ML20248M018
| ML20248M018 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 06/09/1998 |
| From: | Wen P NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Essig T NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9806120238 | |
| Download: ML20248M018 (19) | |
Text
- _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
p QClo
\\
h b' UNITED STATES y'
g j
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
~
D[
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20556-0001 o,
k*****,o June 9,1998 MEMORANDUM TO: Thomas H. Essig, Acting Chief Generic Issues and Environmental Projects Branch Division of Reactor Program Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Peter C. Wen, Project Manager k C, M FROM:
Generic Issues and Environmental Projects Branch j
Division of Reactor Program Management l
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation I
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF JUNE 3,1998, MEETING WITH WESTINGHOUSE I
OWNERS GROUP (WOG) REGARDING RESPONSE TIME TEST (RTT)
ISSUES l
On June 3,1998, a public meeting was held at the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission's (NRC's) offices in Rockville, Maryland, between members of the WOG, Westinghouse, and NRC staff. Attachment 1 lists attendees at the meeting, and Attachments 2 and 3 contain a copy of the material that was handed out at the meeting.
The purpose of the meeting was to discuss the issues related to WOG submittal WCAP-14036-P, Rev 1, " Elimination of Periodic Protection Channel Response Time Tests." Based on its initial review, the staff sent a request for additional information (RAl) to WOG on May 12,1998.
The Westinghouse representative started the meeting by presenting the history and background of the RTT project at the WOG and Westinghouse. The slides used in this presentation are provided as Attachment 2.
The second part of the presentation concemed the RA! and the manner in which the WOG intended to answer the questions. The slides used for this part of the presentation are provided as Attachment 3.
Questions 1 and 2 of the RAI concemed the submittal of the failure modes and effects analysis (FMEA) and test data for the selected instrumentation. The Westinghouse representative stated that he had no problem making the data available, but as it was proprietary, Westinghouse did not wish to submit it to NRC due to the administrative difficulty of providing a non-proprietary version. He suggested that the data be made available in Westinghouse offices in Pittsburgh or Rockville. The staff was not amenable to this, since data used in writing a safety evaluation report (SER) needs to be availhble as the SER is written. The staff said it would look into the difficulty in providing a non-proprietary version, consisting of a cover letter with a minimum l
amount of documentation, and will get back to Westinghouse.
\\
l
)
98~ns SC MFSI3tliB @
c 03 V
9006120238 900609 PDR ADOCK 052 3
~
Thomas H. Essig Question 3 concerned calibration methodology and the adequacy of this methodology to determine RTT failures. Question 4 concerned the effects of RTT degradation and calibration changes in excess of.5%. Question 5 was about the definition of response time. For each of these questions, The Westinghouse representative stated he would respond to the issue in greater detailin the response to the RAl. The detail would be sufficient to show adequacy of the topical report proposal.
Questions 6,7, and 8 concerned the effects of this topical on the Technical Specification (TS) wording, and how exempted and non-exempted instrumentation would be identified. The Westinghouse representative stated he would reword tne proposed TS amendment. Further discussion may be required on this issue.
The representatives of the NRC and Westinghouse agreed that this meeting was useful in accelerating the information exchange.
