ML20245G603

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Denies 890717 Appeals of NRC Denial of Portions of Records Identified on App G,H,J & K.Documents Continue to Be Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 7).Response Is Final Agency Action on Appeals
ML20245G603
Person / Time
Issue date: 08/09/1989
From: Malsch M
NRC OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL (OIG)
To: Bauman L
GARDE, B.P.
References
FOIA-87-535, FOIA-89-A-23, FOIA-89-A-24 NUDOCS 8908160115
Download: ML20245G603 (1)
v • d • e


Text

,

k

@ tscu

' UNITED STATES pg

. [g g

NUCLEAR REGUI.ATORY COMMISSION l

g

p WASHINGTON D.C. 20555

\\,..

/

AUG 0 91989 OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL Ms.' Linda Bauman F0IA Coordinator Law Offices of Billie Pirner Garde 104 East Wisconsin Avenue Appleton, Wisconsin 54911-4897 Re: F0IA Appeals 89-A-23 IG and 89-A-24 IG

Dear Ms. Bauman:

This letter responds to your July 17, 1989 appeals of the Nuclear Regulatory Comission's denial of portions of the records identified on Appendices G, H.

J and K of our June 9 and 29 responses to F01A-87-535.

In response to your appeal, the documents were re-reviewed. On the basis of this review, I affirm the Commission's initial decision.

The documents described in Appendix G were withheld under Exemption 7A of the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 6 552(b)(7)(A) and 10 C.F.R. 6 9.17(a)(7)(1) of the Commission's regulations. The withheld information consists of investigatory records compiled for law enforcement purposes.

Dis-closure could reveal the scope, direction and focus of enforcement efforts, and could act to shield potential wrongdoing or violation of NRC requirements from investigations.

The information withheld from the documents described in Appendices I, J, and K has been withheld under Exemption 70, 5 U.S.C. % 552(b)(7)(D) and 10 C.F.R. 6 9.17(a)(7)(iv). The withheld information consists of names of individuals and other information the disclosure of which could reasonably be expected to reveal identities of confidential sources.

This letter represents final agency action on the above-captioned administra-tive appeals. Judicial review of the denial of documents or portions of docu-ments withheld is available in the Federal District Court in the district in which you reside or have your principal place of business, or in the Federal District Court of the District of Columbia.

1 Sincerely, 1

' 1 / __

/;(

l t

Martin G. Malsch Inspector General (Acting)

Office of the Inspector General 8908160115 890B09 PDR FOIA BAUMAN89-A-23 PDR

IWM_. (k - f /- y 7).7

,,e,%

ettsPowst tvet ig rid e==

i RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF

' ~at i

T'

+

i INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST DUN - 9 1999 A.ee..

.puc.ii ~u e s.,,,.

.o,

n At Out bi t R h

- hYh$W PART t.- AGINCY RECORDS Ritt ASED OR NOT LOCAlfD See checacd boness No egency records subsect to the re4uest have beta located No addatenet egency records sub,ect to the request have been aocated it Requested escords ave asanlabae twough another pubhc distrebut.on program See Commeats Sect.cc

. _ a'e aaready ava fab 6e for pubhc inspect,on and copying in -

Agency recoeds subtect to the 'eQuest that 8 'd'08' feed on Apoendistest 2120 L St'est. N W. Washengton DC 20555 NRC Pubhc Document Room are te.ng made avadable for pubhc mspecten and copyng m

  • Agency records subsect to the request that are edentdied on Appendmest NRC Pubhc Document Room, 2120 L Street. N W.. Washenpton. OC e a tolder under this FOIA number and reovester name The nonproprieta y vers.on of the proposatis) that you agreed to,cu tt m a telephone con ersateoe evth a member of vny staff is now bemg made ava u dee thm rOIA numbe' and reowester name inspecten and copying et the NRC Pubhc Document Room 2120 t it-st. N W, Washington. OC. e a ' older n

may be espected and cop.ed at the NRC Local Pubbe Document Roore. dent.'

