NUREG-1606, Summary of CRGR Meeting 310 on 970909 Re Proposed Rev 1 to GL 91-18,proposed Amends to 10CFR50.55a & Proposed GL on Lab Testing of nuclear-grade Activated Charcoal.Attendee List & Presentation Matl,Encl
| ML20205K256 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 03/30/1999 |
| From: | Jerome Murphy Committee To Review Generic Requirements |
| To: | Travers W NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO) |
| References | |
| RTR-NUREG-1606 GL-91-18, NUDOCS 9904130059 | |
| Download: ML20205K256 (45) | |
Text
l l
- e,k*
6 p
UNITED STATES g
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
%*****)
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20056 4001 March 30, 1999 MEMORANDUM TO:
William D. Travers Executive Director for Operations FROM:
Joseph A. Murphy, Chairman Committee To Review Generi eq irements
SUBJECT:
MINUTES OF THE CRGR MEETING NUMBER 310 The Committee To Review Generic Requirements (CRGR) met on Tuesday, September 9,.
1997, from 9:00 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. W. Kane (NMSS) was presided, as the Acting Chairman, for the moming session of the meeting and Joseph Murphy (RES) served as the Acting Chairman for the aftemoon session. Attachment 1 contains a list of attendees.
D. Matthews and E. McKenna, both of NRR, presented for the CRGR review and endorsement the proposed Revision 1 to Generic Letter 91-18, "Information To Licensees Regarding NRC inspection Manual Section on Resolution of Degraded and Nonconforming Conditions." contains the presentation material used by the staff. CRGR noted that the staff had not requested CRGR review and endorsement of NUREG-1606, " Proposed Regulatory Guidance Related to implementation of 10 CFR 50.59 (Changes, Tests, or Experiments)" Draft for Comments, dated April 1997;" however, the Committee expressed an interest in reviewing 50.59-related staff efforts in the future. Because clarification of a previously accepted staff position was articulated in this document, the Committee recommended that the staff develop plans to clearly communicate the inspection guidance to the Regions to ensure consistent implementation. CRGR supported issuance of the revised generic letter and the attached inspection guidance without requiring them to be issued for public comments.
L. Shao and W. Norris, both of RES, presented for CRGR review and endorsement the proposed amendments to 10 CFR 50.55a. Attachment 3 contains the presentation material used by the staff. The rulemaking addressed ASME Code construction, in-service inspection, and in-service testing activities. CRGR made extensive cornments which improved the backfit arguments on severalissues. The staff's rationale for the proposed amendments became stronger and more defensible. The Committee recommended specific changes to the Statement
'4 Considerations and the Regulatory Analysis. The CRGR comments resulted in a major l
restructuring of the SOC. Consequently, the bases for various technicalissues were strengthened, and the proposal became more focused. The staff agreed with the Committee i
L that the significance of the issues raised and the value added was commensurate with the additional efforts.
l l
In the context of CRGR review of 50.55a rulemaking, RES staff made a resource-saving suggestion that if the Committee were to rely entirely on the Regulatory Analysis instead of the staff having to answer the required CRGR Charter questions, at least a week would be saved in developing the CRGR review package. The Committee accepted this suggestion and plans to include it in the next CRGR Charter revision.
VV67
,f 9904130059 990330 MCl ) i
~
PDR REVOP Mt0CROR NEETING310 PDR r]
] j ti v -
$WIcrc 4 2
I
)
l 1
l William D. Travers l The Committee endorsed the proposed amendments subject to various comments and recommendations.
J. Segala and S. Newberry, both of NRR. presented for CRGR review and endorsement the proposed generic letter on laboratory testing of nuclear-grade activated charcoal. Attachment 4 contains the presentation material used by the staff. The Committee endorset.he proposed generic letter subject to various comments and recommendations.
As the meeting over-ran, Gus Lainas of NRR requested postponing to a later CRGR meeting the briefing on the scope and schedule of the steam generator regulatory framework. The l
Committee accepted the suggestion.
1 Questions conceming these 'eeting minutes should be referred to Raji Tripathi(415-7584).
Attachments: As stated cc: Commission (5)
SECY l
M. Knapp, DEDE F. Miraglia, DEDO J. Lieberman, OE M. Springer, ADM H. Bell, OlG K. Cyr, OGC J. Larkins, ACRS H. Miller, R-l L. Reyes, R-il J. Dyer, R-Ill E. Merschoff, R-IV C. Paperiello, NMSS A. Thadani, RES S. Collins, NRR D. Matthews, NRR S. Newberry, NRR l
Minutes of CRGR Meeting No. 310, September 9,1997 Attendance List
- CRGR Meeting No. 310 September 9,1997 CRGR MEMBERS NRC STAFF C. Rossi for T. Martin D. Matthews, NRR F. Miraglia J. Strosnider, NRR J. Murphy F. Coffman, RES D. Dambly S. Newberry, NRR M. Knapp J. Craig, RES J. Dyer (video teleconferencing)
G. Mizuno, OGC J. Shapaker, NRR CRGR STAFF T. Bergman, NRR M. Malloy, NRR R. Tripathi E. McKenna, NRR H. Walker, NRR B. Thomas, NRR J. Raval, NRR G. Millman, RES A. Murphy, RES E. Brown, AEOD T. Scarbrough, NRR R. Gramm, NRR M. Mayfield, RES D. Terao, NRR M. Mitchell, NRR K. Wichman, NRR R. Hermann, NRR Ken Heck, NRR J. Hayes, NRR J. Flack, RES G. Lainas, NRR C. Beardstee, NRR J. Donoghue, NRR E. Murphy, NRR P. Rush, NRR T. Reed, NRR L. Marsh, NRR R. Emch, NRR J. Lyons, NRR J. Segala, NRR M. Rafky, OGC M. Satorius, OE ACRS STAFF M. Markley ATTACHMENT 1 i
Minutes of CRGR Meeting No. 310, September 9,1997 l
l t
I l
PRESENTATION MATERIALS USED BY THE STAFF ATTACHMENT 2 I
i-
l r
Rx w
Lt G-R C
a R8 n
G1 o
i t
R a
1 l
C 9
gu 7
e OL 9 R 9
TG r
1 o
+
t.
r
+
NO 9
a
+
OT R
e E R I
B r
T1 Ma e
A E
l N
T c
T u
P O
N NI E
Sf E
S o
SI e
E V c
if RE f
O PR
~
e n) c o8 n
1 a
N d
1 d
i 9
u n
g aL 9
d G 5
e o
n d
t o
0 a
5 r
n a
g o
d d
ei s n
e Di a
s v
r o
f e
E o
p oR N
m o
n(
e rp o
s IL M
n it T
n u
o s
o l
i t
oit U
n s
sd O
e t
e n
n R
o m9 e
C e5 m
o r
r f
g iu0 m
n q5 o
ei R
R c
c m
e n
r F
c a
o f
C i
d f
l fa b
n i
t 0
u u
o S1 P
G c
e t
-: !:i !!
