Text

02-Post Examination Comments
	ML25077A013
Person / Time
Site:	Waterford
Issue date:	02/19/2025
From:	Heather Gepford; NRC/RGN-IV/DORS/OB
To:	; Entergy Operations
References
	Download: ML25077A013 (1)
	v • d • e

Question #

SRO Only Answer Cog Level RO Avg SRO Ovr Avg SRO only Avg Fund. Avg RO 92.00%

86.67%

92.00%

85.33%

90.67%

86.67%

85.33%

92.00%

84.00%

90.67%

84.00%

86.67%

93.33%

MISSED 89.00%

86.10%

81.20%

92.86%

SRO 72.00%

88.00%

76.00%

92.00%

68.00%

92.00%

76.00%

84.00%

80.00%

OVR 86.00%

87.00%

83.00%

92.00%

80.00%

91.00%

82.00%

84.00%

86.00%

90.00%

GFES 100.00%

100.00%

83.33%

100.00%

83.33%

100.00%

83.33%

100.00%

1 0

D D

0 B

1 D

0 D

0 C

1 D

0 D

0 14.3%

2 0

C C

0 C

0 0.0%

3 0

B B

0 B

0 D

1 D

1 B

0 B

0 14.3%

4 0

A A

0 A

0 0.0%

5 0

C C

0 C

0 0.0%

6 0

D D

0 D

0 A

1 D

0 D

0 7.1%

7 0

A A

0 A

0 0.0%

8 0

B B

0 B

0 C

1 B

0 B

0 7.1%

9 0

D D

0 D

0 0.0%

10 0

D D

0 D

0 B

1 D

0 D

0 7.1%

11 0

C C

0 D

1 D

1 C

0 C

0 D

1 D

1 C

0 D

1 D

1 C

0 50.0%

12 0

D D

0 D

0 B

1 D

0 D

0 B

1 D

0 D

0 B

1 D

0 D

0 21.4%

13 0

C C

0 C

0 0.0%

14 0

A A

0 A

0 0.0%

15 0

A A

0 A

0 0.0%

16 0

B B

0 B

0 0.0%

17 0

A A

0 A

0 C

1 A

0 A

0 D

1 A

0 A

0 14.3%

18 0

D D

0 D

0 0.0%

19 0

D D

0 D

0 B

1 D

0 D

0 7.1%

20 0

B B

0 B

0 0.0%

21 0

C A

1 C

0 C

0 7.1%

22 0

A A

0 A

0 B

1 C

1 A

0 C

1 A

0 B

1 A

0 A

0 B

1 B

1 A

0 50.0%

23 0

A A

0 A

0 0.0%

24 0

A A

0 A

0 0.0%

25 0

B B

0 B

0 C

1 B

0 B

0 7.1%

26 0

C C

0 C

0 B

1 C

0 C

0 7.1%

27 0

C C

0 C

0 A

1 C

0 C

0 D

1 D

1 C

0 21.4%

28 0

C C

0 C

0 0.0%

29 0

D D

0 D

0 0.0%

30 0

B B

0 B

0 0.0%

31 0

B B

0 B

0 C

1 B

0 B

0 7.1%

32 0

D D

0 D

0 0.0%

33 0

B B

0 B

0 0.0%

34 0

A A

0 A

0 B

1 A

0 7.1%

35 0

D D

0 D

0 0.0%

36 0

D D

0 D

0 B

1 D

0 D

0 B

1 B

1 D

0 D

0 B

1 28.6%

37 0

D D

0 D

0 C

1 D

0 D

0 C

1 D

0 B

1 D

0 21.4%

38 0

B B

0 B

0 0.0%

39 0

C C

0 B

1 C

0 C

0 A

1 C

0 C

0 B

1 B

1 C

0 28.6%

40 0

B B

0 B

0 0.0%

41 0

A A

0 A

0 C

1 A

0 C

1 A

0 A

0 14.3%

42 0

D D

0 C

1 D

0 D

0 C

1 D

0 B

1 C

1 D

0 D

0 C

1 C

1 D

0 C

1 50.0%

43 0

B B

0 B

0 0.0%

44 0

C C

0 C

0 0.0%

45 0

A A

0 A

0 C

1 A

0 A

0 B

1 A

0 14.3%

46 0

C C

0 C

0 0.0%

47 0

A A

0 A

0 0.0%

48 0

B B

0 B

0 0.0%

49 0

D D

0 D

0 B

1 D

0 D

0 B

1 D

0 D

0 14.3%

50 0

D D

0 D

0 0.0%

51 0

C C

0 C

0 D

1 C

0 C

0 7.1%

52 0

D D

0 D

0 0.0%

53 0

B C

1 B

0 B

0 C

1 B

0 14.3%

54 0

B B

0 B

0 A

1 A

1 B

0 B

0 14.3%

