                  .c. Poess daily N both Programs wecredted for            Add ae bollowinglire Iter nwdng agrig lutrs fit pendration seals as sited In          Penetration setalt (fire rated) N EN. F5. PB. SNS N/Elastomer N Tabe 352-6, and If so., pmse        pselronwtthe LRA So      Flotacred from wemther NCracking Clan lnrrmalerialproperties #
shsould befeel*tdrs teTable 33.2-10. LRApsge al-t23. for la t inelon eystl which rerences line hnm 331-58, Fire Prclection Pio rn I. cradled Plesse justify whly te Fire Preecteio Proein-was eel IdMrlifien lthe dectasion odurnn of Tile Ill.
incude the Structures Isbiloring program InTable 3.3.1. FirsProtection 71.0-l(A-19) 3/11-61 lB Ilem a 1-61.
ftemn3al-S8 or.LeVOewd thInLRAtoilude tis progren
Penetration seslait (floot, radilatior) N/EN,FIB, PB. SNS 7 Elasloiner&*Protectedfrom weare#ul Cracking Chlgs I nmairial properties /*lrre*t-lurtoriloring NI MA-12 (TP-7)715&l-44 IC Seisrc Isolation joire/FB, F SNS*#Elaoorrnu 7/Protecled from weather N Crackrng Change in materal propertia 7 Fire protection I VItO-I                     110(A-l9)*11-AI
 
                                                                                                                        /D Saisrro latidin joinJin MS
===Response===
AB~dng eogrity Proli-wlillbecoveoped tW willalbbee tihe aging tin-gusime d bolting Inlho e<ope olicense renewal.
The Bolting Integi-ty Prograe wiilbeinmpleerield prile otho peeod d ederded opeation Inaoortdance withcomistrilne wnbe 3Z Thie rep maenenbimitothe LRA oirudedl o
descriptin d she Bolting Irlegrily Progamn leAtperosces Ae t B and to iartily where tin progran Is aglicate THid hen I. closed to ltemn 373 ABolting WI-egrity Proiaen willbdevioped that willgdrews iineing the effects of aging onbltling Inthe goope olliceree reenwal. The Bolting Integiiy Proge"n wli be inplenmrled prlor to tn period of ntedel ep*eral Inecoehrdee witht velnmi mwble 37 The WAA willbecealehied tolncfulle FireePrdeliton IotPigan inth detaesono If the 3al1-58 df Table 3,1.
Th. reiled disagson Itxt will read as lol.ons Th. Systen Walktown Progren mnnags I oss of mn tral for extend surfaces of gled onponnes. For mene fire prblieion eymeii cofpotrmf.
the Fire Prldetim Piorg-n nll nmr" loss (A ieeli." The Ndte lot the redled line inTaile 332-10 (sled hWis Va exposed lo W~r) will be.l emkrm *B"o 1 E&deg;.
Thid requir enensen nt toft LRA toInuclue descridiono d tih Bolting Irlogr-ty Proga-n InA cpencse Aand Beand to busriy where the prog-en Is applicable T.de eire peel of Id.s Ien I. closed to Nen M The FirePrtectPion porte of lids Hen reqries anarnaemdi to the LRA NRC PNPS Lead Paid. Erach Froebargem,
: PalE, Erach Ugrfdtme Pa 2d 77
 
James Davis-AMR_- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 27 I Number Status Request o91
[ce 3ed l331-P-I17 Tabe 13.11 NaIl l-1.
for 1d-sbnto fireebarler p
tration sels e
xsaposed Noair -mtor a air Indoor tortcoled PNPS credits Fire Protection Program and tles In'lot daciasion oolrn U thisaline Aess was rot
.ead nthe auiliary systemm tales. Fire baSier seas we walualed assltrntural oornjen InSecti.. 35. Cracking anid tlit arge In material p uoperl
: s. of olasorr
: s.
ar manage by Ot Fire Prolection Proganm Hoev.r, In section 15. Tade 5.2-6. BuIkComvowliee, onWsg 15-8z and 35-8m, where lineiltem 3.3.16 Is rvierced PFNIPS oredtIs lbe Fire Protection Program and lie Shrrlures MAnitoring programn Howevr, line Sam 311641 cea ret e"IlCedit sitrure mcriloring program Assa rrsllu d lafct, U S".uc.res or loing Program Is
/t.enced i0add giiece for Inspection d Weleorrc seal.,
.c. Poess daily N both Programs wecredted for nwdng agrig lutrs fit pendration seals as sited In Tabe 352-6, and If so., pmse pselronwt the LRA So incude the Structures Isbiloring program InTable 3.3.1.
Ilem a 1-61.
Reponse NRC PNPS Lead In Tale 352-6 on Page 35-82 of " LRA, the egng fecr for Ath Paid. Erach Ungunddtuer.
doaslorm corlonert peetration sealarl and searoc joint filler in a protected from welher nirmn*erw awe cracking and clange In material Properties Depending lite specifio s  
.i.adiorl, At Fire Protection Progra-mo r ie Sireute Irtorilorirg Program wil r-r.pge af ctdu ot agog For dtaiifoatoir thea o-porni lit-airns will be separaled iro individal line Ierns as ftofs ODaot ft bllowing lit-it-Peneration selsil(fire risect 5oo radialion) H/EN. FB, FILB, PB, SNS
* Easlorrer *ProFecteal Irom weal-e *Craeocig Changs In trlelal propeties I Fir pro(eo tiortrlcrtures IMcniloring //iI.A&#xa3;1 12 (TP-7)*35I1-M  
*1C Smisio joir1 Allu7/FB. SNS2//Elasloer */Protected from weahtr
# Crawkrg Chige inerraeial propert*e #Strr*es Montorina FireProtu.li6n *V1I-I (A-th)*331-61 &C Add ae bollowing lire Iter Penetration setalt (fire rated) N EN. F5. PB. SNS N/ Elastomer N Flotacred from wemther NCracking Clan lnrrmalerial properties #
FirsProtection 71.0-l(A-19) 3/11-61 lB Penetration seslait (floot, radilatior) N/EN, FIB, PB. SNS 7 Elasloiner &*Protected from weare#ul Cracking Chlgs I nmairial properties /*lrre*t-l urtoriloring NI MA-12 (TP-7)715&l-44 IC Seisrc Isolation joire /FB, F
SNS*#Elaoorrnu 7/Protecled from weather N Crackrng Change in materal propertia 7 Fire protection I VItO-I 110(A-l9)*11-AI  
/D Saisrro latidin join Jin MS
* Elaslomno I Proecled from weather I Cracling Change in ntesri properties I0Sruciuretw irorrting #
* Elaslomno I Proecled from weather I Cracling Change in ntesri properties I0Sruciuretw irorrting #
III6/-12 (TP-7)l1351-41 *IC TNs r.rers aanamerdrnw jolla LRA Pa 27d ;77
III6/-12 (TP-7)l1351-41 *IC TNs r.rers aanamerdrnw jolla LRA Pa 27d ;77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf..                                                                                                                                                       Page 28]
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf..
Number Status Request                                                             Response                                                                NRC        PNIPS Lead 39  Aooeptd jT.331-P-181                                                        PNPS bee edged dliver fir.prip wilthvonorv addtessed In                Paid, Erach  Fractrger, Table 322-9. The fud oil SLiy lolts dead driv flrepurp Is Table 3        c31,13.1-64 for sled pipirU piping Ite                                                  IrcludcodInTable 112-7. The rneieAm      deeta sled piping wilh of aoanfp , aod piping dlerwcs apoed tocfS dl. The                alfuel oilIrnalr    alrov ol In Table 332-7 orsVofuel cuply Irmel ofl Ire Ile    to addrlha to daed-dlven fire purrp.          line does eol credt "IeFire Prolecton Preyare.      lthmc ft wtich Is why *t Fire PFoecton Prograrn In reoocrsrrcld by          p1ro'anr cradiled inTbloe 132-7 oref fuel ely          line provide en It GALL Report pNPS sIes toit l1ine                itehr wasnor    acceptalie ailairaive alcroach ll rca-e ft imlects,deagir In csed Lose f rrheleriel deled orponerwts ecposed to lid            Order toS e eveoneistercy with NURE- I0I fts LRAwill be
Page 28]
                                .i was.alddrsed by olher Ife Irn-ledingline hrre 33.1              revised IDcredit the, Fire Ptdectio Prorra. tLRATablAe332-7will 2C and "II 3Z The Firs Proleclion prvoran specfies tO                be revisedcoaed ailnadii<-al line Iter Socredt t Firs Prolecthv to dad drivr lrepcnr be perioically lestedIo ensre                  Prom So  lorrege te lid souplyl                  lol le Diesel ireadntion thot      lid c        lire 0:8 plefowmft. Ihe le d knlior.        Fuid loktirng Progearn TH* will also rumires*vw-e Soline PNPSB..131 hee reltaken "r xcgepion tooits tel ard                her31al-64 sinee n.      cw linehr willepecily 31-64 Mse.
Number Status Request  
1sidmtlidfie as being conmisted wilh te GALLprograen              Table I hmer M-eam., 1.111. FirsPraoectlion prograr Is rot edled In lire Ierr a      320                                              The reudrgte anarnoleml        ISee  RA Pleag, lmilylI'IPNPS be edged driv fllrepuy a fif rnd, sled naoeplo bltaker See.t GALLReport AP.
H PNPS dos have e deda driver Ire purp where Int IRA saclion, IS Caddras ed Is                l3the Fire Prolecaion program wedled 393  Claed  ITI3.1I-P-I9l                                                      The tlemral vorponris d the hr exchnger holicg twoe            se      Paid, Eract  Orliod,,J ok poteriael Smbeing gpoed teea vorbretion d low leWrimatre Table 3.11, Ith 3I31-72 for        msled HVAC dcing ard            dloyed coalirg water ard Ngh dowpdrn Irdoor dyrywdladr wltch ocipornls Interna surlscelea opined bvorcdereairon              oovid reait (heefh nor awIodl) Inwondeceadivr onthe yoolng (Irmred). However. tloe IszoI-.llrlnTdle 2where fnis              cil*    would beoidlecled Inthe tbaon doe lto.sirg Table I inie hremIs rdmecced This line hm.Is inTable              Codeeetion was also Ielmtified onthe csnireodvld asmed 312-3. RBCCW syslrm ad theocnponran Is had                        scrace odthe feed .cP.er houeing ctoloee poleald dtof geoherger hxingFPNPS estat Int dvcugion codurn                    hewing sLflee eorymaluredeorwnreran df tho oing veil hIirg df lire 3 1-72 t      looS.df rrerial d sled vorrponat            laws O or eW to    Se dew poit d toe erocrreig orIne rnll oerfaleo* aped    s      SovordO-*elion Is -      godby  dywdl. These oirvirorre*tra wine comreivaelvy Ior'ified aere ft Syste Wlkdown ingrant The Syer Wkdown                          Wh-0 theteypected nirovimerl would be intoo air withrno Progeare mc gas beeo          dof    erial for calmed -aton lied  vonnoledion ireese  toding waler tleqeralre Is nornasly cornoan bsyl      i&#xfd;lu c-speclonodfaterdl elacas For              reiutarned is - 6F. Spuertn          ikdownwascredled because to yer mwhrme Ilrte,-l caibo sleedsurfaces ear posed to            oipoclod envirormner for bot fto lmed ard aImternal      soralea a oterlnal edaca. atrter-l n!ivin                                    woUd bee . ge, In ither cas.
seraoes  oordtioc wllhbe relren lived Intereal elucefe.
This, low d rnlmial on Inrlernel carbon sliedalulae Is also naer d bye. Syiern Walkelwn Progre Please dlarily how PNPS            xroIlcd to the inrleo l slaisce df to hra      chenger Is  l        earneas tot elernl elurfacein the RBCCWsyslmm P'w 2d      27


James Davis - AMR - Reportoto the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                              Page 29 Number Status  Request                                                    Response                                                           NRC         PNPS Lead 394  Acc.9el  [Tr332-P-01l                                                Simns Iewsges Irierrew and tlerntesenuaces withtOe sare            Peitd Erach Froreberger, Wosrld and envirarnerls, the Systen Wftdown Progrem Coantpw typeseilt. Ihouing .ad turbo clh'ge, InTable        described InRt10 lis more aprocpiate prins  e aan oa tae line taere 132-1 Fire protection -Water ryster and piping InTable     InTable 332-9 tet hwe Indoor air (ire) as an eswlronmert atd 332-f10 FireProtection - He*n syete- raeri-e Tale          crelt tf Fire pratection Pregarc In adolitio line Item 32,1-32 221, Item 3tZI-3      ThsTable line Itsetaddeeses sled      should include the Fire Protection PrFgarn sirce Tatle 332-10 ping mad dating compon~en atd Interral urfaces              InmluaesHalon,yeten piping Imterpalsurfaces tIre credit ft Fire Opcped soair-irelor uncrrametmlad (iramre) erwirorartee    FpateactionProgr-a and ratlp blthe line ian.
===Response===
Discussion Wdmn at item 3.2. 1-32 credts System Walkdowart,Prodc Surveilla*ce ant Franltive                Therisreranarernw        mlaw lethe ILRA Wrlrarenete mad One-Tim Inrepection prograns. Howeaer, the Tate 332-9 and Tale 332- 10 sporan-s idenetfied tanse cr-edt Fire or-tection Proaa-n wth ic rat credlled in thedlscussaon ciid.rn diten 321-3Z Furthwrmore, the preparn deecription of LRA Apedix El 1.131. Fire Proection Progan, does rt IncludeIrepealion aft. tabe Iderfied aoe-parets.
NRC PNIPS Lead 39 Aooeptd jT.331-P-181 PNPS bee edged dliver fir.prip wilthvonorv addtessed In Paid, Erach Fractrger, Table 322-9. The fud oil SLiy lolts dead driv flrepurp Is Table 3
Plee claritythe olsorermrcy betIwn the cradled prOgar In intle 321-32 art ft proararn crad1ed tot ft aboveIdntified coa we types. Also. ptese jstity wly In Fire Prateitio prengarl descriptian does nt addres ir-pectiof'a lea coreoponartypee Inthee two esearns ar enhance  te p-ograemIairclude tee impectioms W5  Closed    rT1332-P-021                                              Ouringtheperlormarce aroutinr n~iteirawe ancanwweeli                Paid. Erach  Froaellrger.
: c31, Ite 13.1-64 for sled pipirU piping Ircludcod InTable 112-7. The rneieAm of deeta sled piping wilh aoanfp, aod piping dlerwcs apoed tocfS dl. The alfuel oilIrnalr alrov ol In Table 332-7 ors Vofuel cuply Irmel ofl Ire Ile to addrlha to daed-dlven fire purrp.
corain lubricating ol. vieui Ir-pectiore ofathe corqnonarts Coponel type headmcerge latee InTable 332-4,                world Identify degsaded cordlions OWl Cocld beattributed t*t Emergency Dieed Genertor eynten atd Tate 332-9, Fre        Inbelctive it Arreyuie Piog-are Th. corective actior p-oag as protection - %.er splelse wme fard  itr  copperalloy apd  PNPS hs slam Ithresholdtortst bortictcaio oddegraded e*posed bolubricating cil ervirorert whidch ,rderence      codetic,. etchthat corrosian a cracking ofcoatpants woadd be Tate 321, Ite 321-9 PNIPS ony creditel tie l               identilied aspart oafiepaog-ar      Thercisewoaoperlrng kAeysis prorage Tne heniate easel ryetior                  expererces at PNPS toate last lv vyerl did not Identity aty T.31.3.                                                     cordliac reports U indiralcedan irollective dl anlysis prograrn or 8t    eidrfied dagaladd carnern Itcodaiion etcheas corresin ar craclkng Ins lubricaing oetemrironerrll This reisi cloperaltng eapederce al PNPS emaes In lieu o a stier.SnImpectimo to prakle      rdiirrtion oath effec dtives the 0I4Arnlyst.
line does eol credt "Ie Fire Prolecton Preyare.
Proretn            i See response 1. itern 376 Paw 29d 77
lthmc ft wtich Is why *t Fire PFoecton Prograrn In reoocrsrrcld by p1ro'anr cradiled inTbloe 132-7 ore f
fuel ely line provide en It GALL Report pNPS sIes toit l1ine itehr wasnor acceptalie ailairaive alcroach ll rca-e ft imlects, deagir In csed Lose f rrheleriel deled orponerwts ecposed to lid Order toS e eveoneistercy with NURE-I0I fts LRAwill be
.i was. alddrsed by olher Ife Irn-leding line hrre 33.1 revised ID credit the, Fire Ptdectio Prorra.
tLRATablAe332-7 will 2C and "II 3Z The Firs Proleclion prvoran specfies tO be revised coaed ailnadii<-al line Iter Socredt t Firs Prolecthv to dad drivr lrepcnr be perioically lested Io ensre Prom So lorrege te lid souply l ire adntion lol le Diesel thot lid c lire 0:8 plefowm ft. Ihe le d knlior.
Fuid loktirng Progearn TH* will also rumires *vw-e So line PNPSB..131 hee reltaken "r xcgepion to oits tel ard her31al-64 sinee n.
cw linehr willepecily 31-64 Mse.
1s idmtlidfie as being conmisted wilh te GALL prograen Table I hmer M-eam.,
1.111. FirsPraoectlion prograr Is rot edled In lire Ierr a 320 The reudrgte anarnoleml ISee RA
: Pleag, lmilylI'IPNPS be edged driv fllre puy a fi f rnd, sled naoeplo bltaker See.t GALL Report AP.
H PNPS dos have e deda driver Ire purp where Int IRA saclion, IS C addras ed l3 Is the Fire Prolecaion program wedled 393 Claed ITI3.1I-P-I9l The tlemral vorponris d the hr exchnger holicg twoe se Paid, Eract Orliod,,J ok poteriael Sm being gpoed teea vorbretion d low leWrimatre Table 3.11, Ith 3I31-72 for msled HVAC dcing ard dloyed coalirg water ard Ngh dowpdrn Irdoor dyrywdl adr wltch ocipornls Interna surlscelea opined bvorcdereairon oovid reait (heefh nor awIodl) Inwondeceadivr onthe yoolng (Irmred). However. tloe Is zoI-.llrlnTdle 2where fnis cil*
would beoidlecled Inthe tbaon doe lto.sirg Table I inie hrem Is rdmecced This line hm. Is inTable Codeeetion was also Ielmtified onthe csnireodvld asmed 312-3. RBCCW syslrm ad theocnponran Is had scrace od the feed
.cP.er houeing cto loee poleald dtof geoherger hxingF PNPS estat Int dvcugion codurn hewing sLflee eorymalure deorwnreran df tho oing veil hIirg df lire 3 1-72 t looS. df rrerial d sled vorrponat laws O or eW to Se dew poit d toe erocrreig or In e rnll oerfaleo*
s aped So vordO-*elion Is -
god by dywdl. These oirvirorre*tra wine comreivaelvy Ior'ified aere ft Syste Wlkdown ingrant The Syer Wkdown Wh-0 the teypected nirovimerl would be intoo air withrno Progeare mc gas beeo d of erial for calmed -aton lied vonnoledion iree se toding waler tleqeralre Is nornasly cornoan bsyl i&#xfd;lu c-speclon odf aterdl elacas For reiutarned is - 6F. Spuertn ikdown wascredled because to yer mwhrme Ilrte,-l caibo sleed surfaces e ar posed to oipoclod envirormner for bot fto lmed ard aImternal soralea n !ivin a oterlnal edaca. atrter-l woUd bee. ge, In ither cas.
seraoes oordtioc wllhbe relren lived Intereal elucefe.
This, low d rnlmial on Inrle rnel carbon slied alulae Is also naer d bye. Syiern Walkelwn Progre Please dlarily how PNPS xroIlcd to the inrleo l slaisce df to hra chenger Is l
earne as tot elernl elurface in the RBCCWsyslmm P'w 2d 27


James Davis -AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                   Page 30 1 Number Status Request                                                         Resonse                                                                NRC          P-PSLead 39  Closetd  [r.32-P-03                                                      Duringth. peorlirroncs ofroutnerreirde-wnne noorvpone o ow            Pdlo, Erach   Frorme*gb.
James Davis - AMR - Reportoto the NRC.doc.pdf Page 29 Number Status Request 394 Acc.9el
seortit lubricating;cit. deeudtrpeystione of thosewqine-ona Cwno1 tyvpeshod ecea w lubese inTable 332-5.                   "nod.4ide-dy dsgeod sordlor thaUcouldbefrihbued l                      loaen Station Blackou desel General c, yslem ard Table 332-6,         Ineffective Cil Anlysis Progran The corrective action progrw a Security DissI Generaltor syolernwetrade trom sled ad         PNPS hs alow Throealdfor ft tcolictor of dguraded epose.l lo arto`Tel st.lvr-..eO         ofhdoil with an aging sordtihOreeuch fl-.t scorreio ar cracking of c*ornlers would be elet of tredoctic of hlot trwanfe dot Wointogr     which       Watilfielas pet of fis progran The revisewof spering relere-ce Taole 341.ahemr34.1-10. PNPS only orecits the         soperie-ce Sf PNPS or the last five yeae drs         Idellty anty Cf nlysis progtant ThN hosueI.im sae as In quisleon              ordtion reports OW indicated onltrofective dl analyuis progran or T.3.31.3                                                        Ot Ide-sifieddgraded w iv, a I corftiore euch as corrosion or racking Insa lubtricaln oil environrnrot This reviewoof opering Aso,plme claritywt/neoft.        aove convoow Ihtos                epe-ience o PNPS se*ain RIranof ane-hire Iimpection to kleorutie Iodinre      r.hne.- heIme- ide-WitifiosWlote        Provide co:firir-ion of Ow oectiveso         the ail Arnlyuis I.V -    toh    fey hove thle soa REAP sontntion.              Provwen Dicing the plot five yeear, nme visua Irpectie of cwr*Tptr containing IsXing oil hove beer pelornod during oc-roclive and preve-tive rmrteanoce ecfvitim. The visul Iepectiwo of see oorrp:wws would Neotifydoadul c*dtioiwe uch as corrosion or cracking tow oould besatribued loon Irnletios 01 Airetyais Poreogm PNPS hte low tfivhod lot t. Mdotificationof dagralod contiwns suchtha corrosion ocrcrcking of owrwos woud be ilrsifled d '"'wed Iho s. se-rtlivo action prog-am No cordtion reports ltdi *nf fl*e d   lgraded wrporO eoidteom.
[Tr332-P-01l Coantpw typese ilt. Ihouing.ad turbo clh'ge, InTable 132-1 Fire protection -Water ryster and piping In Table 332-f10 FireProtection - He*n syete-raeri-e Tale 221, Item 3tZI-3 ThsTable line Itsetaddeeses sled ping mad dating compon~en atd Interral urfaces Opcped so air-irelor uncrrametml ad (iramre) erwirorartee Discussion Wdmn at item 3.2. 1-32 credts System Walkdowart, Prodc Surveilla*ce ant Franltive Wrlrarenete mad One-Tim Inrepection prograns. Howeaer, the Tate 332-9 and Tale 332-10 sporan-s idenetfied tanse cr-edt Fire or-tection Proaa-n wth ic rat credlled in thedlscussaon ciid.rn diten 321-3Z Furthwrmore, the preparn deecription of LRA Apedix El 1.131. Fire Proection Progan, does rt Include Irepealion aft. tabe Iderfied aoe-parets.
such as crooirn wrcracking Ina lubricating dolenvirornr          weer Irstioted ass resl dtee -     inectiwone. The eepla Irpecliwoe S PNPS "e- in lieu o         nwe-fire Inspecion to provid.
Plee clarity the olsorermrcy betIwn the cradled prOgar In intle 321-32 art ft proararn crad1ed tot ft above Idntified coa we types. Also. ptese jstity wly In Fire Prateitio prengarl descriptian does nt addres ir-pectiof'a lea coreoponar typee In thee two esearns ar enhance te p-ograem Iairclude tee impectioms W5 Closed rT1332-P-021 Coponel type head mcerge latee InTable 332-4, Emergency Dieed Genertor eynten atd Tate 332-9, Fre protection -%.er splelse wme fard itr copper alloy apd e*posed bolubricating cil ervirorert whidch
,rderence Tate 321, Ite 321-9 PNIPS ony creditel tie l
kAeysis prorage Tne heniate eas el ryetior T.31.3.
 
===Response===
Simns I ewsges Irierrew and tlerntes enuaces withtOe sare Wosrld and envirarnerls, the Systen Wftdown Progrem described InRt10 is l
more aprocpiate prins aan e
oa ta e line taere InTable 332-9 tet hwe Indoor air (ire) as an eswlronmert atd crelt tf Fire pratection Pregarc In adolitio line Item 32,1-32 should include the Fire Protection PrFgarn sirce Tatle 332-10 Inmluaes Halon,yeten piping Imterpal surfaces tIre credit ft Fire Fpateaction Progr-a and ratlp blthe line ian.
Therisreranarernw mlaw lethe ILRA NRC PNPS Lead Peitd Erach Froreberger, Ouringtheperlormarce aroutinr n~iteirawe ancanwweeli Paid. Erach Froaellrger.
corain lubricating ol. vieui Ir-pectiore ofa the corqnonarts world Identify degsaded cordlions OWl Cocld beattributed t*t Inbelctive it Arreyuie Piog-are Th. corective actior p-oag as PNPS hs slam Ithreshold tortst bortictcaio od degraded codetic,. etchthat corrosian a cracking of coatpants woadd be identilied aspart oafiepaog-ar Thercisewoaoperlrng expererces at PNPS toa te last lv vyerl did not Identity aty cordliac reports U indiralced an irollective dl anlysis prograrn or 8t eidrfied dagaladd carnern Itcodaiion etcheas corresin ar craclkng Ins lubricaing oet emrironerrll This reisi cloperaltng eapederce al PNPS emaes In lieu o a stier.Sn Impectimo to prakle rdiirrtion oa th effec dtives the 0I4 Arnlyst.
Proretn i
See response 1. itern 376 Paw 29d 77
 
James Davis -AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 30 1 Number Status Request 39 Closetd
[r.32-P-03 Cwno1 tyvpes hod ecea w lubese inTable 332-5.
Station Blackou desel General c, yslem ard Table 332-6, Security DissI Generaltor syolern wetrade trom sled ad epose.l lo arto`Tel st.lvr-..eO ofhd oil with an aging elet of tredoctic of hlot trwanfe dot Wointogr which relere-ce Taole 341. ahemr 34.1-10. PNPS only orecits the Cf nlysis progtant ThN hosue I. im sae as In quisleon T.3.31.3 Aso, plme clarity wt/ne oft.
aove convoow Ihtos kleorutie Iodinre r.hne.- he Ime-ide-Witifios Wlote I.V -
toh fey hove thle soa REAP sontntion.
397 Closed
[T3.32-P-04O Stoa co ore ypes I"e-rornell. tublingr valve body In Table 332-14-1%. Oat-as syst*rn rdlerence Table 341.
ltem 341-13. whichcrelts waler chemistry and oe-Urn.
ilmpction proganr ifr verifcation Howver-the ltae 2 Jim Itene do nc Crudt. veMiticoast prograen This 1ste Is I.
as ueatiho 0.31.2 arN T.33t.
Resonse NRC Duringth. peorlirroncs ofroutne rreirde-wnne noorvpone o ow Pdlo, Erach seortit lubricating; cit. deeud trpeystione of those wqine-ona "nod.4ide-dy dsgeod sordlor l thaUcouldbefrihbued loaen Ineffective Cil Anlysis Progran The corrective action progrw a PNPS hs alow Throeald for ft tcolictor of dguraded sordtihOre euch fl-.t scorreio ar cracking of c*ornlers would be Watilfiel as pet of fis progran The revisew of spering soperie-ce Sf PNPS or the last five yeae drs Idellty anty ordtion reports OW indicated onltrofective dl analyuis progran or Ot Ide-sified dgraded w iv, a I corftiore euch as corrosion or racking Insa lubtricaln oil environrnrot This reviewo of opering epe-ience o PNPS se*ain RI ran of ane-hire Iimpection to Provide co:firir-ion of Ow oectiveso the ail Arnlyuis Provwen Dicing the plot five yeear, nme visua Irpectie of cwr*Tptr containing IsXing oil hove beer pelornod during oc-roclive and preve-tive rmrteano ce ecfvitim. The visul Iepectiwo of see oorrp:wws would Neotify doadul c*dtioi we uch as corrosion or cracking tow oould besatribued loon Irnletios 01 Airetyais Poreogm PNPS hte low tfivhod lot t.
Mdotification of dagralod contiwns such tha corrosion ocrcrcking of owrwos woud be ilrsifled d '"'wed Iho s. se-rtlivo action prog-am No cordtion reports ltdi nf fl*e d lgraded wrporO eoidteom.
such as crooirn wr cracking Ina lubricating dol envirornr weer Irstioted ass resl dtee -
inectiwone. The eepla Irpecliwoe S PN PS "e-in lieu o nwe-f ire Inspecion to provid.
oortirrntion oft. electivenesof the Oil Ardysis PFiogto TN.o Itf Is clo eto Itu 376.
oortirrntion oft. electivenesof the Oil Ardysis PFiogto TN.o Itf Is clo eto Itu 376.
397 Closed  [T3.32-P-04O                                                    Sice he Oe-Tirne Inspction (OTI) Prog-oo is       b liabie loeach       Patid. Erach Frordcege.
Sice he Oe-Tirne Inspction (OTI) Prog-oo is b
wClea chlnistry wordroiPograt. itIs also applicalelo oeach lire Stoa co ore        ypes I"e-rornell. tublingr valve body In      ernht crredis a wale- chaistry worol program LRA Table Table 332-14-1%. Oat-as syst*rn rdlerence Table 341.            341 Irdcal tlthf ha      Ore-Tine e*npection   Progran Is credled ltem 341-13. whichcrelts waler chemistry and oe-Urn.            along will, the water chlrnstry wontrdprograne horline hewmfor ilmpction proganr ifr verifcation Howver- the ltae 2 Jim        WhichGALLrsconrrds arse-line Irepeclion loorirm wader Itene do nc Crudt . veMiticoast prograen This 1ste              cirnritry corol.d Toate 2 credts m CMiprograrnthrough I.
liabie loeach Patid. Erach wClea chlnistry wordroi Pograt. it Is also applicalelo oeach lire ern ht crredis a wale-chaistry worol program LRA Table 341 Irdcal ha tlthf Ore-Tine e*npection Progran Is credled along will, the water chlrnstry wontrd prograne hor line hewm for Which GALL rsconrrds arse-line Irepeclion loorirm wader cirnritry corol.d Toate 2 credts m CMi prograrn through rde-ence losth associated Table I tire iet TN.s raequre* an acre-l lothe chehistry p*ov-un doacripin inLAA Agerdoes A ard Bfio leely r-dcateo Sn a. Ore-Tine Ihpection Progaun willoortlirm *t efectiveness ofthe Water Cherislry Cotrol - BMW. Wale-Cherrisiry Cotrld. Auxiliary Systems and ine Waler Cherrtry Cortrod - Closed Codling Waler pro-one.
Is    as ueatiho 0.31.2 arN T.33t.                      rde-ence losthassociated Table I tire iet TN.sraequre* an acre-l         lothe chehistry p*ov-un doacripin inLAA Agerdoes A ard Bfio leely r-dcateoSn a. Ore-Tine Ihpection Progaun willoortlirm *t efectiveness ofthe Water Cherislry Cotrol - BMW. Wale- Cherrisiry Cotrld . Auxiliary Systems and ine Waler Cherrtry Cortrod - Closed Codling Waler pro-one.
This teis closed to uern 372 P-PS Lead Frorme*gb.
This teis     closed to uern372 Pa-g 30d 77
Frordcege.
Pa-g 30d 77
 
James Davis - AMR_- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf..
Page 31]
Number Status Request 39 Closed (T.132-P-CMJ Stdrds stoed copoee tpem
'fioeewdf.
toing asd veato.
InTaolo e 332-1419. Cit-Gas s
-lee rdereree Table 3AtI, iee 341-14, whichorodls waler ChweeSVy and oe-time Inspection prograrn toe verilication. Honwver te ito. 2lieu fler-s do M wedt the voilication prgo L The lathesmoe 0ssqes.ie-.
03312 and T.331.2 MW Closed
'r.132-P-06]
Sted onpoerl types saeojtbr.
hw sscenger slell,-roe, pipirng puep casing, 0te-reodl, and valve body InTable 332-14-19. O1-Gesystem edoe-e Tabe 34?. Ie-341-a wthichreditewalerdteesley and oe-tim Inspedion progran lor verification. However the talds 2tine Ilte-do re seadit tfh verifiolote progra THs Is thu
.seI.
qts ueeasltion 0331.2 and T.331.2
 
===Response===
S-thews9 GesTine I upecIs-l (OTfi Peopen Is eppioall tossach water berenistry ce-trd prope ft Is also epplicable to eah line lIem list sreols swaole cheosery wt progrpme WA Taele 34.1 Iedes. that. Ore-Time epeltion Peog*em Is ea.dted Wong wbhfw waler chlrstry wordl pnogrene lot line It" for which GALL recommends aone-itrue Iepeion t toe-tirm water th"slry o-rled. Table 2credtes hu OTI propaen through rdereace toWhe associated Table I line ltent This resiqre anroeremou lothe chenisle peograem deseiptions in LRA Apis-doe A asd B to olsarly idicate that th Oe-Tim ilnsppeioe Program willcoef[rm ft eolectiveness of th Waler Cheeistry Coilrd - SMa.
al*er Chetnstry Coetrol - ALiliary Systlee and the Waler Chenistry Coderol -Closed Cooling Water progrn Thisfie
.close b
ltern 35Z Sice 9he One-Timn Inlpection (OTI) Progen Is e icte to each wmter chseietry Cwerol prograe, ft Is also gicaloee to ch line item hw cretls water olmslry oetrol program WA TeTte 341 Inecales 9w uhe OCuTiee kIpection Pograom is ceedled along wit
" water chemeistry worol propre-lor tine itees to whlch GALL recoreee aeo e-tinu Inpection towceirm weter ctwenistry werod. Table 2 creeits the OTI prograpem Werooh rdserce tot seste lacted Table I line ieen.
This e-sres annexewroeul loh echeltry ogropm descr0iwe In LRA tperdoes A and B Is cleery Iodicate the the WaC-Tinu b-pection Propam willworirm the ellectveruss df the Waler Chere*rley Cnterod - Ban. VWV"e Chteristry Codtrel - Auxiliety ystey n ad Wa Water Chenistry Coderod - Closed Cosirng wl progrnsr This Ite is closed to ten 372 The aqtorqiesio entrie she Wa last lirseve.dres leo the line In Tabe 332-4-27, RWCU ryste, sled wepaee type It eChev shill, InVesled waler orviroent wilthean a died of tossde
.ere. areVll.C2-14 (A-25).31-47, ard D.
This resires anaodwtelothe LRA.
NRC PNPS Lead Pstet. Erech Froeabarger.
Pedl, Erach FPrelrger, 400 Acoeted (T.132-P-`7]
Table3.32-14-27. RFWCUsysle, steed ooeelnert type hostel esobseer "Isl. In Vrowed waler e&#xfd;resi wrl wimthn sOng efect d o Iw oenetial, PNPS credte Water Ch-etistry COeltd -Closed Codling Waler progrpm and reerenses Table 3S3, line iten 331-17. However, tieu flee 331-17 afrheses Waler Chereistry Ce-troe -.WA
: program, Shtid tine Iter 13i1-47 be referenced whch adlressv the Waler Ciereistey Codedo. Closed Costing VWalecrlefu se-Mu EAP coeetentie? Plate asev4ule-the W.A acso rrdvy.
Pat.. Erach Ungerfditer, aep 31 d 77


James Davis - AMR_- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf ..                                                                                                          .                                  Page 31]
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 32 i Number Status Request
Number Status   Request                                                       Response                                                          NRC          PNPS Lead 39  Closed  (T.132-P-CMJ                                                S-thews9    GesTine IupecIs-l (OTfi Peopen Is eppioall tossach    Pstet. Erech  Froeabarger.
water berenistryce-trd prope ft Is also epplicableto eah line Stdrds stoed copoee tpem            'fioeewdf. toing asd      lIem list sreols swaole cheosery wt progrpme WA Taele veato. InTaoloe 332-1419. Cit-Gas s        -leerdereree  34.1 Iedes. that . Ore-Time epeltion Peog*em Is ea.dted Table 3AtI, iee 341-14, whichorodls waler ChweeSVyand        Wong wbhfw waler chlrstry wordl pnogrene lot line It"        for oe-time Inspection prograrn toeverilication. Honwver te      which GALL recommends aone-itrue Iepeion t toe-tirm water ito. 2lieu fler-s do M wedt the voilication prgo L The        th"slry o-rled. Table 2credtes hu OTI propaen through lathesmoe                    03312 0ssqes.ie-. and T.331.2      rdereace toWheassociated Table I line ltent This resiqre anroeremou lothe chenisle peograem      deseiptions in LRAApis-doe A asd B to olsarly idicate that th Oe-Tim ilnsppeioe Program willcoef[rm ft eolectiveness ofth Waler Cheeistry Coilrd - SMa. al*erChetnstry Coetrol - ALiliary Systlee and the Waler Chenistry Coderol -Closed Cooling Water progrn Thisfie    .close    ltern b    35Z MW  Closed    'r.132-P-06]                                                Sice 9heOne-Timn Inlpection (OTI) Progen Is e icte to each        Pedl, Erach    FPrelrger, wmter chseietry Cwerol prograe, ft Is also gicaloee to ch line Sted onpoerl types saeojtbr. hw sscenger slell,-roe,        hw item      cretls water olmslry oetrol program WA TeTte pipirngpuep casing, 0te-reodl, and valve body InTable        341 Inecales 9w uhe      OCuTiee kIpection Pograom is ceedled 332-14-19. O1-Gesystem edoe-e Tabe 34?. Ie-                    along wit " water chemeistry worol propre- lor tine itees to 341-a wthichreditewalerdteesley and oe-tim                    whlch GALLrecoreee aeo        e-tinu Inpection towceirm weter Inspedion progran lor verification. However the talds 2tine  ctwenistry werod. Table 2 creeits the OTI prograpem Werooh Ilte- do re seadittfh verifiolote progra      THs Is thu      rdserce tot seste lacted Table I line ieen.
                                    .seI. ueeasltion qts      0331.2 and T.331.2 This e-sres annexewroeul lohecheltry          ogropmdescr0iwe InLRA tperdoes A and B Is cleery Iodicate the the WaC-Tinu b-pection Propam willworirm the ellectveruss df the Waler Chere*rley Cnterod - Ban. VWV"eChteristry Codtrel - Auxiliety ysteyn ad WaWater Chenistry Coderod- Closed Cosirng wl progrnsr This Ite is closed to ten 372 400  Acoeted (T.132-P-`7]                                                  The aqtorqiesio entrieshe Wa last lirseve.dresleo the line In      Pat.. Erach  Ungerfditer, Tabe 332-4-27, RWCU ryste, sled wepaee type It Table3.32-14-27. RFWCUsysle, steed ooeelnert type            eChev        shill, InVesled waler orviroent wiltheana    died of hostelesobseer "Isl. In Vrowedwaler e&#xfd;resi wrl wimthn        tossde .ere. areVll.C2-14 (A-25).31-47, ard D.
sOng efect d oIw oenetial, PNPS credte Water Ch-etistry COeltd -Closed Codling Waler progrpm and          This resires anaodwtelothe LRA.
reerenses Table 3S3, line iten 331-17. However, tieu flee 331-17 afrheses Waler Chereistry Ce-troe -.WA program, Shtid tine Iter 13i1-47 be referenced whch adlressv the Waler Ciereistey Codedo. Closed CostingVWalecrlefu se-Mu EAP coeetentie? Plate    asev4ule-          the W.A acso rrdvy.
aep 31d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                      Page 32 i Number Status    Request                                                        Response                                                               NRC       PNPS Lead 401 Aceepled [T332-P.Cli                                                     The apjxoprtoie TaleItham, entry for the line inTable 332.14-27.     Paid. Erach Ungeidler.
===Response===
RWCU ystem. stak.es. seed cooponri type orifice. Instraed Tabe132-14427. RWCUsysten, stailamss steod                     water orwironmert witheanegng afect dios. dnsatial. Is corponera te crific. lntraded water envirornmnt with an         231-24 agng elient d Ie. f nmaerild, raloencas Tale. 331. line lien, 1.1-17. Howener. fheline i*a 1nfor sledl                 Tisariree anamened'wt         Both. LRA.
NRC PNPS Lead 401 Aceepled
[T332-P.Cli The apjxoprtoie TaleI tham, entry for the line inTable 332.14-27.
Paid. Erach RWCU ystem. stak.es. seed cooponri type orifice. Instraed Tabe132-14427. RWCUsysten, stailamss steod water orwironmert witheanegng afect dios. dnsatial. Is corponera te crific. lntraded water envirornmnt with an 231-24 agng elient d Ie.
f nmaerild, raloencas Tale. 331. line lien, 1.1-17. Howener. fheline i*a 1n for sledl Tisariree anamene d'wt Both. LRA.
cornporniis Shtad line hen 111-24 bdeorlere*od, with aftdes.
cornporniis Shtad line hen 111-24 bdeorlere*od, with aftdes.
etoioes. lsed componentsfor t. same EAP? Ptanso afoorean the .RA acoordnqy.
etoioes. lsed components for t.
402 Closed   (35121.4H-0 11                                                 As statel In Section 3 S211.4. PNPS Is.*p.nor. d the Orywell           Ho.M Dan     Atortti, Rlza "Ibel - floor tend klortified noenidone d corro-in of the Loss d iterial di    toGenaal,. Pilting and Crevice          drywdll shell The dywdi sdelf sled hae eocaed surfae and o Corrosion                                                      dtogrdaton of thes coing wa Iderilied" The etate*enIn qewsiorn It non addreesing he curet coidtion toe raher the Ptans., fpsatn for      last a.lemea Inthis sectionae it      Conditioneoqenled tn the tiworeIts ilifftcl to smy tenewillbe said Thief.ore signifterl corrosion othe dr/ywl shdl Is        aloduety no corrosion othee tier tbt ftheeis ressorate tn epd.ene. Does tie tree yoe DO heeo eom                        nstrance Vae co-roeior\ IN ary, will rn be sig**ilcator tneinntdL corosim? If rnotwhy si-;rlart                                  with re*pect to degradation 40  Closed    [lS221.7-H-0 11                                                The ect- method which tny be teed ioddect cracking Is th               Hoang, Dan   Ahrabli, Rwa emisting Corlaininmr Least Rale Progren withatgnerted Utreoric Strees CorresionCracking (SCC)becnmee eigrnicanl for              arre Cbeerved cordtt       het twe the potential for Itpeding ean stardns sled If0 tensile sons and a cor-rsIo                    inenrded functio w'e enal*ated or corrected Inaocor*larwe with 0e nirslror*rl *it  The sirons ,y betoplied alenereJ or          oreetive adji*o ploms. The Cotisnmnent Look Rate Progamis resdtud (iternel). Vivsue VT-3 eaesdtfieneo tny be unable      desoribel InApperdix B to etc tis agingg deno Poetaler etcelhtie cronPanss at PNPS eveperosralionr sleenveand bedlows Plesse Woafity Ith Othen mr*eotd e*n*aninetin to detect thseseyloe dent?
same EAP? Ptanso afoorean the.RA acoordnqy.
404  Closed    3,52211-H-0 11                                                As staded InSection 152221 d thLRA. PNPS has noetrurtures             Hoenw. Dan Aheatdi,Raza et onte cotered by Strctre MonkorIng Prog'airnd       I   ae within Agindfstrisior.Io C-srnaty Structureshfttilornrg                In scope clocer.. rtaosal ard ast-toe teengrginset review.
Ungeidler.
Do yes (PNPS) hIns "y operasing enperince rtaled toot.s Mnes?Piens, provide the daotl.
402 Closed (35121.4H-0 11 Loss d iterial di toGenaal,. Pilting and Crevice Corrosion Ptans., fpsatn for last a.lemea In this section ae it said Thief.ore signifterl corrosion othe dr/ywl shdl Is tn epd.ene. Does tie tree yoe DO heeo eom corosim? If rnot why si-;rlart 40 Closed
405 Closed   135221l8-H -011                                               Thie Wiholates associated with Ite ratal besm seas ewe                 Hoe. Dan  Ahrtali, Raze Impenedl order the Structen Mortoring Programs The oilte Lock Updte tnwear borLjvite Raea teen,Seats InBoW             tldes essociatedwith the tor.. etjpeul sVtetr.e sIn repected by 6dMait aridotiesr Slidcn Sw~pwitSurfaces. As Inicated to       t.e 1513tF) program INe seclion hi ..look-cr detotowest Is o  ro ant in efec recLdring teregaennt N PNPS. Hosever. Lutrile plae         eve Irou*ing wiithn the Strtures Monitoring Program and Insoroce Inspection (ISt-IWF) Pronam .." Please, provide nhecross rf'rerce, Inbetween these two programs Ae 3?d ;7
[lS221.7-H-0 11 Strees Corresion Cracking (SCC)becnmee eigrnicanl for stardns sled If 0 tensile sons and a cor-rsIo nirslror*rl *it The sirons,y be toplied alenereJ or resdtud (iternel). Vivsue VT-3 eaesdtfieneo tny be unable to g
etc tis aging deno Poetaler etcelhtie cronPanss at PNPS eve perosralionr sleenve and bedlows Plesse Woafity Ith Othen mr*eotd e*n*aninetin to detect thse seyloe dent?
404 Closed 3,52211-H-0 11 Agin df strisior.Io C-srna ty Structureshfttilornrg Do yes (PNPS) hIns "y operasing enperince rtaled to ot.s Mnes? Piens, provide the daotl.
As statel In Section 3 S211.4. PNPS Is.*p.nor. d the Orywell Ho.M Dan "Ibel -
floor tend klortified no enidone d corro-in of the drywdll shell The dywdi sdelf sled hae eocaed surfae and o dtogrdaton of thes coing wa Iderilied" The etate*en In qewsiorn It non addreesing he curet coidtion toe raher the Conditione oqenled tn the tiworeI ts ilifftcl to smy tene willbe aloduety no corrosion othee tier tbt fthee is ressorate nstrance Vae co-roeior\\ IN ary, will rn be sig**ilcat or tneinntdL with re*pect to degradation The ect-method which tny be teed ioddect cracking Is th Hoang, Dan emisting Corlaininmr Least Rale Progren withatgnerted Utreoric arre Cbeerved cordtt het twe the potential for Itpeding ean inenrded functio w'e enal*ated or corrected Inaocor*larwe with 0e oreetive adji*o ploms. The Cotisnmnent Look Rate Progam is desoribel InApperdix B As staded InSection 152221 d th LRA. PNPS has noetrurtures Hoenw. Dan et o nte cotered by Strctre MonkorIng Prog'airnd I
ae within In scope c locer.. rtaosal ard ast-toe teengrginset review.
Atortti, Rlza Ahrabli, Rwa Aheatdi, Raza 405 Closed 135221l8-H -011 Thie Wiholates associated with Ite ratal besm seas ewe Impenedl order the Structen Mortoring Programs The oilte Lock Up dte tnwear bor Ljvite Raea teen, Seats InBoW tldes essociated with the tor.. etjpeul sVtetr.e sIn repected by 6d Mait arid otiesr Slidcn Sw~pwit Surfaces. As Inicated to t.e 151 3tF) program INe seclion hi  
..look-cr de to towest Is ro ant o
in efec recLdring teregaennt N PNPS. Hosever. Lutrile plae eve Irou*ing wiithn the Strtures Monitoring Program and Insoroce Inspection (ISt-IWF) Pronam.." Please, provide nhe cross rf'rerce, Inbetween these two programs Hoe.
Dan Ahrtali, Raze Ae 3?d ;7
 
James Davis-AMR - Report tothe NRC.doc.pdf Page 33]
Number Status Request 40 Closed 3&52226-H-0 I1 Aging Sqpport rel covered by Stuctors. Monitoring Prose Plese providc
: 1. More Irdornulion Is needed abtol boiling sate-ias wed lI strhtoral applications atPNPS Irnludng WGroup B1 4poitliona. W a e the bolting rrsfterial wed?
AWe a.e te roni"l Veld strengths end Wqn-bomwl es-rd eved yield sttenh? Desorie the PNPS radiOon ofthe tonng Interity generic Issuei M relates to strectral botling Was aent SnCliual bolting Identfied as po*entally aveejplablea ocracklng dee loSCC? Was ens etrlttrnal btlting rep.0oed -
pent od. h remoio?
2 Describe he scope and Ah lot Class MCC Pressure Raining Bolting How Is loes d preload nweged?
407 Acepted 135.1-13-H* 11t InTatie 35.2-I on Page 3.5-51 lothe LRA, lorsonprtent Belows he AWe shown Is Cio-WE. wnhch 1l a pian-tepedfi. AMP. A Note C hns been aesigned to this AMRline Ilern sorponerw Is dtferen, blo corsistern with manteli. anvirnowmA.
ing sect. and aging neragowant progran Ior NURE-I3180t line item Ths AW Is oomisterlt withNUREG-101 the GALL description Table Il, lien 3 5 1-13 bellows. Explain how the plan-epcitic FlNPS CII-lWE AMP Is consistent with we GALL specified AWP.
 
===Response===
Need Clarication
*oW Is MnOe by the bolting Insegity genrelo Issue?
: 1) Boiting mawleial o PNPS mon=Isis ol A5 -Type loonornrrng to ASTI-A32. and A49D Type Ioortorning itASTM-A4M. per PNPS specpihcation C-94-ER-C-E3 The norninl yieldsrnength lor A3251 s I bsl ad IorA490 Is 130 bol. For stnluctural boling apications, PNPS Is consise with NUREG 180 InI ateging the eltects of aing with d. structures moniloring progan or tSI (IWO). eapegicate. NosPNP$ bolting has been kIdenfied OWe Is sisoepitie Io sCC.
: 2) Ingenera, PFPS traeges loss of nrerial lot booing with vistis Inspectionr. For tlrucliral tolling, he visual ISpectiwe e paen d she Snrctures Monitoring Prornan Ltss s preloed d6e lI sres relaxation (cresp) would orty bee wroern Invery high tetpenaturo aplplicatione (> 7 F) as staled Inte ASMIE Code, Section I1, Parl D, Table 4 No PNPS s*metural bolting openales at >7=F.
Therdora, Iose of preload dbe tostrness relaxation (creep) Is rut an applicabls aging affect tor nILcturl boItling oher ca die of los of preeld linclde Inedeptele booed Jort design and Indefectio irsintenarce pracstcee Loss ofpedoad du tothese caties Is prevented by Incorporation ol IrdiAty gutidn for good boiling prachoes Into PNPS predeaite bor design and neirienense of boi*ed jints.
Un Itern 3 S1-13 addresses la, esrniestseel,arned, disinrila inetal welds: lrm vertlfin vet headert, venllien bellows and dowrnoiners For PNPS venlline bolbvs and associated welds, Is line lets Is ooneislat with de NUREG-1801 AMR rmlls, Id the PNPS CII-IME progra described InAspownix Bisea plana-specifia progrann The Dryweftlalorls vent line bellows hIen
-n LRA Page 35-51 rdelenen" live itho 5.1-13 and correctly Indicts. Note ''.
For the Bolows (reactor vessel aed drywell) line iteh In Tale 3 52-1 onPago 35-51 odte IRA, raeten-e tolIns etnn 35.1-13 Is rul apiopriqetr he hTble 352-1 line itei aBdloes (reaclor vessel ard cywell)'and the cnresporning line iteh In Tale 24.1, Page 24-t13, were ine
'lenely Inclcd~l 1l.he tRAand shoid be ddeled The reactor vessl ard drywall bellows perform m license renewal ineded iorclion. Those.oinorts aen not Wealy-reated and weons-required todeornntrate conplience with regulations Identified in10 CFR544(a)(3). Failueod.he bellows will r'd preere sat'isfolory c f-onnniishvn*
ol ety fasncSon.
Lekge, If any. through tI bellows i ircted so a drain sysnem OWe prevents the leekags Iront cotacting the OWdr surfoaced the drywell shell.
Deletingte linelIterns dscosed taove recsiree enamnerohnaot to we LRA NRC Hoaer Den PNPS Lead Adsabli. Rena Hoeng. Dan Ahtrall. Rera FPa 33d 77
 
James Davis-AMR -, Report to the NRC.doc.pdf
-,Page 3:
Number Status Request J0I Acceped 35.`1-t5-H-01O In Table a52-1 onpaep 35-55 lthd ULRAf Primy Corainrnerl Elecrical Pena ration seea and iaist, lime AMP shown i.SrFWursee onitoring The appicat Is asked 0 nslfy that Ite Cll-lYP AMP will nor be.di In-d lo r-rege the Iagig dlft rnoistur barrier.
Rewonse PNPS prinsary Coratnrsni does r lae a nvo iture barier.
Thindoe anM iros redwrad. fhl refersced li-it-non Page 35-55 appi.a arty Sonpirrwy conlannw electrical penratdon eals and sealant.
Table Ue Ilem n
51-16 wvilbeuaidsted sntmd "Th.aging eflectl cited InrIte NUREI-1801 lear we ls. of sealing and leakage.
teds ofsedaing Isa cornsequeoe of f agirg elects cracking and cirsg. in"rerwial properies For PNlPS, IseCoCraainn Lask Rate programn isis crackirg ard fange In rrlelial propertie Ior tho prifry wortarrmt sdes and gaskes. Thee Is no raisture barier w,,e fts drywdl stea shell becorsa eatwibeds Insthe drywll cwrcrael Ior."
Tis reetire arsendAs lathe LRA NRC PNPS Lead HoenC Drn flrabi, Reza 4C9 Apoegl 13 5 1-44-H-Otj In Table 352-8 onPage 3.5-83 oflli LRA.for 00rporwt seats and gaskes, material rudbs in r protecled lrom seats aiziromrst I
flnag ealect. arecraeodng aid
&#xa2;harge In nrliad properties. Omed Ihs agrig rriosaret progZ rs t
Its Srstluree lMonairgn Progaur The GALL lin hein rd*lacd NI II1.A6-12 aid the Table I rderence Is3.51-44 The role shown IlE.a diffaen P
iar stow nin GALL HoeGAuLir 1tn It A6-12 and Table I Unr benn Il
-&44 bah specify Ih. Sr,.*rsa Ml-loring Pron'agn Explain wl I t rnoe thowsnlr n A insted dl E go Its lower haldOfd thveA 410 Acoaed
[35.1-5&-H-011 In Tabole a5 2-6 on Pago 3 5-73 df.t LRA, Inr oorponerl eectrical aind fstru pan*e aid wolora. Marteri gaflzedled sled Ina o
protected frontl -she airilro-nat; ts agiqg elfect IN tons, Th GALL JIrslfm n rhlascaied i.
I 813-A which alaor
: m. lallowing onPonets: Suppo
.nt..u welds; boiled cor-rectors; s8gppaIornoraga to bLiadng alroue
-xplainwI slf LRA AW Jim IneHn has a Not A shown instead of a Nde C.oadifselt conponewa wdh rasped laoWe GALL Noehirs Or a danarlldnayv, a lettr NdeAwitharnsnb Me no plalnirg M *e omc ponore 1N differai InTable 3.5 2-6 on Peg 35-83 elm. ILRA r oIs onrl seals Hoer Dan and gaskels, rrderial nbbs" Ina protected frorn weather awxironvrs. Note T-ai waed beaase t appdia lothe lap hsa of tI-lirs itemr The WRA %itlbecislified ti i
dic.ale rdo Nsts "W applies olo lowser half of ft lnIslm This reair eanararir*sa*i lam.WA NUREG-1801 doea rno rnerion eway lypa doonrpoarl lea s.be HoarU Don 0stMbt loaaging rnaeganemrt riiew (eq. panel is l In NUREG-t101)t rn dem.
Ist-rnirdogy u da aspaifo i-at Swaya. igs with OW used In GALL Coxresaly, rnrtcnrg p1sa-ooponents lNUREG-1801 -onpens ladles etljactio. ln tlls pardscula case, paes., wNch havero no Ispecific ution dine tIlan tolaloni aid protect Seatrical equiprnert, wer Ionrsitemd spport mtreabers aid Ndl Awn applied The wedof eter No. A or C he. noirrpact onmt agig managemwi revew ra1s.
Nioe A uillbechirad laNes "C-or oMonst a
es rOIalusand imlr.~rena panels aind enclsures. mastial galvanized sled ins prctas Iron weatts enivrorrint inTatt 352-I cnPage 35-73 of the WRA No change hi raiired to dih Oner satien fo this lini itlem Thisrequirem an arrmenr-i lo* thRA.
Ahrabli. Rae Ahrabi, Reze Pay 34 d 77
 
James Davis - AMR -_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf-Page 35]
Number Status Request 411 Accepted 135A-8-H-01]
InTable 352-1 onPage 35-54 ofthe LRA for rornlipwei Torue shdll with the agotg atoec! orectdrrg-fie, Ite rote eigrad sE Note Els coistart with NUREG-180l mreriat, onvironrnat and agng flect Wo aedifteraw eanrJ Fraregerrr proren iscraited Exlrin why this roe IsE wien the AM' down lo tie ili hem In TLAA a t* e irqoiald GALL Une Itse. BIAl-4 also pecities a TLAA 412 Accepted 1351-5-H-011 LRA raie 35&1. len Nobe. 31-5.I has tOe towirg staete~
ndr th dcacteion urn OiThe dywdl sled whre the dywl ahnl Is ortbdded Is leIspacloi In stoatn. withthe Cotrsiral Isevico Inrpection (tWE)
Prfoan and Strcturs Miouiong Proreanf. This Isn dictO? inarii Chrome Pis dmcreion etntearnet ID agree with LRA Section 35.221.4 tel states The drywelf st"d atil ard the tnstture tbarrer where the drywell stall becorre erej Inte rywelo ncreds floor wte Irepected Insacordarce withthe Cortnniaral servics kapecrion (1MS) Progaer ard Strtres Mxitorirg Proger Resonse NRC For Tale 352-1 onPage 35-54 dthe IRA lor cenere Torae Hta. Dan shedl with tfe aeri Slfect racking-laueg, Note "E will be ctaes to Note A.
ThN.rsqdrsrelanandrnel toteo LRA ForLRA Tal,1e31 her It 5.1-5, theidsscmuia InSetion Hos. Dan 312.1.4, Pagp 35-9. shold htae the rdetwnce tomoisfure barrier
: dldel, eiroete PNPS dyrwetidoes rot ocrtain itih ormodty.
FortLRAi Table 35A. her 35.1-5. thedcsoasin colutn shodd reed -The ywdl sled eldl and t* eas where the drywdl shall kecxxee ooresl d
r.l hbe drywdi o-tride floor ee Inpecled In woothiae with te Cor*tanresr Inavice kWpedioi (IWE)
Program" The last seatence fthe Iirl peasgrtaph In LRA Section 35221.4.
stoMld reade -The driywdl ed shdl ad t arese where the drywdt stall beooas eonbs.** Inte dywdil o-ores floor se irspoeald In acordoance with the Cortalr ras Iaoervics Ir fon (MIS)
Prograr" Thisersqir-r netrreer rrt tothe IRA PNPS Lead Ah'rali, RFs Alrabi, Rwa Pap 3d)7
 
James Davis - AMR-Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 36'1 Number Status Request 413 Accepted 135.1-9-HI.011 LRATable 351. Rel ent Nbs 351-9.9 has the flimeirg saernenwt =no the dactason cofunir Not appinbe, SeeSecticn 5.221. This elend bereadia Section 35221 & Howwel. the Inlleing, saewner Ismdaned LRA Section 15 22 1..
eFafigo TIAAe lor the steel drywdl. lore. ard associaed. poeetreiione we watuBle1 and dolnrenteel In section 46-The oontpoert eL.dwShLRATe~e22.a
,NmNt.ew351-9 w.
psnalnr~lo al-eon. p-nar.Swl bellctv, 84ee,o,-
poo!
shell, dee wt=rbnoo,ner Exphen hero Owlr.0,15w 3 51-9 lsena Wp~nabo hen.ow elatig TLAA P. been Pwlorned Ion the WM and pencrareions Expdla whi the Vol II.M vnthed.
andw V,.1 line belloere wenot lised Inl IRA Secions 3 5221.6 and 4.6 em refernced In Table 351. Une Iwl 15148 Resonse Fatigue aweyeee hewe been aelvLeed for Ihe loo.. Iot. vert eytamen o
Ino pwenretione. The Idlownoollinewillbe ed Io Tale* 52-I:
rTono.
errhncl ypeneloraoe lIPBS SRjCarbwon steed /IProlted ofrnwelnerllw ICrekfng If TLMAmA.1 f
tigue I#
HIB4-4(C-13) /3.5.1-9 IAK The weatuain do e lo. voet eysle fatigue analysis cxenrned Shael wasn al ITLAA The sigrilioaer vonribL)or to I
igae ofth Ven eylelm Ie Poae-LOCA ch.ng, a once iplart-litle wart As
-oe wi.l still be only one design basis LOCA Ion th. Iled the Plant. nklhding he perwo dd ee ndod opertiort. It" wlyayi is Mo ba.sed me lime-limrited assun torl and In rot a TLA. Faligue fo fte vent eysel Is
-edrive1 and Is. not ae ge-relleed affect, The dci-c..n ol"m entry Ior Table 3.51 itern 51-8 willbe changed to read as Idloor: "Fai" aerlysis Is le TLAA lot the lore shell. Faligue of01 Oe vent eysln Is warl-aieen a Ithe Nely.ie leno aTLAAL See
-St.
352*.16 The di$c!ssio oolu-n wnry lonTable 35.1 1-l 35.1.9 willbe eher-d o rlMd as lollow.: -Fat!g eralyei Is a T.AA for the Io.
penewdrions. See Stclon 3 5221.a Secton2 5221.6 willbechag e reed eslollowe" T"LAAwo evahoied Inaconhe-ce wllh IOCFR5421(c) endoclmeoled In Section 4 Fatie TI-,
e the o* :
ard enseciated pentralii*e we wealuaed and lo
.ewedI InSectlon 46" Section 35.23. Tirre-Urntlw Agng Anelyse. wilbechengr to reed ase follov: 'TLAA Idertified fIo elstene eononse end conwodiies Iroloee laigue aelymee for the lots and len.
penelrelions. Theec o.0c.. we diecsed In Section 46."
Theeem henge reqoire ent*nenhmel 1o IRA.
NRC PNPS Lead Honi;, D*n Ahrabi.
R1za PW 36fd 77
 
James Davis --AMR -Report to the NRC.docxpdf Page 37 I Number Status Request 414 Aocepted 135.1-12-H-1OI LRATa.el 351. Iten Numtbr 35.1-12 arId.5-13, under the cliacslon colmr dotoo make reference io LRA Seclion 352218 lorrtherwalualio.
EopliMnwhly Uns ltl lar de a
oft 1
.rer faludio gaction Explain t rood Ior.*qnrmrtel dtiorasdo exams lodolect fine cracks ainc..a CLE loaigue adnyll. dos omist.
415 Closid 135.1-16-H-01)
LRA Talel 3S1. hIt Nhart 351-16. tnder the doosaion col-n, states1 "t-Wl. and gaskes wai ot Ircluje inth. Corainrmri IWas-vce Inspection Progn*na at P N P S O r. of ft c m po n ts io r " s It "m r is mrtuelbarriflra.
Explain how PNPS sle. theJontl betweer t6. carlarmlw cywoll helo and drywell acorale floo" Htre ls no moisture barrier. Explain whiy 6.
Inspection df iis Jori isrd n
rpaid 6.f Cmoairnran nsie Inspection Progam 416 Closed (351-33-H-Olj For LRATaIe 351, fIn Number 35.1-33. provide ta rnlir r lorporIerao 61 onWeide experience Inaroup 1-5 antn r Resonse Alnk Ifrom imrs 351-12 and 151-13 will beoadded ioocWon 352216 Section 15.22 1.8 a-ould sltoe -Cycliloading can led to craclkig d l ad and atairlfd. dad penetratir bellow, and dssirrilar madll welds of c1W corzdrar s
o rd SM aa*lt-aoaion pd shal and ownccbaw.
Cracking h*
b tc la ing
[a nopeclail taoctr In6f drywd, lr.
e ard nsodoal p1etation bdilows. percarion doorws, unbraced downeomis, and dssirmilam aedal w"d A
rneview d plant opealing eipoio'r cd rot Idnotify crockigr of the cairWirta ad priawy corn'inrent looago M ds rdbeen klarified as, a 00 n.ca Nonthi seo,6ft Cotanmara Leek Rate Proam withaugminiled lrisorewlo ai and Condraraet isenice Inpection -M wll continue lobe uwed Iodaedt cracking CObe.ed coodnitor-. that have ft oelial for Irrm*elirg
,, Iris-dad faction ore evaluated or acoreced Inasooordance With
: 6. ccrectiNa action piroos. ThM Cortdar Irnemce Iopaction -I WE and Cornaunmr t Leok Rate progarns we descrtbed InApperdx B ThiNrecria anuamdmenl Iat10 RAW TheM Is no gn-to Iall al th0 Jolnt between the coidrraimw dryadll
*hali ad 6t co~rcie floor. Concreie d
rod Is oorsd direcly against 6. drywdl "Ii. Th Intallaison a. shawn asDdt 1 on Drawing C-7I. The Corlairnarn Isenvce Inspection Program InciLdeo Inspecallon odtns Joint (Also.so. audit question 1408 whch a
ddreseso changesl oLRA)
NRC PNPS Lead Hoag Da, Aheabit. Reuoa Hwon Dan Ahrabii, Rate Ayabli. flea The raximum bra lk wao amlels nnlwalmo. toar iGoUqp I-S ocrr Hoe-ng Dan in 6. drywal ard is an tverago tMpasloroe f IWF, reoerence UFSAR Table 5.2-2. For turmoL.r odlido 6f drywall ft1 blk oea mrxira m teIpe-ratro 1 12F Io, GO*rOr 1-5 St-rco. 0 kiorilifed In Table 109-2df PNPS UFSAR. Concrete wotin6f drywll consist f 6. ro-tor pedesal, sacrifical tiald wall and
. drywall floor. A rarca ta. bulk o-naei t.Ir1pooto.e withtn
: 6.
tywat anin bdlow to5 dogreeo F ls obtained ftouO masirtaning average bulk coratnnr-t etspatu wnithnathe linmts allowed by PNPS Too-cal Specfiicaillon Sooton 3.2-H (Page
'4 2-5). Mthouh Upper aclat-or ofthe drywail my oced IO F. the corciale of the 6ywell yisda lower adodatios The drywall cooling aystem poi moa oroig toenma" telrporatura limilrwm rno exceeded The ighet corcdle Inthe dryw Is the sacrificial shald wall. The ocetate In the waml Id not load be-ing Pageprd 77


James Davis- AMR - Report tothe NRC.doc.pdf                                         ..                                                                                                Page 33]
James Davis --AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf  
Number Status Request                                                 Response                                                              NRC        PNPSLead 40  Closed  3&52226-H-0 I1                                          Need Clarication      *oWIs MnOe by the bolting Insegity genrelo    Hoaer Den  Adsabli. Rena Issue?
.Page 38!
Aging Sqpport rel coveredby Stuctors. Monitoring Prose Plese providc                                          1) Boiting mawleialo PNPS mon=Isisol A5 -Type loonornrrng to ASTI-A32. and A49D Type IoortorningitASTM-A4M. per
Number Status Request 417 Accepted 35.1-34-H-01)
: 1. More Irdornulion Is needed abtol boiling sate-iaswed PNPS specpihcationC-94-ER-C-E3 The norninl yieldsrnength lor WGroup B1 lI strhtoral applications atPNPS Irnludng                A3251 s      Ibsl ad IorA490 Is 130 bol. For stnlucturalboling 4poitliona. W a e the bolting rrsfterial wed? AWe        apications, PNPS Is consise with NUREG 180 InIateging a.e te roni"l Veld strengths end Wqn-bomwl es-rdeved    the eltects of aing withd. structures moniloring progan or tSI yield sttenh? Desorie the PNPS radiOon ofthe tonng      (IWO). eapegicate. NosPNP$ bolting has been kIdenfied OWeIs Interity generic Issuei M relates to strectral botling  sisoepitie Io sCC.
LRATalde 3.5t. iw-n Nuber 35.1-34. uroe the dacuseian edlun, does net mke rierfnce loLRA Section 35.22224 (1)bfor further aeual Ion Explan whiyf iirlin is in male tlo fl eoevaluitlon sectioa 418 Accpted
Was aent SnCliual bolting Identfied as po*entally aveejplableaocracklng dee loSCC? Was ens etrlttrnal      2) Ingenera, PFPS traeges loss of nrerial lot booing with vistis btlting rep.0oed - pent od.h remoio?                    Inspectionr. For tlrucliral tolling, he visual ISpectiwe e paen d she Snrctures Monitoring Prornan Ltsss preloed d6e lI sres 2 Describe he scope and Ah lot Class MCC      Pressure  relaxation (cresp) would orty bee wroern Invery high tetpenaturo Raining Bolting How Is loesd preload nweged?            aplplicatione(> 7 F) as staled Inte ASMIECode, Section I1, Parl D, Table 4 No PNPS s*metural bolting openales at >7=F.
[3,5.1-35-H-O1 LRA Taue 351, 1". NHins 35,1-35.
Therdora, Iose of preload dbe tostrness relaxation (creep) Is rut an applicabls aging affect tor nILcturl boItling      oher ca      die of los of preeld linclde Inedeptele booedJort design and Indefectio irsintenarce pracstcee Loss ofpedoad du tothese caties Is preventedby Incorporation ol IrdiAty gutidn for good boiling prachoes Into PNPS predeaite bordesign and neirienense of boi*edjints.
rdor the deiasioa edunn does in make rdatnce IoLRA Section 352224 (2) Icohfltwwaiada E
407  Acepted 135.1-13-H* 11t                                          Un Itern 3 S1-13 addresses la, esrniestseel ,arned,                  Hoeng. Dan  Ahtrall. Rera disinrila inetal welds: lrm vertlfin vet headert, venllien bellows InTatie 35.2-I on Page 3.5-51 lotheLRA, lorsonprtent    and dowrnoiners For PNPS venlline bolbvs and associated Belows he AWe shown Is Cio-WE.wnhch 1l a                welds, Is line lets Isooneislat with de NUREG-1801 AMR pian-tepedfi. AMP. A Note C hns been aesigned to this    rmlls, Id the PNPS CII-IME progra described InAspownix Bisea AMRline  Ilern sorponerw Is dtferen, blo corsistern with  plana-specifia progrann The Dryweftlalorls vent line bellows hIen manteli. anvirnowmA. ing sect. and aging neragowant      -n LRA Page 35-51 rdelenen" live itho 5.1-13 and correctly progran Ior NURE-I3180t line item Ths AW Is oomisterlt  Indicts. Note ''.
inmwhythiselirnktI in a til. e I*"
withNUREG-101 the GALLdescription For the Bolows (reactor vessel aed drywell) line iteh In Tale Table Il, lien 3 5 1-13 bellows. Explain how the        3 52-1 onPago 35-51 odte IRA, raeten-e tolIns etnn35.1-13 Is plan-epcitic FlNPS CII-lWE AMP Is consistent with we    rul apiopriqetr    hTble 352-1 line itei he                    aBdloes (reaclor GALLspecified AWP.                                      vessel ard cywell)'and the cnresporning line iteh In Tale 24.1, Page 24-t13, were ine 'lenely Inclcd~l 1l.he tRAand shoid be ddeled The reactor vessl ard drywall bellows perform m license renewal ineded iorclion. Those .oinorts aen not Wealy-reated and weons- required todeornntrate conplience with regulationsIdentified in10 CFR544(a)(3). Failueod.he bellows will r'd preere sat'isfolory c                  ol    ety fasncSon.
ther ation section.
f-onnniishvn*
419 A-eped 135.1-36-H-Ol]
Lekge, If any. through tI bellows i ircted so a drain sysnem OWeprevents the leekags Irontcotacting the OWdr surfoaced the drywell shell.
LRA Tae 3.51, R" HNuntsr 35A-36, uder the dacut n ladmn does mn mike relnnce to.RA Section 2.5.2224 (3) lor l
Deletingte linelIterns dscosed      taoverecsiree enamnerohnaot to we LRA FPa 33d 77
rt oc aluet[on Explain why thisl nki ri pae tolthe lurlhas euetian ectiaon The ietmst:
*See Sectioa 352221 (5)for dditional dscussia new).
lulhls elarifiation itts section Is for Guope IA-5 7-9.
how.-c XA waled ily loaccesite i oup 6 concrete, Explain why WRA Seetion 3.52224 (3) lisb. ercking d cocrele doe to Stre Coejion Crcking (SCC).
42D Accepted P35 I-H-H01l LRA Tale 3.51. Ren Hints 35.-40, uder Ife diceasionedwMn, Mlee: &#xb6;..PlWt experience hai not Mdoetified li crclia Inooerete tictle capacity ooahlr cocrete aging mnarhnisda NonH-,esi, the Strictures Mririfaing Progan wull oroirm absencoe da*ing effects rekrirg rweregel 1or PNPS concrete eeoneres."
The project ten carrl Rind anrAMR lireItem InTable 21or Wi coronent (Bedrlng concrete ae locations of aptsion ard good anchors god-ped for 1
u0ppor bse pIlele).
Pride. Ue Table 2 Alb, LRA pge nurets, and eaompon* 10 where this "Ml line t-n Is e.&uleld and shwn


James Davis-AMR -, Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                  -,Page                                                                                                        3:
===Response===
Number Status    Request                                                        Rewonse                                                              NRC      PNPS Lead J0I  Acceped    35.`1-t5-H-01O                                                PNPS prinsary Coratnrsni does r lae a nvoiture barier.               HoenC Drn  flrabi, Reza Thindoe anM iros redwrad. fhl refersced li-it-non Page In Table a52-1 onpaep 35-55 lthd ULRAf Primy                    35-55 appi.a arty Sonpirrwy conlannw electrical penratdon Corainrnerl Elecrical Pena ration seeaand iaist,lime            eals and sealant.
NRC NUREG-1180O. Rem NuHirn 351-34 livcale*. O lurlhls enauien Hsng. Dan Is meses"any c oy 10 e6erei envirornsis. No reference was prakvide to lls weauatii in LRA Section 352224 (1) mrme the PNPS nlrast in.m agjressi-e -
AMP shown i.SrFWursee onitoring The appicat Is asked 0 nslfy that Ite Cll-lYP AMP will nor be .di      In-d lo    Table Ue Ilem  n 51-16 wvilbeuaidsted          sntmd "Th.aging eflectl r-rege Iagig the      dlft rnoistur barrier.                      cited InrIte NUREI-1801 lear we ls. of sealing and leakage.
oed l nLRA Table 251, ItR N tser 251-34 rde. the dscuiaion dwmn.
teds ofsedaing Isa cornsequeoe of f agirg elects cracking and cirsg. in"rerwial properies For PNlPS,IseCoCraainn Lask Rate programnisis      crackirg ard fange In rrlelial propertie Ior tho prifry wortarrmt sdes and gaskes. Thee Is no raisture barier w,,e fts drywdl stea shell becorsa eatwibeds Insthe drywll cwrcrael Ior."
For darificalo *RA Tabe 35.1. Une Iten 3.51-34 dec-ion will be rwised toal 'See Sedt-3352224(t)&deg;.
Tis reetire    arsendAs    lathe LRA 4C9  Apoegl    135 1-44-H-Otj                                                  InTable 3.5 2-6 on Peg 35-83 elm.ILRA r oIsonrl            seals    Hoer  Dan  Ahrabli. Rae and gaskels, rrderial nbbs" Ina protected frorn weather In Table 352-8 onPage 3.5-83 oflli LRA.for00rporwt              awxironvrs. Note T-ai waed beaase t appdia lothe lap hsa of seats and gaskes, material rudbs inr protecled lrom            tI- lirs itemr The WRA%itlbecislifiediti rdo dic.ale    Nsts "W seats aiziromrst I          flnagealect. arecraeodng aid      applies olo lowserhalf of ft lnIslm
TNtrexrires ancardmes tlofe tLRA Focrdlarification, WRA Table 35 1, Iten 351-35 disciseln will be Hoang, Dan eieed 1wadd redere*e toSectaon 352224(2). LRA TabeS 351.
                                &#xa2;harge In nrliad properties. Omed Ihs agrig rriosaret progZrs t                Its Srstluree lMonairgn    This reair eanararir*sa*i      lam.WA Progaur The GALL lin hein rd*lacd NIII1.A6-12aid the Table I rderence Is3.51-44 The role shown IlE.a diffaen P iar stownin GALL HoeGAuLir 1tn It A6-12 and Table I Unr benn  Il    -&44 bah specify Ih. Sr,.*rsa Ml-loring Pron'agn Explain wl It rnoe thowsnlrn A insted dl E goIts lower haldOfdthveA 410  Acoaed    [35.1-5&-H-011                                                NUREG-1801 doea rno rnerion eway            doonrpoarl lea s .be lypa                      HoarU Don  Ahrabi, Reze 0stMbt loaaging rnaeganemrtriiew (eq. panel isl        In In Tabolea5 2-6 on Pago 3 5-73 df.t LRA, Inr oorponerl        NUREG-t101)t rn dem. Ist-rnirdogy u da aspaifo i-at eectrical aindfstru        pan*e aid wolora. Marteri          Swaya.igs with OW used In GALL Coxresaly, rnrtcnrg p1sa-gaflzedled sled Ina protected o      frontl -she  airilro-nat; ts ooponents lNUREG-1801 -onpens ladles etljactio. ln agiqg elfect INtons, Th GALLJIrslfm n rhlascaied i.          tlls pardscula case, paes., wNch havero  noIspecific ution dine I 813-Awhich alaor  m. lallowing onPonets: Suppo            tIlan tolaloni aid protect Seatrical equiprnert, wer Ionrsitemd
Rom 351-35 deiaeionawillbereeisled torder toAC 318 Inlieweo ACI-301, sime toe proided rd.er
                                    .nt..uwelds; boiledcor-rectors; s8gppaIornoraga to        spport mtreabers aid Ndl Awn applied The wedofeter No. A bLiadng alroue -xplainwI    slf      LRA AWJimIneHn has a      or C he. noirrpact onmt agig managemwi revew ra1s.
* IoACI should Ied en been ACI 318 and not AC 301.
Not A shown instead of a Nde C.oadifselt conponewa wdh rasped laoWe GALL Noehirs Or a              danarlldnayv, a lettr  Nioe A uillbechirad laNes "C-or oMonst            a  es rOIalusand NdeAwitharnsnb          no Me    plalnirg M *e omc    ponore 1N imlr.~rena panels aind enclsures. mastial galvanized sled ins differai                                                        prctas Iron weatts enivrorrint inTatt 352-I cnPage 35-73 of the WRA No change hiraiired to        Oner satien fo this lini dih itlem Thisrequirem an arrmenr-i lo*    thRA.
Tesrqu*ireeesne*irdmit 1f0o IRA WRA Table 351. Una lIenH Nuber 3SI-36 discussnl will.b Hoen-Dan rehed tread a-Idlows.
Pay 34d 77
FlReation with aggregate II in an applicable agng rtcl'eriamn 1o0 PNPS cocree aroponeis. See Section 35.2221(5) (altlhaigh lo Groape I-5. 7, 9 ths discussion Is elso applicable 10 Grouqp 6) am Sctian 352224(3) umtiowi decussion. NHnethedes, the Suicrtwwe Moitoring Progan will cotrinn Ive aere eof eging edcote regdring -
a-gst 1O PNPS Groap 6 oeoae ecorp-i.s" Due to an axniiistrlive Ovieis he h"ir0ng of LWA Section 352224 (3) Irelverlertly listsree-king ofcon-rdee due lo tresa Core ian Cricing (SCC).Tes section tetIng elodd have be*un with reacking Due to xpepai on a, m Reaction with Agregat...e Sree coroeion cracking I[ ino cescuesed in the bdy of tsie sectioa TN efhage rapiree eanamerner boie RA Building eoeret. at locaions d wtpweia m d
emy ed etenis; Hoew-. Dan godt pact 1or support base pee we shwn as lcuudation aend "Rewwlo, vessed seg paedt" InSRA Table 352-1 (page 35-M5). afouxdeoe inTatles 352-2 twough 352-5 (pes 35-59.
35-61, 35-64, aed 35-67), ard as-Eqf ea pasfilarwdeha.n - in Table 352-6 (page35-80) Fulce elieution isproidlod InWRA section352226(t). page 35-S5 For clarificatio. URA TabIe 35&1. Itern Nuer 3 51-40 daceionl will bervised loadd Sec Section 352226(1)e.
Th.rwpqreenmenwers lothe WIA PNPS Lead Ahabli. Reza Ahrael, Rea Althali, Rea Ah'abli, Rere Page 38d 77


James Davis - AMR -_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf-                                                                                                                                        Page 35]
James Davis - AMR-Report tothe NRC.doc.pdf Page 39f Number Status Request 421 Accepted ft l-5-H-0Vl LRATabeo 3,&1, It" Nutmber 35.1-50. terds tie datenion doumn stales td loess o dmielrIt isno applicable 1OPNPS. NUREG-1833 onPgage 931or ternTP-6 states ansajsied preaednt aIstl for acting this mreerial.
Number Status   Request                                                     Resonse                                                        NRC      PNPS Lead 411  Accepted 135A-8-H-01]                                                For Tale 352-1 onPage 35-54 dthe IRA lor cenere Torae            Hta. Dan  Ah'rali, RFs shedl with tfe aeri Slfect racking-laueg , Note "E will be ctaes InTable 352-1 onPage 35-54 ofthe LRA for         rornlipwei  to Note A.
nwwironnrit, aging effec and proge ra corntretfli 1o the GALL Reget AashownInRNPSER Sectilo 352412, g= =aed steel an staines sleed Ian alidcia air wclrs, rt ooldd rilt In loess of mraelral OA to canstrt Wilfing and t ying ocanl-U.M POimNn
Torue shdll with the agotg atoec!orectdrrg-fie, Ite rote eigrad sE Note Els coistart with NUREG-180l              ThN.rsqdrsrelanandrnel        toteo LRA mreriat, onvironrnat and agng flect Woaedifteraw eanrJ Fraregerrr proren iscraited Exlrin why thisroe IsE wien the AM' down lo tieili hem In TLAAa t* e irqoiald GALLUne Itse. BIAl-4 also pecities a TLAA 412  Accepted  1351-5-H-011                                                ForLRA Tal,1e31 her      It 5.1-5, theidsscmuia InSetion        Hos. Dan  Alrabi, Rwa 312.1.4, Pagp 35-9. shold htae the rdetwnce tomoisfure barrier LRAraie 35&1. len Nobe. 31-5.I has tOe towirg                dldel, eiroete PNPS dyrwetidoes rot ocrtain itih ormodty.
.Ad also be sluseptible loa -si-ilr kindo aging edfect Inthe r
staete~    ndr th dcacteion      urn OiThedywdl sled whre the dywl ahnl Is ortbdded IsleIspacloi In stoatn. withthe Cotrsiral Isevico Inrpection (tWE)          FortLRAiTable35A. her 35.1-5. thedcsoasin colutn shodd Prfoan and Strcturs Miouiong Proreanf. This Isn            reed -The ywdl sled eldl and t* eas where the drywdl shall dictO? inarii        Chrome Pis dmcreion etntearnetID        kecxxee ooresl r.l d         hbedrywdi o-tride floor ee Inpecled In agree with LRA Section 35.221.4 tel states The drywelf      woothiae with te Cor*tanresr Inavice kWpedioi (IWE) st"d atil ard the tnstture tbarrer where the drywell stall  Program" becorre      erej      Inte rywelo ncreds floorwte Irepected Insacordarce withthe Cortnniaral      servics    The last seatence fthe Iirl peasgrtaph In LRA Section 35221.4.
wolro-sre.
kapecrion (1MS) Progaer ard Strtres Mxitorirg              stoMld reade -The driywdl ed shdl ad t aresewhere the drywdt Proger                                                      stall beooas eonbs.** Inte dywdil o-ores floor se irspoeald In acordoance with the Cortalr ras Iaoervics Ir fon (MIS)
Provide a ls-s.o. O th. actsol gol) 82 ant B4dgpverzed sl.
Prograr" Thisersqir-r  netrreer rrt tothe IRA Pap 3d)7
stcrnlnscn an abides, sled PNPS corpaerft wrchwore within the sps license renewal ard exposed loan ait.d, air wwirore"t Discuss the locatio cit-ahese compornens at PNPS and how tW we protected fromn carutlt wat*ng and drying condtiorn, 4M Acceped
[3.5.1-52-H-O11 LAATabTel3 51, Itein Nhet 35.1-52.
inder the d
ia-as odw OW.
t hal Ice.d ls rnc vcai bunction d-s to" lisledmscheris*tos Ian agig effect Proper design praents dsborio% coerload. andI fteLi ds to wO-alry wnt cyclatherwml back Explain how loss of miaejd bcalrcon dituo torresion Is not waing aect wlche reds tobbe ranaged fo t.e period of alenele operati*n If proper desig prweris, dsltortior, oerlowte wrd 1atig.ed cbs ovibratore and cyclic thermas lesds. explain If tUe hes wer been a con gal. failure at PIPS d toulary of thee esordtoirs. Explal n iftwa t eve been a camponenr blis In the niclear Irnsslry das t
o y of these contltes. Explain where siJ*ing siupport boring and slicng cuppotl s0.a1-s we aed Ino-onrdr grotp. B2 and B4 at PNPS and provide th wrvirocnmerltfy we mposed to.