i
fo w
f s
o a
7 a
l s
9 d
e 9
e g
s e
1 v
a S
i p
t ie i
T l
7 c0 t
i N
e0 u
y r
E 5
r lu s
a M
J o
e ret l
M r
t c
t e
u e
e s
O v
n l
o o
C 0l c m
d 4
o C
o y7 r
i f
r I
l L
e e9 B
p t
9 s
r a
1 s
el t
U n
m,t t
E n
t P
e x6 e
eN i
m o1 m
l r
t s
m p
y m
so m
o plu o
r C
AJ c
Mf i
e e
5
gn i
m r
o fnocn y
t o
n i
l n
i S
d o
c i
E d
e t
a n
v a
f U
a o
c e
l i
S f
h d
v i
S e
n c
t e
o i
d s
I a
s e
p t
Y a
c s
i r
e E
g Q
yn g
i l
r S
e t e a
e n
K D
u c
i t
a l
U i
ni i
ibq n
h r
ro a
c gae h
c f
d rbs c
f a o n e
a i
9 o
mr o t
f t
5 r
h pc a
o a
s e
.0s ee r
n t
e s
n s
ss o
o 5
r a
o e
h e
t aa f
i i
f t t
r ee s
r i
oi r r n
d t
c en n
Q cc e
i e
s f
nn a
S dii a
e s o l
Uc P
U B
D
l l
j 9
n S
Q 5
e y
N S
h t
0 O
U g5 w
n i
I n
u T
gi s
n t
nt r
ID a
e o
N v
r r
o i
e p
i e
u l
O o
p q
c p
e v
o e
n o
C c
n r
a ni o
d e
G l
a st n
d b
s i
N d
r o
u e
s ai is oi gd ei s
I i
l t
M u
ai r
c d
e r
a a
gb R
p e
e e
u vb r
s n
s a
r O
8 gt a
g F
1 n
n o
o s
et n
is e
c pi si min N
1 r
s n ml o
n O
9 e
f a
r o
pi y
e d
i C
r c
nt t
r d
c e
a 6
a o
ni i
N el l
0 ut o
t O
t o mp a
y o
et 6la s
et N
L a
r e
o 1
v n
b e
c g
s e
e
/
g n
e y
G p
y n
D i
E e
ai a
E 9
r r
mla a
D nh u
e R5 l
o eh A
eC qD U0 cd c
e R
G N5 r
G ED e
e
~
i l
n S
o i
N t
s O) a t
r s
n 2
ei e
IT pt m
e I
o n
D g
e m
N a
n m
o e
O p
o p
c lu C
si u
c d
d t
i G
't c
q e
l N
n e
e b
h f
u o
f f
c p
s IM (c ei n p
d R
n u
t n
s O
o w
e r
a e
o a
c c
F ed t
e r
N ct s
c n
u O
n u
a o
ah e
n c
r ei s
C d
s o
r i
r f
e i
N i
f e
n u
e e
O gi p
g n
r b
N u
xi o
s d
q e
e e
t
/
e y
c el v
t D
s b
t r
l a
E o
a o
n e
r s
ef p
D pt o e
e c
a m
o A
n p
r e
si r
R R
P o
G ED e
e
SN de O
n I
i T
m d
B ID e
re x
ui N) t O3 e
sd r
d u
n C
p e
t p
r p
Gd a
e p
N
't t
b A
s n
I e
n l
Mo f
l r
i
/o o
w R (c i
8 nt t
O o
au n
n 1
i F
t o
e l
N 1
a a
m i
r t
O 9
v u
e e
e l
C L
p o
c r
N G
o y
s o
t ni ef O
o r
l N
t oi n
b n
e
/
n s
a i
t r
h D
o c
e y
g i
E s
e p
a u
l i
f o
e o
D v
f A
e E
y D
r h
R R
b t
G ED e
.i n
s o
eo t t e
E Q
l a
N S d l
s b
e Ue r n a
yf t
ci t
r o ha g
r o
r tl s
o t n io a
n p
a o wi om p
si v
u ns pS N
itcd s
ev u7 i
O ad pe t
a t
I r
o mr a o T
yr r
n o7 t n C
o o c9 s
A Q
r9 in d t
s t
at S
F s n o1 ma U
f O
n e r
e e
pm h
h1 el t
c2 pb ES me a
a i
v w
oy or R
oo rl t e cr n
pu np U
p o s pJ o o n
O om id an i
t t s C
a n i
i i i r u y
s n e T
ok eo 8
rd ot t e n
ia pr 1
s p
n e
N t
og ui m
im f
s 1
E da f
l o
t a
9 nt ap S
Po n g in ti E
t a
L o
su e
e l
R 6s pl G
c q
s ye P
0e r
r f
s 6v no o
o i
o t
e dd dr oe i
1 t la n
nu7 d
n n
Ge oi o
es mi c
a0 v
i Ec n
s i
l l
t t
o e6 l
l Rnin s
v wm9 wp h
i i
i i
r c
Usa o
e e
il Ndp Pt R
M ss U
ec s
D t
6 o
n r
N 0
p e
A 6
m y
1 r
e R
o iB r
O G
t E
6 a
9 uqd M
R 3
u e n 5
l t
r a E
n U
0 g
0 e
5 9A e
N 7
r M
5 m
n 9
r r
s S
m o
o o
Y f
f 0e 5c T
o s
C s
n i
N n
E n
a fd c
t 2
on l
e S
o p
e r
E o
it np m
n a
g f
M o
ip 6
m o
d n
tA E
i 0
o e
n k
a R
6 r
c c
e a
uo e
1 n
m m
at I
l U
p c
a P
b d
mt e
vs s
i Q
G a
l ee l
on u
i E
u u
ce r
imt E
R n
p g
em a
r g R
U o
r e
r en i
e p
Ti F
N s
t e
e r
v o
e s
a d
d F
h io i
l r
i u
d A
s m
s vr e
ei la n
op v
gs i
m v
o r
l T
b m
e nn S
u o
e c
pi d
oo P
C Lc
'o 2
~
m
Minutes of CRGR Meeting No. 310, September 9,1997 PRESENTATION MATERIALS USED BY THE STAFF ATTACHMENT 3 I
l i
l o
w ry3 II uMi I
n s
t n
n o
o o
t i
c c
ss a
6 t
ir 5
9 c
e i
S m
5 9
e n
)
m 1
S e
6 E 9 R o
0 G
7 C
5 e
e w
6 y
h d
e 5
g y
R t
1 o
i o
v 4
ro l
F h
C e
7
(
o t
t R
9 s
n a
C s9 ih l
wV i
ot r
u 1
t n r
c P
e g
0
,oe d
ee9 e
n emr N T R
1 o
tt e e
e g
o o
B C
mi mlai r
ir b c
n a
t i
e t
u r
E M
mq e a
ee t
i l
l cu n
d oet N
e E
M O
CR pWi n e
g m5 S
S y n s
- r d
9 A
e o
b E e
t h
F a
d f n
9 e
t t
n e
o S
e 1
h r
o tn n
d i
t me o
t e
o e
h r
f a
i s
s t
t in A
n ei t
o d
r v
e U
f Pi d
o n
s D
e e
t a
a r
d P
s e
o t
n I,
a e
X s,,,)j p
d d
d o
a r
p d
n
- f P
U A
a
[
.f lllf
.1' s
1 t
e n
d s
e i
r n
S l
e o
n l
p i
i oB mo d
f s
g t
n C
e o
n s
i t
s n
as n
r e
t t
o er a
o l
s p
