ML20238E750
| ML20238E750 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Hatch  |
| Issue date: | 08/13/1998 |
| From: | Baker E NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Sumner H SOUTHERN NUCLEAR OPERATING CO. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9809020163 | |
| Download: ML20238E750 (9) | |
Text
y 1
August 13, 1998 Mr. H. I L Sumner, Jr.
b5 W-
. Vice President - Nuclear U
e Hatch %:t m3 ltg 18 fjt 7: 20 ye O Bo 2 C
DlT R00!!
g.
Birmingham, Al. 35201-12g5
Dear Mr. Sumner:
This letter is in response to a request from Mr. Hugh Bryant of your staff for statistics on
- allegations received by the NRC concerning Hatch. The attached tables provide a comparison to allegations received at other operating sites for calendar years 1993,1994,1995,1996,1997 and the first seven months of 1998. You may notice changes from statistics previously reported.
The software used to count allegations has been revised to avoid " double counting' allegations that are transferred imm one NRC organization to another. Additionally, the data is audited for accuracy and corrections are made as appropriate.
If either you or Mr. Bryant have any questions concoming the data, you can reach me at (301) 415-8529.
Sincerely, MMk Edward T. Baker, lil Agency Allegation Advisor -
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attachments: As stated cc w/ attachments: see next page DISTRIBUTION:
File Center /Public EBaker CMohrwinkel fi FMiraglia
- BBoger
\\
LOlshan f
T)(g O. De Miranda, Ril A. Boland, Ril B. Mallett, Ril To receive a copy of tNs document. indcate in the box C= Copy w/o attachment / enclosure E= Copy whh attachment / enclosure N = No copy DOCUMENTNAME: Farley NRR EBake 8 //l/98
/ /98
/ /98
/ 198
/ /98 OFFICIAL FILE COPY l
9909020163 990813 l
PDR ADOCK 05000321 x
l P
PDR L
F l
L ___ ___ _
ss arc 8%
UNITED STATES l
y-j T
j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
, f WASHINGTON. D.C. 20eWwooot
,o*
August 13, 1998 Mr. H. L Sumner, Jr.
Vice President - Nuclear Hatch Project Southem Nuclear Operating Company Inc.
P.O. Box 1295 Birmingham, AL 35201-1295 Dear Mr. Sumner.
This letter is in response to a request from Mr. Hugh Bryant of your staff for statistics on allegations received by the NRC conceming Hatch. The attached tables provide a comparison to allegations received at other operating sites for calendar years 1993,1994,1995,1996,1997 and the first seven months of 1998. You may notice changes from statistics previously reported.
The software used to count allegations has been revised to avoid " double counting" allegations that are transferred from one NRC organization to another. Additionally, the data is audited for accuracy and corrections are made as appropriate, if either you or Mr. Bryant have any questions concoming the data, you can reach me at (301) 415-8529.
Sincerely, Of I
?
f y/(n en K tA Et -
r Edward T. Baker, til Agency Allegation Advisor Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attachments: As stated cc w/ attachments: see next page I
i
Edwin I. Hatch Nuclear Plant cc-Mr. Emest L Blake, Jr.
Charles A. Patrizia, Esquire Shaw, Pittman, Potts Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker and Trowbridge 10th Floor 2300 N Street, NW.
1299 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington, DC 20037 Washington, DC 20004-9500 Mr. D. M. Crowe Chairman Manager, Licensing Appling County Commissioners Southem Nuclear Operating County Courthouse Company, Inc.
Baxley, Georgia 31513 P. O. Box 1295 Birmingham, Alabama 35201-1295 Mr. J. D. Woodard Executive Vice President Resident inspector Southem Nuclear Operating Plant Hatch Company, Inc.
11030 Hatch Parkway N.
P. O. Box 1295 Baxley, Georgia 31531 Birmingham, Alabama 35201-1295 Regional Administrator, Region il Mr. P. W. Wells U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission General Manager, Edwin 1. Hatch Atlanta Federal Center Nuclear Plant 61 Forsyth Street, SW, Suite 23T85 Southem Nuclear Operating Atlanta, Georgia 30303 Company, Inc.
U.S. Highway 1 North Mr. Charles H. Badger P. O. Box 2010 Office of Planning and Budget Baxley, Georgia 31515 Room 610 270 Washington Street, SW.
