GO2-20-146, Erratum to Fourth Ten-Year Inservice Inspection (ISI) Program Relief Request 4ISI-09

From kanterella
(Redirected from ML20322A447)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Erratum to Fourth Ten-Year Inservice Inspection (ISI) Program Relief Request 4ISI-09
ML20322A447
Person / Time
Site: Columbia Energy Northwest icon.png
Issue date: 11/17/2020
From: Wolfgramm D
Energy Northwest
To:
Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Shared Package
ML20322A446 List:
References
GO2-20-146
Download: ML20322A447 (63)
v • d • e


Text

Desiree M Wolfgramm Columbia Generating Station P.O. Box 968, PE20 Richland, WA 99352-0968 Ph. 509.377.4792 l F. 509.377.4674 dmwolfgramm@energy-northwest.com Proprietary - Withhold under 10 CFR 2.390. Enclosure 1 contains PROPRIETARY information.

GO2-20-146 10 CFR 50.55a U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ATTN: Document Control Desk Washington, D.C. 20555-0001

Subject:

COLUMBIA GENERATING STATION, DOCKET NO. 50-397 ERRATUM TO FOURTH TEN-YEAR INSERVICE INSPECTION (ISI)

PROGRAM RELIEF REQUEST 4ISI-09

References:

1. Letter from J Kent Dittmer, Energy Northwest, to NRC, Fourth Ten-Year Interval Inservice Inspection (ISI) Program Relief Request 4ISI-09, dated April 22, 2020 (ADAMS Accession Numbers ML20114E235 and ML20114E236)

Dear Sir or Madam:

Please replace Enclosure 2, 1801567.301P.R1 Probabilistic Fracture Mechanics Evaluation for Columbia Feedwater Nozzles, of the referenced letter with Enclosure 1 of this letter. Structural Integrity Associates, Incorporated considers certain information contained in Enclosure 1 to be proprietary and, therefore, requests that it be withheld from public disclosure in accordance with 10 CFR 2.390.

Please replace the non-proprietary Enclosure 3 of the referenced letter with the non-proprietary Enclosure 2, 1801567.301.R1 Probabilistic Fracture Mechanics Evaluation for Columbia Feedwater Nozzles, of this letter. Enclosure 3 of this letter contains the associated affidavit for the request to be withheld from public disclosure.

When Enclosure 1 is removed from this letter, the letter and remaining Enclosures are NON-PROPRIETARY.

There are no new commitments made in this letter. If you have any questions or require additional information, please contact Mr. R. M. Garcia, Licensing Supervisor, at 509-377-8463.

       

November 17, 2020 ENERGY NORTHWEST

GO2-20-146 Page 2 of 2 Executed on the _______ day of November, 2020.

Respectfully, D. M. Wolfgramm Manager, Regulatory Affairs

Enclosures:

As stated cc: NRC RIV Regional Administrator NRC NRR Project Manager NRC Senior Resident Inspector -988C CD Sonoda - BPA - 1399 EFSECutc.wa.gov - EFSEC E Fordham - WDOH R Brice - WDOH L Albin - WDOH

       



GO2-20-127 1801567.301.R1, Probabilistic Fracture Mechanics Evaluation for Columbia Feedwater Nozzle

       



&$/&8/$7,213$&.$*(

)LOH1R

3URMHFW1R

4XDOLW\\3URJUDP7\\SH

1XFOHDU

&RPPHUFLDO

352-(&71$0(

&ROXPELD)HHGZDWHU1R))OH)HDVLELOLW\\6WXG\\IRU3UREDELOLVWLF)UDFWXUH0HFKDQLFV 3)0 

&2175$&712

+/-5HY

&/,(17

(QHUJ\\1RUWKZHVW,QF

3/$17

&ROXPELD*HQHUDWLQJ6WDWLRQ &*6 

&$/&8/$7,217,7/(

3UREDELOLVWLF)UDFWXUH0HFKDQLFV(YDOXDWLRQIRU&ROXPELD)HHGZDWHU1R))OH

'RFXPHQW

5HYLVLRQ

$IIHFWHG

3DJHV

5HYLVLRQ'HVFULSWLRQ

3URMHFW0DQDJHU

$SSURYDO

6LJQDWXUH 'DWH

3UHSDUHU V  

&KHFNHU V 

6LJQDWXUHV 'DWH





$$



,QLWLDO,VVXH



.HYLQ:RQJ







  • DULYDOGH'RPLQJXH]





.HYLQ:RQJ







1RQ

3URSULHWDU\\

9HUVLRQ 

6HFWLRQ

6HFWLRQ

7DEOHV

)LJXUHV

)LJXUHV+/-

$SSHQGL[$

6XSSRUWLQJ)LOHV

5HYLVHGVWUHVVDQG

3)0UHVXOWV





.HYLQ:RQJ







&KDUOHV)RXUFDGH







.HYLQ:RQJ





35235,(7$5<,1)250$7,21

7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('







       

SJ Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('

































35235,(7$5<,1)250$7,21127,&(



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((1

5('$&7('



1RWH3URSULHWDU\\5HIHUHQFHVDUHLGHQWLILHGZLWKD³3'LQWKH6,)LOH1XPEHU



3URSULHWDU\\LQIRUPDWLRQXVHGLQWKHGRFXPHQWLVLGHQWLILHGZLWKEUDFNHWHGEODFNKLJKOLJKWLQJ^^BBBBBB``









       

tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

info@structi nt.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













7DEOHRI&RQWHQWV







,1752'8&7,21



0(7+2'2/2*<



)DWLJXH&\\FOHV



/2$',1*6



7UDQVLHQWV



7KHUPDO0RPHQW



675(66$1$/<6,6



'LPHQVLRQVDQG0DWHULDO3URSHUWLHV



8QLW3UHVVXUH



1R))OH/RDG



7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW



6WUHVV3DWKV



352%$%,/,67,&)5$&785(0(&+$1,&6(9$/8$7,21



3)0$VVXPSWLRQV



'HVLJQ,QSXWV



'HWHUPLQLVWLF3DUDPHWHUV



5DQGRP9DULDEOHV



5(68/76$1'&21&/86,216



5()(5(1&(6

6833257,1*),/(6$







       

APPENDIX A tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

info@structi nt.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















/LVWRI7DEOHV





7DEOH7UDQVLHQW'HILQLWLRQV(YHQWVWKURXJK>@

7DEOH7UDQVLHQW'HILQLWLRQV(YHQWVWKURXJK>@

7DEOH7UDQVLHQW'HILQLWLRQV(YHQWVDQG>@

7DEOH7UDQVLHQW'HILQLWLRQV(YHQWVDQG>@

7DEOH%RXQGLQJ7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQWVRI)HHGZDWHU1R))OH

7DEOH0DWHULDO3URSHUWLHV0HWDOV>@

7DEOH0DWHULDO3URSHUWLHV:DWHU(OHPHQWV>@

7DEOH5DQGRP9DULDEOHV3DUDPHWHU6XPPDU\\

7DEOH'HWHUPLQLVWLF3DUDPHWHU6XPPDU\\

7DEOH3UREDELOLW\\RI'HWHFWLRQ 3R' 'LVWULEXWLRQ>@

7DEOH3UREDELOLW\\RI)DLOXUHIRU3HULRGRI([WHQGHG2SHUDWLRQ







       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('

















/LVWRI)LJXUHV



)LJXUH):1R))OH*HRPHWU\\>@

)LJXUH3LSLQJDQG7KHUPDO6OHHYH,QWHUIDFH/RDGV>@

)LJXUH)LQLWH(OHPHQW0RGHO>@

)LJXUH$SSOLHG3UHVVXUHDQG%RXQGDU\\&RQGLWLRQV9HVVHODQG$QQXODU3UHVVXUH>@

)LJXUH7\\SLFDO$SSOLHG+HDW7UDQVIHU&RHIILFLHQWDQG7HPSHUDWXUH3URILOH>@

)LJXUH%RXQGDU\\&RQGLWLRQVIRU7KHUPDO6WUHVV$QDO\\VHV>@

)LJXUH6WUHVV,QWHQVLW\\5HVXOWIRU3UHVVXUH/RDGLQJ>@

)LJXUH6WUHVV,QWHQVLW\\5HVXOWEDVHGRQ1R))OH8QLW0RPHQW/RDG>@

)LJXUH6WUHVV,QWHQVLW\\5HVXOWEDVHGRQ7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW>@

)LJXUH6WUHVV([WUDFWLRQ3DWK2ULHQWDWLRQVLQWKH):1R))OH

)LJXUH8QLW3UHVVXUH6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV

)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV1R))OH8QLW0RPHQW/RDG

)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW

)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW

)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW'1

)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW

)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW

)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW

)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW

)LJXUH:HOG5HVLGXDO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQIRU3DWKVDQG