Hle P
d i
i s
m f o r
n n
o oB e
w E
o C
n r oe o
C n
d w P
e t
r a
a o r
A l
r e
P eP a
s e
d s
pf l
r r e
sl c
)
o s
ee Oo l
s eu s
r es s
e wi d r e sN n
l C
oo l
naVs e f o
X E
io PB aCenVo XI l
i e
B rg e
r oen t
I d D
e s
r an r
c uir o t
d n s
e ei ah ss a ui e
c st n a l
t t
e w
ca Crei O
s c S
a o
ue V
P NHohneorf ee
,V f Pl i r p f
f f t sf aPs r
V C
i t e
o ooar e o u n
a I
cI
,H n
nnifi nQi e
I no n r
t e l
I E
u o
s l
s c oo iims e ogai c
nn i
edi s
t t t t nl v u
oo M
s c
cc al ciPr i
ii e
u uu xuu u z N(
t t e
cc rERGr ad s r
r r
t t t t r en e e S
P n
nnvdd n r
I s s s
s s e sBcI SS o
ooiee od o e A
d C
CCc nnCnf h ee X
t dd cc u
nt n
rls r rr r air nn ee m m o gR f d
ee e
a oaoot o
rr fiff s mmf n n
ffee r
e is r
s e s sd sd r
et ee ooel ee a
ee RR nccl e
al l
l l
uuoee u ebiu I
l u
i s
RMRRNRRRWFR I
HX I I on I
Boi s
a nn oo H
n5 t
ii Ec HI X I
t t o5 cc I
V I
e HHI VVVVI XX e e MS i
SS I
t 0 S
c5 1
e A1 eeeeeeeeeee S
ee i
/
2 e
d i
l
)
S d
s a
n t
2Cn d
d a
9 n
n e
9Mm e
a d
s 1
d n
e A
o s
n it di d
ei it e
v es a
i n
d a
si s
st E
rt r an n
i s
o c
ol o
A u
dA dC C r
r a
o D
n n nf i
e v
a Y
e e
Eo Eot e
r N
Y h
P 2t 6 I e
i a
h 9
c 9 S r
E c
c
/
u
/I h
E t
n D
i c
w 6
r 8
r o d
/t
/
a e
d 8
s s
8 o
D E
h e
ne fC s
n n
oi na(
i A
d b
b l
i t
l u
m oCi odC v
e P
o d
d nC D
H i
I t e
e e
C eI c
h dd r
hI N
e A
er s
A sd n
e A
in r
i Aa A
A d
b oT b
l l
o a
i y
C d n ut S u 2 )s N
cI Pe P9t no l
t d d gS d 9
n l
e ei t a
h di O
g1 e
n c
m i
o A E nr a
n e
I p
n t
i i
o s
s a kfI kh n
T y
i t
r a
S at a
I T
n an mnI mht e
ei D
o t
n s
m Yd eiI ei o
g e
e uiX u wC l t l
v 3 h E
n o
yi s d
n Rnl R Eo oa i
r rl t
p eb e
m vu l
l e
i i t I
EP a9t at M
n8 c
nie dM 9
e i
i FE(
4 e
e F1S
. A
- .;i:
j!
3 g
.s nt e
d i
l g
t i
r u l
s S
n d
o e p
i n
eR d
p a
ni Rt aP y
,s t
e i
gT l
C n
ib gls g
i ne C
sl pn i
s eei i
s e net ps d
c a
nKu me n
c o
Asd a l
aV a
r r v
,e o t 3 sPcE e
S C
,e r
i t
sRo d
i a
nn M
e l
b r
,f i
una 5
o a i
sd oir i,
3 n ei e t
5 t
o cct c2 poe r i
u 2
s r p ePsC 0
r1 R
nd t
5 s s 1
,dI n
n r a ns s
)s a o st l
oa s
r s
d od gs l
CC ao h
nt oin l
F p
eht e t
Cp mt em r s s
n e
e O
gf v
f u
gMTr o
e oS n
f i i
l s n a
nou i
I r
d o q
E e oV Si uiye Di t c anR I
e P
l t d c
rc rh nner O
oe n
oT ui i
i mqa
(
f t a
f gaep o
d nxr e C
s r s
iE FR s
n t
ePp e
s l
a e
,s s
S u em R s, l
u Ttynt
,i o n Rr u
e l
i t
ni u
t b am I
sP I
n o
iace I
s Xe t t i r c cf I
e s
n e ei u i
l nr no ppaq opm op nnQR s s ue i
re im I I t
t et s c
ce vy e o SOS SC J
e s
t r
e h
4 r
A 1
a Wi P
t s
e c
h a
s e
d e
y 4
v n
T e
i lh e
1 na t
lW u
o a
e S
g d
c r
S t
V U
T le a
a e
d D
v n
d h
e n
a i
s e
m e
a e
W o
t t
T m
t i
e p
1 T
S s
h u
kt d
lp m
n e
NV r
e e
ps u
s o
D F
r T
d s
e ut f
m Sn P
o n OO N r S
e e
h
- eM dd I
M r
f P lp x e e
en ic n
0 Be e
h w
sf n a v
f 0 o ao n e e tun ep c le Mm WN C p
C d
u u
T p p a n
S o
eS pA
=
tt E
o nT dI A
e O
t B
gC sS or f e d
k o
a n
nI Cf o, t m
io h
t e e e
s to u
s e gh f
_ s te f
o e
a u
es ed o
d M B Tn 4
p p
e Re e'
- U e e t5 e
__t U
- p ec d
s s
g n
1 nu u^
J o un e5 nU ol A A, a n k
t c y
ya Ts s i a g
r h mo e o Q0 u
n r
S n
tac km N5 eo n
e e
m A e t
os iag u
kt n
n a
w c
4 e >n tr l o lo h
lop oo IrB u
tnm q
o e o u e a
rC VS Cs r 4 e e
e o
o o
e 4
i f
n s
ht n
a o
w d
o d,
o n
t n
t d
d e
e f
e N
d al n
A e
h r
o m
e a
e 4
rcv e
6 w s t
e A
e B
t m
e n
io h
c p
r m
9 o
in 4
n G
p e
tep a
93 n
E U
u A,
lp luA Ed eT o
r W
c a
1 A e w
tp e
m mp x
o e
L 4
c e
e n
t o
a 0
e h
o e
U )a 4 ms t d N
p o r T
n 5
p a
r oU he s
c r
Vt r
t e
d d
a t
u A
i e R E
Rn e
a S
nP f e wt h
e 5
ry t
cl e
gB u
c ua P
e c
r e
a kv y
B fo nt t
io dS t
B 9
a e
Dd 4 m so r
t F
d iN Ee d
N t
9 r
p o
o a
u de s
u et y 5 lu r
u 1,
p nr c
P e
Ed l
op e
a a
1 a 9R i
s; M L
m A
S r
Cp S
M tpm sM l
e a
ts u
v A
9 k
M e
q c
s t
oC o
n mb s
T e
r e
1, h 6 M O9 T
a eu laa IF C T d
r R
n f
r
.R m
e
)
n o
d sS Cn D g
N It
^
d a
E f
- 2. N i
h e
ne Pr in s e 3
P9 O n a
e e
m oB id (ne n i E
1 t
1 I
e a!
