NUREG-1022, Summary of 930506 Public Meeting Re Draft NUREG-1022,Rev 1 Re Event Reporting Sys.W/O Stated Encl
| ML20045J037 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 05/20/1993 |
| From: | Baranowsky P NRC OFFICE FOR ANALYSIS & EVALUATION OF OPERATIONAL DATA (AEOD) |
| To: | Holahan G NRC OFFICE FOR ANALYSIS & EVALUATION OF OPERATIONAL DATA (AEOD) |
| References | |
| RTR-NUREG-1022 NUDOCS 9307220334 | |
| Download: ML20045J037 (2) | |
Text
brNazac r
m+1 "x, m, O
wp i
' UNITED STATES -
W' o
8 1
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSI WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 y,
,E
'[
A,
,f.
E O 1993 MEMORANDUM FOR:
Gary M. Holahan, Director Division of Safety Programs, AE00 Patrick W. Baranowsky, Chief FROM:
Trends and Patterns Analysis Branch Division of Safety Programs, AE00 t
SUMMARY
OF PUBLIC MEETING ON THE ISSUES RAISED BY PU
SUBJECT:
COMMENT ON DRAFT NUREG-1022, REVISION 1 On May 6, 1993, a public meeting was held to discuss issues raised by public comments on draft NUREG-1022, Revision 1 " Event Reporting Systems - 10 CFR Clarification of NRC Systems and Guidelines for Reporting."
50.72 and 50.73:
Over 60 people attended the meeting, including representatives of AEOD, NRR, A
NUMARC, NUBARG, the BWROG, and several utilities and utility consultants.
-r list of attendees is provided in Enclosure 1.
The draft report, NUREG-1022, Revision 1, was noticed for public comment on The. issues raised by public comments were discussed October 7, 1991.
previously at a meeting on May 7,1992, and a consensus was reached for a At the recent meeting of May 6,1993, those discussions number of issues.
were continued.
The agenda for the meeting, which was published in the _ Federal Reoister on April 8,1993, included a fairly detailed description of the current staff positions with respect to the issues. A copy is provided in Enclosure 2.
A copy of the transcript is A verbatim transcript of the meeting was made.
provided in Enclosure 3.
Highlights of the discussion include the following:
As a result of work during the past year, it appeared that many of the 1..
However, industry representatives remaining issues had been resolved.
still expressed some substantial disagreements with the staff's proposals in the following areas:
The staff proposed Engineered Safety Features (ESF) actuations.
to request that licensees voluntarily report the actuation of a.
specific named systems, such as diesel generators and auxiliary feedwater systems, in those cases where a particular licensee has Industry not identified a particular system as an ESF.
representatives generally object to including voluntary reports'in the guidance document because they believe it will lead to The staff steadfastly ratcheting or pressure for implementation.
) 0:
believes the provision for voluntary reporting is appropriate and will examine guidance on implementation to maintain the voluntary status.
9307220334 930520 00f (f i
.f' ~i 22 ?
PDR'
.. c $h } t ih 7 7)-
1 y
o.
5 Of O
w w
Gary M. Holahan b.
Outside design basis. The staff proposes to consider a plant outside of its design basis when one train of a two train system is unable to perform its safety function for an extended period of time.
In response to industry comments, the staff will clarify the discussion, to indicate that this does not include cases of
" technical inoperability" such as missed surveillances and it does not include relatively short periods of time.
2.
The AE00 staff now plans to redraft the report, obtain office concurrence, and reissue the report for public comment.
(The need for this second public comment period was one of the industry representatives' primary points.)
Following the public comment period, which is expected to be brief, CRGR review and ACRS comments will be sought and the report will be issued in final form.
/5/
Patrick W. Baranowsky, Chief Trends and Patterns Analysis Branch Division of Safety Programs, AE00
Enclosures:
1.
List of Attendees at Meeting 2.
Federal Register Notice of Meeting 3.
1ranscript of meeting Distribution: w/ enclosures TPAB R/F PDR'
. Central File A. Chaffee, NRR M. Taylor, EDO G. Mizuno, OGC M. Schwartz, 0GC w/o enclosures EJordan JRosenthal WJones Dross LSpessard Sisrael PBaranowsky JMacKinnon KBrockman MHarper JGiiter RDenning, NRR RTripathi DAllison DSkeen, NRR BGrimes, NRR STreby RSpence EWeiss, NRR MPadavan JBeeson, ADM JBoardman DGable, ADM H:Pubmtgme g//
AE00 C:TPAB DAllison PBaranotsky 6 / 0/93sr g/g9a 3