ML17263A124: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Adams
#REDIRECT [[U-604367, Response to Nuclear Regulatory Commission Inspection Report 05000461/2017009 and Preliminary White Finding, EA-17-098]]
| number = ML17263A124
| issue date = 09/18/2017
| title = Response to Nuclear Regulatory Commission Inspection Report 05000461/2017009 and Preliminary White Finding, EA-17-098
| author name = Stoner T R
| author affiliation = Exelon Generation Co, LLC
| addressee name =
| addressee affiliation = NRC/NRR, NRC/RGN-III
| docket = 05000461
| license number = NPF-062
| contact person =
| case reference number = EA-17-098, U-604367
| document report number = IR 2017009
| document type = Letter, Licensee Response to Notice of Violation
| page count = 601
}}
See also: [[followed by::IR 05000461/2017009]]
 
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:Exelon Generation
Clinton Power Station 8401 Power Road Clinton, IL 61727 U-604367 September
18, 2017 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory
Commission
ATTN: Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555-0001
Clinton Power Station, Unit 1 Facility Operating
License No. NPF-62 NRC Docket No. 50-461 Subject: Response to Nuclear Regulatory  
Commission  
Inspection  
Report 05000461/2017009  
and Preliminary  
White Finding, EA-17-098  
10 CFR 2.201 References:
1. Letter from Patrick L. Louden (NRC) to Bryan C. Hanson (EGC), "Clinton Power Station -NRC Inspection
Report 05000461/2017009
and Preliminary
White Finding [EA-17-098]," dated August 14, 2017 (ADAMS Accession
No. ML 17226A321)
2. Letter from Theodore R. Stoner (EGC) to NRC, "Notification
of Intention
Regarding
Inspection
Report 05000461/2017009
and Preliminary
White Finding (EA-17-098)," dated August 23, 2017 (ADAMS Accession
No. ML 172358156)
On August 14, 2017, the NRC issued Inspection
Report 05000461/2017009
to Exelon Generation
Company, LLC (EGC). The Inspection
Report identified
a preliminary
finding defined as an Apparent Violation (AV) of 10 CFR 50, Appendix B, Criterion
Ill, "Design Control." The AV was classified
as self-revealing, low to moderate safety significance (White). The AV is related to the failure to evaluate the change in the actual drop-out relay voltages for the Division 1 Emergency
Diesel Generator (EOG) room ventilation
fan resulting
in the EOG being declared inoperable.
The Inspection
Report provided EGC the option to attend a Regulatory
Conference
or submit the EGC position on the finding, in writing, within 40 days of the date of Reference
1. Additionally, the letter required a ten-day response to notify the NRC of the intended response.
On August 23, 2017, EGC submitted
the required ten-day response to notify the NRC that a 40-day written response would be submitted
to provide EGC's position on the finding (Reference
2). The 40-day response is provided in the Attachment, "Exelon Generation
Company's
Position Concerning
the Significance
of Apparent Violation
EA-17-098." 
September
18, 2017 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory
Commission
Page2 The Attachment
to this letter contains a description
and conclusion
of the additional
analysis performed
to evaluate the survivability
of equipment
in the Division 1 EDG room following
a failure of the EDG ventilation
fan 1 VD01 CA. The additional
analysis is enclosed with this letter. EGG recognizes
that a performance
deficiency
occurred and does not dispute the AV or the assigned cross-cutting
aspect. However, after reviewing
new information
provided herein, EGG has reassessed
the safety significance
and has concluded
that the finding has very low safety significance (Green}. The very low safety significance
is based upon additional
analysis and factors beyond those initially
provided to the NRC for use in assessment
of the significance
of the issue. EGC performed
an evaluation
to document reasonable
assurance
of continued
operation
of the EOG for 24 hours following
a start failure of the EDG ventilation
fan. The margins to the survivability
limits for critical devices for the bounding case of a. Large Break Loss of Coolant Accident I Loss of Offsite Power with the doors closed (i.e., no operator action} scenario increased
from the initial evaluation
provided during the inspection
period to the enclosed evaluation
from 11°F 37°F. The margin was calculated
in a manner that addresses
uncertainties, and therefore
provides "reasonable
assurance" of EDG operation
for the PRA mission time. With reasonable
assurance
of operation, EGC reviewed IMC 0609, Appendix A, "The Significance
Determination
Process (SOP} for Findings at Power," Exhibit 2 and could answer all the questions "No". EGC therefore
concludes
that the finding's
significance
meets the definition
of having very low safety significance
and should be characterized
as Green. There are no regulatory
commitments
contained
in this letter. If you have any questions, please contact Mr. Dale A. Shelton, Regulatory
Assurance
Manager, at (217) 937-2800.
Theodore R. Stoner Site Vice President
Clinton Power Station Attachment:
Exelon Generation
Company's
Position Concerning
the Significance
of Apparent Violation
EA-17-098
Enclosure:
EC 620632, Evaluate Survivability
of Equipment
in the Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room Due to Failure of EDG Ventilation
Fan 1VD01CA cc: Regional Administrator
-NRC Region Ill Ms. Karla Stoedter, Chief, Branch 1, Division of Reactor Projects -NRC Region Ill NRC Project Manager, NRR -Clinton Power Station NRC Senior Resident Inspector-
Clinton Power Station 
Attachment
Exelon Generation
Company's
Position Concerning
the Significance
of Apparent Violation
EA-17 -098 
1.0 OVERVIEW Attachment
Exelon Generation
Company's
Position Concerning
the Significance
of Apparent Violation
EA-17-098
NRC Inspection
Report 05000461/2017009
documented
a finding that has preliminarily
been determined
to be White, a finding with low to moderate safety significance, with an associated
apparent violation
of 10 CFR Part 50, Appendix 8, Criterion
Ill, "Design Control," and Technical
Specification (TS) 3.8.1, "AC Sources-Operating." This
finding is associated
with the failure to evaluate the change in the actual drop out voltages for replacement
relays associated
with the Division 1 Emergency
Diesel Generator (EOG) room ventilation
fan. Specifically, Engineering
Changes (EC) 330624 and 366624 failed to evaluate the change in the actual relay drop out voltages on the operation
of the Division 1 EOG room ventilation
fan circuitry
prior to replacing
the X2 and X3 relays on May 18, 2016 and January 2008, respectively.
The failure to properly evaluate the effects of the drop out voltages for both relays prevented
the room ventilation
fan from operating
during an under-voltage
condition, resulting
in the Division 1 EOG being inoperable
from May 18, 2016 to March 11, 2017, a period greater than allowed by the limiting condition
for operation
completion
time provided in TS 3.8.1. During this inspection, Exelon Generation
Company, LLC (EGC) provided the inspectors
with a copy of EC 619834, "Evaluate
Survivability
of Equipment
in the Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room Due to Failure of EOG Ventilation
Fan 1VD01 CA." The purpose of this evaluation
was to demonstrate
that the Clinton Power Station (CPS) Division 1 EOG would operate successfully
during the 24-hour PRA mission time, as described
in the NRC Risk Assessment
of Operational
Events Handbook (RASP), without the fan operating.
The inspectors
reviewed EC 619834 and concluded
that EGC had not provided a reasonable
basis to show the EOG would have been able to perform its function for the PRA mission time. Specifically, panel internal temperature
would have reached approximately
240°F, a point where some of the key components
would have been susceptible
to failure. EGC subsequently
reviewed the NRC's Inspection
Report and performed
additional
analysis and is providing
clarification
and additional
information
associated
with the facts and assumptions
used to assess the significance
of the finding. This additional
information
provides the basis for EGC's position that this finding is consistent
with a finding of very low safety significance (i.e., Green). 2.0 EGC'S POSITION ON NRC INSPECTION
REPORT CONCLUSIONS
The NRC Inspection
Report provides two statements
associated
with EC 619834 for which EGC is providing
clarification
and additional
analysis to demonstrate
that the Division 1 EOG would have performed
its safety function during the 24-hour PRA mission time without the EDG room ventilation
fan running. The two statements
are: Page 1of4 
Attachment
Exelon Generation
Company's
Position Concerning
the Significance
of Apparent Violation
EA-17-098 "The [NRG] inspectors
reviewed Evaluation 619834
and concluded
that the licensee had not provided a reasonable
basis to show the EOG would have been able to perform its function for the PRA mission time. Specifically, panel internal temperature
would have reached approximately
240°F, a point where some of the key components
would have been susceptible
to failure. Based upon this conclusion, the inspectors
continued
with the significance
determination." "The potential
to recover room cooling by opening doors to the diesel generator
rooms was added to the base model. NRG staff reviewed the licensee's
technical
analysis [EC 619834] which included room heat-up calculations
and component
testing and concluded
that if operators
opened doors to the room within 30 minutes after diesel generator
start and ventilation
fan failure there was adequate justification
to conc.lude
the diesel generator
mission would be met." The additional
analysis performed
refined the GOTHIC model to increase the accuracy of the analysis and reclassified
some components
as not needed for the EOG to continue to function (i.e., Critical).
EGC's position is that the additional
analysis provides reasonable
assurance
the EOG would have continued
to operate for the 24-hour PRA mission time without ventilation
fan operation
and without opening the rollup door and the personnel
door. Note that the limiting component's
temperature
margin for the case where the operators
opened the doors within 30 minutes under EC 619834 is 35°F. The limiting component's
temperature
margin obtained in the additional
analysis (without doors open), EC 620632, is 37°F. 3.0 COMPARISON
OF EC 619834 TO EC 620632 LIMITING TEMPERATURE
MARGINS EC 619834 provided the bases for the NRC's determination
that key components
would have been susceptible
to failure. In the NRC Inspection
Report, it states that panel internal temperature
could reach 240°F, a point where some of the key components
would have been susceptible
to failure. EGC reviewed EC 619834 and determined
that the panel where this temperature
could be reached is panel 1 DG01 JA with a resulting
internal temperature
of 244 °F. Table 4.3.1, "Critical
Devices," of EC 619834 provided the listing of the critical devices (category
1, 2 and 4) that were evaluated
along with a summary of the basis for EOG continued
functionality
under the bounding scenario.
In panel 1 DG01JA there were two critical devices, both of which were transformers.
EC 619834 indicates
that these devices will function at a temperature
13°F above the temperature
determined
in the analysis for that panel (i.e., 13°F margin). However, in EC 619834 the components
with the minimum temperature
margin of 11°F are located on 1 DG01 KA. The re-analysis, provided in the Enclosure (i.e., EC 620632), increases
the temperature
margin forthe critical components
in panel 1DG01JA from 13°F to 41°F. The re-analyzed
limiting components
continue to be located on 1 DG01 KA; their temperature
margin was increased
from 11°F to 37°F. Page 2of4 
Attachment
Exelon Generation
Company's
Position Concerning
the Significance
of Apparent Violation
EA-17-098
Thus, the re-analysis
performed
in EC 620632 at least triples the temperature
margin of the critical components
located in 1 DG01JA and on 1 DG01 KA from that of EC 619834 for the bounding case Loss of Coolant Accident I Loss of Offsite Power (LOCA/LOOP)
-Doors Closed case. 4.0 REFINEMENT
OF THE GOTHIC ANALYSIS EGG developed
an engineering
report that evaluates
the impact of refining the GOTHIC Model used in EC 619834 to develop a more realistic
best-estimate
prediction
of temperatures
within the Division 1 EDG room in order to determine
more accurate equipment
survivability
margin. EGG determined
that EC 619834 contained
accumulated
conservatism
in the GOTHIC v. 8.2 model that biased the peak panel temperatures.
EGG then re-evaluated
the room temperatures
by refining the GOTHIC analysis as described
below: 1. The revised analysis used the generator
heat load consistent
with vendor provided information
in lieu of 137%. 2. The panels within the room were modeled as enclosures (i.e., control volumes with thermal conductors
and flow paths) to determine
internal temperatures
in lieu of using the maximum temperature
the panel experiences
on the hottest portion (e.g., the top). 3. Credit for air gaps (e.g., gaps around doors, penetrations
to the outside, and other penetrations)
to the outdoors were modelled.
4. The engine combustion
air inlet piping was credited as a heat sink. 5. The GOTHIC model was re-benchmarked
to align to the test data more closely. 6. Outdoor air was modeled using a diurnal cycle and using a more representative
peak daytime temperature
during the exposure period. 7. For the air flow split associated
with the tank room exhaust fan (1VD02CA), a more realistic
air flow split was utilized.
When the model was refined and two of the limiting critical component's
temperature
limits were reevaluated, the resulting
minimum component
survivability
temperature
margin is 37°F. 5.0 EQUIPMENT
SURVIVABILITY
LIMITS REVIEW The Equipment
Survivability
List provided in EC 619834 identified
equipment
that is critical for the proper functioning
of the Division I EOG during its 24-hour PRA mission time. Under EC 620632 the critical component's
survivability
temperature
limits were reevaluated.
As identified
on EC 620632 Table, "Margin to Survivability
of Critical Components," the generator (G-1 ), exciter (G-2), and engine mounted governors (A9/A9a) survivability
temperature
limits were increased.
The generator
and exciter are the most limiting components
for exposed elevated temperatures.
The increase in their survivability
temperature
limits aided in the increased
margin of 37°F. Page 3of4 
Attachment
Exelon Generation
Company's
Position Concerning
the Significance
of Apparent Violation
EA-17-098
6.0 ADDITIONAL
RISK INSIGHTS As discussed
in EC 620632, temperatures
above -175°F are not reached in the
Doors Closed scenario until almost 20 hours into the event. During the LOOP-Doors
Closed scenario, room temperatures
remain less than 175°F during the 24-hour mission time. This provides additional
time for: 1. Restoring
functionality
to the ventilation
fan (and thus restoring
cooling to the EOG room). This is very likely, given that highly skilled personnel
will be onsite, a simple drawing review would identify the problem, given the chattering
relay, and that restoration
requires no more than the removal of control power fuses and manual fan breaker closure. 2. Opening area doors or providing
alternate
cooling (fans located in doorways, etc.). This "defense in depth" situation
provides multiple opportunities
for success and provides additional
confidence
that the EOG would have operated for the PRA mission time. 7.0 CONCLUSIONS:
The analysis (EC 620632) evaluated
the impact of refining the GOTHIC model for the purpose of generating
a more realistic
best-estimate
prediction
of temperatures
within the Division 1 EOG room in order to determine
equipment
survivability
margin. The refined analysis resulted in reduced room temperatures
and along with increased
equipment
survivability
limits resulted in an increased
survivability
margin for the limiting critical device(s)
for the LOCA/LOOP
-Doors Closed case from 11°F to 37°F. As described
in the Enclosure, the GOTHIC analysis is still judged to be biased slightly in the conservative
direction
and the uncertainty
in the analysis is judged to be less than 5°F. This uncertainty
is small relative to the bounding margin to the survivability
limits of 37°F noted above. EC 620632 demonstrates
that there is reasonable
assurance
that sufficient
margin exists between the environmental
temperatures
and the equipment
survivability
limits for the critical components
associated
with maintaining
the EOG functional
for the PRA mission time. As a result, using NRC's IMC 0609, Appendix A, Exhibit 2, this issue should be characterized
as Green. Therefore, after consideration
of this new information, the appropriate
classification
for the AV should be changed from White to Green. Page 4 of 4 
Enclosure
EC 620632, Evaluate Survivability
of Equipment
in the Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room Due to Failure of EOG Ventilation
Fan 1VD01CA 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO CLINTON POWER STATION Engineering
Change EC 620632 EVALUATION
EVALUATE SURVIVABILITY
OF EQUIPMENT
IN THE DIVISION DIESEL GENERATOR
ROOM DUE TO FAILURE OF EOG VENTILATION
FAN 1VD01CA HU CODE HIGH-3-2 RE: Eric Halverson 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO TABLE OF CONTENTS Description
Pages Title PaQe 1 Table of Contents 1 DesiQn ChanQe Authorization
and Approvals
2 Evaluation
Details and Review Forms (See Passport Topic Notes & Attributes)
Evaluation
Details -20 Attributes:
18 (total) * C-AA-102-F-01, Interdisciplinary
Form * CC-AA-102, F07, and FOB Design Attributes
* CC-AA-102-F-10F (PRA) * CC-AA-102-F-1
OF (Site Reg Assurance)
* CC-AA-102-F-10A (OPS) Attachments (See EC "notes" chicklet)
Attachment
1, KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1, R/03, Operability
of Class IE 267 Equipment
in DG Rooms as a result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Attachment
2, NAl-2007-004
Rev. 0, GOTHIC Analysis 254 Attachment
3, KCI 424-008-TSP-2
Rev. 0, Test Specification
for Determining
29 Component
Survivability
and Operation
in Ambient temperature
not to Exceed 245°F Attachment
4, Evaluation
of EPRI August 22nd, 2017 Notice, PT-082117-122, 1 Subject: 10 CFR Part 21 -Transfer of Information
Notice -GOTHIC-Code error related to thermal conductor
modeling could impact safety related components/applications 
Engineering
Change Print Date: 09/15/2017
EC Number : 0000620632
000 Status/Date
: ACTIVE 09/15/2017
Facility : CPS Type/Sub-type:
EVAL SYS 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
Page: EC Title: EVALUATION
OF EQUIPMENT
SURVIVABILITY
IN DG DIV. 1 ROOM WITH ELEVATED TEMPERATURES
1 Mod Nbr : 0000619834
KWl: NS KW2: KW3: KW4: KW5: Master EC : N Work Group : Outage : N Alert Group: WO Required : N Image Addr : Adv Wk Appvd: Alt Ref. : Auto-Advance:
y Priority : Caveat Outst: y Department
: Resp Engr : NIGEL R KEEN Location : Milestone
Date 010-AUTHORIZ
EC 06/16/2017
110-PREPARE
EC 07/26/2017
120-REVIEW
EC 08/01/2017
210-DEPT RVW-OP 07/28/2017
210-DEPT RVW-01 08/01/2017
210-DEPT RVW-03 07/31/2017
210-DEPT RVW-05 07/28/2017
300-APPROVE
EC 09/13/2017
630-HOLD 1 800-ATTR CLOSED Units Fae Unit CPS 01 Description
UNIT ONE Systems Fae System Description
PassPort KEENNR C130102 GANDMM RUSHRC SHELDA HABLAJ C073648 KEENNR CPS DG DIESEL GENERATOR
Affected Equipment
List Fae Unit Op Sys Di vision CPS 01 Equipment
DGNA lDGOlKA Component
E15 < Equip. Tag: lDGOlKA State: Reviewed?
Y Inst/Rm: Name : DIESEL GENERATOR
lA Temporary
: DEM Aprd Reqd Date: Exp Insvc Date: Expires On : Auto-Asbuild
: Discipline
: Name KEEN NIGEL HALVERSON
ERIC GANDHI MUKESH RUSH ROBERT SHELTON DALE HABLE ANTHONY HENRIQUEZ
AGUSTIN KEEN NIGEL Area System Class DG Minor Rev: Major Rev: Rev Trackable:
Y Inc: N N 06/08/2020
N Reg BJ:'.: ASSIGNED APPROVED APPROVED APPROVED APPROVED APPROVED APPROVED APPROVED MODIFIED CLOSED 
EC Number Status/Date
Facility Type/Sub-type:
CPS 01 Equipment
Component
Equip. Tag: Engineering
Change Print Date: 09/15/2017
0000620632
000 Exelon. ACTIVE 09/15/2017
CPS EVAL SYS 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
Page: 2 DG DGNA lDGOlKA Minor Rev: GOS < Major Rev: lDGOlKA State: Reviewed?
y Inst/Rm: Rev Trackable:
Y Inc : N Name : DIESEL GENERATOR
lA CPS 01 Equipment
DGNA 1DG01KA12
Component
ElS < Equip. Tag: 1DG01KA12
State: Reviewed?
y Inst/Rm: Name : GENERATOR
lA 12 CYL DIESEL CPS 01 Equipment
DGNA 1DG01KA16
Component
ElS < Equip. Tag: 1DG01KA16
State: Reviewed?
y Inst/Rm: Name : GENERATOR
1A 16 CYL DIESEL Reference
Documents
List Facility CPS Subfype DWGC Document MOl-1106 DG Minor Rev: Major Rev: Rev Trackable:
ENGINE DG Minor Rev: Major Rev: Rev Trackable:
ENGINE y y Inc: N Inc: N Sheet 006 Title: GENERAL ARRANGE-CONTROL AND DIESEL GEN BLDG GRADE FL PLAN EL 737 88MO CPS Title: Cross Ref. EC AR AS AS EC PROC ENGINEERING
References
Number 0000619008
03982792 03982792 03982792 0000619834
NSP CC-AA-309-101
TECHNICAL
EVALUATIONS
Sub-Number Description
EVALUATE SURVIVABILITY
OF lSXOlPA AND ASSOCIAT EOID: 1AP11E427X2-41A
MAKING LOUD CLICKING SOU 0700 Complete Root Cause Report (RCR) on this issue 4400 Evaluate DG room temperature
response for past EVALUATION
OF EQUIPMENT
SURVIVABILITY
IN DG DI 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Page 1 of20 UNIT: 01 SYSTEM: DGND TITLE: EVALUATE SURVIVABILITY
OF EQUIPMENT
IN THE DIVISION 1 DIESEL GENERATOR
ROOM DUE TO FAILURE OF EOG VENTILATION
FAN 1VD01CA 1.0 REASON FOR EVALUATION:
The purpose of this evaluation
is to document reasonable
assurance
of continued
operation
of the Emergency
Diesel Generator (EOG) for 24 hours during a failure of the Emergency
Diesel Generator (EOG) Ventilation
Fan 1VD01CA to start as described
below. This EC refines the GOTHIC model developed
in NAl-2007-003, R/2 and removes some of the conservatism
that was biasing the peak panel temperatures
more than required for reasonable
assurance.
The initial evaluation
done in EC 619834 showed 0::11&deg;F margin for the doors closed bounding case 10. The NRC in Ref. 27, enclosure
page 7, did not accept the EC 619834 doors closed cases as not providing
sufficient
margin to provide reasonable
basis for DG function during the 24 hour mission time. This EC 620632 subsequently
increases
the survivability
margin and provides additional
facts and assumptions
in support of a response to the Preliminary
White finding to establish
reasonable
assurance
of EOG operation without operator
action (i.e. doors closed) for the 24 hour mission time. This EC subsequently
supersedes
EC 619834. This EC also provides information
which may be used as input into PRA analysis to * assess the severity of the NRC findings, as applicable.
2.0 BACKGROUND
The following
event is documented
in IR 3982792 and the associated
Root Cause Analysis.
On 3/7/17 during Operator Rounds, the 'C' Area Operator heard a clicking sound coming from Unit Substation
1A (1AP11 E). The sound was coming from relay 427X2-41A, which was cycling every 10 seconds, which is also the design value for the delay timer associated
with the relay. 427X2-41 A (X2 relay) is an Agastat Time Delay Relay (TOR) that provides the signal to reset the Load Shed and Resequencing
Circuit for Diesel Generator
Room Vent fan 1VD01 CA. Troubleshooting
determined
that the 1VD01 CA fan was unable to respond to a demand signal following
an actual under voltage condition, resulting
in Division 1 Diesel Generator
being declared inoperable
on 03/09/2017.
The cycling of the X2 relay was caused by an interaction
between the X2 relay and relay 427X3-41A (X3 relay). The X3 relay had been replaced with a different
model relay in 2008 due to an obsolescence
issue. Replacement
on 03/11/2017
of the X3 relay with a Gould J13 relay (original
design) allowed the circuit to be restored to operable and exit the Emergency
Diesel Generator (EOG) 14 day LCO Action Statement.
The station is taking actions to 1. Determine
the maximum expected temperatures
for the room under LOOP/LOCA
and LOOP scenarios
with a loss of the room cooling function (this EC 620632) 2. Evaluating
equipment
in the room to confirm it would not result in an inadvertent
shutdown of the EOG within 24 hours (this EC 620632) 3. Evaluate potential
recovery actions. The root cause analysis determined
that the X2 (Agastat)
relay, which would cause a failure of the 1VD01 CA fan to start during a loss of offsite power (LOOP), was replaced in May 2016. The impacts of variations
in the drop-out voltage of the relays used in this circuit were not previously
recognized.
The reduction
in drop out voltage operating
margin remained undetected
until occurrence
of the subject event. The time duration the Division 1 EOG was inoperable
was -10 months (between May 2016 and March 2017). 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Page2 of20 However, the X2 relay did not affect the function of the DG Oil Tank room fan 1VD02CA that would continue to run during a LOOP. This fan pulls in cooling air from the outside through various paths and provides some cooling to the DG room. 3.0 EVALUATION
SCOPE The scope of the technical evaluation
is to determine
the peak temperature
of the Division 1 EOG room after loss of room cooling fan 1VD01 CA for 24 hours. This mission time is required by the NRC Risk Assessment
of Operational
Events Manual (RASP) [Ref. 14]. The equipment
in the Div. 1 DG room is evaluated
at the elevated temperature
to determine
if they will impact continued
operation
of the EOG following
a loss of the Division 1 EOG room cooling. This evaluation
was performed
by * Using the GOTHIC Model, to determine
ambient heat-up temperature
* Determining
equipment
survivability
by performing
individual
equipment heat-up evaluations
and/or testing * Determining
operations
response to the EOG vent fan failure by performing
table top exercises
and a simulator
scenario.
Each of these items is evaluated
in the following
sections:
4.1 Evaluate the DG room temperature
through EOG room heat-up evaluations (GOTHIC) 4.2 Determine
survivability
for equipment
essential
for DG function by performing
individual
equipment
heat-up evaluations
or actual testing and comparing
the results to the area temperatures
calculated
above. 4.3 Determine
Operations
response to the EOG vent fan failure 4.0 DETAILED EVALUATION:
4.1 Evaluate the EOG functionality
through DG room heat-up evaluations (GOTHIC) As discussed
in section 2.0, the subject condition
would prevent normal operation
of the EOG room supply fan 1VD01 CA. The Division 1 EOG Room supply ventilation
fan 1VD01 CA would not auto or manually start to provide ventilation
to the EOG Room during an auto-start
of the EOG following
a LOOP scenario [Ref. 2]. Other equipment, including
the DG Oil Tank room fan 1VD02CA, was not directly affected by the issue and therefore
will operate normally [Ref. 5.c]. A heat-up evaluation
of the EOG room was performed, using GOTHIC computer code, to develop temperature
profiles of the room during the 24 hour PRA mission time to establish
baseline temperatures
to determine
the survivability
of the equipment
in the room. The GOTHIC code is general purpose software for transient
thermal hydraulic
analysis.
The GOTHIC model that was developed
was benchmarked
to actual test data from a recent EOG run. GOTHIC has been used in the nuclear industry for the following
items, among others [Ref. 6]: * Peak Pressure and temperature
response during design basis accidents
* ECCS gas bubble accumulation
and migration
* Equipment
environmental
qualification
* HVAC system performance
* Control room habitability
due to heat loads or dispersion
of toxic/radioactive
gases * Room heat-up analysis 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Page3 of20 The following
critical parameters
that affect EDG Room temperature
without the normal 77 ,000 CFM Diesel Room Ventilation (VD) air flow were modeled in the analysis:
1. Hot Metal surfaces, e.g. engine exhaust manifold, engine turbo 2. Warm Metal surfaces, e.g. engine block, cooling pipes 3. Generator
air cooling (i.e. heat load to the room) fan flow rates 4. Lighting 5. Engine exhaust pipe 6. Overall room air volume and temperature
initial conditions, outside air temperature.
7. Wall, Ceiling, Floor areas and materials
to absorb heat 8. Diesel oil tank room exhaust fan flow rate and distribution (i.e. dampers and duct configuration)
9. Personnel
door and rollup door size and location to evaluate natural circulation (for door open cases) 10. Control building temperature
initial conditions
through doors to hallway Locations
of interest in the EDG Room that are affected by temperatures
calculated
in the GOTHIC model are: Panels: * 1PL 12JA * 1PL92JA/1PL93JA
* 1DG01JA * 1DG06SA * 1DG01KA 12cyl * 1 DG01 KA 16cyl * Area: Near doors when opened On April 27, 2017, test data was taken during the normal DG monthly surveillance
at full load [Ref 1 O]: Outside air temperature, room initial temperature, Inlet and outlet temperatures
for the room, Inside room local air temperatures
at 4 places, at shoulder height 1. Near the roll up door (near panel 1PL12JA), 2. Near EDG Transformer
panel location129-AE (near 1DG01JA), 3. Near EOG air start skid (near 1 DG06SA) 4. DG General Area temperatures
Inlet and outlet temperatures
for the generator
with local cooling air velocities
SX (shutdown
service water) heat exchanger
inlet and outlet temperatures
Lube Oil temperatures
Generator
kWe Insulated
EDG engine exhaust pipe temperatures
Air compressors
run time. Thermography:
-Hot Metal surfaces, e.g. engine exhaust manifold at approximately
600&deg;F average [Ref. 23] -Warm Metal surfaces, e.g. engine block, cooling pipes at approximately
160&deg;F average [Ref. 23] The initial model was developed
by MPR based on design drawings and field walk-downs
as documented
in MPR calculation
0065-0061-CALC-001
[Ref. 7]. The model was refined in calculation
NAl-2007-003
[Ref. 3]. The model was further refined in calculation
NAl-2007-004
[Ref. 21]. Adjustments
were made to the GOTHIC model to facilitate
benchmarking
to the test results as follows. -Total heat load was adjusted to match the exit air temperatures
from the EDG room -There are variations
on hot metal temperatures
and warm metal temperatures
from the thermography.
The GOTHIC model split these into 2 groups, with representative
surface areas [Ref. 23], and solved for an appropriate
local heat transfer coefficient
that preserves
total heat load and local temperature
distributions. 
Clinton Power Station * EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Page4 of20 -Generator
metal was taking longer to heat up than engine block and engine exhaust manifold & turbo. Therefore, a slower ramp of heat addition was applied to the remaining
heat load representing
the generator.
-In the NAI model the surface temperature
for the warm engine area was conservatively
increased
from a weighted average of 167&deg;F [Ref. 23] to 172&deg;F and the surface temperature
for the hot engine area was conservatively
increased
from an average of -600&deg;F [Ref. 23] to 700&deg;F (which bound thermography
uncertainties
per Reference
23). -The NAI model also included more refined sub-division
of the Division 1 EOG room. -Refer to Reference
3 and 21 for discussion
of additional
enhancements
of the model. Several different
EOG operating
scenarios
with doors closed and doors open (roll-up and entrance doors) were evaluated
in Reference
3. Based on Reference
3 the bounding cases that constitute
the limiting room heat-up for the Division 1 Diesel Generator
room following
a loss of ventilation
include: Case Operating
Scenario Door Position 10 LO CA/LOOP Closed 12 LOOP only Closed 7 LO CA/LOOP Open The analysis in Reference
3 contained
several conservatisms
that were biasing the peak panel temperatures
higher than required for reasonable
assurances, some of which were subsequently
removed in Reference
21, such as: 1. Approximately
137% of the theoretical
generator
heat load was used in the analysis.
2. Average panel temperatures
or internal panel temperatures
were not credited.
The maximum temperature
the panel experiences
on the hottest portion (e.g. the top) is applied to component
testing limits 3. No credit for air gaps in the room allowing hot air to escape, e.g., gaps around doors, penetrations
to the outside, and other penetrations.
4. Some cool surfaces not credited:
DG combustion
air inlet pipe 5. Conservative
application
of benchmark
penalty of 7&deg;F 6. Design basis 96&deg;F hot summer day outside air and no credit for 24 hour temperature
swings to -17&deg;F [Ref. 25] cooler at night 7. Diesel Oil Tank ventilation
fan flow of 3,020 CFM was conservatively
split at 50% from the EOG room and 50% from outside (calculated
flow from the EOG room was much greater than 50%). To refine the EOG room temperature, the GOTHIC model was refined by removing the conservatisms
listed above [Ref. 21]. The resulting
model was benchmarked
to the test data and the GOTHIC model conservatively (i.e. higher) calculated
the room area temperatures
by 1.6&deg;F to 7.4&deg;F as follows: Measured GOTHIC Calculated
Temperature
Location Description Temperature Temperature
Difference (oF) (&deg;F) [Ref. 21] (oF) 1 Near the Rollup Door 83.1 87.7 4.6 2 Near Transformer
Panel 87.5 89.1 1.6 3 Near Air Compressor
Panel 79 86.4 7.4 4 DG General Area 77.7 81.2 3.5 Note that the margin between the GOTHIC model and the test data exceeded the instrument
uncertainty
of approximately
0.54&deg;F [Ref.23] forthe fluke thermometers
that were used to measure the area temperatures, 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Page 5 of20 indicating
that the analysis was biased in the conservative
direction. The heat load from the GOTHIC benchmark
model was higher (conservative)
than the test results [Ref. 21]. The exhaust and inlet temperatures
were in close agreement
with the GOTHIC Benchmark
as shown in Figure 2 from Reference
21. Figure 2 -Comparison
of Supply and Exhaust Air Temperature (green line -s upply air temperature
measured during the DG su rveillance
test; yellow line -supply air temperature
input into the GOTHIC s imulation; red line -exhaust air temperature
measured during the DG surveillance;
white line -exhaust air temperature
calculated
in GOTHIC) Gothic Analysis Results: The GOTHIC analysis for loss of the Division 1 DG room HVAC for a 24 hour PRA mission time is documented
in Attachment
2. The refined model was used to re-analyze
the cases from the original analysis as Cases ?a, 10a, and 12a. Temperature
profiles are provided for each panel area located in the room for the cases in Attachment
2. A summary of the results are provided below from Reference
21, Table 5-3 for area temperatures
and Table 5-4 for internal panel temperatures
from the GOTHIC Analysis.
I J 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS (Ref. 21, Table 5-3] Maximum Area Temperature
(&deg;F) Out side the Panels Panel Case 7a Case lOa Case 12a LOOP-LB LOCA LOOP-LB LOCA LOOP Only Doors Open Doors Closed Doors Closed 1PL12JA 158 188 167 1PL92JN1PL93JA
139 182 157 lDGOlJA 160 193 172 1DG06SA 150 181 163 lDGOlKA 1 2cyl 156 186 165 lDGOlKA 16cyl 160 193 172 Near Doors at 2 Hours 148 NA NA (Ref. 21, Table 5-4] Internal Panel Temperature
(&deg;F) (Note: Does not include 23&deg;F panel temperature
rise whic h Panel is addressed
in th e eq uipment survivability)
Case 7a Case lOa Case 12a LOOP-LB LOCA LOOP-LB LOCA LOOP Only Doors Open Doors Closed Door s Closed 1PL12JA 148 181 160 1PL92JN1PL9
3JA 134 179 157 lDGOlJA 152 184 166 1DG06SA 142 176 160 lDGOlKA 12cyl 148 181 161 lDGOlKA 16 cy l 151 183 166 The improvement
from the original analysis [Ref. 3] for the hottest panel for each case based on cell temperatures
compares as follows [Ref. 21]: * Case ?a is 31&deg;F lower than Case 7 * Case 1 Oa is 28&deg;F lower than Case 10 * Case 12a is 43&deg;F lower than Case 12 Page 6 of20 It should be noted that the original [Ref. 3] Case 7, 10, and 12 models did not model a separate control volume for the panels. The comparison
provided is between the control volumes developed
in Reference
21 and the hottest cell temperature
reported in Reference
3 based on cell temperatures.
Compared to the results of Reference
3, the maximum temperature
of the hottest panel for each case based on internal panel temperatures
compares as follows: * Case ?a is 39&deg;F lower than Case 7 * Case 1 Oa is 37&deg;F lower than Case 10 * Case 12a is 49&deg;F lower than Case 12 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS P age 7 of20 Of particular
significance
is the fact that all the original Case 7, 10, and 12 simulations
predict closure of the fire dam p ers (at a set-point
of 165&deg;F) associated
with the modeled ductwork early in the simulation. Cases 7a and 12a do not predict closure of the fire dampers and Case 1 Oa predicts closure of the fi re dampers in the last 4 hours o f the simulation (Case 10 shows closure in the first 4 to 8 hours). As l ong as the dampers are open circulation
through the DG O i l Tank room via fan 1VD02CA will provide benefit to the Division 1 diesel generator
room. The dampers stay open for a much longer period of time as compared to the original cases in EC6198 3 4. Attachment
2 shows the resulting
temperature
profiles. Uncerta i nties in the GOTHIC Analysis: Although the new analys i s removed some of the conservatisms
noted above t h e model is still judged to be conservative. For example , the uncertainties
associated
with thermography
of +/-3.6&deg;F, or +/-2% [Ref. 23 & 24], would result in an uncertainty
of-4&deg;F for the engine warm areas a n d -14&deg;F for the hot areas of the engine. These were accounted
for in the analysis by increasing
the engine a rea temperatures
by -5&deg;F for the warm area and -100&deg;F for the hot area as follows: 1. Uncertainties
associated
with thermography
potentially
under predicting
the hot and warm engine temperatures
were eliminated
by: a. Increasing
the hot engine temperatures
by -100&deg;F from the average temperature
of 600&deg;F determined
during the test (to 700&deg;F). b. Increasing
the warm engine temperatures
by -5&deg;F from the average temperature
of 167&deg;F determined
during the test (to 172&deg;F). c. These two increases
resulted in an associated
bias of -4&deg;F conservative
based on the sensitivity
analysis performed
in NAl-2007-004, Attachment
C, page C12 , Case 10b [Ref. 21]. The model was benchmarked
to the test data and the GOTHIC model calculated
the area temperatures
conserv a tively by 1.6&deg;F to 7.4 &deg;F. The margin between the GOTHIC model and the test data exceeds the instrum e nt uncertainty
of approximately
0.54&deg;F [Ref. 23 & 24] for the fluke thermometers
that were used to measur e the area temperature, showing that the analysis was biased in the conservative
direction. As part of the analysis, a sensitivity
run was also performed
assuming an increase in delta T of 0.8&deg;F [Ref. 23], which covers the SRSS of the instrument
uncertainty
of t he fluke thermometers
used to measure air temperatures
of the EOG room supply and return air. The resulting
area and internal panel temperatures, for the bounding LOCA/LOOP
case, increased
by 3&deg;F to 5&deg;F, respectively , based in NAl-2007-004 , Attachment
C , Page C 1 2 , Case 10c [Ref. 21]. The phy s ics for this scenario predominantly
involve heating of air in a large room and heat transfer from the engine a nd generator.
The majority of the heat is from t h e generator
which is an accurate value at a given load. Th e other major heat load is from the engine and was validated
during benchmarking. The analysis method s used by GOTHIC for this type of scenario are based on well understood
and accepted concepts and equatio n s. It is not affected by more complicated
mecha n isms such as those that predominate
in a contain m ent LOCA analysis. The analysis for this type of scenario would subsequently
be very accurate. A measure of the uncertainty
or bias can be determined
by looking at the conservatisms
in the model and the results a s reflected
by the benchmarking. Even though several conservatisms
were removed in the updated analysis , conservatisms
such as the use of elevated temperatures
for the warm and hot area temperatures
remained. Also , the hottest day night temperatures
of the entire 10 month relay failure period was conserv a tively used. Another indication
of the conservat i sms in the model can be seen Reference
21, Table 5-2 where the vendor supplied engine heat load at design area temperatures
(122&deg;F) was compared to the benchm a rk based value (i.e. for engine = 6.15 Btu/hr-ft2). The GOTHIC based heat load at 122&deg;F was 19% conserv a tive [Ref.21] relative to the vendor supplied value. The resulting
model was subsequently
benchm a rked to the test data and as one might anticipate
the GOTHIC model over-pred i cted the area temperatures
by 1.6&deg;F to 7.4&deg;F. As such the analysis was judged to still be sufficiently
conservative
such that addition a l uncertainties
need not be applied to the analysis approach. 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS P age 8 of 20 The overall uncertainty
based in instrument
accuracy investigated
in NAl-2007-004, Attachment
C, Case 10c [Ref. 21] as discussed
above , is therefore
expected to be less than approximately
5&deg;F which is small fraction relative to the margin to the survivability
limits as discussed
in the sections that follow. 4.2 Determine
equipment
survivability
by performing
individual
equipment
heat-up evaluations
or actual testing Electrical
Equipment:
The equipment
that is most susceptible
to failures that could cease DG function under elevated operating
temperatures
is electrical
equipment.
Elevated temperatures
can impact the functionality
of equipment
in several ways. Over time , elevated temperatures
can increase the degradation
of organic materials
in electrical
devices. Elevated temperatures
can also prevent voltage sensitive
devices (e.g., electrical
devices w i th coils) from picking up at desired voltages as it is an es t ablished phenomenon
of most electrical
circuits that the resistance
of a current path will rise as temperature
is increased, resulting
in an increase in the pick-up voltage (and subsequently
earlier drop-out)
of devices with coils. To determine
the scope of electrical
equipment
that needed to be evaluated, a review of the electrical
design drawings [Ref. 5 , E02s and E03s] was performed
and approximately
250 devices were identified
that were associated
with the EOG room and required additional
evaluation.
The detailed evaluation
of this equipment
is i ncluded in Attachment
1 of this EC. The detailed evaluation
considered
the function and the fa i lures modes of the devices to determine
those devices that could prevent the EOG from performing
its required function during the 24 hour mission time. For critical equipment
the threshold
temperatures
for survivability
was determ i ned based on evaluation
or testing. The panel temperature
rise (e.g. 23&deg;F for panel 1PL12JA) was also considered. The following
provides a summary of how critical equipment
was identified. Refer to Attachment
1 for additional
details. The Equipment
Survivability
List identified
equipment
that is critical for the proper functioning
of the Divis i on I Emergency
Diesel Generator.
The " Critical" components
were defined as devices whose failure due to exposure to elevated temperature
could prevent the EOG from performing
its function by, for example , direct tripping the EOG or causing an associated
device to trip the EOG. These components
are further divided into those components
classified
as " critical active" and " critical passive". The critical active components
are capable of direct tripping or causing a trip of the EOG. The critical passive components
are capable of indirect tripping of the EOG due to a passive failure (e.g. loss of continuity). The Equipment
Survivability
List was divided into five categories
based on function and criticality
of the components, and their ability to impact continued
operation
of the EOG as follows: 1. " Yellow"; this group of components
contains devices that can potentially
trip the EOG and are not blocked by the presence of a " LOCA bypass signal". The " LOCA bypass signal" is generated
when conditions
indicative
of a LOCA are detected or when manually activated
by operators.
This list i ncludes instruments
and supporting
devices designed for protection
of the EOG. There are a total of 35 components
in this group with 5 considered
" critical active" and zero " critical passive".
2. " Pink"; this group of components
contains devices that can potentially
trip the EOG but are blocked by the presence of a " LOCA bypass signal". This list includes instruments
and supporting
devices designed for protection
of the EOG. There are a total of 21 components
in this group with 5 considered "critical
active" and zero "critical
passive". 3. " Green"; this group of components
contains devices required for s t arting the EOG. After the EOG starts, these devices cannot provide any tripping function and will not be considered
as being affected by the effect of high temperature. There are a total of 42 components
with no " critical active" or " critical passive" function. 4. " Blue"; this group of components
contains devices that are required for power delivery or regulation. None of these components
can directly trip the EOG but, however , can cause a trip by one of the protecting
devices. There are a total of 38 components
with 11 considered
" critical active" and 10 " critical passive". 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Pag e 9 of20 5. " White"; this group of components
contains devices that have no direct impact to the EOG operation.
There are a total of 123 components
in this group with no "critical
active" or "critical
passive" function. In summary, 21 components
have been classified
as "critical
active". Ten of these devices were functionally
tested at elevated temperatures, in direct support of this evaluation. Ten components
were classified
as "critical
passive". Each of these 31 components
where evaluated
considering
their failure modes and effects. For example: * Failure Mode: A typical electro-mechanical
relay failure mechanism
due to elevated temperature
is a " f ailure to energize".
* Effect: A normally de-energized
relay will not cause an EOG trip because the relay is already in the failed state. A descri p tion of the device function and potential
impact caused by their failure mechanism
is described
in the table below. Note that Agastat relays had been previously
identified
as having "low margin 1" to survivability
limits because, althoug h one had passed testing at 238&deg;F, another Agastat relay had failed at 245&deg;F. Per Failure Modes and Effects Analysis in Supplement
A, it has been determined
that these relays are no longer classified
as critical and have no impact on EOG operation
under the subject scenario. As a result, these components
were remove d from the Critical Components
List. The following
table summarizes
the results for the 21 components
that have been classified
as "critical
active" based on the evaluations
in Attachment
1. Attachment
1, Table V-2 provides the evaluations
for the 10 "Critical
Passive" components.
See Attachment
1 for additional
details on the methodology, design inputs, additional
references
and component
testing temperature
vs time profiles used to perform the evaluations. Evaluation
for Critical Active Components
COMPONENT
MFG PART NO. EVALUATION
1PL12JA-87
We s ting 290B225AIO
Current Diff e r e ntial Relay -This device will trip the EDG upon detection -house of a current differ e nce betw e en the generator
ground bus line and the 4160 V AC bus !Al. The relay was tested at 225&deg;F for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F for 8 hours. The relay did not provide a false trip. Therefore , the relay will not impact the normal operation
of the EDG at 245&deg;F. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F panel temperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in a room ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. 1PL12JA-A4
Wood-2301A Governor Control Assembly -This device controls the EDG speed, ward receiving
feedback from the magnetic pickup speed sensor (AS) and inputs from the speed adjustor (Rl l). The governor control assembly was tested at 207&deg;F for 24 hours, 225&deg;F for 8 hours and 245&deg;F for 8 hours. The output of governor control did not drift from the operating
condition (remained
at 0 YDC for 60HZ operation).
Therefore, the governor control will maintain the normal operation
of the EDG at 245&deg;F. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F panel temperature
rise, the governor control assembly will not impact the EDG normal operation
in a room ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. 1DG01KA-A9/A9a Wood-EGB-13P Actuator Governor (Mounted on Engine) -The function of the governor 1 The associated
equipment
ambient temperature
limit (Tiim;i) would be 238&deg;F minus the 23&deg;F measured panel (1PL12JA)
temperat u re rise or 215&deg;F. In the initial evaluation
done in EC 619834 the room ambient temperature
near the subject panel was 204&deg;F resulting
in 11&deg;F margin. 
Clinton Power Station COMPONENT
MFG PART NO. ward IDGOlJA-CTl
-6 GE,JCS-JCS-0/687X6 0 1PL12JA-32 GE 12GGP53BlA
1PL12JA-40 GE 12CEH51AlA
1PL12JA-51V-l ,-GE 12IJCV51A12A
2 ,-3 EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS EVALUATION
is to modulate and control engine fuel flow in accordance
with system lo a d. The Governor is located on the cool side of the engine (i.e. opposite the turbo chargers)
between the engine and th e jacket water cooler. It will therefor tend to be in a cooler area. Based on VTIP K2861-0002-B, R/87 (Woodward
EBG-Proportional
Governor Actuator , #82340C), the Governor is used on both steam and engine prime movers. Based on VTIP K2861-0002-B (page 9), the recommended
operating
range of the unit is up to 250&deg;F with synthetic
oil. Significant
aging of the oil in the Governor would not occur for minor excursions
in temperature
for a short duration in time. The Governor, once the engine was up and running at steady s tate (which occurs early in the event), is not heavily loaded (i.e. it does not need to move much) and therefor would not develop significant
heat in the oil. Based on NSED Standard MS-01.00, R/46 (Equipment
Lubrication
Standard), the device is to be lubricated
with MOBIL 1 SW-30. MOBIL 1 SW-30 is synthetic
oil that has better performance
in high heat applications
than conventional
motor oils (Attachment
0). Therefore, the governor would be expected to operate for short periods of time (less than 6 hours) at the end of the scenario at elevated ambient temperatures
(-250&deg;F) with MOBIL 15W-30 lubricant.
Current Transformers (CT) -These current transformers
provide current signal to various protecting
devices such as the Current Differential
Relay, Overcurrent
Relay, Reverse Power Relay, Loss of Field Exciter, and Governor.
CT's are robust devices that have no electronic
components. Under the scenario by the time the room sees significant
heating the EDG will be functioning
properly at a steady state and significant
challenge
would not be expected. The CT insulation
was aged at 257&deg;F. The function
of the devices depends on the integrity
of the insulation
system. The CT insulation
was aged at 257&deg;F and functionally
tested before and after aging. Accounting
a panel temperature
rise of 23&deg;F, the component
will function at 234&deg;F room ambient temperature.
Reverse Power Relay -Th e function of this device is to s hut down the EDG upon detection
of reverse power to prevent motorizing
the generator.
Th e relay wa s tested at 225&deg;F for 24 hour s and 245&deg;F for 8 hour s. The rel a y did not provide a fal s e trip. Therefore, the relay will not impact the normal op e r a tion of the EDG at 245&deg;F. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F Panel temperature
rise for pan e l 1PL12JA, the relay will not impact th e EDG normal op e ration in a room ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. Los s of Excitation
R e lay -The function of thi s d e vic e i s to s hut down th e EDG upon d e tection of loss of ex c it a tion on the generator.
The relay w as tested at 225&deg;F for 24 hours followed with an expo s ure to 245&deg;F for 8 hours. Th e relay did not provide a false trip. Therefore, the relay will not impact the normal operation
of the EDG at 2 45&deg;F. Accountin g for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
ri s e for panel IPL12JA, th e relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in a room ambient temperature
of 222 &deg;F. Voltage Restrained
Ov e rcurrent R e lays -The function of th e se device s is to s hut down the EDG upon detecting
over c urr e nt condition. Th e r e lay wa s test e d at 225&deg;F for 24 hour s followed by 245&deg;F for 8 hour s. The relay did not provide a false trip. Therefore, th e relay will not impact th e normal operation
of the EDG at 245&deg;F. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F Page 10 of20 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Page 11 of20 COMPONENT
MFG PART NO. EVALUATION
Panel temperatur
e ri s e, the relay will not impact the EOG normal operation
in room ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. 1PL12JA-Al Basler SR8A2B01B3A
The device regulates
the EOG output voltage and takes input from CTs and PTS and A2 (Series Boost Option) and AlO (Under Frequency
and Over Voltage Assembly). The voltage regulator
was tested at 225&deg;F for 24 hours followed by 245&deg;F for 8 hours. The voltage regulator
performed
its de s ired function and did not provide any fal s e trip signal to the EOG throughout
the 32 hours of test run. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F Panel temperature
rise , the voltage regulator
will not impact the EOG normal operation
in a room ambient temperature
of 222 &deg;F. 1PL12JA-A2
Basler 90-3 7100-100 Series Boost Option -The function of this device is to boost the exciter voltage to maintain rated voltage during EOG operation.
This device has passive components
such as resistor s , capacitors, transformer
and inductive
coil. As the components
were aged at 257&deg;F for -44 days [Ref. SQ-CL0070]
and were functionally
tested before and after aging and there are no moving parts and electronics, the device will function for an operating
temperature
of 257&deg;F. Accounting
for cabinet temperature
rise of 23&deg;F, this device will be functional
at a panel ambient temperature
of 234 &deg;F. 1PL12JA-Al0
Basler 9-1051-00-100
The device detect s under frequency
and over voltage conditions
and provides feedback to Al (voltage regulator)
regulate the voltage. The UFOV was tested at 225&deg;F for 24 hours followed by 245&deg;F for 8 hours. The UFOV performed
its desired function and did not provide any false trip signal to the EOG throughout
the 32 hours of test run. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F Panel temperature
rise, the UFOV will not impact the EOG normal operation
in a room ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. lDGOlJA-CCT GE JCS-0/687X6 The current transformer
provides line current input to the Al voltage regulator.
CT's are robust devices that have no electronic
components.
Under the scenario by the time the room sees significant
heating the EOG will be functioning
properly at a steady state and significant
challenge
would not be expected. The function of the devices depends on the integrity
of the insulation
system. The CT insulation
was aged at 257&deg;F for -93 days [Ref. SQ-CL0046J and functionally
tested before and after aging. Accounting
a pan e l temperature
rise of23&deg;F, the component
will function at a room ambient temperature
of234&deg;F. lDGOIJA-CTI0-11
Basler BE-02463-001
The current transformers
provide line current input to the series boost option (A2). CT's are robust devices that have no electronic
components. The CT insulation
was aged at 257&deg;F for -82 days [Ref. SQ-CL0055].
The function of the devices depends on the integrity
of the insulation
system. Accounting
a panel temperature
rise of23&deg;F, the component will function
at a room ambient temperature
of234&deg;F. 1DG01KA-Gl/G2 IDEAL Generator
and The Generator
provides 3875KW at 4160 volts. The limiting material in Exciter the generator
is judged to be the insulation. The Insulation
is rated for 155&deg;C (Class F). The minimum thermal life of Class F insulation
is more than 1000 hours at 200&deg;C operating
temperature (NUMARC 87-00, Rv. 01). The temperature
rise at full load is 70&deg;C (See Section 5.12 of Ref. Vill.2). Based on TODI-CPS-17-025, the peak load on the EOG during the LOCA/LOOP
case is 3721.2 KW and the peak load for the LOOP case is 3334.8 KW. The EOG is rated for 3900 KW continuous
rating (OWG E02-1AP12, Sheet 031, Rev. J), the corresponding
load for the LOCA/LOOP
and the LOOP is 95.4% and 85.5% respectively. *==
Therefore, the generator
temperature
rise at 95.4% rated load is 63.7&deg;C [70*0.954*0.954
= 63.7&deg;C]. Assuming the same temperature
rise, the 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS P age 12 of20 COMPONENT
MFG PART NO. EVALUATION
generator
will be expo se d to 173.7&deg;C when operating
in an ambient temperature
of230&deg;F (110&deg;C) [i.e., ll0&deg;C + 63.7&deg;C = 1 73.7&deg;C). The generator
temperature
will be 18.7&deg;C above its long term rating of 155&deg;C. However, th e generator
i s rated for 20,000 hours of operation
at 155&deg;C and this life will be reduced by a factor of 3.66 using the 10&deg;C rule for a long term life of more than 227 day s. Therefore
for a short term operation
of 1 day, the impact on the generator
thermal cap a bility wh e n operating
at 230&deg;F is negligible.
The minimum thermal life of 1000 hours at 200&deg;C from the NUMARC 87-00 report also exceed s the EDG thermal stress for 1 day by a large margin. Rotating Bru s hless Exciter -The function of the brushle s s exciter i s to maintain a nearly constant voltage of 4160 volt out of the gener a tor through elimination
of brushes, collector
rings and carbon dust. The insulation
degradation
due to high temperature
has been evaluated
to be the limiting parameter
of interest.
Insulation
is rated for 155&deg;C (Class F). The minimum therma l life of Cla ss F insulation
is more than 1000 hours at 200&deg;C operating
temp e rature (NUMARC 87-00, Rv. 01). The temperature
rise of the exciter is 80&deg;C (See S e ction 5.11 of Ref. Vill.2). The insulation
life is 20000 hours at 155&deg;C. For an operating
environment
of230&deg;F (110&deg;C), the exciter temperature
will reach 190&deg;C. The life at this temperature
is 1767 hours (73 days) using 10&deg;C rule. Therefore
for a short-term operation
of I day, the impact on the exciter thermal capability
when operating
at 230&deg;F is negligible. The minimum thermal life o f 1000 hours at 200&deg;C from the NUMARC 87-00 report also exceeds the Exciter thermal stress for I day by a large margin. (See Attachment
I , KCI Evaluation
Report). 1PL12JA-Kl5 P&B MDR137-8 The relay protects the CCT on lo s s of power by shorting the CCT terminals. The relay shorting also can prevent the CCT output to Al (voltage regul a tor). The tested relay was aged at 225&deg;F energized
at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed by 245&deg;F while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hour s. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not s hort circuit throughout
the 32 hours of test run. Accounting
for a 23 &deg;F panel t e mperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in a room ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. lDGOlJA-PTl, PT2 GE JVM-3/643X92 The potential
transformers
provide input to the voltage regulator (Al). PT's are robust devices that have no electronic
components. Under the scenario by the time the room sees significant
heating the EDG will be functioning
properly at a steady state and significant
challenge
would not be expected.
The function of the devices depends on the integrity
of the insulation
system. The PT insulation
was aged at 257&deg;F for 87 days [Ref. SQ-CLD016]
and functionally
tested before and after aging. Accounting
a panel temperature
rise of 23 &deg;F, the component
will function at a room ambient temperature
of234&deg;F. lDGOUA-Tl
Basler BE-13487-001 Voltage Regulator
Power Transformer
-This transformer
provide voltage information
signal to the UFOV assembly (AlO). Voltage transformers
are robust dev i ces that have no electronic
components
Under the scenario by the time the room sees significant
heating the EDG will be functioning
properly at a steady state and s ignificant
challenge
would not be expected. The function of the devices depends on the integrity
of the insulation
system. The insulation
was aged at 257&deg;F for -82 days [Ref. SQ-CLD079]
and functionally
tested before and after aging. Accounting
a panel temperature
ri s e of23&deg;F, the component
will function at a room ambient temperature
of 234&deg;F. Additional
details are provided in the EOG Survivability
tables in Attachment
1. 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS P age 13 o f 20 4.3 Determine Operations response
to the EOG vent fan failure The failu r e of the Division 1 VD fan to start was presented
to Operations
crews once in the simulator
and tabletopped t w ice. The simulator
performance
had members of multiple crews due to Operations
staffing being aligned f o r the upcoming refueling
outage. All 3 times , the decision was made to open the roll up door and personn e l door to the hallway for Division 1 EOG room. The Shift Operations
Superintendent (SOS) question e d some of the crew members separately
and got responses
from individuals
that they would have , individually, come to the same conclusion.
There we r e d iscussions
concerning
the opening of doors that would cr e ate divisional
separation
issues, but no opposition
to opening the two doors of interest.
The Shif t Operations
Superintendent, therefore, has a very high degree of confidence
based on his discussions
with the crews that any crew would come to the same conclusion
to open the doors. Some of the crews a d dressed opening additional
doors but not all of the crews were willing to , so he was not comfortable
assumin g that additional
doors would be opened. The scenar i o is: * The plant is at power. * O ff-site power is lost. * D iv. 3 starts and is available
for loading * D iv. 1 DG starts but the vent fan does not * D iv. 2 DG does not start Operators
were united in leaving Division 1 DG running and opening the personnel
door and rollup door to the hallway to get whatever cooling it would provide while pursuing restoration
of the Division 2 DG. If Division 2 were op e rating , Division 1 would likely be shut down as the room heats up. In order t o establish
a reasonable
time to complete these actyions, a timed walkdown was performed. A qualified
Equipment
Operator/Safe
Shutdown Qualified (SSQ) Operator performed
the evolution
of opening the roll up door and blocking open the personnel
door to the hallway. The SSQ had to obtain tools and a blocking device a s part of the timed evolution.
These items are readily available
in the EOG rooms. A previously
licensed SRO walked the path that represents
the longest time it would take to get from the most remote place that the SSQ could be expected to be (D i vision 3 SX pump room) to the Division 1 EOG room. Ample cues would be present on a loss of off-site power to cause the SSQ to report to the EDGs as required. The combination
of these two evolutions
was under 30 minutes. 5.0 RE S ULTS AND CONCLUSIONS:
Results: The engineering
report in Attachment
2 provided an accurate prediction
of maximum area temperatures
for the subject scenario within the Division 1 EOG room in order to determine
equipment
survivability
margin. The refined analysis improved the precision
of the model which resulted in increased
margin to equipment
survivability
limits. The mar g ins to survivability
of critical components
can be determined
by comparing
the threshold
temperatures
from table V-1 and V-2 from Attachment
1 t o the applicable
panel or area temperatures
from Attachment
2 as shown in the following
Table. 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS P age 14 of20 Table -Margin to Survivability
of Critica l Components
Panel Comp T y p e Comp D esc ription TL imit T es t e d TLO CA T loo p LOCA LOOP (3) Margin Margin 1PL12JA R17 Al Voltage Regulator
222 y 181 160 41 62 1PL12JA UY AlO UFOV Assembly 222 y 181 160 41 62 1PL12JA xc A2 Series Boost Option 234 n 181 160 S3 74 1PL12JA UY Kl5 Relay , Power Failure Aux 222 y 181 160 41 62 1PL12JA CR2 Rectifier, Freewheeling
234 n 181 1 60 S3 74 1PL12JA MOC Rll Rheostat, Voltage Adju s t 234 n 181 160 S3 74 1PL12JA R4,5 (I) Resistor, Field Limitin g 150 ohm 500 n 181 160 319 340 1PL12JA Rl9 3 2 R everse Po we r Rel a y 222 y 181 160 41 62 1PL12JA R20 4 0 R e l ay, L o ss of Exc it at i on 222 y 181 1 60 41 62 1PL12JA R 2 0 51V-l V o l tage Re str ain e d O ve r c urr e nt Rl y 2 2 2 y 181 160 41 62 Ph. 1 1PL12JA R 2 0 51V-2 Volt age Re s trained Ov e r c urr e nt Rly 2 22 y 181 160 41 62 Ph. 2 1PL12JA R 2 0 5 1 V-3 V o l tage R es tr a in e d O ve r c urr e nt Rl y 2 2 2 y 181 160 41 62 Ph. 3 1PL12JA R20 87 Relay , Differential (Type SA-1) 222 y 181 160 41 62 1PL12JA 1SC-DG859
A4 Governor Control Assembly 222 y 181 160 41 62 lDGOIKA GI 3875KW 4160V Gener a tor 230 193 172 37 58 n (2) (2) lDGOIKA G2 E xc iter 230 193 172 37 58 n (2) (2) lDGOIKA 1DG03KA A9 Actuator Governor (Mounted on 250 193 172 S7 78 Engine) n (2) (2) lDGOlKA 1DG04KA A9/a Actuator Governor (Mounted on 250 193 172 S7 78 Engine) n (2) (2) lDGOlJA CCT Cros s Current Transformer
234 n 184 166 so 68 lDGOlJA CTlO-Current Boo s t Transformers
234 184 166 so 68 11 (I) n lDGOlJA PTl Potential
Transformer , Regulator
234 n 184 166 so 68 lDGOlJA PT2 Potential
Tran s former, Regulator
234 n 184 166 so 68 lDGOlJA TI Tran s former, Voltage Regulator
234 n 184 1 66 so 68 Power lDGOlJA PTl-Fuse , Potential
Transformer
225 184 166 41 S9 FOl Regulator
0.5A n lDGOlJA PTl-Fu s e, Potential
Transformer
225 184 166 41 S9 F02 Regulator
0.5A n lDGOlJA PT2-Fu s e , Potential
Tran s former 225 184 166 41 S9 FOl Regulator
O.SA n lDGOlJA PT2-Fu s e , Potential
Transformer
225 184 166 41 S9 F02 Regulator
0.5A n lDGOlJA TI-FOl Fuse, Transformer
Voltage 225 n 184 166 41 S9 Regulator
Power lDGOlJA TI-F02 Fuse , Transformer
Voltage 225 n 184 166 41 S9 Regulator
Power lDGOlJA TI-F03 Fuse, Transformer
Voltage 225 n 184 166 41 S9 Regulator
Power lDGOlJA CTl-6 CT, Differential
a nd Metering 234 184 166 so 68 (I) n 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Page 15 of20 Note 1-Multiple components
of the same type are combined together.
Note 2 -These temperatures
represent
GOTHIC calculated
room ambient temperatures
since components
are mounted outside panels. All other temperatures
are internal panel temperature.
Note 3-Tlimit is the maximum GOTHIC calculated
ambient temperature
that the equipment
can tolerate and is = equipment
qualified
temperature
minus panel temperature
rise of 23&deg;F (typically)
for critical components
that are inside panel 1PL 12JA and 1DG01JA. Conclusions:
1) Margins to the survivability
limits for critical devices increased
from Ref. 3 to Ref. 21 as follows: a) The margin for the LOCA/LOOP-
Doors Closed (case 1 Oa) increased
from ;:::11&deg;F to ;:::37&deg;F i) The new margin of 37&deg;F for the bounding door closed case (1 Oa) exceeds the margin of 35&deg;F for the LOCA/LOOP-Door
Open case (7) that was determined
in the original evaluation
[Ref. EC 619834] ii) The worst case margin for critical equipment
that is located inside panels (1PL12JA & 1 DG01 JA) was 41&deg;F. The worst case margin for critical devices that were recently tested in support of this evaluation
was also 41&deg;F iii) Note that the ambient temperatures
for the LOCA/LOOP-
Doors Closed at the end of approximately
20 hours was similar to the LOOP-Doors
Closed at 24 hours. (1) The resulting
margins (58&deg;F) shown below for the LOOP Case would therefore
be applicable
for the LOCA/LOOP
case for approximately
20 hours, with significantly
elevated temperatures
present for only the last 4 hours of the scenario due to closure of the dampers at 165&deg;F. (2) It is expected that the operators
will open the roll-up door or the fan will be able to be started, within 20 hours, well before peak temperatures
are reached, by performing
corrective
maintenance
{for example by pulling a fuse to the suspect relay) as directed by the ERO. b) The margins to the survivability
limits for the LOOP-Doors
Closed (case 12a) increased
to ;:::sa&deg;F c) Although it is expected that the dedicated
SSQ Operator(s)
will open the Division 1 EOG room doors when it is recognized
that the HVAC has failed or when the area is becoming uncomfortably
warm, even if the operators
fail to open the roll-up door and personnel
access door the Division 1 EOG will meet its mission time. 2) The overall uncertainty
in the Ref. 21 analysis is judged to be less than 5&deg;F, based on sensitivity
runs performed
in NAl-2007-004, Attachment
C, which is small relative to the bounding margin to the survivability
limits of 37&deg;F noted above. The results demonstrate
that the margin between the expected maximum local area temperatures
in the diesel generator
room after 24 hours for the subject scenario results in a local temperature
much lower than the component
survivability
limits for critical devices. The margin is sufficient
to conclude that the diesel generator
will in fact continue to operate successfully
for the entire PRA mission time without fan cooling or any operator action. The equipment
survivability
margin was calculated
in a manner that addresses
uncertainties, and therefore
provides "reasonable
assurance" of diesel generator
operation
for the desired time period. Based upon the survivability
analyses provided, it can be concluded
that the increased
likelihood
of diesel generator
failure due to room heat-up is in fact virtually
zero, even with the doors closed for the entire mission time. The robust nature of the diesel generator
and supporting
components
ensures its operation
for the duration of the PRA mission. 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Page 16 of20 In addition opening the roll up and entrance doors or restoring
functionality
to the VD Ventilation
fan (and thus restoring
normal cooling to the diesel generator
room) prior to reaching relatively
high temperatures (at -20 hours) are both highly likely, given that dedicated
operators
will be present in the EDG room and additional
highly skilled personnel
will be onsite to assist with fan recovery.
Note that opening of doors is a very simple activity and fan restoration
requires no more than the removal of control power fuses, and manual fan breaker closure. These provide additional
measures of defense in depth, thereby providing
extensive
assurance
that the diesel generator
will operate for the PRA mission time. The combination
of analysis and actual station conditions
and responses
virtually
eliminates
a risk level above baseline for the condition
described
and the associated
safety significance
is therefore
very low (i.e. Green). 6.0 REFERENCES:
1. IR398792 1AP11 E427X2-41A
Making Loud Clicking Sound 2. RCA 3982792 Root Cause Analysis 3. NAl-2007-003, Rev. 2 4. KCI Test Plan 424-008-TSP2
Rev. 0 5. Drawings E02 and E03 Series a. E02-1 DG99, Sheet 1 through 35 b. E02-1AP12, SHT 19 c. E02-1VD99, Sheet 1 & 4 d. E03-1DG01JA
e. E03-1DG01KA, Sheet 1-3 f. E03-1 FP99, Sheet 30 & 45 6. EC 619008 Rev. 0 Section 4.1.1 7. MPR Calculation
0065-0061-CALC-001, Rev. 0, 5/22/17, "CPS Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room Heat-up Evaluation
due to Loss of Ventilation." 8. Cardox video location \\Cpsmsfs01\medialib\Video\SYSTEMS\CO-C02
& GENERATOR
PURGE 9. CPS Procedure
3403.01, Diesel Generator
HVAC (VD) 10. TODl-CPS-17-016, CPS Transmittal
of Design Information
11. Calculation
01 FP11, RIO 12. KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1, Rev. 0, Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan 13. Drawing FL-22176-2
Sht. 10 14. NRC Risk Assessment
of Operational
Events (RASP) Handbook, Volume 1, Internal Events, Revision 2.0, January 2013. 15. Passport Data for Equip Tags (Fire Damper Fusible Link 165&deg;F): a. TIMD030 b. TIMD033 c. TIMD090 d. TIMD200 e. TIMD202 16. Qualification
Reports a. EQ-CL027 b. EQ-CL004 c. SQ-CLD70 d. SQ-CLD79 e. SQ-CLD16 f. SQ-CLD55 17. Drawing 2903-RUS-16 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Page 17 of20 18. Drawing M10-2903 19. USAR table 8.3-3 20. K2861-0002A-A, R116 21. NAl-2007-004, Rev. 0 22. TOOi CPS-17-0041
Rev. 0, CPS Transmittal
of Design Information
23. TOOi CPS-17-0042
Rev. 0, CPS Transmittal
of Design Information
24. NRC Questions
and Responses
emailed 7/14/17, supplemented
7/17/17, and 7/18/17 25. ASHRAE Fundamentals, 2001 26. REP-424-008-RP1, Rev. 3, Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan 27. NRC letter EA-17-098
to Mr. Bryan C. Hanson (Exelon} dated August 14, 2017, "CLINTON POWER STATION-NRG
INSPECTION
REPORT 05000461/2017009
AND PRELIMINARY
WHITE FINDING," Adams Accession
Number ML 17226A321.
7.0 SUPPLEMENTS
AND ATTACHMENTS:
Supplements:
A. Evaluation
of Agastat Timing Relays Used in the EOG Division I. B. Assessment
of Impacts per CC-AA-102
Attachments
The following
are located in the passport "Notes" chicklet:
1. KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1, Rev. 3, Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan 2. NAl-2007-004, Rev. 0, "Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Room Uncertainty
Evaluation" 3. KCI Test Plan 424-008 TSP-2, Rev. 0, 'Test Specification
for Determining
Component
Survivability
and Operation
in Ambient Temperature
not to Exceed 245&deg;F" 4. Evaluation
of EPRI, August 22nd, 2017, Notice PT-082117-122, Subject: 10 CFR Part 21 -Transfer of Information
Notice -GOTHIC -Code error related to thermal conductor
modeling could impact safety related components/applications 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Page 18 of20 Supplement
A: Evaluation
of Agastat Timing Relays Used In The EOG, Division I. The Agastat timing relays provide time delay for different
types of control functions.
In the application
of the EOG control system, there are various uses of the Agastat timing relays, but none of them can be considered
critical for the proper functioning
of the EOG. There are three different
configurations
of Agastat timing relays: One in category 1 (Yellow) One in category 2 (Pink) One in category 4 (Blue) Category 1 AGASTAT TIMING RELAY (K41) provides a 2-second window to open the contact of relay K41X to remove the tripping signal for the over speed trip solenoids (L03 and L03A). The solenoids
L03 and L03A trip the mechanical
over speed trip mechanism
on both engines (12 cyl and 16 cyl). The purpose of the Agastat timing relay is to remove the tripping signal after 2 seconds because the over speed trip mechanism
latch up closed and will not require the presence of any signal to remain closed. Should the Agastat fail to energize, the tripping signal will still reach the over speed trip solenoids
through the normally close contact of the Agastat relay and carryout the intended function of the over speed actuation
switches (S9 and S9A). Note that under the subject scenario the EOG is running correctly
and at steady state well before significant
room heat-up occurs and therefor an over speed condition
is not postulated.
Category 2 AGASTAT TIMING RELAY (K5) provides a 50 seconds time delay to allow the various engine systems to stabilize
at their normal operating
levels. After the 50 seconds time delay lapses, the following
protecting
devices will be able to trip the engine upon detection
of abnormal condition:
Low Oil Pressures (S19, S19A), and High Coolant Temperatures (S25, S25A). Should the Agastat timing relay fail after the engine is operating, these four devices will not be able to trip the EOG. However, the failure of the Agastat relay by itself will not trip the EOG. Note that these four devices are among the various instruments
that are bypassed by the presence of a LOCA bypass signal. They have also been evaluated
for the expected room temperatures
during the subject scenario.
Category 4 AGASTAT TIMING RELAY (K6) provides a 1.5-second
time delay to allow Field Flashing.
Field Flashing is required to ensure that sufficient
residual magnetism
will exist to allow the generator
to build up voltage during startup. Relay K6 also allows remote adjustment
of engine speed during startup. Since these functions
are required only during startup when the EOG room temperature
is still low, there will be no impact to the EOG operation
under the subject scenario at elevated room temperatures. 
L Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Page 19 of20 Supplement
B: Assessment
of Impacts per CC-AA-102, Design Input and Configuration
Change Impact Screening.
If no impacts exist, state so. The purpose of this evaluation
is to provide reasonable
assurance
of continued
EOG operation
for the 24 hour mission time following
a failure of the Division 1 DG Room Cooling Fan 1VD01CA to start on a LOOP signal. It may also be used to develop inputs for PRA analysis to address the severity of an NRC finding relating to the failure of the Division 1 DG Room Cooling Fan 1 VD01 CA to start on a LOOP signal. Therefore
there are no configuration
changes made as a result of this evaluation.
The CC-AA-102
checklist
will be used as a guide to determine items
that are evaluated
for the PRA analysis.
4.1.4.1 -IDENTIFY Basic SSC Functions
The design functions
of the Division 1 DG Room Cooling System are described
in USAR Section 9.4.5.1 and subsequent
sub-sections, "Each diesel-generator
facility ventilation
system is designed to limit the maximum -temperature
to 130&deg;F corresponding
to a summer design outside temperature
of 96&deg;F in the diesel-generator
room." 4.1.4.2/4.1.4.3
-IDENTIFY Configuration
Change safety classification
and Seismic Classification.
This evaluation
serves to provide reasonable
assurance
of operation
of the EOG for a condition
that is no longer in place (i.e. historical).
It is subsequently
classified
as non-safety
related and non-seismic.
4.1.5 -PROVIDE the performance
requirements
and design conditions (including
margin) of the SSC needed to evaluate the change from the existing to the modified systems, structures, or components:
The 1VD01 CA fan is required to supply cooling flow to the Division 1 DG room to maintain room temperature
below 130&deg;F for reliable operation.
However, due to the relay failure, the fan was not able to perform this function.
This evaluation
determines
the temperature
in the Division 1 DG room with no room cooling and evaluates
if the associated
equipment
in the room can still function for 24 hours following
loss of room cooling. 4.1.9 -DETERMINE
changes required to existing Design Analysis or new parameters
that require new calculations
or calculation
revisions
that are used to assess the acceptability
of a system or a component
function in meeting various physical requirements.
Much of this evaluation
is based on calculations
from vendors including
Zachary Group, MPR Associates
and KCI. These inputs are not intended to be design basis analyses, but instead to inform the PRA model. 4.1.11 -IDENTIFY any Failure Effects requirements.
The root cause evaluation
determined
that the failure of the Division 1 DG Room Fan to start was caused by the failure to recognize
the variations
in the dropout voltage and associated
impacts of the relays used in this circuit. 4.1.14 DETERMINE
environmental
conditions
and impacts. The Division 1 DG room temperature
due to the failure of the room fan to start is determined
via GOTHIC analysis as described
in Attachment
2. 
Clinton Power Station EC 620632 RIO EVAL DETAILS Page 20 of20 4.1.18 -DETERMINE
if the Configuration
Change may affect the existing Probabilistic
Risk Assessment (PRA). Mitigating
System Performance
Index (MSPI} Basis Document PRA content and shutdown risk models by using the screening
checklist
in CC-AA-102-F-04.
Since the information
in this evaluation
will be used to address the severity of an NRC finding and may be used as input to risk evaluations, the PRA group will review this evaluation.
See 4.1.42 for Interfacing
Department
reviews. 4.1.19-EVALUATE if System Operational
Requirements
have changed. System operational
requirements
have not changed. However, operator actions to mitigate the loss of room cooling event are described
in this evaluation.
4.1.33 IDENTIFY Mechanical
System Characteristics
where design limits are placed on the mechanical
properties
of a system or component.
The Division 1 DG Room temperature
on loss of cooling is determined
via GOTHIC analysis as described
in Attachment
2. In addition, the function of each affected component
is described
in this evaluation.
4.1.35 -IDENTIFY Electrical
requirements
where limits are placed on the electrical
properties
of a system or component.
The functions
of the Division 1 DG room equipment
are described
in the KCI Report in Attachment
1. 4.1.36 -IDENTIFY Instrument
and Control requirements.
including
digital technology
requirements.
The instruments
located in the Division 1 DG room are described
in this evaluation.
4.1.42 -DETERMINE
Interfacing
Department
Impact of the Configuration
Change, such as Operations, Plant Engineering, Training (including
Plant Simulator}.
Maintenance.
Reactor Engineering, Radiation
Protection
and others (see CC-AA-102-F-10A
through 10H} There are no configuration
change impacts; the following
interfacing
department
reviews are performed:
Risk Assessment (PRA), Electrical
Design Engineering, Operations, and Regulatory
Assurance.
J 
Engineering
Change EC Number Facility Type/Sub-type:
Attributes
00006.2063.2
CPS EVAL SYS Attribute
Sub-category:
Attribute
Name CC-AA-102-F-01
CC-AA-102-F-07
CC-AA-102-F-08
CC-AA-10.2-F-lOA
CC-AA-102-F-lOF
CC-AA-102-F-lOF
000 DAR Value COMP COMP COMP OPS-COMP PRA -COMP SITE REG ASS -COMP Print Date: 09/11/.2017
Exelon. Page: 1 PassPort Date C13010.2 07/25/2017
C130102 07/25/2017
C13010.2 07/25/2017
GANDMM 08/01/2017
GANDMM 08/01/2017
GANDMM 08/01/2017 
Engineering
Change 000 Print Date: 09/11/2017
.,;;li!/llS1J!!
EC Number Facility Type/Sub-type:
0000620632
CPS EVAL SYS Exelon, Page: 2 Attributes
Attribute
Sub-category:
EVAL Attribute
Name Value PassPort Date HUMAN PERFORMANCE
RISK CODE HIGH-3-2 C130102 07/25/2017
Attribute
Note Text Risk Rank of HIGH-3-2 requires an augmented
review, "Independent
Review by Station" This was satisfied
by a set of independent
reviews. 1. DG room heat-up analysis (Gothic analysis)
performed
by Zachery with inputs from MPR contained
in NAI-2007-003, Rev. o, "Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Room Heat-up Evaluation" was independently
reviewed by Chris Brennan. No fatal flaws were identified.
2. Evaluation
package (EC 619834, Rev. 0), "Evaluation
of Equipment
Survivability
In DG Div. 1 Room with Elevated Temperatures" was independently
reviewed by Corporate
Reg. Assurance, Pat Simpson. No fatal flaws were identified.
Since EC 620632 Supersedes
EC 619834 Ranking is same. This EC only enhances to show margin & Oigin Methodlogy
is unchaged, therefore, no addtional
reivew required. 
Design Attribute
Review (DAR) Page 1of5 CC 0 AA*102*F*01
Revision O IDENTIFY THE APPLICABILITY
OF THE FOLLOWING
TO THE DESIGN CHANGE. WHEN A TOPIC IS DETERMINED
TO BE APPLICABLE, THEN PLACE THE APPLICABLE
TOPIC INFORMATION
IN THE DESIGN CHANGE. IF THE INFORMATION
IS INSTALLATION-RELATED, THEN PLACE THIS INFORMATION
IN THE INSTALLER
INSTRUCTIONS (ATTACHMENT
C IN CC-AA-103).
IF NOT INSTALLATION-RELATED, THEN PLACE THE TOPIC INFORMATION
IN A SEGREGATED
DESIGN CONSIDERATION
SECTION, OR WITHIN THE DOCUMENTATION
REQUIRED BY THE PROCEDURES
GOVERNING
A PARTICULAR
ATTRIBUTE.
OPTIONAL FIELDS "TRACKING
OF ACTION" AND "REFERENCES" ARE AVAILABLE
FOR NOTATION BY THE PREPARER IF DESIRED TO ASSIST THE PREPARER IN MANAGING THE ACTIVITY.
' Engineering
Change Number: 620632 Revision Number: 0 Section Design Change Attribute
App Ii Tracking of References
cable Action (optional)
4.1.4.1 IDENTIFY Basic SSC Functions
181 See Design Considerati
on -. Summary in EC (DCS) 4.1.4.2 IDENTIFY Configuration
Change safety 181 SeeDCS classification.
4.1.4.3 IDENTIFY Seismic Classification
of the SSC. SeeDCS 4.1.5 PROVIDE the performance
requirements
and SeeDCS design conditions (including
margin) of the SSC needed to evaluate the change from the existing to the modified systems, structures, or components.
4.1.6 DETERMINE
the design requirements
necessary
D NIA to facilitate
periodic surveillance
testing and acceptance
testing that is necessary
for the Configuration
Change being considered.
4.1.7 DETERMINE
the Codes, Standards, and D NIA Regulatory
Requirements
applicable
to the Configuration
Change. 4.1.8 IDENTIFY PWR Sump GL 2004-02 Program D NIA impacts PWR sites only 4.1.9 DETERMINE
changes required to existing Design D NIA Analysis or new parameters
that require new calculations
or calculation
revisions
that are used to assess the acceptability
of a system or a component
function in meeting various physical requirements.
4.1.10 If Redundancy, Diversity
and Separation
D NIA requirements
are identified
or affected, then REVIEW the original design basis as well as any subsequent
modifications.
4.1.11 IDENTIFY any Failure Effects requirements.
[ZJ NIA (See CC-AA-102
Attachment
12) 
Design Attribute
Review (DAR) Page 2 of 5 Engineering
Change Number: 620632 Section Design Change Attribute
4.1.12 IDENTIFY Fire Protection
and Appendix R Safe Shutdown requirements, by using the "Screening
for Approved Fire Protection
Program (AFPP) Impact'', CC-AA-102-F-02.
NFP A 805 Units -IDENTIFY the impact on NFP A 805 requirements
by using CC-AA-102-F-02, "Screening
for Approved Fire Protection
Program (AFPP) Impact". 4.1.13 DETERMINE
any Material requirements, such as material grade, product form, compatibility
with existing or other new materials, galvanic interaction
between dissimilar
metals, special welding material requirements, critical properties, performance
characteristics, alternative
materials
as well as any Material Suitability
reguirements
such as compatibility, electrical
insulation
properties, protective
coating, corrosion
resistance, mechanical
insulation
etc. necessary
for the Configuration
Change. 4.1.14 Determine
environmental
conditions
and impacts. Also see EN-AA-103.
4.1.15 DETERMINE
if Environmental
Qualification (EQ) of equipment
is affected. (see CC-AA-102-F-03)
4.1.16 REVIBW the Operating
Experience
databases
through the INPO Internet Site or equivalent
in accordance
with Pl-AA-115:
4.1.17 DETERMINE
if the configuration
change may affect the existing INPO Consolidated
Data Entry (CDE) database.
4.1.18 DETERMINE
if the Configuration
Change may affect the existing Probabilistic
Risk Assessment (PRA), Mitigating
System Performance
Index (MSPI) Basis Document PRA content, and shutdown risk models by using the screening
check.list
in CC-AA-102-F-04.
NFPA 805 Units -PERFORM a review of the configuration
change for impact on the Fire PRA per ER-AA-600-1068.
[NFP A-805 Site Risk Management
Engineer]
4.1.19 EVALUATE if System Operational
Requirements
have changed. 4.1.20 IDENTIFY any Human Factors requirements.
CC*AAc102-F-01
Revision 0 Revision Number: 0 App Ii Tracking of References
cable Action {optional)
D NIA D NIA See DCS D NIA D NIA D NIA SeeDCS NIA D NIA 
Design Attribute
Review (DAR) Page 3 of 5 Engineering
Change Number: 620632 Section Design Change Attribute
4.1.21 IDENTIFY procedure
changes per direction
in CC-AA-102-F-09.
4.1.22 IDENTIFY any changes or additional
training requirements
for various departments, per direction
in CC-AA-102-F-09.
4.1.23 CONSIDER the functional
and physical system interface
requirements, including
the effect of cumulative
tolerances
between the subject system or component
and adjacent or related support systems, structures, and components
that may have been affected by the Configuration
Change. 4.1.24 DETERMINE
specialized
layout and arrangement
requirements.
4.1.25 DETERMINE
if the Radiation
Protection/
ALARA programs are affected by review of changes that affect any of the following
during normal or post accident conditions:
Radiation
sources; changes affecting
controlled
radiation
areas; primary coolant fluid systems (Cobalt Materials);
contaminated
systems; radiation
monitoring
systems; HV AC Systems which could transport
airborne contaminants;
change or alter shielding. (see CC-AA-102-F-05)
4.1.26 DETERMINE
the need for walkdowns
to look at accessibility
to the work area(s) and any special installation
considerations
that need to be addressed
during design development.
4.1.27 DETERMINE
Accessibility
for maintenance, repair and In-Service
Inspection (ISI) and In-Service Testing (IST), and the conditions
under which these activities
will be performed.
4.1.28 DETERMINE
handling, storage, cleaning, and shipping requirements, as well as transportability
requirements
for items which require special handling during transit from supplier to site, from site to vendor (for repair), or from site receiving
to final placement
in the plant. 4.1.29 DETERMINE
the effect of the Configuration
Change on existing Emergency
Plan or environmental
and discharge
monitoring
that are used to prevent undue risk to public health and safety. CC*AA-102-F-01
Revision 0 Revision Number: 0 App Ii Tracking of References
cable Action (optional)
D NIA D NIA D NIA D NIA D NIA D NIA D NIA D NIA D NIA 
Design Attribute
Review (DAR) Page4 of 5 Engineering
Change Number: 620632 Section Design Change Attribute
4.1.30 DETERMINE
Industrial
Safety requirements
such as restricting
the use of dangerous
materials, hazardous
chemicals, escape provisions
from enclosures, pertinent
OSHA requirements, and grounding
of electrical
systems. 4.1.31 DETERMINE
impact on nuclear fuel, core components, core design, reactivity
management, criticality
control and accountability
of nuclear materials
as well as transient
and I or accident analysis, by using CC-AA-102-F-06:
4.1.32 DETERMINE
Load Path requirements
for installation, removal, and repair of equipment
and replacement
of major components.
4.1.33 IDENTIFY Mechanical
System Characteristics
where design limits are placed on the mechanical
properties
of a system or components.
4.1.34 IDENTIFY Chemistry
requirements
where limits are placed on the chemical properties
of a system or component
based upon safety, reliability, ALARA, economics, or other considerations.
4.1.35 IDENTIFY Electrical
requirements
where limits are placed on the electrical
properties
of a system or component.
4.1.36 IDENTIFY Instrument
and Control requirements, including
digital technology
requirements.
4.l.37 IDENTIFY Security requirements
such as site monitoring, alarm systems, vehicle barrier systems, security and security lighting.
4.1.38 IDENTIFY Civil/Structural
requirements
where design limits are placed on the structural
properties
of a SSC such as equipment
foundations
and component
supports.
4.1.39 If the Configuration
Change adds, relocates, or alters Seismic Category I mechanical
and/or electrical
components
then ENSURE that the Seismic Dynamic Qualification (SDIQ) of the components
has been addressed
per CC-AA-320-001. CC*AA*102&deg;F*01
Revision 0 Revision Number: 0 Appli Tracking of References
cable Action (optional)
D NIA D NIA D NIA IZl SeeDCS D NIA IZl SeeDCS fZ1 SeeDCS D NIA D NIA D NIA 
Design Attribute
Review (DAR) Page 5 of 5 Engineering
Change Number: 620632 Section Design Change Attribute
4.1.40 DETERMINE
Personnel
Requirements
and Limitations
such as the need for trade specialists
and engineering
experts as well as support personnel, such as Radiation
Chemistry
technicians, welding technicians
with special expertise, use of specific contractor
or station procedures
for installation
or the need for mock-ups for training, installation, or operation.
4.1.41 LIST special procedures
and installation
specifications
that apply, but are not part of the normal installation
procedural
direction.
4.1.42 DETERMINE
Interfacing
Department
impact of the Configuration
Change, such as Operations, Plant Engineering, Training (including
Plant Simulator), Maintenance, Reactor Engineering, Radiation
Protection
and others. (see CC-AA-102-
F-lOA through lOH) 4.1.43 CONSIDER impact on active License Renewal Projects.
4.1.44 REVIEW the proposed changes for conformance
with requirements
of any applicable
Nuclear Electric Insurance
Limited (NEIL) Insurance
Standard, or other appropriate
insurance
standards.
4.1.45 DETERMINE
the impact of the design change on System Vulnerability.
4.1.47 IDENTIFY changes to the plant, both permanent
and temporary, that potentially
impact the switchyard
or the interconnected
transmission
system. Communication
and coordination
of these plant changes with the applicable
transmission
entities is a requirement
of the mandatory
NERC Reliability
Standards.
4.l.48 IDENTIFY potential
impacts on safety related motor operated valves and the Exelon MOY Program. 4.1.49 DETERMINE
the effect of the Configuration
Change on Dry Cask Storage. 4.4 Configuration
Control Activities-
Use of CC-AA-102-F-07 4.5 Determination
of Program Impact -Use of CC-AA-102-F-08
CCa.A.A-102-F-01
Revision 0 Revision Number: 0 Appli Trackang of References
cable Action (optional)
D NIA D NIA SeeDCS D NIA D NIA D NIA D NIA D NIA D NIA [81 
Checklist
of Configuration
Activities
Page 1of3 CC-AA* 102-F-07 Revision 0 Engineering
Change Number: 620632 Rev: Q Applic Prior To -Configuration
Activity able Operation
Procedure
Related Trackine info EC Install Attribute
No * Update Tech Spec or license LS-AA-101
Amendment
No: CONF: TECH SPEC No Update Tech Spec Bases LS-AA-101-1000
No As UFSAR Change Notice Required by LS-AA-107
LS-AA-107
Change Request No: CONF: UFSAR CHANGE NOTICE No Technical
Requirement
Manual Plant Specific Liston AOL CONF: TECH REQMT MANUAL No Desim Bases Database Requirements
CC-AA-207
Input Form CONF: DB DATABASE INPUT No Update Desiim Bases Topical Reports and System Documents
CC-AA-207
Liston AOL No * Update of Critical Control Room Drawings CC-AA-103, -104, -List onADL CONF: CCRD HUNG 112,NF-AA-101
No Additional
Walkdown (s) CC-AA-106-1001
Place applicable
walkdown information
in CONF: DESIGNERS
package WALKDOWN No Affected Equipment
List (AEL) or Component
Record List (PIMs) (CM-6) Plant Specific CONF: EQUIP DATA (NON RTC UPD) No Update setpoint and calibration
database (IISCP or other) Plant Specific No Electrical
Load Monitoring
Plant Specific ADL & Input fonn I CONF: ELMS INPUT No Cable Management
Database (raceway and conduit) program Plant Specific ADL & Input form I CONF: SLICE INPUT No * Update of Nuclear Fuels/Corporate
Engineering
Safety Analysis Accident Analysis (See CC-AA-102-F-lOG)
CC-AA-102-F-lOG
CONF: NF ACC ANLS 
Checklist
of Configuration
Activities
Page2of3 Engineering
Change Number: 620632 App lie Prior To Configuration
Activity able Operation
Procedure
Related Trackin2 info No Plant Barriers Affected Plant Specific No * Offsite Dose Cale Manual CY-AA-l 70-300 No Update VETIP Manuals CC-AA-204
Rev: CC-AA-102-F-07
Revision O ft EC Install Attribute
CONF: BARRIER PROGRAM CONF: ODCM *-CONF: VETIP MANUALS No Update Fire Protection
Documentation
Package and Appendix R CC-AA-209
Change Request No: CONF: FPR CHANGE REQUEST No * Update Use of Locks on Valves OP-AA-l08-l03
Proc on ADL; Equip Data AEL No * Equipment
Tagging & Labeling (CM-6) OP-AA-116-101
Label Request CONF: EQUIP TAGS/LABELS
No Address Open Operability
Determinations
OP-AA-108-
l 15 CONF: OP DETERMINATION
No Update or Create Equipment
Bill of Material SM-AA-300-1002
BOM End Use Analysis CONF: EQUIP BOM No Plant Simulator
Change Required?
TQ-AA-306
cbNF: Si:Ml1LATOR
CHANGES No Functional
Equipment
Group (FEG) Update ER-AA-200
CONF: FEG UPDATE (D046) No Clearance
and Tagging Program (C/O Models Updated) Operations
CONF: TAG OUT C/O MODEL CHANGE No Equipment
PMT Requirements
Plant Specific J CONF: EQUIP PMT CHANGES I (D041) No Other items CONF:MISC 
Checklist
of Configuration
Activities
Page3of3 CC-AA-102-F-07
Revision 0 Engineering
Change Number: 620632 Rev: !! App lie Prior To Configuration
Activity able Operation
Procedure
Related Tracking info I EC Install Attribute
No Emergency
Response Data System Data Point Librarv Update (EROS) EP-AA-123
or EP-OC-Notify NRC within 30 days of change to I CONF:ERDS
123 for Oyster Creek library files No Update Cyber Security Assessment
Database CC-AA-601
I CONF: CYBER SECURITY No List of equipment
being replaced to Site Supply Chain Manager SM-AC-4006
I CONF: LIST EQUIP REPLACED No List of all protective
relays that affect the reliability
of the Bulk Electric System per NERC Reliability
Standard LS-AA-129
I CONF: LIST PROT RELAYS Notes: "*" Indicates
that it must be completed
prior to operation
if the activity is required.
PassPort only-Track
completion
via EC ADL/AEL (if ADL/AEL is applicable)
or EC INSTALL Attribute.
* J 
Checklist
for Programs Impact Page 1of3 CC-AA-102-F-08
Revision 0 Engineering
Change Number: 62032 Rev: !! Applica Prior to Program Activities
hie Operation
Procedure
Related Tracking info EC Install Attribute
No *If Tech Predefine
Surveillance
Program Spec Plant Specific PROO: PREDEFINES (SURV, PM) No Performance
Centered Maintenance (PCM) Program ER-AA-200
PROO: PREDEFINES (SURV, PM) No Create or Revise PCM Template ER-AA-200
PROG: PCM TEMPLATE No Maintenance
Rule Program ER-AA-310
PROG: MIR PROGRAM No Instrument
Calibration
as part of Predefine
Surveillance
Program Plant Specific PROO: INSTR SURVEILLANCE
No Check Valve PM Program ER-AA-400-1001
PROO: CHECK VAL VE PM No MOVProgram
ER-AA-302
PROG:MOV No AOVProgram
ER-AA-410
PROO:AOV No EQ Program CC-AA-203
PROG:EQ No ASME Section XI or O&M IST Program ER-AA-321
PROO:IST No ASME Section XI or O&M ISI Program ER-AA-330
PROO: ISI (ASME XI) No Boric Acid Corrosion
Control (BACC) Program (PWR only) ER-AP-331
PROO: BACC (PWR ONLY) No BWR Reactor Internals/IVVI (BWR only) ER-AB-331
PRbG: RX INTERNALS
No ASME III Code and Auth. Nuclear Inspector/In-service
Inspector
Review Plant Specific PROO: ASME CODE I ANII REVIEW No B&PV Inspection
Program (including
State Boiler Inspector
Notification)
Plant Specific PROO: IDNS VESSEL/RV
TEST No ASME VIII Relief Valve Testing Plant Specific PROO: IDNS VESSEURV TEST 
Checklist
for Programs Impact Page 2 of 3 CC-AA-i 02-f-08 Revision O Engineering
Change Number: 62032 Rev: Q Applica Prior to Program Activities
ble Opeiration
Procedure
Related Tracking info EC Install Attribute
No Non ASME Piping & Comp Support Inservice
Inspection
Program Plant Specific PROO:ISI (NON ASME) No Other Programs that may be Tech Spec required but plant specific Plant Specific PROO:MISC
No Flow Accelerated
Corrosion
Program ER-AA-430
PROG: FAC (FLOW ACC CORROSION)
No Fatie:ue and Transient
Monitoring
Program ER-AA-470
PROO: FATIG & TRANS MON No Lead Shielding
Program Plant Specific PROO; LEAD SHIELDING
No Update & Maintenance
of Consolidated
Data Entry (CDE) database PI-AA-115-1004
PROG:EPIX
No * Emergency
Operating
Procedures (EOP)/Severe
Accident Management (SAM) Program/Emergency
Action Levels (EAL) and/or EAL Thresholds
Plant Specific PROO: EOP/SAM No OL-89-13 Program for Heat Exchangers
and Piping ER-AA-340
PROO: GL 89-13 HX No Environmental
Review EN-AA-103
PROG: ENVIRON SERV NOTIFIED No Stearn Generator
Program ER-AP-420 .PROO: STEAM GENERATOR
No PRA URE Completion, MSPI Basis Document and PRA Model Update Section 4.1.18 of PROO: PRA MODEL CC-AA-102
No Fire PRA Model Update or aouroval per ER-AA-600-1068
to defer Section 4. l.18 of NFPA 805 plants only. CC-AA-102
No Coatings Program CC-AA-205, ER-AA-330-
PROO: CONTAINMENT
COATINGS 008, and MA-AA-716-016
No Appendix J of IOCFRSO ER-AA-380
PROO: IOCFRSO APPENDIX J No Thermal Performance
ER-AA-510
PROG: THERMAL PERFORMANCE
No I Emergency
Preparedness (EP) Programs EP-AA-120
PROO: EP PROGRAMS 
Checklist
for Programs Impact Page 3of3 CC-AA-102-F-08
Revision 0 Engineering
Change Number: 62032 Rev: Q Applica Prior to Program Activities
hie Operation
Procedure
Related Trackin2 info I EC Install Attribute
No I Buried Piping and Raw Water Corrosion
Program ER-AA-5400
I PROG: BP AND RWC No I Cyber Security Program per Requirements
of 10 CFR 73.54 CC-AA-600
I PROO: CYBER SECURITY No I BOP HX Program ER-AA-340-2000
I PROO: BOP HX No I Control Room Envelope (CRE) Habitability
Program Plant Specific I PROO: CRE HABITABILITY
No I Lubricants
Program MA-AA-716-006
I PROG: LUBRICANTS
No I Surveillance
Frequency
Control Program (SFCP) Plant Specific IPROG:SURVEILLANCEFREQ
CONT No I Cable Program ER-AA-300-150
I PROO: CABLE No I Aging Management
Program ER-AA-700-1002 I PROG: AGING No I Diverse And Flexible Coping Strategies (Flex) And Spent Fuel Pool Instrumentation
Program CC-AA-118
I PROO: FLEX . Notes: "*" indicates
that it must be completed
prior to operation
if the activity is required.
PassPort only -Track completion
via EC ADL (if ADL is applicable)
or EC INSTALL Attribute. 
There is no impact to plant operations
or procedures
created by this EC. KAL 
Operations
Department (including
Radwaste)
Configuration
Change Review Checklist
Page 1of2 Configuration
Change Document No: 620632 CC-AA*102-f-10A
Revision O This review covers activities
performed
during the design phase of a Configuration
Change, including
initial meetings, walkdowns, detailed design development, and identification
of impacts on other station programs and areas of responsibility.
Review Requirements
Check 1. The impact on the station equipment, changes in equipment
responses, and changes in operator [gl responses
for different
scenarios
have been discussed.
As the representative
of the Operations
department, I fully understand
the impact, including
training needs, upon my department
and concur that my concerns have been adequately
addressed.
2. I have confirmed
the identified
Programs, Procedures
and Training requirements
are complete, or initiated
tracking for completion, for my department
in accordance
with forms listed below: * CC-AA-102-F-07
-Configuration
Activities (Tracking
No.
* CC-AA-102-F-08
-Programs (Tracking
No. ___ __, * CC-AA-102-F-09
-Procedures
and Training (Tracking
No.
3. Acceptance
criteria for Post Maintenance
Testing and any special tests required to adequately
JZI demonstrate
system operability
following
implementation
of a Configuration
Change have been specified.
4. ALARA for operation
has been considered
in the design. [8] 5. Appropriate
component
labeling is used in the design package, including
drawings.
[gj 6. The Configuration
Change does not interfere
with operation
of existing nearby equipment.
181 7. There are no operating
procedure
changes required by this Configuration
Change that [8] introduce
new susceptibility
to water hammer or hydraulic
transients
that might result in impacting
plant operation.
8. The design can be implemented
within constraints
of plant operation/mode.
This includes an operation
assessment
of all affected systems and interfacing
structures, systems and components
during the mode(s) in which the design change is being implemented.
9. The configuration
change has been reviewed and any new vulnerabilities
as defined in ER-AA-181 2004 and the impact of the design change on the identified
existing vulnerabilities
has been assessed.
10. Impact of this configuration
change on Operator Aids has been reviewed and appropriate
actions have been or will be taken (refer to OP-AA-115-101
and the Operator Aid Log) 11. The configuration
change has been reviewed and impacts on margin are understood.
The design summary adequately
addresses
known margin impacts. (refer to ER-AA-2007)
12. Changes impacting
the Clearance
and Tagging Program have been identified
and are being tracked. 
Operations
Department (including
Radwaste)
Configuration
Change Review Checklist
Page 2 of 2 Configuration
Change Document No: 620632 CC*AA-102*f-10A
Revision O 13. Impact on configuration
control and potential
configuration
control event precursors
have been IZ! identified
and are being addressed.
14. Impacts on FLEX, B.5.b, SBO, flooding protection, fire protection, and other issues requiring operator manual actions have been identified
and are being addressed.
15. Changes to type of M&TE used and test methodology
have been evaluated
per MA-AA-716-040. 16. Impacts to and additions
ofTCA's and TSA's have been processed
per OP-AA-102-106.
My department
has reviewed the Configuration
Change Document (or appropriate
contents)
and understands
the impact regarding
my department's
operations, procedures, and programs.
All Configuration
Change support activities
required of my department
have been identified.
Bob Rush Date: 07/31/17 Operations
Department
Representative (Print/Sign) (For PassPort, see EC Milestone
210-DEPT RVW-OP for Operations
Dept signature
authentication)
Return the completed
form to the Configuration
Change Preparer or Sign Electromcally
in FCMS, PIMS, or PassPort Nigel Keen 
Configuration
Change Review Checklist
for Use by Other Departments
Page 1of1 Configuration
Change Document No: 620632 -PRA CC-AA-102mfm10F
Revision o This review covers activities
performed
during the design phase of a Configuration
Change, including
initial meetings, walkdowns, detailed design development, and identification
of impacts on other station programs and areas of responsibility.
Review Reguirements
I. My department
has participated
in the Configuration
Change process (scope meetings, walkdowns, impact review, etc.) as required and concurred
with the proposed Configuration
Change; and fully understands
the Configuration
Change implications
for my department.
2. I have confirmed
the identified
Programs, Procedures
and Training requirements
are complete, or initiated
tracking for completion, for my department
in accordance
with the forms listed below: CC-AA-102-F-08 -Programs (Tracking
No. URE previously
written ) CC-AA-102-F-09
-Procedures
and Training (Tracking
No. ___,N'-'-A=-=----) 3. Other Considerations
required to be completed
in support of the Configuration
Change: NA 4. The configuration
change has been reviewed and impacts on margin are understood.
The design summary adequately
addresses
known margin impacts. (refer to ER-AA-2007)
My department
has reviewed the Configuration
Change document (or applicable
contents)
and understands
the impact regarding
my department's
operations, procedures, and programs.
All Configuration
Change support activities
required of my department
have been identified.
Affected Plant Department:
Risk Management
Anthony Hable Date: 07-31-17 Affected Plant Department
Representative (Print/Sign) (See EC MileStone
210-DEPT RVW-01 for Other Dept signature
authentication)
Return the completed
form to the Configuration
Change Preparer or Sign Electronically
in FCMS, PIMS, or PassPort This EC provides evidence that the diesel will not fail during mission time, which implies no risk increase over baseline from the SDP conditon. 
Configuration
Change Review Checklist
for Use by Other Departments
Page 1 of 1 Configuration
Change Document No: 619834-SITE REG. ASSURANCE
CC-AA-102-f-10F
Revision 0 This review covers activities
performed
during the design phase of a Configuration
Change, including
initial meetings, walkdowns, detailed design development, and identification
of impacts on other station programs and areas of responsibility.
Review Requirements
1. My department
has participated
in the Configuration
Change process (scope meetings, walkdowns, impact review, etc.) as required and concurred
with the proposed Configuration
Change; and fully understands
the Configuration
Change implications
for my department.
2. I have confirmed
the identified
Programs, Procedures
and Training requirements
are complete, or initiated
tracking for completion, for my departll!ent
in accordance
with the forms listed below: CC-AA-102-F-08-
Programs (Tracking
No. ___ ) CC-AA-102-F-09
-Procedures
and Training (Tracking
No. ) 3. Other Considerations
required to be completed
in support of the Configuration
Change: NA 4. The configuration
change has been reviewed and impacts on margin are understood.
The design summary
adequately
addresses
known margin impacts. (refer to ER-AA-2007)
My department
has reviewed the Configuration
Change document (or applicable
contents)
and understands
the impact regarding
my department's
operations, procedures, and programs.
All Configuration
Change support activities
required of my department
have been identified.
Affected Plant Department:
Reg Assurance
Dale Shelton Date: 6/21/17 Affected Plant Department
Representative (Print/Sign) (See EC MileStone
210-DEPT RVW-01 for Other Dept signature
authentication)
Return the completed
form to the Configuration
Change Preparer or Sign Electronically
in FCMS, PIMS, or PassPort Nigel Keen 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 1 of 267 \KCI ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 Phone {630) 515*2650 * FAX (630) 515*2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Prepared by/Date
Anup Behera Septem.ber
15, 2017 Reviewed by/Date Page 1of83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 2 of 267 \l<CI ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515*2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan REVISION HISTORY Revision#
Issued Date Purpose of Revision Prepared By Reviewed Approved By By 00 6/21/2017
Initial Release AnupBehera
Badar Peter Brunsgaard
Hussain Incorporated
Fauske Test Report FAI/17-0667
and TOD! CPS-17-0044. Identified
critical components
Badar 01 7/28/2017
required for EDG operation
for Anup Behera Hussain Peter Brunsgaard
normal power generation.
This revision completely
supersedes
Revision 00 in its entirety.
Re-evaluated
the temperature
02 8/17/2017
threshold
of the generator, exciter Anup Behera Badar Peter Brunsgaard
and governor actuator.
Added Hussain Attachment
T. 03 9/15/2017
Revised to eliminate
appendices
not AnupBehera
Badar Peter Brunsgaard
providing
any technical
information.
Hussain Page 2 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 3 of 267 <l<CI ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan TABLE OF CONTENTS Section Page Revision History ................... ...............................................................................................
2 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................
3 I Purpose ........................................................................................................................
5 II Summary of the Review .............................................................................................
5 III Background
.................................................................................................................
5 IV Evaluation
Parameters
...............................................................................................
6 V Operability
of Class lE Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of Loss of Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan ............**********..................................*.......**...***.............................
7 V.1 General Discussion
on Impact of Elevated Temperature
on Equipment
..............
7 V.2 Determining
the Impact of Elevated Temperatures
by Tests .................................
10 V.3 Impact of Elevated Temperatures
on the CPS Emergency
Diesel Generator
...... 11 VI Operability
of Diesel Generator
Starting Air System .............................................
82 VII Conclusion
...................................................................................................................
82 VIII References
....................................................................................................................
82 Page 3 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 4 of 267 <;l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www .kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan ATTACHMENTS
Attachment
A FAI Test Report FAI/17-0667, Test Report for Component
Survivability
at Elevated Ambient Temperature, Revision 0, dated July 2017 Attachment B F AI Test Report FAI/17-0612, Relay Drop Out Testing of GE CR120BD04341
and Agastat E7012PD004
Relays for Clinton Power Station, Revision 0 Attachment
C Excitation
Support System Attachment
D Basler Electric UFOV Regulator
Attachment
E Basler Electric SR_ A Regulator
Attachment
F Email Correspondence
-Bussman Fuse Derating Curves Attachment
G LOR-1 Relay Attachment
H Results of System 1000 Query Attachment
I Ohmite Vendor Data Sheets Attachment
J P&B MDR Series Rotary Relay Attachment
K Dynalco Speed Switches/Transmitters
Attachment
L Deleted Attachment
M STC-4371 Field Conditioning
Relay Attachment
N Honeywell
VRS Speed Sensors Attachment
0 Woodward EGB Governor/
Actuator Attachment
P Woodward Magnetic Pickups Attachment
Q Woodward 2301A Load Sharing and Speed Control Attachment
R System 1000 Query Results -Typical Switch Materials
Attachment
S Excerpt from Standard Handbook for Electrical
Engineers
Attachment
T Excerpt from NUMARC 87-00 (Rev. 1), Guidelines
and Technical
Bases for NUMARC Initiatives
Addressing
Station Blackout at Light Water Reactors, dated August 1991. Page 4 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 5 of 267 \l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan I Purpose The purpose of this report is to perform an operability
assessment
of Class IE equipment
in DG rooms (DIV 1) exposed to higher-than-expected
temperatures
resulting
from a loss of diesel ventilation
VD fans. II Summary of the Review As a result of the loss of the diesel ventilation
VD fans, all the Class IE equipment
required for DG operation
and located in the DG rooms will remain operable during the elevated DG room temperatures
for a maximum 24-hour period. III Background
On Tuesday, March 7, 2017, an Equipment
Operator observed a relay cycling every IO seconds from the Division I 480V Unit Substation
lA (lAPI IE). This relay is part of a logic circuit in the 480V Unit Sub IA and supports the under-voltage
load shed and restoration
of the Division 1 Diesel Generator
ventilation.
The logic would initially
shed the DG fan on under-voltage, preclude the fan from restarting, then after IO seconds, once voltage is restored, allow the ventilation
to be restored either by the EDG start or return of the safety bus. The ventilation
is sequenced
on at I 0 seconds after power restoration
per the sequential
start strategy.
The troubleshooting
efforts determined
the relay 427X3-41A (an interposing
relay that acts as a seal-in circuit, in the undervoltage
relay logic for IAPl IE) operates outside of allowable
circuit parameters, causing the cycling of timing relay 427X2-4IA.
Troubleshooting
attachments
identified
both the X2 and X3 relays operated contrary to their expected transient
on de-energization
resulting
in the X2 relay changing contact states before the X3 relay contacts.
This condition
has two impacts: (I) Associated
DG room fan (1 VDOlCA) would be unable to start either automatically
or manually when required, and (2) Ability of Division 1 DG to properly load shed on a bus undervoltage
condition
is affected.
As a result, Division 1 DG was declared Inoperable
at 03 I9 on March 9, 20I7. Page 5 of83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 6 of 267 (l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan As part of the investigation, it was determined
that the identified
relay cycling was initiated.
by a bus undervoltage
condition.
Historical
surveillance
testing was reviewed.
DG integrated
surveillance
procedure
9080.21, which tested Division 1 ECCS system response to a simulated
LOCA I LOOP signal, does test the affected relay logic in a manner to detect this condition.
However, the fast performance
of 9080.21 was in October 2013. The X2 timer relay was replaced in May 2016. Separate testing of the time delay relay function ONLY was last performed
in May 2016, satisfying
the 48 month periodicity
requirement
for the time delay function.
However, this testing does not initiate a bus undervoltage
condition
and would not have been sufficient
to detect this condition
and fully validate proper function of the affected circuit. In the event of a LOOP, the Division 1 EDG would have started and the Generator's
output breaker would have closed providing
voltage to the safety related buses. However, the suspect relays would have prevented
the VD Vent Fan from running and there would have been no cooling to the EDG Room. Without further evaluation
and justification, the EDG would not have been able to meet its mission time. The analysis presented
herein is a collaborative
effort between Clinton Power Station (CPS) and Kiran Consultants, Incorporated (KCI). IV Evaluation
Parameters
This analysis evaluates
operability
of equipment
in the DG Room for a duration of 24 hours at maximum temperature
values as follows: * Panel lDGOlJA 225&deg;F * All Remaining
Components
in the DG Room 215&deg;F Justification
for operation
is provided for equipment
that cannot meet the above parameters.
Page 6 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 7 of 267 <l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan V Operability
of Class lE Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of Loss of Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan V.1 General Discussion
on the hnpact of Elevated Temperature
on Equipment
Elevated temperatures
can impact the functionality
of equipment
in several ways. Over time, elevated temperatures
can increase the degradation
of organic materials.
Elevated temperatures
can also prevent voltage sensitive
devices (e.g., electrical
devices with coils) from picking up at desired voltages as it is a well-known
phenomenon
of electrical
circuits that the resistance
of a current path will rise as temperature
is increased, resulting
in an increase in the pick-up voltage of devices with coils. The analysis presented
herein will generically
address methods for determining
the impact of elevated temperatures
on organic materials
and then specifically
address the effects of elevated temperatures
on voltage-sensitive
devices. This analysis will also specifically
address the impact of elevated temperatures
on normally open relays. V.1.1 Determining
the hnpact of Temperatures
on Organic Materials
V.1.1.1 Arrhenius
Methodology
Arrhenius
methodology
has been shown to be a valid means of modeling temperature
effects and for evaluating
thermal degradation
of non-metallic
materials.
Note that metallic materials
are virtually
unaffected
by environmental
conditions
associated
with temperatures
experienced
in nuclear plant environments, therefore, the impact of elevated temperatures
on metallic materials
is insignificant.
The following
form of the Arrhenius
equation is typically
used when relating service temperature
and duration to a shorter duration at a higher temperature
used for accelerated (thermal)
aging of non-metallic
materials
at actual laboratory
test conditions.
Equation 1 Where: Page 7 of83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 8 of 267 (1(CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan ts = thermal life at normal service temperature
Ts (K) ta = thermal aging duration at aging temperature
Ta (K) = activation
energy (eV) k Boltzmann
constant (8.617 x 10-5 eV/K) V.1.1.2 10&deg;C Rule Another model for assessing
the time-temperature
effects on non-metallic
materials
is the 10&deg;C rule. This rule simply states that chemical reaction rates double and the material life decreases
by one-half for every 10&deg;C increase in temperature.
For example, a material with a thermal life of 20 years at a service temperature
of 40&deg;C will have a thermal life of 10 years at a temperature
of 50&deg;C. V.1.2 Determining
Impact of Elevated Temperatures
on Voltage Sensitive
Devices The DC relays pickup (change state from de-energized to energized
with aux contacts changing state) when the magnetic force generated
by the coil current compresses
a spring and the plunger travels decreasing
the air gap in the iron core to almost zero. The coil current is directly proportional
to the voltage across the coil divided by the coil resistance (Ohm's Law). The coil resistance
is dependent
on the ambient temperature
given the by the following
equation (Equation
2-9 of Attachment
R): Where: 234.4 + t 2 Rt2 = Rt1 * 234.4 +ti Rn= Coil Resistance
at Room Temperature
of tr Rt2 = Coil Resistance
at tz tr= Room Temperature (typically
20&deg;C (68&deg;F)) t 2 = Operating
Temperature
Therefore, using the above equation, the pickup voltage at any temperature
t 2 can be calculated
from the pickup voltage at room temperature
tr by using the following
equation:*
Page 8 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 9 of 267 <l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www .kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Where: 234.4 + t 2 VPickup_t2
= Vpickup_tl
* 234.4 + ti Vpickup_tl
=Coil Pickup Voltage at Room Temperature
ti Vpickup_t2
=Coil Pickup Voltage at Operating
Temperature
tz Using the above equation for pickup voltage, the pickup voltage of DC relay for an operating
temperature
of 238&deg;F (114.44&deg;C)
will increase by 1.37 times the pickup voltage of same relay at room ambient temperature.
V.1.3 Determining
Impact of Elevated Temperatures
on Normally Open Relay A relay is an electromechanical
switch made of 4 basic parts: electromagnet, mechanical
switching
element (that can be attracted
by the electromagnet), spring, and set of electrical
contacts.
The three principle
failure modes of a relay are (1) failure to trip, (2) spurious trip, and (3) short. Relevant mechanisms
by which these failure modes can occur are contamination (metallic
and non-metallic)
and mechanical
wear of the internal switching
element. ,Relays are less likely to unintentionally
close when configured
with normally open contacts.
Therefore, the task for this configuration
is to determine
whether or not abnormal elevated temperatures
can cause the unwanted closure of the normally open relay. For the subject relay switches, the non-energized
state is normally open, meaning that the relay coil is de-energized and the contacts are open, however, due to applied voltage, the relay may experience
some amount of leakage current across the contact. As such, the only credible failure mode under
abnormal elevated temperatures (that would lead to closure of the contacts or enable the relay to carry sufficient
current so as to close the relay circuit) would be degradation
of the nonmetallic
materials
of construction
or significant
leakage current across the contacts.
Each failure mode is discussed
separately.
The non-metallic
materials
of construction
under consideration
are the materials
of the contact block. Note that metallic materials (i.e., the spring and contacts in the relay) are virtually
unaffected
by environmental
conditions
associated
with exposure to abnormal elevated temperatures.
Typical materials
of a relay switch contact block include phenolic, wood flour phenolic, diallyl phthalate, Durez (brand name phenolic), and Page 9 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 10 of 267 (l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515*2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan polycarbonate.
The results of a System 1000 query on these materials (Reference
VIII.4, Attachment
R) indicate that the highest aging temperature
is a minimum of 140&deg;C or the temperature
rating is a minimum of 1 l5&deg;C, meaning that the materials
have been subjected
to these temperatures
without significant
loss of material properties.
As such, any thermal degradation
experienced
at l 15&deg;C (239&deg;F) is not expected to significantly
impact the functionality
of contact blocks constructed
with these typical materials.
Opened contacts will always experience
some minute amount
of leakage current at applied voltages.
At elevated temperatures, there may be some increase in leakage current, however, that increase will be insignificant.
Elevated temperature
conditions
coupled with humidity/moisture
conditions
may also increase leakage current, however, resistance
in these circuits are sufficiently
high such that any resulting
leakage current across the open contacts remains insignificant
when the relay is exposed to elevated temperatures
and humidity/moisture
conditions.
Additionally, the CPS diesel generator
equipment
is located in a room where humidity conditions
are less than 100% RH during normal and accident conditions (i.e., there are no pipe breaks postulated
for the diesel generator
room under accident conditions)
when the equipment
is operating.
Therefore, failure due to leakage current is not a credible failure mode for the normally open relay switches installed
at CPS. In summary, there is no credible failure mode for a normally de-energized
relay switch exposed to abnormal elevated temperatures
in less than 100% RH environment.
V.2 Testing Performed
at FAl Several components
were subjected
to baseline functional tests
per KCI Test Specification
424-008-TSP2 (Reference
VIII-3). Table V.2-1 summarizes
the test results. Table V.2-1-FAI
Test Results Test Manufacturer
Model Description
Component
Performance
when Exposed to 225&deg;F Specimen for 24 hours and 245&deg;F for 8 hours # EUT#l Agastat 7012PD Time Delay Relay Relay did not drop out, coil remain energized
and open contacts did not short out at 225&deg;F for 24 hours. The relay coil dropped out when exposed to 245&deg;F in less than 8 hours. Another similar specimen did not drop out, coil remain energized
and open contacts did not short out at 238&deg;F for 24 hours. EUT#2 Basler 9-1051-00-105
UFOV Assembly Voltage Regulator
in combination
with UFOV Page 10 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 11 of 267 <l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Test Manufacturer
Model Description
Component
Performance
when Exposed to 225&deg;F Specimen for 24 hours and 245&deg;F for 8 hours # provided the voltage regulation
and there was no loss of exciter control. EUT#3 Basler SR8A2B01B3A
Voltage Regulator
Voltage Regulator
in combination
with UFOV provided the voltage regulation
and there was no loss of exciter control. EUT#4 GE 12CEH51A1A
Loss of Excitation
Relay while energized
with EDG rated current and Relay voltage did not provide a false trip. The relay provided a trip when tbe phase angle of the current was varied verifying
the relay was still function to detect loss of excitation
condition
and provide a trip. EUT#5 GE 12GGP53B1A
Reverse Power Relay Relay while energized
with EDG rated current and voltage did not provide a false trip. The relay provided a trio under a reverse oower condition.
EUT#6A GE 12DCV51Al3A
Restrained
Relay while energized
with EDG rated current did not Overcurrent
Relay provide a false trip. The relay provided a trip when the sensed current exceeded the trip current. EUT#6B GE 12IFCV51ADIA
Restrained
Relay while energized
with EDG rated current did not Overcurrent
Relay provide a false trip. The relay provided a trip when the sensed current exceeded the trip current. EUT#7 P&B MDR 137-8 Relay Relay did not drop out, coil remain energized
and open contacts did not short out. EUT#9 Westinghouse
290B225A10
Differential
Relay The relay did not provided a false trip when the (Type SA-1) operating
current was below the trip setting and provided a trip signal when tbe operating
current exceeded the trio setting. EUT#IO Woodward 2301A Governor Control The control assembly did not provide actuating
Assembly voltage when operated at rated frequency
and provided actuating
signal when the frequency
was increased
within 1 % the rated 60HZ frequency.
The control assembly was subjected
to abnormal temperature
exposure of 207&deg;F for 24 hours, 225&deg;F for 8 hours and 245&deg;F for 8 hours. V.3 Impact of Elevated Temperatures
on the CPS Emergency
Diesel Generator
The Emergency
Diesel Generator (EDG) is designed to operate at an ambient temperature
of 122&deg;F (50&deg;C) when the EDG is running and delivering
the required power to the safety related equipment (Reference
VIII. I). The DG room heat is removed by the VD fans and the fans are designed to keep the ambient temperature
below 122&deg;F. With the loss of the VD fan, the DG room ambient temperature
is expected to rise above 122&deg;F as the forced ventilation
to remove the EDG heat is lost. The operability
of all Class IE equipment
required to function when the EDG is operating
was evaluated
for ambient temperatures
of more than 122&deg;F and documented
in Reference
VIII.2. It was previously
established
in Reference
VIIl.2 that all Class lE equipment
required for EDG operation
will remain operable during the elevated DG room temperature
of 140&deg;F for a maximum period of 12 hours. Page 11 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 12 of 267 <l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite ZSS Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515*2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan All the components
located in the Division 1 EDG room has been identified
and documented
in Reference
VIIl.5. All these components
in Reference
VIIl.5 are categorized
as follows: * Components
in Yellow are identified
as tripping interlock
for the Div. I Diesel Generator (Not affected by LOCA Bypass) * * Components
in Pink are identified
as tripping interlock
for the Div. I Diesel Generator (Blocked by LOCA Bypass) * Components
in Light Green are identified
as Starter interlock
for the Div. I Diesel Generator (Not affected by LOCA Bypass) * Components
in Light Blue are identified
with power regulation
* Components
in White will not prevent EDG Operation
After the EDG starts and runs continuously
to supply _the power demand of all loads connected
to the EDG, this report evaluates
the impact of abnormal ambient temperature
on the EDG to maintain its power production
for 24 hours. Therefore, no other electrical
faults are postulated
during this period. Not all components
in Yellow, Pink and Blue are required for the continuous
operation
of the EDG under the abnormal ambient temperature
environment.
These components
are further divided into those components
classified
as "critical
active" and "critical
passive".
The critical active components
are capable of direct tripping or causing a trip of the EDG. The critical passive components
do not cause a trip of the EDG but are capable of indirect tripping oftheEDG.
Table V-1 lists the temperature
threshold
for tripping interlock
and power regulation
components (Yellow, Pink and Blue) those are considered
as "critical
active" for a maximum duration of 24 hours. Table V-2 lists the temperature
threshold
for tripping interlock
and power regulation
components (Yellow, Pink and Blue) those are considered
as "critical
passive" for a maximum duration of 24 hours. Table V-3 lists the temperature
threshold
for non-critical
components
required EDG operation
for a maximum duration of 24 hours, if applicable.
Table V-4 lists non-critical
components (White) not required for EDG operation.
Components
required for start-up (Green) and components
that will not prevent EDG operation (White) are not required for continuous
operation
ofEDG. These components
are re-evaluated
and Table V-3 lists the temperature
threshold
for these Page 12 of 83 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 13 of 267 Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone {630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan components
for a maximum duration of 24 hours, if applicable.
When reviewing
Tables V-1, V-2 and V-3, note the following:
* The 23 &deg;F cabinet temperature
rise noted for various equipment
types in Table V-1, V-2 and V-3 is based on actual measurements
taken inside the DIV II (1PL12JB)
control panel in 1991 when the ambient temperature
was 74.5&deg;F. This measurement
is documented
in calculation
IP-Q-396 (Reference
VIIl.2). Out of all the panels inside the DG room, Panel 1PL12JB (or 1PL12JA) is considered
to have the maximum temperature
rise. Components
in three Panels (1PL92JA, 1PL93JA and 1DG06SA) are not required to function after the EDG starts. The remaining
panels (lDGOlJA, lDGOlKA-12 cyl EDG, lDGOlKA-16 cyl EDG) have either very few components
or components
that are not normally energized.
The major heat producing
components (such motors, solenoids)
in panels lDGOlKA are de-energized
after the EDG starts. There are a few indicating
lights that are energized
in this panel. Therefore, the temperature
rise inside this panel will be negligible , but assumed conservatively
l 8&deg;F in our analysis.
The 10&deg;C (18&deg;F) temperature
rise inside panel is taken from IEEE 649-1980 (IEEE Standard for Qualifying
Class lE Motor Control Centers for Nuclear Power Generating
Stations).
This temperature
rise for cubicles those are more compact have continuous
energized
contactors, control relays, control transformers, and circuit breakers.
The CT/PT panel (lDGOlJA)
has transformers, but these CTs and PTs do not dissipate
significant
power. Therefore, a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise is utilized for this panel conservatively.
* The equipment
that was not in a panel (such as engine-mounted
equipment)
do not have a panel rise applied. * Aging data or temperature
threshold
data stated are taken from Reference
VIII.2 if not stated otherwise. Page 13 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1 , Pg. 1 4 of 267 Cl ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois , 60515 Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Table V-1 Thr e shold Tem p e r atur e s fo r Critical Active C ompo nents R equire d for E D G Operati o n E P a n el I M E lDGOl J A Comp T y p e Co mp D esc r i p tio n CTl-6 Current Transformers, Diffe r e n tial and Meterin MFG GE, JCS-0 E IDGOIKA IDG03KA A9 Actuator Governor WOODWARD (Mounted on Engine) P A R T NO Te mp eratu r e Com m e n t Importa n ce T h res h old {&deg;F) JCS-234 No e l ectronics
is used. The insulation
was aged at 257&deg;F. The function of Ye ll ow 0/687X6 the devices depends on the integrity
of the insu l ation system. Located in panel 1 DGO IJA. Reduc i ng this temperature
by 23&deg;F to account for cab i net tern erature rise, the com onent will function at 234 &deg;F. EGB-13P 250 The Governor is located on the cool s i de of the engine (i.e. opposite the Y e ll ow turbo chargers)
between the engine and the jacket water cooler. It will therefo r tend to be in a cooler area. Based on VTIP 1<286 1-0002-B , R/87 (Woodward
EBG-Proportional
Governor Actuator , #82340C), the Governor is used on both steam or engine prime movers. Based on VTIP 1<2861-0002-B (page 9), the recommended
operating
range of the unit is up to 250&deg;F with synthetic
oil. Significant
aging of the oil in the Governor would not occur for minor excursions
in temperature
for a short duration in time. The Governor , once the engine was up and running at steady s tate (which occurs early in the event), is not heavily loaded (i.e. it does not need to move much) and therefor wo u ld not develop significant
heat in the oil. Based on NSED Standard MS-01.00 , R/46 (Equipment
Lub r ication Standard), the device is to be l ubricated
with MOBIL 1 SW-30. MOBIL 1 SW-30 is a synthetic
oil that has better performance
in high heat applications
than conventional
motor oils (Attachment
0). Therefore , the governo r would be expected to operate for short periods of time (less than 6 hours) at the end of the scenario at elevated ambient temperatures
(-250&deg;F) with MOBIL 1 SW-30 lubricant.
P a ge 14 of 83 I 
E C 620 6 32 , Att. 1 , Pg. 15 of 267 Cl ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan E Panel I M Comp T y pe Comp Description
E 1DGO1 KA 1 DG04KA A9/a Actuator Governor (Mounted on Engine) E I PLI 2JA R20 E 1PLl2JA 1SC-DG859 87 A4 Relay , Differential (Type SA-1) Governor Control Assembly MF G PAR T N O Temperature
Comment Threshold
Importance
WOODWARD EGB-13P WESTINGHOUSE
2908225A IO WOODWARD 2301A OF 250 222 222 The Governor is located on the cool side of the engine (i.e. op po site the turbo chargers)
between the engine and the jacket water cooler. It will therefo r tend to be in a cooler area. Based on VTIP K286 I-0002-B, R/87 (Woodward
EBO-Proportional
Governor Actuator , #82340C), the Governor is used on both steam or engine prime movers. Based on VTIP K286 l -0002-B (page 9), the recommended
operating
range of the unit is up to 250&deg;F with synthetic
oil. Significant
aging of the oil in the Governor would not occur for minor excursions
in temperature
for a short duration in time. The Governor , once the engine was up and running at steady state (which occurs ear ly in the event), is not heavily loaded (i.e. it does not need to move much) and therefor would not develop significant
heat in the oil. Based on NSED Standard MS-01.00 , R/46 (Equipment
Lubrication
Standard), the d e vice is to be lubricated
with MOBIL 1 5W-30. MOBIL I 5W-30 is a synthetic
oil that has better performance
in high heat applications
than conventional
motor oils (Attachment
0). Therefore, the governor would be expected to operate for short periods of time (l ess than 6 hours) at the end of the scenario at elevated ambient temperatures
(-250&deg;F) with MOBIL I SW-30 lubricant.
Ye ll ow The relay was energized
with normal operating
EOG current (5 Amps on the Ye ll ow Restraint
coil and 0.22 Amps on the operating
coil) and 125 VDC for the trip coil at 225&deg;F for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F for 8 hours. The relay did not provide a false trip. Therefore, the relay will not impact the normal operation
of the EOG at 245&deg;F. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EOG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Reference
VIll.6 , Attachment
A). Located in PL! 2JA panel. Rated for 185&deg;F by the manufacturer
for Yellow operation
and 221&deg;F for storage (See Attachment
Q). The governor control assembly was energized
with normal operating
EDG voltage at 207&deg;F for 24 hours, 225&deg;F for 8 hours and followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F for 8 hours. The output of governor control did not drift from the operating
condition (remained
at 0 VDC for 60HZ operation).
Therefore, the governor control will maintain the normal operation
of the EOG at 245&deg;F. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise , the governor control assembly will not impact the EOG normal operation
in an ambient tern erature of 222&deg;F. (see Reference
Vlll.6, Attachment
A . Page 15 of 83 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 16 of 267 Cl ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) 1401 Branding Lane, Su i te 255 Downe rs G r ove , I lli n ois , 605 1 5 Phone (630) 5 1 5-2650 * FAX (6 3 0) 5 1 5-26 54 www.kciconsultants.com
Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan E Panel Com p Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comme n t Importance
I Ty p e T h res h old M E IPL12JA R20 0 Relay, Loss of GE 12CEH51A 222 The relay was energized
with normal operating
EDG current and voltage Pink Excitation
IA and 125 VDC for the trip coil at 225&deg;F for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F for 8 hours. The relay did not provide a false trip. Therefore , the relay will not impact the normal operation
of the EDG at 245&deg;F. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise for panel IPLI2JA , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient tern erature of 222&deg;F. see Reference
Vlll.6, Attachment
A . E IPLI2JA Rl9 32 Reverse Power Relay GE 12GGP53B 222 The relay was energized
with normal operating
EDG current and voltage Pink IA and 125 VDC for the trip coil at 225&deg;F for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F for 8 hours. The relay did not provide a false trip. Therefore, the relay will not impact the normal operation
of the EDG at 245&deg;F. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise for panel IPLl2JA , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient tern erature of222&deg;F. see Reference
Vlll.6, Attachment A . E IPLl2JA R20 51V-l Voltage Restrained
GE 12UCV51A 222 The relay was energized
with normal operating
EDG current and 125 VDC Pink Overcurrent
Rly Ph I 13A for the trip coil at 225&deg;F for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F 12IFCV51 for 8 hours. The relay did not provide a false trip. Therefore, the relay will ADIA not impact the normal operation
of the EDG at 245&deg;F. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise , the rel a y will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. (see Reference
Vill.6, Attachment
A . E 1PLl2JA R20 51V-2 Voltage Restrained
GE 12UCV51A 222 The relay was energized
with normal operating
EDG current and 125 VDC Pink Overcurrent
Rly Ph 2 13A for the trip coil at 225&deg;F for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F 12IFCV5! for 8 hours. The relay did not provide a false trip. Therefore , the relay will AD!A not impact the normal operation
of the EDG at 245&deg;F. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Reference
Vill.6 , Attachment
A . E IPL12JA R20 51V-3 Voltage Restrained
GE 12IJCV51A
222 The relay was energized
with normal operating
EDG current and 125 VDC Pink Overcurrent
Rly Ph 3 13A for the trip coil at 225&deg;F for 24 hour s followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F 121FCV51 for 8 hours. The relay did not provide a false trip. Therefore, the relay will ADIA not impact the normal operation
of the EDG at 245&deg;F. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Reference
Vlll.6 , Attachment
A . Page 16 o f 83 
EC 62 0 632 , A t t. 1, P g. 17 of 26 7 Cl ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) 140 1 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 51 5-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan E Panel Comp Comp Descripti o n I Type M E !DGOIJA CTIO-Current Boot s 11 Transformers
E !DGOIJA TI Transformer, Voltag e Regulator
Pow e r E IDGOIJA PT! Potential
Transformer , Regulator
E !DGOIJA PT2 Potential
Transformer , R egu l ator E IDGOIJA CCT C r oss Current Transforme
r MFG BASLER BASL E R GE
GE GE, JCS-0 PART NO Tem p e r ature Comme n t Thresho l d Importance
O F BE-02463-234 001 B E-13487-234 00 1 NM-234 3/643X92 NM-234 3/643X92 JCS-234 0/68 7 X6 o electronics
is u s ed. The i nsu l ation was age d at 257&deg;F. The function of Blue the devices d epends on the integrity
of the insulation
system. Reducing this t e mperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise , the component
will function at 234&deg;F. Located in Panel IDGOIJA. o e l ectronics
is used. The ins u lation was aged at 257&deg;F. The function of Blu e the devices depends on the integrity
of the insulat i on system. Reducing this t e mperatu r e by 23 &deg;F to acco u nt for c a binet temperature
rise , th e component
will function at 234&deg;F. Located in Panel IDGOIJA. No electronics
is u sed. The insu l at i on was aged at 257&deg;F. The function of Blu e the devices depends on the integrity
of the insu l ation system. Located in panel IDGOIJA. Reducing this temperature
by 23&deg;F to account for cabinet tern erature ri s e , the com onent wi ll function a t 234&deg;F. No electronics
i s u s ed. The insu l ation w as aged at 257&deg;F. The function of Blu e the devices depends on the integrity
of the insulation
system. Located in panel I DGO I JA. Reducing this temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cab i net tern erature rise , the com one n t will functio n at 234&deg;F. o e l ectronics
i s u s ed. The insulation
was aged at 257&deg;F. The function of Blu e the device s depend s on the integrity
of the in s ulation s ystem. Located in pane l lDGOIJA. Reducing this t e mp e rature by 23&deg;F to account fo r cabin e t t e rn erature ri se , th e com onent will function at 234&deg;F. P age 17 of 8 3 I 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 18 of 2 6 7 Cl ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) 1401 Brand i ng Lane , Su i te 255 Downers Grove , Illinois , 60515 P h o n e (6 3 0) 5 1 5-2650 * F AX (6 30) 5 1 5-2 65 4 www.kciconsultants
.com Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Resul t of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan E Panel I M E !DGOIKA E !DGOIKA Comp Type Comp Descripti o n G I 3875KW 4160V Generator
G2 Exciter MFG IDEAL IDEAL PART NO Temperature
Comme n t T h resho ld OF 230 Generator
insulation
is rated for 155&deg;C (Class F). The minimum thermal life of Class F in s ulation is more than 1000 hours at 200&deg;C operating
temperature
(Attachment
T). The temperature
rise at full load i s 70&deg;C (See Section 5.12 of Ref. VIll.2). Based on TODI-CPS-17-025 , the peak load on the EDG durin g the LOCAILOOP
case is 3 721.2 KW and the peak load for the LOOP case is 3334.8 KW. The EDG is rated for 3900 KW continuo u s rating (DWG E02-IAPl2, Sheet 031 , Rev. J), the corresponding
load for the LOCAILOOP
and the LOOP is 95.4% and 85.5% respectively.
Therefore
the generator
temperatu r e rise at 95.4% rated load is 63.7&deg;C [70*0.954*0.954
= 63.7&deg;C]. Assuming the same temperature
rise , the generato r will be expo s ed to 173.7&deg;C when operating
in an ambient temperature
of230&deg;F (110&deg;C) [i.e., 110&deg;C + 63.7&deg;C = l 73.7&deg;C]. The generator
temperature
will be l 8.7&deg;C above its long term rating of l 55&deg;C. However , the gene r ator is rated for 20 , 000 hours of operation
at l 55&deg;C and this life will be reduced by a factor of3 .66 using the 10&deg;C rule for a long term life of more than 227 days. Therefore
for a short term operation
of I day , the impact on the generator
thermal capability
when operating
at 230&deg;F i s negligible. The minimum thermal life of 1000 hours at 200&deg;C from the ARC 87-00 repo rt (Attachment
T) a l so exceeds the Generator
thermal s tress for I da of o eration b a tar e m a r in. 230 Exciter insulation
i s rated for l 55&deg;C (Cla ss F). The minimum thermal life of Class F insulation
is more than 1000 hours at 200&deg;C operating
temperature (Attachment
T). The temperature
rise of the exciter is 80&deg;C (See Section 5.11 of Ref. VIII.2). The insulation
life is 20000 hours at 155&deg;C. For an operating
envirorunent
of 230&deg;F (110&deg;C), the exciter temperature
will reach l 90&deg;C. The life at this temperature
is 1767 hours (73 days) using 10&deg;C rule. The r efore for a s h ort term operation
of 1 day , the impact on the exciter thermal capability
when operating
at 230&deg;F is negligible. The minimum thermal life of 1000 hours at 200&deg;C from th e C 87-00 report (Attachment
T) also exceed s the E xciter thermal s tress for I da of o eration b a lar e mar in. Importance
Blu e Blu e Page 18 of 83 I 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , P g. 1 9 of 26 7 Cl ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants
.com Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan E Pan e l I M E I PLl2J A Comp Ty p e xc E 1PLl 2JA UY E 1PLl 2 J A R l 7 C omp D esc r i ption MFG A2 Series B oost O pt io n BAS L E R A l O UFOV Assem bl y BA S LER A l Vo l tage R egulator BASLE R PART N O T e mp e r at ur e Co mm e n t T h res h o ld Imp o rtance 9 0-3710 0-100 9-1 05 1-00-1 00 S R 8A2BOI B3A OF 234 222 222 Age d at 257&deg;F. Locate d in pa n e l IP Ll 2 J A. Thi s d ev i ce h as p assive co m pone n t s suc h as resist o rs, capac i tors , transforme
r a nd ind u c t ive coi l (S e e Attac hm en t C). Thi s d ev i ce takes i npu t from CT/P T panel an d boosts the exci t er vo lt age to keep the E O G voltage at rated voltage. As the componen t s were aged at 257&deg;F an d th ere are n o movi n g parts an d electro ni cs, the device wi ll fu n ctio n fo r a n o p erating temperature
of 2 5 7&deg;F. Accounting
