ML23226A234

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Post Exam Comments and Analysis with Letter
ML23226A234
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak  
Issue date: 06/22/2023
From: Heather Gepford
NRC/RGN-IV/DORS/OB
To: Sewell S
Luminant, Vistra Operations Company
References
CP-202300330, TXX-23050
Download: ML23226A234 (1)
v • d • e


Text

{{#Wiki_filter:Lumi ant CP-202300330 TXX-23050 July 12, 2023 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Regional Administrator, Region IV 1600 East Lamar Boulevard Arlington, Texas 76011-4511 ATTN: Kelly Clayton Steven K. Sewell Site Vice President

Subject:

Comanche Peak Nuclear Power Plant (CPNPP) Docket Nos. 50-445 and 50-446 Transmittal of Licensed Operator Examination Materials Ref Comanche Peak Nuclear Power Plant (Vlstra Operations Company LLC) P.O. Box 1002 6322 North FM 56 Glen Rose, TX 76043 T 254.897.6113 10 CFR 55.5(b)(2) 10 CFR 55.40(a)

Reference:

NUREG-1021, Revision 12, OL Examination Standards for Power Reactors

Dear Mr. Clayton:

Enclosed please find the attached 2023 Licensed Operator Post Examination Package, Written, per NUREG-1021 Rev 12 ES-4.4-7 for the initial operator licensing written examinations administered on June 22, 2023 at Comanche Peak Nuclear Power Plant (CPNPP) for LC29. These examinations were graded and are submitted based on guidance in the Reference, with concurrence of training supervision. CPNPP requests that the written examinations and operating tests be withheld from public disclosure for the allowed two-year period. This communication contains no new licensing basis commitments regarding Comanche Peak Units 1 and 2. If there are any questions concerning this submittal, contact Mr. Kevin Hegarty at (254) 897-5120 (office), , or at kevin.hegarty@vistracorp.com.

TXX-22050 Page 2 of 2 Sincerely,

Enclosure:

2023 Licensed Operator Post Examination Package, Written c (email) - Heather Gepford, Region IV {Heather.Gepford@nrc.gov] CLO Kelly Clayton, Region IV [Kelly.Clayton@NRC.gov] CLO Natalia Salazar, Region IV [Natalia.Salazar@nrc.gov] CLO Dennis Galvin, NRR [Dennis.Galvin@mc.gov] CLO John Ellegood, Senior Resident Inspector, CPNPP Uohn.Ellegood@nrc.gov] CLO

WRITTEN EXAM ADMINISTRATION SHEET ,Exam Title Date Administered (s(l;o) t.c-z.q ._J /l,C.. (,i\\1..- i I-It-.- ~)!~.,.,... t,/-i,?,,. /,z. $ Name of Requestor Test Question # I -, I Time of Question c,~~, Instructions: Write questions as clearly as possible and provide them to the Proctor. The Proctor will evaluate the examinee's questions, develop an appropriate response, contact the NRC Chief Examiner, as applicable, and then provide the examinee with a written response. The examinee should keep any completed forms with the exam. Examinee's Question: __,_fZ_e._.~..... '-14_~_+-_..11,f_;_}_l_-c.._k __ S_o_p._,_'2-0 _ ?_A-__ Sc_ c._-l-_~_..... __ s_._'-l_. _/ __ Time of response: D 'b3 ) Provided to: g Requesting examinee ONLY All remaining examinees Rez:::rr,o,~ided: S~c.}'-o-S-.4, I..f~+l-c. ~s ,. 12.a.;s;--, Acev...... ul.Jo-INFORMATiON USE TRl-206.01-4 Page 1 of 2 Revision 1

WRITTEN EXAM ADMINISTRATION SHEET Exam Title Date Administered r 'C~.-" [SM) --~ , ~ 2-7, li:r Name of ~eque~tor Test Question # Time of Question Instructions: Write questions as clearly as possible and provide them to the Proctor. The Proctor will evaluate the examinee's questions, develop an appropriate response, contact the NRC Chief Examiner, as applicable, and then provide the examinee with a written response. The examinee should keep any completed forms with the exam. Time of response: __ O_CZ._S-_7______ Provided to: '6 Requesting examinee ONLY INFORMATION USE r,h.,,h, D All remaining examinees 4r"C. TRl-206.01-4 Page 1 of 2 Revision 1