Agency records subject to the teovest that are ident4fied on Append +esi en the Comments Section.

may obtain access to and the charges fo* copymg reco<ds placed e the NRC Pubhc Document ctoom. 2120 L St'eet NA Enclosed is informaten on ho* vou Weshengton DC.

Agency reco*ds sub ect to the 'eQuest a'e enclosed t

Records sutyect to the eeQuest have been refened te anothes Federal agencyl.es) for ee==e* and direct 'cspo8'se to you You wait be billed by the NRC for fees totahng 4

. No In view of NRC's response to tNs secuest. no fue1het acten is beeg f asen on appeal letter dated PART li. A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC OfSCLOSURE Certam eformai.on e the readsted eco'es s bemg **thhee hom pubhc d sclosv e pues ant to tv e.empi.ons described on and for the.easons stat e

sections 8. C. and D Any re. cased portions of the documents foe *Nch oniv part of the rec ond es te ns *@^e d a'e being made awa lab'e for p bic espect copVmg 'n the NRC Pubhc Doc., ment Room. 2120 L Street. N W. Wash.ngton. DC in a to+ der.,nce n

.COMMINTS l

51 ATURE, DIRECTOR IVISION OF F EDOM OF INFORMA1lON AND PUBUCADONS SERylCES l

AMA 44-44 l

I

' i A L O V M UF if.TU:U.Dillva w'm'm

~

PAR [5 b APPUC 5(( EXEMPTi6fiS~

~~ ~~

~

']g]}

~

~

.D e'e be ag withheld in their entetr Or en parl u e the n

Records subiect to the eeouc5f that 8'c desc'* bed on the encfosed Append > lest E semptions and for the reasons set forth belo* Ns,ani lo 5 U S C 552ibi ano 10 Cf R 917 a 9 N8tC Regs abons t

The withheld information is p8opesty Classified pu's., ant to t aec uove Orde' t( s t MPtiON 16 1

The w.thhe6d enfoemanon eetates solely to the inte"a Pe'so"'e' 'u'es and D'o(eds'es of NAC it a(MPTiON 2i 2

'( x(MPTiON >

3 The withheld information is specoscaHv esems'ed V put94 disclosw e by statute encic ated e

f Resind*H Date or F me'. Les octre Ca?. a2 U S C 21612 t(,5 J

SeCisons 141 145 of the Atomic [ne'gv ACI **sc* D'oht/s the d sClosu'e C Section 147 of the Atomac Energy Act *hich pechsb.ts the tsclosure of Unc'essd.ed Safeguards inf o-at.on i42 U S C 2167t

~

I[X[MPflQN a, The wethheld efo<mation is a trade sec'et o' comr*e'c d' o' hnancial informatiori that s beirig *.thheid for me reasonist ir*dtated 4

The mformation is considered to be confident a' Dvs' ness 'D'opheta<v 6 otormat.on j

i The information es considered to be peopnetarv informator pursuant to 10 CFR 2 790idu ti i

The mformation was submitted and reca'wed in coefdence pursuant to 10 CFR 2 790<dif 2 6 The withheid mformation consists of *cie' agency o' #f' adde ^C t ee :o'ds that see ect 3,adable th'ovgh discobe*e 7. ng t>t,gation 't AIMPTiON Si Appi. cable Peivaege

~

'~

Dehberative Pror.ess Disclosvee of predecisioca eto<-afsoe would tend to inhibit the open and fraek es;* age of ideais ess.?nt ai to the debbef auve pec;ess Where secords are withheld m their entirely the ' acts s'e are stoc ably intertemed with the predecas. ora cP a1.on Thes t ago are no reasonahav segregab e 'E!A rnds'ect anQvs'y ento IP e D *Jec's peal proc ess :.' t*.e agenc y portions becavse the release of the f acts wowid pe"%t af' A tt orne g wo'k p'oduct Of% dege iDoc uenerts ree:a ** * ** ano nes m coele ' rys ce of r

miano-l Attoene, - c6ent p%Hege CoAcenda ro%ea atICatea er C u 're..sn

  • N s he'.

