ML22230A113

Tran-M790727: Public Meeting Affirmation Session 79-22

ML22230A113
Person / Time
Issue date:	07/27/1979
From:	NRC/OCM
To:
References
Tran-M790727
Download: ML22230A113 (8)

Text

'J RETURN TO SECRETARIAT RECORDS NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF:

PUBLIC MEETING AFFIRMATION SESSION 79-22 Piece_ Wa shington, D. C .

Dcte - Friday , 2 7 Jul y 19 79 Pages 1 - 6 Telephone :

(202 ) 3,17.3700 ACE - FEDERAL REPORTERS, INC.

Official Reporters 444 North Capitol Street Washington , D.C. 20001 NATIONWIDE COVERAGE* DAILY

l.

i Dl:SCLAIMER This is an hnofficial transcript of a meeting of the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission held ori Friday, 27 July 1979 in the Commissions's offices at 1717 H Street; N. w., Washington, D. c * .The meeting was open to public attendance and observation. This transcript has not been reviewed, corrected, or edited, and it may contain inaccuracies.

• The transcript is intended solely for general informational

• purposes. As provided by 10 CFR 9 .103, i t is not p~rt of the formal or informal record of decision of the matters discu~sed. Expressions*

of opinion in this transcript do not necessarily*reflect final determinations or beliefs. * . No pleading or other paper may be filed

.with the Commission in any pr6ceed~ngas the result of or addressed to any statement or argument contained- herein,* except as the Commission may authorize. . .

• .2 CR6198

- .1 UNITED STATES

• OF AMERICA 2  : NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

- 3 PUBLIC MEETING 4 AFFIRMATION SESSION 79-22 5.

)

6 Room 1130 7

1717 H Street,* N. W.

Washington, D. C.

8 Friday, 27 July 1979 9

The Commission met, pursuant to notice, at 9:40 a.m.

10*

. BEFORE:

11 DRo JOSEPH Mc HENDRIE, Chairman 12

• VICTOR GILINSKY, Commissioner

.13 RICHARDT. KENNEDY, Commissioner 14 PETER Ac BRADFORD, Commissioner 15 . .

JOHN F *.* AHEARNE,

• Commissioner 16 ALSO PRESENT:

.17 Messrs. Eilperi:n, Ostrach, and Chilkc 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Ace-Federal Reponers, Inc.

25

6J .,013 3 mgc P ROC E E D I NGS

'2 C9140 a .m *. )

3 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: The f.irst item this morning is 4 an affirmation session.,* I'.11 ask. the Secretary to lead us 5 , through that.

6 MR .. CHILKs There are two orders.in S-3that the 7 Co.mmission is bei'ng asked to affirm.. The first order is the 8 final. rule which was circulated by Chairman Hendrie on July 9 19., It contains minor revisions to pages 1253 and -54 10 circulated to you by the Solicitor on the 24the The JI separate vtews of Commissioner* Bradfrod were circulated to 12 you on the 24th and the 26th. And the separate views of

• 13 14 15 Commissioner Gilinsky were circulated to you on the 26th.

Chaitman Hehdrie, Commissioner.Kennedy, and Commissioner Ahea.rne had approved the c;,rder as circulated by 16 the Chairman.' s memorandum of July I 9 with -the OTC changes, 17 the minor* changes on the four pages I ennumerated.

18 Commissioner Bradford has approved the order in part, has 19 disapproved it in part, and has attached his separate views

.20. as circulated to you on the 24th ~nd the 26th. -Commissi~ner 21 Gilinsky has disapproved the order and has attached his 22

• separate views which. were circulated to you on the 26th.

23 I would ask you to affirm your votes on that.

24 CHAIRMAN HENDRIEs Those in favor?

25 . {Chorus of ayes.>

61.1,024 mgc CHAIRMAN HENDRIE, Those opposed, or in* part 2 'OPPf)sed?

3, COMMI.SSIONER GILINSKY1 I think we're all voting*

4 aye, 5 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE* Okay. All vote aye to affirm 6

• the tirder.

7 MR. CHILK* The second order that you're being 8 asked to affirm is the proposed extension of interim.rule as 9 recommended by the Solicitor in his memorandum of the 24th, 10 and this will continue the interim rule until the effective 11 date of the final rule, which is 30 days after its

. 12 publtcation in the Federal Register notice. And all of your*

• 13 14 15 off t t;ers have agr.eed to that extension.

CHAIRMAN HENDRIE*

(Chorus of ayes.>

Those in favor?

16 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: So ordered.

17 MR. CH*ILK1 The se-corid affirmation is 79 18 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: Okay *. Go aheadt Sam.

19 MR. CHILK1 SECY-A-79-56, a review of ALAB-542 in 20 the matter of Atlantic Research Corporation, in which the 21 statf has requested a review of an Appeal Board decision and 22 OTC has concurred. The Commission has voted five to 23 nothtng, agreeing for review of that matter, ~nd ,the order.

24 mod! r i ed slightly f ram the. pa per was concurred in by your 25 oft.t.~fes yesterday.

5 '

• • 1

.c:

619801035,

.1 2

=-

• CHAIRMAN HENDRIE*

I'd ask you to* aft irm that.,

I Those in favor?

3 4

5 (Chorus of ayes .. )

CHAIRMANHENDRIE1 MRe CHILK1 So ordered.,

Third, is79-388., It's an appeal,

'6 Anderson FOIA appeal for documents identified as A-4 and 7 A-7.,. The general *counsel recommended a denial of the 8 appeal., The Commission denied the documents referred to in 9 A-4 by vote of five to nothing, denied the documents 10 referred to in A~7 by a v0te of foui to one with *

.11 Commissioner Bradford dissenting but raising no objections

• 12 to the affirmationo 13 I w.ould ask you to affirm the vote ..

14 CHAIRMAN HENDRIEs Those in favor?

.*J 5 , {Chorus of ayes.>

16 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: So ordered.,

17 MR., CHILK: The last one is SECY-79-163-Revision 18 of IO CFR 2.,802 Petition for Rule Making. It's *an amendment 19 to the Rules of Practice..- The Commission voted five to 20 nothing to *approve the changes. Each of you made some 21 modification. Those modifications have geared into the I

22 final document which was coordinated with your offices 23 between the 20th and the 25th, so I would ask you to affirm 24 your vote.

25 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE* Those in favor?

'6 .

1911?~?

mgc * .( Chorus of ayes .. > /

2 . CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: So ordered ..

.3 MR .. CHILKs That completes the affirmation, sir

• 4 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: Goode

'** ;.,_~:::

5 (Whereupon, at 9z 50 a.,m .. , the affirmation meeting 6 *was adjourned.,)

7 8

9 10 JI

. 12 13 14 15 16

.17 18 19

• 20 I

21 22

. 23 24 25