ML20247A308

Affidavit of Bj Elliot.* Advises That Author Responded to Interrogatories 1,3,4,6-10,12,13,16 & 17.Related Correspondence

ML20247A308
Person / Time
Site:	Turkey Point
Issue date:	09/05/1989
From:	Elliot B Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC)
To:
Shared Package
ML20247A265	List: ML20247A260 ML20247A308
References
OLA-4, NUDOCS 8909120089
Download: ML20247A308 (15)

Text

_- _ _

7-

~

e

, i UNITED STATES OF AMERICA- '

o- 1: NUCLEAR' REGULATORY COMMISSION

BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING' BOARD L, -In the Matter of

. Docket Nos. 50-250 OLA-4

' FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT 50-251 OLA-4 COMPANY p 1 (Turkey Point Plant, Units.3 and 4) (P/TLimits)

' AFFIDAVIT OF BARRY J. ELLIOT I, Barry J. Elliot, being duly sworn, state as follows:

I'am employed as a Materials Engineer in the Materials and Chemical Engineering' Branch.. Division of Engineering and Systems Technology, Office of Nuclear. Reactor Regulation of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. . I have provided responses to Interrogatories 1, 3, 4' 6, 7, 8, 9,:10 12, 13, 16, and'17.

I' hereby certify that the. answers are true and correct to the best of my knowledge.

"~

Firry 6K6EH10t Subscribed and sworn before me this d day of d - e A s, 1989.

Wl2dNb AN My comission expires: 7/f/pg ep c-8909120089 890905 n J. : PDR ADOCK 05000250 '

f. . G PDR e g .

t

,['

m, --

y. , c ,

l', '/ ..hI'

~

p 1 AGENDA: 1 u ;,l 1

. . . l MEETING WITH NRC ON TURKEY- POI'; , o.EACTOR VESSEL. j

-APRIL'7,-1977 p;

l

.l

'1.) ' INTRODUCTION AND PURPOSE G. E. LIEBLER' u

i J. N. CHIRIGOS.

2.)"~REACTORVESSELASSESSMENT {

l A.) ACCIDENT ANALYSIS B.) ASME.III' APPENDIX G ANALYSIS.  !

C.) FATIGUE CRACK GROWTH ANALYSIS I W. COOPER  ;

3.).

SUMMARY

l i 4.) DISCUSSION' I q

l l

1

)

l

'i i

.. i j'

L

__ .m m - _ m m _ .__ .__ ____..__m____ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .- _____.____a.__.____._________-_____.____.___m__ ________

> . TABLE

.SyNARY REACTOR OPERATIONS

,' (EY POINT UNIT NO. 4 I9 1.)' DESIGN FLUENCE: 6.05 X 10 N/CM2 (E >l MEV) FOR 40 CALENDAR YEARS.

~

OPERATION AT 2300 MWT AT 80 PERCENT LOAD FACTOR.

2.) DATE OF FACILITY OPERATING LICENSE (2200 MWT)

. APRIL 10, 1973 i

' 3.) INITIAL CRITICALITY JUNE 11,1973 4.) DATE OF INITIAL POWER GENERATION m JUNE 19,'1973.

1 5.) START COMMERCIAL OPERATION SEPTEMBER 7, 1973 L

L G

C 1___ __ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

J.

c 0 TABLE 2~

METHOD OF ASSESSMENT' i TURKEY POINT UNIT NO. 4 REACTOR VESSEL L.

i l

L- 1.) 4 EFPY OR 5 CALENDAR YEARS CORRESPONDING DATE: MARCH 15, 1979 PLANNED' INSPECTION DATE: AUGUST, 1978 2.)LACCIDENTANALYSISOFBELTLINEREGION A.) LOCA B.) LSB USING. CONTINUOUS INSIDE SURFACE FLAW

- 3.) ASME III.-APPENDIX G ANALYSIS OF BELT!INE' REGION

-4',) FATIGUE CRACK GROWTH ANALYSIS OF BELTLINE

- 5. )'

RADIATION SURVEILLANCE-CAPSULE DATA O

e 9

m _ ._ a.__.m __ m._ _ . _ . . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - . _ _ _ _ _ - . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . - _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

[' - <

!( t TABLE 3 l.6'l TURKEY POINT UNIT NO. 4 REACTOR' VESSEL DATA 18 1.) FLUENCE X 13 : N/CM2 (E >l MEV)-

MARCH 1,1977 MARCH 15, 1979 AUGUST, 1978 (ACCUMULATED) (5 CALENDAR YEARS) (INSPECTION) 1/4T 2.7 L 4.6 4.0 SURFACE 4.5 7.6 6.7 t