-n' w as.ca e' pe< soc.a. pn.ac, E x(Mp'ioh (

6. The withheid information is esemoted f'om pwthe o s c s.'e Dec asse es a sciosses *ouid resti se a clear'v,, a t'anee m i( Af MPTiON 7i
7. The withheld intoemation corisists of <ecords corr p es f o* 'a a enicacernent ov'ocses anc s be ng ad"e : ':< t%e reason s ind.cated er'O*c e n 'M 1" *( tt d rg ; ec a,,ge g o, g.' e s I* e E *,@e l'e c bc e and 'oCws of en Disclosu'e could seasocao% !se espe;ted to i"?e 'e e A ** A-e

' fo# cement efforts and t$vs cou'd poss% alloa "e* N 1a*e ac boe. Ae'd 90'e " J A'!.Nduou t' 4. : 9'

.* NoC ecos ter eng 's yn en.cg,g3tn.g e

E xifuPTION 1 i A e.

Desclosure

  • ovid const tute an w warranted ie as.on o' pe*sonal pr.w acy it a(MPflCN 7tC D e

v The.tf o,manon c asists of cames of mowic a s aN: ;"r do"*at or 1%=' 1 sc us't 9 * *.c" c c.cc e ss :

  • at. De e s c-Mec ic e.e s' cert +es ci confident.a sov c es :f.n E MPTiON 7 <D'-

~

e Othe' PART n. C-DENYlNG OFFICIALS ac.com.ned ter :Se ntoer. at.oe..irhe c,s e se :

Pw swant to 10 CFR 9 25'b' anc or 9 25 sci of the U 5 %.: ea Re9eato's Comm'sw *ess anons it *as e

ve hom production or d sclosure and that ts prodschor c' : 5: c.s,*e s :onturn te the evenc eteas' The c,e se e 4i.

s o<e 'o t e sen.a a<e ose o.c a s ideat # -

' mSemabce anc P be anc s 5 %.c es 0" ;, : 4:- mst at e-2-c Rese.... va age, rent 'e r below as denysg off.cea s and t e Deector Divis>on o' 8 ee:oe u

h den.ais that may be appea:ed to t%e (secstive D ecto' " C:( anoas f X Titif OFFICE R[GeOS DENitD A PPE L L A T E OF F iC a.

DENYING OFFICIAL

~

  • G
  • ~~

I SE C84t T AAv af M w&fw]_wtay Sred

,F 'l - u X^

~

7 ALb Aby

- hbh $

^^ V b

hMAn wpA p

&ss x

PART u. D-APPEAL PIGHTS The den.at by each denying official identif.ed in Part 18 C may be appealed to the Appettate Off nal ident.fied m that sect.on Any su6 appeat must be m writeg and must be enade with n 30 days of ceceipt of this response. Appeats must be addressed as appropnate to die (nacutive Duetto< fot Oper at.on erto the Secretary of U S. Nucleer Regulatory Commession. Washington. DC 20555 rid should ciearty state on the emelope and in the tener that n es an Appeal from an initial f Of A occis.on -

emc Foam sea (Part 28 U S. NUCLEAR REGULATOR COMMISetON FOIA RESPONSE CONTiffUATION MM &x gM d

_ _ _ - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ _ _ _ _ _ _.. _ _ _ _. _ _ _ _. _,___.,_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Re: F01A-87-535' APPENDIX E RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE PDR UllDER THE AB0VE REQUEST NUMBER NUMBER ~

DATE DESCRIPT10N 1 86-6 MemotoNoonanfromPoslusny(1page) 1.

6/21/85 subject: Alleger feedback.

2.

9/30/85 Comanche Peak Unit 1 Containment Rock Overbreak/0verexcavation Seismic Evaluation..(20pages) 3.

10/11/85

. Memo for Connelly from Noonan, subject: Review of-Case Information.

(1 page)

-4.

. 8/14/85 Memo. for Mulley from Grimes, subject: 01A Report Inq 86-6.

(2 pages) 5.

8/20/87 Memo for Nulley from Grimes, subject: Inq 86-6 Followup.

(1 page) 6.

9/14/87 Ltr to Juanita Ellis from Grimes, subject: Case Letter Dated July 31, 1985.

