ML20247J116
| ML20247J116 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 07/19/1989 |
| From: | Kenyon T Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| PROJECT-669A NUDOCS 8907310239 | |
| Download: ML20247J116 (119) | |
Text
_ - _ _ - _ _ _
Project No. 669 July 19, 1989 APPLICANT:
Electric Power Research Institute PROJECT:
ALWR Requirements Document
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MEETING TO DISCUSS SOURCE TERM AND RELATED ISSUES FOR THE EPRI ALWR PROGRAM On June 22, 1989, representatives from the NRC, the Electric Power Research Institute, the nuclear power industry, and the public iret to discuss source term and other related issues for the EPRI ALWR Program as discussed in the EPRI Requirements Document. Enclosure 1 provides the list of meeting attendees. is a copy of the handouts used during the meeting.
At the close of the meeting, Dr. Murley stated he would issue the draft SER on Chapter 5 of the EPRI Requirements Document as quickly as practicable, although it may contain open issues. EPRI indicated that was acceptable to them.
/s/
Thomas Kenyon, Project Manager Standardization and Non-Power Reactor Project Directorate Division of Reactor Projects - III, IV, Y and Special Projects Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation cc: Meeting attendees
Contact:
T. Kenyon, NRR/PDSNP 492-1103 DISTRIBUTION
- Docket Fileg NRC & PDRs Commissioner Curtiss J. Sniezek PDSNP Reading T. Kenyon 0GC E. Jordan NRC Participants ACRS 10) g l
PDS N ff D:PD NP bn:sg CMiller j
TKe 7 /13 / 8 9 7//{/89 q.rp 3
g
) {dY 890731023F 090719
')
FOR FROJ 469 A PDC gg FRE CENTER C
~
\\s
\\
4 p
t f *'Gu UNITED STATES
+[
,c([j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
- .g
'.J WASHINGTON, D, C. 20555
%...-/ J July 19, 1989 L +-.. f Project No. 669 I
APPLICANT:
Electric Power Research Institute l
PROJECT:
ALWR Requirements Docurnent j
J
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MEETING TO DISCUSS SOURCE TERM AND RELATED ISSUES i
FOR THE EPP.I ALWR PROGRAM r
On June 22,1989,-representatives from the NRC, the Electric Power-Research 4
institute, the nuclear power industry, and the public net to discuss source terrn and other related issues for the EPRI ALWR Program as discussed in the l
EPRI Requirements Document. Enclosure 1 provides the list of meeting attendees. Enclosure 2 is a copy of the hancouts used during the meeting.
J At the close of the meeting, Dr. Murley stated he would issue the draft SEk on Chapter 5 of the EPRI Requirements Document as quickly as practicable, although it may contain open issues. EPRI indicated that was acceptable to them.
i k
f/1, I
Thomas Kenyon, Project Manager Standardization and Non-Power Reactor Project Directorate Division of Reactor Projects - III, IV,
{
V and Special Projects Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation j
i
Enclosures:
I As stated I
cc: Meeting attendees
Contact:
T. Kenyon, NRR/PDSNP 492-1103 o-_
)
n' e
ATTENDEES ORGANIZATION W. Long NRR J. A. Murphy RES j
T. P. Speis RES
.i L. Soffer' RES F. Eltawile RES C. G. Tinkler NRR I
J. G. Partlow NRR 1
L. S. Rubenstein NRR I
Gary M. Holahan NRR/DRSP i
Susan T. Gray EPRI-R. P Mcdonald Ala/GA C. W. Fay Wisconsin Electric Pwr Co.
Charles W. Jackson Con Edison i
Ed Kintner GPON I
- ]
John Taylor EPRI Karl Stahlkopf EPRI
~ Jack Devine
EPRI L
Dave Leaver Tenera 4
Bill Sugnet.
EPRI I
Helen Nicolaras Pastis NRR/NRC Joe Quirk GE R. B. Bradbury Stone & Webster Regis Matzie Combustion Engineering George Davis Combustion Engineering Roy Woods RES Margo Barron Ebasce Eve Fotopoulos Serch Licensing, Beichtel Chong Lewe NUS Corporation Rabi Singh NRR Stephen Additon TENERA l
Martin Plys FAUSKE and ASSOCIATES, INC.
Walt Pasedag DOE Albert Machtels EPRI/NUMARC
)
Jack Berga EPRI Michael H. Shannon Westinghouse Electric Corp.
T. J. Kenyon NRC/NRR R. J. Serbu NRC/NRR/DREP' R. W. Wright RES/AEB Pat Worthington RES/AEB Ralph Meyer RES/AEB Brad Hardin RES/DRA/ARGIB Thomas King RES/DRA/ARGIB David Shum NRC/NRR/SPLB 4
Thomas J. Walker RES/DSR/AEB i
J. S. Wermiel NRR/ DEST /SPLB l
Ralph Architzel NRR/ DEST /SPLB I
Frank Miraglia.
NRR/ADT Frank C. Skopec NRR/ DEST /RPB J. Gray NRC/0CM/JC l
K. Connaughton NRC/0CM/JC-Thomas H. Cox NRR/PMAS i
M. A. Taylor OEDO Charles Miller NRR/PDSNP Tom Murley NRR Ashok Thacani NRR R. Wayne Houston RES i
J. Wilson NRC/RES/ARGIB
c i
!EPRI i
i I
I i
i I
i i.
DISCUSSION OF
' SOURCE TERM l
^
AND RELATED ISSUES i
l Presented by the Advanced Light Water Reactor Program to Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation i
June 22,1989 I
l t
l l
i i
P e
R l
t l
a n
a W
i r
d o
e L
e k
v A
m o
ro I
m w
n R
o P
i R
fo n
E W
o s
i s
e L
ta u
A e
n s
i v
s g
d n s r
i i
ic o
t la ui c
np o c
io c
e i
t n
t
/
j n
h b
cR od n
ce o
O eW r a t
i t
t L
ol a
e e
c g
vAf r i n
n n
oe od u
l sh in i
t et aa m
t e
rodm m
e t
d n
o r
ne u
M ac e
c o
nfT e
s a cm st ee ur hc na c o t r ar uhg spt o
eo n
D m SS Ep i
r i
o Agenda for ALWR Prograrn Meeting with NRC June 22,1989 l
Introductory Remarks 1:00 PM Program issues 1:15 PM ALWR Program role Regulatory significance of requirements j
!mpact of ALWR Program on design Action requested of NRC 4
Source Term and Related issues 1:45 PM j
l This portion of the agenda is intended to provide a technical basis forproposed ALWR requirements andpotentialfuture requirements, utilizing a logical, technically based approach to source term regulation. For each of the following subject areas, a technicalposition and technicalbasis willbe presented along with the implications to the ALWR design and the NRC action requested:
)
Timing of Fission Product Release from Fuel 1
Magnitude of Fission Product Release from Fuel l
Fission Product Chemical Form lodine Release Fraction to Containment Atmosphere Aerosol Removal from Containment Atmosphere l
Amount of Fuel Clad Oxidized (Hydrogen Generation)
Hydrogen Concentration Necessary for Detonation Containment Vent / Overpressure Protection i
Potential Future issues 4:15 PM Passive plant work Technical basis for change in EPZ requirements Continued source term improvements Closing Discussion 4:45 PM Adjourn
P t
i t
d m
s R
n r
e n
o wi W
o c
a r
oi L
f tc h f
f s
t A
a we i
r t
f o
e e
I p
d n
od R
r n
e n
e e
n P
r k a
e e
b v
,u E
c e
l n
l t
s a
u af l
f c
a o
s e
e f
in C
l w
o i
r t
h i
o s
c f.
i t
m u
e e
t y
e e
t a
g v
s d i
l i
n t
n nb i
r c
e ai i
g v
e c
s l
o o
b e
ns j
i l
t v
o y
c oi r
n n
pn P
y a S.
w e
s u i
e sak U
i r er l
si e
e r a R
e p ee t
e n ah W
t h
x t
l c e s d e
a c t
o s u
i t
mn L
Ps n
r a
n e
e e h t
i e
ol A
f l
s t
uo s
s i
s t
t e
ui a
s e
e e
s s
z u
vdn r
p o
l h
insi me a
oi r d T
me o r
r h ha t
e st a
s y y yr nad e
e r
e e
e P
ol i
p u
n t
h h h Cg ait i
o l
t t
c t
et sAr S U i
a B
\\
o t
k dreow W
l d
ia n
g L
t a
e n A
t g
di p
n n
n s
I o
o g
en e
r e P
i i
m s
o t
1 c
a c
e ni n
z a
d l
t i
o d d ed f
r e
o hn C
a v
t a n
d e
r
)
ni o
o n md h
i a
t f g c
u i
t ns ae s
a lo oe
)
e s
r s
r u
r s
id l
t o
o u
e e
a gn dg f
R s
t r
oi e
n a
r t
nn t
t n
e o
r mf ui Pn n
a s
r el oe o
p n gle f
e Rc ml o
n c
l u
a c
ain i is h W(
sicg cic e
n e e n n o
nh e v uhe L
Dh c
t as cc c
s i
A s
et l
s ei n
s n
si f
ti t
t ay e c
e n
e s o (o r
s r
e mid e
e e
s ohp h
micl nC et t
n ui t
s va s
T w
ef eR i
rl t
t t
r e oUVN eu eno id d
sg sal l
u et o
l t
t t
qI r
pf I
I I
e R
l
margorP R
d W
n L
a de A
s I
hd r
R t
o s n n
d a
P i
l
- b a
n E
as e
l t
e P
v si t
ei g
l i
r n
st t
u e
o n
n t
g m e
t ia my e
s r
t e
n e s B
d o
v u od i
t t
a n
a r
n a
z pi e s
pd mei v l
i i
i t
r h a e
a nt R
od gyi i
l t
h n
sb n W
i i
a wt e nr L
s d oe i
r sph t
A.
n o
eut ef t
t r
e ei r e s
ad a h
h s s o e o
ar pr s T
cbe r gr s
o a o AAu c
d nd nne i
t av I
f
ma rao rP RW y
f n
os LA a
k r
s o n
t m
a ad R
r I
n n
e t
e ye P
en r
a
.u i
g v
E t
s a
a
+d lP g
r n
r 3 n e
e o
o f
g o a r
r p
i t
t s
n e
C m
a t s i
r t
c l
l e
o u e t
R e
i i
t r
o si t
t e
N b
a c
ei B
d ly g
a w
l rt p e f
n d
u g
e e
e pl i
l g e g
hg t
A e
u o
n e
n t n r
s c
S h a
s RF i
l d
eo i
x e
s e
eR me u
H /
r rm o
a vf R d o
a i
s :s wWl a r
e ef s
R n e t
l o
r e
e oP mt g
t l
t r
n n l
W mmc epP l
l r
c n
uB e
ei n
e a
e s
w mid o
L eaA ms n
h e
l ei y
eu r
t t
r ix A
uE e
med r
i n
r ib r
d d e
aP e/
u i
r q
t i
s al o
e e
r n
qu v
t
.s n F c
n e
g o
y e s h
Re t
oh re 0 %p c g
r i i r
s v
n T
Rs e
a e e t
al 0 5 m
n-s s i
WcA 6
1 HD C e n I
I L
ho A
Tc
margor H
P C
R A
W L
O A
R IR P
'N P
E A
P RW L
se A
s u
I t
s R
n s
P e
E i
m m
re e
T t
s a
n e
is c
a o
t r
S s b i
u tc i
s o
s ni e
y a
S t
s g s a o
c eb f
is r
o i
s n
eb P
l a
gd n
t n
t o
B i
eio n
e s
P e
n e
c m
t gd n
a d
5 t
i u
s g al c
a i
c a
r e
n mav A
r e
Dis T
r n
o e
e t
R R
f e
r k r
p c
e s
e Wipi v
W a
r L
e L
l h
A S
A C
~m 4
2 g#
f 1
i SIMPLIFICATION w9 DESIGN MARGIN w <m o._
O9 BEST MATERIALS o un 2
<wC i
LONGER RESPONSE TIME I
, iw:g :: #
g.
LICENSING DESIGN PERFDRMAMCED.E31Gli '^1tlSK^EVALLIA110bl'RASIS ;
~
i
/M i BAEIS
.. mM.V PBAEf570.~,,. P *.)
s,,,tW. te A@ WWy;;/nkyG,.:.;.;;
's I
y '* 2
~ pm
- c o
.,,A r,
u;.ssw+, ry '., ;,, '..,
7@. '
,,ft.:' p... g
- g.
ig WR~]' $ ggp ~jf{yp
.y SAFETY SYSTEMS A ADMIOM.WMN b ADUNSTCORE1Ma440E,s.<. ggy:z #P. g wp 4 DEFe,JS,-
PR M E
~~ Odn I
Pfu 40 -
3 h u W.M N CYPTH w
i FonmusnENT?~
ez CORE DAMAGE patmK,mN e.
$0 AS REQUIRED BY m
.MUTIUTYSperm[gg
<Z REGULATIONS
- FDESIGNEmmm --
W PRA METN+
@js GPEOFIED RETHODS AND9 %~Ns:+CR
~ ~ "
^"P~
x
- wr T
$p e4 mpg %L~.. D "
e, GurERAue a m.a NRC AFPROVED
~~'
'W*W E
o U$
d o'
METHODS AND Wl$;<x%m:>$$,;N.M %: ~ esp.
'E-2 Ms.
w~
- s
- fQggg y)
's. Q, i.9, CRITERIA s
MV,En 9.;
j$f6c.g'h}i
.A l
a "4. l ' g,u f
'";~
l i
.:r p- % p ;a yz.?^
i
{
. t*B82em&4%;;.
, 6 CONSIDER V
CONTAINMENT SYS-
$yACCIDEFE' ~'
. ~E I
TEMS TO MmGATE WCONTA
, 7
{ffgx xMARRANG{[a ACCIDENTS AS 2
zo REQUIRED BY mm y '.
REGULATIONS giQQF S,
e,
., ~.
gACCIDENTPOQQYQ e/CSTATEMENTnMM I
5 Ash &;m a.e w n W W es mR
' 4:xi4s h..
??$Y$ g
- ?
W@Wa#wE.._ _.MG.
