ML20247N139
| ML20247N139 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Fermi  |
| Issue date: | 05/13/1998 |
| From: | Baker E NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Gipson D DETROIT EDISON CO. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9805270057 | |
| Download: ML20247N139 (10) | |
Text
.'
$-/$
ll May-13, 1998
- Mr. Douglas R.. Gipson Senior Vice President Nuclear Generation Detroit Edison Company 6400 North Dixie Highway Newport, MI 48166
Dear Mr. Gipson:
This letter is in response to a request from Mr. Alan Hickman of your staff for statis'ics on t
allegations received by the NRC conceming Fermi 2. The attached tables provide a comparison to allegations received at other operating sites for calendar years 1993,1994, 1995,1996,1997 and the first four months of 1998.
.You may notice changes from statistics previously reported. The software used to count allegations has been revised to avoid " double counting" allegations that are transferred from one NRC organization to another. Additionally, the data is audited for accuracy and corrections j
are made as appropriate.
If either you or Mr. Hickman have any questions conceming the data, you can reach me at (301)415-8529.
I t
Sincerely,N Edward T. Baker, lll Agency Allegation Advisor Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attachments: As stated -
cc w/ attachments: see next page DISTRIBUTION:
File Center /PUBLIC EBaker FMiraglia EAdensam AKugler l
' ' ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '
R MJordan, Rill Ig-
^vg';,R hg((ggggy
,,1 Document Name:p: fermi l
NRRf>f[
OFFICE NAME-EBaker l
DATE 5//S98-4O\\
\\
f 99oS2hdoS799o513 f
pon noocx o5oooo16 i
P.
PDR g
I sQ CEly O
UNITED STATES
-l j
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 2
WASHINGTON, D.C. 2066M201
\\*****/
May 13, 1998 Mr. Douglas R. Gipson Senior Vice President Nuclear Generation Detroit Edison Company 6400 North Dixie Highway Newport, MI 48166
Dear Mr. Gipson:
This letter is in response to a request from Mr. Alan Hickman of your staff for statistics on allegations received by the NRC conceming Fermi 2. The attached tables provide a comparison to allegations received at other operating sites for calendar years 1993,1994, 1995,1996,1997 and the first four months of 1998.
You may notice changes from statistics previously reported. The software used to count allegations has been revised to avoid " double counting" allegations that are transferred from one NRC organization to another. Additionally, the data is audited for accuracy and corrections are made as appropriate.
If either you or Mr. Hickman have any questions conceming the data, you can reach me at (301) 415-8529.
Sincerely, I
l
./
/4 1
Edward T. Baker, lil Agency Allegation Advisor Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attachments: As stated cc w/ attachments: see next page l
l
~
4 Mr. Douglas R. Gipson Fermi 2 Detroit Edison Company cc:
John Flynn, Esquire Senior Attorney Detroit Edison Company 2000 Second Avenue Detroit, Michigan 48226 Drinking Water and Radiological Protection Division Michigan Department of Environmental Quality 3423 N. Martin Luther King Jr Blvd P. O. Box 30630 CPH Mailroom Lansing, Michigan 48909-8130 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Resident inspector's Office 6450 W. Dixie Highway Newport, Michigan 48166 j
l Monroe County Emergency Management
.-)
Division
]
963 South Raisinville l
+
Monroe, Michigan 48161 l
Regional Administrator, Region lll U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 801 Warrenville Road Lisle, Illinois 60532 4351 Norman K. Peterson l
Director, Nuclear Licensing l
Detroit Edison Company Fermi 2 - 280 TAC 6400 North Dixie Highway Newport, Michigan 48166 l
August 19e7 l
l i
ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED - AS OF 4/30/98 5/12/98 Site l1993l1994l1995l1996l1997l1998 ARKANSAS 4
4l 7;__2; 7l 3
DEAVER VALLEY 9
7l 7j 5L8 1
BRAIDWOOD 3
11l 3: 10 17l 2
BiOV055 FERRY 39' 15I 13 27 20' 8
BEUs55fCK 2'5 iud 7[ 8 26 5
l BYRON 3
8 41 6l 12l 5
ChLLAWAY 1_5 2l 5{
k 4
2 CALVERT CLIFFS 6:
7!