(2 pages) i I

_-__________m..___m__

...m__

Re: F01A-87-535 1

APPENDIX F l

J RECORDS PARTIALLY WITHHELD l

NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION AND EXEMPTION I 86-6 1.

Undated Domestic Return Receipt. (1 page)

Ex. 6 2.

8/30/84 Letter to (deleted) from Ippolito.

(1 page) Ex. 6 3.

10/29/84 Telephone Conversation Record.

(1 page) Ex. 6 4

1/28/85 Letter to (deleted) from Noonan.

(1 page) Ex. 6 5.

2/5/85 Domestic Return Receipt. (1 page)

Ex. 6 6.

5/7/85 Letter to (Deleted) from Noonan.

(1 page) Ex. 6 7.

5/9/85 Letter to (Deleted) from Vincent 5. Noonan.

(1 page)

Ex. 6 8.

5/14/85 Domestic Return Receipt. (1 page)

Ex. 6 I 85-11_

9.

2/21/85 Memo for Chairman and Commissioners Waterford 3 from Connelly,(subject:

Allegations.

1 page) Ex. 5 10.

2/28/85 Memo for Ccnnelly from Chilk, subject: Review of Closed Commission Meeting Transcript.

(1 page) Ex. 5 11.

3/7/85 Memo For The Record, from Chilk, subject: Staff Requirements - Discussion of Pending Investigation, 10:00 a.m.,

Tuesday, february 26, 1985, Connissioners' Conference Room, D.C. Office (Closed--Ex. 5 and 7)

(Part 1 - 01 and EDO Staff).

(1 page)

Ex. 5

Re:

F01A-87-535 APPENDIX G RECORDS 7 0 TALLY WITHHELD NUMBER DESCRIPTION AND EXEMPTION 1.

OIA Report 87 EX. 7A 2.

DIA Report 87 EX. 7A 3.

DIA Report 87 EX. 7A 4,

01A Report 187 EX. 7A 5.

OlA Report 186 EX. 7A

s

,....u..

........,,n!.,..l2 C

)

, _ T., *. ;

6r...Li...

v j

  • c:. L:.ac : a twc:a. N ':.!,5sc 2:~:2
a..

pe- ;; 2;30y (202) 232 O'.su I41'?.!EJ7 OP.?!Ci;

)

104 1.. 31hC;; 01N W.'ENUE 1

A PI L D.

i, tvISCoaSIN 54911-4897 August 12, 1987 fMDOM Of INFORMATION F.EE20!rOF INFORMATION JCT REQUEST Di'rectcr

/

~

Offico cf Admir.istration

,k Y U.S.

Nuclear Ragulatory Commission Washington, D.C.

20210 I

70 h'!!O!' :T XAY CONCERN

. Pursuant to'the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA, 5 U.S.C.

552,) the Gover. ment Accountability Project (GAP) requests copies of any and all ager.cy records ar.6 information, including but not limited to notes, l

letters, memoranda, drafts, minutes, diaries, logs, calenders, tapes, t ra r.s cr ipt s, summaries, interview reports, procedures, instructions, engineering analysos, drawings, fjles, graphs, charts, maps, photographs, a g r s. e:.c a t s, handwritten notes, studies, data sheets, notebooks, books, tcicphene m;tssages, computations, voice recordings, computer runoffs, and any.ther data ccmp.ilations, interin. and/or final reports, status reports, a..6 any ar.d all other records relevant to and or generated in connection with all NRC decisions and consideration of the Region IV problems including the rocent considerations of problems in the OIA report 86-10 and subsequent overview inspections.

This reques includes all agency records as defined in 10 C.F.R. 9.3a(b) and the NRC r.anual, Appendix 0211, Parts 1.A.2 and A.3 (approved October 8, 1980) whether they currently exist in the NRC of fical, " working" investigative er other files, or at any other location, including private

  • residences.