-l I>
';-:Ih'[.[..C E Figure 3-1. ALWR Safety with Relationship of Defense-in-Depth and Design Braes r
tne
)
m yr d
t s
o e
P t
t e
n a
v n
e e
R l
)
n ig e v
r W
i r
r n
r y a ui y
t L
at s
s ei ms S e
A i
l f
t y
eC y
a t
I n
n u
t t
R s
R r
n r
iv e
p e
o t
o ci a
n P
g e c) o E
m c
e c
nd t
i t
e a
of s
t i
.s n
c f
i r
e e
r u
s a
gv g
i e
u r
p s e
e
/
n l
t q
5 eai d
r o
wt c
(
e vd o
t o
n n
nt u
R E
s r
i eh e
onl c
P y
0 s
m
- g. ie n
r r
t o
n 1
u o
n avi t
o t
t t
g s
sa a (e n
a S
i i
i t
n e
s t
l e
u n
C o
i t
e yf e
n s mR i g s v
c e
c o
e d
t A;
a e
i r
i s
e n
v n
c u
c H
ain u
r ei e
Sgl t
,t c
eb g p u n
u a
n a
r q e q g e ni id v
A b
n a
e l
e v
e ef e
g a
g maf e
s
(
n do r
r io c
i c
s me pA n
o af e
l i
t i
t e
n i
p a
a gl S g
r lpd t
/
s t t c
an i
i a
a s
e e
n vt a
gicd t
he a
s mn n
e t
t nf e
o ad o
mh n
t r
ai r
s i
e i
e e
s n
t n
e p e e c
od i
S m
e n
g r g e c
d v
t i
me s
ed min un mt i
c e
r t
n e
E ol s
z o
a o
a e
a a t
,e l
d v
i r
meraim c
ei c e 'e t
r s
s d at d
f t
e y n r
ts t /
sp ei z
s i
e g e vh v
g y n e
n a ii v
ae a u l
K v
o p r ol is o
r n
eq r
a o
r a
e e
c p mt p n ci pa r e l
eD E
A r
h T
1 2
3
/
t s
n R
n e
W r
o o
r a
u L
t l
ir s u c
A y
l e
in t
r se s
s t
n o
t a
o nf tk a
e nl i
ir b
m d
e C
n me mr n
y a
n t
ie a
s p e e g
h el rv o
y s m, e
i c
e t
v e
usu r
n v
q i.l da a
n e
e e av i
t ge yd t
e nv e
r t
h t
t gRt e i
u s e b
i l
i t
Wtng n
i q
nh ui 0
r ec eLaa e
ca ob Ap f
1 l
t r
o i
l 5
t t
n e
ea-F rs o
r e u 5
ah nE i
e hm t
t f
c s
t i
t g
o o
el alt 0 R
r t
e o
od hu1 a
l laW t s x r
o m
gL tc p
s e a
me r1
~
aie a
nA l
f t
A l
i t
D e e5 a
cwh wR t
eh e
i e
mTE b
oP des nt s a
l r
l i
a o
o_ts0 o
y e ed p t
v l
t 1
t t
n s d n
e at u or C
n ex e
el d ds i
o l
m1 a
vs c
n i
R ie i
o oer t
o et i
dr sgin f
ti o i
W f
f t
lea u
c kict diuF s
r e
l a
bps n oe e L
qD i
h u
p A
n eC T F Wsm r
I i
m te r
g n
e o P
r g
vt a
sic is staa R
t e
el e g
W d
ur n
l n
u o
L g
emr de i
n b
e n
A r
cp a
I o
i l
sn he6 m m R
la ir y
P e
s-ee c E
e c
s oE dbl i
t i
eh l
0 yo o i
sw1 r
r p
,l t
e o
e C
h ds x mdla c1 ero t
e e
o y
y t
g dn reg o
s t
d e
n b ed xi y f
t u e est i
e a
e eqe n nf oa e
e c a
l S
m ho s x cs e
s st c
d wtn ain e )e dde n
)
i l
r o
.d enr miu b
y i
cla wau u
e s c
- 5. c v a
e r,n bt P
n n
v o i
k e (0 r f a c
oa R
e m yf e s gh i
t r
n amm nie he W
u d e(
ohv c,r i
ci i
L aq nR y eaa l
r t
c A
ne u
t ev or o5n i rrr b 2e c he id,s t
u-s i
r s
e n st i
qai rn dai a eeho o t
hr Ab Stf yTwc
dn n
r ia o
a(
f r
s t
y be ef o c
oh l
e
.ya my i
n
,t u
re c
W o
5 n
L q
gw 0
e A
e r
en u
t I
a o a
q f
t e
n Ct e
r a
n f
d s
d e
ee o
n e
t o
m sd d
a ow m
an e
No e
h d
ee r
t n
p o
m R
l l
lA e
f e
a e
R d "e
\\
h M
t s
5 e
hi v
o l
r b 2
cm i r n
o a
u o
g e5 cd e 0
e r0 k
e 2
i ot s
t t
c a
i a
a x
f r
r C
n e
5 s
F 1
t e
o e om D
s s
s i
t n
a a
e t
o C dR 0
l e
ud) C e
1 o
c y
w5 le yt t
mR adi c
o2 l
l c ob ul d i
l e
n r
a n eba i
t i
D a
peb s
ea y
o n
vr 5
6 7
tb t or o
r a o
0 0
0 Chp c u e o
cy A
Awla 1
1 1
t nr R
Rf n o
s oo P
C o
t t
sc n
l mi u
aq t
t a
i m
mud s
n r
r r n eie e e r
or MF o
ot r
fh c o p/
rc re c e
6 f
ea eps s
o0 P e P si U N1 t
l l
e h
t n
i d
n e
o d
)
i t
n t
n n
o a
n e
n e
i p
t o
e s
m a
o t
r r
u n
e e
i o
s s
c a
nd i
s d
t et n
l e m
n n
g n o
u u
f o
a o
ei r
c n
vt c
c s
mf o
e e
e m
g r t
o d pt i
r e
d o
o o
D r
f s
e r
r f
o e
a s
d p
t s
e a
a y
l l
a e
a ale e
v h
r i
(
r u
c e
r e
o e
l d
s e
s m
l t
i r
ei s
n r
r t
s e
z c
e c
i e
r h
r t
i c
u ehr d
n p
l c
u d n
c e o
ix o
re e
d oiih s
i o
t r d hp o a
v o
T p o ws r
d r
o r
o e
at p
/
i n
t n
f e
a f
n l
n o
o nmt c
e o
e oi c
it s
mda c
v l
u e
n i
e s
s ot u
ot r
i s
f oi n def n
n f
f f
f or c
i ol o e f
e re o
n m
i f
a m
ph e
l t
o n
c n n n
t u
g oi oi np n gi miaioos u
o a
i n
O t
t r
t c
e ct s
o i
d n
mah an smmy o r
roit iT F CFc FaAHC
P t
s c
n
, ieeshr W
r o
at L
o is R
b dc A
nn s
W I
e u
L e
ga r
i ~
o P
r se c
A u
egm E
t s
y u
dd gle n e
f i
o k
l D
a nw s r
i i
o sot tn nnn m
f e
n eke t
r o
o ct m i
e p
n i
l e
t T
a f er r
ori m
o r u e
s nuq f
rot s
oc e c
f nis t f r i
n r
ie a
ao n
u gm b ehg r
t o
nel d g!s i r a
i c
slie S
t i
r ui n n d o q n f
p s
oie eht c
s o
pr cn ems n u
a o e
s5 ee r rebi t
met t
r s
e e e
op e s et m dt dr o c o
ipi i
v v u prdu p
o oq oues a
e )r oes r
rh r
u PCPri sna P
l
e e
t t
a n
c lp e
n m
y a
n ls n
i d
u a
o o
t i
t n
i u
e a
o n
)
G a
nt c
i i
on o
tn t
t i
y i
a at o
s ee n
r t
.t n
o n
r i
d t
t pi c
i a
o r c a
e e c r
l t
r t
f u
d n a e
e h
i g
e f
e m
7o s
p a
3e e
s l at e
o u
7 R
s 0
m l
a e
m tnl cr s
i t
d e
a Gt eui t
cne a
e s
Ea mian r
t t
e i
Rs er gi n
t h
2 ard e
a p
/
l Uu epoo m
o l
s 1
i pN e
%%%d e
o n
h m (e a n
R m
c 54n a
s i
1 r
u 9
a i
t r
t st n
u u
a h
sl n e
o o
o d
w ea e
t t
lb ch h
n n
n t
f a
e o
e gs n
o 1
s nn d
ne m1 i
me mi I
e h
o s
o 4
nlb n sa nt r
i f
0 iye f
e e 4
aoi i
ar nd e s o
i l
t fl t
8 n
o n
e a
i v a cr v
e m
4 of of o
i ef o
1 r
el c
c
- 4. r po mr h
o%o 1
f e o
oor1 f s
h 4
4 g
e 0%t D
4 t
t f
.l on r 4 0
e 0 0 u e % o 3. ca 8
si I
l T
4 s1 5os1 g1 a m o
=
=
l i
a a
n m
s i
1
.t e
e i
e PoA 1
Dl m G. h G. dnRe r
l e
e I
i TR R
TRC RaSA
e h
t n
i d
n e
o d
W
)
i t
n t
n n
o a
n e
L n
e i
p o
e s
m a
o A
t l
t I
r r
e u
n e
e R
i o
s u
s c
a nd i
s.
4 f
d t
et i E
m 'o m
n n
r g n o
u a
o ei o
t c
n v
c c
r r
f o
e e
e s
m g r f
t d
t e
e d
o o
p o i
D s
s e
r r
r f
o a
a s
d p
t l
y l
e e
a a
a e
l a
h e
v i
r l
e e
(
r u
c r
r e
o e
l d
s s
m t
i r
t ei s
n c
r s
e z
c e
t h
u c
ie r
r i
d u
ehr d
n p
l c
od n
ce o
x o
r i
e oiih s
e r
i o
t r d hp o a
v p p o ws T
r d
r o
o e
at
/
i n
n f
e t
a n
f n
o o
o nmt c
e l
o e
i i it c
s s
mda c
v l
u e
n e
s s
ot u
o r
t i
i f
oi n def n
f n
f f
f or c
ol o e f
e f
re o
n m
i o
a m
ph e
l t
n c
n t
n n
u a
oi oi np n gi ni o s u
o a
miaio O
t t
i r
t c
e ct s
o mah an smmy o d
n i
r roit TF CFcFaAH C l
t 3
n e
d d
n cr a i
c ef P
f t
af o R
ai e
l yn e o m
W ar b t
L i
ot e
A r
f omn b o a
I f
oo od R
t r
l t
t o
no P
c ner c r
E i
ul m
e u
l l
de i
or u
nh o wp i
f o
a na rF ey or tnnr e
Pe o o a t
s nv cr o
nh o e pr i
s o
t of o
t c
u n
n t
c im ie a c i
s gn so me h o e
t r
b l
i r e
m ml i
Ff ow t t oi t e
r f e n o f
r c
e os t
r l
uie eh l
a ow st u
aa ge s ed e
r nl l
t el ie b
gi n eu 7
r r d o b
mR t
a ei c
t s
i l
r a u
T aci u
d t
o i
f d n p o
o eiu r e pn r
t t
e en a a
s d ee nt ai on esdh a
ist i
ncle s s le oc R caf F n u
i i
l
t t
e n
c S
h e
u eC t
r dd d
oC t
o a
ce i
cE t t r
h cn cr p
u eAe e e t
d n
h t s
i t
u h
dd(
e oi s
o c
en s L
t i
ar e.n s
ci e A
cpc o
s nml l
ab c f
i i
id n i
t I
dt f
s + a i
r n o e e o o
,. 0 l
sf r n s
e0 o P
i i
t ep c2 v
E s s ac
^
ef e
cu n
h i
c ed r no e eg ea er r
nh or s
ec r
d g d hi t h n
ui me a n e e e e r
i h
d e ed pt h q
s ewros y pi f
i a
st nr ec af e
t l
r d
B a
t u oe d u o
l l
n s o cp n
ee mw%
e e eh t o
l n8 mi 0
a d r
~
c ct ee0 d
t l
i iu i
5 i
t ca nd1 a
etnt er in ar oict hl th uu et cu l
t a
o f
h opu ao d sb o
b d r e e m mbRa eo t
c r a aud e
e t f awn al r t ut ae T
r e t
r l
hiL a t
s r s t
s u t
c c nAh nf nea eau t
ope pe ys oe s r s ns mh mmle t
eer at nae e
t oi gr d m d
d l
f n eos o
h n o
ga sb e) s r si f
t f s e n c
.e s
h l
e o nl e e a
h i
s o t
si eb t
s 2 ac yd ataui Da n
l d
al eiqe e
s e I
n el Af en er Fl Ma u t
i u
e r
s c Sr Twq i
ta p
R u
f s t
or W
a o u
e n mc e L
hn u cn A
h i
r oi eg n
f r
tc yt o
e ob er u t
c peb c
l v
e dlnw i
s l
ol f
t fe a
eca r
S t
nr
~
al e
f uo e
fC l
t e
p f
h o
m iR Su mr m e
t l
R o
a r
er f F o o a o
b hc Wt c cr f
o
,c t s m
ass g
L n or fRr Alat e n
e i
o o
e ol f t
t mr sWf n
e e a t
o u: h u
if eLa ot t
cf s Te sgs c a f
yne ch o e e o
t t
hu f
s ait at e
gt n l
o a ns
,s l
t u
sle axi swb nmi n
e em eo a
mo m i
i ie ch cir0 tf t
i s
ain0 nsl 6
yR ms 6 e
p ee ut phst s
ien qn at a u l
af
,e o tsca ee t
n o el b enh o
- et smn c ea r
A sur ee n
t eqe nr e
at n aa i
r l
t
.i bea s n u a
ahh ql bt t n see e e a
e hr r c otng sr r
c e n
oh eh un de eeh v
so t
ed g
r simu t.
e os o i
ciq r s sfi s a ct e oe Baas Fd l
i
U nn D
gg 2
2
)
)
E m
ii
(
(
O ss R
R ee e
e a
U )n DD o
o r
t t
KDTi n
n g
d AAPm RR d
e o
a ELU(
WW5 70 70e e
r PCR LL6 57 56S S
P lCs AA e
yy R
c R
W k
bb
,000 0
a O E dd0 00 e n ee
.L 7
07 880 1
Pe T V dd 3
34 243 4
RA u
O E )n uu E CRi cc WI l l f
q o e M nom ee L R I
r r tS TUC(
,P P AP r
oE r
at d
n n
t n S
e f
o o
iy iy s
Se C
.e r
r s
s r
d d C
eF a
ra r
u r
ed ed o
E u xu vn vn h
i nc l
o no no R
i ac N Sk aA
.SSoc oc W2 Ff eA
,Ccy o
CCCe nCe n ut n Sof So P 2 r
E ACt e os CCf s
,i o,i r
o o e C
CESf t
t aie EE da da o,r i
t r
cr s ez s ez f
Ce N
OoA,Sel ooe e
u eie ei Ft E
LN NNruFu uFu a
r r
r v
U Crjina e
oif 0 w y.
sl s
,O f l
e Q
rA c
L e w /w IC AAa,ixsaix s
/
0 h
dl tS E
cC CCFueF ue 3ep i
Ar OOw,e/Arpw,p i
tC ep rd S
eOtlne nn
/
t 1
f a RLeReeR e
d!
e e LL
,mD,mD t
nl i
ii vt el s Pe Pe a ao l
nssC l l l l oc gan e nn aaSt eSt e f n I
r s
s ce amrapaaP m m O yi O yi Ro o d
d rr nl LSTOTTH SSLSSLSS W'ssd e
US Bo se l
r V
or c or UV B'
B' on f
t o EE OU DDM M
F yu f e t f E 2P iO r
2 2L L
0v e t
7o s r
Su 1 ce t
s s
e ns ue ~
op e
e b
h t u c
c oret eR n m n
o e t
e o e
dcr m
T u
u e
t f f f o
of
't l l l N
a ou uu c
he mt e i
e BGk GG e
at T
A S
c S
yn e
uer o
e L
hdi dd of e
smh r
si P
R cne nn R yue n
r ql o
ATT r
W aam aa W uee c
P l
er rr
)
)2 2
p(
i
-98/S C
RN
l 4
ELEMENTAL GROUPING AND RADIONUCLIDES USED FOR THE SFD 1-1 j
Numeer Fam21v Elements Isotopes Used for Evaluation l
I Noble Gases Kr.Xe 85Kr. 87Kr. ssKr.135xe, istxe, 43sxe Halogens Br. I 8dBr. 8381. 8331. 8331. '2'I. 8331 3
Alkali Metats Rb.Cs esRb 8'Rb. "Rb. issCs '3'Cs 1
Chalcogens Se Sb. Te 838Te, 83:Te, d33Tc. 833*Te, 83*Te 5
Alkaline Earths Sr.Ba
'8Sr. s2Sr. 83'Ba 6
Rare Earths Y. Zr. Nb Mo Tc
'i=Y '8Y 808Mo. '08Tc, Noble Metais Ru.Rh.Pd.La.
and Other Low Ce. Pr. Nd Pm.
Volatility Elements Sm. and Eu 4
o i
10'*,
i a 10.a ?
5 g
g l
$ 10 l
<,,,,,, e,;ue,,N
. """ #w. s
~'\\
'il I
4
- "a e
,,.os, tone.v.i.>
/
e 10 0 l' e
1
.a.
t
/
.. 2 i
.i 1
s 10, p
,y.
1 m-e s.:e c t, a
Co 5
<* n !l l. -
i\\
4.
- I f,3..-./,4,..
p.
\\\\q_,,I.\\ x l,lf.
u g 3 9.. e - - -,
.a.. \\,,,
v 1
p-
.V u.)
3 10, 3
,4Jf woue s
\\ ll 3 V
g a
/
1
..y,j j :
1 t 16 r
Goup 6 t/ 1 u
' 1 q
~
z 10~" ~
)
1200 1600 2000-2400 2800 3200 3600 4000 Time (s) esss aw.voe4c -
SFD 1-1 Best Estimate Effective Fractional Release' Rates l
i jg3 2500
=
Nena ens reisses rate 4
.. comuaiea sunes
_ ]Q
,g everage temperatur L
E i
.W2000-1 4;
I 10
'r I
4 i
E 5
on.e ee casesunn.. ',f 3
4,.ur.e 3
g com 4
inmoten e
-l17se toewee et
.I 3
I
!/ /
' * *8
- 1500
- i I
metieee J.