55 0

B A

1 C

1 B

0 A

1 A

1 C

1 B

0 B

0 A

1 B

0 D

1 D

1 C

1 A

1 71.4%

56 0

C C

0 C

0 0.0%

57 0

C C

0 C

0 D

1 C

0 C

0 7.1%

58 0

A A

0 D

1 A

0 D

1 A

0 A

0 D

1 A

0 A

0 D

1 B

1 A

0 A

0 42.9%

59 0

D B

1 D

0 D

0 B

1 D

0 D

0 C

1 D

0 A

1 D

0 D

0 28.6%

60 0

B B

0 A

1 B

0 D

1 A

1 B

0 A

1 A

1 B

0 A

1 71.4%

61 0

A A

0 A

0 C

1 A

0 A

0 7.1%

62 0

A A

0 A

0 B

1 A

0 A

0 7.1%

63 0

C C

0 C

0 D

1 C

0 C

0 7.1%

64 0

A A

0 A

0 D

1 A

0 A

0 7.1%

65 0

B B

0 B

0 D

1 7.1%

66 0

D D

0 D

0 B

1 D

0 B

1 D

0 B

1 D

0 D

0 21.4%

67 0

C A

1 D

1 C

0 D

1 C

0 D

1 C

0 D

1 B

1 D

1 C

0 C

0 64.3%

68 0

C C

0 A

1 C

0 C

0 A

1 D

1 C

0 C

0 21.4%

69 0

D B

1 B

1 C

1 D

0 D

0 28.6%

70 0

A A

0 A

0 0.0%

71 0

A A

0 A

0 C

1 C

1 A

0 A

0 C

1 B

1 A

0 C

1 A

0 A

0 35.7%

72 0

C C

0 C

0 0.0%

73 0

B B

0 B

0 0.0%

74 0

C C

0 C

0 D

1 C

0 7.1%

75 0

A A

0 A

0 0.0%

76 1

A 1

1 1

A 0

C 1

A 0

B 1

C 1

A 0

30.0%

77 1

B 1

1 1

B 0

0.0%

78 1

A 1

1 1

A 0

0.0%

79 1

C 1

1 1

C 0

0.0%

80 1

D 1

1 1

C 1

D 0

10.0%

81 1

A 1

1 1

A 0

0.0%

82 1

C 1

1 1

C 0

0.0%

83 1

A 1

1 1

A 0

B 1

A 0

B 1

A 0

B 1

70.0%

84 1

B 1

1 1

B 0

0.0%

85 1

D 1

1 1

D 0

B 1

D 0

10.0%

86 1

A 1

1 1

B 1

A 0

B 1

A 0

C 1

A 0

C 1

50.0%

87 1

B 1

1 1

B 0

0.0%

88 1

C 1

1 1

C 0

D 1

B 1

D 1

C 0

30.0%

89 1

D 1

1 1

D 0

A 1

D 0

10.0%

90 1

D 1

1 1

C 1

B 1

D 0

C 1

D 0

C 1

D 0

50.0%

91 1

C 1

1 1

A 1

C 0

D 1

C 0

A 1

C 0

30.0%

92 1

B 1

1 1

B 0

0.0%

93 1

B 1

1 1

B 0

C 1

B 0

10.0%

94 1

D 1

1 1

B 1

D 0

B 1

D 0

A 1

30.0%

95 1

B 1

1 1

B 0

0.0%

96 1

D 1

1 1

D 0

C 1

D 0

10.0%

97 1

C 1

1 1

A 1

B 1

A 1

C 0

B 1

C 0

B 1

70.0%

98 1

D 1

1 1

D 0

B 1

D 0

B 1

D 0

B 1

D 0

40.0%

99 1

C 1

1 1

A 1

C 0

A 1

20.0%

100 1

C 1

1 1

C 0

0.0%

25 Misse OVR 69 OVR 65 OVR 69 OVR 64 OVR 86 OVR 87 OVR 83 OVR 92 OVR 80 OVR 91 OVR 82 OVR 84 OVR 86 OVR 90 RO 68 RO 65 RO 64 RO 69 RO 63 RO 68 RO 63 RO 63 RO 65 RO 70 SRO 18 SRO 22 SRO 19 SRO 23 SRO 17 SRO 23 SRO 19 SRO 21 SRO 21 SRO 20

Exam

Title:

NRC Written Examination Exam ID# 2025 NRC Written Examination Date Evaluation Instrument Administered: 2/19/2025 Number of Trainees Evaluated: 14 c...... +ion A - Any question receiving greater than 50% failure rate N/A List each question receivinq qreater than 50% failure rate.

Question Review QueStion Failure Conclusion ID Number Rate (%)

RO 55 71.4%

G RO60 71.4%

G RO67 64.3%

G SR08 70%