WRITTEN EXAM ADMINISTRATION SHEET Exam Title Date Administered L...c:z.ct f'.J/L,C l/'.lr\\~~ t,JC.G.- 1~ ) (p fl 'Z- /-z, '3 Name of Requestor Test Question# I lt:r I Time of Question 0,01 Instructions:

  • Write questions as clearly as possible and provide them to the Proctor.
  • The Proctor will evaluate the examinee's questions, develop an appropriate response, contact the NRC Chief Examiner, as applicable, and then provide the examinee with a written response.
  • The examinee should keep any completed forms with the exam.

Examinee's Question: v0"'-t- : ~-k--e. +:rt!\\~~-~ o- ~<.d,-¥-A s? Time of response: Crj/0 Provided to: 8l Requesting examinee ONL y A-s.SVN\\.c.,. ll '-f c;n.~h.s D All remaining examinees R,t!ponse provided: "'"'C °'"' --k,.... c. s~ W'\\' -I-~ fNt-<- rc;clN'--C.* J ' TRl-206.01-4 INFORMATION USE Page 1 of 2 Revision 1

WRITTEN EXAM ADMINISTRATION SHEET Exam Title Date Administered Na,m,~ of Reqye_st_o_r ______________

"1 Test Question# -t,f-Time of Question Instructions:

Write questions as clearly as possible and provide them to the Proctor. The Proctor will evaluate the examinee's questions, develop an appropriate response, contact the NRC Chief Examiner. as applicable, and then provide the examinee with a written response. The examinee should keep any completed forms with the exam. Time of response:._---'-\\ C>_ ~_ f______ Provided to: g Requesting examinee ONL y ("' 1 ('. I

  • D All remaining examinees Response provided: __:..r-'

_ o-_ ~ ;..__r_ ~ __ r-_,_.... _h_ ~ __ ~ __ -=CA

.....:..:."'-_ l:ie

=::_4rc..!:~~~J~ecl~..:...* ---- INFORMATION USE TRl-206.01-4 Page 1 of 2 Revision 1

WRtTTEN EXAM ADMINISTRATION SHEET Exam Title Date Administered (rlz~ /1;'!> Le --z._1 t->(LC. v,:>r-, ~- eX4~ l C,{'LA> ) Name of Requestor T~t Question:# I Lt1

  • l Time of Question Jo l'S" Instructions:

Write questions as clearly as possible and provide them to the Proctor. The Proctor will evaluate the examinee's questions, develop an appropriate response, contact the NRC Chief Examiner, as applicable, and then provide the examinee with a written response. The examinee should keep any completed forms with the exam. Time of response:, ___ / c:>_ -Z._'"L-_____ _ Provided to: _g Requesting examinee ONLY + D All remaining examinees i ' cc l "I t I

  • L l

d cc> ~~ 1P < <.o~'t'ar.,,,_.,,._,....... ~'Cl Response provide : ------------F~--=---------.-1-------------------- INFORMATION USE TRl-206.01-4 Page 1 of 2 Revision 1

WRITTEN EXAM ADMINISTRATION SHEET Exam Title Date Administered Lt. z.~ N a.c. v.) r- ~ !\\--c.- F-Leivv" r~ ) , /1.-,, Iv Name of Requestor Test Question # I s-, I

  • Time of Question to 1g Instructions:

Write questions as clearly as possible and provide them to the Proctor. The Proctor will evaluate the examinee's questions, develop an appropriate response, contact the NRC Chief Examiner, as applicable, and then provide the examinee with a written response. The examinee should keep any completed forms with the exam. Examinee's Question: _ fl'J _ N. _ f __ A_~ __ ~ hA _ ~ __ J_ ~ __ A_ l-k _ e_h_~_ -- _ 1-s __ , ___:_f _z_ ~? __ Time of response: / O Zo Provided to: l5-Requesting examinee ONLY All remaining examinees ReSP.O se provided: fV* £.,.~,., ;""',..._,._ft_ c..c-kc.,:-1f!'- ti? a/-.,..~f;., Ae ,-,,c,,,,--.f,,,..,,,._e.$ INFORMATION USE TRl-206.01-4 Page 1 of 2 Revision 1