3 1
2
- 4: ems
.l
.nitisten i
.c 107 I C
tugtu,e,., I q
r 1
'j U
i
- /.4 e
1000 C
qq* j-j qq* I 500' 20 30 to 50 60 70.'
nm. (mw
.. = = =.. -. = -
I Fraction Release Rate of Noble. Gas j
Measured During the SFD 1-1 Test Compared To The' Temperature History and K'ey Events.,
i c
1 l'
- p h
t n
n er 5
o e ve ah i
mht g
r t
e a
nt o n
t i
R t
p i
n a or i
i Rm Wi W n o a ei t
f h bt R n
L t
C n E o od des cde lea z
As
,l ud si t
ah t
D n oic anm nei t
e h gi al w
hc 5 msa t
i t e
sp pr k r
t ul r
e ce o ot r
c e ad c
o e
t l
s out pf e
y euN ff a
emb r
n D
a vd e
a 1
e h
hen s
eo oiv o
shr C t t u sa s dr t t t t f
p a
i n
o n
oyc e
o t
t emh s
c t n nn c
i mo e
e e
e Cio ere r
A ef v
goo N
l mt r1 r
o arf Rs l
t s
eA eu t t r
e e Ni e
i g
uso p nn r f
n rR aoe ohr g
n qab p
eeaA vch o
Nif AW t
i de t
t Rlei a gd w4 L
l l
rt u
n n
ean k
A t
r1 i
cu d kka d
o
,dn s
dur e
aay e
w3 ea e
edu t
t el t
t t
s s
s 1
sp R
aoc e
l o
l t r c tdu ei eo l
w G. qe spo uq s n o u
ul ra es q
mnt e
e nn e mR e v oo e
ai n R n eaoR a
R rs glvti ro D
nt oi o nia c
n gt n
i o
s a
o of i
t PS d e vt n o
o e ot r
i r
i su v
i t
t t
e c dn nf c Pi cm t
D R LmA Rioin A RaAa t t g
n r
Wt C Wlaci CWe C. o u
r g
as s
La R Lo e RLt Pr s
h so At aN l
Aitd N A a NP 1
2 3
-2 S
8
/6
/ ! l i3 C
Ill d
R N
l L
e h
t n
i d
n e
o d
)
e i
t n
t n
r n
o a
n 6
e n
e i
c p
t o
s m
a o
t r
m u
n e
e is o
a-nd s
i s
r d
t e
t n
l ef n
n n
g o
u u
d a
o ei t
f c
n v
c c
e o
e e
e s
ms m
g r t
pt o
a d
o o
i o
D e
r r
f e
r r
l f
o e
e s
d p
t l
y s
r a
a a
e la a
s e
v h
r i
(
r u
c e
t e
o e
l d
s c
r m
l t
i e
ei s
u n
r s
e z
c e
r d
ie r
r h
t i
c o
ehr d
n p
l c
u r
n ce o
x o
r i
e e
d p
ih s
i i
o t
o d hp o a
v T
r n
o ws r
d r
o p oi o
e a
n t
/t e
a f
f n
i l
n s
o nmt c
e o
e it c
o s
mda c
v l
u e
n i
i e
s f r
ot u
o t
s f oi n def n
n or c
i of f
e f
f o e r e o
n m
i f
l t
o n
a m
ph e
l c
n t
n oi o n np n gi u
gi mia os u
o a
i n
t O
t o
r t
c ct s
o i
i e
d n
ma an smmy o h
roit r
i TF CFcFaAHC
e ro ct n e e s
ht t
t s
c ms i
n u
or o de f
c r
o en ro s
i s
ai PC e e l
el nm r b i
o t d io c
sr uren o
f d ci s
o t
r d p id Fe pem r
neu f s od s oa s
ii s s a
e s n nl i
f o4 oe f
c4 ot 8 iR t
en4 c
d e1 d
a uiD t
r cI i
F n cT ga e
ayh mntah e
r t
h i
Tfow
ma r
e%
a
)
w o
s 1
a5 o
r tn e7 P
l d
d el tea e
e R
d r r
r W
i t
u u
c en s
s L
c ni aio a
a A
d p e
e 2 o m'
m R
I e
i.
IMd n
n P
no Tn o
o E
ah s
i i
t t
ae a%
e t
,i l
h mw lala a
ui u
t s
t 1
l u(
di%
i n s v o v0 sa ae0 ev ere c5 nm nd t
t B
P
)
,s o e u en E at id d u di la T gp ce cl i
c S e am au u
c c e n
D,b e l
i f
l og 2 a 2
e h
F n n r
Mv Mt I
I e
h S
a c
d r
(
e a T e Tm e
s r
s T
n u r e
eo t
o hf f
r e s e h
av e
t t
me o d e d s ns n a i
mle aa a e re u
e pnf sl s e l
x o e
t t
r eie s r s
tah e
ee e
e t
t t
l u
h it lpa m Dt Da i
l v o F r Fl r
o o
n ef Sf Sv I
f(
l
4 6
4 4
5 0
0 1
o o
s D
t t
8 n
F 3 6 4 3 0
8 S
2 2 4 0 0
o 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 1
3 i
t ca 9
90 r
1 F
3 b
0 1
o o
e t
t 4
s D
'0 %
8 8 8 1
0 a
F 0
1 0
0 1
1 2
e S
< 2 0 0 0 0 0 le R
39 l
0 e
1 0
u 1
F o
D t
1 2
n F
6 6 0 0 S
2 2 9 1
0 0 0 o
0 0 0 0 0 0 1
7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
s t
lu 1
2 1
s T
0 0 0 e
S 0
1 2 0 1
0 0 0 5 5 3 4 0 0 0 0 9
R D
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7
E ts S
~
e d
T ez D
s m
id a
m u ms t
F n
G mu mmnid O i
u e
x i
S e
e e
u r
e i
t i
m u
u u
n n
r n
l h
i oiZ b
s l
i i i
r r
t t
e od e
e a
e u
c l
r E
N oCT B CR S A %
l t
l
i1 J
r_
i j/f m
s a
h r
tn a
o o
s m
rP o
n d
w R
o e
e t
t t
W r
s n
n 2
i a
a 0
t o
a I
L U
c c
0 c
C e
A ii l
f f
o f
e 2
1 a
ii t
I r
o R-Q 5 6 0 n
n 4 5 7 6 Q 0 3 0 g g 4
e 3
s
.l F
n y
5 5 4 0 0,
0 0 0 s
s a
P ii e
E o
r n
n e
l o
0 0 0 0 Q 0 0 0i e
i I
t r
s c
n t
rS a
a e
r e
F v
de n
s le a
I e
R rcn i
e d
r oo o
l fe C
r r
e n
t fa o
e r
s oc t
l de u
g s
a m
e at dn R
e mid 2
oc r c f
a i
gn e M
e ht ih T
p cr r
s e
r ub e
u u
ae o
ef t
K CT$RSCE E La t
1 o
5 9
7 2
0 s
s a
4 s
s 8
2 3
a 9
o 2
s s
)
i i
2 1
i i
0
,e I
l l
g no e
h i
t t s c
f e a
or r
u F
et sa e
ur s
ae a
cp e
em 5
5 l
be e
7 2
L t
R h
0 0
'gh nn e
ig hi oo b
h l
i s
o at st a
t c N
w a
e lur 5m sF
- 7. i t
e 0 e Re fh ot s
t a nd on s e a
it el ca)
Te r%
R 2
f P
e 2
s (9 l
Ee a nP Tu e oE l
SF eiT tras 1d 1
2 xio t
t Po
?
s P
P d
e Ede T
E E
Tlar T
T Sc pa S
S eh m hgio Thc r
2 W
C a
RN
eC v
iR taN n n r
o ei t
d tae m
l b
a Ri r
r n
g le Wc o
u o
s i
L e a RF r
t P
Ad eW r
ns Lm R
aa diAo
,W s
p" n df r
4 L
o n
l 4
o ee A
ss
%%%%%% %h e8 c
v4 r
oa o
e1 o
t 1
55501 1 i
pe 7774 0
w f
d i
l t
D s o e k
c oI n
rR r
T8 oP o
t A
C 8
W i
g Rrm9 c
t a
Ne1 o
n r
t f
t r
h ee e
e i
t t
cb s
e i
lu wr r
a um g
e s
k oe A
l r
e o sv e
e r
s o v
R win l
i s
e d a t
l u
l a
en i
r f
wb t
r e
R s e mgn et nt W
l s
s uA ain r si L
t e
b q
R b a gnK A
n eR l
e b
cE d
m N
Ce S RL r
s r,
Pi e
u a nL l
o s
e o
T R "e r iA 1
t l
o E
t Wh e p
cp o
Ao t t L
t r
le Atoe P
Cv l
Re ND 1
[
L l
?
~
m e
a h
rg t
o n
r i
P d
n e
R d
o
)
W i
n t
n t
n o
a e
L n
e n
i p
o e
s m
a o
A t
t r
I r
u n
e e
R i
s o
s 1
i c
a nd P
s d
t et n
E l
e m
n n
g n u
u o
"p-o a
o ei c
c f
t r
c n
v c
a.
s mf o
e e
e od m
g r t
pt J
i r
e d
o o
o D
- ~
r f
s e
r r
f o
e a
s d
p t
s e
a a
y l
l a
e a
al e
v h
r i
e
(
r u
l, c
e r
e o
e l
d s
e s
m l
i r
t s
eir n
s e
z c
e r
t eie c
h r
r t
n i
c u
hr d
n p
l c
ud d ce o
i ix o
re e
d o
ih s
i ohp o a
v o
t r
o T
pi ws r
d r
o r
f o
e a
n p
t
/
n o
e a
t f
n l
mitnmt c
e n
o o
e oi c
s e
s s
r da c
v l
i u
e n
oiot u
o t
i s
f f
n def n
n f
f f
or c
i ol o e f
e i
a re o
n m
f 8
m ph e
l t
o n
c n
t u
g oi oin np n gin mia os u
o a
i O
n t
t o
r t
ic e
ct is o
d n
mah an smmy o r
roit i
x*
TF CFcFaAH C
=- e 7,
)
D margorP fo%
R 4
W r
e 3
d t
or a L
oh A
1 t
t
.d I
Ge n n R
e s i o P
n R ayi eb p E
t i
el h e
,m d
r h t
u o
g eis l
e nh s ad f
l i
b o
i d s e
d oi et a
eimh m
t t
r er s
ch o y,
r r
d l
e t f o
r v f
l e oaa o F
r l
t i
e s
d%n mi e
l i
a s
mSi i1 c
9 c
n e
n ot
.a i
l a ee g c
m h
r r
t t
n o e
n o
i e n m
s s
h dioir i
C c pn it t
oe c
n ameei umddu o ys nt i
n si i
aatan e gh n
ro4 at o
F1 c mfo s
n ecnu ll
l f
a o
l fo tse 3
0 t
7 2l 9
o d
P s F o d
e r
e r
Te r
us F a us a
On ai c e
L a en s
m d s ma i
a g
s n e n
nr a
od ad o o e
i i
i 1
B ad s v a a t
s t
o t
l lui s a u
y a
as eh l
t e
ar c
va v o e
D b et n i
n F e n
t t
e o
ni Sin n v h
et u d
e n c
dl
,s o di o
i i
e c
c e t i c s st r
c T
an ea a o t
h c
i 2
Pt 2
e e
n Ed I
n I
Mi Tt Mi e
d d
T o Sa To c
i i
e ei e
h e e
h d h
h h
Tt Tin Tt 3'
-9 8
/6 CRN
TMI-2 CHEMICAL SPECIES ANALYSIS RESULTS lodine Species in 129 Solution as of 1 Concentration March 1981
( g/ml) lodide (Csl or HI) 0.030 (97 %)
lodate (10 )
0.0006 (1.5 %)
3 Elemental (l )
0.0006 (1.5 %)
a Total lodine 0.031 (100 %)
1 An analysis of how these species could have been produced concludes that fission product iodine entered the water primarily as iodide and not as I
elemental iodine.
l 1
r t
e s
l la v
e P
l m
e i
t s
s p P
h s R
l d
h E
e W
gi t
am Tiwh n
n t
w a a
w i
L n
t s
Sid A
ml m
d aem et h I
u e u
e h n o
ie s r i
t st s
a t
oif P
e s e
c mcb s E
l cs c
o oe a es l
h s h
o f
t it l
r n sl t
e i
t i
twn w
d d eu s s
c i
l i
c o t
d a d
o eioeip t
i l
es e
n ml bf e f
u t
i at dd po u
s t
t an a
si t
e n n e
c o c
e.
ec h
i r nd et o
o R
lo c o
e sp oe
(
y pi umf l
l l
r l
o c n s t
r c
n r
s e e r y oec i
ut e
eut d
d hh s s e i
n qi n
o t
s en u
u sh an t
i T
i i
ee a
o el aa d r t
wh mg f
ela P
of c
t r
r e
s i
f g
o n
m ol u o E
cmi a
m t
f T
u od w
o s ps t
eCo e o t
s h
d s n e
na t
t uh S
o r
r h a n
uw P aad n l
i t
i pi s d
o Eh
,yd wn o
t m )m T
st n
n s en od o a
St i
a i
p u
i ca l
is n o
ei e u e
etr s u u s
s s
h z
h e F o o Tepei l
i f
c A
T c r s cs i
l X
d
,n n
h m
r o a
k t t i
ai n
e wa a
tal s a
b h
r l
g imi a e g
t t t
so nc n
on n
o c
t l n
ti e
r i
t o P
i t
s ot o
r aiami me sit r
ys z
t ip R
r c
uv s
r ps e
e min nm W
vl o
i s
nl l
a or e o ou l
aho ri n sh c o c c cs L
ec f
s s A
emo o f
cde s
ia I
r e o
we se R
nd n
s e sh n a m ai mio t
c o
d sh P
r g et E
tc ihn s o o e th r
t t uo aio el f
e r
t wi pnl Did l
d r
t s
o s t
i ae Fwi i
m nn s m eidcl d
r t
p eo o St s
cip an mn n o lu ni nae d
e u ee t
si i
n s
o a oid boh b ht n se c
t e
sh c
ai ct nsg i
i ot R
scds n rf o
t f e es a got no i
nh i
r eo m
c ainf e an ncd o
I s
d ngmsninis c
y n
i ndih n n a
I no na mHo o sr e
aio h od on o eg io i
i T
si et at md be oula nr t
ii f t s
Co s
r r
o D
o e
rbt f p da s or F
oe e
a pd ht ei
,n o
t ie yg nirde e o v s l
sd anio upicno aCm t
S nr l
st q
ddch e
r a pt i
i erl s
clia ei l
ie eonboe mdg a ed t
ri f
t i
pf s
p he ai os dda ps sg l
umt t
ee s
a ndC vt w e
ngisif c
r c c
r oi on on o
ie at edn e s,o sd i
i i
t t t s
s pegin a
ei i
si
,ybrd s e sc n yd uHl opo l
o k
ghal i
lai cOc et p gt rt i
f t ul u
o ue nq as uhae e
i DsBss AliCCqTthh t
lllll l
4 O* 3 3
5 5
- - VerticsL '"Cs Hornental. '"Cs
'[-Q
\\
verticat. !,,!
10~ r
=
i Hormontal.
==
E a
g e
s 10' r j
1 b
-^ ' * *...
3jh
'l l'
5 0
.e to a
- $f
.)
l 1
1350 K.
temperature,700 K 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 Distance above tcp of fuel (m) reissJO*ME7 07 Depcsition of lodine and Cesium Measured on Horizontal and Vertical Surfaces Above Fuel Bundle After Test SFD 1-3.
I 10" -
. 10
\\
\\
Vertical
\\
~f.
Horizontal
~
~
' /
-- cs1 condensation "Ts E
.?
)
\\
.V N.
(calculaten. TRAP-MELT) l 102
\\
H1 reacted g
2 (calculateo TRAP-MELT) c i
\\
.T E
i o
5
\\.
10 E l
\\
is N
=
8
/
\\
=
o 10.,
d\\
../ -
o i
- j> p u
o E.
- I..f
\\
h.
E
. ~
'.. N, g
I 2
f ',
g
\\
\\.
10' l
4 10
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 Distance above top of fuel (m)
,emoso.iwr.