       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















,1752'8&7,21

$60(&RGH&DVH1>@DOORZVIRUWKHUHGXFWLRQRILQVHUYLFHLQVSHFWLRQSRSXODWLRQIURPWR

RIQR))OHEOHQGUDGLLDQGQR))OHWRVKHOOZHOGVHYHU\\\\HDUVIRU%:5539QR))OHV)HHGZDWHU

QR))OHVZHUHH[FOXGHGIURPWKHVFRSHRI$60(&RGH&DVH1GXHWRWKHFUDFNLQJLVVXHVWKDW

RFFXUUHGLQ%:5IHHGZDWHUQR))OHLQQHUUDGLLGXULQJWKHV



)HHGZDWHUQR))OHFUDFNLQJLVVXHVLQ%:5VZHUHDGGUHVVHGE\\YDULRXVLWHPVLQ185(*>@

6LQFHLPSOHPHQWDWLRQRIWKHVHLWHPVWKH%:5IOHHWKDVRSHUDWHGPDQ\\\\HDUVDQGGHPRQVWUDWHGWKDWWKH

FUDFNLQJLVVXHVKDYHEHHQPDQDJHGHIIHFWLYHO\\7KHUHIRUHWKHUHLVQRZDSRWHQWLDOWRVHHNUHOLHIIRUWKH

IHHGZDWHUQR))OHH[DPFRYHUDJH%:59,3$>@LVWKHWHFKQLFDOEDVLVIRU$60(&RGH&DVH1

IRUWKHUHGXFWLRQRILQVSHFWLRQUHTXLUHPHQWVIRUWKHERLOLQJZDWHUUHDFWRUQR))OHWRYHVVHOVKHOO

ZHOGVDQGQR))OHLQQHUUDGLXV7KDWZRUNZDVVXSSOHPHQWHGE\\SUREDELOLVWLFIUDFWXUHPHFKDQLFV 3)0 

HYDOXDWLRQIRUWKHERLOLQJZDWHUUHDFWRUQR))OHWRYHVVHOVKHOOZHOGVDQGQR))OHEOHQGUDGLL %:59,3

$ >@+HQFHWKHHYDOXDWLRQIRUWKH&ROXPELD*HQHUDWLQJ6WDWLRQ **6 IHHGZDWHUQR))OHVZLOO

IROORZWKHPHWKRGRORJ\\XVHGLQ%:59,3$DQG%:59,3$IRUHVWDEOLVKLQJWKHWHFKQLFDO

EDVLVDQGDGGLWLRQDOJXLGDQFHIRU15&3)0VXEPLWWDOVLVSURYLGHGLQ(35,/HWWHU>@



$SODQWVSHFLILF3)0HYDOXDWLRQLVSHUIRUPHGWRVXSSRUWDUHOLHIUHTXHVWIRUUHGXFWLRQRIH[DPLQDWLRQ

FRYHUDJHIRULQVHUYLFHLQVSHFWLRQVIURPWRRIWKHQR))OHEOHQGUDGLLDQGQR))OHWRVKHOO

ZHOGVIRUWKHIHHGZDWHUQR))OHVHYHU\\\\HDUV





0(7+2'2/2*<

0RQWH&DUORVLPXODWLRQVDUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKWKH6,SURSULHWDU\\VRIWZDUH9,3(512=>@ZKLFKZDV

GHYHORSHGIRU539QR))OHZHOGLQVSHFWLRQVZLWK%:59,3$>@DQGLVWKHVXFFHVVRUWRWKH(35,

VRIWZDUH9,3(5IRU539VKHOOZHOGLQVSHFWLRQVZLWK%:59,3>@%:59,3$DQG%:59,3

$XVHD0RQWH&DUORPHWKRGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHSUREDELOLW\\RIIDLOXUH7KH&*6QR))OHVWUHVVHVDUH

XVHGZLWKSUREDELOLVWLFGLVWULEXWLRQVIURP%:59,3$DQG%:59,3$WRHYDOXDWHWKHSODQW

VSHFLILFSUREDELOLWLHV



7KHDFFHSWDQFHFULWHULRQOLPLWVWKHGLIIHUHQFHLQSUREDELOLW\\RIIDLOXUHSHU\\HDUGXHWRWKHORZWHPSHUDWXUH

RYHUSUHVVXUH /723 HYHQWWREHQRPRUHWKDQ[ZKHQFKDQJLQJIURPIXOO  LQVHUYLFH

LQVSHFWLRQWRLQVSHFWLRQIRUWKH3(2,QWKLVDQDO\\VLVWKHFDVHRILQVSHFWLRQIRU\\HDUVLV

XVHG,IWKHUHVXOWLQJSUREDELOLW\\RIIDLOXUH 3R) SHU\\HDUGXHWRDSRVWXODWHG/723HYHQW LQFOXGLQJ

SUREDELOLW\\RI/723HYHQWRFFXUUHQFHSHU\\HDU>SJ@ LVOHVVWKDQWKHDOORZDEOH3R)RI

[SHU\\HDUIURP185(*>@WKHQWKHUHLVDWHFKQLFDOEDVLVIRUWKHLQVSHFWLRQUHGXFWLRQ

EDVHGRQ&RGH&DVH1





       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















)DWLJXH&\\FOHV

7KHUHVXOWVIURPWKH&*6IHHGZDWHUQR))OHILQLWHHOHPHQWDQDO\\VLVSURMHFW>@DUHXVHGWRREWDLQWKH

VWUHVVHVQHFHVVDU\\IRUWKH3)0DQDO\\VLV7KURXJKZDOOSDWKVWUHVVGLVWULEXWLRQVDUHH[WUDFWHGDWWKH

QR))OHEOHQGUDGLXVDQGQR))OHWRYHVVHOZHOGIRUWKHERXQGLQJIHHGZDWHUWKHUPDOWUDQVLHQWV7KH

IHHGZDWHUWUDQVLHQWVVXPPDUL]HGLQ5HIHUHQFH>@DUHHYDOXDWHGWRREWDLQWKHZRUVWFDVHVZKLFK

ERXQGVWKHRWKHUWUDQVLHQWV



7KHERXQGLQJWUDQVLHQWVIRU&*6):QR))OHDUHREWDLQHGEDVHGRQWKHORDGVHYDOXDWLRQFRQGXFWHGLQ

5HIHUHQFH>@DQGDUHXVHGWRVHOHFWZKLFKWUDQVLHQWVKDYHDVHYHUHUDWHRIWHPSHUDWXUHFKDQJHDQGD

FRQVLGHUDEOHODUJHWHPSHUDWXUHGLIIHUHQFH7DEOHOLVWVWKHVHVL[WUDQVLHQWVDQGWKHQXPEHURIF\\FOHV

IRU\\HDUV





/2$',1*6

)DWLJXHORDGVDUHFRQVLGHUHGLQWKHDQDO\\VHVVXFKDVWKHUPDOWUDQVLHQWORDGVDQGLQWHUQDOSUHVVXUH

&RQFXUUHQWZLWKWKHUPDOWUDQVLHQWORDGVDUHWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJQR))OHPRPHQWORDGV7KHIROORZLQJ

VXEVHFWLRQVGLVFXVVWKHVHORDGLQJVWKDWZLOOEHXVHGLQWKHSUREDELOLVWLFIUDFWXUHPHFKDQLFV 3)0 

HYDOXDWLRQ





7UDQVLHQWV

7KHWKHUPDOWUDQVLHQWVIRUWKH&*6IHHGZDWHUQR))OHDUHREWDLQHGIURPWKHORDGLQJVFDOFXODWLRQ>@

7DEOHWKURXJKVKRZWKHWUDQVLHQWVGHILQLWLRQVZLWKWKHWHPSHUDWXUHDQGSUHVVXUHIRUERWKIHHGZDWHU

VLGH ZKLFKLVGHILQHGDV³):'>@ DQGPDLQVWHDPSLSLQJVLGH ZKLFKLVGHILQHGE\\³$'>@ 7KH

DIRUHPHQWLRQHGWDEOHVDOVRFRQVLVWRIWKHFDOFXODWHGIORZUDWHDQGKHDWWUDQVIHUFRHIILFLHQWVIRUERWKWKH

UHDFWRUSUHVVXUHYHVVHODQGWKHIHHGZDWHUQR))OH5HIHUHQFH>@FRQWDLQVWKHGHWDLOHGFDOFXODWLRQRIWKH

KHDWWUDQVIHUFRHIILFLHQWV7KHWUDQVLHQWVDUHWKHQVFUHHQHGWRREWDLQWKHOLPLWLQJHYHQWVWKDWERXQGWKH

RWKHUWUDQVLHQWV7KHFULWHULDIRUVHOHFWLQJWKHZRUVWFDVHVDUH D WUDQVLHQWVWKDWKDYHDODUJH

WHPSHUDWXUHGLIIHUHQFHDQG E WUDQVLHQWVWKDWKDYHDGUDVWLFUDWHRIFKDQJHLQWHPSHUDWXUH7KH

VFUHHQLQJPHWKRGLVFDOFXODWHGLQWKHVXSSRUWLQJVSUHDGVKHHW3+/-):%RXQGLQJ7UDQVLHQW

6FUHHQLQJDQGWKHIROORZLQJWUDQVLHQWVDUHVHOHFWHGDVERXQGLQJ



  7UDQVLHQW 6WDUWXS VWHSGRZQWHPSHUDWXUHFKDQJHIURP)WR)7):VLGH

VHH7DEOH 

  7UDQVLHQW'1 7XUELQHJHQHUDWRUWULS KLJKWHPSHUDWXUHGLIIHUHQFHRI)7$VLGH

VHH7DEOH 

  7UDQVLHQW /RVVRI):SXPSV VWHSGRZQWHPSHUDWXUHFKDQJHIURP)WR

)7):VLGH VHH7DEOH 

  7UDQVLHQW 5HDFWRURYHUSUHVVXUH VWHSXSWHPSHUDWXUHFKDQJHIURP)WR)

7):VLGH VHH7DEOH 

  7UDQVLHQW ,PSURSHUVWDUWXS VWHSGRZQWHPSHUDWXUHFKDQJHIURP)WR)

7):VLGH VHH7DEOH 



7DEOHVXPPDUL]HVWKHERXQGLQJWUDQVLHQWVZLWKWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJQXPEHURIF\\FOHVELQQHGIURPRWKHU

OHVVVHYHUHWUDQVLHQWV7UDQVLHQWLVLQFOXGHGWRVHJUHJDWHDQGUHSUHVHQWWKHKLJKF\\FOHOHVVVHYHUH

HYHQWVVXFKDV³'DLO\\UHGXFWLRQWRSRZHU' HYHQWF\\FOHV ³:HHNO\\UHGXFWLRQWR

SRZHU' HYHQWF\\FOHV DQG³5RGSDWWHUQFKDQJH' HYHQWF\\FOHV 

       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('

















7KHUPDO0RPHQW

)LJXUHVKRZVWKHSLSLQJDQGWKHUPDOVOHHYHLQWHUIDFHORDGVIRUWKHUPDO5)( WKHUPDOVOHHYHRQO\\ 

2QO\\F\\FOLFORDGVVXFKDVWKHUPDOWUDQVLHQWDQGSUHVVXUHDUHLQFOXGHGGHDGZHLJKWZKLFKGRHVQRW

F\\FOHLVQRWQHHGHG



7KHWZRWKHUPDOH[SDQVLRQPRPHQW 07( FDVHVDUHDVIROORZV ZLWKPRPHQWFRQYHUWHGWRNLSLQ >@



x

&DVH7): )7Y )07( OEIW NLSLQ

x

&DVH7): )7Y )07( OEIW NLSLQ



7KHVHYDOXHVDUHLQFUHDVHGE\\WRDFFRXQWIRUSRVVLEOHIXWXUHFKDQJHVWRSLSLQJDQDO\\VHV



x

&DVH7): )7Y )07( NLSLQ

x

&DVH7): )7Y )07( NLSLQ



$IRUPXODIRU07(LVGHYHORSHGDVEHIRUH>@H[FHSWWKDW D PRPHQWVDUHFRQYHUWHGWRNLSLQDQG

LQFUHDVHGDVVKRZQDERYHDQG E PDLQVWHDPWHPSHUDWXUH 7$ LVXVHG7KHYHVVHOWHPSHUDWXUH

RI)IRUQRUPDORSHUDWLQJFRQGLWLRQVFRUUHVSRQGVWRD7$RI)>@5HODWHGWR7):DQG7$WKH

PRPHQWIRUPXODLV





07( N 7):+/- N 7$+/- VXFKWKDW







 N +/- N +/- DQG





 N +/- N +/- 



6ROYLQJIRUNDQGN\\LHOGV





N NLSLQ)





N NLSLQ)



7KHUHIRUHWKHUPDOH[SDQVLRQPRPHQWFDQEHFDOFXODWHGDV







07(  7):+/-  7$+/- NLSLQ ZLWK7):DQG7$LQ) 





675(66$1$/<6,6

)LQLWHHOHPHQWDQDO\\VLVLVHPSOR\\HGXVLQJDSUHYLRXVO\\GHYHORSHG'ILQLWHHOHPHQWPRGHO )(0 RIWKH

&*6IHHGZDWHUQR))OH>@7KHUHVXOWVGXHWRLQWHUQDOSUHVVXUHDUHFRPELQHGZLWKVWUHVVHVIURP

FRUUHVSRQGLQJWKHUPDOWUDQVLHQWV$OOQHFHVVDU\\VWUHVVWHQVRUVVXFKDVLQWKHFLUFXPIHUHQWLDODQGD[LDO

GLUHFWLRQVDUHXVHGLQWKHVXEVHTXHQWSUREDELOLVWLFIUDFWXUHPHFKDQLFV 3)0 HYDOXDWLRQ7KH

FRHIILFLHQWVRIWKHVWUHVVHVIRUERWKSUHVVXUHDQGWKHUPDOWUDQVLHQWVDUHJHQHUDWHGIRUWKH3)0

HYDOXDWLRQZKHUHWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJFRHIILFLHQWVIRUDVSHFLILFWUDQVLHQWDUHFRPELQHGZLWKWKH

FRHIILFLHQWVRIWKHPLQLPXPDQGPD[LPXPLQWHUQDOSUHVVXUH



7KHPDWHULDOSURSHUWLHVDQGGLPHQVLRQVDUHGHWDLOHGLQILQLWHHOHPHQWPRGHOLQ5HIHUHQFH>@DQGDUH

DOVRGLVFXVVHGLQWKHIROORZLQJVXEVHFWLRQV



       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















'LPHQVLRQVDQG0DWHULDO3URSHUWLHV

)URP5HIHUHQFH>@WKHPDWHULDOSURSHUWLHVRIPHWDOVDUHWDNHQIURPWKH(GLWLRQRIWKH$60(

&RGHZLWKDGGHQGDWKURXJK6XPPHUH[FHSWWKDWKHDWWUDQVIHUSURSHUWLHVDUHIURPWKH6XPPHU

(UUDWD (UUDWDQRWLFHVDUHUHTXLUHGWREHXVHGVLQFHWKH\\DUHFRUUHFWLRQVWRHUURUVLQWKH$60(

&RGH 



7KH):QR))OHDQGVDIHHQGGLPHQVLRQV VHH)LJXUH DVZHOODVPDWHULDOVSHFLILFDWLRQVDUHOLVWHG

IURP5HIHUHQFH>@



x

3LSLQJPDWHULDO6$JUDGH%

x

9HVVHOPDWHULDO6$JUDGH%FODVV

x

9HVVHOFODGGLQJPDWHULDO6$JUDGH)HTXLYDOHQW &U1L 

x

3LSLQJVHFWLRQRXWVLGHGLDPHWHU WKLFNQHVV 

x

9HVVHOFODGGLQJWKLFNQHVV 

x

9HVVHOLQVLGHFODGGLQJUDGLXV 

x

9HVVHORXWVLGHUDGLXV 

x

6DIHHQGLQQHUEUDQFKRXWHUUDGLXVDWWXQLQJIRUN 

x

6DIHHQGOHQJWKDWWXQLQJIRUN 

x

6DIHHQGWXQLQJIRUNUDGLXV 

x

5DGLXVWRORDGDSSOLFDWLRQSRLQWRQWKHUPDOVOHHYH



7DEOHOLVWVWKHWHPSHUDWXUHGHSHQGHQWPDWHULDOSURSHUWLHVIRUPHWDOV>@6SHFLILFKHDWLVFDOFXODWHG

EDVHGRQWKHUPDOFRQGXFWLYLW\\WKHUPDOGLIIXVLYLW\\DQGWKHGHQVLW\\VKRZQLQWKHJHQHUDOQRWHVRIWKH

WDEOH,QDGGLWLRQ3RLVVRQ¶VUDWLR Q HTXDOVIRUWKLVHODVWLFDQDO\\VLV



7DEOHOLVWVWKHWHPSHUDWXUHGHSHQGHQWPDWHULDOSURSHUWLHVIRUWKHZDWHUHOHPHQWVLQWKHDQQXOXV

7KHVHHOHPHQWVKDYHDQHTXLYDOHQWFRQGXFWLYLW\\RI%WXKUIW)>@





8QLW3UHVVXUH

7KH'PRGHOLVFRQVWUXFWHGXVLQJWKH$16<6QRGHGVWUXFWXUDOVROLGHOHPHQW62/,'$UELWUDU\\

OHQJWKVRIDGMDFHQWSLSLQJDQGYHVVHOZDOODUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHPRGHOWRLVRODWHWKHQR))OHIURPHQG