WRITTEN EXAM ADMINISTRATION SHEET Exam Title Date Administered lcz.q fJ'tLC v.),-\\~- ~x~w, (-;~ ) ~ /7,. 1,/7,, ~ Name of Requestor Test Question # I f..f 4:\\ I Time of Question // 'Z-,0 Instructions: Write questions as clearly as possible and provide them to the Proctor. The Proctor will evaluate the examinee's questions, develop an appropriate response, contact the NRC Chief Examiner, as applicable, and then provide the examinee with a written response. The examinee should keep any completed forms with the exam. Time of response:. ___ /_/ _'3_0 _____ _ Provided to: 'S Requesting examinee ONLY D All remaining examinees Response provided: __:,.~_c._-...;.Ci_W u-..1_-i_~ e_"""--+r -M_S_to;_._,,..._~....;_~_r-s.:........:..._}-----ipi-!"'=----'-,:___.:....C:!....,_s:,_4..:..:e::....:""'~*'--- INFORMATION USE TRl-206.01-4 Page 1 of 2 Revision 1

WRITTEN EXAM ADMINISTRATION SHEET. Exam Title Date Administered - Let-~ fv/'IL ~,;t.lt,r- £~"" { S:.-io) 1e I "l, ?, /7., 3 Name of Recjuestor Test Question # I f>O I Time of Question /15"3 Instructions: Write questions as clearly as possible and provide them to the Proctor. The Proctor will evaluate the examinee's questions, develop an appropriate response, contact the NRC Chief Examiner, as applicable, and then provide the examinee with a written response. The examinee should keep any completed forms with the exam. 'j'-..,. (f ~.. Examinee's Question: J,.,b'C s Col.V' ):,...,..+-, b{.e, MeC4...-. Time of response:. _ _.:.,/ _'l._0_0 _______ Response provided: E:'"~ I, ; ~ { ~ +-~" INFORMATION USE Provided to: S Requesting examinee ONLY D All remaining examinees

$ ~vo.i /~ ble -lo. °"s..,....-r ~-< 'I,u;,.f:~,..,.

TRl-206.01-4 Page 1 of 2 Revision 1

WRITTEN EXAM ADMINISTRATION SHEET Exam Title Date Administered Name of Requestor Test Question# Time of Question Instructions: Write questions as clearly as possible and provide them to the Proctor. The Proctor will evaluate the examinee's questions, develop an appropriate response, contact the NRC Chief Examiner, as applicable, and then provide the examinee with a written response. The examinee should keep any completed forms with the exam. Time of response: __ /_'t.._i,._l..... ______ Provided to: S Requesting examinee ONL y Response provided: C kc rt A-e.J -h,,. : ' 9'r-cf-D All remaining examinees 's 'i~ f f "-,_,. /.. .C e°.T C <;Je f,t-,-w. ;~ +-,....:_ INFORMATION USE TRl*206.01-4 Page 1 of 2 Revision 1

WRITTEN EXAM ADMINISTRATION SHEET Proctor Name: 6.J,r-1 f;::G,A,i..-r: Exam: Lt*z..q tJ(l.,C., 6'.Jri.Hc~ A,._ Date: t,/1..1./-,,3 NRC Time Question# Question Called Proctor Response/NRG YES NO

Response

~I fe1"'"$.,,._.f- ~.,_l-c..f' 5oP-?ot.A St c '-- s-.'(. ) -f;.U-c. 11, fC/1. I I St:e.\\--,.,... s-. Lf., ~ ""'"'"') D ,-k..,_.i,.,J..r level Arc.~ ~r.:rr...,_.s """'-.-~\\,,..;:', ry-6':, I *, I- ;, ** -r l,a\\ 0\\9 1~ s~o- '... '"\\) ~--.. ~ "5 "L "lf"" * ~ ~1-r._'-s~ D M4't~-k.... 1:1:a=-~ I '"' -""'1:- "' 'l -i.,,... ...,a..,._U-f. L... ,~-:,. {IJ/vc f ; j -1,,,,,e, -i il'l'\\C.. f-r.. M< o.-. Asso-.. ~ 11' 'I J-f'!_'? fr!t/6 I °' ~ 5""(>,c; ? ~ 't r'"C O'l -{,,.,e_ "f4""1C -1:-*-~ -r,."'_C, - 5"' l t 'f2et.,e~./- /Lc:t'"1e

