ML20214G845

Summary of 770510 Meeting W/Mark II Owners Executive Committee Re Mark II Containment Dynamic Loads Program.List of Attendees & Viewgraphs Encl

ML20214G845
Person / Time
Site:	Nine Mile Point, Susquehanna, Columbia, Limerick, LaSalle, 05000000, Zimmer, Shoreham, Bailly
Issue date:	12/02/1977
From:	Miner S Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
CON-WNP-0191, CON-WNP-191 NUDOCS 8605220556
Download: ML20214G845 (19)

Text

..

DEC 0 2 3977 Docket Hos. 50/322,50/352,50/353,50/358,50/367 50/373, 50/374, 50/337, 50/388 h50/ M a nd 50/410 FACILITIES: Shorehan Nuclear Power Station Unit No.1 Limerick Generating Station Units No.1 and No. 2 William H. Zimer Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1. Bailly Generating Station fluclear No.1 La Salle County Station Units No.1 and NQ? 2 Susquehanna Steam Electric Station Units No.1 and No. 2 WPPSS tiuclear Project No. 2, Nine Mlle Point Nuclear Station Unit No. 2 APPLICANTS:

Long Island Lighting Co., Philadelphia Electric Cincinnati Gas and Electric Co., Northern Indiana Pubite Service Co.,

Comonwealth Edison, Pennsylvania Power and Light Co.,

Washington Public Power Supply System and Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation

SUBJECT:

SUMMA 5!Y OF NEETING HELD ON MAY 10, 1977 TO DISCUSS THE MARK II CONTAIhMENT DYNAMIC LOADS PROGRAN A meeting was held on May 10, 1977 between the Mark II owners executive comittee and NRC management.

The purpose of the cieeting was to discus",

the Mark II owner's program for pesolving the dyr.amic loads problem p:ed program schedule.

Tha attendees list and copfes of the slides given to the attendees are enclosed.

The major topics discussdd are as follows:

1.

Program Plan Overview The Mark II owners described an overall program which had been revised to include a bounding loads approach, short tem program (STP), for early plant assessment and a longer tem program (LTP) consisting of confimatory efforts (enclosure 2).

2.

Chugging loads (enclosure 3)

The Japanese scale size tests which the Mark II owners had indicated would be part of their steam loads program (see April 18, 1977 meeting sucriary by S. Miner) has been delayed because of instrtanentation problems and therefore, Japanese infonnation will not be available in a timely fashion.

The Mark II owners are now looking at alternate sites for conducting the scale size multi-vent tests.

They have a team in Gemany investigating the Geman scale size test program.

In addition they are investigatdog sites in the U. S. A., such as at the.

Croare Corporation, for conducting these tests.

The Mark II owners. j.

l8_

su.a.es. >

unc ro us na

<,.t.) uncu oz.o

• o...........,....,,..,,,........

B605220556 771PO2 PDR ADOCK 05000322 I

A PDH

DECO 2197f

M1 still expect that scale size multi-vent tests will-verify that the 4T full size single vent tests have provided the Lounding chugging loads. They do not propose to conduct full size multi-vent test.

The 11 ark II owners have reoriented their chugging loads program into a bounding loads approach for early plant evaluation such as Zimer. This will be followed by a longer tem loads verification program. The bounding loads program, short tenn program (STP), will be based on the test infomation and existing Gennan infomation.

The 11 ark II owners indicated that if arrangements with the Japanese are finalized, any information that may become available from their tests, will be utilized.

Other Loads The Mark II owners provided a brief description of the safety relief valve program.

(Enclosure 4and5)and The ranshead program (enciesure 4) pool swell program (enclosure 6).

has also been reoriented into a short tem program and a long term program.

Schedu14 The following infomation will be submitted in June:

(a) The 4T Bounding Loads Report (b) The EPRI Evaluation Report (c) The Ramshead Short Tem Program (d) The remainder of the flRC Generic Questions (e) Submerged Structure Report Sumary The staff was not convinced that the : hugging loads problem can be bounded with the 4T test results and scale size multi-vent tests. The staff believes that full size multi-vent tests may be required. However, since a detail description of the proposed chugging program and the results of the analytical portion of the program will be presented to the staff on May 18 & 19, 1977 another management meeting will be schedule for June 1,1977, to discuss this matter further.