James Davis - AMR- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                    Page 36'1 Number Status    Request                                                  Resonse                                                                    NRC        PNPS Lead 413  Accepted 135.1-9-HI.011                                            Fatigue aweyeee hewe been aelvLeedfor      Ihe    loo.. Iot. vert        Honi;, D*n  Ahrabi. R1za eytamen          Ino o    pwenretione. The Idlownoollinewillbe ed Io LRATable 351. Relent Nbs      351-9.9 hasthe flimeirg      Tale* 52-I:          rTono. errhnclypeneloraoe lIPBS SRjCarbwon saernenwt =no the dactason cofunir Notappinbe,              steed /IProlted ofrnwelnerllwICrekfng If TLMAmA.1          f    tigue I#
===Response===
SeeSecticn 5.221. This elend bereadia Section              HIB4-4(C-13) /3.5.1-9 IAK 35221 & Howwel. the Inlleing,saewner Ismdaned        ,
NRC FortLRA Table 35.A, IehinNuaw I3S1-51% thedPsctac sion oroin Hoawy Den sid reaid 'Th.s aging aect Is rnraged by 0. Sn-xtiaes oI*-biig Prog8M Conaorsiw thal roay becoaidtored Ints W2ard BIgro-t-ni consistl o those line iesnt in Talte 352-6 with iolerials glvaized steel, asuirircss, or stainlees sled.
LRA Section 1522 1.. eFafigo TIAAe lor the steel          The weatuain do e lo. voet eysle fatigue analysis cxenrned drywdl. lore. ard associaed. poeetreiionewe watuBle1      Shaelwasn          ITLAA The sigrilioaer vonribL)or to al                                   I    igae ofth and dolnrenteel In section 46- The oontpoert              Ven eylelm IePoae-LOCAch.ng, a once iplart-litle                wart As eL.dwShLRATe~e22.a ,NmNt.ew351-9                    w.        -oe wi.l still be only onedesign basis LOCA Ionth. Iled the psnalnr~lo al-eon. p-nar.Swl bellctv, 84ee,o,-      poo!  Plant. nklhding he perwo ddee ndod opertiort.It" wlyayi is Mo shell, dee  wt=rbnoo,ner Exphenhero Owlr.0,15w              ba.sed me lime-limritedassun torl and Inrot a TLA. Faligue fo 3 51-9 lsenaWp~nabo hen .ow  elatig  TLAAP. been            fte vent            Is eysel    -edrive1and Is.not ae ge-relleed affect, Pwlorned Ionthe WM and pencrareions Expdla whi the Vol II.Mvnthed.      andwV,.1 linebelloerewenot lised Inl  The dci-c..n ol"m entry Ior Table 3.51 itern 51-8 willbe IRA Secions 35221.6 and 4.6emrefernced InTable            changedto read as Idloor: "Fai" aerlysis Is        le TLAAlot the 351. UneIwl 15148                                          lore shell. Faligue of01  Oe vent eysln Is warl-aieen a Ithe Nely.ie leno aTLAAL See      -St.        352*.16 The di$c!ssio oolu-n wnry lonTable 35.1 1-l 35.1.9 willbe eher- d o rlMd as lollow.: -Fat!g eralyei Is a T.AA for the Io. penewdrions. See Stclon 3 5221.a Secton2 5221.6 willbechag e               reed eslollowe" T"LAAwo evahoied Inaconhe-ce wllh IOCFR5421(c) endoclmeoled In Section 4 Fatie *TI-,            e the o* :    ard enseciated pentralii*e we wealuaedand lo .ewedIInSectlon 46" Section 35.23. Tirre-Urntlw Agng Anelyse. wilbechengr                to reed asefollov: 'TLAAIdertified fIo elstene eononse end conwodiies Iroloee laigue aelymee for the lots and len.
This reqdres enaw~a t
penelrelions. Theec o.0c.. we diecsed InSection 46."
lothe IRA PNPS Lead Ahrabtlf. Reza Ahrabli. Rae Loss of material das to rrcesion is al aging effect thi 6s*
Theeem henge reqoire ent*nenhmel 1o                IRA.
case a loss of Internd cliain. Loss d met-anieal Iilooi wosld be consliderl sa essn dirnewdl banc-stan Lois e schnical kinction Isrd aedcy effect, to lethe raelt cfagin edaets.
PW 36fd 77
Ttere hIs been cat-or l bu*swes Inthe Indistry ds 1o ttstatioa, oewtl*l a-td ceassive vibration. Sich bluses plyicalty resi11t kora Irdloliate design a aeve. rather Psei the dale of aging Failtes 6A locyclictherrIws Ie wsvwy rwtfo.
sritwural suiports da e
o ther retalively low berratwarme The ldikng surface mnaer*alswed al PNPS is lhrited whch I a cormrcsn resistat mawerial. Cargneris we Iesmpcted under I-MF for ftors saddle suipogts and SlrJlirw Wtrloring Progracr for thi hbrite Wa
. 1o racidl beamw sIs Plant operaing asperlence hIs nru Idetifled feltseci lifiles cOwy*oois wsed in sltrucltal applicaliors. NornJre Iri s:ry experlac-hbe deantified failure assoctated withliibrite sliding atrfsae. C-at-scds associated withB2gouotping we limiled soi e t"eor raala benin ats and support
-a ades. There weo -
slcing sit-l saurlace assocald wilth te B40d c
rgee gotL-nc ber sliding surfaces al
: PNPS, For clarilicatior% LRATae 35I.,
te 151-52 willberlevsed 1o rad o blows: "Loess d mechan-cal uncston das tot. listed machidsm Is In an agi efect. Such lalurtes tically ra1i Iran inedscasle dosigi or copiewing awes atiher Pit Iron the data of eIng Faitura is 10ocyclic thermal loa d e re -for slriuratl sit-oets dot 1atheir relaively Ik. lsrrcalures.
Thisraepirrensesawntr lot.
IlRA Howur Dan Pbg 3d 77


James Davis --AMR -Report to the NRC.docxpdf                                                                                                  ..                                                 Page 37 I Number Status     Request                                                   Resonse                                                                NRC      PNPS Lead 414  Aocepted  135.1-12-H-1OI                                            AlnkIfrom imrs 351-12 and 151-13 will beoadded ioocWon                  Hoag Da,  Aheabit. Reuoa 352216 LRATa.el 351. Iten Numtbr 35.1-12 arId .5-13, under the cliacslon colmr dotoo              io make reference    LRA      Section 15.22 1.8 a-ould sltoe -Cycliloading can led to Seclion 352218 lorrtherwalualio. EopliMnwhlyUns            craclkigd l ad and atairlfd. dad penetratir bellow, and ltl lar    a de 1oft .rer    faludio gaction Explain t    dssirrilar madll welds of c1W corzdrar os rd SM rood Ior.*qnrmrtel dtiorasdo exams lodolect fine cracks  aa*lt-aoaionpd shal and ownccbaw .
James Davis - AMR -.Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 40 ]
ainc..a CLE loaigueadnyll. dosomist.
Number Status Request 423 Accepted 13&.154-H-0I1 LRAT&boe 34.1. It-. Nurnber 32.-54, w.0W the dewoico colunne oesee ltd los of nros.chrca functon due loft. listed nwachtr.-e. Is e on1 a.ging effec.0 Protper design ycre-1 detar~l., overlowl, and Isligue 01.10 nitoekoy.51 cyclic lthnW kb1. Explain law loss of nst.1 hoi,
Cracking          b tc la ing      h*nopeclail taoctr In6f
1.011
[a drywd,lr. e ard nsodoal p1etation bdilows.percarion doorws, unbraced downeomis, and dssirmilamaedal w"d              A rneviewd plant opealing eipoio'r cd rot Idnotifycrockigr of the cairWirta ad priawy corn'inrent looago M rdbeen        ds klarified 00as, a    n.ca Nonthi seo,6ft Cotanmara Leek Rate Proam withaugminiled            lrisorewloai    and Condraraet isenice Inpection -M wll continue lobe uwed Iodaedt cracking CObe.ed coodnitor-.that have ft oelial for Irrm*elirg
.5 to rosooion Is M an aging elect1 wtich needs lo b.  
                                                                                                ,, Iris-dad faction ore evaluated or    acoreced Inasooordance With
-w.gd fo 1the peritlof dw1.k
: 6. ccrectiNa action piroos. ThMCortdar              Irnemce Iopaction -I WE and Cornaunmr t Leok Rate progarns we descrtbed InApperdx B ThiNrecria anuamdmenl Iat10 RAW 415  Closid    135.1-16-H-01)                                            TheM Is no gn- Iallto      al th0 Jolnt between the coidrraimwdryadll  Hwon Dan    Ahrabii, Rate
.opertion II proper design preens. distortioever otdos mid t.0g..6 to. v~ibrtor0y.01 cyclic esthwr ood si expdlan N f... too ove been a cornono fi lure~ at PNPS its lo any d Ithes. conditons.. Expl en if there hae.er bewen ooywel1urow In.. nuclear Industy due I*oany.1 th...
                                                                                              *hali ad 6t co~rcie floor. Concreie    d    rod Is oorsd direcly LRA Talel 3S1. hIt Nhart 351-16. tnder the                against 6. drywdl "Ii. Th Intallaison a.shawn asDdt 1 on doosaion col-n, states1 "t- Wl. and gaskes wai ot          Drawing C-7I. The Corlairnarn Isenvce Inspection Program Ircluje inth. Corainrmri IWas-vce Inspection Progn*na at    InciLdeo Inspecallonodtns Joint PNPS O r. of ft c m pon ts ior "s It "m    "    r is mrtuelbarriflra. Explain how PNPS sle. theJontl            (Also.so. audit question 1408 whch    a ddreseso changesloLRA) betweer t6. carlarmlw cywoll heloand drywell acorale floo" Htrels no moisture barrier. Explain whiy6.
cwdtro, Exlaiwn whtd PNPS Imspacts for duing VT-3 Visd.rnto.-
Inspection dfiis Jori isrdn    rpaid 6.f Cmoairnran nsie Inspection Progam Ayabli. flea 416  Closed    (351-33-H-Olj                                              The raximum bra    lk wao amlels nnlwalmo. toar iGoUqp        I-S ocrr Hoe-ng Dan in 6. drywal ard is an tverago tMpasloroe f IWF, reoerence For LRATaIe 351, fIn Number 35.1-33. provide ta            UFSAR Table 5.2-2. For turmoL.r odlido 6f drywall ft1 blk oea rnlir r lorporIerao 61 onWeide experience Inaroup          mrxira m teIpe-ratro 1 12F Io, GO*rOr 1-5 St-rco. 0 1-5 antn r .                                             kiorilifed In Table 109-2dfPNPS UFSAR. Concrete wotin6f drywll consist f 6. ro-tor pedesal, sacrifical tiald wall and
0 wce. 1.1 B1 sd 61.3 oofltoon.ert under Its Irm-oic. h'.pe0ctir Prograrn durin~g Us current lice-.. swd Woo antiipated VT-3 visual
                                                                                                . drywall floor. A rarca ta.bulk o-naei t.Ir1pooto.e withtn
.exaistios during Its possible extendedlwicense
: 6. tywat anin bdlow to5 dogreeo F ls obtained ftouO masirtaning average bulk coratnnr-t etspatu wnithnathelinmts allowed by PNPS Too-cal Specfiicaillon Sooton 3.2-H (Page
                                                                                              '4 2-5). Mthouh Upper aclat-or ofthe drywail my oced IO F. the corciale of the 6ywell  yisda lower adodatios The drywall cooling aystem poi          oroig moa toenma" telrporatura limilrwm rno exceeded The ighet corcdle Inthe dryw Is the sacrificial shald wall. The ocetate In the wamlIdnot load be-ing Pageprd 77


James Davis --AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                        ..           .       .     ...               ...                         ..   .       . .     .       .... .Page 38!
===Response===
Number Status    Request                                                          Response                                                        NRC        PNPS Lead 417  Accepted  35.1-34-H-01)                                                    NUREG-1180O.Rem NuHirn 351-34 livcale*. O lurlhls enauien      Hsng. Dan      Ahabli. Reza Is meses"anyc    10 oy e6erei    envirornsis. No reference was LRATalde 3.5t. iw-nNuber 35.1-34. uroe the                        prakvide to lls    weauatii in LRASection 352224 (1) mrme dacuseian edlun, does net mke rierfnce loLRA Section              the PNPS nlrast        in.m agjressi-e - oed l nLRA Table 35.22224 (1)bforfurther aeual Ion Explan whiyf iirlin is          251, ItR N tser251-34 rde. the dscuiaion dwmn.
TIhe decuse... follhorn Ne..ts. 151-54 wae not leydlying that failures hav. not oc d buti OW loss of me..chanca beatsi Is rot an 011.0efec.
in male tlofl              eoevaluitlon sectioa For darificalo*RA Tabe 35.1. Une Iten 3.51-34 dec-ion will be rwised toal 'See Sedt- 3352224(t)&deg;.
Fer lie..., roneose., Etweogy klricaesr.a oturribw 01agn e ffects1 ltha cencase. lose 01 Wored.w function Lose o Warded15 luratim n icities lose 01 rehnical functon The loss of function Is rte 0.0id.0.5 of -agig of1.01 Aging affect. that ould cous. lose d1 mechanical lunction for ornporwe.1. In fter N unber 3 SI-5O w~e atbbeeeed 01.esoh. In Ithe eging noow racss. revsew.. For warncple lose 01 o...wiel doe Sosany nxethaismn Is oftbesse I lTable 35 2-u-sI. listings for cornponent ard piping support A&W. Class 1. Z 3 01 LC (Paeg 35-71). af01 eo..poren sod piping supports (Pegs 3 5-72.
TNtrexrires      ancardmes  tlofe tLRA 418  Accpted  [3,5.1-35-H-O1                                                    Focrdlarification,WRATable 35 1, Iten 351-35 disciseln will be Hoang, Dan    Ahrael, Rea eieed 1waddredere*e toSectaon352224(2). LRA TabeS        351.
C~onporont falues~e at PNPS ard Inth. nuc.w Inlduty hav.
LRA Taue 351, 1". NHins 35,1-35. rdor the                        Rom 351-35 deiaeionawillbereeisled torder toAC 318 Inlieweo deiasioa edunn does in make rdatnce IoLRA Section                ACI-301, sime toe proided rd.er
csoertily.0ocurred du boverolod (tyicallycaused by... oven4 such as waere leo.....) avibratory andl cycictswtd Iced.. Bocasese 01 the-k loscpereting lornparsletee. 1011... clue b cyclic SOwnW loath wostc
* IoACI should Ieden been ACI 352224 (2) Icohfltwwaiada                E  inmwhythiselirnktI  318 and not AC 301.
.lo.ely tos. be 55.01.01 owosn-dlitie Failuresd. 10 distortion a vibratory oods ae also0. occurred due.. Inadequate demlg~ bite.0y11 w.0e. 1.01..owned 011.1. 01 gg FlOPS ltaep knos during VT-3visual tarntirdions 01 gout. BIA. 61.2 and S;.3 cronerts No weitat1.
in    a I*"
with what in required by code.
til.e      ther    ation section.
For darificalicn, llA Table 35S1, kern 3 51-54 will b.erevised to sstat tossof0 tnwtchrcl function u to.
Tesrqu*ireeesne*irdmit      1f0o IRA 419  A-eped    135.1-36-H-Ol]                                                    WRATable 351. Una lIenH    Nuber 3SI-36 discussnl will.b      Hoen- Dan      Althali, Rea rehed tread a- Idlows. FlReationwith aggregate II in an LRA Tae 3.51, R" HNuntsr35A-36, uder the                         applicable agng rtcl'eriamn 1o0PNPS cocree aroponeis. See dacut    n ladmn does mn mike relnnce to .RA Section              Section 35.2221(5) (altlhaighlo Groape I-5. 7, 9 ths discussion 2.5.2224 (3) lor rt l        oc aluet[on Explain why thisl nki    Iselso applicable 10 Grouqp6) am Sctian 352224(3) umtiowi ri pae tolthe lurlhas euetian ectiaon The ietmst:                 decussion. NHnethedes, the Suicrtwwe Moitoring Progan will
1dseiorc.
                                  *See Sectioa 352221 (5)for dditional dscussia new).               cotrinn Ive aere eofeging edcote regdring -      a-gst 1O lulhls elarifiation itts        section Isfor Guope IA-5 7-9.     PNPS Groap 6 oeoae ecorp-i.s" how.-c XA    waled ily    loaccesitei oup 6 concrete, Explain why WRASeetion 3.52224 (3) lisb. ercking d                Due toan axniiistrlive Ovieis he h"irng      ofLWA Section 0
01.. IovelowL.
cocrele doe to Stre Coejion Crcking (SCC).                       352224 (3) Irelverlertly listsree-king ofcon-rdee due lo tresa Core ian Cricing (SCC).Tes section tetIng elodd have be*un with reacking Due to xpepai on a,m Reaction with Agregat...e Sree coroeioncracking I[ ino cescuesed in the bdy of tsie sectioa TN efhage rapiree eanamerner boie RA 42D  Accepted P35 I-H-H01l                                                      Building eoeret. at locaions d wtpweiam emy  d    ed etenis;    Hoew-. Dan    Ah'abli, Rere godt pact 1orsupport base pee we shwn as lcuudation aend LRA Tale 3.51. Ren Hints 35.-40, uder Ife                        "Rewwlo,vessed seg      paedt" InSRA Table 352-1 (page diceasionedwMn, Mlee: &#xb6;..PlWt experience hai not                  35-M5). afouxdeoe inTatles 352-2 twough 352-5 (pes 35-59.
fatigs. due to vibrtory. srd cyclic thenne lowls is rdan aging 011ect tO.rinig toue...gsnnt Such leiws typicayldlyrmwll 1.0..
li Mdoetified    crclia Inooerete tictle capacity ooahlr            35-61, 35-64, aed 35-67), ard as- Eqf ea pasfilarwdeha.n - in cocrete aging mnarhnisda NonH-,esi, the Strictures                Table 352-6 (page35-80) Fulce elieution isproidlod InWRA Mririfaing Progan wulloroirm absencoeda*ing effects              section352226(t). page 35-S5 rekrirg rweregel 1orPNPS concreteeeoneres."
Iredwydsl design evensl rather than. th-e offe.
The project ten carrl RindanrAMR lireItem InTable 21or            Forclarificatio. URATabIe 35&1. Itern Nuer 3 51-40 daceionl Wi coronent (Bedrlng concrete ae locations of aptsion            will bervised loadd Sec Section 352226(1)e.
01 aging Loss of rraterial U1 to cono~ior% whichcould caue oss of.
ard good anchors god- ped for        1 u0ppor bse pIlele).
01n..chanica lurctio.m Is addrssed ndo h5ernb.
Pride.Ue Table 2 Alb, LRApge nurets, and                          Th.rwpqreenmenwers          lothe WIA eaompon* 10 where this "Mlline t-n Is e.&uleld and shwn Page 38d 77
35 1.53 for Groups 61.1. B1.2.
and 61.3 Support nernbe~s.-
TH~es owgi~s fln-hsneilot1.. RA FlIPS inoh01ed Ithe exerw.icn jcirt with the. ashoust piping In Section 43.2 01f.
th RA FlOPS docurnersmior ctes not the-lily
"~ dosign code bersth.0eension (01.0 separate bkm Ithe extw..
pdipin (831ll). Partia cycle. we nota ecwscn far Ith dead1 whlousl 55.1le. sicthoeS. exhaust
: 1.
te001et Is rsuw 0each
.n..rnl operating lsnpsertues withssch.1.11of. te og... Th..
.01..rsios joint isexpo..lsedory to t wn 5.rnbertof fuhllcycles to whicohtherstof ft 1.piping Is eposed T
he expe-eiw joirfis designed specifically to acooswwci.e rnoernents tha sould mull1 low. the. hosting sod codting of thwe exhus ipie 10011.. words.
Iso dosigs olert Is to0ha. bae.. rIeligse response than. the0ral0o lb. pipng Thereoreo PNPS soesurna the piping would be.1w.e Weeling than the.0per..ion jct for I". allowable Snuribof 0 cycle.
prior to reluiring ane-garorlof 0 cracking d1. 10 fatigue NRC PNPS Lead Hlowe Dan Ahralsi. Reza 424 Acceplted TI.e3,32-4, Em.ergency Diesel Gerwotor System. for carbon *led. expansion jpils insanInternal nwirrnmos 01 exhausl g". cretes the TLA* --betigsef Ifor onargng cracking dueo faligue TIMA secti0 432. NonClas I Faligue. assures, ingonarad 7000 thermal cycles for ping eysten?, allowing a stress, raeduiw ftor 0 1.0 Inth.
etrees anaysis This s a good assurnloliot forpe fitings,
,o, however, rewy al bea go9=d assurrtinc for expasion Phlase onfirm If the expanion jcnts.e included In sction 432. asd osiity t.hat th 5aseumrlion of 7000 cycles is appropriate Paid, Erach Fiorsn, Ron Alp 40d 77


James Davis - AMR- Report tothe NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                     - Page 39f Number Status   Request                                                     Response                                                                NRC      PNPS Lead 421  Accepted  ft   l-5-H-0Vl                                              FortLRA Table 35.A, IehinNuaw I3S1-51%thedPsctacsion oroin              Hoawy Den  Ahrabtlf.Reza sid      reaid 'Th.s aging aect Is rnraged by 0. Sn-xtiaes LRATabeo 3,&1, It" Nutmber35.1-50. terds tie                  oI*-biig Prog8M datenion doumnstales td loess        o dmielrIt isno applicable 1OPNPS. NUREG-1833 onPgage 931or ternTP-6        Conaorsiw thal roay becoaidtored Ints W2ard BIgro-t-ni states ansajsied preaednt aIstl for acting this mreerial. consistlo those line iesnt in Talte 352-6 withiolerials ra nwwironnrit,aging effec and proge      corntretfli 1othe  glvaized steel,asuirircss, or stainlees sled.
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 41 I Number Status Request 425 Open -
GALLReget AashownInRNPSER Sectilo 352412, g= =aed steel an staines sleedIan alidcia air                This reqdres enaw~a          t  lothe IRA wclrs, rt ooldd rilt In loess    of mraelral OA to canstrt Wilfing andt ying ocanl-U.M POimNn .Ad also be sluseptible loa -si-ilrkindo aging edfect Inthe          r wolro-sre. Provide a ls-s.o. O th. actsol gol) 82 ant B4dgpverzed sl.       stcrnlnscn an abides, sled PNPS corpaerft wrchwore within the sps            license renewal ard exposed loan ait.d, air wwirore"t Discuss the locatio cit-ahesecompornens at PNPS and how tW we protected fromncarutlt wat*ng and drying condtiorn, 4M  Acceped  [3.5.1-52-H-O11                                              Loss of material das to rrcesion                      6s*
Am part ol ft Tharnel Pos. Opimization Proiect, GE NRC yPWosMM anter III analr~oysis GE Issued a report.
is al aging effect thi      case a Howur Dan  Ahrabli. Rae loss ofInternd      cliain. Loss d met-anieal Iilooi wosld be LAATabTel351, Itein Nhet 35.1-52. inder the                  consliderl sa essn  dirnewdl banc-stanLois e schnical d      ia-as odw    OW.
OE.NE.OO.GE 0.1892-0 Re. 0. Lbrch 200Z Themnal Power-Op~rinzalki Task,=~ - RPV-Stress Lovawiromr Th-eport ovIorohd newo CUFenehrch In some cases are d~flant Own neha 1. shown In" yeRA. Table 43-1.
t    hal ls Ice.d    rnc vcai bunction    kinction Isrd aedcy effect, to lethe raeltcfagin edaets.
Mi&#xfd;n~nCUFa he CI... ICronrvrors. The GE Report, Section 33, Reeyits, sase.tes n fIeaeirol rorzzle CUF reosjotinlion hdoelet a CUF tel Wert Iron, oC lot.0 Simohely. Table a3.13 heigre eonnry test colunn os.M., CTPYTI.TP,J-re Apair% apwli. vales. wre prorkIad IW 3linlost". howrqr. her leawaleol nozzle, only Fine.
d-s to" lisledmscheris*tos Ian agig effect Proper            Ttere hIs been cat-or l bu*swesInthe Indistry ds 1o design praents dsborio% coerload. andIfteLi ds to            ttstatioa, oewtl*l a-td ceassivevibration. Sich bluses plyicalty wO-alry wnt cyclatherwml back Explain how loss of            resi11tkoraIrdloliate design a aeve. rather Psei the dale of miaejd bcalrcondituotorresion Is not waing aect            aging Failtes 6A locyclictherrIws Ie            wsvwy rwtfo.
jrulilywhal<I.0 nsen. Flwoo.provide*aspeortoc cactrd~ed value Aso.o pilease. fretily wh/ the mirled TFPO CUFval"e were neot kldpiited Inth. LRA Table 43.1.
wlche reds tobberanaged fo t.e period of alenele            sritwuralsuiports eda o ther retalivelylow berratwarme The operati*n Ifproper desig prweris, dsltortior, oerlowte wrd  ldikng surface mnaer*alswed al PNPS is lhrited whch I a 1atig.ed cbs ovibratore and cyclic thermaslesds. explain If cormrcsn resistat mawerial.Cargneris we Iesmpcted under tUe hes werbeen a con gal. failure atPIPS d toulary          I-MF for ftors saddle suipogts and SlrJlirw Wtrloring Progracr of thee esordtoirs. Explal n iftwat        eve tbeen a        for thi hbrite Wa      . 1o racidl beamwsIs        Plant operaing camponenrblis In the niclear Irnsslry das o y of these        asperlencehIs nru Idetifled feltseci lifiles cOwy*oois wsed in contltes. Explain where siJ*ing siupport    boring and      sltrucltal applicaliors. NornJre Iri s:ry experlac- hbe deantified slicng cuppotls0.a1-s we aed Ino-onrdr grotp.B2              failure assoctated withliibrite sliding atrfsae. C-at-scds and B4 at PNPS and provide th wrvirocnmerltfy we            associated withB2gouotping we limiled    soi  e t"eor raala benin mposed to.                                                                   -a ats and support    ades. There weo- slcing sit-l        saurlace assocald wilthte B40d      c rgee gotL-nc bersliding surfacesal PNPS, For clarilicatior%LRATae 35I., te 151-52 willberlevsed 1o rad o blows: "Loessd mechan-cal uncston das tot. listed machidsm Is In an agi          efect. Such lalurtes tically ra1i Iran inedscasle dosigi or copiewingawes atiherPit Iron the data of eIng Faitura is 10ocyclicthermalload                e re-for slriuratl sit-oets dot 1atheir relaively Ik. lsrrcalures.
vinaead of old vale Oaiosatod by ALTRAN Corporeilion In 1994 Are taro other IRA TIMA wflione affected by ft TFO project. eroh as Section 42Z RPV N~etron Ernbrittlement Analysis 42 Accpte lT.332-P.OeI Tab.e 3,32-,k EDO SynltrN page 3-78. her carbn wled aspelrson joints. Inon IlnwnW anvir-crte of wlehel gas credl. Ti Im!"ge to mnarge "I agin-g Offac of oreohi-g tie loIfaligoa Ft.... confirmr It TLAM Section 4 32Z NonCla.. I Fadigue, hocludes.#"e asersiveon tons. An so. s TIM qtyrion &
Thisraepirrensesawntr            lot. IlRA Pbg 3d 77


James Davis - AMR -.Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                      Page 40 ]
===Response===
Number Status    Request                                                      Response                                                              NRC         PNPS Lead 423  Accepted  13&.154-H-0I1                                                TIhedecuse... follhorn Ne..ts. 151-54 wae not leydlyingthat            Hlowe Dan    Ahralsi. Reza failures hav. not oc    d butiOW lossof me..chanca beatsi Is LRAT&boe34.1. It-. Nurnber32.-54, w.0W the                   rot an        011.0efec.
NRC a) The Pilgrim records aysln hled Me been Wploed torinclude the Paid, Erach ceragee InCUF due tofte 23 TPO prog-ra Intime losuiport LRA prepiao.i TPO yes.
Fer lie..., roneose., Etweogyklricaesr.a dewoico colunne oesee ltd los ofnros.chrca functon          oturribw01agne ffects1ltha cencase. lose01Wored.w function due loft. listed nwachtr.-e. Is e on1a.gingeffec.0 Protper  Lose o Warded15luratimnicities lose01rehnical functon design ycre-1 detar~l., overlowl,and Isligue 01.10            The lossof function Is rte 0.0id.0.5 of -agig of1.01 Aging nitoekoy .51 cyclic lthnW kb1. Explain law lossof            affect. that ould cous. losed1mechanical lunction for nst.1 1.011 hoi ,      .5 to rosooionIs M an aging elect1    ornporwe.1.In fter N unber 3 SI-5O w~eatbbeeeed 01.esoh. In wtich needs lo b. -w.gdfo      1the peritlofdw1.k            Itheeging noow racss. revsew.. For warncple lose 01o...wiel doe
nirrel impact on CUF as detiled in GE.NE-OXC-CM - I8-9-.
                                    .opertion II proper design preens. distortioeverotdos mid  Sosanynxethaismn Isoftbesse IlTable 35 2- u-sI. listings for t.0g..6 to.v~ibrtor0y.01 cyclic esthwr    oodsi expdlanN      cornponent ard piping support A&W. Class 1.Z 3 01 LC (Paeg f... too ove been a cornono filure~ at PNPS its loany      35-71). af01eo..poren sodpipingsupports(Pegs 35-72.
Rw-I. 32.
d Ithes.conditons.. Explen if there hae .er bewen            C~onporontfalues~eat PNPS ard Inth. nuc.w Inlduty hav.
The re9o=d0 *yle hs.
ooywel1urowIn .. nuclear Industy due I*oany.1 th... csoertily.0ocurreddu boverolod (tyicallycaused by... oven4 such Exlaiwnwhtd PNPS Imspactsfor duing VT-3        as waereleo.....) avibratory andl cycictswtd Iced.. Bocasese      01 cwdtro,Visd      .rnto.-
been sdmod Srd lye PNIPS correctiv. eaion program reires that the Information beaseassed he p*el*t Inpact onther LRA eoctions. PNFPS will q te LRA le 43-1 looIncle lye velues fromn the TPO.
0 wce. 1.1 B1 sd 61.3                      loscpereting lornparsletee.1011... clue b cyclic SOwnWloath the-k oofltoon.ert under Its Irm-oic. h'.pe0ctir Prograrndurin~g        .lo.ely tos. be 55.01.01 owosn-dlitie Failuresd. 10 wostc Uscurrent lice-.. swd Woo antiipated VT-3 visual            distortion a vibratory oods ae also0.occurred due.. Inadequate
In preparing the TPO eibeas aoust hor GE reviewed only incee RPV componertas wones prmui lentoturs, and 11. condlion wweoe mee *were do
                                  .exaistios during Its possible extendedlwicense              demlg~ bite.0y11      w.0e.1.01..owned 011.1. 01 gg FlOPS ltaep knosduring VT-3visual tarntirdions 01 gout. BIA. 61.2 and S;.3 cronerts      weitat1.
'lote TPO and withfasigUe Lag. lactore eater ten 0,5 These CUFewere ne recalcUlated by taeio5al nethods. beL rthw were eetinaled by corswoevarol y ccasing the dresses. deternining the code aelonaboe nettr of cycles ho thE.o
No            with what inrequired by code.
: strese, l line rmrrg th. Increrensl rage factor loh agroup of cyoles conaeidred In f* oiginti stress report. Before f TPO.
For darificalicn, llA Table 35S1, kern3 51-54 will b.erevisedto sstat tossof0tnwtchrcl function u to.     1dseiorc. 01.. IovelowL.
ft CUF for th eewml.s rzlet. (Allnn Report) was listed as.08.
fatigs. due tovibrtory. srd cyclic thenne lowls is rdan aging 011ecttO.rinig toue...gsnnt Such leiws typicayldlyrmwll 1.0..
forh e TPOh CUFIeorveI Io<l.Q Noprecileevalue was ccuaredl As Istated In ft renporee toOueston 345. PNPS will perfonm a new feedwater vezle latigue aralysis prior to ft peeied d Waerded operation b) Nootlhe" e ons of fte IRA wre effetlw by the TPO. The iluence veoues Med In Secion 4 2 ware based on the Idghw power Ied.e TLAA-mdal latigue Is nro an ang maevgemnrl program Urder the Paed, Erach staedndd LRA tonal. TLA.-Arl fbeigue In Ivnertod under the agin msnwI gaenvl progran en. conrwwiee holhdcate Ind a TLM Ifo mntl Istigue applies to O lrne hen The carebon Wed expansion joirt arc dsigned per a. reoquiry,-ens cfASid 831.1 loh alimelt mrInuber of tevlh cyCle. The waeeusion of leigue hor ASCE 831.1 conmponenrs Isdo*orsedinSection 4.32 The ewaeution del-emned teW U. EDGoomponevi willrentin below the cyclelimrit hoe Oyme euch that crcrking Is not Opected PNPS Lead Firnin. Ron Frorebarger.
Iredwydsl design evensl rather than.th-eoffe. 01aging Loss of rraterial U1 to cono~ior%whichcould caueoss of. 01n..chanica lurctio.m Is addrssed ndo h5ernb. 35 1.53 for Groups 61.1. B1.2.
PaWe 41 d 77
and61.3 Supportnernbe~s.-
TH~es owgi~s fln-hsneilot1.. RA 424  Acceplted  TI.e3,32-4, Em.ergencyDiesel Gerwotor System. for            FlIPS inoh01edItheexerw.icn jcirt with the. ashoust piping In          Paid, Erach Fiorsn, Ron carbon *led. expansion jpils insanInternal nwirrnmos 01      Section 43.2 01f. th RA FlOPSdocurnersmiorctes not the-lily exhausl g". cretes the TLA* --betigsefIforonargng            "~ dosign code bersth .0eension (01.0separate bkm Itheextw..
cracking dueo faligue TIMA secti0 432. NonClas I              pdipin (831ll). Partia cycle. we notaecwscn far Ith dead1 Faligue. assures, ingonarad 7000 thermal cyclesfor ping        whlousl 55.1le. sicthoeS.exhaust      te001et Is1.            0each rsuw eysten?, allowinga stress, raeduiw ftor 0 1.0 Inth.          .n..rnl operating lsnpsertues withssch .1.11of.te og... Th..
etreesanaysis This s a good assurnloliot    forpe fitings,  .01..rsios joint isexpo..lsedory tot 5.rnbertof wn T            fuhllcyclesto
                                    ,o, however, rewy al bea go9=dassurrtinc for expasion      whicohtherstof ft1.piping Is eposed        he expe-eiw joirfis designedspecifically to acooswwci.e rnoernents tha sould mull1 low. the. hosting sod codtingof thwe exhus ipie 10011.. words.
Phlase onfirm If the expanion jcnts .e included In            Isodosigs olert Is to0ha. bae..rIeligse response than. the0ral0o sction 432. asd osiity t.hatth  5aseumrlion of 7000 cycles  lb. pipng ThereoreoPNPS soesurna the piping would be .1w.e is appropriate                                                Weelingthan the .0per..ion jct for I". allowable Snuribof  0 cycle.
prior to reluiring ane-garorlof  0 cracking d1. 10fatigue Alp 40d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                           Page 41 I Number Status   Request                                                   Response                                                            NRC        PNPS Lead 425 Open -   Ampart ol ft Tharnel Pos. Opimization Proiect,GE          a) The Pilgrim records aysln hled Me been Wploed torinclude the    Paid, Erach  Firnin. Ron NRC      yPWosMManter III                    GE Issued a report.
James Davis- -AMR-Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 42;1 Number Status Request 427 Closed
analr~oysis                      ceragee InCUF due tofte 23 TPO prog-ra Intime losuiport OE.NE.OO.GE 0.1892-0 Re. 0. Lbrch 200Z Themnal            LRAprepiao.i      TPO yes. nirrelimpact on CUF as detiled in Power-Op~rinzalki Task,=~ - RPV- Stress Lovawiromr        GE.NE-OXC-CM - I8-9-. Rw- I. 32.               The re9o=d0 *yle hs.
[Ta322.P-1t For aging affet d cracking dee to laige. PNPS hea cradled TLAA -
Th- eport ovIorohd newoCUFenehrch Insome casesare          been sdmodSrd lye PNIPScorrectiv. eaion program reires that d~flant Own neha1. shown In"yeRA. Table 43-1.              the Information beaseassed he p*el*t Inpact onther LRA Mi&#xfd;n~nCUFa he CI... ICronrvrors. The GE Report,            eoctions. PNFPS  will q te LRAle        43-1 looIncle lye velues Section 33, Reeyits,sase.tes n fIeaeirol rorzzleCUF        fromntheTPO.
edld togw anc agni; mersgwonw prograr Ior owo~rsuntsin ano Itrir srvirornar. ol
reosjotinlion hdoelet a CUF tel Wert Iron, oC lot.0 Simohely. Table a3.13 heigre eonnry test colunn            In preparing the TPO eibeas aoust hor GE reviewed only incee RPV os.M., CTPYTI.TP ,J-re Apair%apwli. vales.wre            componertas  wones prmui          lentoturs, and 11. condlion prorkIadIW 3linlost". howrqr. herleawaleol nozzle, only    wweoemee *were do            'lote TPO and withfasigUe Lag. lactore eater ten 0,5 These CUFewere ne recalcUlated by taeio5al nethods. beLrthw were eetinaled by corswoevarol y ccasing the Fine. jrulilywhal<I.0 nsen. Flwoo.provide*aspeortoc        dresses. deternining the code aelonaboe nettr of cycles ho thE.o cactrd~ed value Aso.o pilease.fretily wh/ the mirled TFPO    strese, line l          rmrrg th. Increrensl rage factor lohagroup CUFval"e wereneotkldpiited Inth. LRA Table 43.1.            ofcyoles conaeidred Inf* oiginti stress report. Before f TPO.
.rhew gas InTable 13 32A EDO Systenre. howlwa, In TabI 3.3.2-5 S8DO Systrn and Table 3 32.6 S00 SYllten ". Psrnoclo Socoellance ard Pr~enetio.
vinaeadof old vale Oaiosatod by ALTRAN CorporeilionIn    ft CUF for th eewml.s rzlet. (Allnn Report) was listed as .08.
KAdnermen (PSK'M Progrrnr is crecitecL w~nch Irclude nisWs or CIL NDE tech! wa tolimpact ash-ct systern 0cErnonr~to bnwvV cracking Pies. justify wtV ft P7'M prograrn Is not cradiledlo 1th8.
1994                                                      forh e TPOh CUFIeorveI Io<l.Q Noprecileevalue was ccuaredl      As Istated In ft renporee toOueston 345. PNPS will Are taro other IRA TIMA wflione affected by ft TFO        perfonm a new feedwater vezle latigue aralysis prior to ft peeied d project. eroh as Section 42Z RPV N~etronErnbrittlement      Waerded operation Analysis b) Nootlhe"e ons of fte IRA wreeffetlw by the TPO. The iluence veoues Med In Secion 4 2 ware based onthe Idghw power Ied.e 42  Accpte  lT.332-P.OeI                                              TLAA-mdal latigue Isnro an ang maevgemnrl program Urder the          Paed, Erach Frorebarger.
EDO systen corrnonats $or norecgng aging dlect of cracking SIt Is4 onlredted or loss of maerial ad Woinrg 425 Closed
staedndd LRAtonal. TLA.-Arl fbeigue In Ivnertod under the Tab.e 3,32-,k EDO SynltrN page3-78. hercarbn wled          agin msnwI  gaenvl progran en.conrwwiee holhdcate Ind a aspelrson joints. Inon IlnwnW anvir-crte of wlehel gas    TLM Ifo mntl Istigue applies toO lrne hen The carebonWed credl. Ti      Im!"ge to mnarge "I agin-g Offac oforeohi-g expansion joirt arc dsigned per a. reoquiry,-ens cfASid 831.1 tie loIfaligoa                                              lohalimelt mrInuberof tevlh cyCle. The waeeusion of leigue hor ASCE 831.1 conmponenrs        Isdo*orsedinSection 4.32 The Ft.... confirmrItTLAMSection 4 32Z NonCla.. I Fadigue,    ewaeution del-emned teWU. EDGoomponevi willrentin below hocludes.#"e asersiveon tons. An so. s  TIM qtyrion &  the cyclelimrithoeOyme euch that crcrking Isnot Opected PaWe41 d 77
[T.3.2.P-ttj Tate 3.32-9. Fir*ProtecticnWWd.rSysl.A i hpipir silerc, and heheherge Ienst Internol exhe.*t gae aerlrmnent with an agng tilecl of crooking &as to fatig^w PNPS hse. cerdited It. Fire Prtctionto Progncrn to marga te aging afecit The Pr.7-deo-.
6, Acet Criteria. is wencmel to verily that the doead engine vid rot eshibit Igna of degradtioin wrtle It we. rwrsng smh as fdrt go tes Wkege.
Plese Jcetity honw the aging dtrct of Crackirg 1..rreegod by neitying for exhaust 0. 1..%"eg 9 9-e.
Isteskge It Irnplies a tiouglwalI crack tasoo ~o~rrs Vritying 1to Wattage Is r to eadhgleqa agirg noregonert progrwn for Managing cracking


James Davis--AMR- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                          Page 42;1 Number Status  Request                                                  Response                                                           NRC         PNPS Lead 427  Closed  [Ta322.P-1t                                              TL4A-rraf l tIat!. Is not wnagng nrogort program Under the         Paid, Erach Uoyd. Ward atarched LRA tormal, TLAA-omelatti gue In tmed todoer       ft For aging affet d cracking dee to laige. PNPS hea        aging n-2-art prcgamn sea oowerience,to inicate the a cradled TLAA- edldtogw anc agni; mersgwonw                TLAA/or he tae Wligue apies toOl 1-i*lient The EDO ache*W prograr Ior owo~rsuntsin  anoItrir srvirornar. ol        syslerns wedesigned per fte relcrernoret ofAS&E B31.1 orea
===Response===
                                .rhew gas InTable 1332A EDO Systenre.howlwa, In          limniledruttbe dChrnl cycles. The evaluatliondrtigue fo TabI 3.3.2-5 S8DO Systrn and Table 3 32.6 S00            ASIME831.1 -orrporert. hloicused InSecton 432 The SYllten ". PsrnocloSocoellance ard Pr~enetio.            evaJuation determined thet the EDO crarnpoet wilttremainbelow KAdnermen (PSK'M      Progrrnris crecitecLw~nchIrclude    the cycle lit. for 8yeesr such th cracking isrot espected The nisWs or CIL NDE tech! wa tolimpact ash-ct systern          hatest syslervo hothe 1stalimtackou dead gonerotor and 0cErnonr~to  bnwvV    cracking                          security deod genratlor we rot designed to a code ora tMand wherethermel cycles we aconsideraton Thore.cre the Periodic Pies. justify wtV ft P7'M prograrn Is not cradiledlo 1th8. Sf     ifttearceand PoecerwwcetcIhr    ,ce, (PSPtA progarn will EDO systen corrnonats $or norecgng aging dlect of        warog or   aolirtim 8 abseron of cracking due tothenal fatigue cracking SItIs4 onlredtedor loss of maerial ad Woinrg 425  Closed  [T.3.2.P-ttj                                              The eging elfect di atiguo cracking to oorernseivd y Idenfitedhe  Pald, Erach  Fror~brger.
NRC TL4A-rraf l tIat!.
Owlre pusvpdead anine. fie
Is not wnagng nrogort program Under the Paid, Erach atarched LRA tormal, TLAA-omelat ti gue In tmed todoer ft aging n-2-art prcgamn sea oowerience, to inicate the a TLAA/or he tae Wligue apies to Ol 1-i*lient The EDO ache*W syslerns wedesigned per fte relcrernoret ofAS&E B31.1 orea limniled ruttbe dC hrnl cycles. The evaluatlion drtigue fo ASIME 831.1 -orrporert. hloicused InSecton 432 The evaJuation determined thet the EDO crarnpoet wilttremain below the cycle lit. for 8yeesr such th cracking isrot espected The hatest syslervo hothe 1stalim tackou dead gonerotor and security deod genratlor we rot designed to a code or a tMand wherethermel cycles we aconsideraton Thore.cre the Periodic Sf ifttearce and Poecerwwce tcIhr
* he*at o-onrwf were Tate 3.32-9.Fir*ProtecticnWWd.rSysl.A ihpipir            denigmnedper ASM 831.1 cod, a lined Mr . of vye.. would silerc, and heheherge Ienst Internol exhe.*t gae              8.Uesthod for estcepitily tocracking due to heigue Since be the aerlrmnent with an agng tilecl ofcrooking &as to fatig^w  the syslern Isnormaly In stardby and wed prinmrily ducing teatin*
,ce, (PSPtA progarn will warog or aolirtim 8 abseron of cracking due tothenal fatigue PNPS Lead Uoyd. Ward Fror~brger.
PNPS hse.cerdited It. Fire Prtctionto Progncrnto marga    Itis tinlikely toreoch aey legtlitrie Unreslcid to pro**e fatigue te aging afecit The Pr.7- deo-. 6, Acet                    rackirg, Furthenrore. throughn'oriloring and trending d Criteria. is wencmel to verily that the doeadenginevidrot  performanco     data ndoerthe Fire Prolection Program. ereckirg of eshibit Igna of degradtioin wrtle It we. rwrsng smh as    sysatemrn   onpoerls willbeidertiied and correcled through in fdrt    go tes Wkege.                                      corectiveactin program As deecribed Insection B 1.1la, oevtcse lon ofdtogeadd perform me produced 'racrive actions Plese Jcetityhonwtheaging dtrct of Crackirg1. .rreegod    Ireludng engine repacemrel In2(2g prior to leos d Worded by neitying for exhaust 0. 1..%"eg 9 9-e. Isteskge It    kurction. Coeequertly, corrinudInTiecrtaiion dft8 Fire Irnpliesa tiouglwalI crack tasoo Wattage Is to
The eging elfect di atiguo cracking to oorernse ivd y Idenfited he Ow lre pusvp dead anine.
                                                                  ~o~rrs Vritying 1to r eadhgleqa agirg noregonert progrwnfor Protecton Prog's.r provlde. tesore assrance eing fects will be n-reged f the 8deead ire punp emhecel scbsystelo. In Managing cracking                                        arhiiort PNPS performs fire purp irepecSon, testing aNd naienence Ineocordance withNFPA 25which would also detect Z. pre.ee. o oracking In the sehet ysylemprior toloss of IrlwW functionrc TK3 Itoer Is cloeed to tern 378 Pap 42d 77
fie he*at o-onrwf were denigmned per ASM 831.1 cod, a lined Mr.
of vye..
would be the 8.Uesthod for estcepitily tocracking due to heigue Since the syslern Is normaly In stardby and wed prinmrily ducing teatin*
Itis tinlikely toreoch aey legtlitrie Unreslcid to pro**e fatigue rackirg, Furthenrore. through n'oriloring and trending d performanco data ndoer the Fire Prolection Program. ereckirg of sysatemrn onpoerls willbeidertiied and correcled through in corectiveactin program As deecribed Insection B 1.1la, oevtcse lon ofdtogeadd perform me produced  
'racrive actions Ireludng engine repacemrel In2(2g prior to leos d Worded kurction. Coeequertly, corrinudInTiecrtaiion dft8 Fire Protecton Prog's.r provlde. tesore assrance eing fects will be n-reged f the 8deead ire punp emhecel scbsystelo. In arhiiort PNPS performs fire purp irepecSon, testing aNd naienence Ineocordance with NFPA 25which would also detect Z. pre.ee. o oracking In the sehet ysylem prior to loss of IrlwW functionrc TK3 Itoer Is cloeed to tern 378 Pald, Erach Pap 42d 77


James Davis - AMR -,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                               .                                                                                        Page 43 Number Status   Request                                                             Response                                                          NRC            PNPFS  Lead 429   Cloudr   [T332-P-121                                                         The progarn deecrilion listed inSection E1.131 nmtchee the        Paid, Erech      Frombarer.g doscripblon died InGALL section )t Mr. Fire Protection which bnRt.AScrft,333.273. PINIFSa           ele. ft ftcarlbo             Inclesre ft dee driven fire pr*r The whe, piping and steel deed sahml hiping andoorinewn.1 tnthe Are                     coryonents arepatl fthe firecrxp Enirnents for eagig prcection cylernt     Is manarged by fth Fire Prodcrtion             agerti          01the cehein Lceytemnt we described [or attribdee Prngrn TheFirvProteciwrProgcrarneeavisret                          3-pearnaders mn loredinmpeo led and 6-aceeplarce criteria f the Inspection ofdiesel cexhatl pipng       an01ocnrriprwits I.       prograM mna~ge loss       nereWiW.
James Davis - AMR -,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 43 Number Status Request 429 Cloudr
This tem Isclosed tonlem 375.
[T332-P-121 bnRt.AScrft,333.273. PINIFSa ele. ft ftcarlbo steel deed sahml hiping and oorinewn.1 tnthe Are prcection cylernt Is manarged by fth Fire Prodcrtion Prngrn The FirvProteciwrProgcrarneeavisret Inspection ofdiesel cexhatl pipng an01 ocnrriprwits I.
II FirePrdlectonProgcrar      tttA a1.1a1) Iscraded   tforw inaging eging01this. eornpon           orte. rieee sapyddnwhlt lito eystmrorrtonrislwerd Included Inft. progce.
mna~ge loss nereWiW.
description   d fth Fire Protc~tion Progrcn, Furtm-n9. no wilecerneft Is catresea VWlwodd root.e ftco can~rents n,rit*Ff     F Fydeetwioni   Progeecr 433 Closed   (T332-P 131                                                         Se. fle res.oae to Iten 394 ft adtreses  eceeaw in Tnble a12-9      Paid, Errach    Fronabergar, For thepip*n* nponart line inmInTable 332-10 that hac SdeerinrtI loqeetion T.3.3Z1.fth aytkM hascradled                  Indoor air (irc) a an aneirowrrnl theFire Protecticn Progein Fire Prtdection   ProraerIn~c l1wo GALL     AKVXI M38.           lmbodt.                          f ai..W tIepection of01e aterr'nl swrc. 01ftheHlon Imepaction   d InternalSurfaese    oflcd~ne           Pipingcrd    sycten pipngrard taiks Sin@e metlrrn surfaces wereprneeclive OrcrtirrCnrryreftas c rcecrnrrmne.d           Io GALLJimr            01 Inrternal iacaseeies    we epo**od to th sae erwironert, the V D2-16, wind Is dreferece by the applicarl5 ftc tin.Ji             Fir. Prdlecticn Prograc Isal*uqae for inareng ft aging alfects Rental. Th. GaLLAW'X35M owes ftt 01c.j Inspectionr                 of conponrn*a            dryal to kn- air.
II Fire Prdlecton Progcrar tttA a1.1a 1) Iscraded tforw inaging eging 01 this. eornpon orte. rieee sapyddn whlt lito eystmr orrtonrisl we rd Included Inft. progce.
ofInternal@c._.e dftcrl oorriponrtsc           Inperformed  .1wirg
description d fth Fire Protc~tion Progrcn, Furtm-n9. no wilecerneft Is catresea VWl wodd root.e ftco can~rents n, rit*Ff F Fydeetwioni Progeecr 433 Closed (T332-P 131 SdeerinrtI loqeetion T.3.3Z1. fth aytkM has cradled Fire Prtdection Proraer In~c l1wo GALL AKV XI M38.
: r. or~lr
Imepaction d Internal Surfaese oflcd~ne Piping crd Orcrtirr Cnrryreftas c rcecrnrrmne.d Io GALL Jimr V D2-16, wind Is dreferece by the applicarl5 ftc tin.Ji Rental. Th. GaLL AW' X35M owes ftt 01c.j Inspectionr of Internal @c._.e df tcrl oorriponrtsc In performed
                                                    -erin.Ilc.n actnivll. lo, llcibteieanae d1       Th. Itn 1. losed to Itern 378.
.1wirg or~lr
corrosion  toIrdcale possible loscoftraetwia SincePNPSta Loinrg       ft FireProtection    Prograe. Inlie 01 GALLAM' 70M3 pt" aseeee         cen thon.ft Fire Protcrtionl Prog'ern percdarnethis    viceet trsipcrti     As written InIna LR, fth Fire Pracetinr ProgearntIs Maerteqeee torwango loss of instcni!d 1w trese orpnenycct&
: r.  
431 Closedt   T322-P-011                                                       NUREG-1801 does rno specity XMI. Mta Fdigwe of Reector              Pa1rilt  Wayre  Ungerilter, Coolant Presswe Bowvty InIn AMP codwln ior fters Idertifyirn Table 32Z qesetiert I                                               cumrultive ladfgu dernage NUREG-81I iderlifies ofige as a TLA ra8d    ralerweogJidce InSAP Section 43 winh Infirn The Ft4PSR61.12 Fatige IMonitoing tecrad~le 1wr                     dencribe. keatrr.1 o0faligue Ina variety d ways dwwdfV ong    wt rna-grrg fth aging lladt Creet'ingWig.01 1w coro~naenl               conernpor. Since NUREG-1801 dos rot cradt ft Falige In fth RtHA(Table     Nerter 322- 1), ADS (Tatie N-berdn           Monitoring Prograr, exceptioe In inaproran hove m beering on1 322- 3). HPIC (Tee. N-ore 3 22 4). FICIC (TableNufter                Jimselection 1 rot.
-erin.Ilc.n actnivll. lo, llcibteieanae d1 corrosion to Irdcale possible losc of traetwia Since PNPS ta Loinrg ft Fire Protection Prograe. In lie 01 GALL AM' 70M3 pt" aseeee cen thon. ft Fire Protcrtionl Prog'ern percdarne this viceet trsipcrti As written In Ina LR, fth Fire Pracetinr Progearn tIs Maerteqeee torwango loss of instcni!d 1w trese orpnenycct&
32Z2 5) eysterre. hnnnat cec. fth cwrerrnpoent.et been ansigned Note KorNote 'C%How~eew,th FlIPS EK1.12 Fafigo Monitoring proogwnr ec mceptidore,loth. GALL progwrar X AM. MWd Fadig.. 01Reactor Coolant Preenwe Bowrlarr. Therefore Nd.e *Ccshod be Node *Doand Ntne.
431 Closedt T322-P-011 Table 32Z qesetiert I The Ft4PS R61. 12 Fatige IMonitoing te crad~le 1wr rna-grrg fth aging lladt Creet'ing Wig.01 1w coro~naenl In fth RtHA (Table Nerter 322-1), ADS (Tatie N-berdn 322-3). HPIC (Tee. N-ore 3 22 4). FICIC (Table Nufter 32Z2 5) eysterre. hn nnat cec. fth cwrerrnpoe nt.et been ansigned Note KorNote 'C% How~eew,th FlIPS EK1.12 Fafigo Monitoring proogwnr ec mceptidore, loth. GALL progwrar X AM. MWd Fadig.. 01 Reactor Coolant Preenwe Bowrlarr. Therefore Nd.e *Ccshod be Node *Doand Ntne.
AKchmAd    be NoteIBas appropriate for ftc. conyrpwwt Page 43d 77
AK chmAd be NoteI Bas appropriate for ftc. conyrpwwt


James Davis- AMR- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                          .                .Page                                                        44:1 Number Status  Request                                                        Response                                                                NRC            PNPS Lead 432 Cloeed  [T322-P-02                                                      ABoling nteriy Progas' willbededqloped Vi- willecdrkssef                Pavriichl tynr  Frontbargo-,
===Response===
Tging m2nngwsl dollingSInthe seepeo lice                reeal.
NRC The progarn deecrilion listed in Section E1.131 nmtchee the Paid, Erech doscripblon died In GALL section )t Mr. Fire Protection which Inclesre ft dee driven fire pr*r The whe, piping and coryonents arepatl fthe firecrxp Enirnents for eagig agerti 01 the cehein Lceytemnt we described [or attribdee 3-pearnaders mn loredinmpeo led and 6-aceeplarce criteria f the prograM This tem Is closed tonlem 375.
Table 322. 9seation 2 The Bliling kItegity Progern witltrenptrlnmJed prior loth period The PNPS 8,1.30 Spysln hlkdewn Progen Is used bo                of dendleedoperaeion inacdorhre withoornrtiet nutber X ddweet d rm      catron sled boilng Imnted dGALL XLMIB Boiting Inlegrily. XI.MIi lrvoke vied VT-I aeenireatin or      TNt reriree eanaroevlme lot. LRA toiredi descriplor. of tolling lees lhan2 rnchs Indaenr.          It Is rut elmni V I  th BSlling Inlegrily Prograrn InAppyedc      Aard        ealdto Wdtilfy I. send or boiling Val Is*aned in acoerdbtce withlth            m woso ifL progerm is aeplicoela Systerm %Wkd-onProgrm Wet st*rarcd Iswed for vite "repecllionof boiling un      "fSyster Wikelown Progran, he                              TN. hen le cal      %,harr to      M3.
Se. fle res.oae to Iten 394 ft adtreses eceeaw in Tnble a12-9 Paid, Errach For thepip*n* nponart line inm InTable 332-10 that hac Indoor air (irc) a an aneirowrrnl the Fire Protecticn Progein lmbodt.
433  Closed  [T322-P-]                                                      Sin&e fhe Or-Tirme Inspecion (OTI) Progs.. Is epplicable towh          Paviich, Wanyr  Froengort, waner cetaridry controlproea'. ifIs also plicable to ,h llne Table 322, qestion 3                                            hem if-elcrecis a waler chis"try control program LRATaele 321 fresealee ..l he Ore-Tins Inspection Progras Is cmeled Sirese steled ensled conporerl that we epceed So                along wi0l he wete chestry control progares lo line hterelor tested walarin Table 322 do ral specify one-lrnse                wech GALLrecwrewdw    y a oe-Wre Ibpeclion to cornirm wamet Iripeclort to clted        rle dnalaiat allheuoh Table 321      che-istry cosrtd. Table 2 credi he Ofttprogam TfnoUg'h Irdcalea OTtL dtdOTI$*. AMF Sor es. orporoete for                timermo lothe asesclaed Tele I line len.
a i..W tIepection of01e f
co-ssleencywith Table 321 or provide a Jutificalloiorn ml pernfrring OTI.                                                  TN. repires eonrw        r lthe chewritry progr" deskorilore InILA Apparel- A ard B b cleary icleis thet he Or-Tirne osctlion Progrne  willo-diirm he ilfecsli      *Wet f the Chenislry Conirol - BER. Warn Chle-lstry Cortrcl - Ateiliary ystisns and the Walee Cl-snitry Cortrd - Closled Cooling Wer progrsre TN. Item i.ctoeed s, Itre 372.
aterr'nl swrc.
434  Cloeed  (T322-P-04]                                                                                                                              PFvirlch, Wayne Frc    '.ge, The Sijreln Whetilorre Progean Istnot tile        tnlreet Iteriom le, Table 322. qieion 4                                            riOngard crewl1 s9ein- u.es hey hse been exposedSW Irepeclion Wuingnire-eren.e and repairs As tnrcoled l the If Is mt den Ifthe System WVelklen Progean provkdesIn          lias. In Sectlion 3d hfe LRA, he Syslan Walkdomn Fingrr Irnsection Ilerir stlacts dc nion alea oonpoierts                manages agng lft exteal surfnactesdf orwews-a.          The progran ipred to Indor r IrmLOM Fees, prode doetils                  alsoesrregee lossed erial frorn lr rW        swine. Insiuilion. In sihring Ispection of irntior surfacees or Ins odmponrt.          wNch Irleel mete        ral rtenalse ridle edrwnrir-mrl cor*rGretion we the sans euch S elere swurfaoe        eonditi Is reteertativ a d iner    surface coreslime 435  Closed  (T222-P-MJ                                                      ThI. enoi* piping compres Inltables 332-A. 322-5. and                    Painich W"yn. Ungertdler, 332-14-16. Itwhih Nde C'ws        ehig-s      hMoe itele ahte Tale 322. ptelion 5                                            eariro-ent. Thi eysere represented by fhte tables ao all ESF systere. hrweer. NUREO-1801 does rat irclude the contirelion heMrn bers 322-4. 322-5i. al 332-14-16 -eelsirtes              d etandse sol In slen encirorvneet foranry ESFconTynse sled piping oironorts (eg onficee, dreairoe). Please            (ChapemV). Corerienly, coprisni            w    trensdeloest-e srd etplain wly Note Cwas assigned tI ftse coipoeres                powe conesion iyslemrs conrr s (Chree %III)whre              lhe stainless selslsea cornitrt ion Is addeestd Sis the eystens dot'    nmtclh a Note wC'Is aNlied PaW 44d 77
01 fthe Hlon sycten pipngr ard taiks Sin@e metlrrn surfaces we reprneeclive 01 Inrternal iacaseeies we epo**od to th sae erwironert, the Fir. Prdlecticn Prograc Is al*uqae for inareng ft aging alfects of conponrn*a dryal to kn-air.
Th. Itn 1. losed to Itern 378.
NUREG-1801 does rno specity XMI. Mta Fdigwe of Reector Pa1rilt Way Coolant Presswe Bowvty InIn AMP codwln ior fters Idertifyirn cumrultive ladfgu dernage NUREG-81I iderlifies ofige as a TLA ra8d ralerwe ogJidce InSAP Section 43 winh Infirn dencribe. keatrr.1 o0 faligue Ina variety d ways dwwdfV ong wt conernpor. Since NUREG-1801 dos rot cradt ft Falige Monitoring Prograr, exceptioe In ina proran hove m beering on1 Jim selection 1 rot.
PNPFS Lead Frombarer.g Fronabergar, re Ungerilter, Page 43d 77


3-CID 10 Item                        Lead        Project Type                Due Date      Due Date RAIslInput          Due    Date SE Input              Status/Comments            0c One time Relief Request from ASME                                                                                          Complete              q                          CD Section XI Code Requirments                S. Samaddar LA - Watts Bar                                                        5/31/06          Complete One Time Extension of Contaiment                                                                                                                I:A is going to clarfe Integrated Leakage Rate Interval          H. Ashar    LA - Prairie Island                                                                    due date.
James Davis-AMR-Report to the NRC.doc.pdf
H. Ashar/                                                    Complete                        e    BI ikais          -1          CL Five Year CILRT Extension                  R.Jackson  LA - Watts Bar                                    4/15/06                              ackae
.Page 44:1 Number Status Request
                                                                                                                                                '                **e        0 Amendment Re: Contingent Installation                                                                                        I %            9 of Temp. Spent Fuel Rack                  S. Samaddar LA - Monticello                                    8/1/06              l                On Tracl;;
NOAA MOU                                  Y. Li                                          ASAP                                                Pe          it.
Complete DG-1 145 Sections C.I.3.7-C.I.3.13        T. Cheng    Draft Guide                      5/30/06                                              Complete
* R. Jackson/                                                                                        .
Primary Containment LRT Program            H. Ashar    LA - La Salle                                                                          Working Progress Complet&#xfd;                                              Secretary has the Ts u na m i                              Y. Li        _            _ _ _ _ _ _c_
_.,_.__ _. 5 /9 /0 6        K      'It__ .      .  .
Update SRP Section 2.4.1, 2.4.2,                                            ,                                                                    i                  ithke 2.4.3, 2.4.4, 2.4.5, 2.4.6, 2.4.7, 2.4.8, t                                                                                            '      *          $            due 2.4.9, 2.4.10,2.4.11, 2.4.12,2.4.13, & S. Samaddar/    Update Section 2.4z-                                jg        is      a.ir.        ,        "ttea          a 2.4.14                                    G. Bagchi    New Reactor                            ?      -            *                  -
                                                                                                                .                                  g          0 Using Fiber-Reinforced Polymer (FRP)
System to Strengthen Concrete            J. Ma / R.                                                                        '"-
Masonry Walls                            Jackson      LA- Oconee                                                          11_                I nT            1-_t.
Update - SRP Section 3.8.1, 3.8.2,                    Update Section 3.8 -
3.8.3, 3.8.4, & 3.8.5                    D. Jeng      New Reactor                      1/30/07    0      8          H    11        ,*    Bor              "
Update Section 3.5.1.3        -                          3                      w a'p"      G' SRP Section 3.5.1.3 Turbine Missiles      J. Ma        New Reactor                                  _          _                              concurrence only M. Valentin-Tornado Design Basis                      Olmeda      LA - Fermi 2                      11/1/06        9/15/06              12/15/06          Working Progre!E C
I                I    I-a.


C-CD (n
===Response===
NRC PNPS Lead 432 Cloeed
[T322-P-02 ABoling nteriy Progas' willbededqloped Vi-willecdrksse f Pavriichl tynr Frontbargo-,
Tging m2nn gwsl dolling SInthe seepeo lice reeal.
Table 322. 9seation 2 The Bliling kItegity Progern witltrenptrlnmJed prior loth period The PNPS 8,1.30 Spysln hlkdewn Progen Is used bo of dendleed operaeion inacdorhre withoornrtiet nutber X ddweet d
rm catron sled boilng Imnted dGALL XLMIB Boiting Inlegrily. XI.MIi lrvoke vied VT-I aeenireatin or TNt reriree eanaroevlme lot. LRA toiredi descriplor. of tolling lees lhan 2 rnchs Indaenr.
It Is rut elmn i V I th BSlling Inlegrily Prograrn InAppyedc Aard eald to Wdtilfy I. send or boiling Val Is *aned in acoerdbtce withlth m
woso ifL progerm is aeplicoela Systerm %Wkd-on Progrm Wet st*rarcd Is wed for vite "repecllion of boiling un he "fSyster Wikelown Progran, TN. hen le cal to
%, harr M3.
433 Closed
[T322-P-]
Sin&e fhe Or-Tirme Inspecion (OTI) Progs.. Is epplicable to wh Paviich, Wanyr Froengort, waner cetaridry control proea'. if Is also plicable to
,h llne Table 322, qestion 3 hem if-el crecis a waler chis"try control program LRA Taele 321 fresealee..l he Ore-Tins Inspection Progras Is cmeled Sirese steled en sled conporerl that we epceed So along wi0l he wete chestry control progares lo line htere lor tested walar in Table 322 do ral specify one-lrnse wech GALL recwrewdw y
a oe-Wre Ibpeclion to cornirm wamet Iripeclort to clted rle d nalaiat allheuoh Table 321 che-istry cosrtd. Table 2 credi he Oftt progam TfnoUg'h Irdcalea OTtL dtd OTI$*. AMF or S es. orporoete for timermo lothe asesclaed Tele I line len.
co-ssleency with Table 321 or provide a Jutificalloiorn ml pernfrring OTI.
TN. repires eonrw r
lthe chewritry progr" deskorilore In ILA Apparel-A ard B b cleary icleis thet he Or-Tirne osctlion Progrne willo-diirm he ilfecsli f the
*Wet Chenislry Conirol - BER. Warn Chle-lstry Cortrcl - Ateiliary ystisns and the Walee Cl-snitry Cortrd - Closled Cooling Wer progrsre TN. Item i.ctoeed s, Itre 372.
434 Cloeed (T322-P-04]
Table 322. qieion 4 If Is mt den If the System WVelklen Progean provkdes In Irnsection Ilerir stlacts dc nion alea oonpoierts ipred to Indor r Irm LOM Fees, prode doetils sihring Ispection of irntior surfacees or Ins odmponrt.
435 Closed (T222-P-MJ Tale 322. ptelion 5 heMrn bers 322-4. 322-5i. al 332-14-16
-eelsirtes sled piping oironorts (eg onficee, dreairoe). Please etplain wly Note Cwas assigned tI ftse coipoeres PFvirlch, Wayne Frc
'.ge, The Sijreln Whetilorre Progean Is tnot tile le, tnlreet Iteriom riOng ard crewl1 s9ein-u.es hey hse been exposed SW Irepeclion Wuing nire-eren.e and repairs As tnrcoled l the lias. In Sectlion 3d hfe LRA, he Syslan Walkdomn Fingrr manages agng lft exteal surfnactes df orwews-a.
The progran alsoesrregee lossed erial frorn lr rW swine. Insiuilion. In wNch Irleel met e ral rtenalse ridl e edrwnrir-mrl cor*rGretion we the sans euch S elere swurfaoe eonditi Is reteertativ a d iner surface coreslime ThI. enoi*
piping compres Inltables 332-A. 322-5. and 332-14-16. Itwhih Nde C'ws ehig-s hMoe itele ahte eariro-ent. Thi eysere represented by fhte tables ao all ESF systere. hrweer. NUREO-1801 does rat irclude the contirelion d etandse sol In slen encirorvneet foranry ESF conTynse (Chapem V). Corerienly, coprisni w
trensde loest-e srd powe conesion iyslemrs conrr s (Chree %III) whre lhe stainless selslsea cornitrt ion Is addeestd Sis the eystens dot' nmtclh a Note wC'Is aNlied Painich W"yn.
Ungertdler, PaW 44d 77
 
RAIslInput SE Input Item Lead Project Type Due Date Due Date Due Date Status/Comments One time Relief Request from ASME Complete q
Section XI Code Requirments S. Samaddar LA - Watts Bar 5/31/06 Complete One Time Extension of Contaiment I:A is going to clarfe Integrated Leakage Rate Interval H. Ashar LA - Prairie Island due date.
H. Ashar/
Complete e
I B ikais
-1 Five Year CILRT Extension R.Jackson LA - Watts Bar 4/15/06
' ackae
**e Amendment Re: Contingent Installation I %
9 of Temp. Spent Fuel Rack S. Samaddar LA - Monticello 8/1/06 l
On Tracl; ;
NOAA MOU Y. Li ASAP Pe it.
Complete DG-1 145 Sections C.I.3.7-C.I.3.13 T. Cheng Draft Guide 5/30/06 Complete
* R. Jackson/
Primary Containment LRT Program H. Ashar LA - La Salle Working Progress Complet&#xfd; Secretary has the T s u n a m i Y. L i 5 /9 / 0 6 K
'It__
_ _c_ _.
Update SRP Section 2.4.1, 2.4.2, i
ithke 2.4.3, 2.4.4, 2.4.5, 2.4.6, 2.4.7, 2.4.8, t
due 2.4.9, 2.4.10,2.4.11, 2.4.12,2.4.13, & S. Samaddar/
Update Section 2.4z-jg is a.ir.
"ttea a
2.4.14 G. Bagchi New Reactor
?
0 g
Using Fiber-Reinforced Polymer (FRP)
System to Strengthen Concrete J. Ma / R.
Masonry Walls Jackson LA-Oconee 11_
I nT 1-_t.
Update - SRP Section 3.8.1, 3.8.2, Update Section 3.8 -
3.8.3, 3.8.4, & 3.8.5 D. Jeng New Reactor 1/30/07 0
8 H
11 Bor Update Section 3.5.1.3 -
3 G'
w a'p" SRP Section 3.5.1.3 Turbine Missiles J. Ma New Reactor concurrence only M. Valentin-Tornado Design Basis Olmeda LA - Fermi 2 11/1/06 9/15/06 12/15/06 Working Progre!E 3-CID 10 0c CD CL 0
I CI I-a.
 
EGCB Branch Assignments C-CD (n
0 cI~
0 cI~
EGCB Branch Assignments                                                                                          :ij CD RAIs Input       SE Inputc                                 0    *0 0
:ij CD
Item                     Lead           Project Type     Due Date Due Date         Due Date           Status/Comnlerits 5.
*0 0
License Renewal (LR) -                         *fjI.                       qa,        j Scoping and Screening: Structures   D. Jeng       Pilgrim                           9/1/06 K       'Iqf k             Wor~p~g;,Ss                   CD Structures & Component Supports                                                               .r..
5.
AMRs & AMPs associated w/Drywell                                                                                                                       0 f!8,               'I                     *0.
CD 0
Shell                               D. Jeng~       LR - Pilgrim                     9/2/06111 S4I   &#xfd;1/0                 o*       66r             0 0
*0.
License Amendment                             5:1 a FL   z                                       -o South Texas ILRT Extension           Z. Cruz-Perez (LA) - South Texas               Coplt/06                           OnI   T-       .
00
Complete      'N/W.
-o RAIs Input SE Inputc 0
Vermont Yankee Safety Review         J. Ma         LR - Vt. Yankee                   6/29/06 gell                 6     Wor06,Hgress Vermont Yankee Safety Review         J. Ma         LR- Vt. Yankee                     9/1/06                   06       W6ress D.C. Cook - ASME Code                                                               Complete       'Co     plete Re.Containment Inspection           Z. Cruz-Perez LA - D.C. Cook                   2/22/06         M/2, 00i*{     .      - WO-_         .5I CEUS Ground Motion Project Final                                                                   *,a:a         0. 1   H -. t Report (EPRO 1009684)               C. Munson     NEI Interactions                 9/15/06                   (                i.=-;-
Item Lead Project Type Due Date Due Date Due Date Status/Comnlerits License Renewal (LR) -
Scoping and Screening: Structures   J. Ma         LR- Oyster Creek                                           -o       _"t________              _..
qa,
Torus- TLAA                         H. Ashar       LR -Oyster Creek                                       AN                             ,
*fjI.
Containment Tendon Surveillance     S. Samaddar   LA - Farley                                                     a&     -ft     N Structures & Component Supports                                                                             i-                               'a AMRs & AMPs associated w/Drywell                                                                             iei  e,                 -
j Scoping and Screening: Structures D. Jeng Pilgrim 9/1/06 K  
Shell                               J. Ma           LR - Oyster Creek                                   .9/31;06         CoAef('-
'Iqf k Wor~p~g;,Ss Structures & Component Supports  
Complete .
.r..
Rebar Corrosion TLAA                 H. Ashar       LR - Oyster Creek                                   6/20/06         Coilete Complete                       T Containment Tendon Surveillance     T. Terry       LA- Vogtle                       5/30/06         10/30/06         On Track Emergency Cooling Pond and                                                                                             i Inventory Requirement               S. Samaddar   LA - Arkansas                                                           orking ProgresA Z Integrated Leak Rate Testing (ILRT)                                                 Complete                               Ais going to change Interval Extension                 IH. Ashar     INEI Interactions                   5/1/06                               ie date.
AMRs & AMPs associated w/Drywell f!8,  
'I Shell D. Jeng~
LR - Pilgrim 9/2/06111 S4I &#xfd;1/0 o*
66r License Amendment 5:1 a FL z
South Texas ILRT Extension Z. Cruz-Perez (LA) - South Texas Coplt/06 OnI T-Complete
'N/W.
Vermont Yankee Safety Review J. Ma LR - Vt. Yankee 6/29/06 gell 6
Wor06,Hgress Vermont Yankee Safety Review J. Ma LR-Vt. Yankee 9/1/06 06 W6ress D.C. Cook - ASME Code Complete  
'Co plete Re.Containment Inspection Z. Cruz-Perez LA - D.C. Cook 2/22/06 M/2, 00i*{  
-WO-_  
.5I CEUS Ground Motion Project Final  
*,a:a
: 0. 1 H t Report (EPRO 1009684)
C. Munson NEI Interactions 9/15/06 i.=-;
(
Scoping and Screening: Structures J. Ma LR-Oyster Creek  
-o
_"t ________
Torus-TLAA H. Ashar LR -Oyster Creek AN Containment Tendon Surveillance S. Samaddar LA - Farley a& -ft N
Structures & Component Supports i-  
' a AMRs & AMPs associated w/Drywell e,
iei Shell J. Ma LR - Oyster Creek  
.9/31;06 CoAef(' -
Complete.
Rebar Corrosion TLAA H. Ashar LR - Oyster Creek 6/20/06 Coilete Complete T
Containment Tendon Surveillance T. Terry LA-Vogtle 5/30/06 10/30/06 On Track Emergency Cooling Pond and Inventory Requirement i
S. Samaddar LA - Arkansas Integrated Leak Rate Testing (ILRT)
Complete Interval Extension I H. Ashar INEI Interactions 5/1/06 orking ProgresA Z A is going to change ie date.