At!achments: As stated cc w/atts: See next page DISTRIBUTION: See attached page
. Document Name: G:\\PWX\\MSUM0603.wog A
OFFICE PM:PGEB SC:ljCB, SC:PkEf NAME PWen:ayb JMaubh FMulewicz DATE 6/ 9/98 6/ 7/98 6/ '[/98 OFFICAL OFFICE COPY 1
I
/
l 3
NRC/WOG MEETING ON RESPONSE TIME TEST ISSUES LIST OF ATTENDEES June 3,1998 NAME ORGANIZATION Jerry Mauck NRR/DRCH/HICB Paul 1.oeser NRR/DRCH/HICB Marvin Dent Southern Nuclear Jack Stringfellow Southern Nuclear Michael Eidson Southern Nuclear Chris Morgan Westinghouse i
Dick Miller Westinghouse Jim Andrachek Westinghouse l
l
)
G
)
O T
FT W(
O(R N G P
O N U
I I O
T T AS R
NE G
G I T N
M I
E T
S I
8 R
LM E
9 E
EI E
9 T
M 1
N N
E C
3 W
O S e
R n
O MN A O N
u
/
J E
R P G
S S
U GE O
OR W
O R C H
PI G
GD N
O O I
S P
E W
G Y
N T
I I
T L
C I
Y E
B S
L T
A R E I
S L
E L
U G EC T
A D
E C N T
C F
R C A O
R P
O N
I O H RP O
Y S
O TC 57 E
T T
N O N V
E D
A Y
N O 9
V N
E T
1 D
N S
I E
SI A
M F
ET I
I N
T T
E A
T E
A OA NU T
T N
N V
S DRB E
I O
NI O
R N
R I
U T
T OL R
D E
E T
Q C
I A C
L E
E E
E TC G
R F
T A
R A
RT F
U D E I
K U
U F T E
B L
D A
C Q
O ER B
I N
R R A E
A R
E D
R E A
T G T E
S OR I
R V
MO N
N E C B
T E
O D E S
Y O
F S
E C
ET R
L R
I E N B BN T
ME IF T
P I D TO O
S 7
7 I E T
N T A C
O 9
E C
1 T T N A S
E T A E SD E
S S
3 RL A A O
N U P
A 8
S 3
BP HR D
O O H
PH I
I E
LM TG T
ST C
T E
E T
EI E
T R
CC RD R
RW I
D
,E E
DM R
U G
Q I
E I
S F S U
E H
U I
S QN ET T O
R I
,EO T
G ES AE TA H O
G NT E. E S D
T N
U I
E EI EC L
OR R
(NE R MECT D S
S BNS E E
MC OHT I
TWC N AR T R
T
,E E
LO C U
A I
I A D A
F S A E
D G
F N CILWT E
IT A)
P V
D O
C FE E
I RE SA A
E TU B
P T
C R ASE P P N RGT NDR CT N
E I
O A O A AE NO O
D N F
S G
I I
O FR H SRH AN T
NO E GTWT A
AI SP T I T WN G EOOH R
CA E
O
/G E N D SN C A
R LG B
IN R I
LI L
B FI TI N H TO,AME A
L SN C A C
A HI OT RTA HNGHN C
CL EA E E T TONCA F
I I I I L O
I TLN H R TDH L NG AM AI T OANWI I
N A
,RU E
T ON OI N
DR I
GL O
E TTG AAL B OR E
N U I
U M
E D I
TAN RCAHT S E
P E E TRI TI CSA E
C S F I
D S REW GL D N N
N I
N N NB AI A
E P IMEL MI R T GU N
VS SN USEO E
EE RO E
ILPF DI DEDR NR
G IVED L
ED N
F O
'D I
ITAN I
T MT ta I
NC L R
_ PIG sII I
EC
. SE D
_. SRI N D O O 2
E I
S MR E
00 R
1 AE N7 RP
,E S
0L I
GF 0G N
3P 7E OO R
P G
OL O
MIA 1
r W
Ef E Dt S E
t S
GRW B E
SESC TSS RHRE S
R E
EN PDPS I
G N
PI E
N T I
S R
S D
TE P
N 6
E RT E
O 9
V
/
T O
E P
1 OE NU I
B S
D R
S PM B
E R
E P
E S
T R
I O
RT R D O
U P
N A
S A
O E S
I N
R E SD N
H S
O I
S NU A
S 2
S P N E
E EL S C
L I
S O
SC T L
V A
MP P
OS O NN Y
B E
E T
A T
A R
T I
N A
R R T L R
S A
E I
T SOP 1 T F