If any records as defined in 10 C.F.R. 9.3a(b)'and the NRC Manual, supra, and covered by this request have been destroyed and/or removed af ter this reqces, please provide all surrounding records, including but not-limited to a list of all records which have been or are destroyed and/or recoved, a description of the action (s) taken relevant to, generated in conn-ection with and/or issued in order co implement the action (s).

i

d, twea.; - "'indjng t !. -- info n,.ition

.i n

/s e 3...,... ;.-

e n. :;. C q"n<> t a f ; i;! '. :,

f i

.f l i n <.: ? m ir

c. n. ' < b.

2.}

cj -

>.i.'
.;

,3 ),

m.:' i n r.

u n ; a t.

it,

n-partisan ;- *;ie i nt ece ;t o r ti.:. t.., - e t; ; o.

cr:.c r a ~

'o; 'n!

,nd <

"n unvet:..ea'.

Thi nngh pu b l i. i:

O n t : i: t :-h,

.c F,;,' <. r

  • r r. - ^ :.

h: : '"N ur+rs os o.2 nts of <:overnment j

ccccuntib. I r,,,

. :c 4 it

..v i : < r

. t ri ; ' 'h i s t l e t J o,. c r C l i n i c, GAP offers l

rssis;.: nee to leer.1 pab}ic.interv. and citizonn groups and interveners in the ccncorn f er safety at nucle <2 r p o..'e r p l a n t. s.

We are requesting this information as part of on ongoing monitoring project of the NBC's ef f orts to protect..public health and saf ety at and near nuclet.r processing plants and radioactive waste facilities.

For any documents or portions that you deny due to a specific FOIA e:< emp t i on, please, orc'de an index itemizinq and describing the docutnents The index should provide a detailed or pertions of dec.:nnts a thheld.

justification of foJr grou:'ds f or claiming each eyemption, explaining why each ex2mption is relevant.to the document or portion of the document Rosen (I), 404 F.2d 020 in:Jcx 15,je:'c;u i red unde r V_aughn v.

re withheld.

This ied, 415 U.S: 977 (1974).

(D.C. Cir. 1973),

cert.. i.

We lock forwcrd to ycur response to this request within ten (10) working' days.

Si ncerely,

M!)

Linda Bauman TOIA Coordinator

.Ilidwest Office

% s p o.u c t o this recuest should be n:niled bo the Midwest Office:

I r, f,. 'r:isconsi:. Avenue -B hppleotn,- Wisconsin o4911-4897

~

l, I

l I

l l

1 l

i l

e 1

j I

m._________.______

J

_,t,,

'['

x]

RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF jw JX a t.a.

s

^

lNFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST 3 g g 1999 j

fj' Docati =v staisi neam,s.,

u 4

m outstos

~h/d h bsYtW M d 8 a

PART 4.- AGENCY RECOHDS RELEASED OR NOT LOCATED (See checaect bones)

No egoincy records subrect to the feQuest have been located.

No addstCnal agency feCords subpect to ths request have been located See Comments Section Roguested records e<e available through anothat put,lec distr @ution progsam Agency *eCo'ds subWct to the request that 4*e edentified on Append siesi 3,, pg,eady avadable for publ*c especten and con *; e t*

NRC em Document Room. 2021 L Street. N W.. Washington. OC 20555 M

Agence eceos subject to t*ie reavest that are adentified on Appendin es.

are being made avadable for public insecten and cop, g <n to e

2021 L Street. N W. Washington. DC. en a fo de, under thes FOiA number and eeoueste, name n

NHC PW Document Room The nonproprietary versson of the proposalisi that You agreed to accept an a telephone conversation with a member of my staff 4 no* being *Made available 'c Abs..

inspecten and copying at the NRC Pubisc Document Room 2021 L Street. N W. Washington. DC. en a folde* under this FOtA number and ' roaster name Agenc, +ecords sub,ect to the request that are.dentified on Aopend m.es may be enspected and ecosec at the NRC Lccal Public Document Roore wpr n the Comments Secison.

