ML19327C049: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Created page by program invented by StriderTol
 
StriderTol Bot change
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
| number = ML19327C049
| number = ML19327C049
| issue date = 11/02/1989
| issue date = 11/02/1989
| title = Responds to 891019 Ltr & Documents Discussion of Various Issues Raised During 891024 Visit to Plant.Util Fully Aware of NRC Requirements & Obligation
| title = Responds to & Documents Discussion of Various Issues Raised During 891024 Visit to Plant.Util Fully Aware of NRC Requirements & Obligation
| author name = Long R
| author name = Long R
| author affiliation = GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES CORP.
| author affiliation = GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES CORP.
Line 11: Line 11:
| contact person =  
| contact person =  
| document report number = C-89-759, C000-89-0759, NUDOCS 8911150157
| document report number = C-89-759, C000-89-0759, NUDOCS 8911150157
| title reference date = 10-19-1989
| document type = CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS, EXTERNAL CORRESPONDENCE, EXTERNAL LETTERS ROUTED TO NRC
| document type = CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS, EXTERNAL CORRESPONDENCE, EXTERNAL LETTERS ROUTED TO NRC
| page count = 2
| page count = 2
Line 17: Line 18:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:.
{{#Wiki_filter:.
              .      .                                                                                                                  ,
I OPU Nesteet CeeperoWen One Upper Ponc Road i
          .    .                                                                                                                          ;
er Parsippany, Nem, lersey 070$4 i
I OPU Nesteet CeeperoWen er                                                                One Upper Ponc Road Parsippany, Nem, lersey 070$4 201 316 7000 i
201 316 7000 TELEX 136 482 l
i
Wrlier's Direct Dial Number; j
                                                                                                                                          ,
i November 2, 1989 l
TELEX 136 482                   l Wrlier's Direct Dial Number;     j i
?.
    ,
C000-89-0759 j
November 2, 1989                                                     l
o A. J. McMahon, Acting Director J
?.                                                                   C000-89-0759                                                         I o                                                                                                                                       j A. J. McMahon, Acting Director                                                                                         l J
Division of Environmental Quality Department. of Environmental Protection State of New Jersey CN 027, Trenton, NJ 08626-0027 j
Division of Environmental Quality Department. of Environmental Protection State of New Jersey                                                                                                     ,
m i
CN 027, Trenton, NJ       08626-0027                                                                                   j m                                                                                                                                         ;
i


==Dear Mr. McMahon:==
==Dear Mr. McMahon:==
 
l I
l
This is in response to your letter of October 19, 1989 and documents our discussion ~of the various issues during your visit to the Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station on October 24, 1989.
          ,                                                                                                                              I This is in response to your letter of October 19, 1989 and documents our                                             .
-The implication from the statement in your letter that *...GPU Nuclear (GPUN) t does not feel there is a rieed to meet certain Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) licensing requirements...' does not represent our view.
discussion ~of the various issues during your visit to the Oyster Creek Nuclear                                       .
I don't know how i
Generating Station on October 24, 1989.                                                                               ;
you came to believe it, but it just isn't so.
                                                                                                                                        !
GPUN has always and does today
                  -The implication from the statement in your letter that *...GPU Nuclear (GPUN)                                         t does not feel there is a rieed to meet certain Nuclear Regulatory Commission                                         !
  ,
(NRC) licensing requirements...' does not represent our view. I don't know how                                       i you came to believe it, but it just isn't so. GPUN has always and does today
''
(
(
recognize that it must meet all NRC requirements under our license.                               This is           l clearly stated and emphasited in our Mission, Values, Polices and Procedures.                                         ;
recognize that it must meet all NRC requirements under our license.
We (as other licensecs) do discuss with the NRC their requirements and where                                         i appropriate and acceptable to the NRC, seek clarifications, exemptions or exceptions that are warranted for the specific conditions at CCNGS.                             NPC                 ,
This is l
                                                                                                                                        '
clearly stated and emphasited in our Mission, Values, Polices and Procedures.
requirements for the OCNGS recognize and incorporate any such specific items.
We (as other licensecs) do discuss with the NRC their requirements and where i
                                                                                                                                        !
appropriate and acceptable to the NRC, seek clarifications, exemptions or exceptions that are warranted for the specific conditions at CCNGS.
The margin of safety for the OCNGS is essentially captured in the Final Safety                                       ;
NPC requirements for the OCNGS recognize and incorporate any such specific items.
s              Analysis Report and Technical Specifications where the facility licensing bases                                     i and operating limits are contained.               The licensing requirements were                                   ,
The margin of safety for the OCNGS is essentially captured in the Final Safety Analysis Report and Technical Specifications where the facility licensing bases i
        ,'
s and operating limits are contained.
        -        established during the initial licensing process and have been revised, as                                           ,
The licensing requirements were established during the initial licensing process and have been revised, as appropriate, to incorporate evolutionary issues that develop in the regulatory process.
appropriate, to incorporate evolutionary issues that develop in the regulatory process. Your thought that *. . .there is a wide divergence between GPUN meeting
Your thought that *...there is a wide divergence between GPUN meeting NRC requirements for a full term operating license...and actually proving that the plant has an adequate margin of safety in 1989.', appears not to recognize that the license is a dynamic document that is modified when relevant issues arise. As stated above, GPUK operates the plant within the requirements of the license thus ensuring that the margin of safety for the plant is maintained.
            >
8911150157 691102 Opol l
NRC requirements for a full term operating license...and actually proving that                                       '
PDR ADOCK 05000219 P
the plant has an adequate margin of safety in 1989.', appears not to recognize that the license is a dynamic document that is modified when relevant issues
PDC r
        ,
GPU Nuclear Corporation is a subsid.ary of Generat Public UtMties Corporation
arise. As stated above, GPUK operates the plant within the requirements of the                                       ,
license thus ensuring that the margin of safety for the plant is maintained.
                                                                                                                                        ,
8911150157 691102                                                                                     Opol         !
PDR   ADOCK 05000219                                                                                               l P                   PDC                                                                                     .
r GPU Nuclear Corporation is a subsid.ary of Generat Public UtMties Corporation
                                    .                        _        _              . _ - .                        .-        ,  _