HIIHFWV)LJXUHVKRZVWKHILQLWHHOHPHQWPRGHO $16<6LQSXWILOH&*6):1LQSLQWKHSURMHFW

FRPSXWHUILOHV 



)URP5HIHUHQFH>@DYHVVHODQGDQQXODUXQLWSUHVVXUHRISVL 3 LVDSSOLHGWRWKHLQVLGHVXUIDFH

RIWKHYHVVHODQGLQWKHDQQXODUJDS&DSORDGV 3FDS DUHDSSOLHGWRWKHIUHHHQGVRIWKHYHVVHODQG

WKHUPDOVOHHYHXVLQJWKHHTXDWLRQ







3FDS 35L 5R+/-5L ZKHUH







5L LQVLGHUDGLXVRIYHVVHORUWKHUPDOVOHHYH





5R RXWVLGHUDGLXVRIYHVVHORUWKHUPDOVOHHYH

7KHQHJDWLYHVLJQDIWHUWKHHTXDOVVLJQLQGLFDWHVWHQVLRQDSSOLHGWRWKHPRGHOKRZHYHUVLQFHWKH

WKHUPDOVOHHYHSRLQWVLQZDUG WRZDUGWKHSUHVVXUHVRXUFH LWGRHVQRWWDNHDQHJDWLYHVLJQ7KHVWUHVV

       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













UHVXOWRIWKHXQLWSUHVVXUH)($ZLOOEHVFDOHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHPLQLPXPDQGPD[LPXPSUHVVXUHRIHDFK

WUDQVLHQW6\\PPHWU\\ERXQGDU\\FRQGLWLRQVDUHDSSOLHGDWV\\PPHWU\\SODQHVDVVKRZQLQ)LJXUH



1R))OH/RDG

)LJXUHVKRZVWKHUHTXLUHGIRUFHDQGPRPHQWORFDWLRQV>@7KHJOREDOFRRUGLQDWHV\\VWHPXVHGLQWKH

)(0 KDV;D[LDOWRQR))OH<YHUWLFDODQG=SHUULJKWKDQGUXOH>VXSSRUWLQJILOH&*6):1LQS@

,Q5HIHUHQFH>@EHQGLQJPRPHQW OELQ FDVHVDUHDQDO\\]HG7KHPDJQLWXGHRIWKHPRPHQWLV

FDOFXODWHGLQWKH$16<6LQSXWILOHIRUWKHVHORDGFDVHV0(&+3,3,13LQWKHVXSSRUWLQJILOHV7KH

VWUHVVUHVXOWVEDVHGRQWKHXQLWPRPHQWORDGLQJZLOOEHVFDOHGEDVHGRQWKHFDOFXODWHGPRPHQW VHH

6HFWLRQ GXHWRWKHUPDOH[SDQVLRQSHUHDFKWUDQVLHQW7KHFDOFXODWHGVFDOLQJIDFWRUVDUHLQD

VSUHDGVKHHWFRPSXWDWLRQ&*6):1R]B0WK)DFWRULQWKHVXSSRUWLQJILOHV

%RWKWKHSLSLQJORDGVDUHDSSOLHGXVLQJWKH7$5*(WDUJHWHOHPHQWW\\SHWRFUHDWHDSLORWQRGH7KH

&217$FRQWDFWHOHPHQWW\\SHLVXVHGWRFUHDWHDFRQWDFWVXUIDFHDWWKHSLSLQJRUWKHUPDOVOHHYH

HQG7KHSLORWQRGHDQGVXUIDFHDUHERQGHGWRJHWKHUVRWKDWWKHPRPHQWDSSOLHGWRWKHSLORWQRGHLV

WUDQVIHUUHGWRWKHFRQWDFWVXUIDFH



7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW

7KHGHILQHGERXQGLQJWKHUPDOWUDQVLHQWV>@DUHDQDO\\]HG VHH7DEOH DSSO\\LQJWHPSHUDWXUHV 7 DQG

WKHDSSURSULDWHKHDWWUDQVIHUFRHIILFLHQWV K WRWKHLQVLGHVXUIDFHRIWKHPRGHO VHH7DEOHWKURXJK 

)LJXUHLOOXVWUDWHVWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRIKLQ%WXVHFLQ)IRUDQH[DPSOHFDVH

$16<662/,'VWUXFWXUDOHOHPHQWVDUHVZLWFKHGWR62/,'WKHUPDOHOHPHQWVIRUWKHUPDO

WHPSHUDWXUHGLVWULEXWLRQDQDO\\VLV)RUWKHUPDOVWUHVVDQDO\\VLV62/,'VWUXFWXUDOHOHPHQWVDUHXVHG

7KHPHFKDQLFDOERXQGDU\\FRQGLWLRQVXVHGIRUWKHWKHUPDOVWUHVVDQDO\\VLVDUHVKRZQLQ)LJXUH



6WUHVV3DWKV

7KHFULWLFDOVWUHVVSDWKVDUHVHOHFWHGIRUWZRORFDWLRQVRQWKHIHHGZDWHUQR))OH)RXUSDWKV 3WKURXJK

3 DUHFKRVHQDWWKHEOHQGUDGLXV7ZRDGGLWLRQDOSDWKV 3DQG3 DUHVHOHFWHGDWWKHQR))OHWR

YHVVHOVKHOOZHOGV VHH)LJXUH 'HWDLOHGQRGDOORFDWLRQRISDWKVDUHDVIROORZV



x

3DWK3  QR))OHWRYHVVHOVKHOOEOHQGUDGLXV IURPQRGHWRQRGH

x

3DWK3  QR))OHWRYHVVHOVKHOOEOHQGUDGLXV IURPQRGHWRQRGH

x

3DWK3  QR))OHLQVLGHVXUIDFHWRRXWHUEOHQGUDGLXV IURPQRGHWRQRGH

x

3DWK3  QR))OHLQVLGHVXUIDFHWRRXWHUEOHQGUDGLXV IURPQRGHWRQRGH

x

3DWK3  QR))OHWRYHVVHOVKHOOZHOG IURPQRGHWRQRGH

x

3DWK3  QR))OHWRYHVVHOVKHOOZHOG IURPQRGHWRQRGH



6WUHVVSDWKV3DQG3DUHVHOHFWHGVLQFHWKHLUVWUHVVLQWHQVLWLHVDUHPD[LPXPDWWKHQR))OHEOHQG

UDGLXVEDVHGRQWKHDQDO\\VLVRIWKHXQLWSUHVVXUHORDG VHH)LJXUH 7KHDUURZKHDGVRIVWUHVVSDWKV

3DQG3 VHH)LJXUH DUHEDVHGRQWKHPD[LPXPVWUHVVLQWHQVLW\\DWWKHRXWHUEOHQGUDGLXVIURPWKH

XQLWPRPHQWORDGDQDO\\VLV VHH)LJXUH 6WUHVVSDWKV3DQG3DUHVHOHFWHGEHFDXVHWKHVHSDWKV

KDYHWKHPD[LPXPVWUHVVLQWHQVLWLHVDWWKHLQVLGHVXUIDFHRIWKHQR))OH VHH)LJXUH 6WUHVVSDWKV3

DQG3DUHDOVRFRQVLGHUHGDVFULWLFDOVWUHVVSDWKVVLQFHWKH\\FRUUHVSRQGWRWKHDSSUR[LPDWHFHQWHURI

WKHQR))OHWRYHVVHOZHOGV

$16<6PDFUR*HQVWUHVVPDFLVXVHGWRH[WUDFWWKHVWUHVVHVIRUHDFKSDWK,QWKHFRRUGLQDWHV\\VWHP

56<6 WKH]D[LVLVRULHQWHGDORQJWKH539D[LV)RUVWUHVVSDWKV33DQG3WKHKRRSVWUHVV

       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













6<LVH[WUDFWHG)RUVWUHVVSDWKV33DQG3WKHD[LDOVWUHVV6=LVH[WUDFWHG7KHRXWSXWFRQVLVWV

RIWKLUGRUGHUSRO\\QRPLDOVWUHVVFRHIILFLHQWVLQWKHVXSSRUWLQJILOHV VHH$SSHQGL[$ DQGLVXVHGLQWKH

3)0DQDO\\VLV



352%$%,/,67,&)5$&785(0(&+$1,&6(9$/8$7,21

7KHSUREDELOLVWLFHYDOXDWLRQLVSHUIRUPHGIRUWKHFDVHRILQVSHFWLRQIRUWKHH[WHQGHGRSHUDWLQJ

SHULRGRI\\HDUV



)RUWKHQR))OHEOHQGUDGLXVUHJLRQDQR))OHEOHQGUDGLXVFUDFNPRGHOIURP5HIHUHQFH>@LVXVHGLQWKH

SUREDELOLVWLFIUDFWXUHPHFKDQLFVHYDOXDWLRQ)RUWKLVORFDWLRQDQGFUDFNPRGHOWKHDSSOLFDEOHVWUHVVLV

WKHVWUHVVSHUSHQGLFXODUWRDSDWKGHILQHGGHJUHHVIURPWKHWDQJHQWGUDZQDWWKHEOHQGUDGLXV



)RUWKHQR))OHWRVKHOOZHOGHLWKHUDFLUFXPIHUHQWLDORUDQD[LDOFUDFNGHSHQGLQJRQZHOGRULHQWDWLRQ

FDQLQLWLDWHGXHWRHLWKHUFRPSRQHQWIDEULFDWLRQ LHFRQVLGHULQJRQO\\ZHOGLQJSURFHVV RUVWUHVV

FRUURVLRQFUDFNLQJ7KHSUREDELOLW\\RIIDLOXUHIRUDFLUFXPIHUHQWLDOFUDFNLVOHVVWKDQDQD[LDOFUDFNGXH

WRWKHGLIIHUHQFHLQWKHVWUHVV KRRSYHUVXVD[LDO DQGWKHLQIOXHQFHRQWKHFUDFNPRGHO+RZHYHUWKLV

SUREDELOLVWLFIUDFWXUHPHFKDQLFVHYDOXDWLRQIRUWKHQR))OHDQGYHVVHOVKHOOZHOGFRQVLGHUVERWK

FLUFXPIHUHQWLDODQGD[LDOFUDFNV GHSHQGLQJRQZHOGRULHQWDWLRQ 



$QD[LDOHOOLSWLFDOFUDFNPRGHOZLWKDFUDFNDVSHFWUDWLRRIDO LVXVHGLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQIRUWKH

QR))OHWRVKHOOZHOG7KHLQVSHFWLRQSUREDELOLW\\RIGHWHFWLRQ 3R' FXUYHIURP5HIHUHQFH>)LJXUH

@ VHH7DEOH LVXWLOL]HGZLWKDWHQ\\HDULQVSHFWLRQLQWHUYDO7KHFDOFXODWLRQRIVWUHVVLQWHQVLW\\IDFWRU

LVDWWKHGHHSHVWSRLQWRIWKHFUDFN



7KHDSSURDFKXVHGIRUWKLVHYDOXDWLRQLVFRQVLVWHQWZLWKWKHPHWKRGRORJ\\SUHVHQWHGLQ%:59,3>@

$0RQWH&DUORVLPXODWLRQLVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJDYDULDQWRIWKH9,3(5SURJUDP>@7KH0RQWH&DUOR

PHWKRGFDQEHXVHGWRVROYHSUREDELOLVWLFSUREOHPVXVLQJGHWHUPLQLVWLFFRPSXWDWLRQ$PHDQYDOXH

VWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQDQGGLVWULEXWLRQFXUYHDVGHILQHGLQWKHUDQGRPYDULDEOHVVXPPDU\\ 7DEOH GHILQHV