for cab in et tem p erature rise of23&deg;F , this device will be func ti onal at 23 4&deg;F outs id e the anel IPLl2 J A. Blue The UFOV is req u ired whe n th e E O G i s runnin g 4 to 7 HZ b e l ow 60HZ. Bl u e Age d at 25 7&deg;F. R ate d for 1 5 8&deg;F b y m a nu facturer (S ee Attac hm e n t 0). Loca t e d i n 1PLl2JA p a n e l. The UFOV was aged at 225&deg;F e n ergized for 24 h o u rs followed with an expos ur e to 245&deg;F wh il e ene r gized for 8 ho ur s. The UFOV performe d its des ir ed functio n and d id n ot p rovide any false trip signal t o the EOG througho u t the 32 hours oftest run. Acco u nting for a 23&deg;F cu b i c l e t e m perature rise, the UFOV will n ot im p act the E OG n o rm al o p eratio n in an am bi en t te rn eratu r e of222&deg;F. see R eference VIIJ.6 , See Attac hm e nt A Aged at 257&deg;F. No dera t ing a t 158&deg;F (See Attac hm ent E). Located in Blu e I PLI 2 J A pane l. The voltage r egu l ator was aged a t 225&deg;F energ i zed fo r 24 hours followed w i th an expos ur e to 245&deg;F while ene r gized for 8 ho u rs. The vo l tage r egu l a t or p erformed i t s d esi r e d func t ion and d i d no t provide any fa l se trip signal t o th e EOG t hr o u ghou t th e 32 h o u rs of t est run. Acco un ti n g fo r a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise , the voltage r eg ul ator will not impact the EOG n orma l operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Refe r ence Vlll.6 , Attachment A . Page 19 of 83 I 
EC 62 0 632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 20 of 2 6 7 Cl ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) 1401 Branding lane , Suite 255 Downers Grove , Illino i s, 60515 Phone (630) 515*2650 * FAX (630) 515-2 654 www.kciconsultants.com
Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan E Pa n el I M Comp Type E !PLJ2JA UY LEGEND FOR "STATE" Co mp Description
MFG Kl5 Relay , Power Failure P&B Aux EOG o eration EDG o eration PART NO Temperature
Comment Threshold
Importa n ce OF MDR137-8 222 This relay is normal l y energized
and short circuits the generator
CT under Blue loss of 125 VDC power supply. As the relay energized
during EDG normal operation, the relay coil failure will impact the continued
operation
ofEDG. Per SQ-CLD-039, the relay was aged at l 25&deg;C (257&deg;F) and functionally
tested during an environmental
test at l 53&deg;F. Manufacturer
rating i s 149&deg;F (see Attachment
J). Accounting
for 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise , the relay will remain functional
for an ambient temperature
of l 26&deg;F. An identical
relay (MOR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;F energized
at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circ u it integrity
and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours of test run. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. (see Reference
VIII.6, Attachment
A . Page 20 of 83 I 
I L EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 21 of 267 Cl 1 401 B r anding Lane , Su i te 255 Downer s Grove , Illino i s , 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FA X (630) 5 15-2 6 54 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan T bl V 2 T h a e -: r e s h I d T 0 e mp er atu res i C .. I P o r nti c a ass 1 ve c ompon e n ts R e qm re d i E D G O o r 1p e r ati o n E Pa n el Comp Comp
Descri p tion MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Im p o r tance I Type Threshold
M (OF) E IDGOIJA PTl-FOI Fuse , Potential
Bussman HVU 225 The HVU fuses are installed
in panel lDGOIJA. Based on NEC Blue Transformer
Regulator
requirements , the fuses are sized at least 125% above the O.SA maximum load current and rounded up to the next available
fuse size. Therefor as long as the fuse is derated to more than 80% (l /1.25) of its rating, the fuse will carry the load current and not prov i de a false trip. Based on calcu l ation IP-Q-396 (Attachment
15, page 11 , note 19), the materials
used in HVU type fuses are not susceptible
to thermal degradation. The HVU is a Non-Dual Element Fuse. Attachment
F shows that the current carrying capacity(%
ofrating)
and Opening Time (% ofrating)
as a function of ambient temperature. Based on Attachment
F, the HVU fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperature
of 120&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore, even at operating
temperature
of 248&deg;F the fuse has 15% margin above the design maximum full load current. With a conservative
cab in et temperature
rise of23&deg;F, the fuses will not provi de a false trip and carry the load c u rrent for a cab i net o u tside ambient temperature
of225&deg;F. Note that the opening time under a fault will also decrease , but the fuse will still provide protection
under this conditio n. Page 21 o f 83 I State p 
EC 6 20 632, Att. 1 , Pg. 22 of 267 E I M E Cl 1401 Brand i ng Lane , Suite 255 Downe rs Grove , Illino i s , 60515 EN GINEE R ING CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 51 5-2650 * F AX (6 3 0) 515-2 6 54 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Ty p e IDGOlJA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Cla s s 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Resul t of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO T e mperatur e Comment Threshold (OF) PT1-F02 Fuse , Potential
Bus s man HVU 225 The HVU fuse s are in s talled in panel 1 DGO IJA. Ba s ed on N E C Tran s forme r Regul a tor requirement
s, the fuse s are s ized at least 125% above the 0.5A maximum load current and rounded up to the next a v ailable fu s e size. Therefor as long a s the fuse i s derated to more than 80% (111.25) of its rating, the fuse will carry the load current and not provide a false trip. Based on calculatio
n IP-Q-396 (Attachment
15 , page 11, note 19), th e materials
used in HVU type fuse s ar e not suscepti b le to therma l degradatio
n. The HVU is a No n-Dual Element F u se. Attachment
F shows that the current carrying capacity (% of rating) and Opening Time (% of rating) as a funct i on of ambient t e mp e r a ture. Based on A t t ac hment F , th e HVU fuse will b e d e r a ted to 95% o f its rating at an opera t ing amb i ent temperature
of l 2 0&deg;C (24 8&deg;F). Therefore , even at op e rating temperatur
e o f 248&deg;F the fu s e ha s 15% margin above the des i gn maximum full load current. With a con s ervative cabinet temperature
ri s e of23&deg;F, the fu s e s wi ll not provide a fal se trip and carry the load current for a cabinet out s ide ambient temperature
of225&deg;F. Note that the opening time under a fau l t will al s o decrea se, but th e fu s e will still pro v ide protecti o n und e r thi s condit i on. Importance
Blue Pa g e 22 of 83 I State p 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 23 of 267 E I M E Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove , Illino i s , 60515 E N GINEERING
CONSULT A NTS Phone (630) 515-2 6 5 0 * F AX (6 30) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IDGOIJA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Descri p tion MFG PART NO Tem p erature Comment Threshold (OF) PT2-FOI Fuse, Potential
Bussman HVU 225 The HVU fuses are installed
in panel I DGO I JA. Based on NEC Transfonner
Regulator
requirements, the fuses are sized at least 125% above the 0.5A maximum load current and rounded up to the next available
fuse size. Therefo r as long as the fuse is derated to more than 80% (\/1.25) of its rating , the fuse will carry the load c u rrent and not provide a false tri p. Based on calculatio
n IP-Q-396 (A t tachment 15, page 11, note 19), the materia l s used in HVU type fuses are not s u scep t i b le to !henna! degradat i on. The HVU is a No n-Dual E l e m ent F u se. Attac hm ent F shows that the c urr e n t carrying capacity (% of rating) an d Opening Time (% of r ating) as a function of ambient temperature. Based on Attachment
F , the HVU fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperature
of 120&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore , even at operating
temperature
of 248&deg;F the fuse has 15% margin above the design maximum full load current. With a conservative
cab i net temperature
rise of23&deg;F , the fuses will not provide a false trip and carry the load c u rrent for a cabinet outside ambient temperature
of 225&deg;F. Note that the opening time under a fault will also decrease , but the fuse will still provide protection
unde r this condition.
Importance
Blue Page 23 of 83 I *--1 I I State p 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 2 4 of 2 6 7 E I M E Cl 1401 Branding Lane , Suite 255 Downers Grove , Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IDGOlJA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Thres hold (OF) PT2-F02 Fuse, Potential
Bussman HVU 225 T h e HVU fuses are installed
in panel IDGOIJA. Based on NEC Transformer
Regulator
requirement
s, the fuses are s ized at least 125% above the 0.5A maximum load current and rounded up to the next available
fuse size. Therefor as long as the fuse is derated to more than 80% (I /1.25) of its rating , the fuse will carry the load current and not provide a false trip. Based on calcu l ation IP-Q-396 {Attachme n t 15 , page 11, note 19), the materials
used in HVU type fuses are not susceptible
to thermal degradation. The HVU is a Non-Dual Element Fuse. Attachment
F shows that the current carry in g capacity(%
ofrating)
and Opening T im e(% of rating) as a function of ambient temperature. Based on Attachment
F , the HVU fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperature
of l 20&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore, even at operating
temperature
of 248&deg;F the fuse has 15% margin above the design maximum full load current. With a conservative
cabinet temperature
rise of23&deg;F , the fuses will not provide a fals e trip and carry the load current for a cabinet outside ambient temperature
of225&deg;F. Note that the opening time under a fault will also decrea s e , but the fuse will still provide protection
under this condition. Importance
Blue Page 24 of 83 I State p 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 2 5 of 267 E I M E Cl 1401 Branding lane , Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois , 60515 E NGIN EE R ING CO N S U LTA N TS P hone (630) 515-2650 * F AX (630) 5 15-26 5 4 www.kciconsultants
.com Pa n el Co mp Type IDGOIJA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Co m p D esc r i p tio n MFG PART NO Te m pe r at u re Co m ment Threshold (OF) TI-FOi F use, T r ansforme r B u ssman HVU 225 The HVU fuses a r e installed
in pane l 1 DGO I J A. Based on NEC Vo l tage R egulator requirements , the fuses are sized at least 125% above the Power maximum load current and rounded up to the next available
fuse size. Therefor as long as the fuse is derated to more than 80% (I /1.25) of its rating, the fuse w ill carry the l oad c u rrent and not provide a false trip. Based on calcu l atio n IP-Q-396 (Attachment
15, page 11, note 19), the materials
used in HVU type fuses are not susceptib l e to therma l degradation.
The HVU is a Non-Dual Element F u se. Attac h ment F s h ows that the current carryi n g capacity(%
of rating) and Opening Time (% ofrating)
as a fu n ction of amb i ent tempe r ature. Based on Attac h ment F , the HVU fuse wi ll be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambien t temperature
of l 20&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefo r e, even at operating
temperature
of 248&deg;F the fuse has 15% margin above the design maximum full loa d current. With a co n servative
cabinet temperature
rise of23&deg;F, the fuses will not provide a false trip and carry the loa d c u rrent for a cabinet outside am b ient temperature
of 225&deg;F. Note that the opening time un d er a fault will also decrease , but the fuse will still provide p r otection unde r this cond i tion. Im p ortance Blue Page 25 o f 83 j S t ate p 
EC 620632, Att. 1 , Pg. 26 of 267 E I M E Cl 1 401 Branding Lane , Su i te 2 55 Downer s Gro v e , Illi no is, 605 1 5 EN GINEERING
CONSUL T ANTS Phone (630) 5 1 5-26 5 0 * F AX (6 3 0) 5 1 5-2 6 54 www.kciconsultants.com
Pa n el Comp Type IDGOlJA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Room s as a Resul t of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Threshold (OF) Tl-F02 Fuse, Transformer
Bussman HVU 225 The HVU fuses are i n stalled in panel l DGO I JA. Based on NEC Voltage Regula tor requirements, the fuses a re sized at least 125% above the Power maximum load current and rounded up to the next available
fuse size. Therefor as long as the fuse is derated to more than 80% (1/l.25) of its rating, the fuse will carry the load current and not provide a false trip. Based on calculatio
n IP-Q-396 (Attachment
15 , page 11, note 19), the materials
used in HVU type fuse s are not susceptible
to thermal degradation. The HVU is a Non-Dual Element Fuse. Attachment
F shows that the current carrying capacity (% of rating) and Opening Time (% of rating) as a function of ambient temperature.
Based on Attachment
F, the HVU fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperature
of l 20&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore, even at operating
temperature
of248&deg;F the fuse has 15% margin above the design maximum full load current. With a conservative
cabinet temperature
rise of23&deg;F , the fuses will not provide a false trip and carry the Load current for a cabinet outside ambient temperature
of 225&deg;F. Note that the opening time under a fault will also decrease , but the fuse will still provide protection
under this condition. Importance
Blue Page 26 o f 83 I State p 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 27 of 26 7 Cl ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
1401 Branding Lane , Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illino i s, 60515 P hone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants
.com KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) E Panel Comp I Type M E lDGOIJA E IPLl2JA MOC E 1PLI2JA E 1PLl2JA LE G EN D FO R "ST A TE" Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Resul t of a Loss of t he D i e s e l Ve nt ilation V D Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Threshold (OF) TI-F03 Fuse, Transformer
Bussman HVU 225 The HVU fuses are i n stalled in panel IDGOIJA. Base d on NEC Voltage Regulator
requirements, the fuses are sized at least 125% above the Power maxim u m load current and rounded up to the next available
fuse size. Therefor as long as the fuse is d e rated to more than 80% (1/1.25) of its rating , the fuse will carry the load current and not provide a false trip. Based on calculation
IP-Q-396 (Attachment
15 , page 11, note 19), the materials
used in HVU type fuses are not susceptible
to therma l degradation.
The HVU is a Non-Dual Element Fuse. Attachment
F shows that the current carryi n g capacity(%
of r ating) and Opening Time (%of ratin g) as a function of ambient temperature. Based on Attachment
F , the HVU fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperature
of l 20&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore, even at operating
temperature
of 248&deg;F the fuse has 1 5% margin above the design maximum full l oad current. With a conservative
cabinet temperature
rise of23&deg;F , the fuses will not provide a false trip and carry the load c u rrent for a cabi n et outside ambient temperature
of225&deg;F. Note that the opening time unde r a fault will also dec r ease , but the fuse will still provide protection
under this condition.
Rll Rheost at, Voltage BASL E R 90-72300-234 Aged at 257&deg;F. Loc a ted in IPLl2JA panel. It is a passive device Adjust 116 and therefore
will function at 257&deg;F. Accounting
for cabinet t emperature
rise of 23 &deg;F, the rheostat can function at 234 &deg;F. CR2 Rectifier , MOTOROLA INll98 234 Aged at 257&deg;F. Diodes are age i nsensitive. Reducing this Freewhee li ng temperature
by 23 &deg;F t o account for cabinet temperature
rise , the component
will function at 234&deg;F. R4 , 5 Resistor, Field OHMIT E 0605 500 Located in panel I PL! 2JA. The resistors
use alloys whose ohmic Limiting 150 ohm value s change very little with temperature
and use Ceramic as the insulating
material (See Attachment
n. Ceramic can withstand
high temperatures
above I 000&deg;C and therefore
these resistors
are age-insensitive.
Conservatively
assumed not affected below 500&deg;F. Importance
Blue Blue Blue Blue I P I Critical Passive Com p onents (ca p able of causing an indirect tripping of the EOG) P a ge 2 7 o f 83 State p p p p 
E C 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 28 of 267 Cl 1401 Branding Lane , Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60 5 15 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.c om KCI R e port REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Table V-3 Threshold
Temperatures
for Non Critical Components
Required for EDG Operation
E Panel Comp Comp
Description
MF G PAR T N O T emperature
C omment Importanc e I T y pe Thre s hold M (O F) E lDGOlKA AS Magnetic Pickup ELECTRO 3045A 248 Aged at 25 7&deg;F. Rated for 248&deg;F by the manufacturer.
Yellow (Mounted on Engine) CORP Honeywell
is the product manufacturer.
See Attachment
N. This device is engine mounted and therefore
sees no cabinet temperature
rise. Therefore, the device is operationa
l at 248&deg;F. E lDGOlKA So l L03 Solenoid Engine Over EMO 8246103 239 Thi s solenoid va l ve is energized
to shutdown fuel to the engine Yellow speed Shutdown for an overspeed
condition. Under normal EOG operation , the solenoid valve is not required to change sta t e (go from de-energized
to energ ized state). Per SQ-CLD-034 , the device was aged at l 25&deg;C (257&deg;F) and functionally
tested during an environmental
test at l53&deg;F. Since it was unaffected
by thermal aging and not required to be energized
under normal EOG operation, it would be good to at least to 257&deg;F. Conservatively
assuming a l 0&deg;C (I 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise , the device is operational
at 239&deg;F. E lDGOlKA Sol L03A Solenoid Engine Over E MO 8246103 239 Thi s solenoid valve is energized
to shutdown fuel to the engine Yellow speed Shutdown for an overspecd
condition.
Under normal EOG operation, the solenoid valve i s not required to change sta t e (go from de-energize d to energized
state). Per SQ-CLD-034 , the device was aged at l 25&deg;C (257&deg;F) and function ally tested during a n environmental
test at l 53&deg;F. Since it was unaffected
by thermal aging and not required to be energized
under normal E OG operation , it would be good to at least to 257&deg;F. Conservatively
assuming a l0&deg;C (18&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the device is operational
at 239&deg;F. E IDGO IKA ISS-S9 Over Speed Switch EMD 8422449 239 Device does not have any elec tronics. Ju s t a passive switc h Yellow DGll9 closed by a mechanical
means. The in s ulation was aged at 257&deg;F. The function of the devices depends on the integrity
of the insulation
sys t e m. Located in panel l DGO l KA. This panel has compo n ents that produ ce low heat. Conservative
ly a ss uming a l 0&deg;C (l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
ri s e, the d evice is opera ti onal at 239&deg;F. Page 28 of 83 S tate p DE DE DE 
EC 62 0 6 32 , At t. 1 , P g. 2 9 of 2 6 7 E I M E E E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IDGOIKA !SS-DGIJ8 IDGOIKA DIODE I DGOIKA DIODE IDGOIKA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Tem pera ture Comme nt Threshold
(O F) S9A O ve r Speed Switch EMD 8422449 239 Device doe s not have any electronics. Ju st a passive switch closed by a mechanical
means. The insulation
was aged at 257&deg;F. The function of the devices depends on the integrity
of the insulation
s ystem. Located in panel IDGO I KA. This panel has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a I 0&deg;C (I 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise , the device is operational
at 239&deg;F. CR? Diode , Arc MOTOROLL INll98 239 Aged at 257&deg;F. Diodes are age insensitive. Located in panel Suppression
A I DGO I KA. This panel has components
that produce low he at. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C (18&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise , the device is operational
at 239&deg;F. CR8 Diode , Arc MOTOROLL INI 198 23 9 Aged at 257&deg;F. Diode s are age in s en s itive. Located in panel Suppression
A I DGO I KA. Thi s panel has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a I 0&deg;C (I 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the device is operational
at 239&deg;F. TB9 Terminal Blocks 227 These a re typically
GE EB25-12W terminal blocks (Drawing 61090 , Rev. H, Sheet 2). Insulation
material was aged at 248&deg;F for I 072 hours. The tcnninal block was functional
before , during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section 5. I 0 of Ref. VIII.2). The contact block of r elays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;F and h a d there was no co nt act failure (Reference
VIII.6 , Attachment
A). Therefore , using 245&deg;F for any kind of terminal block and accounting
a I 0&deg;C (I 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise (conservative), the terminal block will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 227&deg;F. Importanc e Y ellow Ye ll ow Yellow Yellow Page 29 of 83 State DE p p p 
E C 6 2 063 2 , At t. 1 , Pg. 30 of 267 E I M E Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Ty p e IPLl2JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Descr i ption MFG PART NO Te m perature Comment Th r eshold {oF) K41 Relay Over speed Trip Agastat 7012PE 222 This timer relay is normally de-energized.
On over-s p eed, Over Time Dela y Speed Switche s S9 or S9A closes and energizes
relay coil K3. K3 contact "a" closes and energizes
relay coils K4 l and K4 l X. K4 l has a "b" contact in series with the K4 l X coil. After 2 seconds , the K41 X coil is de-energized
because K41 "b" contact opens after 2 seconds. K41X contacts drive 2 of2, engine over-speed shutdown solenoids
L03 & L03A. This relay does not energize when the EDG is running normally and relay failure (contact failure) will not impact EOG operation.
See OWG E02-IDG99 , Sht 011 (Rev. 0) This family of relays (Agastat 7012 series) was functionally
tested while being aged at 225&deg;F energized
at 125 VOC for 24 hours. The relay did not drop out or the open contacts did not short out. The relay was aged at 245&deg;F for another 8 hours and experienced
drop out. The relay was then aged at 238&deg;F energized
at 125 VOC for 24 hours and did not experience
drop out or short out. Since this relay is normally de-energized
drop out or pick-up is not a concern and the relay will be good to 245&deg;F. This relay is located in I PLI 2JA panel; accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EOG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (sec Reference
VnI.6 , Attachment
A) . Importanc e Y e ll o w P a ge 30 of 83 Stat e DE 
EC 6 20 6 32 , A t t. 1 , Pg. 31 of 26 7 E I M E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illino i s, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
P hone (630) 515-2650 * F AX (6 3 0) 5 1 5-2 654 www.kciconsultants.com
Pane l Co m p Type 1 PL12JA Fl6 1PL12JA F16 KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Descri p ti o n MFG PART NO Tem p eratu r e Comment T h re s ho ld (O F) F07 Fuse, Protective
Bussman NON-15 225 The NON fuses are installed
in panel 1PL!2JA. Based on NEC Circuitry
requirements , the fuses are sized at least 125% above the maximum load current and rounded u p to the next available
fuse size. Therefor as long as the fuse is derated to more than 80% (l/1.25) of its rating, the fuse will carry the l oad cu rr e n t and not provide a false trip. The NON is a No n-D u al Element Fuse. Attachme nt F shows that the current carrying capacity(%
of rating) and Opening Time (%of rating) as a function of ambient temperature.
Based o n Attachment
F, the NON fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperature
of 120&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore, even at operating
temperature
of 248&deg;F the fuse has 15% margin above the design maximum full load current. The cabinet temperature
rise is 23&deg;F and the fuses will not provide a false trip and carry the load current for an ambient temperature
of 225&deg;F. F07-l Fuse, Protective
Bussman NON-15 225 The NON fuses are installed
in panel 1PL!2JA. Based on NEC Circuitry
requirements , the fuses arc sized at least 125% above the maximum load current and rounded u p to the next available
fuse size. The r efo r as long as the fuse is derated to mo r e t han 80% (1/1.25) of its rating, the fuse will carry the load c u rrent and not provide a false trip. The NON is a Non-D u al Element Fuse. Attachment
F shows that the current carrying capacity (% of rating) and Opening Time (% of rating) as a function of ambient temperature.
Based on Attachment
F , the NON fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperature
of l 20&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore , even at operating
temperature
of 248&deg;F the fuse has 15% margin abo v e the design maximum full load current. The cabinet temperature
rise is 23&deg;F and the fuses will not provide a false trip and carry the load current for an a mbient temperature
of 225&deg;F. Importa n ce Ye ll ow Yellow Page 31o f 83 State p p 
E C 62 0 63 2 , Att. 1 , Pg. 32 of 26 7 E I M E E Cl 1 401 Branding Lane , Su i te 255 Downe rs G r o v e , Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phon e (6 3 0) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 5 1 5-26 5 4 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel C o m p Ty p e 1PLl2JA Fl6 1PLl2JA Fl6 KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Tem p erature Comme n t Th r es ho l d (OF) Fl2 Fuse, Governor Bussman OTlO 225 The OT fuses are installed
in panel l PL l 2 J A. Based on NEC requirement
s, the fuses are s ized at lea st l 25% above the maximum load current and rounded up to the next available
fuse size. Therefor as long as the fuse is derated to more than 80% (1/1.25) of i ts rating , the fuse w i ll carry the load current and not provide a false trip. The OT is a Non-Dual Element Fuse. Attachment
F s hows that the current carrying capacity (% of rating) and Opening Time (%of rating) as a function of ambient temperature. Based on Attachment
F , the OT fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperature
of l 20&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore , even at operating
temperature
of 248&deg;F the fuse has 15% margin above the design maximum full load current. The cabinet temperature
rise i s 23&deg;F and the fuses will not provid e a false trip and carry the load current for an ambient temper a ture of 225&deg;f. Fl2-l Fuse, Governor Bussman OTlO 225 The OT fuses are installed
in panel 1PL!2JA. Based on NEC requirement
s, the fuses are sized at least 125% above the maximum load current and rounded up to the next available
fuse size. Therefor as long as the fuse i s derated to more than 80% (1/1.25) of i t s rating, the fuse will carry the l oad curre n t and not provide a false trip. The OT is a Non-Dual Element Fu se. Attachment
F shows that the current carrying capacity(% of rating) and Opening Time (% ofrating) as a function of ambient temperature. Based on Attachment
F , the OT fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperatur
e of 120&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore , even at operating
temperature
of 248&deg;F t h e fuse has 15% margin above the design max i mum full load current. The cab i net temperature
rise is 23&deg;F a n d the fuses will not provide a false trip and carry the load current for an ambient temperature
of225&deg;F. Importance
Y e ll ow Ye ll ow Page 32 o f 83 State p p 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 33 of 267 E I M E E Cl 1401 Branding lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove , Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type 1PL12JA UY IPL12JA UY KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Tem p e ratur e Comment Thre s hold (O f) 86 Lockout Relay , Hand ELECTROS 78050 234 This Lock Out R elay (LO R) is normally de-energized
and Reset WITCH e n erg i zed to trip and stop the E DG. Located in 1PL!2JA panel. The LOR was aged at 257&deg;F and therefore
the coil insulation
has a minimum temperature
rating of 257&deg;F. The relay has to p i ck up in the a bnormal temperature
environment.
The pick up voltage for a 125 VDC coil is 40 VDC at room ambient temperature (See Att a chment G). The pick up voltage will increase by 42% at an operating
temperature
257&deg;F to 57 VDC which less than the avai l ab l e voltage of 125 VDC. Accounting
for a cabinet temperature
rise of23&deg;F , the relay will pick up at 234&deg;F and trip the E DG. Note that this protective
feature is not required for this scenario since the EDG is assumed to be running normally. K34 Relay, Lockout GE 12HGA1 lJ 216 Located in panel I PL l 2J A. Under normal EOG operation , the Auxili a ry 52 relay is de-energized. This relay is energ i zed on overspeed
to shutdown and lockout EOG. Under normal EDG operation , the relay contacts are open and two open contacts are in series with the lock out relay 86. Per SQ-CLD-068 , the r e la y was aged at 2 l 2&deg;F and functionally
tested during an environmental
test at 1 72&deg;F. The open contacts due to dielectric
failure of the contact block aided by moisture.
The open contacts will not short circuit in an environment
of 239&deg;F (see Section V.1.3). Therefore , using the temperature
limit of239&deg;F and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperatu r e rise , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 2 l 6&deg;F and will not provide a false trip to s hutdown the EDG. Importance
Ye ll ow Ye ll ow Page 33 of 83 S tat e DE D E 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 3 4 of 2 6 7 E I M E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove , Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 5 15-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Pa n el C o m p Ty p e IPLl2JA IPLl2JA !HS-DG116 KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Desc r iption MF G PART N O T e m p e r a tur e Comme n t T hr eshol d (*F) KL Relay , LOCA Bypass GE CR l 20BDO 222 This relay is a normally de-energized
125 VDC relay (Owg E02-4341 I OG99, SH 010) and in s t a lled inside pan el I PLI 2JA. This relay is energized
on the onset of a LOCA signal (RPV level or high drywell pressure)
and the r elay contacts are used a s permi ssive for EOG operat ion. The relay pick up voltage measured by test at F AI under normal am b ient temperature
(20&deg;C) is 74.1 VDC (see Attachment
B). As the re l ay will be energized
on the onset of EOG start (LOCA a nd/or LOOP), the re l ay will p i ck up. Howeve r , the relay will be exposed to extreme temperatu r es both from the temperature
rise of the relay coil , abnormal temperature
around I P LI 2JA panel and panel temperature
rise of I PL I 2JA. Under this extreme temperatur
e, the relay coil insulation
s hould not lose its insulation
dielectric
strength for the coil to short circuit and the relay dropping out under the LOCA/LOOP
or LOOP environment.
The temperature
rise of the rela y at nominal terminal voltage of 125 VOC is I 8&deg;C (32.4&deg;F) [Reference
Vlll.6, Attachment
A]. The cubicle temperature
rise for IPL12 J A is 23&deg;F. Ass u ming the panel IPL12JA to be exposed to 222&deg;F after 24 hour s of E OG operation, t h e relay coil will be exposed to a total coil temperature
of277.4&deg;F
(222&deg;F ambient+ 23&deg;F cabinet tempera tur e rise+ 32.4&deg;F relay co i l temperature
ri se). The relay was aged at 280&deg;F fo r 784 hours (Nutherm Report EGC-9785 R , Rev. I , Page 33). The accelerated
aging temperature
of280&deg;F is more than coil temperature
of277.4&deg;F. In addition, the coil magnet wire insulatio n is po l yester with polyu r e t hane (Nutherm Re p ort EGC-9785R, Rev. I , Page 31) th at is r ated for 392&deg;F (System 1000 material numbers 338 , 340 and 551 , see Attachment
1-l). The r efore , the coil temperature
capability
exceeds the temperature
inside the panel IPL12JA by I 14.6&deg;F margin. Th e activation
energy of the coil magnet wire insulation
is 1.35 eV. Using Arrhenius
equation , the agi ng time of784 hours at 280&deg;F is equivalent
to 897 hours (37 days) at 277.4&deg;F. Therefore , the relay coil w i re will not degrade its electrical
properti es an d relay will not de-e nergize in one day of EOG operation
when the I PL! 2JA is exposed to 222&deg;F. Note also that shou l d the r elay drop out the EOG would con t inue to run unless other protective
r elays actuate, which does not need to be assumed for this scenario.
Sl8 Switch, Emergency
GE CR2940W 234 In s u l atio n material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel Stop K202H 1PL12JA. Reducing this temperatu r e by 23&deg;F to account for cabin e t temperature
rise, the co m ponent will function at 234&deg;F. I m po r tance Y e ll ow Yellow Page 34 of 83 S tate EIDE p 
EC 62 0 6 32 , Att. 1 , P g. 3 5 of 2 6 7 E I M E E E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane , Su i te 255 Downers Grove , Illinois , 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Pho n e (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Pa n e l C omp Ty p e lPLl2JA U Y lPLl2JA !HS-DG029 l PLl2JA SY lPLl2JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Descri p tion MFG PART NO Tempera tur e Comment Threshold
{oF) K3 R elay, Ove r s p eed P&B MDR 1 37-8 222 Pe r SQ-eLD-039 , the re l ay was aged at 125&deg;e (257&deg;F) and shutdown f u nctio n ally tested during an e n vironmental
test at 153&deg;F. Man u facturer rating is l 49&deg;F (see Attachment
J). This re l ay is normally de-energized
and only energized
under overspeed
condition
by speed switches S9 or S9A. Under normal EOG operation, the relay coil failu r e does not impact the EOG capability
of power generation.
An identical
relay (MOR 1 37-8) was aged at 225&deg;F energized
at 125 vo e for 24 ho u rs followe d with an exposure to 245&deg;F wh il e energized
at 125 voe for 8 ho ur s. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours oftest run. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EOG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Reference
VIII.6, Attachment
A). 86TS Test Switch WESTINGHO
129A501G 234 Insu l ation material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel USE 01 lPLl2JA. Reducing this temperature
by 23&deg;F to account for cabinet tem p eratu r e rise, t h e com p onent will function at 234&deg;F. K41X Relay Over speed Trip WESTINGHO
ARD420SR 216 Pe r SQ-eL0-063 , the r e l ay was aged at l 25&deg;C (257&deg;F) and USE functionally
tested during an environmenta
l test at l 53&deg;F. This relay is normally de-energized
and is energized
ifthe EOG speed reaches 1035 RPM. Under th i s condition , the relay is energized
for 2 seconds by relay K4 l. This re l ay shu t s down the fuel to the EOG by energ i zing L03 and L03A sole n oid. Under normal EOG operation (no over speed), this relay will be de-energized.
The open contacts will not short circuit in an environment
of 239&deg;F (see Section V.1.3). Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
r ise, the relay will not impact the EOG normal operation
and not provide a false trip to shutdown the ED in an ambient temperatu r e of 2 l 6&deg;F. A7 Potentiometer , Engine WOOOWAR 8271-099 234 Insulation
material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in pa n el Speed Raise, Lower D I PL! 2JA. Reducing this temperature
by 23&deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at 234 &deg;F. Importance
Yellow Ye ll ow Y e ll ow Y e ll ow Page 35 of 83 State DE p DE p 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , P g. 36 of 267 E I M E E E Cl 1401 Brand i ng Lane , Suite 255 Downe r s Grove , Ill i nois , 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 5 1 5-2650 * FAX (6 3 0) 5 15-26 54 www.kciconsultants.com
P a nel Comp Type 1PLl2JA
1PLl2JA 1PLl2JA KCI Report REP-424-008
-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan C omp D es cription MFG PART N O T em p erature C ommen t Thres ho ld (oF) TBl Terminal Block s 222 These a r e typically
GE EB25-12W terminal blocks (Drawing 61090 , Rev. H, She e t 2). Insulation
material wa s aged at 248&deg;F for 1072 hour s. The terminal block wa s functional
before , during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section 5.10 of Ref. Vlll.2). The contact block of r elays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;F and had there was no contact failure (Reference
Vlll.6, Attachment
A). Therefore , using 245&deg;F for any kind of terminal block and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperatu r e rise (conservative), t h e terminal block will not impact the EOG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. TBI Terminal Blocks 222 These are typically
GE EB25-12W terminal blocks (Drawing 61090 , Rev. H, Sheet 2). Insulation
material was aged at 248&deg;F for 1072 hours. The terminal block was functional
before, during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section 5 .10 of Ref. VIIl.2). The contact block ofrclays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;F and had there was no contact failure (Reference
VIIl.6 , Attachment
A). Therefore, using 245&deg;F for any kind of terminal block and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise (conservative), the terminal block will not impact the EOG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. TBll , Term i nal Block s 222 These a r e typically
GE EB25-12W termin a l blocks (Drawing TBPS 61090 , Rev. H, Sheet 2). Insulation
material was aged at 248&deg;F for 1072 hours. The terminal block was functional
before, during and after the therma l aging regimen (Section 5.10 of Ref. VllI.2). The cont a ct block of relays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;F and had there was no contact failure (Reference
Vlll.6 , Attachment
A). Therefore , using 245&deg;F for any kind of terminal block and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise (con s ervative), the terminal block will not impact the EOG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. Importanc e Y e ll ow Y e llow Yellow Page 36 o f 83 Stat e p p p 
E C 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 3 7 o f 267 E I M E E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove , Illi n ois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www .kciconsultants.com
Pa n el Comp Type 1PLl 2JA I PLl2JA I PLl2JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Com p Desc r ipti on MFG PART NO Te mp erature Comme n t T h res h ol d (OF) TB12 T e rm inal Bl o ck s 2 22 These a r e typ i ca ll y GE EB25-I 2 W te rmin a l bl ocks (D r awing 6 1 090, R ev. H , Sheet 2). Ins u lat i on m a teri a l wa s aged at 248&deg;F for I 072 hour s. Th e terminal b l ock wa s functiona l before , durin g and a ft er th e therma l agin g re g im e n (Sectio n 5.1 0 of R e f. V Il l.2). The contact block of relays having s imilar material wa s ag ed a t 245&deg;F and h a d th e re was no c o n tact fail u re (Refere n ce VIII.6 , Attachm e nt A). The r e fore , u s ing 245&deg;F fo r any kind of t e rmi n al bloc k and a c count ing a 23&deg;F ca bine t temperature
rise (con s ervat i ve), t h e terminal b l ock wi ll n ot i m pact the EOG no rm al o p eration i n an a mbi e n t tem p eratu r e of222&deg;F. TBl2 T ermin a l Block s 222 Th es e a re typic a lly G E EB25-12W termina l b locks (D rawing 6 10 9 0 , Rev. H , She e t 2). In s ulation m a ter i al wa s aged at 248&deg;F fo r I 072 hour s. Th e t e rmina l block wa s func t ional before , durin g and a ft er the therma l a gi n g r e gimen (S e ction 5. I 0 of R e f. VIII.2). The c o nt a ct block of r elays having simi l ar ma t eria l w a s ag ed at 245&deg;F a nd h a d th ere was no cont a ct failure (Reference
Vlll.6 , Attachment
A). Th e r e fore , usin g 245&deg;F for any kind of termina l blo c k an d acco u nting a 23&deg;F cabinet temperatu r e ri s e (con s ervative), the t ermina l b l ock will not impact the EOG normal op e ration i n an a mbient temperature
o f 222&deg;F. TBl2 T e rm i n a l Bl oc k s 222 Th ese ar e typic a lly G E EB 2 5-12W t e rmin a l bloc k s (Dr a win g 6 10 9 0 , Rev. H , Sh ee t 2). In s u l ation m a teri a l wa s aged at 24 8&deg;F for I 072 hours. The t e rminal block was func t ional before , during and after the thermal agi n g regimen (Section 5. I 0 of R e f. VIll.2). T h e contact b l ock ofre l ays having simi l ar ma t erial w a s a g ed at 245&deg;F and h a d there was no cont a ct fai l ur e (Referenc e VIIl.6, Attachmen t A). Th e r efore , usi n g 245&deg;F for any kind of terminal block an d acco u nting a 23&deg;F cabi n et tem p era t u r e rise (co n s ervative), th e t e rminal block will not impact the E O G n o rm a l op e rati o n i n an ambi e nt t e mp e rature o f 222&deg;F. Impo r tance Yello w Ye ll ow Yellow Page 37 of 83 State p p p 
EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 38 of 267 E I M E E E E E Cl 1401 Brand i ng Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove , Ill i no is, 605 1 5 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 5 1 5-26 5 0 * FAX (6 3 0) 5 1 5-26 54 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Co m p Ty p e 1PLI2JA 1PLl2JA 1PLl2JA IDGOlJA IOGOIJA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comme n t T h reshold (OF) TB15 Terminal Blocks 222 These are typically
GE EB25-12W terminal blocks (Drawing 61090 , Rev. H, Sheet 2). In s ulation material wa s aged at 248&deg;F for I 072 hours. The terminal block
was fw1ctional
before , during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section 5.10 of Ref. VIII.2). The contact block of relays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;F and had there was no contact failure (Reference
YIIl.6 , Attachment
A). Therefore , usin g 245&deg;F for any kind of terminal block and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise (con s ervative), the terminal block will not impact the EOG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. TB15 Terminal Blocks 222 The s e are typically
GE EB25-12W terminal blocks (Drawin g 61090 , Rev. H , She e t 2). Insulation
material was aged at 248&deg;F for 1072 hours. The terminal block was functiona l before , during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section 5.10 of Ref. Vlll.2). The contact block of relays having similar material w a s aged at 245&deg;F and had there was no contact fa i lure (Reference
VIIl.6 , Attachment
A). Therefore , using 245&deg;F for any kind of terminal block and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise (conservative), the terminal block
will not impact the EOG normal o p eration in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. TBl7 Termina l Block s 222 These a r e typically
GE EB25-12W terminal blocks (Drawing 61090 , Rev. H , Sheet 2). Insulation
material was aged at 248&deg;F for 1072 hours. Th e terminal block was functiona l before , during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section 5.10 of Ref. VIII.2). The contact block of r elays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;F and had there was no contact failure (Reference
YIIl.6 , Attachment
A). Therefore, using 245&deg;F for any kind of terminal block and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise (conservative
), the terminal block will not impact the EOG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. T4 Transformer , Neutral GE 9T28Y560l
Not Required Non-IE. The neutral grounding
transformer
is required to detect Grounding
forEDG grounding
fault vo l tage. Under normal EDG operation
a ground Operation
fault is not postu l ated. RI Re s istor , Grounding
WESTIN GHQ 6-Not Requir e d Non-IE. The groundin g re s i s tor limits the ground fault curren t. US E R20SED40 forEDG Under normal EDG oper a tion a ground fault i s not postulated. 0 Operation
Importance
Yellow Yellow Yellow Pink Pink Page 38 o f 83 State p p p ON p 
EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 39 of 267 E I M E E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane , Suite 2SS Downers Grove , Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630} 515-2650 * FAX (630} 5 1 5-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel C om p Type IDGOIKA lPS-DG063B lDGOIKA JPS-DG062B IDGOlKA ITS-DGOllA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Des c ri p t i on MFG PART NO Tem p e r ature Comment Thresho l d (OF) Sl9 Low Oil Pressure EMD 8358930 239 Aged at 257&deg;F and has no temperature
sensitive
components. (Shutdown)
Located in panel 1DGO1 KA. This panel has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C ( ! 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise , the device is operational
at 239&deg;F. S19A Low Oil Pressure EMD 8358930 239 Aged at 257&deg;F and has no temperature
sensitive
components. (Shutdown)
Located in panel I DGO I KA. This panel has components
that prod u ce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a I 0&deg;C (l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise , the device is operational
at 239&deg;F. S25 High Coo l ant SQUARED 9012-239 The temperature
switch closes when the coo l ant temperature
Temperature
AEW-42 exceed above 205&deg;F and energizes
relay K35 and relay K35 (Shutdown)
contacts energize the lock out relay tripping the EDG. Under normal EDG operation
the S25 switch will not actuate. The temperature
switch is an immersion
type switch. The thermal element of the switch contains a liquid that boils when a predetermined
temperature
is reached. The expansion
of the liquid when it vaporizes
causes a pressure to be exerted upon a metal bellows located inside the coupling connection. The be ll ows is connected
to a pl unger which actuates the electrical
switch (Refe r ence VTIP K-286 IB-0002). The switc h has a rating of260&deg;F , an operating
range of 145-210&deg;F and a set-point
of205&deg;F (Reference
PASSPORT). On a diesel that is running prope r ly (i.e. maintaining
-I 70&deg;F) the switch contacts would be open. Since the thermal element is immersed in the d iesel jacket water that is maintained
a t -I 70&deg;F increased
area temperature
s will have no impact on the switch. The open contacts do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material failure (Se e Section V.1.3). As the switch is not in the panel , the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of 239&deg;F and will not provide a false trip below thi s temperature. Importance
Pink Pink Pink Page 39 o f 83 State DE DE DE 
EC 620632, Att. 1 , Pg. 40 of 267 E I M E Cl 1401 Branding lane , Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IDGOIKA ITS-DG012A KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Tem p eratu r e Comment Threshold (OF) S25A High Coo la nt SQUARED 9 012-23 9 The temperature
s witch clo s e s when the coolant temperature
Temperatur
e AEW-42 e xceed above 205&deg;F and energi z e s rela y K35 and relay K35 (Shutdown) contacts energi z e the lock out relay tripping the EDG. Under normal EDG operation
the S25A s witch will not actuate. The temperature
switch is an immersion
type switch. The therma l element of the switch contain s a liquid that boil s when a predetermined
temperature
is reached. The expansion
of the liquid when it vaporizes
causes a pres s ure to be exerted upon a metal bellows located inside the coupling connection. The bellows i s connected
to a plunger which actuates the electrical
s witch (Reference
VTIP K-2 861B-0002).
The switch has a rating of260&deg;F , an operating
ran g e of 145-210&deg;F and a set-point
o f 205&deg;F (Reference
PASSPORT). On a diesel that is runnin g properly (i.e. maintaining
-170&deg;F) the switch contacts would b e op e n. Since th e thermal elem e nt is immer se d in the die s el jacket wat e r that is maintained
at -I 70&deg;F i ncreased area temperatures
will ha v e no impact on the switch. The open contacts do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material failure (See Section V.1.3). As the switch is not in the panel , the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of 239&deg;F and will not provide a fa l se trip below this temperature. Importance
Pink Page 40 of 83 I State DE 
Att. Cl 1 , Pg. 41 of 267 1401 Branding lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 5 15-2 650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
E Panel Comp I Type M E IPLl2JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Thresho ld (OF) K5 Relay, Safety Setup A gas tat 7012PD 222 This relay is energized
after l 25RPM. This relay bas a 50 Time Delay second delay , which prevents false alarm indication
and protective
shutdown during startup due to low oil pressure or high engine coolant temperature. The K5 relay prevents tripping from S19A , S25A, Sl9 and S25 during the first 50 seconds (E02-IDG99 sht. 008 and 010). If the relay drops out it will simply prevent the tripping of the EDG due to high temperature
or low pressure via S19A, S25A, Sl9 and S25 which is not an issue for a properly running EDG. See comment for Relay K41. This family ofrelays (Agastat 7012 series) was functionally
tested while being aged at 225&deg;F energized
at 125 VDC for 24 hours. The relay did not drop out or the open contacts did not short out. The relay was aged at 245&deg;F for another 8 hours and experienced
drop out. The relay was then aged at 238&deg;F energized
at 125 VDC for 24 hours and did not experience
drop out or short out. Since drop out of this relay would only serve to eliminate
protective
trips of the EDG, as stated above, the relay would not trip the EDG and the relay will not short at 245&deg;F. This relay is located in 1PLl2JA panel; accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. (see Reference
VIII.6 , Attachment
A) . Importance
Pink Page 41 of 83 I State EN 
E C 62 0 632 , Att. 1 , P g. 42 of 2 6 7 E I M E E . Cl 1401 Branding l ane, Su i te 255 Downe r s Grove , Ill i nois , 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630} 515-2650 * FAX (630} 5 1 5-26 54 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel C o m p T y p e IPLl2JA R20 IPLl2JA UY KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Co m p D escri p tio n MFG PART NO Te mp erat u re Com m e n t T hr es hol d (O F) 590 Relay, Ground GE 121AV51D 216 Thi s r e l ay operat es o n a voltage in pu t from th e ne u tral groun d Dete c tin g IA tr a n s former (T4) b y energizing
59GX rel a y th a t pick s up a K36 relay and K36 relay energizes
the lock out rela y 86 that trip s the E DG (E02-IDG99 , Sheet 13 , Rev. F; E 0 2-1APl2 , Sheet 031 , R e v. J; E02-IDG99 , Sheet 11, Rev. S; E 02-IDG99, Sheet 10 , Rev. Z). Under n o rmal EDG operation, the voltage across the ne u tral ground transformer
T4 will b e zero (ba l anced vo l tage and n o ground fault) and therefore
there will be no voltage across this relay to change the state of the relay. The open contacts will not short ci r c u it in an environment
of239&deg;F (see Section V.1.3). Therefore , using the t e mperature
l i m i t of239&deg;F and accounting
a 23&deg;F cab in et temperature
rise, the re l ay will n ot impact the EDG normal o p eration in an ambient temperature
of216&deg;F and will not provide a false trip to shu td own the EDG. K35 Relay , Lockout GE 12HGAllJ 216 Located in panel IPLl2JA. Under normal EDG operation , the Aux i liary 52 relay is d e-energized. This re l ay is energized
on over coolant temperature
or low oil pressure to pickup the locko u t re l ay and s h utdown E D G. Under normal EDG operation , the relay contacts are open and two open contact s are in series with the lock out re l ay 86. Per SQ-CLD-068 , the relay was aged at 2 I 2&deg;F and functio n ally tested during an environmental
test at l 72&deg;F. The open contacts due to di e l ectric fa i l u re of the contact b l ock a id e d by moisture.
The ope n co n tacts will not short c ir c u it i n an enviro nm e n t of 239&deg;F (see Section V.1.3). Therefore , using the temperature
limit of239&deg;F and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet tem p erature ri s e , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an a mbient temperature
of 2 l 6&deg;F and wi ll not provide a fa l se trip to s hu tdown the EDG. Importa n ce Pink Pink Page 42 of 83 J State ON DE 
EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 43 of 267 E I M E E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Su i te 255 Downe r s Grove , Illino i s , 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Co mp Type 1PL12JA UY 1PL12JA
1PL12JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Descri p tion MFG PART NO Te mp e r atu r e Comme n t Threshold (OF) K36 Relay, Lockout GE 12HGA11J 216 Located in panel 1PL!2JA. Under normal EOG operation , the Auxiliary
52 relay is de-energized.
This re l ay is energized
on generator
fault to pickup the lockout relay and shutdown EOG. Under normal EDG operation , the relay contacts are open and two open contacts are in series with the lock out relay 86. Per SQ-CLD-068 , the relay was aged at 212&deg;F and functionally
tested during an environmental
test at l 72&deg;F. The open contacts due to dielectric
fail u re of the contact block aided by moisture. The open contacts will not short circuit in an environment
of 239&deg;F (see Section V.1.3). Using the temperature
limit of 239&deg;F and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 2 l 6&deg;F and will not provide a false trip to shutdown the EDG. RIO Resistor , Target Trip OHMITE 0402 Age Located in panel I PL! 2JA. The resistors
use alloys whose 500 ohm Insensitive
ohmic values change very little with tempe
.rature and use Ceramic as the insulating
material (See Attachment
I). Ceramic can withstand
high temperatures
above 1000&deg;C and therefore
these resistors
are age-insensitive. Conservatively
ass u med not affecte d b elow 500&deg;F. R7 , 8 , 9 Resistor , Target Trip OHMlTE 0402 Age Located in panel 1PL!2JA. The resi s tors use alloys whose 500 ohm Insensitive
ohmic values change very little with temperature
and use Ceramic as the insulating
material (See Attachment
I). Ceramic can withstand
high temperatures
above l 000&deg;C and therefore
these resisto r s are age-insensitive.
Conservatively
assumed not affected below 500&deg;F. Im po rtance Pink Pink Pink Page 43 of 83 State DE p p 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 44 of 267 E I M E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Su i te 255 Downers Grove, Illino i s , 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 5 1 5-265 4 www.kciconsultants
.com Panel C o mp Ty p e 1PLl2JA R20 IPLl2JA R20 KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Threshold (OF) 32X Relay, Reverse Power P&B MDRl37-8 222 Per SQ-CLD-039 , the relay was aged at 125&deg;C (257&deg;F) and Aux functionally
tested during an environmental
test at 153&deg;F. Manufacturer
rating i s 149&deg;F (see Attachment
J). This relay is normally energized
after EDG start and remains de-energized
for EDG n ormal operation. This relay is e n ergized under reverse powe r flow to the EDG. For n orma l operation
of the EDG, the relay coi l failure does not impact the EDG capability
of power generation
as the coil is de-energ i zed. An identical
r elay (MDR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;F energ i zed at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed with an expo s ure to 245&deg;F while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours of test run. Accounting
for a 23 &deg;F cubicle temperatur
e rise , the relay will not impact the EDG norm a l operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Reference
VIII.6, Attachment
A). 40X Relay, Loss of P&B MDR137-8 222 Per SQ-CLD-039 , the relay was aged at 125&deg;C (257&deg;F) and Excitation
Aux fu n ctionally
tested during an environmental
test at I 53&deg;F. Manufacturer
rating is I 49&deg;F (see Attachment
J). This r elay i s norma ll y energized
after EDG start and remains de-energized
for EDG norma l opera t ion. This relay is energized
under loss of excitation
when EDG i s running. Fo r norma l operation
of the E DG , the relay coil failure does not impact the EDG capability
of power generation
as the coil is de-ene r gized. An identical
relay (MDR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;F energi ze d at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F whil e e nergized at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not s hort circuit throughout
the 32 hours oftest run. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Reference
Vill.6, Attachment
A). Importa n ce Pink Pink Page 44 of 83 State DE DE 
L EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 45 of 267 E I M E E E Cl 1401 Branding lane , Suite 255 Downer s Grove , Illinois , 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Pho n e (630) 5 1 5-2 6 5 0 * FAX (6 3 0) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel C o mp Type IPLl2JA R20 IPL12JA R20 1PLl2JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diese l Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Threshold (OF) 51VX Voltage Restrained
P&B MDR137-8 222 Per SQ-CLD-039, the relay was aged at 125&deg;C (257&deg;F) and Overcurrent
Aux functionally
tested during an envirorunental
test at 153 &deg;F. Manufacturer
rating is I 49&deg;F (see Attachment
J). This relay is normally energized
after EDG start and remains de-energized
for EOG normal operation. This relay is energized
under over current condition
when EDG is running. For normal operation
of the EDG , the re l ay coil failure does not impact the EOG capability
of power generation
as the relay is de-energized.
An identical
relay (MDR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;F ene r gized at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not s hort circuit throughout
the 32 hours of test run. Accounting
for a 23 &deg;F cubicle temperature
rise , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Reference
VIII.6 , Attachment
A). 59GX Relay, Ground P&B MDR137-8 222 Per SQ-CLD-039, the relay was aged at 125&deg;C (257&deg;F) and Detect i ng Aux functionally
tested during an environmental
test at 153&deg;F. Manufacturer
rating i s 149&deg;F (see Attachment
J). This relay is normally energized
after EDG start and remains de-energized
for EDG normal operation. This relay is energized
under a phase to ground fault when EDG is running. For normal operation
of the EDG , the relay coil failure does not impact the EDG capability
of power generation
as the relay is de-energized.
An identical
relay (MDR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;F energized
at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours of test run. Accounting
for a 23 &deg;F cubicle tempe r ature rise , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operat i on in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Reference
VIlI.6, Attachment
A). K6 Relay , Field Flash Agastat 7012PC 222 This relay is required for EDG start and de-energized
after EDG Time Delay picks up speed. See comment for Relay K41. Importance
Pink Pink Blue P a ge 45 o f 83 State DE DE DE 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 46 o f 267 E I M E E E E E Cl 1 401 Brand i ng Lane , Su it e 255 Do w n ers G r ove , Illino i s , 605 1 5 E NGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
P h o n e (6 3 0) 515-265 0 * FAX (6 30) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IPL12JA IPLl2JA !HS-DGl28 IPL12JA !HS-DG130 1PLl2JA !HS-DGJJO lPL12JA lUAY-DG29l KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Descr i ption MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment T h resho l d (DF) T2 Transformer , Isolation
BASLER BE-10493-Not Required Hand switch S4 removes this transformer
from energizing
in Manual Volt Adjust 001 for EDG start "Auto" mode. or Ooeration
SI I Switch, Governor GE IOAA065 216 This is an SBM switch. Insulation
material was aged at 185&deg;F Adjust (EQ-GEN063).
Located in IPL12JA. The open contacts will not short circuit in an environment
of 239&deg;F (see Section V.1.3). Therefore, using the temperature
limit of239&deg;F and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise , the switch will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 2 l 6&deg;F and will not provide a false trip to shutdown the EDG. Sl2 Switch, Voltage GE IOAA065 216 This is an SBM switch. Ins ul ation material was aged at I 85&deg;F Adjust (EQ-GEN063). Located in IPL12JA. The open contacts will not short circuit in an environment
of 239&deg;F (sec Section V. l .3). Therefore , using the temperature
limit of239&deg;F and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise , the switch will n ot impact the EOG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 2 l 6&deg;F and will not provide a false trip to shutdown the EDG. S4 Switch, Voltage GE 10CH685 216 This is an SBM switch. Insulation
material was aged at J 85&deg;F Regulator (EQ-GEN063).
Located in JPL12JA. The open contacts will not short circuit in an environment
of 239&deg;F (see Section V.1.3). Therefore , using the temperature
limit of239&deg;F and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise , the switch will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of216&deg;F and will not provide a false trip to shutdown the EDG. KIR Relay, Idling GE CR120BDO Not Required Energized
when EDG is idling (DWG E02-IDG99, SH 8). 4341 for EDG start Re l ay is D e-energized
to run in "Auto" mode. Only closed or Oneration
contacts are used to interlock
various components. Importance
Blue Blue Blue Blue Blue Page 46 of 83 J State ON p p p DE 
EC 620632, Att. 1 , Pg. 4 7 of 267 E I M E E E E E E E Cl 1401 Brandi n g Lane , Su i te 255 Downers Grove , Illinois , 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-26 5 0 * FAX {630) 5 1 5-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Co m p Ty p e I P L12JA !HS-DG291 1PL12JA IPLl2JA IPLl2JA IP Ll 2JA IPLl2JA IPLl2JA EC KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Desc r iption MFG PART NO Te mp e r ature Comment Threshold (OF) SW-IDLE Sw i tch, Run Idle GE SB! 216 The switch is n ormally open and c l osed for idling the EDG. Insu l ation material was aged at 180&deg;F. SB-I and SBM switch have same material of construction. Located in panel I PL! 2 J A. The open contacts will not short circuit in an environment
of 239&deg;F (see Section V.1.3). The r efore , using the temperature
limit of239&deg;F and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet tempera tu re rise , the switch will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an amb i ent temperature
of 2 I 6&deg;F. CR! R ect i fier , Field F l ash MOTOROLA INil98 234 Aged at 257&deg;F. Diodes are age insensitive.
Reducing th i s temperature
b y 23 &deg;F to acco u nt for cabinet temperature
rise , the component
wi ll function at 234&deg;F. R6 Resistor , Fie l d Shunt OHMITE 0701 Age Located in panel IPL12JA. The resistors
use alloys whose 25 ohm Insensitive
ohmic values change very little with temperature
and use Ceramic as the insulating
material (See Attachment
I). Ceramic can withstan d h i gh tem p era tu res above I 000&deg;C and therefore
these r esis t ors are age-i n sensitive.
Conservatively
assumed not affected be l ow 500&deg;F. Rl4 Resistor, Field OHMITE 0902 Age Located in pane l I PL! 2JA. The resistors
use alloys whose Flashing Insensitive
ohmic values change very little with temperature
and u se Ceramic as the insu l ating material (See Attachment
I). Ceramic can withstand
high temperatures
above I 000&deg;C and therefore
these resis t ors are age-in se nsitive. Conservatively
assumed not affecte d below 500&deg;F. K43 Relay, Voltage Ra i se P&B MDRl37-8 Not Req u ired This re l ay u sed to raise EDG voltage manua ll y from a re m ote forEDG panel by provi d ing i np u t to RI I. Operation
K44 Relay, Vo ltag e Lower P&B MDR137-8 Not Required This relay used to lower EDG voltage manually from a remote forEDG panel by providing
input to R 11. Ooe r a t ion Al2 Manual Voltage S&SS 13595 Not Non-IE. The voltage contro l device is removed from EDG Control Assembly Connected. voltage under "A uto" operation.
Importa n ce Blue Blue Blue Blue Blue Blue Blue Page 47 of 83 State p p p p DE DE ON 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 48 of 267 E I M E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane , Suite 255 Downers Grove, Ill i no i s , 605 1 5 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * F AX (6 3 0) 515-2 6 54 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type 1PLl2JA UY 1PL92JA KY KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comme n t Threshold (OF) K7 Relay, Aux Field Flash WESTINGHO
ARD440SR Not required This relay is energized
field flash and de-energized
for EOG USE for EOG normal operation. operation
and will not Insulation
material was aged at 257&deg;F. Under normal EOG provide a fa l se operation
after field flash, this relay will not be energized.
The trip open contacts will not short circuit in a n environment
of 239&deg;F (see Section V.1.3) and will not provide a false trip to shutdown the EOG. Al4 Breaker Closi n g BASLER 90-68200-Not Required The equalizing
timer is a permiss i ve device that delays t h e start Equalizing
Timer 100 during EOG of the SX p ump on a dead bus when the EDG auto starts. The Run timer contacts allow the breaker to close. This is to keep the EOG from loading the entire bus load at the same time. Once the timer is activated
on a start signal , and the pump is started, this component
is no longer needed. The failure of the timer contact (open contacts to close) will not de-energize
the trip coil of the breaker. The SX pump moto r gets l oaded at I 0 seconds after the EOG start (ref e rence USAR Tab l e 8.3-13). Under no rm al operation
of the EOG, the fai lu re of the timer contac t will n ot impact the co n tinue d operation
of the EOG or the SX pump motor. Aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel IPL92JA. There is no panel temperature
rise. Importance
Blue Blue Page 48 o f 83 I State DE ON 
EC 620632 , At t. 1 , P g. 4 9 of 26 7 E I M E Cl 1 401 Brand i ng Lane , Suite 255 Downers Gr o ve, Illino i s, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Pa n e l C o mp Ty p e IP L 9 2J A R2 0 KCI Report R E P-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp D es cript io n MFG PART NO Te mp e r a tur e Comme n t T h resho l d (oF) A13 Field Co n dit i oning S&SS STC-4 3 71 239 Th e Al3 (Fiel d Co nd itioning R elay As s em bl y) r e l ay is e n e r gize d R elay Assembly after t h e LP CS pump m otor gets l oa d ed i mm ediate l y afte r t h e EDG start (Reference
USAR T ab l e 8.3-13) aod the SX p u mp motor gets loaded a t I 0 se c on d s after the EOG start (r eference USAR Table 8.3-13) (See Drawing E02-IDG99, S h t 0 1 6 , Re v. P). The A l 3 re l a y is energized
with 125 VDC and re l ay Kl contact seal in the LPCS ao d SX contac t s that ene r gized the Al3 relay (Dwg STC-4373, R ev. A aod Attachme n t M). Re l ay K2 and K3 are e n e r gize d an d a 9 0 ohms resistance (RI 5) i s pu t in series w ith the RI I (a u toma ti c volta g e co n tro l r esis t o r fo r th e Vo l tage R egu l a t or) that increase the vo l tage across the exciter windi n g b y the vo l tage regu l ator. After few seco n ds (based on the t i ming circu i t ofQ2 aod Q5), th e re l ay s K2 and K3 get de-e n ergize d. After the K2 an d K3 relays are de-energized, 65 ohms (R l6) comes i n series with the RI I for norma l E D G ope r at i o n (Dwg STC-4373, R ev. A a nd Attac hm e n t M). Th is a ll h a p pens with in few secon d s a fter the E D G start when th e temperatu re i n pane l I PL92JA is sti ll no rma l. Ba s ed o n SQ-CLD-049 , the Al3 relay was therma ll y aged at l 25&deg;C (257&deg;F) for 7 8 days with no signs of degradation. It wa s functionally
check ed b e fore and after aging. It was also functiona ll y tested (i.e. cycle d) wh i le u ndergoing
a thermal extremes t est at 153&deg;F. Th e r efo r e th e re l ay will perform its fu n ction afte r EDG starts. For c ontin uou s o peration o f th e EOG, the ope n co n tact ofK3 re l a y sho ul d not s h ort and R16 re s istance should remain at 60 ohms. As the re l ay was aged at 2 5 7&deg;F , the R 16 pote nt iometer wi II mai n tain its res i stance. The o p en contacts wi ll no t s h ort circ u it in a n enviro n ment of239&deg;F (s ee Sect i on V.1.3). There i s no pane l temperature
ri s e as the re i s no h eat gene r ating componen t s in this local p ane l. Therefore
the K3 r elay w ill not sho rt at a t e mp erature li m i t o f 239&deg;F an d Al3 r e l ay wi ll not impact the co n tin u e d o p eration of the EDG. I m po r tance B lu e Page 4 9 of 83 I State ON 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , P g. 5 0 of 2 6 7 E I M E E E E E E E Cl 1 40 1 Branding Lane , Suite 255 Downe rs G r ove , Illino i s , 605 1 5 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 5 1 5-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Co mp T yp e IP L9 3J A KY IDGOIKA Sol IDGOIKA Sol ID GO I KA Sol IDGOIKA Sol IDGOIKA MOTOR IDGO I KA MO T OR KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp D es cr ipt i on MFG PART N O Te mp e r atu r e Com m e n t T h res hold (OF) Al4 Breake r Closi n g BASLER 90-68200-Not R e qui red The e qu alizi n g ti m e r is a pe rmi ssive d evice t h at d elays t h e s tart Equaliz i ng T i mer 100 during EOG o f the L P pu mp on a dea d bus w h en the E O G auto starts. Th e Run t i mer contacts a ll ow the breake r to close. This i s to keep the E OG fr o m loa d ing the entire b u s load at th e same time. Once the ti m er is activa t ed o n a start signa l , an d th e pu m p is started , th i s co mpon e n t i s n o l onger n eede d. The fa ilure of the tim e r contac t (th at is op e n contac t s to close) wi ll n ot de-energize
the tri p co i l of th e br eake r. The L PCS pump m oto r gets l oade d at i mme di ately after the EOG start (Referen c e USAR Tab l e 8.3-13). Un d er normal operation
of the EOG , the failu r e of the timer contact will not impact the co n tinued operation
of the E OG or the L PCS pump motor. Age d at 257&deg;F. Located in p a n el I P L92 J A. The r e is no pane l tem p eratu r e rise. LOI So l enoid Air Start E MO 9 08 1 1 3 5 Not Requ ir ed Not req uir ed afte r EOG s tart. for E O G Operation
LO IA Solenoid Air St a rt E MO 90 8 1135 N ot Requir e d Not requi r ed a ft e r EOG s tart. fo r EDG Operation
L0 2 Solenoid Ai r S t a rt EMO 9081135 Not R eq u ired Not req u i r e d a fter E OG s tart. for EOG Op e ra ti o n L0 2A S ol eno i d Ai r S ta rt E MO 9 0 8 1135 Not Requ i r e d Not required aft e r E OG s tart. for E OG Operation
K.3 2 Motor St a rter, T urbo !TE P202 C l2 1 Not Required Not requir e d a ft e r E OG s tart. So a k back for EOG Operation
K32A Motor St a rt e r , Turbo IT E P202Cl21 Not Requir e d Not required a ft e r E OG s t a rt. So a k ba c k forEDG Opera t ion I m p o rta n ce Blue Gre e n Gr ee n Green
Gr e en Gr ee n Gr ee n Page 50 of 83 I State ON DE DE DE D E OFF
OFF 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , P g. 51 of 2 6 7 E I M E E E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 5 1 5-2650 * FAX (630) 5 1 5-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type lDGOlKA MOTOR lDGO!KA MOTOR lDGOlKA !PS-DG063C lDGO I KA !PS-DG062C KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Te mperatur e Com ment Threshold (OF) K33 Motor Starter, Fuel ITE P202Cl21 Not Required Not required after EDG start. Prime fo r EDG Operation
K33A Motor Starter , Fuel ITE P202C!21 Not Required Not required after E DG start. Prime forEDG Operation
S24 Cranking Motor SQUARED 9012-Not Required This pressure switch opens if the oil pressure i s above 20 psig Lockout ACW-21 fo r EDG and l ocks out the e n g ine cranking.
Not required after EDG start. Operation
Located in panel lDGOIKA. The switch contact does not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
failure (See Section V .1.3 ). This panel bas components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
a ss uming a 10&deg;C (l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise , the switch will function at an am bi ent temperature
of221&deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
S24A Cranking Motor SQUARED 9012-Not Required This pressure switch opens ifthe oil pressure is above 20 psig Lockout ACW-21 forEDG and locks o u t the engine cranking. Not required after EDG start. Operation
Located in panel IDGOlKA. The switch contact does not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
fa ilu re (See Section V.1.3). This panel has c ompo n ents that produce low heat. Conservatively
a ss uming a 10&deg;C (l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperatur
e ri s e, the switch will funct i on at an ambient temperature
of 221&deg;F and will not pro vide a false trip below this temperature. Importa nc e Green Green Gre e n Green Page 51of83 I State OFF
OFF D E DE 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 52 of 267 E I M E E Cl 1401 Brand i ng lane , Suite 255 Downe rs G r ove , Illino i s , 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (6 3 0) 515-26 54 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IDGOIKA !SE-DG308A IDGOIKA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Tempe r ature Comment Threshold (OF) A3SE Speed Switch WOODWAR 5430-929 225 A magnetic speed sensor consists of an iron cored coil with a Magnetic P i ck-up D magnet attached to one end. When a piece o f ferrous metal is mo v ed towards the e nd of the sensor it changes the shape of the magnetic field in the coil , this changing magnetic field then induces current to flow in the windings of the coil resulting
in a small amount of el e ctricity being generated
each time the gear tooth moves past it. The engine speed is a function of the frequency
of the pulse (Reference
VTIP K2861-002A). There would be no change in frequency
at elevated temperatures
since the frequency
is a function of engine RPM and number of teeth. The sensor is attached to the lower part of the engine which would be cool compar e d to the rest of the room since the en g ine coolant is maintain e d to -I 70&deg;F. These types of sensors are robust and the operating
temperature
range of the device is -67 to 225&deg;F (Referenc e: Passport Equipment
Parameters). In addition , this failure of device ha s no con s equence on the continuous
operat i on of the EDG. See device"A3PS" for more information. TB7, TBD Term i nal Blocks 227 These are typically
GE EB25-12W terminal blocks (Drawing 61090 , Rev. H , Sheet 2). Insulation
material was aged at 248&deg;F for I 072 hours. The terminal block was functional
before , during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section 5 .I 0 of Ref. Vlll.2). The contact block of relays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;F and had there was no contact failure (Reference
VIII.6 , Attachment
A). Therefore, using 245&deg;F for any kind of terminal block and acco tm ting a I 0&deg;C (I 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
ri s e (con s erv a tive), the terminal block will not impact the EOG normal operation
i n an ambient temperature
of 227&deg;F. Importance
Green Gre e n Page 52 of 83 State ON p 
EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 53 of 267 E I M E E E E Cl 1 401 B r anding Lane , Suite 255 Downe r s Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENG I NEE R I NG CO N SULTANT S Ph o n e (6 30) 515-2650 * F AX (630) 5 1 5-265 4 www.kciconsultants.com
Pa n el C o mp Type IDG-OlKA 1PL12JA UY 1PLl2JA Fl6 1PL12JA Fl6 KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diese l Ventilat i on VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Threshold (OF) TBS, TBD Terminal Blocks 227 These are typically
GE EB25-12W terminal b l ocks (Drawing 61090, Rev. H, Sheet 2). Insulation material
was aged at 248&deg;F for 1072 hours. The termina l block was functional
before, during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section 5.10 of Ref. Vill.2). The contact block of relays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;F and had there was no contact failure (Reference
Vill.6 , Attachment
A). Therefore, using 245&deg;F for any kind of terminal block and accounting
a 10&deg;C (l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise (conservative), the termina l b lock will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 227&deg;F. Kl7 Relay, Over Crank Agastat 7012PD 222 This relay is energized
for 10 seconds. After EDG reaches 125 Timer RPM , this relay is de-energized.
See comment for Relay K4 l. F06 Fuse, Turbo Soak back Bussman FRN-10 Not Required Not requi r ed after EDG start as the turbo sack back motors are 250VFusetron
after EDG not required for EDG operation. Aged at 257&deg;F. De r ated to start or 70% at l 85&deg;F operating
temperature.
Fuses are sized minimum Operation
125% of full load current. Therefore, Fuse will operate at l 85&deg;F or below (as 70% of 125% is more than 87.5%). Accounting
fo r a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise, the fuse is operational
at 162&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL12JA. See Attachment
D. Fuse trip at higher ambient temperature
has no safety consequence
and on EDG operation.
F06-l Fuse, Turbo Soak back Bussman FRN-10 Not Required Not req u ire d after EDG start as the turbo sack back motors are 250VFusetron
afterEDG not required for EDG operation.
Aged at 257&deg;F. Derated to start or 70% at l 85&deg;F operating
temperature.
Fuses are sized minimum Operation
125% of full load current. Therefore , Fuse will operate at ! 85&deg;F or below (as 70% of 125% is more than 87.5%). Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise, the fuse is operational
at 162&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL12JA. See Attachment
D. Fuse trip at higher ambient temperature
has no safety consequence
and on EDG ooeration. Importance
Green Green Green Green Page 53 of 83 State p DE p p 
EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 54 of 267 E I M E E E E Cl 1401 Branding lane , Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illino i s, 605 1 5 ENGINEERIN
G CONSU L TANTS Pho n e (630) 515-2650 * F AX (6 30) 5 15-26 54 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type 1PL12JA Fl6 IPL12JA Fl6 1PL12JA Fl6 IPL12JA Fl6 KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Re s ult of a L oss of the D i esel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment T h res h old (OF) F06A Fuse , Turbo Soak back Bussman FRN-10 Not Requir e d Not required after EOG start as the turbo sack back motor s are 250VFusetron
afterEDG not required for EDG operation.
Aged at 257&deg;F. Derated to start or 70% at 185&deg;F operating
temperature. Fuses are sized minimum Operation
125% of full load current. Therefore, F u se will operate at l 85&deg;F or below (as 70% of 125% is more than 87.5%). Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise, the fuse is operational
at l 62&deg;F. Loc ate d in panel IPL12JA. See Attachment
D. Fuse trip at higher ambi e nt temperature
has no safety consequence
and on EOG operation. F06A-l Fuse, Turbo Soak back Bussman FRN-10 Not Required Not required after EDG s tart as the turbo sack back motors are 250VFusetron
afterEDG not required for EDG operation.
Aged at 257&deg;F. Derated to start or 70% at I 85&deg;F operating
temperature.
Fuses are sized
minimum Operation
125% of full load current. Therefore, Fuse will operate at l 85&deg;F or below (as 70% of 125% is more than 87.5%). Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cabinet t e mperature
rise, the fuse is operational
at ! 62&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL!2JA. See Attachment
D. Fuse trip at higher ambient temperature
has no safety consequence
and on EDG operation. F09 Fuse , Priming Pump , Bus s man FRN-10 Not Required Not required after EDG start as the fuel priming pump motors 250VFusetron
afterEDG are not required for EDG operation.
Aged at 257&deg;F. Derat e d to start or 70% at 185&deg;F operating
temperature. Fuses are sized minimum Operation
125% of full load current. Therefore , Fuse will operate at l 85&deg;F or below (as 70% of 125% is more than 87.5%). Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise, the fuse is operational
at 162&deg;F. Located in pan e l I PL I 2JA. See Attachment
D. Fuse trip at higher ambient temperature
has no safety consequence
and on EDG operation. F09-l Fuse, Priming Pump, Bussman FRN-10 Not Required Not required after EDG st art as the fuel priming pump motor s 250VFusetron
afterE DG are not required for EDG operation. Aged at 257&deg;F. Derated to s tart or 7 0% at 185&deg;F operating
temperature.
Fuses are sized minimum Operation
125% of full load current. Therefore , Fuse will operate at l 85&deg;F or below (as 70% of 125% is more than 87.5%). Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise, the fuse is operational
at 162&deg;F. Located in panel 1PLl2JA. See Attachment
D. Fuse trip at higher ambient temperature
has no safety consequence
and on E DG operation. Importance
Green Green Green Green Page 54 o f 83 I State p p p p 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 55 of 267 E I M E E E E Cl 1401 Branding lane , Su i te 255 Downers Grove, Illinois , 60515 ENG IN EERI N G CO N SULTANTS Ph o n e (6 3 0) 515-2650 * FAX (63 0) 515-265 4 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Com p Ty p e 1PLl2JA Fl6 1PLl2JA Fl6 1PLl2JA Fl6 1PLl2JA Fl6 KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Desc r ipt i on MFG PART NO Te m perature Comme n t T h reshold (OF) F09A Fuse, Priming Pump, Bussman FRN-10 Not Required Not required after EOG start as the fuel priming pump moto r s 250VFusetron
after EOG are not requi r ed fo r EOG operatio n. Aged at 257&deg;F. Derated to start or 70% at l 85&deg;F operating
temperature. Fuses are sized minimum Operation
125% of full load current. Therefore , Fuse will operate at l 85&deg;F or below (as 70% of 125% is more than 87.5%). Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise, the fuse is operational
at 162&deg;F. Located in panel 1PLl2JA. See Attachment
D. Fuse trip at higher ambient temperature
has no safety consequence
and on EOG operation.
F09A-l Fuse, Priming Pump, Bussman FRN-10 Not Required Not required afte r EOG start as the fuel priming pump motors 250VFusetron
afte r EOG are not required for EOG operation.
Aged at 257&deg;F. Derated to start or 70% at l 85&deg;F operating
temperature. Fuses are sized minimum Operation
125% of full load current. Therefore , Fuse will operate at l 85&deg;F or below (as 70% of 125% is more than 87.5%). Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise, the fuse is operational
at 162&deg;F. Located in panel 1 PLI2JA. See Attachment
D. Fuse trip at higher ambient temperature
has no safety consequence
and on EOG operation. F05 Fuse, DC Motor Bussman FRN-15 Not Required Not required after EOG start as the turbo sack back and Control Circuit after EOG circulating
oil pump motors are not required for EOG operation. start or Aged at 257&deg;F. Derated to 70% at l 85&deg;F operating
temperature. Operation
Fuses are sized minimum 125% of fu ll load current. Therefore , Fuse will operate at 185&deg;F or below (as 70% of 125% is more than 87.5%). Accounting
fo r a 23&deg;F cab i net temperature
rise , the fuse is opera t ional at 162&deg;F. Located in panel 1PLl2JA. See Attachment
D. Fuse trip at higher ambient temperature
has no safety conseQuence
and on EDG operation.
F05-l Fuse, DC Motor Bussman FRN-15 Not Required Not req u ired after EDG start as the turbo sack b ack and Control Circuit afterEDG circulating
o i l pump motors are not required for EDG operation. start or Aged at 257&deg;F. Derated to 70% at l 85&deg;F operating
temperature.
Operation
Fuses are sized minimum 125% of full load current. Therefore, Fuse wi ll o p erate at l 85&deg;F or below (as 70% of 125% is more than 87.5%). Accounting
for a 23&deg;F ca b inet temperature
rise, the fuse is operational
at 162&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL12JA. See Attachment
D. Fuse trip a t higher ambient temperature
has no safety consequence
and on EDG operation. Importance
Green Green
Green Green Page 5 5 o f 8 3 State p p p p 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 56 of 267 E I M E E E E E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type JPL12JA SS JPL12JA UY IPL12JA UY IPL12JA !HS-DGl14 IPL12JA !HS-DGJ08 JPL12JA !HS-DGI06 KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Threshold (oF) A3 Speed Switch Dynalco STC-4240 Function is Rated fo r J 60&deg;F by the manufacturer.
See Attachment
K. Assembly not required Located in panel I PL! 2JA. EDG s tart Thi s speed switch closes after EDG reaches 850 RPM and picks up Relay K22. Relay K22 disables the fuel priming motor starter. The fuel priming motor is not required after EDG start and continued
operation
of the EDG. Therefore , function of the switch does not impact continued
operation
of the EDG. Any fai lur e of the switch (open contact not closing) will not disable the fuel priming pump
motor which is not required for continued
operation
of the EDG. K20 Rel a y , DC Mo to r GE 12HGAI IJ Not Required As s oc i ated with fuel priming pump control. Nor required after Starter Aux 52 EDG start. Insulation
material was aged at 212&deg;F. Located in panel IPL12JA. K20A Relay, DC Motor GE 12HGAJ 11 Not Required Associated
with fuel priming pump control. Nor required after Starter Aux 52 EDG start. Insulation
material was aged at 212&deg;F. Located in panel I PL! 2JA. S39 Switch , Engine GE 165BIDA2 Not Required The switch has it s own fuse and provides indication.
Failure of Maintenance
26SSM4C8 for EDG start the switch does not impact any other circuit as the fuse will or Operation
isolate the fault. Insulation
material was aged at J 80&deg;F. The open contacts will not short circuit in an environment
of 239&deg;F (see Section V.1.3). Therefore , using the temperature
limit of 239&deg;F and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of216&deg;F. SJ4 Switch , START GE CR2940W 234 Insulation
material wa s aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel A202C 1PL!2JA. Reducing thi s temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise , the component
will function at 234&deg;F. Sl3 Switch , S T OP GE CR2940W 234 Insulation
material wa s aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel A202E IPL12JA. Reducing thi s temperature
by 23&deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise , the component
will function at 234 &deg;F. Importance
Green Gre e n Gre e n Green Green Gr e en Page 56 of 83 State ON DE DE p p p 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 57 of 267 E I M E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane , Su i te 255 Downe r s Grove, Illino i s, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Pho n e (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 5 1 5-2 654 www.kciconsultants.com
Pa n el Co mp Type IPL12JA UY 1PL12 J A UY KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan C o mp Descri pti on MFG PART NO Te mp eratu r e Co m me n t Thres h o l d (oF) KIO Relay , Crank and Field P&B MDR134-l 222 This relay is norma ll y energized.
As the relay is energized
Disconnect
during E D G normal operation, the relay coil failure will impact the continued
operation
of EDG. Per SQ-CLD-039 , the relay was aged at 125&deg;C (257&deg;F) and functionally
tested during an environmental
test at 153&deg;F. Manufacturer
rating is 149&deg;F (see Attachment
J). A similar relay (MDR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;F energize d at 125 VDC for 24 h o u rs followe d wi th an expos ur e to 245&deg;F whi l e energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours oftest run. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F c u bicle temperature
rise , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. (see Refe r ence Vlll.6, Attachment
A). K13 Relay , Pilot 125vdc P&B MDRJ37-8 222 This relay is normally e n ergized. As the relay energized
during Engine Start-Run EDG n orma l operation, the re l ay co i l failure will impact the conti n ued operation
ofEDG. Per SQ-CLD-039, the relay was aged at l 25&deg;C (257&deg;F) and functionally
tested during an environmental
test at 153 &deg;F. Man u facturer rating is l 49&deg;F (see Attachment
J). An i dent i cal relay (MDR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;F e n erg i zed at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts d id not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours oftest run. Accounting
for a 23 &deg;F cubicle temperature
rise , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient t emperature
of222&deg;F. (see Refe r ence Vlll.6, A t tachment A). Importance
Green Green Page 57 of 83 I State EN EN 
EC 620632, Att. 1 , Pg. 58 of 2 67 E I M E E Cl 1401 Brand i ng lane , Su i te 255 Downers Grove , Illino i s , 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IPLl2JA UY 1PLl2J A UY KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Th re s hold (OF) KI6 Relay , Engine Starter
P&B MDR137-8 222 Per SQ-CLD-039 , the r e lay was aged at 125&deg;C (257&deg;F) and Con tr ol functi o nally te s ted durin g an environmental
te s t at 153 &deg;f. Manufacturer
ratin g i s 149&deg;f (see Att a clun e nt J). This r e la y is normall y energi ze d during E OG s tart and then remain de-energized
aft e r the EOG has reached 125 RPM and under norm a l E OG operation. After E OG start, the r e lay coil failure does not impact the EOG c a p a bility of power generation
as the rel a y is de-energized. An i dentical relay (MDR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;f energi ze d at 125 voe for 24 hours followed with an expo s ure to 245&deg;f while ene rgiz ed at 1 2 5 VOC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours oftest run. Accounting
for a 23 &deg;f c ubicle temperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EOG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;f. (see Reference
VIII.6, Attachmeot
A). K22 Relay , Aux 125VD C P&B MDR137-8 222 Thi s relay gets en e rgi z ed by A3 speed s wi t ch after EDG reache s Acce s sorie s 8 50 RPM. This R e l ay disables the fuel priming motor starter. The fuel primin g motor is not required after EOG s tart and continued
operation
o f th e EDG. A s th e relay is energized
during EOG normal operat i on , the relay c oil fa i lure will impact the continued
operation
ofEDG. Manufacturer
rating is I 49&deg;F (s ee Attachment
J). An id e ntic a l r e l ay (MDR 137-8) wa s aged at 225&deg;f energized
at 125 VDC fo r 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;f while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hour s. The coil maintained
the circui t integri ty and open conta c t s did not s hort circuit thr o ughout the 32 hour s of t es t run. Acc o untin g for a 23&deg;f cub i cle temperature
rise , the rel a y will not impact the EDG norm a l operation
in an ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. (see Reference
VIII.6 , Attachment
A). Importance
Green Green Page 58 of 83 State DE EN 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 59 of 267 E I M E E Cl 1401 Branding lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IPLl2JA UY IPL12JA UY KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Threshold (OF) K25 Relay, Crank Control P&B MDRl37-8 222 Per SQ-CLD-039, the relay was aged at 125&deg;C (257&deg;P) and functionally
tested during an environmental
test at 153&deg;P. Manufacturer
rating i s 149&deg;P (see Attachment
J). This relay is normally energized
for I 0 seconds during EDG start and then remain de-energized
under normal EDG operation. After EDG start , the relay coil failure
does not impact the EDG capability
of power generation
as the relay is e-energized. An identical
r elay (MDR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;P energized
at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;P while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours of te s t run. Accounting
for a 23 &deg;P cubicle temperature
rise , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;P. (see Reference
Vill.6, Attachment
A). K4 Relay, Over Crank P&B MDR137-8 222 This relay get e nergized if the EDG fails to start. Once the EDG (Failure to Start) start and runs , the relay is de-energized.
Under normal EDG operation , thi s relay will be de-energized. An identical
relay (MDR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;P energi z ed at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;P while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours of test run. Accounting
for a 23 &deg;P cubicle temperature
rise , the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;P. (see Reference
Vill.6 , Attachment
A). Importance
Green Gr ee n Page 59 of 83 I State DE DE 
EC 620632, Att. 1 , Pg. 60 of 267 E I M E Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IPL12JA UY KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Threshold (OF) K19 Relay, Control Setup P&B MOR-5095 222 This is latching relay and is de-energized
after EOG start (E ngine) Latch i ng immediately. Aged at 257&deg;F. Manufacturer
rating is l 49&deg;F (see Attachment
J). Under normal EOG operation , this relay is de-energized.
Under normal EOG ope r ation, this relay will be de-energized. An simi l ar relay (MOR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;F ene r gized at 1 25 voe for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F while energi z ed at 125 voe for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit i n tegrity and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours of test run. Accounting
for a 23 &deg;F cubicle temperature
rise , the relay will not impact the EOG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Reference
Vill.6 , Attachment
A). Importance
Green Page 60 of 83 I S tat e DE 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 61 of 267 E I M E Cl 1 401 B rand i ng l ane, Suite 255 Downers Grove , Illino i s , 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (6 3 0) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 5 1 5-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IPL12JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Descripti o n MFG PART NO Temperat u re Comment Thresho l d (OF) A3PS 24VDC PS , Speed PHOENEX 2938578 Not Required Woodward ESl50222 is part number for the mounting hardware. Switch Assembly after EDG Per Passport, part the power supply is Phoenix Part# 2938578 Start and rated for 70&deg;C (158&deg;F). The power supply A3PS is rated for 50 watts and provides powe r to the Speed Switch Assemb l y that has power rating of 5 watts (A3). The speed s witch talces input from the magnetic pickup (A3SE) and drives a MIO tachometer
mounted on the engine. An identical
power supply was aged at 207&deg;F (97&deg;C) energized
at 125 VDC for 24 hours and output voltage maintained
at 24 VDC while delivering
50% load. The load on this power s upply i s less than 50%. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise, the power supply will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient t e mperatur e of 184&deg;F (see Reference
Vlli.6, Attachment
A). The speed switch contacts de-e nergi ze Kl 6 relay above 125 RPM, energize K5 relay above 125 RPM and energize K22 Relay above 850 RPM. The relay de-energization
and ene r gization talces place immed i ately as EDG picks up speed to a steady state speed of900 RPM much before pane l PL12JA is ex posed to temperature
184 &deg;F. If the power supply is not available
in an environment
above l 84&deg;F, the EDG will not shut down with the following
lo ss of alarm and protection
function: * lo ss of alarm function for oil filter r estric ted , low oil le ve l , low oil tem perature and fuel fi lt e r restricted
* los s of protection
for low oil pres s ure and high coolant temperature
* fuel priming mot or sta rter is not di sa bled. The fuel primin g motor is not requir e d afte r E DG start and continued
opera tio n of th eE DG. Therefore , the A3PS i s not required after EDG start and continued
operation
of the E DG. Importance
Green Pa ge 61of 8 3 State ON 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 62 of 267 E I M E E E Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove , Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-26 54 www.kciconsultants.com
Pa n el Co m p Ty p e 1PL12JA 1PL12JA 1PL12JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Descri p t i on MFG PART NO Tem p erature Com m ent T h res h o ld (D F) TB13 Terminal Block s 222 These are typically
GE EB25-12W terminal bl ocks (Drawing 61090, Rev. H , Sheet 2). Insulation
material was aged at 248&deg;F for I 072 hour s. The terminal block was functional
before , during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section 5.10 of Ref. VIIl.2). The contact b l ock of relays having simi l a r material was aged at 245&deg;P and had there was no contact fai l ure (Reference
Vill.6, Attachment
A). Therefore , using 245&deg;P for any kind of terminal b lock and accounting
a 23 &deg;P ca b inet temperature
rise (conservative), the terminal block will not impact the EOG normal o p eration in an ambient temperature
of 222&deg;P. TBl4 Terminal Block s 222 These are typically
GE EB25-12W terminal blocks (Drawing 61090, Rev. H, Sheet 2). Insu l ation material was aged at 248&deg;P for 1072 hours. The terminal b lock was functiona l befo r e, during and after the thermal aging regimen (Sect i on 5.10 of Ref. Vill.2). The contact block of relays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;P and had there was no contact failure (Reference
Vill.6, Attachment
A). Therefore , u s ing 245&deg;P for any kind of terminal block and accounting
a 23&deg;P cabinet temperatu r e rise (conservative), the terminal block will not i mpact the EOG norma l o p eration i n an ambient temperature
of 222 &deg;P. TB14 Terminal Block s 222 The se are typically
GE EB25-12W terminal blocks (Drawing 61090, Rev. H, Sheet 2). Ins u lation material was aged at 248&deg;P for I 072 hours. The terminal block w as functional
before , during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section 5.10 of Ref. Vill.2). The contact block of relays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;P and had there was no contact failure (Reference
VIII.6 , Attachment
A). Therefo r e , using 245&deg;P for any kind o f termina l b lock and acco un ting a 23&deg;P cab i net temperature
rise (co n se rvative), the terminal block will no t impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;P. Importance
Gr e en Green Green Page 62 of 83 State p p p 
EC 620632, Att. 1 , Pg. 63 of 267 Cl E N GINEER I NG CONSULT A NTS 1401 Bra n ding Lane , Suite 255 Downers Grove , Illinois, 60515 Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 5 1 5-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) E Panel Comp I Type M E 1PL12JA Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diese l Ventilation
VD F an Comp Descriptio
n MFG PART NO Temperature
Comment Thresho l d (OF) TB14 Terminal Blocks 222 These are typically
GE EB25-12W terminal blocks (Drawing 61090, Rev. H , Sheet 2). Insu l ation material was aged at 248&deg;F for I 072 hours. The terminal block was functiona l before , during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section 5.10 of Ref. VIII.2). The contact block of relays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;F and had there was no contact failure (Reference
VIII.6, Attachment
A). Therefore, using 245&deg;F for any kind of terminal block and accounting
a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise (conservative), the terminal block wi ll not impact the EDG normal operation
in an amb i ent temperature
of222&deg;F. Imp o rtance Green LEGEND FOR "STATE" DE Relay is de-energized
during EDG operation
EN Relay is energized
during EDG operation
ON Component
requires power and is ON during EDG operation
OFF Component
requires power and is OFF during EDG operation
E/D Relay maybe energized
or de-energized
during EOG operation
p Passive Components
P age 63 of 83 I State p 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 64 of 267 Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Table V-4 Non-Critical
Components
Not Required for EDG Operation
E Panel Comp Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment I Type M E IDGOIKA HEATER HI Heater, Immersion
EMD 8398082 Required before the EOG start. Not required after EOG start an d opens on h igh temperature.
E IDGOlKA HEATE R HIA Heater , Immersion
EMO 8398082 R e quired before the EOG start. Not required after E OG start and opens on high temperature. E IDGOIKA ITS-S26 Low Oil Temperature
EMO 8447100 De vice does n ot h ave any electronics. Just a passive switch closed by a mechanical
DG075A means. The insulation
was aged a t 257&deg;F. The function of the devices d epends on the in t egrity of th e insulation
system. Located in panel l DGO I KA. This pan e l has components
that produce l ow heat. Conservatively
assuming a I 0&deg;C (18&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the device is operational
at 239&deg;F. E IDGOIKA ITS-S26A Low Oi l Temperature
EMD 8447100 De vi ce does not have an y electronic
s. Just a p a ssive switch closed by a mechanical
DG074A means. The insulation
was aged at 257&deg;F. The function of the devices depend s on the integrity
of the insulation
sys tem. Located in panel I DGO I KA. This panel has components
that produce low h eat. Conservatively
assuming a I 0&deg;C (l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, th e device is o per ationa l a t 239&deg;F. E IDGOlKA ITS-S30 Immersion
Heater EMO 8447102 D evic e do es not have any electronics.
Just a passive swi tch closed by a mechanical
DG087 Control means. The insulation
was aged at 257&deg;F. The function of the de v ice s depend s on the integrity
of t h e in sulation system. Located in panel IDGOlKA. Thi s panel has co mp onents that produce lo w h eat. Conservatively
ass uming a I 0&deg;C (l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the device is o pe rat i ona l at 239&deg;F. E IDGOIKA ITS-S30A Immersion
Heater EMD 8447102 Dev ice does not have any electronics. Just a p ass ive swi tch closed by a m echanical
DG086 Control me a n s. The insulation
was aged a t 257&deg;F. Th e function of the devices d e pends on the integrity
of the insulation
system. Located in panel IDGO !KA. This panel has com pon ents that produce low h eat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C (l8&deg;F) cabinet tem p erature rise, the device is operational
at 239&deg;F. E IDGOIKA MOTOR B3 Motor, Cir c ulating Oil EMD 8455815 Age d at 257&deg;F. Oil circ ulating pump motor is not required afte r EOG start. Pump E IDGOIKA MOTOR B3A Motor, Circulating
Oil EMD 8455815 Aged at 257&deg;F. Oil circulating
pump motor is not required after EOG start. Pump E IDGOlKA IDG-B4 Motor , Fuel Prime EM O 8 455 815 Ag ed at 257&deg;F. Fuel Prime mo tor i s not r e quired afte r E OG start. 633PA E IDGOlKA IDG-B4A Motor, Fuel Prime EMD 84 55 815 Aged at 257&deg;F. F u e l Prime m otor is not required after EOG start. 631PA E* IDGOlKA !LS-SIS Low Oil Level EMD 8 4 64151 Non-I E. This level switc h clo s es on low oil level a nd energ i zes relay Kl that provides DGOSS ann un ciatio n and indication.
Not required after EOG Importance
White White White White White Whit e White White White White White Page 64 of 83 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 65 of 267 E I M E E E E E E E <J<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IDGOIKA lLS-DG054 IDGOIKA lPS-DG123 IDGOIKA lPS-DG122 IDGOlKA lSI-DG146 IDGOIKA lPS-DG165 IDGOIKA lPS-DG164 IDGOlKA lPDS-DG051 KCI Report REP*424*008*RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment S15A Low Oil Level EMD 8464151 Non-IE. This level switch closes on low oil level and energizes
relay KIA that provides annunciation
and indication.
Not required after EDG S22 High Crankcase
EMD 8475932 This switch energizes (picks up) K23 relay. Relay K23 provides indication
and Pressure annunciation
ofhiidi crankcase
pressure (E02-IDG99, Sheets 11, 14 and 15). S22A High Crankcase
EMD 8475932 This switch energizes (picks up) K23A relay. Relay K23A provides indication
and Pressure annunciation
of high crankcase
pressure (E02-IDG99, Sheets 10, 14 and 15). MIO Tachometer
GE 50-103-Non-IE. Agedat212&deg;F.
111FAFA2 PLZ S43 Low Turbocharger
SQUARED 9012-This pressure switch opens on low oil pressure for the turbo soak back pump. This pump Low Pressure ACW-21 is not required after EDG start. Located in panel lDGOlKA. The switch contact do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material -dielectric
failure (See Section V.1.3). This panel
has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C (l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of 221 &deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
S43A Low Turbocharger
SQUARED 9012-This pressure switch opens on low oil pressure for the turbo soak back pump. This pump Low Pressure ACW-21 is not required after EDG start. Located in panel lDGOlKA. The switch contact do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
failure (See Section V.1.3). This panel has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C (18&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of221&deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
S40 Oil Filter Restricted
SQUARED 9012-This PD switch closes ifthe oil pressure is above 35 psi and energizes
relay K39 that AEW-1 provides annunciation
and indication.
Not required after EDG start. Located in panel lDGOlKA. The switch contact do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
failure (See Section V.1.3). This panel
has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C (l8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of 221 &deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
Importance
White White White White White White White Page 65 of 83 J 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 66 of 267 E I M E E E E <J<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, lllinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IDGOlKA lPDS-DG050 IDGOIKA JPS-DG063A IDGOlKA JPS-DG062A IDGOJKA ITS-DGOllB KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment S40A Oil Filter Restricted
SQUARED 9012-This PD switch closes ifthe oil pressure is above 35 psi and energizes
relay K39A that AEW-1 provides annunciation
and indication.
Not required after EDG start. Located in panel IDGOIKA. The switch contact do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
failure (See Section V.1.3). This panel has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C {l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of 221 &deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
S6 Low Oil Pressure SQUARED 9012-This Pressure switch closes if the oil pressure is above 26 psi and energizes
relay Kl (Alarm) AEW-21 that provides annunciation
and indication.
Not required after EDG start. Located in panel IDGOIKA. The switch contact do. not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
failure (See Section V.1.3). This panel has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C {l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of 221 &deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
S6A Low Oil Pressure SQUARED 9012-This Pressure switch closes if the oil pressure is above 26 psi and energizes
relay KIA (Alarm) AEW-21 that provides annunciatfon
and indication.
Not required after EDG start. Located in panel IDGOIKA. The switch contact do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
failure (See Section V.1.3). This panel has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C {l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of 221 &deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
SS High Coolant SQUARED 9012-This temperature
switch closes high coolant temperature
above 195&deg;F and energizes
Temperature (Alarm) AEW-42 relay K2 that provides annunciation
and indication.
Not required after EDG start. Located in panel lDGOIKA. The switch contact do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
failure (See Section V.1.3). This panel has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C (l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of 221 &deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
Importance
White White White White Page 66 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 67 of 267 E I M E E E E (KCI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IDGOIKA ITS-DG012B IDGOlKA ITS-DG075B IDGOlKA ITS-DG074B IDGOlKA lPDS-DG047 KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment SSA High Coolant SQUARED 9012-This temperature
switch closes high coolant temperature
above 195&deg;F and energizes
Temperature (Alarm) AEW-42 relay K2A that provides annunciation
and indication.
Not required after EDG start. Located in panel lDGOlKA. The switch contact do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
failure (See Section V.1.3). This panel has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C (18&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of221&deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
S7 High Oil Temperature
SQUARED 9012-This temperature
switch closes high oil temperature
above 250&deg;F and energizes
relay AEW-45 Kl 1 that provides annunciation
and indication.
Not required after EDG start. Located in panel lDGOlKA. The switch contact do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
failure (See Section V.1.3). This panel has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C (l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of 221 &deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
S7A High Oil Temperature
SQUARED 9012-This temperature
switch closes high oil temperature
above 250&deg;F and energizes
relay AEW-45 Kl IA that provides annunciation
and indication.
Not required after EDG start. Located in panel lDGOlKA. The switch contact do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
failure (See Section V.1.3). This panel
has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a l0&deg;C (18&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of 221 &deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
S35 Fuel Filter Restricted
SQUARED 9012-This PD switch closes at 50 psi and energizes
relay K27 that provides annunciation
and AEW-9 indication.
Not required after EDG start. Located in panel lDGOlKA. The switch contact do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
failure (See Section V.1.3). This panel
has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C (l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of221&deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
Importance
White White
White White Page 67 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 68 of 267 E I M E E E E E E E E E E <J<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515*2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type lDGOIKA IPDS* DG046 lDGOIKA HEATER lDGOlKA MOTOR lDGOIKA MOTOR lDGOIKA MOTOR lDGOlKA MOTOR lDGOIKA lDGOIKA lDGOIKA lDGOIKA KCI Report REP*424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment S35A Fuel Filter Restricted
SQUARED 9012* This PD switch closes at 50 psi and energizes
relay K27 A that provides annunciation
and AEW-9 indication.
Not required after EDG start. Located in panel lDGOlKA. The switch contact do not fail below 239&deg;F due to material dielectric
failure (See Section V.1.3). This panel has components
that produce low heat. Conservatively
assuming a 10&deg;C (l 8&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will function at an ambient temperature
of 221 &deg;F and will not provide a false trip below this temperature.
H3 Generator
Space WITH Not required after EDG start. Heater GEN IB3 Motor, Turbo Soak Not required after EDG start. back Pump IB3A Motor, Turbo Soak Not required after EDG start. back Pump IB7 Motor, Turbo Soak Not required after EDG start. back Pump IB7A Motor, Turbo Soak Not required after EDG start. back Pump Air Dryer Relays Control NIE Function.
Not required after EDG start. Component
-lCR, 2CR Air Dryer Relay Timer NIE Function.
Not required after EDG start. Component
-!CT Air Dryer Switch Selector NIE Function.
Not required after EDG start. Component
-lSS Air Dryer Indicating
Light NIE Function.
Not required after EDG start. Component -IL Importance
White White White White White White White White White White Page 68 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 69 of 267 E I M E E E E E E E E E <J(CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type !DGOlKA !DGOIKA MOTOR !DGOIKA MOTOR !DGOIKA !DGOIKA !LS-DG285 !DGOIKA !LS-DG286 !DGOlKA !DGOIKA !DG06SA SlO KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment Air Dryer Tenninal Blocks These are typically
GE EB25-12W tenninal blocks (Drawing 61090, Rev. H, Sheet 2). Component
Insulation
material was aged at 248&deg;F for 1072 hours. The terminal block was functional -TBl, TB2 before, during and after the thennal aging regimen (Section 5 .l 0 of Ref. VIlI.2). The contact block ofrelays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;F and had there was no contact failure (Reference
VIlI.6, Attachment
A). Therefore, using 245&deg;F for any ldnd oftenninal
block and accounting
a 10&deg;C (18&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise (conservative), the terminal block will not impact the EDG nonnal operation
in an ambient temperature
of227&deg;F. B7 Motor, Oil Circulating
Not required after EDG start. B7A Motor, Oil Circulating
Not required after EDG start. GNDBUS Ground Bus Metal bus use to connect to station ground. LS Low Coolant Level This level switch closes under low level and picks relay K2 that provides annunciation
and indication.
Not required after EDG start. LS Low Coolant Level This level switch closes under low level and picks relay K2A that provides annunciation
and indication.
Not required after EDG start. Retired( G3) Signal Generator
Spared and not connected. (Retired in place) TB4 Tenninal Blocks These are typically
GE EB25-12W tenninal blocks (Drawing 61090, Rev. H, Sheet 2). Insulation
material was aged at 248&deg;F for 1072 hours. The terminal block was functional
before, during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section 5. l 0 of Ref. VIII.2). The contact block of relays having similar material was aged at 245&deg;F and had there was no contact failure (Reference
VIII.6, Attachment
A). Therefore, using 245&deg;F for any ldnd oftenninal
block and accounting
a 10&deg;C (18&deg;F) cabinet temperature
rise (conservative), the tenninal block will not impact the EDG nonnal operation
in an ambient temperature
of227&deg;F. !PS-Switch, Air Pressure SQUARED 9012-This pressure switch protects the air compressor
for high pressure.
Not required after 1DG003A Control ACW-22 EDG start as the pressure switch would trip the motor after few minutes into the EDG start. Rated at 185&deg;F. See Table 1 of Ref. VIII.2. Located in panel 1DG06SA. This cabinet has cabinet temperature
rise as all the equipment
are de-energized
after EDG start. The switch can function up to l 85&deg;F. Importance
White White White White White White White White White Page 69 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 70 of 267 E I M E E E E E E E <l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www .kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IDG06SA SlOA IDG06SA S37 IDG06SA S38 IDG06SA B6. IDG06SA B2 1FP02JA PNLA 1PL12JA F16 KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment lPS-Switch, Air Pressure SQUARED 9012-This pressure switch
protects the air compressor
for high pressure.
Not required after IDG005A Control ACW-22 EDG start as the pressure switch would trip the motor after few minutes into the EDG start. Rated at 185&deg;F. See Table 1 of Ref. Vill.2. Located in panel IDG06SA. This cabinet has cabinet temperature
rise as all the equipment
are de-energized
after EDG start. The switch can function up to 185&deg;F. !PS-Switch, Low Starting SQUARED 9012-This pressure switch
closes under low air pressure and picks relay K12 that provides IDG003B Air Pressure ACW-9 annunciation
and indication.
Not required after EDG start. Rated at 185&deg;F. See Table 1 of Ref. Vill.2. Located in panel IDG06SA. This cabinet has cabinet temperature
rise as all the equipment
are de-energized
after EDG start. The switch can function up to 185&deg;F. !PS-Switch, Low Starting SQUARED 9012-This pressure switch
closes under low air pressure and picks relay Kl 2 that provides IDG005B Air Pressure ACW-9 annunciation
and indication.
Not required after EDG start. Rated at 185&deg;F. See Table 1 of Ref. Vill.2. Located in panel IDG06SA. This cabinet has cabinet temperature
rise as all the equipment
are de-energized
after EDG start. The switch can function up to 185&deg;F. IDGOlCA Motor, Air Not Required after EDG start. Compressor
IDGOlCB Motor, Air Not Required after EDG start. Comoressor
1FP02JA D-G lADAYTANK
ALISON A888-Panel 1FP02JA is a Fire Protection/Detection
System. This panel has no direct function ROOM WPS CONTROL M556 on the Diesel Generator
SUPERVISORY
PANEL Fll Fuse, Circuit Breaker Bussman FRN-20 Aged at 257&deg;F. Derated to 5% at more than 120&deg;C (248&deg;F) operating
temperature
by Control linear extrapolation (see Attachment
F). The load on the fuse are indicating
lights (no more than 6) and these are GE ET 16. The indicating
light have low wattage consumption (around 6 watts). Rounding the wattage of the indicating
light to 10 watts, fuse load will be less than 60 watts and the fuse current will be 0.5 amps. The fuses are rated for 20 Amps. Therefore, one can conservative
assume that the fuse loaded no more than 5% of its rating. Therefore, Fuse will not false trip below 225&deg;F accounting
for a 23&deg;F cabinet temperature
rise in panel IPL12JA. Importance
White White White White White White White Page 70 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 71 of 267 E I M E E E <l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type 1PL12JA Fl6 1PL12JA F16 1PL12JA F16 KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment Fll-1 Fuse, Circuit Breaker Bussman FRN-20 Aged at 257&deg;F. Derated to 5% at more than 120&deg;C (248&deg;F) operating
temperature
by Control linear extrapolation (see Attachment
F). The load on the fuse are indicating
lights (no more than 6) and these are GE ET 16. The indicating
light have low wattage consumption (around 6 watts). Rounding the wattage of the indicating
light to 10 watts, , fuse load will be less than 60 watts and the fuse current will be 0.5 amps. The fuses are rated for 20 Amps. Therefore, one can conservative
assume that the fuse loaded no more than 5% of its rating. Therefore, Fuse will not false trip below 225&deg;F accounting
for a 23 &deg;F cabinet temperature
rise in panel 1PLl2J A. FllA Fuse, DG Output Bussman NON-0.5 The NON fuses are installed
in panel 1PL12JA. Based on NEC requirements, the fuses Voltage Test Point are sized at least 125% above the maximum load current and rounded up to the next available
fuse size. Therefor as long as the fuse is derated to more than 80% (1/1.25) of its rating, the fuse will carry the load current and not provide a false trip. The NON is a Non-Dual Element Fuse. Attachment
F shows that the current carrying capacity(%
of rating) and Opening Time (% of rating) as a function of ambient temperature.
Based on Attachment
F, the NON fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperature
of 120&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore, even at operating
temperature
of248&deg;F the fuse has 15% margin above the design maximum full load current. The cabinet temperature
rise is 23 &deg;F and the fuses will not provide a false trip and carry the load current for an ambient temperature
of225&deg;F. Fl2A Fuse, DG Output Bussman NON-0.5 The NON fuses are installed
in panel lPLl 2JA. Based on NEC requirements, the fuses Voltage Test Point are sized at least 125% above the maximum load current and rounded up to the next available
fuse size. Therefor as long as the fuse is derated to more than 80% (111.25) of its rating, the fuse will carry the load current and not provide a false trip. The NON is a Non-Dual Element Fuse. Attachment
F shows that the current carrying capacity(%
of rating) and Operring Time (% of rating) as a function of ambient temperature.
Based on Attachment
F, the NON fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperature
of 120&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore, even at operating
temperature
of248&deg;F the fuse has 15% margin above the design maximum full load current. The cabinet temperature
rise is 23 &deg;F and the fuses will not provide a false trip and carry
the load current for an ambient temperature
of 225&deg;F. Importance
White White White Page 71 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 72 of 267 E I M E E E E <l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type 1PL12JA Fl6 1PL12JA Fl6 1PL12JA 1PLl2JA UY KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment FlO Fuse, Remote Bussman OT3 The OT fuses are installed
in panel lPLI 2JA. Based on NEC requirements, the fuses are Indicating
Light sized at least 125% above the maximum load current and rounded up to the next available
fuse size. Therefor as long as the fuse is derated to more than 80% (111.25) of its rating, the fuse will carry the load current and not provide a false trip. The OT is a Non-Dual Element Fuse. Attachment
F shows that the current carrying capacity(%
of rating) and Opening Time (% of rating) as a function of ambient temperature.
Based on Attachment
F, the OT fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperature
of 120&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore, even at operating
temperature
of248&deg;F the fuse has 15% margin above the design maximum full load current. The cabinet temperature
rise is 23 &deg;F and the fuses will not provide a false trip and carry the load current for an ambient temoerature
of225&deg;F. Fl0-1 Fuse, Remote Bussman OT3 The OT fuses are installed
in panel 1PL12JA. Based on NEC requirements, the fuses are Indicating
Light sized at least 125% above the maximum load current and rounded up to the next available
fuse size. Therefor as long as the fuse is derated to more than 80% (111.25) of its rating, the fuse will carry the load current and not provide a false trip. The OT is a Non-Dual Element Fuse. Attachment
F shows that the current carrying capacity(%
of rating) and Opening Time (% of rating) as a function of ambient temperature.
Based on Attachment
F, the OT fuse will be derated to 95% of its rating at an operating
ambient temperature
of 120&deg;C (248&deg;F). Therefore, even at operating
temperature
of248&deg;F the fuse has 15% margin above the design maximum full load current. The cabinet temperature
rise is 23 &deg;F and the fuses will not provide a false trip and carry the load current for an ambient temoerature
of225&deg;F. H2 Space Heater, CHROMALO OT-1025 Non-IE. Heater is de-energized
after EDG start. Switchgear
x 41 Exciter Field ELECTROS 7805D This Lock Out Relay (LOR) is normally de-energized
and energized
to trip and stop the Discharge
Circuit WITCH EDG. Breaker Located in 1PL12JA panel. The LOR was aged at 257&deg;F and therefore
the coil insulation
has a minimum temperature
rating of257&deg;F. The relay has to pick up in the abnormal temperature
environment.
The pick up voltage for a 125 VDC coil is 40 VDC at room ambient temperature (See Attachment
G). The pick up voltage will increase by 42% at an operating
temperature
257&deg;F to 57 VDC which less than the available
voltage of 125 VDC. Accounting
for a cabinet temperature
rise of23&deg;F, the relay will pick up at 234 &deg;F and trip the EDG. Note that this protective
feature is not required for this scenario since the EDG is assumed to be running normallv.
Importance
White White White White Page 72 of 83 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 73 of 267 E I M E E E E E E E E E E
E E (KCI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630} 515-2650 * FAX (630} 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type 1PL12JA 1PL12JA lEI-DG096 1PL12JA III-DG090 1PL12JA IJI-DG092 1PL12JA ISI* DGlOO 1PL12JA IJI-DG094 1PL12JA IHS-DG096 1PL12JA IHS-DG090 1PL12JA lXE-DG102 1PL12JA lJY-DG094 1PL12JA IHS-DG112 1PL12JA IHS-DG134 KCI Report (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment AlS Alarm Horn FEDERAL 4SON Non-IE M4 AC VOLTMETER
GE 103021PZ Non-IE. Aged at 2S7&deg;F. UL2 Ml AC AMMETER GE 103131LSS
Non-IE N2 M2 AC WATTMETER
GE 103221AR Non-IE ETlDTC M7 FREQUENCY
GE 103372AT Non-IE METER AT2 M3 ACVARMETER
GE 103772AG Non-IE LRIDMC SS Switch, VOLTMETER
GE 10AA004 This is an SBM switch. Insulation
material was aged at 18S&deg;F (EQ-GEN063).
Located in 1PL12JA. The voltmeter
reading is a NON-IE function, but the switch dielectric
failure will impact control circuit integrity.
The switch material has a minimum temperature
rating of 239&deg;F (see Section V.1.3). Therefore, using the temperature
limit of239&deg;F and accounting
a 23 &deg;F cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of216&deg;F. Sl Switch, AMMETER GE 10AA013 This is an SBM switch. Insulation
material was aged at 18S&deg;F (EQ-GEN063).
Located Phase Selector in 1PL12JA. The ammeter reading is a NON-IE function, but the switch dielectric
failure will impact control circuit integrity.
The switch material has a minimum temperature
rating of 239&deg;F (see Section V.1.3). Therefore, using the temperature
limit of239&deg;F and accounting
a 23 &deg;F cabinet temperature
rise, the switch will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of216&deg;F. MS RUNNING TIME GE S0-240-Non-IE METER 311AAAB1 M3T V ARMETER Phase GE 700X84Gl Non-IE Shifting Transformer
S32 Switch, Manual Fuel GE CR2940UA Insulation
material was aged at 2S7&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL12JA. Reducing this Prime 202B temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at234&deg;F. S21 Switch, Oil Circulating
GE CR2940UA Insulation
material was aged at 2S7&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL12JA. Reducing this Pump#2 203A temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at 234&deg;F. Importance
White White White White White White White White White White White White Page 73 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 74 of 267 E I M E E E E E E E E E E E E (MCI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type 1PLl2JA lHS-DG138 1PL12JA lHS-DG142 1PLl2JA lHS-DG>l80 1PLl2JA lHS-DG136 1PL12JA 1PL12JA 1PL12JA lHS-DG140 1PLl2JA 1PLl2JA 1PLl2JA 1PLl2JA 1PLl2JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment S28 Switch, Immersion
GE CR2940UA Insulation
material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel 1PLl2JA. Reducing this Heater#2 203B temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at 234&deg;F. S42 Switch, Air GE CR2940UA Insulation
material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL12JA. Reducing this Compressor
H2 203B temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at 234&deg;F. S20 Switch, Oil Circulating
GE CR2940UB Insulation
material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL12JA. Reducing this Pump #1 203A temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at 234&deg;F. S27 Switch, lmmersion
GE CR2940UB Insulation
material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL12JA. Reducing this Heater#! 203B temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at 234&deg;F. 816 Switch, Annunciator
GE CR2940W Insulation
material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL12JA. Reducing this Reset A202B temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at 234&deg;F. S17 Switch, Annunciator
GE CR2940W Insulation
material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL12JA. Reducing this Silence A202B temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at 234&deg;F. S29 Switch, Air GE CR2940W Insulation
material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL12JA. Reducing this Compressor
A202B temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at 234&deg;F. S31 Switch, Annunciator
GE CR2940W Insulation
material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel 1PLl2JA. Reducing this Acknowledge
A202B temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at 234&deg;F. S41 Switch, Annunciator
GE CR2940W Insulation
material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel 1PLl2JA. Reducing this Test A202B temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at 234&deg;F. F20 Fuse, Isolation
Gould A2KIOR Isolation
Annunciator.
Non IE function.
Annunciator
Shawmut F20-l Fuse, Isolation
Gould A2KIOR Isolation
Annunciator.
Non IE function.
Annunciator
Shawmut Kl Relay, Low Oil P&B MDR137-8 This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by S6 under low oil pressure Pressure below 26 psi. Under normal EDG operation, this switch will be open and relay is de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
Importance
White White White White White White
White White White White White White Page 74 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 75 of 267 E I M E E E E E E <J(CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone {630) 515*2650 * FAX {630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type 1PL12JA 1PL12JA 1PL12JA 1PL12JA UY 1PL12JA 1PL12JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment Kll Relay, High Lube Oil P&B MDR137-8 This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by S7 under high oil temperature
Temperature
above 250&deg;F. Under normal EDG operation, this switch will be open and relay is de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
KllA Relay, High Lube Oil P&B MDR137-8 This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by S7 A under high oil temperature
Temperature
above 250&deg;F. Under normal EDG operation, this switch will be open and relay is de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
Kl2 Relay, Low Starting P&B MDR137-8 This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by SlOA under low starting air Air Pressure pressure.
Under normal EDG operation, this switch will be open and relay is de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG oneration.
K18 Relay, Engine Cooling P&B MDR137-8 This relay gets energized
by Kl 3 relay after EDG start. Relay K22 de-energizes
the Aux immersion
heaters and generator
heater. As the relay energized
during EDG normal operation, the relay coil failure will impact the continued
operation
ofEDG. Manufacturer
rating is 149&deg;F (see Attachment
J). An identical
relay (MDR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;F energized
at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours oftest run. Accounting
for a 23&deg;F cubicle temperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Reference
Vill.6, Attachment
A). Kl A Relay, Low Oil P&B MDR137-8 This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by S6A under low oil pressure Pressure below 26 psi. Under normal EDG operation, this switch will be open and relay is de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG oneration.
K2 Relay, High Coolant P&B MDR137-8 This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by SS under high coolant Temperature
temperature
above l 95&deg;F. Under normal EOG operation, this switch will be open and relay is de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
Importance
White White White White White White Page 75 of 83 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 76 of 267 E I M E E E E E <l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IPL12JA PY IPL12JA PY 1PL12JA 1PL12JA 1PL12JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment K23 Relay, High P&B MDR137-8 This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by S22 under high crankcase
Crankcase, Pressure pressure.
Relay K23 provides indication
and annunciation
of high crankcase
pressure (E02-IDG99, Sheets 11, 14 and 15). It does not provide a trip function.
Under normal ' EDG operation, this relay will be de-energized.
After EDG start, the relay coil failure does not impact the EDG capability
of power generation.
An identical
relay (MDR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;F energized
at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours of test run. Accounting
for a 23 &deg;F cubicle temperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. (see Reference
VIII.6, Attachment
A). K23A Relay, High P&B MDR137-8 This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by S22A under high crankcase
Crankcase, Pressure pressure.
Relay K23 provides indication
and annunciation
of high crankcase
pressure (E02-IDG99, Sheets 10, 14 and 15). It does not provide a trip function.
Under normal EDG operation, this relay will be de-energized.
After EDG start, the relay coil failure does not impact the EDG capability
of power generation.
An identical
relay (MDR 137-8) was aged at 225&deg;F energized
at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours of test run. Accounting
for a 23 &deg;F cubicle temperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Reference
VIII.6, Attachment
A). K24 Relay, Low Fuel Level P&B MDR137-8 This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
under low fuel level. The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
K27 Relay, Fuel Filter P&B MDR137-8 This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by S35. if the fuel filter gets Restricted
restricted.
Under normal EDG operation, this switch will be open and relay is de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
K27A Relay, Fuel Filter P&B MDR137-8 This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by S35A ifthe fuel filter gets Restricted
restricted.
Under normal EDG operation, this switch will be open and relay is de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
Importance
White White White White White Page 76 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 77 of 267 E I M E E E E
E E E <;l<CI 1401 Branding lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IPLl2JA 1PLl2JA 1PL12JA 1PLl2JA
1PLl2JA 1PLl2JA 1PL12JA R20 KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment K2A Relay, High Coolant P&B MDR137-S This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by SSA under high coolant Temperature
temperature
above 195&deg;F. Under normal EDG operation, this
switch will be open and relay is de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
K2A Relay, High Coolant P&B MDR137-S This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by SSA for high coolant Temperature
temperature
above 195&deg;F. Under normal EDG operation, this switch will be open and relay is de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
K39 Relay, Oil Filter P&B MDR137-S This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by S40 if the oil filter gets Restricted
restricted.
Under normal EDG operation, this switch will be open and relay is de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate anounciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
K39A Relay, Oil Filter P&B MDR137-S This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by S40A if the oil filter gets Restricted
restricted.
Under normal EDG operation, this switch will be open and relay is de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate anounciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
K40 Relay, Low Oil P&B MDR137-S This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by S26 switch for low oil Temperature
temperature
below S5&deg;F. Under normal EDG operation, this
switch will be open and relay de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
K40A Relay, Low Oil P&B MDR137-S This relay is normally de-energized
and get energized
by S26A switch for low oil Temperature
temperature
below S5&deg;F. Under normal EDG operation, this
switch will be open and relay de-energized.
The relay contacts initiate annunciation
and indication
function.
Not required after EDG start and EDG operation.
K42 Relay, Control Power P&B MDRl37-S This relay used to provide 125 VDC power availability
for the turbo soak back, Failure circulating
oil and fuel priming pump motors. These motor are not required after EDG start. The relay coil is energized, and coil failure will not impact 125 VDC supply to other control circuits.
Importance
White
White White White White White White Page 77 of 83 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 78 of 267 E I M E E E E <)(Cl 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type IPLl2JA UY 1PL12JA 1PL12JA 2TS-DGJA-1 1PL12JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment KIOX Relay, Crank and Field P&B MDR138-8 This relay is normally energized.
As the relay is energized
during EDG normal Disconnect
Aux operation, the relay coil failure will impact the continued
operation
of EDG. Per SQ-CLD-039, the relay was aged at 125&deg;C (257&deg;F) and functionally
tested during an environmental
test at 153&deg;F. Manufacturer
rating is 149&deg;F (see Attachment
J). A similar relay (MDR 137-8) was aged at225&deg;F energized
at 125 VDC for 24 hours followed with an exposure to 245&deg;F while energized
at 125 VDC for 8 hours. The coil maintained
the circuit integrity
and open contacts did not short circuit throughout
the 32 hours of test run. Accounting
for a 23 &deg;F cubicle temperature
rise, the relay will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of222&deg;F. (see Reference
Vill.6, Attachment
A). ASPS Power Supply TOPAZ 2875-Non-IE. DC to DC power supply for annunciator
and fused. 125VDC TSI Test Switch (Type FT-WESTINGHO
129A514G Insulation
material was aged at 257&deg;F. Located in panel 1PL12JA. Reducing this 1) USE 01 temperature
by 23 &deg;F to account for cabinet temperature
rise, the component
will function at 234&deg;F. ( 6 Triplets)
Indicating
Lights NIE Function DS13, DS14, DS15, (4 Pairs) '1 DS13-DS15 Importance
White White White White Page 78 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 79 of 267 E I M E E E E E E E E <;l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type 1PL12JA 1PL12JA 1PL12JA 1PL12JA 1PL12JA 1PLl2JA 1PL12JA 1PL12JA KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment lA/B, Annunciator
Windows NlE Function 2A/B, 3A/B, 4AIB, 5AIB, 6AIB, 7A/B, 8A/B, 9AIB, lOA/B, llA/B, 2A/B, 13A/B, 14A/B, 15A/B, 16A/B, 17A/B, 18A/Bl A8R,A8Rl Relay, Annunciator
Non-lE DISC Disconnect
Switch The disconnect
switch is a passive device and material of construction
are similar to terminal blocks. DSl, DS2, Indicating
Lights NlE Function DS3, DS4, DSS, DS8, DS9, DSlO, DSll, DS12 DS17A/B/ Indicating
Lights NlEFunction
c DS7 Indicating
Lights NlE Function K42A Relay, Per ECN-Associated
with Soak back and Fuel Prime Pumps. These pumps are not required after 30727 EDG start. Alarm function (DWG: 61092 Sht. 002) S36 Switch, Panel Interior Non-lE Lighting Importance
White White White White White White White White Page 79 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 80 of 267 E I M E E E M M M M M (l(CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type 1PL12JA 1PL12JA 1PL38N PNLA Duct DOS Duct DOS Duct DOS Duct DOS Duct DOS KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment TB16 Terminal Blocks These are typically
GE EB2S-12Wterminal
blocks (Drawing 61090, Rev. H, Sheet2). Insulation
material was aged at 248&deg;F for 1072 hours. The terminal block was functional
before, during and after the thermal aging regimen (Section S.10 of Ref. VIII.2). The contact block ofrelays having similar material was aged at 24S&deg;F and had there was no contact failure (Reference
VIII.6, Attachment
A). Therefore, using 24S&deg;F for any kind of terminal block and accounting
a 23 &deg;F cabinet temperature
rise (conservative), the terminal block will not impact the EDG normal operation
in an ambient temperature
of 222&deg;F. VOl& 120VAC Outlets NIE Function V02 1PL38N Unit heater Cont. PNl CUSTOM FABPER These component
have no direct impact on DG Function.
CONTL.PAN
B/MC-llS ELS 1VD12YA DIESEL PACIFIC AIR CAT#: Per Drawing Ml0-2903, Note 3, The damper actuator (1FZVD004)
is installed
but it is GENERATOR
ROOM PRODUCTS NH9SG267 not connected
electrically.
Therefore
it is not powered and would not change state due to ISOLATION
3Nl99 temperature
rise. DAMPER Serial: 8149B2S28
64-01-002
lVDOSYA DIESEL RUSKIN NIBD23 Per DWG 2903-RUS-16, The fusible link is rated at 160&deg;F. Therefore
the Damper will GENERATOR
ROOM MFG.CO. shut at temperatures
above 160&deg;F. Not in DG trip Circuit. FIRE DAMPER 1VD08YA OIL TANK ROOM RUSKIN NIBD23 DGroom heat detector sends signal to fusible link at 190&deg;F. (1C02ED, EE, EF, EG, lA (ROOM Dl-2) MFG.CO. EM). Electro Thermal link (ETL) fusible link gets signal to melt at 190&deg;F. Therefore
the FIRE DAMPER Fire Fire Damper will shut at 190&deg;F. No direct impact on EDG. But impact on room cooling Damper is considered
in DG heat up analysis lVDlOYA DAY TANK ROOM RUSKIN NIBD23 DGroomheat
detector sends signal to fusible link at 190&deg;F. (1C02ED, EE, EF, EG, 1A(ROOMD3-
MFG.CO. EM). Electro Thermal link (ETL) fusible link gets signal to melt at 190&deg;F. Therefore
the 2)FIRE DAMPER Fire Damper will shut at 190&deg;F. No direct impact on EDG. But impact on room cooling is considered
in DG heat up analysis IVD26YA DIESEL RUSKIN NIBD23 Per DWG 2903-RUS-16, The fusible link is rated at 160&deg;F. Therefore
the Damper will GENERA TOR ROOM MFG.CO. shut at temperatures
above 160&deg;F. Not in DG trip Circuit. FIRE DAMPER Importance
White White White White White White White White Page 80 of 83 J 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 81 of 267 E I M E M (l(CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
Panel Comp Type Room F05 Room V20 KCI Report REP*424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan Comp Description
MFG PART NO Comment 1VD02CA DIESEL BUFFALO Fan Motor Westinghouse
motors are used in harsh zones and qualified
by Buffalo Forge. Motors are GENERATOR
VENT PUMPS 365BL,FR.
qualified
for 212&deg;F for 40 years (Ref. EQ-CL004, Tab F, Report D0-146F).
OIL ROOM IA DIV.BUFFAL
Westinghou
EXHAUST 0 (B517) seMTR, 5 FAN/motor
HP,TEFC 213T ISX063A Motor Operated Valve LIMITORQU
SMB-000 This model of MOY s are used in the harsh zones of the plant and are qualified
for 250&deg;F (MOY) DIESEL GEN ECORP. (Equipment
for 84 hrs. and 200&deg;F for 25.75 days (Reference
EQ-CL027, page C24). IAHEATEXCH
Tag ID OUTLET VAL VE No.: SYZ00531-A4-RS) Importance
White White Page 81 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 82 of 267 <!l<CI 1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515-2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan VI Operability
of Diesel Generator
Starting Air System The subject Clinton
Diesel Generator
Starting Air Receiver Tanks (1DG04TA, B) are part of the Division 1 DG Air Skid (1DG06SA), as shown on drawing M05-1035, Sheet 1, Rev. AF. This assembly supplies air for the main engine starting system. These tanks are shown on vender drawing 61396, Rev P. As per the notes section of this drawing, these tanks have a design pressure of 300 psig and a design temperature
of 300&deg;P. The design temperature
encompasses
the maximum postulated
event temperature
of 17 4 &deg;P. In addition, each of these tanks is protected
against over pressurization
by a pressure relief valve (1DG04TA, B), with a set relief pressure of 275 psig. Per passport, the vender drawing for the relief valve is C95760-34, Sheet 1, Rev. A. This valve is of metal construction
with a Viton 0-ring as the only metallic part. Viton is a brand of synthetic
rubber and :fluoropolymer
elastomer
commonly used in 0-rings. Compounds
of Vi ton remain substantially
elastic indefinitely
when exposed to laboratory
air oven aging up to 399 &deg;P, per the manufacturer's
web site (www.chemours.com/Viton/en
selection-guide.pdf).
Therefore, the relief valve will still function to prevent over pressurization
of the subject air tanks during the postulated
event. In summary, the Diesel Generator
Starting Air Receiver Tanks will not rupture as a result of the postulated
high temperature
event; this is based on their design and the presence of a functioning
pressure relief valve. VII Conclusion
All components
required for continuous
operation
of the EDG including
the diesel generator
itself will remain operable for 24 hours in an ambient temperature
of 230&deg;F except for components
in panel 1PL12JA. Panel 1PL12JA components
required for continuous
operation
of the EDG will remain operable for24 hours in an ambient temperature
of 222&deg;P. VIII References
VIII.I Specification
K-2861, Emergency
Diesel Generator
Sets, Clinton Power Unit 1, Illinois Power Company, dated Jan 31, 1986. Page 82 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 83 of 267 <l<CI ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
1401 Branding Lane, Suite 255 Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515 Phone (630) 515-2650 * FAX (630) 515*2654 www.kciconsultants.com
KCI Report REP-424-008-RP1 (Rev. 03) Operability
of Class 1 E Equipment
in DG Rooms as a Result of a Loss of the Diesel Ventilation
VD Fan VIIl.2 Calculation
IP-Q-396, Operability
Evaluation
of Equipment
at Elevated Temperature
in Diesel Generator
Room, Revision 001. VIIl.3 KCI Test Specification
No. 424-008-TSP2, Test Specification
for Determining
Component
Survivability
and Operation
in Ambient Temperatures
not to exceed 245&deg;F, Revision 001. VIIl.4 Deleted VIIl.5 TODI # CPS-17-0044, Revision 0 VIIl.6 F AI Test Report F AI/17-0667, Test Report for Component
Survivability
at Elevated Ambient Temperature, Revision 0, dated July 2017 (Attachment
A) Page 83 of 83 I 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 84 of 267REPORTNO.:REP-424-00B-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE A1 of A23 WORLD LEADER IN NUCLEAR AND CHEMICAL PROCESS SAFETY Report No.: FAI/17-066
7 Test Report for Component
Survivability
at Elevated Ambient Temperature
Revision 0 Project No.: KCI-Clinton-Relay
Submitted
to: KC/ Engineering
Downers Grove, Illinois Prepared by: William E. Berger Reviewed by: Alfredo Garcia July, 2017 *1 6W070 83"" STRt:::E:T
* BURR RIOGE, tt..LINOIS
60527 (677l FAUSKE: 1 OR 1630) 323*6750 * F"AX: !630l 966-548 l * E-MAIL: INF'o@FAUSK!LCOM 
EC 620632, Att * 1, Pg. 85 of 267REPORTNO.:REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 FAl/17-0667
Rev. 0 CALCULATION
NOTE COVER SHEET SECTION TO BE COMPLETED
BY AU'IJIOR(S):
PAGE A2 of A23 Page 2of23 July, 2017 Cale-Note
Number: F AI/17-0667
Revision Number: 0 Title: Test Report for Component
Survivability
at Elevated Ambient Temperature
Project Number Project/Subject:
Clinton Diesel Generator
Room Components
or Shop Order: KCI-Clinton-
Relay Purpose: Document results of tests performed
on components
located in Clinton Power Station diesel generator
room Methods of Analysis*:
Testing Acceptance
Criteria*:
NIA Results Summary: Testing completed
in compliance
with test specification.
Does this document contain Proprietary
Information? (Yes/No, if Yes whose infonnation
is it?) *Can be NIA and/or a reference
to this information
in the Design Analysis can be provided.
References
of Resulting
Reports, Letters, or Memoranda (Optional)
Author(s):
Name (Print or Type) Signature:
Responsibility:
William E. Berger SECTION TO Br; COMPLETED
BY VERIFIER(S):
Verificr(s):
Name (Print or Type) Responsibility:
Alfredo Garcia Each verifier signature
confirms they have completed
a separate 3-Pass Verification
Checklist.
SECTION TO BE COMPLETED
BY EDITORIAL'REVJEWER:
Reviewer(s)
Name: (Print or Type) Alfredo Garcia SECTION TO BE COMPLETED
BY RESPONSIBLE
MANAGER: Manager Name: (Print or Type) Brenda A. Lorenz Final PDF Yes, Exelon Completion
Date: (MM/DD/YYYY)
07/12/2017
Approval Date: (MM/DDIYYYY)
07/12/2017
Approval Date: (MM/DDNYYY)
07/12/2017
Approval Date: (MM/DDIYYYY)
07112/2017
Responsibilities
of authors/verifiers
arc documented
Independence
of verification
is confirmed 
 
