ML20238F681
| ML20238F681 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Vogtle  |
| Issue date: | 08/13/1998 |
| From: | Baker E NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Benjamin Beasley SOUTHERN NUCLEAR OPERATING CO. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9809040190 | |
| Download: ML20238F681 (9) | |
Text
August 13, 1998
{
(
ur. B. B.ni.y i1ECEP M D qv-Vice President Southem NuclearOperateg Company,Inc.!K3 !M IU I'I 7 20 P.O. Box 1295 Birmingham, AL 35201-1295 PUBUC DOCUl'.EH.I ROOM
Dear Mr. Beasley:
This letter is in response to a request from Mr. Hugh Bryant of your staff for statistics on allegations received by the NRC concemang Vogtle. The attached tables provide a comparison to allegations received at other operating sites for calendar years 1993,1994,1995,1996,1997 and the first seven months of 1998. You may notice changes from statistics previously reported.
The software used to count :":7":5.s has been revised to avoid " double counting" allegations that are transferred from one NRC organization to another. AMR{dy, the data is audited for accuracy and corrections are made as appropnate.
j If either you or Mr. Bryant have any questions concoming the data, you can reach me at (301) 415-8529.
Sincerely, MM@
Edward T. Baker, lil Agency Allegation Advisor Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attachments: As stated cc w/ attachments: see next page
/
DISTRIBUTION:
/
File Center /Public EBaker CMohrwinkel y
FMiraglia BBoger DJaffe O. De Miranda, Ril A. Boland, Rll B. Mallett, Ril To recewe a copy of this document, indicate in the bor C= Copy w/o attachment / enclosure E= Copy with attachment / enclosure N = No copy DOCUMENTI4AME Vogtle NRR EBake 8 /d/98
/ /98
/ 198
/ /98
/ /98 OFFICIAL FILE COPY 9809040190 980913 7
PDR ADOCK 05000424 P
PH
/
UNITED STATES
) *' l j
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION o
,C WASHINGTON. D.C. 20666-4001 August 13. 1998 Mr. B. Beasley Vice President Southem Nuclear Operating Company Inc.
P.O. Box 1295 Birmingham. AL 35201-1295
Dear Mr. Beasley:
This letter is in response to a request from Mr. Hugh Bryant of your staff for statistics on allegations received by the NRC conceming Vogtle. The attached tables provide a comparison to allegations received at other operating sites for calendar years 1993,1994,1995,1996,1997 and the first seven months of 1998. You may notice changes from statistics previously reported.
The software used to count allegations has been revised to avoid " double counting" allegations that are transferred from one NRC organization to another. Additionally, the data is audited for accuracy and corrections are made as appropriate.
If either you or Mr. Bryant have any questions conceming the data, you can reach me at (301) 415-8529.
Sincerely, an' Edward T. Baker,111 Agency Allegation Advisor Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attachments: As stated cc w/ attachments: see next page 9
l l
Vogtle Electric Generating Plant cc:
Harold Rehois, Director Mr. J. A. Bailey Department of Natural Resources Manager, Licensing 205 Butler Street, SE. Suite 1252 Southem Nuclear Operating Atlanta, Georgia 30334 Company, Inc.
P. O. Box 1295 '
Attomey General Birmingham, Alabama 35201-1295 Law Department 132 Judicial Building Mr. J. Gasser Atlanta, Georgia 30334 General Manager, Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Mr. R. D. Barker Southem Nuclear Operating Program Manager Company, Inc.
Fossil & Nuclear Operations P. O. Box 1600 Oglethorpe Power Corporation Waynesboro, Georgia 30830 2100 East Exchange Place P. O. Box 1349 Regional Administrator, Region 11 Tucker, Georgia 30085-1349 i
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory l
Commission Charles A. Patrizia, Esquire Atlanta Federal Center Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker 61 Forsyth Street, SW., Suite 23T85 10th Floor Atlanta, Georgia 30303 1299 Pennsylvania Avenue j
Washington, DC 20004-9500 i
Office of Planning and Budget l
Room 615B Arthur H. Domby, Esquire 270 Washington Street, SW.
Troutman Sanders Atlanta, Georgia 30334 NationsBank Plaza 600 Peachtree Street, NE.
Mr. J. D. Woodard suite 5200 Executive Vice President Atlanta, Georgia 30308-2216 Southem Nuclear Operating Company, Inc.