  • F 1~e.~,..._ /.

fJ o f-'!'.... --1,,.e r O'f5o

    • .,. f;,..__~ ~ &,\\ C*.-,

fo '1 c; I-I QC J.,....,,_ tt ~ D be ('°":JcJ. l(q ~ta :eJ,.. ten -k. ;~""+ ('~ ~&;,+~,;,,, ~~fed It"'" I '-ii~ 10I~ .....,."' ~ 1-o,s arc. ei.l(A...-:"'":)? s D co-,~:,.,..,,.,..._+ {Ar -s. (l,Jfv,../- e,.rt!.. -h,..c '1.Afvft:'3 ~ /,lo.C+.,.,-- ;,.~ 1013 SI 'f-#-4.C~~ I: 'Z-s D c-~ .. :~J ' Instructions: Make multiple copies of !he first page, as needed, for questions during exam. For all questions, document on Page 2 the receipt of any questions, the question #, and whether or not the NRC was called. !Ea question Is.liQ! documented on page 1, I!::ffil:l document both the question, response provided and the NRC comments on thi:. form. INFORMATION USE TRl-206.01-4 Page 2 of 2 Revision 1

XAM ADMINISTRATION SHEET Proctor Name: NRC Time Question# Question Called Proctor Response/NRC YES NO

Response

/,s,......J-:"~ "P-h IA} ~ ~-,.l..4-L. fZc -~~~ w ~ 4k t11..0 Yt:t re:'~,..*,-, 1-c "' c--rle-f-e ~t\\,~;_...... rp.. e.:r~~ ~9 ""' ~+ j~~~-"'.... -.~ ~.\\-q~'k,*,..., 

-A~ f':**+.f"

"'~~.l--f,._c; ? ~-\\,eM, go !), C "> 4 G,. ~ \\:,.J 'So.\\- '.!:::* le..... ""'..,...... ~,-;,.~-I--~- IJ'53 41 ,,7 ',i "'""*~ \\.. ble..J.t:. !}(flcS:~ "~ I tl 0 ~~ sv,,rr ~~ ,.,-e,-r't.4P'1, """ '.,e.,,.,. ~ f.F F:oP....., : " be- : J Clt:ir'cf:cJ ~,') :s. /'l. I ) ~s-- ("(~11:'~C~ 1.... ~-> k'41\\

  • 1'--

.,_<.,;l-t::f!r~er-../.o I\\'\\., l \\- j fl~ "? cf-5 eo...~ bG 1ff / :.e.r.1,J, c..£-('C ~;_,.J.:... ~<--<- 0 Instructions: Make multiple copies of the first page, as needed, for questions during exam, For all questions, document on Page 2 the receipt of any questions, the question#, and whether or not the NRC was called.

  • If a question Is NOT documented on page 1, THEN document both the question, response provided and the NRC comments on this form.

INFORMATION USE TRl-206.01-4 Page 2 of 2 Revision 1

EXAM ITEM ANALYSIS Exam Matcode: Number of Trainees: 5 N/A, LC29 ILOT NRC 6/22/23 Exam Date: Issue Report # 2023-004981 Training Program: ILOT Exam Validated: ~ Yes No Basis for Exam Analysis: '81 Any question > 50% failure rate (Complete Section A) D > 25% overa II exam failure rate {Complete Section B} Program Owner request (Complete Section B) D Any question having multiple correct answers or no correct answer {Complete Section A) SECTiONA Question Failure Basis ID Rate(%) Code Corrective Action 79 60 G None, question is not flawed and adequately covered by associated objectives In lesson material. 82 60 G None, question is not flawed and adequately covered by associated objectives in lesson material. 92 60 G None, question is not flawed and adequately covered by associated objectives in lesson material. 97 60 G None, question is not flawed and adequately covered by associated objectives In lesson material. Basis Codes: A. Insufficient training for the teaming objective tested E. Incorrect answer In the exam key B. Learning objectives not adequately covered In the F. More than one correct answer lesson plan G. Question acceptable

c. Poorly worded or invalid learning objective H. Other (state reason In table or on additional sheet)