Original Signed ByI s.mr Sydney Miner Pro.fect Manager Light Water Reactors Branch No. 3 ulvision or VmJect riana gement

.3WR.13 LWS Q a "* = >

Enc 1 sures: SMin

c :

OParr 5

2

,,Xs hated 12/ t 12/ / /77_

=c rom m o.m mcx u.o

• m................-...- -

DEC 0 01977 Washington Public Power Supply System ATIN: Mr. N. O. Strand Managing Director 3000 George Washington Way Richl/ind, Washington 99352 cc:

Joseph B. Knotts, Jr., Esq.

Debevoise & Liberman*

Shoreham Builoing, Suite 700 800 35th Street, N.W.

Washington, D. C.

20005 i

Richard Q. Quigley, Esq.

Washington Pub)ic Power Supply System 3000 George Washington Way Richland, Washington 99352

GEC C G//

Contwnwealth Edison Company ATIN: Mr. Byron Lee, Jr.

Vice President P. O. Box 767 Chicago, Illinois 60690 cc: Rishard E. Iowell, Esq.

Isham, Lincol'n & Beale One First National Plaza 2400 Chicago, Illinois 60670 O

Northern Indiana Public Service Cor.pany cca:

iteredi,th HemphiiI, Jr Esq.

Asststant General Counsel Bethlehem Steel Corporation flartin Tower Dethlehem, Pennsylvania 18016 tillI f am 11. Eichhorn, Esq.

Eichhorn, florrow & Eichhorn 5243 Ilohman Avenue llamond, Indiana 46320 Edward W. Osann, Jr., Esq.

iJol r, Hubcard, Leydid, Voit & Osann, Ltd.

e Suite 4600 One I!Yi Plaza Chicago, Illinois 60611 tlarvin N. Benn, Esq.

Special Assistant Attorney General 134 flor th LaSalle Street Suite 2222 Chicago, 111inois 60602 itoce' t J. Vollen, Esq.

109 Nor th Dear bor n Str eet Chicago, Illinois 60602 florthern Indiana Public Service Company ATTil: fir. H. P. Ly'le, Vice President Electric Production & Engineering 5265 Holman Ave.

Hamond, Indiana 46325

...s....-

g

r 1

ces:

Joseph B.-Knotts, Jr., Esq.

Debevoise & Liberman 700 shorenam Building 806 Fif teenth Street, N. W.

Washington, D. C. 20005 Richard Q. Quigley, Esq.

Washington Public Power Supply System P. O. Box 968 Richland, Washington 99352 Washington Public Power Supply System ATTN: Mr. Kneil 0. Strand Managing Director 3000 George Washington Way Richland Washington 99352

I l

CCs:

Eugene' 8'. Thomas, Jr.

LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby & MacPae 1757 N Street, N. W.

Washington, D. C.

20036 Anthony Z. Roisman, Esq.

Roisman, Kessler & Cashdan 102515th Street, NW I

Washington, D. C.

20036 Mr. 'ichard Goldsmith R

Syracuse University College of Law l

E. I. White Hall Campus l

Syracuse, New York 13210 T. K. DeBoer, Director Technological Development Programs l

l New York State Energy Office Swan Street Building i

Core 1 - 2nd Floor Enpire State Plaza Albar.y, New York 12223 I

l I

Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation ATTN: Mr. Jerald K. Rhode l

Vice President Engineering 300 Erie Boulavard West l

Syracuse New York 13202 4

E Lcng Island Lighting Corapany ces: Edward M. Bar ratt, Caq.

Getkiral Councel Long Island Lighting Company 250 Old Country Road Flineola, tiew York 11501 IW ard J. Wal'.h. Esq.

General Attortry, Long taland Lighting Cortpany 250 01d Country Road Flineola, Wew York 11501 f1r. Thoma Durke Project Manager Shcrcham fluelear Power 3tation P. O. Cox 610 Wading River. tiew York l!792 Director, Technical D' velo:x:ent Programa Stata oC slew York Cnergy Of fice Agency Bailding 2 Empire State Plaza A1bany, ilew Yor k 12223 i: tard L. 31au 31au and Conn, P.C.

300 l.;r th Droahiy Jer ici,o, New Yor k 11753 Irving Like. L:a s, teilly, tike and 3cnnleder 2uo i! cat Main street Babylon, Wew York 11702 f!!ia Technica1 AT;oeiatec 366 Calitornia Avenue Unite 6 Palo Alto, California '34309 Lon1 Island Lic tin:) C.p n '. n,

ATIN:

Mr. Andrew W.

..nttord li ces r'res i den t 175 fast Old Country Pr.+1 H i r; k e, v i l 10, fl.tw Yor k IiHDI

C Philadelphia Clectric Coi.1pany cc: Troy -6. Conner, Jr., i:sq.