m d
O e
mt ad T
s r
r a
ips eA Vs T
o lg n
ei iA e
ta W
5 R+a r
^ _i m
x t
4 I
>g C e u
q r
r n
E P e
e En Pu e
s n
f o
M C8 eh 9
C p
n o
IR lp et 2 s s n g9 d t f
f n e o n1 no s
s in a
si Po n
o e
p c
a C, P t
e d
od u
a u S c
E r
S ri a s e
eM r
M o s
t s 3
n ho uml i e c it ph p
u r
e Fi s
d eC e
Sa Cr mg p6 o
t f
b d s u A d H
u oa OE t
ey B
I n ae Ei or 0
ts e
nm x
e n
nt S
ClC r
f e e
r s SE i
t i
E9 toa i
s W
3 s u gd u
Pc r n w
f f
r s
n iu t
a s n do o on d a ne t
Co oA aRn o m
8 pc Es M
Hi eE nd oq l
e ul e e es e
a f s 1 e d mes n rF sd st P 9 Ue oe su tos u9 tnet le a o e u ue 1
t r
d smf c m
sl n
A o
e O (1 r
o8 eBa d
e r u yd yc da ed i
rh sd Q
lal r
r9 e
e o uu et d
p c
r d ra n UA N
CV US P1 mdl A S MA ta C
iu1 lpo a lo9 lolo c
r A
t el n
nsi qd ud u6 uw e
S e n 9
ImWM -
V1 VF Ra -
e e
e e
naC h
y t
n eR g
a s
o u
t c
u M
uN o
d M c
r e
sd e
tr e o w si f s B
nA e p
o nIN s
r nu nd t
i6 o
t n
o r o I
lc t
n i w m9 m oq od N
o n9 r
Ce tA r
f f o f
et of n e rR o
y t 1 s
o e tu4 a
sr Vc oN n
f e
M oPh e ed C
d a
r 9
eg rS ee r
o i
WC e
o v
u hin leo 1
n o s u seo ta b
f s
E f
o l
e o m
nh ee Fh t Ls t
ie r
a h
nm s5 y
l r
d r
d T, t oo gs do r n ree s5 i >
b isde Er o -
n s
L 2E a gd f..t tem P0 d
eal e
r N e eE 5
Doa 9g uL
.o ce d
t s
O o
- b. s Ltp 9n od8 o
9
.P B
i5o I T ge nice 1
i c
- 1. e Tt d
mt vd imc Dn nW1 Nt r
n e9 e o G d bd s
An t
u a
r d ef in la k
Kt eA nt r P e
e PaA e
M o
t oDN P. T twod Ae e TC U
t r
yo ao ct 4
u nt e ne QR n e e1 n
d1 o
S gN f
f s e egd e Bos oA dml iN e
e r
nnd s u tU E s '"
nen dA s
ouA e
s s r nD dle ee egn oCn U
f i
e a
h o
tad pao MNo ie8 ed uB O
eM P e
ncP ro v9 ce fnl t dsu en r 5 e u t
y v
c s
en c r
t e9 es oao pe da e UA^
PR1 SU CCN Ub InMP t
ew
- 5. wt n m
e 0
ho 5eo V
5Bc e
e j
!j 4
i; 9j-l!{I
.i i
5e d
i m
l t
S r
i os o
a
,f r
gk e
e g
n c
t o
d o
i a
eD nC P
u t o r
rB t
t f a
a f
co n
d 9 Po o
at l
fi p0 rt e
ur i
t 1
oc a
nip U
Fu d
aS 0
r
- t p
M d h5 ns U
t o n n
io s
ya n5 cC e
t t
i t r
l ot ul n
i it a
ra u
Mh e
s n q
Ut t
n e
,I nig oia R) 9 0T:
Cr gh 1
nis O5 am t
0 2
o 5
5 a (e i f
5 r w
1 es ToD s
g st 0 o e n eey r e 5 r ce 0
nBl os5 P
ot i
a iUo ri r
s 5
t yn Ps T
Ps t
t ul n
aS n
R ot A nwI hI d o eo t
rC Reint sl d ed a
l e oat r
r n d s h
t f a
aa nI e
sk Car wI a )y L
hi c
s5 p AS S r 5 o t
t s
I I
na n0 o o
r y(
st 0
nob o5 c ll s
u a n
uh sl 1
oC i
t nu s5 I Fn e g A
s,n e o s e n
V-nR s
no rM o
o ae oi A
s t
I t r 0
C e, i
r I i iHi s
I ae e2 l c s
u niV e1 an c
f s
na oaq oir ny or P5 e
r id e e
ue i
t e
t e
a iv a sd cot
- 5. R SML LE NInR c
C 0t R5 o
N$N e
=
\\
ii l!
i t
6 e
d s
il t
S nn y
s oe n
h t
n o
p n
s o
e it o
ge p
i a
s r
d o
nmle m e
n l
ir e Ro t
i p
a h
e r n
S e
O e
P ei eCa 5 c
u ef m
d n
e n
N q
s o 5 e
n e
d i
)a g
a o
ge n
0 i
O d
d r
n u
n e
C nR cn5 es J
o p
h Er i
of I
e s
Li i
t i
t i d
g tc F
W ea t f T
d n
u e
r p Aao i
A r
r c
u e
t t
pe A
e s
a n
rR nlap 2
e l
9 n
n p
e e
e vo T
o e
s t e h Ec t
i 9
g C
R s
nd i
1 n
Wr S I
(
f n
I t
o E
o o
o M
l o e yC T
f s
n C
a a
h o
t n
N c
st Mw v e e
e a
e I
E p C B
o oin s
L MU t
s t
sl ri l
i pvh e
A d
s e o n
u e
a M
sF pit E
h t i l
I AcW G
T A
k n o l
rA X
D s
s eT e
s ot t
t c
or u s
s on n
/
U s
e b e e
i ioB d m m
Lg e
r I
J r
d rf n
P n e e
,i I
d d
t e I
Gd A
Hd d
oa ve o ag g
nv end N
A t
u u
H i
N R
d N
I e
o AJ J
t e mC i
t g g
a t t c e o
s on n
i o e gy O
E C
e Ni i
mN Rdb r
r E
o s e e
o ud I
N T
D I e e
i t
n n
Ls sJe T
A ugs e
ei I
d d
d g g
e i
G s
r o
on n
it Mne C
N w
C CE E
dn o
i r r
e e ed E
E e
tume ed r
f o
oe s
S o
F h g ninA e gt t
e id c
u ino s
WJ LEN U
0 lll
7e
)e d
ilS u
r d
h
,.l o
a n
g
- e. v es a
u i(
p e
o n
a I
u r
s a R
l l
d e o
s h
am C
P s
I T
o g
E La n
e d
i gt c
y v
d n u u
l b
o A
N i o d
sb or y
s r a P
l e
4 O
e R
9 t
ve f
el o
n 9
c i
I Ry e
o o
1 r c b
J T
l T
a g
oh p
d g
n A
f c
a nh C
e n
i i
s r
c t
i U
T iw o
oi e
o t
t I
as N
s r e
m nt M
ud t
c M
)a o e l a r
o a o A
pl r s vl SE n
Fn s
I Ec d
e o
d i
a L
gl e
di n
o gm a
s n
L n r B
ei e
a i
t v i
d s n h
t e e
I d
e i
c s n v
b o H
A Dy u
e e a
i r
d S
T G H
ohP 4
gr t
9 na a
9 pi T
y r e il h
n N
