ML20246L610
| ML20246L610 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Ginna  |
| Issue date: | 08/15/1989 |
| From: | Mecredy R ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORP. |
| To: | Gallo R NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I) |
| References | |
| RTR-NUREG-1021 NUDOCS 8909070006 | |
| Download: ML20246L610 (3) | |
Text
-. -_
.3 j.'.
m-7 3Dkt f
f' cj C '
m,,
ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION e 89 EAST AVENUE, ROCHESTER, N.Y. 14649-0001 m.wll O U 2,oo L
August 15, 1989 Mr. Robert Gallo l
Operation Branch Chief U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commicsion Region I 475 Allendale Road King of Prussia, PA 19406
Subject:
Operator Requalification Examinations R.E. Ginna Nuclear Power Plant Docket No. 50-244
Dear Mr. Gallo:
As requested during our telephone conversation of July 21, 1989, attached you vill find a comparison of RG&E's Ginnt. Requalification Program Evaluation results to the requirements of NUREG 1021 (ES-601).
RG&E's Requalification Program Evaluation was found to be in compliance with all ES-601 requirements except section C.3.b. (1) (b).
Failure of 50% of the Licensed Operators to successfully complete all sections of the examination exceeds the allowed 25% needed for a satisfactory program evaluation.
As a result of this one exception, the Ginna Requalification Program is designated as
" Unsatisfactory".
As specified in RG&E's correspondence to you dated July 24,
- 1989, RG&E is undertaking certain program enhancements to assure a satisfactory evaluation during the next scheduled Program Evaluation.
Very truly yours, ubtl h
Robert C, Meeredy General Manager Nuclear Production 6E: B PZ ST 69.
Att:
P.
Bissett, Chief Examiner
} Fd l0 8909070006 890815
/
FDR ADOCK 05000244
/do J V
/I
g.
[
ATTACHMENT ES-601 PROGRAM EVALUATION CRITERIA SECTION REQUIREMENT RESULT Program Evaluation - General C.3.b. (1) (a) 90% pass / fail decisions agreement between 100% agreement NRC and facility-grading of the written and operating examinations.
C. 3.b (1) (b)
At least 75% of all operators pass the examination; not including individuals selected who had previously passed the l
examination.
50%
C. 3.b (1) (c)
The program is judged satisfactorily in accordance with the guidance given for the simulator evaluation.
UNSAT C.3.b. (1) (d)
The program meets the requirements of 10CFR55. 59 (c) (2), (3) and (4), or is l
based on systems approach to training.
SAT C.3.b. (2) (a)
The same common JPM is missed by at least 50% of the examinees.
N/A C.3.b. (2) (b)
The same question about the same common is missed by at least 50% of the examinees.
N/A C.3.b. (2) (c)
The facility failed to train and evaluate operators in all positions permitted by their individual licenses.
N/A C.3.b. (2) (d)
Failure to train operators for "in plant" JPM's.
N/A C.3.b. (2) (e)
Less than 75% of the examinees correctly answer 80% of the common JPM questions.
N/A C.3.b. (2) (f)
More than one facility evaluator is determined to be unsatisfactory per the " Evaluation of Facility Evaluators".
N/A
___________-_______a
=.
-SECTION REQUIREMENT RESULT Program Evaluation - Simulator D.l.C. (2) (c)
- 1. A program may be judged UNSATISFACTORY if the NRC judges at least one crew UNSATISFACTORY and the facility evaluators judge the same crew SATISFACTORY.
N/A
- 2. A program may be judged UNSATISFACTORY if there is less than 90% agreement between the NRC and the facility one the individual pass / fail determinations with the facility evaluating fewer individuals UNSATISFACTORY.
N/A 3.
If the facility evaluators juige crew performance UNSATISFACTORY and the NRC does not, remedial training is indicated but the program will not be penalized for holding a higher standard of operator performance.
N/A
- 4. If more than 1/3 of the crews are determined to be UNSATISFACTORY by the NRC regardless of individual failure, the overall program shall be judged UNSATISFACTORY.
U/A I
Program Evaluation - Walkthrough D.2.C. (2) (b)
- 1. 90% pass / fail decision agreement between the NRC and facility grading of the walk-through examinations.
100%
- 2. At least 75% of all operators pass i
the walkthrough examination.
92%
D.3.C. (2) (b) o 90% pass / fail decisions agreement between NRC and facility grading, and, 100%
o At least 75% of all operators pass the examination.
9/11 = 81.8%*
l
- One individual scheduled to take initial exam on 8/10/89
{
l l
i i
t l
)
L-_-___
-