Resident inspector P. O. Box 1295 Vogtle Plant l
Birmingham, Alabama 35201-1295 8805 River Road l
Waynesboro, Georgia 30830 Steven M. Jackson Senior Engineer-Power Supply Office of the County Commissioner Municipal Electric Authority Burke County Commission of Georgia Waynesboro, Georgia 30830 1470 Riveredge Parkway, NW.
Atlanta, Georgia 30328-4684 Mr. Hugh Bryant P. O. Box 1295 BIN B019 l
Birmingham, AL 35201-1295 l
- ~
- ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED. MOST TO LEAST CY98 - 7/39/98 8/11/98 l
Site l1993l1994l1995l1996l199711998 MILLSTONE 2 & 3 28 !
20' 34! 49i 53!
2_6 ST LUCIE 4! 11 211 46i 69! 23 DIABLO CANYON 12i 13 1 61 22 18! 19 NINE MILE POINT 10!
7 ill 12 8'
14 SALEM / HOPE CREEK 13 22 20l 43! 20 12 BROWNS FERRY 39 15 13! 23!
20, 12 COOK 6
10 4'
3!
6! 12 VERMONT YANKEE 3!
2 5
9!
4! 12 BRUNSWICK 25l 11 7
8; 26l 10 WOLF CREEK 6! 12 6: 13I 20' 10 INDIAN POINT 2 6:
1 6l 6 11 10' TURKEY POINT 13l 9,
12i 16l 19:
9 DRESDEN 12 12l 12)
___1 1 ! 13 9
OUAD CITIES 5
9 7
1 21 13t 9
LASALLE 5
15]
7 9l 11 9
BYRON 3!
8l d
5! 11 9
i WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 8;
6[ 14I 18l 23 8
g SAN ONOFRE 8; 16: 30j 32l 32j 7
SUSQUEHANNA 8!
8 8; 34! 24!
7 COOPER 3; 15! til 14l 19' 7
CLINTON 12l 18; Si 20l 33!
6 WATTS BAR 69l 64i 50l 2Bl 14!
6
~ SOUTH TEXAS 38' 211 15] 25! III 6
POINT 8EACH 1
4I 3:
41 10; 6
ARKANSAS 4
4!
7i 2l 7l 6
HARRIS 2!
4!
3l 2i 3:
6 OCONEE il 4'
il 8:
2; 6
CRYSTAL RIVER 5l 3l 6! 21l 20l 5
HATCH 4I 8'
6!
4! 17!
5 INDIAN POINT 3 25 14! 11j 6! 15!
5 SEQUOYAH 31 7
19l 27I 13:
5 GRAND GULF 3:
2 2;
9:
4' 5~
COMANCHE PEAK 19I 5'
14! 19! 13 4
WATERFORD 5!
3' 16! 21i 11!
4 OYSTER CREEK i
9 3,
5:
4! 10 4
FORT CALHOUN 7,
di 4'
di 10 4
_ RIVER 8END 211 12! 21! 17i 8
4 SEABROOK 4!
5!
3-6 4!
4 PALO VERDE 40; 23 18 22! 19:
3 PERRY 8
7{
2i 10; 9l 3
CATAW8A 3'
7!
2 5
8 3
DAVIS-8 ESSE 10! 10 7 2i til 6
3 CALVERT CLIFFS 6
7, F
71 6-3 fl'T2 PATRICK 8~
3' 7l Si SP5
~
PEACH BOTTOM 6'
8 3
4l 5;
3 3
CALLAWAY 5
2!
5:
71 4:
3 MCGUIRE 8!
3l 4!
3' 3~
PALISADES 5:
6' 8:
5:
3 3
PILGRIM 19; 9;
8l 51 2l 3
BRAIDWOOD 3l 111 3;
9! 16l 2
LIMERICK 16! 1 21 4!
SI 9'
2
. BEAVER VALLEY 9!
7i 7j SE L 2
DUANE ARNOLD 2l 2i 3?
l 3
5 VOGTLE 7l 11] 11l 6l 13 1
FERMI 9
19 8'
18!
8' 1
THREE MILE ISLAND 4l 2i II li 4!
1
. RO8INSON 4!
2}
3:
il 2i 1
FARLEY il 2i 3;
6l 2
1 1
MONTICELLO 2l l
l 6,
2; 1
PRAIRIE ISLAND di 2!
3 7!
5-NORTH ANNA 12!
2:
8!
4!