Encios.c is eformation on how you may obtem access to and the cha*ges for copying records placed m the NRC Puboc Document Room 2G. Speet N/

Washaston DC Agenci records subsect to the request a<e enci ssed g[

[

Records subject to the reavest have been eef e<<ed to another Federal agencyrest fos review and dieect response to you 1ou ed be billed by the NRC for fees totahng 8 in view of NRC's response to the request. no furthes acteon is being tc' :* on appeal lettet dated Ne PART II. A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PUBUC DISCLOSURE Ce<taen efo, mat.on e the reovested records is being *.ihbeid f<om public d'sclosu'e ou suant to the e nempens oescribed,n and ice the eas:-s stated in er sectens B C and D An, re. eased portens of the docuanents for wh.ch ont, oari o' the record is be,ng notacid are be.ng made avasiaose to wo..; insoec.

a-c copyeg c the NRC Pubhc Document Room. 2021 L Street. N W, Washegton. DC m a fewer unce th.s 8 0 A numbe' and f eQuester name COMMENTS fb

  • f f f r-- Ma 2G de ned Ad~

? " * " R *.:m _A p.c L / a A M a A"'

g,s pf Q

4-

/

a,try A A=r

,jl nJendM*

1 SIGNATUME. O TO. DiviSi FF EEDOM OF INF ATION AND PUBUCATIONS SERVICES b L4,w=

-Y y'

/

/

M 7[ @ P~hf6 l

1

- - _ _ ~ _ _ _ _ _. _. _ _ _ _. _ _ _ _., _. _ _ _. _. _ _

R cceds subget to the reoucsf that ere disefibsd on the enclostd Appsnoistrel hjd[are beirig withhMd m their entirety Egmptions and ter thz seasons ces forth below pwevent to 5 U S C. 552tbl and 10 CFR 917(e) of NRC R3gulatione.

g / The,,thbeid informet*on as prop *'fV Cl388ed purewent 13 (secutive O< der itxtMPTION 11 to the etemet personnel rules and procedu es of NRC. f(XEMPTION 21 r'

2. The withheid eformeten r*:elee solefY r
3. (be withhow eiermeten e asocifically esempted from pubhc disenesuee by statute ed.cated MXEMPitON &

Sections 1411a5 of the atomic Ene'gv Art which prohibits the ersciosu e of Resteetted Deva or Formeriv Rest' acted Date 442 U $ C 216121656 1

m the Atormc Ene'ev Act *Nc*. proh+ta the disclosure of Unctessif.ed Safeguerde information s42 U S C 2167 1

Section 147 of

4. The withheid eformaten.e e neede secret or cv. 4:cial or feenciet info mation that.a beme withheid for the euontal and.cated. itztMPrtON 4 The information se cone.dered to be conf d*nt'et busmei,e (proorietaryl eforrneten.

The informaten is cone.dered to be propnote'y informaten puesvant to 10 CFR 2 790tdHil.

The mformaten was oubrmited and received in confedence pursuont to 10 CFR 2.790tdH21 8.. The wethheid informaten consets of eteragency or antesapency escords that are not evadsbie through discomery dunne ktigation d*EMPTION 51 Appiecable Pnvilege Deliberative Process D sclosure of p'ettecisional eformaten would tend to mNbit the open and frank eschenge of ideas essentisi to the delib7stwo o<oces Where records sie withheid e their entirety, the f acts are saasincaDiv intertweed with the peedoc.sional mformation There aiso are tvi reasonsbty segregetae 'ect a port.one because the eeteses of the facts would permet en anderact mowww mio the p<edecesonal peocess of tne ag*new Attorney work p<oduct pr vdege (Documents p<epe'ed by an attome, in contemptat.on of ht.gaten i Attorney-chent pt.wwege # Confidential commun. cations between en af former and h's her Cbent I

$, The withheld information 41 esempted fforn pubhc disclosure teCasse rts d'sclos#8

  • ovid 'esult in e cleotiv w *8' ranted mvesson of personet pnvecy (ExtMPTION 6 n

7, The wtthhelo information Cons sts of records compiled for 18* enforcement purposes and 6 being withheli,58 the eessonts) mdecated. IExtMPTION 71 Desclosure could reasonaDPt be empeCW d to *ieffe's with an enlo' cement pvoceedmg becawse it cowld veves: the scope, directen and focus of en' fortoment eHorts. and in s could poss@v allow them to take act.on to sh ead potent.a' *#ongdoing or a vio2 tion of NRC *egwirements from evestigators 4

u (XEMPTION 7 (AH D.ectosure would constitute en unwerrented evasion of personal pnvecy (EXEMPTION 7tC))

