ML20245B354

Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents.App a Available in Pdr.App B Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 7). Records Also Submitted to Another Federal Agency for Review. No Further Action Will Be Taken on FOIA Appeal 86-A-217

ML20245B354
Person / Time
Site:	Cook
Issue date:	06/05/1987
From:	Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
To:	Bauman L GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT
Shared Package
ML20244B889	List: IA-86-718, Advises That Team Insp Will Be Conducted During Wk of 820412.Region Will Pursue Circumstances Surrounding Statements in Indicating Facility Met Requirements of App R ML20244B886 ML20245B354
References
FOIA-86-718 NUDOCS 8706110257
Download: ML20245B354 (5)

Text

W, .. .. .. . .

,j$. 51987

n. ,y.,,,-..

1. i n. d.. a. B.. a. u, ma n P

. . . -4..... . .

.. . . , . _ .m. . . . . . . . . . . . . - . . .

. .w AR

- . T .I _R f COR.D..S_Rf.'_L E.A 5f D. O.._R N.O..T. LOC A tt o 13,4

. ..go.,. 0. t.w_ ,_s >

so %.x, ..< c.. . o. , so r. %.. ... e now.o 8e sneana, n,m ..w.e. saa, ,o r. .n.,, ,,,, o,,,,. >owea aow, wo.e, u cno r. ..co..m.1.., ,o.-i,- .e aoo. o.. ...r,au ou... .ecau.,.- e.onn..no w ,no- ~ %acro w,coow m.-ia=~

XX fMF M St. w N W Weseing'oa DC Ao,m , w e.s e,u ne ,n, ..a .., r e ... ,a e.* r 4 ,-o..

,, o, .m ,, ~ . . .., en uni.c -.neoor.ro<oc R oo*a 17t ? w St.e,' N W .,.8.. m. sac *,.w.co % -. i W e.m,igioa

.. .- _.._....'.....-_..._4Di . r a +o.de ., ace tw+ 8 0t A arbe, aad ,em,p,. r.y .*

. - . . . - - . . . . -- .. r.

t .,, nos,0c.,,,, . ....ou, r , e..w . . ,. , ,,,. ., a in , ,,.. .,, , . . , % , , m.,,,, w , , ~ . ,..t ., o , -, .,m . ~. o, y -.3 ,, . .w, ,,, n ,,y < +,e, o., -

I

.coto,,.< r. vepau am ,..,=>o- i r i r H si..., s a w.. -,.o.,

at . . . .w. y . ,4o.4 ,.,o.,,no,,a ..... ,-.

I t< >e..o .. .+, ,.- or a o. , o ...., nu,, ,,u ,,, io .,o ~ .. 2,. . . ,eo ,.u,.a u., , . .,.

L -. . . . . . . .

m.w r n .c nom.~,,,, a,,0.- , m - s..

, s w Wus.vo oc l Aa,% m. = u,.n to r. .. w ,,, . <,,m, a , .ncs.e, m, s,, ..., o. ~ ...

+. 6 .... %

4s.. a,.mo . , 4. om.oe,. ... ci,o ,a e, co-, c.n-K x l R .i c. u a n c ~ ..ou,,,, , ,,, e,. ..... . a n . cr,. < ,.o. ... yr, , ,, . u, . ,,,,. eu.. .w . , s . o..

X X ! '" * * *

• C * " " '** "' ' ** ' "'u "'u '** *"' .'or'd", . w,4 Oc t.o b e r 23.1986. .86-A 217 P A R T 11 A.. . J.N#0.R M. Af..l0N ,W_.ITH.HE LO F R.O.M. .P,U B LIC, Of SCLO. . SURF

-X X I ca**." +'me<* - ** .*m.e= .e i o .o **. ,a '.u p .m.< nee to n

'i.o-. e c ari e ... w.,+,,, . v . , o., v.me'.s n .*.W o.., a .. ., ..m 3 .+ e ,o',c3,.eg 4 a.m.bao 'e ne,o m. .noas ste,o en P,1**ei' the NaC P .ohct ,,e oDoco-ent an , .. noo, a m.- 't ? w s,.w % W , e. . . ~ ,,,uo,, o, ps.u.c ,ny.c,,o ,,o c co, eg ,,

w,v. g.ca DC .c a 4,o, ,,nde, th.s 8 04 ., - e+ rd .,x e,t, e,-,

co, , meres .