Mr. R. D. Barker Atlanta, Georgia 30334 Program Manager Fossil & Nuclear Operations Harold Rehels, Director Oglethorpe Power Corporation Department of Natural Resources 2100 East Exchange Place 205 Butler Street, SE., Suite 1252 P. O. Box 1349 Atlanta, Georgia 30334 Tucker, Georgia 30085-1349 Steven M. Jackson Mr. Hugh Bryant Senior Engineer-Power Supply P.O. Box 1295 1
Municipal Electric Authority BIN B019 of Georgia Birmingham, AL 35201-1295 h
1470 Riveredge Parkway, NW Atlanta, Georgia 30328-4684
ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED MOST TO LEAST CY98 7/31/98 8/11/98 Site
!1993l1994l1995 l1996(1997l1998 MILLSTONE 2 ai 3 28-20: 34 49 53l 26 ST LUCIE 4
11 21 46 69; 23 DIABLO CANYON 12 13 16 22
- 18) 19 NINE MILE POINT 10!
7 11l 12, 8! 14 SALEM / HOPE CREEK 13 22 20l 43! 20I 12 BROWNS FERRY 39 15 13I 23! 20 12 COOK 6
to 4
3!
6 12 VERMONT YANKEE 3
2 5
91 4
12 BRUNSWICK 25 11 7
8! 26 10 WOLF CREEK 6
12 6
13! 20 10 INDIAN POINT 2 6!
1 6
6I 11 10 TURKEY POINT 13' 9
12 16 19 9
DRESDEN 12 12 12 11 17 9
QUAD CITIES 5
9 7
12 13 9
LASALLE 5
15 7
9 11 9
8YRON 3
8, 4
5 11 9
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 8!
6! 14 18 23, 8
SAN ONOFRE 8! 16 30, 32 32 7
SUSOUEHANNA 8!
8 8] 34 24 7
COOPER 3
15 til 14 19l 7
- CLINTON 12! 18!
8(20 33' 6
WATTS 8AR 691 64I 50! 28 14 6
SOUTH TEXAS 38 21 15} 25 11 6
POINT BEACH 1
4 3!
4 10 6
ARKANSAS 4
4, 7j-2j 71 6
HARRIS 2
4 3'
2i 3!
6 OCONEE 1
4 1
Bi 2!
6 CRYSTAL RIVER 5,
3 6
21 20' 5
HATCH 4
8' 6,
4 17 5
INDIAN POINT 3 25 14 ill 6! 15 5
SEQUOYAH 31 7
19I_ 27j 13 5
GRAND GULF 3
2 21 9I 4
5 COMANCHE PEAK 19' 51 14l 19l 13l 4
WATERFORD 5
3 16! 21! ill 4
OYSTER CREEK 9
3l 5!
4) 10' 4
FORT CALHOUN 7'
4' 4l 4! 10:
4 RIVER BEND 21 12! 21l 17l 8!
4 SEA 8 ROOK 4
5!
3t 6i 4!
4 PALO VERDE 40: 23! 18I 22i 19:
3 PERRY 8!
7]
2! 10:
9l 3
CATAWBA 3!
7l 2i 5!
8!
3 DAVIS-8 ESSE 10! 10!
2i 111 6l 3
CALVERT CLIFFS -
6!
71 8:
7i 6'
3 FITZPATRICK 8!
3l 7l 5!
SI 3
PEACH BOTTOM 6!
8!
3' 4!
51 3
CALLAWAY ST 2!
51 7'
di 3
MCGUIRE 8t 3!
4 3!
3 PALISADES 5
6!
8j 5
3' 3
PILGRIM 19l 9!
8' Bl 2
3 BRAIDWOOD 3! 11 3;
9: 16 2
LIMERICK 16! 12 4!
5 9,
2 BEAVER VALLEY 9!
7 71 5
Bi 2
DUANE ARNOLD 2!
2 3l 3) 2 VOGTLE 7j 11 11l 6 111 1
1 FERMI 9'
19 8'
18f 8!
1 THREE MILE ISLAND 4
2 1l 1
4 1
RO81NSON 4
2 3:
1 2
1 FARLEY -
1}
2 3!
6i 2
1 MONTICELLO 2l l
l 6!
2!
1 PRAIRIE ISLAND 4!
2I 3l 71 5!
NORTH ANNA 12l 2!
8!
4!
3; SUMMER 2
3!
2; 9!