3 ISUMMER 2;
3 2
9 2
Page 1
' ALLE ATIONS RECEIVED - MOST TO LEAST CY98 7/31C8 8/11/98 11993 1994I1995l19961199711998 She SURRY 5
5 3:
3 1
KEWAUNEE 1
1 1
1 OlNNA 1
1 1
4 1
1 J
n Page 2
I DISCRIMINATION ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED _. MOST TO LEAST Cv98 7/31/98 8/11/98 l
She l1993I1994l1995l1996l1997I1998
)
MILLSTONE 2 & 3 11 15 12 26' 23 4
l SUSOUEHANNA 2
1 1
2 4
SALEM / MOPE CREEK 3
5 7
10<
3, 3
CLINTON 2
Si 6l 2
OUAD CITIES 1
2 3l 2
l POINT BEACH 1
1 1
2 2
,DIABLO CANYON 1
2 1
5 2
2 DUANE ARNOLD 1
1 2
SAN ONOFRE 5
4 3l 6
6 1
BRUNSWICK 6
1 1
31 5
1 PALO VERDE 14 11 4
2 2
1 INDIAN POINT 3 3-3 5
1 2
1 COOPER 5!
2 1
OYSTER CREEK 1
2 1
1 1
COMANCHE PEAK 1
1 3
1 1
SEAVER VALLEY 4
1 1
1 NINE MILE POINT 2
1 4
1 1
1 TURKEY POINT 4
2 1
1 ST LUCIE 2
3 1
1 1
MCGUIRE 4
1 HARRIS 1
1 INDIAN POINT 2 3:
1 1
VERMONT YANKEE 2
1 WATTS BAR 18: 18i 16 6
4
_8RAfDWOOD 4!
1 2
di BROWNS FERRY 4
4!
3' 4
4l WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 4!
4 2
4!
WOLF CREEK 1
3:
DRESDEN 3;
1 2l 3;
PERRY 2{
2_
1 3;
3!
SO_UTH TEXAS 16!
71 5
7i 3,
LASALLE l
21 3'
2]
LIMERICK 2;
}
1 2j COOK 3:
1}
1 1
2!
WATERFORD 2i l
5 7
21 PILGRIM 2
2' 2i 2i
- SEQUOYAH 11 2
3I 6
2' THREE MILE ISLAND 1
FORT CALHOUN 2
2 1
1 DAVIS-BESSE 2
1 1
1 CALLAWAY 1l 1
1 1
1 VOGTLE 4!
1 OCONEE 1
1 1
FITZPATRICK 2
1 1
PEACH BOTTOM 1
21 1
1 PALISADES 1
il 1
FERMI 4
3 3
4 1
SEABROOK 1
PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
BYRON 1
1 GRAND GULF 1
1 NORTH ANNA 1
1 SUMMER 1
ARKANSAS 1
3 1
- SURRY 1
l CRYSTAL RIVER 2
1 4!
3 HATCH 1
R.OBINSON 3
CALVERT CLIFFS II 3
3 Pa9e 1
ALLEGATIONS SUBSTANTIATED IN YEAR RECEIVED - 7/31/98 8/11/98 o
l Site I1993l1994l197.oI1996l1997l1998 ARKANSAS 1
Il 4'
2' 5:
1 l
BEAVER VALLEY 1
31 1
3 BRAIDWOOD 1
6; 2
3+
4I 2
l DROWNS FERRY 14 Bi 5
7j 4:
1 BRUNSWICK 10:
6i 5
Si 15!
1 BYRON I
1 2
3 5l 2
CALLAWAY 3!
3' 3'
l CALVERT CLIFFS 3'
1 Il 41 l
CATAWBA 1
3 1
2!
3 CLIN _ TON 4
9 5
9! 15j 3
1 COMANCHE PEAK 7
3' 4
6 6:
'_ COOK 2
7 6
2 2
6 COOPER 2
5 7
7 7
1 CRYSTAL RIVER 1
2 4
1 21 5
DAVIS-BESSE 21 4
1 21 1
DIABLO CANYON ll 8!
8l 6!
8 2
DRESDEN 7i Si 6!
5! 10l 1
DUANE ARNOLD 2i 1l 1
l 2!
FARLEY i
l 1_2l 2!
1 FERMI Si 5!
1!
8' 2i
.FITZPATRICK i
2l 3!
I I
FORT CALHOUN 1j 2f 2i 2
4:
GINNA l
l 1l 2}
ti GRAND GULF 1
il 2i 3
ti HARRIS lj j
1 l
tj 2
HATCH 2i 3
2 2! 10 1
INDIAN POINT 2 2!
i 2
3 4!
3
. INDIAN POINT 3 10j 4l 2!