1 1

.I i

i 1

1 1

9706 O .c - 870605 6 718 PDR MA ,

s, ..s m. m. . . . , . . , ,,

W v =rit n-~x Q _ ._.__. ..

exc roRu ase e.-.

en. .

1

,l

• e b

.R . $> ...q ,, l u- u ,- 4 gp '. -- . . ,,

f,' .

), .?f . w, ,e

, ,, ..o + 1;3 . #,,- . c

m. , ...

i -a .

n v

. y +  :... .

,f '

l )* "

k

.I g .

') '

w g agg.

-. ye .

, . s VRtEDOM OF IMORMATION ACT RESPONSE 1.n A NL YHj u > rm t'86-718 DA't PANT 11 B APPLICABLt potA l $[ MPtiONS uW ' MC Es

' ii VW ~ .j A

'>rds subiett to the reduest that are deu.nbed in the emlosed Atipend<es B ..

Ietmpt.or's and for the reawns set forth below pu'suant to 5 U S C 557bl WW 10 Cf H 9 W (A NRC Regula ionsve t+mg wit *iheld m the

_m . . . , . . _ _ _ . . . . _ . . _ . . _ . . _ . .

, .i th, e

. v*r id m+o,wi.on .s p or ,i, cuss.e.*o pu,%.g., in t . rmt. , onie, ti.M .I

• t w ms t .

_. . . ~ .

_ _ _ . i 2 4e .ithheld mforWierm *e.a'eg sniply to fa l .... -

r ictema' pessor5nel Nies a#5d regr eda s

,% d %H( ( 9 ( W'Ill.h 21

.I 1

l 3 ine tm .rto,wnon soucri, e.,mpieo e.o- pot,k mos... in, ,,cuee in,imea e itvat.oN 3

- _ . . . . _ _ . . _ . . ~ . . ._

j $8CtsDM 141145of the Ato*st (ne'gv Act ehed D,0bstuTS tec $stl96w, of Nf 6t'de'l Da?. e " f ****e*'y Ae%P'('ed Dats $42 U S C 21612165>

j . . . -

. . ~

Secten tat o+ va e Ato. i,c ew.gv Act .a.& mon b.is the ci. wow o' uroanAe1 sa'ege wieat,on '42 U s c 216h 4

{

the methheid information is a v.aoe secret m comeneroat ce financial er,fo mat on that 4 tww o"%.at Nu t*e 4easonast edested :gr.(VPtiON di 1

(

_ _ . _ _ _ _ _ . _ . . - - . (

] t%e meo.mation 4 co- oe,eo no t. cos er,,, ow..n,u io,op.. eire ,ne ,maien i o I

th. e o-ce 4 corsee ee to d vor.eian ,c9,woon rew, io to es a > waw e

, vme mio,meen an s, arm o en ,*, e..oo .n roevaence im- a va.e.g, un.se tvwr , , o (

• n ; '90.o s;:

j 5 the rheo r o,maten cor m o ics ecagem o, e

sie

.ose teao in . nae.i ine one ene erenn e.:a arae os ideas -aagem euc <e<~m-t e to ene a a, a,e no.i seat.. v.e phn e.a.w + me + mm F.,am e, o<os ovew a e . 1ero.enn.ge.cn osooise of reoeciserat .n't *m meo. mien e.o e t* , nat. etv. the ' acts a,e reet"rao+.

eirerectned and ann entjulty ento i*e treepred c one.oe.pl D'enstes p*otees of the egencythe,e eso ve no ,enon.t% ereg t #actue: mvra if Xf MPelON 56 ' ec imam the . ew of the v ts ound p s

_- l 6 The *'th*eio e'ormat on is esempted 'ro,n pubs.c asciosve t>ecause es o.sdosve noud <*w j i 'ea% uena"aated in.asion of pesonW p",acy aptMPitON F t

to .ened r+o-aren co-, t o m.s sngarorv ,ecewis u.

vaco io, i, e-wome,, g o oc v.:ps s teeg 6.ianeto to, twe re soe.si .no.c e *o 4*E VPTION Ps t o wow,e om,io meer+er .e e e'o<temeni p<o . . . _

yy e sen 3.e< , on ro ws o, reo,coment enom ea v%s couto pou.os, ano. raem to tone wmc to e.e4e r,ne.e,c come .,o, teauw ., eo#o rever tw.c .,urgy n a v.cieur

% ..~ em e,r r.esnero,s .ptvatioN h A o o sa c om.o.-. ,i.co-.s,,ee s .... ,eo .a.. ~ . . . ... , o co , ,<

1

._ \

t>e ic+o,. ree cons,sese c nrnes n' #ovous. ev, new e . so +c.on me ,stiow, c. ..

