ML20247R519

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Summary of ACRS Subcommittee on Matls & Metallurgy 890620 Meeting.Topics Discussed Include Use of Low Use Vessels & Conservatisms of ASME Section Iii,App G Fracture Toughness Curves
ML20247R519
Person / Time
Issue date: 08/02/1989
From:
Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards
To:
Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards
References
ACRS-CT-1947, NUDOCS 8908080032
Download: ML20247R519 (13)


Text

..

q, f/L.

jP6s n -

dT-M4 7 k.

& $ Y#$$

  1. M 5 M nt14 4 x2 m _

~.

3. y (76 m @ 2.0 /184.

JUL 5f)89~

& M htic d W W A $,., &,r.,.ecl.a 15 % %

U V

t.-

$& w 4-y&J p.y A 4 - vse A fQ f

Y f~

b

]

!at a MAS M 24 6 a--

6 Y$ 4ns y

M y n L wk.

h88,5,,

[

2.

i'M.) r4 y

~ K : ' '~ ^

~

p..

g s.

Md $[

~

d N

M h47c-1 h...

,h[ sj AFV J Mww +Waf WMt

[

~~

j h--.

%g M$4 / thy w-1 6-..

I 1.$/ V h a f h.68 5, Wi J

y f---

-~),

' d?. ' >

f-----

~^

Me..?

p W'

4..

  1. 4 L-..

M

^5~

-~

-. ___f_._ _.-s/h$ Mb % W d$

~

Yfl j

l 8908000032 890802 C l!I~Y

~7I j

C~7d2 PDR ACRS

'0 LE El~19 KL__

_ _-___DEC__-__-___--____ _ _ _ _ _

I

8.

.xs; 5qQg c.r,p@ra..; w _ u

(

rra Iges(vr/s4178+).A

, 4 & m? % i iY W Mf #d &.

[

f S w p, +W paes p

,4 w % M_f44prI_

ACv w. g.

... T - ~ '.._

T&yn 617tf} ~# &ndy., u..__

n+ n4VLJ uf x-M O,.~

l.

1 4

i b

& 4; ze '177 A NsN5+/*

A

.t w &

JM; T S &_. _.

~

~

l (M'W N

M N

F.

.$ k.

sff h

y N4 M

.Y N

- + - - - -

e g_ _ _._..

w.A.

& 6 A Mtie m n'id Ac^e.de_dW

(......

==&.

y..-

.'h O

n

_M a MO m M M.m, 9 8 OO

  • O N

O 4

M D

e ut. W @@@ $6 g.

gg.g l*;disi Gk..

3 w

.2e.

i

x+-

I w.

. (-

a

.m AudsateJ : n, O d & da, M.4J LEN t

(

Ehi z.

u ?'L/ ~ v y 4 2. dea & x &E A A $ t.,

~

~.,q -

,& Ad AA44 % 4k.fndi&m..

I L

,yMLm&.

p c4 App 4 A y.%$n g, Q M.). m p _..

1 7

g l

fy V

&y f okd & S.~ ~ ~

l3 &

hu w.

~

(-

(WB) p _m gg.

,i l4 m &.zu ku (m kn) m qAp/4 A. &* -.

H i

y-s c <,s f = I 4 f V E.