The efo,mation cons.sts of nemos of moiv dvals eno other informat<en the disclosure of wh ch could reasonabt, be enoected to reves!.dentites of conhdent'*t poweges dx(MPTION 7 (DH OTHLs4 PART N. C-DENYING OFFICIALS Puesvent to 10 CFR 9 25tb> end or 9 25 tcl of the U S. Nuclear Reguistory Comm,nion regulei.ons. it has teen determ.ned that the informaten wnhheid,s ese-.ot The persor's esponsible foe the denial are those otheieis. dent ec 8

from prodwetion or disclosure arwt that its production or d'sclosw'e 's contrary to the pubi.c eterest below as denyme officiais and tne Drector. Div sen of Freedom of Informat on and Pwbiscetions Serv cos Othee of Admeistration and Resowices Vanagerr.ent f oe e%

den.als that may be appered to t%e taecut<ve Daector fo' Ope <Gtens 4001 TITLE /OFFICI RECOROS DENI(D APPELLATE OF FfCtAL '

DENYING OFFICIAL SECRETARY' JG EDO

? N d f t h s,ai %

WPY bM ffM%Y b

X

/

MK v

i i

I PART N. D-APPEAL R;OHTS The denist by each denying off.c.af identif.ed in Port it C mey to appented to the Appettate Offacist idenuf.ed m that wction. Any such appesi must be in wr#tmo and anuse be mode withen 30 dero of rece.pt of this veeponse. Appeels must be addeossed es appropriate to the EsecutNo Director for Operationpto the Secretary of the Co nmesen s U.s. Nuci.e, n.,uietory comm.nen. wahension, DC 2os5s. and.wid ciearfy etsie on the.nvuope.nd in the ierter that n i. en Appear f,om en in,ii. FOiA Dece.w U.S. NUCLEAR REGUt.ATORY COMWS40 unc PORu 444 (Port 21 I" **'

FOIA RESPONSE CONTINUATION

  • A N g 2G; 4 % %

Re:.f01 -

Tf7*77 -- -

APPENDIX [

RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE POR UNDER THE ABOVE REQUEST NUMBER NUMBERJ DATE DESCRIPTION f W U' p/f/tA M.rne.7.2 d &>n j,

~

,p,9 vs s:/

w Wr.&&

J a ~.+ -

E/W M/r/ff

%d 2 A.A

- he z.

// 71 -

4.'/.Apro;rae j W X -446 4 -

secuna

//mA

/ 5 l/p

T)h3[

Re:

FOIA--

APPENDIX [

RECORDS. PARTIALLY W1THHELD

NUMBER, DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION 91-29

/..

///f/Ts' W

'0$k m 4 :--e BX. W 3 side-

&&"+

M.A Oppy

~

2

57. 29 S

h--u__._.--___.._.__..__._

.__..___._.__m._

I7' 5I

.Re:

FotA-APPENDIX RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELD NUMBER

. DAT E '

DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION

/.

k

<h J

9A4?2) '

tc f &),fx.7.9 Ur y

Re: FOIA-N-[3[

APPENDIX RECORDS ENCLOSED NUMBER ~

DATE DESCRIPTION N

' (f/y '

sr 7D ik1lf?Y

)DA~1-<bvl)n,, pp s

2 A,s cy 3.

trW/8/

w X % %'

d#

fr:JA12e f %

a J d > W( 4 f,. J u-9 n rV /

p J E2. 79 C

__m_._____.__-..__

4 G b.'i ':.:.", w' C ? M C 0 E /. 'il ?/ T!' O H G

':e :..e -

.a /weca N W Svae 202

.- ~.. q.x (202) ?32 0%U

e....,.

l

,m 1

'i411/,il:.3T OP?!Ci; 10.; L.