A E
P M
I F
SN S
EL N O Y
E L
OS 2
D SS I
SE ON L RU M
T R 3
N AD O
6 E
O A OO I
Y S 35 I
T N
H D AT AN M
S I
1 9 SH GN
- /
E G
OE P5 A
/
)
A NG Y
EI T S E
I ET H
OD C D I
MS RSS W
OT T
T L
R ME" AOE U
R S
U OVS LHWA D HC RS A
C N T I
(
RI A
ME EE T
E ", E I
E S
F R
M OD R
S RS N
R 1
'SFE ST SR A
D VE E
E ER D T L ES E
LC L
P O
AI P
R L DN D
R F
Z RI I
I I
C
,U VO A V O VE I
E D
L I
3Q OP T OMOMPN A
I S
T4 E RE N RE RI OE E
T S
L N
M A
E C
N E
I O
T T
S P
I S
RK M
SL Y
CC O
E A
C S
S C
T R N
N N
NS G
EA O
A I
H NF T
C O
O S C
E L
P/
E D
D MS F
E
)
T F
S T
2N O R A
N S
C I
)
C
(
P E
EA N
E N
N S
L S
YI T
O O
S A N FS A
N N
I I
E
(
T T
N S
I H O T Y R
O O
C A
O O
I N A T
I I
PT L
ST S
T T
E T
T W
I E E NS MC C
T N
C T
C D
E E
O E
E N
I D OE E
T T
R MT O
O O
P U
O IT O
O TMEY S
R R
S R
R C
M R
AI DB Y
P P
S T
P T
S E
E S
S S
E T
A E
Y,N E
S S
C N
T O
R P
MT R O T
E E
O I
S E
AT A
C C
R R
A R
G D N
I S
F T
P O E O
O P
A S
T S
R R
E E
Y R E C
RE E D A
P P
L L
D A
P OH C A P
I 0
0 G
C L
L L
O FN E R E
0 0
A U
O E
TP S
1 3
7 7
E N
S R
OM R
RI NG P
EO E
X L O F
I I
PT I D S
PC
)S DRAC LA 39 N
/2 1
A
/
S 5
N C
M R
P A
X L
N R
U N
N O
O T
(
G LF N
IT N
D O
N O
A O
E R
E I
P R
O T
T T
I T
U R
C N
C N
T S
T E
E E
SE S
U T
MT O
D E
E O
U O
R E
L E
R N
D R
R R
P I
T P
P C
E E
P T
P R
G V
S S
2 E
E 9
L E
N L
S N
/
T 2
E Z
A O
E I
C R
A 1
I S
R R
V T
D S
U R
N O
A S
R E
E N
S E
I S
P L
D T
O S
I E
I E
W M0 C
L L
0 U
O P
T R
O E
3 C
P P
T 7
N S
M N
S U
Y O
F S
C
D DE N
S A
U S S N
N D N O
O R O I
I AI T
TS CT C
CN C
M F
E EOM O N A
T TI A U
R O
O TR RF G
R E S O
P A G DD R
Y R U O NR P
P SA R N
I A
8 L
O A A T
L 9
/
M U O
E 2
2S P
EE V I
G L
R 2
SC E T T
E
/
E I
1 C
R F P
D O
E T
AOML T
DA N
N N
1 HREI O
ES I
A v
A eR L
PPT P R
TD D
1 FSD P
SN E
2 P
6 E A T
E 3
D OYN S
T E
L 0
A S
P N SO E
DI L
G 4
1 E
OICY C
NR P
A L
E O
AT M
E PA E
I G T
B R
DR O
R C
B A O P
EO C
O W
L 0
TT S
F L
L U
0 I
AC N
A D
I 1
N 7
UA MS E
W D
LE D
T I
E T
N AR N
EM T
F I
L N
A V N A
E EI S
DT M
T O
0 C
0 P
E S
B G
3 S
S Y
U O
7 S
US S'
V i
i u
f
.d 3
qe ei mn T
u N
dl e
f e
o t
a r sb f
sh y
0 r
A t
c s
T i
h )o T
i 1
e Y
A i
g ;.
c e at A
N d
e a O
u r L
r jo r
I f
ob E
S d
f R
i I
n s l
t a
V a n Ac w&
E An E e e
e r
Mo R
E o si e vE P
Mp Ft e
lu rL F m y
at d rG 6
o o
i oA 3
N e c nl
?
h ob Amf i
0 s
eE O
t t
4 u
d a E ml 1
I s
e d o e e b S Mt T
t ni s
e aP r
h P
C S
r a
at F sis l
a b
A E
T o
s v g
ya t
f eS vS C
T S
r yn h
a e
N WO E
d e
l i
i t
n S
e d h rd oPI T
k nf a u ri t
t O
N R
AN l
t c
u o mc o
P E
c n
p eC(
i G
O p
o s ri pt C
M i
r W s.