,y ..a .,, ,o rt,1,,s ,, cone,or.,si pu,,,, ,htvPtioN BDr l PARt il C - DENYING Of flCIA6, --

P phear *n 10 Cf 8 9 9 Pf1.H $ 1% rd 'Fe C $ Nwea> Ae$elaisto Gwna4 sip *egda5=ms a bA4 <

cid +c as evt rhon y dmiosse .e coaean te t% outA e'*.es, tre pe.wng ..sg#cs.io, ,toer$ We- y ;cd b M 16 e .t40eNtion m@he+f1 is eseact4'swa p,oow(te**Ge &VtN.' e 1 i

Q.vegen of Rw ies a^d Deco *69 ONe of Adwim spaten , re area 3, twe,e on for 4% doNis the mas be apposied to the (seg4.iwe Doectoe toe ole etions tooes ,cs,ni.'M beten es oe +rg o*'os

~

_ ._ C(hytNG Cf OCIAL - . _ . . _ . _ . fifLE 08 8'C1 7 kl W4M DEN'tD APPla A ?! Of 8sCIAL -

IDirector, Office of Ben B. Hayes """'" ' 9-

__ . . _ . , . . _ .. ~_.j. investigation 05 See AppendiLB _ X

.___ . . _ _ . . _ . _ _ . _ . . _ _ m_..,_.-

m_....,...._... . _ . _ . - . . . - . _ , -- _ . . .. . .

. . - ~ . . . _ - ~ . . ~ . . - - . . . .%. .

_....P. A. R t il D, A P P. ( A L RIG H, . ,f .$,e_

The denial wnteg and must bybeeach enadedeneng evtthin X) offecialident, days of receipt offeed m Part Appeats this response. H C may must bebeaccealed nriduw to the AppWteWM identAed m that section Any such the Sec retary of the Commrssion. U S Nocica' Regulatory Commission._Washityton< Q d.m appropriate to the E secutive Director for Operations ce to

. -- an@rM e

Re: F01A-66-718 APPENDIX A RECORDS MAINTAlhfD AMONG PDR FILES' 4

1. 3/i7/81 Letter to Denton from Hunter responain9 to Eisenhut letter datea 11/14/80. (6 pages) Ah0.: 8104060589 l

2. 3/9/bc Letter to Dolan from Norelius re: information needed prior to 4/12-16/82 special team inspection (2 pages)  !

ANO: 8203160201(PDR) l

3. 3/30/82 Letter to keppler from Hunter re: Cook Special Team Inspection (2 pages) ANO: 8405110145' 4 4/ 8/8E Letter to Hunter from Keppler re: Cook Special Team Inspection (1 pages) ANO: 8204300104.(CF)

5. 6/11/82 Letter to Denton from Hunter - Exemption request (11 pages)

AN0: 8206150328 (PDR) ,

)

6. 9/22/82 Letter to Dolan from Norelius w/encic are Inspection Reports No. 50-315/82-08 (DETP); 50-316/82-08 (DETP) (29 pages) ANO: 8210060387 PDR.

7 9/22/82 NRC Inspection Report - Special Team Anspection.

AN0: 8210060387 & 8210060387A

8. 2/15/83 Letter to Denton from Hering re: defic'iencies identified by PLC re: fire fighting strategies (2 pages) ANO: 8302220373

9. 3/31/83 Letter to Denton from Hunter re: Section 111 G Compliance (9 pages) Ah0: 8304070125 PDR

10. 9/20/83 Letter to Felton from Alexich re: PLCSurvey(2pages)

ANO: 8312120066 POR

11. 11/22/83 Letter to Dolan from Varga re: Alternate Safe Shutdown Capability (19pages) ANO: 6312090183 POR

12. 3/8/84 Letter to Denton from Alexich re: Appendix R Exemption ,

Request (3 pages) ANO: 8403160034 PDR~

1

13. 3/8/84 Letter to Denton from Alexich - Appendix R Exemption Request (5 pages) ANO: 8403130202 nw

1 Re: F0!A-86-718 l

APPENDIY A I (Continued)

RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG PDR FILES

]

14. 4/16/84 Letter to Dolan from Eisenhut re: schedule on Fire Protection modifications'(2 pages) Ah0: 8405020098 (POR)

16. 5/31/84 Memo for bilinsky from Harrison, subject: Differing l Professional Opinion " Interpretation of Appendix F<" l datec May 2,1984 EBERLf, et.al., (3 pages), j Ah0: 8604250078(PDR)  !