James Davis 7 AMR - Repo0rt t the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                 Page 47]
James Davis 7 AMR - Repo0rt t the NRC.doc.pdf Page 47]
Number Status Request                                                         Rewonnse                                                              NRC            PAPS Lead 441 Closed U2I21-3-P-01J                                                   Sinee f Oe-Time Inspection (OTI) Progpar 1. applicable to ech        Pavirch, Wayre  Feotnber waterc fir      control propameiIIs also applioale to aeh line Table 321-3 ,       -S,-6. -9. -10. -15. 16 -18, qoalan 2 Ile hat credte a water chierfry acool progren LRATatla 32.1 incel.es thP fl O&#xfd;r-Tle Inspection Prograni is credted Tih.. lire rtbs         wecify Oru-Tkhnspeaflactre lov           log cwkhtfe naerchamislry      cosed prograne or linsiterns lor with aothir prograe such Water Cl-rnati or Lublca-irq           wich GALL wneco smr      l a one-irm Irupecton tocrconwrmwater oil An*sysi. Howee. Table 322 canuorts t                       cheistry coatrd. Table 2credits ft OTI prograe fUlou aereWprd loti.e Tal.e II Ir firs ii-             specify neu   rderence sothe associated Table I line Item.
Number Status Request 441 Closed U2I21-3-P-01J Table 321-3,  
live Inspectron lodetect ossd nfaiertal. Pleas heeqe corpora linei&fs 10il"'"eo          One-Ti. Inspection or       Dourg th perfornurco dfroisne neirlennce onorprws VW provide flu basiis [or clfng OTL                                  otlain tkicaing oil, visud Inrspecltonsdh fme's.orewsn woUd dkledy deadid codtio' tel eouldbetbribied loan reflective Oil Avnfyeie Progr*,t The correctiveaction Iprian eI PNPS wa fow Whaelhd or Ifsklttficalion of deeaded f ehfaecroe or cracking oforpor*ri Mrdlis -hl                                          wodd be Ideruified as - ofdn proarr Th. reciew d OWdire epieece d PNPS or Its last Wieyars dSdrd Idelify any contion reports 01 indicared an Irlectiv rio arenysis progane or hat Idertlied doeaded conponerI condoionseuch a* corroeion or cracfdnigIn V luiiirig oil enlf rn-e, Th. reew dldpeing aperimete PNPS rev In I[-a ol         a     -Un- Irspection to provide oorilrn-tion dlte etfectiveess df the Oil Arslysia Program TN. repira anarerutr u         othe chornsatry progpa description In LRAApedee Aard Bto clearly idicate hat the Or'sTirne Inspection Progare willoo*firm fts olfictis-sos dothe War Cleristry Cotrol - BliP. itw       Chernistry Cantroe - Amiliary Satenr aed Pt Waler Chfrnitey Cortrol - Closed Cooling Vts progan'su Th. ieff 1. claed tootean 372 Duing the pa*l ive pans. nwr vcsual Inrpectiore d coaporrers
-S,-6. -9. -10. -15. 16 -18, qoalan 2 Tih.. lire rtbs wecify Oru-Tkhnspeaflactre lov with aothir prograe such Water Cl-rnati or Lublca-irq oil An*sysi. Howee. Table 322 canuorts t
                                                                                              .ortalnieg lUrticating cit hve been pefrned dring corrective eed prestos nruarerane aecvitia. The vist inrpecto'sd           oPthese
aereWprd loti.e Tal.e II firs Ir ii-specify neu live Inspectron lodetect ossd nfaiertal. Pleas heeqe corpora linei&fs o 10il"'"e One-Ti.
                                                                                                    .aowoul     Idetrify do ledl cornditions uch woa scarion d
Inspection or provide flu basiis [or clfng OTL Rewonnse Sinee f Oe-Time Inspection (OTI) Progpar 1. applicable to ech waterc fir control propamei IIs also applioale to aeh line Ile hat credte a water chierfry acool progren LRATatla 32.1 incel.es thP fl O&#xfd;r-Tle Inspection Prograni is credted log cwkhtfe naerchamislry cosed prograne or linsiterns lor wich GALL wneco smr l a one-irm Irupecton tocrconwrm water cheistry coatrd. Table 2credits ft OTI prograe fUlou rderence sothe associated Table I line Item.
or cracking PSWruid bel'ribted loan Infectlive OfilAreysia Paoem       PNPS hfas arc fIrafa:l loh the Idonaktttioir od dopaded aordtios euch Ph cOrrosionor cracking d oorrpoawas souldbe NIerlitie adantered Intothe corrective action progparn No carciom reports PS Idorl ied deaced conporunl coduli'ns, etch ascorrosion or cracking ine lUbicaling oil eeirorvr         were IrNliatedasa reslt doPe inspections These past Inspections aNPS   FeraIn     lie*dars-In. Irepelon o prmoide cafirnfion dh. dteciive'ssolte Oil Arnaysis Progran Ths [ternIa closed go Iem 376 Pby 47d 77
Dourg th perfornurco dfroisne neirlennce onorprws VW otlain tkicaing oil, visud Inrspecltons dh fme  
's.orewsn woUd dkledy deadid codtio' tel eould betbribied loan reflective Oil Avnfyeie Progr*,t The corrective action Iprian eI PNPS w a fow Whaelhd or Ifs klttficalion of deeaded Mrdlis -hl f ehf aecroe or cracking oforpor*ri wodd be Ideruified as -
of dn proarr Th. reciew d OWdire epieece d PNPS or Its last Wie yars dSd rd Idelify any contion reports 01 indicared an I rlectiv rio arenysis progane or hat Idertlied doeaded conponer I condoions euch a* corroeion or cracfdnig In V luiiirig oil enlf rn-e, Th. reew d ldpeing aperimete PNPS rev In I[-a ol a  
-Un-Irspection to provide oorilrn-tion dl te etfectiveess df the Oil Arslysia Program TN. repira anarerutr u othe chornsatry progpa description In LRA Apedee Aard Bto clearly idicate hat the Or'sTirne Inspection Progare willoo*firm fts olfictis-sos do the War Cleristry Cotrol - BliP. itw Chernistry Cantroe - Amiliary Satenr aed Pt Waler Chfrnitey Cortrol - Closed Cooling Vts progan'su Th. ieff 1. claed to otean 372 Duing the pa*l ive pans. nwr vcsual Inrpectiore d coaporrers
.ortalnieg lUrticating cit hve been pefrned dring corrective eed prestos nruarerane aecvitia. The vist inrpecto'sd oPthese
.aowoul d Idetrify do ledl cornditions uch woa scarion or cracking PSW ruid bel'ribted loan Infectlive OfilAreysia Paoem PNPS hfas arc fIrafa:l loh the Idonaktttioir od dopaded aordtios euch Ph cOrrosion or cracking d oorrpoawas sould be NIerlitie ad antered Into the corrective action progparn No carciom reports PS Idorl ied deaced conporunl coduli'ns, etch ascorrosion or cracking ine lUbicaling oil eeirorvr were IrNliated asa reslt do Pe inspections These past Inspections aNPS FeraIn lie* dars-In. Irepelon o prmoide cafirnfion dh. dteciive'ssolte Oil Arnaysis Progran Ths [tern Ia closed go Iem 376 NRC PAPS Lead Pavirch, Wayre Feotnber Pby 47d 77


James Davis - AMR -,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                   Page 48 i Number Status Request                                                     Resonse                                                              NRC            PNPS Lead 442 Closad   [T321-35-P-01]                                                                                                                   Ptwirdc, Wayre  Ivy. Ted Iern 212.35 pecitis to Periodc S-ittanceand Preventive Tale 32l-35A quetion 3                                      tore-ewe (PS1P" Proarn Intetad afO AV0. Opon-Cyclo Coning Waer Systse Prog'an, bscaroe teo erwironinet Ihdioted The GALL o*paitia Il 1)0 , Open Cycle Coling ter              as rawwater intlables 22-6 mrd322-7 is Used hoiderfity wate Syster, Prrogng and PNfPScreats theplart speciti          Wtch hiuntreeted bul I nad pert f to raw coding water osyeln Penodo Survaillnc and Prweeertive Martnanwe                  Theedfore toheprevetive actinre Irovn GL89-13 toat we derthbed In Progra'nt    AJOnh te plant specific prong'a prineS. for      NUREG-1801 XM20 dorot       apply. The rerring preiewins action visu ardor UT impection asin XI.M,        cldosenot provide  specified In lX 20 Is rlo =etally anongong AlP errert, faolii for prertive aloene Provide Mu-titoaticawon lot M ading      the deslg acoraeltation t oaaons            oe eo-otrcW ot aropriate mr-imdals. The site correrive action prioger pronldae re ablte assrarce tO Bfappropriate            trita were ad proitded in to riginal ocnponrni dnig%anerrerling proterne would be saluted arl appropriate oniraclmn actions woald betaken ho ob~es tooe protlte.
James Davis - AMR -, Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 48 i Number Status Request 442 Closad
443  Closed  [Geweal-P-01]                                                A Bolting Inleapity Frograt will be dweopedl Ot will ddoressthe      Psoinide,Wa tn    Frrberger.
[T321-35-P-01]
agirg osuganwit ol .ting Infto so" oflicen. renewal.
Tale 32l-35A quetion 3 The GALL o*paitia Il 1)0, Open Cycle Coling ter Syster, Prrogng and PNfPS creats the plart speciti Penodo Survaillnc and Prweeertive Martnanwe Progra'nt AJOnh te plant specific prong'a prineS. for visu ardor UT impection asin XI.M, cldose not provide for prertive aloene Provide Mu-titoaticawon lot M ading 443 Closed
In gaeal, Systeir %tkdown Iscrdited for manang LCM for bolting Howevr, oter aging daectamny beactive Ior        The Bolitg Ingr aity Progras will be inplarnenlw prior itot pril bolting amd System Walkdown does rM provide for proenraiye    d sede       operi*ain ionaeordance with oryrilrent nattier 32 oiT    . Agj Ei ats fIortbati*rgshtdber        gel wider to tmbrultaot a Beting integ'ity Programn inaccordan-e      Thsis     rawarowerirt Srofto LRAhoinclualt descriptions d withtOAu. prorant    vmitS                                  to Boling Iblagrity Progra'n.tryperdoea Awd Bad loiartily werefot proer.r Isapplcale THo itm. tldosed hiIte- 373 444  Claw    [o-al-P-Mi                                                  Trotugh rnito*ing of air quaily. the Ire1rurnnr Atr Ousliry Prograrn Pavnirct VW"yr Nichels. Bill nirrleairn Irotrarwnt air fret     gsligroficarl orntarnwrta ind walte, Cown.o s Intoe ST oystemto      ft we sypoeed to            toraeby prewling loss o retrial. Th. approach homerwgng
[Geweal-P-01]
                                  .urs a sir weomwagW with to Itplar-peciio                  lose atroter-la . non. oWNathanie ekW*       age onitoring wd knlruM e Air  *lOity ProFg' (PNPS AMP 8.1.17). TNh          repelttlve Irspe-ion be *rarosore. Perrnmrco sulmorinig Lrnder prosa. anly rnritors to* oro    awly. However, "t GALL      toe shreranco rniaa&*sae* active.owonart tOWwail be Copressed Air tailoring Progran. XI.14. @Bllorely            Irclulod Inperforn-woce testing. No aotilord agng allecl were requires tlsting be shag. rateo. Impection fororrosior%      idertitiel whose owegarnat requirrd Brae other attribes of toe amd perforrr e laeing cororo*nte. t          proerar(s)      Congossed         rtrMlloririg Propgam MA124. Recent Ine-rnal pronite $or hese ackitiorol rertoworeas? NIfte              Inspections d toe air receiver lors ld rntslrechecks f tohe adiutiorol regire~el of XI.M 4 ore ad covered by araher      instnrmn air oys.err hme aoddet-ted signific.eart ororon or prepmar please pronide Jatiaioation for not lWding Br        rniste. In the oytsernThiee past Irpectore at PNPS am. In Ttu oornrvtw Isapplicable to ft IA ysle. aswell.            lieuao one.doe Irnpection hoproide oortirrnwtion atft aetiveve os lthe Iretrnarit Ar C*atly prlo*o. inrmrrwng aging olecto altoorponens aspao.ed hiimrtrrs           air withxl to aciticn. prepare atrihule recorrmerdW by GALL XIW4 P4w8d 77
In gaeal, Systeir %tkdown Is crdited for manang LCM for bolting Howevr, oter aging daecta mny beactive Ior bolting amd System Walkdown does rM provide for proenraiye oiT
. Agj Ei ts a
fIortbati*rg shtdber gel wider to tmbrulta ot a Beting integ'ity Programn inaccordan-e withtOAu. prorant vmitS 444 Claw
[o-al-P-Mi Cown.o s Intoe ST oystemto ft we sypoeed to
.urs a sir weomwagW with to Itplar-peciio knlruM e Air
*lOity ProFg' (PNPS AMP 8.1.17). TNh prosa. anly rnritors to* or o
awly. However, "t GALL Copressed Air tailoring Progran. XI.14. @Bllorely requires tlsting be shag. rateo. Impection fororrosior%
amd perforrr e laeing cororo*nte.
t proerar(s) pronite $or hese ackitiorol rertoworeas?
NI fte adiutiorol regire~el of XI.M 4 ore ad covered by araher prepmar please pronide Jatiaioation for not lWding Br Ttu oornrvtw Isapplicable to ft IA ysle.
aswell.
Resonse Iern 212.35 pecitis to Periodc S-ittanceand Preventive tore-ewe (PS1P" Proarn Intetad afO AV0. Opon-Cyclo Coning Waer Systse Prog'an, bscaroe teo erwironinet Ihdioted as raw water intlables 22-6 mrd 322-7 is Used hoi derfity wate Wtch hi untreeted bul I nad pert f to raw coding water osyeln Theedfore tohe prevetive actinre Irovn GL89-13 toat we derthbed In NUREG-1801 XM20 dorot apply. The rerring preiewins action specified In lX 20 Is rlo =et ally anongong AlP errert, faoli i the deslg acoraeltation t o aaons oe eo-otrcW ot aropriate mr-imdals. The site correrive action prioger pronldae re ablte assrarce tO Bf appropriate trita were ad proitded in to riginal ocnponrni dnig% aner rerling proterne would be saluted arl appropriate oniraclmn actions woald betaken ho ob~es tooe protlte.
A Bolting Inleapity Frograt will be dweopedl Ot will ddoress the agirg osuganwit ol.ting Infto so" oflicen.
renewal.
The Bolitg Ingr aity Progras will be inplarnenlw prior ito t pril d sede operi*ain ionaeordance with oryrilrent nattier 32 Thsis rawarowerirt Srofto LRAhoinclualt descriptions d to Boling Iblagrity Progra'n. tryperdoea Awd Bad loiartily werefot proer.r Is applcale THo itm. tl dosed hi Ite-373 Trotugh rnito*ing of air quaily. the Ire1rurnnr At r Ousliry Prograrn nirrleairn Irotrarwnt air fret gsligroficarl orntarnwrta ind walte, toraeby prewling loss o retrial. Th. approach ho merwgng los e atroter-la. non. oWNathanie ekW*
age onitoring wd repelttlve Irspe-ion be *rarosore. Perrnmrco sulmorinig Lrnder toe shreranco rniaa&*sae* active.owonart tOW wail be Irclulod Inperforn-woce testing. No aotilord agng allecl were idertitiel whose owegarnat requirrd Brae other attribes of toe Congossed rtrMlloririg Propgam MA124. Recent Ine-rnal Inspections d toe air receiver lors ld rntslre checks f tohe instnrmn air oys.err hme aod det-ted signific.eart ororon or rniste. In the oytsern Thiee past Irpectore at PNPS am. In lieuao one.doe Irnpection hoproide oortirrnwtion atf t aetiveve os lthe Iretrnarit Ar C*atly prlo*o. inrmrrwng aging olecto altoorponens aspao.ed hiimrtrrs air withxl to aciticn. prepare atrihule recorrmerdW by GALL XIW4 NRC PNPS Lead Ptwirdc, Wayre Ivy. Ted Psoinide, Wa tn Frrberger.
Pavnirct VW"yr Nichels. Bill P4w8d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                       ...                                    .. .. Page49_
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf  
Number Status Request                                                   Response                                                           NRC             PNPS Lead 445 Closed   P31.1-J-01)                                               Th.actui wa.irovrsowtn l              flor   n#eoopocs ate ai .ee-ain/y     Jackson, Wibur   Firnnir Ron te sane regardens d i. listed lerpaturen     The enviroews Sone off hensMa redrlW o Ilon 3.1.1-2 are described       s*pnclyingthe two lempeatur. raengs Irdicate     iWthe eyslear InnLRATatbe112-1 aslInenvelrmnwrl ofTreeted Water         lerpenaue Istabove Ithe trehs d value that can ressllincrecking S322 dog Fand ear.o ae descrlbed as In TreatedWaer W   cue lofaigue for the specific oaponereatnerial. TheInorerul 270 deg F.                                               faigue throsid for eti*rtee sl is 2701F ard lor carbwonsend, 227F as stted Inthe EWRIlMochw"il Tools (EPRIReport FPnnsojustify Whe use oe two lmperature rangee to describe 1C056).
.. Page49_
We ifuirw"",foot We conponers L roIl upto Iten 3.1.1-2 46 Ckoed   (3?. -J-O                                                 Drarwirngsware wraiteabe or NRC rwiew durir fe eta visit         Jacksoni Witslb   Cten, we rI-careHwinrge; Nozles -Hal Seal Lit-fl (Nit NI3).
Number Status Request  
447 Closed   (.I.-J-0M                                                 The license renewal function of those   a rte (prenssre         Jackscr   W slbur Firnin, Ron boiunadry) a -ns the odd besween the ID)Stchenet aid Whe InLRA Tiale &12-1. WeCarpae          TypeIDAttachrani   vewsen Becaute.so       arpormre aredrectly afached o.the ooe Wads (wors sray. drywr hoIddown pads, edc) we Inslicaled   preesure botrday, they were
 
* given an ireende aonifVvdy as haing WheIrtenlerd bunctionat prnsure bourndal.         tlrction d preeesureb ldery. This a.weonsisteol with We**mdinnmr dvresd lOatthm*l   o   dwdsInNUREG-A80I Soction- IVAI-12 Pleese ju(ify Wethese aorpoawts provide apressure               XI oMAU 448 Closed   31.t-J-0                                                 These attachnenw widc *arot specificy listed In te reaclor       Jackscr, Wlbur   Firnd; Ran veedselstrs respot h       rwv, ey e boundonby  the faruts d tha LRA Tbe.te3.2-f.2-r1icae OWet   forWIDAltasc* t Widc. reow Any veneed stres repev dcnepW ASMIESectio fit oonresir the eging delet c Ctracking-lal IgLWIs nweged by a TLAA   CUFi orty [or those Ioediona We1the desiger fit could be fatige liniting While only fO liuniting ssaresaectuly calcUciew4 tstd eisei e n*towsthl entire veesel Ple.ediscuss whether those achprbonl           explicitly addre sed Inthe TL/A afbtie        by the resite     e   A copy c the vessel Ctressrepod (Cortuation Enrineering TLAA. &.e the nseciticTLAA      *t*e n*gs he aging       CENC-1139) w- prodc lothe Inspeco.
===Response===
NRC PNPS Lead 445 Closed P31.1-J-01)
Th.actui l wa.irovrsowtn flor n#eoopocs ate ai.ee-ain/y Jackson, Wibur Firnnir Ron te sane regardens d i.
listed lerpaturen The enviroews Sone off hens Ma redrl W o Ilon 3.1.1-2 are described s*pnclying the two lempeatur.
raengs Irdicate iW the eyslear InnLRATatbe112-1 aslInenvelrmnwrl ofTreeted Water lerpenaue Istabove Ithe trehs d value that can ressllincrecking S322 dog Fand ear.o ae descrlbed as In TreatedWaer W
cue lofaigue for the specific oaponereat nerial.
TheInorerul 270 deg F.
faigue throsid for eti*rtee sl is 2701F ard lor carbwon send, 227F as stted Inthe EWRIlMochw"il Tools (EPRIReport FPnnso justify Whe use oe two lmperature rangee to describe 1C056).
We ifuirw"",fo ot We conponers L roIl upto Iten 3.1.1-2 46 Ckoed (3 ?. -J-O Drarwirngs ware wraiteabe or NRC rwiew durir fe eta visit Jacksoni Witslb Cten, we rI-care Hwinrge; Nozles -Hal Seal Lit-fl (Nit NI3).
447 Closed
(.I.-J-0M The license renewal function of those a
rte (prenssre Jackscr W slbur Firnin, Ron boiunadry) a  
-ns the odd besween the ID) Stchenet aid Whe InLRA Tiale &12-1. We Carpae TypeIDAttachrani vewsen Becaute.so ooe arpormre aredrectly afached o.the Wads (wors sray. drywr hoId down pads, edc) we Inslicaled preesure botrday, they were
* aonifVvdy given an ireende as haing Whe Irtenlerd bunction at prnsure bourndal.
tlrction d preeesur eb ldery. This a.weonsisteol with We **mdinnmr dv resd lOatthm*l o
dwdsI nNUREG-A80I Soction-IVAI-12 Pleese ju(ify Wethese aorpoawts provide apressure XI oMAU 448 Closed 31.t-J-0 These attachnenw widc *a rot specificy listed In te reaclor Jackscr, Wlbur Firnd; Ran veedsel strs respot h rwv, ey e boundon by the faruts d tha LRA Tbe.te3.2-f.2-r1icae OWet forW ID Altasc* t Widc.
reow Any veneed stres repev dcnepW ASMIE Sectio fit oonresir the eging delet c Ctracking-lal IgLW Is nweged by a TLAA CUFi orty [or those Ioediona We1 the desiger fit could be fatige liniting While only fO liuniting ssares aectuly calcUciew4 tstd eisei e n*t owsthl entire veesel Ple.ediscuss whether those achprbonl explicitly addre sed Inthe TL/A af btie by the resite e
A copy c the vessel Ctress repod (Cortuation Enrineering TLAA. &.e the nsecitic TLAA
*t*e n*gs he aging CENC-1139) w-prodc lothe Inspeco.
effects CrCracking-tal igL in tine cnrTo*er?
effects CrCracking-tal igL in tine cnrTo*er?
PaW 49d 77
PaW 49d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                           Page 50!1 Number Status Request                                                   Respontse                                                         NRC            PNPS Lead Asa*Wnified Int. dacusioan Ornn earyot Table 31.1 ent 13           Jacksont, Wlbr  Flnenl, Ro (31.1-13), VWaerChemistry Contrd -BWRis augn-ared byh.
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 50!1 Number Status Request In LRAT&abl 112-3, carlon clad pipin and Piint~gs valves Ina trestad w~gaets'irwrnasi we shown as hainitg tealing 417. ole los of. mfeial. Th. Sor
In LRAT&abl 112-3, carlon clad pipin and Piint~gs        Or.Timn Inspeclion Progrnt loassu.e *alt-ehea       dtlhe water valves Ina trestad w~gaets'irwrnasi we shown as hainitg  ehadry progwn ThN Isitr whiweven tie water chenstry tealing 417. olelos of. mfeial. Th. Sor -a.,gne-A        prograi is radlied The Water C*rninsy Cntrld - BWR and progarent eetw          by cn~tnayodncl GALL.bllne te    Or.Tim Inspciati Proegna, by theladves, sasty the Volsc 1. Tabe. Ihern 13. IsWater Charrstryd              NUREG-Ie1 re. -          sonlaeliOs.
-a.,gne-A progarent eetw by cn~tnayodncl GALL. bllne te Volsc 1. Tabe. Ihern 13. Is Water Charrstryd C-Ti-ns.kpetonie.
Th. ISI PrograntI sPensa       ihe C-Ti- ns.kpetonie.                                        Water Chniatlry and One Timn Ihspedien FProg., bWilnot ricessary Ioatisty bth NUREG-1801 ,aeoncrswvtions. Sire.Ie Fot piping and fittng and valves with diaetera -. C NMS  Wat.e Cheraistry Cacrrd -BW8 ard Cia-Timn hrstien ro-aong thea gini nagagrenw pog'a Is shoewn a-Water                aroonmsterl with Ith NUREG"IEoprogen.,aNdNe "weC"ls CharniatryCor*CI - BM"1 ard bkavniic hmapenior In LRA    appropiate Sbre Ite ony viable onomtlonfolr these ppng and Tad*.312-3 I ppig wd littings ad vave with                                                    osarter cotpotwrs. Nde valve lines Ilsi NV.CI-6for Isolatioens darn~ae -r NPS, We aging Oregonert prog en Is shown        "C" .. l Ibasegd as ba~s Chenistry Control- BM'W InLRA TableS1.2-1 The note asanlgaf- with the line lhentsInIRA Tabl.        Foa onrrpoen     with daettlar . 4- NPS. th atwer Is thelsae 11.2.3 Is NoteC*                                          BothWater Chonds" Corhsd -tBWR       ted O(.Tim Inspectlon Prog-en. "selybotheseeornonas., whichIs consiaten with the oooeraowayion- d NUREG-1801. Since he only viable nasyarisas I aset. piping and valve line Iso/VCI-6 for Fa Oe carboen steed  piping wd fitting ad valves with    latidon ordanenr conlarwts. Nale "C nut beused dedeera~ -r NPS, pleats proide. justificatin that Nd.e C Is ths "ede rotte.b apy rleeSae opnenyasa F"e cahen lad piing and Shyn ard valves with daeraa
Fot piping and fittng and valves with diaetera -. C NMS the a gini nagagrenw pog'a Is shoewn a-Water Charniatry Cor*CI - BM"1 ard bkavniic hmapenior In LRA Tad*.312-3 I
                              . 4* NPS. pl=s. providejustificain tha Not. CIs the rrad da oen oapplylotft      ca.neervasase Also, loeOwea eernpoenwdbPea Proidedjustifctiodinfor rot parleniniia os-albs isayeni astaronsdd by GALL.line lient Vol-1. ITausc l.11- 13.
ppig w d littings ad vave with darn~ae -r NPS, We aging Oregonert prog en Is shown as ba~s Chenistry Control - BM'W In LRA Table S1.2-1 The note asanlgaf-with the line lhents In IRA Tabl.
Fa 50,7
11.2.3 Is NoteC*
Fa Oe carboen steed piping wd fitting ad valves with dedeera~ -r NPS, pleats proide. justificatin that Nd.e C Is ths "ede rotte. b apy r leeSae opnenyasa F"e cahen lad piing and Shyn ard valves with daeraa
. 4* NPS. pl=s. provide justificain tha Not. CIs the rad r
oen da oapply lotft ca.neervasase Also, loe Owea eernpoenwd bPea Proided justifctiodin for rot parleniniia os-albs isayeni astaronsdd by GALL. line lient Vol-1.
ITausc l.11-13.
Respontse Asa*Wnified In t.
dacusioan Ornn earyot Table 31.1 ent 13 (31.1-13), VWaer Chemistry Contrd -BWRis augn-ared byh.
Or.Timn Inspeclion Progrnt loassu.e *alt-ehea dtlhe water ehadry progwn ThN Is itr whiweven tie water chenstry prograi is radlied The Water C*rninsy Cntrld - BWR and Or.Tim Inspciati Proegna, by theladves, sasty the NUREG-Ie1 re.
sonlaeliOs.
Th. ISI PrograntI sPensa ihe Water Chniatlry and One Timn Ihspedien FProg., bWi lnot ricessary Ioatisty bth NUREG-1801,aeoncrswvtions. Sire. Ie Wat.e Cheraistry Cacrrd -BW8 ard Cia-Timn hrstien ro-aong aroo nmsterl with Ith NUREG"IEo progen.,aNdNe "weC"ls appropiate Sbre Ite ony viable onomtlonfo lr these ppng and valve lines Ilsi NV.CI-6 for Isolatioens osarter cotpotwrs. Nde "C".. l Ibasegd Foa onrrpoen with daettlar. 4-NPS. th atwer Is thelsae Both Water Chonds" Corhs d -tBWR ted O(.Tim Inspectlon Prog-en.  
"sely bothese eornonas., whichIs consiaten with the oooeraowayion-d NUREG-1801. Since he only viable nasyarisas I aset.
piping and valve line Iso/VCI-6 for latidon ordanenr conlarwts. Nale "C nut beused NRC PNPS Lead Jacksont, Wlbr Flnenl, Ro Fa 50,7
 
James Davis - AMR -,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf
.. Page 51]
Number Status Request
 
===Response===
450 Closed
[1..t-J-CO]
: 1) As iarepanol InSection B 123 odth IRA oThenaerws d ft rogarr include (a) deemrnimon doto In LRATafle &L12.1, eon.cti Ioirrypon wihaging
&aTde sizeosna roneanseessne-ciTref-iaineld Ii atitio:n diedt sofmedalar c
NM roltt cLo io LRA Talbe I Fir.e liar anticrotmer plare agn effects.
anl cpwlcrin ecierlantc (b) 4.1.1-14 sho, tOw aging taprt Is licprdov be y Wyralor kltdicatlio ol d
iat Inslection keatoionr Inthe sysnim ao Chrneisty Cotrd-BWA and nimtle. InWaedior; clhers of oowgonrl btnad on the ing ael.a (c) de-raration oi to
: 5. congponerns withaging Sffeet -Lofn WMarier tlat rol iaarinuon teohnique incluldrg eco*eilo-a crilaril tat rwoud be W tIo LRA Tabe I line it-r 41.1-14 nho ft! aging SllecveiIn nansrlilg to egng Sffect tor wrichrte cororerl Is nragncwi8 provided by Waler Chrarisnry Contdro -
Warainert and (d) evalation f the oeed for Idlow-up eartrinaiora BWi.
Tim -nrespondling line iotn InGALL -Une 14 in to ""rftor te progression o any asin degademiron Volo e 1, Tabie 1-dshmws fto Ang I gaorert In aofitklc gA*aen of NUREG-1801 Ifor MAW and XMA willibe Proram a "Water ChoinsW and "Or-Tiena Inpseti" wed to wect serve poires IRA Nol. I1.22 ragraph 3, Indicaes tot OC-Time Ispection dcreeperenlatl eoarnies willbet sed loo-dirm
: 2) They will beinluedod Inthe popodalion from whch te o arnles th effectvernass On hWer Cherrstry Cotrol prgan ane selected tMch specirf ie.ms willbe Irmpeded will be doermined byagting the tguidees hrcm NURE-1801, Section Ckeatiort
)20 I andt A.MI when PNPS ItplasrTn tin prog*an Peassn dec.ss to rieria feo seneftnhe to sarnpe pd*its
: 3) Tihe coerpo-wos &we welded to tO. reacto cooldas preosu-tor the O-Tirm lrnletio-sa botndary. Coreec5uerly, tean contonerts werm coservatively dear arlraoda* k,.tr-i ivg-esa boeroy. Tirrn &.I--
Wil the Tln'rmt Pawwta li roll r to LRATaie I line aWecOridered otject Io agirn r eoomrarsvion in lIart41.1-14 bespecifically Impeated? Or.willt y be NUREG-1801 liar IVAI-7.
Ileluded In tho popation Iram whNch owrponents we edecld o on-tim In.lecaion, Ii rot specifically Pleense desrie hr w tam he t
ro inedlot provide the Irteaded tc-ion d Proresse Bo-do
*y Does Wpreesnrn bo-rdtoy -in" caed - amrn RPVpresnur-torobry.
451 Closed Ia31.1-J-"
The ddectors Indicaeld as 6stielo" (CRD)waw detectors for preno-a and leae Inthe **rnm eccurnelalor-,
Pelse clarity lto tnction dfto cornparo InTabln 11.2-3 Idaksfied on*D ectcr (CRD)? Is IN. the rod poston Irndioator onsnatly.
aonrswattng nine?
452 Cloned 13,1.t-J-CB A copwl dWFIP-139 wosnproided Ioft Irmpacor, Plesse nake avalable during the sto vnsit a c-py ofth SWRVIP recomnrodaions reamed tos*sng warrgetmn d the sletn drye.
NRC PNPS Lead Jackuonr Wits, Firrirn Ron Jack-eoc WItr Fithn, Ron Jackson. Wlits,
: Cha, Wai FP. 5O1d 77
 
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 52 I Number Status Request 453 Mcceplal f33. 14-M0 The GALLs recommended ang traragora5 pro Sm l
the sltem yw Is 'Aplar5-speciic.g, P.w program islobeevsuelad hI Table 3.12-2 the Aging Iv sw Program Iandtifled for ft sin, dryer is 'BM Vessed hlemeu$ and Ndte TEl.apsled PleMs. slin why Note E (rather then Ndte A) i. applied Sor the line ier The lud sion of dNodes on LRA pages 30-4 and 30-5 sitmes that 1le&ler designl fom we standard Maes bs0ed on Apperdx F dN NEI 95-10 (RMdaaan 30-3).&deg; The referencs is o HNEt 96-&I, Revision BI Howa.., review of the rdle -
finds Ma Append. F Isa.od lnstiry Guibgase on Revisd 544(a)(2) Syoping Criteriari ad Ndss wse csciased In Tae 42-2 itwel dtch ut Ms..
Fuse
'ral this adnnihirsia e. wem Intl. LRA 454 Closed 111.1-J-l0 GALL be, VIAl-5 Irdicales M penetatioIu r IlSm l*,lc ard Sor the drain lineroll up i
GALL. Viot..
1, Table 1. Itea 40. Th. LRA does nn inrciat Oe pelfalronr form" drain linelad ilor Ow rnorito rolldpSo LRA Table 3.1.1. Baen 4M. Plejse uttify why the drain line pentatiotns and the flux inortor penetrations we ro 4S5 Closed
([l.1-J-1l In LRA Table 312.I th agg dal itcracking Smr CRO Sltb Titus and InCore Howinmi Is dhwn a mrseged by Water Cherdsiry Contrd and SMM Vlsset Interis APS In GALL to asing eilit os*caing lom thees ronaonons is sihown a.s wag*d by Water Cheiistry Contrd ard BW PlMese csss-why PNPS ten IbmLded tIts iory*en In the 6 Vessel Interesl progr raher t in the 6MM Ponsrationm prograrn asrecsw-dod by GALL
 
===Response===
e Td is T
edl rather than Ndoe 'A becase the NRC ard NEI 87.0d hi ". No.e 'Frasti Nun Note 'Awhen GALL sp..r.. a pgnt-speciic 1roganx Ths lId caet s need for te staf ho relv the actwcstalblity ofSnt progran, whie Nose 'A' womd Indicale that w
h sew e ofd te progsn hadl slre, been acsi.ed as dncauled n ithe GALL report Th. apprcpriate rduu-erce mr U. iRA staatd m*rne Is NEI 95-10.
Revision 6, Awpads C ratlher tNn Auperdx F. This rsclUr..
arnwtart ionm LRA Aporlion dIis qjasiin reqtirns dariiicatia Table S12-1 does no Inlue a cornpe lyps spsecficialy mrned -ta mornitm psnststiom" The Immns hol ing s, wihch povide vesse pwslrlons Sm, flu. deaectors. ase te d stlaiess ated ad Sor the aging ellect docrsckig ft pirter p
o Tale al I Is isAwn 40.
The drain nozzle InTable 31.2ol, which presabidy Is the dnrine peaisratin indlcaed Innthe u ator% Is omeyseld ofcarbon sisd, so rdIl4, o Table I1.1 Hann 40. Sm statins adool carourts, woAid be irproprqiale.
ThI.
PNPS 6MM Perstratioia Program is Ectnsstarl with he NUREG-1801 Section XI WB, which aersonly SLCIOP ozle and Irturimn paewrations aa.disc-esn InBWRVIP-2* and BWMVIP-49. PNPS Incldes the CRO slit, bbes and Insrirmusr hoIings Inn 6MM Ves.d Irindl Program -ety asomaled by BWRV1P-47. Lower PlMum whchlsminiLudd InNUREG-1801 program XI.9. TN is sltightly Inoiuislr with NUREG-1801 Setion IV. A PNPS Idl Jt was begeto be cmuistenl with In*
panm In Saotin XI em t one ll. ieans in Setion IV At PNPS, both the 6MR Penetrationu Prog, and the BWR Ves.d blamrss Prngam w. Isrerartaed by the sans plus predure NRC PNPS Lead Jahckm WtIol Finnin, Ros t
Jackom, Wlb Finin, Ron Jacksna WWbr Finn. RoMn Pay R of 77


James Davis - AMR -,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                           ..                                            ..          .        .        .    .      ...            .  .. .. Page 51]
James Davis - AMR -Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 53 ]
Number Status   Request                                                           Response                                                              NRC            PNPS Lead 450  Closed     [1..t-J-CO]                                                      1) As iarepanol InSection B 123 odth IRA                              JackuonrWits,  Firrirn Ron oThenaerwsd ft rogarr include (a) deemrnimon doto In LRATafle &L12.1,eon.cti Ioirrypon              wihaging      &aTde sizeosna roneanseessne- ciTref-iaineld Ii            atitio:n diedt        c sofmedalar          cLo NM rolttio    LRA Talbe I Fir.eliar    anticrotmer plare      agneffects. anl cpwlcrin ecierlantc (b) 4.1.1-14 sho, tOwaging taprt            Is licprdov bey Wyralor kltdicatlio ol d iatInslection keatoionr Inthe sysnim ao Chrneisty Cotrd- BWA and nimtle. InWaedior; clhers of            oowgonrl btnad on the ing ael.a (c) de-raration oito
Number Status Request 456 Closed 1t.1t--121 in LRATaele 3.12-2 ft Conenorot Type Ccrtrd rod guide thebe - kbo" Is In anOraWroremehl d'Treeld water >270 dog-F. *asd to Corponet Type tCortrol rd guide hubl e -
: 5. congponernswithaging Sffeet-Lofn WMarier tlat rol              iaarinuon teohniqueincluldrg eco*eilo-a crilaril tat rwoud        be W tIoLRA Tabe I line it-r 41.1-14 nho ft! aging                SllecveiIn nansrlilg to egng Sffecttor wrichrte cororerl Is nragncwi8 provided by Waler Chrarisnry Contdro -               Warainert and (d) evalation f the oeed    for Idlow-up eartrinaiora BWi. Tim -nrespondling line iotn InGALL -Une 14 in              to ""rftor te progressiono any asin degademiron Volo e 1, Tabie 1-dshmws fto Ang I            gaorert          In aofitklc gA*aen of NUREG-1801 Ifor MAW and XMA willibe Prorama "Water ChoinsW and "Or-Tiena Inpseti"                    wed to wect serve poires IRA Nol. I1.22        ragraph 3, Indicaes tot OC-Time Ispection dcreeperenlatl eoarnies willbet sed loo-dirm          2) They will beinluedod Inthe popodalionfrom whch te    o arnles th effectvernass OnhWer Cherrstry Cotrol prgan                  ane selected tMch specirf ie.mswillbe Irmpeded will be doermined byagting tguidees the          hrcm NURE-1801, Section Ckeatiort                                                        )20 I    andt A.MI when PNPS ItplasrTn tin prog*an Peassndec.ss to rieria feo seneftnhe    to sarnpe pd*its        3) Tihe coerpo-wos &we      welded to tO. reacto cooldas preosu-tor the O-Tirm lrnletio-sa                                      botndary. Coreec5uerly, tean contonerts wermcoservatively dear arlraoda* k,.tr-i        ivg-esa boeroy. Tirrn &.I--
base. Islnanerwironsert d Treeed water >482 de-F'.
Wil the Tln'rmt Pawwta li      roll r to LRATaie I line          aWecOridered otject Io agirn r          eoomrarsvion in lIart41.1-14 bespecifically Impeated? Or.willt y be              NUREG-1801 liar IVAI-7.
Pls.e clarify what Is mee i by Cortrol rod guide kthe -
Ileluded In tho popation Iram whNchowrponentswe edecld o on-tim In.lecaion, Ii rot specifically Pleense desrie hr w tam the ro      inedlot provide the Irteaded tc-ion d Proresse Bo-do          *yDoes Wpreesnrn bo-rdtoy -in"      caed - amrn RPVpresnur- torobry.
bette and splden why t. enrirorwt s. different koo the
451  Closed  Ia31.1-J-"                                                         The ddectors Indicaeld as 6stielo" (CRD)waw detectors for            Jack-eoc WItr    Fithn, Ron preno-a and leae Inthe **rnm eccurnelalor-,
'Cont rod guide le
Pelse clarity lto tnction dfto cornparo InTabln 11.2-3 Idaksfied on*D ectcr (CRD)? IsIN. the rod poston Irndioatoronsnatly. aonrswattngnine?
-tube" 457 Closed
452  Cloned    13,1.t-J-CB                                                                                                                            Jackson. Wlits, Cha,    Wai A copwldWFIP-139 wosnproided Ioft Irmpacor, Plesse nake avalable during the sto vnsit a c-py ofth SWRVIP recomnrodaions reamed tos*sng warrgetmn d the sletn drye.
[3.1.1-J-131 In LRATable 112-3 the arty componaeis Iderlitied as
FP. 5O1d77
=nirho U.
the a tig o*et c.
d Lo erial ids toFAC and Incl Inthe Flow Acodelred C&#xfd;rosion AW ee cartbn sled piping and flirng >- 4' NPS. Th. GALL descriplion of the FAC Aip (XIMt7) dinot ritoll apipicability of this program based on pipe darnter. peise justily why orly he large-dbanoer pdpigin Table 31.2-3 Is ircludod InUTh FAC po'arn Plse. Idetly the piping s.irts that we Included in the FAC progre Ino IRA Table 3 1.2-458 Closed 13.1.1 414 InLRATaleI12-2 Iorccrporeont withaing teol 1ace cf IWeitler thel roll up to IRA Table I hm 3 1.147, U.
NVP Is Ikertifid as nWale CheMsrsy Control BWR."
However, InU. GALL U. aging onect of l.s.
d MAsterial lor these con po.r. "Is noenegod by bth Water Chodilry and Inteovic. Irepecoin (rWB. IC, NVs aWdO. Plesse Juaity why Wtter Cheerrislry Contrcl - BWR with no asoociated Irevpotion hisadelptle Daseree lie aging ffe.l of Loss WIterial or thet. corponerTs


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                  .          ..                        .....                                      Page 52 I Number Status    Request                                                          Response                                                         NRC         PNPS Lead 453  Mcceplal  f33. 14-M0                                                              T is edl ratherthan Ndoe 'A becase the NRC ard NEI e Td                                                          Jahckm WtIol          t Finnin, Ros 87.0d hi ". No.e 'Frasti Nun Note 'Awhen GALLsp..r.. a The GALLs recommended ang traragora5 pro                  l Sm    pgnt-speciic 1roganx Ths lId caets      need for te staf ho the sltem yw Is 'Aplar5-speciic .g, -            P.w            relv the actwcstalblity ofSnt progran, whie Nose 'A' womd programislobeevsuelad          hI Table 3.12-2 the Aging        Indicale w that h sewe ofdte progsn hadlslre,    been acsi.ed as Iv      sw Program Iandtifled for ft sin, dryer is 'BM        dncauled nithe GALLreport Vessed hlemeu$ and Ndte TEl.apsled PleMs. slin why Note E (rather then Ndte A) i. applied Sorthe line  ier      Th. apprcpriate rduu-erce mrU. iRA staatd m*rneIs NEI 95-10.
===Response===
Revision 6, Awpads C ratlher tNn Auperdx F. This rsclUr. .
NRC The CROT base Is located neri the bIlomr oiU guide tube and Jackson, Wibur supports U contro rod whns Ut.rive hi disconnected ard reroed lor srlvce.
Thelud      sion ofdNodes on LRA pages 30-4 and 30-5            arnwtart ionm LRA sitmes that 1le&ler designl fom we standard Maes bs0ed on Apperdx F dNNEI 95-10 (RMdaaan 30-3).&deg; The referencs is o HNEt 96-&I, Revision BI Howa.., review of the rdle -
The contrl rod gude tube Is mode of sasiries sted. It ersironert hI givo as >270 &#xb6;F became U. is U. tlhrehold fIr taligue of Wl*-lrin $leel prteh EPRI Moohanioel Tools
finds Ma Append. F Isa.od lnstiry Guibgase on Revisd 544(a)(2) Syoping Criteriariad Ndss wsecsciased In Tae 42-2 itwel dtch ut              Ms.. 'ral this Fuse adnnihirsia e. wem Intl. LRA 454  Closed    111.1-J-l0                                                      Aporlion dIis qjasiin reqtirns dariiicatia Table S12-1 does      Jackom, Wlb  Finin, Ron no Inlue a cornpe lyps spsecficialymrned -ta mornitm GALL be, VIAl-5 Irdicales M penetatioIu          r IlSm        psnststiom" The Immnshol ings, wihch povide vesse l*,lcard Sorthe drain linerolli up GALL.Viot.. 1,          pwslrlons Sm,flu. deaectors. ase te      d stlaiess ated ad Sor Table 1. Itea 40. Th. LRA does nn inrciat Oe                                                      p the aging ellect docrsckig ft pirter    o Tale al I IsisAwn 40.
((tomo). Th. guide tUe tbe h eadn dcCASS ad corespuotly IMs*aroert was quoted se >482 -
pelfalronr form" drain linelad ilor    Ow rnorito rolldpSo LRA Table 3.1.1. Baen4M. Plejse uttify why the drain line        The drain nozzle InTable 31.2ol, which presabidy Is the dnrine pentatiotns and the flux inortor penetrations we ro              peaisratin indlcaed Innthe u ator%Is omeyseld ofcarbon sisd, so rdIl4, o Table I1.1 Hann40. Smstatins adoolcarourts, woAidbe irproprqiale.
as t Is Ui.
4S5 Closed      ([l.1-J-1l                                                      ThI. PNPS 6MM Perstratioia Program isEctnsstarl with he          Jacksna  WWbr Finn. RoMn NUREG-1801 Section XI WB,which          aersonlySLCIOP ozle and InLRA Table 312.I th agg dal itcracking SmrCRO                  Irturimn paewrations aa.disc-esn InBWRVIP-2* and Sltb Titus and InCore Howinmi Is dhwn a mrseged by                BWMVIP-49. PNPS Incldes the CRO slit,bbes and Insrirmusr Water Cherdsiry Contrd and SMM Vlsset Interis APS                hoIings Inn 6MM Ves.d Irindl Program -ety asomaled In GALL to asing eilit os*caing lomthees            ronaononsis by BWRV1P-47.Lower PlMum whchlsminiLudd InNUREG-1801 sihowna.s wag*d by Water Cheiistry Contrd ard BW                program XI.9. TN is sltightlyInoiuislr with NUREG-1801 Setion IV. A PNPS Idl Jtwas begeto be cmuistenl with In*
threshold lor lwod' oai'riftlearl InCASS. The liting terperolure wase*istedor oach ob nporort Both cofrpora swo the soae l*erpeonlurn Ptnw-eccelersted corroesion (PtC) hi ad expected ht.. belasgilioeri Jackson, With aging insctarewism U.
panmIn Saotin XI em t one ll. ieansin Setion IV At PlMese csss- why PNPS ten IbmLdedtIts              iory*en      PNPS, both the 6MR Penetrationu Prog, and the BWR Ves.d In the6        Vessel Interesl progr    raher t    inthe 6MM    blamrss Prngam w. Isrerartaed by the sans plus predure Ponsrationm prograrnasrecsw-dod by GALL Pay R of 77
ft norlty of U. moacor coole-t systemn (ircldi*g piping and 1linig, <4 NPS)
Us.
he fire. areisier dldr med (such as, ncra. dlchrge hteder, we spray. HI-PCt nucler sysb*rn prnsler raldil. PASS. RCIC, RHR, co* &C) or twe II luttle flow whle In ue (CRD,NBVt, RWCU). in LRA Ta.le 312-3, carbo stel piping sogrret
>-4' NPS (sooh ea leedwaotr pipirng we Ircluied InoUe FAC Protage PIPS has reiswed U. FAC prowae and *rrlined U.t inclutres a portion f
r.mtor vnsed drain piping thaU supplies RWCI, and teId. hi erall the-caronsteclo pipin-g PPPS willadd ik of seleri clue to flto clealo taed coarion to 11he line entry or srrel bore piping (<4" NPS) InLRA tbe 3 12-3 (paeg 31 I-").
The nsw wary willIdetify FPow accder*ted crroiorn as a seperate eging tloct as done lorthe large bore carbon led l
pipng entryo pegs 1.8 The GALL corwisor will be Volume 2 ita iV.C 1-7 which rolls up to Tab[ 11. 1a-4 This reqdreir an errandirathi the LRA The Itese InTaete 11.2-2 U.a roll Utp to Uir Im 3.1.1-47 (GALL
: Jackson, iutr to 14V N item IV.AI-6) are ict lose cid U.i..l dhide pling and crevice -r-iou NUREO-IOI repeaedly credts Water Chenilry Control - BWR anegted byte Cue-Tirre Irpection pro-a. to virege gsloe ci nirerlal dui io pining and ereice corrosion (for saerye IVAI-8, IVAl-I1). Thi progra. coirtnrtion Isr a lse e
to lags IVis aging elfect Inl ht the losol rrelerial due toipining and crea o cwrosioi o the Isternol is r1o dfterel fte th. Ioeo o mnlerial due hi piling and corrosion fo. otier etailos slte coron -tl exposed lorhi clomor clarl. As Mald snTaele 1.1.
ft Ore-Time Ispection Progra. willverity ofwlilveeso ite Wale Clerristry Conrdl -SWR Prograt PNPS Lead Finr.n, Ron Firrin, Ron Finrnir Ron PW 53d 77


James Davis - AMR -Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                       Page 53 ]
James Davis - AMR_- Report.t the NRC.doc.pdf  
Number Status Request                                                   Response                                                                  NRC            PNPS Lead 456  Closed  1t.1t--121                                                The CROT base Is located neri the bIlomr oiU guide tube and                Jackson, Wibur  Finr.n, Ron supportsU contro rod whns Ut.rive hi disconnected ard inLRATaele 3.12-2 ft Conenorot Type Ccrtrd rod guide      reroed lor srlvce.
.Page 54]
thebe - kbo" Is InanOraWroremehl  d'Treeld water >270 dog-F.*asd to Corponet Type tCortrol rd guide huble -     The contrl rod gude tube Is mode of sasiries sted. It base. Islnanerwironsert d Treeed water >482 de-F'.       ersironert hI givo as >270 &#xb6;F became U. is U. tlhrehold fIr Pls.e clarify what Is mee by  i Cortrol rod guide kthe - taligue of Wl*-lrin $leel prteh EPRI MoohanioelTools bette and spldenwhy t. enrirorwt s. different koo the      ((tomo). Th. guidetUe tbe h eadn dcCASS ad
Number Status Request t9 Aootied 111.14-lJ-5 I-LRATatIe a1.1. 11r Nurbs 3.1.1-48 Disaasion IrelIU*olasWa~atu,
                                'Cont rod guide le        -tube"                         corespuotly IMs*aroert was quoted se >482 - as t Is Ui.
'In-a ic. Irspacion Isaro agtbt btq-,o ats
threshold lor lwod' oai'riftlearl InCASS. The liting terperolure wase*istedoroach    ob nporort Both cofrpora swo the soae l*erpeonlurn 457  Closed [3.1.1-J-131                                              Ptnw-eccelerstedcorroesion(PtC) hi ad expected ht..     belasgilioeri    Jackson, With    Firrin, Ron aging insctarewism U. ft norlty of U. moacorcoole-t systemn In LRATable 112-3 the arty componaeisIderlitied as          (ircldi*g piping and 1linig, <4 NPS)       he. fire. areisier dldr Us
<. NPS." ASME Section Xl.
                                =nirho U.the a      o*et c. Lod tig                erial ids toFAC and  med (such as, ncra. dlchrge hteder, we spray. HI-PCtnucler Incl      Inthe Flow Acodelred C&#xfd;rosion AW ee cartbn        sysb*rnprnsler raldil. PASS. RCIC, RHR, co* &C) or twe II luttle sled piping and flirng >- 4' NPS. Th. GALL descriplionof  flow whle In ue (CRD,NBVt, RWCU). inLRA Ta.le 312-3, carbo the FAC Aip (XIMt7) dinotritoll apipicability of this    stel pipingsogrret >-4' NPS (sooh ea leedwaotr pipirng we Ircluied program based on pipe darnter. peise justily why orly he  InoUe FAC Protage large-dbanoer pdpigin Table 31.2-3 Isircludod InUTh FAC po'arn Plse. Idetly the piping s.irts that we          PIPS has reiswed U. FAC prowae and *rrlined U .t inclutres Included in the FACprogre Ino    IRA Table 31.2-         a portion    f r.mtor vnsed drain pipingthaU supplies RWCI, and teId.hi erallthe- caronsteclo pipin-g PPPS willaddik        of seleri clue to flto    clealotaedcoarion to 11heline entry or srrel bore piping (<4"NPS) InLRA tbe 3 12-3 (paeg 31I-").
Tabl. l 20 2C0-1. Exafoniran Categoy B-J. rayir.
The nsw wary willIdetify FPowaccder*ted crroiorn as a seperate eging tloct as done lorthe large bore carbon l led pipng entryo pegs 1.8 The GALLcorwisor will be Volume 2 ita iV.C1-7 which rolls up to Tab[ 11. 1a-4 This reqdreir an errandirathi      the LRA 458  Closed  13.1.1    414                                            The Itese InTaete 11.2-2 U.a roll Utpto Uir Im 3.1.1-47 (GALL              Jackson,   iutr  Finrnir Ron to    14V                                  dhide pling and Nitem IV.AI-6) are ict lose cidU.i..l InLRATaleI12-2 Iorccrporeont withaing teol 1ace            crevice -r-iou NUREO-IOI repeaedly credts Water Chenilry cf IWeitler thel rollup to IRA Table I hm 3 1.147, U. Control - BWR anegted byte Cue-Tirre Irpection pro-a. to NVPIs Ikertifid asnWale CheMsrsy Control BWR."                gsloe ci nirerlal dui iopining and ereice corrosion (for virege However,InU. GALLU. aging onect of l.s. d MAsteriallor    saerye IVAI-8, IVAl-I1). Thi progra. coirtnrtion lse        Isra    e these conpo.r. "Is noenegod by bth Water Chodilry and      to lags IVis aging elfect Inlht the losol rrelerial due toipining Inteovic. Irepecoin (rWB. IC,NVs aWdO. Plesse Juaity      and crea o cwrosioi o the Isternol is r1odfterel fte th. Ioeo o why Wtter Cheerrislry Contrcl - BWR with no asoociated      mnlerial due hi piling and corrosion fo. otier etailos slte Irevpotion hisadelptle Daseree lie aging ffe.l Loss    of  coron-tl      exposedlorhi clomor clarl. As Mald snTaele 1.1.
Strfce. (Wu nr Volumlric) eacairdion for presa..
WIterial or thet. corponerTs                            ft Ore-Time Ispection Progra. willverity ofwlilveeso ite Wale Clerristry Conrdl -SWR Prograt PW 53d 77
re:airing "e inCclas Ipipe OtW I<a4 NPS. Plaee re l I* ta" aiianrl in llem 31.1-48 Disconsswio h -ia ASWE S.cIi X rayu f
staale sba 460
)cjed jal.-J-16 InLRA Tat*lall.I. Itae Nier aLt.1-a Dilsluon rIc"fudw toa awat -CrackirlIn saled owoponrts dus It ith'eel and iratad od I
llwr l
lar ditr y dteodert w wader deristry, soorly OtW C)i-Tlmn kwection Pro Is Iredtitel Howeer, thle era ao lint teams In he 3 X2 Tables wher. "rne-Tlwna Ispectioa by Itself roll. up to wari Nu.ber 31.1-48. Plea. *ain the awwet Intro slecy b oween lie LRA italamot and th. way VW the rolitnpsloite-n Nmber 31.1-48 a. dot-Inft. WRA


James Davis - AMR_- Report.t the NRC.doc.pdf                                    .Page                                                                                                          54]
===Response===
Number Status  Request                                                      Response                                                              NRC          PNPS Lead Wfile AME Cod. kt.. MB-25DD-1 (Cctegory B-N-I) doe. r"r.
Wfile AME Cod. kt.. MB-25DD-1 (Cctegory B-N-I) doe. r"r.
Vr-I orVT-3i4mpeclon *ilho ieloloranad-a ard weoqati stulurn, 11do. rot reuire Ispeolian d th ivority dith rterrelt. Tierdoe, cradling ISI Woe lr"rng losa dI mnierial dI l Intmarls In gonaeal 1. Irnaropriata.
Vr-I orVT-3i4mpeclon *ilho ieloloranad-a ard we oqati stulurn, 11 do. rot reuire Ispeolian d th ivority dith rterrelt. Tierdoe, cradling ISI Woe lr"rng losa dI mnierial dI l
The PNP<PS G-T- rac-litn       Pmo-       will Irt       e. lft raufth doher bapacliors W eaeplrmd Iclding IR Irpatlici   done per ASME XlIWS-250-l &-N-2aid othi
Intmarls In gonaeal 1. Irnaropriata.
                                                                                              ,P*oilutlo Iepecatons.
The PNP<PS G-T-rac-litn Pmo-will Irt
t9  Aootied  111.14-lJ-5                                                  Pe tws h talent en ISI does ot apply Is         .sledng       Wa   Jacksona Wilbu  Firsi; Roa ahohdtare "acden PNPS does rb tadlt tIt o*- rig I- LRATatIe a1.1. 11r Nurbs 3.1.1-48 Disaasion                ramrgaret dpiping; <o. ISI lypiocty only rep.grf surLic.
: e. lft raufth doher bapacliors W eae plrmd Iclding IR Irpatlici done per ASME XlIWS-250-l  
IrelIU*olasWa~atu, 'In-a ic. Irspacion Isaro                .arrinsmo     ea..e oft        ip apr, e         a.4 efects reasiring aid agtbt        btq-,o ats    <. NPS." ASME Section Xl.      raagnre Iritialaoonea ID. ralora woclid nt tredil SI eor Tabl. l      2C0-1. Exafoniran Categoy B-J. rayir.
&-N-2aid othi
20                                            lnrertg iha affect..
,P*oilutlo Iepecatons.
Strfce.(Wu nr Volumlric) eacairdion for presa..
Pe tws h talent en ISI does ot apply Is.sledng Wa ahohd tare "acd en PNPS does rb tadlt tIt o*- rig ramrgaret dpiping; <o. ISI lypiocty only rep.grf surLic.
re:airing      "e inCclas Ipipe OtW I<a4 NPS. Plaee          An WRAarrmnenr Is rolupred PNPS will wi d he LRA to re      l I* ta" aiianrl inllem 31.1-48 Disconsswio h    -ia da1O a. a*towal 'Inaloia Inselot           is rod appliiabla bo ASWE S.cIi X rayu            f  staale sba                  corp-itcc< 4oNPS. Iram a. dscussia In line ieml1.1-4 Tloawillreauiraana trwrlw       ta. WRA 460  )cjed    jal.-J-16                                                    For atlcfitoe thea.sletU       *Cracking Inaid toapoates             Jmcklo% W*it    Ungrdaler.
.arrinsmo oft ea..e ip
doe bothwrmWand ntotrit loding Isla droydoeslent                   at InLRA Tat*lall.I. Itae Nier        aLt.1-a Dilsluon          waderchemistry, soorly a.eCt-Tine Inspction Prop-at rIc"fudwtoa awat -CrackirlInsaled owoponrts dus              I. traitta alould baddala It ith'eel and iratadod        I larl llwr ditr y dteodert w wader deristry, soorly OtWC)i-Tlmn kwection                A.F WA ara-t       Is raiird PNPS willead a. WLRA           t.
: apr, e
Pro          Iredtitel Howeer, thleeraao lint teamsIn he Is                                                    lol.a staear-n 'Cracking inasledterroat. do. lo t-eat-ade 3 X2 Tables wher. "rne-Tlwna Ispectioa by Itself roll. up    ad nadtko IoadgIbMr drectly iqnaeni an waler to wariNu.ber 31.1-48. Plea. *ain          the awwet                        ti chernistry. "ony       Oa-Tint Iopeclion Prograrn . crailedt Intro slecy b        oween lie LRA italamot and th. way VW      arn a *lsdcuion In line ftem 3.1.1-48.
aid a.4 efects reasiring raagnre Iritialao on ea ID. ralora woclid nt tredil SI eor lnrertg iha affect..
the rolitnpsloite-n Nmber 31.1-48 a. dot- Inft. WRA Thaswaitlrlqudrsenateadit     Ilea. WRA Fbpg 54d"7
An WRA arrmnenr Is rolupred PNPS will wi d he LRA to da1O a. a*towa l 'Inaloia Inselot is rod appliiabla bo corp-itcc< 4o NPS. Iram a. dscussia In line ieml 1.1-4 Tloawillreauiraana trwrlw ta. WRA For atlcfitoe the a. sletU  
*Cracking Inaid toapoates doe bothwrmW and ntotrit loding Isla droydoeslent at wader chemistry, soorly a.e Ct-Tine Inspction Prop-at I. traitta alould baddala A.F WA ara-t Is raiird PNPS willead a. WLRA t.
ade lol.a staear-n 'Cracking inasled terroat. do. lo t-eat-ad nadtko IoadgI bMr drectly iqnaeni an waler chernistry. "ony ti Oa-Tint Iopeclion Prograrn. crailedt arn a *lsdcuion In line ftem 3.1.1-48.
Thaswaitlrlqudrsenateadit Ilea. WRA NRC PNPS Lead Jacksona Wilbu Firsi; Roa Jmcklo% W*it Ungrdaler.
Fbpg 54d" 7


James Davis - AMR - Reportto the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                         Page 55 II Number Status Request                                               Response                                                          NRC            PNPS Lead 461 Aaisdl    3.1.1-J-171                                           TIMEUNE OF SHROUD ACCESS HOLE COVER EXAMINATIONS:                Jacksont Wlbr  Pados. Rich InGALL V*l* 1, Table 1. Ske 49 an augoeed               1SS8 -GE Issueos SIL462 Impaction wing UT ar othe denowtratied ac-om1e Impection Is recaowendud for BrM. with acrwice nfh     -1991 (RFO-8) - UToIboh coova (for cit. faw. oy) s&#xa2;ems hode mere.
James Davis - AMR - Reportto the NRC.doc.pdf Page 55 II Number Status Request 461 Aaisd l 3.1.1-J-171 InGALL V*l* 1, Table 1. Ske 49 an augoeed Impaction wing UT ar othe denowtratied ac-om1e Impection Is recaowendud for BrM. with acrwice nfh s&#xa2;ems hode mere.
                                                                                        -19M2 (RFO.9).-UTodbth      o*ne (lot cim-ad radt flaws)
Doos PNPS tvo a cwcce Inthe acs.
Doos PNPS tvo a cwcce Inthe acs.       hco.ers?
de hco.ers?
de
Coos PNPS perform ar impwcticn d she acas hode Waver Wing UT or oth dawo traled meqplable Irepcticn tachrqeu?
                                                                                        . 1995 (RFO-I0). UT dzzeo dor.        cow oary Coos PNPS perform ar impwcticn d she acas hode Waver Wing UT or oth dawo traled meqplable Irepcticn       -19% (RFO-I0) -VT-I debedh maws tachrqeu?
                                                                                        - 2I  -GE louus $1L462 Rm.l on 301
                                                                                        -2X13 (RFO-14)-EVT-1 ctald ho        es.
                                                                                        -205 (RFO-15) - -      asa
                                                                                        -2007 (RFO-16)-Maneoimpoct 0a18 dgeaes byVT.I
                                                                                        -.20  (RFO-17)-PMa      lohapectal0 dagoea byVT-I Pigrim willcontinuo SoImpat ie am o damceasahl        daIo0 degreeo mad0deogma visuallyat ard Syear Inerodo, reapectiely. iring the cnt      lacen-singperiod I new BWRViP gtidi e Isa  losaso tss e      nooront. FPNPSwill poerorm Impectioe In maordorce withithat gt*,adeo Wt-in the lirt 6 yera d t    period d tende opetiwon mrdesy 12 years hweotetr, FNPS will Lsperctthe acm s hioe coers with UToWlhods. Airaltiody, PNPSwillinp*ai flu memo dhe
                                                                                        -wes Inaceorderwe withBRMViP gidolines shodd ouch This 1. ornoitwt fen 34 4G2 Cloosd  [3a1.1-J-8                                            Category B-Gt- d the ASM)aloa            ocaim tie rtierems for        u Jack"sa    lbWi  Par    Rich all preasr-relairningboiling >2da. inlhe ISI Proagwn&#xfd; The owlo RA Table 3.1.21- 1 eists 1 I pogra he            atsthe AM wed to  reuires a vkatlteria (dltranc) exmawf all RPVackaure altuc moanagg Ite aging effe olcrm king InOtl"w Pressure    (marirtaed Inplace) a"d aVT-I voslo m-a m all RPV clacato* ts" Boundry Boling - Upper hied Rlamgebne and ntds - CRD  eary lOyews.
Riange boiing Moe IdWetify the ASMa Exasrumlion Category and Resulr-,tss thal me apoicable for these  Caltgory B-0-2 d the AStE X)a odce orcains the reqiars      [lor
                                  -onoes                                              preosur-relairingblting aZ2"da inthe ISI Progrnt Theacode reeIpte a VT-I vioial maw eary 10myen for bIdling Insh $
casgosp (Includea CRD NVgo b.i1ingRPV hed N7& NS o-zze Rarnge olting).
PW 56d 77


James Davis - AMR_- Report to the NRq.doc.pdf                                                                                                ---                                                Page556:1 Number Status  Request                                                          ReWonse                                                            NRC           PNPS Lead 4    o3 Accted  (1tl.-Jt19                                                      NUREG-1801 prog-am X.Mt12 lTlrnol Aging Ertoittaenol ci Cast Jackson, WibW        Fin-in,Ron Asualiti SlsirdessSled (CASSr)egiee soCASS preese LRA Table 31.2.2 Idtrfdes *Tlnna Aging ErntciOflen-             boundry coponts Inlthe ACS. This proJgan Is noi aplicable d CASS" IS AMP o manags ft agi effect d                          to PNPS, as we lone noCASS prewsne toamd'y ooporis.
===Response===
                                *rfd*fni Inftacrto lou.hn4r
NRC PNPS Lead TIMEUNE OF SHROUD ACCESS HOLE COVER EXAMINATIONS:
* for "'as  l      opn.t *te        NUREG-t801 prorgw XIM3,      I   ThZTroolAgng aird Netkon tCortrl Rod GOdo.Tub. -Basen, Fuel Suppot Mneca-                 InradaliionEbrilftlefnt iCael Awleliic Stainless Sled (CASS)*
Jacksont Wlbr Pados. Rich 1 SS8 -GE Issueos SIL 462
Fou Laf,      and Jd Pomp Asseolieas jvaIou                      applies S reator vessel Internals (roriprewe bounsdry) pinces O-onas-].* H-o              LRATable &-2 saysrwthe              trade of CASS. Th . ntimed cormoral.s above neeall reactor NUREG-t801 ProTnm fThw"lr Aging Enftritlen*w of                  vessd nlierrl and reooverad by heyprogre bIorne CAW I. "rn' egicabla? at PN PS Please correct wt usify          Instarces. thC .RA relon SoTh. not Agrg Enciflernet d CASS ee cpoerst In sisleturIy twe LRA Also, ICan WA                  Programe asa shyoteuedndrre lon and witheah/ptirk tothe orrnlion Is ro        pie.e. -ooseted the Ndt. Ior each        Thernol Agng and Nearion Iradlaon Entritlteoenl di Cal di the thr ocoponert line Iters we validaed or clwra              Autenitis Slaintes. Sled (CASS) Progran For dcicaticn, Itkoe lo beconislant withary clhagoes irde oIn. LRA                                                          a Instarces willbe revised to cterly Indicate  e appropriate prg-ron TN*isre    siroananodriri Isothu WRA 464  Ctosd  131.1-J-20I                                                      Toclarityft RA dicussion Inline Item 1l.t-5Z, f praes'rd        ol Jnkbson, tlbr  Firrnn, Ron sigrlicad aging dtner owens no wanging dinte repaving; GALL Volurne ITable tUne 521doti.fe. t aging allects              nonegonwIt THNis    1.conistelr withthe EPRI Mach-icW Toie lor RCPS closue bdling as nCracingOAso SCC. ls of              OtWdonolconsider loedi aterial die oSoww omaging          dnectlot nateri du. to wner, Ies of pro load &s; lothernel effcts,        boited cloaews. In addtiotr los of moerial delA o weer was now gsket creep al d       t-loeelo. Only ft aging dfect o            Mirtified asan area dconcern Ilthe ocltiion odGSI-29lor "Crkfni Is Idenflied I"LRA Table 3.1.2-1fot      :oponerC        boling TI. gerer spetem dblingbowtihoih isl it eM il Mrdlvlo LRAUr lI-e 31.1-52 Th. 'Discsti sio' In                Is no rottinely dsassentled. Occasional Chrod lailuris dui Io C RA Ior Uns 11- 11.1-52 proviedesc the                                        dssion of ty        ws inecIrearesm oluhsa gdtri        ste not age related bAl e Cu othe asgng efectt lised InGALL me not Included                evenl-driven cordlithnsOW wtereolved when they occur.
-1991 (RFO-8) - UToIboh coova (for cit. faw. oy)
applicabe 51PPS.
-19M2 (RFO.9).- UTo dbth o*ne (lot cim-ad radt flaws)
Boiling al PNPS Insdeatd-t      adi 7ecTaor steel. or irnilar mnaerial. acep In specaelizedapplication whee slaines. sieed bolfing i utilized Los of prel oad doe Iteostr  relaxaton (creop)
. 1995 (RFO-I0). UT dz zeo dor. cow oary
Please provide e PNPS b  bi    fort    Oiscassioontate~n        wold oily bea concern Inver high twmcnar applicatons (,
-19% (RFO-I0) -VT-I debedh maws
l      ntdustry opeatinrg seperirce Indicales OW loss i          7W(r) as stated lnto ASI Cods, Sewtion I. Pat D. Table 4. No rnleSl dseoow          is oloa slgnlficart aging effect lot hei  MIPS bolfing operates at >7WlF. Therelore. o" of prelodl Os Io biling' Msle. claily whot Is n*wei by'n: ssignificar-           alens rdacaulon (creep) Is o nappliceagie ng egdct for t agin efoc.." t                                                  reactor coolrnt eystel A nopyd thie swionmd    shtcode was maildale ding the adt.
- 2I
Please provoids sopyofdtnlehncal i'ernce(s) sipyonting Cu W A            n tha *Loea o preload d.e beltre mrAW                            .
-GE louus $1L 462 Rm.l on 301
relaxation (creep) would oily bee cncern invery Ngh lepn*oalwe applicalions (> 70Ddog-F).
-2X13 (RFO-14)-EVT-1 ctald h o es.
Fagde56 f 77
-205 (RFO-15) - -
asa
-2007 (RFO-16)-Maneoimpoct 0a18 dgeaes byVT.I
-.20 (RFO-17)-PMa lohapect al0 dagoea byVT-I Pigrim willcontinuo SoImpat ie am o damceasahl d aIo0 degreeo mad 0deogma visuallyat ard Syear Inerodo, reapectiely. iring the cnt lacen-sing period I new BWRViP gtidi e Is a losaso tss e noo ront.
FPNPS will poerorm Impectioe In maordorce withithat gt*,adeo Wt-in the lirt 6 yera d t period d tende opetiwon mrd esy 12 years hweotetr, FNPS will Lsperct the acm s hioe coers with UToWlhods. Airaltiody, PNPSwillinp*ai flu memo dhe
-wes Inaceorderwe withBRMViP gidolines shodd ouch This 1. ornoitwt fen 34 Category B-Gt-d the ASM)a loa ocaim tie rtierems for all preasr-relairningboiling >2da. inlhe ISI Proagwn&#xfd; The owlo reuires a vkatlteria (dltranc) exmaw f all RPVackaure altuc (marirtaed Inplace) a"d aVT-I voslo m-a m all RPV clacato* "
ts eary lOyews.
Caltgory B-0-2 d the AStE X)a odce orcains the reqiars
[lor preosur-relairingblting aZ2"da inthe ISI Progrnt Theacode reeIpte a VT-I vioial maw eary 10myen for bIdling Insh $
casgosp (Includea CRD NVgo b.i1ing RPV hed N7& NS o-zze Rarnge olting).
4G2 Cloosd
[3a1.1-J-8 RA Table 3.1.21-eists 1
1 he I pogra ats the AM wed to moanagg Ite aging effe rm olc king InOtl"w Pressure Boundry Boling - Upper hied Rlamge bne and ntds - CRD Riange boiing Moe IdWet ify the ASMa Exasrumlion Category and Resulr-,tss thal me apoicable for these
-onoes Jack"sa u
lbWi Par Rich PW 56d 77


James Davis - AMR - RepOrt to the NRC.doc.pdf ..-.                                                                                                                                             Page 57]
James Davis - AMR_- Report to the NRq.doc.pdf Page556:1 Number Status Request 4
Number Status Request                                                      Response                                                                NRC            PNPS Lead 465  Closed  ll.1-J-21]                                                  0-91-17, Oewmi Safety Iosu 29. Bditngigd*jadti              orafmloIln Jockso% Wilbur  Ce  tori.
o3 Accted (1tl.-Jt19 LRA Table 31.2.2 Idtrfdes *Tlnna Aging ErntciOflen-d CASS" IS AMP o manags ft agi effect d
                                                                                              -o-le jowe plo-rIs dadI 017191. The CLi sired no The LRADiaw*aoOn or Un. hoe 11.1-52Ircludes tha              respon- o      odocteltld ooro-pornonca wao ibtritetd PNPS d no staltM      -To address lwo boting lopcrdord conerns,        dd ratiow OL91-17 In199gt a or    a-review stmory wao proklded bo PNPS hs takl actions loaftes. NUREG-1339.                    tie NRC audt leaht "rng the sit visit R..duLion dc enc      Soety    tssue 29: Bolting Degadtion orFailurein Nuclear Po.er Planish!                          Potly as a reedt Ofite PNPS raiwvo cL W9-17,Station IMrwennce pr*OUre fiorbltiiU 3 M4-52 was divelopta              based Ple.se ikllny ad govfd. a copy of any prvio.i, dockelted    on EPRI NP-507. *Good Boling Pracic*e*.
*rfd*fni Inftacrto lou.hn4r
corr      de InwoNchPNPS doocribes It actioi and awrsrilwts (1iiarr) witreogo:d oNUREC-1339.
* for "'as l
4a  Closed  131.1-J-22                                                    Inthe Noo-Clos I Macoaitcal kirla-t'ion            tilcitno and      Jack-%WIbbur    Firrh Ron Mecheaical Tools. Revision 3,EPRI, Palo AJto, CA 200t. 1003055 in LRATableo12-1 alline onki            flarfie thesong offedo (The Mocharical Togs) Appendox ., low alloy stedelyo od to LooLa kotoerit" for thsecorxroti ypa "Chot. Barg.         irdoor air contidong noostur (hurnidcty)Is tjaectlbloss of osub. mi. walsher, wd bhinrgs,* NoteH'is appied o            noearialsd6 d    ot0- afrn rnontelI*o of general cororois Ths this li15lem, Ircicotirg VW the aqng dofdt Is no In          botilinghten ha ths noteal ard rwioroar 1 oontlmlion aod NUREC-1801 orthisonorar            no taral ard e-wirormrn!  tmidora he aging affect Is applicale In acoordewe with Be cortrsntion                                                    petarinrg esqymene proved Inthe Reactor Heid Closuro Studs Proon%errs*ation ci1I rIStlor head doow.e tmta sod aisut Pleae Idalily ard dscuts the rexhwdrn taet creat the          xaoTinotionoi 18 Ws and lB woaolr during RFOIS lotnd no nw aOng efld oLas di Lkhr.is Inthese owomreti.                  ratordle Iadcldioe d lo  *c    i raial Ples.. kirlity ard describe PNPS-speciic or Inrldty e*syairco where the agoig effect        ."Los solft r.o Pas  LRA Taole Uno Ite31.1-52 b.basedonNUREC-180I, Volune I.
opn.t *te tCortrl Rod GOdo. Tub.  
been oserved inth1se oer.oneis.                             Table I which afdesse lossoodnotaril di only Io wear for carboo and staliress *leol bolting Since to NUREG-1801 line Ple. Irdtda a&    da-s.io f why Lose ofMthi    i      i..,  torn ds 6. adte any odhi aging mneorisroe hIWrostl in agog        pyl taplicable      t eo ono theslo          sto 201 6 for   hoso merla, It woo deeaed t           the line lien is nro*Wicabio cononeals tat rdltluto LRAT*ble Ure Ilen31l.l-              for lossod na-l    otr gtor ,2 re9 corrosion.
-Basen, Fuel Suppot Mneca -
Pad 57d77
Fou Laf, and Jd Pomp Asseolieas jvaIou O-onas-].
* H-o LRA Table &-2 says rwthe NUREG-t801 ProTnm fThw"lr Aging Enftritlen*w of CAW I. "rn' egicabla? at PN PS Please correct wt usify ee cpoerst In sisleturIy twe LRA Also, IC an WA orrnlion Is ro pie.e. -oose ted the Ndt. Ior each di the thr ocoponert line Iters we validaed or clwra lo beconislant withary clhagoes irde oIn. LRA 464 Ctosd 131.1-J-20I GALL Volurne ITable tUne 521doti.fe. t aging allects lor RCPS closue bdling as nCracing OA so SCC. ls of nateri du. to wner, Ies of pro load &s; lothernel effcts, gsket creep al d t-loeelo.
Only ft aging dfect o "Crkfni Is Idenflied I"LRA Table 3.1.2-1 fot :oponerC Mrdlvlo LRAUr lI-e 31.1-52 Th. 'Discsti sio' In the C
RA Ior Uns 11-11.1-52 proviedesc dssion of ty Cu othe asgng efectt lised In GALL me not Included applicabe 51 PPS.
Please e
provide PNPS bi for b
t Oiscassioon tate~n l
nt dustry opeatinrg seperirce Indicales OW loss i rnleSl dseo ow is olo a slgnlficart aging effect lot hei biling' Msle. claily whot Is n*wei by'n:
ssignificar-agin t
efoc.."
Please provoids sopyof dtn lehncal i'ernce(s) sipyonting Cu A
W mrAW n
tha *Loea o preload d.e.beltre relaxation (creep) would oily bee cncern in very Ngh lepn*oalwe applicalions (> 70D dog-F).
ReWonse NRC PNPS Lead Fin-in, Ron NUREG-1801 prog-am X.Mt12 lTlrnol Aging Ertoittaenol ci Cast Jackson, WibW Asualiti Slsirdess Sled (CASSr)egiee soCASS preese boundry coponts Inlthe ACS. This proJgan Is noi aplicable to PNPS, as we lone noCASS prewsne toamd'y ooporis.
NUREG-t801 prorgw XIM3, I
ThZTrool Agng aird Netkon Inradaliion Ebrilftlefnt iCael Awleliic Stainless Sled (CASS)*
applies S reator vessel Internals (roriprewe bounsdry) pinces trade of CASS. Th. ntimed cormoral.s above neeall reactor vessd nlierrl and reooverad by heyprogre bIorne Instarces. thC.RA relon SoTh. not Agrg Enciflernet d CASS Programe asa shyoteued ndrre lon and withea h/ptirk tothe Thernol Agng and Nearion Iradlaon Entritlteoenl di Cal Autenitis Slaintes. Sled (CASS) Progran For dcicaticn, Itkoe Instarces willbe revised to cterly Indicate a
e appropriate prg-ron TN*isre siroananodriri Isothu WRA Toclarityft RA dicussion Inline Item 1l.t-5Z, f praes'rd ol sigrlicad aging dtner owens no wanging dinte repaving; nonegonwIt THNis 1.conistelr withthe EPRI Mach-icW Toie OtW donol consider loedi aterial die oSoww omaging dnect lot boited cloaews. In addtiotr los of moerial del A
o weer was now Mirtified asan area dconcern Ilthe ocltiion odGSI-29 lor boling TI. gerer spetem dbling bowtihoih isl it eM il Is no rottinely dsassentled. Occasional Chrod lailuris dui Io ws inecIrearesm oluh sa gdtri ste not age related bAl e evenl-driven cordlithns OW wte reolved when they occur.
Boiling al PNPS Insdeatd-t adi 7e cTaor steel. or irnilar mnaerial. acep In specaelized application whee slaines. sieed bolfing i utilized Los of prel oad doe Iteostr relaxaton (creop) wold oily bea concern Inver high twmcnar applicatons (,
7W(r) as stated lnto ASI Cods, Sewtion I. Pat D. Table 4. No MIPS bolfing operates at >7WlF. Therelore. o" of prelodl Os Io alens rdacaulon (creep) Is o n appliceagie ng egdct for t reactor coolrnt eystel A nopy d thie swionmd shtcode was maildale ding the adt.
Jnkbson, tlbr Firrnn, Ron Fagde 56 f 77


James Davis - AMR -,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf ...                                                                                                     ..                                  Page 581 Number Status Request                                                       Response                                                       NRC           PNPS Lead 467 Cloa     11.1-J-23                                                   P'hotalin sales har flow reat Tosaa  we Mprese rdaiingl        Jackson, Wlbur  Firrin, Ron ponrwis (no presso boeundaryluriycn. They wa a as pa*ns LRA Table 11.2-3Includs a line Item lor tMn Slesrline         tha IsIsreotl Ibide the alan slern piping The ains steam Flow Rstoricnlo. eds dfCASS. 1nan -wir-el           of       piping sthe preoems btudvy. Conreluefrly. the atlsa sle fow Trealsed Wwr . 482 dog-F, agng dffectof Redction In           rehritorus aenru agnoold *ardcOa for GALLprogran XIMIZ FrsmuroToughness FmrClass I piong nwonol               made o) No, PNPS heMnor dne te scre*ing for t*e nsin ales, line of this mralwel, Inaths ilnronrnwt and withthis aging       ftow orlicto,.
James Davis - AMR - RepOrt to the NRC.doc.pdf..-.
effe1t, te GALLrasos.srab         t     MP XI.M2. "Thetrml     b) Whls teh Itrpecsion pore        arhe      al hs r yetboeen  da oped, te Agng Emnniht*err, d Cast Austemiot Stsiles Staod             plannedrylion        Isasvisual eanioedion parlmed by kee*ing a (CASS). In u of the rscomn-edad AP. PNPS propoeae             awerss Ito theamln sleowline 10 ue aOn-Tie Ikpection.                                     n) Reduction d FractureToughress (Crooking) and Lo*sof timi d theal stlew tine flow rehtlolors ae not oonoclred likldy O     itho-:                                                 effects doing t. period d extended ofwardion (No agong of thosa tretrictlts.idenlified byNUREG-1801). Loos od aterial witl be The GALL-reoo-mont l AP includes screeningcriteria b         Miligated by BRM -Water Chods"y Coatrol. Norwholet, PNPS dalarMire whch CASS aorponaes awe att*tialy                 hes conitted tocdo a one-itreo Ipec lion tSo wrilytha time aging s.uceplibtle o therssl aging ofl'itite-     aid reg-ire               we rot edfeats as          urrin Since the flow rstlrio*or we na premsure agnarrled Itrpection Has PNPS appledthe Koraening           relairing ncon irls. theOre-Tire Iympectlin Progaen It crieria to te tin S&#xfd;asslne Flow Rsmictos? I so, what         eiiate tonnseg the aleets of aging washe reaetis?
Page 57]
Fless describe wha e*l*erl ion reqairroaris, sflhods and aWaistdd w1lb1 besd InFPNPSa prnopoeed     Oe-Time Ibelpeion odthe tin,Senarrine Flow Restictse.
Number Status Request 465 Closed ll.1-J-21]
PlMese jusify that a n*t-Ti we Itrpetlon providosadalte aging nwagwent of t*e in SSterdine Flow Rastriclonl dring tlh period of aWadard olpralion.
The LRADiaw*aoOn or Un. hoe 11.1-52 Ircludes tha staltM
468 Cloaed 13.1.1-J-24]                                                 As stated Insa queiion, tIem 31.1-53 rmera to stosl nopornts. JacksKr Wibur  Usgredlr, CASS Itscomiered stainless Sadel.The soeeiad and awiro-nr IRA Its Number 11.1-53 Ciawaion tla., "Thw.rara no           corinatireon d stainless stla In losed cyleacooing water doe s*lea onpen       of tde Class I redoo vensd, vessal       us pw Inthe RCS (CI-qiar IV) labedof NUREO-180l; tedore, Itrnarels a ractor     aoort prossure boundary ae*pe     to   te line fienttthe purp -oe-Varra baerrie Ia nr.ged tothe a
-To address lwo boting lopcrdord conerns, PNPS hs takl actions loaftes. NUREG-1339.
nloeid cycl odirn waler."     However. LRATable 3o1.2-3     ESF tase dNUREG-1801.
R..duLion dc enc Soety tssue 29: Bolting Degadtion orFailure in Nuclear Po.er Planish!
(pege 3.1-68) ilrrudes lire tirnt tr PunF -ow -Ther borid (RR) rndle of CASS where ise ang irwaeg-1 progrars awe iderotlod as Watlr Cherstry Cotrol - Closed Cooling Wsla ard "ieasvice Impwlio. These line hterr wpow lobe Irnmistmerswiththe Discuassion inl.1-5.
Ple.se ikllny ad govfd. a copy of any prvio.i, dockelted corr de In woNch PNPS doocribes It actioi and awrsrilwts (1iiarr) witreogo:d oNUREC-1339.
Ple. eplain why those lirear not Incorsistent wilhthe Discueionlnsl.1-53 mnonsec the Inconsiste*ay.
4a Closed 131.1-J-22 in LRATableo12-1 alline onki flarfie thesong offedo LooLa kotoerit" for thse corxroti ypa "Chot. Barg.
osub. mi. walsher, wd bhinrgs,* NoteH'is appied o this li15lem, Ircicotirg VW the aqng dofdt Is no In NUREC-1801 orthis onorar no taral ard e-wirormrn!
cortrsntion Pleae Idalily ard dscuts the rexhwdrn taet creat the aOng efld oLas di Lkhr.is Inthese owomreti.
Ples.. kirlity ard describe PNPS-speciic or Inrldty e*syairco where the agoig effect
."Los s olft r.o Pas been oserved inth1se oer.oneis.
Ple. Irdtda a& da-s.io f why Lose i ofMthi i..,
agog taplicable pyl theslo e
t o ono sto 201 6 for cononeals tat rdltluto LRA T*ble Ure Ilen31l.l-
 
===Response===
0-91-17, Oewmi Safety Iosu 29. Bditngig d*jadti ora fmloIln
-o-le jowe plo-rIs dad I 017191. The CLi sired no respon-o d no odocteltld ooro-pornonca wao ibtritetd PNPS dd ratiow OL91-17 In199gt a or a-review stmory wao proklded bo tie NRC audt leaht "rng the sit visit Potly as a reedt Of ite PNPS raiwvo cL W9-17, Station IMrwennce pr*OUre fior bltiiU 3 M4-52 was divelopta based on EPRI NP-507. *Good Boling Pracic*e*.
Inthe Noo-Clos I Macoaitcal kirla-t'ion tilcitno and Mecheaical Tools. Revision 3, EPRI, Palo AJto, CA 200t. 1003055 (The Mocharical Togs) Appendox., low alloy sted elyo od to irdoor air contidong noostur (hurnidcty) Is tjaectl b loss of noearialsd 6 d
o t0- afrn rnonte lI*o of general cororois Ths botiling hten ha ths noteal ard rwioroar 1 oontlmlion aod tmidora he aging affect Is applicale In acoordewe with Be petarinrg esqymene proved Inthe Reactor Heid Closuro Studs Proon% errs*ation ci1I rIStlor head doow.e tmta sod aisut xaoTinotion oi 18 Ws and lB woaolr during RFOIS lotnd no nw ratordle Iadcldioe d *c lo i raial LRA Taole Uno Ite31.1-52 b.based onNUREC-180I, Volune I.
Table I which afdesse loss ood notaril di only Io wear for carboo and staliress *leol bolting Since to NUREG-1801 line torn ds
: 6. adte any odhi aging mneorisroe hIW rostl in hoso merla, It woo deeaed t the line lien is nro *Wicabio for lossod na-l otr r,2 gto re9 corrosion.
NRC PNPS Lead Jockso% Wilbur Ce tori.
Jack-% WIbbur Firrh Ron Pad 57d77
 
James Davis - AMR -,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf...
Page 581 Number Status Request 467 Cloa 11.1-J-23 LRA Table 11.2-3 Includs a line Item lor tMn Slesrline Flow Rstoricnlo. eds df CASS. 1nan -wir-el of Trealsed Wwr. 482 dog-F, agng dffect of Redction In Frsmuro Toughness Fmr Class I piong nwonol made of this mralwel, Inaths ilnronrnwt and withthis aging effe1t, te GALL rasos.srab t
MP XI.M2. "Thetrml Agng Emnniht*err, d Cast Austemiot Stsiles Staod (CASS). In u of the rscomn-edad AP. PNPS propoeae 10 ue a On-Tie Ikpection.
O itho-:
The GALL-reoo-mont l AP includes screening criteria b dalarMire whch CASS aorponaes awe att*tialy s.uceplibtle o therssl aging ofl'itite-aid reg-ire agnarrled Itrpection Has PNPS appled the Koraening crieria to te tin S&#xfd;asslne Flow Rsmictos? I so, what washe reaetis?
Fless describe wha e*l*erl ion reqairroaris, sflhods and aWaistdd w1lb1 besd InFPNPSa prnopoeed Oe-Time Ibelpeion odthe tin, Senarrine Flow Restictse.
PlMese jusify that a n*t-Ti we Itrpetlon providos adalte aging nwagwent of t*e in SSterdine Flow Rastriclonl dring tlh period of aWadard olpralion.
468 Cloaed 13.1.1-J-24]
IRA Its Number 11.1-53 Ciawaion tla., "Thw.rara no s*lea onpen of tde Class I redoo vensd, vessal Itrnarels a ractor aoort prossure boundary ae*pe to nloeid cycl odirn a
waler." However. LRATable 3o1.2-3 (pege 3.1-68) ilrrudes lire tirnt tr PunF  
-ow -Ther borid (RR) rndle of CASS where ise ang irwaeg-1 progrars awe iderotlod as Watlr Cherstry Cotrol - Closed Cooling Wsla ard "ieasvice Impwlio.
These line hterr wpow lobe Irnmistmers withthe Discuassion inl.1-5.
Ple.
eplain why those lirear not Incorsistent wilhthe Discueionlnsl.1-53 mnonsec the Inconsiste*ay.
 