Comparison of Test SFD 1-3 Measured and Calculated lodine Behavior-
b e
d h e et h
st t
aaf eh o l
t e
n r s o
t go esi t
n er id g p s
o u y i
t l
t s r c
d u
s ui e
s dh h
e oTt r
R p
g n min r
t ou u s
s nd i
e s e l
l T
po ifer s 2
h e or pe t
pa P
o u f
F t
n s e a T
oh F
mt s
n a
,i O
d d e d
o e L
ot va i
l sh fe o r
et pb n oed e e t
nid r
osi c
ad i r c
o wia P
r s
d e I
l l
H d
ut Ho l
a s
i d
d o
y w
o nt yw nr aF n
ae ahB la l
di a
l t
nd mh s
P c a e h
Ct i
r t
m
,l oi v
i w
nwr s
f e
el o v
h o s eg et en e
cs s nn wt w erd d o e
oi i
t t
c s
r er oa l
eio o ao e
b sH i
I mgs yd f
H n
f h ol e
l cH h nl e v e
s E
c u
cd s il o
k i
i o
gish u uo m
u y
d r
e t
n si ml w
ce r e r
o i
s p
s s sina or t
r t t e
mr t
i idt n h
e t
o e
uai eh i
l t
m oDt bi whi t
t s
r i
t s
Fi
,e e
t e
C eSs d
i t
n sae d e l
h b
no Cmv eb h
i r
C t
si c o
eo nl i
s en aamidt w
o n r
i n
pit h
e sd t
ur nn o
c d u t
t t
a o ob d ece oe r
ub ct e
nf i
l
,i o
i c
t r
l r
i l
B n
s os a at o
si rC st w
i l
i a
c o
l iof t
vhd ssd c
i r i
t vo o ie Ctse adb ewt d
2 ib r
c h
i x
c h e o
a Met e ee geb I
c T b cs mvp u
u ix h r eu o
t ept sce c c i r r
hi s i
a o
oh xo h
t e e I
r l
B FTen Hrb Awo
c h
in d
c d a e
i ta n
r h
g h
ar u
w i
t k
s o q
e ad ut e
n en o a r
Rid pa eh e
s 2 b Wio t
e y, as-Lf o
hr gwM t
Ao I
t o o
t t e
an el T n
dn he blot w
n o d
i t v d
a o
at f
n c
i s n t
l ic ui y k
da d
e
,r i
en o eo efr t
o ar a wrt e
l t
l cea co r
en l
cg dhe ehm a
i r
c d
pt ne o epv H x
,s in hs msn p
eoy l
i nt a r oi r r a
ofowfomr w
st e e
o in v
i t
g a
sa ol eo tu%t at dei n
c nce r
b 3u wne n n dH O
la 0. o eh ai o
i pe v
t n
e0 m tamf )d r
ol yo ahno 2i aff o
t s ti ti e n al a
c n c 1
l c t % (e r
e ai in e e e a
dw m n n3 ph a
c e ao0 n a mst t
i g
s cn gc i
e e<drooletnw l
si D
ait l
r da o
i 2oh hs e ee c it yt a acl l
ef n n t
mi I
Mn o ai w t u t
n n
i d
ea l
e ee e
T r %
ci o
ei g r
o dn mr cur eb0 hr8 nsd ep nqo i
ieoEoies l
i Ta2 Sri Sri t
e m
n f
a i
o d
r o
g y
o i
Rr t
r i
o P
o R Wf R
r E
a Lmt W
R j
o SAr m
D od L
W nf e
A
. % %A L
ts 5
al s
"p a a
d 7
a r
v e
oi e
e 2 9 h
c 1
t s
t e
p emle o
w l
i h
a ve r
n p
t h
eh e
k t
o o
a Cdc n
r r
o i
i h
n o4 d P
W t
t i
t o
c 5
1 eC o
i A
,f vR3 o
r t
e o
e N1 e
t g
p p
m:
r r
n a
ph n G.
ge r
A i G.
f o Av o
h t
i R
t C
wRl i
i t
t l
aa g% %%
na u
n k
cr tnie n1 i
r s
d o
5 4dr e
e mid 9
d i
e e t
e e
wr r
es s
t t
tl t
s R
ae sA i
uhn x
e l
eic l
sa u
w coE uR t t q
eRc q
l ai R at Wo eW mu e
mh r
c RL f
rt r oL m
A r
t ga n
gt An n
r o pio o e e olat io e
op vd r
r Ps cpi emf t
a t
t sn nl c
cle t
i Re A Ra e
e uiAv a
c n
n oi WinCWe r
pt n miaCe i
t gR D Ld RLt ond e
a r
r r o Ai N A a P c loE P ONo o
l l
t
[
1 2
mar d
a e
o d
r n
P e
n p
o RW
)
i s
t n
t n
o a
u L
n e
n i
s o
e m
a o
A t
t r
d r
I o
n e
e R
n is.
c a
a-nd P
i s
t et n
le m
o n
g n E
o u
u f
o t
o ei t
c c
n v
r c
d e
e e
s mf e
m g r od s
o o
pt i
o r
e D
a r
r r
f s
o p
e a
e ef d
t r
s e
ee a
y l
l l
a e
a al rh v
h i
r e
(
r u
c e
r sp o
e d
s e
s s
m l
t i
i ei s
n r
ho e
z c
e r
tc h
r eiml d
n p
r t
c i
c u
c u d n ht o
x o
r i
a s
e e
d oi r d wt o
a v
i ot o
T r
p o en r
d r
o n e e
a n
p t
/
i n
t f
a f
n l
n o oimt c
e o
ois d
c e
mon c
v l
u e
n i
e s
s i
i r
t adef o
u i
s f
of n
n on or c
t i
f f
f f
e ol r e o
n m
i f
a no ph e
l t
o n
c o c.
np n gin t
u g oi
. os u
o a
mie ni t
O t
s o
o r
t ch c
e i
i d
n mah at smmy o r
r i
nit TF C Fi FaAHC
/
e re h
tn n p
e a s
S d h i
o Cd ctcr m
R n a e a
t et yw o A
h n nl t
ea y
t mmr lt n
onfon a r i e
f at c
t ni m
d n ei f
e n
s omn c
g a
ni ia en os l
i r
s t
ed i
r vi n
en e s
o id el n
b C
h e ed i
c ph e i
t e
h s r
h wuoc 4 t
s d4 t
e e e8 n s gr o
e 4
i d
ae t
mk d 1
o e
oaiD i
s f
c e nI s
o el oT r
a nb ocn e
ohf i
e i
ce cd t
l ci n e e
l ahbwaem R
r f
uu l
i ed aqs e
h n ves n
Taasa i
do
(
m n
d a
i r
e e
g n
s) o ay r
id e a e
P o
r lew e
R i
r e )y h
w n
et W
a a
r n
p s
L ow i
bh d
C A
o s r t I
u d
ia a i
R p
e o n
k h e a
P ad t
s E
I i
a eu f
f p q og o
l
% (m i
d(
)y e
s 5
a r
y u
ur t
s s o u n w
i e
h a
at oi t
n b p a
e B
mv ar p
e n
n e sk l
ni p
u n i
a o e d p oa c
i t
r e u et ao t
i e
s n l
n u c uh ao l
h af st gi t
v o eg
(
c c
r e%
e n
%l t
e l
i t
s p 1
o n3 T
e0 e a
<c t
d c
,e s
2 s c a e
sh i
t c
P st l
at F e en n
t i u
2 e Tf Dd m
F e
F e IMn Oh S u r
Tia Lt s
l em a a t
l e n h o h o e
T c Tf nm r
I l
ma r
,s m
a S
o e
o C
r p
r s R
P i
f p
.sde nl ec a e R
a isa nh W
i nr af r
t i
r o e e u fdn o
L t
A i
l a es i
t t e n
azd mr I
tn hie R
e l
lon P
tee o e t
r s o o m d sia E
r e ot locr n r e ei wer s c a
oiat oa s
s pe n h r
ea ey s
s) atho bw i
ot c s
ad dl t tf t
noo n s
o l
Be ar o
eus u
c phcd Too wr i
l f r a n o u e t
e i
t r
nf mi oh a i
ct gr s
pc e et o in s
i i
shh hap n n o d gh e a wt hc ei td f
r so c(
rhs yTl u
t a
or%
r e
s o el sl i
T a
et se4 e% ga ot 7 gi a~
m0u d r
7s e em, s
t mA e n tfsoE mnr e e rCi e od eAs kci t
c Ed Li v cc i
r Co
,S apa r
i r
A ye LeeC Mt r
hhR o e t
et r et v e
o hnu hr e h
Toft T ps
I I
TMI-2 FRACTION OF IODINE CORE INVENTORY AIRBORNE IN. CONTAINMENT
'31 - Airborne Fraction 1
Time of Sample 3 days after accident
.00005 July '79
.0003 May 1980
.00002 l
l 4
i LOFT FP-2 IODINE RELEASE DATA PRIOR TO REFLOOD (FRACTION OF IODINE RELEASED FROM FUEL) k Collection Upper Low Pressure Isotope RCS Tank Plenum injection Line
'3'l 0.33 0.03 0.6 0.02 I
- - L
)re le z t
s oe e
A m
M e,,
s o
U v
t Eso r
ro t r
iw s
.1s c t
np
{
a os ma e
R m
j ro pm m
a a u
v (g
^
c n
N ipe r
D e
lo w
U s
o L
o '8 t
rel n
li AI a
po l
lo oo n^
c e
n k
o y
o is r
rB am le i
s ps r
ue p
sv TFO d
n L
te e lal io in tc e
uS e
h mI in t
n iP d
i f
io SL Ct a Cc o
EIo w
e t
i n
la c
v e
le/
(
tnm e
c e
~ S>-
g t
imr i
un s
a s r
r s o e
e 2
e e
t
'd ai nv C pea t
e i
x m
P emts o
no sp x
g m
A G
u 3
q r )
e Q,
g,.
p o
t r
o a
lo mr u
a a e g
e n t
i c
i
[(
t e
F ta Sg 3
n g
en re i
l z
iru
, A' c k
s i L
- c. a s
0 P i-e e
g r
1 r
1B P
no m
g i
tc n
a r
i e
e g
yl b
o l
ao w
r de s
e P
wc f
he r
e R
t W
th u
c s
at s
a r
p n af f
i r
L si e
u e
A ud ms h
oe e
I t
e e
R ru r
n n
s eiei P
s h
l E
a l
ga w
td t
i e
n n w
am s
e u e
ub d e
i l
e c
fl e
f l
ir t
s he e
eei p
u s
t w w s
nf o4 l
o e p-u em e
yh e1 l
s
.u t
d i
D l
t i
i e
(s ado i
eF l
de o at T S R
oc v
ee r
o s d d d
s D
do n n l
fe n s
F ra e
el a a c
t l
S oe f
s s s
i 3
n o
onC-t po d 1
riod s
i o
e eg eD i
de sF r
i ai t
f t
s aS r
i so n
t n e
a ci t
l u
ud eh e%
s t
r qde o
t1 ot eb D<
e r ah n
pr l
F ),
b t
i nnfos Sd g oe r
i e
i t e l
ic t
l sk g s st lain n
x e
s oe io etaN FcMm n
I
II :
E
'5
- -- Vertical. '8'Cs ld r
\\
Honzontat. '**Cs Vertical. '8'I 1
g
-[.
,\\
Honzental. I j
Ir1 Wv s i
ile i
~
1:
s i
De;
/ /-
{
?~
S 1
l
" 18
'V r
1
.N.**s
- /
I Puk A
t 1350 K.
temperature.700 K 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 Distance above top of fuel (m) reis sao. tier.o7 Deposition of lodine and Cesium Measured on Horizontal and Vertical Surfaces Above Fuel Bundle After Test SFD 1-3.
10 ;
2 10
g.
\\
Vertical
- ~
\\
, ~-- ?..
Horizontni E
e-
-- csI condensation cz e
\\
V (calcutatec. TRAP-MELT)
..f
..10'2
\\
HI reacted
]
g
?
(calculatec TRAP-MELT)
\\
e es i
'g
\\,
.g 4
10 N
5 c
8
/
\\
=
- j*/ <
co 10':
\\
a;
+
u u
p O
~l
%'N, l
E f'./
g 2
y
\\
l 10" 10
O.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 Distance above top of fuel (m) esis om.twr u Comparison of Test SFD 1-3 Measured and Calculated lodine Behavior
m n
el i
ho P
d d
e t s e
e h
no R
tr s
v t
r i
iam ee W
e n
u r
s n
o a
e a
b war ra h b L
p c
s t
ee wd A
s e
o 4.ot r
l I
t u v
at r
R n
amto' 4me s
oo 1
a h
n ur ph P
n r
5 d1 i gw ss E
o1 s nD m a
a e o n e T
td~
Fd h d al w
3 Sat e tra e
es n
vns chh c
s l
1 n t t o
eoi idi ih i
De nwd sr i
t d
leaT Fda e
oto n
r o
bc c
o Soeoin e
a el e ni a a
r l
e r
n nl t
iclp er 4
a oi eod l
r a
t et or x nl ia t
1 4dn wnie e dic
- e e t
oht e or 1
t t n D
r u eci iv ie Dol b dwl a s
f eC ah im F
F pf e cn c hm S
Ss t
oi ne nnisd f o nah l
rt ei cyu o c t
d i
egaho no r
t s
n n
ei fArpc ot t
a cb e
f aa td d i
e m
donre a e e i
f t f o a 3
et e i
r ct f
c o
el a r.
at i
a i
l I
r3 sc acl o
pl l
s1 anio ei og 1
odt -
cv m pi sn t
n bems aaias D
oa wD e s of e er rh ere r
F es oF h rh e u e h x v t
S ACdS T pc a sb Tein l
I~~~~[Acoeclor SYD3Ee$l~~l DN-Oeleyeo neutron
~
l l
IC-Gross gamma l
Aeros '
000 1
^ ^ ^ Unfilterea Ge $ monitor Filtered UVU Go-Gamma spectrometer i
Uh' C3
{ k { cas samples!
I ! I gas samotes I
i l
DN 5
h "2. tor,-
' c Nat I
L tC d
- moni c
I i
T;6 Flowmeter j
2$
+
Deposition 6.,,,.,;.
,4 ecupons
^ '-Gas sample Go O N.Concenser g.a,.,,
L.,.mC)
$7(SFD 13 anc g
g.*-
p;,,,,,,,
- /
14 only)
Compressor separator $7 Collection
'f $28 J
h. pile tanu in 7 7 Licuid
^
,h tune grac Ge
\\ eated A
H
)
pienum
=
- ='-
EE
,, Test fuel pgo,' meter Fi er Nat Test cociant j
Liould sample
(
CEI Steam Pump l-Z ~~l sms i
t M Gas M Licuid 1
Schematic diagram of the PBF Test Effluent Sampling and Monitoring System 0.48 0.44 SFD 1-3 SPD 1 A Ei 0.40 Preflush (/'t! lilillllllill Q E
,E:
>- 0.3S
=-
i 022 E
.E.
I.
E :.
e 0.28 '-
El 5
M.=*
5 0.24 <
P== 1 o
o 0.20 Plenum oset Pee BCf
'.=, j c
.9 0.16 < -
g.
b 0.12 h5 l
0.08 l
U~:
=-
l 0.04 i
0.00
' ~'
- 1 8
15 3D Distance from fuel bundle (m) pets o ro. tis 7.so Comparison of iodine and cesium deposition mea.i. ired after Tests SFD 1-3 and 1
1 y
g m
l nedne ot eic iatda il ti f
cdsi r
ae a u 0
0 0
P u
FmpB 8
8 4
r S
R e n mDo W
i LA 3
IR
)
nd g H
P en O
E o
inip s
cap
%(
ti i
l 0
6 0
A at 8
3 5
8 7
6 7
t re u
FRi d O n
5.
5 1
9 l
n n
s aM e
s H d R
s O
n a
a a
t Mn N H 7
s o
6 2
8 2
8 sO ei e
0 0
4 1
3 o
s l
l t 1
T bc 1
0 0
0 0
0 0
sC ua l r o
e oF r
s el c
S a
o a
s c
o L
y r
i t
p e i) y a s
c/
to c
oe (m t
0 l
i 1
o p
0 7
7 5
4 3
r V
9 y
1 9
9 7
2 2
pt o
-nt o
o r
n p
d d e
e s
)
)
0 s
)
)
)
t
)
U
(
(
'A B
C U
s
)*
(
e 1
2 3
i
)
1 3
3 T
3 o
2
(
B B
B A
A A
A C
C C
L L
L L
I l
\\
.. AEROSOL C;5ERATION SYSTEM j!
l
- . FIACTCR VESSEL
[
- 3. INTERNALS MODELI.ING WR
{
. FRESSURI;ER
- 3. FILIEF TA';K b
- 6. F!NAL TILTER
^
1 Q
.-.}
e k
k
)
/
&U i
3 60
' % 'g &[
~
s v
p f
I
/
?
i
,s" 2
( m
/
A
/
V
\\
I l
f l
o g
om l
t
(
Fig 3:3 Test facility arrangement for Tests 4 and 7 j
l
f AUXILIARY BUILDING OAC D.