EC 620632, Att * 1, Pg. 86 of 267REPORTNO.:REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE A3 of A23 FAl/17-0667
Rev. 0 3-PASS VERIFICATION
CHECKLIST
Verifier Name: Alfredo Garcia
Date: 07/12/2017
Page 3 of23 July, 2017 (MM/DDNYYY)
Document Number & Rev.: FAl/17-0667, Rev. 0 Method(s)
of Verification: (attach pages as needed) Design Review D Independent
Review or Alternate
Calculations
D Testing D 3-Pass Method rgj 3-Pass Verification
Review Topic First Pass Were the general theme, scope of document and scope of review clear? Second Pass Other (specify)
D Yes No D Do the references
appear to be documented
correctly?
Is there enough information
1 rgj D I present to ensure the referenced
document is retrievable? (Include F AI QAR number for f FAI documents.)
! If applicable, do the acceptance
criteria seem appropriate? D D Does the technical
content of the calculation
note make sense from a qualitative
rgj D standpoint
and are appropriate
methods used? Third Pass Do the results and conclusions
meet the acceptance
criteria? D D Do the results and conclusions
make sense and support the purpose of the calculation
f rgj D note? i Has the technical
content of the document been verified in adequate detail? Examples of rgj D technical
content include inputs, models, techniques, output, hand calculations, results, tables, plots, units of measure, etc. Does the calculation
note provide sufficient
detail in a concise manner? Note that rgj D sufficient
detail is enough information
such that a qualified
person could understand
the analysis and replicate
the results without consultation
with the author. Are proprietary
markings in place, as appropriate?
If applicable, are the references
accurate?
If applicable, do the references
to other documents
point to the latest revision?
If not, are the reasons documented?
Are the references
retrievable?
Are computer code names spelled correctly?
If applicable, are numerals included in the official code name as appropriate?
Has the documentation
for which the verifier is responsible
been read word-for-word?
D D D D D NIA D D 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 87 of 267REPORTNO.:REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE A4 of A23 FAl/17-0667
Rev. 0 EDITORIAL
REVIEW CHECKLIST
Page 4 o/23 July, 2017 Reviewer Name: Alfredo Garcia Date: 07/12/2017
Document Number: FAI/17-0667, Rev. 0 (MM/DDIYYYY)
Yes No NIA General Documents
1. Proofread
the document for general format, readability, punctuation, and grammar. Are these acceptable
to you? 2. Is the documentation
legible, reproducible
and in a form suitable for archiving
as a Quality Record? (This includes confirming
the .pdf and .doc files are identical
in content.)
3. Are all the pages sequentially
numbered and are the document number and revision number listed on each page? 4. Is the Record of Revision page filled in correctly
including
Revision, Date, and Description of Revisions, if applicable?
5. Are the page numbers in the Table of Contents provided and correct? 6. Are Acronyms defined in the document (either individually
or on a separate page)? 7. Are Figures labeled consistently
and do they include units of measure? 8. Are the units of measure clearly identified
and used throughout? 9. Do all cross references
to tables, figures, references, and sections point to an object of the given type? 10. Are symbols (e.g., Greek letters) used correctly? 11. Is sufficient
information (including
F AI QAR number for F AI documents)
provided for all "References" to facilitate
their retrieval
including
documents
not maintained
as quality records, or has a copy been provided in an Appendix to the report? 12. Are all References
listed referred to in the text and vice versa? 13. Is the content of the Appendices
consistent
with what the document states it is? D Cale Notes Body of Cale Notes 14. Is all information
in the cover page header block completed
appropriately? 15. Are the responsibilities
of the author(s)
and verifier(s)
clearly documented? (e.g. by page numbers, section numbers, etc.) 16. Is the report revision number on each page? 17. Are Tables labeled consistently
and do they include units of measure? 18. Is background
information
and purpose of the calculation
clearly stated in the appropriate section? 19. If applicable, have the limits of applicability
been listed? D 20. If applicable, are open items identified?
D 21. Are the Acceptance
Criteria listed in the appropriate
section (if applicable)?
D 22. Does the Cale Note include a discussion
on the methodology
used? 23. If applicable, are references
to the utility, plant, unit, and cycle correct with respect to spelling and consistency
of use? D D D D D D D D
D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D 
EC 620632, Att * 1, Pg. 88 of 267REPORTNO.:REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE AS of A23 FAl/17-0667
Rev. 0 Page 5 oJ2J July, 2017 Yes No N/A Body of Document 24. Is the Summary/Conclusion
consistent
with the purpose stated and consistent
with the results section? Computer Runs 25. Are the computer codes used clearly identified
and is all required information
included (per D F3-8.3-1, Attachment
1) included?
26. If applicable, are all electronic
files listed in the electronically
attached file listing? D 27. If applicable, does the electronically
attached file listing appropriately
reference
the codes D used? Checklists
28. Has the verifier initiated
one or more of the Verification
Methods of review in the Verification
Method Checklist?
29. Has the verifier provided an explanation
of the method ofreview in the Verification
Method [;gl Checklist?
30. Is an explanation
or justification
for any "NO" responses
on the 3-Pass Methodology
D Checklist( s) presented?
31.' Are Author's responses
provided to Additional
Verifier Comments or noted as not required?
D A_dditional
for Software Cale N ote_s 32. Is the software name, version number, and
system state(s) where the software was created D or validated
provided? (or, is a reference
for the software validation
provided?)
33. If results are based on code development
or modifications, is a source code listing or D reference
to a controlled
location of the source code included?
Alternately, if results are based on available
software is the software in a controlled
location?
34. Does the software output include the date of execution? (This could be in the form of a table D or an output file header.) 35. Does the software input include a description
of what is being analyzed? (In the body of the D report or description
header in the input file text.) Editorial
Reviewer Comments (if needed): None. D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D 
' EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 89 of 267REPORTNO.:REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 FAI/17-0667
PAGE A6 of A23 Rev. 0 RECORD OF REVISIONS
Rev. 0 Date (Month, Year) July, 2017 CAP AL Issue ID (If Applicable)
Original issue. Revision Description
Page 6 o/23 July, 2017 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 90 of 267REPORTNO.:REP-424-00B-RP1
FAI/17-0667
REVISION:
03 PAGE A? of A23 Rev. 0 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page 7 o/23 July, 2017 CALCULATION
NOTE COVER SHEET ....................................................................................
2 3-PASS VERIFICATION
CHECKLIST
........................................................................................
3 EDITORIAL
REVIEW CHECKLIST
............................................................................................
4 RECORD OF REVISIONS
........................................................................................................
* .... 6 TABLE OF CONTENTS ................................................................................................................
7 LIST OF FIGURES ........................................................................................................................
8 LIST OF TABLES ..........................................................................................................................
9 1.0 PURPOSE ..............................................................................................................................
10 2.0 TEST SPECIMENS
...............................................................................................................
11 3.0 RECEIPT INSPECTION
.......................................................................................................
12 4.0 ABNORMAL TEMPERATURE
EXPOSURE ....................................................................
18 4.1 Agastat Time Delay Relay (EUT-1) .............................................................................
18 4.2 Basler UFOV Assembly (EUT-2) & Basler Voltage Regulator (EUT-3) ....................
18 4.3 GE Loss of Excitation
Relay (EUT-4) .........................................................................
19 4.4 GE Reverse Power Relay (EUT-5) ...............................................................................
19 4.5 GE Restrained
Overcurrent
Relay (EUT-6A & 6B) ....................................................
20 4.6 P&B Relay (EUT-7) .....................................................................................................
20 4.7 Phoenix Power Supply (EUT-8) ...................................................................................
20 4.8 Westinghouse
Differential
Relay (EUT-9) ...................................................................
20 4.9 Woodward Governor Control Assembly (EUT-10) .....................................................
21 5.0 TEST EQUIPMENT
AND CALIBRATION
........................................................................
22 6.0 SUMMARY ..........................................................................................................................
23 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 91 of 267REPORTNO.:REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE AB of A23 FAI/17-0667
Rev. 0 LIST OF FIGURES Page 8 o/23 July, 2017 Figure 3-1 Agastat Time Delay Relay (EUT-1) .....................................................................
12 Figure 3-2 Basler UFOV Assembly (EUT-2) .........................................................................
13 Figure 3-3 Basler Voltage Regulator (EUT-3) .......................................................................
13 Figure 3-4 GE Loss of Excitation
Relay (EUT-4) ..................................................................
14 Figure 3-5 GE Reverse Power Relay (EUT-5) .......................................................................
14 Figure 3-6 GE Restrained
Overcurrent
Relay (BUT-6A) ......................................................
15 Figure 3-7 GE Restrained
Overcurrent
Relay (EUT-6B) ......................................................
15 Figure 3-8 P&B Relay (EUT-7) .............................................................................................
16 Figure 3-9 Phoenix Power Supply (EUT-8) ...........................................................................
16 Figure 3-10 Westinghouse
Differential
Relay (EUT-9) ...........................................................
17 Figure 3-11 Woodward Governor Control Assembly (EUT-10) .............................................
17 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 92 of 267REPORTNO.:REP-424-008-RP1
FAJ/17-0667
REVISION:
03 PAGE A9 of A23 Page 9 of23 July, 2017 Rev. 0 LIST OF TABLES Table 2-1 Equipment
Under Test ..........................................................................................
11 Table 4-1 Basler Test Results ................................................................................................
19 Table 4-2 GE Loss of Excitation
Test Results ......................................................................
19 Table 4-3 Westinghouse
Differential
Relay Test Results .....................................................
21 Table 5-1 Test Equipment
.......................................
.' .............................................................
22 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 93 of 267REPORTNO.:REP-424-00B-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE A10 of A23 FAI/17-0667
Rev. 0 1.0 PURPOSE Page JO of23 July, 2017 The Clinton Diesel Generator
room may be exposed to elevated temperatures
during diesel operation
combined with the loss of room HV AC system. These temperatures
would exceed the rating of components
associated
with the diesel generator
circuit. The purpose is to test these components
at 225&deg;F and 245&deg;F and monitor their performance.
Testing is performed
in accordance with KCI test specification
424-008-TSP2, "Test Specification
for Determining
Component
Survivability
and Operation
in Ambient Temperatures
not to exceed 245&deg;F" Rev 001 (FAI QAR 5.178), herein referred to as the Test Specification.
This report documents
test results from implementation
of the test specification. 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 94 of 267REPORTNO.:REP-424-008-RP1
FAI/17-0667
Rev. 0 2.0 TEST SPECIMENS
REVISION:
03 PAGEA11 ofA23 The equipment
under test (EUT) is identified
in Table 2-1. Table 2-1 Equipment
Under Test Test Specimen # Manufacturer
Model EUT-1 Agastat 7012PD EUT-2 Basler 9-1051-00-105
EUT-3 Basler SR8A2B01B3A
EUT-4 GE 12CEH51A1A
EUT-5 GE 12GGP53BlA
EUT-6A GE 12UCV51Al3A
EUT-6B GE 12IFCV51AD1A
EUT-7 P&B MDR 137-8 EUT-8 Phoenix 2938578 EUT-9 Westinghouse
290B225Al0 (Type SA-1) EUT-10 Woodward 2301A Page 11 of23 July, 2017 Description
Time Delay Relay UFOV Assembly Voltage Regulator
Loss of Excitation
Relay Reverse Power Relay Restrained
Overcurrent
Relay Restrained
Overcurrent
Relay Relay 125 VDC -24 VDC Power Supply Differential
Relay Governor Control Assembly 
EC 62063 2 , Att. 1, Pg. 95 of 267 REPORTNO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE A12 of A23 FAl/17-0667 R ev. 0 3.0 RECEIPT INSPECTION
Pag e 12 o/23 July, 201 7 Eleven components
were delivered
to Fauske & Associates, LLC on June 5th, 2017. The receipt i n spection was performed
in accordance
with Fauske & Associates, LLC Level 3 procedure
F3-9. 7-1 Visual Inspection, and KCI Test Specification
Number 424-008-TSP2
Rev. 001. A ll of the manufacturer, modeVpart
number, and serial number information
was verifie d and fo und to be correct for the components
list ed in Table 2-1. Photographs
of the test specimens
w ere taken and are presented
below. All test specimens
were free from obvious signs of physical damage. No physical anomalies
were noted. Figure 3-1 Agastat Time Delay Relay (EUT-1) 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. F Al/17-0667 Rev. 0 9 6 0 f 2 6 7 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION: 03 Figure 3-2 Figure 3-3 PAGE A13 of A23 --*-.-.-...... **W.C ""' .... ---MWDCM--JOVDCAf0.
1A Basler UFOV Assembly (EUT-2) STATIC VOLTAGE R[GULATOR
_,. .. Basler Voltage Regulator (EUT-3) Page 13 of23 July, 2017 
EC 62063 2 , Att. 1, Pg. 97 of 267 REPORTNO.: REP-424-008-RP1
FAl/17-066 7 REVISION: 03 PAGE A14 of A23 Rev. 0 Figure 3-4 GE Loss of Excitation
Relay (EUT-4) Figure 3-5 GE Reverse Power Relay (EUT-5) L Page 14 of23 Jul y, 2017 
EC 62 0 632 , At t. 1 , Pg. 98 of 267 REPORTNO.: REP-424-008-RP1
FAI/17-0 6 6 7 REVISION:
03 PAG E A15 of A23 R ev. 0 Figure 3-6 GE Restrain e d Overcurrent
Relay (E UT-6A) Figure 3-7 GE Restrained
Overcurrent
Relay (EUT-6B) P age 1 5 o/23 J u l y, 2017 
E C 62 0 632 , A tt. 1, Pg. 99 o f 267 REPORTNO.: REP-424-008-RP1 FAJ/17-066 7 REVISION: 03 PAGE A16 of A23 R e v. 0 Figure 3-8 P&B Relay (EUT-7) Figure 3-9 Phoenix Power Supply (EUT-8) P age 16 o/23 Jul y , 2017 
E C 62 0 632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 1 00 of
FAI/17-066 7 REVISION:
03 PAGE A17 of A23 R ev. 0 Figure 3-10 Westinghouse
Differential
Relay (EUT-9) Figure 3-11 Woodward Governor Control Assembly (EUT-10) Pa ge 1 7 of23 Jul y , 2017 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 101 of
FA//17-0667
REVISION:
03 PAGE A18 of A23 Rev. 0 4.0 ABNORMAL TEMPERATURE
EXPOSURE Page 18 of23 July, 2017 The EUT's will be exposed to 225&deg;F for 24 hours with functional
test performed
after one hour of exposure and at the end of the 24 hour period. Oven temperature
will then be raised to 245&deg;F and EUT's exposed to the elevated temperature
for 8 hours. Functional
tests will be performed
after one hour of exposure to the elevated temperature
at the end of the test cycle prior to removal from the oven. 4.1 Agastat Time Delay Relay (EUT-1) Baseline functional
tests were performed
in accordance
with section 4.2.1 of the test specification.
The average of three measurements
for pickup voltage was 92.4VDC, for dropout voltage 24.1 VDC and the coil holding current 66mA. The relay timer was set to 50s and upon energizing
the relay with 125VDC, the timer timed
out and the normally closed contact opened. This contact was then monitored
with a digital meter (DVM) to ensure the contact remained open during the during the temperature
exposure testing. The contact remained open for the 24 hour period at 225&deg;F but the coil shorted out during the testing at 245&deg;F. A new relay was configured
in the same manner and exposed to 238&deg;F for 24 hours and successfully
completed
this test. 4.2 Basler UFOV Assembly (EUT-2) & Basler Voltage Regulator (EUT-3) The voltage regulator
and under voltage over frequency (UVOF) units were interconnected
and powered by a 240V AC three phase source as described
in Attachment
A of the test specification.
The connections
to the generator
field were simulated
using light bulbs of approximately
500W. The frequency
was decreased
from 60Hz and the light bulb extinguished
at 53.3Hz. The frequency
was then raised back to 60Hz where the bulb re-illuminated
at 53.9Hz. The voltage was then ramped up, at 245V AC the bulb extinguished.
The voltage was returned to 240V AC and the bulb re-illuminated.
During the abnormal temperature
tests the light bulb remained illuminated
indicating
no under frequency
or overvoltage
signal occurred.
Functional
testing was repeated during the temperature
excursions
with results as follows: 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 102 of
REVISION:
03 PAGE A19 of A23 FAI/17-0667
Rev. 0 Table 4-1 Basler Test Results Test Sequence Frequency (Hz) Bulb Extinguished
1 HR@225&deg;F 51.1 24Hr@225&deg;F
53.7 1Hr@245&deg;F
49.6 8Hr@245&deg;F
49.7 4.3 GE Loss of Excitation
Relay (EUT-4) Page 19 of23 July, 2017 Voltage (V AC) Bulb Extinguished
246.4 247.7 247.7 248.0 The relay was wired in accordance
with the test specification, Attachment
D, section D-3. The voltage phase angle was set to +30&deg; and the current phase angle to 0&deg; using the Doble F2253 and the light bulb wired into the circuit did not illuminate.
The current phase angle was then stepped down in increments
of -1 &deg;. At -11 &deg; the relay operated and the bulb illuminated.
The relay current phase was then set back to 0&deg; and the relay was then exposed to 225&deg;F for 24 hours and 245&deg;F for 8 hours. During testing
the light bulb did not illuminate
indicating
the relay did not operate. During testing the relay phase angle was again adjusted until a trip occurred illuminating
the light. These results are as follows: Table 4-2 GE Loss of Excitation
Test Results Test Sequence Phase Angle 1 hour into 225&deg;F test _90 End of 225&deg;F test _go 1 hour into 245&deg;F test _90 End of245&deg;F test -60 4.4 GE Reverse Power Relay (EUT-5) The relay was wired and tested in accordance
with the test specification
Attachment
E. The relay current coil carried 5.0A continuously
and voltage coil was subjected
to 120 VAC to simulate 95% generator
load. The relay was de-energized
and phase connections
B and C flipped and when re-energized
the monitoring
light illuminated
indicating
the relay operated.
The relay was then energized
and subjected
to 225&deg;F for 24 hours and 245&deg;F for 8 hours without the light illuminating
thus indicating
no false operation.
At one hour into the 225&deg;F test and at completion
of this test the B and C phases were switched as described
for the baseline functionals
and the relay operated.
At one hour into and at completion
of the 245&deg;F test the phases were switched and the relay operated. 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 103 of 26R_EPORTNO.:REP-424-008-RP1
FAI/17-0667
REVISION:
03 PAGE A20 of A23 Rev. 0 4.5 GE Restrained
Overcurrent
Relay (EUT-6A & 6B) Page20of23
July, 2017 The relays were connected
in accordance
with Attachment
B of the test specification.
A light bulb was wired into the circuit to monitor whether the relay operated.
Current to the relay was . gradually
increased
until the bulb illuminated
indicating
the relay operated, the current value was llA. For the temperature
testing at 225&deg;F and 245&deg;F 4.0A was supplied to the relay coil and the light bulb monitored.
The light bulb did not illuminate
thus indicating
no false operation
of the relay. 4.6 P&B Relay (EUT-7) Baseline functional
tests were performed
in accordance
with section 4.2.6 of the test specification.
The average of three measurements
for pickup voltage was 73.4VDC, for dropout voltage 29.SVDC and the coil holding current 81.7mA. 125VDC was applied to the relay coil. An open relay contact was monitored
to ensure the relay did not drop out throughout
the temperature
exposure.
The contact remained open throughout
the test at 225&deg;F for the 24 hour indicating
the coil did not drop out. The relay failed (dropped out) during the 245&deg;F test. 4. 7 Phoenix Power Supply (EUT-8) Baseline functional
tests were performed
in accordance
with section 4.2. 7 of the test specification.
The output voltage and voltage at 80% load current were measured three times and averaged.
The value at no load was 24.lVDC and at 80% load current, 23.9VDC. For the abnormal temperature
testing the power supply was energized
with 125VDC with a load equivalent
to 50% of the load carrying capability
of the power supply. After one hour at 225&deg;F the power supply shutdown.
Power supply load was reduced to 20% and testing resumed at 225&deg;F, however the power again dropped out. At this point, deviations
from the test specification
were provided.
The oven temperature
was lowered to 207&deg;F and the load was maintained
at 20% for 24 hours. With about 3 hours remaining
the load was increased
back to 50% and the test completed
without further incidence.
There was no testing at 245&deg;F. 4.8 Westinghouse
Differential
Relay (EUT-9) The relay was wired in accordance
with Attachment
C of the test specification.
SA was supplied to the restraint
coil. The operating
coil to each phase was increased
until the relay operated.
The operating
currents where the relay operated were as follows: Phase A: 0.266A Phase B: 0.259A Phase C: 0.257 A 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 104 of
REVISION:
03 PAGE A21 of A23 FAI/17-0667
Rev. 0 Page 21 o/23 July, 2017 The restraint
coil to the relay carried 5A continuously
and the operating
coil, 0.22A. A bulb was placed into the circuit to monitor whether the relay operated.
The bulb did not illuminate
during the 225&deg;F test or the 245&deg;F test. The functional
tests were performed
on Phase A during exposure to 225&deg;F. These tests consisted
of increasing
the phase A current until the relay tripped. The following
are the results: Table4-3 Westinghouse
Differential
Relay Test Results Time During 225&deg;F Test Phase A amps where relay tripped 1 Hour 0.247 3 Hour 0.220 24 Hour 0.243 4.9 Woodward Governor Control Assembly (EUT-10) The governor control system was configured
as shown in Attachment
F of the test specification.
The governor actuator operates to protect the diesel generator
unit from an over speed condition.
A magnetic pickup monitors engine speed and operates an actuator to reduce engine speed on an over speed condition.
The magnetic pickup was simulated
with a function generator
and the actuators
with a 50 ohm resistor.
At an input frequency
of 3975Hz the voltage across the resistor was zero volts indicating
no pickup of an over speed condition.
The frequency
was then raised to 4075Hz and the voltage across the resistor increased
to 19.74VDC.
The voltage returned to zero when the frequency
dropped back to 3975Hz. During testing at 225&deg;F and 245&deg;F the voltage across the 50 ohm resistor was monitored
with a DVM. The DVM showed zero volts with the function generator
set to 3975Hz during the test indication
that no over speed signal was generated.
At one hour into the 225&deg;F and 245&deg;F test and at the end of both tests the frequency
was raised to 4075Hz, the voltage recorded at 19.74VDC.
The voltage returned to zero in all cases when the frequency
dropped back to 3975Hz. 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 105 of 26R_EPORTNO.:REP-424-008-RP1
FAI/17-0667
REVISION:
03 PAGE A22 of A23 Rev. 0 5.0 TEST EQUIPMENT
AND CALIBRATION
The test equipment
used is identified
in Table 5-1. Table 5-1 Test Equipment
Equipment
Manufacturer
Model Serial/ID#
Power Supply Chroma 61604 616040003187
Power Supply Chroma 61604 616040003197
Power Supply Chroma 61604 616040003355
Power Supply APT 320XAC 4100203 Power Supply APT 320XAC 4100105 Power Supply APT 320XAC 4100109 Power Supply APT 320XAC 4100068 Multi-Meter
Fluke 87V 20890147 Clamp-Meter
Fluke 376 25480485WS
Multi-Meter
Fluke 45 5045 Page22 of23 July, 2017 Calibration
Expiration
Date 3/15/2018
2/14/2018
11/18/2017
1/30/2018
1/30/2018
1/30/2018
1/30/2018
11/17/2017
10/31/2017
1/30/2018 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 106 of 26REPORTNO.:REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE A23 of A23 FAI/17-0667
Rev. 0 6.0 SUMMARY Page 23 of23 July, 2017 Testing was completed
in accordance
with the test specification
as outlined in Section 4.0 ofthis report. The occurrences
of any anomalies
are also included in Section 4.0. 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 107 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP*424*00B*RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 81OF818 A. f:
*--Report No.: FAI/17-0612
Relay Drop Out Testing of GE CR120BD04341
and Agastat E7012PD004
Relays for Clinton Power Station Revision 1 Project No.: KCI-Clinton-Relay
Submitted
to: KC/ Downers Grove, Illinois Prepared by: Alfredo Garcia Reviewed by: William E. Berger September, 2017 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 108 of 267 TABLE OF CONTENTS REPORT NO.: REP*424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 82 OF 818 LIST OF FIGURES ........................................................................................................................
3 LIST OF TABLES ..........................................................................................................................
4 1.0 Background
............................................................................................................................
10 2.0 Purpose ..................................................................................................................................
11 3.0 Test Specimens
......................................................................................................................
12 4.0 Test Procedure
.......................................................................................................................
13 4.1 Test Setup .....................................................................................................................
13 5.0 Test Results ...........................................................................................................................
14 5.1 Receipt Inspection
........................................................................................................
14 5.2 Baseline Functional
Test ..............................................................................................
15 5.3 Circuit Operation Testing
..................................................................*..........................
16 6.0 Conclusion
.............................................................................................................................
18 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 109 of 267 LIST OF FIGURES REPORT NO.: REP-424*008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 83 OF 818 Figure 4-1 Mounted Test Specimens
......................................................................................
13 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 110 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE B4 OF B18 LIST OF TABLES Table 3-1 Test Specimens
.....................................................................................................
12 Table 5-1 Baseline Test Results ............................................................................................
16 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 111 of 267 FAJ/17-0612
Rev. 1 REPORT NO.: REP*424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 85 OF 818 PagY:. 5 of 18 September, 2017 CALCULATION
NOTE COVER SHEET *-----* --*--SECTION TO BE COMPLETED
BY AUTIIOR(S):
-*---------Cale-Note
Number: FAf/17-0612
Revision Number: 1 --------Title: Relay Drop Out Testing of GE CR120BD04341
and Aga<>tat F.70 I 2PD004 Relays for Clinton Power Station -----i Project Number ProjcctiSubject:
Relay Testing or Shop Order: KCI-Clintun-Rclay
--*---***---
Purpose: Perform relay drop out testing on GE CR120BD04341
andAgastat
E7012PD004
relays Methods of Analysis*:
Tc:-1ting
-----Acceptance
Criteria*:
NIA ---***-----Results Summary: Rev.1 Removed proprietat1'
statements
from report per customer request.
Does this document contain Proprietary
Infom1ation? (Yes/No, if Yes whose infonnation
is it?) No *Can be N/A and/or a referc:nce
lo this information
in the Design Analysis can be provided.
References
of Resulting
Reports, Letters, or Memoranda (Optional)
Author(s):
Completion
Date: Kame (Print or Type) -e/f'brr''. Responsibility: (M1v1/DD/YYYY)
Alfredo Garcia ALL {)?__ / / L( L:JDC::j . . Y I 7 ----------*-*--, --*----------'*----.. -----! SECTION TO BE co:rvIPLETED
BY VERIFIER(S):
-------* Verifier(s):
Approval Date: I Name (Print or T)pc) s;;ze: Responsibility: (tvi.M/DD/YYYY)
William .E. Berger dJ!f!,,_,-:i::
r/ ALL cYth7' /2&deg;1/ ____ , --/ r----Each verifier signature
confinns they have completed
a separate 3-Pass Verification
Checklist.
--*-**-'"-----**----.-*-
------SECTION TO BE CO:MPLETED
BY EDflORIAL
REVIEWER:
-* -**--*--Reviewer(s)
Name: Final PDF Approval Date: (.Print or Type) Signature:
Check*: (MM/DD/YYYY)
"\Villiam
E. Berger
Gt a 9' /;v /z.012 D 7 z *At lca"t one individual (verifier, editorial
reviewer, or manager) is responsible
for an editorial
review of the final, signed off version of the PDF. That responsibility
is delegated
here (by check box), and by their signature
the delegate accepts and ! --* --: ! i a?kil._owled&estheir
responsibility
to perform this final review step. ----' ] ! SECTION TO BB COMPLETED
BY RESPONSIBLE
MANAGER::
-----**" ' Manager Name: Approval Date: (Print or Type) (MM/DD/YYYY)
Brenda T .orenz o c; lJlf_L.Joi
7 "*----C.,-(_ . ') I i Responsibilities
of ai1thors/veritiers
are documented
!ill Independence
of verification
is confim1ed
121 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 112 of 267 Ftl.l/17-0612 .R.ev. l REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 86 OF 818 3-PASS VERIFICATION
CHECKLIST
P{{ge 6 of l 8
2017 Verifier Name: \ViUiam E.
Date: a 9 .;, Lf" I Z..c.>i 7 {MVl/llONYYY)
Document Kumher & Rev.: FAVl 7-0612 Rev.1
Metho<l(s)
of VerifJcatio:-i; (ottach pages as tieedcd) Des[gtt Re\fieW D Jndcpcndcr.t
Review ur AlLcnw.ic
Calculatiom
Method 0 Other{5pecify)
3NPass Verification
Topic First Palls Were the genera.I theme. sccpc of do.:.;.ume:::i.t
and scope of review clear?
Do the references
al)pear to be documented
corr.xtly?
Is there enough informati::,i-1:
present to e:isure 1hc: referenced
documt,'nl
is ret:-ievable? (Include FA.I QAR 1m:nber for F."1 documents.)
I If a;Jplicabk.
do the acceptance
criteria seem appropriate'?
:
the tedwical content of tl1e ca1colatio11
note make sense from a qm[i.UJ.tive
standpoint
an(l arc appropriate
methods *Jsed? Thh*rl Pnss Do the rnsulLs a:-id wnGlusiumJ
ma::t the acccptauci::
critcrill'?
Do the results <'lml conc::lm;iom
make sense and support purpose o: the ca:culatior..
note? ; Ilas the teclm.ical
content of the documenL
v-t:ri3.ed
in adequate dct11il? Exa:nples
of = kch.n;.cal
conten.t incluC:e inputs, models, techniques, out.put, hand cak:*..11ations, results, tables, plots, units of measUl'e, etc. Does tlte calculat!on
n;:ite prll\'i<lt:
:>uffo:it::nl
in a conc.:ise
manner? Note that st:fficient
detail i.s enough infomi.ation
such thnl a qualifie:d
person -could *mderstand
the i mmlysis and replicate
the rcsnlts without consultation.
wieh the author. Arc propriccary
mark.i:;igs
in place, m ap;:m::ipriate?
If applicable, are the references
acctmiw? If applir.::<.iblli, do the references
to other documents
point 1o the falcsL rcvfoiun? (f vot, arc the r:;:asons
documented?
Are the references
1-etrievable?
Are
code 1wmes s;ielled correctly?
If applicable, are num:::rals
included.
iu the official code name as apprnpriate?
; Has the documentation
for which llio verifier is responsible
been read word-for-word?
Yes D D Testlng D T D D D D D D D D D D D D N/A D 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 113 of 267 FAI/17-0612
Rev. 1 EDITORIAL
REVIEW CHECKLIST
REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 87 OF 818 Pagr 7of18 September, 2017 Reviewer Name: William E. Berger
Document Number: FAV17-0612
Rev.l Date: t?C( b.t/ Lk1 1 (:rvfrvrroD/YYYY)
-
1. Proofread
the document for general fonnat, readability, punctuation, and grammar. Are these acceptable
lo you? 2. Is the documentation
legible, reproducible
and in a form suitable for archiving
as a Quality Record? (This includes confirming
the .pdf and .doc files are identical
in content.)
3. Are all the pages sequentially
numbered and are the document number and revision number listed on each page? 4. Is the Record of Revision page filled in correctly
including
Revision, Date, and Description
of Revisions, if applicable?
5. Are the page numbers in the Table of Contents provided and correct? 6 . .?\re Acronyms defined in the document (either individually
or on a separate page)? 7. Are Figures labeled consistently
and do they include units of measure? 8. Are the units of measure clearly identified
and used throughout?
9. Do all cross references
to tables, figures, references, and sections point to an object of the gi vcn type? 10 . .1\re symbols (e.g., Greek letters) used correctly?
11. Is sufficient
infom1ation (including
FAI QAR number for FAT documents)
provided for all "References" to facilitate
their retrieval
including
documents
not maintained
as quality records, or has a copy been provided in an Appendix to the rep01t? 12. Are all Reterences
listed referred lo in the text and vice versa? 13. Ts the content of the Appendices
consistent
with what the document states it is? Body of Cale Notes 14. Is all information
in the cover page header block completed
appropriately?
15. Are the responsibilities
of the aulhor(s)
and verifier(s)
clearly documented? (e.g. by page numbers, section numbers, etc.) 16. Is the report revision number on each page? 17. A.re Tables labeled consistently
and do they include units of measure? 18. Is background
infomiation
and purpose of the calculation
clearly stated in the appropriate
section? 19. If applicable, have the limits of applicability
been listed? 20. If applicable, are open items identi tied? 21. Are the Acceptance
Criteria listed in the appropriate
section (if applicable)?
22. Does the Cale Note include a discussion
on tJ1c methodology
used? 23. If applicable, arc references
lo the utility, plant, unit, and cycle correct with respect to spelling and consistency
of use? Yes &l &1 IXJ lYJ D [lJ D D ,El D [YJ D D D D It! No NIA D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D rn D J8J D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D [3l' D @ D D psi D DI 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 114 of 267 FA1i17-0612
Rev. I REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE BB OF 818 Pa[:&#xa5; 8of18 Sr!ptember.
2017 Yes No N/A Body of Document 24. Is the Summary/Conclusion
consistent
with the purpose stated and consistent
wilh Lh.: results se.ction?
Computer Runs 25. Are the computer codes used clearly identified
and is all required information
included (per D F3-8.3-1, Attachment
1) included?
26. lf applicable, are all electronic
files !isled in the clcctronfoally
attached file listing? D 27. If applicable, does the electronically
allached file listing appropriately
reference
the codes D used? Checklists
28. Has the verifier initialed
one or more of the Verification
Methods of review in the Verification
Method Checklist?
1 29. Has the verifier provided an explanation
of the method of review in the Verification
Method Checklist?
30. Is an explanation
or justification
for any "NO" responses
on the 3-Paiis Methodology
Checklist(s)
presented?
31. Are Author's responses
provided to Additional
Verifier Comments or noted as not required'?
* D 32. Is the software name, version number, and system state(s) where the software was created D or validated
provided? (or, is a reference
for the software validation
provided?)
33. If results are based on code development
or modifications, is a source code listing or D reference
tu a controlled
location of the source code included?
Alternately, if results are hased on available
&sect;Oftware is Lhc software in a controlled
location?
34. Doel'l the software output include the date of execution? (This could be in the form of a table D or an output file header.) 35. Does the software input include a description
of what is being analyzed? (In the body of the D report or description
header in the input file text.) Editorial
Reviewer Comments (if needed): D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D D 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 115 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 89 OF 818 RECORD OF REVISIONS
Rev. Date CAP AL Issue ID Revision Description (Month, Year) (If Applicable)
0 June,2017
Original issue. 1 September, Removed Proprietary
statements
from report per customer 2017 request. 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 116 of 267 1.0 Background
REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 810 OF 818 The 480V Bus IA sequencing
control circuit relay logic for the 480 V Bus IA sequencing
circuit recently demonstrated
latent relay race for the VD fans. As the design does not provide stored DC relay energy to be dissipated, the
logic is dependent
on the relay parameters (i.e., coil inductance, coil time constant, drop out voltage and core air gap). The success of the logic sequence is limited by the drop out times of the two relays (GE CRI20BD0434I
and Agastat E70I2PD004)
and their drift of coil parameters
over time. In this specific case, the relay parameters
supported
the logic sequence in the past before replacement
of equivalent
relays that may have introduced
tolerances
and a mismatch between the relay parameters
that are causing a race in the logic sequence.
[Test Specification
#424-008-TSPI
Rev.00] 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 117 of 267 2.0 Purpose REPORT NO.: REP-424*008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 811 OF 818 The purpose of this test report is to document relay drop out time testing of GE CR120BD04341
and Agastat E7012PD004
relays per test specification
number 424-008-TSPl
Rev.00. Testing consisted
of measuring
electrical
properties
including
drop out time of the relays under various test conditions. 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 118 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 812 OF 818 3.0 Test Specimens
The equipment
under test (BUT) included the following
test specimens:
Table 3-1 Test Specimens
,,:.
... : ,,
EUT#l GE CR120BD04341
EUT#2 GE CR120BD04341
EUT#3 Agastat E7012PD004
Relay Relay Time Delay Relay 
EC 62 0 632 , A tt. 1, P g. 11 9 of 26 7 4.0 Test Procedure
REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 813 OF 818 The test sequence and test procedure
are defined in Section 4.0 of KCI Test Specification
Number 424-008-TSPl
Rev.00. The test specification
is archived in the Fauske Quality Assurance
Archive under QAR number 5.178 along with this test report. 4.1 Test Setup During testin g, the relays were mounted horizontally
on a panel to simulat e plant orientation.
A photograph
of the test setup can be found in Figure 4-1 below. The relays were wired consistent
with the circuit configuration
found in Section 4.3 of th e test specification. Figure 4-1 Mounted Test Specimens
4.2 Test Instrumentation
The following
instrumentation
was used during t e sting: Instrument
Description
Serial Number Calibration
Due Date Chroma AC Power Supply 616040003355
11118/17 Agilent LCR Met e r MY54150107
4/3/18 Fluke 45 8865045 1/30/18 Fluk e 87V 20890147 11/17/17 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 120 of 267 5.0 Test Results 5.1 Receipt Inspection
REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVIS I ON: 03 PAGE B14 OF B18 A receipt inspection
was performed
on all 3 EUTs upon arrival to the test facility.
The EUTs were shipped from the Clinton Station and were brand new components.
The receipt inspection
was performed
in accordance
with Fauske & Associates
Level 3 procedure
F3-9.7-1 Visual Inspection.
The receipt inspections
demonstrated
that the test specimens
were not damaged during shipping and were in normal physical condition
prior to the start of testing. No evidence of degradation, discoloration, or cracking was found during the inspection. The manufacturer
and model numbers were identified
and documented.
Laboratory
identifiers
were assigned to the test specimens
consistent
with Table 3-1. This means that EUT #1 was assigned to one of the two available
GE relays, EUT #2 was assigned to the second available
GE relay while EUT#3 was assigned to the Agastat relay. Photographs
of the test specimens
were taken during the inspection. Photographs
of the receipt inspection
are found below. Figure 5-1 GE CR120BD04341
(1 of2) Receipt Inspection
Photos-Side
Views 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 1 21 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 815 OF 818 Figure 5-2 GE CR120BD04341
(2 of2) Receipt Inspection
Photos-Top and Bottom Views Figure 5-3 Agastat E7012PD004
Receipt Inspection
Photos 5.2 Baseline Functional
Test Baseline tests were performed
in accordance
with section 4.2 of the KCI test specification
number 424-008-TSPl.
The baseline functional
test results are summarized
in Table 5-1 below. During pick-up voltage testing EUT #2 demonstrated
abnormally
high pick-up voltage values 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 122 of 267 RE P ORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVIS I ON: 03 PAGE 816 O F 818 through two attempts. On the third pick-up voltage test attempt, EUT #2 failed to operate. The relay was allowed to cool but was not able to operate again. KCI was notified of this anomaly. EUT #2 was not utilized for the remainder
of testing. BUT #1 and BUT #3 completed
baseline functional
testing without issues. Table 5-1 Baseline Test Results Test Coil Coil
Pick-Up C o il Drop-Out Dr o p-Out Resistance
Inductance
Vo l tage Current Voltage Specimen (kO) (H) (V) (m.A) (V) Time(ms) EUT#l 6.0 15.2 74.1 20.1 8.9 141.6 EUT#2 5.9 15.3 N I A NIA NIA NIA BUT#3 1.8 10.4 77 66.3 20.3 64.1 5.3 Circuit Operation
Testing A test circuit was built in accordance
with the drawing in Section 4.3 of KCI Test Specification
Number 424-008-TSPl
Rev.00 utilizing
BUT #1 and BUT #3. The relay circuit logic reproduced
the Clinton Power Station logic sequence issue when energized
and tested. Meaning, EUT #1 did not drop out after the 10 second time delay on BUT #3 occurred.
The relay circuit logic sequence was unsuccessful
each time the circuit was energized.
Follow up tests were performed
on the relay circuit. The tests consisted
of 1) taking relay coil current measurements
on both EUT #1 and BUT #3 during circuit operation
and 2) measuring
EUT #3 contact opening time. Coil current measurements
were taken for both relays during the relay logic sequence.
The minimum coil current measured for BUT # 1 was 16 mA. The expected minimum amount of coil current required for the relay to drop out was 1.4 mA. The minimum coil current observed for EUT #3 was 56 mA. The expected minimum amount of coil current required for the relay to drop out was 10.8 mA. These high coil current values suggest that the relay circuit design does not provide the stored energy in the relays to be properly dissipated. This delay in energy dissipation
is long enough to allow the circuit logic to reset and initiate another 1 0 second time delay on BUT #3. Since BUT #1 did not drop out, the normally closed contact of BUT #3 was tested to observe if the contact would actually open even though both BUT #1 and BUT #3 were not dropping out. The contact opening time tests were performed
on a normally closed contact on BUT #3. A 5 VDC signal was p l aced across one of the normally closed contacts on BUT #3. The testing demonstrated
that, after the 10 second time de l ay of BUT #3, the normally closed contact on BUT #3 would open for 25 milliseconds
and return to its normally closed state. This means that despite the fact that BUT #3 does not drop out, the relay's normally closed contacts still operated 
EC 62063 2 , Att. 1, Pg. 1 23 of 2 67 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 817 OF 818 as expected.
Therefore, the operation
of EUT #3's contacts is a mechanical
action and not a r e sult of the relay dropping out. 5.4 Manual
Relay When EUT #1 is energized , the tip of the plunger move s outward. Manually pressing the plunger i n an attempt to de-energize
the relay required considerable
force and was difficult
to execute. R emoval of the "+" wire to the 3 contact on EUT #3, the half coil wire connected
to contact 4 on EUT #1, or the"-" wire to the EUT #1 coil would result in de-energizing
EUT #1. 5.5 Thermal
Due to the relay circuit logic being unsuccessfu
l at the onset of testing , thermal aging was not performed
on the EUTs. 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 124 of 267 6.0 Conclusion
REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 818 OF 818 When energized, the relay circuit logic tested in this report was not successfu l and reproduced
the Clinton Power Station issue each time. Further tests demonstrated
that both EUT #1 and EUT #3 do not drop out upon completion
of the logic sequence due to the design not allowing the stored energy in the relays to be dissipated.
EUT #3 mechanically
operates its normally open/normally closed contacts
after the 10 second time delay for 25 milliseconds
before the relay resets back to its normally closed state due to the relay's inability
to drop out. EUT #1 does not drop out within the 25 millisecond
window due to the amount of coil current keeping the relay energized
and allows the relay circuit to reset. 
EC 62063 2 , Att. 1 , Pg. 125 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-4 24-008-RP1
REVISION: 03 I PAGE C1 OF C1 
E C 62 0 632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 126 of 26 7 It is not unusual for power generating
systems to operate below rated speed during periods of warm-up or pr i me mover maintenance. If the resulting
underfrequency
condition
persists , damage may result to the electrical
system as the SR vo l tage regulator
attempts to ma in ta i n rated generator
output voltage. The Basler UFOV250A and UFOV260A are designed to protect the generating
system against sustained
low speed operation
by reducing regulator
output and , t hereby , generator
voltage. By addi n g the optional overvo l tage circuit breaker , the
regulator
system can be protected
against overvoltage
conditions. DESCRIPTION
The UFOV250A and UFOV260A prevent the vo l tage regu l ator from maintaining
rated generator
voltage when generator
frequency
decreases more than 4 to 7 Hertz below nominal va l ue. When the underfrequency
circuit assumes control , the reduct i on in generator
output is proport i onal to the degree of the underfrequency
condition.
When the frequency
returns to nominal , the output of the SR regulator
i s automatically
increased , thereby increas i ng generator
output to nom i nal. To provide overvoltage
protection, a circu i t breaker is ad d ed to trip when the appl i ed voltage exceeds a predetermined, adjustable
value (125%-150%
of nominal). The circuit breaker contacts are nected in series with the voltage regulator
power input lines so that t he SR re gulator AC power (terminals
3 and 4) i s removed when the bre a ker trips. FEATURES * Des i gned for use with Basler SR-A , SR-F , and SR-H families of voltage regulators. * Protects generator, voltage regulator , and associated
equipment
against underfrequency/overvoltage
* cond i tions. * Models for both 50 and 60 Hz operat i on. * Operates on NEMA standard vo l tages to 600 V AC. * Overvoltage
trip adjust. * Compact , rel i able , economical.
* Mechan i cally rugged. * CSA certified. * Overvoll a ge p rotecbon provided when com p an i on c l rc.u 1 t breaker i s use d. R E PORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 01OF04 UFOV250A/260A
UNDERFREQUENCY/
OVERVOLTAGE
PROTECTIVE
MODULES Class 200 Equipment
SPEC I FICATIONS
Page 2 ORDER I NG Page 2 OU T LINE DRAWINGS Page 3 INTERCONNECT
DIAGRAM Page4 &sect;.Basler Electric SPD-5 2-93 P. D. BO X 269 HIGHLAND, IUINOIS , U.S.A. 62249 PHONE 611-&S.-23-41
FAX 618-i5HJ51 
E C 62 06 32 , Att. 1 , Pg. 1 2 7 of 26 7 UFOV250A/260A REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE 02 OF 04 SPECIFICATIONS
INPU T POWER: Vo lt age 1 20 , 208 ,2 40 , 41 6 ,480 o r 6 00 F req u ency Mode l U FOV 250 , 50 Hertz Model U F O V 260 , 60 H e rtz P hase S i ngle 1 00-. =I--!IO'I UNDERFREQUENCY
OPERA TI ONAL T HR E SHO L D: 4 to 7 Hz b e l ow nominal. -w. UNDERFREQUENCY
OPERATIONAL
PARAMETERS
: S e e Figure 2. OVERVOLTAG
E ADJUST LIM I TS: 125-150% of nom i na l. C I RCU I T BREAKER CONTACT RATING: P/N 05390 -50 amp@ 480 V AC P/N 05391 -50 a mp@ 250 V AC A M BIENT OPERATING
TEMP E RA T UR E: -40&deg;C to+ 70&deg;C (-40&deg;F to +15 8&deg;F). SHOCK: 15 Gs i n any p l a n e. D I MENSIONS: See Figu r es 3 an d 4. FINIS H: D ark b r o w n , lusterless. textu r ed , ba k ed e n a m e l. WEIG HT: 10 pounds net; 12 pounds sh i pp i ng. -i !L 10'. Mt. &sect;----r-+-' lO ClM**.:ci>
*111 0.ocr 110111 If the generator
I s operated at l ess than rated speed. reg ul ator output current to the e x cite r fi e l d i s reduced and generator
output voltage i s pro p ort i onate l y d ec r eased. The graph i nd i cates t he p ercentage
of genera t or out put voltage that will be obta i ned for a specific reduction
i n frequency. As an examp l e. if a 60 Hz genera t or i s ope r a ti ng at 50 Hz , generator
output voltage w i ll be between 82% and 95% of nom i nal. The " spread' i n t h e envelope (shaded a r ea) i s a func ti on o f operat i ona l temperat u re and no rma l t ol e rance 1 n compo n ents. *Data appl ie s t o p art nu m bers 9104100 1 00 (UFOV 260A) and 9105 1 00101 (UFO V 250A). S i m i lar uni ts of
des i gn (Part numbe r s 9040000100
and 90400 00 104) we r e also id entified wi th Model Numbers U F O V2 6 0/250. T hose units have an u nd e rfre q uency ope r ational thresho l d of 1 0 Hz below n om in a l. For f u rt he r i nforma t ion rega r d i ng such un i ts , con t act the factory. Figure 1 -Und erf r eq ue ncy Oper at i o n al Paramet e r s HOW TO ORDER R e f er to t h e following
chart to determ in e your req ui rements. Wh e n u s i ng any o f these And d e s i r in g I n a 60 H e rtz I n a 50 Hertz B asler vo ltag e t h i s protection
power system , power sys t em , r e g ulat o r s OR DER ORD E R SR4A U n de rfre auen c v onlv M o de l U F OV 26 0A orotect iv e m od ule M o de l UFOV 2 5 0A orot ec t i ve modul e SR 8 A Model UFOV 260 A p ro t ective mo d ule M odel UFO V 2 50A pro tect i ve m od u le SR4F AND A N D SR8F U n derf r eq uen cy a nd P/N 0 539 0 c i r c ui t breaker P I N 0 53 90 c ir cu i t b reak er S R32A Ov ervo l ta ge (sin g l e po le) (sin g l e po le) SR3 2H OR OR SR 63 H P/N 0 5391 ci rc u i t br eaker P/N 0 5391 ci rcui t br e a ker SR1 25 H (do ub le pol e)' (d ouble pol e)' *selec t t he d o ub le p ole b r e a ker i f (1) terminal A. on the S R-A r egulator i s uti li zed; or (2) if t erm i nal F O on t he SR-F a n d S R-H regul at or i s utili z ed. 2 
I * .j "' .... ;;;;; EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 128 of 2 6 7 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE D3 OF D4 U FOV25 0 A/260A (\Ml (l et.I --*126 ------<t> -u;oo ------1' MJI. (\401 t 5.100 ----'"1 ('M l) 4.000 oov uoo llMI uu (t) PO. -, U60 (U} C.000 (10 2 1 1&00 (1$6) &#xa9; I <.:* l:J76 AEP-. 0> ;;-H r;*1 e I * OIOO ("I RU. Figure 2 -UFOV 250/260 Outline Drawing / t.tif 1 4 1) M7. -----1.I ZG *-*.31 6 -----(16el (IU) uoo -U&O ----'""1 ('MO) I W.I I (i) 0 r I I I I I U76 (34) 11 11. ' -Lfl.: {'.:j *'t-( l.1 75 IU I 'd 2-c]o.M r p l I '1111. 0600 IUI / 4 1, ma. IO.H -* 0.nl (0) CIA. RU. / \.11'6 !"" (C 1) ' flfU. *. 3 0' -.....__ _ _. l'Tllll' ll llQTATiiD
:10 Figure 3 -Circuit B reaker Outline Drawing All d r a w i n gs and data subject t o change wit h out notice. 3 
I * E C 62 063 2 , At t. 1, Pg. 1 2 9 o f 26 7 U FOV250A/260A REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION: 03 PAGE D4 OF D4 INTERCONNECTION
DIAGRAM II a II ............. , -* D * Figure 4 -Typical I nterco nne ction for U F O V A N D SR 4A/SR8 A Vo ltage Re gu lator *Refer to instruction
manual for proper interconnection
of UFOV 250/260 with SR-F , SR-H , and SR-32A voltage regu l ator. SAMPLE SPECIFICATION
A device is requ i red to protect the power generating
system a gainst underfrequency
and overvoltage
conditions. The unit shall have the capability
o f ing regula t or output when generator
frequency creases 4 to 7 Hertz below nominal. When the frequency returns to its nominal value the regulator
output shall automatically
increase to provide adequate field current for nominal generator
output voltage. The device shall automatically
open a circuit breaker controlling
power input to the voltage regulator
if generator
output voltage exceeds 140% of nominal. The module must be capable of 240 VAC , 60 Hertz tion. Environmentally , t he device shall be capable of satisfactory
operat i on in the temperature
ra n ge of -40&deg;C to+ 70&deg;C (-40&deg;F to +158&deg;F). T he device shall be a Basler Model UFOV260A Underfrequ
e ncy/Overvoltage
Protective
Module w i th P/ N 05390 Circuit Breaker. &sect;Basler Electric R O UTE 143 , BOX 269. H I GHLAND. ILLIN OIS U.S.A. 62249 P.A.E. Les Pins , 673 1 9 Wa sse lonne Cede x FRANCE PHONE 618-654-23 41 FAX 618-654-235 1 PHONE (33-3-88) 8 7-1010 FAX (33-3-88) h ttp://www ba sle r.co m , in fo@basler.com t 
-EC 620632, Att. 1 , Pg. 130 of 26 7 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE E1 OF E4 SR 4A, SR6A , SRBA , SR9A, SR32A Static Voltage Regulators
SR_A voltage regulators
are applicable
to any s i ze or type of alternator
/exciter system. FEATURES * Output voltage ratings of 32 , 63 , and 125 VDC ava i lable. * 1 /2% regulat i on. * Fast regula t or response. * No electrolytic
capacitors. * For use with brush or brushless
rotary exciters o r as a shunt type static exciter. * Ava i lab l e for either 50/60 or 400 Hz operation. * S i ngle or three phase sens i ng available. * Paralleling
provisions. * Adjustable
stability
c i rcu i t. * Ava i lable w i th any of three time constants. * Designed to withstand
severe shock and v i brat i on. * Complete line of accessories
available. * CSA cert i fied. ADDITIONAL
INFORMATION
INSTRUCTION
MANUAL Request Publ i cation 9017700990
(SR4 and 8), 9017700991 (SR6 and 9), 9075000990
(SR32) &sect;.Basler Electric DESCRIPTION
and SPECIFICATIONS
page 2 ACCESSORIES , INTER-CONNECTS and OUTLINE page 3 ORDERING page 4 ROUTE 143 , BOX 269 HIGHLAND, ILLINOIS 62249 , U.S.A. PHONE 618*654-2341 FAX 618-654-2351 SA-2 1-97 
-..., ! E C 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 13 1 of 267 SR_A VOLTAGE REGULATORS
REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE E2 OF E4 DESCRIPTION
As more sophisticated
power consum i ng dev ice s become ava i lable, electrical
energy sources must velop greater and more precise power capabilities
to satisfy their demands. Ideally suited for alternator
systems of larger size and for more precise regulation
requirements.
the Basler SR_A series of regulators
has been proven on all types of power systems t hroughout
the world. Over 25 , 000 SR_As are meeting the requ iments of emergency , " no-break", peaking and ous power systems every day. The Basler SR_A tors are an outstanding
value in performance, reliability , and cost. Basler SR_A regulators
are available
w i th 7 ampere continuous
capability
for 50/60 Hz or 400 Hz generator
appl i cations having either a 63 or 125 volt field , or w i th 20 ampere cont inuous capabil i ty for 50/60 Hz ing systems with 32 VDC fields. Comp l ete ratings , outl i ne dimensions , and typical interconnections
are included in this bulletin. Paralleling
provisions
and three phase sensing are optional and become an integral part of the regulator
when specified
at the time of order placement.
A complete line of accessory
devices complements
the SR_A regulators
for 50/60 Hz installations. Many of these same accessor ie s are available
for 400 Hz machines. A list of accessory devices
for SR_A regulators is i ncluded in this bulletin. SPECIFICATIONS
PARALLEL FIELD MAX. POWER IN PUT (1) OUTPUT RATING SENSING (2) COMPENSATION
RESISTANCE
WEIGHT MODEL Max. 1 M inute M ax. Freq. Cont inu o us M ax. For ci ng Volts VA Burd en Amp s VA M in. M ax. Net Volts Hz VA (3) (Input) Burden Ohms Ohm s Lbs. Vo l ts Amps Vol ts Amps P er ph ase SR4A 120 50/60 840 63 7 90 10 10 5 25 9 400 12.S SR6A 120 400 840 63 7 90 tO NEMA STD. 10 5 25 9 4 00 12.5 SR BA 240 50/60 1 600 1 25 7 1 80 10 1 2 0/208/ 240/416/ 10 5 25 18 400 12.S SR9A 2 4 0 400 1680 125 7 18 0 10 480/600 1 0 5 25 18 400 12.S SR32A 60 50/60 1200 32 20 4 5 28 1 0 5 25 \.6 4 00 \8 NOTES. 1. If correct voltage i s no1 available
to< power i npul , a s.;t abie Power lransf00J1er
must be sele<:ted.
(Seo Power Isolatio n rran*former
BUii etin). 3. Wien regulator
i s operated al less tha n maximum output. power isol ation tt a nsfOffiler
rating can De determ i ned by multiplying
lnpul volU by OC outpul currenl. 2. Sensing voltage may be s i ng le o r t/lfee phase. TABLE 1 REGULATION
ACCURACY: Less than +/-1/2% over full range of alternator
loading. REGULA TOR RESPONSE:
Less than 17 milliseconds. REGULA TOR DRIFT: Less than +/-1/2% pe r 104&deg;F (40&deg;C) ambient tempeture change. REGULA TOR SENSING: Both single and three phase sensing are available (See Table 2). VOLTAGE ADJUST RANGE: M i nimum +/-10% of nominal voltage. FINISH: Dark brown , lusterless , textured , baked enamel. AMBIENT OPERA TING TEMPERATURE
: From -67&deg;F (-55&deg;C) to +158&deg;F (+70&deg;C) without ing. 2 STORAGE TEMPERATURE
RANGE: From -85&deg;F (-65&deg;C) to +212&deg;F (+100&deg;C) with no degradation
of components. PARALLEL COMPENSATION:
5A@25 VA , droop adjustable
to approximately
5%. POWER DISSIPATION:
Less than 60 Watts at continuous
rat i ng , less than 170 Watts in the SR32. SHOCK: Withstands
up to 15 Gs. VIBRATION:
W i thstands up to 5 Gs at 260 Hz. WEIGHT: See Table 1. Sh i pp i ng Lbs. 14 14 14 14 20 
EC 62 0 632 , Att. 1 , P g. 132 of 26 7 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE E3 OF E4 SR_A VOLTAGE R E GULATORS ACCESSORIES
*POWE R I SOLAT ION TRANSFORMERS
*EXCITA T ION SUPPORT SYSTEM (Ser i es Boost Option) * UNDERFREQUENCY/OVERVOL
TAGE PROTECTION
*VAR/POWER
FACTOR CONTROLLER , SCP 250 *CURRENTTRANSFORMERS
* MAN U A L VOLT A GE CONTROL * MOTOR OPERA TED CONTROL D I MENS I O N S l SR4A , 6A T SR32A SR 8A , 9 A A 11.50 13.00 @ B 8.41 8.5 3 c 4.19 7.25 D 10.81 12.31 E 5.00 --m 5.00 F .34 .34 G 1.70 1.77 .265 DIA. MT G. H O L E , * PLA C E S B ------e 1-+-------D
.-------A--------.i
F i g ure 1 -Outline Drawi n g (SR_A Regulat or) SENS IN G VOL T AGE 'NOT I NCLUD E D I N SR32A FI ELD PO W ER AUTO OFF o MAN U AL POWER PARAU.a INP UT COMPENSA TI O N 4 BRUSH TYPE EXC I TE R f i gu re 2 -Typ i c al I nt er conne ction Di a g ra m (Fo r operation
wi th brush-type rotary exciter) SE N SIN G VO LT AGE FIE L D POWER E1 E 2 E 3 H F* *NOT I NCLU D ED I N SR 3 2A PARAU.E1.
C OllPEN S A TlOll NOTE: All d imensi o ns are I n I nche s (m*IW meters). A ll draw i n gs and data sub j ect to change wi l houl not ic e BRU S H Lf SS E XC ITER Fig u r e 3 -Typica l Interco n nection Diag ra m (For operation
wi th brushless
rotary exc i ter) 3 
E C 620632 , At t. 1, Pg. 1 33 o f 26 7 SR_A VO L TAGE REGU LA TORS REPOR T NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION: 03 PAGE E4 OF E 4 SAMPLE SP E CIF I CAT I ON The voltage regu l ator shall be a static type , equipped w i th a si l icon di o de and thyristor (SCR) power stage to control the exc it er fie l d current as required t o mai n tain a constant and stable generator
output vo l tage w i thin +/- %% of nominal for all steady sta t e loads from no load to full load. A 5% variation
in frequency
and the effects of field heat i ng shall not affect the unit's regulation
performance. The regula t or shall have (single) (three) phase sensing with the sensing c i rcuit i solated from the power stage. Stab i l i ty and voltage range adjustments
s h all be mounted on the regula t or circuit board. The voltage reference
shall be obtained from a zener diode of low therma l coefficient
for stability
over a wide operating
temperature
range. leling provis i ons , if necessary , shall be an i ntegral part of the regulator
and shall be isolated from the sens i ng voltage input in such a way as to permit reactive load compensation
by eitherthe
react i ve droop or t he react i ve d i fferential (cross-current)
method. The voltage regulator
shall be a Basler E l ectric Company type SR_A , or approved equa l. HOW T O ORDER Spec i fy mode l and descript i on: Basler Model SR_A-Voltage regulator. The model numbe r of the SR_A regula t or is a comb i nat i on of letters and numbers ind i cating the features which are included in a particular
regulator. The following
style chart represents
the standard product offering. These models are available
w i th a 3-day s t andard lead t i me , subject to total order demand and parts availability . A) &.irtac:e
moUl"lled
.___ _ __.I [K]-l:fil
[fil D [fil 0 D ---,
2)PaJai191
ptOVisions'w'ittl
ed 1 ustable 1bde viMfltHl$10f
16} Selec1at.ll*
3 phase unsing with Facioo COMectOfl
3) Vollago Adiust Rh.ostt.l
supplied sepa r ately ""'i tn fegulatOt
l A) fOf us* on a* bn.lSIMYJ)e
and most brut>Mu exciters on generat0f'$
rated ove.r El fOf
bnJstiess
exciler (pft'natly
oci g..ieretors
r1 t ed 1 SiOkW or Mn) or whh al rotary OKC!terl t$R32A) The follow i ng styles are available on a spec i a l order basis. The lead time is 8 weeks. 4 A) No relay 8) !Mid-up ro la y C)Hotmoti CJll iy aea!ed r eb.y ---i 2) Voll>!l* 1'dj\nt rheoout il\'{9rnalfy
3} Voltage Adju1 1 Rheottat
s eparatety r og<U.lor 4) Vo ttage Adj us t rh lOStat 1n 1ern a1tv lnstah<S Wilh loci<lng shaft l A) F at use on all brush-type
and most bru:shiess
exCi t trS on generators
r a.1od <Wer 1 50kW B) FOf UM as stalk: exciter (SRA. a. and 32) C) For UH wth f0 t&#xa5;Y 8Jl'.C i ter tSR61111d!I)
O J For \I.Se u stoatk excaor (SR6and9) E) F or vu with brushloss
excl 1er (pri m arily on gonet a t ots rar ed 1 SOl<W 0t d.n lil l r otary oxcitclrt
(SR32A) &sect;Basler Electric ROUTE 143 , BOX 269 , H I GHLAND, ILLINOIS U.S.A. 622 4 9 P.A.E. L es Pins , 673 1 9 Wa s selonne C e de x FRA N CE P H ONE 618-654-2341 F AX 618-654-235 1 PHONE (33-3-88) 87-1010 F AX (33-3-88) 87-0808 h tt p://www.b a sl e r.com. info@basle r.com I I i r 
E C 62 063 2 , Att. 1, Pg. 134 of 26 7 From: To: Subject: Date: Attachments:
E!!a....G.i!!s "Anup B e hera" FW: Inquirey from Bussmann website Tuesday , May 09, 2017 7:34: 00 AM Temperature
Perating -Pua! Element.pdf
Temperat u re deratjng -Non dual Element.odf
Same curves as before , with a little more detail for the dual element Ella From: FUSETECH@Eaton.com
[mailto:FUSETECH@Eaton
.com] Sent: Tuesday, May 09, 2017 6:07 AM To: egills@kciconsultants.com
Subject: RE: Inquirey from Bussmann website NON is a non-dual element fuse where as FRN-R is a dual element fuse. Attached is the de rating curves for dual and non-dual element fuse. Regards , Saptarshi
Roy Sr. Applications
Engineer Bussmann Division Eaton 114 Old State Road Ellisville, MO 63021 tel: 636-527-1270 fusetech@eaton.com
www.eaton.com/bussmannserjes
REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 R E VISIO N: 03 I PAGE F1 O F F4 
EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 135 of 267 From: Ella Gills [mailto:egills@kciconsultants.com
] Sent: Monday, May 08, 2017 9:25 PM To: FUSETECH Subject: Inquirey from Bussmann website Can you provide derating curves for Bussmann NON and FRN fuses? Thanks, Ella Bruce-Gills
KCI Engineering
REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION: 03 I PAGE F2 OF F4 
EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 136 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION: 03 I PAGE F3 OF F4
-760F -40&deg;F -4&deg;F 32&deg;F 68&deg;F 104&deg;F 140&deg;F 176&deg;F 212&deg;F (-60&deg;C) (-40&deg;C) (-20&deg;C) {0&deg;C) (20&deg;C) (40&deg;C) {60&deg;C) (B0&deg;C) (100&deg;C) AMBIENT Ambient Affect Chart for Non-Dual-Element
Fuses 
E C 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 1 37 o f 267 4 o I I I &deg;'' drt I._ ** I ...... !\ \ '-' --*--REPORT NO.: REP-4 24-008-RP1 REVIS I ON: 03 I PAGE F 4 OF F4 Tiilq -; -***
-* -, l --**-* jt* -., j* :11:. :i1*1.1j. *111 1,' I 11 '11111 1 ,,,,* .. *. I 11* 1'11 I '. * : . . : . ; .. . * . * . . * * * I . * . , , * 1 : * * tttrl I tj,, I * I , 1 * .: ! i.. 11. I , l 1 * i , I ! . , ,, . 111
*-.... f'.l. .**. ...,..., f-rW*
I j-*m''-H+T-H+l+-H+H+H+
+-H I* ., '1 **1 !' I **1 . * . I** . '.. . . . " ' ,;!. 1111 I 1.1 ,* ! : 11 ; 111 l''I 1' !11 !1" " : '1 1*, II' I I * I I ' I I ' * I I 1 * ; * * * * " * : * I * I ; ! . I I : * * I I I I:: i (r. J P lffffi iT 11 rr >Pi. i1i i[i)n ij 11 ,.;u ,: . 0 Fr?1 11 :1*:i J'. t-r ,\.:t a .Q * t :.: f A : riA.! !J;* i 1
f rit m j+1H ld+r t+'-1 i !i I I. I '!I . I: 11 ! I : i I 1111 I: I " : : I * *1 -* ! I * .. I. I * I I * ! I ! . I : I; 'I 1 1 1 q ! 11 ! .. : : .'I 1 1 ! I ; I : I 1,' I I , I* 1: . . *' I I * ' ,t L*I. *. I m*
--*tr *-*n *-, .. r. . --* **-* -* ....... "". .. . **--* ***1 "' .. .,. I'" ---* .. --.,,.r .,. I ". : :1 11111 ! lli : .1: iii: . . : ll* I ' . I 1 : *1 * : I *1 *::1 .::* :. .w I '.1*,* i:1 II II . : : : : ' I: . . . . . 11* 1: " 1 A .. *1 . , *-. i . *-*-* :---. *---.. . . . . 'I . ' ,* " . ! I. I *-T-ri 1+-ri-'1: ;HTH'
I * ( ! . 'f;' ' . . ' I I l *T! I . . . ' I ; : ' ' : : * I l : I : ' I I' I f I t 1 rr.rW.11t H
:**;* !::
-, I . -* ;-* .* * 1*** .... ,*-*:-i :;-; *:1 i;-; ..
i1r:* :0:1 ;m-,*:
[i'+H+l+l-M++++H+H
__ ++++1++-H++H
-1 11:1_.tf l11 1.: *t '. :** .... -:! *, '1* l 1::*
II f 11* ,.! t 1: l!ji iili 1i . ;1 i1 ,,,, lj' Ii jll1' 1p-LI '!'!II.. . -*--. ! I. ,.: ; :*11 '.11 !ijl *Ill . -* , * I 11 . I if , , 1 1 * I I . 4-j i 11 r -. . . . , 1 , , , , I , * * . , . 1 , , 11 'I *r1* 11'1' "TT 1r1rr ll'i"1iT l'rl 11*1*: . 111111 -. ;-r-* ::,. f!-1*. *1rn-:-:-1** jl* ., ll11 1Tt'l-n;ll-r"i-'1
rt+lti+ 111 t+t+MH+t+++++H-
l f+H+t_++l_+H++H+t+H 11 ,; . I' . I : I. . I I .. 'I I:, ; i I 1' I I i : I I -.... : I !: * ' .1 I ' . I I I I ; 11 I , * ! ; '1 I '1" I .. ; I * I * ' f ,. * ' I * I l I *1 . ' . , I -...._ * 'I 1' ' I I I i I I ' t* " I 11 ! i .Ii ! ; ! ! : 1 J l j I Tl 7111 '.: * 11 i * * '! 1 i: Ii 1: * ! , ! ! * r;e g} : :  ".. ';+f 1 1
11i 11!1;' 1: 1*11;: r: i f: i! 11
*11 111:1'1111r1
*i 1-1'-" , .. * ...: *1 rr .. t *:!11*1 1 *11*11!l1 1: 1:11; 1 11 1 * 1 I ' I " l I I * ' * * --* * . ' ; * t Ii . I \i Pl -,... I I I . * . I I Ii **:I *11
h1 i *1 ,, . "* 11111, ,,. 11 i 11'1 11111 mnn. I '1 ,,.., , *:. ''! I i .  *11* i * 'I '11* . I 11.tt 11 i ! 1I,1 .li .. 1. . I I: _:. . ; _ L .;.. I 1 i!!-I 'J + '. -I. -j . --,, ..:... i l I !i . I : I I LL I l . n T ml rrr. . . . . r.j+ : .,.. . j ir * ! rri 1 * ' I I * . I r ; I i 'I' I ' ! I 1* 1'!11 . ITT l ;-r T 1 I +I it r 11 . ; . . H-t-t-t-1 t-tttt-t+ttt1rtttt1'tt+HH+t+i+t+H . oi 1. . i 11 1 !I' 1 I" .1 ii * 1 1 * ..l : . : I I:;. , 1 r Ja t t ri > ; .. : : : *:. 11 i r , llili.. * * 1 . * 1 1 * I 11 : " 1 . I 1. IJ ! 1 -ill il i ! I! I l, i! ; I: I ; ; 1; 4. '1 '!r;] . " I I., 'I;. 11: I 11 I I ' I , I* I Ill '1 il; . . I* ! t; ! ': Fi l ff M l r-t+H-t+t+++H+T-'++Hf+H
I ' I I I I * I . I 'I (.1 I I . Ji b '-"*" . . I * I : l..!. . I . I . ! I 1 1 1 Tt1' J I *-.* **** ir***; " 11'-* *-;i *** ** * * -:-** 1*rjl
**,: j 111..._* 1 1 *, -1 n+1 H +H++!+H+l+H++m
I*: ii:! "I ,:, * * 2' 1 1 .. ,.-,;,: : * * t:iir iz!1* I** :i! -. .* . 1 ni.1 * (: l lNf IN . I d I IJ 1: 1 1 *: 1; !*1 1 q*: .... z 1: F r *:i .. ---U9 1 ifa! T 1' 1'! ! 1 Jl" 111 1 'it 1111 **1: i 1 11 1 1 1 t i +tt h :; *; '. :: I ( . ( .,ti'. 1 :inij*
"1'! 1;: i *. ," .... ,-r 1i1 1 1 hti !Iii... I * * :-* i 'I '-.: :"' n "": j+-n---il
*H+i+t+++++++H-++H+H
I I 'ii I . 'I I I I' I'. i.O::... . . } _.;. . I 1 Ji ; ,.!. 'i ; . . I 1 i I I: i I 11 I '"' ; 1 I:; I I :r ...... t "Ii 1 1 I I'' *11 -r-li--=-l.&.,I ... --.. ., h'6i r--...... 1 t .1 11 r ri , '.'11 :111 :.:! i11 '!'111111 . 1111 i:11 i1 1.,.1 TH: ,....1ii rtttti iJ TH-tt tt+ffirt+t+l
1I11 . I II I I\ ' t.,. * ' ( t:" I * \ : w L1. '* . " . I I ti .1 I ..... 11 I " * , I I +-'-:-rr **1* .. * ... ,..... ,.. ii-+* * ** *-"!'11: r::* '1t.-*--* -*--r-rr rr:*
....... r1 ,. .....HTiiiii-t11ttttt+tti
'H ii : : ! : ! ; i : . . * .. ,.. +.4 rn &deg; c ( -ti!P q n * I l : : 1 : ; . : , I iii i * * ii , ! I 1 * ' ! : ; , ! 11 11 i : 1 ! * 1 ; : .. '..,: 1 " * ! i I I .. IB 1 Ii11. ii!: i"' :.J*: . i:1: : 11 +-1 1i: o*f 1 , w.: 111M1111 i'l*i: *1li i111. *, ?11 *1:1 .. *u'lli I! i 111 .&#xb5; . , , .'...:l.i. . * 1&deg;. 't' r . * , 1 * * *, 1 I 1 1 * * , * 111 l . 4 1., hl+ \... .1 1 1
.. "' '?!f *("+a-q: 1)i 1 .: 111 1 T!111 !I 1 1!11:: if}"F!ll.
i !1 "-..1! :llf++, l-H+l+H+H-H-!+H+
H+H *f' J 1 T :.-111111 n llJ.c U U Jilli 111 !g i. 11, +ttt+H+ttt+H lttl+H-Hfl 1 i1 , 1!:1 !*:I :11; * ;.*I :*1! 1111: i .. * 1*1' ,. i o' i I! ii I I 1 I!!* 1!:i
ii
l':; :_ !1 ;q 111:_ '.:ii 111111 llli :ii 1!1 il'.l!lil_ !l!I U! I I I If 11 !ITf T. rl* 'I f*ji I' 11T ,,,.-':,,, *11* Ii 1!1' I m1 j I 111! ilt I. '11 ,,., I :r ++,it ,H+t++t+H-H+Hm=Httf:t-1+1=1
* 1:: :. iii 1 1!*. *11:** *1' ***1:!!!,.; 1!*:*!1!: 1 11111 11**:.:1 1* i;j l;l'i11 .'11:1 . !1,; Ii -1 1 1 .. 11 i' ':n' 1111111
:1 ... **;i-;-+H:*l.+ =1* 11 1* ! Ill* rr 1 1 * 1 1* I 11 I 1 1 1 1. ,il* 1:1: :'.:' ! 1 i . I I TI I* Hi1 .. ". I' (( I,. I jl I I fl .. 11 o,:l.I I -I I! I I -Ji.I... i I 1
i'T ...
*-1-..., .... 11' ' __ , '-T--r*-r--:-1 .. 1-** 11n .,,. ..,.. rn *-,,,. j;ll 1-I : ,j!: *1! ljl! :111 ,,.. .;: I*! 11'11 .1,; :,:. ;t i; !:II I I. 'I 11 p" . , 1*11 1'i 1' *'1* .,J 'I I I 1111 I I *:1 i , !1 I *r:i!* .. '*: , .. ;/.:;i i1ti ,1!.
*111: 1 ,1 1 1 1 '*!I'* 
E C 62 0 632 , A tt. 1 , Pg. 1 38 o f 26 7 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION: 03 I 1 Technical
Publication
LOR-1 HIGH SPEED MULTI-CONTACT
LOCK-OUT RELAYS FOR POWER INDUSTRY APP LI CATIONS e ELECTROSWITCH
SWITCHES & RELAYS . UNIT OF ELECTRO SWITCH CORP. 180 King Avenue, Weymouth , Massachusetts
02188 Rlone: 781-3350200
Fax: 781-3.354253
www.dedlUMitdl
.oom 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 139 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION:
03 PAGE G2 OF G14 HIGH SPEED MULTI-CONTACT
LOCK-OUT RELAYS FOR POWER INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS
ELECTROSWITCH
Weymouth, Massachusetts
ABSTRACT The Series 24 Lock-out Relays are high-speed (as low as eight milliseconds)
control relays used primarily
as auxiliary
relays in applications
requiring
many contacts (up to 4 8). The LOR is an electric-trip
and manual-reset
device. The LORJER is an electric-trip
and either manual or electric-reset.
The LORJSR is an electric*
trip and self-reset
device. All units have mechanical
position indicator
target s. Th ey are qualified
to ESC-STD-1000, which includes aging and seismic vibration
requirements
to ANSI/IEEE
323-1984 and ANSI/IEEE-344-1987
for class IE uses in nucl ear power generating
stations.
The testing also satisfies
ANSI/IEEE
CJ?.90-1989 and ANSI/IEEE
C37.98-1987. INTRODUCTION
Lock-out Relays of various types are often used in the electrical
power industry.
These auxiliary
relays are electric-trip, manual or e l ectric-reset
control relays for th e purpose of tripping and locking out circuit breakers or other devices automatically
when a fault or other det ermined condition
exists. Lock-out-relays
are generally
used in conjunction
with protective
relays to prote ct transformers, buses , and rotating machinery
in various electrical
systems. Fig. l. Series 24 LOR Manual-reset
Lock-out Re l ay Initial Release -September
15, 1977 Revised-January 3, 1980 Added LOR/SR -February I, 1983 Revised-March 15 , 19 85 Revised-April 15 , 1987 Revised-June
1, 1991 Revised-February 15 , 1993 Revised-February 10 , 1994 Revised -September
I, 2012 1 Lock-out Relay applications
often require ten or more N.O. and N.C. contacts. The relays can be u se d to change sequences
such as shutting down a faulty pump and then initiating
the action to start-up a standby pump or bypassing
a faulty circuit by opening and closing bre akers. Lock-out-relays
are normally l atched in the RESET position and trip-out to a TRIP position when commanded. There are th en manua l-r eset, electric-reset, and self-reset versions
to get back to the RESET position. Fig. 2. Series 24 LOR/ER Electric-reset
Lock-out Relay and LOR/SR Self-reset
Lock-out Relay High-speed, rugged, multi-contact
units are needed. This paper describes
a family of Lock-out relays with up to 48 co n tacts that operate as quickly as eight milli-seconds
and are seismic shockproof.
BAS I C CIRCUIT OPERATION
The control of the Lock-out Relays for operation
as a rela y requires no special wiring. They only require a N.O. contact (SI) to command the LOR to TRIP and the Electric-reset
LORJER need s an additional
N.0. contact (S2) to initi ate the command for RESET. The choice of SI should tak e in consideration
the burden data of trip coil, LOR/T, since SI will "make"; this current. This circuit is self-interrupting
with the LOR contacts so SI need not be concerned
with the "break" of the TRIP circuit. On the electric-reset
LOR, S2 needs to make only the Kl relay circuit so the burden of the LORJR does not affect S2. Any pilot duty device is acceptable
for both Sl and S2. 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 140 of 267 Manual-reset
LOR Circuit + __________
Q : LOR I CONTROL PKG I I "---------8
S1 COi'c----1
R i I L OR i ! LOR I __ fl _______ J Fig. 3. Manual-reset
LOR Control Circuit Schematic (shown in RESET position)
The standard station control bus voltage is used. The LOR, as shown, is in the RESET position. The LOR/T coil form represents
the linear solenoid that releases the lat ch that locks the LOR in the RESET. The mechanical
design is described
lat er under THE ELECTRO-MECHANICAL
DRIVE. The LOR contacts shown are normally closed in the reset position.
They are w ith in the LOR control package. G and B are tie points to connect the LOR to the control circuit. C and F are internal connection
points shown for info rmation. To command the Lock-out Relay to TRIP, SI is closed. This comp letes a circuit across the LOR trigger solenoid , which operates, causing the device to snap to the TRIP position.
It locks into this position and remains there indefinitely.
When this happens, the LOR contacts open, thereby removing the con trol circuit from the bus. The unit will stay locked-out
in the TRIP position until manually reset. S 1 may be an auxiliary
contact -from a breaker, a protective
relay, or from another auxiliary
device like a relay. The condition
of the Lock-out Relay is visible by the handle location and a mechanical
target within the nameplate (Black for RESET, Orange for TRIP) Electric-reset LOR/ER Circuit
B3 Fig. 4. Electric-reset
LOR/ER Control Circuit Schematic (shown in the RESET position)
2 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008
-RP1 REVISION:
03 PAGE G3 OF G14 The Electric-reset
Lock-out Relay operates from the con trol bus voltage like the manual-reset
version. The LOR/ER, as shown, i s in the RESET POSITION.
The LOR/T coil form is the same linear solenoid that is used in the manual-reset
LOR, and controls the l atch that Jocks the LOR/ER in the RESET position. The LOR/R coil form represents
the rotary solenoid that is used to reset the LOR/ER electrically.
Kl is a relay used to control the rotary solenoid. This enables S2 to be a low level contact. It controls only the Kl relay coil. The Kl contact operates the high current rotary solenoid.
TBl , TB2, and TB3 are terminal block connections, and F and H are LOR tie points -all are for connection
to the control bus. G, B, and TB4 are internal tie points shown for information
only. The command of the LOR/ER to the TRIP position i s the same as with the manual-reset LOR which was previously
described.
When tripped, the NC LOR contact in the LOR/T circuit opens removing LOR/T solenoid from the circuit. When this happens, the LOR NO contact in the Kl relay circuit closes enabling this circuit to be used. To command the LOR/ER to reset , S2 is closed. This comp letes the circuit to the Kl relay and it operates closing contact Kl. This completes
the circuit to the LOR/R rotary so l enoid and it indexes to the RESET position. When this happens , the N.O. LOR contact opens. This opens the circu it on the Kl relay coi l. The Kl relay drops out, opening contact Kl that opens the rotary solenoid LOR/R circuit. At the same time , the N.C. LOR contact , in the linear solenoid LOR/T circ uit , closes , setting up the LOR/ER for the next TRIP command. SI and S2 should be momentary
contacts and should not stay closed. If both contacts are closed at the
a "pumping" action will result with the LOR/ER mdexmg back a nd forth between the RESET and TRIP positions. The handle and targ et indicators
are the same on the standard electric-reset
LOR/ER as th e manual reset LOR. The handle on the high-speed
LOR/ER is not an indicator
and remains in the vertical position and the target must be manually reset (see page 9). Self-reset
LOR/SR Circuits The self-reset
Lock-out Relay operates from th e control bus voltage like the LOR and LOR/ER. The LOR/SR, as shown in Fig. 5 and 6, is in the RESET position.
The LOR/T coil is the same linear solenoid that i s used in all LOR's, and controls the trigger that locks the LOR/SR in the RESET position. The LOR/R is the same rotary solenoid used in the LOR/ER and is used to electrically
reset the LOR/SR. Kl and K2 are two relays with N.O. contacts used in the control circuit. B-A is a N.O. contact and E-F-G is a form "C" co ntact --both in the control circuit. F-G is N.C. in the reset position whi le F-E is N.O. TBl, TB2, TB3, and TB4 are terminal block connec tion points for the user. RI and R2 make up a bridge circuit on 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 141 of 267 both the INSTANTANEOUS
RESET and the TIME DELAY RESET units. In addition, the TIME DELAY RESET version has an additional
IE-IF normally open (NO) contact to isolate the K2 coil plus the time delay circuit, consisting
of RI and C2-C3-C4, which are wired in parallel.
DI protects the ca paci tors from a possible incorrect
polarity hookup. The INSTANTANEOUS
RESET version of the LOR/SR will reset itself within 80 milliseconds
after the fault has cleared itself (SI opens). This circuit is illustrated
in Fig. 5. LOR/SR: C:ONTHL PACOOE SUPPUBI Fig. 5. Instantaneous-reset
circuit for the Self-reset (shown in RESET position)
Lock-out relay The LOR/SR trips in the same manner as the manual-reset
LO R. With SI closed (simulating
*the commanded
or fault condition)
B-A contact closes and E-F contact closes. In this manner E-F and A-B are both connected
to the (+) bus so the Kl coil sees no voltage difference
and cannot operate. Th e refore, the LOR/SR will not reset and may remain in the T RI P position indefinitely
while the RIR2 bridge draws only enough milliamps
to maintain the voltage balance of the bridge and well below the dropout current of any 0.2 amp. target relays that may be part of the circuit. When Sl opens (indicating
the fault or pre-determined
con d ition has cleared), the RlR2 bridge becomes unbalanced
since the E-F contact , although closed , is in the SI conta c t circuit. Kl operates , closing contact Kl and K2 operates, clo s ing con t act K2 and the rotary solenoid LOR/R operates and indexes to the RESET position completing
the cycle. Contacts E-F and A-B then open, dropping out relays Kl and K2 (and their contacts). Contact F-G clo s es, setting up the LOR/SR for the next command. The TIME DELAY SELF-RESET (shown in RESET position)
version of the LOR/SR, illustrated
in Fig. 6, operates in the same manner as the instantaneous
reset version except the R3-Cl-C2-C3-C4
circuit causes a time delay of from 300 to 600 milliseconds
from the time SI opens until the LOR/SR contacts reclose. 3 + LOPJSR COK'mOL PACKAOE SUPPUB1 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION: 03 PAGE G4 OF G14 l Fig.6. Time-delay Self-reset
circuit for the LOR/SR Operating
Voltage The LOR, LOR/ER, and LOR/SR Lock-out Relays are direct current actuated auxiliary
relays. Because they are only actuated for short periods of tim e and are self-interrupting , they may be subjected
to maximum design voltage indefinitely
without exceeding
the 50&deg;C temperature
rise in ambient conditions
as high as 55&deg;C. This is using class 105 insulation
and the applied thermo-couple method of temperature
determination. The Lock-out Relays operate reliably over the full voltage ranges described
in ANSI/IEEE
C37.90-1989, the "Standard
for Relays and Relay System s Associated
with Electric Power Apparatus." These ratings are shown below: COIL A,B c 0, E, G, K F, H TABLE I Coil Operating
Range* ;NOMINAL VOLTAGE. 24VOC 48VOC 125 voe 2so voe ; ' NORMAL . VOLTAGE i:
RANGE ' ( 19.2 to 28 voe 38.4 to 56 voe 100 to 140 voe 200 to 280 voe *From ANSI/IEEE
C 37.90-1989 The trip and reset solenoid coil s provide reliable operation
over a wide RANGE of operating
conditions. Trip coils A, B, C, D, E, and F have substantial
overlapping
voltage ranges enabling some "custom-fitting" depending
on the desired speed versus current burden. Trip coils G and H have controlled
threshold
voltage levels to insure that the unit will not trip at half-voltage. G and H coils are useful where cummulative
stray voltages due to capacitive
and other effects might be impressed
on the LOR coil causing occasional
nuisance trips. The full voltage ranges are shown on Tables II and III. The Threshold
Voltage shown is the minimum level that can produce a TRIP operation. This is not a reliable operation
and this voltage level should not be normally used. The normal operation
should be within the limits of the Operating
Range. The Operating
Range represents
the design limits for reliable operation.
Safety factors are included so operation
can 
EC 62063 2 , Att. 1,. Pg.' 142 of 26 7 occur above and below the indicated
range as previous l y expl a in e d. TABLE II Trip C oil V oltage D ata '.* THRESH O LD'*. . ; , ! . OPER ATIN G* .. COIL; VaLrAGE *;11; .RANo/E .;} .. '
; ... . *(."** ;&#xa5;,.I A 24 VDC 6 VDC 10-4 0 VDC B 24 VDC 9 VDC 18 -5 0 V DC c 48 VDC 12 VDC 24-70 VDC 125VDC 16VDC 30-140 V DC D 120 VAC 20 VAC 30-140 V AC E 125 VDC 23 VDC 45-140 VD C 250 VDC 33 VDC 70-28 0 VDC F 240 VAC 40VAC 60-28 0 VAC G 125 VDC 70VDC 90-1 4 0 VOC H 250 VDC 140 VDC 180-280 VDC K 12s voe 16 VDC . 100-1 s o voe Not e: D coi l has been tested and approved fo r us e@ 120VAC TABLE III Res e t Coil Voltage D a t a *,*I , ,.. . ; j::: . If/ *1 : ,, .*<.;.; it CO I L ' NOM I N A L.;: , * : H ,i: ' * [ ': * :\-* ': . . .. " '.t t ;* * A 24 VDC 19.2 to 28 voe c 48 v o e . 38.4 to 57.6 voe D 12s v oe 10 0 to 140 v o e F 2so voe 200 to 275 voe Coil Burden Data Th e LOR , LOR/ER, and LOR/SR solenoid coil burd e n dat a i s outlined i n Table IV. As pr e viously explained, the control bus n e ed s to be able to supply the burden detai l ed in Table IV but does not n ee d to interrupt
it -the units are self-interrupting. The reset coil i s hard-w ir e d to the c o ntrol bus so the actuating
means (S2 i n Fig. 4) i s not subjected
to the burden (only the Kl coil burden a t les s than 1 ampere) Sl controlling
the trip coil does " make" and c arry the trip c oi l current. 4 ,. ' REPORT N O.: REP-424-00 8-RP1 RE VISION: 03 PAGE GS O F G14 TABLE IV Coil Burden Data i * * TRiP CO I L ,*;; ,,,.,-, R ESET COIL" '.'**: i: :* COIL.* . ' ., : CO IL 'BURDEN * , t t . CIRCUIT CIR C Ul.T * . *!'.;OIL * 'cic *' , ': (amps): * * * ' VOLTS . : ; *@RATED;. DC OHM S', i@RATED O f:!MS .. -(, ' ....... . . * VOL T AGE' @2s 0 c . . . ' . '.' * ', ,: ... A 24 VDC 3.3 7.3 0.7 33.8 B 2 4 VDC 7.7 3.1 ----c 48VDC 13.0 3.7 3.0 15.9 D 125 VDC 27.0 4.6 12.4 1 0.1 E 125 VDC 50.0 2.5 ----F 250VDC 104.0 2.4 80.6 3.1 G 12 5 VDC 27.0 4.6 ----H 250VDC 104.0 2.4 ----K 1 2 s voe 27.0 4.6 ----Trip Coi l Current -Voltage Characteristics
Th e trip coils may be u se d over a wide rang e of voltage lev e ls as pr e viously d e scrib e d. To aid in this selection
Fig. 7 graphs th e volta g e/current ch a racteristics
of the trip coils. These values are the same for the manual-reset
LOR, the el e ctric-reset
LOR/ER , and th e self-reset LOR/SR Lock-out Relays. Fig. 7 is u se d with th e R e sponse Time gr a ph of Fig. 8. T a rget s election d a ta is det a il e d on Table V and VI and Fig. 9 to 12. 12 LJc*: L O R
t 1' . CHJ.\.RACT
E 1 RI. T I CS OF T HE T RI P C OILS \ t o-< I : I e! '. c ; 0 ! '.1 -u ..... 'jq I l .:. 1 1 a t --t+' . I I 1: '-' . I . <> , , ::! , ' t 8. ;p'" l i 85 /1 : 1 I .i /" 4 J : '* j I v c,0'" i.j.,-,cil
0 i 3 ---I 1/ / I:
/ coll: f ., --: 2 V! / -* . ;I / --i I 1 -i ,; I : 20 4> eo 801001:nl 14> 11101m1200
Z2U402CI02ill0
DC 'VOLT AGE AfPLED TO COI L F ig. 7. Trip Solenoid Coi l Burden Data 
l EC 62063 2 , Att. 1, Pg. 143 of 267 TABLEV LOR Trip Coil Selection
for Positive Target Operation
LOR TRIP CO I L A B c D E G H 1 .... :* ., OPERATING
! , , T * * * 1 .I .* * : \ , " i : DC VOLTS -0.,iA.TARqEJ
:: " ; 21\TARGET; 24 A,B,C 48 B, C, D, E 100 D,E,F 125 D, E, F, G D 140 D, E, F D 190 F D 250 F, H D TABLE VI Suggested
minimum DC Voltage required for Positive Target Operation
with Manual Reset LOR. (Actual values may vary). 12 12 42 90 95 24 40 118 80 95 105 75 105 40 150 70 125 90 180 Res p onse Time -Trip So l enoid 90 Fig. 8 shows the hi gh-speed response of the Lock-out Rel a ys. The values given are total response to close N.O. contacts.
The values are for ten deck LOR's and eight deck LOR/ER's and LOR/SR's. There is very little difference
in smaller units. Th e response time of the trip coil of the spe e d electric-reset
Lockout-relays
is the same as the rese t LOR's. Response Time -Reset So l enoid The reset time of the electric-reset (LOR/ER) Lock-out Rel a ys is generally
not an important
applications
consideration
so a graph has not been prepared. The response is approximate
l y fifty milliseconds
at rated voltage for all coils. The reset times of the se lf-r eset LOR /SR is described
on pag e 3. 5 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION: 03 Target s used with Loc k-out Relays All th e Lock-out Relays have a mechanical
target as part of the nameplate
-Black for RESET and Orange for TRIP. This indicates
the condition
of the LOR. The target resets when the LOR resets (with the except ion of the high-speed
trip electric-reset LOR/ER and self-reset
LOR/SR where the memory target is manua ll y reset). The addition of the optional LIGHTED NAMEPLATE
to the LOR provid es local and SCAD A verification
of trip coil integrity.
It also provides local LED indication
of the presence of a continuing
trip signal to the LOR, which alerts the operator not to reset a manual LOR into a fau l t. The lighted nameplate
has two LEDs. The right LED is controlled
by the circuit that detects an Incoming trip signa l to the LOR. If such a signal is present, then the right LED is lit. This is impor t ant since it warns the operator not to a t tempt to reset the LOR with a trip signal present, which can d amage the LOR trip coi l. The left LED is controlled
by the circuit that monitors the LOR trip coil. When the trip coil is intact and the LOR is in the normal RESET position , this LED is lit. The s a me trip coil monitor circui t contro l s the SCADA output of the lighted nameplate.
If the trip coil should open for any reason, then the SCADA output closes. The SCADA output also closes if power to t h e LOR is lost and when the LOR is in the TRIP position. External targets may also be used in conju n ction with the LOR's to show the condition
of th e devices that are being controlled. The most common 0.2A targets operate satisfactorily
with an LOR. The 0.6A targets are also genera ll y satisfactory.
2A targets need spec i a l attention.
Selection
of LOR trip coils are shown in Table V with minimum required DC voltages for position targ et operation
shown on Table VI. 2A targets are generally
slow acting. The response time of the LOR's is genera ll y too fast for them to respond. F rom Tables V and VI , it is seen that only trip coil D will respond and onl y at 118VDC or more. In order to u se 2A targets at lower voltages, suggested
circuits have been developed.
The standard circuit with no additiona l circuitry
is shown on Fig. 9 for comparison.
Figs. 10 to 12 are shown as suggested
solutions.
Table VI shows the minimum vo lta ges to apply with these circuits to get position 2A target operation.
These circuits were developed
using target relays with coi l characteristics
shown on Table VII. TABLE VII ' Target Relay Coil Characteristics
: TESTS BASED
"'.< ; , TARGET c;o 1L CHARACTE.RI ST I CS I . -* :''l 2A:,. I Coil Resistance (ohms) 8.15 0.71 0.1 95 Pull-In Current (amps) 0.1 5 0.45 1.75 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 144 of 267'
+ .----------
LOR! I CONTROL PKG I i _________
_ Target relay co i l ----------, LOR Interrupter
contacts LOR trip coil LOR interrupter
contacts ----------.i
Fig. 9 typical LOR trip circuit with target relay coil in series with LOR coil
+ Fig. 10 LOR trip circuit with resistor (Rp) in Parallel with LOR trip coil (not supplied with LOR -see Table VI for recommended
Values)
+ LOR interrupter
contact LOR interrupter
contact Target relay coil C1 Fig. 11. LOR trip circuit with RC network --is momentarily
connected
with LOR coil increasing
current in 2A target. Cl discharges
through RI when. LOR is reset. See Table VI for recommended
values of Cl. . Requires special LOR. Contact Factory.
+ Target relay coil Rs LOR interrupter
contacts L OR trip coll LOR interrupter
contacts Fig. 12. LOR trip circuit with series resistor (Rs) chosen to reduce trip coil wattage. Value-chosen
to obtain 5 amperes for 5 milliseconds
or longer through target relay coil. See Table VI for reconunended
values. 6 Transient
Protection
REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REV I SION: 03 The LOR , LOR/ER, and LOR/SR Lock-out Relays are designed and tested to operate reliably in a normal power industry environment.
This includes being subjected
to transients
on the control bus up to 5kV. Since the LOR is normally isolated from the Bus, it will experience
transients
only if they occur in the operating
mode. This precludes
the possibility
of a detrimental, accumulating
effect over the life of the unit. As such, no transient
prote&#xa2;tion
is needed. Because of the nature of the operation
of the solenoid coils, the LOR does generate transients
that may be of interest to the user. These transients
are less than 2kV and generally
in the 1.5kV to 1.8kV range. In systems consisting
of components
that meet IEEE Std. C37.90.l these transients
will not cause any issues. BASIC RELAY CONTACTS The LOR , LOR/ER , and LOR/SR Lock-out Relay contacts operate on the original, reliable principle
of knife switches --double sided , double-wiping, spring wiper blades closing on both sides of a terminal.
To provide a closed contact, two tenninals
are bridged or shunted. Fig. 13 shows this contacting
arrangement.
Fig. 13. Double-sided, double-wiping
knife-type
Contact configuration.
Contact Materials
The wiper blades are made from a phosphor-bronze
alloy that combines superior spring qualities
with good electrical
conductivity. This material and blade design has been proven by extensive
laboratory
testing as well as more than thirty years of field u.se and experience.
Initially
used in rugged naval ship applications , it is also used in industrial
applications
such as railroad locomotives
and earth moving equipment.
It has been used for more than forty years . in power industry applications, as well. The blade assembly is shockproof
and virtually
bounce-proof
This makes it ideal for high-speed , make, quick-break
devices like the LOR, LOR/ER, and LOR/SR. j 
EC 62063 2 , Att. 1, Pg. 145 of 267 The blades are formed, assembled, and riveted nearly closed. The gap is machine adjusted to provide a uniform high pressure.
The gap does not change with time and use. Normal use tends to improve the contact surfaces due to the rubbing action. This provides a burnishing
as well as cle a ning action. The contact surface conductivity
is enhanced by a silver overlay stripe that la sts the life of the unit. This ensures a good contact , even in those cases where the LOR , LOR/ER , and LOR/SR are not operated for long periods of tim e. The terminals
are made of electrically
and mentally compatible
copper material with a silver overlay stri pe at the contact area plus an overall silver pla t e to ensure a good, durable contact surface for customer wir i ng purposes. Similarly, the terminal screws are mad e from s ilver-plated
brass. Number of Decks Available
Table VIII shows the maximum number of decks and contacts avai l able for reliable operation: TABLE VIII MAXIMUM DECKS AVAILABLE
*' " ! MAXIMUM .LOR TYPE i ; : : it ' 1 ' 'DECKs *::-1 CONTACTS LOR 12 48 LOR/ER HI SPEED TR I P 10 40 LOR/ER STD SPEED TRIP 8 32 LOR/SR INST ANT RESET 8 32 LOR/SR TIME DELAY RESET 7 28 Contact Deck Arrangement
** The blade and terminal configuration
enables th e use of multi-contacts
in the same deck , and simple stacking procedures
enable the fabrication
of many independent
contacts in one relay. Specifically, two NO contacts and two NC contacts are provided in each deck, and up to twelve decks can be stacked , resulting
in a rela y with up to 48 contacts (24 N.O. and 24 N.C.). The deck arrangement
is illustrated
in Fig. 14. The contacts operate reliably, using every contact and terminal illustrated. For good practice, however, it is suggested
that polari zed voltages having opposite polarity sho u ld not be used on adjacent contacts.
This is because of t h e remote possibility
of flasho.ver
during transition
between adjacent contacts ** especially
at the higher DC ratings, or in highly inductive
circuits.
7 REPORT NO.: R I EP-424-008-RP1 . , REVIS ION: 03 I PAGE GB OF G14 Fig. 14. Basic LOR Deck Layout The illustration
of Fig. 14 is for tl;ie first deck. For deck units the second digit of the terminal number is the same as shown but the first digit changes to denote the deck number. As an example, terminal 82 is in the eighth deck , directly under terminal 12 and used together with terminal 88. Contact Charts The previous illustration
shows how the LOR's are constructed
and is shown as information
for the user. Traditional
contact charts are normally used , as shown on Fig. 15. ! POS. "' tu CONTACTS c.. (/) 0 a:: w I-a:: 1101Hl--013
x 11201Hl--018
x 1501Hl--017
x 1 601 H 1--0 1 4 x 2101H1--0
23 x 2 2201 H 1--0 28 x 2501 H l--0 27 x -..._ 2601 H l--0 24 x
x Fig. 15. LOR , LOR/ER, and LOR/SR Lock-out relay Chart Contact Ratings The LOR , LOR/ER, and LOR/SR Lock-out relays have been tested to many different
circuit conditions.
The in terrupt in g ratings are based on 10,000 operations
of life, using suddenly applied and removed rated voltage, with no extensive
burning of contacts. Inductive
ratings are based on tests and u sing standard inductance
L/R=0.04 for DC and cos6=0.4 for AC. Short-time
and cpntinuous
ratings are based on temperature
rise in contact members and supporting
parts not exceeding
so 0 c above ambient. 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 146 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION: 03 I PAGE G9 OF G14 24-------------
i--------1__,.
1----------
,----,__,, ....... __ .._,__24 2:3 22 !o 21 I o Q *N ,_ :20 c i s 1 1 9 .o 'LI.I i CI> * 17 1 6 15 1 4 113 1 2 l o 11 1* 110 0 0 LI.I 9 (:I) I :::; : I : 9 I I -l I -f I i i i I I I I : I I I I i I ! I I I I, I ! I I I '1\ I I I I i I I I l 1\ '\I I I ' '1* '.._ i '
: .., I 1 *.. ri.. '-f 1! ....,__.,._
__ ......,,....__
C:O JL I ll --+-1 1
I 'I\.. ,... 1 1 i -..--*"-' L0 1 RISR 1 1' I"\ "&deg;' l)f..._ """' -1 ! I'"-.. I. !COIL f" 14 1--t--+-' "--11--..,....-f"-
COIL C. .1\.
i E . , ' r-IL OR/!rn -COl l L A I LOR/ER '\ \ c O t l L 0 [ 1 1 lO R/SR -----LO R/ER------,-LOR/SR I'\* lOFVER ' -13 I LOR/SR \ I .,,,..,,........., __ LO R/SR ir.-' ___ I I I : ... I \ COi l.i< *"\_ 12
I I ., i \I I I"" -11 1:1: 1 I ' I I \ '\I I I : FQl i l H +---++-" ...,* l t---fi---il---1"+-
11 .....,,...\-+t-
.... \'H----+---+-
u o R .,, ! 1 0 l,
..... -* t-=t--t-c 0 I L ""'. [ LO A: ' -I 1 t \ I \_' * _ \ \ 10 20 3(J "'&deg; Ci() >COIL F -lOR . w "'&deg; 00 80 100 12'0 3 "'&deg; 160 1:130 200 720 24(1; :200 300 OCVOLTS Fig. 8. LOR/ER and LOR/SR Lock-out Relay response times (l 0 deck LO R , 8 deck LOR/ER or LOR/SR For LOR/ER ot LOR'SR's, use LOR response tim es. .j I 7 7 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 147 of 267 Allowable
Variation
From Rated Voltage The relay contacts are not sensitive
to normal variations
in voltage. The interrupting
capaci ty is important
as indicated
in Table IX. Variations
of plus and minus twenty percent in rated voltage need not be considered
as long as the interrupting
current is not exceeded.
TABLE IX Contact Ratings for Series 24 LOR, LOR/ER, and LOR/SR Lock-out Relays
d Ho' *R i T; i i i ,, ' CONTACT .l * :**r: *\"I; '. ', '': 'COr-!TINUOUS
* CI R CUIT .r INQUCTIVE;*f:!
.. ; ' * . I . .* . " 1 R/\TING*' *'--! " .. ' VOLTS SINGLE; *. * I S 0 INGLE' '.*:i\! ! ' .. *: ' !/, 3 (amps)' t coNTAcr : c6NrAcT *r t ; M ! . . : 125 voe 3 1 60 30 250 voe 2 1/2 60 30 120 VAC 20 15 60 30 240 VAC 15 5 60 30 480VAC 10 5 60 30 600 VAC 6 5 60 30 *The making ability for 125VDC circuit breaker coils is 95A-125VDC , Short-time
is for 1 minute. THE ELECTROMECHANICAL
DRIVE The switch portion of the Lock-out Relay is the field pro v en Series 24 Instrum e nt and Control Switch. In this application, it is a two-position
device -TRIP and RESET. There is a powerful coil spring mechanism
to drive it from the RESET* position to the TRIP position. The device is held in the RESET position by a latch and locking mechanism.
This is released by a small linear solenoid for electric tripping. The LOR is manually reset by rotating the handle against the coil springs. The LOR/ER is eit h er manua ll y reset or electrically
reset utilizing
a separate rotary solenoid mechanism.
The LOR/SR is self-resetting
when the tripping condition
has bee n removed. These mechanisms
are described
below. The TRIP Mechanism (Patent #3649793)
Industry requirements
for Lock-out Relays include: *high-speed
*seismic shock-proof
*multiple
contacts To get the multi-contact feature and maintain positive and rugged action, heavy spring action is required.
This requires a locking mechanism
to hold back a spring wind-up of forty-inch
pounds of torque. To get high-speed
release , a solenoid is needed. Ordinarily, a large solenoid is required to do this. Large solenoids
are inherently
slow so a small linear sole n oid is used to release the latch. By nature, small linear solenoids
do not deve l op much force, so a mechanical
adv a ntage is needed. 8 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 The trigger mechanism
was invented to provide the mechanical
advantage.
One pound of force from the linear solenoid releases the latch that locks the device against forty inch pounds of torque. The trigger' uses the principle
of coincident
radii of two rollers -one cannot roll without the other. The two rollers are shown in Fig. 16. large roller segment of large roller Fig. 16. Relationship
of two rollers with coincident
radii The relationship
of roller sizes is to get the mechanical
advantage
needed. Since only a small part of the larger roller is needed, a segment was cut out to reduce si z e and inertia. Fig. 17 shows the small roller,
roller segment, and their relationships
with the linear solenoid and the relay operating
shaft. As shown, the trip mechanism
is in the RESET position. This was done by rotating the handle and relay shaft (1) clockwise
against the relay shaft stop pin (2). When the roller ann (3) and the small ro ll er ( 4) clear the large roller segment (5), the retaining
spring (6) positions
the large segment (5) against the stop pin (7). The handle and shaft (1) is now_ released, allowing the roller arm (3) to spring return
until the small roller (4) comes to rest on the farge roller segment (5) When the two rollers contact , the mechanical
force generated
acts along coinc i dent radii (c ommon centerline). Neither roller can rotate; the LOR is locked and reset. Fig. 17. LOR TRIP Mechanism 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 148 of 26 7 To initiate a TRlP action the linear solenoid (8) is actuated.
The solenoid push rod (9) provides a one pound release force to the large roller segment (5) moving it by the release distance (IO). When this happens , the roller arm (3) i s free to rotate counterdockwise
to the TRIP position where an internal stop mechanism
stops the rotation.
The RESET Mechanism
The manual reset LOR is reset by manually turning the relay handle clockwise
to the RESET position where it locks in. The electric-reset
LOR/ER is either manually reset the same way or . electrically
reset using the solenoid circuit previously
described.
The LOR/SR resets with a solenoid circuit similar to the LOR/ER. The HIGH-SPEED
-TRlP Electric-reset
Mechanism
The high-speed
TRIP electric-reset
or self-reset out Relay has two features used to accomplish
a reliable tripping action in less than eight milliseconds:
I. The rotary solenoid is disengaged
from the relay shaft after it is used to e lectrically
reset the device. This reduces the drag on the relay shaft enabling the speed TRIP. The handle always resets in the vertica l position. Therefore , it is not used as a position indicator.
It is used only to reset the LOR/ER or LOR/SR manually. The Target is the position indication. 2. The mechanical
target indexes to TRIP (Orange) when the LOR/ER or LOR/SR trips but does not r eset (to Black) when the LOR.ER or LOR/SR is electr ically reset. The target is reset manually with a lever on the face of the nameplate.
This enables a station operator to observe and record the fact that the LOR/ER or LOR/SR did TRlP -a much less expensive
method than u sing recorders. VERlFICATION
TESTING The Series 24 LOR, LOR/ER, and LOR/SR out Relays have been tested to many different
service conditions
to insur e that they will operate satisfactorily
as general devices --special use. For power industry applications
the testing is performed
in accordance
with the following
standards:
ANSI/IEEE-323-1984
Oualifving
Clas s IE Equipment (or Nuclear Power G e nerating Stations ANSI/IEEE-344-1987 Recommended
Practices
for Seismic Qualification
of Class IE Equipment
for Nuclear Pow er Generating
Stations ANSI/IEEE
C37.90-1989 Relays and Relay $vstems Asso ci ated with Electric Power Aoparotus
ANSI/IEEE
C37 .98-1987 S e ismic Testing o(R e lays 9 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION: 03 PAGE G11 OF G14 The testing is p erformed in accordance
with ESC-STD-1000 -General Specific atio ns for Rotary Sw_itches and Auxiliary
Relays for Utility Applications
including
IE Equipment
Requirements
for Nuclear Power Generating
Stations.
The tests include ratings eva l uation tests, aging tests to simulate forty years operat i ng life , and seismic tests. Aging Test s Aging tests are run in accordance
with ANSI/IEEE
323-1984 and ESC-STD-1000
and cons is t of the following (run in sequence): I. Visual and mechanical
examination
2. Circuit configuration
3. Dielectric
Withstanding
Vo 1 tage-2200VRMS
4. Insulation
resistance
-100 megohms minimum at 500 VDC 5. Contact resistance
-10 milliohms
maximum at rated current 6. Radiation
aging-10 megarads (10 7) 7. Elevated temperature
-120 hours at 80&deg;C 8. Elevated humidity -96 hours at 95% RH 9. Temperature
rise (contacts)-
50&deg;C maximum 10. Aging -10,000 cycles at 20A-120VAC
and 3A-125VDC (both resistive)
11. Seismic vibration
-ZP A= Sg 12. After test measurements (in order)-items 3,4,5,9,2,1
Details on the background
of these te sts, plus the methods and procedures
are outlined in ESC-STD-1000.
Seismic Tests The Series 24 LOR, LOR/ER, and L OR/SR Lock-out Relays are subjected
to frag ility testing in a seismic environment
after aging to an accelerated
life estimated
to be forty years. This sequence is outlined under Aging Tests. The seismic tests are in accordance
with ANSI/IEEE
344-1987 and ANSI/IEEE
C37.98-1987.
The tests are performed
in accordance
with ESC-STD-1000. Broadband
repeatable
multi-frequency
input motions are us ed. The Fragility
Resp onse Spectrum (FRS) envelopes
the Standard Response Spectrum (SRS) shown i n Fig. 18, using a biaxial input motion. The "g" rating of the Lock-out Relays are d e fin ed as the ZP A (zero period acceleration).
The "g" rating, then , is Sg. The Series 24 LOR and LOR/ER are tested in the normal RESET position, the TRlP position, and during transition
from RESET to TRlP. The LOR/SR is tested in th e RESET position. 
EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 149 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION:
03 I 2 I ' ' n I .......__1-.---;i_........
4 M z ._i -ll l'--A-&.4.-
16 Hz +'-ii 12.5 -I .'-. l: i : 1: tti ,
0 -+-+-4-1
ZP A-5 g -1--IL-: r-. H 1 4 1---1---J* -+--1--1--
i -j-.j-.,+l-1-1+---J ,_I -i--33Hz ! i I 3 -4--i , l..JI., +11-1---1 ,!--l--r--r---r--r-++-H-r--+--li-
1 -t+-l , HHH-IH 1 H I ' ! I I i I I I ' I I I , -i -I ! 1
at 5qr, Damping Fig. 18. Multi-frequency
Broadband
Standard Respon s e Spectrum (SRS) ! ;! 10 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 150 of 26 7 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVIS I ON: 03 HOW TO ORDER LOCK-OUT RELAYS 1. Select desired trip-coil
from data on pages 4 and 6. 2. Select reset coil voltage from chart below. 3. Choose appropriate
catalog number below. PAGE 4 .i , , 4. Units are supplied with engraved nameplate (code l 7C-2L22) unless otherwise
specified.
5. For other than standard relays shown below (or for your own documentation
purpo ses) complete DESIGN GUIDE (shown on pages 12, 13, 14). MANUAL-RESET
LOR EC. K*s. -'i' . * ., .* . *. > '*1'** :*1 ! .. '. ;. 'piTALOG NUMBERS w. lt.h TR.I P COILS D * *
.. ** ***1t**** ""' ** * '**!. ... : 1t  "*/co1L:C: ' ti <: con: o ;,; ;'COILE
.. COILG f' ;** * (COILH) DECKS 3 5 8 3 5 8 3 5 8 3 5 8 3 ' 7803A 78036 7803C 78030 7803E 7803F 7803G 7803H 7805H 7808H 7810H 7803K 7805K 7808K 7810K 5 8 10 7805A 7808A 7810A 78056 7808B 78106 7805C 7808C 7810C 78050 78080 78100 7805E 7808E 7810E 7805F 780BF 7810F 7805G 7808G 7810G STANDARD TRIP ELECTRIC-RESET
LOR/ER RESET COIL r m:> '
! ': ' ..** fj , *t ! I -.ylth TR I P. ') li , O lJ AGE'. .. , C\)ILC) f:Ol , LP'. , c_qlLE. COILF;. CO)LG 24VDC ' 24 voe 24 voe 48 voe 48VDC 48VDC 125 voe 125 voe 125 voe 250 VOC 250VOC 250VOC 7823AA : 7823BA 7825AA 78 28AA 7823AC 7825AC 7828AC 7823AD 7825AD 7828AO 7823AF 7825AF 7828AF 78256 A 78286A 78236C 78256 C 78286C 782360 782560 782860 78236F
78256F 78286F 7823CA 7823DA 7825CA 7828CA 7823CC 7825CC 7828CC 7823CO 7825CO 7828CO 7823CF 7825CF 7828CF 78250A 7828DA 7823DC 7825DC 7828DC 782300 782500 782800 78230F 7825DF 78280F 7823EA 7823FA 7825EA 7828EA 7823EC 7825EC 7828EC 7823ED
7825ED 7828ED 7823EF 7825EF -::* 7828EF 7825FA 7828FA 7823FC 7825FC 7828FC 7823FD 7825FO 782 8FO 7823FF 7825FF ,, :-*<f.' 7828FF 7823GD 7825GO 7828GD HIGH-SPEED
TRIP,ELECTRIC-RESET
LOR/ER *' ; ; l . NUMBERS with TRIP CO I LS DECKS** .: RESET. COIL* : t 1 : .'. t" f'. l' 5 ' *.. '*.. ' . .. t ('' **: voLTAGE'" t CO I L D ,, it' .. *COILE * , COIL F
... *, .*** .. . . 3 125 voe 783300 7833ED 7833FD 5 125 voe 783500 7835ED 7835FD 8 125 voe 783800 7838ED 7838FD 10 125 voe 784000 7840ED 7840FD 3 . 250 voe 78330F 7833EF 7833FF 5 250VOC 78350F 7835EF 7835FF 8 250 voe 78380F 7838EF 7838FF 10 250 voe 78400F 784DEF 7840FF : '' ' 'i :. ' : ' . 'co11:: H--t.J l'j c: o.1i:K*'**. .... 1.H: .. --i 7823KA 7823HF
7825HF 7828 H F 7825KA 7828KA 7823KC 7825KC 7828KC ' 7823KD 7825KD j 7828KD 7823KF 7825KF 7828KF STANDARD TRIP, INSTANT-RESET, SELF-RESET
LOR/SR STANDARD TRIP, TIME-DELAY
RESET,SELF-RESET
LOR/SR DECKS RESET.COIL cATAl.oG
w1tti VOLTAGE. " ' COIL q i; COil E;t)/!'ci'oiL F 1 ';;'.CO I L G okcK t RESET COIL ; CATALOG
11 th : rn 1_P f OILS . ' . VOLTAGE ; COI L D
E '** i
3 125 VDC 784300 . 7843ED. 7843FD 7843GD 3 125 voe 785300 7 853 ED 7853FO 7853GO 5 125 voe . 784500 7845ED 7845FD 7845GO 5 125 voe 785500 7855ED 7855FD 7855GO 8 12s voe 784800 7848ED 7848FD 7848GO 7 125 voe 785700 7857EO 7857FD 7827GO HIGH-SPEED
TRIP, INSTANT RESET.SELF-RESET
LOR/SR HIGH-SPEED
TRIP, TIME-DELAY
RESET, SELF-RESET
LOR/SR DECKS.
;t CATA L<;l\J NUM6.ERS with TRIP CO I LS : ; *I , **: ; . * , * , ._ . ; I *.COIL ll cd1L i o !" * ,,
E. * '* F t l VOL . . . . ( . -' , . . RESEI CATALOG TR I P cold ' dECKS COIL' . :i;*1'.*it* . 1:! ' ' VOLTAGE co1L o ,, '.' * coii. f : ' 3 12s voe 786300 7863EO 7863FD 3 12s voe 787300 7873ED 7873FD 5 125 voe 786500 7865EO 7865 FD 5 125 voe 787500 7875ED 7875FO 8 125 voe 786800 7868ED 7868FO 7 125 voe 787700 7877ED 7877FO 11 
E C 620632 , At t. 1 , Pg. 151 of 26 7 REPORT NO.: REP-424-0 0 8-RP1 . REVISION:
0 3 I ELECTROSW,TCH
Check out these other Gr e at Products from the Ele c troswitch
Family! : I ' 
EC 62 0 632, A tt. 1 , Pg. 1 52 o f 26 7 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION: 03 PAGE H 1 OF H2 WRIGHT System 1000 Revision 17.0.d Arrhenius
File Report Arrhenius
Material File Item Descript i on: No De sc r i pt i on Provided Material N u mber: Commercia l Name: 338 BELDSOL Gener i c Name: Manufacture
r: POLYURETHANE
WITH POL YAMIDE BELDEN Material Classificat
i on: Failure Parameter: Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
CABLE/WIRE
INSULATION
DIELECTRIC
STRENGTH 1.3582 15 , 762.64407734 -28.07861890 0.99532304 Material Thic k ness (in.): N I A Item Descrip t i on: No Descr i p ti on Provided Material Numbe r: Commercia l Name: Generic Name: Manufactu r er: Material C l assification
: Failure Parameter: Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercep t: Correlation
Coefficien
t: Material Thickness (in.): 340 BELDURE POLYURETHANE
BELDEN CABLE/WIRE
INSULATION
DIELECTRIC
STRENGTH 1.3588 15 , 769.22349815 -27.29389850
0.99999998 N I A Item Desc ri p ti on: No D e s cri pt i on P r ov i ded Material Number: Commerc i al Name: Generic Name: Manufac t urer: Material C l assification
: Failure Parameter:
Act i vation E nergy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlatio
n Coefficien
t: Material Th i ckness (in.): 06 June 2017 18:30 UTC 551 HUDSOL URETHANE-B I MW-2 POLYURETHANE
HUDSON WIRE CO CABLE/WIRE
INSULA T ION DIELECTRIC
STRENGTH 1.3540 15 , 713.65787916 -27.77730440
0.99213304 N I A Temperature
Rating: 130C Highest Aging Temp.: 200C Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 209-83D Arrhenius
Page Number: 2 Temperature
Rating: 130C Highest Aging Temp.: 200C A r rhenius Lib. Code No.: 327-84C A r rhenius Page Num b e r: 2 T emperature
Ra ti ng: 130C H i ghest Aging Temp.: 200C Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 409-85C Arrhenius
Page Numbe r: 2 Page 1of2 
I EC 620632, Att. 1 , Pg. 153 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION:
03 I PAGE H2 OF H2 WRIGHT System 1000 Revision 17.0.d Arrhenius
File Report References
Library Code 209-830 ARRHENIUS
PLOTS FOR BELDEN WIRE 327-84C STATISTICAL
DATA BELDEN'S BELDURE 409-85C LIFE CURVES FOR VARIOUS POLYMER COATINGS ON 18 AWG WIRE 06 June 2017 18: 30 UTC Page 2 of 2 
EC 62063 2 , Att. 1, Pg. 154 of REP-424-008
-RP1 REVISION: 03 PAGE 11 OF 139 Ella Gills From: Sent: Ella Gills <egills@kciconsultants
.com> Tuesday, May 09, 2017 1: 56 PM To: 'Anup Behera' Subject: Oh mite Anup, All catalogue/brochure
information
is on the U-dri v e in your personal folder. The part number cross reference
is as follows: OLD NEW 0151 RJISlOO 0601 LlOOJ25R 0605 LlOOJ150 0701 Ll 75J25R 0902 L225J50R 0959 DOOK50R F523 F55J2K5 1 
2 6 7REPORT NO.: R EP-424-008-RP1
CIHMl;E EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 156 of REVISION:
03 PAGE 13 OF 139 Cross Reference
Manufacturing
Company I Old to New Stock Part Numbers e Old No. New No. Old No. New No. Old No. New No. Old No. New No. Old No. New No. Old No. New No. Old No. New No. 1727 B12J350 2302 PFE5KR120
2841 85J6R2 3790 L 12J330 3951 92J750 4126A 91J1K4 442 1 93J900 1728 B12 J 400 2303A PFE5KR140
2842 B5J6R8 3792 L12J390 3952 92J800 4127 91J1K5 4422 93J910 1729 B12J450 2304A PFE5KR160
2843 85J7R5 3794 L12J470 3953 92J82 0 4128 91 J1 K6 4423 93J1KO 1730 B 12J500 2305A PFE5KR180
2844 B5J8R2 3796 L12J560 3954 92J900 4129 91J1K8 4424 93J1K1 1731 B12J600 2306 PFE5KR250
2845 B5J9R1 3798 L12J680 3955 92J910 4130 91J2KO 4425 93J1K2 1732 812J700 2306A PFE5KR220
2846 B5J10R 3800 L12J820 3956 9 2 J1KO 4131 91J2K2 4426 93J1K3 1733 812J750 2308 PFE5KR330
2847 85J11R 3802 L1 2 J1KO 3957 92J1K 1 4132 9 1J 2K4 4426A 93J1K4 1734 812J800 2308A PFE5KR300
2848 85J1 2 R 3804 L12J1K2 3958 92J 1K2 4133 9 1J 2K5 4427 93J1K5 1735 B12J900 2309A PFE5KR370
2849 B5J13R 3806 L1 2J 1K 5 3959 92J1K3 4134 91J 2 K7 4428 93J1K6 '1736 . 812J1KO 23 10 PFE5KR500
2850 B5J15R 3808 L12J1K8 3960 92J 1 K4 4135 91J3KO 4429 93J1K8 1737 B12J1K1 23 11 PFE5KR750
2851 B5J16R 3810 L12J2K2 3961 92J1K5 4190 RES7K5 4430 93J2KO 1738 B12J1K2 2312 PFE5K1ROO
2852 B5J18R 3812 L1 2J2K7 3962 92J1K6 4191 RES10K 4431 93J2K2 1739 B12J1K25 2313 PFE5K1R60
2853 B5J20R 38 14 L1 2J3K3 3963 92J1K8 4192 R ES 1 2K5 4432 93J2K4 1740 B12J1K5 2317 PFE5KR600
2854 B5J22R 3816 L12J 3K9 3964 92J2KO 41 93 RES15K 4433 93J2K5 1741 B1 2J1 K75 23 18 PFE5KR670
2855 B5J24R 3818 L12J4K7 3965 92J2K2 4200 RH S7K5 4434 93J2K7 1742 B12J2KO 2319 PFE5K1R30
2856 B5J27R 3820 L1 2 J 5K6 3966 92J2K4 4201 RHS10K 4435 93J3KO 1743 B12J2K25 2331A PFE5K2R20
2857 B5J30R 3822 L12J6K8 3967 92J2K5 4202 RHS15K 4436 93J3K3 1744 B12J2K5 2332A PFE5K2R80
2858 B5J33R 3824 L12J8K2 3968 92J2K7 4203 RHS20K 4436A 93J3K5 1745 .B12J3KO 2333A PFE5K3R50
2859 B5J36R 3826 L12J10K 3969 92J3KO 4204 RH S25K 4437 93J3K6 1746 B12J3K5 2334A PFE5K4R50
2 860 B 5 J39R 3828 L12J12K 4030 91J1 RO 4210 RJS15K 4438 93J3K9 1747 B12J4KO 2335A PFE5K5R40
2 86 1 B5J43R 3830 L12J15K 4031 91J1R1 4211 RJS20K 4439 93J4KO 1748 B12J4K5 2336A PFE5K6R80
2862 B5J47R 3832 L12J18K 4032 91J1R2 4212 RJS25K 4440 93J4K3 1749 B12J5KO 2337A PFE5K8R50
2863 B5J51R 3834 L 1 2 J 22K 4033 91J1 R 3 4213 RJS30K 4440A 93J4K5 1750 B12J6KO PFR5K1 1R O 2864 B5J5 6 R 3836 L 12J27K 4034 91J1R5 4214 RJS40K 4441 93J4K7 1 752 B12J7K5 2339 PFR5K13RO
2865 B5J62R 3838 L 12J33K 4035 91J1R6 4215 RJSSOK 4442 93J5KO 1753 B12J8KO 2340 PFR5K17RO
2866 B5J68R 3840 L1 2 J 39K 4036 91J1 R8 4330 93 J1R O 4443 93J5K1 1754 B12J8K5 2341 PFR5K 20RO 2867 B5J75R 3842 L12J47K 4037 91J2 RO 4331 93J1R1 4444 93J5K6 1754A B12J9KO 2342 PFR5K25RO
2868 B5J82R 3843 L 12J51K 4038 91J2R2 4332 93J1R2 4445 93J6KO 1755 B12J10K 2501 C300KR10 2869 B5J91R 3860 92J1RO 4039 91J2 R4 4333 93J1 R 3 4446 93J6K2 1756 B12J11K 25 0 2 C300KR12 2870 B5J100 3861 92J1R1 4041 91J2R7 4334 93J1 R 5 4447 93J6K8 1757 B12J12K 2503 C300KR16 2871 B5J110 3862 92J1R2 4042 91J3RO 4335 93J1R6 4448 93J7KO 1758 B12J12K5 2504 C300KR20 2872 B5J120 3863 92J 1R 3 4043 91 J3R3 4336 93J 1R8 4449 93J7K5 1759 B12J13K5 2505 C300KR25 2873 B5J130 3864 92J1R5 4044 91J3 R6 4337 93J2RO 4450 93J8KO 1761 B12J1 5K 2506 C300KR31 2 874 B5J150 3865 92J1R6 4045 91J3R9 4338 93J2R2 4451 93J8K2 1762 B1 2 J16K 2507 C300KR40 2875 B5J160 3866 92J1R8 4046 91J4RO 4339 93J2R4 4452 93J9KO 1763 B12J17K5 25 08 C300KR50 2876 B5J180 3867 92J2RO 4047 91J4R3 4341 93J2R 7 4453 93J9K1 1764 B12J18K 2509 C300KR63 2877 B5J200 3868 92J2R2 4048 91J4R7 4342 93J3RO 4454 93J10K 1765 B12J20K 2510 C300K R8 0 2878 B5J220 3869 92 J 2R4 4049 91J5RO 4343 93J3 R 3 4530 95J1RO 1766 B12J22K5 2511 C300K 1R O 2879 B5J240 3871 92J2R7 4050 9 1J5R1 4344 93J3 R6 4531 95J1A1 1767 B12J2 5K 2512 C300K1R2 2880 B5J270 3872 92J3RO 4051 91J5R6 4345 93J3R9 4532 95J1R2 1768 B12J30K 2513 C300K1R6 2881 B5J300 3873 92J3R3 4053 91J6R2 4346 93J4RO 4533 95J1R3 1769 B12J35K 25 14 C300K2RO 2882 B5J3 30 3874 92J3R6 4054 91J6R8 4347 93J4 R 3 4534 95J1R5 1770 B 12 J40 K 2515 C300K2R5 2883 B5J36 0 3875 92J3R9 4056 91J7R5 4348 93J4 R 7 4535 95J1R6 1771 B1 2 J45 K 2516 C300K3R1 2884 B5J390 3876 92J4RO 4058 91 J8R 2 4349 93J5RO 4536 95J1R8 1772 B1 2 J5 0K 25 17 C300K4RO 2885 B5J430 3877 92J4R3 4060 91J9 R1 4350 93J5 R1 4537 95J2RO 1800A B 20JR50 2518 C300K5RO 2886 B5J470 3878 92J4R7 4061 91 J1 0R 4351 93J5R6 4538 95J242 1802A B20J1RO 25 19 C300K6R3 2887 B5J510 3879 92 J 5RO 4062 91 J11R 4353 93J6R2 4539 95J2R4 180 28 B 20J2RO 2520 C300K8RO 2888 B5J560 3880 92 J 5R1 4063 91J12 R 4354 93J6R8 4541 95J2R7 180 2C B20J3RO 2521 C300K10R 2889 B5J620 3881 92J5R6 4064 91J13R 4356 93J7R5 4542 95J3RO 18020 B20J4RO 2522 C300K 12R 2890 B5J680 3883 92J6R2 4065 91J15R 4358 93J8R2 4543 95J3R3 1803 B20J5RO 2523 C300K16R 2891 B5J750 3884 92J6R8 4066 91J16 R 4360 93J9R1 4544 95J3R6 18 04 B 20J 10R 2524 C300K20R 2892. B5J820 3886 92 J 7R5 4067 91J18R 4361 93J10R 4545 95J3R9 1805 B 20J25R 253 0 C35KR02 2893 B5J910 3888 92J8R2 4 068 91J20R 4362 93J11R 4546 95J4RO 1805A B 20J40R 253 1 C35KR04 2894 B5J1KO 3890 92J9R1 4069 91J22 R 4363 93J12R 4547 95J4R3 1806 B 20J50R 2532 C35KR06 2895 B5J1K1 3891 92J10R 4070 91J24R 4364 93J13 R 4548 95J4R7 1807 B 20J75 R 2533 C35KR08 2896 B5J1K2 3892 92J11R 4071 91J25 R 4365 93J 1 5R 4549 95J5RO 1808 B 20J 100 2534 C35KR10 2897 B5J1K3 3893 92 J1 2R 4072 91 J 27 R 4366 93J 1 6R 4550 95J5R1 1808 A B 20J125 2535 C35KR15 2898 B5J1K5
3894 92J13R 4073 91J30 R 4367 93J18R 4551 95J5R6 1809 B20J150 2536 C35KR20 2899 B5J1K 6 3895 92J15R 4074 91J33 R 4368 93J20R 4553 95J6R2 181 0 B20J200 2537 C35KR25 2900 B5J1K8 3896 92 J1 6R 4074A 91J35R 4369 93J22R 4554 95J6R8 1811 B 20J250 253 8 C35KR30 2901 B5J2KO 3897 92J 18R 4075 91J36 R 4370 93J 2 4R 4556 95J7R5 1812 B20J300 2539 C35KR40 2902 B5J2K2 3898 92J20R 4076 9 1J39R 4371 93J25R 4558 95J8R2 181 3 B 20 J3 50 2540 C35KR50 2903 B 5 J2K4 3899 92J22R 4077 91J4 0R 4372 93J27R 4560 95J9R1 1814 B20J400 2541 C35KR60 2904 B5J2K7 3900 92J24R 4078 91J43R 4373 93J30R 4561 95J10R 1815 B20J500 2542 C35KR80 2905 B5J3KO 3901 92J25R 4079 91 J4 7 R 4374 93J33R 4562 95J11R 1816 B 20J650 2543 C35K1RO 2906 BSJ3K 3 3902 92J27R 4080 91 J 50 R 4374A 93J35R 4563 95J12R 1817 B 20J700 2544 C35K1 R 25 2907 B5J3K6 3903 92J30R 4081 91J5 1R 4375 93J36R 4564 95J13R 1818 B20J750 2601 E300KR10 2908 B5J 3K9 3904 92J33R 4082 91 J 56 R 4376 93J39R 4 565 95J15R 1819 B 20J800 2602 E300KR12 2909 B5J4K3 390 5 92J35R 4084 91J62R 4377 93J40 R 4566 95J16R 1820A B 20 J900 2603 E300KR16 2 91 0 B5J4K7 3906 92J36R 4085 91J68R 4378 93J43R 4567 95J18R 1821 B 20J1KO 26 04 E300KR20 2911 B5J5K1 3907 92J39R 4087 91J75R 4379 93J47R 4568 95J20R 182 2 B 20 J1K2 2605 E 300KR25 2912 B5J 5K6 3908 92J40R 4089 91J82 R 4380 93J50R 4569 95J22R 18 23 B 20J 1K2 5 2606 E300KR31 2913 B5J6K 2 3909 92J43R 4091 91J9 1R 4381 93J51R 4570 95J24R 1824 B 20 J1K5 2607 E300KR40 2914 B5J6K8 3910 92J47R 4092 91J100 4382 93J56R 4571 95J25R 1825 B 20 J1K75 2608 E300KR50 2915 B5J7K5 3911 92J50R 4093 9 1J110 4384 93J62R 4 572 95J27R 1827 B20J2KO 2 609 E300KR63 2916 B5J8K 2 3912 92 J5 1R 4094 91J120 4385 93J68R 4573 95J30R 1828 B20J2K25 2610 E300KR80 2917 B5J9K1 39 13 92J56R 4095 91J130 4387 93J75R 4574 95J33R 1830 B20J2K5 2611 E300K1RO 2918 B5J10K 3915 92J62 R 4096 91J 150 4389 93J82R 4574A 95J35R 1831 B20J2K75 2612 E300K1R2 2919 B5J11K 39 16 92J68R 4097 91 J160 4391 93J91R 4575 95J36R 1832 B20J3KO 2613 E300K1R6 2920 B5J12K 3918 92 J75R 4098 91 J180 4392 93J100 4576 95J39R 1833 B 2 0J3K5 E300K2RO 2921 B5J13K 3920 92J82R 4099. 91J20 0 4393 93J1 1 0 4577 95J40R 1834 B 20J4KO 2 15 E300K2R5 2922 B5J15 K 3922 92 J 9 1R 4100 9 1J 22 0 4394 93J 1 20 4578 95J43R 1835 B 20J4K5 2616 E300K3R1 2923 B5J16 K 3923 92 J1 00 4 1 01 91J240 4395 93J 1 30 4579 95J47R 1836 B2dJ5KO 2617 E300K4RO 2924 B5J18 K 3924 92J110 410 2 91J250 4396 93J150 4580 95J50R 1837 B20J6KO 2618 E300K5RO 2925 B5J 20K 3925 92J120 4103 91J27 0 4397 93J160 4581 95J51R 1838 B20J7KO 2619 E300K6R3 3723 L 12JR51 3926 9 2 J130 4104 91 J 3 00 4398 93J1 80 4582 95J56R 1839 B20J7K 5 2620 E300K8RO 3730 L12J1RO 392 7 92J150 4105 91J33 0 4399 93J200 4584 95J62R 1840 B20J8KO 2621 E300K10R 3734 L12J1R5 3926 92 J 160 4105A 91 J350 4400 93J220 4585 95J68R 1840A B 20J9K O 2622 E300K12R 3738 L1 2 J2R 2 3929 92J180 4106 91 J360 4401 93J240 4587 95J75R 1841 B 20 J10K 2623 E300K16R 3742 L1 2J3R3 3930 92J200 4107 91J390 4402 93J250 4589 95J82R 184 2 B20J12K5 2624 E300K20R 3746 L12J4R7 3931 92J220 4108 91J400 4403 93J270 4591 95J91R 1843 B20J15K 2822 B 5J1RO 3750 L12J6R8 3932 92J240 4109 91J430 4404 93J300 4592 95J100 1844 B20J20K 2823 B5J1R1 3754 L12J10R 3933 92J250 4109A 91J 4 5 0 4405 93J330 4593 95J110 1845 B20J25K 2824 B 5J1R2 3756 L12J12R 3934 92J270 4110 91J47 0 4405A 93J350 4594 95J120 1846 B 20J30K 2825 B5J1R3 3758 L12J15R 3935 92J300 4111 91J500 4406 93J360 4595 95J130 184 7 B 20J35K 2826 B5J1R5 3760 L12J18R 3936 92 J 33 0 4112 91 J5 10 440 7 93J390 4596 95J150 1848 B 20J4 0K 2627. B5J1R6 3762 L 12J22R 3937 92J350 4113 91J56 0 4408 93J400 4597 95J160 1849 B 20J 45K 2628 B 5J1 R8 3764 L12J27R 3938 92J360 4114' 9 1J600 4409 93J430 4598 95J180 1850 B 20 J50K 2829 B 5J2RO 3766 L12J33R 3939 92J390 4115 9 1 J62 0 4409A 93J 4 50 4599 95J200 1851 B 20J55K 2830 B5J2R2 3768 L12J39R 3940 92J400 4116 91J68 0 4410 93J470 4600 95J22 0 1652 B 20J60K 2831 B5J2R4 3770 L12J47R 394 1 92J430 4117 91 J700 4411 93J500 4601 95J240 1853 B 20 J6 5K 2832 B 5J2 R7 3772 L12J56R 3942 92 J4 50 4118 91J75 0 4412 93J510 4602 95J250 1854 B20J70K 2833 B5J3RO 3774 L12J68R 3943 92J470 4119 91 J800 4413 93J560 4603 95J270 1855 B20J75K 2834 B5J3R3 3776 L12J82R 3944 92J500 4120 91J820 4414 93J600 4604 95J 300 1856 B 2 0J80K 2835 BSJ3R6 3778 L12J100 3945 92J510 4121 91J900 4415 93J620 4605 95J330 1657 B 20J85K 2836 B5J3R9 3780 L 1 2J120 3946 92J560 4122 91J910 4416 93J680 4605A 95J350 1858 B 20J90K 2 837 B5J4R3 376 2 L1 2J 150 3947 92J600 4123 91J1KO 4417 93J700 4606 95J360 1859 B 20 J95K 2838 B5J4 R7 3784 L12J180 3948 92J620 4124 91J1K1 4418 93J750 4607 95J390 1860 B 20 J100K 2839' B5J5 R1 3786 L1 2 J220 3949 92J680 4125 91J1K2 4419 93J800 4608 95J400 230.1. PFE 5KR 10 0 . 2840 B5J5R6 3788 L12J270 3950 92J700 4126 91 J1K3 4420 93J820 4609 95J430 80 Ohmite Manufacturing
Company , 3601 Howard St., Skokie, lflinois 60076, Tel. 708/675-2600 , Fax 708/675-1505 
EC 62&deg;063 2' Att. 1, Pg. 157 of 2 6 7REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION: 03 PAGE 14 OF 139 O HMIT E Cross Reference
Manufacturing
Company e Old t o New.Stock Part Numbers Old No. New No. Old No. New No. Old NO. New No. Old No. New No. Old No. N ew No. Old No. New No. 4609A 95J450 4784 90J62R 4921 ACS!KO 5 877 ASJ750 F319 F30J 1 KO L0151 AHL100 4610 95J470 4785 90J68R 4922 AC S 1K 5 5878 RSJ800 F320 F30J1K5 L0152 AHL1 2 5 4611 95J500 4787 90J75R 4923 AC S2K 5 5879 RSJ1KO F3 2 1 F30J 2 KO L0153 AHL175 4612 95J510 . 4789 90J82R 49 2 4 A C S 3K5 5880 ASJ1K2 F32 2 F30J2K 5 L0154 RHL250 4613 95J5gg 4791 90J91A 4925 AC SS KO 5881 RSJ1K3 F323 F30J 3 KO L0155 RHL3 5 0 4614 95J6 4792 90J100 4948 RCL 1 0 A 5882 R 5 J1K8 F324 F30J4KO L0 1 56 RHL500 4615 95J6 0 4793 90J110 4949 RCL 15R 5883 RSJ2KO F325 F30J5KO L0157 RHL750 4616 95J680 4794 90J120 4950 ACL 2 5R 5883A R5J2K2 F326 F30J7K5 L0158 RHL1KO 4617 95J700 4795 90J130 4951 RCL3 5 R 5884 RSJ2K5 F32 7 F3 0 J1 0 K L0159 AHL1K5 4618 95J750 4796 90J150 4952 R C LSO R 5885 RSJ3KO F40 1 F40J1RO L0160 RHL2K5 4619 95J800 4797 90J160 4953 R C L 75A 5885A RSJ3K3 F4 02 F4 0J 1R 5 L0161 RHL3K5 4620 95J820 4798 90J180 4954 R C L!OO 58858 RSJ3K9 F403 F40J 2 R O L0162 RHLSKO 4621 95J900 4799 90J200 4955 RCL1 50 5887 RSJ4K7 F404 F40J3 R O L4190 REL7K5 4622 95J91 0 4800 90J220 4956 RCL200 5888 R5JSKO F405 F40J4RO L419 1 REL10K 4623 95J1KO 4801 90J240 4957 R C L 25 0 5889 RSJ 5 K6 F406 F40J S RO L4192 REL12K5 4624 95J1K1 4802 90J250 4958 R C L 3 5 0 5890 RSJ6K2 F407 F40J7R 5 L4193 REL15K 4625 95J1K2 4803 90J270 4959 RCL 5 00 5891 RSJ7K5 F408 F40J1 0 R L4200 RH L 7K 5 4626 95J1K3 4804 90J300 4960 R C L7 5 0 5892 RSJ8K2 F40 9 F40J 25 R L4201 AH L 10K 4626A 95J1K4 4805 90J330 4961 R C L1K O 5893 R5J9KO F410 F40J40R L4202 AHL15K 4627 95J1K5 4805A 90J350 4962 R CL1K5 5893A RSJ9K1 F411 F4 0JSOR L4203 RHL20K 4628 95J1K6 4806 90J360 4963 RCL2K5 5894 RSJ10K F41 2 F40J75R L4204 RHL25K 4629 95J1K8 4807 90J390 4964 RCL3K5 5895 RSJ12K F413 F40J1 0 0 W0101 REE1RO 4630 95J2KO 4808 90J400 4965 R C LS KO 5896 RSJ15K F414 F40J1 50 W0102 REE2RO 4631 95J2K2 4809 90J43 0 5800 R3J1RO 5897 RSJ20K F415 F40J 200 W0102A REE2R5 4632 95J2K4 4809A 90J450 5801 R3J1R5 F101 F10J1RO F416 F40J2 5 0 W0103 REE3RO 4633 95J2K5 4810 90J470 5802 . R3J2RO F102 F10J2RO F417 F40J400 W01 OJA AEESRO 4634 95J2K7 4811 90JSOO 5803 R3J 2 R4 F103 F10JSRO F418 F40J5 00 W0104 AEE6RO 4635 95J3KO 4812 90J510 5804 A3J3RO F104 F10J7A5 F41 9 F40J75 0 W0105 REE8R O 4636 95J3K3 4813 90J560 5805 R3J3R9 F105 F10J10R F420 F40J1KO W0106 REE10R 4636A 95J3K5 4814 90J600 5806 R3J S R1 F106 F10J15R F4 2 1 F40J1 K 5 W0107 REE15A 4637 95J3K6 4815 90J620 5807 R3J7R 5 F107 F10J20R F42 2 F40J 2 KO W0108 REE25R 4638 95J3K9 4816 90J680 5808 R 3J10R F108 F10J25R F423 F40J2K 5 W0109 REE35R 4639 95J4KO 4817 90J700 5809 R3J1 5 R F 1 09 F10J30R F424 F40J3KO W0110 REESOR 4640 95J4K3 4818 90J750 5810 R3J 2 0R F110 F10J40R F425 F40J4KO W0111 REE7 5R 4640A 95J4K5 4819 90J800 5811 R3J3 0 R F 111 F 1 0JSOR F426 F40JS K O W0112 AEE100 4641 95J4K7 4820 90J820 5812 R3J S OR F112 F 1 0J75R F4 27 F40J7K5 W0113 REE12 5 4642 95JSKO 4821 90J900 5813 R3J5 6 R F113 F10J100 F4 2 8 F40J10K W0113A REE150 4643 95JSK 1 4822 90J910 5814 R3J68A F1 14 F10J125 F429 F40J15K W0114 REE175 4644 95JSK6 4823 90J 1K O 5815 A3J8 2 R F115 F10J150 F430 F40J20K W0114A REE200 4645 95J6KO 4824 90J1K1 5816 R3J1 00 F116 F10J 2 00 F431 F 4 0J 2 5K W0115 REE2 5 0 4646 95J6K2 48 25 90J1K2 5817 R3J1 2 0 F117 F10J 2 50 F501 F55J1RO W0116 REE35 0 4647 95J6K8 4826 90J1K3 58 18 R3J1 5 0 F1 18 F10J300 F502 F55J1R5 W0117 REESOO 4648 95J7KO 4826A 90J1K4 58 19 R3J200 F119 F10J400 F503 F55J2RO W0118 REE750 4649 95J7K5 4827 90J1K5 5820 R 3J250 F120 F10J500 F504 F55J3RO W0119 REE1KO 4650 95J8KO 4828 90J1K6 5821 R3J 2 70 F12 1 F10J600 FSOS F55J4R O W0120 REE1K5 4651 95J8K2 4829 90J1K8 5822 R3J300 F122 F10J 75 0 F506 FSSJSRO W0121 REE2K 5 4652 95J9KO 4830 90J2KO 5823 R3J33 0 F123 F10J1KO F507 F 5 5J7R5 W0122 REE3K5 4653 95J9K1 4831 90J2K2 5824 R3J 390 F124 F10J1K 2 5 F508 F55J10R W0123 REE5KO 4654 95J10K 4832 90J2K4 5825 R3J430 F125 F10J1K 5 F509 F55J25A W4190 REE7K5 4655 95J 11K 4833 90J2K5 5826 R3J 5 00 F126 F10J1 K75 F510 F55J40R W4191 REE10K 4656 95J12K 4834 90J2K7 5827 R 3J560 F127 F10J2KD F 5 11 F55J50R W4192 REE 1 2K 5 4657 95J13K 4835 90J3KO 5828 R3J600 F128 F10J 2 K5 F5 1 2 F5 5J 7 5 R W4193 REE15K 4657A 95J14K 4836 90J3K3 5829 R3J 62 0 F129 F 10J3KO F513 F 55 J10 0 4658
4836A 90J3K5 5830 R3J75 0 F130 F10J4KO F514 FSSJ 150 4659 95J16K 4837 90J3K6 5830A R3J8 2 0 F131 F10JSKO F515 F55J 2 00 46598 95J17K 4838 90J3K9 5831 R3J910 F20 1 F 2 0J1RO F516 F55J 2 50 4660 95J18K 4839 90J4KO 5833 R3J1 KO F202 F 2 0J2RO F517 F5 5J 400 4661 95J20K 4840 90J4K3 5834 A3J1 K2 F203 F 2 0JSRO F518 F5 5J 50 0 4662 95J22K 4840A 90J4K5 5835 R3J1 K 5 F204 F20J10A F519 F 55 J7 50 4663 95J24K 4841 90J4K7 5836 R3J1 K B F205 F 2 0J15R F520 F 55J1KO 4664 95J25K 4842 90J5KO 5837 R3J2KO F206 F20J25R F521 F55J1K 5 4730 90J1 AO 4843 90J5K1 5838 R3J2K4 F207 F 2 0J40R F522 F55J 2 KO 4731 90J1A 1 4844 9 0JSK6 5839 R3J2K 7 F208 F 2 0JSO R F523 FSSJ 2 K 5 4732 90J1R2 4845 90J6KO 5840 R3J 3 K O F209 F20J75R F52 4 F 55 J 3 K O 4733 90J1R3 4846 9 0J6K2 584 1 R 3J3K9 F210 F 2 0J100 F525 F 55 J4KO 4734 90J1R5 4847 90J6K8 5842 R3J 4K7 F211 F 2 0J 1 50 F526 F SSJ S KO 4735 90J1R6 4848 90J7KO 5843 R3J5KO F212 F 2 0J200 F52 7 F55J7K 5 4736 90J1R8 4849 90J7K5 5844 R3JSK6 F2 1 3 F20J250 F528 F55J10K 4737 90J2RO 4850 90J8KO 5845 R3J6K2 F214 F20J300 1'529 F55J15K 4738 90J2R2 4851 90J8K2 5846 R3J6K8 F215 F 2 0J400 FSJO F55J 2 0 K 4739 90J2R4 4852 90J9KO 5847 A3J 7 K5 F216 F 2 0J500 F5 3 1 F55 J 25K 4741 90J2R7 4853 90J9K1 5848 R3J9 KO F217 F 2 0J800 F53 2 FSSJ JO K 4742 90J3RO 4854 90J10K 5849 *R3J10K F218 F 2 0J1KO L010 1 REL1RO 4743 90J3R3 4855 90J11K 5850 RSJ1AO F219 F20J1K25 L0102 REL2RO 4744 90J3R6 4856 90J12K 5850A RSJ1R 5 F220 F 2 0J1K5 L0 1 02A REL2R5 4745 90J3R9 4857 90J13K 5851 RSJ 2 RO F221 F20J2KO L0103 REL3AO 4746 90J4RO 48576 90J14K 5851A RSJ3RO F222 F 2 0J2K5 L0103A AEL5RO 4747 90J4R3 4858 90J15K 58518 R5J 3 R 9 F223 F 2 0J3KO L0104 REL6R O 4748 90J4R7 4859A 90J16K 5852 RSJSRO F224 F20J3K5 L010 5 REL8RO 4749 90J5RO 4859C 90J17K 5852A RSJ5R6 F225 F20J4KO L0106 REL10A 4750 90J5R1 4860 90J18K 5853 RSJ10R F226 F20J5KO L0107 REL15R 4751 90J5R6 4861 90J20K 5854 RSJ1 5 R F227 F20J6KO L0108 AEL25 R 4753 90J6R2 4862 90J22K 5855 RSJ18R F228 F 2 0J7K5 L0 1 09 REL35R 4754 90J6R8 4863 90J24K 5856 R SJ20R F229 F20J10K L0 1 10 REL50R 4756 90J7R5 4864 90J25K 5856A R 5J2 2 R F230 F20J12KS L0111 AEL75R 4758 90J8R2 4865 90J27K 5857 RSJ2 5 A F231 F20J15 K L0112 REL100 4760 90J9R1 4866 90J30K 5858 RSJ30R F232 F20J20K L 0113 AEL125 4761 90J10R 4867 90J33K 5859 RSJ40R F233 F20J25K L 0113A REL150 4762 90J11A 4867A 90J35K 5860 R 5J50R F234 F20J30K L0114 REL 1 75 4763 90J12R 4868 90J36K 5860A RSJ51R F235 F 2 0J35K L0114A REL200 4764 90J13R 4869 90J39K 58608 R SJ56R F236 F20J4 0 K L0115 REL 2 50 4765 90J15R 4870 90J40K 5861 RSJ68R F237 F20J50K L0116 REL350 4766 90J16A 4871 90J43K 5862 ASJ7 5 R F301 F30J1RO L0117 REL500
90J18R 4871A 90J45K 5863 RSJ8 2 R F302 FJOJ1A5 L0118 RE L 750 4768 90J20R 4872 90J47K 5864 RSJ1 00 F303 F30J2RO L0119 AEL1KO 4769 90J22R 4873 90J50K 5865 R5J1 20 F304 F30J3RO L0120 REL1K 5 4770 90J24R 4874 90J51K 5866 RSJ150 F305 F30J5 RO L0121 REL2K-5 4n1 90J25R 4908 RCS10R 5867 RSJ160 F306 F30J10 A L01 22 REL3K5 e 4n2 90J27R 4909 RCS15R 5868 RSJ200 F307 F30J15R L0123 REL 5 KO 4773 90J30R 4910 RCS25R 5869 R5J 22 0 F308 F30J25R L0140 AHL1R O 4n4 90J33R 4911 RCS35R 5870 RSJ25 0 F309 F30J40R L0141 RHL 2 RO 4n4A 90J35R 4912 RCS50R 5870A RSJ27 0 F310 F30J50R L0142 AHL J RO 4775 90J36R 4913 RCS75R 5871 RSJ300 F311 F30J75 A L0143 AHL6RO 4776 90J39R 4914 RCS100 5872 RSJ330 F312 F30J100 L0144 RHLSRO 47n 90J40R 4915 RCS150 5873 RSJ350 F313 F30J150 L0145 AHL10A 4na 90J43R 4916 RCS200 5874 RSJ4 00 F314 F30J200 L0146 RHL15A 4779 90J47R 4917 ACS250 5875 RSJ500 . F315 F30J250 L0147 AH L 25R 4780' 90J50R 4918 RCS350 5875A RSJ510 *F316 F30J400 L0148 RHL 35R 4781 . 90J51 R '4919 RCS500 58756 RSJ 560 F317 F30J500 L0149 AHL50R 4782&deg; 90J56 R 4920 RCS750 5876 R SJ600 F318 * F30J750 L0150 -AHL75R 
. -REPORT * -EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 158 of 26 r* REVISION: 03 8 Selecting
A Rheostat PAGE 15 OF 139 OHMITE. STEP 1 Determine
Resistance
and Watts Ohm's Law (a) R = Ell or I = E/R or E = RI Ohm's Law , shown in formula form above , enables determination
of the resistance
when the required voltage and current are known. When the current and voltage are unknown, or the best values not decided on , at least two of the three terms in Ohm's Law must lie measured in a trial circuit (see Engineering
Manual Bulletin 1100). Note that the maximum current to be determined
is the current of the load before the rheostat resistance
is inserted. On the other hand , the maximum resistance
occurs with the minimum current. (b) W = 12R or W = El or W = E 2/R Power, in watts, can be determined
from the formulas above, which stem from Ohm's Law. Note that the rated wattage of a uniform wound rheostat i s calculated
using the maximum cu rre nt and the total rheostat resistance.
The Summation
Watts are calculated
instead for a taper wound rheostat as explained
under " Tapered Rheostats;* page 14. Short Cut Method Use an Ohm i te Ohm's Law Calculator (convenient
slidechart) or use Ohm's Law Chart in the Engineering
Manual , Bulletin 1100. Set known values as explained
on the Calcu la tor , or Chart, and read the sought for OHMS , WATIS (or other terms). Calculation
Method Using the Ohm's Law formulas g i ven above , and explained
in grea te r deta i l in the Engineering
Manual , calculate
the unknown values. How to conduct tests when a tria l must be made of the actual apparatus
is explained
in the Manual. STEP 2 Power Rating or Physical Size of Rheostat General: Rheostat watt ratings are based on the condition
that the moving contact is set so that all of the winding is in the circuit. This makes the condition
the same as that of a fixed res i stor (assuming
a uniform rheostat wind i ng) and we may then say that a rheostat operated at a constant wattage will attain a steady temperature
which is m i ned largely by the ratio between the size (surface area) and the wattage dissipated.
The temperature
stabilizes
when the sum of the heat loss rates (by radiation , convection and conduction)
equals the heat input rate (proportionage). The greater the rheostat area per watt to be dissipated, the
the heat loss rate and therefore
the lower the temperature
rise. Manufacturing
Company Free Air Watt Rating In general, for commercial
rheostats , the relation of the "Free Air Watt Rating" of vitreous enameled rheostats
to the physical size has been set at such a figure that: " When operated at their rated watts the temperature
rise of the hottest spot shall not
300&deg;C (540&deg;F) as measured by a thermo-couple, when the temperature
of the ing air does not exceed/40&deg;C (104 &deg;F). The temperature
is to be measured at t he hottest point on the embedding
mater ia l of a rheostat mo u nted on a vertical metal panel in free , st i ll air space with at least one foot of clearance
to the nearest object , and with unrestricted
circulation
of air:' This is in accordance
w i th standards
of the "Nati ona l Electrical
Manufactu r ers Association" (NEMA) and the " Underwriters
' Laboratories:
* Electronic
Industries
Associat i on (form erly RETMA) standards
provide for a maximum attained hot spot temperature of 340&deg;C for rheostats
of 100 watts or less and 300&deg;C for rheostats
of greater wattage. The reference
ambient is 25&deg;C. Military Rheostat Spec ific ation MIL-R-22 prov i des for a maximum hot spot temperature
attained (on the exposed winding) of 340&deg;C for rheostats
of 100 watts o r less and 390&deg;C for la rger rheostats. The reference
ambient is 25&deg;C. The temperature
rise , w i th all resistance
in the circuit , is not directly proportional
to the wattage but follows the curves as shown in Fig. 1 and Fig. 2. \ RHEOSTAT L O AO-PEACENT HA T ED WATTS Fig. 1: Hot spot temperature
rise of a rheostat for various specifications. The temperature
rise on a tapered rheostat does not exceed the rated maximum , but the location of the hot spot , for each pos i tion of the contact , depends on the taper design. In the usual rheostat application , the current is reduced as the resistance
is inserted in the c i rcuit and so the operating
temperature
is much less than the maximum rated temperature. If the maximum current is actually carried as a constant value , t he hot spot temperature
builds up as the resistance
is added and levels off at the maximum rated temperature
starting at approximately
30% rotation. 
f EC 62063 2 Att 1 P g 159 f 26'fEPORTNO.: REP-424-008-RP1 ; ' * ' * O REVISION: 03 -\ .... .. I '* Selecting
A Rheostat PAGE 16&deg;F 139 OH MITE ;? i Curren t Rating When selecting
a rheostat for a particular
application, it is the c u rrent rating, rather than the wattage rating , which directly indicates
the usability. For any given wattage size and res i stance, the max i mum current to be carried through any part of a uniform w i nding is determined
from Ohm's Law, l=v'W/R. The current va l ues for all stock rheostat resistances
are given in the stock tables. The minimum current (occurring
at maximum resistance)
is a factor influencing
the rheostat watt size required , as expl a ined under "Taper ed Rheostats'.
' When a rheostat i s connected
as a potent i ometer, i.e., bridge d across the line with the load connected
between one end and the moving contact , the minimum current is the "bleeder" current (through the entire winding). The maximum potent i ometer current is the sum of the bleeder current and the maxi mu m load current. Tapered Windings A "tapered w i nding" consists of two or more smoothly join ed sections wound with larger wire for the higher cu r rent section s. Characteristics
of tapered windings are explained
fully starting on page 14. Application
Modifications
of Power Ratings To allow for the differences
between the actual service conditions
and the " Free Air Watt Rating" i t is sound '\ engine er i ng practice to operate the rheostats
a t modific a-J t i ons of nominal rating. The details by which such ratings can be e stimated are given hereafter.
Most thermal calculations , however, involve so many factors which are usually not accurately
known , that at best they are ' i _/ only ap p roximations. i -CAii' *AG< CUIW[ fCW'UU o T llll( \111.llll l W'Ot:L 1' *l tM a!ZI: 0' JltMCOSTAT
I NTH IS IUNOE. ... t----+---+-----t
----< Fig. 2: Hot Spot temperature
rise of a typical rheostat versus percentage
of w i nding in circuit. The factors which affect the temperature
rise act nearly independently
of each other and are summarized
as follows: 1. Ambient Temperature:
As the maximum perm i ssible operating
temperature
is a set amount , any increase in the ambient temperature
subtracts
from the permissible
temper at ure rise and therefo r e reduces the permissible
watt loa d. 2. Enclosure:
Enclosure
limits the removal of heat by convection
currents in the air and by radiat i on. The walls of the enclosure
also int r oduce a thermal barrier between the air contacting
the rheostat and the outside cooling Manufacturing
Company air. Hence, size, shape , orientation, amount of ventilat i ng openings , wall th i ckness , material and finish , all.affect
the temperature
rise of the enc l osed rheostat.
Reduction
of rating is generally
necessary
only if the housing is on ly slightly larger than the rheostat , totally enclosed and where the ratio of I ma x. to I min. is less than two. 3. Grouping:
Rheostats
mounted in standard tandem frames do not require derating.
Other conditions
should be studied for possible effects. 4. Altitude:
The amount of heat wh i ch air will absorb varies with the density , and therefore
with the altitude above sea level. At altitudes
above 100 , 000 feet , the air is so rare that the rheostat loses heat practically
only by rad i ation (and conduction
). .. 5. Pulse or Rotating Operation: This is not an environmental
condition
but a circuit condition. As a pulse of power (or th e vary i ng power in the rheostat as the contact is rotated) when averaged over the total on and off time results in less heat per unit time than for continuous
duty, the temperature
ris e is affected.
This may permit higher pulse power. The conditions
must be expert l y considered
for conservative
ra ti ng. Fig. 3: Rheostat derating for amb i ent temperature
for various specificat
i ons. o l'O*o *o* --**O-**O 1o*l 1t:*T T"C*'1:**T l.a t -"S. 6. Cooling Air: Forced circulation
of a ir over a rheostat removes more heat per un i t time than natural convection
does and therefore
permits an increased
watt dissipation. Liquid cooling also can increase the rating. 7. Limited Temperature
Rise: It is sometimes
des i rable to operate a rheostat at a fraction of the Free Air Watt Rating in order to keep the temperature
rise low. This may be to protect adjacent heat sensit i ve apparatus; to hold the resistance
value very prec i sely both w i th changing load and over long periods of time and to insure maximum life. 8. Other Considerations:
HIGH RESISTANCE. High ance units, which require the use of very small diameter wire , generally
should operate at reduced temperature
and voltage for maximum reliability.
HIGH VOLTAGE. The total volts must be limited to a reasonable
ratio with respect to the ins ulation breakdown
values , etc. 9 , I I 
i1 I EC I* L I 6 2 0 6 3 2 ' At t . 1 ' pg . 1 6 0 0 f 2 6 10 Selecting
A Rheostat PAGE 11 OF 139 OHMITE. MILITARY AND OTHER SPECIFICATIONS. The special physical operating
and test requirements
of the applicable
industrial
or military specification
must be considered.
Military specification
rheostats
should be ordered by their MIL numbers. Temperature
Coefficient
of Resistance
The res is tance alloys used for all except the lowest ohmic values show such little change with temperature
that in most power circuits the resistance
is considered
constant with load. For special applications
which require very constant resistance, it may be desirable
to specify the maximum permissible
TC (temperature
coefficient
of resistance).
and the range of temperature, and consequently
to use only certain types of resistance
alloys. For low TC (and other) applications , Ohmite can vide rheostats
with an " Ohm i cone" (silicone-ceramic)
coating. "Ohmicone" is processed
at much lower atures than vitreous enamel and therefore
makes control of TC and tolerance
easier. Data on the TC of various alloys is given in the Engineering
Manual. * Determining
the Power Rating Short-Cut
Method: Appropriate
scales on the " Step 2 Short Cut Chart" in the Resistor Catalog can also be used for r heostats. Locate the known application
modifications
of Free Air Conditions , multiply the correction
factors for ambient, altitude, etc , together with the rheostat Watts *0 2 m ax. x R meo) to obtain the minimum Watt Size Required. Calculation
Method: Obtain derating factors from graphs in th i s catalog and the Engineering
Manual and calculate
necessary
allowances. Manufacturing
Company STEP 3 Selecting
the Rheostat Model and Mechanical
Features A uniformly
wound rheostat can be chosen quite easily from the many models and res i stances listed on pages 9 to 13. It is only necessary
to se l ect one with the desired resistance
which has a current value not less than the maximum current of the circuit. When the desired resistance
falls between the standard values listed , use coded specification
number to order. Taper wound rheostats
of the required resistance
and with both max i mum and minimum current ratings not less than those of your application
may be selected from listings on pages 35 through 38. Oh mite will be pleased to design a tapered rheostat for your application
based on the required.resistance, mum and min i mum current and nature of the load. The minimum size model for a three-section
taper can be determined
with fair accuracy by the method g i ven on page 15. Additional
Features-Mechanical
and Electrical
The Rheostat Guide , pages 4 and 5 , indicates
the more commonly used additional
features and the pages on wh ic h detailed information
will be found. Mechanical
features include such typical items as special mounting bushings and shafts, tandem mountings, and auxiliary
switches. Electr i cal features include special w i nding angles , and tapers. Special attention
may be required for extra long rotation life, unusual vibration , resolution , linearity , etc. The possible combinations
of additional
features are great. In add i tion, spec i al designs to meet customer requests can be created. SUGGESTIONS
FOR ORDERING FOR STANDARD RHEOSTATS
1. Quantity.
2. Resistance. 3. Catalog Number. 4. Model and Watt Rating. 5. Itemize knobs and all other accessories
separately.
FOR MADE-TO-ORDER
RHEOSTATS
1. Quantity. 2. Resistance.
3. (a) Coded Specification
Number and Resistance. (For Uniform Wound Rheostats
where applicable.) (b) Ohmite Specification
Number and Resistance. On reorders of special rheostats , the use of this number will assure exact duplication. (c) Catalog Number of standard Tapered Rheostats. 4. Model , Watt Rating and whether Tapered Winding is desired. 5. Maximum current. 6. Minimum curre.nt (for Tapered Winding).
7. Resistance
Tolerance
if other than standard +/-10%. 8. Give Catalog Number, Type Number or Code Word for all Additional
Features plus description
of special shafts , etc. 9. I temize knobs and all other accessories
separately. 10. MIL Rheostats
should be ordered by MIL number. CODED SPECIFICATION
NUMBER Model -Ohms -s ft ha Tvoe M *p ax. ane -1trona ea ure Add". IF t E , H , J , G , As Required. F=Flatted Number 352, etc.,-. Letter R R=Round of Off Pos. K, L , P, N , used for S=Screwdr i v er Eighths decimal (sta ndard fo r 375, etc., LO , LA,&LE) ToggleSw.
R, T,orU point LO=Locking " SHALO" T2=Two in Tandem LA=Locking " SHALA" T3=Three in Tandem LE=Locking " SHALE" *Substitute
the shaft Type No. from pages 16or18 instead of max. panel thickness
when one of these shafts is to be used. Ex ample 1: H-7R5 S2-T2 . This is a Mod el H rh eos t a t , 7.5 ohm s, w i th screwdr iver slott ed shaft fo r 1 4" pan e l and mounted two in t a ndem. Example 2: J-500-5028-352 This is a Model J rh eos t at, 500 ohm s, with a catalog it em special sha lt (from table page 16)-a nd wit h Type 352 Off Po sition. Rheostats
with following
features may be specified
using code formula described
above: * Standard or Special Resitance
* Off position or auxiliary
switches * Standard, round, screwdriver
and locking shafts * Standard cages * Catalogue(!
panel length bushing or shaft * Tandem assemblies
Rheostats
with following
features may not be coded but are assigned a serial specification
number at the factory: * Tapered or special winding * Combination
of more then 2 "aliditional
features" * Customer designed specia l shafts and features 
------E C 62 063 2 Att 1 Pg 16 1 Of 26.....REPORTNO.:
REP-424-008-RP1 ' . ' . r. REVISION: 03 Taper Wound *OHMITE Manufacturing
Company Fig. 28: Size comparison
of uniform and tapered rheostats
for a specific application. Rheosta t windings are sometimes
tapered , i.e., wound in two to five (or more) sections of d i minishing
w i re or ribb on sizes. These sections are so smoothly joined that only the change in wire size tells where the sections connect (see Fig. 28). For a given application , the taper may accomplish
one or more of the following: 1. Make possible the use of a smaller rheostat.
2. Provide more uniform control (i.e., more nearly linear control) at all positions
of the contact arm. 3. Make p ossible special curves of res i stance (or of the controlled
effect) versus rotation. 4. Make p ossible the w i nd i ng of higher resistance
on a given s ize rheostat , for a g i ven maximum amperage. Because tapered windings involve extra manufacturing
operatio n s , tapered rheostats
when ordered s i ngly or in small qu a nti ti es generally
cost mo r e than uniformly
wound rheostat s of t he next l a rger size. Tapers are generally
not suitable unless the
ratio of maximum to minimum current is 1.5 or g reater. When l a rge quant i ties are involved (the necessa r y quantity depending
upon the rheostat model and number of sections)
the tapered unit generally
become s the more economical
one. For conven i ence and economy in making preliminary
tests to determ i ne the resistance
and current rating, a stock (linear) rheostat is f r equently used. How Size Is Reduced When the moving contact of a rheostat is on the first turn of w i re or ribbon , th i s turn must carry the maximum current. But as the resistance
is put into the circuit, the succ e ed i ng turns never have to carry more than a certain fraction of the maximum current , because the current tapers off from the maximum to some minimum value. He n ce , in a un i fo r m , or linear winding , the latter t i ons of the winding operate at lower wattages (12R) per square inch than the rated values. The tapered winding , us i ng smaller size wire for each section , proportioned
for the current to be carr i ed, increases
the ohms per inch of winding in success i ve sections. This makes the watts dissipated
per square inch of winding section more nearly approach the rated wattage value. As the core area required for a g i ven wattage dissipation
is less when operated at h i gher watts pe r square inch than for lower watts per square inch, the total core size i s reduced. * Ohmite taper designs use the largest wire practicable
for each section so that great durability
is maintained. How Better Control ls Produced Fig. 29 shows how the current varies (in a typical case) with the percent rotation of t he rheostat contact. Because a uniformly
wound rheostat adds a constant number of ohms per degree of rotation to a constantly
increasing
number of ohms , the current changes ever more slowly as the resistance
is increased (curve " A" Fig. 29). A tapered winding (curves " B" and " C") by increasing
the number of ohms per degree of rotation as the total ohms in circuit i ncre a ses, makes the current curve more nearly linear. 17 
r-EC 02 0 6" 3 2, At C I , PC g. 16 2 o-{ 2 6 --fE P ORT NO_:
REVIS I ON: 03 'I *1 { f, 18 raper Wound RheostafsGE
l gOfl 39 OHMITE. 100 r---....----r------r---,-----, IOO .. r 50 "' a
10 40 60 80 PEii CENT ROTATION OF RHEOSTAT SHAFT Fig. 29: Typical curves of load variation
with shaft rotation for uniform and taper-wound
rheostats. Se l ecting a Tapered Rheostat Tapers depend, among other factors , on the ratio of the maximum to the m i nimum current and upon the way in which the current varies between these end points. Tape r s , therefore, are designed for specific circuits. For any given set of rheostat conditions (resistance , maximum and minimum current) it is generally
possible to design more than o'ne size of tapered rheostat.
That is , any of the var i ous Oh mite rheostats
can be used the wattage rating of which is sufficiently
greater than the required Summation
Watts (I:W I ma< XI min. X R rheo)-the smaller rheostat generally
having more sections than the l arger. The choice bet\Neen the models will depend upon the space requirements, mounting conditions, and upon the quantity ordered. In small quantities
the larger rheostat of fewer sections sometimes
costs l ess than the smaller rheostat of greater number of sections. Approximate
Size of Tapered Rheostat Method I. The approximate
size of a tapered rheostat, for specified
conditions, having an average number of sections (3) can be determined
as follows: 1. Determine
Summation I:W= I ma<. X f m i n. X R . K /max. 2. Determme = -1 -. mm. Round off the figure to the next highest number in Col. K, F i g. 30. 3. Select Factor F from Tab l e Fig. 30. (Note: For greater accuracy, the exact value of K can be used and Ffound by interpolation
in the Table.) Manufacturing
Company 4. Determine
Rheostat Model (Watt Size). Multiply I:Wby F and choose smallest rheostat having a watt rating equal to or greater than this product. I Example: i Rheostat Ohms= 20 1 I max. = 12.6 amps. I m in.= 1.27 amps . 1. I:W= 12.6x 1.27x20 = 321 watts 2. K = 1 2.6 = 9 9 Round off to 10. 1.27 . 3. F = 2.13 (from table Fig. 30) 4. I:WxF = 321 x 2.13 = 684 Model T = 750 which is greater than product 684 and therefore
3 section Model T can be used. K F K F 1.5 1.15 5 1.70 2 1.26 7.5 1.93 3 1.45 10 2.13 4 1.60 Fig. 30: Table of factor F for tapered rheostat selection (three sections). The Oh mite Engineering
Department
will be glad to recommend
the most econom i cal unit and to design the taper upon receipt of full information (see page 8 "How To Order"). Standard Taper Rheostats.
The rheostats
listed on pages 35 to 39 include taper-wound
units wh i ch can be used for field control or other purposes, such as the control of heating elements or other loads of constant resistance. Method II. An alternate
design method sometimes
can be used which results in a rheostat of smaller size and/or fewer number of taper sections than that provided by the Method I des i gn. Method II specifies
a rheostat , the wattage size of which is equal to (or sometimes
less than) the calculated
Summation
Watts. Such designs operate at higher hot spot temperatures than the Method I des i gns. Direction
of Taper. To indicate the direction
of taper, a sketch, similar to Fig. 31 WIRE S I DE VIEW or a statement , should he included when ordering.
The direct i on of taper shown is dard and will be pl i ed unless otherwise
ordered. It is described
as "counterclockwise
increase i n resistance
when viewed from the knob side'.' c9.,, .. OF LOW RESISTANCE
END OF TAPERED WINDING 
EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 163 of 2 6 j<EPOR I NO.: Rt:P=424-668-kP1
REVISION: 03 -OHMITE Bushings and Shafts for Small Rheostats (Models C, E, H, J, G, K, L) Y,," FOR H*L :4." FORE P OSITIO N OF CO NTACT 1 4-BUSHING , IN RE L ATI O N TO FLAT 3 18"* 32 ON SH AF T TH'D.W I TH _,
RETA INING I" 3/32" TH'K. I Ul _ R I NG -......______
w-2 1 f-,".EX.NUT gg
:; 1.i..1.1.. + "
l *'"'J .... l <[ /, .. D RILL 3116" D I A.
1/16" FOR MODE L H-L;
PRO J ECTI O N l/a" FOR C & E FLATTED Fig. 32: Flatted shaft for Y a" and Y 4" diameter '1[ci 1/32 *FO R H*L 1/6 4" F OR E f
DRIL L I N PAN E L 3116" FOR H-L 11 8" FOR C EIE D IA. ,, I , , R E T A INING ./I :: RING
NON*TURN l/ 1 6" FOR MODEL H-L; W AS HER 7/64" F OR MO DEL C; PROJECTION
5/64" F OR M ODEL E RO U ND Fig. 33: R ound shaft for Va" and 1/4'' diameter PAGE 110 OF 139 Manufacturing
Company STANDARD SHAFT VARIATIONS
FOR MODEL C' ANO E (l't" Dia. Shatt) 'SHAFT PROJECTION
(C J FROM RETAINING
RING-SHAFT
CODES ANO TYPE NUMBERS BUSHING ' SCREWDRIVER
surr MAX. PROJ. " A" FLAnED ROUND PANEl Non-LocJcina
Shaft Locking Shalt STD. LONG STD. LONG STD. SPECIAL REG. LOCK. 1%, 1%4 11%, 11. '%. 1'%, l2%1 2'%, \!, l!o u,.(, Xa o/is F V, R V, 572A S V, 573A 5738 573C 5730 *v, --y. 1%2 F1 R1 576A S1 577A 5778 577C 5770 *1 -t57SC v, ---------t5798 t579C Y. 'lo F2 R2 5S1A S2 5S2A 5S28 5S2C 5S2D *2 t5838 t583C P roj. from Mt g. Surface to end W' 'lo" 1:4'' %" 'lo" H i" 2" 2:4'' 'lo" l's'' of shaft for W'pa nel (2) (I) Add obtain pro 1 ec1lon from fro nl ol b u shing t o end o f sha lt. (2) For PFMS (p r ojec:io n moun ting surface to end of shalt); lor panels olher than .. acid diNerence
belwee n Ille dlosen bushing pro j ection and W' to pro j ection shown. (3) Fi al l eng lh; \I," f or all. (4) Model C li m i:ed at p r esenllo 577A, 5 78C. 5790 , and 579C. No. 577A i.standa 1d o n Model C and used i ns tead of St "P r efix consisti n g of code !or ty pe <l f l ocknu t m ust be added as i n L 0 1, LA t, LE1. For ot h er th a n the standa rd shaft wrt h sc r ewd ri ver
indica:e w ith acditional
p r ef.x lette r such as FL 0 1 , or RL.0 1. tPref ix consis ti ng o f code l or lype of l oc knu t mu sl be added as i n LE57 98 (LA i s n o t app lica!J!e). slotted bushing for a locking device are also available
with bushings to accommodate
var ious panel thicknesses. They can be obtained with different
projections
beyond the retaining
ring to accommodate
special knobs , or auxiliary
devices, etc. ) H-Lf , Afr BUSHING IC _L_ -D I A. -4--.._*,, , Where appearance
requires that the knob be close to the panel or space is limited , and the panel is thin , the Ya" panel bushing is used. Bushings for a 1/i s" panel can be made also . Shafts with Flat ) .J T/ . ,,
RE T AININ G c::.l i;. 1/16" FOR MODE L H-L; "-. R I NG / 7 /64" FOR MODE L C; DR I LL HOLE_.:::,,. NON-TURN 5/64" FOR MOD EL E IN PAN E L 3/16" FOR H-L l/8"fORCEIE
SLO TTE D Fig. 34: S lotted (Screwdriver)
shaft for Va" and 1/4" diameter Standard shafts for Models C and E rheostats
are round with a Y 4 "-32 bush i ng for mounting on panels to Ya" thick; for Models H , J , G, Kand L rheostats , standard shafts have a f lat and a 3/a"-32 threaded bushing-long
enough for mounting on panels up to Y4" thick. Shafts without a flat, with a screwdriver
slot, or with screwdriver
slot and The standard flat is always located so that a perpendicular to the flat is in line with the r heostat contact and on the opposite s i de of the shaft. This agrees with the normal locat ion of a set screw on a knob and results in the arrow-head
or pointer, if any, pointing to the location of the contact. Symbol "F" describes
this type of shaft i n the rheostat coded designation (for standard front p rojec t ion only). Shafts without Flat (Round) A plain round end is sometimes
preferred
when it is desired to be able to line up the knob with certain panel calibration
marks , to fit a coupling gear , etc. Rheostat code sy mbol i s "R" (for standard front projection
only). STANDAllD
SHAFT VARIATIONS
FDR MODELS H , J , 6 , KAND L !Y." Dia. Shatt) 'Shalt Pro Joction (CJ from Rota l n i ng Ring-Type Nos. B ushing Mu. Pr o J. " A" F latt ed' Round Panel Reg-Std. Long Std. Long ular Typo 11..it l''ht 1%t 11%." w* W' Fl 502A 5028 502C R1 5 1 2A 5128 t%" %" F2 503A 5038 503C R2 513A 5138 y,'' 'lo" F4 504A 5048 504C R4 514A 5 1 48 W' F 6 505A 5058 505C R6 515A 5158 1" 11"' FS 506A 5068 506C RS 5 1 6A 5168 1\S" 1%" F12 507A 5078 507C R 12 517A 5178 2" 2 W' F16 508A 5088 508C , R16 51SA 51S8 P rojec t i o n F rom Mtg. Surfa c e To W' 1!4'' 2" 2 W' %'' 1!4'' 2" End o f Sh a lt For Y." Pa n el (2) .. ( f) Add l>z to obla 1 n p r oiecton from
of bush i ng 1 0 end o f sh aft (2) F or PFM S (pro j ection from mou ntin g surtace) fo r panels olher than %" add d1tte1"'1ce
between t he des'.r ed bu sh i ng p rojection
and\'." l he PFMS shown. (3) F lat length; 'l>," f o r a ll. Short 2%t y.n 51 2C 5120 513C 5130 514C 5140 515 C 5 1 50 516 C 5 1 60 517 C 5170 51SC 51SO 2\4''
'Shalt Pro jection (CJ from Reta i n i ng Ring-Type
Nos. Bu shi ng Screwd river Slot Max. Prol. "A" Non-Lockin
g Shalt Lock ing Shalt Panel Reg-Lock-Std. Med. long Std. Long ul1r Type ing %t ''ht 1%," 2%," %t X" t%t .. Y." W' S 1 552E 552A 5528 552C '1 t 562F t562E :l:Y." %" %" S2 5 53E 553A 5538 553C *2 t563F t563E w* 'lo" W' S4 554 E 554A 5548 554C *4 t564F t564E :Y." l's'' 1 1"' S6 555E 555A 5558 555C '6 t565F t5 65E 1" 1 W' 1 3/o" SS 556E 55 6A 556 8 556C *s t566F t 566E 1V," 1 3/o" 1 W' S12 557E 557A 557 8 557C *1 2 t567F t 567E 2" 2 W' 2%" S16 558E 558A 55SB 55aC '16 t56SF t56SE P rojection
From Mt g. Surface To W' w* 1!4" 2" 2!4" *" 2%2" 1 W' End o f Shalt Fo r Y." Panel (2) Prefuc cons 1 stJng of code l or type of locknut mu s l b e added as in L0 1 , LA f, or LE1 (see page 1 7). For other than the standa r d shalt with scte'Ndriver
slot, i ndicate with prefix l etter such as Fl01, or RL 01. t Prefuc cons i Sl i ng o f code for lype o f l ocknut must be added as i n L0 562F or L E562F (LA i s not applicable-see
pag e 17). tStandard
19 ------------
. -. -r-.:H EPORTNO.".'" RE P=zr 24-=008=RP , .*-Ee Att. 1 , Pg. 1 6 4 of 26 1.. REVISION: 03 Bushings and Shafts for Small Rheostats
PAGE 111 OF 139 OHMITE*! *! ' 20 (Models C, E, H, J, G, I<, L) Shafts with Screw-Driver
Slot This type of shaft is used to permit operation
by a screwdriver instead of a knob when the rheostat is to be adjusted infrequently
or when possibility
of tampering
with the setting must be minim i zed. Symbol " S" is used in the code (for standard front projection
only). Locking Type Screw Driver Shafts A slotted bushing for use with special nuts as described
below can be supplied. Rheostat code shaft and bush i ng symbols are "LO," " LA ," or "LE" depending
on the type of locking nut. Special Shafts Commercial
shafts for Models E , H , J, G, Kand Lare o r d i narily of zinc-plated
steel. Stainless
steel is standard on Model C. Bushings are unplated brass , but can be supplied zinc or nickel-plated
at extra cost. All shafts listed in m i litary specification
MIL-R-22 are available
also. For special shafts made to order; supply a drawing or complete dimensions. Specify dimension "A;' which is the projection
of the bushing beyond the rheostat assembly nut. The retaining
ring i s not included in th i s d i mension. Dimension
" A" is (nom i nally) the sum of the given maximum panel thickness
plus the thickness
of the mounting nut and an allowance
for manufacturing
tolerance. The bushing should be another 1/1 s" longer if a lock-washer (see *page 26) is to be used. See page 26 for " Shoulder Nuts" which are used with screwdriver
shafts (3/s"-32 bush i ng) when i t is desired to keep the end of the shaft protected
in a recess. Use shoulder nut No. 6057 for bush i ng lengths over 1/4 ". Heavy Duty Stop and 3/a" Dia. Shaft Rheostat Models H, J , G , Kand L can be provided with a :Y a" diameter shaft sleeve with a special heavy duty stop for use on industrial
applications , especially
where large d i ameter knobs are used. The stop can safely withstand
stopping torques of 80 pound-inches. As the stationary
stop is part of the special mounting bracket and the moving stop is a part of the 3/a" diameter sleeve, the stopping torque is not transmitted
i nto the rheostat.
Shaft projection, special drilling, etc., can be varied. Heavy Duty Stop, 3/a" Dia. Shaft Code Word and Tapped Mounting Bracket .............
S,HABS I /4-20 N C -2 8 T W O H O L E S *Sp e cify for l e n gth s other than 1" Fig. 35: Heavy duty stop for small rheostats.
Manufacturing
Company Shafts with Rear Extension
Special shafts with a n e.ictension
on the rheostat wire side can be prov i ded , so tha 1 other apparatus
can be coupled to enable operation
by the rheostat knob. Valves and switches are examples b f items frequently
coupled. For Shaft Extensions
on Wire Side, Y4'' Diam._ .. _ .... _ . Advise desired length D i stance from mounting surface to end of shaft must be given. Provide a sketch for special drilling , etc. BEHIND MO UN TIN G SU RFACE ' ----e Shaft Locking Devices for Models C, E, H, J, G, K, L Shaft Max. D i a. Panel A B Slot F 6 H See See %, (El y,, w '(,, % p. 1 6 p. 1 6 lt, ,O x See See Yii lt,, W o/,6 1 Yl2 1 p.16 p.1 6 y,, o Fig. 37: Shaft locking devices. J %2 x Shaft clamping or "locking" dev i ces which discourage
or prevent tampering
with a rheostat setting , consist of a special nut on a split and tapered bushing (Fig. 37). The lock nut has a match i ng internal taper which forces the segments of the bushing against the shaft. Several types of nuts are ava i lable as shown. The knurled edge disc type is for tightening
with the fingers and is sometimes
employed with a knob-type shaft. The standard shaft end is normally slotted fo r screwdriver
unless otherwise
ordered. To order the shaft-lock
feature, state panel ness and proper code word shown below and/or specify bushing and shaft assembly when possible by the type numbers shown on page 16. Code Word* Hexagon Nut Locking Device ................ SHALO Cap Nut Locking Device .................... SHALA Knurled Round Nut Locking Device ........... SHALE *" LO, LA or LE" are used in coded specification. \ 
Ee 6 2 6 63 t A:tt 1* -1 p g. 1 6 5 0 t -2 6 ""}Af-r>O'R'ffi o.: REF'-424-uuB
-RPi REVISION: 03 -O HMIT E PAGE 112 OF 139 Shafts for Lar g e R he ostats (Models P, N, R, T, U) P'OS I TION OF CONTACT IN llfLATION
TO FLAT /OH SHAFT t J Fl.AT TED POSITION OF CONTACT IN RELATION TO STOP jHAFT ROUND Manufacturing
Company SLOTTED Fig. 38: Flatted shaft. Fig. 39: Round
Fig. 40 Slotted (screwdriver)
shaft. Specia l Shafts Standa r d rheostat shaft assemblies , as illustrated
on stock units, have a sh a ft with a flat for the set screw of a knob , and are long enough for mounting on panels up to Y4" thick (when used with knob Cat. No. 5 1 04 or 5105). Shafts w i thout a flat , or with a screw-driver
slot are also avai l ab l e. While t h e standard shaft is generally
used on thin panels as well as on pane l s up to the maximum, shorter shafts are available
and are frequently
used when \. it is de s ired to have the knob and pointer close to the dial , j or pan e l. Standard shafts are zinc plated steel. Stainless
stee l , T y pe 416 or 303 , is a v ailable at extra cost. j Sha ft s i n all lengths per MIL-R-22 are also availab l e. Specia l length shafts or shafts with special drilling etc., can be supplied.
P l ease s u bmit a drawing. FLATTED ROUND PANEL THICKNES S A e Proj. lgth. Pro j. from of Code from Code Mfg. Flat Symbol Mfg. Symbol Surface Surface lio" to Y. 1'%z'' 1" F3 ' 1'%z'' R3 1 ,.+" x1W' 2" 1%,"' FHJ' 2" R1 0 (S td.) 1%" to2 v.'' 3" 1'/,,"' . 3" R1 B " " (1) 1' Pa n e l mait fo r S6 and 2 lo r Sl6. (2) Only F 3 can >e supplied 1 0< !his r ange ol panel l h ickncsscs.
(3} Only F 10 can be supplied l or this range of pane l thicknesses. (4} Ava ila bl e tn W' inc r emen ts from F ll t o F1 8. POS I T ION OF CONT A CT I N RELATION TO SLOT ON SHA FT L----<--[tJ Fig. 41: Shaft locking device. SCREW-DRIVER
SLDT ProJ. from Code Mfg. Symbol Sur11ca &#xa5;." $6 1 1 Y." $10 2" St6 1 Shafts with Rear Extension
Special shafts with an extension
on the rheostat wireside can be provided. Rheostats
can also be made w i th the normal front end cut off and the rear extended for tion from the wire side only. For Shaft Extension
on Wire Side, 1 1/1s" Dia ...........
Advise desired length D i stance from mounting surface to end of shaft must be g ive n. Provid e a sketch if any special drilling , etc., is requ i red. Fig. 42: Shaft with rear extension. Screw C l amp Locks The locking device for rheostats
with 3/s" shafts takes the form of a split arm fastened to the mounting p a n el as shown in Fig. 41. When the hex socket cap screw is t igh t ened , the spl i t arm i s clamped to the shaft, preventing
* rotation.
The shaft is slotted for screw-driver
operation. Screw Clamp Locking Device .... Code W o r d: SHA L L Specify shaft selected from foll o wing table or give projection
from moun t ing surface for othe r panels. Panel Shalt Project i on Shalt Thickness
From Mounting "JYpe No. Sur11ce \io" t o'ls" incl. $6 1h" to 1 o/,{ inc l. 1 v.'' S1 0 21 
*' :*1 'I '' . ' '' L:;. '1!:
1 11:
*\I. fl l i!l !f "I .1. f :11 I i!i .'j l::1i ti: r ','1 ..:, f " I
n '" !: :;i ,, ., . 1.i* 1 i ft: r*: " ., 1:: I ' if I ,. **1. ( ;f* i" 1; 1. .J' *,, .. ,. : 1 ,,,, J>.bob. 1 , Pg. 1 66 of 2rs fEPORTNO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION: 03 :&deg;!.:. t1 ; .a w; AJY4<?2fo-#'
l} E ?!'Et&#xb5;* &-...... _ PAGE 113 OF 139 Standard Tandem Assemblies
OHMITE.,. Fig.43: Standard assembly of twoModelJ
rheostats
Standard Tandem Assemblies
Oh mite rheostats
can be supplied mounted two, three, or more in tandem for simultaneous
control of several circuits , or phases of a circuit , by means of a single knob, as shown in Figs. 43 to 50. The rheostats
are spaced to permit the i r operation
at the same ratings as when individually
mounted. Tandem rheostats
are frequently
connected
in series (and sometimes
in paralel) to obtain increased
wattage dissipation
over that of a single rheostat for a given panel space, or because the wattage required exceeds that of a single rheostat.
Frames consist of plated stee l strip , as illustrated, with mounting holes for panel or shelf mounting. Two , three , or four rheostats
are generally
connected
by Oh mite-made
universal
jo i nts which provide smopth action with a minimum of backlash. Greater numbers of rheostats
are connected
by a single through-shaft, which may be plied also tor 2 to 4 rheostats
at option of Oh mite or the customer.
As many as ten rheostats
can be arranged i n tandem on special frames; details supplied on request. Manufacturing
Company Mixed Models: Tandem assemblies
of different
model rheostats
can be ordered , but such rheostats
are cially made to make angle of rotation of all of the rheostats
the same as that of the smallest rheostat.
The largest rheostat is mo J nted next to the panel and i ng dimensions
for that size apply to the mixed assembly. Ordering Information:
Give Tandem Mounting Catalog Number and specify rheostats
completely. When the rheostats are not identical, their location with respect to the panel should be given. Shaft lengths are as indicated
in Figs. 44 to 46. Spec i fy panel thickness
or shaft length if other than standard is desired . Shaft Diameter P, N, R, T & U: Model P, N, R, T, and U tandem assemblies
can be supplied with 112'' diameter through-shafts
instead of 3/e" diameter. All large tandems of more than 4 rheostats
in tandem are supplied with V 2" diameter shafts as standard. Location of Flat on Tandem Shafts: The standard t i on of the flat on a tandem shaft has been selected so that when the tandem frame is mounted on a panel with the frame vertical , the pointer on a knob will rotate symmetr i cally about the vertical center-line. Note that both the rheostat and the flat have been rotated 90&deg; from the normal mounting position with the center-lead
vertical and down. If the user intends to mount the rheostats
per this latter method, the tandem assembly can be ordered with the flat on the shaft the same as on an individual
rheostat , i.e., the perpendicular
to the flat is 180&deg; from the contact. Spec i fy on order: " Fla t on shaft to be 180&deg; from contact: ' Factory Assembled
Aheo-stat Watts Model Each E 12\f' Model E-T3 Tandem 2-in-tandem 3-i n-tandem Cat I Weigh t N o. (lbs.) Cat I Weight N o. (l bs.) 6640 I .080 6641 I .164 1Bndem Rheostat Assemblies
ModelE Fig. 44: Dimensions
for Model E tandem assemblies
\ 
\ :) j 2 6
NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION: 03 Factory Assemble d PAGE 114 O F 139 -OH MITE 1Bndem Rheostat Assembl ies Manu f acturing Company RHEOSTAT Mo d al Watts Each H 25 J so G 75 K 10 0 L 1SO RHEOSTAT Model Watts Each p 22S N 300 R soo T 7 50 u 1000 Models H, J, G, K, L A 3'h" 3'h'' 4%" 4%" 4'!." A 5'7(," 6 Y,," 51:y,s" 7 7(," 7 7(," _.,,..
,,,,..,....
COUPLING P OSt Tl ON OF CONTACT IN REL:.7 1 0N T O FLAT ON SHAFT Max.Pane l Code F2' F4 F6 F8 F1 2 F16 In. Std. 'h" &#xa5;." 1" 1 'h" 2" Tandem M s %," '%." Ye'' 11Ai" W' 1%" 1:.\" 1%" 1%" 2'h'' 2W' 2%'' 'Will fit o/.s" max. pane l with panel nut: W' max. panel wilhout p ane l nut Fig. 45: Dimensions
for Model H , J , G , Kor L tandem assemblies
DIMENSIONS
8 c D E F v w S W' 2%" 1" '%," '1Aa" l W' S'h'' 3" 1" lo/,," 1%s" IY,g" 2'h" 6W' 411.'' lX" 1%" 1'%," 'Yi g'' 3%" 6W' 4'!." 1 11." l'Y,," 11As" 3%'' 7'/.'' S" 1'/.'' 2" 2*/,," '1As" 4"1." NOTE: Catat09 Numbers t or 4 rheosta t s in Tandem are: H = 6620 , J = 6621 , G = 6622 , K = 6623 , L = 6624 Models P, N, R, T, U POS I TION O F CO"IT A CT IN RE L ATION TO FL A T ,.........
oN SHAFT Code F1 0' F3 F1 8 Max.Panel In. 'h" to 1 V." I-le" l o%" 1'h" to 2'!." 'S landatd Fig. 46: Dimensions
for Model P, N , R, Tor U tandem assemblies
DIMENSI O NS 8 c D E F v w 9Y,," 7" 1'h" 2'h" 1'!." 7" 1'h" 3" 3\t,o" Va" !%" 9Y, ," B W' 1'h" 4" 4o/is" Va" 3" 13" 1'h" 5" ... W' 3V." 11 Yia" 13" 1'h" 6" 6%" Va'' 6" N OTE: Catalog Numbers for 4 rheostats
in Tandem a r e: P 6625, N = 6626, R = 6627 , T = 6628, U = 6629 y z 2" 1 1 1Ae 11 2" 1"/it;" 2'h" 1"As" 2'h" 1 11,1,611 2'h" Aatlongth
s 0 2" 1 Yie" 1 'o/,," 1'l11" 3" 1 9A1" y z 3'h" 2'h" 3'h" 2 W' 3'h" 2'h" 4" 3" 4" 3" 23 
, ,...E C ___ 6 2 b 6 3 2 I 16 8 *-r x fREPORT NO::; REP=424-=tl08
-A t t * 1 , P g* o 6 REV ISION: 03 24 18ndem Coupling Kits PAGE 115&deg;F 139 OH MITE Fig.47: Typical assembly and tandem kit T ANDEM KIT CAT NQ. 6"91 _ __, ,_LI 3 HOLES BUS H I N G IA-3 2 THO. DR I L L 1/8 HO LE IN PANE L W I TH 1/16 THICK HE X NUT. FOR NON-T U AN PROJECTI O N J I MOUNT I NG PANEL-1/16 THK. MA X.--j / Fig. 50: back assembly of Model J rheostats
Fig. 48: Dimens i ons , Model E tandem kit When the depth beh i nd a panel is too limited for a standard type tandem assemb ly, a " Back-to-Back" Tandem Assembly may fit as it is somewhat shorter. As illustrated , the rear rheostat is mounted inside the frame , back-to-Manufacturing
Company Tandem coupling kit consists of steel " U" frame , coupling with set screws , mica washer, hex key and instruc t ions. The kit i s intended for field assembly, coupling two standard rhe q stats. The coupling fastens to the shaft of the back unit-projections
on the coupling engage the recesses in the driving hub of the front unit. Ordering Information
Coupli ng Kit for two Model E Rheostats
.. Stock No. 6591 Coup l ing Kit for Model Hor J ........... Cat. No. 6532 Coupling K i t for Model G , Kor L ......... Cat. No. 6533 S I D E V I E W C a t. No. 6532 6533 Rheo. Model H J G K L A 8 c '%:." 1%" 2%," 1)132" 1 31'.'." ,, 2o/,," 1%" 1 Y." 2o/io" 1 Y,," l o/." 2o/io" 2 2 2'/.o" FRO N T VIEW CA T. NI D 1o/ig" 1%t 1'%,'' 12%" 2 o/,," FR O N T V I EW CAT. Ht 6533 O NL Y Fig. 49: Dimensions , tandem kit for Models H , J , G, K , L Back-To-Back
18ndem Assemblies
back with the first rheos tat. "Back-to-back" tandem frame dimensions
are the same as the standard frames , except for the depth. When mounting Models H, J, G , R , or Lon these frames , a hole 3/s" in diameter is required in the panel to clear the assembly nut. Two f n Tandem B-to-B B-to-B Depth Tandem Depth Tandem Model Beh i nd F rame Model Be/Jln d Frame Panel Cat. No. P a nel Ca t. No. H 2 1 Yie" 6 63 0 p 5;{e" 66 3 5 J 2'\I,*" 66 3 1 N 5 1 1A11" 6636 G 3%" 6 6 3 2 R S Y,," 6637 K 3%" 663 3 T 6 W' 66 38 L 4V." 6634 u 6 W' 6 6 39 \ \. 
EC 6 20632 , Att. 1 Pg 169 of 262ft:PORI
NG.: Rt:P-424-0UB-RPi ' * REVISION: 03 -OH MITE Sequence Coupled Rffeosiats
Fig. 51: Sequence-couple
rheostats "Sequence
Coupling" is a method (Pat. No. 3, 127,582) of coupling two rheostats
in tandem so that they can be rotated by a single knob, in succession (or " sequence") rather than together as in conventional
ganged devices. Either the " front" or " back" rheostat can be arranged t o rotate fi rst. Sequence coupling is obtained by means of a special hub which links the two rheostats. Advantages
of this feature are: (1) The physical size of tandem rheostat assemblies
used for motor speed control can be reduced considerably.
Where c onventional
tandem rheostats
are used in combined motor-armature , motor-field
or combined motorfield, generator-field control, opposite halves of the two rheost a ts must be "zero" resistance
to perm it full current \ to be ma i ntained in one circuit wh i le the current is varied J in the other circuit (Fig. 52). With sequence-coupled
rheost a ts , however, each rheostat controls its circuit in turn while the other rema i ns fixed at the max i mum current position. Hence, the zero resistance
halves are not required (F i g. 53) and rheostat size may be approximately
halved. (2) Resolution
of adjustment
is significantly
increased
because control is possible over approximately
650 degrees of rotation. (3) Seq u ence-coupled
rheostats
can be wound to provide , in combination, a taper; which permits a higher ratio of maximum to minimum current combined with h i gh total resista n ce , than is otherwise
feas i ble. Fig. 52: Conventional
tandem rheosta t in field and armature circuit of motor. Fig. 53: Sequence-coupled
rheostat in field and armature circuit of motor. Rheostat Sizes: Sequence-coupled
rheostats
can be
in the following
sizes: / Front Position (Adjacent
to Knob End)-Models
P, N , R , T. U (res p ectively 225, 300, 500, 750, 1000 watts). Back Position-Models
J, G, K , L , P, N, R, T, U (50, 75, 100, 150, 225, 300, 500 , 750 and 1000 watts). Note: The "front" or " back" rheostat actually can con-Manufacturing
Company sist of more than one rheostat, conventionally
ganged, so that one group of rheostats
is, in effect , sequence-coupled
to another group. Sequence:
One of the follow i ng sequences
of operation
should be specified. Sequence ''f{' Operation (Code Word: SECOA): When the knob is turned clockwise
from the extreme clockwise
position , the "front" rheostat (closest to the knob) turns through its full rotation before the " back" one does. When the knob is turned in a CCW direction
from the extreme CW position, then the back rheostat turns first. Sequence "B" Operation (Code Word: SECOB): When the knob is rotated clockwise
from the extreme CCW pos iti on, the back rheostat turns first. Panel Thickness:
Standard assemb l y accommodates
up to 1 1/1s" panel; specify greater thicknesses.
Mounting Considerations:
A tandem frame is normally arranged to mount on a panel i n horizontal
pos i tion. If the Sequence Coupling Dia l is desired , and the frame must be mounted vertically
on the panel, then the rheostat mounting screws must be countersunk
i n the p a nel. D im ensions of sequence-coupled
tandem assemblies
are approximately
the same as shown on page 20.* ever , the frames are tapped for 1/4 -20 mounting screws on ly, everi whe re the r e ar e three or more rheostats
in tandem. An end support may therefore
be required.
Motor Drives can be supplied. Submit requirements. *rhe "W" dimension
for Model U rheostat changes to 3*" and the ''A" d imensi on to 7%1' in a sequence coupling arrangement
Sequence Coupling Dials A "sequence-coupling" dial and knob are available
which prov i de a specif ic reading for every setting of the knob throughout
its double (approximately
650 degree) tion. Between the points where one rheostat stops and the other begins its rotation , the movable (calibrated)
plate i s tripped by a p i n on the knob pointer. This plate shifts to expose one of two sets of numbers (0-100, or 100-200) through holes in the cover plate. The sequence coupling d i al assembly is held on the pane l by four-self-tapping
screws. A choice of dials is available
to accommodate
the screws used in mounting the rheostat.
Sequence Coupling Dial and Knob Kits Front Rheostat D ia l-Knob Requires Rheos1 1 1* Mounllng Kit Rheostat Screws Cal No. t frame Pto U FlatHd. 5020 Hor. or V e rt p 5021 N Round 5022 Horiz. R Head 5023 Only T o rU 5024 'N e xt to panel. tSee "Mcunnno Conside r auons" abov e. 25 
.. -E e -5-2 ... o .... 5-3 .........
2-,-A ... t ,....,,...t
-.-1-, -,1 7 0 0 f 2 6 -fEPORT NO.: REP*424--008-RP REVISION: 03 PAGE 117 OF 1 39 Toggle Switches OH MITE Fig.56: ModelJ with toggle switch and extra lug ARM ROTATES PAST THIS { BEFORE TOGGLESWITCH IS ACTUATED. / Fig. 55: Model J with toggle switch RESISTANCE
WINDING /ENDS HERE. ARM ROTATES PAST . ' THIS { BEFORE TOGGLE* 0 'SWITCH IS ACTUATED ....... SWITCH IS IN OPEN ' POSITION WHEN TACT ARM IS ON THIS LUG. operation
toggle switch Description:
The toggle switch is operated with a pos i ti ve snap after the rheostat arm has been rotated through from 30&deg; (Model H) t o 5&deg; (Mode l U) appro x imately. Th e operation
takes place while the rheostat contact is on the end lug only on Model P rheostats
or larg e r. Depth of rheostat i s increased
approximately
112;* except on Model R, it is 5/s:' Two switches can be mounted on the same rheostat , to operate at opposite ends of rotation. Application:
When an auxiliary switch must be operated with a minimum amount of rheostat shaft rotat i on , or operation
of the switch must occur at a closely specified
angular location, regardless
of direction
of rotation , a sensitive , snap action switch (such as a " Micro-Switch")
is requ i red. Functions
are otherwise
the same as for Fig. 58: Rheostat with sens i tive switch a toggle-switch. These switches are also used when certain MIL specificat
i ons must be met. Depth of rheostat behind panel is increased
3/4" approximate
l y. Sen siti ve Sw i tch Type Number Counter-Clo ck-Contact Rating S iz e Rheost a t clock-w i se Form Model w i se End" End" SPOT 15A. 125/250 VAC v E , H.J. 380 480 G. K.L S PO T 15A t 125/250/480 V AC B K,L, N , P. 38 1 481 A, T , U SPOT SA. 1 25/250 VAC SM E 379 479 O POT 10A. 1251250 VAC OT P , N , R , 385 485 T,U O POT 1 O A. 1 2 5/2 5 0 VAC D H t oU 386 486 t20 A rating avai l able fo r d w ell operation
in w hich switch r emains actuated thruo u t desired angle of rola ti on. " Rola t ion observed from k n ob end of shatt Manufacturing
Company Standard Lugs: Toggle switch opens the rheostat circuit or switches an independent
circuit. Recommended
for 115V service on all models. Extra Lug: Enables sw i tching of rheosta t and an independent circuit. Also used on Models H, J, G, Kand L wh e n the oper a tion of switch must occur outside the lim i ts of resist a nce change. For all models. i Dwell Operation:
Switch is operated at either end of rotation and remain s in same state when direction
of shaft rotation is reve r sed , un t il the other end of th e tion , where the sw i tch is re-set. Act i on accomplished
by double-pro
n ged operat i ng lever wh i ch pushes , but not pull , the toggle switch lever at both ends of r otat i on. Us e d to extend range of rheostat by alternately
adding o r removing a s e ries res i stor; also for motor reversal.
Availab l e on any m o del rheosta t. Toggl e Type Numbe r s Swit c h Rat i ng With Std. lug s W i th Extra lug 1 2 5 V. AC ar DC *c.c. End *c. End *c.c. End *c. End SPST-N.O., t 6A 355 455 357 457 SPST-N.C.,t
6A 375 475 377 477 OPOT , 6A 360 460 363 463 SPOT, 3A 346 446 348 448 SPO T, 12A 346A 446A 348A 4 4 8 A OPDT, t5A, AC 360 A 460A 363A 463A 'Re la t i on observed t:om knob end o r shatt. doc kw ise or cou nie r-clockwise. tSwitch cx>S i tioo w h en r heostat arm i s on lug. Dwe ll Oper. *c.c. Ead *c. End 3550 3750 3750 3550 360 0 3600 3460 3460 346AD 346 A D 360A D 360AO Sensitive
Switches Description:
A basic size , or a small size , sensit i ve sw i tch and actuator are mounted by means of a bracket and operated by a lever or cam attached to the rheostat
shaft or contact arm. Available
on any mode l. As listed in the table , the mechanism
can be arranged to opera t e the s witch at ei t her end of rotation , or at any inte r mediate point. When ordering the latter type , the point of t i on (and tolerance
on location)
must be specified
in degrees , as well as t he type of switch. Switch Rating Notes: Fo r tungsten fi l ament lamp loads the size B switch rating is 30A. i nrush and normal 3A. A size BA switch is also available
rated at 20A. and lamp l oad of 75A. inrush , 1 OA. normal; ordered by adding A to the Type No. Special SPOT switches for 125\/. DC with rating of 1 OA., non-i nductive circu i t , c an be specified
by adding MT to Type No. 381 or 481. Sw i tch Description
S i ze D i mensio n s Term i na l s Trad e N1me ar Equ i v. B Solder lugs, std. Micro Swrtch Basic v 1%{ x %" x '&#xa5;.tt" Sc r e w s, st d. Mi c r o Swi t ch V-3 OT Screws , std. M icro Switc h OT-2 R 0 So l der lugs, std. Licon 22-104 S M 2&#xa5;.u" x 2%/' x W 1 Solder lug s, std. M icro 1 S M 1
J" *.1 ., , ... / ., 
EC 62663 2 , Att. 1, Pg. 171 of 2 6'f<EPDRI ND.: Rt:P-424-608-kP1
REVISION: 03 -----------Rheostat Additional
Fe'mutlJs
CJHMITE Dead-Lug Off-Position
Fig. 59 Model Hwith Type 351 Off-Position
CORE MADE WITH DEPRESSION
AT THIS POINT TO MAKE CONTACT SNAP OFF LUG ONTO INSULATION
--,fe1EJllmi
Application:
To open the rheostat circuit at the high ance p o sition. For light-duty
and medium resistance
values. Description:
The resistance
winding is disconnected
at one lug so that the circuit is opened as the contact passe s onto the lug. This is the simplest construction. For fine wire rheostats , or units for heavy current or frequent adjustment , Type 353 (this page) is recommended. Clockwise
End Position (as illustrated)
.... Type No. 351 Counterclockwise
End Position. . . . . . . . . Type No. 451 \ Snap-Action
Off-Position
} . Application:
The most popular form for general service. Opens the rheostat circuit at either the high or low ance end. Descri p tion: The circuit is opened as the contact brush snaps i nto an insulated
notch next to the lug. Provides definite indexing action. Additional
Detent: The lug at the off-position end of the windin g can be provided with an embossed ridge which provid es a detent effect on the rotation to signal the operator (by sense of feel) the approach to the off position. Cut-Off Lug: The projecting
part of the lug at the offpositio n can be omitted on any style off-position
when specified
on order. Add " COL'' suffix to Type Number. location Std. With (from Wire Side View) Type No. Detent C l ockwise End 352 352A C o unter-cl ockwise End 452 452A Dead-Section
Off-Position
Application:
To open the rheostat circuit at either the high or low resistance
position. Used mostly for medium duty apparatus
type applications
where no indicated
off-position
is desired. Description:
The circuit is opened as the contact brush \ passes off the lug onto an insulated
section at the same j level-otherwise
similar to Fig. 60. Position at Right (Standard)
............ Type No. 353 Position at Left (Opposite)
.............
Type No. 453 Manufacturing
Company Fig.60: ModelHwith
Type352 Off-Position
OFF-POSITION
Fig. 61: Modell with Switching
Lugs Off-Position
Ratings Toggle switches should be used generally
for line voltage applications
and direct current use above 20 volts. The exact current and voltage rating of an off-position
depends on the specific circuit in which it is used. The use of a capacitor
for spark suppression
is generally
helpful on direct current. Switching
Lugs Application:
The addition of switching
lugs to a rheostat is not for the purpose of an off-position
but rather to add a tap switch action at the end of the rheostat wind i ng so as to achieve the effect of a special tapered wind i ng of a type not otherwise
possible.
Description:
As shown in Fig. 61, several insulated
lugs , to the number desired, are located near the end of the rheostat rotation. They are to be connected
to external resistances
which are switched into the circuit by the rheostat contact brush. If Switching
Lugs are required, advise quantity and placement.
BRIDGED GAP AND 360&deg; WINDINGS FOR UNLIMITED
ROTATION Fig. 62: ModelNwith
bridge for limited rotation Switching
Lugs .................
Code Word: ZAPIN Rheostats
can be constructed
without stops and with a track between the ends of the windin.g to provide for unlimited
rotation. Rheostats
can also be made with 360&deg; cores and continuous
winding, with taps as required. Bridged Gap Feature ............. Code Word: BRIGA 360&deg; Winding Feature ............ Code Word: CIRWI 27 
"" , EC 62 1)-(3-'.),2--:Att 0 f 2 6-fEPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
--, ' * ' -'-'=' * -REVISION:
03 .. , . ; i l; . ; . i ];l , I '* it I l/ I,\ i' I ,, I j* ' "' !r ,. .1 "1 ,l ::1 *t ll l -' 28 Rheostat Additional
Fealures OHMITE Fig.63 Rheostat with less than standard winding angle Rheostats
can be supplied with winding spaces and angles of rotation less than standard. The wattage rating of such rheostats
is reduced approximately
in proportion . For example, a Model J rheostat, 50 watts rat i ng, when provided with a winding of 180&deg; from center of lug to center of lug , would be reduced to 180/300 x 50, or 30 watts rating. The rotation specified
is from stop to stop , which is approximately
15&deg; more (varying with the model) than the degrees occupied by the winding alone, because of the width of the terminal lugs. Less than Standard Rotation Code Word: and Winding Feature ..................... LESWI Special Stops Rheostats
can be supplied with a fixed or an adjustable
stop limit i ng the angle of rotation to any desired part of the total possible rotation. Generally, such rheostats
are used where it is desired to leave a certain amount of res i stance in the circuit at all times. However; a standard rheostat and separate resistor are often to be recommended. An adjustable
stop increases
the tion behind the panel by approximately
Y 2". Advise Fixed Minimum Stop Feature, All Models .... Placement
Adjustable
Stop Feature, Advise Back of Panel-All
Models .............. placement
For Adjustable
Stop Feature, Advise Front of Panel-Models
P to U only ....... placement
Tapped Windings Rheostats
can be supplied with taps at any point or points on the winding. The tap is usually a lug of the same dimensions
as the regular terminals. An adjustable
tap can be provided, also. Rheostats
with lower than normal torque are sometimes
wanted when they are to be remotely controlled
and operated by very small motors. Low torque is accomplished by eliminating
friction at the center-lead
by ting the compression
spring and using a flexible shunt connection
to the contact (see Flexible Shunt). The torque for any given rheostat model will be somewhat greater on low resistance
units than on high resistance
units. Low Torque Feature ............. Code Word: LOTOR REDUCED TORQUE RHEOSTATS
Rheoslat Approx. Rheostat Approx. Model Torque Model Torque H 1.5-3 oz. in. p 1.25-2.25 lb. i n. J 2-3.5 oz. in. N 1.25-2.25 lb. i n. G 2-4 OZ. in. R 1.25-2.2 5 lb. i n. K 3-5 oz. in. T 1.25-2.25 l b. i n. L 3-6 oz. in. u 1.25-2.25 l b. i n. Manufacturing
Company Fig. 64: Rheostat with flexible shunt and low torque Flexible Shunts Rheostats
can be equipped with a flexible shunt directly connecting
the moving contac t and the center-lead. This is sometimes
called for when the circuit requires that even minute variations
in slip-ring to center-lead ance be eliminated. Type No. Flexible Shunt (S Amps. Max.) For H, J, G, K, L ..... 204 Flexible Shunt (Over S Amps.) J, G, K, L, P, N, R, T, U . 203 Quick-Connect
Terminals
Terminals
to receive standard female " quickconnectors" or " push-on" connectors
can be pro-vided on most rheostats. Fig. 65: Typical rheostat with In addition to single termi-terminals
for push-on connection
nations, a double o r twin terminal permitting
two connections
at one terminus is also available. TermJnal t For Width Number Rheostats
:Y,e'' 5 3-1 8 8 H W' 53-2 5 0* H, J, G , K,L , P,N , R, T, U '!." (Twin) 53-25DT H, J , G , K, L , P, N , A. T, U *53.25 0 a nd 53-2 5 B T a l so ava il ab l e. T h re e-w a y typ e-acce p ts s t an d a rd Yi" f em al e q uick con n ec t or, 6-3 2 sc r ew and nut o r sol d e r ing. tProvi d e<I a t al l thr ee meos l at connec t loos un l ess otherwise
s p ecified. Other Terminals
Model H rheostats
can be provided with special size terminals
with .156" diameter holes to receive No. 6 screws , maximum. Terminals
for No.6 Screw on Model H ......... Type S6 Welded Nuts on Terminals
Rheostats
can be provided wit h nuts welded to the nals to permit screwdriver
fastening
of connections. Screws are not provided unless specified. Positions
are specified
from wire-side
view. Nuts are No. 6-32 on Model H and No. 8-32 on l arger models. Clockwise
lug and center lead ............. Type SSA Counter-clockwise
lug and center lead ....... Type SSB All three terminals
....................... Type SSC Terminal Bolts Description
Cit. No. Fo r M odel H-3 se ts eac h C{)ns is ting o t 1 No. 2-56 x W' sc rew, 2 h ex. n uts and 1 lockwas he r . . .... .. 5 0 7 5 For M odels J , G , K o r L-3 se ls e a ch consis li ng o f: I N o. 8-32 x W' sc r ew , 2 hex. n u t s, 1 e ach fl a t , cup a nd lock wa s hers . .................. 5 0 77 For M odels P, N , R , T, U-3 se t s ea c h cons i sting of: 1 N o. 8-32 x %" sc r e w, 2 hex. nut s , 1 ea c h fl a t , c up and l ock w a sh e r s . . . . . . . . . . ..... 5079 
' } g. 7 --REVISION:
03 Rheostat Knobs,
OH MITE Rheos t at Knobs Knobs are made of black plastic and fasten by means of two screwdriver
slotted set screws (except No. 5102 , 5103 , 5 150 and 5151 which have one screw). Knobs can be ord e red with hexagon socket set screws by adding suffix -A to catalog number. Indicating
lines are white filled; p ointers are bright plated. Any knob can be used with any model of rheostat having the corresponding
shaft d i ameter. Knob No. 5116 is recommended
for general us e where a small bar type knob is wanted. Knobs must b e specified
on order; when desired. Knob Description
Dia. Bar Knob. 2 Y." long -Bar Knob , 1 Y." long -Handwh ee l with P ointer 3 W' Handwhee l withou t Point er 3Y." H a ndwhe e l with P ointe r 3 Y." Handwheel
w itho ut Pointe r 3Y." F i nger-Grip
w i th Pointer 1%" F inger-Grip w i thout Pointer 1%1/ F inge r-Grip w i th P o i n t er 2%" F inger-G rip without Pointer 2%" Bar Knob, 4&#xa5;.'' l ong-Requires
cross-pin and tapped hole in shaft -Bar Knob, 1 'h" long -Finger-G rip without Pointer 2%" F inger-Grip
w i th Pointer 2%" Bar Knob , 1 'h" long, AN-3220-3 M ilitary Style-Dull F inish -Fi nger-G r ip 1 'h" Finger-Grip %" ""D"-Shaped
hole to deep llat Fig.67: Standard Dials Typical rheostat dial Rheostat Dials For Rheostat H ,J , G, K, L P, N, R, T, U C , E Hole Pointer C*t. D i a. R*dlus No. W' 1 W' 5102 W' %" 510 3 %" 2%,'' 5104 %" -5 1 05 1.14" 2%," 5 1 06 Y." -5107 'A" 1%," 510 9 !,.{" -5110 W' 5 1 11 1A" -5 112 %" 1 o/io" 51 1 5 Yc" y.11 5116 %" -5124 %" 11%:z" 5 1 30 *y.11 %" 5 1 36 W' -5150 W' -5 1 51 Dia l Catalog Diam. No. 2 3/,6 11 5000 5'h'' 500 1 1 Y.'' 5 007 Manufacturing
Company Rheostat Mounting Brackets Fig. 68: Rheostat mounting brackets and insulating
washer no. 6028 Mounting Brackets are made of zinc-plated
steel. They furn i sh a conven i ent mounting for units located and controlled
on the rear of a panel , in an enclosure
or for "breadboard" construction.
HORIZONTAL
TYPE Mtg. Mtg. Hole For Models Hol e For Width Height Cat No. Cent ers Dia. Max. Screw H , J 3" No. 8 2'i{6" 1 1 1A6 11 6520 G , K, L 5" %" No. 8 4%&11 2 o/ie" 652f VERTICAL TYPE Mtg.Hole Height Mtg. For to Hole for Models Hol e Dia. Max. Shafi Size Cit No. Centers Screw Cente r H , J, G 1%," %," No.6 1%" W' 6522" H , J,G 1%," o/32'1 No.6 1%" o/a"t 6523 *s upplied w i th insula tin g fibre bushing , Cat. No. 6028, as illus tr a t ed , for %" d1a bushing of r heos tals, t o provide additio n a l in su l a tion to gr ound. tlnclud es %" d i a. h o l e at 'h cente r for standard non-turn washer. Shoulder Type Mounting Nuts Fig.69 Shoulder nuts are used when it is desired to have the end of a screw-driver
slotted shaft below the top of the mounting nut. The nuts are tapped 3/a"-32 and require a 7/1s" d i ameter hole in the panel. Refer to page 17 for more information
on use. Shoulder Nut, "C" = 7/32" ...*..*....... Cat. No. 6056 Shoulder Nut, "C" = 15/32 11 ************** Cat. No. 6057 Non-Turn Washers PO SITION IZ *O SITIO* 9 =@: POS ITI OH) *d tTAN ... HOLE I N PAN EL ---).. , POS IT ION 6 ,...-": (
; '-" \..._) ,_.. S U ltFACE*IS*lf S) --1&-Fig. 70: How non-turn washer is used. Dials a r e made of alum i num with the figures and lines natural aluminum on an etched black background.
Dials are calibrated
to indicate the approximate
percentage
of resistance
in the circuit (clockwise
increase).
Dials No. 5000 a n d 5007 are secured by the rheostat mounting nut. Di al No. 5001 is separately
fastened by means of ) No. 6 s c rews, or it can be held by the rheostat mounting ./ screws. To prevent rheostats
which are mounted by a single ing, such as the Models H, J, G, K, (and sometimes
L) from turning on the panel, they are provided with a washer which has a projecting
lug to fit into an additional
hole in the panel. The lug can be ordered located at any 90&deg; position, and it can be bent down if not wanted. Supplied in " 6 o'clock" position unless otherwise
specified . Mounting Nuts Standar d N ut: %"*32 th readed ... ac r oss f lats by :y,," thick , zinc plated s1eel .... Cat. No. 6500 Standard Non-Turn Washer-"B" = 5/3'1." ... Cat. No. 5050 Long Tip Non-Turn Washer-"B" = V4'' .... Cat. No. 5051 Narrow Tip Non-Turn Washer-"B" = 5/32 11 x Vs" .................... Cat. No. 5052 29 
-f E C 62 06 32 , Att. 1 , P g. 1 7 4 of 2 6 fU:POR I Nb.: REP-424-00B-RP1
REVISION: 03 PAGE 121 O F 139 OHMITE ; Rheostat Cages '; *I *'' M ,] Fig. 71: Table-mounted
cage for Model J with Series Plug Terminal No. 607 Fig. 72: Table mounted cage for Model R with Terminal No. 604 Fig. 73: Typical cages for panel mounting.
Application:
A ventilated
enclosure
should be used when a rheostat is to be mounted where there is possibi l ity of mechanical
injury or likelihood
of human contact with electrically
" live" parts. Cages also provide a convenient
means of table top mounting and are a necessity
for portable applications. Class i ficat i ons of cages per NEMA definitions
are given under that heading. Dustproof
cag e s are frequently
used where there are unusual amounts of dust or particles
in the air: Cage Wattage Ratings: Rheostats
in ventilated
enclosures
can be used at full wattage , but rheostats
in dustproof
enclosures
must generally
be operated at reduced age to avo i d overheating
caused by the absence of lation. Rheostats
in circuits where the ratio of maximum to minimum current exceeds 2 can be operated at full ing, but rheostats
where the current ratio is less , should be operated at not over 50% of the free air wattage. Manufacturing
Company Cage Types: A variety of qages are available
to meet different
requirements.
cages are the General Purpose Ventilated
Type (;pv or Dustproof
Type GPO. Lightweight
Sealed Type LWD, Explosion-proof
EXP, Weather-proof
or Watertight
Type WP, Drip-proof
Type DP, Gastight Type GTR , Hermetically
Sealed (Gas or Air Filler) Type HSG and Fluid Fi l led HSF are also available
i n some sizes. Standard General Purpose Cages Description:
Ven ti lated cages have perforated
met a l sides and are gray wrinkle finished.
Dustproo f cages are similar but without ventilating
holes. TERMINAL TYPES Cogos con bo supplied with termlnols
as l isted below Terminal Ava i lable fype On No. B inding Posts-2 Termin als L,P,N,R,T,U
601 Binding Post s-3 Termin a l s L,P,N,R,T,U
602 W ire L eads-2 Asbesto s Insulated
W ire s , 6 inc h es l ong All 603 W ire Leads-3 Asbestos l nsulale d Wir es. 6 inches long All 622 BX Cable-2 Conduct0<, 6 i nches long P.N.R,T ,U 604 BX Clamp and 6" Wire Lead s P,N , R,T,U 605 Pipe Fl ange for 'h" Cond u it, wilh 2 Wire Lead s , 6 Inches long L ,P, N , R ,T,U 606 Line Cord-6 ft., Heate r (Type HPD) with Series Plug All 6or Li ne Cord-6 ft., Hea t er Type wi th Rubber Covered Cord (T ype HSJ an d Series Plug) All 607R' Line Cord-6 ft., Heavy Duty R u bb e r Covered with Heavy D uty Plug A ll 628 Lin e Cord-6 ft., Heavy Duty Rubber Cove re d with G rounding Terminal Plug All 623 90&deg; Elbow " Condulet" f i tt ing w it h 3*wire lead s P , N , A ,T,U 624 Outlet Box 4" x 4" with 3 T e rminal Strip P,N,R , T,U 625 Outlet Box 4" x 4" with 6 Terminal Strip P,N,R ,T, U 626 Screw and N ut Te r m i nals-3, with Coverp l ate and 2 dia. hole for BX fitting, etc. P,N,R, T,U 627 " Speci fy No. 607G o r 60 7G R i f grounding
plug is required. STANDARD VENTILATED
AND DUSTPROOF
RHEOSTAT CASES ... ; 30 For Rheostat Model t H Cage Diameter . ... 2:Y," Height or Depth Behind Panel . .. 2" M ounting B ol t Rad ius . l Y,," M ounting Bolt Slots (120&deg; Apart) fo r Screw Size No. 1 0 App r oximate Weight , Pou n ds (without rheostat) . 0.18 Table Mounted Ventilated
Cage Cat. No .. 6550 Table M oun ted Dusproof C a ge Cat No. 6570 Equ ipment ..................... . .. ... A *eack*of*Panel Ventilated
Cage Cat. No .. 6560 *Back*of*Pan el Du stp roof Ca g e Cat N o. 6540 E qu ipment B " Mode ls H. J, G. K , L mou n t b y me a ns of rh eostat bus h i n g on panels up to 3/,6 th ick. Models P. N, R, T, U m oun t b y means ol 3 screws on pa n e l s up to I'>" t h i ck except 1" o n Mode ls P and N. tFor Mode l E rheostat cages , see pages 9 and 29 . J 3'-'" 2" 1 1 o/i1" No. 1 0 0.26 655 1 657 1 A 6561 6541 B & K l p N 3W' 3:Y." 4 W' 7'h" 7'h" 2%" 2%" 2%" 31'.'' 3Y." 2W' 2Y." 2%" 4Y." 4 1,{'' No. 10 N o. 10 No. 10 1/c'' 0.41 0.4 1 0.53 1.25 1.25 6552 6 553 6554 6555 6556 6572 65 7 3 657 4 6575 6576 A A A c c 6562 6563 6564 6565 6566 6542 6543 6544 6545
6546 B B B c c Equi p ment A: T e rmi nal No. 603, K n ob No. 5116, D i a l No. 5000. E q uip m ent B: T e r m in a l N o. 60 3 , K n ob N o. 5 1 50. Equipment
C: T ermina l N o. 604, Knob N o. 5105 A T u 91/," 13&#xa5;,," 13&#xa5;,," 4 Y." 4 1;{e" 4 1o/i," 5"h," 7%" 7%" V." W' W I 2.0 6.8 6.8 6557 6558 6559
6577 6578 6579
c c c 6567 6568 6569 6547 6548 6549 c c c 
-------------*------* E C 62 06 32 , Att. 1 , Pg. 175 of 2 6'fEPORT NO.: REP-424-008
-R P1 REVISION:
03 \ _) Rheostat Cage s PAGE 1 22 OF 139 OH MITE Manu f acturing Company NEMA-NEC Enclosure
Class i fications
The " National Electrical
Manufacturers
Association" (NEMA) Industrial
Standards
IC-2-128 provides for a variety of enclosures
to meet differen t ambient conditions. NEMA NEC Listed below are the princ i pal types, the correspond
i ng National Electrical
Code designations (from article 500) and the equivalent
Oh mite type designations. (Nat i onal Electrlc1I (N1tlon1I
Electrical
DESCRIPTION
PER STANDARDS
OHMIT! TYPE DESIGNATIONS
Mf g. Association) Code) TYPE CLASS CLASS GROUP TYPE DESCRIPTION
I Ge n eral Purpose V entilated
o r Cl ose d GPV Sheet M etal En closure with Perf orated M eta l (D ustp r oof) (o r GPO) Sides I A Semi D ust-light
GP O Shee t M etal E nclosure v ll l&I V D us t-T ight Heavy W alle d Cast E nclosu r e wit h T hreaded VII I I C, D H azardous L ocations (Gas) EXP Co ver F astening (or Ground Join t s) IX 11 ,F&G II E , F&G H aza r do u s L oca t io ns (D ust) "Explosion-Proor
* I ll W ea t her-Resistant
WR Cast Enclosu r e with Gasketed Cover and IV Watertight
Shalt XII Industr i al Endosure-Dirt
and Oilproof N ote: As s i ze.
delivery time, and cost vary g rea tly w i th th e type o f enclosure , the exact type r equi r ed should be ca r efu ll y considered
before making a selection.
Series Plug Terminal -=tt+J--------_; : ----------.. I : I F i g. 74: Ser i es Plug No. 6050 for Terminals
No. 607 and No. 607R App li c a tion: For connect i ng a rheostat (or resistor)
in series with a l oad and the line by s i mply plugg i ng the load attachment
plug i nto the series plug wh i ch itself is plugged into the power receptacle. Also available
with ground i ng terminal.
Description:
The series p l ug consists of a bakelite body w i th a receptacle
in the top and prongs on the bottom. The series plug is connected
to the rheostat by means of a line cord. ' Series Plug only ...................... Cat.No. 6050 Series Plug with Grounding
Pin . . Cat. No. 6050G Series Plug with 6 ft. Heater Cord . . . . . . Type No. 607* Series Plug with 6 ft. Rubber Cord ....... Type No. 607R* 'Spec i fy No. 607G or 607GR i f grounding
plug is r equired. Heat or Other Control Rheostats
Wattage of Dev i ce Rheost1t To B e Contralln
Control Wins Volts Cal No. 40-65 11 5 S R C65 85-100 115 S RC100 120-150 115 S RC150 175-220 11 5 SRC220 300-350 115 SRC350 430-500 115 SRC500 C1ge Dimensions
Dia. Height 3W' 2" 31,i" 2" 2W' 3 o/." 2'%'' 4 W' 2W' 7W' 3Y." N et Weight lbs. .58 .58 .93 1.05 1.63 2.25 Application:
To control the temperature
i nvo l ved in heatsealing , wax and solder pots , soldering
irons , furnaces and for other uses within the specified
current range. Description:
The rheostats
listed are mounted in rated, gra y w rinkle fin i shed meta l cages with kn ob and dial, Series Plug and six-foot heater type cord as described
above. Designed to reduce power in load by approximately 50% maximum , for 115V. use. 31 
 