DVHWRISRVVLEOHLQSXWVDQGWKHLUSUREDELOLWLHVRIRFFXUULQJ8VLQJWKLVGRPDLQRISRVVLEOHLQSXWVDVHW

RILQSXWVDUHJHQHUDWHGIRUXVHLQGHWHUPLQLQJZKHWKHUWKHQR))OHZLOOIDLOXVLQJFRQYHQWLRQDO

GHWHUPLQLVWLFIUDFWXUHPHFKDQLFVPHWKRGRORJ\\7KHQXPEHURIVLPXODWLRQVLQZKLFKWKHQR))OHLV

GHWHUPLQHGWRIDLOGLYLGHGE\\WKHQXPEHURIVLPXODWLRQVUXQJLYHVWKHSUREDELOLW\\RIIDLOXUH



7KH9,3(5SURJUDPZDVGHYHORSHGDVSDUWRIWKH%:59,3>@HIIRUWIRU%RLOLQJ:DWHU5HDFWRU

%:5 UHDFWRUSUHVVXUHYHVVHO 539 VKHOOZHOGLQVSHFWLRQUHFRPPHQGDWLRQV7KHVRIWZDUHZDV

PRGLILHGLQWRDVHSDUDWHYHUVLRQLGHQWLILHGDV9,3(512=IRUXVHLQWKLVHYDOXDWLRQ7KHGHWDLOHG

GHVFULSWLRQRIWKHPHWKRGRORJ\\LQFRUSRUDWHGLQWKH9,3(59,3(512=SURJUDPLVGRFXPHQWHGLQ

5HIHUHQFHV>@DQG>@7KHPRGLILHGVRIWZDUHIRUWKLVSURMHFWLVLGHQWLILHGDV9,3(512=WRGLVWLQJXLVK

IURPWKHRULJLQDO9,3(5VRIWZDUHDQGLVYHULILHGRQDSURMHFWVSHFLILFEDVLV>@WRHQVXUHWKH

PRGLILFDWLRQVPDGHWRWKH9,3(5VRIWZDUHDUHIXOO\\TXDOLW\\DVVXUHG







       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















3)0$VVXPSWLRQV

7KHIROORZLQJDVVXPSWLRQVXVHGLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQDUHEDVHGRQSUHYLRXV%:59,3GHYHORSPHQW

SURMHFWV'HWDLOVRIHDFKDVVXPSWLRQDUHSURYLGHG

 )ODZVDUHDVVXPHGWREHDOLJQHGSDUDOOHOZLWKWKHZHOGGLUHFWLRQDVMXVWLILHGLQ%:59,33>@

 2QHVWUHVVFRUURVLRQFUDFNLQLWLDWLRQDQGIDEULFDWLRQIODZVDUHDVVXPHGSHUQR))OHEOHQG

UDGLXVDVMXVWLILHGLQ%:59,3$6(5>@

 2QHVWUHVVFRUURVLRQFUDFNLQLWLDWLRQDQGIDEULFDWLRQIODZLVDVVXPHGSHUQR))OHVKHOOZHOGDV

MXVWLILHGLQ%:59,3$>@

 7KH15&3UHVVXUH9HVVHO5HVHDUFK8VHUV¶)DFLOLW\\ 3958) IODZVL]HGLVWULEXWLRQDUHDVVXPHG

WRDSSO\\DVMXVWLILHGLQ(35,5HSRUW:(35,>@

 7KHZHOGUHVLGXDOVWUHVVGLVWULEXWLRQDWWKHQR))OHVKHOOZHOGLVDVVXPHGWREHDFRVLQH

GLVWULEXWLRQWKURXJKWKHZDOOWKLFNQHVVZLWKNVLPHDQDPSOLWXGHDQGNVLVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ

IURP%:59,3$>@

 8SSHUVKHOIIUDFWXUHWRXJKQHVVLVVHWWRNVLLQZLWKDVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQRINVLLQIRUXQ

LUUDGLDWHGPDWHULDOFRQVLVWHQWZLWK%:59,3$>@

 6WDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQRIWKHPHDQ.,&LVVHWWRSHUFHQWRIWKHPHDQYDOXHRIWKH.,&DVMXVWLILHG

LQ%:59,3$6(5>@







       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















'HVLJQ,QSXWV

6HFWLRQSUHVHQWVWKHLQSXWVPRGHOHGGHWHUPLQLVWLFDOO\\DVFRQVWDQWVDQG6HFWLRQGHVFULEHV

WKHSUREDELOLVWLFLQSXWVFRQVLGHUHGWREHUDQGRPYDULDEOHV



'HWHUPLQLVWLF3DUDPHWHUV

7DEOHVXPPDUL]HVWKH&*6):GLPHQVLRQVIURPWKHQR))OHGUDZLQJV>@DQGQRUPDORSHUDWLQJ

FRQGLWLRQVIURPWKHWKHUPDOF\\FOHGLDJUDPV>@7KH/723HYHQWSUHVVXUHDQGWHPSHUDWXUHDUH

VSHFLILHGLQWKH%:59,336DIHW\\(YDOXDWLRQ>@



0RUHGHWDLOHGLQSXWSDUDPHWHUVXVHGIRULQVHUYLFHLQVSHFWLRQ ,6, LQWHUYDOIDWLJXHF\\FOHVDQGVWUHVV

GLVWULEXWLRQVDUHGHVFULEHGLQWKHIROORZLQJVHFWLRQV

,Q6HUYLFH,QVSHFWLRQ

LQVSHFWLRQIRU\\HDUVLVXVHG7KHSUREDELOLW\\RIGHWHFWLRQ 3R' GLVWULEXWLRQIXQFWLRQDVVRFLDWHG

ZLWKLQVSHFWLRQLVVKRZQLQ7DEOH>@

 6WUHVVHV

6WUHVVHVGXHWRLQWHUQDOSUHVVXUHDQGWKHUPDOWUDQVLHQWVZHUHGHWHUPLQHGLQWKHVWUHVVDQDO\\VLV>@

&RHIILFLHQWVRIOLQHDUL]HGVWUHVVSDWKVDUHREWDLQHGIRUWKH3)0DQDO\\VLV

 :HOG5HVLGXDO6WUHVVHV

&RQVLVWHQWZLWK%:59,3$>@WKHZHOGUHVLGXDOVWUHVVHV :56 DUHDVVXPHGSUHVHQWLQWKH

QR))OHWRVKHOOZHOGVIRU3DWKVDQG7KH:56GLVWULEXWLRQDWWKHQR))OHVKHOOZHOGLVDVVXPHGWREH

DFRVLQHGLVWULEXWLRQWKURXJKWKHZDOOWKLFNQHVVZLWKNVLPHDQDPSOLWXGHDQGNVLVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ

VHH)LJXUH 1R:56LVSUHVHQWLQWKHQR))OHEOHQGUDGLXVUHJLRQIRU3DWKVDQGDQGQR))OH

LQVLGHVXUIDFHWRWKHRXWHUEOHQGUDGLXV3DWKVDQG





5DQGRP9DULDEOHV

5DQGRPYDULDEOHVXVHGLQWKH1HYDOXDWLRQDUHVXPPDUL]HGLQ7DEOH0RUHGHWDLOHGLQSXW

SDUDPHWHUVXVHGIRU6&&,QLWLDWLRQ6&&*URZWKDQGIDWLJXHFUDFNJURZWKDUHGHVFULEHGLQWKHIROORZLQJ

VHFWLRQV

 0DWHULDO&KHPLVWU\\

7DEOHSUHVHQWVWKHZHOGFKHPLVWULHV &XDQG1L DORQJZLWKWKHVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQDQG

GLVWULEXWLRQVIRUWKHQR))OHIRUJLQJDQGWKHQR))OHWRYHVVHOZHOGVZKLFKDUHIURP%:59,3$

6DIHW\\(YDOXDWLRQ>@

 )OXHQFH

7KH&*6):QR))OH 1 H[SHULHQFHVIOXHQFH^^;;;;;;;;;;;;;``QFPIRU\\HDUVRISODQW

RSHUDWLRQ>@$VVXFKDERXQGHGIOXHQFHRI(QFPLVXVHGIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIWKH

IHHGZDWHUQR))OHV





>D@

       

tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

info@structi nt.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













 6WUHVV&RUURVLRQ&UDFNLQJ,QLWLDWLRQ

7KHVWUHVVFRUURVLRQFUDFNLQJ 6&& LQLWLDWLRQPRGHOLQWKH9,3(512=SURJUDPLVDSRZHUODZ

UHODWLRQVKLS7KHFDVWVWDLQOHVVVWHHO6&&GDWDLQD%:5HQYLURQPHQWLVXVHGDVVSHFLILHGLQ%:59,3

>6HFWLRQ@DQGXVHGLQ%:59,3$>@DQG%:59,3$>@7KLVPRGHOKDVWKH

IRUP

















 



ZKHUH

7 WLPHKRXUV

 DSSOLHGVWUHVVNVL



7KHUHVLGXDOSORWVKRZVWKDWDORJQRUPDOGLVWULEXWLRQSURGXFHVWKHEHVWILWIRUWKHGDWD7KHORJQRUPDO

UHVLGXDOSORWZLWKWKHOLQHDUILWRIWKHGDWDLVVKRZQEHORZ

















 





ZKHUH

  [+/- 

 GDWDPHDQ

 GDWDVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ

[ OQ 7DFWXDO7SUHGLFWHG 



 6WUHVV&RUURVLRQ&UDFNLQJ*URZWK

7KH6&&JURZWKPRGHOLQ9,3(512=SURJUDPLVDSRZHUODZUHODWLRQVKLSIURP185(*&5>@

7KHUHODWLRQVKLSXVHGLV

















 





ZKHUH

GDGW VWUHVVFRUURVLRQFUDFNJURZWKUDWHLQKU

.

VXVWDLQHGFUDFNWLSVWUHVVLQWHQVLW\\IDFWRUNVLLQ





7KHUHVLGXDOSORWVKRZVWKDWD:HLEXOOGLVWULEXWLRQSURGXFHVWKHEHVWILWIRUWKHGDWD7KH:HLEXOO

UHVLGXDOSORWZLWKWKHOLQHDUILWRIWKHGDWDLVVKRZQEHORZ

















 



ZKHUH

<

OQ OQ  )  

)

FXPXODWLYHGLVWULEXWLRQIURPWR

[

OQ GDGW DFWXDO GDGW SUHGLFWHG 













       

tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

info@structi nt.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















 )DWLJXH&UDFN*URZWK

7KHIDWLJXHFUDFNJURZWKGDWDIRU6$*UDGH%&ODVVDQG6$&ODVV FDUERQPRO\\EGHQXP

VWHHOV LQDUHDFWRUZDWHUHQYLURQPHQWVDUHUHSRUWHGLQ5HIHUHQFH>@IRUZHOGPHWDOWHVWLQJDWDQ5

UDWLR DOJHEUDLFUDWLRRI.PLQ.PD[³5' RIDQG7RSURGXFHDIDWLJXHFUDFNJURZWKODZDQG

GLVWULEXWLRQIRUWKH9,3(512=VRIWZDUHWKHGDWDIRU5 ZDVILWWHGLQWRWKHIRUPRI3DULV/DZ7KH

5 IDWLJXHFUDFNJURZWKODZZDVFKRVHQIRUFRQVHUYDWLVP7KHFXUYHILWUHVXOWRIWKHPHDQIDWLJXH

FUDFNJURZWKODZLVSUHVHQWHGZLWKWKH3DULVODZVKRZQDVIROORZV















 







ZKHUH 



D FUDFNGHSWKLQ







Q F\\FOHV







'. .PD[+/-.PLQNVLLQ



$FRPSDULVRQWRWKH$60(6HFWLRQ;,IDWLJXHFUDFNJURZWKODZLQDUHDFWRUZDWHUHQYLURQPHQWLV

GRFXPHQWHGLQ5HIHUHQFH>@DQGLWVKRZVDUHDVRQDEOHFRPSDULVRQZKHUHWKH6HFWLRQ;,ODZLVPRUH

FRQVHUYDWLYHRQJURZWKUDWHDWKLJK'.