2!
r Pa9e 1 t__________________________
.,y ALLE!ATK)NS RECE!VED MOST TO LEAST CY98 7/31/98 8/11/98 1
he
'1993!19M l1995l1999l1997 (1993 SURRY 5
6 3'
3 1
KEWAUNEE 1
i j
q GINNA 1
3 y
4 3
4 l
i:
L Page 2
(
t u
F
. DISCRIMINATION ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED MOST TO LEAST CY98 7/31/!8 8/11/98 l..
Site I1993 '1994l1996l1996l1997 (1998 MILLSTONE 2 & 3 11 15 12-26 23 4
$USOUEHANNA 2
1 1
2 4
SALEM, HOPE CREEK 3
5 7
10 3-3 i
CLINTON 2
3 6[
2 I
OUAD CITIES 1
2 3!
2 POINT BEACH 1
1 1
2i 2
DIABLO CANYON 1
2 1
5 2
2 DUANE ARNOLD 1
1 2
SAN ONOFRE 5
4 3
6 6,
1 BRUNSWICK 6
1 1
3 5
1 PALO VERDE 14 11 4
2 2
1 INDIAN POINT 3 3
3 5
1 2
1 COOPER 5
2 1
OYSTER CREEK 1
2 1
1 1
COMANCHE PEAK 1
1 3
1 1
BEAVER VALLEY 4
1 1
1 NINE MILE POINT 2
1 4
1 1
1 TURKEY POINT 4
2 1
1 ST LUCIE 2
3 1
1 1
MCGUlnE -
4 1
HARRIS 1
1 INDIAN POINT 2 3
1 1
VERMONT YANKEE 2
1 WATTS BAR 18 18! 16 6
4 BRAIDWOOD 4!
1 2
4I BROWNS FERRY 4
4 3:
4 4!
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 4
4 2
4l WOLF CREEK 1
3l DRESDEN 3
1 2
3:
- PERRY 2!
2, 11 3:
3' SOUTH TEXAS 16!
7' 5'
7 3i LASALLE l
2 3
2i LIMERICK 2!
1 2I COOK-3t 1
1 il 2!
WATERFORD 2
5 7'
2i PILGRIM 2
2!
2 21 SEQUOYAH 11 2'
3i 6
2 THREE MILE ISLAND 1
FORT CALHOUN 2
2 1
-1 DAVIS-BESSE 2
1 1
1 CALLAWAY 1
1 1
1 1
VOGTLE 4
1 f
OCONEE 1
1 1
FITZPATRICK
-2 1
1 PEACH BOTTOM 1
2 1
1 PALISADES 1
1 1
FERMI 4
3 3
4 1
SEABROOK 1
PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
BYRON 1
1 GRAND GULF 1
1 NORTH ANNA 1
1 SUMMER 1
ARKANSAS 1
3-SURRY 1
CRYSTAL RIVER 2
1 4
3 HATCH 1
ROBINSON 31 CALVERT CLIFFS Il 3
3<
l i
l Page 1
]
+
. ALLEGATIONS SUBSTANTIATED IN YEAR RECEIVED - 7/31/98 8/11/98 Site -
'1993l1994 I1996l1996l19971998 ARKANSAS 1
1 4!
2 5
1 BEAVER VALLEY 1
3 1
3 BRAIDWOOD 1
6 2
3 4
2 BROWNS FERRY 14 8
5 7
4 1
BRUNSWICK 10 6
5 5
15 1
8YRON 1
2 3
5 2
CALLAWAY 3
3 3
CALVERT CLIFFS 3
1 1
4 CATAWSA 1
3 1
2 3
CLINTON 4
9 5
9 15 3
COMANCHE PEAK -
7 3
4 6
6 COOK 2
6 2
2 6
COOPER 2
5 7
7 7
1
- CRYSTAL RIVER 1
2 4
12 5
DAVIS-BESSE 2
4 1
2 DIABLO CANYON 1
8 8<
6 8
2 DRESDEN 7
5 6
5 10 1
DUANE ARNOLD 2
1 1
2 FARLEY 1
2 2
1 FERMI 5
5 1
8 2
FITZPATRICK 2
3 FORT CALHOUN 1
2 2
2 4
GINNA 1
2 1
GRAND GULF 1
2 3
1 HARRIS 1
1 1
2 HATCH 2
3:
2 2
10:
1 INDIAN POINT 2 2
2 3
4 3
INDIAN POINT 3 10 4
2 1
2 KEWAUNEE 1
1 LASALLE 2
6:
5 2
4 1
LIMERICK 7
41 1
4 2l 1
MCGUIRE 1
1 1
11 MILLSTONE 2 & 3 14 4
5
'11 7
1 MONTICELLO 2
1 NINE MILE POINT 1
2 3
1 4
1 NORTH ANNA 2
2 2
1 OCONEE 2
2 1
2 OYSTER CREEK 2
1
- 3i 2
PALISADES 1
2 21 2
Il PALO VERDE 5
9 Bi 9,
8 PEACH BOTTOM 1
2 1
2i PERRY 2
3 1
3:
1 PILGRIM 41 Il 1
il POINT BEACH 31 2
21 6:
1 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
1 2!