                                                            . _ - - .        _
.o'
  .o'                                                                                           ,
'A.
            '
J. McMahon, Acting Director f
      = . 'A. J. McMahon, Acting Director                                                     f Department of Environmental Protection                                               i
=
                                                                                                '
Department of Environmental Protection i
November 2, 1989 Page 2 i
November 2, 1989 Page 2 i
As you recognise at any given time there may be a nunber of open issues which         ,
As you recognise at any given time there may be a nunber of open issues which are the subject of discussion with the NRC.
are the subject of discussion with the NRC. The NRC has chosen in the Full           ;
The NRC has chosen in the Full Term Operating License process to address the Systematic Evaluation Program, 1
Term Operating License process to address the Systematic Evaluation Program,         1 NUREG-0737 and Environmental Impact Statement issues and bring these issues to       ,
NUREG-0737 and Environmental Impact Statement issues and bring these issues to closure as part of the process.
closure as part of the process. For open issues that have been determined to         j have significant inpact on the plant and corporate resources, GPUN utilises the     !
For open issues that have been determined to j
Long Range Planning Program (LRPP) to manage these items. Both issues               !
have significant inpact on the plant and corporate resources, GPUN utilises the Long Range Planning Program (LRPP) to manage these items. Both issues identified by the NRC (e.g. GL 88-01 concerning intergranular stress corrosion
identified by the NRC (e.g. GL 88-01 concerning intergranular stress corrosion       {
{
eracking) and issues identified by GPUN to enhance plant safety and reliability       ,
eracking) and issues identified by GPUN to enhance plant safety and reliability are addressed by the LRPP.
are addressed by the LRPP.     This program was developed to assess, coordinate     j and schedule major work tasks of projects at the OCNGS, including those mandated or proposed by the NRC.       The LRPP and resultant plan / schedule are   ;
This program was developed to assess, coordinate j
license conditions, and, as a result, receive NRC review and approval. Open         l NRC issues that have not yet been identified as having a significant impact on       i the plant (e.g. Individual Plant Examination), are the subject of                   ;
and schedule major work tasks of projects at the OCNGS, including those mandated or proposed by the NRC.
                                                                                                '
The LRPP and resultant plan / schedule are license conditions, and, as a result, receive NRC review and approval. Open l
correspondence and periodic meetings with the NRC. Consequently, timely resolution of open issues is mutually agreed upon by GPUN and NRC.
NRC issues that have not yet been identified as having a significant impact on i
* We appreciated the opportunity to meet with you and your staff on October 24, 1989 and believe these meetings serve to increase the communication between our     ;
the plant (e.g. Individual Plant Examination), are the subject of correspondence and periodic meetings with the NRC.
organisations and would hope they continue. Further, as the result of this           !
Consequently, timely resolution of open issues is mutually agreed upon by GPUN and NRC.
meeting, it is our understanding that you intend to request that the NRC hold a     t public meeting with respect to the FTOL process. Acknowledging this intent, CPUN believes that the NRC should be given latitude as to the forum of this         !
We appreciated the opportunity to meet with you and your staff on October 24, 1989 and believe these meetings serve to increase the communication between our organisations and would hope they continue. Further, as the result of this meeting, it is our understanding that you intend to request that the NRC hold a t
meeting. Should NRC agree to host a public meeting, GPUN would fully support         (
public meeting with respect to the FTOL process.
Acknowledging this intent, CPUN believes that the NRC should be given latitude as to the forum of this meeting.
Should NRC agree to host a public meeting, GPUN would fully support
(
and participate as requested.
and participate as requested.
Ver ' tru         yours,                 !
Ver ' tru
                                                                                                '
: yours,
1   )                  .
)
(/ s )*                     fM.
1
(/s )
* fM.
R. L. Long Vice President a.74 Director Planning and Nuclear Safety RLL/ctb (OCNGS)
R. L. Long Vice President a.74 Director Planning and Nuclear Safety RLL/ctb (OCNGS)
S cc Nr. William T. Russell, Administrator Region I                                                                       t U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 475 Allendale Road King of Prussia, PA     19406 j            gDocument Control Desk                                                             ,
S cc Nr. William T. Russell, Administrator Region I t
l U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 475 Allendale Road King of Prussia, PA 19406 g ocument Control Desk j
'
D l
Mail Station PI-137 Washington, D.C. 20555
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Station PI-137 Washington, D.C.
                                        .                            _          _  _ ,  . _.}}
20555
_.}}