1 im ob E
Pse in d
M eh Pie e
(
O N
s l
r sb mi ed od a et s e S
BT o
I G
aw A
d r f nt r
r I
sap Pt T
o l
o Be t
e s
d uf S
ns c ni i
C E
e ec oD n v n
od E
D mkA e
ds iR Wd o
a a
e s s o eut t
f i
f A
r o
ar S
C i qN BG sd a
e6 s
uh on t
I qt e Pa S
e9 M
r e
r a
s9 S
ReA n1 CC C
ce i
h
~
NN N
Lt S
t 1li
i e
s s
e r
o hf u
o B
h t o s
1 x
T f
s I
i o n I
A d
t n
n s
l o
l I
Q e
e n
i E
N p
m o
As r i
ND p
e s
ee zV i
r l
mA p
v i
e OO l
o i r ht a 0
p r
t e
i r 5
u P
Ut IT C Eg S
a t
s oL o
r t
t f
r a
s I
T CM oP P
u e
o s z R
M e
E t
ei s e nm ei l
SO Uc F
1 a
st i
n nU ea C
A-1 r e
g c o OE h
r t u 0
Q Ao i
is N
Qr L T TH s
1 t
P mA y
N e es T
f t
r A
io s
nB f
r y S
et t
e oQ uo i
ND Pl a
mi qh x
i s
e eC a
S ed n
e n
ot Ry h
ON d u t
l oQ o
pe it s d e N
mp r
I A
C B I p o
h n
l T
r uT d
AI Mx oA Pe o
l Wd v
u Ty s
i Od o
f e o lu TX n
aG e o t
gs W
ni e e l
t rI uh I
h p i
f s a gI RS MN t
p oS eI l
dA e
n s
o t
s O
o nn d n t
h I
s I
T I o e o LI a 'r C
i si I
y s
I t osI T
Xn B
s n I
e e
I c piIvI e o o o
- 1C nw1 ei nS r r n s s P Pi o
o oO A
ni is AE v
i e
t u e
t t
c o c
c e Qir eh hAc S
eh N
St N
i i'
9 d
e e
d e
s s
il h
i S
h a
l t
a g
T B
m n
t f
t e
r
)
i 4"
s l
o c
o e
u N
e i
o f
l R
s r
r t
f 6
n a
0 e
5 A
4-o E
l 5
d N
a 1
y 7
i t
n l
t d
c r
u n
r U
(
t 9
t i
a e
r c
o b
e O
e F
P no P
r i
t i
s r
D o
h r
R t
i I
R u
t c
A N
2 g
e F
a T
WO C
n s
i t
C n
s f
i c
r A
0 m
o s
e A
P s
O a
v 1
a it x
a L
a O
s l
C H
k m
C h
B E
1 N
g a
r t 9 x
c e
o r
s n0 i
i I
Oi n
f a
o1 d
r n
r f
o s
t F
n e
I p
B i
t n
C M0 l
I ep m
I T
P ll n
d 5
p u
a e n
o t
i c
6 A
I D
l R
A o
S e
mv a
t e
N P
e S E V
1 a
r deF r
n I
O M1 O
nA 8
C rC V
n I
H o
an 1
n o
t c
i X
e i
m 8
MA o
u0 m
i s
h s
y c
d a
T q1 d
t l
e a
e uu n
x e
n Xl l
l a
p r
sS a
n Ro E
C a
e E
o m
I T
e i
f F
Rt 8
c c9 e
I t
I o
C a
0 n
r l
8 r
A9 Bn o
e e
dg i
I I
g s
t 8
t 9
o s
ui X
Ri n ir v
oi e
d1 di e
e t
e e
k B
CM N
m t e l
t T
c s-iB up 0
i a
r v
eo 2
a i
N E
e d
r a
nT 5-u t
o c
C l
e l
id Wx MC D
ut 8
o nl i
2 oa Ld O
U I u s o E
V r
Wd e
s e
r s
3 r
p aW n
n e
i t
e e
d sU I
L e
v h g t
s H
o i
ic n
t T
O m
R Tis e
t e
n l
f e r
I t n a
nh a
o at i
a oD L
Xi a a 4
i C
VD n
l s
c u
t t
t i
1 Po na nl em r
r q
i 1
e q
yM c
s oi ep d
C ue e
e C
n -
E S
s i s i l Rmcb mmD a0 t
i l t n
S S
n ay e
eu 2
I a
FS G
ee SP eo G
M1 A
dt pC l
s L
oy mn C
CS I o
,l l
l' i
}
r s
m o
e f
ru I
u d
d V
s r
e e
e c
X t
m v
o n
r y
O r
e d
P m
n l
o t
t e
a fr n
n T
l e
p s
m U
I e
e m
I Ps e
e e
I d
r v
c n
gu nt P
o n
o o
r T
i i
iS p
S r
e t
e r
m t
n e
Bd A
k m
r if e
t I
i n
t c
Ta s
n a
e C
t a
Be r
Us n
c i
t d
u i
I l
e f
Ao q
2 l
I l
o i
AB m
n eC e
3-Bn R
I e
g C
i V
od r
S t i e
oy h
D i
t n
u A
Nl G
t ya q
X t
f e
l e
B d n o
p l
e s
I pe R
us e
4 o
e s
1 o r u
D Al T
l zz e
WP e
al c
u C
d o n
d N
e e n eR D
luN n
t t o B
o a
ai l
E G
o s
r d a t
t a P
W n, g
rI t
i s
pc f n eX n
Uf ki i
cF n
P o
i P
i l
a o
)I p n
ms h a e
i e n n u Bh A
Di d o t
t P
nit Do oQ Ar t
p P
ac e
i s
e ni Ml s
s e c
(
e I tf x
sS ev I
l e
eo 0 n I
s r n Br 2 n nA E
I e
o Ve ui P
1 o is s
s s
t h e
d at er ct c
xV ed n
ne An n
i c e He iP o
a t
d r o n I s s
e ud hM i
i n o r a Dr o n i
l e c Pt PP Ra T6 p
t pa n
m pe To o
. 'i
,) !
i
l gn i
R n r e
d i e il t c S
G 1
nn R
3 e o C
r mcin e
R e
yg l
t b
o pt n E
m mfei a
t t
s d
e e
I at i
Sf T
e o
k e
c s
t v
e n
a c T
t o
D n
e it a mhaB r
o c
i E
p n
Lr mTt i
e e
t p
o p
t L
A e
s e t t o
a di n
x uL Ced t
c e
t d
e E
qc ya e C
n m
m l
ei i t e
r rS a
c Re a
m I
m n
n t
LI R
e6 o
a t e d
o nuGt eG i
n 9
l c
w9 C
p t
loh a e1 c
m aa Vir t r i
i i
o rn wa N
v9 i
b C
pi o
l om nW t t E
f s
r o
pa e ed g r
P t
e e e
pr e sl n G
r si ui r
s ag ns ok t b o
o U
n r e n a
oWm emf P
t I
c e
i c
t s
I a Lnt e Le d
a al I
v e
I i
t r
h u I
co h
d r
I o fIosT R r
s e
p t
iN I
v o
t r
si yI t e i
V nn b
e p
rm cI sh e
l i
I i eVxt n
e eo u
c p
m f
Eo t
/
X G
P e
a n o gxt R
n e
rio e mC I
Ud c
r I
I mly nNn 2
e s
I D
V o.
e a
I t
t t
n G
or I pe vs i
e e
R Ca Epod N
xN L
mA yn NADA t
i E
d g c
B nu mU al n
i ni r
o N
MV c
P et e
o pe n6 C
P pe e99 7
A AMG1 1
i G
!i.
l:!