8VLQJWKHUDQNRUGHUHGUHVLGXDOSORWLWLVVKRZQWKDWD:HLEXOOGLVWULEXWLRQLVUHSUHVHQWDWLYHIRUWKHGDWD

7KH:HLEXOOUHVLGXDOSORWZLWKWKHOLQHDUFXUYHILWRIWKHGDWDLVVKRZQEHORZ

















 





ZKHUH 



\\ OQ OQ  ) 







[ OQ GDGQ DFWXDO GDGQ PHDQ 







) FXPXODWLYHSUREDELOLW\\GLVWULEXWLRQ











       

tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

info@structi nt.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















5(68/76$1'&21&/86,216



7DEOHSUHVHQWVWKHUHVXOWVRIWKHSUREDELOLVWLFIUDFWXUHPHFKDQLFVHYDOXDWLRQIRUQRUPDORSHUDWLRQDQG

/723HYHQWV



)RUQRUPDORSHUDWLRQIRUDOOSDWKVDWWKHQR))OHEOHQGUDGLXVDQGWKHQR))OHWRVKHOOZHOGQRIDLOXUHV

RFFXUUHGLQPLOOLRQVLPXODWLRQVIRU\\HDUVZLWKLQVSHFWLRQ7KHSUREDELOLW\\RIIDLOXUH 3R) IRU

QRUPDORSHUDWLRQLVFDOFXODWHGWREHOHVVWKDQIDLOXUHPLOOLRQVLPXODWLRQV\\HDUV [SHU

\\HDU7KHFDOFXODWHG3R)IRUQRUPDORSHUDWLRQIRUDOOSDWKVLVOHVVWKDQWKHDOORZDEOH3R)RISHU

\\HDUDQGPHHWVWKHDFFHSWDQFHFULWHULRQIURP185(*>@



)RU/723HYHQWVIRU3DWKDWWKHQR))OHWRVKHOOZHOG/723IDLOXUHVRFFXUUHGLQPLOOLRQVLPXODWLRQV

IRU\\HDUVZLWKLQVSHFWLRQ7KHFRQGLWLRQDOSUREDELOLW\\RIIDLOXUH 3R) IRU/723HYHQWVIRU3DWK

LVFDOFXODWHGWREHIDLOXUHVPLOOLRQVLPXODWLRQV\\HDUV [SHU\\HDU$FFRXQWLQJIRUDQ

/723HYHQWRFFXUUHQFHRI[SHU\\HDU>SJ@WKHFDOFXODWHG3R)IRU/723HYHQWVIRU3DWK

LV[SHU\\HDUZKLFKLVOHVVWKDQWKHDOORZDEOH3R)RISHU\\HDUDQGPHHWVWKH

DFFHSWDQFHFULWHULRQIURP185(*>@



)RU/723HYHQWVIRUDOORWKHUSDWKVDWWKHQR))OHEOHQGUDGLXVDQGWKHQR))OHWRVKHOOZHOGQRIDLOXUHV

RFFXUUHGLQPLOOLRQVLPXODWLRQVIRU\\HDUVZLWKLQVSHFWLRQ7KXVIRUDOORWKHUSDWKVWKH

FDOFXODWHG3R)IRU/723HYHQWVLVOHVVWKDQ[SHU\\HDUZKLFKLVOHVVWKDQWKHDOORZDEOH3R)

RISHU\\HDUDQGPHHWVWKHDFFHSWDQFHFULWHULRQIURP185(*>@



7KXVWKHIHHGZDWHUQR))OHVDUHTXDOLILHGIRUUHGXFHGLQVSHFWLRQXVLQJ$60(&RGH&DVH1

WKURXJKWKHSHULRGRIH[WHQGHGRSHUDWLRQ









       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















5()(5(1&(6

 $60(&RGH&DVH1³$OWHUQDWLYH5HTXLUHPHQWVIRU%RLOLQJ:DWHU5HDFWRU %:5 1R))OH,QQHU

5DGLXVDQG1R))OHWR6KHOO:HOGV6HFWLRQ;,'LYLVLRQ')HEUXDU\\

 8615&5HSRUW5HYLVLRQ%:5)HHGZDWHU1R))OHDQG&RQWURO5RG'ULYH5HWXUQ/LQH1R))OH

&UDFNLQJ5HVROXWLRQRI*HQHULF7HFKQLFDO$FWLYLW\\$185(*1XFOHDU5HJXODWRU\\

&RPPLVVLRQ 15& 1RYHPEHU

 %:59,3$%:59HVVHODQG,QWHUQDOV3URMHFW7HFKQLFDO%DVLVIRUWKH5HGXFWLRQRI,QVSHFWLRQ

5HTXLUHPHQWVIRUWKH%RLOLQJ:DWHU5HDFWRU1R))OHWR9HVVHO6KHOO:HOGVDQG1R))OH%OHQG5DGLL

(35,3DOR$OWR&$&$((35,35235,(7$5<

 %:59,3$%:59HVVHO,QWHUQDO3URMHFW3UREDELOLVWLF)UDFWXUH0HFKDQLFV(YDOXDWLRQIRUWKH

%RLOLQJ:DWHU5HDFWRU1R))OHWR9HVVHO6KHOO:HOGVDQG1R))OH%OHQG5DGLL(35,3DOR$OWR&$

((35,35235,(7$5<

 %:59,3/HWWHUIURP13DOP (35, WR'5XGODQGDQG35D\\QDXG 8615& :KLWH

3DSHURQ6XJJHVWHG&RQWHQWIRU3)06XEPLWWDOVWRWKH15&)HEUXDU\\$'$06

$FFHVVLRQ1R0/$

 6,&DOFXODWLRQ5HYLVLRQ³9HULILFDWLRQRI6RIWZDUH9,3(512=9HUVLRQ'

 %:59,35HSRUW³%:55HDFWRU3UHVVXUH9HVVHO6KHOO:HOG,QVSHFWLRQ5HFRPPHQGDWLRQV

%:59,33 '(OHFWULF3RZHU5HVHDUFK,QVWLWXWH756HSWHPEHU((35,

35235,(7$5<

 'HOYLQ6$5LFFDUGHOOD3&µ)UDFWXUHPHFKDQLFVDQDO\\VLVRI-$(5,PRGHOSUHVVXUHYHVVHOWHVW¶

$60(393&RQIHUHQFH3DSHU393

 6,&DOFXODWLRQ3DFNDJH1R5HYLVLRQ³/RDGLQJIRU&*6)HHGZDWHU1R))OH

$QDO\\VLV'

6,&DOFXODWLRQ3DFNDJH1R5HYLVLRQ³)LQLWH(OHPHQW0RGHORI&*6)HHGZDWHU

1R))OH$QDO\\VLV'

6,&DOFXODWLRQ3DFNDJH1R5HYLVLRQ³)LQLWH(OHPHQW7KHUPDODQG6WUHVV$QDO\\VLV

RI&*6)HHGZDWHU1R))OH'

9,3(59HVVHO,QVSHFWLRQ3URJUDP(YDOXDWLRQIRU5HOLDELOLW\\9HUVLRQ $SULO 6WUXFWXUDO

,QWHJULW\\$VVRFLDWHV

&%,1XFOHDU&RPSDQ\\'UDZLQJ93)1R5HYLVLRQ &9,1R%VKUHY

 11R))OH$VVHPEO\\ )HHGZDWHU 6,)LOH1R

&%,1XFOHDU&RPSDQ\\'UDZLQJ93)1R5HYLVLRQ &9,1R%VKUHY 

³6KHOO5LQJ$VVHPEO\\'6,)LOH1R

'RF1R&9,%*('UDZLQJ1R(6KHHW5HYLVLRQ5HDFWRU9HVVHO

7KHUPDO&\\FOHV6,)LOH1R

(QHUJ\\1RUWKZHVW'RFXPHQW1R(13( QRUHYLVLRQQR &HUWLILHG6SHFLILFDWLRQIRU

'\\QDPLFVDQG7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQWV'XHWR3RZHU8SUDWH085DQG<HDU3URMHFWHG&\\FOHV

6,)LOH1R



       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













8615&5HSRUW³)LQDO6DIHW\\(YDOXDWLRQRIWKH%:59HVVHO,QWHUQDOV3URMHFW%:59,35HSRUW'

7$&1R0'LYLVLRQRI(QJLQHHULQJ2IILFHRI1XFOHDU5HDFWRU5HJXODWLRQ1XFOHDU5HJXODWRU\\

&RPPLVVLRQ-XO\\

(35,5HSRUW1R:(35,³(YDOXDWLRQRIHIIHFWRILQVSHFWLRQRQWKHSUREDELOLW\\RIIDLOXUHIRU

%:51R))OHWR6KHOO:HOGVDQG1R))OH%OHQG5DGLL5HJLRQ'5HYLVLRQ

7HFKQLFDO%DVLVIRU5HYLVLRQRI3UHVVXUL]HG7KHUPDO6KRFN 376 6FUHHQLQJ/LPLWLQWKH3765XOH

&)5 185(*9RO$XJXVW

'HVLJQ,QSXW5HTXHVW1)HHGZDWHU1R))OH(YDOXDWLRQIRU&ROXPELD'HVLJQ,QSXW5HTXHVW

6,)LOH1R

185(*&5$SSHQGL[%³([SHUW3DQHO5HSRUWRQ3URDFWLYH0DWHULDOV'HJUDGDWLRQ

$VVHVVPHQW'3XEOLVKHG)HEUXDU\\

%DPIRUG:+³$SSOLFDWLRQRIFRUURVLRQIDWLJXHFUDFNJURZWKUDWHGDWDWRLQWHJULW\\DQDO\\VHVRI

QXFOHDUUHDFWRUYHVVHOV'-RXUQDORI(QJLQHHULQJ0DWHULDOVDQG7HFKQRORJ\\9RO6,)LOH

1R

(35,/HWWHU³%:59,36XSSRUWRI$60(&RGH&DVH1,QVHUYLFH,QVSHFWLRQ5HOLHI'

$XJXVW6,)LOH1R



       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













7DEOH7UDQVLHQW'HILQLWLRQV(YHQWVWKURXJK>@















K%WXKUIW)

7UDQVLHQW

WVHF 7):) 7$) 3):SVLJ 3$SVLJ )JSP  GLDP aGLDP



















'HVLJQK\\GURWHVW

























































































6WDUWXS





























































































































7XUELQHUROOSDUW



































7XUELQHUROOSDUW





























































































































'DLO\\UHGXFWLRQSDUW



































'DLO\\UHGXFWLRQSDUW



































HHNO\\UHGXFWLRQSDUW 

































HHNO\\UHGXFWLRQSDUW 

































7XUELQHWULSSDUW

























































































7XUELQHWULSSDUW







































































3DUWLDO)+%SDUW



































3DUWLDO)+%SDUW



















       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













7DEOH7UDQVLHQW'HILQLWLRQV(YHQWVWKURXJK>@















K%WXKUIW)

7UDQVLHQW

WVHF 7):) 7$) 3):SVLJ 3$SVLJ )JSP  GLDP aGLDP



















7*WULSSDUW















































































































































7*WULSRWKHUSDUW







































































2WKHUVFUDPVSDUW















































































































































5HGXFWLRQWRSRZHU





















































+RWVWDQGE\\



































6KXWGRZQQRUPDO06,9VRSHQ

























































































6KXWGRZQYHVVHOIORRGLQJ



































6KXWGRZQ







































































8QEROW



















       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













7DEOH7UDQVLHQW'HILQLWLRQV(YHQWVDQG>@















K%WXKUIW)

7UDQVLHQW

WVHF 7):) 7$) 3):SVLJ 3$SVLJ )JSP  GLDP aGLDP



















/RVVRI):SXPSVSDUW



























































































































































































































































/RVVRI):SXPSVSDUW

























































































6LQJOHUHOLHIRUVDIHW\\YDOYHEORZGRZQ

































































































































































1DWXUDOFLUFVWDUWXS



















       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













7DEOH7UDQVLHQW'HILQLWLRQV(YHQWVDQG>@















K%WXKUIW)

7UDQVLHQW

WVHF

7):)

7$)

3):SVLJ

3$SVLJ

)JSP 

GLDP

aGLDP



















5HDFWRURYHUSUHVVXUH



















































































































































































$XWRPDWLFEORZGRZQ





























































































































,PSURSHUVWDUWXS





























































































































3LSHUXSWXUH









































       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













7DEOH%RXQGLQJ7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQWVRI)HHGZDWHU1R))OH