+ TO SCRUBBER STEAM CoOH MO j
e MnD D
D THROUGH THE WALL
@ 'M SAMPLE STATION (41 HEATER I
WALL CONDENEATE Nf7ROGEN Mg STEAM D
HEATER wt I
\\
Y PLASMA Y
M i
l TORCH I
CESIUM Mn VAPORIZER
-HEATER AEROSDL MIXING d.O Oi)
CHAMBER
@c g_,
AC E
i i
Figure 3(b). Location of instrumentation for test LA1.
i I
e n
h t
o y
o dl t
ew r
o o
t W
i t
sl u
s o
b L
py A
i r ea t
I d m n
R o
ey c
P o
b ei E
t r
yh a n
l t
a e
n t
k h e
r c c o
n i
l i
o l
h s p
l w wt m
i i
n i
t me n
a e
l d
oi a
z s
r i
sf c e n t
r e
,c b e o
vga n
od p
nie i
t iph c
yc a
it d p l
v e
n e a e
sSo k e i
aCg h
l R
eRn o
t t n
l i
rd d ni es n n sy i
l a e r
tc p
na ume oe i
d ud am t
o ne zr rplez e
i r i
t npr o
o pe or p ac ie a
v u r
s p
s v
e ipe o
F ur Rs l
n i
g d
on e
t i s
d Cn n
Re e o c
pt A
Ni u e d
s l
e h e sg sR
%%%%P t
h a
iwt yk oW 5004 f
r k o o a pL 71 1 e
oA r
t ot nl r
c n
we er P
o o
l p
vf l
n i
is e
i t
wa l
c eb s
r A
mi ola ah ci r t a
g go ev ot h a D
n I
r t
e d
T P
i f
t v
on g
u a
s n
i l
Rt a
s Wn ne 0
i t
500 r
or s
0 e
2 L e e
i i
1 t
Al ch x
t R
a ap E
r s
.eR o
f taW Rm d L Wta oA L
t t t
nm Ann s
r ee na e d
s o
emm t
ipt n
oe s nn oio e
s bb t
ar e eRS cl c aer pt m
n l
i bi vu onv e
o eo r on od se l
Nd s P ce E
NloCT 1
m e
a h
r a
t n
orP i
t d
n n
R e
e o
d W
m n
t
)
i n
n e
n o
a L
n i
i p
a a
o A
t o
e s
t t
r I
r u
n e
e R
i o
s o
nd P
s c
s d
c e
t l
n e
m n
g n E
o u
u f
o a
m ei t
c n
v c
o r
s mf o
e e
e r
t f
g r od pt i
o r
e d
o l
D s
e a
r r
f o
e a
s v
d p
t s
e a
o y
l a
e a
al e
m h
i r
e
(
r u
c e
r e
e d
s l
e l
i r
t e
s r
ei s
n r
r t
s z
c e
l c
ie o
h r
t i
c u
ehr s
d n
p c
u d n
ce o
x o
r i
e e
d oiih i
r o
t r d hp e a
v o
T r
p o ws a
d r
o t
/
p i
o a
n n
t e
f f
n o
o nmt c
e n
l c
e o
oi c
mda u
i t s
v l
r ot d e
n i
e s
s e
u o
t i
s f
oi n or n
n f
c i
f f
f f
r ol o e ef e
t o
a m
ph o
n m
i f
l e
n c
n nD t
n n
gin u
g oi oi os miaio u
o a
O i
n t
t r
t c
e ct s
o i
d n
mah an sm my o r
roit iTF CFcFaAHC I
jL
~
m argo rP e
d m
h e
R em o
nh W
t t
u r
s L
i f
sd s A
n l
a I
o a la s
,n R
v e or d a P
r eoh E
o e aot mh t
r t
se cr ep uer g
Rs dd a onl o
r uh l
p c
om l
ne u l
st owm oA i
s r
s ee r r et i
n aa f
r Ae oes f
r e m
et t
s ae mh c
r c pl n u n ss a a i
i da n ovd ot amoi u
ca mg rn ht e
Po et r y nC mned o r
et o
amt a l
vn al u
i i
oicg s
a s
mt o e ns r i
e os F
Rcai n
r ts i
o N
e u
t h
E m
e t
)s K
f u
o h
e V
c c
d I
s R
n h
a g
i fr n
A ao w
l u
i l
vi t
Moc t
s s
te d md m:
o i
s t
s e n e e t
i r
x n
ar r n a u
p a
a
,l l
A o e h g f
t l
sl cn n
u N ob el e
s i
mt v
e n
Or a t
e n o
e i
r s
Ma o r
)
i s
s t
Ef s al d
dl c
l i
no a
s Doa va n
as p
a e e on o
o B
E c mo er m
r i
ta z e i
e et Cn i
r a s
sa y
i ek l
t n
a a
At a t i Li m av e
nc s
r c
x h a d
p p
i i
n h o s
t r
geo i
g t
n n
t d
o wc o
e i
y eo c
s t
h d h t o o dt ut u n m
r n
i c
r l
g g o
l i
e cdb o
a l
i n ea ci e
d y t
T h
ni t
i t
h i
s s e od s
p d
i ao d
(
ih cd t
r t a
nl bt a
s
(
t e
n n
ad c
i mt n ein s
yo i
e t
s i
e j
i a
r t
i e
od c c r
r o
e r
i py pr h
pa a
s e
r m
e p
ot e
l x r eas E
d o
ct a s
s e
Ci ein s
s or h
i lolcas An u
r e t
s L o ff gt h t oe c
ya f
c i
r v e
e c D
h w o
ea ef h e l
Ah mf Tb lA e
i
)*
(
)
t s
r i
h se d
r f
o rv h
o po s
m is t
e u
n R
ff e
0 i
0 5 0 d
c 0
5 i
i c
t 1
3 1
s g
i
~
~
~
~
n i
f l
f a
i l
t e
e te o
R s
C lan l
o a
i
)
t v
a o
~
t r
i h
v m
laa
(
r v
e o g R
2 ml a
5 e v 4 4 e
6 r o t
4 4 0 0 y
a P
am
~
~
~
~
r e R
pry lu S
s yc t
i c
yai l
r p i
t n po r
osc a
s ss o P
r r r
ee g
ddy
)r i i h
ssh
(
nn oo dn e
CCa 1
m 0 5 0 0 i
>)
T 0
0 1
2 o( 2
EgmOEZu kmO)VOJ. OOZ$z6Ey9Z aE ^
8 i
1 o-0 6
g 6
6 0*
1 j
1 1
1 i*
o'
- 1
- - ::i
~::*
~
E -
~ i:
i-O OA OE8 S N N N N T WA A A A E L
N U U U U S T
A A A AA A D
2 U H H6 (E A P
A Y Y P T
(
G G T H A O
I
(
i,..
,U R R
)
I S
)
S O O d
_)
S S -
T T
(
(
WO-E E R S
T Y T
F F N
N-
)
)
to" e
T IM E
(
s
)
t,.
o' e *g g
4 s
. A'.
8 O
S G
\\
A d, e j
i, O
i,.
o'
fI 1
llj!ll
~
rOg_a Noo)uOa 8Z0mz B Oz 9sE..
c i
i i
i 0~
D n
o o
o o
o I
i i
1
- s ! ?=
- .1-
.: E g1 g-1 -
M 0'
V O 0A O l
L S.N N
N _N N
A W
__A A
A A A
4 NU U
U U U
A A A A P
U.A A.
O
(
6 6 6 9
-A.H U
S
.Y N
T
(
(
(
G N
.C,.C I
_(
V T
U
_.R
_.C E E E
. O _.
1,.
S E
N N H
/e.
S 0'
.S
)
E O
.C _N T
E L L
.(
M
_L N.
C E
T C. ;H.
.F
_I l
-l
.N-I
)
R.
.)
)
i,.
o' T
I M
E
(
s
)
i o'
- ..\\
N #.
V t
a'?
A\\
\\
\\
s
\\
,O N
i S
g o'
N\\
N O
i,.
RN G
aY
%g o
L D
W G
8 8
-7 4
3 r
i.
o*
o l
lj I!I II
1 1
1 1
i 0
0' 0
0 i
o" 4
E.
~ : -
-. )
s o'
I A O5e n
i e
S N N N T F
l_
f i W A A A E
r.
N U U U S A
og T
A A,A A
6 N.1 U -
,4 4 D 4
P A
A U
A H H H T
O Y Y Y A S
A H G G G l
T cA Y R R
.P l
G O O O T
a6 R
cp O
,S S
E S
S uo i,.
(
l
(
(
F f E
T o
U N
.N P
l s a t H
9 t t S.W D i
)
i e l
R nt
)
os E
T Y
s
)
. r s
e u
l t
s e
a T
i I
Mi.
s h
e/
o Eo, r
n
(
e s
)
t o
a t
a l
.l g
g l
I I
I I
i I
I I
l I
,1 I
c
\\
i o
i g
i o
\\
\\
t
\\
\\
c i,.
\\
o*
\\
o N'
n c.
\\
I l
>\\
u 1
t
\\
Og\\
)\\
ra t
l g
g g
I I
l l
I l
I i i ;
I i
on s
v i.d l
c i
ts R
i la Re W
Wr L
L g A
y n
Ai n
g l
z l
a n
,i si i
et p
d u
ol r
t a
o a s ev c
l r
n vo c
n ko em a
ai d
t o
e a e
P or l
l i
R t
t u t
e c
nc el Ct S
a a
A mc Rl e
u s
e Nc g
n0 n
iv i
i t
a0 o
hr e
n tn N
ia R
t 1
t oR wp i
cF kr l
o u
eC d
of d
r s
0 e
wP e
lb e
a s
R s
1 t
t l
R we e
iS e
l lod u
w u
al q
e q
lama e
mh e
v R
at R
e so r o nam n
gt n
imh e o
oe o
r i
v i
r t
ml c
Pi c
r t
e t
ao A
Ra A
ter s n
dgo C
We C
r or R
Lt R
or e TPa N
Aa N
l 1
2 I
m e
a h
ra t
n
)
i n
P de o
no R
i d
t W
i t
a t
n n
r a
n e
L e
e n
p o
e s
m n
o A
r et I
i u
n e
cd R
s o
s i
c a
P s
nt n
d t
le m
n n
e n
E o
u u
f o
a o
a ei t
c c
v s
mf o
o c
r e
e od m
r t
r d
pt i
r e
d o
o D
y r
f s
e r
f h
o p
e a
s t
(
l l
s e
a a
a e
a al e
v d
r i
e r
c e
r e
o e
e u
l s
z t
e s
m l
i r
s i i n
r r
t s
e d
c e
c i
h ie r
r tc u
ehr x
n p
l c
u d n
ce o
o o
re e
d oiih s
i r d hp o d
ta v
o T
r p o ws r
a r
o o
e p
l t
/
i n
f e
a c
n t
f n
n o
o nmt e
o l
e oi mda c
e c
i t s
v u
u n
i e
s s
r ot f
o t
i s
f n
oi n def c
n i
or f
f f
f ol o e o
e i
r e n
m f
a m
ph l
t o
n c
n t
e u
g oi oi np n gi n
n os u
o a
miaio i
n t
O t
o r
t c
e ct s
n imah an smmd r
r oit y o iTF CFc FaAH C 1
s a
e n
)
hs B
hoi 2
t t n
n%D d8 i
t a
)
s eb o5(Ln/
add o
da hin 1
7 a/
i x
t t
t cl d s
9 o a s
s s
a aa esid nt se e e ]) ela o n r
ec aia dh(f r
i r
e n
f i t e
n gh bciBot 4 uet i
cd nc
,enoh3 qmuc i
e d e 5 p gf l
e t
i i0 rfdc siew5 ooA t
r G
d sr ad e
,e
)
r e pmDintRBspe t
s l
t 2
ct eF Ec2e r
n aa t
H eehr gatsCRefHv l
gnhi0 (f
u m C oi t s1 sed Se
/
f s e n r
ut i
r o se n nPn r
n e c io e
e ocf ahaf v
o o
o cd mPc ic Bt t
ss r
lem AL i
din no t
aa u
su a
cSeeso of sr d
%t oRhdht i
i it net u
t c
a a
a 0oDAtsrTr u v e i
u x
0h s E a g [- el opx t
e
.d ac es 1i t
O w
n O gd e s vc
(
l i
n eDn s n E ad e ia
.nh g
od m ed s oky at e
r e i
e sl r
l n
t h
rh do vC ial o is sit af Rc ef i
f ol u
i l
d yct no is pb qb l ni Rs s n t
d t
umeed n Wlieio a
e Ct e
a sRsRs e
avt ef s
r C
sN eRs e emLeu l
n i
yeiv ear b
r i
n p eeWl vuot eAhm ai oheLnc qca t
hRtoo t
nTb Aaare eS TPb c r
ys-l
le d
n o
o m
i f
t "e
o a
r g
d a
o e
k o
n c
l f
o e
e l
b M
l r
G T
g e
n r
2 o
2 P d i
H c
u P Al 0
/
5 s
F L c
vt u
E n
T i
n r
u o
F R o
a o
v
/
n i
mb e
OP u
i r
r L A a
ta mt p
D se t
u a
d s C s
S e
e nS a
i c
d a
c e i
x r
O s
n o
g o f o t
e c
a o c i
si d
r E d d
e md g
a e
d n
B pO e
e ra u e v e t
r g x D s
a pt a i
l d
a e
or u d c
c2 P pt mem i
l d
A mo a
o pa inI a
h MA in V C Sd cT M lC e
T i
i
e ta e
B s
r m
o D
is d
c L
i t
a s s n
ro e
B ei a
s nf h
n m
t y
l t
l sl eel a
o e
ea s gi nmW o
i R
b n sotnk i
go t
r Bt a
a er r r u
5 d
vd e c af c
yt a En 2
ni ot mts l
o a
/
at nh t
pa s
s R
v 4
Ai i
ei l
.C E
n e ege h x r
0 Ri snt t
e m
d sie k
1 sn P
eh sed i
r s
t r
v e e
e e nv uc z c i
i R
e s e o x c t
n l
i lih Bg M
Ud Ceic Uw o
t n
o Dr Ld f
y oH
)
sr s
co e
i f u
t s
ss s
i it n
g r n s
o n
e e i
i s
t i
t e
a a
s cm l
z u
e t
a B
ai s
a ss s
r i
e i
m r
r d
e p
i r
n ei s
ai g
yo v
o t t ip r
h r
h u
i l
s co at n
p ne Cq e
yI i
p R
am e
a e
D ro r
P c e o
e R
g aE t
i v
cd d
t n
si l
i d o v
ug it is gn na o
el o
v r
n ei i
e rd mr df r e a e pn i
r.
t u
c g
r t
el es c
t n
gh sr iL e
e o ei ua t
n Mi Dc Dw Mm
(
l
~
maraorP s
no t
et n
R i
n gd e
W t
l o
u oe a
L l
s rs t
e do v
A i
i r
y p un a
I hxd qo R
l r
a i
e ree et P
a tn o sd nd E
n e
fe a o oi oix e
m rwl t
f a o e
G ve e i r rg e
r r
e 2
p e
n x
s on ni c e ed H
e yrdh gd a e
eet nl
/
b vtd ec l
a n n
a se a o e gl o
c ah ru i
wr edf l
i t
p ev m ye a
p t
t n oi h v an d.
e t
i ye d e g i cnt i
td l
ih n d a x
s ci ccTo c
i O
s e c a
t%
e l
r a
ia
.alu0 g
B d
2n 2
or s5 y-io et I
n l
nM Mt l I f
a ru a
i c
o Trm2o d
T e
b i
aI n
e en d
eMa h
he het a
c Tt T gs T t h
o e
lC T
f>
1 l
ma rgorP n
RW i
n r
s e
n o
tn w
o L
i y
k A
l i e
o et t
l r
a nd p
a d d R
I a
oid r
c e m
oi e ciw h
ma P
l e
raalpo c
v E
n s e pf n
el l
e gar e
ge t
G ua ef b
ad l
o ko smbs o
cm e
2 rat n t
o doo d
b) l H
a ni e
l d
t e ni s
t d
ee
/
nr e o a u
n ds c c n
o e
ou mfdc o
b ct i
on r
i
)
e ar n
dor y
t d
pev
,a a
e no a
't xisd c
f vRd d
n et r oOe nr s
a o uel o
r i
t gtnt t
n cof u
pC m s
x c
f t
(
e ab d mDo s
r e
r i
O i
t e
t s e es s
s iI o(
r 2 d f
eres rl i i g
s xr cs r
n i
o Ei e c
a epreno et pP c
n B
rwst hl Od F
a e
i l r
aDen e
i t
d a h yopye
,a o c pe T 2 l
et PloeF l
t i
d c
oa lth l
I iec sly b OM i
Ae a
n et ged eaAvs L T r
h har r l
n hn ea C
c T a ad a T a Mdh i
eT
560 450 390 400 350 H (kg) 2 200 i
t
?
E i
^^
^P MELCOR SCDAP/
MARCH AhA OE 0B j
Figure 2-1 Comparison of TMI-2 hydrogen generation data with-model predictions.
f 18
3 p-j
~
l i
1 i
i Table 2-3.
MAAP-00E ALWR APPLICATION MATDIY
{
SUMMARY
OF CASES ANALYZED Operator Sequence Initiated Recovery of Care.