Q f
e e
g m
k h
o l
m n
y a
o S
i t
r r
o t
i s
l g
t S
ees b
o S
i d
Tni a
r s
n el a pop t
o a
vAB aTt n
5 e
Csn 0
l e
agn ee m
s Vng s er 6
i i
i c
i s r 9
e N
s s
r dt e a nu l
seD BcC L
p e
e e
x t
r G
p O
E aT i
r r
nLi u
I e
e ee g
e o
S v
pmd dh t
is a
Oin eteT T
l t
s V
rTU Dsf n
e e
a e
A oktey f u u
s o
s oqs s
n t
e ooi C
l s
r ri ne d
Mt b ore u
e i
c s n
P it I
v S a it e
o d
p a",v s
Ln F
t r
e aa csi e
t P
et n
t I
ahC f v e tam i
c e
D Cy eT V rl f m
ht
)
l i
e af Ti RdO VVE i
t Tm t
i e
O ysM m
Si l t s cd e em I b er m
i a
e r
ni f uf dt u MG o
i c o oas o
ol a
rn C
uC s
i e Si i
e r
e q
tcR
",D c
e pE g
e e N
e n
P n
I sd 0Ca
",O r Res i
b n o
E T
ua 1Rr s
r n
d h S
S m 9Nu 5 om e
l T
s 0t a c
u
(
8 s
D E
e o
r ", A i
r 6
T gD ee g
L oh 9Mo n-9 OE kn Wi t
t c e e
i t
nd rd r v
eW e
oO Ll v t
ai e eP a
C Mtrf cio t
s e aA H
t l
lug I
S o er l
rvPn Le s
i T
n h
Ri ME i r e r o
cRs e
c e i
e t
du nutoi r yb n
d s t
i il s
os eSnd et r e d nn nfea e
e e
OK ia G
t c
sT O
PM nn ao e as i
e o
I aCC GSE L
pe R
om T
ri PT S
=
e t
f 3j!
- I
a e
f d
e du t
f l
x a
u B
s e
t o
d n
N S
e n
W l
o d
g o
u e
t h
n a
d s
o d
i e
W t
a r
a k
e r
s o
e e
c a
t l
u "g i
c d
t e
n s
a B
a g
s l
i a
U n
P s
F n
n vn e
r i
o r
c R
o y
p Ei C
i t
i p
a L
i t
e c
f P
",P G
a a
3 Be i
p s
h e e t
1 3 b
a o
R F
S r
3 Rl d
o i
y f
f a p B C
t o
n T
5 s ot e
e a
g f
n s
s s
p R n
a o
2 n
n f
Nl ye o
S a
a c r
v t
s o
o i
i l
i i
e c e
a l
f c
s t
t eC fe S
a o
u a
s DA i
i d
d l
n d
C n
a t
,s D
an l
t e
sI a
i o
o c
Ci ng o
t R
r t
o C
C mi t
T s
o n i
c o
f m
b u
I e
g l
i d w ip a
b u
d N
s n
a t i l
e n
X o a di v
u e
c d
o i
nP o
S S
R e
i l
CF o
r s
v a
i t
3 C
p r
o w
U e
o a
D L
r N
ef s
p o
T o
y e
n s f
s o ia A
l r
g n
p l
Ue tC f
e al d
t A
a n
g O O
c a
e n
i f
t i
N e
d n
p s
r e
l o n ey a
l u
m D
t I
Ta Cg S u
u l
q o
o a
m r
e l
r r
t r e e
t T
G d p en v
a e
W V
C e
o e e dE e
v s
o n
d N
i i
l i
C N
c t
n c
b b
h T
ao s
e t
Ut e
c ci n
y a
R O
u I
ic t
l i
d h
e na o
n i
E P
mA a r d
S t
W d
ai C
O t
t I
r h e s
l d
u u
e d
h mt S
P ey To ci s
s o
s en A
eL u
e a
dM M
W a
bi e
M Mi Pr l
o r
3 C
at B
"A u
S e r e
s t
a nd e
n pu s
q o
S Bp man e
o e
el d
,o i
i e
3T s
s i
2 y R d
c a l
r n
t A
d m ew e
c cv u
l t
c A
o aE o
5t a
e
- c L
ue e o l
W Ne C
n s
a i
j A a
C oT DL L
g g
n Un eb C
f is f
n N
Wr o
y k e o
ni od s u s
s r
i e aS s
e a
c oe l
e d
t a r o
e t d C
I sf Hg n
mu win ad e
i d
r o
s t
S e
f a e
t ee S
C s
eo e
vi iA dd a
og m
f t l
s i
ei au e
W s r t
r ue v
r n e
od i
ne SO P
RR e
et r-ci L
ir e
F LC e
e e
R e
e e
I I
i
e M
v e
i d
t i
a ls S
r t
E s
i I
n T
f i
I o
m d
V n
A n
ia o
os t
tiW N
c a
d A
l i
n ce a
T nv s
N oi d
t t
n ca e
e E
e g m
w M
Re e
o E
rN r
l i
l u
o od q
C e
e F
f A
st R
e t o I
L l
n a
B P
eV XE mff n
o c
i t
h N
d R
e a c
NR
/
rt e
e iS T
t f
i u
a e
h s
OA qed i
I g
t l
i a
eh n c
iMS n
I P
Rt e o
e hd c
B T
E e cd c
n R
vi R
o o
t ihA C
t y
t N
i aW5 ln a
d 0
E n
9 O
c l
2 r r9 d
o i
u 2
e o1 d
S 4
t f u
e W
l l
e o
D A
A "s, h W
e x
B t
W
", m o s
d, i
d I
4 n
a 5 et o
n t n s
r e
E i
5 i
st n G
p NI i
L v e p
t d om l
A ne C
r a
I eet Pe R
i r
a c
F mr s
T ei s u r
a eo eq e
C R
Ccp h e 0
A a r TR m1 el B
d po m
U oe c o
n S
CRI e
C e
=
j I
)
S I
e d
s il t
S n
y g
e n
l m
t i
s t
t o
p sd M
o o n Me d
m e
A r
eA A
1 h
7 e
s 9
Tu tn 1
- s s s e
e m
c mI n
eo m
i t t o
S I
n l
C a
ai o 5
us g
5 dis n
im 0
v in 5
Y id m ia 5
no R
m o
I C
e t
n A
R og tne n
ed di M
.e mo eg C
v r te d
iU M
e nf lp eo ce e n m
ma R O U
o Ad C
n e
s S
he BI y
t d r
9d yt l
a n a
1 A
e Mm e
e N
hd mly t n s
s t
I e a not n
Bn eCe we di md o
u meq i
l t v
ui t e el od o ar a
E C pF Ri Wr r
i o
ece Ct s e mir t
Gi h a o n o it d
r
4 TNEMHCATTA 1
l I
i i
i I
FFATS EHT YB DESU SLAIRETAM NOITATNESERP l
l l
l l
it n:
i 7991,9 rebmetpeS,013.oN gniteeM RGRC fo setuniM
.. - -. -.. - - - -.. =.
.u.