REV I S I ON: 03 *] Rheostat Cages PAGE l 230Fl39 OH MITE f 1 j '" f f l*.* !' \ 32 Fig. 76: A special explosion-proof
rheostat enclosure
Explosion-Proof
Enclosures
Oh mite explosion-proof
enclosures
are primarily
for use in hazardous
locations
where the atmosphere
may carry explosive
gases or dust. . These enclosures
meet the requirements
of NEMA Type VII , C l ass I, Haza r dous Locations (gas). (NEC Class 1, Group C and D); and NEMA Type IX , C l ass II, Groups F and G, Hazardous
Locations (dust), (NEC Class 11 , Groups E , F and G). They also meet the requirements
of NEMA Type V, Dust-tight, (NEC C l ass Ill and I V). The enclosures
are made of thick-walled
castings with accurate l y ma c hined, tight titting covers and tight titting shaft. If exp l osive mixtures penetrate
the enclosure
and a r e ignited by a spark or heat, the flame will be extinguished
by coo l ing as the products of combustio n go through the small clearance
openings, thus preventing
ign i tion of the explosive
mixture on the outside of the enclosure. sures for surface mounti n g or back of panel, can be supp l ied for Models H to U single or two in tandem. Further information
will be supplied for specific requests. 'Hermeticall
y' Sealed Rheostats
To completely
isolate rheostats
from t h e ambient sp h ere , rheostats
can be supplied in 'hermetical
l y' sealed enc l osures. Terminals
are b r ought out t h rough g l ass seals. The shaft is sealed by a special 0-ri n g. The enc l osures may be filled with dry gases or various liquids. Recommendations
w ill be made for specific cases. Man u facturin g Company Sealed Light w eight Enc l osures For Rheostat *M od els E, H, J , G , or K Fig. 77 Compact enclosures , made from lightweight
drawn cups , and equipped with two or three screw term i na l s (or 3 solde r lu gs), as requ i red , are a v ailable for the Model E H J , G, and K rheostats. They are dust-tight, b ut not
ically sea l ed. The enclosures
are permanently
closed by a rolled double seam. The Model E , Hand J enclosures
correspond
to the sizes called for in Militar y
tions M I L-R-22 and Models Hand J as included in MIL-R-67 49. When units are desired to meet the MIL specifications , they should be ordered by th e code designatio n of the pertinent
specificat
i on. Commercial
types a r e listed in the tab le. Unless o t herwise specified , stats ordered with off-position
will have t h ree termina l s. *Model C normall y enclosed;
M odel E stocked enclosed and u n enclosed-see
page 9. Model D es cript i on Avg. Wt. C at. No. With Rhea. Terminals
D ia. length P ounds E 2 1%." 1\1,," .0 6 6 584 A E 3 H'&/1 .06 6 5 84 8 H 2 l o/." l o/." .3 0 6 5 80A H 3 1&#xa5;." l o/." .3 0 658 08 J 2 2\4'' 1%" .4 5 6581A J 3 2'h" 1%" . .4 5 658 1 8 G 2 3'li'&" 21!." .7 5 6 582 A G 3 3't'is" 21!." .75 658 2 8 K 2 2V." .9 0 6 58 3A K 3 211." .90 6583 8 " Note. Bushings fo r Y. thick panel, max., ('h" f or M ode l E) supp l ied as standard.
T wo t er m i na l s wil l be connec.l ed /o r counter-c l oc kw ise i n crease o f resista n ce, a s v i ewed f r om k n o b , u nless oth erw i se o rd er e c. When solde rin g l u gs a r e w an t e d. th ey mu s t be s p eci fied; ad d s uffix L t o Ca t. No. R h eosta t o h ms, current , etc., mu st be speci f ied. 
EC 620632 Att 1 Pg 177 Of 26-REPORTNO.: REP-424-008-RP1 ' * ' * /'. REVISION: 03 -Motor Speed Control PAGE 124&deg;F 139 OHMITE Application:
Rheostat control of the speed of fractional
and i nt eg ral horsepower
motors is the most widely cable me thod , is gene ra lly the simplest and is easily added t o existing installations.
Ohmite rheostats
provide close, s mooth, compact , convenient
motor-speed
control in cou n tless industrial
and appliance
uses, such as: Arc Lamps Respirators
Blue-P r inters Dental and Medical Equipment
F i lm Pr i nters Flame Cutters Motion Picture Projecto rs Mach i ne Tools Fans Portable Tools Blower s Laboratory
Mixers Pumps Model Trains Unit Heaters Advantages
of Ohmite Rheostats: Smooth , close, contin u ously variable control, permanently
good ance , freedom from deteriorat
i on , and compactness
make Ohmite rheostats
ideal for this services.
All Mo t ors Not Speed Controllable:
While all types of direct current motors can be speed-controlled , only a few kinds o f alternating
current motors are controllable , hence it is essent i al to obtain the correct type of A.C. motor ) when speed control i s required.
Speed controllable
motors ' are list e d in the table on page 31. The f o llowing alternating
current motors are not speed control l able: Split Phase, Repulsion
Start-Induction
Run, Repulsion-Induction, Capacitor
Start and Run (except for special fan duty motors), Capacitor
Start-Induction
Run , Synchr o nous, and Squirrel Cage. No type of speed control is g e nerally available
for standard models of these motors because of the use of centrifugal
starting switches , inherent constant speed or other design details. Choice of Motor Depends on the Load: Only the universal motor (a form of series-wound
motor) i s available
for service on both alternating
and direct current. It is a high-speed
type of motor (3000 to 15 , 000 R.P.M.) with strong s tarting torque. The speed var i es widely with change s in the load. Generally,.the rheostat setting for a given speed will be slightly different
on A.C. than D.C. because the characteristics
of a series motor change with the type of current. Resistors
are often connected
in the circuit on D.C. to make the characteristics
more nearly identical
with the A.C. characterist
i cs. The shunt wound direct current motor has a very slight change of speed with loa d s. Motor manufacturers
find it necessary
to change the i nheren t characteristics
such as starting torque , running torque, et c., to suit different
applications
of the same )motor and therefore
rheostats, too , must be designed to / Manufacturing
Company suit each particular
application. In general , motors of similar rating made by different
manufacturers
require somewhat different
rheosta t s for best control. Fig. 79: An application
of a rheostat in a special cage for motor speed control Speed Control Laws for D.C. Motors: Speed is tional to the voltage across the armature and inversely
proportional
to the field flux. Torque (turning moment expressed
in pound-feet
or ounce-inches)
is proportional
to the product of the ture current and the field strength. These laws apply to all forms of direct current motor speed control and help explain the principles
underlying
the different
control circuits. Different
Types of Control: Several different
types of control are shown in the table on page 31. A study of this table will he l p to show that the choice of contro l depends on: 1. Whether A.C. or D.C. or universal
operation
is required. 2. The type of motor. 3. The type and amount of load. 4. The exactness
of speed control des ir ed. 5. The speed range to be covered. Another circu i t , not shown , uses two rheostats
connected
in tandem, one in series with the armature and one in parallel with it. This circuit is used to produce very s l ow speed control of shunt wound motors. In addition to the circuits shown, Oh mite rheostats
are util!zed on the of speed control which are used on A.C. motors of integraffiorse-power
sizes. There are also multi-speed variations
of the circuits shown which ut ili ze Ohmite Power Tap switches and Ohmite Fixed Resistors
; also governor-controlled
motors which utilize Oh m it e Fixed Resistors. Oh mite VT Variable Transformers
can also be used on AC; applications , or on DC in conjunction
with a rectifier:
33 
( E C *i I !. , t " ,; ;l c t. : I 34 62 06 32 , Att. 1 , Pg. 1 78 of 26 ft:PDRING.!
Rt:P!424-66S-RPI REVISION: 03 -OH MITE Motor Speed Control PAGE 125 OF 139 Manufacturing
Company Rheostats
with Reversing
Switch: Rheostats
with two separate windings and a toggle switch can be supplied for single knob speed control and reversing
of D.C. moto r s. One winding controls forward speed , the other reverse. Rheostats
Individually
Designed:
Loads have been sified for general calculation
as (a) Machine Duty , where the current is assumed 80% at 50% speed , and (b) Fan Duty , where the load current is assumed as reduced to 40% of maximum at 50&deg;/p of full load speed. Fig. 80: A reversing-type , speed control rheostat Type of Control I. SER IE S RHEOSTAT II. ARMATURE SHUNT RHEOSTAT Ill. COMB I NED ARMATURE SHUNT ANO S ER IES RHEOSTAT S IV. ROTOR SERIES R HEO STA T S V. F I ELD RHEOSTAT V I. ARMATURE SER I E S RHEOSTAT VI I. COMB I NED FI EL D ANO ARMATURE SERI E S RHE OS TA TS VIII. A U TO-T RANSFORMER
WITH TAP SW I TCH Type of Motor D.C. Series or S h unt D.C. P e r manent M agnet Universal
A.C. Series A. C. Repu l sion A. C. Shaded Po l e D.C. Series A.C. Series Un i versal D.C. Series A.C. Series Un i versal A.C. Polyphase
W ound R o t o r D.C. Shunt D.C. Shunt D.C. Shunt Specia l A.G. Capac i t or Mo t or Whi l e loads have been grouped arbitrarily
in the above two classifications, eac h application
varies from th ese theoretical
values to such an extent that for the best control , the rheostats
must be designed for the particular
application. This means that the actual currents and resistances under load must be obtained to permit proper design; the nameplate
data from the motor is generally
insuffic i ent. General Characteristics
of Control Most used for fractional
H.P. appliances, A.C. or Universal , where the load is consta n t or variations
in speed with load are unimportant.
Speed w i ll vary wi d e l y with the load. 50% r eduction of f ull load speed is m aximum u sed o n l arger mot ors-more on smaller motors-depe
n ds on type of load. R educes speed but mai n tains t o r que. Speed w ill vary l ess w i de l y with th e l oad than w it h Ser i es Contro l. 50% reduction
of full load speed is maximum used on large r motors-more on s m alle r motors-depe
n ds on type of load. W i dest speed r ange-maintains
torque-u seful wher e load varies. Spe ed will rema i n f airly constant regardless
of loa d. Rang e of 5 t o 1 or m ore is possib le depend ing on type of load. Standard me t hod f or w ound roto r motors-also
used o n sing l e-phase type. Speed will vary w i th the l oad. 50% r ed u ctio n in speed is the m aximum genera ll y used. Greate r r ed u ctio n is poss i ble. Most u s ed type f o r i ntegra l H.P. i ndustrial
app l ica ti ons. Speed rema in s f a irl y consta nt a t any load. Speed increases
w i th added r esi s t ance. Range depends on motor design. F iel d must never be opened. U sed to lower speed. Speed will vary with load. Speed decreases
as res i stance i s added. 50% maximum on la rger motors. Used for w i dest speed range. Speed varia t i o n w ith load d ependin g o n posit i on o f control. Speed range depends on mot or design. U sed fo r fan type duty or other low starting torque , co n stant type of lo ads. will vary w i th load. Speed range depends on mol o r design. / \ J 
6 2 O 6 3 2 Att 1 p 17 9 0 f 2 6 'fEPbRT Nb.: REP-424-008-RP1 ,\.... ' . ' g. REVISION:
03 ----------------
Motor Driven RheostafsE
126&deg;F 139 OH MITE ), i ) Fig. 81: Typical Ohmite motor-driven
rheostat assembly Ohm i te rheostats, either single or in tandem, can be motor o perated under remote control. While customers
can adapt
of their own to the rheostats , Oh mite offers standard reversible
motor drives assembled
to the rheost a t of your choice. These standard drives encompass a s election of traverse speeds designed to meet the most frequent requirements
and faster delivery can be provided on these. The standard drives are available
with 1 15-vo l t DC or AC motors in traverse speeds as follows: Concentric
Control Rheostat Assemblies
Fig. 82: T a ndem assembly with rheostats
independ e ntly controlled
Two rheostats
can be separately
controlled
by means of concentrically
located knobs. This may be done for convenienc e i n operation , to conserve panel space , or where it may b e desired to use one rheostat as a vernier for another: The two rheostats
are mounted on a tandem assembly frame w i th the shaft of the rear unit extending
through the hollow shaft of the first. A hand-wheel, or knob, controls /the rheostat closest to the mounting panel and a smaller knob controls the other rheostat.
DC Motor (Seconds)
3.4 10*1 2 40-50 100-120 Manufacturing
Company TRAVERSE SPEED AC Motor (Seconds)
4 8 16 30 45 The standard arrangement
includes the necessary
limit switches and cams to stop traverse at the end of the rotational
arc. Reversal is accomplished
by moving a 3-position
control switch to the "reverse" position.
Users may also specify additional
switches for programming
assoc ia ted equipment
during the traverse of the rheostat.
Non-Standard
Drives: Ohmite can adapt motor drives to meet applications
where the requirements
are so special that the standard motor driven assemblies
are not suitable. Such requirements
could include special speeds, 360 degree rotation using " bridged-gap" rheostats (page 24). self-revers
i ng rotation , special auxiliary
programming
switches, slip clutches , combinations
of rheostats
and other controls such as transformers
or composition
potentiometers
and other variations. Complete specifications
in such cases must be submitted
to Oh mite for engineering
evaluat i on and quote. Any combination
of mode l s of rheostats
can be mounted for concentric
control , with the larger rheostat preferably
next to the panel. When the largest rheostat is no larger than a Model L , the hollow shaft is 1/4" diameter and the through-shaft
is 3/1s" diameter.
When the larger rheostat is a Model P, N, R, T, or U, the standard hollow shaft is%" diameter and the through shaft is 1/4" diameter.
A hollow shaft of 112" diameter and through-shaft
of 3/s" diameter can be supplied also. The tandem assembly can consist of more than two rheostats
with the additional
rheostats
turning with either shafts. Mount i ng dimensions
are lar to an equivaleht
standard tandem assembly. Write for further information
for specific applications. Panel ness must be given. Combinations
with Other Contro l s: Tap switches, low power wafer-type
switches, composition
potentiometers
or variable transformers
can be combined with rheostats
in concentric
control assemblies, with the auxi l iary device operated by the through-shaft. Concentr ic Control T ancem M io . . Code Word: CO NCO 35 _ _J 
" EC . l I f f I '* 36 62 0 632' Att. 1, Pg. 1 s'b of 2 6fl&bkFN6.: F<f:P-424-008-RPI
REVISION: 03 -OHMITE * PAGE 127,.()F 139 Rheostat for Lamp D1mm1ng 120 .,; ... "'100 ... :I! c ..J * 80 .... :c "' :::; ..... 60 z ... "' "' a 40 .... z "' <.> 20 "' "' A. 0 ;; LAMP RESISTANC&#xa3;
-... > ,_a: -*-5 *-... t;;/ f 0 \ v "'/ I . I >< I v \ /VitURRENT
I A <( ..J GI /
I (SCALE AT RIGHT) 1 J I / 'I I I I I /J , ' I .... I ,/ -r EXAMPLE.J-
:[__ ----I ,,..,.,,,,, I *-._ I 20 40 60 80 PER CENT LAMP VOLTAGE I -I I I LIGHT LUNENS ----100 --.,; ... "' ... 400 !i 0 5:! 320 l c ..J ... 240 &deg; ... z ... <.> 160 ... 80 ; :c 0 0 120 s :c "' Fig. 83: Average curves for tungsten filament lamps An Oh mite Rheostat , when connected
in series with an incandescent
l amp, provides ideally smooth, gradual trol of light output from full intens i ty to any desired degree of dimming. Such control is utilized in photography ing of subjects, projection
and contact printers , and safe lights); in medicine and dent i stry (examination
lights); in aviation (i nstrument
lights); in advertising
displays, ter stage lighting, and in other applications. The size and resistance
of the rheostat is determined
by the lamp to be controlled
and the amount of dimming desired. Because a larger rheostat or a tapered winding of more sections is needed for blackout than for 1 % light , important
economies
can often be made if it is ble to open the circuit before blackout.
It is strongly recommended
that the minimum amount of light desired be determined
by a substitution
trial or by measurement
with a photo-electric
light meter, as visual estimates
generally are not sufficiently
accurate. The curves in Fig. 83 show the per cent lamp current , voltage, and resistance, and the per cent required stat ohms for any percentage
of dimming. The curves apply to 115 volt standard tungsten filament lamps and , in general, to any other lower voltage tungsten filament lamp. Rheostats
listed i n the table cover the most mon applications.
They are unmounted
units, taper wound as required. The second letter of the Catalog Number corresponds
to the model, details of which will be found on pages 9 to 13. A knob, as listed on page 26, should be Manufacturing
Company ordered if one is desired. Our Engineering
Department
will be glad to recommend
the proper rheostat for any special application
on
of the following
information
: Lamp type , volts and
current , minimum light (in per cent of maximum).
pnd off-position
if wanted. For uncommon types of lamps, supply a sample for test or a curve of light and current versus volts. lAMP DIMMING RHEOSTATS
lamp Minimum Brilliance
of Light as Percentage
of Full In t ensity Watts 10% 1%
Blackout 25 LHA25 LJ825 LJ C25 LJ D 25 40 LHA40 LJ8 4 0 LGC20 J..K D40 50 LJASO LGBSO LKCSO LKDSO 60 LJA60 L K860 LKC60 LKD60 75 LJA?S LKB75 LKC75 L LD75 1 00 LKA100 LK8100 LKC 1 00 LP D1 00 120 LKA120 L LB120 LPC 1 20 L N D120 150 LKA150 LLB 150 LNC150 LND150 180 LKA180 LNB180 LNC 18 0 L ND180 200 LLA200 LNB200 LNC200 L ND200 &sect;No. 1 'LGAl LNB l LAC 1 LAD1 &sect;No. 2 'LLA2 LRB2 LTC2 LU02 &sect;No. 4 'LNA4 LU84 tLTTC4 tLUUD4 '50o/o light instead ot 1 0%. tTwo rheostats
in tand em. +Light is r educed to '4% and the n t h e circuit is opened by a No. 352 Off-P osi li on. &sect;N umbe r s 1 , 2 an d 4 are p ho t o fl ood lamps which o p e r ate at 250, 500 and 1 000 wans respec t ively. Motor Driven Lamp Dimmers Oh mite rheostats
arranged for motor drive are often used as faders in advert i sing d i splays. Such rheostats
are of the bridged gap type (page 24) for continuous
rotation. Fig. 84 (A) shows a method of using one rheostat to fade between two lamp banks (both going out as the arm passes the center lead). Figure 84 (B) shows a method for gradually
bringing a lamp from out to full on and back to out once every revolution. (Al (8) Fig. 84: Fader circuits arranged for continuous
rotation ) ) I 
E C 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 181 of 2 6 'fEPORT NO.: REP-4 24-008-RP1
REV I S I ON: 03 -CJHMITE .. Rheostats
for Military Specifications
PAGE 1 28 OF 139 , Ohm i te power rheostats
have seen serv i ce i n mi l itary ' applications
for many years. They have established
their noted dependabi l ity in widely dispersed
areas subject to the extremes of environment
from the tropics to the arctic. Ohmite's inert, all ceramic and metal construction
is the reason for the durab i lity and ruggedness
required to meet the exhaustive
test s of the military spec i fications.
All of the styles (sizes) required by the fundamental
rheostat specification , MIL-R-22 (Resistors, Variable , Wirewo u nd , Power Type) from the tiny 5 watt Style RP05 Slotted with locking bushing Flatted with locking bushing Enclosed with locking bushing Fig. 86: Typical locking-type rheostats
supplied under MIL-R-22. F ig. 87: Aircraft Power Rheostats
for MIL-R-6749
Manufacturing
Company Fig. 85: Rheostat sizes furnished
under MIL-R-22 (Model C) to the 1000-watt
RP55 (Model U) are supplied by Ohm i te with the var i ous options requ i red by the military options such as enclosures , locking shafts with slots or flats , off-positions, etc. Oh mite also supplies rheostats
to meet military spec i fication MIL-R-6749
for Aircraft Rheostats. This ficat io n covers 25 and 50-watt enclosed rheostats
used in a ir craft , primarily
for light dimming purposes.
The physical sizes co rr espond to Styles RP11 and RP1 6 of MIL-R-22 with a f e w differencess. The entire specified
range of winding tapers is provided under this specification. To Order: When a QPL item i s required always order by Milita r y Designation , not by Oh mite Type number. Military Wall Designation
Size RP0 50 5 RP06 12.5 RP07 6.25 RP10 25.0 RP 11 12.5 RP 1 5 50 Noles: <D 1,000 ohms, max. Mll-R-22 RHEOSTATS , WIREWOUND
Ohmite Military Type Designation
Model C, RP 16 enclosed Model E RP20 Model E, RP25 enclosed RP30 Model H RP351<D Model H , RP401<D enclosed RP451<D Model J RP501<D R P551<D Mll-R-5749
RHEOSTAT S&#xa9;: AN (Enclosed) AN3155 25 and 50 w a n MIL-R-15109 RHEOSTATS: H I-SHOCK Mod e l s EQl, H@. J, G, K <ll Not app l icable to GAMESA (Canadian equiv. to DESC-E) <ll Al so enclosed Watt Ohmlte Size Type 25 ModelJ, enclosed 75 Model G 100 Model K 150 Mode l L 225 Model P 300 Mode l N 500 Mode l R 750 Model T 1000 Model U 37 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 1 REVISION: 03 Generator
Field ControY 11&deg;/Jeostats
OHMITE 38 Application:
Ohmite Vitreous Ename l ed Rheostats vide smooth , c l ose, gradual control of generator
voltage. The permanence
of their characteristics, smoothness
of operation, exactness
of control , and compactness
have made them first choice among generator
and switchboard
designers. By providing
practically
continuous
variation
of resistance
in even the smallest sizes, they have made possible great savings in control-pane
l space. This makes them particularly
useful on portable equipment , such as we l ding generators
and power supplies. Range of Sizes: With a series of ten wattage sizes, there is an Oh mite rheostat, or tandem rheostat assemb l y, suitable for every size generator
in the range from the smallest to u nits of several hundred kilowatts. Ind i vidually Designed:
Oh mite field rheostats
will be individually
designed by our Engineering
Department
to fit each generator
field condition
upon receipt of the fo ll owing information
: State whether self or separately
excited, give field resistance (hot), maximum field current (state at what volts for se l f-excited
machines), minimum field current, r h eostat resistance (if known). For se l f-excited
mach i nes it is desirable
to supply a field magnetization
curve. Standard Designs: The rheostats
listed on the following
pages are tapered or uniformly
wound, as required , designed to provide control for separately
or self-excited
generators.
A n umber of models with differently
tapered windings are listed for each resistance
value. Current values depend on both the maximum voltage and the field resistance. Maximum design volts used were 32, 40, 64 , 80, 100 , 125, 160, 200, 250, 320 and 400. Ratios of rheostat resistance
to fie l d resistance
were set at equal, 1.6 times , 2.5 t i mes or 4 times. 180 160 .... :! 120 "' 0 100 er ' ; 80 0 > 60 4 0 20 0 ..... , v , I/ v 0 CEIL 1 1 NG .VOLT si) NO LOAD GENERATED , 1--...-v I VOLTAGE ['-.,. L--i--./ I I -RATED
v v ', , IV v v v VOLTAGE / ' l/v
RHED. v " !/ y 1'. NO LOAD MAGNET I ZATION CURVE FOR SELF* EX C ITED v " GENERATOR
' v ' }FIELD RHEOSTA T K i"-, OHMS r'-.FIELD VOLTS f-t i-_ VOLTAGE ACROSS I ..... FIELD i ..... !' ..... I ..... _ 0.5 1.0 FIELD AMPERES 1.5 Fig. 88: Design curve for fie l d rheostat Manufacturing
Company Fig. 89: Typical field control rheostat , wire side view. Design of Field Rheostat For Se l f-Excited
Generator
A magnetization
curve (such as Fig. 88) for the particular
machine should be obtained from the generator facturer. The no load curve is used for machines which may be operated without load or with a light l oad; a full l oad curve may be used for a generator
which is permanently
connected
to a load. The first step is to l ocate the "ceiling volts" -the highest voltage up to which the generated
voltage will build when there is no resistance
in series w i th the fie l d. At this point E G = R tield X /field* A straight line drawn through zero and "ceiling volts" represents
the voltage necessary
to prod u ce the field current at any intervening
point. The vert i cal distance between this line and the curve of generated
voltage represents
the voltage drop which must be taken up by the field rheostat.
The second step is to draw the curve of field rheostat ohms versus field current. This is obtained by Ohms' Law: Rheostat Ohms= Volts Drop in R h eostat...,. Field Amps. The total resistance
required will depend upon how low it is desired to bring the termina l voltage . Knowing the maximum voltage , the resistance
and maximum and minimum currents, a rheostat may be selected from the tab l es or O h mite engineers
wi ll design a spec i a l unit for the job. ,*) ' _) 
EC 62063 2 , Att. 1 , Pg. 18 3 of 2 6 '"fEPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION: 03 PAGE 130 OF 139 Rheostats (Potentiometers)
Wirewound
MODEL C Max. Ohmic Voltage (RMS)* 305 Behind panel "B" (in.Imm Ref.) 0.875/22.23 Diameter "D" (in.Imm Ref.) 0.515/ 13.08 Dimension "C" Shaft Rotation Model Type Watts range Core (in.Imm Ref.) torque (+/-5&deg;) C R CS/RCL 7.5 10.0-5K enclosed 0.25-3 oz. in. 300&deg; * Se e Ca t alog #203 for comp l ete d eta ils. Mounting:
Panels to 0.125" (3.18mm) thick with 1/4-32 bushing and hex nut CM' thick). Ohmic Model Type Watts range Core E R ES/REL 12.5 1.0-15K open -E REE 12.5 1.0-15K enclosed * See Catalog #2 03 for compl ete d e tail s.
shaft MODEL E Max. Voltage Behind panel "B" Diameter "D" Dimension "C" (RMS)* (in.Imm Ref.) (in.Imm Re!.) (in.Imm Ref.) 305 0.688/17.46
0.875/ 22.23 0.594/15.08 305 1.219/30.96
1.047/ 26.59 unenclosed
0.531" 13.49mm 6.35mm 0 0 0 () Mount i ng: Panels to 0.125" (3.1 Bmm) thick with 114-32 bushing and hex nut C/15" thick). Dimensions
for referenc e on ly; consu l t factory for d et ails. 0.406" 10.32mm Since all rh eosta ts/pot e ntiomet e rs are electro-mechanical
d evices, they are subject to mechan ica l wear and, therefore, have a finite lif e. Models H , J , K, Land N are listed und e r UL File No. E-10946 a nd CSA File No. 21309 unl ess noted oth erwise. All rheostats
are 10% toleranc e. 1-866-9-0HMITE * ln t'l 1-847-258-0300 *F ax 1-847-574-7 522 * www.ohmite
.co m * info@ohmite.com 187 -Shaft Rotation torque (+/-50) 1-6 oz. in. 300&deg; 1-6 oz. in. 300&deg; 
E C 62 0 632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 184 of 26-fEPORTNO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION: 03 PAGE 131 OF 139 Rheostats (Potentiometers)
Wirewound
MODELS H 1 J 1 G 1 K 1 L Max. Ohmic Voltage Behind panel "B" Model Type Watts range Core (RMS)* (in.Imm Ref.) H RHS/RHL 25 1.0-25K open 500 1.375/34.93
J RJS 50 0.5-50K open 750 1.375/34.93 G RGS 75 0.5-50K open 900 1.750/44.45
K RKS 100 0.5-50K open 1000 1.750/44.45
L RLS 150 0.5-50K open 1200 2.000 I 50.8 * Mo de l s H , J , G , and K a l so a va i lab le i n encl o se d v e r sions. * S ee Ca t a l o g #2 03 for c o m pl ete d eta il s. 0.5". 1 2.7 mm
dr i ll 0.188" (4.7 6 mm) hole in pan e l. w ash e r not included O o inmode/L 0.344" 8.7 3mm Diameter " D" (in.Imm Ref.) 1.560/ 39.62 2.31 I 58.67 2.75 I 69.25 3.125/ 79.38 4.00 /101.60 0.75" 19.05 m m sh aft locking nu t Dimension "C" Shaft Rotation (in.Imm Ref.) torque 0.940/23.88 0.25-0.5 lb. in. 1.56 /39.62 0.25-2 lb. in. 1.78 /45.21 0.5-2 lb. in. 1.9 1 /48.51 0.5-2 lb. in. 2.28 /57.91 0.5-3 lb. in. Mounting:
Panels to 0.25" (6.35mm) thick with 3/e-32 bushing and hex nut (3/32" thick) (or with 10-32 x 0.75 flat-head screws for model L only). (+/-50) 300&deg; 300&deg; 300&deg; 300&deg; 300&deg; hole s for: no. 2 scre ws (model H) no. 8 s crew s (J , G , K , L) mounting bracket on m o d ef L only 0.875" 2 2.23 mm _ __.>1+--standard shaft (m o d e l s H , J , G , K , L) locking shaft (onl y model H sto c k e d) MODELS P 1 N 1 R 1 U Max. Ohmic Voltage Behind panel " B" Diameter " D" Dimension "C" Shaft Rotation Model Type Watts range Core (RMS)* (in.Imm Ref.) (in.Imm Ref.) (in.Imm Ref.) torque (+/-50) p RPS 225 1.0-30K open 1300 2.125/53.98
5.00 /127.00 2.97 175.44 2.5-4 lb. in. 310&deg; N RNS 300 1.0-50K open 1225 2.375/60.33
6.00 /152.40 3.44 /87.38 2.5-5 lb. in. 320&deg; R RRS 500 1.0-20K open 1450 2.125/53.98
8.00 /203.20 4.31 /109.47 4.5-7 lb. in. 325&deg; u RUS 1000 1.0-20K open 1600 3.000 I 76.2 12.00 /304.80 6.38/162.05 3.5-7 lb. in. 335&deg; * See C a t al o g #2 0 3 for co mplete d e t ai l s. Dimension
" M" I p 0.875" 22.23 mm N 1.188" 30.16 mm R 1.5" 38.1 mm u 3" 76.2 mm D Mounting:
Panels l to 1.25" (31.75mm) thick with 11 4-20 flat-head screws. (continued)
188 1-866-9-0HMIT E * ln t'l 1-8 47-25 8-0300 *F ax 1-8 47-57 4-7 522 * www.ohm i t e.c om * i n f o@oh mite.co m 
EC 62 06 32 , Att. 1, Pg. 18 5 of 2 6 -fEPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION: 03 PAGE 132 OF 139 Rheostats (P ot entiometers)
Wirewound
ORDERING INFORMATION
Code Watts Model Shaft Core CL = 7.5 C Lo cking Enclos e d CS= 7.5 C Standard Enc l o s ed EE = 1 2.5 E S tanda rd Enclosed EL = 12.5 E Lo cking Op en E = RoHS compliant
I ES= 12.5 E Standard Op en G S= 75 G Standard Open HL = 25 H Lock i ng Op e n
Rh eostats W irewou n d Po tentiometers
RCSRSOE H S= 25 H Standard Open JS = 50 J Standard O pen KS = 1 oo K Standard Open LS = 150 L Standard Open N S= 300 N Standard Op e n PS = 225 P Standard Open RS= 500 R Standard Open U S= 1000 U Standard Open 7.5W Model C 12.SW Model E = ... .. "' "' "' .c c .c c "' .. :ii .. :i! 0 CD .,; u u u Ci.i 0 "' 0 c "' ...J ...J w PlrtNo. .. .. I I E I I I E Prefix>-"' "' (./') -' a. (./') -' LJ.J a. 6 SufftxY (.) (.) LJ.J LJ.J LJ.J
E a: a: a: a: a: < 0.5-R50 1 -1RO ii ii ii 3.53 1.5-1R5 2 -2RO ii ii ii 2.50 2.5-2R5 ii ii ii 2.24 3 -3RO ii ii ii 2.04 4 -4RO 5 -5RO ii ii ii 1.5B 6 -6RO ii ii ii 1.44 7.S -7R5 B -BRO ii ii ii 1.25 10 -10R ii ii O.B6 ii ii ii 1.12 12 -12R 12.5-12R5 1S _,.o ii ii 0.71 t/ i1 i1 n 01 16 -16R 22 -22R 25 -25R ii ii 0.55 ii ii ii 0.71 35 -35R ii ii 0.46 ii ii ii 0.60 dQ -4 0R 50 -50R ii ii 0.39 ii ii ii 0.50 75 -75R ii ii 0.32 ii ii ii 0.40 BO -BOR 100 -100 ii ii 0.27 ii ii ii 0.36 12s -'"" t/ t/ t/ 0.3? 150 -1 50 ii ii 0.22 ii ii ii 0.29 160 -160 175 -1 75 ii ii ii 0.27 200 -200 ii ii 0.19 ii ii ii 0.25 2?S -22S 250 -250 ii ii 0.17 ii ii ii 0.22 300 -300 325 -325 350 -350 ii ii 0.15 ii ii ii 0.19 400 -" 00 500 -500 ii ii 0.12 ii ii ii 0.16 600 -600 700 -700 750 -750 ii ii 0.10 ii ii ii 0.13 BOO --800 900 -900 1000 -1KO ii ii 0.086 ii ii ii 0.10 1200 -1K2 125 0
1500 -1 5 ii ii 0.071 ii ii t/ 0.090 1600 -1K6 1750 -1 K75 1BOO -1K8 2000 -2KO 2250 -2K25 2500 -2K5 ii ii 0.0 55 ii ii ii 0.0 7 0 3000 -3KO 3500 -3K5 ii ii 0.046 ii ii ii 0.060 4500 -4 K5 5000 -5KO ii ii 0.039 ii ii ii 0.050 7500 -7K5 ii ii ii 0.041 8000 --BKO 10000 -10K ii ii ii 0.035
ii ii ii 0.031 i1 i1 i1 o 020 20000 -2 0K 2 5000 -25 K 30000 -30K 4 0000 -40K 50000 -50K *Check Eble for stand a rd res i stance v a l ues and maximum c urrent value s 25W Model H sow 75W = Model J Mode l G .. "' .c c "' :ii u 0 "' "' "' ...J .. .. .. I I E I E I E "' "' "' (./') -' a. a. (./') a. :r; :r; E E '-" E a: a: < a: < a: < ii 10.0 ii 12.3 ii ii 5.00 ii 7.07 ii B.66 ii ii 3.54 ii 5.00 ii 6.12 ii ii 2.BB ii 5.00 ii 3.53 ii 3.BB ii ii 2.04 ii 2.BB t/ 31R ii ii 1.77 ii 2.50 ii ii 1.5B ii 2.74 ii 2.04 ii t/ 1 ?Q ii 1.76 ii 2.17 ii 1.50 ii ii 1.00 ii 1.73 ii ii O.B45 ii 1.19 ii ii 0.707 ii 1.00 ii 1.23 ii ii 0.575 ii 1.00 ii 0.790 ii ii 0.500 ii O.B66 ii ii 0.445 t/ o ii 0.575 ii ii 0.375 ii 0.612 ii 0.d 70 ii ii 0.316 ii 0.408 ii 0.500 ii ii 0.2 6 7 ii 0433 ii ii 0.2 2 2 ii 0.316 ii 0.388 ii ii 0.182 ii 0.316 ii 0.250 ii ii 0.155 ii 0.224 ii 0.274 ii ii 0.129 ii 0.224 ii 0.1 76 ii 0.194 ii ii 0.100 ii 0.1 41 ii 0.173 ii ii 0.084 ii 0.119 ii ii 0.070 ii 0100 ii 0123 ii ii 0.05B ii 0.100 ii 0.0 7 9 ii ii 0.050 ii 0.070 ii 0.08 7 t/ ii 0.n41 t/ 0 OSR ii ii 0.035 ii 0.050 ii ii 0.032 ii 0.045 ii 0.041 ii 0.035 ii 0.03 2 Resistance
Value .. E xample: R so = o.soo 1RO = 1 0 7R5 = 7.50 250 = 2500 1Ko = 1 , 0000 1K75= 1 , 7500 4K5 = 4 , 5000 soK = so , oooo 100W 150W Model K Model l "' "' .. .. I E I E "' "' (./') a. (./') a. "" -' a: a: ii 14.1 ii 17.3 ii 10 ii 12.3 ii 7.07 ii B.65 ii 5.75 ii 7.07 ii 4.47 ii 5.4 B ii 3.65 t/ 4.47 ii 3.16 ii 3.BB ii 3.163 ii 2.50 ii 2.0 ii 2.450 ii 2.070 ii 1.4 1 ii 1.735 ii 1.15 ii 1.415 ii 1.00 ii 1.225 ii 1.000 ii 0.707 ii O.B65 ii 0.775 ii 0.575 ii 0.655 ii 0.500 ii 0.447 ii 0.54B ii 0.365 ii 0.447 ii 0.316 ii 0.346 ii 0.258 ii 0.2B 8 ii 0.224 ii 0.259 ii 0.200 ii 0.224 ii 0.1B2 ii 0.141 ii 0.115 ii 0.141 ii 0.100 ii 0.122 1-866-9-0HM ITE * lnt'l 1-84 7-25 8-0300 *F ax 1-847-574-7522 * www.ohm ite.com * info@ohmite.com 189 * RoH S compliant
product available. Add "E" suffix to part number to sp ec ify. * M ade-to-order rheo stats available: Contact nearest Ohm ite sales office. * V oltage rating depend ent on r es i stance valu e. 225W 300W soow 1000W Model P Model N Model R Model U "' "' "' "' .. .. .. .. I E I E I E I E "' "' "' "' (./') a. (./') a. (./') a. (./') a. a.. E z E a: E :::> E a: < a: < a: < a: < ii 15.0 ii 17.32 ii 22.3 ii 31.6 ii 1B.2 ii 25.B ii 10.6 ii 12.24 ii 15.B ii 22.4 ii 14.1 ii 20.0 ii B.66 ii 10.00 ii 1 2.9 ii 1B.3 ii 7.50 ii B.66 ii 11.2 ii 15.B ii 6.71 ii 7.75 ii 10.0 ii 14.1 t/ dO ii 6.3 2 ii 7.90 ii 11.2 ii 4.74 ii 5.48 ii 10.0 ii 6.30 ii 8.95 ii 3.87 ii 4.47 ii 5.60 ii 7.90 ii 3.00 ii 3.46 ii 4.47 ii 6.33 ii 3.54 ii 2.12 ii 2.45 ii 3.16 ii 4.47 ii 1.73 ii 2.00 ii 3.6 5 ii 2.52 ii 1.50 ii 1.73 ii 3.16 t/ ?.00 ii 1.22 ii 1.41 ii 1.69 ii 2.39 ii 1.06 ii 1.22 ii 2.11 ii 1.41 ii 0.866 ii 1.00 ii 1.B3 ii 1.24 i1 n 750 ii O.B66 ii 1 dB ii 1.00 ii 1.41 ii 0.56 7 ii 0.655 ii 0.81 7 ii 1.1 5 ii 0.500 ii 0.57B ii 0.707 ii 1.00 ii 0.433 ii 0.500 ii 0.38 7 ii 0.447 ii 0.577 ii O.B16 ii 0.358 ii 0.41 4 ii 0.336 ii 0.387 ii 0.500 ii 0.300 ii 0.346 ii 0.447 ii 0.633 V' = St a ndard values; check availab ility Rheo stats are silicone-ceramic
coated at and above the following
ohmic values: Model C: all Model G: SOOOQ Model E: 750Q Model K: SOOO Q Model H: 2000Q Model L: 7500Q Model J: SOOOQ 
EC 62063 2 , Att. 1, P g. 186 of REP-424-0 08-RP1 REV I SION: 03 210 Series Divi doh m Vitre o us Enamel A dj ustab l e Power FEATURES PAGE 133 OF 139 *Terminals
suitable for soldering
or bolt connection.
*Adjustable
l ug supplied *High wattage applications
*Al l-welded construction
*Rugged lead free vitreous enamel coating. *Flame resistant
coating *Additional
adjustable
lugs available
* RoHS compliant
product available. Add "E" suffix to part number to specify Choose Oh mite's 210 Type adjustable
res i stors for applications
requiring
settings at different
resistance
values. These wirewound
resistors
are equipped with an adjustable
lug, making them ideal for adjusting
circuits , obtaining
odd resistance
values and ting equip ment to meet various line vo l tages. 21 O Type resistors
feature a hollow core to permit secure fasteni n g with spr i ng-type clips or thru b ol ts with washers. They also offer the durability
of lead free vitreous enamel coat i ng and al l-welded construction.
Mounting brackets not included with resistors. SERIES SPECIFICATIONS
Series Wattage Ohms Core Code Voltage Standard Terminal 012 12 1.0-10K 0 565 57 025 25 1.0-25K K 625 40 050 50 1.0-100K K 1625 40 075 75 1.0-100K K 2625 40 0100 100 1.0-100K M 2845 40 0175 175 1.0-1 OOK p 3595 46 0225 225 1.0-100K p 4595 46 0500 500 1.5-15K s 4970 45 01000 1000 3.0-27.7K s 8900 45 Oth e r si z es av aila b le; cont a ct Ohm it e. Also ava i labl e in low co st Cen t ohm or S i lic on e coating; con tac t Ohmite. CHARACTERISTICS
Adjustability
10% to 90% of full value. Wattage is proportional
to this adjusted resistance
value. Coating Lead free vitreous enamel. Large models (500 watts and up) are supplied in Silicone Ceramic. Also availab l e in low-cost Centohm coating; Consult factory. Core Tubular ceram i c. Terminals
Solder coated radial lug. RoHS solder composition
is 96% Sn , 3.5% Ag , 0.5% Cu Adjustable
Nicke l p l ated steel. (Screwdriver
type adjustable
lug supplied terminal standard. Other types, i ncluding si l ver contact units , available.) Derating Linearly from 100% @ +25&deg;C to 0% @ +350&deg;C. Tolerance
+/-10% (K) Power rating Based on 25&deg;C free air rating. The stated wattage rating applies only when the entire resistance
is in the circuit. Setting the lug at an intermediate
point reduces the wattage rating by approximate
l y the same proportion. Example: If the lug is set at half resistance , the wattage is reduced by approx. one-half. Overload 10 times rated wattage for 5 seconds. Temperature
+/-260 ppm/&deg;C coefficient
Dielectric
1000 VAC: 12 to 100 watt rat i ng. 3000 VAC: 175 and 225 watt withstanding
ing (measured
from terminal to mounting bracket) vo l tage Max. amps To calculate , use the formula 'IP!R. Power limitations
for high tance values: When resistance
exceeds the resistance
values l i sted below , derate the Power Rating by 25% to improve reliability
: Power Resistance
No power rating value derating neces-12W 4 , 5000 sary for ratings 25W 9 , 0000 higher than SOW 20 , 0000 100W. 75W 35 , 0000 100W 50 , 0000 1-866-9-0HMITE * lnt'l 1-847-258-0300 *Fax 1-847-57 4-7522 * www.ohm i t e.com * info@ohmite.com 109 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 1 87 of 2 6 fEPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REV I S I ON: 03 PAGE 1 34 OF 139 210 Series D i vidohm Vitreous Enamel Adjustable
Power DIMENSIONS (in./ mm) Series Wattage l D c Core Code Standa r d Terminal 012 12 1.75/ 44.4 0.313 / 7.94 0.1 88 / 4.76 0 5 7 025 25 2.0 I 50.8 0.562 / 14.3 0.313 / 7.94 K 40 050 50 4.0/101.6 0.562 / 1 4.3 0.313 / 7.94 K 40 075 75 6.0 / 15 2.4 0.562 / 14.3 0.313 / 7.94 K 40 I L I 0100 100 6.5 / 165.1 0.750 / 19.1 0.50 / 12.7 M 40 0175 175 8.5 / 215.9 1.125 / 28.6 0.7 5 / 19.1 p 46 0225 225 10.51 266.7 1.125 / 2 8.6 0.7 5 / 19.1 p 46 0500 500 12.0 / 304.8 2.50 / 63.5 1.75 / 44.5 s 4 5 01000 1000 20.0 / 508.0 2.50 / 63.5 1.75 /44.5 s 4 5 ORDERING INFORMATION
Coating I I D25K100E B la nk = Vitreous C = Centohm S =Silicone
RoHS Compliant
I I -, I --, Serles Wattage Tolerance
Ohms J = 5% 1A0=10 K = 10% 25 0 = 2500 1KO = 1,0 000 25K = 25,0000 25K5 = 25 , 5000 Standard Values c "' "' c c "' .,, c .,, c c t:: "' c c "' -"' .,, .... -"' .,, T =-.. Part N o. l l l l I I I I > "" .. "" "" "" "" 0 "E Prefix> 0 "' "' 0 0 "' "' 0 "' 0 .... "' 0 0 Wattage ..c: Suffi x Y Ci "' "' .... Ci Ci "' "' Ci c 0 0 0 0 0 1.0 1ROE .... .... .... .... .... .... .... 2 2 ROE .... .... .... .... .... .... .... 3 3ROE .... .... .... .... .... .... 4 4R OE .... .... .... .... 5 5R OE .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... 7.5 7R 5E .... .... 10 10RE .... .... .... .... .... .... .... 15 15RE .... .... .... 20 2 0RE .... .... 25 25 RE .... .... .... .... .... .... .... 50 S ORE .... .... .... .... .... .... .... 75 75 RE .... .... .... 1 00 100E .... .... .... .... .... .... .... Made-to-order
Parts Core Diameter Terminal Type See " Co r e and See u R esistor T erminal s Terminal fo r Tu bu l a r I _J_ RoHS Compliant
I 21050K405ROOJE
., ,.---,-Coating Wattage 2 1 O =Vi t r eous 4rn =Silico n e Ceram i c 61 O = Ce ntohm "' .,, =--"' l: Part No. I I ... *e Prefix> "" "" "' "' ..c: Suffix Y Ci N c 0 150 150E .... .... 200 200E .... .... 250 250E .... .... 300 300E .... .... 400 400E .... .... 500 500E .... .... 7 50 7 50E .... .... 800 BOOE .... 1 , 00 0 lKOE .... .... 1 ,2 5 0 1K25E .... .... 1 , 500 -1K5E .... .... 2,000 2KOE .... .... 2 , 500 2K5E .... .... c .,, I "" 0 .,., 0 .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... Ohms R500 = 0.5000 1ROO = 10 250R = 2500 1KOO = 1, 0000 25KO = 25,0000 25K5 = 25,5000 Wattage c .,, .,, c .... "' .,, .... --"' I l l I "" "" 0 "' "' "' 0 .... "' .... Ci Ci "' 0 0 .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... L-To l erance J = 5% K = 10% c c c c c I ., "' = I -;; > "" 0 ... 0 0 *e 0 0 .,., Ci ..c: 0 c 3,000 4,000 5 , 000 6 , 000 7 000 .... .... 7 , 500 10 , 000 12 , 000 .... .... 15 , 000 20,000 25,000 50 , 000 100,000 See 270 ser i es custom core and terminal Info Wattage c c "' .,, c .,, -"' .,, .... -Part No. l l I l l P r efix> "" 0 "' "' 0 "' 0 SuffixY Ci "' .,., .... Ci 0 0 0 3KOE .... .... .... 4KOE .... 5KOE .... .... .... .... 6KOE .... ?KOE .... .... 7K5E .... .... .... 10KE .... .... .... .... .... 12KE 15KE .... .... 20KE .... .... .... 25KE .... .... 50KE .... .... 100KE .... .... .,, t:: I "" "' .... Ci .... .... .... v = Standard va l ues; check availab i lity at www.ohmite.com
50KQ and 1 OOKQ resistance
values i nvolve very fine resistance
wire and should not be us e d in critical applicatio
n s without burn-in and/or therma l cyc l ing. 110 1-866-9-0HMITE * lnt'l 1-847-2 58-0300 *Fax 1-8 47-574-7522 * www.ohmite.com
* info@ohmite
.com .,, "' "' l "' "' N 0 .... 
EC 620 6 32 , Att. 1 , Pg. 1 88 of REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION: 03 PAGE 135 OF 139 250 Series 'Thin' Stackohm
Vitreous Ename l Power When limited space is a consideration, choose Ohmite's " thin" stackable
250 Type resistors.
These oval-shaped
ceramic-core
resistors
feature a low profile to permit installation
in spaces with height restrictions.
They are also equipped with integral mounting brackets so they can be fastened to a chassis and stacked in locations
with limited surface area. When properly fastened, the mounting brackets add a heat sinking benefit resulting
in a smaller size per watt. Durable 250 Type resistors
are fully welded and coated with lead free vitreous enamel. FEATURES *Small size-to-power
ratio. *Stackable
*Integral
mounting bracket conducts heatto mounting surface. *Low profile for use in equipment
where space is limited. *All-welded construction.
* RoHS compliant
product available. Add "E" suffix to part number to specify. SERIES SPECIFICATIONS
Series Wattage Ohms Max. Voltage* F10 10 1.0-15K 187 F20 20 1.0-50K 815 F30 30 1.0-10K 281 F40 40 1.0-25K 655 F55 55 1.0-30K 1405 Adjustabl e ver si on s and oth e r size s a v ailabl e; Consult Ohmite A ls o avail a bl e i n low cost Cen t ohm or Silicon e c o a ting; Con s u l t Ohmit e. * M ax imum Vo l tage is ba sed o n Ohm's La w [V=-/P*R] a s limited by th e r e sita n c e v a lue of specifi e d produc t CHARACTERISTICS
Coating Lead free vitreous enamel Core Ceramic Terminals
Tinned lug with ho l e. RoHS solder compos i t i on i s 96% Sn , 3.5% Ag , 0.5% Cu Derating Linearly from 100% @ +25&deg;C to 0% @ +350&deg;C Tolerance
+/-5% (J) Power rating Based on mounting a single resistor on a metal surface measu r ing 10" (254mm) square by 0.04" (1.016mm) thi c k. Reduce rat i ng by 1 5% when mounting on non-metallic surface Overload 10x rated wattage for 5 seconds i f max. voltage is not exceeded Temperature
1 to 200: +/-400 ppm/&deg;C coefficient
Over 200: +/-260 ppm/&deg;C Dielectric
with-500 VAC: 10 and 20 watt rating. 1000 VAC: 30 , 40 and 55 watt rating (meastanding voltage sured from lug to mounting bracket) Max_ amps To calculate , use the formula v'P/R 110 1-8 6 6-9-0HMITE * lnt'l 1-847-258-0300 *Fax 1-8 4 7-57 4-752 2 * www.ohmit e.com * info@ohm i t e.c om 
EC 620632 , A tt. 1, Pg. 18 9 0 f 2 6 ;REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION: 03 PAGE 136 OF 139 250 Series 'Thi n' Stackohm
Vitreous Enamel Power DIMENSIONS (in.Imm) Diam. 0.125'-"' 3.175mm I 0.110": L 2.776 mm-+ ,._ ___ A ____ , 0.625" 15.8 75 mm ---0) -.I I .... 0.125"' 3.175 mm 0.25 0'-t 0.375' t d =lfi 6.350 mm_ j_ 9.525 mm + Diam. 0.109' 2.776mm Di a m. 0.196' --4.9 79mm I 0.25 0' L 6.350 mm-+ i.----A ----1 0.125'-'-r---------.
&#xa9;1&sect;: --"' -.I I+ C\I 0.250". 6.350mm 3.1 75m m.-rr=J= 0.43 8' Ll' JLl..1.1 t.113mm Series Wattage length l Length A F10 10 0.750 / 19.050 1.000 I 25.400 F20 20 2.000 I 50.800 2.313 / 58.750 F30 30 1.250 / 31.7 50 2.000 I 50.800 F40 40 2.000 I 50.800 2.750 I 69.850 F55 55 3.500 I 88.900 4.250 / 107.950 'Reference
dim ension on ly; var ies according
to re sista nc e value. Note: When r esistors are stacked , us e wa s hers or spacers as required to in sure clearance
and imp rov e powe r dissipation. MOUNTING Derating for stacked mounting In addition to the standard box bracket , stud type brackets are av a ilable for stacking the standard size resistors. Stud type brackets are available
in two heights: standard (SS, 0.437"/11.113mm)
and high (SSH , 0.531"/13.494mm). The SSH stud is recommended
when stacking the adjustable
Type 260 , a s it assures clearance
for the adjustable
lugs to pass eachot h er. Spacer washer No. 6027 (O.D. 0.219"/5.556mm , l.D. 0.125"/3.175mm , thickness
0.094"/2.381mm) is recommende d for use with the miniature
adjustable
and fixed tors to prov i de clearance , as explained
above , or increased
wattag e. See chart. Stacked resistors
should be derated to prevent excessive peratures
due to proximity. Approximate
ratings are given in the table. Percent of Single Unit Rating 02so*L r.=of= t o.375" 6.350 mm_u*--==""'----*u _i 9.525 mm + Diam. 0.1 96"-No. of Resistors
Std. or Inter. Miniature
2 70 70 3 60 60 4 50 50 1 2.7m m 1-866-9-0HMITE * lnt'l 1-84 7-25 8-0300 *Fax 1-847-574-7522
* www.ohm ite.co m * info@ohmit e.com 111 Miniature
with 0.094" (2.381 mm) Spacer Washer 75 69 60 (continued) 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 19 Q of 2 6 '"fEPORT NO.: REP-424-008
-RP1 REVISION: 03 250 Series 'Thin' Stackohm
Vitreous Enamel Power PAGE 137 OF 139 CORE AND TERMINAL SELECTION
For Made to Order Type 250 Stackohm Resistors
Code Core Dlmens l ons t Max. for Standard Free Air Wattage Rating* Length L WidthW Thickness
T Min. Practical
Core Ohms Ohms Dia. Fig. No. D i mension A Dimens i on B Terminal Miniature
10 0.750" (19.0SOmm) 0.375" (9.525mm) 0.125" (3.175mm) 1 15 , 000 TA 1 1.000" (25.400mm)
0.375" (9.5 25mm) 15 1.000" (2 5.400mm) 0.375" (9.525mm) 0.1 25" (3.175mm) 1 25,000 TA 1 1.250" (31.750mm)
0.375" (9.5 25mm) 20 2.000" (50.800mm) 0.3 75" (9.525mm) 0.1 25" (3.175mm) 1 50,000 TA 1 2.313" (58.750mm) 0.375" (9.525mm) 1 2 0.688" (17.463mm)
0.594" (15.081 mm) 0.234" (5.953mm) 1 20,000 T B .. Intermediate
21 1.000" (25.400m m) 0.813" (20.638mm) 0.250" (6.350 mm) 1 8,000 TD 2 1.313" (33.350mm) 0.594" (1 5.081mm) 25 1.500" (38.1 OOmm) 0.813" (20.638mm) 0.250" (6.350mm) 1 15,000 TD 2 1.8 13" (46.050mm) 0.594" (15.081mm) Standard 30 1.250" (31.750mm)
1.000" (25.400mm)
0.250" (6.350mm) 1 10 , 000 TE 5 1.750" f 44.450mml
0.938" (23.813mm) 3 , 4 2.000" 50.800mm 40 2.000" (50.800m m) 1.000" (25.400mm)
0.250" (6.35 0mm) 1 25 , 000 TE 5 2.500" !6 3.5 00mm l 0.938" (23.813 mm) 3 , 4 2.7 50" 69.850mm 55 3.500" (88.900mm) 1.000" (25.400mm)
0.250" (6.350mm) 1 30 , 000 TE 5 4.000" (1.1.600mm) 0.938" (23.813mm) 3 ,4 4.250" (107.950mm) 70 4.750" (120.650mm) 1.000" (25.400mm) 0.250" (6.350mm) 1 120 , 000* TE 5 5.250" f 133.350mml 0.938" (23.813mm) 3 , 4 5.500" 139.700mm 95 6.000" (15 2.400mm) 1.000" (25.400mm)
0.250" (6.350mm) 1 1 so.ooo* TE 5 6.500" !165.100mml 0.9 38" (23.813mm) 3 , 4 6.75 0" 171,450mm
*Bas ed on mounting on steeel panel 10" (254mm) x 10" x 0.040" (1.016mm). *These sizes are O hm i cone (si li cone-ceramic) coated-type 450-460. **User suppl i es brackets. t 1ns ide dimens i ons of core are: 0.250" (6.350mm) x 0.04 7" (1.191 mm) for TA; 0.406" (1 0.319mm) x 0.047" (1.19 1mm) for TB; 0.438" (11.113mm) x 0.063" (1.588mm) f or TD; 0.672" (17.069mm) x 0.063" (1.588mm)
fo r TE. Ser i es I ORDERING INFORMATION
RoHS Compliant
I Made-to-order
Parts *F20J1ROE See web-Term i nal Type Tolerance
RoHS I ,.-I ---,-Coating Wattage Tolerance
Ohm s B l a n k= Vitreou s F = 1% 1 RO = 10 C = Centohm H = 3% 250 = 2500 S = Sili c on e J = 5% 1 KO = 1 , 0000 K = 10% 25K = 25 , 0000 25K5 = 25 , 5000 Standard Values Wattage g: Cl Cl Cl Cl ..... ., N "' ... ..... "' Oi Part No. Oi Part No. > I I I I l > u Prefix> u Prefix> *e ...., ...., ...., ...., *e C) C) C) C) "' .c SuffixY u: "' .... tf .c SuffixY c u.. u.. c Cl l C) u:
S e e " Res i stor Term i na ls for J = 5% I Ci&deg;mpllant
I I Series Wattage & Mounting Brackets Vitreous enam e l: Core Code (user supplies bra cket for cor e TB) 25 = 250 F i xed See " Core and B = Stack i ng box 26 = 260 Ad j ust a ble T e rm i na l Se l ection" S = Stac ki ng stud, std. h e igh t S ili cone ceram i c: H = Stack i ng stud high 45 = 450 F ixe d U = Unit type 46 = 460 Ad j ustabl e Wattage Wattage Cl Cl Cl ..... ., Cl Cl Cl Cl ..... N "' ... ..... "' -N "' ... ..... Oi Part No. l l l l > l I I I l u Prefix> *e ci ci ci C) C) C) "' C) "' N "' .... "' .c Suff i x Y u: 12 ;::!: tf u.. u.. u.. u.. c Ohms Example: 1ROO = 10 250R = 2500 1KOO = 1 , 0000 25KO = 25,0000 25K5 = 25 , 5000 51 51 51 51 51 51 5 7 57 57 57 57 1 1ROE t/ t/ t/ t/ t/ 50 SORE t/ t/ t/ t/ 1 ,5 00 1K5E t/ t/ t/ t/ t/ = Standard values; 1.5 1 R5 E t/ t/ t/ 7 5 75 R E t/ t/ 2,000 2KOE t/ t/ t/ 2 2 ROE t/ t/ t/ t/ t/ 100 100 E t/ t/ t/ t/ t/ 2 , 500 2K5E t/ t/ t/ t/ t/ check availability
at 3 3ROE t/ t/ t/ 150 150E t/ 3 , 000 3KOE t/ t/ t/ t/ www.ohmite.c om 4 4ROE t/ t/ 200 200E t/ t/ t/ t/ 4 000 4KOE t/ t/ 5 5ROE t/ t/ t/ t/ t/ 250 250E t/ t/ t/ t/ 5 , 000 5KOE t/ 7.5 7R5E t/ t/ t/ 300 300E t/ 6 , 000 6KOE 10 10 RE t/ t/ t/ t/ 400 400E t/ t/ t/ 7 , 500 7K5E t/ 15 1 5RE t/ t/ t/ 500 500E t/ t/ t/ t/ t/ 10 , 000 10KE t/ t/ 20 20RE t/ 75 0 7 50 E t/ t/ 15 000 15KE t/ 25 25RE t/ t/ t/ t/ t/ 800 800 E t/ 20 , 000 20KE t/ 30 30RE t/ 1 , 000 1KOE t/ t/ t/ t/ t/ 25,00 0 25KE t/ 40 40RE t/ 1 , 250 1K25E t/ t/ 40 , 000 40KE t/ 112 1-866-9-0HMIT E * ln t'l 1-847-258-0300
*Fax 1-847-574-7522 * www.ohmite.com * info@ohmit e.co m 
EC 620632 , Att. 1, Pg. 1 9 1 of 26f EPORTNO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION: 03 PAGE 138 OF 139 270 Series Vitreous Enamel Power FEATURES Select 270 Type fixed resistors
for applications
requiring
wattage ratings from 12 to 1000 watts. The 2 7 0 Type resistors
are equipped with lug nals suitable for soldering
or sturdy bolt connection.
When secure mounting is required, the hollow core of the s e resistors
permit fastening
with spring-type brack e ts, thru bolts or thru bolts with slotted-steel
brack e ts. *Terminals
suitable for soldering
or bolt connection
*High wattage applications
*Rugged lead free vitreous enamel coating *Flame resistant
coating Suitable for rugged applications, the 270 Type resistors
feature all-welded
construction
and durable lead free vitreous enamel coating. Mounting brackets not in c luded with resistors. *All-welded
construction
* RoHS compliant
available
*"Fast on" option -see terminal 538 , http://www.ohmite.com/techdata/terminals.pdf
Serie s L12 L25 -L50 L100 L175 L225 L500 L100 0 SERIES SPECIFICATIONS
Wattage Ohms Core Code Voltage Std. Terminal Non-Inductive
versions available; Other s ize s availab l e; Also available
in 12 0.1-51K D 565 57 l ow cost Centohm or Silicon e coating; Consult Ohm ite. 25 0.15-100K K 625 40 * Max imum Volt age is based on 50 0.38-2 60K K 1625 40 Ohm's Law [V=V'P*R] as limi ted by the resistance
value of specified
product 100 0.23-101 K M 2845 40 175 0.13-101 K p 3595 46 225 0.16-12 9K p 4595 46 500 0.38-218K s 4970 45 1000 0.69-392K s 8900 45 CHARACTERISTICS
Coating Lead free vitreous enamel. Large models (500 watts and up) are supplied in Silicone Ceramic. Also availab l e in low-cost Centohm coating; Consult factory. Core Tubula r ceramic. Terminals
Solder coated rad ial lug. RoHS solder compos ition is 96% Sn, 3.5% Ag, 0.5% Cu Derating Linearly from 100% @ +25&deg;C to 0% @ +35 0&deg;C. Tolerance
+/-5% 1Q and over (J); +/-10% unde r 1Q (K) Power rating Based on 25&deg;C free air rating. Overload 10 times rated wattage for 5 seconds. Temperature
coefficient
1 to 20Q: +/-400 ppm/&deg;C; Above 20Q: +/-2 60 ppm/&deg;C Dielectric
withstanding
voltage 1000 VAC: 12 to 100 watt rating. 3000 VAC: 175 to 225 watt rating (Measured
from term ina l to mount ing bracket) Max. amps use the formula ,/P/R Power limitations
for When resistance
exceeds the resistance
values listed, derate the Power Rating by 25% to high resistance
values improve reliability. No power derat i ng necessary
for ratings higher than 100W Power Resistance
rating value 12W 3 , 900 Q 25W 12 , 000Q sow 35 , 000 Q 100W 75 , 000Q Mounting Hardware see http://www.ohmite.com/techdata/lug
-mount in g.php (continued)
1-866-9-0HM ITE * lnt'l 1-84 7-258-0300 *Fax 1-84 7-574-7522 * www.ohmite.com
* info@o hmite.com 113 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 192 of 2 6 '"fEPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION:
03 PAGE 139 OF 139 270 Series Vitreous Enamel Power DIMENSIONS
in.Imm Series Wattage L D L12 12 1.75 / 44.4 0.313 / 7.94 L25 25 2.0 I 50.8 0.562 / 14.3 .i.. L50 50 4.0/101.6 0.562 / 14.3 ...i. D c L100 100 6.51165.1 0.750 / 19.1 ..... L175 175 8.5 / 215.9 1.125 / 28.6 L l225 225 10.5 / 266.7 1.125 / 28.6 L500 500 12.0 / 304.8 2.50 / 63.5 L1000 1000 20.0 1 508.0 2.50 / 63.5 c 0.188 / 4.76 0.313 / 7.94 0.313 / 7.94 0.50 / 12.7 0.75 / 19.1 0.75 / 19.1 1.75 / 44.5 1.75 / 44.5 * http://www
.ohmite.com/techdata/200*210
*270-custom.pdf Standard ** http://www.ohmite.com/techdata/terminals
.pdf ORDERING INFDRMATIDN
Non-Inductive
Made-to-order
Non...f nductlve Blank = Standard Core Code* D K K M p p s s F = Fast on B la n k = Standard
I N = Non-i nd uctive RoHS Comp If ant I N = Non-In du ctive I Core D ia mete r See *eore and Terminal Selection*
I RoHS Compliant
I I L ll 25JlOOE I
Coating Blank = V itreous C =Centohm s = smcone --,-I -----r Wattage Tolerance
Ohms J = 5% 1R0=10 K = 10% 250 = 2500 1KO = 1 , 0000 25K = 25,0000 25K5 = 25,5000 Standard part numbers for 270 series Ohmic Ohmic value 12 Watt value 12 Watt .. = 270 1 50K405ROOJE TOhm s 270 * Vitreous RSOO ... 0.5000 470 =Si l icone Ceramic M :*rmlnal &deg;!'YP8 See Res i stor
1 KOO.1 ,ooo n for T ubular Cores 25 K O = 25*000 0 25K5 * 25,5000 custom core and terminal Info Wattage 0 0 II) II) 0 0 II) 0 0 .... N 0 0 .. N II) N II) = I Tolerance
J = 5% K = 1 0% II) N 0.51 .., L 12JKR51 E 180 v' L12J180E I ... Part No. l l l I l I ... P1rtNo. ,. ,. l 1 .., L 12J1 ROE 270 .., L 12J270E 3.3 .., L 12J3R3E 330 .., L 12J330E 4.7 .., L12J4R7E 390 .., L 12J390E 10 .., L12J10RE 470 .., L 12J4 70E 12 .., L12J12RE 560 .., L 12J560E 15 .., L12J15RE 1000 .., L12J1KOE 22 .., L 12J22RE 1200 .., L12J1K2E 27 v' L 12J27R E 1500 .., L12J1K5E 33 .., L 12J33RE 2200 .., L12J2K2E 47 .., L 12J47RE 2700 .., L12J2K 7E 68 .., L 12J68RE 4700 .., L12J4K 7 E 82 .., L 12J82RE 10000 .., L12J10KE 100 .., L12J100E 18000 .., L12J18KE 150 .., L12J150E 22000 .., L12J22KE 51000 .., L12 J51KE V' = Standard values; check availability
using the worldwide
inventory
search at www.ohmite.com Red outlined values supplied in Silicone-Ceramic coatings instead of vitreous enamel. ... *e .c c 1 2 3 4 5 10 15 25 50 7 5 100 125 150 200 250 500 750 800 1 ,000 1 500 2 , 000 Prefix> ..., ..., C) C) ll) ll) C) C) ll) C) C) .... N C) C) Suffix Y N ll) :::; :::; N ll) :::; _, _, _, _, 1 ROE v' .., .., .., .., 2ROE v' .., .., .., .., 3ROE v' .., .., .., .., 4ROE v' ti' .., .., .., 5ROE v' ti' ti' .., .., 1 OR E v' ti' ti' .., .., 15R E v' 25RE v' .., .., ti' .., SOR E v' .., ti' .., .., 75RE v' .., .., .., .., 100E .., .., .., .., .., 125E .., .., 150E .., .., .., .., .., 200E .., .., 250E .., .., .., .., .., 500E .., .., .., .., .., 750E .., .., .., .., BOOE v' .., 1KOE ti' .., .., ti' .., 1 KSE v' .., .., .., 2KOE v' .., .., .., .., 114 1-866-9-0HMITE
* tnt'l 1-847-258-0300 *Fax 1-847-574-7522 * www.ohmite.com * info@ohmite
.com ... Prefix> e "' .c SufflxY N c _, 2,500 2K5E .., 3 , 000 3KOE .., 3 , 500 3K5E .., 4,000 4KOE .., 5 000 5KOE .., 6 , 000 6KOE .., 7 , 500 7K5E .., 10 , 000 10K E .., 12 , 000 12KE v' 15 000 15KE v' 20 , 000 20KE v' 25 , 000 25KE v' 30 , 000 30KE 35 , 000 35KE 40 000 40KE .., 50 , 000 50KE v' 60 , 000 60KE 75 , 000 75KE 100 , 000 100K E v' 150 000 150K E 200 , 000 200KE 250 , 000 250KE Std. Term.** 57 40 40
40 46 46
45 45 Wattage 0 0 II) II) 0 0 0 0 .... N 0 0 II) N II) T l l I l I ..., ..., ..., C) C) ll) "' C) C) C) C) .... N C) C) ll) :::; :::; N ll) :::; _, _, _, ti' .., .., ti' .., .., .., .., .., ti' .., .., .., .., .., .., .., .., .., ti' .., .., .., .., .., .., .., .., .., .., -.., ti' .., m .., .., .., .., .., .!'.'.. .., .., .., 
EC 62 06 3 2 , Att. 1, Pg. 1 9 3 of 267 RB S ma ll 4PD T M e dium 24PDT Features * AC and DC coils, latching and non-latching. * 4PDT th ro u gh 24 PDT conta c t arrangements. * Contacts will not chatter when relays are subjected
to high-im pa ct shock blows of 2000 ft.-lbs. Contact Data Ar r ang e m ents: 4 Form C (4PDT) through 24 Form C (24PDT). Contact Ratings Single Contacts Two Contacts in Se rie s 10A. 11 5VAC 3A , 440VAC 3A, 28VDC 15A, 1 15VAC O.BA, 125VDC 1 .SA , 125VDC The above A C contact ratings are based on contact loa ds hav i ng a 50% power factor. The DC co ntact r atings are based on resist ive loads. Contact S e ct i on F IX ED CO NTA CT REPORT NO.: REP-424-00B*RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE J1 OF J2 MOR series 10 Amp Rotary Relay For Demanding
Shock & Vibration
Applications
Ope r ate Data @ 25&deg;C I Typ e Typ. Oper a t e Time (m s) Small AC Non*Latching
5 to 12 Sm all DC Non-Latching 15 to 30 Small AC Lat chi ng 6 to 1 2 Small DC Lat ch ing 10 t o 16 Medium AC Non-Latching
6 to 1 2 ! Med iu m D C Non-Latching
65 to 90 I Med i um AC Lat c h i ng S to 14 Medium D C Latch i ng 30 t o SO f:(/CO j Ele crronics Typ. Rele as e Time (m s) 5 to 1S 5 to 15 N/A N/A 6 t o 20 10 to 30 N/A N/A L a tch i ng T w o-Posi ti on Typ es: E xc ep t for t he lat chi ng feature, MOR latching re l ays utilize the same general construction
as non-latching
ty pes. They ha ve two se t s of coils and prov ide a latching two-po sition operat i on. Contacts Shown With CoR 1*2 De-Ene rg ized and Coil 3-4 Energ ized. Environm e ntal Data Temperature
Range: St andard models: o*c to +65'C Spec ial order models: o*c to +90&deg;C. Mec h anical Data T e rmin a t i o n: #5-40 screw termina l s supplied. W ei g h t (App r o x.): S mall-4 & 8PDT: 32 oz. (0.914 kg); 12PD T: 33 oz. (0.9 43 kg). M e dium -16PDT: 72 oz. (2.04 k g); 24PDT: 74 oz. (2.10 kg). Ordering Information
and Coil Cha r acte r is t ics -No m ode l s in th is s e r ie s are m a i ntained in stock. T y pe Pa rt Num b er C on t ac t s C oll Voltag e Co ll C u rr e n t D C Coll Co ll Pow e r* B re akdow n (60 H z. for AC) (Amp s) Res is tan ce (Ohms) (Watts) (Volt s RMS) S mall MDR-131-1 4PDT 115VAC 0.2 15 66 6.5 1 , 230 N on-MDR-131-2 4PDT 440VAC 0.045 1,256 5.1 1 ,S 80 Latc h i n g MDR-135-1 4PDT 2 SVDC 0.362 76 10.0 1.308 MDR-1 37-S 4PDT 125VDC 0.0S2 1 ,520 10.3 2 , 375 MDR-134-1 SPOT 115VAC 0.215 66 6.5 1,230 MDR-134-2
SPOT 4 4 0VAC 0.045 1,2 56 5.1 1 , SSO MDR-136-1
SPOT 2SV DC 0.362 76 10.0 1,30S MDR-13S-S
SPOT 125VDC O.OS2 1 ,520 1 0.3 2, 375 MDR-163-1 12PDT 115VAC 0.230 62 6.9 1 , 230 MDR-163-2 12PDT 440VAC 0.055 940 6.3 1.SSO M e d i um MDR-170-1 16PDT 1 15 VAC 0.620 S.4 17.0 1 , 230 Non -MDR-170-2
16PDT 440VAC 0.1 60 107 1 7.0 1.SSO Latchi n g MDR-172-1
16PDT 2SV D C 0.66 7 42 1S.7 1.3 0S MDR-1 73-1 16PDT 1 25V DC 0.125 1.024 16.0 2.375 MDR-141-1 24PDT 115VAC 0.620 S.4 17.0 1 , 230 MD R-141-2 24PD T 440VAC 0.1 60 107 17.0 1 , SSO MDR-167-1 24PDT 2SV DC 0.66 7 42 1 S.7 1 , 30S MDR-142-1 24PDT 12 5V DC 0.125 1,024 1 6.0 2 , 375 Small MDR-67-2 4PDT 115VAC 0.1 50 210 5.5 1,230 La tching MDR-409 1 4PDT 440VAC 0.02 0 4 , 500 3.0 1 , SSO MDR-67-3 4PDT 2SV D C 0.778 36 21.S 1,30S MDR-5060 4PDT 125VDC 0.164 760 20.6 2,375 MDR-4076 SPOT 115VAC 0.150 210 5.5 1 , 230 MDR-4092 SPOT 440VA C 0.020 4,500 3.0 1 , 8SO MDR-5 03 5 SPOT 2S VDC 0.77S 36 2 1.S 1,30S MDR-50 6 1 SPOT 125V D C 0.164 760 20.6 2.375 Me dium MDR-6064 12PDT 115VAC 0.3SO 24 12.0 1 , 23 0 Latch ing MDR-6065 12PDT 440VAC 0.055 540 5.7 1 , SSO MDR-7020 12PDT 2SV DC 0.316 SS.6 S.S 1 , 308 MDR-7035 12PDT 125VDC 0.083 1 ,5 00 10.4 2 , 375 MDR-66-4 16PDT 115VAC 0.3SO 24 12.0 1 , 230 MDR-6066 16PDT 440VAC 0.055 540 5.7 1 , 8SO MDR-7025 16PDT 28VDC 0.316 88.6 s.s 1 ,30S MDR-7036 16PDT 125V DC 0.0S3 1 , 500 10.4 2 , 375 Actual Wa l t me ter readings 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 194 of 2 6 7 O utline Dimen s i o ns Tolerances:
Decimals t .010 (+/- .25) Unless Otherwise
Specified
Small Models Medium Mode l s 2 COI L .281 +/- .005 D I A. (7.1 4 +/- .13) 4 HOLES T yco E lect ronics C or poration -P&B , W i nston-Sale
m. N C 27 10 2 Techni c al Support Cente r: 1-800-52 2-67 52, www.pandbrelays
.com O ve r all H ei ght 4POT 3.13. (79.5mm) Max. SPOT 3.53" (89.7mm) Max. 12PDT 3.ss* (98.6mm) Max. REPORT NO.: REP-424-008
-RP1 REVISION:
03 PAGE .J2 OF .12 1:qco / Et ec rronic s Coil and Conlact Termi nal Screws #5-40 Supplied 5 4 COIL O verall H e i g ht 1 2 P O T 4.6 3" (117.6mm) M a x. 1 6 PO T 5.00" (1 27.0mm) Max. 24 P OT 5.7 5" (1 46. lmm) Max. Co il and Contac t Terminal Screws #5-4 0 Supplied S pe c i fi c at ions and ava i lab il ity s ub jec t to change w itho ut noti c e. 1 3C6370 Pr i n t e d i n U.S.A. IH/5-01 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 195 of 267 ...... << )
S$T-2000A/H
Series Speed Switches/
Transmitters
SST-2000ATM
and SST-2000HTH
Series Speed
mitters receive signal input from a passive or active magnetic pickup, shaft encoder, cQn*tact
ffowmetet;
etc., ta provide proportional
analog outputs and either 0, 2, or 4 relay trip setpoints.
2-Year Warran*ty
FEATURES * Proportional
outputs cf ellher4-2[}
mA (standard), 0-5 Vdc, or 0-1 O Vdr: are fleld-setectable..
Standard 0-1 rnA<:!t:
output included, * Models avallablewlth
ur:i tot'our alarm'setpolnt.s.
* F'leld-selectable
1requency
range. * Field*adJustabla
sensltlvity
control. *
for many
of sensors, Including
conls.ct closure Input, * Repeateroutput
drf ven nounlera and
digital
such as Dynalco's
and SPD-700. * Regu!:ated
14 Vdo ou1put powers acilve pickups (e.g. MS 10), acaessarle$, . an.d dlgltat meters such as D PM-1 {15 arMTH-1.o:m, and the 12 Vdc ven;;lons
of lhe fr1tema.lly
Hghted SP Dw 1 ODL a l1d
* Alarms ara ftehH:onflgurnbta
for DPDT (SST-2400Aor-H
only),
underspaed, energize.
de-energize, latch, auto-reset.
* I nleg ralVERIFY, roquiros exterrialrneter.
Permits v[ewl l'Jg and setting of :e.etpcfnt
veilu a without actuatiP1f)
the r-el ays .. REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K1 OF K37 VTIP MANL 0899F Page 1of4 CJVNALCO CONTROLS *THIRD PARTY APPROVALS
CSA (Canadrs.n
StandarrJs
AsS4ci1'iUon)
SST-20.0{)A
Gen era! certmcaHon:
LR 92270 SST-2llOOH
Cl. I, Div. 2, Grp. D
Appro'fl1f
oontfngent
upon housmg an $ST-2DOOH
&ifes
irl a
enckJsure.
CE (Conformlt6
&#xa3;urope{ln)
SST .. 2QOOA &
891336/EEC,
lnc!"u5trfal;
72/23JEEC, Low Volta.ge
ABS. (Am9rloan
BurC1au of Sflippfng)
s ST -2DOOA Serles only Nnerican Burea lJ of Shlpplng:
type ap prnva1 for use In cla,ssS<l
* Input Frequency:
Full-."Jcale
from 0-0.1 Hz (8 pulses per ml.nuta} to Q-50 1 000 Hz. * Function:
Converts fre:quency
Input (spaed, rate) Into rlnaar pr-opatt1onal
do Olltp ut. Provides ararm setpu:nta
for overA afld unde;rspeed
control and for sequentta1
1 =itartup;
and shutdown swihlhing.
* AplJHc:ati(:;tis:
rncludas
!JP drivers, !nstrumentatl<in, precess control, n:icordin9
1 meesurement.
* Signal Sonrc:as;
1nc1udasmsgnetioplckups, a.a generators, contant closures, photocells.
* Output Range Ca pabmty: CXJmmt s-ourca up to fi[} mAdc output always i11oluded.
*Alarm Setpofnts:
Ava!lable
wlltl two or four rala.ys. Also availabJ a. 'With no
If ooly proportional
are requlred. 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 196 of 267 1*** S PEC.IFICATION
S \.. . ELECTRICAL
Input Slgrill.I
Frequancy
Range: Sranc'ard
input ranga is ffa ld...salectable
from 0-80 Hz to 0-:.!0 kHz. Rarigea as low as 0--0 .1 H;;i: up *ta fl-50 ,000 Hi are available "optlo ns. Wavaf<?.mi
can be pulsed,
square, lTL, or CMOS. Full-scale
frequencyadjusWble
Using
and a calibration
pcte.ntrcimeter
underneath
tha oovet plate. Input Slgnal S&nsitlvny:
Fle!d-e.dfusfab1e
1rom
5 tnVrms to 100. mVl'ms by
potentiomater.
Normal factory se-tting Iii 25mVrrns.
Jumt;iarlrigtetrnin1;1130to
1 f
Uta unit to a 1.Q Volt
for.operation
from logio levels, shaftencodera, Dynalco PG-27'8pulssr, or oontaci closures.
Maxlmum pennl$5il:ile
signal la 50 Vrms for the standard unit lnpl.rt. tni.pedance-;
Naar1y
at IPW slfjnal levers; a minimum of 1 0 k&l at
levels exceed Ing +15.0 Y peak or*-1.0 V pe<lk. Powe:r: 115 Vao +/-10%, 47-420. Hz/22-30 Vdc, maximum 5* W or 150 mAdo. Optloool;
:220 Va.a, +/-10%, so1eo
Proportional
output: 4-20 mAdo, The maximum c*, load la 1 kn wlth the unit powered by 1151220 Vac or 30 Vdc; 750 ohms w[th the unit powered by 22 Vdc, The maxlmum lpad
llM<'lr between 22 Vdc anc:i 30 Vdo. Switches be rsaath tha cover plate allow ael1;1t!tlot1
of 0-S Vd c:ror D-.1 o Vdc for use into an external load resl.'ltar.ce
of20 kQ or higher. Other oustorn rarl{los are avalk1ble, Tho ouiput cmrenl is ind'apsncient
cif [pad resistance
up to U,e rated JoaQ ra!:llsfa
nee. span and zero adju5.tment
poteritio:mete{s
ar:e located be.neath th.e fror.it c:ove r pll'te. They minimUh1 !ild)Ui;lment
of ;1:5% of fUll-scala, AulCillary
Meter Output: Praportionat tnAdo, flltsted, for meter or
r k1ads up to 750 o. A
adlustrnent
po1entiometer
allows oalibretlon
for partlcular
1)"1eter used. If a* m(;)ter Is not connl3cted, these terminills
yield 1rn unloaded
output of
Vdc with an Internal
of
10 kn. Supply Olrlput: Regulatecl
+14 Vdc (+/-6%}, al termlnala
11{+) and 4(....:):
maximum load 40 mAdo.
Output:. Square wave 14 v*paak*tny
peak. posiWe at ten:nln;;ils
2S and 4 to operate sTgn;;;il-powerad
tachometers
c* SPD-100 and SPD-700. Output uaa'b1e* as a high ravel s[gnal source. for counters, ate. Maximum lot'ld: 2 mA. REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K2 OF K37 VTIP MANL OS9BF Page2 of4 Outp"ut Ripple ahd Noh1e: 0.1 % of full*scale
* maximum over 10% to 100% of
Verlfylng
&tpolnis:
No Input sif)MI rsqllired.
Jurnperln-g
spe-olflc
terminals
overrides
t!ie 0-1 mA
rnst.er output at termil11!1.ls
7 and a; insmad, lhe aotus I setpolnt value Is output and viewed lls11'1g ar:i eitt&ma.I
me:ter.at
1erm)nal 7 and a. Forexan1)le, Jurnpering
tt:nmlnati;;
12 an* d 1 e provides ttie vatU.e Of .setpoio11
et"termlnals
7
8. Thhrnllows
viewing. artd adJ 1.1 sting relay setpol nts without havrng to run* the eriglne. (Ul'llt must be powered.)
Response
150 mflliseconds, *10% to 90% rise, is slahdatd.
frequemcyranges
below 80 Hz are proportionally
slower. Linearity:
0.1 % of full-scale
{O.O!i % , typical}, all outputs.
Less than 0.06% of full-.iicale
change. wlth a.10% change. ln supply voltage. The typloar temperature
oaefflcletit
Is +/-D.G1%
(:tll,01B%
RELAYS t.oglc; Field-programmable
PY s.wtt<:::he$
tor oversp 13E.ld, u rspee.d, ene1rglz.e,
latoh, auto-res$t, and
st1rltts:
Contact rating: 6.0 A.@ 28 Vdc or 115 Vac (roW;tive),*
2.0 A @ Vaet. Maxrmum fnd1.1fllivfJ
/otld 75 Vc:fc, MM, Into fiQ[Jml-f, for up ra 100,000 t;YW.es,*
SPOT. tt "H"
C'1ntaal ratkig; 5 A
@ 24 Vdi::,* .1. 0 A @ 120 Vac,* 0.5 A@ 220 SPDT/ .,,,FlJr DPDT. relays 1 4i 3 tind 2 & 4 wMk
iois
DP&#xa3;ff mps. Ala;rm* .Setpolnt!l;
Relay satpoints
'!are easlty adjustable
ualng 25--tvrn Qarmet
Potenllomeoor
oojuslments
are
throL19h holee In tt\e <::over*p1ata.
Hysteresis (dlff'ep:infial
between pulHn arid dropout) ls typically
1% or full-scale
fraq\,Jency.
INl&:A.NAL.CO:M
MONSf lSOLA TION: Signal.Input sltje, tarmltoaJ
6} Is common the auxlliary
01Jtput (!ow sida, terminal 7), 1o de:: supply (termloaf
4 )1 andto1he r.naltJ pn.:,iportlt:mal
output low slda {1e rmrnal 9 ). Relay o:mtacts are a1WaY$ Isolated, a. Whet"I powered wlth*ac; all oJrou ltry Is
from Ille power Una by the bullt*in supply1ransformer, b. ViJhen powered with de, ihe transmrtteroutput
Is not ieoJe.ted
from the de power srnuce. f!i.J"ry load driven by the transmlt!.er (I.a. recorder, oonlroller, ,,,,,.--
0 .... , etc.) mu$t
the same-common as tile negative ( ... ../
of lhe de supply ot"sflQulcl
have an
no*atlng inp!.it
totally laolatad frpm lhe do "i *i 
' EC 620632, Att. 1, 197 of 267 (RB.Unj
Isaltltt(tn
-COHfllt11tdl
power source ppwer!11g .ltle transmitter.
A locp isolator should be &#xb5;sad
appUcatlons.
A 6i ghel
tra11eformar
opthm ia avan iible to Isolate tt1e tranamltter
Input rrom Iha proba or sensor. Al.ARM DlSABLE: Jumperlng
terminal 31 to terminal 7 disables all alarms, aJlowlns for startup w ndftlons and
funcllons.
ALARM ResET:
Qfterminal
32 totennlnal
7 resat!! aitl latclisd alarm5. Petmanent
Jumpsrlng
all latehlng alarms to reset OPTIONS
XP and NEMA rated enclosures
ere aval lebfe, OPEN PICKUP; Relay 1 swlmties In
open Qr dlsconnected
magnetic plcli:up.
Relay 1 wm stltl rooctwhen
ltasetpolnt:smersed.
NOTE: Not REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K3 OF K37 VTIP MANL 0899F Page 3 of4 tntflllab19
with signal lso!atkm transfmmeroptlon..
PNl:&#xb5;MATIC:
TRtP; PU1$e& relay 1 rot 100 rnllllsac:onds;
trips optional Dynalco' SPVAioQ Solan old Pneumatic::
varva on ov.arspeed.
UNDERSP!:;EP
CLASS LOGrc: Atrne re-lay2 as satpolnt.
2 is* traverse-cl
on trioreaslng
spaed. Pulsas telay 2 as ss1polnt 2 fa traversed
ori decreasing
spee,d. Use for tripping th,& pneumatic
on underspead
or for gMerBI underu
e!eotiical
s.hutdown.
EXPANDED SCALE 1 NPUT: Provides full meter outpllC, full proportional
output, and Ml setpolnt range over a 11mlted Input range e, r1 *. rnA a.nd 4-20 mA overaoo...1000
H:z. rnputtrequericy.
ENVIRONMENTAL
Tl:M?E RATURE
to +71oC} oparaUng:.
-40"F to
(-40oe to +82QC} storage. Weight: 2.6 lbs {1, 17 HOWTOORDER
A l11o1Jgh numy SST-2000,A
& SST-ZOOQH
parameters fleld*progremrnabla, most lll'lifs are 11e\ at th1:;i factory. Sta.rtdard
f>DW1ir: 115 Vact22.-;JO
Vdc. [SBi.I Item (r) fer optional power,] * Please-sPf!olfy;
1. FuU-soale
fraqueni:::y
for e:<ample:
0-1 000 Hz com;Jtipond&
to meter display
cf0-2000 rpm. *
slgnal frequeacy
{Ha:) = B!U-sr;afa
rpm X no,
gear ful;lth ao *Standard
from 0-BIJ to 0-...2\J l<Hz, *Sae S(g) for nonstandard
ranges. 2. Srghal
Sea B(t) & B(m) for optional 'nf}uts. 3. Specify Moclet: (Se9 Tf'J{td*P<Rty
Appm11t1!s, front page)&deg; [S&#xa3;Wond dfgft = numlJ(Jr ofsetpolnts}
SST-WOOA or SS7;2000H
:<:!! 0 Setpolnts
SST-2.200A
or SST-20 OOH "" 2 Se1polnts
or lS
= 4 S&tpolnts
4. Specify for
relay Htpoin'l l a) ValLJe* of the setpoint * b/ OvarspHd or undsrspeed
alarm c Et1er9l2es
or dei-energfzGs
C!n alarm d Autcimatlc
or !atoning on ararrn (e.) DPDT relay function {See 8(f)1 s .. Propi:Jrtlonal
output (e.g. 4-2.0 rnA) o\lgr-tha
fUll"'S{lale
ftequehcy
rariga Ii pacified lh Item i. G. Specify any peripheral
eriulptl'le-l'lt
to be furnished
e,g. magnetic pickup, pulsar, re')'lote
analog meter, remote dlgltal meter, '1. Optional el'lclosutn:XP
and NEMAtated
e11crosurea
avaUabJe.
:1 8. Speelfy optional features
r;>PT(ON_S (above) for dstaJJs. {iii) Sigrial Isolation
transformer, (b) Signal ls.olatioll
and lnput llmlt[ng resistor ro sense ttle fraqtieooy (l F a pow&r n11e. (SpeoifY.
lnpllt voltage rarigei) (c) Opan Plcl<up Alarming on setpoint 1, ( d) Set up r4'1La:y_
1 to transfer fer only 1 ()Cl mill Isa cQ n as oil over&pei:1d:
1,1sed tQ pwlse DY!lafoo'sSolen-0id
PneurnatJc
Valve spy. *. 200. ( e) . Set u tl re lay 2 for CI a.as !ogle ll"fl".l !lifer for tinly , 100 mllllseoond$
ott underspeed. (f) OPDT for ralays 1 and 2 avalla.ble
rmly on four .setpe>lnt
unfts; provides.two
DPDT relays. (gj Nonstandard
rnput ranges
D-0: 1 Hz; maxtmurri:
0-50,000 Hz). . (h) Expanded scale lriput. Speclfy di splay range. (j) 220 vao, +/-10%, 501*10 Hz/22-ao Vdc. Ci) C1JStom proportions.I
output 11'nge (:50 mA @ :20 V, maximum, 1 (k) Custom meter outpllt
(2 mA @ 10 V, tnaxirnutn).
*G) Desensitized
input, . trl) Nonstendard
{e.g. TTL, contact closure} Input signal. * i I I ' ' 
EC 62 0 632, Att. 1, Pg. 198 of 2 67 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 ( REVISION:
03 I PAGE K4 OF K37 CON,..ECTION
DIAGRAM VTIP MANL 0899F Page 4 of 4 +USE SHtELDEO CABl..E:
Conneot ungre>undtJd
shleld to
4. To
electrical
noise lntelference, route power Ihle 21nd ;:ill relay c;onnactlons
aaparate'ly
from the !ilgn.al, rnflter, and re:nt Hna5. CAUTION: If ahlald (;)ontacts
ground, a ground loop may oc:cur; damage to thei unit can result
4 1 6, 7, afld 9 ats lntema I
ed togeth!'lrto
oommon. +A11y .slngie VERIFY satpol11t .jumper will enable tha ccrreu apom:llng
&etpornt*
to be displayed
on a meter oonnaoted
to tetminats
7 and 6. Drawings shown are fdenticaf
far both an SST-2400A
or SST-2400H '"'i'irl'iiiiii'T,.
1 Z J i sir;:3M *i:t-13 i : ,......
14 I I I MTPOlllT a I ; j
'i &deg;l"' 1 !j" .. .i ....
......
.... 111! 'VIIUPY41TPlllHU
* *** *1 2 *** 3 4-SETPOINT ADJUSTMENTS
1lll 1'10
:rl NO :
2!J. NO :; RErY Z8 NO 29 -n'\'lllQlmvt
BC> 3t
32
RELAY AND WIR,NG DJAGRAM
OUTLINE DRAWlNG
tn l11ch!!.8 (cm) SSi*:ulOOA
andSST-20CIDli MltlemllrtJi
1Jf 0)1[113lco
Conlrol!i.
DYNALCO CCJJllTiIDLS
RESERVES THE RIGHT TO CHANGE:-WESE
SPfCIFICATIONS
WITHOUT t-lO-:-IGi:;.
FOR. GOMPL!=.rE
Sf'ECIFICATION
INfORMAilON,
A.DYNA!..CO
REPRSS"ENTATIVE.
() r*' ***--....
C...J 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 199 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE KS OF K37 ff......._, l.l, ' ....... * SST-2000 Series ' VTIP MANL ssr .. 2000 Page 1 of 33 Universal
Speed
& Speed Transmitter
An Dperator 1 s Guide* ., r I I I I I ! 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 200 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
c:. ( \. ........ ii *I REVISION:
03 I iPAGE K6 OF K37 VTIP MANL SST-2000 c**-'\ * Page 2 of 33 ) .........
Copy1tgltt
Specifications
and info.rmation
herein are subject to change without noti,ce. D;tna1co Contmls reserves the-rlgbe
to make change5 to eguipment.de:3m&deg;bed
herein tO improve; function or design. Although infun.nation
in this manual has been. carefully
revie\vcd
and is believed to betcliable, Dyna.ko Controls
any liab.ility .fotspecial,
o:r consequential a.rising out of the application
or use of the equi:i;ment
described
Wein. Warranty ts limited and cannot exceed.the
prl.Ce pttidforthe
prod&#xb5;ct upOJ:L V?hldt -warranty
is based. Cop:Yrigbt
@2001. All ;rlg11Ui reserved.
SST-2200A, SST-2400H .are trademarks
of Dynalco Controls.
Dynalco Controls 3690 N. W.-53rd Street, Fort Lauderdale, F1.. 33.309 U.S.A . * (9:54) 73M300 Fax (954)
www.dyrialco.CPm.
* m.ailbo:ii:@dyn,a!co.com
Printed in U.S.A. .. ' ,, ...... .. L . ._,,1 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 201 of 267 Contents REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K? OF K37 VTIP .MANL SST-2000 Page 3of33 Chapter 1 Gettins Started 1 About yout speed sw:itc.'l:!. . * . . . . .
* . . . ... _ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
* . .... , 2 Models. , ........ , ...........................................
4 Features .........................................................
4 Speci.fiCEitio?lS
..... ' . "' I .. .. .. .. * * " * * .. II * I .. * .. .. * * I * * * * * * * * * * I * * * * * I **** 5 Chapter 2 lnSitaU1ng
the SST .. zOOONH 9 MOlJiltin.g
the unit * * * .. ' ' * 1 ,. " * * , " " .. " .. " * .. " " " + r .. * " * * * ** * * " * * * " r r 1 J Q .About Electrical
Connections
...*. _ . * . . . . . . . . . .
* . . . . * . , .*..*...*
10 Connectillg
Signal Input&#xa3;. , *.*................... , .. , ... ! ....... 11 Chapter 3 Powering
Devices 13 Powering an S'.PD-100, .. 100, ()!"&#xa2;her freque.Q.cy
ins!ruments , , ..... , 14 UsingDPM-105
meters a5 external s_pei:::dindicatoi:s , ***.* , ...**. , .*.* 14 Powering Zero Velocity Pickups and Othct" Loads ....**.*.... , ..**** 16 Driving an SPV-200 Solenoid Pneumatic
Valve ............***...*..
17 Chapter 4 Calibrating
the Speed Switch . 19 Locating the prognunnting
switch inshuctions
................... , .. 20 Cha:iigfng
the
iapu.t frequency
range ......*................
21 Input frequency
range less than 80 Hz full-scale . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
... 21 Input frequeru!)'
range.grearerthl'm
2Qt000 Hz full-!K!ale
*.*..... : ....... 21
the SST *2000A/,H
....................... , ......*......
22 Calibrating
the 4*20 mA l'ropo.rtional
Output . , ..*..**..**.*
f ***.* , . 24 Progi:runo:rlng
Set Poinm and Rclays .* , ***. , * , .*....... , .. , , *..... 25 Adjusting
Signal Sensitiv.ity . . . . * . . . . * . . . . . . . .
.. . . . . . . . . . .
* . . . .... 2 7 Response Time ......... , ................. , , .........*.*.....
28 Adjusting
Indhi.dTJal
Set :Points . . * . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
...*..*.*....*
28 Verlfylng
Sef.t:ointValllelj. , , .............. , ................ , ... :n Adjusting
Set Foint Values .........*........
* .................. , 32 m 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 202: of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE KS OF K37 _______ vr_._1P_M_A_N_L_s_s_r_-2_o_oo
______ Pa_g_e 4 of 33 () 1 --c .. ( \ .. Chapter Getting Started *i I .) I (,) 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 203 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K9 OF K37 ( ,.' -** () ChaRter 1 About your speed switch VTIP MANL SST
Page S of 33 2 WARmNG * When the SST*2000AIH
Ser1es Spee:J Swi.tchJTransmitter
is tised as the primary overspeed
shutdovm devic:e, it must be. tested regularly.
The SST *2000A.IH
serie;s is a speed switch signal &#xb5;-ansmitter
that provides alarm set points for overw and 1.lildetspeed
ro.ntra1 fer sequet..tlal, startup, and shutdown switdring
for: How .it works * engine*s * macwnes t * II? drivers * .:inst:ruinentatitm.
+ process control + * recilrdins
+ measurement
The SST-2000A/H
accepts a
*freq_uency
input value from Q-0.1 H;z; (6
per millut.e)
ta
Hz,
0-80 Hz: to 0-20,000 Hz. Examples of input devices inclu.de:
+ passive or active magnetic pich.tp$ *, shaft encoderi.l
t * contact cl<:l!:W:es
t _flow meters * photoceUs
The speed switch converts frequency
input (speed 1 rate) into linear proportional
dcoutpllts:
+ Q-.-1 mA
.. meter out) * 4-20 mA (:standard*
proportiqnal
out} +* 0-5'\rdc (switch selectable)
+ 0-l 0 V de {swjtcb. !!electable)
It provides 0, 2 1 or 4 re)ay trip set points {depending
on the model) 
I I EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 204 of 267 C. (_ ... / \_ Physical Dfmensttms .Fii:c. 1-1 Top s1de v{ew 01' the SST-2000A/H. .Dimeruions
1n loc;hes
Sp_e<:ta L e.xpt<1stori
pro of* housfngs kits (cornpletli!
with mountiri!!
hardwilr6') also avaHal>le.
5ee }iP rat!'ld housings on pZl&e 6. I 3.ltl
I 3.M REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K10 OF K37 Get.tins Started VTIP MANL SST-2000 {'\
6 of33 \. I ...... * ----(.lj.2)
--1.111 ---* (4.e' !  _Lr..=::;;================::::'.J
3 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 205 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K11 OF K37 Cha.pier 1 Models Features 4 Model No. Of Set Points lrd Party Certtficatlon(s}
VflP MANL SST-2000 Page7 of33 A
-stand(j"rd
rel<<ys SST-1.000A
0 CSA: general certlf1ce.tlon
LR 9-22.70 SS"!'.*22.00A
2. A BS: type
CE: B9'/336[EEC, Light Industrial
SST-2.400A
4 CE: 72./2 3 /EEC, Low Voltage Dfiec:tf\le
11
hermfttcally
sealed relayg SS'r-2.000H
0 CSA:. Class D1v, Z, Grp. 0.t l.R *f5322* I .. SST-:1.200ii
2. C.E: 89/J.36fEEC, Light lndus:trliil
c"E; 72123 /EEC, Low Vol tageo Di rec:t1ve SST-l400H
4
cont1nQent
upon hou5!ns. ;;1n SST*2001JH
d1Mce in l'l CSA*r;:ertmed
I anclcs.ura.
..
F.fel!f*program1m1,t>le
for: iilnsors, 1nc.lud1ng
contact tlosure Input, Sources magnetic p1ckupio, ac
c:ontoc.t
photoc-etb.
Input * Fllll*scal@
vallles from D*O, 1 Ht. (6 pub;.e!5lrninute)
to 0*20 kHz. Frequenc;y
t
ranl!e and
control. Alarm Set 0 SST*2000A/H
only proport:iooa!
output is req1.11:red)
Potnts 2. SST* 2200A/t:I
: 4 SST* 240QAIH Ati!rm Atarmg are fie1d*c::orif1g1.1rable
for overspeed, undetspeed
1 Settirigs
onel'i!:U;t.
de*energiz.e
j tatd1, aoto* reset. Alm-m Disable au atarrn.'i (far $tgrtup c-ond1tk>n.s
and
functions)
D{sabla. Ah1rm Reset t
aleirms * Permane11tly
converts all
alarms to 11.ata*reset
Set Point lnt<!igral
VERtFY perrn1ts vlew1fli an.d
ohet po1nt vat1Je Verifieatiori
without
the
a11
meter.
Q-1 mA and +20 rnA {st11ndard)
Outputs 0-5 Vdi:: or 0-10 Vrlc (ftetd*selectable
l .. Output &epell!ter
O'Lltput drlves counters and self*powered
tacho!l1eters, P{]wer Regulated
14 Vdc output power.i; acttve pkkups; acces:soriets, lind meters (e.g. DPM-105; MTH-1030;
SPD*100L;
LST*100L).
I Out pot Currtirtt
sr:1UiC.ft
up to 50 mAdc output always
Rang-e* 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 206 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K12 OF K37 Specifications
Input Sfgnat Frequency
; Wavefnrm:ti
Siijnal
Input Impedance
Power Input ? rp portion.a
I Oug>lJ!. c*** Output currant
11df ,; Awdlfary
Output Supply Output Repeater Output
Ripplrt an<l Moise Response Tl me Lfnear{ty ( StabHity Getting Started VTIP MANL ssr .. 2o!lo () Page 8 of 33 **-*** t 0*20 \l.Hi (staCJdard) (fteld*adjustable)
+ D*0.1 Hi; (spec{al order)" + 0-80 H:i:: (s,podal order} t O*SOK Hz (speda.l order} ' t AccBpt:1 pulsed, sinusoldal, square, iTL. or CMOS * 2.5
seltil'.IS)
+ .:5 mVrms to mo rnVrnis (fleld*adjustable)
* t 50 Vrms <maximum for standard untts) + 1.0 volt threshold (requires
fnput
t Nearly infinfte at low $lgnal
* 1 O kn {min, l at 5i'ilt"l al:; wi:c:eedlog
'f'.1 !i. 0 V peak, -1. 0 V pei;1k. + 115 VaC: :1:10%, 47*420 1-z * 22-30 \Ide:, ma)(lm'llm
5WGr150 mAd't: + 220 Va.c, 50/60 Hi: (optional)
t 0-1 rnAdc
** 4*20
: * (1-5 Vdc.or 0-10Ydi;: (fte!d*sl'!lP.Ct()ble;
for external la:ad 20 r.n. or higlier) i *Custom ran11es-Ava1lable
MAXIM.UM LOAD t 1 l<.n with. 1151 220 Vac or 30 Vik power + 75 O Cl hrm wtth 22 Vd c power t
r between 22 af\d JO Vdc Independent
Qf load resistance
up ta tile rated load resistance
I :1:5% (m1n1rnum}
of ft.11l--sa1te
i .Proportional
0-1 mAdc, fittered.
for ineter or recorder kiads up to 750 n. Regulated
+14 Vdc .:1:5%; 40 rnAdc: (maximum load} ..
wave 14 V peak.*(o*pe1:1k, iero based,
go-his o. ti of full-sc.a.le
maxJmum over 10% to
of futl*scale, 150 mmiseconds, 10% to rise (standard).
Full*:1c:11le
ranges bel<M ao Hz are propor:t1onally
-0. i % offull-sc:ale
{0.05%,
all oUtpllts.
,,. Less tnan 0.05% of fuU-scatec.lla.ngewfth
a 10%
1n supply
Temp. coeff,
% per * F <:1:0.01&%
per *q 5 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 207 of 267 Chapter 1 Relays Logh: A Serles
H Serles CQotact Rating Ahmn Pofnts Hysterests
Tr.ansformer
; l::NC-3000
ENC:-4000
ENC-5000 6 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K13 OF K37 VTIP MANL
Page 9of33 swltc.hes
for! t
t eMrgtm/de-energl2'.e
*
* SPST /l)PDr (2 DPDT set potnts rnaxtmum}
* 6.0 A @ 2.B Vdc or 115 Vac {rest$tiVe)
.. 2.0 A @ \lac + 1.0 A fnto 500 mH for up to 100,000 .cyi;[es t S?DP ' ,.For Dl'DT. REI (ay!i 1 ft. 3 a.'ld 2 e: 4 vrork together as
OPDT tr1ps. + SA (resii;.tive)
@ 2.4 Vdc:: + 1.0 A@ 120 Vac * 0,5 22.0 * SPDT" .,ror DP OT, Relays 1 a '.) and 2. et 4 work together .!ls :!iep-arate
DPDT trip:s, : Adjus.table, 2.5*tLltn
i:ermet potentiometers
t 1% of fuU-scale.frequenc:y
t Optlanal.
Isolates the transmltter
input from the
or sensor. XP Cast Houl;ling:
S"H x 10''W x 5" D; 1QO's Window+ P-ootton UL/CSA C:.\a:o;s
I, GroU(:fs CiD Clas:s II, Groups E,F,G MEMA 3,4 XP Cast Hous1ng: 8"H x 10''W x 5" D; 100's window UL/CSA. I, :Groups B,C, 0 cta.ss 11, Group$
f, G i tl.EMA J.4 Sheel Mt!ta:l 6"H x 9"W X4'1 Vi 1i No Wfndow Sheet Meta;l 8"H x 10"W :x Di NEMA 1'2; t-lo Wk1dow --x_p C11st
7"H x 9"Wx 5"o; No Window
Class 1 1 GrDups C,O;
II, Orcups E,fjG 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg .. 208 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K14 OF K37 c /" \. .... -Getting Started Opticn:s:
VTIP MANL *SST-2000 Page 10 of \ ... ../
.............
--.__, EnclorPJires
Open Pfckup XP and HEMA rated
are available.
Relay 1 swltche? In.the event of an opEln or dtmmnecteci
magnetic pkkup. Relay 1 wlll st1lt react when 1ts point 1li tn1versed
{field* configu ra bte).
Not a*iai lab le with stg;nal f sp lation tran;f ormt;:r _optllon.
Pneumatic
Trlp Pulser;. relay 1for100 mm1sllcand!i
Underspeed
C1*u:i: nc:" l.:.ogiC Expanded Sc:;al* hlpUl Environ mentlil Temperature
Range Weight Trips
SPV-2.00 Solenoid Pneumatic
Valve on overspe!ed (optional)
Arms rela.y 2 as set point 2 1s traversed
on 1ncreas1ng
speed, Pul$es relay 2 l'IS :set po1rit .2. 1:s
on dec:reasins
spel!{j. for tripping t.he pneumatic
SPV*20[} Oil underspeed
or for ge:1eraL underspeed
electrfc:a.t
shlJtdown.
F'rovldes
full meter output, full prc:pol'liotial*output, and full set point range over a l1mited ft'lput range e.g. 0-1 mA and 4-t.O mA ovar 800*1000 Hz {nput frequency.
.40* F ta 11-160"F (-4o*c to -1'71 *c:;*) operatins
-..:10* F to ..
F (-.40 *c to +82"C)
2.6 llls (1, 17 kg} 7 ....... (' 'j \ *' ., ... 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 209 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 , REVISION:
03 I :PAGE K15 OF K37 VTIP MANL SST-2000 p*ags 11.of 33 Chapter 2 lnstalli.ng
the SST-2000A/H
*! 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 210 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I P.AGE K16 OF K37 \ ... * t ' I '* Chapter 2 Mounting the unit VTIP MANL SST-2000
Page 12 of 33 / The SST-2000A/E
ls imtaned "Using standard hand tools. It is generally
fo a panel or enclosure
uslttg stari dard pntctices.
About Electrical
Connections
Internal Commons, 'solation
10 WARNING: AVOID DArAAGE W.Hrn DC-POWf.REI)
Install-a
current toop 1solator between the 4-ZOmA output and the load if the toad does not reference
the same common a,s the SST-ZOOOAIH
* . Signal inpu.t (low
terminal 6) .is common to the arutil:iatY.
output (low side.: temtlnal 7), to the de supply (tei;nllnal4)t
and to fueltlain:proportional
output low s:ide (terminal Rela.y contacts are always .isclated
When p01Wll't!d
1vith m:: all cirruitry
is isolated from the power line by the built-in supply transfonner
lf'htn powered wklt rk! the tta.nsmltter
01.ttput is f'Jor. isolated from the d{: power sotn'Ce. Any load driven 'by the transmitter (i.e. reoord.eri
controller, etc.) must have
common as the negative sick of the dc.supp!y.
IDs.tall a loop isoiator hetli\'CCJ:l
the 4-20mA .output and the load if the load does ntlt
same oommcn as the SST*2000.
Flg. 2-1 Electrical
Connection
oraW'ina.
ai e ill) II Use gl)ielded
cabltl': ll:il ... 'r' 11) KO shj eld t<i termfn:al
4.
110 Ro*uw
Une a:nd
.!ill!!J.fL.
"&deg;* l relay t;Ortnectio
ns
NO :l'IJIJfJ\fi!
separate fro rn signal IHl!llA &#xa9; meter and reset U11es
..
to p reverit elec:trical
NO, &#xa9; @ nofse ltiterterence. ' lenninats
4, 6, 1i and. ...
O,.'fl'(.T
'71 c Rl:S.fl\'
l'IQ,i 9 a ref interni!illY
tied *..... *-**** ....*..
l. &#xa9;1 @ ;2.f) NG
tc
[ r *-* ... 11mtllrrr.t
i ts! lllil'WJllQ.JM'VT
comrnoll unles.s unit i * , .........
::ro M!>Elll'O"TBWI
""&deg; ! i ' .. ( >.rl.t"Sn.u;:'!Ts
OJH Ul*v.410.Cl11'>E<IOlll
hcis signal
.$1 -11111*111\
TDlJNll""-'
: I : ' JQP>>...U:A\'_.\INl.I&sect;
tntmformer.
Ill that
mi:
case, terminal 61s * f.s.ola.ted, ....... __ , ... , -* .. I \ \ 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 211 of 267 REPORT NO.: :REP-424-008-RP1 ' ....... Connecting
Signal Inputs Connecting
a .. 278 Pulser , REVISION:
03 I PAGE K17 OF K37 Install 1ng the SST --2 OOOA/ H VTIP MANL
13 of 33 CoMeci: eignal source Comm.on to terminal 6 on the SST-2000A/H.
Connect sjgna1 HI to te.nninals
on the SST-2000AIH.
Fis. 2-2 Cormec:tinE
a PG-278 Pulsf'r to the SST-4000A/H.
Terminals
11 !Uld 30 an the SST-2000A/H
arejumpered
to create a one vo1t threshold.
11 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 2l 2 of 26 7 ( \.._ REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K18 OF K37 VTIP MANL SST-2000 Page 14of33 Chapter Powering External Devices () , .. .........
\ ) ........ 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 213 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
C) ,* Chapter 3 i REVISION:
03 I PAGE K19 OF K37 Powering an SPD-100, SPD*700 1 or other frequency
instrum*ents
VTIP MANL SST-2000 Page 1.5 or33 . The SST-2000A/H
has a repeater oulplit that C!Bh be used to p(.iwer extemal freqneni:..'Y
insttmnents.
A square wave (14-volt peak-to-peaki
positive-going)
is brought 011t at terminals
2*9 and4 (common) to drive self-powered
digital tachometers
such as the SF0-100, SPD-70(), and "MTH-lOaD 1 or to use as a conditioned
high kvel signal source into counters or other
The frequency
of the signal .is equal to that being app1:i!!d
at signal input terminals
S ( +) & 6 (-}. This tn.l.:q)uthas
an internal
of 1 kn, Using D PM-10 5 meters as external speed indicators
You am lJSe the
as lln external indicator.
You can C!Onnect one O.t more DPM-105 meters tu your SST*200DA/H.
The 0;1 mAmeter output of the SST-2000A/H
[terminals
7 (-)and 8 (+)]is .ra.ctory-cab'b:tated
info an
load of 40 0, The loa,d resistance
of the DPM-105" is 95 Q. (.)
one DPM-105 14 1 On the DPM-105, retain the:jumperacross
termlnals
1and2. 2 Connect the meter as showu in.Fig. 3..J. ' 3 Cah"bratefue
$ST-2000A/H.
Ftg. 3.3 ConnecL1ng
one PPM.-105 tc the SST*2000AIH.
* Keep the jumper between term1nal 1 a 2. on the OPM-105 * ... -.........
----........ -....... * -**_, ... . oc Pi:rwerH 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 214 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K20 OF K37 ( \..., .. VTIP MANL SST-2QOO Page 16 of 33 Powerfng External Devjces * Confum the meter is properly connected
to the SST-2000A/H, * Use a
gfl!netator (e.g. F-16)"to apply
to tennina1 5 (HI) & {COlv.1) on the SST-2000A/R
Mrodrnuin
signa1 foput. ?s. *SO VJ.tIJ.8 fox a standard unit. t Aqj&#xb5;st MS'l'Ell CALIBRATE
potentiometer
on the . ; SST*2000A/H
for the ap_propri<Jte
fuIJ.-sc:aie
reading on each :o!M-105.
+ Use a DPM*l 05 data shff:t, if necessacy
1 to cal1brate
the DPM-lOS: meters. Connecting
more than one DPM-105 1 .kmovethejuru.peracross
terminals
1 and2*on each
2 Connect the metei:s as i1hown in Fig. 3-4. l
the S ST-2<lOOA!H.
Fig, 3*4 * Connecting
more than one DPM-105 to tt'le SST*2000AJH.
tfoj001pe1
bell>.lee11
uruililllk
1 &,2 * Confirm. the meter is properly cqnn.ected
to. t11e $ST .. 20QOA/H. + App1y full-imtle
frequency
to terminal5 (HI) &.. 6 (COM) on the SST*2000A/H.
Maximuin signal input j:; 50 Vrm.s for a standatd unit. + Adjust the MB TERCALI13RA.'I'Epotentiomete;i:onthe
SST.200DA/Hfurth.eap
propriatefull..scalereadingon
eacli DPM-:105'.
t Use 11 DPM-105 data. 5heet, ifnece:>Sary, to calibrate
the DPM-:105 mete.re. *
--15 () 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg .. 215' of 267 REPORT NO.:. -REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE 1<21 OF K37 ,.*-*-*,)
n. I \ ... ,_..... , __ Chapter 3 . VTI P MAN L SST "2000 Powering.Zero
Velocity Pickups and*Other
Loads I Page 17 of33 Theregulakd
14 Vdc-mpplybroughtoutat
tenninafa
11 (+) & 4{-1has a. capacity of 40 mA. Th.is output can :pl'.>Wer
zero velocity :pickups (e.g. M928) and digital indimtarslike
a DPM.105. 1 CoMect the M9Z8 pickup as indicated
inFig. 3.5. *. 2 J1.1mper tetnti:ilals
11 and 30.&#xa2;9
the input s:ighal to a 1.0 V threshold. . 3 .Adjust i!ligrutl
sensitivity
if necessary.
Se.e 27 for in$tic::tlons
on * haw to acijust mpu.t s:e.nsitiV.ity.
F'tg. 3-5 Jumper tennfnals
11 and :fo w deserattt7.e
the-in
c1rcL;J1t
tp a one-volt threshold.
$Sl>.2000A&deg;H
SPl;EO 6\1/ITt:fl
16 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 216 of 267* REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K22 OF K37 c.*. ( Pov./ering
External Devices Driving an SPV-200 Solenoid Pneumat;c
Valve VTIP MANL SST-2000 ( .. '"" PE!,ge 1 8 of 33 * ) 1., ** 1 WARNll-lG:
TO AVOll.J SPV-200 COIL MMAGE Use a current limiting resistor 1n series with the de power source arid the transfenirig
relay contacts, The SPV
cai1 has a :resistance (lf 50 n <m.d ;requires
6 V de ta trip, Switching
the Regulated
14 Vdc Supp"ty The regulated
14 Vdc supply at termma.1:s
11 (+) & 4 (-)does notha.-ve
the capadty tn drive the SPV-200 continually.
When th<! SST-2000A/H
transm.itter
is supplied with the Pneumatic
Trip Option tor Overspeed, Relay 1 tra:n..'=fei:s
for only 100 :millis.eoonds
on overspeed;
the 14 volt supply can then be used 'With a series limiting
to p owe.r tlte
Use *a Wwatt,
n :rtsistor
in aeries with the 14 volt supply. SST-roOOAll
l fbilay "': CCfllact Fig. 3*6 Swltch1ng
the regulatei:l
14 Vdc supply. +14
Catt-n1:111 1}4W Switching
28 Vdc When-switchiog28
Vdc-!ntothe
coil, llsea
watt, 180 Oresistorin
series with the SPV-200 coil. . .
Ca:I Fig. 3*7 Switching
the 28 V<lc supply.
ComlllQn 5-1GW 17 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 217 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE 1<23 OF K37 VTIP MANL SST-2000 Page 19 of33 Chapter 4 Calibrating*
the* Speed Switch* 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 218 of 267 Chapter 4 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I P,AGE K24 OF K37 c Locating the programming
*switch instructions
VTlP MANL SST-2000 ,,, . ......._ Page 20 of 33 (, / c .. 20 Fig. 4-8 A fult descrlptlGll
at the
switches cind controls 1s toc:*ated
:the top p
of tJ\e SSTr20DOAIH.
1 Use a no. 1. or no. 2 PhUl fps screwdriver
to remove thr;. top plate of the 5witch, 2 The understde
of the ptate <<.intaim ln:>trllctfons
for_now to: + late!) *$el palrit retays on alarm * actut1.te
relays on overspeed
* actuate 2. relays s!rnult.aneaus_ly
{DiS PPDT relay) t de*energl::i:e
relays en atarm * change prop{]rtional
output to 0*5 Vele or 0-10 Vdc t rEii:alibrate
the
1nput frequency
range {switch A settings} OP OUT ZEiRO llllCIP r.;:1 S.P * .(j O/i II s,p_ t DE;. S.1'. Ola 7 7 S.P.. 2 O/S 4 l>E e' 6 2 tATC11 S.1".31 DE 6 B l!I c S.I". 1 LA.TCH S.P.1 DPI) -4 S.f'. 1 ors S.P.41ATC
H 3 o 3 o S.P. :2 05* 'S.f>.2 llPD:' 2 F" 2 F 1(JIJ PllOP. DUT i>.P.a Ul.TCH t F *1 f tll/F'ROP..
OUT
._ _ ___, .Alla R c;o,fJAT ICI NS: $.P.= SIOTPOINl'
CJlS"' 0.VERSPIH!Clri
UIS<>
DEi:,.. DE!:NER!'.!!<.E[)
Ri;rER 10: *SS f.2C:OO A & fl WIUllJALFOR
lflFO.
4-3 l'AISl'.l. MNG11 YffML_____@
CAL I * ., ? 7 !'l
5 A
4 3 z i 0 t r, SIGifAI-""01 SENSliM'IY SWITOH 'A" POSITION 'I(; l'ROOU!;NOV
RANt;iE IN ..00-.1 ;:2,a;.1*
.13 :3.S: .1a,.17 4-131.17*.22
.2Z* .e ie.s: 2S T,S; JIS-IS : ?','<!,6;
.<!S-.00 * A,7,S: .. 9'.'l 1,2. a:,s, ei.e: .83. 1.og 1:.88*1.12;2:"1,1*1.4
;9; 1A* 4:1,Q *25 : 6:2.5. 3.2 ; B:M * 4.2 7;4,2-B.!1
i 7;:2: 6'.S-M :1.4. 7;,,ll * Q,1 *
12 ::\!, S.'4.(1. 7;12:: 'la.5 * 1,2.S,4,tl.e,
* .... 1 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 219 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K25 OF K37 Calibrating
the SQeed Switch
Ch::i.nging
the full .. scale input frequency
range vr1P MANL ** . Page 21 of 33 You can !let the standard full*scs.1.e
frequency
rrutge frotn as low as Q-80 to as high as 0-20 kHz. 1 Remove the top pla-:-e. from the
to re"real "N' DIP .switches.
2 Use Table 4-1, page* 23t*or*the
und.e.rside
of the top plate (battQm of Fig. 4-9, p1;tge 22) ta determ1ne
the comet DIP switch settings, 3 Calibrate
the SST-2000A/H
using the proc:edure
011. page* 22. Input frequency
range "less than 80 Hz fullyscale
The full-scale
frequency
:input range is
1.ip at the fuctory when a.II. SST-2000A/H
is ord{lred.
'The SST-2COOA/H
can easily be .field-modified
for any standard full scale input frequency.
range: from 0-8 0 FJ'z tn 0.-20,{)00
Hz using the procedure
Recalibration . ofFrill...S
ca.le Inpat Frequency
Range. Field-changing
the SST-2000AJH
to accept input freqoences
rm than 0-80 Hz full-.mde
is mK m:ommended.
Damage might result that could void the product warranty.
Please contact me
Customer Serwce Department
at (954) 739-4300 for gu.ida:nce
in manging fur a. lpw input frequoncy
range. Input frequency
range greater than 20,000 Hz full-scale
TI1e full-scale
frequency
:input range .ii; usually set "U.P at the: far;:.tory
when an SST-2000AJH
is ordered, 'Jli.e SST *2.000A/H
c:at1 ea 5ily be
fo:r my staudard fuU si:;:ale input .frequency
;1;angc from 0-80 HZi to 0...-20,0ClO
Hz using the procedure
Recalibration
of FulJ.-Scale
Input Fl'eque:n.cy
Range. Fie1d*cb<1lJ.ging
the SST-ZOOOA/H
to acceptfuput
frequencies
gm1:ter-tha.n
[).20t{l00
HZ fi.ifl...scal.e
is trot rewmmended.
Damage m!ght rr.snl.t th.at could void the product warranty.
con.tact the-:Oyaaloo
Customer Sm-ice (95.4) 739-430Q fur goidance in ananging for a high input ftequency
range. 21 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 220 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
c: (_ * REVISION:
03 I PAGE K26 OF K37 Chapter 4 Calibrating
the SST .. 2000A/H VTIP MANL SST-2000 ****-**) Page 22 of 33 (._. * 22 WARNING I Callbrate
the speed swH.ch: * fmmediately
after any contact i::h ange in Switch A * before adjust1ng
set
or pr(lpartjonal
dutpUt You mus.t
the SST-2000A/H
if you have :made a i;ha.ngcdn
the fi.dl-scrue
frequency
range {changed contacts to DlP switch A)_ 1 D.isconnect
aey
to terminals
1 & 8. Mark.: or positi()])
the wires so they can be correctly
reuttacl:u:d
later. 2 Connect a digital voltmeter
acOO!is
7(-) & 8 ( + ). 3 Connect a
generator{e-g.
F-16) tennillals
5 (HI) & 6 (COM). Use the frequency
generator
to ]nput tlrn new fuU-..i;cale
4 * Adjust the FREQ RANGE TRlM potent:imneter
fbr l 0.00 V de on the voltmeter. (See Fig. 4-9.) 5 * Reattach the meter tliat is: normally conncctc:d
to-w:mfon.hi
7(-) & 8 (+). Ob,smit' pohr!t.;v.
Ftg. 4-9 The
arrangements*
for* the fl.ilki!:a\e
frequency*
rt.1n!!!e
switch (A} are* D.l1 undersrcre
oHha top* plate.
PA.'i'1!
::r,u: .1-:11,e:.1a-.t7
-4,11:.U-.2?
;s,a*JJ 1,8>.30-.5 e:.oi.1.(lt
11.!0*L12;1ol,1
* l.4 <:I< 1"4*1.B.
: s:rn.a.z :i;.
* 'i ,. ...... '\ __ ) (''') ._-:-...... 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 221 of 267 VTIP MANL SSl'-2000, la.hie 4-1 Tabla of full*:scale
frequency
and the c:orrespondirig
switch. 0. tll!i * 0.10 11N 1 ON settfngs.
o;Hl * 0.13 0,1J. 0.17 0 .* 11 * o.iz. (};'22 -0,.30 0.30 * O.lB
o.5o 0.48 -0,6J 0.62* a.t3 tl.63 .. 1.G9 <l.86 -1.12 1.10 '-1.40 1.40 ... 1.90 , .90 -2.50 2.50-J.:.w 3.1.0 -4.20 4.:2.0 ... 5."50 5.la & 6.90 ()."90 -9:'10 9.10 -12.0 1,2.0 -*1 !i.*5 15.1 <2.0.0 1, 8 Z, 8 3, B 4t8 5, 8 6, a 1, a 1, z; s 1 4 7 B
1 z 4 6. 7 7, 1. 4t 7 Z, 3 S ti l, 6t 7 1, 2, 3, 4r 5, 6 1 l REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K27 OF K37 80-100 100. 130 130. 170 170. 22{) no. 300 3ll0. 380 3SO -SOD -630 630 -a30 830. 1,090 860*1,120
1, 100 . 1,400 1,40Q. 1,900 1",900 * 2,500 2,500 * .3 200 3,200. 4,200 4t200 . s,:sao 5,300. 6 900 6 900 * 9-HlO 9 1 00 * 1 t., 000 12,00-0 -15, 500
IJO * 20,000 23 
EC 620632,
1, Pg. 222 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K28 OF K37 C .. ( Ch.apter 4 Calibrating
the 4*20 mA Proportional
Output VTIP rvtANL SST"2000 ('-, Page 24 of 33 *. ___ ./ 24 . ' : You* must calibrate
thi:: speed switch if the standard proportional
output of 4 to 20 m.A is th.all.yd
to * 0:-5' V de ushlg*81hritch
C 1, or * 0-10 Vdc using switch CZ To calibrate
the new proportional
1 .fJ;tach a digital voltm.etet
to terminals
9 (-)*& 10 (+/. 2 Apply 10% of the full.-scale
frequency
to input temiifials
S ( + )i fi (-). 3 Adjust the PROP OUT ZERO :B.djum: potentiometer
{See Fig. 4-10, befow} to yfold 10% of
proportional
output on the \rol trnete.r *. ,-----Fig, 4"10 The PROP OUT I
OUT ZERO ZERO and PROP OUT SPAr-1 I 0-. adjLlstm'ffitS
>'\nil located in r J the upper rlght comer under the top pl.B.te a( the SST*2000A/H.
OtJT SPAN 4 Apply LOOC..fi offulI.scale
to termina1s
5 (+) & 6 (-). 6-Torn PROP OUT SP AN adjtlSt poten.tiom.eter (Sec example below} to y!eld 100% of full-scale
propoitional
output on the vo!tmetf3r . 6 * Rep oat 5tcps 2, 3, 4, and S three or four times to a.sswc accu:t:acy.
A i1ri1t cat1brated
for 0-500 Hz Input Is be1ng recalibrated
to P*10 V'dc proport1on.al
outpllt (from 4A20 mAdc propol"t1onal
output). *Apply 1 n% of Hz) to terminals
5 (.i.) &; 6 {-). *
PROP OUT SPAN
potentfometer
to Vield 1.000 Vdi: on the voltmeter.
t Aj.'lply futl* si:ale frequel'lCY
{500 Hz) *to term1nal.s
S ( +) a b(-). * rum PROP {)UT ZERO a,djust potentiometer
to yle',d 10.00 Vdc. * Rsp-eat .3 Qf 4 times for accuracy, () 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 223 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K29 OF K37 Catlbrati11g
the Speed Switch Programming
Set Points and Relays VTrP MANL SST-2000 Paga .2S of 33 Remove the top plate fl:om the SST-2000A/H
to reveal.DIP
switches B rm.,:f C. Use DIP
B and C to program rela.y set points to: ,+*energize (OFF) I de-eMrglz-e (ON) on alarm + non-latch (OFF)/ latch (ON) cm. ala.llll * actuate SPST (OFF} I DPDT (ON) trip*on alarm * change proportional
voltage output f'iii. 4* 1 Df P swfti:t\ set,tl ngs ava:labte
to you depend on the model of speed switc:h you
+ SSFl!40QA/H
have fo\1r set point
adjustments (DlP .switches
a arid q. * SST*2200AIH
series
only have relays 1 and 2 (ad;l 1.rstabte
Pl P *swit1:h q. * SST*2000A/H.
sWitchel haYI:' no 5et point relays:, 8.P. OIS s.r. 4 ots S.P. 4 DE S.P.3 DB 8.P. 1 DPDT 3.P. 4 LATCH S.P. 2DPDT 3.P, 3 L.AlCf.i El ., 5 B 4 0 2 r 1 F a -7 6 c 4-3 2. 1 0 f "F S.P. 1 D.E 8,P, 10!8 S.P. 1 LA.TOH S.P, 1 LAIOl-l S.P. 1 OlS 8.Jl. :2.DE 10V PROP, O.UT
OUT The 1mdendffi,:
cf fuc: top plate oolllilins
labels for
DIP switch. setting. Resetting
a latched
To moment[Uily
i'ellet a.latched
rela.y,jumpex
teinUnals
*.3.2 and 7. 25 
EC 620632, Att. 1, 224 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K30 OF K37 (_ .. c:. C. Set points 3 a: 4 and selectfng
DPDT trip VTIP MANL SST-2000 [\ Page 26 of 33 \ . ..J Wl-IEH ALL 8 5WITCt-ffS
i\RE OFF t
3.and 4
energ1zecl,
* noti*latching
+all relays are SPST EXAMPLE: To set relays ani;I 4 to actuatet
and latdl on over:speed, turn 011 B1j B3, B5, B6, B-1, and Ba. 'fum Ol'l*B to ... B1 LATCH s..n point l on 21.larm ACTUATE relay 4
with relay creat1rig
two Form C ccnta<:ts
for set point 2 (DPb-T relay). 33 I.A TCH set point 4 -on a!arrn M ACTUATE relay 3
relay 1, c:reat1ng
two .t
set pti1nt 1 (DPDT relay). 65 DE>ENERGIZE
relay 3 an
Bil [)J!:.ENERGIZE
rt!lay 4 on alann Bi ACTUATE set po1nt 4 en
BB ACTUATE 5et point J.11n O\f(tFspeed
*. Set points 1 & 2:
ft 0-10 Vdc proportional
output WHE.N ALL C SWITCH ES ARE OFF * the proporl1ona.l
*output is 4-20 mA + relll.ys 1 and 2 are energt1:ed, underspl.!td
t noo* tat<::lied
EXAMPLE::
To
the p roporUonal
o-1oydc, ;:md set relay :2 to a ctu01 te, e
a.rid
Otl overspeed, turn on CZ, C:.6 1 and C?. 26 Turn on C to ..* C1 Chi'!nfle
proportlonal
output to 0*5. Vdc*. Confirm CZ..1.s PFF. tz Ch11ngll's
output tci 0* 10 Vdc*. Confirm C1 1s Off. C3 DE*ENERGllE
relay 2. ort alarm. C4 ACTUATE relay 1 on ovenpeed, non*latch.
Cs LATCH relay 1 on ara.tm. C6 lATCH
2 011 11lann. C7
relay 'l an over.;peed, nl?n*latch.
cg
reray 1 on afarm. * Requfres recalibration.
("\ ) .. ...,,. 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 225 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
() Adjusting
Signal Sensitfvfty
Desensitizing
Standard Inputs : REVISION:
03 I PAGE K31 OF K37 Calibratil1S
tile Speed Sw1tch *vr1P MANL SST-2000 Pa9e 27of3S Signal sensitiY.ity
is factory set to 2.5 'mVJD18 (about 35 mV pcaktir 70.mV peakMto-peak}*and
most applications . Ftg. 4-12. sfgna\ :!!el'l.'11tMty
(;Q nt 1"4Jl is located Ul\der the A !) IP swltth. ..,
15 A RMIO.E OOITCH 4 #-1;.IPl'P!
....... &deg;"'1'&deg;1 '"Ir.I f"ll' niw
rR5:.iJUD'tt:"'; . 3 2 1 0 *f SIGNP!...
SalSIIM!Y
Highe( sensitivities
can 'be more vulnerable
to noise. To raise Sil?'ruitivity
Tum the SIGNAL SENSITIVITY
potentiometer (Fig. 4.12) clockwise.
At full clockwjse
totatlon, sensitivity
is approximately
5 m. Yilll.3. To lower sensftfvf
f;y Tum the SIGNAL SENSITIVITY
potentiometer
.:mmte:rclockwise, At full
rotation, the sensitivity
i5
100 m.Vnns. * Desensitizing
Closure Jumper te.nnit&#xb5;J.ls
30 and 11 to desensitize
the mtlt to about 1 Vrm!J. Signal S e:ns1ttvity
pot setting d(Jes: not affccl thll procedure.
Ptg. 4-13 Jumper 1 t.o 30 desen$ttlze
the 5ST-100tlA/H
for contact closure input. * ** , ........ ,,i;mo1KT,1 r** ........ "
l : 1 .. " fil!l.l'QJ!i.it
i ; t ,,, ..
3 ; ! I
.. ' ..... l.ll!J"IOl'I
ClAlJaHl\l'E
@ @ @ :? 2ll 1(1 21 *o '22 "' 2:a re 14 0 2!l ll El1LV' tlO.:t IHlAV NO,<l' .. : Jmt,v " NQ,4 @ @ 28 !D "* ' ;,HI
31
32
0 27 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg'.. 226 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K32 OF K37 c: ... ( '-* Chapter4 Response Time VTIP MANL SST-2000 ,,-...,., : Page 28 of 33 * ("' )' . *-
time is the time :rf)qu.i.red
f9t :the proportional
outputs to change fl:4l:tn 10% to 90% of the mulmum. calibrated
value fut a:n instantaneous.
st.ep change of input frequency.
Response ti,mc affects the tr.ail
of the rel.iws. Stands.rd
:response
time :is 150 .11tilliseconds.
over all ' Rl:.LAY K.C:SPONSE
Contact DynakQ if you need a different
rela res onse tilne. standara*
m:put frequency
rangee: 0.80 &
to 0-20jooo full-scale.
fuls:pon$!? below 80 H:li full.scale
are proportlona.Uy
slower. While other response times can be provided, field modillca.tion
is not ;rcc901mended
damage -qrlght
that cou_Li V9id the product
Contact Dyrialca if you.need a different
relay
time. Adjusting
Individual
Set Points .23 1 Verify th.at the
is caljbrated
to the 001.'l'ect
full-scfile
frequency
range (see page 22). 2 *Tools required:
Eitl-rer a very
saewdrivet
or a t:ramfonner
alignment
tooI;
generator (Dynalco's
F-16 o.r equivalent), 3 Frovide a signal ;;ource. Uge an. F-16 signal generator
or similar zero-crossing
sjgnal smirce, ot use the
signal generated
by lhe l'rl.agt\etlC
pickup on the engine_ 4 Applya*frequencysignalto
te..'1Ilinals
5 & 6. This frequency
input sliocld equ!!.l the target lU'lv.f value of-the set point being adjusted.
F1;;ir examvle: Ci\kulatc
the set point .frequency
for a.gear with 72 teeth rotating at 800RPM,. . Frequmcy(Hz)
*(SO())><
(72 ttetl!l _ 96(} Hz (to terminals
5 & 6) 60 Alternate
Method 1: Adjusting
set points while* the engine is not runni-:ig
* U s.e a signal grmerator
to adjust ind:.viriual
set points when lhe engine iS not
and if you do nat
an
RPM meter. 1 Disconnect
the wires to terminals
5 & 6. Mark ar position the: wires to assure C&#xa2;l'rect replacem.fnt. . ..... (' ) ......... 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 227 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K33 OF K37 () 0 VTIP MANL SST .. 2000 Page
33 Calibrating
the Speed Switch 2 Apply the calculated
set po.Int frequency
to
5 (HI) & 6(COM). ' 3 .Jwply operating
p*owei: to the. SST-2000AIE'..
See lid of }'Ollr SST-2000NH
ox spec sheet for. poweJ
4 Select the app.ropriate
set poi'nt trirn pot. 5 Tum pot; * CQunterclockwise
to lower the set pointvafo.e (reduce*the
speed at which the point relay will trip}. + Clockwise
ta raise the set paint value (increase
the spl'!ed. at which the. set point relay will trip). 6 Tam the pot slowly so as not to pass.the target set point by a large amount. The pot has fine resolu.ti.onj
:io a large change in set po.int .may take several tu.ms. 7 While aFlju:sting
the pot, li!i.ten for the: Ielay to trjp at the set point You c:!aXL hear a distinct click when the:
trander. If high ambient noise makes it impossible
ta hear the rela.y click: "USe an ohmmete:r
as
in Alt.emate
Method 2.1 below. . B Fine tune the adju.stm.e:nt:
+ After the. relay trips, sJm.vly REVERSE the
of th.e set poi'lt pot*until
the !clay again trips. t Again, slowly turn *me pot FORWARD until the may
9 Reattach the wires to renninals
5 {Hi) & 6"( COM). Observe polarity.
1 0 Repeat; fhe above procedute
for other set poin:t5 to be changed. Alternate
Method 2: Adj.usting
Individual
Set Po1nts While The Engine Is Operating . A mm.mllcal
overspeed
val11e is one that will not stress the engine. tr:i:e Altett).ate
Method 3 fo adjust set points while the engine is operating
at a. non-criticfll
speed. NOTE: when the set pomt value is :reached the reh1:.y'Will
ca'llSe an engine shutdown.
or activate whaw.ter is cOIUlect-ed
to that relay. A critical overspeed
is
the actual engine shutdown overspeed;
running Use Alternate
Method J to adju;t set
while the. ,
is
at NON&#xa5; CRITICAL speed <lnly. the engmr= at !:hls l'lPeed iii generally
not desit'ed.
Use Alternate:
Method 1 ff you cannot _guarant.ee*erigine
oven;peed.
1 Run the engine at the desired SIJeed using: 29 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 228 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K34 OF K37 ........ C .. Chapter 4 VTIP MANL SST-2000 t an RFM indicator/tachometer
operating
from One of tire proportional
outputs of the SST-.2000A/H:
Page 30of33 .*
on o:rnear the engine .. 2 Wait for-the Rl?M to stabilize:. When RPM is stab!e 1 select fhe a.ppr:oJ?riate
set pj'.rlnj;
trim pot" , 4 Follow the
inAitemate
Method 1; steps l * 10. A'ternate
Method 3: Adjusting
individual
set points in high noise * areas * rfhigh amhm noise makes it
to
relay clm1c 1 Disconnect
the wire from: * t:J?.e center
Qf the SST*2000A/H
set pond relay being adjustt:d.
t
one of the
two contac[,s*
on. the saQ:Ie relay. [Mark the wires or position them.so they can be correctly
reattached,)
2 Connect an ohmmet.er
to the center tennlrutl
of this relay Emd to either o.nc of the other tenninals
of this relay. [If adjUsting
Relay 1 i connect the ohmmeter to tenni:nf!]s
18 & 17 or l 8 &. 19.] ':fhe ohmmeter will indicate either a short or an open condition
depending
on whiclt tennillals
axe cbosen . . 3 Ac:ljust the re1ay as outlined in
l: 1-10. V1ben Ote rt:la:y trips, the ohmmeter will $]).aw ' sl;iort
open,
to the indication
it ha;:l 'helhre the relay tripped. 4 Reiittach
the wires to 'thi: relays, 5 Repeat the above procedure
fot othtt set po-in.ts to b.e changed. ('-*_. * .. _) ( 0 30 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 229 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K35 OF K37 0 Catibrati
ng the
Switch Verifying
Set Point Values VTIP MANL SST-2000 Page; 31 of 3S .. ,.. The
Jumper does not interfere
with the normal operation
of any relays. 4*20 mA proportioflal
m1tpl1t (termi nats. 9 B: 1 Dr is NOT affoc;too
by thfs procedl..lr*e.
The 14 Vdc pulsed output is not affected by this procedure.
You can view and adjust thE: :set paint
without having to run the engine, Nora. The SST-2 OOOA/H (no si:::t poinu.) *does not have set point!l . 1 Jump er terminal 16 with the terminn1 that co.rresponds
*with the set point you want to. view (for SST0220.0AIH
and
+: Set point !:jumper 16 to 12 + Set point 2: jumper 16 to 13 t Setpoint3:juroper
16 to 1.4 +* Set point4: jumper 16 to 15 2 \Vhen you jumper* the two terminals, the 0-1 roA output rneti:r conne<:ted
to E.ennh1als
7 and S disconnects
and
RPM <frequency, rate, et(l.) value at that set poln.t 3 \Vhen :thejumpexs
are reQ10ved, meter switches back to its nonnal o:pe1.'ation.
Ftg. 4* 14 Verif}' the set polnt values and vfew the RPM tfrequi;;ncy, rate, etc.) on the O-f mA otitput
r
to terminals
7 8: B. .@ {Shown rs the procedure
for* veriMrlfl
Set-pc;;int 1.) , *..* , ........
:** .......
* i . .. ?,l;f,ffill'{( ". . . * I 1 .. '\. I* I I":.* I I* t * * I .. 11 * I* I* -o IL I* I O
Sf:YPOINTS
3 91;.TP(llNT
ADJUSTt.lF.:Nl"S
31 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 230 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K36 OF K37 ( (-* *' C. Chapter 4 Adjusting
Set Point Values VTIP l\AANL SST-2000 ("\ = Page 32 of 33 .... .J 32 WARNING You tan adjust.set
points while the engine or other device fa operating.
H9WEVert ff YoU adjU!it a set point ralay to a value tower than the curren:t operating relay will trip. You will need a.0-1 mA meter for
If a meter was supplied with the spi::ed. switc!It y:ou can use it Otherwise 1 you ca:n. use a DJ?M * 105 meter, or any O*lmA amm.etei.
T&#xb5;eextemal
metersb,ocld
be calibrak:d: "il-1 mA.= o*to-fu11-sca:le
input frequenct 1 of the SST-2000AJH. the
or
ttutl'.l];ler
label th.at accompanied
the urtit fOl' the full-scale
fteq>Jen.cy
value. 1 Observe polarity.
Connect an extm1al 0-1 m.A. meter to. texlnfuals
7(-) &8 (+). Z Depending
on the set point ro be adjusted, connect a tertlporaey
jumper .from : * Terminal 16to12 (for Set point 1) or * Terminal 16 lo 13 (for Set point 2} or t Teyminal 16 to 14 (for Set point 3) or +
l 6 to 15' (for Set point 4) 3 The 0-1 mA. mete.r.-vritl
now l.udicate.
the: CIL"1'ent
for chos&i
_page 31). 4 If
firstac:ljust
the selected set point using procedures
outlined in Adj ustlng lndlvidual
set poinrs 1 page 28. 5 *Romove the temporary
jumpe:r, 6 *The output from terminals
7 & S will again provided the standatd 0-1 mA proportio.ru&#xb5;
output. 7 Repeat steps l for additional
set points. (_._) 
I EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 231 of 267 (-"\ J ., ..... Index c M
l5Jt21-23,ZS,27, W, 31 commnns 1 10 cont.act
"'}.7 0 CSl\,. Class 1, Div.2, Gip_ D {H serle5), 4* geaernl certifkation
\A /ierJcs), 4. p cum:itJcop
iwlator, 10 D dcpowcr, 10 dinre:c.sions, DP'M-105, 14 E
cornrnaJl.:5, 10 <:Cn.llC!cti.OM;
10 5 R*
specffitai:lans, 7
ezp-lnslo:o.*p.i:nof
llous=iig:o;, ti
devices, 15, lS, 17 D:PM-106'., 14 }vf!'ff.-10.ID, 14 SPD-lOO, 14 SPD-700, 14-s SPY-20(1, 1'1 F: fc.-.ttvre:>, 4 frequ1mcy
for actpD!n.W, 28 1ablc:, 2S full<<Ate iri.P"llt
frcquericy
IJ!.Dge, 2! H
o x
l l dese:i9it!,dng, 2? full :scale l'mlgc, :21 reruitlvlt}*, 2.1 instillfng, !) r 11 isoll!.tor, 10 L latched l'!l.ay I iJ reiettlng, 25 m\ld.fi
4 autprit, 24 4*20 u_A, 24 PG-278
11 pidi:upS p.m*erlng, 16 pOwet HI oo* HI c.xtema1 devim, 13, 15, 17 :MY.2S, 16
!7 :mu vdocicy pickups, 16 prap:il"tji;mal
output, M relay, 25 :r:esp:>nte, 28 serpahi.ts, 6, 20" setpcints, 25 1 &.i, 20 3 &.4,. 2li S: 10 V -prop. OUtpnt, 26 M,justmg, * 28, 32 DPbT. trlp, 26
31 size, .3 sm..rna, 14 SPD-700, "14
5 :KP h1mslngs 1 6 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE K37 OF K37 VTIP MANL SST-2000 Page 33of33 33 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 232 of 267 ATTACHMENT
L Deleted 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 233 of 267 I '**-*-*-*-
.... **---... ---*-**----***
0 ... * STC-4371.
FIELD CONDIT.I.ONG
' .-RELAY JUNE 1984 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I 'PAGE M1 OF M7 
EC
Att. 1, Pg. 234 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I . PAGE M2 OF M7 ,, ... '* := .. *:* GENERAL DESClUP'ltON
The STC-4371 Field. Conditioning
Relay is a
relay assembly used In conjunction
with a
PRS 211.
*Equa]jzer
to prepare the field of a
diesel generator
to support a very.1arge*inductive
load lmmecUately
upon br@ker closure. * . . Jn opera,tion, the STC-4371 _will provide a signal to the voltage regulator "to increase generator
voltage. Tht9 will help voltage regulator
to compensate
!or the voltage dip ca:l,\Sed
by the large anticipated
load. . . ', .
CAUBRAtJON
Rl5 and ltl6 Dench Adjustments
*
is employed.
to
the
4:l71 ;ii'ield Conc:litioomg
Re41-y Rl5 .and R16 potentiometer
setpoints:
* . . . 1. Rl's Adjustment:
a. Pis connect an wires at trn relay i&#xb5;;seinbly
ter.minal
board (TBl, Figure 1). b. Connect a *Volt-ohmmeter
to terminals
4 and 5 of
NOTE "" The -meter shall be s*et up .to. read'.ohms
in the lowest .scale ava.Uable
in which 65 ohms will be indicat.ed
near the center of the dial (f Cx-e:Xample, R x 1). This wm provide the most accurate 'measurement
and adjustment.
The ohmmeter shall be zeroed *tn this scale before being connected
to the relay. ter.mlnal
board. c. Adjust potentiometer
R16 to obtain a meta-reading or 65 ohms, then tighten the potentiometer
look nut. 2. R15
a. Co1:uwct a
jumper from tM.
of diode CR4 to turret* terminal .2. (See 'Figure 1 for component
* * * b.. Connect a temporary
jumper (rom the anode of diode ORS to turret terminal 2. c; Connect 120 VDC power to terminals
1 and 2 of TB-1 as shown in Figure 1. d. Adjust potentiometer
R15 to obtain a meter reading or 90 ohms; then tighten the a<ljusUng
locknut. * : * e. Di:Sconnect
the power leads *and ohmmeter leads Crom terminal board TJ3.:.l; then remove the jumpers !rom the circuit board. Timing Adjustments:
-once R15 and R16 have been properly caUbrated, final timing .shall to ensure, that the voltl!-ge
adjustment
i;ignal to the v<;>ltage
regulator
fs strengthened (to quickly restore the generator
output voltage to th!3 desired 'level), then (to help, dampen voltage overshoot
by the voltage r"eigulator). . 1. Required Equipment.
-The following
calibration
equipment
is required to carry out the timing adj\lstrnents
of the STC-4371 Field Conditioning
Relay: STC-4371 1 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 235 of 267 *, REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE M30F M7 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 236 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE M4 OF M7 , t. .. ' ' \1') '9:) ''' Q.. *_:; **:: ""! !. ,_..! r) ....... ,
0q 0o 0-0 u !j_ ... u -0 Ii? TURllET 0 . . 0 0 'c;. s s ; . . LJ Ed.**. 02* *L1* *
*o ....... *.**.,; ...... :.. .... . . . .. ,* *.'.* . . .* .. *'. : . ...
... **.*.
-, '"':''''-ID ...:::: 0 $TC 4371 106 0 Note: Temporary
RlS. Adjustmentjumpers
are revised by CPS, on Figure i, to show correct polarity as investigated
within MW:o D86078 [Refere11ce
Vendo.r Manual Revision 43] . ()HlollollEl"E9' . ,. Figure 1. STC-4371 Potentiometer
Rl5 and R:l6 Adjustment
Connections
a. 120-volt and 24-volt DC power supplies b. Pol;lble-pole, momentary
contact switch c. GBJ.vanom.eter*
Amplifier
d. Light Beam Osrilltogra.I>h, or High-Speed
Brush
NOTE All testing end adjustments
shall .be performe9
using calibrated
Instrumentation, the calibration
or which shall be traceable
to the National Bureau or Standards.
All instruments
used shall be recorded in the test data records.*
* 2. Test Set-Up. The .equipment
shall be conneeted
to the
as sl)o:w.n in Figure 2 to monitor the "breaket" close 11 signal, and the operation
of relays K2 end K3. . NOTE The actlll;ll
locations
o! diodes CR4 and CR5 are $howndn Figure 1. :i SI'C-4371
c*** .... ..... ) ("') 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 237 of 267 '* REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE M50FM7 0 ' . .() 3. Calibration.
Procedure
*. The desired operating
sequence 0!0 the STC-4371 fs _shown in. Figure The timing o! the
K2 and KS pull-in and drop-out events is. controlled
by the adjustment
potenOometers, $8 listed in Table 1. The potentiometer
adjustment
screws are turned .to increa8e the delay time, ;and counter-clockwiSe
to
tl:le delay. On
3, the : zero point of *the horizontal
axis corresponds
to the initial nbreaker close" signaL . DELAY ADJUSTMENT
PO.TBNTJOMETER
R9 R10 R11 Rl2: Table 1. Potentiometer
P'unctt'ons
CONTROLLED . EvENT K2Pull-in
K2 DrQp--Out
K3-Drop-out K3.
.. Adjust the delay
until. the timing relatiomhtps
the
clO!Se" signal and the relay K2 end K3 events matches.thOse
shown in Figure a *. * Plnally, the Basler PRS211 Time Equalizer
may need a final adjustment
to synchronize
it with the Pleld . Conditonlng
Relay. Using the time adjustment
on the *front of the
equalizer, set the lUlit so that the breaker actually closes *and loa,d is applied at 16 cycles. Further minute adjustments
i:&#xb5;ii.y be necessary
to Insure the voltage transient
will remain within the
provided in Figure 3. 120 V .D.O.{ ... . + BTC .UT1 CJt.U. B!MCll TUI' CONMBC'llOK
SCHEMA11C.
GALYAMOMJ!.TER
AMPtJPIBR
r 13 tMPUT * CJ\$ *r : 12 IHPUT 01C>20S04
05 _J -:It INPUT -OUTPUT -I ( TO LIOHT HA MOM!lfTAl\Y
oacJLLOORAP
I I CONT.ACT I -:: -I * ., .* I. M H Flgure 2 ..
Timing Adjustment
Calibration
Equipment
CoMectlons.
STC-43'11
' . 3 
EC. 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 238 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE M60FM7 '* *:* 4 VDC.o;. '3lNPUT ovnc-UO Vt>C_ 12 lNPUT ovnc-:4 V*DC-11 INPUT ovnc-D 8 UOHT BEAM OSCJLLOORAPH
AnJUsTMBNTs
POR STC "3Tl VOL'l'AOE
ACRO!llS K3 RELAY 2DCYCLES S3CYCLES :to (CYCLES}" PAPER SPEED 50 JKCH/QC SBT MARKER POR IU 'I11EK COUNT THE *DMU)tfi AND MULTlPLY BY .I TO COHVBRT TO CYCLES,' ' Figure 3. STC-4371 Relay Timing
Relationships
STC-4371 
EC
Att. 1, Pg. 239 of 267 () * B A .. ) I I *1 . t--tlll I I . 11 I "'" l.&0110,C.
,_ It) ,, I 6 ,I. 4 (OtlC..lCIW!H;
R&O:t $fC-4)11 VCLJAGt (j)
EXTERNAL C:ONNECTltliS
_
.. " u ..
na'!olr>Uill'&deg;'
U.hiiU UloUWAl.\
P.lllr 00.
"" 1 10,11,1.t
_..u "'""""" JU<!<. ilfhl$'"
fr,rtllCll',h
1til1w1u111
jfil;:;,:.
,.,..,. ,,,.,,,..
'*'*''"''
1.1.1.r.u.1
**** u-111 a.0,1 ... M :mr=11 r.u.11-u .. l.IU*lfl
11r.*10Rll
l1U1W.WLllll tt!r.
IT .. "''" .. m.o.1w.c11*
':l:Hlt' I REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE M7 OF M? 3. I 2* .1 l"*hJI ..... .. H Uo :i
...
Ucz*IA._ .y:,. IUll&fPl&l
*
:!.w :m:.: fuli.'''1111\11
U*tl **:::: tml
.. \IWl*MTH 51:*11 Jui tn-'J ... :11 .. !,Mll4 'w.r.a" .wrn*ti"""'" m: rif::m .,. D . c ! *i n I I I I I I I 1 * u 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 240 of 267 High Resolution
Industrial
VRS Magnetic Speed Sensors DESCRIPTION
High Resolution
VRS sensors are designed for use in applications
where precise timing pulse is required, and/or fine pitch gears are used. Proper alignment
of the sensor is required.
Passive VRS (Variable
Reluctance
Speed) Magnetic Speed sensors are simple, rugged devices that do not require an external voltage source for operation.
A permanent
magnet in the sensor establishes
a fixed magnetic field. The approach and passing of a ferrous metal target near the sensor's pole piece (sensing area) changes the flux of the magnetic field, dynamically
changing its strength.
This change in magnetic field strength induces a current into a coil winding which is attached to the output terminals.
FEATURES * Self-powered
operation
* Direct conversion
of actuator speed to output frequency
* Simple installation
* No moving parts * Designed for use over a wide range of speeds * Adaptable
to a wide variety of ccmfigurations
* Customized
VRS products for unique speed sensing applications
* Housing diameters:, 5/8 in (M16) 3/8 in (M12) * Housing material/style:
stainless
steel threaded * Terminations:
MS3106 connector, preleaded
* Output voltages:
17 Vp-p to 170 Vp-p REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE N1 OF N2 Honeywell
The output signal of a VRS sensor is an ac voltage that varies in amplitude
and wave frequency
as the speed of the monitored
device changes, and is usually expressed
in peak to peak voltage (Vp-p). One complete waveform (cycle) occurs as each target passes the sensor's pole piece. If a standard gear were used as a target, this output signal would resemble a sine wave if viewed on an oscilloscope.
Honeywell
also offers VRS sensors for general purpose, high output, power output, high temperature
and hazardous
location applications, as well as low-cost molded versions.
POTENTIAL
APPLICATIONS
* Engine RPM (revolutions
per minute) measurement
on aircraft, automobiles, boats, buses, trucks and rail vehicles * Motor RPM measurement
on drills, grinders, lathes and automatic
screw machines * Motor RPM measurement
on precision
camera, tape recording
and motion picture equipment
* Process speed measurement
on food, textile, paper, woodworking, printing, tobacco and pharmaceutical
industry machinery
* Motor speed measurement
of electrical
generating
equipment
* Speed measurement
of pumps, blowers, mixers, exhaust and ventilating
fans * Flow measurement
on turbine meters * Wheel-slip
on autos and locomotives
* Gear speed measurement 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 241 of 267 High Resolution
5/8 INCH (M16*) SENSORS CONTINUED (All dimensions
for reference
only. mm/[in]) *Contact Honeywell
for availability
of metric mounting thread versions.
G enera IS T f *pec1 1ca ions Parameter
Min. output voltage Coil resistance
Chisel pole piece width Min. surface speed Operating
temp. range Mountina thread Catalog Listing Weight Characteristic
300 Vp-p 910 Ohm to 1200 Ohm 1,14 mm [0.045 in] 0,38 mis [15 inls] typ. -55 &deg;C to 120 &deg;C [-67 &deg;F to 250 &deg;F] 518-18 UNF-2A 3045A 70 g [2.5 oz] G eneral Specifications
Parameter
Min. output voltage Coil resistance
Chisel pole piece width Min. surface speed Operating
temp. ranae Mountina thread Catalog Listing Weight Characteristic
65 Vp-p 120 Ohm to 162 Ohm 1, 14 mm [0.045 in] 0,38 mis [15 inls] typ. -55 &deg;C to 120 &deg;C f-67 &deg;F to 250 &deg;Fl 5/8-18UNF-2A
I [0.750] I Parameter
Characteristic
Inductance
450 mH max. Gear pitch range 24 DP (module 1.06) ferrous metal aear Optimum actuator N/A *' Max. operating
15 kHz typ. frequency
Vibration
Mil-Std 202F Method 204D Termination
MS3106 connector
Parameter
Characteristic
Inductance
85 mH max. Gear pitch range 24 DP (module 1.06) ferrous metal oear Optimum actuator NIA Max. operating
40 kHz typ. frequency
Vibration
Mil-Std 202F Method 204D Termination
MS3106 connector
7,92 3046A 70 g [2.5 oz] (%)* :..14-.-l
[0.312] I
[0.030] I I 4 sensing.honeywell.com
REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE N2 OFN2 Test Condition
Specifications
Parameter
Characteristic
Surface speed 25 mis [1000 inls] Gear 8 DP (module 3.17) Air gap 0,127 mm f0.005 inl Load 1.25 kOhm resistance
Test Condition
Specifications
Parameter
Surface speed Gear Air gap Load resistance
f 12119.05 -[0.750] l Characteristic
25 mis [1000 inls] 8 DP (module 3.17) 0,127 mm ro.005 inl 1.25 kOhm 
Ee 620632, Att. 1,
REVISION:
03 PAGE 01Of03 In general, the oil used in the prime mover will be satisfactory
for use in the governor.
The governor/actuator
oil supply is self contained.
Sump capacity is 1 1/2 quarts. When an empty governor is filled. add oil until it drains out the vent hole in the sight glass. This should require about 47 ounces of oil. Immediately
after starting and with the engine running, check the oil level in the sight glass. If the oil level is above the sight glass line, oil should be drained. If the oil level is below the line, add new, clean oil to bring the level up. NOTE When a oil cooler or starting booster is used, additional
oil will be required depending
on the size of the cooler or booster and the length of the lines connecting
it to the.governor.
Proper selection
of the oil used in the actuator is necessary
to realize best governor performance
and maximum service life. The oil should have a minimum tendency to foam or retain air, form sludge, or deposit varnish. It should protect actuator t'*-,I.NT OIL LISTto IS 0"'1. 'r A SUCC&#xa3;S:'r0t'i
use 1HC OI!. Of 0 tO..IFc OiO:CC WITH TH[.
lw'!$C0Sol1T
... S IHOfC .. T[O IN 1HE CHAAT parts from corrosion
and not be detrimental
to oil seals or paint. Refer to Woodward manual 25071 for more complete information
on selection
of oils for use in hydraulic
actuators (governors).
The oil selected should have a high viscosity
index, within the -range of 100 to 300 SUS at normal operating
temperatures.
Only oils of the grade specified
for a particular
temperature
range should be used. Figure 2-3 shows the viscosity
of oils at the different
operating
temperatures.
Operating
the governor with oil which does not fall in the acceptable
operating
range on the chart can . cause erratic governor operation
and possible damage to the governor.
Oil contamination
is the major cause of actuator troubles.
Use only new oil or filtered oil. Containers
used for filling the actuator must be clean and should be rinsed with a light grade of the same oil before use. R(CQt.llril(NO(L
RCti:'>UMtriDti:*
U?P[R Ulol1'f
LU,,.4(9 U PC TRCl.[Ul,I
0( S YNT"1[ 0&. IS 20QT Dt. IS, :'!:tO-:-Figure 2-3. Oil Viscosity
Chart 9 .. 
EC 62n632 Att. Mob1lli"M
1, R'9>oR?i4&.:
REVISION:
03
... I of3 PAGE 020F 03 Business lines (http://corporate.exxonmobil.com/?query=http%3a%2f%2fwww.mobil.com%2fenglish-US%2fPassenger-Vehicle-Lube%2fpds%2fGLXXMobil-
1 -SW30#business-lines)
MO bi 1* (http://corporate.exxonmobil.com)
ExxonMobil
> Mobil 1 SW30 PDS (https://www.exxonmobil.com/Passenger-Vehicle-Lube/Mobil-1-SW30/pds-US) , English Mobil 1-SW-30 Passenger
Vehicle Lube Mobil, United States Advanced Full Synthetic
Engine Oil Product Description
Mobil 1 * SW-30 is an advanced full synthetic
engine oil designed to keep your engine running like new by providing
exceptional
wear protection, cleaning power and overall performance.
Mobil 1 SW-30 meets or exceeds the requirements
of the industry's
toughest standards
and outperforms
our conventional
oils. Mobil 1 technology
comes as standard equipment
in many different
vehicles, including
select high-performance
vehicles.
Features and Potential
Benefits Mobil 1 SW-30 is made with a proprietary
blend of high performance
synthetic
basestocks
fortified
with a precisely
balanced component
system. The SW-30 viscosity
grade is one of the most recommended
viscosity
grades for new cars. Mobil 1 SW-30 is uniquely designed to help provide unsurpassed
levels of performance, cleaning power and engine protection, while meeting the demanding
ILSAC GF-5 performance
standards.
Features Advantages
and Potential
Benefits Advanced Full synthetic
formula Helps prevent deposits ana sludge build-up to enable long engine life Excellent
overall lubrication
and wear protection
performance
for many driving styles Outstanding
thermal and oxidation
stability
Outstanding
performance
during the maximum oil change interval recommended
in a vehicle's
owners manual Enhanced frictional
properties
Excellent
low temperature
capabilities
Applications
Aids fuel economy Quick cold weather starting for ultra fast protection
Helps to extend engine life Mobil 1 SW-30 is recommended
for all types of modern vehicles, including
high-performance
turbo-charged, supercharged
gasoline and diesel valve fuel injected engines found passenger
cars, SUVs, light vans and light trucks. * Mobil 1 SW-30 is general purpose engine oil for many types of cars * Mobil 1 Sw-30 is not recommended
for 2-Cycle or aviation engines, unless specifically
approved by the manufacturer.
Specifications
and Approvals
Mobil 1 SW-30 meets or exceeds the requirements
of: ACEA A1/B1 API SN, SM, SL,SJ ILSAC GF-5 6/19/17, 11:09 PM 
EC 6206321: Att. Mobil I TM 5W-jQ 1, R'.Ef>oR-J2i40\:
REVISION:
03 http://www.mobil.com/
english-
ube/pds/G
... 2 of3 PAGE03 Of 03 Ford WSS-M2C946-A, WSS-M2C929-A
Mobil 1 5W-30 has the following
builder approvals:
General Motors SeNice Fill dexos1" {license number GB1 A0915015)
Honda I Acura HT0-06 Mobil 1 5W-30 is recommended
by ExxonMobil
for use in applications
requiring:
General Motors 4718M General Motors 6094M Typical Properties
Mobil 1 5W-30 SAE Grade 5W-30 Viscosity@
100&deg;C, cSt (ASTM 0445) 11.0 Viscosity, @ 40&deg;C, cSt (ASTM 0445) 61.7 Viscosity
Index 172 Sulfated Ash, wt% (ASTM 0874) 0.8 Phosphorous, wt% (ASTM 04981) 0.08 HTHS Viscosity, mPa*s@ 150&deg;C (ASTM D4683) 3.1 Pour Point, &deg;C (ASTM D97) -42 Flash Point, &deg;C (ASTM D92) 230 Density @15.6 &deg;C, kg/I (ASTM 04052) 0.855 Health and Safety Based on available
information, this product is not expected to produce adverse effects on health when used for the intended application
and the recommendations
provided in the Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) are followed.
MSDS's are available
upon request through your sales contract office, or via the Internet.
This product should not be used for purposes other than its intended use. If disposing
of used product, take care to protect the environment.
Mobil, Mobil 1 and the Pegasus design are trademarks
of Exxon Mobil Corporation, or one of its subsidiaries.
05-2017 Exxon Mobil Corporation
22777 Springwoods
Village Parkway Spring TX 77389 1-800-ASK
MOBIL (275-6624)
Typical Properties
are typical of those obtained with normal production
tolerance
and do not constitute
a specification.
Variations
that do not affect product performance
are to be expected during normal manufacture
and at different
blending locations.
The information
contained
herein is subject to change without notice. All products may not be available
locally. For more information, contact your local ExxonMobil
contact or visit www.exxonmobil.com (http://www.exxonmobil.com)
6/19/17, 11 :09 PM 
EC 620632 , Att. 1 , Pg. 245 of 267 Ella Gills From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachment
P Cordially , Anup Behera , Ph. D KCI (630)515-2650 x 17 (630)56 1-0463 {Cell) Anup Behe r a <abehera@kciconsultants
.com> Tuesday , June 20 , 2017 8:4 8 AM 'Ella Gills' FW: Heres anothe r on e REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1 REVISION: 0 3 PAGE P1 OF P 1 From: Halverson, Eric D:(Contractor
-GenCo-Nuc)
[mailto:Eric.Halverson@exeloncoro.com
] Sent: Tuesday, June 20 , 2017 8: 39 AM To: Anup Behera Cc: Peter Brunsgaard
Subject: RE: Heres another one Anup , please include the picture below i n the attachment
associated
w i th the Magnetic Pick-up. I bel i eve it is Attachment
P. " llOUllTllO
lYJI( 54-11 UtlF lllll&#xa3;AD Ol'Ell TEMP RAHGE -47T022S DECF OIJ1'Fl1T
lllPEllAAC&#xa3;
011MS
R0197Ct.T
S(RIAl
__ SIZI: -
VOLTAGE
'1;5 I/RIIS Mii ,,. 1 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 246 of 267 Nf:,N w 0 0 D w ARD REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGEQ1OF02
Product Manual 02303 (Revision
B, 9/2015) Original Instructions
2301A Load Sharing and Speed Control 9900-430, 9900-431, 9900-432, 9900-433 Installation
and Operation
Manual 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 247 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGEQ20FQ2
2301A Control Specifications
Part Numbers: 9900-430 9900-431 9900-432 9900-433 Speed Ranges (switch selectable):
Range 1 Range2 Range 3 (factory setting) Range 4 Steady State Speed Band Load Sharing Approximate
Weight (may vary slightly depending
on model) 2301A Dimensions
Power Supply Rating: High Voltage Models Low Voltage Models Operating
Temperature
Storage Temperature
Maximum Ambient Humidity Vibration
Test Shock Test SPM-A Synchronizer (optional):
Speed Trim (optional):
24 V, forward-acting
24 V, reverse-acting
110 V, forward-acting
11 O V, reverse-acting
500-1500 Hz 1000-3000
Hz 2000-6000
Hz 4000-12 000 Hz +/-1/4of1% of rated speed +/-5% of rated load 1.9 kg/4.2 lb see Figure 1-1 90-150 VDC or 88-132 VAC 50/60 Hz, 12 W 20-40 VDC, 12 W -40 to +85 &deg;C (-40 to +185 &deg;F) -55 to +105 &deg;C (-67 to +221 &deg;F) 95% at 38 &deg;C (100 &deg;F) (US MIL-STD 167)-4 Gs between 5 and 500 Hz (US MIL-STD 901 C)--60 Gs -5 to +5 VDC for -3.3% to +3.3% speed change OR -1.5 to +1.5 VDC for-1 % to +1 % speed change 100 kQ maximum load 0-10% speed decrease with 0-100 n pot (1 W) 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 248 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE R1 OF RB WRIGHT System 1000 Revision 17.0.d Arrhenius
File Report Arrhenius
Material File Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: 13 Commercial
Name: ACME 2-520 Generic Name: Manufacturer:
DIALLYL PHTHALATE, GLASS FILLED ACME Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): PLASTIC DIELECTRIC
STRENGTH 2.1701 25, 183.37323870
-48.92302560
0.00000000
N/A Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 616 LEXAN POLYCARBONATE
GENERAL ELECTRIC CO PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 1.4519 16,849.45591645
-32.64128440
0.99998522
0.125 Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 05 June 2017 17:39 UTC 617 LEXAN 101 POLYCARBONATE
GENERAL ELECTRIC CO PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 1.4891 17 ,281 .12829989
-33.68882070
0.99994154
0.125 Temperature
Rating: 130C Highest Aging Temp.: N/A Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 158-83D Arrhenius
Page Number: 2 Temperature
Rating: 75C Highest Aging Temp.: 140C Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 362-84B Arrhenius
Page Number: 77 Temperature
Rating: 115C Highest Aging Temp.: 178C Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 151-83B Arrhenius
Page Number: 2 Page 1 of 8 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 249 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE R2 OF RB WRIGHT System 1000 Revision 17.0.d Arrhenius
File Report Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 618 LEXAN 103 POLYCARBONATE
GENERAL ELECTRIC CO PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 0.6733 7,814.21164116
-10.63495050
0.99998756
0.125 Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 619 LEXAN 141 POLYCARBONATE
GENERAL ELECTRIC CO PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 1.1540 13,392.94840540
-24.01708290
0.99999680
0.125 Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 05 June 2017 17:39 UTC 620 LEXAN 2014 POLYCARBONATE
GENERAL ELECTRIC CO PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 0.7767 9,014.09393307
-13.13611930
0.99998223
0.125 Temperature
Rating: 1 OOC Highest Aging Temp.: 240C Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 151-838 Arrhenius
Page Number: 2 Temperature
Rating: 115C Highest Aging Temp.: 195C Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 151-83B Arrhenius
Page Number: 2 Temperature
Rating: 110C Highest Aging Temp.: 235C Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 151-838 Arrhenius
Page Number: 2 Page 2 of 8 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 250 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE R3 OF RB WRIGHT System 1000 Revision 17.0.d Arrhenius
File Report Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 621 LEXAN 2014 POLYCARBONATE
GENERAL ELECTRIC CO PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 0.7653 8,882.44150690
-12.81498310
0.99999054
N/A Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 624 LEXAN 940 POLYCARBONATE
GENERAL ELECTRIC CO PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 1.1717 13,598.25423908
-24.69685320
0.99992693
N/A Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 05 June 201717:39
UTC 625 LEXAN 940 POLYCARBONATE
GENERAL ELECTRIC CO PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 1.2535 14,547.39736555
-27.07192920
0.99998654
0.125' Temperature
Rating: 11 DC Highest Aging Temp.: 162C Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 174-83C Arrhenius
Page Number: 1 Temperature
Rating: 11 OC Highest Aging Temp.: 152C Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 174-83C Arrhenius
Page Number: Temperature
Rating: 11 OC Highest Aging Temp.: 150C Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 349-84B Arrhenius
Page Number: 2 Page3 of 8 
-------------
----------------------------------------------
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 251 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE R40FR8 WRIGHT System 1000 Revision 17.0.d Arrhenius
File Report Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 650 MERLON M-40 POLYCARBONATE
MOBAY CHEMICAL CORP PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 1.1847 13,748.18255115
-24.42061880
0.00000000
0.125 Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 651 MERLON M-40 POLYCARBONATE
MOBAY CHEMICAL CORP PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 1.1847 13,748.18255115
-24.42061880
0.00000000
0.0625 Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 05 June 2017 17:39 UTC 652 MERLON M-50 POLYCARBONATE
MOBAY CHEMICAL CORP PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 1.1847 13,748.18255115
-24.42061880
0.00000000
0.125 Temperature
Rating: 115C Highest Aging Temp.: N/A Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 198-83C Arrhenius
Page Number: 3 Temperature
Rating: 115C Highest Aging Temp.: N/A Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 198-83C Arrhenius
Page Number: 3 Temperature
Rating: 115C Highest Aging Temp.: N/A Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 198-83C Arrhenius
Page Number: 3 Page 4 of 8 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 252 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGER50FR8 WRIGHT System 1000 Revision 17.0.d Arrhenius
File Report Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.}: 653 MERLON M-50 POLYCARBONATE
MOBAY CHEMICAL CORP PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 1.1847 13,748.18255115
-24.42061880
0.00000000
 