16. 6/7/64 Letter to Dolan from Keppler transmitting SALP (30 pages)

AN0: 8406120108(PDR) )

1 i i i

i l 1 5

i l

! l 3

l I

I l

I w w.

Re: F01A-86-718, Appendix B NRC records related to non-compliance at D.C. Cook of Fire Protection Regulations l

z

.l 1

l

-~ U' , . Li ,zat' A '~

3 'X: - _

1

' DVERNMENT ACCOUNTADluTY PROJECT

• 4 555 Connecticut Avenue. N.W.. Suite 202 Washingtm D.C. 20036 (202)232 8550 Government Accountability Project Midwest Offict 3424 N. Marcos Lane  !

Appleton, WI 54911 {

(414) 730-8533 )

/

Sept en.ber 3 0, 1986 i

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST F M OFIN M M eCI REQUEST Director f0ZA~% %

Office of Administration

/ g.

Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:

Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), 5 U.S.C.

552, the Government Accountability Project (GAP) requests copies of any and all agency records and information, including but not j limited to notes, letters, memoranda, dr af ts, minutes, di aries, j logs, calendars, tapes, transcripts,' summaries, interview reports, procedures, instructions, engineering analyses, drawings, files, graphs, charts, maps, photographs, agreements, handwritten notes, studies, data sheets, notebooks, books, telephone messages, computations, voice recordings, cumputer runoffs, any other data compilations, interim and/or final reports, status reports, and any and all other records relevant to and/or generated in connection with any information known to the NFC about the non-compliance of an NRC fire proction rule issued ir; November 1980, at the Donald C. Cook nuclear power plant in Michigan.

This request includes all agency records as defined in 10 C.F.R. 9.3a(b) and NRC Manual, Appen.i n x 0211, Parts 1.A.2 and A.3 (approved October 8, 1980) whether they currently exist in the NRC officia1, " working", invest (gative or other files, or at any other locarion, including private residences ,

If any records, as defined in110 C.F.R. 9.3(b) and the NRC Manual, supra, and covered by this request have been destroyed and/or removed after this request, please provide all surrounding records, including but not limited i.o a list of all records which have been or are destroyed and/or removed, a description of the  :

, action (s) taken relevant to, generat ed in connection with, and/or issued in order to implement the action (s).

l 1

bl20 A 110P48 Humn >

l'DR HMA '

DAUMAN86-718 PDR l

l t

'M 4 .

yy e iy --

(2)

GAP requests that fees be waived, bee w - "IInding the inf ormation can be considercel as primarily bo wr i t t ing the general public," 5 (J . S . C . 522(a)(4)(a). CAP es a aan profit, non-partisan public interest organization car ern.'d with honest and open government. Through public outreach, the Project promotes whistleblowers as agents of governmc.* accountability.

Through its Environmental Whistleblower Clin:c, GAP offers assis-tance to local public interest and citizens groups and interveners j in the concern for safety at nuclear power plants.  !

We are requesting the above information as part of a monitoring project on the adequacy of Region III and thMTC's ef fort s to protect public safety and health at nuclear power plants in the mid-west.

For any documents or portions that you cieny due to a specific j 1

FOIA exemption, please provide an index i tem rt ing and describing the documents or portions of documents withhe'1d. The index should provide a detailed justification of your gro;: !s for claiming each exemption, explaining why each exemption is r. levant to the document or portion of the document withheld. This ir. lex is required under Vcughn v. Rosen (I), 484 F2d 820 (D.C. Cir. 19731, cert. denied, 415 U.S. 977 (1974).

We look forward to your response to this request within ten working days.

Sincerely, i < s c/

,f, G A fyjj>

Lir.a Bauman FOI A Coortlinator Midwest Office

)

l 1

i i

%