===Response===
P'ho talin sales har flow reat Tosaa we Mp rese rdaiingl ponrwis (no presso boeundary luriycn.
They wa a as pa*ns tha Is Isreotl Ibide the alan slern piping The ains steam piping sthe preoems btudvy. Conreluefrly. the atlsa sle fow rehritorus aenru agnoold *ardcOa for GALL progran XIMIZ o) No, PNPS heM nor dne te scre*ing for t*e nsin ales, line ftow orlicto,.
b) Whls teh Itrpecsion pore ar he hs r al yetboeen da oped, te planne drylion Is a svisual eanioedion parlmed by kee*ing a awerss Ito the amln sleow line n) Reduction d Fracture Toughress (Crooking) and Lo*s of timi d theal stlew tine flow rehtlolors ae not oonoclred likldy effects doing t. period d extended ofwardion (No agong of thosa tretrictlts.idenlified byNUREG-1801). Loos od aterial witl be Miligated by BRM -Water Chods"y Coatrol. Norwholet, PNPS hes conitted tocdo a one-itreo Ipec lion tSo wrily tha time aging edfeats we as rot urrin Since the flow rstlrio*or we na premsure relairing ncon irls. the Ore-Tire Iympectlin Progaen It eiiate tonnseg the aleets of aging NRC PNPS Lead Jackson, Wlbur Firrin, Ron As stated Ins a queiion, tIem 31.1-53 rmera to stosl nopornts.
JacksKr Wibur
: Usgredlr, CASS Itscomiered stainless Sadel. The soeeiad and awiro-nr corinatireon d stainless stla In losed cyleacooing water doe us pw Inthe RCS (CI-qiar IV) labed of NUREO-180l; tedore, te line fient tthe purp
-oe -Varra baerrie Ia nr.ged tothe ESF tase dNUREG-1801.
P'ay 511d;?7
P'ay 511d;?7


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                             Page 59]
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 59]
Number Status Request                                                     Response                                                          NRC            PNPS Lead 4   C69sJ      3to.3--                                                   The.selectn o the aging affct ol oss$of Materls or of    oagi    Jelk.sor Wild,  Urotdletm, dclcl was dq'o-lmli won the tonralur os the3 conrmpomsduring
Number Status Request 4
                                  *NPSLRATabe 13.2-3 Icudes         trsm for Ing and       norma opmolioe C lonoils wilthatsnp osu abons the fitmngsm ded carbon sld Ins environrrvm cir-indoor         biling poart wmler will preclude m0oistureaccuawici. Asa (ext). Sons cdthese enr.es ha mnging edfet of     dowsf  tlmer f co*vnenience.the transition poirs wnss sutmd at Do interil; -nt dfthew entries have snging effect of         tepor*arsi threshnld of 22IF for leakingduo o toig        Insteel
C69 sJ 3to.3--
                                *rnons.For ia neinis wilthang affect ofrot', Nolo 101     Althoue toss i      oeporasa car be below this thrshld during is w1piid and staies. "Hiho-oner       surfacestaemp uro ghuiown corduior. end      roos coreponrsb wUld possibly a" piectke, nmsture aco*nUlion-thad           remidt In     ternpalures btl abon ad below this tieslcid dtring nroned perationthse copormts shoild raietyN em, beat a mperalure bScown 3Mca de pts*nt Cor          nisou ly. even during Pleei clarityshe high terpr asre onodtions that we         shuvdown nditions, inire      amcurvalioi W A benegligible netnioreodInths noot Wed Isthe'high telperatde tIshr d? For pipingld expmiemne slgrilicarl                 ThMPiPS position on losci praterial m      n enlmtlorsiurmfof siclod lenmeramr catngess duing opanalion, spoimosirldy wid       piping grew A d eairlie ticene rwsna application nlmwp c.
*NPS LRA Tabe 13.2-3 Icudes trsm for Ing and fitmngs m ded carbon sld Ins environrrvm cir-indoor (ext). Sons cd these enr.es ha mnging edfet of dow sf interil;  
permoargodoperation atllarperature below Ow high           toes odtals"      on lemralsuacen Is nomnaltyircnagoc by tmirdaoure threshold Is swaredcr antcitiated or tose       systse wslkdonsu; hotwer. sysler wasldowns dori Impaet*p3 piping and fitingswhere the agg effect Is 'nort?           entemior mInlate of iamed pipi ng trims tihnsulation ts rwmnold Piens. deiscusshe metodogy tht PNPS wes tolidenlty        ior nienie5rce There Is n          It raeovs irdlatio andcretaly Ioeed wch   bpipn is clasified w hsasing agng edect d"los o      of   Impect ipe aealm      udacs ascs3lot eh      M-emrires iae ndmter and wih hoagissar ffect ol -none"                   Inulation prevenms noisltur accuwmdkaon which In torn Feorts tosscf rmnterias. PFPs plan Is to Impact tnimilaMed steel p1iping for tos nawterial viA systne w,,lkdowrnnd nol reovees my Imuldiiro 470 Acceted f3l.t-J-261                                                 Table 3,1.1. IAn rsutm 31.1-2 specifies M aging ed1ectof          Jackson, Wiosur Firne, Ron cracking do lo stiress oorsion crncking lot carbon and stainles PNPS VRATable 112-3 contain two line itenmfor tolting       celd reactor ctolat yste prnessurebotundaryoosro boltitn (flatsg. vaes. alccr where the nm ia is eishl low alloy   Ikavios Inspection bolting ronrenoss Is specified In GALL
-nt dfthew entries have snging effect of
                                .lsed or stainle. stseele threirronse Is Air-lndoo         XI.MISt Boting kesrity. forinerageenm deracking and tofci (iederl), and 3M slog dm   llt 1. cracking                 naterilof pressre retaining bolting impaled Inaccordance with AStE Secction . Therefore. reimniceI epaclion to acceptabol lo Pis.e Stntlfy fM -li-           hPatcaew tNIsagng deft     mraging cracking Imreactor coolant prnsur bom y boltling In thew co.npoiws. P*ian juitiy td te     3 mrvice         Howwe, aBilting Integriy Progian M credis Iosmice Irspeidonpooganpid  maging.f'     mrmrrnanmiocthw,       Irspealioni wllbedd    cpkWth3Mwill addres 3M agng maosrgnmto clbolting ln3M opop ci licmroe renwal.
*rnons. For ia neinis wilthang affect ofrot', Nolo 101 is w1piid and staies. "Hiho-oner surfacestaemp uro piectke, nmsture aco*nUlion-thad remid t In Pleei clarity she high terpr asre onodtions that we netnioreod Inths noot Wed Is the'high telperatde tIshr d? For pipingld expmiemne slgrilicarl lenmeram r catngess duing opanalion, spoimosirldy wid permoargo doperation atllarperature below Ow high tmirdaoure threshold Is swared cr antcitiated or tose piping and fitings where the agg effect Is 'nort?
perlormZ 1,IrtemnWO     tUmllop wi~ngl fsi            thepinoni. mimtedai spost.m Plan.sclarilywhothr FNPSwilltadoodoping a Tis requiresn          sardrarmt tothe LRA loirclude descripions d bolting Irtogrity progrn nmored onSaction 70MIS to       the Boiling IntegrityProrins IntAppndires AortdA aondtoidentify Itro tgese cornponers.                                     wherothe progran s apicable ThiSlean Is closed Itone 37f Psv 59d 77
Piens. deiscus she metodogy tht PNPS wes to lidenlty wch bpipn is clasified w hsasing agng edect o d"los of ndmter and wih ho agiss ar ffect ol -none" 470 Acceted f3l.t-J-261 PNPS VRA Table 112-3 contain two line itenm for tolting (flatsg. vaes. alccr where the nm ia is eishl low alloy
.lsed or stainle. stseele threirronse Is Air-lndoo (iederl),
and 3M slog dm llt
: 1. cracking Pis.e Stntlfy fM -li-hPat caew tNIsagng deft In thew co.npoiws.
P*ian juitiy td te 3
mrvice Irspeidon pooganpid maging.f' mrmrrnanmio cthw, perlorm Z 1,IrtemnWO fsi tUmllop wi~ngl the pinon i. mimtedai spost.m Plan.s clarilywhothr FNPS willtadoodoping a bolting Irtogrity progrn nmored onSaction 70 MIS to Itro tgese cornponers.


James Davis* AMR
===Response===
            -   -  Report to the NR,C.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                          Page 60j Number Status Request                                                      Response                                                        NRC            PNPS Lead 471 Chewd  [31.14-271                                                  Theerg effect d cracking de iofalige deperds anthe t#nnet      Jackson, WINr    Unreidlte, and mrncheroT" Io:ding dOwe corepn en is effectively In LRATable 112-3, W-AP cosntintion Bdfin. Sarlless          Indejendkfl datoe einrofent at ite sueatcedthe cononsrt.
The.selectn o the aging affct ol oss$ of Materls or of o agi dclcl was dq'o-lmli won the tonralur os the3 conrmpoms during norma opmolioe C lonoils wilth atsnp osu abons the biling poart wmler will preclude m0oisture accuawici. Asa tlmer f co*vnenience. the transition poirs wnss sutmd at Do tepor*arsi threshnld of 22IF for leaking duo o toig In steel Althoue toss i
sled, Air-Irdwrk, Cracldrg-faligue.TLAA -toe notesawe "A,    The tablesInNUREG-1801, Vdws. Z.Cheatie IV(odske d 1.B." Plae explainwtyrnde l          Is apicabe bhiti linre  S ecltin Al) IiucdeJcnrenfl withan air evironwr ardan ite-                                                        andngent S cngtdue        toe fnatigue Wile ed aomelira roud hens been med as a seidiltton, ite nhce d a line within the cse-podrng esten dable    (Table N.CI inthis cae) was prderned Pant specifcNde 105 eplaine ft the dffteence In sneinrwne      ecnIcs ileptabe lothe edetion dacracking due to laig-e.
oeporasa car be below this thrshld during ghuiown corduior.
472  Closed  311.1J-281                                                  The girg effect d onclakingdue to faieg depends onthe fenel    Jeclkenn Wilbur  Ungin/dten.
end roos coreponrsb wUld possibly a" ternpalures btl abon ad below this tieslcid dtring nroned peration thse copormts shoild raietyN em, beat a mperalure bScow n 3Mca de pts*nt Cor nisou ly. even during shuvdown nditions, inire amcurvalioi W A benegligible ThM PiPS position on losci praterial m
endinecteniccoadng      a  " enunpinsent "ndIs dlladvely hiLRATaue 112-1. MtAPoewnsioe e -Cloueeflarge                Indeperdet dcthe enuironrenl ale stlurfac dhe otnponet studl oa O-th* presure b xeouncy    bdlir* Low &nay steed. Thetable. InNUREG-1801. Vdu. e 2.Chte" IV(edide d Ar-rien, CraCkn-latigIeT.".T        -Ihe noa re'C, 10.V      Sutbeeticin Al) htclude cenponetsr with neairenwvironing ad en Ple=e euqain winro te 105 is applicable        tinelt It"n.             a aqng enlct uenhirk* die to letigue. Wile onea tese line oculd have been wed as sutbtituioncth chice d a line witer thC orespordng estern tbod (TabolNIAI l thiNrae) wase pirderred Plate specific Ndte 105 e*epains bi the dflerence In enironnets Is accepotde kthe ealuaton d crackling due to fatigue.
n enlmtlor siurmfof si clod piping grew A d eairlie ticene rwsna application nlmwp c.
Fy    60d 77
toes od tals" on lemral suacen Is nomnalty ircnagoc by systse wslkdonsu; hotwer. sysler wasldowns dori Impaet*p 3 entemior mInlate of iamed pipi ng trims tihnsulation ts rwmnold ior nienie5rce There Is n Ioeed It raeovs irdlatio and cretaly Impect ipe aeal m udacs ascs e h 3lot M-emrires iae Inulation prevenms noisltur accuwmdkaon which In torn Feorts toss cf rmnterias. PFPs plan Is to Impact tnimilaMed steel p1iping for tos nawterial viA systne w,,lkdowrn nd nol reovees my Imuldiiro Table 3,1.1. IAn rsutm 31.1-2 specifies M aging ed1ect of cracking do lo stiress oorsion crncking lot carbon and stainles celd reactor ctolat yste prnessure botundary oosro boltitn Ikavios Inspection bolting ronrenoss Is specified In GALL XI.MISt Boting kesrity. forinerageenm deracking and tofci naterilof pressre retaining bolting impaled Inaccordance with AStE Secction. Therefore. reimniceI epaclion to acceptabol lo mraging cracking Im reactor coolant prnsur bom y boltling Howwe, aBilting Integriy Progian M credis Iosmice Irspealioni wllbedd cpkWth3M will addres 3M agng maosrgnmto cl bolting ln3M opop ci licmroe renwal.
Tis requiresn sardrarmt tothe LRA loirclude descripions d the Boiling Integrity Prorin s IntAppndires AortdA aond toidentify wherothe progran s apicable ThiSlean Is closed Itone 37f NRC PNPS Lead Jelk.sor
: Wild, Urotdletm, Jackson, Wiosur Firne, Ron Psv 59d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf ..                                                                                                                                  Page 61 I Number Status   Request                                                     Resonse                                                      NRIC        PNPS Lead 473  CMoeod  131.14-259                                                    The cracking rlayred bin 0~ ea,reis stresso            c=king erorion    Jckson Wjlb  Rrir.A Ron ddto tainless sis cladding TN. wasnot entered b*ad on In LRATa.l 112-1. ahd olklwing corponawts Ne                 BWRVtP-74, Kudwas beaed oedreter = iost toolsasd rndelwry Idnlrad as heviri ad ging tffectof cewk!ng and Nod. H         oeraing espey*r*-    NUREG-101 alseo epifie cracking dea to te wietl Doar. (Bdorn Heed); Dorre (Uppe Cloas.r             SCC fan agiag eoffct for n    tarless sled raeerial ntriies Head); FI.nge (Shelf clowur flange and Upper heod             Ndte *ret omsiws ech as Nozzle, Drain (N 11) which Is terdad closereRange);Vess Sal11(Bdlir. shal); Vessel shel           carbon ateel heo lIs cracking otry other ta    ackirg-tstfrs.
James Davis* - AMR - Report to the NR, C.doc.pdf Page 60j Number Status Request  
(Irt-erodale ozzle mhet, low.er shel, t4       shall); Nozzle
 
(,Mn stern)&#xfd; Talds 3-1 In BWMVIP-74-A(sertor Pressure Veasel Inspection ad Flaw Evolmion GAtdddims for Ucere Renewal) addrese verbou poteriald ea related i Irdolce ft oo-eponerasto which the echaleieKr ad eahhai r. apply. Excep for ahe ma-cetm-rn df aigue which applesee eons di the conPora*r lited into paragraph atwo, there lenorrehhalmr In Table 3-1 o BVWVIP.74-A thl cases cracking and Ith BWMVlP-74-A Idalsfie as applicale omah c romponerls     listed abso Plea. provide a dis*cssion d the rneodclog thea FPNPS uasd boddwer       ltth Ithadngg ffect d'crackirgr Is giicate for Owacornporarts listed In the first pw*snaph, tbovo.PleseIdotiy tha n*s&#xfd;ciene(.) lhd cause cracking Inthese ooponpes.
===Response===
Plea.s aoplin how orwhhdl PNPS lmorpoed the Ilrorn-tlion contained In BYVRVIP-74-AInto its ddernitriaon ad cracking eswe agirg affect applicabe for Ite cornponars..
NRC PNPS Lead 471 Chewd
[31.14-271 The erg effect d cracking de io falige deperds anthe t#nnet Jackson, WINr Unreidlte, and mrncheroT" Io:ding dOwe corepn en is effectively In LRATable 112-3, W-AP cosntintion Bdfin. Sarlless Indejendkfl datoe einrofent at ite sueatcedthe cononsrt.
sled, Air-Irdwrk, Cracldrg-faligue.TLAA -toe notesawe "A, The tables InNUREG-1801, Vdws. Z.Cheatie IV(odske d 1.B." Plae explainwtyrnde l Is apicabe bhi ti linre S
ecltin Al) IiucdeJcnrenfl withan air evironwr ardan ite-andngent S cngtdue toe fnatigue Wile ed aome lira roud hens been med as a seidiltton, ite nhce d a line within the cse-podrng esten dable (Table N.CI in this cae) was prderned Pant specifc Nde 105 eplaine ft the dffteence In sneinrwne ecnIcs ileptabe lothe edetion da cracking due to laig-e.
472 Closed 311.1J-281 The girg effect d onclaking due to faieg depends onthe fenel Jeclkenn Wilbur Ungin/dten.
end inecteniccoadng a " enunpinsent "nd Is dlladvely hiLRATaue 112-1. MtAPoewnsioe e -Cloueeflarge Indeperdet dcthe enuironrenl ale stlurfac dhe otnponet studl oa O-th* presure b xeouncy bdlir* Low &nay steed.
Thetable. InNUREG-1801. Vdu. e 2.Chte" IV(edide d Ar-rien, CraCkn-latigIeT.".T
-Ihe noa re'C, 10.V Sutbeeticin Al) htclude cenponetsr with neair enwvironing ad en Ple=e euqain winro te 105 is applicable lt tine It"n.
aqng enlct a uenhirk* die to letigue. Wile one a tese line oculd have been wed as s utbtituioncth chice d a line witer thC orespordng estern tbod (TabolNIAI l thiN rae) wase pirderred Plate specific Ndte 105 e*epains bi the dflerence In enironnets Is accepotde kthe ealuaton d crackling due to fatigue.
Fy 60d 77
 
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf..
Page 61 I Number Status Request 473 CMoeod 131.14-259 In LRATa.l 112-1. ahd olklwing corponawts Ne Idnlrad as heviri ad ging tffect of cewk!ng and Nod. H te wietl Doar. (Bdorn Heed); Dorre (Uppe Cloas.r Head); FI.nge (Shelf clowur flange and Upper heod closereRange); Vess Sal11 (Bdlir. shal); Vessel shel (Irt-erodale ozzle mhet, low.er shel, t4 shall); Nozzle
(,Mn stern)&#xfd; Talds 3-1 In BWMVIP-74-A (sertor Pressure Veasel Inspection ad Flaw Evolmion GAtdddims for Ucere Renewal) addrese verbou poteriald ea related echaleieKr i
ad Irdolce ft oo-eponeras to which the eahhai r. apply. Excep for ahe ma-cetm-rn df aigue which applese e eons di the conPora*r lited into paragraph atwo, there leno rrehhalmr In Table 3-1 o BVWVIP.74-A thl cases cracking and Ith BWMVlP-74-A Idalsfie as applicale om ah c romponerls listed abso Plea. provide a dis*cssion d the rneodclog thea FPNPS uasd boddwer th lt Ith adng g ffect d'crackirgr Is giicate for Owa cornporarts listed In the first pw*snaph, tbovo. Plese Idotiy tha n*s&#xfd;ciene(.) lhd cause cracking In these ooponpes.
Plea.s aoplin how or whhdl PNPS lmorpoed the Ilrorn-tlion contained In BYVRVIP-74-A Into its ddernitriaon ad cracking es we agirg affect applicabe for Ite cornponars..
Pleasa dscuas th plert-specff ic
Pleasa dscuas th plert-specff ic
* Irbaltry experierco reoiend by PNPS Inm irddaheddernenaton ad cracking Ismagnrg alled agictile Smrthos.ccrrponrt.f Fbge61d 77
* Irbaltry experierco reoiend by PNPS Inm irdd ahe ddernenaton ad cracking Ismagnrg alled agictile Smrthos. ccrrponrt.f Resonse NRIC PN PS Lead The cracking rlayred bin 0~ ea, reis stres so erorion c=king Jckson Wjlb Rrir.A Ron ddto tainless sis cladding TN. wasnot entered b*ad on BWRVtP-74, Kud was beaed oedreter iost
=
tools asd rndelwry oeraing espey*r*-
NUREG-101 alseo epifie cracking dea to SCC fan agiag eoffct for n tarless sled raeerial ntriies Ndte *ret om siws ech as Nozzle, Drain (N 11) which Is terdad carbon ateel heo l Is cracking otry other ta ackirg-tstfrs.
Fbge 61d 77
 
James Davis-AMR-Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 621 Number Status Request 474 Accepted 3.1.I-J-30 In LRATedo Il12-1, thecompowl Stabilizs Paers (utnd SVp~t, " StaliliZ. Fd$. envct skirt) Is bntJliSid as hFving waging affed di'kls d fnelaid" end the AW.
hawevlc. Inspection Cuea*i-Wht Is the I.erturies tha omas the aging fecd dices d nmtarial?
Plase describe to IFser.ce Inupection aor th Stablizer pesa: WldS Is" suawniauion treioery? Exasrriion reduire*dr? Exa*l*,tion
,alhtd? Acceptrce standt d?
Ate tine an/ currernly a.roved rdid requests aplicable for tri corror, i?
475 Closed ITLAH-01t The aplicand Ia reuesled to poosile the design coda. for the lirnposa, ortus down canerN**l header nd tor*.atachel Fona Nd SRW pling o, resiew


James Davis- AMR- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                      Page 621 Number Status    Request                                                    Response                                                                 NRC          PNPS Lead 474  Accepted    3.1.I-J-30                                                The entry Intable 3.1.2-I Is [or both the eupo1 skirt and the           Jacksono WIlb  Finrir; Ron stabilizer pd. The support aki was oervativdy conidered In LRATedo Il12-1, thecompowl Stabilizs Paers (utnd        eoqWiii to Ices d Martel as It rotwinis bdow 22D F. The SVp~t, " StaliliZ. Fd$. envct skirt) Is bntJliSidas        stabilizer pactswe located om he aides d te vessel, aNd ae hFving waging affed di'kls d fnelaid" end the AW .          tlpicaly gredat t c 2 0 F. Cosiastent with othe IRA hawevlc. Inspection                                        o0npontwsn. thee pd*hd           rd. be sbject IDloes d naleaialu The LRA will beclailied to InblcaS. tha- t Fnd rnaluid wery Cuea*i-                                                    applies only toh     wrWoralirt Wht Is theI.erturies tha omas the aging fecd dices          Th. re Ur. snratnerd       it ltthe IRA d nmtarial?
===Response===
The sitailizra p-d we Inspected nerAShE Section ) Table Plase describe to IFser.ce Inupection      thaor Stablizer    iWB-2-0.I catry B-K. The code (forotla 71o Tabie pesa: WldS Is" suawniauion treioery? Exasrriion            iWB1-926C-Icategoy B-K)alSws slace exanirelion frh nus reduire*dr? Exa*l*,tion ,alhtd? Acceptrce standt d?        amcesibe aide d the weld At PNPS the top side of the weldIs Ate tine an/ currernly a.roved rdid requests aplicable for  acesitle and PNPS par1rm. Imagnto partiole tmting d the lop tri corror, i?                                              ide d each brackS waid In ewry 10 year knteeSl PNPS neetshe cole rql"Iremutsl    rNd neredone   hano rdSid reoast lot wees Iupecllo,.
The entry Intable 3.1.2-I Is [or both the eupo1 skirt and the stabilizer pd. The support aki was oervativdy conidered eoqWiii to Ices d Martel as It rotwinis bdow 22D F. The stabilizer pacts we located om he aides d te vessel, aNd ae tlpicaly gred at c
475  Closed    ITLAH-01t                                                  II) The elsigr cold crethe ywdel     liner plate isASk Code.           HNoM  Dan    Cthn Larie Section IL The code Icludee Coda Case 1330.I and Cone Case The aplicand Ia reuesled to poosile the design coda. for    1177-5, and e laest eiltion as of June 9,1967. [RdFerdce the lirnposa, ortusdown canerN**l header nd                  Cicago Brklyand Frm (CBS&)donw nt 9-O04{ Fot the lca tor*.atachel Fona Nd SRW pling o, resiew                    shell, the deign ode ln AS       Code. Section Il. The cod.
t 0
Irledte Cole Case 1330-1 and Codl Case 1177-5.ad the Watet adiio as d June 9,1967. It was law walusledlD the           piralerus s OfASmE Section III DCllenoI with adudend through Smm             1977 and Code Case N-197 as pFrud the Mark1 Toru Prograrr IRdoe@noe Tdledne Ergireering Sevice (TES) d-omm1e TRA-cO-.1]
2 F. Cosiastent with othe IRA o0npontwsn. thee pd *hd rd. be sbject ID loes d naleaialu The LRA will beclailied to InblcaS. tha-t Fnd rnaluid wery applies only toh wrWor alirt Th. re Ur. snratnerd it ltthe IRA The sitailizra p-d we Inspected ner AShE Section ) Table iWB-2-0.I catry B-K. The code (forotla 71o Tabie iWB1-926C-I categoy B-K) alSws slace exanirelion frh n us amcesibe aide d the weld At PNPS the top side of the weldIs acesitle and PNPS par1rm. Imagnto partiole tmting d the lop ide d each brackS waid In ewry 10 year knteeSl PNPS neets he cole rql"Iremuts l
121The crigts daeignmode for the lorm. dtwrornartl he1dw ia ANSI 831.1. 1967 ellion Itwas IS.w weuted toe req Lruarts d ASM Section IIIDlsiel I with adfoat through Sumnmer1977 nd Code Cane N-197 as par d the Wlk I To7r. Proegam.
rNd neredone hano rdSid reoast lot wees Iupecllo,.
II) The elsigr cold cre the ywdel liner plate is ASk Code.
Section IL The code Icludee Coda Case 1330.I and Cone Case 1177-5, and e laest eiltion as of June 9,1967. [RdFerdce Cicago Brklyand Frm (CBS&) donw nt 9-O04{ Fot the lca shell, the deign ode ln AS Code. Section Il. The cod.
Irledte Cole Case 1330-1 and Codl Case 1177-5. ad the Watet adiio as d June 9,1967. It was law walusled lD the piralerus s Of ASmE Section III DCllenoI with adudend through Smm 1977 and Code Case N-197 as pFru d the Mark 1 Toru Prograrr IRdoe@noe Tdledne Ergireering Sevice (TES) d-omm1e TRA-cO-.1]
121 The crigts daeign mode for the lorm. dtwrornartl he1dw ia ANSI 831.1. 1967 ellion Itwas IS.w weuted toe req Lruarts d ASM Section III Dlsiel I with adfoat through Sumnmer 1977 nd Code Cane N-197 as par d the Wlk I To7r. Proegam.
(Reference TES dco e TR-5310-1.
(Reference TES dco e TR-5310-1.
[31The riidrnl deigm code for the twin aStached piping Ie ANSI B31.1. 1967 sdgo ituwas   aw Ma valuatedlthe    o   r*Aurument d ASE Section III. 1977 ed.lto withAdkerdn throulg Swnr               t977 as F d the Plak I T7r". FPranm Pipe aptM arstyeis was pedlcrwed In Saction Ill Suibsction NF [Rfderene T7S d.o~man TR-53I10-2.
[31 The riidrnl deigm code for the twin aStached piping Ie ANSI B31.1. 1967 sdgo ituwas aw a M
(4qThe crigitn design code 1w the SIV piping [e ANSI B31.1, 1967
valuated o lthe r*Aurument d ASE Section III. 1977 ed.lto withAdkerdn throulg Swnr t977 as F d the Plak I T7r". FPranm Pipe aptM arstyeis was pedlcrwed In Saction Ill Suibsction NF [Rfderene T7S d.o~man TR-53I10-2.
                                                                                                              .
(4q The crigitn design code 1w the SIV piping [e ANSI B31.1, 1967 diliorm NEwas laew auled o the first anchor Ira ew ftl to the r.*srumws d AStvE Sectiom III, 1977 eltion, with addowd through Sa 1977 as prt dethe tkt I Tcram Prorarm (Rde-erce TES d-ocamrt TR-530tS2-. The SRVW/L piping was anayzed ow high. dschnrge oflw as patd dthe Thirnu Power Oltirizasio0 (TPO) Progran So"e amne denigri cl NRC PNPS Lead Jacksono WIlb Finrir; Ron HNoM Dan Cthn Larie fPW,Ud 77
diliorm NEwaslaew    auled o the first anchor Ira ew   ftl       tothe r.*srumws d AStvE Sectiom III, 1977 eltion, with addowd through Sa         1977 as prt dethe tkt I Tcram Prorarm (Rde-erce TES d-ocamrt TR-530tS2-. The SRVW/Lpiping was anayzed owhigh. dschnrge oflwas patddthe Thirnu Power Oltirizasio0 (TPO) Progran So"e amne denigri cl fPW ,Ud77
 
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 63j Number Status Request


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                  Page 63j Number Status Request                                                Response                                                           NRC     PNPS Lead 478 Closed   TLAA-H-M                                             PNPS Pe tacked SRlVwac-Uo.r Irn I12 to26 A2oAI of 14               HowU Dan Chiw. Ieis acuutiom have been racordod on vave A,and 13 each onvalves 8, The slieant Is resqated so provide a alaen Indlcating   Cad D. Using e" 14actuatiom Inth slhirloen yee peroit ft "n ft slrrei   doi. =dMatrlrb of 60-year, 85V         rojosled scbtati- k, the rest of 60 years se 31 lifts. Th. -ater actuaiona ud   n the design faigus alyslste rrmanm valid Of lifts Ine first 21 years dipant life(1I72 -198I ) werenot ard woierveiva, based on the sct- SRV acb los         recorded These. lfts wearerea keaql In ft1 ealy years. so coued through0                                         PNPS eatilIded Iese 21 yeats sli lrine mhe     recorded te   This Vields12) lifts Inth. Kirst21 years Coartning e eardy peiodLt recorded pitl     and Omptroejcedperiod. ies mill bean estinmaed 165 lifts inOD years.
===Response===
PNPS plart speiofioaysils (Telyne Engineering Serices docmerl TR-5310-2) stalea Us IUse IlVperlratiorm areqaLified be 750 CycldeofnI-           load Ness onINs. the proojeced CUF fo0years Iecsloaleld a O.QM PA W       77
NRC PNPS Lead 478 Closed TLAA-H-M PNPS Pe tacked SRlVwac-Uo.r Irn I12 to26 A2oAI of 14 HowU Dan Chiw. Ieis acuutiom have been racordod on vave A, and 13 each onvalves 8, The slieant Is resqated so provide a alaen Indlcating Cad D. Using e" 14actuatiom Inth slhirloen yee peroit ft "n ft slrrei doi. =dM atrlrb of 60-year, 85V rojosled scbtati-k, the rest of 60 years se 31 lifts. Th. -ater actuaiona ud n the design faigus alyslste rrmanm valid Of lifts Ine first 21 years dipant life(1I72 -198I ) werenot ard woierveiva, based on the sct-SRV acb los recorded These. lfts wearerea keaql In ft1 ealy years. so coued through0 PNPS eatilIded Iese 21 yeats sli lrine mhe recorded te This Vields 12) lifts Inth. Kirst 21 years Coartning e eardy peiod Lt recorded pitl and Om ptroejced period. ies mill bean estinmaed 165 lifts inOD years.
PNPS plart speiofio aysils (Telyne Engineering Serices docmerl TR-5310-2) stalea Us IUse IlVperlratiorm areqaLified be 750 Cyclde ofnI-load Ness onINs. the proojeced CUF f o0years Ie csloaleld a O.QM PA W 77


James Davis - AMR -_Report tothe NRC.doc.pdf                         ..                                                                                                    Page 641 Number Status Request                                         Re*nase                                                                NRC      PNPS Lead 477 Closed TrLAI4H-.31                                     Teledyne Ernneering S-Avlces dteun               TR-5310-2 dcorsefts   Hoeng Dan Fin, lon ecrms elvaumioe frr the SRV pipi ng or veiow load crnrtnlione, Pless provide Fatigue Aalys is f te SRVedacherge    i dtee rol nIode, a lige       asnelysis (The faeigue enalysil of piping d Fatigue &Weysi  d oe Toe etachadpiping  the SRV piping along with all the         thform eachad piping) (TAP le bouet by WR-751, lIe GE itc I corsairmnw progeant WPR-751concluded &a for all plia- aendpipingeyslerne woeidered, Inall cases the fague         asgefactore henestoed for 40-ye pelarlile es less 1- 0.5. Ine worsl&#xfd;ceee ecew-ioh Wrtecdng plest life hoean adlU onal 20 yews woUd proeo Leapge befoar below0.75. Since this l less lien 10, dhe faligue creirea wesalied. The WR-751 genei c leligue rlys.. InisA protecled for Vheperiod of .lded       operatn In accornarce with 10 CFR5421(c)(I)(li).
James Davis - AMR -_Report tothe NRC.doc.pdf Page 641 Number Status Request 477 Closed TrLAI4H-.31 Pless provide Fatigue Aalys is f te SRVedacherge piping d Fatigue &Weysi d oe Toe etachad piping Re*nase NRC Teledyne Ernneering S-Avlces dteun TR-5310-2 dcorsefts Hoeng Dan ecrms elvaumioe frr the SRV pipi ng or veiow load crnrtnlione, i dtee rol nIode, a lige asnel ysis (The faeigue enalysil of the SRV piping along with all the th form eachad piping) (TAP le bouet by WR-751, lIe GE itc I corsairmnw progeant WPR-751 concluded &a for all plia-aend piping eyslerne woeidered, Inall cases the fague asge factore for henestoed 40-ye pelar lile es less 1-0.5. In e worsl&#xfd;ceee ecew-ioh Wrtecdng plest life hoe an adlU onal 20 yews woUd proeo Leapge befoar below 0.75. Since this l less lien 10, dhe faligue creirea we salied. The WR-751 genei c leligue rlys.. In isA protecled for Vhe period of.lded operatn In accornarce with 10 CFR5421(c)(I)(li).
APNPSjprit epecific ewlysis addreesee VheSRVriclhrge pipin and Its etcporn, as well as Vherain vee peneralion though whichVte SRVdschi'e erers .efarm, Ths arelnis slae VtatV SRVpenesralions we qualifled for 7500 cycles of ersxir load while IVe SRVe we epecled Inn$9 less thn50 cycles at
APNPSjprit epecific ewlysis addreesee Vhe SRVriclhrge pipin and Its etcporn, as well as Vhe rain vee peneralion though whichVte SRVdschi'e erers.e farm, Ths arelnis slae Vtat V SRVpenesralions we qualifled for 7500 cycles of ersxir load while IVe SRVe we epecled Inn $9 less thn 50 cycles at
                                                                                  -I     m Ised andmlessthen 4530 cycles a pertial load The repor orldtude           V.e 7WD cycles of frnxisu load bounds both di rSince
-I m Ised and mless then 4530 cycles a pertial load The repor orldtude rSince V.e 7WD cycles of frnxisu load bounds both di
                                                                                  .s by such e large ngin and imirermother signicantl kowds we Inproeid en . lir the peroration ws messued aeceptcUe herfatigus withui herthsr wleal ion - Increesing h 40 yey cycles by IS for the period of aitmdeId operation worid still beay 75 rresirrn load cyclesand 675Mlow old cycles he et0WCc050 rrxed load cycle, less V I- e 750D rnwirnsrr loa cycles perninted The fatigue ewlysisheltfor peerations tihus rewire valid IheV. period ofesledndl oestr             Inaocondlwe with ICCFR 64 21(c)(l)(i).
.s by such e large ngin and imire rmother signicantl kowds we Inproeid en. lir the peroration ws messued aeceptcUe her fatigus withui herthsr wleal ion - Increesing h 40 yey cycles by IS for the period of aitmdeId operation worid still be ay 75 rresirrn load cycles and 675M low old cycles he et0WC c050 rrxed load cycle, less V I-e 750D rnwirnsrr loa cycles perninted The fatigue ewlysis he ltfor peerations tihus rewire valid IheV. period of esledndl oestr Inaocondlwe with ICCFR 64 21 (c)(l)(i).
The PNPS         5l-r-specisaealysis (TR-5310-2)relerenw the g9o- GE lvk I Cortaneit pogr                   fo otheerlone aelached piping The results diV. ge-erio GE tMrk       I ooIaeir'nere progra (based wAI years of opeaion) wee that 92%of                 TAP wowd hoe cureastive usage actorns     d les t.             em at 100%
The PNPS 5l-r-specis aealysis (TR-5310-2) relerenw the g9o-GE lvk I Cortaneit pogr fo otheer lone aelached piping The results di V. ge-erio GE tMrk I
0.3.and woild boreesege faclos less "n 05 Cor.eaeively rultipiing V. CUF=br 1.5 shows that kGOrye              (icperar irs 57% d=h TAP wold harveCUFebdow 0.45 and 10D%would lee CUFe below 0.75. These lcultioons have itha been pr*jeced h-roodh th periodof etencled peralion in accordance with 10 CFR 54 21(c)(1)(ii).
ooIaeir'nere progra (based w AI years of opeaion) wee that 92% of TAP wowd hoe cureastive usage actorns d les t.
aW 64Bd77
0.3. and em at 100%
woild bore esege faclos less "n 05 Cor.eaeively rultipiing V. CUF=br 1.5 shows that kGOr ye (icperar irs 57% d=h TAP wold harve CUFebdow 0.45 and 10D% would lee CUFe below 0.75. These lcultioons have itha been pr*jeced h-roodh th period of etencled peralion in accordance with 10 CFR 54 21(c)(1)(ii).
PNPS Lead Fin, lon aW 64Bd 77


James Davis -AMR - Repor to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                   .Page                   651 Number Status Request                                                   Response                                                                NRC      PNPS Lead 4W   Closed Whte I.tte operairg halory ar buried pipeI teerar. ofthe   In the past 5years ter.e h. beearn      ileted exprerien with the        Davwls.Jw  Ky. Ted rtrtr   of Ir'paclons and mV leeks and ther c.,           Ispection f bWriedpiprig a PNPS. This wporierwe has acvcrred (Irnerred criWerru caased leesa)? Have y buried pip.       rrardy onhUe Oteewaler arergarard dastrtion systim. This been replaced do oecorroion oarcosing pratlern? I the     Systemn Isagevrinnaly 35 yeprs old and conists of oerrt lined phased ray UT technique I. setd h-wwill UV. qeliied       nelllle Ieron    plpe with trebarcd al joinrs. ThereshV.been no how willUto operators beqalline"?
James Davis -AMR - Repor to the NRC.doc.pdf  
hnd                                                  history of sigitiican leaks el        ttirn ther        two Irn*aaces, ore In 2001 and one Int205, In the first wet the rundargrouad
.Page 651 Number Status Request 4W Closed Whte I.tte operairg halory ar buried pipeI teerar. ofthe rtrtr of Ir'paclons and mV leeks and ther c.,
                                                                                                                                            "              ine dlown s*t-ew of U-L-22laled The prd&#xfd;edaeoausa of lailurewas tram likely induead by ninor fatbricaion aronrliaacxornrc ed by rrrdrJe Irnstaldion lach~ryars. When hds piping wea wacnined It was found toVe overall Invry good cornditrian terrfly escej for a sell araN safurfac corroaor sttrltvted to verrdne Irntallation teek ii.      In the second weertthe 8r mn grgaradpipe Ilaled In the ares of he N2teai wa4evnttothe EDO buaidrn Due b congestion and t presence OIhe ftr which was Irntalled cltyea          .ntheIrulallstiandUo pipin It        not iwaposas.e tb dgupfth plping to seenre            mitand dleriree the e        oedthe Mir.thibt rjW bordaeedlWUtrtalation dire terle inafldaeon to these two tmainw there hev been a rnwter of valves excavaed during nrirten-eric which ouad U. vtavea an piplng toWe In er'wkay good cordt Front ae eaddtioalt hislorval perspeclivm U. salt evice waste (SSW) eystev o PNPS Ve. ecperieed loks        hateha e aried trei (screaretra. loa.iliary bays) piping asea result oi ternal corrosivne The cripgral piping mnserial wee rubber lined carton Seadwrapled withrarinorced Itearlass wrapping and val tr searaed felt and howy Krafl paper. Th. loeks were dotervnined to be U. result of the degraded ratber liring beirg Incartect with see water. These pipes veealmes been replaced wilthr irned TilUrn wrapped with U. &eveeeaederne hogrg              so the original pip& Thi. pipe replacerweri Occarred in 199 anl 1997. In addition thU SSW buhed dischrge piping (also rdtter lired arbon sled with Werrlal pip. wrapplng same astral pipinr terar.U euiliary bay tothe dharge cord also eaperierced awae Irnernd rleione t t allare    la doUhe nrer lining Two4T      AYrbha of 22errer pipe. (are onse ch loop) werereplaced In 1999 as aresul of the failed          tr iing and interredorresion. Thees edos were reptaced withearlone sle cod        d    Ilreredly and "enleevy withrarreipy comting Th. piping Ot was rerned was
(Irnerred criWerru caased leesa)? Have y buried pip.
                                                                                        .arfined slier Its wraping was rsnoved and Its mtlred suriacea was berd WobV.      Ing*d vordtitn, Sinrce #a tiPe. U. enire length of btoh SSW braisd discharge Ivop hbes been lined Ireerrelly with c    iedrndaptcepip. linir*ng B Loop 1.2C,01and A" Loopin20C Th. pIhsed array Inspactiontschrvnq was provided wersty seen eianlo of5apotential fLriar earninstiron technrique fard olher retade thniqupees will potentally beadeo toasese U.        tendiaton of ieearlos portions of bried pipingwilhol the reed V.rexcavation.
been replaced do oecorroion oar cosing pratlern? I the phased ray UT technique I. setd h-wwill U V. qeliied hnd how willUto operators beqalline"?
This evceiaion was taken to allowe . potential waeddis techips or others In lieu of evcavatirg pipig in      crder o preoide a mtae ettlie seaarnr t of overari piping conditio while elinieing the plarteiat for darnagInrgUe pipng divng svavaiare Rage 65d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the N RC.doc.pdf .Page                                                                                                                              66, Number Status Request                                                  Response                                                            NRC        PNPS Lead Since a stiperir Irspectlon techriq Inarn yed "talble. specifics regrdning ,a*firf.kon dtfe proces Rd    "ecotviiare  we rot evaimse 494  Closed  FW linesher. InTalie 332-14-1 (LRApeges 33-134          The clrctladirg water eysterncosisfto primrify of two clrcUatirm    Wert Peter  toy Ted lrfough137) referenoe Tabole3.41i en3.41-8 and credt    water purr. Rd asmedSa.ed plpin and valves as shown pricrreily PWM Pro'aer twMnge Vh aging effect d LOM for sled        on Wtl. The reiew todelarrne te IOCFR 544(a)(2) piping. pipngconponwt. ad ping denerrnsexposed to       corrponeatslwed aspeces approach tel Idertified allcoponeri raw wafer. Planesidertify the specific orponerns Inotse  ypes and raleriet cocrtreiion Ind.e syslt    enel    waere:inscope Circmlaing Water Systert lv we represeted by twe        hi dd int Iii lirdvokuaicorfport rnbers As kJorified InLRA Table 2 line iems rd provide proceduem Under which      Table 223 14-B. the oclywems          tiathe e obikvd ng OW were PSM wilnbeirilewnele tonw            dhedrgingaffectof  siof dodwere die con.p.r        insde e reononsers arnd lee fnie.
===Response===
LOM cue togeoneral, pi41nngcyec*e MC. and Woingi                                      s only portions of the Intake iruuro    es were icdled were dt Iflake st-tclure typoclorife pup room and ctorireflon ares.
In the past 5years ter.e h.
The cowponrwts Intclded ifting. circutatingwafer ptmp casings.
beearn ileted exprerien with the Ispection f bWried piprig a PNPS. This wporierwe has acvcrred rrardy onhUe Otee waler arergarard dastrtion systim. This Systemn Is agevrinnaly 35 yeprs old and conists of oerrt lined nelllle Ieron plpe with trebarcd al joinrs. ThereshV.been no history of sigitiican leaks el ther ttirn two Irn*aaces, ore In 2001 and one Int205, In the first wet the " rundargrouad ine dlown s*t-ew of U-L-22 laled The prd&#xfd;edae oausa of lailure was tram likely induead by ninor fatbricaion aronrliaa cxornrc ed by rrrdrJe Irnstaldion lach~ryars. When hds piping wea wacnined It was found toVe overall Invry good cornditrian terrfly escej for a sell araN safurfac corroaor sttrltvted to verrdne Irntallation teek ii.
th aovoe grud pipngeruling Orr-mowire. the corenrer rlii otili Rd cross conect valve, a nps-io jokes Rd dte asociaedvnet dran and Imtrurnrt vaoe bociss. The water box scavergi~d systhr shown eo I 1ior iorW Inose, .Adthe pertlcon Rd still Iorm apreesure bortany for the water bores we Ircluded. As Iderkiirftedonl12 Sha the reeikual chlrine eaople puip tars longerwed] II portirn. d the systerrwere frcludRd thefstill boim leepressure bouachry.
In the second weert the 8r mn grgarad pipe Ilaled In the ares of he N2teai wa4evnt tothe EDO buaidrn Due b congestion and t presence O I he ftr which was Irntalled cltyea
AsIrdceaed In lAifaoret 3of LRPO-., Agng kI4nge*rrt Prograsr Evaltion Report (MAIER), proceues dorn mist fort I-epection ofdthe. rponerts. aRd aecorplie listing of awporarce thaR willbeinclucled inths proceirsm Is n wetiletl A sitafed InLRA Appedx BRd Cowierifol 21, prorapr acflivify Irrpmernirlng dotumre willbeeh*r-ced priololroe periodo mtwrded operation to lrcorporoe tee atiribues oftns Irspecdon desc'ibedinthe AMPER. Td wi*fassur d d deecls caginrg wllbef areagdhd eh R d Icasoie on-rporeis willco'irtielto pemiom ithiritndedol tndons cenrialfn with tcoirwe licensing hesls lor Re period d slarded opert ion fPW 66d 77
.nthe Irulallstian dUo pipin It iwa not posas.e tb dgupfth plping to seenre mitand dleriree the e oedthe Mir.thi bt rjW bordaeedlWU trtalation dire terle inafldaeon to these two tmainw there hev been a rnwter of valves excavaed during nrirten-eric which ouad U. vtavea an piplng toWe In er'wkay good cordt Front ae eaddtioalt hislorval perspeclivm U. salt evice waste (SSW) eystev o PNPS Ve. ecperieed loks hateha e aried trei (screaretra. loa.iliary bays) piping asea result oi ternal corrosivne The cripgral piping mnserial wee rubber lined carton Sead wrapled withrarinorced Itearlass wrapping and val tr searaed felt and howy Krafl paper. Th. loeks were dotervnined to be U. result of the degraded ratber liring beirg Incartect with see water. These pipes vee almes been replaced wilthr irned TilUrn wrapped with U. &evee eaederne hogrg so the original pip& Thi. pipe replacerweri Occarred in 199 anl 1997. In addition thU SSW buhed dischrge piping (also rdtter lired arbon sled with Werrlal pip. wrapplng same astral pipinr terar. U euiliary bay tothe dharge cord also eaperierced awae Irnernd rleione t la t allare do Uhe nrer lining Two4T AYrbha of 22errer pipe. (are onse ch loop) werereplaced In 1999 as aresul of the failed tr iing and interre dorresion. Thees edos were reptaced withearlone sle d
cod Ilreredly and "enleevy withrarreipy comting Th. piping Ot was rerned was
.arfined slier Its wraping was rsnoved and Its mtlred suriacea was berd WobV.
Ing*d vordtitn, Sinrce #a tiPe. U. enire length of btoh SSW braisd discharge Ivop hbes been lined Ireerrelly with c
iedrndaptce pip. linir*ng B Loop 1.2C,01 and A" Loop in20C Th. pIhsed array Inspaction tschrvnq was provided wersty seen eianlo of5 apotential fLriar earninstiron technrique fard olher retade thniqupees will potentally beadeo toasese U.
tendiaton of ieearlos portions of bried piping wilhol the reed V.r excavation.
This evceiaion was taken to allowe. potential wae ddis techips or others In lieu of evcavatirg pipig in crder o preoide a mtae ettlie seaarnr t of overari piping conditio while elinieing the plarteiat for darnag Inrg Ue pipng divng svavaiare Rage 65d 77 NRC PNPS Lead Davwls. Jw Ky. Ted


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                             Paae 67:1 I
James Davis - AMR - Report to the N RC.doc.pdf.Page 66, Number Status Request 494 Closed FW linesher. InTalie 332-14-1 (LRApeges 33-134 lrfough 137) referenoe Tabole 3.41i en3.41-8 and credt PWM Pro'aer tw Mnge Vh aging effect d LOM for sled piping. pipngconponwt. ad ping denerrns exposed to raw wafer. Planes idertify the specific orponerns Inotse Circmlaing Water Systert lv we represeted by twe Table 2 line iems rd provide proceduem Under which PSM wilnbeirilewnele tonw dhed rging affect of LOM cue togeoneral, pi41nng cyec*e MC. and Woingi
Number Status   Request                                                     Response                                                                NRC      PNPS Lead 495    Closed Fw. In. here, InTabe a3.2-14-1 (IRA p"33.134 mci            Scoreof th circationg walersystn piping In scipe tor                    W.r Plmer  Ivy.Ted 135). PNiPSclaim~edVW Cial infg Water Sys1er                  lWrimerte Fide iOCFR 50%1 (a)12)elcownwthe piidrg &
carrponws di piping ev teic. whchamenude cdplastic.         frelr~om doagrarr Is p~ipin code. 46 and JIF. Pipe cian. JE is loe noaging affect4 - wder. contoleolatio dreal "c rev      fiberglass reinforcedplastic. As Identlied in#*u PNPS waler Irimn.J envs Otem.                  no0 raelejal Whel kind ofpsic              Specification lot Pipin MOOD. piping code JF allows Pu we d we#"u.      " me .0    y a. .c+/-meottoeo agin".?              PVC piping ParNote 3onWI 1l. son,              f hepuiping1.PVC, The 55 gallon drkc .1-owron co12 Sha.d I wtich is ft .4tekintIn.A hentis also PVC.
Aging select.t wereidert-ifedlto. (a)(2) corripaonet Ircluded in AN"%iM30an1"gPueNcnCluis I Mxheicat t enntatmseodo 0.44ddi. and Wcohe.-cal Tools, RevisionZ EPRI. PaloAlto CA 10030I (The Mwhw-ical Tods). Inetooornoe. with ft Sctor Mo1-*.1Tool.            dAppardl A,PVCand of.
tI-mrPitlioe we .la!M1vdY"eflciwI bywateror Iseidity. The eoow.In questionrme Insistedl indoors and containrawowaler.
Thersior* baedm conth Mexlarical Tools        arndIrclostryoperetiog ftedymioa. Pe piping hte.,na ging aleffet regiring nurege-anex Inraw water or condnsteaitonerroiro-orri.
46 Cloued  P. lie AwnsInTable 332-14-1 witihnot. F(LRA peg              As Irdicaled Ikiltactcnm 3do LRPD-M2Aging ktaregensnre                  WONPete    Ivy,Tel 3 3.133). the aplicar6 proposed to manaege cracking mci      Progimn El upton Rapon (MoPER), Inupecticnewill beperforrmed clveorin materlialproperties of the sloolser for condaoner  to delernine Pu awfw*o crondiionmnd        flu.441Pyd Pu circrifaling wponsion (Ot exposed to re.. wate "c oovleealion In        waler mprpeoon foints. A. Irdicated Inrthe APER..a Or.tra1 environrtwin Ae~MIP        of Periodc S-11anlace mnd  representative euqopleci thu wpmrelon joints wilibeelarlty Prevreniv,.klirserace, (PSP& Pleano.provide fachical        Imupactedmndrnun~ey Aweadevemy5 years to verity nosinmicn justiication set wV PSPM.alone Iseriiclel to nunnage "u      arooking or.1 abe a      ornsfl~ifa whileflexing sloecornerca-el.s agingQellesof. crackirgngd changeIn. rnsterial Properties.                        mcdpysyical rrnunpdaamof A visual Insecretion,                              Peonporwi cih Orawls OWlPu sasoeel , is rot cracking arcS019 PueInceri properiias of flexibiliy ma still aereopele lor Pueaxpegion joinl to nulotein Ito preaue bamc1.rpendero allect ealey-reatoed OornponnerS Idtrylsl operating experimen loo cornorrmi.          ofpi.
lype he.asowIu        Puthrm1.y of    citupoolicor a1-oud    beadormee to torang.res agi.ng adoot..
497    ClcueI ThreelOneherne InTable332-14-1 (LRApeges 33.134.              Mt-i. thesecoonoIncrarlme nrwgod by Pu selectiveisaotir0              We, Pter  I"y,Ted 135, mnd  136). 1hueappicent proposed tonm.a" LOMo        Peerogalr Ito  Puternms! surface, Pu selecive he-c.ng progmrarIs coppe alloy >1S% Znlor pipinrQstrainer healing and vaive      rot credited with A. romuegaerleof lose      ol tnerualmlo, aslerrul body wpoeed      tooonderalio erlewlr Orwirorma Wing          ere1w. Ina me conl P.1."5 byoortlastion. I Puee convoeal.
Al to Systemn alolown. Pleese provide techical                werme to expeience selective heohn% Pueeging elloot willncac on jnelificalion as wtl Sysler Walkdown alt" Is enificiem to    Pndhe Identlied by ft SelectivetalcnrO Prolgra forPu lreral nanage Ptu goy aellt of LOM Do ycu cosider Puegson          u,rfooe Pul I. wospeel to -o vsl., Mdorem" sigriint seelective afect c loss cdrierial dme to selective leaching for Pue      leonding Is esperiencdoen Puxternal ft            sowlacePu Is weted conl linheitens.                                                  by periodic oorderealiwn The. nInetou        Inarinirrel mroral d sCecolrcyi Pu to proemieIn.a poeniwoc      cornlcruaic movirarnet, Theelrder PueSystonrr%ubdmon Progerarala" is anpeotwi to he en elepezle progrwerr the  Puetlerel seinee ol Owe caronpored PRi- 67d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                          Page 68 Number Status  Request                                                    Response                                                           NRC         PNPS Lead 498  Closed  Owen line here In Table 3.32-14-9 with roteO (Extraction    As can be seen Insection 4242 ci LRPO-. Aging Mwge.t                We. PaeA  Ivy, Ted Steanr System the ayllpOA prosced tIornw          &#xa2;rackiro  Program Evah-tion FRepo (AWFER).the wateroerristry LO and cracking-fatigse of rickld alloy lm exceanson (lm    conlrol-BT Pwogremrircludoe periodio noitoring and conrdol syosed toIraded waler wirngwaler ohlnrstry or/rol BWM      known ddrlrtrall eotnriarts such as cHioricke, dissolved and TLAAr"        lalig. Two lire ites relaed Ic TL*.      osyger. and sutl.e corcerratios below the leds known Io reit ner    betiguewill beharped Io Question 141-W-01fbe        In loss of material or crac*rg As idettified In Aachsrtr 2 ofthe clsoeasok, For. " othr 9hine hter, paes provide            APERea One-Tirre Inspectioe Progrrt will be ceylaed loverity lechrical Juetificationas wihyWaler Cheisitry Coerol BW1    Ve tectovenoaese  althe waler ch .istry ootrd-BWi progars lo alone Ie gullciern kt-nge the aging efects of crackirng    ferege lhe agh  n etffc of loss d neterial aed oraclkri and LOlA                                                    Therelore the wortrwiton itese two proganre Is suitert lo "nage the agrig alfectl o cracking ard lossf Irateirl Ior ricke alloy ooparels eosed tolereaed waler.
===Response===
TN. reirsse anavdrrso leth. oc*raltry proge desortiaOo In LtRAAglpecoas A and B to clerly Itnlcaae VW hesOe-Tire Inpertlon Progras willooortir the sftectiveecs dfth Wale Chresatry CorteS 8MI. Water Clrnialtry Corero - Acoillary Stale>. end th Waler Chervistry Coreod - Closed Coirng Waler TN.shter . clsed tosete      372.
NRC PNPS Lead Since a stiperir Irspectlon techriq Inarn yed "talble. specifics regrdning,a*firf.kon dtfe proces Rd "ecotviiare we rot evaimse The clrctladirg water eystern cosisfto primrify of two clrcUatirm Wert Peter toy Ted water purr.
499  Closed  rrA3214]                                                     eoeccordtea with AP 1A.13. proceUses willbeetherced                Pald. Erach lay, Ted (ee*3.      and 6)I0 seily thel the dielr      ne does n. ehbit In Tae 33.2-9. FikPrdection - Waler SystenmPNPS              igne d deg'adation wlie urerina csch    t -Wl  on, lbke ol.
Rd asmedSa.ed plpin and valves as shown pricrreily on Wtl.
credts ISA AP 111.13A. FireProlection Program lo            cooland(aeket waler), orexheral p leskasge Troul noinitoirig rwelge lose rnee1d aed WolingofVay Iron*aed c opper        rd reding 0 perornanrce data, epeciftially Jackao coding waler, ally >15% Zneal eacleoger shll and tlbe. Howeeer, he        oulang and elaosd    rsleria fIo.heIlre purlp dowedJackal waler hae Fire Protection proram c&#xfd;o*rplion does InotaackdethOe        eacrger willbe rlereifieded craced ttoalr the corresote ororrlers nor hbeethe proges beet enhenced leIolude        actin progran As described toopepring eperience Ior AlP Viese coapnerts                                              E1t1t.1, obewtalion, d0legreded perlorrrnece prorcked correcdive action> Including endnerelracerrerh in22        priorlo lossof Plese clariy how he FirProlection Prograe, witllmrerege      Iieldul nction Coreeely. cortcired              errrlerasion 01 he hese agng eafects nor these coMnonats.                    Fire Prosection Poarr yravd re"sed.eale esor            e eging dinect will be mreagdlo the deeadIra Pp jackal watle he achangor. Inadditin, PNPS performw lireprp Irereotion. leelrig aM trearearce Inacortacsne with NFPA25 whch would also deel hce preence 01agng effects In the jackal waler eyseleprior to hcest  i closded function.
The reiew todelarrne te IOCFR 544(a)(2) corrponeatslwed aspeces approach tel Idertified all coponeri ypes and raleriet cocrtreiion Ind.e syslt enel waere:inscope hi dd int Iii lirdvokuai corfport rnbers As kJorified In LRA Table 223 14-B. the oclywems tiathe e obikvd ng OW were siof dod were die con.p.r fnie.
ThNsIte- 1. closed lo fte" 37&
insde e reon onsers arnd lee only portions of the Intake iruuro s
Pw Ud 77
es were icdled were dt Iflake st-tclure typoclorife pup room and ctorireflon ares.
The cowponrwts Intclded ifting. circutating wafer ptmp casings.
th aovoe grud pipnge ruling Orr-mowire. the corenrer rlii otili Rd cross conect valve, a nps-io jokes Rd dte asociaed vnet dran and Imtrurnrt vaoe bociss. The water box scavergi~d systhr shown eo I 1 ior iorW In ose,.Ad the pertlcon Rd still Iorm apreesure bortany for the water bores we Ircluded. As Iderkiirfted onl12 Sha the reeikual chlrine eaople puip tars longer wed] II portirn. d the systerr were frcludRd thef still boim lee pressure bouachry.
As Irdceaed In lAifaoret 3of LRPO-., Agng kI4nge*rrt Prograsr Evaltion Report (MAIER), proceues dor n mist for t I-epection ofdthe. rponerts. aRd aecorplie listing of awporarce thaR willbeinclucled inths proceirsm Is n wetiletl A sitafed InLRA Appedx B Rd Cowierifol 21, prorapr acflivify Irrpmernirlng dotumre willbeeh*r-ced priololroe periodo mtwrded operation to lrcorporoe tee atiribues of tns Irspecdon desc'ibedinthe AMPER. Td wi*f assur d d de ecls caginrg wllbef areagdhd eh R
d Icasoie on-rporeis willco'irtiel to pemiom ithiritndedol tndons cenrialfn with tcoirwe licensing hesls lor Re period d slarded opert ion fPW 66d 77


James Davis -AMR -, Report tothe ,NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                             - -- Page 69 Number Status Request                                                     Response                                                                NRC        PNPS Lead S10  Cleod  [T23.I151                                                    At PNPS piping codes45. JF, JO ard HT we plastic or fiberglaes.         Pael. Erach  fry. Ted As ldttfied Into PNPS Specficatiion lor Piping          Q pispeclass Ilet. LRA. PNPS s Itdicaled &deg;NaNonrt UorAE.AW                JE i fiberglass reiriced plastic, piping code JF allows the we   s earrtnrtiar ineseral Ta.blea Inseclion 3. Uorplaslic          py*irnyl hmaide (PVC) plpri and clm HT piping Is PVC. Per aranwts Iarn a ea'vironsrwlt.                               rde 3 on X11, ears d she pipe code JOIs PVC.
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Paae 67:1 I
Please Ida-rl  whet Wi.s) d plastic arl,,id In fare) Leed    Scene epecifin earper-at/s areo        Identified asplastic Inth. LRA at PNPS.                                                       that e not IncludedInthe piping elmasrnwy sheds which rectired eoaonr-u speclfic reviews lIdenirty the material.       For imtace ears ernpqnrtse      setch a te let showon M2*12sehl I IsIdentiied onthe drawinig as a 5 glln PVC drum ae earn pipng like the piping onaM73 shed 3 Is WItied onthe drawing I ellainret.l polyiryl ehloride (CPVC).
Number Status Request 495 Closed Fw. In. here, InTabe a3.2-14-1 (IRA p"33.134 mci 135). PNiPS claim~ed VW Cial infg Water Sys1er carrponws di piping ev teic. whchame nude cd plastic.
The fWeonil yste- table 3 12-7 M-n ide-rilee a piastic fieter htusing teed arthe station blackod dead led el siterX-t7&
loe no aging affect wder. contoleolatio dreal "c rev waler Irimn.J envs 4
S These ae peastlc bowl.atthe    ttolt    dthe fitl.lSrteing tht edlled water and aedirnt The exent type d plastic [a            bmotkown led waseelected fore e bythe erigidre nwwactrer intis appdicatioan Inwdiina siwItalU        l theepatlimtegeriari deecnibed above ItiSar etpoed todirecteurCidt lad was designed lobe wed with fuedol. Therdore. as staed In the ESPRIMchteici Teods rnn of tehasearnpsrerl Isexpected lo eperienre aging dffectsthat redr. ncaeegoeren In th erwiroennls toswich they are eaposed 5ot  Acepted (r*1a6l1                                                    The only table IW did ot idently loss of merial Ia eaerneas              Pal. Erach Ivy,Ted Mtedbolting In an air-edoor enrirany-nl was Table3 3 2-7 leet In ears Table ? PNPS has eaed "Non-N'r" for                 led oiilsrystem Las of menr        Is an egng dfect reqpiring AtAMP etblindion lortn   etiriges Meedboiling Ins,             regerra      "n shoel- hto been Idea tiedfor t.e stairties sted
-Otem.
                              ,ir-a.d- "ironr*r       lvWe       InTable 3.32-5 wd i,                      bolting with an ewvireon      o air-okekooar. The aging affectIs 3.32-9. PNPS Idlrtiled losol cnrial     asi n eing ent     nrereged by the Sysm Wahkdnen Proragm esne nete'arenren sent loent ""'t"atir                                   d cralnied the eyelet walkdwn pgraen toU     "'age ths agieg affectd In The reire      aennt.rdnt      lothe WRA an erfdor gaorwrnrrt. stairisl*ees led rai'W* ced " be sescptible Uolossol aerial.
Whel kind ofpsic no0 raelejal we#"u.
.0 me y a..c+/-meot toeo agin ".?
46 Cloued P.
lie Awns InTable 332-14-1 witihnot. F(LRA peg 3 3.133). the aplicar6 proposed to manaege cracking mci clveorin materlial properties of the sloolser for condaoner wponsion (Ot exposed to re.. wate "c oovleealion In Or.tra1 environrtwin Ae~MIP of Periodc S-11anlace mnd Prevreniv,. klirserace, (PSP&
Pleano. provide fachical justiication set wV PSPM. alone Is eriiclel to nunnage "u agingQ ellesof.
crackirg ngd change In. rnsterial Properties.
 
===Response===
Score of th circationg waler systn piping In scipe tor lWrimerte Fide iOCFR 50%1 (a)12)elcown wthe piidrg &
frelr~om doagrarr Is p~ipin code. 46 and JIF. Pipe cian. JE is fiberglass reinforced plastic. As Identlied in#*u PNPS Specification lot Pipin MOOD. piping code JF allows Pu we d PVC piping ParNote 3onWI 1l. son, f hepuiping1. PVC, The 55 gallon drkc.1-owron co12 Sha.d I wtich is ft
.4 tekin tIn.A hent is also PVC.
Aging select.t were idert-ifedlto. (a)(2) corripaonet Ircluded in AN"%iM30 an1"g Pue NcnCluis I Mxheicat t enntatmseodo 0.44ddi. and Wcohe.-cal Tools, Revision Z EPRI. Palo Alto CA 10030I (The Mwhw-ical Tods). Inetooornoe. with ft Mo1-*.1Tool.
Sctor of.
dAppardl A, PVC and tI-mrPitlioe we.la!M1vdY "eflciwI by water or Iseidity. The eoow.In questionr me Insistedl indoors and contain rawo waler.
Thersior* baedm conth Mexlarical Tools arnd Irclostry operetiog ftedymioa. Pe piping hte.,n a ging aleffet regiring nurege-anex Inraw water or condnsteaiton erroiro-orri.
As Irdicaled I kiltactcnm 3do LRPD-M2 Aging ktaregensnre Progimn El upton Rapon (MoPER), Inupecticne will be perforrmed to delernine Pu awfw*o crondiion mnd flu.441Py d Pu circrifaling waler mprpeoon foints. A. Irdicated Inrthe APER..a representative euqople ci thu wpm relon joints wilibeelarlty Imupacted mnd rnun~ey Awead evemy 5 years to verity nosinmicn arooking or.1 a abe ornsfl~ifa whileflexing sloecorner ca-el.s A visual Insecretion, mcd pysyical rrnunpdaamof cih Peonporwi Orawls OWl Pu sasoeel, is rot cracking arcS 019 Pue Inceri properiias of flexibiliy ma still aereopele lor Pue axpegion joinl to nulotein Ito preaue bamc1.rp ende ro allect ealey-reatoed OornponnerS Idtrylsl operating experimen loo cornorrmi.
ofpi.
lype he.asow Iu Pu thrm1.y of citupoolicor a1-oud be adormee to torang.res agi.ng adoot..
Mt-i. these coonoIncrarlme nrwgod by Pu selective isaotir0 Peerogalr Ito Puternms! surface, Pu selecive he-c.ng progmrar Is rot credited with A. romuegaerle of lose ol tnerualm lo, aslerrul ere1w. Ina me conl P.1."5 by oortlastion. I Puee convoeal.
werme to expeience selective heohn% Pue eging elloot willncac on Pnd he Identlied by ft Selective talcnrO Prolgra for Pu lreral u,rfooe Pul I. wospeel to -o vsl., Mdore m" sigriint se elective leonding Is esperiencdoen ft Puxternal sowlace Pu Is weted conl by periodic oorderealiwn The.
nIne tou Inarinirrel mroral d sCecolrcyi Pu to proemie In.a poeniwoc cornlcruaic movirarnet, Theelrder Pue Systonrr %ubdmon Progerar ala" is anpeotwi to he en elepezle progrwerr the Puetlerel seinee ol Owe caronpored NRC PNPS Lead W.r Plmer Ivy. Ted WON Pete Ivy, Tel 497 ClcueI ThreelOneherne InTable332-14-1 (LRApeges 33.134.
135, mnd 136). 1hue appicent proposed tonm.a" LOMo coppe alloy >1S% Znlor pipinrQ strainer healing and vaive body wpoeed tooonderalio erlewlr Orwirorma Wing Al to Systemn alolown. Pleese provide techical jnelificalion as wtl Sysler Walkdown alt" Is enificiem to nanage Ptu goy aellt of LOM Do ycu cosider Puegson afect c loss cd rierial dme to selective leaching for Pue linhe itens.
We, Pter I"y, Ted PRi-67d 77
 
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 68 Number Status Request
 
===Response===
NRC PNPS Lead 498 Closed Owen line here In Table 3.32-14-9 with roteO (Extraction As can be seen In section 4242 ci LRPO-.
Aging Mwge.t We. PaeA Steanr System the ayllpOA prosced tIo rnw
&#xa2;rackiro Program Evah-tion FRepo (AWFER). the water oerristry LO and cracking-fatigse of rickld alloy lm exceanson (lm conlrol-BT Pwogremr ircludoe periodio noitoring and conrd ol syosed toIraded waler wirng waler ohlnrstry or/rol BWM known ddrlrtrall eotnriarts such as cHioricke, dissolved and TLAA r" lalig.
Two lire ites relaed Ic TL*.
osyger. and sutl.e corcerratios below the leds known Io reit ner betigue will beharped Io Question 141-W-01 fbe In loss of material or crac*rg As idettified In Aachsrtr 2 o fthe clsoeasok, For. " othr 9hine hter, paes provide APERe a One-Tirre Inspectioe Progrrt will be ceylaed lo verity lechrical Juetification as wihy Waler Cheisitry Coerol BW1 Ve tectovenoaese althe waler ch.istry ootrd-BWi progars lo alone Ie gullciern kt-nge the aging efects of crackirng ferege lhe agh n etffc of loss d neterial aed oraclkri and LOlA Therelore the wortrwiton itese two proganre Is suitert lo "nage the agrig alfectl o cracking ard loss f Irateirl Ior ricke alloy ooparels eosed tole reaed waler.
TN. reirss e anavdrrso leth. oc*raltry proge desortiaOo In LtRA Aglpecoas A and B to clerly Itnlcaae VW hes Oe-Tire Inpertlon Progras willooortir the sftectiveecs dfth Wale Chresatry CorteS 8MI. Water Clrnialtry Corero - Acoillary Stale>. end th Waler Chervistry Coreod - Closed Coirng Waler TN.shter. clsed tose te 372.
Ivy, Ted 499 Closed rrA3214]
eoeccordtea with AP 1A.13. proceUses willbeetherced (ee*3.
and 6) I0 seily thel the dielr ne does n. ehbit In Tae 33. 2-9. FikPrdection - Waler Systenm PNPS igne d deg'adation wlie urerina csch t -Wl on, lbke ol.
credts ISA AP 111.13A. FireProlection Program lo cooland (aeket waler), or exheral p leskasge Troul noinitoirig rwelge lose rnee1d aed Woling ofVay Iron*aed opper c
rd reding 0 perornanrce data, epeciftially Jackao coding waler, ally >15% Zneal eacleoger shll and tlbe.
Howeeer, he oulang and elaosd rsleria fIo.he Ilre purlp dowed Jackal waler hae Fire Protection proram c&#xfd;o*rplion does Inotaackde thOe eacrger willbe rlereified ed craced ttoalr the corresote ororrlers nor hbeethe proges beet enhenced leIolude actin progran As described toopepring eperience Ior AlP Viese coapnerts E1t1t.1, obewtalion, d0legreded perlorrrnece prorcked correcdive action> Including endnerelracerrerh in 22 priorlo loss of Plese clariy how he FirProlection Prograe, witllmrerege Iieldul nction Coreeely. cortcired errrlerasion 01 he hese agng eafects nor these coMnonats.
Fire Prosection Poarr yravd re"sed. eale esor e eging dinect will be mreagd lo the deead Ira Pp jackal watle he achangor. Inadditin, PNPS performw lireprp Irereotion. leelrig aM trearearce Inacortacsne with NFPA25 whch would also deel hc e preence 01 agng effects In the jackal waler eysele prior to hcest i closded function.
ThNs Ite-1. closed lo fte" 37&
Pald. Erach lay, Ted Pw Ud 77
 
James Davis -AMR -, Report tothe,NRC.doc.pdf
-- Page 69 Number Status Request S10 Cleod
[T23.I151 Ile t. LRA. PNPS s Itdicaled &deg;NaNonrt Uor AE.AW earrtnrtiar ineseral Ta.blea Inseclion
: 3. Uor plaslic aranwts Iarn a ea'vironsrwlt.
Please Ida-rl whet Wi.s) d plastic arl,,id In fare) Leed at PNPS.
5ot Acepted (r*1a6l1 In ears Table ? PNPS has eaed "Non-N'r" for AtAMP etblindion lortn etiriges Meed boiling Ins,
,ir-a.d- "ironr*r lvWe i, InTable 3.32-5 wd 3.32-9. PNPS Idlrtiled losol cnrial asi n eing ent loent esne nete'arenren sent  
""'t"atir d cralnied the eyelet walkdwn pgraen toU "'age ths agie g affectd In an erfdor gaorwrnrrt. stairisl*ees led rai'W*
ced be sescptible Uoloss ol aerial.
Pleae clarity this iserpsey.
Pleae clarity this iserpsey.
Fby 6d      77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                            Page 70 I Number Status  Request                                                        Rewonse                                                        NRC        PNPS Lead 6M  Closed    TA3.217                                                        The Scoe of Protgraot section d tl 1.3*- of the LRAsides city  Paid. Erach  lq. Ted water Its hkenIrrn the Townd Ptyodh water ronin aid dstried I. Table 33 2-14-2?, PNPS has cridled the litoe                  troghc    toe poltae and sartary wawer rysten altown water Cetsislty Controld Anillary Syons progeaIn o na            the presure City water Ismollored and traded by toe Town ol ng ectcl ldsodnaloral          ooiro,*orsca Into            Ptyrnoulhto n*d to rougia*ios oftoe Corwrnwnel* d f pdt&ie aid antary wawersysteon. Ho*oe, ft proram                Iassachuses.
===Response===
docrition a*d the scope d te prorac m orty addess stato ocling wale chenistry. The ority aeit    where potatoe      As etated Intoe "etectton ofkgig Etto ection ot , I.31 ot ard rhtary water Is rnoisticld Isinto fenli      cr            te LRA,vwification      thowwer rnoritto*g and treament bythe deteciconclsgerog  affet..                                    Town of Ptynou* Isallt*ctne will occur ndertho O-Tim hpectim Priogrart which enitl Irypictono to verity tho Plea Julity why potate aid s*ei lry water I-ns Identified      dtiveness of watew cherastry onroed prograe to wre tot Inthoeprowa doeclrirt*it and cope d work or qLWpl~            salgnicart doadtion laind occurring ad copont Inted tpengronrant iocnlc it                                          tcatrton Is lrroll d d*rirgto perWWd  oetenloew opwaelln Therdare ploale and eattry wowerIs ircludel In tho progra.
At PNPS piping codes 45. JF, JO ard HT we plastic or fiberglaes.
SM  Open-       aliton 4.3-1: kittfy wtichoilAo              w a:llty        Thil rWooe addresses Oueotion504 ard Ouceoton505              Maid", Jiw  Firnic, Aon Plant    gracsIiAMcR Tables 31.2-1. -Z ad -weredesigne            to tSection Ill. Claritywrochcoorspl.ealotnnio clly groulp recaived a. ASVtESection IIICUF caicUalion, aid Identity wtch omrnodlly grow llirg InLRA Table 43.-1 proides the agpicagte CUFred. I no CUF coneahIon was performed. justty S thesis for otoluion eMo p"crcoe an accetaile AWM'bow            to aginge0ffectcracking tatlgud In eoct*e with to criteri in 10 CFR 5421(c)(1)(iii). I anexcloein fron perlorning eCUF o.o&#xa2;uatico Is based mnanASME Section IIt,proide to paragrph In to Cod.
As ldttfied Into PNPS Specficatiion lor Piping Q pispe class JE i fiberglass reiriced plastic, piping code JF allows the we s
504  Cloedr  Oeotion 43-32 tLety whichocnponros InAMR Tablee                  Answerel InQuestion 53.                                        M ~ l, Ji    FinwucRon 3112-I1. -Z ad -3wee desirne Inaccorderce witht ASME B1.1 Code. Clarity whelhets -omoonrly          grows were esuadted horanaclabe estreo relsctio aoanets b aouwlonto. 7000        rst cyes tin roccerdnce with to)Ba1.? Code. Idotity whetsl*
py*irnyl hmaide (PVC) plpri and clm HT piping Is PVC. Per rde 3 on X11, ears d she pipe code JO Is PVC.
(1) to ealowale stress, redluci*c analysi reraire bounded unde IOCFR 5421(c)(t)(i).
Scene epecifin earper-at/s areo Identified asplastic Inth. LRA that e not Included Inthe piping elm asrnwy sheds which rectired eoaonr-u speclfic reviews lIdenirty the material.
(2) the eilowablestesl range needs to be reduced In acrortdnoe with toe etresareoction criteria Inthe Bt31.
For imtace ears ernpqnrtse setch a te let showon M2*12s ehl I Is Identiied onthe drawinig as a 5 glln PVC drum ae earn pipng like the piping onaM73 shed 3 Is WItied onthe drawing I ellainret.l polyiryl ehloride (CPVC).
Code loco,"Ty with IOCFR 5421(1)(t)ii)ce (3) t agong iedl "crackhig- fInigio' noot lobe sargod oe to peiod df Wended (EPO) opratio Inoecomdance with 10CFR5421(c)(t)(iii)and prtotee anaccplaltle AM' to rnonge the a*g effect Ftog104f77
The fWe onil yste-table 3 12-7 M-n ide-rilee a piastic fieter htusing teed arthe station blackod dead led el siter X-t7&
These ae peastlc bowl.atthe S
ttolt dthe fitl.lSr teing tht edlled water and aedirnt The exent type d plastic [a bmotkown led waseelected fore e bythe erigidre nwwactrer intis appdicatioan Inwdiina siwItalU l theepatlimtegeriari deecnibed above It iS ar etpoed todirecteurCidt lad was designed lobe wed with fued ol. Therdore. as staed In the ESPRI Mchteici Teods rnn of tehas earnpsrerl Is expected lo eperienre aging dffects that redr. ncaeegoeren In th erwiroennls tos wich they are eaposed The only table IW did ot idently loss of merial Ia eaerneas Mted bolting In an air-edoor enrirany-nl was Table3 3 2-7 lee t led oiilsrystem Las of menr Is an egng dfect reqpiring regerra "n shoel-hto been Idea tied for t.e stairties sted bolting with an ewvireon o air-okekooar. The aging affect Is nrereged by the Sysm Wahkdnen Proragm The reire aennt.rdnt lothe WRA NRC Pael. Erach Pal. Erach PNPS Lead fry. Ted Ivy, Ted Fby 6d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                 Page 71 I Number Status Request                                                     Response              NRC          PNPS Lead O505 Closed   Question 4.3-1. Fm,rwpipig oceonoewisftoom city              Answered lnOueslion SM  I. Jim  Finn. Ron gWo~. in LAA Tables 3,112.1.-Z and -3 th werenot de.ig-1 IoAS&C Soohon III oAltE B031.1 IdentifywNch de.7, code.applies to te particula connwity g90t and clarity whoete lft deign ool. requireda nsdl i lmto enslysis. Ia m"        ldiig &-"yiswa reSlirA sow w hat typeof motltibe Ocalculatonwas rectkedre  lobe pewlonowand discus how: (1) ft analysis narai,. bowdng t"i.' 10CFR 5421(c)(1)(1),(2) hes beeni projeclel loll. wpirati of ftO,EPO arl rernara aeoqatble pure ftod    110 CFRS.1ol)I,' (3) whthero en AM' readl lob. prpoe to enwge ft aling oflect of
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 70 I Number Status Request 6M Closed TA3.217 I. Table 33 2-14-2?, PNPS has cridled the litoe Cetsislty Control d Anillary Syons progeaIn o na the ng ectcl ldsodnaloral
                                *omreoog- W9Wo be fth EPO end stalewNeh AM' will be wLoalow"g, ". agi ogdect. Ifa meta Iltigmear-elysis was no perlarmal and oraclting talige need. tobe rawgsk thel EPO. proposean  aroo Ipeb. AWI.,' thel lwgnwmg        dctlea girgelsoet Inaewordancewith the criterion In 10 CFR 54 2t(O)(1)(liii 606  Open - Owetion 4 3-4 Forncn-p~ipg oorelwnrtal-m                dty                        Madolt. Jimn  Finrn, Ron Plant  gr~~ In LRA Table. 3,22-K. 13 2.X and 3A 2.5, klalify wbleh daeigi code anllie. ltottierpartier. co~nodry grw~i and clarify whether ft tloelgncode reqtidad a meotalIstige.
: iro, oo
enelYsi H1ametal lg.i7 a-Wyirsi moo tarack
*orsca Into pdt&ie aid antary wawer systeon. Ho*oe, ft proram docrition a*d the scope d te prorac m orty addess stato ocling wale chenistry. The ority aeit where potatoe ard rhtary water Is rnoisticld Isinto fenli cr detecicon clsgerog affet..
                                ._rnmrl.lz who          ci" ofp    aibige. cietietion wee r.:pdrw lb. aorw              ldw        bw (1) the =rle.i renerre Ewodr    'nor'w. tWCIOFR 542t~o)(t)(l)
Plea Julity why potate aid s*ei lry water I-ns Identified Inthoe prowa doeclrirt*it and cope d work or qLWp l~
(2) be. bowripFojleted loftw expirotion di ft EPO mld wiaceceptable
tpengronrant iocnlc it SM Open-aliton 4.3-1: kittfy wtichoilAo w a:llty Plant gracsI iAMcR Tables 31.2-1. -Z ad -weredesigne to tSection Ill. Claritywrochcoorspl.ealotnnio clly groulp recaived a. ASVtE Section III CUF caicUalion, aid Identity wtch omrnodlly grow llirg InLRA Table 43.-1 proides the agpicagte CUF red. I no CUF coneahIon was performed. justty S thesis for otoluion eMo p"crcoe an accetaile AWM' bow to aging e0ffect cracking tatlgud In eoct* e with to criteri in 10 CFR 5421(c)(1)(iii). I anexcloein fron perlorning eCUF o.o&#xa2;uatico Is based mnan ASME Section IIt, proide to paragrph In to Cod.
                                    -                  pWetri 1010 O1R5421(c)(1)(ii). ar (3) whether anAWt newds lobe propoed      wi lenwaga the aging allo~t d'eraeiong lege be09    fort EPO mldelate whichAl      will be wed 10newgs ft agirg elfeel.
504 Cloed r
Ieaci rntl    ligue anrlysie woo rot performed mld *cracking
Oeotion 43-32 tLety whichocnponros InAMR Tablee 3112-I1. -Z ad -3wee desirne Inaccorderce with t ASME B1.1 Code. Clarity whelhets -omoonrly grows were esuadted hor anaclabe estreo relsctio aoanets b aouwl onto. 7000 rst cyes tin roccerdnce with to) Ba1.? Code. Idotity whetsl*
                                .bigLW reachl lo be ear*gor    bhe EPO.proposean soce=ieAM' berlb ffwegwwte              of lb. agongeffect In ewrlrawthWe critorion in t0 CFR 54 2t(o)(t)(iii).
(1) to e alowale stress, redluci*c analysi reraire bounded unde IOCFR 5421(c)(t)(i).
PaW 77d 77
(2) the eilowable stesl range needs to be reduced In acrortdnoe with toe etresa reoction criteria Inthe Bt31.
Code loco,"Ty with IOCFR 5421(1)(t)ii)ce (3) t agong iedl "crackhig-fInigio' noot lobe sargod oe to peiod df Wended (EPO) opratio Inoecomdance with 10CFR5421(c)(t)(iii)and prtotee anaccplaltle AM' to rnonge the a*g effect Rewonse NRC The Scoe of Protgraot section d tl 1.3*-
of the LRA sides city Paid. Erach water Its hken Irrn the Townd Ptyodh water ronin aid dstried troghc toe poltae and sartary wawer rysten altown water presure City water Is mollored and traded by toe Town ol Ptyrnoulh to n*d to rougia*ios of toe Corwrnwnel* f d
Iassachuses.
As etated Intoe "etectton ofkgig Etto ection ot, I.31 ot te LRA, vwification tho wwer rnoritto*g and treament bythe Town of Ptynou* Isallt*ctne will occur nder tho O-Tim hpectim Priogrart which enitl Irypictono to verity tho dtiveness of watew cherastry onroed prograe to wre tot salgnicart doadtion lai nd occurring ad copont Inted tcatrton Is lrroll d d*rirg to perWWd oetenloew opwaelln Therdare ploale and eattry wower Is ircludel In tho progra.
Thil rWooe addresses Oueotion 504 ard Ouceoton 505 Maid", Jiw Answerel InQuestion 53.
M l,
~
Ji PNPS Lead lq. Ted Firnic, Aon Finwuc Ron Ftog 104f77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                 -.-. ..                          ..                          .. Page 72j Number Status Request                                                         Response                                                              NRC        PNPS Lead 507  Open -    C.llt a 43-5 h.e sWiiation stalesist welN. ra                  hItsaems          listo reactor vese Ianers werebuilt toft            Matoeh, Jiw  Fiwirt Roa NRC      mrroflory. the design olhe RPV Irsarel saponers IsIn          Irlet of AS Caotion Xlca          front the FSAR. GE made tits accordane with th itrieat o ASMESection [li. Plees.           atataret Issnry aat. FSARs barBWsof Pilgrssta vironp ClarifyIroa both a reialaory and tecntical poirt of viso whl Is srn by dealgred Inacooroance whiith. "irtord ASM          This stateri rsa. ahd the design d the reactor Irterals was Seclion Ill. Identifywhich Edition o ASMC Section IIIis        bettaer -rmaorvrcial grade q.aity. Miwials, watl fickrnss, Wing referred lowith respect tline design al  a. RPV        confrlction techsiques (including wtding) were what wousd haeo Iriaerls.                                                     been wed for atASCE sonyon-at However, arstyse, and testing weasnor pntorWrnl or docarwialed as rsrod for a oorrFoneln deielgned "Inacoarneo wath a.eAStE ooda As no specific code was adhered to. no specific osde year was specified however. emth        a rinerwasedeeiig    as pal othe plara dotgn Itcan beassrred the sa.e ide year (1965) was tad for gaeal g r-LRA Section 4112 willberevilsed to dades.the aaems Ihs the Iartrala as designed to th Ilent o the ASNE oode as loltlos:
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 71 I Number Status Request O505 Closed Question 4.3-1. Fm, rwpipig oceonoewisftoom city gWo~. in LAA Tables 3,112.1. -Z and -3 th werenot de.ig-1 IoAS&C Soohon III oAltE B031.1 Identify wNch de.7, code.applies to te particula connwity g90t and clarity whoete lft deign ool. required a nsdl i lmto enslysis. Ia m" ldiig
                                                                                                "43.1.2 Reactor Vassl Intersls A review of a. dign basis doouarw reveals ad the day frlarfls      ponsa Iforawhchthfeesa fatige areysisli          dreore shroud stablizer (Us rock). Ohereedt o a repair to strcturalty replace a aur/eretaalshroLd weld. scororudng a. we Thi astysis Is sTLAA Th. r-eis-us CUPFideotiaiedhora. shotd for 40 yeas of oealion Is 0.31 The CUF Is Included In Section 4t1.
&-"yiswa reSlirA sow w
The Falig*J tIrbioring Proga*w* enaures a latig*a raryses renran validby sorilOrirg the actual ntmbers o cycles ad evauaating tfen agirotathe design values frnurrtas afallowable cycle. Tisvtlirited agirg wly*as (atlgue aratyse) for a.e      core shronI statilizar will renvin vlid Ior a.eperiod a Wtarded operationInacordance with 10CFR 5421t(c)()(1) or the esffcts of sging onthi Intendedfunt-on(s) wittbeaacatatly mataged aora.
hat type of motlti be Ocalculaton was rectkedre lobe pewlonow and discus how: (1) ft analysis narai,. bowdng t"i.' 10CFR 5421(c)(1)(1), (2) hes beeni projeclel loll. wpirati of ftO, EPO arl rernara aeoqatble pure ftod 110 CFRS.1ol)I,' (3) whthero en AM' readl lob. prpoe to enwge ft aling oflect of
pariod ofextended opatlion inacoordauce with tO CFR 5421(c)(t)(iii).
*omreoog-W9Wo be fth EPO end stale wNeh AM' will be wLoa low"g, ". agi ogdect. Ifa meta Iltigmear-elysis was no perlarmal and oraclting talige need. tobe rawgs k thel EPO. proposean aroo Ipeb. AWI.,' thel lwgnwmg dctlea girgelsoet Inaewordance with the criterion In 10 CFR 54 2t(O)(1)(liii 606 Open -
Thasrecqtre anamrdrt            toth    RA.
Owetion 4 3-4 For ncn-p~ipg oorelwnrtal-m dty Plant gr~~
508  Open -  Csastion4 3-" The firsttill paragraph on pgo 4 3-2states      PNPS Ideaified no braccs rrsohari*s (flaw growth) analyss          th  doft, Jim  Pi.riri, Ron NRC        d fracture wharios ansalyses,  or flaw growth anwysas ase  wera TLAA.
In LRA Table. 3,22-K. 13 2.X and 3A 2.5, klalify wbleh daeigi code anllie. ltottierpartier. co~nodry grw~i and clarify whether ft tloelgn code reqtid ad a meotal Istige.
TLAMs lar PNPS tWhastyWs awebased an sra-tlirntld assmua lom Idrraty alt fracdae rnseclrics or flaw growth      The readet odthe t'NtS revew a these ratyse aw Nodal In salety assmaarsats at sed fw criteria tor TIJUsMin tO          Section 24 o PNPS docurre LRPD.C-. -Ustal Ainng Andys.es CFR 543 If ary sist, wri Section 4 0 f the WRA          No    -Mocl-ical FPaigue. Three law growth analyses were tound (the incude thesi as TLAAs ftr thewlaaioation and evalulte          CRD rnozle toad ca wad, a.the        Recto Recirciualion mtzle thes inaccorkance withtheaequira  rea s of 10 CFR              th-rmal Weaves, and Reactor Recirailadion nomzls NYF). Nonr a 5421(o)(l). itnlus wou0ht lctelo Irtorswtion tjoustity        thess artys-a wea TLAA sooetat=lity dl th racture stecharos or law growth anruyse. fly bactaurssactaos or flaw    igO-th anlysee tha rd theml TLAA criterawiallbeasluated by tle NRC's technical slall Inth. Diviaon Coponeornrt        rilty, CCios at Nucetar Reaclor Regulation
enelYsi H1a metal lg.i7 a-Wyirsi moo tarack
                                                                                                            &#xfd;p 72d ;7
._rnmrl.lz who ofp ci" aibige. cietietion wee r.:pdrw lb.
aorw ldw bw (1) the =rle.i renerre Ewodr
'nor' w. tWCIOFR 542t~o)(t)(l)
(2) be. bowri pFojleted loftw expirotion di ft EPO mld
-wiaceceptable pWetri 10 10 O1R5421(c)(1)(ii). ar (3) whether anAWt newds lobe propoed wi lenwaga the aging allo~t d'eraeiong lege be09 fort EPO mld elate which Al will be wed 10 newgs ft agirg elfeel.
Ie aci rntl ligue anrlysie woo rot performed mld *cracking
.bigLW reachl lo be ear*gor bhe EPO. propose an soce=ieAM' ber lb ffwegwwte of lb. agong effect In ewrlrawth We critorion in t0 CFR 54 2t(o)(t)(iii).