t g
p(
u N
N o
s I
I 8
t r n s
s m
T O
D T
n ei sk Pd I
9 O
E 9
e d w e
i c
o nt I
E T
n r a ge t
ss a s 1
I S
o o r nh e et y E
A R
N 3
p nd c
i l
s b c r M
M E
O E
t m
I c
s o o r e n a r P
o
.t t
o s
p e i
C R
P N
c Aa et v
t P eh i
i R
O F
S Em mr d 0 R o U
a t
N F
O E
c e
a0 J
t r
R e
Mh i
b 3 s o t
/
N N
r s7 ef i
G r
F c el a
T O
L I
o s
s a I
E c
ed n c wd
,d w
O L
n e
e WA T
N e
h o g gatad n
i pn n
si i0 a n v
t N
A N
h f a e
0 Du r
t o y e r O
N A
e r u e1 t b rt t
o o
s l
I I
r sb f d t 7 s ot e I
I e
c T
M m
o e y f s s
C w
p i
y f e e nA I
e nt h Ti et oE I
i l
D L
d c s i
o i
s ol d
t s
l n&c pM a
b r D
E n
i e
A a
h a t b a o s n
a a io s l
f erF t
e nt e n i
i c
md r o ad R
e wh i
mte r e ui v e e e t
t 1
mh O
a f f t
at e md a c
n e
t f od odd t
u F
a e
e r ed P ei t
n q
l t
st o c a Ae m T
e s e s r s
.d f o r o
i t
e s oi n s r r g Cs kic S
d e
ipu e
nol eP e e u f
t a
h o q u n oi u p d) We me m c p E
r t
A c e N
ih U
1 t
t oi a s s s Qi e
r eOd wx c a e r E
d e a e Q
n id s ted r t
wTmI n
a x
E o
M vui r ai a s
a
,iTat m e
c r rag R
F olcT oi n
e t
i g
t r
f f c
d eE nAeCAed d s
e pnT r
it c
s eR sidMiE NEE n n v a i
e e
h i
t o u o c s u s s
s s nja eF eMoTMpo e
u t
h rI Q
s a a m oeBt eTF pOF mBPI a
e e o ph h
eR o
C s
W P pf sT*
T.
. RP a C*
.N I
l l
r A
e R
R.
e
l ll l
l l
s d
i d
n n
a o
,n a
%t e
. e e,
c s
e m
c 5 e n
l f
b e n
2 f o
a f e p
e a r t t t
o s
s s
n e
e c x e e t
ma r
h i
t 1
s et n
t e
u e e
v rd a e
N r
m m
o h
m O
n a
f yt i
e ixh t
l i
)i t
I g
S e
al n
e s u ab d
l I
s t
V a
mi o
a e u
w t
i e )y j
e E
r a
c r
s e
pbl g
c et f
R n
s n f
o e
n rdk ir a e e
l i i
P n
e n pul e
t a
ro s
pot e
s n
6 c p o
a wo 3
N y
n i
b im m
erd m g
0 O
no e
e n n
4 s
e 1
I d
c h
h a n n
e a
T "
c e t
d we P
C S e.
o%o s
e e d
( r n
s p
A E
T u
uh a
e u d
(5 e C T S
o t
h ui l
l a r2 s l
N WO E b
a n s
1 a
t vi r
af u R T i
o v
cf b O N d
P E
n r n o e s
nr c o e t
o e u u
G O
i i
a p
C M t
s cd sl i
n c o e
s N
N a a I
I e
a r r
e a ue v l
8 T
O D
T p
po I
s d
a o o r 9
g O E 9
o a
s t e n
et c c I
n n E
T I
S n
c r a
rd si 1
i s
E A
R N 3
ah e r
e e a
t o a c a n d
s e
n n M ME O E
Is h s r dl pa u o
P
?