6RXUFH/RDGLQJIRU&*6)HHGZDWHU1R))OH$QDO\\VLV>@



(YHQW

'HVFULSWLRQ

&\\FOHV

%RXQGLQJ(YHQW

1HZ,'



&\\FOHV

\\HDUV

RIF\\FOHV



'HVLJQK\\GURWHVW



7UDQVLHQW

/7





6WDUWXS





7XUELQHUROO LQFUHDVHWRUDWHGSRZHU





'DLO\\UHGXFWLRQWRSRZHU



7UDQVLHQW

/7





HHNO\\UHGXFWLRQWRSRZHU





5RGSDWWHUQFKDQJH





7XUELQHWULSIURPORDGZ

E\\SDVV



7UDQVLHQW

/7





3DUWLDOIHHGZDWHUKHDWHUE\\SDVV





2WKHUVFUDPV





5HGXFWLRQWRSRZHU





+RWVWDQGE\\06,9VRSHQ





6KXWGRZQQRUPDO06,9VRSHQ





6KXWGRZQYHVVHOIORRGLQJ





6KXWGRZQ





8QEROW IRUUHIXHOLQJ 





6LQJOHUHOLHIRUVDIHW\\YDOYHEORZGRZQ





1DWXUDOFLUFVWDUWXS





7XUELQHJHQHUDWRUWULS



7UDQVLHQW

7





/RVVRI):SXPSVLVRYDOYHFORVH



7UDQVLHQW

7





5HDFWRURYHUSUHVVXUH



7UDQVLHQW

/7





$XWRPDWLFEORZGRZQ





,PSURSHUVWDUWXS



7UDQVLHQW

/7





3LSHUXSWXUH







       

tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

info@structi nt.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













7DEOH0DWHULDO3URSHUWLHV0HWDOV>@

'HVFULSWLRQ

7)

N%78KUÂIWÂ) 

&S%WXOEP)

LQLQ)

(SVL

&DUERQDQGORZDOOR\\VWHHO 















































































































































6WDLQOHVVVWHHO











WKHUPDOVOHHYH











6$JUDGH) &U1L 











FODGDVVXPHGHTXLYDOHQW











































































































1LFNHOEDVHGDOOR\\











VDIHHQGVWVDIHHQG











H[WHQVLRQDQGWKHUPDOVOHHYH











H[WHQVLRQ











6% 1L&U)H 































































































  • HQHUDOQRWHV

7 WHPSHUDWXUH( PRGXOXVRIHODVWLFLW\\D PHDQFRHIILFLHQWRIWKHUPDOH[SDQVLRQN FRQGXFWLYLW\\&S VSHFLILF

KHDW'HQVLW\\LVOEPLQIRUFDUERQDQGORZDOOR\\VWHHOOEPLQIRUVWDLQOHVVVWHHODQGOEPLQIRU

QLFNHOEDVHGDOOR\\>@(YDOXHVDUHOLQHDUO\\LQWHUSRODWHGDW)

7KHVHYDOXHVDUHFRQYHUWHGWR%78VHFLQ)IRULQSXWWR$16<6

)RUFDUERQDQGORZDOOR\\VWHHOWKHWKUHH(YDOXHVDUHIURPWKH$60(&RGH>@DQGDUHDVIROORZV



VWYDOXHSLSLQJ6$JUDGH% &PD[ 



QGYDOXHQGVDIHHQGH[WHQVLRQ6$FODVV, &0Q6L&PD[ 



UGYDOXHYHVVHO6$JUDGH%FODVV &0Q0R1L 6$FODVV,, &0R&U1L 





       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















7DEOH0DWHULDO3URSHUWLHV:DWHU(OHPHQWV>@

7)

&S%WXOEP)

UOEPIW









































































  • HQHUDOQRWHV

7 WHPSHUDWXUH&S VSHFLILFKHDWU GHQVLW\\

&RQGXFWLYLW\\LV%WXKUIW)9DOXHVDUHOLQHDUO\\LQWHUSRODWHGDW)







       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













7DEOH5DQGRP9DULDEOHV3DUDPHWHU6XPPDU\\

5DQGRP3DUDPHWHU

0HDQ

6WG'HY

'LVWULEXWLRQ

5HI

)ODZGHQVLW\\QR))OHVKHOO

ZHOG IDEULFDWLRQ 

SHUZHOG

0HDQ

3RLVVRQ

>@

)ODZGHQVLW\\QR))OHDQG

QR))OHVKHOOZHOG 6&&

LQLWLDWLRQ 

SHUZHOG

0HDQ

3RLVVRQ

>@

)ODZGHQVLW\\QR))OHEOHQG

UDGLXV IDEULFDWLRQ 

SHUQR))OH

0HDQ

3RLVVRQ

>@

)ODZVL]H IDEULFDWLRQ 

QD

QD

3958)

>@

HOGUHVLGXDOVWUHVV

WKURXJKZDOO NVL 



LQVLGHVXUIDFH

FRVLQHGLVWULEXWLRQ



1RUPDO

>@

1QR))OH

WRVKHOO

ZHOG

&X





1RUPDO

>@

1L





1RUPDO

>@

,QLWLDO57QGW

q) 





1RUPDO

>@

1QR))OH

IRUJLQJ

&X





1RUPDO

>@

1L





1RUPDO

>@

,QLWLDO57QGW

q) 





1RUPDO

>@

)DVWQHXWURQIOXHQFH

QFP 

H

  

QD

>@

.,&XSSHUVKHOI NVLLQ 





1RUPDO

>@

6&&LQLWLDWLRQWLPH KU 

7 [ V 

5HVLGXDO

\\ [



/RJQRUPDO

>@

6&&* LQKU 

.GHSHQGHQW

GDGW [ . 

.!NVLLQ

5HVLGXDO

\\ [



HLEXOO

>@

.LQGHSHQGHQW

GDGW [

.NVLLQ

QD

QD

>@

6&&WKUHVKROG NVLLQ 





1RUPDO

>@

)DWLJXHFUDFNJURZWK )&* 

LQF\\FOH 

GDGQ 

[ G. 

5HVLGXDO

\\ [



HLEXOO

>@

)&*WKUHVKROG NVLLQ 





1RUPDO

>@





       

tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

info@structi nt.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















7DEOH'HWHUPLQLVWLF3DUDPHWHU6XPPDU\\























1RWH7KHIHHGZDWHUQRUPDORSHUDWLQJWHPSHUDWXUHLVXVHGDVDFRQVHUYDWLYHDSSURDFKFRPSDUHGWRWKH

QRUPDORSHUDWLQJWHPSHUDWXUHRIWKHUHDFWRUSUHVVXUHYHVVHO SVLJ >@



7DEOH3UREDELOLW\\RI'HWHFWLRQ 3R' 'LVWULEXWLRQ>@

)ODZ6L]HLQ

&XPXODWLYH3R'



























































3DUDPHWHU

9DOXH

5HI

'LPHQVLRQV

9HVVHO7KLFNQHVV H[FOXGHVFODGGLQJ 

LQFKHV

GHULYHGIURP>@

9HVVHO5DGLXV WRYHVVHOVXUIDFH 

LQFKHV

>@

9HVVHO&ODG7KLFNQHVV

LQFKHV

GHULYHGIURP>@

2SHUDWLQJ&RQGLWLRQV

1RUPDO2SHUDWLQJ7HPSHUDWXUH 5HJLRQ$ 

)

>@

1RUPDO2SHUDWLQJ3UHVVXUH ):6LGH 

SVLJ

>@

/723(YHQW7HPSHUDWXUH

)

>@

/723(YHQW3UHVVXUH

SVLJ

>@

       

tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

info@structi nt.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















7DEOH3UREDELOLW\\RI)DLOXUHIRU3HULRGRI([WHQGHG2SHUDWLRQ



/RFDWLRQ

33DWK

3UREDELOLW\\RI)DLOXUH 3R) 

LQVSHFWLRQIRU\\HDUVRI3(2

$OORZDEOH3R)SHU

\\HDUIURP

185(*>@

3R)SHU\\HDUGXHWR

1RUPDO2SHUDWLRQ  

3R)SHU\\HDUGXHWR

/723(YHQW    

1R))OH%OHQG5DGLXV

3







3





1R))OH,QVLGH6XUIDFH

WR2XWHU%OHQG5DGLXV

3





3





1R))OHWR6KHOO:HOG

3





3





1RWHV

 

)RUVWUHVVSDWK3/723IDLOXUHVRFFXUUHGLQPLOOLRQVLPXODWLRQVZLWKLQVSHFWLRQIRU

\\HDUV)RUDOORWKHUSDWKVQR/723RUQRUPDORSHUDWLRQIDLOXUHVRFFXUUHGLQPLOOLRQVLPXODWLRQV

ZLWKLQVSHFWLRQIRU\\HDUV

 

7KH/7233R)DFFRXQWVIRUDSUREDELOLW\\RI/723HYHQWRFFXUUHQFHSHU\\HDU

>SJ@







       

tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

info@structi nt.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



















)LJXUH):1R))OH*HRPHWU\\>@

       

0 711e"

© NOZZLE, SA-508, Cl.II (D

SAFE ENCi, SB-166, INCONEL (D

THERMAL SLEEVE EXTENSION, SB-166

© THERMAL SLEEVE, SA-336, CI.F0

@ SA FE END E)(TENS! ON, SB - 1u.

SM£ END l:XTEt--lS r N, SA-508 1 C1. i 3"

9 '8 II 9 13.: 3'2.

lJ)

~

jO b 3Y."

..,.__ r 1, lJj

.:i O',

lJI

(;J

)}!

l1l

01)

~

o 7s)

© 2q,

-2. 13t





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('









































3LSLQJORDGV5 







7KHUPDOVOHHYHORDGV5 





)LJXUH3LSLQJDQG7KHUPDO6OHHYH,QWHUIDFH/RDGV>@







       

tr Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



















)LJXUH)LQLWH(OHPHQW0RGHO>@













       

1 El.EJvlENTS MAT NUM Columbia Ferowater Nozzle (J

Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

3 El.EJvlENTS MAT NUM ANSYS R14.5 MAR 29 2019 08:18:08 Plill NO.

1 ANSYS R14.5 MAR 29 2019 08:18:08 Plill NO.

1 info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















)LJXUH$SSOLHG3UHVVXUHDQG%RXQGDU\\&RQGLWLRQV9HVVHODQG$QQXODU3UHVVXUH>@







       

1 ELEJvlENTS MAT NUM u

PRES

- 9408.69

- 6370.5

-7889.6 Columbia Feedwater Nozzle (J

Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

LL1 11

.Llllllll I I I I I I I ILLt[J 1:~~:::11111111111;:

M,/!!l!!!J!!l!!m !H~!!I!!i!

l!!J!Mll!l!l!l!lm!l!!U!!J!J!!ll!

ANSYS R14.5 MAR 13 2019 13:25:03 Pl.ill NO.

1 info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



















)LJXUH7\\SLFDO$SSOLHG+HDW7UDQVIHU&RHIILFLHQWDQG7HPSHUDWXUH3URILOH>@

7RSILJXUHVKRZVKHDWWUDQVIHUFRHIILFLHQWLQ%78 VHFLQ) ORZHUILJXUHVKRZVDSSOLHGWHPSHUDWXUHLQ) 

       

tr Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

.004001

.004606

.005212

.005817

.006423

.007028

.007634

.008239

.008845

.00945 Colmb:iil. Feedwater Nozzle 422.1 436.533 450.967 465.4 479.833 494.267 508.7 523.133 537 -557 552 Colurbia Feedwater Nozzle info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('

























)LJXUH%RXQGDU\\&RQGLWLRQVIRU7KHUPDO6WUHVV$QDO\\VHV>@













       

1 C

(J Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

2 ELEJ:v!ENTS TYPE NlJM u

CP ANSYS R14.5 MAR 19 2019 16:46:54 Plill NO.