0.0625 Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.}: 654 MERLON M-6400 POLYCARBONATE
MOBAY CHEMICAL CORP PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 1.1847
13,748.18255115
-24.42061880
0.00000000
0.125 Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
 
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.}: 05 June 2017 17:39 UTC 655 MERLON M-6400 POLYCARBONATE
MOBAY CHEMICAL CORP PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 1.1847
13,748.18255115
-24.42061880
0.00000000
0.0625 Temperature
Rating: 115C Highest Aging Temp.: N/A Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 198-83C Arrhenius
Page Number: 3 Temperature
Rating: 115C Highest Aging Temp.: N/A Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 198-83C Arrhenius
Page Number: 3 Temperature
Rating: 115C Highest Aging Temp.: N/A Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 198-83C Arrhenius
Page Number: 3 Page 5 of 8 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 253 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE R6 OF RB WRIGHT System 1000 Revision 17 .O.d Arrhenius
File Report Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 658 MERLON M-6600 POLYCARBONATE
MOBAY CHEMICAL CORP PLASTIC TENSILE IMPACT STRENGTH 1.1847
13,748.18255115
-24.42061880
0.00000000
0.125 Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 859 NOT STATED PHENOLIC ROGERS CORP PLASTIC DIELECTRIC
STRENGTH 0.9054 10,508.01262288
-15.07727990
0.99975307
0.0625 Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: 1045 Commercial
Name: PLASKON-DIALL
52-70-70 Temperature
Rating: 115C Highest Aging Temp.: N/A Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 198-83C Arrhenius
Page Number: 3 Temperature
Rating: 150C Highest Aging Temp.: 230C Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 330-84C Arrhenius
Page Number: 19 Generic Name: Manufacturer:
DIALLYL PHTHALATE, GLASS FILLED PLASKON Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 05 June 2017 17:39 UTC PLASTIC DIELECTRIC
STRENGTH 2.1701 25, 183.37323870
-48.92302560
0.00000000
N/A Temperature
Rating: 130C Highest Aging Temp.: N/A Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 158-830 Arrhenius
Page Number: 2 Page 6 of 8 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 254 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE R70F RB WRIGHT System 1000 Revision 17.0.d Arrhenius
File Report Item Description:
No Description
Provided Material Number: Commercial
Name: Generic Name: Manufacturer:
Material Classification:
Failure Parameter:
Activation
Energy: Slope: Intercept:
Correlation
Coefficient:
Material Thickness (in.): 1649 DUREZ 18441 PHENOLIC, WOOD FLOUR FILLED HOOKER CHEMICAL AND PLASTICS PLASTIC NOT STATED 2.2900 26,575.37
420000 0.00000000
0.00000000
N/A Temperature
Rating: 150C Highest Aging Temp.: N/A Arrhenius
Lib. Code No.: 476-86C Arrhenius
Page Number: 62 Notes: ACTIVATION
ENERGY STATED IN REPORT 05 June 2017 17:39 UTC Page 7 of 8 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 255 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-00B-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE RB OF RB WRIGHT System 1000 Revision 17.0.d Arrhenius
File Report References
Library Code Title 151-838 GENERAL ELECTRIC CO LETIER, DATED 5/1B/B2, ON LExAN 101, 103, 141AND2014
ARRHENI DATA 158-830 ARRHENIUS
CURVES FOR DIALL YL PHTHALATE (DAP). MIL TYPE SDG-F 174-83C LIFE CURVE FOR LEXAN 940 AND 2014 198-83C MERLON POLYCARBONATE-THERM
AGING DATA & GAMMA STERILIZATION
OF MERLON POLYCARBONATE
DATA 330-84C RESISTANCE
OF PHENOLIC MOLDING MATERIALS
TO DEGRADATION
AT HIGH TEMPERATUR
349-848 GE LETIER WITH ARRHENIUS
PLOT FOR LEXAN 940 362-848 AGING-SEISMIC
CORRELATION
STUDY ON CLASS 1 E EQUIPMENT
476-86C MATERIAL ACT. ENGS. THERMOGRAVIMETRIC
ANLS. & DIFFRNTL SCANNING CALORIMETRY
THEORY & APPL. 05 June 2017 17:39 UTC Page B of B 
JOOk ables ectronics
echnicians
tee rs its Design Standard Handbook for Electrical
Engineers
DONALD G. FINK Editor-in-Chief
General Manager and Executive
Directo-f (Retired), Institute
of Electrical
and Electronics
Engineers;
formerly Vice
Research, Philco Corporation, President
of the Institute
of Radio Engineers, Editor of the Proceedings
of the IRE; Fellow of.the IEEE; Fellow of the IEE (London);
Emiiwnt Member, Eta Kappa Nu; Member of the National Academy of Engineering
Associate
Editor H. WAYNE BEATY Senior Editor, Electrical
World; Member of the Institute
of Electrical
and Electronics
Engineers
and of the IEEE Power Engineering
Society's
Transmission
and Distribution
Committee
Eleventh Edition McGRAW-HILL
BOOK COMPANY New York St. Louis San Francisco
Auckland Bogota Diisseldorf
Johannesburg'
London Madrid Mexico Montreal New Delhi Panama Paris Sao Paulo Singapore
Sydney Tokyo Toronto ' ' 
nf equal and opposite to the conductors
and dielectrics
is ;es. A substance
may have Y low but may be unsuitable
?ractically.*nonconducting
at .ently heated. For*numerical
' principal
materials
used m :lectrons, in addition to those I they were the particles
of a lied; each electron gains a , is in the direction
opposite.
*motion the electrons
collide S* loss is supposed to account tcting, state by such
as nes, arcs, or glowing metals* is due to free electrons. tion .. The movement of free trolytes), the passage of an Atoms ofmetals and hydro-' current, while oxygen and solid conductors
electricity
the matter .. For details of terials that are intermediate
is often sensitive
to y are the basis for transistors
:lady and there are no. emfs terminals
of tlie conductor
is (2-1) iance of the conductor.
The (2-2)
of the conduc-1 volts, the resistance
r is in >hms). n's law becomes (2-3) (2-4) tor. the axis of the cylinder *the iortional
to the cross
(2-5) the resistivity (or specific ms materials, see Sec. 4. m I I I ' ' l j REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I* Continuous-Current
Circuits
S2 OF S2 The conductance
of a cylmdrical
conductor
is A g=<TT (2-6) where CT (sigma) is called the
conductivity
of the material.
Since g = l/r, the relation also holds that 1 CT=-p (2-7) 15. Change of Resistance
with Temperature.
The resistance
of a conductor
varies with the temperature.
The resistance
of metals and most alloys increases
with the temperature, while the resistance
of carbon and electrolytes
decreases
with the temperature.
For usual conditions, as for about 100&deg;C. change in temperature, the resistance
at a temperature
t 2 is given by / ,.-B12 =* R11[l + a1 1 (t, -ti)] (2-8) where R 1 i is the resistance
at an initial temperature
ti and a" is called the temperature
coefficient
of resistance
of the material for the initial temperature
t" Fo:r copper having a conductivity
of 100% of the International
Annealed Copper Standard, a 20 = 0.00393, where temperatures
are in degrees Celsfas (see Sec. 4). An equation giving the same results as Eq. (2-8), for copper of 100% conductivity, is R 12 = 234.4 + t, (2-9) R" 234.4 + t 1 where -2.34.4 is called the "inferred
absolute zero" because if the relation held (which it does*not over such a large range) the resistance
at that temperature
would be zero. For hard-draW!l
copper of 97.3% conductivity, the numerical
constant in Eq. (2-9) is changed to 241.5. See Sec, 4 for values* of these numerical
constants
for copper; and for oj:her metals see Sec. 4 under the metal being considered.
For 100% conductivity
copper, 1 lltt = _2_3_4_.4_+_t_1
(2-10) :whe;_ R" and R 12*have been measured, as at the beginning
and end of a heat run, the "temperature
rise by resistance" for 100% conductivity
copper is given by R12 -R" ( 44 ) t 2 -ti = R 23 . + t 1 tl (2.-11) 16. Resistances
and Conductances
in Series. When two or more resistances
are connected
in series, the equivalent
resistance
of the combination
is equal to the sum of the resistances
of the individual
resistors, or *.. r,.=r 1+r 2+*** (2-12) When
are connected
in series, the equivalent
conductance
g,. is mined from the relation 1 1 1 -=-+-+.''
(2-13) g,. g, g, *that is, the reciprocal
of the equivalent
conductance
is equal to the sum of the reciprocals
of the individual
conductances.
17. Resistances
and Conductances
Connected
in Parallel.
The equivalent
resistance
r,. of a parallel combination
of resistors
is determined
from the relation (2-14) or in conductance
notation g,.=g,+g2+***
(2-15)
==:__:::_::-::
__
__ ::._:::::::
___ =-=--=* =-=--=-:::'.:::::::-"""*--=--=--------=
a 11 t w IV 0 z <.( w 1 l 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 258 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424*008*RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGET1 0FT10 NUMARC 87:..00 * Rev. 1 Guidelines
and Techn*ical
Bases for NUMARC lnitiative*s
Addressing
Station ... Blackout at Light *wa.ter Reactors August 1991 *' *' . Nuclear Management
and Resources
Council, Inc. 1776 Eye Street, N.W. Washington, DC 20006-2496 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 259 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424*008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE T2 OF T10 GUIDELINES
AND TECHNICAL
BASES FOR NUMARC INITIATIVES
ADDRESSING
STATION BLACKOUT AT LIGHT WATER REACTORS Technical
Support Provided By: Nuclear Utility Group on Station Blackout (NUGSBO) Principal
Investigators: . Devonrue, Ltd. Winston & Strawn August 1991 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 260 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE T3 OF T10 FOREWORD Revision 1 to NUMARC 87-00 presents in one volume all generic guidance developed
for meeting the requirements
of the station blackout rule, 10 CFR &sect; 50.63. In particular, Revision 1 includes appendices
providing
guidance relative to emergency
diesel generator (EOG) reliability
programs and equipment
operability
that were not available
for inclusion
in Revision 0. Additional
appendices
provide supplemental
clarifying
guidance distributed
subsequent
to issuance of NUMARC 87-00, Revision 0. Lastly, revision bars in the right margin indicate where the text has been revised to incorporate
errata from the original document.
As discussed
in Appendix K, the Nuclear Regulatory
Commission
has documented
their acceptance
of this guidance.
Included in this revision is the acceptance
of a methodology
for effective
monitoring
and maintaining
EOG reliability
consistent
with Appendix D of this document.
NOTICE This report was prepared in connection
with work sponsored
by the Nuclear Management
and Resources
Council, Inc. (NUMARC).
Neither NUMARC nor any of its employees, members, or consultants
make any warranty, expressed
or implied, or assume any legal liability
or responsibility
for the accuracy, completeness
or usefulness
of any information, apparatus, product or process disclosed
in this report, or represent
that its use would not infringe privately-owned
rights. The opinions, conclusions, and recommendations
set forth in this report are those of the authors and do not necessarily
represent
the views of NUMARC, its employees, members or consultants. 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 261 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-00B-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE T4 OF T10 CONTENTS 1. INTRODUCTION
..........................................................................................................................
1-1 I.I GUIDANCE AND DOCUI\1ENT
STRUCTURE
...................................................................
1-1 1.2 NUMARC INITIATIVES
..................................................................................................
1-2 (1) Initiative
IA ---RISK REDUCTION
.......................................................................
1-2 (2) Initiative
2 ---PROCEDURES
...............................................................................
1-2 (3) Initiative
3 ---COLD STARTS ..................... , .........................................................
1-3 (4) Initiative
4 ---AC POWER AVAILABILITY
............................................................
1-3 (5) Initiative
5A---COPING ASSESSMENT/EOG
PERFORMANCE
..............................
1-3 1.3 SUPPORTING
INFORMATION
........................................................................................
1-4 2. GENERAL CRITERIA AND BASELINE ASSUMPTIONS
..................................................................
2-1 2.1 GENERAL CRITERIA ...............................................................................................
2-1 2.2 INITIAL PLANT CONDITIONS
..................................................................................
2-2 2.2.1 Assumptions
.................................................................................................
2-2 2.2.2 Basis ............................................................................................................
2-2 2.3 INITIATING
EVENT ..................................................................................................
2-2 2.3.1 Assumptions
.................................................................................................
2-2 2.3.2 Basis ............................................................................................................
2-3 2.4 STATION BLACKOUT TRANSIENT;
..........................................................................
2-6 2.4.1 Assumptions
.................................................................................................
2-6 2.4.2 Basis ............................................................................................................
2-7 2.5 REACTOR COOLANT INVENTORY
LOSS .................................................................
2-7 2.5.1 Assumptions
.................................................................................................
2-7 2.5.2 Basis ............................................................................................................
2-8 2.6 OPERATOR ACTION ................................................................................................
2-9 2.6.1 Assumptions
.................................................................................................
2-9 2.6.2 Basis ............................................................................................................
2-9 2.7 EFFECTS OF LOSS OF VENTILATION
......................................................................
2-9 2.7.1 Assumptions
.................................................................................................
2-9 2.7.2 Basis ............................................................................................................
2-11 2.8 SYSTEM CROSS-TIE
CAPABILITY
...........................................................................
2-15 2.8.1 Assumptions
.................................................................................................
2-15 2.8.2 Basis ............................................................................................................
2-15 2.9 INSTRUMENTATION
AND CONTROLS .....................................................................
2-15 2.9 .1 Assumptions
.................................................................................................
2-15 2.9.2 Basis ..... ......................................................................................................
2-16 2.10 CONTAINMENT
ISOLATION
VALVES ......................................................................
2-16 2.10.1 Assumptions
.................................................................................................
2-16 2.10.2 Basis ............................................................................................................
2-16 2.11 HURRICANE
PREP ARA TIO NS .................................................................................
2-17 2.11.1 Assumptions
.................................................................................................
2-17 2.11.2 Basis ............................................................................................................
2-17 iii 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 262 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE TS OF T10 3. REQUIRED COPING DURATION CATEGORY ................................................................................
3-1 3.1 PROCEDURE
OVERVIEW ........................................................................................
3-1 3.2 PROCEDURE
...........................................................................................................
3-1 3.2.1 Step One Determine
The Off-site Power Design Characteristic
Group .......................
3-1 Part 1.A .......................................................................................................
3-2 Part l.B ........................................................................................................
3-3 Part 1.C .......................................................................................................
3-6 Part 1.D**.;:,;;;**
..................................................................................................
3-9 Part 1.E ........................................................................................................
3-10 3.2.2 Step Two Classify The Emergency
AC Power Configuration
.................................
3-12 Part 2.A Determine
the Number ofEAC Power Supplies Normally Available
.........
3-14 Part 2.B Determine
the NumberofNecessary
EAC Standby Power Supplies ..........
3-14 Part 2.C Select the EAC Power Configuration
Group .........................................
3-15 3.2.3 Step Three Determine
The Calculated
EDG Reliability
..........................................
3-15 3.2.4 Step Four Determine
Allowed EOG Target Reliability
..........................................
3-16 3.2.5 Step Five Determine
Coping Duration Category ..................................................
3-18 3.2.6 Required Action .............................................................................................
3-19 4. STATION BLACKOUT RESPONSE PROCEDURES
..........................................................................
4-1 4.1 OVERVIEW .............................................................................................................
4-1 4.2 OPERATING
PROCEDURES
GUIDELINES
...............................................................
..4-1 4.2.l Station Blackout Response Guidelines (NUMARC Station Blackout Initiative
2.a) .... .4-1 4.2.2 AC Power Restoration (NUMARC Station Blackout Initiative
2.b) .........................
4-4 4.2.3 Severe Weather Guidelines (NUMARC Station Blackout Initiative
2.c) ....................
4-4 4.3 SUPPORTING
INFORMATION
............................................. ....................................
4-6 4.3.1 Station Blackout Response Guidelines
................................... ...........................
.4-6 4.3.2 AC Power Restoration
Guidelines
.....................................................................
4-11 5. COLD STARTS ............................................................................................................................
5-1 5.1 DISCUSSION
.......................................................................... ................................
5-1 5.2 ACTION ..................................................................................................................
5-1 6. EMERGENCY
AC POWER AV AILABILlTY
....................................................................................
6-1 6.1 DISCUSSION
...........................................................................................................
6-1 6.2 ACTION ....................................................................
; .............................................
6-1 7. COPING WITH A STATION BLACKOUT EVENT .............................................................................
7-1 7.1 OVERVIEW .............................................................................................................
7-1 7.1.1 CopingMcthods
............................................................................................
7-1 7.1.2 Coping Duration ............................................................................................
7-2 7.2 COPING ASSESSMENT
.................................................................
; ..........................
7-2 7.2.1 Condensate
Inventory
for Decay Heat Removal ....................................................
7-2 Supporting
Information
...................................................................................
7-5 Analysis .......................................................................................................
7-5 Results .........................................................................................................
7-6 7.2.2 Assessing
the Class 1E Battery Capacity ............................................................
7-7 Discussion
....................................................................................................
7-7 Procedure
......................................................................................................
7-8 Supporting
Information
...................................................................................
7-9 7.2.3 Compressed
Air .............................................................................................
7-10 Discussion
....................................................................................................
7-10 Procedure
......................................................................................................
7-10 Supporting
Information
...................................................................................
7-12 7 .2.4 Effects of Loss of Ventilation
...........................................................................
7-12 Discussion
....................................................................................................
7-12 Procedure
......................................................................................................
7-13 Supporting
Information
...................................................................................
7-18 7.2.5 Containment
Isolation
.....................................................................................
7-21 Discussion
....................................................................................................
Procedure
......................................................................................................
7-22 iv 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 263 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-008-RP1
REVISION:
03 f PAGE T6 OF T10 APPENDIX A. DEFINITIONS
.............................................................................................................
A-1 APPENDIX B. AL TERNA TE AC POWER CRITERIA ...........................................................................
B-1 APPENDIX C. SAMPLE AAC CONFIGURATIONS
..............................................................................
C*l APPENDIX D. EDG RELIABILITY
PROGRAM ....................................................................................
D-1 D. l Introduction
...............................................................................................................
D-1 D.2 Definitions
..............................................................................
: .................................
D-2 D.3 Monitoring
EDG Reliability
........................................................................................
D-4 D.3.1 Maintaining
EDG Reliability
Data ....................................................................
04 D.3.2 Determining
Performance
and Reliability
Indicators
..............................................
D-5 D.3 .2.1 Determining
Unit EDG Perfonnancc Indicator for
Last 20 Demands .............
D-5 D.3.2.2 Determining
Unit EDG Reliability
Indicator
for Last 50 Demands ...............
D-5 D.3.2.3 Determining
Unit EDG Reliability
Indicator
for Last 100 Demands .............
D-0 D.3.2.4 Special Conditions
.............................................................................
D-0 D.3.3 Relating the Calculated
Unit EDG Performance
and Reliability
Indicators
to Trigger Values for Selected Target Reliability
.............................................................................
D-7 D.2.3.1 Use of the Exccedence
Trigger Values .....................................................
D-7 D.3.3.2 Successful
Test/Demand
......................................................................
0-8 D.3.3.3 Unsuccessful
Test/Demand
-No Trigger Values Excccded ...........................
D-8 D.3.3.4 Unsuccessful
Test/Demand
-One Trigger Value Exceeded
...........................
D-9 D.2.3.5 Unsuccessful
Test/Demand-50
and 100 Demand Trigger Values Exceeded .... D-9 D.3.4 Actions for Individual
Failures and for Exceedence
of One or More Trigger Values ...... D* 10 D.3.4.1 Actions for Plants That Do Not Exceed Either Trigger Value ......................
D-12 D.3.4.2 Actions For Plants Exceeding
a Single Trigger ........................................
D-13 D.2.4.3 Actions for Plants That Exceed the 50 and 100 Demand Triggers .................
D-15 D.2.4.4 Problem EDG ....................................................................................
D*16 D.3.4.5 Post Exceedence
Actions ......................................................................
D*17 D.3.4.6 Rccordkceping
...................................................................................
0-17 D.3.4.7 Reporting
to NRC ..............................................................................
D-17 APPENDIX E. TOPICAL REPORT ON EFFECTIVE
ELEMENTS OF AN EDG RELIABILITY
PROGRAM (APPENDIX
D TOPICAL REPORT) ....................................................................................................
&#xa3;-1 E. l Introduction
...............................................................................................................
E* l E.2 Surveillance
Needs ......................................................................................................
E-1 E.2.1 Reliability
of Subcomponents
and Support Systems .............................................
E-2 E.2.2 Failures Caused by Surveillances
.......................................................................
E-3 E.2.3 Frequency
and Scope of Surveillance
Testing .......................................................
E-4 E.3 Performance
Monitoring
..............................................................................................
E-7 E.4 Data Systems ............................................................................................................
E-10 E.4.1 Data Input .....................................................................................................
E-10 E.4.2 Data Capture .................................................................................................
&#xa3;-11 E.4.2.1 Surveillance
Test Results .....................................................................
E-12 E.4.2.2 EDG Failure History ...........................................................................
E-12 E.4.2.3 Root Cause Analysis ..........................................................................
E-13 E.4.2.4 Manufacturer's
Data .c ..........................................................................
E-13 E.4.2.5 Input from Preventative
and Corrective
Maintenance
Programs ...................
E-13 E.4.2.6 Industry Operating
Experience
...............................................................
E-13 E.4.3 Data Storage and Retrievability
.........................................................................
E-13 E.5 Maintenance
Program ..................................................................................................
E-14 E.6 Failure Analysis and Root Cause Investigation
................................................................
E-15 E.7 Problem Closcout ......................................................................................................
E-18 E.8 Methodology
for Determining
Programmatic
Deficiencies
..................................................
E-19 E.8.1 Assessing
actual Failure History Against Critical Review Elemcnts .........................
E-19 E.8.2 Potential
Dominant Failure Modes ....................................................................
E-23 E.8.2.1 Failure Modes and
Effects Analysis (FMEA) .................
; .........................
E-24 E.8.2.2 Quality Improvement
Programs (Demming Methods) ................................
E-26 E.8.2.3 Kepner Tregoe Techniques
....................................................................
E-26 v 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 264 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-00B-RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE T7 OF T10 APPENDIX F. ASSESSMENTS
OF EQUIPMENT
OPERABILITY
IN DOMINANT AREAS UNDER STATION BLACKOUT CONDITIONS
..............
.-.................................................................................................
F-1 F. l Introduction
...............................................................................................................
F-1 F.1.1 General Guidance ............................................................................................
F-2 F.1.2 Procedure
......................................................................................................
F-2 F.1.3 Exrunple .......................................................................................................
F*3 F.1.4 Assumptions
and Definitions
............................................................................
F-4 F .2 Equipment
Previously
Evaluated
...................................................................................
F-8 F.2.1 General Statement
of Mcthod ............................................................................
F-8 F.2.2 Guidance .......................................................................................................
F-8 F.2.3 Procedure
......................................................................................................
F-8 F.2.4 Examples ......................................................................................................
F-8 F.3 Equipment
Design Capability
........................................................................................
F-10 F.3.1 General Statement
of Method ............................................................................
F-10 F.3.2 Guidance ............................................
: ...........................................................
F-10 F.3.3 Proccdurc
......................................................................................................
F-11 F.3.4 Examples ........ : ...................................
,: ..........................................................
F-11 F.4 Materials
..................................................................................................................
F-16 F.4.1 General Statement
of Method ............................................................................
F-16 F.4.2 Guidance ..............
; ........................................................................................
F-16 F.4.3 Procedure
..................
* .............. .....................................................................
F-16 F.4.4 Examples ......................................................................................................
F-17 F.5 Equipment
Inside Instrumentation
and Control Cabinets ....................................................
F-18 F.5.1 General Statement
of Method .......................................
; .....................................
F-18 F.5.2 Guidance ........................................
.' ..............................................................
F-18 F.5.3 Procedure
....................................................................
; .................................
F-18 F.5.4 Exarnple ..........................................................................
; .............................
F-19 F.6 Generic Studies and Experience
............................................
* .........................................
F-20 F.6.1 General Statement
of Mcthod ....................................
; .......................................
F-20 F.6.2 Guidance .......................................................................................................
F-20 F.6.3 Proccdurc
.....................................................................
.-................................
F-20 F.6.4 Examplcs ......................................................................................................
F-21 F. 7 Plant-Specific
Experience
and Tests ...............................................
* ................................
F-22 F.7.1 General Statement
of Method ............................................................................
F-22 F.7.2 Guidance .......................................................................................................
F-22 F.7.3 Proccdure
......................................................................................................
F-22 F.7.4 Examples ......................................................................................................
F-22 APPENDIX G. TOPICAL REPORT ON ASSESSMENTS
OF EQUIPMENT
OPERABILITY
IN DOMINANT AREAS UNDER STATION BLACKOUT CONDITIONS (APPENDIX
FTOPICAL REPORT) .....................
G-1 G.1 Introduction
...............................................................................................................
0-1 G .2 Mechanical
Equipment
.....................................
; ................................. .......................
G-3 G.2.1 Equipment
Evaluations
....................................................................................
0-4 G.2.1.1 Pumps .............................................................................................
G-4 G.2.1.2 Turbines ..........................................................................................
0-6 G.2.1.3 DC Motors, Fans, and Blowers ............................................................
0-8 G.2.1.4 Valves ............................................................................................
G-10 G.2.1.5 Motor Operated Valve Actuators
... ; ......................................................
0-12 G.2.1.6 Mechanical
Turbine Governors
............................................................
0-14 G.2.2 Failure Mode Evaluations
................................................................................
0-15 G.2.2.1 Bearing Failure .................................................................................
0-15 . 2.2.2 Fatigue-Induced
Failure ......................................................................
0-20 G.2.2.3 Creep-Induced
Failure .........................................................................
0-24 G.2.2.4 Winding Failure ................................................................................
G-26 G.2.2.5 Seal Fa.I.lure
.....................................................................................
0-27 0.2.3 Experience
with Mechanical
Equipment.
.............................................................
0-29 G.2.3.1 Motor Expericnce
..............................................................................
0-29 G .2.3 .2 Motor Operated Valve Actuator Experience
............................................
G-31 G.2.4 Rcferences
.....................................................................................................
G-32 vi 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 265 of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-00B*RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE TB OF T10 G.3 Electrical
and Electronic
Equipment
...............................................................................
G-34 G.3.1 Equipment
Evaluations
....................................................................................
G-35 G.3.1.1 Control and Instrumentation
Cables ......................................................
G-35 G .3 .1.2 Switches and Relays ..........................................................................
G-37 G.3.1.3 Sensors and Electronic Transmittcrs
......................................................
0-39 G .3.1.4 Electronic
Turbine Governors
..............................................................
G-42 G.3.2 Equipment
Failure ModeEvaluations
.................................................................
0-44 G.3.2.1 Thennally-Induced
Reliability
Decrease .................................................
G-44 G .3 .2.2 Insulation
Degradation
.......................................................................
G-46 G.3.3 Experience
with Electrical
and Electronic
Equipment.
............................................
G-47 G .3 .3 .1 Switches Experience
..........................................................................
G-47 G.3.3.2 Electronic
Transmitter
Experience
.........................
: ..............................
0-48 G.3.3.3 Cables and WiresExperience
...............................................................
G-48 G.3.4 References
.....................................................................................................
0-50 G.4 Materials
..................................................................................................................
0-53 G.4.1 Thennal Properties
of Commercial
Plastics .........................................................
0-54 G.4.2 Thcnnal Properties
of Commercial
Lubricants
.....................................................
0-55 G.4.3 Referenccs
.....................................................................................................
G-56 APPENDIX H. ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTS OF LOSS OF VENTILATION
UNDER STATION BLACKOUT CONDITIONS (Formerly
Appendix E) ...................................................................................................
H-1 H.l Introduction
...............................................................................................................
H-1 H.2 Dominant Areas of Concern .........................................................................................
H-1 H.3 Analysis of Compartment
Heatup ..................................................................................
H-1 H.3.1 Model Dcscription
..........................................................................................
H-2 H.3.2 RCIC Pump Room with No Openings ...............................................................
H-11 H.3.3 RCIC Pump Room with a Compartment
Opening ...............................................
H-12 H.4 Nomenclature
............................................................................................................
H-13 APPENDIX I. RESPONSES
TO QUESTIONS
RAISED AT THE NUMARC 87-00 SEMINARS ...................
1-1 1.1 General Questions
......................................................................................................
1-1 1.2 Section 1 Introduction
.................................................................................................
1-1 1.3 Section 2 General Criteria and Baseline Assumptions
........................................................
1-2 1.4 Section 3 Required Coping Duration Category .................................................................
I-4 1.5 Section 4 Station Blackout Response Procedures
..............................................................
I-10 1.6 Section 7 Coping with a Station Blackout ......................................................................
1-13 1.7 Appendix A Definitions
...............................................................................................
1-22 1.8 Appendix B Alternate
AC Power Criteria ........................................................................
1-23 1.9 Appendix C Sample AAC Configurations
.......................................................................
I-26 1.10 Appendix F Assessments
of Equipment
Operability
in Dominant Areas Under Sta ti on Blackout Conditions
............................................................................... , ................................
I-28 I. I I Rule Response Format and Schedule ..............................................................................
I-28 APPENDIX J. NUMARC 87-00 SUPPLEMENTAL
QUESTIONS
AND ANSWERS ...................................
J-1 J. I General Questions
......................................................................................................
J-1 J.2 Section 1 Introduction
.................................................................................................
1-1 J.3 Section 2 General Criteria and Baseline Assumptions
........................................................
J-2 J .4 Section 3 Required Coping Duration Category .................................................................
J-4 J.5 Section 4 Station Blackout Response Proccdurcs
..............................................................
J-6 J.6 Section 7 Coping with a Station Blackout Event.. ............................................................
1-6 J .7 Appendix B Alternate
AC Power Criteria ........................................................................
J-7 J.8 Appendix C Sample AAC Configurations
.......................................................................
1-8 J.9 NUMARC 87-00 Major Assumptions
............................................................................
1-10 APPENDIX K. NRC CORRESPONDENCE
..........................................................................................
K-1 APPENDIX L. REFERENCES
............................................................................................................
L-1 vii 
EC 6 2 0 6 3 2 1 At t . 1 , Pg * 2 6 6 0 f 2 6 7 REPORT NO.: REP-424*008*RP1
REVISION:
03 I PAGE T9 OF T10 GUIDELINES
AND. TECHNICAL
BASES FOR NUMARC INITIATIVES
NUMARC 87-00 Revision 1 G.2.3 Experience
with Mechanical
Equipment
This section summarizes
the available
experience
with motors and motor operated valve actuators
at elevated temperatures.
G.2.3.1 Motor Experience
Insulation
is used in a motor to electrically
insulate the windings from mechanical
parts of the motor as well as to insulate the spaces between the turns of the coil winding. Also considered
to be insulation
are those materials
used to secure the windings and to make them rigid and impervious
to ambient conditions.
There arc four basic classes of insulating
materials
currently
recognized
by the motor industry.
Each differs according
Lo its physical properties
and can withstand
a certain maximum operating
temperature (frequently
termed total temperature.
or hot spot temperature)
and provide a practical
and useful insulation
life. The insulation
classes and their maximum operating
temperatures
are12,13:
INSULATION
CLASS CLASS A CLASS B CLASS F CLASS H RATED TEMPERATURE
OF INSULATING
SYSTEM 900 c 130&deg;C 1ss 0 c 1so 0 c The thermal ratings for the insulating
material in motor windings is assigned on the basis of a series of accelerated
aging testsl4,15.
In these tests the insulating
system is exposed to temperatures
significantly
higher than those experienced
during normal operation.
Figure G .2* 11 shows actual tested time-temperature
life for various insulation
classes. The shaded area represents
the range of experimental
results obtained for the insulation
classes. This figure demonstrates
that even the most limiting insulation
classes should be expected to function at ambient temperatures
above 180&deg; C for the limited duration of a four hour station blackoul G-29 
EC 620632, Att. 1, Pg. 267 Of 267 REPORT NO.: REP-424-00B-RP1
REVISION:
03 PAGE T10 OF T10 GUIDELINES
AND TECHNICAL
BASES FOR NUMARC INITIATIVES
Aging Time (hr) 10000 1000 Class NUMARC 87-00 Revision 1
100 150 200 250 Temperature
(0 C) Figure G.2-11: Range of Thermal Limit Curves for Tested Systemsl 6 G-30 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 1 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI Report Release Report Number: NAI-2007-004
Revision Number: 0 Title: Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator Room GOTHIC
Uncertainty
Evaluation
Client: Exeloi::i/Clinton
Power Station Description:
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 1 of47 The purpose of this engineering
report is to supplement
the analysis of the Division 1 Diesel Generator
room heat-up due to loss of the DG room emergency
fan documented
in Reference
[8.14]. Uncertainty
is present within that analysis as well as several modeling conservatisms.
This engineering
report evaluates
the impact ofremoving
some of those conservatisms
for the purpose of generating
a less-conservative, more best-estimate
prediction
of room temperatures
within the Division 1 Diesel Generator
room in order to determine
room temperature
margin. Author -Jordan Penley Date -t1JJ
Reviewer -Rodney Harvill Date
Project Manager -Steven Winter Date NAI Management
-Steven Winter Date NAI-QA-1-04
Rev 5 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 2 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 2 of47 Check items in the following
lists to verify that project documentation
and engineering
calculations
that relate to this report are complete.
It is the responsibility
of the Report Author and Reviewer to confirm that the required Project documentation
is complete to the extent necessary
to cover the release of this Report.* The Report Author is responsible
for archiving
the report and the supporting
documents.
Mark any items that are not applicable
as NIA. Yes NI A Project Documentation
Checklist
D IZI Project QA Plan. IZI D Project Engineer Training and Qualification
Forms for engineers
involved with this report. D IZI Project QA Training Certification
Forms for engineers
involved with this report. IZI D Reports utilizing
software evaluated
against identified
code errors for potential
impact on the analysis.
IZI D Supporting
documents
reviewed and signed. IZI D Model parameters
reviewed for references/assumptions, documentation, and checked against cited value. IZI D Review Summary Report completed, including
NAI.review
scope, comments and resolution, and client comments and resolution.
D IZI Report complies with relevant Purchase Order QA requirements.
IZI D Report listing in PCS complete, including
document title, date, originator, description
and intended archive location.
Report and supporting
documents
must be archived within 1 month of the final signature
date. NAI-QA-1-04
Rev 5 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 3 of 254 Table of Contents Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 3 of47 Page No. 1.0 Objective
..................................................................................................................
5 2.0 Inputs ........................................................................................................................
7 2.1 GOTHIC Models ..................................................................................................
7 2.2 Generator Heat Load
Profile Generation
.............................................................
7 2.3 Tank Room Exhaust Fan Flow Split from the Division 1 Room Recirculation
and Supply Ductwork .....................................................................................................
7 2.4 Atmospheric
Conditions
.......................................................................................
7 2.5 Temperature
Sensor Locations
during Diesel Generator
Testing ........................
7 2.6 Exhaust Pipe Leakage ..........................................................................................
7 2.7 Electrical
Panel Free Volume and Panel Wall Thickness
....................................
8 2.8 Combustion
Air Piping Parameters
......................................................................
8 3.0 Assumptions
.............................................................................................................
8 4.0 Methodology
...............................................................
_. ............................................
8 4.1 Computer Code ....................................................................................................
8 4.2 Adjustment
of Tank Room Exhaust Fan Suction Flow Split from Supply and Recirculation
Ductwork ..................................................................................................
8 4.3 Panel Modeling ....................................................................................................
9 4.4 Generator
and Engine Block Heat Load ..........................................................
:*** 9 4.5 Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room Leakage Path .............................................
14 4.6 Combustion
Air Inlet Piping ..............................................................................
16 4.7 Outdoor Air Temperature
...................................................................................
18 4.8 Diesel Generator
Test Data Temperature
near Transformer Panel
Cell Correction
.....................................................................................................................
19 4.9 Generator
Heat Release and Dispersion
.............................................................
19 4.10 GOTHIC Bug AI 8.2-079a .............................................................................
20 5.0 Results ....................................................................................................................
21 5 .1 Benchmark
Results .............................................................................................
21 5 .2 Results ................................................................................................................
26 5.2.1 Case 7a Results ...........................................................................................
28 5.2.2 Case lOa Results ............
* .............................................................................
34 5.2.3 Case 12a Results .........................................................................................
40 6.0 Conclusions
.....................................................................................
; ......................
45 7.0 Computer Files .......................................................................................................
46 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 4 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTIDC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 4 of47 8. 0 References
..............................................................................................................
46 Total Number of Pages -47 Attachments
Number of Pages Attachment A -8.2 Installation
QA Docmnentation
.........................................................
18 Attachment B -Difference
Reports .................................................................................
15 6 Attachment C -Sensitivities
on Case lOa .........................................................................
30 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 5 of 254 1.0 Objective
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 5 of47 The purpose of this engineering
report is to supplement
the analysis of the Division 1 Diesel Generator
room heat-up due to loss of the DG room emergency
fan documented
in Reference
[8.14]. Uncertainty
is present within that analysis as well as several modeling conservatisms
discussed
below. This engineering
report evaluates
the impact of removing some of those conservatisms
for the purpose of generating
a less-conservative, more best-estimate
prediction
of room temperatures
within the Division 1 Diesel Generator
room in order to determine
room temperature
margin. Cases 7, 10, and 12 documented
in Reference
[8.14] constitute
the limiting room heat-up cases for the Division 1 Diesel Generator
room following
a loss of ventilation.
Several conservatisms
were implemented
in those cases as discussed
below: 1. The panels within the room were not modeled as enclosures.
Instead, temperatures
of the control volume cells that encompassed
the panels were used to characterize
the temperatures
of the panels. Since the panel exists within an enclosure, the temperature
of the affected panel equipment
will be at a temperature
lower than that of the ambient temperature.
2. As discussed
in Section 4.4, the generator
heat load was conservatively
maximized
and the engine heat load conservatively
minimized.
3. Credit for air gaps to the outdoors was not credited.
4. The engine combustion
air inlet piping, which would act as a heat sink, was not modeled. 5. Outdoor air was conservatively
modeled at a constant value. Credit was not taken for the diurnal cycle. Furthermore, the temperature
selected was conservative.
6. When the tank room exhaust fan (1 VD02CA) is operating, it will draw air in from the Division 1 DG room and from the fan room. The Reference
[8.14] analysis under Input 2.3 conservatively
assumed an even flow split between these two areas. 7. The heat load associated
with the generator
will be released and dispersed
throughout
the room mainly by the fans that are built into the generator.
The Reference
[8.14] model did not model generator
heat release and dispersion
in this manner. Heat was deposited
into a single cell such that some of the heat would not be drawn up by the modeled generator
fans. This is conservative, however, since the location where the heat was deposited coincided
with one of the panels of concern. The conservatisms
will be examined and removed in this analysis in order to quantify the available
margin and provide a more realistic
room temperature
heat-up. Specifically:
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 6 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTEilC Uncertainty
Evaluation
-NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 6 of47 1. The panels within the room will be modeled as enclosures (i.e., control volumes with thermal conductors, and flow paths). Additionally, blockages
will be included to ensure that the total free volume associated
with the room is not estimated.
2. The generator
heat load will be corrected
to use a value consistent
with vendor information.
The engine heat load will be subsequently
corrected
by performing
the benchmark
outlined in Section 4.12 of Reference
[8.14]. 3. Credit for air gaps to the outdoors will be modelled.
4. The engine combustion
air inlet piping, which would act as a heat sink, will be modeled. 5. Outdoor air will be modeled using a diurnal cycle and using a more representative
peak daytime temperature.
6. For the flow split associated
with the tank room exhaust fan (I VD02CA), a more realistic
flow split will be utilized.
7. Generator
heat load release and dispersion
will be more accurately
modeled. Additionally:
* From the benchmark
of the GOTHIC model to test data (Section 5. I of Reference
[8.14]), the GOTHIC calculated
temperature
near the transformer
panel was under-predicted
by approximately
7&deg;F. From Reference
[8.16], the cell that should have been selected for comparison
to the test data is cell 39. This will be corrected.
* GOTHIC Bug AI 8.2-079a is addressed.
Concerning
AI 8.2-079a, for spanned external conductors, the total modeled conductor
area of all the subconductors
may differ from the specified
value. A spanned external conductor
is subdivided
based on the relative exposed surface area in the connecting
cells (for a general span) or the relative surface area in contact with the blockage associated
with the spanned surface. If the exposed surfaces are consistent
with conductor
geometry, then the error in the modeled conductor
area is negligible.
These changes will create the following
models: * CPS IA DG Benchmark
a.GTH --* CPS IA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7a.GTH * CPS IA_DG LoV LOOP-LOCA_Case
lOa.GTH * CPS IA DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case I2a.GTH Lastly, Attachment
C performs additional
sensitivities
on Case I Oa. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 7 of 254 2.0 Inputs 2.1 GOTHIC Models Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
The Benchmark, Case 7, Case 10, and Case 12 GOTHIC models are taken from Reference
[8.14]. 2.2 Generator
Heat Load Profile Generation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 7 of47 Reference
[8.17] transmits
file "lA DG Loads_ZNE
CorrectedJMF3.xlsx", which is used in the generation
of generator
heat load profiles.
2.3 Tank Room Exhaust Fan Flow Split from the Division 1 Room Recirculation
and Supply Ductwork Reference
[8.15] determines
the air flow through the Division 1 Room as supplied by the Tank Room Exhaust Fan (1VD02CA)
for the condition
in which the lVDOlCA Supply Fan fails to start when demanded during LOCA and LOOP accident scenarios.
The exhaust fan will pull flow from the supply ductwork and DG Room via the exhaust ductwork in the Division 1 Room associated
with 1VDO1 CA. Between the supply and DG Room, Reference
[8.15] indicates
a flow split whereby 220 cfm of the flow is extracted
from the outside through leakage across closed dampers and 2800 cfm of the flow is extracted
from the Division 1 Room. 2.4 Atmospheric
Conditions
From Reference
[8.17], the outdoor air peak daytime temperature
is 90&deg;F, the daytime temperature
swing is l 7&deg;F, and outdoor temperature
as a function of time resembles
a sinusoidal
profile. The outside air design dry-bulb and mean coincident
wet-bulb (1 %) temperatures
for Decatur, Illinois are 90.6&deg;F and 75.5&deg;F, respectively, per Reference
[8.3]. The dry bulb temperature
is approximately
the same as that provided by Reference
[8.17], therefore
the wet-bulb temperature
of 75.5&deg;F is used in conjunction
with the 90&deg;F outdoor air peak daytime temperature
to develop a value for humidity.
Using the psychrometric
chart from Reference
[8.3], the corresponding
relative humidity is 50%. 2.5 Temperature
Sensor Locations
during Diesel Generator
Testing Reference
[8.13], Attachment
A, shows the location of temperature
sensors used during diesel generator
testing (Reference
[8.7], Attachment
6). 2.6 Exhaust Pipe Leakage A total leakage area of 1 Oft 2 was used in the analysis.
One flow path was identified
in Reference
[8.15], which indicates
that the leakage area around the Division 1 Diesel Generator
exhaust pipe is 1 Oft 2. This area is characteristic
of the penetration
through the DG room ceiling and the penetration
through the roof. Additional
leakage paths exist around doors, etc., but were not credited.
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 8 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
2.7 Electrical
Panel Free Volume and Panel Wall Thickness
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 8 of47 From Reference
[8.16], the walls of the electrical
panels within the Division 1 Diesel Generator
room are 11 gauge carbon steel and the free volume is congested
by 30%. 2.8 Combustion
Air Piping Parameters
Parameters
used in the creation of combustion
air piping thermal conductors
are provided by Reference
[8.9], Section 8.12. From Reference
[8.15], the wall thickness
ofthe piping is 3/8". 3.0 Assumptions
3.1 Reference
[8.2], Input 4.3.1 conservatively
reduces the free volume of the modeled rooms. It is assumed that no further reductions
in free volume are required.
4.0 Methodology
4.1 Computer Code The GOTHIC version 8.2 (QA) computer code (Reference
[8.1]) is used for this analysis.
GOTHIC is developed
and maintained
under NAI's QA Program that conforms to the requirements
of 10CFR50 Appendix Band lOCFR Part 21. Detailed descriptions
of available
GOTHIC user options and models are included in the user and technical
manuals. Information
about GOTHIC qualification
is available
in the qualification
report. All known GOTHIC computer bugs are considered
and dispositioned
by this analysis.
Transients
were run on computer CARTSOl with an Intel Xeon E5-4650 processor
running Windows Server 2012 Rev 2 Standard 64-bit, which is qualified
to run GOTHIC 8.2(QA) under the NAI QA program. The GOTHIC 8.2 installation
QA documentation
is provided in Attachment
A. 4.2 Adjustment
of Tank Room Exhaust Fan Suction Flow Split from Supply and Recirculation
Ductwork When the tank room exhaust fan (1 VD02CA) is running, it will draw in air through both the supply ductwork and the DG Room via recirculation
ductwork in the Division 1 Room when the 1 VDOlCA Supply Fan fails to start. From Input 2.3, 220 cfm of the flow is extracted
from the outside and 2800 cfm of the flow is extracted
from the Division 1 room. To implement
this approach, the flow rate assigned to volumetric
fan 8Q is changed to 2800 cfm. Since the flow rate assigned to the tank room exhaust fan (volumetric
fan 2Q) is fixed at 3020 cfm, the balance of flow will be (220 cfm) will automatically
be pulled from the outside since the associated
network link, 7L, is not constrained.
The way in which flow split is modeled is discussed
in Section 4.7 of Reference
[8.14]. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 9 of 254 4.3 Panel Modeling * Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 9 of47 Panels were modeled using information
from Reference
[8.6]. Reference
[8.6] provides panel dimensions
and panel locations
within the room, including
distance off the ground for mounted panels and panels sitting atop pedestals.
Control volumes for each panel were developed
using this information.
Given the relatively
small space within each enclosure, it is assumed that the conditions
within each panel will be homogeneous
and so the associated
control volumes are not subdivided.
For added conservatism, the free volume is reduced by a value of30% (Input 2.7) to accommodate
congestion
within the panel. Thermal conductors
to represent
each of the six walls of the panels are modeled using 11 gauge carbon steel material (Input 2.7). For thermal conductors
that sit atop a concrete pedestal or are mounted to a concrete wall, a thermal conductor
is not modeled since the concrete would be included in the thermal conductor
type. The concrete would act as a heat sink and its exclusion
is conservative.
To ensure that free volume of the room is not over-estimated, blockages
are modeled for each enclosure
using information
from Reference
[8.6]. One vertical flow path is connected
to the top of each control volume. Each flow path represents
a 2mm leakage path to allow the control volume pressure to equalize with the pressure of the diesel generator
room. As a control volume heats up or cools down, vapor will expand or contract causing changes in temperature
which, in this application, is artificial.
Allowing pressure to equalize prevents artificial
compression
heating. 4.4 Generator
and Engine Block Heat Load The generator
heat load is modeled using a fixed heat rate (i.e., independent
oflocal conditions
and a function of time only), implemented
through the use of heater component
8H. A heat rate profile is supplied to that component
using forcing function 3T. The basis for function 3T in the benchmark
is developed
in Reference
[8.2]. For the analysis cases, the basis was originally
provided by Input 2.1 of Reference
[8.14]. The engine block heat load is modeled using thermal conductors
1 and 2 to represent "warm" and "hot" surfaces, respectively.
Their thermal conductor
type and surface area is based on physical characteristics
of the engine. A bounding temperature
is applied to the inside (i.e., engine-side)
surface of these thermal conductors.
The amount of heat rejected into the room will be a function oflocal temperatures.
The heat transfer coefficient (surface option 6) applied to the outside (i.e., room-side)
is determined
through benchmarking (Section 4.12 of Reference
[8.14]). This value is iterated during benchmarking
to affect the total diesel generator
heat load (i.e., the sum of the generator
heat load and the engine block heat load) such that the room air exhaust temperature
as calculated
by GOTHIC is consistent
with test data (Reference
[8.7], Attachment
6). July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 10 of 254 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTIIlC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page IO of47 It is conservative
to allocate the total diesel generator
heat load such that the generator
heat load is maximized
and the engine block heat load is minimized
since the former is not dependent
on room temperature
and the latter is dependent
on room temperature.
As the diesel generator
room heats up, the engine block will reject less heat into the room. The conservative
value used in the original benchmark
to characterize
the generator
heat load at a fully loaded condition
is 153 Btu/sec per Reference
[8.2]. From Reference
[8.4], the quasi steady generator
electrical
output is 3747 KW. From Reference
[8.8], pdfpage 18 of28, the full load power is 3900 KW and efficiency
as a function of generator
fractional
loading is given for a power factor of 0.80 and 1.00. On pdfpage 19of28, the power factor is 0.80. For efficiency
as a function of generator
fractional
loading, a curve fit is applied to the data points in excel to produce the following
equation:
Where: 1J = -0.0413&#xa3;2 + 0.0878L + 0.9234 T\ = efficiency (decimal)
L = fractional
loading Heat load as a function of time is then calculated
using first principles:
Q=P (l-77) out 17 Where: Q = waste heat Pout= generator
power output= 3747 KW Pm = generator
power input July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Equation 1 Equation 2 Equation 3 Equation4 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 11 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 11 of47 At 3747 KW, the fractional
loading is 0.961, the efficiency
is calculated
as 0.970, and the generator
heat load is calculated
as 111.227 Btu/sec. The steady state heat load value in forcing function 3T of the benchmark
model is 153 Btu/sec, which is a conservative
over-estimation
of the generator
heat load and * conservative
under-estimation
of the engine block heat load. In other words, ifthe total diesel generator
heat load is the sum of both the generator
and engine block heat loads and, at steady state, is a fixed value, over-estimating
the generator
heat load requires the engine block heat load to be under estimated.
However, it should be noted that the heat load value that corresponds
to the end of the test ( 4920 seconds) in that forcing function is only 132.1 Btu/sec but that the heat load is assumed to increase to 153 But/sec at 4 hours per Reference
[8.2], Table 5-2. It is this same heat load value of 153 Btu/sec upon which all accident heat load profiles are based per Reference
[8.4] .. In order to more accurately
model the generator
heat load value, the engine block heat load to the Diesel Generator
room can be increased
by at least 42 Btu/s (i.e. 153-111).
The generator
heat load (by the end of the test) is reduced to its nominal value of 111.227 Btu/sec. In order to conserve the total diesel generator
heat load (total diesel generator
heat load is generator
heat plus engine block heat load), the engine block heat load must be increased, which is accomplished
by increasing
the overall heat transfer coefficient (U) to 5.158 Btu/hr-ft 2-&deg;F for the warm and hot portions of the engine. In doing so, the total diesel generator
heat load approximately
matches the test results by the end of the test (in actuality, it is slightly conservative)
and, prior to that, is greater than the total diesel generator
heat load indicated
by the test, which is conservative.
This is shown in Table 4-1. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 12 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTEilC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 12 of47 Table 4-1 -Adjusted Total Diesel Generator
Benchmark
Heat Load Compared to Test Data Total Generator
Heat Load qtest (1) qgen (4) Tarea (2) Uwarm A (5J T (5J q (6) Uhot A (5J T (5J (6) warm warm warm hot hot ot LST Kw<2 J 11(3) (Btu/hr-:ft2
-(Btu/hr-(Btu/s) (Btu/s) (oF) OF) (fi2) (oF) (Btu/sec)
ft2-oF) (:ft2) (oF) (Btu/sec)
10:45 AM 264 3750 0.97 86.6 77.6 10:50AM 275 3750 0.97 89.0 77.2 10:55AM 278 3700 0.97 91.4 77.l ll:OOAM 280 3750 0.97 94.0 77.2 11:05 AM 280 3800 0.97 96.4 77.9 11:10 AM 278 3700 0.97 98.8 77.8 11:15 AM 285 3750 0.97 101.4 77.6 11:20AM 289 3700 0.97 103.8 77.5 11:25 AM 287 3750 0.97 106.3 77.6 11:30AM 292 3750 0.97 108.8 77.8 11:35 AM 296 3800 0.97 111.2 77.8 1 -Taken directly out of the GOTHIC model from forcing :function
4T 2-Reference
[8.7], Attachment
6 3 -calculated
using Equation 1 5.158 848 172 114.7 5.158 80 5.158 848 172 115.1 5.158 80 5.158 848 172 115.3 5.158 80 5.158 848 172 115.l 5.158 80 5.158 848 172 114.3 5.158 80 5.158 848 172 114.5 5.158 80 5.158 848 172 114.7 5.158 80 5.158 848 172 114.8 5.158 80 5.158 848 172 114.7 5.158 80 5.158 848 172 114.4 5.158 80 5.158 848 172 114.5 5.158 80 4 -forcing function 3T from CPS_lA_DG_Benchmark.GTH
multiplied
by 0.72697 to reduce 153 Btu/sec at end of function to 111.227 Btu/sec 700 700 700 700 700 700 700 700 700 700 700 5 -Taken directly out of the GOTHIC model. Awarm and Twarm are associated
with thermal conductor
1, Ahat and Thot are associated
with thermal conductor
2 6 -q = UA X (Tsurface -Tarea) 7 -qtotal =
+ qwarm + July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 71.3 71.4 71.4 71.4 71.3 71.3 71.3 71.4 71.3 71.3 71.3 qtotal(7) (Btu/sec)
272.6 275.5 278.1 280.5 282.0 284.7 287.4 290.0 292.4 294.5 297.0 
 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 13 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTIITC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 13 of47 The revised engine block heat load is compared to the engine block heat load calculated
using vendor supplied information
for engine heat load to the room under design conditions.
From Reference
[8.7], Attachment
3, page 3, the heat radiation
from the engine and accessories
is estimated
at 2 Btu/min per KW. From Reference
[8.12], the nameplate
design ambient temperature
of the diesel generator
is 122&deg;F. The revised engine block heat load is re-calculated
using 122&deg;F as the ambient temperature
and compared to the heat load as calculated
using the vendor provided estimate of 2 Btu/min per KW as follows: Table 4-2-Benchmark
Generator
Heat Load at 122&deg;F Compared to Vendor Heat Load at Design Ambient Temperature
of 122&deg;F Tarea Dwann Awann Twarm qwann Uhat A hat That qhot qtotal qvendor LST KW (oF) (Btu/hr-(ft2) (oF) (Btu/sec) (Btu/hr-(ft2) (oF) (Btu/sec) (Btu/sec) (Btu/sec)
ft2-"F) ft2-oF) 10:45 AM 3750 122 5.158 848 172 60.7 5.158 80 700 66.3 127.0 125.0 10:50 AM 3750 122 5.158 848 172 60.7 5.158 80 700 66.3 127.0 125.0 10:55 AM 3700 122 5.158 848 172 60.7 5.158 80 700 66.3 127.0 123.3 11:00 AM 3750 122 5.158 848 172 60.7 5.158 80 700 66.3 127.0 125.0 11:05 AM 3800 122 5.158 848 172 60.7 5.158 80 700 66.3 127.0 126.7 ll:lOAM 3700 122 5.158 848 172 60.7 5.158 80 700 66.3 127.0 123.3 11:15AM 3750 122 5.158 848 172 60.7 5.158 80 700 66.3 127.0 125.0 11:20 AM 3700 . 122 5.158 848 172 60.7 5.158 80 700 66.3 127.0 123.3 11:25 AM 3750 122 5.158 848 172 60.7 5.158 80 700 66.3 127.0 125.0 11:30 AM 3750 122 5.158 848 172 60.7 5.158 80 700 66.3 127.0 125.0 11:35 AM 3800 122 5.158 848 172 60.7 5.158 80 700 66.3 127.0 126.7 The resulting
engine block heat load at the design temperature
of 122&deg;F is conservative
relative to the vendor data. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 14 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 14 of47 It should be noted that sufficient
SX/DG heat exchanger
margin exists in order to accommodate
the engine block heat load should a portion of the 127 Btu/sec no longer be released to the room. At 3800 KW, the required heat removal from the engine by the SX/DG heat exchanger
based on vendor information (Reference
[8.7], Attachment
3, page 3) is 50 Btu/min per KW, or 11.4 x 10 6 Btu/hr (3800KW x 50 Btu/minx 60 min/hr). The available
heat removal for the 16 cylinder and 12 cylinder engines, according
to their heat exchanger
specification
sheets (Reference
[8.7], Attachment
2) is 13.37 x 10 6 Btu/hr (7.67 x 10 6 Btu/hr + 5.70 x 10 6 Btu/hr). The resulting
margin is 1.97 x 10 6 Btu/hr (approximately
550 Btu/s) or approximately
15%. The degree of conservatism
associated
with generator
heat load value of 153 Btu/sec will also be demonstrated
using the existing GOTHIC models. It is noted that the use of 153 Btu/sec is used in the excel workbook provided by Reference
[8.17] since it is the generator
heat load upon which all accident heat load were developed
as mentioned
previously.
The conservatism
in the original Case 7, 10, and 12 analyses can be determined
by correcting
the generator
steady state heat load to 111.227 Btu/sec and increasing
the engine block overall heat transfer coefficient (U) to correct its heat load and affect the calculated
exhaust temperatures
to match test data exhaust temperatures.
For the generator
heat load, the heat load is reduced from 153 to the realistic
value of 111.227 Btu/sec in the benchmark
model by multiplying
the dependent
values of forcing function 3T by 0.72697 (111.227 divided by 153). In Cases 7, 10, and 12, the heat load is reproduced
by using the excel workbook provided by Input 2.2. The excel workbook is modified to use a steady state heat load value of 111.227 instead of 15 3 and the resulting
LOOP-LOCA
and LOOP-TRANS
heat load profiles are used to update forcing function 3T in Cases 7, 10, and 12. This is carried out as follows in the "lA DG Loads_ZNE
CorrectedJMF3 .xlsx" workbook:
* On worksheet "LOOP-TRANS
corrected", cells B2 through B23 are modified in that the value of 153 at the end of the cell formula is changed to 111.227. * The LOOP-TRANS
heat load profile is provided on the worksheet TRANS Table3" for use in forcing function 3T. * On worksheet "LOOP-LBLOCA
corrected", cells B2 through B23 are modified in that the value of 153 at the end of the cell formula is changed to 111.227. * The LOOP-LOCA
heat load profile is provided on the worksheet "LOOP-LBLOCA Table3" for use in forcing function 3T. A re-benchmark
is then performed
following
the method of Reference
[8.14], Section 4.12. The resulting
overall heat transfer coefficient (U) represents
the corrected
engine block heat load, which is used to update surface option 6 in Cases 7, 10, and 12. 4.5 Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room Leakage Path A vertical flow path representing
leakage around the diesel exhaust pipe is added to the model that connects control volume 1 (the Division 1 Diesel Generator
room) to control July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 15 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 15 of47 volume 11 (Outside Air). The exhaust pipe penetrates
the ceiling of the Division 1 Room as well as an additional
ceiling slab per Reference
[8.10] before being exposed to outdoor air. Reference
[8.10] shows an additional
enclosure
at elevation
788' but identifies
it as "air exhaust".
It is therefore
assumed that at elevation
788', the exhaust pipe is exposed to the atmosphere.
Parameter
Value Basis a. Volume A 1 Division 1 Generator
Room b. End A Elevation (ft) 760.98 Top of control volume 1 (ceiling penetration)-
0.02 ft. 0.02 ft prevents flow path from being flush with top of control volume which is consistent
with modeling guidelines
in the GOTHIC user manual, page 26-31 c. End A Height (ft) 0.01 Flow path is a ceiling penetration, small height utilized.
d. VolumeB lls3 * Outside Air e. End B Elevation (ft) 788.01 Roof elevation, Reference
[8.10] + 0.01 ft. 0.01 ft prevents flow path from being flush with top of control volume which is consistent
with modeling guidelines
in the GOTHIC user manual, page 26-31 f. End B Height (ft) 0.01 Flow path is a roof penetration, small height utilized.
g. Flow Area (ff) 10 Input 2.6 h. Hydraulic
Diameter (ft) 5 Arbitrary (see explanation
below) i. Inertia Length (ft) 41 Cell center to cell center method (see Section 4.4 of Reference
[8.14]) 41 ft= (788 -760.98) + 4/2 + 24/2 4 ft = height of cell in volume 1 24 ft = height of cell in volume 11 J. Friction Length (ft) 0 Bounded by loss coefficient (see Section 4.4 of Reference
[8.14]) k. Forward Loss 5.56 The flow path is two penetrations.
A loss Coefficient
coefficient
of 2. 78 characterizes
an orifice for which the open area is mall relative to the wall area (GOTHIC user manual, page 26-27). 5.56 = 2.78 + 2.78 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 16 of 254 Parameter
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
Value Basis NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 16 of47 1. Reverse Loss 5.56 Same as forward loss coefficient
Coefficient
From the Reference
[8.1] user manual, page 12-10, the flow path hydraulic
diameter is used to calculate
the wall friction head given by Equation 12.2 from the user manual: Where: fl pl M=---Dh 2 f = friction factor calculated
by the GOTHIC solver 1 = friction length of the flow path Dh = hydraulic
diameter p = fluid density in the flow path v = fluid velocity in the flow path Equation 5 The leakage flow path uses a friction length set to zero. All friction is modeled through the use of a loss coefficient
equal 5.56, which bounds both wall friction head and form loss. Since the friction length is zero, the wall friction head will be zero for any hydraulic
diameter.
Therefore, the hydraulic
diameter is set to an arbitrary
value of 5 ft. 4.6 Combustion
Air Inlet Piping The combustion
air inlet piping is modeled using information
from Reference
[8.9], Section 8.12 (Input 2.8). Information
is provided in that section on four thermal conductors
that model combustion
air inlet piping, which is adapted for use in this engineering
report. The information
used is as follows: * The four thermal conductors
added to the GOTHIC models in this engineering.
report are spanned across consistent
x, y, and z-grid planes with respect to Reference
[8.9], Section 8.12. * The surface area assigned to each thermal conductor
and conductor
type is identical
to those in Reference
[8.9], Section 8.12. * The parameters
used to generate thermal conductor
types for 36" and 24" piping are identical
to the parameters
used to generate thermal conductor
types for 3 6" piping and 24" piping in Reference
[8.9], Section 8.12. It should be noted that Reference
[8.16] indicates
that the use of Reference
[8.9] is acceptable.
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 17 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 17 of47 Equation T8.5b on page 4.18 of Reference
[8.3], which provides a Nusselt number correlation
for forced flow of a cooling fluid through a pipe, is used to calculate
a heat transfer coefficient:
Nu= 0.023Re 415 Pr 03 Equation 6 Properties
for air at 100&deg;F are used to calculate
a heat transfer coefficient
for each of the two different
sized combustion
air pipes. Had a lower temperature
been selected, the result would have been higher heat transfer coefficients
and increased
heat sink effect of the combustion
air inlet piping. 100&deg;F is bounding with respect to the inside surface temperature
of the piping as calculated
by GOTHIC. Parameter
24" Pipe 36" Pipe Basis a. Diameter (ft) 2 3 Input 2.8 b. Flow rate ( cfi:n) 16,140 Reference
[8.11] c. Velocity (ft/sec) 87.4 38.6 Calculated
d. Density (lbm/ftj)
0.0709 Reference
[8.3], page 30.63 e. Specific Heat 0.2407 Reference
[8.3], page 30.63 *-(Btu/Ihm-&deg;F) f. Thermal conductivity
4.347E-6 Reference
[8.3], page 30.63 (Btu/sec-ft-&deg;F)
0.01565 Btu/hr-ft-&deg;F
x 3600 sec I hr g. Viscosity (lbm/ft-sec)
l.283E-5 Reference
[8.3], page 30.63 0.0462 lbm/ft-hr
x 3600 sec I hr h. Prandtl Number 0.7106 Specific heat x viscosity
I conductivity
1. Reynolds Number 9.56E5 6.35E5 Calculated
h. Nusselt Number 1264 911 Equation 6 1. Heat Transfer Calculated
Coefficient (Btu/hr-ft
2 -9.887 4.752 OF) As the piping absorbs heat, the airstream
temperature
will increase.
In order to bound uncertainty, the temperature
of the air stream just as it enters the engine is applied to the inside surface of piping thermal cqnductors.
This is calculated
using a control variable as follows: Where: Equation 7 q = heat transfer through the piping thermal conductors (capture by the control variable)
ri1 = combustion
air mass flowrate (Ihm/sec) (input into the control variable)
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 18 of 254 m NUMERICAL
N\J. APPLICATIONS
fl: L"ft SK.It, Cf ?.Ii.CHI!\
IJC. Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTIDC Uncertainty
Evaluation
Cp =specific
heat= 0.2407 Btu/lbm-&deg;F (input into the control variable)
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 18 of47 T cold = outdoor air temperature (passed to the control variable through the use of a separate control variable)
It should be noted that for the benchmark
case, T cold is set to 45&deg;F based on MET tower data provided by Reference
[8.7], Attachment
6. Since the first 5 seconds of the simulation
is used to initialize
thermal conductor
temperature
thermal conductor
heat transfer will be large enough to result in values of T hot that will cause the model to crash. Therefore, an intermediary
control variable is used such that ifthe elapsed time is less than 0, q is set equal to zero (in other words, no correction
is applied), otherwise
it is calculated
by GOTHIC. Both the calculated
heat transfer coefficient
and temperature
are applied to the inside surface of the piping thermal conductors
as a specified
ambient and HTC surface option. Since the smaller diameter piping will split off the total intake flow, the smaller of the two calculated
heat transfer coefficients (which corresponds
to the larger diameter piping) is applied to all of the piping thermal conductors.
For the outside of the piping thermal conductors, a new surface option is created. The surface option uses the direct heat transfer option, the default diffusion
layer model (with film roughening)
for condensation (condensation
will not occur so this selection
is inconsequential), the horizontal
cylinder model for natural convection, and a user defined correlation
for the forced convection
option. Equation T8.14 on page 4.18 of Reference
[8.3] provides the following
Nusselt number correlation
for external flow for cross flow over a cylinder:
[ ]4/5 0.62 Re 112 Pr 113 Re 518 Nu=0.3+ 1+ [1 + ( 0.4 I Pr)"' J" ( 282,000) Equation 8 The correlation
is applied through a surface option that implements
the user defined option for forced convection.
The Nusselt number is calculated
through the use of control variables, which is applied to the surface option (GOTHIC will automatically
back-calculate
a heat transfer coefficient
from the Nusselt number). The control variables
are configured
to pull local parameters (density, viscosity, cell-centered
hydraulic
diameter, cell-centered
velocity, etc.) directly from the cells associated
with the combustion
air inlet piping thermal conductor
in order to calculate
a local heat transfer coefficient
for each cell. 4.7 Outdoor Air Temperature
The outdoor air temperature
is varied over a 24 hour period using the following
equation:
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 19 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 19 of47 T = T max -T.wing x (o.5 sin( 2 m ) + 0.5J 24x3600 Equation 9 Where: T = temperature
as a function of time T max =peak daytime temperature
T swing = daytime temperature
swing The peak daytime temperature
is set to 90&deg;F and the temperature
swing is set to l 7&deg;F (Input 2.4). Equation 9 is used to develop a temperature
profile from 0 to 86,400 seconds in 60 second intervals, which is input into the model as forcing function 11 T and referenced
by boundary conditions
lP and 2F. The intent is to start and end the simulation
with an outdoor air temperature
of 90&deg;F. From Input 2.4, the relative humidity is 50%. Since temperature
will vary as a function of time, the relative humidity should be input as a steam volume fraction, otherwise
GOTHIC will calculate
the steam volume fraction using the time varying temperature
and assuming a constant relative humidity of 50%. From Reference
[8.2], atmospheric
pressure is 14.3 psia. From Reference
[8.3], page 30.41, the saturation
pressure of water at 90&deg;F is 0.699 psia. From Reference
[8.3], page 1.12, equation 24, relative humidity is steam partial pressure divided by steam saturation
pressure;
the steam partial pressure is therefore
0.350 psia (0.5 times 0.699 psia). The steam volume fraction is 0.024 (0.350 I 14.3), which is input into boundary conditions
lP and2F. 4.8 Diesel Generator
Test Data Temperature
near Transformer
Panel Cell Correction
From the benchmark
of the GOTHIC model to test data (Section 5.1 of Reference
[8.14]), the GOTHIC calculated
temperature
near the transformer
panel is under-predicted
by approximately
7&deg;F. This is due to the temperature
being extracted
from the incorrect
cell for use in comparison
to the test data. From Reference
[8.16], the cell that should
be selected for comparison
to the test data is cell 39, which the model is modified to reflect. 4.9 Generator
Heat Release and Dispersion
The heat load associated
with the generator
will be released and dispersed
throughout
the room mainly by the fans that are built into the generator.
Modifications
are made to the model to more accurately
produce this effect. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 20 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 20 of47 Flow paths 30 through 33 each contain a volumetric
fan and simulate the generator
fans. Flow paths 30 and 31 represent
the bottom portion of the generator
while flow paths 32 and 33 represent
the top portion of the generator.
The volumetric
fans draw suction from* end A of these flow paths. Heater component
SH is used to simulate the generator
heat load and exists in cell 39. Flow paths 30 through 33, end A, are moved to this cell and their orientation
is kept the same. The elevation
of end A of these flow paths is changed to 742 ft and the height changed to 2.5 ft, which covers the entire height of cell 39. From the GOTHIC user manual, page 16-56, for a flow path with a volumetric
fan, the flow through the-flow path is completely
controlled
by the fan specifications and the normal force balance for the flow path is bypassed.
Therefore, these specifications
for elevation
and height are acceptable.
By configuring
the flow paths in this way, heat released by heat component
SH will be drawn directly into the modeled generator
fans and dispersed
throughout
the room, which is more realistic.
4.10 GOTHIC Bug AI 8.2-079a GOTHIC Bug AI S.2-079a is checked by opening one of the solver output files (.SOT) associated
with any one of the model runs (i.e., CPS_lA_DG_Benchinark_a.SOT).
Subconductors
are listed in the "Conductor
Input" section. The "Cond" column corresponds
to a global index of all the subconductors.
The "Base" column corresponds
to thermal conductor
number as seen in the Thermal Conductors
table in the GOTHIC * user interface.
When a thermal conductor
appears more than once in the "Base" column, it means that the thermal conductor
is spanned and has been broken up into subconductors.
A thermal conductor
is affected by GOTHIC Bug AI S.2-079a ifthe sum of the surface areas of its subconductors
is significantly
different
than the surface area specified
in the Thermal Conductors
table. In other words, when a thermal conductor
is "spanned", it is broken up into subconductors.
The sum of the surface areas of those subconductors
should be equal to the surface area of the thermal conductor
as a whole. The surface area can be determined
by summing the surface area values under the Side 1 "Surf A" and Side 2 "Surf A" columns. Side 1 refers to the A side of the thermal conductor
while Side 2 refers to the B side of the thermal conductor.
Conductor
9 is affected by this bug. Its subconductors
add up to a value of 3237 ft 2 but should add up to a value of2376 ft 2. Furthermore, the conductor
represents
the wall between the Division 1 and Division 3 rooms but is spanned to the wrong cells. First, spanning is corrected
by assigning
Side A of conductor
9 to the east wall of control volume 3 (the Division 3 room) and assigning
Side B of conductor
9 to the west wall of control volume 1 (the Division 1 room). To correct the area, the surface area assigned to the conductor
is changed to 2350 ft 2 , the basis of which is through trial and error. With a value of 2350 ft 2 assigned to conductor
9, the subconductor
areas add up to 2376 ft 2. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
-------------------------------
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 21 of 254 5.0 Results 5.1 Benchmark
Results Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTIIlC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 21 of47 Surface option 6, which is the heat transfer coefficient
associated
with the engine surface thermal conductors, was changed to 6.15 Btu/hr-ft 2-&deg;F in order to affect the GOTHIC calculated
heat load to match the target load. It is noted that this value is consistent
with typical heat transfer coefficient
values for forced convection
in gases per Reference
[8.5], Table I.I (from 25 to 250 W/m2-&deg;F or 4.4to 44 Btulhr-tt2-&deg;F).
This value is used to calculate
the engine block heat load using 122&deg;F as the ambient temperature
for comparison
to the vendor provided estimate of 2 Btu/min per KW similar to what was done in Table 4-2 -this is shown in Table 5-2, which shows that the resulting
engine block heat load is conservative.
Results of the benchmark
are shown below in Figure 1, Figure 2, and Table 5-1. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 22 of 254 Jul/24/2017
20: 13:08 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTIDC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS
_ 1 A_DG _Benchmark_a. GTH NAI-200 7-004 Revision 0 Page 22 of47 Figure 1 -Comparison
of Total Heat Rate Transferred
into the Division 1 DG Room (red line -heat rate calculated
from the DG Surveillance
test; white line -heat rate used in the GOTHIC model) July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 23 of 254 Jul/24/2017
20: 13:19 GOTHIC Version B.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1
A_DG _Benchmark_
a. GTH NAI-2 007-004 Revision 0 Page 23 of 47 Figure 2 -Comparison
of Supply and Exhaust Air Temperatu r e (green line -supply air temperature
measured during the DG surveillance
test; yellow line -supply air temperature
input into the GOTHIC simulation;
red line -exhaust air temperature
measured during the DG surveillance;
white line -exhaus t air temperature
calculated
in GOTHIC) July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 24 of 254 ("-f..I J NUMER I CA L 1'1, APPUCAT IO NS 'L'f' !.iC lf'i a M.Ut t.1 1 !f<.t.f.!J rt:. UC Clinton Di v i s ion 1 Di esel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Eva lu ation NAl-2007-004
Revision 0 P age 24 of47 Table 5-1-Division 1 R o om Temperature
Comparison
at Four Locati o ns Measure GOTHIC Temperature
Corresponding
Calc ulat e d Location D escription
Temperature
Temperature
Difference
Time (o F) (o F) (o F) (sec) 1 Near the Rollup Door 83.1 87.7 4.6 4800 2 Near Transformer
Pane l 87.5 89.1 1.6 4860 3 Near Air Compressor
Pan e l 79 86.4 7.4 4920 4 DG General Area 77.7 8 1.2 3.5 5040 5 Exha u s t Air Temperature
84.7 84.7 0 4920 Notes: I. The measured tem peratures at
these lo cations are at the e nd of the DG surveillance
test. The temperatures
calc ulat ed b y GOTHIC model are at the respecti v e time. July 25 , 2 0 17 9:4 0 AM EDT 
NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
EC 620632, Attachment
2 , Page 25 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 25 of 47 Table 5-2 -Benchmark
Generator
Heat Load at 122&deg;F Compared to Vendor Heat Load at Design Ambient Temperature
of 122&deg;F for 6.15 Btu/hr-ft2-&deg;F
Heat Transfer Coefficient
T area Uwarm Awarm T warm qw arm Uhot A hot Th at q hot qt otal Qve ndor LST KW (oF) (Btu/hr-(ft2) (oF) (Btu/sec) (Btu/hr-(ft2) (oF) (Btu/sec) (Btu/sec) (Btu/sec) ft2-oF) ft2-oF) 10:45 AM 3750 122 6.150 848 172 72.4 6.150 80 700 79.0 151.4 125.0
10:50 AM 3750 122 6.150 848 172 72.4 6.150 80 700 79.0 151.4 125.0
10:55 AM 3700 122 6.150 848 172 72.4 6.150 80 700 79.0 151.4 123.3 ll:OOAM 3750 122 6.150 848 172 72.4 6.150 80 700 79.0 151.4 125.0 11: 05 AM 3800 122 6.150 848 172 72.4 6.150 80 700 79.0 151.4 126.7
ll:lOAM 3700 122 6.150 848 172 72.4 6.150 80 700 79.0 151.4 123.3 11: 15 AM 3750 122 6.150 848 172 72.4 6.150 80 700 79.0 151.4 125.0
11:20 AM 3700 122 6.150 848 172 72.4 6.150 80 700 79.0 151.4 123.3 11: 25 AM 3750 122 6.150 848 172 72.4 6.150 80 700 79.0 151.4 125.0 11:3 0AM 3750 122 6.150 848 172 72.4 6.150 80 700 79.0 151.4 125.0 11:35 AM 3800 122 6.150 848 172 72.4 6.150 80 700 79.0 151.4 126.7 July 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 26 of 254 NUMERICA L APPLICAT IO NS 5.2 Results Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 26 of47 The resulting
temperature
impact is rounded to the nearest &deg;F. For Cases 7a through 12a, key numeric analysis output data is shown in Table 5-3 and Table 5-4. For Table 5-3, the maxim u m temperature
reported for each panel is the maximum cell temperature.
For Table 5-4, the temperature
reported for each panel is the temperature
inside each control volume used to model each panel. Table 5-3 -Summary o f bou nd ing electrical
panel temperature
results with va r i o us generator
loa d profiles and various combinations
of door positions (max cell temperature)
Case Number Panel 7a lOa 12a Maximum Temperature
(&deg;F) 1PL12JA 158 188 167 1PL92JA/1PL93JA
139 182 157 lDGOlJA 160 193 172 1DG06SA 150 181 163 lDGOlKA 12cyl 156 186 165 lDGOlKA 16cyl 160 193 172 Near Doors at 2 Hours 148 N IA N I A Table 5-4 -Summary of electrical
pane l internal tem p erature res u lts with various generat o r lo ad pr o files and vari o us combinat io ns of door positions
Case Number Panel 7a lOa 12a Maximum Temperature
(&deg;F) 1PL12JA 148 181 160 1PL92JA 134 179 157 1PL93JA 134 179 157 lDGOlJA 152 184 166 1DG06SA 142 176 160 lDGOlKA 12cyl 148 181 161 lDGO 1 KA l 6cyl 151 183 166 Limiting plots of ce ll temperatures
for Cases 7a through 12a are provided in Figure 3 through Figure 20. Most of the panels occupy more than one cell in the Division 1 Room control volume. As such, the temperatures
of the most limiting cells containing
a given panel are shown in the plots. Additionally, the temperature
inside the control volumes used to model the panels is included within the figures. J uly 25, 20 17 9:4 0 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 27 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTIDC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAl-2007-004 Revision 0 Page 27 of47 For the temperature
plots, the GOTHIC plot variable is displayed
across the top of the plot. For instance, "TVlsl4" is the vapor temperature
of cell 14 inside control volume 1. For lumped parameter
volumes, "s#" will be absent. Compared to the results of Reference
[8.14], the maximum temperature
of the hottest panel for each case based on cell temperatures
compares as follows: * Case 7 a is 31 &deg;F lower than Case 7 * Case lOa is 28&deg;F lower than Case 10 * Case 12a is 43&deg;F lower than Case 12 Compared to the results of Reference
[8.14], the maximum temperature
of the hottest panel for each case based on internal panel temperatures
compares as follows: * Case 7a is 39&deg;F lower than Case 7 * Case 1 Oa is 3 7&deg;F lower than Case 10 * Case 12a is 49&deg;F lower than Case 12 It should be noted that the original Case 7 , 10, and 12 models did not model a separate control volume for the panels. The comparison
provided is between the control volumes developed
in this calculation
and the hottest cell temperature
reported in Reference
[8.14] based on cell temperatures.
Of particular
significance
is the fact that all the original Case 7, 10 , and 12 simulations
predict closure of the fire dampers associated
with the modeled ductwork early in the simulation. Cases 7a and 12a do not predict closure of the fire dampers and Case lOa predicts closure of the fire dampers in the last 4 hours of the simulation (Case 10 shows closure in the first 4 to 8 hours). This allows circulation
through the ductwork to provide benefit to the Division 1 diesel generator
room for a much longer period of time as compared to the original cases and is one of the main reasons why temperatures
are significantly
lower than those predicted
in Reference
[8.14]. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 28 of 254 5.2.1 Case 7a Results JuV24/2017
20: 36:00 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 C lin ton D iv i s ion l D iesel G e n erator Roo m GOTHI C Unce rt a in ty Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\C PS_ 1 A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ Case _7a. GTH Figure 3, CPS DG Room Case 7a, Panel 1PL12JA Temperatur
e s July 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT N Al-2 00 7-004 R ev i si on 0 P age 28 of47 
EC 62 0 632 , Attachment
2 , Page 29 of 254 JuV24/2017
20: 36: 00 GOTHIC Version 8.2{QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Di ese l Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A
_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a
.GTH NAI-2007-004
R evisio n 0 Page 29 of47 Figure 4, CPS DG Room Case 7a, Panel 1PL92JA and 1PL93JA Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 30 of 254 JuV24/2017
20: 36:01 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 C l i n ton D ivision l D iesel Generator
Room GO THIC Uncertainty
Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007
-004_RO\C PS_ 1 A_ DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ Case_ 7a.GTH Fi g ure 5, CPS DG Room Case 7a, Panel lDGOlJA T emperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 P age 30 of47 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 31 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
JuV24/2017
20: 36: 01 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
_RO\CPS_ 1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH Figure 6, CPS DG Room Case 7a, Panel 1DG06SA Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Re v ision 0 P age 31 of47 
EC 620632, A ttachment
2 , Page 32 of 254
NUMERICAL
I APPLICATIONS
* L:h S IOt , a* 9.t l'!I?\ hol.U!'-'l
BC JuV24/2017
20: 36: 01 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 C lin ton Di v i s ion l D iese l Generator
Room GOT HI C Uncertai n ty Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
_RO\CPS _ 1 A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ Case_ 7a.GTH Figure 7 , CPS DG Room Case 7a , Panel lDGOlKA 12-cyl. Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-0
04 Revisi on 0 P age 32 of47 
 