Latest revision as of 07:25, 31 December 2024

Responds to & Documents Discussion of Various Issues Raised During 891024 Visit to Plant.Util Fully Aware of NRC Requirements & Obligation
ML19327C049
Person / Time
Site: Oyster Creek
Issue date: 11/02/1989
From: Long R
GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES CORP.
To: Mcmahon A
NEW JERSEY, STATE OF
References
C-89-759, C000-89-0759, NUDOCS 8911150157
Download: ML19327C049 (2)


Text

.

I OPU Nesteet CeeperoWen One Upper Ponc Road i

er Parsippany, Nem, lersey 070$4 i

201 316 7000 TELEX 136 482 l

Wrlier's Direct Dial Number; j

i November 2, 1989 l

?.

C000-89-0759 j

o A. J. McMahon, Acting Director J

Division of Environmental Quality Department. of Environmental Protection State of New Jersey CN 027, Trenton, NJ 08626-0027 j

m i

Dear Mr. McMahon:

l I

This is in response to your letter of October 19, 1989 and documents our discussion ~of the various issues during your visit to the Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station on October 24, 1989.

-The implication from the statement in your letter that *...GPU Nuclear (GPUN) t does not feel there is a rieed to meet certain Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) licensing requirements...' does not represent our view.

I don't know how i

you came to believe it, but it just isn't so.

GPUN has always and does today

(

recognize that it must meet all NRC requirements under our license.

This is l

clearly stated and emphasited in our Mission, Values, Polices and Procedures.

We (as other licensecs) do discuss with the NRC their requirements and where i

appropriate and acceptable to the NRC, seek clarifications, exemptions or exceptions that are warranted for the specific conditions at CCNGS.

NPC requirements for the OCNGS recognize and incorporate any such specific items.

The margin of safety for the OCNGS is essentially captured in the Final Safety Analysis Report and Technical Specifications where the facility licensing bases i

s and operating limits are contained.

The licensing requirements were established during the initial licensing process and have been revised, as appropriate, to incorporate evolutionary issues that develop in the regulatory process.

Your thought that *...there is a wide divergence between GPUN meeting NRC requirements for a full term operating license...and actually proving that the plant has an adequate margin of safety in 1989.', appears not to recognize that the license is a dynamic document that is modified when relevant issues arise. As stated above, GPUK operates the plant within the requirements of the license thus ensuring that the margin of safety for the plant is maintained.

8911150157 691102 Opol l

PDR ADOCK 05000219 P

PDC r

GPU Nuclear Corporation is a subsid.ary of Generat Public UtMties Corporation

.o'

'A.

J. McMahon, Acting Director f

=

Department of Environmental Protection i

November 2, 1989 Page 2 i

As you recognise at any given time there may be a nunber of open issues which are the subject of discussion with the NRC.

The NRC has chosen in the Full Term Operating License process to address the Systematic Evaluation Program, 1

NUREG-0737 and Environmental Impact Statement issues and bring these issues to closure as part of the process.

For open issues that have been determined to j

have significant inpact on the plant and corporate resources, GPUN utilises the Long Range Planning Program (LRPP) to manage these items. Both issues identified by the NRC (e.g. GL 88-01 concerning intergranular stress corrosion

{

eracking) and issues identified by GPUN to enhance plant safety and reliability are addressed by the LRPP.

This program was developed to assess, coordinate j

and schedule major work tasks of projects at the OCNGS, including those mandated or proposed by the NRC.

The LRPP and resultant plan / schedule are license conditions, and, as a result, receive NRC review and approval. Open l

NRC issues that have not yet been identified as having a significant impact on i

the plant (e.g. Individual Plant Examination), are the subject of correspondence and periodic meetings with the NRC.

Consequently, timely resolution of open issues is mutually agreed upon by GPUN and NRC.

We appreciated the opportunity to meet with you and your staff on October 24, 1989 and believe these meetings serve to increase the communication between our organisations and would hope they continue. Further, as the result of this meeting, it is our understanding that you intend to request that the NRC hold a t

public meeting with respect to the FTOL process.

Acknowledging this intent, CPUN believes that the NRC should be given latitude as to the forum of this meeting.

Should NRC agree to host a public meeting, GPUN would fully support

(

and participate as requested.

Ver ' tru

yours,

)

1

(/s )

  • fM.

R. L. Long Vice President a.74 Director Planning and Nuclear Safety RLL/ctb (OCNGS)

S cc Nr. William T. Russell, Administrator Region I t

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 475 Allendale Road King of Prussia, PA 19406 g ocument Control Desk j

D l

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Station PI-137 Washington, D.C.

20555

_.