Tvoe(Pasis[1)(2)
Deoressurizatiok3) iniectie;A)(5)(6)
Yes No t;
t
't NO 2'
3
(
1.
X 1,
X.
2.
Large LOCA (LDB)
X X
2.
Large LOCA (LDB)
X X
A.
X
(
S.
X X
5.
Small LOCA (LDB) 1 X
X 7.
X 1
X i
8.
Small LOCA (LDB)
X X
9.
Small LOCA (LDB)
X X-
- 10. Small LOCA (LDB)
X X
l
- 11. SB0 (REB)
X X
.2. 550 (LDB)
X X
I i
- 13. SB0 (LDB) i X
X
- 14. SB0 (REB)
X X
- 15. SB0 (LDB)
X X-
- 16. 530 (REB)
X
.X i
l
-i Notes: ')
Basis:
i Licensing oesign casts (LDB) or Risk Evaluation Basis (REB) i 2)
All LOCA cases include loss of all' injection I
3)
Depressurization by operator action at steam generator dryout 4) t 3. recovery at core uncovery.
5) t2 recovery within 1/2 hour of core uncovery 6) t3 recovery at I-hour after core uncovery 22-
R e
h Wg t
Ln n
n
)
i B
Ad o
o D
f o g
o n
t L
ol
%i i
mf 3nd a
(
e r
s u
4e r
irh
~0p e
s t
t n
a ci 1 e e
B ew pd p
G n
s s u
e n
g asl n o 2
s o a e oi i
t i
H e
t c s t
a s
ad D d) e r
i eBv ex
/
a iD no l
n n
pLin e
p(
gd i
o s
a e
a n
sr nl c i
t e ns o e
i a
c ea c gle eBe o u d
L b h d i
r f
i nt s gf ye x
ai o h v O
s i
hs t
s ey wc i
E De o a r
g a
n B Ogvht s n Dn o e
i l
c sl a
d cPsel i
a t
d nAnr uv i
e i
Aced s us a
eqa hc Mi nLaRec l
C e
T
'l
- '(;c Table 2-4 Licensino Desien Basis-MAAP-00E Pesuits Su-rsrv-
'or !n-vessel (Recovery cases)
Secuence Secuence S/G DevoutgSec) of
% Act1ve(I-
' Tim
'Jumee r Tvoe Core Uncoverv Claddino 0xidirea-2 Large LOCA NA 119 0.0%
3 Large LOCA NA 119 3.3%
6 Small LOCA 3629 4741 43.2%
8 Small LOCA 3629 4351 0%
9 Small LLCA
~3629 4351 0%
'0 Small LOCA 3529 4351-2%
'2 SB0 4801 6708-0%
13 SB0 4801 6708' 2.0%
15 SB0 4801
'6099-
'0%
(1)S/G s Steam cenerator -
1 (2) Active clad defined as zirconium inventory in cladding within core boundary.
Calculation utilizes total zirconium inventory.
{
1 i
i i
I 1
-l l
i 25 l
g
,en
,r g
o d
s ul n
e d
id d
sg el i
i n
s a p
n e
af nl d an a
e a ed yr i
o e
cl a e
,sl sed es t
l b
e sc f e sgel ra i
i t
)
o s s n e
n yl ad a
B s
e eiv c
u ol Si E
a hvdnf
~i w l
~
v r
l e
ao Ro e
R s
t e
oi t
f fo oogv dsf Wp u
r n
l a
(
l ef ni i
e sh e
t y,n c xye Lt i
n m t,i or v Aa i
G s
y a
ei h
i oiva gvc yt t
r t
a e
t e amn n
a bm t
2 B
v u h cee s
idit o
bt H
n c
orl drn de a
r a arai aee et o
e ttl l
v s
l d
/
i tl iy l
t oiu caa r
rnieq ewi vt n
a v
oS t
u u
oorpt e o
o fi a
r ru an l
t e oq ah nanm%
odo ht e s e i
t vi t
e5 wla iV a
E w
ii i
t xt c
cr7
,u%
cd e
d k
s u
a o o
o em0 n n s
e dl,rct s u0 e a ix s
oeef i
a c1 u n n R
a r st o%
c ct O
n c
psin8 qo sf n e yau eio g
o v eo5 ti t
o e
ti v sb sat i
a i
n sa m
gn etam f z a a oiz i
r t
ri u
oicco sd r
i i
d B
gnofrn ne dn e u u rd r
e d n ol o
ec ci y
e o ps s t
d a c z l
yi edi s s a
c ey hdcr e a sn u at.r t
e e t
e ad pl u
m gd ehoi sp p r
in s a el d
l r rni n
C h
n hc o ea i
x nr x he e n
A a Ti c t r o O e po TDd ceT l
y f
i o
t r
v ns e
a oi t
c i
rg f
tbn a
f aei
)
2 o
cdl r
o l
u
(
s l
sa o
6".
7 t
eaf h
n mo ri 9
7 2
5 9
e ds e
2 c
r et 1
0 8
0 9
8 f
det n
1 t
a 1
1 1
1 f
nl e o
c go e
ael d
nl dp o
e
)
oe e
eoo t
z 4
LR h
rmrl i
t u
d o
'p d
(
s l s o
u i
g ep x
nl 7
7 7
7 n
a h
d o
ii oer 2
sV 0
3 9
4 6
7 f nt r e
i i
y.
- o e
t g
t s 2
0 0
3 4
2 5
ae l
uer i gt c
n 1
g et na i
i bV e l
i t
en s aiw d
l s
rnf d a scr.
e h
e t i A r
eous r
a i
s a
y vl d 'y p
l e
e a
L
)
l c
et rrdl e
C C
3 7
va e
ei rT L
(
7 7
7 0
l 1
m t ecv eS e
n i
I 0
0 0
0 ti fh ua wW u
y e
C 9
0 3
r g
C at aTdc R
f e
o vs o
sI v
r re p
re n
e o
d l
e -
u e
iy l
7 4
ph oe v
9 st t y t
ih i
c C
0 0
0 0
0 ns at s tt t
R l
D 8
1 oe eiin i
c 1
1 cb h v i
dy a
o F
an nb l
N eV eh r
gn cg o
,e eceg o
f
(
s 7
7 rt oeoi n
se 4
8 9
2 1
5 3
u ch rh si t
l er e
V o 7
8 3
0 5
0 l d tdc id n
s
- f 3
3 4
5 3
4 6
au enl e bo c
1 n
d yn ro e
i s
ne I
e I B f o ui u
el r
V b
n~
q df e
e il l
p x
l r) 0 4
0 7
2 3
0 eo t ol r yy f
euc 7
3 1
9 5
3 8
s opoe di a
st nooi rl s
sl e 0
7 5
1 9
5 r
sis 3
7 7
3 9
4 2
vu r
t na e
1 er c
ph v
n ea(
1 1
1
' o eee er e
l Vf i
th hthd h
t y
a t at n we r
r
- e w
a v
o ee) 9 7
1 1
yn o
n di p
8 9
1 rv c t o t eiy et e
ooe 1
8 4
5 0
3 9
1 i
0 7
3 7
8 0
vr stdi ae h
t t c r
C cS 1
4 4
6 5
6 ao r
ev n[
l f e
U cf eoh a uf r
ft cr ce a
A yT e
n I
l rS rl eh ag s
I A
C A
A dW euc cn n
I C
0 C
C e
0 1
O O
R n s qi i
o ce 1
m aI os r
sd i
L L
np ee -
an t
i d e t vrm we u
ey e
u l
l uT g
l l
l eh a
aa p
b q
r i
a a
0 0
0 u
ohht ce i
i mt ce' e
k e
a l
S S
5 5
5 so e
e m
m 0
8 0
sm r
S l
l l t cs ar t
i t u n
ar rmh e t l o
f owh ai c
s mr t
a eg rf s ef n
s n e
th e
t ai t seg el g
e cd il u
re o
cr o
grpo cs r
ne o
nb or ns d
l eh oerh oe l l Af lddt C v ly um 4
5 7
1 4
6 qir I
f 1
1 1
)
)
eN
)
)
S 1
2 3
4
(
(
(
(
l
4'$
1 i
% OF EQUIV ALENT CLAD i
=
~
=,
=.
c.
x.
~.
=
~
x
=
e,
~
x x
~
=
a c
e m
.j....
\\
_a m
w a
nu m
i i
m.
a.
ro i
i o
i u
2 O
Z i
n
("N 1
i O
i
~
B
\\
__J i
n u
i t
)
U t
W 1.0 1
to O
y s
t
.v t
)
~w n
i u
_)
1 w
e
)
n g
t______-)
c s
g S
=!
i_;
u.
C3 c
ul to
~
i...lii,.
,,1,,,,I,,,,1,,,,I,,,,.l,,,,j,,,,1,,,,
o 0001 006 008 00/_
009 005 005 00E 00E 001 0
CDM) N300BOAH 20 55tdW B-19
m n
P i
n d
h e
n 5
t R
i n
g a
B 2
w W
o og,eE n
L
/
n e rdivhR 6
o i
A t
i t
yd o n0 t
a Hubsh e1 s
i IR t
ai g e o
r l
Sca w o p
P e
ridnorrh E
n n
e
,eied R
t sbt pei ah y g W
t e
rd thn G
a scie Ls i
l t h y s x gl e n
2 Cla eoo a Ao e
tf ei H
Rnd g,o m ha t
asnt l
W gi d e t i t
einsn u
/
t c
p g Lnddme n e e n
Aiua rtl ef o c r t
o fi f
oscriet ct o
n s
a i
t pel u eu e
a wps eu qd b or e u af e r
t s
um u
d v
c r
i e
wc l
ed dvBco ix d
rn nidi ho nc of O
e t
e a acLod rk t
s a
t n st er et s ct a do g
el pnn%i n
eo s
n iw t
u n
s a
m s5ie o n e mi7nmi om i
e o
d r
i t
R c eatpmrrea c a d
r p
ri r
i nCu e eu e m Cf a
o R qm ct qn eRe oce e e l
Ne i
r c a d r gR N h C
t t
cA f
m e
a h
r n
a t
n o
or i
i P
t d
a e
n R
d o
W
)
t n
t n
n o
e L
n e
e i
d A
p t
o e
s m
a r
t I
u n
e n
R r
is o
s i
c a
n e
P e
v n
E s
d l
t e
m n
n g e o
u u
f o
a o
r i
r c
n pt c
c s
mf o
e od m
g o e
t t
t i
r e
d o
o o
D s
e r
r a
r f
p f
e a
s d
ir y
l l
s e
a a
e e
a al e
v h
t r
e
(
i c
e r
e o
r u
l d
c s
e s
m l
i r
e s
n r
t s
e z
n e
c h
ie r
r o
t i
c u
ehr d
p l
i c
u d n
c e o
x i
t r
ih s
a e
e d
o i
o r
v r d hp o o
T o
t r
p o ws r
d n/
o e
a p
i n
e a
et f
f n
n o
o nmt c
c l
o e
oi n
v i t s
mda c
l u
e ot i
e s
s ot u
r i
n oi n def c
n s
f i
or f
f f
f f
n e
ol o e i
r e o
f a
m ph e
m l
t o
n c
n n g n t
u g oi oi np n oi os u
miaio a
r i
n O
t t
t ic ct s
od n
e mah an smmy o
r r oit iT F CFc FaA HC
T m
rg P
d R
vR W
ios no a
L oW i
t t
atL A
a h
A I
n t%r R
0o P
o n1 E
f t
o e
iw e
v ioi t
D t
slea o bv n
p r
ee e
C bs g
Rt n o
Nso u c r
t d
nmly e
r y
r ne r ov H
uio t
c ar e f
etb o
hn eo t
n sct o
wn-o o i
cy t
h t
n sni i
l e
s a eb ga i
t v
s aon e
pdro dt r
ot sye P
n ehd y
T S
/
l
E m
n a
e o
r a
g e
t h
r o
e h
n r
t re g
P i
t er2 m
e e
r s
n n hah a
r c
a R
gt ara oin%
ep ym W
l f
o h
t r
i sgst t
e3 n
d e
a ng e et L
i i
t a
n d m1 t
gn A
n erd mr i
c mo e
I n
t e o
a uid i
ai m on ol m R
n f
ciae n
t i
t egwn P
nt n ea nt i
o R
gni g
f iayn oa E
t r i
te Wa of s
set i
r o s
n ht le nac e
c
%c osnt s n o
o L mrc D
o Af o n
7c ce u a s c ot a d
2a c
nt n
r r
c l
o eni o
san e
det na muR e
s f
eW t
r ei a
n mcatai erL i
g e
er nl r
a d
n l
a t
o b
r ao s
2l ehntlnaA f
r a
o n
Ht o
et n i
t r
nt n
oia o
ni n ni n
d o
t a
ai me a n
m
%c sho umin we s
y y et c o t
r rt e
3i et H
d t
c p ci a
u u e d
1 f s
r og u s e o
e i
od 2
f n r
e mt o
ed D pur o
fo mnbsa H
ol i
an e es s
y s xte x n
u e
ot y
r egt n ;i r
u o ndr eTm sia r
S u
ei d
t t n ini x
ou e o
i t
t t n mD2 t
i
%n me nne eDH x
g gn id i
i i
i r
t s
n i
m ei i
3 gg yi r
t t o o
a a i ab uo%
s n st 1
i r
e a2 t
vBH eed na nt sm qt 3 t
s n
ee1 ge e or o n ef o v
r r
e el y er r
a r
glaiu sl so g oi Ri r r
t ut t et r
co cd g
x sc smas a R uf P
i e qi r n r
ec eel in%Tth e m T a Td e eoWdT h 3 hr eLonD r
dt c1 Tod AcD eT m
3,
)
mar a -
c e
d o
r h
n P
i m
T a
R n
a n
n y
em W
o y
t r
ga L
d i
e oe p
rt A
t o
a m
o ds I
e R
n r
r y
e p
h o
h P
h e
et E
t t
r h ),
e h
u t
o D
y o
x ni t
t t
t b
oa i
m pr i
n l
n i
e b
o c
ue a
s c i
g n
n n
t s
dne o
o e
nl e i
r t
ear r
d t
e n
pvu d
D en i
eitua y
n c
p dqr a
H e
h (e e i
y s
dr o
dsm p
t f
n t
t A
eed i
i o
ameh wn e r
r t
ot n
o ad t
t l i n
l td "s e l
ea I
i ig ew cr n o
t a
t r
t s
md i
nn l
sl inie oe n i
n s
l ic o e
a na yc tani t
v B
os n
no a t
i l
o i
nbi ocr i
t e
a a o l
t t
t r
c ni a a enn t
oi n n dee P
in td o o gc eyn en t
t h
Do e e hxo c
cDd Toc eT 6
6
-9 8
/6 CR N
lll
M l
l e
c
- 3. e c
n 0a n
o np i
o a
t s
a hn i
t n
t a
o e
sp t
n e
so d
e o
n l
t e
ea n e
h b do t
u nt i
D n
t a a y
e a
n t
n h
,n,o i
e iw:
l r
t b
eioe g
a ee td tea l
l o
nba r
o a c mna o n bs t
t d
e oc ea 1
i y
D sdt ri r
pt n
s i
H c
me o
hau i
s i
t sim g
dn f
it n
yo e
iao o
wt l
r he R
i g g s n t
l n
ni n
e u n l
he e
c s a o
h e
p t
I c
et eo i
t s
r b
O hnM a s u
n is d
T 5
n5 t
e a
se f
a I
n e D
6 c6 v
B oc
/
H D
ern e
it x l
ea r
a ae 2
2 pt l
eh c
n P
oh m
t i
ms n
1 1
a t
t d
h ei x as cDw Edl i
e eT i
)
m f
h o a
t n
r i
r r
wo o a g
t y
o o
t 0c hg n
r t
i i,n e
t 1 a l
t i
win s
s f
b e
f a
i r u n
a oa
( u e
w n
em v
y dq r
r o
o es ob ee u
t t
t i
t r t
ss c
x s
t e
d c
o a
s i
a D
gl f n er m
i a
pe n
n ny a
xt 2
c o
uo ym e e e
ir r i
H e
s m
t dt b
e n
n a
e r
se se r5 i
D t
v et a 2 3
t n
n n s s
%r 1
ei a
I n
n mm e%
0 a
a e
e r0 2
o n e c2 n
s g
at n
n e
i o
m s
ih a
s e
t z
r a
ny t
e o s 2i hi a
t s Hw r
c d
cyn rl e t
o y5 elet R y
S r
Rai r2 ac e t
mW H
o f
d Wir mta f
e a L
Lr
%o r
a n
3o g gd A f
s A pe i
r o
t s n c
c t
cm ndM i e e
nn e 1 t i
tl n
ag i
a ol sb r
f dc of aie2 f
i a
o E
ein l
f t
e
.a e a y6 an i
f i
ti A
t cng ys t)1 eo t
r rt n
s ego nsf re h b%
c a eyo od pi rsd i
e s
td x
ef m0 n pc el v
a y
y r
e B
eh w a o
i 3
l s
s a ra st eh c
p oc r
n e l
l i
l t
t a
med et s
fi P
c i
de c swmu es o n rn aic e%5 a
in ec e ethe ei r cr h02 h
pht t
ti c
Sap T11 S w o Ti n
e T
margo r
ro P
s on s
ns R
f n
y dw a
aa e o w
w W
t f
o i
l th h
L i
n td i
t b
c s a
A ie r
w a
a u
o i
e a
,i I
n d )4
%t n
a p
R n
o y
o7
- 8. e
%s P
r o
t r
e c-e D
B 7l
- 4. e d
E t
e s
2c 7m n
D n
no i
c 2a o
a
=a n
t l
=f e
f9 O
n a
6 e
t u-2 O e g
t h
o e
a oB Hm 2
t r
g D
h
,a H
d s
e y
l
%f t
o it la ws
%c t
h en
- 9. a r
n n
t
- 2. l e
d n
d (t o2 y
e n
c a st 1i 3u0 8 i
f H
m n a 1b2 1
i=n r
r -
ho e g
= uP o
ir t
i t
t l
f e
it i
o p
wae 2 2e s n
s t
t rc x
L gc H o Hc e e
n E
Naa
,n ut l
,d f a
Sf e0 h 1
l o
e no v
td m 2 t 2i i
s i
t u
i a
aPw Poa q
t i
n s
th e
a s2f l
n t
t tHt so s st e
B n
eid eye e
s v
e ya t ae r
r t
ac l
t a
t e
a r
i c Sr v S pw e
Sdi r
c E %i T g r Tst s
f ae i
P n
n Nl s Ndly e h
G3g eb nnh f
n n
i c
V1 s doi aoT I
e T
[
M P
tue n
ot R
ba W
o n
i ait t
o o
L i
t sinait n
A a
t a i
o n
nt an o
I ot hod o
iat t
t ahe e )s o t
f d
r
.e nt b en l
o naa go D
t y e abo gi t n
ad hot ia r
t.r r ti ie t
r a r p o (s i b e
e e
nl i
et yr g
n al p et a t
o E
a e ccb h
r r gd eo i
n i gh e urr t
r i
n d
oie oi p t
sia sd i
odit
,m y
t a
yt t
i H
i uin gn y t
i t
dt enio rel i
i f
n r
s e emh ig o
n g
I ua b
ni eih l
n s
qm i
et l
.a e
n w gni s
i o
s rf o
r a
yoin os i
a t
t B
gsaiol cn n
o rr rt eai eega l
e a
s t
ndar na c
erl g uin v
of a at i
e n
e el cso r
h hndf eitxe e
e P
cTt ad Bed e
T f
l
1 i
4 1
i I
1 a
4 l
l REQUIREDBE3:.GY )
FOR DETONATICN l l
AT 13% R, i
PLANAR CHARGE 1
COfENEDTUBE AT 13% H2 l 1
@ ~ N:J"HARC WRX2dHED 2 ORDERS NN.