USED IN CALCULATIONS ,

2.) CHEMISTRY - VENDOR CEP.TIFICATES 7 RT NDT-COPPER PHOSPHORUS INITIAL BASE METAL -- 0.010 50 WELD METAL 0.21 0.021 NA USEDINCALCULATIONS(WDATAl BASE METAL' O.054 ,

0.010 50*F WELD METAL 0.31 0.011 3*F 3.) RTNDT AT 1/4T - WELD METAL MARCH 1, 1977 MARCH 15, 1979 AUGUST, 1978 W CURVES- 129 149 144 R.G. i.99 1 51 196 183 18 2 SHELF WELD METAL IS 58 FT LB AT 5.7 X 10 N/CM 18 OCCURS AT 5 EFPY OR JUNE, 1980 VESSEL 1/4T FLUEN?E OF 5.7 X 10 4

_______.__m______m_._._____ w

a n e t o i 5 5' rr . 2 2

- r ge .

et 0 6 0 1 0 5 ti 4 2 4 3 4 2 r '

C a

C - S t 1 6 s . - - - -

e 0 6 - - - -

r 3 4 -

r .

a a-s S

- R r A a E e ,

Y Y x a )

R r mh c A a 4 D d .n N . n ti h h h h

. E d e i(

t t p p t t p p O L l l n 3 9 N A e a i 7 3 e e e e C w C

• D D D D T 0 2 I 5 h 5 l l l l N t a a a a U R r c c c c O i i i t t i i t t T F g N i i i i r r I S n r r O I o

• C C C C P S i " )_

Y g I o o o o Y L e " hc 8 0 N N N N E A r 5 2

< K N .

.n R A e s ti 0 0 U r e i(

T T o v n N c r i E u a D

I i n c C d C w a e n

A l r d f t o 9 9 9 h 9 9 9 l 9 t a 9 T e 1 1 1 i  % DM t 1 N . . .

n t2 T t . G. G. G.

e r

. w mc R f A i WR W. R WR e G. 1 / h f R 3 n S m

u d 08 c n 1 r a t 0 i n 1 c es .t e x

s u n r r u o o 6 o h c e u g w e

7 n n r o i i e = P P t t p n s p T e e o e o V s t C W C N a i C A C B B O S f S L L L 0 3 ,

a

m . , - - - - - - . - - - - - . - - , - - - , - - - - , . - - - - - - , -

M 9

4

.9 4

e

• 2 , o..

Q o

~ .

1. g O - r- ,

1' b M f a (p Ob~ g b m + .Q o g -

h k -. - c .

4: as. d- -

, += .3

$ o C SC 5

~ .

c> < g 3 a n =

=

p Z e

• M a * *

< t d e Jir J .$.e 5

~ al E

.e j j 0

4 T

4

=

s "

't $ $ $

L j $

l  %'~~ - sc

% . O V [e N - e

'g >

f " '" = . , ** g  %

• an, \

A ** m,  %

, g

~

\

y - * g - g g

s

[

N,g '

?  %  % '

VI l g g o

tng g "

l l I l I I ss*i l 0EEEE8! 8 3 2 *

, (11/ isx) 8'x -

j

{

. I

h o

. . y, s

a O

6 l

.g O

l-- 9 0 .k o

All E -

o o

T r E o X n I d o U

$ "f --

e '

a$

, e .'

b

~

S%

• 4st g v

~,

C. l- - 2 O*

=-

a>7 of s4 "

-y

=

D "y g $4

~

s n3 d 3l eF

z  %

.4

. o Z I. 'y~ s . \

% 0 Ng\g "

4 .

• J tN\

4e D S ' ~

J a k

55 b M T O

I I I I l l l l l g b$$ $2 -

8.

E o o

.=-

o

~

o h l$M) ) .

9 e

• *me ==nne

'.t.', .. !

RES'ULTS OF FATIGUE CRACK' GROWTH. EVALUATION -

'b TURKEY POINT UNIT NO. 4 REACTOR VESSEL BELTLINE REGION 4

Final Flaw Depth (in.) After-(-)

Postulated

, Initial Calendar Years of Operation-

- Flaw Depth'

(inch)- 5* 10 I. 0.125 0.125' O.126 0.250 0.253 0.255 0.500 0.509 0.518 0.750 0.771 0.791 1.000 1.037- 1.073

• ConservativelyLinterpolated from results calculated for 10 years.

l 4

9 L'

4

$~

.s. . w. _ ab. - _.___._..___-_i.____.___.__._._____.___._.__m_________.______m____.__ _ _,._.

i KIR CURVE.S {

' 1RMbt RTED K IR Ct4RVES cRLcutRTED usi HG '

W METHOD st[. . Y # h Q u 5. ~/ x t ow /cm' t -

gq[ . .