11 2i KEWAUNEE Il
}
}
II I
LASALLE 2i 6'
5 2
4i 1
1 LIMERICK 7i 4'
il 4'
2!
1 MCGUIRE I
11 1l 1
il MILLSTONE 2 & 3 14!
4' 5!
11 7i 1
MONTICELLO 2!
l 1[
NINE MILE POINT 1!
2l 3'
1 4!
1 NORTH ANNA 2
I 2l 2!
1 OCONEE I
2:
I 2'
1 2
OYSTER CREEK 2
Il 3'
2 PALISADES 1
2!
2; 2
1!
PALO VERDE 5;
9 8
9l 8
PEACH BOTTOM i
11 2-1 21 i
PERRY 2'
3 1
3 1
PlLGRIM i
4' il 1
1l l
t FOINT BEACH I
3' 2'
2:
6 1
PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
li 2!
2i OUAD CITIES 1
5' 3'
4 7;
1 i
RIVER BEND 111 6!
9' 4!
Si 1
ROBINSON 2:
1!
Il li 1
SALEM / HOPE CREEK 3-11!
7! 12l 5!
1 SAN ONOFRE 1
8 12 9' ill SEABROOK 1
11 1
il SEQUOYAH 71 il B.
11 7:
1 SOUTH TEXAS 16:
91 6
9 7'
i ST LUCIE 1
2 13 26: 31 5
SUMMER 1
1 6'
SURRY 4
1 1
1 SUSOVEHANNA 3:
2 1
18 11 l
THREE MILE ISLAND 1l Il l
2 l
TURKEY POINT 7i 4!
5 6
9 1
VERMONT YANKEE 2i il 2!
Il 2:
2 E6GTLE 2!
4l 3
5' 3
5ASHINGTON NUCLEAR 4
4 7
6 6
1 Page1
.w_--__
ALLE7ATIONS SUBSTANTIATED IN YEAR RECEIVED 7/31/ 8 8/11/98
+-
Site I1993119941199511996l1997l1998 l
WATERFORD I
3i 2l 11 7
2l 1
WATTS BAR 33i 29! 16 11 4!
1 WOLF CREEK 51 7I 1
6 9l 2
i Page 2 l
4 OPEN ALLEGATIONS MOST TO LEAST 7/31/98 8/11/98 Site 1996h D96l1997l1998I Total
~
MILLSTONE 2 & 3 2
12 5
12l 31
_DIABLO CANYON 1
1 15!
17 SALEM / HOPE CREEK 1
3 1
9:
14 WATTS BAR 2
4 3
el 13 BRUNSWICK 1
5 6!
12 ST LUCIE 1
10!
11 TURKEY POINT 1
8!
9 COOK 1
2 5
8 BROWNS FERRY 1
2 5
8 DRESDEN 1
1 6!
8 SAN ONOFRE 2
51 7
PERRY 2
3-1 6
POINT BEACH 2
4 6
_ UAD CITIES 1
1 4
6 Q
SEQUOYAH 2
1 3:
6 COOPER 1
5!
6 WOLF CREEK 1
4!
5 SUSQUEHANNA 1
4' 5
VERMONT YANKEE 5l 5
PILGRIM -
2 3:
5 WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 1
4!
5 GRAND GULF 5!
5 4[ 5 HATCH 1
i INDIAN POINT 2 1
4l 5
INDIAN POINT 3 1
1 2!
4 BYRON 4l 4
C_LINTON 2
2i 4
FORT CALHOUN 8
4!
4 SEABROOK 1
3 4
NINE MILE POINT 1
3:
4 LASALLE t
41 4
OYSTER CREEK 1
1 2!
4 SOUTH TEXAS 1
3' 4
CRYSTAL RIVER 3
3 DAVIS-BESSE 1
2 3
CALLAWAY 3
3 OCONEE l
3 3
DUANE ARNOLD i
1 1
Il 3
{
3; 3
HARRIS 3'
3 PALISADES 1
2i 3
PALO VERDE 3
3 MONTICELLO 1
II 2
,QALVERT CLIFFS 2:
2 FITZPATRICK 2I 2
RIVER BEND 2i 2
PEACH BOTTOM 2
2 VOGTLE 1
il 2
COMANCHE PEAK 2i 2
WATERFORD 2i 2
pATAWBA 1
1 2
BEAVER VALLEY 1
1 FERMI 1
1 KEWAUNEE 1
1 MCGUIRE 1
1 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
1 SUMMER 1
1 LIMERICK 1
1 Page 1