------EC 620632, Attachment
2 , Page 33 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
JuV24/2017
20: 36: 02 GOTHIC Version 8.2{QA) -Oct 2016 C lin ton Division l Diesel Generator
Room GOTIDC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\CPS_1 A_DG_LoV_L OOP-LOCA_C ase_7a.GTH Figure 8, CPS DG Room Case 7a , Panel lDGOlKA 16-cyl. Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Re visi on 0 Page 33 of 47 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 34 of 254 5.2.2 Case lOa Results JuV24/2017
20: 36: 03 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Di esel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertai nt y Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ Case_ 1 Oa.GTH Figure 9, CPS DG Room Case lOa, Panel 1PL12JA Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 34 of47 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 35 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
JuV24/2017
20: 36: 03 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division l Di esel Generator
Room GOTIIlC Uncertainty
Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\CPS
_ 1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Oa.GT H NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 35 of 47 Figure 10, CPS DG Room Case toa , Panel 1PL92JA and 1PL93JA Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 36 of 254 JuV24/2017
20: 36: 04 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 D iesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
_RO\CPS_ 1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Oa.GTH Figure 11, CPS DG Room Case lOa, Panel lDGOlJA Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 36 of47 
EC 62 0 632 , Attachment
2, Page 37 of 254 ( f.. I J NU MERICAL 1 '1""41 APPLICATIONS
* t:f f !.D i Cf !.l'l tl l!'I M.Ut._, l :. UC JuV24/2017
20: 36:05 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Oa.GTH Figure 12, CPS DG Room Case lOa, Panel 1DG06SA T emperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 37 of 47 
EC 620632, Attachment
2 , Page 38 of 254 JuV24/2017
20: 36:05 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Di ese l Generator
Room GOTIITC Unce rtainty Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_R O\CPS_ 1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Oa.GTH NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 38 of47 Figure 13, CPS DG Room Case lOa, Panel lDGOlKA 12-cyl. Temperatures
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2 , Page 39 of 254 JuV24/2017
20: 36: 05 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division l Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
_RO\CPS_ 1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Oa.GTH Figure 14, CPS DG Room Case lOa, Panel lDGOlKA 16-cyl. Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Pag e 39 of47 
EC 6206 3 2 , Attachment
2 , Page 40 of 254 5.2.3 Case 12a Results JuV24/2017 20: 36: 16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\C
l inton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS
_ 1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Figure 15, CPS DG Room Case 12a, Panel 1PL12JA Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 40 of47 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 41 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
JuV24/2017
20: 36: 16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Di vis ion I Di esel G e ne rator Room GOTIDC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\Clin
ton\NA l-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-TRANS_Case_12a
.GTH NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Pa ge41 of47 Figure 16, CPS DG Room Case 12a, Panel 1PL92JA and 1PL93JA Temperatures
July 25, 2017 9: 40 AM EDT 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 42 of 254
NUMERICAL
1 '1il APPLICATIONS
*Ch S O. ct !)J:tl l?'l UC Jul/24/2017
20: 36:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2{QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Di v ision l Di ese l Generator
Roo m GOTIITC Uncertainty
Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
_R O\CPS_ 1A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Figure 17, CPS DG Room Case 12a, Panel lDGOlJA Temperatures
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
R evis ion 0 Pag e 42 of47 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 43 of 254 JuV24/2017
20: 36: 17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 C lint on Division l D iesel G e n erator R oom G O THIC Uncertai n ty Eva l uation File: C:\Work\Penley\Cl
i nton\NAl-2007
-004_RO\CPS_ 1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-TRANS
_ Case_ 12a.GTH F igure 18 , CPS DG Room Case 12a , Pan e l 1DG06SA T emperatures
July 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT NAI-2007-00 4 Re v ision 0 P age 43 of47 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 44 of 254
NUMERICAL
1 '119t APPLICATIONS
* t: f 1 a !,11.C t11!'1
nc JuV24/2017
20: 36: 17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 C lin ton D iv i sion 1 Diese l Ge n erator R oom GO TIITC Uncertai n ty Eval u ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\CPS_ 1A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS
_ Case_ 12a.GTH Figur e 19, CPS DG Room Case 12a , Panel lDGOlKA 12-c y l. Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004 R evisio n 0 P age 44 of47 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 45 of 254 JuV24/2017
20: 36: 17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Figure 20, CPS DG Room Case 12a, Panel lDGOlKA 16-cyl. Temperatures
6.0 Conclusions
NAI-2 007-004 Re visi on 0 Page 45 of47 This engineering
report supplemented
the analysis of the Division 1 Diesel Generator
room heat-up due to loss of the DG room emergency
fan documented
in Reference
[8.14] by evaluating
the impact ofremoving
the conservatisms
discussed
in Section 1.0 for the purpose of generating
a less conservative, more best-estimate
prediction
of room temperatures
within the Division 1 Diesel Generator
room in order to determine
room temperature
margin. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 46 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTIIlC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page 46 of47 As was discussed
in Section 5 .2, removal of those conservatisms
resulted in a decrease in panel temperature
predictions, the smallest improvement
being a 28&deg;F decrease for Case lOa. Results of this evaluation
can serve as input to a DG room survivability
evaluation.
Together, the GOTHIC analysis and component
survivability
evaluation
can become input to a Probabilistic
Risk Analysis (PRA) that supports a significance
determination
process associated
with the loss of the Division 1 DG room emergency
fan. As such, there are no further recommendations
or suggestions
for follow-up
actions based on the conclusions
of this engineering
report. Each case was examined carefully
and no anomalies
of execution
outside of Reference
[8.2] and [8.15] limitations
occurred.
7 .0 Computer Files Table 7-1-GOTHIC Case Files File Name --Description
--CPS lA DG Benchmark
a.GTH Benchmark "a" GOTHIC File CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7a.GTH Case 7a GOTHIC File CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case lOa.GTH Case 1 Oa GOTHIC File CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case lOb.GTH Case 1 Ob GOTHIC File -----CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case lOc.GTH Case lOc GOTHIC File CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case lOd.GTH Case 1 Od GOTHIC File CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12a.GTH Case 12a GOTHIC File 8.0 References
8.1 GOTHIC Thermal Hydraulics
Analysis Package, Version 8.2 (QA) October 2016. 8.2 MPR Calculation
0065-0061-CALC-001, Rev. 0, 5/22/17, "CPS Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room Heat-up Evaluation
due to Loss of Ventilation." 8.3 ASHRAE Fundamentals
2013 8.4 CPS-17-033
Rev. 0, CPS Transmittal
of Design Information.
8.5 Incropera
et. al, "Fundamentals
of Heat and Mass Transfer", 6th Ed. 8.6 CPS-17-026
Rev. 0, CPS Transmittal
of Design Information.
8.7 CPS-17-016
Rev. 0, CPS Transmittal
of Design Information.
8.8 Clinton Vendor Technical
Manual K2861A-0001, Rev. 0 8.9 Engineering Evaluation
RWA-1716-001, Revision 0, "Red Wolf Associates
Incorporation
of Improvements
and Enhancements
to the Clinton Power Station July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 47 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation (CPS) Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room Heat-up Evaluation
due to Loss of Ventilation
(0065-0061-CALC-OO
1 )" NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page47 of47 8.10 Drawing MOl-1110, Revision H, "General Arrangement
Sections "A-A" & B"" 8.11 CPS-17-029
Rev. 1, CPS Transmittal
of Design Information.
8.12 Clinton Vendor Technical
Manual K2861-0002-B, Rev. 087 8.13 NRC 7/6 Meeting Questions
and Exelon Responses
8.14 Calculation
NAI-2007-003, Revision 2, "Clinton Division l Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Heat-Up Evaluation" 8.15 CPS-17-0041
Rev. 0, CPS Transmittal
of Design Information.
8.16 CPS-17-0042
Rev. 0, CPS Transmittal
of Design Information.
8.17 CPS-17-0043
Rev. 0, CPS Transmittal
of Design Information.
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 48 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
Attachment
A. 8.2 Installation
QA Documentation
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Al of A18 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 49 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NA1-QA-1-18
R(w J I ttr l7 NAI Software lnslallati.on
Quaillkalion
Software Name <llld Vcn;icn: GOTHIC 8.2(().o\)
CQmpmt>11'"ode
Nmnc: CAR"l"Slll
Compu:er
HP DL56(J Scn*er. i:4} lnli::I Xt!t111 E:'i4ti:l0
CF't:s @2:'J(J(lHz
Comput>:!r
0.i;<>ratmg
System aud V1:rsi>JcL:
Winoow.i
2012 Rev 2 Str.ndaf<l
64-::iit Tc;11t nitre* Fcbniary 3, 201 7 Dc:scdpt:on
of l1tst,tllal:un
a11d
Rr1n gtesLb,1:
Vcrific<l
1nlomatcd
compariwn
p10gmn O!.ilpul ittdic;;tt!S
all 7 .:;cm1p.irisor:s
are
b le De
11.ml R csolu tfon No
W;)N ldcntiftcd.
j::pf-'*'l'
lns1il 11 H tkm :. 'A?"l=t:
Samauth1 I'. Smdt:}' /
SbJl\)ll K. Thome July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI -2007 -004 Revision 0 Page A2 of Al 8 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 50 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NA.l-QA-1*18
Rel' I '.! ()f 17 GOTHIC
Sup&#xb5;ort Pros:r2m (GISP} 1.1 (Nov 1 2016 16:40:26)
Ran on Fri Feb 03
2017 Ran on node
Input File Options Value Default dircetory
for
l's: C: I User:!;/ smelley5/Documents/GOTHIC_lns-ta
11_ Te5t Uefault directory
2's: Files (xSG)/GDTIHC/S.
2(0A)/sarnple
Tyoe c*f f.ill!'s for rnmpari5on:
Remove trailing cntl and sraces:
<ill ..:ntl th<i;'acter:s;
If remcwe all cntl chars, replaci:-w:...:h spaces: Match lines by case: EJ(cltu:le
case sensitive
llnes/entdes
each
header in details Exclude case insensiti*1e
lire:;/entries
*nmp;irl ;;nn hi;>;irlf"r
1n ilf>Til115
Rcnovc on cxc:uslon
set: each comparison
header in details [}Oublc !".:itching
Critcrfo dirl -dir:.! -typs -cool -cntl -ws -case -ex.cl -exclm t"inCJo<cl
value value Treat doubles >a
<is a zerC>: -z At>s<>lLtte
ditf-e-renc:e
ac:ceptanc:e: -a Percent dif-:=erence
acceptance: -p 01..rt:put
Pr'ifit (()ntro! L:/Program
SOT True Fa::.se True True see below See befoi; Set: bdoi; Current le-023 le-012 G.01 { 11rri-nr l\ppeno outp*..its
to existing files (cmd arg -append Fa:se Ornly output the number of failed comparisons
to : -no_cutput
False Summary autput file (cmd arg anly): -s c: \Users\sn1elleys\DC>cu111ents
\GOTtUC_lnstall_rest\gtest_report.
txt Detail outi::ut file-(crm:l -d July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page A3 of Al 8 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 51 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
Tltle for comparison
;1 line: Do Mt print di
it less tt\an: Limit -File to "this man'(
Limit s1.nomary
fEe tc this many e1'rors: Liri1t sumrnar-y
tile to thiS nany excludes:
Limit detail t:his many
Limit detail fi:e tc this many
Limit detail tile to this nany excludes:
compa t'lson 1 -
riles: -t.l.tle -dittpt -msc -rnst--msexe! -mdci -mde -m:!exc!
1 J of 17 le-025 10 rn 10 100 106 100 [ 1 J SOT: r: /llsP.rs/sllli'l
l
_
Te<:r/el<<1l'llp
l e_h!.ir. -.oT [2] SOT: c: /Progran Files (x86)/GOTHIC/8.
2(Qi'!.)/sanpfaiexample_bwr.SOT
di>fa11l-::-
<) type SOT
[1]
Hun litle, ___________
_ Run D2te. ****-**-*****
CO<ll::.uter.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * CAA1S01, 1 Processor!>
Solver ID.____________
GOTiiIC !L 2(QA}, Oct 1016 S[)llfer Pa::t!_. _ ** _..... C: \Pr*ogra"tl
files
Sc>lVE!I"" Date ***** -* * * * * 01t.Jil\/2011i-15
:4Ei: 58, cs = 28887 S1N File Path **.*.*...
c :ws.ers.\sr'.ielleys.
\example_owr .srn SIN File Date.........
03Fell2017-13
:50: 12, cs = 49225 SGR File Path **. _ ***** c: \Use1's\soelleys\Docu111t-n
ts \GOTliIC_Ins
tcll_rt::st\.
SGll File Date ... __ **** 0_?Feb2017-13:SG:15, CS = 56767 File [2] Header: -it* :Iii: :t: t::+:lt
tr;.t :it 'K 'JI:. :t"' jl: +:;+;:+ :+ :t.,.; t; +::+"'ti Iii::+* jc ii:: +:.:t:;+ ;4:,.;: :t. t::t.::+ :It: :Ir; F. .. * t: t:: ic:+ :it :-et::+::+.:+.:+
:ii:: :t. t: "'* :M: t; July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page A4 of Al 8 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 52 of 254 Him I it:le ..*..........
Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
Run Date......
* * * . * . * . 01No*t2016-16
:43 :42 cooputer'
******* ''..... NCMSENS, 1 Pt'o.te!>!:OI"!'.;
solve1' ID........ . . . . .
wwrc 8.2(QA}, oa 2016 NAJ-QA-1-18
Re,* I 4 of17 Solver Path...... . . . . . K: \got:hii:\version;;\EL2\Win32\bin\gothic_s;.
exe Solver Date ***** ,..... "'.<1No 1 12016-16:43:15, CS = 28887 SIN File Path ........ . K:\gothic\..,ersions\8.2\,Jin32'.sample\.\exanple
i>'"1r.SIN
SIN File J)atG.........
01Novl011i-16:43:40, cs = 49H:. SGR File Patr ........ . K :\gcrthic'wersions\8.
2\Alin32'.sample\.
\exanple_bwr .SGP. SGR File I>at:G *** '..... 0111oV2016-16:'13;'13, cs -56767 [1] r21 UK! fll [l] OK: [1] [l] OK: [1] Pl OK! [1] [2] OK: r1.i [:J] OK:
Date ****. ,. El3FebZe17*13:50:13
Start: Date ****. ,, i'l1No112016-16:43:42
Line 2lf>:.! -Line el(cluded
Current Date **.. , 83Feb2017-13:50:13
current Date.....
EllNovztH'6-Hi:43:42
Line 2163 -Line
CPTime *********..
CPTime **.*****..
' 1.5G250ee-02
se(onds a.000000e+00
secands Line 2169 -Line e1<*cluded
Start: Date ****.. , 83Feb2017-13:50:13
Line 2776 -Line excluded current Datt:.... . El3Ft:bW17-n:
50: 15 current DatE?.....
a1Nov2016-16:43:4S
Line 2Tl7 -Line el(cluded
CPTime .*.*****.. , 2..593750e+00
seconds n' Ii me.......... . ;i
Line 2783 -Llr'le excluded July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page AS of Al 8 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 53 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
acceptable.
Lines compared
Cert pal' ls on 2
riles: l\Al-QA*l*Ul
Re,* I 5 ofl7 [ l] sor: c: .SOT (2) SOT: ('./Progr"all'.l
Files (X&6)JGOTHIC/8.2(QA}/sample/example.SOT
tlon default opt:ions <> compal'ing
as type SOT File [1] Header:
Run Title.............
t)(omplc Run Date ..** ,,........
03Feb20n-n:s0:18
Computer ****..********
CARTSOl, 1
Solver" ID ****.*.******
GOTHIC 8.2(QA), Oct 2e15
Path *..***..***
C:\Program
Files (1CS6) \GOrHIC\8
.2(Q.'1.)\bin\,gothic_s .exe solver"
*..********
01Nov2016
15:46:58, cs -2BS87 SIN File Path .***.*.**
c: \USel's\s111elleys
\Do-cuments
Test\. \f!Xatt1p.'-e.
SI)4 SIN File Date.........
03Fell2017-13:50:18, cs = 32920 SGR
Path .*.******
c:\Us.ers\s111elleys\Di)t:Ument:>\GOTIIIC_Inst:.!:lll_1es.t\.\exMple.5GR
!>Git .. ile Date. ________
t:!; = olYb4 File [2] Header: "t:T;>oJ:*i<'i':*:i
:f :txf:t: +"*:t: :to: ** ::t :f:tx:t: t: +::+ *:t: :fo: .. *:t::f:xt-:
t: t:*:>f' :f: t. t::t*:t::-t:
*** t$:i-:*1::t::+
:t :f: f: P:un Title.... . * . . * * * * * eManple P.un Date..... . * * . * * * * * 01Nov2016-15
:43: 3.S July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page A6 of Al 8 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 54 of 254 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
Computer ....... ,,.,,.. rKARSTENS, 1
Solver ID .....*.....*.
GOTHIC B.2(QA), Oct
Rft* l 6(}f17 Solver P<itil...... . . . * * ;: : \goth le \w:rslo:1s\8.
Z\liin3Z\b:l.n\gothk_:s.
e.xe solver Date...........
01NOV2.0'16-16:43:.15, cs = ZBBB7 SIN File Date.... . . . . .
0trJav21U6-16:43:
3$, C!> = ;!2.92'1 SGll Vile Path ***... , . * K:
2\Win32\E;ample\.
\example.SGR
SGll file Date ***.. , * . . eUJav21U6-16:43 3il, CS = 61954 [1] )tart llatf' .......
[2] Start Date ....... 0trJ0'11616-16:43:33
C*Jc:: line 757 -Line excluded [1] Current Date ..*..
[2] Current Dilte., ... 0rno*12.&!6
16:43:38 OK: line 758 -Line excluded ri1 CPTime *..........
l.562500e-02
seconds [2] CPTime .****......
0.0eel:}00e+0e
sec.om.ls
OK: line 764 -Line excluded [1] start Date *......
['] 'it<irt l);ltf' .......
OK: Line 1261 -line e:.::cludf!d
[l] current Dote ....* 03Fel>W17
13:5'3: 18 [2] Current Date ..*.. etrJa*..-2a
16-16: 43 : 39 C'K: Line 12G2 -Line eKdudt:d [1] CPTlme .***.....**
4.531250-t-01
seC<Jr'UJS
[l] CPTime *.... , ..*.. 6.864044<!-01
secamls CK: line 1258 -Line excluded Ccrrparison
3 -Cc<<p,orir.g
filc:i: July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page A7 of Al8 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 55 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAT-QA-1-18ReY
l 7 ofl7 (1 j SOT: C:/User*s/ .SOT (2] SOT: C:/Pra.gram
l=iles (x&6)/GCTHIC/8.2(QA)f.sar:if>le/e:>c:arrple_P'"r.SOT
Non default optiuns. <..> Ca.mparing
as type SUI File fll Header:
Run Title ****..*.*****
Run Date *****..*.**.**
03Feb2017-13:56:20
Cooputct'..............
CART5'31, 1
Solver ID **.**** '..... G07HIC 8.2(QA), Oct 2016 Solver Path...........
(:\Program
l=iles (:<8G}\GOTHIC\8.2(QA)\bin\gothic:_s.e.xe
soliJer Date...........
0111ov101c-1S
:4&: !>!!, c.s SIN File Path ..*.**.**
c:\Users.\s:nelleys\Do:u:nents\G-OTHIC_Install_Test\.\exa111ole_p.,,T.SIN
SHI File D<ite.........
03Feb2017-13:
50: 20, CS = 48 SGR File Path ..*.*....
C
\ 'i:'llf'l
l _1 e,*t\.
e_ri1o:r.
"[ill 5GR rile Date ..*.*****
03r-eb2017-13:50:21, CS= 37386 File L2] Heacer:
nun Title .***..****.**
F:.un [late.... . . . . . .
* * . * 01tlov2016-16
:43 :48 Conputer ********.*****
NCARSTENS, 1 Processors
<.;nlw*r m .............
rm:u1c !C7(1lk}, net /1-tln Solver Path...........
K: \Jlothic\versiocis.\B
s. exe Soll/*!" Date ... -* ...... 01tlOV2016-16:43:15, cs= 28887 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page A8 of Al 8 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 56 of 254
NUMERICAL
1 '1il APPLICATIONS
II
SIOI'. a !)UUfl M.UtUl!f.Cr..t!llli:.; "u.c
Path ****.****
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I(: \gothic\version.!:\S..
2\Winll\sal'.lple\.
\example_pwr.Silll File oate **.*.*...
01Nov201b-l6:43:4S, cs= 48 SGR File Path ***..*.*.
K: \gothic\versicins\8.
\example_pwr.SGR
[1]
Date.. . * * * . C>3Fet>2011-13
:se: 20 [2] Start Date ..***..
OK: Line 93<1 -Line exclu:led
f 11 Current C*ate **.. , 93Feb2'111-13
:50: 21 [ l] rurrFnt
<11NOV7i'llf,-
H'i :43 OK: Linc 931 Linc cxdu:lcd [L] lPlime-..........
seconds [2] CPTime...........
3.1w020e-a2
seconds OK: Line 937 -Line exclutieo
[l] Start Date.......
<13Fd>2!J17-13:5e:20
[2] St8rt Date ....... 91Nov2016-16:43:4:8
OK: Line 1329 -Line excluded [l] current Dote ****.
13:5e:21 [2:] Current Date.....
91Nov2'116-16:43:48
U:<: Line 1B0 -Line excluded [1] CPTime ****..****.
2.031250e-01
sEconds :iJ CPTime ***.*..**.*
2.S0S.01Se-G1
seconds OK: Line 1336 -Line exduded Stcrt Date ..****.
[Z] Start Date .......
OK: Li!ie 1678 -Llile 1] f)1rrPnt" ll;i"tj>.....
*1-H
n [2] current Dote *.*.. a1Nov2a16
16:43:49 OI(* Line 1679 -Line e:i:cluded
[l] CPTime...........
3.59J750e-01
:seconds '.2] CPTime ...**..*...
4.l12027e-01
seconds OK: Line 166.5 -Line excluded July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT l\AJ-QA-1-18
Kev 1 8 c:ifl 7 NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page A9 of A18 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 57 of 254 (r'-1\..1]
NUMERICAL
'""' APPLICATIONS
.. i.::t, sn ct 9rttm M.ur.:.n
1r.c. Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
[l] Start Date .****** 03Feb2017-13:50:20
[2]
uate ..*....
OK: Line 212>27 -Line excluded " No mnrE' i;xi:-1u<;inno;;
will hi; rPpnrti;d
in NAl-QA*l-18
Re'' 1 ?c.1r 17 c: \Users\ srre.Ueys
\l:ocoments
\GOTHIC_Install_
Test\gtest_repor-t.
txt. c r;pta ble . Lines coopa reel 2571. ccnparison
ll -C:cnparing -file!:: [1] SOT:
(2] SOT:
files {J<86)/roTHIC/8.2(QA)/sample/pre_el(ample.SOT
Non
opticns <> Compuin1l
as tyi::e SOT File [1] Heaaer:
Run Title....... . . * * * * JH'e example Run Date..............
03Feb2017-13:50:24
computer ..*****.******
CARTS01, l
Solver ID .*****.*..***
GGTHIC 8.2(QA), Oct 2016 so11.*er Path...........
C:\Progr-arn
Fill&#xa3;ls
\rm I t<ff\1:1."J (QA) \hi n\e;.-rthir
_ "-l"'lCI"'
Solver Cate ...........
01Nov2016-15:46:5.8, CS= 28887 SIN
Patr. ........ .
SIN File
******.**
03Fcb2017
13:S0:24, cs -112 SGP. File
******...
(:\Users\sr:relleys\Cocuments\GOTHIC_Install_Test\.\pre_eJ<ample.SGfl
SGR file
*******.*
03reb2017-13:50:24, CS= 25521 File [2] 11eaoer: July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page AlO of Al8 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 58 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTIDC Uncertainty
Evaluation
Run Title *.********..*
pre_examplc
Run [}ate. , . . * * * . . . * . . * 01t4o\12016-16
:43: 35
....**********
NCAR5i[NS, 1 Processors
<;nlvPr rn ... ___ .... __ . GOTHTC' :oi.;i(QA), Oct )016 NAl-QA-M!I
Rey 1 10 of 17 Solver Pa':h **.********
K:\gcttiic\veri;ions\8.2\Win32\bin\i;-::ithic_s.exe
Salver Da':e **** , ****** 01tvov2016-16:43;15, CS= 28887 SIN File Path *.*.*****
li::\gotnic\vers.ions\2.2\olin3:2\sarrple\.\pre_exanp:Le.!>IM
SUI File Date.........
01t<.lov2016-16:43:33, CS = 112 SGR File Path *********
K:\sotnic\vers.ions\2.2\olin3:2\sarrple\.\pre_exanp:e.!>GR
SGR File Date ******.**
CS= 25521 [1] Start Date ****.** 03Feb2017-13:50:24
PJ 5"1'art D;it!'.......
01<: Line '152 -Line
[1]
Date ***** e3Feb2017*13;50:24
[2] Cur'rerrt
Date.....
01t\m*2016-16
:43: 36 OK: n;> 4fH -I 1ne f'lCClrnferl
(1] CPTime *.******...
1.562S00e-G2
[2] CPTime ****.******
seconds OK: L:.ne 469 -Line excluded [lJ start Date.......
e::!Feb2017-13:50:24
[2] S,tart Date.......
OK;
G59 -Line excluded [l] rurr..,nt
!J;it'P ..... ('l'.!Fph:;'017-13:'>0:74
[2] current Date .*.*.
OK: L:.ne 660 -Line eMcluded [1] PJ CPTime .*******.**
seconds IPTlmf' ...........
1.lUl400qe-ffl
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page All of Al8 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 59 of 254
NUMERICAL APPLICATIONS "L.:ft SIOt', a-9.ItU?'I
IJ.I:. 01<: Line 666 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
-Line e:l(cluded
[1] Star':: Date ... --*. CBl=eb2017-B:50:24
[l] Start Date *.****.
01<: Line B36 -Line e:l(cluded
[1] [urrent Date _____ 03Feb2017-13:50:24
[l] current !>ate.....
01Nov2015-16
:*13: 36 OK! Line B37 -Line e:l(cluded
[1] CPTime ...... **-** 6.250000e-G2
seconds [2] CPTime .*....**...
1.872011e-0l
Ok: Line B43 -Line e:l(cluded
[1] Star'= Date .. **-**
[2] Start Date ..**.*.
01<: Line 1013 -Line e:l(cluded " No toore exclusions
will be repor*ted
in NAl-QA*l-Ul l 11of17 C : \Users \.s;melleys:
\Document
1: \GOT HI {_Install_
Test \.gt est _report. t lo!t . Cc-mparison
accept:;ible.
Lines ccrrpared
1337. (nmp;irio::nn
c;. -comi:<<H'iTlg
tiles: [1] 5t1T: r.: /llo;;ero;;/<;.mf'l
l
_Tno.t-;il
l_Tf'o;.t/ti;5t1
S. <;OT [i] SCT: C:/Pt'ogr<im
Files (X86)/GCTHIC/8.2{QA)/samp1e/test15.SCT
Nor det-ault options <>
ao::
'OT l P. (1]
Run Title .**..........
Run Date *******.......
comptJter
******** ,..... CAl\TS01, 1 Pracessnri>
SOl\*f!t'" ID ****.**. , . . . . GOTHIC B .2(QA), Oct 2016 Solver-PattL .***.. ,... C:\Pr'C:*gram
Files (lil'f> )\C,UIH I c:\K. "J(QA) \bi n\i:;othir
-.f')!f' July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
RevisionO
Page Al2 of Al8 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 60 of 254 SIN
Path ........ . Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation .liel' l 12 of 17 c: \Users\s11elleys\Documents
\GOTHlC_Install_Hst\.
\testis. SIN SIN File Date, *. ''''.. 03Fcb2917
cs -32 SGR File Path ***. '' .** C:
\GOTHIC_Install_Test\.
\t:st1S. SGR SGR File Date..... . * * * 03Feb2917-13:
se: 27, cs = 63977 File [2] Header:
Run Title., , *.........
Run Date... . * * * . . . . . .
* 0rnov2.t116-15:43:
53 c*omp101"Pr... . . . . . . . . . . .
I HJ\, 1
Soll;e;r ID .............
GOTHIC 8.l(QA). Oct 2315 5oh*er Path...........
K: \gothic\versicrns\3.
2\L/in32\bin\gothic_s.e:oc:e
Solver Date *****. , .*** 01Nov2&16-16:43:1S, CS= 28887 SIN File Path.... . . . . . K: 'lgothic\versio;is.\8.
2\Win32\s3mplE\.
\test1S.SIN
SIN File Date.........
rarnov2ft16-16:43:
50, cs = 32 SGR File Path... . . . . . * K ! \gothie\l/er'!;ions\!L
SGF: File D<itc.... . . . * * 01Nov2&16
16:43 53, cs -63977 [l] Start Date ....*.. 03Feti2ft17-13:50:26
[2] start Date.. . . . . .
011oiov2.t1!6-15:43:
53 OK: line 694 -Line excluded [1J current Date. . . . . 03F@2817-B:
50: 26 [2] Current Date .....
GK: I.inc 695 Linc excluded [1] r21 CPTime ..***....**
t.5G25aee-02.
seconds CPTime *...*...*..
l.56ee1ee-02
seconds July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Al3 of A18 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 61 of 254 OK; [1] [2] OK: [1] [2J OK: [1] [2] OK: [1] [2] (11(: Lir:e 701 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation -L ilie extluc!ed
<,r.'lr"t
D;i1"p *.**...
Stort Date *.*..** 01Nov2016
16:43:53 Lire 9JB -Line excluded Current
***** 03F2b2017-13:50:26
Current [)ate.....
91Nav2016-16
:43 :53 Llr:t:-984 -Lille ext:luiJet1
CPTime ***.*.*...*
CPTime ***.*.*****
3.437502e-01
seconds 4.524029e-01
seconds lir:E 990 -Line excluded StoM: Date.......
03F*:::b2017
13:50:26 Start Date *.**.** 01Nov2016-16:43:53
I 1nF-1M9 fll Current
**..* 93feb2017-13:Sa:26
[2] Curr-e11t
Dat:e.....
01Nov2016-16
:43: 54 o K : Lire 12 50 -Line ex eluded [1] [2] UK: CPTime *****.***.*
G.Z5eeoee-01
seconds CPTime ***.*.**.*.
6.854044e-01
seconds Lir.e 11!>6 -Line excluded [lj Start Date *.**... 03Feb2017-13:Sa:26
(7] <;r;ir"t Oil"tl' .. -----
OK: Lir1e 1513 -Line excluded ,.. Na more exclusions
1*ill be reported in i'OAT-QA-l-lS
Rn l Li af 17 c: \Users \s111elleys\DlJcu111en
ts \GDTI1IC_Install_
Test\gtest_report.
txt. Comparison
acceptable.
Lines compared 2e21. ccnpciri:.oo
e; Ccaparing
(1] '>Ill : c*:
l
lti If_ In 5t'll l _ lf'51"/teo;t-;r;
_<,CJ 1 [2] SOT: C:/Progr'am*Files (X86)/GOTHIC/8.2(QA}/S:'intple/test23.SOT
lion default opi::!ons
<> comparing
cs type SOT Flle [1] Ht::atle1':
P.u11 Title **...*****.**
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page A14 of Al8 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 62 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
Run Date *.*****.*****.
03Feb2617-13:50:29
co.nputer'
***.**.**.*.**
CARTS01, 1
So1'te1' ID.............
GOTHIC B.2(0,o\}.
Oc:t 2016 Solver Path ***.....***
C:\Program
1)<86 )\GOTHIC\B
.2(QA) \bir.\gothic_s
5IN File Path *********
RI!\>* I 14.ofl7 c: \lJse1's.\smeHeys\1Jocu111tnts
\GOTtuc_rnstall_Test\.
\test23. srn SIN eile Date ...... _ ..
CS= 48 S6R File Path ***.*****
r:
\t,ps1"73.
SGR SGR Hle Date.........
CS = 2A54 file f2l Header:
Run Title *************
Run Date..............
0Ulov2&16-16:43
:57 computer'
.*******.**
,.. PICARSTENS, 1 P-rocessors
Solve1' ID **.*******
'. * GOTHIC B' 2(0,o\}. Oc:t 2016 Sol*1er Path...........
K: \gothic\versions\8
.2\Win32\bin\go-:::hic_s .exe Sol'ler Date...........
0Ulov2fl16-16:43:1S, CS = 28887 SIN File Path *********
SIN File Date.........
0UIOVZll'16-16:43:
55, cs = 46 SGR File Path.........
I'.: \gothic\versions\8
.2\Win32\s,ample\.
\test23_s.GR
SGR File Date **.** , *** 01Nov2fl16-16:44:06, CS= 24S4 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Al5 of A18 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 63 of 254
NUMERICAL
1 ""'41 APPLICATIONS
* t:ff SK:t. Ct !>rttln
114:. Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
[1] start D<:>te.......
03Feb2017-B:50:29
[2) S.tar-t D2te *.. ,... 0H,m12016.-15
:43: 57 OK: Line GBl -Line excluded [1] C'ilrN'nt
l)<it<>. .* . . fHl-P.h:t01
l-H:':>fl:/'!
[2] curNmt [)ate.....
0U.0\'2016-15:'13:Ss
OK: Line 682 -Line
(1]
**......***
[2] CPTfae...... . . . . . 4. 680030e-fl2
seccnds * OK: Line 688 Linc excluded [l] Start Date.,.....
03Feb2017-B:50:29
[2] Start Di;te.......
011\0\'2016-15:43:57
OK! Line 987 -Line e>1cluded
[1] Current Date, . . . * 03Feb2017-B
:50: 32 [::'] l(1rrPnt ll<!TP. ..*** Bll\'11-'::tlill6-ll'i:44:fl'.\
OK: Line 988 -Line exeluded [1] CPTime .........**
seconds (2]
*****....**
seconds UK: Line 994 -Line
f1 l Star-t Date.......
03Feb2017-B:50:29
[2] Slar*t Date.......
OK: Line 1270 * Line e.xc:luded
[1] curr<:nt ootc.,...
133Fcb2017
B :se: 37 [2] Current Date.....
011\o..*2016.-15
:44:*8 OK: L!ne: 12:7.l -Line e>:cluded
(1)
**........*
seconds [2] CPTime **..*. , ..*.
seconds OK: Line 1277 * Line E!xcluded
comparison
Lines compar*ed
1*199. comparison
i -compnring
NAl-QA-1-18
Re"* 1 15 of 17 f1l SCT: C:/Users/smelleys/Documents/GOTHlC
Install Test/test.26.SOT
[2] SGT: c: /Progran;
Files (X86)/GOTt-:IC/8.
2.(Ql\)/san;pleitest26.SCT
Non default option$ <> comparing
as type SOT July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page A16 of A18 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 64 of 254
[1]
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAT--Q.\-1-18
Rev 1 16 of17
Run Title ..****.***..*
Run Date ...*********.*
03FebZ017-13;50:43
......**.*.*.*
CARTS01, 1
ID * , * * * * .. * * * * * GOTHJ C !!. 2 (QA), O::lc:t 2016 solver r<ith...........
C:\rrogr<1m
F:.k:; (x86)\GOTl-.IC\8.
2(QA)\bin\gothic
s .axe Solver Date.......... . 01Nov2016-15
:46: 58, cs 28887 sn File Path ***.***..
c: \lJsers\sr'.lelleys\Documents\GOTHIC_Itistall_Test\.
\testlti .srn File Date **.***..*
03FcbZ017
13;50:43, cs -32 File Path ........ . C:\Users\s11elleys\Documents\GOTHIC_Install_rest\.\te!>tZ6.SGR
SGR File Date.........
03FebZ0l7-13;
50:43, cs = 25474 Header!
Rlln T1tlP ............ . llun Date,,............
01Nov2316-115:44!13
...*.****..*.*
NCARSTENS, 1 Processors
Solver lE) ********** , , * GOTllJC 3. 2(QA), Dct 2e1G Solver Dat:e...........
01Nov2016-16:43!15, CS = 2BB87 Sn File Path... . . . . . . K: \gothic\vers.ions\8.
2',Wicl32\s<impl8\.
\test26. 5IN SH File Date *****.*.*
01NOVW1G-1G;44:DB, cs -32 Sull J.ile Path.........
K ! \gothic\versions\!L.l\Win'.:!:.l.\sample\.
\test:!<>.
SGR July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Al 7 of A18 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 65 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
SGR rile Date ..**.***.
CS= 25474 tlJ [2J OK: (lJ [2.] OK: [1] [2] OK: [1] [2] OK; [1] [2.] OK: Start Date.......
03Febl.017-13:S0:43
Start Date.......
01No\*2tl16-16:44:10
Line "-ll0 -Line excluded Current Data.....
03f.eb2a17-13:50:43
Current Dato::. * * . . i'llNC*\*
2016-16 : 44; 111 Lf.ne l.81 -LiM exc:luded
start Date.. * . * . . i'13Fd:izet7-1J:
50; 43 Star't Date.......
<>lNovl.016-16:44:1<>
Line 753 -Line ei<cluded
Curr-ent
..... <>3Feb2017-13:S0:43
Current Data.. . . . 01No\*2016-16:44:10
LL-1e 754 -Line excluded CPTime **..****.*.
CPTime ***.******.
9. 3C*00G0e -El2 seconds Line 7ti0 -Line excluded Cofl'iladson
acceptable.
Lines compared B98. Sumnary Number of file sets compared:
7 Number nf files sets that failed comparison:
0 Com11arlsons
successful
'!Al*QA*l-1!1
Rev I 17 ofl7 Sumnary Report is C:\!Jsers\smelleys.\Doc:uments\GOTHIC_Install_TE!st\gtest_repnrt.txt
Detail Report is not creatad 0 File
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page A18 of A18 
Comparison
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 66 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
Attachment
B. Difference
Reports CPS lA DG Benchmark.GTH
vs. ---NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl ofB156 CPS lA DG Benchmark
a.GTH ......................................................................................
2 --CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH vs. ------CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7a.GTH ..........................................................
.29 ----CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH vs. ------CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case lOa.GTH .........................................................
70 ------CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case lOa.GTHvs. ------CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case lOb.GTH .......................................................
111 ----CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case lOa.GTHvs.
------CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case lOc.GTH .......................................................
113 ----CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case lOa.GTHvs.
------CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case lOd.GTH .......................................................
114 ----CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTHvs.
------CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case lZa.GTH .....................................................
116 ----July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 67 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Network Links -Table l Link Vol Elev Vol Elev Description
A F (ft) B (ft) lL DG Room to Tank ls7D /N 751. ln 747. ,. 2L DG Room to Day ln 747. 746. 3L DG Room to Oil ln 747. 736. 4L Day Tank Room t 743. 2n 743. SL Oil Tank Room t 733. 2n 743. 6L Tank Rooms to O 2n 743. lls3 w 787. 7L DG Room to Tank 12 771. ln 747. Graphs Graph curve Number # Title 1 2 3 0 M&E Imbalance
EM EE 1 Benchmark
Heat Rate Comparison
cvlC DC4T 2 Benchmark
Exhaust/ /Inlet Tempe TVlslOS DCST TV12 4 DC6T 3 Div 1 DG Room Upper SubVolurne
TVlslOS TVlsl06 TVlsl07 TVlsl02 4 Div 1 DG Room Doors to Hall TVls41 TVls42 TV1s43 TVls44 5 Div 1 to Hallway Pressure PRls44 PR4sl24 PR12 PR9 6 DG Room Temeprature
TVls39 TVlsB TVlsll TVlslOS 7 Fan Room and outside Air Tempe TV7 TV1ls2 TV12 8 Fan Flow Rate LV7L LV6L 9 24hr Benchmark
T TVlslOS DCST 10 24hr Benchmark
Heat cvlC DC4T 11 DG Room T v Benchmark
1 TVls47 /TVl1140 DC7T DCBT \TVloJ9 12 DG Room T v Benchmark
2 TVls35 DC9T DClOT TVls37 13 Hallway, 762' I & 712' TV4sl24 TV9 TVlO 14 Wall Temperature
for the Small TA3s2 15 Atmospheric
Pressure PRllsl PR1ls2 PRlls3 16 Atmospheric
BC Flow Rates FVlO FVll 17 Recirculation
Mass Flow FV23 FV24 18 Leakage Flow Rate FV28 FV29 19 Hallway Door Flow Rates FVlS FV14 FV16 FV17 20 Relative Humidity Above the Ai RHlsSS RH1s86 RH1s87 21 Temperature
Above the Air Comp TVlsSS TV1s86 TV1s87 22 Di vl DG Panel Temperatures
TVls43 TVls40 TVls39
TVlsS 23 Components
of Averages TVlsS TVlsS
TVlsll TV1s40 24 Panel 1PL12JA Temperatures
TVlsl4 TVlslS TV1s30 TVls31 25 Panel 1PL12JA Temperatures
TVls46 TV1S47 TV1s62 TVls63 26 Panels 1PL92JA/1PL93JA
Tempera TVls12 I I \TVlS \TV16' 27 Panel lDGDlJA Temperatures
TVls7 TVlsB TVls23 TVls24 28 Panel lDGOlJA Temperatures TV1s39 TV1s40
'lVlsSS TVls56 29 Panel 1DG06SA Temperatures
TVlsS TV1s6 TVls21 TVls22
30 Panel lDGOlKA 12cyl Temperatur
TVlsll TV1s27 TVls43 TVls59 31 Panel lDGOlKA 16cyl Temperatur
TV1s7 TV1s23 TV1s39 TVlsSS 32 Panel Bulk Average Temperature
cvlOC cv14C cvlBC 33 Panel Bulk Average Temperature cv22C cv26C
cv30C 34 Division 1 Room Door DPs DP14 DPlS DP34 35 Division 1 Room Rollup Door DP DPl.6 DP17 DP35 DP36 36 Div 1 DG Heat Absorption
cv2C Volumetric
Fan -Table 2 Vol Flow Flow Heat Heat Fan Flow Rate Rate Heat Rate Rate
Disch # Option (CFM) FF Option (Btu/s) FF Vol lQ I Time I 3020. I I Time I 0. I I lsB6 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 5 TV1s103 PRlO TV1s37 TVls43 I )TV14 \TV14 I )TV17 )TV17 )TVl* )TVl* \TV20 NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B2 ofB156 curve Ops Ll"cvlOC (1PL12 Ll."cv22C
(1DG06 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 68 of 254 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Volumetric
Fan -Table 2 (cont.) 2Q ;Q 4Q SQ 6Q 7Q SQ Time Flow Option Time Time Time Time Time
Time Time Min 0.001 0.001 0.001 Plow (CFM) 4250. 4250. /1510. \2800. 1.s '"' Ratio Run Options Option Restart Option Start Time (sec) Parallel Processes
Preprocessor
Multithreadin9
Revaporization
Fraction Maximum Mist Density llbm/ft3)
Drop Diam. FrOf!I Mililt (in) Minimum RT Coeff. (B/h*ft2-F)
Refe:z:ence
P:i;e111,,.1re (psia) Maximum Pressure (psia) Forced Ent. D:rop Diam. (in) Vapor Phase Head Correction
Kinetic Energy Vapor Phase Liquid Phase Drop Phase Force Equilibrium
Drop-Liq.
Conversion
QA Logging Dcb1.1g Output Level Debug Starting Time Step D!;!b1.1g
Time St!;!p Frequency
Restart Dump on CPU Interval (sec) Pressure Initialization
Iteration
Pressure Initialization
Convergenc:
Solver Command Line Options Function Model Gen. Heat Rate Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.; Heat Rate (B'l'U//sec)
Option Ti= Time Time Time Time Time Time End Time Dcp. Var. Ind. Var. '* I '* I Heat (Btu/s) Time Domain Data Print Graph /60. )k \10. Setting /4 \8 NONE DEFAULT DEFAULT IGNORE DEFAULT DEFAULT INCLUDE INCLUDE INCLUDE IGNORE INCLUDE l.Oe-6 llcp. Var. I/*.* \l.053274
"* Disch Vol lls3 la54 lo Dump Ph Chng Relax T T Scale DEFAULT July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Sh1.1toff
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B3 ofB156 2 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 69 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) Model Gen. Heat Rate Ind. Var.; Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Heat Rate (BTU//sec:)
Inci. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Oep. Var. 120. /B.4 /12.6 )6,106548
)9.159822
16.B 20.9 )12.213096
)15.1'3673
360, 25.l 29.3 )18 .24047 )21.300221
480. 33.S 540. 37.7 )24 .353495 )27.40676'9
41.9 660. 46.l )30.460043
)33.513317
50.J 780, 54.4 )36.566591
)39.547168
58.6 62.8 )42.600442
)45.653716
960. 67. 1020. 71.2 )48.70699
)51.760264
1080. 73.S 1140. 75.9 )53,432295
)55.177023
78.2 80.5 )56.849054
82.9 )58.521085
85.2 )60.265813
)61.937844
87.6 1500. 89.9 )63.682572
)65.354603
92.2 94.6 )67 .026634 96.9 )68.771362
99.2 )70 .443393 )12-115424
1800. 101.6 l.860, 102.2 )73.860152
)74.296334
102.8 105.7 )74.732516
)76 .840729 2520. 108.6 111.6 )78.948942
)81.129852
114.5 117.4 )83.238065
)85.346278
120.4 4020. 123.3 )87.527188
)89.635401
4320. 126.2 129.2 )91.743614
)93.924524
132.l. 153. )96.032737
\111.22641
le .. 09 153. \111.22641
Control Volume Parameters
Vol Vol Elev Hyd. D. L/V IA SA Min Film Description (ftJ) (ft) (ft) (ft) (ft2) FF (ft) l* DG Room (Div. 1 DEFAULT DEFAULT DG Room (Div, 2 DG Room (Div. 3 ,, Hallway 143900. Day Tank Room Oil Tank Room 14000. 712. "* Mako up Air Sup Rest of El 737' 737. "* DEFAULT Rest of El 762' 712' El Outside Air 23750. 762. 13 Interposing
Int 1000. 762. "* I= I= I= /DEFAULT /DEFAULT )!!.x )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )!!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )iixx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT \20 \lDGOllCA
16cyl \9.868 \739.458 \5.833 \0.883 \DEFAULT \ \DEFAULT Control Volume Opt.ions Vol S Wave Pool HMT Pool Pool l'C'es. Pool Dp. "" Burn ICIE' * Damper Mult Opt Correction
FF Tracking Opt Drag lo I 1. I DEFAULT I LOCAL I ON I I ON I NONE I ON July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Min Film I= >= >= >= >= >= \ NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B4 ofB156 3 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 70 of 254
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
J ul/24/2017
20:59:1 6 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Control Vol.ume Options (cont.) Vol S Wave Pool EMT Pool Pool Pres, Fool Dp. ... Burn ICIP * Damper Mult Opt CorrectiQn
FF Tracking Opt Drag " 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON " l. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON 4* 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON s l. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON 6 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON 7 l. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON 8 l. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON ' 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON 10 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON 11* 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON 12 l. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON 13 l. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON I= /DEFAULT I= I= I= I= /><=>< }i!xx )DBPAtJLT
DBFAULT }xxxxxxx }ii.,. )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xxxxxxx )DBFAtJLT
Dl!:FAtJLT }xxxxxxx }DEFAULT J>EFAULT }xxxxxxx )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xxxxxxx }ii.,. )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xxxxxxx \20 \1. \DEFAULT \LOCAL \ON \ \ON \NONE \ON Laminar Leakage Lk Rate Ref Rof Ref Sink Leak Vol Factor Preas Temp Humid or Model Rep Subvol Area * ('/br) (psial (F) (t) Src Option Wall Option (ft2J '" o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT ,. o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT ,. o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 4a 0, CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT s 0. CNST T tlNIFORM DEFAULT ' 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 7 o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT . 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT ' 0, CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 10 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT ''" 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 12 o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT " o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT /xxxxxxx /xxxxxxx I= /xxxxxxx /DEFAULT }i!xx >== )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xxxxxxx )== )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xxxxxxx }xxxxxxx }xxxxxxx )== )DB FAULT DEFAULT }xxxxxxx }xxxxxxx }xxxxxxx >== )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xxxxxxx )== )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xxxxxxx }xxxxxxx >== )DEFAULT DEFAULT \20 \0. \ \ \ \ \CNST T I \UNIFORM \DEFAULT Turbulent
Leakage Ref Ref Sink Leak Vol Temp Humid Model Rep Subvol (!!;/hr) (pe:iaJ (F) (t) Option Wall Option {ft2) '" CNST T July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT fL/D NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page BS ofB156 4 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 71 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 'l\lrbulent
Leakage (cont.) Lk Rate Ref Ref Ref Sink Leak Vol Factor Press Temp Humid or Model Rep Subvol Area * (t/hr) (p::ila) (Fl "' Sre Option Wall Option (ft2) 6 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 7 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT ' o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT ' 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 10 '* CNST T UNIFORM DB FAULT 11' o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 12 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT lJ 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT />=a< /xxxxxxx /xxxxxxx /xxxxxxx /xxxxxxx /xxxx I= /xxxx /xxxxxxx /DBFAfILT )i!.x )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx >== )DBFAlJLT
DEFAULT )iixx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx >== )DEFAULT DEVAULT )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx >== )DBFAOLT DEFAULT )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx >== )DEFAOLT DB FAULT )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx >== )DEFAULT DEFAULT )i!.x )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx >== )DEFAULT DEFAULT \20 \0. \ \ \ \ \CNST T \ \UNJ:PORM
\DEFAULT Discrete Burn Parameters Min Min M= Flame Burn un Vol Length speea (ft) (ft/Iii) Opt " o.ss DEFAULT FBR 0,55 0.07 o.os 0.55 DEFAULT .. DEFAULT 0.07 DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 0.55 DEFAULT a.cs DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 0.05 0.55 DEFAULT 10 0.05 o.ss DEFAULT 11' 0.07 o.o5 DEFAULT DEFAULT 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 13 0.07 0.05 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR /"""" /=xxx /=xxx I= /DEFAULT /DBFAULT /"""" /DBFAULT /"""" )i!.x )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )"""" )DEFAULT DEFAULT )iixx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )"""" )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )"""" )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )"""" )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xxxx )DEFAULT DEFAULT ):X )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )"""" )DEFAULT DEFAULT \20 \0.0"7 \0.05 \0.55 \DEFAULT \DEFAULT \DEFAULT \FBR Continuous
Bu:rn Paramatcrs
Vol Min H2 Min Vol Flow H20 H20/H2 llbm/al Ratio ,. 1000. l. L o.os 0.55 1000. o.os o. o.os 1. 1000. 1. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT fL/D I= >= >= >= >= >= >= \ NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B6 ofB156 5 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 72 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Continuous
Burn Parameters (cont.) Vol Min H2 Min Vol Flow H20 H20/H2 Prac (lbm/s) Ratio lOOQ. 10 0.05 l. o. 0.05 1. l2 l. 13 0. 0.05 o.ss 1000. l. /xxxx I= I= I= I= )i!xx )ixxxxx )ii.a )ixxxxx )ixxxxx )ixxxxx )ixxxxx )ii.a )!xx.xx \20 \0. \0.05 \0.55 \1000. \l. Mechanistic
Burn Rate Parameters
Min Min Turb Vol H20 Temp Limit B= Frac Frac: Frac No. {lbm/ftl-s)
FF (Fl FF Opt 1* o. 1. 1. 350, ,, o. 0. 1. DEFAULT 350. o. DEPAOLT 350. BOIS l. l. BOIS o. o. l. l. 350, l. l. DEPAULT 350. 350, BOIS l. l. o. 0. 350. BOIS 10 l. DEFAULT 350. EDIS o. 13 o. l. l. 350, '"""" I= /xxxxxxx '"'&deg;""""'
/xxxxxxx /DBFAULT '"" I= '"" '"""" )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx }DB:P'AULT
DEFAULT )xx )xx >= )ii.a )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )DEFAULT DBFAOLT >= )xx >= )ixxxxxx )ixxx..x )DEFAULT DBFAOLT )"" )xx >= )ixxx..x )ixxx..x )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )xx >= )ixxx..x )ixxxxxx )DEFAULT DB FAULT )xx )xx >= )ixxxxxx )ixxx..x )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )xx >= \20 \0. \0. \l. \l. \DEFAULT \ \350. \ \RD rs Mechanistic
Burn Propagation
Parameters
Turb FF '"""" )xxxx )xx= )xx= )xx= )xx= )xxxx \ Unburned Burned CC Plow Flame lg Min lg Min lg Max Aut.o Ig Vol H2 Vcl Thick Temp (ft/s) {ft.) (P) a.a4 0.04 0.16'1 0.05 0.55 a.04 0.164 a.as o.ss 0.04 a.164 a.as a.04 a.as o.ss DEFAULT 0.04 o.aa1 0.05 0.55 DEFAULT 10 0.001 0.04 0.164 0.05 0.55 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B7 ofB156 6 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 73 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1 A DG Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Mechanistic
Burn Propagation
Parameters (cont,) Unburned Burned CC Flow Pl a.me Ig Min Ig Min lg Mnx Vol H2 H2 Vel Thick H2 02 Steam * Frac FF Frac FF (ft/s) FF (ft) FF Frac Frac
Prac 12 0.04 0.001 DEFAULT 0.164 0.04 0.05 o.ss 13 0.04 0.001 DEFAULT 0.164 0.04 0.05 o.ss '"""" I= /xx I= /xx /DEFA1J'LT
/xx I= /xx I= I= I= )i!.x )xx )xx )DEFAULT :DEFAULT )xx )xx )xx )xx )DEFAULT DBFAULT )xx )xx ).,, ).,, )DEFAULT DBFAULT ).,. )xx )xx )xx )DBFAULT DEFAULT ).,. ).,. )xx )xx )DEFAULT Dli:li'AUL'I' )xx )xx )xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )xx '" \0.04 \ \0.001 \ \DEFAULT \ \0.164 \ \0.04 \0.05 \0.55 Pipe Paramel:ers
Relal:ive
Lam Modulus of Vol Rough-Geom OP IP Elasticil:y
Stiffness
* ness Fact (inl (inl (pa!) Factor 1' DEFA " DEFA " DEPA " DEFA 5 DEFA ' DEFA 7 DEFA 8 DEFA ' DEFA 10 DBFA 11* DBFA 12 DBFA 13 DEFA '"""" I= /DBFA I= I= I= )i!.x >= )DEPA DBFA >= >= )xx= >= )DEPA DBFA >= >= >= >= )DBFA DEPA >= >= )xx= >= )DEPA DBFA >= >= >= >= )i!.x >= )"BFA DEPA >= >= >= >= >= )DBFA DBP'A >= >= >= >= \20 \ \DEPA \ \ \ \ Flow Paths -Table l Vol Blci.v Vol Elev "' Tilt Description (ft) (ft) (ft) (ft) (deg) Hatch {El 762 f Hatch (762' Hal 760. Hatch (762' Hal 762. Hat.ch (El 737 [ 0.1 Hat.ch (737'Half
735. Hatch (737'Half
735. Make Up Supply 763. 0.1 0.1 Normal Fan to D 0.1 Is86 755. Exhauat from DG 760. 0.1 10 Outside Air 737. Out.side Air 0.1 Divl-Div2
Upper 2s19 Divl-Div2
Lower 737. DG Rl Door (Low 737. lsl6 737. 2.5 15 DC Rl Dooi:-(Mid 4s64 739.5 ls32 2.5 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Auto Ig Temp (F) FF DEFAULT DEFAULT /DEFAULT /xx )DEFAULT DBFAULT )xx )DEPA1J'LT
DBFAIJLT )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT ).,. )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx \DBFAtrLT
\ (deg) NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B8 ofB156 7 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 74 of 254 m NUMERICAL
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
NAI-2007-004
AF>PLICATIONS
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Revision 0 nn*.*"J!"l'-l(\*:"*r1r:--*.n.r
*,;.r.n.rn.m:l'.i.:-:
t-r Evaluation
Page B9 ofB156 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
a I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -Table 1 {cont.) Vol Elev Vol Blev Tilt Description
{ft} (ft) {ft) (ft) (deg) (deg) CG Rl Rollup (L 737. DG Rl Rollup (L Z.5 739.5 Z.5 lB 01-03 Roll Up 742. ls41 " Dl-DJ Roll Low 1. 1'9 737. 1. Dl-03 Up 3s24 742. 742. 737. 737. Emergency
Fan t 763. la70 750. 769. 748. Recirc to Fan R 759, 774. Emergency
Suppl 774. " Oil Fan Supply 774. 0.1 774. 0.1 " BC to Intake 13 0.1 749. 0.1 LoV Leakage Pat lle2 " Hallway Leakage 749. 11511 749. JO Gen Fan Flow Lo /ls7 /738. /l.S ls6 1.5 )1s39 )74Z.
Gen Fan Flow Lo 1s7 738. 738. )1s39
)2-5 Gen Fan Flow Hi ls SS 2. J.s54 )1sJ9 )iits )2-5 Gen Fan Flow Hi lsSS 2. 744.5 \ls39 \742-\2.5 DG Rl Door (Top 4.sl24 2.1667 DG Rl Rollup (U 742. 742. 2.5 DG Rl Rollup (T 4sl83 s 744.5 '" N 744.5 2.5 /==xx I= /x /xxxx:JU<
I= /x=xxx
I= I= I= Pressur >= >= )i!.x }xxxxx >= Preseur >= >= Pressur >= >= )!i.x Pressur >= >= )!k 12cyl P }xxxxx }xxxxx )!!xx 16cyl P >= >= \" \Exhauet Pipe Le \lslll. \t \760.98 \0.01 \lls3 \B \788.01 \0.01 \ Flow Paths -Table 2 Flow Flow Hyd. Inertia Friction Relative Dep Path Diam. Length Length
Rough-Bend T= Flow (ft2) (ft) (ft) (ft) (deg) Dpt Dpt " le-05 NONB NONB NONE 160. 15. le-05 NONB 160. NONE NONB NONE NONB le.+05 NONB le+ OS 5. DEFA NONE 10.7 10.7 NONB 5. NONE NONE 20, 5.5 NONE 1' NONB 10.7 NONB 10.7 DEFA NONE 66.39 NONE 21.3 '" 0, NONE 21.3 lc-05 NONE July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 75 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flo.., Paths -Table 2 !cont.) Flow Flow Hyd. Inertia Friction Relative Lam Cop Path ,., .. Diam.. Length Length Rough-Bend T= Flow (ft2) (ft) (ft) (ft) (deg) Dpt Dpt 120. DEPA NONE " NDNB 120. o. le-OS NONE 0,073 DEPA NONE DEPA NONll JO '* l. '* le-08 NONE l. " NONE 1. s. DEPA NONE N&T NONE 34 6.5 5,5 0. 0. N&T NONE 35 20. 5.5 0. DEPA o. N&T NONE: " 20. 5. 5.5 0. 0. DEPA 0. NONE /=a I= I= I= I= I= /DEPA I= I= I= >= >= )DEPA DEPA >= >= )DEPA DEPA >= >= )DBPA DEPA )ixxxxxxx
>= >= )DBFA DEPA )!i.x >= >= )DEPA DBFA ):X >= >= )DEPA DBFA )!!xx >= >= )DBPA DEPA \44 \10. \5. \41. \ \DBFA \0. \N&1' \NONE Flow Paths -Table 3 Flow ""'* Rev. Crieical Eltit Drop Hcmog. Path Comp. Flow Breakup Flow Coeff. C'oef:t:.
Dpt. Model Coeff. Model Dpt. 0.1 OFF OFF O.l OFF D.1 OFF o. OFF 0.1 OFF o. 0,1 OFF OFF D.1 2.78 OFF OFF 1.5 o. OFF 1.5 OFF 0. OFF OFF 2.78 o. 2.78 o. OFF DFF 16 OFF OFF " 0.1 OFF OFF 2.78 2,78 OFF l. OFF o. OFF OFF July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page BIO ofB156 9 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 76 of 254 (l'N)
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -Table 3 (cont.) Flow Fwd. Rev. Critical Exit Drop Homog. Path Loss Loss Comp, Flow Loss Breakup Flow * Coeff. FF Coeff, FF Opt. Model Coeff. Model Opt. 33 1. 1. OFF OFF 0. OFF OFF J4 2.78 2.78 OFF OFF 0. OFF OFF JS 2.78 2.78 OPF OFF 0. OFF OFF 36 2.78 2.78 OFF OFF 0. OFF OFF I= /xx I= /xx I= I= I= )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )OFF )xx )xx >E: \44 \5.56' \ \5.56 \ \OPP \OPP \0. \OPP \OFP' Flow Paths -Table 4
Reverse Prop Flow Min Min *= Min Min M= Burn With Path H2 02 H20 H2 02 H20 Time Zero P<op Frac Frac Frac Fr'lC Frac Frac Frac
Flow Opt 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 o.os 0.06 0.05 o.ss 0.06 0. 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 o. 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 o.os I 0.55 o.os 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.05 0,55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 I NO I C:OFLOW 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0,05 0.06 0.05 0,55 0.06 0.05 0,06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 I o.55 0,06 0.05 0,55 0.06 0.05 0.55 o.5 I NO 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 12 I 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 13 0,06 o.os 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 I NO I C:OFLOW 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 o.55 o.5 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 .05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 .05 0.55 0.06 0.05 o.55 0.06 I 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 19 I 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.05 .05 I 0 .05 0.55 0.06 I 0.05 I 0.55 I 0.06 0.05 5 o.os 0.06 I 0.05 I 0.55 0.06 0.05 5 0.06 o. 0.55 0.06 0.05 I 0.55 0.5 I NO I C:OFLOW " I 0.06 I 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 .OS 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 I 0.55 o.5 33 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 o.os J4 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 35 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 o.os " 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 o.os 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= >= )i!x. >= \39 \0.06 \0.05 \D.55 \0.06 \0.05 \0.55 \0.5 \NO \COFLOW July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bll ofB156 10 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 77 of 254 m NUMERICAL
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
NAI-2007-004
APPLICATIONS
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Revision 0 :. n 'J rJ:"'l'.f.
"-r*l'l .. ""l.r -... r. r)'.r.it.rrr:r-1:-:
tr Evaluation
Page Bl2 ofB156 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
11 \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1
A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -Table 4. (cont.) Fon.oard Reverse Prop Flow Min Min Min Min With Path Time Prop Frac Frac Fl OW' Opt I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= >= )!ix. >= >= )!!xx >= \44 \0.06 \o.os \O.SS \0.06 \0.05 \0.55 \0.5 \NO \COFLOK The:r:mal
Conductors
Cond Vol Srf Vol Srf Cond s, A. Init. Gq> Description
Opt Opt Typ* (ft2) T. (F) I/X DO (Warm) {Conv) DG (Hot) (Conv) DG Rl B Wall l*B ZoW 2376. DG Rl S Wall .936. 78, DO Rl N Hall .936. DG Rl Ceiling Under Fan Room la!17-1 1Z 1000, 7* Divl Ceiling-762
78, Divl Floor 1'F 10 3800. DG Rl W Wall /3sW /11115-10
/2376. \JsB \lsW \2350. Wall (Tank Raom -DG Rl.) Wall (DG R2 -Hallway) Wall (DO R2 -Other rooms) 2400. Wall (DG R2 -Outside Air) llsl 670. Div2 to 912' 10 15s Div2 to 962' 1's DivJ ta Amh. Jss llsl DivJ to 962' DivJ to 912' 10 3600. 78. '" Ceiling {El 737ft Hallway) 6000. 78. Hallway Floor 10 78. Wall (El 737ft Hallway -Outside Air) '"" ll.sl. Wall (Tank Room -Outside Air) l.lsl 120. 78. Wall {Fan Room -Other Rooms) 1800. Wall (Fan Room -Outside Airl Wall (El 737ft Other Rooms -Outside Air} Wall (El 762ft Other Rooms -Outside Air) 10000. 78. Wall {El 712ft -outside Air) 10000. Fan Roam to Amh. Fan Rm ta 962' Fan Rm to Amb (ceiling)
lZ I= I= I= I= I= I= I= North Side )i!xxxx )!,,. )!,,. );:..,. South Side )i!xxxx )!,,. )!,,. );:..,.
Sida )i!xxxx )!,,. )!,,. );:..,.
Side )i!xxxx )!,,. )!,,. );:..,.
Sida )i!xxxx )!,,. );:..,. North Sida )!,,. )!,,. );:..,. South Side )iixxxx )!,,. )!,,. );:..,. >= )!!xx
Sida )!,,. )!,,. );:..,.
Side )!,,. )ix. );:..,. >= Bottom Side )iixxxx )!xx )ix. );:..,. >= )!ix. North Side )iixxxx )!,,. )!,,. );:..,. )!.xxx >= South Side )!,,. )!,,. );:..,. )!.xxx )!!xx
Side )!,,. )!,,. );:..,. )!.xxx )!!..
Side )!,,. )!,,. );:..,. )!.xxx
Side )!,.,. )ix. );:..,. )!.xxx )!!xx Bottom Side )!,.,. );:..,. )!.xxx >= \47s \lDGOlJA North Sido \17 \1 \ls7-56 \1 \7 \16.25 \78. \X \ July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 78 of 254 [t+J]
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 TheJ;tnal
Conductors (cont.) Cond Vol Srf Vol * Description
A Opt B /=x I= I= I= I= )!!:x South Sida }ix. Eaet Side }ix.
Side }ix.
Side North Side }i!xxxx }ix. South Side )i!xxxx }ix.
Side }ix.
Side }ix. 'I'op Side Bottom Side }ix. 12cyl North Side }i!.xxx }ix. 12cyl South Side }i!.xxx }ix. 12cyl East. Side }i!.xxx }ix. 12cy1 West Side )i!.xxx }ix. 12cyl Top Side }i!.xxx 12cyl Bottoill.
Side }i!.xxx 16cyl North Side }ix. 16cyl south Side }ix. 16cyl East Sida }ix. 16cyl West. Sida }ix. l&'cyl Top Side 16ayl Bottom Side
Air Piping
Air Piping
Air Piping \138 \DG Combuet. Air Piping \le71-B \B \le71-B Thermal ConCluctors
-Radiation
Parameters
Cond Therm. Rael. Emiss. Therm. Rad. Emiss. Side A Side A Side B Side B Scope No No FULL FULL 1'* FULL 21* FULL July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Srf Opt I= }ix. }ix. }ix. }ix.
}ix. }ix. }ix. }ix. }ix. }ix.
}ix. }ix.
}ix. }ix. }ix. )ix. );::.. );::.. );::.. \7 Cond S. A. Type (ft2) /xxxx I= )k )!.xx }!.xx )!.xx \8 \UB.6 NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B13 ofB156 12 Init. Grp T. (F) l/X * I= I= }!x.xx }xxxx }!x.xx }xxxx }!x.xx }xxxx }!x.xx }xxxx }!x.xx }xxxx }!x.xx }xxxx }xxxx }!x.xx }xxxx }!x.xx }xxxx }!x.xx }=x }!x.xx }xxxx }!x.xx }=x }!x.xx }=x }!x.xx }=x }!x.xx }xxxx }!x.xx }=x }!x.xx }=x )=x )!x.xx )=x )!x.xx )=x )!x.xx )=x )ixxxx )ixxxx )ixxxx \78. \I \4 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 79 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:16 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductors
-Radiation
l?arameters (cont,) Cond Therm. Rad. Emiss. Therm. Rad. Emiss. * Side A Side A Side B Side B Scope " No No FOLL " No No FULL I= /xxxxxxx /xxxxxxx I= I= )xxxxxxx >= )=..,. >= )xxx=xx )=..,. )!!!x )xxxxxxx >= )=..,. >= >= )=..,. >= )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx >= )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )iixx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx >= )=..,. >= )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxx=xx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx >= )=..,. >= >= )=..,. >= >= )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx >= )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. >= )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx >= )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx >= )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )!!:x )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )!!,.,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. }xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=..,. )xxxxxxx >= )=..,. \73s \No \ \No \ \FOLL Thermal Conductors
-Ice Parameters
Side A. Side B Node Arca Joo Cond. Spacing Thick. Thick. (in) Nodes Opt.ion (in) Porosity (in) Porosity July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B14 ofB156 13 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 80 of 254 (N'J)
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductors
-Ice Parameters (cont.) -------Side A -----------Side B ----Node Area Ice Ice Cond. Spacing Max FF Thick. Ice Area Thick. Ice Area * (in) Nodea Option (in) Porosity FF (in) Porosity FF " NONE NONE " NONE NONE lOs NONE NONE 11* NONE NONE 12' NONE NONE lJ* NONE NONE Us NONE NONE lSs NONB NONE 16s NONE NONE 17s NONE NONE l" NONE NONE 19s NONE NONE '" NONE NONE 21s NONE NONE 22 NONE NONE 2J NONE NONE " NONE NONE 25 NONE NONE 26 NONE NONE 27 NONE NONE 28 NONE NONE " NONE NONE 30 NONE NONE /xxxx /xxxxxxx I= Ix= /NONE I= /xxxx /NONE I= /xxxx )xxxxxxx >= )x= )NO!!B NONE )xx=x )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )xx= >= )xxxxxx )NONE NO!!B >= )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )x=x )= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )i!!x )xxxxxxx >= >= )NO!!B NONE )xx=x )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )=xx )xxxxx )x= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE RONN )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )=x )NONE NONE )=xx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )x=x )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )=xx )xxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )!!xx )xx= )xxxxx )x= )xxxxxxxx )xxxx
>= )xxxx )xx= )xxxxx )xxxxxx )Woel )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE "&deg;"" )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx >= )NONE RONN )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )!ix. )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx
>= )xxxx )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )!!,,,. )xx= )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NO!!B )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )"ONE NONE >= )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xx= )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )x= )NONE NONE }xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )i!:x )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )x= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE }xxxxxxxx )xxxx )!!:x )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )!i:x )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )HONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )=xx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx }xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )!!:x )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx }!!!x )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx \67e \ \ \ \NONE \ \ \NONE \ \ July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B15 ofB156 14 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 81 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductors
-Ice Parameters (cont..) -------Side A -----------Side B Node ., .. Ice Ice Cond. Spacing M= FF Thick, Ice >rea Thick. Ice * (in) Nodes Option (in) Porosity FF (in) Poro:Jity
'"""" I= I= I= /NONB I= '"""" /NONB I= }xxxxxxx >= >= }NONE NONB >= }xxxx }NONE NONE >= }xx= }xxxxx }xxxxxx }NONE NONE >= }xxxx }NONB NONB >= }xx= >= >= >= }xxxx
>= }xxxxxxx >= }xxxxxx
>= }xxxx }NONB NONE >= >= >= >= }NONE NONB }xxxxxxxx
}xxxx }NONE NONB >= \7Ja \ \ \ \NONE \ \ \NONE \ Thermal Conductor
Types Type Thick. o.o. Heat Description (in) (in) Regions (Btu/ft.J-:i)
Ceiling/Floor
Internal Hall 12. 20 External Hall o. o. 10 ' Internal Block WALL 11.625 '"""" /xxxxxxx '"""" '"""""""'
I= '""""""" /=xxxxxx
>= }!xx.
>= ,, \24* Piping \1"1JBB \0.375 \24-\13 \0. Forcing Function Tal:ilei:i
FF# Description
Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Points Constant lT DG Harm Temp Time (eec:) Temperatur
00 Hot Temp Time (sec) Temperatur
Model Gen, Heat Time (sec) Heat Rate 4S 4T Benchmark
Heat Time (aec) Benchmark
Benchmark
EXhau Time (sec) Benchmark
GT Benchlllark
Inlet Time (Bee) Temperatur
43 Benchmark
Loe l Time (sec) Tcmpcratur
Benchmark
Loe 2 Time (sec) Te.mperatur " OT Benchmark
Loe J Time (sec) Tcmpcratur
lOT Benchmark
Loe 4 Time (sec) Te.mpe.ratur
15 I= \lll' \Outdoor Air l'eill. \l'illle lsocl \l'emperatur
\2 Conductor
Surface Options -Table 1 Opt Description
1 Wall 2 Ceiling Side J Floor Side '1 OG Warm Temper 5 00 Hot Temperat '"""" for DG }!xx.
,, \DG Intake HTC Trana fer Opt.ion Direct Direct Direct Sp Temp Sp Temp Sp Conv \Sp Conv Cnd/ Sp Nominal Cnd Value Opt Opt /4.9 I= I= I= >= }xxxx >= >= }!! >= }!xx \4.752 \ \ ---->rea FF '"""" }xxzx }xxxx }xxxx }xxxx }xxxx \ FF '"""" }xxxx }xxxx \ Nat Opt July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Opt }xx= NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B16 ofB156 15 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 82 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Conductor
Surface Options -Table 2 surf Min Max Convection
Condensation
Rad to Steam Opt Phase Liq Liq Bulk Temp Bulk Temp Emissivity
# Opt Fr act Fract Model FF Model FF Dry Wet 1 VAP Tg-Tf Tb-Tw DEFAULT DEFAULT 2 VAP Tg-Tf Tb-Tw DEFAULT DEFAULT 3 VAP Tg-Tf Tb-Tw DEFAULT DEFAULT 4 5 6 VAP Tg-Tw 0. 0. /=xx I= /><= I= /xxxxxxx />=< '"""""""'
/xxx /DBFAOLT /DEFAULT }k >= >= }xxx }xxx )DBP'AO'L'l'
DBFAOLT )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xxxxx >= >= }xxxxxxx }xxx }xxxxxxx >= )DBFAOLT )DEFAULT \9 \VAP \ \ \'l'g-'l'w \ \ \ \0. \o. Conductor
Surface Options -Table 3 Surf Char. Nam Minimum Char.
Opt Length Vel Vel Conv HTC Height Length # (ft) (ft/s) FF (B/h-f2-F) (ft) (ft)
1 DEFAULT DEFAULT
DEFAULT 2 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT 3 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT 4 DEFAULT DEFAULT 5 DEFAULT DEFAULT 6 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT I= /xxxxxx I= /DEFAULT ''&deg;""""" /=xx }k }xxxxxx }xxxxxx >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >== >== }k }xxxxxx }xxxxxx }xxx )DEFAULT }=xx \9 \ \ \ \DEFAULT \DEFAULT \DBPAtJ'LT
Conductor
Surface Options -Table 4 Surf Total Peak Initial BD Post-BO Post-BD Opt Const Heat Time Exp Value Exp Exp Direct # CT (Btu) (sec) XT (B/h-f2-F)
yt xt FF 1 2 3 4 5 6 /xxxxxx I= I= /xxxxxx I= /xxxxxx '""""""" '"""""""'
}k }xxxxxx >= >= }xxxxxx >= }xxxxxx >= >= }xxxxxx }xxxxxx >= }xxxxxx }=xx \9 \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ Control Variables
CV Fune. Initial Coeff. Coeff. # Description
Form Value G ao Min lC Div 1 DG Heat Load sum 0. 1. 0. -le+32 2C Div 1 CG Heat Absorption
0. -1. 0. -1e+32 3C Bounding Panel T_bulk_avg
0. 1. 0. -1e+32 4C Bounding Panel T_max 0. 1. 0. -le+32 SC Door T_bulk_avg
@ Operator Act if 0. 1. 0. -le+32 6C Door T_max @ Operator Action if 0. 1. 0. -le+32 7C Panel 1PL12JA [Vole] 0. 1. 0. -le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Upd. Int. Max Mult. le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B 17 ofB156 16 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 83 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 9C 10C 11C 12C 13C l4C lSC 16C l8C 1'C 20C 22C 23C 24C 25C 26C 27C 29C 30C 31C 32C 33C 34C 35C 36C 37C 38C 3'C 40C /x=x )!!ix )!!ix )iiix )i!ix )i!ix )!iix \63C Description
Panel 1PL12JA [Temv] Panel 1PL12JA (Vole] [Temv] Panel 1PL12JA T_bulk_avg
Panel lPL92JA/lPL93JA
[Vole] Panel 1PL92JA/1PL93JA
[Temv] Panel 1PL92JA/1PL93JA
[Vole] [T Panel 1PL92Ja/1PL93JA
T_bulk_a Panel lDGOlJA [Vole] Panel lDGOlJA [Temv] Panel lDGOlJA [Vole] [Temv) Panel lDGOlJA T_bulk_avg
Panel 1DG06SA [Vole] Panel 1DG06SA [Temv] Panel lDG06SA [Vole] [Temv] Panel 1DG06SA T_bulk_avg
Panel lDGOlKA l2cyl [Vole] Panel lDGOlKA l2cyl [Temv] Panel lDGOlKA 12eyl [Vole] [Tem Panel lDGOlKA 12eyl T_bulk_avg
Panel lDGOlKA 16eyl [Vole] Panel lDGOlKA 16eyl [Temv] Panel lDGOlKA 16eyl [Vole) [Tem Panel lDGOlKA 16eyl T_bulk_avg
Rollup Door [Vole] Rollup Door [Temv] Rollup Door [Vole] [Temv) Rollup Door T_bulk_avg
Personnel
Door [Vole] Personnel
Door [Temv] Personnel
Door [Vole] [Temv] Personnel
Door T_bulk_avg
Max Door Temperature
Max Door T_bulk_avg
/xxxxxxx Air Temperature
Heat '!'ransfer
Heat Transfer + Dela
That .. :z
+ Vy**2 + Vz**:z)
**(2/3)] ** (1/4)
(1/2) *Pr** (1/3) / (l+ (0
** (5/B)
** (5/B)] ** (4/5)
(1/2)*Pr**(l/3)/
[1+ (0 \Local Nu Control Variables (cont.) Fune. sump rod div sump rod div sump rod div sum prod div .sump rod div sump rod div sump rod div sump rod div /xxxxxxx \own Initial Value 0. 0. 0. o. 0. 0. o. 0. 0. o. o. 0. 0. o. 0. o. 0. o. 0. o. 0. o. 0. 0. o. o. 0. 0. /xxxxxxx \0. Coeff. l. l. l. l. 1. l. 1. 1. l. 1. l. l. l. l. l. 1. l. l. l. l. l. l. l. l. l. l. 1. 1. 1. l. /xxxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx
)ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx \1. Coeff. aO Min 0. -le+32 o. -le+32 o, -le+32 o, -le+32 0. -le+32 0. -le+32 o. -1e+32 0. -le+32 o. -le+32 0. -le+32 0. -le+32 -1e+32 O. -le+32 o, -le+32 o. -le+32 O. -le+32 0. -le+32 o. -le+32 O. -le+32 O. -le+32 a. -le+32 O. -le+32 o. -le+32 O. -le+32 a. -le+32 a. -le+32 O. -le+32 O. -le+J2 0. -le+32 0. -le+32 a. -le+32 o. 0. /xxxxxxx -le+32 /xxxxxx
)ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx \0.3
 