t a c dd oe o t
C R
P N
? e g
n id nl r sb R O F S t i c
N F
O E U
e u n
e u
u l
a at a o a a o
s i
d ps J
a wh e R
a s wts c s N
N c v t
ae e
/
o t
r ya a
ct s s G
t e h wt O
L I
o an ol e s c s o s n
O L
n s I
E r n sh s eeh o a i
l r ps WA T N
oa i s m s a e
c ot d r N A N
wt s
e s
yeu e n al grirh u c i
l l
s s
m O N A
a a a n
e
,ot o n e
i ur nei a wt sd w I
I s
I x
T MIC c n P a c s t
al h
rt e s%
o r I
I ai e
m t
t o a n0 D
L ee t nh h
t o0 e sh a
%e h n
,s t
D E
h s si2t h
t s,
A "
t a h
o si e
i0t0 d pns rd a e r i
e R
r c w2 yb 2
e e
ond s
ue ff w mpad o e O
o o c nct l
d f od n
o c
i F
a a
e o
h d eVt c
e ye f a t
ms i
s r l
em:ie T
s u
t et d y u
d t h a o sis S
eb e
a s
s t
h mc e
E l t us e m :s u
uol ad t i r
U 2
s an t
u ue l
e e xa Q
e wvI a
ud d
h h r Q
n l
r e e.i/ u t
mt r
f s n i
a el E
o au v
sf ri t
po oa n o
A aAt R
a i
r a
f E
Enruf s
eb h
e ot prtsh t
a r e
MgMnir e
ht o
u t
r eo s
e oc et o
st n
FuFo papi Q
ah air o
eh empme s
s s s s
s e s o p
ht h a
Wa P rw s
TlaTcCteR I
l e
o A
e R
R e
ll
a n o
e u-l f
n e
t l
I r
o n
iw?
e o
t ed a
n e r a s o s
a i
1 c n t
n h
s e
i N
f i
c c
a i
e O
ni e i
g v
h l
l t
I h a w
S s ch a
i e a s
I t
t e
V b
s s
d e
E r u e
u t
o o t f m l
R n
c n
o n
t l
P n a o t
i i
e ci c
d i
6 i t l
ct u
u 3
N a
f n r d
o i
0 O
f eb o
w 4
udi r
1 I
sil p
t T
ya u
s c
P C
S t
g d
b A
E T
u oa r
l l
a C
T S
s os c
d e
e e
N WO E
rd t
n r
T o u o
a R
Th b p
O N
P E
Tte r e
m d
i G
O C
M Rmt t
s o
N N
a a
c I
I 8
n n b
T O
D T
I 9
ot n
i O
E 9
ei a s
e I
E T
t h a
e 1
s I
S a a r w w
b E
A R
N 3
rb e m
o e
t M ME O
E ci t l
P n a a n a
n C
R P
N c c r
i e
o g
R O
F S
i U
n ed t o
v i
N F
O E
a y
J ah na r
R t t I r
p h
r N
N a
/
a b
e G
s?i e
s O
L hI I
e s
O L
l h
s e
I E
.d a
t t
WA T
N ddt c n
c e
n e
e e e c e N
A N
wt eh i
c n
i O
N A
o ef e
h r
cf t
d e
l I
I h t a n z
IT M
C d e c
a I
s e i
i a
l I
I g
b d i
s t
e D
L n e e
e u
r t
b st i
D E
t e c y
o u
s yigt g
e f
b A
e i
t b o e o
s r
R el d 3
o e
t l
t i
t r o ah ed e n
d g
a O
F h o r o
o n
t o
l s
h a h
o o
t i
T edt s t
t i
et s
e d
t o
a S
t n
a a ml e
m h
r u
E t
u t
s n
e b
s U
3 n,ne Q
o m
i 6
or l
Q n
3itoi a
i t
aT r
c E
o 0 t a
n 4 a rT o
r o
l R
i f
a t
r b b
i 1
iR s
b t
i i
e a
c e
Pi l
la e s
a r
e l
u a
Ac c r n
c b
p Q
CeH o
et u
.i
. s l
t sn p
h s a s o Wh we s
TteCteN i
IA e
t R
R
=
o s
i i
t h
5 a
n nt 0
d o al l
a d
rd it i
e e
rW ge a
e e
c e c r
a b h x
dl w?