8 7i 6
1_
CATAWBA 3:
71 2l Bl 8'
1_
CLINTON 12]
18, 8 20 33, 5
COMANCHE PEAK 19' 6! 14 59Il2I 2
COOK 6'
10!
4l 3'
6!
8 QOOPER 3 J 51 11} 14 19' 6
CRYSTAL RIVER 5'
3L6[ 21 20 5
DAVIS-BESSE 10! 10l 2! 11 6,
1 DIABLO CANYON 12j 13; 161 22 18 12 i
DRESDEN 12!,
12!.
12l 1 21 18:
3 DUANE ARNOLD 2!
2j 3;
I 3
2 FARLEY 1!
2j 3l 6( 2!
1 FERMI 9
19 8: 18 B:
1 1
FITZPATRICK Bi 3;
71 Si 5!
1 EORT CALHOUN 7
4!
4l 4! 10$
3 GINNA 1
1 II 4!
11 2h 9!
4!
G_ RAND GyLF l
3 2
1 HARRIS 2,
4 3
21 3!
4 HATCH 4!
8:
6
- 4) 17j 4
INDIAN POINT 2 6!
1 6!
6! 12i 7
isDIAN POINT 3 25 14 11 6
15i 4
I KEWAUNEE 1
1 1
Il LASALLE 5
15 7! 10 13; 5
LIMERIQ_K 16! 12!
4!
5 9:
1 MCGUIRE l
8l 3!
4 3
1 I
MILLSTONE 42l 45! 46! 711 743 20 MONTICELLO 2!
l 6!
2!
1 NINE MILE POINT 10i 7! 11 12 8! 10 NORTH ANNA 12 2'
8 4
3 OCONEE 1
4 1!
8 2
5 OYSTER REEK 9;
3]
5!
4! 10 1
PALISADES 5!
6 B!
5!
3!
2 PALO VERDE 40j 23 Q _8 L22i 19l 2
PEACH BOTTOM 61 8:
3' 4l 5'
2 SRRY 8) 7!
2 10!
9 3
PILGRIM 19:
9:
8!
Si 2:
1
. POINT BEACH 1!
4!
3' 4I 10 3
PRAIRIE ISLAND 4!
2; 3
7i 5
QUAD CITIES 5!
9l 7
13I 14; 6
RIVER BEND 21 12] 21 17 8!
3 ROBINSON 4
2 3
1 2I 1
i SALEM / HOPE CREEK 13! 22 20[ 43f 20!
9 SAN ONOFRE 8l 16 30!, 32) 32l 3
SEABROOK 4i 5,
6i di 2
SEQUOYAH 31!
7' 1 __ 2 7~
13 3
SOUTH TEXAS 38l 21 15 25 11 5
ST LUCIE 4l 11 21 46 69 16 SUMMER 21 3-2 9'
2 SURRY 5!
5!
3:
3 1
7 SUSOUEHANNA 8,
8:
8' THREE MILE ISLAND 4!
2!
1l, 34 24 4
i 2
4 1
TURKEY POINT 13l 9'
12L 16I 19i 7
VERMONT YANKEE 3
2 5:
9:
4!
9 VOGTLE 7l 11 11 6! til 1
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 8'
6 14 18' 23 4
Page 1
l ALLEGATIONS RECElVED AS OF 4/30/98 5/12/98
\\
Site l1993l1994l1995l1996l1997l1998 WATERFORD i
6L_3,__16j_21 ! 11j_2 3
i WATTS BAR f
69' 64!
60' 28! 13 WOLF CREEK f
6 12; 6 13 20 7
i'dN I
7! 17l B 14I 51 9
i
~
i i
1 l
i i
l l
Page 2
4 O
DISCRIMINATION ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED - AS OF 4/30/98 5/12/98
)
(
Site l1993 l1994 l1996l1996 l1997l1998 ARKANSAS 1
3!
BEAVLR VALLEY 4-1 1
BRAIDWOOD 4
il 2
4 BROWNS FERRY 4
4 3'
4 4)
BRUNSWICK 6!
1 1
3!
6 1
BYRON 1
1
'C'ALLAWAY 1
1 1
1 1
l CILVERT CLIFFS 1
3:
3:
.CLINTON 2
3j 6
1 C_OMANCHE PEAK 1
1 3:
1 1
COOK 3,
1 1
1 2
1 COOPER l
5-2 1
CRYSTAL RIVER 2]
1 4
3-DAVIS-BESSE 2
1 1
1 DIABLO CANYON 1
2 1
5 2
1 DRESDEN 3
1 2
2 DUANE ARNOLD 1
1 2
FERMI 4!