iM8 J MAGNITUDE m
, '.:g;;,
t);.-
id%jf.
"#Ai:sw N
a a.
+44 N
12 KV ARC 3VER3OrMk:P ylgp MAGru swa M
,\\
duk? '
4 2711 EP
'7 m:n 480 V ARC
- h t..,.rb e,
.,.g.;
.s
$.f:.
- Sg:;:
n.;
g,.
J.hi :j:E N
@a,.M.j
\\\\.
u'
, W,,its, 1.
x wm
.,:4-m' 4%y WP ness i b;.
. ARC
- S!A
~ a$
($ W r
w &*
yj:t-w NN
.j <. 7;e N
r*.;; E 3.At
\\
Thk,pklst
~u,,4..
)
m-x a n:
lC-NITE:. S Ahy?' '"
W*, h 2 V54: Y M1*,.#
l
$!JW
!%ws
]
' ^k*:;
- g
MPj?
M!.
sg:<'
t,*hM.T.
$b '
gN
^
- n:8 J ijh 1
MATCH E.:-
i
- py
- ;e n:p..
s&: *
@n*W.
n w
3 2
3 4
5 6
7 8
9 10 11 0
10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 l b2 i b3 i
JOULES /SECOND i
i Figure 2 16 Comparison of ignition source energies with sources required for detonation.
1 i
l i
51 i
l 1
o et z
n n
s l
i e
e s n o
e e n of l
bnmn eio i
t e aa n a t
a s glfh nro a
atint o
c n
hr e a
o
,dcM her c
T yn c
t e
e Dha4 en h
hoh D
D%n2 t
t c g
t
,5ex an n n
n T
o tM hei 1
o s
t g e
if Dio u
t g
D s
s8 so e
e ry nml td b o
y au c ay 1
r b
r ad ch mt e t
d n
nist drT i
y o
oinbn n eD moe iwD H
i i
t t
v eo a
a dn cl s
r na e u nroh f
i t
ot g e of o
i t
nt a nn d
ai fl d e
I n
deaa pi w i
r v
t u n
- t r
o s oar td afo e
l del i
t e i
l t
s n olyn ae oc n
a tl ot o
nap n l
Bi ai g ec eo e
tdet an s
a edro m
hit l
v a
r et a e
c gviel i
r r
a e gleM eben i
r nf sic pn go n
l P
h ebsc0 x a de t
c D o u a3 Ecjd u
eT 7
m
)
oM o
m P
t t
a c
r2 r
ol ei R
e t
r i
i n
a1 y aa t
t s
r ns o
W o
yxl ys n
a sf i
l l
i e
s a ah ed L
i r
a r
t dMe di e
l t
e yhi rde A
l cw a
n9idT np n
r ir I
d dvi R
n D
m n
ar no u i
i 2ahtD 2i a
n e
rq P
o Hti h
sg ape E
t awr H )5 i
c 2er r
iadn e
%h gfo %2 e Hlpl eo n t
D 5s ny 5f g
n ti o a%m ri o
n 1 elor 1
r ie et 0
v et a a
r n
i rl r o vir opss ot 2 )0 (e c n l
r t
e r s g
f c f
n r4 e
T mee sam g
D si t oft a%e r
c i
c e
t tf t
f o
D u )5 m n ue6 e
el 0
n oD 3n l
s s
rD r
1 ot s
sl t
e a x vl o n
c n d
y e o0e rc f
ut r oe e
b r
r y
r3b s c o ih2 m H
n T o td T (s M o
eaf gtH f
e n
rf oDt sl a T eM meia cau Dm4 5
r l
l i
DaeoDa c D a0 naht t
f t
l a
fl o
d wden Dc7 ee t n i
o s
oo t
et t
el a s e s. i st mtst c i
t n
n al e
c nd(.u t
t tn cel n%e e
eir o i e nR n
I o
e e
v (s n c nr n a v0s mt ab a d gW i
n at ur i
t s
n2 s e
ey nl t
r vr n oc aL n
s uias uhs i
ahb eyco eio u
do cnmA i
e a
t e
i i
r nt v
B hr hwc q hi c l
t n l
ain td dd e
l a
t t
e 2e ewa l
ee g
e g
2l r
a gnt c
ning nHn R nHs cn r
r s
esf ii P
n inla%eva a%naWla%o i
i i
s ceiT l
n n s gD h
c3nr c5h L r
c3r ai i
c S1 u a S1 c A S1 c S c sD eT l
-m
\\
~
._.Z '.
]IL 2E 50 -
b.
o-DEFLAGRATION - NO OBSTACLES
.z g
DETONATION - NO OBSTACLES G
D-DEFLAGRATION - OBSTACLES
<c 5
DETONATION - OBSTACLES u.
e x-z z
G,?.
~
g w
s
-3~
c.
O 0
^
^
^
0 5
10 b
20 75 30 HYDROGEN MOLE FRACTION, %
Figure 2 1-LAME accaratus DDT results (reprecuted from Reference 43).
l l
1 53 l
margo s
r e
e P
c r
r u
R n
u r
n o
a s
h s
W o
p h
i l
d s
u a
p l
o e
n b
c L
r a
n g
r A
T d
e u
i e
a g
ta D
v g
r a
R i
t I
f r
d D
io o
o a
a r
n P
a P
r r
o l
t vp d
h) u P
E o
n y
t b
t e
ae h
g5 6
u e
v ob n2 t
r 6
a e
f.
e r
D e
tl l
da h
3 o
t e
l r
e p
P nh t
t 4
s a
p n
as:
w h
h a
i h
o th e
gng s gp a C
h t
t n
g s
noi e
na p)
C
(
xitd c )5 or i
o e
i
(
s g w5 r
isu a
r l
s r
u mnl p2 aa o2 o
t t
c d
o n
r an s3 s af3 l
a eri e
l y
e tt d 4 nP e
t f
4 d m
H F
o nt e
e
,h i
t mo n sh v6 th l
r n
f oie op np o a
er s
p t
a ramlc a se a
i o
i r
sr s
pne ng ep eg s m
rt n
e otog e a valcr a v
o o
D e n
,r t
sdral a sh aa s
c )6 l
g d
t er aP nC sP n
e4 i
t a(
s r oa m,t b
,i n
r tn3 ut t
i s6 s
o6 a
s t - t e
a ann ge r
e4 v
B eoe gr gr g) v r
e n u nt f5 f5 e
nt fi i
mipdsodp o o
e t
i ca d
l i
r a
irnia vl ia 2
2 f
P c
i gi oh oc oh e
e a
c at vC rn vC s3 s3 in el nA( P e A( U4 U4 f
h peo c Sdc e
T a
7-98
/6 EN 1
P n
i n
h R
n o
W t
i i
w r
o e
L ie n
A t
i t
r r a
ca o
I i
R t
n Rs s
P i
o Ws o
e E
p t
Ll e
Ao R
r D
e2 W
n tH Ls h
n Ao t%
e p
eit g
e3 ha c1 l
t o
c y
u f t t
r a oi p g l
d dsb e e i
r c
y nea ct arn a n H
uo e
wtx or t
r f
eie t
u imd wc o
vetd of n
d
- r. n ioho e
ee v rk o
ts ema er t
i do t
el n
u pinoiw e
a mtat s
t n e e onn om v
R coe c a e
cc r
i r
nC Cf i
tf P
o R af Re Nhu Nh i
t t s t
c A
m e
a r
h g
t o
n rP i
d n
e R
o d
W
)
i t
n t
n n
o a
L n
e n
e i
o e
s m
a o
A p
t t
r I
u n
e e
n r
c a
n d o
R is o
s i
P i
s e
t l
d t
n C
E le m
n n
g u
u f
o a
o e
e c
n v
t c
r s
mf o
e e
o m
g r r
t od r
e d
o o
p D iD f
s e
r r
f o
e e
a s
d t
r l
y s
e a
a a
u la al e
v h
s i
(
r e
c e
r e
o e
s l
d e
e s
m l
t i
r ei r
n r
r t
s e
z c
b c
ie r
h t
i r
c u
ehr d
n e
l c
ud n
ce o
x o
v i
e d
oiih s
i o
o t
r d hp o a/
o T
r p o ws r
d r
t o
e a
n p
t n
i n
f e
a f
n o
o nmt c
e e
l o
it c
v oi s mda c
le n
t i
e s
s u
r ot u
o n
i s
f oi n def f
f f
f or c
e n
i ol o e f
r e o
n m
i f
a m
ph e
n l
t o
n c
n t
u g oi oi np n gi n
os u
o a
miaio i
n t
O t
r t
c e
ct s
o i
d n
mah an smmy o r
r oit iT F CFcFaA H C
margorP tne ne R
d
,i P
R al W
)
b c
d c F
Wisa L
k ea C
L nr A
taf C
A oo I
o w
R e
i l
(
t u
r c
mre y
o c n P
t f
e u E
n i
t r u l
t o s b
n oy i
a rl a
ad e pia.
f m
ye b nmt i
l t
t r
nm o ae n n r
e e r
o ed pyi dt e
r u f
s io r
e eaq cp c
r r
se c
e pn u sr ad a
P sl a ey e n l
i aa f cr r a t
,b eo e
t e
n sd t
n nn a vl o
enl eb t
e nni u
eat mu sa m
a g
r ri mt g nn e os iar ni n
e a
f e t
ei ee t
d i
r t
m n
v n
l i
a u e ob l
n e
i u
t qcd cd c v
,e t
n exn o
ea a u u t
l yr l
r od nr u R. n n n
o eat C
ao a
owr ms e V
p sf i
i t
nr n
s L et i
n d oe e
s Ad e nit ac n i
i eig i
r n
t p
e vv o e n ns oe ct u o
h r r r o o ne i
n Tpp Acc Cud y
S g
flllll ll
no de i
t t
a y
c l
t u
e c
l i
ib t
t l
e s a
a o
e e c
p r
v f
a P
mi o
c tc o e s
n c
t j
s b
o
,s o le i
i t
l d
a b
er n r
g u
u o a
i t
t P
at g
i i
e c e
m f e r
r t
t n
o no d
e or e
f p
d i
r t
i i
s nt u
c en q
c t
ve ey a
n em r c d
e r
t t
n ps ne e
m v
t e
eu nv o
e en mq r
e p
r di nr m
if icd a
iu c n t
i e
r q
aa ng o
oa f
e ey c
v m
s r
R o
d a e
ist a ed r
nl g
u R
eu ge a
t t
g u o e
r W
Ee Rc F
x r
LA l
l
e ta e
m ro i
d c
xo e
o p
l r
v o
t c
m o
c r
e d
o r
n r
p i
a f
d mty h
g n
ta i
ii n
a p
l i
ri t
t n
n t
ob e
o c
f a
v c
e r
sp e
i r
e d
t a
p r
e a c u
nC i
t r
y v
e p
,u t
mn i
a o
y l
ib c
t s
o a
o i
r l
ei i
t b e p
rt ag n
at a a
cn o
pw iug i
a t
i qi na ta c) t o e r
t ei gn it h u
ne a
g RM zt d m i
n f
i i r e
n on R
us m o
oia c
W l
f t sn ei ys yn r a t i t
o L
r i
ic pt n vb v
A e
a e a n o
Dc Cd Ci (
se r
v W
W u
i S )c.
s t
e C
C a
Mt R
nCr C
e e
y y e
c) t r
c c
,s n us o W C y.
ed u u
F n n r
s e
d n e e o ot t
s t
n sB Di na e a
n u ui i
c e
r r
o q qtcu e
C(
ea eWp w )s e e epmAn p
p t
e r
i t
f e
e o
i r
f js s a dF et c mE r
y v
eis c
n nmr n
nAhl e
t r
i i
o i
vt i
e oad er s v og i
i gb r s i
n eSia ey amp nd i
r v
acor m p
t f
e sl oi oy op eI h s s i
i r S ); a
(
t yo t
h y
i
,f f
r i0n;nsP of Rc yt e
c t t t
P t
i
(
gn c
n e
iaO ya aO yawn i
t 1 lif nxs o
b a t
s e>et B t
dBi as t
pB r
i i
sd l
n syd e n( t i
aS b u i
i a
r r n
l m
ei c
e nbSr vh e
ad sz e
v ni r o a
a t
d s e
n i
d r
i l
rdCer d r nr er ou m
eRsc o
i t
r i
c nc( es df ae
- s s d
s e
v n
mRie
) i t
v n
yi c
u r
i r
e aG cd sa e
r nd aes sWd y
A oe esu yD n
p sty t
iE am yBtye r
r i
t y
a t
t e
R cy/ e d r s( ed r f c
l uc1 v i
oa b d ne f
d n
<d o
ai ut Rs ad ps W
i t r
n s e pf t
n ih d g Ho v
ee l
L t
uo u n nl et en r
Dino s
sir r ;
r o qe ei C
t l
A h
n n
i ar md wd d
d vt p d o l
e n
eA es ed wi ei m
i i e
cf e e e vA ve v
t va i
f r
r iP ipu o
oc oys v
or r e r r r
t r a enR nSu es i
g pg pu pf pp iOqd o s
e nl ma mo maaH me i
r n
SL r ic s
st R s
r I
l I
I I
e t
x E
m s
ar e
e g
r l
nb o
u a
r i
P t
ai mn g
l a
me r
oo n n R
R i
e d e f d di W
W r
us F
er ne B
L t
l vo o s cn A
n om ia ne n
t r
t i
I ub
,m e
R o
p md b
r 5 e s
r i
P e
r8 v
t u
i t
i
- f n0 o
u c
E
~
t 1
n i
l i
yl t p o1 sr s
r e
r p c
e o s i
v m
w em l
t r
f i
t n
bi Fo pi A
s e e
aS Dl al t
r e
a R
um l
l i
Cb hi P) a P
se t
vy c n d
ai ao Dt R
t t r e
ev t
r o l
n 't db ht i
en na a
Ro W0 p r
t p
do ais e
f L
5 m
l r e or s iC yvm ab or A
1 a
i 1
t yf e r
- R c
ae sl d
l i
sp o
G t
l W
c(
bk s nwt u
i i
t s
e d
E ia o
t A
any n
sdh n
L e
R s
t s
i i i A.