f

,W W

w i

WM 4(r W

$,4

~~~

f Y

Y4

.+....m

  • > = =

c_

. W &. $ $. 4 % A n m W 1.. / A -. R H-- _ _.. _ _

a A4 k ^)if N..&A,__ M.

,.5../'

hh 9 s

a w

me-

% A W R K it

3

+

s qq u.-

..ew Y.-

.(I%&>

.sz

  • u.s J o.71), Atf A.J /

8 ges

, h u sE, 4tc N A 4.

.M MUI' Ya**#.

f C

M J

M I-M A Am g

3

.es.

A 1

ay,,,

l

  • L. 3ke K e

e..

- e It.

I

- u.m e aN 3

i udxA &

N,ye 3

q

.te Asnt. m &p #...__J sue

[....

Aa.use Ku A, AF s%. '

A.7 4,4 i

l

.;as.y ;'.. _

r ~

k-W, I

-- + ---

.e

_4 m,

N

. :f SQkyi.

.p
y...

. 3,,

c..;.

g 4,/ g aM fa s a a

w e.7 4 A*/ $ & C.. k.m Hg 6~>c c

44 p r= %. a a+

(iu w + + ~;< ~~e,

61

  • l..

=~c m M 4 g

g e'*

,A <o.4 sw a e-m u

t.

T-T&,,,

O QA 1s pM.5

^

M

- =

L..

y. e rs> v ~.f. A. a -

w, %

j i

& & M, M 6G AStf[ ce,ws, _ W_.

p.

?

, Mw&p oy.d /A.,, L.... E~ ~ ~

~

.y s.

I[

4 l

M^

W H....._ -

4,-r4g h b

W/

_. 75 4

e-.

{.

-mi.e.

.~=

9..

~~.

.en.

. a.. n..

k,T '('

e 7 f..

4

$4 -

,,.a

, Wr$&y^-

^~

0 WSC4@i?

M ad A #c. & _

WWC i

te k W-q u N h T h h 5 G d & d ? A X au:aupeua m &rsn_

f&

4 M A y h s G USE 71 *

^

I o

f; e

& N2 8 A h_; "

N

& VRE m ofr W d

ba m ~a e m m. - +=

s c4 % s e tyf~ 4

i..;. -.a.

~~

>~

nops.- ~ s u4 m,f. W u n

~

1.

ss ~9 -

3,, ~h 47A4..#

O-

.=

ae

=

h MID g -=

~

mee.

~_s ~.. n.uq.

.d u s~,_s

+xwmmpr~vm.

=

p. r. cg > -ar m.
  • l_______________~__._____.

---_--=s==s--_21___.,-

Pj'4,-

c 4..h.

7

,,S T-i{

f; o

6 S

)td1' -

~

~

~

C i

t 7

m F E 4

R Sy (S

OV i

e s

yT n q g;.,I e

EU A

ow PC

  • o

'o A

i u c g,

y t-t H S n

S a

eb 0

S, E g

n 5

y K 'f n J m g

i 1

e s

1 DN c

N H S PP p

A G E

U A

D SO T TOC 0

F) 0 l

I o

1 H

rE S (K M S

Y E TA c

TS b

i K

, s.

T A E j

D r

0 D R 1 5 TN l

IL R R

A A N T-V O

r

(

DI o

LNT n

LAC T

E R

I fl o

W )c S i-6KF j

O

(

D NN A O I

o g

T S

S A l

I ST

.~

4h Ei j-N I

RI p}-

p;[h, EE SH

~

o g; o

T 0

0 o

o 0

0 0

0 0

0 y.

t 0

8 s

o 2

0 8

6 4

2 2

1 i

t 1

1

'r

,Q 5 0fz4 3.M u>VygaS w$ o@u.

)

e

!l

o, A!W3%$XM%' '

r-g-

q q 3 j

1 l

l i

l O

I i

I 1

I / 1 *1 -; I. r]

'L -

l

).

{ i j

i

.. -.i 1

i 1

t [

t

._.a..._

E-lh jfTEEL A.(High hachirs,M M N $ t Joo.

p j

1

.1 1

76 s

j l

i

.o 4

j a b u

.,1

{

i

.a 4

', j

'5 FEEL 8

$TE E L*' S _ ;._!_