3 3'
4 1
FITZPATRICK 2
1 1
FORT CALHOUN 2
2 1
1 GRAND GULF 1
1 HARRIS 1
1 HATCH 1
1 INDIAN POINT 2 3
1 1
INDIAN POINT 3 3
3 5
1 2
LASALLE 2
3 2
LIMERICK 2
1 1
MCGUIRE 4
MILLSTONE 11 15 12 27 22 3
NINE MILE POINT 2
1 4
1 1
NORTH ANNA 1
1 O_CONEE 1
1 1
. OYSTER CREEK 1
2 1
2 PALISADES 1
1 1
PALO VERDE 14 11 4
3 2
1 PEACH BOTTOM 1
2 1
1 PERRY 2
2 1
3 3
PILGRIM 2
2 2
2 POINT BEACH 1
1 1
2 2
PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
QUAD CITIES 1
2 3:
1 RI.VER BEND 6
1 10 6
1 ROBINSON 3:
1 SALEM / HOPE CREEK 3!
5 7
10 3
2 SAN ONOFRE 4
4 3
6 6
SEABROOK 1
SEQUOYAH 11 2
3 6
2 SOUTH TEXAS 16 7
5 7
3 ST LUCIE 2
3' 2
1 1
SUMMER 1
SURRY 1
1 SUSQUEHANNA 2
1 1
2 3
THREE MILE ISLAND 1
TURKEY POINT 4
2 1
1 VERMONT YANKEE 2
1 VOGTLE 4
1 WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 4
4 2
d i WATERFORD 2
5 7
2I l
WATTS BAR 1B 1B 16 6
3j WOLF CREEK 1
3l ZION 4
1 10' 2
Page 1
~
ALLEGATIONS SUBSTANYlATED IN YEAR RECEIVED - AS OF 4/30/98 5/12/98 l
)
Site l 1993 l 1994 l 1996 l 1996 l 1997 l 1998 l
ARKANSAS 1
1{
4 2
(
BEAVER VALLEY 1
3:
11 2
BRAIDWOOD 1
6!
2i 4
41 1
BROWNS FERRY 14 8!
SI 7 4i 1
_ BRUNSWICK 10 6'
5!
4 13; BYRON 1
2!
4 4!
1 t
.CALLAWAY 3l 3'
3i l
CALVERT CLIFFS 3?
1 1
4l
_ CATAWBA 1
3 1
2 3!
4 CLINTON 4
9 5
9 13!
COMANCHE PEAK 7'
31 4
6 Sj COOK 2
61 2'
2!
1 COOPER 2
51 7
7 6!
1 dhYSTAL RIVER 1
2 4
1 21 4!
DAVIS BESSE 2
4 1
2l l
DIABLO CANYON 1
8 8
6l 8!
1 DRESDEN 7
5 6
6i 9!
1 DUANE ARNOLD 2
1 1
2' FARLEY 1
2 2
FERMI 5
5 1
8 1
FITZPATRiCK 2
3 FORT CALHOUN 1
2 2'
2 3
GINNA 1
2 1
GRAND GULF 1
2 3
1 HARRIS 1
1 1
HATCH 2
3 2
21 10 1
INDIAN POINT 2 2
2 31 4
1 INDIAN POINT 3 10 4
2 1
2 KEWAUNEE 1
1 LASALLE 2
6 5
3.
2 T
LIMERICK 7
4 1
4 3'
MCGUIRE 1
1 1
1 MlU. STONE 20 18 10 18 12 1
MONTICELLO 2
1 NINE MILE POINT 1
2 3:
1 3
NORTH ANNA 2
2!
2 1
OCONEE 2
1 2
1 OYSTER CREEK 2
1 3:
2 PALISADES 1
2 2
2 1
pat 0 VERDE 5
9, 8
9 7
PLACH BOTTOM 1
2!
1 2
PERRY 2
3!