s ae e yuc v
U le r t e
ccmtest y
No R
t r
at n
i Pe a d ne f
W Oh s n ev aye a
d r
f t
uo siu d
i n
v n
e L
B r, e yqr Riq e
i t
ep ie m
ct t
r A
d ed s
asmWss e
i e sn u
l nl nb e
pj i
e v no L eu r
xd i
o e/c mnaR Ass p
ea v
rd d eeW i
r l
pn i
e L
s mo e PnA r t cf n
I i
e tx E
g(
d r ee s v so e
r d s
s d e t
W e
dt n
a r
a e
p L
m u
n c A
i t
ei e
t I
a en v
e b a o
r F
st p
a n m
h e e
m s
i t
v s
n t
t e
n n v e
e i
t eo v
n vr m
e e) ep e
l m
a r
vd ai u
n l
i e 't nt q
re r n e
r n
e a r
n t
Po xc e
t i
i ei g
m f
RC n
a mg o
W(
t r
oi o
f rS b
s L
f a
t s
c n
A o n e
g c
ff i
t e
is e.
i ust ml v
b en s
a id a r
i i
i t
s nRp e
c l
i s
f n
cwt e
o n
e e
n t
F L e r
e x
D Ar F
B r
i u
n E
Cic
- f(
,n igra m
M ly e
a R
l t
s i
at 5t h
h n 2 c t
t e
e i
t f
s s o
.f Wt np n e t
t eh
,n e s e
va gl t
l e
na a m d
r e i
f o
t o e h
s Ge t
ye ele r
r c
r b p
i n
o a yu r
ee mv teq ut r
n f
e qi se i
e(
s aR
)
r nb S
"e t
oo f
e 8
sis r
i g
o
~
Cn 0 a e
f n
ef t
i 1
o r
l Ri t
< e cg r y n
Nis r
yi t
oei t
s l
t x
ga eu f
t f
a sraa a
eE c
l l
f s
al e
c "e l
a y
ce Mi i
r s
ys a b o l
V cu e
ud l
i a
lo cg p
l w
i p
n Ro W
di Cl s Wl u u a
R Ro a
L Nwc Ai s W
LA
y t
e i
l ro r
i f
o b
e r
n a
e oc b
C h
i it t o
R ai n
t s
o d
t l
r N
n eb i
i t
P r
d a
pa c
e rb u
e o d
e h
p t
r e
t r
s e
np r
u c
s F
i i
lb R) l n
i a
D mWv i
e o
a t
C s
c F
e oLi t
r t
y a
Aa o
t e
t l
n e
t u
n a
c b a e
l l
m v
t n
ah e
i r t u
t e
u e e c n
m e
t d n nt e
o e c
n m
ne u
r l
n o
am v (n a i
i a
s t
s xe snt d
e i
t d
el on p
i l
p n
e ni l
e a
o d
pm oa t
m e
mii m
e l
a t
C e
oo a u e b
ct pr x
t l
n n ui d
e i
e aa cnu l
l l
t a
o c
aq u
e n
nm si a
e o
e cmr c
s it e
c o
P r Pa i
F u F r i
t Cq Cp i
m d
Ce Ci r
n o
C
t p
q 6 e e
v e
t c
n r
rEi n
e F
7 o0 a t
o d
f e
1 e97777E nx c r
i c
s c
s Pt c
aEEEEE 0 o1 "
n a
e00000 1
i r t r x
euo F e l
1 1 1 1 1 Cm e
e xx xxx 1 io t
r Ce e
R521 21 6 c b )n r
r v
a o ei e
Pei u
h s
F r r
q e
s tye Cet t
e hR Cwi n
r e
c l
P p
wR n
F1 af y f
i m
eW m
C0 yot e
t f
aL o
C01 1 45 t f i
a s ua r
r A
p ics t
x s
t ue e
a" cd E
l h
v 6
seie l
l hb y i
t if t
P s n 66677E ot u o ei h
l EEEEE 0 nspp F
1 d eRm t
l s
pd w
F00000 i
C mi D1 e
x l
nWe 1 1 1 1 ul C
ap xx xx x 7 n
l o uL e g
C521 528 w
xp r
i ea s
eAe e
nc ew gn d
gn ABCDE seth "g ne i
as e
iwe e
c eeeee eu on b
r o
e c ccccc d qt i
t n nnnnn er n lo o d n e eeeeel a sao l
ie a
f n
s u uuuuuut h hit i
l es nq qqqqqqo c cmi t
h a o e eeeeeeT uaia r
Th Cs SSSSSS S e (s p
N
.q B
e F
7 r
re A
0 e1 8877E nt sn s
w e
e aEEEEE 0 l
o c
1 mn e00000 l
x a
r l
1 1 1 1 1 oee e xxxxx 3
)
r gu R521 21 3 t
o r
f e aq
'n ne n
1 o0 gas C
s mf i
o et
(
P d ny P
1 c
e sF n
F1 t
0 nd eC aie C0 C
cu C01 1 45 l
l pcq p
a:
a e e
76 e
mwg r r h o f
a oa EE e
6 t
eh 77777E r
t h
00 ar x
s 1 1 e
t v
h u EEEEE 0 E
d a xx
,a e F00000 d
t t 1x l
r ec D1 ue 1 7 ef 1 1 1 1 P
u xxxxx 5 oh 68 v
F ct nd C521 521 e
n n ge:
C go s
a wir t
o etah ABCDE Ci h
s s
,d h e
t e e eeeee r at o c ccccc d c e
ys n nnnnn an dd g e eeeeel e
iesieC uuuuuut a
h u t
cq nlpad qqqqqqo u e opt n eeeeeeT r
Ss Casa SSSSSS
e a
h s
t i
e P
W s
F a
L c
C y.
A s
Cc I
n i
h ee
)
t gu d
n aq r
i e e
't d
vf r
n e
a e o
cu wg C
d o a m
(
e:
2 l
r o aa 2
nd s
t n
e ee i
e s a e l
r p
b a tno e
76 c
m i
sr a
ac EE mg a
h n 00 n
x Fd oc i
i 1 1 t
E Dl xx u
u t
Co 35 nd e e P
w 31 r
e m
F hP et o t
C F
ie r
h C
gC uv uC qi t
o e n r
e e
h g
a c t
a sn n
r e e ui s vv hi E a Td
n o
ey i
tc b na t
e or n
t no t i o
i r
d s e
e d
r u n b
nr se l
t i
P r
nk o e o
h o
a ec i
e sm ab a
t t
tat t
r e
n gt et t
r s
a u
ni e
a h
i t
r eu v
e i
s vq ml t
e e
b t
s
.h ar n
dh m cd e
e l
r a et i
l r f e
h u nieo m
r t
eot p
et g n
s wo diey h
r i
mpr a
sr s es e
oo t
nt n :e nu c
h nty v
l i
d ol oi aRr cb c atp ei O
r t
f n
a a
e ug oWd r
t ei od d qe
/
r t
cL n d s n e et n
Aa
~
r n sin e
sei i
d e
et s sd t
et e e n
i e
n n V
n eC o
gn s b e l
u g
c nign d m i
mR y
t i
t i
ne e nl s
y sl n
f n
eon ela e e e r
l i
caa e
dt d i
c vnd t
t t i
ye ynn m
l i
ih Aa e n oo l
l r
t e ah up sh r
Sit Acf n
wsis o
i sl Rs b
a e a Wl a
o r ct t
i oes L h n
F ne Ap oC
[(
l l
)d
'tnoc
(
t n
ru o
o r
c o
i j
t t
a ee m
c ns e
t mi e
t l
o ly nu b
c m
l i
r a
ai y
e f t l
P n
t fniu et l
o od k s y
i s
e e
ul cge s
t i
l b
r t
d nr d
g i
a l
u t
i sk esd u n s
nr n u oi l
tn t
o e o wn i
s e
d w c
e vic e v e
e n L
r r
a s
r e u y
ee p
f
.a hh d y o
r r
t t ol i
l sl e
e a
eo
,f t
ni cp d n o v
ot n n
d ee c
O e
a e n vs b
st o p
a eu t
/
i t
y l
t p
e as a o n
n c
u t
e ed cme t
n vn a
g c o V
a mn ai t
c e
t n e el n c i
t el btsa aj l
e l
n mb u yh b
a n
e nr P sc o
i i i m
ase t
n nd o n ia Cu t
n oC l
t k n e ro t
w mn e
ea b
d r l p i
t nu s
aqy u
eb mis s
eRt s
u n
tn a sRa n
eb l
iWp s
v e o
eL e d
r t
ni sAo i
t ew ef f
c h oe m y-A nt er t
b r
t i
a a s s pw g
u i
t n
nd a
e r si on v
ci a
i e
t d nr l
d c eo5 u
nir t
i s
ae st r n
elu e e
Pe uot p
R F g qs a
C ee a
r r h C
rC n
ni n
eo oet o
ih ni k
t d
ct et i
e a
l s
Ad mc v
r eluo Ca ui f
i ct s s Rwo re s e NtoDc r
I
s d
t n
n a
e s
m n
s t
e o
n e
v e
i t
u o
c m
r u
s p
e d
s m
e r
i r
u i
i q
e mZ e
P R
r re E
u T
y t
r t
u e
o l
s i
i c
f t
F t
r s
Up u
i e
o s
t la S
a nc b
an i
l o
t d
P l
n e
a C
u c
e e
n n
v n i
t ig i
h si t
o n
c s s P
o e
ae C
T PD 1
2 3
\\
s s
W m
L tnr A
s ee m
I mT e
t t
s ee n
y rc e
s i
r u
ml u
o q
n r
o t
i e
a n
R S t
o n
n c
g o
nB t
c c
is e
e e
u m
gD d
d d e
iL a
s r
t t
o i
s s
e r
m p
y t
ee mk e
e o
n u
s Dh a
t i
t e
al o
g t
s t
n y r oi n
l s
r s
s f
o n
g i
oy l
t t
s g y n ni n
p i
t b
ai ai o
e m
f s
o e
pi s
r x
c g ma l
ed s d s
mei e
s n
y i
e gd r
t t
l t
t t
t l
i pt n
n n
n ai u
n i
l i
e e
e ek q e b
u mc ab ei a
d e
mmmm t
e y r c
af n
n n
n i
s c
b r
l xf a
a a
aS a
s a
a i i i i E A R
i n
n n
n Ci e
t h
t t
t t
lx c
s Wo o
o oC u
c oQR P CCCCE AAP E C 7
margo t
r n
P e
m RW s n s
si a L
m at t
pn A
nr y o I
ee b c R
d y P
mT nr E
ee a a rc ms t
m i i i
r d r u
epe u
m q
r t
c e s e o) m d y e
t R Sd e
gi s s
s e
nt y
t l
nBe m
s ib u o s
yeb ot r
u i
st g
t gD n aul n n
n r o osi l
iLi o
or r
r ct ct l
np s
t k s nt i
t t
een a
n al oc em oeo cu ma l
Dho o
cl o ie nped e s s
t c y
t e
gor t
t agig foy(
t r i n
i napu l
nr i
as ok qe b
b ekk eianed a
s maad s
i s e or c t
ed n eel i
el ss c b
i l
i l
l e
er Ss s a a
l a V V w pC f pt Rt et h
i nSI WoiS y p cs mc uCB c oQR r
e BCMMDSERAPEC af xf E A
/
o e
t y
n c
t r
o n
r p
o yi a
o mn t
l aZ e c t
t f
r Pt k u p
eo n
id e
oo t i t t o
t u
ac l
p a
l e
c E
l r
c mq u
i nd i
x nlP wZ a
ao a e i
e ne sP c
r r gp t
r i
n ov E
b r
l aii lt o
u rd oZ t
s f
u pP i
P u d c s o p
s pE u
n e
a e
R (q u
d r n d
t o
ae P sR W8 so n
t n ah sa L 8 yW i
r e
ei a
i t
t i
l 9
gL l
yr a
A c
i t
f e
1 u
yor ad n
nA l
o d
o l
d ntyf ni o
ey r
f t
o s
i t
a ga s
t e
eiy n
a aM) y l
l ci r yo r
t r
st b
R eia c
e s
r l
i pp unt ei r sl e
oin b
u f t Z
s a an oe ni c
cpe t
t s
a ei sa r
r f t s
n em a a P
h r
r o
et e
ea Rr js se Pf E
mt p a
ai y
v Ww mh a
s e
l l
t gi o at au L
r s
y r
gat Al so nh p na l
t r
ot n
et o
l mis r
ov e:
e a r
es ei t
r e c
t P
ms vi si sd an t
i f
y no o
n s n i
Rt o
sh Ce Ost em e
r e
r n
s ac Se Dnf t i Woqe r
t oa e
u a P e Ub Ecs n d t
Lf I
f AereR i
l
1 i
l l
eg a
k e
u O~
m
.O.,
- u) j
- O
'E u) Gll 3-
. c *3 C I
g E
m mE#
h @' V C Q
Og@C COO e
m maC I
a Crem*
E.s g.E 5
a m
C mC O Og)V $
E"T*
T I
g
-2 O
G g
EG 6*C IE (U s 3 $
A i
V gu2O W
i a.!S 8' a) a '
,E
<c j o E a)f3 E<C me8 2
mIE dt e O -8 O
O C
D zom g o m *S y
rS Z C :V E ES X u)
C (U
5O E *CU Q)* -d h q)<.9 O @
g Oc 1
(U h$
V$ m.
m g =g eV. a3 j
E u) $
C.
gj $ 0
.{
C.C ^ % mg>e
.I nc>o8eeC $. m ' E u>
\\
E e
m m e) -
E C ~
3 m E vi e" CL.w p E E 2 C.2 m
Ee S
- 3 m
3 Q)
@ L a) oom m.e s e a m.e m 2.m E 3C C, 2. s_ >) >E e
a) 1 cr, D CU o0 o
e, u). x Q) u) o> D 7
u) J o
gg W
w g y 4 g g e m $]V-D Cgv g
0 6 6
_C
=
E g m 3 c) N O U[
V gQ CD C
-3
+.
3 g3.CJ m C" <lC C CU ~._ V c)C 'U,2 g) i x
s <:C 3_ g *G u).9 u)COgO
[
g q)
O CU C
3 o y q) *8 Ti. $ a) D I
J O)V e.e 3 @ g -Q y g G.S O)*'
C $ u) g 4
C C c) e (o
o.t C
=>Co.
+O X m Q. Q) *C Oq ox C
H W CU W G.9 CU O O. W u) O Q) u -
)
I
)
e o
e e
E h
a
)
margo tn r
l e
r o
P m.
o r R R
t s
fk nW W
ucwr se o
oe o me e
cL L
rS f
s e
b nA A
l i
Dv e e I
ei t
i d
srs s
s ei s
gv R
t a
e nt nbs cs:s o o o P
r s
d e e e r a n p d pe E
r su ubo e
m mas o
e y pu i
s has e
snt r
e r u si ga e
r s
ic N
u s
Ric h
odi n
sf o e i
eD ci W ei wf ne q
g d
sas sn Rt osLd si e
oR e
se r
o Re pde A gm W i b at n
ath cin d
WmezRisyL u
un i
t r
ylr a o t
sn oAG L eiW l
c rl et ovs i
i A
uU L a ca o
Ait gtEn t
oq A
el a
i l r
u e
el o
dgl R u
e
.i f
t t
.l e neb g gi o
tRRla r
n n s eeEf oar ad eio c
mt So mnlei n
rt y
np at l
a r
rDn ob p
nel e
o hia p s ev a t
a i
t ml 5i s
r c
iat aP up m
mc rubl e sR u nn r ti t
e l
oct o aac eS c eh el m
mc vc v
e c A ps s
t e
eai nt nt u
d ae e
a o
ai t
.hr ky u am S
e s o sl n
sl wsCc t
i ti r
l u ana r
ra e
e e e ek ut c vor rht o ecg n c u n l
e o s ot u
af o
o e nr e Wb m-rap r
s R pI g
f
=,
{
1l l
l