Ph i l o :. i: h i a El.2rtric "

Cotiner. Iloore & Corter ATTil:

'ir. E Ar-e

't 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. L!.

Vico rreiuent en~ Jen.m Waahington, D. C.

20006 C mnse r 2301 riarkor c tr. et

11. William AnJercon, Ccq.

Ph i l ale i ph i a, Pentny l van i a 10101 Daputy Attorney Ganeral Room $12, Itain Capitol Guilding Ilarrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 Frank R. Clokey, Esq.

Special Assictant Attorney Gent al Room 216, Towne flouce Apartrents P. O. Ocx 2063 liarrisourg, Pannsylvania 17105 ficr.orable Laarence Cougnlin ilouce of Reprenontativen Congreau of the United States Wash ing ton, D. C.

20515 Roger B. Reynolds, Jr., Esq.

324 Swede Street IJorr istown, Pennsylvania 19401 tiillard C. ilet; el, Csq.

312 ilain Street Cast Greenville, Pennsylvania lev 41 t,awrence Sager, nay.

Sager & Sager A3.30ciates 45 ili'Jh Street Pntrntnwn, Pennnylvania 19464 Jocepli A. Jmyth Aa:3tstant County Solicitor County of llontgomery Courthou1e florr13 town, Penncylvania I9404 Cu jen^ J. Uradley Phi l ylol ph i ) Clectric c epany AGoctate General Counuel 2301.' tar ket Str eet PnilaJelphia, Pennsylvania 19101

$0-356 L.ih-1 tim 11. ZIit1ER tiUCLEAR awe.'CR STATICli, UNIT L I. Peltier cc Continued:

Dayid B. Fankhauser, PnD 3569 14ine Mile Road Cincinnati, Ohio 45230 Thomas A. Luebbers, Esq.

Cincinnati City Solicitor Room 214 - City Itall Cir.cinnati, Ohio 45202 Troy B. Conner, Esq.

Conner, Moore & Cober 1747 Pennsylvania Ave ti.W.

Washington, D.C.

20006 4

s 50-358 L..R-1 WM. H. ZIMMER NUCLEAR =0WER STATION, UNIT 1 I. Peltier The Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company AI'IN : Mr. Earl A. Borgmann Vice President - Engineering P. O. Dox 960 Cincinnati, Ohio 45201 cc: Mr.EilliamJ.Moran General Counsel The Cincinnati Gas & Electric Co.

P. O. Box 960 Cincinnati, Ohio 45201 Mr. William G. Porter, Jr.

Porter, Stanley, Arthur, & Platt 37 West Broad Street Colunbus, Ohio 43215 Mr. Robert Killen, Chairman of the Board & Chief Executive Officer Tha Dayton Power & Light Company P. O. Box 1034 Daycon, Ohio 45401 Mr. J. Robert Newlin, Counsel The Dayton Power & Light Company P. O. Box 1034 Dayton, Ohio 45401, Mr. Stephen Schumacher Mia.ni Valley Power Project P. O. Box 252 Dayton, Onio 45401 Ms. Augusta Prince

.601 Stanley Avenue Cincinnati, Onio 45226 l

Mr. J.mus D. Flynn Manager, Licensing & Environmental Affairs j

The Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company i

P. O. Box 960 l

Cincinnati, Ohio 45201 j

Mr. J. P. Fenstermaker l

Senior Vice President - Operations Columbus & Southern Ohio Electric Co.

j 215 North Front Street Columbus, Chio 43215 e

r Commonwealth Edison Corrpeny ATnJ: Mr. Byron Ipe, Jr.

Vice President P. C. Box 767 Chicago -Illinois 60690 e

cc: Ricnard E. Powell, Esq.

Isha n, Lincoln a Beale One First tJational Plaza 2400 Cnicago,111 incis 60670 U

S

r Pennaylvania Power and Lignt Company A1'nJ:

Mr. Nnrman W. Curtis Vice Presi+nt - Engineering and Construction 2 North ~tlinth Street Allentown, Pennsylvania Id101 cc:

Mr. Earle fl. Mead Project Mar.ager Peansylvania Power & Light Company 2 tiorth Ninth Street Allentown, Pennsylvania 16101 Gerald Charnoff, Esq.

Shaw, Pittman, Potts, Trowbridge

& Madden 1000 ft Street, fl. W.

Washington, D. C.

20036 Mr. William E. Barbericn Licensing Engineer Pennsylvania Power & Light Conpany 2 North Ninth Street Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 Mr. Robert J. Shovlin, Project Manager Susquehanna Pennsylvania Power & Light Company 2 Nortn Ninth Street Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 liub!rt Barnes, Ea].