i e
e e p 1
la e
k t
mr N
c s o
e a i/
O e
t n
t d s
ga o s
e e IS n ct e
s r I
a o
ni V
h ed a
s e d
o p
c o r y
e p
E t hi c
es r R
nt u a
r e n q e
r o
r u
yb P
nI e c
nl 6
p? e c
ai l
3 N
msb a
,w e
n l
04 O
o u s ud i
1 I
cl e f r
- a e n
s T
t s vs o
s a P
C S
ot n
%i e c t
A E
T pf e
c e a
i c 5 r ch s C
T S
ut e e ri 0 b r
l N WO E
hd s
l i
u nl s
T ei l
t l
ud O
N R
f l a a i
P E
ib w h c f e n s c G
O e a s d
o s t
C M
nn s n l
i e o b
t r
N N
I I
o o s
c 8
a si e u a c p T
O D
T I
o r
9 t
t l
u n a c f
e e e
b s o c
O E
9 I
E T
1 r a?
r s i
t l
t i I
S e
t s
d a e a a a ot E
A R
N 3
d a
r s e c n M ME O
E s
nh e
r o
u dh r sb ywd P
rt i
i i
C R
P N
ne f
e af l
I n a R
O F
S ci U
ob%c o c i
o e
N F
O E
.i 0 g et t J
t d5 r R
a e p
n e a n 0
/
N N
d r0 3
a s r e G
O L
I n
7 a e s h
nb r O
L d c el e E
rddio i
I f
c af WA T
N gi et n e ci i
e s e a l
N A
N d n c r a m ef d
o O
N A
c ei 0
t t
xb 0i h
y I
t n
.b I
H e s l
I 1
e T
M C
nh c c 7 s ys d ya i
t n
.bl e
I I
ot at e o ut D
L ps r n h
dd s c pe e e a D
E mI ue t
s t r r c r r e ai p
A o
. c e f
o r r u mm R
c%ni af f
t 4
yb q ai s nl e O
a 5. i d i
h 0 nr n
e r rt a a go F
u o
c eo n t
o o l
s T
sdif r r e ad e i
e et t
a pr v nb d a e s
S t
r s e a E
a e m
e t
u n f
nh s eb u
t o a i
U s
a rb ot t i
cl Q
d t
ci l
s Q
6 x a yu 4
3 e c e md c b s E
0 h
r n
yt ya r a e
R 4
nt o
l r al d r l
o c
f a e e a gc a e 1
r mb e
c oe cd m it i
s P
i e
u s
r rh e n a u
Ac u n r o n
o pt pu r t
f s o g Q
Cct o
ei i
s b o a s t Wiia p
ih r o r
n n c I
ToNiP I
s s
I A
e R
R
- e m
e I
I
at T,i sl t
s t
s a h
c y
n u c e e t
i s
f n s e a ci nh p
h e ut s t
o si o o
c vl pe a nd t ei v
t vo r e s
t c
c e o 3
1 mtel eh rb 4
l u ed t N
a o of mnt a
(
O r r u u n%
f i g
t f
pot o
I n
t e
t ih i5 S
n a
eh%iug yo I
t u
t c u f
s V
k t
al 3 c r o ct n
i E
t i6 ri r e n o
t c
i R
nh c
h pi c
,n h t o uc a s o e
c e p
P af yt m
m i t t
e a
m b e i
o e n r i
6 ni nf t n
i s
t s
3 N
o o i
i pt o o e o e e
t f
0 O
et ih n
a i
4 l
t e s t t o
v I
d e ai u n 1
i r
T t
ninl o n w s
s e
P C
S s e gf a p f o a
i s
r hi e vs el d
n A
E T
i sd r e d e f t r
b e
o C
T S
es pe e s
c c
N WO E
hdirh gf s
f go p%
e e
o T
Teet t r
O N
R i
P E
c es r n S 5 p
e it o
x r
xh G
O h
s C
M yet d et m
e u
i c
s I
I a r r nhi e o y
a N
N n
8 e o ot Tr e
T O
D T
wt f ct f l
i I
9 l
f O
E 9
t e e e a e a
m et c
I E
T shd h u nmm 1
i I
S e
et t t
p p
a E
A R
N 3
r ai s
e rt h wr t
n y
s M
M E
O E
f a e oi o
e d
t ri t
e f
P f phdh ps r
s C
R P
N i
i t
n s e v
F S
d s pe a
R O