m~r e
a ae c
de ta v
n i
i t
t e
c e
A M
s e
t r
d n
e e
t a
t r
m e
G er h
L c
i r
u 7
c a
q 9
n a
a e
9 r
l ir el R
1 a
B a
g e
l co c
9 e
s n
i e n uc r
r S
m e
e GoNr e
a n
b P
t e
m n
ys fh G
e h
S d
oC t
g w
p o
e t
s e
e J
n n
S a
i o
v i
l p
t e
P s
R o
e o
rP T
te y
e r
tt o
i t
m a
m r
o o
C ba L
I l
I
s dra r
d e
n t
s a
t n
t e
o m
S L
it w
e t
c e
t s
r s
n i
e s
e r
c n
o e
s o
y T
i iv S
n s
i i
h e
D tc s
r n
t u
G t
A i
e o
d n
c
'w n
f i
e d
s t
v a
s u
m e
o iD r
O m
o e
t t
e s
t r
s l
c e
e g
o r
f i
i F
l u
k b
k p
o F
o c
r f
q c
S r
a u
n e
a E
P B
P E
R B
e O
O O
9 O
e ii
.;: ! ie t
se c
s n
f re e
ot u
l q
gfi e
nl r iai s
t e
s n
soh o
ect t r m
c e c ah t
en ihi e
dcw ti t
id o
s et s
f o i
fi rhn y
oo et e pt i
t S
dd as na e
i n
a r rhs it u
n eg e
t n qr o o
eu c i
i it sb r sr nr t n e a
oo a e n r
s h
n l
t ad t o a l
t ia S
F ny Tsm i
t eb e a el s
t F
ot vpni pn amis S
e a
ed hamb E
hi ssr t c el og e c eaf n r
c a so eis u n ncpn r
e da c al e l
ef ihic Ro Lcwi l
9 9
i
}1 i
- ro
)
f d
s e
m u
e m
t n
s e
y i
t t
s S
n y
g S
o n
)
i n
S n
s C
o T
a n
t i
(
t G
e e
a l
s r
S C
n t
(
o m
l r
iF m
p iA m
e e
n t
t t
o s
n oc s
y e
g it y
a S
d n
F l
i S
S u
t i
c d
E c
n c
l r
e A
i n
c m
u g
i t
B n
o e
t s
g i
a R
o m
g n
n i
e i
i t
t r
P o
n d
a a
n T
i t
r o
l l
n i
d u
o r
e s
o R
n t
m a
y B
C a
l l
i n
G c
o n
r H
d s
F a
y t
i le a
t e
n e
l F
n b
e i
g o
u h
r o
d r
n e
C F
S A
S C
a m
E n
S E
t I
9 e
G
,i j
i!l j!i!:
L
s e
l t
o a
o t
l l
l t
u c
m a
l o
s9 a s ro i
o t
c e1 ret s
r sC or c t
e a
o f
na o
D daf r
h d
r ev c
s G
nca in P
o d
hie ays t
t 9
e th sca
,l 8
d t ut 2 tn nh s
9 a
n sgo eice r
e e
ent 1
cu g
mri mim T
3 e
d5 f
nf 0
d en e1 ie d
8 ga e a
s e
nc cf t ra 3
c ayx o ne e
Dl a
t y rrcer ol t
a o
cf b l
i a
Mo p
an st Tc e
er c yng d
Sr mioa r
ri n t
a o
eict f a ni u
Ah tf a doa s t
sf ra nie n c e
y e e s O
ae r
otar hh u
srpa eo cdc l
et h.
e a n h
t t i
l rf a
himc sri f
t eo f
t nou hgs i
h n
t ee t y niom w
t o
r ids i
oi s
n w
o s
s l
t gol b
nioa sid5 s
si l
da u
t r h
iat y Rt e1 m
ap e
ndnb W s, f r
s d
io t
e da r
a o st s
P Rf0 l
n c erct s
p gem rWo1 i
b ae i
eehi h
o nf t
h Ddtl FBio o
St T
r P
9 9
9 O
i.
i lI
.llj!;
!8
e e bsae s
l lieht n wl t uo ethi) t sr a si0 rl h
d5.
oat r "s
t t o nt t
an) or 2
e(dc a n
s r
t ed et P e
n pidt o cna nR m
a r e e
c c a F.
ed i
ma s pi C r
lp i
4 u
c p
ot eo c0 s
d 3
q a
o e
s r n salya1 n
D.
R i
r e age so l
o s og fit l
u y
t t a ea sA r
l t
c n I
a o
n a e n
vs i
bx c
dit l
r a
ei o
i ec e i
b rl ct abnd l
g P
a t
gg t c gn k
n b
nn aeionie i
dascep ht c
o a
t t i i t o a
dp aa r
it H
rr
)
a c
rt p
nrA ee 1(
d B
A m
pp ynlaef o
oo el do I
r eap M
o n9 utacr u1 l l T
R AA s uia l l aqolxenC s
l r
12 et cwD o
t odf uoG n
Taond(
o C
y t
i l
i b
e a
s c
o i
p lp r
p u
A P
~
4 g
jiijj;
- 1i ii
1 l
n-it oe i r n
d t
p u
a a
s r
ry da
)
G bt ew tii d
r-s ai un d
s l
a e
e e
t cm o
ei u
c en l
t u bs h
i n
u be dv N"
ame e
i l
t t
r ur l
f a pui n
o o ru o e et c
c s ql ch o
gr a
e o nT C
2 na cn r ai c
a i
3 th t r l
7 sC ndoa pd9
(
e un nh e8 d
8 Td d
d ni 1 a
c gs9 n
N et asid iv e
u ha hede sre I
t er c
t v 9nds e sb o
nt 7a n u t
i Gam r
c i
9raf 1 e
,o
&we g
sA c
k e
l s
3ot n G3e i
c c
0t no E 0D n
8rei 8
a e
3e t
B c
Dt ma d 3n eDi i
r e e Mmirb h
d if cme i
e l
D Taui aTu Sarqu t
eq tSs Apre AAs i l.
s
.i' t
l
! ;I.Il i
!i I
tse 9
t 8
t 9
s d
1 e
e t
t 3
a 0
d d
8 e
t t
u 3
a o
D d
t n
M u
a T
o o
o S
n t
t D
A a
t t
)
E s
s o
o e
e d
O t
t t
t e
N t
t t
t u
s s
a a
s h
e e
h h
n t
t t
t i
t t
n t
e w
y t
t i
e a
a S
S n
m t
v h
h T
T n
r t
t o
d e
u r
r n
S S
i i
C e
m S
T T
e e
h h
m d
la r
r t
t
(
n i
i A
e r
h h
t t
n e
e h
h d
S m
e t
t i
i w
w n
T A
n h
h t
u y
S C
w w
c c
I t
t e
e i
i o
c T
n n
r n
R e
t e
e a
a g
g n
N i
i c
c l
l r
e n
n p
p k
9 e
g a
a m8 m
c m
x i
i i
o9 o
l l
p p
c1 c
a E
E B
m m
n3 n
o o
i0 i
c c
t8 t
o3 o
n nl o nD nlo i
i t
t o tM s c s
s c s
t o n
nt nT nt a
ao aS ao l
l r
l l
r p
pp pA pp 1
2 3
4 p
p p
p u
u u
u o
o o
o r
r r
r G
G G
G i!
ji,
\\i
- li!
i!i1
r e
er e
t ce h
t r9 nh t
s t
e n e
o1 ei e
s o f
r e d
L eC e
icit i
f o v
ri c D s.
et o
ed c
nGs S
r xn i
r p
eo i
na t
rra oT r
a e
hueb nr d
o c shg n
t i
n t
l rsin oe r
a si n
t e
eaei d h o
dt a t
l hef s o
nr don Sd 9
cL e e G
t e
Tn 8
oG oi t c g
s v s c e e 9
t n r t
1 on e
oi sm i
i e
dr mt oa 3
pd an l
ri f
n r
fd s
a pi n h
0 it o
dt e
wd l
8 e e t
t s s u s
p n oer l
r a n su u
3 as e n s o D
nu ho e
u t
oc eh sodr e
r c ti T
P d
s M
e s t e t
i t
ee s
t T
r a9hh n9 i
ar l
h 8t t e8 S
ad hc e
t s t 9 hr c9 A
nn i
t s1t o
.l e
i1 ao sd l
ei e
i e3w0 t3 c
et et i
a n
F s0 0
h 8 e
om e
a0 n
s s
n 8 g1 t
n e3nt 3
r pr em la cDir sD f
of ce t
e o
ya e
e r
o M pP uM i
n c
i l
l r
pi r
l t
t c
rTmd qT r o r
eSon eS a
b efn l
l a
AAca RA Ae hC
)
)
)
1 2
3
(
(
(
d!