James Davis- AMR -Report to the NRC.doc.pdf .                                    .          .          .        .              .          .-                                                  Page_73 Number Status  Request                                                          Response                                                               NRC         PNPS Lead 5*  .ccead  I36.Z2.N-071                                                    Loss d mteriat dus to nhrowad        wear Is an fng efect Eom  atrain  Ng*ryau D.t  Strou4 Mko and suspension Itrdatrs it lhea we lejecl to siguificant In LRA Sectian 3622, you have stated            rnchytaoal          -rov    . Apossibtlecause [or iovenaralor"e Insulators Is aid war [- an aging efecot Elmeainard auspeelon I tralora            bowing the ogporitd Iarenieion caoLCtor, allowing "e Inltht VtWya. ruieto irnverarart.Weer hasEne        rbeen      oofcl      hewing frannBids b alie Althou V.s reotwinm Is to ayierat during rodin Inpecotio. IMl -nagod                for  prel**tt, Itnhdtry aqeryerce has saicoontraraniesion corottilo te period ol altaded opwalio, surace -utwould nrl                    ro randty swing and VW when Stay ft dA bia etoatantial onc
===Response===
                                  ..aa .a es l irl-drtd Ention aid ta, lardno a                winr, fay do noe cairt      to swing for very long orce    at wind has igntfioawnwa"n Provide a Elchi,;a justification d wl          ordadkd PNPS hos ntrantarl easioncotedoro ea lwi by lossodornmeial d.e b rnacotioi weer carnad by wird              Ngh-dlag trendatorsIn-ecope d licens renewal and I*tado blowing d supornd traacnsissonccrndctms Is ril an                loos of aeral dA so a  wehr fdhgh-otage Jnisatore Is na an aging etoed roqliring n*regfr*i      Em Egi-voltage              aging etfeot re.uiring"n              oarWe period of adleded tEm Inaultoros isa, provide atlechiod justificaion dowry            cparationt eulace rut woud rotcaao acooed irlendod fuiaon ard ier a alg7iticar c arcen    Emrthtp-ltage Iitla-ore if ltl      Varla airto*nre merialseah asnn da sadl and Inckstrinc warr gaid Eorme periodd  omisled operation                    deflneel can corcarniate Insulactor  suracs. The bildup Sf surfaeoatariralion tI gra*d ard In mot area washed away by rain, whlethe gaed and ool        Irsrdot" eaurtacs a PNPS aid" Incmaton      reaa valS PNPS acWind Slygw:d (RTV eliconm) eoelings to ema ewitchnardIniamor horeaims lastover. Surface wortaiiralion can bea pyodean In ama where Uwe ae greate connratdions S airborne pIhlidee sech ae noar facilities W deotaigoesod. PNPS Il nmolcaied near ayWcililiesW prodte aira-      panficld uh, as*iact. Themorl eurface criariatlcar Isrno arqpp fi*ttle afng rnach*nsen Ear Ngh-oltags tr*uatorn S PNPS.
Answered lnOueslion SM NRC PNPS Lead I.
LRASectioni36222 hto a"llpo Inthea      ruh p1agra.-o The paragraph shrM teed a Idlowa: "MEmhonicl wer is at alng diedmfor strainand soaeyaon nlsuators In              y arV aO  e        hiect b
Jim Finn. Ron Madolt. Jimn Finrn, Ron PaW 77 d 77
rio rt. Wea= tas nr been a -arent"ring rdina Irspections II If urrn-      for Ete    paiod d atdal operatioa, surlaco cortan'rrnalc world ro cause a "e of Ireandd fntion ad ihs. isrd4a.igriioart corat" T        aisra~reeaneanmidmilt lofhe LRA 510 Closed  13622-N-cal                                                      Snre ariolta airbornenraterials ech as    dut, et ad Irndusia          Nguyen, D.t  Srou4 Mkst efluetasa can catmniraale inuatorede acee. The bUiiop d Varios airborne nalerials sech as duAt and Industrial            surfare ortamiration I* gra&nSad In reoar              waet    away by effluent cn cortairaae Imtatmr ourfavcee.A large bUildep          rain,watethe ealed and coeed insalator surfaces alPNPS al"t d corcarnirstion anrf      the coandtor vodlg*a totrack        In oorarniraha removal. PNFPSaried Stygeid (RTVslicone) along We sutrace ae sseety and can End o insulator              coating hoionae ewinlctardinsdadors to reh ce tlaseter. Surface flash".        planwatrystac-oecerndraioia athadral              onrtariratlon can boa prcodm Inares whaie there awegreater toIet d and Industrial          i rul a aignriicalo agirfg diect          onceaciona d alirborre prtidee ecah e ner faciliies OW reqiuing iragaraent Em flr-ovdage Irailm*s at PNPS.              dschaga aooE. PNPS i. M locealed rer any faclilies that prodce airbone partcleo sch as "oicor som. Thedafe. surface eoacarirnsliontarot ancjptlicale afg    ingtrersin Emr hgh&#xfd;-vdtage Ibnsateors l FaIPS FbWf3d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                         -- Page 741 Number Status   Request                                                     Response                                                                   NRC           PNPS Lead SlI   Cl..d   [36 22.N-09]                                                 Apolenleal irelenim contriuting toaeing d switchyard buI                   Ngey, Duc       Stroud. Mks ooreetione Isoursaelemeiddier, wNch can lend to Irnreased Frovide a lechtcr juelifutir ion d wly Inrerased raieletace  wriact ar er       orbrresislance Connectbon   e     lsace ceidaion Is d swhhyard buee onre            clue to ibaion Is red n      n signiflea Ifmwitchyadbus ennectiorbe at PNPS sine 6t aging elect reiuirinrg rgwrwt                                wilelryard bes ooeectione arewdded Therdo mraginegdecls due Iboeuace rrmidide e areirted lobe reeg               lod the period d a rled epenrmse ThI. acevrclsneebebite    devicles Iryld             eedl 6.
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 72j Number Status Request 507 Open -
Maintene Ruleprngra.           In edrtion, memograpqiIs perlormed at local "aOweaye monethaboirrr            n the Iregrity d the eeerlctilon. TH. progar will eire           Intothe period dselearded eOlatio 6:2  A  e.yd  131.11-13)                                                    A. staled In PNPS AAPM-33, erackirngclue blaew rowh Is                   Jacksorn Wilbur Fled; Ron reeged bythe Irepaeeon repkmrewnel Is$orClassI oenreri In LRA Taele 31.1, herr Number 48, b aplicable fr Clao I          cesrdamee wIthASME Secoin XI, Subsection IWB Becauee iing fling. ard blrnch Iir- <NPS e xposed b reelo          lreervlcelmpeten per ASCE Selieon XI Is required inrodaceree coolart The GALLRepo Ireicates tat the agig effects d          withlOCFR 5055a, eacling due bn law grovldhIs n Identified en cracking due toth"re! and rreharcal lcedrg apply Ior        he Wese In itacihrrrt 1.VCrocking du bnlew growth I.
C.llt a 43-5 h.e sWiiation stales ist welN. ra NRC mrroflory. the design olhe RPV Irsarel saponers IsIn accordane with th itrieat o ASME Section [li. Plees.
bath earbo eel arnd      ld nies. .led o1erryreed            esledored equialen thoe NUREG-1801 wiry 6 cracking due ID Hewveer, nClass I pling OcenTerets nreds dI ebr              threwi and rechrecal loading The ISI Proegar aplie ty Class seel weroled uplto tr i line Item                            I cambe sled plipng eomrcnrnaf adPNPS PlIses.      aln why m carbon sled  elpng eonprerts ae      The IRA willbe clarified tosh        tOWcracking Is an aing dffed rdled up ho  tis line At. ltre no Class I carte sled        requiring Inegerert Is Class I crbn sled ppirng piping eoerpo*rats <NPS4SlPNPS? I her. meClarse              oNPS C4a PNPS and OWthe approprrae aging neregere eaten sled piping emirer*re          NNPS4 aNPN      then    prograrr Include the IS! Proegra and he Ore-Tiree hrepeconi PIesse )ustifywhy they mte enrdled tpk0ine ilee V1.1-8.      Prograer The decuresin**olurn l       orIstew 3.1.1-.4 willbereviled yo beconsilstent with tni chn.g The crediedaging mreagerert Porolrr will be he sane as those listed or tIe NUREG-1801 line h-er. eeresporldng SoIRA Table 31.11. Hew48 Tisreuires enamendrnet inthe LRA 513  Accepted As s Idlow-up roqueslion T321-35.P-01 (ite 442) we 6        Th. Pierioi SJ,eiTlole and Prevent.ve irlleeo                 (PSPI4       Paviret Wayne,   Ivy,Ted Ite line iter. O1WIell. upb Iter 3.2I-W onty credits te      Program Is mrer apprtpriate 1o   inrage     l     sd mwl Iospiping C wrenmeN      Leok Rate prograewor letragng th ging        eed valve body Ins raawwatler        el eirsrn*rl InTabls 322-7.
Clarify Iroa both a reialaory and tecntical poirt of viso whl Is srn by dealgred Inacooroance whiith. "irtord ASM Seclion Ill. Identify which Edition o ASMC Section III is Wing referred lowith respect tline design al a. RPV Iriaerls.
effect d be. d6nterial. In acsowdence witoGALL XI.S4 hes proser by itself d-I ct derl Mt5aging dogedelti*n leo intiared. Plearsexplan how the use 66.                  Th. IRA will bierevied lo *eril ies prearn Inrtead6t Certeirenre Look Rate progasr I[ acceptable by led) Io      Coertantrel Ledk Rale Progrr minarge to          the sgng effect d6 eo
508 Open -
_"g. aging de"cts                                        d rMeeial inharelhet, the disussionIn lem 321-35 Taile 321 willbe reisled Ibrad as                 "Tle h.: PTh.
Csastion 4 3-" The first till paragraph on pgo 4 3-2 states NRC d fracture wharios ansalyses, or flaw growth anwysas ase TLAMs lar PNPS tWh astyWs awe based an sra-tlirntld assmua lom Idrraty alt fracdae rnseclrics or flaw growth salety assmaarsats at sed fw criteria tor TIJUsM in tO CFR 543 If ary sist, wri Section 4 0 f the WRA No incude thesi as TLAAs ftr thewlaaioation and evalulte thes inaccorkance withthe aequira rea s of 10 CFR 5421(o)(l). itnlus wou0ht lctelo Irtorswtion tjoustity sooetat=lity dl th racture stecharos or law growth anruyse. fly bactaurs sactaos or flaw igO-th anlysee tha rd theml TLAA criterawiallbeasluated by tle NRC's technical slall Inth. Diviaon Coponeornrt rilty, CCios at Nucetar Reaclor Regulation
pe       Sveillarce sule ad Fr-ive keiirtenrece Proeya.n reneg the less dlerial           m Ior stedeornpnrtes exposed a         o raw wat.-
 
TNP repires anamenerri         1othe IRAto rteise Table 322-7.
===Response===
NRC PNPS Lead hItsaems listo reactor vese Ianers werebuilt toft Matoeh, Jiw Fiwirt Roa Irlet of AS C aotion Xl ca front th e FSAR. GE made tits atataret Issnry aat. FSARs bar BWsof Pilgrssta vironp This stateri rsa. ahd the design d the reactor Irterals was bettaer -rm aorvrcial grade q.aity. Miwials, watl fickrnss, confrlction techsiques (including wtding) were what wousd haeo been wed for atASCE sonyon-at However, arstyse, and testing weasnor pntorWrnl or docarwialed as rsrod for a oorrFoneln deielgned "In acoarneo wath a.e AStE ooda As no specific code was adhered to. no specific osde year was specified however. em th a riner wasedeeiig as pal othe plara dotgn It can beassrred the sa.e ide year (1965) was tad for gaeal g r-LRA Section 4112 willberevilsed to dades. the aaems Ihs the Iartrala as designed to th Ilent o the ASNE oode as loltlos:
"43.1.2 Reactor Vassl Intersls A review of a. dign basis doouarw reveals ad the day frlarfls ponsa Iforawhchthfe esa fatige areysisli dreore shroud stablizer (Us rock). Ohe reedt o a repair to strcturalty replace a aur/eretaal shroLd weld. scororudng a. we Thi astysis Is sTLAA Th. r-eis-us CUPFideotiaied hor a. shotd for 40 yeas of oealion Is 0.31 The CUF Is Included In Section 4t1.
The Falig*J tIrbioring Proga*w* enaures a latig*a raryses renran valid by sorilOrirg the actual ntmbers o cycles ad evauaating tfen agirota the design values fr nurrtas af allowable cycle. Tisvtlirited agirg wly*as (atlgue aratyse) for a.e core shronI statilizar will renvin vlid Ior a.e period a Wtarded operation Inacordance with 10CFR 5421t(c)()(1) or the esffcts of sging onthi Intended funt-on(s) wittbeaacatatly mataged aor a.
pariod of extended opatlion inacoordauce with tO CFR 5421(c)(t)(iii).
Thasrecqtre anamrdrt toth RA.
PNPS Ideaified no braccs rrsohari*s (flaw growth) analyss th doft, Jim Pi.riri, Ron wera TLAA.
The readet od the t'NtS revew a these ratyse aw Nodal In Section 24 o PNPS docurre LRPD.C-. -Ustal Ainng Andys.es
-Mocl-ical FPaigue. Three law growth analyses were tound (the CRD rnozle toad ca wad, a.the Recto Recirciualion mtzle th-rmal Weaves, and Reactor Recirailadion nomzls NYF). Nonr a thess artys-a wea TLAA
&#xfd;p 72d ;7
 
James Davis-AMR -Report to the NRC.doc.pdf.
Page_73 Number Status Request 5*
.ccead I36.Z2.N-071 In LRA Sectian 3622, you have stated rnchytaoal war [- an aging efecot Elm eainard auspeelon I tralora Inltht VtWy a. ruieto irnverarart. Weer hasEne rbeen ayierat during rodin Inpecotio.
I Ml
-nagod for te period ol altaded opwalio, surace -ut would nrl
..aa.a es l irl-drtd Ention aid ta, lardno a igntfioawn wa"n Provide a Elchi,;a justification d wl lossod ornmeial d.e b rnacotioi weer carnad by wird blowing d supornd traacnsissonccrndctms Is ril an aging etoed roqliring n*regfr*i Em Egi-voltage Inaultoros isa, provide atlechiod justificaion dowry eulace rut woud rot caao a cooed irlendod fuiaon ard ier a alg7iticar c arcen Emr thtp-ltage Iitla-ore if ltl warr gaid Eorm e periodd omisled operation
 
===Response===
Loss d mteriat dus to nhrowad wear Is an fng efect Eom atrain and suspension Itrdatrs it lhea we lejecl to siguificant
-rov Apossibtle cause [or iovenaral or"e Insulators Is aid bowing the ogporitd Iarenieion caoLCtor, allowing "e oofcl to hewing frann Bids b alie Althou V.s reotwinm Is prel**tt, Itnhdtry aqeryerce has saicoon traraniesion corottilo onc ro randty swing and VW when Stay ft dA bia etoatantial winr, fay do noe cairt to swing for very long orce at wind has ordadkd PNPS hos ntrantarl easion cotedoro ea lwi by Ngh-dlag trendators In-ecope d licens renewal and I*tado loos of aeral dA so weh r a
fd hgh-otage Jnisatore Is na an aging etfeot re.uiring "n oar t Em We period of adleded cparationt Varla airto*nre merials eah asnn da sadl and Inckstrinc deflneel can corcarniate Insulactor suracs. The bildup Sf surfae oatariralion tI gra*d ard In mot area washed away by rain, whlethe gaed and ool Irsrdot" eaurtacs a PNPS aid" Incmaton reaa valS PNPS acWind Slygw:d (RTV eliconm) eoelings to ema ewitchnard Iniamor ho reaims lastover. Surface wortaiiralion can bea pyodean In ama where Uwe ae greate connratdions S airborne pIhlidee sech ae noar facilities W deotaigo esod. PNPS Il nmolcaied near ay Wcililies W prodte aira-panficld uh, as*iact. Themorl eurface criariatlcar Is rno arqpp fi*ttle afng rnach*nsen Ear Ngh-oltags tr*uatorn S PNPS.
LRASectioni36222 hto a"llpo Inthea ruh p1agra.-o The paragraph shrM teed a Idlowa: "MEmhonicl wer is at alng diedm for strainand soaeyaon nlsuators In aO y
arV e
hiect b
rio rt. Wea= tas nr been a
-arent "ring rdina Irspections II If urrn-for Ete paiod d atdal operatioa, surlaco cortan'rrnalc world ro cause a "e of Ireandd fntion ad ihs. is rd 4a.igriioart corat" T
aisra~reeaneanmidmilt lofhe LRA Snre ariolta airborne nraterials ech as dut, et ad Irndusia efluetasa can catmniraale inuatorede acee. The bUiiop d surfare ortamiration I* gra&nS ad In reo w
ar aet away by rain, watethe ealed and coeed insalator surfaces al PNPS al"t In oorarniraha removal. PNFPS aried Stygeid (RTVslicone) coating hoionae ewinlctardinsdadors to reh ce tlaseter. Surface onrtariratlon can boa prcodm Inares whaie there awe greater onceaciona d alirborre prtidee ecah e ner faciliies OW dschaga aooE. PNPS i. M locealed rer any faclilies that prodce airbone partcleo sch as "oic or som. Thedafe. surface eoacarirnslion tarot ancjptlicale afg ingtrersin Emr hgh&#xfd;-vdtage Ibnsateors l FaIPS NRC Ng*ryau D.t PNPS Lead Strou4 Mko 510 Closed 13622-N-cal Varios airborne nalerials sech as duAt and Industrial effluent cn cortairaae Imtatmr ourfavcee. A large bUildep d corcarnirstion anrf the coandtor vodlg*a totrack along We sutrace ae sseety and can End o insulator flash".
planwatrystac-oecerndraioia athadral and Industrial to Iet d i rul a aignriicalo agirfg diect reqiuing iragaraent Em flr-ovdage Irailm*s at PNPS.
Nguyen, D.t Srou4 Mkst FbW f3d 77
 
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 741 Number Status Request SlI Cl..d
[36 22.N-09]
Frovide a lechtcr juelifutir ion d wly Inrerased raieletace d swhhyard bue e onre clue to ibaion Is red n aging elect reiuirinrg rgwrwt 6:2 A
e.yd 131.11-13)
LRA Taele 31.1, herr Number 48, b aplicable fr Clao I iing fling. ard blrnch Iir- <NPS e xposed b reelo coolart The GALL Repo Ireicates tat the agig effects d cracking due toth"re!
and rreharcal lcedrg apply Ior bath earbo eel ld arnd nies. led o1erryreed Hewveer, nClass I pling OcenTerets nreds dI ebr seel weroled uplto tr i line Item PlIse
: s.
aln why m carbon sled elpng eonprerts ae rdled up ho tis line At. ltre no Class I carte sled piping eoerpo*rats <NPS4SlPNPS? I her. me Clarse eaten sled piping emirer*re NNPS 4 aNPN then PIesse )ustify why they mte en rdled tpk 0ine ilee V1.1-8.
513 Accepted As s Idlow-up roqueslion T321-35.P-01 (ite 442) we 6 Ite line iter. O1W Iell. upb Iter 3.2I-W onty credits te C
wrenmeN Leok Rate prograe wor letragng th ging effect d be. d6nterial. In acsowdence wito GALL XI.S4 hes proser by itself d-I ct derl Mt5 aging dogedelti*n leo intiared. Plearsexplan how the use 66.
Certeirenre Look Rate progasr I[ acceptable by led) Io
_"g. aging de"cts
 
===Response===
NRC PNPS Lead Apolenleal irelenim contriuting toaeing d switchyard buI Ngey, Duc Stroud. Mks ooreetione Is oursaele meiddier, wNch can lend to Irnreased wriact ar er orbr resislance Connectbon e
lsace ceidaion Is n signiflea Ifmwitchyadbus ennectiorbe at PNPS sine 6t wilelryard bes ooeectione arewdded Therdo mragineg decls due Iboeuace rrmidide e areirted lobe reeg lod the period d a rled epenrmse ThI. acevrclsneebe bite devicles Iryld eedl 6.
Maintene Ruleprngra.
In edrtion, memograpqi Is perlormed at local "aO weaye monetha bo irrr n the Iregrity d the eeerlctilon. TH. progar will eire Intothe period dselearded eOlatio A. staled In PNPS AAPM-33, erackirng clue blaew rowh Is Jacksorn Wilbur Fled; Ron reeged bythe Irepaeeon repkmrewnel Is$orClass I oenreri In cesrdamee wIthASME Secoin XI, Subsection IWB Becauee lreervlcelmpeten per ASCE Selieon XI Is required in rodaceree withlOCFR 5055a, eacling due bn law grovldh Is n Identified en he Wese In itacihrrrt 1.V Crocking du bnlew growth I.
esledored equialen thoe NUREG-1801 wiry 6 cracking due ID threwi and rechrecal loading The ISI Proegar aplie ty Class I cambe sled plipng eomrcnrnaf ad PNPS The IRA will be clarified to sh tOW cracking Is an aing dffed requiring Inegerert Is Class I crbn sled ppirng oNPS C4a PNPS and OW the approprrae aging neregere prograrr Include the IS! Proegra and he Ore-Tiree hrepeconi Prograer The decuresin**olurn l
or Istew 3.1.1-.4 willbereviled yo beconsilstent with tni chn.g The crediedaging mreagerert Porolrr will be he sane as those listed or tIe NUREG-1801 line h-er. eeresporldng So IRA Table 31.11. Hew 48 Tisreuires enamendrnet inthe LRA Th. Pierioi SJ,eiTlole and Prevent.ve irlleeo (PSPI4 Paviret Wayne, Ivy, Ted Program Is mrer apprtpriate 1o inrage l
sd mwl Ios piping eed valve body Ins raaw watler el eirsrn*rl InTabls 322-7.
Th. IRA will bierevied lo *eril ies prearn Inrtead 6t Coertantrel Ledk Rale Progrr to minarge the sgng effect d6 eo d rMeeial inharelhet, the disussionIn lem 321-35 Taile 321 willbe reisled Ibrad as "Tle h.: PTh.
pe sule Sveillarce ad Fr-ive keiirtenrece Proeya.n reneg the less m
dlerial Ior sted eornpnrtes exposed a
o raw wat.-
TNP repires anamenerri 1othe IRAto rteise Table 322-7.
321 ands*Apepxd B Pjge 74d 77
321 ands*Apepxd B Pjge 74d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                       Page 75 Number Status Request                                               Resonse                                                            NRC          PNPS Lead 514 Accepted 1j1.1-MI                                               Tthun OIwapplication, It. OCr-Tke Inspection (OTt) Program        JactwMo Wlsrb  FinreS Ron hwabusn Irealed as a aqipportprWm    sor      the waem cter$isley LRATabl. ems .1.-14. t1.1-15 aid31.1-47 allincllde     pr aran foitnhew  ptrpes d verifying water chemistry progein dclnsiem Isying hat aging d Iht sonapnens rduing WP   effectivereas. The O-Tlme Inspection Progam has io bean o hose laneswill beby Water Chwaistly auyreaed by th treated w an agin        gumal prograsi dcsrtly applcbe the Ons Tine I-spectien Prong'm A"athri ad LPROD-C.       eystyne Ithat redl water cheisry toearng niraageaut ThN Revision Cn providea a list d AMtA. affected by the   treaatii was comisidard appriprale since the verilication S waer OCrn-Tee Inpection Actvitias. Howeve, Atachmen 2     chereistey progran alectivrness willbea" Iretgrated task OWa does Z Incluet A.aMM-1 (Remclor Prassues Vessel) w   silieaedfecliveness d. Oe proasm toeall systers ths crWa waler AMM-32 (Rasole Vessel flmeis) Inthe listadafected    chertrfy Ift waler Oteistry preogad"aslvera$ willnoi be AMRFIA.                                              wilied aserately fom wnh ayater For th cases wthr IVe COe-Tine Irspectin Progras airtbsses oiponot specific Please priwida anexlanat en d wty AM I-31and          Inpectylin, thi. listed In the IRA asiae agng rnurergsrl AMPtM-2 mand Included InAltantsile 2d LtRPD-O.        poanm dretly applicale toID as     omponenas Revision M New wwitPNPS -ra UIMappropriate m-Urnse kiptoone aroperutned for toe RPV aid WIA      The testrowd Atactoir 23d LRPO-02 dm.tifie. t' activities d cofpiones where such Itepwtione we craeled for Adng    ft On-Tirna Irspection Program Pl willverity waler chenisliry kMrbgmawl duie th parnrll dWlarded operation?        prograi effectivnass lot all systemr O credt water chenistry.
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 75 Number Status Request 514 Accepted 1j1.1-MI LRATabl.
TNs line applies to the walm chwristry prOgrer. Incluinrg Vwle Cheriasty Contrlr -SMt. wtch Inturn appies toireli dthe system Uistsdinthl.agpicaI*m       Th" rercmr praesse vassel and rec1te vassal Irert$s comepoeess       credt the Water Chmdistay Comard -B6R program. sothia lineappliea obvkIRM-31 and AMPA3*2 TheI trnarinrg lin dAdtachma         2d LRPO- Mortifyactivities d the Ore-Tine Irnpectin Prograr thas address nompomw specific Ir*Ipatior     Arpicabi a systemn we Idetrlied for these Inspections.
ems.1.-14. t1.1-15 aid31.1-47 allincllde dclnsiem Isying hat aging d Iht sonapnens rduing WP o hose lanes will beby Water Chwaistly auyreaed by th Ons Tine I-spectien Prong'm A"athri ad LPROD-C.
PAW l*d 77
Revision Cn providea a list d AMtA. affected by the OCrn-Tee Inpection Actvitias. Howeve, Atachmen 2
does Z Incluet A.aMM-1 (Remclor Prassues Vessel) w AMM-32 (Rasole Vessel flmeis) Inthe lista dafected AMRFIA.
Please priwida anexlanat en d wty AM I-31 and AMPtM-2 mand Included InAltantsile 2d LtRPD-O.
Revision M New wwit PNPS
-ra UIM appropriate m-Urnse kiptoone aroperutned for toe RPV aid WIA cofpiones where such Itepwtione we craeled for Adng kMrbgmawl duie th parnrl l dWlarded operation?
Reson se Tthun OIw application, It. OCr-Tke Inspection (OTt) Program hwa busn Irealed as a aqipport prWm sor the waem cter$isley pr aran foitnhew ptrpes d verifying water chemistry progein effectivereas. The O-Tlme Inspection Progam has io bean treated w an agin gumal prograsi dcsrtly applcbe the eystyne tha t I
redl water cheisry toe arng niraageaut ThN treaatii was comisidard appriprale since the verilication S waer chereistey progran alectivrness willbea" Iretgrated task OWa silieae dfecliveness
: d.
Oe proasm toe all systers ths crWa waler chertrfy Ift waler Oteistry preogad"aslvera$
willnoi be wilied aserately fom wnh ayater For th cases wthr IVe COe-Tine Irspectin Progras airtbsses oiponot specific Inpectylin, thi. listed In the IRA asiae agng rnurergsrl poanm dretly applicale toID as omponenas The test rowd Atactoir 23d LRPO-02 dm.tifie. t' activities d ft On-Tirna Irspection Program Pl willverity waler chenisliry prograi effectivnass lot all systemr O credt water chenistry.
TNs line applies to the walm chwristry prOgrer. Incluinrg Vwle Cheriasty Contrlr -SMt. wtch Inturn appies toireli dthe system Uistsdinthl.agpicaI*m Th" rercmr praesse vassel and rec1te vassal Irert$s comepoeess credt the Water Chmdistay Comard -B6R program. sothia lineappliea obvkIRM-31 and AMPA3*2 TheI trnarinrg lin dAdtachma 2d LRPO-Mortify activities d the Ore-Tine Irnpectin Prograr thas address nompomw specific Ir*Ipatior Arpicabi a systemn we Idetrlied for these Inspections.
NRC PNPS Lead JactwMo Wlsrb FinreS Ron PAW l*d 77
 
James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 76]1 Number Status S15 Cttw -
Plant Request LRA Tatoe43-I providese lft lmitin 40-yew ard:t&#xfd;e usage lacor, (CUF)kor fte RPV. RPV Interal
: aondonts, sot reactor coole peteour. boundary (RCP8)`pip1`ng wsredcagned IoASME Section IIL With It exception of One CUFovalues or RPV foowater nozzte., PNPS les accepted the TLM rmetal tehgoe CUFetelyse "d staedI tel Ins 40-ye-CUF
-ooclsiorl
-'o eid to, lperiodd of ededod operation (EPO) In aooordaneo with IOCFR 54 2 o
rO)(f)(i)tor the affete of cracking t gidge" willbemaregod tor lthe EPO.
The last peragtaph on Page Il Id LRPD-C6 aides thait o,.
en WI ohf i*t doign esels transients defined tnIts UFSAR povection stow ist the allowede limit, as defined by "i RPV vycliclooed entysis, willbe es&#xa2;eded b hew* the snd ofi te pIaiodded tatded opetafis." Theloag'aph Whate tales te"* Adlalleds analysis beyond he scope of tHs report would be remireid to rwe.eds CUF. N's.
trswislimits n
re infct sceceld and VW 'The exitirng cycle nnitoring programn wil mneto r tse cycles and riide mor-ecj action upon approshing a lirt, Please eLain how One ND.-year CUF concluson wtl remin valid for lhv EPO when PNPS Report No t.RPO-C06 Imple lW Vl CUFe houmd be recat Iatei ad projected out W years. Plebe eake ine-coo "t fact ar Draft C'renlitnet 31 resuires correti-eo actn when the CUFe soes 1.0' and not whenft l
rs tn*anw tcn of fMP I B1.12, Faetg.e Monitoring Progam' dotist*nsn the actual tansiete cycles will anrerpeh We rnds of deeigt ansient cycles tot s alslowed tinoe design basis.le the CUF8 should h.e been projected ad recalcualaed to 60-years. as Irdicaded In LRPD.M provideoa ommtmnen when the Myer CUF. veluse ortlhe RCPlooTpone.
wilt he provided totOs NRC o, review and approval undsr either 10 CFR 54 21(c)(1)(ii) or (iW). The response loiNs queston may rsy"re amornrel oft Comrilment 31 eador UFSAR S*o4*s'n t S..r.y Deecription A221. 'Cte. H Me*sl Faiguee Ths Ift. goes with Ift 425 ReWponse NRC LRPD-C6 was rnd IrlewdI to I"ply t* Vs CUF ihoud beprojected Medoffo Jim Wot toO year Inaocordeoce with IOCFR 5421c)(1I)(1).CUF&in Table 43-1 we based oneassumed nurrse of trsnsiet cycles, rC ste runt*s years. These CUFsate d neceseseao 40-ywr Hlnitirg values A. long as the cyces we no eoese.
ft CUFP do no rood tobe recalculaled WIle ome ofr n t Vs ntos d cyc*e*
p"oaected for 60 yeart InTabne, 4 3-2 *ced V* design basie assuntpiors tor numers t
d cytcles.the FaVtigoue Monitorin ProTan assure.
tee I erseysee will berewised toincreese Vs allowabie number d cyclee betore accleng I design base s assuke ietione.
WVil. LFIPD projects r ts. teat excesd V design kasi.
ssumptios.
the projections re cono.etive and Vs actual reib*s of cycles nmy rot aceed Vs design koe. assumption on Vse numetrs of ctcles. CUFP will require r"WtCa alion It Vhe ntms.
of Vato l Israrents approach Vt deslgn basis value.
Because Vns CUFainTabe[ 43-1. withthe exception of t leedwaler nozzte, we well below 1. Vt allowable,.urbert of cydes cra be Inctreed throto reansaysis eesstritg h" nus n rss d cycle.
PNPS Lead Finrc% Ron SIB Open -
The TPO proqect documeneted Vs reeults of reactor vessel Pled*
fisgue usage tectors of Uniting compont In table 3-2 In GEreporl GE-N'E-COCO-ODO-1898-OZ Row0 March 20.
In Vs sunrnay Table, ft staee thel lo, CRD nozzle -stub tbe, Vs seting PNPS CUF valu w- 0 8, and I. now chenged to 0870 to TPO. Howe" Vthe IRA Tote l431. wNhih idoifie. cIasse ICUF va1:e. Vs CRD nozoztevalue o
O8 was nd kelxoiitd Please justify why the value was roe Included In Vs IRA Paei. Erach FPrltH Ron FPa 0 21 01d 77


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf                                                                                                                                                         Page 76]1 Number Status Request                                                               ReWponse                                                              NRC        PNPS Lead S15  Cttw -   LRA Tatoe43-I providese lft lmitin                                    LRPD-C6was rndIrlewdI to I"ply t* Vs CUF ihoud beprojected MedoffoJim              Finrc% Ron Plant    40-yew ard:t&#xfd;e          usage lacor, (CUF)kor fte RPV. RPV            WottoO year Inaocordeoce with IOCFR 5421c)(1I)(1).CUF&in Interal                  sot reactor coole peteour. boundary aondonts,                                  Table 43-1 we based oneassumed nurrse oftrsnsiet cycles, (RCP8)`pip1`ng          wsredcagned IoASME                            rC ste runt*s        years. These CUFsate d neceseseao 40-ywr Section IIL With It exception of OneCUFovalues or RPV                  Hlnitirgvalues A. long as the cyces we no eoese.        ft CUFP foowater nozzte., PNPS les accepted the TLM rmetal                    do no rood tobe recalculaled WIle ome      ofr tVs n  ntos d cyc*e*
James Davis -AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf.Page.77]
tehgoe CUFetelyse "d staedI tel Ins 40-ye- CUF                       p"oaected for 60 yeart InTabne,4 3-2 *ced V* design basie assuntpiors
Number Status Request 517 Open -
                                        -'o
Ouaatlon 43-8 PNIPS pravildd the Prject team withlt Plass stress alyses and cuidalt'. usage factor cakctions tar ftw PNPS rarirculatioa lacemrl piping systems ad care s wlsltabilizers Inthe Idlowing dowimeils:
                                  -ooclsiorl            eid to,lperiodd of ededod operation          tor numers t d cytcles.the FaVtigoue  Monitorin ProTan assure.
*ODC23A404 &23A40t Re.Al, Pilgrim rciilaion Piping Raplawelnar.
(EPO) In aooordaneo with IOCFR 54 2              o rO)(f)(i)tor the    tee I erseysee will berewised toincreese Vs allowabie affete of cracking tgidge" willbemaregod torlthe EPO.                  number d cyclee betore accleng I design bases assukeietione.
June 27, l90
The last peragtaph onPage IlId LRPD-C6 aides thait o,.               WVil. LFIPD projects r          ts. teatexcesd V design kasi.
* GE Repor 25A5685 RevIsion 1. Stres Reapol -Shoa Staillzers Vessel, June 19. 1995.
en WI ohf  i*t doign eselstransients defined tnIts                    ssumptios. the projections re cono.etive and Vs actual UFSAR povection stow ist the allowede limit, as defined              reib*s     of cycles nmy rot aceed Vs design koe. assumption by "i RPV vycliclooedentysis, willbe es&#xa2;eded b        hew* the      on Vsenumetrs of ctcles. CUFP will require r"WtCaalion It sndofi  te pIaioddedtatded opetafis." Theloag'aph                    Vhentms. of    Vato l Israrents approach Vt deslgn basis value.
* GE Report GENE-771-79-1194 Revision Z Sou Repeit Hard.er. Sties Ainlynl,J-re 19, 1995 LRATable 43-1 list* MIhf Ulniting 40-ye-CUF J
Whate tales te"* Adlalleds analysis beyond he scope of              Because VnsCUFainTabe[ 43-1. withthe exception of t          leedwaler tHs report would be remireid to rwe.eds          . CUF. N's.         nozzte, we well below 1. Vt allowable ,.urbert ofcydes trswislimits n      re infct sceceld and VW 'The exitirng            cra be Inctreed throto reansaysis    eesstritg h"   nusnrss d cycle nnitoring programnwil mneto r tse cycles and riide              cycle.
r to vec~rcda=n piping 1 CA110 and 1tt Ore liriling 40 ype CUF for Oire corse lhrd alstIizua I. 0.330. Th. linmting 40 year CUFvalusa provided Inthme reports for tnes ootponal$s we 09 a3 0i O0 respeclively. These vale-do rct conretfae othe 4C-ye CUF values provided in LRA Ta*e 43-1. F-pin wly ti-4C-yew CUF value in tin. d.*ign ta". tia*ewiwia drietrair Ikm -ye valtue pronidod InLLRA Table 43-1 I Ihti.
mor-ecj action upon approshing a lirt, Please eLain how OneND.-year        CUF concluson wtl remin valid for lhv EPO when PNPS Report No t.RPO-C06 Imple lW Vl CUFe houmdbe recat Iatei ad projected out W years. Plebe eake      ine-coo      "t fact ar Draft C'renlitnet 31 resuires correti-eo actn when the CUFe soes 1.0' and not whenft      l    tn*anw rs        tcn offMP IB1.12, Faetg.e Monitoring Progam' dotist*nsn the actual tansiete cycles will anrerpeh We rnds ofdeeigt ansient cycles tot s alslowed tinoe design basis.le the CUF8 should h.e been projected ad recalcualaed to 60-years. as Irdicaded In LRPD.M provideoa ommtmnen whenthe Myer CUF. veluse ortlhe RCPlooTpone.                wilt he providedtotOs NRC o,review and approval undsr either 10 CFR 54 21(c)(1)(ii) or (iW).The response loiNs queston may rsy"re amornrel oftComrilment 31 eador UFSAR S*o4*s'n      tS ..r .y Deecription A221. 'Cte. H Me*sl Faiguee Ths Ift. goes with Ift 425 SIB  Open -  The TPO proqectdocumeneted Vs reeults of reactor vessel                                                                                      Paei. Erach  FPrltH Ron Pled*  fisgue usage tectorsof Uniting compont In table 3-2 In GEreporl GE-N'E-COCO-ODO-        1898-OZ Row0 March 20.            In Vs sunrnay Table, ft staeethel lo, CRD nozzle -stub tbe, Vs seting PNPS CUF valu w- 0 8, and I. now chenged to 0870 to TPO. Howe" VtheIRA Tote l431. wNhih idoifie. cIasse ICUF va1:e. Vs CRD nozoztevalue        o      O8 was nd kelxoiitd Please justify why the value was roe Included In Vs IRA FPa0 2101d77
designs basis d(re-do rot calstittie tie mnel oure-t design basis CUF ba lar the repqawenrl recirculation piping systei e" cres sralstatsllz$, clarity wthdoi cumLws do patain he lawet design basis CUF salcUlatians fr these oawpowt owrrcay groups. Staid I*s bte ct ase, lais Queltin willrernaoencpen trait st can review the apprcps*tie deigi basis catilwons tr Ia caieprel ooaniuy wowpe.


James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf .Page.77]
===Response===
Number Status  Request                                                      Response          NRC         PNPS Lead 517  Open -  Ouaatlon 43-8 PNIPSpravildd the Prject team withlt                              Madoff. Jim Finnirr Ron Plass  stress alyses and cuidalt'. usage factor cakctions tar ftwPNPS rarirculatioa    lacemrl piping systems      ad cares wlsltabilizers Inthe Idlowing dowimeils:
NRC PNPS Lead Madoff. Jim Finnirr Ron FtPp 770d 77}}
                                *ODC23A404&23A40t Re.Al, Pilgrim              rciilaion Piping Raplawelnar. June 27, l90
* GE Repor 25A5685 RevIsion 1. Stres Reapol -Shoa Staillzers Vessel,      June 19. 1995.
* GE Report GENE-771-79-1194 Revision Z Sou            Repeit Hard.er. Sties          Ainlynl ,J-re 19, 1995 LRATable 43-1 list* MIhf Ulniting40-ye- CUF    J r to vec~rcda=n piping 1 CA110and 1tt Oreliriling 40 ype CUF for Oirecorse lhrd alstIizua I. 0.330. Th. linmting40 year CUFvalusa provided Inthme reports for tnes ootponal$s we 09 a3 0i      O0    respeclively. These vale-do rct conretfae othe 4C-ye CUF values provided in LRA Ta*e 43-1. F-pin wly ti- 4C-yew CUF value in tin. d.*ign ta". tia*ewiwia drietrair Ikm -ye valtue pronidod InLLRATable 43-1 I Ihti. designs basis d(re- do rot calstittie tie mnel oure-t design basis CUF ba      larthe repqawenrl recirculationpiping systei e" cressralstatsllz$, clarity wthdoi cumLws do patain he lawet design basis CUF salcUlatians    fr these oawpowt owrrcay groups. Staid I*s bte ctase, lais Queltin willrernaoencpen trait    st can review the apprcps*tie deigi basis catilwons tr Ia        caieprel ooaniuy wowpe.
FtPp 770d77}}

Latest revision as of 06:58, 15 January 2025

Email: (PA) Fwd: Questions and Answers of Pilgrim LRA Aging Management Reviews
ML062480379
Person / Time
Site: Pilgrim
Issue date: 06/30/2006
From: Dan Hoang
NRC/NRR/ADRO/DLR
To: Jennifer Davis, Dang Nguyen, Wen P
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
%dam200612
Download: ML062480379 (80)
v • d • e


Text

James Davis - Fwd: Questions and Answers of Pilgrim LRA Aging Management Reviews Page 1 From:

Dan Hoang To:

Duc Nguyen; James Davis; Peter Wen; wapavinich @ comcast.net;jacksonwr@ msn.com ;erachp @ comcast.net Date:

06/30/2006 2:07:32 PM

Subject:

Fwd: Questions and Answers of Pilgrim LRA Aging Management Reviews Gentlemen, Here they are.

Enjoy Dan

c:\\temp\\qW)00001 JMP Page 1!

c:\\tem,\\GW}0001..TMP.P...

1 Mail Envelope Properties (44A5685C.5BF: 17: 35826)

Subject:

Reviews Creation Date From:

Created By:

Fwd: Questions and Answers of Pilgrim LRA Aging Management 06/30/2006 2:07:24 PM Dan Hoang DVH@nrc.gov Recipients comcast.net wapavinich (wapavinich @comcast'net;jacksonwr@msn.com;erachp@comcast.net) nrc.gov OWGWPO03.HQGWDO01 JAD (James Davis) nrc.gov TWGWPO01.HQGWDO01 DTNI (Duc Nguyen) nrc.gov TWGWPO04.HQGWDO01 PXW (Peter Wen)

Post Office Route OWGWPOO3.HQGWDOO1 TWGWPO01.HQGWDOO1 TWGWPO04.HQGWDO01 comcast.net nrc.gov nrc.gov nrc.gov Files MESSAGE Mail Options Expiration Date:

Priority:

ReplyRequested:

Return Notification:

Concealed

Subject:

Security:

Size 444 Date & Time 06/30/2006 2:07:24 PM None Standard No None No Standard

.c:\\temp\\GW}00001,TMp

.Page2.'

Junk Mail Handling Evaluation Results Message is not eligible for Junk Mail handling Message is from an internal sender Junk Mail settings when this message was delivered Junk Mail handling disabled by User Junk Mail handling disabled by Administrator Junk List is not enabled Junk Mail using personal address books is not enabled Block List is not enabled

James Davis - AMR -_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 1 I NRC LRA AMR Audit of PNPS Number Status Request 341 AcMeed InTable 41-I dists LRA te applicant ddrotIdenlfy ca"e lead cycle *Unit as a TLAA lotr te Crawe within the sope dat Heow renewa. Nonatmy, based onUne desgn code d Uhe crane, a lead cycle lUit Is sptcified at rated capacity ovar the rerael projected lilfe Therfaore.

ie geralty naecesary sopealotrn eTLAA relating ocrane u

ead cycles eatinsaled toscur upto Use addthe U

teaded period opaslkn Please actain w Uths crareload cycle timit was not included as a TL.Ak 342 Asceted InTable 43-I. Lh*insm CUFor Clue I Cc res, noae 2 addre*ses actiwn rues for ASME Csda Flees. mplain wt tsee res ate, Resonse NRC PNPS Lead The license renewal

tie, In 10 CFR543, dalines aTLAA maa Paid. Erach Fitch Ron licersee calculaion or aralysie that. am'on other things. lranee tinrr-limiled aseurrics definael by Us arat operfling lani For crans, Ihtwr Ia calculatior r arelysie rlased to crare load cycles. In addliton iU t arber atcycles IsNOT basad onthne matra qcring tarn, ClMA-70 apecilles a allowable ltrmas range based onjirt cataelry and sevilceclass.aservice clasn Is tased onsload lams (nrho ective load lector) and rut' of cycles. The projtcled cycles lot Uhe PNPS reactor buikldng crawe we wall below "t d Use cycle rarias, gven In CIAA70 The dscus'sio aoduram, Atwn 33,1-1 alTable 3.31 willhe clariaed Io reed as followse -No PNPS calculaion, or anlysis rdalal ocutnAlive tawgue darrge lo a*ea cteCrawe rc the datiatlior ad TLAA In tO CFR 543 The proectade cycles tor Us PNPS r*eL' bilding san's we well below U cycle ranges given InClAkA.70. Stwi cres we ev aucaed as etructural csrry'eels in swum 3.5" This reapree anaenadmrne Ioths LRA The assifls onthe RPV rain aloen vcl ard Iranerae nozzles Paid, Erach Firrin, Rlu we rild and vreeeee reanin balow Us acturat-e lUrnl. The

'sigirt CE (Corrustion Engineer fg) vsesd ansysie deaisrratee Ust Uhe realraonerats t IASE Seclion Ill-196S wilhaum-r 196 Atdends (Origirel Csolrrictia Coda), PFraraph N-4151 Vessels Nd Readring Analys*i for Cyclic()pas'ior were mL Th*e wae Ia. cortirmad to be the case In fs Atran ayal.ysi`

A nistake.. lls In Table 43-1 at hU LRA The recirctiation cui*

nAszle USage tact'o see not nd the crileiad praglraph N-ISt1.

LRA Table 4.3.1 willberrevisled Iadd the apprclriale usage factor lor Use reclrcdalion oCl razzle Nol 2will o lnger bearplied Io iU recirculiarion".'ootel r et Ndle 2 wi be revised so reed as olue.

Detailed fatige anatysis ia not r-yired sircea Crristst nests Uhe requmareie atAShds Section In -1965 wilhearrotwr lIt9 Addna (Origial Coulrmation Code), Pasagraph N-415t1 Veees Nd Reqiring Analys*i for Cyclic Cplalion Thesreqtree anarneetwl bssfh LRA Pag 1d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page2 2 Number Status Request 343 Accepted Sectia 4 31.3. Class I piping and camrp.-I. states all rerai~rnin RCS prssure bsmrdy pipig In designed and arslyrzed In a-rea44l "ithANSI B31.1. Howasa. In sectimnAla3, on page 4 3-It inplie V la higee analysl wrists for I~looa piping (asoh in pad d the RCS prsswoa boasdoy piping =as.

and.iyzai lAW B31..).

Ploeas olrgly the dsocreorcy. uince B31.1 dcoe al r"Asra, a taligia analysis OdotUaidi 344 Acoepted Sovlon 4113.

Clasi pi pik and oowp-nal sasad paragraph aides thal Ith design trarseons we bacedka and oasakatad to ara that cycle Iirnil, wenoroea, aoa d,

Unreby asa~ing that CUF. do M,

.ead 10A it htlwt saltas Ma con~fstionta d tis prograt lOwelore will SatO "14 the aIlcoted nanbor d Inrersas cycles Is a,

..oawlo Caaayseloly, the TLAA (fatgue analyasas)

[or Clase I piping and conponent willir anfaid fo0 r the periaild olrtded opeaion In aoer"ow with 10 CFR 642 1 (c)(1)(l)m orte oabec. daging w,1 th Iteded Ifolin(ar) will beaderi~tedy nonagod IW the pariod d adenla oparaliss In aoosrdaro with 10CFR 54 21 (c)(I)(MIi The by Itself 00.44 ba a tu slas 51.1.,

Imwwas cyicl coO1.iic doas rot address the effetla dS ariO'r-tal Iig.^ wtich Is rot Includedl her, Akncwled~jrg gtha setiss 433s arldrear" eroirrvanial W~ig^~ pt..

clarity low OW4 goclion Is god inio the 11sonlusis mrade In aoction 43.1.3,

Response

Section 431.3 dthe R~A Ios crart. PNPS 1.a noahelapeciric folig.

analysis lort. leek-er ip iiog Section 433 dth ll RA Is discmaing the offets d tha raomew coolant Pdrwirawo on Iiig-Eriargy willornroe ft generic (NUREG-52in( va1445 $or theawe spray asal od the FIR Ufa15 nozzle and the Iawha51er piping iron Table 43-a There wea rPtdPS-secaific wel4yse lo, teeIasa onelle aSe ine rasycose t Qustison 346A belvw for the PNPS

=lswt for parforatnrg EAF (onvinxrssarlly adfutedlalIotiq)

TH. raeira. ananvaotnerl Iofta RA PN;; wiIladd f foldloingasentence al11 ft d d Swticn 411.M

'Th. effects d the reasolo coolert Porprmonal onlatioir wre addresedl In Section 4 33 d ft IRA*

TheaTLAAaddressed by Sevtion 4 31.3 Is calcujielm OCIJFa willosi arlooriig Ior the effecs drawls, coolaterS aionars,ae TH. TLAA orneina valid for ft period ci ortendd capratim as kng as lie analyzednrbore d transients Is nct.. cewal Theacalculaton dS CIJF accounting to, the affects d the reats coolant Wir1100nwr1ceos not aris, as thW etsrers licensing basia cdcas rot raqrol consclraeicon dS oirormarosI Idioma tacura.

Since 10 CA 114 3 dolins. TIA~s as ficwe.. calcsicra anPd analysesa.

Uwe Isao a aTLMA Owi corko~ers.orwroreratl gaigue ImicnoN To re-ro the parcaeive inpdisat icn dim arcaaling the atlowale ronter dS transet ati

-4 oI.nsa CUFa to exceed I., the followinrg c1W~

will benmod tot In RA, IRASection 4311. page 4 34 willhawolified as ldlona Th.

P14PS Fatigue Mcbiloring Progirs ar"am. that ftW nater od tasirent cyclsas.ryenrel by ft plerS roaian withinthe allowable waters dS cycles. Prd hence the ossyonal CUF.

rorrain below "rW analyzed values.

IRA Section, 4.31.3. Second sarteceal Our ta aood paragraph, will ba ochanged as lollowa

-Th. design trersier. wetrakedbr Pnd wacisted to "ars. tast cycla lirt. seawi m.ossde Oedry assaring tat CUFa rernain below ther analyzedvluesras TN.rapeeeradre serreoS o"

IAA NRC Paid, Erach Paid. Erach PNPS Lead Finrin, Ron Finrine Ren Pbge 2d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 3 Number Status Request 345 Accepted Sectio 4.3.I.4, Feedwater Nozzle Faigue stlaes e Iis earapoted wage factor fotr flaeedwaler nozzles.

conridertg th the cerretly analyzed sylate deign translents and rapid cycling Vro.u me period d Warded geeaUoM, Is ft.

.0 899 THe nate Is no carted. Pleae wiplain ht ths naurber wm cacuated 346 Open -

Ssctiol 43`3, Effect o Relor Water Exawrwi erwt on NRC FMagta Lile Please provide tee detals onyour Iknpemertlii plen A 1owwills fterth reriret ofl fte ligue selysos be perfornee Wit t consider firtle d-ted erelysee?

B. Kan aging ewroarnert progtr Is wed, please Imtlide a at-mitmtte IoDssu tor NRCappral 24 nuoh priorso snlering perlod of lersied operalion.

C. WO11 replaernatw beao t me eats neerial typ?

347 Accepted Tasle 43-$ Note I stales 'No PNPS-specifo vasue was available; wed generic value froa NUREGCR-=."

a Wrong NUREG leratfied - sheid ft be NUREG-62MO?

bt Th. NUREG-81W CUF is be aedt mte specific plant used IntOe NUREG ard Is dMpadel onatW plart* piping configuraeion Tha value cardb M ed tar PNPS calcjationI Please justiyhow h value applies toPNPS rieas me NPS piping wconigu slions atrns asme NUREO-6260 plaed arproolde ePNPS specific CUFvaluw

Response

NRC ThM Thlwntl Poer Oplimizatia Task Report T030 up aed the Paid, Erach teedwater nozzle CUF to<1.0 beted onthe aessociated (15%) peter Wetre Th extrapalion InaLRA section 43L1.4 Is tha o longer valid PNPS will odlfy the LRA todlde islatrapdatiora PNPS willperform a raw, Ieadwater ozzle fatigue a*alysl prior tomfe period l extended peerswa THie co*irrtned Is Iter 3 5 mfe PNPS com.er.re tor license THosreaprsenatetrnatrr tomet IRA A Further relireenof f te ASME Class I lmigue arelysls for mhe Paid. Etach RPV and nozzle localtios willbe perlored considering mhe proddaed uranber Iranmierns e ch location at*aled o the and cf fte aerdedd icerse period wsing refined fIrle dated

.atvu.tiom a sapicabe The refined arWysis will amourd tor entrlnri wri decls as apic abIe wing oe FEN methedolog described by me GALL reperl or *ohe Indrstry Codes and Starsdds a approved by NRC.

B License rerneal Cormaent 31 1rclubs a cwmlti to sabTil me aging e'atine progranio tome NRC 24 trnths prior t1o me periodcfmterdaod operaion Ift ging nweagrnrtd prograt option is chsera C. Apprvrises replacerdnt Male ril will be slected In accordarce with PNPS designeortrd Iocedam. If repleateo n Is acloest A Yes.

ls is a lypo It tid be NUREG-4281.

Pald. Erach B ThM CUFvalws fato NUREG-6M were Indedeo am typical values wed to preit tme rgil*d othe efct of considering me reactor ceolat erwirotrel onfaligue tor PNPS. PNPS willaseod me LRA to reaove the CUFs from Ta*ie 43-3 me we taean frt NUREG-62X0.

see Ite 346 for PNPS's omrraim-et topelorm adtditionel sfirornmW9dl y eacusled tai angs lyses prier tome period oi Tls response reqlirm te arta*trel tome LRA FlPS Lead Fin1,% Ron Firrirn Ron Piorrt% Rat PFgu 3 1 77

James Davis - AMR_- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf.

.Page 41 Number Status Request 349 Closed 13.11-W-01J In r-m lineItIn nTablee 342-2, 3.2-14-3. 9.10.

I,17and 18d ice StWel and Power Cemerlion System ape pic.ant cradte TLMA - MWal Fatig" to nengy Wne aging afect d end latig.. (convilive ati;gu d-ego).

and Itdlcites Wet the eraludion ci 54 TLAA is addressed InSection 4A3ofo IRA Hower ', happesawl the

writ, of dthe Section 43 does M co.' Wthe dioelscri loi rntel omo

,'e Please tlsai Whe dscrepertcy 35O Accepted

(.*4t-W-M Section 34222 (t)dft 'RA(ppge 34-4), ft-appicant L cd otaerial due to general. pittirg and crtwice corrosioni ice cotbo, sledt dying piping contyora-is. and terioeysed totreated wit.' ard for carbon stele piping and carnpant exposedltoetst-I[am song elect reqoiring trere~

Inthe stem and power corverslion systemno it PN ald hais nage by We Watet Chesnistry Coarolr -BWR antd Priodc Sta~llaerc and Preventive hrtlnwerr (PS'4 Proga'nes" Please tlarity

,e ftoe suarwy, regarding the u of PSPM proram Is the we d PSPM progam Is in fimJof the OTI progra to verity We electiser.s o thf V*We.

Cheoistry Coarol -SWR prograes or we ofe tAEM oaritirton willbemanaged by wing PSPM alone 351 Closed (34.t-W-031 W1 h. OTI prograr not crdlted lor those linetter. In Tinles 342-x and Table3.32-14.x (mrosporcing to Vtll E-33. oordeonele syslemrn Vlt.C-.6..trectiat stesm systent VtIIID2-7.

leodwer system and VIIt B2-6, tain atem systern) OW rference tohn 34.1-4?

Response

NRC PNPS Lead Usting TLAA -nstl taltge inthe latle in Section 3hindraies Wear Peter FinPh Ron Oetthe ooltJor lon teige weeprelee, add tha y reeded to be toelsedi Associted orrponerthe were st*e*"rinty evarmted InLRPD-C, TILAA

- Molda Fatigue I Wae evalutiona toud no TLA. Itwe rnot fisled InSect-a 4Ad fte IRA For clarificatio, Entergy will revises e Section 3 tahes to rernro Whe TLA* -rials totgue aries whueev tosre waee oessCciata:

TLAA docsds1 inSection 4Al lb LRA The item ha closed toit" MS.

The Secthon 34222 (1) lrotthr salutuon dectssion Ih referenced Weor Peter Ungvotdter.

byTaie 341 somenl 3

-Z 24t1-4 and41-6 ", Thedsocein tintt entry otilen 341-6 irdcite tha lhe PSPM proaresn applies to fe coda-sate storagetorts. AJthoid the wat.' In theseeta-ts wooed btubjein tothe wa.er chttantry corols -BWR progevm We PS'M p rarg s to stlicler to tlweage lose oi rmaterial and was the Only progren credlted ifor se latos. See OW rtponse tovptsstion 3 4"- (iltm i353) weich dotum lt gat the We.er Cheristry Ca-trdl - BMR pIOger shoald have been cr*dted along with et PSPM progea lot Whe wlensae storage totMs This reanresi sJoIeer/erns nems lo the WRA Sirces e Ore-Time Anqyection (OTt) Progr.

to applicable Is hch Wen, Peter Froaterger water cheidrity conrd progan, tI is also applicaie to each line Item that cre*its a waet.' ohonitry contro progano RAWTaTle 34`1 Inciates en IW OnisTino Inspection Prograem Is urthed along wihthe wat.r dlensitry otrdrl prograem lot line iHhem lot which OALL rearrvc dse

-hI1m Irnsecion toooahirm water cheniatry control Table 2tredts We OTI progam ntough rdeterce tohe associated Taile I line Item Thiererpireevnarnetrrct sothectenstry progea deocritionr In WRA eAppend-Aard BIo clearly itncite Wel t Wa O-Time Inspection Prog*am wiltocvhirm the slftctiveres of We Whter Cheristry Control.-MR. Water Cho iatry Cntrol-AmMatiry Systeom and We Water Chreniatry Cotroh-Cloese Coding Water prorrem.

Tis it" is closed to tem 372 Page 4 d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 5 I Number Status Request M5 Closed 1311.1-W-041 Wiry Is OTI prgrr Mo cradled for tlý n hoerni. In 000np0.,0.0 i1condon8801, e78180.) that reforeme it-.

3.41-11?

353 Closed pal1.W-CS)

TI. applicat ref.oremt GALL Itern VlIiiE-4D (.1.1 tank In cond0ensate systar) 10. f condensate01 storage apteI cabo I.W. lank, m listed InLRA Tek11. 142-t. (paeg 34-28). but t-k.. credit of PSPPJ 1. ns"eg ther agingeffc of0..

loss f

.1.

Th. GALL uson~e~.ing

'War.

Chernisry.r0d OCTrprograrr Ior 11i. compne.nt en AEM

..100ia, P1700.11 the PSP. a desribed In PNPS LRA Si.211( IPe

-0~ stringent Inspection rqirwnert than OTI. it dos,.. Include0.1 conro~lling water cIhoristry 10 Ml(5MZe cornp-40, wopm.. 10egyasiva, -,ir-.t Please :I;=

,ly relying ort PSPM alone is suficient for treaing the GAL. rseornrnnc,01os7e 10 rna-eg 1. agng effect of loss of Inal.10110. 11We coroneae storage 07010.1 car.ori stee lar0k sy010., (paeg 3.3 171) and1 Table 33.2-14.11, 10ee3.olo header

,.~0 dananed 8701.0yser (paeg 33-1781). also referene GALL ften Vill E-40. Wt7 10 OTI prv~ogr M0 credited 10.tos line.

10.11, OW0,,

.refrec kern 3 41-6

Response

Sims Me. Ons-Tirns Inspection (071) Prograrn Is applical 1so eah water carnisry control Program it Is1.

alo applicablet each liIne along w4th 11, ot lercenrisry control p00grari.I lineft.nt for.1 which1 GALL reconwrar1 a00.0.110. Inspectimoe conf.irm, water atan stry control. Table 2 credits the OTI prog.'ntrI~ough reference b01 IheasociatedTidl I. life t.em.

THe rectuires 00warnordre lothe charritry p000,0.1 descriptions In LRA Appedices A and 81 Solealy Ir000. that00 ft

-Tko.

Irpecti0. Prograne 0iltoo0.0ir th..effcir.ero 011the Water and th0, Waler Chernist Control-Closed Cooling Water prograrne.

Tisherno 1.0closedto0110. 37M Sims Itn.

00.010.80(8 storage larit cortai. flud OeW 10 sotect 10 the controls 01f1 theate Charritry Conrold - OWR Program~ the pro00,. applies to11 thelak TI. LtA will beclarifid to wpicilly crad1 the Water Ctanien Cont1rol - B'AR Progan, Inaddtion to PSPM with nwoegng One eflects cofging 1rII.

the codensat 010.05 bl( 5,01000.s aposedbth tr1eaed0010 water. arst,1,0 r.0 Sims the Ore-Ti,,. Inspection (OTi) Progran, Is applicabe to each water charrstry control prograrn 11100Is aloappicoble t0o eachtire 1(0,011that crcnlie,0.

a aercwni00117control progran As see0d In LFIA Table 34. 1, the GreTirsIn.sp0ection Progrer00 Icradled to1 weily ofclons the water chernistry owrol. pr00,orn for tir 1100,.11100. 11.rfeece.l 3 4.14-Th* rectuires anarnordywat 1011. charrisy p000,0n descriptions In LRA Apprdices A anl lB t1o larl Indicate that ft Gr-Tin.

inspeciion Prograrrl wii conf1irm,11 0theti of the Viol, ClWdetrp Cortro1-SMI Viter Ctwneislryd0.001l-Auxiiiry Opel.,.

0.0d the Water Chardstry Conrord-Closed Cooling Water progran..

Th* 110. Is closed 10110. 372 NRC Wen, Poteo WON. Peter PNVPS Lead Fronacrgb.r GrIiwkl, Jac0k PFa 5d 77

James Davis-AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 6 1 Number Status Request 354 Closed 34.t-W-0C]

Whf In OTI prosare not crdled for fle inre hew In Table 332-14-35 (wresponing to VILA-I14) thet redeuence e-n 34.1-77 355 Closed (3.4.1-W-0" Wy Is OTI progra not credled for tIre. Hoe iew In Table 122-4, HPCI System (pags 32-49) and Table 12-5. RCIC System, (pge. 32-62) (onrraspondin to V1i E-tO) that rderence ite 341-9?

Response

During lhe peornemce roetine rreirlenmce onecirenei f

soatin klbicaling oil vieua irepecl" df these oari-owl.

would Idetlity degtaded oowdlienl ti-at sxid beeatribled loan inerfective Ol Aslyss program The corrective action progton at PNPS has alow tireehold lo tIe ntification d degraded wsrdtiio such th-h.tcroson or crackingr c ornlonerts woud be Idrntified as pean oft is proge'n The reiew of crerating tpereice S PNPS fr the last five yrea id iM Identily aew condtion reportsin Iindcted -I nelitecline il aenalysis progeer or

-n Idwrled degeaeld ceyoren I condtilie stch as corosion a cracking Ina libricating oil envireortoiw Tide reviewer d

eracing e.pyiewe at PNPS eneva Inle sifa re-ine Irepection to proetde oordim.,,on d re e d

ecilvuee e

Oil Ataetysi Prog'aeo During t peet five yes. ney visel Irnpechoned comnpormes ontainrng hdhlcing li-heve tees perlorred dxing corrective and preventie rteirene e achvilim. The visuel Inpectione ci ihe oonionels woUIdidetitfy degrade cordtionr sucheas croslm ac cracking ta coLad be attrbied toes Inotelctive Oil Amelytis Progran.

PNPS hm elaw thre*hld Wline I*lwlic*l*on c deg oed conslie-e etch O wroslon w cracking s s*ertwlaens waid bee~litiel aet eue-lloothe wrsctioveaclon progrnoa No condition reports M idart Itied degraded ca-prpst

ontlionr, eJch s sorstic, t smoracking in Ia lbricating oil envirortret were Initiated esa reeuit of tme lirspeclion. The-e past iWtectio a PNPS e nvelinfie s

croe-inm. Inepecton to proide saoIroorfi c ihe difectivness c tie ail Arnlye[s Program Tie iten Is s*omed o Iten 376, ime the One-Time Inspection (OTI) Pograrn is appcable toech water chseitry weal progrum It ie also applicble eo teh line eis Uzin cruetd a water chetistry coinrol pnogeao LRA Tide 341 tIncatsa O tie One-Time Inspection Prograo Is creited along with the water cheristry wortdcl progeara for line horns bte whychGALL reoiefnds se-hUne Impapection towconirm waler civeistry werld. Taebl 2 creits tie OTIprograin tnvji rderence toft ass*ciated Table I line item Thid redree esanearendent the c¢eritry progran descriplions IntLRA 4*pudcee Aand Bto clt erly idicae that the Ore-Tine Irepectl* n Progrem willoortirm the dtuectivenues of the Vateu Citestey Ceird-OWR. Water Chen Isy Cotrid-Ami*eruy Sysleres and fe Water Cheoisy Cortrol-Ckoed Coding Wauer progrews Ths id t le cisla to i*edn 372 NRC Wen, Per.

We. Petu PNPS Lead Frortue*rgr.

Frorebarger.

Paw 6d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 7 Number Status Request 356 Closed

,l1i-W-O8]

Wy IsOTI proran rot cradted Wo foe e ertiar In Table 312-6, Staion BackoeL Dieds.l (Ogv 13-90) and Tabl 32-6, Securly Dined Geneastor System (page 13-110) (correspordog toVIII,0-15) tl reference iten 341-(10 357 Cloed e

,14l-W-OM WVA Is OTI pograrm ro crated lo thoee lint a*roe In Table a42-2. lMn C-olr er and ISIV L.Wage Pat;ray, Table 332-14-9. Extincfion Ste System Table 332-14-16, HPCI. Tade 3.32-14-18. bln Slent System and Table 3a2-14-1I. OClgre and A*grnarned C11ge Spate t U rdelence ita 34.1-137

Response

Durirg thte rfortlcere d -ini trairtetw o

aorpo.

-e conlain kibricatirg oil. viaLel Irspections of these conivonos aouid blaniry dejaed cordteis Wet toAd be attriloed loa Ireflecvtie 0i1 Anlysie Prograr The co-rectivo action progoa at PNPS lee a le S

tesidd he W idenfication Vdto-aded wriditio:

such ft! corrosion ow rackingrofdV orporne wodd be Idu-ified aseert po fis program The ravowofdoperating et ierice at PPPS he te last five year. dd rot kdlrifty any conrition reports tl Iredcalted an Inaeotive oil trelyeie program or tat Idanified dograded conp-ar I conditions euch se corrosion or crackirg Inna tirk'icatng oil awirrerr Teis review f operating apariernce al PNPS area In lie V e one-tirre Irepecti-n to provIde nord*drtton of We effectioveens of te Ci Arelysis Program Doring te paet five years, Inaty visual I.pec:ot of ooneotryc s reaingrt brt*fOs cW heoe been perormad rOtWn correcti*e aod prevertive neirta*roe ecivities. The vaiel Inspectiose VI theen otrponaran woaid idaity deg-aded orodltiora euch as coroicln or cracking ea coud bestilosied tow Intlfectlve Cil Anelysi Progrem PNPS lee aloe tfeshld iorthe We krtifiosn o degeded cordloe nsch fl-t corrosion a crackirg of Icortrpevts would be idMrasfied and eel Ineo Whe corrective action progTern Nooordsion reporle tat

  • dt Mod de7aded conporte-cotdtions.

ewch asnorroeion or cracking Inn ludicating oil -ihorne wawn (rifilated -sa reattl of te Irapecotme. Thees past Itepetirlm at PNPS e-e In lie. of a cne-i oie irpnton lo proide cordio*rhetiar VIe d

olle enf thWe Oil Anysis Progem TN. taer is closed to felr 376.

SoremWe One-Time Inspection (OTI) Pro7ant Is ap*v-.ate tIo ach waeer chiaristry cornrol progearr ItI s also apidiase bI each line Item Via credits a water chermstry contrd Program (RA Table 33.1 Irdcalta tl Whe One-Time Inpection PFroasm Is craded aorg wit the water ohereiery control ponsgme for Ilne e hoe waich GALL reoorandf e onre-tli Inspectlon to confirm water chwriatry corlrd. Table 2 credits We COI1 progant through rferenrce to fe associsled Table I line iter TNs readree anaeror*rf loe ofthernietry progran doscriptions InLRA Aeaoerce A a-Bto clearly iriscate VW We Gte-Tine Irpecyion Program willcoirm the dinotivene; of We Water Chearitry Corlrot-BW, MtWer Chlarn ry Coradi-Aueiliay -yster.

ard the Water Chetvwriy Control-Cloeed Coding Water proga-ne.

TN. ita Is cloed Io hoart 372 NRC War% Peter Wan Ppter PNPS Lead Proiabarger.

Frotne.W, PIg 7d 77

James Davis - AMR -_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 8:1 Number Status Request 35 Clneod 1341-W-101 Sinm. Wan Ward 'C'were ued invariow Tabe 312-14-x line ilens, whch reterenaw 0-34l-14, wyOTl prOca hi bno crediled for Eoee line?

359 Closd

[34.-W-t1]1 Seirde "C8 was wed InTable 33.2-14-4. Condeasate Derineralizer System line ilens, which reference tern 3.41-15. why OTI prograa i.cre ml.twld or thee line?

Response

Sircem e One-Tirme Inpecti (OTI)Proaar Is applicabe beach water cherAlry contral rorara 1liseso applicable b each limn hen th crodtsawafer cheistry corrol progarn LRATatte 331 Incicae tEato Oý-Tina Inspection Prag-arn I creadled along withbth water helristry coertrl proeg-m for Jim itane for which GALL recommends awoe-tlam Inspection boewlirm waler chemistry contrd. Table 2 credits to OTI progr-a Uhr refererce lothe aesocialed Tabie I line then Ths reqdreemanamardbt loate cheaialry p-ag-em descrptirs In liA )Apendicen Aand Eto clearly Jndicale OW the One-Timr Impection Program willoorfirm the ecrivete dt the Waler Cernsety Control -*MER. Water Ctshatlry Corcrd - Aailiary Syslern and eat Wafer Chlrde*ry Control - Closed Codirg Watr pro~ragw.