U s s a eht u c o
N F
O E
o ei
,s s
r J
R wc nn a e s o t
r p
oo o e s s
n
/
N N
t u
t p
e G
O L
rii l I
n pi iP n e m
t t O
L r
E nn eh 3
i I
WA T
N e eii o
u 6
mt r
f t N
A N
mhf t
e e n e e n
.t t
s a
ndd a u ri i
%n O
N A
t i
t l t s a u e t
e ed i
I H
sh n e n
g 0 f I
c nv q
T M
C nwor o e n 5 o e
m Ra e g l
I I
o c r c a D
L pme o e n h
r e
n l
c oi r
D E
s s c a
f t e o mf np e s u
i i
A r r e ei e e
f h h h
ot r e q
t e
i et e
R eTt rt 5
t s
ht s e c
h e r
O m.ipo n
n m
e f
a t
gt o
uh s
F di m
t e
i i ns/%
e t
t Fi i
T n ei r
t hdi 3
s e w "e
i 1
e t
S f t n
- 6 e
s t u n i
f s
e E
e s o e1 u
ue o
m l
di ph gn a
U 5
o m
vp a
,s n a Q
h t
6 s Q
n 3 n r e et r
ge r es s
e sih nb e r e
E o
0 o vb r o
gf h
4if R
i i
1 oie f
t t t
t t
go a
e e s s.i g
s l
t c e e u a e
e ut r s e
Pi nt n
Wmi"l l
l Ai b b a et s
t u
) i f
r r n
o u et af v go Q
Cc pf e p
o et pe s u e e
e Wspat h oe p
h at h el a
h e a
c st nr s
Tt sTRvM IA e
R R
t f a a t
h s
t e
mr ri u
.i 1
f q wne N
o o r l
O hcl a
s t
c l
w.i n
I i
S od w p
e I
h et o
n V
s r r t
o E
e uo s
p R
s s p h
m i
a s e e a r o
t y
c P
lpel 6
b a b
h c
c 3
N
",l d
l i i
p et h
0 O
yi r r f wt e o w
o 4
I i
1 rt vp y
T e r o e e
P C
S v oh c r t
l A
E T
p t l t
ca e n na x
C T
S h ri e c e
N WO E
t d
np i
i l T
wa e o
y R
o f
O N
cb pt P
E di i
i t
e pr ms n
G O
C M
c o c i
t s oh e
N N
I I
a e
ct d
8 T
O D
T 9
pid ay l
s i
I l
O E
9 eh t f b l
I E
T 1
rt o i
i s yn rd w
I S
E A
R N
3 e
b u r i
s M ME O
E nd n o c v o e s.
s t
n c e nd P
C R
P N
o ei o
e i
o t t r
F S
nt c
a p i
R O
U t e l
a N
F O
E a v ot c m l
i t J
c o pn wo i
R f
e N
N
/
if c me n
i O
L ct c m T
c x G
i I
t ee O
L I
E e o c e Tn pn WA T
N pn Re s e l
l p
n l
e S s a N
A N
nm f o ab tn oi o p c
l O
N A
a ei e
i H
init nm n v c
t o I
I o
T M
C nod o
h a i
r t c ch I
I h pd o
p e
D L
c mai a
t h e
r m
D E
Tc p
ut ni t c o r h
o A
fl si ah 8
nf a
e w w
l R
d ioTv r
p sTo eM ed t
O n
t r
eRp h
h n s
F a
et c
t a t
t f p a
T 7
" d oa wl wT p
S e
o e oT d und h r E
6 r no n eR h
U oi i t
a es s
wt a bi b e Q
n n nw it i
r E
o e o r r ri h ci e c o c u mi R
i s p s
t t e q
v e
e s
f hl e i
e e
I t e r Dr Dr euJ I
6 7
8 A
R e
nt ur o s r
e s e ne n l
i i n a
nc mo vwt e n ed n o pe o
i s e h e ad e e P n l
r r t i h e yAr r
f e
ef nic m r
t neCoh e nl r t
o i
l of s
t 1
f r
sWef a
no d e u o i
ed f f yt N
ga 2
nir r
e es O
o u o 3. d eo p e
i hh yn3 l
a rf l
I e
o at t n
t S
o r
o e n,naidi naPT d v I
h yi na u n u odAT i
s V
o t
c t t t l
a q eCR E
e ei oh c e
s t anWl R
mf dit n1 r i