Pennaf vania Power & Lignt Company l

901 ilamilton Street Allentown, Pennsylvania id101

s

. ENCLOSURE 1 ATTENDEES LIST I

NRC Limerick R. DeYoung V. Boyer R. Tedesco R. Heinemen D. Vassallo

0. Parr WPPSS No. 2 S. Miner G. Lainis D. Renberger J. Knight Zimmer

l j

E. Borgman H. Bunkman La Salle J. Johnson i

Shoreham A. Wofford Nine Mile Point Unit 2 i

S. Mannel i

i Bailly-H. Lyle i

Susquehanna 1

N. Curtis l

I 1

i k

ENCLOSURE 2 MK II CONTAlflMEtiT PROGRAM PLAN OVERVIEW 4

B00f1DIrlG LOADS FOR CONFIRf1ATORY

, PLANT ASSESSMENT EFFORTS DYNAMIC FORCING

~

MULTIVENT CHUGGING

~

LOADS DETERMINATION FullCTIONS REPORT (IllCLUDESS/RVALVEj METHOD & VERIFICATION 4T LOAD REPORT RAMSHEAD METHODOLOGY ~

VERIFICATION 4T APPLICATIONS MEMORAtlDUM QUEriCHER METHODOLOGY VERIFICATI0tl 7

a i

il i

1 ARS 5/77

ENCLOSURE 3 CIPJGG!r:C L_05DS.,

4T Applir.ation s

47 Tests

/ Memorandum

~-~~~~

Phase !. !! &

+

Wrt T rn Single Cell Model h

sf [lbin[rf it/f, M'oje[

c a.+3r. o r

4i Coun4 ting C

3 Anamet Study on 4T

> load Report-- ->

KW & Other Data Review l

lh9f.t, le_m_FLSI 4T Tests

---

~~

Mul tivent y

Method for 1

-s detemining MultiventModel l

Mark !! Loads o

- g2 n_g Scaling _

Design Docue nts Chu i for Hork II Pi.ints

+

tcag Tem Multivent Tests J

l r:Rc DFrR Final rogram

[Yerif cation y Review

)_ Updates _) DFFR

/ Multivent German _MLV_ Tests _

ilethod s/

h Plant JAERI M/V Tests,

{

Long Term Fluid Structure Interaction for Test Interpretation h

ARS 5/77 t

8 4

-J

n-s

.f *JI T Y e.a ! F T 'il,' '!! LC

• D S ENCLOSURE 4

.,,.,,g

_.n......

f f%ntiteilo "In Plant" Test

~ ' f IIsi1 D'ynIraI'c

~

Parshead Pipe C.,1gjr,inJfodgl I7 s

DFFR Pev. 2 Model d

~

lant Data

[DTFRRev.2 g,,,

P

.'* -t Tem Ramshead

-r ; ram

~

~

P..? thod

/ Verificat_ ion b & R Thid Structure Interaction Preliminary Check of R.H. Model Preliminary Mixing E0$81S.ta,t_em;nt__

t Mnnticello

"!n Plent"Tes t

_, Final j

Censecutive Actuation y, s i s s

Transient Anal l

I r

New A

.r y Ter n j Final s

DFFR rnra:n

-)

Ramshead hRC

' Updates

/

DFFR w

s Application

'N Review itethod Hatpr,C,1c,ar,1 g_Mpfel 7t s/

Stean Discharge -

4 Plant t:ixing t'odel Unique

> Evaluation }

\\

ngTernFluidStructurh s

Interaction for Test l

l j

sy ARS 5/77 l

l L

l I

I i

i

~

~.

ENCLOSURE 5 Quenchers Quencher Pipe Clearing Model Water Clearin_g Model Caorso "In Plant" Test Improved s

7

[ Quencher x

tiRC DFFR x

Final s

3 Application

/

Review

/

Updates DFFR Nethod Steam Discharge 7]

fiix_ing Model s,f

>I Plant

(

Unique Evaluation Consecutive Actuation Transient Anal sj_s_

t Phillipsburg Tokai 2 Long Term Fluid Structure Interaction for Test ARS 5/77 w

e i

s

ENCLOSURE 6

~

POOL SWELL LOADS EPP.! Data Evaluation 4T Tests e

Pool Swell

} Pool Swell NRC DFFR Final Rogel _ _

Ap 1 ca tion

)- Review y Updates 0FFR

-9

\\ /

1mgast_ Tests _

p Unique

> Evaluation Jmgact Model 5

s

?

ARS 5/77 1

9

.3