Ths iel

1.

lcloed o Item 372 Si the One-Tine hIspeclion (OTI) Proagean Is applicable each wafer c*nealry correl propaanit lie Meo appicabe b eech lIne hem rn credits a waler chairalry control prog-arn IRA Tale

33. Indlcale dM the OCw-Thae Inspection Bragem Is cr*eled alon wits. waler chaniety control p-oagare 1r line le for whichGALL rerraxc ewe-67aw Inspection locorirm waler chertniry wontrd. Tabe 2 creits "m OTI frog-am lfrou*

reafereme lothe asacialeod Taibe I line itear The reUire anawrdnrt Ilothe ciherdlry p"egar enweriptiow In IRA A nwdce. A and B bo clery Imicate thnt t On-Time Impection Pro'ag-willcortirm fhe elfeclicerwe d ft Waler Cherelry Cemrl - EWM, Waler Ch**try Conrrcl

  • Awiaiary salerM and mhs Waler Chernstry Connrol - Closed Caolir Waler pro'harb.

This ften1 closed boharn 372 NRC Wen. Pale Wen. P.er PNPS Lead Frorebager.,

Fromaergar.

Pb-g 8d 77

James Davis - AMR - Reoort to the NRC.doc.pdf Page L

Number Status Request

__0 Closed 134.1-W-121 Scims wlot "awci OCwwo din ITable 342-1A Cadio,"

Sorawge Systoni ard vaic Table 3,a2-14-x line Name witch referenc Htnn 3&IMGý wh/ OTt program Is not credited Nor 0-9o tflo?

Mity I. OTO prcgrcs Mw crdedw to, tic.. line Items In T&abl 3A 2-14X Twrbin Oonwattw ar Amiliary Sys[o.

(correpoming ioVIll.A-3) fto referece leron M41-18?

Re#'onae NRC Sims toe COn-Tin, Itoiocticn (OTt) Program I. apocaleto acah Wen, Peter wate ctwrri"y control prgami Ist also egtiCab. lo ch line lion trot retsa.wcon Cicottry comrtol L ATable 33.1 Irdoic tot tOWO One-Tim. Iropoction Prcgram Is creidle along with toe walechmilsry cc,-tro pograns icr Iina It.,e for nItich GALL recmornds a oconetim loportion 10confrmr warer chmlstry control. Table 2creds Ito 07t Program twoocgr referenco to the associated Table I line Item.

Ths rotpira, onawcrmldf to Ow cherctotry Program dw~r~lors In LRA Apperdea, Aarci8 to clearly iricoleto the CO-Timo lrap ionto Prognra wiltcoodirm toe dtcto

, cit.

YA Chorristry Control - BWiR. Wate Ctwnriciry Coircio.Amilwry Syaternen ar-itre Walw Chemistry Corircil - Closed Coding Wftw The it-, 1. closed I to 11-372 Owing ft eop rmnoceof coi 01.no irinowce mcronponens tOw Wrh Peter contan kirricaling cii nitoal Irspections ci Ira, comonentsol ocoi Identiuty dsg'rdod vordtlcr OW acrid baftnitAo lown Ircleitoctil.C Analysis Program The corroti. action Program a POtS Fee slow. threshldd lorto kletficrtiCoi fl citgradel cordior-O owth Mat corrcosio a crackinrg cf corgo-orl. world bo katitiwi a, part di tis Program Tho reiw wof opcherating wprpiocs a[ PONtS Icr tho 1831 In. ywe ld Mo Idonlity r cordiion rep"t "o Ircicotei a, Irinelwfti oil nlysis Program or tot Idlitiriw degraded compa.- I ccrnitioro s~in a, corrosion or cracidng IM& hirriootiry oil wtwimronti. TN. rovecparatin orpwience EA PONtS sras n Ow ofia, co-Urnos Iropati or prmkQci irrrmoiiflc tho Oia~ofa fito Cil Arrolysis Ocirg fto paut Ive yews. Iron vinrol Inapseciona ofccomponent corlaring trWicating oil two. been peroromod "ring correctiveoan pcowanire merreawooo activities. The viaWo inopotions of troo.

3o'cnl wccdd klarlify dagracle c Aodro-eawh a, corrosion or crackin tot cold be a~ittrii SodI a, Ircitoctiv. C1 Arotysis Program POtS ltw a lowt tinasbnd I-r th o rtlitcation at dengraeld ocacfiton ech tot ccnrceion a cracking of cor-rorror world bo Iletiwlifed er-l wwel Itro toe ccorrectie action potors Noecord ion reports tol dlora jfied degradorl courpcro cordliont, owth acrcsono ar cracking In. ta icaing cil ervironirnwt, wo Initiatedi as a roach of to.s. Irgchtion These pral Inspections at PNPS O"ve In ha, cof. co-na.

tim ropection to oincud.

confirmation di toe elloctiverasof. toe Oil Arlysis Prog'ram TN. fIeto Is cloudr to No 376.

PRorhobgw.,

PNPS Lead Fmrobergr, FIar 9d 77

James Davis-AMR_-_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 10_

Number Status Request

Response

NRC PNPS Lead 362 CloecI

[341-W-141 Drirng ft p*fow-fce mi reain. mrltlte onoorponef VW War% pglm Frfebfger, flon trckting oil. visual inrpedicnre dye eorolpowes st OTI program nt oradled lot thoe tine enta In would tdottfy degraded cord Itt coWld be aelribwed toan TWde 342-14-35. Tultm Geneatof ard Am iliary System Inctlecilve ail/ *keyds Progrem. The arentive action po*acm al (oorsepordirg io Vitt A-9 wed Vlt.O-3 )itha referene h-em PNPS Ia a low Ctahed lot r " idrtifcation d degraled 34 M-t?

Oondtifo awch Ml coroeion cracking d cw.M s newocd be idefied as paet d s progr-an The raciew di operating pesyweme d PNPS lot u test five yeses tld r.l Idotlity ondtlion ?Wafts Vt tndcaleoe an lreitective cil areysit rogream or Wt Idetdifi dowlej oaen I crdhtot etch - corrsion a oactking ina t&ricaling oil ervtrormsfw. Thes reaiew O operating apertere S PNPS seees In iet olea ore-drm. Impection lo prnoide oorirn-dion ct ftelolottivenee d We Oil Aretysie Progrem Coring f pest live youe.

any visual Irepecticre d oNonaoes OnOtring tfbrtlting Ot htae bean performed "icin corrective mci mcwaive nterarorrce ecttinee The viet Irapapeclt d 11se 9onpoewie woodr Ility degraded contior etch s

comrtion ot cracking W couLd beeasbtrdd loa Inbflective 0it Analysl Progrm PNPS Pas a low fleshd lot Whe Id fiatioston d degraded cordtioe etch IWe oroeton ot cracktngd c oponnesf woUsd belderiflied Wrd aered tnro the coreofiveaction progr*er No ordtion reports ItW Mdalifiel deaded owryrt cojrior, etch as =ýcrin or Cracking toe totitoting ottei oni wee Irtitited asa rtes te d

se ilepeoýttor TThee past irpyctio" at PNPS *-e tn lieu doa ot-Nm ln.pa o Itoo op-ovtde oinrnation dc We effectveness ci We Oil A-etysis Progrant TNs hem Ist osed bltem 373 Alp Tod 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 11 '1 Number Status 3M Open -

NRC Request 1341-W-151 Table.4.1. bn,,34. I., stee heitntyceed loni,-

coddor PNPS wase Sn Sytern lmkdzown Prog'on "0 "mop~ the egog eflect of Ion. of ntraln doe togeneral.

pittn~ and crevc corrosin hrough the ue dperiodic vistot Inspections. The GALL Report reooninands the, AWo di Abooeground Steel Tn*. Prog'nrn (GALL. )0. M29) to be used WVId te 5.Sysle. Wlkdtown Prograno nry b~e n aceptable efternaot for Aboveground Sledi Tanrs AWd lor Inspectiort thn Abomeground Steel Tit.

NAW has eorn.

prograr ttriLitjee rota ddresed intl., Systen, Waikdhown Progre"" Forexant~ple, the Sysltno Welkdow. Progtym Is silent ten prwlion actions. he the A qotrord Sleel Taink Aid' Imloeso proertn'v hneasure to rniligme corrosion by protecting the sottwti surfaeoefc steed tanks withpain or contings tnnlooedarce with elnoteed Irobustry toacric&

Pleae. ntplain how the prate Iva actions and detection di 84.g 41nt. at Iroconnthte loations euch es I' two, bdottn msoeoe will be pedrolree he the at5ieot twit.. wing the Syster VWolkdofl Aid.

Response

NRC PNPS Lead Prevwoive Actios:

Weon Pter Ford Bry*n P0.9Ie coatns warser applied drilngtaloNion or Instrailtion co the estimt tanks well before dcreocpm of agirng rnwenonart proran for license renewal The Syster Waekdown Prog'an isils vistal Inepectiot. of snrel surfaces dcarbon sled oenk to id*ty dograddion of eolings. seeearts.

d caulkinrg plus Indications ofleage The sile correctrie action process wool d retire "umlion and repai., K nacesmy, dldeogradod coaings orcanrihir Deaction d Aging Effects The conrotoe etorage tatk Ise a

-on feelty related cabon eled twtk that contains teeted water. The tank site on a eocrele pod withasand and noI base cuthion that Is designd to reorne rootebte om tn he l om of the tan to nennreze t.e poentlial for coerrelort The ned.ls of the twit wich Nob eskecited to oortinuow welling we pwetod.a Ilyireynced loh corrosion and piting Iudng ir In ib-e ereas (urder water) as docuewled in siteprocedure NES&- TNo*

n en procedure also.inwocts0 I

e erior cmnkir attho basen ofthe tank for cracking Inorder b prevent weter accmilalion ndithen Inwk The proc re iscredited In he Periodic Srell.ce and Prverlivne W1l progetan secttl. 4.17 and Atlachmre 3d LRPO-2 hore tnager-i of the xnternal and Ierred etlrcee of this tWtk Anr degrdyon of the kieteres of the tttk will rese Ina codition report nd an weluation ofthe n tenln ofthe cordltior whichy rW Irvolve dtltasono xnnrinelion to-doienrr remnirnng thickness.

Booma. the onvironrne*, Inidene e to I eidslinicartly hbrt thn the en viro,1 o*nthe unddeside of the twit. irnd degrdnaton wtotd be ntep ed long beo. corroeion onthe odi~d.

N degradation cmcuro the Irede (ircluding en lrm).

amtinetione d the degraded waos would tetyire a delnninrtioe, of the rarniring waot thicldkes wtich mures the itegrily of th itn*

Is nairtained However, o0enoure et significant degradation on the boton ofhel e tak Ihs rotocurring PNPS cm'ti. to pnero rm a ore *0n tieerasco i ticknens Warin*tion Inaoeassitble aess ontre bollo n

of t condenslae tlage twit priort othe priod of Wleadrd operaion Stwarvd wartiration and snrVIing techinigme willbetitlized Thes Is tolnrti number 36 This rtree anareno :re t to the LRA Pbge lld 77

James Davis.-AMR -Report to the NRC.doc.pdf_.

Page 12 Number Status Request

Response

NRC PNPS Lead 364 Closud 1341-W-161 ABotting Holity Progrom willbedevoloped OW willaddrcss fts Wetn Peter Frortaber.e aglng nagow of ltitig Inthe op.

liLcense renewal.

Tabe 34.1. hei 341-2Z. or teel botting and oloae4 tiling wqxsed toar withatemn or water leatagok air -

Th. Bolting logdty Prooei witllbe inerroraiod prior to the period oedioor (edterret). or r irdoor urcodrotils (eaterra,). The of atteded operation Inaooordence withtowuwtowl otter 3Z aWicart rderernes GALL Herne VIU.H-I ard H-4for Os clswe blting In vario Siestr eod Power Corersion TH. rectpree anawor, rt tothe LRA to include decrilion. of SysBen W lised In LRA Tabe 342-1 and 332-14-., 1L.

IOn Solting Inlegrity Proga..n InApperndes Aand Btad toiestlFy taken credit tr the Systern AWokdown Proga-en to enruge where the prograr Is applicabo Ine agen diect of losse drneorial. Th. GALL Rerot nnoo d AM' XtM18, Boltling ineaity Prog*-e wth T~is item Is closed to itn 373 Indcueo saoorprteheiv boiling Iietog-y progrant as delinretet InNUREG-13W, and Irontry renonmiwdeliora, so dolinseed In Ow EPRI report NP-5769. Poe.. jmsity how ft. addltional atititxes listed InGALL AMP XI M18 tor alngr naenagarwit docawsJ b:ting are adressed In f.

System Wlokdwn Prog-en Ige 12d 77

James Davis-AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 13 -1 Number Status 3

OPM -

NRC Request 136Z2-N-011 In LRA Table3 62.1 tdc, Cablecconnatiocrts (fltallio parts'. y aes "Wo ted that no agig toffts ardno AWIs'1 roqtAir NUREO-l,1t. Risicl

1. AM' )a.E6 'Electrical C.i. Cc~i2"n "a Sdject to 10 CFR 50.4 Ercir-netwtel 0,colitcation Racid~rctwis spotif. that 0-doe'oot W=ciatld with cables within the sieepal Wi..

c en patc d~' thsi proqar r~grd...dcOito,

.noialdwk nh ccii,.empmsoc on~onon. AJo.rdwt 1 peg 107. M ard 257 ofNUREG-I=

sTachincol B... lan Recsickn to the License Re'newl Gdaroc.

Dmwwbte lot wic i~ition I nfotrion regorcling AM' (I.E&

Ponolia be~.

is ar

~os incknc ong moMS with U'. Ion Oo,~ei

'or cable ecantectlnot or p'onkle sitwiictioion for wN an AW 1. n. necessary.

Region Th. PNPS electrical NcPI. AVIE-0t. In setent 34.1 attic. Iloe coble corrections (rnealdio partse).

  • An wlonion di thermal cyclings chntiO hatirU electrical tranaiena, vibration, oharnica contarintdio mwroso and Omcltimo alrercng Ior ito teldtiO part dloottleol cabile correlce tionliWeet itie c~noag altooto

- Mialolic Parsdelectricaileo cable conntections.

potertialty expcose to Ileetmi cynlirg td crnrio Nlls ng we thoe. carrtyig Silgntoott current In powner cstl circtit. Typically. powter cables we Ina cortitn-a not fronthe uq~Ay 10' thebad Thoew,dothe~

on 11tit' e* pat d.a oti-WWnrnaledr W

ed.*Ljod 1 agng neagtoret.

recieto.

- Th@.m led ohn cd cimdtt prodectine devces 81 hig w orart.

nitignte strnsO wnoond" witheletrol faiLts ard Itrsionuits In ackuilor4 rrohaicn l cutrea asicittt with electricol hLlAs Is rot condble a~ng rnuehonim beoo. di the tlnw trcl-ecy di

=weonece ke acch lotiti Thedeorei electrical transients wor'd applicbeaicc'crcear.

  • MatioicWe d.O lc troli.Icali Oo wel icceeo~d lovibratIcn we Ithon, iseotiaetn with wliv eeewonat that caoa vibration, Booaa Ity we p.1 dn ancmei ooerponuni they wet rM cotwlo 10 r--wQ egg s

-1teli

  • Cetroech~caieoiia.n SoleclIn cas a.dftiarpltS.

Reltin el" dd..

cori enicinerdals Ioo aretena Ituitlo plar Wirting. tben cotr dotrn plantS apeticon Sucth a releae. atd Isaloects. wotoci bew en t M~l On fclet c aieo Irtewclition, their locaim nsride ective conpwootcs protects Ithe rnitiloe potts dielootrielcolic coe tin'sronmetotnrchone Thereforeti s croncot 1. en apilicable,

  • Oxcidatim n -

ooeronon muetocy occur In th' pretnce d tro~tire a ortaffiroition etcoh ae Irdolusotr poehtIonst ctd coit dopoeitis.

Etolocone.

on mlic.ic nideriols proe"draltrl connections front

nnvituro, or oceerrnatiton.

Stern boned connections we econsidered pott di an ctli,* dnice ard :a n'rtei" nd by the lart briroenonoo Rule prograr, Owee wec no agig efltnts ro*4ring trocorrctt lot bolted oort'.otiot'. d coble Smnteo Since PNPS uirtoic'. cable connectoo'. tattlera ccerc neaitiew progrant ard tean o itictio doan a~gir n=tido dot 10 ncce connections.. nto Is nccedo In witiohn to1the Wrtwottc* Rtle prograný NRC PNP$ Lecad Ng~jw% Owo StrO.c4 lott Fb, 13d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 14 1 Number Status Request 30 Acceped 13622-N-124 In LRATdse 3,62-1 mde hig voltage Inudalor (SBO), you have al ted noaging offeic and no Ao Is r*iy,.dr You bathe itaed In Section 36222 dfo I.RA. thea PNPS 1. locald now, the ea o wk.. selt*raay Is coaidored How-.m salt Wpay oildUp Isa shorl-ler.

Coten based on local weeath cordtions (woot driveo)

Therdooe. you huve concluded lhit Lautace cordaniruso Is nol enalricable aging in'ctsism lor high voltage Irudelors at PNPS.

NUREG t800 RAw. 1. Standard Rolaw Plan lor Revliow

[k-Rocal Aplicalion lot N.1-, Pa.w. Pl1, Section 36222 ideltified degradation of high voltage ilrdalot In paeeoc. S salt deposits or mUfiac.

ocrtandtwo Vats. arorn.

ciderls ih sdoalu salt ane Indrtrial S"lu'ed car ooarniane Imsia, s-faces A large loalap, od conweiretion crities the oomnLlor voltage o track Wong fth swlace eno beeiy aid on lead to Ilaor flash oer. Surface 0ortannnaion can beproblar Inareea where flies we garear coeoaration of asrbarner p.ttle. such as h lacilitiss tist dicherge cod o* nor U luas oast whe.e salt eprey I. preodeMt. Irdtty apageding ecprileme Identified to potential of lose of olsilte Power "u lont dcposieion Poswibchyard ieuiatot.

On MIDech 17. Ite, Crystal RiveUt a3sepericed aloss ol th 2 kV ecitolyrd (wnr offtsile power to sady-rdale d losase) when a lipht rain caued icirng across sait-ladtn 232 iVinuailor and opened brais Inn witclylard in March 1993. the Brursick Unit 2 switchyard poerorcd s lash cerSof eons hifvollage Iraniakors The lncierl was crilboed loe witer steorm In th **

Sim*r OZ Pilgrim st.tic has alsoIs eperienced s-eda Ios dollsts power eoeos when weon storem dPositel salt onlthe 345 kV swilchyar oaasing the inidalor toare logruand In lidh S ihese Indalry and plait opedat ing erpriencrs, proeide f.iticaion ofuty iAM'P la m( necssary,

Response

As shown by the OE (Operiing Experience) cited In eNs imsstor%

filashover due to salt oontatneifo nof insaators Is cased by eents. lyttcally ato-m. regaedess of t. age o the Irsdators.

Thes Is cloerly rd 11.ct S aging Therdore s&rlace eortarrnaction lord anapp floos aging eschnronm for hitp->dage Ifreaors at PNPS sitho Ithe cdition ls caused by seies weate conditiorn =crelated I*o agi ancaging mreege progrom la r a KVcrla to address tlhl fcet HowWe. Wuile Salt sway loihdipi s af et-lerm cncesn beased on loal wpedar condit.n (wert-drlv en). aCh bldup ean case pr0fern with the oftae power s'Wy ystleo Boca-e Sea operating siperieure, PNPS heas -liled Sylgead (RTV silicwie) cairg o oorne awictyean Irsiatoas loroues flasaliva. The addition d Sylgeid to to k.l-a tor In At hai liktlihdood d lraifakur lhan r.

Systeon walkdowm we perfornmd at least eone par raluding cycle aid we r*Wrery pelf'raid emns Irs**tly todo a visual Imrpetion S toe ultwtcy*sd hIi-**lage ilsualors Vlst me Ir-ccoe of loese renewal Inac oodanc. with EN-DC-178 These walkdewn will*otitus Iio be perloreil into tie pwiod of elendcd eagaino LRPD-02 win be revised as follows:

The Systern Walkdown Program will brevised IoInclude ft vi"al Irnpeclion of Nhvilotage Irtialo rein-acape of llcene renewal.

NRC PNPS Lead Nguyeci D.

Sou4 Mk.

Pay 14d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 15 Number Status Request 367 Cleat 13622-N-031 In LRA, Table 362-4, udor swittchyrd ba and connectionr, pc y

aohs staIed tha hooing dfils reoqirinl engorat ard MAW lasqiredA NUREG tBM. Re 1.

Standard Rootw Plan for Review of Ucaes Renewal Application Ior Ncsleo, Power Plat, Sectioc 36223 Idklifios Ios od preload Is an aging afect for switlchyard bul corretons. Toqe toaxaaton fir bolted connection Is a concern for totchyard bus correctionr and trasaission orotdctor cor-ections. An sledtrica corwtion coat be designed to remaian tig sand rratan good fodlithvity Outa large learperalre range. Moding aIs deign rqurae.l t dilfficift *n serald specified Wtthe bolt and An couctor are difterel and have diffren raiet of taron eyaowio.

For ewrsa copper o ur.al w,

bul/cordsioor Wnerials spelrd Mast. thet mswt boting itdocole Ih.arS stiess isadded tostr-sse Icrre al ass..tY, An jori atbers or last-ers can ield S plastic deforuation wre dring th ersal lodig (i.e.

hietqP) whan ta connection coos. tPe ()or willtbeaose EPRI docmerat TR-10421Z Bdted Joinit lorerswce &

Agppicatio*t &W rscocr*,ads I.tec ion of blted 1*di.

or evidence dof-ehalir signs d blring r disolorsici, ad Irdlcalion d toes hods Pmoide adecasior. i.

twl Iorqe reFoato fIr boiled carootcion of wilchyard bus is no a conern fir PNPS.

368 Closed 13622-N-04]

In LRA. Section 36 223. y-hame sltatec t PNPS doe ri Silize trarwmission conodcto rs in lhe circwits lor reocay d Staita pow. lotionig am SO. Decrie 1*0 reovery Ipae-a fIr PNPS. Cortirm that nortaraftnsion coidCtora asre tlized In the circwts fhr recovery peths.

Sllcqt thleearasws with a

.main ow line dagrats

Response

AJ PNPS, bw to bt c**ecti*s wre waodod Ireland of boiled Switchyard bate ae cornn-oted by fltible con'oiots totaicolors ad tiac ateoront c

Sincea withanid buo is typicaly ladeora cstantr lad lberanal cyctingthal oodLd caase torque relacolion Is Irfreuert. With roooaectiaos lowlratirge apellna, *ibrationis na amaing siachanism Ia switchiyard bts. The switchyard on-csot s to thb otartp trasftrnr se pert of the active esattby rnitrianed by the plar srairlesrce progra Thdrore.

torique relaxatiorn Is ha ana*ing lst rairilng fftnr*aga hoa switctyard bat Inatdtili ternogrpy hI performad at test or0e wary6 orthe tornsiktan An irsogrity oft tscorroctiron The progisec witl cortir In tro An peiod of letaaded cpraon The preferred e-of oWtait. power oron ftics A 345kV swithyard The foodfrt Ahen awilctyard Ieoaens. 352-2 and 3523A betds by switctard beo bth startp Ira*a*aner, X4, and Pa berds by owcrgoiwnd cobeas both eddey basa In te plart The talecate ollsito power aouce cone freorn ft23kV awilchyard ad trews tIos breaerc 252 by unodlargoud* cables lobe shuAdown trareforna. X13, ad ha by crodrgrwod calete bobls A8. Fretn ASftn lpowe troeas by crorgicun d cables tothe sedy blaeias in the pIf.

Neithr PNPS recovery path for offtite power wee trardesorion ocroctors These palha astohw onFigos l25-od Ane IRA NRC PNPS Lead Nguyen. Owo Sroud4 Mile Ngyt,, Die Strood Mks Ifa 15d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.Ddf Page 16 1 Number Status Request 39 Closed 13612-N-c6 Slxttee. art VOW-aee (SSC*) relied mI. eddoy ervitysee er pieri evaluation to pw.*ca furclin diet

d..

,,.de ecevirew with teo "Ohesde cegddnee kaetdiontieehvd(IOCFR5063) wewliothe scoe Ci Uow.

r VOW 1 lyour atrrsdo ac (MAC)

... c Weo I. Od S80 requiremntse? Are all 20Cs (irchdrg sdodricet o-onpwwls) es-ieode wth AhC ewcaa lrehetel in th. scope, of licensee renewal? K t0" weed

not, mlan wPV Mn. N tOW wer p-oide an AM fhe Iorg-liro paesive S9Cc associafed wi~thttw AC sources.

370 Accoplal

[3022-N-06 Are all electricat erd t&C cordarivcl psenhatinta 20? I rid. prcIde Ah~s ard AWs for ton.EO electrical areS t&C ecrtatirw,erl penelralion. The AlsWe ttri Ircitoe bthl organc ( I.PE. XLPO. arx! SF1 trierat coni~clorlogla I Ingieson etc..) as wailta fnoerro etwerial C-oh as cabe ilattrs. spoxejee pctti ng conypoerds, correcto, pcin.

plugs, areS told gwonende).

Response

AS PNPS. the station blackout deed goneat or provides the alterrtse AC power source. Al SSC associaled withhe AAC desed ae In acope lor license renewal. Te LRA proide the song h m-goWel rariew ruLets for lo-ivedt passive SSCS aessodatel with fet AC power seuce In each decipline secton cithe LRA NRC PNPS Lead Ng.ye.x Dwc Ssroud Mle The PNPS IRA Seti-3622 willbereoised ra reeaIdlowt.

Ngwner Duc Strou *lAke

  • Sorne f tme p1endraion essenliee at PNPS are rut EQ The rce-EO penetraton aseetblies awe aubject boagirg nenree t

ereiew. The aftf meregmenwl review is procidel InAMRE.01 ar-me AWP fo pentaton assertly pigels Is provided Inthe non-EQ Insulated caebes erd conectiora proamrn will marege te gng dffectsof ft penetration Merty cabse ard conections. Tabel 362-1 Ictludes mhe selciced pnrelclion eCoxdutor ard cornnections In the lir tetm for electrical cabes and coreeion Mr e.*ject 1o0t0 CFR 50.49 -EQ.

The tntural repon for he k connmtliee, AMWCC6, acdresses the penot-aoen esser" cortponeri, aeds are seding dests that horm mhe radological ortrol berrierher cotlaitrert InhTatle 352-1.

The reiree aneamrdcre some lILRA Pba 16d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 17 1 Number Status Request 371 Closed

[G331.-P-0t Tabls a33214-1 throuh 33aZ4.35 adress non-saelny reated cwn'oSnere affecting seaty relted.stgrne H -owe

r. these 1.. le.

ads*... II sal h systems Inection 33%

Aoiliary Systerms. w.0.0

Owns, on these systers bdeon tosecton 32. ESF Systeon. and section 34, Seett "l Power Cwersion (S&PC) System.

Tables 3314-7.

14-16. 14-25, ad 14-28 we lor sysbem tal belotg to Section 32 ard tables 3314-1. 14-Z 14-5.149. 1410.

14-11. 14-17. and 14-. 8 Ire

[or systern that belong to Section 34 The Toble I Ifte referece also specifies Table 321 ard 341. The af.l report and the SE we based on.ysterns sadedli InGALL Repor sectin.

f ESF, Adiliary. aod S&PC systoes.

As written in the IRA, it will rn0e the audt report and SER corfusing beca.se to ESF syslemn swciOn 32 write-will irclude Tables from section 3.3o and the SPC yet-section 34 wrie-q will kwIrde Taeles from. eclion 33 Different relmenewrite theae sections.

Piasse justify whythe rn-,-sde.y sytlerm assocliled with ESF and S&PC systernm wre lnclued In the Aemillary system leactirt 372 Accepted 1Q33 1-P-02 Di.screpncy between Tale 331 fine item. and Tables 332-X Ior thoe lim nle 111W credt water cherl*etry owal analysi. programn an a verilficalion program such a on.rtime Inspeclion (OTI) program The Taell I itemt I cositern with the GALL reporl "nd correcty creits the charn'try proeani and the OTI progeam or lor pdart-epecilfc progrtm lesocredts chlrwstry and OTI programs. However.

the Table 2 line Itenr th reerence these Table I line Ite do not cmr0t the OTt pogran The.. Table 2 tine hen. however h.0e & Imro. 'N, or 'C'w~ch slel. t1 it 1I consisterl with the M.AP cobination inth. GALL Plea.e tusli17 why the OT progra Is 1ot crdled inTable

2. een th'ough I is creadled In Table I and Wrote A ilonies totea consitency with GALL for MAP ooenirelior,

Response

NRC Section 14 Irldoh al

,11 0.

yl.te-l Iveo Iht*ootd functicns Paod, Eraec th out 10CFR 544(a)(2) or ty*hsical Irneraction To IOicale IndvivW eystm Included In the rg n-garnore* rensw for (a)(2),Tade 332-14 Is $,1bcllvded by syslem For exanpl*, Taole 332-14-1 Is for h cir(culating water sysltem a syste mWolOh only

e. cor*pornerts Included lor (a)(2). For th cre mseWy system, Tale 332-14-7 shows thenne crts Included foh (a)(2)t K since to systmn hi also Inscop. he other reasons. Table 332-2 shows theowponens Inctluded h544(a)(1) and(a)(3)

The argin mananeentr review of the eystn. tW hwee fuecions OUs mot IOCFR 54 (a)(2) f phyica fInteraction, was done eparately from the r-iew otf ethen. with irnended furcio that 1o 0

IOCFR 044 (&)(t) or (a)(3). The redcs do tis review were presented seperately so Owl they oomld be reviewed eepaaeldy on th bssi. Ot physi*e pr 1 oirrity ralhe *tn yster furclionr TH*

0tOws a reniewer to clearly delingish which componret ty"e. In.a system were irlucded for t0CFR 04 4(a)(2) hoe "*siael Ireractiono Since moet of these. yster re eiliary syst-n they were added as paet oftt swiliafy Nysles section PNPS Lead Frombergr, Since the Ce-Ticr Inspection (OT1) Pfonn Is oyli*bl.*e boeach water cheristry Cortrol programr it i also applicabe lo each line Itecm Oha credits a water chetestry cortl program IRA Toble 331 Itotaoeo tht to One-Tirm Inspection Progarn Is credted along with the water chenistry cntrol prograns het line Ite, hr whch GALL recorMneds aoornoime Inspection to ortirm water chornisry corrd, Table 2 credits to OTI program through reference tothe associated Taole I line hlem This ruorcrese naerndne*r totho cohrrsry progoa.r dloscriptiors In LRA Appendices Arad B1to clearly Indicate " the One-Time Inspection Program willconrirm te effectivrenes ofthe WtVoer Chenristry Control - BMi. Witor Chenristry Conrlrd - Auxiliary Systrne *ond the Water Chernistry Cortrot - Closed Cooing Water pron*rre.

Petd. Erach Fgo.-.

Page 177d 77

James Davis - AMR-Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page1*81 Number Status Request M7~ Acepte jG3.31-P-03 PNPS does rel Ircntne Boiing Q k1ogrty Progmran Intha LRA.

howwar credta Cittm progmrarn W alternate lo the bohingr Integrity progrann The GALL Rqxdr AM' )O.M18, Bolting IrWaity, Prograr prwio. solaran eoyarci ma s In' othe 10-slmn

,w11 usohion spec~iicaly raoorom-midion asotaoolod with preventive 0330,, such as selection di bolting rnstaril, weaof cibr Ii ardo

-Mc ants arol witittional reo-r-witions of NUREO-139 Borne di the afttrrmta progratr tray beaaooapito for lpecolion h-...OWa dra not0 wkires. Ith prtwenthro action.-

Plasna clarify tow PNiPS trade threse rooonwtw~ordil whan w.ing attarrate, prograns, wr please cracit a Botilin Iteria~ty Progrn for the t variota T~o 22line Herne as appropriate For section a3, tis applie o ITabl S33. II. ln it-a 3.1-19. 3.3.1-27.

3.3.1-4Z.

a3.1-43, 331-5%, ar 311-711 374 A..ple 1T.3&1-P-0tt T~a lll33?. Rom 3111. 1or stolecrns withmagang afftofl curvooorwiifatiu Idia-agr.g tha GALL raconrarnb TIA to be wcahatod for satvretura gilrsdo-i rt.

Tha dacrasron aotio.Z sates. a-at tis line Itent was not wed In

.aaction 33, however st." ca.-

m aretwatale 1.n*action 35 Tact, 35.2-2 aci &S52.4 atkkaaa Grin.. b1A k, an a~rgeffedtl cib.dciWetrials. C-Arrald alg-o danaga of cranesaisrcm aoal wfsee ainsetion 35 r n tnl TLAA section 4.7 (4art1 specific TLAA). iAlo sao TLA queation.

Pleasa alpyben whera tisa line Hann as addressed Int ih RA Reponse ABcitirg Irlogrity Progranr willbedelocped Ot wllttmaasa Ith agrng of n

bagla inthei r ao f license reerwal A copy ct a

rrtaea nml progra baasisdoc d

n Ir to Wtirg Ilegrity Program willbelproided lor raiso with ft LIRA The Bootirg hriagty Progart willbaintrpl~or prior oothe priod d wdrtao operation Inraccocnk with coartrtitle rl-rdtm 3Z Thlarequirsaaarnamamerr lotha LRAbtrclude doscriptionsca tI-Boltirng horgty Progatr InA*g*dca Aarsd Bard m

oidtnity wheroatha prograc Is applieable Asdined In 10 CFR 54 3, a TLAA In a IIoaeea calculation or analysis that. roMr coa things, Involves fiý-lirritwl saamptiora defined by the currern operating term Theore In anatysia for sled crams. al PNPS that aatisfies the ddirlitiorn CMA-70 dcefinea allowable stresa range blasd ojniot category and sarvice class SeMce class Is batnl on load class (r.an etilve load Lador) "f a

rtbw d cycles.

Howa... the nr.o f ci yclea I. NOT basad on 4 yaws of operation dt Iis crane The arlicitpted cyctaa for th PNPS reactor bildg en a c

. we watl belaon any of th cycle rangas gvar In CMAA*7Q Based o-realistic atirratae arid 11-htoriol ratae o we od th r"an.. oa.

a-a PNPS reactor blilrng ar kratir

.lk.dg cr*me would take ovr-350 yanrs to reach It. rrirruc cycle range for CMA.A-70. Comewaryay tro Is no TLAA associated with a" load cycles.

NRC PNPS Lead patel. Erach Frcabarg.r, Paid, Erach Fincrn, Ron Fage l8d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf

-Page 19 1 Number Status Request 375 Closd Ti3ll-P-O]

Tabled.1, hean 311-5, lorkhS exchanger eiposed bo tr=d wafer G C (I40F), dascusaion oald. that OTI wl be wed ai vrification program for wao cl-han"iry.

lcwwer.

l:,

lone lIosnelai In Table 332-3 where iem 331-5 Ia r

.elasot OTI program h.not crailed See queslion G(3l.2 above 378 Closed

[7 I-P-Cm Taee 131, IIn3

.I-I4 f1 sted ciounarts fepo.eld to Itrlcatirng Oil. GALL report reconrerch lubricating ol aenlysis progam ard OTI as.a veriuication prog*am Howe-e, In fth docesio section only the di sartysis pregram I cretled Sectan 3.3227. tern Ist1ates OWa orerrig pwience at PNPS Ias nornirmnd "h effectiveness dlof the prom In naintairing cotlanirnth withn linits mh that corrosion hns not and wil rWt slecl li

-We Ereijor Ovis caqor, doo s

PlMn explain hw PNPS can make I.s slateart It Irspecon has rnt been perormnd.

Response

Sme the Owe-Tims Inspection (OTI) Program Is aplicae to. ech water cherniwry corcrd progan, it ls also applicable to ach line hoen M crdles a water chlanstry carcl progranm LRA Tate 331I Inrdateio a tin. Ons-Tiws Wpection Program I credited along witheiv, water chearaitry co*r*r progras for line hers Sr whmch GALL r

,tract asatin-,

vp*clkn tooortimr water Cha.iWtry rerd. Tabls 2credls the O0I program noug releece tobte so*cialed Ts I line item THs reuires asnrawt lothe chenioaty irogram descriptios in LRA Atpesdose Asard B to clearly dlcae inat the Ors-Tince Irspaction Progran wlllcordirm ft effectveness of Ins Water Cheiatary Codtrod

  • SMl. Vter Cherristry Contro* - Auxiliary Synlatr. and.he Water Coni*stry Conmro -Closed Codiing Water This Iten Is closed to Ite 372 During pelrformanrce d rourin rrnaid rce acrc on orna n o

conion lutricating oil. visual Inspesoho. d ten.e Oworvnwth would detly dgrwld cordtio nto coid beattributed tow Irdleclive Oil Arlysis Program The correcrhn acsOn program al PNPS hea s low ttsshcdd r ft-lderfioatian d degraded oon'lior such thno aoroste.

o creaking Of Corlpents would be Idontilied en pa of dtis program The rtiewo loperating eperience at PNPS 1w 1ft las* five years dd not kdernily cordlion reports no Irdoaed ani snldfectho oil alynis progran oa nO Idontidliw dagra cd -op.nen IS -ditons such s corrosion or craaking Ins lifricaling ol eniromerfn TTa tarrylo ating eperlence at PNPS so.ee In Heau O a -- thme Inspectin to provide condirmioion of d"

effectiveness o the Ohi A-,lynis Program_

During the Irat lye yearsmy visual Irapecs*,ies of opornse owtning litrialing nil haee been perormed during corrciveeard preverve rrairerwce actliviles., Th visual Irpecies of Unese onipnareis wauM Idety deg-adw o'orduim each ae corrosion or cracking In acid be att-ibuted to en indlfectve il Anlysis Programc PNPS as a low ineshDid for itn Vidionhifafon of degraded coritions such no orrosion or cracking of aonporends would be denailid ard wded I into t

corirslivo acton pinogram Nonondliwon reports o derstified degraded conaoe cordliona, mclh -=rcreion or cracking in a lubricating oil enaironrr*. were Inlialed n a reeiul di nOe Inapeohona These post ikpeclions at FIPS serve In lieu of a c dihne Inspection to prakide ondirion i ihce dlelivensies dO.the Oil Arlysis Program Paid, e rach Frosbager, NRC PNPS Lead Paid, Erach Fronbagar, Pag 19d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 201 Number Status Request 377 Closed

[T3S1.P-04j Table 3 3.1 hem 1&1-17 for steel elements exposed treaed~n Waler d ewnon states te OTI willbe ade w Verification progrm, for Waerd ch"W~ary. R.I.eW %"~.eei-T331.2 and W33.1.2 Tleis ppif sosem" line law. Invenoca Tdabe* OW ntelrdn it-3321.17.

378 A-aeped (l,33.1-P.C6 Tabl. 33.1. lmi 13.1-18 loe steal mid SS deeel a~ron eeleeel pip u Inth deoeeeon Ocokenrefe rdencesectoion 13.227 "Mn 3k lor th.e eedalsiort Secio 3.3227 it-3 sttese that the carbon at"l deed1 P-Mca pipling "

comonoents In " t ire prolectimn csyt"n lIsnnegac by, the Fire Pro'eclio Prog-t The Fire Frotection Frowarn twee nioalw inspections of dese at satmat piping ard conponred to mnnae lotw d material. Howener, A~pini 8.1.1a i pogrant claecnipticn wboohkiclonlifie S sp nlondor-aod lies In scope Ict Inspeclion icee.ut cobol. ft. hececlion ofIl he desel eeteal piping ard contowrtsl. Thare Ismne erernoenl klertiiied hll,.

program wrile~vt~co Ircolue fig isection lbrnig the period of eatWop eration.

Fleae, mpaidn lii. dacrepecy beweneri seclion a33227 Ile-3ard itreAkP~ al.13.1 progrant dencdplin or heolsl the Inspection 1n. teAKV e-an erietrnane

Response

NRC Since the One-Time Inepection (OTI) PFogrn Is applicabe to each PaFl, E.ach water craistey contrd program. it is aso aplicatle to sech line ibm S. creditsa waler lhenlwny no r'ol grogeam.

LRATable 331 Irdcales ttl at One-Tire Inspetion Program is credled along wth the waler ¢hTristry corol I proge*sa or linefianes Wo whoch GALL recommendis a

-onseine kisacon l0cod/irm water cherristry control Table 2 credte One OTI progrm throtlr Odererve tote associated Table I line heIm.

THe requires eneenckeni lote oherlniery progran deecriptiorn In LRA Aperdcee Aard Bto clearly Inclcale that the OeTime Inspection Prograen willoorlirm ft fle e

tineee ite *ater Choeristry Cornrol BWSM. Water Chrnistry Control - A.iliaty Systerm end ft Water Cernistry Cont0,* -Ceoed Colirg Water programs The It" Is cosed lo t-r 372 Erewnemerwe Will be nede to te Fire Proeclion program tooredl Paid, Erach eeisling or irrplnearl nen prwenline irtlmeenle tasn $or Ine Ire purp cdeed to morve W all aging effects IdeMoriid In Table 332-9 lineileeIls e apply tothe ireepump deedl conporen we adeuwately mneaged art reraed fotlionre ra9n irtireel withoe crediirig te delectlion oleakagnekasmranig agineg alect The recirme naormna eri IoLRA aplrodcee Aaed B PNPS Lead FronbaWrger.

Pabg 20d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 21 I Number Status Request 379 Closed

[TZI.I3-P-C6J Table 3 1. h 3a3 1-21 lor stle carpoties eposled Ib lutbricaing oil This Is hi usame Issue as in queltion T.331.3 dooe. except V*

fssoni Is 3.3229. Iten 2 380 Clousd

['.1.P.O7]

Tablee*1.

Isem3

-1.23 for S8hemu mclor*er comporans asposed 5toeared water. Tinsisthesime I-seIn questio-T.331.2 above, except th pectio, Is 332210, U-e2 Resonse Durng the perlormence of ruine nairawn.ce on*oompowts a

cotain kluricalirn oil, visual Irspscons of Owas chrporal wsold detily degraded cotditio, fla. could be attribued loa Ineffective l Anlysis Prosgrm The corrective action program d PNPS has a low hOrshiid Sm ft Identicatlion c degraded conditions such hVt sorrelo a cracking ofd ospowis wold dbe Icrtiwled as Part of sia progbam The review of operating ypeiarnce al PFPS for thr last five yests id rot Ideniy tany cordtion rports Owl Idcated as Indlectioe oil stlysis proram af hu idablied 1de.ahl sorpon s t co¢nd*one suh as sorrosion or cracking Isa lubriiry cil oir*rolrwsto Trrds resview opertsieinr acpeience a PNPS svei, ins iu c a on-t.im Inspection to Provide costiration oO f slsoiveares of the Oil Aralyss P'rogram, Drir fth psl fivt ypets, re visual Ispections slssomponests owttdiry ktutlcalir 0 otl hwoe beent perforred during corretive and prevetntve rintenace activities The visual inspections dtes awooulr s

rO Identify degraded condition suh as corosion a cookin Ma urd be atlribuled to an Ineffective ait Analysis Prosgrm. PNPS as a low Uneshold Som ft Idnlfioasiorn of degraded codiroras such OW corrosiona ocracking of ctonw s

wold be rlaelified ad aiowed loo te correcto action progam Noooilitiort r Os

  • ldat ified dagraded component
cordolio, such as cotsiors a. cracki Ina lubricating oil irý snir were Iritiialel asa reull o W*.

irp*sp ons. Thee last Itspsctiosr aS PNPS sane In sle of a ane-thie Irnpection lo provide confirmation sift i.affeciveress of the Oil Anaysis Progran TNis hae Is losed tolae 376.

Sic ft Orns-Timr Inspoction (OTI) Program Is aqyicdole to each water olarnstry ontrol program, his ais applicable tiosch line itm ha crtall a waler acemstry cohrol Pogramn iAA Table 33.1 Irlcabee B*ut the Om-Tire Inspection Program Is cradled along with ft water cerstry corol programs Som line htems Som whrchGALL rexrmmsnrn aonsw-tira Ispaclion OCtoirm wale' cohristry contro. Taele 2 credta llx OTIprogram Oveugh rdsorace lothe easociated Tales I ins hemr Tics raequir asasr ms-sw lotha cherristry program descrimlioe In LRA Appaodcea A asd B so clearly Itdcale folts 9

Cra-Time Inspection Program willowfirm the effectliowens of Ithe Wale Chlanistry Control - BWER WViee Chemnstry Cothrci - Auxiliaty Syslem and "t Waie, Chemistry Control - Closed Cooling Waler programs This hrt Icloead to hen 372 NRC Paid. Erach Patd, Erach PNPS Lead Ftmsbarger.

FPordb9r.

fPge 21 d 77

James Davis - AMR-,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 22]

Number Status Request 381 Ckosd IT3-P.P.C8l Ta e33f, ioen 331-24 foe SSaed alurinurm coorers-sl sposed to oreted water. The is ih ease Issuea In qustion TZl.1.2 above. sc.0t

  • ection 1 33.2.2 10.

iten 2 Thee weover 80line Iles ass*ialed wththlis In dflerel Wide 23.

Closed rrzal-P-Ch]

Table 3.3A he,3.1-26 Ir topper altoposoporon ePOSed toklbricaing oil. TNsIs ft sace Issue wn queslion T.311.3 aoot scmW the lectcon is&322l0.

fte 4

Response

Snce 1he O-Time Irepection (OTI) Psogaso Ia1 oiblte to each water cherristry cotlrol program flt i oo alsolicaeIo bach line lorn thl credltsawler oharristry contol progara LRATlale 331 Irdlates live tIe OfwTirns Irspotion Progas Is crudted along withhfe water cheosly conero proarse for Irlies fe lor wMich GALL recmronds conewtin Inspection locorfirm water chenistry conred. Table 2redts Ie OTI progon throU,

rdece-. lothe essoaied Ta.e I line Item TN. re*ires an wxlrn bo te ohwrdslry progio*n decrlptlio In LRA A'peadoes Aard Bto aInty 'dalest t he One-Timn Impaction Progrwn willoorfirm It elellctieness of ft Water Chemistry Cortrol

  • BM, Water Clesistry Controd - Amitiaely Syst1ne ard the Waier Chw,9dty Conod - Closed Cooling Waier progan's.

TNs hen Is closed to tern 372 During the peeforme of routine niares-ce onconpone-ss tW contaln oebricaling cil. vistual Inspeio*e ofithese cootponarts would kdortify docgaded condition te could beitributed toan Inellsctive C1l Arlysie Program TheI orreclive adion progrm at PNPS has allow 'rnhold lorthe Identtfioion S degralwd soodltions ech tel oreosion or cracking of corponees would be kidrified as peerl o fis program The rio dol openaing eoperieice dl PNPS a loth lasl live years dld no Idkily wy cosmolion reports l Inctcaled an Ineffective ol iwtysis progont or fed kidrlifie degraded *e*rper I codhos tuch as orrosion or ocsking Insa luricaling oil dvirronmrs This reviewonqOpeeaing cpeeie-ce al PNPS seoves Is lieu o ane-Iioe Inspection Io provinsde co-nion ote teactivse at oe Oil Arwtysis During " peal five yers,,ey invst irsua eiora cioerponasi.

Ohti'nig liubric.aing

  • lhave been perlormeld dueng oarective an preoslive tarnelarce activilies. The visual iupectioe cithese cornoonsos would kierlily deg-aded corcior scth-as-o-rnon or cracking Vel otid bea*truited toean Insffectve OCi Anwlyss Program PNPS Wo a low thres:tcd tot*e idMeification of degradod co-ilio such el corosion or cracking o sotryosort.

would beldontifihe sid sared iro the Icreclive action program Nocoendlion epots te e o

orlilid degrwded horl lpose-r wdtiors, euch as corrosion or ýracking Ina lubricaling oil sclirotw, were IritiaeWd "sa real chies. Inepetoohe Thee peol Irlpections el =NPS serve in lieu a ow-rw irsir tion Io provide orfirrmnon d "te atctlivenrs of ite Oil Arsysis Progaom TN. iteon Iledb horn 376.

NRC PNPS Lead Paid, Erach FPerotrgor.

Paid. Erach x !22fd 77

James Davis -=AMR - Report to the N.RC.doc.pdf..

page 23 Number Status Request 3M Cloed T3a31-P-10i Table 33.1t. hln 31-30 for SSeOerorancs

-ePoed Io sodiut, peaborale Isolutio Tis isthe sane Issue as In question T.331.2 above. ecept uh slection Is 13 22I0.

htj a 384 Closed 231-P-it)

Tale 3a1i, kem333.1.33 for SScenwoc*ws xposed to lubricaing oil. TN. is the ae Issuie as In question T.13.1.3 tb7.A eAq the secton Is 33z221i.

It-2

Response

SLes Ohe OCi-Tin. Irs otsen (OTI) Proor Is bagTica' l each waler heaeisry aold prog'am I. It also applicable to each line II.. lVS cr*afs a water ©cnislry woetr* ogarn RA Table 33.1 indcaes M to Ot-Tirni Impaction Prega Is erated along Withte waler cnhildry oetrtol programv for linarts lor wich GALL recoenvradr awono-Uirn Insmpeiot locornirm waler canistry owerod. Table 2 ýerlle ft OTI proga freem rder-n. bIthe associated Table I line htem ThN raedrea amanrdral tobtse cetstry progran doaerildow In LRA AFppdiea Adard8 lo blerly Indcate "- the Onr-Tin.

hrpal*n Progarn ailloonfirm the sfftlivaea df the Waler ChMsry Control - BR, Waler Chwistry Coered - hAillaey Systeas and w Waler Chwistry Certrd -Cleaed Cooling Waler proIngra Th ae Is bloaed lo ft-372 Drirg thw paiernses l roedia friarta cs oncenyonsraid wertain lubrionting oil. vsual Inspect d tsie samiger/a would Idertify degraded cordion l sa iould beOir*buled loan Inefective 0il An~ysie Progaren The worecliv action prograrn at PNPS has asow tvashld borth*

Intrialion adogadad wondtions etch Ol woeoion o cracking d ooopones Woeld be Idilliied as pad dl INs proga The reaiew of operaing aperaels a PNPO1. the lau s liveayt s a

rs Identtly any wondlion reporlt I Irdealted an Inoalelivs dl aralysis pregan or ta Idertile da gladl saoponen I wotdlions such as worroesin a rawking In a lubrkicsinri oil enawreraer.

TNs. ra*iwA cdqaaling atpetaiee S PNPF saew Inlia one-lire Impaeslion bo prav.

confirmation d us affectve-d the 01 AjtlyaiS Prograi During us past flye years. n" visual Inesptioer decrqtoerws ortaieig lubricating ol hhaw been plernd during s

oha-raieard prevenive linirenance aechtivit 1.he visetal iapalies d Ineae soarpss awould Idertify dgraded condtlioe etch as reilon or cracking IW could be atiled lo an Infaictie C0I Analysis Progam. PNPS bas a low Icymhold Ior uhs Idenlication ol dssayd sashdier-e such t watroeion or crackdng d cenagarco would be 1dartilied and ereed Ino us woreaclive action Pro*earn Necordhion rorli OS Ider ifled d*ogaded corporerS e*niliona.

such as e' s'aking In a luereaietg W*lal wfeers -ea Inflaled as a realt of tI-as lesecao-s. These peel inspetions S PNP; sase In lOeu a onea-rns Irnpselion lo prwide ceetirnaeion do ue fectinveras d the 01 i-Alysis Prog-am Tha itean Is doed lo Itesn 376.

NRC Paid. ErBch PNPS Lead Froeabarg*r, Paid. Erach Fronsarga.

A,- 23d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 24 1 Number Status Request 35 Closed

[T,33.1.P.I21]

Tatle 331, Item3.3.1-37 lor SSwconpoat wpomed lo IOledl da. >r0C (>140F). Th. line len applies Io RWCU ytsle ard GALL Repor recpoort ALP ]M5, BVWR Reanlor Wae Cleaspe Syslenr The aplican *lidea "SwOemwt I to GLWO-l Olain thai K=SCC Inpection a RWCU piping o dsi. de te Conlairnenl Ioldaion vain. Is reoeor-ded only Wll acuitans assoclaed withGOL9-t0 on, ncor oprlte aive.ae.oorrplede Sinte PNPS lea salisfaltorlty corroed all actios requested In NRC GlL M9-10. fe Wane Chleniory Control BWR Program s wsed In lies of lhe O Rae Wate Clesnp Systen Progm-to Menage thei polnial aging elfect. Howe*, ft AMP also siaw S"I addition to med lIng th criterior piping Is oWs natlerial that 1.r I.

imilnt to 3SCC.

Please co9-rm wcil grati sdtanreims niorlnN in wed and jutlfy tl it. resistant to K3SCC.

396 Closed

.T.311-P-122 Sarre Issue as qemdio T.3312 above aim> apies here whcre OTI is noi credited in Table 2 line Krens whce 3.a1-37 s rdareced

Response

NRC Origina Type 304 slainless sled piping and fitting between drfyall Paid. Erach penetration X-14 and the 0" x 4C resdcr donmrstrean d M0-1201-5 wemepulaced with type 316L. Mairoest s$led.

PNPS Lead Taylor. Ady Since she One-Timn Ispection (OTI) Progean Is applicable to aoch Paid. Erach water aranistry c<liro progan Ht is also amioadde eto ech line hen, tie credits a water Chimisry wontrd progran IRA Table 33.A Idicales that e Cto m-Tirne Impection Progran Is crealed along With th waer Choaisiry conrol progra1om for line ilere mI which GALL reonoranfoni see-ore pllupct Iocoolurc war.'

cIOisry ctntolrd. Table 2crllas t*e OTI progran thlrough rdefr*nce S letoalald Toasl I lire ien Thie rooirns morranw ree toite cheanrty prog"e dwScrlpiorns In LRA Appendices Aand to clery Indicate Ow the One-Tine Iepej0io Progran willcolirm the sllelvenna d the Waler Chrerostry Control. BM. Waler Chonristry Contrl - Auxiliary Systanm aid We Walte Crari.ary Ccora - Cloed Coding Wale poogroms Thi iemn is cosed Io Nern 372 Fiort*uger.

y No2rd 77

James Davis - AMR -_ Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page,25]

Number Status Request 387 Closed T.3I31-P-131 Table 3.1. 1,ier331.38 for SSooenponents arposed to treaed water '60C (>,1F).

Th. i. the sarne Issue as in quetion T 11.2 aboven Resonse Sims the OC Ti Inpection (OTI) Ptogram Is applice to each water cherritry contro prog*amn IfI alsoapicabe toeach Uni iem tHat credits a waler cIenistry cornrol prorarn LRA Tatbe a1I nrdates t

N he a-Tn Inspection Program Is credted along with the waler cheansiry coorol progrnare 1or lins R lo which GALL renoraot acnts-ime Inection tocortirm water chelnistry wontrd. Table 2credits N OTI progthrough rdererce tothe associaed Table I line lam,+

This rayiressnarnudaowtrothe oNchaastry program doeocriptimns In LRA Appendices Aand bto clmerly kidcal.,

the OraTimn Inpection Program willoorlirm the dfectivenes of e Water Chenistry Conror -SWM. Wter Cherislty Conrd - Aailiary Syslnea a the Waler Chardstry Control - Closed Cooling NI" progrars.

Thie Heam Is ctoeai t hem 372.

No carbon sed larts InNte W oil systel ea sed to air -cwidoor ar. Inctded lnacope for Iaa*

renewal. Th. WRA will be arweded tolrebraoi.he line Kam Intabe 332-7 oe carborn *led tan-to apoaed toair-oudoor. The discussion for b

ine em &3140 will be aner to Irate te line he ar Is used Thlsrerqdres asplertam rr endrr a

othN WRA NRC Pald. Erach PNPS Lead Fror-brger, 88 Ac.paled IT 31-P-14 Table 31., laen 3,1-4D Ib ed lank Indeed fuel oil lysam aqxoeoad Ioair-Ldoor a*dm awiroremt. The GALL Report reewrnard AW Xl C9 Abovego.ld Sled Tatne. howee PNPS Ia creding a iffered prograrM Syslam Walkdown Program. This program Is oonaistert with GALL Report AMP X].IM. Exlernsl Surlacae W orini.

While Nh Ssteam Walkdown Program Ise aoooplable alterabe rAn"greexo Steel Tarts AWP eI nleapc.ileot howa.e the Atovegoud Sled Tates AMP sncner prevenrive actiors aoocied. wilt A th are rd aterased in the System Walkdcown Prora Furherore Nhe GALL AM apecifiee wall tickness rneurearndl of t bortoam iK Ni s pqporld onte~e o *monene. Io.ýraions.

PIesse clarifyH the eoo tarks

.we ca(ed wilh protective pairl ot oating In acoo*lsr ewith irdatry practie, and whether eadla orcaLlking Is applied atte Interface eale betwean t. Nabk and N. fbadation asm pmr the GALL MVl l.W9 Pleasa sta.e how the tar* [a uppouted Paid. Erach Nichols. Bill ft? ZIo 77-

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf

__Page 26]!1 Number Status Request 389 Closecl T.1I.P.151 Tae 33.1. lIem 1i.t143, I" steel bolting aed tions.

b1ir Ingeosed to air -Iedoor esncrolieI (sduerel) or aire-Atoer (Externl). The GALL Reportc mmmd.

AM XI MieBtirg Ilngrity prom e howteer PNPS Is creiting a dffwwe pogram System Walkdown Progeein PNPS Irdc.ls hae thes*ystemi wallen progarn i. eintlat lo XIM. Exlernal Surfaces Ibtitring Progrwen Howewer, the XI.tc AP does nt lave my preventive actin. wherleg th Boting Itegrity Prograni c*ders preo*entive action Pese Justify how the pvereive actios d GALL NA' XI.MIS We a.diressed inthe. ssten walkdown prograin 390 Acetoode IT.alt-P-lO(

Table 3.3it. itei all-O8. ke sled exlenal sluacem WaP<.ed toair--l'oor rtdled (d(ermi), air Uldoor (Wc-e1). ad codenejton (dmernei). For those line itee InTalle 2s where ine lsTale Ilin Men Is referenced 6or boiling, sa Issue s colestSonT.

shsould befeel*tdrs teTable 33.2-10. LRApsge al-t23. for la t inelon eystl which rerences line hnm 331-58, Fire Prclection Pio rn I. cradled Plesse justify whly te Fire Preecteio Proein-was eel IdMrlifien lthe dectasion odurnn of Tile Ill.

ftemn3al-S8 or.LeVOewd thInLRAtoilude tis progren

Response

AB~dng eogrity Proli-wlillbecoveoped tW willalbbee tihe aging tin-gusime d bolting Inlho e<ope olicense renewal.

The Bolting Integi-ty Prograe wiilbeinmpleerield prile otho peeod d ederded opeation Inaoortdance withcomistrilne wnbe 3Z Thie rep maenenbimitothe LRA oirudedl o

descriptin d she Bolting Irlegrily Progamn leAtperosces Ae t B and to iartily where tin progran Is aglicate THid hen I. closed to ltemn 373 ABolting WI-egrity Proiaen willbdevioped that willgdrews iineing the effects of aging onbltling Inthe goope olliceree reenwal. The Bolting Integiiy Proge"n wli be inplenmrled prlor to tn period of ntedel ep*eral Inecoehrdee witht velnmi mwble 37 The WAA willbecealehied tolncfulle FireePrdeliton IotPigan inth detaesono If the 3al1-58 df Table 3,1.

Th. reiled disagson Itxt will read as lol.ons Th. Systen Walktown Progren mnnags I oss of mn tral for extend surfaces of gled onponnes. For mene fire prblieion eymeii cofpotrmf.

the Fire Prldetim Piorg-n nll nmr" loss (A ieeli." The Ndte lot the redled line inTaile 332-10 (sled hWis Va exposed lo W~r) will be.l emkrm *B"o 1 E°.

Thid requir enensen nt toft LRA toInuclue descridiono d tih Bolting Irlogr-ty Proga-n InA cpencse Aand Beand to busriy where the prog-en Is applicable T.de eire peel of Id.s Ien I. closed to Nen M The FirePrtectPion porte of lids Hen reqries anarnaemdi to the LRA NRC PNPS Lead Paid. Erach Froebargem,

PalE, Erach Ugrfdtme Pa 2d 77

James Davis-AMR_- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 27 I Number Status Request o91

[ce 3ed l331-P-I17 Tabe 13.11 NaIl l-1.

for 1d-sbnto fireebarler p

tration sels e

xsaposed Noair -mtor a air Indoor tortcoled PNPS credits Fire Protection Program and tles In'lot daciasion oolrn U thisaline Aess was rot

.ead nthe auiliary systemm tales. Fire baSier seas we walualed assltrntural oornjen InSecti.. 35. Cracking anid tlit arge In material p uoperl

s. of olasorr
s.

ar manage by Ot Fire Prolection Proganm Hoev.r, In section 15. Tade 5.2-6. BuIkComvowliee, onWsg 15-8z and 35-8m, where lineiltem 3.3.16 Is rvierced PFNIPS oredtIs lbe Fire Protection Program and lie Shrrlures MAnitoring programn Howevr, line Sam 311641 cea ret e"IlCedit sitrure mcriloring program Assa rrsllu d lafct, U S".uc.res or loing Program Is

/t.enced i0add giiece for Inspection d Weleorrc seal.,

.c. Poess daily N both Programs wecredted for nwdng agrig lutrs fit pendration seals as sited In Tabe 352-6, and If so., pmse pselronwt the LRA So incude the Structures Isbiloring program InTable 3.3.1.

Ilem a 1-61.

Reponse NRC PNPS Lead In Tale 352-6 on Page 35-82 of " LRA, the egng fecr for Ath Paid. Erach Ungunddtuer.

doaslorm corlonert peetration sealarl and searoc joint filler in a protected from welher nirmn*erw awe cracking and clange In material Properties Depending lite specifio s

.i.adiorl, At Fire Protection Progra-mo r ie Sireute Irtorilorirg Program wil r-r.pge af ctdu ot agog For dtaiifoatoir thea o-porni lit-airns will be separaled iro individal line Ierns as ftofs ODaot ft bllowing lit-it-Peneration selsil(fire risect 5oo radialion) H/EN. FB, FILB, PB, SNS

  • Easlorrer *ProFecteal Irom weal-e *Craeocig Changs In trlelal propeties I Fir pro(eo tiortrlcrtures IMcniloring //iI.A£1 12 (TP-7)*35I1-M
  • 1C Smisio joir1 Allu7/FB. SNS2//Elasloer */Protected from weahtr
  1. Crawkrg Chige inerraeial propert*e #Strr*es Montorina FireProtu.li6n *V1I-I (A-th)*331-61 &C Add ae bollowing lire Iter Penetration setalt (fire rated) N EN. F5. PB. SNS N/ Elastomer N Flotacred from wemther NCracking Clan lnrrmalerial properties #

FirsProtection 71.0-l(A-19) 3/11-61 lB Penetration seslait (floot, radilatior) N/EN, FIB, PB. SNS 7 Elasloiner &*Protected from weare#ul Cracking Chlgs I nmairial properties /*lrre*t-l urtoriloring NI MA-12 (TP-7)715&l-44 IC Seisrc Isolation joire /FB, F

SNS*#Elaoorrnu 7/Protecled from weather N Crackrng Change in materal propertia 7 Fire protection I VItO-I 110(A-l9)*11-AI

/D Saisrro latidin join Jin MS

  • Elaslomno I Proecled from weather I Cracling Change in ntesri properties I0Sruciuretw irorrting #

III6/-12 (TP-7)l1351-41 *IC TNs r.rers aanamerdrnw jolla LRA Pa 27d ;77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf..

Page 28]

Number Status Request

Response

NRC PNIPS Lead 39 Aooeptd jT.331-P-181 PNPS bee edged dliver fir.prip wilthvonorv addtessed In Paid, Erach Fractrger, Table 322-9. The fud oil SLiy lolts dead driv flrepurp Is Table 3

c31, Ite 13.1-64 for sled pipirU piping Ircludcod InTable 112-7. The rneieAm of deeta sled piping wilh aoanfp, aod piping dlerwcs apoed tocfS dl. The alfuel oilIrnalr alrov ol In Table 332-7 ors Vofuel cuply Irmel ofl Ire Ile to addrlha to daed-dlven fire purrp.

line does eol credt "Ie Fire Prolecton Preyare.

lthmc ft wtich Is why *t Fire PFoecton Prograrn In reoocrsrrcld by p1ro'anr cradiled inTbloe 132-7 ore f

fuel ely line provide en It GALL Report pNPS sIes toit l1ine itehr wasnor acceptalie ailairaive alcroach ll rca-e ft imlects, deagir In csed Lose f rrheleriel deled orponerwts ecposed to lid Order toS e eveoneistercy with NURE-I0I fts LRAwill be

.i was. alddrsed by olher Ife Irn-leding line hrre 33.1 revised ID credit the, Fire Ptdectio Prorra.

tLRATablAe332-7 will 2C and "II 3Z The Firs Proleclion prvoran specfies tO be revised coaed ailnadii<-al line Iter Socredt t Firs Prolecthv to dad drivr lrepcnr be perioically lested Io ensre Prom So lorrege te lid souply l ire adntion lol le Diesel thot lid c lire 0:8 plefowm ft. Ihe le d knlior.

Fuid loktirng Progearn TH* will also rumires *vw-e So line PNPSB..131 hee reltaken "r xcgepion to oits tel ard her31al-64 sinee n.

cw linehr willepecily 31-64 Mse.

1s idmtlidfie as being conmisted wilh te GALL prograen Table I hmer M-eam.,

1.111. FirsPraoectlion prograr Is rot edled In lire Ierr a 320 The reudrgte anarnoleml ISee RA

Pleag, lmilylI'IPNPS be edged driv fllre puy a fi f rnd, sled naoeplo bltaker See.t GALL Report AP.

H PNPS dos have e deda driver Ire purp where Int IRA saclion, IS C addras ed l3 Is the Fire Prolecaion program wedled 393 Claed ITI3.1I-P-I9l The tlemral vorponris d the hr exchnger holicg twoe se Paid, Eract Orliod,,J ok poteriael Sm being gpoed teea vorbretion d low leWrimatre Table 3.11, Ith 3I31-72 for msled HVAC dcing ard dloyed coalirg water ard Ngh dowpdrn Irdoor dyrywdl adr wltch ocipornls Interna surlscelea opined bvorcdereairon oovid reait (heefh nor awIodl) Inwondeceadivr onthe yoolng (Irmred). However. tloe Is zoI-.llrlnTdle 2where fnis cil*

would beoidlecled Inthe tbaon doe lto.sirg Table I inie hrem Is rdmecced This line hm. Is inTable Codeeetion was also Ielmtified onthe csnireodvld asmed 312-3. RBCCW syslrm ad theocnponran Is had scrace od the feed

.cP.er houeing cto loee poleald dtof geoherger hxingF PNPS estat Int dvcugion codurn hewing sLflee eorymalure deorwnreran df tho oing veil hIirg df lire 3 1-72 t looS. df rrerial d sled vorrponat laws O or eW to Se dew poit d toe erocrreig or In e rnll oerfaleo*

s aped So vordO-*elion Is -

god by dywdl. These oirvirorre*tra wine comreivaelvy Ior'ified aere ft Syste Wlkdown ingrant The Syer Wkdown Wh-0 the teypected nirovimerl would be intoo air withrno Progeare mc gas beeo d of erial for calmed -aton lied vonnoledion iree se toding waler tleqeralre Is nornasly cornoan bsyl iýlu c-speclon odf aterdl elacas For reiutarned is - 6F. Spuertn ikdown wascredled because to yer mwhrme Ilrte,-l caibo sleed surfaces e ar posed to oipoclod envirormner for bot fto lmed ard aImternal soralea n !ivin a oterlnal edaca. atrter-l woUd bee. ge, In ither cas.

seraoes oordtioc wllhbe relren lived Intereal elucefe.

This, low d rnlmial on Inrle rnel carbon slied alulae Is also naer d bye. Syiern Walkelwn Progre Please dlarily how PNPS xroIlcd to the inrleo l slaisce df to hra chenger Is l

earne as tot elernl elurface in the RBCCWsyslmm P'w 2d 27

James Davis - AMR - Reportoto the NRC.doc.pdf Page 29 Number Status Request 394 Acc.9el

[Tr332-P-01l Coantpw typese ilt. Ihouing.ad turbo clh'ge, InTable 132-1 Fire protection -Water ryster and piping In Table 332-f10 FireProtection - He*n syete-raeri-e Tale 221, Item 3tZI-3 ThsTable line Itsetaddeeses sled ping mad dating compon~en atd Interral urfaces Opcped so air-irelor uncrrametml ad (iramre) erwirorartee Discussion Wdmn at item 3.2. 1-32 credts System Walkdowart, Prodc Surveilla*ce ant Franltive Wrlrarenete mad One-Tim Inrepection prograns. Howeaer, the Tate 332-9 and Tale 332-10 sporan-s idenetfied tanse cr-edt Fire or-tection Proaa-n wth ic rat credlled in thedlscussaon ciid.rn diten 321-3Z Furthwrmore, the preparn deecription of LRA Apedix El 1.131. Fire Proection Progan, does rt Include Irepealion aft. tabe Iderfied aoe-parets.

Plee clarity the olsorermrcy betIwn the cradled prOgar In intle 321-32 art ft proararn crad1ed tot ft above Idntified coa we types. Also. ptese jstity wly In Fire Prateitio prengarl descriptian does nt addres ir-pectiof'a lea coreoponar typee In thee two esearns ar enhance te p-ograem Iairclude tee impectioms W5 Closed rT1332-P-021 Coponel type head mcerge latee InTable 332-4, Emergency Dieed Genertor eynten atd Tate 332-9, Fre protection -%.er splelse wme fard itr copper alloy apd e*posed bolubricating cil ervirorert whidch

,rderence Tate 321, Ite 321-9 PNIPS ony creditel tie l

kAeysis prorage Tne heniate eas el ryetior T.31.3.

Response

Simns I ewsges Irierrew and tlerntes enuaces withtOe sare Wosrld and envirarnerls, the Systen Wftdown Progrem described InRt10 is l

more aprocpiate prins aan e

oa ta e line taere InTable 332-9 tet hwe Indoor air (ire) as an eswlronmert atd crelt tf Fire pratection Pregarc In adolitio line Item 32,1-32 should include the Fire Protection PrFgarn sirce Tatle 332-10 Inmluaes Halon,yeten piping Imterpal surfaces tIre credit ft Fire Fpateaction Progr-a and ratlp blthe line ian.

Therisreranarernw mlaw lethe ILRA NRC PNPS Lead Peitd Erach Froreberger, Ouringtheperlormarce aroutinr n~iteirawe ancanwweeli Paid. Erach Froaellrger.

corain lubricating ol. vieui Ir-pectiore ofa the corqnonarts world Identify degsaded cordlions OWl Cocld beattributed t*t Inbelctive it Arreyuie Piog-are Th. corective actior p-oag as PNPS hs slam Ithreshold tortst bortictcaio od degraded codetic,. etchthat corrosian a cracking of coatpants woadd be identilied aspart oafiepaog-ar Thercisewoaoperlrng expererces at PNPS toa te last lv vyerl did not Identity aty cordliac reports U indiralced an irollective dl anlysis prograrn or 8t eidrfied dagaladd carnern Itcodaiion etcheas corresin ar craclkng Ins lubricaing oet emrironerrll This reisi cloperaltng eapederce al PNPS emaes In lieu o a stier.Sn Impectimo to prakle rdiirrtion oa th effec dtives the 0I4 Arnlyst.

Proretn i

See response 1. itern 376 Paw 29d 77

James Davis -AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 30 1 Number Status Request 39 Closetd

[r.32-P-03 Cwno1 tyvpes hod ecea w lubese inTable 332-5.

Station Blackou desel General c, yslem ard Table 332-6, Security DissI Generaltor syolern wetrade trom sled ad epose.l lo arto`Tel st.lvr-..eO ofhd oil with an aging elet of tredoctic of hlot trwanfe dot Wointogr which relere-ce Taole 341. ahemr 34.1-10. PNPS only orecits the Cf nlysis progtant ThN hosue I. im sae as In quisleon T.3.31.3 Aso, plme clarity wt/ne oft.

aove convoow Ihtos kleorutie Iodinre r.hne.- he Ime-ide-Witifios Wlote I.V -

toh fey hove thle soa REAP sontntion.

397 Closed

[T3.32-P-04O Stoa co ore ypes I"e-rornell. tublingr valve body In Table 332-14-1%. Oat-as syst*rn rdlerence Table 341.

ltem 341-13. whichcrelts waler chemistry and oe-Urn.

ilmpction proganr ifr verifcation Howver-the ltae 2 Jim Itene do nc Crudt. veMiticoast prograen This 1ste Is I.

as ueatiho 0.31.2 arN T.33t.

Resonse NRC Duringth. peorlirroncs ofroutne rreirde-wnne noorvpone o ow Pdlo, Erach seortit lubricating; cit. deeud trpeystione of those wqine-ona "nod.4ide-dy dsgeod sordlor l thaUcouldbefrihbued loaen Ineffective Cil Anlysis Progran The corrective action progrw a PNPS hs alow Throeald for ft tcolictor of dguraded sordtihOre euch fl-.t scorreio ar cracking of c*ornlers would be Watilfiel as pet of fis progran The revisew of spering soperie-ce Sf PNPS or the last five yeae drs Idellty anty ordtion reports OW indicated onltrofective dl analyuis progran or Ot Ide-sified dgraded w iv, a I corftiore euch as corrosion or racking Insa lubtricaln oil environrnrot This reviewo of opering epe-ience o PNPS se*ain RI ran of ane-hire Iimpection to Provide co:firir-ion of Ow oectiveso the ail Arnlyuis Provwen Dicing the plot five yeear, nme visua Irpectie of cwr*Tptr containing IsXing oil hove beer pelornod during oc-roclive and preve-tive rmrteano ce ecfvitim. The visul Iepectiwo of see oorrp:wws would Neotify doadul c*dtioi we uch as corrosion or cracking tow oould besatribued loon Irnletios 01 Airetyais Poreogm PNPS hte low tfivhod lot t.

Mdotification of dagralod contiwns such tha corrosion ocrcrcking of owrwos woud be ilrsifled d '"'wed Iho s. se-rtlivo action prog-am No cordtion reports ltdi nf fl*e d lgraded wrporO eoidteom.

such as crooirn wr cracking Ina lubricating dol envirornr weer Irstioted ass resl dtee -

inectiwone. The eepla Irpecliwoe S PN PS "e-in lieu o nwe-f ire Inspecion to provid.

oortirrntion oft. electivenesof the Oil Ardysis PFiogto TN.o Itf Is clo eto Itu 376.

Sice he Oe-Tirne Inspction (OTI) Prog-oo is b

liabie loeach Patid. Erach wClea chlnistry wordroi Pograt. it Is also applicalelo oeach lire ern ht crredis a wale-chaistry worol program LRA Table 341 Irdcal ha tlthf Ore-Tine e*npection Progran Is credled along will, the water chlrnstry wontrd prograne hor line hewm for Which GALL rsconrrds arse-line Irepeclion loorirm wader cirnritry corol.d Toate 2 credts m CMi prograrn through rde-ence losth associated Table I tire iet TN.s raequre* an acre-l lothe chehistry p*ov-un doacripin inLAA Agerdoes A ard Bfio leely r-dcateo Sn a. Ore-Tine Ihpection Progaun willoortlirm *t efectiveness ofthe Water Cherislry Cotrol - BMW. Wale-Cherrisiry Cotrld. Auxiliary Systems and ine Waler Cherrtry Cortrod - Closed Codling Waler pro-one.

This teis closed to uern 372 P-PS Lead Frorme*gb.

Frordcege.

Pa-g 30d 77

James Davis - AMR_- Report to the NRC.doc.pdf..

Page 31]

Number Status Request 39 Closed (T.132-P-CMJ Stdrds stoed copoee tpem

'fioeewdf.

toing asd veato.

InTaolo e 332-1419. Cit-Gas s

-lee rdereree Table 3AtI, iee 341-14, whichorodls waler ChweeSVy and oe-time Inspection prograrn toe verilication. Honwver te ito. 2lieu fler-s do M wedt the voilication prgo L The lathesmoe 0ssqes.ie-.

03312 and T.331.2 MW Closed

'r.132-P-06]

Sted onpoerl types saeojtbr.

hw sscenger slell,-roe, pipirng puep casing, 0te-reodl, and valve body InTable 332-14-19. O1-Gesystem edoe-e Tabe 34?. Ie-341-a wthichreditewalerdteesley and oe-tim Inspedion progran lor verification. However the talds 2tine Ilte-do re seadit tfh verifiolote progra THs Is thu

.seI.

qts ueeasltion 0331.2 and T.331.2

Response

S-thews9 GesTine I upecIs-l (OTfi Peopen Is eppioall tossach water berenistry ce-trd prope ft Is also epplicable to eah line lIem list sreols swaole cheosery wt progrpme WA Taele 34.1 Iedes. that. Ore-Time epeltion Peog*em Is ea.dted Wong wbhfw waler chlrstry wordl pnogrene lot line It" for which GALL recommends aone-itrue Iepeion t toe-tirm water th"slry o-rled. Table 2credtes hu OTI propaen through rdereace toWhe associated Table I line ltent This resiqre anroeremou lothe chenisle peograem deseiptions in LRA Apis-doe A asd B to olsarly idicate that th Oe-Tim ilnsppeioe Program willcoef[rm ft eolectiveness of th Waler Cheeistry Coilrd - SMa.

al*er Chetnstry Coetrol - ALiliary Systlee and the Waler Chenistry Coderol -Closed Cooling Water progrn Thisfie

.close b

ltern 35Z Sice 9he One-Timn Inlpection (OTI) Progen Is e icte to each wmter chseietry Cwerol prograe, ft Is also gicaloee to ch line item hw cretls water olmslry oetrol program WA TeTte 341 Inecales 9w uhe OCuTiee kIpection Pograom is ceedled along wit

" water chemeistry worol propre-lor tine itees to whlch GALL recoreee aeo e-tinu Inpection towceirm weter ctwenistry werod. Table 2 creeits the OTI prograpem Werooh rdserce tot seste lacted Table I line ieen.

This e-sres annexewroeul loh echeltry ogropm descr0iwe In LRA tperdoes A and B Is cleery Iodicate the the WaC-Tinu b-pection Propam willworirm the ellectveruss df the Waler Chere*rley Cnterod - Ban. VWV"e Chteristry Codtrel - Auxiliety ystey n ad Wa Water Chenistry Coderod - Closed Cosirng wl progrnsr This Ite is closed to ten 372 The aqtorqiesio entrie she Wa last lirseve.dres leo the line In Tabe 332-4-27, RWCU ryste, sled wepaee type It eChev shill, InVesled waler orviroent wilthean a died of tossde

.ere. areVll.C2-14 (A-25).31-47, ard D.

This resires anaodwtelothe LRA.

NRC PNPS Lead Pstet. Erech Froeabarger.

Pedl, Erach FPrelrger, 400 Acoeted (T.132-P-`7]

Table3.32-14-27. RFWCUsysle, steed ooeelnert type hostel esobseer "Isl. In Vrowed waler eýresi wrl wimthn sOng efect d o Iw oenetial, PNPS credte Water Ch-etistry COeltd -Closed Codling Waler progrpm and reerenses Table 3S3, line iten 331-17. However, tieu flee 331-17 afrheses Waler Chereistry Ce-troe -.WA

program, Shtid tine Iter 13i1-47 be referenced whch adlressv the Waler Ciereistey Codedo. Closed Costing VWalecrlefu se-Mu EAP coeetentie? Plate asev4ule-the W.A acso rrdvy.

Pat.. Erach Ungerfditer, aep 31 d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 32 i Number Status Request

Response

NRC PNPS Lead 401 Aceepled

[T332-P.Cli The apjxoprtoie TaleI tham, entry for the line inTable 332.14-27.

Paid. Erach RWCU ystem. stak.es. seed cooponri type orifice. Instraed Tabe132-14427. RWCUsysten, stailamss steod water orwironmert witheanegng afect dios. dnsatial. Is corponera te crific. lntraded water envirornmnt with an 231-24 agng elient d Ie.

f nmaerild, raloencas Tale. 331. line lien, 1.1-17. Howener. fheline i*a 1n for sledl Tisariree anamene d'wt Both. LRA.

cornporniis Shtad line hen 111-24 bdeorlere*od, with aftdes.

etoioes. lsed components for t.

same EAP? Ptanso afoorean the.RA acoordnqy.

Ungeidler.

402 Closed (35121.4H-0 11 Loss d iterial di toGenaal,. Pilting and Crevice Corrosion Ptans., fpsatn for last a.lemea In this section ae it said Thief.ore signifterl corrosion othe dr/ywl shdl Is tn epd.ene. Does tie tree yoe DO heeo eom corosim? If rnot why si-;rlart 40 Closed

[lS221.7-H-0 11 Strees Corresion Cracking (SCC)becnmee eigrnicanl for stardns sled If 0 tensile sons and a cor-rsIo nirslror*rl *it The sirons,y be toplied alenereJ or resdtud (iternel). Vivsue VT-3 eaesdtfieneo tny be unable to g

etc tis aging deno Poetaler etcelhtie cronPanss at PNPS eve perosralionr sleenve and bedlows Plesse Woafity Ith Othen mr*eotd e*n*aninetin to detect thse seyloe dent?

404 Closed 3,52211-H-0 11 Agin df strisior.Io C-srna ty Structureshfttilornrg Do yes (PNPS) hIns "y operasing enperince rtaled to ot.s Mnes? Piens, provide the daotl.

As statel In Section 3 S211.4. PNPS Is.*p.nor. d the Orywell Ho.M Dan "Ibel -

floor tend klortified no enidone d corro-in of the drywdll shell The dywdi sdelf sled hae eocaed surfae and o dtogrdaton of thes coing wa Iderilied" The etate*en In qewsiorn It non addreesing he curet coidtion toe raher the Conditione oqenled tn the tiworeI ts ilifftcl to smy tene willbe aloduety no corrosion othee tier tbt fthee is ressorate nstrance Vae co-roeior\\ IN ary, will rn be sig**ilcat or tneinntdL with re*pect to degradation The ect-method which tny be teed ioddect cracking Is th Hoang, Dan emisting Corlaininmr Least Rale Progren withatgnerted Utreoric arre Cbeerved cordtt het twe the potential for Itpeding ean inenrded functio w'e enal*ated or corrected Inaocor*larwe with 0e oreetive adji*o ploms. The Cotisnmnent Look Rate Progam is desoribel InApperdix B As staded InSection 152221 d th LRA. PNPS has noetrurtures Hoenw. Dan et o nte cotered by Strctre MonkorIng Prog'airnd I

ae within In scope c locer.. rtaosal ard ast-toe teengrginset review.