D. Poorly worded or invalid test item or answer Conclusion Summary Corrective Action* NOTE: Any significant changes to the exam require the exam to formally be reviewed and approved. Significant changes imply any changes other than minor wording clarification. Performed By: Kevin Hegarty Date: 6/28/23 Print Approved By: Jo I Training SupeNlsor P Date: _ 7_11_,_J /_23=---- NTG-104-7 Rev 13 Pagel of 1

For Information Only Affected Rev/PCN Pages 8 1 9 1 10 1 11 None 12 13 1 Record of Changes Page 1 of 1 Oescrlptron of Changes Added step to document explanation for the selected problem code IAW TR-2017-3428. Added tracking number IAW PCR-20-140. Reformatted to align with NISP TR-02 PCR-22-1996 Revision 11 was not used. Revision 12 is being created to correct auto-effective Issue related to Importing conversion documents Into ATR Editor. Resolve the Issue regarding auto-effective import for,form NTG-104-7. Revised section Basis for Exam Analysis, 4th checkbox to state: Any question having multiple correct answers or no correct answer (AI-IR-2023-002135-1) Update one of the bases for exam analysis options to include the word 'exam'. Example: >25% overall EXAM failure rate (PCR-23-2336).

~ 11* r"'ICl 11,IDI ' ':1111.,.,Kll', 4,, afv1 tis 6........ . *.. *- - I* '-** II -- - I -. I 1-75-RO I 75-100 SRO Or)ly VALUE: 1 1 1 \\ 1 I 1, 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 \\ 1 1 1 \\ 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I, ' 1 1 KEY ANSWERS C C D D B C A B D B D D A C C C B D B A C A A B B C B C C D C B C C A D B D D A A A C B C C D A C A NAME TOTAL~ PTS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 2! 29 30 31 32 33 ~ 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 so 88.0 86.0 B A D D B B 88.0 66.0 D D B B C B 86.7 65.0 B A C C A r 88.0 66.0 C A A A A C C A 86.7 65.0 A D D A B A A 90.7 68.0 B B 8 C A 92.0 69.0 D D B B 94.7 71.0 8 D 85.0 85.0 A 8 D A a A 83.0 83.0 D C B A A B B ~ 90.0 90.0 C A 92.0 92.0 A B 8 D 87.0 87.0 B A D B C B D TolalMIIIHd:

  • 3* 2 4 11111 -

l - 2-- 2 1!11! 2 2 "' 2 3

  • 2 2

2 3 .... i' ~--- ~-z1/4'.;,,.!~!1~ ir~"=:i: :- ~; -- ;... ~,~~~~. "" - -~. ~-:-__._. :, 1.75 RD l7S.100 SRD Do" VALUE: 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1, 1 1 1, 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I C KEY ANSWERS, A D C A B A D B A B A C C C B C A C B B A B B B C C A C A D A B C D C C C D 8 C B B B D B C B C A C NAME SRO% RO% 51 52 53 54 55 S$ 5? sa 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 811 00 81 U 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 10C 88.0 B C A 88.0 A D A 86.7 B A D A D 88.0 D 86.7 A C B l 90.7 C 92.0 D A 94.7 C D l 72.D 89.3 C D 8 C A 0 D A B 88.0 81.3 B C A A D D A 0 0 A 84.0 92.0 D A D D B A D C 92.0 92.0 D C A A I 80 0 89.3 D C A A D A I Total Missed: 2J111"'1 4 3 3 "' llli I 3 U!I 3 Ill! 3 2 1 3 2 3 2 I 3 ~11 I off}}

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML23226A234&oldid=3770213"