D Corrective Action The system description (SD-CED) states Lower Electrical limit uses the RSPTs on page 12. The color of the CEA position light at CP-2 is covered in the SD on page 22. Answer B is correct. No changes are required to the question.

OP-901-401 Step C.1 states either CROAI causes the automatic action. Step 8.3 and its sub-steps state that positive pressure is obtained via manual valve operation. No changes are required.

Section 5.2 of OP-100-010 states that Attachment 7.1 shall be used for declaring systems inoperable.

Additionally, there is a note stating that a shift update should only be used when declaring equipment operable within the same shift, otherwise it would require a brief with appropriate personnel.

No chanqes are required.

The use of the word "only" after isolating the PMU ignores the requirement of T.S. 4.0.1 which states "Failure to meet a Surveillance... shall be failure to meet the LCO."

To clearly document the minimum actions need to meet the LCO answer A should have discussed the requirement to be in compliance and periodicity of the appropriate surveillances.

Action 3.1.2.9.b has 2 required surveillances, 4.1.2.9.3 and 4.1.2.9.4. Surveillance 4.1.2.9.3 defines that isolating the primary makeup flow path means "verified to be isolated by either locked closed manual valve, deactivated automatic valves secured in the isolation position, or by power being removed from all charging pumps, at least once per 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br />."

Due to the use of "only" and the lack of wording to be in compliance with the required Surveillances, there is no correct answer for this question.

Enterqv Nuclear Pace 1 of 2 E-DOC TITLE:

E-DOC NO.

I TQF-201-EV02 REV#

Post Exam Analysis DRR-HQN-2024-00782 05

SRO 22 170%

IG I

This is the exact example in the T.S. Bases, no action required.

Review Conclusion A. Insufficient training for the learning objective tested B. Learning objectives not adequately covered in the lesson plan C. Poorly worded or invalid learning objective D. Poorly worded or invalid test item or answer E. Incorrect answer in the exam key F. More than one correct answer G. Question acceptable H. Other (state reason in table or on additional sheet)

Section B - Greater than 25% overall exam failure N/A Conclusion Summary Corrective Action SRO 8 has no correct answer.

Remove SRO 8 from the exam and regrade All other high miss questions are acceptable.

the exam.

Review performed by:

Date:

Approved by:

Date:

Retention:

) entergy NUCLEAR Page 2 of 2 E-DOC TITLE:

POST EXAMINATION ANALYSIS I

E-DOC NO.

I REV#

TQF-201-EV02 03 I

ML25077A013

Text

Title:

Navigation menu

Search