Atortti, Rlza Ahrabli, Rwa Aheatdi, Raza 405 Closed 135221l8-H -011 Thie Wiholates associated with Ite ratal besm seas ewe Impenedl order the Structen Mortoring Programs The oilte Lock Up dte tnwear bor Ljvite Raea teen, Seats InBoW tldes essociated with the tor.. etjpeul sVtetr.e sIn repected by 6d Mait arid otiesr Slidcn Sw~pwit Surfaces. As Inicated to t.e 151 3tF) program INe seclion hi

..look-cr de to towest Is ro ant o

in efec recLdring teregaennt N PNPS. Hosever. Lutrile plae eve Irou*ing wiithn the Strtures Monitoring Program and Insoroce Inspection (ISt-IWF) Pronam.." Please, provide nhe cross rf'rerce, Inbetween these two programs Hoe.

Dan Ahrtali, Raze Ae 3?d ;7

James Davis-AMR - Report tothe NRC.doc.pdf Page 33]

Number Status Request 40 Closed 3&52226-H-0 I1 Aging Sqpport rel covered by Stuctors. Monitoring Prose Plese providc

1. More Irdornulion Is needed abtol boiling sate-ias wed lI strhtoral applications atPNPS Irnludng WGroup B1 4poitliona. W a e the bolting rrsfterial wed?

AWe a.e te roni"l Veld strengths end Wqn-bomwl es-rd eved yield sttenh? Desorie the PNPS radiOon ofthe tonng Interity generic Issuei M relates to strectral botling Was aent SnCliual bolting Identfied as po*entally aveejplablea ocracklng dee loSCC? Was ens etrlttrnal btlting rep.0oed -

pent od. h remoio?

2 Describe he scope and Ah lot Class MCC Pressure Raining Bolting How Is loes d preload nweged?

407 Acepted 135.1-13-H* 11t InTatie 35.2-I on Page 3.5-51 lothe LRA, lorsonprtent Belows he AWe shown Is Cio-WE. wnhch 1l a pian-tepedfi. AMP. A Note C hns been aesigned to this AMRline Ilern sorponerw Is dtferen, blo corsistern with manteli. anvirnowmA.

ing sect. and aging neragowant progran Ior NURE-I3180t line item Ths AW Is oomisterlt withNUREG-101 the GALL description Table Il, lien 3 5 1-13 bellows. Explain how the plan-epcitic FlNPS CII-lWE AMP Is consistent with we GALL specified AWP.

Response

Need Clarication

  • oW Is MnOe by the bolting Insegity genrelo Issue?
1) Boiting mawleial o PNPS mon=Isis ol A5 -Type loonornrrng to ASTI-A32. and A49D Type Ioortorning itASTM-A4M. per PNPS specpihcation C-94-ER-C-E3 The norninl yieldsrnength lor A3251 s I bsl ad IorA490 Is 130 bol. For stnluctural boling apications, PNPS Is consise with NUREG 180 InI ateging the eltects of aing with d. structures moniloring progan or tSI (IWO). eapegicate. NosPNP$ bolting has been kIdenfied OWe Is sisoepitie Io sCC.
2) Ingenera, PFPS traeges loss of nrerial lot booing with vistis Inspectionr. For tlrucliral tolling, he visual ISpectiwe e paen d she Snrctures Monitoring Prornan Ltss s preloed d6e lI sres relaxation (cresp) would orty bee wroern Invery high tetpenaturo aplplicatione (> 7 F) as staled Inte ASMIE Code, Section I1, Parl D, Table 4 No PNPS s*metural bolting openales at >7=F.

Therdora, Iose of preload dbe tostrness relaxation (creep) Is rut an applicabls aging affect tor nILcturl boItling oher ca die of los of preeld linclde Inedeptele booed Jort design and Indefectio irsintenarce pracstcee Loss ofpedoad du tothese caties Is prevented by Incorporation ol IrdiAty gutidn for good boiling prachoes Into PNPS predeaite bor design and neirienense of boi*ed jints.

Un Itern 3 S1-13 addresses la, esrniestseel,arned, disinrila inetal welds: lrm vertlfin vet headert, venllien bellows and dowrnoiners For PNPS venlline bolbvs and associated welds, Is line lets Is ooneislat with de NUREG-1801 AMR rmlls, Id the PNPS CII-IME progra described InAspownix Bisea plana-specifia progrann The Dryweftlalorls vent line bellows hIen

-n LRA Page 35-51 rdelenen" live itho 5.1-13 and correctly Indicts. Note .

For the Bolows (reactor vessel aed drywell) line iteh In Tale 3 52-1 onPago 35-51 odte IRA, raeten-e tolIns etnn 35.1-13 Is rul apiopriqetr he hTble 352-1 line itei aBdloes (reaclor vessel ard cywell)'and the cnresporning line iteh In Tale 24.1, Page 24-t13, were ine

'lenely Inclcd~l 1l.he tRAand shoid be ddeled The reactor vessl ard drywall bellows perform m license renewal ineded iorclion. Those.oinorts aen not Wealy-reated and weons-required todeornntrate conplience with regulations Identified in10 CFR544(a)(3). Failueod.he bellows will r'd preere sat'isfolory c f-onnniishvn*

ol ety fasncSon.

Lekge, If any. through tI bellows i ircted so a drain sysnem OWe prevents the leekags Iront cotacting the OWdr surfoaced the drywell shell.

Deletingte linelIterns dscosed taove recsiree enamnerohnaot to we LRA NRC Hoaer Den PNPS Lead Adsabli. Rena Hoeng. Dan Ahtrall. Rera FPa 33d 77

James Davis-AMR -, Report to the NRC.doc.pdf

-,Page 3:

Number Status Request J0I Acceped 35.`1-t5-H-01O In Table a52-1 onpaep 35-55 lthd ULRAf Primy Corainrnerl Elecrical Pena ration seea and iaist, lime AMP shown i.SrFWursee onitoring The appicat Is asked 0 nslfy that Ite Cll-lYP AMP will nor be.di In-d lo r-rege the Iagig dlft rnoistur barrier.

Rewonse PNPS prinsary Coratnrsni does r lae a nvo iture barier.

Thindoe anM iros redwrad. fhl refersced li-it-non Page 35-55 appi.a arty Sonpirrwy conlannw electrical penratdon eals and sealant.

Table Ue Ilem n

51-16 wvilbeuaidsted sntmd "Th.aging eflectl cited InrIte NUREI-1801 lear we ls. of sealing and leakage.

teds ofsedaing Isa cornsequeoe of f agirg elects cracking and cirsg. in"rerwial properies For PNlPS, IseCoCraainn Lask Rate programn isis crackirg ard fange In rrlelial propertie Ior tho prifry wortarrmt sdes and gaskes. Thee Is no raisture barier w,,e fts drywdl stea shell becorsa eatwibeds Insthe drywll cwrcrael Ior."

Tis reetire arsendAs lathe LRA NRC PNPS Lead HoenC Drn flrabi, Reza 4C9 Apoegl 13 5 1-44-H-Otj In Table 352-8 onPage 3.5-83 oflli LRA.for 00rporwt seats and gaskes, material rudbs in r protecled lrom seats aiziromrst I

flnag ealect. arecraeodng aid

¢harge In nrliad properties. Omed Ihs agrig rriosaret progZ rs t

Its Srstluree lMonairgn Progaur The GALL lin hein rd*lacd NI II1.A6-12 aid the Table I rderence Is3.51-44 The role shown IlE.a diffaen P

iar stow nin GALL HoeGAuLir 1tn It A6-12 and Table I Unr benn Il

-&44 bah specify Ih. Sr,.*rsa Ml-loring Pron'agn Explain wl I t rnoe thowsnlr n A insted dl E go Its lower haldOfd thveA 410 Acoaed

[35.1-5&-H-011 In Tabole a5 2-6 on Pago 3 5-73 df.t LRA, Inr oorponerl eectrical aind fstru pan*e aid wolora. Marteri gaflzedled sled Ina o

protected frontl -she airilro-nat; ts agiqg elfect IN tons, Th GALL JIrslfm n rhlascaied i.

I 813-A which alaor

m. lallowing onPonets: Suppo

.nt..u welds; boiled cor-rectors; s8gppaIornoraga to bLiadng alroue

-xplainwI slf LRA AW Jim IneHn has a Not A shown instead of a Nde C.oadifselt conponewa wdh rasped laoWe GALL Noehirs Or a danarlldnayv, a lettr NdeAwitharnsnb Me no plalnirg M *e omc ponore 1N differai InTable 3.5 2-6 on Peg 35-83 elm. ILRA r oIs onrl seals Hoer Dan and gaskels, rrderial nbbs" Ina protected frorn weather awxironvrs. Note T-ai waed beaase t appdia lothe lap hsa of tI-lirs itemr The WRA %itlbecislified ti i

dic.ale rdo Nsts "W applies olo lowser half of ft lnIslm This reair eanararir*sa*i lam.WA NUREG-1801 doea rno rnerion eway lypa doonrpoarl lea s.be HoarU Don 0stMbt loaaging rnaeganemrt riiew (eq. panel is l In NUREG-t101)t rn dem.

Ist-rnirdogy u da aspaifo i-at Swaya. igs with OW used In GALL Coxresaly, rnrtcnrg p1sa-ooponents lNUREG-1801 -onpens ladles etljactio. ln tlls pardscula case, paes., wNch havero no Ispecific ution dine tIlan tolaloni aid protect Seatrical equiprnert, wer Ionrsitemd spport mtreabers aid Ndl Awn applied The wedof eter No. A or C he. noirrpact onmt agig managemwi revew ra1s.

Nioe A uillbechirad laNes "C-or oMonst a

es rOIalusand imlr.~rena panels aind enclsures. mastial galvanized sled ins prctas Iron weatts enivrorrint inTatt 352-I cnPage 35-73 of the WRA No change hi raiired to dih Oner satien fo this lini itlem Thisrequirem an arrmenr-i lo* thRA.

Ahrabli. Rae Ahrabi, Reze Pay 34 d 77

James Davis - AMR -_Report to the NRC.doc.pdf-Page 35]

Number Status Request 411 Accepted 135A-8-H-01]

InTable 352-1 onPage 35-54 ofthe LRA for rornlipwei Torue shdll with the agotg atoec! orectdrrg-fie, Ite rote eigrad sE Note Els coistart with NUREG-180l mreriat, onvironrnat and agng flect Wo aedifteraw eanrJ Fraregerrr proren iscraited Exlrin why this roe IsE wien the AM' down lo tie ili hem In TLAA a t* e irqoiald GALL Une Itse. BIAl-4 also pecities a TLAA 412 Accepted 1351-5-H-011 LRA raie 35&1. len Nobe. 31-5.I has tOe towirg staete~

ndr th dcacteion urn OiThe dywdl sled whre the dywl ahnl Is ortbdded Is leIspacloi In stoatn. withthe Cotrsiral Isevico Inrpection (tWE)

Prfoan and Strcturs Miouiong Proreanf. This Isn dictO? inarii Chrome Pis dmcreion etntearnet ID agree with LRA Section 35.221.4 tel states The drywelf st"d atil ard the tnstture tbarrer where the drywell stall becorre erej Inte rywelo ncreds floor wte Irepected Insacordarce withthe Cortnniaral servics kapecrion (1MS) Progaer ard Strtres Mxitorirg Proger Resonse NRC For Tale 352-1 onPage 35-54 dthe IRA lor cenere Torae Hta. Dan shedl with tfe aeri Slfect racking-laueg, Note "E will be ctaes to Note A.

ThN.rsqdrsrelanandrnel toteo LRA ForLRA Tal,1e31 her It 5.1-5, theidsscmuia InSetion Hos. Dan 312.1.4, Pagp 35-9. shold htae the rdetwnce tomoisfure barrier

dldel, eiroete PNPS dyrwetidoes rot ocrtain itih ormodty.

FortLRAi Table 35A. her 35.1-5. thedcsoasin colutn shodd reed -The ywdl sled eldl and t* eas where the drywdl shall kecxxee ooresl d

r.l hbe drywdi o-tride floor ee Inpecled In woothiae with te Cor*tanresr Inavice kWpedioi (IWE)

Program" The last seatence fthe Iirl peasgrtaph In LRA Section 35221.4.

stoMld reade -The driywdl ed shdl ad t arese where the drywdt stall beooas eonbs.** Inte dywdil o-ores floor se irspoeald In acordoance with the Cortalr ras Iaoervics Ir fon (MIS)

Prograr" Thisersqir-r netrreer rrt tothe IRA PNPS Lead Ah'rali, RFs Alrabi, Rwa Pap 3d)7

James Davis - AMR-Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 36'1 Number Status Request 413 Accepted 135.1-9-HI.011 LRATable 351. Rel ent Nbs 351-9.9 has the flimeirg saernenwt =no the dactason cofunir Not appinbe, SeeSecticn 5.221. This elend bereadia Section 35221 & Howwel. the Inlleing, saewner Ismdaned LRA Section 15 22 1..

eFafigo TIAAe lor the steel drywdl. lore. ard associaed. poeetreiione we watuBle1 and dolnrenteel In section 46-The oontpoert eL.dwShLRATe~e22.a

,NmNt.ew351-9 w.

psnalnr~lo al-eon. p-nar.Swl bellctv, 84ee,o,-

poo!

shell, dee wt=rbnoo,ner Exphen hero Owlr.0,15w 3 51-9 lsena Wp~nabo hen.ow elatig TLAA P. been Pwlorned Ion the WM and pencrareions Expdla whi the Vol II.M vnthed.

andw V,.1 line belloere wenot lised Inl IRA Secions 3 5221.6 and 4.6 em refernced In Table 351. Une Iwl 15148 Resonse Fatigue aweyeee hewe been aelvLeed for Ihe loo.. Iot. vert eytamen o

Ino pwenretione. The Idlownoollinewillbe ed Io Tale* 52-I:

rTono.

errhncl ypeneloraoe lIPBS SRjCarbwon steed /IProlted ofrnwelnerllw ICrekfng If TLMAmA.1 f

tigue I#

HIB4-4(C-13) /3.5.1-9 IAK The weatuain do e lo. voet eysle fatigue analysis cxenrned Shael wasn al ITLAA The sigrilioaer vonribL)or to I

igae ofth Ven eylelm Ie Poae-LOCA ch.ng, a once iplart-litle wart As

-oe wi.l still be only one design basis LOCA Ion th. Iled the Plant. nklhding he perwo dd ee ndod opertiort. It" wlyayi is Mo ba.sed me lime-limrited assun torl and In rot a TLA. Faligue fo fte vent eysel Is

-edrive1 and Is. not ae ge-relleed affect, The dci-c..n ol"m entry Ior Table 3.51 itern 51-8 willbe changed to read as Idloor: "Fai" aerlysis Is le TLAA lot the lore shell. Faligue of01 Oe vent eysln Is warl-aieen a Ithe Nely.ie leno aTLAAL See

-St.

352*.16 The di$c!ssio oolu-n wnry lonTable 35.1 1-l 35.1.9 willbe eher-d o rlMd as lollow.: -Fat!g eralyei Is a T.AA for the Io.

penewdrions. See Stclon 3 5221.a Secton2 5221.6 willbechag e reed eslollowe" T"LAAwo evahoied Inaconhe-ce wllh IOCFR5421(c) endoclmeoled In Section 4 Fatie TI-,

e the o* :

ard enseciated pentralii*e we wealuaed and lo

.ewedI InSectlon 46" Section 35.23. Tirre-Urntlw Agng Anelyse. wilbechengr to reed ase follov: 'TLAA Idertified fIo elstene eononse end conwodiies Iroloee laigue aelymee for the lots and len.

penelrelions. Theec o.0c.. we diecsed In Section 46."

Theeem henge reqoire ent*nenhmel 1o IRA.

NRC PNPS Lead Honi;, D*n Ahrabi.

R1za PW 36fd 77

James Davis --AMR -Report to the NRC.docxpdf Page 37 I Number Status Request 414 Aocepted 135.1-12-H-1OI LRATa.el 351. Iten Numtbr 35.1-12 arId.5-13, under the cliacslon colmr dotoo make reference io LRA Seclion 352218 lorrtherwalualio.

EopliMnwhly Uns ltl lar de a

oft 1

.rer faludio gaction Explain t rood Ior.*qnrmrtel dtiorasdo exams lodolect fine cracks ainc..a CLE loaigue adnyll. dos omist.

415 Closid 135.1-16-H-01)

LRA Talel 3S1. hIt Nhart 351-16. tnder the doosaion col-n, states1 "t-Wl. and gaskes wai ot Ircluje inth. Corainrmri IWas-vce Inspection Progn*na at P N P S O r. of ft c m po n ts io r " s It "m r is mrtuelbarriflra.

Explain how PNPS sle. theJontl betweer t6. carlarmlw cywoll helo and drywell acorale floo" Htre ls no moisture barrier. Explain whiy 6.

Inspection df iis Jori isrd n

rpaid 6.f Cmoairnran nsie Inspection Progam 416 Closed (351-33-H-Olj For LRATaIe 351, fIn Number 35.1-33. provide ta rnlir r lorporIerao 61 onWeide experience Inaroup 1-5 antn r Resonse Alnk Ifrom imrs 351-12 and 151-13 will beoadded ioocWon 352216 Section 15.22 1.8 a-ould sltoe -Cycliloading can led to craclkig d l ad and atairlfd. dad penetratir bellow, and dssirrilar madll welds of c1W corzdrar s

o rd SM aa*lt-aoaion pd shal and ownccbaw.

Cracking h*

b tc la ing

[a nopeclail taoctr In6f drywd, lr.

e ard nsodoal p1etation bdilows. percarion doorws, unbraced downeomis, and dssirmilam aedal w"d A

rneview d plant opealing eipoio'r cd rot Idnotify crockigr of the cairWirta ad priawy corn'inrent looago M ds rdbeen klarified as, a 00 n.ca Nonthi seo,6ft Cotanmara Leek Rate Proam withaugminiled lrisorewlo ai and Condraraet isenice Inpection -M wll continue lobe uwed Iodaedt cracking CObe.ed coodnitor-. that have ft oelial for Irrm*elirg

,, Iris-dad faction ore evaluated or acoreced Inasooordance With

6. ccrectiNa action piroos. ThM Cortdar Irnemce Iopaction -I WE and Cornaunmr t Leok Rate progarns we descrtbed InApperdx B ThiNrecria anuamdmenl Iat10 RAW TheM Is no gn-to Iall al th0 Jolnt between the coidrraimw dryadll
  • hali ad 6t co~rcie floor. Concreie d

rod Is oorsd direcly against 6. drywdl "Ii. Th Intallaison a. shawn asDdt 1 on Drawing C-7I. The Corlairnarn Isenvce Inspection Program InciLdeo Inspecallon odtns Joint (Also.so. audit question 1408 whch a

ddreseso changesl oLRA)

NRC PNPS Lead Hoag Da, Aheabit. Reuoa Hwon Dan Ahrabii, Rate Ayabli. flea The raximum bra lk wao amlels nnlwalmo. toar iGoUqp I-S ocrr Hoe-ng Dan in 6. drywal ard is an tverago tMpasloroe f IWF, reoerence UFSAR Table 5.2-2. For turmoL.r odlido 6f drywall ft1 blk oea mrxira m teIpe-ratro 1 12F Io, GO*rOr 1-5 St-rco. 0 kiorilifed In Table 109-2df PNPS UFSAR. Concrete wotin6f drywll consist f 6. ro-tor pedesal, sacrifical tiald wall and

. drywall floor. A rarca ta. bulk o-naei t.Ir1pooto.e withtn

6.

tywat anin bdlow to5 dogreeo F ls obtained ftouO masirtaning average bulk coratnnr-t etspatu wnithnathe linmts allowed by PNPS Too-cal Specfiicaillon Sooton 3.2-H (Page

'4 2-5). Mthouh Upper aclat-or ofthe drywail my oced IO F. the corciale of the 6ywell yisda lower adodatios The drywall cooling aystem poi moa oroig toenma" telrporatura limilrwm rno exceeded The ighet corcdle Inthe dryw Is the sacrificial shald wall. The ocetate In the waml Id not load be-ing Pageprd 77

James Davis --AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf

.Page 38!

Number Status Request 417 Accepted 35.1-34-H-01)

LRATalde 3.5t. iw-n Nuber 35.1-34. uroe the dacuseian edlun, does net mke rierfnce loLRA Section 35.22224 (1)bfor further aeual Ion Explan whiyf iirlin is in male tlo fl eoevaluitlon sectioa 418 Accpted

[3,5.1-35-H-O1 LRA Taue 351, 1". NHins 35,1-35.

rdor the deiasioa edunn does in make rdatnce IoLRA Section 352224 (2) Icohfltwwaiada E

inmwhythiselirnktI in a til. e I*"

ther ation section.

419 A-eped 135.1-36-H-Ol]

LRA Tae 3.51, R" HNuntsr 35A-36, uder the dacut n ladmn does mn mike relnnce to.RA Section 2.5.2224 (3) lor l

rt oc aluet[on Explain why thisl nki ri pae tolthe lurlhas euetian ectiaon The ietmst:

  • See Sectioa 352221 (5)for dditional dscussia new).

lulhls elarifiation itts section Is for Guope IA-5 7-9.

how.-c XA waled ily loaccesite i oup 6 concrete, Explain why WRA Seetion 3.52224 (3) lisb. ercking d cocrele doe to Stre Coejion Crcking (SCC).

42D Accepted P35 I-H-H01l LRA Tale 3.51. Ren Hints 35.-40, uder Ife diceasionedwMn, Mlee: ¶..PlWt experience hai not Mdoetified li crclia Inooerete tictle capacity ooahlr cocrete aging mnarhnisda NonH-,esi, the Strictures Mririfaing Progan wull oroirm absencoe da*ing effects rekrirg rweregel 1or PNPS concrete eeoneres."

The project ten carrl Rind anrAMR lireItem InTable 21or Wi coronent (Bedrlng concrete ae locations of aptsion ard good anchors god-ped for 1

u0ppor bse pIlele).

Pride. Ue Table 2 Alb, LRA pge nurets, and eaompon* 10 where this "Ml line t-n Is e.&uleld and shwn

Response

NRC NUREG-1180O. Rem NuHirn 351-34 livcale*. O lurlhls enauien Hsng. Dan Is meses"any c oy 10 e6erei envirornsis. No reference was prakvide to lls weauatii in LRA Section 352224 (1) mrme the PNPS nlrast in.m agjressi-e -

oed l nLRA Table 251, ItR N tser 251-34 rde. the dscuiaion dwmn.

For darificalo *RA Tabe 35.1. Une Iten 3.51-34 dec-ion will be rwised toal 'See Sedt-3352224(t)°.

TNtrexrires ancardmes tlofe tLRA Focrdlarification, WRA Table 35 1, Iten 351-35 disciseln will be Hoang, Dan eieed 1wadd redere*e toSectaon 352224(2). LRA TabeS 351.

Rom 351-35 deiaeionawillbereeisled torder toAC 318 Inlieweo ACI-301, sime toe proided rd.er

  • IoACI should Ied en been ACI 318 and not AC 301.

Tesrqu*ireeesne*irdmit 1f0o IRA WRA Table 351. Una lIenH Nuber 3SI-36 discussnl will.b Hoen-Dan rehed tread a-Idlows.

FlReation with aggregate II in an applicable agng rtcl'eriamn 1o0 PNPS cocree aroponeis. See Section 35.2221(5) (altlhaigh lo Groape I-5. 7, 9 ths discussion Is elso applicable 10 Grouqp 6) am Sctian 352224(3) umtiowi decussion. NHnethedes, the Suicrtwwe Moitoring Progan will cotrinn Ive aere eof eging edcote regdring -

a-gst 1O PNPS Groap 6 oeoae ecorp-i.s" Due to an axniiistrlive Ovieis he h"ir0ng of LWA Section 352224 (3) Irelverlertly listsree-king ofcon-rdee due lo tresa Core ian Cricing (SCC).Tes section tetIng elodd have be*un with reacking Due to xpepai on a, m Reaction with Agregat...e Sree coroeion cracking I[ ino cescuesed in the bdy of tsie sectioa TN efhage rapiree eanamerner boie RA Building eoeret. at locaions d wtpweia m d

emy ed etenis; Hoew-. Dan godt pact 1or support base pee we shwn as lcuudation aend "Rewwlo, vessed seg paedt" InSRA Table 352-1 (page 35-M5). afouxdeoe inTatles 352-2 twough 352-5 (pes 35-59.

35-61, 35-64, aed 35-67), ard as-Eqf ea pasfilarwdeha.n - in Table 352-6 (page35-80) Fulce elieution isproidlod InWRA section352226(t). page 35-S5 For clarificatio. URA TabIe 35&1. Itern Nuer 3 51-40 daceionl will bervised loadd Sec Section 352226(1)e.

Th.rwpqreenmenwers lothe WIA PNPS Lead Ahabli. Reza Ahrael, Rea Althali, Rea Ah'abli, Rere Page 38d 77

James Davis - AMR-Report tothe NRC.doc.pdf Page 39f Number Status Request 421 Accepted ft l-5-H-0Vl LRATabeo 3,&1, It" Nutmber 35.1-50. terds tie datenion doumn stales td loess o dmielrIt isno applicable 1OPNPS. NUREG-1833 onPgage 931or ternTP-6 states ansajsied preaednt aIstl for acting this mreerial.

nwwironnrit, aging effec and proge ra corntretfli 1o the GALL Reget AashownInRNPSER Sectilo 352412, g= =aed steel an staines sleed Ian alidcia air wclrs, rt ooldd rilt In loess of mraelral OA to canstrt Wilfing and t ying ocanl-U.M POimNn

.Ad also be sluseptible loa -si-ilr kindo aging edfect Inthe r

wolro-sre.

Provide a ls-s.o. O th. actsol gol) 82 ant B4dgpverzed sl.

stcrnlnscn an abides, sled PNPS corpaerft wrchwore within the sps license renewal ard exposed loan ait.d, air wwirore"t Discuss the locatio cit-ahese compornens at PNPS and how tW we protected fromn carutlt wat*ng and drying condtiorn, 4M Acceped

[3.5.1-52-H-O11 LAATabTel3 51, Itein Nhet 35.1-52.

inder the d

ia-as odw OW.

t hal Ice.d ls rnc vcai bunction d-s to" lisledmscheris*tos Ian agig effect Proper design praents dsborio% coerload. andI fteLi ds to wO-alry wnt cyclatherwml back Explain how loss of miaejd bcalrcon dituo torresion Is not waing aect wlche reds tobbe ranaged fo t.e period of alenele operati*n If proper desig prweris, dsltortior, oerlowte wrd 1atig.ed cbs ovibratore and cyclic thermas lesds. explain If tUe hes wer been a con gal. failure at PIPS d toulary of thee esordtoirs. Explal n iftwa t eve been a camponenr blis In the niclear Irnsslry das t

o y of these contltes. Explain where siJ*ing siupport boring and slicng cuppotl s0.a1-s we aed Ino-onrdr grotp. B2 and B4 at PNPS and provide th wrvirocnmerltfy we mposed to.

Response

NRC FortLRA Table 35.A, IehinNuaw I3S1-51% thedPsctac sion oroin Hoawy Den sid reaid 'Th.s aging aect Is rnraged by 0. Sn-xtiaes oI*-biig Prog8M Conaorsiw thal roay becoaidtored Ints W2ard BIgro-t-ni consistl o those line iesnt in Talte 352-6 with iolerials glvaized steel, asuirircss, or stainlees sled.

This reqdres enaw~a t

lothe IRA PNPS Lead Ahrabtlf. Reza Ahrabli. Rae Loss of material das to rrcesion is al aging effect thi 6s*

case a loss of Internd cliain. Loss d met-anieal Iilooi wosld be consliderl sa essn dirnewdl banc-stan Lois e schnical kinction Isrd aedcy effect, to lethe raelt cfagin edaets.

Ttere hIs been cat-or l bu*swes Inthe Indistry ds 1o ttstatioa, oewtl*l a-td ceassive vibration. Sich bluses plyicalty resi11t kora Irdloliate design a aeve. rather Psei the dale of aging Failtes 6A locyclictherrIws Ie wsvwy rwtfo.

sritwural suiports da e

o ther retalively low berratwarme The ldikng surface mnaer*alswed al PNPS is lhrited whch I a cormrcsn resistat mawerial. Cargneris we Iesmpcted under I-MF for ftors saddle suipogts and SlrJlirw Wtrloring Progracr for thi hbrite Wa

. 1o racidl beamw sIs Plant operaing asperlence hIs nru Idetifled feltseci lifiles cOwy*oois wsed in sltrucltal applicaliors. NornJre Iri s:ry experlac-hbe deantified failure assoctated withliibrite sliding atrfsae. C-at-scds associated withB2gouotping we limiled soi e t"eor raala benin ats and support

-a ades. There weo -

slcing sit-l saurlace assocald wilth te B40d c

rgee gotL-nc ber sliding surfaces al

PNPS, For clarilicatior% LRATae 35I.,

te 151-52 willberlevsed 1o rad o blows: "Loess d mechan-cal uncston das tot. listed machidsm Is In an agi efect. Such lalurtes tically ra1i Iran inedscasle dosigi or copiewing awes atiher Pit Iron the data of eIng Faitura is 10ocyclic thermal loa d e re -for slriuratl sit-oets dot 1atheir relaively Ik. lsrrcalures.

Thisraepirrensesawntr lot.

IlRA Howur Dan Pbg 3d 77

James Davis - AMR -.Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 40 ]

Number Status Request 423 Accepted 13&.154-H-0I1 LRAT&boe 34.1. It-. Nurnber 32.-54, w.0W the dewoico colunne oesee ltd los of nros.chrca functon due loft. listed nwachtr.-e. Is e on1 a.ging effec.0 Protper design ycre-1 detar~l., overlowl, and Isligue 01.10 nitoekoy.51 cyclic lthnW kb1. Explain law loss of nst.1 hoi,

1.011

.5 to rosooion Is M an aging elect1 wtich needs lo b.

-w.gd fo 1the peritlof dw1.k

.opertion II proper design preens. distortioever otdos mid t.0g..6 to. v~ibrtor0y.01 cyclic esthwr ood si expdlan N f... too ove been a cornono fi lure~ at PNPS its lo any d Ithes. conditons.. Expl en if there hae.er bewen ooywel1urow In.. nuclear Industy due I*oany.1 th...

cwdtro, Exlaiwn whtd PNPS Imspacts for duing VT-3 Visd.rnto.-

0 wce. 1.1 B1 sd 61.3 oofltoon.ert under Its Irm-oic. h'.pe0ctir Prograrn durin~g Us current lice-.. swd Woo antiipated VT-3 visual

.exaistios during Its possible extendedlwicense

Response

TIhe decuse... follhorn Ne..ts. 151-54 wae not leydlying that failures hav. not oc d buti OW loss of me..chanca beatsi Is rot an 011.0efec.

Fer lie..., roneose., Etweogy klricaesr.a oturribw 01agn e ffects1 ltha cencase. lose 01 Wored.w function Lose o Warded15 luratim n icities lose 01 rehnical functon The loss of function Is rte 0.0id.0.5 of -agig of1.01 Aging affect. that ould cous. lose d1 mechanical lunction for ornporwe.1. In fter N unber 3 SI-5O w~e atbbeeeed 01.esoh. In Ithe eging noow racss. revsew.. For warncple lose 01 o...wiel doe Sosany nxethaismn Is oftbesse I lTable 35 2-u-sI. listings for cornponent ard piping support A&W. Class 1. Z 3 01 LC (Paeg 35-71). af01 eo..poren sod piping supports (Pegs 3 5-72.

C~onporont falues~e at PNPS ard Inth. nuc.w Inlduty hav.

csoertily.0ocurred du boverolod (tyicallycaused by... oven4 such as waere leo.....) avibratory andl cycictswtd Iced.. Bocasese 01 the-k loscpereting lornparsletee. 1011... clue b cyclic SOwnW loath wostc

.lo.ely tos. be 55.01.01 owosn-dlitie Failuresd. 10 distortion a vibratory oods ae also0. occurred due.. Inadequate demlg~ bite.0y11 w.0e. 1.01..owned 011.1. 01 gg FlOPS ltaep knos during VT-3visual tarntirdions 01 gout. BIA. 61.2 and S;.3 cronerts No weitat1.

with what in required by code.

For darificalicn, llA Table 35S1, kern 3 51-54 will b.erevised to sstat tossof0 tnwtchrcl function u to.

1dseiorc.

01.. IovelowL.

fatigs. due to vibrtory. srd cyclic thenne lowls is rdan aging 011ect tO.rinig toue...gsnnt Such leiws typicayldlyrmwll 1.0..

Iredwydsl design evensl rather than. th-e offe.

01 aging Loss of rraterial U1 to cono~ior% whichcould caue oss of.

01n..chanica lurctio.m Is addrssed ndo h5ernb.

35 1.53 for Groups 61.1. B1.2.

and 61.3 Support nernbe~s.-

TH~es owgi~s fln-hsneilot1.. RA FlIPS inoh01ed Ithe exerw.icn jcirt with the. ashoust piping In Section 43.2 01f.

th RA FlOPS docurnersmior ctes not the-lily

"~ dosign code bersth.0eension (01.0 separate bkm Ithe extw..

pdipin (831ll). Partia cycle. we nota ecwscn far Ith dead1 whlousl 55.1le. sicthoeS. exhaust

1.

te001et Is rsuw 0each

.n..rnl operating lsnpsertues withssch.1.11of. te og... Th..

.01..rsios joint isexpo..lsedory to t wn 5.rnbertof fuhllcycles to whicohtherstof ft 1.piping Is eposed T

he expe-eiw joirfis designed specifically to acooswwci.e rnoernents tha sould mull1 low. the. hosting sod codting of thwe exhus ipie 10011.. words.

Iso dosigs olert Is to0ha. bae.. rIeligse response than. the0ral0o lb. pipng Thereoreo PNPS soesurna the piping would be.1w.e Weeling than the.0per..ion jct for I". allowable Snuribof 0 cycle.

prior to reluiring ane-garorlof 0 cracking d1. 10 fatigue NRC PNPS Lead Hlowe Dan Ahralsi. Reza 424 Acceplted TI.e3,32-4, Em.ergency Diesel Gerwotor System. for carbon *led. expansion jpils insanInternal nwirrnmos 01 exhausl g". cretes the TLA* --betigsef Ifor onargng cracking dueo faligue TIMA secti0 432. NonClas I Faligue. assures, ingonarad 7000 thermal cycles for ping eysten?, allowing a stress, raeduiw ftor 0 1.0 Inth.

etrees anaysis This s a good assurnloliot forpe fitings,

,o, however, rewy al bea go9=d assurrtinc for expasion Phlase onfirm If the expanion jcnts.e included In sction 432. asd osiity t.hat th 5aseumrlion of 7000 cycles is appropriate Paid, Erach Fiorsn, Ron Alp 40d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 41 I Number Status Request 425 Open -

Am part ol ft Tharnel Pos. Opimization Proiect, GE NRC yPWosMM anter III analr~oysis GE Issued a report.

OE.NE.OO.GE 0.1892-0 Re. 0. Lbrch 200Z Themnal Power-Op~rinzalki Task,=~ - RPV-Stress Lovawiromr Th-eport ovIorohd newo CUFenehrch In some cases are d~flant Own neha 1. shown In" yeRA. Table 43-1.

Miýn~nCUFa he CI... ICronrvrors. The GE Report, Section 33, Reeyits, sase.tes n fIeaeirol rorzzle CUF reosjotinlion hdoelet a CUF tel Wert Iron, oC lot.0 Simohely. Table a3.13 heigre eonnry test colunn os.M., CTPYTI.TP,J-re Apair% apwli. vales. wre prorkIad IW 3linlost". howrqr. her leawaleol nozzle, only Fine.

jrulilywhal<I.0 nsen. Flwoo.provide*aspeortoc cactrd~ed value Aso.o pilease. fretily wh/ the mirled TFPO CUFval"e were neot kldpiited Inth. LRA Table 43.1.

vinaead of old vale Oaiosatod by ALTRAN Corporeilion In 1994 Are taro other IRA TIMA wflione affected by ft TFO project. eroh as Section 42Z RPV N~etron Ernbrittlement Analysis 42 Accpte lT.332-P.OeI Tab.e 3,32-,k EDO SynltrN page 3-78. her carbn wled aspelrson joints. Inon IlnwnW anvir-crte of wlehel gas credl. Ti Im!"ge to mnarge "I agin-g Offac of oreohi-g tie loIfaligoa Ft.... confirmr It TLAM Section 4 32Z NonCla.. I Fadigue, hocludes.#"e asersiveon tons. An so. s TIM qtyrion &

Response

NRC a) The Pilgrim records aysln hled Me been Wploed torinclude the Paid, Erach ceragee InCUF due tofte 23 TPO prog-ra Intime losuiport LRA prepiao.i TPO yes.

nirrel impact on CUF as detiled in GE.NE-OXC-CM - I8-9-.

Rw-I. 32.

The re9o=d0 *yle hs.

been sdmod Srd lye PNIPS correctiv. eaion program reires that the Information beaseassed he p*el*t Inpact onther LRA eoctions. PNFPS will q te LRA le 43-1 looIncle lye velues fromn the TPO.

In preparing the TPO eibeas aoust hor GE reviewed only incee RPV componertas wones prmui lentoturs, and 11. condlion wweoe mee *were do

'lote TPO and withfasigUe Lag. lactore eater ten 0,5 These CUFewere ne recalcUlated by taeio5al nethods. beL rthw were eetinaled by corswoevarol y ccasing the dresses. deternining the code aelonaboe nettr of cycles ho thE.o

strese, l line rmrrg th. Increrensl rage factor loh agroup of cyoles conaeidred In f* oiginti stress report. Before f TPO.

ft CUF for th eewml.s rzlet. (Allnn Report) was listed as.08.

forh e TPOh CUFIeorveI Io<l.Q Noprecileevalue was ccuaredl As Istated In ft renporee toOueston 345. PNPS will perfonm a new feedwater vezle latigue aralysis prior to ft peeied d Waerded operation b) Nootlhe" e ons of fte IRA wre effetlw by the TPO. The iluence veoues Med In Secion 4 2 ware based on the Idghw power Ied.e TLAA-mdal latigue Is nro an ang maevgemnrl program Urder the Paed, Erach staedndd LRA tonal. TLA.-Arl fbeigue In Ivnertod under the agin msnwI gaenvl progran en. conrwwiee holhdcate Ind a TLM Ifo mntl Istigue applies to O lrne hen The carebon Wed expansion joirt arc dsigned per a. reoquiry,-ens cfASid 831.1 loh alimelt mrInuber of tevlh cyCle. The waeeusion of leigue hor ASCE 831.1 conmponenrs Isdo*orsedinSection 4.32 The ewaeution del-emned teW U. EDGoomponevi willrentin below the cyclelimrit hoe Oyme euch that crcrking Is not Opected PNPS Lead Firnin. Ron Frorebarger.

PaWe 41 d 77

James Davis- -AMR-Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 42;1 Number Status Request 427 Closed

[Ta322.P-1t For aging affet d cracking dee to laige. PNPS hea cradled TLAA -

edld togw anc agni; mersgwonw prograr Ior owo~rsuntsin ano Itrir srvirornar. ol

.rhew gas InTable 13 32A EDO Systenre. howlwa, In TabI 3.3.2-5 S8DO Systrn and Table 3 32.6 S00 SYllten ". Psrnoclo Socoellance ard Pr~enetio.

KAdnermen (PSK'M Progrrnr is crecitecL w~nch Irclude nisWs or CIL NDE tech! wa tolimpact ash-ct systern 0cErnonr~to bnwvV cracking Pies. justify wtV ft P7'M prograrn Is not cradiledlo 1th8.

EDO systen corrnonats $or norecgng aging dlect of cracking SIt Is4 onlredted or loss of maerial ad Woinrg 425 Closed

[T.3.2.P-ttj Tate 3.32-9. Fir*ProtecticnWWd.rSysl.A i hpipir silerc, and heheherge Ienst Internol exhe.*t gae aerlrmnent with an agng tilecl of crooking &as to fatig^w PNPS hse. cerdited It. Fire Prtctionto Progncrn to marga te aging afecit The Pr.7-deo-.

6, Acet Criteria. is wencmel to verily that the doead engine vid rot eshibit Igna of degradtioin wrtle It we. rwrsng smh as fdrt go tes Wkege.

Plese Jcetity honw the aging dtrct of Crackirg 1..rreegod by neitying for exhaust 0. 1..%"eg 9 9-e.

Isteskge It Irnplies a tiouglwalI crack tasoo ~o~rrs Vritying 1to Wattage Is r to eadhgleqa agirg noregonert progrwn for Managing cracking

Response

NRC TL4A-rraf l tIat!.

Is not wnagng nrogort program Under the Paid, Erach atarched LRA tormal, TLAA-omelat ti gue In tmed todoer ft aging n-2-art prcgamn sea oowerience, to inicate the a TLAA/or he tae Wligue apies to Ol 1-i*lient The EDO ache*W syslerns wedesigned per fte relcrernoret ofAS&E B31.1 orea limniled ruttbe dC hrnl cycles. The evaluatlion drtigue fo ASIME 831.1 -orrporert. hloicused InSecton 432 The evaJuation determined thet the EDO crarnpoet wilttremain below the cycle lit. for 8yeesr such th cracking isrot espected The hatest syslervo hothe 1stalim tackou dead gonerotor and security deod genratlor we rot designed to a code or a tMand wherethermel cycles we aconsideraton Thore.cre the Periodic Sf ifttearce and Poecerwwce tcIhr

,ce, (PSPtA progarn will warog or aolirtim 8 abseron of cracking due tothenal fatigue PNPS Lead Uoyd. Ward Fror~brger.

The eging elfect di atiguo cracking to oorernse ivd y Idenfited he Ow lre pusvp dead anine.

fie he*at o-onrwf were denigmned per ASM 831.1 cod, a lined Mr.

of vye..

would be the 8.Uesthod for estcepitily tocracking due to heigue Since the syslern Is normaly In stardby and wed prinmrily ducing teatin*

Itis tinlikely toreoch aey legtlitrie Unreslcid to pro**e fatigue rackirg, Furthenrore. through n'oriloring and trending d performanco data ndoer the Fire Prolection Program. ereckirg of sysatemrn onpoerls willbeidertiied and correcled through in corectiveactin program As deecribed Insection B 1.1la, oevtcse lon ofdtogeadd perform me produced

'racrive actions Ireludng engine repacemrel In2(2g prior to leos d Worded kurction. Coeequertly, corrinudInTiecrtaiion dft8 Fire Protecton Prog's.r provlde. tesore assrance eing fects will be n-reged f the 8deead ire punp emhecel scbsystelo. In arhiiort PNPS performs fire purp irepecSon, testing aNd naienence Ineocordance with NFPA 25which would also detect Z. pre.ee. o oracking In the sehet ysylem prior to loss of IrlwW functionrc TK3 Itoer Is cloeed to tern 378 Pald, Erach Pap 42d 77

James Davis - AMR -,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 43 Number Status Request 429 Cloudr

[T332-P-121 bnRt.AScrft,333.273. PINIFSa ele. ft ftcarlbo steel deed sahml hiping and oorinewn.1 tnthe Are prcection cylernt Is manarged by fth Fire Prodcrtion Prngrn The FirvProteciwrProgcrarneeavisret Inspection ofdiesel cexhatl pipng an01 ocnrriprwits I.

mna~ge loss nereWiW.

II Fire Prdlecton Progcrar tttA a1.1a 1) Iscraded tforw inaging eging 01 this. eornpon orte. rieee sapyddn whlt lito eystmr orrtonrisl we rd Included Inft. progce.

description d fth Fire Protc~tion Progrcn, Furtm-n9. no wilecerneft Is catresea VWl wodd root.e ftco can~rents n, rit*Ff F Fydeetwioni Progeecr 433 Closed (T332-P 131 SdeerinrtI loqeetion T.3.3Z1. fth aytkM has cradled Fire Prtdection Proraer In~c l1wo GALL AKV XI M38.

Imepaction d Internal Surfaese oflcd~ne Piping crd Orcrtirr Cnrryreftas c rcecrnrrmne.d Io GALL Jimr V D2-16, wind Is dreferece by the applicarl5 ftc tin.Ji Rental. Th. GaLL AW' X35M owes ftt 01c.j Inspectionr of Internal @c._.e df tcrl oorriponrtsc In performed

.1wirg or~lr

r.

-erin.Ilc.n actnivll. lo, llcibteieanae d1 corrosion to Irdcale possible losc of traetwia Since PNPS ta Loinrg ft Fire Protection Prograe. In lie 01 GALL AM' 70M3 pt" aseeee cen thon. ft Fire Protcrtionl Prog'ern percdarne this viceet trsipcrti As written In Ina LR, fth Fire Pracetinr Progearn tIs Maerteqeee torwango loss of instcni!d 1w trese orpnenycct&

431 Closedt T322-P-011 Table 32Z qesetiert I The Ft4PS R61. 12 Fatige IMonitoing te crad~le 1wr rna-grrg fth aging lladt Creet'ing Wig.01 1w coro~naenl In fth RtHA (Table Nerter 322-1), ADS (Tatie N-berdn 322-3). HPIC (Tee. N-ore 3 22 4). FICIC (Table Nufter 32Z2 5) eysterre. hn nnat cec. fth cwrerrnpoe nt.et been ansigned Note KorNote 'C% How~eew,th FlIPS EK1.12 Fafigo Monitoring proogwnr ec mceptidore, loth. GALL progwrar X AM. MWd Fadig.. 01 Reactor Coolant Preenwe Bowrlarr. Therefore Nd.e *Ccshod be Node *Doand Ntne.

AK chmAd be NoteI Bas appropriate for ftc. conyrpwwt

Response

NRC The progarn deecrilion listed in Section E1.131 nmtchee the Paid, Erech doscripblon died In GALL section )t Mr. Fire Protection which Inclesre ft dee driven fire pr*r The whe, piping and coryonents arepatl fthe firecrxp Enirnents for eagig agerti 01 the cehein Lceytemnt we described [or attribdee 3-pearnaders mn loredinmpeo led and 6-aceeplarce criteria f the prograM This tem Is closed tonlem 375.

Se. fle res.oae to Iten 394 ft adtreses eceeaw in Tnble a12-9 Paid, Errach For thepip*n* nponart line inm InTable 332-10 that hac Indoor air (irc) a an aneirowrrnl the Fire Protecticn Progein lmbodt.

a i..W tIepection of01e f

aterr'nl swrc.

01 fthe Hlon sycten pipngr ard taiks Sin@e metlrrn surfaces we reprneeclive 01 Inrternal iacaseeies we epo**od to th sae erwironert, the Fir. Prdlecticn Prograc Is al*uqae for inareng ft aging alfects of conponrn*a dryal to kn-air.

Th. Itn 1. losed to Itern 378.

NUREG-1801 does rno specity XMI. Mta Fdigwe of Reector Pa1rilt Way Coolant Presswe Bowvty InIn AMP codwln ior fters Idertifyirn cumrultive ladfgu dernage NUREG-81I iderlifies ofige as a TLA ra8d ralerwe ogJidce InSAP Section 43 winh Infirn dencribe. keatrr.1 o0 faligue Ina variety d ways dwwdfV ong wt conernpor. Since NUREG-1801 dos rot cradt ft Falige Monitoring Prograr, exceptioe In ina proran hove m beering on1 Jim selection 1 rot.

PNPFS Lead Frombarer.g Fronabergar, re Ungerilter, Page 43d 77

James Davis-AMR-Report to the NRC.doc.pdf

.Page 44:1 Number Status Request

Response

NRC PNPS Lead 432 Cloeed

[T322-P-02 ABoling nteriy Progas' willbededqloped Vi-willecdrksse f Pavriichl tynr Frontbargo-,

Tging m2nn gwsl dolling SInthe seepeo lice reeal.

Table 322. 9seation 2 The Bliling kItegity Progern witltrenptrlnmJed prior loth period The PNPS 8,1.30 Spysln hlkdewn Progen Is used bo of dendleed operaeion inacdorhre withoornrtiet nutber X ddweet d

rm catron sled boilng Imnted dGALL XLMIB Boiting Inlegrily. XI.MIi lrvoke vied VT-I aeenireatin or TNt reriree eanaroevlme lot. LRA toiredi descriplor. of tolling lees lhan 2 rnchs Indaenr.

It Is rut elmn i V I th BSlling Inlegrily Prograrn InAppyedc Aard eald to Wdtilfy I. send or boiling Val Is *aned in acoerdbtce withlth m

woso ifL progerm is aeplicoela Systerm %Wkd-on Progrm Wet st*rarcd Is wed for vite "repecllion of boiling un he "fSyster Wikelown Progran, TN. hen le cal to

%, harr M3.

433 Closed

[T322-P-]

Sin&e fhe Or-Tirme Inspecion (OTI) Progs.. Is epplicable to wh Paviich, Wanyr Froengort, waner cetaridry control proea'. if Is also plicable to

,h llne Table 322, qestion 3 hem if-el crecis a waler chis"try control program LRA Taele 321 fresealee..l he Ore-Tins Inspection Progras Is cmeled Sirese steled en sled conporerl that we epceed So along wi0l he wete chestry control progares lo line htere lor tested walar in Table 322 do ral specify one-lrnse wech GALL recwrewdw y

a oe-Wre Ibpeclion to cornirm wamet Iripeclort to clted rle d nalaiat allheuoh Table 321 che-istry cosrtd. Table 2 credi he Oftt progam TfnoUg'h Irdcalea OTtL dtd OTI$*. AMF or S es. orporoete for timermo lothe asesclaed Tele I line len.

co-ssleency with Table 321 or provide a Jutificalloiorn ml pernfrring OTI.

TN. repires eonrw r

lthe chewritry progr" deskorilore In ILA Apparel-A ard B b cleary icleis thet he Or-Tirne osctlion Progrne willo-diirm he ilfecsli f the

  • Wet Chenislry Conirol - BER. Warn Chle-lstry Cortrcl - Ateiliary ystisns and the Walee Cl-snitry Cortrd - Closled Cooling Wer progrsre TN. Item i.ctoeed s, Itre 372.

434 Cloeed (T322-P-04]

Table 322. qieion 4 If Is mt den If the System WVelklen Progean provkdes In Irnsection Ilerir stlacts dc nion alea oonpoierts ipred to Indor r Irm LOM Fees, prode doetils sihring Ispection of irntior surfacees or Ins odmponrt.

435 Closed (T222-P-MJ Tale 322. ptelion 5 heMrn bers 322-4. 322-5i. al 332-14-16

-eelsirtes sled piping oironorts (eg onficee, dreairoe). Please etplain wly Note Cwas assigned tI ftse coipoeres PFvirlch, Wayne Frc

'.ge, The Sijreln Whetilorre Progean Is tnot tile le, tnlreet Iteriom riOng ard crewl1 s9ein-u.es hey hse been exposed SW Irepeclion Wuing nire-eren.e and repairs As tnrcoled l the lias. In Sectlion 3d hfe LRA, he Syslan Walkdomn Fingrr manages agng lft exteal surfnactes df orwews-a.

The progran alsoesrregee lossed erial frorn lr rW swine. Insiuilion. In wNch Irleel met e ral rtenalse ridl e edrwnrir-mrl cor*rGretion we the sans euch S elere swurfaoe eonditi Is reteertativ a d iner surface coreslime ThI. enoi*

piping compres Inltables 332-A. 322-5. and 332-14-16. Itwhih Nde C'ws ehig-s hMoe itele ahte eariro-ent. Thi eysere represented by fhte tables ao all ESF systere. hrweer. NUREO-1801 does rat irclude the contirelion d etandse sol In slen encirorvneet foranry ESF conTynse (Chapem V). Corerienly, coprisni w

trensde loest-e srd powe conesion iyslemrs conrr s (Chree %III) whre lhe stainless selslsea cornitrt ion Is addeestd Sis the eystens dot' nmtclh a Note wC'Is aNlied Painich W"yn.

Ungertdler, PaW 44d 77

RAIslInput SE Input Item Lead Project Type Due Date Due Date Due Date Status/Comments One time Relief Request from ASME Complete q

Section XI Code Requirments S. Samaddar LA - Watts Bar 5/31/06 Complete One Time Extension of Contaiment I:A is going to clarfe Integrated Leakage Rate Interval H. Ashar LA - Prairie Island due date.

H. Ashar/

Complete e

I B ikais

-1 Five Year CILRT Extension R.Jackson LA - Watts Bar 4/15/06

' ackae

    • e Amendment Re: Contingent Installation I %

9 of Temp. Spent Fuel Rack S. Samaddar LA - Monticello 8/1/06 l

On Tracl; ;

NOAA MOU Y. Li ASAP Pe it.

Complete DG-1 145 Sections C.I.3.7-C.I.3.13 T. Cheng Draft Guide 5/30/06 Complete

  • R. Jackson/

Primary Containment LRT Program H. Ashar LA - La Salle Working Progress Completý Secretary has the T s u n a m i Y. L i 5 /9 / 0 6 K

'It__

_ _c_ _.

Update SRP Section 2.4.1, 2.4.2, i

ithke 2.4.3, 2.4.4, 2.4.5, 2.4.6, 2.4.7, 2.4.8, t

due 2.4.9, 2.4.10,2.4.11, 2.4.12,2.4.13, & S. Samaddar/

Update Section 2.4z-jg is a.ir.

"ttea a

2.4.14 G. Bagchi New Reactor

?

0 g

Using Fiber-Reinforced Polymer (FRP)

System to Strengthen Concrete J. Ma / R.

Masonry Walls Jackson LA-Oconee 11_

I nT 1-_t.

Update - SRP Section 3.8.1, 3.8.2, Update Section 3.8 -

3.8.3, 3.8.4, & 3.8.5 D. Jeng New Reactor 1/30/07 0

8 H

11 Bor Update Section 3.5.1.3 -

3 G'

w a'p" SRP Section 3.5.1.3 Turbine Missiles J. Ma New Reactor concurrence only M. Valentin-Tornado Design Basis Olmeda LA - Fermi 2 11/1/06 9/15/06 12/15/06 Working Progre!E 3-CID 10 0c CD CL 0

I CI I-a.

EGCB Branch Assignments C-CD (n

0 cI~

ij CD
  • 0 0

5.

CD 0

  • 0.

00

-o RAIs Input SE Inputc 0

Item Lead Project Type Due Date Due Date Due Date Status/Comnlerits License Renewal (LR) -

qa,

  • fjI.

j Scoping and Screening: Structures D. Jeng Pilgrim 9/1/06 K

'Iqf k Wor~p~g;,Ss Structures & Component Supports

.r..

AMRs & AMPs associated w/Drywell f!8,

'I Shell D. Jeng~

LR - Pilgrim 9/2/06111 S4I ý1/0 o*

66r License Amendment 5:1 a FL z

South Texas ILRT Extension Z. Cruz-Perez (LA) - South Texas Coplt/06 OnI T-Complete

'N/W.

Vermont Yankee Safety Review J. Ma LR - Vt. Yankee 6/29/06 gell 6

Wor06,Hgress Vermont Yankee Safety Review J. Ma LR-Vt. Yankee 9/1/06 06 W6ress D.C. Cook - ASME Code Complete

'Co plete Re.Containment Inspection Z. Cruz-Perez LA - D.C. Cook 2/22/06 M/2, 00i*{

-WO-_

.5I CEUS Ground Motion Project Final

  • ,a:a
0. 1 H t Report (EPRO 1009684)

C. Munson NEI Interactions 9/15/06 i.=-;

(

Scoping and Screening: Structures J. Ma LR-Oyster Creek

-o

_"t ________

Torus-TLAA H. Ashar LR -Oyster Creek AN Containment Tendon Surveillance S. Samaddar LA - Farley a& -ft N

Structures & Component Supports i-

' a AMRs & AMPs associated w/Drywell e,

iei Shell J. Ma LR - Oyster Creek

.9/31;06 CoAef(' -

Complete.

Rebar Corrosion TLAA H. Ashar LR - Oyster Creek 6/20/06 Coilete Complete T

Containment Tendon Surveillance T. Terry LA-Vogtle 5/30/06 10/30/06 On Track Emergency Cooling Pond and Inventory Requirement i

S. Samaddar LA - Arkansas Integrated Leak Rate Testing (ILRT)

Complete Interval Extension I H. Ashar INEI Interactions 5/1/06 orking ProgresA Z A is going to change ie date.

James Davis 7 AMR - Repo0rt t the NRC.doc.pdf Page 47]

Number Status Request 441 Closed U2I21-3-P-01J Table 321-3,

-S,-6. -9. -10. -15. 16 -18, qoalan 2 Tih.. lire rtbs wecify Oru-Tkhnspeaflactre lov with aothir prograe such Water Cl-rnati or Lublca-irq oil An*sysi. Howee. Table 322 canuorts t

aereWprd loti.e Tal.e II firs Ir ii-specify neu live Inspectron lodetect ossd nfaiertal. Pleas heeqe corpora linei&fs o 10il"'"e One-Ti.

Inspection or provide flu basiis [or clfng OTL Rewonnse Sinee f Oe-Time Inspection (OTI) Progpar 1. applicable to ech waterc fir control propamei IIs also applioale to aeh line Ile hat credte a water chierfry acool progren LRATatla 32.1 incel.es thP fl Oýr-Tle Inspection Prograni is credted log cwkhtfe naerchamislry cosed prograne or linsiterns lor wich GALL wneco smr l a one-irm Irupecton tocrconwrm water cheistry coatrd. Table 2credits ft OTI prograe fUlou rderence sothe associated Table I line Item.

Dourg th perfornurco dfroisne neirlennce onorprws VW otlain tkicaing oil, visud Inrspecltons dh fme

's.orewsn woUd dkledy deadid codtio' tel eould betbribied loan reflective Oil Avnfyeie Progr*,t The corrective action Iprian eI PNPS w a fow Whaelhd or Ifs klttficalion of deeaded Mrdlis -hl f ehf aecroe or cracking oforpor*ri wodd be Ideruified as -

of dn proarr Th. reciew d OWdire epieece d PNPS or Its last Wie yars dSd rd Idelify any contion reports 01 indicared an I rlectiv rio arenysis progane or hat Idertlied doeaded conponer I condoions euch a* corroeion or cracfdnig In V luiiirig oil enlf rn-e, Th. reew d ldpeing aperimete PNPS rev In I[-a ol a

-Un-Irspection to provide oorilrn-tion dl te etfectiveess df the Oil Arslysia Program TN. repira anarerutr u othe chornsatry progpa description In LRA Apedee Aard Bto clearly idicate hat the Or'sTirne Inspection Progare willoo*firm fts olfictis-sos do the War Cleristry Cotrol - BliP. itw Chernistry Cantroe - Amiliary Satenr aed Pt Waler Chfrnitey Cortrol - Closed Cooling Vts progan'su Th. ieff 1. claed to otean 372 Duing the pa*l ive pans. nwr vcsual Inrpectiore d coaporrers

.ortalnieg lUrticating cit hve been pefrned dring corrective eed prestos nruarerane aecvitia. The vist inrpecto'sd oPthese

.aowoul d Idetrify do ledl cornditions uch woa scarion or cracking PSW ruid bel'ribted loan Infectlive OfilAreysia Paoem PNPS hfas arc fIrafa:l loh the Idonaktttioir od dopaded aordtios euch Ph cOrrosion or cracking d oorrpoawas sould be NIerlitie ad antered Into the corrective action progparn No carciom reports PS Idorl ied deaced conporunl coduli'ns, etch ascorrosion or cracking ine lUbicaling oil eeirorvr were IrNliated asa reslt do Pe inspections These past Inspections aNPS FeraIn lie* dars-In. Irepelon o prmoide cafirnfion dh. dteciive'ssolte Oil Arnaysis Progran Ths [tern Ia closed go Iem 376 NRC PAPS Lead Pavirch, Wayre Feotnber Pby 47d 77

James Davis - AMR -, Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 48 i Number Status Request 442 Closad

[T321-35-P-01]

Tale 32l-35A quetion 3 The GALL o*paitia Il 1)0, Open Cycle Coling ter Syster, Prrogng and PNfPS creats the plart speciti Penodo Survaillnc and Prweeertive Martnanwe Progra'nt AJOnh te plant specific prong'a prineS. for visu ardor UT impection asin XI.M, cldose not provide for prertive aloene Provide Mu-titoaticawon lot M ading 443 Closed

[Geweal-P-01]

In gaeal, Systeir %tkdown Is crdited for manang LCM for bolting Howevr, oter aging daecta mny beactive Ior bolting amd System Walkdown does rM provide for proenraiye oiT

. Agj Ei ts a

fIortbati*rg shtdber gel wider to tmbrulta ot a Beting integ'ity Programn inaccordan-e withtOAu. prorant vmitS 444 Claw

[o-al-P-Mi Cown.o s Intoe ST oystemto ft we sypoeed to

.urs a sir weomwagW with to Itplar-peciio knlruM e Air

  • lOity ProFg' (PNPS AMP 8.1.17). TNh prosa. anly rnritors to* or o

awly. However, "t GALL Copressed Air tailoring Progran. XI.14. @Bllorely requires tlsting be shag. rateo. Impection fororrosior%

amd perforrr e laeing cororo*nte.

t proerar(s) pronite $or hese ackitiorol rertoworeas?

NI fte adiutiorol regire~el of XI.M 4 ore ad covered by araher prepmar please pronide Jatiaioation for not lWding Br Ttu oornrvtw Isapplicable to ft IA ysle.

aswell.

Resonse Iern 212.35 pecitis to Periodc S-ittanceand Preventive tore-ewe (PS1P" Proarn Intetad afO AV0. Opon-Cyclo Coning Waer Systse Prog'an, bscaroe teo erwironinet Ihdioted as raw water intlables 22-6 mrd 322-7 is Used hoi derfity wate Wtch hi untreeted bul I nad pert f to raw coding water osyeln Theedfore tohe prevetive actinre Irovn GL89-13 toat we derthbed In NUREG-1801 XM20 dorot apply. The rerring preiewins action specified In lX 20 Is rlo =et ally anongong AlP errert, faoli i the deslg acoraeltation t o aaons oe eo-otrcW ot aropriate mr-imdals. The site correrive action prioger pronldae re ablte assrarce tO Bf appropriate trita were ad proitded in to riginal ocnponrni dnig% aner rerling proterne would be saluted arl appropriate oniraclmn actions woald betaken ho ob~es tooe protlte.

A Bolting Inleapity Frograt will be dweopedl Ot will ddoress the agirg osuganwit ol.ting Infto so" oflicen.

renewal.

The Bolitg Ingr aity Progras will be inplarnenlw prior ito t pril d sede operi*ain ionaeordance with oryrilrent nattier 32 Thsis rawarowerirt Srofto LRAhoinclualt descriptions d to Boling Iblagrity Progra'n. tryperdoea Awd Bad loiartily werefot proer.r Is applcale THo itm. tl dosed hi Ite-373 Trotugh rnito*ing of air quaily. the Ire1rurnnr At r Ousliry Prograrn nirrleairn Irotrarwnt air fret gsligroficarl orntarnwrta ind walte, toraeby prewling loss o retrial. Th. approach ho merwgng los e atroter-la. non. oWNathanie ekW*

age onitoring wd repelttlve Irspe-ion be *rarosore. Perrnmrco sulmorinig Lrnder toe shreranco rniaa&*sae* active.owonart tOW wail be Irclulod Inperforn-woce testing. No aotilord agng allecl were idertitiel whose owegarnat requirrd Brae other attribes of toe Congossed rtrMlloririg Propgam MA124. Recent Ine-rnal Inspections d toe air receiver lors ld rntslre checks f tohe instnrmn air oys.err hme aod det-ted signific.eart ororon or rniste. In the oytsern Thiee past Irpectore at PNPS am. In lieuao one.doe Irnpection hoproide oortirrnwtion atf t aetiveve os lthe Iretrnarit Ar C*atly prlo*o. inrmrrwng aging olecto altoorponens aspao.ed hiimrtrrs air withxl to aciticn. prepare atrihule recorrmerdW by GALL XIW4 NRC PNPS Lead Ptwirdc, Wayre Ivy. Ted Psoinide, Wa tn Frrberger.

Pavnirct VW"yr Nichels. Bill P4w8d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf

.. Page49_

Number Status Request

Response

NRC PNPS Lead 445 Closed P31.1-J-01)

Th.actui l wa.irovrsowtn flor n#eoopocs ate ai.ee-ain/y Jackson, Wibur Firnnir Ron te sane regardens d i.

listed lerpaturen The enviroews Sone off hens Ma redrl W o Ilon 3.1.1-2 are described s*pnclying the two lempeatur.

raengs Irdicate iW the eyslear InnLRATatbe112-1 aslInenvelrmnwrl ofTreeted Water lerpenaue Istabove Ithe trehs d value that can ressllincrecking S322 dog Fand ear.o ae descrlbed as In TreatedWaer W

cue lofaigue for the specific oaponereat nerial.

TheInorerul 270 deg F.

faigue throsid for eti*rtee sl is 2701F ard lor carbwon send, 227F as stted Inthe EWRIlMochw"il Tools (EPRIReport FPnnso justify Whe use oe two lmperature rangee to describe 1C056).

We ifuirw"",fo ot We conponers L roIl upto Iten 3.1.1-2 46 Ckoed (3 ?. -J-O Drarwirngs ware wraiteabe or NRC rwiew durir fe eta visit Jacksoni Witslb Cten, we rI-care Hwinrge; Nozles -Hal Seal Lit-fl (Nit NI3).

447 Closed

(.I.-J-0M The license renewal function of those a

rte (prenssre Jackscr W slbur Firnin, Ron boiunadry) a

-ns the odd besween the ID) Stchenet aid Whe InLRA Tiale &12-1. We Carpae TypeIDAttachrani vewsen Becaute.so ooe arpormre aredrectly afached o.the Wads (wors sray. drywr hoId down pads, edc) we Inslicaled preesure botrday, they were

  • aonifVvdy given an ireende as haing Whe Irtenlerd bunction at prnsure bourndal.

tlrction d preeesur eb ldery. This a.weonsisteol with We **mdinnmr dv resd lOatthm*l o

dwdsI nNUREG-A80I Soction-IVAI-12 Pleese ju(ify Wethese aorpoawts provide apressure XI oMAU 448 Closed 31.t-J-0 These attachnenw widc *a rot specificy listed In te reaclor Jackscr, Wlbur Firnd; Ran veedsel strs respot h rwv, ey e boundon by the faruts d tha LRA Tbe.te3.2-f.2-r1icae OWet forW ID Altasc* t Widc.

reow Any veneed stres repev dcnepW ASMIE Sectio fit oonresir the eging delet c Ctracking-lal IgLW Is nweged by a TLAA CUFi orty [or those Ioediona We1 the desiger fit could be fatige liniting While only fO liuniting ssares aectuly calcUciew4 tstd eisei e n*t owsthl entire veesel Ple.ediscuss whether those achprbonl explicitly addre sed Inthe TL/A af btie by the resite e

A copy c the vessel Ctress repod (Cortuation Enrineering TLAA. &.e the nsecitic TLAA

  • t*e n*gs he aging CENC-1139) w-prodc lothe Inspeco.

effects CrCracking-tal igL in tine cnrTo*er?

PaW 49d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 50!1 Number Status Request In LRAT&abl 112-3, carlon clad pipin and Piint~gs valves Ina trestad w~gaets'irwrnasi we shown as hainitg tealing 417. ole los of. mfeial. Th. Sor

-a.,gne-A progarent eetw by cn~tnayodncl GALL. bllne te Volsc 1. Tabe. Ihern 13. Is Water Charrstryd C-Ti-ns.kpetonie.

Fot piping and fittng and valves with diaetera -. C NMS the a gini nagagrenw pog'a Is shoewn a-Water Charniatry Cor*CI - BM"1 ard bkavniic hmapenior In LRA Tad*.312-3 I

ppig w d littings ad vave with darn~ae -r NPS, We aging Oregonert prog en Is shown as ba~s Chenistry Control - BM'W In LRA Table S1.2-1 The note asanlgaf-with the line lhents In IRA Tabl.

11.2.3 Is NoteC*

Fa Oe carboen steed piping wd fitting ad valves with dedeera~ -r NPS, pleats proide. justificatin that Nd.e C Is ths "ede rotte. b apy r leeSae opnenyasa F"e cahen lad piing and Shyn ard valves with daeraa

. 4* NPS. pl=s. provide justificain tha Not. CIs the rad r

oen da oapply lotft ca.neervasase Also, loe Owea eernpoenwd bPea Proided justifctiodin for rot parleniniia os-albs isayeni astaronsdd by GALL. line lient Vol-1.

ITausc l.11-13.

Respontse Asa*Wnified In t.

dacusioan Ornn earyot Table 31.1 ent 13 (31.1-13), VWaer Chemistry Contrd -BWRis augn-ared byh.

Or.Timn Inspeclion Progrnt loassu.e *alt-ehea dtlhe water ehadry progwn ThN Is itr whiweven tie water chenstry prograi is radlied The Water C*rninsy Cntrld - BWR and Or.Tim Inspciati Proegna, by theladves, sasty the NUREG-Ie1 re.

sonlaeliOs.

Th. ISI PrograntI sPensa ihe Water Chniatlry and One Timn Ihspedien FProg., bWi lnot ricessary Ioatisty bth NUREG-1801,aeoncrswvtions. Sire. Ie Wat.e Cheraistry Cacrrd -BW8 ard Cia-Timn hrstien ro-aong aroo nmsterl with Ith NUREG"IEo progen.,aNdNe "weC"ls appropiate Sbre Ite ony viable onomtlonfo lr these ppng and valve lines Ilsi NV.CI-6 for Isolatioens osarter cotpotwrs. Nde "C".. l Ibasegd Foa onrrpoen with daettlar. 4-NPS. th atwer Is thelsae Both Water Chonds" Corhs d -tBWR ted O(.Tim Inspectlon Prog-en.

"sely bothese eornonas., whichIs consiaten with the oooeraowayion-d NUREG-1801. Since he only viable nasyarisas I aset.

piping and valve line Iso/VCI-6 for latidon ordanenr conlarwts. Nale "C nut beused NRC PNPS Lead Jacksont, Wlbr Flnenl, Ro Fa 50,7

James Davis - AMR -,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf

.. Page 51]

Number Status Request

Response

450 Closed

[1..t-J-CO]

1) As iarepanol InSection B 123 odth IRA oThenaerws d ft rogarr include (a) deemrnimon doto In LRATafle &L12.1, eon.cti Ioirrypon wihaging

&aTde sizeosna roneanseessne-ciTref-iaineld Ii atitio:n diedt sofmedalar c

NM roltt cLo io LRA Talbe I Fir.e liar anticrotmer plare agn effects.

anl cpwlcrin ecierlantc (b) 4.1.1-14 sho, tOw aging taprt Is licprdov be y Wyralor kltdicatlio ol d

iat Inslection keatoionr Inthe sysnim ao Chrneisty Cotrd-BWA and nimtle. InWaedior; clhers of oowgonrl btnad on the ing ael.a (c) de-raration oi to

5. congponerns withaging Sffeet -Lofn WMarier tlat rol iaarinuon teohnique incluldrg eco*eilo-a crilaril tat rwoud be W tIo LRA Tabe I line it-r 41.1-14 nho ft! aging SllecveiIn nansrlilg to egng Sffect tor wrichrte cororerl Is nragncwi8 provided by Waler Chrarisnry Contdro -

Warainert and (d) evalation f the oeed for Idlow-up eartrinaiora BWi.

Tim -nrespondling line iotn InGALL -Une 14 in to ""rftor te progression o any asin degademiron Volo e 1, Tabie 1-dshmws fto Ang I gaorert In aofitklc gA*aen of NUREG-1801 Ifor MAW and XMA willibe Proram a "Water ChoinsW and "Or-Tiena Inpseti" wed to wect serve poires IRA Nol. I1.22 ragraph 3, Indicaes tot OC-Time Ispection dcreeperenlatl eoarnies willbet sed loo-dirm

2) They will beinluedod Inthe popodalion from whch te o arnles th effectvernass On hWer Cherrstry Cotrol prgan ane selected tMch specirf ie.ms willbe Irmpeded will be doermined byagting the tguidees hrcm NURE-1801, Section Ckeatiort

)20 I andt A.MI when PNPS ItplasrTn tin prog*an Peassn dec.ss to rieria feo seneftnhe to sarnpe pd*its

3) Tihe coerpo-wos &we welded to tO. reacto cooldas preosu-tor the O-Tirm lrnletio-sa botndary. Coreec5uerly, tean contonerts werm coservatively dear arlraoda* k,.tr-i ivg-esa boeroy. Tirrn &.I--

Wil the Tln'rmt Pawwta li roll r to LRATaie I line aWecOridered otject Io agirn r eoomrarsvion in lIart41.1-14 bespecifically Impeated? Or.willt y be NUREG-1801 liar IVAI-7.

Ileluded In tho popation Iram whNch owrponents we edecld o on-tim In.lecaion, Ii rot specifically Pleense desrie hr w tam he t

ro inedlot provide the Irteaded tc-ion d Proresse Bo-do

  • y Does Wpreesnrn bo-rdtoy -in" caed - amrn RPVpresnur-torobry.

451 Closed Ia31.1-J-"

The ddectors Indicaeld as 6stielo" (CRD)waw detectors for preno-a and leae Inthe **rnm eccurnelalor-,

Pelse clarity lto tnction dfto cornparo InTabln 11.2-3 Idaksfied on*D ectcr (CRD)? Is IN. the rod poston Irndioator onsnatly.

aonrswattng nine?

452 Cloned 13,1.t-J-CB A copwl dWFIP-139 wosnproided Ioft Irmpacor, Plesse nake avalable during the sto vnsit a c-py ofth SWRVIP recomnrodaions reamed tos*sng warrgetmn d the sletn drye.

NRC PNPS Lead Jackuonr Wits, Firrirn Ron Jack-eoc WItr Fithn, Ron Jackson. Wlits,

Cha, Wai FP. 5O1d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 52 I Number Status Request 453 Mcceplal f33. 14-M0 The GALLs recommended ang traragora5 pro Sm l

the sltem yw Is 'Aplar5-speciic.g, P.w program islobeevsuelad hI Table 3.12-2 the Aging Iv sw Program Iandtifled for ft sin, dryer is 'BM Vessed hlemeu$ and Ndte TEl.apsled PleMs. slin why Note E (rather then Ndte A) i. applied Sor the line ier The lud sion of dNodes on LRA pages 30-4 and 30-5 sitmes that 1le&ler designl fom we standard Maes bs0ed on Apperdx F dN NEI 95-10 (RMdaaan 30-3).° The referencs is o HNEt 96-&I, Revision BI Howa.., review of the rdle -

finds Ma Append. F Isa.od lnstiry Guibgase on Revisd 544(a)(2) Syoping Criteriari ad Ndss wse csciased In Tae 42-2 itwel dtch ut Ms..

Fuse

'ral this adnnihirsia e. wem Intl. LRA 454 Closed 111.1-J-l0 GALL be, VIAl-5 Irdicales M penetatioIu r IlSm l*,lc ard Sor the drain lineroll up i

GALL. Viot..

1, Table 1. Itea 40. Th. LRA does nn inrciat Oe pelfalronr form" drain linelad ilor Ow rnorito rolldpSo LRA Table 3.1.1. Baen 4M. Plejse uttify why the drain line pentatiotns and the flux inortor penetrations we ro 4S5 Closed

([l.1-J-1l In LRA Table 312.I th agg dal itcracking Smr CRO Sltb Titus and InCore Howinmi Is dhwn a mrseged by Water Cherdsiry Contrd and SMM Vlsset Interis APS In GALL to asing eilit os*caing lom thees ronaonons is sihown a.s wag*d by Water Cheiistry Contrd ard BW PlMese csss-why PNPS ten IbmLded tIts iory*en In the 6 Vessel Interesl progr raher t in the 6MM Ponsrationm prograrn asrecsw-dod by GALL

Response

e Td is T

edl rather than Ndoe 'A becase the NRC ard NEI 87.0d hi ". No.e 'Frasti Nun Note 'Awhen GALL sp..r.. a pgnt-speciic 1roganx Ths lId caet s need for te staf ho relv the actwcstalblity ofSnt progran, whie Nose 'A' womd Indicale that w

h sew e ofd te progsn hadl slre, been acsi.ed as dncauled n ithe GALL report Th. apprcpriate rduu-erce mr U. iRA staatd m*rne Is NEI 95-10.

Revision 6, Awpads C ratlher tNn Auperdx F. This rsclUr..

arnwtart ionm LRA Aporlion dIis qjasiin reqtirns dariiicatia Table S12-1 does no Inlue a cornpe lyps spsecficialy mrned -ta mornitm psnststiom" The Immns hol ing s, wihch povide vesse pwslrlons Sm, flu. deaectors. ase te d stlaiess ated ad Sor the aging ellect docrsckig ft pirter p

o Tale al I Is isAwn 40.

The drain nozzle InTable 31.2ol, which presabidy Is the dnrine peaisratin indlcaed Innthe u ator% Is omeyseld ofcarbon sisd, so rdIl4, o Table I1.1 Hann 40. Sm statins adool carourts, woAid be irproprqiale.

ThI.

PNPS 6MM Perstratioia Program is Ectnsstarl with he NUREG-1801 Section XI WB, which aersonly SLCIOP ozle and Irturimn paewrations aa.disc-esn InBWRVIP-2* and BWMVIP-49. PNPS Incldes the CRO slit, bbes and Insrirmusr hoIings Inn 6MM Ves.d Irindl Program -ety asomaled by BWRV1P-47. Lower PlMum whchlsminiLudd InNUREG-1801 program XI.9. TN is sltightly Inoiuislr with NUREG-1801 Setion IV. A PNPS Idl Jt was begeto be cmuistenl with In*

panm In Saotin XI em t one ll. ieans in Setion IV At PNPS, both the 6MR Penetrationu Prog, and the BWR Ves.d blamrss Prngam w. Isrerartaed by the sans plus predure NRC PNPS Lead Jahckm WtIol Finnin, Ros t

Jackom, Wlb Finin, Ron Jacksna WWbr Finn. RoMn Pay R of 77

James Davis - AMR -Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 53 ]

Number Status Request 456 Closed 1t.1t--121 in LRATaele 3.12-2 ft Conenorot Type Ccrtrd rod guide thebe - kbo" Is In anOraWroremehl d'Treeld water >270 dog-F. *asd to Corponet Type tCortrol rd guide hubl e -

base. Islnanerwironsert d Treeed water >482 de-F'.

Pls.e clarify what Is mee i by Cortrol rod guide kthe -

bette and splden why t. enrirorwt s. different koo the

'Cont rod guide le

-tube" 457 Closed

[3.1.1-J-131 In LRATable 112-3 the arty componaeis Iderlitied as

=nirho U.

the a tig o*et c.

d Lo erial ids toFAC and Incl Inthe Flow Acodelred Cýrosion AW ee cartbn sled piping and flirng >- 4' NPS. Th. GALL descriplion of the FAC Aip (XIMt7) dinot ritoll apipicability of this program based on pipe darnter. peise justily why orly he large-dbanoer pdpigin Table 31.2-3 Is ircludod InUTh FAC po'arn Plse. Idetly the piping s.irts that we Included in the FAC progre Ino IRA Table 3 1.2-458 Closed 13.1.1 414 InLRATaleI12-2 Iorccrporeont withaing teol 1ace cf IWeitler thel roll up to IRA Table I hm 3 1.147, U.

NVP Is Ikertifid as nWale CheMsrsy Control BWR."

However, InU. GALL U. aging onect of l.s.

d MAsterial lor these con po.r. "Is noenegod by bth Water Chodilry and Inteovic. Irepecoin (rWB. IC, NVs aWdO. Plesse Juaity why Wtter Cheerrislry Contrcl - BWR with no asoociated Irevpotion hisadelptle Daseree lie aging ffe.l of Loss WIterial or thet. corponerTs

Response

NRC The CROT base Is located neri the bIlomr oiU guide tube and Jackson, Wibur supports U contro rod whns Ut.rive hi disconnected ard reroed lor srlvce.

The contrl rod gude tube Is mode of sasiries sted. It ersironert hI givo as >270 ¶F became U. is U. tlhrehold fIr taligue of Wl*-lrin $leel prteh EPRI Moohanioel Tools

((tomo). Th. guide tUe tbe h eadn dcCASS ad corespuotly IMs*aroert was quoted se >482 -

as t Is Ui.

threshold lor lwod' oai'riftlearl InCASS. The liting terperolure wase*istedor oach ob nporort Both cofrpora swo the soae l*erpeonlurn Ptnw-eccelersted corroesion (PtC) hi ad expected ht.. belasgilioeri Jackson, With aging insctarewism U.

ft norlty of U. moacor coole-t systemn (ircldi*g piping and 1linig, <4 NPS)

Us.

he fire. areisier dldr med (such as, ncra. dlchrge hteder, we spray. HI-PCt nucler sysb*rn prnsler raldil. PASS. RCIC, RHR, co* &C) or twe II luttle flow whle In ue (CRD,NBVt, RWCU). in LRA Ta.le 312-3, carbo stel piping sogrret

>-4' NPS (sooh ea leedwaotr pipirng we Ircluied InoUe FAC Protage PIPS has reiswed U. FAC prowae and *rrlined U.t inclutres a portion f

r.mtor vnsed drain piping thaU supplies RWCI, and teId. hi erall the-caronsteclo pipin-g PPPS willadd ik of seleri clue to flto clealo taed coarion to 11he line entry or srrel bore piping (<4" NPS) InLRA tbe 3 12-3 (paeg 31 I-").

The nsw wary willIdetify FPow accder*ted crroiorn as a seperate eging tloct as done lorthe large bore carbon led l

pipng entryo pegs 1.8 The GALL corwisor will be Volume 2 ita iV.C 1-7 which rolls up to Tab[ 11. 1a-4 This reqdreir an errandirathi the LRA The Itese InTaete 11.2-2 U.a roll Utp to Uir Im 3.1.1-47 (GALL

Jackson, iutr to 14V N item IV.AI-6) are ict lose cid U.i..l dhide pling and crevice -r-iou NUREO-IOI repeaedly credts Water Chenilry Control - BWR anegted byte Cue-Tirre Irpection pro-a. to virege gsloe ci nirerlal dui io pining and ereice corrosion (for saerye IVAI-8, IVAl-I1). Thi progra. coirtnrtion Isr a lse e

to lags IVis aging elfect Inl ht the losol rrelerial due toipining and crea o cwrosioi o the Isternol is r1o dfterel fte th. Ioeo o mnlerial due hi piling and corrosion fo. otier etailos slte coron -tl exposed lorhi clomor clarl. As Mald snTaele 1.1.

ft Ore-Time Ispection Progra. willverity ofwlilveeso ite Wale Clerristry Conrdl -SWR Prograt PNPS Lead Finr.n, Ron Firrin, Ron Finrnir Ron PW 53d 77

James Davis - AMR_- Report.t the NRC.doc.pdf

.Page 54]

Number Status Request t9 Aootied 111.14-lJ-5 I-LRATatIe a1.1. 11r Nurbs 3.1.1-48 Disaasion IrelIU*olasWa~atu,

'In-a ic. Irspacion Isaro agtbt btq-,o ats

<. NPS." ASME Section Xl.