! e 4 t.

1 5C-Y a n s f t r t

  • d-Y b o M & nc-h ? % ? '

To rame-hr

_7,unnes s)

., j i

11 l I i p

C 10 0 200 300 400 'f t,, i ks %.

~P OSTUL ATE D CHARPY ' CURVES _.__._.

i i g

l 200 U-7)

N.Ic P A st1p X)

.ST E E L A NrA

_5TE E L B (TransfemO __. _

~

~

IOC 1

:.- 1

.i i

i.

e O

o 800 LO'Y

  • F DERIVED K CURVES 3

%W, Ip.

/,

l_

AsME Kr,w._.

200

.1 -

__1..*

.g 1

/

__ 5 7 t1-A.

-i n

4'

_I I

.i

. _$ TEEL B 1

i_.

I 8

/

/

[00 2- -.

t

1 i C PC em O u E w T s. '( s 1 A A t o. I 3 Aim A e 0 D~c M R s s = 0 t / I a A n s sS RA r FW 1 M M CcC IT e R T i T NA P N3 I 1 a 4 Uo I7 ame 1 + TD FL E 0 0 0 0 0 0 I H 0 5 0 5 0 SW 3 2 2 1 1 o E >. s. 2 ~ 4c yzo3O mE3 5.* a f j j i i i 8. pe e ) 1 5 -4 /?++ft /7*4v y ~ h.< q /O fA..SD,-. O y x %v M& Q yff(5SE) H' e (- .L W emiD 8SD".48s' M^ ysv % B&W 4 w' &, A gL n M N e A w - e p w q A ~..E s p w. f w Wre e me. eene summme g.eenpe da.be de +4M'lh-*+ N'- N >=me. m au. L . - Ad&f & y 4 (FM) cm$w. A Stt E _... Wateggie $p e sum ______.__1 ' ' ~ ^ ^ " ~ ~ ~ ^ ^ - - - F-1 j.,.. 1. 7 l (, 7 Mite, W &,<a M ~ W 14A M HS (t.cres), <~A 4Gaa M y& & ACrvn&&A & Q,yA L ne4,. M q w qv vse M.&/ uay & M-js4 ye nd 44. J-

4. Grr.e

, mA m @ (% >gle), K 'e - m.p, a s -c a g W k nw f Nx-d-&p g.pg4 0 M N N ?? A;/ ~ Al 0 A p Q,Nvnec-#7 u, @ M a1ya2, a<ap s m ww, ATE A M m W # d i ken)-.. We.amais e ..e ee-oe wen e e.p==+.e** .( e -41/ m 3 0..w f ( N W r A

  • A A. 4 m W gkO

., p$N A AhvA & M ~ ____um-mm.m_ e-3 i i g 4 \\p#M^ 4 A d~ u.se. \\ i - 4 p t a %s M - p s y -.._.rpa p% q& M, lM M N ASTM y W, m &,. w Ap q d5~~ .a ,a a ra vn.yany; \\&&Y L & N b eld & Q l e { x 44+ y 7 ~ m a m Ig (Q T ' J..u h A & i p r,n-fre m(~.a b o vw~y4 &+ e 4 4=? W mmgg

h..

t L-. M, 4f.

d.._h_...

i '9 i s I4 4 a.v> L 7.Tk m # S W Ab.a m---.. f e.., W. l_ Q ~ ~. -. / = L-- -- l ' ' - - ~ l 4 1 4 l i V U w Q i f Q u p 4 c -g:4 t d L ) e4~

  • gw, d.----.

4t~tndt A $ & & s t use 34 A~~Ab 4 w Y;44

  • M a R JwWy x 44 h k kr A P M,J~f"'#Q Q Kz w,L. _ a_. Ar:j cm4 +: -A-] '

f __SW 0 -hb = -!2 h --? & t "I l Gtifut.4+ & uk U-fA W M. % M' % ' " Yj[ p 7- )),1 4-27: 9 { M N M _.f A!RS hfe.t "Pd <L '- eu ax, y.r-3 es,a mneqM A p r--> g.r-s /%CY&)%L y s'-/4 r-s-, p 1 s ~ HM un i M r-r Ln u.sy jy r-iy.4 sat._ AtRS V "Fs<.LXa,s~ 4 d s % p? W, m , /t.csa4; Ve-u/ ~ % A O ~ W &K"~JM) .L.... I -