1 info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



















)LJXUH6WUHVV,QWHQVLW\\5HVXOWIRU3UHVVXUH/RDGLQJ>@







0D[LPXPVWUHVVLQWHQVLW\\

DW1RGH

       

1 NODAL SOLUTION STEP=l SUB =1 TIME=l SINT (AVG)

DMX =. 08114 SMN =10. 6068 SMX =50855. 4 ANSYS rmu FEB 16 2020 15 : 45 : 48 1 0. 6068 11309. 5 22608. 3 33907. 2 45206 5660. 03 1 6958. 9 28257.7 39556. 6 50855. 4 Col umbi a Feedwater Nozz l e (J

Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



















)LJXUH6WUHVV,QWHQVLW\\5HVXOWEDVHGRQ1R))OH8QLW0RPHQW/RDG>@

7KHILJXUHLVDVSHFLILHGYROXPHRILQWHUHVWUHIHUWR)LJXUHIRUWKHFRPSOHWHPRGHO 































0D[LPXPVWUHVVLQWHQVLW\\

DW1RGH

       

1 NODAL SOLUTION STEP=3 SUB =1 TIME=3 SINT (AVG)

DMX =. 547E- 05 SMN =. 081412 SMX =1. 62702 CP ANSYS Fil~.1 FEB 16 2020 17 : 23 : 25

. 081412

. 424881

. 768349 1. 11182 1. 45529

. 25314 6

. 596615

. 940084 1. 28355 1. 62 702 Col umbi a Feedwat er No zz l e (J

Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



















)LJXUH6WUHVV,QWHQVLW\\5HVXOWEDVHGRQ7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW>@

7KHILJXUHLVDVSHFLILHGYROXPHRILQWHUHVWUHIHUWR)LJXUHIRUWKHFRPSOHWHPRGHO 















0D[LPXPVWUHVVLQWHQVLW\\

DW1RGH

       

1 NODAL SOLUTION STEP=20 SUB =1 TIME=341.7 94 SINT (AVG)

DMX =. 402815 SMN =1694. 89 SMX =26599. 2 ANSYS F/18.1 FEB 16 2020 18 :27: 38 1 694. 89 7229. 18 12763. 5 18297. 8 23832 4462. 04 9996. 32 15530. 6 21064. 9 26599. 2 Col umbia Feedwater Nozzle (J

Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



























)LJXUH6WUHVV([WUDFWLRQ3DWK2ULHQWDWLRQVLQWKH):1R))OH







3

3

3

3

3

3

       

1 ELEMENTS MAT NUM Col umbi a Feedwater Nozz l e (J

Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



























)LJXUH8QLW3UHVVXUH6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV





       

60

-=-

(/)

.::t!

50

(/)

(/)

Q) 40 en O')

C

  • s; 30 0

.::t!

0 (U

20 l) 10 0

(J Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

0.0 0.2 Unit Pressure (Internal) 0.4 0.6 0.8 Normalized path length (inch/inch) 1.0 Path 1 Path 2 Path 3 Path4 Path 5 Path 6 info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



























)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV1R))OH8QLW0RPHQW/RDG











       

6.E-04

=-

4.E-04 VI VI VI 2.E-04 Q)

Cf)

0) 0.E+00 C *s; 0

-2.E-04 0

ro

() -4.E-04

-6.E-04

-8.E-04 tr Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

0.0 0.2 FW Nozzle Unit Moment 0.4 0.6 0.8 Normalized path length (inch/inch) 1.0 Path 1 Path 2 Path 3 Path4 Path 5 Path 6 info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



























)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW









       

60 50

=-

Ill 40

.¥. -

Ill Ill Q) 30 L.. -

(f)

C')

20 C '>

0 10

.¥.

0

<U 0

L..

0

-10

-20 (J

Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

Transient 3 (Start-up)

Path 1 (Max)

1------+*****************************.............................. *****************************-

Path 1 (Min)

Path 2 (Max)

Path 2 (Min)

Path 3 (Max)

Path 3 (Min)

Path 4 (Max)

Path 4 (Min)

Path 5 (Max)

Path 5 (Min)

Path 6 (Max)

Path 6 (Min) 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Normalized path length (inch/inch) info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



























)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW







       

25 20

=-

(/)

.::t:.

15

(/)

(/)

Q)

L.....

10 (f)

C')

C

  • s; 5

0

.::t:.

0 0

ro L..

0

-5

-10 (J

Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

0.0 Transient 6 (Weekly Reduction to 50% power)

Path 1 (Max)

Path 1 (Min)

Path 2 (Max)

Path 2 (Min)

Path 3 (Max)

Path 3 (Min)

Path 4 (Max)

Path 4 (Min)

Path 5 (Max)

Path 5 (Min)

Path 6 (Max)

Path 6 (Min) 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Normalized path length (inch/inch) info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



























)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW'1







       

VI

~

VI VI Q)

L..

Cf)

0)

C

  • s; 0

~

0 ro L..

0 (J

Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

50 40 30 20 10 0

-10

-20 0.0 Transient 1 ODN (Turbine Generator Trip)

Path 1 (Max)

Path 1 (Min)

Path 2 (Max)

Path 2 (Min)

Path 3 (Max)

Path 3 (Min)

Path 4 (Max)

Path 4 (Min)

Path 5 (Max)

Path 5 (Min)

Path 6 (Max)

Path 6 (Min) 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Normalized path length (inch/inch) info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



























)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW







       

50 40

-=-

Ill

~

30 Ill Ill Q) 20 Cl)

O>

C

  • s; 10 0

~

0 0

ro 0

-10

-20 tr Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

0.0 Transient 14 (Hot Standby, MSIVs Open)

Path 1 (Max)

Path 1 (Min)

Path 2 (Max)

Path 2 (Min)

Path 3 (Max)

Path 3 (Min)

Path 4 (Max)

Path 4 (Min)

Path 5 (Max)

Path 5 (Min)

Path 6 (Max)

Path 6 (Min) 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Normalized path length (inch/inch) info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



























)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW





       

VI

~

VI VI Q)

L..

u5

0)

C

  • s; 0

~

0 ro L..

0 Transient20-2 (Loss of FW Pumps lso-ValveClose) 30 - -----------------~

25 -----+-----1---**********

20 -

+------<------>******************************

l----------<

15 10 _.___,__

0

-5

-10 -20 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Normalized path length (inch/inch)

Path 1 (Max)

Path 1 (Min)

Path 2 (Max)

Path 2 (Min)

Path 3 (Max)

Path 3 (Min)

Path 4 (Max)

Path 4 (Min)

Path 5 (Max)

Path 5 (Min)

Path 6 (Max)

Path 6 (Min) tr Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



























)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW











       

40 35 30

(/)

25

(/)

(/)

20 Q)

(/)

15 CJ)

C 10 0

5 0 ro 0

0

-5

-10

-15 (J

Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

0.0 Transient22 (Reactor Overpressure)

Path 1 (Max)

Path 1 (Min)

Path 2 (Max)

Path 2 (Min)

Path 3 (Max)

Path 3 (Min)

Path 4 (Max)

Path 4 (Min)

Path 5 (Max)

Path 5 (Min)

Path 6 (Max)

Path 6 (Min) 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Normalized path length (inch/inch) info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



























)LJXUH7KURXJKZDOO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQV7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQW







       

35 30

=-

25 II)

.::it:. -

20 II)

II)

Q) 15 CJ)

0) 10 C
  • 5 5

0

.::it:.

0 0 ro 0

-5

-10

-15 (J

Structural Integrity Associates. Inc.

0.0 Transient26 (Improper Startup)

Path 1 (Max)

Path 1 (Min)

Path 2 (Max)

Path 2 (Min)

Path 3 (Max)

Path 3 (Min)

Path 4 (Max)

-=*.......

Path 4 (Min)

Path 5 (Max)

Path 5 (Min)

Path 6 (Max)

Path 6 (Min) 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Normalized path length (inch/inch) info@structint.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com G





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJHRI

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('



























)LJXUH:HOG5HVLGXDO6WUHVV'LVWULEXWLRQIRU3DWKVDQG





\\ ([ [  [





























HOG5HVLGXD6WUHVV NVL
HOG7KLFNQHVV LQFK

       

tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

1 info@structi nt.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJH$RI$

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('

















6833257,1*),/(6









       

tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

APPENDIX A info@structi nt.com m 1-877-4SI-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJH$RI$

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('













6WUHVV$QDO\\VLV6XSSRUWLQJ)LOHV



)LOHQDPH

'HVFULSWLRQ

&*6):1LQS

):1R))OHILQLWHHOHPHQWPRGHO

&*6):13UHVVXUH,13

):1R))OHPRGHOXQGHULQWHUQDOSUHVVXUH

0(&+3,3,13

):1R))OHPRGHOXQGHUQR))OHXQLWORDGLQJV

75$16,(176,13

):1R))OHWKHUPDOWUDQVLHQWORDGLQJV

&20321(176,13

,QSXWILOHFRQWDLQLQJVXUIDFHGHILQLWLRQVIRUWKHUPDODQDO\\VHV

7(03/$7(BY0$&

0DFURXVHGWRUXQWKHWUDQVLHQWDQDO\\VHV

  • HQ6WUHVVPDF

0DFURWKDWJHQHUDWHVSRO\\QRPLDOFRHIILFLHQWVRIVWUHVVIRUDOOSDWKV

  • HW3DWKPDF

0DFURWKDWJHQHUDWHVSDWKLQ$16<6$3'/

  • (73$7+7;7

7H[W)LOHWKDWGHILQHVVWUHVVSDWKV

675BB&2(B&69

6WUHVVFRHIILFLHQWVRXWSXWV 

 &*63UHVV 8QLW3UHVVXUHUXQ 

 &*63,3 1R))OH8QLW0RPHQW 

 77'17777

 7KHUPDO7UDQVLHQWUXQ 

 333333

&*6B):1R]B0WKB)DFWRU[O[V

6FDOLQJIDFWRUFDOFXODWLRQIRUWKHPRPHQWGXHWRWKHUPDOH[SDQVLRQ

&*6B):1R]B%RXQGLQJ

7UDQVLHQW6FUHHQLQJ[OV[

6SUHDGVKHHWVHOHFWLRQRIWKHERXQGLQJWUDQVLHQWV>@

&*6B):1R]B6WUHVV&RHII[OV[

3DWK3RO\\QRPLDO'LVWULEXWLRQ6XPPDU\\

1RWH)LOHVDUHJHQHUDWHGIURPWKHLQSXWILOHRI5HIHUHQFH>@





       

tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

info@structi nt.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @





)LOH1R

5HYLVLRQ

3DJH$RI$

)5



7+,6'2&80(17&217$,169(1'2535235,(7$5<,1)250$7,217+$7+$6%((15('$&7('















3UREDELOLVWLF)UDFWXUH0HFKDQLFV6XSSRUWLQJ)LOHV



)LOH1DPH

'HVFULSWLRQ

3DWK,13

3DWK287

9,3(512=LQSXWDQGRXWSXWILOHVIRU3DWKDWQR))OHEOHQGUDGLXV

3DWK,13

3DWK287

9,3(512=LQSXWDQGRXWSXWILOHVIRU3DWKDWQR))OHEOHQGUDGLXV

3DWK,13

3DWK287

9,3(512=LQSXWDQGRXWSXWILOHVIRU3DWKDWQR))OHLQQHUVXUIDFHWRRXWHU

EOHQGUDGLXV

3DWK,13

3DWK287

9,3(512=LQSXWDQGRXWSXWILOHVIRU3DWKDWQR))OHLQQHUVXUIDFHWRRXWHU

EOHQGUDGLXV

3DWK,13

3DWK287

9,3(512=LQSXWDQGRXWSXWILOHVIRU3DWKDWQR))OHWRVKHOOZHOG

3DWK,13

3DWK287

9,3(512=LQSXWDQGRXWSXWILOHVIRU3DWKDWQR))OHWRVKHOOZHOG

9,3(512=S(;(

9,3(512=H[HFXWDEOHSURJUDP

,63&732'(;(

9,3(512=SUREDELOLW\\RIGHWHFWLRQFXUYHLQSXWILOH

)/:'675%(;(

9,3(512=IODZVL]HGLVWULEXWLRQFXUYHLQSXWILOH





       

tr Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

info@structi nt.com m 1-877-451-POWER C, structint.com @

GO2-20-127 Affidavit for Withholding

       

       

e Structural Integrity Associates, Inc.

November 11, 2020 Attention:

Document Control Desk Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission' Washington, DC 20555-0001 5215 Hellyer Avenue, Suite 210, San Jose, CA 95138 I (408) 833-7329 dshim@Structint.com

Subject:

Request for Withholding of the Following Commercial Document:

1) SI Calculation No. 1801567.301P, Revision 1, "Probabilistic Fracture Mechanics Evaluation for Columbia Feedwater Nozzle" To Whom It May Concern:

This is a request under 10 C.F.R. §2.390(a)(4) that the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC")

withhold from public disclosure the information identified in the enclosed Affidavit consisting of the commercial information owned by Structural Integrity Associates, Inc. ("SIA") identified above (the "Calculations"). Copies of the Calculations and the Affidavit in support of this request are enclosed.