t t
a ad a si s
- 3. i ai u
s a ui e h met P
e Ph 3T t
h c h f l
f na i
6 t
aI vATsT h e l
t a
3 N
dt eC oR c
n e e 0
e c 4
O e s es a
v ihMdWTi d e t
r ob n a 1
I Ta o r nrhe T
v r
c s P
C S
oTa a erin pa e o t
f pcf t r
pzh A
E T
e at f i e
aTr e c s C
T S
pP e f o ch e
o np eTl u f
N WO E
Pact o
m n
l T
ACa nl oS aRiwt i
ai n
O N
R C Wic s a vt a a o sh n
l P
E f r n ct e c 2 o o
WeTipmhi G
O i
i C
M c
i shTn n
h 3. l i
a h
i N
N c
t I
I it g p w3i l
8 T
O D
T 9
h Rial ci s rd w f
e I
i O
E 9
Tinf s e e r u o nP I
e E
T 1
ooh rte f a I
S
.d nt of v l
E A
R N 3 5 e n f
i A
l s1 9f od n os wdr 3. C M ME O
E 9it ni s
i i
e u
c3W P
t s
l t
a ai a e r e
a C
R P
N 1
t n
s R
O F
S n
e n
s cd a U
r e v
n/
s e i
i i N
F O
E s
m plupdB at nh ed J
R bi g
n ot n e n h
N N
mr e r
/
i sl k mahi ei c
t n
G O
L I c n ai I
t e o e a Ts o cd O
L l
I E
t s
l pnh m
- s. d e
u pi e WA T
N e e l
f t
e
.t f
mii N
A N
S sh na vlal e
cf t
o a
o ei 8
c ot r t
v u
h c pn O
N A
nPi it ot t
i H
d iDh a mppr eS e I
I c
n T
M C
n 2
wcb pa hl d o
ai a p 3d rf u n
Tct i
I I
a 6 n oc s na T
o D
L i
e D
E 7
1 ee aCh T s. inn 3 af
- e s pet Rw Rrhcd A
6 P r rS s o
s es e r uo nO Ne R
As sl e a
nTc t
O n
Ce n a cNr s
s s
a e r/
ci s
n s ei S o t
Wp r
F o
u l
o rf n s n i
i nI r c mo e
i t
eh T
i t ps if s n s
ddh c s
i e o S
e e et e ei od eP l
sl s
E t
p u
vt fTu o c o et o oAa m U
Q B
s t
r e erh cl C
o t
Q pl sh ot e a m
e c e
bd aWh r
psit f nj E
l u n r
Ty o
a n a el d s a gd n
d ei R
f f o rb e o e.
f s
A e
aTne ai siP r vP s
t t f n
sTid pi sA poA ai t
r T
s e neC e pC T o
eRt nnc e p h p p
h s
Tocoocd yW TaWR f
c ait eR e
Westinghouse Owners Group cc:
Mr. Nicholas Liparuto, Manager Regulatory and Engineering Networks Westinghouse Electric Corporation Mail Stop ECE 4-15 P.O. Box 355 Pittsburgh, PA 15230-0355 Mr. Andrew Drake, Project Manager Westinghouse Owners Group Westinghouse Electric Corporation Mail Stop ECE 5-16 P.O. Box 355 Pittsburgh, PA 15230-0355 Jack Bastin, Director Westinghouse Electric Corporation 11921 Rockville Pike, Suite 107 Rockville, MD 20852 Mr. Hank Sepp Westinghouse Electric Corporation PO Box 355 Pittsburgh, PA 15230-0355 i
1 I
l
)
Mtg. Summary w/ WOG Re Response Tima Test issues Dated h!i!f8>
~
Distribution:
,, Hard Cany
' 1 Docket File?
PUBLIC PGEB R/F OGC ACRS PWen EMail SCollins/FMiraglia BSheron RZimmerman BBoger JRoe DMatthews TEssig FAkstulewicz LSpessard JSWermiel JMauck 4
PLoeser l
GTracey, EDO
)
'l
)
1 4
-a
_ _ _ _ _.. _ - _ _.. _ _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. _