it i]j!;
- f
- !! ) ;!1 1i
98 f
4 9
o d
1 s
n 3
y na 0
a i3 8
d o
t 3
0 cs D
6 ep f
Su M
n i
o o
hr T
h t
s iG S
t i
n w
Ai w
a n
o n
r t
ti he iS o
s ss n s t t n
drT e e wr ue i
i i
t o
r er t
c e
s avi s e i
q e
is e e e
r u
drh s s c c r
f net ne n n t
c n
atay or a a n
s o
t l f cd dt e
s s
C gi
,d r p i
s nt n a oe m
D o
uia o
c c d
l t
l t a s c c n
t oss i
g uu d e
n a a e
n n
cgtl r
e r o iau c oi nS m
e d
nb ho s
,a d
i i
ft T
a m
a a
e dmt w d
yr ee S
i f
c e th T
a e
L i
e t
i d
st is u
n l
c s
gdl d oi et a
r n er e
s t
r o
gaba m Pn e
s d
t o nm t
o n
t i
e x 'e n e nc ee m r.
c i
f a
t c e e
n F
clee a r
g bv bt pst o mn a
ut i
lf ns f
e E
nme n ei sh sl a
e cw hs es ooch e
r o t
i eh ccl t e ol i
l l fl au st
)))
s no os sf 123 f
i
(((
c E ce eo r
e rr r
e eh a e de x ht h h da t
e t
o ct ad f
t l
ot ed e
l e
i c
hn h
w 6. e Ta Tth C B. b j
R l
u l
NVs O
9 j: :.
,iji!i
- l!
il:
loco to r
9 P
8 t
9 s
1 e
T 30 e
t 8
a 3D m
e M
t l
T A
S n
A A
tse to:
s t
o St n
Tla d o o
nc r e a i
mh t
AC c
y A
de tn 9
t e
8 m
o9 s
t 1 d
l n
a3 e
e o0 c8 m
r3 u
A ah D S
C M q
T tsT e_
o eS N
TA R
m" l
se o
Y N
989 1 -
30 e8 r
i3uqD eM R
T SS TA i\\
i.;!
t ii!
i l
s h
h r
e t
t i
i t
o h
f i
k w ew t
cns 0
r ain eh e
e 0
beo ct d
c 1
ri nt e
n e a a a a n t
t s e u
d ha r
r tl a
oh4 i
t l
a su r
i p
P dt f
3 k
reg oe g o D.
eee c cm d
c t
n a
t sr c no n
t i ti b
en a ec a
dnl l
ed e
n l
c n nd re a
m c
ie 9
o cia ift gm n
1 i
e a
na l
i r
l t
s et s aot C
eit r
i rmi p
l n ae oc s D
s ehl c
n n
t u re G
sma m
u g
r i
e av o sol o ).
ac P ci c
srC ham o
b n
a4 f
()
s huR che i
s rtd s
g
(
o t
gni s )a nN i
t iol i
D yeg hni e
idc r (9 e
n nit l
b e
s uA t0 w
m nl t
on s
t t1 i
dt t t e s e
e cI e
if e
s s
0 l
cnM c5 ot r
t yi e
k srx tds i
i i
,T rR i
c e a e e
u l
a u s sfft q
t sf eF sh eae e
nt o nC B
qei r
en e
t et s ren g0 e cw ss o e
r r e n eh s
umi
~ s1 o
if sn e eht o
cet ho ru t
n c
ct e
f d
ril
,s orn i
,o iuo en l
iaa eS e
eqs t
r o c
h hee oi ahp mTs:
T Trr f s i
l t r c
r ei l
eim oiu e rv h ho sesh e o t
hr hei Twc fI t re 1
2 Tp 9
9 9
- iI !
l llel
{;
j j)I fli!ll;
i i
M cch 30, 1999 William l> Travers The Committee endorsed the prnposed amendments subject to various comments and recommendations.
J. Segala and S. Newberry, both of NRR, presented for CRGR review and endorsement the j
proposed generic letter on laboratory testing of nuclear-grade activated charcoal. Attachment 4 contains the presentation material used by the staff. The Committee endorsed the proposed generic letter subject to various comments and recommendations.
As the meeting over-ran, Gus Lainas of NRR requested postponing to a later CRGR meeting the briefing on the scope and schedule of the steam generator regulatory framework. The Committee accepted the suggestion.
Questions concerning these meeting minutes should be referred to Raji Tripathi (415-7584).
Attachments: Ac stated cc: Commission (5)
SECY M. Knapp., DEDE F. Miraglia, DEDO J. Liebennan, OE M. Springer, ADM H. Bell, OlG K. Cyr, OGC J. Larkins, ACRS H. Miller, R-l L. Reyes, R-ll J. Dyer, R-fll E. Merschoff, R-IV C. Paperiello, NMSS A. Thadani, RES S. Collins, NRR D. Matthews, NRR S. Newberry, NRR j
Distribution:
File Center (w/atts.)
PDR (NRC/CRGR)
CRGR SF CRGR CF DDambly BSheron JJohneon, Rll MVirgilio MFederline JMitchell JJohnson, OCM Streby JStrosnider DMatthews JCraig JShapaker Qistribution via e-mail (w/o atts.)
GMizuno TBergman MMalloy EMcKenna KWichman RHermann REmch JLyons JSegata MRafky MSatorius DISK / DOCUMENT NAME: S:\\CRGR\\ MINUTES.310 Compiled by Garmon West based on CRGR records and the draft 1998 CRGR Annual Report to the Commission To r:ceive a copy of this document. indicate in the box: "C" = Copy w/o attachment. "E" = Copy w/ attachment. "N" = No copy j
OFC CRGR i
C C:QF @
C NAME RTripathi J
DATE 3b'99 3499
i i
i l
I March 30, 1999 William D. Travers The Committee endorsed the proposed amendments subjec* to various comments and recommendations.
J. Segala and S. Newberry, both of NRR, presented for CRGR review and endorsement the proposed generic letter on laboratory testing of nuclear-grade activated charcoal. Attachment 4 contains the presentation material used by the staff. The Committee endorsed the proposed j
generic letter subject to various comments and recommendations.
As the meeting over-ran, Gus Lainas of NRR requested postponing to a later CRGR meeting the briefing on the scope and schedule of the steam generator regulatory framework. The Committee accepted the suggestion.
1 Questions conceming these meeting minutes should be referred to Raji Tripathi (415-7584).
Attachments: As stated cc: Commission (5)
SECY j
M. Knapp, DEDE F. Miraglia, DEDO J. Lieberman, OE M. Springer, ADM H. Bell, OlG K. Cyr, OGC J. Larkins, ACRS H. Miller, R-l L. Reyes, R-ll J. Dyer, R-ill E. Merschoff, R-IV C. Paperiello, NMSS A. Thadani, RES S. Collins, NRR D. Matthews, NRR S. Newberry, NRR Distribution:
File Center (w/atts.)
PDR (NRC/CRGR)
CRGR SF CRGR CF DDambly BSheron JJohnson, Rll MVirgilio MFederline JMitchell JJohnson, OCM Streby JStrosnider DMatthews JCraig JShapaker Distribution via e-mail (w/o atts.)
GMizuno TBergman MMalloy EMcKenna KWichman RHermann REmch JLyons JSegala MRafky MSatorius DISK / DOCUMENT NAME: S:\\CRGR\\ MINUTES.310 Compiled by Garmon West based on CRGR records and the draft 1998 CRGR Anrual Report to the Commission To recdve a copy of this document. indicate in the box: "C" = Copy w/o attachment. "E" = Copy w/ attachment. "N" = No copy OFC CRGR i
C C:QF 98 C
NAME RTripathi J
DATE 3#99 3hh9
_