SIA desires to disclose the Calculations with proprietary information identified with brackets, { { } } ( { { This sentence is an example. ), in confidence to fulfill commitments outlined in Energy Northwest Contract 355228 (SIA Project 1801567.00). The Calculations are not to be divulged to anyone outside of the NRC nor shall any copies be made of the Calculations provided herein. If you have any questions about the legal aspects of this request for withholding, please do not hesitate to contact me at ( 408) 833-7329. Questions on the content of the Calculations should be directed to Kevin Wong (408) 833-7357. Sincerely, un Shim, Ph.D. Director, Analytical Services Structural Integrity Associates info@structint.com m 1-877-451-POWER e structint.com ~

        AFFIDAVIT RE:Request for Withholding of the Following Commercial Document:

1)

SIA Calculation No. 1801567.301P, Revision 1, "Probabilistic Fracture Mechanics Evaluation for Columbia Feedwater Nozzle" I, Do Jun Shim, being duly sworn, depose and state as follows: I am the Director of Analytical Services at Structural Integrity Associates, Inc. whose principal office is located at 5215 Hellyer Ave., Suite 210, San Jose, CA 95138 ("SIA") and I have been specifically delegated responsibility for the above-listed Calculations that is sought under this Affidavit to be withheld (the "Calculations"). I am authorized to apply to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") for the withholding of the Calculations on behalf of SIA. SIA requests that the Calculations with proprietary information identified within brackets, { { } } ( { { This sentence is an example.} } ), be withheld from the public on the following bases: Withholding Based Upon Privileged And Confidential Trade Secrets Or Commercial Or Financial Information:

a.

The Calculations are owned by SIA and constitutes commercial information which has not been placed in the public domain by SIA.

b.

SIA made a substantial economic investment to develop the Calculations and, by prohibiting public disclosure, SIA derives an economic benefit. The Calculations are entitled to the protection of the United States copyright laws. If the Calculations were publicly available to consultants and/or other businesses providing services in the electric and/or nuclear power industry at no cost, these entities would be able to use the Calculations for their own commercial benefit and profit and without expending the substantial economic resources required of SIA to develop the Calculations.

c.

SIA made a substantial investment of both money and employee hours over an extended period of time in the development of the Calculations. As a result of such effort and cost, both in terms of dollars spent and dedicated employee time, the Calculations are highly valuable to SIA.

d.

A public disclosure of the Calculations would be highly likely to cause substantial harm to SIA's competitive position. If a party does contract with SIA to obtain the information contained herein, it would require an investment of money, time and effort equivalent to that expended by SIA for the party to duplicate the Calculations. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on November 11, 2020. Sincerely, Do un Shim, Ph.D. Director, Analytical Services Structural Integrity Associates ~ Structural Integrity Associates, Inc. inlo@structint.com mi 1-877-45!-POWER '9 structint.com @)

        CALIFORNIA JURAT GOVERNMENT CODE § 8202 A notary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the identity of the individual who signed the document to which this certificate is attached, and not the truthfulness, accuracy, or validity of that document. State of California County of _ ~ __ {_a._Q_l.¥7,_ll ___ _ 11\\YINTZU JEANNIE WIN-GARDNER Notary Public - California z ~ J Santa Clar a County ~ "' ~ Commission // 2297944 omm. Expires Jul 20, 2023 Place Notary Seal and/or Stamp Above Subscribed and sworn to (or affirmed) before me on this fl dayof N11ton b,-r Date Month (1) 1)o J t,Ln , 20 lD, by Year (and (2) __ ~- ~-----~------- ---l, Name(s) of Signer(s) proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person(s) who appeared before me. Signature ~---------------- OPTIONAL----------------~ Completing this information can deter alteration of the document or fraudulent reattachment of this form to an unintended document. Description of Attached Document Title or Type of Document: A:ff /DAV 11 ---+-, ~~~----------------------- Document Date: N ovun ker /} I ~l 6 7.,,D Number of Pages:---"--'------ Signer(s) Other Than Named Above: ________________________ _ ©2018 National Notary Association

Certificate Of Completion Envelope Id: 28F40C16CF6D4CB1A2B083B853F03993 Status: Completed

Subject:

Please DocuSign: GO2-20-146.pdf Source Envelope: Document Pages: 111 Signatures: 3 Envelope Originator: Certificate Pages: 5 Initials: 0 Sandra Christianson AutoNav: Enabled EnvelopeId Stamping: Enabled Time Zone: (UTC-08:00) Pacific Time (US & Canada) P.O. Box 968 Richland, WA 99352-0968 sjchristianson@energy-northwest.com IP Address: 66.119.205.190 Record Tracking Status: Original 11/12/2020 6:02:56 AM Holder: Sandra Christianson sjchristianson@energy-northwest.com Location: DocuSign Security Appliance Status: Connected Pool: FedRamp Storage Appliance Status: Connected Pool: Energy Northwest Location: DocuSign Signer Events Signature Timestamp Sandra Christianson sjchristianson@energy-northwest.com Licensing Engineer -PR Energy Northwest Security Level: Email, Account Authentication (Optional) Signature Adoption: Pre-selected Style Using IP Address: 66.119.205.190 Sent: 11/12/2020 6:07:18 AM Viewed: 11/12/2020 6:07:39 AM Signed: 11/12/2020 6:07:55 AM Electronic Record and Signature Disclosure: Not Offered via DocuSign Richard M. Garcia rmgarcia@energy-northwest.com Licensing Supervisor Energy Northwest Security Level: Email, Account Authentication (Optional) Signature Adoption: Pre-selected Style Using IP Address: 66.119.205.190 Sent: 11/12/2020 6:07:58 AM Resent: 11/16/2020 8:11:33 AM Viewed: 11/17/2020 12:02:04 AM Signed: 11/17/2020 12:08:14 AM Electronic Record and Signature Disclosure: Not Offered via DocuSign DesireeM.Wolfgramm dmwolfgramm@energy-northwest.com Security Level: Email, Account Authentication (Optional) Signature Adoption: Pre-selected Style Using IP Address: 66.119.205.190 Sent: 11/17/2020 12:08:16 AM Viewed: 11/17/2020 3:06:29 PM Signed: 11/17/2020 3:10:30 PM Electronic Record and Signature Disclosure: Accepted: 11/17/2020 3:06:29 PM ID: 29ea5ef2-d8c7-44fb-b866-1847bd5162b5 Company Name: Energy Northwest In Person Signer Events Signature Timestamp Editor Delivery Events Status Timestamp Agent Delivery Events Status Timestamp Intermediary Delivery Events Status Timestamp Docu~ 11 sfC::IIIH ll [ DocuSigned by: .s~ ~ F2D930AF04F0471...

Certified Delivery Events Status Timestamp Carbon Copy Events Status Timestamp Witness Events Signature Timestamp Notary Events Signature Timestamp Envelope Summary Events Status Timestamps Envelope Sent Hashed/Encrypted 11/12/2020 6:07:18 AM Certified Delivered Security Checked 11/17/2020 3:06:29 PM Signing Complete Security Checked 11/17/2020 3:10:30 PM Completed Security Checked 11/17/2020 3:10:30 PM Payment Events Status Timestamps Electronic Record and Signature Disclosure

ELECTRONIC RECORD AND SIGNATURE DISCLOSURE From time to time, Energy Northwest (we, us or Company) may be required by law to provide to you certain written notices or disclosures. Described below are the terms and conditions for providing to you such notices and disclosures electronically through the DocuSign system. Please read the information below carefully and thoroughly, and if you can access this information electronically to your satisfaction and agree to this Electronic Record and Signature Disclosure (ERSD), please confirm your agreement by selecting the check-box next to I agree to use electronic records and signatures before clicking CONTINUE within the DocuSign system. Getting paper copies At any time, you may request from us a paper copy of any record provided or made available electronically to you by us. You will have the ability to download and print documents we send to you through the DocuSign system during and immediately after the signing session and, if you elect to create a DocuSign account, you may access the documents for a limited period of time (usually 30 days) after such documents are first sent to you. After such time, if you wish for us to send you paper copies of any such documents from our office to you, you will be charged a $0.00 per-page fee. You may request delivery of such paper copies from us by following the procedure described below. Withdrawing your consent If you decide to receive notices and disclosures from us electronically, you may at any time change your mind and tell us that thereafter you want to receive required notices and disclosures only in paper format. How you must inform us of your decision to receive future notices and disclosure in paper format and withdraw your consent to receive notices and disclosures electronically is described below. Consequences of changing your mind If you elect to receive required notices and disclosures only in paper format, it will slow the speed at which we can complete certain steps in transactions with you and delivering services to you because we will need first to send the required notices or disclosures to you in paper format, and then wait until we receive back from you your acknowledgment of your receipt of such paper notices or disclosures. Further, you will no longer be able to use the DocuSign system to receive required notices and consents electronically from us or to sign electronically documents from us. All notices and disclosures will be sent to you electronically           

Unless you tell us otherwise in accordance with the procedures described herein, we will provide electronically to you through the DocuSign system all required notices, disclosures, authorizations, acknowledgements, and other documents that are required to be provided or made available to you during the course of our relationship with you. To reduce the chance of you inadvertently not receiving any notice or disclosure, we prefer to provide all of the required notices and disclosures to you by the same method and to the same address that you have given us. Thus, you can receive all the disclosures and notices electronically or in paper format through the paper mail delivery system. If you do not agree with this process, please let us know as described below. Please also see the paragraph immediately above that describes the consequences of your electing not to receive delivery of the notices and disclosures electronically from us. How to contact Energy Northwest: You may contact us to let us know of your changes as to how we may contact you electronically, to request paper copies of certain information from us, and to withdraw your prior consent to receive notices and disclosures electronically as follows: To contact us by email send messages to: ECRMSupport@energy-northwest.com To advise Energy Northwest of your new email address To let us know of a change in your email address where we should send notices and disclosures electronically to you, you must send an email message to us at ECRMSupport@energy-northwest.com and in the body of such request you must state: your previous email address, your new email address. We do not require any other information from you to change your email address. If you created a DocuSign account, you may update it with your new email address through your account preferences. To request paper copies from Energy Northwest To request delivery from us of paper copies of the notices and disclosures previously provided by us to you electronically, you must send us an email to ECRMSupport@energy-northwest.com and in the body of such request you must state your email address, full name, mailing address, and telephone number. We will bill you for any fees at that time, if any. To withdraw your consent with Energy Northwest To inform us that you no longer wish to receive future notices and disclosures in electronic format you may:

i. decline to sign a document from within your signing session, and on the subsequent page, select the check-box indicating you wish to withdraw your consent, or you may; ii. send us an email to ECRMSupport@energy-northwest.com and in the body of such request you must state your email, full name, mailing address, and telephone number. We do not need any other information from you to withdraw consent.. The consequences of your withdrawing consent for online documents will be that transactions may take a longer time to process..

Required hardware and software The minimum system requirements for using the DocuSign system may change over time. The current system requirements are found here: https://support.docusign.com/guides/signer-guide-signing-system-requirements. Acknowledging your access and consent to receive and sign documents electronically To confirm to us that you can access this information electronically, which will be similar to other electronic notices and disclosures that we will provide to you, please confirm that you have read this ERSD, and (i) that you are able to print on paper or electronically save this ERSD for your future reference and access; or (ii) that you are able to email this ERSD to an email address where you will be able to print on paper or save it for your future reference and access. Further, if you consent to receiving notices and disclosures exclusively in electronic format as described herein, then select the check-box next to I agree to use electronic records and signatures before clicking CONTINUE within the DocuSign system. By selecting the check-box next to I agree to use electronic records and signatures, you confirm that: x You can access and read this Electronic Record and Signature Disclosure; and x You can print on paper this Electronic Record and Signature Disclosure, or save or send this Electronic Record and Disclosure to a location where you can print it, for future reference and access; and x Until or unless you notify Energy Northwest as described above, you consent to receive exclusively through electronic means all notices, disclosures, authorizations, acknowledgements, and other documents that are required to be provided or made available to you by Energy Northwest during the course of your relationship with Energy Northwest.}}

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=GO2-20-146,_Erratum_to_Fourth_Ten-Year_Inservice_Inspection_(ISI)_Program_Relief_Request_4ISI-09&oldid=3829542"