ML23348A193

SECY-89-208: Interim Report - Draft Criteria for Package Drop and Aircraft Crash Tests for Plutonium Air Transport (PAT) Packages

ML23348A193
Person / Time
Issue date:	07/12/1989
From:	NRC/SECY
To:
Shared Package
ML23348A192	List: ML23348A193 ML23348A194
References
SECY-89-208
Download: ML23348A193 (3)

Text

.;.,,,

, l( I

\\ '

- _ _sj: I..

I

July 12, 1989 POLICY ISSUE (NEGATIVE CONSENT) SECY-89-208 For: The C011111issioners From: Victor Stello, Jr.

Executive Director for Operations

Subject:

AIRCRAFT CRASH TESTS FOR PLUTONIUM AIR TRANSPORT (PAT) INTERIM REPORT - DRAFT CRITERIA FOR PACKAGE DROP AND PACKAGES

Purpose:

To inform the C0111J1ission of the staff's intent to forward the Interim Report to the Power Reactor and Nuclear Fuel Development Corporation (PNC} of Japan.

Background:

Section 5062 of Public Law 100-203 (Murkowski Amendment}

requires testing of containers used to transport plutonium by aircraft from a foreign nation to another through U.S.

- tainers are safe. The Connis~fon was previously infon,ed airspace, and NRC certification to Congress that the con-of the staff's interpretation of the requirements of Section 5062 (SECY-88-302 dated October 25, 1988). The C011111ission was also infonned of the Agreement between the Nuclear Regulatory C0111111ssion (NRC) and PNC establishing a Afr Transport Packages (SECY-88-329 dated December 1, _ Testing and Adlllinistrative Program for Certifying Plutonium 1988). The ProgrilRl is funded by PNC in accordance with the Allendment. The COll'Dlission was also asked to approve Airlines (PSA} Flight 1771 as representing a worst actual staff's selection of the crash of Pacific Southwest aircraft accident for purposes of determinin~ "worst case" testing conditions required by Section 5062 (SECY-88-344 dated December 15, 1988}. On May 15, 1989, the Corranission was briefed on the status of Phase One of the Testing and Administrative Progru.

CONTACT:

John R. Cook, NMSS 49-20458 The Coounissioners 2

In the subject Interim Report (Enclosure 1), the contractor, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL),

sWTJRarizes the effort to date on Phase One, including a description of its investigation of the impact conditions experienced by PSA Flight 1771, and proposed criteria for package drop and aircraft crash tests. PNC requested that an interim report on draft package testing criteria be forwarded at this time to aid PNC in the selection of a shipment mode and in budget preparation related to the retransfer of plutonium from Europe to Japan. PNC also requested cost and schedule estimates for continuation of the Testing and Administrative Program (Enclosure 2).

Discuss ion: The Interim Report identifies aircraft impact angle, velocity, and*the hardness of the ground surface as the basic crash severity components.

• Based on the fl 1 ght data accounts, the contractor detennined that the PSA Flight recorder, ground radar-tracking data and eyewitness 1771 impact angle with respect to ground surface was 60° for the center of mass trajectory, and the velocity at impact was 630 mph. The contractor characterized the crash site surface hardness by conducting in-situ measurements and drilling core samples to determine surface geology, penetrability and other standard geological parameters.

The Interim Report draft package drop criteria are speci fied basically in terms of a cargo aircraft's maximwn cruising altitude and the corresponding package impact equivalent to or harder than the PSA crash site. The airvelocity at sea-level, with hardness of the impact area minimum 60° aircraft impact angle, and 630 mph impact craft impact-condition test criteria are specified as a velocity with the same impact area hardness criterion as for the test aircraft, package loading arrangement, test that for the drop test. The report also specifies criteria measurements, etc. The draft acceptance criteria for the range, remote control and flight-tennination systems, drop and aircraft crash tests are the same as those for Type B packages meeting hypothetical accident conditions, and are specified in 10 CFR 71 and in NRC's existing criteria for certification of plutonium air transport packages (NUREG-0360).

1

• The COIJl]1issioners 3

Conclusion:

Staff believes the draft test criteria are sufficiently developed at this time for purposes of discussion with PNC.

Scheduling: July 14, 1989, and that staff meet at PNC headquarters the PNC has requested that this report be forwarded to PNC on week of July 31, 1989 for technical discussions on the report. The final report for Phase One activities is scheduled for completion by September 30, 1990.

Coordination: This paper has been coordinated with the Office of the General Counsel, and it has no legal objection.

Reconmendation: As specified in the NRC/PNC Agreement Schedule, the staff intends to provide PNC with a copy of the Interim Report and cost/schedule estimates for continuation of the Program on July 14, 1989, unless the Connnission directs otherwise.

~r 1Executive Director !t~r;;g for Operations

Enclosures:

(Commissioners, SECY and OGC only) 1. Draft Criteria* for Package Drop and Aircraft Crash Tests - An Interim Report

2. Cost and Schedule Estimates for NRC Activities Phases II, III and IV

SECY NOTE: In the absence of instructions to the contrary, SECY will notify the staff on Friday, July 14,

1989, that the Commission, by negative consent, assents to the action proposed in this paper.

DISTRIBUTION:

Commissioners OGC OIG GPA EDO ACRS SECY