\-le.+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32
le+32 le+32
le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32
le+32 le+32
le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 1e+32 le+32 /xxxxxx \le+32 NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl8 ofB156 Upd. Int. Mult. '"""""""'
\0. 0. 0. 0. 0. o. o. 0. 0. o. o. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. o. 0. o. 17 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 84 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Turbulence
Parameters
1----Liquid --1 1----Vapor --1 Vol Molec. Turb. Mix.L. PrT ScT Mix.L PrT ScT Phase # Diff. Model (ft) No. No. (ft) No. No. Option ls NO NONE 0. 0. 0. 0. 2s NO NONE 0. 0. 0. 0. VAPOR 3s NO NONE 0. 0. 0. 0. VAPOR 4s NO NONE 0. 0. 0. 0. 5 NO NONE 0. 0. 0. 0. VAPOR 6 NO NONE 0. 0. 0. 0. VAPOR 7 NO NONE 0. 0. 0. 0. VAPOR 8 NO NONE 0. 0. 0. 0. VAPOR 9 NO NONE 0. 0. 0. 0. VAPOR 10 NO NONE 0. 0. 0. 0. VAPOR lls NO NONE 0. 0. 0. 0. 12 NO NONE 0. 0. 0. 0. VAPOR 13 NO NONE 1. 1. 1. 1. VAPOR /xxxxx /xxxxx /xxxxxxx /xxxxxx /xxxxxx /xxxxxx I= /xxxxxx /xxxxxx /xxxxxx )i!x.x )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )i!x.x )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )i!xxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx \20 \NO \NONB \ \1. \1. \ \L \1. \VAPOR Cell Blockages
-Table 1 Volume ls Blockage No. Description
Type 1 Day Tank Room BLK B I N /xxxxx /xxxxxxx /x /x /x >ni )ixxxx >ni )!xx.,. >ni >ni )!xxxx >ni >= 12cyl )i \8 \1DG01KA 16cyl \BLK \B \I \N Cell Blockages
-Table 2 Volume ls Blockage Coordinates
& Dimensions (ft) No. Xl Yl Zl X2 Y2 Z2 X3 Y3 Z3 1 0. 0. 0. 10. 10. 10. I= /xxxxxx /xxxxxx /xxxxxx /xxxxxx /xxxxxx /xxxxxx /xxxxxx /xxxxxx /xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )ixxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )!xx.,. )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )!xxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx >= >= >= \B \2!L479 \11.583 \2 .458 \30 .479 \14. \8.292 \ \ \ July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT L /xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )x= \ Angle (Deg) /xxxxxx )xxxxxx
)xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )x= \ Curb Height NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl9 ofB156 0. /xxxxxx \0. 18 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 85 of 254 ( r+J)
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 X-Direction
Cell Face Variations
Volume ls Cell Blockage Area Hyd. Dia. Loss Drop De-ent. No. No. Porosity FF (ft) Coeff. FF Factor def On 1. 1000000. 0. o. lsl 1 0. le-06 0. 0. lsS 1 1. 260. 0. 0. lsl 7 1 0. le-06 0. 0. ls21 1 1. 260. 0. 0. ls33 1 0. le-06 0. 0. ls37 1 1. 260. o. 0. ls49 1 0. le-06 0. 0. ls53 1 1. 260. o. 0. ls65 1 1. 20. o. 0. />ae<Z.XXX
I= I= I= I= /xx I XXIU'X >= ) .. >= ) .. >= ) .. >= ) .. )O* x XXX'C >= ) .. >= ) .. cccccc xxx >= ) .. >= ) .. )0* xxxxxx >= ) .. )0-xxxxxxxxxxxx )ix...... ) .... ) ..
\1921 ,, \l. \ \6'81.822
\0. \ \0. Z-Direction
Cell Face Variations
Volume ls Cell Blockage Area Hyd. Dia. Loss Drop De-ent . curb Ht No. No. Porosity FF (ft) Coeff. FF Factor (ft) def On 1. 1000000. 0. o. lsl 1 0. le-06 0. 0. ls2 1 1. 36. 0. o. lsS 1 1. 260. 0. 0. lsl7 l 0. le-06 0. 0. lsl8 l 1. 36. 0. 0. ls21 l 1. 260. 0. o. ls33 1 0. le-06 0. 0. ls34 1 1. 36. 0. 0. ls37 1 1. 260. 0. 0. ls49 1 0. le-06 0. 0. lsSO l 1. 36. o. 0. ls53 1 1. 260. 0. 0. /=xxx /=xxx /=xxxx /xxxx /xxxxxxxxx
I= /xx /xxxxxxxxxxxx
/xxxxxxxx >= ) ..
......... ) .... ) .. ) .... ) ..
......... >= ) .. )!;. ......... >= ) .. >= ) .. )ix......
>= ) .. )0* xxxxxxxx >= ) .. .... )ix......
>= ) ..
......... >= ) .. )!;. xxx )ix...... ) .... ) .. ) .... ) .. )O* ..... )ix......
>= ) .. )ix...... ) .... ) .. )0-....... )ix......
>= ) .. )o* )ix...... ) .... ) ..
xx \la43 \7 \l. \ \158.88 \0. \ \0. \0. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT o. 0. o. 0. 0. o. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B20 ofB156 19 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 86 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Z-Direction
Cell Pace Variations (cent.) Cell I= \ls39 Cell No, .. , lol 152 155 lsl7 lslB ls21 lsJJ lsl4 ls37 ls49 la SO 1953 ls65 I=
\la39 Blockage )!xxxxxx )!xxxxxx \B Porosity /xxxxxxxx )ixxxxxxx )ixxxxxxx
\1. Volume Variations
Volume ls Blockage Volume No. Porosity On l 1 1
1 l l l l l l l 1 1 I= /xxxxxxxx )ixxxxxxx
)!.x.x.x )ixxxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxxx )ixxxxxxx )ixxxxxxx )ixxxxxxx
)!xxxxxx )ixxxxxxx
\B \1. l. 0. l. l. 0. l. l. 0. l. l. 0. l. 1. l. /xxxx )xxxx )xxxx \ FF /xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx
)xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx \ Volume ls Hyr;i.. Dia. (ft) I= \596,978 Byd. Dia. (ft) 1000000. le-06 "* 260, le-06 "* 260. le-06 "* 260. le-06 "* 260. 20, I=
\571.38501
Comluct:or
Surface Options -Natural Convect;icm
Variables
surf Op< C'oeff. /xxxxxxxx \0. Drop De-ent. /:ex /xxXTXT'TTY7T'{.
\ \O. curb Ht !ft) /xxxxxxxx \0. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B21 ofB156 20 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 87 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1
A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Conductor
Surface Options -Natural Convection
Variables (co htc " (k/l) * (A + e*Gr**C:*Pr**D)
surf Opt Conv Var A Conv Var B Ccmv Var c Norn. Norn. ' 0. 0.5.9 0.25 /xxxx /xxxxxxx /xxxxx /xxxxxxx /xxxxx I= )k }xxxxx )xxxxx )!xxx )xxxxx )xxxxx \* \0. \0,53 \ \0 .25 conductor
surface Options -Forced Convection
Variables
htc " (k/ll . IA + B*Re**C*Pr**D)
Surf Opt Conv Var A Conv Var B Conv Var C Norn. FF 0.8 0.037 0.037 0.8 ' 0. 0.023 0.8 /xxxx /xxxxxxx /xxxxx I= /xxxxx I= )k )xxxxx )!xxx )xxxxx )xxxxx \* \0. \ \0.023 \0.8 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File, Thermal Conductor
Type Panel Steel FF /xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx /xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx \ Mat. Bdry. (in) Thick {inl Sub* Heat Region regs. Factor 0,00648 0.009'72 0.01296 o. 0.02268 0.0677 0. 0,01424 0.10104 0.11528 0.00648 10 0.121'76 0.00324 Following
table in t:he Compare File but not in the current: File. Function llT Outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 0. I I 1e+06 I Conv Var D Norn. 0.25 /xxxxxxx /xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx \0,25 \ Conv Var D Norn. 0.333
0.333 0.4 I= /xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx \0.4 \ July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAl-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B22 ofB156 21 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 88 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 41C Outdoor Air Temperature:
G=l.O a0=0. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
tfunc Y=G* interp (alXl, tableX2) Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value Etime I cM I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 Table DCllT 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 42C DG Intake Heat Transfer:
G=l.O a0=0. min:::i-l.e32
max=l.e32
sum Y::::G* (aO+a1Xl+a2X2+
*** +anXn) Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value ii Cond_grp_heat
(1) I cC70sl I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Thermal Conductor
Type 24" Piping Mat. Bdry. Thick Sub-Heat Region (in) (in)
regs. Factor 0. 0. 00324 0. 0.00324 0. 00648 0. 0.00972 0. 01296 0. 0.02268 0.02592. 0. 0. 0486 0. 05184 0. 0 .10044 0. 06864 0. 0 .16908 0. 06864 0. 0. 23772 0. 04434 0. 0. 28206 0. 04434 0. 10 0. 3264 0. 02592 0. 11 0.35232 0.01296 0. 12 0 .36528 0.00648 0. 13 0.37176 0. 00324 0. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Thermal Conductor
Type 36" Piping Mat. Bdry. Thick Sub-Heat Region (in) (in)
regs. Factor 0. 0. 00324 0. 0.00324 0.00648 0. 0.00972 0. 01296 0. 0. 02268 0. 02592 0. 0.0486 0. 05184 0. 0 .10044 o. 06864 0. 0 .16908 0. 06864 0. o. 23772 0. 04434 0. 0.28206 0. 04434 0. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B23 ofB156 22 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 89 of 254 m N UMERICAL PPLICATIONS
A nn*.*rJ:"'r
*-1 i"'l-r*n *41,r *;.r.
w Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparis I Current File: on: Double entries indicate differences.
C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG Benchmark.GTH
e: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
0:59:17 \Compare Fil Jul/24/2017
2 GOTHIC Versi on 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Region 10 11 " lJ Tho rmal Conductor
'l'YPe (cont.) Mat 36" Piping Bdry. (in) o.3652B Thick Sub* (in) regs. Factor 0. Following
tab le in the Compare File but not in the Current File. D # 1 2 Function Components
Control Variable 44C G Intake That: G=l.O aO=O. min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
Gothic_s Name sum YcG* (aO+alXl+a2X2+, .. +arutn) Cvval (O) Cvval (0) variable location Coef. cv41C 1. cv43C O. 21783386 Following
tab le in the Compare File but not in the Current File. # 1 2 3 Following
# 1 2 Following
# 1 Function Components
Control Variable soc Local Rho*V*D: G=l.O aO:::O. min:::-l.e32
max=l.e32
tab tab mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *aruCn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. Name location Rm cV@ 1. CVVal (0) cv49C 1. Dhyd cV@ 1. le in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 45C Local Vx**2: G=l.O aO=O. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anXn), aO unused Gothic_s Name Uccxv Uccxv Variable location cV@ cV@ Coef. 1. 1. le in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 46C Local Vy**2: G=l.O aO=O. min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anXn) , aO unused Gothic_s Name Uccyv Variable location cV@ Coef. 1. Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 Max value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B24 ofB156 23 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 90 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function Components (cont.) Control Variable 46C Local Vy**2: G=l.O aOaO. min,,-l.e32
rnax=l.el2
mult Y*G*(a1Xl*a2X2*
*** *anxnJ, ao unused Gothic:_s
Variable location Uccyv I Coef. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. # Function Components
Control Variable 4 7C Local Vz**2: G=l. O aO=O. min=-1. e32 maxc:l. e32 mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anXn), ao unused Gothic_s Name Ucczv Ucczv Variable location cV@ cV Coef. a 1.
1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 4BC Local (Vx**2 + Vy**2 + Vz**2): G=l.O aO=O. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
Yc:G* (aO+alXl+a2X2+
... +anJCn) Gothic_ " Variable Coef. Name location CVVal (0) cv4SC 1. CVVal (0) cv46C 1. CVVal (O) cv47C 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 49C Local IVI' G::ol a0=.5 min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
"'a2X2 or G* (alXl) "'ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a 11 Cvval(O) I cv4BC I 1. I Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable SlC Local Re: G=l.O aO=O. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
div Y=G* (aO+a2X2)
/ (alXl) Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Visv I cV I 1.1 CVVal (O) cvSOC 1. Min. Value Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 I I I Value Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B25 ofB156 24 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 91 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG Benchmark.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components , Control Variable 52C Local cp*mu: G=l.O aO=O. min=-l.e32
max::::il.e32
mult Y::::G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
*** *anXn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value I Cpv I cV I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 Viscv cV@ 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 53C Local Pr: G=l.O aO=O. min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
div Yc:G* (aO+a2X2)
I (alXl) Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value I Condv I cV@ I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 CVVal (O) cv52C 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 54C Re**l/2: G=l.O aD=O.S min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl) "a2X2 or G* (alXl) "ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value 11 Cvval (0) I cvSlC I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable SSC Pr**l/3: G=l.O a0,,,0.333
min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl) "a2x2 or G* (alXl) "ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value 11 Cvval (O) I cvS3C I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 56C O. 62*Re** (1/2) *Pr** (1/3) : G=O. 62 ao.,o. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anXn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value CVVal (0) I cvS4C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 CVVal (0) cvSSC 1. -le+32 le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B26 ofB156 25 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 92 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable S?C (0.4/Pr)**(2/3)'
G::oO. 54288 aO=-. 667 min=-1. e32 max=il. e32 exp Y=G* (aO+alXl) "a2X2 or G* (alXl) "'aa Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value 11 CVVal (0) I cv53C I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Fwlction Components
Control Variable SBC [l+(0.4/Pr)**(2/3)]**(1/4):
G=l.0 aO=l min=-1.e32
max=l .e32 exp Y=G* (aO+alXl) "a2X2 or G* (alXl) ""ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value CVVal (0) I cv57C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 o_ne cM 0 .25 -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 60C (Re/282000)
** (S/8)' G=.625 a0=0.000392
min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
"'a2X2 or G* (alXl) "'ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value
11 Cvval (0) I cvSlC I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 61C [1+ (Re/282000)
** (5/8)] ** (4/5) : G=l. o aO=l min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
"'a2X2 or G* (alXl) '"'ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value Cvval (0) I cv60C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 One CM 0.8 -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 62C o. 62*Re** (1/2) *Pr** (1/3) / [l+ (0 .4/Pr) ** (2/3) J ** (1/4) * [l+ (Re/282000)
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anXn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value Cvval (0) I cv59C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 CVVal (0) cv61C 1. -le+32 le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B27 ofB156 26 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 93 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG Benchmark.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:17 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 59C 0. 62*Re** (1/2) *pr** (1/3) I [l+ (0 .4/Pr) ** (2/3)] ** (1/4) ' G=l. 0 aO=O. m div Y=G* (aO+a2X2)
I (alXl) Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Cvval (O) I cvSBC I 1. I Cvval (0) cv56C 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 63C Local Nu: G=l.0 a0=0 .3 min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
sum Y=G* (aO+alX1+a2X2+
..* +anXn) Gothic s Variable Coef. -# Name location a 11 Cvval (0) I cv62C I 1. I Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 43C DG Intake Heat Transfer+
Delay: G:::l.O a0:::-5 min:::-l.e32
max=l.e32
if (a1Xl+a0<0
alXl+aO:::O
alXl+aO>O)
Y=Ga2X2 Y:::Ga3X3
Y=Ga4X4 Gothic_ s Variable Coef. Name location a 1 Btime cM 1. One cM 0. One CM 0. Cvval (0) cv42C 1. Min. Max Value Value -le+32 I le+32 -le+32 le+32 Min. Max Value Value -le+32 I le+32 Min. Max Value Value -le+32 le+32 -le+32 le+32 -le+32 le+32 -le+32 le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAl-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B28 ofB156 27 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 94 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:19 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Volume Initial Conditions
Total Vapor Liquid Relative Liquid Liq. Vapor Liquid Vol Pressure Temp. Temp. Humidity Volume Comp. Tracer Tracer
# (psia) (F) (F) (%) Fract. Set Set Set def 14.3 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE ls 14 .3 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 2s 14. 30335 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 3s 14. 31195 130. 130. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 4* 14.28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 5 14 .3 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE
NONE 6 14. 28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE
7 14 .3 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 8 14. 31195 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE
9 14.28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 10 14. 28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE lls 14 .3 /96. /'J6. /40. 0. NONE NONE NONE )"* )"* )''* 12 14 .3 ... ... 40 * 0. NONE NONE NONE \90. \90. \50. 13 14.28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE Graphs .. Graph Curve Number # Title 1 2 3 4 5 0 M&E Imbalance
EM EE 1 Benchmark
Heat Rate Comparison
cvlC DC4T 2 Benchmark
Exhaust/ /Inlet Tempe TVlslOS DCST TV12 DC6T 3 Div 1 DG Room Upper SubVolume
TVlsl05 TVlsl06 TV1sl07 TV1s102 TVlsl03 4 Div 1 DG Room Doors to Hall TV1s41 TVls42 TVls43 TV1s44 5 Div 1 to Hallway Pressure PR1s44 PR4s124 PR12 PR9 PRlD 6 DG Room Temeprature
TVls39 TVlsB TVlsll TV1s105 7 Fan Room and Outside Air Tempe TV7 TV11s2 TV12 8 Fan Flow Rate LV7L LV6L 9 24hr Benchmark
T TVlslOS DCST 10 24hr Benchmark
Heat cvlC DC4T 11 DG Room T v Benchmark
1 TVls47 /TV'ls40 DC7T DC8T \TVlsl9 12 DG Room T v Benchmark
2 TV1s35 DC9T DClOT TVls37 13 Hallway, 762'. & 712' TV4sl24 TV9 TVlO 14 Wall Temperature
for the Small TA3s2 15 Atmospheric
Pressure PRllsl PR1ls2 PR1ls3 16 Atmospheric
BC Flow Rates FVlO FVll 17 Recirculation
Mass Flow FV23 FV24 18 Leakage Flow Rate FV28 FV29 19 Hallway Door Flow Rates FV15 FV14 FV16 FV17 20 Relative Hurni di ty Above the Ai RRlsBS RRls86 RR1s87 21 Temperature
Above the Air Comp TVls85 TVlsB6 TVlsB7 22 Divl DG Panel Temperatures
TV1s43 TV1s40 TV1s39 TVlsS TV1s37 23 Components
of Averages TVlsS TVlsB TVlsll TVls40 TV1s43 24 Panel 1PL12JA Temperatures
TV1s14 TVlslS TV1s30 TVls31 I 25 Panel 1PL12JA Temperatures
TVls46 TVls47 TVls62
TV1s63 )TVH \'l'Vl4 26 Panels 1PL92JA/1PL93JA
Tempera TV1s12 I I \TVlS \'l'V16 27 Panel lDGOlJA Temperatures
TV1s7 TVlsB TVls23 TVls24 I 28 Panel lDGOlJA Temperatures
TVls39 TV1s40 TV1s55 TV1s56 )TV17 29 Panel 1DG06SA Temperatures
TVlsS TV1s6 TV1s21 TV1s22 )TV17 30 Panel lDGOlKA 12cyl Temperatur
TVlsll TVls27 TV1s43 TV1s59 )TV18 31 Panel lDGOlKA 16cyl Temperatur
TV1s7 TVls23 TVls39 TVlsSS )TV19 \TV20 32 Panel Bulk Average Temperature
cvlOC cv14C cvlBC 33 Panel Bulk Average Temperature cv22C cv26C
cv30C 34 Division 1 Room Door DPs DP14 DP15 DP34 35 Division 1 Room Rollup Door DP DP16 DP17 DP35 DP36 36 Div 1 DG Heat Absorption
cv2C July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT I NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B29 ofB156 28 curve Ops \L2*TV15 (1PL93J /Ll*cvlOC
(1PL12 \Ll-cvlOC (lPLla Ll 11 cv22C (1DG06 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 95 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:19 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Fluid Boundary Conditions
-Table 1 Press. Temp. Flow s BC# Description (psia) FF (F) FF (lbrn/s) FF p lP Outside Air 14 .3 ,,. I N 2F Outside Air 14. 266 )11 10000 N \1 \11 3P Emergency
Suppl 14 .3 72 N 4P Make-up Supply 14 .3 78 N Fluid Boundary Conditions
-Table 2 Liq. V. Stm. v. Drop D. Drop Drop BC# Frac. FF Frac. FF (in) FF GSD Frac. lP /840 NONE 1. 0. )0.024 2F B40 NONE 1. 0. \0,024 3P H25 NONE 1. 0. 4P H25 NONE 1. 0. Volumetric
Fan -Table 2 Vol Flow Flow Fan Flow Rate Rate Option (CFM) FF lQ Time 3020. 2Q Time 3020. 3Q Time 77567. 4Q Time 4250. SQ Time 4250. 6Q Time 4250. 7Q Time 4250. SQ Time /1510. \2800. Time DT DT DT Dorn Min Max Ratio 0 .001 0.1 le+ OB 0 .001 /1.S 1. )'** o. 001 l.5 1. o. 001 )U 1. \0.5 Run Options Option Restart Option Start Time (sec) Parallel Processes
Preprocessor
Multithreading
Revaporization
Fraction Maximum Mist Density (lbm/ft3)
Drop Diam. From Mist (in) Minimum HT Coeff. (8/h-ft2-F)
Reference
Pressure (psia) Heat Option Time Time Time Time
Time Time Time Time End Time 5. 100. 1000. 86400. Heat Heat Rate Rate (Btu/s) FF 0. 0. 0. 0. o. o. 0. 0. Time Domain Data Print Graph Int Int 1. /60. 10.
\10. 60. 60. /60. 3600. \3600. Setting /1 \J NONE 0. 0 YES DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT 0 .0 IGNORE Cpld FF BC# Disch Vol ls86 lls3 ls70 ls6 ls8 ls54 ls56 ln Gas Error Relax T DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT J ON OFF Elev. 0 Trip Trip (ft) N 749. N 10 800. N 749. N 749. Flow Heat Outlet Frac. FF (Btu/s) FF Quality DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT Dump Ph Chng L Flow Int T Scale Shutoff 0. DEFAULT DEFAULT 0. DEFAULT DEFAULT 0. DEFAULT DEFAULT 0. DEFAULT DEFAULT July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT FF NAl-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B30 ofB156 29 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 96 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7 .GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:19 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Run Options (cont.) Option Maximum Pressure (psia) Forced Ent. Drop Diam. (in) Vapor Phase Head correction
Kinetic Energy Vapor Phase Liquid Phase Drop Phase Poree Equilibrium
Drop-Liq.
Conversion
QA Logging Debug Output Level Debug Starting Time Step Debug Time Step Frequency
Restart Dump on CPD Interval (sec) Pressure Initialization
Iteration
Pressure Initialization
Convergenc
Solver Command Line Options Fwlction 3T Model Gen. Heat Rate Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. var.: Heat Rate (BTU//sec)
Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 0. 0. 4. 9 5. /0.25 9. 9 )0.18 10. 0.59 23 .9 )0.43 24. 1.42 39 .9 )1.03 40. 2.44 119. 9 )1.77 120. 7.39 899 .9
900. 1199. 9 )40.89 1200. 72.37 4919. 9 4920.
7199. 9 7200.
14399.9
14400. 21600. )104.15 86400. 152.24 \110.68 Setting DEFAULT INCLUDE IGNORE INCLUDE INCLUDE INCLUDE IGNORE INCLUDE OFF 3600. 1.0e-6 Dep. Var. /0.2 )0.15 0.49 )0.36 1.41 )1.02 2.36 )1.71 7.3
)40.31 70,14
)102.96' 152.24 \110.6'8 Control Volume Parameters
Vol Vol Elev Ht Hyd. D. Description (ft3) (ft) (ft) (ft) ls DG Room (Div. 1 82470. 737. 24. 24. 2s DG Room (Div. 2 54300. 737. 24. 24. 3s DG Room (Div. 3 64300. 737. 24. 24. 4s Hallway 143900. 737. 24. 24. Day Tank Room 1300. 737. 10. 10. Oil Tank Room 14000. 712. 24. 24. Make up Air Sup 10000. 762. 24. 24. Rest of El 737' 247000. 737. 24. 24. Rest of El 762' 480000. 762. 24. 24. 10 712' El 480000. 712. 24. 24. lls Outside Air le+07 737. 74. 20. 12 Fan Room 23750. 762. 24. 24. 13 Interposing
Int 1000. 762. 24. 24. )i!.,. )Llmx \15 \1PL93JA \0.787 \739.917 \1.354 \0.463 L/V IA SA Min Film (ft2) FF (ft) DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT /DBFAlJLT /DBFAlJLT )DBFAULT DEFAULT )DBFAULT DBFAtJLT \DBFAULT \DBFAULT July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Min Film FF \ NAl-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B31 ofB156 30 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 97 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-064_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:19 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Control Volume Parameters (cont.) Vol Vol Elev Ht Hyd. D. L/V IA SA Min Film Min Film * Description (ft3) (ft) (ft) (ft) (ft2) FF (ft) FF l=x I'&deg;"""&deg;"'
I= I'&deg;"""&deg;"' I"'&deg;""""'
/DEFAULT l=x /DEFAULT I'&deg;"""&deg;"' )i!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xxxx )DBFAULT DBFAUL:r )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xxxx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )!!xx >== )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xxxx )DEFAULT DBI!' AULT )i!x. )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xxxx )DEFAULT DBFAULT '" \lDGOlltA
16cyl \9.868 \733 .458 \5.BJJ \D.883 \DBFA'tl'LT
\ \DBFAULT \ Control Volume Options Vol S Wave Pool HMT Pool Pool Pres. Pool Op. "" Bu= ICIP * Damper Mult Opt Correction
FF Tracking Opt Drag lo 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON " 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONH ON " 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON " 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON s 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON 6 l. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON ' 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON ' 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON ' 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON 10 l. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON ll* 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON 12 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON 13 1. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON lxxxx I= /DEFAULT I= I= lxxxx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )DEFAULT DEl!'AULT >= )i!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )i!x. )DEFAULT DEFAULT \20 \1. \DEF AUL? \LOCAL \ON \ \ON \NONE \ON Laminar Leakage Lk Rate Ref Ref Rof Sink Leak Vol Factor Temp Humid Model Rep subvol ('l/hrl (paial {Fl ,., Option Wall Option {ft2) DEFAULT UNIFORM DEFAULT UNIFORM UNIFORM UNIFORM DEFAULT 13 CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT lxxxx I= I= lxxxx I= /DBFAULT >= )xxxx >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT )i!xx >= )xxxx )xxxx >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT )i!xx )==x )xxxx >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )xxxx )xxxx >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )xxxx )xxxx >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT \20 \0. \ \ \ \CNST T \UNIFORM \DEFAULT July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B32 ofB156 31 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 98 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS _ 1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:19 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Turbulent
Leakage Lk Rate Ref Ref Ref Sink Leak Vol Factor Press Temp Humid or Model Rep Subvol Area # (t/hr) (psia) (F) (t) Src Option Wall Option (ft2) fL/D ls 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 2s 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 3s 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 4s 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 5 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 6 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 7 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT B 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 9 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 10 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT lls 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 12 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 13 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT Ix= I= I== I== I= I= I= lxxxxxxx /DEFAULT I= )xxxxxxx >= )x= >== )DEFAULT DBFAUL'l'
>= >= )=x )x= >== )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=x )x= >== )DEFAULT DBFAUL'I'
>= )i1a )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )x= >= >== )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xxxxxx )i!xz )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >= >= >== )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )i!xx >== )xxxxxxx >= )x= )x= >== )llBFAtJLT
DEFAULT >= \20 \0. \ \ \ \ \CNS'l' T \ \UNIFORM \DEFAULT \ Discrete Bu:rn Parameters
Min Min Max Burn Flame Burn Un Vol H2 02 H20 Length Speed Rate Burn Burn
# Frac Frac Frac (ft) (ft/s) FF Frac Opt ls 0. 07 0 .05 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 2s o. 07 0 .OS 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 3s o. 07 0 .OS 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT
DEFAULT FBR 4s a. 01 0 .OS 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 5 0. 07 0. 05 O. SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 6 0. 07 0. 05 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 7 0 .07 0 .OS 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR B o. 07 0. 05 o. 55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 9 0. 07 0. 05 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 10 0. 07 0. 05 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR lls 0. 07 0. OS 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 12 0. 07 O. OS 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 13 0. 07 0. 05 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR I= I= I= /DEFAULT /DEFAULT /DEFAULT )i!.,. )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )i!x. )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT )i1a )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )!!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )i!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xxxx )DEFAULT DEFAULT \20 \0.07 \0.05 \O.SS \DEFAULT \DEFAULT \ \DEFAULT \FBR Continuous
Burn Parameters
Vol Min H2 Min Max Max Burn Vol Flow 02 H20 H20/H2 Frac (lbm/s) Frac Frac
Ratio ls 0. 0. 05 0 .55 1000. l. 2s 0. 0. 05 0 .55 1000. l. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B33 ofB156 32 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 99 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_? .GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_?a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:19 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Continuous
Burn Parameters (cont.) Vol Vol 10 12 13 )i!xx )!!xx \20 Vol 10 13 )i!xx )!!xx )!!xx \20 Vol Min H2 Flow (lbrn/s) o. o. \0. Min H2 o. o. o. \0. Unburned Min o.os 0.05 o.os 0,05 o.os 0.05 I= \0.05 Min \o. o. o. o. o. Burned H20/H2 Ratio 0.55 1000. 1. 0,55 1000. 1. o.ss 1000. 1. 0.55 1000. 1. 0.55 1000, 1. I= I= I= )ixxxxx )ixxxxx )ixxxxx )ixxxxx )ixx.x. )ixxxxx \0.55 \1000. \1. Mechanistic
Burn Rate Parameters
l. 1. 1. l. 1. 1. 1. 1. \l. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1.
1. 1. \1. (lbm/ft3-s)
DEFAULT DEFAULT DBFAULT DEFAULT /DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT \DEFAULT Mechanistic
Burn Propagation
Parameters
CC Flow Flame Thick (ft/sl (ft) DEFAULT 0.164 Turl:> Tu.rkl Temp Limit (F) Opt EDIS 350. EDIS 350. EDIS 350. I= >= >= >= >= >= >= >== >= >= >= >== >= >= >== >= >= >= \ \350. \ \EDIS \ Ig Min Ig Min Ig Max Auto lg Temp (Fl 0.05 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B34 ofB156 33 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 100 of m NUMERICAL
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
APPLICATIONS
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
;., n *, rJ1"1'-I
:"*l"J I!"' 'oil.( "';.e n,nt.m:l'.i:-:
tr Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_7 .GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:19 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Mechanistic
Burn Propagation
Parameters (cont.) Vol 10 lls 12 13 )i!xx )i!x. \20 Vol * 1' 2s 3s .. 5 ' 7 ' 9 10 lls 12 13 /xxxx )!!xx )i!xx )ii.. \20 Unburned Burned CC Flow Flame H2 Vol Thick (ft/s} (ft) 0.04 0.001 DEFAULT 0.164 0.04 0.001 DEFAULT 0.164 0.001 0.164 0.04 0.001 DEFAULT 0.164 0.04 DEFAULT 0.04 0.001 DEFAULT 0.164 0.04 DEFAULT 0.164 0.04 0.001 DEFAULT 0.164 />=CDOO< /xx /rx= /xx /DEFAULT /xx />OCDOOO< )xx ),,,, )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )xx )xx )DEFA11LT
DEFAULT )xx )xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx \0.04 \ \0.001 \ \DEFAULT \ \0.164 Pipe Parameters
Relative Rgugh-ne,gs I= >= >= >= >=
>= >= \ Description
Hatch {El 762 f Hatch (762' Hal Hatch (762' Hal Hatch (El 7J 7 f Hatch (737' Half Hatc:h (737'Half
Make Up supply Normal Fan to D Hxhau.st from OG L*m Geom Fact DEFA DEPA DEFA DEFA DEFA DEFA DEPA DEFA DEFA DEFA DBFA DEFA DEFA /DBP'A )DEPA DEFA )DEPA DEPA )DEPA DEPA )DEPA DEPA )DEPA DEPA )DEFA DEPA \DEPA Mg<iulue gf OD ID Elasticity {in) {in) (psi) I= '"""""" /xxxxxxxxxx
>= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= )xxxxxxxxxx
>= >= >= \ \ \ Flow Patha -Table l Vol "' A (ft} (ft) 760. 760. 10 0.1 10 763. 0.1 Ig Min H2 0,04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 '"" /"-""'<XXX )xx ),,,, )xx )xx )xx )xx \ \0.04 Stiffne,g,g
Factor I= >= >= >= >=
>= >= \ Vol 4s47 1sBEi lg Min Ig Max 0.05 0.05 o.ss 0,05 a.SS o.os o.ss 0.05 0.05 o.os o.ss \0.05 \0.55 Tilt (ft) (ft) (deg) 762. O.J 762. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Auto Ig To mp (F) DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT /DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAlJLT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT \DEFAULT {deg) 254 /xx )xx )xx ),,,, )xx )xx )xx \ NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B35 ofB156 34 
----------------
-----EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 101 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7 .GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:19 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -Table 1 (cont.) F.P. Vol Elev Description (ft) Outside Air 737. outside Air 12 Divl-Div2
Upper ll Divl-Div2
Lower 1 .. " 00 Rl Door (Low 4*4 737. DG Rl Door (Mid 16 DG Rl Rollup (L 737. 00 Rl Rollup (L 739.5 Dl-DJ Roll Up 3s27 " Dl-DJ Roll Low 737. Dl-DJ Up 742. 21 Dl*DJ Low 3** Emergency
Fan t 763. 23 Fan & Duct 12 769. Re.circ to Fan R 759. Emergency
Suppl Oil Fan supply 27 BC to Intake 13 LoV Leakage Pat Hallway Leakage. 4a270 749. Gen Fom Flow Lo Gen Fan Flow Lo 32 Gen Fan Flow Hi Gen Fan Flow Hi /ls7 /738. )lo39 )742. '" 738. )1s39
ls SS )llil39
ls SS \ls39 \742. DG Rl Door (Top 742. DG Rl Rollup (U 742. " DO Rl Rollup (T 744.5 '"""" I= /lll: /:iccoccx Preasur )i!xx.x
)!!.. Presaur
)!!xx Prossur Pressur
)!!,.. Pressur )i!xxx. l2cyl P 16cyl p , .. \Exhaust Pipe La \lalll \:r \760.98 Flow Paths -Table 2 Flow Flow Hyd, Inertia Friction Path Diam. Length Length {ft2) (ft) (ft) (ft) 160. 15. 160. 15. 3. "* 3. s. 3. 42,69 s. 1e+05 "* s. 10.7 '* lB Vol (ft) 1. 2sl9 1. '" ls16 2 .* 5 ls13 ls29 l. "' "' ls70 0.1 lla2 0.1 /1.5 )'*' 1.5 )l:' ls54 )t' \2.5 2,1667 '*' lsGl I= I= \0.01 \llsJ Relative Rough-o. o. le-05 le-05 27. le-OS o. le-05 o. Elev (ft) 742. 739,5 737. 742. 750. 749. 738. 744.5 N 744.5 /lll: /:x:xxxxlll:
\B \788.01 Dep Bend I deg) OEFA DEFA Ht (ft) 1. 1. '*' l. l. '* 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 I= \0.01 Dpt o. o. Tilt (deg) /xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx \ Strat Flow DP' NONE NONI!! NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE NONE July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT (deg) /xxxxx >= )xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxx NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B36 ofB156 35 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 102 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:19 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -Table 2 (cont. J Flow Flow Hyd. Inertia Friction Relative D*p Mom Strat Path Diam. Length Length Rough-*=* Flow (ft2) (ft) {ft) (ft) Fact (deg) Opt Opt 40. le-OS NONE 10.7 '" le-05 DEFA NONE 21 l0.7 4,2 " NONE 22 66.39 " DEFA NONE 2J..3 '*' 5. le-05 DEFA NONE 21.3 DEFA 0. NONE '* 0. le-OS NONE 5, DEFA o. NONE 120. s. o. le-OS NONE s. 0.073 '* 0. le-OS 0, NONE l, 0.021 " 0.001 NONE l, le-OB DEFA NONE '* s. DEFA N&T NONE 5, 0, NONE NONE " 6.5 5.5 OEFA NONE s. NONE 36 20. 5. S,5 0. 0. DEFA 0, N&T NONE />= /xxxxxxxx
/xxxxxxxx
/xxxxxxxx
/xxxxxxxx
'"""""""'
/DEPA I= I= I= >= >= )DEPA DEPA ):.X )!!xx >= >= )DEPA DEPA ):.X )i!.x >= )xxxxxxxx )DEPA DEPA >= >= )DEPA DEPA )=:x >= >= )DEPA DEPA >= >= )DEPA DEPA ):.X )!!.,. >= >= )DEPA DEPA ):X \44 \10. \5. \41. \ \ \DEPA \O. \N&T \NONE Flow Paths -Table 3 Flow Fwd. Rev. Critical Exit Drop Homog. Comp. Flow Breakup Flow Coeff. Coeff. Opt, Model Coeff. Model Opt. 0.1 0.1 OFF OFF 0.1 0.1 OFF 0.1 OFF OFF 0.1 0.1 2.78 1.5 1.S 0.01 0.01 0, OFF 0.01 2.78 2.78 2.78 16 2.78 OFF OFF 2.78 o. 2.78 2.78 2.78 0.1 2.78 2.78 2.78 OFF 26 2.78 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B37 ofB156 36 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 103 of 254 [N'J)
Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:19 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flov Paths -Table 3 (cont.) Flow Fwd. Rev. Critical Exit Drop Homog. Path Lo,. Loss Comp. Flow Lo .. Breakup Flow Coeff, FF CCeff. FF Opt. Model Coeff. Model Opt. 2.78 2.78 OFF OFF o. OFF 0 28 I 2.78 2.78 OFF OFF 0. OFF 0 29 2.78 2.78 OFF OFF 0. OeF OFF 1. l. OFF OFF 0. OFF OFF 1. 1. OFF OFF 0. OFF OFF 1. l. OFF OFF 0. OFF OFF " 1. l. OFF OFF o. OFF OFF 34 2.78 2.78 OFF OFF o. OFF OFF 35 2.78 2.78 OFF OFF 0. OFF OFF " 2.78 2.78 OFF OFF 0. OFF OFF '""""' '"""""'&deg;"'
/xx '"""""""'
/xx '""""" '"""""""'
'"""""" '"""""&deg;"'
I= )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )!!.,. )xx )xx )xx )xx )!!.,. )xx )xx \44 \5.56 \ \S.56 \ \OPP \OFF \0. \OPP \OPP Plow Paths -Table 4 Forward Reverse Prop Flow Min Min Max Min Min Max *= Hi th Path H2 02 H20 H2 02 H20 Time Zero Prop Plow Opt 0,06 o.os 0.55 o.ss 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO COFLOH 0,06 I 0,05 I o.ss 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 0.06 0.05 0,55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 0,55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 10 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 11 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 12 0,06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO COFL' 13 0,06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 14 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 15 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 16 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0,05 0.55 0.5 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLO 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLO 0,06 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO PLOW 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 0,05 0.55 0.5 0.05 0.55 0.5 0.06 0.05 I 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 o.ss 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 I NO I COFLOW 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 NO CO FLOW 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 0.06 I o.os I 0.55 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 0.06 0.05 0.55 0.5 I NO 0.06 I 0.05 I o.ss 0.06 *" 0.05 0.55 0.06 0.55 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B38 ofB156 37 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 104 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_?a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:19 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -Table 4 Forward Flow Min Min Max Min Path Frac Frac Frac Frac 0.05 o.ss o.os 0.05 0.55 0.06 I= I= I= I= )!!xx )!ix,. )!i.x )!ix,. \44 \0.06 \D.05 \0.55 \0.06 Cond Description
PG (Warm) (Convl DG (Hot) (Conv) 3s DG Rl E Wall 4s PG Rl S Wall PG Rl N Wall Gs 00 Rl Ceiling Under Fan Room Divl Ceiling-762
Div! Floor DG Rl W Wall Wall {Tank Room -C(J Rl) lls Wall {DG R2 -Hallway) 12.s Wall {DG R2 -Other rooms) Wall (DG R2 -outside Air) 14s Div2 to 912' lSs Div2 to 962' Divl to Amb. l 7s Div3 to 962' Divl to 912' Ceiling (El 737ft Hallway) Hallway E"loor Wall (El 737ft Hallway -Outside Mr) Wall (Tank Room -outside Air) Wall (E"an Room -Other Rooms) Wall (Fan Reem -Outside Air) (El 737ft Other Rooms -OUtside Air) Wall (El 762ft Other Reome -outside Air) Wall (El 712ft -Outside Air) E"an Reem to Amb * E"an Rm to 962' 30 Fan Rm to Amb (ceiling)
/'Dr.XX /:JCXXJOOUt
)!i:x North Side South Side East Side West Side 'Iop Side North Side South Side )!!xx West Side )!!xx 'Iop Side Bottom Side \41 \1PL9:ilJA
North Sida {cont.J Reverse Min Frac o.os I= \0.05 Prop M= Hi th Time Prnp Frac Frac Flow Opt o.ss NO CO FLOW 0.55 CO FLOW 0.55 o.s NO COFLOH I= I= I= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= \0.55 \O.S \NO \COP'LOW 'Ihennal Conductors
Vol Srf Vol Srf ConO: Opt Opt Type (ft2) ls7-59 1s11 ls7l loB 2376. loS 936. loN 4s3-36 ls97-l 1000. lalD4-2900. leF 10 3800. /lsW /lsS-10 /2376. \3sE \lsW \2350. ls2-50 200. 4s5-36 670. 2400. llal 3'C 3600. 10 3600. llsl 3, 936. 960. 12 2 3 1 1521. I= I= I= I= /x= )i!xxxx )in )in )i!xxxx )in )in )i!xxxx )in )in )i!xxx,. )in )in )i!xxxx )i.x )i.x )in )in )in )in )in )in )i.x )i.x )i.x )i.x \16 \1 \lal.2 \1 \7 \0.705 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B39 ofB156 38 Init. Grp T. (F) I/X 78. 78. 78. 78. 78. 78. 78. 78. I= \78. \X \ 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 105 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:19 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal conductors (cont.) Cond Vol Srf Vol Srf Cond S. A. * Description
A Opt B Opt Typ* (ft2) /xxxx /xxxxxxx I= />O<X I= I= /xxxx )!ix. South Side )ix. )ix. )ix.,. )!ix.
Side )ix. )ix. )ix.,. )!!xx
Sida )ix. )ix. )ix.,.
Side )ix. )ix. )ix.,. )!!xx Bottom Side )ix. )ix. )ix.,. North Side )ix. )ix. )ix.,. South Sida )ix. )ix. )ix.,. EllBt Sida )ix. )ix.
Sid* )ix. )ix. 'I'op Side )ix. )ix. North Side )ix. )ix. South Sida )ix. )ix.
Sida )ix. )ix.
Side )ix. )ix.
Side )ix. )ix. )ix.,. Bottom Sid* )ix. )ix. 12cyl North Side )ix. >= )ix. )ix.,. l.2cyl South Side )ix. >= )ix. )ix.,. 12cyl East Sida )ix. >= )ix. )!i:x 12cyl West Side )!i...x )ix. >= )ix. )ix.,. 12cyl Top Side )!i...x )ix. )ix. )ix.,. 12cyl Bottom Sida )!i...x )ix. )ix. )ix.,. 16cyl North Sida )ixx )ix. )ix.,. l6cyl South Sida )ix. )ix. )ix.,. 16cyl Bast Side )ix. )ix. )ix.,. 16cyl West Side )ixx )ix. )ix.,. )!!xx 16cyl Top Sida )ix. )ix. )ix.,. )!ixx 16cyl Bottom Sida )ix. )ix. )ix.,.
Air Piping )!xx );'... )!.xx
Air Piping )!xx );'... }!.xx
Air Piping )!xx );'... )!.xx \73s \Dll Combust. Air Piping \ls71-8 \B \ls71-8 \7 \B
Thermal Conductors
-Radiation
Parametera
Cond Tha=. Rad. Emisa. Th arm. Rad. Emias. Side A Side A Side B Side B Scope No No No No No No No No 11* No No No 19* No No No FULL " No FULL July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B40 ofB156 39 Init. Gcy T. (Fl l/X * I= /xxxx )ix.xx )xxxx )ix.xx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )ix.xx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )ix.xx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx >= )ix.xx )xxxx >= >= )xxxx )xxxx )ixxxx )!.xx )ixxxx )!.xx )ixxxx )!.xx \78. \I ,. 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 106 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductors
-Radiation
i:'arameters (cont.) Cond Therm. Rad. Emiss. Therm. Rad. Emiss. * Side A Side A Side B Side B Scope 23 No No FULL 24 No No FULL 25 No No FULL 26 No No FULL 27 No No FULL 2' No No FULL 29 No No FULL 30 No No FULL I= '""""""" I= I= /xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >= >= >= >= >= >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >= )xxxxxxx >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!!xx )xxxxxxx >= )!!xx )xxxxxxx >= >= >= )xxxxxxx >= )xxxxxxx >= )!!xx >= >= )!!xx )xxxxxxx >= >= >= )!!xx >= >= >= >= >= >= )xxxxxxx >= >= >= )!i:x >= >= >= >= >==->= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >==->= >= )xxxxxxx >= )i!!x >= >= >==->= >= >==-)!i!x )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >==->= >= >==-)xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >==-)xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >==->= >= >==-)xxxxxxx >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >==-)xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >==-)!!.. )xxxxxxx >= >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >==-)xxxxxxx >= \73s \No \ \No \ \FULL Thei:mal Conductors
-Ice Parameters
Sid" A Side B Node Cond. Spacing Thick. *Area Thick. Cinl Nodes Option (in) Porcsity (in) Porosity I I I I I I I I July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B41 ofB156 40 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 107 of 254 (N'J]
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductors
-Ice Parameters (cont.) -------Side A -----------Side B ----Node Ar** Ie* Iee Cond. Spacing Max FF Thick. Iee Area Thick. Iee Area * (in) Nodes Option (inl Porosity FF {in) Porosity FF 2 NONB NONE " NONE NONE .. NONE NONE 5* NONB NONE .. NONB NONE '" NONE NONE .. NONE NONE '" NONE NONE 10* NONE NONE ll* NONE NONE 12* NONE NONE 12* NONE NONE "" NONE NONE 15" NONE NONE 16* NONE NONE 17" NONE NONE 18" NONE NONE l** NONE NONE "" NONE NONE 21" NONE NONE 22 NONE NONE 2J NONE NONE 24 NONE NONE 25 NONE NONE " NONE NONE 27 NONE NONE 28 NONB NONE " NONE NONE JO NONE NONE /x= /=x I= I= /NONB I= /x= /NONE I= I= )!i!x }xx= }=x >= }NONE NONE >= }xxxx }NONE NONE >= }=x }xxxxx }xxxxxx }NONE NONE >= }xxxx }NONE NONE >= >= }=x }=x }xxxxxx }NONE NONE >= }xxxx }NONE NONE >= }xxxx )i!!x }=x >=-}xxxxxx }NONE NONE >= }xxxx }NONE NONE >= }xxxx }xxxxxxx }xxxxx >= }NONE NONE >= }"""" )NONE NONE >= }xxxx }xx= >=-}xxxxxx }NONE NONE >= }xxxx }NONE NONE >= }xxxx }=x }xxxxx }xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )"""" )xx= )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx }NONE NONE >= )xxxx
>= )xxxx )!!xx }xx= )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx >= }NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )!!.x )xxxxxxx >= )xxxxxx >= )xxxx }NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx }!!.x )xxxxxxx >= >=
>= }xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx }!!,.,, }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx }NONE NONE >= )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONE NONE >= >= }!!,.,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxx >=
>= )xxxx }NONE NONE >= )xxxx }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )HONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx }xxxxxx }NONE NONE >= }xxxx }NONE NONE }xxxxxxxx )xxxx )!i:x )xxxxxxx >= }xxxxxx }NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx }NONE NONE >= )xxxx }=x )xxxxx >= }NONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx >= }NONE NONE >= }xxxx }NONE NONE >= )xxxx )xxxxxxx }xxxxx >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx }xxxxxxx }xxxxx >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE }xxxxxxxx
}xxxx )xx= >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx }NONE NONE >= )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx
>= }xxxx )xxxxxxx >= }xxxxxx }NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx
}xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )HONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx }xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE >= }=x \6ls \ \ \ \NONE \ \ \NONE \ \ July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B42 ofB156 41 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 108 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_
RO\CPS_ 1 A_DG_ LoV _ LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductors
-Ice Parameters (cont.) -------Side A -----------Side B ----Node Area Iee Ice Cond. Spacing Max FF Thick. Iee Area Thick. Ioe Area * (inl Nodes Option Unl Porosity FF (in) Porosity FF /xxxx I= /xxxxx I= /NONE /xxxxxxxx
/xxxx /NONE I= /xxxx )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )!ixx >= )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONB NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx >= )xxxxx >= )NONE NO!ll! >= )xxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxx >-= )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx >= )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )=xx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )Wolm )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NO!ll! >= )xxxx )!ixx >= )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NO!ll! NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )Zi:x )xxxxxxx )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxx \73s \ \ \ \NONE \ \ \NONE \ \ Thermal Conductor
Typea Type Thick. O.D. Heat Heat Description
Geom (in) (in) Regions (Btu/ft3-B)
Ceiling/Floor
12. 0. 0. Internal Hall WALL 12. 20 Ex.ternal
Wall WALL 36. o. 2J o. OG Harm WALL l. o. 10 o. DG Hot WALL 0. * Internal Block WALL 11.625 20 /xxxx I= /xxxx I= /xxxxxxxx
/xxxxxxx /xxxxx= /xxxx )hxx
>= )xxxx )!xx,.
>= )xxxx ,, \24" Piping \TOBE \0.375 \24. \13 \O. Forcing Function Tables FF. Description
Ind. var. Dep. Var. Points Constant:
DG warm Temp Time !sec) Tempcratur
DG Hot Temp Time (sec) Temperatur
Model Gen. Heat Time (sec) Heat Rate Benchmark
Heat Time (sec:) Benchmark
45 Benchmark
Exhau Time (sec) Benchmark
Benchma:i;:k
Inlet Time (sec) Temperatur
7T Benchmark
Loe 1 Time (sec) Temperatur
14 Benchmark
Loe 2 Time (sec) Temperatur
14 9T Benchmark
Loe 3 Time (sec) Temperatur
Benchmark
Loe 4 Time {sec) Temperatur
15 I= \llT \Outdoor Air Tem. \Time (sec) \Te:mperatur
\1535 Data Files File Inter-Output Detail * Name -Type palate Files Level l I /CPS_lA_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7 .osv I TIHB I YES I SINGLE I RffiL I= \2 \Case_ 7a _ Panel_Tei:nperatures.
csv \TIME \YES \SINGLE \FULL July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B43 ofB156 Format Option 42 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 109 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-0ci4_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Conductor
Surface Options -Table 1 Surf Heat end/ Sp Nat For Opt Transfer Nominal Cnv Cnd Cnv env Cnv # Description
Option Value FF Opt Opt HTC Opt Opt 1 Wall Direct DLM-FM VERT SURF USER DEF 2 Ceiling Side Direct DLM-FM FACE DOWN USER DEF 3 Floor Side Direct OLM-FM FACE UP USER DEF 4 DG Warm Temper Sp Temp 1. lT 5 DG Hot Temperat Sp Temp 1. 2T 6 HTC Sp Conv /4.9 l>aoa< I'&deg;"""&deg;"' I= I= I= I= I=== for 00 >= >= )"""" >= >= )!.xx )ixxxxxxx
)!! >== >= )!xx >=== >== ,, \DG :Intake HTC \Sp COnv \4.75:Z \ \ \ \ \ \ Conductor
Surface Options -Table 2 Surf Min Max Convection
condensation
Rad to Steam Opt Phase Liq Liq Bulk Temp Bulk Temp Emissivity
# Opt Fract Fract
Model FF Model FF Dry Wet 1 VAP Tg-Tf Tb-Tw DEFAULT DEFAULT 2 VAP Tg-Tf Tb-Tw DEFAULT DEFAULT
3 VAP Tg-Tf Tb-Tw DEFAULT DEFAULT 4 5 6 VAP Tg-Tw 0. 0. l>aoa< I== I= I= I= I=== I= /DEFAULT /DEFAULT >= >= >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )!.xx >== >= >= >=== >= >== >= )DEFAULT )DEFAULT ,, \VAP \ \ \Tg-Tw \ \ \ \0. \0. Conductor
Surface Options -Table 3 Surf Char. Nom Minimum Char. Cond. Opt Length Vel Vel Conv HTC Height Length # (ft) (ft/s) FF (B/h-f2-F) (ft) (ft) DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT
I== I= I= I= /DEFAULT I== I=== >= >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >== >== )!.xx >= >= >= )DEFAULT >=== >=== ,, \ \ \ \DEFAULT \DEFAULT \DEFAULT Conductor
Surface Options Table 4 surf Tot.al. Peak Initial BD Post.-BD Post-BD Opt Const Heat Time Exp Value Exp Exp Direct # CT (Btu) (sec) XT (B/h-f2-F)
yt xt FF July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B44 ofB156 43 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 110 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7 .GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Conductor
Surface Options -Table 4 {cont.) Surf Total Peak Initial BD Post-BO Post-BO &deg;'' Const Heat Time Exp Value Exp Exp Direct * CT (Btu) (sec) XT (B/h-f2-P)
ye " FF I= /=x I= I= I= I= /=oaua< )h.x >= )=x >= >= >= >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx ):,.,.. >= >= >= >= >= >= )xxxxxxx ,, \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ Control Variables
Initial Coeff. Coeff. Description
Fo= Value ao Min Div l DG Heat Load -le+32 2C Div l DGl Heat Abaorpticin
-1. 3C Bounding Panel T_bulk_avg
o. Bounding Panel T_max 1e+32 SC Door T_bulk_avg
fiil Operator Act if l. le+32 Door T_m.a.x Ql Operator Action if -le .. 32 Panel 1PL12JA [Vole] 0. l. o. -le+32 le+32 ac Panel 1PL12JA [Tel!IV] l. le+32 Panel 1PL12JA [Vole] [Temv] sump rod -le+32 Panel 1I'Ll2JA T_l:Julk_avg
div le+32 llC Panel 1PL92JA/1PL93JA (Vole] l. -le+32 12C Panel 1PL92JA/l.PL93JA
[Ternv] -le+32 Panel. 1PL92JA/l.PL93JA
[Vole] [T sump rod -le+32 le+32 Panel 1PL92Ja/ll?L93JA
T_bulk_a div o. l. le+32 lSC Panel lDGOlJA {Vole] l. 0. 16C Panel lDGOlJA [Temv] Panel lDGOlJA (Vok] [Temv] sumprod -le+32 Panel lDGOlJA T_bulk_avg
div o. le-+-32 1'C Panel 1DG06SA [Vole] l. Panel 1DG06SA [Temv] l. le+32 21C Panel 1DG06SA [Vole] [Temv] surnprod o. -le+32 Panel l.DG06SA T_bulk_avg
div l. Panel lDGOlKA l.2eyl [Vole] Panel l.DGOl.KA
12eyl [Temv] o. -le+32 le+32 Panel lDGOlKA 12eyl (Vole] [Tern sumprod l. Panel lDGOlKA. 12eyl T_bulk_avg
div Panel lDGOlKA 16eyl [Vole] l. Potnel lDGOlKA 16eyl [Temv] 2'C Panel lDGOlKll.
16eyl [Vole] [Tern sumprod Panel lDGOlKA l.6eyl T_bulk_avg
div Roll.up Door [Vole] -le+32 Roll.up Door (Temv] l. Roll.up Door [Vole] [Temv] sump rod le+32 Roll.up Door T_bulk_avg
div 3SC Personnel
Door [Vole] l?ersonnel
Door [TemvJ -le+32 Personnel
Door [Vole] [Temv] sump rod 0. o. 1e+32 Personnel
Door T_bulk_avg
div Max Door Temperature
Max Door T_bulk_avg
0. l. 0. I= I= )!ii. Air Temperature )!iix
Heat Transfer
Heat Transfer + Dela
That .. 2 )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx
+ Vy**2 + vz**2) )ixxxxxx )=wv1 \SOC \Local Rho*v*o \mu1t \0. \l. \0. \-la ... 32 \le ... 32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Upd. Int. Mult. I=
\0. o. o. o. o. o. NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B45 ofB156 44 
L_ EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 111 of 254 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS
_ 1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Control Variables (cont.) CV Fune. Initial Coeff, Coeff, * Delil'cription Value G ao Min Max /=x />OOC<XXX
/=xxxx /=xxxx /=xxxx /x==x I= I= )ixx.xxx )ixx.xxx )ixx.xxx )ixx.xxx )ixx.xxx )i!ix
(1/2) *Pr .. (l/3) .. (2/3) )i!ix
.. (2/3)] ** (1/4) )ixx.xxx )ixx.xxx
(1/2) *Pr*'* (l/Jl I [l+ (o )ixx.xxx
** (5/8)
u (5/8) J ** (4/Sl )ixx.xxx )ixx.xxx
.. (1/3)/[1+(0 )ixx.xxx \&JC \Local Nu \eum \0. \l. \0.3 \-18+32 \le+32 Turbulence
ParamaterB
1----Liquid --1 1----Vapor --1 Vol Molec. Turb. Mix.L. Mix.L Phase Diff. Model (ft) No. (ft} No. No. Option 1' NO NONE o. o. " NO NONE o. o. o. VAPOR NO NONE o. o. VAPOR .. NONE o. o. 0. o. o. 0. VAPOR NONE o. o. 0. VAPOR NO NONE o. o. VAPOR NO NONE o. o. o. o. VAPOR NO NONE 0. o. o. 0. VAPOR 10 NONE o. o. VAPOR 11* o. o. 0. 12 NO NONE 0. o. VAPOR 1J NO NONE l. l. l. l. VAPOR /x=x /x=x /=xxxx I= I= /x=xx I= I= I= I= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= \20 \NO \NONE \l. \l. \l. \l. \VAPOR Coll Blockages
-Table 1 Volume ls Blockage No. Description
Type l Day Tank Room BLK B I N /x=x /=x /x /x /x )!)i >: )ixxxx )!)i ): )!xxxx )!)i ): )ix.xx )!)i ): )!)i ): 12cy1 )!)i >: \8 \1DG01KA 16cyl \BLK \B \J: \N July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Upd. Int. Mult. I= \0. NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B46 ofB156 45 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 112 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Cell Blockages
-Table 2 Volume ls Blockage Coordinates
& Dimensions (ft) Angle No. Xl Yl Zl X2 Y2 Z2 X3 Y3 Z3 L (Deg) l 0. o. 0. 10. 10. 10. I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= >= >= >-= >= >= )!.x.x )i!xxxx >= >= >= >= >= )!x.xx >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= )xxxxxx >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= \8 \29.479 \11.583 \2.458 \30.479 \14. \8.292 \ \ \ \ \ X-Direction
Cell Face Variations
Volume ls Cell Blockage Area Hyd. Dia. Loss Drop De-ent. No. No. Porosity FF (ft) Coeff. FF Factor def On 1. 1000000. 0. -0. lsl l 0. le-06 0. 0. ls5 1 1. 260. o. 0. ls17 l o. le-06 o. 0. ls21 l 1. 260. o. 0. ls33 l o. le-06 o. 0. ls37 l 1. 260. 0. 0. ls49 1 0. le-06 o. 0. ls53 l 1. 260. 0. o. ls65 l 1. 20. 0. 0. /UJUaa<X '""""""' /xxxxxxxx
'""""' I= '"""""""'
/xx I """"' )=xx )xx )0-:XXJCX )=xx )xx )=xx )xx )0-XJCI: )=xx )xx )0. )=xx )xx )O* )xx )0. )""""' )xx )O* )""""' )xx )0* ::iuccc:x:x )=xx )0. lCCCCCC )!xx..xx )ixxxxxxx
)=xx
\ls:zl \6 \1. \ \68l.B22 \0. \ \0. Z-Direction
Cell Face Variations
Volume ls Cell Blockage Area Hyd. Dia. Loss Drop De-ent. Curb Ht No. No. Porosity FF (ft) Coeff. FF Factor (ft) def On 1. 1000000. 0. 0. lsl 0. le-06 0. 0. 0. ls2 1. 36. 0. 0. 0. 1s5 1. 260. 0. 0. 0. ls17 o. le-06 0. o. 0. lslB 1. 36. 0. 0. 0. ls21 1. 260. 0. 0. 0. ls33 0. le-06 0. 0. 0. ls34 1. 36. 0. 0. 0. ls37 1. 260. 0. o. 0. ls49 0. le-06 0. 0. 0. lsSO 1. 36. 0. 0. 0. ls53 1. 260. o. 0. 0. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Curb Height 0. I= \0. NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B47 ofB156 46 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 113 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\ Compare File:
C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Z-Direction
Cell Face Variation:r (cont.) Volume ls Cell Blockage Are* Hyd. Dia. Less Drop De-ent. Curb Ht No. No. Porosity FF (ft) Coeff, FF Factor (ft) '"""""""'
/xxxx I= /xx )xxxx )xx )'* )xxxx )xx )!;..=**xxxx )xxxx )xx )'* )xxxx )xx )xxxx )xx )'* *= )xxxx )xx )ixx.x.x )xxxx )xx )ixx.x.x )xxxx )xx )ixx.x.,.
)!x..xxxx )xxxx )xx )'* )ixx.x.x )xxxx )xx )'* )ixx.x.x )!x..xxxx )xxxx )xx )'* )ixx.x.x )xxxx ) .. )'* )ixx.x.,. )=xx ) .. )ixx.x.,.
)!x..xxxx )xxxx )xx
ccccc xx )Zx..xx. )xxxx )xx )k..xx. )xxxx )xx )1.xxxxx )!x..xxxx )xxxx )xx )'* >=== )xxxx )xx >=== )xxxx )xx )O* \la39 \8 \1. \ \586.978 \0. \ \o. \0. Volume Varia.t:ions
Volume ls Cell Block.age
Volume Hyd. Dia. No. No. Porosity FF (ft) def On 1. 1000000, 1'1 l o. le-06 1'2 l 1. 36, 1'5 l 1. 260. ls17 l 0. le-06 1:118 l 1. 36, lB21 l 1. 260. 11133 l o. le-06 1934 l 1. "* 1Bl7 l 1. 260. lll'l.9 l 0. le-06 lsSO l 1. 36, ls53 l 1. 260. ls65 l 1. 20. /=xxxx '"""""""'
/xxxx I= )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )ixxxxxx )!x..xxxx )xxxx )!....xx )ixx.x.x )ixx.x.x )xxxx )ixx.x.,.
)!x..xxxx )ixx.x.x )xxxx )xxxx )ixx.x.,. )xxxx )ixx.x.x )xxxx \la::17 \7 \1. \ \158.76504
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B48 ofB156 47 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 114 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Volume Variations (cont.) Volume ls Cell Blockage Volume Hyd.. Dia. No. Porosity (ft) I= /zxxx I= )hxxxxx )zxxx )h..xxx )zxxx )kxxxx )xxxx \ls39 \8 \1. \ \571.38501
Conductor
Surface Options -Natural Convection
Varia);Jles
htc .. (k/l) * (A + B*GrUC*Pr**D)
Surf Opt Conv Var A Conv Var B Conv Var c FF FF 6 0.59 0.25 I= I= I= I= >= )=xx >= )xxxxx \9 \0. \ \0.551 \ \0.25 Conductor
Surface Options -Forced Convection
Variables
htc -(k/l) * (A + B*Re*"'C*Pr**D)
Surf Opt Conv Var A Conv Var B Conv Var c Norn.. FF FF Nom. 0.037 o.s 0.037 6 0.023 0.8 I= I= I= >= )!xxz >= >= ,, \0. \ \0.023 \ \o.e Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Thermal Conductor
Type Panel Steel Bdry. Thick Sub-Region (in) linl 0.00648 0.01296 0.02592 0.0191 0.014.24 0.11528 0.00648 FF Nom. 0.25 I= I= >= >= )xxxxx >= \ \0.25 \ Conv Var D Nom. FF 0.4 I= I= >= >= >= >= \ \0.4 \ 0. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B49 ofB156 48 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 115 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductor
Type (cont. J 7 Panel Steel Mat. Bdry, Thick Sub-Heat Region * linl (in) reg3. Factor 10 I 1 I 0.12176 I 0.00324 I , I o. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Ind. Function llT Outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 0. 90. 60. 120. 89. 9996764 180. 240. 89. 9987054 300. 360. 89. 9970873 420. 480. 89. 994822 540. 600. 89. 9919099 660. 720. 89.9883511
780. 840. 89.9841458
900. 960. 89. 9792944 1020. 1080. 89.9737973
1140. 1200. 89. 9676549 1260. 1320. 89.9608677
1380. 1440. 89. 9534361 1500. 1560. 89. 9453608 1620. 1680. 89. 9366423 1740. 1800. 89. 9272813 1860. 1920. 89.9172786
1980. 2040. 89. 9066348 2100. 2160. 89. 8953509 2220. 2280. 89. 8834276 2340. 2400. 89. 8708659 2460. 2520. 89. 8576667 2580. 2640. 89. 8438311 2700. 2760. 89.82936 2820. 2880. 89.8142546
2940. 3000. 89. 7985161 3060. 3120. 89. 7821455 3180. 3240. 89. 7651443 3300. 3360. 89. 7475137 3420. 3480. 89. 7292549 3540. 3600. 89. 7103695 3660. 3720. 89.6908588
3780. 3840. 89. 6707244 3900. 3960. 89. 6499678 4020. 4080. 89. 6285904 4140. 4200. 89. 6065941 4260. 4320. 89. 5839804 4380. 4440. 89. 5607511 4500. 4560. 89. 5369079 4620. 4680. 89. 5124527 4740. 4800. 89 .4873873 4860. 4920. 89.4617136
4980. 5040. 89.4354336
5100. 5160. 89.4085493
5220. 5280. 89. 3810628 5340. 5400. 89. 352976 5460. 5520. 89. 3242913 5580. 5640. 89. 2950106 5700. Dep. Var. 89. 9999191 89. 9992718 89. 9979772 89. 9960355 89. 9934468 89. 9902113 89. 9863292 89. 9818008 89. 9766266 89. 9708068 89. 9643419 89. 9572324 89. 9494789 89. 9410819 89. 9320421 89. 9223601 89. 9120368 89. 9010728 89. 8894691 89. 8772265 89. 8643459 89. 8508284 89. 8366749 89. 8218865 89. 8064644 89. 7904097 89. 7737237 89. 7564076 89. 7384627 89. 7198905 89. 7006923 89.6808695
89. 6604238 89. 6393566 89. 6176695 89. 5953643 89. 5724426 89. 5489061 89. 5247567 89 .4999961 89 .4746264 89 .4486493 89 .4220669 89. 3948812 89.3670943
89 .3387083 89.3097253
89 .2801476 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page BSO ofB156 49 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 116 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function {cent.} Outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. var.: Temperature
IP} Ind. var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 5760. 89.2651364
5880, 83.2346708
5940. 6000, 89.2036162
6060. 6120. 89.1719749
6180. 6240. 89.1397494
6300. 6360. 89.1069421
6420. 6600. 6660. 6720. 89.0050545
6780. 6960. 88.9342675
7020. '7140. 7200. 88.8612159
7260. 7320. 7560. 7620. 7680. BB.7084088
7740. 7920. 88.6286998
7980. 8040. 8100. 8160. 88.5468194
8280. 88.5050726
8340. 8460. 8520. 88.41!19819
8700. 8760. 8820. 9000. 9060, 9120. 88 .1980914 9240. 88.1521693
9300. 9600. 9660, 9720. 87.9634507
9780. 9900. 9960. 10080. 87.816731
1014.0. 10200. 87.7668574
10260. 87.6656821
10500. 10620. 10680. 10860. 10920. 11040. 87.4045962
11100. 11220. 11400. 87.24251.68
11520. 87.1876101
11580, 1164.0. 87.1322704
11820. 11880. 87.0203084
11940. 12000. 86.3636947
12180. 12300. 12360. 86.7913744
86.7331225
12540. 12660. 12720. 86.6154277
Dep. Var. 89.2499774
89.1878687
89.1234183
89,090321
89.0566457
89.0223949
88.9875713
88.9521774
BB.91621Gl
88.8796899
88.7667509
88.7279939
88.6488316
88.6084323
88,5674917
88.03999 88,4414532
88.3547791
88,3106574
88.2208614
88.1290181
88.0351556
87.987476
87.9393024
87.8906384
87.8414877
87.7918541
87.7417413
87.5885665
87.4841252
87.377861
87.3240554
87.2151179
87,1599942
87.0'18'1579
86.9920538
86.9352315
86.8779953
86.8203495
86.7622986
86.6'1'1.9989
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B51 ofB156 50 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 117 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Lo\f_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 li'Unction (cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.' Tirne (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 86.5559937
12900. 86.526132
12960. 86.4961746
86.4359751
13140. 86.3753997
13260, 86.34451725
13380. 86.2838419
13500. 86.222347
13560. 86.15114644
13680. 86.1294318
13740. 86.098283
86.0670467
13860. 86.0357234
86.0043137
85.9728183
14100. 85.9095727
14160. 85.8778236
85.8459912
14520. 85.6856003
85.6532806
14640. 85.6208818
85,5884045
14760. 14820. 85.5232172
14940. 85.4577234
15000. 85,4248632
15060. 85.3589193
15180, 85.3258367
85.2926814
15360. 65.2261548
85.1927847
15480. 15540. 85.1258343
15600, 85,0922552
85.0586078
157!10. 15840, 84.9572615
!14.9233469
15960. 84.8893671
16020. 16140. l.6200. 84.71.85133
16320. 84.684156
16380. 84.6497382
16440. 84.61.52604
84.5807233
16620. 84.4767627
84.44151515
16800. 84.4071712
16860. 84.3722921
16920. 16980. 84.3023705
84.2673293
17160. 17220. 84.16185124
84.1265445
84.0913465
17460. 17520. 17580. 83.9141304
83.8429175
83.77l5262
83.7357653
83.69996151
18060. 18120. 83.62823 83.592303
18240. 83.5203301
18420. 83.412084
18660. 18960. 83.1218765
19020. 19080. 19140. 19320. 19380. 82.8296929
19500, 19740. 19860. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B52 ofB156 51 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 118 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
/Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ind. FU.nction (cont.) llT Outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: 'l'irne (.gee) Dep. Var.: Temperature (Fl Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. var. 19920. 82.53588.94
19980. 82.090679
20040. 82.4622273
20100. 82.4253684
82.3884919
82,3146889
20340. 82.2777638
20400, 82.2408238
82.2038698
82.166.9023
20640. 82.0559266
82.018.9126
81.9818887
20880. 81.9448556
20940. 81. 9078141 21000. 81.8707648
21060. 81.8337084
81.7966457
81.7595774
81.7225041
21360. 81.6483454
21420. 81.6112616
21480. 81.5741756
21540. Bl .5370881 21600. 81.5 21660. 21720. 81.4258244
21780. 81.3887384
81.3516546
81.3145735
22140. Bl.1662916
22200. 81.1292352
22260. 81.0921859
22320. Sl.0551444
81.0181113
80.9810874
22500. 22560. 22620. 80,8700778
80.8330977
80.7961302
80,7591762
80.7222362
B0.6853111
23160. 80.5377727
80.4641106
23400. 23460. 80.3537671
23760, 80.1703071
80.1336882
80,0970.954
80.0605292
24000. 79.9874799
24120. 24180. 79.9145457
24360. 24420. 79.6964898
79.5157144
79.4436639
25020. 79.407697
25140. 25320. 25380. 79.1214534
79.0858696
79.0503317
25680. 79.0148405
78.9793966
78.8733555
78.8029104
26100. 78.7326707
78.6626417
78.6277079
26400, 26460. 78.558005
78.5232373
78.4538724
26880, 78.315844
78.2814867
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B53 ofB156 52 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 119 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function {cont.} outdoor Air Temperatu:re
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep, Var.: Temperature
{F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 27000. 78.2471908
27060. 78.2129568
27120. 78.1787854
78.1446772
27300. 78.0766531
27360. 78.0427385
27420. 78.00BBB!n
77.9751074
27540. 77.9413922
77.9077448
27780. 77.8072153
27900. 77.7405461
27960. 77.7073186
28080. 77.6080717
77.5751368
77.4767828
77.41.15955
28620. 77.3467194
28680. 77.31439.97
28860. 77.1859239
77.1221764
29160. 29220. 29280. 76.9956863
29340. 76.9642766
29400. 76.9329533
76.901717
76.8705682
295!10. 76.8395075
76.8085356
29700. 76.777653
29760. 76.7468603
76.6246003
76.5942659
76.%40249
30180. 76.5338778
76.5038254
76.3845723
30540. 76.3550011
76.3255279
30660. 76.2961531
30720. 76.2668775
76.2086256
76.1796505
30960. 76.1220047
31080. 76.0933351
31140. 76.0647685
31200. 76.0363053
31260. 76.0079462
31320. 75.9796916
75.8955606
75.7848821
31800. 75.7574832
32160. 75.5687811
32280. 75.54::!2712
32460. 75.4634243
75.3088468
75.2582587
33360. 75.0849686
75.0606.976
33480. 75.0365493
33540. 75.012524
33600. 74.9886222
33960. 74.8478307
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B54 ofB156 53 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 120 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) llT outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var., Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 34080. 74 .8019086 34140. 74.7791386
34200. 34260. 74.733983
34320. 34380. 74.6893426
74.6452209
34560. 34620. 74.6016212
74.5800181
34800. 34860. 34920. 34..980. 74.4739871
74.4531806
74.4325083
35280. 35340. 74,3311727
74.2720061
35640. 35700. 74.2140779
74.1.950455
35880. 74.1761521
35940. 74.1573982
74.1387841
74.1203101
36120. 74.1019766
36180. 36240. 36300. 36360. 74.0300545
36420. 74.0124287
36480. 36600. 73.9604079
73 .9433543 36720. 73.9264445
36780. 73.90.9679
36900. 73.8602506
73.844065
37080. 73.8280251
37140. 73. 8121313 73.7963838
73.780783
37560. 73.7049894
37620. 37920. 73.6189372
37.980. 73.6051188
73.5914507
73.5779331
38160. 38280, 38400. 38460. 73.4875473
73.4160196
73.4046357
73.3395762
39360. 39540. 39720. 39780. 73.2615373
39840. 3.9.900. 73.2348557
73.21785'15
73.2095903
40260. 40320. 40440. 73.1633251
40560. 73.1561689
40620. 73.1491716
73.1423333
40740. 73.1356541
73 .1291341 73.1227735
73.1105309" 41040. 73.1046491
41100. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAl-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B55 ofB156 54 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 121 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7 .GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) 11T outdoor Air Temperature.
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. var. Dep. Var. 73.0933652
73.0879632
73.0827214
73.0727187
73.0679579
41520. 73.0633577
41580. 73 .0589181 73.0546392
41700. 73.0465639
41880. 41940. 73.0356581
42000. 73.0323451
42060. 73.0291932
73.0262027
42180. 73.0233734
42240. 73.0181932
42360. 73.0158542
42480, 73 .0097887 73.00Sl.78
42840, 73.0029127
42900. 73.0020228
42960. 73.0012946
73 .00072(12.
43200. 43260, 73 .0000809 43320, 73.0003236
43380. 73 .0007282 7J.0012!M6
43500. 73 .0020228 43620. 73 .0039645 43580. 73,0065532
73.0080901
73 .00978(17
73,0136708
73.0158542
73.0181992
73.0207056
73.0233734
73.0262027
73.0323451
44580. 73.0427676
44640. 73.0465639
73.0505211
44760. 73,0546392
44940. 73.0679579
45060. 73.0776399
45120, 73.0827214
73.0879632
73.0Sl33652
73.0989272
45360. 73.1046491
73.1105309
73.1227735
45660. 73.1356541
45780. 73.1491716
73.1561689
73.17064 46020. 73.1781135
73.1857454
46200. 73.2014839
73.2262763
46440. 73.2435924
46740. 46800. 73.2896305
73.2993077
46920. 46980. 73.3191305
73.3500322
73.3714096
47340. 73.3823305
73.3934059
73.4275574
47700. 73.4510939
47760. 73.4630921
73.5000039
73.5126127
73.5382864
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
RevisionO
Page B56 ofB156 55 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 122 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_Lo\l
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) llT Dl.ltdoor
Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time {sec) Dep. Var.' Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 48240. 73.5645664
73.577.9331
48360. 73.5914507
48420. 73.6051188
48480. 73.6189372
48540. 73.6329057
48600. 73.647024
48660. 73.6612917
48720. 73.6757087
48780. 73.6902747
73. 7348636 49020. 73.7500226
49080. 73.7653292
49140. 73.780783
73.7963838
49260. 73.8121313
49320. 73.8280251
49380. 73.844065
49560. 73.8930579
49620. 73.909679
73.9604079
49860, 73.9776051.
50040. 74.0300545
50100. 74.0478226
50400. 74.1387841
50460. 74.1573982
74.1761521
74.1950455
50640. 74 .2140779 50700. 74.2332491
74.2915912
74.3113135
74.3311727
51060. 74.3511684
51120. 74.3713002
51180. 74.3.915677
51240. 74.4119705
51300. 74.4325083
51360. 74.4531806
51420. 74 .4739871 51480. 74 .4949274 74.516001
74.5372076
51660. 74.5585468
51780. 74.6016212
74.7115982
52140. 74.733983
74.7564966
52260. 74.7791386
74.8019086
52380. 74.8248061
74.8478307
52500. 74.8709819
52560. 52620. 74.9176625
75.0849686
75.1093616
53520. 75.3088468
75.3343179
75.3599063
75.4373712
53940. 75.4634243
54000. 75.4895924
54060. 75.5158748
54240. 75.5954038
54360. 75.6489861
75.6759446
54480. 75.8677296
54900. 75.8955606
55200. 55260. 76.0647685
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
RevisionO
Page B57 ofB156 56 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 123 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_7 .GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_ LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_?a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.} outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var. ; Time (sec) Dep. var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 76.0933351
55380. 76.1220047
76.1507767
76.1796505
76.2377014
55660. 76.2668775
76.2961531
55860. 76.3550011
76.4142409
56040. 76.4440063
76.473868
56160. 76.5038254
56220. 76.5338778
56280. 76.5640249
56340. 76.5942659
56460. 76.6550275
56580. 76.7161581
56640. 76.7468603
76.777653
76.8395075
76.301717
57000, 76.9329533
57060. 76.9642766
57120. 76.9956863
57180. 77.0271817
77.0587622
77.1221764
77.1859239
77.2179212
77.25 57660. 77.2821597
77.3143997
577!10. 77.37!11182
57900. 77,4441505
58020. 58140. 77.5422766
58260, 77.6080717
58320. 77.6410808
77.7073186
58500. 58560. 58620. 77.8072153
58740. 58800. 58860. 77.9413922
77.9751074
59990. 78.0089897
59040. 78.0766531.
5!1160. 78.1106329
59220. 59280. 78.1787854
78.2129568
59400. 59460. 78.2814!167
59520. 78.315844
78,4192767
59760. 78.4539724
59940. 79.559005
78.6277079
60120. 60180. 78.6976295
78.7326707
78.8029104
60480. 60540. 78.9086535
60600. 60660. 79.0503317
60960. 61020. 79.1927562
79,2294738
61140. 79.2642347
79.3000381.
79.37177 79.4436639
61500. 61620. 61800. 79.66026'33
79.6964898
61980. 79.7G90451
79.8053726
62280. 62340. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B58 ofB156 57 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 124 of 254 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) llT Outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. var. 62400. 62460. 62520. 80.0970954
62640. B0.17Dl07l
62700. B0.24362 62820. 62880. 80.3170286
62940. 63000. 80.3905274
63120. 80,4641106
63180. 63240. 80,5377727
63300. 63360. 63420. 80.6853111
80.7591762
63660. 63720. 80.90707 63900. 63960. 64080. 64140. 64200. 81.1292352
64260. 64320. Bl.2033543
81.277.059
64500. 81.3516546
64620. 64680. 81.4258244
64740. 64800, 6020. 81.5741756
64980. 65040, 81.6483454
65100. 81.7225041
65220. 65340. 65400. Bl.8707648
65460. 65520. Sl.9448556
65580. 65820. 65880. 82.1669023
65940. 66240. 82.3884919
66300, 66360. 82.4622273
66420. 66600. 66840. 82.75638 67200. 67260. 83.049002
Bl.1946274
67620. 67680. 83.2672494
67860. 68040. 83.4842856
68100. 68160. 83.5563361
68220. 68100. 68520. 83.7715262
68580. 68700. 68880. 69000. 84.1-970896
84.2673293
69420. Dap. Var. 80,0605292
80.1336882
80.3537671
80.5009321
80.5746316
80.6484015
80,8700778
81.0181113
81.0921859
81.1662916
81.3887384
81.4629ll9
81.6854265
81,7595774
81.8337084
82.0559266
82.1299222
82.2777638
82.4253684
82.4990679
82.7196873
83.0125201
83.7357653
83.8072438
83.8785466
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B59 ofB156 58 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 125 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function {cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var,: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Dep. Var. 69480. 84.3373583
69540. 69600. 69660. 84.441995
69780, 84.5114738
69840. 84.5461276
69900. 84,5807233
69960. 84.6152604
70020, 70080. 84.684156
70320. 84.8212146
70380. 84.8553228
70440. 84.8893671
70500. 84.9233469
84.9572615
70620. 84.9311103
85.0922552
70860. 71040. 71160. ss.2nss14
85.3258367
71280. 71640. 71700. 85.5884045
71760. 85.6208818
85.6532806
71940. 85.7178403
85.75 72060. 85.7820788
72120. 85.8140761
72180. 85.8459912
86.0043137
72540. 86.0357234
86.0670467
72660. 86.098283
72720, 86.1294318
86.1604925
72840. 86.15114644
86.222347
86.3449725
86.4057341
73320. 86.4359751
73380. 86.4661222
73440. 86.4961746
73560. 86.5559937
73620. 86.5857591
73800. 86.6744722
73860. 86.7038469
73920. 86.7331225
73980. 86.7622985
74100. 85.8203495
86.9066649
86.9352315
74760. 87.1322704
74820. 87.1599942
87.2969861
87.5626288
75780. 87.5885665
87.7165065
76140. 87.7918541
76500. 87.8906384
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B60 ofB156 59 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 126 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Corriparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) llT outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. var. Dep. Var. Ind. var. Dep. Var. 76560. 87.3150314
76620. 87.9393024
87.9634507
76740. 87.987476
88.0113778
88.0351556
76920. 76980. 17040. 88.1057407
77100. 88.1290181
77160. BB,1521693
77220. 88 .1751939 88.1980914
88.2208614
88.266017
77520. 98,2884018
77580. 88. 3106574 88.3327833
88.3547791
77760. 88.3766445
77820. 88.3983789
88.4199819
88.4414532
78000, 78060. 88.5050726
88.5260129
78240. 78300. 88.5674917
78360, 88.5880295
88.6084323
88.6286998
88.6488316
78600, 78660. 88.6886865
78720. 88.7084088
78780. 88. 7279939 78840. BB.7474414
78900. 88.7667509
88.7859221
88.8049545
88.8238479
88.8426018
79200. 88.8612159
79260. 88.8796899
7!:1320. 79380. 88.9521774
79560. 79620. 79680. 79740. 89.0223949
89.03959.21
89.0566457
89.0735555
89.1069421
89.1234183
89.1397494
89.155935
80400. 89.2036162
80460. 89.219217
80520. S9.2346708
80580. 89.2499774
89.2651364
89.2801476
89.2950106
89.3097253
80880. 81000. 89.352976
81060. 89.3670943
89.3948812
81360. 89.4617136
81660. 81720. 89.5369079
81900. 89.5489061
89.5607511
89.5724426
82200. 89.6065941
89.6176695
82320. 89.6285904
89.6393566
89.6908588
89.7006923
89.7103695
82860. 83100. 83160. 89.7651443
89.7737237
89.7904097
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAl-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B61 ofB156 60 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 127 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ind. Var. 83640. 83760. 84120. 84360. 84480.
84600. 84960. 85920. 86160. 86640. 87240. 87500. 87840. 87960. 88080. 88920. 89400. 89760. 90600. Function {cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var. : Temperature
{F) Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 89.82936 83700. 89.8366749
83820. 89.8508284
89.8576667
89.8708659
89.8772265
89.8834276
89.8894691
89.8953509
84300. 89.9120368
89.9172786
84540. 89.9223601
89.9272813
84660. 89.9320421
89.9410819
89.9453608
89.9534361
89.9608677
89.9708068
89.9737!173
85380. 89.9766266
89.9792944
89.9902113
89.9919099
89.9934468
89.994822
89.9960355
89.!:1987054
89.9996764
86340. 89.9999191
89.9992718
89.9987054
86820. 89.9960355
86940. 89.51934468
89.9919099
89.9883511
87160. 89.51863292
89.9841458
87300. 89.9818006
89.9766266
89.9737.973
87540. 89.9708068
89.9676549
87660. 89.9643419
89.9608677
87780. 89.9494789
89.9453608
89.9066348
88620. 89.88946511
89.8708659
88860. 89.8643459
89.8576667
89.8064644
89.7985161
89460, 89.7904097
89.756'1076
89.7384627
89.7103695
89.6908588
89.6604238
89.6065941
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B62 ofB156 61 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 128 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_?a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ind. Var. 90720. 90960. 91080. 91200. 91440. 91560. !11680. 91800, Function (cont.) llT outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (see) Dep. Var. : Temperature (Fl Dep. Var. Ind. var. 89.5839804
90780. 89.5369079
91020. 8;1,5124527
91140. 91260, 91380. 89.4354336
91500. 89.4085493
89.3810628
91740. 89,352976
89.3242913
91980. 89.2950106
Dep. Var. 89.5724426
89.5489061
89.5247567
89.4999961
89.4746264
89.4486493
89.3670943
89.3097253
Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 41C Outdoor Air Temperature:
G=l. O aO=O. min=-1. e32 max=l .e32 tfunc Y=G*interp (alXl, tableX2) Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Etime I cM I 1.1 Table DCllT l. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 42C DG Intake Heat Transfer:
G=l.O aO=O. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
Gothic_s Name sum Y"'G* (aO+alXl+a2X2+
..* +arum) variable location Coef. Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value I Cond_grp_heat
(1) I cC70sl I 1. I -le+32 1 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Thermal Conductor
Type 24" Piping Mat. Bdry. Thick Sub-Heat Region (in) (in)
regs. Factor 0. 0. 00324 0. 0. 00324 0. 00648 0. 0. 00972 0. 01296 0. 0. 02268 0. 02592 0. 0.0486 0. 05184 0. 0 .10044 0. 06864 0. 0 .16908 0. 06864 0. 0. 23772 0. 04434 0. 0.28206 0. 04434 o. 10 0. 3264 0. 02592 0. Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B63 ofB156 62 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 129 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:20 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductor
Type (cont,) 24n Piping Mat. Bdry. Thick Sub-Heat Region (in) (in) regs. Factor 11 0.35232 0.01296 0. 12 o.36528 0.00648 0. 0.37176 0.00324 o. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Currerit File. Thermal Conductor
Type 8 36 11 Piping Mat. Bdry. Thick Sub-Heat Region # (in) (in) regs. Factor 1 1 0. 0.00324 1 0. 2 1 0. 00324 0. 00648 1 0. 3 1 0. 00972 0. 01296 1 0. 4 1 0. 02268 0. 02592 1 0. 5 1 0. 0486 0. 05184 1 0. 6 1 0 .10044 0. 06864 1 0. 7 1 0.16908 0. 06864 1 0. 8 1 0.23772 0. 04434 1 0. 9 1 0.28206 0. 04434 1 0. 10 1 0.3264 0. 02592 1 0. 11 1 0. 35232 0. 01296 1 0. 12 1 0. 36528 0. 00648 1 0. 13 1 0.37176 0.00324 1 0. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 44C DG Intake That: G=l.0 aO=O. min=-l.e32
rnax=1.e32
sum Y=G* (aO+a1Xl+a2X2+
*** +anXn} Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a CVVal (0) I cv4l.C I 0.21783386
1.1 Cvval (0) cv43C Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. # Function Components
Control Variable SOC Local Rho*V*D: G=l.0 a0=0. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
mult y .. G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *aruen), aO unused Gothic 5 Variable Coef. -Name location a Rm cV@ CVVal (0) cv49C Dhyd cV@ 1. 1. 1. Min. Max Value Value -l.e+32 I le+32 -le+32 le+32 Min. Max Value Value -le+32 le+32 -le+32 le+32 -le+32 le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B64 ofB156 63 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 130 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:21 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 4SC Local Vx**2: G=l.O aO=O. min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anXn), aO unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Uccxv I cV@ I 1.1 Uccxv cV 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 46C Local Vy**2: G=l.O aO=O. min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anXn), aO unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Uccyv I cV I 1.1 Uccyv cV 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 4 7C Local Vz**2: G=l.O aO:oO. min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
..* *anXn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Ucczv I cV@ I 1.1 Ucczv cV@ 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 48C Local (Vx**2 + Vy**2 + Vz**2) : G=l. a aO=O. min=-1. e32 max=l. e32 Y=G* (aO+a1X1+a2X2+
... +anXn) Gothic_s Variable Coef. Name location Cvval (0) cv45C 1. Cvval (0) cv46C 1. Cvval (O) cv47C 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 49C Local lvl' G=1 a0=.5 min=-l.e32
max::l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+a1Xl) "a2X2 or G* (alXl) "ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a 11 Cvval {O) I CV48C I 1. I Min. Max Value Value -le+32 I le+32 -le+32 le+32 Min. Max Value Value -le+32 I le+32 -le+32 le+32 Min. Max Value Value -le+32 I le+32 -le+32 le+32 Min. Max Value Value -le+32 le+32 -le+32 1e+32 -1e+32 1e+32 Min. Max Value Value -le+32 I le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAl-2007-004
RevisionO
Page B65 ofB156 64 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 131 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:21 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control variable SlC Local Re: G=l.O aD=O. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
div Y=G* (aO+a2X2)
I (alXl) Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value Visv I cV@ I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 Cvval (O) cvsoc 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 52C Local cp*mu: G=l.O a0=0. min:::-l.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anXn), aO unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value I Cpv I cV I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 Viscv cV@ 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 53C Local Pr: G=l.O aO=O. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
div Y=G* (aO+a2X2)
I (alXl) Gothic_a Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value Condv I cV I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 Cvval (O) cv52C 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 54C Re**l/2: G:::l.O aO=O.S min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl) "a2X2 or G* (alXl) "'ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value 1 I Cvval (0) I cv51C I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable SSC Pr**l/3: G=l.O a0=0.333 min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl) "a2X2 or G* (alXl) ""ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value 1[ Cvval (O) I cv53C I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B66 ofB156 65 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 132 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_ LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:21 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 56C o .62*Re** (1/2) *Pr** (1/3): G=0.62 aO=O. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *arum), aO unused Gothic_s variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value Cvval (0) I cv54C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 CVVal (0) cvSSC 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 57C (0.4/Pr)**(2/3)'
G=D.54288
a0=-.667 min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl) "a2X2 or G* (alXl) "ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value 11 CVVal (0) I cv53C I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File, FUnction Components
Control Variable SSC [l+(0.4/Pr)**(2/3)]**(1/4):
G=l.0 aO=l min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
Aa2X2 or G* (alXl) "'aO Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value I CVVal (0) I cv57C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 One cM 0 .25 -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. FWlction Components
Control variable 60C (Re/282000)
** (5/8): G=.625 a0=0.000392
min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
'"'a2x2 or G* (alXl) Aao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value 1 I CVVal (0) I cvSlC I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 61C [l+ (Re/282000)
** (5/8)] ** (4/5): G=l. O aO=l min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
Aa2X2 or G* (alXl) Aao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value CVVal (OJ I cv60C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 One cM 0 .8 -le+32 le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B67 ofB156 66 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 133 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 7.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:21 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 62C O. 62*Re** (1/2) *Pr** (1/3) I [1+ (O. 4/Pr) ** (2/3)] ** (1/4) * [l+ (Re/282000)
mult Y"'G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *arum). ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a CVVal {O) I cv59C I 1.1 CVVal {O) cv61C l. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 59C O. 62*Re** (1/2) *Pr** (1/3) I [1+ (0. 4/Pr) ** (2/3)] ** (1/4) : G=l.O aO=O. m div Y=G* (aO+a2X2)
I (alXl) Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a CVVal (0) I cvsac I 1.1 CVVal (0) cv56C 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 63C Local Nu: G=l.O a0=0.3 min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
sum Y::::iG* (aO+a1Xl+a2X2+
... +arum) Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a ii CVVal {O) I cv62C I 1. I Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 43C DG Intake Heat Transfer + Delay: G=l.O ao"'-5 min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
if (alXl+aO<O
alXl+aO=O
a1Xl+a0>0)
Y==Ga2X2 Y=Ga3X3 Y=Ga4X4 Min. Max Value Value -le+32 I le+32 -le+32 le+32 Min. Max Value Value -le+32 I le+32 -le+32 le+32 Min. Max Value Value -le+32 I le+32 Gothic_ s Variable Max Coef. Min. Name location Value Value Etime One One CVVal (0) cM CM cM cv42C 1. 0. 0. 1. -le+32 -le+32 -le+32
-le+32 le+32 le+32
le+32
le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Data File: 2 File Name: Case_7a_Panel_Temperatures.csv
File Type: TIME Parameter
Start Time Time Increment
End Time Description
Value UNUSED UNUSED UNUSED Reference
X, Y, Z July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B68 ofB156 67 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 134 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_7.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_7a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:21 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Data File; 2 (cont.) File Name: case_7a_Panel_Temperatures.cev
File Type: TIME Parameter
Description
Value Reference
X,Y,Z Volume UNUSED 0,0,0 Item 1 TV14 Item 2 TV15 Item 3 TV1' Item 4 TV17 Item 5 Item 6 TV1' Item 7 TVZO July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B69 ofB156 68 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 135 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:22 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Volume Initial Conditions
Total Vapor Liquid Relative Liquid Liq. Vapor Liquid Vol Pressure Temp. Temp. Humidity Volume Comp. Tracer Tracer # (psia) (F) (F) (%) Fract. Set Set set def 14 .3 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE ls 14 .3 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 2s 14.30335 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 3s 14. 31195 130. 130. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 4S 14.28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 5 14 .3 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 6 14.28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 7 14 .3 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 8 14. 31195 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 9 14.28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 10 14.28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE lls 14 .3 /96. /'J6. /40. 0. NONE NONE NONE m: }"* }SO* 12 14 .3 ... 40. 0. NONE NONE NONE \90. \90. \50. 13 14 .28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE Graphs Graph Curve Number # Title 1 2 3 4 5 0 M&E Imbalance
EM EE 1 Benchmark
Heat Rate Comparison
cvlC DC4T 2 Benchmark
Exhaust! /Inlet Tempe TVlslOS DCST TV12 DC6T 3 Div 1 DG Room Upper SubVolume
TVlslOS TV1s106 TVlsl07 TV1s102 TVlsl03 4 Div 1 DG Room Doors to Hall TVls41 TVls42 TVls43
TVls44 5 Div 1 to Hallway Pressure PR1s44 PR4s124 PR12 PR9 PRlO 6 DG Room Temepra t ure TVls39 TVlsB TVlsll TVlslOS 7 Fan Room and Outside Air Tempe TV7 TV1ls2 TV12 8 Fan Flow Rate LV7L LV6L 9 24hr Benchmark
T TVlslOS DCST 10 24hr Benchmark
Heat cvlC DC4T 11 DG Room T v Benchmark
l TVls47 /TV1s40 DC7T DCST \TVlsn 12 DG Room T v Benchmark
2 TV1s35 DC9T DClOT TV1s37 13 Hallway, 762', &: 712' TV4s124 TV9 TVlO 14 Wall Temperature
for the Small TA3s2 15 Atmospheric
Pressure PRllsl PR1ls2 PRlls3 16 Atmospheric
BC Flow Rates FVlO FVll 17 Recirculation
Mass Flow FV23 FV24 18 Leakage Flow Rate FV28 FV29 19 Hallway Door Flow Rates FV15 FV14 FV16 FV17 20 Relative Hurni di ty Above the Ai RHls85 RHls86 RHls87 21 Temperature
Above the Air Comp TVlsSS TVls86 TVls87 22 Divl DG Panel Temperatures
TVls43 TVls40 TVls39
TVlsS TVls37 23 Components
of Averages TVlsS TVlsB TVlsll TVls40 TVls43 24 Panel 1PL12JA Temperatures
TVlsl4 TVlslS TVls30 TVls31 I 25 Panel 1PL12JA Temperatures
TVls46 TVls47 TVls62 TVls63
}lV14 \TV14 26 Panels 1PL92JA/1PL93JA
Tempera TVls12 I I \TVl.S \TV16 27 Panel lDGOlJA Temperatures
TV1s7 TVlsS TVls23 TV1s24 I 28 Panel lDGOlJA Temperatures
TV1s39 TV1s40 TVlsSS TVls56 )TV17 29 Panel 1DG06SA Temperatures
TVlsS TV1s6 TV1s21 TV1s22 }l'Vl7 30 Panel lDGOlKA 12cyl Temperatur
TVlsll TVls27 TVls43 TVls59 )l'V18 31 Panel lDGOlKA 16cyl Temperatur
TVls7 TVls23 TVls39 TVlsSS }""" \TV20 32 Panel Bulk Average Temperature
cvlOC cvl4C cv1sc 33 Panel Bulk Average Temperature
cv22C cv26C cv30C 34 Division 1 Room Door DPs DP14 DPlS DP34 35 Division 1 Room Rollup Door DP DP16 DP17 DP35 DP36 36 Div 1 DG Heat Absorption
CV2C July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT I NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B70 ofB156 69 curve Ops \L2*TV15 (1PL93J /LPcvlOC (1PL12 \LPcvlOC (1PL12 Ll"cv22C (10006 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 136 of 254 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:22 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Fluid Boundary Conditions
-Table 1 Press. Temp. Flow s BC# Description (psia) FF (F) FF (lbrn/s) FF p lP outside Air 14 .3 '" I N 2F Outside Air 14. 266 );, )11 10000 N \l \ll 3P Emergency
Suppl 14 .3 72 N 4P Make-up Supply 14 .3 78 N Fluid Boundary Conditions
-Table 2 Liq. v. Stm. V. Drop D. Drop Drop BC# Frac. FF Frac. FF lP /H40 )0.024 2F H40 \0.024 3P H25 4P H25 Volumetric
Fan Vol Flow Flow Fan Flow Rate Rate # Option (CFM) FF lQ Time 3020. 2Q Time 3020. 3Q Time 77567. 4Q Time 4250. SQ Time 4250. 6Q Time 4250. 7Q Time 4250. SQ Time /1510. \2800. Time DT DT DT Dorn Min Max Ratio 0 .001 0 .1 le+OB o. 001 /1.5 1.
0. 001 1. )*-* 0. 001 l.5 1. \0.5 Run Options Option Restart Option Start Time (sec) Parallel Processes
Preprocessor
Multithreading
Revaporization
Fraction Maximum Mist Density (lbm/ft3)
Drop Diam. From Mist (in) Minimum HT Coeff. (B/h-ft2-F)
Reference
Pressure (psia) (in) FF GSD Frac. NONE 1. o. NONE 1. 0. NONE 1. 0. NONE 1. 0. -Table 2 Heat Heat Heat Rate Rate Option (Btu/s) FF Time 0. Time 0. Time o. Time 0. Time o. Time o. Time o. Time o. Time Domain Data End Time 5. 100. 1000. 86400. Print Graph Int Int 1. /60. 10. )k \10. 60. 60. /60. 3600. \3600. Setting /l \3 NONE 0. 0 YES DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT 0. 0 IGNORE Cpld FF BC# Disch Vol ls86 lls3 ls?O ls6 lsB ls54 ls56 ln Gas Error Relax T DEFAULT
DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT J ON OFF Elev. 0 Trip Trip (ft) N 749. N 10 800. N 749. N 749. Flow Heat Outlet Frac. FF (Btu/s) FF Quality DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT Dump Ph Chng L Flow Int T Scale Shutoff 0. DEFAULT DEFAULT
o. DEFAULT DEFAULT 0. DEFAULT DEFAULT 0. DEFAULT DEFAULT July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT FF NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B71 ofB156 70 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 137 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1
A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 O.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:22 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Run Options (cont. l Option Maximum Pressure {psia) Forced Ent. Drop Diam. (in) Vapor Phase Head Correction
Kinetic Energy Vapor Phase Liquid Phaae Drop Phase Force Equilibrium
Drop-Liq.
Conversion
QA Logging Debug Output Level Debug Starting Time Step Debug Time Step Frequency
Restart Dump on CPU Interval {sec) Pressure Initialization
Iteration
Pressure Initialization
Convergenc
Solver Command Line Options Function 3T Model Gen. Heat Rate Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. var.: Heat Rate (BTU//sec)
Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 0. 0. 4. 9 5. /0.25 9. 9 )0.18 10. 0.59 23 .9 )0.<3 24. 1.42 39 .9 )l.03 40. 2.44 119. 9 )l.77 120. 7.39 899. 9
900. 1199. 9 )40.89 1200. 72.37 4919. 9 4920.
7199. 9 7200.
14399.9
14400. 21600. )104.15 86400. 152.24 \110.68 Setting INCLUDE INCLUDE INCLUDE l.Oe-6 Dep. Var. /0.2 )0.15 0.451 )0.36 1.4l )l.02 2.36 )1.7l 7.3
)40.31 70.14
)102.96 152.24 \110.68 Control Volume Parameters
Vol Vol Elev Ht Hyd. D. # Description (ft3) (ft) (ft) (ft)
ls DG Room (Div. 1 82470. 737. 24. 24. 2* DG Room (Div. 2 54300. 737. 24. 24. 3s DG Room {Div. 3 64300. 737. 24. 24. 4S Hallway 143900. 737. 24. 24. 5 Day Tank Room 1300. 737. 10. 10. 6 Oil Tank Room 14000. 712. 24. 24. 7 Make up Air Sup 10000. 762. 24. 24. 8 Rest of El 737' 247000. 737. 24. 24. 9 Rest of El 762' 480000. 762. 24. 24. 10 712' El 480000. 712. 24. 24. 11* Outside Air le+07 737. 74. 20. 12 Fan Room 23750. 762. 24. 24. 13 Interposing
Int 1000. 762. 24. 24. I= )i!xx \15 \1PL93JA \D.787 \739.917 \l.354 \D.463 L/V IA SA Min Film (ft2) FF (ft) DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT /DBFAULT /DBFATILT )DBFAULT JJBFAULT )DBFAULT DBFAULT \JJBFAULT
\ \DEFAULT July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Min Film FF \ NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B72 ofB156 71 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 138 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:22 GOTHIC Version B.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Control Volume Parameters (cont.) Vol Vol Elev Ht Hyd. D. L/V IA SA Min Film Min Film * Description (ft3) (ft) (ft) (ft) (ft2) FF (ft) FF '"""" /xxxxxxx I= '""""""" /XXXXXXX /xxxxxxx /DBFAUL'I'
'"""&deg;' /DEFAULT I= )i!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFA1l'LT
DEFAULT }xxxxxxx )i!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )DEFAULT DEFAtJLT 12cyl )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xxxx )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xxxxxxx \20 \lDQOlXA 16cyl \9.868 \739.458 \S.833 \0.883 \DEFAULT \ \DEFAULT \ Control Volume Options Vol Pool HMT Pool Pool Pres. Pool Dp. Bum ICIP Damper Mult Opt Correction
Tracking Opt Drag 1. DEFAULT NONE " ON LOCAL l. DBFAULT ON ON NONE LOCAL 1. NONE LOCAL l. ON ON 1. ON NONE DEFAULT NONE ON DEFAULT LOCAL ON 13 1. LOCAL ON ON NONE ON '"""" I= /DEFAtJLT
I= I= /xxxxxxx /xxxxxxx I= '"""" )!!xx )!xx.xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )=xx )i!xx )!xx.xx )DEFAULT DB FAULT )=xx )i!xx )!xx.xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )=xx )DEFAULT DBI!' AULT }xxxxxxx )!xx.xx )DEFAULT DB FAULT }xxxxxxx )i:!.x )!xx.xx )DBll'AULT
DB FAULT }xxxxxxx \20 \1. \DBFAtJLT
\LOCAL \ON \ \ON \NONE \ON Laminar Leakage Ref Ref Sink Leak Vol Temp Humid Model Rep sub vol (t/hrl (psial (Fl ,,, Option Wall Option (ft2) DEFAULT UNIFORM CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT UNIFORM DEFAULT 13 o. UNIFORM DEFAULT /xxxxxxx /xxxxxxx /=xx /xxxxxxx I= /xxxxxxx /DEFAULT )!!xx }xxxxxxx )=xx }xxxxxxx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )i:!.x }xxxxxxx }xxxxxxx }xxxxxxx )"""" }DEFAULT DEFAULT )i!xx }xxxxxxx }xxxxxxx )=xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xxxxxxx )=xx }xxxxxxx )DEFAULT DBFAUL'l' )i!xx }xxxxxxx )=xx }xxxxxxx )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xxxxxxx }xxxxxxx }xxxxxxx }DEFAULT DEFAULT \20 \0. \ \ \CNST T \ \tJNIFORM
\DEFAULT July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B73 ofB156 72 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 139 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Turbulent
Leakage Lk Rate Ref Ref Ref
Sink Leak Vol Factor Press Temp Humid or Model Rep Subvol Area # (%/hr) (psi a) (F) <*> Src Option Wall Option (ft2) fL/D ls 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 2* 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 3s 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 4* 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 5 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 6 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 7 0. CNST T u_NIFORM DEFAULT 8 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 9 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 10 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT lls o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 12 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 13 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT '"""" /xxxxxxx '""""'&deg;"'
/xxxxxxx /xxxx I= /xxxx /xxxxxxx /PBFAtJLT
I= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx >== )DBFA1JLT
DEFAULT >= )xxxxxxx )>=xxxx )xxxxxxx )=x )=x >== )DEFAULT DBFAtJLT >= )xxxxxxx )>=xxxx )xxxxxxx )=x )=x >== )DBFAtJ'LT
DEFAULT >= )xxxxxxx )>=xxxx )xxxxxxx )=x )xxxx >== )DBFAtJLT
DBFAUL'l'
>= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=x )xxxx >== )DBFAtJLT
DEFAULT >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=x )=x >== )DBFAtJLT
DEFAULT >= \20 \0. \ \ \ \ \CNST 'I' \ \t1NIFORM
\DEFAULT \ Discrete Burn Parameters
Min Min Max Burn Flame Burn Un Vol H2 02 H20 Length Speed Rate Burn Burn # Frac Frac Frac (ft) (ft/s) FF Frac Opt ls o. 07 0. 05 0. 55 DEFAULT DEFAULT
DEFAULT FBR 2* 0. 07 0. OS 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 3* 0. 07 0. OS o .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT
DEFAULT FBR 4* 0. 07 o. 05 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 5 o. 07 0. 05 o. SS DEFAULT DEFAULT
DEFAULT FBR 6 0. 07 0. OS 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 7 0. 07 0. OS 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 8 o. 07 0. OS O .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 9 0. 07 0. OS 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 10 0. 07 0. OS o.ss DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR lls 0. 07 0. OS O .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 12 o. 07 0. OS 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 13 o. 07 0. OS O .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR I= I= I= /DBFAULT /DEFAULT '"""" /DEFAULT )i!x. )DBFAULT DBFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )=x )DEFAULT DBFAULT )DBPAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )=x )DEFAULT DEFAULT )!!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )=x )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )=x )DEFAULT DEFAULT ):X )i!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )=x )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT \20 \0.07 \0.05 \0.55 \DEFAULT \DEFAULT \ \DEFAULT \FBR Continuous
Burn Parameters
Vol Min H2 Min Max Max Burn Vol Flow 02 H20 H20/H2 Frac (lbm/s) Frac Frac Ratio ls 0. 0. OS 0 .SS 1000. l. 2* o. 0. 05 0 .SS 1000. l. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B74 ofB156 73 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 140 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_1
O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_10a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Continuous
Burn Parameters (cont.) Vol Min HZ Min M= "= Burn Vol Flow H20/H2 Frac (lbm/s) Ratio o.os l . .. 1000. o. o.os l. o.ss o. 0.05 1000. l. o. 0.05 l, 0,55 1000.-" 1000, o.os o.ss o.os l3 0. 0.05 0.55 1000, 1. I== I= I= I= )!!xx >=xx >=xx )!xx.xx >=xx >=xx )!xx.xx >=xx )!!xx >=xx \20 \0. \0.05 \0,55 \1000, \1. Mechanistic
Burn Rate Parameters
Min Min Lam Burn Turb Turb Vol H20 Temp Limit (lbm/ftJ-sJ (F) Op' ls 1. 350. EDIS 2* l. 350. EDIS 1. l. 350. EDIS 1. DBFAUI.T l. 350. l. 1. 350. EDIS 0. 1. lls o. l, 1. 350. EDIS 350. l3 0. 1. 1. 350. EDIS /DEFAULT I= I= )!!xx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )DEFAULT DB FAULT >= >= >= )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= >= >= )i!xx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )DB FAULT DBFAULT >= >= >= )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )DB FAULT DEFAULT >= >= >= )i!xz )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )DEFAULT DB FAULT >= >= >== )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= >= >= >== \20 \0. \0. \l. \1. \DEFAULT \ \350. \ \EDIS \ Mechanistic
Burn Propagation
Parameters
Unburned Burned CC Flow Ig Min Ig Min Ig Max Auto lg Vol Vel Thick Steam Temp PF Frac (ft/s) (ft) FF (F) ,, 0.001 0.04 o.os 0.001 DEFAULT 0.04 o.os 0.55 DEFAULT 0.164 0.04 0.55 DEFAULT 0.04 0.164 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B75 ofB156 74 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 141 of 254 m NUMERICAL
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
NAI-2007-004
APPLICATIONS
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Revision 0 nn* .. rJ:"r'-ln.*r*r11!-""-11.r
*;.en.r.n.rrr.r-1:-:
t&#xa5;" Evaluation
Page B76 ofB156 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
75 I Current File: C:\Work\PenletClinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Pen
ey\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_1
Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Mechanistic:
Burn Propagation
Parameters
!cont.) Unburned Burned cc Flow Flame Ig Min lg Min Ig Max Auto Ig Vol H2 Vol Thick H2 Steam To mp FF (ft/s) (ft) (F) FF 0.001 0,164 0.04 DEFAULT 0.04 DEFAULT 0.04 0.164 0.04 o.os 0.04 0,04 o.ss DEFAULT 10 0.001 DEFAULT 0.164 0.04 o.os DEFAULT 0.04 DEFAULT 0.04 o.os DEFAULT 12 0.001 0.164 0.04 0.55 13 0.001 DEFAULT 0.164 0.04 0.55 DEFAULT '"'&deg;"' /xx />=0000< /xx /DEFAULT /xx /=x /xx />=0000< /=x /DEFAULT /xx }xx }xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xx }xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xx }xx }xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xx }xx )DEFAULT PED' AULT }xx }xx }xx )DEFAULT DEFAtJLT }xx }xx )DEFAOLT DBFAtJLT }xx )ii.,. }xx }xx )DBFAULT DEFAULT }xx }xx )DB:FAtl'LT
DEFAULT }xx ).,. }xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT ).,. ).,. )DEFAULT DBFAULT }xx ).,. }xx )DEFAULT DBPAULT }xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT }xx \20 \0 .04 \ \0.001 \ \DEFAULT \ \0.154 \ \0.04 \0 .os \0.55 \DEFAULT \ Pipe Parameters
Relative Lam Modulus of Vol Rough-Geom OD ID Elasticity
Stiffness
* ness Fact (in) (in) (pd) Factor l* DEFA " DEFA " DEFA " DEFA 5 DEFA ' DEFA 7 DEFA . DEFA ' DEFA 10 DEFA 11* DEFA 12 DEFA lJ DEFA /xxxx I= /DEPA I= I= I= '"""""""' >= )DEPA DEFA >= >= >= >= )DEFA DEPA >= >= >= >= )DEPA DEPA >= >= )XXXXDOU<XX
>= )ii.,. >= )DEPA DEPA >= >= )XXXXDOU<XX
>= )!!xx >= )DEPA DHFA >= >= )XXDOU<XXXX
>= >= )DEPA DEPA >= >= >= \20 \ \DBPA \ \ \ \ Plow Paths -Table 1 Elev Vol Elev Tilt Description (ft) (ft) (ft) (ft) (deg) (deg)
Hatch (El 762 f 760, 762. 0.1 Hatch (762' Hal 760, 762. 0.1 Hatch (762' Hal 762. Hatch (El 737 f 735. Hatch (737'Half
735. Hatch (737'Half
735. Maka Up supply Normal Fan to D 762. D.l 755. Exhaust f["om DG 760. 0.1 lls3 787. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 142 of 254 m NUMERICAL
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
NAI-2007-004
APPLICATIONS
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Revision 0
.... "1.r
t&#xa5;' Evaluation
Page B77 ofB156 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
76 I Current File: C:\Work\Penleri\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Pen
ey\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -Table 1 (cont.) F.P. Vol Elev Ht Vol Elev Ht Tilt Rot. Description (ft) (ft) (ft) (ft) (degJ (deg) Outside Air lbl 0.1 lP outside Air lls3 2F Divl-Div2
Upper 742. 742. Divl-Div2
Lower "' 737. 737. 00 Rl Door (Low 4*4 lsl6 737. DG Rl Door (Mid 41364 2.5 ls32 739.5 16 DG Rl Rollup (L 737. 2.5 lsll 737, 2.5 DG Rl Rollup (L 4s63 2.5 ls29 2.5 Dl-03 Roll Up 3s27 1. 1B4l 742. 1. " Dl-03 Roll Low 3*9 737. 737. 1. 20 Dl-03 Up 742, 1. ls37 742. 1. Dl-DJ Low '"' 1. 1"5 Emergency
Fan t 12 750. 12 769. 4. Recirc to Fan R lslDS 759. 2. 12 Emergency
suppl l3 12 774. Oil Fan Supply 13 774. l!C to Intake 774. 0.1 0.1 LoV Leakage Pat 13 1182 774. 0.1 " Hallway Leakage 749. O.l 0.1 Gen Fan Flow Lo /le7 /738. /1.5 738. )1s39 )742. )U Gen Fan Flow Lo 1'7 738. 738. 1.5 )1e39
Gen Fan Flow Hi ls SS 744,5 2. )1*" HU:s )2.5 33 Gen Fan Flow Hi la SS 2. ls56 2. \ls39 \742. \2.S 34 PG Rl Poor (Top 742, 2.1667 la48 DG Rl Rollup {U 4sl23 ls4.5 742. 36 DG Rl Rollup (T s ls61 N 744.S 2.> '"""" '""""""&deg;'
I= /:ir:: /7COCXXX /xxxxxx /xxxxxx /x /xxxxxx. I= Ix= I= Pressur >= >= )i!xx Pressur >= >= Prossur >= >= Pressur >= >= >= >= 12cyl P >= >= )!ix,. 16cyl P >= >= \44 \Exhaust Pip* Le \lslll \T \760.98 \0.01 \11113 \B \788.01 \0.01 \ \ Flow Paths -Table 2 Flow Flow
Hyd. Inertia Friction Relative Dep Diam. Length Length Rough-Bend Flow {ft2) (ft) (ft} (ft) {deg) Ope Ope 40. le-OS NONE NONE 160. 3. NONE '* le-OS NONE 15. DEFA NONE 160. 15. 3. o. le-05 NONE 7.1 NONE 42.6.9 NONE 20. o. le-05 NONE NONE 10.7 NONE 13 10.7 4.2 3. le-05 NONE 14 7.5 5. o. NONE 7.5 17 20. 5. o. o. 0. NONE '*' NONE July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 143 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_10.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Flow Path {ft2) 10.7 21 10.7 " " " /x= )i!xx )!ix,. )!!xx \44 Path " 21.3 5. 20. I= \10, Fwd. Loss Coeff. 0.1 0.1 0,1 0.01 2,78 2.78 Flow l'atha -Table 2 (cont.) Hyd. Inertia F:riction
Diam. Length Length (ft) (ft) {ft) .. .. 0. '* '*' '*' o. 0. 2. l. s. 5. 5.5 o. I= I= I= )x=x= )x=x= )x=x= )xx= )x=x= >= )xx= \5. \41. \ Flow Paths -Table 3 Rev. Critical Comp. Flow Coeff. Ope. Model 0.1 2.79 OFF Relative Dep Rough-Bend Flow (deg) Ope NONE le-05 DEFA le-05 le-05 DEFA le-OS o. NONE le-05 NONE le-05 o. 0.001 o. DEFA o. 0. NOT NONE /xx= /DBFA I= '"""' I= )x=x= )DBFA DEFA )=.,. ):=x )x=x= )DEFA DEPA )=.,. )xx= )DEFA DEFA )=.,. >= )DEPA DEFA )xx= )DEFA DEFA )=.,. ):=x )x=x= )DEFA DEPA )=.,. >= )DEFA DEFA )=.,. \DEPA \0. \NkT \NONE """ Drop Homog. Breakup Flow Coeff. Model Ope. OFF OFF OFF o. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B78 ofB156 77 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 144 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1
A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -Table 3 (cont.) Flow Fwd. critical Exit Drop Homog, Path Comp. Flow Lo .. Breakup Flow Coeff. Coeff. Opt. Model Coeff. Model Opt. 2.78 2.78 2.78 OFF 2.78 2.78 o. OFF 1. OFF OFF 1. OFF 1. OFF o. OFF 33 1. 1. OFF o. OFF 34 2.78 2.78 OFF OFF OFF 2.78 2.78 o. OFF OFF " 2.78 2.78 OFF OFF 0. OFF OFF /xxxx I= /xx /xxxxxxxx
"&deg;' I= I= I= I= I= )xx )xx )i!xx )xx )xx )iixx )xx ),.,. )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx )xx \44 \S.SG \ \S.56 \OFF \OPP \0. \OFF \OFF Flow Path:;i -Table 4 Forward Prop Flow Min Min Min Min With Path H20 Time Prop Frac: Frac: Flow Opt 0,06 NO CO FLOW 0,05 o.ss con.ow 0.55 o.os o.ss 0,06 0.05 o.os NO CO FLOW 0.06 o.os CO FLOW o.os o.os 0,06 0.06 0.05 o.ss o.s 0,06 0.06 0.06 o.ss COFl.OW 0,06 o.os 0.06 0.55 0.06 '-' 0.06 0.06 21 0.06 0.06 CO FLOW 0.06 0.55 0.06 0.06 o.s NO CO FLOW 0.06 0.05 o.os 0.06 o.os o.o5 0.55 D.5 31 0.06 0.55 0.06 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B79 ofB156 78 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 145 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -Table 4 Fo:r:ward
Flow Min Min Min Path H2 Frac Frac 0.06 o.os 3S 0.06 o.os 36 0.06 0.05 0.55 I= I= I= I= )iix. )!i.x )!i.x )!!xx \44 \0.06 \0.05 \0.55 \0.06 Cond Description
DG (Warm) {Conv) DG (Hot) (Conv) DG Rl E Wall PG Rl s Wall Ss PG Rl. N Hall 00 Rl. Ceiling under Fan Room Pivl Ceiling-762
Divl Floor !3s DG Rl w Wall Wall {Tank Room -DG Rl) lls Wall {PG R2 -Hallway) Hall {PG R2 -Other rooms) Wall {PG R2 -Outside Air) Div2 to 912' lSs Piv2 to 962' PivJ t1;1 Amb. l 7s Div3 to !362' lBs Div3 to !312' Ceiling (El 737ft Hallway) Hallway Floor Wall (El 737ft Hallway -outside l!.ir) Wall (Taruc Room -outside Air) Wall (Fan Room -Other Rooms) Wall (Fan Room -outside Ai:t") (El 737ft Other Rooms -Outside Ai:t") Wall (El 762ft Other Rooms -Outside Air) Wall (El 712ft -Outside Air) Fan Room to Amb. Fan Rm to !362' Fan Rm to Amb (ceiling)
/]COQ(. /:iocaoax )ii:x North Side South Side East Side West Side Top Side )!!xx North Side South Sida )!!xx West Side Top Side Bottom Side. \41 \1PL92JA North Side (cont.) Min I= \0.05 Prop M= *= With Time Prop Flow Opt o.ss '*' CO FLOW I= I= I= >= >= >= >= >= >= >= \0.55 \0.5 \NO \CO FLOW Thermal Conductors
Vol Srf Vol Srf Cond S. A. Opt Opt Typo (ft2) ls7-59 1:;17-59 648. "* llsl 936. bN 1:1104-2900. l*F /JsW /lsS-10 /2376. \3sE \lsW \2350. 2*N 4s5-36 670. 3*C 3600. 3*F 3600. 10 120. 936. 2 ' I= I= I= I= )!xx )!xx )!xx )!,.,. )!xx )!xx )!,.,. )!xx )!xx )!xx )!,.,. )!,.,. )!xx )!,.,. )!xx )!xx )!xx )!xx )!,.,. )!xx \16 \I \lsl2 \1 \7 \0.705 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B80 ofB156 79 Init. Grp T. (F) I/X 78. 78. 78. 78. 78. 78. 78. 78. 78. I= I= \78. \X \ 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 146 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 O.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20 :59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductors (cont.) Cond Vol Srf Vol Srf Cone'! S. A. * Description
A Opt B Opt Type (ft2) /=x '""""""" I= I= I= I= /=x /==> )!ix,. South Side )i.. )i.. )k )!ix.
Side )i.. )i.. )k )!!,.,.
Side )i.. )i.. )k
Side )ixx )k Bott= Side )ixx )k North Side )i.. )!xx )k south Side )!xx )!xx )k
Side )!xx )i.. )k
Side )!xx )!xx )k
Side )!xx )k North Side )!xx )!xx )k South Side )!xx )i.. )k
Side )!xx )!xx )k
Side )!xx )i.. )k
Side )!xx )k Bottom Side )ixx )k 12cyl North Side )!xx )!xx )k 12cyl South Side )i.. )!xx )k 12cyl Ell.St Side )i.. )!xx )k )!i:x 12cyl West Side )i.. )i.. )k 12cyl Top Side )!xx )k )!ixx 12cyl Bottom Sido )ixx )k 1Gcyl Horth Sida )i.. )!xx )k 16cyl South Sida )i.. )i.. )k 16cyl Ba.st Side )!xx )i.. )k 16cyl Wast Sida )!xx )i.. )k )!!xx 16cyl Top Sida )!xx )k l6cyl Bottom Sida )!xx )k
Air Piping )!,.. );:.,. )!xx,.
Air Piping )!xx );:.,. )!xx,. }illxxxx
Air Piping )!,.. );:.,. )!.xx \73s \DG Combuat. Air Piping \ls71-8 \8 \ls71-8 \7 \B \H8.6 Thermal Conductors
-Radiation
Parameters
Cond Therm. Rad. Therm. Rad. Emiss. Side A Side A Side B Side B Scope No ,, No 15* "' 1 .. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B81 ofB156 80 Init. Grp -* T. {F) I/X * I= '"""" )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx >= )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx >= )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!..xx )=x )!xxxx )!..xx )!..xx )=x )!..xx )!..xx )!..xx )=x )ix.xx )!-)ix.xx )!-)ix.xx )!-\78. \I \4 
L EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 147 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_Lo\i
_ LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductors
-Radiation
Parameters (cont,) Cond Therm. Rad. Emias. Therm. Rad. Emiss. * Side A Side A Side B Side B Scope 23 No No FULL 24 No No FULL 25 No No FULL 26 No No FULL 27 No No FULL 2B No No FULL 2* No No FULL JO No No FULL /xxxxxxx /xxxxxxx I= /xxxxxxx '""""""" )xxxxxxx >= )=x )=x )=x >= )xxxxxxx >= >= >= )=x >= )=x )xxxxxxx )!!.,. )=x )=x )!!xx >= )=x >= J=x )!ix. )=x >= )=x J=x )!!xx )=x )=x )!!,.,. )=x )xxxxxxx )=x >= >= J=x )=x >= )!!:x )=x >= )=x >= >= J=x )=x >= )xxxxxxx Jxxxxxxx )i!!x )=x )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >= )=x >= >= )=x )=x >= )=x >= )i!:x )=x )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >= >= >= >= )=x )=x )!!:x )=x >= )!i:x >= >= )!!:x >= >= >= >= )!!xx )=x )xxxxxxx >= >=->= )=x )=x >= >= )=x \7Js \No \ \No \ \F11LL Thermal Conductors
-tee Parameters
Side A Side B Node Cond. Spacing Thick. Thick. (in) Nodes Option (inl Porosity (in) Porosity July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B82 ofB156 81 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 148 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20 :59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductors
-Ice Parameters (cont.) -------Side A -----------Side B ----Node >re* Ice Ice Cond. Spacing M= FP Thick. Ioe ""'" Thick. Ice >re* * (in) Nodes Option (in} Porosity FF (in) Porosity FP 2 NONB NONE " NONB NONE " NONB NONE .. NONB NONE ,. NONB NONE ,, NONE NONE .. NONB NONE ,, NONB NONE 10* NONB NONE llo NONE NONE '" NONE NONE '" NONE NONS '" NONE NONS 15* NONB NONE '" NONE NONS 17* NONE NONS '" NONE NONS 19* NONE NONE ,., NONE NONE 21* NONS NONE 22 NONE NONE 2J NONE NONE " NONE NONE 25 NONB NONE 26 NONE NONE 27 NONE NONE " NONB NONS " NONB NONS 30 NONE NONE />=a I= I= I= /NONE I= />=a /NONE '""&deg;""""'&deg;
'""""' >= >= >= )NONE HONS >= )xxxx >= )xxxxxxxx )xxxx >= >= >= )HONS NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONB NONB >= )xxxx >= >= )NCNS NONE >= )xxxx )HONB NCNS >= )xxxx >= >= )NCNS NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NO!ra >= )xxxx )i!!x >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NO!m NONE >= )xxxx )i!xx >= >= )NONE HONS >= )xxxx )*on NO!ra >= )xxxx >= )xxxxxx )"ONE HONS )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx >= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx >= )xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )xxxxxxxx
)>=a >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )!ixx >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx >= >= )HONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )!!xx >= >= )HONS HONS >= )xxxx )NCNS NONE )xxxxxxxx )xux )!!xx >= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx
)>=a )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xux )NONE NONB )xxxxxxxx )xux )!!xx >= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )HONE NONB )xxxxxxxx )xxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xax )xxxxxxxx )xax )!!!x >= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )HONE NONE >= )xxxx )xxxxx >= )NONE NONS >= )xxxx )NONE NONB )xxxxxxxx )xxxx >= )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )ii:x >= )xxxxx >= )NONS NONE >= )xxxx
>= )xxxx )!!:x >= >= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx >= >= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx >= )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xax )xxxxxxxx )x= )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xax )NONS NONE )xxxxxxxx )x= )i!:x )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE )xaxxxxx )xax )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xax )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE )"""""""' )xux )NONE NONE )"""""""' )x= )i!:x >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )x= >= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )x= )xaxxxxx )xux >= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xax )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xax \lila \ \ \ \NONE \ \ \NONE \ \ July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B83 ofB156 82 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 149 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 1 O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Therm.al Conductors
-rce Parameters (cont.} -------Side A -----------Side B ----Node l\rea Ice Ice Cond. Spacing Max FF Thick. Ice l\rea Thick. Ice l\rea * {in) Nodea Option (in) Porosity FF (in) Porosity FF '"'&deg;"' I= /xxxxx I= /NONE /xxxxxxxx
/xxxx /NON& /xxxxxxxx
/xxxx )!ixx >= )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE )=xx )=x )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )!ixx >= )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx >= )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )"ONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx >= )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx
)=x )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE >== )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )"ONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx \7Js \ \ \ \NONE \ \ \NON& \ \ Thermal Conductor
Types Type Thick. o.o. Heat Heat Description
{inl (in) Regions (Btu/ft3-a)
Ceiling/Floor
12. o. Internal Wall WALL 12. o. 20 External Wall o. 23 1. DG Hot WALL o. 10 o. ' Internal Block WALL 11.625 0. 20 0. '"'&deg;"' /xxxxxxx /xxxx /xxxxxxxx
/xxxxxxxx
/xxxxxxx /xxxxxxxxxxx
/=x
>= )xxxx )!xx. )iixxxxx )=x \9 \24ft Piping \TtJBB \D.375 \24. \13 \0. Forcing Function Tables FFO Description
Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Points Constant DG Warm Temp Time {sec) Temporatur
2T DG Hot Temp Time {sec) Temperatur
Hodel Gen. Heat Time (sec) Heat Rate 4T Benchmark
Heat Time (sec) Benchmark
ST Benchmark
Exhau Time (sec) Benchmark
43 Benchmark
Inlet Time (sec) Tempcratur
7T Benchmark
Loe 1 Time (sec) Temperatur
Benchmark
Lac 2 Time (sec) Temperatur
14 " Benchmark
LOC 3 Time (sec) Temperatur
lOT Benchmark
Lac 4 (sec) Tempel:'atur
15 /xxxxxxx /=x /=x I= \llT \outdoor Air Tem \Time I sec) \Temperatur
\1535 Data Files File Inter-output Detail ' Name Typo palate Files Level 1 I /CPS_lA_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Cose_10.csv
I I ITS I SINGLE I =L /xxxxx
/=x /=x /xxxxxx /xxxxxxx \2 \Case_lOa_Panel
_Temperatures.
csv \TZME \1<BS \SINGLE \FULL July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Form.at Option NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B84 ofB156 I(= 83 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 150 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Conductor
Surface Options -Table 1 Surf Heat Cnd/ Sp Nat For Opt Transfer Nominal Cnv Cnd Cnv
Cnv Cnv # Description
Option Value FF Opt Opt HTC Opt Opt 1 Wall Direct DLM-FM VERT SURF USER DEF 2 Ceiling Side Direct DLM-FM FACE DOWN USER DEF 3 Floor Side Direct DLM-FM FACE UP USER DEF 4 DG Wann Temper Sp Temp 1. lT 5 DG Hot Tempera t Sp Temp 1. 2T 6 HTC Sp Conv /4.9 /=x />=>x>a< I= '"" '"""" I= I= I= I= forDG )xx= )"" )=x >= >=
)!xx,. )=x >= )!.,. >= \* \DG Intake HTC \Sp Conv \4.752 \ \ \ \ \ \ Conductor
Surface Options -Table 2 Surf Min Max Convection
Condensation
Rad to Steam Opt Phase Liq Liq Bulk Temp Bulk Temp Emissivity
# Opt Fract Fract
Model FF Model FF Dry Wet 1 VAP Tg-Tf Tb-Tw DEFAULT DEFAULT 2 VAP Tg-Tf Tb-Tw DEFAULT DEFAULT 3 VAP Tg-Tf Tb-Tw DEFAULT DEFAULT 4 5 6 VAP Tg-Tw 0. 0. '"""" I= I= I= /==x I= I== I= /DEFAULT /DEFAt7LT >= >= >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )!xx,. >= >= >= )==x >= )DEFAt7LT )DEFAULT \9 \VAP \ \ \Tg-Tw \ \ \ \0. \0. Conductor
Surface Options -Table 3 surf Char. Nom Minimum Char. Cond. Opt Length Vel Vel Conv HTC Height Length # (ft) (ft/s) FF (B/h-f2-F) (ft) (ft)
1 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT
2 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT
3 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT
4 DEFAULT DEFAULT
5 DEFAULT DEFAULT 6 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT '"""" I= I= I= /DEFAULT /==x /==x >= >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >== >== )!xx,. >= >= >= )DEFAULT >== >= \* \ \ \ \DEFAULT \DEFAULT \DEFAULT Conductor
Surface Options -Table 4 surf Total Peak Initial BD Post-BD Post-BD Opt Const Heat Time Exp Value Exp Exp Direct CT (Btu) (sec) XT (B/h-f2-F)
yt xt FF July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B85 ofB156 84 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 151 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1
A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Conductor
Surface Options -Table 4 (cont.) Surf Total Pook Initial BO Post-BD Pol:!lt-BD
DpC Const: Heat Time Exp Value Exp Exp Direct ' er {Btu) (.sec) XT (B/h-f2-F)
yt " FF I= I= I= I= /xxxxxxx /xxxxxxx >= >= >= >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!.xx >= >= >= >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx ,, \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ Control Variables
Initial Coeff. Coeff.
Description
Value Min Max lC Div l PG Heat Load l. le+32 Div 1 DG Heat Ab:Jorption -le+32 Bounding Panel T_bulk_avg
o. l. Bounding Pomel T_maJl Door T_bulk_avg
:ill Operator Act if Door T_ma:ii:;
WI Operator Action if l. -le+32 le .. 32 7C Panel 1PL12JA [Vole] o. le+32 Panel 1PL12JA [Temv] l. Panel 1PL12JA (Vole] [Temv] sump rod l. lOC Panel 1PL12JA T_bulk_avg
div -le+32 Panel 1PL.92JA/1PL93JA
[Vole] 0. o. -le+32 le+J2 lZC Panel 1PL92JA/1PL!13JA
[Temv] 1. Panel 1PL92JA/1PL!l3JA
{Vole] [T aurnprod 1. l<C Panel 1PL!l2Ja/1PL!l3JA
T_bulk_a div l, o. -le..,32 Panel 1DG01JA [Vole] 0. o. le+32 Panel lDGOlJA [Temv] l. le+32 l7C Panel lDGOlJA {Vole] (Temv] aumprod -le+32 Panel lDGOlJA T_bulk_avg
div o. le.f.32 Panel 1DG06SA [Vole] -le+32 le+32 Panel 1DG06SA [Temv] -le+32 Panel 1DG06SA (Vole) [TemvJ aumprod 1. le+32 Panel 10006SA T_bulk_avg
div 0, l. o. le+32 23C Panel lDGOlKA 12eyl [Vole] l. 24C E'anel lDGOll<A l2eyl [Temv] l. 25C Panel lDGOlKA l2eyl [Vole] [Tem sump rod o. l. le+32 26C Panel lOOOlKA 12eyl T_bulk_avg
div o. l. o. -le+32 le+32 Panel lDGOlKA 16eyl [Vole] -le+32 Panel lDGOlKA 16eyl [Ternv) l. Panel lDGOlKA 16eyl [Vole] [Tem sump rod 1. Panel lDGOlKA 16eyl T_bulk_avg
div 1. Rc;illup Door [Vole] Rollup Door [Ternv) Rollup Door [Vole] [Temv] sump rod o. l. Rollup Door T_bulk_avg
div lc+32 Personnel
Door [Vole] Personnel
Door [Temv] o. Personnel
Door [Vole] [Temv] sump rod l. Personnel
Door T_bulk_avg
div Max Door Temperature
Max Door T_bulk_avg
0, l. 0. le+J2 '""""""" '""""""" I= I= )!!ix >= Air Temperature )ixxxxxx
Heat. Transfer )ixxxxxx
Heat Tranafor .f. Dela )ii.x..x )ixxxxxx
Thot. )ixxxxxx
>==. )ixxxxxx
)==. )ixxxxxx
)==. )ixxxxxx
+ vy**z + vz:**2) )ixxxxxx )!!ix )ixxxxxx \SOC \Local Rho*V*D \mult \0. \1. \0. \-le+32 \le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Upd. Int. Mult. I= \0. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o.
o. NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B86 ofB156 85 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 152 of 254 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Control Variablea (cont.) c:v Fune. Initial Coeff. Coeff. * Description
Form Value G ao Min Max '""""' I= '""""'&deg;"'
'""""'&deg;"'
'""""'&deg;"'
'"""""""'
I= I= (l/2) *PrH (l/J) .. 12/3)
(2/3)] ** (l/4)
(1/2) "'Pr** (1/3) / [l+(O
** (5/8)
** (5/8)] .. (4/5) \63C \Local Nu \sum \0. \1. \0.3 \-le+32 \le+32 * Turbulence
Parameters
1----Liquid --1 1----Vapor --1 Vol Mclee. Tllrb. Mix.L. PrT ScT Mix.L PrT ScT Phase Diff. Model (ft) Ne. (ft) Ne. Ne. Option " NO NONE o. 0. 2s NONE 0. o. o. o. VAPOR 3* NO NONE o. o. 0. VAPOR .. NO NONE o. o. NO NONE o. o. o. o. VAPOR NO NONE 0. 0. o. VAPOR NO NONE 0. 0. o. 0. NO NONE 0. 0. o. VAPOR 10 NO NONE o. o. VAPOR 11* NONE o. o. 0. 12 NO NONE o. 0. o. VAPOR 13 NO NONE 1. 1. 1. 1. VAPOR '""""" '""""" /=x I= I= I= I= I= I= I= >= )ix.xxx )ix.xxx >= )ix.xxx )ix.xxx )iixxx >= )ix.xxx )ix.xxx >= )ix.xxx )ix.xxx )i!xxx >= )ix.xxx )ix.xxx >= )ix.xxx )ix.xxx >= )ix.xxx )ix.xxx >= )ix.xxx )ix.xxx )i!xxx >= )ix.xxx )ix.xxx >= )ix.xxx )ix.xxx >= )ix.xxx )ix.xxx >= )ix.xxx )ix.xxx \20 \NO \NONE \ \1. \1. \1. \1. \VAPOR Cell Blockages
-Table l. Volume 1.s Blockage No. Description
Type 1 Day TanJt Room BLK B I N /x=xx /=x /=x /x /x /x )!)i )!}i )!}i )!}i >== )!}i 12cyl )!)i \B \1DG01KA 16cyl \BLlt \B \J: \N July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Upd. Int. Mult. I=
 
\0. NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B87 ofB156 86 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 153 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
10.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:23 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Cell Blockages
-Table 2 Volume ls Blockage Coordinates
& Dimensions (ft) Angle No. Xl Yl Zl X2 Y2 Z2 X3 Y3 Z3 L (Deg) 1 0. 0. 0. 10. 10. 10. lxx= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= >= >= )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )!.xx. )i!xxxx >= )xxxxxx >= )xxxxxx >= )!.xx. >= )xxxxxx >= >= >= >= )xxxxxx )xxxxxx >= )xxxxxx )!.x.x )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxxxx \8 \29.479 \11.583 \2.458 \30.479 \14. \8.292 \ \ \ \ \ X-Direction
Cell Face Variations
Volume ls Cell Blockage Area Hyd. Dia. Loss Drop De-ent. No. No. Porosity FF (ft) Coeff. FF Factor def On 1. 1000000. 0. 0. -lsl 0. le-06 0. 0. ls5 1. 260. 0. 0. lsl 7 0. le-06 0. 0. ls21 1. 260. 0. 0. ls33 0. le-06 0. o. ls37 1. 260. 0. o. ls49 0. le-06 0. o. ls53 1. 260. o. o. ls65 1. 20. 0. 0. I= I= I= I= /xxxxxx:xzxxxx >= >= >= )!ixxxxxxxxxx >= >=
\ls21 \6 \l. \ \681.822 \0. \ \0. Z-Direction
Cell Face Variations
Volume ls Cell Blockage Area Hyd. Dia. Loss Drop De-ent. curb Ht No. No. Porosity FF (ft) Coeff. FF Factor (ft) def On 1. 1000000. 0. 0. lsl 0. le-06 0. 0. 0. ls2 1. 36. 0. 0. 0. ls5 1. 260. 0. 0. 0. lsl? 0. le-06 0. o. o. ls le 1. 36. 0. o. o. ls21 1. 260. 0. 0. 0. ls33 0. le-06 0. 0. 0. ls34 1. 36. o. o. o. ls37 1. 260. o. o. 0. ls49 0. le-06 o. o. 0. lsSO 1. 36. 0. 0. 0. ls53 1. 260. 0. 0. 0. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Curb Height 0. I= \0. NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B88 ofB156 87 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 154 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_1
O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_10a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Z-Direction
Cell Face Variations (cont.) Volume ls Cell Blockage Area Hyd. Dia. Loss Drop De-ant. curb Ht No. No. Porosity FF (ft) Coeff. FF Factor (ft) /xxxx I= I= /xx
I= )xxxx )xx )O* )xxxx )xx )O* XlCCCCCCCICCCC )xxxx )xx )!ixxxxxxxxxx )xxxx )xx )xxxx )xx )!X:xxxxx::xxxxx )xxxx )xx
xx )xxxx )xx )xxxx )xx )0 * xxx:iuccxx )xxxx )xx )0. )xxxx )xx )xxxx )xx )0* xxxx )xxxx )xx xxx )xxxx )xx )xxxx )xx xxxx )xxxx )xx )xxxx )xx )0. )xxxx )xx )0* xx=xxx )xxxx )xx )xxxx )xx \ls39 ,, \1. \ \586.'78 \0, \ \0. \0. Volume Variations
Volume ls Cell Blockage Volume Hyd. Dia. No. No. Porosity FF (ft) def On 1. 1000000. 1'1 l 0, le-06 1*2 l 1. 36. 1*5 l 1. 260, lsl7 l o. le-06 Isle l 1. 36. la21 l 1. 260. lslJ l o. le-06 ls34 l 1. 36. la37 l 1. 260. ls49 l 0. le-06 lsSO l 1. 36. lsSJ l 1. 260. ls65 l 1. 20. I= /xxxx=x /xxxx I= )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )!x..xx. )xxxx )ixxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx )ixxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx )ixxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx )ix..xxxx )xxxx \ls27 \7 \1. \ \158.76504
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B89 ofB156 88 
L __ _ EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 155 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Volume Variations (cont.) Volume la Cell Blockage Volume Hyd.. Dia. No. No. Porosity (ft) />==<= /xxxx I= )ixxxxxx )xxxx )ixxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx \ls39 \8 \1. \ \571.JBSOl
Conductor
Surface Options -Natural Convection
Variables
htc * {k/lJ * (A + e*aruc*pruo)
Surf Conv Var B FF Nom. FF ' o.59 0.25 /xxxx I= I= ''&deg;"""&deg;"&deg;'
);:..,. >= >= )xxxxx >= ,, \0. \ \0.59 \ \O.:ZS Conductor
Surface Options -Forced Convection
Variablea
htc * (k/l) * (A + B*Ra*"C*PrUDJ
Surf Opt Conv Var B Conv Var c FF Nom. o.a 0.037 0,037 ' 0.8 /xxxx I= I= );:..,. >= >= >= ,, \0. \ \0.023 \ \0.8 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the CUrrene File, Thermal Conductor
Type Panel Steel Bdry. Thick Sub-Region (inl (in) regs. 0.02268 0.02592 0.0486 0.0191 0.0191 0.10104 0.11528 0.00648 FF 0.25 I= I= >= >= )xxxxx )xxxxx \ \o.:zs \ conv Var O FF FF 0,333 I= I= >= >= >= >= \ \0.4 \ o. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B90 ofB156 89 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 156 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductor
Type (cont.) , Panel Steel Mat. Bdry. Thick Sub-Heat Region * {in) (inl regs. Factor 10 I l I 0.12176 I 0.00324 I l I 0. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function llT Outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. o. 90. 60. 89.9999191
120. 89.9996764
180. 89.9992718
240. 89. 9987054 300. 89. 9979772 360. 89.9970873
420. 89.9960355
480. 89.994822
540. 89.9934468
600. 89.9919099
660. 89.9902113
720. 89.9883511
780. 89.9863292
840. 89.9841458
900. 89.9818008
960. 89. 9792944 1020. 89. 9766266 1080. 89.9737973
1140. 89.9708068
1200. 89. 9676549 1260. 89. 9643419 1320. 89. 9608677 1380. 89. 9572324 1440. 89.9534361
1500. 89.9494789
1560. 89.9453608
1620. 89.9410819
1680. 89. 9366423 1740. 89. 9320421 1800. 89. 9272813 1860. 89. 9223601 1920. 89.9172786
1980. 89.9120368
2040. 89. 9066348 2100. 89. 9010728 2160. 89.8953509
2220. 89.8894691
2280. 89.8834276
2340. 89.8772265
2400. 89.8708659
2460. 89.8643459
2520. 89. 8576667 2580. 89. 8508284 2640. 89. 8438311 2700. 89. 8366749 2760. 89. 82936 2820. 89. 8218865 2880. 89. 8142546 2940. 89. 8064644 3000. 89.7985161
3060. 89.7904097
3120. 89. 7821455 3180. 89. 7737237 3240. 89.7651443
3300. 89.7564076
3360. 89. 7475137 3420. 89. 7384627 3480. 89. 7292549 3540. 89. 7198905 3600. 89.7103695
3660. 89.7006923
3720. 89.6908588
3780. 89.6808695
3840. 89.6707244
3900. 89.6604238
3960. 89. 6499678 4020. 89. 6393566 4080. 89.6285904
4140. 89.6176695
4200. 89. 6065941 4260. 89 .5953643 4320. 89.5839804
4380. 89.5724426
4440. 89.5607511
4500. 89.5489061
4560. 89.5369079
4620. 89.5247567
4680. 89. 5124527 4740. 89. 4999961 4800. 89 .4873873 4860. 89. 4746264 4920. 89.4617136
4980. 89.4486493
5040. 89.4354336
5100. 89.4220669
5160. 89. 4085493 5220. 89. 3948812 5280. 89. 3810628 5340. 89. 3670943 5400. 89.352976
5460. 89.3387083
5520. 89.3242913
5580. 89.3097253
5640. 89.2950106
5700. 89.2801476
July 25, 2017 '9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B91 ofB156 90 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 157 of 254 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinfon\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ind. Vilr. 57GO. 5880. 6000. G24.0. 6360. 6600. 6720. 684.0. 6960. 7440. 75120. 8520. 864.0. 8760. 9120. 9600. 9960, 10560. 10920. 11040. 1164.0. 11880. 12120. 12240. 12600. 12720. Function (cont.) outdoor Air Temporature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) """* Vilr. Ind. Va.r. Dep. Var. 851.2G513G4.
5820. 89.2499774
5940. 89.219217
851.2036162
851.1719749
6180. 89.155935
89.13974514.
6300. 89.1234183
6420. 89.090321
851.0735555
6540. 89.0566457
89.0395921
6660. 89.0223949
89.005054.5
6780. 88.9875713
6900. 88.9521774
88.9342675
1020. 7140. 88.8796899
7260, 7380. 88.7859221
7500. 88.7667509
88.74744.14
7620. 88.7279939
88.7084088
BB.6886865
88.6688273
7860. BB.6488316
88.6286998
7980. 88.6084323
88.5880295
8100. 88.5674917
88.54681.94.
s220. 8340. 88.483999
88.4.627924
8460. 88.4414532
88.3983789
8700. 88.3547791
8820. 88.3106574
88.2884018
8940. 88.266017
88.2435034
9060. 88,2208614
9180, 88.1521693
9300. 88.1290181
88.1057407
9420. 88.0823375
88.058809
9540. 88.0351556
9660. 87.51874.76
9780. 51900. 87.8906384
87.8414877
87.816731
1014.0. 87.7668574
87.6656821
10500. 87.6143883
87.5885665
87.5626288
1074.0. 10980. 87,4.312189
87.4045962
11100. 87.377861
87.3510139
11220. 87.2969861
87.2698063
8"1.2151179
87.159994Z
87.104.4.394
87.0765018
87.0181579
86.9920538
86.9636947
86.8779953
86.82034.95
86. 7913744 124.ZO. 86.7622986
86.7331225
86.5857591
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B92 ofB156 91 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 158 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 O.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version B.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function {cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var. : Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep, Var. 86.5559937
86.526132
86.4961746
13020. 13080. 13140. 86.4057341
13200. 13260. 86.344.9725
13320. 86.314453
13380. 86.2838419
13440. 86.2531397
13500. 86.222347
13560. 13620. 86.1604925
l.3680. 13740. 86.0670467
13860. 86.0357234
86.0043137
85.9728183
85.9412378
14100. 14160. 14220. 14280. 85.8140761
85.7820788
14520. 85.6856003
14580. 85.6532806
14640, 85.6208818
14700. 85.5884045
14760. 85.5558495
85.5232172
15000. 85.4248632
15060. 85.3319283
15120. 85.3589193
15180. 85.3258367
15240. 15300. 85.2261548
85.1927847
85.1593443
15540. 15600. 15660. 15720. 85.0248926
15780. 84.9911103
15840. 84.51572615
155100. 84.92334651
155160. 84.8893671
16020. 84.82121.46
84.7870432
16200. l.6260, 84.7185133
16320. 84.684156
16380. 84.64517382
84.6152604
84.5461276
16680. 84.4767627
16740. 84.4419515
16800. 16860. 84.3373583
84.3023705
84.2673293
84.2322355
17160. 17220. 84.1266445
84.0559993
83.9851595
83.9496683
17640. 17700. 83.6999619
83.6641166
18120. 18180. 18240. 83.4482033
83.412084
18540. 83.3759282
18600. 83.3397367
18660. 8).3035102
18720.
83.1946271
18960. 83.0125201
82.9760095
82.9029046
82.8663118
19440. 19500. 82.75638 19800. 19860. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B93 ofB156 92 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 159 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_1
O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1
A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Fu.notion (cont.) llT outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 19920. 82.5358894
19980. 82.4.990679
20040. 82.3515985
20280. 82.3146889
20400. 20460. 82.2038698
82.1669023
20580. 82.1293222
20Ei40. 82.09293 20700. 82.0559266
20760. 82.0189126
81.9818887
20880. 81.9448556
81.9078141
21000. 81.75166457
21180. 81.7595774
21240. 81.7225041
21420. Bl.6112616
21600. 81.5 21660. 81.4629119
21720. 81.4258244
21780, 81.3887384
22080. 81,2033543
81.1662916
22260. 81.0921859
80.9810874
22560. 80.90707 80.7961302
22860. 80.7222362
80.6484015
23040. 80.6115081
80,5746316
80.4641106
23340. 80.4273088
23400. 80.3905274
23460. 80.3537671
23760. 23820. 80.1336882
80.0970954
23940. 80.0605292
24240. 79.8781235
24300. 79.8417323
79.805372G
79.7327506
24540. 79.5157144
79.4796699
79.4436639
79.3000381
25260. 79 .2642347 25560. 79.0858696
25620. 78.9793966
26100. 78.7677645
26520. 26580. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B94 ofB156 93 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 160 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 1 O.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ind. Function {cent.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.; Time {sec) Dep. Var. : Temperature (F) Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 27060. 27120. 78.1787854
27180. 27240. 78.1106329
2736'0. 78.0427385
27420. 27480. 77.9751074
27540. 27600. 77.9077448
27660. 27840. 77.7738452
27900. 27960. 77.7073186
77.6410808
28140. 28260. 28620. 28680. 28800. 77.25 28860. 77.1859239
28980. 29040. 77.1221764
29100. 29220. 29280. 76.9956863
29340. 29400. 76.9329533
29460. 29520. 29580. 29640. 76.8085356
29700. 29760. 76.7468603
29820. 29880. 29940. 30000. 76.6246003
30060. 30120. 76.5640249
30180. 30480. 76.3845723
30540. 30840. 76.2086256
30900. 30960. 76.l5077G7
31020. 31080. 76.0933351
31140. 31200. 16.0363053
31260. 31320. 75.979691-6
31440. 75.9234982
31500. 31560. 31680. 75.8123899
31740. 31800. 31860. 32460. 32640. 75.3856117
32760. 75.183269
33180. 33300. 33420. 33540. 33600. 74.9886222
33660. 74.941191
33960. Dep. Var. 78.2129568
78.1446772
78.0088837
77.9413922
77.8741657
77.7405461
77.6080717
77.5422766
77.3467194
77.2821597
77.2179212
77.1540088
76.9642766
76.901717
76.8395075
76.777653
76.7161581
76.6550275
76.5942659
76.5338778
76.3550011
76.2961531
76.1796505
 
76.1220047
76.0647685
76.0079462
75.8955606
75.7848821
75.5687811
75.4634243
75.3599063
75.3088468
75.1585123
75.1093616
74.9648444
74.8248061
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B95 ofB156 94 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 161 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1
A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 r:unction (cont.) 11T outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time {sec) Dep, Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Oep. Var. 34080. 74.8019086
74.7791386
74.7564966
34260. 74.733983
74.71.15982
34380. 74.6893426
74.6672167
34560. 34620. 74.6016212
34680. 74.5585468
74.5372076
34920. 74.4949274
74 .4739871 74.4531806
35100. 74.4325083
74.3915677
74.3713002
74.3511684
74.3311727
35460. 74,3113135
74.2140779
35820. 74.1950455
74 .1761521 35940. 74.1573982
74.1387841
36120. 36240. 74.0657325
36300. 74.0478226
36360. 74 ,0300545 36420. 74.0124287
36540. 73.9776051
36600. 73.!1604079
36660. 73.9433543
73.9264445
36780. 73.909679
73.8765817
73.844065
37080. 37200. 73.7963838
37260. 73.780783
37320. 37440. 73.7348636
37500. 73.7198524
37560. 73. 7049894 37620. 73.6902747
37680. 73.6757087
37740. 73.6612917
37800. 73.647024
73.6189372
37980. 73.6051188
38040. 73.5914507
38100. 73 .5779331 73.5645664
38220. 73.5513507
73.5382864
38400. 38460. 73.4510939
73.4160196
73.4046357
73.3934059
39840. 73.2524863
3!:1900. 73.2435924
73.21785'15
73.20148)!:1
40260. 73.1935356
73.1491716
40680. 73.1423333
40740. 41100. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B96 ofB156 95 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 162 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 10.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_10a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) UT outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (Fl Ind. Var. Dep. var. Ind. Var. Dap. Var. 41160. 41220. 73.0727187
73.0679579
41520. 73.0633577
41580. 73.0589181
41640. 73.0546392
41700. 41760. 73.0465639
73.0427676
41880. 73 .0391323 41940. 73.0356581
42000. 42060. 42120. 73.0262027
42180. 73.0207056
7J.01Bl992
42360. 73.0158542
42420. 73.0136708
42480. 42540. 42660. 73.005178
73.0039645
73.0029127
42960. 43020. 73.0003236
43140. 73,0000809
43200. 43260. 73.0003236
73.0007282
43440. 43500. 73.0020228
73.0029127
43620. 73,0033645
73.005178
73.0065532
73.0080901
43860. 73,0097887
73.0116483
43980. 73.0136708
73.0158542
44100. 73,0181992
44.l60. 44280. 73.0262027
44340. 44400. 73.0323451
73.0391.323
73.0427676
44640. 73.0465639
44700. 73.050521.l
73.0589181
73.0633577
45000. 73.0727187
45060. 73.0776399
45120. 73.0879632
73.0:;133652
73.0989272
73.1046491
73.1105309
45600. 73.1291341
45660. 45960. 46020. 73.201.4839
73.2262763
46440. 46500. 46560. 73.2707451
46800. 73.2896305
46860. 46920. 73.3091412
46980. 73.3191305
73.3292756
47160. 47280. 73.3714096
47340. 47460. 47640. 73.4392489
73.4510939
73.4630921
 
73.4875473
73.5000039
48060. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B97 ofB156 96 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 163 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var,: Temperature (F) Ind. var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 48240. 73.5645664
73.5914507
48480, 73.6189372
48600. 73.647024
48960. 73 .7348636 49200, 73.7963838
49560. 73.8930579
49680. 50040. 50160. 50280. 74.101.Sl766
50520. 74.1761521
74.2140779
50760. 74.25255B6
74.2915912
51000, 51120. 51240. 74.411.9705
51600, 51720. 51840. 74.62JJ5S5
51960. 74.66721.67
52080. 74,7115982
52200. 74.7564966
52320. 52440. 74.8478307
52560. 52680. 74.941191
75.0365493
75.0849686
53160. 75.183269
53400. 75.2834935
75.3343179
75.3856ll7
53880. 75.4373712
75.4895924
75.6489861
54480. 75.7574832
75.8123899
75.8677296
55080. 73.5779331
48420, 73.6051188
73.6329057
73,6612917
48780. 73.6902747
48900. 7J. 7198524 49140. 73. 780783 49260. 73.8121313
73.844065
49500. 73.8765817
49620. 73.909679
49860. 73.9776051
49980. 74.0124287
74.0478226
74.0837839
74.1203101
50460. 74.l57J9B2
51540. 51780. 51900. 52140. 52260. 52380. 52620. 53460. 54300. 55260. 74.1950455
74.2332491
74.2720061
74.3511684
74.3915677
74,4325083
74.4739871
74.5585468
74.6016212
74.6452209
74.6893426
74.733983
74.7791386
74.8248061
74.8709819
75.1093616
75,2081459
75.2582587
75.3088468
 
75.3599063
75."11'1335
75.4634243
75.6759446
75.7301937
75.7848821
75.9515421
76.0079462
 