2{_
QUAD CITIES 1
5 3
4!
7, 1
1
' RIVER BEND 11 6
9' 4!
6!
1 ROBINSON 2!
I 1
1 1
SALEM / HOPE CREEK 3! 11 7
12 5
1 l
SAN ONOFRE 1
8 12 9
11 l
_SEABROOK 1
1 1
1 SEQUOYAH 7L 1 8
11 7
SOUTH TEXAS 1 61 9,
6 9,
7 ST LUCIE 1
2' 13 26 31 5
SUMMER 1
1 6
SURRY 4
1 1
-1 SUSQUEHANNA 3
2 1
18 11 THREE MILE ISLAND 1
1 2
I TURKEY POINT 7
4 5
61 9
1 1
1 VERMONT YANKEE 2
1 2
li 21 2
1 VOGTLE 2
4 3:
5!
3!
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 4
di 7i 6'
61 Page 1
_.4
~
ALLE!ATIONS SUBSTANTIATED IN YEAR RECEtVED 7/31/98 8/11/98 sn.
!iesslies4liesslisselise711oes WATERFORD 3!
2 Ill
-7 2!
1 WATTS BAR 33l 29 18! 11 41 1
WOLF CREEK 51 7
16 6
el 2
L Page 2
(*
4
OPEN ALLEGATIONS - MOST TO LEAST - 7/31/"8 8'11/98 1
Site 1995 1996I1997 l19981 Total MILLSTONE 2 & 3 2
12 5
12 31 DIABLO CANYON 1
1 15 17 SALEM / HOPE CREEK 1
3 1
9 14 WATTS BAR 2
4 3
4 13 BRUNSWICK -
1 5
6 12 ST LUCIE 1
-10 11 TURKEY POINT 1
8 9
COOK 1
2 5
8 SROWNS FERRY 1
2 6
8 DRESDEN 1
1 6
8 SAN ONOFRE 2
5 7
PERRY 2
3 1
6 POINT BEACH 2
4 6
OUAD CITIES 1
1 4
6 SEQUOYAH 2
1 3
6 COOPER 1
5 6
WOLF CREEK 1
4 5
_SUSQUEHANNA 1
4 5
1 VERMONT YANKEE 5
5 PILGRIM 2
3 5
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 1
4 5
GRAND GULF 5
5 HATCH 1
4 5
I INDIAN POINT 2 1
4 5
INDIAN POINT 3 1
1 2
4 BYRON 4
4 CLINTON 2
2 4
FORT CALHOUN 4
4 SEABROOK 1
3 4
NINE MILE POINT 1
3 4
LASALLE 4
4 OYSTER CREEK 1
1 2
4 SOUTH TEXAS 1
3 4
CRYSTAL RIVER 3
3 DAVIS-BESSE 1
2 3_
CALLAWAY 3
3 OCONEE 3!
3 DUANE ARNOLD
-1 1
1}
3 ARKANSAS 3;
3 HARRIS 3!
3 PALISADES 1
21 3
)
PALO VERDE 3i 3
MONTICELLO 1
2 CALVERT CLIFFS 2
2 I
FITZPATRICK 2
2 RIVER BEND 2
2 3
PEACH BOTTOM 2
2 VOGTLE 1
1 2
COMANCHE PEAK 21 2
WATERFORD 2
2 CATAWBA 1
1 2
BEAVER VALLEY 1
1 FERMI 1
1 i:
KEWAUNEE 1
1 MCGUIRE 1
1 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
1 SUMMER 1
1 d
LIMERICK 1
1 Page1 k_..
"~-
_ = _..
,