,' 'S-5

• t D

),$ o . . s I .

/

jLs%E HETAL lif -

, j p BASE HETRL l $

10 0 -

p %JELD ME.T9L WELD METRL [ p JS . - -

/ /

t 30 .-

a o#p 1$ -

s -

i i . i . . i

- 20 0 -100 0 100 2.00 100

[uT RTNbT jI >

F Re.1oJ tve Tempem4uv c. Ve.v 5 w S D t3no mic' Ev ac.f wv e,. l ok3b%e59 O BRSE M E.T A L suavEILLeHCE 3 TtARKEY PotNT 3

$ UJELb METAL .I %M ES

• Y

t ,

REACTOR VESSEL MATERIAL' SURVEILLANCE PROGRAM .i FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY

_ TURKEY POINT NUCLEAR FACILITY ni 1.) ESTIMATED MAXIMUM FLUENCE (E >l MEV) AT THE INNER SURFACE OF THE REACTOR VESSEL WALL AS OF 1/1/77

• UNIT #3 - 5.33 x 10 18 N/CH 2

18 2 UNIT #4 - 4.47 x 10 N/CM 2.) NUMBER OF EFFECTIVE FULL POWER YEARS (EFPY) 0F OPERATION ACCUMULATED AS OF 1/1/77 UNIT #3 - 2.68 EFPY UNIT #4 - 2.17 EFPY 3.) VESSEL FABRICATOR - BABC0CK & WILCOX COMPANY 4.) A.) -LOCATION OF WELDS IN THE REACTOR VESSEL - SEE SKETCH B.) INFORMATION RELATIVE TO WELDS IN BELTLINE REGION OF THE VESSEL 1.) SHOP CONTROL NUMBER OR PROCEDURE QUALIFICATION NUMBER -

NOT AVAILABLE AT THIS TIME 2.) FILLER METAL AND HEAT NUMBER - SEE TABLE 3.) TYPE OF FLUX AND HOT NUMBER - SEE TABLE 4.) WELDING PROCESS - SEE TABLE 5.) POST WELD HEAT TREATMENT UNIT #3 AND #4 1100 TO 1150*F - 48 HRS. (B&W WELD QUAL. TESTS) l 1100 TO 1150*F 1/4 HRS. (INTER TO LOWER SHELL WELD) 1125'F 1/4 HRS. (SURVEILLANCE KELD) i 0

7 i; _ _ _ - _ _ __. - - - - _ _ _ _ - _ _ - - _ _ _ - _ - _ _ _

s 9 '

% N. ,

27.

3 y

t

!a. .

u - ,

d .-, 6.-): CHEMICAL COMPOSITION.~- SEE TABLE; av y.

7.) DROPWEIGHT:--NOT PERFORMED:

E  : 5.) A&B.)1 INFORMATION ON WELD MATERIAL INCLUDED-IN THE VESSEL MATERIAL SURVEILLANCE PROGRAM - SEE TABLE; ,

9 4

I. ,

[.  ;

4 h

i

-1 i

i I _

'i. 1

., i i

1 1

l

'i 1

9 5

l u

j .:. ,

i e

i

'q i

-.4 .

+

4

-A .- _ _ _ __ _ . . _ _ _ . - . _ _ . _ . _ . . - - . _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ - _ . - - - . - - _ . - _ _ -

a

U 1 5 - - - 2 1 7 C 2 2 - - - 0 2 1 0 6 9 8 8 5 6 6 4 M 3 3 4 4 6 6 3 5 I 7 4 0 4 5 6 7 0 N 5 6 9 0 8 7 5 5 1

R 7 6 1 3 2 2 7 6 C 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 i 2 2 4 3 2 2 2 7 S 5 4 3 2 2 2 5 4 3 s r

4 5 4 0 9 5 4 3 i o S 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 a p

N . 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 e

0 T

I r-N r U o f

T 1 8 0 0 8 9 1 5 N ~ P 2 1 1 1 0 0 2 1 d l '

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 e o 0 s u

P Y e E r K a R 8 2 3 6 6 2 8 4 U N 2 5 7 6 7 8 2 2 l T .H a 1 1 1 1 t

, e s

s m l

. a 7 8 4 4 4 5 7 8 u n

C 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 a

m e

r a

5 7 1 D 9 8 2 9 s L 2 2 1 4 D r

, E , 5 D .C C L , e

) W ) D 9 6 8 E ) h 9 2 3 8 8 7 W 9 t 4 L 4 8 4 D ,

)

o 2 L 4 . . . L 2 L 1 5 E 29 . o o o L 15 E 7 l 74 H 77 o N N N E 74 W 5 l 4 S 5 N H 4 24 A 8 . 8 t t t S 8 N 88 o . o t a a a o A 7 -

T N . R N . a e e e R N . M 1 .