76.0647685
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B98 ofB156 97 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 164 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ind. Var. 55440. 55560. 55680, 55800. 56280. 56520. 56640. 56880. 57000. 57120. 57360. 57480. 57600, 57720. 57960. 58080, 58200. 58920. 5!:1160, 59280, 59520. 5.9640. 60960. 61440. 61680. 61800. 61920. 62040. 62280. Function (c:ont.) llT Outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature
{Fl Dep. Var. Ind. var. Dep. Var. 76.0933351
76.1220047
76.1507767
55500. 76.1796505
55620. 76.2377014
55740. 76.2961531
76.3255279
76.3550011
76.3845723
76.4142409
56100. 76.5038254
76.5338778
76.5640249
56340. 76.5942659
76.6246003
56580. 76.7161581
76.7468603
56700. 76.777653
56940. 76.9329533
57060. 76.9642766
76.9956863
77.0271817
77.0587622
77.0904273
57420. 77.1540088
57540. 77.2179212
57660. 77 .2821597 77 .3143997 57780. 77. 3467194 77.3791182
57900. 77 .4115955 58020. 77.4767828
58140. 77. 5422766 58260, 77.6080717
77.6410808
77.6741633
58500. 77.7738452
77.8072153
77.8406557
77.8741657
77.9077448
58860. 77. 9413922 58980. 78.0088897
78.ll06329
59220. 78.1446772
78.1787854
78.2129568
78.2471908
59460. 78.2814867
59580. 78.3847396
78.4192767
78.4538724
78.558005
60060. 78.66264.17
78.6976295
60540. 60660. 61020. 79.2284738
61140. 79.2642347
79.3000381
61500. 79.5157144
61740. 79.6240718
61860. 61980. 79.7690451
62100. 79.8417323
62340. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B99 ofB156 98 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 165 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_Lo\l
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sac) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 62400. 62460. 80.0605292
62520. 62580. 80.1336882
62640. 80.1703071
80.2069512
62760. 80.24362 62820. 80.2803127
62880. 80.3170286
62940. 80.3537671
63000. 80.3905274
80.4273088
63120. 63180. B0.5009321
63240. 80.5377727
63300. 80,5746316
63360. 80.6115081
63420. 80.6484015
80.7222362
80.7Sn762
63660. 80.7!161302
63720. 80,8330!il77
63780. 80.8700778
80.90707 80.9440734
63.960. 64020. Bl,OlBllll
64080. 81.0551444
641.40. 81.0921959
64200. 64260. 81.1662916
81.2033543
81.2404226
64440. 81.2774959
81.314.5735
64.560. 64.620. 81.3887384
64680. 81.4258244
64.74.0. 81.4629119
81.5 81.5370881
64920. 81.5741756
81.6112616
65040. 65100. 81.6854265
65280. 65340. 65400. 65460. 81.9078141
81.9448556
81.9818887
65640. 82.0189126
82.0559266
65760. 82.09293 82.1299222
65880. 82.1669023
6594.0. 82.2038698
66000. 66060. 82.2777638
66120. 82.3146889
66180. 82.3515985
82.38849U
82.4.253684
66360. 66420. 82.4990679
66480. 82.5358894
66540. 82.5726912
66600. 82.6094726
66660. 82.6462329
82.6829714
82.7196873
66840. 82.7930488
82.8663118
672DO. 67260. 83.0854543
83.1218765
83.1582677
83.1946274
67620. 67680. 83.2672494
67740. 83.3035102
678DO. 67860. 68040. 68100. 68160. 83.5563361
83.592303
83.6641166
83.7357653
68520. 68580. 83.8072438
83.842!H7S
83.9496683
68880. 83.9851595
68940. 84.0206034
69000. 69060. 84.1618924
69360. 84.2673293
69420. 84.3023705
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page BlOO ofB156 99 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 166 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_1
O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1
A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ind. Var. 69480. 69600. 69720. 69840. 69960. 70200, 70320. 71160. 71280, 71760. 72120, 72240. 72360. 72480. 72600. 72960. 73080. 73200. 73320. 73440. 73680. 73800. 74400. 74640. 75360. 75600. 75840. 76080. 76200, 76440. Function {cont.) llT Outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 84.3373583
84.4071712
84.4767627
84.5461276
84.6152604
84.684156
84.7528092
84.8212146
84.8893671
85.0248926
85.0922552
85.2926814
85.3589193
85.4248632
85.5558495
115.75 85.8140761
85.8778236
86.0043137
86.0670467
86.1294318
86.1914644
86.2531397
86.314453
86.4359751
86.4961746
86.6154277
86.6744722
86.8492233
87.1322704
87.1876101
87.2969861
87.3510139
87.'1577288
87.5104076
87.5626288
87,6656821.
87.7165065
87.8661236
69540. 69900. 70020. 70260. 70380. 70500. 70620. 70860. 70980. 11100. 71220. 71340. 71580. 71820.
72060. 72180. 72420. 72540. 72660. 73260. 73380. 73500. 74460. 74940. 75660. 75900, 76020, 76140. 76380. 76500, Dep. Var. 84.3722921
84.441995
84,5114738
84.5807233
84.6497382
84.7185133
84.7870432
84.8553228
84.9233469
85,0586078
85.3258367
85.3919283
85.4577234
85.5232172
85.5884045
85.6532806
85.7178403
85.8459912
85.9095727
86.0357234
86.098283
86.222347
86.28384.19
86.3449725
86.4661222
86.64451989
86.7038469
86.8779953
87.1599942
87.3240554
87.377861
87.5365757
87.5885665
87.6911532
87.8414877
87.8906384
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
RevisionO
Page BlOl ofB156 100 
L EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 167 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cent.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. var. : Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 76620. 76680, 88.0113778
76860. 76'920. 76980, 77040. 88.1057407
77100. 77160. 77220. 77280. 77400. 88.2435034
88.2884018
77580. 77640. 88.3327833
77760.
77880. 88.4199819
77940. 78120. 78180. 78240. 88.5468194
78300. 78360. 88.5880295
78600. 88.6'688273
78720. 78780. 78840. 88.7474414
78960. 88.7859221
79080. 79140. 88.8612159
79260. 79380. 88.9342675
7956'0. 88.9699455
79620, 79680. 89.0050545
79800. 79860, 80040. 89.1069421
80100. 80160. 89.1397494
80280. 8034.D. 89.2036162
80520. 89.2346708
80580. 806'40. 80700. 89.2950106'
80880. 80!140. 89.352976
81360. 89.4354.336
81420. 89.4617136
81840, 89.5369079
81900. 89.5607511
89.6065941
82320, 89.6285904
82380. 89.670724.1
82680. 82800. 82860. 89.7292549
83160. 89.7651443
83220. 89.8142546
Dep. Var. 87.9393024
87.987476'
88.0351556'
88.0823375
88.1290181
88.1751939
88.2208614
88.266017
88.3106574
88.3547791
88.3983789
88.4414532
88.5260129
88.56'74917
88.6084323
88.6488316'
88.6886'865
88.7:Z79939
88.7667509
88.8049545
88.8426'018
88.8796899
88.9521774
88.9875713
89.0223949
89.0566457
89.090321
89.1234183
89.155935
89.219217
89.2499774
89.3097253
89.3670943
89.4486493
89.5721.4.26
851,6176695
89.6393566
89.GBOB695
89.7006923
89.7384.627
89.7737237
89.7904097
89.8218865
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl02 ofB156 101 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 168 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1
A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time {sec) Dep. Var,; Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 83640, 89.82936 83700. 89.8366749
89,8438311
89.8576667
83940. 89.8643459
84000. 89.8708659
84060. 89.8772265
84120, 89.8834276
84180. 89.8894691
89.8953509
89.9010728
84360, 89.9066346
84480. 89.9172786
84600. 89.9272813
84660. 89.9320421
84720. 89.9366423
84840. 84900. 89.9494789
84960. 89.9534361
89.9572324
85080, 89.9608677
85260. 89.9708068
85320. 89.9766266
85440, 89.9792944
89.9863292
89.9883511
85740. 85860. 89.9934468
esno. e9_994e22
89.9970873
86100. 89,9979772
89.!1987054
86220. 89.9996764
86340, 89.99991.91
86400. 86460. 89.9999191
89.9996764
89.9987054
86700. 86760. 86820, 89.9960355
89.994822
87120. 87180, 89.9863292
89.9841458
87300. 87360. 87480. 89.9737973
87540. 89.9708068
87600. 89.9676549
87660. 89.9643419
89.9608677
89.9366423
89.9172786
88800. 89.8708659
88980, 89160.
89280. 89340, 89.8064644.
89.7.985161
894.60. 89,6908588
90300. 89.6604238
89.6285904
90510. 8!:1.6176695
90600. 89.6065941
90660. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B103 ofB156 102 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 169 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (soc) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 30720. B9.SBHB04
901140. BSl.5607511
89.5489061
90.960. 89.5365107!1
89.5247567
851.5124527
!11140. 89.4999.961
91260. 89.4746264
91320. 89.4617136
89 .4486493 89.4354336
89.4220669
91560. 89.4085493
Sll620. 91680. 89.3810626
91740, 89.3670943
89.352976
89.3387083
91920. 92040. 89.2950106
Following
table in the compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 41C Outdoor Air Temperature:
G::il. 0 a0=0. min=i-1. e32 max=l. e32 tfunc Y=G*interp (alXl, tableX2) Gothic_s Variable Coef. Name location Etime I CM I 1.1 Table DCllT 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 42C DG Intake Heat Transfer:
G=l. O aO=O. min:::-1, e32 max=l. e32 Yr=G* (aO+alXl+a2X2+
... +anXn) Gothic_s Name cond_grp_heat
(1) Variable location cC70sl Coef. l. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Thermal Conductor
Type 24" Piping Mat. Bdry. Thick Sub-Heat Region (in) (in) regs. Factor 0. 0. 00324 0. 0. 00324 0. 00648 0. 0. 00972 0. 01296 o. 0.02268 0. 02592 0. 0. 0486 0. 05184 0. 0 .10044 0.06864 0. 0 .16908 0.06864 o. 0.23772 0. 04434 0. a. 28206 0. 04434 0. 10 0. 3264 0. 02592 0. Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 I Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl04 ofB156 103 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 170 of 254 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 O.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Region 11 12 13 Thermal Conductor
Type (cont.) Mat. 24n Piping Bdry. (in) 0.35232 0.36528 D.37176 Thick (in) 0.01296 0,00648 D.00324 Sub-Heat regs. Factor 0. 0. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Thermal Conductor
Type 8 36 11 Piping Mat. Bdry. Thick Sub-Heat Region # (in) (in)
regs. Factor 1 l 0. 0.00324 1 0. 2 1 0. 00324 0.00648 1 0. 3 l 0. 00972 0.01296 1 0. 4 1 0.02268 0. 02592 1 0. 5 1 0. 0486 0. 05184 1 0. 6 1 0 .10044 0. 06864 1 0. 7 1 0 .16908 0. 06864 1 0. 8 1 0. 23772 0. 04434 1 0. 9 1 0. 28206 0. 04434 1 0. 10 1 0. 3264 0. 02592 1 0. 11 1 0. 35232 0.01296 1 0. 12 1 0.36528 0.00648 1 0. 13 1 0.37176 0. 00324 1 0. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. # 1 Function Components
Control Variable 44C DG Intake That: G=l.0 aO=O. min=-1.e32
max=l.e32
Gothic_s Name sum Y=G* (aO+a1Xl+a2X2+
*** +amen) Variable location cv41C Coef. a Cvval (0) Cvval (OJ cv43C O. 21783386 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. # Function Components
Control Variable 5 OC Local Rho*V*D: G=l.O a0=0. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y=>G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
..* *anXn). aO unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. Name location a Rm cV@ Cvval (0) cv49C Dhyd cV@ 1. 1. 1. Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 -le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32
le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page BIOS ofBl56 104 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 171 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control variable 45C Local Vx**2: G=l.O aO=O. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anXn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Uccxv I cV@ I 1.1 Uccxv cV@ 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 46C Local Vy** 2 : G:ol.O aO=O. min=-1. e32 max::::l.
e32 mult Y=G* (a1x1*a2x2*
... *arucn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a I Uccyv I cV@ I 1.1 Uccyv cV@ 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 4 7C Local Vz**2: G=l.O aO=O. min=-1. e32 max=l. e32 mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anJCn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a I Ucczv I cV@ I 1.1 Ucczv cV@ 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 4 BC Local (Vx**2 + Vy**2 + Vz**2): G=l.O aO=:O. min:=:-l.e32
max=l.e32
Y""G* (aO+alXl+a2X2+
... +arum) Gothic_ s Variable Coef. Name location CVVal (0) cv45C 1. Cvval (O) cv46C 1. Cvval (O) cv47C 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 49C Local /vj: G=l a0=.5 min=-l.e32
max:=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+a1Xl) "a2X2 or G* (alXl) "ao Gothic_s Name Variable location Coef. Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value I I I Cvval (0) I cv48C I 1. 1 -le+32 I Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B106 ofB156 105 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 172 of 254 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_1
Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable SlC Local Re: G=l. O aO=O. min=-1. e32 max=l. e32 div Y=G* (aO+a2X2)
I (alXl) Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value Visv I cV I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 Cvval (0) cvsoc 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 52C Local cp*mu: G=l. 0 aO=O. min=-l .e32 max=l .e32 mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anJCn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value Cpv I cV I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 Viscv cV 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 53C Local Pr: G::::l.O aO=O. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
div Y=G* (aO+a2X2)
I (alXl) Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value Condv I cV I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 Cvval (O) cv52C 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 54.C Re**l/2: G=l.O aO::::O.S
min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y::::G* (aO+alXl) "a2X2 or G* (alXl) "ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value 11 Cvval (0) I cvSlC I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable SSC Pr**l/3: G::::l.O a0=0.333 min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
'"'a2X2 or G* (alXl) '"'ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value 11 Cvval (O) I cv53C I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page BI07 ofB156 106 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 173 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Case 10.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control variable 56C 0. 62*Re** (1/2) *Pr** (1/3): G=O. 62 aO::iO. mini:i-1.
e32 max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1x1*a2x2*
*** *arum), ao unused Gothic_s variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value CVVal (OJ I cv54C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 CVVal (OJ cv55C 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 57C (0 .4/PrJ ** (2/3J' G=O. 54288 aO=-. 667 rnin=-1. e32 max=l .e32 exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
""a2X2 or G* (alXl) "ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max ff Name location a Value Value 1[ CVVal (OJ I cv53C I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable SBC (l+(0.4/Pr)**(2/3)]**(1/4):
G=l.0 aO=l min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+a1Xl)
'"'a2X2 or G* (alXl) "ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max ff Name location a Value Value CVVal (OJ I cv57C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 One cM 0 .25 -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 60C (Re/282000)
** (S/B): G= .. 625 a0=0. 000392 min,,,-1.
e32 max,,,,1.e32
exp y.,,a* (aO+alXl)
'"'a2x2 or G* (alXl) '"'ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value 1[ Cvval (0) I cvSlC I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 61C [l+ (Re/282000)
** (5/8)] ** (4/5): G"'l. O aO=l min=-l .e32 max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
"'a2X2 or G* (alXl) "'ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value CVVal (OJ I cv60C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 One cM 0. 8 -le+32 le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl08 ofB156 107 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 174 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_1
O.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 62C 0 .62*Re** (1/2) *Pr** (1/3) / [1+ (0 .4/Pr) ** (2/3)] ** (1/4) * [l+ (Re/282000)
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
**. *anxn). ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Cvval (O) I cv59C I 1.1 Cvval (0) cv61C 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 59C O. 62*Re** (1/2) *Pr** (1/3) I [l+ (0. 4/Pr) ** (2/3)] ** (1/4) : G=l.O aO::O. m div Y=G* (aO+a2X2)
I (alXl) Gothic_s variable Coef. # Name location a Cvval (O) I cvsec I 1.1 Cvval (0) cv56C 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. # FUnction Components
Control Variable 63C Local Nu: G=l.O a0=0.3 min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
Gothic_s Name Y=G* (aO+a1Xl+a2X2+
... +anXn) Variable location Coef. Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value I I Cvval (0) I cv62C I 1. 1 -le+32 I Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 43C DG Intake Heat Transfer+
Delay: G=l.0 a0=-5 min=-l.e32
max::::il.e32
if (a1Xl+a0<0
alXl+aO=O
alXl+aO>O)
y,,,Ga2X2
Y=Ga3X3 y,,,Ga4X4
Gothic_ s Variable coef. # Name location Etime cM 1. One cM o. One cM o. Cvval (0) cv42C 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Data File: 2 File Name: Case_loa_Panel_Temperatures.
csv File Type: TIME Parameter
Start Time Time Increment
End Time Description
Value UNUSED UNUSED UNUSED Reference
X, Y, Z Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 -le+32 -le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B109 ofB156 108 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 175 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
10.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:24 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Data File: 2 (cont.) File Name: Case_loa_Panel_Temperatures .csv File Type: TIME Parameter
Description
Value Reference
X,Y,Z Volume UNUSED 0,0,0 Item 1 TV14 Item 2 TV15 Item 3 TV16 Item 4 TV17 Item S TV18 Item 6 TV1* Item 7 TV20 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page BllO ofB156 109 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 176 of 254 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Ob.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59 :25 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Data Files File Inter-# Name Type palate l I /CPS_lA_DG_LoV_LOOP-LOCA_C***_lOa.cav
I TIME I YES )CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
C5so 10b.cl!lv
2 Case lU11. Paner Temperatures, Csv TIME YES \Case:=1ob:=Panel=
Temperatures, csv Conductor
Surface Options -Table 1 Surf Opt # l 2 3 4 5 6 7 B 9 Ind. Heat Transfer Nominal Description
Option Value FF Wall Direct Ceiling Side Direct Floor Side Direct DG Warm Temper Sp Temp l. lT DG Hot Temperat Sp Temp l. 2T HTC Sp Conv /6.15 \5.8 Herz Cyl for DG Direct DG Intake Sp Ambie DG Intake HTC Sp Conv Var. 0. 120. 240. 360. 480. 600. 720. 840. 960. 1080. 1200. 1320. 1440. 1560. 1680. 1800. 1920. 2520. 3120. 3720. 4320. 4920. le+06 Function 2T DG Hot Temp Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var. : Temperature
Dep. Var. Ind. Var. BO. 60. /350. 180. )375. 650. 300. )696 .428571 700. 420. )750. 700. 540. )750. 700. 660. )750. 700. 780. )750. 700. 900. )750. 700. 1020. )750. 700. 1140. )750. 700. 1260. )750. 700. 1380. )750. 700. 1500. )750. 700. 1620. )750. 700. 1740. )750. 700. 1860. )750. 700. 2220. )750. 700. 2820. )750. 700. 3420 *. )750. 700. 4020. )750. 700. 4620. )750. 700. 21600. )750. 700. \750. l. 44 4. 752 Dep. Var. /200. )214.285714
500. )535. 714285 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750 *. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. )750. 700. \750, Cnd/ Sp Nat Cnv Cnd Cnv Cnv Opt Opt HTC Opt DLM-FM VERT SURF DLM-FM FACE DOWN DLM-FM FACE UP DLM-FM HORZ CYL 9 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Output Detail Files Level I SINGLE I FULL SINGLE FULL For Cnv Opt USER DEF USER DEF USER DEF USER DEF I NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bll l ofB156 Format Option 110 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 177 of 254 NUMERICAL
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_1
Oa.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Ob.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:25 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function lT DG Warm Temp Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature
Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 0. 80. 60. /151. )153. 6'33720 120. /16'2. 180. 172. )164. 825581 )175. 240. 172. 300. 172. )175. )175. 360. 172. 420. 172. )175. )175. 480. 172. 540. 172. )175. )175. 600. 172. 660. 172. )175. )175. 720. 172. 780. 172. )175. )175. 840. 172. 900. 172. )175. )175. 960. 172. 1020. 172. )175. )175. 1080. 172. 1140. 172. )175. )175. 1200. 172. 1260. 172. )175. )175. 1320. 172. 1380. 172. )175. )175. 1440. 172. 1500. 172. )175. )175. 1560. 172. 1620. 172. )175. )175. 1680. 172. 1740. 172. )175. )175. 1800. 172. 1860. 172. )175. )175. 1920. 172. 2220. 172. )175. )175. 2520. 172. 2820. 172. )175. )175. 3120. 172. 3420. 172. )175. )175. 3720. 172. 4020. 172. )175. )175. 4320. 172. 4620. 172. )175. )175. 4920. 172. 21600. 172. )175. \175. 1000000. 172. \175. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision o* Page Bl 12 ofB156 111 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 178 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oc.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:26 GOTHIC Version B.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Data Files File Inter-Output Detail # Name Type polate Files Level 1 I /CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Caoe 10a. cov I TIME I YES I SINGLE I FULL )CPS -lA -DG-LoV-LOOP-LOCA
-Case -lOc. csv 2 Case llJ11. P!lileI Temperatures.
Csv TIME YES SINGLE FULL \Casa::::ioc::::Pa.nel::::Temperaturas.
csv Conductor
Surface Options -Table 1 Surf Heat Cnd/ Sp Nat For Opt Transfer Nominal Cnv Cnd Cnv Cnv Cnv # Description
Option Value FF Opt Opt HTC Opt Opt 1 Wall Direct DLM-FM VERT SURF USER DEF 2 Ceiling Side Direct DLM-FM FACE DOWN USER DEF 3 Floor Side Direct DLM-FM FACE UP USER DEF 4 DG Warm Temper Sp Temp 1. lT 5 DG Hot Tempera t Sp Temp 1. 2T 6 HTC Sp Conv /6.15 \6.8 7 Herz Cyl for DG Direct DLM-FM HORZ CYL USER DEF 8 DG Intake Sp Ambie 1. 44 9 9 DG Intake HTC Sp Conv 4. 752 July 25, 2017
AM EDT I NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 PageB113 ofB156 Format Option 112 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 179 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Od.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:27 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Data Files File Inter-# Name Type palate 1 I /CPS lA DG LoV LOOP-LOCA
Caae 10a.oav I TIME I YES )CPS -lA-DG-LoV-LOOP-LOCA-
Case -lOd.csv 2 Case ltJa Paner TemporatUros.
Csv TIME YES
csv Conductor
Surface Options -Table 1 Surf Heat Opt Transfer # Description
Option 1 Wall Direct 2 Ceiling Side Direct 3 Floor Side Direct 4 DG Warm Temper Sp Temp 5 DG Hot Temperat Sp Temp 6 HTC Sp Conv 7 Herz cyl for DG Direct B DG Intake Sp Ambie 9 DG Intake HTC Sp Conv Run Options Option Restart Option Start Time (sec) Parallel Processes
Preprocessor
Multithreading
Revaporization
Fraction Maximum Mist Density (lbm/ft3)
Drop Diam. From Mist (in} Minimum HT Coeff. (B/h-ft2-F)
Reference
Pressure (psia) Maximum Pressure (psia) Forced Ent. Drop Diam. (in) Vapor Phase Head Correction
Kinetic Energy Vapor Phase Liquid Phase Drop Phase Force Equilibrium
Drop-Liq.
Conversion
QA Logging Debug Output Level Debug Starting Time Step Debug Time Step Frequency
Restart Dump on CPU Interval (sec) Pressure Initialization
Iteration
Pressure Initialization
Convergenc
Solver Command Line Options Cnd/ Nominal Cnv Value FF Opt 1. lT 1. 2T /6.15 \5.6 1. 44 4. 752 Setting /3 \2 NONE 0.0 YES DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT 0. 0 IGNORE DEFAULT DEFAULT INCLUDE IGNORE INCLUDE INCLUDE INCLUDE IGNORE INCLUDE OFF 0 0 1 3600. 1. Oe-6 Sp Nat Cnd Cnv Cnv Opt HTC Opt DLM-FM VERT SURF DLM-FM FACE DOWN DLM-FM FACE UP DLM-FM HORZ CYL 9 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Output Detail Files Level I SINGLE I FULL SINGLE FULL For Cnv Opt USER DEF USER DEF USER DEF USER DEF I NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B114 ofB156 Format Option 113 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 180 of 254 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oa.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Od.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:27 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ind. Var. 0. 120. 240. 360. 480. 600. 720. 840. 960. 1080. 1200. 1320. 1440. 1560. 1680. 1800. 1920. 2520. 3120. 3720. 4320. 4920. le+06 Ind. Var. 0. 120. 240. 360. 480. 600. 720. 840. 960. 1080. 1200. 1320. 1440. 1560. 1660.
1800. 1920. 2520. 3120. 3720. 4320. 4920. 1000000. Function 2T DG Hot Temp Ind. Var. : Time (sec) Dep. Var. : Temperature
Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 80. 60. /350. 180. )"'* 650. 300. )742,857142
700. 420. )BOO. 700, 540. )BOO. 700. 660. )Boo. 700. 780. )BOO. 700. 900. )BOO. 700. 1020. )"'* 700. 1140. )"'* 700, 1260. )BOO. 700. 1380. )'"* 700. 1500. )BOO. 700. 1620. )'"* 700. 1740. )*oo. 700. 1860. )"'* 700. 2220. )'"* 700. 2820. )"'* 700. 3420. )"'* 700. 4020. )'"* 700. 4620. )'"* 700. 21600. )'&deg;'* 700. \BOO. Function lT DG Warm Temp Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var. : Temperature
Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 80. 60. /162. 180. )164.825581
172. 300. )175. 172. 420. )175. 172. 540. )175. 172. 660. )175. 172. 780. )175. 172. 900. )175. 172. 1020. )175. 172. 1140. )175. 172. 1260. )175. 172. 1380. )175. 172. 1500. )175. 172. 1620. )175. 172. 1740. )175. 172. 1860. )175. 172. 2220. )175. 172. 2820. )175. 172. 3420. )175. 172. 4020. )175. 172. 4620. )175. 172. 21600. )175. 172. \175. Dep. Var. /200. )228.571428
SOD. )571. 42 8571 700. )BOO. 700. )Boo. 700. )Boo. 700. )"'* 700. )BOO. 100. )BOO. 700. )"'* 700. )"'* 700. )BOO. 700. )'"* 700. )'"* 700. )'"* 700. )'"* 700. )'"* 700, )'"* 700. )'"* 700. )"'* 700. )"'* 700, )"'* 700. \800. Dep. Var. /151. )153.633720
172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. )175. 172. \175. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page BllS ofB156 114 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 181 of 254 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_ LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Volume Initial Conditions
Total Vapor Liquid Relative Liquid Liq. Vapor Liquid Vol Pressure Temp. Temp. Humidity Volume Comp. Tracer Tracer (psia) (F) (F) (%) Fract. Set Set Set def 14 .3 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE ls 14. 3 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 2S 14.30335 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 3s 14. 31195 110. 110. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 4s 14.28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 14. 3 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 14.28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE
14. 3 78. 78. 90. o. NONE NONE
NONE 14. 31195 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 14.28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE 10 14. 28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE lls 14 .3 /'JG. /'J6. /40. 0. NONE NONE NONE )*** )'** )*** 12 14 .3 ... . .. 40. 0. NONE NONE NONE \'JO. \'JO. \50. 13 14.28805 78. 78. 90. 0. NONE NONE NONE Graphs Graph Curve Number # Title l 2 3 4 5 0 M&.E Imbalance
EM EE l Benchmark
Heat Rate Comparison
cvlC DC4T 2 Benchmark
Exhaust! /Inlet Tempe TVlslOS DCST TV12 DC6T 3 Div 1 DG Room Upper SubVolume
TVlslOS TVls106 TV1s107 TV1s102 TVlsl03 4 Div l DG Room Doors to Hall TV1s41 TVls42 TV1s43 TV1s44 5 Div 1 to Hallway Pressure PR1s44 PR4sl24 PR12 PR9 PRlO 6 DG Room Temeprature
TV1s39 TVlsB TVlsll TVlslOS 7 Fan Room and Outside Air Tempe TV? TV1ls2 TV12 8 Fan Flow Rate LV7L LV6L 9 24hr Benchmark
T TVlslOS DCST 10 24hr Benchmark
Heat cvlC DC4T 11 DG Room T v Benchmark
1 TVls47 /TVle40 DC7T DCBT \TV1s39 12 DG Room T v Benchmark
2 TVls35 DC9T DClOT TVls37 13 Hallway, 762', & 712' TV4s124 TV9 TVlO 14 Wall Temperature
for the Small TA3s2 15 Atmospheric
Pressure PRllsl PRlls2 PR1ls3 16 Atmospheric
BC Flow Rates FVlO FVll 17 Recirculation
Mass Flow FV23 FV24 18 Leakage Flow Rate FV28 FV29 19 Hallway Door Flow Rates FV15 FV14 FV16 FV17 20 Relative Humidity Above the Ai RHlsBS RH1s86 RH1s87
21 Temperature
Above the Air Comp TV1s85 TVls86 TVlsB7 22 Divl DG Panel Temperatures
TV1s43 TVls40 TVls39 TVlsS TVls37 23 Components
of Averages TVlsS TVlsB TVlsll TVls40 TVls43 24 Panel 1PL12JA Temperatures
TV1sl4 TVlslS TVls30 TV1s31 I 25 Panel 1PL12JA Temperatures TV1s46 TV1s47
TVls62 TV1s63 )TV14 \TV14 26 Panels 1PL92JA/1PL93JA
Tempera TVls12 I I \TVlS \TVJ.6 27 Panel lDGOlJA Temperatures
TVls7 TVlsB TVls23 TV1s24 I 28 Panel lDGOlJA Temperatures
TVls39 TV1s40 TVlsSS TV1s56 )TVJ.7 29 Panel 1DG06SA Temperatures
TVlsS TV1s6 TVls21 TV1s22 )TV17 30 Panel lDGOlKA 12cyl Temperatur
TVlsll TV1s27 TVls43 TV1s59 )TVJ.* 31 Panel lDGOlKA 16cyl Temperatur
TVls7 TVls23 TVls39 TVlsSS )TVJ.* \TV20 32 Panel Bulk Average Temperature
cvlOC cv14C cvlBC 33 Panel Bulk Average Temperature
cv22C cv26C cv30C 34 Division 1 Room Door DPs DP14 DP15 DP34 35 Division 1 Room Rollup Door DP DP16 DP17 DP35 DP36 36 Div 1 DG Heat Absorption
cv2C July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT I NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bll6 ofB156 115 curve Ops \L2"TV15 {1PL93J /Ll*cvlDC
(1PL12 \Ll*cvlDC
(1PL12 Ll 11 cv22C (1DG06 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 182 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version B.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Fluid Boundary Conditions
-Table 1 Press. Temp. Flow s BC# Description (psia) FF (F) FF (lbm/s) FF p lP Outside Air 14 .3 /36 I N 2F Outside Air 14. 266 );. )ll 10000 N \l \ll 3P Emergency
Suppl 14 .3 72 N 4P Make-up Supply 14 .3 78 N Fluid Boundary Conditions
-Table 2 Liq. v. Stm. v. Drop D. Drop Drop BC# Frac. FF Frac. FF (in) FF GSD Frac. lP /H40 NONE 1. 0. )0.024 2F H40 NONE 1. 0. \0.024 3P H25 NONE 1. 0. 4P H25 NONE 1. 0. Volumetric
Fan -Table 2 Vol Flow Flow Fan Flow Rate Rate
Option (CFM) FF lQ Time 3020. 2Q Time 3020. 3Q Time 77567. 4Q Time 4250. SQ Time 4250. 6Q Time 4250. 7Q Time 4250. SQ Time /1510. \2800. Time DT DT DT Dom Min Max Ratio 0. 001 0 .1 le+ OB 0. 001 /1.5 1. )O.S 0. 001 l.S 1. 0. 001 1. \0.5 Run Options Option Restart Option Start Time (sec) Parallel Processes
Preprocessor
Multi threading
Revaporization
Fraction Maximum Mist Density (lbm/ft3)
Drop Diam. From Mist (in) Minimum HT Coeff. (B/h-ft2-F)
Reference
Pressure (psia) Heat Option Time Time Time Time Time Time Time Time End Time 5. 100. 1000. 86400. Heat Heat Rate Rate (Btu/s) FF 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. o. Time Domain Data Print Graph Int Int 1. /60. 10. )k \10. 60. 60. /60. 3600. \3600. Setting /l \2 NONE o. 0 YES DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT 0.0 IGNORE Cpld FF BC# Disch Vol lsB6 lls3 ls70 ls6 lsB ls54 ls56 ln Gas Error Relax T DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT J ON OFF Elev. 0 Trip Trip (ft) N 749. N 10 800. N 749. N 749. Flow Heat Outlet Frac. FF (Btu/s) FF Quality DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT Dump Ph Chng L Flow Int T Scale Shutoff 0. DEFAULT DEFAULT 0. DEFAULT DEFAULT
0. DEFAULT DEFAULT 0. DEFAULT DEFAULT July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT FF NAI-2007-004 .Revision
0 PageB117 ofB156 116 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 183 of 254 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Run Optiom1 (cont.) Option Maximum Pressm:e (psial Forced Ent. Drop Diam. {in) Vapor Phase Head Correction
Kinetic Energy Vapor Phase Liquid Phase Drop Phase Force Equilibrium
Drop-Liq.
Conversion
OA Logging Debug Output Level Debug Starting Time Step Debug Time Step Frequency
Restart Dump on CPU Interval {sec) Pressure Initialization
Iteration
Pressure Initialization
Convergenc
Solver Command Line Options Function 3T Model Gen. Heat Rate Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Heat Rate (BTU//sec)
Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 0. 0. 4 .9 s. /0.07 9 .9 )O.OS 10. 0.41 23. 9
24. 39. 9 )'-72 40. 1.81 119 .9 )1->2 120. 5.59 899 .9
900. 1199. 9 1200.
4919. 9 )Uo?=a 4920. 7199. 9 7200. )fi4?:s 14399.9 14400.
21600.
86401. \103.55 Setting INCLUDB IGNORB INCLUDE INCLUDE l.De-6 Dep. Var. /0.07 )O.OS 0.14 )8:&sect;, )0.71 l. 65
)"*** Go.ea
)84.21 123.5
\lOJ.55 Control Volume Parameters
Vol Vol Elev Ht Hyd. D. # Description (ft3) (ft) (ft) (ft) ls DG Room (Div. 1 82470. 737. 24. 24. 2s DG Room (Div. 2 54300. 737. 24. 24. 3s DG Room (Div. 3 64300. 737. 24. 24. 4s Hallway 143900. 737. 24. 24. s Day Tank Room 1300. 737. 10. 10. 6 Oil Tank Room 14000. 712. 24. 24. 7 Make up Air Sup 10000. 762. 24. 24. 8 Rest of El 737' 247000. 737. 24. 24. 9 Rest of El 762' 480000. 762. 24. 24. 10 712' El 480000. ?12. 24. 24. lls Outside Air le+07 ?37. 74. 20. 12 Fan Room 23?50. ?62. 24. 24. 13 Interposing
Int 1000. ?62. 24. 24. )!!.,. \15 \1PL93JA \0.787 \739.917 \l.354 \0.463 L/V IA SA Min Film (ft2) FF (ft) DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT /DBFAULT /DBFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT \DEFAULT \ \DEFAULT July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Min Film FF \ NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B118 ofB156 117 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 184 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-TRANS_Case_12.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA)-Oct2016 Control Volume E'arameters
{cont.) Vol Vol Elev Ht Hyd. D. L/V IA SA Min Film Min Film * Description (ftJ) {ft) (ft) (ft) (ft2) FF {ft) FF /=x '"""""'&deg;"'
'""'&deg;"""'&deg;'
'"""""""'
I= '"""&deg;&deg;""" /DBFAOLT /DEFAOLT '""""""" )i!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )DBFAOLT DEFAULT )t>EFAOLT
DBFAOLT >= )DBFAtJLT
DEFAULT )xxxxxxx )i!xx >== )DEFAULT DKFAOLT >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )i!xx )DEFAULT DBFAOL'I' )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= \20 \lDGOlltA
Heyl \9.868 \739.458 \5.833 \0.883 \DEFAOLT \ \DEFAtJLT
\ Control Volume Options Vol S Wava Pool HMT Pool Pool Pres. Pool Op. Bu= Damper MUlt Opt Correction
Tracking Opt Drag l* LOCAL ON 2, DEFAULT ON NONE LOCAL ON ,, LOCAL ON DEFAULT LOCAL NONE ON LOCAL 1. DEFAULT ON NONE l. ON 1. NONE '" DEFAULT LOCAL ON 12 l. LOCAL ON 13 l. DEFAULT LOCAL ON ON NONE ON I= /DRFAULT I= I= I= /xxxxxxx I= )i!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xxxxxxx )DRFAOLT DEFAULT >= )i!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )i!xx )DEFAULT DEFAtJL'l' )xxxxxxx )i!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xxxxxxx \20 \1. \DEFAULT \LOCAL \ON \ \ON \NONE \ON Laminar Leakage Lk Rate .. , Ref Sink Leak Vol Temp Humid Model Rep Subvol (\/hr) (psia) (Fl ,., Option Wall Option (ft2) ,, o. UNIFORM CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 13 CNST T I= I= I= /xxxxxxx I= /xxxxxxx /DEFAULT )!!xx >= >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT )i!xx >= >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT )i!,.. >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT )i!xx >= )>=>ca >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )DEFAULT DEFAULT '" \0. \ \ \CNST T \ \UNIFORM \DEFAULT July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bll9 ofB156 118 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 185 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Turbulent
Leakage Lk Rate Ref Ref Ref Sink Leak Vol Factor Press Temp Humid or Model Rep Subvol Area # (%/hr) (psia) (F) (%) Src Option Wall Option (ft2) fL/D ls 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 2s 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 3s o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 4s 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT s o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 6 o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 7 o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 8 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 9 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 10 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT lls o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 12 0. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT 13 o. CNST T UNIFORM DEFAULT /xxxx I= l=x /=x I= /xxxx I= '"""" I= /DEFAULT I= )i!xx )=x >= >= )xxxx )"""" )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= >= >= )xzxx )"""" )DEPA17LT
DEFAULT >= >= >= )"""" )xzxx )DEFAU'LT
DEFAULT >= >= >= >= )"""" )xxxx )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= )i!.x >= >= >= )"""" )xxxx )DEFAULT DEPA ULT >= )ii.,. >= >= >= )"""" )"""" )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= \20 \0. \ \ \ \ \CNST T \ \UNIFORM \DEFAULT \ Discrete Burn Parameters
Min Min Max Burn Flame Burn Un Vol H2 02 H20 Length Speed Rate Burn Burn
# Frac Frac Frac (ft) (ft/s) FF Frac Opt ls 0 .07 0. OS 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 2s 0. 07 0. OS 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 3s 0. 07 o. OS 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 4s 0. 07 0 .OS 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR s 0. 07 0. OS 0. 5S DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 6 0 .07 0. OS 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 7 0 .07 0. OS 0 .5S DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 8 0 .07 o. 05 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 9 0. 07 0.05 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 10 0. 07 0 .05 0.55 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR lls 0. 07 0. 05 0. SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 12 0. 07 0. 05 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT FBR 13 0. 07 0. 05 0 .SS DEFAULT DEFAULT
DEFAULT FBR I= I= I= /DEFAULT /DEFAULT '"""" /DEFAULT )i!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )"""" )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAtJLT
DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )"""" )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAtJLT
DEFAULT )&deg;EFADLT DEFAULT )DEFAtJLT
DEFAULT )i!.x )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )"""" )DEFAULT DEFAULT )ii.,. )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT \20 \D.07 \0.05 \0.55 \DEFAULT \DEFAULT \ \DEFAULT \FSR Continuous
Burn Parameters
Vol Min H2 Min Max Max Burn Vol Flow 02 H20 H20/H2 Frac (lbm/s) Frac Frac Ratio ls 0. 0 .OS a.SS 1000. l. 2s 0. 0 .OS O .SS 1000. l. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl20 ofB156 119 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 186 of 254 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV_LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ccntinuous
B= Parameters (cont.) Vol Min H2 Min Max *= Vol Flow H20/H2 Frac (lbm/s) Ratio o.os 1000. o.os 1000. l. 0.05 1000, 1. o.os l. o.ss 1. o. 1000. o. 0.05 1000. l. 1000. o.os o.ss 1. o. 0.05 1000. 1. 13 0. 0.05 0.55 1000. l. I= I= I= I= >=xx )ixxx.x >=xx )ixxx.x )i!.x )ixxx.x \20 \0. \0.05 \0.55 \1000. \1. Mechanistic
Burn Rate Parameters
Min Min M= Lam Bum Turb Turb Vol H2 Pa Temp Limit No. (lbm/ft3-s) (F} Opt 1. 350. DEFAULT BOIS 0. 1. 350. 4* DEFAULT Bl>IS 1. DEFAULT BOIS 350, l. DEFAULT BDIS 1. 350. l. DEFAULT 350. EDIS 1. 350. 0. 1. l. 350. /=x /=x /=x /DEFAULT I= I= I== I== )!!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= >= >= )!!xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= >= >== )DEFAULT DEFAULT >= >= >= \20 \0. \o. \1. \1. \DEFAULT \JSa. \ \EDIS \ Mechanistic
Burn Propagation
Parameters
Unburned Burned l'lame lg Min lg Min lg MaX Auto lg Vel Thick Temp FF (ft/s) (ft) (F} 0,04 o.ss o.ss 0.164 o.55 DB FAULT DEFAULT 0.04 0.05 o.ss 0.164 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT FF NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B121 ofB156 120 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 187 of 254 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LciV
_LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Mechanistic
Burn Propagation
Parameters (cont.) Unburned Burned cc Flow Flame Ig Min Ig Min Ig Max Auto Ig Vol H2 Vol Thick H2 Temp (ft/s} (ft) (F) 0.001 DEFAULT 0.04 DEFAULT 0.001 0.04 D.164 10 0.001 DEFAULT 0,04 DSFAULT 0.001 0.04. 0,55 12 0.04 0.164 0,04. 0.05 l3 0.04 0.001 0.164 0.04 a.SS /xx /xx /DEFAULT /xx /xx /DEFAULT /xx )!!xx )xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )iixx )xx )xx )DEFAULT DBll'AULT )xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )xx )xx }DBFAOLT DBFAOLT )xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )i!xx )xx )xx )DB FAULT DEFAULT )xx )xx )DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx )i!xx )xx )xx )DEFAULT DB FAULT )xx ),.,. }DEFAULT DEFAULT )xx \20 \0.04 \ \0.001 \ \DEFAULT \ \0.164 \ \0.04 \O.OS \O.S5 \DEFAULT \ Pipe Parameters
Ri:olative
Lam Modulua of Vol Rough-Geom 00 ID Elasticity
Stiffness
* ne:Js Pact (in) (in) (p:d) Factor ,. OBFA " DBFA .. DBFA .. DBFA 5 OBFA 6 DEL"A 7 DEPA ' DEPA ' DEPA 10 DEFA ll* DBFA 12 DEPA 13 DEL"A /xxxx '""""'&deg;""'
/DBFA '"""""" I= I= I= )!!xx )DEPA DEPA )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxx= >= )DBFA DEPA )xxxxxx )xxxxxx >= >= )DEPA DEPA )xxxxxx )xxxxxx >= >= )DEPA DEPA )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxx= >= )i!xx )DEPA DEPA )xxxxxx )xxxxxx )xxxx= >= )DEFA DEFA )xxxxxx )xxxxxx >= >= \20 \ \DEFA \ \ \ \ Flow Paths -Tabh 1 Vol Rlev Vol Elev Tilt Description (ft) (ft) (ft} {ft) (deg) {deg} Hatch (El 762 f 0.1 762. 0.1 Hatch (762' Hal 760. 0.1 762. Hatch (762' Hal 760. ?62. Hatch (Bl 737 f Hatch (737'Half
Hatch (737'Half
Make Up supply 7451. Normal Fan to D ?62. Exhaust from DG lslOS 760. 787. 0.1 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B122 ofB156 121 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 188 of 254 m NUMER.ICAL
Clinton.Division
1 Diesel Generator
NAI-2007-004
APPLICATIONS
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
RevisionO
;. n 'J rJ:"'t'-1
ri* r*ri I':,..
*;.e n.rat.rn:l'-1:":
tT Evaluation
Page Bl23 ofB156 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12.GTH 122 \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -'!able 1 (cont.) Vol Elev Vol Elev Tilt Description
A (ft) (ft) (ft) (ft) (deg) (deg)
10 Outside Air llsl 737. 0.1 lP 749. 0.1 Outside Air 0.1 12 Divl-Div2
Upper lsJ6 742. 742. 13 Divl-Div2
Lower 737. 1. 2'1 737. 1. 14 DG Rl Door (Low ... 737 * 2.s lsl6 737. DG Rl Dogr (Mid DG Rl Rollup (L . ., 2.s 1s1J 737, 17 DG Rl Rollup (L 4s63 ls29 2.S 1' Dl-03 Roll Up 315127 742. 1. ls41 742. l. Dl-DJ Roll Low 20 Dl-03 Up 3s24 742. l. ls37 742. 1. "' Emergency
Fan t 763. 0.1 ls70 750. .. 24 Recirc to Fan R lslOS 2. 12 2. 2S Emergency
Suppl 13 774. 0.1 774. 0.1 26 Oil Fan Supply 13 774. 0.1 12 774. BC to Intake 0.1 749, LoV Leakage Pat 13 lls2 0.1 Hallway Leakage 7451. llial 7451. 0.1 Gen Fan Flow Lo /1s7 /738. /l.S 1'6 738. )1s3SI )742. )'** Gen Fan Flow Lo 1*7 738. l.S )lsJSI HU:s )'*' 32 Gen Fan Flow Hi 1s55 '* ls54 '* )11139
)2.5 33 Gen Fan Flow Hi ls55 '* ls56 744.5 '* \1a39 \742. \2.S DG Rl Door (Top 49124 2.1667 la4B DG Rl Rollup (0 1945 742. 2.s " DG Rl Rollup (T 4slB3 s 744.5 2.5 ls61 * 744.5 2.S '"""" '""""""" I= /x /XXXXJllX
I= I= /x /lUCXlOO<
'"'&deg;"""' I= '""""" Pressur >= >= Pressur )xxxxx >= )!!xx Presaur )xxxxx )xxxxx Preasur )xxxxx >= )!ix. Prossur )xxxxx )xxxxx l2cyl P )i!.x.x )xxxxx )xxxxx
P )xxxxx >= \44 \Bzhaust Pipe Le \lslll \T \760.98 \0,01 \llsJ \B \788.01 \0.01 \ \ Flew Paths -Table 2 Flow Flow
Hyd. Inertia Friction Relative Dep Diam, Length Length Rough-Bend Flow (ft2) (ft) (ftJ (ft) {deg) Opt Opt le-OS 3 ** NONE 7.1 i. le-OS DEFA 42.651 7.4 20. NONE 7.5 5. 5.5 DBFA 20. o. o. 18 '*' le-OS July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 189 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_ LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -Table 2 (cont.) Flow Flow
Hyd. Inertia Friction Relative Lam Dop St rat Path Diam. Length Length Rough-Bend T= Flow (ft2) (ft) (ft) {ft.) !deg) Opt Opt 40. '*' DBFA NONE le-OS NONE 10.7 o. NONE 66.39 51.19 le-05 DBFA NONE ... '* DBFA 24 21.3 '* le-05 o. NONE 3. NONE " NONE 0.073 '* o. le-05 NONE 2. 2. o. NONE 1. le-OB DBFA NONE 31 N&T NONE 32 " 2. le-OB o. NOT NONE 1. G.5 " o. DBFA 20. " o. " 20. 5. s.s 0. 0. DBFA 0. NONE I= I= '"""""""'
I= I= /PBFA />= I= I= >== >= )DBFA DBFA ):X >= >= )DEPA DBFA )!!xx >= >= )DBFA DBFA )ixxxxxxx
>= >= >"= )!ix. >= >= )DBFA DBFA )!!xx >= >= )DEPA DEPA ):X )!!xx >= >= )DEPA DEPA ):X \44 \10. '" \41. \ \ \DEPA \0. \N&T \NONE Flow Paths -Table 3 Flow Fwd. Critical Exit Drop Homog. Path Lo8' Comp. Flow Loss Breakup Flew Cceff. Cceff. Opt. Model Coeff. Model Ope. 0.1 OFF OFF OFF 0.1 0.1 OFF OFF 0.1 0.1 OFF o. OFF o.l OFF OFF 0.1 OFF 0.1 0.1 OFF OFF 2.78 OFF 1.5 OFF OFF 1.5 OFF OFF OFF OFF OFF OFF OFF OFF 2.76 o. OFF 2.78 OFF 2.76 2.76 OFF OFF 2.?B OFF 2.78 OFF OFF July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B124 ofB156 123 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 190 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-TRANS_Case_12a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -Table 3 (cont.) Flow Fwd.. critical Exit Drop Homog. Path Loss Comp. Flgw Losa Breakup Flow Coeff. Coeff. Opt. Model Coeff. Model Opt. 27 OFF OFF 2.78 OFF OFF 29 2.78 OFF OFF 30 l. o. n l. 32 l. o. OFF l. o. OFF 2.78 OFF OFF OFF 36 2.78 2.78 OFF OFF 0. OFF OFF '"""' I= '"" '""""""" '"" '""""" I= '""""""" I= ).,. '"" )!!xx '"" '"" )!!xx '= '= '"" '"" )!i.x ).,. '"" '"" '= '"" '= \44 \S.56 \ \5.56' \OFF \OFF \0. \OFF \OFF Flow Paths -Table 4 Forward Prop Flow Min Min Min Min With Path Time Prop Frac Opt 0,06 0.05 0.05 CO FLOW 0.06 0.06 NO CO FLOW o.os 0.5 0,06 NO COFLOlf 0,55 0.06 10 0,55 0.06 O.> NO *0.06 0,55 o.ss 0,06 0,06 0,06 o.ss o.ss 0.5 o.os 21 0.06 0.55 0.06 o.ss 0.06 o.os o.os D.55 CO FLOW 0,06 D.55 0.5 o.ss o.os 0.06 0.06 0.06 CO FLOW o.os 0.06 0.06 0.06 o.os 0.55 o.ss July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B125 ofB156 124 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 191 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_ LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Flow Paths -Table 4 (cont.) Forward RevcrBc Prop FlgW Min Min Mox Min Min Mox With Path Time Prop Frac Frac Frac Frac Flow Opt 0,06 o.os o.ss o.os NO a.as 0.55 0.06 0,05 0.55 COFLOlf " 0.06 0.05 o.ss 0.06 0.05 0.55 o.s NO CO FLOW '"""""' I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= >= )!!.. >= )!!,. >= >= )!ix,. >= )!ix,. >= )!ixx >= \44 \0.06 \0.05 \0.55 \0.06 \0.05 \0.55 \O.S \NO \COi!' LOW Thermal Conductorir
Cond Vol Vol Srf Description
Opt Opt Typo {ft2) DG (Wann) (Conv) 1117-5::1
848. DO (Hot) (Conv) 11i?l eo. DG Rl E Wall loE DG Rl S Wall "' llel 936, ,, DG Rl N Wall 1'N 936. ,, DG Rl Ceiling under Fan Room ls97-1 Divl Ceiling-762
2900. Divl Floor 1'F 10 DG Rl W Wall /Jaw /lsS-10 /2376. \JDB \lsW \2350. 10s Wall (Tank Room -DG Rl} 200. 11* Wall {DG R2 -Hallway) 2'N 4s5-36 670. 12* Wall (DG R2 -othar rool!llJ)
2'E 2400. 13* Wall IDG R2 -outside Air) ,,, llsl 6"70. Div2 to 912" "' 15* Div2 to 962" 2'0 2800. Div3 to /\mb. JoS Div3 to 962" 3sC 36"00. 19* Div3 to 912' 33F 3600. Ceiling {El 737ft Hallway) Hallway Floor 10 ,,, Hall {El 737ft* Hallway -outside Air) 4sW 384. Wall (Tank Room -Outside Air) llsl 120. Wall (Fan Room -Other Rooms) Wall (Fan Room -Outside Air) 936. Wall (El 737ft Other Room.s -Outside Air) 10000. Wall (El 762ft Other Rooms -Outside Air} Willl !El 712ft -Outside Air) 10 llsl Fan Room to Aroh. ,, 960. 29 Fan Rm to 962' 12 936. JO Fan Riii to Am.b (ceiling)
12 2 3 1 1521. /xxxx /=x /x=xxx I= I= I= /xxxx )ii!x North Side )!!.xx. )i.x )i.x South Side )!!.xx. )i.x )i.x
Side )!!.xx. )i.x )i.x
Side )!!.xx. )i.x )i.x )!!!x
Side )!!.xx. )ixx )ixx )!!.. North Side )i.x )i.x South Side )i.x )i.x
Sid* )i.x )i.x
Side )ixx )ixx )!!a Bottom Side )ixx )ixx \'1 \1PL92JA North Sid* \lG \1 \1812 \1 \7 \0.705 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl26 ofB156 125 Init. G'P T. (F) ,,, "* ". 79. 79. 78. "* 79. 79. 78. 78. 78. I= )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx \7B. \X \ 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 192 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-TRANS_Case_12.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Com:l.uctors (cont.) Cond Vol Srf Vol Srf Cond S. A. * Dei!lcription
A Opt B Opt Type (ft:2J /xxxx '""""""" I= /xxx I= I= /xxxx I= South Sida )ixx )ixx )k
Side )ixx )ixx )k
Sida )ixx )ixx )k )!i.x
Side )k )k );:.,.,. Bottom Sida )k )k )k North Side )ixx )ixx )k )!!:x South Side )ixx )ixx )k )!i:x EaDt Sida )ixx )ixx )k
Side )ixx )ixx )k
Side )k )k )k North Side )k )k );:.,.,. South Side )ixx )ixx )k
Sida )ixx )ixx )k
Sida )ixx )ixx )k
Side )k )k )k Bottom Side )k )k )k J.2cyl North Side )k )ixx )k J.2cyl South Side )k )ixx )k 12cyl Bast Side )ixx )ixx )k J.2cyl Wost Side )ixx )ixx )k J.2cyl 'l'op Side )k )k )k 12cyl Bottom Sida )k )k )k J.6cyl North Side )ixx )k )k )!i:x 16cyl South Side )ixx )k )k 16cyl Bast Side )k )k )k 16cyl West Side )ixx )ixx )k )!i.x 16cyl "rep Side )k )k )k )!i.x 16cyl BcttCllll
Side )k )k )k
Air Piping )!,.,. );:.,. )!.xx
Air Piping )!,.,. );:.,. )!.xx
Air Piping )!,.,. );:.,. )!.xx \73s \DG Ccmbust. Air Piping \ls7l-8 \8 \ls71-8 \7 \8 \198.6 Thermal Conductors
-Radiation
Parameters
Ccnd Therm. Rad. Emiss. Emiss. Side A Side A Side B Side B Scope No FULL ,. '" lls No FULL No 14s 15* 18' July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B127 ofB156 126 Init. .,,, T. {F) I/X * /xxxxxx I= /=xx )xxxx )xxxx >= )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )..,.,. )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )i.x.x )!.xx )i.x.x )!.xx )i.x.x )!.xx \78. \I \4 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 193 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_ LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Therm.al Conductor.s
-Radiation
Parameters (cont.) Cond Therm. Rad. Em!as. Therm, Rad. Em.iss * * Side A Side A Side B Side B Scope 23 NO No FULL 24 NO No FOLL 2S No No FULL " NO No FULL 27 NO No FULL 28 No No FULL ., NO No FULL JO NO No FULL /xxxxxxx /xxxxxxx '"'&deg;"""&deg;" /xxxxxxx /XXXXXXX )!i:x )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!!:x )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )i!.x )xxxxxxx >= )xxxxxxx >= )xxxxxxx >= )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >= )!ixx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!!xx )xxxxxxx >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!!:x )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!!!x )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!!!,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!!:x )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!i:x )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!!xx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!!,.,. )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx \7Js \No \ \No \ \FULL Thermal Conductors
-Ice Parameters
Side A Side B Node Cond. Spacing Thick. Thick. (inl Option (in) Porosity {in) Porosity July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl28 ofB156 127 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 194 of 254 (r+JJ
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductors
-Ice Parameters (cont,} -------Side A -----------Side B ----Node Area Ice Ice Cond. Spacing FF Thick. Ice Area Thick. Ice Area * (in) Nodes Option (in) Porosity FF (in) Porosity FF 2 NONE NONE " NONE NONE " NONE NONE .. NONE NONE ,, NONE NONE 7' NONE NONE " NONE NONE ,, NONE NONE '" NONE NONE 11' NONE NONE '" NONE NONE 13* NONE NONE '" NONE NONE "' NONE NONE 16* NONE NONE 17* NONE NONE lBs NONE NONE "" NONE NONE 20s NONE NONE 21* NONE NONE 22 NONE NONE 23 NONE NONE 24 NONE NONE 25 NONE NONE 26 NONE NONE 27 NONE NONE 28 NONE NONE " NONE NONE 30 NONE NONE /xxxx I= I= I= /NONE '""'&deg;""""'
'""""' /NONE I= /xxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONI! NONE >= }xxxx }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxx >= >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx }xxxxxxx >= >=
>= }xxxx )"&deg;"" NO?IE >= }xxxx )i!xx }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx
>= }xxxx >= >= >= )"ONE NONI! >= }xxxx )RONE NON3 >= }xxxx )i!.x }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx
>= }xxxx )i!.x }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx
>= }xxxx }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx }NONE NONE >= )xxxx }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )"ONE NONE >= }xxxx }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )!ixx )xxxxxxx >= )xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )!!.,. )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )!ixx }xxxxxxx >= >= )"ONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )!!.,. }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE }xxxxxxxx
}xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )!!:x }mxxxx >= >= }NONE NONE }xxxxxxxx
}xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE }xxxxxxxx
}xxxx }NONE NONE >= }xxxx }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE }xxxxxxxx
}xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= }xxxx }NONE NONE >= }xxxx )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )HONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE }xxxxxxxx
}xxxx )x=xxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxx }xxxxxxx >= }xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx
}xxxx }xxxxxxx >= )xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx }xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx
>= }xxxx )i!:x }xxxxxxx >= )xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx )xxxxxxx >= >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxx )NONE NONE >= }xxxx \6l!i! \ \ \ \NONE \ \ \NONE \ \ July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl29 ofB156 128 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 195 of 254 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductors
-Ice Parameters (cont.) -------Side A Node Area Ice Cond. Spacing M= FF Thick. Ice * (in) Nodes Opt.ion (in) Porosity /xxxx /xxxxxxx /xxxxx I= /NONE I= )xxxx= )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE >= )xxxxxxx )xx= )xxxxxx )NONX NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xx= >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx
)!ixx )xxxxxxx )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xx= )NONE NONE >= )xxxxxxx )xxxxx >= )NONE NONE )xxxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )=xx )xxxxxx )NONE NONE >= \73s \ \ \ \NONE \ Thermal Conductor
Types Type Thick. O.D. Description (in) {in) Ceiling/Floor
Internal Hall External Wall 1. DG Hot WALL 6 Internal Block WALL 11.625 I= /xxxxxxx /xxxx /xxxxxxxx
/xxxxxxxx
>=
>= ,, \24" Piping \TtJBE \0.375 \24. Forcing Function Tables ... Description
Ind. var. Dep. Var. Constant OG Warm Temp Time (sec) Tcmpc.ratur
DG Hot Temp Time (sec) Temperatur
Model Gen. Heat Time (sec) Benchmark
Heat Time (sec) Benchmark
Benchmark
Exhau Time (sec) Benchmark
Benchmark
Inlet Time (sec) Temperatur
7T Benchmark
Loe 1 Time (sec) Temperatur
Benchmark
Loe 2 Time (sec) Temperatur
Benchmark
Loe 3 Time (sec) Temperatur
lOT Benchmark
Loe 4 Time (sec) Temperatur
/xxxx /xxxxxxx /xxxxxxx \11T \outdoor Air Tem \Time (sec) \Temperatur
Pile ff Name 1 I /CPS _lA _DG _LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Cose _12. csv
\2 \Case _12a_ Panel._ Temperatures.
csv. 0. -----------Side B Ice Area Thick. FF (in) I= /NONE )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxx )NONX NONE )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxx
>= )NONE NONE )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxx )NONE NONE )xxxx \ \NONE Regions 20 23 20 /xxxxxxx \13 Points 45 15 15 I= \1535 lee Porosity I= >= )xxxxxxxx )xxxxxxxx
)=xx= >= >=
>=
>= )xxxxxxxx )xxxxxxxx )xxxxxxxx
\ Heat (Btu/ft.3-s)
o. o. I= \0. ----Area FF /xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx >= )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx \ Heat FF /xxxx )xxxx )xxxx Data Files Inter-Type polate I I I= \TIME \YES July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Output Detail Files Level I SINGLE I =L I= /"&deg;"""""" \S:WGLE \POLL NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl30 ofB156 Format Option I(= 129 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 196 of 254 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_12.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:29 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Conductor
Surface Options -Table 1 surf Heat Cnd/ Sp Nat For Opt Transfer Nominal Cnv end Cnv Cnv Cnv # Description
Option Value FF Opt Opt HTC Opt Opt 1 Wall Direct DLM-FM VERT SURF USER DEF 2 Ceiling Side Direct DLM-FM FACE DOWN USER DEF 3 Floor Side .Direct DLM-FM FACE UP USER DEF 4 DG Warm Temper Sp Temp 1. lT 5 DG Hot Temperat Sp Temp 1. 2T 6 HTC Sp Conv /4.9 I= '""""""" /xxxxxxx I= I= I= I= /xxxxxxx /xxxxxxx for DQ >=== >= >= >= >= )!..,. )!! >= >== )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx ,, \DG Intake HTC \Sp Conv \4.752 \ \ \ \ \ \ conductor
Surface Options -Table 2 Surf Min Max Convection
Condensation
Rad to Stearn Opt Phase Liq Liq Bulk Temp Bulk Temp Emissivity
# Opt Fr act Fract Model FF Model FF Dry Wet 1 VAP Tg-Tf Tb-Tw DEFAULT DEFAULT 2 VAP Tg-Tf Tb-Tw DEFAULT DEFAULT 3 VAP Tg-Tf Tb-Tw DEFAULT DEFAULT 4 5 6 VAP Tg-Tw 0. 0. I= I== I= I= I== I= I== I= /DBFAlTLT
/DEFAULT >= >= >= >= }DEFAULT DEFAULT )DEFAULT DEFAULT )!..,. >= >= >= >== >= >== >= )DEFAULT )DEFAULT ,, \VAP \ \ \Tg-Tw \ \ \ \0. \0. Conductor
Surface Options -Table 3 Surf Char. Norn Minimum Char. Cond. Opt Length Vel Vel Conv HTC Height Length # (ft) (ft/s) FF (B/h-f2-F) (ft) (ft) 1 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT 2 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT 3 DEFAULT DEFAULT
DEFAULT 4 DEFAULT DEFAULT
5 DEFAULT DEFAULT 6 DEFAULT DEFAULT DEFAULT I= I= I= I= /DEFAULT I== I== >== >= >= )DEFAULT DEFAULT >== >== )!..,. >= >= >= )DEFAULT >== >== ,, \ \ \ \DEFAULT \DEFAULT \DEFAULT Conductor
Surface Options -Table 4 Surf Tot.al Peak Initial BD Post-BO Post-BO Opt Const Heat Time Exp Value Exp Exp Direct CT (Btu) (sec) XT (B/h-f2-F)
yt xt FF July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
RevisionO
PageB131 ofB156 130 
L __ EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 197 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _ LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Conductor
surface Options -Table 4 (cont.) surf Total Peak Initial BP Post-BD Post-BO Ope Cenat Heat Time Exp Value Exp Exp Direct ff CT (Btu) (sec) XT (B/h-f2-F)
ye " FF /rxxx I= I= I= I= I= I= /xxxxxxx '= '= >= '= >= )xxxxxx )xxxxxxx )xxxxxxx )!.,.,. )xxxxxx >= >= >= >= >= )xx=xx ,, \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ Control Variables
Fune. Initial Coe.ff. Coe.ff. Description Value aO Min Div l DG Heat Load le.,.32 Div 1 DG Heat Abeo:rption
-1. -let-32 le+32 Bounding Panel T_bulk_avg
o. 1. o. le+32 Bounding Panel T_max Door T_bulk_avg
a Operator Act if Door T_max l.l Operator Action if 1. -le+-32 le+32 'c Panel lPL12JA [Vole] 1. -le.,.32 le+32 Panel 1PL12JA [Temv] o. o. le+l2 Panel 1PL12JA [Vole] [Temv] eumprod J.e+l2 lOC Panel 1PL12JA T_bulk_avg
div 1. -le*32 le*J2 llC Panel 1PL92JA/1PL93JA
[VoleJ 1. -le*32 le*32 Panel 1PL92JA/1PL93JA
[TcmvJ o. le+32 Panel lPL92JA/lPL93JA
[Vole] [T a ump rod 1. -le+32 let32 l<C Panel lPL92Ja/lPL93JA
T_bulk_a div o. -le+32 le+l2 Panel 1DG01JA [Vole] 0. 1. le+32 16C Panel lDGOlJA [Temv] le+32 Panel lDGDlJA [Vole] [Temv] sump rod o. letl2 18C Panel lDGOlJA T_bulk_avg
div o. 0. le+32 1'C Panel 1DG06SA [Vole] 1. o. -le+J2 le+32 20C Panel 1DG06SA [Temv] -le ... 32 le+32 Panel 1DG06SA [Vole] (Temv] a ump rod o. -le+32 le*l2 22C Panel 1DG06SA T_bulk_avg
div 0. 1. -le+J2 le+32 Panel lDGOlKA l2cyl [Vole] -lc+32 le*32 Panel lDGDlKA 12cyl [Temv] 1. -le*l2 le*32 Panel lDGDlKA 12cyl [Vole] [Tem a ump rod o. 1. o. -le+32 le*32 26C Panel 1DG01KA 12eyl T_bulk_avg
div 0. 1. 0. le+32 Panel lDGDlKA 16eyl [Vole] 1. -la*l2 J.e+32 Panel lDGDlXA 16eyl [Temv] 29C Panel lDGDlKll 16cyl [Vole] (Tem aumprcd o. o. -le ... 32 le*32 Panel lDGOlKA 16cyl T_bulk_avg
div o. le*32 Rollup Door [Vole] Rollup Door [Temvl -ie ... 32 le.,.32 JJC Rollup Door [Vole) [Temv] a ump rod 1. o. -le+J2 le+32 Rollup Door T_bulk._avg
div o. lOTJ2 '5C Personnel
Door [Vole] Personnel
Door [Temv] 1. le+32 Personnel
Door [Vole] (Temv] sump rod o. -le+32 Pl!rsonnel
Door T_bulk_a.vg
div le+32 Max Door Temperature
le.,.32 40C Max Door T_bulk_avg
0. o. -le+l2 le+32 /xxxxxxx I= I= )!!ix )=.i Air Temper11oture
Heat Trll.Dsfar
Beat Transfer + Dola )!i.x..x
Thot )!!ix
+ Vy**2 ... vz**2) )!!ix \SOC \Local Rho*v*D \mult \0. \1. \0. \-le+32 \le+J:Z July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Upd. Int. Mult. \0. NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B132 ofB156 131 o. o. o. 0. o. o. o. o. 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 198 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Control Variables (cont.) CV Fune. Initial Coeff. Coeff, * Description
Form Value G ao Min Max '"""" '""'&deg;"""" I= '"""""&deg;"'
I= I= I= I= )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx
(1/2) *Pr** (1/3)
(2/3)] ** (1/4) )ix.xxxx )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx
** (5/8)
u (5/8)] ** (4/S) )ixxxxxx )ixxxxxx
(1/2) *Pr** (1/3) I [l+ (D =;,,xx )ixxxxxx \63C \Local Nu \sum \0. \1. \0.3 \-lo+32 \le+32 Turbulence
Parameters
1----Liquid --1 1----Vapor --1 Vol Mclee, Turb. Mix.L. ScT Mix.L PrT ScT Phase Diff. Model (ft) No. (ft} No. Option ls NO NONE o. o. 0. 0. 2s NO o. 0. o. o. NO NONE o. o. 0. VAPOR ,. NO NONE o. o. NONE 0. o. o. 0. VAPOR NO NONE o. 0. NO NONE o. 0. VAPOR NO NONE o. o. 0. 0. NO NONE o. VAPOR NO lls o. o. 12 NO NONE o. 0. VAPOR 13 NO NONE 1. l. 1. 1. VAPOR !== I= I= I= I= I= I= I= )xxxxxx >= )iixxx >= >= >= )xxxxxx >= )xxxxxx )i:xxx >= >= )i!xxx >= >= \20 \NO \NONE \1. \1. \ \l. \l. \VAPOR Cell Blockages
-Table 1 Volume ls Blockage No. Description
Type l Day Tank Room BLX B l N /x. /x. /x >ni ): >ni ): )ixxxx )!}i ): )ixxxx >ni ): )ixxxx )=li ): 12cy1 >ni \B \1DGD1XA 16cy1 \BLK \B \I \N July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B133 ofB156 Upd. Int. Mult. I= \0. 132 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 199 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Cell Blockages
-Table 2 Volume ls Blockage Coordinates
& Dimensions (ft) Angle No. Xl Yl Zl X2 Y2 Z2 X3 Y3 Z3 L (Deg) 1 0. o. 0. 10. 10. 10. I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= I= >= >= )xxxxxx )= >= )!..xx >= )xxxxxx >= >= )xxxxxx )!.xx. >= >= )xxxxxx >= >= )!..xx >= >= )xxxxxx )xx=x >= >= )xxxxxx >= >= >= >= )xxxxxx >= >= >= \8 \29.479 \11.583 \2.458 \30.479 \14. \8.292 \ \ \ \ \ X-Direction
Cell Face Variations
Volume ls Cell Blockage Area Hyd. Dia. Loss Drop De-ent. No. No. Porosity FF (ft) Coeff. FF Factor def On 1. 1000000. 0. 0. lsl 1 0. le-06 0. 0. lsS 1 1. 260. 0. 0. lsl 7 1 0. le-06 0. 0. ls21 1 1. 260. 0. 0. ls33 1 0. le-06 0. 0. ls37 1 1. 260. 0. 0. ls49 1 0. le-06 0. 0. ls53 1 1. 260. 0. 0. ls65 1 1. 20. 0. 0. I= '"""" I= I= /xx /JCll:Xll:XXJl:XltXXX )xxxx ) .. )0. .. ... )xxxx ) .. )0. X'O'XXXXXXXXX )xxxx ).,. )O* )xxxx ) .. )O* )!..xx.. )xxxx ) .. )O* )i.....x ) .... ) .. )!Xxxxxxxxzxx )i.....x )xxxx ) .. )0* xxxzxx )i.....x )xxxx ) .. )0. * .... )i.....x )xxxx ) .. )!Xxxxxxxxxxx )i.....x )!xx..... )xxxx ) .. )!xzxxxxxx::xxx
\11121 \6 \1. \ \681.822 \0. \ \D. Z-Direction
Cell Face Variations
Volume ls Cell Blockage Area Hyd. Dia. Loss Drop De-ent. curb Ht No. No. Porosity FF (ft) Coeff. FF Factor (ft) def On 1. 1000000. 0. 0. lsl 0. 1e-06 0. 0. 0. ls2 1. 36. 0. 0. 0. lsS 1. 260. 0. 0. 0. 1s17 o. le-06 0. 0. 0. ls18 1. 36. 0. 0. 0. ls21 1. 260. 0. 0. 0. 1s33 o. le-06 0. 0. o. ls34 1. 36. 0. 0. 0. ls37 1. 260. 0. 0. 0. ls49 0. le-06 0. 0. 0. ls SO 1. 36. 0. 0. 0. ls53 1. 260. 0. 0. 0. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT Curb Height 0. I= \0. NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B134 ofB156 133 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 200 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries ind.icate
differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Z-Direction
Cell Face Variations (cont.) Volume ls Cell Blockage Aro* Hyd. Dia. Loss Drop De-ent. CW:b Ht No. No. Porosity FF {ft) Coeff. FF l.l'ac:tor (ft) /xxxx I= /xx /xxxxxxxxxxxx )xxxx )xx )0. )xxxx )xx )0. axxxxx )xxxx )xx )0. xxxxxmxxxx )xxxx )xx )O* = )xxxx )xx )O* =xx )xxxx )xx )0. xxxxxxx. )!x.xxxx )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )xx )D, )!x.xxxx )xxxx )xx )!x.xxxx )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )xx )0* :ii::ic )!x.xxxx )xxxx )xx )O* xxxxxxxxxxxx )!.x...x )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )xx )0. xx )!.x...x )xxxx )xx )!.x...x )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )xx )0. """" )ixxxx.xx )xxxx )xx )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )xx )0. )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )xx )0* xxx )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )xx )0. xx )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )xx )!xx.xx. )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )xx \lal9 \8 \1. \ \586.978 \0. \ \0. \0. Volume Variations
Volume ls Cell Blockage Volume Hyd. Dia. No. Porosity (ft) 1000000. lslB 1. 1a21 "* ls37 l /xxxx I= )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )xxxx )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )!x.xxxx )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx )ixxxxxxx )xxxx )xxxx )ixxxxxxx )xxxx \ls27 \7 \1. \15B. 76504 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B135 ofB156 134 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 201 of 254 File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Volume Variations (cont.) Volume ls Cell Blockage Volume Hyd. Dia. Porosity (ft) )"""" )!.xx.xx )"""" \lsl!J \8 \l. \ \571.38501
Conductor
Surface Options -Natural Convection
Variallles
htc * (k/ll * (A + e*cruc*Pr**D)
Surf Opt Conv Var c FF ' 0. 0.59 0.25 I"""" I= I= )k >= >= )!.xx >= >= ,, \0. \ \O.S!il \ \0.25 Conductor
Surface Options -Forced Convection
Variables
htc * lk/l) * (A + B*Re**C:*Pr**D)
Opt C:onv Var C Nom. FF Nom. 0.8 0,037 0,037 ' 0. D.023 O.B I"""" I= I= )k >= )!.xx >= >= ,, \0. \ \0.023 \ \0.8 Following
table in the Compare File but. not in the current File. Thermal Conductor
Type Panl!l Steel Bdry. Thick Sub-Region (in) (in) regs. 0.00324 0.00648 0,02592 0.01511 0.0191 0.014.24 0,00648 0.25 I= I= >= >= >= }xxxxx \ \0.25 \ FF Nom, 0,333 I= I= >= >= >= >= \ \0.4 \ o. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B136 ofB156 135 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 202 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Thermal Conductor
Type (cont.) 7 Panel Staal Mat. Bdry. Thick Sub* Heat Region * (in) linl regs. Factor 10 I l I 0.12176 I 0.00324 I l I o. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function llT Outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. o. 90. 60. 89. 9999191 120. 89. 9996764 180. 89. 9992718 240. 89. 9987054 . 300. 89. 9979772 360. 89.9970873
420. 89. 9960355 480. 89. 994822 540. 89. 9934468 600. 89. 9919099 660. 89. 9902113 720. 89. 9883511 780. 89.9863292
840. 89. 9841458 900. 89. 9818008 960. 89.9792944
1020. 89. 9766266 1080. 89. 9737973 1140. 89. 9708068 1200. 89.9676549
1260. 89. 9643419 1320. 89. 9608677 1380. 89. 9572324 1440. 89.9534361
1500. 89. 9494789 1560. 89.9453608
1620. 89. 9410819 1680. 89. 9366423 1740. 89. 9320421 1800. 89. 9272813 1860. 89. 9223601 1920. 89. 9172786 1980. 89. 9120368 2040. 89. 9066348 2100. 89. 9010728 2160. 89. 8953509 2220. 89. 8894691 2280. 89. 8834276 2340. 89. 8772265 2400. 89. 8708659 2460. 89.8643459
2520. 89. 8576667 2580. 89. 8508284 2640. 89. 8438311 2700. 89. 8366749 2760. 89. 82936 2820. 89. 8218865 2880. 89. 8142546 2940. 89. 8064644 3000. 89. 7985161 3060. 89. 7904097 3120. 89. 7821455 3180. 89. 7737237 3240. 89. 7651443 3300. 89.7564076
3360. 89. 7475137 3420. 89. 7384627 3480. 89. 7292549 3540. 89. 7198905 3600. 89. 7103695 3660. 89. 7006923 3720. 89. 6908588 3780. 89. 6808695 3840. 89. 6707244 3900. 89. 6604238 3960. 89. 6499678 4020. 89. 6393566 4080. 89,.6285904
4140. 89. 6176695 4200. 89. 6065941 4260. 89. 5953643 4320. 89.5839804
4380. 89.5724426
4440. 89. 5607511 4500. 89.5489061
4560. 89.5369079
4620. 89.5247567
4680. 89. 5124527 4740. 89.4999961
4800. 89.4873873
4860. 89.4746264
4920. 89.4617136
4980. 89. 4486493 5040. 89. 4354336 5100. 89. 4220669 5160. 89. 4085493 5220. 89. 3948812 5280. 89. 3810628 5340. 89. 3670943 5400. 89. 352976 5460. 89. 3387083 5520. 89. 3242913 5580. 89.3097253
5640. 89. 2950106 5700. 89.2801476
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B137 ofB156 136 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 203 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ind. var. 5760. ssso. 6000, 6240. 6360, 6600. 6720. 6840. 7080. 7440, 7560. 7680. 7800. 7920. 8400. 8760. 8880. 9120. 9240. 9360. 9600. 9120. 9840. 9960. 10080. 10200. 104'1.D. 10560. 10920. 11400. 11520. 11760,
11880, 12000. 12120. 12240, 12360. 12480. Function (cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec:) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 89.2036162
89.1069421
89.0050545
88.9342675
BS.7859221
88.7474414
88,6286998
88.5880295
88.5468194
88.5050726
88.4627924
BIL2884018
88.2435034
88.1521693
88.1057407
BB.0113778
87.9634507
87,816731
87.4045962
87.3510139
87.2969861
87.1322704
86.9636947
 
86.9066649
86.8492233
5820. 6180. 6300. 6660, 6900. 7140. 7500, 7620. 7740. 7860. 7980, 8460. 89.2499774
89.1878687
119.155935
89.1234183
89.05664.57
89.022394.9
88.9875713
88.9162161
88.87961199
88.7667509
88.7279939
88,6084323
88.5674.917
88.5260129
BB.4Bln9 88.3983789
88.3106574
8940. 88.266017
9060. 88.2208614.
9300. 88.1290181
9420. 88.0823375
88.0351556
5660. 87.9874.76
9780. 87.9393024
87.8906384.
87.8414877
10140. 87.7417413
87.6911532
87.5365757
87.48'11252
87.4312189
11100. 87.2151179
11580. 87.1599942
12060. 12180. 12300. 86.8203495
86.7622986
86.5857591
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl38 ofB156 137 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 204 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (Fl Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Oep. Var. 12840. 86.5559937
12960. 86.4961746
86.4661222
13080. 86.4359751
13140. 86.3753997
13260. 86.34451725
13320. 86.314453
13380. 86.2838419
13440. 86.2531H7
13500, 86.222347
86.1604925
13680. 86.1294318
13800. 86.0670467
13860. 86.0357234
13920. 86.0043137
85.9412378
14100. 85.9095727
14160. 85.8778236.
14220. 85.8459912
14280. 85.8140761
14400. 85.75 14460. 85.7178403
85,6856003
14580. 85.6532806
14640. 85.6208818
14760. 85,55584!15
14880. 85.4905083
14940. 85,4577234
85.3.919283
15120. 85.3589193
15180. 85.3258367
15240. 85.2926814
1.5300, 85,2594539
85.1927847
85.1258343
15600. 85.0922552
84.99111.03
15840. 84.9572615
15900. 84.9233469
15960. 84.!1893671
16020, 84.7185133
16320. 84.664156
16380, 84.6497382
16440. 84.61.52604
16680. 84.4767627
16740. 84.441995
84.4071.712
16860, 17040. 84.2673293
84.1618924
17400. 83,9851595
83.7715262
18120. 83,62823 83.5563361
18300. 83.5203301
83.4482033
83.412084
18600. 83.3397367
18660. 83.3035102
83.2672494
18960. 19020. 19140. 83.0125201
82.9394708
82.9029046
82.8296929
19500. 19560. 151860, 82.S726!H2
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl39 ofB156 138 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 205 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) llT Outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var.: Temperature (Fl Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 82.5358894
20040. 20100. 82.3146889
20340. 20400. 82.2408238
20460, 20700. 20760. 82,0189126
20820, 81.9448556
81.7966457
21180. 21240. Bl.7225041
21300. 21600. 21660, 22080, 81,2033543
22140, 22200. Bl.1292352
22260. 80.8330977
22800. 80.7591762
80.6653111
23040. 80,6115081
23100. 23160. 110.5377727
23400. 80.3905274
23460. 110.31702116
23580. 23640. 80.24362 23760, 80.1703071
231120. 23940. 24300. 79.8053726
25140. 25200. 79.300038'1
25260. 25320. 253110. 79.1570825
79.011511696
25620. 25680. 25980, 711.8029104
26100. 262110. 711.6626417
26460, 265110. 78.315844
26940. Dep. Var. 82.4990679
B2.42SJ684
82.2777638
82.2038698
82.0559265
81.981!1887
81.9078141
81..7595774
81.6854265
81..5370881.
81.4629119
81.1662916
80.7961302
80.5746316
110.5009321
110.427301111
110.3537671
80.21103127
80.13361182
80.0605292
79.9874799
79.9145457
79.6240718
79.4796699
78.7677645
711.6976295
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B140 ofB156 139 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 206 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) llT outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (aee) Oep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Oap, Var. Ind. Var. Pep. var. 78,2471908
27060. 78.2129568
271110. 78.1446772
27240. 78.1106329
78.0766531
27360. 78.0427385
27420. 78.0088897
27540. 77.9413922
27600. 27660. 77.8741657
27720. 77.8406557
27900. 77.7405461
27960. 77.7073186
77.6741633
77.6080717
77.5751368
77,5094917
28380. 77.4767828
28500. 77.4115955
28560. 28620. 77.3467194
28680. 77.3143997
77.2821597
77.25 28860. 77.2179212
77.18592351
29100, 2!1160. 77.0587622
77.0271817
29280. 76.9956863
29340. 76.9642766
29400. 76.9329533
29460. 29520. 76.8705682
29580. 76.8395075
29640. 76.8085356
76.777653
76.7468603
76.6550275
30000. 76.6246003
30060. 76.594265!:1
30120. 76.5640249
30180, 76.5338778
76.5038254
76.4440063
76.414240!:1
30480. 76.3845723
30660. 30840. 76.2086256
30900, 76.1796505
30960. 76.1507767
31020, 76.122004.7
76.0933351
31320. 75.9796916
31380. 75.9515421
75.9234982
31740. 75.7848821
75.7301937
75,5422712
75.4373712
75.4114335
75.3856117
32760. 75.3088468
75.2834935
32940, 75.2582587
33180. 75.0849686
75.0365493
33600. 74.9648444
33720. 33780. 74.9176625
74.8942593
33960. 34020. 74.8248061
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B141 ofB156 140 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 207 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_ LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time {sec) Dep. var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 34140. 74.7791386
74.733993
34320. 74.7115982
34440, 74.6672167
74.6452209
74.6233555
34620, 74.6016212
74.5585468
74.516001
34980. 74.47398?1
35040. 74.4531806
35100. 74.4325083
35160. 74.3511694
3541>0. 74.3113135
74.2915912
35700. 35760. 74,214077.9
35820, 74.1950455
35940. 74.1573982
74.1019766
36180. 36240. 74.0657325
36300. 74.0478226
36360. 74.0300545
36420. 74.0124297
73.9776051
73.960407.9
36660. 73.9433543
36720. 73 .9264445 73.909679
73.87651117
7J .844065 37140. 73.8121313
37200. 73.7963838
37260. 37380. 73.7500226
37440. 37560. 37620. 73.6902747
37690. 37740. 73.6612917
37800. 73.6189372
37980. 73.6051188
3S040. 38100. 73 .5779331 38220. 73.5513507
38280. 73.5253736
73.5126127
38460. 38580. 73.4510939
38940. 73.4046357
39000. 73.3714096
39300. 73.3395762
39360. 73.3292756
73.3091412
73.2801095
73.2707451
39900, 73.2435924
73.2348557
40260. 73.1935356
73.l.7064
73.1561689
40620, 40680. 40740, 73.1356541
73.1291341
40860. 41040. 73.1046491
41100. 73.0989272
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B142 ofB156 141 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 208 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) llT outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sac) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 41160. 73.0933652
41220. 73.0679632
73.0776399
41400. 7J .0727187 73.0679579
73,0633577
41580. 73.05891Sl
73.0546392
41700. 73.0505211
41760. 73.0465639
41620. 73.0427676
41940. 73. 0356581 42000. 73.0323451
42060. 42120. 73.0262027
42180. 73.0233734
73.0207056
42300. 42360. 73.0158542
73.0136708
42480. 73.0116489
42720. 73.005178
73.0039645
42840. 7J.002n21
42900. 73.0020228
42960. 73.0012946
73.0007282
73.0003236
43260. 73.0000809
43320. 73.0003236
43500. 73.0020228
43560. 73.0039645
43680. 4374.0. 73.0065532
43800, 73.0080901
43660. 73.0116489
43980. 44040. 73.0158542
44100. 73.0181992
44160. 73.0207056
44220. 73.0233734.
44280. 73.0262027
73.0.?.91932
73.0323451
44460. 44520. 73. 0391323 44640. 73.0465639
44700. 73.0546392
73.06751579
45000. 73 ,0727187 45060. 73.07763Sl9
45120. 73.0879632
45420. 7J .1105309 45600. 46020. 46440. 46500. 46560. 73.2615373
73.2801095
4.6600. 46860. 73 .2SISl3077
46920. 73.309141.?.
46980, 73.3191305
73.3292756
4.7280. 73.3714096
47400. 73.4160196
47700. 73.4510939
41760. 73.46309.?.l
73.4.8754'13
48060. 73.5253736
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl43 ofB156 142 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 209 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTH \ Compare File: C :\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ind. Var. 48360. 46600. 48720. 48840. 48960. 49080. 49560. 49800. 49no. 50280, 50400. 50520. 50640. 50760. 51240. 51360. 51480. 51600. 51720. 51840. 51960. 52080. 52200. 52320. 52440. 52560. 52680, 52920. 53160. 53400. 535:?.0. 54000. 54120, 54480, 54960. 55200. Function (cont.) llT Outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time {aec) Pep. Var.: Temperature (F) Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 73.55114507
73.6189372
73.647024
73.6757087
73.7049894
n.1Gsnn 49140. 73.7963838
49260. 73.8280251
73.8930579'
49620. 73.9264445
73.9949455
49SIBO. 74.1387841
50460, 74.1761521
74.2140779
74.2525586
50820. 74.4119705
51300. 74.4949274
74.5372076
51660. 74.6233555
51900. 74. 7115982 52140. 74.7564966
52260, 74.8019086
52500. 74.9886222
52860. 75.183269
53580. 75.3343179
53700. 75.3856117
53820. 53940. 75.5954038
54300. 75.6489861
54420.
54540. 75. 7574832 75.8677296
76.0363053
55260. Dep. Var. 73.5779331
73.6051188
73.6329057
73.6612917
73.6902747
73.7500226
73.780783
73.8121313
73.84.4065
73.8765817
73.909619
73.9776051
74.0124287
74,0478226
74.0837839
74.1203101
74.1950455
74.2332491
74.2720061
74.3113135
74.3511684
74.3915677
74.4739871
74.516001
74.6016212
74.6452209
74.6893426
74.733983
74.7791386
74.8248061
74.8709819
74.9176625
75.012524
75.0606976
75.1585123
75.2081459
*15.2582587
75.4634243
75.5158748
75.5687811
75.622139
75.6759446
75.7301937
75.7848821
75.9515421
76.0647685
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B144 ofB156 143 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 210 of 254 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-TRANS_Case_12.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function {cent.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (see) Dep. Var.: Temperature (Fl Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. 55440. 76.1507767
76.2086256
76,2668775
55800. 76.3255279
76.3845723
56040. 76.4440063
56160. 76.5038254
56260. 76.5640249
76.6246003
76.685547
56640. 76.746B603
56760. 76.8705682
57000. 76.9329533
 
76.9956863
57360. 57480. 77.1859239
77.25 77.3791.182
57960. 7'1.5094917
58200. 58320. 77.6410808
77.7073186
58560. 77.8406557
58800. 77.9077448
59160. 78.1106329
78.315844
59640. 78.3847396
78.5:232373
78.8029104
60480. 78.9440007
?'il.0148405
60960. 79.228<1738
79.3000381
79.37177 61440. 61800. 61920. 79.7327506
79.8781235
62280. Var. Dep. Var. 55380. 76.1220047
76.1796505
76.2377014
76.25161531.
76.3550011
55980. 76.4142409
76.473868
56220. 56340. 76.5942659
56580. 76.7161581
56700. 56820. 76.8395075
76.901717
57060. 76.9642766
57180. 57300, 77.1540088
77.2179212
57660. 77.2821597
57780, 77.4115955
58020, 77.4767828
77.5422766
77.6080717
77.674.1633
58620. 77.8741657
58860. 77.9413922
59100. 59220. 78.2129568
59460, 59580. 59700. 78.4192767
78.7677645
78.8381076
60540. 78.9086535
78.9793966
79.0503317
60900. 61.020. 61140. 79.2642347
79.3358834
61500. 61740. 61860, 79.6964898
 
79.7690451
62340. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl45 ofB156 144 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 211 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ind. Var. 62400. 62640. 62880, 63240. 63Jt;i0. 63720. 64080, 64560. 64680. 64.920. 65400. 65760. 65880. 66240. 66480. 66840. 67680. 67800. 68040. 68160. 68760. Function (cont.) llT Outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time (sec) Dep. Var. : Temperature (F) Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. Var. 80.0239905
62460. 80.0605292
80,0970954
62580, 80.1336882
80.1703071
80.24362 62820. 80.2803127
80.4273088
B0.5377727
63300. 80.5746316
80.6115081
80.6484015
63540. 80.7222362
80.7591762
80.8330977
63780. 64020. 81..0lBlJ.lJ
81,0551444
64140. Bl.. 0.921859 81,1292352
64260. 81.1662916
81.2404.226
Bl.3145735
81.3516546
64620. 81.3887384
81.4258244
64740. 81.4629119
81.8707648
Ei54.60. 81..90781.41
81.9448556
65820. 82.1299222
82.16'.69023
6594.0. 82.2038698
82.3884.919
66300. 82.4253684
82,4622273
66420. 82.4990679
82.5358894
66540. 82.5726912
82,6094726
82.6462329
82.6829714
66780. 82.71.96873
82.756)8 66900. 82.9029046
67140. 67260. 83.1946274
83.2672494
67740. 83,3397367
67860. 83.3759282
83.5563361
68220. 83.62823 68340. 83.6641166
83.7715262
68580. 83.9141304
83.9496683
83.9851595
6894.0, 84.0206034
69060. 84.09134.65
69420. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B146 ofB156 145 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 212 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_Case_12.GTH
\ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Ind. Var. 69480. 69600. 69840. 69960. 70320. 70440. 70560. 70680. 71040. 71160. 71280. 71640. 71760. 71880. 72120. 72360. 72480. 72720. 72960. 73200. 73320. 73440. 73680. 73800. 74160. 74640. 74760.
74880.
75000. 75120. 75240. 75480.
75600. 75840. 75960. 76080. 76440. Function (c:ont.J llT outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time {sec) Dep, Var.: Temperature (F) Dep. Var. Ind. Var. 84,3373583
69540. 84.4071712
69660. 84.4767627
84.5461276
69900. 84.6152604
84.684156
84.7528092
70260. 84.8212146
70380. 84.8893671
84.9572615
70620. 85.0248926
70740. 85.0922552
70860. 85.1593443
70980. BS.2261548
71100. 85.2!126814
71220. 85.3589193
71340. 85.4248632
85.4905083
85.5558495
71700. 85.6208918
71820. 85.6856003
71940. 85.75 72060. 85.8140761
72180. 85.8778236
BS.9412378
72420. 86.0043137
72540. 86.0670467
72660. 86.1294318
72780. 86.1914644
86.2531397
86.3753997
73260. 86.435!1751
73380. 86.4961746
73500. 86.5559937
86.6154277
73740. 86.6744722
73860. 86.7331225
74100.
74220. 86.9066649
86.9636947
87.0765018
87.1322704
74820. 87.1876101
74940. 87.2969861
75180. 87.3510139
75300. 75420. 87.4577288
75540. 87.5104076
75660. 87.5626288
87.6143883
87.6656821
76020. 87. 7165065 76380. 87.8661236
76500. Dap. Var. 84.3722921
84.441995
84.5114738
84.6497382
 
84.7185133
84.9233469
85.0586078
85.1258343
85.2594539
85.3919283
85.4577234
85.5884045
85.6532806
85.7178403
85.8459912
85.9095727
85.9728183
86.0357234
86.098283
86.1604925
86.222347
86.2838419
86.344972.5
86.4661222
86.526132
86.6449989
86.7038469
96.7622986
87.1599942
87.2151179
87.3240554
87.377,861
87.5365757
87.5885665
87.6911532
87.7417413
87.7918541
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B147 ofB156 146 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 213 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.; Tit11e (sec) Pep. Var.: Temperature (F} Incl. Var. Pep. Var. Ind. Var. Pep. Var. 76560. 87.9150314
76620. 87.9393024
76680. 87.9634507
8B.Dll377B
765120. BB.058809
88.1057407
77100. 88.1290181
77160. 88.1980914
77340. 88.2208614
77400. 88.2435034
77460. 88.266017
77520. 88.3106574
88,3327833
77700. 88.3547791
77760. 77880, 78120. 88.5050726
78240. 88.5468194
78300. 88.5674917
78360. BB.5980295
784.20. 88.6084323
BB.6286998
78540. 88.6488316
78600. BS.6688273
78660. 88.6886865
78720. 88.7084088
78780. 88.7279939
78840. 88.7474414
88.7667509
78960. 79080. 88.8238479
H140. 79200. 88,8612159
79260. 88.8796899
88.9162161
79560. 88.9875713
79680. 7!1920. 89.0735555
79980. 89.1069421
80100. 89.1234183
80160. 89.1397494
89.155935
89.1719749
80340. 89.1878687
89.2036162
80460. 80520, 89.2346708
80580. 89.2499774
80640. 89.2651364
80700. 89.2801476
80880. 89.3242913
80940. 89.33870!13
81000. 89.352976
81060. 89.3670943
89.4220669
81360, 89,4354336
81420. 89.4486493
81720. 89.5124527
89.5247567
81840. 89.5369079
81900. 89.54.89061
89.5953643
89.6176695
89.6285904
89.6393566
89.6499678
82680. 89.6908588
89.7006923
89.7292549
83160, 89.7651443
83220. 89.8142546
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B148 ofB156 147 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 214 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (c:ont.) 11T outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.: Time {sec:) Dep. Var.: Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind.. Var. Dep. Var. 83640. 89.82936 89.836670
89,843B3ll
89.8576667
84000. 89.8708659
84060. 89.8772265
84120. 89.8834276
0.8894691
84240. 89,8953509
89.9010728
84360. 89.9066348
89.9120368
84480. 89.9172786
84540. 89.9223601
89.92728l3
84660. 89.9320421
84720. 89.9366423
84780. 89.9410819
84840. 89.9453608
89.9494789
89.9534361
85020. 89.9608677
85200. 89.9676549
89.51708068
85320. 89.97375173
85380. 89.9766266
89.9792944
85500. 85560. 89.9841.458
85620. 851.51863292
89.9883511
851.51902113
89.99U099
85860. 85920. 85980. 851.9960355
89.9970873
851.51979772
86160. 89.9387054
89.95192718
89.9996764
86340. 86400, 89.51999191
89.9996764
86580. 86640. 89.9987054
86700. 89.51979772
86760, 89.9970873
89.9960355
89.994822
865140. 87000. 89.9919099
89.9902113
87120. 89.9883511
89.9863292
89.984].458
87480. 89.9737973
87540. 89.9708068
87600, 89.9676549
87660. 89.9643419
89.9608677
89.9534361
87960. 89.9453608
88020. 88080. 89.9366423
89.8894691
88740, 89,8708659
88920. 89.8576667
88980. 89.8508284
851100. 89.8218865
89280. 89.81.42546
89340. 89.8064644
89.7985161
89460. 89.7821455
89.765144.3
89700. 89760. 89820. 851.7384627
89.7292549
89.7103695
89.7006923
90120. 89.6908588
!:10180. 8!il.68086!il5
90300. 89.6604238
89.6499678
90420. 89.6285904
90510. 89.6176695
90600. 89.6065941
90660. 89.5953643
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B149 ofB156 148 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 215 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-oo""4_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_
Case_ 12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Function (cont.) outdoor Air Temperature
Ind. Var.' Time (aec) Dep. Var. : Temperature (F) Ind. Var. Dep. Var. Ind. Var. Dep. V3.r. 90720. 89.5839804
90780. 89.5724426
89.5607511
89.5489061
90960. BSl.53690751
89.5247567
91200. 89.4873873
91260. 89.4746264
89.4220669
91560. 89.4085493
91620. 89,3948812
91680. 89.3810626
91740, 89.3670943
.91800. 89.352976
89.3387083
91!120. 92040, 89,2950106
Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 41C Outdoor Air Temperature:
G=l.O aO::O. min::::i-l.e32
max=l.e32
tfunc Y=G*interp (alXl, tableX2) Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value Etime I cM I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 Table DCllT 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 42C DG Intake Heat Transfer:
G=l.O a0=0, min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
sum Y=G* (aO+alXl+a2X2+
... +anXn) Gothic_s variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value 11 cond_grp_heat (l) I cC70sl I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Thermal Conductor
Type 24 11 Piping Mat. Bdry. Thick Sub-Heat Region (in) (in) regs. Factor 0. 0. 00324 0. 0.00324 0.00648 0. 0. 00972 0. 01296 0. 0. 02268 0. 02592 0. 0.0486 0. 05184 0. 0 .10044 0. 06864 o. 0 .16908 0.06864 o. 0.23772 0. 04434 0. 0. 28206 0. 04434 0. 10 0. 3264 0. 02592 o. July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAl-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl50 ofB156 149 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 216 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-TRANS_Case_12.GTH
\Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Region 11 12 13 Thermal Conductor
Type (cont.) Mat. 24" Piping Bdry. (in) 0.35232 0.36528 0.37176 Thick {in) 0.01296
0.00648 0.00324 Sub-Heat regs. Factor o. o. 0. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Thermal Conductor
Type 8 36 11 Piping Mat. Bdry. Thick Sub-Heat Region # (in) (in)
regs. Factor 1 1 0. 0. 00324 1 0. 2 1 0.00324 0.00648 1 0. 3 1 0. 00972 0. 01296 1 0. 4 1 0.02268 0. 02592 1 0. 5 1 0. 0486 0. 05184 1 o. 6 1 0 .10044 0. 06864 1 0. 7 1 0 .16908 0.06864 1 0. 8 1 0.23772 0. 04434 1 0. 9 1 0.28206 0. 04434 1 o. 10 1 0. 3264 0. 02592 1 0. 11 1 0. 35232 0. 01296 1 0. 12 1 0. 36528 0. 00648 1 0. 13 1 0.37176 0. 00324 1 o. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 44C DG Intake That: G=l.O aO=O. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
sum Y=G* {aO+a1Xl+a2X2+
*** +anXn) Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Cvval (0) I cv41C I 0.21783386
1.1 Cvval (0) CV43C Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. # Function Components
Control Variable soc Local Rho*V*D: G=l.O aO=O. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y;;::;G* (a1Xl.*a2X2*
... *anXn}, ao unused Gothic_ s Variable Coef. Name location a Rm cV@ Cvval (0) cv49C Dhyd cV@ 1. 1. 1. Min. Max Value Value -1e+32 I le+32 -1e+32 le+32 Min. Max Value Value -le+32 le+32 -1e+32 le+32 -1e+32 le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page BISI ofB156 150 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 217 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File, Function Components
Control Variable 45C Local Vx**2: G=l. 0 aO=O. min=-1. e32 max=l. e32 mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
*.. *anXn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Uccxv I cV I 1.1 Uccxv cV 1. Following
table in the compare File but not in the current File. Function components
Control Variable 46C Local Vy** 2 : G=l.O aO=O. minc-l.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anXn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Uccyv I cV I 1.1 Uccyv cV 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control variable 4 7C Local Vz**2: G=-1.0 aO:::O. min=-1. e32 max=l. e32 mult (a1Xl*a2X2*
... *anXn) , ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Ucczv I cV I 1.1 Ucczv cV 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File, Function Components
Control Variable 4 BC Local (Vx**2 + Vy**2 + Vz**2): G=l.O aO=O. min:::-l.e32
max=l.e32
Y=G* (aO+alX1+a2X2+
... +anXn) Got:hic_s
Variable Coef. Name location Cvval(O) cv45C 1. Cvval (0) cv46C 1. Cvval (0) CV47C 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 49C Local IVI: G"'l aO=o.S min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
'"'a2X2 or G* (alXl) ... aO Gothic_s Name Variable location Coef. Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value I I I Cvval (0) I cv48C I 1. 1 -le+32 I Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 1e+32 1e+32 Max Value le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl52 ofB156 151 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 218 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable SlC Local Re: G=l.O aO=O. min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
div Y=G* (aO+a2X2)
I (alXl) Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Visv I cV I 1.1 Cvval (0) cvsoc 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 52C Local cp*mu: G=l.O a0=0. rnin=-1.e32
max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
*.. *anXn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Cpv I Viscv cV I cV 1.1 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 53C Local Pr: G:::::l. O aOc:O. min:::::-1.
e32 max:::::l.
e32 div Y=G* (aO+a2X2)
I (alXl) Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a Condv I cV I 1.1 Cvval (O) cvS2C 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable S4C Re**l/2: G=l.O aO=O.S rnin=-l.e32
max,.,l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
'"'a2X2 or G* (alXl) '"'ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a 1 I Cvval (0) I cvSlC I 1. I Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable SSC Pr**l/3: G=l.O a0=0.333 min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+a1Xl)
'"'a2X2 or G* (alXl) '"'ao Gothic_s Name Variable location Coef. Min. Value -le+32 I -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 I -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 I -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 I Min. Value Cvval (0) I cvS3C / 1. 1 -le+32 I Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 Max Value le+32 Max Value le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl53 ofB156 152 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 219 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_12a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 56C O. 62*Re** (1/2) *Pr** (1/3) : G=O. 62 aO=O. min=-1. e32 max=l.e32
mult Y=G* (a1x1*a2x2*
**. *anXn), ao unused Gothic_a Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value CVVal (0) I cv54C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 Cvval (0) cvSSC 1. -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 57C (0.4/Pr)**(2/3)'
G=O ,54288 aO=-. 667 min=-l .e32 max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl) "a2x2 or G* (alXl) '"'ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value 11 CVVal (O) I cv53C I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable SBC [l+(0.4/Pr)**{2/3)]**(1/4):
G=l.0 aD=l min=-l.e32
max,,,l .e32 exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
"'a2X2 or G* (alXl) "ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value CVVal (0) I cv57C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 One cM 0 .25 -le+32 le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 60C (Re/282000)
** (S/8): G::::.625
aO=D.000392
min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl)
'"'a2X2 or G* (alXl) '"'ao Gathic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value l I CVVal (0) I cvSlC I 1. I -le+32 I le+32 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 61C [l+(Re/282000)**(5/8)]**(4/5):
G=l.O aO=l min,,,-l.e32
max=l.e32
exp Y=G* (aO+alXl) "a2X2 or G* (alXl) "ao Gothic_s Variable Coef. Min. Max # Name location a Value Value CVVal (0) I cv60C I 1.1 -le+32 I le+32 One cM 0 .8 -le+32 le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page B154 ofB156 153 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 220 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
RO\CPS 1A DG LoV LOOP-TRANS
Case 12.GTH \ Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12a.GTH Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 62C O. 62*Re** (1/2) *Pr** (1/3) I [l+ (0. 4/Pr) ** (2/3) J ** (1/4) * [l+ (Re/282000)
mult Y=G* (a1Xl*a2X2*
.*. *anJCn), ao unused Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a CVVal (O) I cv59C I 1.1 CVVal (0) cv61C l. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 59C o. 62*Re** (1/2) *Pr** (1/3) I [l+ (O. 4/Pr) ** (2/3)] ** (1/4) : G=l.O aO=O. m div Y=G* (aO+a2X2)
I (alXl) Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a CVVal (0) I cvsec I 1.1 CVVal (0) cv56C 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the Current File. Function Components
Control Variable 63C Local Nu: G=l.O a0=0.3 min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
sum Y=G* (aO+alXl+a2X2+
... +anXn) Gothic_s Variable Coef. # Name location a 1 I CVVal (0) I cv62C I l. I Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Function Components
Control Variable 43C DG Intake Heat Transfer+
Delay: G=l.O a0=-5 min=-l.e32
max=l.e32
if (alXl+aO<O
alXl+aO=O
alXl+aO:.O)
Y=Ga2X2 Y=Ga3X3 Y=Ga4X4 Gothic_ s Variable Coef. Name location Etime cM 1. One cM 0. One cM 0. CVVal (0) cv42C 1. Following
table in the Compare File but not in the current File. Data File: 2 File Name: Case_l2a_Panel_Temperatures.csv
File Type: TIME Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 Min. value -le+32 Min. Value -le+32 -le+32 -le+32 -le+32 Parameter
Description
Value Reference
x. Y, Z Start Time Time Increment
End Time UNUSED UNUSED UNUSED Max Value I le+32 le+32 Max Value I le+32 le+32 Max value I le+32 Max Value le+32 le+32 le+32 le+32 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page BISS ofBlS6 154 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 221 of 254 NUMeRICAL
APPLICATIONS
File Comparison:
Double entries indicate differences.
Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
I Current File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1 A_DG_LoV _LOOP-TRANS_Case_
12.GTH \Compare File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_LoV_LOOP-TRANS_Case_12a.GTH
Jul/24/2017
20:59:30 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 201_6 ___________
---, Data File: 2 (cont.) File Name: Caae_l2a_Panel_Temperatures ,csv File Type: TIME Parameter
Description
Value Reference
X, Y, Z Volume UNUSED 0,0,0 Item l TV14 Item 2 TV15 Item 3 TV16 Item 4 TV17 Item 5 TV18 Item 6 TV19 Item 7 TV20 July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Bl56 ofBI56 155 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 222 of 254 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTIIlC Uncertainty
Evaluation
Attachment
C. Sensitivities
on Case lOa July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Cl ofC30 
....----------------------------
--------------------
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 223 of 254 C.1 Objective
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
This attachment
performs three sensitivities
on Case lOa as follows: NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page C2 ofC30 * Case lOb will re-run Case lOa using a surface temperature
of 175&deg;F for thermal conductor
1 (engine block "warm" surface) and a surface temperature
of 750&deg;F for thermal conductor
2 (engine block "hot" surface) per Reference
[8.16]. Prior to running Case 1 Ob, the change will be benchmarked.
* Case 1 Oc will re-run Case 1 Oa based on a re-benchmark
whereby the benchmarking
is conducted
such that the calculated
room exhaust temperature
is 0.8&deg;F higher by the end of the generator
test (i.e., at 4,920 seconds) than the room exhaust temperature
indicated
by the test data (Reference
[8.16]). * Case lOd will re-run case lOa using a surface temperature
of l 75&deg;F for thermal conductor
1 (engine block "warm" surface) and a surface temperature
of 800&deg;F for thermal conductor
2 (engine block "hot" surface) per Reference
[8 .16]. Prior to running Case 1 Od, the change will be benchmarked.
Benchmarking
is performed
in accordance
with Section 4.12 of Reference
[8.14]. C.2 Approach -Engine Block Surface Temperature
Changes Thermal conductor
1 represents
the wami (i.e., l 72&deg;F) surface of the engine block. It uses surface option 4 to apply a constant surface temperature
which references
forcing function.
Surface option 4 references
forcing function 1 T. Forcing function 1 Tis temperature
as a function of time. All entries except the first (which constitutes
the initial temperature
of the engine block) are multiplied
by 175/172 to change the steady state temperature
values to 175&deg;F (Reference
[8.16]) for Cases lOb and lOd and to maintain the same shape of curve for all intermediate
temperature
values. Thermal conductor
2 represents
the hot (i.e., 700&deg;F) surface of the engine block. It uses surface option 5 to apply a constant surface temperature
which references
forcing function.
Surface option 5 references
forcing function 2T. Forcing function 2T is temperature
as a function of time. All entries except the first (which constitutes
the initial temperature
of the engine block) are multiplied
by 750/700 to change the steady state temperature
values to 750&deg;F (Reference
[8.16]) for Case lOb and to maintain the same shape of curve for all intermediate
temperature
values. For lOd, the values are multiplied
by 800/700 to change the steady state temperature
values to 800&deg;F (Reference
[8.16]) and to maintain the same shape of curve for all intermediate
temperature
values C.3 Set B Benchmark
Results Surface option 6, which is the heat transfer coefficient
associated
with the engine surface thermal conductors, was changed to 5.8 Btu/hr-ft 2-&deg;F in order to affect the GOTHIC calculated
heat load to match the target load. It is noted that this value is consistent
with typical heat transfer coefficient
values for forced convection
in gases per Reference
[8.5], Table 1.1 (from 25 to 250 W/m2-&deg;F or 4.4 to 44 Btu/hr-ft 2-&deg;F). This value is used to July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 224 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Di esel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Eva luation NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Pa ge C3 of C30 calculate
the engine block heat load using 122&deg;F as the ambient temperature
for co mparison to the vendor provided estimate of 2 Btu/min per KW similar to what was done in Table 4-2 -this is s hown in Table C.3-2, which shows that the resulting
engine block heat lo ad is conse rvative. Results are shown below in Figure C-1, Figure C-2, and Ta bl e C.3-1. Jul/24/2017
20: 13:3 9 GOTHIC Version 8.2{QA) -Oct 2016 File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
_ RO\CPS _ 1 A_ DG _Benchmark_b. GTH Figure C-1-Comparison
of Total Heat Rate Transferred
into the Division 1 DG Room (red line -heat rate calculated
from the DG Surveillance
test; white line -heat rate used in the GOTIDC model) July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 62 0632 , Attachment
2 , Page 2 2 5 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Jul/24/2017
20: 13: 47 GOTHIC Version B.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Di v i s ion 1 D iesel G e n erat or Ro o m GOTHI C U n ce rta i n ty E v a lu at i o n File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\CPS_1A_DG_Benchmark_b.GTH NAI-2 0 07-004 R evis ion 0 P age C4 of C30 Figure C-2 -Comparison
of Supply and E x haust Air Temperature (green line -supply air temperature
measured during the DG surveillance
test; yellow line -supply air temperature
input into the GOTHIC simulation;
red line -exhaust air temperature
measured during the DG surveillance;
white line -exhaust air temperature
calculated
in GOTHIC) July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620 632 , Attachment
2, Page 22 6 of 254 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertaint
y Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Re v ision 0 Page CS ofC30 Table C.3-1-Division 1 Room Temperature
Comparison
at Four Locations
M eas ur e GOTHIC Temperatur
e C orr e sponding C a lculated Location Descripti on T e mperature
T e mp e ratur e Diff e renc e Time (o F) (o F) (o F) (sec) 1 Near the Rollup Door 83.1 87.6 4.5 4800 2 Near Transform e r Panel 8 7.5 89.1 1.6 4860 3 Near Air Compr ess or Panel 79 8 6.3 7.3 4920 4 DG General Area 77.7 81.3 3.6 5040 5 Exhaust Air Temp e ratur e 84.7 84.7 0 4920 Notes: 1. The mea s ur ed t e mperatures
a t these location s are a t th e end of t he DG s urveill a nce test. The t e mperature s calculated
b y GOTHIC mod e l are at the re s p e cti ve time. Table C.3-2 -Adjusted Total Diesel Generator
Benchmark
Heat Load Compared to Test Data Total Generator
Heat Load for Set C T area U wann A w arm T wann q warm U bot Ah ot Th ot qh o t qt ota l q vendor LST KW (o F) (Btu/hr-(ft 2) (o F) (Btu/sec) (Btu/hr-(fi2) (o F) (Btu/sec) (Btu/sec) (Btu/s e c) ft2-o F) ft2-&deg;F) 10:45 AM 3750 122 5.800 848 175 72.4 5.800 80 7 50 80.9 153.4 125.0 10: 50AM 3750 122 5.800 8 4 8 175 72.4 5.800 80 7 50 80.9 153.4 1 2 5.0 10: 55 AM 3700 122 5.800 84 8 175 72.4 5.800 80 7 50 80.9 153.4 1 23.3 11: 00 AM 3750 122 5.800 84 8 175 72.4 5.800 80 7 50 80.9 153.4 1 2 5.0 11: 05 AM 3800 122 5.800 848 175 72.4 5.800 80 750 80.9 153.4 12 6.7 ll:lOAM 3700 122 5.800 8 4 8 175 72.4 5.800 80 7 50 80.9 153.4 123.3 11: 15 AM 3750 1 22 5.800 8 48 175 72.4 5.800 80 7 50 80.9 153.4 1 25.0 11: 20 AM 3700 122 5.800 84 8 175 72.4 5.800 80 750 80.9 153.4 1 23.3 11: 25AM 3750 1 22 5.800 848 175 72.4 5.800 80 7 50 80.9 153.4 1 2 5.0 1 1: 30 AM 3750 122 5.800 848 175 72.4 5.800 80 750 80.9 153.4 1 2 5.0 1 1:35AM 3800 122 5.800 848 175 72.4 5.800 80 7 50 80.9 153.4 1 26.7 C.4 Set C Benchmark
Results Surface option 6 , which is the heat transfer coefficient
associated
with the engine surface thermal conductors, was changed to 6.8 Btu/hr-ft 2-&deg;F in order to affect the GOTHIC calculated
heat load to match the target load. It is noted that this value is consistent
with typical heat transfer coefficient
values for forced convection
in gases per Reference
[8.5], Table 1.1(from25
to 250 W/rn2-&deg;F or 4.4 to 44 Btu/hr-ft 2-&deg;F). This value is used to calculate
the engine block heat load using l22&deg;F as the ambient temperature
for comparison
to the vendor provided estimate of 2 Btu/min per KW similar to what was done in Table 4-2 -this is shown in Table C.4-2, which shows that the resulting
engine block heat load is conservative.
Results are shown below in Figure C-3, Figure C-4, and Table C.4-1. J uly 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 62 0 632 , A tta ch m e nt 2 , Pa ge 22 7 o f 25 4 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Jul/24/2017
20: 13: 59 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 C linton Di v i s ion l D iese l Ge n erator Ro om GOTHI C U n ce rt ainty Eva lu a t io n File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\CPS
_1A_DG_Benchmark_c.GTH NAI-2007-004 Revisi on 0 Page C6 o f C 3 0 Figure C-3 -Comparison
of Total Beat Rate Transferred
into the Division 1 DG Room (red line -heat rate calculated
from the DG Surveillance
test; white lin e -heat rat e used in the GOTHIC model) July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 228 of 254 Jul/24/2017
20: 14:04 GOTHIC Version B.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Di v i s ion l Di esel Generator
Room GOTIITC Uncertainty
Eva lu ation F i le: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\CPS
_ 1 A_DG _Benchmark_
c. GTH NAI-2007-004
R evisi on 0 Pa ge C7 ofC3 0 Figure C-4 -Comparison
of Supply and Exhaust Air Temperature (green line -supply air temperature
measured during the DG surveillance
test; yellow line -supply air temperature
input into the GOTHIC simulation;
red line -exhaust air temperature
measured during the DG surveillance;
white line -exhaust air temperature
calculated
in GOTHIC) July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 229 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page CS of C30 Table C.4-1-Division 1 Room Temperature
Comparison
at Four Locations
Measure GOTHIC Temperature
Corresponding
Calculated
Location Description
Temperature
Temperature
Differenc e Time (o F) (o F) (o F) (sec) I Near the Rollup Door 83.1 88.6 5.5 4800 2 Near Transformer
Panel 87.5 89.9 2.4 4860 3 Near Air Compressor
Panel 79 87.1 8.1 4920 4 DG General Area 77.7 81.7 4 5040 5 Exhaust Air Temperature
84.7 85.5 0.8 4920 Notes: I. The measured temperatures
at these location s are at the end of the DG survei llance te st. The temperatures
calculated
by GOTHIC model are at the respective
time. Table C.4-2 -Adjusted Total Diesel Generator
Benchmark
Heat Load Compared to Test Data Total Generator
Heat Load for Set C T a r ca U wann A wann T wann q warm Uh ot A hot Tho* q total q vcndo r LST KW (o F) (Btu/hr-(ft 2) (o F) (Btu/sec) (Btu/hr-(fi2) (o F) (Btu/sec) (Btu/sec) (Btu/sec)
ft2-o F) ft2-&deg;F) 10:45 AM 3750 122 6.800 848 175 84.9 6.800 80 750 94.9 179.8 125.0 10: 50AM 3750 122 6.800 848 175 84.9 6.800 80 750 94.9 179.8 125.0 10: 55 AM 3700 122 6.800 848 175 84.9 6.800 80 750 94.9 179.8 123.3 11: 00 AM 3750 122 6.800 848 175 84.9 6.800 80 750 94.9 179.8 125.0 11: 05 AM 3800 122 6.800 848 175 84.9 6.800 80 750 94.9 179.8 126.7 11: 10 AM 3700 122 6.800 848 175 84.9 6.800 80 750 94.9 179.8 123.3 11: 15 AM 3750 122 6.800 848 175 84.9 6.800 80 750 94.9 179.8 125.0 11: 20AM 3700 122 6.800 848 175 84.9 6.800 80 750 94.9 179.8 12 3.3 11: 25AM 3750 1 22 6.800 848 175 84.9 6.800 80 7 50 94.9 179.8 125.0 11: 30AM 3750 1 22 6.800 848 17 5 84.9 6.800 80 750 94.9 179.8 125.0 11:35AM 3800 122 6.800 848 175 84.9 6.800 80 750 94.9 179.8 126.7 C.5 Set D Benchmark
Results Surface option 6, which is the heat transfer coefficient
associated
with the engine surface thermal conductors, was changed to 5.6 Btu/hr-ft 2-&deg;F in order to affect the GOTHIC calculated
heat load to match the target load. It is noted that this value is consistent
with typical heat transfer coefficient
values for forced convection
in gases per Reference
[8.5], Table 1.1(from25
to 250 W/rn2-&deg;F or 4.4 to 44 Btu/hr-ft 2-&deg;F). This value is used to calculate
the engine block heat load using 122&deg;F as the ambient temperature
for comparison
to the vendor provided estimate of 2 Btu/min per KW similar to what was done in Table 4-2 -this is shown in Table C.5-2, which shows tha t the resulting
engine block heat load is conservative.
Results are shown below in Figure C-5, Figure C-6, and Table C.5-1. July 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT 
E C 62 0 632 , A tt achme nt 2 , Page 230 o f 2 5 4 Jul/24/2017
20: 14: 15 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 C lin to n Di v ision 1 Di esel G e n e rator Room GOTHIC U n ce rtaint y E v alu a ti o n File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\CPS
_1A_DG_Benchmark_d.GTH NAI-2007-004
R ev i si on 0 P a g e C 9 o f C30 Figure C-5 -Comparison
of Total Heat Rate Transferred
into the Division 1 DG Room (red line -heat rate calculated
from the DG Surveillance
test; white line -heat rate used in the GOTHIC model) Ju l y 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT -___,,,,,,.
I 
E C 62 0 632 , A tt achmen t 2 , P a ge 23 1 o f 254 Jul/24/2017
20: 14: 21 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clint on Di v i s ion I D iesel G e n era t o r Roo m GOTIIT C Unc e rtain ty Eva lu a ti o n File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_Benchmark
_d.GTH NAI-2 00 7-004 R evis ion 0 P a g e C l O o fC 30 Figure C-6 -Comparison
of Supply and Exhaust Air Temperature (green line -supply air temperature
measured during the DG surveillance
test; yellow line -supply air temperature
input into the GOTHIC simulation;
red line -exhaust air temperature
measured during the DG surveillance;
white line -exhaust a i r temperature
calculated
in GOTHIC) July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 232 of 254 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Cll ofC30 Table C.5-1-Division 1 Room Temperature
Comparison
at Four Locations
Measure GOTHIC Temperature
Corresponding
Calculated
Location Description
Temperature
Temperature
Difference
Time (O f) (&deg;F) (O f) (sec) l Near the Rollup Door 83.l 87.5 4.4 4800 2 Near Transformer
Panel 87.5 89.l 1.6 4860 3 Near Air Compressor
Panel 79 86.3 7.3 4920 4 DG General Area 77.7 81.3 3.6 5040 5 Exhaust Air Temperature
84.7 84.7 0 4920 Notes: l. The mea s ured temperatures
at these locations
are at the end of the DG surveillance
test. The temperatures
calculated
by GOTHIC model are at the respective
time. Table C.5-2 -Adjusted Total Diesel Generator
Benchmark
Heat Load Compared to Test Data Total Generator
Heat Load for Set C T area U warm Aw arm T w arm qwarm Uh o t A bot Th o t qhot ql o tal q ve nd o r LST KW (O f) (Btu/hr-(ft2) (of) (Btu/sec) (Btu/hr-(tt2) (o f) (Btu/sec) (Btu/sec) (Btu/sec)
ft 2 _o f) ft2-&deg;F) 10:45 AM 3750 122 5.600 848 175 69.9 5.600 80 800 84.4 154.3 125.0 10:50AM 3750 122 5.600 848 175 69.9 5.600 80 800 84.4 154.3 125.0 10: 55 AM 3700 122 5.600 848 175 69.9 5.600 80 800 84.4 154.3 123.3 11: 00 AM 3750 122 5.600 848 175 69.9 5.600 80 800 84.4 154.3 125.0 11: 05AM 3800 122 5.600 848 175 69.9 5.600 80 800 84.4 154.3 126.7 ll:lOAM 3700 122 5.600 848 175 69.9 5.600 80 800 84.4 154.3 123.3 11:15 AM 3750 122 5.600 848 175 69.9 5.600 80 800 84.4 154.3 125.0 11:20 AM 3700 122 5.600 848 175 69.9 5.600 80 800 84.4 154.3 123.3 11: 25 AM 3750 122 5.600 848 175 69.9 5.600 80 800 84.4 154.3 125.0 11:30 AM 3750 122 5.600 848 175 69.9 5.600 80 800 84.4 154.3 125.0 11: 35 AM 3800 122 5.600 848 175 69.9 5.600 80 800 84.4 154.3 126.7 C.6 Results The resulting
temperature
impact is rounded to the nearest &deg;F. For Cases 1 Ob through 1 Od, key numeric analysis output data is shown in Table C.6-1 and Table C.6-2. For Table C.6-1, the maximum temperature
reported for each panel is the maximum cell temperature.
For Table C.6-2, the temperature
reported for each panel is the temperature
inside each control volume used to model each panel for Cases 1 Ob through 1 Od J u l y 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 6 2 06 32 , Attachment
2 , Pag e 23 3 of 2 54
NUMERICA L rt&deg;" APPLICAT IO NS * SIOt , a' .!)o.It11!'i M.Uft.IJ :.. llC Clinton Division 1 Di e sel Gen e rator Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
NAI-2007-004 Re v ision 0 Page Cl2 ofC30 Table C.6-1 -Summary of bounding electrical
panel temperature
results with various generator
load profiles and various combinations
of door positions (max cell temperature)
Case Panel lOa !Ob lOc lOd Maximum Temperature
(&deg;F) 1PL12JA 188 191 191 192 1PL92JN 1PL93JA 182 185 185 187 lDGOlJA 193 196 196 197 1DG06SA 181 184 184 185 lDGOlKA 1 2 c vl 1 8 6 189 188 190 lDGOlKA 16cyl 193 196 196 197 N e ar Doors at 2 Hours N I A N I A N I A N I A Table C.6-2 -Summary of electrical
panel internal temperature
results with various generator
load profiles and various combinations
of door positions
Case P a n e l lOa !Ob lOc lOd Intern a l Cabin e t Temperatur
e (&deg;F) 1PL12JA 181 185 186 1 87 1PL92JA 179 183 184 185 1PL93JA 179 1 83 1 8 4 1 85 lDGOlJA 184 188 18 7 1 89 1DG06SA 176 179 179 1 81 lDGOlKA 12cyl 181 184 184 1 86 lDGO 1 KA 16cyl 183 187 186 1 88 Limiting plots of cell temp e ratures for Cases 1 Ob through 1 Od are provided in Figure C-7 through Figure C-24. Most of the panels occupy more than one cell in the Division 1 Room control volume. As such, the temperatures
of the most limiting cells containing
a given panel are shown in the plots. Additionally , the temperature
inside the control volumes used to model the panels is included within the figures. For the temperature
plots , the GOTHIC plot variable is displayed
a cross the top of the plot. For instance, "TV 1s14" is the vapor temperature
of cell 14 inside control volume 1. For lumped parameter
volumes, "s#" will be absent. J u l y 25 , 2 0 17 9: 40 AM E D T 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 234 of 254 C.6.1 Case lOb Results JuV24/2017
20: 36: 06 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Di visi on 1 D iesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS
_ 1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Ob.GTH Figure C-7, CPS DG Room Case lOb, Panel 1PL12JA Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Pag e Cl3 ofC30 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 235 of 254 JuV24/2017
20: 36:06 GOTHIC Version 8.2{QA) -Oct 2016 C lin ton Di vis ion l D iese l Ge n erato r Room G OTHI C U n ce rt ai n ty Eva lu at i on File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\CPS_ 1A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ Case_ 1 Ob.G T H NAI-2007-004 R evisi on 0 Page Cl4 ofC3 0 F igur e C-8 , CPS DG Room Case lOb , Panel 1PL92JA and 1PL93J A T e mp e ratur e s July 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT 
EC 62 0 632, A ttachme nt 2 , P a ge 236 of 254 ( f\. I] NU MERICAL
APPLICATIONS
* L:h << 9 L ti l!\ t-L U!.:.rl
nc JuV24/2017
20: 36: 07 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 C lin ton D iv i s ion 1 D iesel G e n erator Ro om GOTHI C U n ce rtain ty Eva lu a ti on File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
_RO\CPS_ 1A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA
_ Case_ 1 Ob.GTH Figure C-9, CPS DG Room Case lOb, Panel lDGOlJA Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT N AI-2007-004 R evisi on 0 P age C 1 5 ofC3 0 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 237 of 2 54 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
JuV24/2017
20: 36: 07 GOTHIC Version 8.2{QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTIDC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007
-004_RO\CPS
_ 1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Ob.GTH Figure C-10, CPS DG Room Case lOb, Panel 1DG06SA Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page Cl6 ofC30 
EC 620632 , A t tachment 2 , Page 238 of 254 JuV24/2017
20: 36: 08 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 C l i n ton Divis i on 1 D iesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\CPS_ 1 A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ Case_ 1 Ob.GTH NAI-2007-0
0 4 Revision 0 P age C17 ofC3 0 Figure C-11 , CPS DG Room Case lOb, Panel lDGOlKA 12-cyl. Temp e ratures July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632 , A tt achment 2 , Page 239 of 254 JuV24/2017
20: 36: 08 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Cl in ton Division l D iese l Generator
R oom GOTIITC Unce rt ainty Eva lu ation F i le: C:\Work\Penley\C
l inton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_ 1A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ Case_ 1 Ob.GTH NAI-2007-004
Revisi on 0 P age C l 8 ofC3 0 Figur e C-12 , CPS DG Room Cas e lOb , Pane l lDGOlKA 16-c y l. T e mperatur e s July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 62 0 632 , A tta chment 2 , Page 240 of 254 C.6.2 Case lOc Results JuV2412017
20: 36: 09 GOTHIC Version 8.2{QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton D ivision 1 Di esel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Eva lu ation F il e: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004
_RO\CPS_ 1A_DG_LoV
_LOOP-LOCA_Case_
1 Oc.GTH Figure C-13, CPS DG Room Case lOc, Panel 1PL12JA Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Re v ision 0 P age C19 ofC30 
E C 62 0 632 , Attachment
2, P age 241 of 254 JuV24/2017
20: 36: 09 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 C linton Di vis ion 1 D iesel G e n erator Ro om GO T IIl C U n ce rt ainty Eva lu a ti o n File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007
-004_RO\CPS_ 1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ Case_ 1 Oc.GTH N AI-2 0 07-004 R evisi on 0 Pa ge C2 0 of C 3 0 Figure C-14, CPS DG Room Case toe , Panel 1PL92JA and 1PL93JA Temperatures
Ju l y 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 242 of 254 ( "-t..1] NUMERICAL
1 '11, APPLICATIONS
11 l:h !i lOt , Cf .!).[h l!'I
UC JuV24/2017
20: 36: 10 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTIIlC Uncertai n ty Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS
_ 1A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Oc.GTH Figure C-15, CPS DG Room Case lOc, Panel lDGOlJA Temperatures
July 25, 2017 9: 40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Pag e C21 ofC30 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 243 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
JuV24/2017
20: 36:10 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Di ese l Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007
-004_RO\CPS
_ 1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ Case_ 1 Oc.GTH Figure C-16 , CPS DG Room Case toe , Panel 1DG06SA Temperatures
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2 007-004 Re visi on 0 Pag e C22 ofC3 0 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 244 of 254 JuV24/2017
20:36: 11 GOTH I C V ersion 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Cli n ton D ivision 1 D iesel Ge n erator Room GOTHIC Unce rt ainty Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\CPS_ 1A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ Case_ 1 Oc.GTH NAI-2007-0 04 Revision 0 P age C23 ofC3 0 Figure C-17, CPS DG Room Case toe , Panel lDGOlKA 12-cyl. Temperatures
J u l y 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT 
EC 620632 , Attachment
2 , Page 245 of 2 54 ("'-1\.1]
NUMERICAL
1 '1, APPLICATIONS
'C h !..l!t'l!'I M.Uf.:.1 1, C t..r!U'I:.. nc JuV24/2017
20:36: 11 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Cli n ton Divis i on 1 D iese l Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Wo rk\Penley\Cl i n t on\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_ 1 A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ C a s e_ 1 Oc.GT H NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page C24 ofC3 0 Figure C-18 , C PS DG Room Case toe , Panel lDGOlKA 16-c y l. Te mperatures
July 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT 
EC 620632 , At t achment 2 , Page 246 of 254 C.6.3 Cas e lOd Result s J uV24/2017
20: 36: 12 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 C lin ton D iv i s ion 1 D iese l Ge n erator Room GOT HI C Uncertai n ty Eva lu at i on File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007
-004_RO\CPS_ 1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ Case_ 1 Od.GTH Figur e C-19, CPS DG Room Case lOd , Panel 1PL12J A Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-00 4 Revisi on 0 P age C25 of C3 0 
EC 62 063 2 , Attachm ent 2 , Page 247 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
JuV24/2017
20: 36: 13 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA} -Oct 2016 Clinton Division l Di esel G e n erato r Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007
-004_RO\CPS_ 1A_DG_LoV _L OOP-LOCA_Case_ 1 Od.GTH NAI-2007-004
R evisi on 0 P age C26 ofC30 Figure C-20, CPS DG Room Case lOd, Panel 1PL92JA and 1PL93JA Temperatures
July 25, 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2 , Page 248 of 254 JuV24/2017
20: 36:13 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG_LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Od.GTH Figure C-21, CPS DG Room Case lOd, Panel lDGOlJA Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page C27 ofC30 
EC 620632, Attachm e nt 2 , Page 249 of 254 NUMERICAL
APPLICATIONS
JuV24/2017
20: 36: 14 GOTHIC Version 8.2{QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTIIlC Uncertainty
Eva lu ation File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl
-2007-004_RO\CPS_
1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_
Case_ 1 Od .GTH --Figure C-22, CPS DG Room Case lOd, Panel 1DG06SA Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT NAI-2007-004
Re visi on 0 Page C28 of C30 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 250 of 254 JuV24/2017
20:36: 14 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division 1 Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evalua tion File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS
_ 1A_DG _LoV _LOOP-LOCA_ Case_ 1 Od .GTH NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Pa ge C29 of C30 Figure C-23, CPS DG Room Case lOd, Panel lDGOlKA 12-cyl. Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9:40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 251 of 254
NUMERICAL
rt&deg;" APPLICATIONS
11 L: fi sia-, a !Jlnl!'i t.t..ur.:.1 1
llC JuV24/2017
20: 36: 14 GOTHIC Version 8.2(QA) -Oct 2016 Clinton Division I Diesel Generator
Room GOTHIC Uncertainty
Evaluation
File: C:\Work\Penley\Clinton\NAl-2007-004_RO\CPS
_ 1A_DG _LoV _L OOP-LOCA_Cas e_ 1 Od.GTH NAI-2007-004
Revision 0 Page C30 ofC3 0 Figure C-24, CPS DG Room Case lOd, Panel lDGOlKA 16-cyl. Temperatures
July 25 , 2017 9: 40 AM EDT 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 252 of 254 CC-AA-103-1003
Revision 12 ATTACHMENT
2 Owner's Acceptance
Review Checklist
for External Design Analyses Page 1of3 Design Analysis No.: NAl-2007-004
Contract #: 611349 Rev:O Release #: N/A No Question Instructions
and Guidance Yes I Nol N/A 1 Do assumptions
have All Assumptions
should be stated in clear terms with enough D D sufficient
documented
justification
to confirm that the assumption
is conservative.
rationale?
For example, 1) the exact value of a particular
parameter
may not be known or that parameter
may be known to vary over the range of conditions
covered by the Calculation.
It is appropriate
to represent
or bound the parameter
with an assumed value. 2) The predicted
performance
of a specific piece of equipment
in lieu of actual test data. It is appropriate
to use the documented
opinion/position
of a recognized
expert on that equipment
to represent
predicted
equipment
performance.
Consideration
should also be given as to any qualification
testing that may be needed to validate the Assumptions.
Ask yourself, would you provide more justification
if you were performing
this analysis?
If yes, the rationale
is likely incomplete.
2 Are assumptions
Ensure the documentation
for source and rationale
for the D D compatible
with the assumption
supports the way the plant is currently
or will be Assumption
is way the plant is operated post change and they are not in conflict with any conservative
operated and with the design parameters.
If the Analysis purpose is to establish
a licensing
basis? new licensing
basis, this question can be answered yes, if the assumption
suooorts that new basis. 3 Do all unverified
If there are unverified
assumptions
without a tracking D D assumptions
have a mechanism
indicated, then create the tracking item either tracking and closure through an ATI or a work order attached to the implementing
mechanism
in place? WO. Due dates for these actions need to support verification
prior to the analysis becoming
operational
or the resultant
plant chanqe beinq op authorized.
4 Do the design inputs The origin of the input, or the source should be identified
and D D have sufficient
be readily retrievable
within Exelon's documentation
system. rationale?
If not, then the source should be attached to the analysis.
Ask yourself, would you provide more justification
if you were performing
this analysis?
If yes, the rationale
is likely incomplete.
5 Are design inputs The expectation
is that an Exelon Engineer should be able to D D correct and reasonable
clearly understand
which input parameters
are critical to the with critical parameters
outcome of the analysis.
That is, what is the impact of a identified, if change in the parameter
to the results of the analysis?
If the aooropriate?
impact is larqe, then that parameter
is critical.
6 Are design inputs Ensure the documentation
for source and rationale
for the D D compatible
with the inputs supports the way the plant is currently
or will be way the plant is operated post change and they are not in conflict with any operated and with the design parameters.
licensinq
basis? 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 253 of 254 CC-AA-103-1003
Revision 12 ATTACHMENT
2 Owner's Acceptance
Review Checklist
for External Design Analyses Page 2 of 3 Design Analysis No.: NAl-2007-004
Rev: 0 No Question Instructions
and Guidance Yes I No IN/A 7 Are Engineering
See Section 2.13 in CC-AA-309
for the attributes
that are D D [8J Judgments
clearly sufficient
to justify Engineering
Judgment.
Ask yourself, documented
and would you provide more justification
if you were performing
justified?
this analysis?
If yes, the rationale
is likely incomplete.
8 Are Engineering
Ensure the justification
for the engineering
judgment D D [8J Judgments
compatible
supports the way the plant is currently
or will be operated with the way the plant is post change and is not in conflict with any design operated and with the parameters.
If the Analysis purpose is to establish
a new licensing
basis? licensing
basis, then this question can be answered yes, if the judgment suooorts that new basis. 9 Do the results and Why was the analysis being performed?
Does the stated [8J D D conclusions
satisfy the purpose match the expectation
from Exelon on the proposed purpose and objective
of application
of the results? If yes, then the analysis meets the Design Analysis?
the needs of the contract.
10 Are the results and Make sure that the results support the UFSAR defined D D [8J conclusions
compatible
system design and operating
conditions, or they support a with the way the plant is proposed change to those conditions.
If the analysis operated and with the supports a change, are all of the other changing documents
licensing
basis? included on the cover sheet as impacted documents?
11 Have any limitations
on Does the analysis support a temporary
condition
or D D [8J the use of the results procedure
change? Make sure that any other documents
been identified
and needing to be updated are included and clearly delineated
in transmitted
to the the design analysis.
Make sure that the cover sheet appropriate
includes the other documents
where the results of this organizations?
analysis provide the input. 12 Have margin
impacts Make sure that the impacts to margin are clearly shown [8J D D been identified
and within the body of the analysis.
If the analysis results in documented
reduced margins ensure that this has been appropriately
appropriately
for any dispositioned
in the EC being used to issue the analysis.
negative impacts (Reference
ER-AA-2007)? 13 Does the Design Are there sufficient
documents
included to support the [8J D D Analysis include the sources of input, and other reference
material that is not applicable
design basis readily retrievable
in Exelon controlled
Documents?
documentation?
14 Have all affected design Determine
if sufficient
searches have been performed
to D D [8J analyses been identify any related analyses that need to be revised along documented
on the with the base analysis.
It may be necessary
to perform Affected Documents
List some basic searches to validate this. (AOL) for the associated
Configuration
Change? 15 Do the sources
of inputs Compare any referenced
codes and standards
to the current [8J D D and analysis design basis and ensure that any differences
are reconciled.
methodology
used meet If the input sources or analysis methodology
are based on committed
technical
and an out-of-date
methodology
or code, additional
reconciliation
regulatory
may be required if the site has since committed
to a more requirements?
recent code 
EC 620632, Attachment
2, Page 254 of 254 CC-AA-103-1003
Revision 12 ATTACHMENT
2 Owner's Acceptance
Review Checklist
for External Design Analyses Page 3of3 Design Analysis No.: NAl-2007-004
Rev: O No Question Instructions
and Guidance Yes/ No IN/A 16 Have vendor supporting
Based on the risk assessment
performed
during the pre-job D D technical
documents
brief for the analysis (per HU-AA-1212), ensure that and references
sufficient
reviews of any supporting
documents
not provided (including
GE DRFs) with the final analysis are performed.
been reviewed when necessary?
17 Do operational
limits Ensure the Tech Specs, Operating
Procedures, etc. contain D D support assumptions
operational
limits that support the analysis assumptions
and and inputs? inputs. Create an SFMS entry as required by CC-AA-4008.
SFMS Number: 59542 
------*--------
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 1 of 29 (KCI ENGINEERING
CONSULTANTS
Test Specification
Title Page Project Number: 424-008 r Document Number: 424-008" TSP2 Revision Number: 00 Title: Test Specification
for Determininq
Component
Survivability
and Operation
in Ambient Temperature
not to Exceed 245"F Nuclear Safety Related: DYES Total Number of Pages: ---'-:1_9..;._
__ _ Date of Issue: 611212017
Prepared by; Print Cheeked by: B. Hussain Print Approved by: P. Brunsaaard
Pr Ent I 0 AKB .5.i1112G17
BH l'lo'1112U17
PB !--
-----REV I DY OA"!l( ('.Hl\r.Kr.D
APPROVED (g]NO 5111*'2011
--.. --I nATl( Sign <KCI c:.;c1 ...
PROJXO. DOCI.NO. 6/12/2017
Date F.NGTNEERlNG
CONST:T ,T ANTS *-I 424-fiWi ---1 42<f.008-TSP2
*-:'>l:C:Ll!.AR
SA FF.TY RF.I.A Tm 0 \'TIS D KO ----
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 2 of 29 Revision No. 0 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSP2
Revision:
00 Page: 2of10 Revision Summary Summary of Changes Initial issue for use. .. 
1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 3 of 29 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSP2
Revision:
00 Page: 3 oflO Table of Contents Title Page Revision Summary Table of Contents BACKGROUND
PURPOSE TEST SPECIMENS
PROCEDURE
REFERENCES
List of Attachments
Basler UFOV Relay and Voltage Regulator
1 2 3 4 4 4 5 9 Attachment
A Attachment
B Attachment
C Attachment
D Attachment
E Attachment
F GE Overcurrent
Relay Test-Models# 12IJCV51Al3A
and 12IFCV51AD1A
Differential
Relay Type SA-1 (Westinghouse, part# 290B225A10)
GE Loss of Excitation
Relay Test -Model# 12CEH51A1A
GE Reverse Power Relay Test -Model# 12GGP53C1A
Woodward Governor Control Assembly Model 2301A 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 4 of 29 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSP2
Revision:
00 Page: 4of10 Test Specification
for Determining
Component
Survivability
and Operation
in Ambient Temperature
not to Exceed 245&deg;F 1.0 BACKGROUND
The Division 1 EDG room may be exposed to temperature
above 204 &deg;F due loss of ventilation
when the EDG is in operation.
Under this scenario, various control components
required for EDG operation
will be exposed to ambient temperature
beyond the published
temperature
rating by the manufacturers.
2.0 PURPOSE 2.1 The purpose of this specification
is to monitor performance
of various control devices when exposed to 225&deg;F and 245&deg;F ambient temperature.
2.2 Testing performed
per this specification
will determine
if the control devices perform their required function and/or not provide a false trip signal to other connected
control components.
3.0 TEST SPECIMENS
3 .1 The equipment
under test (EDT) includes the following
test specimens:
TABLE3 1 T tS -: es ipec1mens
Test Specimen#
Manufacturer
Model Description
EUT#l Agastat 7012PD Time Delay Relay EUT#2 Basler 9-1051-00-105
UFOV Assembly EUT#3 Basler SR8A2B01B3A
Voltage Regulator
EUT#4 GE 12CEH51A1A
Loss of Excitation
Relay EUT#5 GE 12GGP53BlA
Reverse Power Relay EUT#6A GE 12IJCV51A13A
Restrained
Overcurrent
Relay EUT#6B GE 12IFCV51AD1A
Restrained
Overcurrent
Relay EUT#7 P&B MDR 137-8 Relay EUT#8 Phoenix 2938578 125 VDC -24 VDC Power Supply EUT#9 Westinghouse
290B225A10
Differential
Relay (Type SA-1) EUT#lO Woodward 2301A Governor Control Assembly 3.2 Testing shall be conducted
in the following
sequence, with the details of each test specified
in Section 4.0 of this test specification:
* Receipt inspection
* Baseline functional
test * Functional
test at 225&deg;F oven temperature (Pre-thermal
aging) * Thermally
aged for 24 hours at 225&deg;F and monitor performance
parameters 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 5 of 29 * Post-thermal
aging baseline functional
test * Functional
test at 245&deg;F oven temperature
Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSP2
Revision:
00 Page: 5of10 * Thermally
aged 8 hours at 245&deg;F monitor performance
parameters
3.3 TOOLS AND EQUIPMENT
* DC Current Source (shall be able to provide up to SA) * Assortment
of shop made test lead jumpers * Single pole switch (rated for 125VDC, 5A) and can operate in 200&deg;F environment
* Wiring cables * Multi-meter
for sensing DC current * DC Power Supply (125V, 5A) 4.0 TEST PROCEDURE
The test laboratory
shall execute the test segments as delineated
in this section. 4.1 Receipt Inspection
4.1.1 Identify the manufacturer, model/part
number, and serial number (if available)
for the test specimens.
Record all nameplate
information.
Assign laboratory
identifiers, if desired. 4.1.2 Photograph
the test specimens
from various angles. 4.1.3 Verify that the test specimens
are free from obvious signs of physical damage. Visually inspect and verify the following:
* Absence of cracking or bubbling on test specimens
cases. * Absence of pitted or burned contacts.
* For relay coils, absence of cracking or discoloration
of coil insulation, and absence of crystal growth. 4.2 Baseline Functional
Test Mount each EUT to simulate field installation.
4.2.1 Choose EUT #1 (Agastat time delay relay). Set the time delay relay dial to 50 seconds. Measure and record the following:
* Pick up voltage (information
only) and Drop out voltage * Coil current at 125 VDC Perform and record the above measurements
three times at room ambient temperature.
Determine
and record the average of the three readings.
Do not move the time delay dial setting between tests. 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 6 of 29 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSP2
Revision:
00 Page: 6of10 4.2.2 Choose EUTs #2 and 3 (Basler UFOV Relay and Voltage Regulator).
Measure and record the following:
* Connect the UFOV to the voltage regulator
as shown in Fig. A-1, Attachment
A * Perform test per Section 5-2 of voltage regulator
manual (Attachment
A) * Ramp the frequency
of240V AC power supply shown in Fig. A-1from60Hz
down to 53Hz. Ramping down should cause the lamps to dim or extinguish
at 56Hz. * Set the 240V AC power supply back to 60Hz and ramp the voltage to 248 volts. The lamps should dim or extinguish.
4.2.3 Choose BUT #4 (GE Loss of Excitation
Relay, models# 12CEH51AIA).
See attachment
D, section D-1 for tools and equipment required
for this test * CALIBRATE
relays per attachment
D, section D-2 * CONNECT the relays as shown on figure D-1 * PERFORM functional
testing of the relays per D-4 * ENSURE the functional
test meets acceptance
criteria in table D-1 * RECORD the ammeter readings at various intervals
in table D-1 Perform and record the above measurements
three times at room ambient temperature.
4.2.4 Choose BUT #5 (GE Reverse Power Relay, models# 12GGP53B1A).
See attachment
E, section E-1 for tools and equipment
required for this test * CALIBRATE
relays per attachment
E, section E-2 * CONNECT the relays as shown on figure E-1 * PERFORM functional
testing of the relays per E-4 * ENSURE the functional
test meets acceptance
criteria in table E-1 * RECORD the ammeter readings at various intervals
in table E-1 Perform and record the above measurements
three times at room ambient temperature.
4.2.5 Choose BUT #6A and 6B (GE Overcurrent
Relay, models# 12IJCV51Al3A
and 12IFCV51AD1A
respectively). 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 7 of 29 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSP2
Revision:
00 Page: 7of10 See attachment
B, section B-1 for tools and equipment
required for this test. Perform separate test for each relay model * CALIBRATE
relays per attachment
B, section B-2 * CONNECT the relays as shown on figure B-1 * PERFORM functional
testing of the relays per B-4 * ENSURE the functional
test meets acceptance
criteria in table B-1 * RECORD the ammeter readings at various intervals
in table B-1 Perform and record the above measurements
three times at room ambient temperature.
4.2.6 Choose EUT #7 (P&B Relay). Measure and record the following:
* Pick up voltage (information
only) and Dr_op out voltage * Coil current at 125 VDC Perform and record the above measurements
three times at room ambient temperature.
Determine
and record the average of the three readings.
4.2.7 Choose EUT #8 (Phoenix 125 VDC to 24 VDC Power Supply). Measure and record the following:
* Output voltage at no load * Output voltage at 80% load current (use a resistive
load) Perform and record the above measurements
three times at room ambient temperature.
Determine
and record the average of the three readings.
4.2.8 Choose BUT #9 (Westinghouse
SA-1 Differential
Relay). See attachment
C, section C-1 for tools and equipment
required for this test. Perform test as outlined in Attachment
C * Relay calibration
is not required for this relay. * WIRE relay as shown in figure C-1. * PERFORM test per section C-4 * Verify no trip with zero operating
current Perform and record the above measurements
three times at room ambient temperature. 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 8 of 29 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSP2
Revision:
00 Page: 8of10 4.2.9 Choose BUT #10 (Woodward
Governor Control Assembly).
* Connect the Governor Control Module as shown in Fig. F-1, Attachment
F. * Verify the output voltage across the 50.Q resistor is approximately
OVDC when the circuit is energized
and the function generator
is set to 3975 Hz. * Slowly increase the function generator
frequency
and note the frequency
when the voltage across the resistor begins to increase to 19VDC. The frequency
should be within +/- 1 % of the baseline test. * Set the frequency
back to 3975Hz and verify that the voltage across the 50.Q resistor returns to approximately
OVDC. * Instantaneously
step the function generator
from 3975Hz to 4974Hz. The voltage across the resistor should reach 19VDc instantaneously.
Perform and record the above measurements
three times at room ambient temperature.
4.3 Abnormal Temperature
Exposure at 225&deg;F Place EUTs 1thru10 in one or more ovens at 225&deg;F and wire them so that its function can be monitored
for 24 hours exposure at this temperature.
4.3.1 Choose BUT #1 (Agastat time delay relay). Energize the relay coil with 125 VDC and monitor for coil drop out. Also monitor an open contact for contact resistance.
4.3.2 Choose EUTs #2 and 3 (Basler UFOV Relay and Voltage Regulator).
Measure and record the following:
* Connect the UFOV to the voltage regulator
as shown in Fig. A-1, Attachment
A * Ramp the frequency
of240V AC power supply shown in Fig. A-1from60Hz
down to 53Hz. Ramping down should cause the lamps to dim or extinguish
at 56Hz. * Set the 240V AC power supply back to 60Hz and ramp the voltage to 248 volts. The lamps should dim or extinguish.
4.3.3 Choose EUT #4 (GE Loss of Excitation
Relay, models# 12CEH51A1A).
Connect the relay as shown on figure D-1 and energize with 5 Amps of load current at 120 VAC. Monitor the lamp or bulb in the trip circuit. 4.3.4 Choose BUT #5 (GE Reverse Power Relay, models# 12GGP53BlA).
Connect the relay as shown on figure E-1 and energize with 5 Amps of load current at 120 VAC. Monitor the lamp or bulb in the trip circuit. 4.3.5 Choose EUT #6A and 6B (GE Overcurrent
Relay, models# 12IJCV51Al3A
and 12IFCV51AD1A
respectively).
Connect each relay as shown on figure B-1 and energize with 4 Amps of load current. Monitor the DMM. 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 9 of 29 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSP2 Revision:
00 Page: 9of10 4.3.6 Choose BUT #7 (P&B Relay). Energize the relay coil with 12S VDC and monitor for coil drop out. Also monitor an open contact for contact resistance.
4.3.7 Choose BUT #8 (Phoenix 12S VDC to 24 VDC Power Supply). Energize the power supply with 12S VDC with a SO% load on the 24 VDC output. Monitor for load current. 4.3.8 Choose BUT #9 (Westinghouse
SA-1 Differential
Relay). Connect the relay as shown on figure C-1 and with IR at S amperes and adjust the operating
current (1 0) to 0.22 Amps. Verify the
relay does not operate. Monitor the lamp or bulb in the trip circuit. 4.3.9 Choose BUT #10 (Woodward
Governor Control Assembly).
Connect the Governor Control Module as shown in Fig. F-1, Attachment
F. * Verify the output voltage across the son resistor is approximately
OVDC when the circuit is energized
and the function generator
is set to 3975 Hz. * Slowly increase the function generator
frequency
and note the frequency
when the voltage across the resistor begins to increase to 19VDC. The frequency
should be within+/- 1 % of the baseline test. * Set the frequency
back to 397SHz and verify that the voltage across the son resistor returns to approximately
OVDC. Perform functional
tests as outlined above after one hour exposure at 22S&deg;F. Age the specimens
for 24 hours and monitor the performance
in suitable interval (at the test facility convenience)
Repeat above Section 4.2 functional
test before removing the specimens
from the oven at 22S&deg;F. 4.4 Abnormal Temperature
Exposure at 24S&deg;F * Increase the oven temperature
from previous test exposure from 22S&deg;F to 24S&deg;F. * Perform functional
tests as outlined in Section 4.3 after one hour exposure at 24S&deg;F. * Repeat above functional
test before removing the specimens
from the oven at 24S&deg;F. 5.0 REFERENCES
S.1 S.2 5.3 Clinton Drawing E02-1AP04, Sheet 17 Basler Electric Instructional
Manual for Underfrequency/Overvoltage
Module Models: UFOV 2SOA & UFOV 260A, Publication
Number: 9 IOSl 00 99X, Rev. E, dated Feb 2000. ; .. '' Basler Electric Instructional
Manual for Voltage Regulator
Model: SR4A & SR8A, Publication
Number: 9 0177 00 XX, Revision R, Dated 09/97 
.EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 10 of 29 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSP2
Revision:
00 Page: 10 of 10 5.4 GE Instructions
for Loss of Excitation
Relay Type CEH51A, GEK-27887H
5.5 GE Instructions
for Ployphase
Power Directional
Relay for Ant-Motoring
Protection, Type GGP53C, GEK-34117G
5.6 GE publication
GEK-34117G (Power Directional Relay Instruction
manual) 5.7 GE Instructions
for Time Overcurrent
Relays with Voltage Restraint
Types IFC51AD and IFC51BD, GEK-49946E
5.8 GE Instructions
Relay Types IJCV51A, IJCV51B, IJCV52A and IJCV51B, GEK-2029A
5.9 ABB Instruction
Leaflet 41-348.1 lC for Type SA-1 Generator
Differential
Relay 5.10 Woodward Product Manual 02303 for 2301A Load Sharing and Speed Control, Revision B, dated 9/2015. 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 11 of 29 ATTACHMENT
A Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: Al of A4 Basler UFOV Relay and Voltage Regulator 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 12 of 29 El E2 E3 A B 240V AC 3<1> 60Hz Adj. .;.--SA .;.--SA .;.--SA A<jJ 1---+---+-----il-
F+ B<jJ ,__ _______ ,__ __ _ C<jJ l--+-----4,__-----4t-
.;.--.;.--SA SA 1 2 c D N UFOV F-Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: A2 of A4 SR VOLTAGE REGULATOR
A-p Fig. A-1 7 6 1750 25W 4 3 2 1 B A 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 13 of 29 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: A3 of A4 ,si:ctie>Ns " *. .. .
.. . .. * inspection
shDU!d be made on this.WJit
to insure it is kept clean and free from dirt and Also, if is reoommended
the cailnectioiis
belwe&#xa3;in 1he regula1DT
and the .sysleffi
bEi ched.ed and lightened
at this lime. * Due to a prnteclilre
transparant
confurmal
coaling. rapair an the printed circuit board is difficull
and should only be. attempted
by quaffied pe.sanat An lest. used to detennlne
if 1he iajula1Dr
is basically
opera1funal, @wn bl!l'mv. Ref'e.-llo FJQUra' 5-1. * mMA. IRllA: lNT9 i:EQuiu; 1-PHAllE Ut D l'u.8; . TWCI IKi!NTir;IAL
llLUl8
PQlt MBA. Figwe5-1.
OperalionalTest.
a MD'llE! l:he_wrra
011 the sensing !ransfo!mer (TI} ID the llmninal fisted below: SR4A: Move ta 120 V tap. SR8A: Move le 240 V lap. b. Adjust Ille voltage stability
poienliometer
{R4) fuliy counter-c!Dckwise (CCW). c. Ccnnect the voltage regulamc-as in. FllJUre &.-.1. The bulb should *bE! 120 V and not mare 1hlm 300 w. See Note 1 of ttie: drawing for the SRRA. d. Ad"jUst !he va!tage adjust potentiome1er
for maximum
e. Ccmnect the ragu!a1Dr
to lhe pawer source. The bulb should flash oo * moment.arify
and then extinguish.
5-1 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 14 of 29 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: A4 of A4 f. Skm.IJY atrjUSl the adjUst rfieoStat
ll:iWam min.inium
resisfance.
l}l:i! light billb soou!d raactdull
brilliarice
befcre miniinum rasi:stance
ts attained. (If the light
iDummate.
aCrJUst
Rdjusbnent(R3), s-At. r'egufating
pOint. a small change in lhe vofta9e adjust pcitenli!mlES
shriuld tum *ttie light 'bUfu ci0 at
!he nQht Stays on, Hie reguialn.-is
defecfure_ . . * h. This test* may not reV8al a shmjlity problem. tiOweYet, rriliiling
tile stability
cidjilsimerit (EM) shooid affect the light's tum cr&l'lum cff lime. * -* * * i._ Befure reins!alling
the 11Cltage regulator
into
n!!Xllll'lectthe
sensing {T1) -as it was befCre perfOOning
SJ:ep 'a. l.s-l:mfutACEM'ENTPARIS'
.* *---*.I The (Fili,ura.
5,2) and tallies {Table !F1 and 5-2) i:ooiains
only those and .assembl!es
whfch !lJe mailitenance
Figura 6-3. the wirmg diagram. *when Ordering ref)liioemefit
parts, fmrii BBsfeT Becblc alWays specify deScription
of tlle ib!m, 1he part riumber. 'ilritl the qUamity_ LEGEND 1. CllCUIT llDAAD Ml*. I. iwWi.EL.lla
TIWl&FoRllEFI . INDl.lllTiD
WIDER nElll n ... ll!lllllNlili
TIWll!l'Dllllll!!
..
!l.Pll!w ** CIRCQp AD.llllilT
IWlllOmt 1. YOLTMI!!!
ADJUST' FHIO!mU' ._ llTltiiUTY
Alu.IE' Ill. rtDMMM.. &#xa5;CLT/dE IETTINlll
@ 0119 @ Q!l4 &#xa9; Qml @ CRiii @ Cltl1 @ OA1tl I I I I I I I I I I I *1** *1: *I I'* I'-* A-* 'P S -4 : I *. 1 D 0 \ 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 15 of 29 ATTACHMENT
B Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: Bl ofB4 GE Overcurrent
Relay Test -Models# 121JCV51A13A and 12IFCV51AD1A 
B-1 EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 16 of 29 TOOLS AND EQUIPMENT
* AC Current Source * 120V, lOOW light bulb * Ammeter * 125VDC Power Supply * 120V AC power supply Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: B2 ofB4 B-2 RELAY CALIBRATION
NOTE: The relay settings below are per station calculation
19-AN-14 table 1 (applies to models 12IJCV51A13A
and 12IFCV51AD1A).
The settings reflects existing plant configuration.
1. ENSURE the tap screws are screwed into the ten-ampere
tap (GIH) for the IFCV, and into the 1 OA tap for the IJCV (Ref. E02-1AP04, Sheet 017) 2. SET the time delay to 3 seconds for both relays B-3 WIRING SETUP NOTE: Relay wiring setup (applies to models 12IJCV51A13A
and 12IFCV51AD1A)
in figure B-1 are based on plant schematic
diagram E02-1DG99
sheet 011. The wiring setup reflects existing plant configuration.
1. SET the voltage source to provide 120V AC 2. SET the current source to supply approximately
4.2A ac to simulate CT secondary
current with the generator
at full load for (see basis below): Per E02-1APOI
sheet 005, the diesel is rated for 4.16KV, 3875KW at 0.8PF, and is loaded not more than 85% of rated power. Also each CT ratio have turns ratio of 800-5A. At full load: I= (3875000W
* 0.85)/ (0.8PF * 4160V * ..../3) = 571.435A With CT ration of 800-5A, CT secondary
at full load= (571.435 * 5)/800 = 3.571A 3. SET the DC power supply to provide 125VDC. ENSURE the DMM reads zero current when the setup is powered up. 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 17 of 29 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 POWER SUPPLY 125VDC + Page: B3 of B4
I t.:J I I 7 s I I 5 r:: : I I I I I I I -I I GE OVERCIJRREl'-JT
RELAY I I MODEL #121FCV51A01A
I I I I I I I --JDMMf---1/lllllr-l-tJ
2 6 C:-1--RESISTOR I I l.5KO I I sow L -------
FIGUREB-1
Wiring setup for Overcurrent
Relay B-4 RELAY FUNCTIONAL
TEST Bench Test: AC CURRENT SOURCE 1. The wiring setup is powered up and verified to no trip (a trip is indicated
by the illumination
of a 120V, lOOW light bulb and the DMM) 2. The current source is gradually
increased
until the light bulb illuminates.
The current value should be recorded.
Oven Test: * The wiring setup is powered up and current source is set to 4.2A. The setup is placed in the oven. Monitor and record DMM reading and light bulb. 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 18 of 29 B.5 TEST RESULTS Bench Test: Expected TABLEB-1 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: B4 of B4 Result Light bulb should illuminate
when the For the 12IJCV51A13A:
Record current when Light bulb illuminated
current approaches
lOA (+/-2A) for both relays For the 12IFCV51AD1A:
Record current when Light bulb illuminated
Oven Test: TABLEB-2 DMM Reading (Amps)/Light
bulb status Expected Result O/Not lit 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 19 of 29 ATTACHMENTC
Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPI
Revision:
00 Page: Cl ofC3 Differential
Relay Type SA-I (Westinghouse, part# 290B225Al0) 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 20 of 29 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: C2 of C3 C-1 TOOLS AND EQUIPMENT
* 120V-100W, 120V-200W, and 130V-200Wlightbulbs
* Variable resistor * Ammeter * 125VDC Power Supply * 208V AC power supply C-2 CALIBRATION
NOT REQUIRED FOR THIS TEST C-3 WIRING SETUP + EXT. RESISTOR 2.24K SS 4011 REQ FOR 250VOC RATED Of------1[
= DC .i--t::=>-PHASE:2
@  lG>A 19 17 @ 13'  I I SAi RELAY I . (FRONT VIEW) I PHASE 3 I I I I I I I I I .__ ---J t -.a---_____ j VOLTAGE o---------1..__----<
12$ WLT WI. SWITCH Figure C-1 Differential
Relay Type SA-1 Wiring Setup C-4 RELAY FUNCTIONAL
TEST NOTE: Test instruction
is per ABB relay type SA-1 user manual 208 VAC * Differential
Characteristic:
Apply IR of 5 amperes and adjust the operating
current (Io) until the relay operates.
Repeat for each phase as shown on the figure above. 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 21 of 29 C.5 TEST RESULTS Bench Test: Expected TABLE C-1 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: C3 of C3 Result Phase 1: Record current when Lamp and light bulb illuminates
The relay should operate and the indicator
lamp should light with an operating
Phase 2: Record current when Lamp and current (Io) of 0.25 +/- 0.012 amperes. light bulb illuminates
Phase 3: Record current when Lamp and light bulb illuminates
Oven Test: TABLEC-2 Indicator
Lamp/Light
bulb status Expected Result The lamp or bulb should not be lit 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 22 of 29 ATTACHMENT
D Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: Dl ofD3 GE Loss of Excitation
Relay Test -Model# 12CEH51A1A 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 23 of 29 D-1 TOOLS AND EQUIPMENT
* 120V, 1 OOW light bulb * 6.9ohm, lOOW resistor * 125VDC Power Supply * 120V AC power supply * 50-SVA CTs * D-2 RELAY CALIBRATION
NOTE: Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: D2 ofD3 The relay settings below are per station calculation
19-AN-14 table 1, the settings reflects existing plant configuration.
See GE publication
GEK-27887H (Loss Of Excitation
Relay Instruction
manual) for more detail 1. OFFSET setting: Set the tap screw for L is at 0.0, and tap screw for H is at 1.0 for a relay offset of 1.0 Ohm. 2. RESTRAIN setting: Set upper restrain tap (Iu) to 6, and the lower restrain tap (IL) to 40; for a total restrain of 46%. D-3 WIRING SETUP 120//3 13.90 120//3 c LOSS OF EXCITATION
RELAY Figure D-1 Loss of Excitation
Relay Type CEH51A 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 24 of 29 D-4 RELAY FUNCTIONAL
TEST Bench Test: Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPI
Revision:
00 Page: D3 ofD3 1. With the setup wired as shown above, power up the setup and adjust the three phase load bank to draw approximately
5A from each phase of the power 120VAC supply. 2. Based on the CT turns ratio of 10: 1, 7-loops on the primary side will generate a secondary
current of 3.5A (see basis is section B-3 step 2). This simulates
the generator
running at full load. Ensure the relay does not trip. 3. With the setup de-energized, carefully
lift the leads on relay terminals
7 and 8, reverse connections
to simulate a loss of excitation.
The relay should trip Oven Test: * Place the setup in the oven. Power up the setup and adjust the load bank to pull 5A from each phase of the 120VAC source. Monitor light bulb. D.5 TEST RESULTS Bench Test: TABLED-I Expected Result Light bulb should illuminate
when the leads on relay terminals
7 and 8 are reversed Oven Test: TABLED-2 Indicator
Lamp/Light
bulb status Expected Result The lamp or bulb should not be lit 
EC 620632, _Attachment
3, Page 25 of 29 ATTACHMENT
E Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPI
Revision:
00 Page: El ofE3 GE Reverse Power Relay Test -Model# 12GGP53CIA 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 26 of 29 Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: E2 of E3 E-1 TOOLS AND EQUIPMENT
* 120V, lOOW light bulb * 6.9ohm, 1 OOW resistor * 125VDC Power Supply * 120V AC power supply * 50-5VA CTs E-2 RELAY CALIBRATION
* TIME DELAY setting: Set the time delay knob to 5 and half (for a 15 seconds delay). E-3 WIRING SETUP 50:5 CT ""' 7--TURNS SA
9 14 120V 13.90 -120/./3 N) ------\. / 120//3 2
"13. 90 ' .i 5 7-TURNS 5. ""' ./'I e' ' 7 8 REVERSE TER'--tli-41-N-'--A-L
1-r-<::r----e
o-b c-d e-f TO *\-RIP RELA y 12 REVERSE POWER RELAY Figure E-1 Reverse Power Relay Type GGP53C 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 27 of 29 E-4 RELAY FUNCTIONAL
TEST Bench Test: Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPl
Revision:
00 Page: E3 of E3 1. With the setup wired as shown above, power up the setup and adjust the three phase load bank to draw approximately
5A from each phase of the power 120VAC supply. 2. Based on the CT turns ratio of 10:1, 7-loops on the primary side will generate a secondary
current of3.5A (see basis is section B-3 step 2). This simulates
the generator
running at full load. Ensure the relay does not trip. 3. With the setup de-energized, carefully
lift the leads on relay terminals
3 and 4, 5 and 6, 7 and 8. Reverse connections
on these terminals
to simulate reverse power. The relay should trip Oven Test: * Place the setup in the oven. Power up the setup and adjust the load bank to pull 5A from each phase of the 120VAC source. Monitor light bulb. E.5 TEST RESULTS Bench Test: TABLEE-1 Expected Result Light bulb should illuminate
when the terminals
on the relay for each phase are swapped. Oven Test: TABLEE-2 Indicator
Lamp/Light
bulb status Expected Result The lamp or bulb should not be lit Lamp or bulb did not light up 
EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 28 of 29 ATTACHMENT
F Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPI
Revision:
00 Page: Fl of F2 Woodward Governor Control Assembly Model 2301A 
<( ..... 0 M N _J w 0 0 26 25 13 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 EC 620632, Attachment
3, Page 29 of 29 , ... I J 120V AC AcjJ Generate + 125VDC A. Test Specification
No.: 424-008-TSPI
Revision:
00 Page: F2 of F2 DVM 3&#xa2;
60Hz Adj. CcjJ Fig. F-1 
EC 620632, Attachment
4 Evaluation
of EPRI August 22"d, 2017 Notice PT-082117-122, Subject: 10 CFR Part 21-Transfer of Information
Notice -GOTHIC-Code Error related to thermal conductor
modelling
could impact safety related components/applications
From: Winter, Steven D.[mallto:*winters@zachrygrnup.com]
Sent: Monday, August28, 2017 4:42 PM * To: Freeman 1. John.M:(GenCo"'Nuc);
Gandhir Mukesh M:(GenCo-Nuc)
Cc: Lane, Jeffrey W. * Subject: RE: EPRI Part 21 Transfer-ofiriformation
Notice related to GOTHIC vS.1 and vB.2 John aM Mukesh, Zachry has completed
the evaluation
of Projects 2003 {Clinton SX Pump-Room
Heat-up) and 2007 {Clinton DG Room Heat-up) for any adverse effects related to GOTHIC Al8.2-095, which was described
in th,e Part 21 Notice from EPRI. ow evaluation
involved (a} retrrevingthe
GOTHIC .GTH fF!es developed
for the Clinton* reports frorn our QA storage, (b) running each GOTHIC .GTH file on a single CPU core, and {c} re-running
each GOTHIC .GTH file.after
implementing
the workaround
described
in the Part 21
This process lets us identify any changes to the GOTHIC .SIN (which
a .GTH fife c9ntairiedthe
GOTHIC error) ang let5 us compare results qf each case, before and after theworRaround
all while controlling
for
varfap!es.
For the two Clinton
there were no visible differences
in the results; any engineering
condusions
in the report5 ere unaffected.
Some .GTH files we:re, however, f!agg&#xa2;d as producing
different .SIN fifes after the workarou.nd
was performed.
We provide the .GTH. files ta you for your use* in the future. Aftematwely, you can implement
the simple workaround
the next trrne you use any of the .GTH files from these two projects.
If you *want the 'ftxed' files, let me know and I will transmit them via Sharefi!e.
As these projects were non-OA, this should be an acceptable
*niethod of
the files. Please !et me knovl/ if you have any questions.
*Thank you, Steve Steven D. Winter Manager I Principal
Consultant
I:;
}}

Latest revision as of 14:30, 17 August 2019

Redirect to:

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML17263A124&oldid=1878578"