1 3
1 PILGRIM 4
1 1
1 POINT BEACH 3
2 2
6 1
PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
1 2
2 QUAD CITIES 1
5 3
5 5
1 RIVER BEND 11 6
9 di 6
ROBfNSON 2,
1 1
1 SALEM / HOPE CREEK 3'
11 7
12 5
1 SAN ONOFRE 1
8 12 9
10 SEABROOK 1
1 1
1 SEQUOYAH 7
1 8,
11 7
SOUTH TEXAS 16 9
6' 6
5 ST LUCIE 1
2 13 26 31 1
SUMMER 1
1 6
SURRY 4
1 1
1 SUSQUEHANNA 3
2 1
18 10 THREE MILE ISLAND 1
1 2!
TURKEY POINT 7
4 5
6 7i 1
VERMONT YANKEE 2
1 2
1 2!
VOGTLE 2
4 3,
6 3!
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 4
4 7i 6
6)
Page1
ALLEGATIONS SUBSTANTIATED IN YEAR RECEIVED - AS OF 4/30/98 5/12/98 l
3 Site l 1993 l 1994 l 1995 l 1996 l 1997 l 1998 l
WATERFORD 3
2; 11!
71 2!
i WATTS BAR 33 29' 16 11) 4!
1 WOLF CREEK 5!
7i Il 6T 8'
l
'EIO'N 11 Sl 4
7; 25i 1
i 1
1 l
l Page 2
8 OPEN ALLEGATIONS - AS OF 4/30/98 5/12/98 Site l 1994 l 1995 l 1996 l 1997 l 1998 l Total l ARKANSAS i
f I
2-1-
3' SI[VER VALLEY I
l 1[
[
1 BRAIDWOO_D i
i 11 1
BROWNS FERRY 2l 3l 5l 10 BRUNSV/lCK 21 8
51 15 j
BYROP-1 2_
3 l
CALLAWAY 2
2 CALVERT OLIFFS 1l 1
, CATAWBA 2
2; 4
CLINTON 4!
5l 9
- gpMANCHE PEAK f
1 1
COOK 1
2 5!
8 ddOPER 1
1 5'
7 CRYSTAL RIVER 1
4, 3
8 DAVlS;BESSE 1
l 1
DIA_BLO CANYON 1
1 1
9l 12 pRESDEN 1
2:
1l 4
DUANE ARNOLD 1
1 24 4
FAALEY 1!
1 FERMI IITZPATRICK_
1 Il 2
l il 1
FORT cay % T!
1 3
4 GRAND Cut '
2; 2
H_ARRIS 5!
5 HATCH 1
3' 4
INDIAN POINT 2 1
6:
7 INDIAN POINT 3 1
2 2
5 KEWAUNEE 1
l 1
LASALLE 2
4' 6
LIMERICK 1
1[
2 MCGUIM 1
2l 3
MILLSTONE 1
3; 18 18 16i 56 MONTICELLO l'
1!
2 NINE MILE POINT 1
1 7{
9 OCONEE 6
6 OYSTER CREEK f
2 1
4 PALISADES 1
1 2
PALO VERDE 1
2 3
PEA _CH BOTTOM 2
2 PERRY 2
4 tj 7
PILGRIM 2
2J 4
POINT BEACH 2
2 4
PRAIRIE ISLAND 2!
2 QUAD CITIES 1
3:
5 9
RIVER BEND 3!
3 ROBINSON l
11 1
SALEM / HOPE CREEK 1
3' 3:
7i 14 SAN ONOFRE 2!
3E 2l 7
SEABROOK 11 2!
2!
5 SEQUOYAH 3;
1 2;
6 SOUTH TEXAS 41 2
5!
11 S_T LUC 52 1
13!
14 SUMMER 1
I 1
SUSQUEHANNA 2
27 4
THREE MILE ISLAND 1
l 1
TURKEY POINT 1
3 6!
10
' VERMONT YANKEE 9:
9 VOGTLE 2
1 3
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 1
4 5
WATERFORD 1
3 3
WATTS BAR 3:
5 3
Il 12 g_
WOLF CREEK I
3 7I 10 Page 1
l OPEN ALLEGATIONS - AS OF 4/30/98 5/12/98 0
sa.
I 1994 I ises I isse I iss7 l toss l Tot.i ZION I
I I
1 11 6
17 i
i I
1 i
Page 2 i
E-_-_.---__--________---_-_-_---
--