N o E o e H H H E o H 6o. d E tN T tN H W tN C N l M a N a e e e O a T . e D et I et e r r r L et U ot W L Ho Ho r i i i Ho D No E L O L i W W W O L L c W e T e W T e O t r rx rx G G G rx T ax A E i u L i u G L i u eu C Wl L Wl 5 5 5 L Wl L Hl d N F E F 5 1 1 1 E F L F g

e A e H e 1 0 0 0 H e E e r L g0 S g0 0 8 8 8 S g0 H r0 L a8 a8 8 E E E a8 S i8 e I P E P E . P W m E e L e " " " R e R e b V d Z " d " 2 6 6 E " d E " d u R "8 n Z 8n 8 3 1 1 T N

8n

/i W

O 8n

/i S

U /i 0 /i f / 5/ /

S 1 L N 1L I 3 3 I 1L L 1L

_ 1 -

C 2 2 2 - 2 - 1 -

O 9 0 1 8 6 1 4 7 M 4 4 4 4 3 5 5 5

,. . ,i

~

I 5 6 7 4 7 9 0 4 N 5 '4 5 0 5 7 5 9 1

R 6 - 2 3 7 4 6 -

C 1 - 0 0 1 0 0 -

i 1 8 4 3 2 1 7 6 S 5 4 5 2 5 3 4 2 4

O 6 1 7 0 4 - 3 5 N S 1 1 1 2 1 - 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 - 0 0 T

I N

U T 4 4 0 - 5 8 N -

0 1 2 0 I P 2 1 1 1 - 1 O 0 0 0 0 0 - 0 0 P

Y E

K R 5 8 7 4 0 U 2 0 9 T N 4 6 4 6 2 6 2 7 M 1 1 1 1 1

4 7 7 6 4 7 8 8 6 C 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

, , 5 0 D ) )

8 8 L 5 2 2 D_ 1

, E 0 4 L , C 7 0 E ) 8 2

) W 1 4 9 9 2 2 8 W 9 7 1

4

^

L 7 7 4 D C 2 L . L 2 . L ) 6 1 7 E . 9 . 9 o L 1 5 o E 7 8 75 H o6 O6 N E 74 N W 5 4 S N6 N6 H 4 24 .

8 8 8 t S 8 t N 88 o o . t t a o a A 7 N T N . R a . a . e R N . e M 1 .

N . o E eo eo H E o H H 6o t E tN T HN HN W tN C N a M a N e O a e T . e D et I et et r L et r U ot H L Ho ro ro i Ho i D No E L O iL iL W O L W L e W e T W W T e O t r rx -

x x G rx G T ax i E i u L Cu Cu L i u eu W C Wl L 8l &l 5 L Wl 5 L Hl N F E CF CF 1 E F 1 L F 5 A e H 0 H e 0 E e 1 L g0 S . 0 . 0 8 S g0 8 H r0 0 L a8 m8 m8 E a8 E S i8 8 I P . E A A . P W E E e L e e " R e " R e E

V " d Z d " d 2 E " d 2 " d R 8n Z "8 n 8n 3

/

T N

8n

/i 3

/

W O

8n

/i "8

/

U /i 0 /i /i S 1 L N 1 L 1 L 5 I 1L 5 L 1 L 1 l'

7 7,7 m --

c L) R 14 E. N . s OT,- f 6 C.TO A ~- E S S C L$' ..

of"1 x

, r

.-r p u:

( ~

m L

( -

• huarr e-2

• . ant goz2.LC SHCu ro [MrcR. bCLL k)EL D J

I I

..( '

lrJTE R. bH C L $, Tb lou) Cit $&LLL CL D G

en t

4 Lowt.,t Lc L L ro Dure. Hee >J' cLO 9

k O

M t .

.zi___--- - - _ _ _ . - -

, _ . _ _ . - - - - - , - - - ~ - - - - -

--v-~~--

[

.r.r.Y' t V;-Q: -d :e.,  :

y it

- . 1 , . >.!

(.",' , '.

i

-I i- J ;-

[~.[

_ +:

,.!<s, ,! t <,

\ .

-4 '

r s_ -

l ,

t 5

>j..

I 1

'6 i

T Ir.-

h 1-i1 1

f. 'i ;

i 4

l I

i i

l I

1

.I a

2 I

e 1

'. ',( J. I k -J J

1 s

f

,,.' '}lA , --- _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _

_ -----. - . _ _ _ b i