Tabl. l 20 2C0-1. Exafoniran Categoy B-J. rayir.

Strfce. (Wu nr Volumlric) eacairdion for presa..

re:airing "e inCclas Ipipe OtW I<a4 NPS. Plaee re l I* ta" aiianrl in llem 31.1-48 Disconsswio h -ia ASWE S.cIi X rayu f

staale sba 460

)cjed jal.-J-16 InLRA Tat*lall.I. Itae Nier aLt.1-a Dilsluon rIc"fudw toa awat -CrackirlIn saled owoponrts dus It ith'eel and iratad od I

llwr l

lar ditr y dteodert w wader deristry, soorly OtW C)i-Tlmn kwection Pro Is Iredtitel Howeer, thle era ao lint teams In he 3 X2 Tables wher. "rne-Tlwna Ispectioa by Itself roll. up to wari Nu.ber 31.1-48. Plea. *ain the awwet Intro slecy b oween lie LRA italamot and th. way VW the rolitnpsloite-n Nmber 31.1-48 a. dot-Inft. WRA

Response

Wfile AME Cod. kt.. MB-25DD-1 (Cctegory B-N-I) doe. r"r.

Vr-I orVT-3i4mpeclon *ilho ieloloranad-a ard we oqati stulurn, 11 do. rot reuire Ispeolian d th ivority dith rterrelt. Tierdoe, cradling ISI Woe lr"rng losa dI mnierial dI l

Intmarls In gonaeal 1. Irnaropriata.

The PNP<PS G-T-rac-litn Pmo-will Irt

e. lft raufth doher bapacliors W eae plrmd Iclding IR Irpatlici done per ASME XlIWS-250-l

&-N-2aid othi

,P*oilutlo Iepecatons.

Pe tws h talent en ISI does ot apply Is.sledng Wa ahohd tare "acd en PNPS does rb tadlt tIt o*- rig ramrgaret dpiping; <o. ISI lypiocty only rep.grf surLic.

.arrinsmo oft ea..e ip

apr, e

aid a.4 efects reasiring raagnre Iritialao on ea ID. ralora woclid nt tredil SI eor lnrertg iha affect..

An WRA arrmnenr Is rolupred PNPS will wi d he LRA to da1O a. a*towa l 'Inaloia Inselot is rod appliiabla bo corp-itcc< 4o NPS. Iram a. dscussia In line ieml 1.1-4 Tloawillreauiraana trwrlw ta. WRA For atlcfitoe the a. sletU

  • Cracking Inaid toapoates doe bothwrmW and ntotrit loding Isla droydoeslent at wader chemistry, soorly a.e Ct-Tine Inspction Prop-at I. traitta alould baddala A.F WA ara-t Is raiird PNPS willead a. WLRA t.

ade lol.a staear-n 'Cracking inasled terroat. do. lo t-eat-ad nadtko IoadgI bMr drectly iqnaeni an waler chernistry. "ony ti Oa-Tint Iopeclion Prograrn. crailedt arn a *lsdcuion In line ftem 3.1.1-48.

Thaswaitlrlqudrsenateadit Ilea. WRA NRC PNPS Lead Jacksona Wilbu Firsi; Roa Jmcklo% W*it Ungrdaler.

Fbpg 54d" 7

James Davis - AMR - Reportto the NRC.doc.pdf Page 55 II Number Status Request 461 Aaisd l 3.1.1-J-171 InGALL V*l* 1, Table 1. Ske 49 an augoeed Impaction wing UT ar othe denowtratied ac-om1e Impection Is recaowendud for BrM. with acrwice nfh s¢ems hode mere.

Doos PNPS tvo a cwcce Inthe acs.

de hco.ers?

Coos PNPS perform ar impwcticn d she acas hode Waver Wing UT or oth dawo traled meqplable Irepcticn tachrqeu?

Response

NRC PNPS Lead TIMEUNE OF SHROUD ACCESS HOLE COVER EXAMINATIONS:

Jacksont Wlbr Pados. Rich 1 SS8 -GE Issueos SIL 462

-1991 (RFO-8) - UToIboh coova (for cit. faw. oy)

-19M2 (RFO.9).- UTo dbth o*ne (lot cim-ad radt flaws)

. 1995 (RFO-I0). UT dz zeo dor. cow oary

-19% (RFO-I0) -VT-I debedh maws

- 2I

-GE louus $1L 462 Rm.l on 301

-2X13 (RFO-14)-EVT-1 ctald h o es.

-205 (RFO-15) - -

asa

-2007 (RFO-16)-Maneoimpoct 0a18 dgeaes byVT.I

-.20 (RFO-17)-PMa lohapect al0 dagoea byVT-I Pigrim willcontinuo SoImpat ie am o damceasahl d aIo0 degreeo mad 0deogma visuallyat ard Syear Inerodo, reapectiely. iring the cnt lacen-sing period I new BWRViP gtidi e Is a losaso tss e noo ront.

FPNPS will poerorm Impectioe In maordorce withithat gt*,adeo Wt-in the lirt 6 yera d t period d tende opetiwon mrd esy 12 years hweotetr, FNPS will Lsperct the acm s hioe coers with UToWlhods. Airaltiody, PNPSwillinp*ai flu memo dhe

-wes Inaceorderwe withBRMViP gidolines shodd ouch This 1. ornoitwt fen 34 Category B-Gt-d the ASM)a loa ocaim tie rtierems for all preasr-relairningboiling >2da. inlhe ISI Proagwný The owlo reuires a vkatlteria (dltranc) exmaw f all RPVackaure altuc (marirtaed Inplace) a"d aVT-I voslo m-a m all RPV clacato* "

ts eary lOyews.

Caltgory B-0-2 d the AStE X)a odce orcains the reqiars

[lor preosur-relairingblting aZ2"da inthe ISI Progrnt Theacode reeIpte a VT-I vioial maw eary 10myen for bIdling Insh $

casgosp (Includea CRD NVgo b.i1ing RPV hed N7& NS o-zze Rarnge olting).

4G2 Cloosd

[3a1.1-J-8 RA Table 3.1.21-eists 1

1 he I pogra ats the AM wed to moanagg Ite aging effe rm olc king InOtl"w Pressure Boundry Boling - Upper hied Rlamge bne and ntds - CRD Riange boiing Moe IdWet ify the ASMa Exasrumlion Category and Resulr-,tss thal me apoicable for these

-onoes Jack"sa u

lbWi Par Rich PW 56d 77

James Davis - AMR_- Report to the NRq.doc.pdf Page556:1 Number Status Request 4

o3 Accted (1tl.-Jt19 LRA Table 31.2.2 Idtrfdes *Tlnna Aging ErntciOflen-d CASS" IS AMP o manags ft agi effect d

  • rfd*fni Inftacrto lou.hn4r
  • for "'as l

opn.t *te tCortrl Rod GOdo. Tub.

-Basen, Fuel Suppot Mneca -

Fou Laf, and Jd Pomp Asseolieas jvaIou O-onas-].

  • H-o LRA Table &-2 says rwthe NUREG-t801 ProTnm fThw"lr Aging Enftritlen*w of CAW I. "rn' egicabla? at PN PS Please correct wt usify ee cpoerst In sisleturIy twe LRA Also, IC an WA orrnlion Is ro pie.e. -oose ted the Ndt. Ior each di the thr ocoponert line Iters we validaed or clwra lo beconislant withary clhagoes irde oIn. LRA 464 Ctosd 131.1-J-20I GALL Volurne ITable tUne 521doti.fe. t aging allects lor RCPS closue bdling as nCracing OA so SCC. ls of nateri du. to wner, Ies of pro load &s; lothernel effcts, gsket creep al d t-loeelo.

Only ft aging dfect o "Crkfni Is Idenflied I"LRA Table 3.1.2-1 fot :oponerC Mrdlvlo LRAUr lI-e 31.1-52 Th. 'Discsti sio' In the C

RA Ior Uns 11-11.1-52 proviedesc dssion of ty Cu othe asgng efectt lised In GALL me not Included applicabe 51 PPS.

Please e

provide PNPS bi for b

t Oiscassioon tate~n l

nt dustry opeatinrg seperirce Indicales OW loss i rnleSl dseo ow is olo a slgnlficart aging effect lot hei biling' Msle. claily whot Is n*wei by'n:

ssignificar-agin t

efoc.."

Please provoids sopyof dtn lehncal i'ernce(s) sipyonting Cu A

W mrAW n

tha *Loea o preload d.e.beltre relaxation (creep) would oily bee cncern in very Ngh lepn*oalwe applicalions (> 70D dog-F).

ReWonse NRC PNPS Lead Fin-in, Ron NUREG-1801 prog-am X.Mt12 lTlrnol Aging Ertoittaenol ci Cast Jackson, WibW Asualiti Slsirdess Sled (CASSr)egiee soCASS preese boundry coponts Inlthe ACS. This proJgan Is noi aplicable to PNPS, as we lone noCASS prewsne toamd'y ooporis.

NUREG-t801 prorgw XIM3, I

ThZTrool Agng aird Netkon Inradaliion Ebrilftlefnt iCael Awleliic Stainless Sled (CASS)*

applies S reator vessel Internals (roriprewe bounsdry) pinces trade of CASS. Th. ntimed cormoral.s above neeall reactor vessd nlierrl and reooverad by heyprogre bIorne Instarces. thC.RA relon SoTh. not Agrg Enciflernet d CASS Programe asa shyoteued ndrre lon and withea h/ptirk tothe Thernol Agng and Nearion Iradlaon Entritlteoenl di Cal Autenitis Slaintes. Sled (CASS) Progran For dcicaticn, Itkoe Instarces willbe revised to cterly Indicate a

e appropriate prg-ron TN*isre siroananodriri Isothu WRA Toclarityft RA dicussion Inline Item 1l.t-5Z, f praes'rd ol sigrlicad aging dtner owens no wanging dinte repaving; nonegonwIt THNis 1.conistelr withthe EPRI Mach-icW Toie OtW donol consider loedi aterial die oSoww omaging dnect lot boited cloaews. In addtiotr los of moerial del A

o weer was now Mirtified asan area dconcern Ilthe ocltiion odGSI-29 lor boling TI. gerer spetem dbling bowtihoih isl it eM il Is no rottinely dsassentled. Occasional Chrod lailuris dui Io ws inecIrearesm oluh sa gdtri ste not age related bAl e evenl-driven cordlithns OW wte reolved when they occur.

Boiling al PNPS Insdeatd-t adi 7e cTaor steel. or irnilar mnaerial. acep In specaelized application whee slaines. sieed bolfing i utilized Los of prel oad doe Iteostr relaxaton (creop) wold oily bea concern Inver high twmcnar applicatons (,

7W(r) as stated lnto ASI Cods, Sewtion I. Pat D. Table 4. No MIPS bolfing operates at >7WlF. Therelore. o" of prelodl Os Io alens rdacaulon (creep) Is o n appliceagie ng egdct for t reactor coolrnt eystel A nopy d thie swionmd shtcode was maildale ding the adt.

Jnkbson, tlbr Firrnn, Ron Fagde 56 f 77

James Davis - AMR - RepOrt to the NRC.doc.pdf..-.

Page 57]

Number Status Request 465 Closed ll.1-J-21]

The LRADiaw*aoOn or Un. hoe 11.1-52 Ircludes tha staltM

-To address lwo boting lopcrdord conerns, PNPS hs takl actions loaftes. NUREG-1339.

R..duLion dc enc Soety tssue 29: Bolting Degadtion orFailure in Nuclear Po.er Planish!

Ple.se ikllny ad govfd. a copy of any prvio.i, dockelted corr de In woNch PNPS doocribes It actioi and awrsrilwts (1iiarr) witreogo:d oNUREC-1339.

4a Closed 131.1-J-22 in LRATableo12-1 alline onki flarfie thesong offedo LooLa kotoerit" for thse corxroti ypa "Chot. Barg.

osub. mi. walsher, wd bhinrgs,* NoteH'is appied o this li15lem, Ircicotirg VW the aqng dofdt Is no In NUREC-1801 orthis onorar no taral ard e-wirormrn!

cortrsntion Pleae Idalily ard dscuts the rexhwdrn taet creat the aOng efld oLas di Lkhr.is Inthese owomreti.

Ples.. kirlity ard describe PNPS-speciic or Inrldty e*syairco where the agoig effect

."Los s olft r.o Pas been oserved inth1se oer.oneis.

Ple. Irdtda a& da-s.io f why Lose i ofMthi i..,

agog taplicable pyl theslo e

t o ono sto 201 6 for cononeals tat rdltluto LRA T*ble Ure Ilen31l.l-

Response

0-91-17, Oewmi Safety Iosu 29. Bditngig d*jadti ora fmloIln

-o-le jowe plo-rIs dad I 017191. The CLi sired no respon-o d no odocteltld ooro-pornonca wao ibtritetd PNPS dd ratiow OL91-17 In199gt a or a-review stmory wao proklded bo tie NRC audt leaht "rng the sit visit Potly as a reedt Of ite PNPS raiwvo cL W9-17, Station IMrwennce pr*OUre fior bltiiU 3 M4-52 was divelopta based on EPRI NP-507. *Good Boling Pracic*e*.

Inthe Noo-Clos I Macoaitcal kirla-t'ion tilcitno and Mecheaical Tools. Revision 3, EPRI, Palo AJto, CA 200t. 1003055 (The Mocharical Togs) Appendox., low alloy sted elyo od to irdoor air contidong noostur (hurnidcty) Is tjaectl b loss of noearialsd 6 d

o t0- afrn rnonte lI*o of general cororois Ths botiling hten ha ths noteal ard rwioroar 1 oontlmlion aod tmidora he aging affect Is applicale In acoordewe with Be petarinrg esqymene proved Inthe Reactor Heid Closuro Studs Proon% errs*ation ci1I rIStlor head doow.e tmta sod aisut xaoTinotion oi 18 Ws and lB woaolr during RFOIS lotnd no nw ratordle Iadcldioe d *c lo i raial LRA Taole Uno Ite31.1-52 b.based onNUREC-180I, Volune I.

Table I which afdesse loss ood notaril di only Io wear for carboo and staliress *leol bolting Since to NUREG-1801 line torn ds

6. adte any odhi aging mneorisroe hIW rostl in hoso merla, It woo deeaed t the line lien is nro *Wicabio for lossod na-l otr r,2 gto re9 corrosion.

NRC PNPS Lead Jockso% Wilbur Ce tori.

Jack-% WIbbur Firrh Ron Pad 57d77

James Davis - AMR -,Report to the NRC.doc.pdf...

Page 581 Number Status Request 467 Cloa 11.1-J-23 LRA Table 11.2-3 Includs a line Item lor tMn Slesrline Flow Rstoricnlo. eds df CASS. 1nan -wir-el of Trealsed Wwr. 482 dog-F, agng dffect of Redction In Frsmuro Toughness Fmr Class I piong nwonol made of this mralwel, Inaths ilnronrnwt and withthis aging effe1t, te GALL rasos.srab t

MP XI.M2. "Thetrml Agng Emnniht*err, d Cast Austemiot Stsiles Staod (CASS). In u of the rscomn-edad AP. PNPS propoeae 10 ue a On-Tie Ikpection.

O itho-:

The GALL-reoo-mont l AP includes screening criteria b dalarMire whch CASS aorponaes awe att*tialy s.uceplibtle o therssl aging ofl'itite-aid reg-ire agnarrled Itrpection Has PNPS appled the Koraening crieria to te tin Sýasslne Flow Rsmictos? I so, what washe reaetis?

Fless describe wha e*l*erl ion reqairroaris, sflhods and aWaistdd w1lb1 besd InFPNPSa prnopoeed Oe-Time Ibelpeion odthe tin, Senarrine Flow Restictse.

PlMese jusify that a n*t-Ti we Itrpetlon providos adalte aging nwagwent of t*e in SSterdine Flow Rastriclonl dring tlh period of aWadard olpralion.

468 Cloaed 13.1.1-J-24]

IRA Its Number 11.1-53 Ciawaion tla., "Thw.rara no s*lea onpen of tde Class I redoo vensd, vessal Itrnarels a ractor aoort prossure boundary ae*pe to nloeid cycl odirn a

waler." However. LRATable 3o1.2-3 (pege 3.1-68) ilrrudes lire tirnt tr PunF

-ow -Ther borid (RR) rndle of CASS where ise ang irwaeg-1 progrars awe iderotlod as Watlr Cherstry Cotrol - Closed Cooling Wsla ard "ieasvice Impwlio.

These line hterr wpow lobe Irnmistmers withthe Discuassion inl.1-5.

Ple.

eplain why those lirear not Incorsistent wilhthe Discueionlnsl.1-53 mnonsec the Inconsiste*ay.

Response

P'ho talin sales har flow reat Tosaa we Mp rese rdaiingl ponrwis (no presso boeundary luriycn.

They wa a as pa*ns tha Is Isreotl Ibide the alan slern piping The ains steam piping sthe preoems btudvy. Conreluefrly. the atlsa sle fow rehritorus aenru agnoold *ardcOa for GALL progran XIMIZ o) No, PNPS heM nor dne te scre*ing for t*e nsin ales, line ftow orlicto,.

b) Whls teh Itrpecsion pore ar he hs r al yetboeen da oped, te planne drylion Is a svisual eanioedion parlmed by kee*ing a awerss Ito the amln sleow line n) Reduction d Fracture Toughress (Crooking) and Lo*s of timi d theal stlew tine flow rehtlolors ae not oonoclred likldy effects doing t. period d extended ofwardion (No agong of thosa tretrictlts.idenlified byNUREG-1801). Loos od aterial witl be Miligated by BRM -Water Chods"y Coatrol. Norwholet, PNPS hes conitted tocdo a one-itreo Ipec lion tSo wrily tha time aging edfeats we as rot urrin Since the flow rstlrio*or we na premsure relairing ncon irls. the Ore-Tire Iympectlin Progaen It eiiate tonnseg the aleets of aging NRC PNPS Lead Jackson, Wlbur Firrin, Ron As stated Ins a queiion, tIem 31.1-53 rmera to stosl nopornts.

JacksKr Wibur

Usgredlr, CASS Itscomiered stainless Sadel. The soeeiad and awiro-nr corinatireon d stainless stla In losed cyleacooing water doe us pw Inthe RCS (CI-qiar IV) labed of NUREO-180l; tedore, te line fient tthe purp

-oe -Varra baerrie Ia nr.ged tothe ESF tase dNUREG-1801.

P'ay 511d;?7

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 59]

Number Status Request 4

C69 sJ 3to.3--

  • NPS LRA Tabe 13.2-3 Icudes trsm for Ing and fitmngs m ded carbon sld Ins environrrvm cir-indoor (ext). Sons cd these enr.es ha mnging edfet of dow sf interil;

-nt dfthew entries have snging effect of

  • rnons. For ia neinis wilthang affect ofrot', Nolo 101 is w1piid and staies. "Hiho-oner surfacestaemp uro piectke, nmsture aco*nUlion-thad remid t In Pleei clarity she high terpr asre onodtions that we netnioreod Inths noot Wed Is the'high telperatde tIshr d? For pipingld expmiemne slgrilicarl lenmeram r catngess duing opanalion, spoimosirldy wid permoargo doperation atllarperature below Ow high tmirdaoure threshold Is swared cr antcitiated or tose piping and fitings where the agg effect Is 'nort?

Piens. deiscus she metodogy tht PNPS wes to lidenlty wch bpipn is clasified w hsasing agng edect o d"los of ndmter and wih ho agiss ar ffect ol -none" 470 Acceted f3l.t-J-261 PNPS VRA Table 112-3 contain two line itenm for tolting (flatsg. vaes. alccr where the nm ia is eishl low alloy

.lsed or stainle. stseele threirronse Is Air-lndoo (iederl),

and 3M slog dm llt

1. cracking Pis.e Stntlfy fM -li-hPat caew tNIsagng deft In thew co.npoiws.

P*ian juitiy td te 3

mrvice Irspeidon pooganpid maging.f' mrmrrnanmio cthw, perlorm Z 1,IrtemnWO fsi tUmllop wi~ngl the pinon i. mimtedai spost.m Plan.s clarilywhothr FNPS willtadoodoping a bolting Irtogrity progrn nmored onSaction 70 MIS to Itro tgese cornponers.

Response

The.selectn o the aging affct ol oss$ of Materls or of o agi dclcl was dq'o-lmli won the tonralur os the3 conrmpoms during norma opmolioe C lonoils wilth atsnp osu abons the biling poart wmler will preclude m0oisture accuawici. Asa tlmer f co*vnenience. the transition poirs wnss sutmd at Do tepor*arsi threshnld of 22IF for leaking duo o toig In steel Althoue toss i

oeporasa car be below this thrshld during ghuiown corduior.

end roos coreponrsb wUld possibly a" ternpalures btl abon ad below this tieslcid dtring nroned peration thse copormts shoild raietyN em, beat a mperalure bScow n 3Mca de pts*nt Cor nisou ly. even during shuvdown nditions, inire amcurvalioi W A benegligible ThM PiPS position on losci praterial m

n enlmtlor siurmfof si clod piping grew A d eairlie ticene rwsna application nlmwp c.

toes od tals" on lemral suacen Is nomnalty ircnagoc by systse wslkdonsu; hotwer. sysler wasldowns dori Impaet*p 3 entemior mInlate of iamed pipi ng trims tihnsulation ts rwmnold ior nienie5rce There Is n Ioeed It raeovs irdlatio and cretaly Impect ipe aeal m udacs ascs e h 3lot M-emrires iae Inulation prevenms noisltur accuwmdkaon which In torn Feorts toss cf rmnterias. PFPs plan Is to Impact tnimilaMed steel p1iping for tos nawterial viA systne w,,lkdowrn nd nol reovees my Imuldiiro Table 3,1.1. IAn rsutm 31.1-2 specifies M aging ed1ect of cracking do lo stiress oorsion crncking lot carbon and stainles celd reactor ctolat yste prnessure botundary oosro boltitn Ikavios Inspection bolting ronrenoss Is specified In GALL XI.MISt Boting kesrity. forinerageenm deracking and tofci naterilof pressre retaining bolting impaled Inaccordance with AStE Secction. Therefore. reimniceI epaclion to acceptabol lo mraging cracking Im reactor coolant prnsur bom y boltling Howwe, aBilting Integriy Progian M credis Iosmice Irspealioni wllbedd cpkWth3M will addres 3M agng maosrgnmto cl bolting ln3M opop ci licmroe renwal.

Tis requiresn sardrarmt tothe LRA loirclude descripions d the Boiling Integrity Prorin s IntAppndires AortdA aond toidentify wherothe progran s apicable ThiSlean Is closed Itone 37f NRC PNPS Lead Jelk.sor

Wild, Urotdletm, Jackson, Wiosur Firne, Ron Psv 59d 77

James Davis* - AMR - Report to the NR, C.doc.pdf Page 60j Number Status Request

Response

NRC PNPS Lead 471 Chewd

[31.14-271 The erg effect d cracking de io falige deperds anthe t#nnet Jackson, WINr Unreidlte, and mrncheroT" Io:ding dOwe corepn en is effectively In LRATable 112-3, W-AP cosntintion Bdfin. Sarlless Indejendkfl datoe einrofent at ite sueatcedthe cononsrt.

sled, Air-Irdwrk, Cracldrg-faligue.TLAA -toe notesawe "A, The tables InNUREG-1801, Vdws. Z.Cheatie IV(odske d 1.B." Plae explainwtyrnde l Is apicabe bhi ti linre S

ecltin Al) IiucdeJcnrenfl withan air evironwr ardan ite-andngent S cngtdue toe fnatigue Wile ed aome lira roud hens been med as a seidiltton, ite nhce d a line within the cse-podrng esten dable (Table N.CI in this cae) was prderned Pant specifc Nde 105 eplaine ft the dffteence In sneinrwne ecnIcs ileptabe lothe edetion da cracking due to laig-e.

472 Closed 311.1J-281 The girg effect d onclaking due to faieg depends onthe fenel Jeclkenn Wilbur Ungin/dten.

end inecteniccoadng a " enunpinsent "nd Is dlladvely hiLRATaue 112-1. MtAPoewnsioe e -Cloueeflarge Indeperdet dcthe enuironrenl ale stlurfac dhe otnponet studl oa O-th* presure b xeouncy bdlir* Low &nay steed.

Thetable. InNUREG-1801. Vdu. e 2.Chte" IV(edide d Ar-rien, CraCkn-latigIeT.".T

-Ihe noa re'C, 10.V Sutbeeticin Al) htclude cenponetsr with neair enwvironing ad en Ple=e euqain winro te 105 is applicable lt tine It"n.

aqng enlct a uenhirk* die to letigue. Wile one a tese line oculd have been wed as s utbtituioncth chice d a line witer thC orespordng estern tbod (TabolNIAI l thiN rae) wase pirderred Plate specific Ndte 105 e*epains bi the dflerence In enironnets Is accepotde kthe ealuaton d crackling due to fatigue.

Fy 60d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf..

Page 61 I Number Status Request 473 CMoeod 131.14-259 In LRATa.l 112-1. ahd olklwing corponawts Ne Idnlrad as heviri ad ging tffect of cewk!ng and Nod. H te wietl Doar. (Bdorn Heed); Dorre (Uppe Cloas.r Head); FI.nge (Shelf clowur flange and Upper heod closereRange); Vess Sal11 (Bdlir. shal); Vessel shel (Irt-erodale ozzle mhet, low.er shel, t4 shall); Nozzle

(,Mn stern)ý Talds 3-1 In BWMVIP-74-A (sertor Pressure Veasel Inspection ad Flaw Evolmion GAtdddims for Ucere Renewal) addrese verbou poteriald ea related echaleieKr i

ad Irdolce ft oo-eponeras to which the eahhai r. apply. Excep for ahe ma-cetm-rn df aigue which applese e eons di the conPora*r lited into paragraph atwo, there leno rrehhalmr In Table 3-1 o BVWVIP.74-A thl cases cracking and Ith BWMVlP-74-A Idalsfie as applicale om ah c romponerls listed abso Plea. provide a dis*cssion d the rneodclog thea FPNPS uasd boddwer th lt Ith adng g ffect d'crackirgr Is giicate for Owa cornporarts listed In the first pw*snaph, tbovo. Plese Idotiy tha n*sýciene(.) lhd cause cracking In these ooponpes.

Plea.s aoplin how or whhdl PNPS lmorpoed the Ilrorn-tlion contained In BYVRVIP-74-A Into its ddernitriaon ad cracking es we agirg affect applicabe for Ite cornponars..

Pleasa dscuas th plert-specff ic

  • Irbaltry experierco reoiend by PNPS Inm irdd ahe ddernenaton ad cracking Ismagnrg alled agictile Smrthos. ccrrponrt.f Resonse NRIC PN PS Lead The cracking rlayred bin 0~ ea, reis stres so erorion c=king Jckson Wjlb Rrir.A Ron ddto tainless sis cladding TN. wasnot entered b*ad on BWRVtP-74, Kud was beaed oedreter iost

=

tools asd rndelwry oeraing espey*r*-

NUREG-101 alseo epifie cracking dea to SCC fan agiag eoffct for n tarless sled raeerial ntriies Ndte *ret om siws ech as Nozzle, Drain (N 11) which Is terdad carbon ateel heo l Is cracking otry other ta ackirg-tstfrs.

Fbge 61d 77

James Davis-AMR-Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 621 Number Status Request 474 Accepted 3.1.I-J-30 In LRATedo Il12-1, thecompowl Stabilizs Paers (utnd SVp~t, " StaliliZ. Fd$. envct skirt) Is bntJliSid as hFving waging affed di'kls d fnelaid" end the AW.

hawevlc. Inspection Cuea*i-Wht Is the I.erturies tha omas the aging fecd dices d nmtarial?

Plase describe to IFser.ce Inupection aor th Stablizer pesa: WldS Is" suawniauion treioery? Exasrriion reduire*dr? Exa*l*,tion

,alhtd? Acceptrce standt d?

Ate tine an/ currernly a.roved rdid requests aplicable for tri corror, i?

475 Closed ITLAH-01t The aplicand Ia reuesled to poosile the design coda. for the lirnposa, ortus down canerN**l header nd tor*.atachel Fona Nd SRW pling o, resiew

Response

The entry Intable 3.1.2-I Is [or both the eupo1 skirt and the stabilizer pd. The support aki was oervativdy conidered eoqWiii to Ices d Martel as It rotwinis bdow 22D F. The stabilizer pacts we located om he aides d te vessel, aNd ae tlpicaly gred at c

t 0

2 F. Cosiastent with othe IRA o0npontwsn. thee pd *hd rd. be sbject ID loes d naleaialu The LRA will beclailied to InblcaS. tha-t Fnd rnaluid wery applies only toh wrWor alirt Th. re Ur. snratnerd it ltthe IRA The sitailizra p-d we Inspected ner AShE Section ) Table iWB-2-0.I catry B-K. The code (forotla 71o Tabie iWB1-926C-I categoy B-K) alSws slace exanirelion frh n us amcesibe aide d the weld At PNPS the top side of the weldIs acesitle and PNPS par1rm. Imagnto partiole tmting d the lop ide d each brackS waid In ewry 10 year knteeSl PNPS neets he cole rql"Iremuts l

rNd neredone hano rdSid reoast lot wees Iupecllo,.

II) The elsigr cold cre the ywdel liner plate is ASk Code.

Section IL The code Icludee Coda Case 1330.I and Cone Case 1177-5, and e laest eiltion as of June 9,1967. [RdFerdce Cicago Brklyand Frm (CBS&) donw nt 9-O04{ Fot the lca shell, the deign ode ln AS Code. Section Il. The cod.

Irledte Cole Case 1330-1 and Codl Case 1177-5. ad the Watet adiio as d June 9,1967. It was law walusled lD the piralerus s Of ASmE Section III DCllenoI with adudend through Smm 1977 and Code Case N-197 as pFru d the Mark 1 Toru Prograrr IRdoe@noe Tdledne Ergireering Sevice (TES) d-omm1e TRA-cO-.1]

121 The crigts daeign mode for the lorm. dtwrornartl he1dw ia ANSI 831.1. 1967 ellion Itwas IS.w weuted toe req Lruarts d ASM Section III Dlsiel I with adfoat through Sumnmer 1977 nd Code Cane N-197 as par d the Wlk I To7r. Proegam.

(Reference TES dco e TR-5310-1.

[31 The riidrnl deigm code for the twin aStached piping Ie ANSI B31.1. 1967 sdgo ituwas aw a M

valuated o lthe r*Aurument d ASE Section III. 1977 ed.lto withAdkerdn throulg Swnr t977 as F d the Plak I T7r". FPranm Pipe aptM arstyeis was pedlcrwed In Saction Ill Suibsction NF [Rfderene T7S d.o~man TR-53I10-2.

(4q The crigitn design code 1w the SIV piping [e ANSI B31.1, 1967 diliorm NEwas laew auled o the first anchor Ira ew ftl to the r.*srumws d AStvE Sectiom III, 1977 eltion, with addowd through Sa 1977 as prt dethe tkt I Tcram Prorarm (Rde-erce TES d-ocamrt TR-530tS2-. The SRVW/L piping was anayzed ow high. dschnrge oflw as patd dthe Thirnu Power Oltirizasio0 (TPO) Progran So"e amne denigri cl NRC PNPS Lead Jacksono WIlb Finrir; Ron HNoM Dan Cthn Larie fPW,Ud 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 63j Number Status Request

Response

NRC PNPS Lead 478 Closed TLAA-H-M PNPS Pe tacked SRlVwac-Uo.r Irn I12 to26 A2oAI of 14 HowU Dan Chiw. Ieis acuutiom have been racordod on vave A, and 13 each onvalves 8, The slieant Is resqated so provide a alaen Indlcating Cad D. Using e" 14actuatiom Inth slhirloen yee peroit ft "n ft slrrei doi. =dM atrlrb of 60-year, 85V rojosled scbtati-k, the rest of 60 years se 31 lifts. Th. -ater actuaiona ud n the design faigus alyslste rrmanm valid Of lifts Ine first 21 years dipant life(1I72 -198I ) werenot ard woierveiva, based on the sct-SRV acb los recorded These. lfts wearerea keaql In ft1 ealy years. so coued through0 PNPS eatilIded Iese 21 yeats sli lrine mhe recorded te This Vields 12) lifts Inth. Kirst 21 years Coartning e eardy peiod Lt recorded pitl and Om ptroejced period. ies mill bean estinmaed 165 lifts inOD years.

PNPS plart speiofio aysils (Telyne Engineering Serices docmerl TR-5310-2) stalea Us IUse IlVperlratiorm areqaLified be 750 Cyclde ofnI-load Ness onINs. the proojeced CUF f o0years Ie csloaleld a O.QM PA W 77

James Davis - AMR -_Report tothe NRC.doc.pdf Page 641 Number Status Request 477 Closed TrLAI4H-.31 Pless provide Fatigue Aalys is f te SRVedacherge piping d Fatigue &Weysi d oe Toe etachad piping Re*nase NRC Teledyne Ernneering S-Avlces dteun TR-5310-2 dcorsefts Hoeng Dan ecrms elvaumioe frr the SRV pipi ng or veiow load crnrtnlione, i dtee rol nIode, a lige asnel ysis (The faeigue enalysil of the SRV piping along with all the th form eachad piping) (TAP le bouet by WR-751, lIe GE itc I corsairmnw progeant WPR-751 concluded &a for all plia-aend piping eyslerne woeidered, Inall cases the fague asge factore for henestoed 40-ye pelar lile es less 1-0.5. In e worslýceee ecew-ioh Wrtecdng plest life hoe an adlU onal 20 yews woUd proeo Leapge befoar below 0.75. Since this l less lien 10, dhe faligue creirea we salied. The WR-751 genei c leligue rlys.. In isA protecled for Vhe period of.lded operatn In accornarce with 10 CFR5421(c)(I)(li).

APNPSjprit epecific ewlysis addreesee Vhe SRVriclhrge pipin and Its etcporn, as well as Vhe rain vee peneralion though whichVte SRVdschi'e erers.e farm, Ths arelnis slae Vtat V SRVpenesralions we qualifled for 7500 cycles of ersxir load while IVe SRVe we epecled Inn $9 less thn 50 cycles at

-I m Ised and mless then 4530 cycles a pertial load The repor orldtude rSince V.e 7WD cycles of frnxisu load bounds both di

.s by such e large ngin and imire rmother signicantl kowds we Inproeid en. lir the peroration ws messued aeceptcUe her fatigus withui herthsr wleal ion - Increesing h 40 yey cycles by IS for the period of aitmdeId operation worid still be ay 75 rresirrn load cycles and 675M low old cycles he et0WC c050 rrxed load cycle, less V I-e 750D rnwirnsrr loa cycles perninted The fatigue ewlysis he ltfor peerations tihus rewire valid IheV. period of esledndl oestr Inaocondlwe with ICCFR 64 21 (c)(l)(i).

The PNPS 5l-r-specis aealysis (TR-5310-2) relerenw the g9o-GE lvk I Cortaneit pogr fo otheer lone aelached piping The results di V. ge-erio GE tMrk I

ooIaeir'nere progra (based w AI years of opeaion) wee that 92% of TAP wowd hoe cureastive usage actorns d les t.

0.3. and em at 100%

woild bore esege faclos less "n 05 Cor.eaeively rultipiing V. CUF=br 1.5 shows that kGOr ye (icperar irs 57% d=h TAP wold harve CUFebdow 0.45 and 10D% would lee CUFe below 0.75. These lcultioons have itha been pr*jeced h-roodh th period of etencled peralion in accordance with 10 CFR 54 21(c)(1)(ii).

PNPS Lead Fin, lon aW 64Bd 77

James Davis -AMR - Repor to the NRC.doc.pdf

.Page 651 Number Status Request 4W Closed Whte I.tte operairg halory ar buried pipeI teerar. ofthe rtrtr of Ir'paclons and mV leeks and ther c.,

(Irnerred criWerru caased leesa)? Have y buried pip.

been replaced do oecorroion oar cosing pratlern? I the phased ray UT technique I. setd h-wwill U V. qeliied hnd how willUto operators beqalline"?

Response

In the past 5years ter.e h.

beearn ileted exprerien with the Ispection f bWried piprig a PNPS. This wporierwe has acvcrred rrardy onhUe Otee waler arergarard dastrtion systim. This Systemn Is agevrinnaly 35 yeprs old and conists of oerrt lined nelllle Ieron plpe with trebarcd al joinrs. ThereshV.been no history of sigitiican leaks el ther ttirn two Irn*aaces, ore In 2001 and one Int205, In the first wet the " rundargrouad ine dlown s*t-ew of U-L-22 laled The prdýedae oausa of lailure was tram likely induead by ninor fatbricaion aronrliaa cxornrc ed by rrrdrJe Irnstaldion lach~ryars. When hds piping wea wacnined It was found toVe overall Invry good cornditrian terrfly escej for a sell araN safurfac corroaor sttrltvted to verrdne Irntallation teek ii.

In the second weert the 8r mn grgarad pipe Ilaled In the ares of he N2teai wa4evnt tothe EDO buaidrn Due b congestion and t presence O I he ftr which was Irntalled cltyea

.nthe Irulallstian dUo pipin It iwa not posas.e tb dgupfth plping to seenre mitand dleriree the e oedthe Mir.thi bt rjW bordaeedlWU trtalation dire terle inafldaeon to these two tmainw there hev been a rnwter of valves excavaed during nrirten-eric which ouad U. vtavea an piplng toWe In er'wkay good cordt Front ae eaddtioalt hislorval perspeclivm U. salt evice waste (SSW) eystev o PNPS Ve. ecperieed loks hateha e aried trei (screaretra. loa.iliary bays) piping asea result oi ternal corrosivne The cripgral piping mnserial wee rubber lined carton Sead wrapled withrarinorced Itearlass wrapping and val tr searaed felt and howy Krafl paper. Th. loeks were dotervnined to be U. result of the degraded ratber liring beirg Incartect with see water. These pipes vee almes been replaced wilthr irned TilUrn wrapped with U. &evee eaederne hogrg so the original pip& Thi. pipe replacerweri Occarred in 199 anl 1997. In addition thU SSW buhed dischrge piping (also rdtter lired arbon sled with Werrlal pip. wrapplng same astral pipinr terar. U euiliary bay tothe dharge cord also eaperierced awae Irnernd rleione t la t allare do Uhe nrer lining Two4T AYrbha of 22errer pipe. (are onse ch loop) werereplaced In 1999 as aresul of the failed tr iing and interre dorresion. Thees edos were reptaced withearlone sle d

cod Ilreredly and "enleevy withrarreipy comting Th. piping Ot was rerned was

.arfined slier Its wraping was rsnoved and Its mtlred suriacea was berd WobV.

Ing*d vordtitn, Sinrce #a tiPe. U. enire length of btoh SSW braisd discharge Ivop hbes been lined Ireerrelly with c

iedrndaptce pip. linir*ng B Loop 1.2C,01 and A" Loop in20C Th. pIhsed array Inspaction tschrvnq was provided wersty seen eianlo of5 apotential fLriar earninstiron technrique fard olher retade thniqupees will potentally beadeo toasese U.

tendiaton of ieearlos portions of bried piping wilhol the reed V.r excavation.

This evceiaion was taken to allowe. potential wae ddis techips or others In lieu of evcavatirg pipig in crder o preoide a mtae ettlie seaarnr t of overari piping conditio while elinieing the plarteiat for darnag Inrg Ue pipng divng svavaiare Rage 65d 77 NRC PNPS Lead Davwls. Jw Ky. Ted

James Davis - AMR - Report to the N RC.doc.pdf.Page 66, Number Status Request 494 Closed FW linesher. InTalie 332-14-1 (LRApeges33-134 lrfough 137) referenoe Tabole 3.41i en3.41-8 and credt PWM Pro'aer tw Mnge Vh aging effect d LOM for sled piping. pipngconponwt. ad ping denerrns exposed to raw wafer. Planes idertify the specific orponerns Inotse Circmlaing Water Systert lv we represeted by twe Table 2 line iems rd provide proceduem Under which PSM wilnbeirilewnele tonw dhed rging affect of LOM cue togeoneral, pi41nng cyec*e MC. and Woingi

Response

NRC PNPS Lead Since a stiperir Irspectlon techriq Inarn yed "talble. specifics regrdning,a*firf.kon dtfe proces Rd "ecotviiare we rot evaimse The clrctladirg water eystern cosisfto primrify of two clrcUatirm Wert Peter toy Ted water purr.

Rd asmedSa.ed plpin and valves as shown pricrreily on Wtl.

The reiew todelarrne te IOCFR 544(a)(2) corrponeatslwed aspeces approach tel Idertified all coponeri ypes and raleriet cocrtreiion Ind.e syslt enel waere:inscope hi dd int Iii lirdvokuai corfport rnbers As kJorified In LRA Table 223 14-B. the oclywems tiathe e obikvd ng OW were siof dod were die con.p.r fnie.

insde e reon onsers arnd lee only portions of the Intake iruuro s

es were icdled were dt Iflake st-tclure typoclorife pup room and ctorireflon ares.

The cowponrwts Intclded ifting. circutating wafer ptmp casings.

th aovoe grud pipnge ruling Orr-mowire. the corenrer rlii otili Rd cross conect valve, a nps-io jokes Rd dte asociaed vnet dran and Imtrurnrt vaoe bociss. The water box scavergi~d systhr shown eo I 1 ior iorW In ose,.Ad the pertlcon Rd still Iorm apreesure bortany for the water bores we Ircluded. As Iderkiirfted onl12 Sha the reeikual chlrine eaople puip tars longer wed] II portirn. d the systerr were frcludRd thef still boim lee pressure bouachry.

As Irdceaed In lAifaoret 3of LRPO-., Agng kI4nge*rrt Prograsr Evaltion Report (MAIER), proceues dor n mist for t I-epection ofdthe. rponerts. aRd aecorplie listing of awporarce thaR willbeinclucled inths proceirsm Is n wetiletl A sitafed InLRA Appedx B Rd Cowierifol 21, prorapr acflivify Irrpmernirlng dotumre willbeeh*r-ced priololroe periodo mtwrded operation to lrcorporoe tee atiribues of tns Irspecdon desc'ibedinthe AMPER. Td wi*f assur d d de ecls caginrg wllbef areagdhd eh R

d Icasoie on-rporeis willco'irtiel to pemiom ithiritndedol tndons cenrialfn with tcoirwe licensing hesls lor Re period d slarded opert ion fPW 66d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Paae 67:1 I

Number Status Request 495 Closed Fw. In. here, InTabe a3.2-14-1 (IRA p"33.134 mci 135). PNiPS claim~ed VW Cial infg Water Sys1er carrponws di piping ev teic. whchame nude cd plastic.

loe no aging affect wder. contoleolatio dreal "c rev waler Irimn.J envs 4

-Otem.

Whel kind ofpsic no0 raelejal we#"u.

.0 me y a..c+/-meot toeo agin ".?

46 Cloued P.

lie Awns InTable 332-14-1 witihnot. F(LRA peg 3 3.133). the aplicar6 proposed to manaege cracking mci clveorin materlial properties of the sloolser for condaoner wponsion (Ot exposed to re.. wate "c oovleealion In Or.tra1 environrtwin Ae~MIP of Periodc S-11anlace mnd Prevreniv,. klirserace, (PSP&

Pleano. provide fachical justiication set wV PSPM. alone Is eriiclel to nunnage "u agingQ ellesof.

crackirg ngd change In. rnsterial Properties.

Response

Score of th circationg waler systn piping In scipe tor lWrimerte Fide iOCFR 50%1 (a)12)elcown wthe piidrg &

frelr~om doagrarr Is p~ipin code. 46 and JIF. Pipe cian. JE is fiberglass reinforced plastic. As Identlied in#*u PNPS Specification lot Pipin MOOD. piping code JF allows Pu we d PVC piping ParNote 3onWI 1l. son, f hepuiping1. PVC, The 55 gallon drkc.1-owron co12 Sha.d I wtich is ft

.4 tekin tIn.A hent is also PVC.

Aging select.t were idert-ifedlto. (a)(2) corripaonet Ircluded in AN"%iM30 an1"g Pue NcnCluis I Mxheicat t enntatmseodo 0.44ddi. and Wcohe.-cal Tools, Revision Z EPRI. Palo Alto CA 10030I (The Mwhw-ical Tods). Inetooornoe. with ft Mo1-*.1Tool.

Sctor of.

dAppardl A, PVC and tI-mrPitlioe we.la!M1vdY "eflciwI by water or Iseidity. The eoow.In questionr me Insistedl indoors and contain rawo waler.

Thersior* baedm conth Mexlarical Tools arnd Irclostry operetiog ftedymioa. Pe piping hte.,n a ging aleffet regiring nurege-anex Inraw water or condnsteaiton erroiro-orri.

As Irdicaled I kiltactcnm 3do LRPD-M2 Aging ktaregensnre Progimn El upton Rapon (MoPER), Inupecticne will be perforrmed to delernine Pu awfw*o crondiion mnd flu.441Py d Pu circrifaling waler mprpeoon foints. A. Irdicated Inrthe APER..a representative euqople ci thu wpm relon joints wilibeelarlty Imupacted mnd rnun~ey Awead evemy 5 years to verity nosinmicn arooking or.1 a abe ornsfl~ifa whileflexing sloecorner ca-el.s A visual Insecretion, mcd pysyical rrnunpdaamof cih Peonporwi Orawls OWl Pu sasoeel, is rot cracking arcS 019 Pue Inceri properiias of flexibiliy ma still aereopele lor Pue axpegion joinl to nulotein Ito preaue bamc1.rp ende ro allect ealey-reatoed OornponnerS Idtrylsl operating experimen loo cornorrmi.

ofpi.

lype he.asow Iu Pu thrm1.y of citupoolicor a1-oud be adormee to torang.res agi.ng adoot..

Mt-i. these coonoIncrarlme nrwgod by Pu selective isaotir0 Peerogalr Ito Puternms! surface, Pu selecive he-c.ng progmrar Is rot credited with A. romuegaerle of lose ol tnerualm lo, aslerrul ere1w. Ina me conl P.1."5 by oortlastion. I Puee convoeal.

werme to expeience selective heohn% Pue eging elloot willncac on Pnd he Identlied by ft Selective talcnrO Prolgra for Pu lreral u,rfooe Pul I. wospeel to -o vsl., Mdore m" sigriint se elective leonding Is esperiencdoen ft Puxternal sowlace Pu Is weted conl by periodic oorderealiwn The.

nIne tou Inarinirrel mroral d sCecolrcyi Pu to proemie In.a poeniwoc cornlcruaic movirarnet, Theelrder Pue Systonrr %ubdmon Progerar ala" is anpeotwi to he en elepezle progrwerr the Puetlerel seinee ol Owe caronpored NRC PNPS Lead W.r Plmer Ivy. Ted WON Pete Ivy, Tel 497 ClcueI ThreelOneherne InTable332-14-1 (LRApeges 33.134.

135, mnd 136). 1hue appicent proposed tonm.a" LOMo coppe alloy >1S% Znlor pipinrQ strainer healing and vaive body wpoeed tooonderalio erlewlr Orwirorma Wing Al to Systemn alolown. Pleese provide techical jnelificalion as wtl Sysler Walkdown alt" Is enificiem to nanage Ptu goy aellt of LOM Do ycu cosider Puegson afect c loss cd rierial dme to selective leaching for Pue linhe itens.

We, Pter I"y, Ted PRi-67d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 68 Number Status Request

Response

NRC PNPS Lead 498 Closed Owen line here In Table 3.32-14-9 with roteO (Extraction As can be seen In section 4242 ci LRPO-.

Aging Mwge.t We. PaeA Steanr System the ayllpOA prosced tIo rnw

¢rackiro Program Evah-tion FRepo (AWFER). the water oerristry LO and cracking-fatigse of rickld alloy lm exceanson (lm conlrol-BT Pwogremr ircludoe periodio noitoring and conrd ol syosed toIraded waler wirng waler ohlnrstry or/rol BWM known ddrlrtrall eotnriarts such as cHioricke, dissolved and TLAA r" lalig.

Two lire ites relaed Ic TL*.

osyger. and sutl.e corcerratios below the leds known Io reit ner betigue will beharped Io Question 141-W-01 fbe In loss of material or crac*rg As idettified In Aachsrtr 2 o fthe clsoeasok, For. " othr 9hine hter, paes provide APERe a One-Tirre Inspectioe Progrrt will be ceylaed lo verity lechrical Juetification as wihy Waler Cheisitry Coerol BW1 Ve tectovenoaese althe waler ch.istry ootrd-BWi progars lo alone Ie gullciern kt-nge the aging efects of crackirng ferege lhe agh n etffc of loss d neterial aed oraclkri and LOlA Therelore the wortrwiton itese two proganre Is suitert lo "nage the agrig alfectl o cracking ard loss f Irateirl Ior ricke alloy ooparels eosed tole reaed waler.

TN. reirss e anavdrrso leth. oc*raltry proge desortiaOo In LtRA Aglpecoas A and B to clerly Itnlcaae VW hes Oe-Tire Inpertlon Progras willooortir the sftectiveecs dfth Wale Chresatry CorteS 8MI. Water Clrnialtry Corero - Acoillary Stale>. end th Waler Chervistry Coreod - Closed Coirng Waler TN.shter. clsed tose te 372.

Ivy, Ted 499 Closed rrA3214]

eoeccordtea with AP 1A.13. proceUses willbeetherced (ee*3.

and 6) I0 seily thel the dielr ne does n. ehbit In Tae 33. 2-9. FikPrdection - Waler Systenm PNPS igne d deg'adation wlie urerina csch t -Wl on, lbke ol.

credts ISA AP 111.13A. FireProlection Program lo cooland (aeket waler), or exheral p leskasge Troul noinitoirig rwelge lose rnee1d aed Woling ofVay Iron*aed opper c

rd reding 0 perornanrce data, epeciftially Jackao coding waler, ally >15% Zneal eacleoger shll and tlbe.

Howeeer, he oulang and elaosd rsleria fIo.he Ilre purlp dowed Jackal waler hae Fire Protection proram cýo*rplion does Inotaackde thOe eacrger willbe rlereified ed craced ttoalr the corresote ororrlers nor hbeethe proges beet enhenced leIolude actin progran As described toopepring eperience Ior AlP Viese coapnerts E1t1t.1, obewtalion, d0legreded perlorrrnece prorcked correcdive action> Including endnerelracerrerh in 22 priorlo loss of Plese clariy how he FirProlection Prograe, witllmrerege Iieldul nction Coreeely. cortcired errrlerasion 01 he hese agng eafects nor these coMnonats.

Fire Prosection Poarr yravd re"sed. eale esor e eging dinect will be mreagd lo the deead Ira Pp jackal watle he achangor. Inadditin, PNPS performw lireprp Irereotion. leelrig aM trearearce Inacortacsne with NFPA25 whch would also deel hc e preence 01 agng effects In the jackal waler eysele prior to hcest i closded function.

ThNs Ite-1. closed lo fte" 37&

Pald. Erach lay, Ted Pw Ud 77

James Davis -AMR -, Report tothe,NRC.doc.pdf

-- Page 69 Number Status Request S10 Cleod

[T23.I151 Ile t. LRA. PNPS s Itdicaled °NaNonrt Uor AE.AW earrtnrtiar ineseral Ta.blea Inseclion

3. Uor plaslic aranwts Iarn a ea'vironsrwlt.

Please Ida-rl whet Wi.s) d plastic arl,,id In fare) Leed at PNPS.

5ot Acepted (r*1a6l1 In ears Table ? PNPS has eaed "Non-N'r" for AtAMP etblindion lortn etiriges Meed boiling Ins,

,ir-a.d- "ironr*r lvWe i, InTable 3.32-5 wd 3.32-9. PNPS Idlrtiled losol cnrial asi n eing ent loent esne nete'arenren sent

""'t"atir d cralnied the eyelet walkdwn pgraen toU "'age ths agie g affectd In an erfdor gaorwrnrrt. stairisl*ees led rai'W*

ced be sescptible Uoloss ol aerial.

Pleae clarity this iserpsey.

Response

At PNPS piping codes 45. JF, JO ard HT we plastic or fiberglaes.

As ldttfied Into PNPS Specficatiion lor Piping Q pispe class JE i fiberglass reiriced plastic, piping code JF allows the we s

py*irnyl hmaide (PVC) plpri and clm HT piping Is PVC. Per rde 3 on X11, ears d she pipe code JO Is PVC.

Scene epecifin earper-at/s areo Identified asplastic Inth. LRA that e not Included Inthe piping elm asrnwy sheds which rectired eoaonr-u speclfic reviews lIdenirty the material.

For imtace ears ernpqnrtse setch a te let showon M2*12s ehl I Is Identiied onthe drawinig as a 5 glln PVC drum ae earn pipng like the piping onaM73 shed 3 Is WItied onthe drawing I ellainret.l polyiryl ehloride (CPVC).

The fWe onil yste-table 3 12-7 M-n ide-rilee a piastic fieter htusing teed arthe station blackod dead led el siter X-t7&

These ae peastlc bowl.atthe S

ttolt dthe fitl.lSr teing tht edlled water and aedirnt The exent type d plastic [a bmotkown led waseelected fore e bythe erigidre nwwactrer intis appdicatioan Inwdiina siwItalU l theepatlimtegeriari deecnibed above It iS ar etpoed todirecteurCidt lad was designed lobe wed with fued ol. Therdore. as staed In the ESPRI Mchteici Teods rnn of tehas earnpsrerl Is expected lo eperienre aging dffects that redr. ncaeegoeren In th erwiroennls tos wich they are eaposed The only table IW did ot idently loss of merial Ia eaerneas Mted bolting In an air-edoor enrirany-nl was Table3 3 2-7 lee t led oiilsrystem Las of menr Is an egng dfect reqpiring regerra "n shoel-hto been Idea tied for t.e stairties sted bolting with an ewvireon o air-okekooar. The aging affect Is nrereged by the Sysm Wahkdnen Proragm The reire aennt.rdnt lothe WRA NRC Pael. Erach Pal. Erach PNPS Lead fry. Ted Ivy, Ted Fby 6d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 70 I Number Status Request 6M Closed TA3.217 I. Table 33 2-14-2?, PNPS has cridled the litoe Cetsislty Control d Anillary Syons progeaIn o na the ng ectcl ldsodnaloral

iro, oo
  • orsca Into pdt&ie aid antary wawer systeon. Ho*oe, ft proram docrition a*d the scope d te prorac m orty addess stato ocling wale chenistry. The ority aeit where potatoe ard rhtary water Is rnoisticld Isinto fenli cr detecicon clsgerog affet..

Plea Julity why potate aid s*ei lry water I-ns Identified Inthoe prowa doeclrirt*it and cope d work or qLWp l~

tpengronrant iocnlc it SM Open-aliton 4.3-1: kittfy wtichoilAo w a:llty Plant gracsI iAMcR Tables 31.2-1. -Z ad -weredesigne to tSection Ill. Claritywrochcoorspl.ealotnnio clly groulp recaived a. ASVtE Section III CUF caicUalion, aid Identity wtch omrnodlly grow llirg InLRA Table 43.-1 proides the agpicagte CUF red. I no CUF coneahIon was performed. justty S thesis for otoluion eMo p"crcoe an accetaile AWM' bow to aging e0ffect cracking tatlgud In eoct* e with to criteri in 10 CFR 5421(c)(1)(iii). I anexcloein fron perlorning eCUF o.o¢uatico Is based mnan ASME Section IIt, proide to paragrph In to Cod.

504 Cloed r

Oeotion 43-32 tLety whichocnponros InAMR Tablee 3112-I1. -Z ad -3wee desirne Inaccorderce with t ASME B1.1 Code. Clarity whelhets -omoonrly grows were esuadted hor anaclabe estreo relsctio aoanets b aouwl onto. 7000 rst cyes tin roccerdnce with to) Ba1.? Code. Idotity whetsl*

(1) to e alowale stress, redluci*c analysi reraire bounded unde IOCFR 5421(c)(t)(i).

(2) the eilowable stesl range needs to be reduced In acrortdnoe with toe etresa reoction criteria Inthe Bt31.

Code loco,"Ty with IOCFR 5421(1)(t)ii)ce (3) t agong iedl "crackhig-fInigio' noot lobe sargod oe to peiod df Wended (EPO) opratio Inoecomdance with 10CFR5421(c)(t)(iii)and prtotee anaccplaltle AM' to rnonge the a*g effect Rewonse NRC The Scoe of Protgraot section d tl 1.3*-

of the LRA sides city Paid. Erach water Its hken Irrn the Townd Ptyodh water ronin aid dstried troghc toe poltae and sartary wawer rysten altown water presure City water Is mollored and traded by toe Town ol Ptyrnoulh to n*d to rougia*ios of toe Corwrnwnel* f d

Iassachuses.

As etated Intoe "etectton ofkgig Etto ection ot, I.31 ot te LRA, vwification tho wwer rnoritto*g and treament bythe Town of Ptynou* Isallt*ctne will occur nder tho O-Tim hpectim Priogrart which enitl Irypictono to verity tho dtiveness of watew cherastry onroed prograe to wre tot salgnicart doadtion lai nd occurring ad copont Inted tcatrton Is lrroll d d*rirg to perWWd oetenloew opwaelln Therdare ploale and eattry wower Is ircludel In tho progra.

Thil rWooe addresses Oueotion 504 ard Ouceoton 505 Maid", Jiw Answerel InQuestion 53.

M l,

~

Ji PNPS Lead lq. Ted Firnic, Aon Finwuc Ron Ftog 104f77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 71 I Number Status Request O505 Closed Question 4.3-1. Fm, rwpipig oceonoewisftoom city gWo~. in LAA Tables 3,112.1. -Z and -3 th werenot de.ig-1 IoAS&C Soohon III oAltE B031.1 Identify wNch de.7, code.applies to te particula connwity g90t and clarity whoete lft deign ool. required a nsdl i lmto enslysis. Ia m" ldiig

&-"yiswa reSlirA sow w

hat type of motlti be Ocalculaton was rectkedre lobe pewlonow and discus how: (1) ft analysis narai,. bowdng t"i.' 10CFR 5421(c)(1)(1), (2) hes beeni projeclel loll. wpirati of ftO, EPO arl rernara aeoqatble pure ftod 110 CFRS.1ol)I,' (3) whthero en AM' readl lob. prpoe to enwge ft aling oflect of

  • omreoog-W9Wo be fth EPO end stale wNeh AM' will be wLoa low"g, ". agi ogdect. Ifa meta Iltigmear-elysis was no perlarmal and oraclting talige need. tobe rawgs k thel EPO. proposean aroo Ipeb. AWI.,' thel lwgnwmg dctlea girgelsoet Inaewordance with the criterion In 10 CFR 54 2t(O)(1)(liii 606 Open -

Owetion 4 3-4 For ncn-p~ipg oorelwnrtal-m dty Plant gr~~

In LRA Table. 3,22-K. 13 2.X and 3A 2.5, klalify wbleh daeigi code anllie. ltottierpartier. co~nodry grw~i and clarify whether ft tloelgn code reqtid ad a meotal Istige.

enelYsi H1a metal lg.i7 a-Wyirsi moo tarack

._rnmrl.lz who ofp ci" aibige. cietietion wee r.:pdrw lb.

aorw ldw bw (1) the =rle.i renerre Ewodr

'nor' w. tWCIOFR 542t~o)(t)(l)

(2) be. bowri pFojleted loftw expirotion di ft EPO mld

-wiaceceptable pWetri 10 10 O1R5421(c)(1)(ii). ar (3) whether anAWt newds lobe propoed wi lenwaga the aging allo~t d'eraeiong lege be09 fort EPO mld elate which Al will be wed 10 newgs ft agirg elfeel.

Ie aci rntl ligue anrlysie woo rot performed mld *cracking

.bigLW reachl lo be ear*gor bhe EPO. propose an soce=ieAM' ber lb ffwegwwte of lb. agong effect In ewrlrawth We critorion in t0 CFR 54 2t(o)(t)(iii).

Response

Answered lnOueslion SM NRC PNPS Lead I.

Jim Finn. Ron Madolt. Jimn Finrn, Ron PaW 77 d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 72j Number Status Request 507 Open -

C.llt a 43-5 h.e sWiiation stales ist welN. ra NRC mrroflory. the design olhe RPV Irsarel saponers IsIn accordane with th itrieat o ASME Section [li. Plees.

Clarify Iroa both a reialaory and tecntical poirt of viso whl Is srn by dealgred Inacooroance whiith. "irtord ASM Seclion Ill. Identify which Edition o ASMC Section III is Wing referred lowith respect tline design al a. RPV Iriaerls.

508 Open -

Csastion 4 3-" The first till paragraph on pgo 4 3-2 states NRC d fracture wharios ansalyses, or flaw growth anwysas ase TLAMs lar PNPS tWh astyWs awe based an sra-tlirntld assmua lom Idrraty alt fracdae rnseclrics or flaw growth salety assmaarsats at sed fw criteria tor TIJUsM in tO CFR 543 If ary sist, wri Section 4 0 f the WRA No incude thesi as TLAAs ftr thewlaaioation and evalulte thes inaccorkance withthe aequira rea s of 10 CFR 5421(o)(l). itnlus wou0ht lctelo Irtorswtion tjoustity sooetat=lity dl th racture stecharos or law growth anruyse. fly bactaurs sactaos or flaw igO-th anlysee tha rd theml TLAA criterawiallbeasluated by tle NRC's technical slall Inth. Diviaon Coponeornrt rilty, CCios at Nucetar Reaclor Regulation

Response

NRC PNPS Lead hItsaems listo reactor vese Ianers werebuilt toft Matoeh, Jiw Fiwirt Roa Irlet of AS C aotion Xl ca front th e FSAR. GE made tits atataret Issnry aat. FSARs bar BWsof Pilgrssta vironp This stateri rsa. ahd the design d the reactor Irterals was bettaer -rm aorvrcial grade q.aity. Miwials, watl fickrnss, confrlction techsiques (including wtding) were what wousd haeo been wed for atASCE sonyon-at However, arstyse, and testing weasnor pntorWrnl or docarwialed as rsrod for a oorrFoneln deielgned "In acoarneo wath a.e AStE ooda As no specific code was adhered to. no specific osde year was specified however. em th a riner wasedeeiig as pal othe plara dotgn It can beassrred the sa.e ide year (1965) was tad for gaeal g r-LRA Section 4112 willberevilsed to dades. the aaems Ihs the Iartrala as designed to th Ilent o the ASNE oode as loltlos:

"43.1.2 Reactor Vassl Intersls A review of a. dign basis doouarw reveals ad the day frlarfls ponsa Iforawhchthfe esa fatige areysisli dreore shroud stablizer (Us rock). Ohe reedt o a repair to strcturalty replace a aur/eretaal shroLd weld. scororudng a. we Thi astysis Is sTLAA Th. r-eis-us CUPFideotiaied hor a. shotd for 40 yeas of oealion Is 0.31 The CUF Is Included In Section 4t1.

The Falig*J tIrbioring Proga*w* enaures a latig*a raryses renran valid by sorilOrirg the actual ntmbers o cycles ad evauaating tfen agirota the design values fr nurrtas af allowable cycle. Tisvtlirited agirg wly*as (atlgue aratyse) for a.e core shronI statilizar will renvin vlid Ior a.e period a Wtarded operation Inacordance with 10CFR 5421t(c)()(1) or the esffcts of sging onthi Intended funt-on(s) wittbeaacatatly mataged aor a.

pariod of extended opatlion inacoordauce with tO CFR 5421(c)(t)(iii).

Thasrecqtre anamrdrt toth RA.

PNPS Ideaified no braccs rrsohari*s (flaw growth) analyss th doft, Jim Pi.riri, Ron wera TLAA.

The readet od the t'NtS revew a these ratyse aw Nodal In Section 24 o PNPS docurre LRPD.C-. -Ustal Ainng Andys.es

-Mocl-ical FPaigue. Three law growth analyses were tound (the CRD rnozle toad ca wad, a.the Recto Recirciualion mtzle th-rmal Weaves, and Reactor Recirailadion nomzls NYF). Nonr a thess artys-a wea TLAA

ýp 72d ;7

James Davis-AMR -Report to the NRC.doc.pdf.

Page_73 Number Status Request 5*

.ccead I36.Z2.N-071 In LRA Sectian 3622, you have stated rnchytaoal war [- an aging efecot Elm eainard auspeelon I tralora Inltht VtWy a. ruieto irnverarart. Weer hasEne rbeen ayierat during rodin Inpecotio.

I Ml

-nagod for te period ol altaded opwalio, surace -ut would nrl

..aa.a es l irl-drtd Ention aid ta, lardno a igntfioawn wa"n Provide a Elchi,;a justification d wl lossod ornmeial d.e b rnacotioi weer carnad by wird blowing d supornd traacnsissonccrndctms Is ril an aging etoed roqliring n*regfr*i Em Egi-voltage Inaultoros isa, provide atlechiod justificaion dowry eulace rut woud rot caao a cooed irlendod fuiaon ard ier a alg7iticar c arcen Emr thtp-ltage Iitla-ore if ltl warr gaid Eorm e periodd omisled operation

Response

Loss d mteriat dus to nhrowad wear Is an fng efect Eom atrain and suspension Itrdatrs it lhea we lejecl to siguificant

-rov Apossibtle cause [or iovenaral or"e Insulators Is aid bowing the ogporitd Iarenieion caoLCtor, allowing "e oofcl to hewing frann Bids b alie Althou V.s reotwinm Is prel**tt, Itnhdtry aqeryerce has saicoon traraniesion corottilo onc ro randty swing and VW when Stay ft dA bia etoatantial winr, fay do noe cairt to swing for very long orce at wind has ordadkd PNPS hos ntrantarl easion cotedoro ea lwi by Ngh-dlag trendators In-ecope d licens renewal and I*tado loos of aeral dA so weh r a

fd hgh-otage Jnisatore Is na an aging etfeot re.uiring "n oar t Em We period of adleded cparationt Varla airto*nre merials eah asnn da sadl and Inckstrinc deflneel can corcarniate Insulactor suracs. The bildup Sf surfae oatariralion tI gra*d ard In mot area washed away by rain, whlethe gaed and ool Irsrdot" eaurtacs a PNPS aid" Incmaton reaa valS PNPS acWind Slygw:d (RTV eliconm) eoelings to ema ewitchnard Iniamor ho reaims lastover. Surface wortaiiralion can bea pyodean In ama where Uwe ae greate connratdions S airborne pIhlidee sech ae noar facilities W deotaigo esod. PNPS Il nmolcaied near ay Wcililies W prodte aira-panficld uh, as*iact. Themorl eurface criariatlcar Is rno arqpp fi*ttle afng rnach*nsen Ear Ngh-oltags tr*uatorn S PNPS.

LRASectioni36222 hto a"llpo Inthea ruh p1agra.-o The paragraph shrM teed a Idlowa: "MEmhonicl wer is at alng diedm for strainand soaeyaon nlsuators In aO y

arV e

hiect b

rio rt. Wea= tas nr been a

-arent "ring rdina Irspections II If urrn-for Ete paiod d atdal operatioa, surlaco cortan'rrnalc world ro cause a "e of Ireandd fntion ad ihs. is rd 4a.igriioart corat" T

aisra~reeaneanmidmilt lofhe LRA Snre ariolta airborne nraterials ech as dut, et ad Irndusia efluetasa can catmniraale inuatorede acee. The bUiiop d surfare ortamiration I* gra&nS ad In reo w

ar aet away by rain, watethe ealed and coeed insalator surfaces al PNPS al"t In oorarniraha removal. PNFPS aried Stygeid (RTVslicone) coating hoionae ewinlctardinsdadors to reh ce tlaseter. Surface onrtariratlon can boa prcodm Inares whaie there awe greater onceaciona d alirborre prtidee ecah e ner faciliies OW dschaga aooE. PNPS i. M locealed rer any faclilies that prodce airbone partcleo sch as "oic or som. Thedafe. surface eoacarirnslion tarot ancjptlicale afg ingtrersin Emr hghý-vdtage Ibnsateors l FaIPS NRC Ng*ryau D.t PNPS Lead Strou4 Mko 510 Closed 13622-N-cal Varios airborne nalerials sech as duAt and Industrial effluent cn cortairaae Imtatmr ourfavcee. A large bUildep d corcarnirstion anrf the coandtor vodlg*a totrack along We sutrace ae sseety and can End o insulator flash".

planwatrystac-oecerndraioia athadral and Industrial to Iet d i rul a aignriicalo agirfg diect reqiuing iragaraent Em flr-ovdage Irailm*s at PNPS.

Nguyen, D.t Srou4 Mkst FbW f3d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 741 Number Status Request SlI Cl..d

[36 22.N-09]

Frovide a lechtcr juelifutir ion d wly Inrerased raieletace d swhhyard bue e onre clue to ibaion Is red n aging elect reiuirinrg rgwrwt 6:2 A

e.yd 131.11-13)

LRA Taele 31.1, herr Number 48, b aplicable fr Clao I iing fling. ard blrnch Iir- <NPS e xposed b reelo coolart The GALL Repo Ireicates tat the agig effects d cracking due toth"re!

and rreharcal lcedrg apply Ior bath earbo eel ld arnd nies. led o1erryreed Hewveer, nClass I pling OcenTerets nreds dI ebr seel weroled uplto tr i line Item PlIse

s.

aln why m carbon sled elpng eonprerts ae rdled up ho tis line At. ltre no Class I carte sled piping eoerpo*rats <NPS4SlPNPS? I her. me Clarse eaten sled piping emirer*re NNPS 4 aNPN then PIesse )ustify why they mte en rdled tpk 0ine ilee V1.1-8.

513 Accepted As s Idlow-up roqueslion T321-35.P-01 (ite 442) we 6 Ite line iter. O1W Iell. upb Iter 3.2I-W onty credits te C

wrenmeN Leok Rate prograe wor letragng th ging effect d be. d6nterial. In acsowdence wito GALL XI.S4 hes proser by itself d-I ct derl Mt5 aging dogedelti*n leo intiared. Plearsexplan how the use 66.

Certeirenre Look Rate progasr I[ acceptable by led) Io

_"g. aging de"cts

Response

NRC PNPS Lead Apolenleal irelenim contriuting toaeing d switchyard buI Ngey, Duc Stroud. Mks ooreetione Is oursaele meiddier, wNch can lend to Irnreased wriact ar er orbr resislance Connectbon e

lsace ceidaion Is n signiflea Ifmwitchyadbus ennectiorbe at PNPS sine 6t wilelryard bes ooeectione arewdded Therdo mragineg decls due Iboeuace rrmidide e areirted lobe reeg lod the period d a rled epenrmse ThI. acevrclsneebe bite devicles Iryld eedl 6.

Maintene Ruleprngra.

In edrtion, memograpqi Is perlormed at local "aO weaye monetha bo irrr n the Iregrity d the eeerlctilon. TH. progar will eire Intothe period dselearded eOlatio A. staled In PNPS AAPM-33, erackirng clue blaew rowh Is Jacksorn Wilbur Fled; Ron reeged bythe Irepaeeon repkmrewnel Is$orClass I oenreri In cesrdamee wIthASME Secoin XI, Subsection IWB Becauee lreervlcelmpeten per ASCE Selieon XI Is required in rodaceree withlOCFR 5055a, eacling due bn law grovldh Is n Identified en he Wese In itacihrrrt 1.V Crocking du bnlew growth I.

esledored equialen thoe NUREG-1801 wiry 6 cracking due ID threwi and rechrecal loading The ISI Proegar aplie ty Class I cambe sled plipng eomrcnrnaf ad PNPS The IRA will be clarified to sh tOW cracking Is an aing dffed requiring Inegerert Is Class I crbn sled ppirng oNPS C4a PNPS and OW the approprrae aging neregere prograrr Include the IS! Proegra and he Ore-Tiree hrepeconi Prograer The decuresin**olurn l

or Istew 3.1.1-.4 willbereviled yo beconsilstent with tni chn.g The crediedaging mreagerert Porolrr will be he sane as those listed or tIe NUREG-1801 line h-er. eeresporldng So IRA Table 31.11. Hew 48 Tisreuires enamendrnet inthe LRA Th. Pierioi SJ,eiTlole and Prevent.ve irlleeo (PSPI4 Paviret Wayne, Ivy, Ted Program Is mrer apprtpriate 1o inrage l

sd mwl Ios piping eed valve body Ins raaw watler el eirsrn*rl InTabls 322-7.

Th. IRA will bierevied lo *eril ies prearn Inrtead 6t Coertantrel Ledk Rale Progrr to minarge the sgng effect d6 eo d rMeeial inharelhet, the disussionIn lem 321-35 Taile 321 willbe reisled Ibrad as "Tle h.: PTh.

pe sule Sveillarce ad Fr-ive keiirtenrece Proeya.n reneg the less m

dlerial Ior sted eornpnrtes exposed a

o raw wat.-

TNP repires anamenerri 1othe IRAto rteise Table 322-7.

321 ands*Apepxd B Pjge 74d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 75 Number Status Request 514 Accepted 1j1.1-MI LRATabl.

ems.1.-14. t1.1-15 aid31.1-47 allincllde dclnsiem Isying hat aging d Iht sonapnens rduing WP o hose lanes will beby Water Chwaistly auyreaed by th Ons Tine I-spectien Prong'm A"athri ad LPROD-C.

Revision Cn providea a list d AMtA. affected by the OCrn-Tee Inpection Actvitias. Howeve, Atachmen 2

does Z Incluet A.aMM-1 (Remclor Prassues Vessel) w AMM-32 (Rasole Vessel flmeis) Inthe lista dafected AMRFIA.

Please priwida anexlanat en d wty AM I-31 and AMPtM-2 mand Included InAltantsile 2d LtRPD-O.

Revision M New wwit PNPS

-ra UIM appropriate m-Urnse kiptoone aroperutned for toe RPV aid WIA cofpiones where such Itepwtione we craeled for Adng kMrbgmawl duie th parnrl l dWlarded operation?

Reson se Tthun OIw application, It. OCr-Tke Inspection (OTt) Program hwa busn Irealed as a aqipport prWm sor the waem cter$isley pr aran foitnhew ptrpes d verifying water chemistry progein effectivereas. The O-Tlme Inspection Progam has io bean treated w an agin gumal prograsi dcsrtly applcbe the eystyne tha t I

redl water cheisry toe arng niraageaut ThN treaatii was comisidard appriprale since the verilication S waer chereistey progran alectivrness willbea" Iretgrated task OWa silieae dfecliveness

d.

Oe proasm toe all systers ths crWa waler chertrfy Ift waler Oteistry preogad"aslvera$

willnoi be wilied aserately fom wnh ayater For th cases wthr IVe COe-Tine Irspectin Progras airtbsses oiponot specific Inpectylin, thi. listed In the IRA asiae agng rnurergsrl poanm dretly applicale toID as omponenas The test rowd Atactoir 23d LRPO-02 dm.tifie. t' activities d ft On-Tirna Irspection Program Pl willverity waler chenisliry prograi effectivnass lot all systemr O credt water chenistry.

TNs line applies to the walm chwristry prOgrer. Incluinrg Vwle Cheriasty Contrlr -SMt. wtch Inturn appies toireli dthe system Uistsdinthl.agpicaI*m Th" rercmr praesse vassel and rec1te vassal Irert$s comepoeess credt the Water Chmdistay Comard -B6R program. sothia lineappliea obvkIRM-31 and AMPA3*2 TheI trnarinrg lin dAdtachma 2d LRPO-Mortify activities d the Ore-Tine Irnpectin Prograr thas address nompomw specific Ir*Ipatior Arpicabi a systemn we Idetrlied for these Inspections.

NRC PNPS Lead JactwMo Wlsrb FinreS Ron PAW l*d 77

James Davis - AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf Page 76]1 Number Status S15 Cttw -

Plant Request LRA Tatoe43-I providese lft lmitin 40-yew ard:týe usage lacor, (CUF)kor fte RPV. RPV Interal

aondonts, sot reactor coole peteour. boundary (RCP8)`pip1`ng wsredcagned IoASME Section IIL With It exception of One CUFovalues or RPV foowater nozzte., PNPS les accepted the TLM rmetal tehgoe CUFetelyse "d staedI tel Ins 40-ye-CUF

-ooclsiorl

-'o eid to, lperiodd of ededod operation (EPO) In aooordaneo with IOCFR 54 2 o

rO)(f)(i)tor the affete of cracking t gidge" willbemaregod tor lthe EPO.

The last peragtaph on Page Il Id LRPD-C6 aides thait o,.

en WI ohf i*t doign esels transients defined tnIts UFSAR povection stow ist the allowede limit, as defined by "i RPV vycliclooed entysis, willbe es¢eded b hew* the snd ofi te pIaiodded tatded opetafis." Theloag'aph Whate tales te"* Adlalleds analysis beyond he scope of tHs report would be remireid to rwe.eds CUF. N's.

trswislimits n

re infct sceceld and VW 'The exitirng cycle nnitoring programn wil mneto r tse cycles and riide mor-ecj action upon approshing a lirt, Please eLain how One ND.-year CUF concluson wtl remin valid for lhv EPO when PNPS Report No t.RPO-C06 Imple lW Vl CUFe houmd be recat Iatei ad projected out W years. Plebe eake ine-coo "t fact ar Draft C'renlitnet 31 resuires correti-eo actn when the CUFe soes 1.0' and not whenft l

rs tn*anw tcn of fMP I B1.12, Faetg.e Monitoring Progam' dotist*nsn the actual tansiete cycles will anrerpeh We rnds of deeigt ansient cycles tot s alslowed tinoe design basis.le the CUF8 should h.e been projected ad recalcualaed to 60-years. as Irdicaded In LRPD.M provideoa ommtmnen when the Myer CUF. veluse ortlhe RCPlooTpone.

wilt he provided totOs NRC o, review and approval undsr either 10 CFR 54 21(c)(1)(ii) or (iW). The response loiNs queston may rsy"re amornrel oft Comrilment 31 eador UFSAR S*o4*s'n t S..r.y Deecription A221. 'Cte. H Me*sl Faiguee Ths Ift. goes with Ift 425 ReWponse NRC LRPD-C6 was rnd IrlewdI to I"ply t* Vs CUF ihoud beprojected Medoffo Jim Wot toO year Inaocordeoce with IOCFR 5421c)(1I)(1).CUF&in Table 43-1 we based oneassumed nurrse of trsnsiet cycles, rC ste runt*s years. These CUFsate d neceseseao 40-ywr Hlnitirg values A. long as the cyces we no eoese.

ft CUFP do no rood tobe recalculaled WIle ome ofr n t Vs ntos d cyc*e*

p"oaected for 60 yeart InTabne, 4 3-2 *ced V* design basie assuntpiors tor numers t

d cytcles.the FaVtigoue Monitorin ProTan assure.

tee I erseysee will berewised toincreese Vs allowabie number d cyclee betore accleng I design base s assuke ietione.

WVil. LFIPD projects r ts. teat excesd V design kasi.

ssumptios.

the projections re cono.etive and Vs actual reib*s of cycles nmy rot aceed Vs design koe. assumption on Vse numetrs of ctcles. CUFP will require r"WtCa alion It Vhe ntms.

of Vato l Israrents approach Vt deslgn basis value.

Because Vns CUFainTabe[ 43-1. withthe exception of t leedwaler nozzte, we well below 1. Vt allowable,.urbert of cydes cra be Inctreed throto reansaysis eesstritg h" nus n rss d cycle.

PNPS Lead Finrc% Ron SIB Open -

The TPO proqect documeneted Vs reeults of reactor vessel Pled*

fisgue usage tectors of Uniting compont In table 3-2 In GEreporl GE-N'E-COCO-ODO-1898-OZ Row0 March 20.

In Vs sunrnay Table, ft staee thel lo, CRD nozzle -stub tbe, Vs seting PNPS CUF valu w- 0 8, and I. now chenged to 0870 to TPO. Howe" Vthe IRA Tote l431. wNhih idoifie. cIasse ICUF va1:e. Vs CRD nozoztevalue o

O8 was nd kelxoiitd Please justify why the value was roe Included In Vs IRA Paei. Erach FPrltH Ron FPa 0 21 01d 77

James Davis -AMR - Report to the NRC.doc.pdf.Page.77]

Number Status Request 517 Open -

Ouaatlon 43-8 PNIPS pravildd the Prject team withlt Plass stress alyses and cuidalt'. usage factor cakctions tar ftw PNPS rarirculatioa lacemrl piping systems ad care s wlsltabilizers Inthe Idlowing dowimeils:

  • ODC23A404 &23A40t Re.Al, Pilgrim rciilaion Piping Raplawelnar.

June 27, l90

  • GE Repor 25A5685 RevIsion 1. Stres Reapol -Shoa Staillzers Vessel, June 19. 1995.
  • GE Report GENE-771-79-1194 Revision Z Sou Repeit Hard.er. Sties Ainlynl,J-re 19, 1995 LRATable 43-1 list* MIhf Ulniting 40-ye-CUF J

r to vec~rcda=n piping 1 CA110 and 1tt Ore liriling 40 ype CUF for Oire corse lhrd alstIizua I. 0.330. Th. linmting 40 year CUFvalusa provided Inthme reports for tnes ootponal$s we 09 a3 0i O0 respeclively. These vale-do rct conretfae othe 4C-ye CUF values provided in LRA Ta*e 43-1. F-pin wly ti-4C-yew CUF value in tin. d.*ign ta". tia*ewiwia drietrair Ikm -ye valtue pronidod InLLRA Table 43-1 I Ihti.

designs basis d(re-do rot calstittie tie mnel oure-t design basis CUF ba lar the repqawenrl recirculation piping systei e" cres sralstatsllz$, clarity wthdoi cumLws do patain he lawet design basis CUF salcUlatians fr these oawpowt owrrcay groups. Staid I*s bte ct ase, lais Queltin willrernaoencpen trait st can review the apprcps*tie deigi basis catilwons tr Ia caieprel ooaniuy wowpe.

Response

NRC PNPS Lead Madoff. Jim Finnirr Ron FtPp 770d 77

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML062480379&oldid=5358599"