View source for IA-85-213, Comments on BNL Re Proposed Review of Concerns Expressed by Ee Kent.Nrc May Expand on Insp Previously Performed at Plant But Should Not Duplicate Work Already Performed by Region V & NRR

{{Adams
| number = ML20215L758
| issue date = 08/28/1984
| title = Comments on BNL Re Proposed Review of Concerns Expressed by Ee Kent.Nrc May Expand on Insp Previously Performed at Plant But Should Not Duplicate Work Already Performed by Region V & NRR
| author name = Foster J
| author affiliation = NRC
| addressee name = Harrison J
| addressee affiliation = NRC
| docket = 05000329, 05000330
| license number = 
| contact person = 
| case reference number = FOIA-85-213
| document report number = NUDOCS 8706260165
| title reference date = 08-23-1984
| package number = ML20215K202
| document type = INTERNAL OR EXTERNAL MEMORANDUM, MEMORANDUMS-CORRESPONDENCE
| page count = 2
}}

=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:re equs t 28. 1084 MEHL-           'E.;M l-OP:      J. H6rr2ioh.
F ROM:                               J. Forte'. Cory ) : enc e- Speciellst 5!.'!.0E.C1:            E F X" HA'.'EN PEV] Eli OF E. E. IENT CONCERNS
      ,        h4 .   .
rr a c m c: 16 Er col t.even Net 2 onel         L&boratcry       1 otter    of Augm t 23.                J oE : . r egercij ng thei r pr oposed review of the concernt e:p estc-d              L: Mr .       E.! nio E er 1 Lent.
* As           you - I.nc o. . these conc er r.s re] ate to welding practices at                Sen Onoi           e. Pt] : seds s ,       end N;diend.      A   comprehensive        review was
    ; p> & :oss3-              p a r i ce n.e d   by RV end NRR as to       Mr . .. .llent's concernt-rt).tive tc Sen Onofre and generic disagreements.With the ASME and             ALG w.r1 d i n g        Coden     (end   other Standarde such ~ as ANSI q.':1i(icetion r c qui r ements                  . An inspection of specific welde et the           I12 dl end pl ant wet conduct ed immediately after receipt-of the' Kent             el l ec at i ons .      An 01 A r evi ew of RV's handling of           the Kent al] eget 2 ont has aleo been per f or med.                     It'is my understanding that
     .DI:RIII sti3) hec an .unc ompl e ted case regarding Kent.
My' 9enerir comment on tho'broolhaven letter'is.that'the present
     . e < i cm t h e..1 c' t e 1imited to concerns at Mid)end end                          Pe J i sades..  '
e n . ''      the e) ) .rget i on iE oothaven t!24)specificel)y referred to R11I in          t h e P'.' I + c 2 e l ] r.; pe ct s on Rer>or t Geport- Nos.         50-206/82-31.
t.. -- 3 : 1 C . - T 1.
         .                             57--36::/'6;-27 ) . Whi1e we may e.: pend 'on-             the ihtpect2on               pr e v2 c.ur ] y performed at Midi and in r esponte t c. . . Mr .
Kent's              s pec 2 f 2 c    weld concerns,         we s,hould not      duplicets wor 1.
elready. edequatel y perf ormed by RV and NRR.                          My specific comments are at follev:
: 1.       A] ] eg e t i ons. 4: 16 t il l 7 rhould go to DI A orL be d2 tmi ssect.
: 2.         ] c enne.i )ocitc al 1 ege t i on fl26 in the c ei. egor i : et i on .1~2 Et s.
: 3. Al1oget2ons #25 end tis 3 should be dismiesed.
: 4.        AlIeget2ons $135, tt 38, tf 45 relate to Palisades                    and should not be closed out-of-hand.
: 5.        rd l eg a t i on r #42 end itS8 are the como,              .yet    are    categori:od di f f er e nt ] *, .
: 6.        T h t. i nt er vi ew trenter2pt of the Augut,t 32,              '1992 i ntei vi ev of
                . !P . F.ent et hi l l we.s apparentl y. not revi ewed f or.' el l eget i ont .
James E. Foster Comp 1iance Specialist-r 8706260165 870619 FOIA E                                               g PDR PDR
                                                                                               .O CARDE85-213                               _q L .:

{
p' u,,. J j-e .4 a4
                                    '9     r -':   <,,    :s..,, .-;.s,6, b              *
(' S     /s ' /7 , c 4 ..s'd st. A         :x' 2:p   7 a /; 4 ',. f 4
                                                    .r,
                                                          ?< ! L a .x d i -C 7 L-'sa''...s/-i.s.A,a;,/c2l4.;w 4d.
   # t/ 2 t L'S g ! ,,43 , c y p cljl/l....'(            g, f , , ,7 . . /
sv.r.e.. J     . m:.. A  ol,n,vc.A         ,x.   . u..-/ 4./     . < > s F 2 s~      J '' A A O x ) , ( / .d. . slu NS3
   # W ,eA>!/ x.,s, w          <
                                         /ue /qu nu;/r.:-r pyH M.
s.'N zs.gz - 2 7sf w/ra si bfL.n. /,      c .. ',' #VA
                                 ,.E.l+ w k / 2 5 mi l &CW .4v.kfr-)E s.
As2      &^                    "    ''       "         ''
                                                              .2 6 .2 e c x.).
l 1
l 1
4 4
G-1}}