."IhCONCIN AVENUE

/ PP:/_'; O::, tvISC0;!SIM 54911-4897 August 12, 1987 LPJJDOM OF INFORMATIO!(

F3EErC:: OF INFORMATI'ON ACT P.EQUEST

/gg Y'.

Directcr Office of A b:,nistratz,on U.S. ::uclea r 'Ragulatory Commission Washington, D.C.

20210 70 1 !!OM IT F.AY C' MCERN P.ars.mnt to the zeedom of Information Act (FOIA, 5 U.S.C.

502,) the Gove r.=ent Accountabili' Project (GAP) requests copies of any and all ager.cy records ar.6 inf ormation, including but not limited to notes, lotters, memorando, drafts, minutes, di_ ries, logs, calenders, tapes, t ra r.s cript s, summaries, interview reports, procedures, instructions, engineering analysos, drawings, files, graphs, charts, maps, photographs, agrcenents, handwritten notes, studies, data sheets, notebooks, books, tcic hcr.e messages, computations, vcice recordings, computer runoffs, and any :.ther data compilations, interir. and/cr final reports, status reports, and a:.y s.;d all other records relevant to and or generated in connection with all NRC decisions and consideration of the Region IV problems including the recent considerations of problems in the OIA report 86-10 and subsequent overview inspections.

This reques: includes all agency reccrds as defined in 10 C.F.R. 9.3a(b)

- and the NRC Manual, Appendix 0211, Pa r t s 1. A. 2 a nd A. 3 (approved October 0,1980) whether they currently exist in the NRC offical, " working" investigative or other files, or at any other location, including private residences.

I ~ c.y records as defined in 10 C.F.R. 9.3a(b)'and the NRC Manual, supra, and covered by thi: r6'uest have been destroyed and/or removed after this reqces:, please provide all surrounding records, including but not limi:ed to a list of all records which have been or are de_stroyed and/or removed, a description of the action (s) taken relevant to, generated in conn-ection with and/or issued in order to imp *_ement the action (s).

%J

.";, lv e n a.m.- " " i n:l i n g t;- : n f e m.3 i ion c.i n a

.w ;.. ;.. ;, -

ry. n" n i ;iW';, " ' '. 11.:;.t:

{

i. f~itina i m i. < :. n e. i i i.. - J

.s - :, r.

ie i ni e re.;t
. ).' :.: ii
.; ),

s;;.:' i r.

r wn-;,t.. !i, ne n - p,rt i u r.n

)

org6:.. i t i o.

c :. - r.c ^

i 0;

t ind t"on 00v01n.ea'.

Tnrough pubtic

'hintieb),uors as aaen:s of government.

i o u t r.:.. r:i, r ;w 1rcy:.

N

(

c c cc.;n t a b i it,.

..:0 9h it

.vi,cr.mta: '.'h i s t l e b 3 c e. e r Clinic, GAP offers a s si s t r.nce to 1;ca; p.ib)ic, inter?s and citizenn groups and interveners in the ccr. corn for safety ct nuclet.r power piants.

We are requesting this information as part of an ongoing monitoring project of the NBC's ef forts to protect,public iiealth and saf ety at and near l

f acilities.

nuclecr processing plants and radioactive waste that you deny due to a specific FOIA For any documents or portions exemption, please >rcriae an index itemizing and describing the documents The index should provide a detailed or pcrtions of dec.:.nents wi thheld.

explaining why justificat icn of your grou:-ds f or claiming each exemption, each exemption is relevant..to the document or portion of the document (I), 404 F.2d 020 index 1, required under Vaugl n,v.,Rosen 5

i withheld.

'Th i s (D.C. Cir. 1973), cert. ti e n i ed, 415 U.S: 977 (1974).

i We Ic,ck f orwcrd to jour response to this request within ten (10) working days.

Sincerely; o

W)

Linda Bauman FOIA Coordinator liidwest Office

k s p o.i s c to this recuest shoujd be r.niled to the Midwest Of fice:

". 0 4 E.

isconsi
. Avenue -B Appleotn; Wisconsin 54911-4897 b

e 9

J

- - - - - - - - - - _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20245G603&oldid=3909644"